WEBVTT
00:19:46.618 --> 00:19:47.719
GOOD AFTERNOON WE'RE WAITING FOR
00:19:47.786 --> 00:19:49.288
A COUPLE MEMBERS TO COME DOWN SO
00:19:49.354 --> 00:19:50.656
WE CAN START AT LEAST AS A
00:19:50.722 --> 00:19:51.690
SUBCOMMITTEE.
00:19:51.757 --> 00:19:55.227
SO IF YOU'RE LISTENING -- IN
00:19:55.294 --> 00:19:56.862
YOUR BOSS IS LOST TELL THEM TO
00:19:56.929 --> 00:19:58.430
COME DOWN TO ROOM ONE TWENTY SIX
00:19:58.497 --> 00:20:14.780
I BELIEVE IS RIGHT
00:20:19.117 --> 00:20:19.184
.
00:20:19.184 --> 00:20:21.887
AGAIN WE'RE WAITING FOR A COUPLE
00:20:21.954 --> 00:20:30.762
MEMBERS AND ASSEMBLY EDUCATION.
00:20:30.829 --> 00:20:32.331
WE REALLY NEED A MEMBER OF THE
00:20:32.397 --> 00:20:34.199
REPUBLICAN PARTY HERE SO WE CAN
00:20:34.266 --> 00:20:39.037
START AS A SUBCOMMITTEE.
00:20:39.104 --> 00:20:44.309
SYSTEM WORKING NOW [inaudible]
00:20:44.376 --> 00:21:00.492
IT IS
00:21:15.173 --> 00:21:15.340
[inaudible]
00:21:15.407 --> 00:21:19.511
REMEMBER [inaudible]
00:21:19.578 --> 00:21:36.495
A FIVE WE DON'T
00:21:43.435 --> 00:21:58.784
-- OKAY GOOD
00:21:58.850 --> 00:22:00.118
AFTERNOON WE'RE GONNA START IS
00:22:00.185 --> 00:22:00.686
SUBCOMMITTEE WE'RE GONNA GO
00:22:00.752 --> 00:22:05.490
AHEAD HERE -- GOOD AFTERNOON.
00:22:05.557 --> 00:22:06.825
I AM CALLING THIS HEARING OF THE
00:22:06.892 --> 00:22:08.160
ASSEMBLY EDUCATION COMMITTEE TO
00:22:08.226 --> 00:22:09.761
ORDER AS A SUBCOMMITTEE ONLY AT
00:22:09.828 --> 00:22:11.163
THIS TIME.
00:22:11.229 --> 00:22:12.064
BECAUSE WE DO NOT YET HAVE A
00:22:12.130 --> 00:22:15.667
QUORUM -- SO HOLD ON CALLING THE
00:22:15.734 --> 00:22:19.571
ROLL -- WE HAVE EIGHT BILLS ON
00:22:19.638 --> 00:22:21.173
THE AGENDA TODAY INCLUDING THREE
00:22:21.239 --> 00:22:22.374
ON CONSENT.
00:22:22.441 --> 00:22:23.742
THE MEASURES ON CONSENT ARE AS
00:22:23.809 --> 00:22:28.146
FOLLOWS SB ONE SEVENTY FOUR SB.
00:22:28.213 --> 00:22:31.216
FIVE EIGHTY TWO AND SB -- STR.
00:22:31.283 --> 00:22:35.187
EIGHT WITH THAT -- WE ARE READY
00:22:35.253 --> 00:22:36.254
HAVE OUR FIRST AUTHOR.
00:22:36.321 --> 00:22:40.392
IT IS SENATOR PORTANTINO IT IS.
00:22:40.459 --> 00:22:42.861
WE'LL TAKE A BILL NUMBER --
00:22:42.928 --> 00:22:47.065
THREE TWENTY FIVE FIRST I GUESS --
00:22:47.132 --> 00:22:47.699
TWENTY EIGHT THREE TWENTY EIGHT
00:22:47.766 --> 00:22:51.169
IN ITS FINAL ORDER TO I BELIEVE
00:22:51.236 --> 00:22:51.403
I LOVE.
00:22:51.470 --> 00:22:53.939
PLAN NUMBER.
00:22:54.005 --> 00:22:55.640
TWO WHEN YOU MAY PROCEED WHEN
00:22:55.707 --> 00:22:56.875
READY -- CENTER YOU'RE RIGHT
00:22:56.942 --> 00:22:58.877
THERE GOOD THANK YOU CAN I WELL
00:22:58.944 --> 00:22:59.745
THAT'S FINE.
00:22:59.811 --> 00:23:03.982
WE'LL TAKE UP -- FILE.
00:23:04.049 --> 00:23:04.549
THREE TWENTY EIGHT FIRST I'M
00:23:04.616 --> 00:23:05.717
SORRY IT WILL TAKE UP TO TWENTY
00:23:05.784 --> 00:23:06.318
ABSOLUTELY I'M SORRY I CAN'T I
00:23:06.384 --> 00:23:07.586
CANNOT HEAR YOU.
00:23:07.652 --> 00:23:09.821
NO I WAS GONNA ASK YOU TO THE
00:23:09.888 --> 00:23:10.655
OTHER ONE FIRST BUT I'LL DO YOU
00:23:10.722 --> 00:23:11.623
WANT TO DO.
00:23:11.690 --> 00:23:13.291
YOU CHOOSE DON'T BOTHER ME.
00:23:13.358 --> 00:23:14.659
I LET'S DO -- LET'S JUST GO
00:23:14.726 --> 00:23:16.695
RIGHT.
00:23:16.762 --> 00:23:17.329
TO THREE TWENTY EIGHT THERE WERE
00:23:17.395 --> 00:23:18.130
THREE OF SB THREE TWENTY EIGHT
00:23:18.196 --> 00:23:20.031
FILE ITEM NUMBER.
00:23:20.098 --> 00:23:22.968
TWO THAT THAT GO.
00:23:23.034 --> 00:23:24.202
SO LET US FIRST ESTABLISH A
00:23:24.269 --> 00:23:26.738
QUORUM IF WE MAY SENATOR -- A
00:23:26.805 --> 00:23:28.607
SURGERY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
00:23:28.673 --> 00:23:30.909
O'DONNELL PRESENT O'DONNELL HERE
00:23:30.976 --> 00:23:32.644
KILEY KILEY HERE.
00:23:32.711 --> 00:23:33.512
DEEP.
00:23:33.578 --> 00:23:37.315
KALRA MCCARTY SMITH.
00:23:37.382 --> 00:23:38.150
SMITH HERE WEBER [inaudible]
00:23:38.216 --> 00:23:40.919
WEBER HERE.
00:23:40.986 --> 00:23:42.921
WE DO HAVE A CORE CORE HAS BEEN
00:23:42.988 --> 00:23:44.156
ESTABLISHED YOU MAY PROCEED WHEN
00:23:44.222 --> 00:23:47.092
READY WE'RE GONNA GO WITH SB
00:23:47.159 --> 00:23:47.626
THREE TWENTY EIGHT FIRST I
00:23:47.692 --> 00:23:48.193
BELIEVE.
00:23:48.260 --> 00:23:49.461
A MAYBE YOU MAY PERCY.
00:23:49.528 --> 00:23:51.463
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR AND
00:23:51.530 --> 00:23:55.567
MEMBERS -- I AM PROUD TO PRESENT
00:23:55.634 --> 00:23:56.501
SB.
00:23:56.568 --> 00:23:58.503
THREE TWENTY EIGHT TODAY ON
00:23:58.570 --> 00:24:00.172
SCHOOL START TIME.
00:24:00.238 --> 00:24:01.973
TEENAGERS IN OUR COUNTRY FRANKLY
00:24:02.040 --> 00:24:03.542
ARE SLEEP DEPRIVED.
00:24:03.608 --> 00:24:04.709
IT'S A PUBLIC HEALTH SEPARATE
00:24:04.776 --> 00:24:07.712
EPIDEMIC AND ACCORDING TO
00:24:07.779 --> 00:24:09.114
CONCLUSIVE MEDICAL RESEARCH.
00:24:09.181 --> 00:24:10.315
THE PRIMARY CAUSE OF THE
00:24:10.382 --> 00:24:12.517
EPIDEMIC IS EARLY SCHOOL START
00:24:12.584 --> 00:24:14.719
TIMES THAT ARE NOT ALIGNED WITH
00:24:14.786 --> 00:24:16.655
THE BIOLOGICAL SLEEP NEEDS OF
00:24:16.721 --> 00:24:19.457
ADOLESCENT CHILDREN -- SB THREE
00:24:19.524 --> 00:24:20.292
TWENTY EIGHT WILL UPDATE THE
00:24:20.358 --> 00:24:21.860
CALIFORNIA EDUCATION CODE.
00:24:21.927 --> 00:24:24.062
WITH A PUBLIC HEALTH PARAMETERS
00:24:24.129 --> 00:24:24.696
FOR MIDDLE AND HIGH SCHOOL START
00:24:24.763 --> 00:24:25.463
TIMES.
00:24:25.530 --> 00:24:28.600
THE REGULAR SCHOOL DAYS BEGAN AT
00:24:28.667 --> 00:24:29.167
EIGHT THIRTY AM OR LATER FOR
00:24:29.234 --> 00:24:30.202
HIGH SCHOOLS.
00:24:30.268 --> 00:24:32.571
AND EIGHT AM OR LATER FOR MIDDLE
00:24:32.637 --> 00:24:34.172
SCHOOLS THAT IS A DIFFERENCE
00:24:34.239 --> 00:24:36.341
FROM LAST YEAR'S A BILL AND WE
00:24:36.408 --> 00:24:38.443
THINK IT'S ACTUALLY A VERY GOOD
00:24:38.510 --> 00:24:40.278
AMENDMENT.
00:24:40.345 --> 00:24:41.246
FROM LAST YEAR AND MAKES THE
00:24:41.313 --> 00:24:42.814
BILL -- BETTER BECAUSE IT
00:24:42.881 --> 00:24:44.683
RESPECTS THE SCIENCE BUT GIVES
00:24:44.749 --> 00:24:46.451
LOCAL DISTRICTS FLEXIBILITY
00:24:46.518 --> 00:24:47.586
BETWEEN THEIR MIDDLE SCHOOLS AND
00:24:47.652 --> 00:24:49.554
THEIR HIGH SCHOOLS AND THAT WAS
00:24:49.621 --> 00:24:51.056
A SUGGESTION THAT CAME UP AND WE
00:24:51.122 --> 00:24:52.924
THOUGHT IT WAS PRUDENT SO WE
00:24:52.991 --> 00:24:54.593
INCORPORATED INTO THE BILL --
00:24:54.659 --> 00:24:56.962
THIS COMES FROM A RECOMMENDATION
00:24:57.028 --> 00:24:58.263
FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF
00:24:58.330 --> 00:25:00.232
PEDIATRICS THE CENTERS FOR
00:25:00.298 --> 00:25:01.867
DISEASE CONTROL AND PREVENTION
00:25:01.933 --> 00:25:04.236
AND MANY HELL OTHER HEALTH AND
00:25:04.302 --> 00:25:05.403
MEDICAL ORGANIZATIONS.
00:25:05.470 --> 00:25:07.339
DESPITE DECADES OF OVERWHELMING
00:25:07.405 --> 00:25:09.007
AND COMPELLING EVIDENCE OF THE
00:25:09.074 --> 00:25:11.276
HARM TO TEENS FROM EARLY WAKE UP
00:25:11.343 --> 00:25:12.210
TIMES.
00:25:12.277 --> 00:25:13.511
THE VAST MAJORITIES OF
00:25:13.578 --> 00:25:14.880
CALIFORNIA SECONDARY SCHOOLS
00:25:14.946 --> 00:25:17.849
ABOUT 80% STILL BEGIN BEFORE
00:25:17.916 --> 00:25:18.850
EIGHT THIRTY AM.
00:25:18.917 --> 00:25:21.386
SO THAT THEY PREVENT MOST TEENS
00:25:21.453 --> 00:25:23.755
FROM GETTING. TO THE GETTING THE
00:25:23.822 --> 00:25:26.691
DOCTOR RECOMMENDED -- SLEEP FOR
00:25:26.758 --> 00:25:28.727
GROWING BODIES AND BRAINS.
00:25:28.793 --> 00:25:30.428
ACCORDING TO THE CDC THE AVERAGE
00:25:30.495 --> 00:25:32.230
SECONDARY SCHOOL START TIME IN
00:25:32.297 --> 00:25:34.065
CALIFORNIA IS.
00:25:34.132 --> 00:25:34.666
EIGHT OH SEVEN AND MANY START
00:25:34.733 --> 00:25:37.535
FIRST PERIOD -- WELL BEFORE.
00:25:37.602 --> 00:25:38.403
SEVEN THIRTY EARLY SECONDARY
00:25:38.470 --> 00:25:40.138
SCHOOL START TIMES FRANKLY HARM
00:25:40.205 --> 00:25:41.673
CHILDREN'S HEALTH AND SAFETY IN
00:25:41.740 --> 00:25:42.807
MANY WAYS.
00:25:42.874 --> 00:25:44.042
INSUFFICIENCY LEAP AMONG
00:25:44.109 --> 00:25:46.044
ADOLESCENTS CAUSES HIGHER RATES
00:25:46.111 --> 00:25:48.780
OF DEPRESSION ANXIETY SUICIDAL
00:25:48.847 --> 00:25:50.749
THOUGHTS ACTIONS BEHAVIOR
00:25:50.815 --> 00:25:53.385
PROBLEMS OBESITY DIABETES.
00:25:53.451 --> 00:25:55.320
DROWSY DRIVING A CAR ACCIDENT
00:25:55.387 --> 00:25:57.389
SUBSTANCE ABUSE AND SPORTS
00:25:57.455 --> 00:25:58.423
INJURIES.
00:25:58.490 --> 00:25:59.524
THESE EARLY SCHOOL HOURS ARE
00:25:59.591 --> 00:26:00.825
CONTRIBUTING FACTORS TO THE
00:26:00.892 --> 00:26:02.827
NUMBER ONE AND NUMBER TWO CAUSE
00:26:02.894 --> 00:26:03.995
OF DEATH AMONG YOUNG PEOPLE LET
00:26:04.062 --> 00:26:07.132
pTHESE EARLY SCHOOL HOURS ARE
00:26:07.198 --> 00:26:08.934
CONTRIBUTING FACTORS TO THE
00:26:09.000 --> 00:26:10.635
NUMBER ONE AND NUMBER TWO CAUSES
00:26:10.702 --> 00:26:13.605
OF DEATH AMONG YOUNG PEOPLE.
00:26:13.672 --> 00:26:14.372
ARE ACCIDENTS AND SUICIDE.
00:26:14.439 --> 00:26:15.941
I DON'T WANT TO READ.
00:26:16.007 --> 00:26:18.643
ABOUT ANYMORE TEENAGERS -- WHO
00:26:18.710 --> 00:26:20.245
HAVE TRIED FOR OF SUCCEEDED IN
00:26:20.312 --> 00:26:21.513
TAKING THEIR OWN LIFE I JUST
00:26:21.579 --> 00:26:23.048
DON'T WANT TO READ THAT ANYMORE?
00:26:23.114 --> 00:26:24.215
AND WE BELIEVE THIS BILL WILL
00:26:24.282 --> 00:26:25.517
HELP.
00:26:25.583 --> 00:26:27.786
STEM THOSE -- SUICIDE --
00:26:27.852 --> 00:26:29.220
THOUGHTS AND OCCURRENCES.
00:26:29.287 --> 00:26:31.589
THE STATUS QUO ALSO CAUSES WORSE
00:26:31.656 --> 00:26:33.825
ACADEMIC OUTCOMES RESEARCH SHOWS
00:26:33.892 --> 00:26:35.527
THAT SLEEP DEPRIVATION AMONG
00:26:35.593 --> 00:26:37.028
ADOLESCENTS STUDENTS.
00:26:37.095 --> 00:26:38.663
BECAUSE A SLEEPING IN CLASS
00:26:38.730 --> 00:26:39.965
DIFFICULTY PAYING ATTENTION
00:26:40.031 --> 00:26:42.567
FORGETFULNESS MORE ABSENCES MORE
00:26:42.634 --> 00:26:45.203
TARDY'S MORE DISCIPLINARY ACTION --
00:26:45.270 --> 00:26:47.706
WORSE GRADES AND TEST SCORES AND
00:26:47.772 --> 00:26:49.007
HIGHER DROPOUT RATES.
00:26:49.074 --> 00:26:50.742
AND THE STATUS QUO IS ACTUALLY
00:26:50.809 --> 00:26:52.477
WIDENING THE ACHIEVEMENT GAPS
00:26:52.544 --> 00:26:53.445
AND HEALTH DISPARITIES IN OUR
00:26:53.511 --> 00:26:55.113
STATE BECAUSE EARLY STARTS ARE
00:26:55.180 --> 00:26:56.915
PROVEN TO HER DISADVANTAGED
00:26:56.982 --> 00:26:57.382
CHILDREN.
00:26:57.449 --> 00:27:00.085
THE MOST MANY STUDIES SHOW THAT
00:27:00.151 --> 00:27:01.987
DISADVANTAGED CHILDREN ALREADY
00:27:02.053 --> 00:27:02.787
GET LESS SLEEP THAN THEIR MORE
00:27:02.854 --> 00:27:04.990
PRIVILEGE PEERS AND THEY FACE
00:27:05.056 --> 00:27:06.925
MORE OBSTACLES GETTING. TO EARLY
00:27:06.992 --> 00:27:08.426
BELLS ON TIME AND ARE
00:27:08.493 --> 00:27:10.161
DISPROPORTIONATELY AFFECTED BY
00:27:10.228 --> 00:27:11.529
THE HARM OF DEVELOPMENTALLY
00:27:11.596 --> 00:27:13.198
INAPPROPRIATE START TIMES.
00:27:13.264 --> 00:27:15.433
THE GOOD NEWS IS THAT ACCORDING
00:27:15.500 --> 00:27:17.836
TO THE CDC LATER START TIME
00:27:17.902 --> 00:27:19.771
SEARCH THE SINGLE MOST COST
00:27:19.838 --> 00:27:20.271
EFFECTIVE PUBLIC HEALTH
00:27:20.338 --> 00:27:21.339
INTERVENTION.
00:27:21.406 --> 00:27:22.907
WITH THE POTENTIAL TO HELP THE
00:27:22.974 --> 00:27:24.709
LARGEST NUMBER OF CHILDREN TO
00:27:24.776 --> 00:27:26.511
COMBAT THE ADOLESCENT SLEEP LOSS
00:27:26.578 --> 00:27:27.512
EPIDEMIC.
00:27:27.579 --> 00:27:29.247
THERE'S EXPANSIVE AS EVIDENCE
00:27:29.314 --> 00:27:30.582
SPANNING DECADES THAT WHEN
00:27:30.648 --> 00:27:33.485
SCHOOL STARTLING SKIT MORE SLEEP.
00:27:33.551 --> 00:27:35.720
THEY'RE HEALTHIER HAPPIER LESS
00:27:35.787 --> 00:27:37.622
LIKELY TO CONTEMPLATE SUICIDE
00:27:37.689 --> 00:27:38.690
LESS LIKELY TO GET IN THE CAR
00:27:38.757 --> 00:27:40.158
ACCIDENTS THERE TENANTS GOES UP
00:27:40.225 --> 00:27:41.593
THE GRADES GO UP.
00:27:41.659 --> 00:27:43.194
AND GRADUATION RATES GO UP AND
00:27:43.261 --> 00:27:44.863
IN CALIFORNIA INCREASED
00:27:44.929 --> 00:27:46.031
ATTENDANCE MEANS INCREASED
00:27:46.097 --> 00:27:47.966
AVERAGE DAILY ATTENDANCE FUNDS
00:27:48.033 --> 00:27:50.802
TO SCHOOLS -- AND AS IF THAT
00:27:50.869 --> 00:27:51.836
WEREN'T ENOUGH THE RAND
00:27:51.903 --> 00:27:53.171
CORPORATION PROJECTS THAT
00:27:53.238 --> 00:27:55.006
CALIFORNIA'S ECONOMY WILL GROW
00:27:55.073 --> 00:27:56.541
BY ABOUT ONE BILLION DOLLARS A
00:27:56.608 --> 00:27:57.909
YEAR OVER THE NEXT.
00:27:57.976 --> 00:27:59.811
DECADE AS A RESULT OF HIGHER
00:27:59.878 --> 00:28:01.679
GRADUATION RATES FEWER CAR
00:28:01.746 --> 00:28:03.281
ACCIDENTS WOULD LATER START AND
00:28:03.348 --> 00:28:05.383
OTHER COMPLICATIONS FROM OUR
00:28:05.450 --> 00:28:06.985
CURRENT EARLY START TIMES.
00:28:07.052 --> 00:28:08.787
AND EVERY YEAR THE EVIDENCE JUST
00:28:08.853 --> 00:28:09.988
KEEPS AMOUNTING.
00:28:10.055 --> 00:28:11.289
A RECENT STUDY OF THE SEATTLE
00:28:11.356 --> 00:28:12.857
PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICTS A LARGE
00:28:12.924 --> 00:28:14.426
URBAN DISTRICT WHICH ADOPTED
00:28:14.492 --> 00:28:15.527
LATER START TIMES.
00:28:15.593 --> 00:28:17.829
CONFIRMED THE PREVIOUS FINDINGS
00:28:17.896 --> 00:28:19.330
WITH THE SHIFT A LATER START
00:28:19.397 --> 00:28:20.732
STUDENTS ARE GETTING MORE SLEEP
00:28:20.799 --> 00:28:22.834
GETTING BETTER GRADES AND
00:28:22.901 --> 00:28:24.402
ATTENDING SCHOOL MORE OFTEN.
00:28:24.469 --> 00:28:25.804
ATTENDANCE IMPROVE THE MOST THAT
00:28:25.870 --> 00:28:28.206
SCHOOLS WITH THE MOST LOW INCOME
00:28:28.273 --> 00:28:29.340
STUDENTS COMEY SAID AGAIN
00:28:29.407 --> 00:28:31.276
TENANTS IMPROVED AT THE SCHOOLS
00:28:31.342 --> 00:28:31.810
WITH THE MOST LOW INCOME
00:28:31.876 --> 00:28:32.710
STUDENTS.
00:28:32.777 --> 00:28:33.945
STUDENT ATHLETES ARE BIG
00:28:34.012 --> 00:28:35.580
BENEFICIARIES OF HEALTHY SCHOOL
00:28:35.647 --> 00:28:37.382
START TIMES AS WELL ACCORDING TO
00:28:37.449 --> 00:28:39.250
RESEARCH WELL RESTED STUDENT
00:28:39.317 --> 00:28:40.819
ATHLETES PERFORM BETTERIN THEIR
00:28:40.885 --> 00:28:41.453
SPORT.
00:28:41.519 --> 00:28:43.922
AND GET INJURED LESS OFTEN.
00:28:43.988 --> 00:28:47.592
WE KNOW THAT HEALTHY SCHOOL
00:28:47.659 --> 00:28:48.326
HOURS.
00:28:48.393 --> 00:28:49.027
WE KNOW THAT HEALTHY SCHOOL
00:28:49.094 --> 00:28:50.428
HOURS THERE ARE HUNDREDS OF WELL
00:28:50.495 --> 00:28:50.962
RUN SCHOOL DISTRICTS A CUT
00:28:51.029 --> 00:28:52.130
ACROSS THE NATION THAT THRIVE
00:28:52.197 --> 00:28:53.665
WITH LATER AGE APPROPRIATE START
00:28:53.731 --> 00:28:54.566
TIMES.
00:28:54.632 --> 00:28:55.867
AT THEIR MIDDLE AND HIGH SCHOOLS
00:28:55.934 --> 00:28:57.268
THEY HAVE HEALTHIER AND SAFER
00:28:57.335 --> 00:28:59.204
STUDENTS AND SUCCESSFUL SPORTS
00:28:59.270 --> 00:29:01.339
PROGRAM THE DATA AND EVIDENCE IS
00:29:01.406 --> 00:29:02.340
COMPELLING.
00:29:02.407 --> 00:29:03.408
EARLY MIDDLE AND HIGH SCHOOL
00:29:03.475 --> 00:29:04.809
START TIMES CLOSE A PUBLIC
00:29:04.876 --> 00:29:06.644
HEALTH AND SAFETY RISKS TO OUR
00:29:06.711 --> 00:29:07.412
STATE YOU.
00:29:07.479 --> 00:29:09.481
AND FRANKLY I JUST THINK IT'S
00:29:09.547 --> 00:29:12.050
TIME DID YOU PUT THAT DATA AND
00:29:12.117 --> 00:29:13.818
THE RESEARCH AND THE RESULTS TO
00:29:13.885 --> 00:29:15.753
USE AND HELP THESE KIDS.
00:29:15.820 --> 00:29:16.788
THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
00:29:16.855 --> 00:29:18.590
FREQUENTLY SETS HEALTH AND
00:29:18.656 --> 00:29:20.125
SAFETY STANDARDS FOR OUR PUBLIC
00:29:20.191 --> 00:29:22.160
EDUCATION SYSTEM. FOR EXAMPLE
00:29:22.227 --> 00:29:24.095
ONE SCIENTIFIC EVIDENCE REVEALED
00:29:24.162 --> 00:29:25.864
THE DANGERS OF ASBESTOS LEAD
00:29:25.930 --> 00:29:28.666
PAINT SMOKING -- IMMUNIZATION --
00:29:28.733 --> 00:29:30.969
THE LEGISLATURE ACTED TO PROTECT
00:29:31.035 --> 00:29:32.103
KIDS.
00:29:32.170 --> 00:29:34.272
SO TO THE LEGISLATURE CAN AND
00:29:34.339 --> 00:29:35.373
SHOULD ACT IN ACCORDANCE WITH
00:29:35.440 --> 00:29:37.275
ITS AUTHORITY AND RESPONSIBILITY
00:29:37.342 --> 00:29:39.210
TO PROTECT CALIFORNIA'S SIX
00:29:39.277 --> 00:29:40.812
MILLION PUBLIC SCHOOL CHILDREN.
00:29:40.879 --> 00:29:43.281
FROM A PUBLIC HEALTH RISK SO.
00:29:43.348 --> 00:29:44.749
OBVIOUSLY WHEN APPROPRIATE I
00:29:44.816 --> 00:29:46.651
WOULD RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN
00:29:46.718 --> 00:29:48.553
AYE VOTE WITH ME TODAY I HAVE DR
00:29:48.620 --> 00:29:50.155
RAFAEL PALLADIO FROM STANFORD
00:29:50.221 --> 00:29:51.856
UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF MEDICINE.
00:29:51.923 --> 00:29:53.525
I HAVE JOY WAKE FROM START
00:29:53.591 --> 00:29:56.628
SCHOOL LATER AND I HAVE DR ANOOP
00:29:56.694 --> 00:29:58.429
CURRY POT A CHILD PSYCHIATRIST
00:29:58.496 --> 00:29:59.931
WITH SCRIPTS HEALTH AND
00:29:59.998 --> 00:30:01.299
PRESIDENT OF THE CALIFORNIA
00:30:01.366 --> 00:30:03.501
SLEEP SOCIETY. TO MAKE OUR CASE
00:30:03.568 --> 00:30:06.905
SO I WOULD RESPECTFULLY ASK THEM
00:30:06.971 --> 00:30:07.505
TO HAVE THE TIME TO MAKE THEIR
00:30:07.572 --> 00:30:09.440
CASE.
00:30:09.507 --> 00:30:11.075
I YOUR FIRST WITNESS I BELIEVE
00:30:11.142 --> 00:30:12.577
YOU HAVE SIX MINUTES SO I YOU
00:30:12.644 --> 00:30:14.779
MAY HAVE CUT IT UP ANY ANYWHERE
00:30:14.846 --> 00:30:18.049
YOU DESIRE SO THERE YOU'RE.
00:30:18.116 --> 00:30:19.484
NOT USED AT ALL.
00:30:19.551 --> 00:30:20.285
THANK YOU.
00:30:20.351 --> 00:30:20.919
GOOD AFTERNOON AND THANK YOU FOR
00:30:20.985 --> 00:30:21.953
THIS OPPORTUNITY I'M A PROFESSOR
00:30:22.020 --> 00:30:22.453
AND PHYSICIAN I STANFORD
00:30:22.520 --> 00:30:23.922
UNIVERSITY. TOO MANY HOUSEHOLDS
00:30:23.988 --> 00:30:25.390
BEGIN THE DAY WITH A STRUGGLE TO
00:30:25.456 --> 00:30:26.858
GET THEIR TEENS OUT OF BED.
00:30:26.925 --> 00:30:28.026
AND IT ENDED A WITHIN ARGUED
00:30:28.092 --> 00:30:30.094
ABOUT GOING TO SLEEP.
00:30:30.161 --> 00:30:30.995
SB THREE TWENTY ACRES PARENTS
00:30:31.062 --> 00:30:32.530
AND STUDENTS MORE CONTROL OVER
00:30:32.597 --> 00:30:33.932
THEIR HEALTH.
00:30:33.998 --> 00:30:34.966
THE EVIDENCEIS CLEAR AND
00:30:35.033 --> 00:30:36.034
OVERWHELMING THERE ARE LESSONS
00:30:36.100 --> 00:30:37.202
ARE SUFFERING FROM HARMFUL
00:30:37.268 --> 00:30:38.536
CHRONIC SLEEP DEPRIVATION.
00:30:38.603 --> 00:30:39.537
EARLY SCHOOL START TIMES ARE
00:30:39.604 --> 00:30:41.206
PROVING TO BE MODIFIABLE
00:30:41.272 --> 00:30:42.407
CONTRIBUTOR TO THEIR SLEEP
00:30:42.473 --> 00:30:43.875
DEPRIVATION.
00:30:43.942 --> 00:30:45.043
SCIENCE TEACHES US THAT OUR
00:30:45.109 --> 00:30:45.577
LESSONS ARE PARTICULARLY
00:30:45.643 --> 00:30:46.978
VULNERABLE TO SLEEP DEPRIVATION
00:30:47.045 --> 00:30:48.580
BECAUSE THERE'S A BIOLOGICAL
00:30:48.646 --> 00:30:49.914
SHIFT IN THEIR BRAINS RHYTHMS.
00:30:49.981 --> 00:30:52.417
MOST TEENS CAN'T JUST GO TO
00:30:52.483 --> 00:30:53.618
SLEEP EARLIER.
00:30:53.685 --> 00:30:54.385
THE AMERICAN CARRY PEDIATRICS
00:30:54.452 --> 00:30:55.386
HAS DETERMINED THAT EARLY SCHOOL
00:30:55.453 --> 00:30:58.723
START TIMES PREVENTS MOST TEENS
00:30:58.790 --> 00:30:59.357
FROM GETTING HEALTHY SLEEP THEY
00:30:59.424 --> 00:30:59.991
NEED.
00:31:00.058 --> 00:31:03.161
A SCIENTIFIC REVIEW OF NEARLY
00:31:03.228 --> 00:31:03.761
SIX HUNDRED THOUSAND TEENAGERS
00:31:03.828 --> 00:31:04.829
HAS FOUND THAT TO SLEEP DURATION
00:31:04.896 --> 00:31:06.998
IS AN INDEPENDENT RISK FACTOR.
00:31:07.065 --> 00:31:08.800
FOR DEVELOPMENT OF SUICIDALITY.
00:31:08.866 --> 00:31:10.101
THE LOWEST RISK IS FOR STEVE
00:31:10.168 --> 00:31:11.869
DURATIONS OF EIGHT TO NINE HOURS.
00:31:11.936 --> 00:31:13.771
MOST TEENAGERS ARE LUCKY TO EVEN
00:31:13.838 --> 00:31:15.673
GET SEVEN HOURS ON SCHOOL NIGHTS.
00:31:15.740 --> 00:31:16.874
SCHOOL ADMINISTRATIONS OF PUSH
00:31:16.941 --> 00:31:18.710
SCHOOLS TO START TOO EARLY.
00:31:18.776 --> 00:31:19.611
THIS HAS LED TO PHYSICAL AND
00:31:19.677 --> 00:31:21.546
MENTAL HEALTH PROBLEMS INCLUDING
00:31:21.613 --> 00:31:23.948
INCREASED CAR ACCIDENTS.
00:31:24.015 --> 00:31:24.916
ALL OF YOU PROBABLY KNOW
00:31:24.983 --> 00:31:26.050
TEENAGERS ON ANTI DEPRESSANTS
00:31:26.117 --> 00:31:27.619
SLEEPER RESTORED TO BRING IN
00:31:27.685 --> 00:31:29.087
HEELS THE MIND.
00:31:29.153 --> 00:31:29.654
THESE KIDS BRAINS ARE STILL
00:31:29.721 --> 00:31:32.257
DEVELOPING.
00:31:32.323 --> 00:31:33.591
THE GOOD NEWS IS THAT RESEARCH
00:31:33.658 --> 00:31:34.459
HAS CONSISTENTLY SHOWN THAT
00:31:34.525 --> 00:31:35.727
DELAYING TO SCHOOL START TIME IS
00:31:35.793 --> 00:31:36.294
IMPROVE THE WELL BEING OF
00:31:36.361 --> 00:31:37.495
TEENAGERS.
00:31:37.562 --> 00:31:38.696
THE BIOLOGY OF THE STEEP CANNOT
00:31:38.763 --> 00:31:39.864
CONTINUE BE TREATED AS AN
00:31:39.931 --> 00:31:41.466
INCONVENIENCE.
00:31:41.532 --> 00:31:42.634
THIS STATE IS NOT BEING ASKED A
00:31:42.700 --> 00:31:43.768
SET SCHEDULE FOR INDIVIDUAL
00:31:43.835 --> 00:31:44.969
DISTRICTS.
00:31:45.036 --> 00:31:46.571
THE STATE ASSEMBLY BEING ASKED
00:31:46.638 --> 00:31:47.839
TO ESTABLISH A FLOOR AND HOW
00:31:47.905 --> 00:31:49.607
EARLY SCHOOLS CAN FORCE
00:31:49.674 --> 00:31:51.142
TEENAGERS TO BE IN CLASS.
00:31:51.209 --> 00:31:53.344
LET THERE BE NO DOUBT THE WEIGHT
00:31:53.411 --> 00:31:54.746
OF THE EVIDENCE IS SO COMPELLING
00:31:54.812 --> 00:31:56.147
THE PROFESSIONAL HELP SOCIETIES
00:31:56.214 --> 00:31:57.315
ARE CALLING FOR ACTION.
00:31:57.382 --> 00:31:58.950
THE AMERICAN OKAY PEDIATRICS
00:31:59.017 --> 00:32:00.518
STANFORD CHILDREN'S HOSPITAL THE
00:32:00.585 --> 00:32:01.319
AMERICAN ACADEMY OF SLEEP
00:32:01.386 --> 00:32:02.854
MEDICINE THE NATIONAL SLEEP
00:32:02.920 --> 00:32:04.255
FOUNDATION CALIFORNIA ZIP
00:32:04.322 --> 00:32:05.390
SOCIETY AMONG SEVERAL OTHER
00:32:05.456 --> 00:32:06.958
ORGANIZATIONS INCLUDING LAW
00:32:07.025 --> 00:32:08.359
ENFORCEMENT.
00:32:08.426 --> 00:32:09.027
AGREED AT THIS BILL IS THE RIGHT
00:32:09.093 --> 00:32:09.827
THING TO DO.
00:32:09.894 --> 00:32:11.462
THERE ARE ZERO HEALTH
00:32:11.529 --> 00:32:13.731
ORGANIZATIONS OPPOSING THIS BILL.
00:32:13.798 --> 00:32:14.966
NOT A SINGLE.
00:32:15.033 --> 00:32:16.167
ONE NOW YOU HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY
00:32:16.234 --> 00:32:17.235
TO TRANSLATE THE SCIENCES THE
00:32:17.302 --> 00:32:19.003
SOUND PUBLIC HEALTH POLICY AND
00:32:19.070 --> 00:32:20.038
SEND THE MESSAGE THAT WE VALUE
00:32:20.104 --> 00:32:21.172
HEALTH OF OUR CHILDREN OF ALL OF
00:32:21.239 --> 00:32:22.206
THE CONCERNS.
00:32:22.273 --> 00:32:25.043
PLEASE GIVE THESE GUYS A BREAK
00:32:25.109 --> 00:32:27.578
AND LET THEM SLEEP THANK YOU.
00:32:27.645 --> 00:32:28.746
THANK YOU EVEN FOR KIDS WITH
00:32:28.813 --> 00:32:29.881
GOOD SLEEP HABITS EARLY SCHOOL
00:32:29.947 --> 00:32:31.649
START TIMES MANDATE THAT MOST
00:32:31.716 --> 00:32:33.217
TEENS WAKE UP AT TIMES THAT
00:32:33.284 --> 00:32:35.019
DOCTORS SAY INCREASE THE RISK
00:32:35.086 --> 00:32:36.688
FOR MANY ILLNESSES SUICIDE AND
00:32:36.754 --> 00:32:37.689
ACCIDENTS.
00:32:37.755 --> 00:32:39.057
I'M SURE WE WOULD ALL LIKE TO
00:32:39.123 --> 00:32:40.291
THINK THAT CHILDREN'S HEALTH AND
00:32:40.358 --> 00:32:41.426
SAFETY IS THE NUMBER ONE
00:32:41.492 --> 00:32:42.627
PRIORITY IN OUR PUBLIC EDUCATION
00:32:42.694 --> 00:32:43.828
SYSTEM.
00:32:43.895 --> 00:32:45.263
BUT IN THIS CASE AT SOME
00:32:45.330 --> 00:32:47.432
DISTRICTS IT ISN'T PRIORITIZED.
00:32:47.498 --> 00:32:49.300
THOSE IN THE SYSTEM WITH A STAKE
00:32:49.367 --> 00:32:51.235
IN THE STATUS QUO HAVE TOLD YOU
00:32:51.302 --> 00:32:52.570
ALL OF THE MANY ADMINISTRATIVE
00:32:52.637 --> 00:32:54.739
OBJECTIVES THAT THEY VALUE MORE
00:32:54.806 --> 00:32:56.174
THAN THE HEALTHY SCHOOL START
00:32:56.240 --> 00:32:58.710
TIMES FOR TEENS.
00:32:58.776 --> 00:33:02.146
THAT'S WHY OUR CHILDREN NEED SB.
00:33:02.213 --> 00:33:03.047
THREE TWENTY EIGHT CURRENTLY
00:33:03.114 --> 00:33:04.449
SCHOOL DISTRICTS CAN DISREGARD
00:33:04.515 --> 00:33:06.050
THIS HEALTH AND MEDICAL POLICY
00:33:06.117 --> 00:33:07.985
GUIDELINES AND CONTINUE TO HARM
00:33:08.052 --> 00:33:09.454
THE PUBLIC HEALTH OF TEENS WITH
00:33:09.520 --> 00:33:11.389
DEVELOPMENTALLY INAPPROPRIATE
00:33:11.456 --> 00:33:12.423
SCHOOL HOURS.
00:33:12.490 --> 00:33:13.925
THE STATE WIDE POLICY IS THE
00:33:13.991 --> 00:33:15.226
REMEDY.
00:33:15.293 --> 00:33:17.028
AND IT'S NECESSARY BECAUSE
00:33:17.095 --> 00:33:19.230
ADOLESCENT SLEEP DEPRIVATION IS
00:33:19.297 --> 00:33:21.099
A PUBLIC HEALTH EPIDEMIC WHOSE
00:33:21.165 --> 00:33:24.902
PRIMARY MODIFIABLE BECAUSE IS
00:33:24.969 --> 00:33:26.904
THIS PUBLIC EDUCATION POLICY.
