WEBVTT
00:19:10.282 --> 00:19:11.650
SIMPLY JUDICIARY COMMITTEE WE
00:19:11.717 --> 00:19:13.452
DO NOT YET HAVE A QUORUM WE
00:19:13.519 --> 00:19:14.820
HAVE A COUPLE AUTHORS TO WILL
00:19:14.887 --> 00:19:17.656
START AS A SUB COMMITTEE
00:19:17.723 --> 00:19:19.892
PENDING OTHER MEMBERS. WHO WILL
00:19:19.958 --> 00:19:22.861
BE JOINING US SO WE'LL START
00:19:22.928 --> 00:19:28.600
WITH ITEM NUMBER ONE AB TWENTY
00:19:28.667 --> 00:19:29.201
FOUR SIXTY THREE. THIS WEEK'S
00:19:29.268 --> 00:19:31.603
BILL SO FOR THOSE OF YOU WHO
00:19:31.670 --> 00:19:33.939
ARE WATCHING AND OUT ON THE
00:19:34.006 --> 00:19:36.808
PHONES WE ARE AGAIN HOLDING A
00:19:36.875 --> 00:19:39.545
COMMITTEE HEARING TRYING TO BE
00:19:39.611 --> 00:19:41.713
SOCIALLY DISTANT AND
00:19:41.780 --> 00:19:43.348
APPROPRIATE THERE IS PLENTY OF
00:19:43.415 --> 00:19:46.051
OPPORTUNITY TO WEIGH IN EITHER
00:19:46.118 --> 00:19:48.387
TELEPHONICALLY OR IN OUR VIDEO
00:19:48.453 --> 00:19:50.222
ROOM LOOKS LIKE SOMEBODY'S IN
00:19:50.289 --> 00:19:51.323
THE VIDEO ROOM. AND THAT IS
00:19:51.390 --> 00:19:54.192
GOOD. THERE IF YOU WANT TO CALL
00:19:54.259 --> 00:19:56.929
IN AND JOIN. THERE IS A PHONE
00:19:56.995 --> 00:20:00.432
NUMBER ON THE- BROADCAST THAT
00:20:00.499 --> 00:20:02.134
YOU CAN CALL IN OR YOU CAN
00:20:02.200 --> 00:20:03.969
CHECK OUT THE COMMITTEE WEBSITE
00:20:04.036 --> 00:20:05.504
AND GET ALL THE INFORMATION
00:20:05.571 --> 00:20:08.674
THERE. SO OPERATOR IF YOU WOULD
00:20:08.740 --> 00:20:12.144
OPEN THE PHONE LINES FOR AB
00:20:12.210 --> 00:20:12.711
TWENTY FOUR SIXTY THREE. WE
00:20:12.778 --> 00:20:18.483
WILL. THEN THE AGAIN. AND AS
00:20:18.550 --> 00:20:20.619
MENTIONED BEFORE BEING PROPERLY
00:20:20.686 --> 00:20:22.621
ATTIRED IN THIS COMMITTEE IS
00:20:22.688 --> 00:20:26.158
WEARING. THE MASS SKATE FACE
00:20:26.224 --> 00:20:28.493
MAX GOOD FOR THE NEW SYSTEM MS
00:20:28.560 --> 00:20:30.596
WICKS THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR
00:20:30.662 --> 00:20:33.432
AND MEMBER. AN URBAN INSTITUTE
00:20:33.498 --> 00:20:35.167
REPORT FROM DECEMBER NINETEENTH
00:20:35.233 --> 00:20:36.702
SORRY DECEMBER TWENTY NINETEEN
00:20:36.768 --> 00:20:38.770
ESTIMATED 26% OF CALIFORNIANS
00:20:38.837 --> 00:20:40.772
HAD A DEAD IN COLLECTION. SINCE
00:20:40.839 --> 00:20:41.940
THE START OF THE COPA NINETEEN
00:20:42.007 --> 00:20:42.741
PANDEMIC CALIFORNIA'S
00:20:42.808 --> 00:20:44.242
UNEMPLOYMENT RATE JUMPED FROM
00:20:44.309 --> 00:20:46.545
FIVE POINT 5% TO RECORD FIFTEEN
00:20:46.612 --> 00:20:49.214
POINT 5% IN APRIL. WITH FOUR
00:20:49.281 --> 00:20:51.083
POINT SIX MILLION CALIFORNIANS
00:20:51.149 --> 00:20:51.717
WHO HAVE FILED FOR UNEMPLOYMENT
00:20:51.783 --> 00:20:54.086
CLAIMS. THEREFORE WITH A COVER
00:20:54.152 --> 00:20:55.287
