WEBVTT
00:23:38.383 --> 00:23:41.720
MORNING WELCOME TO THE ASSEMBLY
00:23:41.787 --> 00:23:43.822
PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION
00:23:43.889 --> 00:23:46.191
COMMITTEE HEARING TODAY. IT IS
00:23:46.258 --> 00:23:48.460
MAY FIFTH TWENTY TWENTY. TO
00:23:48.527 --> 00:23:50.295
START I LIKE TO THANK ALL THE
00:23:50.362 --> 00:23:52.998
STOP THAT HAVE MADE OUR RETURN
00:23:53.064 --> 00:23:53.965
TO THE CAPITAL TO HEAR THE
00:23:54.032 --> 00:23:56.434
BILL'S POSSIBLE THIS INCLUDES
00:23:56.501 --> 00:23:58.637
STAFF FROM THE ASSEMBLY RULES
00:23:58.703 --> 00:24:00.138
THE ASSEMBLY SERGEANTS AND THE
00:24:00.205 --> 00:24:01.973
LEGISLATIVE DATACENTER WHO PUT
00:24:02.040 --> 00:24:04.309
IN COUNTLESS HOURS PROCURING
00:24:04.376 --> 00:24:05.911
AND CONFIGURING THE NEW
00:24:05.977 --> 00:24:07.746
EQUIPMENT AND TECHNOLOGY. WERE
00:24:07.813 --> 00:24:09.147
ABLE TO USE TO MAXIMIZE
00:24:09.214 --> 00:24:11.516
OPPORTUNITIES FOR PARTICIPATION
00:24:11.583 --> 00:24:13.585
AND I'LL HEARINGS. TO THAT END
00:24:13.652 --> 00:24:15.353
I WILL NOW SURE A FEW NOTES
00:24:15.420 --> 00:24:16.988
ABOUT THE LOGISTICS OF OUR
00:24:17.055 --> 00:24:19.324
HEARING TODAY. REGARDING PUBLIC
00:24:19.391 --> 00:24:21.860
PARTICIPATION TO HELP PRESERVE
00:24:21.927 --> 00:24:23.862
THE SAFETY OF EVERYONE HERE.
00:24:23.929 --> 00:24:25.330
AND ENSURE THE PUBLIC'S ACCESS
00:24:25.397 --> 00:24:28.600
TO THE DISCUSSION. DUE TO THE
00:24:28.667 --> 00:24:30.669
CURRENT STATE HOLE ORDER WE ARE
00:24:30.735 --> 00:24:33.004
PRACTICING PHYSICAL DISTANCING
00:24:33.071 --> 00:24:34.439
HERE IN THE HEARING ROOM AND
00:24:34.506 --> 00:24:36.374
THROUGHOUT THE CAPITOL BUILDING
00:24:36.441 --> 00:24:38.710
SO WE ARE ONLY ABLE TO HAVE A
00:24:38.777 --> 00:24:40.512
LIMITED NUMBER OF PEOPLE WATCH
00:24:40.579 --> 00:24:42.247
AND PARTICIPATE IN THE HEARING
00:24:42.314 --> 00:24:45.116
IN PERSON. THAT BEING SAID WE
00:24:45.183 --> 00:24:46.685
WILL ABIDE BY TYPICAL COMMITTEE
00:24:46.751 --> 00:24:48.987
PROCEDURES. AND HAVE TWO
00:24:49.054 --> 00:24:50.856
PRIMARY WITNESSES IN SUPPORT
00:24:50.922 --> 00:24:53.225
AND TO IN OPPOSITION TESTIFYING
00:24:53.291 --> 00:24:55.927
FOR TWO MINUTES EACH. WE HAVE A
00:24:55.994 --> 00:24:57.896
FEW DIFFERENT OPTIONS FOR
00:24:57.963 --> 00:25:00.332
WITNESS TESTIMONY TODAY. FOR
00:25:00.398 --> 00:25:02.367
THE PUBLIC IN THE ROOM TODAY EN
00:25:02.434 --> 00:25:05.036
ROUTE FORTY TWO OH TWO WE ARE
00:25:05.103 --> 00:25:06.605
HAVING A PHYSICALLY DISTANT IN
00:25:06.671 --> 00:25:09.374
PERSON HEARING. IN THIS SPACE
00:25:09.441 --> 00:25:11.643
WE CAN ONLY ACCOMMODATE ELEVEN
00:25:11.710 --> 00:25:14.012
MEMBERS. A MINIMAL CONTINGENT
00:25:14.079 --> 00:25:16.147
OF STAFF AND A LIMITED NUMBER
00:25:16.214 --> 00:25:18.016
OF PUBLIC AND MEDIA SO WE CAN
00:25:18.083 --> 00:25:22.153
MAINTAIN SIX FEET OF SPACING.
00:25:22.220 --> 00:25:23.521
THEY'RE ALSO STRICT PHYSICAL
00:25:23.588 --> 00:25:25.090
DISTANCING PROTOCOLS FOR THE
00:25:25.156 --> 00:25:26.691
PUBLIC TO ENTER AND LEAVE THE
00:25:26.758 --> 00:25:29.227
CAPITAL EVER THOSE HERE TODAY
00:25:29.294 --> 00:25:30.362
TO MAKE PUBLIC COMMENT AT THE
00:25:30.428 --> 00:25:32.731
APPROPRIATE TIME. IF ANY MEMBER
00:25:32.797 --> 00:25:34.532
OF THE PUBLIC AND THE ROOM
00:25:34.599 --> 00:25:36.234
WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY ON A BILL
00:25:36.301 --> 00:25:37.702
PLEASE RAISE YOUR HAND AND I
00:25:37.769 --> 00:25:39.070
WILL ASK YOU TO APPROACH THE
00:25:39.137 --> 00:25:42.207
MICROPHONE. I WOULD ASK THAT
00:25:42.274 --> 00:25:42.707
THE PUBLIC NOT TOUCH THE
00:25:42.774 --> 00:25:45.443
MICROPHONE. YOU CAN EXIT THE
00:25:45.510 --> 00:25:47.312
HEARING ROOM ONCE YOU ARE DONE
00:25:47.379 --> 00:25:47.913
TESTIFYING WILL RETURN TO YOUR
00:25:47.979 --> 00:25:50.515
SEAT. PLEASE BE SURE TO OBSERVE
00:25:50.582 --> 00:25:52.284
PHYSICAL DISTANCING UPON
00:25:52.350 --> 00:25:54.152
LEAVING THE CAPITOL INCLUDING
00:25:54.219 --> 00:25:56.655
LIMITING ELEVATOR USED TO ONE
00:25:56.721 --> 00:25:59.457
PERSON AT A TIME. NOW FOR DIAL
00:25:59.524 --> 00:26:02.427
IN WITNESSES WE WILL ALSO BE
00:26:02.494 --> 00:26:03.929
USING A MODERATED TELEPHONE
00:26:03.995 --> 00:26:06.131
SERVICE THROUGH WHICH ANY
00:26:06.197 --> 00:26:08.934
WITNESS CAN TESTIFY ON A BILL.
00:26:09.000 --> 00:26:09.501
THE CALL IN NUMBER FOR THIS
00:26:09.567 --> 00:26:17.075
HEARING IS. EIGHT SEVEN SEVEN
00:26:17.142 --> 00:26:17.642
SIX NINE TWO EIGHT NINE FIVE
00:26:17.709 --> 00:26:22.180
SEVEN AND THE ACCESS CODE IS.
00:26:22.247 --> 00:26:22.781
ONE THREE ONE FIVE FOUR TWO OH
00:26:22.847 --> 00:26:24.249
TWO. YOU CAN ALSO FIND THIS
00:26:24.316 --> 00:26:25.750
NUMBER ON THE ASSEMBLY PRIVACY
00:26:25.817 --> 00:26:28.286
COMMITTEE WEBSITE AS WELL AS ON
00:26:28.353 --> 00:26:30.588
YOUR TV SCREEN. IF YOU'RE
00:26:30.655 --> 00:26:32.424
CALLING END PLEASE PLAN TO DO
00:26:32.490 --> 00:26:34.326
SO AS THE AUTHOR OF THE BILL
00:26:34.392 --> 00:26:36.227
YOUR TESTIFYING ON IS
00:26:36.294 --> 00:26:38.063
BEGINNING. HIS OR HER BILL
00:26:38.129 --> 00:26:40.732
PRESENTATION. THE OPERATOR ON
00:26:40.799 --> 00:26:41.566
THE LINE WILL GIVE YOU
00:26:41.633 --> 00:26:43.168
INSTRUCTIONS ON HOW TO BE
00:26:43.234 --> 00:26:45.503
PLACED IN THE QUEUE BASED ON
00:26:45.570 --> 00:26:46.905
WHETHER YOU SUPPORT OR OPPOSE A
00:26:46.972 --> 00:26:49.107
BILL. IF YOU'RE CALLING AND
00:26:49.174 --> 00:26:50.875
PLEASE ELIMINATE ALL BACKGROUND
00:26:50.942 --> 00:26:52.944
NOISE. THIS INCLUDES MEETING
00:26:53.011 --> 00:26:54.512
YOUR LIVESTREAM BROADCAST IN
00:26:54.579 --> 00:26:56.581
YOUR SMART DEVICES TO REDUCE TO
00:26:56.648 --> 00:26:58.950
SOUND DISTORTION. YOU CAN ALSO
00:26:59.017 --> 00:27:04.789
CALL THE COMMITTEE AT. NINE ONE
00:27:04.856 --> 00:27:05.423
SIX THREE ONE NINE TWO TWO ZERO
00:27:05.490 --> 00:27:05.957
ZERO IF YOU'RE HAVING ANY
00:27:06.024 --> 00:27:06.858
PROBLEMS WITH THE MODERATED
00:27:06.925 --> 00:27:09.461
PHONE SERVICE. AND MY STAFF
00:27:09.527 --> 00:27:10.228
WILL BE THERE TO TRY TO HELP
00:27:10.295 --> 00:27:13.198
OUT. I ALSO WANT TO NOTE THAT
00:27:13.264 --> 00:27:13.898
WE ARE ACCEPTING WRITTEN
00:27:13.965 --> 00:27:15.900
TESTIMONIES. THROUGH THE
00:27:15.967 --> 00:27:18.370
POSITION LETTER PORTAL ON THE
00:27:18.436 --> 00:27:20.972
COMMITTEE'S WEBSITE. THANK YOU
00:27:21.039 --> 00:27:22.140
FOR BEARING WITH US AS WE
00:27:22.207 --> 00:27:23.208
IMPLEMENT NOT THAT'S TO
00:27:23.274 --> 00:27:24.709
CONTINUE TO SERVE THE PEOPLE OF
00:27:24.776 --> 00:27:27.345
CALIFORNIA. WHILE ALSO BEING
00:27:27.412 --> 00:27:29.280
MINDFUL THERE'S RESPECTFUL OF
00:27:29.347 --> 00:27:31.449
THE PUBLIC'S HEALTH CONCERNS AT
00:27:31.516 --> 00:27:36.988
WE ALL FACE. AT THIS TIME LET'S
00:27:37.055 --> 00:27:39.391
ESTABLISH QUORUM BEFORE WE ARE
00:27:39.457 --> 00:27:42.227
GONE SO MADAM SECRETARY WOULD
00:27:42.293 --> 00:27:44.295
YOU PLEASE CALL THE ROLL FOR ME.
00:27:44.362 --> 00:27:54.239
HERE. YOUR DEAR YEAH YEAH
00:27:54.305 --> 00:28:02.313
LAWLER. GALLAGHER. YEAH RIGHT%
00:28:02.380 --> 00:28:07.318
YEAH WE ARE QUORUM. NOW TURNING
00:28:07.385 --> 00:28:09.120
TO THE BILLS BEFORE US TODAY IN
00:28:09.187 --> 00:28:10.522
RESPONSE TO THE CONSTRAINTS
00:28:10.588 --> 00:28:12.123
CIRCLE THAT NINETEENTH CRISIS
00:28:12.190 --> 00:28:13.224
IS PLACED ON THE LEGISLATIVE
00:28:13.291 --> 00:28:15.527
PROCESS THE COMMITTEE ELECTED
00:28:15.593 --> 00:28:17.062
TO FOCUS ATTENTION DISCUSSION
00:28:17.128 --> 00:28:18.763
ON BILLS THAT ADDRESS ONLY THE
00:28:18.830 --> 00:28:20.632
MOST URGENT ISSUES AND ISSUES
00:28:20.698 --> 00:28:22.300
THAT ARE CRITICAL FOR AN
00:28:22.367 --> 00:28:24.369
EFFICIENT RECOVERY. LIMITING
00:28:24.436 --> 00:28:26.004
THE AMOUNT OF BILLS THAT WILL
00:28:26.071 --> 00:28:27.072
BE HEARD WAS A DIFFICULT
00:28:27.138 --> 00:28:29.140
DECISION AND ONE THAT I DO NOT
00:28:29.207 --> 00:28:31.042
TAKE LIGHTLY. MY COLLEAGUES
00:28:31.109 --> 00:28:32.444
HAVE PROPOSED MEANINGFUL
00:28:32.510 --> 00:28:34.813
LEGISLATION ADDRESSING DIVERSE
00:28:34.879 --> 00:28:35.847
ISSUES WITHIN THE PRIVACY
00:28:35.914 --> 00:28:37.982
SPACE. MANY OF WHICH I BELIEVE
00:28:38.049 --> 00:28:39.851
WILL ULTIMATELY BE IN THE LONG
00:28:39.918 --> 00:28:41.219
TERM BEST INTEREST OF OUR
00:28:41.286 --> 00:28:42.754
CONSTITUENTS. BUT I ALSO
00:28:42.821 --> 00:28:44.556
BELIEVE THAT AS LEGISLATORS WE
00:28:44.622 --> 00:28:47.025
HOW IS SERIOUS AND SOBER. UP
00:28:47.092 --> 00:28:48.593
DUTY TO PROTECT THE HEALTH
00:28:48.660 --> 00:28:50.128
SAFETY AND PRIVACY INTEREST OF
00:28:50.195 --> 00:28:51.663
OUR CONSTITUENTS ARE MOST AT
00:28:51.729 --> 00:28:55.166
RISK TODAY. IN TWENTY TWENTY.
00:28:55.233 --> 00:28:56.634
THE CRISIS BEFORE US HAS THE
00:28:56.701 --> 00:28:58.870
POTENTIAL TO CHANGE THE PRIVACY
00:28:58.937 --> 00:29:00.905
LANDSCAPE FOR DECADES TO COME.
00:29:00.972 --> 00:29:02.774
AND I'LL RESPONSE WAS SERVE AS
00:29:02.841 --> 00:29:05.110
PRESIDENT FOR LEGISLATORS LAW
00:29:05.176 --> 00:29:06.511
AFTER WE HAVE LEFT THIS
00:29:06.578 --> 00:29:10.682
BUILDING. SIMPLY PUT IT IS
00:29:10.748 --> 00:29:12.650
IMPORTANT WE GET THIS RIGHT TO
00:29:12.717 --> 00:29:14.452
THAT END I ASKED MY COLLEAGUES
00:29:14.519 --> 00:29:15.553
WOULD BILLS IN A PRIVACY
00:29:15.620 --> 00:29:18.123
COMMITTEE TO SUBMIT STATEMENT.
00:29:18.189 --> 00:29:19.924
OF CRITICALITY ARGUING WHY
00:29:19.991 --> 00:29:21.426
THEIR BILLS SHOULD MOVE FORWARD
00:29:21.493 --> 00:29:23.027
THIS YEAR IN LIGHT OF THE COLD
00:29:23.094 --> 00:29:24.762
AT NINETEEN CRISIS. I'M
00:29:24.829 --> 00:29:26.464
GRATEFUL TO MY FELLOW MEMBERS
00:29:26.531 --> 00:29:28.566
WHO ROSE TO THE OCCASION AND-
00:29:28.633 --> 00:29:29.901
LIKE TRUE LEADERS TABLE A
00:29:29.968 --> 00:29:31.369
NUMBER OF YOUR BILLS LEAVING
00:29:31.436 --> 00:29:33.271
ONLY THEMOST URGENT MATTERS
00:29:33.338 --> 00:29:34.873
BEFORE THE COMMITTEE TODAY. AS
00:29:34.939 --> 00:29:36.674
WE STRIVE TO PROVE PREVENT
00:29:36.741 --> 00:29:38.810
TREAT AND CONTROL COVERT
00:29:38.877 --> 00:29:39.844
NINETEEN WE MUST ALSO STRIKE A
00:29:39.911 --> 00:29:42.714
BALANCE BETWEEN. PROTECTING
00:29:42.780 --> 00:29:43.348
PRIVACY IN PROMOTING THE PUBLIC
00:29:43.414 --> 00:29:46.151
HEALTH. AS SUCH I STAND READY
00:29:46.217 --> 00:29:48.686
ALONG WITH MY COLLEAGUES TO
00:29:48.753 --> 00:29:51.089
CLOSELY ANALYZE BOTH. EMERGING
00:29:51.156 --> 00:29:52.957
TO OUR LEGISLATION AND PRIVATE
00:29:53.024 --> 00:29:54.359
AND GOVERNMENT PRACTICES TO
00:29:54.425 --> 00:29:56.895
ENSURE THAT CIVIC. LIBERTY LIT
00:29:56.961 --> 00:29:58.396
CIVIL LIBERTIES ARE NOT
00:29:58.463 --> 00:29:59.931
COMPROMISED AND ALL FIGHT TO
00:29:59.998 --> 00:30:02.267
CONTROL THE PANDEMIC. I FEEL A
00:30:02.333 --> 00:30:04.002
DUTY TO FOSTER AN ENVIRONMENT
00:30:04.068 --> 00:30:04.769
TO ENSURE THAT BOTH
00:30:04.836 --> 00:30:06.171
CALIFORNIA'S COMMITMENT TO
00:30:06.237 --> 00:30:09.641
CIVIL LIBERTY. AND HISTORY OF
00:30:09.707 --> 00:30:11.342
INNOVATION REMAIN INTACT.
00:30:11.409 --> 00:30:13.578
TOGETHER WE CAN GRILL. DURING
00:30:13.645 --> 00:30:15.346
THIS CRISIS IN A MANNER TO FALL
00:30:15.413 --> 00:30:16.381
AT THE THAT WOULD ALLOW THE
00:30:16.447 --> 00:30:18.383
STATE TO BE ADAPTIVE RESPONSIVE
00:30:18.449 --> 00:30:20.151
AND FLEXIBLE TO THE NEEDS OF
00:30:20.218 --> 00:30:22.587
THE STATE AS A WHOLE. I'M SO
00:30:22.654 --> 00:30:24.255
WITH THAT I'D LIKE TO TURN TO
00:30:24.322 --> 00:30:29.060
OUR FIRST AUTHOR- ONE AB TWENTY
00:30:29.127 --> 00:30:29.661
ONE FORTY NINE THIS GONZALEZ I
00:30:29.727 --> 00:30:31.963
LIKE TO INVITE YOU TO. COME ON
00:30:32.030 --> 00:30:34.365
UP TO PRESENT YOUR BILL. JUST A
00:30:34.432 --> 00:30:35.533
QUICK REMINDER FOR THOSE
00:30:35.600 --> 00:30:36.668
WISHING TO REGISTER THEIR
00:30:36.734 --> 00:30:39.938
SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION BY PHONE.
00:30:40.004 --> 00:30:42.941
I ENCOURAGE YOU TO CALL IN NOW.
00:30:43.007 --> 00:30:43.775
THE BEGINNING OF THE
00:30:43.841 --> 00:30:45.376
ASSEMBLYMEMBERS TESTIMONY TO
00:30:45.443 --> 00:30:47.145
AVOID ANY DELAYS. THE PHONE
00:30:47.212 --> 00:30:49.214
NUMBER AGAIN IS EIGHT SEVEN
00:30:49.280 --> 00:30:55.019
SEVEN. SIX NINE TWO. EIGHT NINE
00:30:55.086 --> 00:30:55.987
FIVE SEVEN SO WITH THAT DOW
00:30:56.054 --> 00:30:57.455
WELCOME ASSEMBLY MEMBER
00:30:57.522 --> 00:30:58.923
GONZALEZ OF PLEASE BEGIN WHEN
00:30:58.990 --> 00:31:08.066
YOU'RE READY. THIS BILL WITH
00:31:08.132 --> 00:31:09.434
BROAD THE IDEA WAS BROUGHT TO
00:31:09.500 --> 00:31:10.902
YOU BY LOCAL RESTAURANT AND
00:31:10.969 --> 00:31:12.136
QUITE HONESTLY IT WAS BROUGHT
00:31:12.203 --> 00:31:14.305
TO ME BEFORE HIS HAND AND WHAT
00:31:14.372 --> 00:31:15.373
ABOUT THIS PANDEMIC IN
00:31:15.440 --> 00:31:18.276
WHATEVER. RESTAURANT THE ISSUE
00:31:18.343 --> 00:31:20.178
AT HAND WAS A NUMBER PRACTICES
00:31:20.245 --> 00:31:22.547
THAT SEEM TO GO ON BETWEEN.
00:31:22.614 --> 00:31:25.350
DELIVERY OUT AND RESTAURANTS.
00:31:25.416 --> 00:31:26.784
SOME RESTAURANTS ARE VERY HAPPY
00:31:26.851 --> 00:31:28.152
WITH THE RELATIONSHIP WITH THE
00:31:28.219 --> 00:31:29.487
DELIVERY AFTER SOMEONE HAD A
00:31:29.554 --> 00:31:31.022
LOT OF WORK TO ENSURE THAT THEY
00:31:31.089 --> 00:31:36.427
ACTUALLY HAVE. ACTUALLY
00:31:36.494 --> 00:31:37.962
RESTAURANTS DON'T WANT DELIVERY
00:31:38.029 --> 00:31:40.632
APPS TO DELIVER THEIR FOOD AND
00:31:40.698 --> 00:31:41.199
THERE'S A VARIETY OF REASONS
00:31:41.266 --> 00:31:43.501
FOR WHY. TAKE CONTROL THE
00:31:43.568 --> 00:31:45.503
TEMPERATURE THE TIME PERIOD BY
00:31:45.570 --> 00:31:47.105
WHICH THEIR FOOD GETS-
00:31:47.171 --> 00:31:48.573
DELIVERED THEY THEY HAVE
00:31:48.640 --> 00:31:49.607
CERTAIN STANDARDS THAT THEY
00:31:49.674 --> 00:31:51.075
WANT MATT OR THEY HAVE THEIR
00:31:51.142 --> 00:31:53.278
OWN DELIVERY DRIVERS THAT ARE
00:31:53.344 --> 00:31:53.811
ACTUALLY EMPLOYEES OF THE
00:31:53.878 --> 00:31:56.447
RESTAURANT. WHAT WAS HAPPENING
00:31:56.514 --> 00:31:58.483
WAS THESE COMPANIES WERE
00:31:58.549 --> 00:32:00.852
ADVERTISING AND DELIVERING FOOD
00:32:00.918 --> 00:32:02.587
FROM RESTAURANTS THAT HAD NOT
00:32:02.654 --> 00:32:04.088
GIVEN PERMISSION OR HAD NO
00:32:04.155 --> 00:32:06.591
RELATIONSHIP IN FACT ASKED
00:32:06.658 --> 00:32:07.191
THESE COMPANIES NOT TO DELIVER
00:32:07.258 --> 00:32:09.093
THEIR FOOT. FOR SMALL
00:32:09.160 --> 00:32:10.628
BUSINESSES THAT RELY ON THEIR
00:32:10.695 --> 00:32:13.331
CLIENTELE AND THE REPUTATION
00:32:13.398 --> 00:32:15.366
THIS CREATED A PROBLEM. SO WE
00:32:15.433 --> 00:32:16.200
START SPORTY WITH THE
00:32:16.267 --> 00:32:17.468
RESTAURANTS WAYS IN WHICH WE
00:32:17.535 --> 00:32:19.203
COULD DEAL WITH THE SITUATION
00:32:19.270 --> 00:32:20.938
BECAUSE THERE WERE SOME.
00:32:21.005 --> 00:32:24.776
RESULTS THAT THAT HAPPENED. AS
00:32:24.842 --> 00:32:26.644
AS ARE THERE THERE WERE ACTIONS
00:32:26.711 --> 00:32:28.379
THAT HAPPEN AS A RESULT OF
00:32:28.446 --> 00:32:30.081
THESE DELIVERY DRIVERS POSTING
00:32:30.148 --> 00:32:32.350
THEIR MENUS ONLINE. SOME OF
00:32:32.417 --> 00:32:33.584
WHICH WERE THE DELIVERY
00:32:33.651 --> 00:32:35.486
COMPANIES WOULD THEN GO BACK TO
00:32:35.553 --> 00:32:37.188
THE RESTAURANT AFTER THEY HAD.
00:32:37.255 --> 00:32:39.324
BASICALLY COOPTED PART OF THEIR
00:32:39.390 --> 00:32:41.959
CLIENTELE AND SAY OKAY NOW
00:32:42.026 --> 00:32:43.428
YOU'RE GOING TO PAY US FOR
00:32:43.494 --> 00:32:45.163
THESE DELIVERIES. IN AT THE
00:32:45.229 --> 00:32:47.298
RESTAURANT SAID NO. THEN THE
00:32:47.365 --> 00:32:48.766
DELIVERY COMPANY WHO HAVE ALL
00:32:48.833 --> 00:32:50.201
THE INFORMATION AND I JUST
00:32:50.268 --> 00:32:51.736
WANNA GIVE YOU AN EXAMPLE LET'S
00:32:51.803 --> 00:32:53.004
SAY YOUR FAVORITE CHINESE
00:32:53.071 --> 00:32:54.472
RESTAURANT IS DOWN THE STREET.
00:32:54.539 --> 00:32:55.573
AND IT'S KINGS CHINESE
00:32:55.640 --> 00:32:57.442
RESTAURANT AND EVERY FRIDAY
00:32:57.508 --> 00:32:59.344
NIGHT YOU AND YOUR SPOUSE OR
00:32:59.410 --> 00:33:01.045
MONGOLIAN BEEF EVERY FRIDAY
00:33:01.112 --> 00:33:02.647
NIGHT YOUR TRADITION. HAPPENS
00:33:02.714 --> 00:33:08.119
QUITE OFTEN. AND SO YOU CALL. A
00:33:08.186 --> 00:33:08.686
COMPANY I DON'T WANT TO CALL
00:33:08.753 --> 00:33:10.655
ANY OF THEM OUT TO HAVE IT
00:33:10.722 --> 00:33:11.456
DELIVERED HOME FOR YOUR DATE
00:33:11.522 --> 00:33:12.323
NINE. HAPPENS EVERY FRIDAY
00:33:12.390 --> 00:33:16.127
NIGHT. WELL I'M BE NUTS TO YOU
00:33:16.194 --> 00:33:17.261
THEY GET A SPAT WITH THE
00:33:17.328 --> 00:33:18.463
RESTAURANT AT THE RESTAURANT
00:33:18.529 --> 00:33:18.930
DOESN'T WANT TO PAY A
00:33:18.996 --> 00:33:20.832
COMMISSION TO THEM AND SO
00:33:20.898 --> 00:33:22.467
INSTEAD THE COMPANY BECAUSE
00:33:22.533 --> 00:33:23.701
IT'S THE DELIVERY COMPANY THAT
00:33:23.768 --> 00:33:25.269
NOW HAS ALL YOUR INFORMATION
00:33:25.336 --> 00:33:26.604
YOUR LIKES WHEN YOU ORDER IT
00:33:26.671 --> 00:33:28.206
HOW MUCH YOU ORDER SAYS. YOU
00:33:28.272 --> 00:33:29.774
KNOW WHAT. WE'LL GIVE YOU THAT
00:33:29.841 --> 00:33:35.813
SAME EXACT ORDER BUT FROM KINGS
00:33:35.880 --> 00:33:40.418
CHINESE FOOD TO. SO THERE YOU
00:33:40.485 --> 00:33:42.687
SEEN THE RESTAURANT TO TAKE
00:33:42.754 --> 00:33:45.056
THEIR CUSTOMERS. AND THE
00:33:45.123 --> 00:33:46.057
RESTAURANT HAS NO CONTROL OF
00:33:46.124 --> 00:33:47.792
THIS SO WE STARTED SPORTING
00:33:47.859 --> 00:33:49.594
WAYS IN WHICH THE RESTAURANTS
00:33:49.660 --> 00:33:51.329
COULD HAVE MORE POWER TO
00:33:51.396 --> 00:33:52.230
COMMUNICATE WITH THEIR OWN
00:33:52.296 --> 00:33:54.699
CLIENTS AND TO ENSURE THAT THEY
00:33:54.766 --> 00:33:56.067
ARE ONLY LISTED ON THESE
00:33:56.134 --> 00:33:56.868
PLATFORMS IF THEY HAVE AN
00:33:56.934 --> 00:33:59.270
AGREEMENT. WE STARTED OFF WITH
00:33:59.337 --> 00:34:00.538
A KIND OF SHARING OF
00:34:00.605 --> 00:34:02.707
INFORMATION BILL NOW WE
00:34:02.774 --> 00:34:04.275
UNDERSTOOD THAT THAT WOULD RUN
00:34:04.342 --> 00:34:05.410
INTO SOME PROBLEMS ESPECIALLY
00:34:05.476 --> 00:34:07.211
THIS COMMITTEE BUT PROBLEMS
00:34:07.278 --> 00:34:08.179
THAT WE WANTED TO TRY TO GET
00:34:08.246 --> 00:34:10.448
THROUGH WE HAVEN'T BEEN ABLE TO
00:34:10.515 --> 00:34:13.017
FIGURE THAT PIECE OUT SO WE
00:34:13.084 --> 00:34:14.886
AGREED TO PULL THAT PIECE BACK
00:34:14.952 --> 00:34:16.254
AND STILL CONTINUE TO TRY TO
00:34:16.320 --> 00:34:17.822
WORK ON. WHAT THAT WOULD LOOK
00:34:17.889 --> 00:34:19.791
LIKE CAN CUSTOMERS HAVE THE
00:34:19.857 --> 00:34:22.393
POWER TO SAY YES THE RESTAURANT
00:34:22.460 --> 00:34:24.462
CAN HAVE MY INFORMATION. OR CAN
00:34:24.529 --> 00:34:26.330
THEY OPT OUT OF THAT. BUT
00:34:26.397 --> 00:34:27.465
BECAUSE OF OUR SHORTENED
00:34:27.532 --> 00:34:28.966
SCHEDULE IN THE AMOUNT OF TIME
00:34:29.033 --> 00:34:30.368
WE COULD WORK ON THIS BILL THAT
00:34:30.435 --> 00:34:31.302
PIECE WE'VE TAKEN COMPLETELY
00:34:31.369 --> 00:34:32.603
OUT AND NOW WE JUST HAVE THE
00:34:32.670 --> 00:34:33.871
REQUIREMENTTHAT THERE BE A
00:34:33.938 --> 00:34:35.840
CONTRACTUAL RELATIONSHIP. AND
00:34:35.907 --> 00:34:38.342
ALL THIS SAYS IS BASICALLY THAT
00:34:38.409 --> 00:34:40.845
FOR A DELIVERY PLATFORM TO PUT
00:34:40.912 --> 00:34:43.080
UP THE MANUAL TO PUT THE LOGO
00:34:43.147 --> 00:34:44.048
TO ACT LIKE THERE IS A
00:34:44.115 --> 00:34:45.450
RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN THE
00:34:45.516 --> 00:34:47.318
RESTAURANT THE DELIVERY COMPANY
00:34:47.385 --> 00:34:49.153
THAT THERE HAS TO BE A WRITTEN.
00:34:49.220 --> 00:34:52.023
CONTRACT BETWEEN THE RESTAURANT
00:34:52.089 --> 00:34:53.624
AND THE DELIVERY COMPANY THIS
00:34:53.691 --> 00:34:55.092
WILL PREVENT THE RESTAURANTS
00:34:55.159 --> 00:34:57.295
WHO DON'T WANT TO BE LISTED
00:34:57.361 --> 00:34:59.497
FROM BEING LISTED IT'S SIMPLE
00:34:59.564 --> 00:35:02.433
IT'S FAIR AND AS WE MOVE OUT OF
00:35:02.500 --> 00:35:03.668
THIS PANDEMIC WHEN SO MANY
00:35:03.734 --> 00:35:06.237
RESTAURANTS HAVE. RELIED IN
00:35:06.304 --> 00:35:07.205
SOMETIMES TO THEIR KNOWLEDGE
00:35:07.271 --> 00:35:08.105
SOMETIMES WITHOUT THEIR
00:35:08.172 --> 00:35:09.807
KNOWLEDGE ON DELIVERY AND PICK
00:35:09.874 --> 00:35:11.742
UP IT'S A WAY FOR THEM TO GAIN
00:35:11.809 --> 00:35:13.611
SOME CONTROL ESPECIALLY SMALL
00:35:13.678 --> 00:35:16.247
RESTAURANTS OF THE RELATIONSHIP
00:35:16.314 --> 00:35:18.249
WITH OUR CUSTOMER AGAIN SO WITH
00:35:18.316 --> 00:35:20.184
THAT- I ASKED I KNOW THAT
00:35:20.251 --> 00:35:21.352
THAT'S WILL NEED WORK THE
00:35:21.419 --> 00:35:24.021
ISSUES ADDRESSED IN. ANALYSIS
00:35:24.088 --> 00:35:26.624
ARE ISSUES PRIMARILY- FOR THE
00:35:26.691 --> 00:35:28.659
JUDICIARY COMMITTEE- AND I
00:35:28.726 --> 00:35:29.894
UNDERSTAND THAT BUT BECAUSE OF
00:35:29.961 --> 00:35:31.062
COURSE AGAIN WERE UNDER KIND OF
00:35:31.128 --> 00:35:33.664
UNUSUAL TIMES- THIS IS WHERE
00:35:33.731 --> 00:35:35.633
THIS BILL IS NOW THE PRIVACY
00:35:35.700 --> 00:35:36.667
CONCERNS HAVE BEEN STRIPPED IF
00:35:36.734 --> 00:35:38.436
WE PUT ANYTHING THAT WHAT WOULD
00:35:38.503 --> 00:35:40.338
RESULT IN KIND OF THE SHARING
00:35:40.404 --> 00:35:41.339
OF INFORMATION IT WILL COME
00:35:41.405 --> 00:35:42.640
BACK TO THIS COMMITTEE AND WE
00:35:42.707 --> 00:35:43.508
WERE WE SAID WE'RE WORKING
00:35:43.574 --> 00:35:44.809
CLOSELY WITH THE COMMITTEE. BUT
00:35:44.876 --> 00:35:46.010
FOR NOW IT'S JUST GOVERNING
00:35:46.077 --> 00:35:47.144
THAT CONTRACTUAL RELATIONSHIP
00:35:47.211 --> 00:35:49.680
WITH THAT I RESPECTFULLY ASK
00:35:49.747 --> 00:35:51.682
FOR NINE ON A BILL THAT I THINK
00:35:51.749 --> 00:35:53.317
MIGHT BE THE FIRST THE BOTH THE
00:35:53.384 --> 00:35:53.784
CALIFORNIA RESTAURANT
00:35:53.851 --> 00:35:54.819
ASSOCIATION THE CALIFORNIA
00:35:54.886 --> 00:35:57.221
LABOR FEDERATION SUPPORT. THANK
00:35:57.288 --> 00:35:59.957
YOU VERY MUCH. GREAT THE BILL'S
00:36:00.024 --> 00:36:01.726
VINCE MOVED AND SECONDED LET'S
00:36:01.792 --> 00:36:03.661
SELF FIRST TO GO TO OUR WITNESS
00:36:03.728 --> 00:36:06.297
IN SUPPORT OF THE LEGISLATION I
00:36:06.364 --> 00:36:08.432
BELIEVE WE HAVE MR MATSON OF
00:36:08.499 --> 00:36:10.167
FROM CALIFORNIA RESTAURANT
00:36:10.234 --> 00:36:11.235
ASSOCIATION BY WAY OF
00:36:11.302 --> 00:36:13.371
TELEPHONE. MISTER SUN NOW YOU
00:36:13.437 --> 00:36:17.141
ARE YOU THERE. YES MISTER CHAIR
00:36:17.208 --> 00:36:18.776
GOOD MORNING COULD MAKE YOU THE
00:36:18.843 --> 00:36:21.445
MAP THAT WILL BE. GOOD MORNING
00:36:21.512 --> 00:36:22.680
THE MOMENT THAT WOULD DOUBLE
00:36:22.747 --> 00:36:24.549
YOUR RESTAURANTS THIS NATION.
00:36:24.615 --> 00:36:25.816
IN STRONG SUPPORT OF ASSEMBLY
00:36:25.883 --> 00:36:28.486
MEMBER CONSULT BILL AB TWENTY
00:36:28.553 --> 00:36:29.820
FORTY NINE AS YOU HEARD THE
00:36:29.887 --> 00:36:30.688
BILL REQUIRED DELIVERY
00:36:30.755 --> 00:36:32.657
PLATFORMS TO RECEIVE PERMISSION
00:36:32.723 --> 00:36:33.758
FROM A RESTAURANT PRIOR TO
00:36:33.824 --> 00:36:36.527
POSTING A RESTAURANT LOGO- MENU
00:36:36.594 --> 00:36:38.162
ON THE PLATFORM. DOES MIGHT
00:36:38.229 --> 00:36:38.696
STRIKE YOU AS COMMONSENSE
00:36:38.763 --> 00:36:40.298
PRINCIPLE JUST GOOD BUSINESS
00:36:40.364 --> 00:36:42.466
PRACTICE WE AGREE HOWEVER
00:36:42.533 --> 00:36:43.601
THAT'S NOT WHAT'S HAPPENING ON
00:36:43.668 --> 00:36:45.069
THE GROUND. IN MANY OF YOUR
00:36:45.136 --> 00:36:46.604
DISTRICTS WITH REGARDS TO THE
00:36:46.671 --> 00:36:48.439
DELIVERY AFTER THE LOCAL
00:36:48.506 --> 00:36:49.807
COMMUNITY RESTAURANTS. ROBERTS
00:36:49.874 --> 00:36:51.709
BUT IT'LL NO MEANS NEW IT'S
00:36:51.776 --> 00:36:54.278
BEEN- INCREASING AT A RAPID
00:36:54.345 --> 00:36:55.913
RATE OVER THE YEARS AND IT
00:36:55.980 --> 00:36:57.248
CERTAINLY GOT MORE PRONOUNCED
00:36:57.315 --> 00:36:59.750
DURING THE PUBLIC. HEALTH
00:36:59.817 --> 00:37:01.452
CRISIS WITH WILL BE NINETEEN.
00:37:01.519 --> 00:37:03.554
IT'S BEING EXAGGERATED. BUT IT
00:37:03.621 --> 00:37:05.056
DEEPER WE FIND OURSELVES IN THE
00:37:05.122 --> 00:37:06.457
CRISIS PARTICULARLY BECAUSE
00:37:06.524 --> 00:37:07.892
RESTAURANTS ARE NOW LIMITED TO
00:37:07.959 --> 00:37:09.961
ONLY OPERATING WILL TAKE OUT
00:37:10.027 --> 00:37:11.862
AND DELIVERY. LIKE MANY NEW
00:37:11.929 --> 00:37:13.230
TECHNOLOGIES THE EMERGENCE OF
00:37:13.297 --> 00:37:14.966
TO DELIVERY PLATFORMS CREATED
00:37:15.032 --> 00:37:16.434
IN DIRECT INSTRUCTION AND
00:37:16.500 --> 00:37:17.568
STATEWIDE FOOD. SERVICE
00:37:17.635 --> 00:37:20.671
COMMUNITY AND THAT DESTRUCTION
00:37:20.738 --> 00:37:21.238
IS BECOME MORE PRONOUNCED AS
00:37:21.305 --> 00:37:22.907
I'VE MENTIONED. THE TYPE
00:37:22.974 --> 00:37:24.375
BUSINESS PRACTICE THAT THAT'S
00:37:24.442 --> 00:37:25.977
ON THE WOMAN DEVELOP THIS IS
00:37:26.043 --> 00:37:28.679
GOING. TO ADDRESS MAY HELP THE
00:37:28.746 --> 00:37:30.715
FOOD DELIVERY ABSTRACT TRAFFIC
00:37:30.781 --> 00:37:32.750
TO THEIR WEB PLATFORMS BUT HER
00:37:32.817 --> 00:37:33.217
RESTAURANT THE CREATES
00:37:33.284 --> 00:37:36.020
CONFUSION. IT HURTS OUR BRANDS
00:37:36.087 --> 00:37:37.221
IT HURTS OUR INDEPENDENT
00:37:37.288 --> 00:37:40.291
RESTAURANTS AND IT CERTAINLY
00:37:40.358 --> 00:37:41.025
THE TRUCK STOP OR OPERATIONS.
00:37:41.092 --> 00:37:42.526
THE SOME CASES RESTAURANT
00:37:42.593 --> 00:37:43.661
THIRTY HAVE A DELIVERY SYSTEM
00:37:43.728 --> 00:37:45.029
IN PLACE OPERATED BY THEIR OWN
00:37:45.096 --> 00:37:46.831
EMPLOYEES. IF THEIR MENU AND
00:37:46.897 --> 00:37:48.766
THEN LISTED ON AND I'M NOT
00:37:48.833 --> 00:37:50.601
AUTHORIZED TO DELIVERY PLATFORM
00:37:50.668 --> 00:37:54.805
pABOUT THE RESTAURANT AND THE
00:37:54.872 --> 00:37:55.806
DELIVERY DRIVER WHO SHOWS UP.
00:37:55.873 --> 00:37:57.108
THE CUSTOMER THE DRIVER IN THE
00:37:57.174 --> 00:37:58.275
RESTAURANT AND UP LOSING
00:37:58.342 --> 00:38:00.011
BECAUSE THE CUSTOMER DOES NOT
00:38:00.077 --> 00:38:01.746
GET THEIR FOOD. SOMETIMES THE
00:38:01.812 --> 00:38:03.347
DRIVER HE ATE AND THE
00:38:03.414 --> 00:38:04.915
RESTAURANTS REPUTATION IS
00:38:04.982 --> 00:38:06.651
DAMAGED IN THE IN THE MEANTIME.
00:38:06.717 --> 00:38:07.818
ANOTHER IS WITH THIS GOOD
00:38:07.885 --> 00:38:09.286
DELIVERY PLATFORMS MIGHT POST
00:38:09.353 --> 00:38:11.555
AN OUTDATED MENU. FOR A LOCAL
00:38:11.622 --> 00:38:13.524
AT THE RESTAURANT. THE CHANCES
00:38:13.591 --> 00:38:15.660
ARE FOR CUSTOMERS ORDERING WITH
00:38:15.726 --> 00:38:17.862
AN OUTDATED MENU OR OUTDATED
00:38:17.928 --> 00:38:19.463
PRODUCT. FROM THE RESTAURANT
00:38:19.530 --> 00:38:21.632
THE THIRD PARTY APPS WEBSITE.
00:38:21.699 --> 00:38:22.967
THEN THERE'S GONNA BE ISSUES
00:38:23.034 --> 00:38:24.301
WITH THEIR FOOD ORDER. THAT
00:38:24.368 --> 00:38:25.536
LEADS TO CONFUSION BUT NOT JUST
00:38:25.603 --> 00:38:27.538
CONFUSION AT LEAST THE ANGER AT
00:38:27.605 --> 00:38:29.640
THE RESTAURANT IT IS VIEWED AS
00:38:29.707 --> 00:38:32.977
THE RESTAURANTS FALL WHEN THE-
00:38:33.044 --> 00:38:33.878
BALLPARK AFTER THE TO THE
00:38:33.944 --> 00:38:36.080
RESTAURANT. AS WE ALL KNOW
00:38:36.147 --> 00:38:38.649
RESTAURANTS ARE BASING ON
00:38:38.716 --> 00:38:40.317
OF YOU SENIOR DISTRICT MORE
00:38:40.384 --> 00:38:41.552
THAN EVER IF YOU RETURNED YOUR
00:38:41.619 --> 00:38:43.020
DISTRICTS IN MID MARCH TO SERVE
00:38:43.087 --> 00:38:44.388
YOUR CONSTITUENTS THAT
00:38:44.455 --> 00:38:46.457
RESTAURANTS- AND UNBELIEVABLY
00:38:46.524 --> 00:38:48.225
UNCHARTERED TERRITORY WITH THE
00:38:48.292 --> 00:38:51.429
PUBLIC HEALTH- EPIDEMIC. WE'VE
00:38:51.495 --> 00:38:53.030
ESTIMATED THAT MORE THAN ONE
00:38:53.097 --> 00:38:54.098
MILLION RESTAURANT EMPLOYEES TO
00:38:54.165 --> 00:38:56.300
CALIFORNIA'S BEEN LAID OFF- LOW
00:38:56.367 --> 00:38:57.601
TO BEGINNING THE CORE
00:38:57.668 --> 00:38:59.503
CORONAVIRUS OUTBREAK IN MARCH.
00:38:59.570 --> 00:39:01.172
IN THE MONTH OF APRIL ESTIMATED
00:39:01.238 --> 00:39:02.339
REVENUE LOSSES FOR THE FOOD
00:39:02.406 --> 00:39:04.208
SERVICE INDUSTRY IS OVER SIX
00:39:04.275 --> 00:39:06.210
BILLION DOLLARS. AT THE SAME
00:39:06.277 --> 00:39:07.311
TIME THE FOOD DELIVERY
00:39:07.378 --> 00:39:08.512
PLATFORMS ARE EXPERIENCING
00:39:08.579 --> 00:39:10.347
UNPRECEDENTED GROWTH AS
00:39:10.414 --> 00:39:12.917
CONSUMERS ARE REQUIRED STATE
00:39:12.983 --> 00:39:14.285
HOMES THE MATTER PUBLIC HEALTH.
00:39:14.351 --> 00:39:15.653
THAT'S WHY IT'S MORE IMPORTANT
00:39:15.720 --> 00:39:16.987
NEVER TO ENSURE THE RESTAURANT-
00:39:17.054 --> 00:39:18.122
DELIVERY PLATFORMS ARE
00:39:18.189 --> 00:39:20.257
OPERATING IN PARTNERSHIP. IN A
00:39:20.324 --> 00:39:22.026
WAY THAT BENEFITS THE CONSUMER
00:39:22.093 --> 00:39:23.728
THE RESTAURANT THE FOOD
00:39:23.794 --> 00:39:25.663
DELIVERY PLATFORM. WHAT A
00:39:25.730 --> 00:39:26.664
PLATFORM USES A RESTAURANT
00:39:26.731 --> 00:39:28.032
LOWER MENU THAT APPLIES TO
00:39:28.099 --> 00:39:29.233
PARTNERSHIP BETWEEN THE TWO
00:39:29.300 --> 00:39:31.068
ENTITIES NOT ALL FOOD DELIVERY
00:39:31.135 --> 00:39:32.436
PLATFORMS TAKING SUCH
00:39:32.503 --> 00:39:33.771
AGGRESSIVE TACTICS TO GROW
00:39:33.838 --> 00:39:36.574
THEIR BUSINESS. BY ON UP RIGHT
00:39:36.640 --> 00:39:38.476
USE OF OUR PRODUCTS. I'M GOOD
00:39:38.542 --> 00:39:39.677
DELIVERY CLASSROOMS ARE TRUE
00:39:39.744 --> 00:39:41.846
PARTNERS WITH RESTAURANTS. WE
00:39:41.912 --> 00:39:44.148
BELIEVE ALL FOOD TO PLATFORM TO
00:39:44.215 --> 00:39:45.783
COMMIT PARTNERSHIPS THAT ARE
00:39:45.850 --> 00:39:47.518
MUTUALLY BENEFICIAL DELIVERY
00:39:47.585 --> 00:39:48.919
PLATFORM USES THE RESTAURANT
00:39:48.986 --> 00:39:51.255
LOGO THE MENU WITHOUT THE
00:39:51.322 --> 00:39:53.424
PERMISSION THE BENEFIT TO THE
00:39:53.491 --> 00:39:54.992
TO DELIVERY PLATFORM OUTWEIGHED
00:39:55.059 --> 00:39:56.460
ANY POTENTIAL BENEFIT OF
00:39:56.527 --> 00:39:58.262
EXPANDING RESTAURANTS CUSTOMER
00:39:58.329 --> 00:39:59.797
BASE. THIS BILL HELPS RESTORE
00:39:59.864 --> 00:40:02.199
THAT EQUITY BACKING OF THE
00:40:02.266 --> 00:40:05.402
RELATIONSHIP. THE THAT. ARE IF
00:40:05.469 --> 00:40:06.904
YOU WILL THE MIDDLE PERSON WITH
00:40:06.971 --> 00:40:08.372
MILLIONS IF NOT BILLIONS
00:40:08.439 --> 00:40:10.608
FUNDING IT LONG FRUSTRATED MANY
00:40:10.674 --> 00:40:11.809
IN THE RESTAURANT COMMUNITY
00:40:11.876 --> 00:40:13.511
WITH THESE TYPES OF PRACTICES.
00:40:13.577 --> 00:40:15.346
PRACTICES THAT SOME PLATFORMS
00:40:15.412 --> 00:40:17.248
TO DISMISSIVELY TERMS CLERICAL
00:40:17.314 --> 00:40:18.716
ERRORS WHEN THEY HAVE
00:40:18.783 --> 00:40:21.652
UNAUTHORIZED USE OF OUR
00:40:21.719 --> 00:40:23.387
PRODUCTS ON THEIR WEBSITE.
00:40:23.454 --> 00:40:24.722
WHILE OTHERS INCLUDING A SAN
00:40:24.789 --> 00:40:25.823
FRANCISCO MEMBER OF THE BOARD
00:40:25.890 --> 00:40:28.159
OF SUPERVISOR HAVE TURNED THAT
00:40:28.225 --> 00:40:29.760
PREDATORY DELIBERATE PRACTICE.
00:40:29.827 --> 00:40:32.263
THIS BILL AB TWENTY ONE FORTY
00:40:32.329 --> 00:40:33.864
NINE THE SIMPLE STEPS. AND HELP
00:40:33.931 --> 00:40:35.199
GET THE SKILLS OF EQUITY BACK
00:40:35.266 --> 00:40:36.367
TOWARDS THE LOCAL COMMUNITY
00:40:36.433 --> 00:40:38.302
RESTAURANT WHICH HAD TREMENDOUS
00:40:38.369 --> 00:40:39.570
VALUE TO THE STATE'S OVERALL
00:40:39.637 --> 00:40:41.205
RESTAURANT COMMUNITY. AND WE'RE
00:40:41.272 --> 00:40:42.573
PROUD THAT THAT SIGNAL THE
00:40:42.640 --> 00:40:44.575
RESTAURANT COMMUNITY BOASTS 60%
00:40:44.642 --> 00:40:46.710
CALIFORNIA RESTAURANT. OWNED BY
00:40:46.777 --> 00:40:48.212
PEOPLE OF COLOR THE RESTAURANT
00:40:48.279 --> 00:40:49.513
COMMUNITY AT LEAST PRIOR TO
00:40:49.580 --> 00:40:50.915
COPE WITH NINETEEN WAS THE
00:40:50.981 --> 00:40:52.149
LARGEST PRIVATE EMPLOYER IN THE
00:40:52.216 --> 00:40:53.818
SATE OF CALIFORNIA. AND HAD
00:40:53.884 --> 00:40:55.319
THE LARGEST GENERATION IF
00:40:55.386 --> 00:40:57.321
THEY'LL LOCAL. OF STATE AND
00:40:57.388 --> 00:40:59.089
LOCAL SALES TAX WHICH WE ALL
00:40:59.156 --> 00:41:01.358
KNOW NOW ESPECIALLY COMMUNITIES
00:41:01.425 --> 00:41:04.328
ARE GONNA DEPEND ON THE BILL
00:41:04.395 --> 00:41:04.895
TAX DOLLARS MORE THAN EVER.
00:41:04.962 --> 00:41:06.096
YOU'LL LIKELY HEAR PROPONENTS
00:41:06.163 --> 00:41:07.131
THAT THE CURRENT BETTER ALLOWED
00:41:07.198 --> 00:41:09.200
DRESSES THIS PROBLEM. IT'S BEEN
00:41:09.266 --> 00:41:10.367
A HANDFUL OF RECENT LAWSUIT
00:41:10.434 --> 00:41:12.236
CALIFORNIA ILLINOIS AND NEW
00:41:12.303 --> 00:41:13.904
HAMPSHIRE BETWEEN RESTAURANT-
00:41:13.971 --> 00:41:15.873
DELIVERY PLATFORMS OVER
00:41:15.940 --> 00:41:17.575
COPYRIGHT INFRINGEMENT. OTHER
00:41:17.641 --> 00:41:18.642
STATES DO ARE CONTEMPLATING
00:41:18.709 --> 00:41:20.377
SIMILAR LEGISLATION THAT THIS
00:41:20.444 --> 00:41:22.246
INTELLIGENCE PRESENTING TODAY
00:41:22.313 --> 00:41:24.548
BANNING THE ON OFF RIGHT USED
00:41:24.615 --> 00:41:26.050
RESTAURANT LOGO OR MANY.
00:41:26.116 --> 00:41:27.518
FEDERAL COPYRIGHT LAW IS NOT
00:41:27.585 --> 00:41:29.253
CLEAR AND WOULD NOT PROVIDE
00:41:29.320 --> 00:41:29.720
ENOUGH PROTECTION THE
00:41:29.787 --> 00:41:31.555
RESTAURANT. THAT WAS STATING
00:41:31.622 --> 00:41:33.490
THAT FEDERAL OUT SOME INTIMATE
00:41:33.557 --> 00:41:35.426
INTERMEDIARY STILL ACTIVE USER
00:41:35.492 --> 00:41:37.795
MENU ANYWAY. THIS IS CERTAINLY
00:41:37.862 --> 00:41:39.864
EVIDENCE WE FEEL THAT FEDERAL
00:41:39.930 --> 00:41:42.166
LAW DOES NOT DETER THE ACTIVITY
00:41:42.233 --> 00:41:43.767
AND MAY EVEN ALLOW IT. THERE'S
00:41:43.834 --> 00:41:45.436
LITTLE LEGITIMATE ROLE FOR TH
00:41:45.502 --> 00:41:48.739
STATE TO DEEM A PRACTICE UNFAIR
00:41:48.806 --> 00:41:50.708
UNDER STATE LAW AND PROHIBITED.
00:41:50.774 --> 00:41:52.276
I DON'T THINK ONE CAN ARGUE
00:41:52.343 --> 00:41:53.878
THAT COPYRIGHT LAWSUIT PROCEEDS
00:41:53.944 --> 00:41:55.145
ALLSTATE EFFORT LEAST UNFAIR
00:41:55.212 --> 00:41:57.748
BUSINESS PRACTICES MR SUDDEN
00:41:57.815 --> 00:42:02.553
QUOTING. GOOD PLACE CUT. PLEASE
00:42:02.620 --> 00:42:03.954
PROCEDURE OUT OF CONDITIONS
00:42:04.021 --> 00:42:06.023
MATT AS A AS A MATTER OF PUBLIC
00:42:06.090 --> 00:42:07.424
POLICY FOR THIS COMMITTEE WITH
00:42:07.491 --> 00:42:08.692
A CALIFORNIA SHOULD STEP UP AND
00:42:08.759 --> 00:42:09.860
BRING THE EQUITY INTO THE
00:42:09.927 --> 00:42:10.594
RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN
00:42:10.661 --> 00:42:12.863
RESTAURANTS AND FOOD DELIVERY
00:42:12.930 --> 00:42:14.698
PLATFORMS. THANK YOU YOU
00:42:14.765 --> 00:42:15.666
OUTLINED SOME PARAMETERS
00:42:15.733 --> 00:42:16.734
MOMENTS AGO AT THE BEGINNING OF
00:42:16.800 --> 00:42:18.636
THIS HEARING. FOR THE LAND IS
00:42:18.702 --> 00:42:19.837
IN WHICH YOU SUGGEST THIS
00:42:19.904 --> 00:42:20.871
COMMITTEE LOOK AT BILLS IN THE
00:42:20.938 --> 00:42:22.740
MIDST OF COVERED NINETEEN. WE
00:42:22.806 --> 00:42:24.441
APPRECIATE THAT AND WE THINK
00:42:24.508 --> 00:42:26.010
THIS BILL ALIGNS PERFECTLY WITH
00:42:26.076 --> 00:42:27.745
THAT VISION. THANK YOU FOR YOUR
00:42:27.811 --> 00:42:28.879
TIME CONSIDERATION WE
00:42:28.946 --> 00:42:29.947
APPRECIATE THE HOLDING THIS
00:42:30.014 --> 00:42:31.215
HEARING AND ALLOWING US THE
00:42:31.282 --> 00:42:32.650
TEST BY THROUGH THESE REMOTE
00:42:32.716 --> 00:42:34.418
MEANS. AND WE CERTAINLY THANK
00:42:34.485 --> 00:42:35.252
THE ASSEMBLY WOMAN FOR HER
00:42:35.319 --> 00:42:36.520
LEADERSHIP ON THIS ISSUE AND WE
00:42:36.587 --> 00:42:37.888
ASK FOR YOUR AYE ABOUT THANK
00:42:37.955 --> 00:42:39.623
YOU. I THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR
00:42:39.690 --> 00:42:41.258
YOUR TESTIMONY MISTER CERTAIN-
00:42:41.325 --> 00:42:42.860
AT THIS POINT LIKE TO TURN TO
00:42:42.927 --> 00:42:44.895
ALL OTHER SUPPORTERS SAW
00:42:44.962 --> 00:42:47.031
ONLINE. PLEASE IDENTIFY
00:42:47.097 --> 00:42:51.235
YOURSELF- YOUR ASSOCIATION AND
00:42:51.302 --> 00:42:57.741
YOUR POSITION. AND IS THERE
00:42:57.808 --> 00:42:59.009
ANYONE WHO WANTS TO MAKE A
00:42:59.076 --> 00:43:00.477
COMMENT AND SUPPORT AT THIS
00:43:00.544 --> 00:43:04.114
BILL PLEASE PRESS ONE THEN ZERO.
00:43:04.181 --> 00:43:05.282
AGAIN IF THERE IS ANYONE WHO
00:43:05.349 --> 00:43:06.784
WOULD LIKE TO MAKE A COMMENT IN
00:43:06.850 --> 00:43:08.819
SUPPORT OF THIS BILL PLEASE
00:43:08.886 --> 00:43:10.888
THAT'S ONE ZERO. AND ONE MOMENT
00:43:10.955 --> 00:43:29.573
PLEASE.
00:43:33.777 --> 00:43:36.046
HEARING NO ONE LET'S
00:43:36.113 --> 00:43:41.652
TURNED HER ORTEZ ON SOME WE DO.
00:43:41.719 --> 00:43:43.787
AND WE HAVE AMALIA AND MANY
00:43:43.854 --> 00:43:46.757
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HELLO CHAIR
00:43:46.824 --> 00:43:47.925
AND MEMBERS OF THE MILLION THE
00:43:47.992 --> 00:43:48.926
MONEY REPRESENTING THE
00:43:48.993 --> 00:43:50.127
CALIFORNIA TRAVEL ASSOCIATION
00:43:50.194 --> 00:43:52.262
AND WE ARE A PART OF THE SELF
00:43:52.329 --> 00:43:53.664
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. ANYONE
00:43:53.731 --> 00:43:58.736
ELSE. AND ONE MOMENT FOR YOUR
00:43:58.802 --> 00:44:00.938
PATIENT PLEASE WE DON'T HAVE A
00:44:01.005 --> 00:44:10.481
FEELING CAN THANK YOU. AND WE
00:44:10.547 --> 00:44:14.585
HAVE A COMMENT FROM LONG RANGE
00:44:14.651 --> 00:44:17.621
THE HOLY PLACE BY HAND. MISTER
00:44:17.688 --> 00:44:19.289
CHAIR NUMBER COMMITTEE- MY NAME
00:44:19.356 --> 00:44:20.824
IS MAUREEN MAHONEY ON BEHALF OF
00:44:20.891 --> 00:44:23.293
CONSUMER REPORTS WE VERY MUCH
00:44:23.360 --> 00:44:24.628
SUPPORT THE GOAL OF THIS
00:44:24.695 --> 00:44:25.996
LEGISLATION AND WE APPRECIATE
00:44:26.063 --> 00:44:28.332
YOUR CONSIDERING IT- WE DO HOPE
00:44:28.399 --> 00:44:29.800
TO WORK WITH THE AUTHOR TO
00:44:29.867 --> 00:44:31.101
INSURE THAT THE LEGISLATION
00:44:31.168 --> 00:44:32.369
DOESN'T IN IMPORTANTLY
00:44:32.436 --> 00:44:34.104
INTERFERE WITH CONSUMERS. ARE
00:44:34.171 --> 00:44:35.239
THINKING BECAUSE REVIEWS ARE
00:44:35.305 --> 00:44:37.274
OTHER GENERATED CONTENT- BUT
00:44:37.341 --> 00:44:39.710
AGAIN THANKS VERY MUCH FOR
00:44:39.777 --> 00:44:42.079
CONSIDERING LEGISLATION. THANK
00:44:42.146 --> 00:44:47.885
YOU MUCH ANYONE ELSE. AND WE DO
00:44:47.951 --> 00:44:55.793
HAVE ONE MORE IN Q. ONE MOMENT.
00:44:55.859 --> 00:44:58.829
THANKS IF THERE'S NO ONE ELSE
00:44:58.896 --> 00:45:02.299
SO LET'S TURN TO OPPOSITION. I
00:45:02.366 --> 00:45:03.534
BELIEVE WE HAVE MR ROBERT
00:45:03.600 --> 00:45:04.935
CALLAGHAN FROM THE INTERNET
00:45:05.002 --> 00:45:07.838
ASSOCIATION OF TESTIFYING WE AT
00:45:07.905 --> 00:45:11.075
THE FALL. AND ALSO- IS CORNY
00:45:11.141 --> 00:45:13.277
JENSEN SO PLEASE GO AHEAD
00:45:13.343 --> 00:45:17.214
MISTER CALLAHAN. THANK YOU
00:45:17.281 --> 00:45:18.782
MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS- ROBERT
00:45:18.849 --> 00:45:19.883
CALLAGHAN WITH THE INTERNET
00:45:19.950 --> 00:45:22.052
ASSOCIATION AND- WE ARE OPPOSED
00:45:22.119 --> 00:45:23.787
TO THE BILL AND PLAN FOR THE
00:45:23.854 --> 00:45:25.522
PRIVACY RELATED REASONS THAT
00:45:25.589 --> 00:45:28.225
WERE. NOT FULLY LAID OUT IN THE
00:45:28.292 --> 00:45:30.427
COMMITTEES ANALYSIS. THE DATA
00:45:30.494 --> 00:45:32.296
SHARING MANDATE- WE DO THANK
00:45:32.362 --> 00:45:34.064
THE AUTHOR FOR REMOVING THIS
00:45:34.131 --> 00:45:36.700
LANGUAGE- THROUGH THE MEMBERS
00:45:36.767 --> 00:45:38.602
ARE TAKING TODAY THAT SAD. BUT
00:45:38.669 --> 00:45:40.003
WE'RE STILL WORKING THROUGH THE
00:45:40.070 --> 00:45:42.072
IMPLICATIONS RAISED BY THE NEW
00:45:42.139 --> 00:45:43.674
LANGUAGE OF THE EXPRESS WRITTEN
00:45:43.740 --> 00:45:46.243
CONSENT REQUIREMENTS- AMONG THE
00:45:46.310 --> 00:45:47.945
CONCERNS RAISED IN ALICE'S WERE
00:45:48.011 --> 00:45:51.115
ALSO- DURING THE EXTENT TO
00:45:51.181 --> 00:45:52.883
WHICH- IT MAY NOT NECESSARILY
00:45:52.950 --> 00:45:55.018
LEAD TO. INTERRUPTIONS IN
00:45:55.085 --> 00:45:56.487
SERVICE FOR THE MARRIED
00:45:56.553 --> 00:45:58.355
RESTAURANTS TO DO BENEFIT FROM
00:45:58.422 --> 00:45:59.656
BEING LISTED ON A TO DO EVERY
00:45:59.723 --> 00:46:01.391
PLATFORM AND ACTUALLY DO WANT
00:46:01.458 --> 00:46:04.328
TO BE ON THE PLATFORM SO- WE
00:46:04.394 --> 00:46:05.362
LOOK FORWARD TO FURTHER
00:46:05.429 --> 00:46:06.597
DISCUSSIONS WITH THE AUTHORS
00:46:06.663 --> 00:46:08.465
OFFICE AND THE PROPONENTS OF
00:46:08.532 --> 00:46:10.234
THE BILL. MOVING FORWARD THANK
00:46:10.300 --> 00:46:11.869
YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH MISTER
00:46:11.935 --> 00:46:13.737
CALLAHAN LET'S NOT- NOW O TO
00:46:13.804 --> 00:46:15.772
MS SO COURTNEY TENSE AND FROM
00:46:15.839 --> 00:46:18.842
TECHNET. PLEASE GO AHEAD MR
00:46:18.909 --> 00:46:21.145
ANSON. YOU MISTER KAREN MEMBERS
00:46:21.211 --> 00:46:23.714
CORPS IN JENSEN ATTACK MATT AND
00:46:23.780 --> 00:46:26.150
TECH MATT IS ALSO OPPOSED AB
00:46:26.216 --> 00:46:26.783
TWENTY ONE FORTY NINE AND GRANT
00:46:26.850 --> 00:46:27.985
AND I WANT TO ECHO THE COMMENTS
00:46:28.051 --> 00:46:29.253
OF THE INTERNET AT THE BEACH
00:46:29.319 --> 00:46:30.954
AND- WE DO APPRECIATE THE
00:46:31.021 --> 00:46:32.389
PRIVACY PROVISIONS BEING
00:46:32.456 --> 00:46:33.824
REMOVED FROM THE BELL AND ARE
00:46:33.891 --> 00:46:35.192
REVIEWING THE WORKABILITY AND
00:46:35.259 --> 00:46:36.527
THE EXPRESS WRITTEN CONSENT
00:46:36.593 --> 00:46:38.529
LANGUAGE. BUT YOU HAVE DONE
00:46:38.595 --> 00:46:40.330
CONCERNS WE LOOK FORWARD TO
00:46:40.397 --> 00:46:41.431
WORKING WITH THE AUTHOR AND
00:46:41.498 --> 00:46:42.733
SPONSORS CAN FIND A PATH
00:46:42.799 --> 00:46:43.600
FORWARD THAT WORKS FOR
00:46:43.667 --> 00:46:45.269
RESTAURANTS AND FOOD DELIVERY
00:46:45.335 --> 00:46:47.137
PLATFORM. THE RELATIONSHIPS OUR
00:46:47.204 --> 00:46:48.405
MEMBER COMPANIES HAVE WHAT
00:46:48.472 --> 00:46:49.706
THEIR RESTAURANT PARTNERS IS A
00:46:49.773 --> 00:46:51.575
VERY IMPORTANT ONE NO BETTER
00:46:51.642 --> 00:46:52.576
HIGHLIGHTED BY THE WORKER
00:46:52.643 --> 00:46:54.311
COMPANIES HAVE DONE. FOR THE
00:46:54.378 --> 00:46:56.280
INDUSTRY DURING THE COLD BUT
00:46:56.346 --> 00:46:57.648
NINETEEN CRISIS AND WE WANT TO
00:46:57.714 --> 00:46:58.849
ENSURE THE BILL WILL BENEFIT
00:46:58.916 --> 00:47:00.918
THE INDUSTRY AS A WHOLE THANK
00:47:00.984 --> 00:47:05.889
YOU. THANK. YOU VERY MUCH ARE
00:47:05.956 --> 00:47:06.456
THERE ADDITIONAL. IN THE- IN
00:47:06.523 --> 00:47:10.527
ALL. TO THE BILL. AND IF
00:47:10.594 --> 00:47:11.762
THERE'S ANYONE WHO WOULD LIKE
00:47:11.828 --> 00:47:13.931
TO MAKE A COMMENT IN OPPOSITION
00:47:13.997 --> 00:47:16.867
TO THE BILL PLEASE AT ONE AND
00:47:16.934 --> 00:47:21.672
ZERO. AND ONE MOMENT AFFECTS
00:47:21.738 --> 00:47:29.346
COMMON. THANK YOU FOR YOUR
00:47:29.413 --> 00:47:55.973
PATIENCE SHARKS. YEAH. WE HAVE
00:47:56.039 --> 00:47:57.908
A COMMENT FROM SAMANTHA CORBIN
00:47:57.975 --> 00:48:01.478
PLEASE CLAN. WHAT THE COURT ON
00:48:01.545 --> 00:48:02.679
BEHALF OF THE ELECTRONIC
00:48:02.746 --> 00:48:04.648
FRONTIER FOUNDATION I'D LIKE TO
00:48:04.715 --> 00:48:06.283
THINK THE AUTHOR FOR HER WORK
00:48:06.350 --> 00:48:07.050
HE WOULD NEED AND THAT THEIR
00:48:07.117 --> 00:48:09.286
CONCERNS RELATED TO PRIVACY IN
00:48:09.353 --> 00:48:10.087
THE MEASURE WITH HER AMENDMENTS
00:48:10.153 --> 00:48:11.788
TODAY WE DO HAVE SOME
00:48:11.855 --> 00:48:14.491
OUTSTANDING CONCERNS ALREADY
00:48:14.558 --> 00:48:15.459
ACCUMULATED BY COLLEAGUES.
00:48:15.525 --> 00:48:17.127
OBVIOUSLY AND WE LOOK FORWARD
00:48:17.194 --> 00:48:17.961
TO WORKING ON THE ISSUES WITH
00:48:18.028 --> 00:48:20.397
THE OFFERING JUDICIARY. THANK
00:48:20.464 --> 00:48:26.670
YOU. THERE ARE NO FURTHER
00:48:26.737 --> 00:48:28.672
COMMENT THANK YOU IF THERE ARE
00:48:28.739 --> 00:48:30.474
NO FURTHER COMMENTS PLEASE-
00:48:30.540 --> 00:48:32.175
LET'S BRING IT BACK TO THE
00:48:32.242 --> 00:48:32.676
COMMUNITY FOR QUESTIONS
00:48:32.743 --> 00:48:34.811
COMMENTS. MR OBERNOLTE GO
00:48:34.878 --> 00:48:36.947
AHEAD. THANK YOU MISTER
00:48:37.014 --> 00:48:38.715
CHAIRMAN OF THIS IS A- AN
00:48:38.782 --> 00:48:40.284
INTERESTING BILL OBVIOUSLY KIND
00:48:40.350 --> 00:48:41.585
OF A NEW SITUATION WITH A DATE
00:48:41.652 --> 00:48:42.686
AMICK BETWEEN FOOD DELIVERY
00:48:42.753 --> 00:48:44.655
PLATFORMS AND RESTAURANTS. BUT
00:48:44.721 --> 00:48:46.623
NOT A NEW ISSUE AT ALL I MEAN
00:48:46.690 --> 00:48:48.625
WE HAVE A- HUNDRED YEARS OF
00:48:48.692 --> 00:48:51.628
CASE LAW WHERE- MANUFACTURES OR
00:48:51.695 --> 00:48:53.063
WHOLESALERS HAVE YOU KNOW WHICH
00:48:53.130 --> 00:48:54.264
IS THE RATE OF THE RESTAURANT
00:48:54.331 --> 00:48:55.799
IN THIS CASE HAVE DISPUTES WITH
00:48:55.866 --> 00:48:58.635
DISTRIBUTORS OF PRODUCTS. AND
00:48:58.702 --> 00:49:01.305
THE- FEDERAL LAW HAS HAS PRETTY
00:49:01.371 --> 00:49:03.106
NARROWLY CONSTRAIN THE ABILITY
00:49:03.173 --> 00:49:05.342
OF A MANUFACTURER WHOLESALER TO
00:49:05.409 --> 00:49:08.979
PUT. RESTRICTIONS ON THE- THE
00:49:09.046 --> 00:49:10.947
USE OF THEIR PRODUCTS BY PEOPLE
00:49:11.014 --> 00:49:12.916
FURTHER DOWN THE VALUE CHAIN SO
00:49:12.983 --> 00:49:14.184
I'D I'D START OUT WITH A LITTLE
00:49:14.251 --> 00:49:16.053
BIT OF SKEPTICISM. I THINK THE
00:49:16.119 --> 00:49:18.388
PRIVACY. IMPLICATIONS OF THE
00:49:18.455 --> 00:49:19.756
BILL ARE VERY INTERESTING AND I
00:49:19.823 --> 00:49:20.557
HAD TWO QUESTIONS RELATED
00:49:20.624 --> 00:49:21.958
QUESTIONS LASSEN BOTH THE SAME
00:49:22.025 --> 00:49:23.427
TIME AND BE INTERESTED TO HEAR
00:49:23.493 --> 00:49:25.228
YOUR RESPONSE SO THE FIRST OF
00:49:25.295 --> 00:49:27.964
THEM IS THAT- THE BILL AS
00:49:28.031 --> 00:49:29.199
AMENDED. WE PROHIBITS A FOOD
00:49:29.266 --> 00:49:30.934
DELIVERY PLATFORM FROM USING
00:49:31.001 --> 00:49:32.302
THE MENU OR THE LOCAL
00:49:32.369 --> 00:49:33.270
RESTAURANT WITHOUT THEIR
00:49:33.337 --> 00:49:34.871
PERMISSION. SO KIND OF TWO
00:49:34.938 --> 00:49:36.573
DIFFERENT ISSUES IN MY OPINION
00:49:36.640 --> 00:49:38.742
SO THE MENU- IS AN INTERESTING
00:49:38.809 --> 00:49:40.110
CASE BECAUSE THAT'S SOMETHING
00:49:40.177 --> 00:49:42.179
THAT'S ALREADY BEING. PUT OUT
00:49:42.245 --> 00:49:43.513
FOR PUBLIC CONSUMPTION BY THE
00:49:43.580 --> 00:49:45.382
RESTAURANT ITSELF SO IT'S
00:49:45.449 --> 00:49:46.383
ALREADY IN THE PUBLIC DOMAIN
00:49:46.450 --> 00:49:47.451
IT'S NOT SOMETHING THAT'S
00:49:47.517 --> 00:49:48.552
PRIVATE INFORMATION OF THE
00:49:48.618 --> 00:49:51.455
RESTAURANT- SO MY QUESTION IS
00:49:51.521 --> 00:49:52.356
HOW IS THAT NOT FAIR USE
00:49:52.422 --> 00:49:54.558
BECAUSE MIDDLE OF LARGE BODY OF
00:49:54.624 --> 00:49:55.826
CASE LAW THAT SAYS THAT THAT.