00:33:26.971 --> 00:33:28.005
BECAUSE PUBERTY BECAUSE AFTER
00:33:28.072 --> 00:33:29.173
YOU READY KIDS NATURALLY STAY
00:33:29.240 --> 00:33:30.708
AWAKE LATER.
00:33:30.775 --> 00:33:32.243
EARLY SCHOOL START TIMES DEPRIVE
00:33:32.310 --> 00:33:34.612
MOST TEENS OF THE STATE THAT
00:33:34.679 --> 00:33:35.246
THEY'RE GOING BODIES AND BRAINS
00:33:35.313 --> 00:33:35.980
NEED.
00:33:36.047 --> 00:33:38.116
OUR CHILDREN SLEEP HEALTH HAS
00:33:38.182 --> 00:33:38.750
FALLEN THROUGH A RESPONSIBILITY
00:33:38.816 --> 00:33:39.183
GAP.
00:33:39.250 --> 00:33:40.551
DEFAULTING THIS IMPORTANT
00:33:40.618 --> 00:33:42.153
STATEWIDE PUBLIC HEALTH MATTER
00:33:42.220 --> 00:33:43.654
TO OVER FIVE HUNDRED INDIVIDUAL
00:33:43.721 --> 00:33:45.556
SCHOOL BOARDS HAS PROVEN
00:33:45.623 --> 00:33:46.958
DETRIMENTAL TO CHILDREN.
00:33:47.024 --> 00:33:48.559
AFFECTING CHANGE AT THE LOCAL
00:33:48.626 --> 00:33:50.161
LEVEL HAS PROVEN VERY DIFFICULT
00:33:50.228 --> 00:33:51.763
BECAUSE ALL OF THE STRUCTURAL
00:33:51.829 --> 00:33:53.297
BARRIERS THAT EXIST THERE. FOR
00:33:53.364 --> 00:33:55.066
EXAMPLE MANY SCHOOL BOARDS DON'T
00:33:55.133 --> 00:33:57.502
ACTUALLY HAVE THE FINAL SAY ON
00:33:57.568 --> 00:33:58.970
WHAT TIMES ARE SCHOOL START
00:33:59.036 --> 00:34:00.204
BECAUSE OF CONTRACT LANGUAGE
00:34:00.271 --> 00:34:01.706
WITH BARGAINING GROUPS WE
00:34:01.773 --> 00:34:03.141
SUPPORT COLLECTIVE BARGAINING
00:34:03.207 --> 00:34:04.675
BUT NOT FOR OUR KIDS HEALTH IS
00:34:04.742 --> 00:34:05.943
JUST TOO IMPORTANT.
00:34:06.010 --> 00:34:07.445
AND ALTHOUGH ELLIE GAYS ARE
00:34:07.512 --> 00:34:09.213
ACCOUNTABLE FOR A LOT THEY ARE
00:34:09.280 --> 00:34:10.882
NOT ACCOUNTABLE FOR INCREASING
00:34:10.948 --> 00:34:13.551
TEEN SLEEP OR DECREASING DROWSY
00:34:13.618 --> 00:34:15.153
DRIVING ACCIDENTS ETCETERA.
00:34:15.219 --> 00:34:16.654
SO THE MANY EDUCATIONAL
00:34:16.721 --> 00:34:17.922
OBJECTIVES OVER WHICH SCHOOL
00:34:17.989 --> 00:34:19.190
BOARDS ARE ACCOUNTABLE GET
00:34:19.257 --> 00:34:20.792
PRIORITIZED.
00:34:20.858 --> 00:34:21.859
BUT THE LEGISLATURE ON THE OTHER
00:34:21.926 --> 00:34:24.128
HAND ALL OF YOU CLEARLY HAVE THE
00:34:24.195 --> 00:34:26.264
RESPONSIBILITY AND THE AUTHORITY
00:34:26.330 --> 00:34:27.498
TO PROTECT OUR STATE'S CHILDREN
00:34:27.565 --> 00:34:29.133
FROM KNOWN PUBLIC HEALTH AND
00:34:29.200 --> 00:34:31.202
SAFETY RISKS THE AD CODE IS
00:34:31.269 --> 00:34:32.737
FILLED WITH SUCH PROTECTIONS.
00:34:32.804 --> 00:34:33.871
AND BESIDES GIRLS ARE HARM TO
00:34:33.938 --> 00:34:36.207
MORE THAN BOYS FROM THE STATUS
00:34:36.274 --> 00:34:36.607
QUO.
00:34:36.674 --> 00:34:38.176
GIRLS ARE HARMED MORE BECAUSE
00:34:38.242 --> 00:34:39.577
THEY GO THEY GO THROUGH PUBERTY
00:34:39.644 --> 00:34:40.912
CERNER AND AFRICAN AMERICAN
00:34:40.978 --> 00:34:43.247
GIRLS ARE SPECIALLY HARM BECAUSE
00:34:43.314 --> 00:34:45.016
THEY GO PURITY GO THROUGH
00:34:45.082 --> 00:34:45.950
PUBERTY CENTER THAN WHITE GIRLS.
00:34:46.017 --> 00:34:47.385
WE BELIEVE EVERY CHILD DESERVES
00:34:47.452 --> 00:34:48.486
EQUAL PROTECTION FROM KNOWN
00:34:48.553 --> 00:34:50.521
PUBLIC HEALTH RISKS AND NO CHILD
00:34:50.588 --> 00:34:51.322
SHOULD HAVE THEIR HEALTH
00:34:51.389 --> 00:34:52.690
DETERMINED BY THEIR ZIP CODE
00:34:52.757 --> 00:34:54.625
INCOME LEVEL OUR RACE.
00:34:54.692 --> 00:34:56.828
WE TRULY UNDERSTAND THAT HEALTHY
00:34:56.894 --> 00:34:57.395
SCHOOL START TIMES WILL TAKE
00:34:57.462 --> 00:34:58.930
SOME EFFORT AND IN SOME CASES
00:34:58.996 --> 00:35:00.231
RESOURCES.
00:35:00.298 --> 00:35:01.833
BUT THE HEALTH AND WELL BEING OF
00:35:01.899 --> 00:35:05.002
SIX MILLION CALIFORNIA CHILDREN
00:35:05.069 --> 00:35:06.437
ARE WORTH THE EFFORT.
00:35:06.504 --> 00:35:07.038
MANY DISTRICTS NATIONWIDE HAD
00:35:07.104 --> 00:35:08.573
ALREADY PROVEN THAT YOU DON'T
00:35:08.639 --> 00:35:09.607
NEED TO HARM TEENS HEALTH AND
00:35:09.674 --> 00:35:10.942
SAFETY TO EFFICIENTLY ADMINISTER
00:35:11.008 --> 00:35:12.810
SCHOOL DISTRICT A TRANSPORTATION
00:35:12.877 --> 00:35:14.779
DEPARTMENT OR HAVE A THRIVING
00:35:14.846 --> 00:35:16.214
EXTRACURRICULAR PROGRAM.
00:35:16.280 --> 00:35:17.915
AS ADULTS IT IS OUR MORAL
00:35:17.982 --> 00:35:19.584
OBLIGATION TO PROTECT CHILDREN.
00:35:19.650 --> 00:35:21.619
AND AS ADULT LEADERS YOU HAVE
00:35:21.686 --> 00:35:23.621
THE POWER TO DO THAT.
00:35:23.688 --> 00:35:25.690
THANK YOU AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK
00:35:25.756 --> 00:35:28.125
YOUR THANK YOU. FOR YOUR SPEAK
00:35:28.192 --> 00:35:29.393
ABOUT A MINUTE SIR GOD YES THANK
00:35:29.460 --> 00:35:30.394
YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY I AM A
00:35:30.461 --> 00:35:32.163
PRACTICING PHYSICIAN IN SOUTHERN
00:35:32.230 --> 00:35:34.632
CALIFORNIA I'M A BOARD CERTIFIED
00:35:34.699 --> 00:35:37.435
PSYCHIATRIST I TYLER JOHNSON
00:35:37.502 --> 00:35:38.069
PSYCHIATRISTS IN THE PEDIATRIC
00:35:38.135 --> 00:35:39.737
SLEEP MEDICINE SPECIALIST.
00:35:39.804 --> 00:35:41.506
I'M ACTUALLY REPRESENTING THE
00:35:41.572 --> 00:35:42.573
CALIFORNIA ACADEMY OF TYLER
00:35:42.640 --> 00:35:44.408
DOZEN PSYCHIATRISTS THE
00:35:44.475 --> 00:35:45.710
CALIFORNIA PSYCHIATRIC
00:35:45.776 --> 00:35:50.815
ASSOCIATION AND THE CALIFORNIA
00:35:50.882 --> 00:35:51.382
SCHEDULES I DO WHAT I'M THE
00:35:51.449 --> 00:35:52.583
PRESIDENT.
00:35:52.650 --> 00:35:54.151
I HAVE.
00:35:54.218 --> 00:35:55.052
PRACTICE MEDICINE I'VE SEEN MY
00:35:55.119 --> 00:35:57.221
FIRSTHAND THE EFFECTS OF
00:35:57.288 --> 00:35:59.323
DECREASED SLEEP AND UNDER THE
00:35:59.390 --> 00:36:00.491
FOR SLEEP ON MENTAL HEALTH ALL
00:36:00.558 --> 00:36:02.760
OF THESE -- AS CHILDREN WITH THE
00:36:02.827 --> 00:36:03.661
MIDDLE SCHOOL AND HIGH SCHOOL
00:36:03.728 --> 00:36:04.662
I'VE SEEN THEM SOUTH OF WITH
00:36:04.729 --> 00:36:06.564
INCREASED ANXIETY ON BREAKING UP
00:36:06.631 --> 00:36:07.965
INCREASED DEPRESSION OFTEN
00:36:08.032 --> 00:36:09.400
HAVING IN ATTENTION FOCUSED
00:36:09.467 --> 00:36:11.269
ISSUES AND OFTEN GOING AND
00:36:11.335 --> 00:36:12.570
SLEEPING IN CLASS HAVING POOR
00:36:12.637 --> 00:36:13.137
SELF ESTEEM.
00:36:13.204 --> 00:36:14.405
BECAUSE THEY WERE NOT ABLE TO
00:36:14.472 --> 00:36:16.507
COPE WITH THE PRESSURES THEY
00:36:16.574 --> 00:36:18.042
OFTEN GET BIG PLEASE SOMEONE OF
00:36:18.109 --> 00:36:20.478
SLEEP THE NUMBER ONE ISSUE IN
00:36:20.545 --> 00:36:22.280
THIS FILM ARE DECREASED AND WANT
00:36:22.346 --> 00:36:23.648
OF SLEEP THAT THEY GET.
00:36:23.714 --> 00:36:24.982
THE MIDDLE SCHOOL AND HIGH
00:36:25.049 --> 00:36:26.984
SCHOOL KIDS HAVE TREMENDOUS
00:36:27.051 --> 00:36:28.619
STRESS ON TOP OF IT HAVING
00:36:28.686 --> 00:36:30.254
BECAUSE SOMEONE ASLEEP OFTEN
00:36:30.321 --> 00:36:31.656
MAKES THEM.
00:36:31.722 --> 00:36:33.357
WONDERFUL TO HAVE MOMENTOUS
00:36:33.424 --> 00:36:34.692
DISHES.
00:36:34.759 --> 00:36:36.794
I DO THINK THAT SUMMER AYE SIR
00:36:36.861 --> 00:36:39.063
NO AMOUNT OF SLEEP EDUCATION
00:36:39.130 --> 00:36:40.164
WHICH WE CAN FOR A WIDE CAN HELP
00:36:40.231 --> 00:36:42.066
THEM IF THE STATE STILL MANDATE
00:36:42.133 --> 00:36:44.101
THEM TO WAKE UP EARLY.
00:36:44.168 --> 00:36:45.336
AND EARLY THANK THANK YOU.
00:36:45.403 --> 00:36:47.038
APPRECIATE THAT -- AND OTHERS IN
00:36:47.104 --> 00:36:47.538
SUPPORT MAY COME TO THE
00:36:47.605 --> 00:36:48.072
MICROPHONE STATE YOUR NAME
00:36:48.139 --> 00:36:49.373
AFFILIATION AND POSITION ON THE
00:36:49.440 --> 00:36:56.614
BILL ONLY IT IS NOT TIME FOR
00:36:56.681 --> 00:36:58.082
FURTHER COMMENT.
00:36:58.149 --> 00:36:58.382
TOM NELSON.
00:36:58.449 --> 00:36:59.517
REPRESENTING THE CALIFORNIA
00:36:59.584 --> 00:37:02.687
STATE PTA PROUD SPONSOR OF SB.
00:37:02.753 --> 00:37:03.187
THREE TWENTY EIGHT ALSO
00:37:03.254 --> 00:37:03.921
CHAIRPERSON FOR THE PARENT
00:37:03.988 --> 00:37:04.789
ADVISORY COMMITTEE ON EL CAP FOR
00:37:04.855 --> 00:37:06.123
A LARGE DISTRICT REPRESENTING
00:37:06.190 --> 00:37:06.958
OVER A HUNDRED THOUSAND PARENTS
00:37:07.024 --> 00:37:08.459
AND STUDENTS PLEASE PROMOTE.
00:37:08.526 --> 00:37:09.927
THE GENERAL WELFARE FOR IS A
00:37:09.994 --> 00:37:12.263
KILLER THANK YOU THANK YOU.
00:37:12.330 --> 00:37:14.365
OKAY THE NEIER OF REPRESENTING
00:37:14.432 --> 00:37:15.800
STUDENTS ALL OVER SOUTHERN
00:37:15.866 --> 00:37:19.036
CALIFORNIA I SUPPORT SENATE
00:37:19.103 --> 00:37:20.504
THANK YOU.
00:37:20.571 --> 00:37:21.105
THREE TWENTY EIGHT WE GET THE
00:37:21.172 --> 00:37:24.108
DOOR CLOSED IN THE BACK.
00:37:24.175 --> 00:37:24.875
BECAUSE WE CAN THAT LOW MY NAME
00:37:24.942 --> 00:37:26.310
IS NOISE I'M SORRY JUST BECAUSE
00:37:26.377 --> 00:37:27.078
THE NOISE COMES IN.
00:37:27.144 --> 00:37:28.512
SO THANK YOU.
00:37:28.579 --> 00:37:29.513
HELLO MY NAME IS THE KEY TO
00:37:29.580 --> 00:37:30.915
NEIER AND BEHALF OF ALL HIGH
00:37:30.982 --> 00:37:33.184
SCHOOL STUDENTS I SUPPORT BILL.
00:37:33.250 --> 00:37:36.687
SEE I SPEAK.
00:37:36.754 --> 00:37:37.488
THREE TWENTY EIGHT SIMON VIEW
00:37:37.555 --> 00:37:39.423
WITH THE CALIFORNIA COUNCIL OF
00:37:39.490 --> 00:37:41.525
BEHAVIOR HEALTH -- CALIFORNIA
00:37:41.592 --> 00:37:43.661
COUNCIL COMMUNITY PAY FOR HEALTH
00:37:43.728 --> 00:37:47.131
AGENCY AND WE SUPPORT ABOUT.
00:37:47.198 --> 00:37:48.399
HELLO MY NAME IS CARTEL YAY ON
00:37:48.466 --> 00:37:49.934
BEHALF OF ALL STUDENTS IN
00:37:50.001 --> 00:37:53.638
CALIFORNIA I SUPPORT SB.
00:37:53.704 --> 00:37:54.205
THREE THREE EIGHT HELLO I'M
00:37:54.271 --> 00:37:54.739
HEALY PHILLIPS FROM RIO
00:37:54.805 --> 00:37:58.275
AMERICANO AND I SUPPORT SB.
00:37:58.342 --> 00:37:58.909
THREE TWENTY EIGHT HELLO MY NAME
00:37:58.976 --> 00:38:00.211
IS JULIETT DEL CORE OF FOR ME
00:38:00.277 --> 00:38:01.579
AMERICANA HIGH SCHOOL AND I
00:38:01.646 --> 00:38:03.547
SUPPORT THIS BILL.
00:38:03.614 --> 00:38:04.315
HELLO MY NAME IS THE RARE
00:38:04.382 --> 00:38:06.417
AHMANSON I'M FROM MARYLAND HIGH
00:38:06.484 --> 00:38:10.755
SCHOOL AND I SUPPORT SB.
00:38:10.821 --> 00:38:11.322
THREE TWENTY DEBORAH OUGHTON
00:38:11.389 --> 00:38:14.058
COUNSELOR PSYCHOTHERAPIST FOR
00:38:14.125 --> 00:38:16.127
THIRTY NINE YEARS I ABSOLUTELY
00:38:16.193 --> 00:38:21.599
SUPPORT THIS BILL.
00:38:21.666 --> 00:38:22.033
HOW LAME THING TO MY
00:38:22.099 --> 00:38:23.467
PEDIATRICIAN ON BEHALF OF THE
00:38:23.534 --> 00:38:24.869
AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS
00:38:24.935 --> 00:38:28.706
IN STRONG SUPPORT?
00:38:28.773 --> 00:38:30.441
LARA HOLLIS PARENT THANKS FOR
00:38:30.508 --> 00:38:34.545
YOUR SUPPORT ON THIS BILL.
00:38:34.612 --> 00:38:36.347
HELLO LAURIE MORALIS PARENT OF
00:38:36.414 --> 00:38:38.783
TO GRADUATES OF FROM THE SEMI
00:38:38.849 --> 00:38:40.718
UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT.
00:38:40.785 --> 00:38:41.452
CHILE SUPPORT THIS BILL THANK
00:38:41.519 --> 00:38:44.689
YOU.
00:38:44.755 --> 00:38:45.456
HE BERMAN ROW.
00:38:45.523 --> 00:38:48.025
PARENT OF GRADUATES FROM
00:38:48.092 --> 00:38:49.560
CALIFORNIA SCHOOLS.
00:38:49.627 --> 00:38:51.162
I AM DEFINITELY SUPPORTING THE
00:38:51.228 --> 00:38:55.366
STUDENTS AND THIS BILL.
00:38:55.433 --> 00:38:57.368
HI MINUTIA BASHING CAT CAN ON
00:38:57.435 --> 00:38:58.235
GOING TO DISINTEGRATE AND I
00:38:58.302 --> 00:39:01.872
SUPPORT THIS BILL.
00:39:01.939 --> 00:39:03.207
SU CHILLING.
00:39:03.274 --> 00:39:04.475
REGISTERED NURSE START SCHOOL
00:39:04.542 --> 00:39:06.343
LATER.
00:39:06.410 --> 00:39:07.344
I VERY MUCH SUPPORT THIS BILL
00:39:07.411 --> 00:39:12.249
THANK YOU.
00:39:12.316 --> 00:39:14.385
HI MY NAME IS SIMON CATKIN I'M
00:39:14.452 --> 00:39:15.553
GOING TO NINTH GRADE I
00:39:15.619 --> 00:39:17.288
SUPPORTERS BILL.
00:39:17.354 --> 00:39:18.155
SCHEDULING PHYSICIAN WITH
00:39:18.222 --> 00:39:19.323
BECAUSE PERMANENTLY FOR THIRTY
00:39:19.390 --> 00:39:22.426
TWO YEARS I SUPPORT THIS BILL.
00:39:22.493 --> 00:39:24.495
STEPHANIE FREDRICKSON PARENT OF
00:39:24.562 --> 00:39:27.031
TWO TEENS ADD EL CAMINO -- HIGH
00:39:27.098 --> 00:39:29.900
SCHOOL I SUPPORT THIS BILL.
00:39:29.967 --> 00:39:31.969
CHRIS TRAILER PASSED STYLE --
00:39:32.036 --> 00:39:33.370
HIGH SCHOOL GUEST TEACHER
00:39:33.437 --> 00:39:34.238
SUBSTITUTE TEACHER AND PASSED
00:39:34.305 --> 00:39:36.040
PTA PRESIDENT I SUPPORT THIS
00:39:36.107 --> 00:39:38.442
BILL.
00:39:38.509 --> 00:39:40.444
RENDON TO IT ON BEHALF OF ADVICE
00:39:40.511 --> 00:39:43.514
AND SUPPORT.
00:39:43.581 --> 00:39:45.149
MCEWAN PARENT OF TWO CHILDREN
00:39:45.216 --> 00:39:46.317
FROM SAN JUAN UNIFIED SCHOOL
00:39:46.383 --> 00:39:47.785
DISTRICT PASSED ELEMENTARY
00:39:47.852 --> 00:39:49.620
SCHOOL PTA PRESIDENT.
00:39:49.687 --> 00:39:53.190
I SUPPORT THIS BILL.
00:39:53.257 --> 00:39:53.824
KOBE PRESIDING A ON BEHALF OF
00:39:53.891 --> 00:39:55.526
MYSELF AS A WASHINGTON UNIFIED
00:39:55.593 --> 00:39:57.695
SCHOOL DISTRICT -- TRUSTEE IN
00:39:57.762 --> 00:40:00.131
SUPPORT THANK.
00:40:00.197 --> 00:40:01.265
I'M SHANNON SELLABAND
00:40:01.332 --> 00:40:03.534
PEDIATRICIAN A MOTHER OF A
00:40:03.601 --> 00:40:05.202
THIRTEEN YEAR OLD PUBLIC SCHOOL.
00:40:05.269 --> 00:40:07.538
STUDENTS A RESIDENT OF MEMO PARK
00:40:07.605 --> 00:40:10.474
STRONG SUPPORT OF THIS BILL.
00:40:10.541 --> 00:40:11.609
GEN MEMBERS JONATHON FELDMAN
00:40:11.675 --> 00:40:16.247
CHIEFS ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT
00:40:16.313 --> 00:40:16.947
THANK YOU MEGAN ALL RIGHT
00:40:17.014 --> 00:40:18.115
CALIFORNIA MEDICAL ASSOCIATION
00:40:18.182 --> 00:40:20.818
IN SUPPORT.
00:40:20.885 --> 00:40:21.952
MATT ROBINSON KAISER PERMANENTE
00:40:22.019 --> 00:40:24.789
IN SUPPORT.
00:40:24.855 --> 00:40:26.657
SHANNON PRIMER SPECIAL NEEDS
00:40:26.724 --> 00:40:28.159
PARALEGAL I'M I'M ALSO FROM
00:40:28.225 --> 00:40:29.994
EDUCATE ADVOCATE EMPOWER FAMILY --
00:40:30.060 --> 00:40:31.662
CALIFORNIA AND WE ARE IN STRONG
00:40:31.729 --> 00:40:34.598
SUPPORT.
00:40:34.665 --> 00:40:36.133
I'M AND DEL CORE I'M ON THE
00:40:36.200 --> 00:40:37.835
PARENT AND SUPERINTENDENT
00:40:37.902 --> 00:40:39.270
ADVISORY COMMITTEE IN THE SAN
00:40:39.336 --> 00:40:40.905
JUAN UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT IN
00:40:40.971 --> 00:40:44.975
SUPPORT.
00:40:45.042 --> 00:40:46.377
MY NAME IS LIKE SO TO RALLY I'M
00:40:46.443 --> 00:40:47.411
A STUDENT AT REMARK ON A HIGH
00:40:47.478 --> 00:40:49.180
SCHOOL AND I'M IN SUPPORT OF
00:40:49.246 --> 00:40:51.782
THIS BILL.
00:40:51.849 --> 00:40:52.683
BEAR CENTER ON BEHALF OF THE
00:40:52.750 --> 00:40:54.351
PASADENA UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT
00:40:54.418 --> 00:40:58.155
BOARD OF EDUCATION SUPPORT.
00:40:58.222 --> 00:40:59.957
HELLO I'M IN A CAR I AM A PARENT
00:41:00.024 --> 00:41:01.192
OF TWO TEENAGERS.
00:41:01.258 --> 00:41:02.526
THERE IN THE SAN JUAN UNIFIED
00:41:02.593 --> 00:41:05.296
SCHOOL DISTRICT AND I'M HERE TO
00:41:05.362 --> 00:41:05.529
SUPPORT.
00:41:05.596 --> 00:41:08.132
THANK YOU.
00:41:08.199 --> 00:41:10.201
HI PEGGY PARKER I'M WITH THIRD
00:41:10.267 --> 00:41:13.037
DISTRICT PTA MEMBERSHIP V. P. WE
00:41:13.103 --> 00:41:14.672
COVER THE EIGHT COUNTIES AND I'M
00:41:14.738 --> 00:41:16.240
ALSO A GRANDPARENT OF TWO
00:41:16.307 --> 00:41:18.776
TEENAGERS SO I DEFINITELY
00:41:18.843 --> 00:41:20.144
SUPPORT THIS BILL THANK YOU.
00:41:20.211 --> 00:41:21.879
THANK YOU OKAY WILL HAVE THE
00:41:21.946 --> 00:41:23.247
OPPOSITION COME UP [inaudible]
00:41:23.314 --> 00:41:25.049
M. PRESENT.
00:41:25.115 --> 00:41:27.651
THE OPPOSITION TO THE BILL.
00:41:27.718 --> 00:41:29.153
JUST COME FORWARD AND YOU MAY
00:41:29.220 --> 00:41:42.466
SIT AT THE TABLE HERE.
00:41:42.533 --> 00:41:45.135
NUMBER TWO I THOUGHT THEY WERE.
00:41:45.202 --> 00:41:48.205
TOO I'M NOT SURE IF YOU CAN YEAH --
00:41:48.272 --> 00:41:52.209
MORE THE MERRIER.
00:41:52.276 --> 00:41:54.345
AND THEN BAD.
00:41:54.411 --> 00:41:58.249
PROBLEMATIC OKAY.
00:41:58.315 --> 00:42:02.987
CAN I BECAUSE I THINK.
00:42:03.053 --> 00:42:05.022
REFER ME TO ME YEAH.
00:42:05.089 --> 00:42:07.191
YEAH BE READY.
00:42:07.258 --> 00:42:08.692
YES PROCEED WITH X. MINUTES
00:42:08.759 --> 00:42:11.262
TOTAL MY NAME IS IAN CAMPBELL
00:42:11.328 --> 00:42:12.997
PHD -- APPROACHING LOUDER.
00:42:13.063 --> 00:42:14.365
MY NAME IS IAN CAMPBELL PHD I'M
00:42:14.431 --> 00:42:15.633
A PROJECT SCIENTISTS AT THE UC
00:42:15.699 --> 00:42:16.967
DAVIS SLEEP LAB.
00:42:17.034 --> 00:42:17.701
AND THAT ONE IT SAY THE THE
00:42:17.768 --> 00:42:19.203
VIEWS THAT I'M EXPRESSING TODAY
00:42:19.270 --> 00:42:20.471
OR FROM MY MORE THAN TWENTY
00:42:20.537 --> 00:42:22.172
YEARS IN RESEARCH AND SLEEP ON
00:42:22.239 --> 00:42:23.641
AND MORE THAN THAT OR NINETEEN
00:42:23.707 --> 00:42:25.442
OR SO ON ADOLESCENT SLEEP AS A
00:42:25.509 --> 00:42:26.043
SIGN TO THE UC DAVIS AND THEY
00:42:26.110 --> 00:42:26.343
ARE MY OWN.
00:42:26.410 --> 00:42:27.244
AND NOT NECESSARILY THOSE
00:42:27.311 --> 00:42:28.145
UNIVERSE CALIFORNIA HOPE YOU HAD
00:42:28.212 --> 00:42:29.480
A CHANCE TO READ THE LETTER THAT
00:42:29.546 --> 00:42:30.147
IRWIN FIND BURKE AND I WROTE IN
00:42:30.214 --> 00:42:30.948
OPPOSITION TO THIS BILL ARE
00:42:31.015 --> 00:42:32.349
BRIEFLY REVIEW OUR REASONS FOR
00:42:32.416 --> 00:42:33.050
OPPOSING IT.
00:42:33.117 --> 00:42:34.084
MANY ADOLESCENTS TO DO HAVE A
00:42:34.151 --> 00:42:35.252
CIRCADIAN PHASE DELAY THAT
00:42:35.319 --> 00:42:36.186
CAUSES THEM TO PREFER A LATER
00:42:36.253 --> 00:42:37.354
BEDTIME HOWEVER SLEEP SCIENTISTS
00:42:37.421 --> 00:42:38.656
DO NOT FULLY UNDERSTAND THIS
00:42:38.722 --> 00:42:39.790
PHASE DELAY.
00:42:39.857 --> 00:42:40.624
RATHER THAN THAT THE DELAY
00:42:40.691 --> 00:42:42.192
RESULTING FROM CHANGES IN BRAIN
00:42:42.259 --> 00:42:43.827
CIRCUITS THAT RGULATE CIRCADIAN
00:42:43.894 --> 00:42:46.063
RHYTHMS THE BEST EVIDENCE IS THE
00:42:46.130 --> 00:42:47.164
ADOLESCENT SLEEP NEED
00:42:47.231 --> 00:42:48.866
ACCUMULATES MORE SLOWLY ACROSS
00:42:48.933 --> 00:42:50.367
THE DAY AND THIS ALLOWS THEM TO
00:42:50.434 --> 00:42:51.435
STAY UP LATER.
00:42:51.502 --> 00:42:52.870
A RECENT MODELING STUDY
00:42:52.937 --> 00:42:54.104
DEMONSTRATED THAT RATHER THAN
00:42:54.171 --> 00:42:55.739
ACCOMMODATING THE PHASE DELAY BY
00:42:55.806 --> 00:42:56.840
ALTERING SCHOOL START TIME A
00:42:56.907 --> 00:42:58.842
MORE EFFECTIVE APPROACH IS TO
00:42:58.909 --> 00:43:00.477
REDUCE EVENING LIGHT EXPOSURE.
00:43:00.544 --> 00:43:02.313
FURTHERMORE SLEEP RESEARCHERS DO
00:43:02.379 --> 00:43:03.580
NOT FULLY UNDERSTAND HOW SLEEP
00:43:03.647 --> 00:43:05.149
NEED CHANGES DURING ADOLESCENCE
00:43:05.215 --> 00:43:06.717
OUR LAB IS CURRENTLY CONDUCTING
00:43:06.784 --> 00:43:08.953
AN NIH FUNDED STUDY TO ADDRESS
00:43:09.019 --> 00:43:09.687
THIS QUESTION.
00:43:09.753 --> 00:43:11.555
SECOND PROPONENTS FAILED TO IN A
00:43:11.622 --> 00:43:12.790
KNOWLEDGE OF THE EVIDENCE THAT
00:43:12.856 --> 00:43:14.725
THE INITIAL SLEEP IN THE INITIAL
00:43:14.792 --> 00:43:16.026
INCREASE IN SLEEP DURATION
00:43:16.093 --> 00:43:17.428
FOLLOWING SCHOOL START TIMES MAY
00:43:17.494 --> 00:43:18.996
NOT PERSIST.
00:43:19.063 --> 00:43:20.631
IT IS REASONABLE TO ASK IF WE
00:43:20.698 --> 00:43:22.933
DELAY START TIMES WANT TEENS
00:43:23.000 --> 00:43:23.400
JUST STAY UP LATER.
00:43:23.467 --> 00:43:25.269
A LONGITUDINAL STUDY FOUND JUST
00:43:25.336 --> 00:43:26.503
THAT DELAYING PARTS HIGH SCHOOL
00:43:26.570 --> 00:43:28.939
START TIME FROM SEVEN FORTY FIVE
00:43:29.006 --> 00:43:29.473
EIGHT THIRTY AM.
00:43:29.540 --> 00:43:30.841
PRODUCED AN INITIAL TWENTY
00:43:30.908 --> 00:43:32.409
MINUTE INCREASE IN SCHOOL AND
00:43:32.476 --> 00:43:34.144
SLEEP DURATION DUE TO A TWENTY
00:43:34.211 --> 00:43:35.079
MINUTE LATER RISE TIME.
00:43:35.145 --> 00:43:36.780
HOWEVER SIX MONTHS LATER
00:43:36.847 --> 00:43:38.582
BEDTIMES WERE ALSO DELAYED
00:43:38.649 --> 00:43:44.288
TWENTY MINUTES RESULTING IN NO
00:43:44.355 --> 00:43:45.823
CHANGE IN SLEEP DURATION.
00:43:45.889 --> 00:43:47.758
THIRD A NATIONWIDE STUDY
00:43:47.825 --> 00:43:48.392
ORIGINALLY CROSS SECTIONAL STUDY
00:43:48.459 --> 00:43:49.293
SHOWED THAT EIGHT THIRTY MAY NOT
00:43:49.360 --> 00:43:49.860
BE THE APPROPRIATE LIMIT AND
00:43:49.927 --> 00:43:50.761
IT'S CERTAINLY NOT APPROPRIATE
00:43:50.828 --> 00:43:52.096
FOR ALL ALL SITUATIONS.
00:43:52.162 --> 00:43:53.097
THE ASSOCIATION BETWEEN START
00:43:53.163 --> 00:43:54.164
TIME AND SLEEP DURATION.
00:43:54.231 --> 00:43:56.367
WAS STRONGEST PRIOR TO EIGHT AM
00:43:56.433 --> 00:43:58.702
AFTER EIGHT AM THERE WAS NO
00:43:58.769 --> 00:44:01.071
RELATION BETWEEN STILL START
00:44:01.138 --> 00:44:02.339
TIME AND SLEEP DURATION.
00:44:02.406 --> 00:44:03.440
THE AUTHORS RECOMMENDED MORE
00:44:03.507 --> 00:44:04.775
RESEARCH TO BETTER UNDERSTAND
00:44:04.842 --> 00:44:06.510
THE EFFECTS OF SCHOOL START TIME
00:44:06.577 --> 00:44:08.178
CHANGES WE AGREE.
00:44:08.245 --> 00:44:09.179
INSTEAD OF COMPELLING SCHOOL
00:44:09.246 --> 00:44:10.447
DISTRICTS TO ADOPT THE STATE
00:44:10.514 --> 00:44:12.249
MANDATED START TIME WE RECOMMEND
00:44:12.316 --> 00:44:13.584
THAT THE LEGISLATURE PERHAPS
00:44:13.650 --> 00:44:14.885
ASSISTED BY THE CALIFORNIA
00:44:14.952 --> 00:44:16.186
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH AND
00:44:16.253 --> 00:44:16.987
THE MANY SLEEP SCIENTISTS IN THE
00:44:17.054 --> 00:44:17.521
STATE.
00:44:17.588 --> 00:44:18.689
PROVIDE GUIDELINES SO THAT
00:44:18.756 --> 00:44:19.990
SCHOOL DISTRICTS THAT WANT TO
00:44:20.057 --> 00:44:21.258
DELAY START TIMES CAN COLLECT
00:44:21.325 --> 00:44:22.826
APPROPRIATE DATA TO EVALUATE THE
00:44:22.893 --> 00:44:24.328
POSITIVE AND NEGATIVE IMPACTS OF
00:44:24.395 --> 00:44:26.096
THE CHANGE.
00:44:26.163 --> 00:44:27.164
THANK YOU.
00:44:27.231 --> 00:44:28.532
MY NAME IS CINDY GARDNER SCHOOL
00:44:28.599 --> 00:44:29.466
BOARD PRESIDENT FOR ROOM OF THE
00:44:29.533 --> 00:44:31.635
WORLD UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT
00:44:31.702 --> 00:44:32.403
WHICH IS IN THE MOUNTAINS OF
00:44:32.469 --> 00:44:34.304
SAMBAR NAY DINO ENCOMPASSING
00:44:34.371 --> 00:44:35.906
SCHOOL BOUNDARIES A HUNDRED AND
00:44:35.973 --> 00:44:37.107
TWENTY ONE SQUARE MILES.
00:44:37.174 --> 00:44:39.410
IN THE ELEVATION FROM FORTY
00:44:39.476 --> 00:44:41.245
SEVEN HUNDRED FEET TO SEVENTY
00:44:41.311 --> 00:44:43.647
TWO HUNDRED FEET. 71% OF OUR
00:44:43.714 --> 00:44:44.715
STUDENTS RELY ON HOME TO SCHOOL
00:44:44.782 --> 00:44:46.316
TRANSPORTATION DUE TO OUR
00:44:46.383 --> 00:44:47.851
WORKING FAMILIES OUR UNIQUE
00:44:47.918 --> 00:44:50.054
GEOGRAPHICAL CHALLENGES IN THE
00:44:50.120 --> 00:44:50.587
WEATHER CONDITIONS OF OUR
00:44:50.654 --> 00:44:52.689
DISTRICT. TO IMPLEMENT A LATER
00:44:52.756 --> 00:44:54.258
START TIME FOR HIGH SCHOOLS IN
00:44:54.324 --> 00:44:55.826
THE CURRENT STAGGERED START TIME
00:44:55.893 --> 00:44:57.394
SCHEDULE WE HAVE.
00:44:57.461 --> 00:44:58.629
ROOM WOULD NEED TO DOUBLE ITS
00:44:58.695 --> 00:45:00.731
FLEET OF BUSES AND STAFF FOR ONE
00:45:00.798 --> 00:45:02.166
TIME COSTS A THREE POINT TWO
00:45:02.232 --> 00:45:04.668
MILLION DOLLARS AN ONGOING COSTS
00:45:04.735 --> 00:45:05.736
OF ONE POINT FOUR MILLION
00:45:05.803 --> 00:45:06.437
DOLLARS.
00:45:06.503 --> 00:45:07.604
WEARING DECLINING ENROLLMENTS SO
00:45:07.671 --> 00:45:10.207
IN ORDER TO AVOID INSOLVENCY
00:45:10.274 --> 00:45:11.508
THIS WOULD EQUATE TO THE LAYOFF
00:45:11.575 --> 00:45:13.143
OF TWELVE TEACHERS INCLUDING THE
00:45:13.210 --> 00:45:14.611
ENTIRE HIGH SCHOOL'S CAREER
00:45:14.678 --> 00:45:16.914
TECHNICAL EDUCATION DEPARTMENT.
00:45:16.980 --> 00:45:18.949
LAY OFF AN ASSISTANT PRINCIPAL
00:45:19.016 --> 00:45:20.384
FOR COUNSELORS FIVE LIBRARIANS
00:45:20.451 --> 00:45:22.052
AND THREE SECRETARIES THERE
00:45:22.119 --> 00:45:23.954
WOULD BE A REDUCTION OR
00:45:24.021 --> 00:45:25.322
ELIMINATION OF ARE MOST.
00:45:25.389 --> 00:45:26.590
HELPFUL PROGRAMS SUCH AS OUR
00:45:26.657 --> 00:45:28.425
VIRTUAL AND CREDIT RECOVERY
00:45:28.492 --> 00:45:30.761
PROGRAMS THAT HELP THE MOST AT
00:45:30.828 --> 00:45:32.196
RISK STUDENTS GRADUATE.
00:45:32.262 --> 00:45:34.398
THE ELIMINATION OF DRAMA BAND
00:45:34.465 --> 00:45:35.999
FIELD TRIPS CHOIR AND MY
00:45:36.066 --> 00:45:38.235
FAVORITE ATHLETICS WE WOULD ALSO
00:45:38.302 --> 00:45:39.069
HAVE TO LIMóN EIGHT THE
00:45:39.136 --> 00:45:40.737
TEXTBOOK ADOPTION FOR THE NEXT
00:45:40.804 --> 00:45:42.005
THREE YEARS.
00:45:42.072 --> 00:45:44.074
BECAUSE WE CANNOT TRUNCATE OUR
00:45:44.141 --> 00:45:45.976
BUS TURN AROUND TIMES CREATING
00:45:46.043 --> 00:45:47.978
OTHER STAGGERED START TIME
00:45:48.045 --> 00:45:49.513
OPTIONS ALL HAD NEGATIVE
00:45:49.580 --> 00:45:50.848
CONSEQUENCES.