NINETEEN CRISIS MANY
00:20:55.354 --> 00:20:56.688
CALIFORNIANS WHO MAY ALREADY BE
00:20:56.755 --> 00:20:58.657
IN DEBTS WILL FIND THEMSELVES
00:20:58.724 --> 00:21:00.559
AND EVEN MORE HARDSHIP. WITH
00:21:00.626 --> 00:21:01.760
THE INCREASE FINANCIAL STRUGGLE
00:21:01.827 --> 00:21:03.128
SOME LOW INCOME CONSUMERS AND
00:21:03.195 --> 00:21:04.596
HOMEOWNERS MAY ALSO FACE THE
00:21:04.663 --> 00:21:06.565
THREAT OF LOSING THEIR HOMES.
00:21:06.632 --> 00:21:07.532
THE EAST BAY COMMUNITY LAW
00:21:07.599 --> 00:21:09.101
CENTER COMPLETED A REPORT THAT
00:21:09.167 --> 00:21:10.335
INVESTIGATED A PROCESS THE
00:21:10.402 --> 00:21:12.437
CREDITORS HAVE BEEN. SEEKING
00:21:12.504 --> 00:21:13.305
FOR CLOSURES ON HOMES FOR
00:21:13.372 --> 00:21:15.207
JUDGMENTS BASED ON UNSECURED
00:21:15.273 --> 00:21:17.609
DEBT. THIS REPORT FROM THE EAST
00:21:17.676 --> 00:21:18.510
BAY COMMUNITY LAW CENTER FOUND
00:21:18.577 --> 00:21:19.845
THAT THESE CREDITORS HAVE BEEN
00:21:19.911 --> 00:21:21.279
FOR CLOSING HOMES BASED ON
00:21:21.346 --> 00:21:23.015
SMALL AMOUNTS OF DEBT. IN
00:21:23.081 --> 00:21:25.283
PARTICULAR THIS PRACTICE HAS
00:21:25.350 --> 00:21:25.817
BEEN AFFECTING LOW INCOME
00:21:25.884 --> 00:21:27.252
COMMUNITIES OF COLOR. THE
00:21:27.319 --> 00:21:28.487
PRACTICE OF COURSE FOR CLOSING
00:21:28.553 --> 00:21:29.988
ON HOMES BASED ON SMALL AMOUNTS
00:21:30.055 --> 00:21:30.856
OF UNSECURED DEBT IS
00:21:30.922 --> 00:21:31.890
PROBLEMATIC GIVEN THE FINANCIAL
00:21:31.957 --> 00:21:33.191
DIFFICULTIES EMERGING FROM THE
00:21:33.258 --> 00:21:35.160
COPA NINETEEN PANDEMIC. AND
00:21:35.227 --> 00:21:37.462
EXACERBATES EXISTING HOUSING
00:21:37.529 --> 00:21:38.030
HOMELESSNESS CRISIS HERE IN
00:21:38.096 --> 00:21:41.099
CALIFORNIA. AB TWENTY FOUR
00:21:41.166 --> 00:21:41.700
SIXTY THREE WILL ENSURE THAT
00:21:41.767 --> 00:21:42.634
LOW INCOME HOMEOWNERS IN
00:21:42.701 --> 00:21:43.869
CALIFORNIA WILL NOT LOSE THEIR
00:21:43.935 --> 00:21:45.570
HOMES. AS THEY ARE STRUGGLING
00:21:45.637 --> 00:21:47.439
TO PAY THEIR DEBTS ESPECIALLY
00:21:47.506 --> 00:21:47.973
DURING THE COPA NINETEEN
00:21:48.040 --> 00:21:49.808
CRISIS. THIS BILL WILL PREVENT
00:21:49.875 --> 00:21:51.276
FORECLOSURES ON A PERSON'S
00:21:51.343 --> 00:21:52.878
PRINCIPAL PLACE OF RESIDENCE
00:21:52.944 --> 00:21:55.514
AND PREVENT THE FOR THE
00:21:55.580 --> 00:21:55.981
ADDITIONAL INCREASE IN
00:21:56.048 --> 00:21:57.949
HOMELESSNESS. STAKEHOLDERS TO
00:21:58.016 --> 00:21:59.217
RAISE QUESTIONS REGARDING
00:21:59.284 --> 00:22:00.852
DEFINITIONS IN THE BILL. AND
00:22:00.919 --> 00:22:01.720
WE'VE HAD VERY PRODUCTIVE
00:22:01.787 --> 00:22:03.088
CONVERSATIONS WE WILL CONTINUE
00:22:03.155 --> 00:22:04.489
TO WORK WITH THEM TO ALLEVIATE
00:22:04.556 --> 00:22:06.358
ANY ADDITIONAL CONCERNS.