00:49:55.892 --> 00:49:57.427
THE GENERALLY THAT'S FAIR USE
00:49:57.494 --> 00:49:59.329
WITH CAN YOU YOUR PUTTING YOU
00:49:59.396 --> 00:50:00.163
REDISTRIBUTE SOMETHING THAT
00:50:00.230 --> 00:50:01.465
ALREADY HAS BEEN PUT OUT IN THE
00:50:01.531 --> 00:50:02.833
PUBLIC DOMAIN BY SOMEONE. AND
00:50:02.899 --> 00:50:04.501
THEN RELATED QUESTION ON THE
00:50:04.568 --> 00:50:06.636
LOGO. LOGO IS KIND OF A
00:50:06.703 --> 00:50:07.237
DIFFERENT ISSUE THAT'S THAT'S
00:50:07.304 --> 00:50:08.372
UNDER COPYRIGHT LAW WHICH IS
00:50:08.438 --> 00:50:10.640
FEDERAL LAW SO- YOU KNOW
00:50:10.707 --> 00:50:12.142
FEDERAL COPYRIGHT LAWS GOVERNS
00:50:12.209 --> 00:50:13.243
THE USE OF THAT LOOK AT WHETHER
00:50:13.310 --> 00:50:13.910
OR NOT IT'S FAIR USE NOT
00:50:13.977 --> 00:50:16.546
WONDERING HOW. THAT FEDERAL
00:50:16.613 --> 00:50:19.015
LAWS NOT PREEMPTIVE OF ANY KIND
00:50:19.082 --> 00:50:21.251
OF A TEMPLATE THAT WE MAKE HERE
00:50:21.318 --> 00:50:22.586
AT THE STATE LEVEL TO. RESTRICT
00:50:22.652 --> 00:50:25.288
THE USE OF THE LOOK THOSE LONG.
00:50:25.355 --> 00:50:26.923
SO THE FOR. FIRST OF ALL I
00:50:26.990 --> 00:50:27.724
THINK THE WAY THAT YOU'RE
00:50:27.791 --> 00:50:31.595
THINKING OF IT MOM IS- LIKE THE
00:50:31.661 --> 00:50:33.463
MANUFACTURE TO THE DELIVERY YES
00:50:33.530 --> 00:50:34.731
THIS I KIND OF A UNIQUE
00:50:34.798 --> 00:50:35.932
SITUATION THAT WE'RE TALKING
00:50:35.999 --> 00:50:38.168
ABOUT PREPARED HOT FOOD SO
00:50:38.235 --> 00:50:39.069
COULD BE THOUGHT IN A
00:50:39.136 --> 00:50:40.203
COMPLETELY DIFFERENT WAY WHAT'S
00:50:40.270 --> 00:50:42.105
HAPPENING RIGHT NOW THERE'S NO
00:50:42.172 --> 00:50:43.673
AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE DELIVERY
00:50:43.740 --> 00:50:45.175
DRIVER IN THE RESTAURANT IS A
00:50:45.242 --> 00:50:46.943
DELIVERY COMPANY IS ACTUALLY
00:50:47.010 --> 00:50:48.812
PURCHASING FOOD AND RESELLING
00:50:48.879 --> 00:50:51.548
IT TO THE CUSTOMER. THAT I
00:50:51.615 --> 00:50:53.316
THINK EVEN IN EXISTING LAW
00:50:53.383 --> 00:50:55.085
COULD CREATE OTHER ISSUES WHEN
00:50:55.152 --> 00:50:56.186
YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT SURVIVAL
00:50:56.253 --> 00:50:58.455
FOOD- AND SO WE'RE NOT TALKING
00:50:58.522 --> 00:51:01.224
ABOUT A WIDGET OR OR AN ITEM
00:51:01.291 --> 00:51:02.793
RIGHT IN THE SALE OF IT WE'RE
00:51:02.859 --> 00:51:04.261
TALKING SPECIFICALLY ABOUT
00:51:04.327 --> 00:51:06.596
PREPARED FOOD- AS FAR AS THE
00:51:06.663 --> 00:51:08.632
MENU GOES THE PROBLEM WITH
00:51:08.698 --> 00:51:11.234
HAVING AN INTERMEDIARY- SUCH AS
00:51:11.301 --> 00:51:13.370
THE DELIVERY BERNIE. OUT AN
00:51:13.437 --> 00:51:14.504
AGREEMENT IS WHEN THE
00:51:14.571 --> 00:51:16.072
RESTAURANT NO LONGER USES THAT
00:51:16.139 --> 00:51:18.442
MANUAL- THERE'S NO WAY FOR THE
00:51:18.508 --> 00:51:19.709
RESTAURANT TO TELL THE CUSTOMER
00:51:19.776 --> 00:51:21.411
THAT BECAUSE THE CUSTOMERS NOT
00:51:21.478 --> 00:51:23.280
DIRECTLY CONTACTING THE
00:51:23.346 --> 00:51:24.481
RESTAURANT IN THE RESTAURANT IS
00:51:24.548 --> 00:51:27.918
NOT SOMETIMES EVEN KNOWING THAT
00:51:27.984 --> 00:51:29.586
EIGHT DELIVERY COMPANY IS OUT
00:51:29.653 --> 00:51:32.756
THERE- DEAN OLD BANYA. AS SO
00:51:32.823 --> 00:51:35.192
CUSTOMER I SEE THIS HAVE NO
00:51:35.258 --> 00:51:37.360
IDEA THAT THIS RESTAURANT HAS
00:51:37.427 --> 00:51:39.830
NO RELATIONSHIP WITH THE
00:51:39.896 --> 00:51:42.632
DELIVERY COMPANY BECAUSE ARE
00:51:42.699 --> 00:51:43.366
YOU THERE YET GO FOR INSTANCE
00:51:43.433 --> 00:51:47.070
IN THERE IS A- SHIP BETWEEN THE
00:51:47.137 --> 00:51:49.039
TWO COMPANIES I MAY. HE WRAP
00:51:49.105 --> 00:51:51.808
ALL. AND IN BECAUSE SOME OF
00:51:51.875 --> 00:51:53.310
RESTAURANTS BUSINESS IS ALSO
00:51:53.376 --> 00:51:55.979
DRIVEN BY THINGS LIKE YELP AND
00:51:56.046 --> 00:51:58.482
THAT YOU KNOW CRITICISM I'M A
00:51:58.548 --> 00:51:59.883
CUSTOMER I ORDER SOMETHING THAT
00:51:59.950 --> 00:52:01.485
I ASSUME IS ON THE MENU BECAUSE
00:52:01.551 --> 00:52:03.086
THAT'S A MAN YOU THAT HAS BEEN
00:52:03.153 --> 00:52:04.721
GIVEN TO ME IT'S NOT I'M NOT
00:52:04.788 --> 00:52:06.289
TOLD THAT WHEN I ORDER IT IN
00:52:06.356 --> 00:52:08.124
FACT I'M NOT TOLD THAT TOOK
00:52:08.191 --> 00:52:09.159
THREE HOURS LATER WHEN MY
00:52:09.226 --> 00:52:11.094
DELIVERY DOESN'T COM AND THEN I
00:52:11.161 --> 00:52:13.730
GO ON AND EIGHT NEGATIVE
00:52:13.797 --> 00:52:16.566
COMMENT ON YELP AFFECTS THAT
00:52:16.633 --> 00:52:18.768
BUSINESSES. BUSINESS EVEN
00:52:18.835 --> 00:52:20.136
THOUGH THEY HAD NOTHING TO DO
00:52:20.203 --> 00:52:22.005
WITH THIS ENTIRE DISSEMINATION
00:52:22.072 --> 00:52:23.373
THIS IS HAPPENING OVER AND OVER
00:52:23.440 --> 00:52:24.941
AGAIN SO I THINK WE'RE ENTERING
00:52:25.008 --> 00:52:28.245
INTO INTO A NEW. TYPE OF- FAIR
00:52:28.311 --> 00:52:29.913
BUSINESS PRACTICE GOING ON AND
00:52:29.980 --> 00:52:32.449
SO I THINK TO LOOK AT IT AND
00:52:32.516 --> 00:52:33.517
KIND OF THAT NARAL OLD
00:52:33.583 --> 00:52:35.785
MANUFACTURE VERSES SELLER IT IS
00:52:35.852 --> 00:52:38.722
A LITTLE LIMITED- AND THAT'S-
00:52:38.788 --> 00:52:40.323
THE I THINK THE MAIN CREST. I
00:52:40.390 --> 00:52:42.292
WOULD GO THE CALIFORNIA
00:52:42.359 --> 00:52:44.227
RESTAURANT ASSOCIATION SAYS THE
00:52:44.294 --> 00:52:45.562
COPYRIGHT LAWS AREN'T WORKING.
00:52:45.629 --> 00:52:47.497
AND SO WE DON'T KNOW IF THEY
00:52:47.564 --> 00:52:49.533
WOULD BE- FEDERALLY PREEMPTED
00:52:49.599 --> 00:52:50.734
BUT THEY'RE CERTAINLY NOT
00:52:50.800 --> 00:52:52.302
WORKING FOR THESE RESTAURANTS.
00:52:52.369 --> 00:52:54.938
THANK YOU ARE SO THE IT IS TRUE
00:52:55.005 --> 00:52:55.805
THAT THIS IS AN ENGINE
00:52:55.872 --> 00:52:57.507
INTERESTING A NEW SITUATION BUT
00:52:57.574 --> 00:52:58.475
TO THE EXTENT THAT THERE ARE
00:52:58.542 --> 00:53:00.076
UNIQUE ELEMENTS. THAT ARE
00:53:00.143 --> 00:53:02.913
BROUGHT. BY THE FACT THAT THIS
00:53:02.979 --> 00:53:04.781
IS WHAT THE PROVISION OF FOOD I
00:53:04.848 --> 00:53:05.849
THINK THOSE ARE MIGHT MIGHT BE
00:53:05.916 --> 00:53:07.350
HEALTH AND SAFETY CONCERNS ME
00:53:07.417 --> 00:53:08.018
TO THE EXTENT THAT WE'RE
00:53:08.084 --> 00:53:09.386
TALKING ABOUT YOU KNOW FOR LIKE
00:53:09.452 --> 00:53:11.087
FAIR USE AND COPYRIGHT LAW. I
00:53:11.154 --> 00:53:12.055
THINK THE ISSUES REALLY AREN'T
00:53:12.122 --> 00:53:13.456
NEW ISSUES AND YOU KNOW FAIR
00:53:13.523 --> 00:53:14.658
USE HAS DEALT WITH THIS ISSUE
00:53:14.724 --> 00:53:16.092
BEFORE YOU BROUGHT UP THE ISSUE
00:53:16.159 --> 00:53:17.594
OF. WHAT HAPPENS OF THE MENU
00:53:17.661 --> 00:53:19.930
HAS CHANGED. AND THAT'S ALSO A
00:53:19.996 --> 00:53:21.464
FAIR USE ISSUE BECAUSE I MEAN
00:53:21.531 --> 00:53:23.967
WHAT IF I I'M A BLOGGER AND I
00:53:24.034 --> 00:53:25.068
REPOST SOMETHING THAT THE NEW
00:53:25.135 --> 00:53:26.703
YORK TIMES.I HAD AN ARTICLE
00:53:26.770 --> 00:53:28.438
THIS MORNING AND SUBSEQUENTLY
00:53:28.505 --> 00:53:30.206
THE NEW YORK TIMES. DISCOVERS
00:53:30.273 --> 00:53:31.441
AN ACCURACY IN THE ARTICLE NAY
00:53:31.508 --> 00:53:33.043
UPDATED AND I HAVEN'T UPDATED
00:53:33.109 --> 00:53:34.311
MY BLOG IT'S EXACTLY THE SAME
00:53:34.377 --> 00:53:37.881
SITUATION AND YET THAT. THAT'S
00:53:37.948 --> 00:53:40.216
CONSIDERED FAIR USE IN AND JUST
00:53:40.283 --> 00:53:41.818
TO DO THAT WE OFFER. A LOT OF
00:53:41.885 --> 00:53:43.386
WORKING WITH THE- DOESN'T. THE
00:53:43.453 --> 00:53:44.888
MATERIALITY OF WHETHER OR NOT
00:53:44.955 --> 00:53:47.791
WE CAN PREEMPTED BY PASSING A
00:53:47.857 --> 00:53:48.959
ROW SEAT VERSIONS SO I JUST
00:53:49.025 --> 00:53:50.560
HAVE A BIG CONCERNS ABOUT THAT
00:53:50.627 --> 00:53:51.962
I THINK. WHEN THE DUST SETTLES
00:53:52.028 --> 00:53:53.063
WE'RE GOING TO DISCOVER THAT
00:53:53.129 --> 00:53:54.631
THESE ARE ALL ISSUES THAT HAVE
00:53:54.698 --> 00:53:56.366
BEEN LITIGATED ENDLESSLY BEFORE
00:53:56.433 --> 00:53:58.501
AND WE'VE GOT TO FIGURE OUT A
00:53:58.568 --> 00:53:59.336
WAY OF FITTING HAND. SOLUTIONS
00:53:59.402 --> 00:54:02.606
TO THE YOU PROBLEM INTO WORK OF
00:54:02.672 --> 00:54:06.810
WHAT'S BEFORE AND I'M NOT. WHAT
00:54:06.876 --> 00:54:08.044
WE ARE HERE YOU KNOW RISE THAT.
00:54:08.111 --> 00:54:10.246
BUT I ENCOURAGE YOU TO WORKING
00:54:10.313 --> 00:54:12.182
OUT AND I'LL BE. BACK FOR.
00:54:12.248 --> 00:54:14.050
THANK THE YOU MUCH EITHER AT
00:54:14.117 --> 00:54:15.685
THIS KINDS QUESTIONS. BASIC I
00:54:15.752 --> 00:54:18.555
TO GO. I'M QUESTION EITHER FOR
00:54:18.622 --> 00:54:20.223
THE AUTHOR OR PERHAPS FOR THE-
00:54:20.290 --> 00:54:22.759
RESTAURANT ASSOCIATION- SO WHAT
00:54:22.826 --> 00:54:24.527
ARE THE ACTUAL COUPLE QUESTIONS
00:54:24.594 --> 00:54:25.729
AND WHAT'S THE ABILITY UNDER
00:54:25.795 --> 00:54:27.964
EXISTING LAW FOR A RESTAURANT
00:54:28.031 --> 00:54:29.866
THAT DOESN'T WANT THAT THESE
00:54:29.933 --> 00:54:33.436
DELIVERY PLATFORMS- TO COME
00:54:33.503 --> 00:54:34.671
INTO THAT REST ESTABLISHMENT TO
00:54:34.738 --> 00:54:36.973
JUST SAY WE DON'T. ACCEPT
00:54:37.040 --> 00:54:37.874
DELIVERIES FROM COMPANY X. Y.
00:54:37.941 --> 00:54:43.113
Z. AND THEN RELATEDLY- IN CASES
00:54:43.179 --> 00:54:45.482
WHERE RESTAURANTS HAVE REACHED
00:54:45.548 --> 00:54:46.783
OUT TO THESE COMPANIES AND SAID
00:54:46.850 --> 00:54:48.451
WE DON'T WANT YOU TO LIST US ON
00:54:48.518 --> 00:54:50.120
YOUR PLATFORM WHAT IS THE
00:54:50.186 --> 00:54:51.454
RESPONSE GENERALLY BEEN TO THE
00:54:51.521 --> 00:54:56.926
AGREE OR THEY REFUSE. KILEY THE
00:54:56.993 --> 00:54:57.761
MAP BUTTON WITH THE RESTAURANT
00:54:57.827 --> 00:54:59.295
ASSOCIATION I APPRECIATE THE
00:54:59.362 --> 00:55:01.731
QUESTION- MISTER WILL NOT YEAR
00:55:01.798 --> 00:55:05.301
QUESTIONS AS WELL- REALLY WHAT
00:55:05.368 --> 00:55:07.537
WHAT THE ISSUE IS IT HERE AND
00:55:07.604 --> 00:55:08.905
CERTAINLY NO MENUS TO THE
00:55:08.972 --> 00:55:10.273
PREVIOUS QUESTION MENUS. ARE
00:55:10.340 --> 00:55:13.009
OUT IN PUBLIC- ADMITS GONZALEZ
00:55:13.076 --> 00:55:15.078
STATED. THE USE OF THESE
00:55:15.145 --> 00:55:17.147
MATERIALS WITHOUT CONSENT TO
00:55:17.213 --> 00:55:17.781
JEFF THAT THERE'S A
00:55:17.847 --> 00:55:19.282
RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN OUR
00:55:19.349 --> 00:55:20.984
RESTAURANTS AND THE- THIRD
00:55:21.051 --> 00:55:22.952
PARTY ENTITIES WHICH IN MANY OF
00:55:23.019 --> 00:55:24.921
THESE CASES IS NOT ACCURATE.
00:55:24.988 --> 00:55:25.922
AND IT MATTERS FOR A NUMBER OF
00:55:25.989 --> 00:55:28.058
REASONS ONE OF THE REASONS IS
00:55:28.124 --> 00:55:29.893
WE'RE SERVING PREPARED FOOD. WE
00:55:29.959 --> 00:55:32.128
ARE REGULATED RIGHTFULLY SO BY
00:55:32.195 --> 00:55:33.630
LOCAL HEALTH DEPARTMENT ABOUT
00:55:33.697 --> 00:55:36.499
THE CONDITION THAT SUIT. IN
00:55:36.566 --> 00:55:38.601
THESE CASES WE HAVE NO IDEA OF
00:55:38.668 --> 00:55:39.736
THE CHAIN OF CUSTODY OF THE
00:55:39.803 --> 00:55:42.372
FOOD AND SO IT BECOMES VERY
00:55:42.439 --> 00:55:47.944
IMPORTANT ISSUE. COMMUNITY ALSO.
00:55:48.011 --> 00:55:49.512
AT THE RELATED TO PAIR. FOOD
00:55:49.579 --> 00:55:51.214
AND OUR NEED. TO KNOW AND WHO
00:55:51.281 --> 00:55:53.116
IS THIS IT. WITHOUT CONSENT OF
00:55:53.183 --> 00:55:54.217
OUR PRODUCTS ON THE WEB. WE
00:55:54.284 --> 00:55:56.453
DON'T KNOW THAT. MR KILEY IT
00:55:56.519 --> 00:55:58.922
TENDS TO BE A LARGER ISSUE WITH
00:55:58.988 --> 00:55:59.789
THE SMALLER INDEPENDENT
00:55:59.856 --> 00:56:01.458
RESTAURANT AND WE HAVE HEARD
00:56:01.524 --> 00:56:03.493
REPEATEDLY FOR YEARS. WITH AN
00:56:03.560 --> 00:56:05.628
UPTICK IN COMPLAINT LATELY THAT
00:56:05.695 --> 00:56:07.964
THEY DO TRY TO SOLVE THIS ONE
00:56:08.031 --> 00:56:09.699
ON ONE WITH THIRD PARTY ENTITY.
00:56:09.766 --> 00:56:11.668
THIRD PARTY ENTITY USUALLY
00:56:11.735 --> 00:56:13.403
RESPONSE WITH SOME SORT OF IT'S
00:56:13.470 --> 00:56:15.171
A CLERICAL ERROR WILL FIX IT
00:56:15.238 --> 00:56:16.206
AND THAT THAT THE GENERALLY
00:56:16.272 --> 00:56:17.674
HAPPENS IN SO THE SMALLER
00:56:17.741 --> 00:56:19.042
RESTAURANTS THAT DON'T HAVE THE
00:56:19.109 --> 00:56:21.411
LEVERAGE. OF THE LARGER CHAIN
00:56:21.478 --> 00:56:23.246
RESTAURANTS. HAVE LET THE BILL
00:56:23.313 --> 00:56:25.181
OF THE SORT OF. YOU KNOW MUSCLE
00:56:25.248 --> 00:56:27.383
THEIR WAY THROUGH. AND SO IT
00:56:27.450 --> 00:56:29.085
ENDS UP BEING. THE CREW BUT THE
00:56:29.152 --> 00:56:31.287
SMALLER INDEPENDENT RESTAURANTS
00:56:31.354 --> 00:56:33.256
HAVE JUMPED THROUGH. OP NOTE
00:56:33.323 --> 00:56:35.391
THAT. DAMAGE TO THEIR BRAND.
00:56:35.458 --> 00:56:38.995
AND QUESTIONABLE PRACTICES WITH
00:56:39.062 --> 00:56:39.596
THEIR FOOD. I GUESS THE FLIP
00:56:39.662 --> 00:56:44.100
SIDE OF THAT MIGHT. IT WOULD
00:56:44.167 --> 00:56:47.570
BE. MORE LIKELY TO- AGREED TO
00:56:47.637 --> 00:56:50.206
HAVE THEIR- INFORMATION ON
00:56:50.273 --> 00:56:51.741
ESTABLISHED PLATFORM SO THAT
00:56:51.808 --> 00:56:53.476
COULD LEAD TO HIGHER BARRIERS
00:56:53.543 --> 00:56:56.012
TO ENTRY IN THE DELIVERY MARKET
00:56:56.079 --> 00:57:00.350
DO YOU SEE THAT AS A PROBLEM.
00:57:00.416 --> 00:57:02.452
WITH ALL DUE RESPECT MISTER
00:57:02.519 --> 00:57:02.919
KELLY I'M NOT TOTALLY
00:57:02.986 --> 00:57:04.854
UNDERSTANDING THE QUESTION.
00:57:04.921 --> 00:57:06.322
WELL I MEAN IF THIS PASSES AND
00:57:06.389 --> 00:57:07.390
YOU HAVE TO GET EXPRESS
00:57:07.457 --> 00:57:08.691
PERMISSION THEN IT SEEMS LIKELY
00:57:08.758 --> 00:57:09.893
THAT RESTAURANTS WILL BE MORE
00:57:09.959 --> 00:57:10.927
LIKELY TO GRANTED TECH
00:57:10.994 --> 00:57:11.995
COMPANIES WE'VE ALL HEARD OF
00:57:12.061 --> 00:57:13.897
LIKE A GROUNDHOG OR WHAT HAVE
00:57:13.963 --> 00:57:15.765
YOU- SO THAT COULD BE A BARRIER
00:57:15.832 --> 00:57:17.167
TO ENTRY FOR LESS ESTABLISH
00:57:17.233 --> 00:57:18.935
DELIVERY COMPANIES WHO AREN'T
00:57:19.002 --> 00:57:21.104
ABLE TO. I HAVE A WIDER
00:57:21.171 --> 00:57:23.907
SELECTION AVAILABLE. I WOULD
00:57:23.973 --> 00:57:25.575
ARGUE JUST THE OPPOSITE
00:57:25.642 --> 00:57:27.644
ACTUALLY I'M SORRY- I WOULD ASK
00:57:27.710 --> 00:57:28.511
YOU TO IT'S JUST THE OPPOSITE
00:57:28.578 --> 00:57:29.913
THIS WILL. ACTUALLY ALLOW THE
00:57:29.979 --> 00:57:31.648
MARKET TO WORK ACCORDINGLY
00:57:31.714 --> 00:57:33.917
BECAUSE- THE BIG CARRIERS ARE
00:57:33.983 --> 00:57:37.153
TAKING A LARGE PERCENTAGE. OF
00:57:37.220 --> 00:57:38.421
THE OVERALL BILL FROM THESE
00:57:38.488 --> 00:57:40.690
RESTAURANTS WHERE A SMALLER NEW
00:57:40.757 --> 00:57:42.091
START UP COMPANY COULD COME IN
00:57:42.158 --> 00:57:43.560
AND OFFER FAR LASSEN BECAUSE
00:57:43.626 --> 00:57:44.561
IT'S A WRITTEN CONTRACT AND
00:57:44.627 --> 00:57:45.995
THAT'S WELL ESTABLISHED BEFORE
00:57:46.062 --> 00:57:47.497
HAND. IT PROVIDES OPPORTUNITY
00:57:47.564 --> 00:57:51.100
FOR THE MARKET TO WORK. SO THAT
00:57:51.167 --> 00:57:52.202
THAT'S IN CASES WHERE THERE
00:57:52.268 --> 00:57:53.403
ACTUALLY AGREEING TO PAY THE
00:57:53.469 --> 00:57:54.838
RESTAURANT RIGHT SO THERE IS BY
00:57:54.904 --> 00:57:55.972
DEFINITION RT PERMISSIONS FROM
00:57:56.039 --> 00:57:57.774
GRANT. WELL THAT THAT WHAT
00:57:57.841 --> 00:57:59.642
HAPPENS IS RESTAURANTS GET PUT
00:57:59.709 --> 00:58:00.910
IN POSITION SPECIALLY SMALL
00:58:00.977 --> 00:58:02.312
RESTAURANTS OF STARTING OUT BE
00:58:02.378 --> 00:58:03.880
LISTED WITHOUT THEIR CONSENT.
00:58:03.947 --> 00:58:05.081
AND THEN THEIR CUSTOMERS BEING
00:58:05.148 --> 00:58:07.650
RELIANT ON THESE- DELIVERY
00:58:07.717 --> 00:58:10.286
PLATFORMS WITH EIGHTY AT IT AND
00:58:10.353 --> 00:58:10.954
THEN THE DELIVERY PLATFORM
00:58:11.020 --> 00:58:12.589
COMES TO THE RESTAURANT. IN
00:58:12.655 --> 00:58:14.724
ALMOST NOT COURSE THE FASHION-
00:58:14.791 --> 00:58:17.227
REQUIRES THE RESTAURANT TO BUY
00:58:17.293 --> 00:58:20.029
IN. TO THEIR PERCENTAGE BEING
00:58:20.096 --> 00:58:21.364
TAKEN OR TO TAKE THEIR
00:58:21.431 --> 00:58:22.799
CUSTOMERS ELSEWHERE THIS IS
00:58:22.866 --> 00:58:25.301
WHERE- UNFORTUNATELY KIND OF
00:58:25.368 --> 00:58:27.103
THIS BIG BUSINESS HAS IT HAS
00:58:27.170 --> 00:58:28.504
CORRUPTED ON THE ABILITY OF
00:58:28.571 --> 00:58:29.939
SMALL RESTAURANTS TO HAVE THE
00:58:30.006 --> 00:58:33.176
DECISION. SO IT STARTS OFF AS-
00:58:33.243 --> 00:58:35.245
AT WITHOUT THEIR CONSENT AND
00:58:35.311 --> 00:58:36.746
THEN THE- COMPANY I DON'T WANNA
00:58:36.813 --> 00:58:37.981
NAY MANY OF THEM COME IN. AND
00:58:38.047 --> 00:58:39.749
SAY YOU NEEDS NOW AGREE TO THIS
00:58:39.816 --> 00:58:41.885
PERCENTAGE TO SIGNING UP FOR US
00:58:41.951 --> 00:58:43.586
AND THIS IS A PERCENTAGE WE'RE
00:58:43.653 --> 00:58:45.188
GOING TO TAKE. WE LEVEL THE
00:58:45.255 --> 00:58:46.756
PLAYING FIELD BY SAYING THAT'S
00:58:46.823 --> 00:58:47.757
UP FRONT IN THE BEGINNING DO
00:58:47.824 --> 00:58:49.425
YOU WANT TO SIGN ON IT NOT IT
00:58:49.492 --> 00:58:50.793
ALSO ALLOWS SMALL START UP
00:58:50.860 --> 00:58:52.662
COMPANIES TO SAY WE'RE OFFERING
00:58:52.729 --> 00:58:53.563
LESS IT ALSO ALLOWS THE
00:58:53.630 --> 00:58:55.098
RESTAURANT TO MAKE AN EDUCATED
00:58:55.164 --> 00:58:56.132
DECISION ABOUT WHETHER IT'S
00:58:56.199 --> 00:58:58.635
CHEAPER. OR MAKES MORE SENSE
00:58:58.701 --> 00:58:59.569
FOR THEIR OWN EMPLOYEES TO BE
00:58:59.636 --> 00:59:01.704
DELIVERING- THAT FOOD AT SOME
00:59:01.771 --> 00:59:03.139
RESTAURANT STILL STILL HAVE
00:59:03.206 --> 00:59:05.675
BEEN IN THIS- AT PANDEMIC
00:59:05.742 --> 00:59:07.010
ENVIRONMENT WHERE. A LOT OF
00:59:07.076 --> 00:59:08.177
RESTAURANTS HAVE CHOSEN TO DO
00:59:08.244 --> 00:59:10.346
THAT GOES INTO NOT. TO SIMPLY
00:59:10.413 --> 00:59:11.814
ALLOW TAKE OUT RATHER THAN
00:59:11.881 --> 00:59:13.850
DELIVERY AS A AS A WAY TO-
00:59:13.917 --> 00:59:16.052
INSURE THAT THERE'S SOME SORT
00:59:16.119 --> 00:59:17.987
OF QUALITY CONTROL. AND THAT
00:59:18.054 --> 00:59:19.656
WAS OUR SENATOR DID U. S. C. IS
00:59:19.722 --> 00:59:20.990
THERE AN ABILITY I JUST TO SAY
00:59:21.057 --> 00:59:22.959
WE- DON'T WANT THESE DELIVERY
00:59:23.026 --> 00:59:24.327
COMPANIES TO COME IN AND PICK
00:59:24.394 --> 00:59:25.495
UP FOOD FROM A RESTAURANT APART
00:59:25.561 --> 00:59:27.263
FROM WHETHER OR NOT THEIR
00:59:27.330 --> 00:59:27.830
INFORMATION IS LISTED ON THE
00:59:27.897 --> 00:59:33.403
PLATFORMS. YOUR MISTER KELLY I
00:59:33.469 --> 00:59:35.171
THINK ANY RESTAURANT COULD DENY
00:59:35.238 --> 00:59:37.941
SERVICE THAN IN ANY CONTACT-
00:59:38.007 --> 00:59:40.910
THE ISSUE HERE IS. THAT YOU
00:59:40.977 --> 00:59:42.412
KNOW THESE ORDERS THEY THEY
00:59:42.478 --> 00:59:43.880
COME IN A- NUMBER OF DIFFERENT
00:59:43.947 --> 00:59:46.049
WAYS. AND ALL MISS GONZALEZ IS
00:59:46.115 --> 00:59:47.483
ASKING FOR. WHICH WE
00:59:47.550 --> 00:59:50.186
APPRECIATE. IT SOME LEVEL OF
00:59:50.253 --> 00:59:52.322
CONSENT FROM THE RESTAURANT. SO
00:59:52.388 --> 00:59:54.757
THAT THE IMPLIED RELATIONSHIP
00:59:54.824 --> 00:59:58.261
TO THE PUBLIC. IS TRUE OR- IN
00:59:58.328 --> 00:59:59.996
MANY CASES WHICH MAKES THE
01:00:00.063 --> 01:00:02.598
PRICE PEOPLE THERE ARE A LOT OF
01:00:02.665 --> 01:00:03.733
INDEPENDENT RESTAURANT THAT
01:00:03.800 --> 01:00:05.668
ACTUALLY DO NOT. WANT HARD TO
01:00:05.735 --> 01:00:07.203
DELIVER IT THEIR PRODUCT MAY
01:00:07.270 --> 01:00:09.138
NOT LEND ITSELF WELL TO TRAVEL
01:00:09.205 --> 01:00:10.673
OR THEY MAY NOT JUST BE ABLE TO
01:00:10.740 --> 01:00:12.342
DO THE LOGISTICS OF IT OR THERE
01:00:12.408 --> 01:00:13.242
MAY BE A NUMBER ABOUT THE
01:00:13.309 --> 01:00:15.645
RECENT SO. THERE SEEMS TO BE
01:00:15.712 --> 01:00:16.913
DRIVING A CONVERSATION TO SOME
01:00:16.980 --> 01:00:18.948
DEGREE THE PRESUMPTION THAT
01:00:19.015 --> 01:00:21.017
RESTAURANT ONE OF THE LIST AND
01:00:21.084 --> 01:00:23.286
IN MANY CASES THEY DON'T AND SO
01:00:23.353 --> 01:00:25.588
WE'RE SIMPLY ASKING. FOR SOME
01:00:25.655 --> 01:00:29.559
FORMAL PROCESS. REALLY LOW FARE
01:00:29.625 --> 01:00:34.297
OF CONSENT. THANK YOU. THANK
01:00:34.364 --> 01:00:34.831
YOU VERY MUCH UP ANY OTHER
01:00:34.897 --> 01:00:37.567
QUESTIONS OKAY AND GO AHEAD.
01:00:37.633 --> 01:00:38.968
JUST A BRIEF COMMENT I JUST
01:00:39.035 --> 01:00:39.902
WANTED TO THANK THE AUTHOR FOR
01:00:39.969 --> 01:00:40.937
THIS BILL YOU KNOW IT'S A
01:00:41.004 --> 01:00:42.338
SINGLE ANECDOTE BUT IT HAPPENED
01:00:42.405 --> 01:00:43.539
TO A SMALL RESTAURANT THAT I
01:00:43.606 --> 01:00:46.175
LOVE. SIX OR SEAT RESTAURANT
01:00:46.242 --> 01:00:47.410
SIX TABLE RESTAURANT THEY
01:00:47.477 --> 01:00:48.511
COULDN'T HANDLE THE CAPACITY
01:00:48.578 --> 01:00:49.912
WHEN THIS HAPPENED TO THEM AND
01:00:49.979 --> 01:00:50.546
THEY DIDN'T KNOW WHAT WAS GOING
01:00:50.613 --> 01:00:52.015
ON AND THEY COULDN'T SERVE
01:00:52.081 --> 01:00:54.050
THEIR CLIENTELE IN THE WAY THEY
01:00:54.117 --> 01:00:54.617
WANTED AND THEY COULDN'T GET
01:00:54.684 --> 01:00:56.085
OUT OF IT. AND SO I THINK THIS
01:00:56.152 --> 01:00:57.220
IS A REAL PROBLEM THAT HER
01:00:57.286 --> 01:00:58.588
SMALL RESTAURANT SOMEWHERE IN A
01:00:58.654 --> 01:01:00.556
TIME WHERE WE AS A BODY NEEDS
01:01:00.623 --> 01:01:01.791
DO EVERYTHING WE CAN. TO GET
01:01:01.858 --> 01:01:03.259
RESTAURANTS BACK UP AND RUNNING
01:01:03.326 --> 01:01:04.660
IN A WAY THAT IS WORK FOR THEM
01:01:04.727 --> 01:01:09.465
AND WORK TO CAL. CAN THANK MUCH.
01:01:09.532 --> 01:01:12.902
A MISTER GOING AT FIRST I MEAN
01:01:12.969 --> 01:01:13.403
THINK THIS IS A REALLY
01:01:13.469 --> 01:01:16.172
IMPORTANT ISSUE ESPECIALLY IN
01:01:16.239 --> 01:01:19.308
THESE TIMES BECAUSE- IN DURING
01:01:19.375 --> 01:01:21.044
THIS COVERT NINETEEN CRISIS
01:01:21.110 --> 01:01:22.412
CERTAINLY RESTAURANTS HAVE BEEN
01:01:22.478 --> 01:01:25.648
IMPACTED GREATLY- BEAN. ONLY
01:01:25.715 --> 01:01:27.483
ABLE TO DO TAKE OUT AND
01:01:27.550 --> 01:01:29.986
DELIVERY- HAS BEEN A HUGE
01:01:30.053 --> 01:01:31.220
IMPACT TO THEM AND THEN MORE
01:01:31.287 --> 01:01:33.189
MORE PEOPLE ARE RELYING ON THE
01:01:33.256 --> 01:01:37.226
SERVICES- TO GET DELIVERIES YOU
01:01:37.293 --> 01:01:39.762
KNOW DURING THIS TIME SO. YOU
01:01:39.829 --> 01:01:41.097
KNOW THIS IS A HELPFUL TOOL OUT
01:01:41.164 --> 01:01:43.166
THERE THAT IS THAT IS COME UP
01:01:43.232 --> 01:01:45.201
IN SOCIETY IN THE MARKET. OF
01:01:45.268 --> 01:01:47.870
ALLOWING THESE. DELIVERIES AND
01:01:47.937 --> 01:01:49.705
I THINK IT HELPS YOU KNOW AND
01:01:49.772 --> 01:01:52.375
IT HELPS RESTAURANTS AND IT'S
01:01:52.442 --> 01:01:58.815
HELPS THE CONSUMER. BUT I MEAN
01:01:58.881 --> 01:02:00.750
I'VE IN LISTENING TO THE
01:02:00.817 --> 01:02:03.386
TESTIMONY HERE. IT IS NOW IN
01:02:03.453 --> 01:02:05.321
QUESTION- AND I THINK SOME OF
01:02:05.388 --> 01:02:06.155
THIS CAN BE DEALT WITH IN THE
01:02:06.222 --> 01:02:07.690
JUDICIARY COMMITTEE AS YOU AS
01:02:07.757 --> 01:02:09.058
YOU SUGGEST BECAUSE WE GET INTO
01:02:09.125 --> 01:02:10.893
SOME LEGAL ISSUES ABOUT
01:02:10.960 --> 01:02:13.496
COPYRIGHT LAW AND- SUCH A THOSE
01:02:13.563 --> 01:02:17.066
CAN BE HANDLED THERE- BUT IT IS
01:02:17.133 --> 01:02:19.235
INTERESTING TO THINK ABOUT- THE
01:02:19.302 --> 01:02:20.069
ON THE ONE HAND I THINK YOU
01:02:20.136 --> 01:02:22.472
MIGHT SAY. WHO WHO WHO WHO WHO
01:02:22.538 --> 01:02:24.507
WOULD NOT WANT FREE ADVERTISING
01:02:24.574 --> 01:02:26.609
RIGHT- THAT THERE'S A COMPANY
01:02:26.676 --> 01:02:27.810
OUT THERE IS GOING TO PUT YOUR
01:02:27.877 --> 01:02:29.712
BUSINESS'S NAME OUT THERE AND
01:02:29.779 --> 01:02:31.647
NOT CHARGE YOU FOR IT. IS NOT A
01:02:31.714 --> 01:02:34.450
GOOD THING FOR A BUSINESS. YEAH
01:02:34.517 --> 01:02:36.986
HOWEVER. AS BEEN POINT ON ON.
01:02:37.053 --> 01:02:38.788
THIS TESTIMONY IS SORT OF SUEDE
01:02:38.855 --> 01:02:41.424
MY- FEELINGS ON THIS IS OKAY
01:02:41.491 --> 01:02:42.758
WHAT IF YOU'RE NOT PREPARED FOR
01:02:42.825 --> 01:02:45.128
THOSE ORDERS RIGHT AND YOU AND
01:02:45.194 --> 01:02:46.729
YOU HAVEN'T HAD. THAT TIME AND
01:02:46.796 --> 01:02:48.898
THEN. SOMEBODY SUGGESTED WELL
01:02:48.965 --> 01:02:49.765
YOU COULD JUST SAY HEY WE'RE
01:02:49.832 --> 01:02:51.734
NOT GOING TO DEAL WITH YOU OKAY
01:02:51.801 --> 01:02:52.768
BUT NOW THAT CUSTOMER DOESN'T
01:02:52.835 --> 01:02:54.370
GET. THE PRODUCT THAT THEY
01:02:54.437 --> 01:02:55.705
THOUGHT THEY WERE GETTING AND
01:02:55.771 --> 01:02:56.539
THEY AND THEY WERE ASSUMING
01:02:56.606 --> 01:02:57.406
THERE WAS SOME SORT OF
01:02:57.473 --> 01:02:58.975
RELATIONSHIP WHO DOES THAT LOOK
01:02:59.041 --> 01:03:00.376
BAD ON. IT LOOKS BAD ON THE
01:03:00.443 --> 01:03:02.678
RESTAURANT. IT LOOKS BAD ON
01:03:02.745 --> 01:03:04.647
THE- DELIVERY COMPANY TO. BUT
01:03:04.714 --> 01:03:06.349
IT LOOKS BAD ON THE RESTAURANT.
01:03:06.415 --> 01:03:07.316
AS A THEY DIDN'T FOLLOW
01:03:07.383 --> 01:03:10.186
THROUGH- AND SO THAT AND THAT'S
01:03:10.253 --> 01:03:11.120
CERTAINLY NOT SOMETHING THAT
01:03:11.187 --> 01:03:15.158
THEY ASK FOR- AND- SO I THINK
01:03:15.224 --> 01:03:15.958
THAT IS A- AN IMPORTANT
01:03:16.025 --> 01:03:18.194
QUESTION AND- I'LL COME IN A
01:03:18.261 --> 01:03:19.295
LITTLE BIT ON WHAT'S NOT BEFORE
01:03:19.362 --> 01:03:22.532
US- BUT THAT. THE AUTHOR
01:03:22.598 --> 01:03:24.033
STARTED OUT WITH THIS OKAY WHO-
01:03:24.100 --> 01:03:26.469
WHO WHO'S- TUMORS ARE THESE.
01:03:26.536 --> 01:03:27.803
AND I THINK THAT'S AN IMPORTANT
01:03:27.870 --> 01:03:29.272
QUESTION FOR US I MEAN IT'S NOT
01:03:29.338 --> 01:03:31.073
BEFORE US YET BUT IT'S
01:03:31.140 --> 01:03:32.041
SOMETHING THAT THIS COMMITTEE
01:03:32.108 --> 01:03:34.810
SHOULD BE THINKING ABOUT. IS I
01:03:34.877 --> 01:03:36.579
THINK IN A LOT OF CASES IF
01:03:36.646 --> 01:03:37.580
YOU'RE IN YOUR HOME
01:03:37.647 --> 01:03:39.081
JURISDICTION I MEAN IF YOU'RE
01:03:39.148 --> 01:03:40.550
IN. YOUR YOUR PLACE OF
01:03:40.616 --> 01:03:42.485
RESIDENCE YOU ALREADY HAVE
01:03:42.552 --> 01:03:44.220
RESTAURANTS THAT YOU LIKE. AND
01:03:44.287 --> 01:03:45.555
YOU'RE ALREADY A CUSTOMER OF
01:03:45.621 --> 01:03:47.557
THAT RESTAURANT YOU MY ORDERS
01:03:47.623 --> 01:03:49.392
TO THESE- THROUGH THESE
01:03:49.458 --> 01:03:51.327
DELIVERIES TO GET THAT BUT TO
01:03:51.394 --> 01:03:53.429
ME THAT FEELS A LOT MORE LIKE
01:03:53.496 --> 01:03:56.365
YOU'RE ALREADY THEIR CUSTOMER-
01:03:56.432 --> 01:03:57.733
AND SO IT WOULD SEEM TO ME THAT
01:03:57.800 --> 01:04:00.503
BELONGS TO THE RESTAURANT-
01:04:00.570 --> 01:04:02.071
WHERE IT STARTS MOVING OUTWARD
01:04:02.138 --> 01:04:03.706
IS MAYBE. YOU'RE LOOKING FOR
01:04:03.773 --> 01:04:05.174
SOMETHING DIFFERENT. IT WILL
01:04:05.241 --> 01:04:07.777
THEN. DELIVERY COMPANIES GIVING
01:04:07.843 --> 01:04:08.678
YOU A LOT OF CHOICES THAT YOU
01:04:08.744 --> 01:04:10.746
CAN CHOOSE FROM MAYBE THE START
01:04:10.813 --> 01:04:11.581
TO BECOME MORE OF THEIR
01:04:11.647 --> 01:04:14.083
CUSTOMER AND IS THAT THEIR DATA
01:04:14.150 --> 01:04:16.586
AS OPPOSED TO THE RESTAURANTS-
01:04:16.652 --> 01:04:18.521
WHEN YOU GO WHEN YOU GO VISIT A
01:04:18.588 --> 01:04:19.622
LOCATION WHEN I GO DOWN TO SAN
01:04:19.689 --> 01:04:22.124
DIEGO. MAY FOR EXAMPLE AND I'M
01:04:22.191 --> 01:04:23.025
LIKE HEY WHERE'S A GOOD
01:04:23.092 --> 01:04:24.460
RESTAURANT I MIGHT USE ONE OF
01:04:24.527 --> 01:04:27.196
THESE APPS. TWO HEY RECOMMENDED
01:04:27.263 --> 01:04:29.899
ME A GOOD A GOOD PLACE TO GET.
01:04:29.966 --> 01:04:32.201
SOME GOOD FOOD RIGHT. THEN IT
01:04:32.268 --> 01:04:33.703
SEEMS LIKE IT'S MORE LIKE HEY
01:04:33.769 --> 01:04:34.270
THIS IS A SERVICE THEY ARE
01:04:34.337 --> 01:04:36.539
PROVIDING A MUSEUM MORE THERE
01:04:36.606 --> 01:04:38.975
SO IT IS. NO THERE IS SOME
01:04:39.041 --> 01:04:40.042
INTERESTING QUESTIONS THAT WE
01:04:40.109 --> 01:04:44.614
GOT TO DELVE INTO. AND AGAIN
01:04:44.680 --> 01:04:45.214
THIS IS A USEFUL TOOL WE DON'T
01:04:45.281 --> 01:04:50.920
WANT TO. UNDULY BURDEN IT. BUT
01:04:50.987 --> 01:04:53.456
YOU KNOW IT WOULD SEEM THAT
01:04:53.522 --> 01:04:54.090
THERE NEEDS TO BE AT LEAST SOME
01:04:54.156 --> 01:04:55.825
KIND OF. RELATIONSHIP
01:04:55.891 --> 01:04:57.960
ABOLISHED. BETWEEN THE
01:04:58.027 --> 01:04:59.395
RESTAURANT AND THE SERVICE
01:04:59.462 --> 01:05:00.663
AHEAD OF TIME AND I THINK
01:05:00.730 --> 01:05:02.331
THAT'S- I THINK THAT'S WHERE
01:05:02.398 --> 01:05:06.102
THIS BILL IS HEADING SO. AND I
01:05:06.168 --> 01:05:07.136
THINK WE NEED A WE DO ARE THERE
01:05:07.203 --> 01:05:08.304
ARE LEGAL ISSUES ARE GOING
01:05:08.371 --> 01:05:10.339
AFTER ADDRESS BUT I THINK THOSE
01:05:10.406 --> 01:05:10.873
COULD BE ADDRESSED IN THE
01:05:10.940 --> 01:05:13.776
JUDICIARY COMMITTEE. THANK YOU
01:05:13.843 --> 01:05:14.744
VERY MUCH IF THERE ARE NO
01:05:14.810 --> 01:05:16.579
FURTHER QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS I
01:05:16.646 --> 01:05:17.780
WANT TO THANK THE ASSEMBLY
01:05:17.847 --> 01:05:20.082
MEMBER AND HER TEAM FOR. THE
01:05:20.149 --> 01:05:21.384
WORK THAT YOU PUT INTO THIS
01:05:21.450 --> 01:05:24.487
BILL. AS WELL AS- THE AGREEMENT
01:05:24.553 --> 01:05:26.055
TO REMOVE THE TOP PORTION OF
01:05:26.122 --> 01:05:27.023
THE BILL. THAT DEALT WITH
01:05:27.089 --> 01:05:28.791
PRIVACY WHICH PRESENTS SOME
01:05:28.858 --> 01:05:30.526
PROBLEMS OF FOR THE COMMUNITY.
01:05:30.593 --> 01:05:32.061
AND I WANT TO THANK YOU FOR
01:05:32.128 --> 01:05:33.229
DOING THAT AND- AND ALSO WANT
01:05:33.296 --> 01:05:35.298
TO THANK ALL THE WHEN IT. IS
01:05:35.364 --> 01:05:36.966
WHO TESTIFIED EARLIER. AND AS
01:05:37.033 --> 01:05:38.934
WE KNOW AND WE HEARD EARLIER.
01:05:39.001 --> 01:05:41.037
RESTAURANT INDUSTRY HAS REALLY
01:05:41.103 --> 01:05:42.238
SUFFERED. A THE MOST IN A- SALE.
01:05:42.305 --> 01:05:44.273
JOB LOSS IS A- YOU KNOW SINCE
01:05:44.340 --> 01:05:46.742
THE I. SO ALL AT THE SAME. THE
01:05:46.809 --> 01:05:48.411
USE OF THESE. DELIVERY
01:05:48.477 --> 01:05:50.813
PLATFORMS HAVE SEEN. A DRAMATIC
01:05:50.880 --> 01:05:52.848
INCREASE. AS PEOPLE CALTRAIN
01:05:52.915 --> 01:05:54.517
PLACE OKAY. I'D REALLY HOPES TO
01:05:54.583 --> 01:05:55.951
ENSURE THAT AN EQUITABLE AND
01:05:56.018 --> 01:05:57.119
MUTUALLY BENEFICIAL
01:05:57.186 --> 01:05:58.220
RELATIONSHIP. BETWEEN
01:05:58.287 --> 01:05:59.588
RESTAURANTS AND DELIVERY
01:05:59.655 --> 01:06:01.691
PLATFORMS. WHICH REALLY SEEN
01:06:01.757 --> 01:06:03.626
CRITICAL FOR THE RECOVERY OF
01:06:03.693 --> 01:06:05.728
THE- FOOD SERVICE INDUSTRY.
01:06:05.795 --> 01:06:07.363
GOING TO PANDEMIC SO- WITH THE
01:06:07.430 --> 01:06:08.931
AMENDMENT- THAT YOU HAVE
01:06:08.998 --> 01:06:11.067
ACCEPTED TODAY HI WILL BE
01:06:11.133 --> 01:06:13.369
SUPPORTED THE BILL. AND I WANT
01:06:13.436 --> 01:06:14.537
TO THANK YOU AND YOU MAY CLOSE.
01:06:14.603 --> 01:06:18.140
THANK YOU. I WILL I JUST WANT
01:06:18.207 --> 01:06:19.408
TO TOUCH BASE WITH. BUT YOU'RE
01:06:19.475 --> 01:06:20.976
GALLAGHER SAID. IN A- THOUGHT
01:06:21.043 --> 01:06:25.014
BUT I'VE BEEN. LOOKING AT THE
01:06:25.081 --> 01:06:25.614
CENTER TIME THAT QUESTION OF
01:06:25.681 --> 01:06:26.782
WHO IS THE CUSTOM IN WHO. WHO
01:06:26.849 --> 01:06:28.184
SHOULD THAT THE CUSTOMER HAVE
01:06:28.250 --> 01:06:29.585
THAT RELATIONSHIP WITH AND IT'S
01:06:29.652 --> 01:06:31.454
COMPLICATED. AND I DON'T THINK
01:06:31.520 --> 01:06:32.555
THAT THIS CRISIS IS GOING TO
01:06:32.621 --> 01:06:33.756
MAKE IT LESS COMPLICATED.
01:06:33.823 --> 01:06:35.758
BECAUSE I KEEP THINKING ABOUT-
01:06:35.825 --> 01:06:38.094
THE SMALL RESTAURANTS THAT ARE
01:06:38.160 --> 01:06:40.262
GOING TO SLOWLY COME OPEN UP
01:06:40.329 --> 01:06:44.066
RIGHT MAYBE ONE OR TWO- SEATS
01:06:44.133 --> 01:06:46.202
AVAILABLE THERE. TO WANT TO
01:06:46.268 --> 01:06:47.737
BRING PEOPLE AND SO THAT THEY
01:06:47.803 --> 01:06:49.705
CAN HIRE WAIT STAFF SO THEY CAN
01:06:49.772 --> 01:06:51.073
HIRE BACK THEIR STOCK. THEY
01:06:51.140 --> 01:06:52.308
COMMUNICATE WITH THE PEOPLE AT
01:06:52.375 --> 01:06:53.876
HOME THAT HAVE BEEN ORDERING
01:06:53.943 --> 01:06:57.346
THROUGH- AN APT. IF THEY'RE NO
01:06:57.413 --> 01:06:59.081
LONGER IN COMMUNICATION WITH
01:06:59.148 --> 01:07:00.750
THEIR OWN CUSTOMERS YOU KNOW-
01:07:00.816 --> 01:07:05.154
IT IT'S A BERRIER ALMOST TWO.
01:07:05.221 --> 01:07:08.090
OPENING FOR A LOT OF SO. STRONG
01:07:08.157 --> 01:07:10.126
EARLY WE MAY OR MAY NOT GET TO
01:07:10.192 --> 01:07:10.893
A RESOLUTION DOES ISSUES
01:07:10.960 --> 01:07:12.495
BECAUSE OF THE PRIVACY CONCERNS
01:07:12.561 --> 01:07:13.729
IT'S SOMETHING I'D LIKE TO GET
01:07:13.796 --> 01:07:14.463
TO BUT IT'S GOING TO TAKE SOME
01:07:14.530 --> 01:07:16.565
TIME. THAT'S WHY I'VE OFFERED-
01:07:16.632 --> 01:07:18.934
TO PULL THAT PIECE OUT- TO
01:07:19.001 --> 01:07:19.635
CONTINUE TO WORK WITH THIS
01:07:19.702 --> 01:07:21.537
COMMITTEE STAFF AS WELL AS-
01:07:21.604 --> 01:07:22.838
COMMITTEE STAFF IF IT IF IT
01:07:22.905 --> 01:07:24.573
MOVES FORWARD- INTO THE SENATE.
01:07:24.640 --> 01:07:25.541
AND THE WORK ON THE JUDICIARY
01:07:25.608 --> 01:07:26.709
PEACE BUT I THINK THIS IS
01:07:26.776 --> 01:07:28.611
SIMPLE AS WRITTEN AND THIS BILL
01:07:28.677 --> 01:07:29.779
JUST SAYS THERE SHOULD BE A
01:07:29.845 --> 01:07:32.681
CLEAR RELATIONSHIP- AS I THINK
01:07:32.748 --> 01:07:34.016
ALL CONSUMERS BELIEVE THAT
01:07:34.083 --> 01:07:36.952
THERE IS- AS- RESTAURANTS ARE
01:07:37.019 --> 01:07:40.055
ASKING FOR- AND- IT'S NOT TOO
01:07:40.122 --> 01:07:43.192
MUCH OF A BARRIER TO ASK. THESE
01:07:43.259 --> 01:07:46.562
COMPANIES TO CREATE. I RELATE
01:07:46.629 --> 01:07:48.864
WITH THESE WERE. BEFORE AVERAGE.
01:07:48.931 --> 01:07:50.399
CAN BUY THEIR FOR OR OR CHIU
01:07:50.466 --> 01:07:51.133
FROM THERE MAY WITHOUT I
01:07:51.200 --> 01:07:54.437
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR MY- THANK
01:07:54.503 --> 01:07:58.474
YOU VERY MUCH OUT. OF WHY I
01:07:58.541 --> 01:08:01.811
THIS BILL IS GOING TO. OR IS
01:08:01.877 --> 01:08:07.016
SET UP IT IS. HE SAID THE BILL
01:08:07.082 --> 01:08:08.751
HAS BEEN AND SO DOWN MAN
01:08:08.818 --> 01:08:09.385
SECRETARY WOULD YOU CALL WILL
01:08:09.452 --> 01:08:12.822
FORM. THE MOTION IS TO PASS TO
01:08:12.888 --> 01:08:17.927
THE IS FLOOR CHAO HI. KILEY
01:08:17.993 --> 01:08:23.365
BAUER-KAHAN. BERMAN ON MEDINA I
01:08:23.432 --> 01:08:29.738
CORREO. MULLIN GALLAGHER- WENT
01:08:29.805 --> 01:08:36.145
ON. OBERNOLTE WICKS RIGHT. YOU
01:08:36.212 --> 01:08:38.280
HAVEEIGHT VOTES- IT PASSES-
01:08:38.347 --> 01:08:40.883
LITERAL OPEN FOR ABSENT MEMBERS
01:08:40.950 --> 01:08:48.157
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. AND I
01:08:48.224 --> 01:08:49.158
THINK DOCTOR WEBER IS SO
01:08:49.225 --> 01:08:51.393
SUPPOSED TO BE NEXT LET'S WAIT
01:08:51.460 --> 01:08:53.562
A COUPLE MINUTES TO SEE. IF SHE
01:08:53.629 --> 01:09:03.205
IS GOING TO JOIN US SHORTLY.
01:09:03.272 --> 01:09:05.007
I'M TOLD THAT SHE'S STILL IN
01:09:05.074 --> 01:09:06.675
COMMITTEE ON- ONE OF THE BILLS.
01:09:06.742 --> 01:09:11.413
INTO HERS. SO I THINK I A WILL
01:09:11.480 --> 01:09:14.917
PROP- I THINK THAT'S A- THAT'S
01:09:14.984 --> 01:09:17.086
A PRETTY COMPREHENSIVE- BILL A
01:09:17.152 --> 01:09:20.489
CA FIVE. I WILL I WILL EXERCISE
01:09:20.556 --> 01:09:22.858
MY PREROGATIVE SO IS THE CHAIR
01:09:22.925 --> 01:09:24.927
TO GO TO MEMBERS IN THE
01:09:24.994 --> 01:09:27.496
COMMITTEE AND I BELIEVE- MISTER
01:09:27.563 --> 01:09:30.332
BERMAN THIS NEXT TO HE HAS A
01:09:30.399 --> 01:09:33.469
BILL AB TWENTY EIGHT ELEVEN.
01:09:33.536 --> 01:09:34.603
AND LET ME REITERATE FOR THOSE
01:09:34.670 --> 01:09:36.238
WISHING TO REGISTER THEIR
01:09:36.305 --> 01:09:39.141
SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION BY PHONE
01:09:39.208 --> 01:09:41.110
I DO ENCOURAGE ALL OF YOU TO
01:09:41.176 --> 01:09:42.978
CALL AND NOW. AT THE BEGINNING
01:09:43.045 --> 01:09:43.846
OF THE ASSEMBLYMEMBERS
01:09:43.913 --> 01:09:46.048
TESTIMONY JUST TO AVOID ANY
01:09:46.115 --> 01:09:47.850
DELAYS THE PHONE NUMBER AGAIN
01:09:47.917 --> 01:09:52.721
IS. EIGHT SEVEN SEVEN SIX NINE
01:09:52.788 --> 01:09:53.722
TWO EIGHT NINE FIVE SEVEN. SO
01:09:53.789 --> 01:09:55.124
WITH THAT YEAH WELCOME ASSEMBLY
01:09:55.190 --> 01:09:57.226
MEMBER ANYTIME YOU'RE READY
01:09:57.293 --> 01:09:59.562
POLICE BEGAN THANK YOU MISTER
01:09:59.628 --> 01:10:00.863
SUN COLLEAGUES LET ME BEGIN BY
01:10:00.930 --> 01:10:01.864
SAYING I ACCEPT THE COMMITTEE
01:10:01.931 --> 01:10:02.965
AMENDMENTS DEEMED DETAILED
01:10:03.032 --> 01:10:05.334
OPENPAGES NINE AND IN THE
01:10:05.401 --> 01:10:07.670
ANALYSIS. AB ELEVEN WOULD
01:10:07.736 --> 01:10:09.071
STRENGTHENED CALIFORNIA'S
01:10:09.138 --> 01:10:10.906
AUTOMATIC RENEWAL LAW. BY
01:10:10.973 --> 01:10:12.441
ENSURING THAT CONSUMERS CAN
01:10:12.508 --> 01:10:13.709
SUBSCRIBE FOR GOODS AND
01:10:13.776 --> 01:10:15.044
SERVICES ONLINE. THEY CAN
01:10:15.110 --> 01:10:17.346
CANCEL ONLINE AND THAT CAN DO
01:10:17.413 --> 01:10:20.749
SO WITHOUT DELAY OR HAVING TO
01:10:20.816 --> 01:10:21.917
JUMP THROUGH HOOPS. IN ADDITION.
01:10:21.984 --> 01:10:23.118
AB TWENTY IT'LL WOULD REQUIRE
01:10:23.185 --> 01:10:24.787
BUSINESSES TO NOTIFY CONSUMERS
01:10:24.853 --> 01:10:27.790
BEFORE A FREE GIFT TRIAL OR
01:10:27.856 --> 01:10:29.291
PROMOTIONAL OR DISCOUNTED RATE
01:10:29.358 --> 01:10:31.627
EXPIRES. IN RESPONSE TO THE
01:10:31.694 --> 01:10:33.062
ECONOMIC RECESSION TRIGGERED BY
01:10:33.128 --> 01:10:34.930
COVERED NINETEEN MANY
01:10:34.997 --> 01:10:36.465
INDIVIDUALS AND FAMILIES ARE
01:10:36.532 --> 01:10:37.766
SEARCHING FOR WAYS TO SAVE
01:10:37.833 --> 01:10:40.169
MONEY SO THAT THEY CAN BUY FOOD
01:10:40.235 --> 01:10:42.471
AND PAY RENT. ONE OF THE FIRST
01:10:42.538 --> 01:10:43.606
IS THEY WILL TURN IT IS TO
01:10:43.672 --> 01:10:44.673
CANCEL SUBSCRIPTION
01:10:44.740 --> 01:10:46.141
SUBSCRIPTIONS FOR GOODS AND
01:10:46.208 --> 01:10:47.843
SERVICES THAT THEY REALLY ARE
01:10:47.910 --> 01:10:50.145
YOU NEVER USE. UNFORTUNATELY
01:10:50.212 --> 01:10:51.981
MANY BUSINESSES USE A VARIETY
01:10:52.047 --> 01:10:52.982
OF TACTICS TO MAKE CANCELLING
01:10:53.048 --> 01:10:54.650
SUBSCRIPTIONS INCONVENIENT
01:10:54.717 --> 01:10:56.485
CONFUSING AND TIME CONSUMING.
01:10:56.552 --> 01:10:58.587
OR OTHERWISE DIFFICULT. JUST
01:10:58.654 --> 01:11:00.022
RECENTLY A MEMBER OF MY STAFF
01:11:00.089 --> 01:11:01.323
TRIED TO CANCEL HER NEW YORK
01:11:01.390 --> 01:11:03.158
TIMES SUBSCRIPTION ONLINE WHICH
01:11:03.225 --> 01:11:05.060
YOU SUBSCRIBE TO ONLINE AND THE
01:11:05.127 --> 01:11:06.495
ONLY ONLINE CANCELLATION OFFICE
01:11:06.562 --> 01:11:08.197
AND WHAT'S THE CHAT ONLINE WITH
01:11:08.263 --> 01:11:10.165
A CUSTOMER REPRESENTATIVE.
01:11:10.232 --> 01:11:11.800
HOWEVER NO REPRESENTATIVES WERE
01:11:11.867 --> 01:11:14.203
AVAILABLE AT THAT TIME WHICH
01:11:14.269 --> 01:11:15.270
WAS DURING NORMAL BUSINESS
01:11:15.337 --> 01:11:16.905
HOURS. THEREFORE HER ONLY
01:11:16.972 --> 01:11:19.708
OPTION FOR CANCER THE CALL OR
01:11:19.775 --> 01:11:21.110
TEXT A CUSTOMER REPRESENTATIVE.
01:11:21.176 --> 01:11:22.378
THIS EXPERIENCE IN OTHERS
01:11:22.444 --> 01:11:23.746
HIGHLIGHT THE NEED TO
01:11:23.812 --> 01:11:25.714
STRENGTHEN CALIFORNIA LAW TO
01:11:25.781 --> 01:11:26.715
PROTECT CONSUMERS AT A TIME
01:11:26.782 --> 01:11:28.651
WHEN THE MORE AND MORE CAN NO
01:11:28.717 --> 01:11:31.120
LONGER CAN AFFORD. THESE
01:11:31.186 --> 01:11:32.488
SERVICES. DURING THE COUNTING
01:11:32.554 --> 01:11:34.189
IT IS ESPECIALLY IMPORTANT THAT
01:11:34.256 --> 01:11:35.658
CONSUMERS CAN EASILY CANCEL
01:11:35.724 --> 01:11:37.826
SUBSCRIPTIONS THAT THEY MAY NO
01:11:37.893 --> 01:11:39.695
LONGER BE ABLE TO AFFORD. IT IS
01:11:39.762 --> 01:11:41.130
ALSO CRITICALLY IMPORTANT THAT
01:11:41.196 --> 01:11:41.964
CONSUMERS HAVE THESE
01:11:42.031 --> 01:11:43.365
PROTECTIONS GIVEN THE RECENT
01:11:43.432 --> 01:11:45.401
EXPLOSION OF FREE TRIALS AND
01:11:45.467 --> 01:11:46.502
PROMOTIONAL OFFERS BEING
01:11:46.568 --> 01:11:48.337
OFFERED IN THE RESPONSE THE
01:11:48.404 --> 01:11:50.139
COVERT NINETEEN. WITH ME TODAY
01:11:50.205 --> 01:11:52.074
BY PHONE I HOPE THEY WERE
01:11:52.141 --> 01:11:55.277
READY- ARE MET BALL FROM THE
01:11:55.344 --> 01:11:57.246
HEAD OF CONSUMER PROTECTION IN
01:11:57.312 --> 01:11:58.414
THE ALAMEDA COUNTY DISTRICT
01:11:58.480 --> 01:12:00.249
ATTORNEY'S OFFICE. AND DANNY
01:12:00.315 --> 01:12:02.818
CANDLE KAISER. ON BEHALF OF THE
01:12:02.885 --> 01:12:04.286
CALIFORNIA LOW INCOME CONSUMER
01:12:04.353 --> 01:12:06.555
COALITION I RESPECTFULLY ASK
01:12:06.622 --> 01:12:08.357
BROUGH. THANK YOU VERY MUCH SO
01:12:08.424 --> 01:12:11.093
LET'S CENTER ALL OF OUR FIRST
01:12:11.160 --> 01:12:13.662
WITNESS OUT. ARE YOU ONLINE.
01:12:13.729 --> 01:12:25.140
THERE ARE SEVERAL OF YOU. AND
01:12:25.207 --> 01:12:26.408
IS THERE ANYONE WHO WANTS TO
01:12:26.475 --> 01:12:27.609
MAKE A COMMENT AND SUPPORT AT
01:12:27.676 --> 01:12:29.578
THIS BILL PLEASE PRESS ONE
01:12:29.645 --> 01:12:32.314
FOLLOWED BY ZERO. LET'S GO TO
01:12:32.381 --> 01:12:33.916
THE OTHER LET'S GO TO OUR MAIN
01:12:33.982 --> 01:12:36.085
WITNESSES FIRST BEFORE WE GO TO
01:12:36.151 --> 01:12:38.620
THE NEED TO- SUPPORTERS. SOBRE
01:12:38.687 --> 01:12:41.757
MENTAL TRAUMA. MISTER BELL
01:12:41.824 --> 01:12:46.295
TRIAL HI YOU ONLINE. HOW ABOUT
01:12:46.361 --> 01:12:51.433
THE ANY CANDLE KAISER. YEAH
01:12:51.500 --> 01:12:53.869
GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIR MEMBERS I
01:12:53.936 --> 01:12:56.772
WILL GO FIRST. MY NAME AGAIN IS
01:12:56.839 --> 01:12:58.540
DANIELLE CNADA CRIED THERE I'M
01:12:58.607 --> 01:12:59.708
HERE ON BEHALF OF THE
01:12:59.775 --> 01:13:01.643
CALIFORNIA LOW INCOME CONSUMER
01:13:01.710 --> 01:13:03.946
COALITION. AND WE'RE PLEASED TO
01:13:04.012 --> 01:13:06.815
REPORT AB TWENTY EIGHT ELEVEN
01:13:06.882 --> 01:13:08.517
CLICK A STATEWIDE COALITION OF
01:13:08.584 --> 01:13:10.486
LEGALLY PROVIDERS THAT STRIVE
01:13:10.552 --> 01:13:11.520
TO ENSURE THAT ALL PEOPLE
01:13:11.587 --> 01:13:13.021
REGARDLESS OF THEIR INCOME OR
01:13:13.088 --> 01:13:14.823
BACKGROUND OPPORTUNITIES UNDER
01:13:14.890 --> 01:13:16.792
THE LAW. TO ACHIEVE THEIR FULL
01:13:16.859 --> 01:13:18.393
POTENTIAL WE THINK TO ENSURE
01:13:18.460 --> 01:13:20.295
THE ALL CONSUMERS IN CALIFORNIA
01:13:20.362 --> 01:13:22.564
HAVE THEIR VOICES HEARD AND
01:13:22.631 --> 01:13:25.000
THEIR NEEDS RECOGNIZED BY THE
01:13:25.067 --> 01:13:26.635
LEGISLATURE. ARE YOU BRINGING
01:13:26.702 --> 01:13:29.538
MEAL TO DIET DATE YOUR FITNESS
01:13:29.605 --> 01:13:31.106
APPS MORE MY CONSUMER ARE SINCE
01:13:31.173 --> 01:13:33.509
TO PRODUCT THE SERVICES ONLINE.
01:13:33.575 --> 01:13:34.877
AS ASSEMBLY MEMBER BERMAN IS
01:13:34.943 --> 01:13:36.245
STATED IN RESPONSE TO THE ACT.
01:13:36.311 --> 01:13:38.313
IN OF CO THAT NINETEEN MANY
01:13:38.380 --> 01:13:41.150
CALIFORNIANS ARE SEARCHING FOR
01:13:41.216 --> 01:13:42.384
WAYS TO SAVE MONEY NOW. VERY
01:13:42.451 --> 01:13:44.186
CHALLENGING HARD TO SPECIALLY
01:13:44.253 --> 01:13:45.621
IMPORTANT BUT CONSUMERS HAVE A
01:13:45.687 --> 01:13:47.656
CLEAR PATHWAY TO DISCONTINUING
01:13:47.723 --> 01:13:48.757
SERVICES THAT THEY AND THEIR
01:13:48.824 --> 01:13:50.859
FAMILIES NO LONGER NEED OR
01:13:50.926 --> 01:13:52.694
CAN'T AFFORD. AND THE COALITION
01:13:52.761 --> 01:13:54.096
THAT SERVES THE LEGAL AID NEEDS
01:13:54.163 --> 01:13:55.664
OF THOUSANDS OF CALIFORNIANS
01:13:55.731 --> 01:13:57.399
EVERY YEAR CLICK IS KEENLY
01:13:57.466 --> 01:13:59.935
AWARE OF THE CURRENT RECESSION
01:14:00.002 --> 01:14:00.402
THAT THE TAPE CONSUMER
01:14:00.469 --> 01:14:02.971
PROTECTION. THAT PREVENT OUR
01:14:03.038 --> 01:14:04.673
MOST VULNERABLE CITIZENS. I'M
01:14:04.740 --> 01:14:07.075
FALLING FURTHER INTO DEBT AND
01:14:07.142 --> 01:14:08.577
FINANCIAL HARDSHIP. WE SUPPORT
01:14:08.644 --> 01:14:10.479
THE AIM OF AB TWENTY EIGHT
01:14:10.546 --> 01:14:12.581
ELEVEN. TO BOLSTER CONSUMER
01:14:12.648 --> 01:14:13.315
PROTECTION BY ALLOWING
01:14:13.382 --> 01:14:14.917
CONSUMERS TO CANCEL THE PRODUCT
01:14:14.983 --> 01:14:16.385
WITH THE WITH OF ONLINE.
01:14:16.451 --> 01:14:18.220
QUICKLY AND IN A MANNERTHAT
01:14:18.287 --> 01:14:19.288
DOES NOT REQUIRE THE CONSUMER
01:14:19.354 --> 01:14:20.689
TO MAKE PHONE CALLS THREE GAUGE
01:14:20.756 --> 01:14:22.558
WITH ADDITIONAL THEY'LL PERSON.
01:14:22.624 --> 01:14:23.559
WE LOOK FORWARD TO OUR
01:14:23.625 --> 01:14:25.961
CONTINUING SUPPORT ONLY REQUEST
01:14:26.028 --> 01:14:27.563
YOUR AYE THE- THANK YOU VERY
01:14:27.629 --> 01:14:31.266
MUCH- IS MR MAT BELTRAN ALL.
01:14:31.333 --> 01:14:39.641
BELTRAN MOLD ON THE LINE PLEASE.
01:14:39.708 --> 01:14:42.177
I BELIEVE HE WAS CALLING IN BUT
01:14:42.244 --> 01:14:42.711
I DON'T KNOW IF HE'S GONE
01:14:42.778 --> 01:14:45.013
THROUGH YET. ALL RIGHT IF YOU
01:14:45.080 --> 01:14:47.916
ARE ON THE LINE PLEASE PRESS
01:14:47.983 --> 01:14:48.483
ONE FOLLOWED BY THE ROLE AT
01:14:48.550 --> 01:14:58.594
THIS TIME. WHEN WE COME BACK TO
01:14:58.660 --> 01:15:01.330
HOME- LET'S GO TO ALL THE OTHER
01:15:01.396 --> 01:15:04.700
SUPPORTERS. OF FOR THIS BILL.