00:45:50.914 --> 00:45:53.317
STARTING ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS AT
00:45:53.383 --> 00:45:53.884
SEVEN TWENTY EIGHT AM HIGH
00:45:53.951 --> 00:45:55.285
SCHOOL AT EIGHT THIRTY AM IN
00:45:55.352 --> 00:45:57.321
MIDDLE SCHOOL AT TEN FIFTEEN AM
00:45:57.387 --> 00:45:59.456
WOULD MAKE THE FIRST PICK UP AT
00:45:59.523 --> 00:46:01.024
THE MOST REMOTE BUS STOPS.
00:46:01.091 --> 00:46:03.193
AT SIX TWENTY TWO AM FOR THE
00:46:03.260 --> 00:46:04.928
ELEMENTARY STUDENTS SO ARE
00:46:04.995 --> 00:46:07.131
REALLY YOUNG TKA FOUR YEAR OLDS
00:46:07.197 --> 00:46:08.499
ARE GOING TO BE STANDING AT BUS
00:46:08.565 --> 00:46:10.634
STOPS DURING THE WINTER IN THE
00:46:10.701 --> 00:46:12.169
DARK IN THIS NOW.
00:46:12.236 --> 00:46:13.737
THE LAST MIDDLE SCHOOL STUDENT
00:46:13.804 --> 00:46:16.039
BUS DROP WOULD BE FIVE FORTY ONE
00:46:16.106 --> 00:46:16.607
PM.
00:46:16.673 --> 00:46:18.909
AND MAY PRECLUDE PARTICIPATION
00:46:18.976 --> 00:46:20.077
IN AFTER SCHOOL ACTIVITIES LIKE
00:46:20.144 --> 00:46:23.347
KARATE DANCE LESSONS C<c.cyan> AND</c>
00:46:23.413 --> 00:46:28.418
USE SPORTS.
00:46:28.485 --> 00:46:29.586
MY DISTRICT HAS APPROXIMATELY
00:46:29.653 --> 00:46:30.787
EIGHTY NINE POINT 5% OF OUR
00:46:30.854 --> 00:46:31.989
STUDENTS RECEIVING FREE AND
00:46:32.055 --> 00:46:33.190
REDUCED PRICE MEALS SO WHY
00:46:33.257 --> 00:46:33.824
THOUGH GEOGRAPHY OF MY DISTRICT
00:46:33.891 --> 00:46:34.491
IS UNIQUE OUR STUDENT POPULATION
00:46:34.558 --> 00:46:36.026
LOOKS A LOT LIKE THOSE
00:46:36.093 --> 00:46:37.060
THROUGHOUT CALIFORNIA.
00:46:37.127 --> 00:46:38.529
WHO ARE STRUGGLING TO MAKE ENDS
00:46:38.595 --> 00:46:40.931
MEET OUR SINGLE PARENTS AND OUR
00:46:40.998 --> 00:46:42.566
LOW INCOME STUDENTS THEY JUST
00:46:42.633 --> 00:46:43.834
CAN'T GET THEIR KIDS TO SCHOOL
00:46:43.901 --> 00:46:45.202
THAT LATE?
00:46:45.269 --> 00:46:47.037
THEY JUST CAN'T SO WHAT I'M
00:46:47.104 --> 00:46:48.805
ASKING YOU IS FOR THESE
00:46:48.872 --> 00:46:51.375
UNINTENDED NEGATIVE CONSEQUENCES.
00:46:51.441 --> 00:46:54.011
AND OTHERS LIKE IT I WANT YOU TO
00:46:54.077 --> 00:46:59.917
VOTE NO ONE SB. TWENTY NINE
00:46:59.983 --> 00:47:00.417
THREE TWENTY EIGHT GOOD
00:47:00.484 --> 00:47:01.051
AFTERNOON I'M GLAD THAT WOULD
00:47:01.118 --> 00:47:01.552
WORK ON THE DIRECTOR OF
00:47:01.618 --> 00:47:02.052
LEGISLATIVE AFFAIRS AND
00:47:02.119 --> 00:47:03.153
COMMUNITY RELATIONS AT THE
00:47:03.220 --> 00:47:04.588
ALAMEDA CONTRA COSTA TRANSIT
00:47:04.655 --> 00:47:05.422
DISTRICT.
00:47:05.489 --> 00:47:06.857
I'M HERE TO TODAY TO EXPRESS THE
00:47:06.924 --> 00:47:09.193
DISTRICTS OPPOSITION TO SB THREE
00:47:09.259 --> 00:47:09.960
TWENTY EIGHT WHICH WOULD HAVE A
00:47:10.027 --> 00:47:11.962
SIGNIFICANT FISCAL IMPACT ON AC
00:47:12.029 --> 00:47:13.330
TRANSIT OPERATING BUDGET.
00:47:13.397 --> 00:47:14.298
AND PREVENT THE DISTRICT FROM
00:47:14.364 --> 00:47:15.799
PROVIDING THE CURRENT LEVEL OF
00:47:15.866 --> 00:47:17.668
SUPPLEMENTAL SCHOOL SERVICE THAT
00:47:17.734 --> 00:47:18.168
WE DO TODAY.
00:47:18.235 --> 00:47:19.636
EASY TRANSIT PROVIDES A HUNDRED
00:47:19.703 --> 00:47:20.771
AND SIXTY NINE THOUSAND TRIPS A
00:47:20.837 --> 00:47:22.839
DAY INCLUDING ABOUT THIRTY
00:47:22.906 --> 00:47:24.274
THOUSAND DAILY STUDENT TRIPS.
00:47:24.341 --> 00:47:26.009
AT TRANSIT COORDINATES WITH EACH
00:47:26.076 --> 00:47:27.878
SCHOOL TO STAGGER START TIMES TO
00:47:27.945 --> 00:47:29.346
ALLOW MULTIPLE SCHOOLS TO BE
00:47:29.413 --> 00:47:30.781
SERVED BY A SINGLE BUS AN
00:47:30.847 --> 00:47:31.548
OPERATOR.
00:47:31.615 --> 00:47:33.150
THIS COURT NATION ENABLES US TO
00:47:33.217 --> 00:47:34.518
PROVIDE THE MOST EFFICIENT LEVEL
00:47:34.585 --> 00:47:35.953
OF SERVICEAND ALLOWS THESE
00:47:36.019 --> 00:47:37.554
BUSES TO TRANSITION TO COMMUTER
00:47:37.621 --> 00:47:40.757
SERVICE AFTER THE SCHOOL
00:47:40.824 --> 00:47:41.959
SERVICES COMPLETE.
00:47:42.025 --> 00:47:42.793
IF THE SCHOOL START TIMES CHANGE
00:47:42.859 --> 00:47:43.860
THERE WILL BE A SIGNIFICANT
00:47:43.927 --> 00:47:45.295
INCREASE IN DEMAND FOR MORNING
00:47:45.362 --> 00:47:46.930
SERVICE BECAUSE A LATER START
00:47:46.997 --> 00:47:48.098
TIME WILL CONFLICT WITH THE
00:47:48.165 --> 00:47:49.299
MORNING COMMUTE.
00:47:49.366 --> 00:47:51.068
AC TRANSIT SCHEDULES FORTY SIX
00:47:51.134 --> 00:47:52.469
BUSES EACH MORNING COULD TO
00:47:52.536 --> 00:47:54.972
ACCOMMODATE SCHOOL SERVICE IF SB
00:47:55.038 --> 00:47:56.273
THREE TWENTY IS ENACTED THE LOSS
00:47:56.340 --> 00:47:58.041
OF STAGGERED START TIMES AND THE
00:47:58.108 --> 00:47:59.943
INCREASED DEMAND WILL REQUIRE AC
00:48:00.010 --> 00:48:02.112
TRANSIT. TO SCHEDULE A TOTAL OF
00:48:02.179 --> 00:48:03.780
SEVENTY THREE BUSES IN ORDER TO
00:48:03.847 --> 00:48:04.982
PROVIDE THE SAME LEVEL LET'S
00:48:05.048 --> 00:48:06.350
SAME LEVEL OF SERVICE THIS
00:48:06.416 --> 00:48:09.119
REPRESENTS A 60% INCREASE IN
00:48:09.186 --> 00:48:10.153
OPERATING COSTS FOR US.
00:48:10.220 --> 00:48:11.355
WITHOUT ADDRESSING THE COST
00:48:11.421 --> 00:48:13.090
IMPACT OF HOW STUDENTS GET TO
00:48:13.156 --> 00:48:14.825
AND FROM SCHOOL AND HOME AC
00:48:14.891 --> 00:48:16.326
TRANSIT WOULD NOT BE ABLE TO TO
00:48:16.393 --> 00:48:17.494
MAINTAIN THE CURRENT
00:48:17.561 --> 00:48:18.262
SUPPLEMENTAL SERVICE THAT WE
00:48:18.328 --> 00:48:19.363
PROVIDE.
00:48:19.429 --> 00:48:20.397
THEREFORE ON BEHALF OF AC
00:48:20.464 --> 00:48:21.932
TRANSIT I URGE YOU TO VOTE NO ON
00:48:21.999 --> 00:48:23.667
SB THREE TWENTY EIGHT THANK YOU
00:48:23.734 --> 00:48:24.801
THANK YOU OTHERS IN OPPOSITION
00:48:24.868 --> 00:48:26.470
STATE YOUR NAME AFFILIATION AND
00:48:26.536 --> 00:48:28.372
POSITION ON THE BILL ONLY PLEASE.
00:48:28.438 --> 00:48:29.406
NICOLAS CHAVEZ ON BEHALF OF THE
00:48:29.473 --> 00:48:31.041
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF SCHOOL
00:48:31.108 --> 00:48:32.342
TRANSPORTATION OFFICIALS WHO ARE
00:48:32.409 --> 00:48:34.711
LINE ARE COMMON TO THE PREVIOUS
00:48:34.778 --> 00:48:35.345
TWO SPEAKERS IN OPPOSITION THANK
00:48:35.412 --> 00:48:38.415
YOU.
00:48:38.482 --> 00:48:39.616
KEVIN FROM HALF THE COMPTON A
00:48:39.683 --> 00:48:41.051
FIGHT SCHOOL DISTRICT IN STRONG
00:48:41.118 --> 00:48:43.153
OPPOSITION.
00:48:43.220 --> 00:48:43.654
ELIZABETH ASK ABOUT THE
00:48:43.720 --> 00:48:44.288
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF SCHOOL
00:48:44.354 --> 00:48:45.922
BUSINESS OFFICIALS IN STRONG
00:48:45.989 --> 00:48:48.625
OPPOSITION TO THIS BILL.
00:48:48.692 --> 00:48:50.127
SEC BRAMBLE HERE ON BEHALF OF
00:48:50.193 --> 00:48:50.961
THE CALIFORNIA TEACHERS
00:48:51.028 --> 00:48:53.530
ASSOCIATION WE COULD SUPPORT A
00:48:53.597 --> 00:48:54.164
PILOT BUT WE ARE OPPOSED TO THIS
00:48:54.231 --> 00:48:57.567
BILL.
00:48:57.634 --> 00:48:59.102
STEVE ALL COMBAT THE ALAMEDA
00:48:59.169 --> 00:49:00.203
COUNTY TRANSPORTATION
00:49:00.270 --> 00:49:00.771
COMMISSION'S ALSO OPPOSED TO
00:49:00.837 --> 00:49:02.372
THIS BILL.
00:49:02.439 --> 00:49:03.006
THERE CLINICS ON BEHALF OF THE
00:49:03.073 --> 00:49:03.740
SMALL SCHOOL DISTRICTS
00:49:03.807 --> 00:49:04.975
ASSOCIATION AND DECEMBER LEADING
00:49:05.042 --> 00:49:06.610
UP COUNTY DISTRICT ADVOCATES FOR
00:49:06.677 --> 00:49:09.079
BETTER SCHOOLS IN OPPOSITION.
00:49:09.146 --> 00:49:10.013
ERICA HOFFMAN ON BEHALF OF THE
00:49:10.080 --> 00:49:11.348
CALIFORNIA SCHOOL BOARDS
00:49:11.415 --> 00:49:14.084
ASSOCIATION IN OPPOSE.
00:49:14.151 --> 00:49:15.252
JEFF BOCK ON BEHALF OF THE
00:49:15.319 --> 00:49:16.553
RIVERSIDE COUNTY SUPERINTENDENT
00:49:16.620 --> 00:49:20.123
OF SCHOOLS IN OPPOSITION.
00:49:20.190 --> 00:49:21.158
HAVING A CRIED REPRESENTING THE
00:49:21.224 --> 00:49:22.926
ASSOCIATION OF CALIFORNIA SCHOOL
00:49:22.993 --> 00:49:26.229
ADMINISTRATORS ARE ALSO OPPOSED.
00:49:26.296 --> 00:49:27.698
HILLARY HALL SIXTH GRADE TEACHER
00:49:27.764 --> 00:49:29.733
REPRESENTING THE NEW HOLES
00:49:29.800 --> 00:49:32.569
TEACHERS ASSOCIATION WE OPPOSE.
00:49:32.636 --> 00:49:34.271
ESTHER CAM SPECIAL EDUCATION
00:49:34.338 --> 00:49:35.872
TEACHER OF THE NORTH SCHOOL
00:49:35.939 --> 00:49:38.075
DISTRICT ALSO OPPOSE.
00:49:38.141 --> 00:49:39.409
ANDREA BALL IN THE HALF OF THE
00:49:39.476 --> 00:49:40.944
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
00:49:41.011 --> 00:49:42.145
SUBURBAN SCHOOL DISTRICTS AND
00:49:42.212 --> 00:49:43.780
THE ORANGE COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF
00:49:43.847 --> 00:49:46.717
EDUCATION PROPOSED.
00:49:46.783 --> 00:49:47.918
BARBARA DAWSON MIDDLE SCHOOL
00:49:47.984 --> 00:49:49.252
TEACHER INVESTOR I OPPOSE THIS
00:49:49.319 --> 00:49:52.756
BILL.
00:49:52.823 --> 00:49:54.057
DIRECTORY A SOCIAL SCIENCE
00:49:54.124 --> 00:49:55.726
TEACHERS WHO ARE IN HIGH SCHOOL
00:49:55.792 --> 00:49:59.730
DISTRICT I OPPOSE.
00:49:59.796 --> 00:50:01.465
CALLING BURNER SCHMIDT -- FORTY
00:50:01.531 --> 00:50:03.400
FOUR YEAR EDUCATOR FROM GRADES
00:50:03.467 --> 00:50:06.670
K. I. T. K. THROUGH HIGH SCHOOL --
00:50:06.737 --> 00:50:10.440
I OPPOSE THIS.
00:50:10.507 --> 00:50:11.341
MISC APPEAR ST ELK GROVE
00:50:11.408 --> 00:50:13.844
EDUCATION ASSOCIATION I OPPOSE
00:50:13.910 --> 00:50:15.412
THIS BILL.
00:50:15.479 --> 00:50:16.513
MARGIE WERE NOT A KINDERGARTEN
00:50:16.580 --> 00:50:17.347
TEACHER MONEY BILLION FIVE
00:50:17.414 --> 00:50:19.149
CALIFORNIA TEACHERS ASSOCIATION
00:50:19.216 --> 00:50:21.651
OPPOSE.
00:50:21.718 --> 00:50:23.587
I BULLARD DIED UP PRESIDENT
00:50:23.653 --> 00:50:25.389
CONTINUE EDUCATION ASSOCIATION I
00:50:25.455 --> 00:50:29.359
OPPOSE.
00:50:29.426 --> 00:50:29.926
DOUG PETS CASKEY TEACHER AT
00:50:29.993 --> 00:50:31.161
MONTEBELLO UNIFIED SCHOOL
00:50:31.228 --> 00:50:32.396
DISTRICT AND PRESIDENT OF THE
00:50:32.462 --> 00:50:34.131
MONEY BILL TEACHERS ASSOCIATION
00:50:34.197 --> 00:50:37.033
I OPPOSE.
00:50:37.100 --> 00:50:38.535
GOOD AFTERNOON MY NAME IS CHRIS
00:50:38.602 --> 00:50:40.137
BOUCHER I'M A CHEMISTRY TEACHER
00:50:40.203 --> 00:50:41.371
BEVERLY HILLS HIGH SCHOOL IN THE
00:50:41.438 --> 00:50:42.406
BEVERLY HILLS UNIFIED SCHOOL
00:50:42.472 --> 00:50:47.344
DISTRICT I OPPOSE SB.
00:50:47.411 --> 00:50:47.911
THREE TWENTY EIGHT I'M JAMIE
00:50:47.978 --> 00:50:49.613
OSMAN I'M AN ENGLISH TEACHER
00:50:49.679 --> 00:50:50.714
JUNIOR HIGH ENGLISH TEACHER IN
00:50:50.781 --> 00:50:52.215
THE HEART SCHOOL DISTRICT.
00:50:52.282 --> 00:50:54.117
IN SANTA CLARITA AND I OPPOSE
00:50:54.184 --> 00:50:57.654
THIS BILL.
00:50:57.721 --> 00:50:58.855
THANK YOU SIR SIXTH GRADE
00:50:58.922 --> 00:50:59.790
TEACHER AND PRESIDENT OF THE
00:50:59.856 --> 00:51:00.724
INGLEWOOD TEACHERS ASSOCIATION
00:51:00.791 --> 00:51:04.594
WE OPPOSE THIS BILL.
00:51:04.661 --> 00:51:06.129
TIFFANY TERO TWENTY NINE YEAR
00:51:06.196 --> 00:51:08.231
HIGH SCHOOL ENGLISH TEACHER AND
00:51:08.298 --> 00:51:09.266
PRESIDENT OF THE ST LAWRENCE
00:51:09.332 --> 00:51:11.067
VALLEY TEACHERS ASSOCIATION AND
00:51:11.134 --> 00:51:14.538
WE OPPOSE THIS BILL.
00:51:14.604 --> 00:51:16.406
SERGIO MARTINEZ CALIFORNIA
00:51:16.473 --> 00:51:18.675
TEACHERS ASSOCIATION CTA BOARD
00:51:18.742 --> 00:51:20.944
OF DIRECTOR TEACHER OF THIRTY
00:51:21.011 --> 00:51:21.978
SEVEN YEARS WE STRONGLY OPPOSE
00:51:22.045 --> 00:51:25.816
THIS BILL.
00:51:25.882 --> 00:51:27.284
GOOD AFTERNOON EVEN WAY YES I'M
00:51:27.350 --> 00:51:28.251
FROM SAN MEDINA COUNTY TEACHERS
00:51:28.318 --> 00:51:29.686
ASSOCIATION AND THE LOCAL IN MY
00:51:29.753 --> 00:51:30.754
PRESENCE I'M THE PRESIDENT OF MY
00:51:30.821 --> 00:51:31.154
LOCAL SKEWS ME.
00:51:31.221 --> 00:51:32.355
I'M ALSO AN EARLY CHILDHOOD
00:51:32.422 --> 00:51:35.292
SPECIAL EDUCATION TEACHER AND I
00:51:35.358 --> 00:51:38.595
OPPOSE THIS BILL THANK YOU.
00:51:38.662 --> 00:51:39.563
KATHY PIERRE SAMUEL COUNTY
00:51:39.629 --> 00:51:40.797
SUPERINTENDENT SCHOOLS IN A
00:51:40.864 --> 00:51:42.966
SPECIAL EDUCATION EARLY START
00:51:43.033 --> 00:51:45.936
TEACHER AND OPPOSE THIS BILL.
00:51:46.002 --> 00:51:47.270
GET AFTERNOON NUMBER AND A WALK
00:51:47.337 --> 00:51:48.805
OR I'M PRESIDENT OF ASSOCIATED
00:51:48.872 --> 00:51:50.273
CHINO TEACHERS IN SALMON ID
00:51:50.340 --> 00:51:51.975
DON'T COUNTY I'M ALSO A SPECIAL
00:51:52.042 --> 00:51:54.110
EDUCATION TEACHER AND WE OPPOSE
00:51:54.177 --> 00:51:57.581
THE SPELL.
00:51:57.647 --> 00:51:59.349
GOOD AFTERNOON MY NAME IS SUSAN
00:51:59.416 --> 00:52:01.084
SCALA AND I'M THE PRESIDENT OF
00:52:01.151 --> 00:52:03.820
TO LIVE IS TO EDUCATORS -- IN
00:52:03.887 --> 00:52:06.223
SAN DIEGO COUNTY SIXTH GRADE
00:52:06.289 --> 00:52:09.659
TEACHER AND OUR ASSOCIATION
00:52:09.726 --> 00:52:12.229
OPPOSES THIS BILL THANK YOU.
00:52:12.295 --> 00:52:13.597
BOB BLATTNER FOR THE OAK GROVE
00:52:13.663 --> 00:52:16.132
UNIFIED IRVINE UNIFIED NEWPORT
00:52:16.199 --> 00:52:18.802
MESA UNIFIED AND WEST COVINA
00:52:18.869 --> 00:52:20.170
UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICTS IN
00:52:20.237 --> 00:52:22.772
STRONG OPPOSITIONS FOR THE
00:52:22.839 --> 00:52:23.340
REASONS SO ELOQUENTLY STATED
00:52:23.406 --> 00:52:26.643
THANK YOU. TWO WE WALKER
00:52:26.710 --> 00:52:28.345
NATIONAL BOARD CERTIFIED TEACHER
00:52:28.411 --> 00:52:29.646
MIDDLE SCHOOL SCIENCE TEACHER
00:52:29.713 --> 00:52:31.615
AND PRESIDENT OF THE SWEET WATER
00:52:31.681 --> 00:52:33.617
EDUCATION ASSOCIATION.
00:52:33.683 --> 00:52:38.121
AND WHAT I OPPOSE THIS BILL.
00:52:38.188 --> 00:52:39.689
THE COLD WAR -- FOURTH FIFTH
00:52:39.756 --> 00:52:42.158
GRADE TEACHER HERE IN SACRAMENTO
00:52:42.225 --> 00:52:44.794
SEXY UNIFIED. TWENTY YEARS -- I
00:52:44.861 --> 00:52:48.265
STRONGLY OPPOSE THIS PLEASE.
00:52:48.331 --> 00:52:50.233
THANK YOU WILL BRING IT BACK
00:52:50.300 --> 00:52:52.636
BEHIND THE DíAS -- ALL KIND OF
00:52:52.702 --> 00:52:53.236
START OFF HERE WITH SOME OF MY
00:52:53.303 --> 00:52:55.539
THOUGHTS -- IN MY MIND A
00:52:55.605 --> 00:52:56.907
PRACTICAL I'M I'M A PARENT OF
00:52:56.973 --> 00:52:59.009
TWO TEENAGERS.
00:52:59.075 --> 00:53:01.244
BUT A TEACHER FOR A LOT OF YEARS.
00:53:01.311 --> 00:53:03.046
AND YOU KNOW.
00:53:03.113 --> 00:53:04.147
WITH ALL DUE RESPECT YOU KNOW
00:53:04.214 --> 00:53:04.781
WE'VE HEARD OF THE NANNY STATE
00:53:04.848 --> 00:53:06.349
I'M FEARFUL THAT THIS IS THE
00:53:06.416 --> 00:53:06.750
STAVING THE NANNY.
00:53:06.816 --> 00:53:09.553
RIGHT -- IN A AND I THINK THIS
00:53:09.619 --> 00:53:10.754
MIGHT BE GOOD POLICY.
00:53:10.820 --> 00:53:13.657
AT THE DISTRICT LEVEL BUT MY
00:53:13.723 --> 00:53:14.591
CONCERN IS A SETTING THAT I MEAN.
00:53:14.658 --> 00:53:16.092
YES SETTING.
00:53:16.159 --> 00:53:18.094
THE THE SCHOOL BELL FROM
00:53:18.161 --> 00:53:19.829
SACRAMENTO AYE I JUST DON'T
00:53:19.896 --> 00:53:21.665
THINK WE KNOW EACH DISTRICTS.
00:53:21.731 --> 00:53:23.333
NEW ONCE IS ENOUGH TO SAY WELL
00:53:23.400 --> 00:53:24.801
WE KNOW BEST AND THIS IS WHAT IT
00:53:24.868 --> 00:53:25.969
SHOULD BE.
00:53:26.036 --> 00:53:27.537
ACROSS OUR STATE BUT AGAIN I'M
00:53:27.604 --> 00:53:29.573
NOT OPPOSED TO TO STARTING
00:53:29.639 --> 00:53:30.674
SCHOOL LATER AT ALL.
00:53:30.740 --> 00:53:33.209
NOT AT ALL BUT I JUST THINK IT'S
00:53:33.276 --> 00:53:34.210
IT'S GOOD LOCAL POLICY.
00:53:34.277 --> 00:53:35.912
BUT NOT NECESSARILY GOOD STATE
00:53:35.979 --> 00:53:38.448
POLICY TO DESIGNATE THE START
00:53:38.515 --> 00:53:40.083
TIME FOR EACH SCHOOL DAY
00:53:40.150 --> 00:53:41.184
COMMISSION WE SHOULD BE SENATE
00:53:41.251 --> 00:53:43.086
AND TIME AND TIME TO GET TO KNOW
00:53:43.153 --> 00:53:43.720
A LOT OF QUESTIONS YOU RESET THE
00:53:43.787 --> 00:53:44.287
SCHOOL KELLER.
00:53:44.354 --> 00:53:45.589
I WISH SCHOOL STARTED AFTER
00:53:45.655 --> 00:53:46.222
LABOR DAY HOW MANY OF YOU WISH
00:53:46.289 --> 00:53:47.691
THAT WOULD HAPPEN RIGHT BUT I'M
00:53:47.757 --> 00:53:49.359
NOT GOING TO SPONSOR A LAW. TO
00:53:49.426 --> 00:53:51.127
DO THAT BECAUSE I THINK THAT IS
00:53:51.194 --> 00:53:53.930
THE PURVIEW OF A LOCALLY THAT'S
00:53:53.997 --> 00:53:55.365
RIGHT NEXT YEAR ELECTED ELECTED
00:53:55.432 --> 00:53:57.701
WHERE.
00:53:57.767 --> 00:54:00.437
EXACTLY -- RELEASE BOILS DOWN TO
00:54:00.503 --> 00:54:02.806
ME -- IT TOGETHER TAKE TO ME
00:54:02.872 --> 00:54:07.944
THIS WAS ON A SURFBOARD A COW
00:54:08.011 --> 00:54:09.646
AND A TRAIN.
00:54:09.713 --> 00:54:10.480
OKAY A SURF BOARD WISE I'VE
00:54:10.547 --> 00:54:11.848
SHARED BEFORE MY DAUGHTERS IN
00:54:11.915 --> 00:54:12.482
THE SURF TEAM AT OUR LOCAL HIGH
00:54:12.549 --> 00:54:12.849
SCHOOL.
00:54:12.916 --> 00:54:13.450
IN TWO DAYS A WEEK HER FIRST
00:54:13.516 --> 00:54:15.552
PERIOD IS ACTUALLY AT SIX FORTY
00:54:15.619 --> 00:54:16.152
FIVE IN THE MORNING RIGHT SHE
00:54:16.219 --> 00:54:17.087
OPTS INTO THIS.
00:54:17.153 --> 00:54:17.654
AND SHE IS TO BE DOWN IN THE
00:54:17.721 --> 00:54:18.254
WATER.
00:54:18.321 --> 00:54:20.523
RIGHT AND SO FIRST HEARD HER
00:54:20.590 --> 00:54:21.791
FIRST PERIOD IS ACTUALLY SIX
00:54:21.858 --> 00:54:22.425
FORTY FIVE IN THE MORNING COUPLE
00:54:22.492 --> 00:54:22.759
DAYS A WEEK.
00:54:22.826 --> 00:54:25.629
AND SO SHE DOESN'T GO TO FIRST
00:54:25.695 --> 00:54:26.997
PERIOD AT SCHOOL AND AND THIS
00:54:27.063 --> 00:54:28.431
WOULD.
00:54:28.498 --> 00:54:29.199
YOU KNOW KILL THAT PROGRAM
00:54:29.265 --> 00:54:30.333
THERE'S A LOT OF THINGS THAT
00:54:30.400 --> 00:54:32.902
HAPPEN BEFORE SCHOOL THAT NOT
00:54:32.969 --> 00:54:33.703
EVERYBODY'S AWARE OF AND AGAIN
00:54:33.770 --> 00:54:35.071
SHE OPTS INTO THIS PROGRAM IS
00:54:35.138 --> 00:54:37.207
NOT MANDATORY THAT SHE'S ON THE
00:54:37.273 --> 00:54:37.507
SURF TEAM.
00:54:37.574 --> 00:54:39.409
BUT I AM VERY PLEASED THAT SHE
00:54:39.476 --> 00:54:40.677
IS I THINK IT BROUGHT SCHOOL
00:54:40.744 --> 00:54:42.078
SPIRIT BILL SCHOOL COMMUNITY
00:54:42.145 --> 00:54:43.780
WHEN KIDS ARE ENGAGE IN SPORTS
00:54:43.847 --> 00:54:45.849
BEFORE OR AFTER SCHOOL -- SOME
00:54:45.915 --> 00:54:47.550
SCHOOLS HAVE AGRICULTURAL
00:54:47.617 --> 00:54:48.952
PROGRAMS OR CERTAIN PROGRAMS
00:54:49.019 --> 00:54:50.820
THAT THEY DO UNIQUE THING THINGS
00:54:50.887 --> 00:54:52.155
THE MORNING I'M A CITY BOY.
00:54:52.222 --> 00:54:53.790
BUT FROM WHAT I KNOW YOU DON'T
00:54:53.857 --> 00:54:54.290
KNOW COUNT THREE IN THE
00:54:54.357 --> 00:54:55.091
AFTERNOON.
00:54:55.158 --> 00:54:56.359
RIGHT YOU HAVE TO DO IT IN THE
00:54:56.426 --> 00:54:57.961
EARLY MORNING HOURS AND THIS
00:54:58.028 --> 00:54:59.362
AGAIN WOULD.
00:54:59.429 --> 00:55:02.732
POTENTIALLY HARM SOME OF OUR AG
00:55:02.799 --> 00:55:04.801
PROGRAMS AROUND THE STATE -- IN
00:55:04.868 --> 00:55:05.802
A TRAIN THERE'S A SCHOOL IN
00:55:05.869 --> 00:55:06.670
ORANGE COUNTY THAT I'M AWARE OF
00:55:06.736 --> 00:55:08.672
THAT THEY HAVE TO SET.
00:55:08.738 --> 00:55:09.939
THE SCHOOL DAY ACCORDING TO WHEN
00:55:10.006 --> 00:55:11.341
A TRAIN GOES BY BECAUSE SO MANY
00:55:11.408 --> 00:55:13.810
CARS GET BACKED UP BY THIS TRAIN.
00:55:13.877 --> 00:55:15.578
SO AGAIN THERE'S JUST SO MANY
00:55:15.645 --> 00:55:17.514
NUANCES ACROSS OUR STATE AND
00:55:17.580 --> 00:55:18.848
HOUSE WAS OPERATING WHY THEY
00:55:18.915 --> 00:55:20.550
OPERATE ON THE TIME TABLE THEY
00:55:20.617 --> 00:55:21.918
DO THAT I DON'T THINK.
00:55:21.985 --> 00:55:23.653
IT'S GOOD TO TO TO TO GET SET
00:55:23.720 --> 00:55:25.689
THAT THAT THAT START TIME FROM
00:55:25.755 --> 00:55:26.756
SACRAMENTO I'M A MOMENT A LOCAL
00:55:26.823 --> 00:55:28.091
CONTROL GUY I THINK A LOCAL
00:55:28.158 --> 00:55:29.893
SCHOOL BOARD HAS THE EXPERTISE
00:55:29.959 --> 00:55:30.627
TO DO THIS.
00:55:30.694 --> 00:55:32.362
WE'RE STATE THAT'S DIVERSE IN
00:55:32.429 --> 00:55:34.364
PEOPLE YES BUT ALSO GEOGRAPHY
00:55:34.431 --> 00:55:37.634
AND THAT MEANS A LOT OF THINGS --
00:55:37.701 --> 00:55:38.268
I MEAN WHY HAVE A SCHOOL BOARD
00:55:38.334 --> 00:55:39.502
AGAIN IT'S A QUESTION I ASK
00:55:39.569 --> 00:55:42.472
WORKING FAMILIES.
00:55:42.539 --> 00:55:43.073
RIGHT THIS IS GOING TO IMPACT
00:55:43.139 --> 00:55:43.540
THEM.
00:55:43.606 --> 00:55:44.607
AND I COME FROM A DISTRICT WHERE
00:55:44.674 --> 00:55:45.308
THERE WAS A LOT OF WORKING
00:55:45.375 --> 00:55:47.477
FAMILIES AND I KNOW THIS IS
00:55:47.544 --> 00:55:48.545
GOING TO FALL ON OKAY.
00:55:48.611 --> 00:55:51.081
TYPICALLY IS GONNA FALL ON THE
00:55:51.147 --> 00:55:52.048
WOMAN.
00:55:52.115 --> 00:55:53.116
OKAY MY WIFE AT HOME WITH THE
00:55:53.183 --> 00:55:54.484
KIDS RIGHT NOW I'M UP HERE RIGHT
00:55:54.551 --> 00:55:56.386
SHE SAYS HAVING A GOOD TIME.
00:55:56.453 --> 00:55:58.054
RIGHT BUT IT THIS BURDEN IS
00:55:58.121 --> 00:56:00.724
GOING TO FALL ON WORKING WOMEN.
00:56:00.790 --> 00:56:03.026
FROM MY PERSPECTIVE MORE HEAVILY
00:56:03.093 --> 00:56:03.526
THAN OTHERS.
00:56:03.593 --> 00:56:05.128
I WAS GONNA COST CHILDCARE
00:56:05.195 --> 00:56:06.596
ISSUES.
00:56:06.663 --> 00:56:07.163
PEOPLE HAVE TO GO TO WORK I
00:56:07.230 --> 00:56:08.431
DON'T THINK.
00:56:08.498 --> 00:56:10.100
BUSINESS IS GONNA NOT OPEN
00:56:10.166 --> 00:56:11.468
BECAUSE THE SCHOOL DAY OR
00:56:11.534 --> 00:56:12.602
THEY'RE GOING TO CHANGE THEIR
00:56:12.669 --> 00:56:13.570
START TIME BECAUSE THE SCHOOL
00:56:13.636 --> 00:56:14.304
DAY.
00:56:14.370 --> 00:56:17.207
START TIME AT HAS STARTED --
00:56:17.273 --> 00:56:18.441
IT'S GONNA COST MORE MONEY AS
00:56:18.508 --> 00:56:19.542
IT'S BEEN OUTLINED FOR BUSES
00:56:19.609 --> 00:56:20.744
BECAUSE THERE'S ONLY A CERTAIN
00:56:20.810 --> 00:56:21.644
WONDER YOU GOT TO GET KIDS TO
00:56:21.711 --> 00:56:22.378
SCHOOL RIGHT.
00:56:22.445 --> 00:56:23.446
YOU DON'T WANT THEM GOING TO
00:56:23.513 --> 00:56:24.280
SCHOOL AT TEN THIRTY BECAUSE I
00:56:24.347 --> 00:56:25.448
JUST GONNA DRIVE IN LATER INTO
00:56:25.515 --> 00:56:26.916
THE AFTERNOON WITH THE EARLY
00:56:26.983 --> 00:56:28.885
EVENING HOURS WILL BE AT SCHOOL
00:56:28.952 --> 00:56:31.354
SLEEP I THINK THE THE DOCTOR'S
00:56:31.421 --> 00:56:32.088
POINTED OUT THAT.
00:56:32.155 --> 00:56:33.256
THEN WHEN I HEARD AND SAY THE
00:56:33.323 --> 00:56:34.390
RESEARCH SHOWS THAT YEAH KIDS
00:56:34.457 --> 00:56:35.558
MIGHT HAVE SLEPT TWENTY MINUTES
00:56:35.625 --> 00:56:35.859
MORE THAN.
00:56:35.925 --> 00:56:36.793
ALL OF SUDDEN THEY THEY WENT
00:56:36.860 --> 00:56:38.228
ABOUT TWENTY MINUTES LATER RIGHT
00:56:38.294 --> 00:56:39.863
SO I I DON'T KNOW THAT THIS IS
00:56:39.929 --> 00:56:43.733
NECESSARILY GOING. TO LEAD TO
00:56:43.800 --> 00:56:47.203
MORE -- SLEEP BACK TO THE BUSING
00:56:47.270 --> 00:56:50.740
ISSUE WE WE HAVE KIDS OUT THERE
00:56:50.807 --> 00:56:52.509
ON A BUS IN THE DARK.
00:56:52.575 --> 00:56:53.109
RIGHT BECAUSE OF SOME OF THESE
00:56:53.176 --> 00:56:53.977
RURAL COMMUNITIES WHERE THEY
00:56:54.043 --> 00:56:55.078
WORK IN FACT WE HAVE SOME REAL
00:56:55.145 --> 00:56:56.412
COMMITTEES I THINK STILL HAVE A
00:56:56.479 --> 00:56:57.213
FORTY SCHOOL TO AWAIT.
00:56:57.280 --> 00:56:58.448
RIGHT SO WHAT DOES THAT MEAN FOR
00:56:58.515 --> 00:56:59.282
THEM BECAUSE THEY ONLY HAVE A
00:56:59.349 --> 00:57:00.750
CERTAIN WINDOW TO TO TRANSPORT
00:57:00.817 --> 00:57:01.518
KIDS IN THOSE THOSE ARE THOSE
00:57:01.584 --> 00:57:03.219
ARE SIGNIFICANT SAFETY ISSUES A
00:57:03.286 --> 00:57:03.720
KID SITTING OUT THAT.
00:57:03.787 --> 00:57:04.721
A CHILD SITTING OUT IN THE SNOW
00:57:04.788 --> 00:57:06.422
IN THE DARK I DON'T THINK THAT'S
00:57:06.489 --> 00:57:08.158
THAT THAT'S A HEALTHY SITUATION
00:57:08.224 --> 00:57:10.160
THE BLOCK SCHEDULE THAT HASN'T
00:57:10.226 --> 00:57:11.761
BEEN BROUGHT UP.
00:57:11.828 --> 00:57:12.362
BUT I KNOW WITH MY DAUGHTER I
00:57:12.428 --> 00:57:15.064
THINK SHE'S TO BE A SCHOOL LIKE
00:57:15.131 --> 00:57:15.665
SEVEN FIFTY SEVEN FIFTY FIVE A
00:57:15.732 --> 00:57:16.332
COUPLE DAYS A WEEK AND EVERY DAY
00:57:16.399 --> 00:57:18.067
SHE GOES AT NINE THIRTY SO THIS
00:57:18.134 --> 00:57:19.536
WILL SIGNIFICANTLY IMPACT THE
00:57:19.602 --> 00:57:21.404
BLOCK SCHEDULE THAT THE BLOCK
00:57:21.471 --> 00:57:23.473
SCHEDULE OFFICE OFFERS KIDS.
00:57:23.540 --> 00:57:25.842
STUDENTS AND SCHOOLS INTO AN
00:57:25.909 --> 00:57:28.144
ADVANTAGE IN THE ALSO KIDS WHO
00:57:28.211 --> 00:57:28.945
CREDIT RECOVERY MAKE UP THE BOX
00:57:29.012 --> 00:57:30.747
IT WAS GREAT FOR THEM BECAUSE
00:57:30.814 --> 00:57:31.281
THEY CAN ACTUALLY TAKE X.