00:22:06.425 --> 00:22:07.859
CALIFORNIA THERE ARE STRUGGLING
00:22:07.926 --> 00:22:09.227
FINANCIALLY RIGHT NOW MORE THAN
00:22:09.294 --> 00:22:10.996
EVER- NEED TO TAKE STEPS TO
00:22:11.063 --> 00:22:12.597
PROVIDE PROTECTIONS TO THE MOST
00:22:12.664 --> 00:22:14.032
VULERABLE BY ENSURING THAT
00:22:14.099 --> 00:22:15.133
CALIFORNIA RESIDENTS WERE
00:22:15.200 --> 00:22:16.635
FACING FINANCIAL HARDSHIP. CAN
00:22:16.702 --> 00:22:18.203
KEEP THEIR HOMES. THIS BILL HAS
00:22:18.270 --> 00:22:19.905
BEEN- SUPPORTED BY A WIDE
00:22:19.971 --> 00:22:21.606
VARIETY OF CONSUMER GROUPS. THE
00:22:21.673 --> 00:22:22.441
WESTERN CENTER ON LAW AND
00:22:22.507 --> 00:22:24.209
POVERTY THE CALIFORNIA REALTORS
00:22:24.276 --> 00:22:26.945
ASSOCIATION AND AMONG OTHERS-
00:22:27.012 --> 00:22:27.512
AND I WOULD RESPECT FASTER I
00:22:27.579 --> 00:22:29.915
THOUGHT. THANK YOU THIS WORKS
00:22:29.981 --> 00:22:34.853
WE HAVE. TWO WITNESSES TO
00:22:34.920 --> 00:22:37.089
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT MIGUEL SOTO
00:22:37.155 --> 00:22:39.057
AND DOCTOR PRASAD
00:22:39.124 --> 00:22:41.593
KRISHNAMOORTHY AND MY THIS IS
00:22:41.660 --> 00:22:42.961
BOTH THERE ON THE TELEPHONE BUT
00:22:43.028 --> 00:22:44.863
LOOKS LIKE WE HAVE SOMEONE IN A
00:22:44.930 --> 00:22:50.902
REMOTE. VIDEO ROOM. OKAY SO DO
00:22:50.969 --> 00:22:54.806
WE HAVE MISTER SOTO OR- DR
00:22:54.873 --> 00:22:59.244
KRISHNAMOORTHY ON THE PHONE.