01:15:04.766 --> 01:15:06.101
AND IF YOU COULD IDENTIFY
01:15:06.168 --> 01:15:08.470
YOURSELF. GIVE YOUR
01:15:08.537 --> 01:15:09.838
ORGANIZATION AS WELL AS YOUR
01:15:09.905 --> 01:15:15.711
POSITION PLEASE. AND IF THERE
01:15:15.777 --> 01:15:16.411
IS ANYONE WHO WANTS TO MAKE A
01:15:16.478 --> 01:15:19.214
COMMENT IN ORDER THIS BILL
01:15:19.281 --> 01:15:26.221
PLEASE PRESS ONE THEN ZERO. AND
01:15:26.288 --> 01:15:27.623
ONE MOMENT FOR OUR FIRST
01:15:27.689 --> 01:15:29.157
COMMENT AND WE HAVE A COMMENT
01:15:29.224 --> 01:15:32.194
FROM REBECCA HAMMER. MY THIRD
01:15:32.261 --> 01:15:36.265
PLACE CLINTON. I ACTUALLY DO
01:15:36.331 --> 01:15:37.933
NOT HAVE A COMMENT ON THAT
01:15:38.000 --> 01:15:44.773
STUFF THANK YOU THE. ANYONE
01:15:44.840 --> 01:15:48.043
ELSE ON THE LINE AT THE- ONE
01:15:48.110 --> 01:15:50.445
MOMENT AND WE DO HAVE A COMMENT
01:15:50.512 --> 01:15:51.813
FROM DANIELLE GOT TERRACE
01:15:51.880 --> 01:15:55.617
PLEASE CLAYTON. JANUARY. CHAIR
01:15:55.684 --> 01:15:56.385
OF THE BEHALF OF THE CONSUMER
01:15:56.451 --> 01:15:58.086
FEDERATION OF CALIFORNIA IN
01:15:58.153 --> 01:15:59.721
SUPPORT THANK YOU THANK YOU
01:15:59.788 --> 01:16:02.157
VERY MUCH. ANYONE ELSE IN
01:16:02.224 --> 01:16:07.729
SUPPORT OF THE BILL. WE DO HAVE
01:16:07.796 --> 01:16:08.297
ONE MORE ONE MOMENT FOR YOUR
01:16:08.363 --> 01:16:12.668
PATIENCE. THANK YOU. AND WE
01:16:12.734 --> 01:16:14.336
HAVE A MOMENT IN SUPPORT AND
01:16:14.403 --> 01:16:15.671
STEPHANIE MATTHEW PLEASE GO
01:16:15.737 --> 01:16:20.008
AHEAD. KIDDING MELANIE IS ON
01:16:20.075 --> 01:16:21.877
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
01:16:21.944 --> 01:16:23.512
DISTRICT ATTORNEYS ASSOCIATION
01:16:23.578 --> 01:16:31.820
AND THE COURT. THANK YOU. AND
01:16:31.887 --> 01:16:34.389
THERE ARE NO OTHERS IN YOU YEAH
01:16:34.456 --> 01:16:36.024
HELLO SO I HAVE NOT FELT TRAVEL
01:16:36.091 --> 01:16:38.627
HOW THINGS MATT. WELCOME MISTER
01:16:38.694 --> 01:16:41.730
BUSH TRUMP PLEASE GO AHEAD I'M-
01:16:41.797 --> 01:16:43.465
HOW DOES FOR THE CONFUSION GOOD
01:16:43.532 --> 01:16:44.666
MORNING MY NAME IS MATTHEW
01:16:44.733 --> 01:16:45.901
BELTRAME A COMMON ASSISTANT
01:16:45.968 --> 01:16:47.469
DISTRICT ATTORNEY IN ALAMEDA
01:16:47.536 --> 01:16:49.137
COUNTY. I LIKE TAKE A FEW
01:16:49.204 --> 01:16:52.874
MOMENTS IN SUPPORT OF AB TWO
01:16:52.941 --> 01:16:53.508
EIGHT ONE ONE I SPEAK TODAY ON
01:16:53.575 --> 01:16:55.610
BEHALF OF OUR ELECTED DISTRICT
01:16:55.677 --> 01:16:57.412
ATTORNEY NANCY O'MALLEY. BY WAY
01:16:57.479 --> 01:16:58.647
OF BACKGROUND I SERVED AS AN
01:16:58.714 --> 01:17:00.115
ATTORNEY IN THE ALAMEDA COUNTY
01:17:00.182 --> 01:17:01.717
DA'S OFFICE FOR THE PAST
01:17:01.783 --> 01:17:04.519
NINETEEN YEARS. ELEVEN OF WHICH
01:17:04.586 --> 01:17:06.455
I'VE EXCLUSIVELY HANDLE CASES
01:17:06.521 --> 01:17:08.290
INVOLVING A WHITE COLLAR CRIME
01:17:08.357 --> 01:17:10.158
AND CONSUMER FRAUD MOST OF THEM
01:17:10.225 --> 01:17:12.127
CIVIL ENFORCEMENT ACTIONS.
01:17:12.194 --> 01:17:13.595
BROUGHT ON BEHALF OF THE PEOPLE
01:17:13.662 --> 01:17:15.364
THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA. THE
01:17:15.430 --> 01:17:16.465
CONSUMER PROTECTION CASES
01:17:16.531 --> 01:17:18.333
PROSECUTED BY MY OFFICE MOSTLY
01:17:18.400 --> 01:17:19.568
INVOLVE COMPLAINT THE FALSE
01:17:19.634 --> 01:17:22.204
ADVERTISING AND UNLAWFUL AND
01:17:22.270 --> 01:17:23.705
FRAUDULENT BUSINESS PRACTICES.
01:17:23.772 --> 01:17:25.374
THEY IMPLICATE COMPANIES LARGE
01:17:25.440 --> 01:17:27.609
AND SMALL THAT YOU BUSINESS IN
01:17:27.676 --> 01:17:28.176
OUR STATE AND THROUGHOUT THE
01:17:28.243 --> 01:17:30.045
COUNTRY. ON THE STATUTES THAT
01:17:30.112 --> 01:17:31.847
FREQUENTLY ARISE IN THESE CASES
01:17:31.913 --> 01:17:33.949
IS CALIFORNIA'S AUTOMATIC
01:17:34.016 --> 01:17:35.317
RENEWAL LAW BUSINESS AND
01:17:35.384 --> 01:17:38.787
PROFESSIONS CODE SECTION
01:17:38.854 --> 01:17:39.354
SEVENTEEN SIX OH TWO. AS YOU
01:17:39.421 --> 01:17:40.789
KNOW THIS WAS AND REMAINS AN
01:17:40.856 --> 01:17:42.324
IMPORTANT PIECE OF CONSUMER
01:17:42.391 --> 01:17:44.126
PROTECTION LEGISLATION.
01:17:44.192 --> 01:17:45.260
ALTHOUGH AUTOMATIC RENEWAL
01:17:45.327 --> 01:17:46.928
CONTRACT CAN BE A SOURCE OF
01:17:46.995 --> 01:17:48.463
CONVENIENT FOR CUSTOMERS AND
01:17:48.530 --> 01:17:50.699
BUSINESSES. THEY ARE ALSO IN MY
01:17:50.766 --> 01:17:53.602
EXPERIENCE TRAPS FOR THE UNWARY
01:17:53.668 --> 01:17:54.569
SOMETIMES RESULTING IN
01:17:54.636 --> 01:17:56.738
CONSUMERS INCURRING MONTHS AND
01:17:56.805 --> 01:17:59.041
YEARS OF ON NOTICED CREDIT CARD
01:17:59.107 --> 01:18:01.510
CHARGES. THIS IS A PARTICULARLY
01:18:01.576 --> 01:18:03.178
WORRISOME PROBLEM NOW IN THE
01:18:03.245 --> 01:18:05.947
ERA OF CORONAVIRUS AND SHELTER
01:18:06.014 --> 01:18:07.416
IN PLACE ORDERS. WERE MILLION
01:18:07.482 --> 01:18:08.950
HAVE LOST THEIR JOBS AND CAN
01:18:09.017 --> 01:18:11.353
ILL AFFORD TO PAY FOR THINGS
01:18:11.420 --> 01:18:13.188
THEY DON'T USE OR WANT. THE LAW
01:18:13.255 --> 01:18:14.956
CURRENTLY REQUIRES COMPANIES
01:18:15.023 --> 01:18:15.991
THAT WISH TO ENTER INTO A
01:18:16.058 --> 01:18:17.893
CONTRACT WITH CONSUMERS TO MAKE
01:18:17.959 --> 01:18:19.594
DISCLOSURES ENTERTAINED
01:18:19.661 --> 01:18:21.430
AFFIRMATIVE CONSENT. I HAVE
01:18:21.496 --> 01:18:23.065
PERSONALLY HANDLE THE NUMBER OF
01:18:23.131 --> 01:18:24.566
CIVIL CASES IN WHICH COMPANIES
01:18:24.633 --> 01:18:26.535
WERE ALLEGEDTO HAVE VIOLATED
01:18:26.601 --> 01:18:27.936
THE AUTOMATIC RENEWAL LAW
01:18:28.003 --> 01:18:29.404
INCLUDING ACTIONS AGAINST LARGE
01:18:29.471 --> 01:18:31.206
COMPANIES SUCH AS SKYPE AND
01:18:31.273 --> 01:18:34.009
DROPBOX AN ACTIVITY BANDAGE. IN
01:18:34.076 --> 01:18:35.577
MY DISTRICT ATTORNEY COLLEAGUES
01:18:35.644 --> 01:18:36.645
AROUND THE STATE HAVE BROUGHT
01:18:36.711 --> 01:18:37.813
ACTIONS AGAINST OTHER WELL
01:18:37.879 --> 01:18:39.514
KNOWN COMPANIES SUCH AS THE
01:18:39.581 --> 01:18:42.084
HARMONY AND STAMPS DOT COM TO
01:18:42.150 --> 01:18:44.219
NAME. JUST A COUPLE. ALL OF
01:18:44.286 --> 01:18:45.620
THESE CASES I JUST MENTION
01:18:45.687 --> 01:18:46.688
RESULTED IN STIPULATED
01:18:46.755 --> 01:18:48.290
JUDGMENT. WHICH REQUIRED THE
01:18:48.356 --> 01:18:50.092
COMPANY IN QUESTION TO MAKE
01:18:50.158 --> 01:18:50.625
CHANGES TO THEIR BUSINESS
01:18:50.692 --> 01:18:52.894
PRACTICES. THROUGHOUT THE FALL
01:18:52.961 --> 01:18:54.329
THE LETTER AND THE SPIRIT OF
01:18:54.396 --> 01:18:56.465
THE AUTOMATIC RENEWAL LAW. EACH
01:18:56.531 --> 01:18:58.166
CASE ALSO RESULTED IN FILL
01:18:58.233 --> 01:19:00.035
PENALTIES AND POTENTIAL
01:19:00.102 --> 01:19:02.037
CONSUMER RESTITUTION. THE
01:19:02.104 --> 01:19:03.472
AUTOMATIC RENEWAL LAW HAS BEEN
01:19:03.538 --> 01:19:05.340
A REAL ASSET THE CALIFORNIA
01:19:05.407 --> 01:19:07.876
CONSUMERS. IT APPEARED TO ME
01:19:07.943 --> 01:19:09.744
THAT OVER TIME. APPELLEE
01:19:09.811 --> 01:19:12.848
COUNCIL BUSINESSES HAVE COME TO
01:19:12.914 --> 01:19:13.415
RECOGNIZE THE IMPORTANCE OF
01:19:13.482 --> 01:19:15.250
FOLLOWING IT. THE AUTOMATIC
01:19:15.317 --> 01:19:16.651
RENEWAL ARE CURRENTLY WRITTEN
01:19:16.718 --> 01:19:18.720
HOWEVER IS NOT PERFECT. THERE
01:19:18.787 --> 01:19:20.088
ARE SOME HOLD THAT REMAIN. FOR
01:19:20.155 --> 01:19:22.991
EXAMPLE NOTHING IN THE CURRENT
01:19:23.058 --> 01:19:24.259
LAW REQUIRES COMPANIES TO
01:19:24.326 --> 01:19:26.294
NOTIFY CONSUMERS WHEN THEY'RE
01:19:26.361 --> 01:19:28.296
ABOUT TO BE CHARGED EITHER AT
01:19:28.363 --> 01:19:30.866
THE END OF A FREE TRIAL PERIOD
01:19:30.932 --> 01:19:32.667
OR AT THE TIME OF RENEWAL. IN
01:19:32.734 --> 01:19:34.603
THE VAST MAJORITY OF CONSUMER
01:19:34.669 --> 01:19:35.804
TRANSACTIONS THESE DAYS ARE
01:19:35.871 --> 01:19:38.507
COMPLETED ONLINE AND VIA EMAIL
01:19:38.573 --> 01:19:40.208
COMMUNICATIONS. SUCH
01:19:40.275 --> 01:19:40.942
NOTIFICATIONS WOULD BE
01:19:41.009 --> 01:19:42.677
INEXPENSIVE AND EASY TO
01:19:42.744 --> 01:19:46.148
ADMINISTER. ALSO ALTHOUGH THE
01:19:46.214 --> 01:19:47.916
STATUTE IS CURRENTLY WRITTEN
01:19:47.983 --> 01:19:49.317
REQUIRES A COMPANY THAT OFFERS
01:19:49.384 --> 01:19:50.752
AN AUTOMATIC RENEWAL CONTRACT
01:19:50.819 --> 01:19:53.255
ONLINE. ALSO TO ALLOW
01:19:53.321 --> 01:19:55.557
CANCELLATION ONLINE NOTHING
01:19:55.624 --> 01:19:57.459
PREVENT THE COMPANY FOR MAKING
01:19:57.526 --> 01:20:00.061
CANCELLATION TRICKY DIFFICULT
01:20:00.128 --> 01:20:02.397
OR TIME CONSUMING. THE DISTRICT
01:20:02.464 --> 01:20:05.367
ATTORNEY SUPPORT AB TWO EIGHT
01:20:05.433 --> 01:20:06.701
ONE ONE BECAUSE IT STRENGTHENS
01:20:06.768 --> 01:20:07.469
THIS IMPORTANT CONSUMER
01:20:07.536 --> 01:20:09.871
PROTECTION LAW BY HELPING TO
01:20:09.938 --> 01:20:11.973
PLUG THE HOLES. FIRST IT
01:20:12.040 --> 01:20:13.141
REQUIRES THAT A BUSINESS
01:20:13.208 --> 01:20:15.076
NOTIFIED CUSTOMERS AT THE
01:20:15.143 --> 01:20:16.778
CONCLUSION OF A FREE CREEK GIFT
01:20:16.845 --> 01:20:19.681
OR FREE TRIAL PERIOD. BEFORE
01:20:19.748 --> 01:20:21.183
HIS OR HER CREDIT CARD IS
01:20:21.249 --> 01:20:23.618
CHARGED THE FULL AMOUNT TO LET
01:20:23.685 --> 01:20:25.287
THEM KNOW HOW TO CANCEL. GIVING
01:20:25.353 --> 01:20:27.255
KERN CONSUMERS SUCH NOTICE WILL
01:20:27.322 --> 01:20:29.090
HELP ENSURE THAT THEY KNOW WHEN
01:20:29.157 --> 01:20:30.292
AND HOW MUCH THEY WILL BE
01:20:30.358 --> 01:20:31.826
CHARGED AS WELL TO PAINT A
01:20:31.893 --> 01:20:33.361
CLEAR UNDERSTANDING OF THE
01:20:33.428 --> 01:20:35.497
CANCELLATION PROCESS. PROCESS
01:20:35.564 --> 01:20:37.399
SECOND THE BILL MAKES IT CLEAR
01:20:37.465 --> 01:20:38.700
THAT CONSUMERS HAVE THE RIGHT
01:20:38.767 --> 01:20:40.735
TO CANCEL AUTOMATIC RENEWAL
01:20:40.802 --> 01:20:42.971
CONTRACT THAT WILL. WITHOUT
01:20:43.038 --> 01:20:44.806
HAVING TO ENGAGE IN STEPS THAT
01:20:44.873 --> 01:20:46.174
WILL IMPAIR OR RESTRICT THEIR
01:20:46.241 --> 01:20:49.644
ABILITY TO DO SO. THIS IS NOT
01:20:49.711 --> 01:20:51.913
MERELY AN ACADEMIC EXERCISE. IN
01:20:51.980 --> 01:20:54.015
OUR INVESTIGATION. WE HAVE SEEN
01:20:54.082 --> 01:20:56.484
MANY EXAMPLES OF BUSINESSES
01:20:56.551 --> 01:20:58.453
FORCING CONSUMERS TO JUMP
01:20:58.520 --> 01:21:00.222
THROUGH HOOPS. I MAKING THEM
01:21:00.288 --> 01:21:02.624
COMPLETE SEVERAL ON NECESSARY
01:21:02.691 --> 01:21:04.826
STEPS IN ORDER TO CANCEL THE
01:21:04.893 --> 01:21:05.827
AUTOMATIC RENEWAL SERVICE.
01:21:05.894 --> 01:21:08.630
THESE INCLUDE FORCING THEM TO
01:21:08.697 --> 01:21:10.599
ENGAGE IN ONLINE CHAT WITH
01:21:10.665 --> 01:21:13.268
CUSTOMER SERVICE REPS MAY TENTH
01:21:13.335 --> 01:21:15.403
TO DISSUADE THEM FROM CANCELING.
01:21:15.470 --> 01:21:17.439
HIDING A CANCELLATION HYPERLINK
01:21:17.505 --> 01:21:19.007
IN A WEB PAGE THAT IS DIFFICULT
01:21:19.074 --> 01:21:21.910
TO FIND ARE NOT INTUITIVE.
01:21:21.977 --> 01:21:23.778
REQUIRING CONSUMERS TO TAKE A
01:21:23.845 --> 01:21:26.114
SURVEY OR OTHERWISE PROVIDE A
01:21:26.181 --> 01:21:28.183
REASON FOR CANCELLATION.
01:21:28.250 --> 01:21:31.052
OFFERING NARROW WINDOWS OF TIME
01:21:31.119 --> 01:21:31.553
IN WHICH CANCELLATION AS
01:21:31.620 --> 01:21:34.689
POSSIBLE. AND REQUIRING TUMORS
01:21:34.756 --> 01:21:36.791
TO GO TO MULTIPLE STEPS. TO
01:21:36.858 --> 01:21:38.760
PROCESS THE CANCELLATION MY
01:21:38.827 --> 01:21:40.095
COLLEAGUES REPORT HAVING SEEN
01:21:40.161 --> 01:21:42.664
CASES THAT INVOLVE AS MANY AS
01:21:42.731 --> 01:21:44.165
THIRTEEN SEPARATE STEPPED
01:21:44.232 --> 01:21:45.900
INCLUDING MULTIPLE ATTEMPTS TO
01:21:45.967 --> 01:21:47.902
PERSUADE THE CONSUMER TO REMAIN
01:21:47.969 --> 01:21:51.506
WITH THE SERVER. THIS BILL WILL
01:21:51.573 --> 01:21:54.009
RENDER THESE PRACTICES UNLAWFUL.
01:21:54.075 --> 01:21:55.076
ON BEHALF OF THE ALAMEDA COUNTY
01:21:55.143 --> 01:21:56.811
DISTRICT ATTORNEY'S OFFICE WE
01:21:56.878 --> 01:21:58.847
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR VOTE
01:21:58.913 --> 01:22:00.849
YES ON THIS BILL THANK YOU
01:22:00.915 --> 01:22:02.284
THANK YOU VERY MUCH I LIKE TO
01:22:02.350 --> 01:22:05.453
KNOW IF ANYONE ELSE'S SO ON THE
01:22:05.520 --> 01:22:12.727
LINE TO SUPPORT THIS BILL. IF
01:22:12.794 --> 01:22:13.728
THERE IS ANYONE WHO WANTS TO
01:22:13.795 --> 01:22:15.297
MAKE A COMMENT OPPOSITION TO
01:22:15.363 --> 01:22:16.998
THIS BILL PLEASE PRESS ONE.
01:22:17.065 --> 01:22:25.206
ZERO TOM KEPT PARTY TO ONE ZERO.
01:22:25.273 --> 01:22:27.108
AND WE HAVE NOBODY THANK YOU
01:22:27.175 --> 01:22:29.544
VERY MUCH OUT LET'S TURN TO THE
01:22:29.611 --> 01:22:31.980
OPPOSITION I BELIEVE- IS CORNY
01:22:32.047 --> 01:22:33.948
JENSEN FROM TECHCONNECT IS ON
01:22:34.015 --> 01:22:36.217
THE LINE AS WELL AS SHARP
01:22:36.284 --> 01:22:38.153
MUHAMMAD FROM CAL CHAMBER. HI
01:22:38.219 --> 01:22:42.724
YOU ON THE LINE. DIRECTOR CARY
01:22:42.791 --> 01:22:44.159
ACT THAT THE COURT IN JENSEN
01:22:44.225 --> 01:22:46.328
LIKE TECH THAT AND TAKE THAT IS
01:22:46.394 --> 01:22:47.962
UNFORTUNATELY IN OPPOSITION TO
01:22:48.029 --> 01:22:49.731
AB TWENTY EIGHT ELEVEN AS
01:22:49.798 --> 01:22:51.466
CURRENTLY WRITTEN AND BUT WE DO
01:22:51.533 --> 01:22:52.600
APPRECIATE THE AUTHORED THAT
01:22:52.667 --> 01:22:55.537
CAN INTENT OF THE BILL- BUT YOU
01:22:55.603 --> 01:22:56.771
WORRY ABOUT THE WORKABILITY OF
01:22:56.838 --> 01:22:59.774
MANY OF THE PROVISIONS. AND
01:22:59.841 --> 01:23:00.375
TWENTY SEVENTEEN PACKED THAT
01:23:00.442 --> 01:23:01.776
WORKED WITH SENATOR HERTZBERG
01:23:01.843 --> 01:23:04.179
ON HIS AT THE THREE THIRTEEN
01:23:04.245 --> 01:23:05.347
WHICH WENT INTO EFFECT JULY
01:23:05.413 --> 01:23:07.182
FIRST TWENTY EIGHTEEN MONTHS IN
01:23:07.248 --> 01:23:09.017
TWO YEARS AGO- AND TECHNET
01:23:09.084 --> 01:23:10.285
EVENTUALLY TOOK A NEUTRAL
01:23:10.352 --> 01:23:11.419
POSITION ON THAT LANGUAGE
01:23:11.486 --> 01:23:13.321
BECAUSE WE BELIEVE IT WOULD NOT
01:23:13.388 --> 01:23:15.123
COVER BURDEN BUSINESS SAYS AND
01:23:15.190 --> 01:23:16.291
WHAT ENSURE CONSUMERS WERE IN
01:23:16.358 --> 01:23:18.193
POWER TO CANCEL SERVICES
01:23:18.259 --> 01:23:20.862
EASILY. AB TWENTY EIGHT ELEVEN
01:23:20.929 --> 01:23:22.130
WOULD BALAMAND THAT LANGUAGE
01:23:22.197 --> 01:23:23.932
AND I'LL QUICKLY COVER TO
01:23:23.998 --> 01:23:26.901
CONCERNS THAT WE HAVE FIRST THE
01:23:26.968 --> 01:23:27.402
BILL REQUIRES IMMEDIATE
01:23:27.469 --> 01:23:29.304
CANCELLATION WE WANT TO ENSURE
01:23:29.371 --> 01:23:30.772
IT WOULD NOT ALLOW CONSUMERS TO
01:23:30.839 --> 01:23:33.308
BE ABLE TO BE USED FREE TRIAL
01:23:33.375 --> 01:23:35.810
OR SUBSCRIPTION AGREEMENT THAT
01:23:35.877 --> 01:23:39.781
ALLOW THEM TO TAKE ADVANTAGE.
01:23:39.848 --> 01:23:41.983
ALL RIGHT. BUT HAVE A RIGHT
01:23:42.050 --> 01:23:44.919
CANCEL. ALLOWING A CAN TO CAN'T
01:23:44.986 --> 01:23:46.721
NUMBER OF THE TERM TO CREATE
01:23:46.788 --> 01:23:48.189
GET CONCERNS FOR BUSINESS AND
01:23:48.256 --> 01:23:50.925
WE THAT THE MORE PER. CLAIRE
01:23:50.992 --> 01:23:52.560
THAT THE TAKE A FACT THAT THE
01:23:52.627 --> 01:23:54.329
END OF THE BILLING CYCLE SECOND
01:23:54.396 --> 01:23:56.064
THE BILL REQUIRED THE BUSINESS
01:23:56.131 --> 01:23:57.665
TO ALLOW CONSUMER KIDS
01:23:57.732 --> 01:23:59.300
TERMINATE AT WILL AND I FOUND
01:23:59.367 --> 01:24:02.437
AGING AND ANY FURTHER THAT AS
01:24:02.504 --> 01:24:04.005
THE LANGUAGE STAND CURRENTLY IT
01:24:04.072 --> 01:24:05.640
IS UNCLEAR IF THE BUSINESS TO
01:24:05.707 --> 01:24:07.275
BE ABLE TO REQUIRE A PMR TO
01:24:07.342 --> 01:24:09.477
AUTHENTICATE THEMSELVES FOR
01:24:09.544 --> 01:24:11.579
ALLOWING A CANCELLATION IT IS
01:24:11.646 --> 01:24:13.014
OFTEN DIFFICULT IN THE MIND
01:24:13.081 --> 01:24:14.382
CONTACT FOR BUSINESSES CAN
01:24:14.449 --> 01:24:16.017
VERIFY THAT A PERSON IS INDEED
01:24:16.084 --> 01:24:17.652
AUTHOR TO CANCEL THE
01:24:17.719 --> 01:24:19.287
SUBSCRIPTION. AND SOMETIMES
01:24:19.354 --> 01:24:21.489
BUSINESSES TO ASK NUMBER TO
01:24:21.556 --> 01:24:22.957
FIND INTERNET OR VERIFIED BY
01:24:23.024 --> 01:24:24.826
ANOTHER METHOD TO RESOLVE THE
01:24:24.893 --> 01:24:29.631
CANCELLATION OUR CLASS.
01:24:29.697 --> 01:24:30.732
ALTHOUGH THIS PLANE WOULD LIMIT
01:24:30.799 --> 01:24:31.299
THE OF THE OF A COMPANY TO
01:24:31.366 --> 01:24:32.066
ENGAGE DIRECT WTH THEIR
01:24:32.133 --> 01:24:33.368
CUSTOMER. TO BE GIVEN IN OUR-
01:24:33.435 --> 01:24:34.936
TO RESOLVE ISSUE OR DRAFT THE
01:24:35.003 --> 01:24:37.172
CUSTOMERS NEED. OFTEN CONSUMERS
01:24:37.238 --> 01:24:38.940
CAN TAKE ADVANTAGE OF THIS TYPE
01:24:39.007 --> 01:24:40.508
OF DIALOGUE WITH THE BUSINESS
01:24:40.575 --> 01:24:42.143
NEGOTIATE A BETTER PRICE OR
01:24:42.210 --> 01:24:44.479
DIRECT THE STAR MAY HAVE WITH
01:24:44.546 --> 01:24:45.380
THE SERVICE. NOT ALLOWING THE
01:24:45.447 --> 01:24:46.815
ABILITY TO ENGAGE IN ANY
01:24:46.881 --> 01:24:48.716
FURTHER STAT WE BELIEVE THIS
01:24:48.783 --> 01:24:50.218
WOULD HAMSTRING BOTH BUSINESSES
01:24:50.285 --> 01:24:52.821
AND CONSUMERS- AND WE DO LOOK
01:24:52.887 --> 01:24:53.788
FORWARD TO WORKING WITH THE OFF
01:24:53.855 --> 01:24:55.490
THEIR ON THESE ISSUES AND HELP
01:24:55.557 --> 01:24:56.357
THE WILL BE ABLE TO DROP
01:24:56.424 --> 01:24:57.392
PARKING CAN'T. CONCERNING
01:24:57.459 --> 01:24:59.260
MOVING FORWARD THANK YOU AGAIN
01:24:59.327 --> 01:25:01.062
MISTER CHAIR APPRECIATE THE
01:25:01.129 --> 01:25:02.597
COMMITTEE TIME. THANK YOU VERY
01:25:02.664 --> 01:25:05.567
MUCH OF IT IS MISTER MOHAMMED
01:25:05.633 --> 01:25:10.338
ON THE LINE. BUT I AM. ONE
01:25:10.405 --> 01:25:11.573
MOMENT FOR THE CALIFORNIA
01:25:11.639 --> 01:25:13.508
CHAMBER OF COMMERCE- WE ARE
01:25:13.575 --> 01:25:15.043
ALSO RESPECTFULLY- OPPOSED TO
01:25:15.109 --> 01:25:17.212
AB TWENTY ELEVEN OF COURSE WE
01:25:17.278 --> 01:25:18.513
THANK YOU FOR TAKING THE TIME
01:25:18.580 --> 01:25:20.548
AND WE SUPPORT- THE AUTHOR'S
01:25:20.615 --> 01:25:21.783
INTENTION TO PROMOTE
01:25:21.850 --> 01:25:22.884
TRANSPARENCY EMPOWER
01:25:22.951 --> 01:25:24.352
CONSERVATORY AND WE LOOK
01:25:24.419 --> 01:25:25.086
FORWARD TO WORKING AT THE
01:25:25.153 --> 01:25:26.721
AUTHOR ON THESE ISSUES BUT IT
01:25:26.788 --> 01:25:27.722
TURNS OUT THERE ARE SOME ISSUES
01:25:27.789 --> 01:25:29.757
WITH THE LANGUAGE IN THIS BILL-
01:25:29.824 --> 01:25:31.326
THAT WE BELIEVE COULD BENEFIT
01:25:31.392 --> 01:25:33.228
FROM CLERK AGENT SO I WANTED TO
01:25:33.294 --> 01:25:34.462
ADDRESS YOU. ISSUES WITH ALL
01:25:34.529 --> 01:25:36.231
OUR FIRST I WANTED TO ADDRESS
01:25:36.297 --> 01:25:37.699
THIS REQUIREMENT THE BILL
01:25:37.765 --> 01:25:39.267
REQUIRES BUSINESSES TO PROVIDE
01:25:39.334 --> 01:25:40.502
CONSUMERS WITH A NOTICE
01:25:40.568 --> 01:25:41.436
EXPLAINING HOW TO CANCEL AN
01:25:41.503 --> 01:25:42.804
AUTOMATIC RENEWAL OFFER
01:25:42.871 --> 01:25:44.873
CONTINUOUS AUTHOR BUT THE
01:25:44.939 --> 01:25:47.141
REQUIRED. NOTICE MUST BE
01:25:47.208 --> 01:25:49.177
PROVIDED TO THE AT THE THREE
01:25:49.244 --> 01:25:50.345
DAY THAT ABOUT SEVEN DAYS PRIOR
01:25:50.411 --> 01:25:51.579
TO THE EXPIRATION OF THE ALL
01:25:51.646 --> 01:25:53.581
WORK BUT IF INDIVIDUATION RUN
01:25:53.648 --> 01:25:55.083
OFFERS LESS THAN THREE DAYS
01:25:55.149 --> 01:25:57.085
LONG OF NOT REALLY BE POSSIBLE
01:25:57.151 --> 01:25:58.953
TO OPERATE READING NOT AS AN
01:25:59.020 --> 01:25:59.954
ADDITION TO THE LANGUAGE OF THE
01:26:00.021 --> 01:26:07.729
BILL. MANY BILL. OFFICE BY ME.
01:26:07.795 --> 01:26:09.063
SO THE LANGUAGE OF THE BILL
01:26:09.130 --> 01:26:11.699
DOES. MAKE IT DIFFICULT FOR.
01:26:11.766 --> 01:26:12.467
AFTER SUBSCRIPTIONS BY MAIL TO
01:26:12.534 --> 01:26:14.402
GO THOSE NOTICE. OUT AND HOW.
01:26:14.469 --> 01:26:16.571
ME THOSE TIME DEADLINE AS-
01:26:16.638 --> 01:26:17.205
GIVEN THE MAIL SYSTEM UNDER THE
01:26:17.272 --> 01:26:19.541
CURRENT. AND UP INTO. GIVEN THE
01:26:19.607 --> 01:26:20.108
KERN ECONOMIC SITUATION THE
01:26:20.174 --> 01:26:22.243
COST OF OPERATION. IN THE- NO
01:26:22.310 --> 01:26:24.245
WITHIN BURDEN FOR THE FIRST
01:26:24.312 --> 01:26:25.914
BECAUSE REQUIRED THEM TO
01:26:25.980 --> 01:26:27.215
CONNECT WE- AND PERSONNEL
01:26:27.282 --> 01:26:29.450
TOWARDS ME. CHANGE TAKING. CALL
01:26:29.517 --> 01:26:31.452
THANK. AND THOSE CONCERNS THINK
01:26:31.519 --> 01:26:33.488
THAT THEY STILL IS. THAT NEW TO
01:26:33.555 --> 01:26:34.589
BE. ADDRESSED AND THE LIGHT
01:26:34.656 --> 01:26:36.491
THAT. WILL BE ON OUT OF MY
01:26:36.558 --> 01:26:37.959
CHECKING POINT IS THAT. LINK
01:26:38.026 --> 01:26:40.228
BUT REQUIREMENTS. THE LANGUAGE
01:26:40.295 --> 01:26:41.396
WILL ALSO REQUIRE THERE TO BE A
01:26:41.462 --> 01:26:44.399
DIRECT LINK BODY. TO CANCEL OUR
01:26:44.465 --> 01:26:45.667
SUBSCRIPTION THEIR SERVICES
01:26:45.733 --> 01:26:47.168
ONLINE NOW THE ISSUE HERE IS
01:26:47.235 --> 01:26:49.037
THAT THE TECHNICAL REQUIREMENTS
01:26:49.103 --> 01:26:50.305
TO BE A DIRECT. LINK BUTTON
01:26:50.371 --> 01:26:52.674
RULED OUT THE POSSIBILITY FOR
01:26:52.740 --> 01:26:54.409
ALTERNATIVE MEANS OF EMPOWERING
01:26:54.475 --> 01:26:59.747
THE SAME. CONCEPTUAL
01:26:59.814 --> 01:27:01.115
ALTERNATIVES ARE TECHNIQUE
01:27:01.182 --> 01:27:02.650
DIRECT LINK ARE BOUGHT IN FOR
01:27:02.717 --> 01:27:03.618
EXAMPLE IF THE CONCERN CHOICE
01:27:03.685 --> 01:27:05.320
IN POWER BY. THE TALK SWITCH IN
01:27:05.386 --> 01:27:06.921
AND OP OR BY SOME OTHER
01:27:06.988 --> 01:27:08.156
CREATIVE INTO THE USER CAN.
01:27:08.222 --> 01:27:10.458
THAT NOT TECH A LAY OR BY. BUT
01:27:10.525 --> 01:27:11.793
ONE CAN ABOUT HOW THE THING AND
01:27:11.859 --> 01:27:13.094
GOAL COULD ACHIEVED. BY VARIOUS
01:27:13.161 --> 01:27:14.963
IMPOSSIBLE EVEN MORE. GAMES AND
01:27:15.029 --> 01:27:15.930
THAT'S WHY BELIEVE THE LANGUAGE
01:27:15.997 --> 01:27:18.533
HERE COULD. OP A LESS PER. BUT
01:27:18.600 --> 01:27:20.268
ON THAT. AND FOR THOSE REASONS
01:27:20.335 --> 01:27:21.936
WE- FOLLOW THE WE DO FORWARD TO
01:27:22.003 --> 01:27:23.571
WITH THE ON THE DISTRICT THANK
01:27:23.638 --> 01:27:25.673
YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
01:27:25.740 --> 01:27:27.375
ADDITIONAL INDIVIDUALS IN
01:27:27.442 --> 01:27:28.876
OPPOSITION TO THE BILL PLEASE
01:27:28.943 --> 01:27:32.547
IDENTIFY YOURSELF YOUR
01:27:32.614 --> 01:27:35.516
ORGANIZATION AND YOUR POSITION.
01:27:35.583 --> 01:27:36.818
YES A PERSON YES CERTAINLY
01:27:36.884 --> 01:27:54.102
ANYONE OF. PERFECT. IT'S I TRY.
01:27:54.168 --> 01:27:56.838
OUTLINED SORRY BY THE TOO LEAN
01:27:56.904 --> 01:27:59.307
WITNESSES AND- I APPRECIATE
01:27:59.374 --> 01:28:01.376
MISTER BERMAN'S TIME THAT HE
01:28:01.442 --> 01:28:01.843
HAS SPENT WITH US AND
01:28:01.909 --> 01:28:04.979
DISCUSSING THE- BILL THANK YOU.
01:28:05.046 --> 01:28:10.652
MUCH LET'S GO TO THE PHONE LINE.
01:28:10.718 --> 01:28:12.286
ADDITIONAL INDIVIDUALS IN
01:28:12.353 --> 01:28:15.556
AUTHORS ANYWAY BILL. RIGHT IF
01:28:15.623 --> 01:28:17.125
THERE'S ANYONE THAT WANTS TO
01:28:17.191 --> 01:28:17.825
MAKE A COMMENT OPPOSITION OF
01:28:17.892 --> 01:28:19.727
DELTA THESE PAST ONE THAN THEIR
01:28:19.794 --> 01:28:24.365
OWN ONE MOMENT DURING. OKAY WE
01:28:24.432 --> 01:28:25.566
HAVE ON STEVE CARLSON.
01:28:25.633 --> 01:28:31.339
CAROLINA'S OPEN. PLEASE GO
01:28:31.406 --> 01:28:37.011
AHEAD MR CARSON. MR CHAIR
01:28:37.078 --> 01:28:38.146
MEMBERS BE CALLED HIM FOR THE
01:28:38.212 --> 01:28:39.313
ASSOCIATION OF NATIONAL
01:28:39.380 --> 01:28:41.949
ADVERTISERS- FOR THE REASONS
01:28:42.016 --> 01:28:44.385
STATED BY ATTACK THAT AND
01:28:44.452 --> 01:28:46.354
CHAMBER WE REMAIN OPPOSED I
01:28:46.421 --> 01:28:47.388
THINK IT'S IMPORTANT TO LOOK AT
01:28:47.455 --> 01:28:49.824
AGE- FROM A BALANCE STANDPOINT
01:28:49.891 --> 01:28:51.392
WE CERTAINLY UNDERSTAND THE AT
01:28:51.459 --> 01:28:52.093
THE IMPACT THEY CALLED IN A
01:28:52.160 --> 01:28:53.961
PLAID BUT ON CONSUMERS BUT
01:28:54.028 --> 01:28:55.797
COVERED HAD HAD A REMARKABLE
01:28:55.863 --> 01:28:58.099
IMPACT ON ON COMPANIES AS WELL
01:28:58.166 --> 01:28:59.367
AND I THINK WE HAVE TO ACHIEVE
01:28:59.434 --> 01:29:00.902
THAT. I'M NOT HERE BALANCE HERE
01:29:00.968 --> 01:29:02.136
AND UNFORTUNATELY WE DON'T
01:29:02.203 --> 01:29:05.707
THINK WE'RE THERE YET ON A
01:29:05.773 --> 01:29:06.708
TWENTY ELEVEN. THANK YOU ANYONE
01:29:06.774 --> 01:29:10.812
ELSE. YEAH CATHERINE GUNTER
01:29:10.878 --> 01:29:14.082
YOUR LINE OF. HI GOOD AFTERNOON
01:29:14.148 --> 01:29:15.349
THAT THE CATHARINE GUNTER WITH
01:29:15.416 --> 01:29:16.217
THE ENTERTAINMENT SOFTWARE
01:29:16.284 --> 01:29:17.885
ASSOCIATION I RESPECTFULLY
01:29:17.952 --> 01:29:22.023
OPPOSING. TO TWENTY ELEVEN.
01:29:22.090 --> 01:29:24.892
THANK YOU NEXT PLACE. OKAY
01:29:24.959 --> 01:29:26.060
IT'LL BE JUST A MOMENT OKAY
01:29:26.127 --> 01:29:28.529
RURAL ROAD MATCH DAYLAMI YOUR
01:29:28.596 --> 01:29:37.038
LINE IS OPEN. I'M ACTUALLY
01:29:37.105 --> 01:29:41.242
AHEAD. THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR
01:29:41.309 --> 01:29:42.844
MEMBERS RUNOFF GAYLANI WOULD
01:29:42.910 --> 01:29:44.345
NIELSEN MARK MURR ON BEHALF OF
01:29:44.412 --> 01:29:45.146
THE INTERNATIONAL HEALTH
01:29:45.213 --> 01:29:47.448
RACQUET SPORTS CLUB ASSOCIATION
01:29:47.515 --> 01:29:48.049
IN OPPOSITION TO THE BILL AND
01:29:48.116 --> 01:29:51.652
PRINT. THANK YOU NEXT PLACE.
01:29:51.719 --> 01:29:57.692
ONE MOMENT. HM YOUR REMINDED OF
01:29:57.759 --> 01:30:05.500
ON. JIM YORK IF I HAD. MISTER
01:30:05.566 --> 01:30:06.134
CHAIR MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE
01:30:06.200 --> 01:30:08.402
CAN YOU WORK FOR THE CALIFORNIA
01:30:08.469 --> 01:30:10.438
NEWS PUBLISHERS ASSOCIATION ARE
01:30:10.505 --> 01:30:12.740
WE ARE OPPOSED TO AB TWENTY
01:30:12.807 --> 01:30:14.008
ELEVEN RIGHT NOW FOR MANY OF
01:30:14.075 --> 01:30:16.911
THE REASONS THAT- PREVIOUS-
01:30:16.978 --> 01:30:18.179
SPEAKERS IN OPPOSITION
01:30:18.246 --> 01:30:20.348
EXPRESSED BUT WE LOOK FORWARD
01:30:20.414 --> 01:30:22.683
TO WORKING WITH MR BERMAN- OR
01:30:22.750 --> 01:30:26.053
AND- AMENDMENTS THAT HOPEFULLY
01:30:26.120 --> 01:30:27.889
ADDRESS OUR CONCERNS. THANK YOU.
01:30:27.955 --> 01:30:28.456
THANK YOU VERY MUCH OUR NEXT
01:30:28.523 --> 01:30:48.142
PLEASE. ONE MOMENT. OKAY BUT HE
01:30:48.209 --> 01:30:52.680
SAID GARCIA THE LINE IS OPEN.
01:30:52.747 --> 01:30:53.981
HI LOOKING HERE WITH THE
01:30:54.048 --> 01:30:55.516
CALIFORNIA GROCERS ASSOCIATION
01:30:55.583 --> 01:30:57.985
OFTEN OPPOSITION CLEAR WHEN YOU
01:30:58.052 --> 01:31:00.021
DON'T. THANK YOU VERY MUCH AND
01:31:00.087 --> 01:31:08.629
NEXT PLEASE. TALIBAN. TO GET
01:31:08.696 --> 01:31:10.364
GIVE OPPOSITION PLEASE PRESS
01:31:10.431 --> 01:31:14.936
ONE ZERO. IN HERE THERE'S
01:31:15.002 --> 01:31:19.006
NOBODY ELSE COULD HAVE. LET'S
01:31:19.073 --> 01:31:20.441
BRING BACK TO THE COMMITTEE FOR
01:31:20.508 --> 01:31:22.443
QUESTIONS COMMENTS MISTER
01:31:22.510 --> 01:31:24.011
OBERNOLTE GO AHEAD PLEASE.
01:31:24.078 --> 01:31:26.180
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR- MISTER
01:31:26.247 --> 01:31:27.548
BERMAN THIS IS A VERY IMPORTANT
01:31:27.615 --> 01:31:28.883
ISSUE I THINK YOU'RE RAISING A
01:31:28.950 --> 01:31:31.085
NORMALLY I AM VERY SKEPTICAL OF
01:31:31.152 --> 01:31:33.221
LEGISLATION THAT IT ATTEMPTS TO
01:31:33.287 --> 01:31:34.422
INSERT ITSELF INTO THE
01:31:34.488 --> 01:31:36.290
RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN A BUYER
01:31:36.357 --> 01:31:39.160
AND A SELLER BUT I THINK THAT.
01:31:39.227 --> 01:31:40.027
GOVERNMENT HAS AN IMPORTANT
01:31:40.094 --> 01:31:42.296
ROLE TO FILL IN ENSURING THAT
01:31:42.363 --> 01:31:44.999
FREE MARKETS FUNCTION AND EXIST
01:31:45.066 --> 01:31:47.168
AND IN THIS CASE I THINK THAT
01:31:47.235 --> 01:31:48.269
THE DEFINITION OF A FREE MARKET
01:31:48.336 --> 01:31:49.637
IS YOU KNOW YOU HAVE TO HAVE A
01:31:49.704 --> 01:31:50.838
WILLING BUYER AND A WILLING
01:31:50.905 --> 01:31:53.741
SELLER AND IF THE BUYER IS NOT
01:31:53.808 --> 01:31:55.209
WILLING TO PAY THE PRICE OF THE
01:31:55.276 --> 01:31:56.544
THAT RENEWAL SUBSCRIPTION
01:31:56.611 --> 01:31:57.511
BECAUSE THEY ARE ON AWARE OF
01:31:57.578 --> 01:31:58.613
IT. YOU KNOW I THINK THAT
01:31:58.679 --> 01:31:59.714
THAT'S A SERIOUS ISSUE THAT
01:31:59.780 --> 01:32:00.915
NEEDS TO BE ADDRESSED SO I MEAN
01:32:00.982 --> 01:32:02.717
I SEE WE HAVE A OPPOSE
01:32:02.783 --> 01:32:04.785
RECOMMENDATION ON MY ANALYSIS
01:32:04.852 --> 01:32:05.553
HERE BUT I REALLY THINK THAT
01:32:05.620 --> 01:32:06.354
YOU'RE RAISING AN ISSUE THAT
01:32:06.420 --> 01:32:08.055
NEEDS TO BE DEALT WITH. BOB I
01:32:08.122 --> 01:32:09.590
DO HOWEVER THINK THAT THE
01:32:09.657 --> 01:32:11.392
OPPOSITION HAS RAISED SOME GOOD
01:32:11.459 --> 01:32:13.728
POINTS AND IN PARTICULAR IF
01:32:13.794 --> 01:32:15.563
WE'RE MOVING FORWARD WITH THIS-
01:32:15.630 --> 01:32:17.198
I THINK THAT THE POINT ABOUT-
01:32:17.265 --> 01:32:21.168
VERY SHORT DESCRIPTIONS IT IS A
01:32:21.235 --> 01:32:23.404
GOOD ONE IF YOU HAVE A ONE DAY
01:32:23.471 --> 01:32:26.474
SUBSCRIPTION AND THERE'S THIS
01:32:26.540 --> 01:32:29.810
IS DESCRIBE EITHER ONE AT A
01:32:29.877 --> 01:32:33.080
TIME. I'LL BE DAY NOT IS NOT A
01:32:33.147 --> 01:32:36.050
TO HAVE THAT. ARE I THINK THE A
01:32:36.117 --> 01:32:37.985
GOOD CASE WAS MY RAISED ABOUT A
01:32:38.052 --> 01:32:39.420
SOME REASONABLE REQUIRE
01:32:39.487 --> 01:32:40.454
ESTABLISHED AND IT'S AN SUMER
01:32:40.521 --> 01:32:43.057
THAT'S SUBSCRIPTION SO YOU KNOW
01:32:43.124 --> 01:32:45.026
THE LANGUAGE IN THE BILL I WAS
01:32:45.092 --> 01:32:46.494
A LAST MINUTE AMEND. BUT I
01:32:46.560 --> 01:32:47.695
THINK IT NEEDS SOME TO AND TURN
01:32:47.762 --> 01:32:51.098
OF THE RE STAFF THAT THE- BLAUT
01:32:51.165 --> 01:32:56.337
CAKE YEAH. PROVIDE. THOSE I
01:32:56.404 --> 01:32:57.638
HAD. TO CANCEL OF THE SERVICE.
01:32:57.705 --> 01:32:58.839
ALSO TO THE CONCERNED JUST
01:32:58.906 --> 01:32:59.440
HEARD ABOUT. ABOUT ALTERNATE
01:32:59.507 --> 01:33:00.474
METHOD OF CANCELLATION FIRST IF
01:33:00.541 --> 01:33:01.008
YOU DON'T HAVE AN ELECT.
01:33:01.075 --> 01:33:02.310
RELATION WITH A CO. THAT'S
01:33:02.376 --> 01:33:03.110
REALLY NOT ADDRESS THE BILL I
01:33:03.177 --> 01:33:05.246
THINK THAT THOSE THINGS ARE-
01:33:05.313 --> 01:33:06.547
ARE THINGS THAT REALLY NEED TO
01:33:06.614 --> 01:33:08.849
BE. A FINISH UP AS THIS BILL
01:33:08.916 --> 01:33:09.784
MOVES FORWARD SO ARE THOSE
01:33:09.850 --> 01:33:11.552
THINGS THAT THAT YOU WERE
01:33:11.619 --> 01:33:12.486
PLANNING TO WORK ON WITH THE
01:33:12.553 --> 01:33:14.455
STAKEHOLDERS YES ABSOLUTELY.
01:33:14.522 --> 01:33:16.590
THE COMMENTS IN THE CONCERNS
01:33:16.657 --> 01:33:17.992
THAT WERE RAISED IN A REYES BY
01:33:18.059 --> 01:33:20.027
THE OPPOSITION WITH EIGHT SAT
01:33:20.094 --> 01:33:21.162
LAST FRIDAY- WITH I THINK
01:33:21.228 --> 01:33:23.264
EVERYBODY WHO WHO WAITED IN. IN
01:33:23.331 --> 01:33:24.765
OPPOSITION TODAY AND- TOTALLY
01:33:24.832 --> 01:33:26.067
AGREE WITH SOME OF THEIR POINT.
01:33:26.133 --> 01:33:28.970
AND ITS C. CONCERNED WITH SOME
01:33:29.036 --> 01:33:32.139
OTHER POINTS- ON THINGS LIKE.
01:33:32.206 --> 01:33:32.940
MORE ACNE TROLL OPTION FOR
01:33:33.007 --> 01:33:34.842
CANCELING. OPEN THAT AS ONE
01:33:34.909 --> 01:33:36.544
MAKE SURE THAT THE SOLUTION
01:33:36.610 --> 01:33:38.212
ISN'T. DOESN'T HAVE LOOPHOLES
01:33:38.279 --> 01:33:39.046
THAT ARE SO BIG YOU CAN DRIVE A
01:33:39.113 --> 01:33:40.915
TRUCK THROUGH- IT HAS BEEN
01:33:40.982 --> 01:33:43.050
DELICATELY BUT- ABSOLUTELY OPEN
01:33:43.117 --> 01:33:44.185
TO HAVING THOSE CONVERSATIONS
01:33:44.251 --> 01:33:47.121
AND- KIND OF. STRIKE A BETTER
01:33:47.188 --> 01:33:48.556
BALANCE OKAY WILL. BE WITH A
01:33:48.622 --> 01:33:50.491
COMMITMENT I THINK I CAN BE
01:33:50.558 --> 01:33:51.759
SUPPORTIVE. A IS THE BILL OVER
01:33:51.826 --> 01:33:56.931
HERE AND THE. AFTER POLLUTION
01:33:56.998 --> 01:33:58.566
ON THOSE WITH THE PARTICULARS
01:33:58.632 --> 01:33:59.367
PROJECT THAT THANK YOU. THANK
01:33:59.433 --> 01:34:00.167
YOU VERY MUCH OF MEDINA GO AT
01:34:00.234 --> 01:34:01.802
THE- THANK THE- FOR I THINK A
01:34:01.869 --> 01:34:04.805
VERY. SENSE BILL I. THINK THAT
01:34:04.872 --> 01:34:07.174
MANY TIMES SENIORS ESPECIALLY.
01:34:07.241 --> 01:34:10.611
ARE OPEN TO. NOT REALIZING THAT
01:34:10.678 --> 01:34:12.580
WHAT THEY HAVE- COMMITTED TO.
01:34:12.646 --> 01:34:14.448
AND THEN AS I THINK ONE OF
01:34:14.515 --> 01:34:17.151
YOUR- SPONSORS OF THE BILL
01:34:17.218 --> 01:34:20.421
SAID- YEAR AFTER YEAR. PAYING
01:34:20.488 --> 01:34:21.655
FOR SOMETHING THAT THEY'RE
01:34:21.722 --> 01:34:23.124
REALLY NOT USING AND NOT BEING
01:34:23.190 --> 01:34:25.359
AWARE THAT THEIR PAIN THAT ON
01:34:25.426 --> 01:34:27.294
THEIR- ON THEIR CREDIT CARD. SO
01:34:27.361 --> 01:34:30.898
THANK YOU MUCH FOR BRING THIS
01:34:30.965 --> 01:34:31.966
BILL FOR BRIDGES AT. THANK YOU
01:34:32.033 --> 01:34:35.202
MISTER KILEY GO AHEAD PLEASE
01:34:35.269 --> 01:34:38.406
HELLO MISTER BERMAN SO I YEAH I
01:34:38.472 --> 01:34:40.107
LIKED- SENATOR HERTZBERG'S BILL
01:34:40.174 --> 01:34:41.208
AND I THINK THIS IS A GOOD
01:34:41.275 --> 01:34:44.812
BILLS WHILE AND- I THINK THAT-
01:34:44.879 --> 01:34:49.150
YOU KNOW IT IS AN ANTI
01:34:49.216 --> 01:34:51.452
ARTIFICIAL BARRIERS TO ACCESS.
01:34:51.519 --> 01:34:53.888
AND THIS IS A GOOD EXAMPLE OF
01:34:53.954 --> 01:34:55.423
HOW POLICIES THAT ARE PRO
01:34:55.489 --> 01:34:56.457
MARKET ARE NOT ALWAYS NEARLY
01:34:56.524 --> 01:34:58.359
EMBRACE BY- INCUMBENT
01:34:58.426 --> 01:35:03.397
BUSINESSES AND- SO I'M MAD AT.
01:35:03.464 --> 01:35:05.166
PRETTY CONFIDENT GOING ALONG
01:35:05.232 --> 01:35:07.268
WITH THE TODAY MY BROAD CONCERN
01:35:07.334 --> 01:35:08.736
IS JUST THAT IF THIS BECOMES
01:35:08.803 --> 01:35:11.105
SORT OF A- BASIS FOR MASS
01:35:11.172 --> 01:35:13.074
LITIGATION AND YOU HAVE-
01:35:13.140 --> 01:35:15.176
COMPANIES OR WEBSITES THAT ARE.
01:35:15.242 --> 01:35:18.412
NOT TECHNICALLY COMPLYING WITH
01:35:18.479 --> 01:35:20.581
EVERY- PART OF THE BILL THEN
01:35:20.648 --> 01:35:21.982
SUDDENLY- THERE'S ANOTHER CLASS
01:35:22.049 --> 01:35:24.418
ACTION NINE SO THAT IT CAN YOU
01:35:24.485 --> 01:35:25.820
GIVE ME SOME ASSURANCE THERE
01:35:25.886 --> 01:35:26.787
THAT MAYBE THEY'LL BE SOME SAFE
01:35:26.854 --> 01:35:28.322
HARBORS ARE TO MAKE SURE THAT
01:35:28.389 --> 01:35:29.657
DIDN'T MISS VIOLATIONS DON'T
01:35:29.723 --> 01:35:32.560
RESULT IN HUGE LIABILITY. I CAN
01:35:32.626 --> 01:35:35.262
SAY THAT THAT MY INTENT IS NOT
01:35:35.329 --> 01:35:36.931
TO CREATE LAWSUITS- TO HAVE A
01:35:36.997 --> 01:35:38.599
CHAT WITH YOU ABOUT DIFFERENT
01:35:38.666 --> 01:35:40.468
WAYS YOU KNOW DIFFERENT OPTIONS
01:35:40.534 --> 01:35:45.806
TO. CREATE YES THAT THE- EITHER
01:35:45.873 --> 01:35:47.341
SAFE HARBORS ARE OR OTHER
01:35:47.408 --> 01:35:49.410
IDEAS- BUT THAT'S DEFINITELY
01:35:49.477 --> 01:35:53.881
NOT MY INTENT. THANK YOU. THANK
01:35:53.948 --> 01:35:55.883
YOU ADDITIONAL COMMENTS MR
01:35:55.950 --> 01:35:58.018
GALLAGHER AT PLEASE- WHAT ABOUT
01:35:58.085 --> 01:35:59.453
THE ISSUE BROUGHT UP BY A
01:35:59.520 --> 01:36:02.123
POSITION OF. IF FOR ALLOWING
01:36:02.189 --> 01:36:05.226
CANCELLATION. IN THE MIDDLE OF
01:36:05.292 --> 01:36:07.428
A CYCLE YOUR ALLOWING THAT TO
01:36:07.495 --> 01:36:08.796
BASICALLY THIS AND AT THE END
01:36:08.863 --> 01:36:10.131
OF THAT CYCLE IS THAT SOME YOUR
01:36:10.197 --> 01:36:11.799
WORKI THAT'S SOMETHING THAT I
01:36:11.866 --> 01:36:13.467
DO AGREE WITH. SO WE'RE GONNA
01:36:13.534 --> 01:36:15.002
MAKE THAT CHANGE AND WORK WITH
01:36:15.069 --> 01:36:16.103
THE OPPOSITION TO MAKE THAT
01:36:16.170 --> 01:36:17.138
CHANGE WITH THAT WAS A NINE
01:36:17.204 --> 01:36:18.939
TEN. IN IN DRAFTING THE INITIAL
01:36:19.006 --> 01:36:20.007
LANGUAGE AND STUFF I DON'T WANT
01:36:20.074 --> 01:36:22.643
TO. CREATE THAT OPPORTUNITY
01:36:22.710 --> 01:36:27.481
FOR. CUSTOMERS. THANK YOU VERY
01:36:27.548 --> 01:36:30.384
MUCH- THERE ARE NO ADDITIONAL
01:36:30.451 --> 01:36:34.488
COMMENTS SO. I WANT TO THANK-
01:36:34.555 --> 01:36:36.090
THE ASSEMBLY MEMBER FOR
01:36:36.157 --> 01:36:37.491
CARRYING THIS BILL IN THIS IS A
01:36:37.558 --> 01:36:39.527
VERY- CONSUMER FRIENDLY BUILT
01:36:39.593 --> 01:36:42.229
AND- AND I ALSO WANT TO THANK
01:36:42.296 --> 01:36:43.297
YOU FOR AGREEING TO WORK ON
01:36:43.364 --> 01:36:44.365
SOME OF THE ISSUES THAT'S BEEN
01:36:44.431 --> 01:36:46.066
RAISED I THINK SOME OF THEM-
01:36:46.133 --> 01:36:48.002
WERE RAISED IN THE ANALYSIS AS
01:36:48.068 --> 01:36:49.069
WELL I THINK ONE OF WHICH I
01:36:49.136 --> 01:36:50.938
JUST WANNA. ARE SINGLE OUT IS
01:36:51.005 --> 01:36:52.406
THE AUTHENTICATION PIECE I
01:36:52.473 --> 01:36:54.041
THINK WE IS WOULD BE IMPORTANT
01:36:54.108 --> 01:36:56.577
OUR FOR- BOTH SIDES TO
01:36:56.644 --> 01:36:58.579
UNDERSTAND TO VERIFY THAT. THE
01:36:58.646 --> 01:36:59.713
PERSON. PERSON DOING
01:36:59.780 --> 01:37:01.749
CANCELLATIONS INDYCAR PERSON SO
01:37:01.815 --> 01:37:04.185
YEAH SO I APPRECIATE THAT YOU
01:37:04.251 --> 01:37:04.885
KNOW YOUR AGREEMENT YOUR
01:37:04.952 --> 01:37:07.321
WILLINGNESS TO WORK. OUR AND-
01:37:07.388 --> 01:37:09.023
SO WITH THAT HI I THINK THE
01:37:09.089 --> 01:37:09.890
BILL HAS BEEN MOVED AND
01:37:09.957 --> 01:37:11.725
SECONDED SO WOULD YOU PLEASE.
01:37:11.792 --> 01:37:15.329
CLOSE OUR- OF ROMA CLOSE. FREE
01:37:15.396 --> 01:37:16.096
**** ALL THE COMMENTS
01:37:16.163 --> 01:37:17.198
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE
01:37:17.264 --> 01:37:18.465
VOTE DUBLIN OR WITH THE
01:37:18.532 --> 01:37:20.634
OPPONENTS AND- YOU KNOW AGREE
01:37:20.701 --> 01:37:22.102
WITH A LOT OF THE ISSUES OF
01:37:22.169 --> 01:37:23.604
RACE TODAY. THANK YOU WITH
01:37:23.671 --> 01:37:25.573
THAT- MADAM SECRETARY WOULD YOU
01:37:25.639 --> 01:37:27.208
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL FOR ME.
01:37:27.274 --> 01:37:28.709
THE MOTION IS TO PASS AS
01:37:28.776 --> 01:37:30.678
AMENDED TO THE ASSEMBLY FOR
01:37:30.744 --> 01:37:34.481
CHILD HI. KILEY THERE ARE CAN.
01:37:34.548 --> 01:37:38.719
BERMAN HI. MEDINA CARILLO
01:37:38.786 --> 01:37:44.491
MULLIN GALLAGHER. IRWIN
01:37:44.558 --> 01:37:48.195
OBERNOLTE FIVE WICKS HI YOU
01:37:48.262 --> 01:37:51.765
BILLS OUT CONGRATULATIONS. UP I
01:37:51.832 --> 01:37:54.034
NOTICED SAID DR WEBER IS HERE
01:37:54.101 --> 01:37:56.704
IN THE ROOM SO LET ME INVITE
01:37:56.770 --> 01:37:58.606
DOCTOR WEAPON TO COME PRISON
01:37:58.672 --> 01:38:00.608
COME UP AND PRESENT HER BUILT
01:38:00.674 --> 01:38:02.910
AND AS A REMINDER FOR THOSE
01:38:02.977 --> 01:38:04.378
WISHING TO REGISTER THEIR
01:38:04.445 --> 01:38:07.181
SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION BY PHONE
01:38:07.248 --> 01:38:09.250
I ENCOURAGE YOU TO CALL IN NOW
01:38:09.316 --> 01:38:09.984
AT THE BEGINNING OF THE
01:38:10.050 --> 01:38:12.086
ASSEMBLYMEMBERS TESTIMONY. I
01:38:12.152 --> 01:38:13.320
JUST TO AVOID DELAYS THE PHONE
01:38:13.387 --> 01:38:20.427
NUMBER AGAIN IS. 877-692-8957
01:38:20.494 --> 01:38:21.528
AND I WANT TO WELCOME BACK TO
01:38:21.595 --> 01:38:23.564
WEBER TO OUR COMMUNITY AND SHE
01:38:23.631 --> 01:38:26.467
HOUSE SO AB TWENTY FOUR FORTY
01:38:26.533 --> 01:38:27.401
THREE TWO PERCENT- SO ANYTIME
01:38:27.468 --> 01:38:30.237
YOU'RE READY DOCTOR WEBER YOU
01:38:30.304 --> 01:38:33.207
MAY PROCEED. THANK YOU FOR THE
01:38:33.274 --> 01:38:35.075
OPPORTUNITY TO PREVENT AB
01:38:35.142 --> 01:38:38.212
TWENTY FOUR FORTY. OKAY THANK
01:38:38.279 --> 01:38:40.147
YOU STAFFERS CALL FOR HELPING
01:38:40.214 --> 01:38:43.751
NINE MY FELLOW. BOB PUTTING
01:38:43.817 --> 01:38:45.319
BILL TOGETHER AND WORKING IN
01:38:45.386 --> 01:38:47.721
RECENT TO BE PATIENT WITH HIM.
01:38:47.788 --> 01:38:49.790
AND HOPEFULLY A LOT IF YOU
01:38:49.857 --> 01:38:54.161
COULD IN OTHER SINGLE ALL OF
01:38:54.228 --> 01:39:02.503
THIS MAKES THIS BILL SIXTY.
01:39:02.569 --> 01:39:09.910
YEAH. MOVE THEIR OPPOSITION BUT
01:39:09.977 --> 01:39:11.011
IT SHOULD BE NOTED THAT BANKS
01:39:11.078 --> 01:39:12.813
AND CREDIT UNIONS ARE NOT THE
01:39:12.880 --> 01:39:14.682
TARGET OF THIS LEGISLATION.
01:39:14.748 --> 01:39:16.150
DEBT SETTLEMENT COMPANIES ARE
01:39:16.216 --> 01:39:18.285
TARGETED AND EVERY TIME ARGUES
01:39:18.352 --> 01:39:20.788
TARGETED ADVERTISING TO PREYON
01:39:20.854 --> 01:39:22.022
CALIFORNIANS STRUGGLING WITH
01:39:22.089 --> 01:39:23.991
DEBT. THEY PROMISE CONSUMERS
01:39:24.058 --> 01:39:25.059
THAT THEY WILL SIGNIFICANTLY
01:39:25.125 --> 01:39:26.493
REDUCE THE DEBT BY NEGOTIATING
01:39:26.560 --> 01:39:28.128
WITH THE CREDITORS AND STOPPING
01:39:28.195 --> 01:39:30.064
COLLECTION ACTIVITIES. HOWEVER
01:39:30.130 --> 01:39:31.532
INSTEAD OF NEGOTIATING WITH
01:39:31.598 --> 01:39:33.233
CREDITORS SOME COMPANIES SIMPLY
01:39:33.300 --> 01:39:35.035
TAKE THE MONEY WHEN THE
01:39:35.102 --> 01:39:36.203
CONSUMERS COMPLAIN THE DEBT
01:39:36.270 --> 01:39:37.571
SETTLEMENT COMPANY DISAPPEARS
01:39:37.638 --> 01:39:39.173
OUR CLAIMS THAT NO MONEY IS
01:39:39.239 --> 01:39:41.608
LEFT DUE TO THEIR FEES. BEHIND
01:39:41.675 --> 01:39:42.309
THESE FLY BY NIGHT COMPANIES
01:39:42.376 --> 01:39:44.278
ARE PRO RAIDERS WHO COLLECT THE
01:39:44.345 --> 01:39:45.713
MONEY FROM CONSUMERS TO PAY
01:39:45.779 --> 01:39:47.614
CREDITORS BUT IN MANY CASES
01:39:47.681 --> 01:39:49.416
FIND PRETEXT TO KEEP IT. THIS
01:39:49.483 --> 01:39:51.085
POLICY SERVES ALL CALIFORNIANS
01:39:51.151 --> 01:39:52.786
BUT WILL HAVE THE GREATEST
01:39:52.853 --> 01:39:54.188
IMPACT ON PROTECTING THE MOST
01:39:54.254 --> 01:39:55.656
VULNERABLE POPULATIONS.
01:39:55.723 --> 01:39:57.291
FAMILIES OF COLORED NON ENGLISH
01:39:57.358 --> 01:39:58.659
SPEAKING FAMILIES SENIORS AND
01:39:58.726 --> 01:40:00.661
DISABLED INDIVIDUALS LIVING ON
01:40:00.728 --> 01:40:02.262
A FIXED INCOME. CONSUMERS ONE
01:40:02.329 --> 01:40:03.564
ROLE IN DEBT SETTLEMENT A
01:40:03.630 --> 01:40:05.499
SERVICES DO NOT UNDERSTAND THE
01:40:05.566 --> 01:40:06.600
NEGATIVE IMPACT ON THE CREDIT
01:40:06.667 --> 01:40:08.469
REPORT. THAT THEY CAN STILL AND
01:40:08.535 --> 01:40:10.304
IN MANY CASES BE SOON FOR AN
01:40:10.371 --> 01:40:12.773
ENROLLED- DEBT. AND SIX AND
01:40:12.840 --> 01:40:14.108
THAT SUCCESSFUL DEBT SETTLEMENT
01:40:14.174 --> 01:40:16.210
SERVICES REQUIRE AN AVERAGE OF
01:40:16.276 --> 01:40:17.611
FOUR YEARS OF PARTICIPATION
01:40:17.678 --> 01:40:19.079
BEFORE MOST OF THE IN ROLE DEBT
01:40:19.146 --> 01:40:20.714
WILL BE SETTLED. WITH AN
01:40:20.781 --> 01:40:21.849
UNPRECEDENTED NUMBER OF
01:40:21.915 --> 01:40:23.650
AMERICANS FACING AN EMPLOYMENT
01:40:23.717 --> 01:40:24.151
AS A RESULT OF COAL BUT
01:40:24.218 --> 01:40:26.553
NINETEEN. WE ANTICIPATE A LARGE
01:40:26.620 --> 01:40:28.222
RISE IN CONSUMER DEBT-
01:40:28.288 --> 01:40:31.225
ESPECIALLY AS MANY CALIFORNIANS
01:40:31.291 --> 01:40:31.725
ALREADY LIVE PAYCHECK TO
01:40:31.792 --> 01:40:33.227
PAYCHECK. DURING THIS TIME THE
01:40:33.293 --> 01:40:34.762
NEED TO HAUL DECEPTION IN DEBT
01:40:34.828 --> 01:40:36.497
SETTLEMENT IS HEIGHTENED. THE
01:40:36.563 --> 01:40:37.531
NORTH CAROLINA ATTORNEY
01:40:37.598 --> 01:40:38.732
GENERAL'S OFFICE HAS ISSUED A
01:40:38.799 --> 01:40:40.601
WARNING THAT UNSCRUPULOUS DEBT
01:40:40.667 --> 01:40:42.503
SETTLEMENT COMPANIES WILL PREY
01:40:42.569 --> 01:40:44.204
ON UNEMPLOYED AND FINANCIALLY
01:40:44.271 --> 01:40:46.273
STRUGGLING CONSUMERS. IN FACT
01:40:46.340 --> 01:40:47.641
EVEN GOOGLE HAS RECOGNIZED THE
01:40:47.708 --> 01:40:49.276
HARM CAUSED BY MISLEADING AND
01:40:49.343 --> 01:40:50.944
DECEPTIVE BUT ADVERTISEMENT.
01:40:51.011 --> 01:40:52.179
FROM DEBT SETTLEMENT COMPANIES
01:40:52.246 --> 01:40:54.114
AND HAS IMPLEMENTED A POLICY OF
01:40:54.181 --> 01:40:55.048
RESTRICTING ADS FROM
01:40:55.115 --> 01:40:56.617
UNREGULATED DEBT SETTLEMENT
01:40:56.683 --> 01:40:59.787
COMPANIES. AB TWENTY FOUR FORTY
01:40:59.853 --> 01:41:00.387
THREE WOULD PROVIDE A PATHWAY
01:41:00.454 --> 01:41:01.522
FOR INJURES CONSUMERS TO
01:41:01.588 --> 01:41:02.890
RECOVER THE MONEY TAKEN FROM
01:41:02.956 --> 01:41:05.759
THEM. BY PREDATORY ENTITIES.
01:41:05.826 --> 01:41:06.927
THIS BILL WILL HOLD THE PAYMENT
01:41:06.994 --> 01:41:08.095
PROCESSING COMPANIES
01:41:08.162 --> 01:41:09.196
RESPONSIBLE FOR THEIR
01:41:09.263 --> 01:41:10.631
MISLEADING PRACTICES. BY
01:41:10.697 --> 01:41:12.766
EXPLICITLY STIPULATING IN LAW
01:41:12.833 --> 01:41:14.067
THAT PRO RATE IS ARE INCLUDED
01:41:14.134 --> 01:41:15.569
UNDER THE CALIFORNIA CONSUMER
01:41:15.636 --> 01:41:19.173
LEGAL REMEDIES ACT. AB TWENTY
01:41:19.239 --> 01:41:19.640
FOUR FORTY FORTY THREE
01:41:19.706 --> 01:41:20.574
SPECIFIED THAT CALIFORNIA'S
01:41:20.641 --> 01:41:22.810
DEBT SETTLEMENT LAW DOES APPLY.
01:41:22.876 --> 01:41:24.711
TO ATTORNEYS AND LAW FIRMS.
01:41:24.778 --> 01:41:25.979
THIS BILL IS STRUCTURED IN A
01:41:26.046 --> 01:41:27.247
WAY THAT REQUIRED DISCLOSURES
01:41:27.314 --> 01:41:29.249
OF GIVEN- TO GIVE CONSUMERS
01:41:29.316 --> 01:41:31.385
FAIR PRACTICE. FOR NOTICE ABOUT
01:41:31.452 --> 01:41:33.020
WHETHER A DEBT SETTLEMENT PLAN
01:41:33.086 --> 01:41:34.188
IS RIGHT IS THE RIGHT OPTION
01:41:34.254 --> 01:41:35.756
FOR THEM. AND PROHIBIT FALSE
01:41:35.823 --> 01:41:36.890
AND MISLEADING STATEMENTS ABOUT
01:41:36.957 --> 01:41:39.426
THE IMPACT OF DEBT SETTLEMENT
01:41:39.493 --> 01:41:40.828
ON A CONSUMER DEBT. UGH TO
01:41:40.894 --> 01:41:43.096
TESTIFY TODAY WITH ME ON PHONE
01:41:43.163 --> 01:41:45.499
IS DANIELLE CANDLE KAISER ON
01:41:45.566 --> 01:41:46.600
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA LOW
01:41:46.667 --> 01:41:48.402
INCOME CONSUMER COALITION ONE
01:41:48.469 --> 01:41:50.037
OF THE SPONSORS OF THE BILL AND
01:41:50.103 --> 01:41:52.806
CLEAR JOHNSON ROLE HAAS FROM UC
01:41:52.873 --> 01:41:54.741
IRVINE'S CONSUMER LAW CLINIC.
01:41:54.808 --> 01:41:56.076
THANK YOU VERY MUCH- LET'S NOW
01:41:56.143 --> 01:41:57.444
TURN TO THE WITNESSES SO AS
01:41:57.511 --> 01:42:01.181
MISSION. MS KAISER OR MISS YES
01:42:01.248 --> 01:42:05.786
GET OUT. GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIR
01:42:05.853 --> 01:42:07.287
AND MEMBERS DANIEL COUNTER
01:42:07.354 --> 01:42:08.422
BECAUSE YOU'RE SPEAKING ON
01:42:08.489 --> 01:42:10.090
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA LOW
01:42:10.157 --> 01:42:12.059
INCOME CONSUMER COALITION WE
01:42:12.125 --> 01:42:14.661
ARE THE FUNCTIONS AND EIGHTY
01:42:14.728 --> 01:42:15.629
TWO FOUR FOUR THREE. AGAIN
01:42:15.696 --> 01:42:17.331
CLICK OF A COALITION OF MORE
01:42:17.397 --> 01:42:18.866
THAN A DOZEN LEGALLY PROVIDERS
01:42:18.932 --> 01:42:19.933
FROM AROUND THE STATE TO
01:42:20.000 --> 01:42:21.735
COLLECTIVELY THIRTY THOUSAND
01:42:21.802 --> 01:42:23.871
LOW INCOME CONSUMERS EVERY YEAR
01:42:23.937 --> 01:42:25.506
AND IT'S MEMBERS WORK TOGETHER
01:42:25.572 --> 01:42:26.406
TO ENSURE THAT LOW INCOME
01:42:26.473 --> 01:42:27.908
CALIFORNIANS HAVE ACCESS TO ALL
01:42:27.975 --> 01:42:30.210
OF THE PROTECTION OF CALIFORNIA
01:42:30.277 --> 01:42:32.312
LAW. WE APPLAUD DR WEBBER'S
01:42:32.379 --> 01:42:34.481
AUTHORSHIP OF AB TWO FOUR FOUR
01:42:34.548 --> 01:42:35.315
THREE IN THE PROTECTIONS THAT
01:42:35.382 --> 01:42:37.251
WOULD PROVIDE CONSUMERS. WE
01:42:37.317 --> 01:42:38.485
ALSO THANK THE BANKERS AND THE
01:42:38.552 --> 01:42:40.153
CREDIT UNION FOR THE TIME
01:42:40.220 --> 01:42:42.356
THEY'VE TAKEN TO WORK WITH US
01:42:42.422 --> 01:42:44.224
ON THIS BILL LANGUAGE. A DOCTOR
01:42:44.291 --> 01:42:46.660
WEBER HAS STATED THE GOAL OF AB
01:42:46.727 --> 01:42:47.594
TWO FOUR FOUR THREE IS TO AMEND
01:42:47.661 --> 01:42:50.664
THE LRA TO CLEARLY DEFINE HOW
01:42:50.731 --> 01:42:52.266
DEBT SETTLEMENT COMPANY SHOULD
01:42:52.332 --> 01:42:54.201
OPERATE IN CALIFORNIA. AND TO
01:42:54.268 --> 01:42:56.236
ENSURE THE CUTS THAT CONSUMERS
01:42:56.303 --> 01:42:57.137
HAVE THE ABILITY TO BRING AN
01:42:57.204 --> 01:42:59.106
ACTION FOR DAMAGES VIOLATIONS
01:42:59.172 --> 01:43:02.409
LAW. REGULATING THAT SETTLEMENT
01:43:02.476 --> 01:43:03.844
PRACTICES HAVE OCCURRED. THANK
01:43:03.911 --> 01:43:05.178
CREATING PART ABOUT CAN BE
01:43:05.245 --> 01:43:06.880
PROBLEMATIC ESPECIALLY IN THE
01:43:06.947 --> 01:43:08.849
STATUTE OF COMPRISES THE FEEL
01:43:08.916 --> 01:43:10.651
ALRIGHT. WE'RE COMMITTED TO
01:43:10.717 --> 01:43:11.685
CONTINUE TO WORK WITH THE
01:43:11.752 --> 01:43:13.086
STAKEHOLDERS ON LANGUAGE
01:43:13.153 --> 01:43:15.022
RELATING TO COVERAGE. ENSURING
01:43:15.088 --> 01:43:16.189
SURE THAT DEPOSITORY
01:43:16.256 --> 01:43:17.624
INSTITUTIONS THAT ARE NOT THE
01:43:17.691 --> 01:43:20.093
CAUSE OF THE PROBLEM OR NOT
01:43:20.160 --> 01:43:21.295
HELD LIABLE. BUT THAT PAYMENT
01:43:21.361 --> 01:43:22.863
PROCESSORS BUT ARE DEEPLY
01:43:22.930 --> 01:43:24.298
ENMESHED IN THE DEBT HELLO MY
01:43:24.364 --> 01:43:27.000
EFFORTS ARE IDENTIFIED AND MADE
01:43:27.067 --> 01:43:28.669
ACCOUNTABLE FOR THEIR ACTIONS.