00:57:31.347 --> 00:57:31.581
RECURRENCE.
00:57:31.648 --> 00:57:32.182
SO MY FEARS OF THIS WAS THIS
00:57:32.248 --> 00:57:33.817
WOULD ADVERSELY IMPACT.
00:57:33.883 --> 00:57:41.057
THE THE BLOCK SCHEDULE I HAVE
00:57:41.124 --> 00:57:41.457
ANOTHER CONCERN.
00:57:41.524 --> 00:57:42.926
OR OR THOUGHT MAYBE WE SHOULD
00:57:42.992 --> 00:57:44.494
JUST GONNA WRITE A BILL THAT HAS
00:57:44.561 --> 00:57:47.063
PARENTS PUT THEIR KIDS TO BED.
00:57:47.130 --> 00:57:47.697
NINE AND A HALF HOURS BEFORE THE
00:57:47.764 --> 00:57:47.897
STE.
00:57:47.964 --> 00:57:49.566
IN THE SCHOOL STARTS WRITING IS
00:57:49.632 --> 00:57:52.602
REALLY KIND OF AN ISSUE THE
00:57:52.669 --> 00:57:53.203
BOILS DOWN.
00:57:53.269 --> 00:57:54.237
TO OUR PARENTS.
00:57:54.304 --> 00:57:54.938
YOU KNOW INTERACT WITH OUR
00:57:55.004 --> 00:57:55.638
CHILDREN SO SO SO THAT'S AN
00:57:55.705 --> 00:57:56.940
ISSUE THERE IS ANOTHER ISSUE
00:57:57.006 --> 00:57:57.473
THAT'S COME UP AND IT'S AN
00:57:57.540 --> 00:57:57.740
UNKNOWN.
00:57:57.807 --> 00:57:58.341
AND I DON'T THINK WE'RE GONNA
00:57:58.408 --> 00:57:59.876
HAVE AN ANSWER. TO IT RIGHT NOW.
00:57:59.943 --> 00:58:01.344
WOULD IT HAS TO DO WITH EIGHTY A
00:58:01.411 --> 00:58:06.549
MINUTES YOU'VE GOT IT SAYS --
00:58:06.616 --> 00:58:07.584
WITH AN UNKNOWN HERE'S THE BILL --
00:58:07.650 --> 00:58:08.151
AUTHORIZES JUSTER STRONGER
00:58:08.218 --> 00:58:09.552
CLASSES TO A LIMITED NUMBER OF
00:58:09.619 --> 00:58:09.953
PEOPLE'S BEFORE.
00:58:10.019 --> 00:58:11.654
BEFORE THE START OF THE SCHOOL
00:58:11.721 --> 00:58:14.557
DAY -- THAT DO NOT GENERATE ADA
00:58:14.624 --> 00:58:15.859
SO THE THE QUESTION IS HOW DOES
00:58:15.925 --> 00:58:16.893
THAT INTERACTS.
00:58:16.960 --> 00:58:18.094
WITH THE SCHOOLS ABILITY TO
00:58:18.161 --> 00:58:19.262
GENERATE EIGHTY EIGHT WILL THEY
00:58:19.329 --> 00:58:20.930
HAVE ENOUGH MINUTES AT THE END
00:58:20.997 --> 00:58:22.532
OF THE YEAR TO GENERATE ADEQUATE
00:58:22.599 --> 00:58:23.600
ADA SO MAY.
00:58:23.666 --> 00:58:26.102
HAVE A SIGNIFICANT IMPACT ON AT
00:58:26.169 --> 00:58:26.703
AND I DON'T THINK WE HAVE THE
00:58:26.769 --> 00:58:27.303
ANSWER TO THAT THAT'S GOOD I
00:58:27.370 --> 00:58:28.605
CAME UP TODAY AND IT'S GONNA
00:58:28.671 --> 00:58:28.805
TAKE.
00:58:28.872 --> 00:58:30.273
I DON'T THINK THAT YOUR INTENT
00:58:30.340 --> 00:58:31.541
I'M SURE OF THAT WITH THAT THAT
00:58:31.608 --> 00:58:33.209
IS A QUESTION AND AGAIN I WHERE
00:58:33.276 --> 00:58:34.711
I COME FROM IS.
00:58:34.777 --> 00:58:38.047
AGAIN GOOD POLICY POR LAW.
00:58:38.114 --> 00:58:38.681
THAT'S JUST SIMPLY WORST AND I
00:58:38.748 --> 00:58:41.384
DON'T KNOW IF ANYBODY ELSE HAS
00:58:41.451 --> 00:58:43.586
ANY COMMENTS.
00:58:43.653 --> 00:58:44.053
MISTER KALRA.
00:58:44.120 --> 00:58:46.022
THANK YOU MISS SHERRIN THANK YOU
00:58:46.089 --> 00:58:47.690
FOR YOUR THOUGHTS WHICH CAN IN
00:58:47.757 --> 00:58:48.558
YOUR EXPERIENCE AND OUR
00:58:48.625 --> 00:58:49.592
HEARTFELT MEANINGFUL A COUPLE OF
00:58:49.659 --> 00:58:51.094
QUESTIONS FOR THE AUTHOR.
00:58:51.160 --> 00:58:52.896
ONE I UNDERSTAND THIS AS EXAM TO
00:58:52.962 --> 00:58:54.898
RULE SCHOOL DISTRICTS -- WHICH
00:58:54.964 --> 00:58:56.499
WHICH I KNOW HAVE DIFFERENT
00:58:56.566 --> 00:58:58.368
TYPES OF ACTIVITIES.
00:58:58.434 --> 00:58:59.702
THAT -- SOME OF THE URBAN
00:58:59.769 --> 00:59:01.037
DISTRICTS MAY NOT.
00:59:01.104 --> 00:59:06.943
BE ENGAGED AND AND THEN TO THIS
00:59:07.010 --> 00:59:09.946
LAST POINT OF OR THE WHO OPENED
00:59:10.013 --> 00:59:10.980
THE CHAIR TALKING ABOUT.
00:59:11.047 --> 00:59:11.547
YOU HAVING A SERVING CLASSIC
00:59:11.614 --> 00:59:12.181
EARLY IN THE MORNING AND WHAT
00:59:12.248 --> 00:59:13.583
THAT MEANS IN TERMS OF I THINK
00:59:13.650 --> 00:59:14.584
IT'S ITEM FOR THAT SIMPLY SOME
00:59:14.651 --> 00:59:16.085
THE ANALYSIS AND AND LOOKING
00:59:16.152 --> 00:59:17.720
YOUR BILL THERE IS A AN EGG AN
00:59:17.787 --> 00:59:20.590
EXEMPTION OR AT LEAST -- THAT TO
00:59:20.657 --> 00:59:22.225
ALLOW FOR A LIMITED NUMBER OF
00:59:22.292 --> 00:59:23.192
PEOPLE IS TO BE GAUGES CERTAIN
00:59:23.259 --> 00:59:25.094
ACTIVITIES SO -- THAT'S MY
00:59:25.161 --> 00:59:26.629
UNDERSTANDING I DON'T KNOW THAT
00:59:26.696 --> 00:59:28.731
REQUIRES MORE CLARIFICATION AS
00:59:28.798 --> 00:59:29.866
THIS MOVES FORWARD TO MAKE IT
00:59:29.933 --> 00:59:31.601
VERY CLEAR THAT THE KINDS OF
00:59:31.668 --> 00:59:33.803
ACTIVITIES THAT -- THE CHAIR THE
00:59:33.870 --> 00:59:34.737
CHAIR O'DONNELL IS REFERRING TO
00:59:34.804 --> 00:59:36.339
WOULD STILL BE ALLOWED FOR YEAH
00:59:36.406 --> 00:59:38.107
IF I COULD RESPOND. ZERO APPEARS
00:59:38.174 --> 00:59:40.576
EXAM I MEAN THAT THAT'S THAT'S
00:59:40.643 --> 00:59:42.145
THE WHOLE POINT -- IT WAS
00:59:42.211 --> 00:59:46.616
SOMETHING THAT -- THE PTA WAS
00:59:46.683 --> 00:59:48.685
ADAMANT -- IN EXPRESSING BEFORE
00:59:48.751 --> 00:59:49.319
THEY CAME ON BOARD I AGREE WITH
00:59:49.385 --> 00:59:49.752
THAT.
00:59:49.819 --> 00:59:52.388
THOSE OPTIONAL OPT IN.
00:59:52.455 --> 00:59:54.590
PROGRAM THEIR EXAMS YOU KNOW --
00:59:54.657 --> 00:59:57.093
THAT'S THAT'S JUST WHAT THE LAW
00:59:57.160 --> 00:59:58.728
DOES YOU KNOW IF IT NEEDS MORE
00:59:58.795 --> 01:00:00.997
CLARITY WILL BRING MORE BUT WE
01:00:01.064 --> 01:00:03.132
THINK THAT'S PRETTY CLEAR -- AND
01:00:03.199 --> 01:00:04.901
I'M HAPPY TO TO TRY TO TIGHTEN
01:00:04.968 --> 01:00:07.003
THE LANGUAGE BUT YOUR CORRECT
01:00:07.070 --> 01:00:08.438
ASSEMBLY MEMBER THE ZERO PERIOD
01:00:08.504 --> 01:00:10.606
IS EXEMPT -- AN INTERESTING BY
01:00:10.673 --> 01:00:12.675
PRODUCT WHAT SOME SCHOOLS
01:00:12.742 --> 01:00:15.211
ACTUALLY SEE -- IS THAT
01:00:15.278 --> 01:00:17.213
ATTENDANCE AT ZERO PERIOD -- TO
01:00:17.280 --> 01:00:18.715
POSIT A BY PRODUCT THAT MORE
01:00:18.781 --> 01:00:20.116
KIDS WILL OPT INTO THE
01:00:20.183 --> 01:00:21.617
ENRICHMENT PROGRAMS.
01:00:21.684 --> 01:00:23.553
AS ZERO PERIOD MOVES SO FOR
01:00:23.619 --> 01:00:25.488
EXAMPLE IF YOU HAVE A CURRENT
01:00:25.555 --> 01:00:28.358
SCHOOL THAT STARTS AT SEVEN
01:00:28.424 --> 01:00:29.125
THIRTY YOUR APPEARANCE AT SIX
01:00:29.192 --> 01:00:31.160
THIRTY A LOT OF KIDS WON'T.
01:00:31.227 --> 01:00:32.562
OPT INTO A SIX THIRTIES YOU'RE
01:00:32.628 --> 01:00:34.364
PRETTY PARTICULAR WE SEEN BOYS
01:00:34.430 --> 01:00:36.899
MUSIC PROGRAMS WHEN THAT SCHOOL
01:00:36.966 --> 01:00:38.901
MOVES TO EIGHT THIRTY AND ZERO
01:00:38.968 --> 01:00:40.636
APPEARED GOES.
01:00:40.703 --> 01:00:41.204
TO SEVEN THIRTY WE SEEN THE
01:00:41.270 --> 01:00:42.171
NUMBER OF BOYS IN THOSE
01:00:42.238 --> 01:00:43.840
ENRICHMENT PROGRAMS OFTEN AGAIN
01:00:43.906 --> 01:00:45.241
THAT'S VOLUNTARY.
01:00:45.308 --> 01:00:47.010
BUT THAT'S A POSITIVE BY PRODUCT
01:00:47.076 --> 01:00:48.711
OF THAT BUT YOUR PEERS ARE
01:00:48.778 --> 01:00:50.079
EXEMPT.
01:00:50.146 --> 01:00:51.814
AND COMES UP EVERY TIME WE BRING
01:00:51.881 --> 01:00:53.850
IT UP IN THE ANSWERS BUT YEAH SO
01:00:53.916 --> 01:00:54.951
THAT JUSTICE ONE THAT
01:00:55.018 --> 01:00:55.985
CLARIFICATION AND I KNOW THERE'S
01:00:56.052 --> 01:00:56.519
A THERE'S A A NUMBER OF
01:00:56.586 --> 01:00:58.187
DIFFERENT STUDIES AND AND
01:00:58.254 --> 01:00:59.522
THEY'RE STILL -- MAYBE SOME
01:00:59.589 --> 01:01:00.923
LIMIT TO THE NUMBER OF DISTRICTS
01:01:00.990 --> 01:01:03.993
THAT THAT HAVE IMPLEMENTED --
01:01:04.060 --> 01:01:05.495
DELAYED SCHOOL START -- EITHER
01:01:05.561 --> 01:01:06.863
IN THIS STATE OR ANOTHER STATE
01:01:06.929 --> 01:01:08.865
SENATE ACTUALLY DONE STUDIES ON
01:01:08.931 --> 01:01:11.601
IT AND SO -- IF THIS BILL WERE
01:01:11.667 --> 01:01:12.468
TO MOVE FORWARD IF IT EVER GOT
01:01:12.535 --> 01:01:13.836
ENACTED INTO LAW I THINK THAT'LL
01:01:13.903 --> 01:01:15.505
BE IMPORTANT TO GET SOME OF THE
01:01:15.571 --> 01:01:16.839
REPORT BACKS THE STUDIES AS THE
01:01:16.906 --> 01:01:18.975
REAL IMPACTS BECAUSE I THINK
01:01:19.042 --> 01:01:20.143
THERE'S TWO THERE'S TWO VERY
01:01:20.209 --> 01:01:22.512
LEGITIMATE -- OPPOSING OPINIONS --
01:01:22.578 --> 01:01:25.815
BUT I ALSO BELIEVE THAT THE THE
01:01:25.882 --> 01:01:28.084
THE THE THE SCIENCE AND AND I
01:01:28.151 --> 01:01:29.886
KNOW ONE OF THE STUDY SHOWS THAT
01:01:29.952 --> 01:01:31.087
THOUGH THE ONE IS REFERRED TO IN
01:01:31.154 --> 01:01:32.822
THE REPORT IN THE ANALYSIS --
01:01:32.889 --> 01:01:35.425
ACTUALLY ANNOUNCED BY THE STAFF
01:01:35.491 --> 01:01:37.994
BY THE WAY -- THAT IN SEATTLE
01:01:38.061 --> 01:01:39.195
THE LITTER SCHOOL TIMES.
01:01:39.262 --> 01:01:42.165
LED -- TO INCREASING PUNCTUALITY
01:01:42.231 --> 01:01:43.466
AND TEN IS A PERFECTLY AMOUNTS
01:01:43.533 --> 01:01:44.634
ECONOMICALLY DISADVANTAGED.
01:01:44.700 --> 01:01:46.169
SCHOOLS I'M SO I DO THINK THAT
01:01:46.235 --> 01:01:47.537
THERE'S A NUMBER OF X. FACTORS I
01:01:47.603 --> 01:01:49.272
THINK THAT MOVING IT.
01:01:49.338 --> 01:01:50.373
YOUR DOCTOR GONNA HAVE SOME
01:01:50.440 --> 01:01:50.973
PARENTS GONNA BECAUSE OF AN
01:01:51.040 --> 01:01:51.707
ISSUE WITH SOME PARENTS MIGHT
01:01:51.774 --> 01:01:53.409
MAKE IT EASIER -- FOR BUT I DO
01:01:53.476 --> 01:01:55.078
THINK THAT THERE'S NO DOUBT THAT.
01:01:55.144 --> 01:01:56.412
ONCE YOU'RE ACCUSTOMED TO A
01:01:56.479 --> 01:01:57.113
CERTAIN SCHEDULE THAT YOURS YOUR
01:01:57.180 --> 01:01:59.282
SCHEDULE GETS ADJUSTED SO
01:01:59.348 --> 01:02:00.683
THERE'S NO DOUBT THAT IT IT
01:02:00.750 --> 01:02:02.085
WOULD CERTAINLY TAKE.
01:02:02.151 --> 01:02:05.788
SOME EFFORT OF FOR EVERYONE TO
01:02:05.855 --> 01:02:06.923
TO HAVE TO READJUST AND I KNOW
01:02:06.989 --> 01:02:07.356
THAT.
01:02:07.423 --> 01:02:08.691
COSTS -- PARTICULARLY BECOMES
01:02:08.758 --> 01:02:09.992
TRANSPORTATION IS SUCH ARE
01:02:10.059 --> 01:02:11.627
SOMETHING THAT -- WE ALL HAVE TO
01:02:11.694 --> 01:02:15.264
BE CONCERNED ABOUT -- SURE -- I
01:02:15.331 --> 01:02:16.466
WOULD HAVE TO YOU KNOW THE
01:02:16.532 --> 01:02:18.868
DECISION TO COME TO US -- AT
01:02:18.935 --> 01:02:19.535
SOME POINT IF THERE'S A IF THERE
01:02:19.602 --> 01:02:21.771
IS A REAL ISSUE WHEN IT COMES TO
01:02:21.838 --> 01:02:23.072
COST AND TRANSPORTATION WITH
01:02:23.139 --> 01:02:24.941
SOME OF THE DISTANCE I DO HAVE.
01:02:25.007 --> 01:02:26.342
A MORE EXTENSIVE BUSING AND IN
01:02:26.409 --> 01:02:30.246
PARTICULAR -- BUT BUT I I THINK
01:02:30.313 --> 01:02:32.849
THAT -- THE BUT WITH ME IS A
01:02:32.915 --> 01:02:35.284
SIGN IS THE SCIENCE AND AS THE
01:02:35.351 --> 01:02:37.620
CHAIR INDICATED GOOD POLICY --
01:02:37.687 --> 01:02:39.122
GOOD POLICY ISN'T ALWAYS EASY TO
01:02:39.188 --> 01:02:40.756
IMPLEMENT AND SOMETIMES IT'S NOT
01:02:40.823 --> 01:02:41.357
EVEN SUPPOSED TO BE EASY TO
01:02:41.424 --> 01:02:42.658
IMPLEMENT.
01:02:42.725 --> 01:02:43.493
BUT IT DOESN'T MEAN THAT WE
01:02:43.559 --> 01:02:47.330
DON'T PURSUE IT -- AND SO WITH
01:02:47.396 --> 01:03:01.010
THAT I'M I MAKE THEM OUT OF MY
01:03:01.077 --> 01:03:04.247
COMMISSION WITH THE BILL
01:03:04.313 --> 01:03:04.547
[inaudible]
01:03:04.614 --> 01:03:05.815
ANYBODY ELSE.
01:03:05.882 --> 01:03:07.316
SOME REMEMBER SPENT.
01:03:07.383 --> 01:03:07.850
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR I
01:03:07.917 --> 01:03:08.651
PERSONALLY WOULD LIKE TO THANK
01:03:08.718 --> 01:03:09.252
THE AUTHOR MOST SINCERELY FOR
01:03:09.318 --> 01:03:09.886
HIS DILIGENCE IN THIS EFFORT I
01:03:09.952 --> 01:03:10.520
WAS FOLLOWING THIS BEFORE I WAS
01:03:10.586 --> 01:03:11.020
A MEMBER OF THIS BODY.
01:03:11.087 --> 01:03:11.621
AND I KNOW THAT HE APPROACHES
01:03:11.687 --> 01:03:12.722
THIS BECAUSE OF HIS COMMITMENT
01:03:12.788 --> 01:03:13.322
TO OUR YOUNG PEOPLE AND THEIR
01:03:13.389 --> 01:03:13.689
MENTAL HEALTH.
01:03:13.756 --> 01:03:14.357
AND REGRETTABLY I CAN'T BE THERE
01:03:14.423 --> 01:03:14.857
WITH YOU TODAY WITH AN
01:03:14.924 --> 01:03:15.491
AFFIRMATIVE VOTE I AM GOING TO
01:03:15.558 --> 01:03:16.159
ABSTAIN -- BUT I WILL SAY THIS%
01:03:16.225 --> 01:03:16.759
TO OUR COALITION OF EDUCATION
01:03:16.826 --> 01:03:18.027
FOLKS IN THE ROOM.
01:03:18.094 --> 01:03:19.395
THE EVIDENCE IS STARTING TO
01:03:19.462 --> 01:03:21.864
BECOME INCREASINGLY COMPELLING.
01:03:21.931 --> 01:03:23.933
AND WE ARE OBLIGATED AS A STATE
01:03:24.000 --> 01:03:25.735
WITH A SIGNIFICANT MENTAL HEALTH
01:03:25.801 --> 01:03:28.070
CRISIS TO START LOOKING AT HOW
01:03:28.137 --> 01:03:29.772
WE STOP THIS WITH OUR YOUTH.
01:03:29.839 --> 01:03:31.541
AND I CANNOT CONTINUE TO TALK TO
01:03:31.607 --> 01:03:32.875
DISTRICT AFTER DISTRICT TO SAYS
01:03:32.942 --> 01:03:33.876
WE NEED MORE COUNSELLING SUPPORT
01:03:33.943 --> 01:03:35.444
WE NEED A PSYCHOLOGIST ON STAFF
01:03:35.511 --> 01:03:37.013
ABSOLUTELY OF COURSE YOU DO.
01:03:37.079 --> 01:03:38.147
BUT IF THERE IS SOMETHING THAT
01:03:38.214 --> 01:03:39.682
WE CAN DO LIKE THIS THAT WE CAN
01:03:39.749 --> 01:03:41.117
FIGURE OUT THE LOGISTICS OF THAT
01:03:41.184 --> 01:03:43.386
WE CAN FUND OF THE LOGISTICS OF
01:03:43.452 --> 01:03:44.921
TO HELP GIVE OUR STUDENTS ONE
01:03:44.987 --> 01:03:46.422
MORE MEASURE OF SUCCESS AN
01:03:46.489 --> 01:03:47.890
OPPORTUNITY. TO HAVE THAT
01:03:47.957 --> 01:03:49.592
BALANCE IN MENTAL HEALTH WE
01:03:49.659 --> 01:03:50.526
OUGHT TO DO IT AND SO MY
01:03:50.593 --> 01:03:52.261
COMMITMENT IS TO THIS AUTHORS IF
01:03:52.328 --> 01:03:54.297
WE DON'T GET THIS OUT TODAY AND
01:03:54.363 --> 01:03:55.631
I HATE TO NOT BE A PART OF THAT
01:03:55.698 --> 01:03:56.666
BUT WE NEED TO CONTINUE TO MOVE
01:03:56.732 --> 01:03:57.833
THE CONVERSATION BECAUSE
01:03:57.900 --> 01:03:59.001
SOMETIMES WE COMPEL GOOD.
01:03:59.068 --> 01:04:01.137
POLICY CHANGE BY FORCE AND
01:04:01.204 --> 01:04:02.305
SOMETIMES WE COMPILE IT BY AN
01:04:02.371 --> 01:04:04.207
OVERWHELMING AMOUNT OF EVIDENCE
01:04:04.273 --> 01:04:05.441
THAT SAYS IT IS NOW THE RIGHT
01:04:05.508 --> 01:04:07.910
THING TO DO AND IN THAT FIGHT
01:04:07.977 --> 01:04:11.214
AND I AM WITH YOU.
01:04:11.280 --> 01:04:12.582
THANK YOU IF GO AHEAD DOCTOR
01:04:12.648 --> 01:04:14.350
WEBER YES I I DO WANT TO THANK
01:04:14.417 --> 01:04:15.818
THE AUTHOR -- HE'S BEEN VERY
01:04:15.885 --> 01:04:18.120
PERSISTENT AND WITH REGARDS TO
01:04:18.187 --> 01:04:19.989
THIS BILL AND AND OBVIOUSLY IT'S
01:04:20.056 --> 01:04:21.524
EXTREMELY IMPORTANT TO HIM.
01:04:21.591 --> 01:04:24.093
AN IMPORTANT TO TO ALL OF US WHO
01:04:24.160 --> 01:04:26.562
I THINK YOU'RE ABOUT KIDS -- YOU
01:04:26.629 --> 01:04:27.797
KNOW MY MY CONTACT WITH THIS IF
01:04:27.863 --> 01:04:29.232
INFORMATION GOES WAY BACK TO
01:04:29.298 --> 01:04:30.166
WHEN I WAS ON THE SCHOOL BOARD
01:04:30.233 --> 01:04:31.601
WHICH IS SOME TWENTY SOME ODD
01:04:31.667 --> 01:04:33.936
YEARS AGO -- WHERE THE RESEARCH
01:04:34.003 --> 01:04:35.504
BEGAN AND AND PEOPLE BEGIN TO
01:04:35.571 --> 01:04:38.374
TALK ABOUT THE NEED FOR CHANGE
01:04:38.441 --> 01:04:39.976
AND IT'S NOT AN EASY THING I
01:04:40.042 --> 01:04:41.377
THINK THE THE MOST DIFFICULT
01:04:41.444 --> 01:04:42.511
TIME EVER HAD ON SCHOOL BOY WAS
01:04:42.578 --> 01:04:43.846
SIMPLY CHANGING TIMES?
01:04:43.913 --> 01:04:46.382
WHEN SCHOOL STARTS AND STOPS?
01:04:46.449 --> 01:04:47.316
FOUR HOURS WAS FOR BUSING
01:04:47.383 --> 01:04:49.352
REASONS MUCH MORE THAN ACADEMIC
01:04:49.418 --> 01:04:51.020
REASONS AND IT ALWAYS SEEMS LIKE
01:04:51.087 --> 01:04:52.755
IT'S GOING TO CREATE THE END OF
01:04:52.822 --> 01:04:54.590
THE WORLD FOR PEOPLE TO CHANGE
01:04:54.657 --> 01:04:56.058
FROM TWENTY MINUTES TO THIRTY
01:04:56.125 --> 01:04:56.325
MINUTES.
01:04:56.392 --> 01:04:58.694
WHATEVER IT MAY BE AND AND YET
01:04:58.761 --> 01:05:00.096
AND YOU TAKE THAT HARD DECISION
01:05:00.162 --> 01:05:01.697
YOU MAKE WHAT YOU HAVE TO DO AND
01:05:01.764 --> 01:05:03.666
AND INTERESTINGLY ENOUGH THEN
01:05:03.733 --> 01:05:05.501
PEOPLE GO ON WITH THEIR LIVES.
01:05:05.568 --> 01:05:06.469
THEY MAKE THE ADJUSTMENT THEY
01:05:06.535 --> 01:05:08.404
MOVE ON A EVEN FORGET WHAT THAT
01:05:08.471 --> 01:05:09.238
THE STARTING TIME USED TO BE
01:05:09.305 --> 01:05:10.206
BECAUSE NOW THEY'RE ON A
01:05:10.273 --> 01:05:12.275
DIFFERENT TIME AND AFTER.
01:05:12.341 --> 01:05:13.409
WE ADJUST THEIR LIVES TO MAKE IT
01:05:13.476 --> 01:05:15.778
HAPPEN -- THIS IS REALLY ABOUT
01:05:15.845 --> 01:05:17.046
BUT I THINK THAT THE THE MOST
01:05:17.113 --> 01:05:18.347
IMPORTANT THING ABOUT THIS IS
01:05:18.414 --> 01:05:19.915
THAT THIS IS REALLY ABOUT WHAT
01:05:19.982 --> 01:05:21.984
IS GOOD FOR KIDS.
01:05:22.051 --> 01:05:24.287
AND WHAT THE HELPS THEM -- TO
01:05:24.353 --> 01:05:25.755
BASICALLY IT JUST WELL AND TO DO
01:05:25.821 --> 01:05:28.024
WELL IN SCHOOL AND WE SHOULD BE
01:05:28.090 --> 01:05:29.158
SEEKING EVERY.
01:05:29.225 --> 01:05:31.727
METHOD THAT WE CAN FIND TO MAKE
01:05:31.794 --> 01:05:33.362
THE WORLD BETTER FOR OUR KIDS.
01:05:33.429 --> 01:05:35.931
WE SEEM TO BE IN AN AVALANCHE OF
01:05:35.998 --> 01:05:37.933
PROBLEMS IN TERMS OF THE KIDS
01:05:38.000 --> 01:05:40.569
HAVING ISSUES AND DEPRESSION AND
01:05:40.636 --> 01:05:42.138
SUICIDE.
01:05:42.204 --> 01:05:43.572
ALL KINDS OF THINGS THAT WE JUST
01:05:43.639 --> 01:05:46.042
FEEL OVERWHELMED BY AT AND AND
01:05:46.108 --> 01:05:47.677
WELL THIS IS NOT A SILVER BULLET
01:05:47.743 --> 01:05:49.345
IT HAS SOME EVIDENCE THAT SAYS
01:05:49.412 --> 01:05:50.746
THIS CAN BE DONE.
01:05:50.813 --> 01:05:51.781
AND IT CAN BE DONE TO THE
01:05:51.847 --> 01:05:53.049
BENEFIT OF OUR CHILDREN.
01:05:53.115 --> 01:05:54.950
AND I KNOW EVERY DISTRICT WANTS
01:05:55.017 --> 01:05:56.686
TO DECIDE IT'S ONLY ISSUES.
01:05:56.752 --> 01:05:57.753
I'VE HAD A LOT OF THESE
01:05:57.820 --> 01:05:59.422
DISTRICTS WHO ASKED ME THAT WE
01:05:59.488 --> 01:06:01.190
DO THIS SO THEY THEY DON'T HAVE
01:06:01.257 --> 01:06:03.125
TO FIGHT THE BATTLE AT THE LOCAL
01:06:03.192 --> 01:06:04.060
LEVEL AND DEAL WITH ALL THE
01:06:04.126 --> 01:06:05.728
PARENTS TO COME IN THE SCREAMING
01:06:05.795 --> 01:06:06.295
AND THE HOLLERING AND THEN
01:06:06.362 --> 01:06:12.635
THEY'RE SUBJECT TO ELECTION AND
01:06:12.702 --> 01:06:12.935
THEY DON'T.
01:06:13.002 --> 01:06:15.838
KNOW OVERWHELMED BY IT -- BUT
01:06:15.905 --> 01:06:16.739
YOU KNOW I'VE LISTEN TO THIS THE
01:06:16.806 --> 01:06:17.340
STORIES FOR A VERY LONG TIME
01:06:17.406 --> 01:06:18.374
ABOUT WHY WE SHOULDN'T DO IT AND
01:06:18.441 --> 01:06:18.908
AND ALL THE THINGS THAT.
01:06:18.974 --> 01:06:19.408
THAT YOU GIVE PEOPLE AN
01:06:19.475 --> 01:06:20.176
OPPORTUNITY TO BE IN CHARGE OF
01:06:20.242 --> 01:06:20.976
AND TO TAKE AND AND WHAT WE
01:06:21.043 --> 01:06:22.845
BELIEVE IN LOCAL CONTROL OF THE
01:06:22.912 --> 01:06:25.214
REALITY IS WE DO A LOT OF THINGS
01:06:25.281 --> 01:06:26.482
THAT ARE NOT LOCAL CONTROL AND
01:06:26.549 --> 01:06:27.683
WITH ITS TERMS OF CURRICULUM AND
01:06:27.750 --> 01:06:28.918
ALL THOSE KINDS OF THINGS THAT
01:06:28.984 --> 01:06:29.485
WE REALIZE.
01:06:29.552 --> 01:06:31.087
HAVE TO BE DONE AT THIS LEVEL
01:06:31.153 --> 01:06:31.721
THAT'S IN THE BEST INTEREST OF
01:06:31.787 --> 01:06:34.890
OUR KIDS SO THIS IS A DIFFICULT.
01:06:34.957 --> 01:06:37.226
DECISION -- BUT IT'S ONE THAT I
01:06:37.293 --> 01:06:38.894
THINK IS IS WORTH DOING.
01:06:38.961 --> 01:06:40.229
AND EVEN ONE OF OUR MEMBERS
01:06:40.296 --> 01:06:41.931
TALKED ABOUT LAST TIME WAS ON
01:06:41.997 --> 01:06:43.399
THE FLOOR AND THIS IS PROBABLY
01:06:43.466 --> 01:06:45.167
THE CHEAPEST THING WE CAN DO TO
01:06:45.234 --> 01:06:46.802
IMPROVE THE LIVES OF OUR KIDS.
01:06:46.869 --> 01:06:48.170
EVEN THOUGH WE KNOW IT'S GOING
01:06:48.237 --> 01:06:49.271
TO TAKE MONEY FOR BUSING IN
01:06:49.338 --> 01:06:50.906
THOSE KINDS OF THINGS BUT WHEN
01:06:50.973 --> 01:06:52.508
YOU LOOK AT THE OUTCOME IT'S
01:06:52.575 --> 01:06:53.876
WORTH WHATEVER THE EXPENSES THAT
01:06:53.943 --> 01:06:55.378
WE SAVE ONE LIFE.
01:06:55.444 --> 01:06:56.746
IT IS TRULY WORTH IT IF WE CAN
01:06:56.812 --> 01:06:58.781
TRANSFORM MANY OF THE SCHOOLS TO
01:06:58.848 --> 01:07:01.851
HIGHER PERFORMING SCHOOLS -- IT
01:07:01.917 --> 01:07:02.852
IS TRULY WORTH IT BECAUSE WE
01:07:02.918 --> 01:07:04.153
HAVE TRIED SO MUCH AND WE HAVE
01:07:04.220 --> 01:07:05.721
PUT SO MUCH MONEY INTO SO MANY
01:07:05.788 --> 01:07:08.057
OTHER THINGS THAT HAVE NOT
01:07:08.124 --> 01:07:08.491
WORKED.
01:07:08.557 --> 01:07:10.793
AND AND IT BRINGS WEEK MAKES ME
01:07:10.860 --> 01:07:12.795
QUITE SAD YOU KNOW I WAS AT A
01:07:12.862 --> 01:07:13.896
SCHOOL.
01:07:13.963 --> 01:07:16.665
OF THIS WEEKEND AT A AT A SWIM
01:07:16.732 --> 01:07:18.234
MEET FOR MY GRANDKIDS.
01:07:18.300 --> 01:07:18.834
WHEN I JUST HAPPEN TO LOOK AT
01:07:18.901 --> 01:07:19.969
THE DATA FOR THE SCHOOL BECAUSE
01:07:20.035 --> 01:07:21.804
I WAS GOING TO SCHOOL NEED TO
01:07:21.871 --> 01:07:23.339
FIND WHERE IT WAS AND?
01:07:23.406 --> 01:07:26.275
AND WAS IN A COMMUNITY -- AND IT
01:07:26.342 --> 01:07:27.309
MACAM COMMUNIS MAJORITY WHITE
01:07:27.376 --> 01:07:28.944
BUT IT'S SUPPORT COMMUNITY AND I
01:07:29.011 --> 01:07:30.713
WAS I WAS REALLY QUITE UPSET
01:07:30.780 --> 01:07:31.947
WHEN I GOT THERE TO THIS AND AND
01:07:32.014 --> 01:07:34.417
I LOOK AT THE DATA THAT OVER
01:07:34.483 --> 01:07:35.017
HALF OF THE KIDS DROP OUT OF
01:07:35.084 --> 01:07:35.751
SCHOOL.
01:07:35.818 --> 01:07:38.354
OVER HALF OF THE KIDS IN THIS
01:07:38.421 --> 01:07:40.189
DISTRICT DROP OUT OF SCHOOL.
01:07:40.256 --> 01:07:40.990
AND THEY'RE IN THE 30% OFF AND
01:07:41.056 --> 01:07:41.991
ON AND ON AND ON AND WENT ON AND
01:07:42.057 --> 01:07:44.727
ON AND AND I WAS JUST LIKE MY
01:07:44.794 --> 01:07:46.228
GOODNESS WHAT IS GOING ON HERE
01:07:46.295 --> 01:07:47.630
WHY ISN'T THERE.
01:07:47.696 --> 01:07:48.798
A BILL BEING WRONG WHY ISN'T
01:07:48.864 --> 01:07:50.199
THERE SOME ALARM OCCURRING.
01:07:50.266 --> 01:07:52.401
AND AND I KNOW THAT IN THIS ONE
01:07:52.468 --> 01:07:54.336
COMMUNITY THERE'S A LOT OF
01:07:54.403 --> 01:07:55.905
DRINKING THERE'S A LOT OF OF CAR
01:07:55.971 --> 01:07:57.973
ACCIDENTS THAT HAPPEN IS A LOT
01:07:58.040 --> 01:07:59.008
OF TRAUMA AND STRESS.
01:07:59.074 --> 01:08:00.676
AND IN THE END ONE OF THE EAST
01:08:00.743 --> 01:08:02.077
COUNTY SCHOOLS IN SENEGAL COUNTY
01:08:02.144 --> 01:08:03.746
AND IT'S NOT IN MY DISTRICT BUT
01:08:03.813 --> 01:08:04.647
I JUST HAPPEN TO LOOK AT THE
01:08:04.713 --> 01:08:06.615
DATA OF WHAT I SAW AND I SAW A
01:08:06.682 --> 01:08:07.783
LOT OF TRAGEDY.
01:08:07.850 --> 01:08:09.251
AND A LOT OF PAIN IN THIS
01:08:09.318 --> 01:08:11.220
DISTRICT JUST LOOKING AT THE
01:08:11.287 --> 01:08:13.355
INFORMATION OF AND I THOUGHT TO
01:08:13.422 --> 01:08:15.458
MYSELF AND I'VE GOT TO TALK TO
01:08:15.524 --> 01:08:17.493
MY COLLEAGUE WHO'S THAT THE
01:08:17.560 --> 01:08:19.094
SCHOOLS A MEMBER THERE.
01:08:19.161 --> 01:08:20.029
WHY HAVEN'T YOU SET A SET THE
01:08:20.095 --> 01:08:21.430
ALARM WHY HAVEN'T YOU RAISE THIS
01:08:21.497 --> 01:08:22.431
ISSUE I MEAN IT'S INCOME IT IS
01:08:22.498 --> 01:08:23.399
UNACCEPTABLE IN THIS IN THIS DAY
01:08:23.466 --> 01:08:25.701
AND AGE TO HAVE OVER 50% OF YOUR
01:08:25.768 --> 01:08:26.735
KIDS NOT GRADUATED FROM HIGH
01:08:26.802 --> 01:08:27.203
SCHOOL?
01:08:27.269 --> 01:08:29.205
AND AND SO I THINK THERE'S JUST
01:08:29.271 --> 01:08:30.272
SO MANY THINGS GOING ON IN SO
01:08:30.339 --> 01:08:32.041
MUCH PAIN IS SO MUCH DIFFICULTY
01:08:32.107 --> 01:08:34.109
IN FAMILIES AND ALL KINDS OF
01:08:34.176 --> 01:08:34.743
THINGS THAT WE CAN DO A LITTLE
01:08:34.810 --> 01:08:36.245
BIT OF SOMETHING. TO MAKE IT A
01:08:36.312 --> 01:08:38.214
LITTLE BIT BETTER -- AND THIS IS
01:08:38.280 --> 01:08:39.882
SOMETHING THAT CAN BE DONE --
01:08:39.949 --> 01:08:42.017
SAN DIEGO UNIFIED IS IS WORKING
01:08:42.084 --> 01:08:42.852
ON BASICALLY DOING THEIR
01:08:42.918 --> 01:08:44.720
DISTRICT AND IN THIS WAY BECAUSE
01:08:44.787 --> 01:08:46.455
THEY REALIZE THAT WE'VE GOT TO
01:08:46.522 --> 01:08:47.423
DO A BETTER JOB.
01:08:47.490 --> 01:08:51.961
IT WILL BE TO BEEN DOING AND IF
01:08:52.027 --> 01:08:53.229
THIS CAN HELP.
01:08:53.295 --> 01:08:55.030
ALLEVIATE THE PROBLEM SOLVE SOME
01:08:55.097 --> 01:08:55.998
OF IT WE CAN'T SO I WANNA THANK
01:08:56.065 --> 01:08:57.166
THE AUTHOR FOR COMING TODAY.