00:22:59.311 --> 00:23:05.484
YEAH OKAY PLEASE PROCEED. GOOD
00:23:05.550 --> 00:23:07.119
MORNING MY NAME IS SET UP AND A
00:23:07.185 --> 00:23:08.086
STAFF ATTORNEY IN CLINICAL
00:23:08.153 --> 00:23:09.421
INSTRUCTOR AT THE FIFTY
00:23:09.488 --> 00:23:10.655
LAWCENTER WHICH IS A MEMBER OF
00:23:10.722 --> 00:23:12.190
THE CALIFORNIA LOW INCOME TO A
00:23:12.257 --> 00:23:14.126
COALITION OUR CLINIC DIRECTOR
00:23:14.192 --> 00:23:15.794
UNDER THE CONSUMERS EACH YEAR
00:23:15.861 --> 00:23:16.862
WITH THAT COLLECTION MATTERS I
00:23:16.928 --> 00:23:18.396
THINK WITH MANY HOMEOWNERS ARE
00:23:18.463 --> 00:23:19.831
LOW INCOME AND MOSTLY SENIORS
00:23:19.898 --> 00:23:21.933
IMMIGRANTS AND PEOPLE OF COLOR
00:23:22.000 --> 00:23:23.068
WHO IS GOOD FOR SMALL AND TO
00:23:23.135 --> 00:23:24.970
GET THAT. POP UP IN CREDIT CARD
00:23:25.036 --> 00:23:25.971
WITHOUT THIS AROUND FIVE
00:23:26.037 --> 00:23:27.205
THOUSAND DOLLARS MANY OF THE
00:23:27.272 --> 00:23:28.840
SOMEONE OR SUCH TROUBLE PER
00:23:28.907 --> 00:23:29.574
MONTH ANYTHING YEAR TO PAY BACK
00:23:29.641 --> 00:23:31.510
THAT WITH MORE THAN ONE CALL
00:23:31.576 --> 00:23:33.211
KEEPING THE OPEN MEDICAL CARE
00:23:33.278 --> 00:23:35.347
TO REPAY A LOAN BECAUSE OF HIGH
00:23:35.413 --> 00:23:36.882
INTEREST RATE THE IMPACT ON
00:23:36.948 --> 00:23:43.221
FEET. NEVER CATCH UP AND IT.
00:23:43.288 --> 00:23:45.390
TOO WHEN IT. THE WAY TO. OTHER
00:23:45.457 --> 00:23:46.958
BIG HELP MAKE LEVY BUT EVERY
00:23:47.025 --> 00:23:48.994
QUITE OPEN ACOSTA QUESTIONS CAN
00:23:49.060 --> 00:23:49.594
I USE MY HOME I CAN'T BY THE
00:23:49.661 --> 00:23:51.296
MONEY TO PAY THIS THAT. RIGHT
00:23:51.363 --> 00:23:52.464
NOW WE HAVE TO KILL THE PEOPLE
00:23:52.531 --> 00:23:53.632
THAT YES THE FAMILY MIGHT LOSE
00:23:53.698 --> 00:23:54.466
THE WHOLE OVER THE HUNDRED
00:23:54.533 --> 00:23:55.834
UTILITY BILL. FOR THE ONE
00:23:55.901 --> 00:23:57.602
THOUSAND DOLLAR CARD TO. A
00:23:57.669 --> 00:23:59.805
COMPUTER BECAUSE IT UNNECESSARY.
00:23:59.871 --> 00:24:00.405
BELIEVE THE HARMFUL TO SEE BY
00:24:00.472 --> 00:24:01.540
HOME. LIKE PICKING UP AT THE-
00:24:01.606 --> 00:24:03.375
LONG NEVER. RETIRED SCHOOL
00:24:03.441 --> 00:24:04.676
TEACHERS CAN'T PATIENT.