01:43:28.735 --> 01:43:30.237
I'M DOCTOR WEBER HAS STATED
01:43:30.304 --> 01:43:31.672
WHILE GOOGLE HAS RESTRICTED
01:43:31.738 --> 01:43:33.240
THAT PUBLIC COMPANIES
01:43:33.307 --> 01:43:34.875
ADVERTISING WE'RE NOW SEEING
01:43:34.942 --> 01:43:37.477
THE ARRIVAL. OF THE CODE
01:43:37.544 --> 01:43:38.612
NINETEEN RELATED ACADEMIC
01:43:38.679 --> 01:43:40.447
ECONOMIC RECESSION AND AN
01:43:40.514 --> 01:43:42.382
INCREASE IN RADIO TV AND SOCIAL
01:43:42.449 --> 01:43:45.218
MEDIA ADVERTISEMENTS BY
01:43:45.285 --> 01:43:47.154
UNSCRUPULOUS ACTORS. HILL
01:43:47.220 --> 01:43:48.922
STRAIGHT TALK TO WEBBER'S
01:43:48.989 --> 01:43:50.290
POINT. A FREQUENT FALSE
01:43:50.357 --> 01:43:51.858
STATEMENT IN THEIR EYES IS
01:43:51.925 --> 01:43:54.294
QUOTE HEY NOTHING AND CLEARED
01:43:54.361 --> 01:43:55.796
THAT IT STARTLED. THAT
01:43:55.862 --> 01:43:57.264
PARLIAMENT COMPANIES DO CHARGE
01:43:57.331 --> 01:43:59.499
UP FRONT FEES OR THE SUBTLE ONE
01:43:59.566 --> 01:44:02.102
SMALL THAT AND THEN BEGIN TO
01:44:02.169 --> 01:44:03.570
TAKE ALL OF THEIR FEES. THEY
01:44:03.637 --> 01:44:04.972
OFFERED TO STOP THE DEBT
01:44:05.038 --> 01:44:06.373
COLLECTORS FROM CALLING BUT
01:44:06.440 --> 01:44:08.141
THAT DOES NOT MAKE CLEAR THAT
01:44:08.208 --> 01:44:09.643
THEY ENCOURAGE THE CUSTOMER TO
01:44:09.710 --> 01:44:11.945
STOP PAYING ALL THAT. INDIRECT
01:44:12.012 --> 01:44:13.313
ALL COMMUNICATION FROM THE
01:44:13.380 --> 01:44:14.781
CREDITOR TO THE DEBT SETTLEMENT
01:44:14.848 --> 01:44:16.950
COMPANY. THIS BUSINESS MODEL
01:44:17.017 --> 01:44:18.418
LEAVES THE CONSUMER THINKING
01:44:18.485 --> 01:44:21.855
THAT IT IT IS. EVERYTHING FINE
01:44:21.922 --> 01:44:22.556
WELL IT WRECKS THE CONSUMER'S
01:44:22.623 --> 01:44:24.157
CREDIT. AND ARE CAUGHT BY
01:44:24.224 --> 01:44:26.727
SURPRISE REALLY CREDIBLE FILED
01:44:26.793 --> 01:44:28.829
A LAWSUIT TO COLLECT. INITIALLY
01:44:28.895 --> 01:44:30.097
THE COMPANY STRONGLY DISCOURAGE
01:44:30.163 --> 01:44:31.932
CUSTOMERS FROM SEEKING REMEDIES
01:44:31.999 --> 01:44:33.667
SO OFTEN WORKS VERY WELL. SUCH
01:44:33.734 --> 01:44:35.469
A DEBT CONSOLIDATION AND THE
01:44:35.535 --> 01:44:36.970
NEGOTIATING DOWN OF THE
01:44:37.037 --> 01:44:39.039
CONSUMERS CURRENT THAT. THEY'RE
01:44:39.106 --> 01:44:40.474
OUT CALL THESE FORMS OF DEBT
01:44:40.540 --> 01:44:43.610
MANAGEMENT QUOTE CUMBERSOME AND
01:44:43.677 --> 01:44:45.846
UNDESIRABLE. IN CLOSING WITH
01:44:45.912 --> 01:44:47.280
THE RECESSION WE NOW FACE IT IS
01:44:47.347 --> 01:44:48.982
MORE IMPORTANT THAN EVER TO
01:44:49.049 --> 01:44:50.083
PROVIDE CLEAR AND COMPLETE
01:44:50.150 --> 01:44:52.986
PROTECTION TO CONSUMERS WHO ARE
01:44:53.053 --> 01:44:54.321
TRYING TO MANAGE THEIR FINANCES.
01:44:54.388 --> 01:44:56.023
AB TWO FOUR FOUR THREE WILL GET
01:44:56.089 --> 01:44:57.290
CALIFORNIANS THE PROTECTIONS
01:44:57.357 --> 01:44:58.825
THAT THEY NOW NEED I HAVE
01:44:58.892 --> 01:45:00.594
ALWAYS TO START WE URGE YOUR
01:45:00.661 --> 01:45:03.630
AYE THAT. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
01:45:03.697 --> 01:45:04.197
SHALL LET'S NOW TURN TO MISS
01:45:04.264 --> 01:45:08.335
ROSA. A GOOD AFTERNOON MY NAME
01:45:08.402 --> 01:45:09.603
IS QUITE FRANKLY ROCKED BY AND
01:45:09.670 --> 01:45:11.104
THE CLINICAL TEACHING FELLOW IN
01:45:11.171 --> 01:45:12.973
THE CONSUMER LAW CLINIC AT UC
01:45:13.040 --> 01:45:15.075
IRVINE AND PROVIDING TESTIMONY
01:45:15.142 --> 01:45:18.078
TODAY IN SUPPORT AND EIGHTY TWO
01:45:18.145 --> 01:45:18.679
FOUR THREE THREE ON BEHALF OF
01:45:18.745 --> 01:45:19.746
CLIENTS TO THE CLINIC AND ALL
01:45:19.813 --> 01:45:21.048
QUIRK A MEMBER OF THE
01:45:21.114 --> 01:45:23.750
CALIFORNIAN LOW INCOME
01:45:23.817 --> 01:45:25.052
CONSUMERS. OR THE XIN. I TO
01:45:25.118 --> 01:45:26.386
JOINING YEAH I LIVE A LONG
01:45:26.453 --> 01:45:29.089
LEGAL CONSUMER RIGHT TURN. MY
01:45:29.156 --> 01:45:30.490
CLAIMS NEED ALL OF THEIR IN TO.
01:45:30.557 --> 01:45:32.225
THEMSELVES AMERICA. THAT
01:45:32.292 --> 01:45:33.126
SETTLEMENT COMPANIES THAT
01:45:33.193 --> 01:45:35.495
TARGET LOW INCOME CONSUMERS DO
01:45:35.562 --> 01:45:36.329
NOT HELP PEOPLE GET OUT OF
01:45:36.396 --> 01:45:38.899
THAT. INSTEAD THEY PROMISED.
01:45:38.965 --> 01:45:41.068
THE CARD HIGH. AND LOW PEOPLE
01:45:41.134 --> 01:45:43.103
AND WITH MISLEADING ADVERTISING
01:45:43.170 --> 01:45:45.238
THAT PROMISES UNOBTAINABLE FIX
01:45:45.305 --> 01:45:46.540
AND FOR PEOPLE STRUGGLING WITH
01:45:46.606 --> 01:45:47.974
THAT. IN THIS TIME THE MORE
01:45:48.041 --> 01:45:49.710
THAN FOUR MILLION CALIFORNIANS
01:45:49.776 --> 01:45:51.311
ARE OUT OF WORK THE TO THE CLUB
01:45:51.378 --> 01:45:53.880
IN NINETEEN CRISIS. CREDIT CARD
01:45:53.947 --> 01:45:55.082
BILLS ARE PILING NOT. PEOPLE
01:45:55.148 --> 01:45:56.183
WHO ARE STRUGGLING FINANCIALLY
01:45:56.249 --> 01:45:58.819
FALL PREY TO DAMPEN SOLUTION
01:45:58.885 --> 01:46:00.053
I'M TOO GOOD TO BE TRUE I
01:46:00.120 --> 01:46:00.854
PROMISE THERE'S BEEN
01:46:00.921 --> 01:46:02.889
SCRUPULOUS. ABOUT COMPANIES.
01:46:02.956 --> 01:46:04.057
THE PROMISED TO STOP ALL THE
01:46:04.124 --> 01:46:05.659
COLLECTION ACTIVITY CHEAPER
01:46:05.726 --> 01:46:10.530
DEFAULT. THAT CREDIT CARD DEBT.
01:46:10.597 --> 01:46:12.332
I THE CONSUMER RIGHT I WORKED
01:46:12.399 --> 01:46:14.801
WITH CAN TO YOU TO LEGAL. I IS
01:46:14.868 --> 01:46:16.403
HELP WITH THE DEBT BECAUSE WALK
01:46:16.470 --> 01:46:18.004
THE- BAFFLED BECAUSE THEY WERE
01:46:18.071 --> 01:46:19.873
IN IN THE DEATH SADDAM PLAN PAY
01:46:19.940 --> 01:46:21.041
MY- EVERY. THAT THEY THOUGHT
01:46:21.108 --> 01:46:22.476
WILL GO TO I DON'T THAT AND
01:46:22.542 --> 01:46:23.343
STUFF BUT- FROM TRYING TO
01:46:23.410 --> 01:46:26.313
COLLECT. SOME OF MY LEGAL AID
01:46:26.379 --> 01:46:26.880
COLLEAGUES REPORT THAT MORE
01:46:26.947 --> 01:46:27.848
THAN. OF THE- TO COLLECTION
01:46:27.914 --> 01:46:29.416
LONG DEFENDANTS COMING IN HELP.
01:46:29.483 --> 01:46:31.818
OUR IN BOLD IN A AT SOME. OKAY
01:46:31.885 --> 01:46:33.420
CONSUMERS SURPRISE TO LEARN
01:46:33.487 --> 01:46:34.254
THAT THE DEBT SETTLEMENT
01:46:34.321 --> 01:46:35.589
COMPANIES AREN'T SPENDING MONEY
01:46:35.655 --> 01:46:37.124
TO THEIR CREDITORS AND THEN
01:46:37.190 --> 01:46:38.892
INSTEAD THE- CARBURETOR. I
01:46:38.959 --> 01:46:40.460
KEEPING LARGE AMOUNTS AND FEES
01:46:40.527 --> 01:46:42.095
FOR CONSUMERS REMAIN AT RISK OF
01:46:42.162 --> 01:46:43.630
BEING SUED AND THE CREDIT FOR
01:46:43.697 --> 01:46:44.998
IT. THANK BECAUSE THEIR
01:46:45.065 --> 01:46:46.433
ENCOURAGED TO DEFAULT ON ALL
01:46:46.500 --> 01:46:48.101
DAY THAT. I REPRESENTED A
01:46:48.168 --> 01:46:50.003
SENIOR CITIZEN PLANT LIVING IN
01:46:50.070 --> 01:46:51.738
SUBSIDIZED HOUSING THE PAID
01:46:51.805 --> 01:46:52.873
OVER SIX HUNDRED DOLLARS EVERY
01:46:52.939 --> 01:46:54.708
MONTH. ONE IN 50% OF HER
01:46:54.775 --> 01:46:55.942
MONTHLY INCOME COULD THAT
01:46:56.009 --> 01:46:57.477
HURDLE THAT COMPANY FOR OVER
01:46:57.544 --> 01:47:00.013
THREE YEARS. MY CLIENT WOULD GO
01:47:00.080 --> 01:47:00.781
TO FOOD PANTRY BECAUSE THEIR
01:47:00.847 --> 01:47:02.215
FOOD MONEY THE COUNTY THAT THAT
01:47:02.282 --> 01:47:03.617
PART OF MY COMPANY. AND SHE IS
01:47:03.683 --> 01:47:05.318
NOT ALONE CONSUMERS LIVING ON A
01:47:05.385 --> 01:47:07.287
FIXED INCOME FROM SOCIAL
01:47:07.354 --> 01:47:16.396
SECURITY SSI OR DISABILITY. AT.
01:47:16.463 --> 01:47:19.432
YOUR HONOR I'M AND IT. TELL ME
01:47:19.499 --> 01:47:20.534
SOMETHING I DON'T PARTICULARLY
01:47:20.600 --> 01:47:22.836
AGREED THAT THE QUIRK PRO IT
01:47:22.903 --> 01:47:24.504
AND ALL THAT AND HE FEET FROM
01:47:24.571 --> 01:47:25.872
AND CON IS PROTECTED FROM THE
01:47:25.939 --> 01:47:29.242
CO AT. THAT COMPANIES SOCIAL
01:47:29.309 --> 01:47:32.179
FIVE AND WISH ON THE BUS STOP
01:47:32.245 --> 01:47:32.779
THE FLYERS ON TELEPHONE POLES
01:47:32.846 --> 01:47:36.850
IN DIRECT MAIL. AB TWO FOR
01:47:36.917 --> 01:47:38.819
FORTY YEARS REQUIRE DISK TO THE
01:47:38.885 --> 01:47:40.320
FOLDER PLAN POPULAR. REGARDING
01:47:40.387 --> 01:47:41.454
DANGERS OF THAT PART AND THAT
01:47:41.521 --> 01:47:43.056
PEOPLE GOV BENEFITS TO PROTECT
01:47:43.123 --> 01:47:44.558
FROM WAIT FURNISHED. IT ALSO
01:47:44.624 --> 01:47:45.525
SEEKS TO PROTECT NOT IN THE
01:47:45.592 --> 01:47:47.427
SPEAKING. BUY ENSURING THAT
01:47:47.494 --> 01:47:48.495
CONTRACTOR WRITTEN IN THE
01:47:48.562 --> 01:47:51.932
LANGUAGE OF WHICH AND GOSH IT.
01:47:51.998 --> 01:47:52.566
EIGHTY TWO FOUR FOUR THREE ADDS
01:47:52.632 --> 01:47:53.900
TO THE TOOL KIT FOR CONSUMER
01:47:53.967 --> 01:47:55.168
ADVOCATES I ENSURING WE CAN
01:47:55.235 --> 01:47:55.936
HOLD THESE COMPANIES
01:47:56.002 --> 01:47:58.205
ACCOUNTABLE BUT IN A PROMISES
01:47:58.271 --> 01:47:59.439
TO OUR CLIENTS THAT THEY CAN'T
01:47:59.506 --> 01:48:01.408
WAIT TO PROTECT LOW INCOME
01:48:01.474 --> 01:48:02.943
INCOME CONSUMERS WE ARGUED
01:48:03.009 --> 01:48:07.047
ABOUT I. AB TWO FOUR FOUR
01:48:07.113 --> 01:48:08.615
THREE. THANK YOU THANK YOU MUCH
01:48:08.682 --> 01:48:09.216
I DID IT IN ADDITION SUPPORTER
01:48:09.282 --> 01:48:10.717
OUT SORRY WITH THE PH<c.cyan>ERE</c>
01:48:10.784 --> 01:48:12.853
IN THE ROOM SEE NONE LET'S GO
01:48:12.919 --> 01:48:22.362
TO THE PHONE LINES. ANYONE HERE
01:48:22.429 --> 01:48:23.363
WANTS TO MAKE A COMMENT IN
01:48:23.430 --> 01:48:24.865
SUPPORT OF THIS BILL PLUS ONE
01:48:24.931 --> 01:48:27.400
AND ZERO. AMANDA CORP IN YOUR
01:48:27.467 --> 01:48:32.439
LINE IS OPEN. GO AHEAD PLEASE
01:48:32.505 --> 01:48:34.541
WHAT HAPPENED THANK YOU FOR
01:48:34.608 --> 01:48:35.809
CALLING ON BEHALF OF THE
01:48:35.876 --> 01:48:37.010
NATIONAL CONSUMER LAW CENTER
01:48:37.077 --> 01:48:39.846
ALSO IN COURT WITHOUT THINKING
01:48:39.913 --> 01:48:41.581
THANK YOU NEXT PLACE. ONE
01:48:41.648 --> 01:48:50.824
MOMENT. OUR NEXT QUESTION
01:48:50.891 --> 01:48:53.026
BECAUSE THE LINE A TEN GOOD
01:48:53.093 --> 01:48:54.794
HERE ONE MOMENT PLEASE. YOUR
01:48:54.861 --> 01:48:58.164
LINE IS NOW OPEN. DANIEL GOOD
01:48:58.231 --> 01:48:59.266
CARE OF ON BEHALF OF THE
01:48:59.332 --> 01:49:00.367
CONSUMER FEDERATION OF
01:49:00.433 --> 01:49:02.369
CALIFORNIA IN SUPPORT. THANK
01:49:02.435 --> 01:49:07.340
YOU THANK YOU. EXPLAINS THE
01:49:07.407 --> 01:49:14.581
CANADA ONE CAROL FOR SUPPORT.
01:49:14.648 --> 01:49:15.181
ONE ZERO. AND THERE IS NO MARC
01:49:15.248 --> 01:49:18.585
ALMOND. IN THE COMING LET'S GO
01:49:18.652 --> 01:49:19.953
TO THE OPPOSITION SO STARTING
01:49:20.020 --> 01:49:23.356
WITH THE- MELANIE CLEVERNESS
01:49:23.423 --> 01:49:24.824
WITH DE CALIFORNIA BANKERS
01:49:24.891 --> 01:49:27.794
ASSOCIATION. VIA THE TELEPHONE
01:49:27.861 --> 01:49:30.463
AND ROBERT WILSON WITH THE
01:49:30.530 --> 01:49:31.698
CALIFORNIA CREDIT UNION LEAGUE.
01:49:31.765 --> 01:49:35.302
WELCOME HI YOU JUST ARE YOU ON
01:49:35.368 --> 01:49:39.172
THE LINE IN. I AM CAN YOU HEAR
01:49:39.239 --> 01:49:42.142
ME YES GO AHEAD PLEASE. THANK
01:49:42.208 --> 01:49:44.077
YOU MISTER CHAIR NUMBERS I AM
01:49:44.144 --> 01:49:45.312
MELANIE CLEE THAT BUT THE
01:49:45.378 --> 01:49:46.379
CALIFORNIA BANKERS WITH THAT
01:49:46.446 --> 01:49:48.248
THE SHOW AND- APPLIED LIKE TO
01:49:48.315 --> 01:49:49.516
THANK THE COMMITTEE FOR THEIR
01:49:49.582 --> 01:49:51.718
DILIGENT WORK ON THE PROPOSAL
01:49:51.785 --> 01:49:52.585
AND THINK THE AUTHOR AND
01:49:52.652 --> 01:49:53.853
MONSTER'S FOR THE DIALOGUE THAT
01:49:53.920 --> 01:49:56.189
WE THE TABLETS THAT FAR. AND
01:49:56.256 --> 01:49:57.524
FOR THEIR COMMITMENT TO RESOLVE
01:49:57.590 --> 01:49:58.792
OUR ISSUES AND NOT INTACT
01:49:58.858 --> 01:50:00.627
DEPOSITORY INSTITUTIONS NOR THE
01:50:00.694 --> 01:50:03.396
DEPOSIT ACCOUNT BUT THEY ARE.
01:50:03.463 --> 01:50:05.398
CALIFORNIA BANKS ARE IN THE
01:50:05.465 --> 01:50:07.534
BUSINESS OF SERVING THEIR-
01:50:07.600 --> 01:50:09.302
ACTUALLY WENT. STRAIGHT ARE
01:50:09.369 --> 01:50:10.203
MEMBERS SUCCEED WHEN OUR- THINK
01:50:10.270 --> 01:50:11.304
THE AND WE FOR ONE ARE
01:50:11.371 --> 01:50:13.239
COMMUNITY STOPPER. I WOULD LIKE
01:50:13.306 --> 01:50:14.240
TO KNOW THAT OUR MEMBER BANKS-
01:50:14.307 --> 01:50:15.842
ALWAYS ENCOURAGE CUSTOMERS WHO
01:50:15.909 --> 01:50:17.010
ARE EXPERIENCING HURT. TO
01:50:17.077 --> 01:50:19.179
CONTACT THEIR CREDITOR DIRECTLY
01:50:19.245 --> 01:50:21.181
TO WORK OUT ISSUES. HOWEVER WE
01:50:21.247 --> 01:50:22.382
RECOGNIZE THAT THERE ARE TIMES
01:50:22.449 --> 01:50:25.318
WHEN CONSUMER TURN ELSEWHERE TO
01:50:25.385 --> 01:50:27.020
RESOLVE THEIR- VVA APPLIED THE
01:50:27.087 --> 01:50:32.025
AUTHOR IN THE SPONSORED. OF AB
01:50:32.092 --> 01:50:32.592
TWENTY FOUR FORTY THREE FOR
01:50:32.659 --> 01:50:33.426
THEIR WORK TO PROTECT CONSUMERS
01:50:33.493 --> 01:50:34.828
AGAINST UNLAWFUL AND
01:50:34.894 --> 01:50:36.329
UNSCRUPULOUS THAT SETTLEMENT
01:50:36.396 --> 01:50:38.832
PRACTICE SAYS UNFORTUNATELY WE
01:50:38.898 --> 01:50:40.834
REMAIN IN AND OPPOSE THE MARKER
01:50:40.900 --> 01:50:43.436
MENDED POSITION ON THE MEASURE
01:50:43.503 --> 01:50:44.371
WE ARE WORKING THROUGH THE
01:50:44.437 --> 01:50:46.573
INTERNET KEEP IMPLICATIONS OF
01:50:46.639 --> 01:50:47.674
THE AMENDMENTS ADOPTED IN THE
01:50:47.741 --> 01:50:49.642
CANADIAN DOLLAR BUT I WOULD
01:50:49.709 --> 01:50:51.177
LIKE TO KNOW THAT WE APPRECIATE
01:50:51.244 --> 01:50:52.812
THE COMMITTEE'S EFFORT TO BRING
01:50:52.879 --> 01:50:56.282
MARK WHERE HE- HELPING WITH
01:50:56.349 --> 01:50:58.118
THAN WHAT IS CURRENTLY AND
01:50:58.184 --> 01:51:03.490
CRANKS. I DON'T. THANK WHICH IS
01:51:03.556 --> 01:51:05.291
AN IMPORTANT MATTER HOWEVER WE
01:51:05.358 --> 01:51:06.459
ARE SO TRYING UNDERSTAND THE IS
01:51:06.526 --> 01:51:07.794
PARAGRAPH IN TO ENSURE IT
01:51:07.861 --> 01:51:11.097
DOESN'T CREATE AN A CONFLICT
01:51:11.164 --> 01:51:13.166
HOP BY. IMPACTING DEPOSIT
01:51:13.233 --> 01:51:14.901
ACCOUNT RELATIONSHIP OR BROADLY
01:51:14.968 --> 01:51:16.569
CATEGORIZING THESE ENTITIES AS
01:51:16.636 --> 01:51:18.204
UNDESIRABLE AND THEREFORE
01:51:18.271 --> 01:51:19.706
UNABLE TO ACT THAT FINANCIAL
01:51:19.773 --> 01:51:21.674
SERVICES. WE ARE HOPEFUL THAT
01:51:21.741 --> 01:51:22.942
WE MAY CONTINUE TO WORK WITH
01:51:23.009 --> 01:51:24.210
THE AUTHOR IN THE FARM THIRDS
01:51:24.277 --> 01:51:25.545
TO TIGHTEN AND CLARIFY THE
01:51:25.612 --> 01:51:27.113
INTENT IN THE IMPACT OF THE
01:51:27.180 --> 01:51:30.116
MEASURE. AT THAT TIME BUT THE
01:51:30.183 --> 01:51:31.217
DOCTOR THE MOMENT WHILE AN
01:51:31.284 --> 01:51:32.685
IMPROVEMENT DO NOT FULLY
01:51:32.752 --> 01:51:34.154
RESOLVED ARE CONCERNED IN THE
01:51:34.220 --> 01:51:36.389
REMAIN IN A RESPECTFUL OPPOSE
01:51:36.456 --> 01:51:38.024
I'M RECOMMENDED POSSESSION. WE
01:51:38.091 --> 01:51:39.159
LOOK FORWARD TO CONTINUING OUR
01:51:39.225 --> 01:51:41.227
DIALOGUE AND TO WORKING TOWARD
01:51:41.294 --> 01:51:46.533
THE EVENTUAL REMOVAL. OF OUR
01:51:46.599 --> 01:51:47.767
OPPOSITION. REMEMBER TRAINING
01:51:47.834 --> 01:51:49.636
CAN. AND FOR THE OPERA. TO
01:51:49.702 --> 01:51:52.839
TESTIFY IN THE AIR TODAY. THANK
01:51:52.906 --> 01:51:54.040
YOU VERY MUCH NOW GO TO THE ME
01:51:54.107 --> 01:51:56.042
TO USE I START WITH THE ROOM
01:51:56.109 --> 01:51:58.344
HERE I DON'T SEE AN IN. ONE
01:51:58.411 --> 01:52:07.420
PERSON HELP MISTER WILSON GO AT.
01:52:07.487 --> 01:52:09.155
MR ROBERT WILSON ARE YOU ON THE
01:52:09.222 --> 01:52:19.799
LINE PLEASE. I GUESS WE COULD
01:52:19.866 --> 01:52:22.168
COME BACK TO MR LISTEN OF LET'S
01:52:22.235 --> 01:52:24.237
SUCK START WITH ADDITIONAL
01:52:24.304 --> 01:52:30.009
OPPOSITION. ON THE LINE PLEASE.
01:52:30.076 --> 01:52:31.544
AND IF THERE'S ANYONE WHO WOULD
01:52:31.611 --> 01:52:33.046
LIKE TO MAKE A COMMENT IN
01:52:33.113 --> 01:52:35.415
OPPOSITION TO THIS BILL PLEASE
01:52:35.482 --> 01:52:42.122
PRESS ONE ZERO. AND WE HAVE NO
01:52:42.188 --> 01:52:44.824
ONE IN Q. ALL RIGHT LET'S BRING
01:52:44.891 --> 01:52:46.659
IT BACK TO THE COMEDIAN-
01:52:46.726 --> 01:52:49.963
QUESTIONS COMMENTS FROM THE
01:52:50.029 --> 01:52:56.970
COMMITTEE MEMBERS. SEEING NONE.
01:52:57.036 --> 01:52:58.371
I WANT TO TAKE A MINUTE TO
01:52:58.438 --> 01:53:01.040
THANK- DOCTOR WEBER OF FOR
01:53:01.107 --> 01:53:03.343
BRINGING THIS BILL AS WE NOW
01:53:03.409 --> 01:53:05.278
WILL REALLY LITERALLY MILLIONS
01:53:05.345 --> 01:53:06.980
OF AMERICANS ARE LOSING THEIR
01:53:07.046 --> 01:53:09.983
JOBS DURING THIS CRISIS IT'S IT
01:53:10.049 --> 01:53:11.918
IS SO IMPORTANT AT THAT WE
01:53:11.985 --> 01:53:13.686
PROTECT THE FINANCIALLY
01:53:13.753 --> 01:53:15.755
VULNERABLE FOLKS FROM PLAN TO
01:53:15.822 --> 01:53:19.993
TORY SCHEMES. THAT SAID IT IS
01:53:20.059 --> 01:53:22.962
IMPORTANT TO US. PRECISELY
01:53:23.029 --> 01:53:25.165
ALLOCATE LIABILITY TO ALL THE
01:53:25.231 --> 01:53:27.100
BUSINESSES AND PEOPLE THAT ARE
01:53:27.167 --> 01:53:28.601
ACTUALLY DECEIVING CONSUMERS
01:53:28.668 --> 01:53:31.271
FOR PROFIT. AND WITH THE
01:53:31.337 --> 01:53:34.207
AMENDMENTS ACCEPTED TODAY I AM
01:53:34.274 --> 01:53:36.009
VERY PROUD TO SUPPORT THIS BILL
01:53:36.075 --> 01:53:37.544
AND I THINK THE MEN AND START
01:53:37.610 --> 01:53:42.815
THE RIGHT BALANCE- AND- I SEE
01:53:42.882 --> 01:53:43.616
THE BILL HAS BEEN MOVED AND
01:53:43.683 --> 01:53:45.818
SECONDED ALSO AT THIS TIME I
01:53:45.885 --> 01:53:47.420
LIKED ARE STOCKED WITH FOOD TOO
01:53:47.487 --> 01:53:49.656
CLOSE. JUST SIMPLY WANT TO
01:53:49.722 --> 01:53:50.723
THANK YOUR STAFF AND YOU FOR
01:53:50.790 --> 01:53:52.158
WORKING SO CLOSELY WITH THAT'S
01:53:52.225 --> 01:53:53.826
WILL CONTINUE TO WORK WITH
01:53:53.893 --> 01:53:55.428
THOSE WHO HAVE OPPOSITION TO
01:53:55.495 --> 01:53:57.330
SEE IF WE CAN READ SOME KIND OF
01:53:57.397 --> 01:53:59.432
AGREEMENT THAT THERE. MIKE
01:53:59.499 --> 01:54:00.700
AUTHOR MISSED US MEMBER. WHO'S
01:54:00.767 --> 01:54:02.769
ALL WORKED ON THIS. AND THE
01:54:02.835 --> 01:54:04.470
REALLY JUST SIMPLY SAY IT'S
01:54:04.537 --> 01:54:05.405
EXTREMELY IMPORTANT
01:54:05.471 --> 01:54:06.306
PARTICULARLY IN THIS
01:54:06.372 --> 01:54:07.273
ENVIRONMENT THAT WE WORK VERY
01:54:07.340 --> 01:54:08.374
HARD TO PROTECT THOSE WHO ARE
01:54:08.441 --> 01:54:10.076
MOST VULNERABLE. MANY ARE GOING
01:54:10.143 --> 01:54:11.811
TO SUFFER ECONOMIC HARDSHIP AND
01:54:11.878 --> 01:54:13.179
THE LAST THING THEY NEED IS TO
01:54:13.246 --> 01:54:15.448
BE PREYED ON BY INDIVIDUALS WHO
01:54:15.515 --> 01:54:16.716
HAVE NO INTENT OF REALLY
01:54:16.783 --> 01:54:17.250
HELPING THEM. BUT HELPING
01:54:17.317 --> 01:54:18.585
THEMSELVES I RESPECTFULLY ASK I
01:54:18.651 --> 01:54:20.887
BELIEVE FOR TWENTY FOUR FORTY
01:54:20.954 --> 01:54:23.089
THIRD. THANK YOU VERY MUCH UP
01:54:23.156 --> 01:54:25.258
SEC I AM SECRETARY WHICH YOU
01:54:25.325 --> 01:54:27.126
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. THE
01:54:27.193 --> 01:54:28.995
MOTION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED TO
01:54:29.062 --> 01:54:31.531
THE ASSEMBLY FLOOR SHALL I
01:54:31.598 --> 01:54:35.368
SHALL I KILEY. KILEY KNOW OUR
01:54:35.435 --> 01:54:39.072
QUE HAN HI OKAY HAND I BERMAN.
01:54:39.138 --> 01:54:42.942
BERMAN I MEDINA AYE MEDINA I.
01:54:43.009 --> 01:54:52.986
CARILLO. MULLIN. GALLAGHER.
01:54:53.052 --> 01:54:56.356
GALLAGHER NO IRWIN HI- WHEN I
01:54:56.422 --> 01:54:59.892
OBERNOLTE OBERNOLTE NO WICKS
01:54:59.959 --> 01:55:02.996
WICKS I. HI THE BILL IS OUT YOU
01:55:03.062 --> 01:55:04.163
HAVE SIX GO TO LEAVE THE ROLE
01:55:04.230 --> 01:55:05.798
OPEN US EITHER THANK YOU ALL
01:55:05.865 --> 01:55:07.233
THANK YOU THE REMAINING.
01:55:07.300 --> 01:55:11.671
MEMBERS SO THAT BRINGS US TO.
01:55:11.738 --> 01:55:14.407
AB TWO THOUSAND AND FOUR THAT'S
01:55:14.474 --> 01:55:15.775
MISTER CALDERON STILL I
01:55:15.842 --> 01:55:18.444
UNDERSTAND- MIST WAS GONNA
01:55:18.511 --> 01:55:21.314
PRESENT ON HIS BEHALF SO IT
01:55:21.381 --> 01:55:23.816
TIME YOU- ALREADY A MISTER WENT
01:55:23.883 --> 01:55:26.486
AND AT THIS TIME I LIKE AGAIN
01:55:26.552 --> 01:55:28.855
TO REITERATE- FOOT TO DOES SO
01:55:28.921 --> 01:55:31.524
WHO WOULD LIKE TO REGISTER YOUR
01:55:31.591 --> 01:55:33.860
SUPPORT OUR POSITION. FIVE I DO
01:55:33.926 --> 01:55:35.828
IT CALLING NOW AT THE BEGINNING
01:55:35.895 --> 01:55:37.063
OF THE ASSEMBLY MEMBERS
01:55:37.130 --> 01:55:39.232
TESTIMONY TO AVOID ANY DELAYS
01:55:39.299 --> 01:55:43.736
THE PHONE NUMBER AGAIN IS EIGHT
01:55:43.803 --> 01:55:44.337
SEVEN SEVEN SIX NINE TWO NINE
01:55:44.404 --> 01:55:47.940
FIVE. SEVEN SO WELCOME ASSEMBLY
01:55:48.007 --> 01:55:50.877
MEMBER ONE HI- SO ANYTIME
01:55:50.943 --> 01:55:51.911
YOU'RE READY YOU MAY BEGIN
01:55:51.978 --> 01:55:54.147
RIGHT THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR
01:55:54.213 --> 01:55:57.383
AND MEMBERS I AM PRETENDING AB
01:55:57.450 --> 01:55:59.252
TWO THOUSAND FOR TODAY THE HALF
01:55:59.319 --> 01:56:03.723
OF THE SENATE NUMBER CALDERON.
01:56:03.790 --> 01:56:06.993
IT DOESN'T. RIGHT USE USE UP
01:56:07.060 --> 01:56:07.560
THIRD OF ALL CREDENTIALS FOR
01:56:07.627 --> 01:56:09.262
THE PER OF. THE OF COVE IT.
01:56:09.329 --> 01:56:10.229
TEST AND PROVIDE A MINIMUM SO
01:56:10.296 --> 01:56:12.665
THAT MUST BE MET. TO BE
01:56:12.732 --> 01:56:13.232
CONSIDERED A VERIFIED
01:56:13.299 --> 01:56:15.168
CREDENTIALS DURINGTHE CURRENT
01:56:15.234 --> 01:56:17.036
CORONAVIRUS CRISIS ONE OF THE
01:56:17.103 --> 01:56:18.871
MOST CRITICAL TOOLS OUR STATE
01:56:18.938 --> 01:56:21.374
HAS AGAINST THE VIRUSES ARE YOU
01:56:21.441 --> 01:56:22.809
TO TEST FOR THE DISEASE. AND
01:56:22.875 --> 01:56:24.677
PERFORM CONTACT TRACING TO
01:56:24.744 --> 01:56:26.446
UNDERSTAND IT SPREAD. GOVERNOR
01:56:26.512 --> 01:56:28.648
NEWSOME HAS IDENTIFIED TESTING
01:56:28.715 --> 01:56:31.751
AND CONTACT FACING IS ONE OF
01:56:31.818 --> 01:56:34.153
THE SIX CORE INDICATORS. BOTTOM
01:56:34.220 --> 01:56:36.055
FIGHT THE URGENT PERSON A
01:56:36.122 --> 01:56:38.024
STATEWIDE ENGAGEMENT IN TESTING
01:56:38.091 --> 01:56:39.926
AND TRACKING COMMUNITIES ARE
01:56:39.992 --> 01:56:42.829
BEGINNING TO- ARE BECOMING
01:56:42.895 --> 01:56:44.163
INCREASINGLY HESITANT TO ENGAGE
01:56:44.230 --> 01:56:45.665
WITH THESE EFFORTS BECAUSE OF
01:56:45.732 --> 01:56:47.333
PRIVACY CONCERNS WITH HOW THEIR
01:56:47.400 --> 01:56:48.935
PERSONAL HEALTH DATA WILL BE
01:56:49.001 --> 01:56:51.304
USED VERIFIABLE CREDENTIALS
01:56:51.371 --> 01:56:53.072
OFFER A PRIVATE AND SECURE WAY
01:56:53.139 --> 01:56:55.174
TO PROVE AN INDIVIDUAL SCOLDED
01:56:55.241 --> 01:56:56.609
NINETEEN TEST RESULTS WITHOUT
01:56:56.676 --> 01:56:59.011
SACRIFICING THEIR PRIVACY THIS
01:56:59.078 --> 01:57:00.513
BILL WOULD ALLOW ISSUERS OF
01:57:00.580 --> 01:57:02.615
COVERT NINETEEN OF THE COVERT
01:57:02.682 --> 01:57:03.883
NINETEEN TEST TO UTILIZE
01:57:03.950 --> 01:57:05.418
VERIFIABLE CREDENTIALS YEAH
01:57:05.485 --> 01:57:07.854
IMPLEMENTING A MINIMUM STANDARD
01:57:07.920 --> 01:57:09.122
IT WOULD ENSURE THAT SUCH
01:57:09.188 --> 01:57:10.823
CREDENTIALS ARE TRULY PROTECT
01:57:10.890 --> 01:57:12.959
AND CALIFORNIA IS RIGHT TO PROP.
01:57:13.025 --> 01:57:14.227
ALLOWING THEM TO TEST THE
01:57:14.293 --> 01:57:16.062
CRUCIAL EFFORT TO CAN. VIRUS
01:57:16.129 --> 01:57:17.096
AND ULTIMATELY REOPEN OUR
01:57:17.163 --> 01:57:20.400
STATE. WITH ME TO TEST A FIVE.
01:57:20.466 --> 01:57:22.235
A TODAY IS ALLEY MEDINA
01:57:22.301 --> 01:57:24.504
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE
01:57:24.570 --> 01:57:25.972
BLOCKCHAIN ADVOCACY COALITION
01:57:26.038 --> 01:57:28.007
AND DOCTOR RAJ GUPTA ASSOCIATE
01:57:28.074 --> 01:57:30.443
PROFESSOR OF ANESTHESIOLOGY AT
01:57:30.510 --> 01:57:33.780
VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY. THANK
01:57:33.846 --> 01:57:35.882
YOU VERY MUCH AND WELCOME- THIS
01:57:35.948 --> 01:57:37.884
SO IF THE WITNESSES ARE ON THE
01:57:37.950 --> 01:57:44.891
LINE YOU MAY BEGIN AS WELL. BUT
01:57:44.957 --> 01:57:46.459
WHAT THIS IS THANK YOU MISTER
01:57:46.526 --> 01:57:48.027
CHAIR AND COMMITTEE MEMBERS MY
01:57:48.094 --> 01:57:49.729
NAME IS DOCTOR RAJ BUT- AND I'M
01:57:49.796 --> 01:57:50.963
AN ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR OF
01:57:51.030 --> 01:57:52.398
ANESTHESIOLOGY AT VANDERBILT
01:57:52.465 --> 01:57:54.333
UNIVERSITY MEDICAL CENTER.
01:57:54.400 --> 01:57:55.268
THANK YOU FOR THIS OPPORTUNITY
01:57:55.334 --> 01:57:56.936
TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF ASSEMBLY
01:57:57.003 --> 01:58:00.039
MEMBER CALLED RUNS BILL TWO
01:58:00.106 --> 01:58:01.507
ZERO AB TWO YEARS OR FOUR. THE
01:58:01.574 --> 01:58:02.975
CROWN OF OUR SPEND AND FOR
01:58:03.042 --> 01:58:04.677
SOCIETY INTO A PLACE THAT WE
01:58:04.744 --> 01:58:06.345
HAVEN'T BEEN BEFORE AND WE WILL
01:58:06.412 --> 01:58:07.747
NEED NEW TOOLS TO RETURN
01:58:07.814 --> 01:58:09.415
SOCIETY TO A FUNCTIONING LEVEL.
01:58:09.482 --> 01:58:11.717
WHILE STILL MAXIMIZING SAFETY
01:58:11.784 --> 01:58:12.718
PRIVACY AND TRUST IN OUR
01:58:12.785 --> 01:58:15.354
SYSTEM. IN OUR PRIOR WORLD IF
01:58:15.421 --> 01:58:17.123
SOMEONE NEEDED TO PROVIDE A
01:58:17.190 --> 01:58:19.392
VERIFIED. MEDICAL TESTS TO AN
01:58:19.459 --> 01:58:21.294
EMPLOYER OR SCHOOL THEY WOULD
01:58:21.360 --> 01:58:23.162
REQUEST THE DOCUMENTS FROM
01:58:23.229 --> 01:58:23.896
THEIR DOCTOR'S OFFICE OR HEALTH
01:58:23.963 --> 01:58:26.232
SYSTEM. THEN TAKE THE PAPER OR
01:58:26.299 --> 01:58:27.467
ELECTRONIC DOCUMENT TO THE
01:58:27.533 --> 01:58:29.569
PERSON WHO NEEDED IT. AND THAT
01:58:29.635 --> 01:58:31.838
THEIR SUBSEQUENTLY HAVE THEM
01:58:31.904 --> 01:58:32.605
VERIFY EVERYTHING BEFORE
01:58:32.672 --> 01:58:34.574
COMPLETION. FOR EXAMPLE GETTING
01:58:34.640 --> 01:58:36.108
VACCINATION RECORDS TO YOUR
01:58:36.175 --> 01:58:37.710
CHILD'S SCHOOL BEFORE THE NEW
01:58:37.777 --> 01:58:39.378
YEAR BEGAN. THIS COULD TAKE
01:58:39.445 --> 01:58:41.681
DAYS AT BEST AND OFTEN WEEKS TO
01:58:41.747 --> 01:58:44.817
COMPLETE. HOWEVER THIS- IS
01:58:44.884 --> 01:58:45.885
UNACCEPTABLE BECAUSE THESE
01:58:45.952 --> 01:58:47.787
INTERACTIONS THAT THIS WAS
01:58:47.854 --> 01:58:49.388
ACCEPTABLE BEFORE BECAUSE THESE
01:58:49.455 --> 01:58:51.157
INTERACTIONS WERE REPRESENTS
01:58:51.224 --> 01:58:54.227
MOST OF US. IN THE KNOW THAT
01:58:54.293 --> 01:58:58.798
THE TABLE ROOM. HELLO IN
01:58:58.865 --> 01:59:00.833
TODAY'S WORLD WOULD BE CANNIBAL
01:59:00.900 --> 01:59:01.667
TO YOU EXISTING PROCESS EVERY
01:59:01.734 --> 01:59:03.035
TWO OF COURSE MIGHT NAY. THE
01:59:03.102 --> 01:59:03.903
PERSON THEIR TESTING IN FOR
01:59:03.970 --> 01:59:05.972
POKER OF TO THEIR EMPLOYER GOV
01:59:06.038 --> 01:59:08.508
BUILDING A SCHOOL A HOSPITAL
01:59:08.574 --> 01:59:10.943
SALON A GROCERY STORE A CONCERT
01:59:11.010 --> 01:59:12.278
VENUE THE STADIUM OR ANY OTHER
01:59:12.345 --> 01:59:13.846
NUMBER OF PLACES THAT HUMANS
01:59:13.913 --> 01:59:15.648
INTERACT WITH EACH OTHER. THIS
01:59:15.715 --> 01:59:17.917
WOULD BE MULTIPLE TIMES A DAY
01:59:17.984 --> 01:59:18.484
POSSIBLY HUNDREDS OF TIMES A
01:59:18.551 --> 01:59:20.353
WEEK. CALIFORNIA'S CURRENT
01:59:20.419 --> 01:59:21.954
FRAMEWORK FOR TRANSMITTING AND
01:59:22.021 --> 01:59:23.256
STORING THIS IMPORTANT HEALTH
01:59:23.322 --> 01:59:24.757
DATA IT'S SIMPLY NOT SET UP TO
01:59:24.824 --> 01:59:25.791
OPERATE AT THIS SCALE
01:59:25.858 --> 01:59:28.027
SUFFICIENTLY. IN A VERIFIABLE
01:59:28.094 --> 01:59:29.795
CREDENTIAL SYSTEM THE PERSON
01:59:29.862 --> 01:59:31.330
ISSUING THE CREDENTIAL NEEDS TO
01:59:31.397 --> 01:59:32.932
BE A TRUSTED ENTITY FOR EXAMPLE
01:59:32.999 --> 01:59:34.367
A DOCTOR'S OFFICE OR A NURSE
01:59:34.433 --> 01:59:36.168
PRACTITIONER. AND WE ALREADY
01:59:36.235 --> 01:59:38.638
HAVE PROCESSES FOR IDENTIFYING
01:59:38.704 --> 01:59:39.872
THESE PEOPLE INVALIDATING THAN.
01:59:39.939 --> 01:59:41.507
THIS ISSUE OR IS GIVING THE
01:59:41.574 --> 01:59:42.909
CREDENTIALS OF THE PERSON
01:59:42.975 --> 01:59:44.577
THEMSELVES TO HOLD THIS GIVES
01:59:44.644 --> 01:59:46.345
THE INDIVIDUAL TO CONTROL THEIR
01:59:46.412 --> 01:59:47.480
OWN PERSONAL HEALTH INFORMATION
01:59:47.547 --> 01:59:49.882
AND- NOW THAT PERSON HAS THE
01:59:49.949 --> 01:59:50.583
ABILITY TO DISTRIBUTE THAT
01:59:50.650 --> 01:59:52.552
INFORMATION. AND WEBER NEED
01:59:52.618 --> 01:59:54.487
THAT IN A TRUSTED AND SECURE
01:59:54.554 --> 01:59:55.621
WAY WITHOUT HAVING RETURNED
01:59:55.688 --> 01:59:58.558
ISSUING ENTITIES THE TIME. ALSO
01:59:58.624 --> 02:00:00.092
WITHOUT HAVING TO HAVE THE
02:00:00.159 --> 02:00:01.894
RECIPIENT TAKE TIME AND WORK TO
02:00:01.961 --> 02:00:03.362
CONFIRM THE VALIDITY OF THE
02:00:03.429 --> 02:00:05.364
TEST EVERY TIME. THEY WOULD ALL
02:00:05.431 --> 02:00:07.033
BE AUTOMATED. RIGHT NOW WE
02:00:07.099 --> 02:00:09.068
DON'T KNOW WHAT TEST OR CATS
02:00:09.135 --> 02:00:10.836
WILL BE THE MAGIC FORMULA TO
02:00:10.903 --> 02:00:12.271
KEEP US SAFE FROM INFECTION OR
02:00:12.338 --> 02:00:14.073
FROM INFECTING OTHERS. VIRAL
02:00:14.140 --> 02:00:16.275
TESTING ANTIBODY TESTING
02:00:16.342 --> 02:00:18.511
VACCINES OR COMBINATION. THAT
02:00:18.578 --> 02:00:20.212
INFORMATION IS EVOLVING RAPIDLY
02:00:20.279 --> 02:00:22.381
HOWEVER WE CAN GO AHEAD AND
02:00:22.448 --> 02:00:24.283
CREATE A TRUSTED INFRASTRUCTURE
02:00:24.350 --> 02:00:25.718
SYSTEM THAT IS EFFICIENT
02:00:25.785 --> 02:00:28.054
SECURE. AND ADAPTABLE TO THIS
02:00:28.120 --> 02:00:29.522
EVOLVING INFORMATION. THAT WAY
02:00:29.589 --> 02:00:30.957
GOVERNMENT BODIES PUBLIC HEALTH
02:00:31.023 --> 02:00:33.059
OFFICIALS DOCTORS AND
02:00:33.125 --> 02:00:33.693
SCIENTISTS CAN CONTINUE TO MAKE
02:00:33.759 --> 02:00:35.094
THE DECISION. THAT WE NEED
02:00:35.161 --> 02:00:36.662
BASED ON THE TESTING FOR
02:00:36.729 --> 02:00:38.598
SOCIETY AND THE PUBLIC CAN HAVE
02:00:38.664 --> 02:00:39.565
CONFIDENCE THAT WE HAVE A
02:00:39.632 --> 02:00:41.167
RELIABLE WAY TO CONVEY THAT
02:00:41.233 --> 02:00:42.902
INFORMATION. TO EVERYONE WHO
02:00:42.969 --> 02:00:45.438
NEEDS IT. AB TWO ZERO ZERO FOR
02:00:45.504 --> 02:00:46.439
AN IMPORTANT FIRST STEP IN
02:00:46.505 --> 02:00:48.641
ALLOWING THE UTILIZATION OF
02:00:48.708 --> 02:00:49.742
THIS TECHNOLOGY. THANK YOU
02:00:49.809 --> 02:00:53.879
AGAIN FOR THE ON. THE TEST.
02:00:53.946 --> 02:00:54.780
THANK YOU VERY MUCH LET'S GO TO
02:00:54.847 --> 02:00:58.484
OUR NEXT WITNESS. THAT WOULD BE
02:00:58.551 --> 02:01:01.520
A COMMITTEE MEMBER. YES HI THIS
02:01:01.587 --> 02:01:06.325
MEDINA. YEAH THANK YOU FOR YOUR
02:01:06.392 --> 02:01:08.294
PUBLIC SERVICE TODAY I AM.
02:01:08.361 --> 02:01:09.295
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE
02:01:09.362 --> 02:01:11.297
BLOCKING OUT OF THE COALITION
02:01:11.364 --> 02:01:13.399
WE'RE OFFERING AB TALKING FOR
02:01:13.466 --> 02:01:15.201
AND I'M HERE TO SPEAK IN
02:01:15.267 --> 02:01:16.135
SUPPORT OF THE BILL. WITH SO
02:01:16.202 --> 02:01:17.203
MANY PEOPLE OUT OF WORK AND
02:01:17.269 --> 02:01:18.804
BUSINESSES CLOSE AFFECT HER
02:01:18.871 --> 02:01:19.905
LIFE AND COME TO A GRINDING
02:01:19.972 --> 02:01:21.874
HALT. AND WE ALL WANT O GET
02:01:21.941 --> 02:01:23.075
PEOPLE FAITHFULLY BACK TO A
02:01:23.142 --> 02:01:25.611
NORMAL LIFE. HERE WE CAN START
02:01:25.678 --> 02:01:26.779
TO ECONOMIC RECOVERY OF OUR
02:01:26.846 --> 02:01:29.015
STATE. THIS IS WHY CAFFEINE IS
02:01:29.081 --> 02:01:30.650
ONE OF THE SIX CORE INDICATOR
02:01:30.716 --> 02:01:31.951
THE GOVERNOR HAS LEFT LIKE TO
02:01:32.018 --> 02:01:34.687
REOPEN ECONOMY. IT'S IMPERATIVE
02:01:34.754 --> 02:01:35.221
THAT WE OFFER CALIFORNIA
02:01:35.287 --> 02:01:37.256
RESIDENT METHOD OF STORING AND
02:01:37.323 --> 02:01:39.692
SHE- RESULT. THEY GIVE THEM
02:01:39.759 --> 02:01:41.127
CONTROL OF THEIR OWN THE ACT.
02:01:41.193 --> 02:01:43.162
ITSELF IS ACTUALLY CAN YOU
02:01:43.229 --> 02:01:44.430
THREE OVER THE ECONOMY AND
02:01:44.497 --> 02:01:46.999
LUNCH DURING THE HIGHEST LEVEL
02:01:47.066 --> 02:01:52.905
OF PRIVACY FOR AND. WITH YOU
02:01:52.972 --> 02:01:55.975
MAY. YEAH VERY ALLOW THE USE OF
02:01:56.042 --> 02:01:57.243
THEIR CREDENTIAL THE NEW TO
02:01:57.309 --> 02:01:58.611
CREATE MAINTAIN NINETEEN OR
02:01:58.678 --> 02:02:00.579
OTHER. ALL A CLEAR FIVE THIS
02:02:00.646 --> 02:02:03.382
AND- BECAUSE FULL RIGHT MINIMUM
02:02:03.449 --> 02:02:05.051
STANDARDS DO YEAH. WE ARE
02:02:05.117 --> 02:02:05.885
COMMITTED TO WITH COMMITTEE AND
02:02:05.951 --> 02:02:07.453
THE OPPOSITE. HE TO FLY OUT
02:02:07.520 --> 02:02:09.655
THERE. INCREASE MOST FOR.
02:02:09.722 --> 02:02:14.560
LANGUAGE THE PRICE POSSIBLE. I
02:02:14.627 --> 02:02:15.628
KNOW HOW TO KEEP THE FAIRLY
02:02:15.695 --> 02:02:16.796
ACOSTA BUT WOULD LOOK REALLY
02:02:16.862 --> 02:02:18.564
THINK WE WOULD INTEGRATE CAN
02:02:18.631 --> 02:02:21.200
HELP WITH HOW THAT. BUT THE
02:02:21.267 --> 02:02:22.268
INDIVIDUAL PRACTICAL THE TELL
02:02:22.334 --> 02:02:23.836
ME ABOUT THEIR DOCTOR TO GET
02:02:23.903 --> 02:02:25.705
HAPPEN. IF WE NEED TO PRE THAT
02:02:25.771 --> 02:02:28.007
THEY A CO NINETEEN CARPET
02:02:28.074 --> 02:02:30.309
WHATEVER IT TAKES. UNDECLARED
02:02:30.376 --> 02:02:31.811
WITH THE FAN. THEY COULD TAKE
02:02:31.877 --> 02:02:34.580
PATH. TO THEIR DOCTOR AND HAVE
02:02:34.647 --> 02:02:42.188
THE DOCTOR VERIFIED WITH ALL.
02:02:42.254 --> 02:02:44.156
AT PROBABLY THE FOR A Q. R.
02:02:44.223 --> 02:02:46.625
CODE. WHATEVER THEY WANT TO
02:02:46.692 --> 02:02:48.360
SHARE OR CONFIRM THEIR CAPTORS.
02:02:48.427 --> 02:02:50.296
STATUS IF THEY MIGHT GO BACK TO
02:02:50.362 --> 02:02:51.297
WORK AND YOU TO TRANSFER THE
02:02:51.363 --> 02:02:52.598
WORKPLACE. THEY CAN SHARE THE
02:02:52.665 --> 02:02:53.933
INFORMATION THEY WANT. WE NEED
02:02:53.999 --> 02:02:55.334
TO GET BENEFITS. MAKING SURE
02:02:55.401 --> 02:02:56.969
THAT THE GOVERNMENT AGENCY THEY
02:02:57.036 --> 02:03:00.706
WANT INTEREST ALONG. FOR A LOT
02:03:00.773 --> 02:03:02.041
OF TALK ABOUT THAT. CASE
02:03:02.108 --> 02:03:04.210
BLOCKING DOES NOT FOR MEDI DATA
02:03:04.276 --> 02:03:05.878
REALLY NEED TO CONVENE
02:03:05.945 --> 02:03:07.513
INFORMATION FRAUD PERMISSION IF
02:03:07.580 --> 02:03:09.014
YOU'RE LIKE A DOCTOR OR NURSE
02:03:09.081 --> 02:03:10.950
PRACTITIONER TO A PATIENT WE'RE
02:03:11.016 --> 02:03:12.585
NOT DICTATING WITH CAPTAIN KIRK
02:03:12.651 --> 02:03:14.320
ARE STANDARD COULD BE BACK ALL
02:03:14.386 --> 02:03:16.021
RELIANT ON WHATEVER OUR HEALTH
02:03:16.088 --> 02:03:17.823
AGENCIES NOT WHAT IF YOU COULD
02:03:17.890 --> 02:03:18.791
SECURE WAY OF CONVEYING
02:03:18.858 --> 02:03:20.292
INFORMATION AND EMPOWER
02:03:20.359 --> 02:03:21.927
INDIVIDUALS TO HAVE THEIR OWN
02:03:21.994 --> 02:03:25.731
DATA NOT HAVING TO HEAR ABOUT
02:03:25.798 --> 02:03:26.766
ALL HOPE IT WOULD. I WOULD
02:03:26.832 --> 02:03:27.867
THINK THAT YET THAT MANY FEEL
02:03:27.933 --> 02:03:28.934
YOU FOR THREE BEEN LOCKED IN
02:03:29.001 --> 02:03:30.035
THE MORNING TO DISCUSS THEIR
02:03:30.102 --> 02:03:31.537
CONCERNS OF ITSELF I REALLY
02:03:31.604 --> 02:03:32.972
APPRECIATE WORKING WITH YOU
02:03:33.038 --> 02:03:38.944
TOWARD A BETTER VERSION OF THAT.
02:03:39.011 --> 02:03:40.179
AND I THINK. HAT THANK YOU ALL
02:03:40.246 --> 02:03:41.113
FOR YOUR TIME. I THANK YOU FOR
02:03:41.180 --> 02:03:42.815
YOUR TEST LET US GO TO AT THIS.
02:03:42.882 --> 02:03:45.918
SO OF THE BILL. OF THE SITE
02:03:45.985 --> 02:03:47.119
WITH THE RIVER HERE I DON'T SEE
02:03:47.186 --> 02:03:49.455
ANYBODY STEPPING UP SO LET'S GO
02:03:49.522 --> 02:03:51.590
TO THE PHONE LINES. IF YOU
02:03:51.657 --> 02:03:53.926
SUPPORT THIS SO LEGISLATION. OF
02:03:53.993 --> 02:03:56.328
PLEASE IDENTIFY YOURSELF. AND
02:03:56.395 --> 02:03:58.097
YOUR ORGANIZATION AS WELL AS
02:03:58.164 --> 02:04:02.434
YOUR POSITION. AGAIN IF YOU TO
02:04:02.501 --> 02:04:03.435
WANT TO MAKE A COMMENT IN
02:04:03.502 --> 02:04:05.171
SUPPORT OF THIS BILL PLEASE
02:04:05.237 --> 02:04:13.712
PRESS ONE NINE ZERO. AND WE
02:04:13.779 --> 02:04:16.115
HAVE NO COST. TO YOU. THANK YOU
02:04:16.182 --> 02:04:17.750
VERY MUCH LET'S NOW GO TO
02:04:17.817 --> 02:04:25.825
OPPOSITION. I BELIEVE WE HOW OF.
02:04:25.891 --> 02:04:26.358
ONE INDIVIDUAL CEMENT THE
02:04:26.425 --> 02:04:29.295
CORBIN. IN OPPOSITION ARE YOU
02:04:29.361 --> 02:04:33.065
ON THE LINE. I AM THANK YOU
02:04:33.132 --> 02:04:35.434
MISTER CHAIR AT MEDICAL ON
02:04:35.501 --> 02:04:36.335
BEHALF OF THE ELECTRONIC
02:04:36.402 --> 02:04:38.204
FRONTIER FOUNDATION I'D LIKE TO
02:04:38.270 --> 02:04:39.238
THINK THE AUTHORSTOCKTON
02:04:39.305 --> 02:04:40.773
SPONSORS FOR TAKING TIME TO
02:04:40.840 --> 02:04:43.008
SPEAK WITH A DOCTOR AND CAN WE
02:04:43.075 --> 02:04:44.476
DO SO REMAIN OPPOSED TO THE
02:04:44.543 --> 02:04:46.779
MEASURE AS WRITTEN- AS WRITTEN
02:04:46.846 --> 02:04:48.547
A. B. ZERO ZERO ZERO FOUR COULD
02:04:48.614 --> 02:04:50.416
GET A BLANK CHECK TO ISSUERS OF
02:04:50.482 --> 02:04:51.450
MEDICAL TESTS TO SHARE TOUCH
02:04:51.517 --> 02:04:53.619
RESULT WITH. ANYONE WITH NO
02:04:53.686 --> 02:04:54.954
MORE OF A CHECK THEM OUT AND
02:04:55.020 --> 02:04:56.889
HAVE VERIFIABLE CREDENTIALS OF
02:04:56.956 --> 02:05:00.593
DEFINED. BY THE WORLD WIDE WEB
02:05:00.659 --> 02:05:02.027
CONSORTIUM. IT'S UNCLEAR TO US
02:05:02.094 --> 02:05:03.262
TYPICALLY JUST. IS TO
02:05:03.329 --> 02:05:05.331
EXPLICITLY ALLOW FOR THE USE OF
02:05:05.397 --> 02:05:07.433
VERIFIED CREDENTIALS. THEREFORE
02:05:07.499 --> 02:05:09.368
IF THE LEGISLATURE TO DISREGARD
02:05:09.435 --> 02:05:10.936
LIST YOU CREATE BACK TO IN THE
02:05:11.003 --> 02:05:13.205
AREA IF YOU TAKE GREAT CARE NOT
02:05:13.272 --> 02:05:16.041
TO CREATE PROBLEMATICALLY
02:05:16.108 --> 02:05:16.809
PULLED THAT MAY HARM CONSUMERS.
02:05:16.876 --> 02:05:18.344
CAN'T FOR INNOVATION OR
02:05:18.410 --> 02:05:19.712
DISPROPORTIONATELY BENEFIT
02:05:19.778 --> 02:05:20.913
CERTAIN BUSINESS MODEL OVER
02:05:20.980 --> 02:05:23.282
OTHERS. I'VE WRITTEN THE BILL
02:05:23.349 --> 02:05:24.650
LANGUAGE IT'S UNCLEAR AS TO
02:05:24.717 --> 02:05:26.352
WITHOUT WHICH PRIVATE OR PUBLIC
02:05:26.418 --> 02:05:28.354
ENTITIES WOULD BE COVERED AND
02:05:28.420 --> 02:05:30.055
IN WHICH THE CONTENT THAT. AND
02:05:30.122 --> 02:05:31.090
OTHER QUESTIONS THAT WE HAVE
02:05:31.156 --> 02:05:33.058
BEEN UNABLE TO ASCERTAIN AFTER
02:05:33.125 --> 02:05:35.928
FORGET IN THE LATE AT THAT THE
02:05:35.995 --> 02:05:37.329
PROPOSED AMENDMENT. I KNOW
02:05:37.396 --> 02:05:38.564
LIMITING THE SHARING TESTABLE
02:05:38.631 --> 02:05:39.899
PRION FOR QUITE A RING THAT
02:05:39.965 --> 02:05:41.800
SOMEONE TRYING TO ACCESS TEST
02:05:41.867 --> 02:05:43.836
RESULTS VERIFIABLE CREDENTIALS.
02:05:43.903 --> 02:05:45.137
THE BILL CURRENTLY ALLOWED
02:05:45.204 --> 02:05:46.438
ANYONE WITH A VERIFIABLE
02:05:46.505 --> 02:05:49.208
CREDENTIAL TO GET ANYONE ELSE
02:05:49.275 --> 02:05:50.776
TO TEST RESULT. WHAT THE BILL
02:05:50.843 --> 02:05:52.544
FACT SHEET THE DRAFT THAT IT
02:05:52.611 --> 02:05:53.946
MIGHT THE PHILIPPINE AUTOMATED
02:05:54.013 --> 02:05:57.416
CONTRACT FREE THING WE DO NOT
02:05:57.483 --> 02:05:58.017
BELIEVE THAT TO BE CORRECT AS
02:05:58.083 --> 02:05:59.752
WRITTEN. THE AUTOMATED CONTACT
02:05:59.818 --> 02:06:01.220
THREE THING IN THE LAST AT
02:06:01.287 --> 02:06:02.554
LEAST THAT THAT IT'S ALREADY
02:06:02.621 --> 02:06:03.722
BEEN FOUGHT FOR AND THE APPLE
02:06:03.789 --> 02:06:05.891
GOOGLE API FACT. IS THAT
02:06:05.958 --> 02:06:07.893
PROXIMITY OP USERS WILL REPORT
02:06:07.960 --> 02:06:09.895
NO INFORMATION FROM THEIR PHONE
02:06:09.962 --> 02:06:11.030
TWO ESSENTIAL TO THE TENT
02:06:11.096 --> 02:06:12.798
EXCEPT IF THEY ARE CONFIRMED
02:06:12.865 --> 02:06:14.433
I'VE INTERACTED WITH COALBED.
02:06:14.500 --> 02:06:16.402
BUT PROXIMITY IDENTIFIERS THAT
02:06:16.468 --> 02:06:19.939
THEIR PHONE USE THAT WILL THEN
02:06:20.005 --> 02:06:20.539
TRANSMIT THAT DATA TO OTHERS.
02:06:20.606 --> 02:06:21.640
EVEN IF THE BILL MAKES SOME
02:06:21.707 --> 02:06:22.975
PEOPLE FEEL MORE COMFORTABLE
02:06:23.042 --> 02:06:25.110
SHARING THEIR TEST RESULTS. BUT
02:06:25.177 --> 02:06:25.978
SHOULD HAVE NO BEARING
02:06:26.045 --> 02:06:27.279
WHATSOEVER ON THEIR COMFORT
02:06:27.346 --> 02:06:29.448
WHEN IT COMES TO DOWNLOADING
02:06:29.515 --> 02:06:31.116
THINGS LIKE PROXIMITY APPS.
02:06:31.183 --> 02:06:32.084
WHICH ARE ALSO NOT CURRENTLY
02:06:32.151 --> 02:06:33.786
REQUIRED UNDER LAW TO LIMIT THE
02:06:33.852 --> 02:06:35.888
SCOPE AND USE A DATA THAT THEY
02:06:35.955 --> 02:06:37.790
COLLECT. MOREOVER IF MEASURE
02:06:37.856 --> 02:06:38.958
WILL HAVE LITTLE RELEVANCE
02:06:39.024 --> 02:06:40.359
WHATSOEVER TO TESTING WERE
02:06:40.426 --> 02:06:42.294
UNABLE TO MEET THE DEMAND FOR
02:06:42.361 --> 02:06:44.496
TAX IN THE FIRST PLACE. FINALLY
02:06:44.563 --> 02:06:45.397
I'VE WRITTEN THE MEASURE
02:06:45.464 --> 02:06:47.533
SPECIFIED A SINGULAR WAY BY AT
02:06:47.599 --> 02:06:49.168
THE W. THREE V. PROTOCOLS FOR
02:06:49.234 --> 02:06:51.337
TAX DEVELOPERS TO BUILD. THIS
02:06:51.403 --> 02:06:52.705
LOCKED INTO PLACE SINGLE
02:06:52.771 --> 02:06:54.974
STANDARD. BECAUSE TECHNOLOGY
02:06:55.040 --> 02:06:57.142
CHANGES OVER TIME OFTEN RAPIDLY
02:06:57.209 --> 02:06:58.610
BUT DRAFTING COULD CREATE
02:06:58.677 --> 02:07:02.548
FIFTEEN CONNECTICUT POP ON AND
02:07:02.614 --> 02:07:03.215
THE VERY NEAR FUTURE. THANK YOU.
02:07:03.282 --> 02:07:04.950
THANK YOU VERY MUCH ADDITIONAL
02:07:05.017 --> 02:07:06.585
WITNESSES- IN OPPOSITION TO THE
02:07:06.652 --> 02:07:11.457
BILL. ONE ON THE LINE REPEAL
02:07:11.523 --> 02:07:15.461
WITHOUT. YEP WILL GO TO THE
02:07:15.527 --> 02:07:18.864
LINE OF. REBECCA CREAMER MALTER
02:07:18.931 --> 02:07:22.801
PLEASE GO AHEAD. BACK AT KRAMER
02:07:22.868 --> 02:07:24.470
MATTER ON BEHALF OF THE ACLU IN
02:07:24.536 --> 02:07:26.905
CALIFORNIA WE APPRECIATE THE
02:07:26.972 --> 02:07:29.141
OPERATOR AND- I'M SPEAKING WITH
02:07:29.208 --> 02:07:31.310
US YESTERDAY HOWEVER WE DO
02:07:31.377 --> 02:07:33.245
REMAIN. OPPOSED TO THAT STYLE
02:07:33.312 --> 02:07:35.647
THANK YOU. THANK YOU OTHERS IN
02:07:35.714 --> 02:07:41.220
OPPOSITION. THERE WAS ONE THAT
02:07:41.286 --> 02:07:44.823
WAS IN- POSITIVE THAT MISSED
02:07:44.890 --> 02:07:46.658
THE OPPORTUNITY CHRIS ALLEN
02:07:46.725 --> 02:07:53.232
YOUR LINE IS OPEN. BROWN I'M
02:07:53.298 --> 02:07:58.504
I'M THE FOUNDER. STRUCTURE
02:07:58.570 --> 02:07:59.405
SOFTWARE DEVELOPMENT AND
02:07:59.471 --> 02:08:01.573
RESEARCH BUT IN PARTICULAR FOR
02:08:01.640 --> 02:08:04.176
THIS SPEAKING ON BEHALF OF THE
02:08:04.243 --> 02:08:06.645
BROADER INTERNATIONAL STANDARDS
02:08:06.712 --> 02:08:08.814
W. THREE C. AND THE CREDENTIALS
02:08:08.881 --> 02:08:10.682
COMMUNITY GROUP THEREFORE I AM
02:08:10.749 --> 02:08:14.053
CARE- MY TAXES SHE COULD NOT
02:08:14.119 --> 02:08:17.022
WATER SSL TLS THE BROADEST.
02:08:17.089 --> 02:08:27.299
YEAH I HAVE INTERNET TRAFFIC.
02:08:27.366 --> 02:08:30.369
LOBBYIST BY. ON THE NEW
02:08:30.436 --> 02:08:32.704
SECURITY ARCHITECTURE BACK TO
02:08:32.771 --> 02:08:34.406
TOP OFFICIALS IN DECENTRALIZED
02:08:34.473 --> 02:08:38.377
AGAIN A. STANDARD WITH
02:08:38.444 --> 02:08:39.778
WORLDWIDE WEB RESOURCE THE
02:08:39.845 --> 02:08:44.483
SECOND IN LATE STAGES OF THEIR-
02:08:44.550 --> 02:08:47.753
OUR FIVE YEAR. FOR MANY
02:08:47.820 --> 02:08:52.991
QUESTIONS. I DON'T. SIR I DO
02:08:53.058 --> 02:08:56.929
NOT HAVE RECOGNITION. SIR YOUR
02:08:56.995 --> 02:08:57.496
LINE IS KIND OF RIGHT DO NOT
02:08:57.563 --> 02:09:02.601
HAVE. SORRY I WALL. BE MORE
02:09:02.668 --> 02:09:04.470
CLEAR- I DON'T HAVE
02:09:04.536 --> 02:09:06.004
RESERVATIONS THESE NEW
02:09:06.071 --> 02:09:08.207
TECHNOLOGIES OFFER A NUMBER OF
02:09:08.273 --> 02:09:09.608
PRIVACY BY DESIGN AND ADDRESS
02:09:09.675 --> 02:09:11.510
SECURITY ISSUES THAT LEGACY
02:09:11.577 --> 02:09:13.345
CREDENTIALS AND IDENTITY
02:09:13.412 --> 02:09:15.114
TECHNOLOGIES DO NOT
02:09:15.180 --> 02:09:16.982
ORGANIZATIONS INCLUDING THE US
02:09:17.049 --> 02:09:18.717
DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND SECURITY
02:09:18.784 --> 02:09:19.852
THE OLD OR THE CANADIAN
02:09:19.918 --> 02:09:21.019
GOVERNMENT AND A NUMBER OF
02:09:21.086 --> 02:09:23.055
OTHER USE NATIONS ARE COMMITTED
02:09:23.122 --> 02:09:24.456
TO MOVING TOWARD THE SOLUTIONS
02:09:24.523 --> 02:09:27.259
USING THESE. ARCHITECTURES MY
02:09:27.326 --> 02:09:28.760
RESERVATIONS REGARDING THIS
02:09:28.827 --> 02:09:30.762
BILL IS LESS ABOUT THE EFFICACY
02:09:30.829 --> 02:09:32.264
OF THE TECHNOLOGY BUT THE
02:09:32.331 --> 02:09:34.166
IMMATURITY UPPER BOTCHED
02:09:34.233 --> 02:09:35.601
HEALTHCARE PRIVACY IN RISK
02:09:35.667 --> 02:09:38.504
MODELS AND THE EXPECTED PUBLIC
02:09:38.570 --> 02:09:40.405
HEALTH CARE BENEFITS IN REGARDS
02:09:40.472 --> 02:09:42.708
FOR USE OF THESE TECHNOLOGIES-
02:09:42.774 --> 02:09:44.309
ARM WHICH WERE NOT IN THE
02:09:44.376 --> 02:09:46.078
ORIGINAL USE CASES TO FIND AND
02:09:46.145 --> 02:09:47.980
STANDARDS. FOR INSTANCE I FEEL
02:09:48.046 --> 02:09:49.548
THAT THE USE OF SCARAB BIBLE
02:09:49.615 --> 02:09:51.183
CLEANS FOR COMMUNITY
02:09:51.250 --> 02:09:53.685
CREDENTIALS REQUIRE ADDITIONAL
02:09:53.752 --> 02:09:57.289
RISK ANALYSIS. LIKE THE- STAFF
02:09:57.356 --> 02:10:00.192
I HAVE CONCERNS ABOUT THE- THE
02:10:00.259 --> 02:10:01.460
USE OF CREDENTIALS FROM A
02:10:01.527 --> 02:10:05.430
PUBLIC HEALTH- PERSPECTIVE- BUT
02:10:05.497 --> 02:10:07.866
IT'S NOT ABOUT THE TECHNOLOGY
02:10:07.933 --> 02:10:09.902
ITSELF. I DO BELIEVE THAT IF
02:10:09.968 --> 02:10:11.370
THE STATE ASSEMBLY IS GOING TO
02:10:11.436 --> 02:10:12.704
OPERATE SOME FORM OF
02:10:12.771 --> 02:10:15.073
INVESTIGATION PROOF OF CONCEPT
02:10:15.140 --> 02:10:16.408
OR IMPLEMENTATION OF NEW
02:10:16.475 --> 02:10:18.110
PRIVACY PRESERVING HEALTHCARE
02:10:18.177 --> 02:10:19.811
TECHNOLOGIES THAT VERIFIABLE
02:10:19.878 --> 02:10:21.480
CLAIMS IN THE CENTRAL LIKE
02:10:21.547 --> 02:10:24.016
IDENTIFIERS ARE THE STATUS
02:10:24.082 --> 02:10:25.150
ARCHITECTURE AVAILABLE TODAY.