01:08:57.233 --> 01:08:59.401
I'LL BE SUPPORTING THIS AGAIN
01:08:59.468 --> 01:09:00.536
BECAUSE I'VE COME UP LIKE I SAID
01:09:00.603 --> 01:09:01.170
I'VE KNOWN THIS FOR OVER TWENTY
01:09:01.237 --> 01:09:01.837
SOME ODD YEARS AND HAVE NOT BEEN
01:09:01.904 --> 01:09:02.471
ABLE TO MOVE DISTRICTS IN THAT
01:09:02.538 --> 01:09:03.939
DIRECTION -- BUT I THINK AT THE
01:09:04.006 --> 01:09:05.441
STATE LEVEL IF WE CAN PROVIDE
01:09:05.508 --> 01:09:06.942
THE DIRECTION IN THE SUPPORT
01:09:07.009 --> 01:09:08.177
THAT'S NECESSARY THAT MAKES THE
01:09:08.244 --> 01:09:09.712
TRANSFORMATION EASIER FOR
01:09:09.778 --> 01:09:11.447
DISTRICTS WE HAVE TO DO THAT FOR
01:09:11.514 --> 01:09:14.283
OUR KIDS OF NOTHING ELSE THANK
01:09:14.350 --> 01:09:16.285
YOU SO MUCH.
01:09:16.352 --> 01:09:17.219
THANK YOU A SINGLE OF MR KILEY
01:09:17.286 --> 01:09:19.021
I'M SORRY.
01:09:19.088 --> 01:09:20.589
THIS IS THAT I BELIEVE THE THIRD
01:09:20.656 --> 01:09:22.391
TIME THIS BILLS COME BEFORE THIS
01:09:22.458 --> 01:09:24.627
COMMITTEE -- AND ALTHOUGH SHE
01:09:24.693 --> 01:09:25.594
SAID IT'S NOT THE SAME BILL --
01:09:25.661 --> 01:09:27.796
IT -- THIS TIME AROUND -- EXAMS
01:09:27.863 --> 01:09:29.598
RURAL DISTRICTS.
01:09:29.665 --> 01:09:31.734
IT -- STAGGER START TIMES FOR
01:09:31.800 --> 01:09:33.168
MIDDLE SCHOOLS AND HIGH SCHOOLS
01:09:33.235 --> 01:09:34.403
WHICH IT DIDN'T DO BEFORE.
01:09:34.470 --> 01:09:35.871
THE PROVIDES GREATER FLEXIBILITY
01:09:35.938 --> 01:09:37.306
IN THE PREVIOUS VERSIONS OF THE
01:09:37.373 --> 01:09:38.674
BILL ALTHOUGH IN MY VIEW STILL
01:09:38.741 --> 01:09:40.342
NOT ENOUGH STILL NOT THE
01:09:40.409 --> 01:09:41.510
APPROPRIATE LEVEL OF FLEXIBILITY
01:09:41.577 --> 01:09:43.546
AND STILL HAS SOME WAY TO GO IN
01:09:43.612 --> 01:09:45.981
THAT RESPECT -- WHEN I'VE BEEN
01:09:46.048 --> 01:09:47.683
WHEN I FAILED TO VOTE FOR THIS
01:09:47.750 --> 01:09:48.551
BILL IN THE PAST?
01:09:48.617 --> 01:09:49.652
IT'S BEEN.
01:09:49.718 --> 01:09:52.488
A DIFFICULT DECISION BECAUSE THE
01:09:52.555 --> 01:09:54.223
EVIDENCE I THINK IS QUITE
01:09:54.290 --> 01:09:55.791
POWERFUL I THINK THAT THE WEIGHT
01:09:55.858 --> 01:09:57.026
OF THE EVIDENCE ALTHOUGH
01:09:57.092 --> 01:09:58.460
APPARENTLY THERE ARE SOME.
01:09:58.527 --> 01:09:59.562
CONFLICTING STUDIES BUT THE
01:09:59.628 --> 01:10:02.097
WEIGHT OF THE EVIDENCE SUGGESTS
01:10:02.164 --> 01:10:03.899
THERE ARE BENEFITS ALONG.
01:10:03.966 --> 01:10:05.601
SEVERAL DIMENSIONS -- TO OUR
01:10:05.668 --> 01:10:08.137
KIDS WHEN WE START SCHOOL LATER
01:10:08.203 --> 01:10:10.539
AND OUT FROM REDUCE TRAFFIC
01:10:10.606 --> 01:10:11.807
ACCIDENTS.
01:10:11.874 --> 01:10:12.908
TO GRAB INCREASE GRADUATION
01:10:12.975 --> 01:10:14.143
RATES TO IMPROVED ACADEMIC
01:10:14.209 --> 01:10:16.512
PERFORMANCE -- AND TO WHAT
01:10:16.579 --> 01:10:17.980
REALLY STRUCK ME WAS THAT MENTAL
01:10:18.047 --> 01:10:20.382
HEALTH CONSEQUENCES THIS IS BEEN
01:10:20.449 --> 01:10:21.116
A FOCUS OF OUR COMMITTEE WE
01:10:21.183 --> 01:10:22.952
CONVENE AND ADD A INFORMATIONAL
01:10:23.018 --> 01:10:24.253
HEARING EARLIER THIS YEAR.
01:10:24.320 --> 01:10:25.321
REALLY FOCUSED ON THE VERY
01:10:25.387 --> 01:10:26.855
SERIOUS ISSUE OF MENTAL HEALTH
01:10:26.922 --> 01:10:28.324
IN OUR SCHOOLS THE CHAIR AND I
01:10:28.390 --> 01:10:30.025
HAVE JOINTLY AUTHORED BILLS TO
01:10:30.092 --> 01:10:32.294
TRY TO IMPROVE MENTAL HEALTH IN
01:10:32.361 --> 01:10:33.429
OUR SCHOOLS AND THERE'S STILL A
01:10:33.495 --> 01:10:34.196
LOT OF WORK TO DO BUT THE
01:10:34.263 --> 01:10:34.863
EVIDENCE.
01:10:34.930 --> 01:10:36.799
HERE IS VERY POWERFUL WHEN IT
01:10:36.865 --> 01:10:38.367
COMES TO THE IMPACT ON YOUTH
01:10:38.434 --> 01:10:40.069
MENTAL HEALTH OVER SIXTY STUDIES
01:10:40.135 --> 01:10:42.271
LINK SLEEP LOSS WITH SUICIDES
01:10:42.338 --> 01:10:44.273
TEENAGER THE MOST SLEEP DEPRIVED
01:10:44.340 --> 01:10:45.007
AGE GROUP THEY'RE DEVELOPING
01:10:45.074 --> 01:10:45.407
BRAINS.
01:10:45.474 --> 01:10:46.241
ARE ALSO THE MOST VULNERABLE TO
01:10:46.308 --> 01:10:47.776
SUICIDAL THOUGHTS AND THE RISK
01:10:47.843 --> 01:10:49.511
OF SUICIDE DECREASES BY ELEVEN
01:10:49.578 --> 01:10:50.245
AT PERCENT.
01:10:50.312 --> 01:10:55.751
WITH EACH ADDITIONAL HOUR OF
01:10:55.818 --> 01:10:57.820
SLEEP.
01:10:57.886 --> 01:10:58.754
SO WHAT HELD ME BACK FROM
01:10:58.821 --> 01:10:59.388
SUPPORTING THE BILL IN THE PAST
01:10:59.455 --> 01:11:00.489
IS THIS IDEA OF LOCAL CONTROL.
01:11:00.556 --> 01:11:03.025
AT THESE DECISIONS ARE BEST MADE
01:11:03.092 --> 01:11:03.659
BY IN AT THE LEVEL WHERE IT IS
01:11:03.726 --> 01:11:05.728
CLOSEST TO THE FAMILIES THAT ARE
01:11:05.794 --> 01:11:06.228
AFFECTED.
01:11:06.295 --> 01:11:08.530
AND AND LOCAL CONTROL ALLOWS FOR
01:11:08.597 --> 01:11:10.265
DIFFERENT APPROACHES TO BE TRIED
01:11:10.332 --> 01:11:11.500
AND SUCCESS TO BE REPLICATED THE
01:11:11.567 --> 01:11:12.835
TRUTH IS WE DON'T.
01:11:12.901 --> 01:11:15.004
ALLOW FOR NEARLY ENOUGH LOCAL
01:11:15.070 --> 01:11:16.705
CONTROL IN THE STATE.
01:11:16.772 --> 01:11:17.873
WE HAVE -- THIS FIRM IS INVOKED
01:11:17.940 --> 01:11:18.941
SO SELECTIVELY.
01:11:19.008 --> 01:11:20.709
OUR EDUCATION CODE IS WAY
01:11:20.776 --> 01:11:22.011
THICKER THAN IT SHOULD BE
01:11:22.077 --> 01:11:23.145
COMPARED TO OTHER STATE IS ONE
01:11:23.212 --> 01:11:24.713
OF THE REASONS OUR EDUCATIONAL
01:11:24.780 --> 01:11:25.914
OUTCOMES.
01:11:25.981 --> 01:11:27.349
LACK.
01:11:27.416 --> 01:11:29.985
AND IT'S TRUE THAT I'VE HAD OVER
01:11:30.052 --> 01:11:31.520
THE COURSE OF THAT. THREE TIMES
01:11:31.587 --> 01:11:33.422
I CONSIDER THIS BILL MANY SCHOOL
01:11:33.489 --> 01:11:34.790
LEADERS DISTRICT LEADERS SCHOOL
01:11:34.857 --> 01:11:36.625
WHERE MEMBERS REACH OUT AND SAY
01:11:36.692 --> 01:11:37.726
THIS IS A MATTER FOR OUR
01:11:37.793 --> 01:11:40.062
DISTRICT TO THE SIDE -- AFTER
01:11:40.129 --> 01:11:40.562
RECEIVING INPUT FROM OUR
01:11:40.629 --> 01:11:41.630
COMMUNITY.
01:11:41.697 --> 01:11:43.399
BUT LIKE DOCTOR WEBER I'VE ALSO
01:11:43.465 --> 01:11:44.033
HEARD.
01:11:44.099 --> 01:11:45.734
FROM SCHOOL LEADERS AND DISTRICT
01:11:45.801 --> 01:11:46.468
LEADERS.
01:11:46.535 --> 01:11:47.870
WHO SAY THAT THEY WOULD LIKE TO
01:11:47.936 --> 01:11:49.204
MOVE IN THIS DIRECTION BUT THERE
01:11:49.271 --> 01:11:50.506
ARE SYSTEMIC BARRIERS TO DOING
01:11:50.572 --> 01:11:53.342
SO -- THE SUPERINTENDENT OF ONE
01:11:53.409 --> 01:11:54.510
OF THE DISTRICTS IN THE AREA I
01:11:54.576 --> 01:11:57.046
REPRESENT -- MADE THE POINT THAT
01:11:57.112 --> 01:11:58.947
IF THEY'RE JUST RECORDED CHANGED
01:11:59.014 --> 01:12:00.582
AND THEY'D BE OUT OF SYNC WITH
01:12:00.649 --> 01:12:02.818
THE NEIGHBORING SCHOOL DISTRICTS
01:12:02.885 --> 01:12:04.186
WHICH WOULD PRESENT A LOT OF
01:12:04.253 --> 01:12:05.387
CHALLENGES IN TERMS OF ENTRY
01:12:05.454 --> 01:12:06.989
EXTRACURRICULAR ACTIVITIES.
01:12:07.056 --> 01:12:07.823
AND OTHER THINGS AND THERE'S
01:12:07.890 --> 01:12:08.991
EMPIRICAL EVIDENCE TO SUPPORT
01:12:09.058 --> 01:12:10.526
THIS IDEAS WELL THERE'S AN
01:12:10.592 --> 01:12:11.827
ARTICLE HERE FROM THE JOURNAL OF
01:12:11.894 --> 01:12:13.495
EDUCATION -- AND HEALTH WOOD
01:12:13.562 --> 01:12:14.897
SAYS THE BECAUSE OF LOCAL WISE
01:12:14.963 --> 01:12:16.699
CONTROL NEIGHBORING SCHOOLS ARE
01:12:16.765 --> 01:12:18.300
NOT ANSWERABLE TO EACH OTHER AND
01:12:18.367 --> 01:12:20.436
REGIONAL ATTEMPTS AT CHANGE CAN
01:12:20.502 --> 01:12:21.804
BE THWARTED BY ONE SCHOOL BOARD.
01:12:21.870 --> 01:12:23.205
LOCAL CONTROL HAS BECOME IN THIS
01:12:23.272 --> 01:12:24.707
INSTANCE THE REASON THAT SCHOOL
01:12:24.773 --> 01:12:26.275
LOCAL SCHOOL BOARDS HAVE LIMITED
01:12:26.341 --> 01:12:27.876
CONTROL OVER THEIR ABILITY TO
01:12:27.943 --> 01:12:29.278
ACT ON THE RECOMMENDATIONS OF
01:12:29.344 --> 01:12:30.813
THE NATION'S PEDIATRICIANS.
01:12:30.879 --> 01:12:34.016
LOCAL CONTROL BECOMES LOCAL LACK
01:12:34.083 --> 01:12:34.450
OF CONTROL.
01:12:34.516 --> 01:12:35.651
THIS PARADOX AND OF COURSE THE
01:12:35.718 --> 01:12:37.019
OVERWHELMING SCIENTIFIC EVIDENCE
01:12:37.086 --> 01:12:38.454
IS WHY MANY EXPERTS ARE CALLING
01:12:38.520 --> 01:12:40.355
FOR THE STATE'S TO STEP IN THE
01:12:40.422 --> 01:12:42.357
STATE HEALTHY BOUNDARIES. FOR
01:12:42.424 --> 01:12:44.059
SCHOOL START TIMES.
01:12:44.126 --> 01:12:44.493
SO.
01:12:44.560 --> 01:12:45.828
BECAUSE OF THIS COLLECTIVE
01:12:45.894 --> 01:12:47.229
ACTION PROBLEM I THINK THE LOCAL
01:12:47.296 --> 01:12:48.497
CONTROL ARGUMENT AT LEAST CUTS
01:12:48.564 --> 01:12:49.798
BOTH WAYS.
01:12:49.865 --> 01:12:51.533
AT THAT POINT I THINK IT'S ONLY
01:12:51.600 --> 01:12:53.268
FAIR TO DEFER TO THE OVERALL IN
01:12:53.335 --> 01:12:54.603
WYOMING WEIGHT OF SCIENTIFIC
01:12:54.670 --> 01:12:57.072
EVIDENCE AS FAR AS WHAT IS IN
01:12:57.139 --> 01:12:57.406
THE INTEREST.
01:12:57.473 --> 01:13:00.175
OF OUR KIDS -- NOW THAT BEING
01:13:00.242 --> 01:13:02.144
SAID I AS I SAID BEFORE I STILL
01:13:02.211 --> 01:13:03.312
DON'T THINK THERE IS ENOUGH
01:13:03.378 --> 01:13:04.580
FLEXIBILITY.
01:13:04.646 --> 01:13:05.547
IN THE BILL SO I JUST WANT TO
01:13:05.614 --> 01:13:07.349
ASK THE AUTHOR I WOULD YOU
01:13:07.416 --> 01:13:09.251
COMMIT AND FOR WHAT IT IS ONE
01:13:09.318 --> 01:13:10.285
EXAMPLE WITH DISTRICTS THAT HAVE
01:13:10.352 --> 01:13:12.387
A ULTIPLE CONFIGURATIONS OF
01:13:12.454 --> 01:13:13.188
RATE LEVELS.
01:13:13.255 --> 01:13:14.089
THIS CAN PRESENT UNIQUE
01:13:14.156 --> 01:13:15.290
CHALLENGES IN TERMS OF
01:13:15.357 --> 01:13:17.126
TRANSPORTATION OTHER THINGS SO I
01:13:17.192 --> 01:13:17.726
WHAT WOULD YOU BE WILLING TO
01:13:17.793 --> 01:13:19.094
COMMIT TO WORKING TO ADDRESS
01:13:19.161 --> 01:13:20.562
SOME OF THOSE ISSUES TO ARRIVE
01:13:20.629 --> 01:13:21.463
AT THE RIGHT LEVEL OF
01:13:21.530 --> 01:13:23.565
FLEXIBILITY BEFORE -- THIS BILL
01:13:23.632 --> 01:13:25.701
GOES INTO EFFECT SO FIRST OF ALL
01:13:25.768 --> 01:13:27.202
OF THE THANK YOU FOR YOUR
01:13:27.269 --> 01:13:28.837
ANALYSIS -- THE COMMENT YOU MADE
01:13:28.904 --> 01:13:30.506
ARE ARE VERY VERY HELPFUL
01:13:30.572 --> 01:13:32.007
CONVERSATION AND I APPRECIATE
01:13:32.074 --> 01:13:33.876
YOU'VE DELVING SO DEEP INTO IT.
01:13:33.942 --> 01:13:35.110
BECAUSE YOU HAD THE HEART OF THE
01:13:35.177 --> 01:13:36.678
AP HEADED OUT OF THE PARK.
01:13:36.745 --> 01:13:38.847
THE REASON WHY THIS BILL HAS A
01:13:38.914 --> 01:13:41.083
THREE YEAR IMPLEMENTATION CYCLE
01:13:41.150 --> 01:13:42.417
I MEAN I RECOGNIZE THAT IF WE
01:13:42.484 --> 01:13:44.686
SAID TODAY OR JANUARY ONE WHEN
01:13:44.753 --> 01:13:45.921
THIS BE BECOME LAW.
01:13:45.988 --> 01:13:49.158
YOU HAVE TO CHANGE YOUR BILL
01:13:49.224 --> 01:13:49.591
SCHEDULE [inaudible]
01:13:49.658 --> 01:13:50.325
THAT FALL.
01:13:50.392 --> 01:13:51.860
WE KNOW THAT'S TOO MUCH TO ASK
01:13:51.927 --> 01:13:54.062
THE REASON WHY THIS BILL HAS A
01:13:54.129 --> 01:13:55.764
THREE YEAR IMPLEMENTATION CYCLE.
01:13:55.831 --> 01:13:58.467
IS PRECISELY TO ADDRESS SOME OF
01:13:58.534 --> 01:14:00.536
THE CONCERNS YOU BROUGHT UP IS
01:14:00.602 --> 01:14:01.870
TO WORK WITH THE DISTRICTS.
01:14:01.937 --> 01:14:03.672
YOU KNOW THIS WILL FRANKLY FORCE
01:14:03.739 --> 01:14:05.174
DISTRICTS THE PLAN FOR THE
01:14:05.240 --> 01:14:10.813
CHANGE WHICH WILL IDENTIFY IT'S
01:14:10.879 --> 01:14:12.114
MY INTENT.
01:14:12.181 --> 01:14:14.550
DURING THAT THREE YEARS I HAVE
01:14:14.616 --> 01:14:16.552
FIVE AND A HALF YEARS LEFT HERE.
01:14:16.618 --> 01:14:18.020
TO WORK WITH THE DISTRICTS IN
01:14:18.086 --> 01:14:20.622
CONCERT AND IN COLLABORATION TO
01:14:20.689 --> 01:14:24.159
ADDRESS THOSE THINGS FOR EXAMPLE.
01:14:24.226 --> 01:14:24.827
ONE LEGITIMATE ISSUE THAT'S COME
01:14:24.893 --> 01:14:27.129
UP THERE'S A HANDFUL OF SCHOOLS
01:14:27.196 --> 01:14:28.831
OUT THERE THAT DON'T HAVE LIGHTS.
01:14:28.897 --> 01:14:30.632
ON THEIR SPORTS FIELDS THAT'S A
01:14:30.699 --> 01:14:32.367
LEGITIMATE.
01:14:32.434 --> 01:14:34.036
ISSUE YOU KNOW I'M GOING TO WORK
01:14:34.102 --> 01:14:35.571
ON A FUNDING SOURCE TO TRY TO
01:14:35.637 --> 01:14:37.272
HELP THOSE SCHOOL DISTRICTS THAT
01:14:37.339 --> 01:14:38.407
DON'T HAVE LIGHTS DURING THAT SO
01:14:38.473 --> 01:14:39.775
YES I WOULD TOTALLY COMMITTED TO
01:14:39.842 --> 01:14:41.510
WORKING WITH YOU.
01:14:41.577 --> 01:14:43.512
AND THE CHAIR AND MISS SMITH YOU
01:14:43.579 --> 01:14:44.746
KNOW I THINK YOUR POINTS WERE
01:14:44.813 --> 01:14:46.982
WERE WELL TAKEN -- TO THAT'S THE
01:14:47.049 --> 01:14:47.950
WHOLE POINT.
01:14:48.016 --> 01:14:50.052
WE HAVE THREE YEARS TO WORK ON
01:14:50.118 --> 01:14:52.387
IT IN CONCERT BUT IF EVERYBODY
01:14:52.454 --> 01:14:53.555
SAYING NO.
01:14:53.622 --> 01:14:54.456
WE'RE NOT GONNA BE ABLE TO HAVE
01:14:54.523 --> 01:14:57.259
THAT SIT DOWN CONVERSATION.
01:14:57.326 --> 01:14:59.528
THAT GIVES THAT THE ROBUST --
01:14:59.595 --> 01:15:01.530
FOCUS WE NEED SO YES OBVIOUSLY
01:15:01.597 --> 01:15:03.966
I'M GOING TO CONTINUE TO WORK ON
01:15:04.032 --> 01:15:04.800
THOSE ISSUES.
01:15:04.867 --> 01:15:05.834
YOU AND THANK YOU FOR YOUR
01:15:05.901 --> 01:15:09.304
DEDICATION TO THIS ISSUE AND I'M
01:15:09.371 --> 01:15:10.205
I WILL BE SUPPORTING THE BILL
01:15:10.272 --> 01:15:11.740
TODAY.-THANK YOU.
01:15:11.807 --> 01:15:13.675
I SEE NO FURTHER COMMENT -- YOU
01:15:13.742 --> 01:15:15.978
MAY CLOSE THANK YOU -- AND TAKE
01:15:16.044 --> 01:15:18.080
THE CHAIR YOU KNOW.
01:15:18.146 --> 01:15:20.649
I I KNOW THAT.
01:15:20.716 --> 01:15:21.917
WHEN THERE'S A CHANGE THIS
01:15:21.984 --> 01:15:22.885
DRAMATIC?
01:15:22.951 --> 01:15:25.754
YOU KNOW IT'S HARD -- YOU HAVE
01:15:25.821 --> 01:15:27.456
EXPERTS IN THE CLASSROOM YOU
01:15:27.522 --> 01:15:28.924
HAVE SCHOOL BOARD MEMBERS WHO
01:15:28.991 --> 01:15:33.228
HAVE STRUGGLE WITH THESE ISSUES --
01:15:33.295 --> 01:15:34.696
THE COMMENTS YOU'VE ALL MADE OUR
01:15:34.763 --> 01:15:36.899
OUR JERMAINE AND AND THE RIGHT
01:15:36.965 --> 01:15:38.767
QUESTIONS TO ASK WHAT IS THE
01:15:38.834 --> 01:15:40.802
IMPACT ON WORKING FAMILIES WELL.
01:15:40.869 --> 01:15:42.437
THAT'S THE RIGHT QUESTION.
01:15:42.504 --> 01:15:44.039
THE DATA SHOWS THAT UNDER THE
01:15:44.106 --> 01:15:45.540
CURRENT SYSTEM THERE'S A SOCIAL
01:15:45.607 --> 01:15:47.042
INEQUITY IN WORKING CHILDREN
01:15:47.109 --> 01:15:48.043
WORKING FAMILY HOUSEHOLDS ARE
01:15:48.110 --> 01:15:50.078
THE MOST DISADVANTAGED AND GET
01:15:50.145 --> 01:15:51.246
THE LEAST AMOUNT OF SLEEP.
01:15:51.313 --> 01:15:52.581
UNDER THE CURRENT SYSTEM WHO
01:15:52.648 --> 01:15:54.316
GETS THE BIGGEST BENEFIT AFTER
01:15:54.383 --> 01:15:55.851
THE CHANGE.
01:15:55.918 --> 01:15:57.386
THAT COHORT OF STUDENTS.
01:15:57.452 --> 01:15:58.820
WERE ASKING THE APPROPRIATE
01:15:58.887 --> 01:16:01.390
QUESTION ABOUT GETS THE BIGGEST
01:16:01.456 --> 01:16:05.294
BENEFIT -- TRANSPORTATION COSTS
01:16:05.360 --> 01:16:06.795
THE REASON WHY WE STAGGERED
01:16:06.862 --> 01:16:09.197
MIDDLE SCHOOL AND HIGH SCHOOL.
01:16:09.264 --> 01:16:11.700
THIS YEAR IS TO HELP OFFSET ANY
01:16:11.767 --> 01:16:14.336
POTENTIAL TRANSPORTATION COSTS
01:16:14.403 --> 01:16:16.271
THOUGH MOST OF THE DATA AND
01:16:16.338 --> 01:16:17.973
RESEARCH SHOWS.
01:16:18.040 --> 01:16:19.775
THERE IS AN INCREASED COST AND
01:16:19.841 --> 01:16:21.343
SOME DATA SHOWS THAT FOR EVERY
01:16:21.410 --> 01:16:22.911
DOLLAR SCHOOL DISTRICT INVEST
01:16:22.978 --> 01:16:23.979
THEY GET FOUR DOLLARS
01:16:24.046 --> 01:16:24.279
[inaudible]
01:16:24.346 --> 01:16:24.746
IN RETURN [inaudible]
01:16:24.813 --> 01:16:28.350
THE BILL ITSELF.
01:16:28.417 --> 01:16:29.318
SETTING.
01:16:29.384 --> 01:16:31.253
STANDARD.
01:16:31.320 --> 01:16:33.088
IT SAYS NO EARLIER THAN THAT
01:16:33.155 --> 01:16:35.090
DOESN'T MEAN DISTRICTS DON'T
01:16:35.157 --> 01:16:37.192
HAVE THE ABILITY TO ADJUST.
01:16:37.259 --> 01:16:38.560
AND AS POINTED OUT BY
01:16:38.627 --> 01:16:39.861
ASSEMBLYMEMBER KILEY.
01:16:39.928 --> 01:16:41.863
BY RESPECTING THE SCIENCE ON
01:16:41.930 --> 01:16:44.333
MIDDLE SCHOOLS AND SETTING THAT
01:16:44.399 --> 01:16:46.168
MINIMUM. FOR FOR EIGHT FOR
01:16:46.234 --> 01:16:47.936
MIDDLE SCHOOLS AND A MINIMUM FOR
01:16:48.003 --> 01:16:49.538
FOR HIGH SCHOOLS AT EIGHT THIRTY
01:16:49.604 --> 01:16:51.239
AGAIN THOSE ARE MINIMUMS ALLOWS
01:16:51.306 --> 01:16:53.909
DISTRICTS THAT FLEXIBILITY. TO
01:16:53.976 --> 01:16:55.844
WORK IN CONCERT WITH THEIR
01:16:55.911 --> 01:16:58.547
TRANSPORTATION FOLKS TO ADJUST
01:16:58.613 --> 01:17:00.115
THEIR SCHEDULES WE'VE LEFT OUT.
01:17:00.182 --> 01:17:02.384
THE LITTLE KIDS ON PURPOSE FOR
01:17:02.451 --> 01:17:04.586
TWO REASONS A THEIR SCIENCE AND
01:17:04.653 --> 01:17:06.288
BRAIN CHEMISTRY IS DIFFERENT AND
01:17:06.355 --> 01:17:08.757
BE THAT ALSO GIVES DISTRICTS THE
01:17:08.824 --> 01:17:11.059
FLEXIBILITY. FOR THAT THE CHAIRS
01:17:11.126 --> 01:17:13.061
COMMENT ABOUT THE SERVING CLASS
01:17:13.128 --> 01:17:13.929
AND ZERO APPEARED AGAIN THE
01:17:13.996 --> 01:17:16.732
RIGHT QUESTION TO ASK ZERO
01:17:16.798 --> 01:17:17.899
PERIOD.
01:17:17.966 --> 01:17:20.369
IS EXEMPT FROM THIS BILL WAS
01:17:20.435 --> 01:17:22.270
FIRST PERIOD JUST TO BE CLEAR
01:17:22.337 --> 01:17:24.306
DON'T DON'T MISS.
01:17:24.373 --> 01:17:26.174
BUT CHARACTERS MY STATES MOVES
01:17:26.241 --> 01:17:26.808
ABOUT FIRST PERIOD NOT NOT ZERO
01:17:26.875 --> 01:17:29.945
PER SERVING CLASSES DURING FIRST
01:17:30.012 --> 01:17:32.147
PERIOD.
01:17:32.214 --> 01:17:32.948
I'LL BE CLEAR IN A NON
01:17:33.015 --> 01:17:33.582
NEGOTIABLE AND I WILL SUBMIT AND
01:17:33.648 --> 01:17:34.816
COMMIT TO THE CHAIR TO TRY TO
01:17:34.883 --> 01:17:35.851
FIGURE OUT A WAY TO MAKE THE
01:17:35.917 --> 01:17:38.153
CITY THE SURFING CLASS.
01:17:38.220 --> 01:17:39.888
WORK FOR ANYBODY WANTS BY THE
01:17:39.955 --> 01:17:41.690
WAY THIS MAY SHOCK YOU.
01:17:41.757 --> 01:17:42.591
BUT I ACTUALLY SERVED WHEN I WAS
01:17:42.657 --> 01:17:45.360
A KID.
01:17:45.427 --> 01:17:47.763
I DIDN'T LOOK LIKE THIS.
01:17:47.829 --> 01:17:50.999
BUT AND WHEN I WAS A KID I USED
01:17:51.066 --> 01:17:52.734
TO GET IN TROUBLE BECAUSE THERE
01:17:52.801 --> 01:17:54.036
WAS A SURFER'S BEACH.
01:17:54.102 --> 01:17:54.970
AND OF COURSE WE ALL WOULD GO
01:17:55.037 --> 01:17:56.438
OVER TO THE SURFERS BEACH
01:17:56.505 --> 01:17:57.172
BECAUSE THAT'S WHERE ALL THE
01:17:57.239 --> 01:17:59.374
COOL KIDS WERE -- BUT ANYWAY
01:17:59.441 --> 01:18:01.043
PSYCH SUBMIT TO TO TO WORKING
01:18:01.109 --> 01:18:02.577
WITH THE CHAIR TO TRY TO FIGURE
01:18:02.644 --> 01:18:04.513
OUT THE APPROPRIATE WAY. TO
01:18:04.579 --> 01:18:05.380
ADDRESS.
01:18:05.447 --> 01:18:07.115
WHETHER THAT FITS THE DEFINITION
01:18:07.182 --> 01:18:08.650
OF A ZERO PERIOD BECAUSE IT'S
01:18:08.717 --> 01:18:09.951
VOLUNTARY OR NOT.
01:18:10.018 --> 01:18:11.987
YOU KNOW I'M NOT LOOKING TO MAKE
01:18:12.054 --> 01:18:13.021
THIS BILL.
01:18:13.088 --> 01:18:15.290
ARE JEWISH BUT I THINK ASSEMBLY
01:18:15.357 --> 01:18:17.025
MEMBER WEBBER'S -- PERCEPTION
01:18:17.092 --> 01:18:19.261
ABOUT DISTRICT REPRESENTATIVE
01:18:19.327 --> 01:18:21.363
SAYING OFF LINE GOD I HOPE THIS
01:18:21.430 --> 01:18:24.132
BILL PASSES I CAN'T TELL YOU HOW
01:18:24.199 --> 01:18:26.034
MANY SUPERINTENDENTS HAVE COME
01:18:26.101 --> 01:18:27.536
UP TO ME AND SAID.
01:18:27.602 --> 01:18:29.171
I'VE READ ALL THE RESEARCH I'D
01:18:29.237 --> 01:18:31.173
LOVE TO MOVE MY SCHOOL DISTRICT
01:18:31.239 --> 01:18:32.741
BUT I DON'T WANT TO DEAL WITH.
01:18:32.808 --> 01:18:34.576
WITH WITH.
01:18:34.643 --> 01:18:36.678
THOSE ISSUES BECAUSE SO PLEASE
01:18:36.745 --> 01:18:39.481
DO IT THE STAGGERED.
01:18:39.548 --> 01:18:41.049
EXTRACURRICULAR AGAIN PERFECT
01:18:41.116 --> 01:18:43.351
EXAMPLE THERE ARE DISTRICTS OUT
01:18:43.418 --> 01:18:44.619
THERE THAT WANT TO MOVE.
01:18:44.686 --> 01:18:45.854
BUT BECAUSE THEY DON'T WANT TO
01:18:45.921 --> 01:18:48.290
ON STAGGER THEIR EXTRACURRICULAR
01:18:48.356 --> 01:18:49.691
ACTIVITIES SO ALL OF THE
01:18:49.758 --> 01:18:51.693
QUESTIONS THAT HAVE BEEN ASKED.
01:18:51.760 --> 01:18:53.528
ARE THE RIGHT QUESTIONS WE THINK
01:18:53.595 --> 01:18:55.263
THE SCIENCE THE RESEARCH THE
01:18:55.330 --> 01:18:57.599
LACK OF INCREASED COSTS WE THINK
01:18:57.666 --> 01:18:59.000
IT'S IT JUSTIFIES.
01:18:59.067 --> 01:19:01.937
MAKING THIS MINIMUM STANDARD
01:19:02.003 --> 01:19:04.806
BASED ON THE RECOMMENDATION OF
01:19:04.873 --> 01:19:06.975
THE PEDIATRICIANS ABOUT WHAT'S
01:19:07.042 --> 01:19:08.410
IN THE BEST INTERESTS OF OUR
01:19:08.477 --> 01:19:09.411
KIDS.
01:19:09.478 --> 01:19:11.113
SHOULD BE THE OVERRIDING GOAL
01:19:11.179 --> 01:19:13.915
AND AS WHAT'S BEEN SAID IF WE
01:19:13.982 --> 01:19:16.318
SAVE ONE LIFE.
01:19:16.384 --> 01:19:19.187
THAT'S WORTH IT.
01:19:19.254 --> 01:19:20.789
THANK YOU SENATE ONE LIFE THAT'S
01:19:20.856 --> 01:19:22.724
WORTH IT SO I RESPECTFULLY ASK
01:19:22.791 --> 01:19:23.625
FOR AN AYE VOTE THANK YOU ALL
01:19:23.692 --> 01:19:26.061
RIGHT -- MOTION IS -- DO PASSED
01:19:26.128 --> 01:19:29.030
TO APPROPRIATIONS THERE'S BEEN A
01:19:29.097 --> 01:19:32.400
A MOTION AND A SECOND --
01:19:32.467 --> 01:19:33.001
MATHEMATICS AFTER PLEASE CALL
01:19:33.068 --> 01:19:34.369
THE ROLL.
01:19:34.436 --> 01:19:35.837
THE MOTION IS THE PASTOR
01:19:35.904 --> 01:19:37.906
APPROPRIATIONS O'DONNELL NO
01:19:37.973 --> 01:19:39.274
O'DONNELL NO KILEY.
01:19:39.341 --> 01:19:42.811
KILEY AYE DEEP KALRA.
01:19:42.878 --> 01:19:45.947
KALRA AYE MCCARTY SMITH.
01:19:46.014 --> 01:19:46.781
SMITH NOT VOTING WEBER
01:19:46.848 --> 01:19:47.082
[inaudible]
01:19:47.149 --> 01:19:50.018
WEBER I THOSE THREE THE BILL AS
01:19:50.085 --> 01:19:51.686
IS ON BECAUSE THREE VOTES YOU
01:19:51.753 --> 01:19:52.654
HAVE ANOTHER BILL YOU'RE
01:19:52.721 --> 01:19:53.922
PRESENTING YES I DO AND I GET TO
01:19:53.989 --> 01:19:55.557
THAT IN AN ON CALL I APPRECIATE
01:19:55.624 --> 01:19:58.026
IT AND THE TIME YOU GAVE US.
01:19:58.093 --> 01:20:03.498
THANK YOU [inaudible]
01:20:03.565 --> 01:20:09.704
FILE ITEM [inaudible] SIX NINE
01:20:09.771 --> 01:20:11.339
ONE NINE FILE NUMBER SIX FILE
01:20:11.406 --> 01:20:15.577
ITEM OR SIX SB. SIX NINE FIVE
01:20:15.644 --> 01:20:15.844
YOU MAY.
01:20:15.911 --> 01:20:32.194
PROCEED WHEN READY
01:20:42.137 --> 01:20:47.609
-- SURELY.
01:20:47.676 --> 01:20:49.978
I HAVE ANOTHER EASY BILL.
01:20:50.045 --> 01:20:50.946
AS CHAIR AND MEMBERS I'D LIKE TO
01:20:51.012 --> 01:20:51.880
BEGIN BY THANKING YOUR COMMITTEE
01:20:51.947 --> 01:20:52.881
STAFFER WORKING DILIGENTLY WITH
01:20:52.948 --> 01:20:53.848
MY STAFF.
01:20:53.915 --> 01:20:55.083
OVER THE THREE YEARS ON THIS
01:20:55.150 --> 01:20:56.718
VERY VERY IMPORTANT MEASURE -- I
01:20:56.785 --> 01:20:58.286
KNOW KRISTY LOPEZ FROM MY STAFF
01:20:58.353 --> 01:20:58.987
AND YOUR STAFF.
01:20:59.054 --> 01:21:00.589
HAVE REALLY REALLY WORKED HARD
01:21:00.655 --> 01:21:02.190
TO GET THIS BILL WHERE IT IS
01:21:02.257 --> 01:21:04.226
TODAY I'M PRESENTING SB SIX NINE
01:21:04.292 --> 01:21:04.993
FIVE WHICH REQUIRES A LOCAL
01:21:05.060 --> 01:21:06.661
EDUCATION AGENCY TO PROVIDE A
01:21:06.728 --> 01:21:07.429
STUDENT'S PARENT.
01:21:07.495 --> 01:21:08.663
WITH A COPY OF THE COMPLETED
01:21:08.730 --> 01:21:10.398
INDIVIDUAL EDUCATION PLAN OR IEP
01:21:10.465 --> 01:21:11.199
FOR THE EIGHT MOST COMMONLY
01:21:11.266 --> 01:21:12.133
SPOKEN LANGUAGES IN THAT
01:21:12.200 --> 01:21:12.400
DISTRICT.
01:21:12.467 --> 01:21:13.535
WITHIN THIRTY DAYS OF BEING
01:21:13.602 --> 01:21:15.003
REQUESTED AS WELL AS REQUIRE THE
01:21:15.070 --> 01:21:16.838
AYE HE PIECE TO BE TRANSLATED BY
01:21:16.905 --> 01:21:17.739
A QUALIFIED TRANSLATOR.
01:21:17.806 --> 01:21:20.108
THIS BILL ALSO REQUIRE CD TO
01:21:20.175 --> 01:21:21.376
REVISE ITS NOTICE OF PROCEDURAL
01:21:21.443 --> 01:21:22.844
SAFEGUARDS IN ORDER TO INFORM
01:21:22.911 --> 01:21:23.945
PARENTS OF THEIR RIGHT TO
01:21:24.012 --> 01:21:25.380
REQUEST.