00:24:04.743 --> 00:24:06.378
UNDOCUMENTED FAST FOOD WORKERS
00:24:06.444 --> 00:24:07.546
AND OTHER VOLATILE HOMEOWNERS
00:24:07.612 --> 00:24:08.847
WHO HAD LEARNED ABOUT THE RIGHT
00:24:08.914 --> 00:24:10.549
NOW. CALIFORNIA AFFECTED LET
00:24:10.615 --> 00:24:12.017
ANY UNDERTAKEN TO MAKE THAT ACT
00:24:12.083 --> 00:24:16.555
LIKE A MORTGAGE. AB TWENTY FOUR
00:24:16.621 --> 00:24:17.055
SIXTY PREFIX OF THIS AND
00:24:17.122 --> 00:24:17.656
JUSTICE. A QUESTION MARK THE
00:24:17.722 --> 00:24:18.223
WILL EXPLAIN HOW BILLS PAID
00:24:18.290 --> 00:24:19.157
LENDERS AND LEAVE THEM OTHER
00:24:19.224 --> 00:24:21.159
WAYS. A COLLECTED THAT. I'M
00:24:21.226 --> 00:24:22.594
HERE TO EXPECT UNNECESSARY THIS
00:24:22.661 --> 00:24:23.728
BILL IS TO MAKE SURE WE PROTECT
00:24:23.795 --> 00:24:24.796
OUR HOMEOWNERS WHO LIVE IN THE
00:24:24.863 --> 00:24:25.997
HOME BECAUSE THE MEDICAL
00:24:26.064 --> 00:24:27.199
BUILDING AT THE FORT. FOR A
00:24:27.265 --> 00:24:28.900
LONG PRO CARD DOES NOT AB
00:24:28.967 --> 00:24:30.302
POSSESSING AUCTIONED OFF. I'M
00:24:30.368 --> 00:24:31.102
HERE TO SHARE THE HOPE OF EVERY
00:24:31.169 --> 00:24:32.504
PEOPLE LIKE THAT NUMBER THE
00:24:32.571 --> 00:24:33.872
NEXT TIME IF PEOPLE CAN MOTHER
00:24:33.939 --> 00:24:35.307
ACT BUT IF YOU CAN BE EVICTED
00:24:35.373 --> 00:24:36.775
ELLEN PAGE THE CARD THAT. YOU
00:24:36.842 --> 00:24:38.376
CAN FIND A LOOK IN THE EYE AND
00:24:38.443 --> 00:24:42.747
SAY NO. YOUR HOME IS SAFE. WE
00:24:42.814 --> 00:24:43.882
ARE DRIVE HOME. THANK YOU. DOC
00:24:43.949 --> 00:24:48.019
CHRISTIAN MURPHY. I THANK YOU
00:24:48.086 --> 00:24:49.087
MY NAME IS WITHOUT QUESTION
00:24:49.154 --> 00:24:50.522
WITH THE AND I AM A PROFESSOR
00:24:50.589 --> 00:24:52.257
OF LAW AT UC BERKELEY SCHOOL OF
00:24:52.324 --> 00:24:53.358
LAW WHERE I TEACH AND CONDUCT
00:24:53.425 --> 00:24:55.360
RESEARCH IN THE AREAS OF
00:24:55.427 --> 00:24:55.961
FINANCIAL REGULATION AND
00:24:56.027 --> 00:24:58.196
CONTRACT LBGT FROM THE A LAW
00:24:58.263 --> 00:24:59.965
SCHOOL TO PHD IN ECONOMICS FROM
00:25:00.031 --> 00:25:01.032
THE UC BERKELEY DEPARTMENT OF
00:25:01.099 --> 00:25:02.601
ECONOMICS IN MY RESEARCH HAS
00:25:02.667 --> 00:25:04.502
BEEN PUBLISHED. IN LEADING
00:25:04.569 --> 00:25:06.037
JOURNALS AND LAW AND ECONOMICS
00:25:06.104 --> 00:25:08.373
I BELIEVE THAT AB TWO FOUR SIX
00:25:08.440 --> 00:25:09.674
THREE WILL MAKE CONSUMERS
00:25:09.741 --> 00:25:11.376
BETTER OFF- FIRST AND FOREMOST
00:25:11.443 --> 00:25:12.978
THAT MIGUEL EXPLAINED IT WILL
00:25:13.044 --> 00:25:15.080
HELP JUDGMENT DEBTORS TO KEEP
00:25:15.146 --> 00:25:16.014
THEIR HOMES IN THIS IS AN
00:25:16.081 --> 00:25:18.416
ESPECIALLY TIED THE CONCERN- AT
00:25:18.483 --> 00:25:19.584
CALIFORNIA'S CAME INTO THIS
00:25:19.651 --> 00:25:21.419
CRISIS WITH THE HIGHEST PER
00:25:21.486 --> 00:25:22.954
CAPITA DEBT TOTALS IN THE
00:25:23.021 --> 00:25:24.723
COUNTRY AND CURRENTLY HOUSEHOLD
00:25:24.789 --> 00:25:28.960
BORROW TO REPLACE LOST INCOME.