02:10:25.217 --> 02:10:26.218
ALL RIGHT OF COURSE IMPLEMENTED
02:10:26.285 --> 02:10:28.987
STILL NEED TO BE CAREFUL WITH
02:10:29.054 --> 02:10:29.488
THE DETAILS IT IS STILL
02:10:29.555 --> 02:10:30.956
POSSIBLE USE THESE. REYES
02:10:31.023 --> 02:10:34.393
COMPROMISE THEIR INTENDED GOALS
02:10:34.459 --> 02:10:35.928
FOR SECURITY AND PRIVACY. THAT
02:10:35.994 --> 02:10:38.063
BEING SAID CONTINUE USE OF THE
02:10:38.130 --> 02:10:40.165
EXTREMELY CRAP MAN IT LET IT BE
02:10:40.232 --> 02:10:42.367
ARCHITECTURES FOR OUR IDENTITY
02:10:42.434 --> 02:10:44.303
AND PERSONAL HEALTH INFORMATION
02:10:44.369 --> 02:10:48.607
AND THE HEALTHCARE. DAY. I URGE
02:10:48.674 --> 02:10:50.008
YOU TO SUPPORT IN NEW. TO
02:10:50.075 --> 02:10:52.678
ENABLE VERIFIABLE CLAIMS AS AN
02:10:52.744 --> 02:10:54.613
INTERNATIONAL STANDARD TO BE
02:10:54.680 --> 02:10:57.749
ABLE TO BE USED AGAIN ARE YOUR
02:10:57.816 --> 02:10:59.818
OUR FUTURE WORK. THANK YOU FOR
02:10:59.885 --> 02:11:01.220
THE OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK BEFORE
02:11:01.286 --> 02:11:03.155
THE ASSEMBLY ON THIS TOPIC LET
02:11:03.222 --> 02:11:04.456
ME KNOW IF YOU NEED MORE
02:11:04.523 --> 02:11:06.291
DETAILS ON THE TECHNICAL TOPICS
02:11:06.358 --> 02:11:08.560
ABOUT. OTHER WAYS MY EX HE'S
02:11:08.627 --> 02:11:10.462
CAN BE OF SERVICE THANK YOU
02:11:10.529 --> 02:11:12.364
THANK YOU VERY MUCH SIR. DISHES
02:11:12.431 --> 02:11:15.300
ALL OPPONENT PLEASE IDENTIFY
02:11:15.367 --> 02:11:17.035
YOURSELF AND YOUR POSITION. UP
02:11:17.102 --> 02:11:24.710
I'M SORRY I. RIGHT ADDITIONAL
02:11:24.776 --> 02:11:30.349
FOLKS ON THE LINE. AND IF
02:11:30.415 --> 02:11:31.683
THERE'S ANYONE OUT LETTER
02:11:31.750 --> 02:11:34.553
COMMON IN OPPOSITION TO THIS
02:11:34.620 --> 02:11:42.461
BILL PLEASE PRESS ONE AND ZERO.
02:11:42.527 --> 02:11:53.472
WE HAVE KNOWN EACH YEAR. IF
02:11:53.538 --> 02:11:54.806
THERE ARE NO FURTHER
02:11:54.873 --> 02:11:56.141
INDIVIDUALS ONLINE IS BRING
02:11:56.208 --> 02:11:57.576
BACK TO COMMITTEE QUESTIONS OR
02:11:57.643 --> 02:11:58.877
COMMENTS MISTER OBERNOLTE
02:11:58.944 --> 02:12:01.446
FOLLOWED BY THIS WEEK'S I THANK
02:12:01.513 --> 02:12:04.483
YOU MISTER CHAIR- SO I'M
02:12:04.549 --> 02:12:06.251
GENERALLY SUPPORTIVE OF THIS
02:12:06.318 --> 02:12:08.353
IDEA OF USING A VERIFIABLE
02:12:08.420 --> 02:12:10.222
CREDENTIALS AS A TOOL FOR
02:12:10.289 --> 02:12:11.356
HEARING TEST RESULTS. I THOUGHT
02:12:11.423 --> 02:12:13.025
THE OPPOSITION IS AN
02:12:13.091 --> 02:12:15.093
INTERESTING COMMENT WHEN THE
02:12:15.160 --> 02:12:17.562
CRITICISM WAS BROUGHT UP THAT
02:12:17.629 --> 02:12:19.398
THERE PER IT MIGHT BE OTHER
02:12:19.464 --> 02:12:20.732
TECHNOLOGIES THERE ALSO
02:12:20.799 --> 02:12:22.701
APPROPRIATE FOR THIS BUT MY
02:12:22.768 --> 02:12:24.303
REACH IT WAS THAT IT'S JUST
02:12:24.369 --> 02:12:26.805
MERELY IF IT SAYS MAY. I HELP
02:12:26.872 --> 02:12:29.541
CARE PROVIDER THIS TO SHARE
02:12:29.608 --> 02:12:30.509
RESULT. NOT JUST THE LIMIT LIST
02:12:30.575 --> 02:12:31.677
OF. THE USE A VERIFIABLE
02:12:31.743 --> 02:12:33.578
CREDENTIALS SO I WANTED TO ASK
02:12:33.645 --> 02:12:35.113
ABOUT THAT I MEAN IS YOUR- IS
02:12:35.180 --> 02:12:36.281
YOUR UNDERSTANDING OF CURRENT
02:12:36.348 --> 02:12:39.217
LAW. THAT THIS IS REQUIRED FOR
02:12:39.284 --> 02:12:41.987
HEALTHCARE PROVIDER TO SHIP TO-
02:12:42.054 --> 02:12:43.121
I'M SORRY THAT THE TO CURRENT
02:12:43.188 --> 02:12:44.656
LAW PER PROHIBITS HEALTHCARE
02:12:44.723 --> 02:12:46.325
PROVIDER FROM- FROM SHARING
02:12:46.391 --> 02:12:48.660
TEST RESULTS. USING VERIFIABLE
02:12:48.727 --> 02:12:51.096
CREDENTIALS OR MAY HEALTHCARE
02:12:51.163 --> 02:12:53.065
PROVIDER CURRENTLY DO THIS I'D
02:12:53.131 --> 02:12:54.966
I WILL PROBABLY LET THE
02:12:55.033 --> 02:12:56.668
ADVOCATES FOR THE BILL ANSWER
02:12:56.735 --> 02:12:58.937
THAT BUT I THINK I MEAN THE WAY
02:12:59.004 --> 02:13:00.739
THAT I READ. MISTER CALDERON
02:13:00.806 --> 02:13:03.942
SPILL IS THAT THIS IS A ONE
02:13:04.009 --> 02:13:06.378
TECHNOLOGY THAT CAN BE USED. OF
02:13:06.445 --> 02:13:09.147
IN VERIFIABLE. OF CREDENTIALS
02:13:09.214 --> 02:13:10.449
OR IF YOU'RE DOING CONTACT
02:13:10.515 --> 02:13:12.184
TRACING OR IF YOU'RE DOING IT
02:13:12.250 --> 02:13:14.720
IMMUNOLOGY IT IMMUNITY PASSPORT
02:13:14.786 --> 02:13:17.189
SO. IT JUST IT JUST GIVES THE
02:13:17.255 --> 02:13:19.257
ABILITY TO USE BLOCKCHAIN IS
02:13:19.324 --> 02:13:22.627
ONE DATES THAT ONE WAY TO.
02:13:22.694 --> 02:13:23.729
PRIVACY JOURNAL I UNDERSTAND
02:13:23.795 --> 02:13:25.630
THAT MY QUESTION IS ABSENT THE
02:13:25.697 --> 02:13:29.000
BILL. CAN A PROVIDER USE
02:13:29.067 --> 02:13:30.836
VERIFIABLE CREDENTIALS TO SHARE
02:13:30.902 --> 02:13:33.305
TEST RESULT WITH THE PATIENT. I
02:13:33.372 --> 02:13:35.841
THINK THAT'S UP TO- THAT'S UP
02:13:35.907 --> 02:13:37.275
TO HEALTH CARE AGENCIES I DON'T
02:13:37.342 --> 02:13:38.243
THINK THAT THAT'S NECESSARILY
02:13:38.310 --> 02:13:41.246
BEEN DECIDED YET BUT- HOW ABOUT
02:13:41.313 --> 02:13:41.780
THE ADVOCATES ANSWER THAT
02:13:41.847 --> 02:13:43.815
QUESTION. SURE LET'S GO TO THE
02:13:43.882 --> 02:13:48.820
WITNESS. RIGHT YEAH HAPPY TO
02:13:48.887 --> 02:13:50.322
JUMP IN HERE AND THANK YOU FOR
02:13:50.389 --> 02:13:50.922
REMEMBER A LOT OF PEOPLE THAT
02:13:50.989 --> 02:13:53.658
QUESTION- YEAH THERE'S NOTHING
02:13:53.725 --> 02:13:55.827
YOU INCURRED FOR HITTING AT ALL
02:13:55.894 --> 02:13:56.528
AFTER FOR USING THAT I
02:13:56.595 --> 02:13:58.764
UNDERSTAND- THERE THE DOCTOR IN
02:13:58.830 --> 02:14:00.098
WYOMING IS CURRENTLY USING THAT
02:14:00.165 --> 02:14:02.868
CURRENTLY- WHAT THE BILL DOES
02:14:02.934 --> 02:14:04.302
IS THAT IT IS NOT LISTED
02:14:04.369 --> 02:14:06.471
STANDARD EIGHT YOU WOULD FEEL
02:14:06.538 --> 02:14:11.810
COMFORTABLE. WITH A LOT. OKAY
02:14:11.877 --> 02:14:13.111
THE- TO RESTATE THE OF THE BILL
02:14:13.178 --> 02:14:15.013
IS IF A PROVIDER IS GOING TO
02:14:15.080 --> 02:14:17.682
USE VERIFIABLE CREDENTIALS THIS
02:14:17.749 --> 02:14:18.283
WILL ESTABLISH A FRAMEWORK FOR
02:14:18.350 --> 02:14:22.988
DOING SO. FOR USING THAT AIM TO.
02:14:23.054 --> 02:14:23.789
ALL RIGHT THANK YOU FROM OF THE
02:14:23.855 --> 02:14:28.193
BILL. THIS WICKS GO AHEAD
02:14:28.260 --> 02:14:29.728
PLEASE THANK YOU I EVER-
02:14:29.795 --> 02:14:32.197
QUESTION AND A COMMENT- AND
02:14:32.264 --> 02:14:33.165
IT'S A LITTLE BIT SIMILAR TO I
02:14:33.231 --> 02:14:34.666
THINK MISTRAL NINETIES QUESTION
02:14:34.733 --> 02:14:36.201
BUT SO WITH THIS BILL- ANYTHING
02:14:36.268 --> 02:14:38.203
THAT IS CURRENTLY NOT PERMITTED
02:14:38.270 --> 02:14:41.573
UNDER CALIFORNIA LAW. HOW ABOUT
02:14:41.640 --> 02:14:46.011
THE ADVOCATE CANCERS THAT. YEAH
02:14:46.077 --> 02:14:47.412
NO IT WOULD NOT IT WOULD
02:14:47.479 --> 02:14:48.680
CERTAINLY NOT PEOPLE EAT ANY
02:14:48.747 --> 02:14:50.615
HALF HOUR HERE ARE THE AM I A
02:14:50.682 --> 02:14:52.918
OR T. V. P. A STANDARD IT WOULD
02:14:52.984 --> 02:14:54.352
NOT DOING ANYTHING ABOUT IT FOR
02:14:54.419 --> 02:14:56.621
HER TO HELP ME A LOT IT IS
02:14:56.688 --> 02:14:58.924
SIMPLY CLARIFYING. EXPECTED FOR
02:14:58.990 --> 02:15:03.295
A CONVENE INFORMATION. AND
02:15:03.361 --> 02:15:05.063
ESTABLISHMENT OF. YEAH OKAY AND
02:15:05.130 --> 02:15:06.431
JUST A COMMENT IN A I KNOW. MR
02:15:06.498 --> 02:15:07.666
ONES NOT THE AUTHOR I AND I'VE
02:15:07.732 --> 02:15:08.834
SPOKEN WITH THE AUTHOR MISTER
02:15:08.900 --> 02:15:10.735
CALDERON. I MEAN I SHARE SOME
02:15:10.802 --> 02:15:11.837
OF THE PRIVACY CONCERNS BUT
02:15:11.903 --> 02:15:12.537
I'LL GIVE THE ALL INTO
02:15:12.604 --> 02:15:14.539
COURTESY AYE VOTE TODAY TO GET
02:15:14.606 --> 02:15:15.507
OTHER COMMITTEE BUT IT'S MY
02:15:15.574 --> 02:15:17.042
HOPE THAT. THE OTHER CAN WORK
02:15:17.108 --> 02:15:18.844
WITH THE OPPOSITION TO TRY TO
02:15:18.910 --> 02:15:21.713
COME TO SOME SORT OF COMPROMISE
02:15:21.780 --> 02:15:23.482
VERTICALLY IN THE PRIVACY. YEAH
02:15:23.548 --> 02:15:25.951
AND IT. IS A- NOTE FROM MISTER
02:15:26.017 --> 02:15:27.052
CALDERON. REAL THAT HE WILL
02:15:27.118 --> 02:15:28.787
WORK WITH THAT YOU HAVE HALF AN
02:15:28.854 --> 02:15:32.023
ACLU TO. ADDRESS THEIR
02:15:32.090 --> 02:15:32.591
CONCERNS. THAT'S GREAT THANK
02:15:32.657 --> 02:15:36.127
YOU. ADDITIONAL COMMENTS OR
02:15:36.194 --> 02:15:40.265
QUESTIONS. SEEING NONE I THANK
02:15:40.332 --> 02:15:43.335
YOU VERY MUCH OF HIS IRWIN- FOR
02:15:43.401 --> 02:15:43.902
YOUR PRESENTATION FOR MISTER
02:15:43.969 --> 02:15:47.038
CALDERON- THIS BILL- HAS
02:15:47.105 --> 02:15:49.307
SOMEWHAT BEEN A STRUGGLE FOR ME
02:15:49.374 --> 02:15:51.643
I INITIALLY- BUT I THINK THE
02:15:51.710 --> 02:15:53.645
AUTHOR HAS A VISION THAT COULD
02:15:53.712 --> 02:15:54.212
HELP PROTECT THE PRIVACY OF
02:15:54.279 --> 02:15:56.248
MEDICAL TEST RESULTS IN A CHECK
02:15:56.314 --> 02:15:57.782
THAT VISION. IS CHIEF IT COULD
02:15:57.849 --> 02:15:59.317
BE A REAL BENEFIT CALIFORNIA
02:15:59.384 --> 02:16:02.087
RESIDENTS SAYS ECONOMY RE OPENS
02:16:02.153 --> 02:16:04.489
UP I UNDERSTAND THAT THE BILL
02:16:04.556 --> 02:16:06.391
NEEDS ADDITIONAL WORK BUT THE
02:16:06.458 --> 02:16:08.527
SHOW OF HAVING KNOWLEDGE YOU TO
02:16:08.593 --> 02:16:11.730
SECURELY HELP IN DECLINE IT
02:16:11.796 --> 02:16:15.734
THERE I. STE THURSDAY. TO THIS
02:16:15.800 --> 02:16:17.135
IS AND THE COMMITMENT TO
02:16:17.202 --> 02:16:19.771
CONTINUE TO WORK WITH. MY TEAM
02:16:19.838 --> 02:16:21.506
AS WELL AS OUR STAKEHOLDERS IN
02:16:21.573 --> 02:16:22.474
EXPERTS TO ADDRESS THE
02:16:22.541 --> 02:16:24.743
CONCERNS- WITH THE BILL BEFORE
02:16:24.809 --> 02:16:27.212
US AND FOR THAT REASON TODAY I
02:16:27.279 --> 02:16:30.415
WILL SUPPORT THE BILL- HAVING
02:16:30.482 --> 02:16:32.584
SAID THAT I THINK WHEN. THERE
02:16:32.651 --> 02:16:34.386
IS AN OPPORTUNITY FOR THIS BILL
02:16:34.452 --> 02:16:36.588
TO- COME BACK TO THIS COMMITTEE
02:16:36.655 --> 02:16:38.590
SO WILL HAVE A SECOND CHANCE TO
02:16:38.657 --> 02:16:42.160
LOOK AT THE BILL AND- AND I'M
02:16:42.227 --> 02:16:45.196
HOPEFUL THAT- BUT A TIME IT
02:16:45.263 --> 02:16:47.966
COMES BACK- WE WILL HAVE. SOME
02:16:48.033 --> 02:16:52.203
THE SOME OF THESE. REYES IT
02:16:52.270 --> 02:16:53.705
WOULD NOT THE BILL HAS BEEN
02:16:53.772 --> 02:16:57.108
MOVED UP DO I HAVE A SECOND ON
02:16:57.175 --> 02:16:58.543
THAT MOTION IT'S MOVED AND
02:16:58.610 --> 02:17:00.612
SECONDED THAT MR WHEN WOULD YOU
02:17:00.679 --> 02:17:01.846
LIKE TO CLOSE- JUST
02:17:01.913 --> 02:17:03.648
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR PRIVACY
02:17:03.715 --> 02:17:05.317
THANK YOU VERY MUCH OUT SO
02:17:05.383 --> 02:17:07.085
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
02:17:07.152 --> 02:17:09.321
ROLL. MOTION IS TO PASS IS
02:17:09.387 --> 02:17:14.192
ENDED CHAO HI SHALL I KILEY.
02:17:14.259 --> 02:17:16.027
KILEY AYE OUR QUE HAN. OKAY
02:17:16.094 --> 02:17:19.030
HAND I BERMAN. BERMAN AYE
02:17:19.097 --> 02:17:23.201
MEDINA AYE MEDINA I CARILLO. I
02:17:23.268 --> 02:17:27.706
MULLIN GALLAGHER GALLAGHER I
02:17:27.772 --> 02:17:32.477
IRWIN HI- WHEN I OBERNOLTE
02:17:32.544 --> 02:17:35.747
OBERNOLTE I WICKS. WICKS HI THE
02:17:35.814 --> 02:17:38.116
BILL IS OUT CONGRATULATIONS SO
02:17:38.183 --> 02:17:42.120
THAT BRINGS US TO AB THIRTY ONE
02:17:42.187 --> 02:17:43.788
SIXTEEN THAT MISS IRWIN BELK
02:17:43.855 --> 02:17:45.357
AND AGAIN IT WOULD YOU LIKE TO
02:17:45.423 --> 02:17:46.458
REGISTER YOUR SUPPORT OR
02:17:46.524 --> 02:17:48.760
OPPOSITION BY PHONE I DO
02:17:48.827 --> 02:17:50.629
ENCOURAGE YOU TO CALL IN NOW
02:17:50.695 --> 02:17:52.831
AND- WHEN THE ASSEMBLY MEMBER
02:17:52.897 --> 02:17:55.166
OF BEGIN SIR TESTIMONY- THIS IS
02:17:55.233 --> 02:17:57.302
THE TIME FOR YOU TO- DIAL THAT
02:17:57.369 --> 02:17:58.903
NUMBER THE NUMBER NUMBER AGAIN
02:17:58.970 --> 02:18:02.340
IS EIGHT SEVEN SEVEN SIX NINE
02:18:02.407 --> 02:18:08.346
TWO. NINE FIVE SEVEN AGAIN
02:18:08.413 --> 02:18:08.913
EIGHT SEVEN SEVEN SIX NINE.
02:18:08.980 --> 02:18:10.248
FIVE SO WITH WHEN PLEASE
02:18:10.315 --> 02:18:11.916
PROCEED A THANK YOU MUCH
02:18:11.983 --> 02:18:17.188
ASSEMBLY MEMBER TELL US AB.
02:18:17.255 --> 02:18:17.956
THREE ONE ONE SIX. IS A BILL
02:18:18.023 --> 02:18:19.891
WHICH I AM A JOINT OFFERING
02:18:19.958 --> 02:18:23.795
WITH ASSEMBLY MEMBER WICKS AB
02:18:23.862 --> 02:18:24.362
THIRTY ONE SIXTEEN PROVIDES
02:18:24.429 --> 02:18:25.497
CLARITY THAT MOBILITY DEVICE
02:18:25.563 --> 02:18:27.132
INFORMATION IS COVERED UNDER
02:18:27.198 --> 02:18:28.900
CURRENT PROVISIONS OF THE
02:18:28.967 --> 02:18:30.035
CALIFORNIA ELECTRONIC
02:18:30.101 --> 02:18:32.737
COMMUNICATIONS PRIVACY ACT OR
02:18:32.804 --> 02:18:35.940
CAL ACT A AS IT RELATES TO
02:18:36.007 --> 02:18:37.742
LOCAL GOVERNMENT COLLECTION OF
02:18:37.809 --> 02:18:39.344
LOOK. FROM LAST YEAR REQUEST
02:18:39.411 --> 02:18:41.446
THE LEGISLATIVE COUNSEL LOOKING
02:18:41.513 --> 02:18:42.313
TO THE SUBJECT MATTER OF THIS
02:18:42.380 --> 02:18:45.350
BILL AS IT RELATES TO THE LOCAL
02:18:45.417 --> 02:18:46.851
GOVERNOR PERMITTING OPERATIONS.
02:18:46.918 --> 02:18:48.486
OUR RECORD WOULD REQUIRE REAL
02:18:48.553 --> 02:18:49.521
TIME DATA SHARING AND THEY
02:18:49.587 --> 02:18:50.722
CONCLUDED THAT PERMIT
02:18:50.789 --> 02:18:52.424
REQUIREMENTS THAT COMPEL TRIP
02:18:52.490 --> 02:18:54.259
DATA FROM MOBILITY DEVICES ARE
02:18:54.325 --> 02:18:55.860
GOVERNED BY CAL ACT THAT.
02:18:55.927 --> 02:18:57.195
REQUIRING EITHER THE USERS
02:18:57.262 --> 02:18:59.197
CONSENT OR A COURT ORDER TO BE
02:18:59.264 --> 02:19:01.266
COMPLIANT WITH THE LAW. GIVEN
02:19:01.332 --> 02:19:02.434
THAT LOCAL GOVERNMENTS ARE
02:19:02.500 --> 02:19:04.202
DISPUTING THIS INTERPRETATION
02:19:04.269 --> 02:19:05.637
THIS BILL IS SIMPLY MEANT TO
02:19:05.704 --> 02:19:07.872
CLARIFY DID EXISTING LAW WHILE
02:19:07.939 --> 02:19:09.107
PROVIDING A PASSWORD REASONABLE
02:19:09.174 --> 02:19:10.842
AGGREGATE AND THE I. FIVE DATA
02:19:10.909 --> 02:19:12.844
USE. FOR TRANSPORTATION
02:19:12.911 --> 02:19:15.080
PLANNING. AS EFFORTS CONTINUE
02:19:15.146 --> 02:19:17.015
TO USE DATA AND TECHNOLOGY TO
02:19:17.082 --> 02:19:18.717
ADDRESS THIS CALL THAT NINETEEN
02:19:18.783 --> 02:19:19.851
PUBLIC HEALTH EMERGENCY AT THE
02:19:19.918 --> 02:19:22.053
LOCAL LEVEL IS OF CRITICAL
02:19:22.120 --> 02:19:23.088
IMPORTANCE THAT
02:19:23.154 --> 02:19:23.922
MISINTERPRETATION OF EXISTING
02:19:23.988 --> 02:19:26.191
LAW. WHICH HARM THE PRIVACY OF
02:19:26.257 --> 02:19:27.859
CALIFORNIANS ARE NOT ALLOWED TO
02:19:27.926 --> 02:19:30.929
PERSIST. AS NOTED ON PAGE SEVEN
02:19:30.995 --> 02:19:32.697
OF THE COMMITEE ANALYSIS I AM
02:19:32.764 --> 02:19:33.932
HAPPY TO BE TAKING AMENDMENT TO
02:19:33.998 --> 02:19:36.701
SUGGESTED. THAT IMPROVES THE
02:19:36.768 --> 02:19:38.303
BILL'S REFERENCE TO CAL. I'M
02:19:38.369 --> 02:19:41.506
PLEASE JOIN HERE TODAY BY PHONE
02:19:41.573 --> 02:19:43.408
WITH THE ROBERT CALLAGHAN FROM
02:19:43.475 --> 02:19:45.043
THE INTERNET ASSOCIATION AND
02:19:45.110 --> 02:19:51.216
MAP THE CORBIN FROM. ELECTRONIC
02:19:51.282 --> 02:19:53.785
FUN DOWN HERE. THANK GO TO A
02:19:53.852 --> 02:19:54.919
WITNESSES MISTER CALLAHAN ON
02:19:54.986 --> 02:19:57.655
THE LINE. I AM THANK YOU MISTER
02:19:57.722 --> 02:19:59.491
CHAIR AND MEMBERS ROBERT
02:19:59.557 --> 02:20:00.959
CALLAGHAN WITH HERE THIS ISSUE
02:20:01.025 --> 02:20:02.594
SHE HAD NOT A PROUD TO BE IN
02:20:02.660 --> 02:20:04.262
SUPPORT OF AB THREE ONE ONE
02:20:04.329 --> 02:20:06.397
SIX. THE BILL THAT WOULD SIMPLY
02:20:06.464 --> 02:20:08.266
CLARIFY THAT Q. LOCATION AND
02:20:08.333 --> 02:20:09.667
YOUR LOCATION RELATED DATA
02:20:09.734 --> 02:20:11.736
GENERATED FROM THE OPERATION OF
02:20:11.803 --> 02:20:13.738
MOBILITY DEVICES IS PERSONAL
02:20:13.805 --> 02:20:15.106
INFORMATION AND SUBJECT TO
02:20:15.173 --> 02:20:16.508
EXISTING PROTECTIONS AND STATE
02:20:16.574 --> 02:20:18.777
LAW- NAY PLACES OF A WOMAN
02:20:18.843 --> 02:20:20.845
MENTIONED ARE OPENING-
02:20:20.912 --> 02:20:21.312
CALIFORNIA ELECTRONIC
02:20:21.379 --> 02:20:22.881
COMMUNICATIONS PRIVACY ACT AS
02:20:22.947 --> 02:20:25.016
WELL AS THE- RECENTLY ENACTED
02:20:25.083 --> 02:20:26.451
CALIFORNIA CONSUMER PRIVACY
02:20:26.518 --> 02:20:29.220
ACT. AS WAS DISCUSSED IN GREAT
02:20:29.287 --> 02:20:30.822
DEPTH IN A SENATE PROMOTIONAL
02:20:30.889 --> 02:20:32.223
HEARING- JUST THIS PAST
02:20:32.290 --> 02:20:33.725
FEBRUARY THE LEGISLATIVE
02:20:33.792 --> 02:20:36.027
COUNSEL HAS NOW STATED
02:20:36.094 --> 02:20:38.363
REPEATEDLY THAT THE HELD DURING
02:20:38.429 --> 02:20:41.065
OF REAL TIME. SHE LOCATION THE
02:20:41.132 --> 02:20:43.701
GOVERNMENT COVER CAL TECH. FOR
02:20:43.768 --> 02:20:45.136
WHATEVER REPORTER BROTHER
02:20:45.203 --> 02:20:46.971
PROCESS AB MINUTES WE ALSO
02:20:47.038 --> 02:20:51.976
HEARD HEARING- INCREASING
02:20:52.043 --> 02:20:53.611
IMPORT PUBLIC IRAN'S ISSUE
02:20:53.678 --> 02:20:55.213
THERE TO NOT TO BE A- YOU CASE
02:20:55.280 --> 02:20:56.614
FOR THE- NON AGGREGATED TRIP
02:20:56.681 --> 02:20:59.083
DATA SHOWS THE MOVEMENTS OF
02:20:59.150 --> 02:21:00.985
INDIVIDUALS IN NEAR REAL TIME
02:21:01.052 --> 02:21:02.587
OUTSIDE OF AN URGENT LAW
02:21:02.654 --> 02:21:04.255
ENFORCEMENT MATTER. THE REAL
02:21:04.322 --> 02:21:05.523
TIME MONITORING OF MOBILITY
02:21:05.590 --> 02:21:07.692
DEVICE TRIP DATA EVEN IF
02:21:07.759 --> 02:21:08.860
INTENDED FOR LEGITIMATE USE
02:21:08.927 --> 02:21:10.161
SUCH AS TRANSPORTATION PLANNING
02:21:10.228 --> 02:21:12.697
PURPOSE. ADDS TO A REAL THREAT
02:21:12.764 --> 02:21:13.398
OF GROWING GOVERNMENT
02:21:13.464 --> 02:21:15.200
SURVEILLANCE ON THE MOVEMENT OF
02:21:15.266 --> 02:21:16.401
INDIVIDUALS. NOW AGAIN WE'RE
02:21:16.467 --> 02:21:18.069
NOT ARGUING- THROUGH THIS BILL
02:21:18.136 --> 02:21:20.471
THE PUBLIC AGENCIES DO NOT HAVE
02:21:20.538 --> 02:21:21.906
IMPORTANT USES FOR MOBILITY
02:21:21.973 --> 02:21:22.674
DATA BECAUSE THEY CERTAINLY DO
02:21:22.740 --> 02:21:24.943
YOU. AB THREE ONE SIX IS MY
02:21:25.009 --> 02:21:27.579
COMPROMISED PROTECTION AND FROM
02:21:27.645 --> 02:21:28.646
THERE ON WHAT ALSO ENSURING
02:21:28.713 --> 02:21:30.882
PUBLIC IT HE'S SAYS. THERE ARE
02:21:30.949 --> 02:21:32.183
DATED AND ANONYMIZE MOBILITY
02:21:32.250 --> 02:21:34.219
DATA WHICH SHOWS THE TRAPPINGS
02:21:34.285 --> 02:21:39.190
AND INSIGHTS NEEDED FOR
02:21:39.257 --> 02:21:44.295
INFRASTRUCTURE PLANNING YEAH
02:21:44.362 --> 02:21:45.697
THAT. USES FOR DEBT THE BILL TO
02:21:45.763 --> 02:21:47.765
COME. BUT NONE OF WHICH- WILL
02:21:47.832 --> 02:21:48.733
TRIP DAY AND IN EVERY WOULD
02:21:48.800 --> 02:21:50.001
BETTER SERVED WITH TARGETED
02:21:50.068 --> 02:21:52.470
AGGREGATED DATA WE AGREED THE
02:21:52.537 --> 02:21:53.538
COMMITTEES ANALYSIS WANTED
02:21:53.605 --> 02:21:55.340
STATES DEPLETED DOES NOT NEED
02:21:55.406 --> 02:21:56.541
TO BE TIED TO AN INDIVIDUAL OR
02:21:56.608 --> 02:21:58.576
VERGE TRIP. IN ORDER IS FOR THE
02:21:58.643 --> 02:22:00.144
CITY'S INDEED AGGREGATED
02:22:00.211 --> 02:22:01.646
ANONYMOUS DATA CAN PROVIDE
02:22:01.713 --> 02:22:03.381
INSIGHT TO THE TRAVEL PATTERNS
02:22:03.448 --> 02:22:04.582
CONGESTION AND USE GET THEIR
02:22:04.649 --> 02:22:06.618
INFRASTRUCTURE MADE. LOCATION
02:22:06.684 --> 02:22:08.419
DATA IS DEEPLY PERSONAL
02:22:08.486 --> 02:22:10.555
PERSONAL AND AMONG MOST PRIVACY
02:22:10.622 --> 02:22:11.656
SENSITIVE FORMS DATA THAT
02:22:11.723 --> 02:22:17.662
MERITS. CASE PROVIDED IS STILL.
02:22:17.729 --> 02:22:19.831
LIKELY ASK COMMITTEE FOR I ON
02:22:19.898 --> 02:22:20.932
AB THREE ONE ONCE THANK. THANK
02:22:20.999 --> 02:22:21.532
YOU VERY MUCH SO LET'S GO TO
02:22:21.599 --> 02:22:24.869
OUR NEXT. DIRECTOR CHAIR
02:22:24.936 --> 02:22:26.304
MEMBERS MET THE CORPORATE ON
02:22:26.371 --> 02:22:27.672
BEHALF OF THE ELECTRONIC
02:22:27.739 --> 02:22:29.741
FRONTIER FOUNDATION I WOULD BE
02:22:29.807 --> 02:22:30.708
AMENDMENT TAKEN TODAY AND
02:22:30.775 --> 02:22:31.910
COMMITTEE AT THE Q. IN SUPPORT
02:22:31.976 --> 02:22:34.145
OF THREE ONE ONE SIX WHICH AS
02:22:34.212 --> 02:22:35.480
AMENDED WILL STRIKE THE RIGHT
02:22:35.546 --> 02:22:36.381
BALANCE BETWEEN THE NEED TO
02:22:36.447 --> 02:22:38.483
PROTECT INDIVIDUAL PRIVACY. AND
02:22:38.549 --> 02:22:40.151
THE NEED FOR LOCAL AUTHORITIES
02:22:40.218 --> 02:22:41.252
TO OBTAIN THE DATA THAT THEY
02:22:41.319 --> 02:22:42.487
NEED FOR CITY PLANNING PUBLIC
02:22:42.553 --> 02:22:44.088
THAT. I'D ALSO LIKE TO THINK
02:22:44.155 --> 02:22:45.723
THE AUTHORS FOR DRESSING THIS
02:22:45.790 --> 02:22:48.126
IMPORTANT ISSUE AND FOR THE
02:22:48.192 --> 02:22:48.726
ENORMOUS AMOUNT OF TIME THEY
02:22:48.793 --> 02:22:51.095
SPENT DISCUSSING IT WITH US.
02:22:51.162 --> 02:22:52.230
LOW AND REGIONAL PLANNING
02:22:52.297 --> 02:22:53.531
AGENCIES AND JURISDICTIONS
02:22:53.598 --> 02:22:54.699
ACROSS THE COUNTRY ARE
02:22:54.766 --> 02:22:56.434
INCREASINGLY DEMANDING ACCESS
02:22:56.501 --> 02:22:57.902
TO NEW MOBILITY START AT THAT
02:22:57.969 --> 02:22:59.304
AND DEVICES IN ORDER TO BETTER
02:22:59.370 --> 02:23:00.571
PLAN. AND ENSURE THAT THE
02:23:00.638 --> 02:23:02.507
STREETS WORK FOR ALL. THE ABOUT
02:23:02.573 --> 02:23:03.975
THE GRIEF THAT PLANNING AGENCY
02:23:04.042 --> 02:23:05.643
SHOULD BE ABLE TO COLLECT SOME
02:23:05.710 --> 02:23:07.345
DATA IN ORDER TO NSURE NEW
02:23:07.412 --> 02:23:09.280
TRANSPORTATION DEBATE THAT ARE
02:23:09.347 --> 02:23:10.848
DEEPLY DEEPLY. PATIENTLY
02:23:10.915 --> 02:23:13.584
EQUITABLY AND SUSTAINABLY. BUT
02:23:13.651 --> 02:23:15.353
THEY SHOULD NOT BE TO COLLECT.
02:23:15.420 --> 02:23:16.654
PERSONALLY IDENTIFIABLE
02:23:16.721 --> 02:23:18.523
INFORMATION ABOUT WRITERS IN
02:23:18.589 --> 02:23:22.493
ORDER TO DO SO. SO TWO THINGS
02:23:22.560 --> 02:23:23.294
ARE NOT MUTUALLY EXCLUSIVE.
02:23:23.361 --> 02:23:25.163
INDIVIDUAL TRIP DATA IS
02:23:25.229 --> 02:23:26.331
SENSITIVE LOCATION DATA THAT
02:23:26.397 --> 02:23:28.166
PERTAIN TO MOVEMENT OF REAL
02:23:28.232 --> 02:23:30.401
INDIVIDUAL AS SUCH SHE ALWAYS
02:23:30.468 --> 02:23:32.370
BE OFF LIMITS FOR CITY OR
02:23:32.437 --> 02:23:33.871
REGIONAL PLANNING PURPOSES.
02:23:33.938 --> 02:23:35.673
LOCAL AUTHORITIES CAN AND
02:23:35.740 --> 02:23:37.675
SHOULD WE USE AGGREGATED AND DE
02:23:37.742 --> 02:23:40.411
IDENTIFIED TRICKY THAT TO IT
02:23:40.478 --> 02:23:41.980
THEY'RE PLANNING CALL. MEASURE
02:23:42.046 --> 02:23:43.715
TAKE A SIGNIFICANT STEP FORWARD
02:23:43.781 --> 02:23:44.682
TO PROTECTING THE LOCATION
02:23:44.749 --> 02:23:46.451
PRIVACY OF CALIFORNIA ACROSS
02:23:46.517 --> 02:23:48.119
THE STATE WHO RELY ON SHARED
02:23:48.186 --> 02:23:49.754
MOBILITY DEVICES. IT
02:23:49.821 --> 02:23:51.189
APPROPRIATELY RECOGNIZED THAT
02:23:51.255 --> 02:23:51.956
THE SENSITIVE NATURE OF
02:23:52.023 --> 02:23:53.958
INDIVIDUAL TRIP DATA AND ENSURE
02:23:54.025 --> 02:23:55.293
THAT LOCAL AUTHORITIES WILL
02:23:55.360 --> 02:23:57.662
RECEIVE ONLY AGGREGATED NON
02:23:57.729 --> 02:23:59.530
IDENTIFIABLE TRIP DATA. WE'VE
02:23:59.597 --> 02:24:01.733
PROTECTION FOR CRITICAL BECAUSE
02:24:01.799 --> 02:24:03.101
EVEN WITH NAME STRIPPED OUT
02:24:03.167 --> 02:24:04.369
LOCATION INFORMATION
02:24:04.435 --> 02:24:06.971
NOTORIOUSLY EASY TO LIKE THREE
02:24:07.038 --> 02:24:09.107
I GOT. PARTICULARLY FOR HER IF
02:24:09.173 --> 02:24:12.910
YOU OFFER. ESPECIALLY TRUE ONE
02:24:12.977 --> 02:24:16.814
LOCAL FOR ME I. OVER TO. I TWO
02:24:16.881 --> 02:24:17.382
THOUSAND THIRTEEN ON MOBILE
02:24:17.448 --> 02:24:19.817
DATA. HUMAN ABILITY TRADERS ARE
02:24:19.884 --> 02:24:22.820
HIGHLY UNIQUE RESEARCHERS FOUND
02:24:22.887 --> 02:24:24.789
THAT ONLY FOR THE POINT WHERE
02:24:24.856 --> 02:24:28.126
ENOUGH TO UNIQUELY IDENTIFY 95%
02:24:28.192 --> 02:24:31.062
OF ONE POINT FIVE MILLION
02:24:31.129 --> 02:24:31.796
INDIVIDUALS IN THE STUDY.
02:24:31.863 --> 02:24:33.631
FINALLY UPDATED AND QUITE
02:24:33.698 --> 02:24:36.067
IMPORTANTLY EIGHTY THREE ONE
02:24:36.134 --> 02:24:37.135
ONE PERFECT CLARIFY HOW ACT
02:24:37.201 --> 02:24:39.637
APPLIES TO INDIVIDUAL TRIP DATA
02:24:39.704 --> 02:24:40.671
THAT HAS BEEN VALIDATED BY
02:24:40.738 --> 02:24:42.640
LEGISLATIVE COUNSEL. ON ITS
02:24:42.707 --> 02:24:44.342
FACE THE LAW ALREADY CLEARLY
02:24:44.409 --> 02:24:46.511
APPLIES TO TRIP DATA GENERATED
02:24:46.577 --> 02:24:48.813
BY SHARED MOBILITY DEVICES
02:24:48.880 --> 02:24:50.848
HOWEVER CLARIFICATION IS
02:24:50.915 --> 02:24:52.183
NONETHELESS IMPORTANT BECAUSE
02:24:52.250 --> 02:24:53.851
MULTIPLE CALIFORNIA FIT HAVE
02:24:53.918 --> 02:24:56.054
TAKEN THE NOVEL PUT ON THAT THE
02:24:56.120 --> 02:24:58.089
FIGHT HELLO BUT CLEAN MY-
02:24:58.156 --> 02:25:00.658
DEFINITION. DOCU HOW DOES NOT
02:25:00.725 --> 02:25:05.096
APPLY TO THEM. AB THREE ONE SIX
02:25:05.163 --> 02:25:06.531
AND THE CLEAR SIGNAL TO THIRTY
02:25:06.597 --> 02:25:13.337
THE OFFICE. ONE OF. PRIVATE AND
02:25:13.404 --> 02:25:15.573
THEY'VE NEVER BUT THE KITCHEN
02:25:15.640 --> 02:25:17.642
THAT THE ALL INTENDED HOW LEX
02:25:17.708 --> 02:25:19.911
BUT APPLY INDIVIDUALTRIP JENNA
02:25:19.977 --> 02:25:23.581
BY BUT DEVICE AND A COOK BY OF
02:25:23.648 --> 02:25:25.149
THAT TWO THOUSAND MEASURE WE
02:25:25.216 --> 02:25:26.984
HOPE HARD AGREE AS YOU MIGHT
02:25:27.051 --> 02:25:32.023
THINK YOU. THANK YOU. OUR
02:25:32.090 --> 02:25:33.758
SHOULD NO SIMPLE. IN PERSON I
02:25:33.825 --> 02:25:35.193
DON'T SEE ANY LET'S GO TO THE
02:25:35.259 --> 02:25:38.763
PHONE LINES. ANYBODY IN SUPPORT
02:25:38.830 --> 02:25:40.998
OF THE BILL PLEASE SO. IDENTIFY
02:25:41.065 --> 02:25:43.601
YOURSELF AND IN THE
02:25:43.668 --> 02:25:44.168
ORGANIZATION AS WELL AS YOUR
02:25:44.235 --> 02:25:48.573
POSITION. ONE MOMENT PLEASE OUR
02:25:48.639 --> 02:25:52.510
OUR COMMON AGAIN IF YOU ARE AN-
02:25:52.577 --> 02:25:55.780
FOR A BILL THESE AT ONE AND
02:25:55.847 --> 02:26:15.600
ZERO. ONE MOMENT PLEASE.
02:26:37.255 --> 02:26:37.421
COMIC%
02:26:37.488 --> 02:26:38.789
COMES FROM ERIN AT EIGHT ONE
02:26:38.856 --> 02:26:58.109
MOM. YOUR LINE IS OPEN. AND
02:26:58.176 --> 02:27:00.912
YOUR LINE OF OPEN. FOR A
02:27:00.978 --> 02:27:01.779
COMMENT PLEASE IDENTIFY
02:27:01.846 --> 02:27:03.381
YOURSELF AND YOUR ORGANIZATION
02:27:03.447 --> 02:27:06.417
I. JUSTIN HIGHER SILICON VALLEY
02:27:06.484 --> 02:27:08.753
LEADERSHIP GROUP. ARE YOU
02:27:08.819 --> 02:27:13.958
SUPPORTER. YES SORRY- SILICON
02:27:14.025 --> 02:27:14.892
VALLEY LEADERSHIP GROUP IS
02:27:14.959 --> 02:27:17.061
PROUD TO SUPPORT A AB THIRTY
02:27:17.128 --> 02:27:18.062
ONE SIXTEEN THANK YOU SO MUCH
02:27:18.129 --> 02:27:20.097
FOR YOUR TIME THANK YOU VERY
02:27:20.164 --> 02:27:28.673
MUCH. ANYONE ELSE. YOUR LINE IS
02:27:28.739 --> 02:27:34.512
OPEN QUESTION OR COMMENT. HELLO
02:27:34.579 --> 02:27:37.415
YOUR NINE TO FIVE ON. HI FOR IN
02:27:37.481 --> 02:27:39.383
JENSEN WITH TECH THAT- ALSO ON
02:27:39.450 --> 02:27:41.819
THE COURT AT THIRTY THREE ONE
02:27:41.886 --> 02:27:56.000
ONE SIX. THANK YOU NEXT PLACE.
02:27:56.067 --> 02:27:57.668
AND YOUR MIND ABOUT YOUR LINE
02:27:57.735 --> 02:28:02.340
IS OPEN FOR COMMENT. YOUR LINE
02:28:02.406 --> 02:28:18.456
IS OPEN ON. PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:28:18.522 --> 02:28:20.091
NOW FOR NOW FOR THE LINE CAN
02:28:20.157 --> 02:28:22.026
KILL A COMMA THANK YOU VERY
02:28:22.093 --> 02:28:24.629
MUC LET'S NOW GO TO OPPOSITION
02:28:24.695 --> 02:28:25.429
I BELIEVE WE HAVE TO
02:28:25.496 --> 02:28:27.164
INDIVIDUALS ON THE LINE- MISS
02:28:27.231 --> 02:28:29.533
ALL RIGHT SOUNDS FROM THE LA
02:28:29.600 --> 02:28:31.068
DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION AS
02:28:31.135 --> 02:28:33.738
WELL AS- MISTER CLOSE ART FROM
02:28:33.804 --> 02:28:36.307
THE CITY OF SANTA MONICA. ARE
02:28:36.374 --> 02:28:40.544
YOU ON THE LINE SO. YES SO IT
02:28:40.611 --> 02:28:42.813
AROUND CAN YOU HEAR ME YES AGO
02:28:42.880 --> 02:28:46.684
HAD HIS RENTALS. THANK YOU VERY
02:28:46.751 --> 02:28:49.186
MUCH HONORABLE LEGISLATORS AS
02:28:49.253 --> 02:28:50.554
GENERAL MANAGER OF THE STATE'S
02:28:50.621 --> 02:28:51.922
LARGEST CITY TRANSPORTATION
02:28:51.989 --> 02:28:54.425
DEPARTMENT MY FOCUS LIKE YOURS.
02:28:54.492 --> 02:28:55.993
HAS BEEN ON MEETING CRITICAL
02:28:56.060 --> 02:28:58.596
NEED- DURING THIS TIME- MY
02:28:58.663 --> 02:29:00.998
EMPLOYEES ARE TRANSIT DRIVERS
02:29:01.065 --> 02:29:04.168
AND- TRAFFIC OFFICERS AND THEY
02:29:04.235 --> 02:29:05.870
ARE ON THE FRONT LINES AND THEY
02:29:05.936 --> 02:29:08.806
ARE SOFT IT AND RIGHT. MIGHT
02:29:08.873 --> 02:29:10.074
HERE WITH YOU TO GET AWAY FROM
02:29:10.141 --> 02:29:11.809
OUR CRISIS WORK AND THE MEASURE
02:29:11.876 --> 02:29:14.011
HOW SERIOUSLY I TAKE THIS BILL
02:29:14.078 --> 02:29:15.413
AND HAVE SERIOUSLY WOULD AFFECT
02:29:15.479 --> 02:29:16.781
CALIFORNIA CITY. IT WOULD
02:29:16.847 --> 02:29:18.516
RESTRICT OUR ABILITY TO PROTECT
02:29:18.582 --> 02:29:19.884
AND MANAGE THE STREETS AND
02:29:19.950 --> 02:29:21.118
SIDEWALKS AND PROMOTE SAFETY
02:29:21.185 --> 02:29:23.487
ACCESSIBILITY IN EQUITY AS
02:29:23.554 --> 02:29:25.022
PRIVATE AND FOR PROFIT VEHICLE
02:29:25.089 --> 02:29:26.290
OPERATE ON OUR STREETS AND
02:29:26.357 --> 02:29:27.958
SIDEWALKS. TODAY AND
02:29:28.025 --> 02:29:29.327
INCREASINGLY IN THE FUTURE
02:29:29.393 --> 02:29:31.028
ACCESS TO RELIABLE ACCURATE AND
02:29:31.095 --> 02:29:32.430
TIMELY DATA IS ESSENTIAL TO
02:29:32.496 --> 02:29:34.565
THIS WORK. IT'S ONLY THE LAST
02:29:34.632 --> 02:29:36.734
FEW YEARS BUT CITIES HAVE
02:29:36.801 --> 02:29:39.904
GAINED INSIGHT INTO OUT OF IT
02:29:39.970 --> 02:29:42.106
FOR THAT VEHICLE. USE OUR
02:29:42.173 --> 02:29:43.374
PUBLIC STREET. FOR ARE WE
02:29:43.441 --> 02:29:44.342
RELIED ON AGGREGATED. THAT
02:29:44.408 --> 02:29:45.076
TURNED OUT TO BE GROWTH
02:29:45.142 --> 02:29:47.311
MANIPULATED BY COMPANIES. THE
02:29:47.378 --> 02:29:49.113
RESULT WAS INCREASING TRAFFIC
02:29:49.180 --> 02:29:51.682
AND KERR CONGESTION ELEVATED CO
02:29:51.749 --> 02:29:53.417
TWO EMISSIONS. GROWING PUBLIC
02:29:53.484 --> 02:29:56.220
SAFETY CONCERNS REDUCE TRANSIT
02:29:56.287 --> 02:29:57.121
YOUTH AND THE MISTREATMENT OF
02:29:57.188 --> 02:29:58.622
WORKERS THAT REQUIRED THIS
02:29:58.689 --> 02:30:02.026
BOBBY TO PASS. THE FIVE. THAT'S
02:30:02.093 --> 02:30:02.593
THE OPPOSITE OF WHAT WE WERE
02:30:02.660 --> 02:30:04.328
PROMISED. THIS BILL FORTY TWO
02:30:04.395 --> 02:30:07.698
AGAIN REAL COMPANIES AGGREGATED
02:30:07.765 --> 02:30:10.401
DATA TO PROTECT BOOK AND-
02:30:10.468 --> 02:30:11.902
SIMPLY WON'T WORK RELY AND
02:30:11.969 --> 02:30:13.471
TIMELY IT WILL BE EVEN MORE
02:30:13.537 --> 02:30:14.939
ESSENTIAL AT EVERYTHING HE
02:30:15.005 --> 02:30:16.741
GRAPPLES WITH THE EFFECT OF
02:30:16.807 --> 02:30:17.842
THIS PANDEMIC. AND HOW THEY
02:30:17.908 --> 02:30:18.442
WILL SHAPE THE TRANSPORTATION
02:30:18.509 --> 02:30:20.211
LANDSCAPE IMAGE WIDESPREAD
02:30:20.277 --> 02:30:22.446
ECONOMIC DISRUPTION AND LAST X.
02:30:22.513 --> 02:30:24.348
PUBLIC HEALTH CONCERNS. LET ME
02:30:24.415 --> 02:30:26.183
BE CLEAR ABOUT DATA USE AND THE
02:30:26.250 --> 02:30:28.619
CITY OF LOS ANGELES WE COLLECT
02:30:28.686 --> 02:30:30.821
AND PROTECT FROM DISCLOSURE
02:30:30.888 --> 02:30:32.623
ONLY BASIC DATA ABOUT THE FOR
02:30:32.690 --> 02:30:34.291
PROFIT COME. VEHICLE OPERATING
02:30:34.358 --> 02:30:36.761
AND THE PLAY WE NOT COLLECT
02:30:36.827 --> 02:30:37.995
PERSONAL INFORMATION ABOUT
02:30:38.062 --> 02:30:41.432
WRITERS. IN FACT UBER AND JUMP
02:30:41.499 --> 02:30:43.100
INFORMED ITS RIDERS ON ITS OWN
02:30:43.167 --> 02:30:48.172
APT QUOTE. OF THE DAY WE CITIES
02:30:48.239 --> 02:30:49.306
COLLECTED FROM YOUR PERSONAL
02:30:49.373 --> 02:30:56.046
NOT DIVIDE. OR IF I YOU AFTER
02:30:56.113 --> 02:30:56.680
THOUSAND CONSIDERS WERE DROPPED
02:30:56.747 --> 02:30:58.082
ON OUR STREETS WE WANT TO PILOT
02:30:58.149 --> 02:30:58.682
THAT BECAME THE LARGE IN THE
02:30:58.749 --> 02:31:00.017
NAY PROVIDING NO LIVES FOR
02:31:00.084 --> 02:31:01.419
INJURY BEFORE THAT AND THEN THE
02:31:01.485 --> 02:31:04.455
CAT TO MANAGE THESE ALMOST
02:31:04.522 --> 02:31:07.191
FORTY THOUSAND VEHICLES AFFECT.
02:31:07.258 --> 02:31:09.360
WHY OR UNLOCKED THE COPY. US
02:31:09.427 --> 02:31:12.363
AND THAT SANDERS LOCATION. THIS
02:31:12.430 --> 02:31:14.231
SIMPLE REQUIREMENT US TO VERIFY
02:31:14.298 --> 02:31:17.301
DATA INTEGRITY BY. THEN A DAY
02:31:17.368 --> 02:31:18.869
AFTER THE SCOOTER IS USED THE
02:31:18.936 --> 02:31:20.938
COMPANY SENT THE CITY TRIP DATA
02:31:21.005 --> 02:31:23.741
NOT IN REAL TIME WE DON'T
02:31:23.808 --> 02:31:25.476
COLLECT NAMES ADDRESSES CREDIT
02:31:25.543 --> 02:31:26.944
INFORMATION OR ANY OTHER
02:31:27.011 --> 02:31:27.812
PERSONALLY IDENTIFIABLE
02:31:27.878 --> 02:31:29.513
INFORMATION. EVEN THOUGH THE
02:31:29.580 --> 02:31:31.749
DATA RECEIVED BASIC WE KEEP IT
02:31:31.816 --> 02:31:33.050
HIGHLY SECURE ENCRYPTED IF
02:31:33.117 --> 02:31:34.718
SOMEBODY WERE ABLE TO LEGALLY
02:31:34.785 --> 02:31:36.754
ACCESS ARE BROUGHT INCREASE
02:31:36.821 --> 02:31:38.122
DATA. HACK OTHER SOURCES
02:31:38.189 --> 02:31:40.124
INCLUDING OUTSIDE CITY OF LA
02:31:40.191 --> 02:31:42.293
DATABASES TO COBBLE TOGETHER AN
02:31:42.359 --> 02:31:44.161
INDIVIDUAL'S IDENTITY. AND FOR
02:31:44.228 --> 02:31:45.229
THOSE WHO BELIEVE CITIES WITH
02:31:45.296 --> 02:31:47.531
MISUSED DATA AFTER WHO SHOULD
02:31:47.598 --> 02:31:48.899
STOP COLLECTING PARKING TICKET
02:31:48.966 --> 02:31:51.435
REVENUES OF PROCESSING PERMIT.
02:31:51.502 --> 02:31:53.437
FOR KERR DESIGNATIONS AND SPEED
02:31:53.504 --> 02:31:54.738
HOW. PROPERTIES THAT WE MUCH
02:31:54.805 --> 02:31:55.673
PERSONALLY IDENTIFIABLE
02:31:55.739 --> 02:31:57.608
INFORMATION AND ASK FROM
02:31:57.675 --> 02:31:59.610
ABILITY COMPANIES TODAY. THE
02:31:59.677 --> 02:32:01.078
DATA WE COLLECTED NOT A TOOL
02:32:01.145 --> 02:32:03.314
FOR LAW ENFORCEMENT IT WOULD
02:32:03.380 --> 02:32:04.748
ONLY BE ACCESSIBLE WITH A
02:32:04.815 --> 02:32:05.683
SUBPOENA OR WARRANT THE DATA WE
02:32:05.749 --> 02:32:07.885
HAVE A VALUE TO ONE FORCED THE
02:32:07.952 --> 02:32:09.253
COMPANY'S EXTENSIVE DATA IS
02:32:09.320 --> 02:32:12.189
WHAT IS USED CALL NOT OURS.
02:32:12.256 --> 02:32:14.191
THIS DATA IS NOT AT ALL USEFUL
02:32:14.258 --> 02:32:15.459
FOR CONTACT TRACING THE WIRES
02:32:15.526 --> 02:32:17.161
THE FULL TRACK PATTERN THE
02:32:17.228 --> 02:32:19.697
SPECIFIC INDIVIDUAL THROUGHOUT
02:32:19.763 --> 02:32:21.532
THE DAY ACTIVE. ON THE PRODUCT
02:32:21.599 --> 02:32:24.368
THE CASE STATE THE DOCTOR SAID
02:32:24.435 --> 02:32:26.537
I RECEIVED FUNDAMENTAL
02:32:26.604 --> 02:32:30.808
OBSERVING STATUS CHANGES TO THE
02:32:30.875 --> 02:32:35.980
PUBLIC. YEAH BUT WHAT. BUT THAT
02:32:36.046 --> 02:32:37.481
HAS NO I DO THEFT INFORMATION
02:32:37.548 --> 02:32:41.252
AND CAN ONLY IN PUBLIC HEALTH
02:32:41.318 --> 02:32:43.220
THE OFFICIALS SHORT TRIP. THAT
02:32:43.287 --> 02:32:44.588
DIVIDE X. MADE AT LEAST TWENTY
02:32:44.655 --> 02:32:46.023
HOURS A- THAT'S WHY COUNTRIES
02:32:46.090 --> 02:32:47.091
THAT EMPLOYMENT CONTRACT
02:32:47.157 --> 02:32:48.392
TRACING HIS COMMUNICATION
02:32:48.459 --> 02:32:49.793
DEVICE DATA FROM MOBILE PHONES
02:32:49.860 --> 02:32:52.263
NOT RENTED SCOOTER DATA. MARK
02:32:52.329 --> 02:32:53.063
FOUNDER PERSONALLY OWNED
02:32:53.130 --> 02:32:55.099
IDENTITY SPECIFIC KERRIGAN
02:32:55.165 --> 02:32:57.234
POCKET TO PURSUE THROUGHOUT THE
02:32:57.301 --> 02:32:59.537
DAY THE ARGUMENT USED BY
02:32:59.603 --> 02:33:02.273
HEARING ITEM ARE BASED ON A-
02:33:02.339 --> 02:33:03.974
AND- BY. SIGNIFICANT
02:33:04.041 --> 02:33:05.175
TRANSFERRED POLICY. FOR
02:33:05.242 --> 02:33:06.610
CONSIDERATION BY POLICY
02:33:06.677 --> 02:33:07.778
COMMITTEE THAT DELIBERATE
02:33:07.845 --> 02:33:09.713
TRANSPORTATION ISSUES. THE
02:33:09.780 --> 02:33:10.881
TIMING OF THE LEGISLATION ALSO
02:33:10.948 --> 02:33:13.217
UNDERMINE ONGOING WORK BY THIS
02:33:13.284 --> 02:33:14.418
LEGISLATURE AND MULTIPLE STATE
02:33:14.485 --> 02:33:16.587
AGENCY. FOR NEARLY TWO YEARS
02:33:16.654 --> 02:33:17.488
WE'VE BEEN INVOLVED IN
02:33:17.555 --> 02:33:18.889
CONVERSATIONS ABOUT UP WITH
02:33:18.956 --> 02:33:20.457
DATA FROM TWO BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER
02:33:20.524 --> 02:33:22.726
LAURA FRIEDMAN ABOUT AN A. B.
02:33:22.793 --> 02:33:24.261
ELEVEN TWELVE. THIS BILL WOULD
02:33:24.328 --> 02:33:25.829
CODIFY DATA DEFINITIONS THAT
02:33:25.896 --> 02:33:27.831
ARE STILL BEING DISCUSSED.
02:33:27.898 --> 02:33:29.233
WHAT'S WORSE IT EXPANDS THEM TO
02:33:29.300 --> 02:33:32.036
TNC AN AV. FOR BOTH WHICH IS
02:33:32.102 --> 02:33:34.204
THAT THE P. C. AND BMG. ARE
02:33:34.271 --> 02:33:36.607
DEVELOPING REGULATIONS. MUCH
02:33:36.674 --> 02:33:39.009
REMAINS TO BE LEARNED ABOUT
02:33:39.076 --> 02:33:39.577
AUTOMATED VEHICLES OR DRONES
02:33:39.643 --> 02:33:42.947
ARE OTHER YET TO BE A GRADUATE.
02:33:43.013 --> 02:33:45.115
BUT YOU KNOW THEY HAVE. CON FOR
02:33:45.182 --> 02:33:47.084
EMPLOYEE IN THIS AND- A THREE
02:33:47.151 --> 02:33:48.819
ONCE WHAT PLACE REGULATORS ON
02:33:48.886 --> 02:33:50.454
THE SIDELINES AGAIN. A
02:33:50.521 --> 02:33:51.956
SPECTATOR TO INNOVATION RATHER
02:33:52.022 --> 02:33:53.424
THAN PARTICIPANTS AND THAT. IF
02:33:53.490 --> 02:33:55.125
PASSED THIS BILL WOULD YOUR
02:33:55.192 --> 02:33:56.226
CITY'S ABILITY TO MANAGE THE
02:33:56.293 --> 02:33:57.962
PUBLIC RIGHT OF WAY REDUCING
02:33:58.028 --> 02:33:58.829
THE AVAILABILITY OF
02:33:58.896 --> 02:34:00.631
TRANSPORTATION OPTIONS UNDER
02:34:00.698 --> 02:34:01.832
YEARS OF DELIBERATION
02:34:01.899 --> 02:34:03.467
REGULATORY DESIGN. AND
02:34:03.534 --> 02:34:05.235
PREMATURELY RESTRICT EFFECTIVE
02:34:05.302 --> 02:34:07.338
REGULATION OF FUTURE MODE. THE
02:34:07.404 --> 02:34:09.974
CITY OF LOS ANGELES THEREFORE
02:34:10.040 --> 02:34:15.312
STRONGLY OPPOSE THIS BILL. THE
02:34:15.379 --> 02:34:19.883
NEXT SPEAKER IN OPPOSITION.
02:34:19.950 --> 02:34:22.786
WELL HELLO THANK YOU MISTER
02:34:22.853 --> 02:34:25.389
CHAIR MEMBERS. MY NAME IS KYLE
02:34:25.456 --> 02:34:26.624
CODES ARE ON THE SENIOR
02:34:26.690 --> 02:34:27.958
TRANSPORTATION PLANNER- THE
02:34:28.025 --> 02:34:29.793
CITY SANTA MONICA AND I'M HERE
02:34:29.860 --> 02:34:30.995
TO EXPRESS THE CITY'S STRONG
02:34:31.061 --> 02:34:33.831
OPPOSITION TO A. B. THIRTY ONE
02:34:33.897 --> 02:34:34.431
SIXTEEN AS IT WOULD UNDERMINE
02:34:34.498 --> 02:34:35.633
OUR EXISTING SHARED MOBILITY
02:34:35.699 --> 02:34:38.202
PILOT PROGRAM WHICH CURRENTLY
02:34:38.268 --> 02:34:40.971
BEST SERVES THE INTEREST OF OUR
02:34:41.038 --> 02:34:42.539
CITY AND ITS RESIDENTS THE
02:34:42.606 --> 02:34:44.008
DATED ISSUE IN THE BILL IS NOT
02:34:44.074 --> 02:34:44.775
CLOSER TO THE CITY TO
02:34:44.842 --> 02:34:46.577
EFFECTIVELY REGULATE THE PUBLIC
02:34:46.644 --> 02:34:47.745
RIGHT OF WAY. CITY NEED TOOLS
02:34:47.811 --> 02:34:49.279
CAN MEET PUBLIC NEEDS AND
02:34:49.346 --> 02:34:51.548
EXPECTATIONS. IN ITS CRRENT
02:34:51.615 --> 02:34:55.019
FORM. AB THIRTY ONE SIXTEEN TO
02:34:55.085 --> 02:34:56.920
SEVERELY LIMIT THESE TOOLS WE
02:34:56.987 --> 02:34:58.455
ALSO BELIEVE IT IS PREMATURE
02:34:58.522 --> 02:35:00.924
BILL AT THAT SITE AS CITY LIKE
02:35:00.991 --> 02:35:01.892
ARE THERE STILL ARE PILOT
02:35:01.959 --> 02:35:03.727
PROGRAM PHASE OF REGULATION AND
02:35:03.794 --> 02:35:05.629
IS BILLS ALSO INTERCEDE
02:35:05.696 --> 02:35:06.897
INTERCEDES AND ONGOING
02:35:06.964 --> 02:35:10.067
DELIBERATIONS ON AB ELEVEN
02:35:10.134 --> 02:35:11.468
TWELVE BROUGHT TO THE ASSEMBLY
02:35:11.535 --> 02:35:14.338
BY. NUMBER FRIEDMAN- WHICH IS
02:35:14.405 --> 02:35:15.172
ANOTHER BILL THE DEALING
02:35:15.239 --> 02:35:16.440
DIRECTLY WITH THE SHARED
02:35:16.507 --> 02:35:19.510
MOBILITY DEVICE ISSUES. IN
02:35:19.576 --> 02:35:20.044
TWENTY EIGHTEEN AFTER THE
02:35:20.110 --> 02:35:20.644
REGULAR THE LAUNCH OF SHEM
02:35:20.711 --> 02:35:22.379
ABILITY TO BUY SANTA MONICA
02:35:22.446 --> 02:35:24.214
RATHER THAN BANDIT DEVICES LIKE
02:35:24.281 --> 02:35:25.916
MANY OTHER CITIES HAD DONE. WE
02:35:25.983 --> 02:35:27.518
MOVE QUICKLY TO CREATE POWERFUL
02:35:27.584 --> 02:35:29.219
REGULATIONS THAT ENABLE THE USE
02:35:29.286 --> 02:35:30.821
OF THE VICES WHILE ADJUSTING
02:35:30.888 --> 02:35:32.489
SIGNIFICANT PUBLIC SAFETY
02:35:32.556 --> 02:35:34.892
ACCEPTABILITY. AND EQUITY
02:35:34.958 --> 02:35:36.493
CONCERNS OF OUR COMMUNITY.
02:35:36.560 --> 02:35:38.128
TODAY ALL FOUR OF THE PERMITTED
02:35:38.195 --> 02:35:39.797
OPERATORS IN SANTA MONICA HAVE
02:35:39.863 --> 02:35:40.864
COMPLIED WITH THE DATA
02:35:40.931 --> 02:35:41.765
REQUIREMENTS OF OUR PILOT
02:35:41.832 --> 02:35:43.233
PROGRAM. THE DATA THAT THE
02:35:43.300 --> 02:35:44.735
OPERATORS PROVIDE TO THE CITY
02:35:44.802 --> 02:35:46.670
IS CRITICAL TO OUR FUNCTIONS AS
02:35:46.737 --> 02:35:48.038
REGULATORS PLANNERS AND
02:35:48.105 --> 02:35:50.708
MANAGERS OF THE PUBLIC RIGHT OF
02:35:50.774 --> 02:35:52.443
WAY. DATA IS NOT IN REAL TIME
02:35:52.509 --> 02:35:54.445
AND IT CONTAINS NO CONSUMER
02:35:54.511 --> 02:35:56.747
IDENTIFYING INFORMATION. AS IT
02:35:56.814 --> 02:35:59.316
IS CURRENTLY WRITTEN AB THIRTY
02:35:59.383 --> 02:35:59.950
ONE SIXTEEN WOULD FUNDAMENTALLY
02:36:00.017 --> 02:36:01.552
REMOVE THE CITY'S ABILITY TO
02:36:01.618 --> 02:36:02.920
MEANINGFULLY REGULATE CHAIRED
02:36:02.986 --> 02:36:04.388
MOBILITY OPERATORS BY
02:36:04.455 --> 02:36:05.556
PROHIBITING THE CITY FROM
02:36:05.622 --> 02:36:07.157
COLLECTING TRIP DATA IT IS
02:36:07.224 --> 02:36:09.026
VITAL THAT WE MONITOR AND FORCE
02:36:09.093 --> 02:36:11.361
AND UNDERSTAND SURE MOBILITY
02:36:11.428 --> 02:36:12.663
USE WITHIN THE CITY. THE BILL
02:36:12.730 --> 02:36:14.498
WOULD REQUIRE CITY LIKE MONICA
02:36:14.565 --> 02:36:15.999
EITHER ALLOW THE INDUSTRY TO
02:36:16.066 --> 02:36:18.268
SELF REGULATE OR BAN OPERATIONS
02:36:18.335 --> 02:36:19.770
OF THESE TYPES OF SERVICES
02:36:19.837 --> 02:36:22.106
ALTOGETHER. THIS IS THE CHOICE
02:36:22.172 --> 02:36:23.107
WE SHOULD NOT BE FORCED TO
02:36:23.173 --> 02:36:25.409
MAKE. OUR EXPERIENCE HAS TAUGHT
02:36:25.476 --> 02:36:26.343
US THE BY WORKING IN
02:36:26.410 --> 02:36:27.411
PARTNERSHIP WITH SHARED
02:36:27.478 --> 02:36:28.979
MOBILITY OPERATORS WE CAN
02:36:29.046 --> 02:36:31.115
DEVELOP PROTOCOLS THAT WE
02:36:31.181 --> 02:36:33.317
PROTECT CONSUMER PRIVACY WHILE
02:36:33.383 --> 02:36:34.451
ENABLING US TO GET THE DATA WE
02:36:34.518 --> 02:36:36.787
NEED TO EFFECTIVELY REGULATE
02:36:36.854 --> 02:36:37.554
THE INDUSTRY USE OF THE PUBLIC
02:36:37.621 --> 02:36:40.491
RIGHT OF WAY. AB THIRTY ONE SIX
02:36:40.557 --> 02:36:42.626
IN UNDER THESE EFFORTS TO DATE
02:36:42.693 --> 02:36:43.627
AND FOR THAT REASON THE CITY
02:36:43.694 --> 02:36:44.962
SANTA MONICA IS STRONGLY
02:36:45.028 --> 02:36:47.030
OPPOSED AB THIRTY ONE SIXTEEN
02:36:47.097 --> 02:36:50.534
THANK. THANK YOU ARE THERE
02:36:50.601 --> 02:36:57.074
OTHER SPEAKERS IN OPPOSITION.
02:36:57.141 --> 02:36:57.641
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS FROM
02:36:57.708 --> 02:36:59.943
COMMITTEE MEMBERS. ASSEMBLY OUR
02:37:00.010 --> 02:37:02.045
LOOKS THANK YOU I WANT TO
02:37:02.112 --> 02:37:04.314
THANK- MISTER ONE FOR
02:37:04.381 --> 02:37:05.315
PRESENTING THE BILL I'M A PROUD
02:37:05.382 --> 02:37:08.452
JOIN AUTHOR OF THE BILL- AND-
02:37:08.519 --> 02:37:09.253
THE REASON WHY I THINK THIS
02:37:09.319 --> 02:37:10.821
BILL. I THINK INDIVIDUAL
02:37:10.888 --> 02:37:12.990
LOCALIZED ANNA AND LOCATION
02:37:13.056 --> 02:37:14.224
DATA IS REALLY SENSITIVE AND
02:37:14.291 --> 02:37:15.559
MUST BE PROTECTED AT ALL COSTS
02:37:15.626 --> 02:37:16.860
AND I THINK THIS BILL STRIKES
02:37:16.927 --> 02:37:18.562
THE RIGHT BALANCE OF- ALLOWING
02:37:18.629 --> 02:37:21.265
ACCESS TO ANONYMIZE DATA WHILE
02:37:21.331 --> 02:37:22.699
STILL SAFEGUARDING INSIDE IN A
02:37:22.766 --> 02:37:24.868
FULL I DON'T IDENTIFY TRIPPED
02:37:24.935 --> 02:37:30.240
OUT OF SO- LOOK. WORK WHEN FOR
02:37:30.307 --> 02:37:35.579
THE DON'T HAVE. IS THERE. ARE
02:37:35.646 --> 02:37:39.883
COMMON GO AHEAD. YEAH YEAH
02:37:39.950 --> 02:37:46.456
RIGHT THE NUMBER OF THE. THE
02:37:46.523 --> 02:37:50.194
OTHER AS A ONCE. THERE I WAS A
02:37:50.260 --> 02:37:55.666
CHAIR. WE WERE. MAC I THANK YOU
02:37:55.732 --> 02:37:56.800
SO MEMBER OR WENT INTRODUCING
02:37:56.867 --> 02:37:58.502
THIS BILL- I DO HAVE SOME
02:37:58.569 --> 02:38:00.437
CONCERNS- AS WE VOTE ON
02:38:00.504 --> 02:38:03.040
STATEWIDE LAWS WE FIRST
02:38:03.106 --> 02:38:04.641
REPRESENTED THE DISTRICTS THAT
02:38:04.708 --> 02:38:05.676
WE COME FROM AND I REPRESENT
02:38:05.742 --> 02:38:07.444
LAWCENTER AS THE LARGE SITTING
02:38:07.511 --> 02:38:08.278
CALIFORNIA WITH ROBUST
02:38:08.345 --> 02:38:10.681
TRANSPORTATION PLAN IN OUR AN
02:38:10.747 --> 02:38:13.150
OLD ON THE PHONE FOR HER
02:38:13.217 --> 02:38:15.786
TESTIMONY I HAVE CONCERNS WITH
02:38:15.853 --> 02:38:18.322
WELL IN A FORM WHICH PUT CITIES
02:38:18.388 --> 02:38:20.157
BUT- AND STUFF FOR. THEY'RE
02:38:20.224 --> 02:38:22.392
SUPPOSED TO WRITE. A REALLY AS
02:38:22.459 --> 02:38:24.494
A MATTER OF TRUST AND ALLOWING
02:38:24.561 --> 02:38:26.029
FOR PROFIT COMPANIES TO
02:38:26.096 --> 02:38:28.765
AGGREGATE DATA BEFORE PROVIDING
02:38:28.832 --> 02:38:30.667
IT TO THE REGULATORS PROVIDES
02:38:30.734 --> 02:38:31.768
IN MY OPINION A CLEARANCE
02:38:31.835 --> 02:38:33.637
CENTER. ELATION ACRONYM CAN
02:38:33.704 --> 02:38:34.504
ASSIST UNTIL FOR BOTH
02:38:34.571 --> 02:38:36.974
REGULATORY COMPLIANCE AND
02:38:37.040 --> 02:38:38.775
TRANSPORTATION PLANNING BECAUSE
02:38:38.842 --> 02:38:40.143
THESE DECISIONS ARE ONLY A
02:38:40.210 --> 02:38:42.045
SMART THE DATA THAT THEY RELY
02:38:42.112 --> 02:38:43.814
ON. DIRECT ACCESS TO DEVICE
02:38:43.881 --> 02:38:45.883
SPECIFIC INFORMATION EQUIPS
02:38:45.949 --> 02:38:47.451
REGULATORS WITH THE TOOLS TO
02:38:47.517 --> 02:38:50.254
MANAGE THE RIGHT WAY. WHY
02:38:50.320 --> 02:38:51.922
SHOULD WE PREVENT CITIES FROM
02:38:51.989 --> 02:38:53.957
GETTING A LIMITED AMOUNT OF
02:38:54.024 --> 02:38:56.126
DATA IT THIS ALLOWS THEM TO
02:38:56.193 --> 02:38:58.495
VERIFY. THE ACCURACY AND
02:38:58.562 --> 02:39:00.264
VALIDITY OF THE INFORMATION THE
02:39:00.330 --> 02:39:01.832
COMPANIES ARE PROVIDING.