01:21:25.447 --> 01:21:26.848
THE TRANSLATION OF DOCUMENTS
01:21:26.915 --> 01:21:28.450
EXISTING LAW ALLOWS FOR
01:21:28.516 --> 01:21:30.952
TRANSLATED COPY OF THE IEP BUT
01:21:31.019 --> 01:21:33.555
DOES NOT SET A TIME LINE FOR IP
01:21:33.622 --> 01:21:34.889
DOCUMENTS TO BE TRANSLATED --
01:21:34.956 --> 01:21:37.359
WE'VE HEARD STORIES FROM PARENTS
01:21:37.425 --> 01:21:38.927
THAT IT TOOK UP TO A YEAR TO
01:21:38.994 --> 01:21:40.295
RECEIVE THE DOCUMENTS AND IT
01:21:40.362 --> 01:21:43.031
APPEARED. TO BE TRANSLATED USING
01:21:43.098 --> 01:21:45.567
A POPULAR SEARCH ENGINE NOT AN
01:21:45.634 --> 01:21:46.468
ACTUAL TRANSLATOR.
01:21:46.534 --> 01:21:48.069
THE IEP PROCESS CAN BE
01:21:48.136 --> 01:21:50.472
OVERWHELMING AND INTIMIDATED FOR
01:21:50.538 --> 01:21:51.439
SOMEONE FROM IT -- NOT FAMILIAR
01:21:51.506 --> 01:21:52.974
WITH THE PROCESS OF THE
01:21:53.041 --> 01:21:54.409
TERMINOLOGY IS SPECIALLY OF THAT
01:21:54.476 --> 01:21:56.311
PERSON'S PRIMARY LANGUAGE IS NOT
01:21:56.378 --> 01:21:57.345
ENGLISH.
01:21:57.412 --> 01:22:00.081
THE LACK OF HAVING A TIMELY AND
01:22:00.148 --> 01:22:01.583
ACCURATE TRANSLATED IP DOES A
01:22:01.650 --> 01:22:02.984
GREAT DISSERVICE TO BOTH THE
01:22:03.051 --> 01:22:03.885
PARENTS AND THE STUDENTS THINK
01:22:03.952 --> 01:22:04.653
ABOUT.
01:22:04.719 --> 01:22:07.155
HOW PRECIOUS TIME IS TO THOSE
01:22:07.222 --> 01:22:10.191
EARLY LEARNERS IF YOU DELAY
01:22:10.258 --> 01:22:11.960
KNOWING WHAT YOUR I. E. P. IS
01:22:12.027 --> 01:22:12.427
FOR A YEAR?
01:22:12.494 --> 01:22:14.829
THAT'S IRREPARABLE DAMAGE TO THE
01:22:14.896 --> 01:22:15.764
YOUNG PERSON SO THE GOAL OF THIS
01:22:15.830 --> 01:22:17.165
BILL IS FOR PARENTS HAVE
01:22:17.232 --> 01:22:19.367
MEANINGFUL PARTICIPATION.
01:22:19.434 --> 01:22:20.302
IN THEIR CHILD CHILDREN'S IP
01:22:20.368 --> 01:22:23.004
PROCESS WHICH IS REQUIRED BY LAW
01:22:23.071 --> 01:22:24.806
AND ALSO TO PROVIDE PARENTS WITH
01:22:24.873 --> 01:22:27.642
A TRANSLATED COPY OF THE I. R.
01:22:27.709 --> 01:22:29.511
P. I. E. P. WITHIN THAT TIME
01:22:29.577 --> 01:22:30.145
FRAME SO.
01:22:30.211 --> 01:22:31.579
I HAVE ERIC HARRIS FROM
01:22:31.646 --> 01:22:33.815
DISABILITY RIGHTS CALIFORNIA AND
01:22:33.882 --> 01:22:35.083
CHRISTOPHER SANCHEZ FROM
01:22:35.150 --> 01:22:36.651
COALITION OF HUMAN IMMIGRATION
01:22:36.718 --> 01:22:38.653
RIGHTS TO SPEAK ON THE MERITS OF
01:22:38.720 --> 01:22:48.229
SB.
01:22:48.296 --> 01:22:48.830
SIX NINETY FIVE GOOD AFTERNOON
01:22:48.897 --> 01:22:49.431
CHAIR AND MEMBERS MY NAME IS
01:22:49.497 --> 01:22:49.898
ERIC HARRIS AND I'M A
01:22:49.964 --> 01:22:51.199
LEGISLATIVE ADVOCATE WITH
01:22:51.266 --> 01:22:52.300
DISABILITY RIGHTS CALIFORNIA.
01:22:52.367 --> 01:22:52.767
A NONPROFIT ADVOCACY
01:22:52.834 --> 01:22:54.102
ORGANIZATION THAT ADVANCES AND
01:22:54.169 --> 01:22:55.970
PROTECTS THE RIGHTS OF
01:22:56.037 --> 01:22:57.605
CALIFORNIANS WITH DISABILITIES.
01:22:57.672 --> 01:22:59.374
WE HAVE WORKED FOR THE LAST
01:22:59.441 --> 01:23:01.409
THREE YEARS ON THIS BILL WE ARE
01:23:01.476 --> 01:23:04.045
PROUD CO SPONSORS OF SB SIX
01:23:04.112 --> 01:23:04.846
NINETY FIVE A BILL THAT WOULD
01:23:04.913 --> 01:23:06.848
HELP STUDENTS AND FAMILIES GET
01:23:06.915 --> 01:23:07.716
TRANSLATIONS.
01:23:07.782 --> 01:23:11.086
OF INDIVIDUAL EDUCATION PROGRAMS
01:23:11.152 --> 01:23:12.921
ARE I. E. P.'S.
01:23:12.987 --> 01:23:14.522
FASTER WITHIN THIRTY DAYS.
01:23:14.589 --> 01:23:16.458
THIS IS A NECESSITY IN A STATE
01:23:16.524 --> 01:23:17.559
AS CULTURALLY DIVERSE AS
01:23:17.625 --> 01:23:19.494
CALIFORNIA AND WITH SO MANY
01:23:19.561 --> 01:23:21.496
LANGUAGES SPOKEN.
01:23:21.563 --> 01:23:22.097
THANK YOU AND I URGE YOUR AYE
01:23:22.163 --> 01:23:26.534
VOTE.
01:23:26.601 --> 01:23:28.937
GOOD AFTERNOON MR CHEN MEMBERS
01:23:29.003 --> 01:23:30.205
KRISTA RESPONSES WITCHER LE THE
01:23:30.271 --> 01:23:31.306
COALITION FOR HUMANE IMMIGRANT
01:23:31.373 --> 01:23:33.641
RIGHTS WHERE WE ARE CALIFORNIA'S
01:23:33.708 --> 01:23:34.476
LARGEST IN RIGHTS ORGANIZATION
01:23:34.542 --> 01:23:36.211
WE'RE PROUD TO BE A SPONSOR OF
01:23:36.277 --> 01:23:38.279
SB. SIX NINE FIVE FIVE YOU
01:23:38.346 --> 01:23:39.247
PROCESS AS MENTIONED BY THE
01:23:39.314 --> 01:23:40.815
SENATORS VERY INTIMIDATING FOR
01:23:40.882 --> 01:23:42.083
IMMIGRANT FAMILIES WHOSE PRIMARY
01:23:42.150 --> 01:23:43.785
LANGUAGE IS NOT LANGUAGE IS NOT
01:23:43.852 --> 01:23:45.286
ENGLISH MANY TIMES FAMILIES
01:23:45.353 --> 01:23:46.888
REPRESENT HAVE A CERTAIN AMOUNT
01:23:46.955 --> 01:23:47.856
OF DISTRESS.
01:23:47.922 --> 01:23:49.190
DURING THIS PART OF THE IEP
01:23:49.257 --> 01:23:50.458
PROCESS WHEN TRANSLATION IS
01:23:50.525 --> 01:23:53.128
NEEDED. FOR EXAMPLE PARENTS FEEL
01:23:53.194 --> 01:23:55.663
LEFT OUT OF THE CONVERSATION IF
01:23:55.730 --> 01:23:57.198
THEIR SIDE CONVERSATIONS
01:23:57.265 --> 01:24:01.302
HAPPENING I AND I MEDIAN -- AND
01:24:01.369 --> 01:24:02.837
THEY FILL THE SOMETIMES THEIR
01:24:02.904 --> 01:24:03.972
STATED.
01:24:04.038 --> 01:24:05.140
THAT WHEN OUR STAFF HAS NOT
01:24:05.206 --> 01:24:06.641
FULLY TRANSLATED WHAT THEY'RE
01:24:06.708 --> 01:24:08.610
TRYING TO CONVEY AN IP PROCESS.
01:24:08.676 --> 01:24:10.278
PARENTS BECOME MORE FRUSTRATED
01:24:10.345 --> 01:24:11.479
WHEN DOCUMENTS ARE PROVIDER NOT
01:24:11.546 --> 01:24:12.981
PROPERLY TRANSLATED IN FACT AS
01:24:13.047 --> 01:24:14.382
AS MENTIONED EARLIER SOME
01:24:14.449 --> 01:24:15.884
MEMBERS HAVE STATED THAT THEY
01:24:15.950 --> 01:24:17.585
HAVEN'T RECEIVED DOCUMENTS.
01:24:17.652 --> 01:24:19.154
THAT MANY TIMES BEEN TRANSLATED
01:24:19.220 --> 01:24:21.423
BY ON MY SYSTEM SUCH AS GOOGLE
01:24:21.489 --> 01:24:24.759
TRANSLATE NOT WHICH MAKES NO
01:24:24.826 --> 01:24:27.228
SENSE IN THEIR OWN LANGUAGE. SIX
01:24:27.295 --> 01:24:28.296
NINE FIVE ENSURE THAT FAMILIES
01:24:28.363 --> 01:24:30.365
ARE ENGAGED IN IP PROCESS ARE
01:24:30.432 --> 01:24:31.633
NOT TREATED AS SECOND CLASS
01:24:31.699 --> 01:24:33.568
CITIZENS BY ENSURING DOCUMENTS
01:24:33.635 --> 01:24:34.402
PROVIDED.
01:24:34.469 --> 01:24:35.804
DURING IP PROCESS ARE PROPERLY
01:24:35.870 --> 01:24:37.372
TRANSLATED AND GIVEN IN A TIMELY
01:24:37.439 --> 01:24:39.207
MANNER IN DOING SO THIS BILL
01:24:39.274 --> 01:24:41.042
WILL ASSIST IN RESTORING TRUST
01:24:41.109 --> 01:24:42.444
BETWEEN IMMIGRANT FAMILIES ARE
01:24:42.510 --> 01:24:43.645
ENGAGED IN THIS PROCESS.
01:24:43.711 --> 01:24:44.879
SCHOOLS AND OVERALL IN
01:24:44.946 --> 01:24:45.980
GOVERNMENT.
01:24:46.047 --> 01:24:47.549
OUR STATE HAS MADE IT C<c.cyan></c>
01:24:47.615 --> 01:24:49.050
CLEAR COMMITMENT IMMIGRANTS AND
01:24:49.117 --> 01:24:50.151
THEIR CHILDREN OR OFTENTIMES
01:24:50.218 --> 01:24:51.319
CITIZENS OF THE UNITED STATES
01:24:51.386 --> 01:24:52.687
THAT THEY SHOULD BE TREATED THE
01:24:52.754 --> 01:24:54.155
SAME AS ALL OTHER CALIFORNIANS.
01:24:54.222 --> 01:25:01.663
AND SB SIX NINE FIVE DOES THAT
01:25:01.729 --> 01:25:05.300
FOR THOSE REASONS WE ARE DRIVE A
01:25:05.366 --> 01:25:10.004
OTHERS IN SUPPORT.
01:25:10.071 --> 01:25:14.375
GEN GLORIA BEHALF WESTERN CENTER
01:25:14.442 --> 01:25:17.445
ON LAW AND POVERTY.
01:25:17.512 --> 01:25:28.957
GOOD AFTERNOON AND CALIFORNIA
01:25:29.023 --> 01:25:32.460
COLLABORATION AND SUPPORT.
01:25:32.527 --> 01:25:33.561
SHANNON PRIMER SPECIAL NEEDS
01:25:33.628 --> 01:25:34.596
PARALEGAL WHO HAS TO CLIENTS
01:25:34.662 --> 01:25:35.630
WITH THIS ISSUE I'M ALSO WITH
01:25:35.697 --> 01:25:37.298
EDUCATE ADVOCATE AND EMPOWER
01:25:37.365 --> 01:25:39.033
FAMILY CALIFORNIA WE ARE FROM
01:25:39.100 --> 01:25:42.971
SUPPORT.
01:25:43.037 --> 01:25:45.974
AND SEE WHAT OTHER ME NUMBER IS
01:25:46.040 --> 01:25:48.009
A WRESTLING ANGLE SO MOTHER
01:25:48.076 --> 01:25:48.810
THOSE THING IS GOING TO BE IS
01:25:48.877 --> 01:25:50.945
NOT MY NAME IS ROSALYN I'M THE
01:25:51.012 --> 01:25:53.014
MOTHER OF TWO KIDS WITHOUT THE
01:25:53.081 --> 01:25:54.015
SOME.
01:25:54.082 --> 01:25:56.050
I'M ALSO FARM CO FOUNDER OF
01:25:56.117 --> 01:25:58.353
INTEGRATED -- INTEGRATE
01:25:58.419 --> 01:26:00.121
COMMUNITY COMMUNITY
01:26:00.188 --> 01:26:01.589
COLLABORATIVE I SEE SEE WE ARE
01:26:01.656 --> 01:26:03.391
ALL OVER CALIFORNIA WE HOP ON
01:26:03.458 --> 01:26:05.693
GROUPS AND ALL OF A CALIFORNIA
01:26:05.760 --> 01:26:07.896
AND I'M HERE SUPPORTING AND THEY
01:26:07.962 --> 01:26:11.399
IS ME. SIX NINETY FIGHT IN
01:26:11.466 --> 01:26:19.274
SUPPORTING THE EFFORTS TO THEIR
01:26:19.340 --> 01:26:23.278
SEATS THANK YOU THANK YOU.
01:26:23.344 --> 01:26:26.414
ME NUMBER NINETY SANCHEZ SO
01:26:26.481 --> 01:26:30.351
ESTARá PERSON BAND ALL ASSUME.
01:26:30.418 --> 01:26:34.188
ARE LIKE WHEN THE ITEMIZED
01:26:34.255 --> 01:26:39.027
RECEIPT IS STILL UP FOR OUT OF
01:26:39.093 --> 01:26:40.128
ANY SAYS HE ON A IS THE NAME
01:26:40.194 --> 01:26:41.829
NICE ICC.
01:26:41.896 --> 01:26:43.932
I'M SUPPORT FOR THIS HAVE
01:26:43.998 --> 01:26:48.670
RELATED RIGHTS CALIFORNIA.
01:26:48.736 --> 01:26:50.438
HELLO MY NAME IS STORE CONTRARY
01:26:50.505 --> 01:26:52.040
US AND I'M GRANDMOTHER TO IN A
01:26:52.106 --> 01:26:54.108
TESTING GROUND SON I'M A RETIRED
01:26:54.175 --> 01:26:56.244
SCHOOL ADMINISTRATOR IN THE
01:26:56.311 --> 01:26:58.179
TREES UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT.
01:26:58.246 --> 01:26:59.213
AND I'M ALSO IN AND TAKEN OTHER
01:26:59.280 --> 01:27:00.415
WHAT I REPRESENTING THE
01:27:00.481 --> 01:27:02.283
INTEGRATED COMMUNITY
01:27:02.350 --> 01:27:03.751
COLLABORATIVE ORGANIZATION.
01:27:03.818 --> 01:27:05.053
IN STOCKTON AND SURROUNDING
01:27:05.119 --> 01:27:07.689
AREAS I SUPPORT DISABILITY
01:27:07.755 --> 01:27:09.324
RIGHTS.
01:27:09.390 --> 01:27:12.093
IN THE PASSAGE OF SB
01:27:12.160 --> 01:27:12.393
[inaudible]
01:27:12.460 --> 01:27:16.097
SIX NINETY FIVE THANK YOU.
01:27:16.164 --> 01:27:17.865
WHEN I START THIS ME NUMBER IS
01:27:17.932 --> 01:27:20.168
GOOD HE SAID THIS DROUGHT THAT
01:27:20.234 --> 01:27:22.170
HE YOUR APPLE YOU'LL -- THIS
01:27:22.236 --> 01:27:23.938
HEAVILY TO RICE CALIFORNIA BY
01:27:24.005 --> 01:27:27.542
NOT A LESBIAN Là AB SAKES LIVE
01:27:27.609 --> 01:27:29.310
IT SINGLE IS VERY ACCURATE
01:27:29.377 --> 01:27:31.145
PERCENT ON OUR LOCAL MONEY THAT
01:27:31.212 --> 01:27:33.715
THE FATHER IS THE FRENCH CAM.
01:27:33.781 --> 01:27:35.950
MONTH THEY GOT LATE PRO IS DR
01:27:36.017 --> 01:27:40.555
LODI MORE THIS SO YES COLOGNE --
01:27:40.622 --> 01:27:48.129
AND MISS BETTY IS HERE COMO
01:27:48.196 --> 01:27:48.730
FATHER THAT THOSE YOU CLICK ON
01:27:48.796 --> 01:27:50.465
NOTE.
01:27:50.531 --> 01:27:53.034
VERY IMPORTANT TO US LATE.
01:27:53.101 --> 01:27:56.537
BUT AND THEN THERE NEED THE MOST
01:27:56.604 --> 01:27:57.405
INTENDED ONLY A BANK YOU
01:27:57.472 --> 01:28:02.076
[inaudible] FOR WHAT.
01:28:02.143 --> 01:28:03.277
WHEN I STARTED THIS MY NUMBER IS
01:28:03.344 --> 01:28:06.114
MIGHTY SUCH A LOT YOU CAN GO 2%
01:28:06.180 --> 01:28:08.516
ON LONG ISLAND AN EXISTING
01:28:08.583 --> 01:28:10.385
FORCES SALINAS?
01:28:10.451 --> 01:28:12.920
THEY THEY THEY GIVE A CALIFORNIA.
01:28:12.987 --> 01:28:13.388
SHE'S REPRESENTING AN
01:28:13.454 --> 01:28:13.921
ORGANIZATION CALLED FORCES
01:28:13.988 --> 01:28:15.590
UNITED.
01:28:15.657 --> 01:28:19.994
HEY YES THEY IT'S ALMOST ALMOST
01:28:20.061 --> 01:28:23.798
A KEEP IT UP WE HAD A LITTLE IS.
01:28:23.865 --> 01:28:29.437
A LIST OF IT IS. SIX SIX NINETY
01:28:29.504 --> 01:28:32.240
FIVE ME NUMBER IS MARIA YELLOW
01:28:32.306 --> 01:28:32.740
THING ONLY YOU'RE GOING
01:28:32.807 --> 01:28:33.941
O'DONNELL.
01:28:34.008 --> 01:28:35.877
GIVING ALL THE LIGHT THIS BILL
01:28:35.943 --> 01:28:38.146
IN THE GROUP REPORTERS ONLY THIS.
01:28:38.212 --> 01:28:40.214
GIVEN THE BOY IN THE LAW THIS
01:28:40.281 --> 01:28:41.716
SERVICE SAID KNOWING THEY SINGLE
01:28:41.783 --> 01:28:44.852
ESSAY OF A SINGLE WHEN THEY
01:28:44.919 --> 01:28:53.127
CAN'T GO. SEVEN I'M DOING.
01:28:53.194 --> 01:28:54.128
NOW.
01:28:54.195 --> 01:28:56.798
WE DON'T DO THAT HERE.
01:28:56.864 --> 01:28:59.734
WE DO HAVE FUN THOUGH.
01:28:59.801 --> 01:29:01.903
THE NUMBER OF MONEY -- CHARM
01:29:01.969 --> 01:29:03.738
BIGELOW BY.
01:29:03.805 --> 01:29:05.073
SAYING GO THOSE IN THE AT THE
01:29:05.139 --> 01:29:13.981
SOUTHEAST THE VERY SAME MOMENT
01:29:14.048 --> 01:29:17.885
THEY SEEM COOL BUT I THINK.
01:29:17.952 --> 01:29:19.320
WHEN THE THOUGHT OF THEM IN THE
01:29:19.387 --> 01:29:21.055
LETTER THAT I GOT STATUS THING
01:29:21.122 --> 01:29:22.690
WITH THOSE NEW YORK ON OF THESE
01:29:22.757 --> 01:29:23.124
SMALL?
01:29:23.191 --> 01:29:28.029
EVEN WALKWAY UNDERLIES SERVICE
01:29:28.096 --> 01:29:28.663
SAID HAVEN'T THEY SINGLE NOTHING
01:29:28.730 --> 01:29:30.465
OF MY NAME IS ANGIE RIVERA AND I
01:29:30.531 --> 01:29:32.133
AM THE FOUNDER OF UP OIL THE
01:29:32.200 --> 01:29:32.867
FATHERS BUT IT BOTHERS THE
01:29:32.934 --> 01:29:33.501
SPANISH SPEAKING SUPPORT GROUP
01:29:33.568 --> 01:29:34.435
WE'VE BEEN AROUND FOR THIRTY
01:29:34.502 --> 01:29:34.902
YEARS.
01:29:34.969 --> 01:29:36.471
WITH A MEMBERSHIP OF ONE HUNDRED
01:29:36.537 --> 01:29:38.840
PEOPLE AND I ALSO WORK FOR UC
01:29:38.906 --> 01:29:41.242
DAVIS MIND INSTITUTE AS A
01:29:41.309 --> 01:29:42.810
COMMUNITY ADVOCATE AND WE
01:29:42.877 --> 01:29:44.479
SERVICE PEOPLE EVERYWHERE AND I
01:29:44.545 --> 01:29:46.914
DEFINITELY SUPPORT THIS BILL
01:29:46.981 --> 01:29:49.884
THANK YOU.
01:29:49.951 --> 01:29:51.419
ALL I MEAN I'M GONNA START
01:29:51.486 --> 01:29:53.454
MOVING WITH A LIGHT UP FOR YOU
01:29:53.521 --> 01:29:55.123
WHAT IT SAYS WILL NEED US.
01:29:55.189 --> 01:29:56.958
EVEN THEN WAS A BOY YOUNG THOUGH
01:29:57.024 --> 01:30:00.862
IS SERVICE A. C. AND THEN WITH A
01:30:00.928 --> 01:30:02.430
SINGLE CRISIS.
01:30:02.497 --> 01:30:03.498
ALL THE PREVIOUS SPEAKERS WERE
01:30:03.564 --> 01:30:05.299
FROM FORCES UNITED.
01:30:05.366 --> 01:30:06.334
SIMON WHO WITH THE CALIFORNIA
01:30:06.400 --> 01:30:08.302
COUNCIL OF COMMUNITY BE ABLE
01:30:08.369 --> 01:30:10.071
HEALTH AGENCY OR IN SUPPORT.
01:30:10.138 --> 01:30:10.371
THANK YOU.
01:30:10.438 --> 01:30:11.639
SEEN -- FOR THEIR SUPPORT ANY
01:30:11.706 --> 01:30:12.940
OPPOSITION TO THE BILL.
01:30:13.007 --> 01:30:13.775
SEEN OPPOSITION ANY COMMENTS
01:30:13.841 --> 01:30:15.109
READY COMMITTEE MEMBER SINGLE
01:30:15.176 --> 01:30:17.011
COMMENTS MANY THE COMMITTEE
01:30:17.078 --> 01:30:19.747
MEMBERS DO WE HAVE A MOTION.
01:30:19.814 --> 01:30:20.748
THIS BILL THE MOVED AND SECONDED
01:30:20.815 --> 01:30:21.649
MOVE BY MISS SMITH SECOND MOSTER
01:30:21.716 --> 01:30:24.285
KALRA -- THE MOTION IS -- TO
01:30:24.352 --> 01:30:27.255
PASS TO APPROPRIATIONS -- YOU
01:30:27.321 --> 01:30:29.123
MAKE CLOTHES A MAKE UP FOR MY
01:30:29.190 --> 01:30:33.027
LAST CLOSE IN THE SHORT I
01:30:33.094 --> 01:30:35.530
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN IPHONE
01:30:35.596 --> 01:30:35.830
[inaudible]
01:30:35.897 --> 01:30:38.399
JOHN.
01:30:38.466 --> 01:30:40.434
CLOSE RIGHT THERE -- SECRETARY
01:30:40.501 --> 01:30:41.068
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
01:30:41.135 --> 01:30:42.837
THE MOTION IS THE PASTOR
01:30:42.904 --> 01:30:45.173
PREPARATIONS FOR DONALD.
01:30:45.239 --> 01:30:47.942
BY THE DONALD I KILEY.
01:30:48.009 --> 01:30:51.012
KILEY NOT VOTING DEEP KALRA.
01:30:51.078 --> 01:30:53.948
KALRA AYE MCCARTY SMITH.
01:30:54.015 --> 01:30:54.782
SMITH I WEBER.
01:30:54.849 --> 01:30:58.252
WEBER I DOES WORK.
01:30:58.319 --> 01:31:00.288
THE BILL.
01:31:00.354 --> 01:31:04.225
THE BUS FOR VOTE SO IT IS OUT.
01:31:04.292 --> 01:31:05.626
YOUR AVAILABLE FILE ITEM NUMBER
01:31:05.693 --> 01:31:06.661
THREE SENATOR SKINNER.
01:31:06.727 --> 01:31:08.062
FILE ITEM THREE YOU MAY.
01:31:08.129 --> 01:31:10.631
PROCEED WHEN READY.
01:31:10.698 --> 01:31:11.766
WHERE SHE THEIR SHOES?
01:31:11.833 --> 01:31:17.972
IT'S SP.
01:31:18.039 --> 01:31:18.539
FOUR ONE NINE AND WHILE I'M
01:31:18.606 --> 01:31:34.755
THREE YEAH
01:31:40.394 --> 01:31:40.561
[inaudible]
01:31:40.628 --> 01:31:42.964
THE CENTER.
01:31:43.030 --> 01:31:43.764
OKAY.
01:31:43.831 --> 01:31:46.234
AND AFTER -- CENTER SKINNER WILL
01:31:46.300 --> 01:31:47.735
HAVE CENTER HERTZBERG.
01:31:47.802 --> 01:31:55.209
YOU MAY PROCEED [inaudible]
01:31:55.276 --> 01:31:59.547
WELL [inaudible]
01:31:59.614 --> 01:32:05.486
THE YEAH [inaudible]
01:32:05.553 --> 01:32:11.525
YOUR WORKING IN THE SENATE BILL
01:32:11.592 --> 01:32:16.097
AND THE YEAH.
01:32:16.163 --> 01:32:20.434
YEAH BUT I DON'T.
01:32:20.501 --> 01:32:25.273
HEARINGS [inaudible]
01:32:25.339 --> 01:32:33.581
YEAH -- IF YOU [inaudible]
01:32:33.648 --> 01:32:36.784
CATEGORY.
01:32:36.851 --> 01:32:39.287
IT IS NO.
01:32:39.353 --> 01:32:42.790
WE HAVE HAD THREE GRADUATING.
01:32:42.857 --> 01:32:44.091
THE LAST COUPLE OF YEARS AND
01:32:44.158 --> 01:32:49.497
LEGISLATURE ABOUT -- THE
01:32:49.563 --> 01:32:50.698
REQUESTED BY.
01:32:50.765 --> 01:32:58.072
LAW ENFORCEMENT ACTION.
01:32:58.139 --> 01:32:59.106
MOON FAR MORE.
01:32:59.173 --> 01:33:03.210
FAR MORE IMPORTER OR MALICE OR
01:33:03.277 --> 01:33:05.713
WHO KNOWS WHAT THEN IS THERE.
01:33:05.780 --> 01:33:10.618
AND IT'S AN UNFORTUNATE THING.
01:33:10.685 --> 01:33:12.253
BUT IT REALLY IMPACTS THE
01:33:12.320 --> 01:33:15.423
ABILITY OF THOSE KIDS TO SUCCEED
01:33:15.489 --> 01:33:16.724
IN SCHOOL.
01:33:16.791 --> 01:33:20.227
AND THEY HAPPEN TO BE FAR MORE
01:33:20.294 --> 01:33:22.396
SUBJECTED AND ALL OF OUR DATA
01:33:22.463 --> 01:33:24.498
SHOW SAID TO A CATEGORY OF
01:33:24.565 --> 01:33:26.200
SUSPENSIONS CALLED WILLFUL
01:33:26.267 --> 01:33:28.069
DEFIANCE WHICH YOU CAN LOOK AT
01:33:28.135 --> 01:33:30.538
AS SORT OF AN ATTITUDINAL THING.
01:33:30.604 --> 01:33:31.973
AND THAT THERE SUSPENDED FOR
01:33:32.039 --> 01:33:35.843
THAT -- AND WHEN YOU'RE
01:33:35.910 --> 01:33:37.812
SUSPENDED FROM SCHOOL.
01:33:37.878 --> 01:33:39.780
THAT ISN'T A GREAT RECIPE FOR
01:33:39.847 --> 01:33:41.549
SUCCESS IN SCHOOL YOU'RE IN
01:33:41.615 --> 01:33:43.718
EFFECT IT'S COMMUNICATES THAT
01:33:43.784 --> 01:33:45.086
HEY WE DON'T WANTYOU HERE SO
01:33:45.152 --> 01:33:46.687
WHY SHOULD YOU WANT TO BE WHERE
01:33:46.754 --> 01:33:48.022
YOU'RE NOT WANTED.
01:33:48.089 --> 01:33:49.557
AND ADDITIONALLY YOUR LOSS OF
01:33:49.623 --> 01:33:52.493
THAT SCHOOL ING GET YOU BEHIND.
01:33:52.560 --> 01:33:53.928
IN YOUR CLASSES.
01:33:53.995 --> 01:33:55.629
SO WE'VE BEEN TRYING TO ADDRESS
01:33:55.696 --> 01:33:58.232
THIS FOR SOME TIME AND LAST YEAR
01:33:58.299 --> 01:34:00.001
IN THE BUDGET.
01:34:00.067 --> 01:34:01.535
THERE WAS MADE PERMANENT THE
01:34:01.602 --> 01:34:03.304
ELIMINATION OF THIS SINGLE
01:34:03.371 --> 01:34:05.506
CATEGORY OF OF SUSPENSIONS
01:34:05.573 --> 01:34:07.475
CALLED WILLFUL DEFIANCE IN
01:34:07.541 --> 01:34:09.477
GRADES.
01:34:09.543 --> 01:34:11.112
KINDERGARTEN THROUGH THIRD.
01:34:11.178 --> 01:34:13.881
NOW THERE HAVE BEEN MANY MANY --
01:34:13.948 --> 01:34:16.217
ADVOCACY ORGANIZATIONS INCLUDING
01:34:16.283 --> 01:34:17.618
EVEN OUR SCHOOL ADMINISTRATORS
01:34:17.685 --> 01:34:19.487
ASSOCIATION SAID AS WANTED TO GO
01:34:19.553 --> 01:34:21.122
FURTHER SO THE BILL YOU HAVE
01:34:21.188 --> 01:34:23.324
TODAY IS A BILL THAT WOULD
01:34:23.391 --> 01:34:23.624
[inaudible]
01:34:23.691 --> 01:34:25.359
MAKE.
01:34:25.426 --> 01:34:26.794
THERE WOULD ELIMINATE WILLFUL
01:34:26.861 --> 01:34:28.662
STIFF FINES SUSPENSIONS THROUGH
01:34:28.729 --> 01:34:30.731
GRADE FIVE SO ADDING TO WHAT WE
01:34:30.798 --> 01:34:32.033
ALREADY DID.
01:34:32.099 --> 01:34:35.269
BY ADDING GRADES FOUR AND FIVE
01:34:35.336 --> 01:34:36.337
TO THAT PERMANENT THIRD
01:34:36.404 --> 01:34:36.637
[inaudible]
01:34:36.704 --> 01:34:38.372
AND THEN.
01:34:38.439 --> 01:34:40.207
ELIMINATING WILL FOLDS DEFINED
01:34:40.274 --> 01:34:42.076
SUSPENSIONS.
01:34:42.143 --> 01:34:45.913
THROUGH FOR GRADE SIX AND EIGHT
01:34:45.980 --> 01:34:46.547
SIX SEVEN EIGHT SIX THREE WITH A
01:34:46.614 --> 01:34:47.815
FIVE YEAR SUNSET SORTS NOT
01:34:47.882 --> 01:34:50.251
PERMANENT.
01:34:50.317 --> 01:34:52.019
IT HAS A FIVE YEAR SUNSET -- NOW
01:34:52.086 --> 01:34:56.590
I WOULD LIKE TO SEE THIS ISSUE
01:34:56.657 --> 01:34:57.892
STILL ADDRESS HIGH SCHOOL
01:34:57.958 --> 01:34:59.994
STUDENTS BUT I APPRECIATE THE
01:35:00.061 --> 01:35:01.195
ARGUMENTS.
01:35:01.262 --> 01:35:05.499
AND NINE MEAN ARGUMENTS BUT IAPPRECIATE THE PERSPECTIVE OF
01:35:05.566 --> 01:35:07.701
THAT HIGH SCHOOL IS DIFFERENT.
01:35:07.768 --> 01:35:09.837
AND THAT -- THE THE BEHAVIOR IN
01:35:09.904 --> 01:35:10.571
HIGH SCHOOLS DIFFERENT
01:35:10.638 --> 01:35:12.173
EVERYTHING ABOUT THE WHAT
01:35:12.239 --> 01:35:14.408
OPTIONS THE HIGH SCHOOL TEACHERS
01:35:14.475 --> 01:35:18.345
AND SUCH HAVE -- SO I RESPECT
01:35:18.412 --> 01:35:19.880
VERY MUCH THE WAY THE BILL'S
01:35:19.947 --> 01:35:21.015
CONSTRUCTED.
01:35:21.082 --> 01:35:23.451
AND THE AMENDMENTS WE'VE TAKEN.
01:35:23.517 --> 01:35:25.186
BUT I HOPE THAT WE CAN CONTINUE
01:35:25.252 --> 01:35:27.721
OUR CONVERSATION OVER TIME
01:35:27.788 --> 01:35:29.623
AROUND.
01:35:29.690 --> 01:35:31.459
ALSO TRYING TO LOOK AT CREATING
01:35:31.525 --> 01:35:33.494
THE MOST [inaudible]
01:35:33.561 --> 01:35:36.297
OPTIMAL CIRCUMSTANCES IN OUR
01:35:36.363 --> 01:35:38.566
PUBLIC EDUCATION SYSTEM FOR
01:35:38.632 --> 01:35:40.334
STUDENTS TO SUCCEED AND WITH
01:35:40.401 --> 01:35:43.003
THAT I WOULD LIKE MY WITNESSES
01:35:43.070 --> 01:35:44.105
IN SUPPORT TO TESTIFY
01:35:44.171 --> 01:35:44.405
[inaudible]
01:35:44.472 --> 01:35:45.906
THANK YOU.
01:35:45.973 --> 01:35:47.875
GOOD AFTERNOON MY NAME IS JOHN I
01:35:47.942 --> 01:35:49.610
THINK I IS AND I'M A SEVENTEEN
01:35:49.677 --> 01:35:51.011
YEAR OLD RISING SENIOR AT
01:35:51.078 --> 01:35:52.646
GARFIELD HIGH SCHOOL.
01:35:52.713 --> 01:35:53.581
I'M HERE WITH INNER CITY
01:35:53.647 --> 01:35:54.782
STRUGGLE THE BROTHERS THEMSELVES
01:35:54.849 --> 01:35:56.951
COALITION AN ALLEY COUNTY AND
01:35:57.017 --> 01:35:57.585
THE ALLIANCE FOR BOYS AND MEN OF
01:35:57.651 --> 01:35:58.652
COLOR.
01:35:58.719 --> 01:36:00.721
I'M HERE IN SUPPORT OF SB FOUR
01:36:00.788 --> 01:36:01.989
NINETEEN BECAUSE AS A STUDENT I
01:36:02.056 --> 01:36:03.390
FEEL THE SCHOOL ENVIRONMENT HAS
01:36:03.457 --> 01:36:04.758
BECOME SAFER SINCE WE ENDED
01:36:04.825 --> 01:36:05.893
WILLFUL DEFINES AS A MEANS OF
01:36:05.960 --> 01:36:07.495
SUSPENSION.
01:36:07.561 --> 01:36:09.630
IN TWO THOUSAND THIRTEEN THE
01:36:09.697 --> 01:36:10.931
BROTHERS SON SELVES COALITION
01:36:10.998 --> 01:36:12.566
AND OTHER ORGANIZATIONS AND HOW
01:36:12.633 --> 01:36:13.467
THEY PASSED THE SCHOOL CLIMB A
01:36:13.534 --> 01:36:15.302
BILL OF RIGHTS IN LOS ANGELES
01:36:15.369 --> 01:36:17.505
UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT. ONE OF
01:36:17.571 --> 01:36:18.305
THE THINGS THE SCHOOL CLIMB A
01:36:18.372 --> 01:36:19.607
BILL OF RIGHTS DID WAS AND
01:36:19.673 --> 01:36:21.208
SUSPENSIONS IN OUR SCHOOL
01:36:21.275 --> 01:36:22.676
DISTRICT FOR DEFIANCE.
01:36:22.743 --> 01:36:24.845
I WAS A FIFTH GRADER AT THE TIME.
01:36:24.912 --> 01:36:26.480
BECAUSE OF THAT STUDENTS WERE NO
01:36:26.547 --> 01:36:27.915
LONGER PULLED OUT OF CLASS AND
01:36:27.982 --> 01:36:29.350
SUSPENDED FOR MINOR INFRACTIONS
01:36:29.416 --> 01:36:31.085
LIKE WEARING A HAT HAVING YOUR
01:36:31.152 --> 01:36:33.154
BIRDS IN CHEWING GUM.
01:36:33.220 --> 01:36:34.755
AND THEY WEREN'T FORCED TO MISS
01:36:34.822 --> 01:36:37.224
VALUABLE CLASS TIME.
01:36:37.291 --> 01:36:38.826
BECAUSE OF THIS I FELT SAFE
01:36:38.893 --> 01:36:42.029
REGISTERED.
01:36:42.096 --> 01:36:44.165
AS BEFORE NINETEEN ALLOW
01:36:44.231 --> 01:36:44.698
STUDENTS TO STAYING CLASS
01:36:44.765 --> 01:36:45.299
FURTHER.
01:36:45.366 --> 01:36:47.301
STAY IN CLASS AND FURTHER THEIR
01:36:47.368 --> 01:36:48.636
EDUCATION RATHER THAN BE BOTH BE
01:36:48.702 --> 01:36:50.771
PULLED OUT AND FALL BEHIND ON
01:36:50.838 --> 01:36:52.006
CLASS WORK.
01:36:52.072 --> 01:36:53.073
AND A STUDENTS EDUCATION IS
01:36:53.140 --> 01:36:54.942
SUPPOSED TO BE PROTECTED.
01:36:55.009 --> 01:36:56.810
NOT USE AS A THREAT AGAINST THEM.
01:36:56.877 --> 01:36:58.212
BECAUSE OF AS BEFORE NINETEEN
01:36:58.279 --> 01:36:59.380
STUDENTS WHO ARE DEEMED HARD TO
01:36:59.446 --> 01:37:02.483
DEAL WITH.
01:37:02.550 --> 01:37:04.118
WILL NOT WILL NO LONGER BE
01:37:04.185 --> 01:37:06.353
THROWN OUT OF CLASS OR SUSPENDED
01:37:06.420 --> 01:37:07.488
BECAUSE IT'S CONVENIENT.
01:37:07.555 --> 01:37:08.722
RATHER RESTORATIVE JUSTICE
01:37:08.789 --> 01:37:11.192
PRACTICES WILL BE IN IMPLEMENTED.