00:25:29.027 --> 00:25:29.594
IN THE MIDST OF COLD AT NINETY.
00:25:29.661 --> 00:25:31.730
SECONDLY AB TWO FOUR TWO FOUR
00:25:31.796 --> 00:25:32.330
SIX THREE UNLIKELY TO HAVE ANY
00:25:32.397 --> 00:25:34.833
APPRECIABLE EFFECT. ON CREDIT
00:25:34.900 --> 00:25:36.434
MARKETS OVERALL AND THIS IS
00:25:36.501 --> 00:25:38.670
BECAUSE THE OVERALL NUMBER OF
00:25:38.737 --> 00:25:40.005
FOR SALE OUTSIDE OF.
00:25:40.071 --> 00:25:41.172
TRADITIONAL FOR COOK
00:25:41.239 --> 00:25:42.908
FORECLOSURE AND BANKRUPTCY IS
00:25:42.974 --> 00:25:44.142
VERY SMALL IF YOU LOOK AT THE
00:25:44.209 --> 00:25:45.744
EAST PLEASE TAKE MANY DOCTORS
00:25:45.810 --> 00:25:47.545
REPORT. IT'S ON THE ORDER OF
00:25:47.612 --> 00:25:49.881
SEVERAL HUNDRED A YEAR. WHEREAS
00:25:49.948 --> 00:25:51.449
THERE ARE ABOUT SIXTY THOUSAND
00:25:51.516 --> 00:25:53.251
FORECLOSURES AND ABOUT SIXTY
00:25:53.318 --> 00:25:54.219
THOUSAND BANKRUPTCY FILING IN
00:25:54.286 --> 00:25:56.421
CALIFORNIA THE LITTLE IN IN IN
00:25:56.488 --> 00:25:57.355
IN A GIVEN YEAR. SO THIS IS A
00:25:57.422 --> 00:25:59.090
VERY SMALL LITTLE UP LOOK AT
00:25:59.157 --> 00:26:00.292
THE PARK FROM THE STANDPOINT OF
00:26:00.358 --> 00:26:02.193
THE OVERALL CALIFORNIA ECONOMY
00:26:02.260 --> 00:26:03.395
AND OF COURSE IT'S VERY
00:26:03.461 --> 00:26:05.497
IMPORTANT TO THE PEOPLE WHO WHO
00:26:05.563 --> 00:26:07.432
UNDERGO. ALSO KEEP IN MIND THAT
00:26:07.499 --> 00:26:08.600
THE RIGHT OF MORTGAGE AND ALL
00:26:08.667 --> 00:26:09.968
THOSE OTHER SECURED LENDERS.
00:26:10.035 --> 00:26:11.536
ARE COMPLETELY UNAFFECTED ARE
00:26:11.603 --> 00:26:13.571
MOSTLY UNAFFECTED. AS WE ARE
00:26:13.638 --> 00:26:14.706
THE RIGHT THE UNSECURED LENDERS
00:26:14.773 --> 00:26:16.341
IN THE TRADITIONAL FORECLOSURE
00:26:16.408 --> 00:26:17.909
OR IN A BANKRUPTCY SO ALL
00:26:17.976 --> 00:26:19.844
PROJECTS THAT THE KIND OF. ACT
00:26:19.911 --> 00:26:21.479
AND YOUR BEFORE WITH A BIT OF
00:26:21.546 --> 00:26:23.982
THE FOR THE ACTION EFFECTS ON
00:26:24.049 --> 00:26:24.783
CREDIT MARKETS ARE LIKELY TO BE
00:26:24.849 --> 00:26:27.819
SMALL. FINALLY A TWO FORTY
00:26:27.886 --> 00:26:28.787
THREE PRESERVES THE RIGHT TO
00:26:28.853 --> 00:26:30.155
SEEK A COURT ORDERED SALE FOR
00:26:30.221 --> 00:26:31.323
OTHER CREDITORS BUT DID
00:26:31.389 --> 00:26:33.091
<c.cyan>UARDIANS. SEEKING FELT THE</c>
00:26:33.158 --> 00:26:37.128
PORT AND AFTER THE VICTIM SO
00:26:37.195 --> 00:26:37.729
THEIR RIGHTS ARE UNAFFECTED.