02:39:01.899 --> 02:39:04.034
ADDITIONALLY WHILE I UNDERSTAND
02:39:04.101 --> 02:39:06.103
THIS BILL AIMS TO GOVERN DATA
02:39:06.169 --> 02:39:08.572
PRIVACY IT DIRECTLY ADDRESSES
02:39:08.639 --> 02:39:09.873
STOCK WITH MOBILITY
02:39:09.940 --> 02:39:10.741
TRANSPORTATION NETWORK
02:39:10.807 --> 02:39:13.343
COMPANIES AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES
02:39:13.410 --> 02:39:14.311
AND OTHER FUTURE MODES OF
02:39:14.378 --> 02:39:17.347
TRANSPORTATION. IT SEEMS HERE
02:39:17.414 --> 02:39:19.516
THAT THE IMPACTS OF THIS BILL
02:39:19.583 --> 02:39:20.784
WOULD BE SUBSTANTIAL. PETITION
02:39:20.851 --> 02:39:24.121
APARTMENT ACOSTA ST OF CALIPERS
02:39:24.187 --> 02:39:27.124
LARGEST CITIES LOS ANGELES SAN
02:39:27.190 --> 02:39:30.460
JOSE AND I'M FRANCISCO OUT OF
02:39:30.527 --> 02:39:32.296
THE THESE ARE TOP THREE. OUT OF
02:39:32.362 --> 02:39:35.365
FIVE. THE ALL IN OPPOSITION I'M
02:39:35.432 --> 02:39:37.401
NOT SURE I'M CONVINCED THAT
02:39:37.467 --> 02:39:39.236
THIS BILL QUALIFIES TO BE HEARD
02:39:39.303 --> 02:39:41.004
THIS SESSION BASED ON THE
02:39:41.071 --> 02:39:42.072
ARGUMENTS THAT HAVE BEEN SET
02:39:42.139 --> 02:39:44.875
TODAY BUT IF WE INSIST ON
02:39:44.942 --> 02:39:47.778
MOVING FORWARD I THINK THAT WE
02:39:47.844 --> 02:39:48.412
NEED TO HAVE THIS BILL HEARD IN
02:39:48.478 --> 02:39:50.614
TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE AS
02:39:50.681 --> 02:39:51.782
WELL FOR THE AND I WILL BE.
02:39:51.848 --> 02:39:56.453
FROM THIS. OTHER QUESTIONS OR
02:39:56.520 --> 02:39:58.522
COMMENTS FROM COMMITTEE MEMBERS.
02:39:58.588 --> 02:39:59.656
ASSEMBLY WOMAN- ONE WOULD YOU
02:39:59.723 --> 02:40:01.692
LIKE TO CLOSE SIDE I'LL JUST
02:40:01.758 --> 02:40:02.759
MAKE A COUPLE OF QUICK
02:40:02.826 --> 02:40:05.963
STATEMENTS THIS IS- THIS WAS
02:40:06.029 --> 02:40:07.731
REALLY AN ISSUE OF WHETHER CAL
02:40:07.798 --> 02:40:11.068
LACK THE OF ALSO A RELATED TO
02:40:11.134 --> 02:40:12.769
OTHER GOVERNMENT AGENCIES
02:40:12.836 --> 02:40:14.938
BEYOND JUST OF POLICE
02:40:15.005 --> 02:40:19.409
DEPARTMENTS AND THE THIS IS-
02:40:19.476 --> 02:40:21.511
NUMEROUS TIMES LEGISLATIVE
02:40:21.578 --> 02:40:24.715
COUNSEL HAS SAID THAT YES IT'S-
02:40:24.781 --> 02:40:30.087
BLACK BUT IS A REAL TO OTHER
02:40:30.153 --> 02:40:31.588
GOVERNMENT AGENCIES. AND THERE
02:40:31.655 --> 02:40:33.690
ARE THREE ONE YOU HAVE THAT IN
02:40:33.757 --> 02:40:36.326
STATION THE CHIU AND THE FS IN
02:40:36.393 --> 02:40:38.695
SUPPORT OF THE BILL AND AS MS
02:40:38.762 --> 02:40:40.630
CORBIN MISTER CALLAHAN IS WICKS
02:40:40.697 --> 02:40:43.100
SAID THE MOST SENSITIVE
02:40:43.166 --> 02:40:44.634
INFORMATION THAT THERE IS OR
02:40:44.701 --> 02:40:46.870
AMONG SENSITIVE INFORMATION
02:40:46.937 --> 02:40:48.739
THAT THERE IS YOUR LOCATION
02:40:48.805 --> 02:40:52.209
DATA FOR THIS IS TO SAY YOU
02:40:52.275 --> 02:40:54.644
CANNOT TRACK AND IT WELL ON
02:40:54.711 --> 02:40:57.180
CASE. AS THAT WOULD WITH
02:40:57.247 --> 02:40:59.783
PATIENT AND NO PAYMENT IN JAIL.
02:40:59.850 --> 02:41:00.851
YOU TRACK LOCATION DAY ALL THE
02:41:00.917 --> 02:41:04.421
WAY TO SOMEBODY HOME SO I THINK
02:41:04.488 --> 02:41:06.490
THIS- WE ARE GOING TO CONTINUE
02:41:06.556 --> 02:41:09.059
TO WORK WITH THE TRANSPORTATION
02:41:09.126 --> 02:41:10.594
AGENCY. AGAIN AND THEY WILL
02:41:10.660 --> 02:41:12.095
HAVE ACCESS DE IDENTIFIED
02:41:12.162 --> 02:41:13.897
INFORMATION AND AGGREGATE
02:41:13.964 --> 02:41:18.435
INFORMATION THE ISSUE THAT MS
02:41:18.502 --> 02:41:19.770
CARILLO BRINGS IT I THINK IS AN
02:41:19.836 --> 02:41:22.239
ACCURATE ONE. YEAH I MEAN IS A
02:41:22.305 --> 02:41:26.309
GOOD. TO MAKE SURE THAT. IT IS
02:41:26.376 --> 02:41:28.512
ACCURATE. BUT BEING. TO PROVIDE.
02:41:28.578 --> 02:41:31.882
A IN. THAT IS OF THAT IS ABLE
02:41:31.948 --> 02:41:34.117
TO TRACK INDIVIDUAL- TRIP DATA
02:41:34.184 --> 02:41:37.120
I THINK IS OF ANTI PRIVACY AND
02:41:37.187 --> 02:41:39.156
I WOULD LIKE TO JUST STATES
02:41:39.222 --> 02:41:41.558
ASSEMBLY MEMBER KILEY THERE ARE
02:41:41.625 --> 02:41:45.962
TWO MORE PEOPLE ON THE PHONE. I
02:41:46.029 --> 02:41:52.035
DO WE NEED THE- GO GET THEM ON.
02:41:52.102 --> 02:41:57.307
I OKAY. ALL RIGHT SPEAKERS IN
02:41:57.374 --> 02:42:04.514
OPPOSITION IS IT. I KNOW WOULD
02:42:04.581 --> 02:42:13.457
BE THAT'S RIGHT FOR. IS THERE
02:42:13.523 --> 02:42:15.325
ONE ARE YOU IN CONTACT WITH.
02:42:15.392 --> 02:42:33.610
RIGHT. MAYBE WE- YEAH. HE WAS
02:42:33.677 --> 02:42:37.681
ABOUT WERE THE- WITH THE U. POP.
02:42:37.747 --> 02:42:40.584
ALRIGHT ALL. ALL RIGHT I'M TOLD
02:42:40.650 --> 02:42:41.985
THAT THE- TWO REMAINING
02:42:42.052 --> 02:42:45.255
SPEAKERS IN OPPOSITION ALREADY.
02:42:45.322 --> 02:42:47.491
NOW I'M TOLD THAT THEY ARE NOT
02:42:47.557 --> 02:42:50.127
GOING TO SPEAK AFTER ALL. THANK
02:42:50.193 --> 02:42:52.295
YOU READY TO THAT. WE HAVE A
02:42:52.362 --> 02:42:54.131
MOTION WE HAVE A SECOND AND
02:42:54.197 --> 02:42:55.232
MOTION IS DUE PASSED TO
02:42:55.298 --> 02:42:57.601
APPROPRIATIONS MADAM SECRETARY
02:42:57.667 --> 02:42:59.803
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. NOW
02:42:59.870 --> 02:43:03.640
KILEY. AYE KILEY AYE BARRICADE
02:43:03.707 --> 02:43:07.410
HAND. OKAY HAND I BERMAN. AND I
02:43:07.477 --> 02:43:12.716
MEDINA- MEDINA I CARILLO.
02:43:12.782 --> 02:43:19.556
MULLIN GALLAGHER. GALLAGHER HI-
02:43:19.623 --> 02:43:27.030
WHEN I IRWIN HI OBERNOLTE. SIX
02:43:27.097 --> 02:43:29.299
NINE SIX NINE. THE BILL IS OUT-
02:43:29.366 --> 02:43:30.734
I THINK THAT THE ONLY REMAINING
02:43:30.800 --> 02:43:33.870
BILLS ARE- THE CHAIRS SO- HE IS
02:43:33.937 --> 02:43:36.840
ASSURED ME TO BE BACK SHORTLY
02:43:36.907 --> 02:43:37.374
SO WE'LL JUST HAVE TO WAIT
02:43:37.440 --> 02:43:43.079
UNTIL THEN. WHAT WE DO. THE
02:43:43.146 --> 02:43:46.316
MANAGEMENT ALL FIVE OF THEM OR
02:43:46.383 --> 02:43:47.384
YOU KNOW AND SEE OF THE- AND
02:43:47.450 --> 02:43:51.154
THEN- ACOSTA WITH REGARD. TO A
02:43:51.221 --> 02:43:54.391
ARE THERE THE JUST BEINGS. MUCH
02:43:54.457 --> 02:44:06.203
THAT I RIGHT. ALL. OKAY YEAH
02:44:06.269 --> 02:44:21.251
THE- YEAH YEAH YEAH. THIS IS
02:44:21.318 --> 02:44:38.868
NOT. I NOTICED COOL. WE HAVE
02:44:38.935 --> 02:44:45.775
SOMETHING. AND WE'RE I. THAT
02:44:45.842 --> 02:45:03.460
YEAH. YEAH YEAH. YEAH. YEAH.
02:45:03.526 --> 02:45:14.971
YEAH. YEAH YEAH WELL OVER A
02:45:15.038 --> 02:45:28.218
YEAR YEAH. RIGHT OR- YEAH.
02:45:28.285 --> 02:45:37.127
RIGHT RIGHT OFF OUR. BUT IT'S A
02:45:37.193 --> 02:45:44.000
LITTLE BIT. IT'S STILL. OR IS
02:45:44.067 --> 02:45:45.835
SCHOOL AND ONE LOOKS DIFFERENT
02:45:45.902 --> 02:45:48.638
TURNED INTO A WITNESS MICHAEL
02:45:48.705 --> 02:46:08.024
BUT THERE IS.
03:33:32.966 --> 03:33:34.301
BUYERS AN
03:33:34.368 --> 03:33:36.803
EXPONENTIAL RATE FROM ASSISTING
03:33:36.870 --> 03:33:39.239
SMARTPHONE USERS IN UNLOCKING
03:33:39.306 --> 03:33:40.908
THEIR PHONES TO ITS USE IN
03:33:40.974 --> 03:33:43.544
RETAIL STORES CASINOS CONCERTS
03:33:43.610 --> 03:33:45.946
IN AIRPORTS F. R. T. SERVES THE
03:33:46.013 --> 03:33:48.682
PURPOSE OF IDENTIFYING PEOPLE
03:33:48.749 --> 03:33:50.851
FOR A VARIETY OF REASONS. F.
03:33:50.918 --> 03:33:52.186
FORTY ALSO PROVIDES LAW
03:33:52.252 --> 03:33:53.787
ENFORCEMENT WITH A TOOL TO
03:33:53.854 --> 03:33:55.889
ENHANCE PUBLIC SAFETY AS
03:33:55.956 --> 03:33:59.026
EVIDENCED BY ITS RECENT USE TO
03:33:59.092 --> 03:34:01.728
IDENTIFY THIS IS THE KILLER IN
03:34:01.795 --> 03:34:03.931
NEW ORLEANS CAPITAL BECAUSE
03:34:03.997 --> 03:34:07.134
THAT MASS SHOOTING WERE DIE.
03:34:07.201 --> 03:34:07.768
WHAT OTHER EFFORTS TO FIND
03:34:07.834 --> 03:34:09.403
<c.green>HILDREN AND VICTIMS OF HUMAN</c>
03:34:09.469 --> 03:34:12.839
TRAFFICKING. MOST RECENTLY
03:34:12.906 --> 03:34:15.008
GOVERNMENTS ACROSS THE GLOBE
03:34:15.075 --> 03:34:15.576
ARE TURNING KNOWLEDGE G. AN
03:34:15.642 --> 03:34:18.345
EFFORT TO SAVE LIVES ADMITS.
03:34:18.412 --> 03:34:19.980
THREAT POSED BY COVERT NINETEEN
03:34:20.047 --> 03:34:23.750
PANDEMIC. FORTY IS NO EXCEPTION.
03:34:23.817 --> 03:34:25.118
TECH COMPANIES IN THE UNITED
03:34:25.185 --> 03:34:27.788
STATES ARE REPORTEDLY IN TALKS
03:34:27.854 --> 03:34:29.556
WITH THE US GOVERNMENT TO USE
03:34:29.623 --> 03:34:32.426
THE DATA A GATHERING AND DATA
03:34:32.492 --> 03:34:34.995
LOOKING TOWARDS TO TRACK VIRUS
03:34:35.062 --> 03:34:35.696
TRANSMISSION TREATMENTS
03:34:35.762 --> 03:34:37.598
INCLUDING CLEAR VIEW THE I A
03:34:37.664 --> 03:34:39.566
CONTROVERSY ALL COMPANY THAT
03:34:39.633 --> 03:34:42.102
RECENTLY MADE HEADLINES FOR
03:34:42.169 --> 03:34:44.671
ASSEMBLING A DATABASE OF MORE
03:34:44.738 --> 03:34:46.273
THAN THREE BILLION. IS
03:34:46.340 --> 03:34:49.610
COLLECTED THE INTERNET AND MADE
03:34:49.676 --> 03:34:51.979
IT DATA AVAILABLE FORCE MEN ARE
03:34:52.045 --> 03:34:53.981
AND PRIVATE INDIVIDUALS AROUND
03:34:54.047 --> 03:34:55.349
THE COUNTRY. THE REPORT BY U.
03:34:55.415 --> 03:34:57.951
S. NEWS HIGHLIGHTS THE USE OF
03:34:58.018 --> 03:35:01.221
F. R. T. LIKE CLEAR VIEW A AYE
03:35:01.288 --> 03:35:03.523
TO AND I QUOTE IDENTIFY ANYONE
03:35:03.590 --> 03:35:05.225
WHO'S BEEN IN CONTACT WITH THE
03:35:05.292 --> 03:35:06.927
INFECTED PERSON. SIMILAR TO HOW
03:35:06.994 --> 03:35:08.962
TECH COMPANIES RESPONDED IN THE
03:35:09.029 --> 03:35:10.530
U. S. AFTER NINE ELEVEN WITH
03:35:10.597 --> 03:35:12.666
THE PASSING THE PATRIOTIC ACT
03:35:12.733 --> 03:35:14.368
PAVING WAY TO MASS
03:35:14.434 --> 03:35:17.237
SURVEILLANCE. AS WE HIT BUT AS
03:35:17.304 --> 03:35:19.239
WE SIT HERE TODAY DO WE WANT TO
03:35:19.306 --> 03:35:21.041
SIT IDLY BY AND LET THIS HAPPEN
03:35:21.108 --> 03:35:22.776
AGAIN. WITHOUT DEMANDING A
03:35:22.843 --> 03:35:24.778
TRADE CURRENCY ADEQUATE
03:35:24.845 --> 03:35:28.382
OVERSIGHT. LET'S THINK ABOUT IT.
03:35:28.448 --> 03:35:30.417
AN OTHER EXAMPLE HOW BIOMETRIC
03:35:30.484 --> 03:35:32.719
TECHNOLOGY IS IN EVOLVING
03:35:32.786 --> 03:35:33.954
DURING THIS COVERT NINETEEN
03:35:34.021 --> 03:35:36.123
PANDEMIC. IS ITS USE AS A
03:35:36.189 --> 03:35:38.325
SCREENING SYSTEM. IT WAS
03:35:38.392 --> 03:35:39.626
RECENTLY REPORTED THAT A
03:35:39.693 --> 03:35:41.328
SECURITY COMPANY WHOSE
03:35:41.395 --> 03:35:44.364
TECHNOLOGY TO TEXT GUNS IS NOW
03:35:44.431 --> 03:35:46.166
OFFERING A SCREEN SYSTEM
03:35:46.233 --> 03:35:48.302
EQUIPPED WITH THERMAL CAMERAS.
03:35:48.368 --> 03:35:50.270
TO DETECT FEVERS AND ALERT
03:35:50.337 --> 03:35:52.306
SURROUNDING CUSTOMERS OF
03:35:52.372 --> 03:35:54.274
SOMEONE POTENTIALLY CARRYING
03:35:54.341 --> 03:35:57.110
CORONA VIRUS. A PRODUCT IT IS
03:35:57.177 --> 03:35:58.345
PITCHING TO GROW RESTORE
03:35:58.412 --> 03:36:01.081
HOSPITALS VOTING LOCATIONS IN
03:36:01.148 --> 03:36:01.748
DEPLOYING AT GOVERNMENT
03:36:01.815 --> 03:36:04.718
AGENCIES AIRPORTS AND ALSO
03:36:04.785 --> 03:36:06.787
FOUGHT OF FORTUNE FIVE HUNDRED
03:36:06.853 --> 03:36:07.888
COMPANIES. WHICH DEFINITELY FOR
03:36:07.954 --> 03:36:08.755
SEAT IS BECOMING A AN
03:36:08.822 --> 03:36:10.590
ALTERNATIVE TO TECHNOLOGIES
03:36:10.657 --> 03:36:12.025
THAT RELY ON TOUCH BISTRO
03:36:12.092 --> 03:36:14.661
SENSORS. WHAT THIS SAYS TO ME
03:36:14.728 --> 03:36:15.929
IS THAT FACIAL RECOGNITION
03:36:15.996 --> 03:36:18.598
SYSTEMS ARE ALREADY IN USE AND
03:36:18.665 --> 03:36:20.701
CONTINUOUSLY DEPLOYED. THEY'RE
03:36:20.767 --> 03:36:22.502
ALSO CREDITED KERR- CREDIBLE
03:36:22.569 --> 03:36:24.071
CONCERNS REGARDING THE ACCURACY
03:36:24.137 --> 03:36:26.073
OF A FAR T. SYSTEMS ON SOME
03:36:26.139 --> 03:36:28.308
RACIAL OR ETHNIC GROUPS AND
03:36:28.375 --> 03:36:29.743
SEVERAL STUDIES HAVE UNCOVERED
03:36:29.810 --> 03:36:31.545
BIASES IN FACE RECOGNITION
03:36:31.611 --> 03:36:35.182
ALGORITHM. IN IN FACT THAT WAS
03:36:35.248 --> 03:36:35.782
ONE OF THE TWENTY SIX
03:36:35.849 --> 03:36:39.152
LEGISLATORS SO MISS IDENTIFY A
03:36:39.219 --> 03:36:44.157
BY A. F. R. T. SYSTEM WITH A
03:36:44.224 --> 03:36:45.692
MUG SHOT IN TWENTY NINETEEN.
03:36:45.759 --> 03:36:46.827
ACT IS THAT WHILE I FOUR T. OFF
03:36:46.893 --> 03:36:48.762
SOME BENEFITS TO SOCIETY ITS
03:36:48.829 --> 03:36:50.697
USE ALSO COMES WITH SERIOUS
03:36:50.764 --> 03:36:52.733
CHALLENGES THAT MERIT OUR
03:36:52.799 --> 03:36:54.501
SCRUTINY. BECAUSE OF THESE
03:36:54.568 --> 03:36:55.836
CONCERNS THE LEGISLATURE MUST
03:36:55.902 --> 03:36:59.172
REGULATE THE COMPLETE USE OF F.
03:36:59.239 --> 03:37:01.108
R. T. TO MINIMIZE AND YOU LOOK
03:37:01.174 --> 03:37:02.142
AT THE PRICE CONSISTS. IS
03:37:02.209 --> 03:37:05.946
CANCER AND- COMMUNITY. WE
03:37:06.012 --> 03:37:07.314
RECENTLY HAD A HEARING IN
03:37:07.381 --> 03:37:09.549
CALIFORNIA ON THE TOPIC AT THE
03:37:09.616 --> 03:37:10.584
REQUEST OF SOME OF THE GROUPS
03:37:10.650 --> 03:37:13.286
IN OPPOSITION- AND IT HERE TEN
03:37:13.353 --> 03:37:14.588
OTHER STATES HAVE INTRODUCED
03:37:14.654 --> 03:37:16.056
LEGISLATION THAT WOULD REGULATE
03:37:16.123 --> 03:37:17.657
BAND OR STUDY FACIAL
03:37:17.724 --> 03:37:20.227
RECOGNITION SYSTEMS ON MARCH
03:37:20.293 --> 03:37:22.195
THIRTY FIRST TWENTY TWENTY A
03:37:22.262 --> 03:37:23.764
WASHINGTON STATE BECAME THE
03:37:23.830 --> 03:37:26.600
FIRST STATE NATION TO REGULATE
03:37:26.666 --> 03:37:27.667
COMPREHENSIVE. R. T. BY IN
03:37:27.734 --> 03:37:30.537
AGENCIES. TIME HAS COME FOR
03:37:30.604 --> 03:37:31.738
CALIFORNIA TO ESTABLISH A
03:37:31.805 --> 03:37:34.408
ROBUST FRT LAW THAT APPLIES
03:37:34.474 --> 03:37:36.743
EQUALLY ACROSS THE BOARD IN ITS
03:37:36.810 --> 03:37:38.879
USE BY BUSINESSES AS WELL AS-
03:37:38.945 --> 03:37:41.281
PUBLIC ENTITIES AND STRIKES A
03:37:41.348 --> 03:37:42.849
BALANCE BETWEEN ITS APPLICATION
03:37:42.916 --> 03:37:47.120
AND HUMAN RIGHTS ARE AB TWENTY
03:37:47.187 --> 03:37:47.788
TWO SIXTY ONE INCREASED
03:37:47.854 --> 03:37:49.089
TRANSPARENCY THEY OUGHT TO
03:37:49.156 --> 03:37:51.491
ESTABLISH LIMITS ON THE USE OF
03:37:51.558 --> 03:37:53.160
FACIAL RECOGNITION TECHNOLOGY.
03:37:53.226 --> 03:37:55.595
BY COMMERCIAL STATE AND LOCAL
03:37:55.662 --> 03:37:57.130
PUBLIC ENTITIES WHILE
03:37:57.197 --> 03:37:58.698
PROTECTING THE RIGHTS OF
03:37:58.765 --> 03:38:00.167
CONSUMERS RELATING TO
03:38:00.233 --> 03:38:04.471
COLLECTION AND THE USE OF THEIR
03:38:04.538 --> 03:38:05.238
IMAGE OR FACIAL COMPLETES. A
03:38:05.305 --> 03:38:06.807
CIVIC LEADER. INDEPENDENT TEST
03:38:06.873 --> 03:38:08.508
OF THOSE FACIAL RECOGNITION
03:38:08.575 --> 03:38:10.811
SERVICES FOR ACCURACY AND
03:38:10.877 --> 03:38:12.946
UNFAIR PERFORMANCE DIFFERENCES
03:38:13.013 --> 03:38:15.115
ACROSS SUBPOPULATIONS OR
03:38:15.182 --> 03:38:16.950
MEETING THE RELEVANT FACIAL
03:38:17.017 --> 03:38:18.952
RECOGNITION VENDOR TELL US THAT%
03:38:19.019 --> 03:38:20.086
THE NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF
03:38:20.153 --> 03:38:21.288
STANDARDS AND TECHNOLOGY
03:38:21.354 --> 03:38:23.290
PERFORMS. AND THAT IS THE NEXT
03:38:23.356 --> 03:38:25.459
STANDARD THOUGH WHICH IS. WHAT
03:38:25.525 --> 03:38:27.694
PEOPLE CALL THE GOLD STANDARD.
03:38:27.761 --> 03:38:29.329
IT WOULD REQUIRE ALSO A
03:38:29.396 --> 03:38:32.098
CONSPICUOUS IN CONTEXTUAL E.
03:38:32.165 --> 03:38:34.334
APPROACH NOTICE WHEN DEPLOYING
03:38:34.401 --> 03:38:35.035
FACIAL RECOGNITION SIR IN THE
03:38:35.101 --> 03:38:37.070
PHYSICS. OPEN TO THE PUBLIC
03:38:37.137 --> 03:38:38.271
THAT INCLUDE SPECIFIC ELEMENTS
03:38:38.338 --> 03:38:39.973
AND CONSENT FROM THE INDIVIDUAL
03:38:40.040 --> 03:38:42.476
BEFORE ENROLLING THEIR MH OR
03:38:42.542 --> 03:38:44.411
FACIAL TEMPLATE WOULD LIMITED
03:38:44.478 --> 03:38:46.513
EXCEPT- EXCEPTIONS FOR SCRUTINY
03:38:46.580 --> 03:38:48.982
OR SAFETY PURPOSE. I TO THAT
03:38:49.049 --> 03:38:51.051
SERIOUS CRIMINAL OFFENSE AND
03:38:51.117 --> 03:38:52.619
REQUIRING PROPER BECAUSE AS
03:38:52.686 --> 03:38:55.355
WELL. IT ALSO PROHIBITS DENYING
03:38:55.422 --> 03:38:57.290
ACCESS OR SERVICE ON THE BASIS
03:38:57.357 --> 03:38:58.992
THAT THE INDIVIDUAL HOUSE
03:38:59.059 --> 03:39:00.961
EXERCISED THEIR RIGHT. TO
03:39:01.027 --> 03:39:02.762
WITHHOLD CONSENT UNLESS IT IS
03:39:02.829 --> 03:39:04.598
DIRECTLY NECESSARY FOR THE
03:39:04.664 --> 03:39:06.166
PROVISION OF THE SERVICE. IT
03:39:06.233 --> 03:39:12.772
ALSO REQUIRES A PROSSER SIR. OR
03:39:12.839 --> 03:39:14.841
TO DISCRIMINATE UNDER FEDERAL
03:39:14.908 --> 03:39:16.476
OR STATE LAW AGAINST AN
03:39:16.543 --> 03:39:17.878
INDIVIDUAL OR GROUP OF
03:39:17.944 --> 03:39:20.146
INDIVIDUALS. IT ALSO REQUIRES
03:39:20.213 --> 03:39:22.148
MEANINGFUL HUMAN REVIEW WHEN
03:39:22.215 --> 03:39:23.416
USING A FACIAL RECOGNITION
03:39:23.483 --> 03:39:25.685
SERVICE TO MAKE DECISIONS THAT
03:39:25.752 --> 03:39:27.621
PRODUCED LEGAL AFFECTS. OR
03:39:27.687 --> 03:39:29.122
SIMILARLY SIGNIFICANT EFFECTS
03:39:29.189 --> 03:39:30.690
CONCERNING INDIVIDUALS WHICH
03:39:30.757 --> 03:39:32.859
INCLUDE DENIAL OF CONSEQUENTIAL
03:39:32.926 --> 03:39:35.495
SERVICES OR SUPPORTS SUCH AS
03:39:35.562 --> 03:39:37.430
FINANCIAL AND LENDING SERVICES
03:39:37.497 --> 03:39:39.866
HOUSING. INSURANCE EDUCATION
03:39:39.933 --> 03:39:41.768
ENROLLMENT CRIMINAL JUSTICE
03:39:41.835 --> 03:39:43.770
EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES HEALTH
03:39:43.837 --> 03:39:45.372
CARE SERVICES AND ACCESS TO
03:39:45.438 --> 03:39:47.541
BASIC NECESSITIES OR THAT
03:39:47.607 --> 03:39:49.075
IMPACTS CIVIL RIGHTS OF
03:39:49.142 --> 03:39:51.244
INDIVIDUALS IN FACT UNDER THE
03:39:51.311 --> 03:39:53.179
NEW DEFINITION THE TRAIN
03:39:53.246 --> 03:39:54.881
INDIVIDUALS DOING THE OVERSIGHT
03:39:54.948 --> 03:39:56.750
WOULD ULTIMATELY BE RESPONSIBLE
03:39:56.816 --> 03:39:58.818
FOR MAKING DECISIONS. BASED IN
03:39:58.885 --> 03:40:00.687
WHOLE OR IN PART ON THE OUTPUT
03:40:00.754 --> 03:40:02.155
OF THE FACIAL RECOGNITION
03:40:02.222 --> 03:40:04.724
SERVICE IT ALSO GRANTS RIGHT TO
03:40:04.791 --> 03:40:07.227
INDIVIDUALS TO FALL AS- ONE TO
03:40:07.294 --> 03:40:09.462
CONFIRM WHETHER. THEY'RE MH
03:40:09.529 --> 03:40:11.598
OFFICIAL TEMPLATE HUSBAND AND
03:40:11.665 --> 03:40:12.732
ROLE IN THE FACIAL RECOGNITION
03:40:12.799 --> 03:40:14.834
SERVICE. TO CORRECT OR
03:40:14.901 --> 03:40:16.369
CHALLENGING DECISION TO ENROLL
03:40:16.436 --> 03:40:17.938
THEIR IN IMAGE OR FACIAL
03:40:18.004 --> 03:40:20.140
TEMPLATE OR SECURITY OR SAFETY
03:40:20.206 --> 03:40:22.142
PURPOSE THREE TO HAVE THEIR IN
03:40:22.208 --> 03:40:24.311
ROLLED IMAGE OF FACIAL TEMPLATE
03:40:24.377 --> 03:40:25.946
THE LEADER. WITH LIMITED
03:40:26.012 --> 03:40:28.315
EXCEPTIONS AND FOR TO WITHDRAW
03:40:28.381 --> 03:40:29.983
CONSENT TO ENROLL THEIR IMAGE
03:40:30.050 --> 03:40:31.585
OR FACIAL TEMPLATE IN OFFICIAL
03:40:31.651 --> 03:40:33.620
RECOGNITION SERVICE. I FINALLY
03:40:33.687 --> 03:40:35.088
THIS BILL IMPOSES ADDITIONAL
03:40:35.155 --> 03:40:36.990
REQUIREMENTS ON AGENCIES
03:40:37.057 --> 03:40:39.559
DEFINED A STATE OR LOCAL PUBLIC
03:40:39.626 --> 03:40:41.795
ENTITIES WHICH USE OR INTENT TO
03:40:41.861 --> 03:40:44.030
DO BOB PROCURE OR USE FACIAL
03:40:44.097 --> 03:40:45.131
RECOGNITION SERVICES FOR
03:40:45.198 --> 03:40:46.099
EXAMPLE WOULD REQUIRE AS AN AGE
03:40:46.166 --> 03:40:48.034
TO PRODUCE. AND ACCOUNTABILITY
03:40:48.101 --> 03:40:49.803
REPORT REGARDING THE USE OF DOT
03:40:49.869 --> 03:40:51.471
SYSTEM AND ALSO TO COMMUNICATE
03:40:51.538 --> 03:40:53.173
THAT REPORT TO THE PUBLIC AT
03:40:53.239 --> 03:40:56.443
LEAST NINETY DAYS PRIOR TO
03:40:56.509 --> 03:40:58.778
EMPLOYING THE SERVICE WHILE
03:40:58.845 --> 03:41:00.513
ALLOWING FOR A REVIEW AND
03:41:00.580 --> 03:41:02.449
COMMENT. FOR ANALYZING AND THE
03:41:02.515 --> 03:41:05.118
RIVER. SO PERHAPS PROHIBITS THE
03:41:05.185 --> 03:41:09.489
AGING FROM USING AN AGENCY FROM
03:41:09.556 --> 03:41:10.323
YOU CHAU RECOGNITION SERVICE IN
03:41:10.390 --> 03:41:15.095
QUE IN ON TO VETERANS UNLESS.
03:41:15.161 --> 03:41:15.962
CERTAIN STRINGENT REQUIRE AND-
03:41:16.029 --> 03:41:17.530
ARE MET RELATING TO A LAW
03:41:17.597 --> 03:41:19.599
ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATION OF A
03:41:19.666 --> 03:41:21.735
SERIOUS CRIMINAL OFFENSE AS
03:41:21.801 --> 03:41:24.237
DEFINED IN LAW. OR FROM
03:41:24.304 --> 03:41:25.839
GENERALLY APPLYING OFFICIAL
03:41:25.905 --> 03:41:27.207
RECOGNITION SERVICE TO AN
03:41:27.273 --> 03:41:27.974
INDIVIDUAL BASED ON THEIR
03:41:28.041 --> 03:41:29.876
RELIGIOUS POLITICAL VIEW OR
03:41:29.943 --> 03:41:32.112
ACTIVITIES BUT THIS PATIENT IN
03:41:32.178 --> 03:41:33.947
A LAWFUL EVENT OR OTHER
03:41:34.014 --> 03:41:36.249
PERCEIVED RACE ETHNICITY
03:41:36.316 --> 03:41:38.952
CITIZENSHIP PLACE OF ORIGIN AGE
03:41:39.019 --> 03:41:42.155
DISABILITY GENDER. IDENTITY
03:41:42.222 --> 03:41:44.457
SEXUAL ORIENTATION OR OTHER
03:41:44.524 --> 03:41:45.925
CHARACTERISTICS PROTECTED BY
03:41:45.992 --> 03:41:48.128
LAW INCLUDING TO CREATE A
03:41:48.194 --> 03:41:50.130
RECORD OF AN INDIVIDUAL
03:41:50.196 --> 03:41:51.464
EXERCISING THEIR FIRST
03:41:51.531 --> 03:41:52.232
AMENDMENT RIGHT. ALTHOUGH
03:41:52.298 --> 03:41:55.602
BEFORE JANUARY FIRST TWENTY
03:41:55.669 --> 03:41:56.202
THREE TWENTY THREE DOES THIS
03:41:56.269 --> 03:41:57.103
BILL ALSO REQUIRES THE
03:41:57.170 --> 03:41:59.205
CALIFORNIA STATE AUDITOR TO
03:41:59.272 --> 03:42:01.207
CONDUCT BY ANNUALLY AN
03:42:01.274 --> 03:42:03.276
INDEPENDENT AUDIT OF STATE AND
03:42:03.343 --> 03:42:05.345
LOCAL AGENCIES DEPLOYING FACIAL
03:42:05.412 --> 03:42:07.180
RECOGNITION SERVICES. TO
03:42:07.247 --> 03:42:08.915
EVALUATE COMPLIANCE WITH THE
03:42:08.982 --> 03:42:11.384
PROVISIONS OF THIS- TITLE AND
03:42:11.451 --> 03:42:12.952
FINALLY VIOLATIONS OF THIS-
03:42:13.019 --> 03:42:14.387
BILL WOULD BE SUBJECT TO CIVIL
03:42:14.454 --> 03:42:16.589
PENALTIES OF NO MORE THAN
03:42:16.656 --> 03:42:17.524
TWENTY FIVE HUNDRED DOLLARS PER
03:42:17.590 --> 03:42:19.125
FOR EACH VIOLATION WERE MORE
03:42:19.192 --> 03:42:21.294
THAN SEVENTY FIVE HUNDRED FOR
03:42:21.361 --> 03:42:22.796
EACH INTENTIONAL VIOLATION OF
03:42:22.862 --> 03:42:24.597
RECOVER ONLY IN AN ACTION
03:42:24.664 --> 03:42:26.399
BROUGHT BY THE ATTORNEY GENERAL
03:42:26.466 --> 03:42:29.169
AS SPECIFIED. IN CLOSING US
03:42:29.235 --> 03:42:29.769
OFFICIAL RECOGNITION SERVICES
03:42:29.836 --> 03:42:32.105
INCREASING USED BY BUSINESSES
03:42:32.172 --> 03:42:33.907
AND PUBLIC ENTITIES WE MUST
03:42:33.973 --> 03:42:35.675
ENSURE THAT THEY ARE DOING SO
03:42:35.742 --> 03:42:37.210
WITH TRANSPARENT AND ADEQUATE
03:42:37.277 --> 03:42:39.846
OVERSIGHT. WOULD DOT I
03:42:39.913 --> 03:42:44.284
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR
03:42:44.350 --> 03:42:45.518
SUPPORT AND- THANK YOU OUT WE
03:42:45.585 --> 03:42:46.753
HAVE A SPEAKER IN SUPPORT ON
03:42:46.820 --> 03:42:52.192
THE LINE. GOOD AFTERNOON MISTER
03:42:52.258 --> 03:42:54.194
CHAIR MY NAME IS ARION HARKINS
03:42:54.260 --> 03:42:56.262
I AM THE SENIOR DIRECTOR OF
03:42:56.329 --> 03:42:57.964
PUBLIC POLICY WITH MICROSOFT.
03:42:58.031 --> 03:42:59.332
AND I'D LIKE TO THANK YOU IN
03:42:59.399 --> 03:43:00.633
THE COMMITTEE FOR THE
03:43:00.700 --> 03:43:03.403
OPPORTUNITY TO TESTIFY. WE
03:43:03.470 --> 03:43:04.904
SUPPORT AB TWENTY TWO SIXTY
03:43:04.971 --> 03:43:07.240
ONE. BUT IT WOULD IMPOSE MUCH
03:43:07.307 --> 03:43:09.309
NEEDED REGULATION ON BOTH THE
03:43:09.375 --> 03:43:11.644
PRIVATE AND PUBLIC SECTORS USE
03:43:11.711 --> 03:43:13.780
AND DEVELOPMENT OF FACE
03:43:13.847 --> 03:43:15.181
RECOGNITION TECHNOLOGY. WE'VE
03:43:15.248 --> 03:43:18.651
SEEN. RAPID ADVANCES IN
03:43:18.718 --> 03:43:20.353
WIDESPREAD DEPLOYMENT IN YOU
03:43:20.420 --> 03:43:21.387
THE BEST A RECOGNITION
03:43:21.454 --> 03:43:25.625
TECHNOLOGY ALL AROUND US- IN
03:43:25.692 --> 03:43:26.459
ACROSS SOCIETY OVER THE PAST
03:43:26.526 --> 03:43:28.628
DECADE. IN THE TECHNOLOGY IS
03:43:28.695 --> 03:43:31.030
PROVIDING A WIDE RANGE OF
03:43:31.097 --> 03:43:33.299
BENEFITS ACROSS SOCIETY. BUT
03:43:33.366 --> 03:43:34.801
IT'S ALSO LARGELY UNREGULATED
03:43:34.868 --> 03:43:37.804
TODAY. THERE ARE IN EFFECT BUT
03:43:37.871 --> 03:43:40.907
FEW IF ANY RULES IN PLACE.
03:43:40.974 --> 03:43:43.009
GOVERNING IT DEVELOPMENT IN YOU
03:43:43.076 --> 03:43:45.044
AND IT POSES. A THREAT TO
03:43:45.111 --> 03:43:47.213
DEMOCRATIC FREEDOMS TO PRIVACY
03:43:47.280 --> 03:43:49.783
AND CIVIL LIBERTIES. IT POSES
03:43:49.849 --> 03:43:51.885
SERIOUS CONCERNS ABOUT-
03:43:51.951 --> 03:43:54.020
INACCURACIES BY CITIES IN
03:43:54.087 --> 03:43:56.256
DISCRIMINATION. CONCERNS THAT
03:43:56.322 --> 03:43:58.057
ARE HEIGHTENED FOR PEOPLE OF
03:43:58.124 --> 03:44:01.227
COLOR AND FOR MARGINALIZED
03:44:01.294 --> 03:44:02.729
COMMUNITIES. OUR VIEW A CAN
03:44:02.796 --> 03:44:04.197
RACE TO THE BOTTOM IN AN
03:44:04.264 --> 03:44:05.799
UNREGULATED MARKET PLACE
03:44:05.865 --> 03:44:09.736
BENEFITS NO ONE. ABOVE ALL FACE
03:44:09.803 --> 03:44:11.571
RECOGNITION TECHNOLOGY SHOULD
03:44:11.638 --> 03:44:13.206
NOT BE YOU CAN MASS
03:44:13.273 --> 03:44:14.741
SURVEILLANCE OF THE POPULATION.
03:44:14.808 --> 03:44:15.842
AND THAT'S WHY WE'VE BEEN
03:44:15.909 --> 03:44:17.977
CALLING FOR LAWS TO REGULATE
03:44:18.044 --> 03:44:20.580
PAYS A RECOGNITION TECHNOLOGY
03:44:20.647 --> 03:44:21.714
IN THE SUMMER OF TWENTY
03:44:21.781 --> 03:44:25.084
EIGHTEEN. IN OUR VIEW AB TWENTY
03:44:25.151 --> 03:44:25.852
TWO SIXTY ONE WOULD REPRESENT A
03:44:25.919 --> 03:44:27.787
SUBSTANTIAL STEP FORWARD IT
03:44:27.854 --> 03:44:28.822
WOULD IT WOULD IMPOSE
03:44:28.888 --> 03:44:31.090
RESTRICTIONS THAT DO NOT EXIST
03:44:31.157 --> 03:44:33.927
IN LAW TODAY. IT WOULD REGULATE
03:44:33.993 --> 03:44:36.196
THE PRIVATE SECTOR BY AMONG
03:44:36.262 --> 03:44:37.831
OTHER THINGS ADDRESSING
03:44:37.897 --> 03:44:39.199
CONCERNS OF BIAS AND
03:44:39.265 --> 03:44:41.601
DISCRIMINATION BY REQUIRING
03:44:41.668 --> 03:44:43.670
COMPANIES TO BE TRANSPARENT.
03:44:43.736 --> 03:44:45.071
BUT TAKEN TO TASK THEIR
03:44:45.138 --> 03:44:47.140
TECHNOLOGIES FOR BY IT THE END
03:44:47.207 --> 03:44:49.442
DISCRIMINATION BUT TO REQUIRE
03:44:49.509 --> 03:44:51.578
COMPANIES TO ENABLE INDEPENDENT
03:44:51.644 --> 03:44:53.580
THIRD PARTIES TO TEST TAKE OUT
03:44:53.646 --> 03:44:54.914
THE TECHNOLOGY PROVIDE
03:44:54.981 --> 03:44:56.950
DISCRIMINATION. BUT TO REQUIRE
03:44:57.016 --> 03:44:59.285
COMPANIES TO TAKE ACTION TO
03:44:59.352 --> 03:45:01.020
ADDRESS AN INACCURACY THERE BY
03:45:01.087 --> 03:45:03.323
THE THAT HAVE BEEN IDENTIFIED
03:45:03.389 --> 03:45:04.724
IN THEIR TECHNOLOGY. IT WOULD
03:45:04.791 --> 03:45:06.659
AND COMPANIES FROM IN ROLLING
03:45:06.726 --> 03:45:08.595
CONSUMERS PERSONAL DATA IN A
03:45:08.661 --> 03:45:10.296
FACE TO RECOGNITION SYSTEM
03:45:10.363 --> 03:45:13.333
WITHOUT OBTAINING CONSENT- OR
03:45:13.399 --> 03:45:16.536
IN SOME LIMITED. CIRCUMSTANCES
03:45:16.603 --> 03:45:17.136
FOR SECURITY OR SAFETY
03:45:17.203 --> 03:45:19.606
PURPOSES. IT WOULD BAN THE USE
03:45:19.672 --> 03:45:20.640
OF FACIAL RECOGNITION
03:45:20.707 --> 03:45:22.842
TECHNOLOGY TO MAKE SIGNIFICANT
03:45:22.909 --> 03:45:26.179
DECISIONS ABOUT- CONSUMER.
03:45:26.246 --> 03:45:27.413
WITHOUT INSURANCE THE THIS IS
03:45:27.480 --> 03:45:33.019
THE I MEAN THANK YOU YOU. BUT
03:45:33.086 --> 03:45:34.487
ALSO IMPOSE MY NEEDED. ON THE
03:45:34.554 --> 03:45:36.556
GOV YOU OF THE TECHNOLOGY. JUST
03:45:36.623 --> 03:45:38.491
THE HIGHLIGHT A FEW IT WOULD
03:45:38.558 --> 03:45:40.426
REQUIRE STRONG OVERSIGHT AND
03:45:40.493 --> 03:45:41.761
ACCOUNTABILITY OF THE
03:45:41.828 --> 03:45:43.529
GOVERNMENT VIEWED THE PHASER
03:45:43.596 --> 03:45:45.465
RECOGNITION TECHNOLOGY. BY
03:45:45.531 --> 03:45:47.767
REQUIRING AMONG OTHER THINGS UP
03:45:47.834 --> 03:45:50.169
PUBLIC ACCOUNTABILITY REPORT-
03:45:50.236 --> 03:45:52.038
BEFORE AGENCIES WOULD YOU THE
03:45:52.105 --> 03:45:54.707
TECHNOLOGY IT WOULD REQUIRE
03:45:54.774 --> 03:45:55.108
GREATER COMMUNITY
03:45:55.174 --> 03:45:57.076
PARTICIPATION. BEFORE
03:45:57.143 --> 03:45:59.345
GOVERNMENT AGENCIES DECIDE TO
03:45:59.412 --> 03:46:01.614
PROCURE OR ADOPTED TECHNOLOGY
03:46:01.681 --> 03:46:03.449
BY AMONG OTHER THINGS REQUIRED
03:46:03.516 --> 03:46:04.584
PUBLIC NOTICE AND COMMENT
03:46:04.651 --> 03:46:07.520
PERIODS BEFORE AGENCIES SECURE
03:46:07.587 --> 03:46:09.956
THE TECHNOLOGY- IT WOULD SET AN
03:46:10.023 --> 03:46:11.925
APPROPRIATELY HIGH BAR ON THE
03:46:11.991 --> 03:46:13.693
USE OF THE TECHNOLOGY BY LAW
03:46:13.760 --> 03:46:15.528
ENFORCEMENT. BUT BEING THAT YOU
03:46:15.595 --> 03:46:17.330
USE FOR ONGOING SURVEILLANCE
03:46:17.397 --> 03:46:19.866
UNLESS ONE FOURTH AND OBTAINED
03:46:19.933 --> 03:46:21.734
A WARRANT FOR EXIGENT
03:46:21.801 --> 03:46:22.435
CIRCUMSTANCES EXIST. IN FINAL
03:46:22.502 --> 03:46:23.937
IT WOULD APPROPRIATELY BANNED
03:46:24.003 --> 03:46:25.805
THE USE OF FACIAL RECOGNITION
03:46:25.872 --> 03:46:28.508
TECHNOLOGY- BOND POINT ON
03:46:28.574 --> 03:46:30.944
CONSUMERS. BASED ON THEIR FIRST
03:46:31.010 --> 03:46:33.313
AMENDMENT ACTIVITIES OR BASED
03:46:33.379 --> 03:46:34.881
ON THEIR MEMBERSHIP IN A
03:46:34.948 --> 03:46:37.583
PROTECTED CLASS. SO WE APPLAUD
03:46:37.650 --> 03:46:38.918
YOU FOR YOUR LEADERSHIP IN
03:46:38.985 --> 03:46:41.387
EFFORT TO TACKLE THESE ISSUES-
03:46:41.454 --> 03:46:42.355
AND WE LOOK FORWARD TO WORKING
03:46:42.422 --> 03:46:43.990
WITH YOU AND FRANKLY ALL
03:46:44.057 --> 03:46:47.260
STAKEHOLDERS. LAWMAKERS
03:46:47.327 --> 03:46:49.228
ADVOCATE LAW ENFORCEMENT
03:46:49.295 --> 03:46:52.065
GOVERNMENT AND INDUSTRY TO
03:46:52.131 --> 03:46:53.333
ADDRESS THESE ISSUES AND MOVE
03:46:53.399 --> 03:46:56.936
THE- LEGISLATION BOARD THANK
03:46:57.003 --> 03:46:57.470
YOU I'D BE HAPPY TO TRY TO
03:46:57.537 --> 03:46:59.305
ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS. THANK YOU
03:46:59.372 --> 03:47:00.873
MISTER HARKINS OTHER OTHER
03:47:00.940 --> 03:47:13.753
SPEAKERS IN SUPPORT ON THE LINE.
03:47:13.820 --> 03:47:15.421
I HEARING NO OTHER SPEAKERS IN
03:47:15.488 --> 03:47:17.023
SUPPORT WILL MOVE TO SPEAKERS
03:47:17.090 --> 03:47:20.426
IN OPPOSITION- STARTING WITH
03:47:20.493 --> 03:47:31.804
MISTER WARD. GOOD AFTERNOON
03:47:31.871 --> 03:47:32.972
COMMITTEE MEMBERS IS YOUR CHAIR
03:47:33.039 --> 03:47:34.707
THIS VICE CHAIR. MY NAME IS
03:47:34.774 --> 03:47:36.809
GRANT WARD THEM- IN HERE IN
03:47:36.876 --> 03:47:39.445
OPPOSITION TO TWENTY SIX ONE. I
03:47:39.512 --> 03:47:41.447
AM THE PRESIDENT OF C. BUT SAM
03:47:41.514 --> 03:47:41.981
YOU KNOW COUNTY SHERIFF'S
03:47:42.048 --> 03:47:43.182
EMPLOYEE BENEFITS ASSOCIATION
03:47:43.249 --> 03:47:44.917
ALSO SERVED AS THE- BOARD
03:47:44.984 --> 03:47:46.185
APPOINTED PRESIDENT OF SCALE
03:47:46.252 --> 03:47:47.020
THE SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA
03:47:47.086 --> 03:47:49.122
ALLIANCE LAW ENFORCEMENT I SIT
03:47:49.188 --> 03:47:50.823
ON THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS. OF
03:47:50.890 --> 03:47:52.692
CC ONLY A THE CALIFORNIA
03:47:52.759 --> 03:47:54.060
COALITION LAW ENFORCEMENT AS
03:47:54.127 --> 03:47:54.927
WELL AS POOR I CAN THE PEACE
03:47:54.994 --> 03:47:56.429
OFFICERS RESEARCH ASSOCIATION
03:47:56.496 --> 03:48:01.601
CALIFORNIA- SO. IN MY OVER
03:48:01.667 --> 03:48:02.735
TWENTY TWO YEARS AS A LAW
03:48:02.802 --> 03:48:03.836
ENFORCEMENT OFFICER I'VE HAD
03:48:03.903 --> 03:48:05.004
THE OPTION YOU WORK NUMEROUS
03:48:05.071 --> 03:48:06.406
DIFFERENT ASSIGNMENTS AND ONE
03:48:06.472 --> 03:48:07.306
OF THOSE ASSIGNMENTS WAS AS A
03:48:07.373 --> 03:48:08.307
DETECTIVE IN CHARGE OF
03:48:08.374 --> 03:48:09.942
RESEARCHING IN ASSESSING
03:48:10.009 --> 03:48:11.944
BIOMETRIC TECHNOLOGIES. FOR SAM
03:48:12.011 --> 03:48:12.512
YOU KNOW COUNTY IN RIVERSIDE
03:48:12.578 --> 03:48:14.414
COUNTY. NOW THAT YOU KNOW WHO I
03:48:14.480 --> 03:48:16.816
AM. I'D FIRST LIKE TO. POINT
03:48:16.883 --> 03:48:18.985
OUT HOW DIFFICULT IT IS TO DEBT
03:48:19.052 --> 03:48:20.486
TO DEDICATE TIME AND RESOURCES
03:48:20.553 --> 03:48:21.754
TO OPPOSE LEGISLATION IS
03:48:21.821 --> 03:48:23.556
POTENTIALLY HARMFUL TO LAW
03:48:23.623 --> 03:48:24.190
ENFORCEMENT DURING THIS CURRENT
03:48:24.257 --> 03:48:25.992
CRISIS. AT THE TIME WHEN OUR
03:48:26.059 --> 03:48:27.894
FULL FOCUS IS ON IS ON THE
03:48:27.960 --> 03:48:30.029
SHRINK OUR COMMUNITIES. AND IN
03:48:30.096 --> 03:48:32.665
MY CASE MY MEMBERS ARE SAFE AND
03:48:32.732 --> 03:48:34.100
LOOKED AFTER DURING THIS
03:48:34.167 --> 03:48:35.268
PANDEMIC IT UPSETS ME TO KNOW
03:48:35.334 --> 03:48:35.802
THE BILL'S LIKE THIS THAT
03:48:35.868 --> 03:48:37.403
HINDER ABILITY TO DO OUR JOBS.
03:48:37.470 --> 03:48:39.972
BILL BEING PUSHED FORWARD. WE
03:48:40.039 --> 03:48:41.574
UNDERSTAND AND AGREE FACIAL
03:48:41.641 --> 03:48:43.376
RECOGNITION TECHNOLOGIES SHOULD
03:48:43.443 --> 03:48:45.978
BE REGULATED. ALL TECHNOLOGIES
03:48:46.045 --> 03:48:47.780
SHOULD BE WATCHED OVER. AND
03:48:47.847 --> 03:48:49.449
ENSURE OUR PERSONAL FREEDOMS
03:48:49.515 --> 03:48:50.850
AND PRIVACY NGUYEN REASONABLY
03:48:50.917 --> 03:48:53.986
EXPECTED IS PROTECTED. WE
03:48:54.053 --> 03:48:54.520
SHOULD BE WORKING TOWARDS
03:48:54.587 --> 03:48:57.356
SOLUTIONS. I WOULD LOVE TO GO
03:48:57.423 --> 03:48:58.891
INTO DETAIL REGARDING ISSUES
03:48:58.958 --> 03:49:01.894
THAT WE'VE IDENTIFIED IN AB
03:49:01.961 --> 03:49:02.462
TWENTY TWO SIXTY ONE BUT FOR
03:49:02.528 --> 03:49:06.599
THE PURPOSES THIS HEARING- I'D
03:49:06.666 --> 03:49:09.168
LIKE TO POINT OUT TO MAJOR FLAW.
03:49:09.235 --> 03:49:10.603
THE EXTREME LIMITATION IS ON
03:49:10.670 --> 03:49:12.305
LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATORS.
03:49:12.371 --> 03:49:14.373
THIS BILL ALLOWS THE TOOL TO
03:49:14.440 --> 03:49:15.608
ONLY BE USED WHILE MESSI
03:49:15.675 --> 03:49:17.410
GETTING SERIOUS FELONY CRIMES.
03:49:17.477 --> 03:49:18.711
HOWEVER THE MOST COMMON TYPES
03:49:18.778 --> 03:49:21.948
OF CRIMES THAT ARE- ACTUALLY
03:49:22.014 --> 03:49:23.449
USEFUL PROVISION RECOGNITION
03:49:23.516 --> 03:49:30.756
ARE COMPLETELY PROHIBITED. IT'S
03:49:30.823 --> 03:49:32.391
CRIMES LIKE IDENTITY THEFT
03:49:32.458 --> 03:49:34.660
CHECK FRAUD CREDIT CARD FRAUD
03:49:34.727 --> 03:49:36.963
RETAIL THEFT AND BURGLARY THE
03:49:37.029 --> 03:49:38.397
CONSISTENTLY HAVE USABLE FACIAL
03:49:38.464 --> 03:49:40.199
RECOGNITION FROM SURVEILLANCE
03:49:40.266 --> 03:49:42.401
VIDEO FOOTAGE AND IN THIS STATE
03:49:42.468 --> 03:49:44.103
THOSE CRIMES ARE VERY RARELY
03:49:44.170 --> 03:49:47.306
DEEMS SELLING. A MAJOR ISSUE TO
03:49:47.373 --> 03:49:48.674
DO WITH MEN CHEATING A PURGE OF
03:49:48.741 --> 03:49:50.042
IMAGE TEMPLATES MORE THAN THREE
03:49:50.109 --> 03:49:52.411
YEARS OLD. THE IMAGES LAW
03:49:52.478 --> 03:49:54.046
ENFORCEMENT AGENCIES USED TO
03:49:54.113 --> 03:49:56.983
COMPARE AGAINST. THE PROBE
03:49:57.049 --> 03:49:59.218
IMAGE ARE BOOKING PHOTOS THERE
03:49:59.285 --> 03:50:00.953
ARE NO EXPECTATIONS TO PRIVACY
03:50:01.020 --> 03:50:03.122
WHEN BOOKED INTO JAIL IN FACT
03:50:03.189 --> 03:50:03.623
FINGERPRINTING AND
03:50:03.689 --> 03:50:06.359
PHOTOGRAPHING. TIRED NEVER A
03:50:06.425 --> 03:50:07.894
PERFECT TIME TO ENROLL A PERSON
03:50:07.960 --> 03:50:10.663
INTO A DATABASE THEN LOOKING.
03:50:10.730 --> 03:50:13.432
BY THE END OF THAT PROCESS- WE
03:50:13.499 --> 03:50:15.334
KNOW EXACTLY WHO THAT PERSON IS
03:50:15.401 --> 03:50:16.469
AND IF THE PERSON IS NEVER BEEN
03:50:16.536 --> 03:50:18.137
ARRESTED BEFORE THE FIRST
03:50:18.204 --> 03:50:19.405
PROCESS ENSURES THE SAME VISUAL
03:50:19.472 --> 03:50:21.641
CAN BE AGAIN IDENTIFIED IN
03:50:21.707 --> 03:50:24.243
FUTURE REGARDLESS OF WHAT NAME
03:50:24.310 --> 03:50:25.144
OR INFORMATION THEY PROVIDE
03:50:25.211 --> 03:50:27.914
SOME SUBSEQUENT CONTACTS ONE
03:50:27.980 --> 03:50:29.415
FOR SOME. PERSON THIS FEATURE.
03:50:29.482 --> 03:50:31.083
TO HELP PROVIDE IN GATED LEAVES
03:50:31.150 --> 03:50:32.485
WHICH HOPEFULLY RESULT IN
03:50:32.552 --> 03:50:35.955
SOLVING CRIMES IT DOES NOT
03:50:36.022 --> 03:50:36.355
PROVIDE A POSITIVE
03:50:36.422 --> 03:50:37.857
IDENTIFICATION. AS A CANDIDATE
03:50:37.924 --> 03:50:40.193
LIST OF PEOPLE WITH SIMILAR A
03:50:40.259 --> 03:50:42.128
SIMILAR FACIAL GEOMETRY. WE
03:50:42.195 --> 03:50:43.396
WOULD BE HAPPY TO PROVIDE
03:50:43.462 --> 03:50:44.931
ACTUAL CASE SUMMARIES OR
03:50:44.997 --> 03:50:47.066
ARRANGE A DEMONSTRATION OF HOW
03:50:47.133 --> 03:50:48.968
LAW ENFORCEMENT USES THE TECH.
03:50:49.035 --> 03:50:51.704
IS ACTUALLY FIVE IS ACTUALLY
03:50:51.771 --> 03:50:53.573
USE OR DALY INVESTIGATIVE
03:50:53.639 --> 03:50:56.709
PROCESS IT'S VASTLY DIFFERENT
03:50:56.776 --> 03:50:58.511
THAN HOW HOLLYWOOD DEPICTS. SO
03:50:58.578 --> 03:51:00.179
IN CONCLUSION WE RESPECTFULLY
03:51:00.246 --> 03:51:02.348
ASK THAT THIS COMMITTEE HOLD
03:51:02.415 --> 03:51:03.316
OFF ON THAT MOVING THIS BILL
03:51:03.382 --> 03:51:05.384
FORWARD ALTHOUGH WE ADAMANTLY
03:51:05.451 --> 03:51:07.620
OF BILLS CURRENTLY WRITTEN WE
03:51:07.687 --> 03:51:09.789
DO BELIEVE IT CAN BE A MINUTE.
03:51:09.855 --> 03:51:13.092
PUSHES IN INTENT AND- WE BET.
03:51:13.159 --> 03:51:13.793
DO NOT SAID ONE OF ALONE FOR
03:51:13.859 --> 03:51:16.329
TOOLS FIFTEEN YEARS WITH THAT
03:51:16.395 --> 03:51:18.030
I'LL BE HERE TO ANSWER ANY
03:51:18.097 --> 03:51:19.899
QUESTIONS HOW WE ACTUALLY USE
03:51:19.966 --> 03:51:22.835
THE TECHNOLOGY. YOU ANOTHER
03:51:22.902 --> 03:51:25.004
DESIGNATED SPEAKER IN
03:51:25.071 --> 03:51:29.875
OPPOSITION JOINING US BY PHONE.
03:51:29.942 --> 03:51:31.210
MISTER CHAIR AND MEMBERS OF THE
03:51:31.277 --> 03:51:32.245
COMMITTEE MY NAME IS TO MEET
03:51:32.311 --> 03:51:33.179
WITH MINE AND THE GOVERNMENT
03:51:33.246 --> 03:51:34.714
RELATIONS COORDINATOR FOR THE
03:51:34.780 --> 03:51:35.848
COUNCIL ON AMERICAN ISLAMIC
03:51:35.915 --> 03:51:37.750
RELATIONS AND HAVE THE KOBE
03:51:37.817 --> 03:51:38.851
AREA OFFICE. I'M SPEAKING TODAY
03:51:38.918 --> 03:51:43.322
ON BEHALF OF THE COLD IN A P.
03:51:43.389 --> 03:51:45.191
FIVE RIGHTS ORGANIZATIONS AND
03:51:45.258 --> 03:51:48.594
OPPOSITION. TO EIGHTY SIX. THE
03:51:48.661 --> 03:51:52.398
MEMBER SHALL SURE. ALICIA THE
03:51:52.465 --> 03:51:53.966
ONLY A TWENTY TWO SIXTY REMAIN
03:51:54.033 --> 03:51:55.501
DANGER PERMISSIVE OFFICIAL
03:51:55.568 --> 03:51:57.803
RECORD AND THE RED OF THE TOP
03:51:57.870 --> 03:52:00.139
KELP PARTICULARLY TO EMIGRATE
03:52:00.206 --> 03:52:02.842
FULL OF. FIFTY FIVE THE GROUP'S
03:52:02.908 --> 03:52:05.411
OPPOSED BILL AND CONSIDER IT A
03:52:05.478 --> 03:52:07.113
THREAT TO THE HEALTH AND SAFETY
03:52:07.179 --> 03:52:08.881
OF OUR COMMUNITIES PROMINENT
03:52:08.948 --> 03:52:10.950
HEALTH EXPERTS ALSO OPPOSE THIS
03:52:11.017 --> 03:52:13.452
BILL STATING THERE'S NO PUBLIC
03:52:13.519 --> 03:52:15.955
HELPED APPLICATION. ACTUAL
03:52:16.022 --> 03:52:18.691
WRECKING AND OF THE USHERED IN
03:52:18.758 --> 03:52:20.059
BY THE BILL THIS BILL
03:52:20.126 --> 03:52:22.328
LEGITIMIZES THE NON CONSENSUAL
03:52:22.395 --> 03:52:23.829
USE OF FACIAL RECOGNITION BY
03:52:23.896 --> 03:52:25.731
COMPANIES AND GOVERNMENTS AND
03:52:25.798 --> 03:52:27.233
THE CREATION OF FAITH DATABASES
03:52:27.300 --> 03:52:28.901
BUT IMMIGRATION AND CUSTOMS
03:52:28.968 --> 03:52:31.470
ENFORCEMENT HAS ALREADY SOUGHT
03:52:31.537 --> 03:52:33.572
TO EXPLOIT ANOTHER STATE. CAN
03:52:33.639 --> 03:52:35.808
STILL CREE LEGAL FIGHT FOR YOU
03:52:35.875 --> 03:52:37.643
THING FISH RECOGNITION. NEED
03:52:37.710 --> 03:52:39.245
AND DENY ESSENTIAL SERVICES
03:52:39.312 --> 03:52:43.482
SUCH AS ACT TO EMPLOYMENT OR
03:52:43.549 --> 03:52:44.050
CARE WE SHOULD NOT BE MAKING
03:52:44.116 --> 03:52:49.822
CANNOT THANKS THE HARD. DISK.
03:52:49.889 --> 03:52:53.292
HELP STATE OR OPPOSITION IT THE
03:52:53.359 --> 03:52:55.027
BILL WELL PHAM HAVE BY THE
03:52:55.094 --> 03:52:56.829
IMPACTED BY THE NINETY AND
03:52:56.896 --> 03:52:58.431
OTHER PEOPLE IN THE AND OTHER
03:52:58.497 --> 03:53:02.968
MARCH PEOPLE THE LEGISLATURE
03:53:03.035 --> 03:53:04.704
SHOULD NOT PASS LEGISLATION
03:53:04.770 --> 03:53:06.739
THAT. THE NATIONAL HARSHER
03:53:06.806 --> 03:53:09.108
ASIAN. AMERICAN MORE. REMEMBER
03:53:09.175 --> 03:53:10.309
THE LONG LASTING THEIR CHOICES
03:53:10.376 --> 03:53:13.012
MADE DURING TIMES OF CRISIS
03:53:13.079 --> 03:53:14.313
AFTER NINE ELEVEN OUR
03:53:14.380 --> 03:53:15.715
GOVERNMENT LEADERS CHAU TO
03:53:15.781 --> 03:53:17.450
LEGITIMIZE SURVEILLANCE AND
03:53:17.516 --> 03:53:19.085
DISCRIMINATION OVER CARE AND
03:53:19.151 --> 03:53:21.187
COMMUNITY CREATING DAMAGE THAT
03:53:21.253 --> 03:53:24.457
WOULD HELP RECOVERING FROM
03:53:24.523 --> 03:53:25.057
TWENTY YEARS LATER. ASK YOU TO
03:53:25.124 --> 03:53:25.958
AVOID REPEATING THAT HISTORY
03:53:26.025 --> 03:53:28.861
WITH AB TWENTY ONE RESPECTFULLY
03:53:28.928 --> 03:53:30.796
AND ON BEHALF OF THE COALITION
03:53:30.863 --> 03:53:33.399
OF FIFTY FIVE THE BILL RIGHT-ORGANIZATIONS I ASKED THE
03:53:33.466 --> 03:53:36.602
COMMITTEE TO VOTE NO ON AB
03:53:36.669 --> 03:53:39.338
TWENTY TWO SIXTY ONE. THANK YOU.
03:53:39.405 --> 03:53:41.307
YOU ARE THERE OTHER SPEAKERS IN
03:53:41.374 --> 03:53:44.310
OPPOSITION ON THE LINE. OR HERE
03:53:44.377 --> 03:53:45.378
I THINK WE'LL START WITH
03:53:45.444 --> 03:53:46.946
SPEAKERS HERE AND THEN WE'LL
03:53:47.012 --> 03:53:52.385
MOVE TO THAT TELEPHONE. HI KIM
03:53:52.451 --> 03:53:54.120
STONE OF STONE ADVOCACY ON
03:53:54.186 --> 03:53:55.788
BEHALF OF THE ACLU IN
03:53:55.855 --> 03:53:56.689
RESPECTFUL BUT STRONG
03:53:56.756 --> 03:53:58.357
OPPOSITION AND THEN WE HAVE A
03:53:58.424 --> 03:54:00.393
NUMBER OF GROUPS WHO JOINED OUR
03:54:00.459 --> 03:54:03.095
OPPOSITION BUT DIDN'T MAKE IT
03:54:03.162 --> 03:54:05.131
TO THE ANALYSIS MAGLIS THOSE.
03:54:05.197 --> 03:54:07.500
YOU MIGHT THINK. THE A. I. NOW
03:54:07.566 --> 03:54:09.502
INSTITUTE COMMUNITY ADVOCATES
03:54:09.568 --> 03:54:11.537
FOR JUST AND MORAL GOVERNANCE
03:54:11.604 --> 03:54:13.305
THE COUNCIL ON AMERICAN ISLAMIC
03:54:13.372 --> 03:54:15.174
RELATIONS CALIFORNIA CHAPTER.
03:54:15.241 --> 03:54:17.376
EAST BAY COMMUNITY LAW CENTER
03:54:17.443 --> 03:54:19.512
GREEN LINING INSTITUTE NATIONAL
03:54:19.578 --> 03:54:20.880
ASSOCIATION OF CRIMINAL DEFENSE
03:54:20.946 --> 03:54:22.681
LAWYERS. PARTNERSHIP FOR THE
03:54:22.748 --> 03:54:24.383
ADVANCEMENT OF NEW AMERICANS
03:54:24.450 --> 03:54:25.651
PRIVACY RIGHTS CLEARINGHOUSE
03:54:25.718 --> 03:54:28.154
PUBLIC ADVOCATES THE SAME CISCO
03:54:28.220 --> 03:54:30.689
PUBLIC DEFENDER'S OFFICE.
03:54:30.756 --> 03:54:31.957
SHOWING UP FOR RATE JUST SAN
03:54:32.024 --> 03:54:34.994
DIEGO. THE L. G. B. T. Q.
03:54:35.060 --> 03:54:37.930
CENTER LONG BEACH. S. DIEGO
03:54:37.997 --> 03:54:39.432
COAT AND WE THE PEOPLE DIEGO
03:54:39.498 --> 03:54:47.373
COUNTY THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
03:54:47.440 --> 03:54:49.208
DEAR LUCIEN HERE AT TESTIFYING
03:54:49.275 --> 03:54:50.843
ON BEHALF OF THE LOS ANGELES
03:54:50.910 --> 03:54:53.546
POLICE PROTECTIVE LEAGUE THE-
03:54:53.612 --> 03:54:54.680
YOU LABOR UNION THAT REPRESENTS
03:54:54.747 --> 03:54:57.716
THE TEN THOUSAND MEMBERS OF THE
03:54:57.783 --> 03:54:59.485
LAPD IN- AS WELL AS THE SAN
03:54:59.552 --> 03:55:01.153
FRANCISCO POLICE OFFICERS
03:55:01.220 --> 03:55:03.622
ASSOCIATION REPRESENTING TWENTY
03:55:03.689 --> 03:55:06.292
FIVE HUNDRED MEMBERS WE- WILL
03:55:06.358 --> 03:55:07.960
THE LA POLICE PROTECTIVE LEAGUE
03:55:08.027 --> 03:55:10.396
WAS SUPPOSE UNLESS AMENDED
03:55:10.463 --> 03:55:13.933
UNTIL WE REVIEWED THE MINUTES
03:55:13.999 --> 03:55:16.302
THAT WERE CIRCULATED TO US BY
03:55:16.368 --> 03:55:19.205
THE AUTHORS OFFICE WITH THANKS
03:55:19.271 --> 03:55:23.309
FOR BEING ADDED ON THAT BUT IT.
03:55:23.375 --> 03:55:25.778
THE BILL. THERE ARE CHANGES
03:55:25.845 --> 03:55:28.314
THAT THAT ACTUALLY IMPACT DAY
03:55:28.380 --> 03:55:29.915
TO DAY LAW ENFORCEMENT
03:55:29.982 --> 03:55:31.617
OPERATIONS IN IN WAYS THAT ARE
03:55:31.684 --> 03:55:33.185
PERHAPS PROBLEM NOT WILLING
03:55:33.252 --> 03:55:34.720
STOOD FOR SO FOR THOSE REASONS
03:55:34.787 --> 03:55:37.189
WE I HAD TO BE HERE IN PERSON
03:55:37.256 --> 03:55:39.024
TO SAY THAT WE'RE IN STRONG
03:55:39.091 --> 03:55:42.761
OPPOSITION THANK YOU. BUT
03:55:42.828 --> 03:55:43.929
SEEING NO OTHER SPEAKERS IN
03:55:43.996 --> 03:55:46.565
OPPOSITION- HERE WITH US- LET'S
03:55:46.632 --> 03:55:47.299
NOW MOVED TO SPEAKERS IN
03:55:47.366 --> 03:55:49.735
OPPOSITION WHO HAVE- JOINED
03:55:49.802 --> 03:55:55.307
THAT TELEPHONICALLY. AND OUR
03:55:55.374 --> 03:55:57.510
FIRST COMMENT COMES FROM
03:55:57.576 --> 03:55:58.043
SPENCER HAD DONE PLEASE GO
03:55:58.110 --> 03:56:02.214
AHEAD. HI GOOD AFTERNOON ED
03:56:02.281 --> 03:56:05.017
MISTER CHAIR AND MEMBERS OF THE
03:56:05.084 --> 03:56:06.318
COMMITTEE MY NAME IS SPENCER
03:56:06.385 --> 03:56:08.954
HOW CAN ALL BE OFF ALL.