01:37:11.258 --> 01:37:12.760
RELATIONSHIPS CONVERSATIONS
01:37:12.826 --> 01:37:14.828
TRUSTS AND DIALOGUE WILL BE PUT
01:37:14.895 --> 01:37:16.830
IN THE PLACE OF PUNISHMENTS.
01:37:16.897 --> 01:37:17.665
STUDENTS WILL BE ABLE TO EXPLAIN
01:37:17.731 --> 01:37:19.033
TO THE TO THE TEACHERS ARE
01:37:19.099 --> 01:37:20.734
SITUATIONS AND TEACHERS WOULD BE
01:37:20.801 --> 01:37:21.769
ABLE TO GAIN A BETTER
01:37:21.835 --> 01:37:23.404
UNDERSTANDING OF THE STUDENTS
01:37:23.470 --> 01:37:25.639
AND FIND A WAY TO HELP THEM.
01:37:25.706 --> 01:37:27.241
I STATED EARLIER LA YOU IS THE
01:37:27.308 --> 01:37:29.043
HAS ALREADY ENDED WILLFUL
01:37:29.109 --> 01:37:31.145
DEFINES AS A MEANS OF SUSPENSION.
01:37:31.212 --> 01:37:32.646
AND IT HAS SERVED AS A POSITIVE
01:37:32.713 --> 01:37:34.682
EDUCATIONAL CATALYST.
01:37:34.748 --> 01:37:36.350
AS A STUDENT I HAVE SEEN OF
01:37:36.417 --> 01:37:37.885
ASKED CHANGING CLASSROOMS.
01:37:37.952 --> 01:37:39.653
AND HAS BEEN BETTER.
01:37:39.720 --> 01:37:42.022
BETTER FOR EVERYONE.
01:37:42.089 --> 01:37:42.823
STUDENTS OF COLOR AND STUDENTS
01:37:42.890 --> 01:37:44.425
WITH DISABILITIES ARE NO LONGER
01:37:44.491 --> 01:37:45.659
BEING HEAVILY SUSPENDED AS THEY
01:37:45.726 --> 01:37:47.595
WERE BEFORE.
01:37:47.661 --> 01:37:49.463
IT IS IMPORTANT TO SAY THAT ALL
01:37:49.530 --> 01:37:51.031
STUDENTS IN THE STATE DESERVE
01:37:51.098 --> 01:37:51.899
THIS PROTECTION NOT JUST YOUNG
01:37:51.966 --> 01:37:53.000
ADULTS [inaudible]
01:37:53.067 --> 01:37:55.302
YOUNG.
01:37:55.369 --> 01:37:57.071
ALTHOUGH S. BEFORE NINETEEN DOES
01:37:57.137 --> 01:37:58.739
NOT PROTECT HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS
01:37:58.806 --> 01:38:00.674
WE HOPE THE LEGISLATOR IT WILL
01:38:00.741 --> 01:38:02.343
CONTINUE TO WORK WITH US. TO
01:38:02.409 --> 01:38:02.910
PROTECT THE RIGHTS OF YOUNG
01:38:02.977 --> 01:38:04.078
PEOPLE.
01:38:04.144 --> 01:38:05.713
ESPECIALLY VULNERABLE GROUPS
01:38:05.779 --> 01:38:06.847
LIKE STUDENTS OF COLOR.
01:38:06.914 --> 01:38:08.582
STUDENTS WITH DISABILITIES.
01:38:08.649 --> 01:38:11.118
AND LGBT STUDENTS.
01:38:11.185 --> 01:38:12.519
I HOPE TO SEE THIS IMPLEMENTED
01:38:12.586 --> 01:38:13.921
ACROSS THE NATION.
01:38:13.988 --> 01:38:15.489
ONE BUT BEFORE THAT HAPPENS.
01:38:15.556 --> 01:38:18.158
HAS THAT BEEN HERE.
01:38:18.225 --> 01:38:20.160
SO I CAME HERE TO IMPLORE YOU
01:38:20.227 --> 01:38:22.763
PLEASE SUPPORT THIS BILL.
01:38:22.830 --> 01:38:23.364
PLEASE SUPPORT STUDENTS ACROSS
01:38:23.430 --> 01:38:24.898
CALIFORNIA.
01:38:24.965 --> 01:38:26.500
THANK YOU IS THERE ANOTHER WHAT
01:38:26.567 --> 01:38:27.835
ANOTHER WITNESS YES GOOD
01:38:27.901 --> 01:38:29.370
AFTERNOON.
01:38:29.436 --> 01:38:30.204
MR CHEN MEMBERS MY NAME IS
01:38:30.271 --> 01:38:31.605
YVONNE CARRY ON WITH ASSOCIATION
01:38:31.672 --> 01:38:32.072
OF CALIFORNIA SCHOOL
01:38:32.139 --> 01:38:33.107
ADMINISTRATORS.
01:38:33.173 --> 01:38:34.608
ACCESS PROUD TO SUPPORT AS
01:38:34.675 --> 01:38:36.176
BEFORE ONE NINE BECAUSE WILL FOR
01:38:36.243 --> 01:38:38.178
DEFIANCE POLICIES CONTINUE TO
01:38:38.245 --> 01:38:39.280
DISPROPORTIONATELY IMPACT
01:38:39.346 --> 01:38:40.781
STUDENTS OF COLOR AND BECAUSE
01:38:40.848 --> 01:38:41.682
THERE ARE MORE EFFECTIVE
01:38:41.749 --> 01:38:44.551
APPROACHES FOR DEALING WITH REAL
01:38:44.618 --> 01:38:45.819
AND PERCEIVED IT DEFINES.
01:38:45.886 --> 01:38:46.487
THE MAJORITY OF ACCESS
01:38:46.553 --> 01:38:48.022
MEMBERSHIP IS MADE UP OF
01:38:48.088 --> 01:38:49.623
PRINCIPALS AND VICE PRINCIPALS.
01:38:49.690 --> 01:38:52.259
WHOSE JOB INCLUDES -- HANDLING
01:38:52.326 --> 01:38:53.961
DISCIPLINARY ACTIONS AND
01:38:54.028 --> 01:38:55.963
MANAGING CAMPUS SCHOOL CLIMATE.
01:38:56.030 --> 01:38:56.730
IN THIS SEGMENT OF OUR
01:38:56.797 --> 01:38:57.698
MEMBERSHIP REPORTS HAVING
01:38:57.765 --> 01:38:59.300
SUCCESS IMPLEMENTING ALTERNATIVE
01:38:59.366 --> 01:39:00.834
APPROACHES THAT STRENGTH AND
01:39:00.901 --> 01:39:02.002
STUDENT CONNECTEDNESS.
01:39:02.069 --> 01:39:04.238
REDUCE NEGATIVE BEHAVIORS AND
01:39:04.305 --> 01:39:05.873
IMPROVE ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE.
01:39:05.939 --> 01:39:07.174
THESE INCLUDE PROGRAMS THAT
01:39:07.241 --> 01:39:08.442
DEVELOP MEANING MEANINGFUL
01:39:08.509 --> 01:39:09.510
RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN STAFF AND
01:39:09.576 --> 01:39:11.178
STUDENTS.
01:39:11.245 --> 01:39:12.746
ONES THAT RECOGNIZE AND REWARD
01:39:12.813 --> 01:39:16.016
POSITIVE BEHAVIORS -- PROGRAMS
01:39:16.083 --> 01:39:17.651
THAT ADDRESS UNCONSCIOUS BIAS
01:39:17.718 --> 01:39:19.320
STRATEGIES THAT PROMOTE PEER TO
01:39:19.386 --> 01:39:20.254
PEER ACCOUNTABILITY IN CONFLICT
01:39:20.321 --> 01:39:22.122
RESOLUTION.
01:39:22.189 --> 01:39:23.023
BUT EVEN AS MORE AND MORE
01:39:23.090 --> 01:39:24.191
SCHOOLS ARE IMPLEMENTING THE
01:39:24.258 --> 01:39:25.592
STRATEGIES AND REDUCING THEIR
01:39:25.659 --> 01:39:27.428
USE OF SUSPENSIONS ACTS A
01:39:27.494 --> 01:39:28.829
BELIEVES THAT WILL FOR DEFIANCE
01:39:28.896 --> 01:39:30.497
MUST BE ELIMINATED.
01:39:30.564 --> 01:39:32.199
ACCESS CANNOT SUPPORT A POLICY
01:39:32.266 --> 01:39:33.334
THAT OVERWHELMINGLY AND
01:39:33.400 --> 01:39:35.002
DISPROPORTIONATELY IMPACTS
01:39:35.069 --> 01:39:36.203
COMMUNITIES OF COLOR
01:39:36.270 --> 01:39:37.271
PARTICULARLY AFRICAN AMERICAN
01:39:37.338 --> 01:39:38.672
STUDENTS.
01:39:38.739 --> 01:39:39.907
AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDENTS MAKE
01:39:39.973 --> 01:39:41.709
UP JUST OVER 5% OF THE STATE'S
01:39:41.775 --> 01:39:43.610
STUDENT POPULATION GET REPRESENT
01:39:43.677 --> 01:39:45.713
NEARLY 16% OF THOSE WERE
01:39:45.779 --> 01:39:47.414
SUSPENDED FOR WILLFUL DEFIANCE.
01:39:47.481 --> 01:39:49.516
BLACK STUDENTS ARE THREE TIMES
01:39:49.583 --> 01:39:50.617
MORE LIKELY TO BE SUSPENDED FOR
01:39:50.684 --> 01:39:52.019
WORLD WILL FOR THE FINANCE THAN
01:39:52.086 --> 01:39:53.587
THEIR WHITE PEERS.
01:39:53.654 --> 01:39:55.222
AND RESEARCH CLEARLY SHOWS THE
01:39:55.289 --> 01:39:55.823
RISK INVOLVED WITH SUSPENDING
01:39:55.889 --> 01:39:57.157
YOU'VE.
01:39:57.224 --> 01:39:59.360
KIDS WHO ARE SUSPENDED ARE FIVE
01:39:59.426 --> 01:40:00.027
TIMES MORE LIKELY TO DROP OUT OF
01:40:00.094 --> 01:40:00.694
SCHOOL.
01:40:00.761 --> 01:40:01.995
AND ELEVEN TIMES MORE LIKELY TO
01:40:02.062 --> 01:40:03.163
BECOME INVOLVED IN THE CRIMINAL
01:40:03.230 --> 01:40:04.965
JUSTICE SYSTEM.
01:40:05.032 --> 01:40:06.367
STUDENTS ARE SAFEST AND BEST
01:40:06.433 --> 01:40:08.035
SERVED WHEN AT SCHOOL FOR THESE
01:40:08.102 --> 01:40:09.403
REASONS ACCESS SUPPORTS AS
01:40:09.470 --> 01:40:11.105
BEFORE ONE NINE A RESPECTFULLY
01:40:11.171 --> 01:40:12.773
ASK YOUR RIVAL [inaudible]
01:40:12.840 --> 01:40:14.775
THANK YOU.
01:40:14.842 --> 01:40:17.644
OTHERS IN SUPPORT.
01:40:17.711 --> 01:40:18.812
JUST COME UP TO MY CURRENT STATE
01:40:18.879 --> 01:40:21.081
YOUR NAME AFFILIATION AND
01:40:21.148 --> 01:40:24.585
POSITION ON THE BILL ONLY PLEASE.
01:40:24.651 --> 01:40:24.852
ACTUALLY.
01:40:24.918 --> 01:40:26.186
WHEN WE HOPE TO STAY IN SUPPORT
01:40:26.253 --> 01:40:28.088
BUT WE MIGHT HAVE TO PULL ARE CO
01:40:28.155 --> 01:40:29.423
SPONSORS HAVE SINCE IT WAS
01:40:29.490 --> 01:40:30.524
DROPPED -- TWO K. THROUGH EIGHT
01:40:30.591 --> 01:40:31.458
INSTEAD OF K. THROUGH.
01:40:31.525 --> 01:40:33.127
TWELVE I'M HERE FOR THREE YOUNG
01:40:33.193 --> 01:40:37.131
PEOPLE CHRIS CARTER ON A LOPEZ
01:40:37.197 --> 01:40:38.599
AND JEREMY PEROT WHO WERE ALL
01:40:38.665 --> 01:40:41.602
KILLED DURING SCHOOL HOURS --
01:40:41.668 --> 01:40:43.237
LEAVING HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS AT
01:40:43.303 --> 01:40:45.839
ITS MOST DANGEROUS AGE GROUP
01:40:45.906 --> 01:40:46.106
THANK YOU.
01:40:46.173 --> 01:40:50.310
NEXT.
01:40:50.377 --> 01:40:51.445
MARCO PART WITH POLICY LINK IN
01:40:51.512 --> 01:40:52.946
THE ALLIANCE FOR BOYS AND MEN OF
01:40:53.013 --> 01:40:54.181
COLOR IN STRONG SUPPORT LAUSD
01:40:54.248 --> 01:40:54.748
BAND THE SUSPENSIONS FOR OUR
01:40:54.815 --> 01:40:56.150
GRADES FIVE YEARS AGO AND NOW
01:40:56.216 --> 01:40:57.651
THEY HAVE BETTER OUTCOMES.
01:40:57.718 --> 01:40:58.585
YOU CAN'T GET TO THE END USER
01:40:58.652 --> 01:41:00.587
STUDENT SUCCESS WITHOUT HAVE
01:41:00.654 --> 01:41:02.756
BUILT SENTENCE IN SCHOOL THANK
01:41:02.823 --> 01:41:12.966
YOU YES I SUPPORT THE THANK YOU.
01:41:13.033 --> 01:41:14.001
MR MEMBERS KEVIN TRAUMA BEHALF
01:41:14.067 --> 01:41:14.701
THE COMPTON UNIFIED SCHOOL
01:41:14.768 --> 01:41:15.269
DISTRICT IN THE CALIFORNIA
01:41:15.335 --> 01:41:17.337
ASSOCIATION OF BLACK SCHOOL
01:41:17.404 --> 01:41:19.640
EDUCATORS AND STRONG SUPPORT.
01:41:19.706 --> 01:41:20.507
GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIR MEMBERS
01:41:20.574 --> 01:41:21.341
THERE CLINICS ON BEHALF THE SAN
01:41:21.408 --> 01:41:21.842
FRANCISCO UNIFIED SCHOOL
01:41:21.909 --> 01:41:24.912
DISTRICT AND SUPPORT.
01:41:24.978 --> 01:41:26.013
GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIRMAN MEMBERS
01:41:26.079 --> 01:41:28.282
SAID DEBORAH BROWN ON BEHALF OF
01:41:28.348 --> 01:41:31.618
CHILDREN NOW IN SUPPORT.
01:41:31.685 --> 01:41:32.419
GOOD AFTERNOON MISTER CHAIRMAN
01:41:32.486 --> 01:41:33.454
MEMBERS PAMELA GIVES
01:41:33.520 --> 01:41:34.788
REPRESENTING THE LOS ANGELES
01:41:34.855 --> 01:41:37.024
COUNTY OFFICE OF EDUCATION AND
01:41:37.090 --> 01:41:41.528
I'M PROUD TO SUPPORT THIS BILL.
01:41:41.595 --> 01:41:43.063
MY NAME IS COPPING SO I'M WITH --
01:41:43.130 --> 01:41:44.298
MERCED AND SACRAMENTO BLACK
01:41:44.364 --> 01:41:45.866
PARALLEL SCHOOL BOARD AND MARIE
01:41:45.933 --> 01:41:49.069
IN SUPPORT.
01:41:49.136 --> 01:41:51.104
CAN'T BE SURE FOR ACLU OF
01:41:51.171 --> 01:41:55.008
CALIFORNIANS SUPPORT. THREE
01:41:55.075 --> 01:41:57.010
SANDERSON THE ARE CAN YOU SEE P.
01:41:57.077 --> 01:41:57.578
CALIFORNIA COLLABORATION AND
01:41:57.644 --> 01:42:00.581
SUPPORT.
01:42:00.647 --> 01:42:03.350
GOOD AFTERNOON OSKAR LARA WITH
01:42:03.417 --> 01:42:03.884
INNER CITY STRUGGLING WERE
01:42:03.951 --> 01:42:07.054
SUPPORT.
01:42:07.120 --> 01:42:08.422
CALL IMPACT -- WITH LOS ANGELES
01:42:08.489 --> 01:42:08.956
UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT IN
01:42:09.022 --> 01:42:11.358
SUPPORT.
01:42:11.425 --> 01:42:11.992
THEY RETURNED WITH THE BUT THE
01:42:12.059 --> 01:42:14.261
SUN CELLS COALITION SIX BLACK
01:42:14.328 --> 01:42:17.431
STUDENTS ARE SIX POINT 75% ARE.
01:42:17.498 --> 01:42:22.069
MORE LIKELY THANK YOU TO BE.
01:42:22.135 --> 01:42:23.470
THANK YOU SIR THANK YOU.
01:42:23.537 --> 01:42:28.375
I APPRECIATE YOUR PASSION.
01:42:28.442 --> 01:42:29.743
MILLER LIKE A SUB IN USERS
01:42:29.810 --> 01:42:31.211
COALITION IN SUPPORT PROTECTING
01:42:31.278 --> 01:42:33.247
ALL STUDENTS K. THROUGH TWELVE
01:42:33.313 --> 01:42:33.780
FROM THE SCHOOL TO PRISON
01:42:33.847 --> 01:42:36.483
PIPELINE.
01:42:36.550 --> 01:42:38.218
MAY RODRIGUEZ AND EDUCATION
01:42:38.285 --> 01:42:41.655
TRUST WESTERN STRONG SUPPORT.
01:42:41.722 --> 01:42:42.756
ERICA HOFFMAN ON BEHALF OF THE
01:42:42.823 --> 01:42:43.257
CALIFORNIA SCHOOL BOARDS
01:42:43.323 --> 01:42:45.259
ASSOCIATION WE HAVE HAD A
01:42:45.325 --> 01:42:47.060
SUPPORT IF UNLESS AMENDED ON
01:42:47.127 --> 01:42:47.861
THIS BILL OR SUPPORT IF AMENDED
01:42:47.928 --> 01:42:48.762
ON THE BILL.
01:42:48.829 --> 01:42:49.696
BECAUSE OUR CONCERN IS WITH THE
01:42:49.763 --> 01:42:52.266
HIGH SCHOOL PIECE AND THE FACT
01:42:52.332 --> 01:42:53.667
THAT WE STILL DON'T HAVE.
01:42:53.734 --> 01:42:54.868
MULTIPLE SYSTEMS OF SUPPORT WE
01:42:54.935 --> 01:42:56.203
DON'T HAVE RESTORATIVE JUSTICE
01:42:56.270 --> 01:42:57.571
WE DON'T HAVE TRAINING FOR ALL
01:42:57.638 --> 01:42:58.238
TEACHERS ESPECIALLY IN THE HIGH
01:42:58.305 --> 01:42:59.840
SCHOOL ROUND WE DO GREATLY
01:42:59.907 --> 01:43:01.375
APPRECIATE THE AMENDMENTS THAT
01:43:01.441 --> 01:43:02.609
WERE GIVEN AND WE MAY HAVE TO
01:43:02.676 --> 01:43:08.148
HAVE A SUPPORT POSITION.
01:43:08.215 --> 01:43:09.383
URBAN YOUTH JUST COALITION
01:43:09.449 --> 01:43:10.584
HERE'S A SPORT I IN CARE OF
01:43:10.651 --> 01:43:11.685
FRAUD CASE K. THROUGH TWELVE
01:43:11.752 --> 01:43:12.185
THANK YOU.
01:43:12.252 --> 01:43:12.953
THANK YOU.
01:43:13.020 --> 01:43:14.922
SIGNAL FOR THEIR OPPOSITION WILL
01:43:14.988 --> 01:43:16.924
BRING IT BACK TO THE COMMITTEE --
01:43:16.990 --> 01:43:19.126
THANK YOU CENTER -- I'M SORRY I
01:43:19.192 --> 01:43:20.827
APOLOGIZE ANGELES HAND PUBLIC
01:43:20.894 --> 01:43:22.462
COUNCIL I'M SORRY ANGELA TURNER
01:43:22.529 --> 01:43:23.564
PUBLIC COUNCIL IN SUPPORT OKAY
01:43:23.630 --> 01:43:28.502
THANK YOU I APOLOGIZE -- AT
01:43:28.569 --> 01:43:29.102
OPPOSITION YEAH I DO HAVE THE
01:43:29.169 --> 01:43:29.870
OPPOSITION TO THIS BILL I
01:43:29.937 --> 01:43:30.938
APOLOGIZE.
01:43:31.004 --> 01:43:31.972
SEEING OPPOSITION WILL BRING IT
01:43:32.039 --> 01:43:34.241
BACK TO THE COMMITTEE HERE AND
01:43:34.308 --> 01:43:35.509
I'LL JUST COMMENT THANK YOU FOR
01:43:35.576 --> 01:43:37.210
THE BILL SENATOR I KNOW MY
01:43:37.277 --> 01:43:37.678
CONCERN IS REALLY ALL
01:43:37.744 --> 01:43:38.645
SUSPENSIONS.
01:43:38.712 --> 01:43:40.347
AND HAVING BEEN IN A HIGH SCHOOL
01:43:40.414 --> 01:43:42.215
FOR MANY YEARS -- I WOULD NOT
01:43:42.282 --> 01:43:43.216
I'M NOT ONE THAT WOULD SAY YOU
01:43:43.283 --> 01:43:44.618
SHOULD NEVER SUSPEND THERE ARE
01:43:44.685 --> 01:43:45.919
CERTAIN INSTANCES WORLD REALLY
01:43:45.986 --> 01:43:47.220
FOR SAFETY ISSUES ALONE
01:43:47.287 --> 01:43:48.622
SOMETIMES YOU MUST SUSPEND BUT
01:43:48.689 --> 01:43:50.123
YOU SHOULD NEVER SUSPENDED FOR
01:43:50.190 --> 01:43:51.191
WEARING A HAT.
01:43:51.258 --> 01:43:52.159
AND I CAN'T THINK OF ANYTHING
01:43:52.225 --> 01:43:53.493
MORE COUNTERPRODUCTIVE THAN
01:43:53.560 --> 01:43:54.595
SUSPENDING A STUDENT BECAUSE ARE
01:43:54.661 --> 01:43:55.862
LATE FOR SCHOOL.
01:43:55.929 --> 01:43:57.497
SO IF THOSE THINGS ARE GOING ON
01:43:57.564 --> 01:43:58.432
I DON'T THINK YOU REALLY HAVE A
01:43:58.498 --> 01:43:59.399
LEGAL OR NEED A LOT OF PROBLEM
01:43:59.466 --> 01:44:00.567
YOU'RE PROBABLY HAVE AN
01:44:00.634 --> 01:44:03.036
ADMINISTRATIVE PROBLEM -- AND
01:44:03.103 --> 01:44:03.704
I'M THE KIND OF TEACHER YOU KNOW
01:44:03.770 --> 01:44:05.005
I I DIDN'T KEEP REFERRALS MY
01:44:05.072 --> 01:44:06.974
DESK I WAS IN THAT WHAT KIND OF
01:44:07.040 --> 01:44:07.975
GUY I CAN'T TELL YOU IF EITHER
01:44:08.041 --> 01:44:08.675
YEARS.
01:44:08.742 --> 01:44:09.376
YEARS WENT BY WHEN I DIDN'T EVEN
01:44:09.443 --> 01:44:11.511
WRITE -- ONE BECAUSE YOU USE
01:44:11.578 --> 01:44:12.946
YOUR PEOPLE SKILLS RIGHT THE
01:44:13.013 --> 01:44:13.914
RELEASE OF THEIR KIDS THEIR
01:44:13.981 --> 01:44:14.448
GROWING.
01:44:14.514 --> 01:44:16.083
AND YOU GOTTA BE FLEXIBLE
01:44:16.149 --> 01:44:18.085
SOMETIMES YOU KNOW FLEXIBILITY
01:44:18.151 --> 01:44:20.654
INFLEXIBLE -- SO I APPRECIATE
01:44:20.721 --> 01:44:22.222
THAT AGAIN MY REAL CONCERN IS
01:44:22.289 --> 01:44:24.257
ALL SUSPENSIONS AND I KNOW THIS
01:44:24.324 --> 01:44:24.891
YEAR'S.
01:44:24.958 --> 01:44:25.959
TOO SO I'M AND I DON'T TAKE THAT
01:44:26.026 --> 01:44:27.694
AWAY FROM YOU -- SO I SO I
01:44:27.761 --> 01:44:29.029
APPRECIATE THE BILL AND WILL
01:44:29.096 --> 01:44:29.863
HAVE FURTHER CONVERSATIONS
01:44:29.930 --> 01:44:32.265
CLEARLY -- WITH THAT I THINK
01:44:32.332 --> 01:44:34.267
DOCTOR WEBER WANTED TO COME
01:44:34.334 --> 01:44:36.436
RIGHT I WANT -- TO ARE CLEARLY
01:44:36.503 --> 01:44:38.238
THINK -- SENATE FOR FOR BRINGING
01:44:38.305 --> 01:44:39.306
THIS BILL FORWARD IN AND THIS IS
01:44:39.373 --> 01:44:41.541
BEEN SOMETHING ON THE AGENDA FOR
01:44:41.608 --> 01:44:42.609
AT LEAST A LONG AS I'VE BEEN
01:44:42.676 --> 01:44:44.978
HERE -- AND IT'S UNFORTUNATE
01:44:45.045 --> 01:44:46.613
THAT WE HAVE TO AMENDED TO LEAVE
01:44:46.680 --> 01:44:47.781
UP THE HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS
01:44:47.848 --> 01:44:49.316
BECAUSE THAT REALLY IS ONE OF
01:44:49.383 --> 01:44:50.450
THE MAJOR CHALLENGES THAT'S
01:44:50.517 --> 01:44:52.586
THERE THAN WE SHOULD BE ABLE TO
01:44:52.653 --> 01:44:54.354
ADDRESS THAT -- I GUESS IT WAS
01:44:54.421 --> 01:44:55.856
PROBABLY A COUPLE YEARS AGO I
01:44:55.922 --> 01:44:58.392
WAS ASKED INVITED TO GO TO
01:44:58.458 --> 01:44:59.726
WASHINGTON NEW YORK.
01:44:59.793 --> 01:45:00.927
TO PARTICIPATE IN A CONVERSATION
01:45:00.994 --> 01:45:05.999
CONCERNING SUSPENSIONS AND
01:45:06.066 --> 01:45:07.567
EXPULSIONS.
01:45:07.634 --> 01:45:08.735
AND I THOUGHT IT WAS INTERESTING
01:45:08.802 --> 01:45:09.336
I WAS INVITED SO I WENT AND I
01:45:09.403 --> 01:45:10.270
EXPECTED TO YOU KNOW TO LEARN A
01:45:10.337 --> 01:45:11.138
LOT FROM FOLKS ALL ACROSS THE
01:45:11.204 --> 01:45:11.772
COUNTRY IS THE WHAT THEY WERE
01:45:11.838 --> 01:45:12.839
DOING.
01:45:12.906 --> 01:45:14.708
AND A LOT OF THEM WITH THEIR BUT
01:45:14.775 --> 01:45:15.909
WHAT SHOCKED ME MOST WAS I GOT
01:45:15.976 --> 01:45:16.977
THE IN WHO WAS LEADING THE
01:45:17.044 --> 01:45:18.679
CONVERSATION AS A THOR HE'S IN
01:45:18.745 --> 01:45:19.680
THE ROOM WAS AT DEPARTMENT OF
01:45:19.746 --> 01:45:20.847
EDUCATION.
01:45:20.914 --> 01:45:23.016
IN CALIFORNIA -- AND THEY HAD
01:45:23.083 --> 01:45:24.284
ALL THE RESEARCH AND ALL THE
01:45:24.351 --> 01:45:26.153
DATA IN ALL THE INFORMATION IT
01:45:26.219 --> 01:45:26.720
JUST KIND OF BLEW ME AWAY
01:45:26.787 --> 01:45:29.156
BECAUSE YOU I DON'T SEE THEM
01:45:29.222 --> 01:45:30.824
PRESENTING THAT DATE AND THAT
01:45:30.891 --> 01:45:32.125
INFORMATION AND DRIVING IF
01:45:32.192 --> 01:45:33.326
YOU'RE CALIFORNIA.
01:45:33.393 --> 01:45:35.562
AND SO I WAS KIND OF SHOCKED
01:45:35.629 --> 01:45:37.864
THAT THEY WERE THERE AND AND AND
01:45:37.931 --> 01:45:38.899
AND THAT THEY HAVE BEEN DOING
01:45:38.965 --> 01:45:40.767
THIS WORK AND AND WERE REALLY
01:45:40.834 --> 01:45:43.603
STRONG SUPPORT IS AGAINST US THE
01:45:43.670 --> 01:45:44.805
SUSPENSIONS AND EXPULSIONS.
01:45:44.871 --> 01:45:46.440
AND AND YOU KNOW THEY WERE
01:45:46.506 --> 01:45:49.142
INFORMING OTHER STATES ABOUT
01:45:49.209 --> 01:45:51.011
THIS ISSUE WHEN WE WOULD NOT
01:45:51.078 --> 01:45:53.313
LEADING IN PRACTICE SO I JUST
01:45:53.380 --> 01:45:54.748
FOUND IT EXTREMELY.
01:45:54.815 --> 01:45:56.817
INTERESTING FOR ME TO COME THERE
01:45:56.883 --> 01:45:59.019
AND REALIZING THAT I WAS WALKING
01:45:59.086 --> 01:46:01.588
IN TO BE ON THE TEAM OF EXPERTS --
01:46:01.655 --> 01:46:03.123
WHEN I THOUGHT I'D BE HEARING
01:46:03.190 --> 01:46:04.758
FROM OUR OWN DEPARTMENT -- OR
01:46:04.825 --> 01:46:06.093
HEARING FROM OTHER DEPARTMENTS
01:46:06.159 --> 01:46:06.993
AND WE HEARD FROM SOME OF THEM
01:46:07.060 --> 01:46:09.129
AS TO WHAT NEED TO MOVE FORWARD
01:46:09.196 --> 01:46:10.430
AND SO I EVEN TODAY I STILL
01:46:10.497 --> 01:46:12.199
DON'T SEE THEM HERE LEADING THE
01:46:12.265 --> 01:46:13.166
CHARGE.
01:46:13.233 --> 01:46:14.568
THIS IS AN ISSUE THAT WE HAVE
01:46:14.634 --> 01:46:16.203
LOTS OF WORK ON A LOTS OF
01:46:16.269 --> 01:46:18.171
RESEARCH ON AND I THINK IT'S
01:46:18.238 --> 01:46:20.607
SOMETHING THAT -- THAT WE NEED
01:46:20.674 --> 01:46:22.809
TO TAKE THE LEAD ON IT'S IT'S I
01:46:22.876 --> 01:46:23.410
MEAN I DON'T WITH THIS WHEN I
01:46:23.477 --> 01:46:24.544
WAS IN SCHOOL WERE TWENTY SOME
01:46:24.611 --> 01:46:26.079
YEARS AGO ABOUT THE OVER
01:46:26.146 --> 01:46:28.148
SUSPENSIONS AND EXPULSIONS OF
01:46:28.215 --> 01:46:30.817
KIDS IN THE OUTCOMES AND AND ALL
01:46:30.884 --> 01:46:31.985
THOSE THINGS THAT WAS SO UNFAIR
01:46:32.052 --> 01:46:32.786
AND SOMEONE JUST.
01:46:32.853 --> 01:46:33.987
IN DEALING WITH THE CHILDREN OF
01:46:34.054 --> 01:46:35.122
THAT WOULD BEARD WHO WAS GETTING
01:46:35.188 --> 01:46:37.224
SUSPENDED AND EXPELLED AND EVEN
01:46:37.290 --> 01:46:38.759
WHEN WE WOULD ELIMINATED THEY'D
01:46:38.825 --> 01:46:39.493
BE THE KIDS SITTING IN THE
01:46:39.559 --> 01:46:40.694
HALLWAY RATHER THAN IN THE
01:46:40.761 --> 01:46:42.062
CLASSROOM FOR INSTRUCTION.
01:46:42.129 --> 01:46:43.563
SO WE HAVE TO DO A BETTER JOB
01:46:43.630 --> 01:46:45.132
AND WE KNOW WHAT WE NEED TO DO I
01:46:45.198 --> 01:46:46.967
MEAN I WAS LISTENING TO ALL OF
01:46:47.033 --> 01:46:48.168
OUR EXPERTS TALK ABOUT AND I
01:46:48.235 --> 01:46:49.536
THOUGHT TO MYSELF.
01:46:49.603 --> 01:46:50.804
YOU KNOW IT ARE WE GIVING THIS
01:46:50.871 --> 01:46:52.472
INFORMATION FOR TRAINING IN OUR
01:46:52.539 --> 01:46:54.307
SCHOOLS AND ARE WE HELPING FOLKS
01:46:54.374 --> 01:46:56.176
TO UNDERSTAND WHAT THEY'RE DOING
01:46:56.243 --> 01:46:56.777
AND HOW THEY'RE DOING AND IT
01:46:56.843 --> 01:46:58.211
JUST SEEMS. TO BE SUCH A
01:46:58.278 --> 01:47:00.113
TREMENDOUS DISCONNECT HERE IN
01:47:00.180 --> 01:47:01.748
THE STATE BETWEEN WHAT OUR
01:47:01.815 --> 01:47:06.820
DEPARTMENT WAS DOING THIS ABOUT
01:47:06.887 --> 01:47:08.655
FOUR YEARS A SO WHAT I'VE
01:47:08.722 --> 01:47:09.923
DEPARTMENT KNEW AND WAS DOING IN
01:47:09.990 --> 01:47:10.257
RECOMMENDING.
01:47:10.323 --> 01:47:10.891
AND YET WHAT WE WERE DOING IN
01:47:10.957 --> 01:47:11.691
TERMS OF PRACTICE IN THE STATE
01:47:11.758 --> 01:47:12.626
OF CALIFORNIA SO -- I THANK YOU
01:47:12.692 --> 01:47:13.460
FOR BRINGING THIS FORWARD IT'S
01:47:13.527 --> 01:47:15.662
AN ONGOING CHALLENGE -- WE NEED
01:47:15.729 --> 01:47:16.263
TO GET TO THE POINT WHERE WE
01:47:16.329 --> 01:47:18.398
REALLY LOUD ALLOW THE RESEARCH
01:47:18.465 --> 01:47:19.399
IN THE WORK THAT WE DO WITH THE
01:47:19.466 --> 01:47:21.468
STATE DEPARTMENT. TO DRIVE THE
01:47:21.535 --> 01:47:23.270
ACTIVITIES IN THE SUPPORT FOR AT
01:47:23.336 --> 01:47:25.505
OUR SCHOOLS IN THIS AREA BECAUSE
01:47:25.572 --> 01:47:26.406
IT IS EIGHT EIGHT IMPORTANT
01:47:26.473 --> 01:47:29.009
ISSUE AND ALL THE DATA IS CLEAR
01:47:29.075 --> 01:47:29.609
WHAT HAPPENS WHEN KIDS WHEN
01:47:29.676 --> 01:47:31.878
THEY'RE SUSPENDED AND EXPELLED.
01:47:31.945 --> 01:47:33.413
EARLY IN LIFE PARTICULARLY --
01:47:33.480 --> 01:47:34.815
WAS STILL SUSPENDING KIDS IN
01:47:34.881 --> 01:47:36.082
KINDERGARTEN AND ALL THAT STUFF
01:47:36.149 --> 01:47:36.983
THE DEADLY MAKE A WHOLE LOT OF
01:47:37.050 --> 01:47:39.820
SENSE -- BUT I I I THANK YOU FOR
01:47:39.886 --> 01:47:41.254
YOUR WORK AND YOU EFFORTS AND I
01:47:41.321 --> 01:47:44.524
THINK WE HAVE TO JUST CONTINUE
01:47:44.591 --> 01:47:46.159
TO PUSH A LITTLE BIT HARDER.
01:47:46.226 --> 01:47:48.228
MOVE THE BILL.
01:47:48.295 --> 01:47:50.063
IT'S BEEN MOVED AND SECONDED.
01:47:50.130 --> 01:47:50.664
AND I SAID ONE HIGHLIGHT THAT
01:47:50.730 --> 01:47:51.898
THE SUSPENSION RATE IS NOW PART
01:47:51.965 --> 01:47:53.567
OF THE DASHBOARD.
01:47:53.633 --> 01:47:55.202
YES REALLY YES TELLS A LOT RIGHT
01:47:55.268 --> 01:47:56.169
AND REALLY MAKES DISTRICTS PAY
01:47:56.236 --> 01:47:58.171
ATTENTION OR NOT JUST.
01:47:58.238 --> 01:47:59.773
FOR THE FINAL FOR ALL ALL
01:47:59.840 --> 01:48:03.810
REASONS -- SO WITH THAT I SEE NO
01:48:03.877 --> 01:48:04.311
FOR THE COMING FROM THE
01:48:04.377 --> 01:48:05.612
COMMITTEE.
01:48:05.679 --> 01:48:08.181
MISTER KALRA THANK YOU MISTER
01:48:08.248 --> 01:48:11.218
HAND UP SHAPER SHOULD -- AND AND
01:48:11.284 --> 01:48:12.485
HAVE I OBVIOUSLY HAD THE STEP UP
01:48:12.552 --> 01:48:13.119
FOR ANOTHER QUICK MEETINGS DID
01:48:13.186 --> 01:48:13.987
GET A CHANCE TO HEAR SOME OF THE
01:48:14.054 --> 01:48:14.921
DIALOGUE BUT I CAN GUESS AS TO
01:48:14.988 --> 01:48:16.590
WHERE SOME OF IT WAS AND I
01:48:16.656 --> 01:48:18.458
CERTAINLY SUPPORT.
01:48:18.525 --> 01:48:22.295
ANY EFFORT -- FOR US TO REDUCE --
01:48:22.362 --> 01:48:23.697
THE USE OF WILL FOR DEFIANCE --
01:48:23.763 --> 01:48:26.800
IN A MANNER THAT IS EXCLUDING --
01:48:26.867 --> 01:48:28.201
STUDENTS FROM TO SPANISH CASES
01:48:28.268 --> 01:48:30.036
BECAUSE WE KNOW WHO THE TARGET
01:48:30.103 --> 01:48:32.072
IS OFTENTIMES TO DATE AT LEAST
01:48:32.138 --> 01:48:40.380
OF WILLFUL DEFIANCE AND AND I I
01:48:40.447 --> 01:48:42.582
OR FRANKLY.
01:48:42.649 --> 01:48:44.818
I I SECOND OTHER COMMENTS A AS I
01:48:44.885 --> 01:48:46.052
WAS WALKING HEARING FROM DOCTOR
01:48:46.119 --> 01:48:47.354
WEBER -- ABOUT THE EXCLUSION OF
01:48:47.420 --> 01:48:48.955
THAT THE HIGH SCHOOL LEVEL
01:48:49.022 --> 01:48:49.522
BECAUSE I THINK THAT THAT'S
01:48:49.589 --> 01:48:50.824
REALLY WHAT WE'RE SEEING A MUCH
01:48:50.891 --> 01:48:51.424
OF THE DISPARITY THAT THERE'S
01:48:51.491 --> 01:48:52.959
OTHER OPPORTUNITIES TO ENGAGE
01:48:53.026 --> 01:48:54.761
OUR STUDENTS -- OF THAT BOARD
01:48:54.828 --> 01:48:57.764
EVER REASON -- A TEACHER MAY
01:48:57.831 --> 01:48:59.399
BELIEVE IS NOT ENGAGING IN A WAY
01:48:59.466 --> 01:49:00.901
THAT'S HELPFUL TO THEM.