03:56:09.021 --> 03:56:11.457
INDIVISIBLE CALIFORNIA THAT IS
03:56:11.524 --> 03:56:15.594
A- STATEWIDE ORGANIZATION OF
03:56:15.661 --> 03:56:16.762
THOUSANDS OF CALIFORNIANS
03:56:16.829 --> 03:56:19.899
THROUGHOUT THE STATE- WE OFTEN
03:56:19.965 --> 03:56:21.033
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU AND I CAN
03:56:21.100 --> 03:56:22.368
I JUST I REMIND EVERYONE WHO'S
03:56:22.434 --> 03:56:24.670
ON THE LINE THAT- DUE TO TIME
03:56:24.737 --> 03:56:25.237
CONSTRAINTS AND FORTUNATELY
03:56:25.304 --> 03:56:27.540
UNITS TO YOUR NAME- AND YOUR-
03:56:27.606 --> 03:56:29.008
ORGANIZATION AND YOU'RE- ON THE
03:56:29.074 --> 03:56:40.719
BILL. THANK COMMENTED FROM TODD
03:56:40.786 --> 03:56:44.490
SNYDER GLAD. THANK YOU VERY
03:56:44.557 --> 03:56:46.158
MUCH HELLO MEMBERS OF THE
03:56:46.225 --> 03:56:48.761
COMMITTEE AND- RESPECTED CHAIR-
03:56:48.827 --> 03:56:50.529
MY NAME IS TODD SNYDER AND I
03:56:50.596 --> 03:56:51.530
REPRESENT INDIVISIBLE SAN
03:56:51.597 --> 03:56:53.933
FRANCISCO AND I'M HERE TO
03:56:53.999 --> 03:56:56.635
EXPRESS MY STRONG OPPOSITION TO
03:56:56.702 --> 03:57:02.207
AB TWO TWO SIX ONE THANK YOU. I
03:57:02.274 --> 03:57:04.276
NEXT COMMENT AT FROM TAMMY
03:57:04.343 --> 03:57:13.786
KRASNER PLEASE GO AHEAD. OUR
03:57:13.852 --> 03:57:16.155
NEXT COMMON AS FROM ANNA
03:57:16.221 --> 03:57:18.390
KRASNER PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI MY
03:57:18.457 --> 03:57:21.293
NAME IS ANNA KRASNER AND ON
03:57:21.360 --> 03:57:21.827
BEHALF OF INDIVISIBLE SAN
03:57:21.894 --> 03:57:24.530
FRANCISCO I AM- STRONGLY
03:57:24.597 --> 03:57:27.866
OPPOSED TO AB TWENTY TWO SIXTY
03:57:27.933 --> 03:57:33.105
ONE. OUR NEXT COMMA AND FROM
03:57:33.172 --> 03:57:35.641
LEYVA HOLLAND PLEASE GO AHEAD.
03:57:35.708 --> 03:57:37.810
HI MY NAME IS LEAH HOLLAND AND
03:57:37.876 --> 03:57:39.545
I AM SPEAKING ON BEHALF OF BY
03:57:39.612 --> 03:57:41.580
THE FUTURE WHICH IS THE DIGITAL
03:57:41.647 --> 03:57:43.148
RIGHTS ORGANIZATION WITH
03:57:43.215 --> 03:57:44.883
MILLION MEMBERS NATIONWIDE AND
03:57:44.950 --> 03:57:48.621
WE ARE STRONGLY OPPOSED TO
03:57:48.687 --> 03:57:53.459
EIGHTY TWO TO ONE THANK YOU.
03:57:53.525 --> 03:57:55.361
OUR NEXT COMMENT AS FOR
03:57:55.427 --> 03:57:58.263
MARGARET BAKER PLEASE GO AHEAD.
03:57:58.330 --> 03:57:59.932
YES MY NAME IS MARGARET BAKER
03:57:59.999 --> 03:58:01.266
I'M WITH SOUTH STATE PEOPLE
03:58:01.333 --> 03:58:03.602
POWER INCENDIO COUNTY A GROUP
03:58:03.669 --> 03:58:05.104
THAT PROMOTES SOCIAL JUSTICE BY
03:58:05.170 --> 03:58:07.172
NONPARTISAN CIVIC ENGAGEMENT
03:58:07.239 --> 03:58:17.182
AND WE ARE STRONGLY OPPOSED. TO
03:58:17.249 --> 03:58:17.783
EIGHTY TWO TWO SIX ONE. I NEXT
03:58:17.850 --> 03:58:19.551
COMMENT AS FROM FEES HALL
03:58:19.618 --> 03:58:24.623
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HELLO MY NAME
03:58:24.690 --> 03:58:28.160
IS JEFF COLE- WITH TAQLID SAN
03:58:28.227 --> 03:58:33.232
DIEGO. AND WE ARE OPPOSED TO A.
03:58:33.298 --> 03:58:39.672
B. TWO TWO SIX ONE. THANK YOU.
03:58:39.738 --> 03:58:41.173
OUR NEXT COMMENT IF BROWN'S
03:58:41.240 --> 03:58:45.844
LAMPA NAJI PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI
03:58:45.911 --> 03:58:47.413
GOOD AFTERNOON MY NAME IS I AM
03:58:47.479 --> 03:58:49.014
IN A JEEP I'M A COMMUNITY
03:58:49.081 --> 03:58:50.983
ORGANIZER WITH THE COUNCIL ON
03:58:51.050 --> 03:58:52.951
AMERICAN ISLAMIC RELATIONS BUT
03:58:53.018 --> 03:58:54.787
THE GREATER LOS ANGELES AREA.
03:58:54.853 --> 03:58:57.423
AND WE ARE OPPOSED TO EIGHTY
03:58:57.489 --> 03:59:02.961
TWO TWO SIX ONE THANK YOU. OUR
03:59:03.028 --> 03:59:05.431
NEXT COMMON IN FROM TâM
03:59:05.497 --> 03:59:07.366
KINGSTON BECAUSE I HAD. MY NAME
03:59:07.433 --> 03:59:09.001
IS TIM KINGSTON ON A MEMBER OF
03:59:09.068 --> 03:59:10.035
THE SAN FRANCISCO PUBLIC
03:59:10.102 --> 03:59:11.437
DEFENDER'S RACIAL JUSTICE
03:59:11.503 --> 03:59:12.271
COMMITTEE AND WE ARE VERY
03:59:12.337 --> 03:59:15.140
STRONGLY OPPOSED TO AB TWENTY
03:59:15.207 --> 03:59:21.780
TWO SIXTY ONE. I NEXT COMMENT
03:59:21.847 --> 03:59:23.449
AND FROM SEMANTIC WEAPON PLEASE
03:59:23.515 --> 03:59:27.453
GO AHEAD. THE COURT ON BEHALF
03:59:27.519 --> 03:59:28.654
OF THE ELECTRONIC FRONTIER
03:59:28.721 --> 03:59:29.488
FOUNDATION AND PRIVATE YOU'RE A
03:59:29.555 --> 03:59:31.523
CLEARING HOUSE STRONG
03:59:31.590 --> 03:59:38.097
OPPOSITION THANK YOU. NEXT
03:59:38.163 --> 03:59:39.932
COMMON AS FROM MY ASIAN HAIR
03:59:39.998 --> 03:59:43.669
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI THIS IS
03:59:43.736 --> 03:59:45.037
MADE TO HAYES I'M CALLING ON
03:59:45.104 --> 03:59:47.406
BEHALF OF MEDIA DEAFNESS WHICH
03:59:47.473 --> 03:59:49.608
IS BASED OUT IN OAKLAND AND WE
03:59:49.675 --> 03:59:53.011
ARE STRONGLY OPPOSED AB TWENTY
03:59:53.078 --> 03:59:58.917
TWO SIXTY ONE. AN EX COMMUNISTS
03:59:58.984 --> 04:00:02.254
FROM GENOVEVA JONES RIGHT
04:00:02.321 --> 04:00:05.924
PLEASE GO AHEAD. MY NAME IS A
04:00:05.991 --> 04:00:07.793
JOKE RIGHT I AM THE LEGAL
04:00:07.860 --> 04:00:10.195
DIRECTOR BUT CANNOT PARTNERSHIP
04:00:10.262 --> 04:00:11.363
FOR THE ADVANCEMENT OF NEW
04:00:11.430 --> 04:00:12.631
AMERICAN BY AND ALSO THE
04:00:12.698 --> 04:00:16.301
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF COMMUNITY
04:00:16.368 --> 04:00:19.605
ADVOCATE PROJECT A MORAL
04:00:19.671 --> 04:00:22.207
GOVERNANCE. I AM. THE COALITION
04:00:22.274 --> 04:00:24.076
WHICH THE TREND. AND
04:00:24.143 --> 04:00:25.410
RESPONSIBLE OF SURVEILLANCE
04:00:25.477 --> 04:00:27.780
TECHNOLOGY SAN DIEGO COALITION.
04:00:27.846 --> 04:00:30.282
WHICH IS A COALITION MADE UP OF
04:00:30.349 --> 04:00:31.650
THIRTY COMMUNITY ORGANIZATIONS
04:00:31.717 --> 04:00:33.485
REPRESENTING VARIOUS SEGMENTS
04:00:33.552 --> 04:00:35.854
OF OUR COMMUNITY HERE IN SAN
04:00:35.921 --> 04:00:38.290
DIEGO AND WE ALL STRONGLY
04:00:38.357 --> 04:00:40.793
OPPOSE. TWENTY TWO SIX ONE
04:00:40.859 --> 04:00:49.034
THANK YOU. WE HAVE A COMMENT ON
04:00:49.101 --> 04:00:51.336
CURRENT APATHY PLEASE GO AHEAD.
04:00:51.403 --> 04:00:52.704
HI THIS IS ERIN APTIOM
04:00:52.771 --> 04:00:54.339
LEGISLATIVE COUNSEL WITH PUBLIC
04:00:54.406 --> 04:00:55.674
ADVOCATES AND WE STRONGLY
04:00:55.741 --> 04:00:58.110
OPPOSE AB TWENTY TWO SIXTY ONE
04:00:58.177 --> 04:01:04.216
THANK YOU. AND WE HAVE IT FROM
04:01:04.283 --> 04:01:05.918
DANIEL BECAUSE HERE THEY GO
04:01:05.984 --> 04:01:09.154
AHEAD. JANUARY CARRIED ON
04:01:09.221 --> 04:01:11.323
BEHALF OF THE CONSUMER
04:01:11.390 --> 04:01:11.890
FEDERATION OF CALIFORNIA IN
04:01:11.957 --> 04:01:20.232
OPPOSITION. IS THERE ANY
04:01:20.299 --> 04:01:22.100
FURTHER COMMENT PLEASE PRESS
04:01:22.167 --> 04:01:30.209
ONE FOLLOWED BY A LONG. AND WE
04:01:30.275 --> 04:01:31.810
HAVE A COMMENT FROM VANESSA A
04:01:31.877 --> 04:01:36.915
KILLING ME BY HAND. FIRST WITH
04:01:36.982 --> 04:01:39.484
YOUR DEDUCTIBLE IF YOU SEVEN.
04:01:39.551 --> 04:01:41.053
SACRAMENTO MOVE ON AND IF YOU
04:01:41.119 --> 04:01:42.988
FEEL YOU BOARD OF SACRAMENTO
04:01:43.055 --> 04:01:52.331
INSTRUCTORS A SHIP. ONE MOMENT
04:01:52.397 --> 04:02:04.109
WHILE THE NUMBER THANK YOU. AND
04:02:04.176 --> 04:02:04.743
WE HAVE A COMMENT FROM THE SHOW
04:02:04.810 --> 04:02:08.380
KILL. HI GOOD AFTERNOON MEMBERS
04:02:08.447 --> 04:02:10.115
PHYSICALLY SHALL GAIL CALLING
04:02:10.182 --> 04:02:11.350
ON BEHALF OF CALIFORNIA
04:02:11.416 --> 04:02:13.285
IMMIGRANT POLICY CENTER AND WE
04:02:13.352 --> 04:02:15.220
OPPOSE AB TWO TWO SIX ONE THANK
04:02:15.287 --> 04:02:24.263
YOU. AND THERE CLOCK ONE
04:02:24.329 --> 04:02:26.431
COMMENT THANK YOU. THANK YOU
04:02:26.498 --> 04:02:27.733
VERY MUCH TO EVERYONE WHO TOOK
04:02:27.799 --> 04:02:29.268
THE TIME TO CALL IN AND WILL
04:02:29.334 --> 04:02:31.770
NOW BRING IT BACK FOR QUESTIONS
04:02:31.837 --> 04:02:32.404
OR COMMENTS FROM MEMBERS OF THE
04:02:32.471 --> 04:02:34.673
COMMITTEE. WE WOMAN- WAY. THANK
04:02:34.740 --> 04:02:37.442
YOU- I WANT TO- COMMEND THE
04:02:37.509 --> 04:02:38.810
AUTHOR FOR TRYING TO PUT
04:02:38.877 --> 04:02:39.978
TOGETHER A PLAN MORE CARE
04:02:40.045 --> 04:02:41.313
REGULATORY FRAMEWORK WHICH I
04:02:41.380 --> 04:02:42.281
THINK IS OBVIOUSLY VERY VERY
04:02:42.347 --> 04:02:43.415
CRITICAL. THIS IS A NEWER
04:02:43.482 --> 04:02:44.917
TECHNOLOGY THAT THE DESPERATELY
04:02:44.983 --> 04:02:47.419
NEEDS- REGULATION. BUT YOU KNOW
04:02:47.486 --> 04:02:48.820
AS T'S WRITTEN WRITTEN TODAY I
04:02:48.887 --> 04:02:49.988
DON'T THINK THIS FRAMEWORK
04:02:50.055 --> 04:02:52.724
ADEQUATELY- PROTECTS CONSUMERS.
04:02:52.791 --> 04:02:54.526
PROTECTS OUR CONSTITUENTS- AND
04:02:54.593 --> 04:02:55.861
I PARTICULAR CONCERN ABOUT THE
04:02:55.928 --> 04:02:57.162
RACIAL BIAS CONCERNS THAT EVEN
04:02:57.229 --> 04:02:59.064
FLAG BY. OF THE OPPOSITION AND
04:02:59.131 --> 04:03:00.532
HOW THIS BILL WILL IMPACT BLACK
04:03:00.599 --> 04:03:01.400
AND BROWN COMMUNITIES IN
04:03:01.466 --> 04:03:03.268
PARTICULAR- I THINK THERE'S TOO
04:03:03.335 --> 04:03:04.369
MUCH LATITUDE THAT THE
04:03:04.436 --> 04:03:06.605
COMPANIES ARE GIVEN USE- FACIAL
04:03:06.672 --> 04:03:07.739
RECOGNITION TECHNOLOGY WITHIN
04:03:07.806 --> 04:03:10.943
THIS BILL- AND I'M CONCERNED
04:03:11.009 --> 04:03:11.643
ABOUT. HOW COMPANIES WILL
04:03:11.710 --> 04:03:14.579
DETERMINE PROBABLE COPS- AND
04:03:14.646 --> 04:03:16.715
THIS GIVES THEM TOO MUCH FREE
04:03:16.782 --> 04:03:17.282
REIGN AND SO I RESPECTFULLY.
04:03:17.349 --> 04:03:18.283
WILL NOT SUPPORTING THE BILL
04:03:18.350 --> 04:03:20.118
TODAY BUT- MY HOPE MISTER CHAIR
04:03:20.185 --> 04:03:21.486
THAT YOU CAN WORK WITH THE
04:03:21.553 --> 04:03:22.688
OPPOSITION TO TRY TO ALLEVIATE
04:03:22.754 --> 04:03:25.157
SOME OF THESE CONCERNS. YOU
04:03:25.223 --> 04:03:27.960
KNOW THE IT ARE ABLE. I THINK
04:03:28.026 --> 04:03:29.995
STRENGTH IN THE CONSUMER
04:03:30.062 --> 04:03:30.595
PROTECTION EASE OF THIS IDEA.
04:03:30.662 --> 04:03:33.398
DIFFERENT THE BUT AND I. DID
04:03:33.465 --> 04:03:35.534
MY- FOR THIS BILL I HAVE O.
04:03:35.600 --> 04:03:38.804
OPPOSE IT TODAY. SOMEONE ORDERS
04:03:38.870 --> 04:03:41.173
OVER. THANK YOU MISTER VICE
04:03:41.239 --> 04:03:43.075
CHAIR SO- MISTER CHAIRMAN I
04:03:43.141 --> 04:03:44.176
KNOW THIS IS AN AT THAT ISSUE
04:03:44.242 --> 04:03:45.243
THAT YOU'RE VERY PASSIONATE
04:03:45.310 --> 04:03:46.345
ABOUT IT'S AN ISSUE THIS
04:03:46.411 --> 04:03:47.579
COMMITTEE HAS BEEN GRAPPLING
04:03:47.646 --> 04:03:48.847
WITH OVER THE LAST COUPLE OF
04:03:48.914 --> 04:03:50.349
YEARS AND I THINK THE REASON
04:03:50.415 --> 04:03:51.750
WHY IT'S SUCH A DIFFICULT
04:03:51.817 --> 04:03:52.951
ISSUES THAT WE'RE DEALING WITH
04:03:53.018 --> 04:03:55.454
SOMETHING THAT- ISN'T
04:03:55.520 --> 04:03:57.689
INHERENTLY SOMETHING THAT WE
04:03:57.756 --> 04:04:01.059
KEEP PRIVATE. UNTIL WE ARE
04:04:01.126 --> 04:04:02.894
THINK ABOUT THE IMPLICATIONS OF
04:04:02.961 --> 04:04:04.129
HAVING THAT INFORMATION SHARED
04:04:04.196 --> 04:04:06.598
ON A MASS LEVEL SO YOU KNOW THE
04:04:06.665 --> 04:04:08.834
FACT THAT I RECOGNIZE YOUR FACE
04:04:08.900 --> 04:04:10.235
WILL BE SITTING HERE AND I CAN
04:04:10.302 --> 04:04:12.204
TELL MY WIFE- TONIGHT I RAN
04:04:12.270 --> 04:04:14.172
INTO CHECK OUT THE CAPITAL YOU
04:04:14.239 --> 04:04:15.807
KNOW THAT'S NOT A PIECE OF
04:04:15.874 --> 04:04:16.675
PRIVATE INFORMATION THAT I
04:04:16.742 --> 04:04:18.443
REVEALED ABOUT YOU BUT I'M WE
04:04:18.510 --> 04:04:20.178
EXPAND THAT TO BEING DONE
04:04:20.245 --> 04:04:22.014
MILLIONS MILLIONS OF TIMES A
04:04:22.080 --> 04:04:23.882
DAY- THROUGH AN AUTOMATED
04:04:23.949 --> 04:04:25.417
PROCESS IT RAISES SOME VERY
04:04:25.484 --> 04:04:27.853
TROUBLING ETHICAL CONCERNS SO I
04:04:27.919 --> 04:04:29.955
THINK THAT THAT'S WHY WERE
04:04:30.022 --> 04:04:30.956
GRAPPLING WITH THIS ISSUE.
04:04:31.023 --> 04:04:33.425
HOWEVER I ALSO THINK IT'S WORTH
04:04:33.492 --> 04:04:34.926
VISUAL RECOGNITION TECHNOLOGY
04:04:34.993 --> 04:04:39.865
IS ENABLING SOME. SOME BEHAVIOR
04:04:39.931 --> 04:04:42.200
THAT'S VERY BENEFICIAL TO ALL
04:04:42.267 --> 04:04:44.302
OF US HERE IN SOCIETY. AND I
04:04:44.369 --> 04:04:45.203
THINK IT'S IMPORTANT THAT WE
04:04:45.270 --> 04:04:46.471
ESTABLISH A REGULATORY
04:04:46.538 --> 04:04:49.307
FRAMEWORK THAT DOESN'T- DENY US
04:04:49.374 --> 04:04:50.976
THE BENEFITS OF THAT. AND
04:04:51.043 --> 04:04:52.044
UNFORTUNATELY THE BILL THAT YOU
04:04:52.110 --> 04:04:54.012
PUT TOGETHER HERE IT SEEMS TO
04:04:54.079 --> 04:04:56.648
ME IS NOT FOCUS SO MUCH ON. THE
04:04:56.715 --> 04:04:57.849
POTENTIAL ABSES OF THE
04:04:57.916 --> 04:05:00.052
TECHNOLOGY IS IT IS TRYING TO
04:05:00.118 --> 04:05:02.921
CHECK ALL THE BOXES ABOUT WHAT
04:05:02.988 --> 04:05:03.555
PEOPLE HAVE TO DO TO DEPLOY IT.
04:05:03.622 --> 04:05:04.189
I THINK WE BE BETTER SERVED IF
04:05:04.256 --> 04:05:06.892
WE JUST FOCUSED ON. THE PUT THE
04:05:06.958 --> 04:05:09.628
POTENTIAL ABUSES AND PASSED
04:05:09.694 --> 04:05:13.565
LEGISLATION TO CURBING THOSE.
04:05:13.632 --> 04:05:14.633
INSTEAD OF- ATTEMPT STABLE.
04:05:14.699 --> 04:05:18.770
WORK SPECIFICALLY BEEN ABOUT IN
04:05:18.837 --> 04:05:19.404
A GIVEN OUR CURRENT SITUATION.
04:05:19.471 --> 04:05:20.906
WITH RUN OF OUR- THAT THAT'S
04:05:20.972 --> 04:05:21.606
POTENTIALLY BY. USE OF THE-
04:05:21.673 --> 04:05:23.775
RIGHT THROUGH AND TRY WE'RE NOT
04:05:23.842 --> 04:05:24.709
QUITE THERE YET BUT YOU CAN SEE
04:05:24.776 --> 04:05:25.977
A TIME OF THE NOT SO DIFFERENT
04:05:26.044 --> 04:05:27.012
JUST A FUTURE WHERE YOU COULD
04:05:27.079 --> 04:05:30.115
USE. A PARTY TO TRACK AND
04:05:30.182 --> 04:05:32.584
TRACE- SUSPECTED CASES- I KNOW
04:05:32.651 --> 04:05:34.286
THAT I WOULD BE VERY INTERESTED
04:05:34.352 --> 04:05:36.021
IN KNOWING OF GETTING AN
04:05:36.088 --> 04:05:36.621
AUTOMATED REPORT THE TOLD ME.
04:05:36.688 --> 04:05:39.791
IF I HAD THE NEXT CORONAVIRUS.
04:05:39.858 --> 04:05:41.426
USE PAPER RECOGNITION HER. I
04:05:41.493 --> 04:05:43.195
WANT. DOES YOUR BILL PROHIBITS
04:05:43.261 --> 04:05:44.096
BEHAVIOR BECAUSE IT'S MY
04:05:44.162 --> 04:05:45.597
READING OF A SEEMS SEEMS IT
04:05:45.664 --> 04:05:51.970
DOES. ALL THE BILL ITSELF DOES
04:05:52.037 --> 04:05:54.973
NOT REALLY- PROHIBIT DOT PER SE
04:05:55.040 --> 04:06:00.679
OF I THINK- DE UM. ARCTIC DE
04:06:00.745 --> 04:06:03.081
ARE YOUNGER DEFERRED TO- VIA MY
04:06:03.148 --> 04:06:04.049
WITNESS ON THIS QUESTION AS
04:06:04.116 --> 04:06:07.018
WELL BUT- YOU KNOW THE WAITED I
04:06:07.085 --> 04:06:09.788
FORESEE IT IT DOES NOT- YOU
04:06:09.855 --> 04:06:11.490
KNOW I COULD NOT FIND A
04:06:11.556 --> 04:06:13.325
LANGUAGE- PERTAINING TO THAT
04:06:13.391 --> 04:06:14.926
PARTICULAR- YOU KNOW USE BUT
04:06:14.993 --> 04:06:16.027
BUT I DON'T THINK IT DOES I
04:06:16.094 --> 04:06:17.395
MEAN I THINK WOULD DEPEND ON
04:06:17.462 --> 04:06:20.265
THE SOURCE OF THE IMAGE THAT
04:06:20.332 --> 04:06:21.166
YOU'RE USING FOR FEDERAL
04:06:21.233 --> 04:06:23.168
RECOGNITION IF IT WAS A PROP
04:06:23.235 --> 04:06:24.636
BUT SOURCE YEAH THEN I. WOULD
04:06:24.703 --> 04:06:27.205
NEED TO DO I CAN. TO HAVE
04:06:27.272 --> 04:06:28.373
GENERALIZED YOU KNOW IF THEY
04:06:28.440 --> 04:06:29.941
DID HAVE THAT I WOULDN'T DO IT
04:06:30.008 --> 04:06:32.244
WOULD BE AN ILLEGAL USE OF
04:06:32.310 --> 04:06:34.646
CAUGHT GO HEAD TO HEAD YEAH YOU
04:06:34.713 --> 04:06:37.182
PUBLIC COURSE DE. WE NEED SOME
04:06:37.249 --> 04:06:39.417
KIND OF EVIDENCE FOR THE CRIME
04:06:39.484 --> 04:06:45.157
YOU'VE WRITTEN. THE WAIT IT IS.
04:06:45.223 --> 04:06:47.692
OUR IT IS THAT. YOU KNOW I.
04:06:47.759 --> 04:06:48.727
PEOPLE COULD. USE IT FOR.
04:06:48.793 --> 04:06:51.830
THAT'S UP A- IN THE PUBLIC. I
04:06:51.897 --> 04:06:54.633
AND DOT. ANY GOV IN WEBSITES
04:06:54.699 --> 04:07:00.071
ANY. A THAT'S OF A TO PUBLIC
04:07:00.138 --> 04:07:01.206
AND IF YOU KNOW I THINK I'M
04:07:01.273 --> 04:07:02.908
SOMETHING ABOUT THE CLEAR FEEL
04:07:02.974 --> 04:07:05.076
A AYE PARTICULAR SITUATION
04:07:05.143 --> 04:07:07.045
WHERE THEY WERE ACTUALLY
04:07:07.112 --> 04:07:09.981
PROVIDING IMAGES THAT WERE NOT
04:07:10.048 --> 04:07:11.683
ONLY IN THE PUBLIC BUT ALSO
04:07:11.750 --> 04:07:15.453
OBTAINED ARE BY AND- TRANSFER
04:07:15.520 --> 04:07:19.191
FROM AS A FACEBOOK. SO THE BILL
04:07:19.257 --> 04:07:22.127
AT IS AS IS IT IS WRITTEN AUG
04:07:22.194 --> 04:07:25.697
WILL ONLY ALLOW FOR THE
04:07:25.764 --> 04:07:27.632
RETENTION OF INFORMATION THAT'S
04:07:27.699 --> 04:07:31.069
UP IN THE PUBLIC DOMAIN. SO
04:07:31.136 --> 04:07:33.572
OBSOLETE SO THAT THAT IS YOU
04:07:33.638 --> 04:07:36.408
KNOW HOW THAT IS WORKING. OKAY
04:07:36.474 --> 04:07:38.343
SO YEAH IT'S MAKING SURE THAT
04:07:38.410 --> 04:07:41.346
THOSE RAN RIGHT IF I MIGHT JUMP
04:07:41.413 --> 04:07:42.113
IN THIS IS RIGHT HARKENS OF
04:07:42.180 --> 04:07:43.949
MICROSOFT I DON'T BELIEVE THE
04:07:44.015 --> 04:07:46.718
BILL WOULD. PROHIBIT THE USE OF
04:07:46.785 --> 04:07:47.986
FACIAL RECOGNITION TECHNOLOGY
04:07:48.053 --> 04:07:50.155
FOR THOSE SORT THE PURPOSES- IT
04:07:50.222 --> 04:07:52.057
IT YOU KNOW. BUT ON THE ONE
04:07:52.123 --> 04:07:56.061
HAND REQUIRE- CONSENT- IF A
04:07:56.127 --> 04:07:57.529
PRIVATE SOURCES INTENDING TO
04:07:57.596 --> 04:08:01.466
USE THE- TECHNOLOGY FOR THOSE
04:08:01.533 --> 04:08:03.868
KINDS OF PURPOSES. ON THE OTHER
04:08:03.935 --> 04:08:07.539
HAND- NOT UNLESS. A GOVERNMENT%
04:08:07.606 --> 04:08:11.409
AGENCY IS ENGAGING AND- ONGOING
04:08:11.476 --> 04:08:12.911
SURVEILLANCE THEY THEY WOULD
04:08:12.978 --> 04:08:15.947
NOT BE SUBJECT TO THE ONE
04:08:16.014 --> 04:08:19.751
FIREMAN. SO IT IT'S KIND OF
04:08:19.818 --> 04:08:21.386
SPLIT HAIRS BUT- I THINK IT'S
04:08:21.453 --> 04:08:23.488
AN IMPORTANT STATION THAT- THE
04:08:23.555 --> 04:08:25.423
FACT THAT I HAVEN'T GIVEN MY
04:08:25.490 --> 04:08:27.659
CONSENT UNTIL AFTER THE FACT
04:08:27.726 --> 04:08:28.860
YOU KNOW WHERE I SAID OKAY I
04:08:28.927 --> 04:08:30.262
WOULD LIKE I'M IN NOW
04:08:30.328 --> 04:08:32.063
INTERESTED IN. HAVING YOU CAN
04:08:32.130 --> 04:08:33.498
TRACE ME MEANS THAT GOTTA GO
04:08:33.565 --> 04:08:36.401
BACK AND ANALYZE ALL OF THE
04:08:36.468 --> 04:08:38.069
PLACES I MIGHT HAVE BEEN. AS A
04:08:38.136 --> 04:08:39.704
POOR TO YOU KNOW FORWARD
04:08:39.771 --> 04:08:42.774
PROCESS WHERE- WHERE YOU'RE
04:08:42.841 --> 04:08:45.043
ANALYZING IT AS GO AND THEN I
04:08:45.110 --> 04:08:47.746
SAY YES I LIKE TO OPEN THE
04:08:47.812 --> 04:08:50.181
XPOSED ANYWAY LET'S MOVE OUR
04:08:50.248 --> 04:08:50.715
FROM THAT BECAUSE I DON'T
04:08:50.782 --> 04:08:51.316
BELIEVE THE POINT BUT READING
04:08:51.383 --> 04:08:52.784
OF THE OF THAT THAT'S A PART.
04:08:52.851 --> 04:08:55.186
BETTER USE THAT MY READING THE
04:08:55.253 --> 04:08:59.858
BOOKS WITH A LAUGH YEAH THAT'S
04:08:59.924 --> 04:09:04.529
WHAT I MEAN THEY'RE PROBABLY.
04:09:04.596 --> 04:09:05.130
UNDER THE BENEFIT. IS WHERE.
04:09:05.196 --> 04:09:08.199
NEW THEM. SINCE BUT NEVER
04:09:08.266 --> 04:09:10.502
DEVELOP. WE'RE NOT. MISS IT OFF
04:09:10.568 --> 04:09:12.070
IN OUR APPROACH TO REGULATING.
04:09:12.137 --> 04:09:13.672
UP I HAVE A FALL QUESTION CARE
04:09:13.738 --> 04:09:16.474
ABOUT. A FEDERAL LAW. THERE WAS
04:09:16.541 --> 04:09:17.042
A CASE INTO. ELEVEN IN THE
04:09:17.108 --> 04:09:18.310
SUPREME. WHERE IT WAS IT WAS A-
04:09:18.376 --> 04:09:19.544
N. X. THAT. IT REGARD A RELATE
04:09:19.611 --> 04:09:21.413
TO THE- OF IN. THAT WAS
04:09:21.479 --> 04:09:24.516
COLLECTED BY A BUSINESS. AND
04:09:24.582 --> 04:09:26.685
THE SUPREME COURT RULED IN THAT
04:09:26.751 --> 04:09:30.221
CASE. THAT THAT INFORMATION WAS.
04:09:30.288 --> 04:09:32.324
OF MAN RUSSIAN OF FREE SPEECH
04:09:32.390 --> 04:09:33.725
COMMERCIAL FREE SPEECH. YEAH
04:09:33.792 --> 04:09:35.193
ND I AM AND IT WAS A PRETTY
04:09:35.260 --> 04:09:36.961
STARKLY WORDED DECISION AND I'M
04:09:37.028 --> 04:09:39.964
WONDERING HOW. THIS WOULD NOT
04:09:40.031 --> 04:09:41.566
BE FOUND TO BE UNCONSTITUTIONAL
04:09:41.633 --> 04:09:42.834
UNDER THAT DECISION BECAUSE
04:09:42.901 --> 04:09:45.203
PRETTY CLEARLY. IT IS S. AS
04:09:45.270 --> 04:09:46.504
REGARDS THE PART OF THE BILL
04:09:46.571 --> 04:09:47.839
THAT PUTS RESTRICTIONS ON WHAT
04:09:47.906 --> 04:09:49.107
BUSINESSES CAN DO WITH
04:09:49.174 --> 04:09:50.608
INFORMATION IS GATHERED ON
04:09:50.675 --> 04:09:52.577
THEIR PROMISED- PRETTY CLEARLY
04:09:52.644 --> 04:09:54.913
THAT WOULD FALL UNDER. THAT
04:09:54.979 --> 04:09:57.182
SAME CABIN INFORMATION NOT. I
04:09:57.248 --> 04:10:01.553
MR AGAINST AN ACID QUESTION.
04:10:01.619 --> 04:10:03.922
YEAH ASSEMBLY MEMBER THANK YOU
04:10:03.988 --> 04:10:04.556
FOR THE QUESTION I THINK YOU'RE
04:10:04.622 --> 04:10:05.990
REFERRING TO THE STORE OVER
04:10:06.057 --> 04:10:07.192
BECAUSE I AND THAT'S HEALTH
04:10:07.258 --> 04:10:10.628
RATED KATE- AND FOR A NUMBER OF
04:10:10.695 --> 04:10:13.865
REASONS- I THINK AT BEST YOU
04:10:13.932 --> 04:10:16.668
CAN SAY THAT THE IMPLICATIONS
04:10:16.735 --> 04:10:20.438
OF THAT CASE ON. ANY LAW THAT-REGULATES. THE COLLECTION AND
04:10:20.505 --> 04:10:21.973
USE OF DATA PRIVACY LAWS THAT
04:10:22.040 --> 04:10:25.643
THIS LAW. IT IS DEBATABLE. I DO
04:10:25.710 --> 04:10:27.979
NOT THINK THAT IT WOULD RENDER
04:10:28.046 --> 04:10:30.115
THIS PLOT WAR BUT PRIVACY LAWS
04:10:30.181 --> 04:10:32.016
MORE GENERALLY UNCONSTITUTIONAL
04:10:32.083 --> 04:10:34.352
FOR A NUMBER OF REASONS. AMONG
04:10:34.419 --> 04:10:36.254
OTHERS- JUSTICE KENNEDY IN THAT
04:10:36.321 --> 04:10:39.924
CASE. NOTED THAT THEY WERE NOT-
04:10:39.991 --> 04:10:43.027
RENDERING A DECISION AND- ADD
04:10:43.094 --> 04:10:44.963
TO THE POTENTIAL CONFLICT
04:10:45.029 --> 04:10:47.699
BETWEEN THE FIRST AMENDMENT-
04:10:47.766 --> 04:10:50.068
AND PRIVATE LAWS IN THE PAST
04:10:50.135 --> 04:10:53.905
THE TECH. LOGY TO- TO LACK
04:10:53.972 --> 04:10:56.574
INFORMATION ABOUT PEOPLE. THERE
04:10:56.641 --> 04:10:58.877
THAT NUMBER OTHER REASONS WHY I
04:10:58.943 --> 04:11:00.378
DON'T BELIEVE THAT THAT CASE
04:11:00.445 --> 04:11:03.281
WOULD. INVALIDATE THE PRIVACY
04:11:03.348 --> 04:11:07.051
LAWS OR- IN WITH WHICH WE CAN%
04:11:07.118 --> 04:11:09.053
GO INTO IF WE HAD MORE TIME.
04:11:09.120 --> 04:11:13.525
SURE YOU KNOW I WELL I THINK AT
04:11:13.591 --> 04:11:15.059
THE VERY LEAST. WE'LL THIS LAW
04:11:15.126 --> 04:11:15.693
WHAT IF IT PASSED FACED A
04:11:15.760 --> 04:11:17.762
CONCERT JAIL. AND I HAVE TO
04:11:17.829 --> 04:11:19.097
RESPECTFULLY DISAGREE I
04:11:19.164 --> 04:11:19.664
ACTUALLY THINK IT WOULD IT
04:11:19.731 --> 04:11:21.433
WOULD BE OVERTURNED. I FOR THE
04:11:21.499 --> 04:11:22.534
SAME REASONS BECAUSE WE'RE NOT
04:11:22.600 --> 04:11:23.635
TALKING ABOUT DATA THAT'S
04:11:23.701 --> 04:11:25.503
INHERENTLY PRIVATE WHEN I TALK
04:11:25.570 --> 04:11:26.871
ABOUT SOMEONE SOCIAL SECURITY
04:11:26.938 --> 04:11:28.239
NUMBER WE TALK ABOUT SOMEONE'S
04:11:28.306 --> 04:11:29.374
APPEARANCE WHICH IS SOMETHING
04:11:29.441 --> 04:11:30.508
THAT WE REVEAL TO EACH OTHER
04:11:30.575 --> 04:11:35.914
EVERY DAY. SO I SOME. OF WAS
04:11:35.980 --> 04:11:37.615
THERE. A BUT ONE WAY OR THE I
04:11:37.682 --> 04:11:38.349
WOULDN'T YOU TO COULD WORKING
04:11:38.416 --> 04:11:39.818
ON THIS IT'S ON SOMETHING THAT
04:11:39.884 --> 04:11:42.320
I CAN SUPPORT. TODAY I THINK
04:11:42.387 --> 04:11:43.455
IT'S AN INDICATION THAT YOU'VE
04:11:43.521 --> 04:11:45.190
GOT DISAGREEMENT FROM THE THINK
04:11:45.256 --> 04:11:46.458
YOU HAVEN'T GONE FAR ENOUGH.
04:11:46.524 --> 04:11:48.059
COMPARED AT THE SAME TIME
04:11:48.126 --> 04:11:49.360
YOU'VE GOT DISAGREEMENT THAT
04:11:49.427 --> 04:11:50.662
THAT. FROM PEOPLE THAT THINK
04:11:50.728 --> 04:11:51.663
YOU'VE GONE TOO FAR THAT MAYBE
04:11:51.729 --> 04:11:53.431
MEANS THAT YOU'RE ON THE RIGHT
04:11:53.498 --> 04:11:54.999
PATH- I JUST. I DON'T THINK IT
04:11:55.066 --> 04:11:56.367
NOW THE TIME TO MOVE FORWARD
04:11:56.434 --> 04:11:58.570
WITH THIS WHEN THE PERIOD OF
04:11:58.636 --> 04:12:00.338
REVIEW ON. THIS LEGISLATION HAS
04:12:00.405 --> 04:12:03.107
BEEN SHORTS ALL BE RESPECTFUL
04:12:03.174 --> 04:12:04.776
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU MUCH.
04:12:04.843 --> 04:12:09.948
SOME WOMEN WHAT. THANK YOU MISS
04:12:10.014 --> 04:12:12.417
FRAZIER- MISTER TEARS YOU KNOW
04:12:12.484 --> 04:12:15.487
I'M A SUBSTITUTE MEMBER ON THIS
04:12:15.553 --> 04:12:16.588
COMMITTEE TODAY AND I KNOW YOU
04:12:16.654 --> 04:12:18.189
WORK EXTENSIVELY ON THIS ISSUE
04:12:18.256 --> 04:12:19.824
SO I'M GOING TO VOTE TO MOVE
04:12:19.891 --> 04:12:21.559
THE BILL FORWARD BUT- I WOULD
04:12:21.626 --> 04:12:23.094
JUST CAUTION THAT GIVEN THE
04:12:23.161 --> 04:12:25.797
LEVEL OF A- OPPOSITION. THE
04:12:25.864 --> 04:12:27.365
BILL IN ITS CURRENT FORM WILL
04:12:27.432 --> 04:12:28.132
BECOME LAW SO I KNOW YOU'LL
04:12:28.199 --> 04:12:30.001
HAVE TO WORK- THIS ISSUE
04:12:30.068 --> 04:12:32.737
EXTENSIVELY IT'S AN EMERGING
04:12:32.804 --> 04:12:34.939
TECHNOLOGY THAT NEEDS- NEEDS
04:12:35.006 --> 04:12:38.209
LAW HE'S REGULATIONS SO I.
04:12:38.276 --> 04:12:39.210
APPLAUD YOU FOR ENGAGING. ISSUE
04:12:39.277 --> 04:12:41.813
BUT I KNOW THAT- GIVEN THE
04:12:41.880 --> 04:12:43.515
OPPOSITION- YOU'LL MOST
04:12:43.581 --> 04:12:47.519
CERTAINLY HAVE TO A WORK AT. IN
04:12:47.585 --> 04:12:49.687
A CONSIDERABLE WAY TO GET IT TO
04:12:49.754 --> 04:12:52.123
WHERE IT NEEDS TO BE BUT I WILL
04:12:52.190 --> 04:12:55.426
SUPPORT THE BILL. TODAY AT.
04:12:55.493 --> 04:12:58.296
SOME MEMBERS. THANK YOU VERY
04:12:58.363 --> 04:13:00.565
MUCH- TO A COUPLE OF QUESTIONS
04:13:00.632 --> 04:13:02.500
ON SOME OF THE DETAILS IN THE
04:13:02.567 --> 04:13:05.837
BILL- IT'S IS THAT WHEN THERE.
04:13:05.904 --> 04:13:07.605
OFFICIAL TECHNOLOGY THERE WILL
04:13:07.672 --> 04:13:09.908
BE IN COURT TO MEANINGFUL HUMAN
04:13:09.974 --> 04:13:11.609
REVIEW. WHAT WHAT IS OUR
04:13:11.676 --> 04:13:14.379
DEFINITION FOR WHAT MEANING FOR
04:13:14.445 --> 04:13:14.979
HUMAN REVIEW IS WHAT WHAT DOES
04:13:15.046 --> 04:13:18.149
THAT MEAN. OUR THAT MEANS IS
04:13:18.216 --> 04:13:19.517
THAT ANY DECISIONS THAT WOULD
04:13:19.584 --> 04:13:22.186
HI HOW THE LEGAL EFFECT ALL
04:13:22.253 --> 04:13:24.489
WHEN THE TECHNOLOGY IS SO BEING
04:13:24.556 --> 04:13:26.124
DEPLOYED. WOULD REQUIRE
04:13:26.190 --> 04:13:27.926
SOMEBODY WHO'S TRAINED AND HAS
04:13:27.992 --> 04:13:29.494
THE AUTHORITY TO MAKE THAT
04:13:29.561 --> 04:13:32.931
DECISION. TO THAT THAT. YOU
04:13:32.997 --> 04:13:34.132
KNOW THE AS FAR AS WHAT WHAT
04:13:34.198 --> 04:13:35.767
WOULD THAT MEAN BY LEGAL EFFECT
04:13:35.833 --> 04:13:37.569
OUT I THINK THAT'S A LIST OF
04:13:37.635 --> 04:13:38.903
OTHER THINGS THAT I TALKED
04:13:38.970 --> 04:13:40.872
ABOUT INCLUDING LENDING LAWS
04:13:40.939 --> 04:13:42.540
FOR EXAMPLE SOMEBODY WANTS TO-
04:13:42.607 --> 04:13:44.475
APPLY FOR A LOAN. HOUSING
04:13:44.542 --> 04:13:47.011
INSURANCE EDUCATION YES AND
04:13:47.078 --> 04:13:50.582
THAT. THE AND I DON'T MEAN IN
04:13:50.648 --> 04:13:51.716
BUT SO DID MY QUESTION IS ON
04:13:51.783 --> 04:13:53.551
THAT SIDE IT'S MORE THEY CAN
04:13:53.618 --> 04:13:56.020
REVIEWS SITE RIGHT WHO IS IT
04:13:56.087 --> 04:14:02.794
WHO. THIS YEAR THANK YOU TO BE.
04:14:02.860 --> 04:14:03.661
PRIVATE COMPANY THAT YOU THE
04:14:03.728 --> 04:14:05.663
FOR ARE. I MEAN WHO IS A LEFT
04:14:05.730 --> 04:14:07.565
TO OUR ANY STATE. THAT GOING TO
04:14:07.632 --> 04:14:08.232
BE A PLACE TO THE TERM WHAT
04:14:08.299 --> 04:14:09.567
THAT REVIEW MEANS BIG.
04:14:09.634 --> 04:14:11.002
MEANINGFUL THAN I AM BEHOLDER
04:14:11.069 --> 04:14:14.639
RIGHT AFTER. WELL THE YOU KNOW%
04:14:14.706 --> 04:14:16.507
THE LAW SAYS THAT YOU KNOW ANY
04:14:16.574 --> 04:14:18.776
DECISION REGARDING GET OUT OF
04:14:18.843 --> 04:14:20.011
THE ITEMS THAT I MENTIONED
04:14:20.078 --> 04:14:21.813
WOULD HAVE TO BE READ REVIEW BY
04:14:21.879 --> 04:14:26.484
A HUMAN BEING WE'VE BEEN TRYING
04:14:26.551 --> 04:14:27.919
AS TO WHO'S GONNA. GEN THEN NOT
04:14:27.986 --> 04:14:29.587
COMPANY WOULD HAVE TO MAKE THAT
04:14:29.654 --> 04:14:34.325
THE SELF. YEAH SOME MISTER
04:14:34.392 --> 04:14:35.793
CHAIRED BY THIS I'M SORRY IF I
04:14:35.860 --> 04:14:37.362
MIGHT THIS IS RYAN HARKENED
04:14:37.428 --> 04:14:40.031
AGAIN- I THINK YOU KNOW THAT
04:14:40.098 --> 04:14:42.634
THAT IS A DEFINED TERM IN THE
04:14:42.700 --> 04:14:45.637
BILL. AND IT DOES PROVIDE AS AS
04:14:45.703 --> 04:14:47.572
MISTER CHAIR OF NOTED THAT THAT
04:14:47.639 --> 04:14:49.040
THE IN AN INDIVIDUAL MUST BE
04:14:49.107 --> 04:14:51.342
TRAINED AND IT ALSO MUST BE
04:14:51.409 --> 04:14:52.076
SOMEONE WHO IS ULTIMATELY
04:14:52.143 --> 04:14:53.611
RESPONSIBLE FOR MAKING THE
04:14:53.678 --> 04:14:55.647
DECISION. SO IT AS BEST WE READ
04:14:55.713 --> 04:14:58.149
THAT ANYWAY EIGHT- I THINK THAT
04:14:58.216 --> 04:15:00.585
THE CLEAR INTENT IT IS THE
04:15:00.652 --> 04:15:02.920
INDICATE THAT YOU CAN'T JUST BE
04:15:02.987 --> 04:15:04.856
A LOW LEVEL EMPLOYEE WHO SIMPLY
04:15:04.922 --> 04:15:06.958
PUSHING A BUTTON OR OR MOVING
04:15:07.025 --> 04:15:09.827
PAPERS ACROSS HER DESK IT HAS
04:15:09.894 --> 04:15:11.796
TO BE SOMEONE. WITH AUTHORITY
04:15:11.863 --> 04:15:13.598
WITHIN THE ORGANIZATION TO
04:15:13.665 --> 04:15:14.866
RENDER THE DECISION AND SOMEONE
04:15:14.932 --> 04:15:16.401
FRANKLYWHO CAN CHANGE THE
04:15:16.467 --> 04:15:19.070
DECISION- YOU KNOW IT MAY BE
04:15:19.137 --> 04:15:21.239
THAT THERE IS THE NEED FOR
04:15:21.305 --> 04:15:22.674
ADDITIONAL. THE FLUSH OUT WHAT
04:15:22.740 --> 04:15:26.210
THAT IS- BUT WE THINK THAT THE
04:15:26.277 --> 04:15:27.679
CURRENT DEFINITION THE BILL IT
04:15:27.745 --> 04:15:30.415
IS A GOOD START- IN WOULD START
04:15:30.481 --> 04:15:31.749
TO. YOU KNOW PUT SOME
04:15:31.816 --> 04:15:33.751
RESTRICTIONS AROUND AN AREA
04:15:33.818 --> 04:15:37.188
WHERE THERE REALLY AREN'T
04:15:37.255 --> 04:15:38.723
RESTRICTIONS TODAY. THANK THANK
04:15:38.790 --> 04:15:40.458
YOU AND I GUESS YEAH MY CONCERN
04:15:40.525 --> 04:15:44.028
IS THAT. IT THE MOTIVATIONS
04:15:44.095 --> 04:15:45.463
BEHIND THAT HUMAN REVIEW THAT
04:15:45.530 --> 04:15:46.998
ARE CRITICALLY IMPORTANT RIGHT
04:15:47.065 --> 04:15:48.299
AND SO YOU KNOW HE JUST LEAVE
04:15:48.366 --> 04:15:52.570
IT TO THAT COMPANY. YOU KNOW IF
04:15:52.637 --> 04:15:53.638
THE COMPANY IS TELLING THAT
04:15:53.705 --> 04:15:55.339
PERSON HIGH LEVEL LOW LEVEL MID
04:15:55.406 --> 04:15:57.041
LEVEL WHATEVER TRAIN NOT
04:15:57.108 --> 04:15:59.844
TRAINED. YEAH DID TO IMPROVE
04:15:59.911 --> 04:16:02.046
USES THAT SHOULDN'T BE APPROVED
04:16:02.113 --> 04:16:05.249
THEN YOU HAVE A PROBLEM- AND SO
04:16:05.316 --> 04:16:05.917
I DO THINK THAT THIS IS AN AREA
04:16:05.983 --> 04:16:08.720
THAT THAT NEED MORE DEFINITION.
04:16:08.786 --> 04:16:11.322
THE BILL SHOULD THERE BE SOME
04:16:11.389 --> 04:16:14.525
BASE SO FOR. WHAT IN BECAUSE-
04:16:14.592 --> 04:16:15.893
NECESSARY FOR THE PROVISION OF
04:16:15.960 --> 04:16:17.595
THAT SERVICE. MEANS AND THIS IS
04:16:17.662 --> 04:16:20.131
KIND OF THE SAME ISSUE- WHERE
04:16:20.198 --> 04:16:21.966
YOU KNOW HE IS A PROBLEMATIC TO
04:16:22.033 --> 04:16:23.735
JUST LEAVE TO EACH BUSINESS. TO
04:16:23.801 --> 04:16:25.803
DECIDE WHAT IS. CAN QUOTE
04:16:25.870 --> 04:16:27.905
DIRECTLY NECESSARY FOR THE
04:16:27.972 --> 04:16:29.841
PROVISION OF THAT SERVICE. OR
04:16:29.907 --> 04:16:30.641
MAYBE THERE'S MORE DEFINITION
04:16:30.708 --> 04:16:32.910
THE BILL THAT THAT THAT I
04:16:32.977 --> 04:16:35.513
MISSED ALREADY. I THINK WHAT
04:16:35.580 --> 04:16:37.148
YOU'RE REFERRING TO IS- ONE OF
04:16:37.215 --> 04:16:38.683
THE AMENDMENTS THAT WE-
04:16:38.750 --> 04:16:42.153
CURRENTLY HAVE UNDER. I
04:16:42.220 --> 04:16:45.556
BELIEVE- SECTION THREE TEN E.
04:16:45.623 --> 04:16:48.426
ONE OR THEREABOUTS AND- MAYBE
04:16:48.493 --> 04:16:50.394
MAYBE THE BEST WAY TO TOOL-
04:16:50.461 --> 04:16:52.497
RESPONSE YOUR QUESTION IS- IT
04:16:52.563 --> 04:16:53.631
BY USING AN X. AN EXAMPLE FOR
04:16:53.698 --> 04:16:56.434
EXAMPLE- FOR EXAMPLE YOU HOW-
04:16:56.501 --> 04:16:59.170
SOMEBODY USING AND HOW. THAT
04:16:59.237 --> 04:17:02.874
WOULD. POSSIBLY CAPTURE THE
04:17:02.940 --> 04:17:05.710
IMAGE OF THE LAYER- SO THE
04:17:05.777 --> 04:17:10.248
LEVEL OF- CONSENT. IS REQUIRE
04:17:10.314 --> 04:17:11.816
AND THE BILL IN SUCH A WAY THAT
04:17:11.883 --> 04:17:13.718
GIVE GIVE THE GAME ITSELF IF
04:17:13.785 --> 04:17:15.486
THE APPLICATION ITSELF WHAT A
04:17:15.553 --> 04:17:17.789
REQUIRES. THE PERSON'S IMAGE TO
04:17:17.855 --> 04:17:19.624
BE CAPTURED AND THAT IS THE
04:17:19.690 --> 04:17:21.225
THAT IS THE CONSENT THAT DOES
04:17:21.292 --> 04:17:23.895
REQUIRE NOW HOW HOWEVER IF THAT
04:17:23.961 --> 04:17:25.396
PICTURE OF THE OF THAT IMAGE
04:17:25.463 --> 04:17:27.198
HAS TO BE USED FOR SOMETHING
04:17:27.265 --> 04:17:31.068
ELSE. OF THE ADULT SO. CONSENT
04:17:31.135 --> 04:17:34.138
WOULD BE NEEDED AS WELL NOW.
04:17:34.205 --> 04:17:38.743
THE ARE BUT IF YOU KNOW THE
04:17:38.810 --> 04:17:40.244
FACT THAT THE PERSON GIVES
04:17:40.311 --> 04:17:41.112
CONSENT FIRST TIME DOESN'T MEAN
04:17:41.179 --> 04:17:43.648
THAT YOU KNOW IF I CAN COULD BE
04:17:43.714 --> 04:17:45.249
FOR FURTHER DISSEMINATED TO A
04:17:45.316 --> 04:17:47.785
THIRD PERSON. SO IF THAT
04:17:47.852 --> 04:17:49.720
HAPPENS IN A SEPARATE TENTS AND
04:17:49.787 --> 04:17:52.757
WE REQUIRE. JOHN GOTCHA AN AID
04:17:52.824 --> 04:17:53.925
AGAIN THE KIND OF SOMEONE A
04:17:53.991 --> 04:17:54.759
LAST QUESTION MY CONCERN IS
04:17:54.826 --> 04:17:57.862
JUST. ANY BODY CAN JUSTIFY
04:17:57.929 --> 04:18:00.531
REASON TO USE ANYTHING- AND SO
04:18:00.598 --> 04:18:02.834
IF THERE ARE NO STANDARDS THERE
04:18:02.900 --> 04:18:05.436
FOR HOUSTON PERMISSIVE USES. OF
04:18:05.503 --> 04:18:06.370
THE YOU KNOW SOMETHING LIKE.
04:18:06.437 --> 04:18:07.605
DIRECTLY NECESSARY FOR THE
04:18:07.672 --> 04:18:08.573
VERSION OF THAT SERVICE IS SO
04:18:08.639 --> 04:18:12.009
VERY THAT THAT YEAH YOU CAN
04:18:12.076 --> 04:18:15.746
PROBABLY JUSTIFY ANY. DECISION
04:18:15.813 --> 04:18:18.182
YOU KNOW BASED ON ON THAT KIND
04:18:18.249 --> 04:18:19.483
OF A DESCRIPTION SO I THINK
04:18:19.550 --> 04:18:21.085
THAT THAT'S SOMETHING THAT
04:18:21.152 --> 04:18:22.420
NEEDS TO BE SIGNIFICANTLY
04:18:22.486 --> 04:18:25.189
TIGHTENED UP- AND THEN IT YOU
04:18:25.256 --> 04:18:28.326
KNOW I AGREE WITH THE CONCERNS
04:18:28.392 --> 04:18:31.896
AROUND- YOU KNOW. THIS
04:18:31.963 --> 04:18:34.498
TECHNOLOGY NOT BEING USED FOR
04:18:34.565 --> 04:18:38.236
NOT REINFORCING BIAS HE'S
04:18:38.302 --> 04:18:40.371
AROUND RACE AND GENDER AND AGE-
04:18:40.438 --> 04:18:41.706
SO I GUESS YEAH CAN YOU TELL ME
04:18:41.772 --> 04:18:42.406
A LITTLE BIT MORE ABOUT THE
04:18:42.473 --> 04:18:43.975
PROTECTIONS THAT ARE IN PLACE
04:18:44.041 --> 04:18:46.077
TO MAKE SURE. THAT THE USE OF
04:18:46.143 --> 04:18:47.578
THIS TECHNOLOGY ISN'T BIASED
04:18:47.645 --> 04:18:49.513
BASED ON- YOU KNOW THOSE
04:18:49.580 --> 04:18:52.049
FACTORS CHAIR I THINK THERE'S
04:18:52.116 --> 04:18:54.051
SEVERAL LEVELS OF PROTECTION IN
04:18:54.118 --> 04:18:55.820
THAT REGARD FIRST OF ALL OF THE
04:18:55.887 --> 04:18:58.823
LAW REQUIRES THE OF TESTING TO
04:18:58.890 --> 04:19:00.524
BE DONE THE TESTING HAS TO BE
04:19:00.591 --> 04:19:03.761
INDEPENDENT ARE. A WELL. MAKE
04:19:03.828 --> 04:19:08.766
SURE THAT OF. DE OF SUB GROUPS
04:19:08.833 --> 04:19:09.500
AND NOT BEING DISCRIMINATED
04:19:09.567 --> 04:19:11.636
AGAINST. OF YEAH WE ALSO
04:19:11.702 --> 04:19:13.938
PROVIDED THE THIS STANDARD AS
04:19:14.005 --> 04:19:15.506
AS I MENTIONED EARLIER. SO NOW
04:19:15.573 --> 04:19:18.542
PERSON- USING THE TECHNOLOGY
04:19:18.609 --> 04:19:21.078
WOULD HAVE. TO BASICALLY
04:19:21.145 --> 04:19:22.747
SUPPLIED THE WHAT THEY CALLED
04:19:22.813 --> 04:19:25.983
IN ON. THE API WHICH QUALITY
04:19:26.050 --> 04:19:26.851
APPLICATION PROGRAMMING
04:19:26.918 --> 04:19:29.687
INTERFACE. FOR AN INDEPENDENT
04:19:29.754 --> 04:19:32.089
PARTY TO VERIFY TO TELL US. AND
04:19:32.156 --> 04:19:34.425
IF THEY- IF THE TEST ACTUALLY
04:19:34.492 --> 04:19:36.861
COMPLIES WITH THE NEW STANDARD
04:19:36.928 --> 04:19:39.230
AND THERE OKAY. NOW ARE THAT'S
04:19:39.297 --> 04:19:41.899
ONE LEVEL OF SAFEGUARD THAT'S
04:19:41.966 --> 04:19:43.734
ON THE ON THE TESTING PART. NOW
04:19:43.801 --> 04:19:45.803
THE OTHER PART IS THAT. ON THE
04:19:45.870 --> 04:19:48.039
ENROLLMENT HE'S YOU KNOW BEFORE
04:19:48.105 --> 04:19:49.573
THE IMAGES- AND ROLLED INTO A
04:19:49.640 --> 04:19:51.509
DATABASE THAT A CONSENT YOU
04:19:51.575 --> 04:19:52.977
KNOW CONSENT WILL BE NEEDED AS
04:19:53.044 --> 04:19:56.047
WELL. SO THAT'S A SECOND. NOW
04:19:56.113 --> 04:19:59.417
THE PIECES THAT. WHEN IT COMES
04:19:59.483 --> 04:20:02.353
pTO SURVEILLANCE- EXAMPLE OF.
04:20:02.420 --> 04:20:04.555
YEAH THAT BE ALLOWED UNDER
04:20:04.622 --> 04:20:05.957
LIMITED SIR. THAT IS IF IT'S A
04:20:06.023 --> 04:20:08.059
SIN CRIME. AND ALSO IF THERE'S
04:20:08.125 --> 04:20:10.561
A WARRANT REQUIREMENT. BONTA AS
04:20:10.628 --> 04:20:12.163
WELL AS SET UP YOU KNOW THERE
04:20:12.229 --> 04:20:16.534
THERE'S ALSO THE- YOU KNOW THE
04:20:16.600 --> 04:20:17.868
PROVISION THAT WOULD PROHIBIT
04:20:17.935 --> 04:20:20.171
DISCRIMINATION ON THE FEDERAL
04:20:20.237 --> 04:20:28.512
AND STATE LAW. YEAH OKAY. I.
04:20:28.579 --> 04:20:30.414
I'M GONNA VERY BEGRUDGINGLY
04:20:30.481 --> 04:20:32.550
SUPPORT THIS TODAY TO GIVE YOU
04:20:32.616 --> 04:20:34.819
MORE TIME TO WORK ON A LOT OF
04:20:34.885 --> 04:20:36.387
THESE DETAILS WE GOT A LOT OF
04:20:36.454 --> 04:20:38.456
THIS VERY LATE AND DIDN'T HAVE
04:20:38.522 --> 04:20:39.357
A TON OF TIME TO WHAT YOU KNOW
04:20:39.423 --> 04:20:40.558
TO WORK WITH MY STAFF AND
04:20:40.624 --> 04:20:42.326
PERSONALLY REVIEW THINGS THIS
04:20:42.393 --> 04:20:43.627
IS AN IMPORTANT AREA WHERE
04:20:43.694 --> 04:20:45.329
THERE'S MINIMAL REGULATION
04:20:45.396 --> 04:20:47.231
EXISTING NOW AND SO I DO THINK
04:20:47.298 --> 04:20:49.100
SOMETHING NEEDS TO HAPPEN- I
04:20:49.166 --> 04:20:50.368
THINK A LOT OF THE CONCERNS
04:20:50.434 --> 04:20:52.303
THAT HAVE BEEN RAISED. BY BY
04:20:52.370 --> 04:20:54.572
GROUPS ALL OF THE SPECTRUM-
04:20:54.638 --> 04:20:55.973
YEAH THERE ARE SOME VALID
04:20:56.040 --> 04:21:01.012
CONCERNS THERE- AND SO ON I NO
04:21:01.078 --> 04:21:01.879
ONE'S. AND RESPECT YOU IN THE
04:21:01.946 --> 04:21:03.581
KNOW THAT YOU. YOU'RE WORK.
04:21:03.647 --> 04:21:05.016
WITH THESE ORGANIZATIONS I
04:21:05.082 --> 04:21:06.217
DON'T THINK THE ANSWER IS BEING
04:21:06.283 --> 04:21:07.318
THE TECHNOLOGY AND I DON'T
04:21:07.385 --> 04:21:08.786
THINK THE ANSWER IS NOTHING.
04:21:08.853 --> 04:21:09.887
AND SO WE NEED TO FIGURE OUT
04:21:09.954 --> 04:21:12.823
SOMETHING- BUT YOU KNOW THE GUY
04:21:12.890 --> 04:21:15.026
THERE'S A LOT OF WORK TO BE
04:21:15.092 --> 04:21:16.260
DONE I THINK TO FIGURE OUT WHAT
04:21:16.327 --> 04:21:17.762
THAT. WHAT THAT SWEET SPOT IS.
04:21:17.828 --> 04:21:21.499
OF EXPRESSED SOME OF MY- EARNS.
04:21:21.565 --> 04:21:24.268
THE OBVIOUS RESERVE. THE RIGHT
04:21:24.335 --> 04:21:25.703
TO. CHANGE THAT DECISION BASED
04:21:25.770 --> 04:21:28.105
ON HOW THIS GOAL PROGRESSES-
04:21:28.172 --> 04:21:29.740
BUT- I'LL BE WILLING TO GIVE
04:21:29.807 --> 04:21:32.109
YOU A- I COURTESY I'VE TODAY TO
04:21:32.176 --> 04:21:33.310
LET YOU KEEP WORKING ON THIS
04:21:33.377 --> 04:21:35.579
IMPORTANT ISSUE. I THANK YOU. A
04:21:35.646 --> 04:21:40.317
SOMEONE OR ONE. I THINK OF THAT
04:21:40.384 --> 04:21:47.425
WAS LIFELONG DAY CREATE NEW OF
04:21:47.491 --> 04:21:52.163
WORKING ON THE RIGHT OR.
04:21:52.229 --> 04:21:55.633
TECHNOLOGY WE'VE SEEN A LOT OF
04:21:55.699 --> 04:22:01.705
PRETTY EARLY. A LOT YEAR OR.
04:22:01.772 --> 04:22:15.486
LIKE THAT PRIVATE. AND RIGHT I
04:22:15.553 --> 04:22:20.491
HAVE BEEN SPEAKING. WHAT THEY-
04:22:20.558 --> 04:22:29.200
AND- RIGHT OR- THAT. WHILE I DO
04:22:29.266 --> 04:22:31.268
WANT TO SAY SOME THE RECENT AND
04:22:31.335 --> 04:22:39.276
THEN- ONE MORE. I CERTAINLY.
04:22:39.343 --> 04:22:43.747
FIVE AND OF YEAH WE WOULDN'T I
04:22:43.814 --> 04:22:49.053
THINK ONE LAW. FOR OKAY
04:22:49.120 --> 04:22:53.157
PROBABILITY YEAH OVERSIGHT BUT-
04:22:53.224 --> 04:22:55.092
SORRY. WE WANT WE WANT LAUNCH
04:22:55.159 --> 04:22:57.528
TO A PRO OKAY AND BUT WE ALSO
04:22:57.595 --> 04:22:59.997
DO NOT WANT TO HAMPER THEIR
04:23:00.064 --> 04:23:02.500
ABILITY TO SOLVE CRIMES AND SO
04:23:02.566 --> 04:23:04.368
I HOPE THAT YOU AS YOU MOVE
04:23:04.435 --> 04:23:07.371
FORWARD AND WORK WITH ALL THE-
04:23:07.438 --> 04:23:08.973
OPPOSITION ON THIS BILL THAT
04:23:09.039 --> 04:23:12.977
YOU TAKE THAT INTO ACCOUNT THE-
04:23:13.043 --> 04:23:15.679
FOR VICTIMS OF CRIMES. TO FOR
04:23:15.746 --> 04:23:18.115
THE POLICE NOT TO HAVE CERTAIN
04:23:18.182 --> 04:23:20.484
TOOLS I THINK. IS REALLY
04:23:20.551 --> 04:23:23.854
INAPPROPRIATE AND SO- I'VE I
04:23:23.921 --> 04:23:25.356
HOPE TO CONTINUE TO BE ABLE TO
04:23:25.422 --> 04:23:27.491
SUPPORT THIS ON THE FLOOR AND
04:23:27.558 --> 04:23:28.058
ALL BE SUPPORTING IT TODAY.
04:23:28.125 --> 04:23:34.465
THANK YOU. SOMEONE CREEL. THANK
04:23:34.532 --> 04:23:37.334
YOU TEST TEST THIS WORKING OKAY.
04:23:37.401 --> 04:23:39.503
THANK YOU- FIRST- ASSEMBLY
04:23:39.570 --> 04:23:40.571
MEMBER AND CHAIR OF THIS
04:23:40.638 --> 04:23:41.672
COMMITTEE I WANT TO THANK YOU
04:23:41.739 --> 04:23:43.207
FOR YOUR DILIGENT WORK ON THIS
04:23:43.274 --> 04:23:45.876
VERY SENSITIVE MATTER AS A YOUR
04:23:45.943 --> 04:23:48.078
EFFORT AND ALSO AN ENGAGING ALL
04:23:48.145 --> 04:23:50.281
OF THE STAKEHOLDERS- WE KNOW
04:23:50.347 --> 04:23:51.849
THAT CALIFORNIA HAS LED THE WAY
04:23:51.916 --> 04:23:53.150
WHEN IT COMES TO A LOT OF THIS
04:23:53.217 --> 04:23:55.419
TECHNOLOGY- AND IN DOING SO WAS
04:23:55.486 --> 04:23:58.155
ALSO. EMBRACE THIS EMERGING
04:23:58.222 --> 04:24:00.124
TECHNOLOGY IN THE REFORMS THAT
04:24:00.191 --> 04:24:01.959
GO ALONG SIDE OF THAT THOUGH I
04:24:02.026 --> 04:24:03.427
UNDERSTAND THE FUNDAMENTAL
04:24:03.494 --> 04:24:08.432
CONCERN REGARDING. YOUR LADY TO
04:24:08.499 --> 04:24:09.066
TWENTY TWO SIXTY ONE I WANT TO
04:24:09.133 --> 04:24:10.868
REMIND AND NOT GLOSS OVER
04:24:10.935 --> 04:24:12.169
SOMETHING THAT USE THAT YOU
04:24:12.236 --> 04:24:14.872
STATED WHEN YOU FIRST- BEGAN
04:24:14.939 --> 04:24:16.340
YOUR COMMENTS AND REMIND THIS
04:24:16.407 --> 04:24:18.375
COMMITTEE THOSE THAT ARE
04:24:18.442 --> 04:24:21.078
WATCHING- OR LISTENING. THAT
04:24:21.145 --> 04:24:23.914
YOU YOURSELF AS YOU STATED HAVE
04:24:23.981 --> 04:24:26.684
BEEN WRONGFULLY A RECOGNIZED BY
04:24:26.750 --> 04:24:29.653
THIS KIND OF TECHNOLOGY YOU ARE
04:24:29.720 --> 04:24:33.490
A LEADER WITHIN YOUR API
04:24:33.557 --> 04:24:34.124
COMMUNITY IN THE CHINESE UNIT.
04:24:34.191 --> 04:24:36.126
YOUR LEADER AMONG PEOPLE OF
04:24:36.193 --> 04:24:39.196
COLOR WHICH IS IMPACT THE MOST
04:24:39.263 --> 04:24:41.332
US WITH IN BY THE TESTIMONY IN
04:24:41.398 --> 04:24:45.936
OPPOSITION MY TRUCK. YOU CHAIR
04:24:46.003 --> 04:24:46.670
OF THE COMMITTEE HAVE DONE THE
04:24:46.737 --> 04:24:48.639
WORK NEFF. TO ENSURE THAT
04:24:48.706 --> 04:24:49.707
YOU'RE MOVING GOOD POLICY
04:24:49.773 --> 04:24:52.243
FORWARD THE FACT THAT YOU HAVE
04:24:52.309 --> 04:24:53.944
LAW ENFORCEMENT AND CIVIL
04:24:54.011 --> 04:24:54.578
RIGHTS GROUP BOTH IN
04:24:54.645 --> 04:24:56.914
OPPOSITION. LEADS ME TO BELIEVE
04:24:56.981 --> 04:24:58.816
ALSO THAT YOU'VE REACHED A
04:24:58.882 --> 04:24:59.783
MIDDLE GROUND WHERE NO ONE'S
04:24:59.850 --> 04:25:02.820
HAPPY- AND WE KNOW HERE THAT
04:25:02.886 --> 04:25:04.755
OFTEN TIMES. THAT'S THE RIGHT
04:25:04.822 --> 04:25:06.290
PLACE TO BE IN TERMS OF WHAT
04:25:06.357 --> 04:25:08.826
DETERMINES TO BE GOOD POLICY IN
04:25:08.892 --> 04:25:10.894
TERMS OF TRYING TO FIND. A
04:25:10.961 --> 04:25:13.130
MIDDLE GROUND SO I WILL BE
04:25:13.197 --> 04:25:15.599
SUPPORTING YOUR YOUR BILL TODAY
04:25:15.666 --> 04:25:18.435
I ALSO LOOK FORWARD TO THIS MY
04:25:18.502 --> 04:25:20.838
FIRST DAY ON THIS COMMITTEE. SO
04:25:20.904 --> 04:25:22.640
THIS IS THE BEEN INCREDIBLY AND
04:25:22.706 --> 04:25:24.508
LIGHTNING. AND ALSO TO SEE THE
04:25:24.575 --> 04:25:26.377
WAY THAT YOU HAVE MANAGE THE
04:25:26.443 --> 04:25:28.312
BILLS BEFORE IT BEFORE HAND.
04:25:28.379 --> 04:25:30.114
AND THI INCREDIBLY IMPACTFUL
04:25:30.180 --> 04:25:31.548
PIECE OF LEGISLATION THAT COULD
04:25:31.615 --> 04:25:32.816
REALLY SET THE TONE FOR THE
04:25:32.883 --> 04:25:34.018
STATE AND THE REST OF THE
04:25:34.084 --> 04:25:35.019
NATION WHEN IT COMES TO THIS
04:25:35.085 --> 04:25:37.121
EMERGING TECHNOLOGY. AND FACIAL
04:25:37.187 --> 04:25:39.123
RECOGNITION SO I WILL BE
04:25:39.189 --> 04:25:39.723
SUPPORTING THANK YOU THANK YOU
04:25:39.790 --> 04:25:45.963
MUCH. THANK YOU MISTER- AT CHAO
04:25:46.030 --> 04:25:48.132
AND I- I I'LL JUST SAY YOU KNOW
04:25:48.198 --> 04:25:49.733
A COUPLE YEARS AGO WE WORK
04:25:49.800 --> 04:25:51.869
TOGETHER ON A RESOLUTION THAT
04:25:51.935 --> 04:25:52.936
WAS SORT OF A FIRST ATTEMPT TO
04:25:53.003 --> 04:25:54.171
COME UP WITH A SET OF
04:25:54.238 --> 04:25:56.373
PRINCIPLES. ARE RELATED TO
04:25:56.440 --> 04:25:57.908
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE WHICH
04:25:57.975 --> 04:25:59.443
IS IN THE PROCESS OF.
04:25:59.510 --> 04:26:00.944
TRANSFORMING OUR WORLD AN
04:26:01.011 --> 04:26:02.946
EXTRAORDINARY AND REALLY
04:26:03.013 --> 04:26:05.549
UNIMAGINABLE WAYS. AND I WANT
04:26:05.616 --> 04:26:06.250
THE PRINCIPLES OF THAT
04:26:06.317 --> 04:26:07.618
RESOLUTION PASSES COMMITTEE
04:26:07.685 --> 04:26:09.053
PASSED THE ASSEMBLY AND THE
04:26:09.119 --> 04:26:10.854
SENATE- WAS HAVING AN ONGOING
04:26:10.921 --> 04:26:13.123
DIALOGUE WITH- POLICYMAKERS
04:26:13.190 --> 04:26:15.526
AROUND. A MERGING TECHNOLOGIES
04:26:15.592 --> 04:26:17.728
SO THAT WE COULD- ASSURE THAT
04:26:17.795 --> 04:26:19.363
THE BENEFITS ARE REALIZED AS
04:26:19.430 --> 04:26:20.864
MUCH AS POSSIBLE AND IS WIDELY
04:26:20.931 --> 04:26:21.999
SPREAD AS POSSIBLE SO THAT WE
04:26:22.066 --> 04:26:25.636
COULD. GET RISKS ARE INHERENT
04:26:25.703 --> 04:26:26.670
IN THE TECHNOLOGY AND ALSO SO
04:26:26.737 --> 04:26:28.706
THAT WE COULD- MAKE SURE THAT
04:26:28.772 --> 04:26:31.208
THERE IS A BACKLASH AGAINST NEW
04:26:31.275 --> 04:26:33.911
TECHNOLOGIES- THAT'LL ONLY
04:26:33.977 --> 04:26:37.481
ENTERS PROGRESS. ICE THIS BILL.
04:26:37.548 --> 04:26:38.882
RE BRINGING SOME OF THOSE TO
04:26:38.949 --> 04:26:40.784
THE FORE. AND OUT OF FACE. AND
04:26:40.851 --> 04:26:42.886
TECHNOLOGISTS VERY BEGINNING OF
04:26:42.953 --> 04:26:44.555
THE TECHNOLOGIES WERE WILL BE
04:26:44.621 --> 04:26:47.091
HAVING- THESE DEBATES. AND I
04:26:47.157 --> 04:26:49.626
THINK THAT. THE BALANCE YOUR
04:26:49.693 --> 04:26:51.962
STRIKING HERE. YOU KNOW IS
04:26:52.029 --> 04:26:53.864
OBVIOUSLY FAR FROM PERFECT BUT
04:26:53.931 --> 04:26:54.365
IS HEADING IN THE RIGHT
04:26:54.431 --> 04:26:57.334
DIRECTION SO- I AM. HAPPY TO
04:26:57.401 --> 04:26:59.470
SUPPORT. THE BILL TODAY I'LL
04:26:59.536 --> 04:27:01.438
JUST MENTION A FEW- ISSUES THAT
04:27:01.505 --> 04:27:02.673
OTHERS HAVE MENTIONED AS WELL I
04:27:02.740 --> 04:27:04.007
THINK THE LAW ENFORCEMENT ISSUE
04:27:04.074 --> 04:27:05.776
NEEDS TO BE ADDRESSED- I THINK
04:27:05.843 --> 04:27:08.946
THAT THAT. THE IDEA OF CONSENT-
04:27:09.012 --> 04:27:10.581
REALLY NEEDS TO BE FLESHED OUT
04:27:10.647 --> 04:27:11.615
A LITTLE BIT MORE AND ON THE
04:27:11.682 --> 04:27:12.950
GETS OLD ONLY GONNA BE WORKABLE
04:27:13.016 --> 04:27:14.084
FOR CONSUMERS TO HAVE TO GIVE
04:27:14.151 --> 04:27:15.519
AN INDIVIDUALIZED CONSENT TO
04:27:15.586 --> 04:27:17.154
EACH ESTABLISHMENT. AND WE'RE
04:27:17.221 --> 04:27:18.355
GONNA NEED I THINK A BETTER
04:27:18.422 --> 04:27:19.823
SOLUTION THERE AND THEN MORE
04:27:19.890 --> 04:27:21.692
BROADLY. THE QUESTION OF HOW
04:27:21.759 --> 04:27:24.228
THIS RELATES TO. LOCAL
04:27:24.294 --> 04:27:26.797
ORDINANCES OR REGULATIONS OTHER
04:27:26.864 --> 04:27:27.364
LEVELS OF GOVERNMENT I THINK
04:27:27.431 --> 04:27:28.532
NEEDS TO BE THOUGHT THROUGH A
04:27:28.599 --> 04:27:29.433
LITTLE BIT MORE MAYBE THERE ARE
04:27:29.500 --> 04:27:32.736
SOME ISSUES WHERE WE WANT TO
04:27:32.803 --> 04:27:34.671
HAVE. A STATE WHAT SORT OF
04:27:34.738 --> 04:27:37.574
ISLAM THAT'LL JURY OTHER STATES
04:27:37.641 --> 04:27:39.143
SIX. THEIR AREAS WE WANT TO
04:27:39.209 --> 04:27:40.677
HAVE UNIFORMS STAND AND IT'S
04:27:40.744 --> 04:27:47.684
NOT ENTIRELY TO ME WHETHER THE-
04:27:47.751 --> 04:27:50.020
JUST THAT WOULD THAT THOSE BE
04:27:50.087 --> 04:27:51.955
IN MIND IS FORWARD. AND I AM
04:27:52.022 --> 04:27:56.994
NOT PETER MOVED. BECAUSE THANK
04:27:57.060 --> 04:27:58.762
YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH EL
04:27:58.829 --> 04:28:00.931
MEMBERS UP FOR FALL IMMEDIATELY
04:28:00.998 --> 04:28:03.934
ME. EXCEL THE AMENDMENTS-
04:28:04.001 --> 04:28:06.069
TODAY- AND ALSO I WANT TO RELAY
04:28:06.136 --> 04:28:07.604
A MESSAGE FROM THE LA COUNTY
04:28:07.671 --> 04:28:09.506
REGIONAL IDENTIFICATION SYSTEM
04:28:09.573 --> 04:28:11.208
OF THAT HAS BEEN CONVEYED TO ME
04:28:11.275 --> 04:28:13.377
EARLIER ON IT SAYS OUR OFFICE
04:28:13.444 --> 04:28:15.112
AS AN INITIAL POSITIVE VIEW OF
04:28:15.179 --> 04:28:18.248
THE BILL- FROM THE LA COUNTY HI
04:28:18.315 --> 04:28:19.783
DE IDENTIFICATIONSYSTEM JUST
04:28:19.850 --> 04:28:21.385
FOR IT TO. COMMITTEES
04:28:21.452 --> 04:28:24.188
INFORMATION SO THANK YOU VERY
04:28:24.254 --> 04:28:25.989
MUCH FOR ALLOWING ME TO CLOSE-
04:28:26.056 --> 04:28:27.758
SO I LIKE TO CLOSE TODAY'S
04:28:27.825 --> 04:28:29.626
DISCUSSION WITH A LITTLE
04:28:29.693 --> 04:28:33.263
HISTORICAL CONTACTS. UP IN TWO
04:28:33.330 --> 04:28:34.865
THOUSAND ONE ON THEN SENATOR
04:28:34.932 --> 04:28:37.501
DEBORAH BOWL AND AUTHOR SP ONE
04:28:37.568 --> 04:28:39.236
SIXTY NINE. A BILL THAT
04:28:39.303 --> 04:28:41.438
INTENDED TO RESTRICT THE USE OF
04:28:41.505 --> 04:28:43.240
FACIAL RECOGNITION TECHNOLOGY
04:28:43.307 --> 04:28:44.641
IN ORDER TO PROTECT THE
04:28:44.708 --> 04:28:47.144
PERSONAL PRIVACY AND THE
04:28:47.211 --> 04:28:48.378
SECURITY OF THE COLLECTED DATA.
04:28:48.445 --> 04:28:50.380
THAT BILL IS REFLECTED IN THE
04:28:50.447 --> 04:28:52.683
ASSEMBLY JUDICIARY ANALYSIS AT
04:28:52.749 --> 04:28:54.318
THE TIME. WOULD HAVE PROHIBITED
04:28:54.384 --> 04:28:56.186
GOVERNMENT AGENCIES FROM AMONG
04:28:56.253 --> 04:28:57.454
OTHER THINGS COLLECTING OR
04:28:57.521 --> 04:28:59.690
USING BIOMETRIC. INFORMATION
04:28:59.756 --> 04:29:01.091
OBTAINED FROM A USER FISH
04:29:01.158 --> 04:29:03.193
CONDITION TECHNOLOGY. IT
04:29:03.260 --> 04:29:04.328
ACCEPTED LAW ENFORCEMENT
04:29:04.394 --> 04:29:05.996
AGENCIES WHEN ACTING PURSUANT
04:29:06.063 --> 04:29:08.398
TO A WARRANT. AND AUTHORIZE LAW
04:29:08.465 --> 04:29:09.566
ENFORCEMENT TO SHARE THE
04:29:09.633 --> 04:29:10.100
INFORMATION WITH SPECIFIC
04:29:10.167 --> 04:29:12.703
INFORMATION WITHOUT WHO NEED
04:29:12.769 --> 04:29:13.904
ACCESS TO THE INFORMATION FOR
04:29:13.971 --> 04:29:16.073
PURPOSES OF THE PROSECUTION OR
04:29:16.139 --> 04:29:19.009
DEFENSE OF A CRIMINAL CASE. A
04:29:19.076 --> 04:29:19.943
FURTHER THE MEASURE WOULD HAVE
04:29:20.010 --> 04:29:21.612
PERMITTED PRIVATE ENTITIES TO
04:29:21.678 --> 04:29:22.646
USE FACIAL RECOGNITION
04:29:22.713 --> 04:29:24.915
TECHNOLOGY IN SITUATIONS WHERE
04:29:24.982 --> 04:29:26.016
A CONSUMER INITIATES A
04:29:26.083 --> 04:29:27.417
TRANSACTION AND THAT CONSUMER
04:29:27.484 --> 04:29:29.319
CONSENT TO THE USE OF THE
04:29:29.386 --> 04:29:31.321
TECHNOLOGY. IN ALL OTHER CASES
04:29:31.388 --> 04:29:34.324
BUSINESSES COULD HOW. COULD
04:29:34.391 --> 04:29:36.193
ONLY COLLECT BIOMETRIC
04:29:36.260 --> 04:29:37.528
IDENTIFIER INFORMATION AND
04:29:37.594 --> 04:29:39.763
ATTEMPT TO IDENTIFY AND USING
04:29:39.830 --> 04:29:42.900
FACIAL RECOGNITION WHEN IT IS
04:29:42.966 --> 04:29:43.467
REASONABLY NECESSARY TO MAKE
04:29:43.534 --> 04:29:46.803
PUBLIC SAFETY. OR TO PROTECT
04:29:46.870 --> 04:29:49.973
AGAINST A VOTE OF LAW AND WHEN
04:29:50.040 --> 04:29:52.509
SINCE AS PER TO AND CAN SPEAK
04:29:52.576 --> 04:29:54.311
NOTED THAT THE FROM IS
04:29:54.378 --> 04:29:57.347
COLLECTED. FINAL BILL ALL
04:29:57.414 --> 04:29:58.749
RESTRICTED THE IN BUSINESSES
04:29:58.815 --> 04:30:00.183
MAY SELL OR SHARE INFORMATION
04:30:00.250 --> 04:30:01.585
AND INTO TO BE. WHETHER Y.
04:30:01.652 --> 04:30:04.221
SECURE UNDER ACCESS. OF FINALLY
04:30:04.288 --> 04:30:05.923
IT ALSO THE MEASURE AND POSE
04:30:05.989 --> 04:30:09.126
VARYING CIVIL- PENALTIES. IN
04:30:09.192 --> 04:30:10.460
SUPPORT OF THE BILL WERE GROUPS
04:30:10.527 --> 04:30:12.396
LIKE THE ACLU AND THE PRIVACY
04:30:12.462 --> 04:30:14.731
RIGHTS CLEARING HOUSE TODAY
04:30:14.798 --> 04:30:15.732
SOME OF THESE GROUPS CALL MY
04:30:15.799 --> 04:30:18.402
BILL MISGUIDED AND DANGEROUS-
04:30:18.468 --> 04:30:20.370
WHICH IS ALSO AN IMPEDIMENT
04:30:20.437 --> 04:30:21.838
FORCED TO RETURN TO A SAFE AND
04:30:21.905 --> 04:30:25.042
FREE SOCIETY. I'M LAST YEAR
04:30:25.108 --> 04:30:27.611
WHEN I AUTHOR A. B. TWELVE
04:30:27.678 --> 04:30:28.712
EIGHTY ONE WHICH WOULD SIMPLY
04:30:28.779 --> 04:30:30.581
REQUIRED BUSINESS TO DISCLOSE
04:30:30.647 --> 04:30:31.615
WHEN THEY'RE USING FACIAL
04:30:31.682 --> 04:30:33.850
RECOGNITION TECHNOLOGY SIMILAR
04:30:33.917 --> 04:30:36.353
TO SB ONE SIXTY NINE THE ACLU
04:30:36.420 --> 04:30:38.088
AND THE PRIVACY RIGHTS
04:30:38.155 --> 04:30:41.124
CLEARINGHOUSE ALSO POSTED. IN
04:30:41.191 --> 04:30:42.426
TWO THOUSAND ONE THE ACLU ROLE
04:30:42.492 --> 04:30:46.129
IN SUPPORT OF THAT BILL SB ONE
04:30:46.196 --> 04:30:47.664
SIXTY NINE AND A QUOTE HERE. WE
04:30:47.731 --> 04:30:49.499
ARE ENTERING AN ERROR WITH
04:30:49.566 --> 04:30:51.301
TECHNOLOGY IS OUTPACING I'LL
04:30:51.368 --> 04:30:53.804
BASIC PRIVACY RIGHTS. FURTHER
04:30:53.870 --> 04:30:55.606
BETWEEN HIGH TECH COMPANIES AND
04:30:55.672 --> 04:30:56.940
THE GOVERNMENT THERE IS A HUGE
04:30:57.007 --> 04:30:59.710
AMOUNT OF MONEY TO BE MADE. AND
04:30:59.776 --> 04:31:00.310
A HUGE AMOUNT OF PRIVACY TO BE
04:31:00.377 --> 04:31:02.646
LOST. A GOVERNMENT LESS
04:31:02.713 --> 04:31:03.914
EXERCISE SOME CONTROL OVER
04:31:03.981 --> 04:31:06.216
THERE THE RAPIDLY DE DEVELOPING
04:31:06.283 --> 04:31:08.151
USE OF- SOPHISTICATED FACE
04:31:08.218 --> 04:31:09.987
IDENTIFICATION SYSTEMS BEFORE
04:31:10.053 --> 04:31:11.655
BECOME A SOCIETY UNDER CONSTANT
04:31:11.722 --> 04:31:13.957
SURVEILLANCE. IT HAS BEEN
04:31:14.024 --> 04:31:15.459
ALMOST TWENTY YEARS SINCE THAT
04:31:15.525 --> 04:31:17.995
LEGISLATION FAILED PASSAGE
04:31:18.061 --> 04:31:19.763
DESPITE HAVING THE SUPPORT OF
04:31:19.830 --> 04:31:22.299
SOME OF THE VERY SAME GROUPS
04:31:22.366 --> 04:31:22.899
THAT ARE IN OPPOSITION BY BILL
04:31:22.966 --> 04:31:27.037
TODAY. AND I WILL NOTE THAT SB
04:31:27.104 --> 04:31:28.705
ONE SIXTY NINE WAS PRE NINE
04:31:28.772 --> 04:31:29.706
ELEVEN AND THAT SINCE THEN SOME
04:31:29.773 --> 04:31:31.475
OF THESE GROUPS HAVE
04:31:31.541 --> 04:31:33.310
REPOSITIONED THEIR STANCE. I
04:31:33.377 --> 04:31:34.578
WOULD ALSO NOTE THAT INCOME IN
04:31:34.645 --> 04:31:35.612
ACCORDANCE WITH THE CURRENT
04:31:35.679 --> 04:31:37.447
STANCE AB ONE SIXTY NINE
04:31:37.514 --> 04:31:38.982
PROHIBIT THE USE OF FACIAL
04:31:39.049 --> 04:31:40.117
RECOGNITION BY GOVERNMENT
04:31:40.183 --> 04:31:42.653
ENTITIES. HOWEVER THE
04:31:42.719 --> 04:31:43.820
OPPOSITION ADMITS TODAY AND
04:31:43.887 --> 04:31:46.523
THEIR LETTER. TO THIS BILL AND
04:31:46.590 --> 04:31:48.358
I QUOTE THAT EIGHT ICE IS
04:31:48.425 --> 04:31:49.793
TAKING ADVANTAGE OF STATE AND
04:31:49.860 --> 04:31:51.628
PRIVATE FACIAL RECOGNITION
04:31:51.695 --> 04:31:53.597
SYSTEMS THE TARGET IMMIGRANTS
04:31:53.664 --> 04:31:54.998
POLICE HAVE USED IT TO TARGET
04:31:55.065 --> 04:31:56.967
PEOPLE OF COLOR GOVERNMENTS ARE
04:31:57.034 --> 04:31:59.403
USING IT TO A PRESS RELIGIOUS
04:31:59.469 --> 04:32:01.004
MINORITIES AND DISCOURAGE FREE
04:32:01.071 --> 04:32:03.607
EXPRESSION. THIS MEANS THAT THE
04:32:03.674 --> 04:32:04.474
INTEGRATION OF FACIAL
04:32:04.541 --> 04:32:06.476
RECOGNITION TECHNOLOGY OUR
04:32:06.543 --> 04:32:08.211
EVERYDAY LIVES HAS PERSISTED
04:32:08.278 --> 04:32:10.347
OVER A SPAN OF TWENTY YEARS BY
04:32:10.414 --> 04:32:11.882
BOTH PRIVATE AND GOVERNMENT
04:32:11.948 --> 04:32:14.051
ACTORS. LAST YEAR CALIFORNIA
04:32:14.117 --> 04:32:15.552
TOOK AN IMPORTANT STEP TO
04:32:15.619 --> 04:32:16.953
ADDRESS THE USE OF F. R. T. AND
04:32:17.020 --> 04:32:20.157
LIMITED CIRCUMSTANCES LIKE BODY
04:32:20.223 --> 04:32:20.757
ONE CAMERAS WITH A THREE YEAR
04:32:20.824 --> 04:32:22.492
MORATORIUM. SO WHAT HAPPENS
04:32:22.559 --> 04:32:24.094
AFTER THREE YEARS IF WE DO
04:32:24.161 --> 04:32:25.996
NOTHING HERE TODAY. IN A
04:32:26.063 --> 04:32:27.230
COMPREHENSIVE WAY AS WAS THE
04:32:27.297 --> 04:32:29.032
CASE ALMOST TWENTY YEARS AGO IT
04:32:29.099 --> 04:32:30.033
WILL BECOME INCREASINGLY
04:32:30.100 --> 04:32:32.035
COSTLY. AND DIFFICULT TO
04:32:32.102 --> 04:32:33.136
IMPLEMENT THESE REGULATIONS
04:32:33.203 --> 04:32:34.905
SINCE MORE ENTITIES WILL HAVE
04:32:34.971 --> 04:32:36.606
DEVELOPED FRT INFRASTRUCTURES
04:32:36.673 --> 04:32:38.942
WITHOUT CONSIDERATION FOR THESE
04:32:39.009 --> 04:32:40.944
COMMENTS FOR THESE LIMITS. DO
04:32:41.011 --> 04:32:42.245
WE WANT TO WAIT ANOTHER TWENTY
04:32:42.312 --> 04:32:44.848
YEARS UNTIL IT IS TOO LATE ONLY
04:32:44.915 --> 04:32:45.849
TO LOOK BACK TO THIS DAY IS A
04:32:45.916 --> 04:32:47.684
TIME. WHERE WE COULD HAVE DONE
04:32:47.751 --> 04:32:49.186
SOMETHING TO CONTROL THE FATE
04:32:49.252 --> 04:32:51.021
OF OUR FUTURE AS IT RELATES TO
04:32:51.088 --> 04:32:52.756
THE TECHNOLOGY. I'M NOT WILLING
04:32:52.823 --> 04:32:55.992
TO WAIT AND WE CAN ACT NOW TO
04:32:56.059 --> 04:32:59.896
FINISH THE WORK. THAT'S THE WE
04:32:59.963 --> 04:33:02.332
STARTED WITH THE SP ONE SIX
04:33:02.399 --> 04:33:02.799
NINE AND WE CAN DO IT
04:33:02.866 --> 04:33:05.035
COLLECTIVELY SO WITHOUT I ASK
04:33:05.102 --> 04:33:08.038
FOR YOUR IBM. MOTION IS IT DO
04:33:08.105 --> 04:33:09.339
PASSED APPROPRIATIONS MONTHS
04:33:09.406 --> 04:33:15.846
AFTER IT WAS CALLED. I THINK WE
04:33:15.912 --> 04:33:16.379
HAVE A SECOND FROM SOMEONE
04:33:16.446 --> 04:33:21.651
CARILLO. THE MOTION IS TO PASS
04:33:21.718 --> 04:33:24.054
AS AMENDED TO APPROPRIATIONS.
04:33:24.121 --> 04:33:27.724
CHAO HI CHAO AYE KILEY AYE
04:33:27.791 --> 04:33:31.461
KILEY AYE OUR QUE HAN. THERE
04:33:31.528 --> 04:33:36.767
CAN NO BERMAN. BERMAN I MEDINA.
04:33:36.833 --> 04:33:42.072
MEDINA I CARILLO CREEL I MULLIN.
04:33:42.139 --> 04:33:47.077
MULLIN I GALLAGHER. IRWIN FIVE
04:33:47.144 --> 04:33:49.913
IRWIN I OBERNOLTE OBERNOLTE NO
04:33:49.980 --> 04:33:53.850
WICKS NOW WORKS NOW. THE BILL
04:33:53.917 --> 04:33:56.553
IS OUT WE HAVE A SECOND BILL
04:33:56.620 --> 04:34:01.825
FROM MR CHOW AT THIS IS A BE
04:34:01.892 --> 04:34:02.392
TWO THREE TWO ZERO THANK YOU
04:34:02.459 --> 04:34:03.593
VERY MUCH MISS CHAIR AND I HOPE
04:34:03.660 --> 04:34:05.796
THIS WILL BE A LITTLE EASIER
04:34:05.862 --> 04:34:08.098
FOR BOTH OF YOU. AB TWENTY
04:34:08.165 --> 04:34:08.865
THREE TO WOULD REQUIRE THAT
04:34:08.932 --> 04:34:10.367
CONTRACTORS DOING BUSINESS WITH
04:34:10.433 --> 04:34:11.968
A STATE AGENCY TO MAINTAIN
04:34:12.035 --> 04:34:13.670
CYBER INSURANCE. IF THE
04:34:13.737 --> 04:34:15.338
CONTRACTOR RECEIVES OR HOUSE
04:34:15.405 --> 04:34:17.140
ACCESS TO RECORDS CONTAINING
04:34:17.207 --> 04:34:18.975
PERSONAL INFORMATION. THE
04:34:19.042 --> 04:34:20.610
CONTRACTING STATE AGENCY WOULD
04:34:20.677 --> 04:34:21.878
DETERMINE THE LEVEL OF CYBER
04:34:21.945 --> 04:34:23.280
INSURANCE SUFFICIENT TO COVER
04:34:23.346 --> 04:34:25.649
LOSSES RESULTING FROM A CYBER
04:34:25.715 --> 04:34:27.884
SECURITY BREACH. IN RECENT
04:34:27.951 --> 04:34:29.085
YEARS SO WE HAVE SEEN CYBER
04:34:29.152 --> 04:34:30.453
ATTACKS AND DATA BREACHES SO
04:34:30.520 --> 04:34:32.589
SKYROCKETED. MANY OF US HAVE
04:34:32.656 --> 04:34:34.491
HEARD OF THE HACKING INCIDENT
04:34:34.558 --> 04:34:35.959
ON THE OFFICE OF PERSONNEL
04:34:36.026 --> 04:34:37.994
MANAGEMENT OPM IN TWENTY
04:34:38.061 --> 04:34:38.762
FIFTEEN WHERE THE SENSITIVE
04:34:38.829 --> 04:34:40.564
INFORMATION. OF TWENTY ONE
04:34:40.630 --> 04:34:43.266
MILLION AMERICANS WAS EXPOSED.
04:34:43.333 --> 04:34:44.668
THESE PEOPLE WERE AWAITING
04:34:44.734 --> 04:34:46.102
THEIR BACKGROUND CHECKS. SINCE
04:34:46.169 --> 04:34:47.137
THE COVER NINETEENTH ENDEMIC
04:34:47.204 --> 04:34:48.672
HIT TE CYBERATTACKS INCREASE
04:34:48.738 --> 04:34:50.240
OVER SIX HUNDRED PERCENT.
04:34:50.307 --> 04:34:51.474
HOSPITALS WERE HIT BY
04:34:51.541 --> 04:34:53.543
RANSOMWARE ATTACKS AND BREACHES
04:34:53.610 --> 04:34:55.045
AFFECTING TE LAB TESTING OF
04:34:55.111 --> 04:34:56.680
THE VIRUS. BY LIKING- STAFF
04:34:56.746 --> 04:34:58.215
FROM DATA INPUT PATIENT
04:34:58.281 --> 04:35:00.317
INFORMATION. DRUG DOSAGE HAVING
04:35:00.383 --> 04:35:02.052
BEEN STOLEN AND DELAY IN
04:35:02.118 --> 04:35:04.521
PROVIDING. CRITICAL CARE EVEN
04:35:04.588 --> 04:35:06.089
LEADING TO DOUBTS. STATE
04:35:06.156 --> 04:35:07.891
AGENCIES ARE JUST AS VULNERABLE
04:35:07.958 --> 04:35:09.593
FOR EXAMPLE WITHIN THE LAST TWO
04:35:09.659 --> 04:35:10.927
THREE YEARS CYBER CRIMINALS
04:35:10.994 --> 04:35:12.829
ALSO HIT ON THE CALIFORNIA MEN
04:35:12.896 --> 04:35:13.930
OF FOOD AND AGRICULTURE. PUBLIC
04:35:13.997 --> 04:35:18.335
HEALTH DEPARTMENT- OF- FISH AND
04:35:18.401 --> 04:35:19.736
WILDLIFE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE-
04:35:19.803 --> 04:35:22.439
AND ALSO SOME OF THE YOU SEE
04:35:22.505 --> 04:35:25.442
AND CAL STATE CAMPUSES AND-
04:35:25.508 --> 04:35:26.810
LIKE BAKER BILL A BILL BECAUSE
04:35:26.877 --> 04:35:30.680
IT. ARE OUR- SORRY. THE LIST
04:35:30.747 --> 04:35:32.515
GOES ON. THESE IT IT REACHES
04:35:32.582 --> 04:35:33.283
ALL DESIGNED TO DISRUPT AN
04:35:33.350 --> 04:35:34.084
ORGAN BILL AND THEY COME IN
04:35:34.150 --> 04:35:36.052
FORMS LIKE MAILLET A RANSOM
04:35:36.119 --> 04:35:37.487
DENIAL O SERVICE WITH
04:35:37.554 --> 04:35:38.989
OBJECTIVES TO COMPROMISE THEIR
04:35:39.055 --> 04:35:41.258
NETWORKS AND SENSITIVE DATA
04:35:41.324 --> 04:35:42.125
THEY COULD ALSO IMPACT A
04:35:42.192 --> 04:35:43.393
CRITICAL INFRASTRUCTURES SUCH
04:35:43.460 --> 04:35:45.061
AS ALL PUBLIC RATE HOSPITALS
04:35:45.128 --> 04:35:46.496
NOT TO MENTION THE FINANCIAL
04:35:46.563 --> 04:35:48.798
EXPOSURE THAT THEY CREATE CYBER
04:35:48.865 --> 04:35:50.800
INSURANCE SO WILL HELP ADDRESS
04:35:50.867 --> 04:35:52.302
THE INCREASING NUMBER OF CYBER
04:35:52.369 --> 04:35:54.137
ATTACKS BY HELPING AN
04:35:54.204 --> 04:35:56.706
ORGANIZATION TO MITIGATE RISKS-
04:35:56.773 --> 04:35:57.807
EXPO BY OFFSETTING COST
04:35:57.874 --> 04:35:59.509
INVOLVED. WITH THE RECOVERY
04:35:59.576 --> 04:36:01.311
AFTER A SIDE OF REACH THE
04:36:01.378 --> 04:36:02.779
AVERAGE COST OF AN ATTACK IS
04:36:02.846 --> 04:36:05.048
ABOUT TWENTY THOUSAND DOLLARS.
04:36:05.115 --> 04:36:07.150
CYBER INSURANCE WOULD ALSO HELP
04:36:07.217 --> 04:36:07.851
TO ONE INCENTIVIZE AN
04:36:07.918 --> 04:36:10.487
ORGANIZATION TO BILL ROBUST.
04:36:10.554 --> 04:36:12.555
CYBER SECURITY SYSTEM AND ALSO
04:36:12.622 --> 04:36:14.424
TO ENCOURAGE BEST PRACTICES SO
04:36:14.491 --> 04:36:16.059
WITHIN AN ORGANIZATION IT'S IN
04:36:16.126 --> 04:36:18.228
FACT ESTIMATED THAT 60% OF THE
04:36:18.295 --> 04:36:19.896
SMALL BUSINESSES GO OUT OF
04:36:19.963 --> 04:36:21.264
BUSINESS WITHIN SIX MONTHS OF A
04:36:21.331 --> 04:36:23.033
CYBER ATTACK. IN CALIFORNIA AT
04:36:23.099 --> 04:36:24.768
LEAST 25% OF THE ANNUAL
04:36:24.834 --> 04:36:25.802
GOVERNMENT CONTRACTING DOLLARS
04:36:25.869 --> 04:36:27.804
IS BEING PAID. TO CERTIFY SMALL
04:36:27.871 --> 04:36:30.307
BUSINESSES A CYBER INSURANCE
04:36:30.373 --> 04:36:32.409
CAN HELP PROTECT CONSTITUENTS
04:36:32.475 --> 04:36:34.444
AND TAXPAYERS WHO RELY ON SALL
04:36:34.511 --> 04:36:36.413
BUSINESSES SERVICES. IN
04:36:36.479 --> 04:36:38.048
ADDITION STATE AGENCIES HAVE A
04:36:38.114 --> 04:36:38.848
DUTY TO PROTECT CALIFORNIA
04:36:38.915 --> 04:36:41.384
RESIDENTS. PERSONAL INFORMATION
04:36:41.451 --> 04:36:42.652
UNDER THE INFORMATION PRACTICES
04:36:42.719 --> 04:36:44.721
ACT OF NINETEEN SEVENTY SEVEN
04:36:44.788 --> 04:36:47.023
OR IPA. THE ACT EVEN ALLOWS FOR
04:36:47.090 --> 04:36:48.158
CIVIL ACTION OF DAMAGES TO BE
04:36:48.224 --> 04:36:49.526
FILED AGAINST A GOVERNMENT
04:36:49.592 --> 04:36:51.995
AGENCY WHICH IS AN EX. ALEX
04:36:52.062 --> 04:36:53.330
EXCEPTION TO THE GOVERNMENT
04:36:53.396 --> 04:36:55.532
IMMUNITY THAT NORMALLY PROTECTS
04:36:55.598 --> 04:36:57.100
A GOVERNMENT ENTITY FROM TORT
04:36:57.167 --> 04:36:59.202
CLAIMS. ALL OF THIS MAKES IT
04:36:59.269 --> 04:37:02.272
IMPERATIVE FOR A CONTRACTORS
04:37:02.339 --> 04:37:04.207
DOING BUSINESS WITH THE STATE
04:37:04.274 --> 04:37:07.277
WHAT. ALL PERSONAL INFORMATION
04:37:07.344 --> 04:37:09.612
TO CARRY SO SURE IS SO I
04:37:09.679 --> 04:37:11.848
RESPECT AS YOUR- OF PORT IN
04:37:11.915 --> 04:37:16.252
I'VE- THANK GOD WE HAVE ANY. IN
04:37:16.319 --> 04:37:16.820
SUPPORT HERE WITH US IN THE
04:37:16.886 --> 04:37:18.855
ROOM. HOW ABOUT- WITH US BY
04:37:18.922 --> 04:37:27.030
PHONE. YOU HAVE A COMMENT AT
04:37:27.097 --> 04:37:28.565
THIS TIME PLEASE PRESS ONE
04:37:28.631 --> 04:37:35.105
FOLLOWED BY TWO. SURE NO
04:37:35.171 --> 04:37:37.340
SPEAKERS AND SUPPORT WE DO HAVE
04:37:37.407 --> 04:37:39.075
TWO SPEAKERS DESIGNATED IN
04:37:39.142 --> 04:37:40.410
OPPOSITION WHO I BELIEVE ARE
04:37:40.477 --> 04:37:43.213
BOTH WITH US BY PHONE. I WILL
04:37:43.279 --> 04:37:46.916
NOT START WITH MS CURTIS. FROM
04:37:46.983 --> 04:37:52.956
THE FROM CLEARLY. WE CAN. GREAT
04:37:53.023 --> 04:37:53.990
GOOD AFTERNOON MISTER CHAIRMAN
04:37:54.057 --> 04:37:55.825
AND MEMBERS THANK YOU FOR BEING
04:37:55.892 --> 04:37:57.027
HERE TODAY DURING THESE TRYING
04:37:57.093 --> 04:37:58.161
TIMES AND PROVIDING ME THE
04:37:58.228 --> 04:37:59.329
OPPORTUNITY TO TESTIFY MY
04:37:59.396 --> 04:38:00.497
NAME'S LAURA CURTIS AND I'M
04:38:00.563 --> 04:38:02.098
HERE ON BEHALF OF COMP HERE THE
04:38:02.165 --> 04:38:03.400
COMPUTING TECHNOLOGY INDUSTRY
04:38:03.466 --> 04:38:05.502
ASSOCIATION WE APPRECIATE AND
04:38:05.568 --> 04:38:07.003
MISTER OF STAFF AND HIS
04:38:07.070 --> 04:38:08.938
ANALYSIS AND THEIR WILLINGNESS
04:38:09.005 --> 04:38:10.540
TO DISCUSS THE BILL WITH OUR
04:38:10.607 --> 04:38:12.308
COALITION HOWEVER WE ARE HERE
04:38:12.375 --> 04:38:14.177
AT. THE EIGHTY TWENTY THREE ONE
04:38:14.244 --> 04:38:15.578
THE MEMBER OF OUR ORGANIZATION
04:38:15.645 --> 04:38:16.913
HAVE A MUTUAL GOAL OF ENSURING
04:38:16.980 --> 04:38:18.381
PRIVACY IN PROTECTING SENSITIVE
04:38:18.448 --> 04:38:19.549
DATA HOWEVER THE PROPOSED
04:38:19.616 --> 04:38:20.850
STATEWIDE TYPE INSURANCE
04:38:20.917 --> 04:38:22.485
MANDATE AS DEFINED WILL ONLY
04:38:22.552 --> 04:38:24.054
DRIVE UP THE COST A STATE
04:38:24.120 --> 04:38:26.956
AGENCY CONTRACT AB TWENTY THREE
04:38:27.023 --> 04:38:28.224
TWENTY WOULD CREATE ADDITIONAL
04:38:28.291 --> 04:38:29.893
AND UNNECESSARY FINANCIAL
04:38:29.959 --> 04:38:31.261
BURDENS ON ORGANIZATIONS
04:38:31.327 --> 04:38:32.829
CONTRACTING STATE AGENCY THERE
04:38:32.896 --> 04:38:34.464
ARE MEN OF PAPER INSURANCE
04:38:34.531 --> 04:38:36.366
SHOULD BE NEGOTIATED IF NEEDED
04:38:36.433 --> 04:38:37.534
DURING THE REQUEST FOR PROPOSAL
04:38:37.600 --> 04:38:41.805
PROCESS RATHER THAN THEY DID
04:38:41.871 --> 04:38:45.408
MANAGE. YOUR TECHNOLOGY BUT-
04:38:45.475 --> 04:38:45.909
ALL APPROACH WHICH AND-
04:38:45.975 --> 04:38:47.510
TECHNICAL LOOKS. THAT THE PRO
04:38:47.577 --> 04:38:49.112
GETS IN A- THAT. PROCURED AND
04:38:49.179 --> 04:38:50.246
SO. AND DETERMINE THE-
04:38:50.313 --> 04:38:51.881
INSURANCE NEEDS FOR PARTICULAR
04:38:51.948 --> 04:38:53.716
ARE HE- BASED ON A RELEASED
04:38:53.783 --> 04:38:55.452
REALISTIC AND NECESSARY COST
04:38:55.518 --> 04:38:57.454
BENEFIT ANALYSIS. THAT TAKES
04:38:57.520 --> 04:38:59.155
INTO ACCOUNT IF AND WHAT LEVELS
04:38:59.222 --> 04:39:01.357
OF CYBER INSURANCE ARE CALLED
04:39:01.424 --> 04:39:02.125
FOR IN LIGHT OF THE SENSITIVITY
04:39:02.192 --> 04:39:03.893
OF THE INFORMATION BALK. OTHER
04:39:03.960 --> 04:39:05.428
AVAILABLE CURRENT POLICIES THAT
04:39:05.495 --> 04:39:06.930
MAKE COVER LOSSES AND EXPLODED
04:39:06.996 --> 04:39:08.565
ARREST AMONG OTHER FACTORS WE
04:39:08.631 --> 04:39:10.100
CURRENTLY SEE NO BARRIERS TO
04:39:10.166 --> 04:39:11.568
THE ABILITY OF STATE AGENCIES
04:39:11.634 --> 04:39:12.769
TO REQUEST I BRING TRYING TO
04:39:12.836 --> 04:39:13.436
WHEN AND WHERE THEY DEEM
04:39:13.503 --> 04:39:14.938
APPROPRIATE. IN FACT
04:39:15.004 --> 04:39:16.272
CONTRACTORS TO STATE AND LOCAL
04:39:16.339 --> 04:39:17.040
GOVERNMENTS ARE ALREADY
04:39:17.107 --> 04:39:18.374
REQUIRED TO KERRY INSURANCE
04:39:18.441 --> 04:39:19.442
LOST COVERAGE AND LOCAL
04:39:19.509 --> 04:39:20.877
GOVERNMENTS ARE INCREASINGLY
04:39:20.944 --> 04:39:22.645
DEMANDING IT CONTRACTORS CARRY
04:39:22.712 --> 04:39:24.681
HIGHER LOST COVERAGE. WE ARE
04:39:24.747 --> 04:39:26.983
GOING TO AB TWENTY THREE TWENTY
04:39:27.050 --> 04:39:27.517
EIGHT ADDITIONAL FINANCIAL
04:39:27.584 --> 04:39:29.953
BURDEN CONTRACTORS WHICH WILL.
04:39:30.019 --> 04:39:37.427
OF ENTRY FOR NEWER OR SMALLER
04:39:37.494 --> 04:39:40.263
COMPANIES TO MAYBE. THIS IS.
04:39:40.330 --> 04:39:41.664
BECAUSE IS LIKE TO SEE TO
04:39:41.731 --> 04:39:42.966
BETTER RESULTING IN HIGHER.
04:39:43.032 --> 04:39:43.867
ACOSTA THIS. IN CLOSING WE DO
04:39:43.933 --> 04:39:44.534
NOT BELIEVE THAT STATE MANDATES
04:39:44.601 --> 04:39:46.402
A CRACKED UP UNDER SECOND. AND
04:39:46.469 --> 04:39:47.203
IT FEELS TO CREATE A BETTER
04:39:47.270 --> 04:39:48.371
OUTCOME FOR THE PARTIES
04:39:48.438 --> 04:39:50.073
INVOLVED ESPECIALLY THE- FOR
04:39:50.140 --> 04:39:51.207
THIS REASON AND WE ARE- TO
04:39:51.274 --> 04:39:52.842
ASSEMBLY MEMBER KALISPELL. BUT
04:39:52.909 --> 04:39:53.810
IF THIS BILL WERE TO MOVE
04:39:53.877 --> 04:39:54.811
FORWARD WE LOOK FORWARD TO
04:39:54.878 --> 04:39:56.679
WORKING WITH HIS STAFF AND- THE
04:39:56.746 --> 04:39:57.981
COMMITTEE STAFF ON THAT.
04:39:58.047 --> 04:39:59.782
MEASURE THANKS SO MUCH FOR THE
04:39:59.849 --> 04:40:01.584
OPPORTUNITY. WE APPRECIATE.
04:40:01.651 --> 04:40:03.887
THANK YOU ALSO SPEAKING OUT IN
04:40:03.953 --> 04:40:08.491
OPPOSITION IS MISTER MUHAMMAD.
04:40:08.558 --> 04:40:10.793
THIS WHAT MUHAMMAD CALIFORNIA
04:40:10.860 --> 04:40:11.427
CHAMBER OF COMMERCE CAN HEAR ME
04:40:11.494 --> 04:40:16.266
CORRECTLY. YES WE CAN. WELL
04:40:16.332 --> 04:40:17.634
GOOD AFTERNOON SURE MEMBERS AND
04:40:17.700 --> 04:40:19.502
THANK YOU FOR ALLOWING US TO BE
04:40:19.569 --> 04:40:20.236
HEARD HERE UNDER THE
04:40:20.303 --> 04:40:21.704
CIRCUMSTANCES WE APPRECIATE YOU
04:40:21.771 --> 04:40:23.840
ALL BEING HERE AND- THANK YOU
04:40:23.907 --> 04:40:25.208
TO THE STAFF AND COMMITTEE OF
04:40:25.275 --> 04:40:26.709
COURSE WITH REGARD TO THIS BILL
04:40:26.776 --> 04:40:27.577
WE APPRECIATE THE AUTHOR'S
04:40:27.644 --> 04:40:29.345
INTENTION- THE GO TO THE PRO
04:40:29.412 --> 04:40:31.548
BUT IT'S OUT THERE ARE SOME
04:40:31.614 --> 04:40:32.715
ISSUES WITH THE LANGUAGE- THE
04:40:32.782 --> 04:40:34.551
READ CONCERNS PARTICULARLY FOR
04:40:34.617 --> 04:40:36.452
SMALL. SO I WANT DRUG BE MADE
04:40:36.519 --> 04:40:39.756
TODAY FIRST EXCUSE ME FIRST
04:40:39.822 --> 04:40:41.958
BILL LANGUAGE IS UNCLEAR IT
04:40:42.025 --> 04:40:43.159
REGARDS TO SEVERAL DIFFERENT
04:40:43.226 --> 04:40:44.861
PORTIONS OF THAT ARE THE BILL
04:40:44.928 --> 04:40:47.096
WOULD FOR EXAMPLE BENEFIT FROM
04:40:47.163 --> 04:40:47.997
BUYING WHETHER BIT HIS WITH
04:40:48.064 --> 04:40:50.667
STAYING CARP WHICH ARE RECALL
04:40:50.733 --> 04:40:51.768
TO A POINT A DUPLICATE.
04:40:51.834 --> 04:40:54.070
SEPARATE POLICIES FOR A
04:40:54.137 --> 04:40:56.206
DUPLICATE COUNTRY COVERAGE FOR
04:40:56.272 --> 04:40:57.707
CONTRACTOR THAT MIGHT BE
04:40:57.774 --> 04:41:01.644
REQUIRED. WE CAN REQUIRE TO
04:41:01.711 --> 04:41:02.912
PURCHASING. COULD BE TIED TO
04:41:02.979 --> 04:41:04.013
WHAT THE CON ITSELF AND BY
04:41:04.080 --> 04:41:05.515
RECEIVE PERSON FROM. BUT THE
04:41:05.582 --> 04:41:06.683
LANGUAGE OF THE BILL DOES NOT
04:41:06.749 --> 04:41:08.885
EXACTLY ADDRESS THIS- AN
04:41:08.952 --> 04:41:09.719
ADDITIONALLY WE ALSO BELIEVE
04:41:09.786 --> 04:41:10.520
THE BILL INTENDS TO BE
04:41:10.587 --> 04:41:12.322
PERSPECTIVE ONLY. AND WE WOULD
04:41:12.388 --> 04:41:13.623
HOPE THAT THE AUTHOR WOULD
04:41:13.690 --> 04:41:14.390
CONSIDER ADDING EXPRESS
04:41:14.457 --> 04:41:16.226
LANGUAGE TO MAKE THAT CLEAR.
04:41:16.292 --> 04:41:17.260
THE BILL WOULD ALSO REQUIRE
04:41:17.327 --> 04:41:18.861
CONTRACTORS SECURITY CYBER
04:41:18.928 --> 04:41:20.463
INSURANCE SUFFICIENT TO COVER
04:41:20.530 --> 04:41:22.265
ALL LOSSES RESULTING FROM
04:41:22.332 --> 04:41:24.400
POTENTIAL UNLAWFUL ACCESS TO OR
04:41:24.467 --> 04:41:25.401
DISCLOSURE OF PERSONAL
04:41:25.468 --> 04:41:27.604
INFORMATION- THIS LANGUAGES
04:41:27.670 --> 04:41:29.305
ARE. PROBLEMATIC BECAUSE OF THE
04:41:29.372 --> 04:41:31.541
TERM ALL LOSSES COULD INCLUDE
04:41:31.608 --> 04:41:32.542
WATER THEY'RE NOT IS ALSO THE
04:41:32.609 --> 04:41:34.143
CONTRACTORS BREACH OF THE
04:41:34.210 --> 04:41:34.978
AGREEMENT. AND THE TERM
04:41:35.044 --> 04:41:36.613
POTENTIAL UNLAWFUL ACT SIR
04:41:36.679 --> 04:41:39.215
DISCLOSURE IS NOT TAILORED BY
04:41:39.282 --> 04:41:40.850
ANY MEASURABLE HARM- THIRDLY
04:41:40.917 --> 04:41:42.485
RELATES TO THE AMOUNT. BRIDGE
04:41:42.552 --> 04:41:44.754
COVERAGE THE BILLSTATES THAT
04:41:44.821 --> 04:41:46.122
IT SHALL BE IN AN AMOUNT
04:41:46.189 --> 04:41:48.725
DETERMINED BY THE CONTRACTING
04:41:48.791 --> 04:41:49.692
AGENCY. AND WE BELIEVE THAT
04:41:49.759 --> 04:41:52.829
THIS LANGUAGE HERE COULD BE. IT
04:41:52.895 --> 04:41:55.198
FROM GARDEN. WE SHOULD THE
04:41:55.265 --> 04:41:55.798
AMOUNT OF COVERAGE REQUIRE BY
04:41:55.865 --> 04:41:57.000
STATE AGENCIES IT'S A ALL
04:41:57.066 --> 04:41:57.900
RELATED TO THE OF DAY. OR THE
04:41:57.967 --> 04:41:59.602
SENSE OF THE DATA OR EVEN THE
04:41:59.669 --> 04:42:01.070
SIZE OF THE CONTRACT AND IN
04:42:01.137 --> 04:42:02.305
THAT SAME BEING WE DO BELIEVE
04:42:02.372 --> 04:42:03.473
THAT INSURANCE REQUIREMENTS ARE
04:42:03.539 --> 04:42:04.941
BEST ADDRESSED DURING THE RP
04:42:05.008 --> 04:42:06.943
PROFITS BUT BECAUSE- STATE
04:42:07.010 --> 04:42:08.211
MANDATES DRIVE UP. OUR BARRIERS
04:42:08.278 --> 04:42:10.179
OF ENTRY FOR BUSINESSES WANT TO
04:42:10.246 --> 04:42:11.614
COMPETE FOR THE CONTRACT AND
04:42:11.681 --> 04:42:12.915
THAT'S NOT ONLY ABOUT FOR SMALL
04:42:12.982 --> 04:42:15.418
BUSINESSES BUT AFTER. BY
04:42:15.485 --> 04:42:16.519
LIMITING COMPETITION AND
04:42:16.586 --> 04:42:17.620
ULTIMATELY DRIVING UP COST
04:42:17.687 --> 04:42:19.188
TAXPAYERS LOOK FOR THOSE
04:42:19.255 --> 04:42:19.956
REASONS WE ARE RESPECTFULLY
04:42:20.023 --> 04:42:21.924
POSE AND WE DO LOOK FORWARD TO
04:42:21.991 --> 04:42:22.725
WORKING WITH THE AUTHOR ON
04:42:22.792 --> 04:42:24.727
THESE ISSUES. THANK YOU AGAIN
04:42:24.794 --> 04:42:27.897
FOR LET ME TO SPEAK. THANK YOU
04:42:27.964 --> 04:42:28.998
ARE THERE OTHER SPEAKERS IN
04:42:29.065 --> 04:42:30.633
OPPOSITION HERE IN THE ROOM OR
04:42:30.700 --> 04:42:39.909
ON THE TELEPHONE. WE DO HAVE
04:42:39.976 --> 04:42:56.192
SOMEONE IN Q. ONE MOMENT PLEASE.
04:42:56.259 --> 04:42:59.228
YOUR LINE IS OPEN FOR COMMENT.
04:42:59.295 --> 04:43:00.763
HI THIS IS COURTNEY JENSEN
04:43:00.830 --> 04:43:02.999
WEDTECH MATT- ALSO IN
04:43:03.066 --> 04:43:04.434
OPPOSITION AND ECHO THE
04:43:04.500 --> 04:43:07.570
COMMENTS- YEAH AND THAT
04:43:07.637 --> 04:43:15.978
CALIFORNIA PROPERTY THANK YOU.
04:43:16.045 --> 04:43:16.512
ALL RIGHT HEARING NO OTHER
04:43:16.579 --> 04:43:21.517
SPEAKERS IN UP. IT WAS THERE
04:43:21.584 --> 04:43:22.118
ANOTHER SPEAKER OPPOSITION I'M
04:43:22.185 --> 04:43:26.122
SORRY. NOW THERE'S ONE UP OKAY
04:43:26.189 --> 04:43:28.358
THANK YOU THANK YOU LET'S TAKE
04:43:28.424 --> 04:43:28.891
IT BACK TO MEMBERS OF THE
04:43:28.958 --> 04:43:33.563
COMMITTEE. YES SOMEONE ON THE-
04:43:33.629 --> 04:43:35.231
YOU KNOW I THINK THERE IS ALL
04:43:35.298 --> 04:43:37.133
OF A LOT OF POTENTIAL WITH
04:43:37.200 --> 04:43:39.602
CYBER- INSURANCE AND THIS IS
04:43:39.669 --> 04:43:41.104
BEEN A DISCUSSION THAT WE'VE
04:43:41.170 --> 04:43:43.406
HAD AT AND CSL AT- YOU KNOW
04:43:43.473 --> 04:43:45.908
WITH WITH LEGISLATORS THAT ARE
04:43:45.975 --> 04:43:47.643
WORKING ON CYBER ISSUES OF OVER
04:43:47.710 --> 04:43:50.246
THE LAST YEAR. UNFORTUNATELY
04:43:50.313 --> 04:43:51.748
THE CONSENSUS IS THAT THE MID
04:43:51.814 --> 04:43:53.583
THE INDUSTRY IS JUST NOT MATURE
04:43:53.649 --> 04:43:55.651
ENOUGH TO GET THAT THERE'S NO
04:43:55.718 --> 04:43:57.987
REAL CONSISTENCY AND THE
04:43:58.054 --> 04:44:00.490
COVERAGE AND OF THAN WE DID
04:44:00.556 --> 04:44:02.592
HEAR ANECDOTALLY THAT A LOT OF
04:44:02.658 --> 04:44:04.060
THESE- CYBER INSURANCE
04:44:04.127 --> 04:44:07.230
COMPANIES ARE ACTUALLY OF THAT
04:44:07.296 --> 04:44:09.699
WHEN A COMPANY AT IS THE OR
04:44:09.766 --> 04:44:12.135
GOVERNMENT HAS A RANSOM WHERE
04:44:12.201 --> 04:44:14.003
IT ACT. THAT OF THEIR JUST
04:44:14.070 --> 04:44:15.972
SETTLING AND PAYING OFF THE
04:44:16.038 --> 04:44:18.641
RANSOMWARE AND AT AS YOU KNOW
04:44:18.708 --> 04:44:21.611
THAT'S EXTREMELY BAD POLICY FOR
04:44:21.677 --> 04:44:23.780
ESPECIALLY GOVERNMENT AGENCIES
04:44:23.846 --> 04:44:25.748
BECAUSE IT JUST ENCOURAGES THE-
04:44:25.815 --> 04:44:28.484
PACKERS TO CONTINUOUS SO I KNOW
04:44:28.551 --> 04:44:31.220
VENTURE DO THE THAT CYBER
04:44:31.287 --> 04:44:34.557
INSURANCE IS THAT THAT IS THAT.
04:44:34.624 --> 04:44:35.758
IT'S GOING TO MATURE I JUST
04:44:35.825 --> 04:44:38.428
DON'T THINK IT'S A RIGHT NOW
04:44:38.494 --> 04:44:39.195
AND I THINK THIS COULD BE
04:44:39.262 --> 04:44:41.631
COUNTERPRODUCTIVE SO- I'M GONNA
04:44:41.697 --> 04:44:46.202
BE LAYING ON BILL TODAY.
04:44:46.269 --> 04:44:49.539
SOMEONE WILL ROOMS IN. THANK
04:44:49.605 --> 04:44:51.307
YOU MISTER VICE CHAIR UP MR
04:44:51.374 --> 04:44:52.375
CHOW WANTED TO GIVE YOU THE
04:44:52.442 --> 04:44:54.677
OPPORTUNITY TO A REACTS TO A
04:44:54.744 --> 04:44:56.913
CAL CHAMBERS QUESTION ABOUT THE
04:44:56.979 --> 04:45:00.316
METHODOLOGY BY WHICH A-
04:45:00.383 --> 04:45:02.285
CONTRACTING AGENCY WOULD GO
04:45:02.351 --> 04:45:04.153
ABOUT CALCULATING THE AMOUNT OF
04:45:04.220 --> 04:45:06.689
REQUIRED INSURANCE GIVEN THE
04:45:06.756 --> 04:45:07.423
BROAD LANGUAGE OF THE BILL THAT
04:45:07.490 --> 04:45:09.992
SAYS. A SUFFICIENT TO COVER ALL
04:45:10.059 --> 04:45:12.295
LOSSES RESULTING FROM POTENTIAL
04:45:12.361 --> 04:45:16.032
UNLAWFUL ACCESS. HI YES OF AT
04:45:16.098 --> 04:45:16.966
THIS POINT WE DON'T WANT THE
04:45:17.033 --> 04:45:18.835
LANGUAGE TO BE TOO PRESCRIPTIVE
04:45:18.901 --> 04:45:21.404
AND I THINK- IT IS PRUDENT FOR
04:45:21.471 --> 04:45:23.172
US TO ALLOW THAT DECISION TO BE
04:45:23.239 --> 04:45:25.775
MADE- AT THE LOCAL LEVEL- AT
04:45:25.842 --> 04:45:27.977
THIS AGENCY LEVEL- SO THAT
04:45:28.044 --> 04:45:29.779
BECAUSE THEY KNOW WHAT'S- WHAT
04:45:29.846 --> 04:45:31.180
INFORMATION IS BEING COVER
04:45:31.247 --> 04:45:32.849
WHAT- BUT THE CALL YOU KNOW
04:45:32.915 --> 04:45:35.918
THE- POLICY OUGHT TO BE SO- I
04:45:35.985 --> 04:45:39.355
THINK THAT- THE DECISION IS TO
04:45:39.422 --> 04:45:41.224
ALLOW THE AGENCIES TO THIS
04:45:41.290 --> 04:45:44.694
QUESTION- TO DETERMINE EXACTLY
04:45:44.760 --> 04:45:46.762
HOW MUCH ARE THE POLICY OUGHT
04:45:46.829 --> 04:45:48.397
TO BE AND ALSO WHAT INFORMATION
04:45:48.464 --> 04:45:50.399
IS BEING COVER- OF HEAVY SAID
04:45:50.466 --> 04:45:54.370
THAT I THINK. D. ARE YOU KNOW
04:45:54.437 --> 04:45:55.838
WE'RE DEFINITELY FLEXIBLE AND
04:45:55.905 --> 04:45:58.708
OPEN TO- TAKING A LANGUAGE- ARE
04:45:58.774 --> 04:46:00.943
GOING FORWARD I KNOW THAT- YOU
04:46:01.010 --> 04:46:02.912
KNOW THERE'S BEEN A CURFEW
04:46:02.979 --> 04:46:05.248
OTHER ISSUES HAVE BEEN RAISED
04:46:05.314 --> 04:46:11.320
THOUGHT WHICH I DEEM TO BE R.
04:46:11.387 --> 04:46:14.023
M. AS- AND- NOT BEING. AS FOR
04:46:14.090 --> 04:46:16.392
AS THE- THIS WILL I THINK WE
04:46:16.459 --> 04:46:17.026
CAN ALSO TAKE DOES WELL BECAUSE
04:46:17.093 --> 04:46:18.294
SOME TO NOT REALLY DEAL WITH
04:46:18.361 --> 04:46:19.195
PERSONAL INFORMATION IT'S A
04:46:19.262 --> 04:46:21.564
LIBRARY OR SOMETHING LIKE THAT-
04:46:21.631 --> 04:46:24.934
AND ALSO THE- TO PUT IT IF
04:46:25.001 --> 04:46:27.570
NATURE OF- LET'S SEE. WHAT'S
04:46:27.637 --> 04:46:28.137
REQUIRED UNDER THIS LAW AND
04:46:28.204 --> 04:46:30.740
EXISTING POLICIES SO I
04:46:30.806 --> 04:46:32.742
DEFINITELY DON'T WANT. FULL TO
04:46:32.808 --> 04:46:35.611
PAY EXTRA REDUNDANT POLICY OF-
04:46:35.678 --> 04:46:38.180
SO I THINK THAT CAN BE- THAT
04:46:38.247 --> 04:46:40.449
CAN BE MODIFIED AS WELL- AS
04:46:40.516 --> 04:46:42.618
WELL AS THE OTHER OTHER ISSUES
04:46:42.685 --> 04:46:44.587
THAT DOESN'T BEEN BROUGHT UP-
04:46:44.654 --> 04:46:46.622
SO YEAH SO I TOTALLY.
04:46:46.689 --> 04:46:48.524
UNDERSTAND IT AND THE CONCERN
04:46:48.591 --> 04:46:50.760
RAISED AND- UNFORTUNATELY WE
04:46:50.826 --> 04:46:52.161
DON'T HAVE TIME TO REALLY LOOK
04:46:52.228 --> 04:46:54.030
INTO THE ISSUE. ALL WHEN THIS
04:46:54.096 --> 04:46:55.498
ISSUE SURFACE SO I COULD JUST
04:46:55.565 --> 04:46:57.066
HAVE A COUPLE DAYS AGO. SO YOU
04:46:57.133 --> 04:46:58.000
KNOW THOSE ARE ISSUES THAT I'LL
04:46:58.067 --> 04:46:59.869
BE VERY HAPPY TO LOOK LOOK INTO
04:46:59.936 --> 04:47:01.804
AND ALSO TRY TO FIX THANK YOU I
04:47:01.871 --> 04:47:03.306
SHARE THAT CONCERN WITH THE
04:47:03.372 --> 04:47:03.839
BROADNESS OF THE LANGUAGE
04:47:03.906 --> 04:47:05.708
BECAUSE- A JUST PLAIN READING
04:47:05.775 --> 04:47:07.310
OF THE BILL WHEN IT SAYS.
04:47:07.376 --> 04:47:10.179
SUFFICIENT TO COVER ALL LOSSES
04:47:10.246 --> 04:47:12.448
WOULD SUGGEST THAT YOU SHOULD
04:47:12.515 --> 04:47:14.884
TAKE AN EXTREME VIEW POINT OF.
04:47:14.951 --> 04:47:16.485
THE VERY MAXIMUM OF THE
04:47:16.552 --> 04:47:18.621
POTENTIAL LOSS WHEREAS OTHER
04:47:18.688 --> 04:47:20.022
CUT FORMS OF INSURANCE THAT'S
04:47:20.089 --> 04:47:22.091
NOT THE WAY THAT IT'S DONE. AT
04:47:22.158 --> 04:47:23.559
THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA FOR
04:47:23.626 --> 04:47:24.694
EXAMPLE REQUIRES DRIVERS TO
04:47:24.760 --> 04:47:27.296
HAVE LIABILITY INTO. BUT I
04:47:27.363 --> 04:47:28.898
DON'T KNOW ABOUT THE WERE A
04:47:28.965 --> 04:47:30.900
COUPLE COVER. ATTENTION AND SO
04:47:30.967 --> 04:47:32.435
MAYBE YOU COULD SUBSTITUTE.
04:47:32.501 --> 04:47:34.437
SAYS OR SOMETHING LIKE THAT IT
04:47:34.503 --> 04:47:36.305
IT AS YOU SAY. GIVING THE
04:47:36.372 --> 04:47:38.874
CONTRACTING AGENCY THE ABILITY
04:47:38.941 --> 04:47:40.376
TO DETERMINE A REASONABLE
04:47:40.443 --> 04:47:42.511
AMOUNT BUT NOT PRESCRIBING THEM
04:47:42.578 --> 04:47:45.881
TO HAVE TO COVER THE MAXIMUM
04:47:45.948 --> 04:47:47.416
AMOUNT. I'LL QUESTION ABOUT
04:47:47.483 --> 04:47:48.618
COMPANIES ABILITY TO SELF
04:47:48.684 --> 04:47:49.952
INSURE BECAUSE TYPICALLY WHEN
04:47:50.019 --> 04:47:51.120
WE IMPOSE A REQUIREMENT ON
04:47:51.187 --> 04:47:53.089
COMPANIES WE DO ALLOW THEM. TO
04:47:53.155 --> 04:47:54.056
CERTIFY THAT THEY HAVE THE
04:47:54.123 --> 04:47:56.359
ASSETS NECESSARY. TO COVER A
04:47:56.425 --> 04:47:58.361
LOSS AND IF THAT'S THE CASE BUT
04:47:58.427 --> 04:48:00.863
WE DON'T REQUIRE THEM TO BUY A
04:48:00.930 --> 04:48:02.465
COMMERCIAL PRODUCT. AND I
04:48:02.531 --> 04:48:04.100
DIDN'T SEE THAT- THAT KIND OF
04:48:04.166 --> 04:48:05.768
LANGUAGE IN YOUR BILL AND I WAS
04:48:05.835 --> 04:48:06.402
WONDERING WHAT YOU'RE THINKING
04:48:06.469 --> 04:48:08.471
ABOUT IT. YEAH HI- I'M FAMILIAR
04:48:08.537 --> 04:48:09.772
WITH THAT ALSO BECAUSE WHEN I
04:48:09.839 --> 04:48:11.273
SERVED ON A LOCAL SCHOOL BOARD
04:48:11.340 --> 04:48:13.042
I. WE DID EXACTLY THAT WE SELF
04:48:13.109 --> 04:48:15.411
INSURED AND TO A CERTAIN LIMIT
04:48:15.478 --> 04:48:17.647
AND ANYTHING BEYOND THAT WOULD
04:48:17.713 --> 04:48:18.347
BE COVERED BY IT YOU KNOW I
04:48:18.414 --> 04:48:20.149
POLICY. SO THAT'S SOMETHING
04:48:20.216 --> 04:48:23.719
THAT WE ALSO LOOK INTO AYE AYE
04:48:23.786 --> 04:48:25.287
I THINK- WE HAVEN'T HAD A
04:48:25.354 --> 04:48:27.957
CHANCE. TO SEE LET'S SEE. I
04:48:28.024 --> 04:48:29.592
INDUSTRY FIRST OR- ANYBODY.
04:48:29.659 --> 04:48:30.226
NOBODY HAS ACT COME UP WITH ANY
04:48:30.292 --> 04:48:31.560
SUGGESTIONS ABOUT THIS BILL
04:48:31.627 --> 04:48:33.763
UNTIL RECENTLY SO. SO THIS IS
04:48:33.829 --> 04:48:35.431
SOMETHING AND OTHER EVERY THAT
04:48:35.498 --> 04:48:36.832
WE ARE VERY HAPPY TO LOOK INTO
04:48:36.899 --> 04:48:38.534
AS WELL. I'VE SELF INSURANCE
04:48:38.601 --> 04:48:41.070
AND OTHER OTHER POTENTIAL HERE
04:48:41.137 --> 04:48:42.004
IS THAT WE SHOULD TOUCH ON.
04:48:42.071 --> 04:48:44.106
pTHAT WOULD STILL ACCOMPLISH
04:48:44.173 --> 04:48:45.741
YOUR PURPOSE BECAUSE- IF YOU'RE
04:48:45.808 --> 04:48:47.343
INTENDING TO MAKE SURE THAT
04:48:47.410 --> 04:48:49.578
COMPANIES CAN SURVIVE. AND ALSO
04:48:49.645 --> 04:48:50.880
THE CLAIMS GET PAID IF YOU HAVE
04:48:50.946 --> 04:48:52.314
A FAIRY FINANCIALLY HEALTHY
04:48:52.381 --> 04:48:53.549
COMPANY THAT'S WILLING TO MAKE
04:48:53.616 --> 04:48:54.884
THAT- THAT KIND OF
04:48:54.950 --> 04:48:55.951
DEMONSTRATION I THINK THAT
04:48:56.018 --> 04:48:57.219
THAT- YOU KNOW THAT. THERE
04:48:57.286 --> 04:48:58.487
WOULD STILL ACCOMPLISH WHAT
04:48:58.554 --> 04:49:00.022
YOU'RE TRYING TO DO HERE. I
04:49:00.089 --> 04:49:03.259
GOTCHA THANK YOU. MR CHAO WOULD
04:49:03.325 --> 04:49:05.127
YOU I LIKE TO CLOSE. I JUST
04:49:05.194 --> 04:49:06.629
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE VOTE
04:49:06.696 --> 04:49:08.330
AND- YOU KNOW ONCE AGAIN I
04:49:08.397 --> 04:49:10.066
APOLOGIZE FOR. GIVING SO MUCH
04:49:10.132 --> 04:49:12.601
INFORMATION WITHIN SYSTEM SO
04:49:12.668 --> 04:49:13.202
YOU KNOW SUCH A SUCH A SHORT
04:49:13.269 --> 04:49:15.237
TIME PERIOD SO. BUT I
04:49:15.304 --> 04:49:16.505
APPRECIATE YOUR ATTENTION AND I
04:49:16.572 --> 04:49:18.140
WANT TO APOLOGIZE FOR THE DELAY
04:49:18.207 --> 04:49:20.176
THAT. YEAH DURING THE RECESS
04:49:20.242 --> 04:49:21.177
AND- I THANK YOU FOR YOUR
04:49:21.243 --> 04:49:22.244
ATTENTION. WITHOUT A-
04:49:22.311 --> 04:49:24.780
RESPECTFULLY ASK PRIVATE. I
04:49:24.847 --> 04:49:25.381
BELIEVE WE NEED A MùT. ON A
04:49:25.448 --> 04:49:30.720
SECOND. BUT A SEPARATE CALL THE
04:49:30.786 --> 04:49:33.823
ROLL. THE MOTION IS TO PASS TO
04:49:33.889 --> 04:49:36.559
APPROPRIATIONS CHILD BY CHILD
04:49:36.625 --> 04:49:42.231
HI KILEY. KILEY KNOW OUR CAN.
04:49:42.298 --> 04:49:46.535
BERMAN HELLO. MEDINA MEDINA I
04:49:46.602 --> 04:49:50.840
CARILLO. CREEL I'M MULLIN
04:49:50.906 --> 04:49:56.011
MULLIN AYE GALLAGHER. IRWIN
04:49:56.078 --> 04:49:59.849
OBERNOLTE OBERNOLTE NO WICKS
04:49:59.915 --> 04:50:12.228
WICKS. IT'S. ALL AT THE BILL
04:50:12.294 --> 04:50:14.296
WAS ON CALL- I'M GONNA HAND THE
04:50:14.363 --> 04:50:17.066
GAVEL BACK TO- CHAIR- CHAO AND
04:50:17.133 --> 04:50:19.268
WE CAN PROCEED TO. THIS THANK
04:50:19.335 --> 04:50:38.154
YOU.
04:50:45.694 --> 04:50:54.370
THERE ARE. LIKE WILDLIFE
04:50:54.436 --> 04:50:56.939
THERE'S VOMITING WHAT IF
04:50:57.006 --> 04:50:59.341
ANYTHING LINE. YEAH THEY GOT
04:50:59.408 --> 04:51:05.748
OVER THERE ANYWAY. RATHER YEAH
04:51:05.815 --> 04:51:18.027
YEAH. WE DON'T. DON'T AFTER W.
04:51:18.093 --> 04:51:33.776
BOB. YEAH. THIS I DON'T I DON'T
04:51:33.843 --> 04:51:36.378
WANT TO TOUCH THE MIKE. HOW QUE
04:51:36.445 --> 04:51:42.117
OF. I COULD JUST CALL IT OUT I
04:51:42.184 --> 04:51:47.723
THINK I'LL. SO LOOK AT THIS
04:51:47.790 --> 04:51:51.527
TIME LET'S. TWO THE ADD ONS I
04:51:51.594 --> 04:51:54.663
STARTING WITH- TWO THOUSAND
04:51:54.730 --> 04:51:56.265
FOUR CALDERON PLEASE CALL THE
04:51:56.332 --> 04:52:07.443
ABSENT MEMBERS. MULLIN THANK.
04:52:07.509 --> 04:52:14.216
MULLIN NINE. HAS NINE VOTES
04:52:14.283 --> 04:52:18.320
OKAY NEXT WE HAVE- AB TWENTY
04:52:18.387 --> 04:52:22.625
FOUR FORTY THREE WEBER. THE
04:52:22.691 --> 04:52:24.927
MOTION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED TO
04:52:24.994 --> 04:52:27.897
THE ASSEMBLY FLOOR CARILLO.
04:52:27.963 --> 04:52:32.835
CORREO HI MULLIN. MULLIN HI.
04:52:32.902 --> 04:52:34.870
NEXT WE HAVE TWENTY THREE
04:52:34.937 --> 04:52:37.106
TWENTY CHILD. PLEASE CALL THE
04:52:37.172 --> 04:52:40.175
ABSENT MEMBERS. MOTION IS TO
04:52:40.242 --> 04:52:41.577
PASS AS AMENDED TO THE ASSEMBLY
04:52:41.644 --> 04:52:47.716
FLOOR MULLIN. MULLIN HI. NEXT
04:52:47.783 --> 04:52:49.985
WE HAVE- AB THIRTY ONE SIXTEEN
04:52:50.052 --> 04:52:51.053
IRWIN PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
04:52:51.120 --> 04:52:53.122
MEMBERS MOTION IS TO PASS
04:52:53.188 --> 04:53:03.132
MULLIN- MULLIN AYE. YEAH YEAH.
04:53:03.198 --> 04:53:06.135
IN TWO THOUSAND AND FOUR
04:53:06.201 --> 04:53:08.904
DESERVE ONE. THIRTY ONE SIXTEEN
04:53:08.971 --> 04:53:19.615
IRWIN. THIRTY ONE SIXTEEN IRWIN
04:53:19.682 --> 04:53:21.817
THE MOTION IS TO PASS AS
04:53:21.884 --> 04:53:24.820
AMENDED TO APPROPRIATIONS. OUR
04:53:24.887 --> 04:53:32.995
HI CHAO I. CORREO. HI MULLIN I
04:53:33.062 --> 04:53:38.567
HAVE. I OBERNOLTE OBERNOLTE NO.
04:53:38.634 --> 04:53:41.303
NEXT WE HAVE AB TWENTY EIGHT
04:53:41.370 --> 04:53:41.904
ELEVEN BERMAN PLEASE CALL THE
04:53:41.971 --> 04:54:00.055
ABSENT MEMBERS.
04:54:02.658 --> 04:54:02.858
I THINK HAVE
04:54:02.925 --> 04:54:04.827
EVERYONE VOTING ON BERMAN ALL
04:54:04.893 --> 04:54:07.229
RIGHT NEXT WE HAVE AB TWENTY
04:54:07.296 --> 04:54:10.499
ONE FORTY NINE THAT'S- GONZALEZ
04:54:10.566 --> 04:54:19.441
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
04:54:19.508 --> 04:54:20.476
THE MOTION IS TO PASS AS
04:54:20.542 --> 04:54:22.144
AMENDED TO THE I THINK I HAVE
04:54:22.211 --> 04:54:24.747
EVERYONE ON THEMSELVES OKAY XFR
04:54:24.813 --> 04:54:27.950
ONLY WE HAVE AB TWENTY TWO
04:54:28.017 --> 04:54:28.584
SIXTY ONE CHILD PLEASE CALL THE
04:54:28.650 --> 04:54:32.388
ABSENT MEMBERS. SECOND SALAS
04:54:32.454 --> 04:54:35.090
THIS ONE IS CHILD AT THE LAST
04:54:35.157 --> 04:54:36.358
ONE WAS GONZALEZ TWENTY ONE
04:54:36.425 --> 04:54:39.161
FORTY NINE. I ADD ON OKAY I'M
04:54:39.228 --> 04:54:40.729
GONNA COME CHECK THAT YOU GUYS
04:54:40.796 --> 04:54:44.500
ARE JUST A MOMENT. YEAH AB
04:54:44.566 --> 04:54:45.134
TWENTY TWO SIXTY ONE THE MOTION
04:54:45.200 --> 04:54:46.802
IS TO PASS AS AMENDED TO
04:54:46.869 --> 04:54:48.637
APPROPRIATIONS. AND WE HAVE
04:54:48.704 --> 04:54:57.413
GALLAGHER. YOU HAVE GALLAGHER.
04:54:57.479 --> 04:55:05.120
GALLAGHER I. THAT HAS EIGHT
04:55:05.187 --> 04:55:11.560
THAT IS OKAY SO WE- COMING DOWN.
04:55:11.627 --> 04:55:14.430
I'VE TO START. THE LAST ONE
04:55:14.496 --> 04:55:18.767
BEING AB TWENTY THREE TWENTY.
04:55:18.834 --> 04:55:21.336
THE LAST ONE WAS AB TWENTY
04:55:21.403 --> 04:55:23.372
TWENTY THREE TWENTY. THE MOTION
04:55:23.439 --> 04:55:27.943
IS TO PASS TO APPROPRIATIONS.
04:55:28.010 --> 04:55:31.313
AND WE HAVE GALLAGHER.
04:55:31.380 --> 04:55:42.624
GALLAGHER NOW. FIVE VOTES. WE
04:55:42.691 --> 04:55:47.563
GOT EVERYBODY. OKAY DEAF BILL
04:55:47.629 --> 04:55:49.932
FAILS. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
04:55:49.998 --> 04:56:17.559
EVERYONE. THANK GOD. KEVIN YEAH.
04:56:17.626 --> 04:56:29.438
RIGHT RIGHT. YOUR. YEAH I.
04:56:29.505 --> 04:56:48.423
RIGHT.
04:56:55.264 --> 04:57:00.469
AND WE GET YEAH OKAY SO
04:57:00.536 --> 04:57:22.758
WE ARE YEAH. TURN.