01:49:00.967 --> 01:49:05.572
I THINK THAT -- HAVING.
01:49:05.639 --> 01:49:06.439
I I THINK THAT THERE'S AN
01:49:06.506 --> 01:49:07.841
OPPORTUNITY EVEN AS THIS BILL --
01:49:07.908 --> 01:49:10.543
GOES FORWARD TO BETTER DEFINE.
01:49:10.610 --> 01:49:12.212
BOTH OF WILL FOR THE FINANCES
01:49:12.279 --> 01:49:14.014
THE SUBJECT SUBJECTIVITY OF IT
01:49:14.080 --> 01:49:17.050
THAT IS SUCH THE IS SO MUCH AN
01:49:17.117 --> 01:49:18.285
ISSUE WE HAVE OTHER.
01:49:18.351 --> 01:49:19.352
BILL'S GOING FORWARD IN THIS
01:49:19.419 --> 01:49:21.021
BODY REGARDING AN IMPLICIT BIAS
01:49:21.087 --> 01:49:22.122
FOR EXAMPLE A NUMBER OF
01:49:22.188 --> 01:49:23.490
DIFFERENT INDUSTRIES.
01:49:23.556 --> 01:49:25.158
AND THE EMPRESS OF BY IS THAT
01:49:25.225 --> 01:49:26.960
EXIST AMONGST ALL OF US AS PART
01:49:27.027 --> 01:49:29.562
OF THE OF THE DATA THAT OCCURS
01:49:29.629 --> 01:49:30.764
REGARDING WILLFUL DEFIANCE
01:49:30.830 --> 01:49:32.499
SUSPENSIONS EXPULSIONS WHAT HAVE
01:49:32.565 --> 01:49:33.700
YOU.
01:49:33.767 --> 01:49:35.869
THAT -- IS A DISPROPORTIONATELY
01:49:35.936 --> 01:49:38.838
AFFECTS -- PARTICULARLY -- THE
01:49:38.905 --> 01:49:39.906
YOUNG MEN OF COLOR BUT CERTAINLY
01:49:39.973 --> 01:49:42.509
YOUNG STUDENTS OF COLOR.
01:49:42.575 --> 01:49:45.512
AND THE SUSPENSION SHOULD BE
01:49:45.578 --> 01:49:46.579
MADE VERY CLEARLY IS AN OPTIONAL
01:49:46.646 --> 01:49:48.748
LAST RESORT -- WHEN ADDRESSING
01:49:48.815 --> 01:49:50.016
BOTH OF DEFIANCE RATHER RATHER
01:49:50.083 --> 01:49:52.118
THAN REMOVING IT I UNDERSTAND
01:49:52.185 --> 01:49:53.320
CERTAINLY THE THE CHAIR AND
01:49:53.386 --> 01:49:55.255
OTHERS CONCERNS OF HAVING ALL
01:49:55.322 --> 01:49:57.090
THE TOOLS AVAILABLE BECAUSE
01:49:57.157 --> 01:49:58.458
TEACHING IS NOT EASY?
01:49:58.525 --> 01:49:59.259
AND I THINK WE ALL AGREE WITH
01:49:59.326 --> 01:50:00.527
THAT WE WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT
01:50:00.593 --> 01:50:03.129
TEACHERS TO HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY.
01:50:03.196 --> 01:50:04.564
TO TEACH ALL OTHER STUDENTS AND
01:50:04.631 --> 01:50:05.932
AND THAT THERE'S ISSUES WITH ANY
01:50:05.999 --> 01:50:06.900
GIVEN STUDENT THAT SHOULD BE
01:50:06.967 --> 01:50:09.336
ADDRESSED I THINK THAT WE SHOULD.
01:50:09.402 --> 01:50:10.704
BUT IT TO THAT POINT THERE
01:50:10.770 --> 01:50:11.404
SHOULD BE AS MANY TOOLS AS
01:50:11.471 --> 01:50:13.273
POSSIBLE RATHER THAN THE
01:50:13.340 --> 01:50:15.275
SUSPENSION ROUTE -- PROVOKE OR
01:50:15.342 --> 01:50:17.277
SHORT OF THE SUSPENSION ROUTE
01:50:17.344 --> 01:50:18.945
AND SOME HOLE I HOPE THAT.
01:50:19.012 --> 01:50:20.981
AS THIS BILL MOVES FORWARD AND
01:50:21.047 --> 01:50:24.217
AS THIS ISSUE CONTINUES TO BE
01:50:24.284 --> 01:50:26.086
DEBATED -- IN THE IN THE YEARS
01:50:26.152 --> 01:50:28.488
AHEAD THAT WE HAVE A RECOGNITION
01:50:28.555 --> 01:50:30.223
THAT WE SHOULD USE ALL TO WHAT
01:50:30.290 --> 01:50:31.758
THE THE ALL THE TOOLS AVAILABLE
01:50:31.825 --> 01:50:33.259
SHOULD BE USED TO LIFT UP OUR
01:50:33.326 --> 01:50:35.261
STUDENTS AND TO PROVIDE.
01:50:35.328 --> 01:50:36.262
CERTAINLY A SAFE ENVIRONMENT FOR
01:50:36.329 --> 01:50:37.697
EVERYONE BUT REALLY DAHLE AND
01:50:37.764 --> 01:50:39.099
GOAL IS TO MAKE SURE HEALING ALL
01:50:39.165 --> 01:50:40.033
OF OUR STUDENTS.
01:50:40.100 --> 01:50:41.935
OF ANY ISSUES THAT THEY MAY BE
01:50:42.002 --> 01:50:42.836
GOING THROUGH THAT'S KEEPING
01:50:42.902 --> 01:50:44.738
THEM FROM HAVING A FULL
01:50:44.804 --> 01:50:45.605
EDUCATIONAL EXPERIENCE AND
01:50:45.672 --> 01:50:46.539
EXCELLING.
01:50:46.606 --> 01:50:47.941
US WITHOUT A A WILL SUPPORT THE
01:50:48.008 --> 01:50:51.077
BILL ALTHOUGH I DO THINK -- THAT --
01:50:51.144 --> 01:50:53.313
BUT I I WOULD SUPPORT IT PRIOR
01:50:53.380 --> 01:50:54.948
TO AMENDMENTS -- AND AND THINK
01:50:55.015 --> 01:50:56.316
THERE'S STILL AN OPPORTUNITY FOR
01:50:56.383 --> 01:50:57.584
US TO CONTINUE TO DISCUSS THIS
01:50:57.650 --> 01:50:59.819
IN TERMS OF SOME OF THE CHANGES
01:50:59.886 --> 01:51:00.720
THAT THAT.
01:51:00.787 --> 01:51:07.394
CONTINUE TO FOCUS ON THE CHILD
01:51:07.460 --> 01:51:08.661
ON THE STUDENTS THANK YOU.
01:51:08.728 --> 01:51:09.829
THANK YOU A SINGLE FOR THE
01:51:09.896 --> 01:51:10.663
COMMENT FROM THE COMMITTEE THERE
01:51:10.730 --> 01:51:12.265
HAS BEEN IN MOTION THE MOTION IS
01:51:12.332 --> 01:51:16.870
TO PASS AS AMENDED -- I KNOW I
01:51:16.936 --> 01:51:17.771
CAN GET THERE.
01:51:17.837 --> 01:51:19.506
ARE YOU MAY CLOSE THANK YOU
01:51:19.572 --> 01:51:21.574
ASKED FOR YOUR I'VE LOST MAKE
01:51:21.641 --> 01:51:24.544
SURE YOU CLOSE SO CLOSE WELL.
01:51:24.611 --> 01:51:26.713
WE HAVE A CLOSE FAST DRIVE ASK
01:51:26.780 --> 01:51:29.382
FOR YOUR AYE VOTE.
01:51:29.449 --> 01:51:30.950
YOU CAN TAKE MORE TIME.
01:51:31.017 --> 01:51:32.018
OKAY THANK YOU SENATOR.
01:51:32.085 --> 01:51:34.287
NOW WITH THAT -- PUT THEM
01:51:34.354 --> 01:51:35.488
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
01:51:35.555 --> 01:51:36.890
THE MOTION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED
01:51:36.956 --> 01:51:38.725
TO THE ASSEMBLY FLOOR O'DONNELL.
01:51:38.792 --> 01:51:40.093
O'DONNELL AYE KILEY.
01:51:40.160 --> 01:51:42.162
KILEY NO DEEP [inaudible]
01:51:42.228 --> 01:51:44.130
NO KALRA.
01:51:44.197 --> 01:51:45.932
KALRA I MCCARTY.
01:51:45.999 --> 01:51:49.069
MCCARTY EYES SMITH SMITH I WEBER.
01:51:49.135 --> 01:51:51.805
WEBER I'D.
01:51:51.871 --> 01:51:53.640
THOSE FIVE ALSO IT IS OUT.
01:51:53.706 --> 01:51:55.742
THANK YOU THANK YOU [inaudible]
01:51:55.809 --> 01:51:57.310
THANK YOU [inaudible]
01:51:57.377 --> 01:52:00.180
OKAY.
01:52:00.246 --> 01:52:01.714
MISTER ROB GET UP HERE BEFORE
01:52:01.781 --> 01:52:02.949
SOMEONE COMES IN.
01:52:03.016 --> 01:52:04.918
AND BEFORE YOU.
01:52:04.984 --> 01:52:07.187
START MISTER ROTH I JUST WANT TO
01:52:07.253 --> 01:52:08.154
HIGHLIGHT BEFORE YOU KNOW WE IN
01:52:08.221 --> 01:52:09.322
THIS COMMITTEE USUALLY PEOPLE
01:52:09.389 --> 01:52:10.857
WALK OUT AS A LOT OF NOISE.
01:52:10.924 --> 01:52:13.059
THIS IS PROBABLY OUR LAST RIGHT
01:52:13.126 --> 01:52:14.094
NOW.
01:52:14.160 --> 01:52:17.297
SCHEDULED HEARING OF THE OF THE
01:52:17.363 --> 01:52:18.731
YEAR THERE MAY BE ANOTHER WHO
01:52:18.798 --> 01:52:21.134
KNOWS BUT MAYBE NOT I JUST WANT
01:52:21.201 --> 01:52:22.235
TO THANK THAT THE COMMITTEE
01:52:22.302 --> 01:52:23.369
STAFF TONYA [inaudible]
01:52:23.436 --> 01:52:25.238
AND CHELSEA.
01:52:25.305 --> 01:52:26.873
AND MARGUERITE.
01:52:26.940 --> 01:52:29.309
AND DEBBIE AND SOPHIA -- LEANS
01:52:29.375 --> 01:52:30.243
AND HELPS THE COMMITTEE
01:52:30.310 --> 01:52:32.145
SOMETIMES TOO AND OF COURSE JOHN
01:52:32.212 --> 01:52:34.114
C. WHO REALLY RUNS THE SHOW THE
01:52:34.180 --> 01:52:34.747
COMMITTEE SECRETARY SO I JUST
01:52:34.814 --> 01:52:35.582
WANT.
01:52:35.648 --> 01:52:39.619
TO HIGHLIGHT THEM FOR THEIR WORK --
01:52:39.686 --> 01:52:42.789
THIS YEAR AND AND AND THEY'RE
01:52:42.856 --> 01:52:43.389
ALWAYS GREAT THEY'RE GREAT TO
01:52:43.456 --> 01:52:43.690
WORK WITH.
01:52:43.756 --> 01:52:44.557
SO WITH THAT WE'RE GOING TO HEAR
01:52:44.624 --> 01:52:46.493
FROM US SENATOR ROBB WE'RE GONNA
01:52:46.559 --> 01:52:48.728
GO TO FILE ITEM NUMBER.
01:52:48.795 --> 01:52:50.964
FILE ITEM NUMBER.
01:52:51.030 --> 01:52:54.200
FIVE WHICH IS SB. FIVE EIGHTY
01:52:54.267 --> 01:52:55.902
SIX YOU MAY PROCEED THANK YOU
01:52:55.969 --> 01:52:57.137
MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS OF WELL
01:52:57.203 --> 01:52:58.438
FIRST I'D LIKE TO BEGIN BY
01:52:58.505 --> 01:52:59.906
ACCEPTING THE PROPOSED AMENDMENT
01:52:59.973 --> 01:53:01.141
PRESENTED IN THE COMMITTEE
01:53:01.207 --> 01:53:03.143
ANALYSIS AND TO ECHO YOUR
01:53:03.209 --> 01:53:05.178
EARLIER COMMENTS I WANT TO THANK
01:53:05.245 --> 01:53:07.447
YOUR STAFF FOR THEIR EFFORTS TO
01:53:07.514 --> 01:53:08.948
IMPROVE THIS BILL.
01:53:09.015 --> 01:53:10.316
THE BILL IS -- RESPONSE TO
01:53:10.383 --> 01:53:11.985
CONCERNS RAISED AN INFORMATIONAL
01:53:12.051 --> 01:53:13.520
HEARING THAT -- WE HELD ON
01:53:13.586 --> 01:53:14.888
CAREER TECHNOLOGY THE NEW
01:53:14.954 --> 01:53:16.156
ECONOMY.
01:53:16.222 --> 01:53:17.957
AT THAT PARTICULAR HEARING -- I
01:53:18.024 --> 01:53:19.425
HEARD FROM A VARIETY OF
01:53:19.492 --> 01:53:20.860
STAKEHOLDERS CONCERNED OVER THE
01:53:20.927 --> 01:53:22.128
GROWING NEED FOR SKILLED LABOR
01:53:22.195 --> 01:53:23.296
TO MEET LOCAL INDUSTRY
01:53:23.363 --> 01:53:24.864
EMPLOYMENT GROWTH.
01:53:24.931 --> 01:53:26.232
THIS BILL ATTEMPTS TO SIMPLY
01:53:26.299 --> 01:53:28.168
ADDRESS THE CONCERN BY PROVIDING
01:53:28.234 --> 01:53:30.303
A FORUM FOR THE LOCAL WORKFORCE
01:53:30.370 --> 01:53:31.838
DEVELOPMENTBOARD'S. TO WORK
01:53:31.905 --> 01:53:33.339
CLOSELY WITH COMMUNITY COLLEGES
01:53:33.406 --> 01:53:34.774
IN HIGH SCHOOL DISTRICTS AS THEY
01:53:34.841 --> 01:53:36.743
DEVELOP THEIR COLLEGE AND CAREER
01:53:36.809 --> 01:53:40.113
ACCESS PATHWAYS IT'S SIMPLY.
01:53:40.180 --> 01:53:42.215
AN INFORMATIONAL FLOW BILL.
01:53:42.282 --> 01:53:44.284
THANK YOU I'M SUPPORT ANY ANY
01:53:44.350 --> 01:53:47.187
SUPPORT FOR THE BILL -- ANY
01:53:47.253 --> 01:53:49.556
OPPOSITION TO THE BILL SEEN
01:53:49.622 --> 01:53:50.190
OPPOSITION WILL BRING IT BACK TO
01:53:50.256 --> 01:53:53.426
THE COMMITTEE -- ANY ANY
01:53:53.493 --> 01:53:55.128
COMMENTS READY COMMITTEE MEMBERS.
01:53:55.195 --> 01:53:56.529
SEEN A CONSUMMATE COMMITTEE
01:53:56.596 --> 01:53:57.830
MEMBERS DO WE HAVE A MOTION.
01:53:57.897 --> 01:53:59.599
MISMAS MOVES -- SECONDED BY
01:53:59.666 --> 01:54:01.935
MISTER KALRA -- IN THE THE
01:54:02.001 --> 01:54:04.671
MOTION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED.
01:54:04.737 --> 01:54:07.473
AND YOU MAY CLOSE.
01:54:07.540 --> 01:54:08.174
LIKE THIS FOR A VOTE THANK
01:54:08.241 --> 01:54:09.742
MISTER THANK YOU SENATOR --
01:54:09.809 --> 01:54:11.377
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL THE MOTION
01:54:11.444 --> 01:54:13.413
IS TO PASS AS AMENDED TO THE
01:54:13.479 --> 01:54:15.181
ASSEMBLY FLOOR O'DONNELL HI
01:54:15.248 --> 01:54:16.916
O'DONNELL AYE KILEY.
01:54:16.983 --> 01:54:19.819
KILEY AYE DEEP.
01:54:19.886 --> 01:54:21.754
DEEP I KALRA.
01:54:21.821 --> 01:54:23.323
KALRA AYE MCCARTY.
01:54:23.389 --> 01:54:25.124
MCCARTY AYE SMITH.
01:54:25.191 --> 01:54:26.125
SMITH I WEBER [inaudible]
01:54:26.192 --> 01:54:28.528
WEBER I'D.
01:54:28.595 --> 01:54:31.197
BILL HAS SEVEN VOTES THANK YOU
01:54:31.264 --> 01:54:32.999
SENATOR THANK YOU MISTER MEMBERS.
01:54:33.066 --> 01:54:34.367
AND THEN WE'RE GONNA MOVE ON WE
01:54:34.434 --> 01:54:36.469
HAVE ONE MORE MISTER HERTZBERG.
01:54:36.536 --> 01:54:38.371
IF YOU'RE LISTENING AND YOU'RE
01:54:38.438 --> 01:54:40.873
IN HIS OFFICE BETTER GET IN HERE.
01:54:40.940 --> 01:54:41.841
WHEN WE TAKE UP THE CONSENT
01:54:41.908 --> 01:54:43.476
CALENDAR WILL WAITING FOR
01:54:43.543 --> 01:54:44.077
SENATOR HERTZBERG TO COME DOWN
01:54:44.143 --> 01:54:46.179
HERE?
01:54:46.246 --> 01:54:47.113
THE CONTENT CALEDON MOVED AND
01:54:47.180 --> 01:54:51.351
SECONDED.
01:54:51.417 --> 01:54:53.586
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
01:54:53.653 --> 01:54:56.356
FILE ITEM ONE SB ONE SEVENTY FOR
01:54:56.422 --> 01:54:57.223
THE MOTION IS TO PASS TO
01:54:57.290 --> 01:55:01.094
APPROPRIATIONS FILE ITEM FOR SB
01:55:01.160 --> 01:55:02.095
FIVE EIGHTY TWO THE MOTION IS
01:55:02.161 --> 01:55:03.663
THE PASTOR.
01:55:03.730 --> 01:55:06.032
FILE ITEM EIGHT S. J. R. EIGHT
01:55:06.099 --> 01:55:08.401
THE MOTION IS BE ADOPTED TO THE
01:55:08.468 --> 01:55:09.936
ASSEMBLY FLOOR.
01:55:10.003 --> 01:55:11.904
O'DONNELL IN THE MOVED AND
01:55:11.971 --> 01:55:13.640
SECONDED PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
01:55:13.706 --> 01:55:15.341
O'DONNELL AYE O'DONNELL AYE
01:55:15.408 --> 01:55:16.009
KILEY.
01:55:16.075 --> 01:55:17.777
KILEY I'D DEEP.
01:55:17.844 --> 01:55:20.013
DEEP I KALRA.
01:55:20.079 --> 01:55:21.581
KALRA I'D MCCARTY.
01:55:21.648 --> 01:55:24.250
MCCARTY EYES SMITH SMITH I WEBER
01:55:24.317 --> 01:55:24.550
[inaudible]
01:55:24.617 --> 01:55:29.055
WEBER I THE BILL HAS SEVEN VOTES
01:55:29.122 --> 01:55:29.922
ARE THAT THE CONSENT CALENDAR
01:55:29.989 --> 01:55:30.690
HAS A MOTIVE IS OUT.
01:55:30.757 --> 01:55:32.258
WE'RE STILL WAITING FOR SENATOR
01:55:32.325 --> 01:55:32.925
HERTZBERG.
01:55:32.992 --> 01:55:36.596
HE'S ON HIS WAY.
01:55:36.663 --> 01:55:37.196
HOW MUCH TIME SHOULD BE GIVEN
01:55:37.263 --> 01:55:40.099
COMMITTEE?
01:55:40.166 --> 01:55:41.868
WHAT ABOUT SECONDS?
01:55:41.934 --> 01:55:50.476
HOW MY ALONG [inaudible]
01:55:50.543 --> 01:55:55.515
CALLS.
01:55:55.581 --> 01:55:56.849
GOOD JOB WHAT WE LIVE THE CALL
01:55:56.916 --> 01:56:00.453
MAKING.
01:56:00.520 --> 01:56:01.487
PLEASE CUT PLEASE OF KOREA.
01:56:01.554 --> 01:56:03.756
FILE ITEM TO SB.
01:56:03.823 --> 01:56:04.357
THREE TWENTY EIGHT THE MOTION
01:56:04.424 --> 01:56:04.957
WAS TO PASS TO APPROPRIATIONS
01:56:05.024 --> 01:56:07.560
WITH THE CHAIR VOTING NO DEEP.
01:56:07.627 --> 01:56:07.827
MCCARTY.
01:56:07.894 --> 01:56:28.314
MCCARTY I BILLS FOR VOTED IS OUT
01:56:51.938 --> 01:56:52.171
[inaudible]
01:56:52.238 --> 01:57:07.086
VETERANS.
01:57:07.153 --> 01:57:07.687
YEP BUT WILL MOVE TO ADD ON'S
01:57:07.754 --> 01:57:12.158
NOW.
01:57:12.225 --> 01:57:15.061
FILE ITEM SIX SB SIX NINETY FIVE
01:57:15.128 --> 01:57:15.862
THE MOTION IS THE PASTOR
01:57:15.928 --> 01:57:17.530
APPROPRIATIONS WITH THE CHAIR
01:57:17.597 --> 01:57:18.264
VOTING I'D [inaudible]
01:57:18.331 --> 01:57:23.302
DEEP.
01:57:23.369 --> 01:57:24.203
DEEP NO.
01:57:24.270 --> 01:57:25.071
MCCARTY [inaudible]
01:57:25.138 --> 01:57:30.309
MCCARTY I THE BILL HAS FIVE
01:57:30.376 --> 01:57:33.446
PHONES IT IS OUT.
01:57:33.513 --> 01:57:34.380
THE LAST DAM.
01:57:34.447 --> 01:57:37.083
YEAH IT IT IT DOES -- MISTER
01:57:37.150 --> 01:57:42.989
DEEPENED AND WELCOME TO THE
01:57:43.055 --> 01:57:45.324
EDUCATION COMMITTEE MISTER DAVE.
01:57:45.391 --> 01:57:52.732
WHAT DID YOU DO TO GET HERE?
01:57:52.799 --> 01:57:58.471
DON'T SAY OR DON'T SAY SORRY.
01:57:58.538 --> 01:58:00.039
OKAY WITH THAT WILL MOVE TO FILE
01:58:00.106 --> 01:58:03.876
ITEM NUMBER.
01:58:03.943 --> 01:58:06.212
FILE ITEM SEVEN IS SB. SEVEN
01:58:06.279 --> 01:58:06.846
FORTY THREE MISTER HEARD CENTER
01:58:06.913 --> 01:58:07.780
HERTZBERG YOU MAY.
01:58:07.847 --> 01:58:09.048
PROCEED WHEN READY.
01:58:09.115 --> 01:58:10.883
THANK YOU SHERMAN I AM -- HERE
01:58:10.950 --> 01:58:12.251
TODAY IT HAS TAKEN THE TIME TO
01:58:12.318 --> 01:58:14.020
INTRODUCE THIS MEASURE. TO
01:58:14.086 --> 01:58:15.421
CORRECTIVE ANOMALY.
01:58:15.488 --> 01:58:17.056
IN THE DESIGN BUILD METHOD AS IT
01:58:17.123 --> 01:58:18.891
RELATES TO THE CONSTRUCTION OF
01:58:18.958 --> 01:58:19.926
SCHOOLS.
01:58:19.992 --> 01:58:21.794
THERE'S BEEN SOME CONFUSION IN
01:58:21.861 --> 01:58:24.030
CASE OF TOWARD A ABOUT WHETHER
01:58:24.096 --> 01:58:25.665
WHEN YOU HAVE A DESIGN BUILD
01:58:25.731 --> 01:58:26.799
CONTRACT.
01:58:26.866 --> 01:58:30.069
AND THE END SEQUEL UC BOTH ON
01:58:30.136 --> 01:58:31.637
TWO SEPARATE PASS WITH THE
01:58:31.704 --> 01:58:33.139
CONFLICT WITH EACH OTHER.
01:58:33.206 --> 01:58:34.707
AND SO IF SO IF IF THE SCHOOL
01:58:34.774 --> 01:58:36.843
BOARD APPROVES THE DESIGN BUILD
01:58:36.909 --> 01:58:37.743
PROCESS.
01:58:37.810 --> 01:58:39.879
IS THAT CONSIDERED APPROVAL OR
01:58:39.946 --> 01:58:40.379
NOT.
01:58:40.446 --> 01:58:42.915
SO WE'RE TRYING TO DO IS TO
01:58:42.982 --> 01:58:43.816
CLARIFY.
01:58:43.883 --> 01:58:44.984
AS WE DEAL WITH ALL THESE GREAT
01:58:45.051 --> 01:58:46.752
ISSUES OF WILD FIRES AND CHARTER
01:58:46.819 --> 01:58:48.588
SCHOOLS AND ALL THE GREAT ISSUES
01:58:48.654 --> 01:58:49.589
OF THE DAY.
01:58:49.655 --> 01:58:51.357
OFTEN THE MECHANICS OF
01:58:51.424 --> 01:58:53.426
GOVERNMENT ARE INFORMED BY
01:58:53.493 --> 01:58:54.894
THINGS IT APPEARS SMALL.
01:58:54.961 --> 01:58:56.829
BUT IMPACT IN A SIGNIFICANT WAY
01:58:56.896 --> 01:58:58.397
THE OPERATION OF GOVERNMENT THIS
01:58:58.464 --> 01:58:59.765
IS ONE OF THOSE LITTLE THINGS
01:58:59.832 --> 01:59:01.400
THAT WE'RE DOING. TO CORRECT
01:59:01.467 --> 01:59:03.870
THAT -- WITH THE BUILDING TRADES
01:59:03.936 --> 01:59:05.304
AS PART OF THIS JUST TO MAKE
01:59:05.371 --> 01:59:06.472
SURE THAT THE AWARDING OF A
01:59:06.539 --> 01:59:07.840
CONTRACT.
01:59:07.907 --> 01:59:09.575
APPROVING DESIGN BUILD IT --
01:59:09.642 --> 01:59:12.345
PROJECT -- IF FOR TWO PURPOSES
01:59:12.411 --> 01:59:14.413
DOES NOT WORK CAN CONTRADICTION
01:59:14.480 --> 01:59:16.315
WITH WITH C. CUT.
01:59:16.382 --> 01:59:18.518
AND WITH THIS.
01:59:18.584 --> 01:59:20.286
I HAVE MY WITNESS TALK AND
01:59:20.353 --> 01:59:21.354
FURTHER EXPLAINED.
01:59:21.420 --> 01:59:23.089
THE PROBLEM WITH HERSELF.
01:59:23.155 --> 01:59:24.657
THANK YOU TERRY MEMBERS -- MY
01:59:24.724 --> 01:59:25.691
NAME IS OLGA SHILOH WITH LOS
01:59:25.758 --> 01:59:27.860
ANGELES UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT --
01:59:27.927 --> 01:59:29.228
WE ARE PLEASED TO BE THE SPONSOR
01:59:29.295 --> 01:59:31.264
OF SB SEVEN FORTY THREE WHICH
01:59:31.330 --> 01:59:33.032
CLARIFIES THAT DESIGN BUILD
01:59:33.099 --> 01:59:34.333
PROJECT DELIVERY METHOD.
01:59:34.400 --> 01:59:35.601
DESIGNED BILL PROJECT DELIVERY
01:59:35.668 --> 01:59:36.869
METHOD PROVIDES MANY
01:59:36.936 --> 01:59:37.837
EFFICIENCIES TO SCHOOL
01:59:37.904 --> 01:59:39.205
CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS INCLUDING
01:59:39.272 --> 01:59:41.507
COST EFFECTIVE USE OF FUNDS AND
01:59:41.574 --> 01:59:43.209
EX BUT I TO PROJECT COMPLETION.
01:59:43.276 --> 01:59:44.343
SINCE DESIGN BILLS TOUCHES WERE
01:59:44.410 --> 01:59:46.679
ORIGINALLY MADE OPERATIVE IN TWO
01:59:46.746 --> 01:59:48.114
THOUSAND AND TWO LA UNIFIED HAS
01:59:48.180 --> 01:59:49.515
AWARDED TWENTY THREE CONTRACTS
01:59:49.582 --> 01:59:51.417
OF A CUMULATIVE TOTAL OF NEARLY
01:59:51.484 --> 01:59:52.885
ONE BILLION DOLLARS.
01:59:52.952 --> 01:59:54.353
CURRENTLY WE ARE WORKING ON A
01:59:54.420 --> 01:59:55.755
DESIGN BUILD CONTRACTS TO BE
01:59:55.821 --> 01:59:58.024
AWARDED TOTALING OVER EIGHT
01:59:58.090 --> 01:59:59.458
HUNDRED MILLION DOLLARS.
01:59:59.525 --> 02:00:00.760
LA UNIFIED PURSUIT DESIGN BUILD
02:00:00.826 --> 02:00:02.328
PROJECTS WHEN A DETERMINATION IS
02:00:02.395 --> 02:00:04.196
MADE THAT THE CONTRACT
02:00:04.263 --> 02:00:05.565
CONTRACTING METHOD WILL REDUCE.
02:00:05.631 --> 02:00:07.667
PROJECT COST EXPEDITED PROJECT
02:00:07.733 --> 02:00:09.735
SCHEDULE INTO PROVIDE FEATURES
02:00:09.802 --> 02:00:10.970
NOT ACHIEVABLE THROUGH THE
02:00:11.037 --> 02:00:13.205
TRADITIONAL DESIGN BED BUILD --
02:00:13.272 --> 02:00:14.173
CONTRACTING METHODS.
02:00:14.240 --> 02:00:15.308
WE HAVE FOUND THAT A PROJECT
02:00:15.374 --> 02:00:17.376
SCHEDULED IS REDUCED BY FORTY
02:00:17.443 --> 02:00:18.945
SIX MONTHS ON AVERAGE.
02:00:19.011 --> 02:00:20.746
THE X. BUT I'D NATURE OF DESIGN
02:00:20.813 --> 02:00:22.949
BUILD WHILE TIMELY AND COST
02:00:23.015 --> 02:00:24.350
EFFECTIVE SOMETIMES RYAN RUNS
02:00:24.417 --> 02:00:26.252
INTO TIMING ISSUES WHEN IT COMES
02:00:26.319 --> 02:00:28.120
TO THE CALIFORNIA ENVIRONMENTAL
02:00:28.187 --> 02:00:29.655
QUALITY ACT REVIEW.
02:00:29.722 --> 02:00:31.457
IN ORDER TO EVALUATE EVALUATE
02:00:31.524 --> 02:00:33.059
WHETHER PROPOSED PROJECT IS IN
02:00:33.125 --> 02:00:34.193
COMPLIANCE WITH THE C<c.cyan> IT IS</c>
02:00:34.260 --> 02:00:35.261
NECESSARY TO HAVE CERTAIN
02:00:35.328 --> 02:00:36.896
INFORMATION KNOWN.
02:00:36.963 --> 02:00:38.664
ABOUT IT IN THAT CAN ONLY BE
02:00:38.731 --> 02:00:39.832
REVEALED THROUGH THE DESIGN
02:00:39.899 --> 02:00:41.400
DEVELOPMENT STAGE THIS OCCURS
02:00:41.467 --> 02:00:47.506
AFTER A CONTRACT IS AWARDED.
02:00:47.573 --> 02:00:48.541
DUE TO DEATH OFTENTIMES BOARDS
02:00:48.608 --> 02:00:49.108
OF EDUCATION APPROVED THESE
02:00:49.175 --> 02:00:50.009
CONTRACTS BEFORE THE
02:00:50.076 --> 02:00:50.977
ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW IS COMPLETE.
02:00:51.043 --> 02:00:51.811
RECENTLY THE STATE DISTRICT
02:00:51.877 --> 02:00:53.512
AWARDED A DESIGN BUILD CONTRACT
02:00:53.579 --> 02:00:54.480
TO MODERNIZE WAS ABOUT HIGH
02:00:54.547 --> 02:00:56.449
SCHOOL WHICH WAS ARGUED BY SOME
02:00:56.515 --> 02:00:57.416
THAT THE ACTION MEANT THE LA
02:00:57.483 --> 02:00:59.285
UNIFIED HAD ALREADY APPROVED IN
02:00:59.352 --> 02:01:00.720
THE PROJECT.
02:01:00.786 --> 02:01:01.687
AND COMMITTED ITSELF TO AN
02:01:01.754 --> 02:01:02.922
IRREVERSIBLE INDEFINITE COURSE
02:01:02.989 --> 02:01:04.423
OF ACTION WITHOUT CONDUCTING
02:01:04.490 --> 02:01:06.225
APPROPRIATE ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW
02:01:06.292 --> 02:01:08.594
UNDER SEEK WHAT SB SEVEN FORTY
02:01:08.661 --> 02:01:09.762
THREE WHILE PROTECTING TO SEE
02:01:09.829 --> 02:01:12.064
WHAT PROCESS CLARIFIES.
02:01:12.131 --> 02:01:17.670
THE LA UNIFIED RETAINS THE RIGHT
02:01:17.737 --> 02:01:18.237
TO TERMINATE A DESIGN BUILD
02:01:18.304 --> 02:01:18.638
CONTRACT.
02:01:18.704 --> 02:01:19.605
BEFORE THE PROJECT IS SUBMITTED
02:01:19.672 --> 02:01:20.272
TO THE DIVISION OF STATE
02:01:20.339 --> 02:01:21.774
ARCHITECT MODIFIED THE DESIGN
02:01:21.841 --> 02:01:23.309
AND IN CORPORATE MITIGATION
02:01:23.376 --> 02:01:24.644
MEASURES IDENTIFIED IN THE
02:01:24.710 --> 02:01:26.612
ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW DOCUMENT
02:01:26.679 --> 02:01:27.546
FOR THE PROJECT.
02:01:27.613 --> 02:01:30.016
SB SEVEN FORTY THREE HARMONIZES
02:01:30.082 --> 02:01:32.184
THE ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW PROCESS
02:01:32.251 --> 02:01:33.152
WITH THE RECOGNIZE ECONOMIC
02:01:33.219 --> 02:01:35.688
BENEFITS A FORTY TWO LA UNIFIED --
02:01:35.755 --> 02:01:36.989
FOR THESE REASONS WE ARE PROUD
02:01:37.056 --> 02:01:40.459
TO SPONSOR SB SEVEN FORTY THREE
02:01:40.526 --> 02:01:41.060
AND RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR
02:01:41.127 --> 02:01:41.627
IPHONE.
02:01:41.694 --> 02:01:42.395
THANK YOU OTHERS IN SUPPORT OF
02:01:42.461 --> 02:01:44.363
THE BILL THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR
02:01:44.430 --> 02:01:44.964
AND MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE
02:01:45.031 --> 02:01:46.065
JEREMY SMITH HERE BEHALF OF THE
02:01:46.132 --> 02:01:47.333
STATE BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION
02:01:47.400 --> 02:01:49.301
TRADES COUNCIL ALSO SUPPORT
02:01:49.368 --> 02:01:49.568
THANK YOU.
02:01:49.635 --> 02:01:50.870
THANK YOU.
02:01:50.936 --> 02:01:53.606
ARE ANY OPPOSITION TO THE BILL.
02:01:53.673 --> 02:01:55.274
SEEING NO OPPOSITION ANY
02:01:55.341 --> 02:01:55.841
COMMENTS FROM THE COMMITTEE
02:01:55.908 --> 02:01:57.276
MEMBERS.
02:01:57.343 --> 02:01:59.045
THE MOVE I MISS SMITH BY SEX
02:01:59.111 --> 02:02:02.715
SECOND I WAS MCCARTY -- YOU MAY
02:02:02.782 --> 02:02:04.784
CLOSE THAT THE MOTION IS
02:02:04.850 --> 02:02:05.084
[inaudible]
02:02:05.151 --> 02:02:09.889
DO PASS -- YOU MAKE CLOSE.
02:02:09.955 --> 02:02:11.057
THAT'S RESPECTFULLY AS FROM
02:02:11.123 --> 02:02:11.657
ABOUT THANKS SO MUCH THANK YOU
02:02:11.724 --> 02:02:12.258
AND WHAT WE'RE ALL HERE AND
02:02:12.324 --> 02:02:13.492
WE'RE ALL LISTENING I HAVE TO
02:02:13.559 --> 02:02:14.694
TAKE ONE MOMENT HERE AND THANK
02:02:14.760 --> 02:02:16.495
MISTER BECKER AS WELL I THINK
02:02:16.562 --> 02:02:17.830
EVERYBODY BUT YOU.
02:02:17.897 --> 02:02:20.366
QUE AND YOU'RE THE NICEST GUY
02:02:20.433 --> 02:02:22.168
HERE.
02:02:22.234 --> 02:02:22.702
GEN.
02:02:22.768 --> 02:02:24.336
YOUR POSITIONS ARE OFTEN CRAZY
02:02:24.403 --> 02:02:27.239
BUT OU KNOW A VERY NICE GUY SO --
02:02:27.306 --> 02:02:28.641
THANK YOU FOR BEING YOU.
02:02:28.708 --> 02:02:30.109
<c.red>N DOING WHAT YOU DO WE NEED A</c>
02:02:30.176 --> 02:02:32.111
LOYAL OPPOSITION THERE'S TOO
02:02:32.178 --> 02:02:34.080
MANY ALL ASPECTS THAT ARE AT
02:02:34.146 --> 02:02:35.014
LEAST MOST OF IT.
02:02:35.081 --> 02:02:37.349
AND THANK GOD BOB FOR HIS.
02:02:37.416 --> 02:02:40.586
INVALUABLE GUIDANCE AS WELL AS
02:02:40.653 --> 02:02:41.587
HARD WORK THROUGHOUT THE YEAR.
02:02:41.654 --> 02:02:43.389
THANK YOU MISTER KILEY UP PLEASE
02:02:43.456 --> 02:02:44.757
CALL THE ROLL.
02:02:44.824 --> 02:02:46.392
THE MOTION IS TO PASS TO THE
02:02:46.459 --> 02:02:48.894
ASSEMBLY FLOOR O'DONNELL.
02:02:48.961 --> 02:02:51.063
HI O'DONNELL AYE KILEY.
02:02:51.130 --> 02:02:52.598
KILEY AYE DEEP.
02:02:52.665 --> 02:02:55.668
DEEP I'D KALRA.
02:02:55.735 --> 02:02:57.703
KALRA AYE MCCARTY.
02:02:57.770 --> 02:03:00.239
THE EYES SMITH SMITH I WEBER
02:03:00.306 --> 02:03:00.539
[inaudible]
02:03:00.606 --> 02:03:03.576
WEBER I'D.
02:03:03.642 --> 02:03:04.777
THE BILL HAS SEVEN ROADS IT IS
02:03:04.844 --> 02:03:06.378
OUT THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN
02:03:06.445 --> 02:03:07.012
THANK YOU MEMBERS PUSH IT MUCH.
02:03:07.079 --> 02:03:10.316
THANK YOU.
02:03:10.382 --> 02:03:11.517
SO WHAT WE CAN ADJOURNMENT.
02:03:11.584 --> 02:03:12.885
WITH THAT.
02:03:12.952 --> 02:03:20.292
THIS MEETING IS ADJOURNED.
02:03:20.359 --> 02:03:23.763
THE MONEY FACTOR [inaudible]
02:03:23.829 --> 02:03:38.844
OKAY --