00:26:37.796 --> 00:26:38.763
THE GOOD AT WHAT WE TYPICALLY
00:26:38.830 --> 00:26:40.031
DO NOT RESEARCH THAT ABOUT WHAT
00:26:40.098 --> 00:26:41.633
AB TWO FOUR SIX THREE LIKELY
00:26:41.700 --> 00:26:44.102
EFFECTS WILL BE- WE- GENERALLY
00:26:44.169 --> 00:26:46.304
LOOK TO- PAPERS THAT STUDY
00:26:46.371 --> 00:26:47.806
EFFECTIVE INCREASES IN THE
00:26:47.872 --> 00:26:49.307
HOMESTEAD EXEMPTION. IN THE
00:26:49.374 --> 00:26:50.608
QUEUE AND ACT LOOKS PLAYED WHAT
00:26:50.675 --> 00:26:52.544
THE GOOD AT THE ELEGY. IF WE
00:26:52.610 --> 00:26:53.712
TAKE THAT HOMESTEAD EXEMPTION
00:26:53.778 --> 00:26:56.314
RESEARCH AB TWO FOUR SIX THREE
00:26:56.381 --> 00:26:57.816
IS LIKELY TO ACTUALLY INCREASE
00:26:57.882 --> 00:26:59.517
THE TOTAL AMOUNT OF ON SECURE
00:26:59.584 --> 00:27:01.052
CREDIT. THAT THE TEAM BY
00:27:01.119 --> 00:27:03.555
CONSUMERS. AND INCREASE WILL BE
00:27:03.621 --> 00:27:04.756
LARGEST FOR LOW INCOME
00:27:04.823 --> 00:27:06.758
HOMEOWNERS. AND THE REASON WHY
00:27:06.825 --> 00:27:08.860
IS THAT AB TWO TO FOUR SIXTY
00:27:08.927 --> 00:27:09.961
WILL ACTUALLY INCREASE CREDIT
00:27:10.028 --> 00:27:12.330
DEMAND AMONG BORROWERS. WHO
00:27:12.397 --> 00:27:13.398
VALUE THE INSURANCE THAT IT
00:27:13.465 --> 00:27:15.500
PROVIDES. AND THE EXISTING
00:27:15.567 --> 00:27:16.801
EMPIRICAL RESEARCH SUGGESTS
00:27:16.868 --> 00:27:18.803
THAT THIS DEMAND AFFECT
00:27:18.870 --> 00:27:21.339
OUTWEIGH ANY SUPPLY BACKED. UP
00:27:21.406 --> 00:27:25.944
TO THE- BY LENDERS. AB FOUR SIX
00:27:26.011 --> 00:27:27.045
THREE I'D LIKE LOW FLUX. IN
00:27:27.112 --> 00:27:28.513
CONSUMER EXPAND THE OF TIME IN
00:27:28.580 --> 00:27:30.181
THINK ABOUT THE SIMPLY IN THE
00:27:30.248 --> 00:27:31.316
EVENT OF A FORCED HOMES HELP
00:27:31.383 --> 00:27:32.484
THAT WOULD NORMALLY HAPPEN
00:27:32.550 --> 00:27:34.386
UNDER EXISTING LAW THAT DIDN'T
00:27:34.452 --> 00:27:35.987
HAPPEN CONSUMERS WILL BE ABLE
00:27:36.054 --> 00:27:37.055
TO STAND. UP SPEND MORE ON THE
00:27:37.122 --> 00:27:39.891
SHELVES. THIRDLY AB TWO FOUR
00:27:39.958 --> 00:27:41.226
SIX WITH UNLIKELY THE FACT
00:27:41.292 --> 00:27:42.260
DELINQUENCY THAT ALL IN
00:27:42.327 --> 00:27:44.863
UNSECURED MARKETS. IT MAY HAVE
00:27:44.929 --> 00:27:45.897
A SMALL INCREASE IN INTEREST
00:27:45.964 --> 00:27:47.165
RATES FOR SOME SAID OF
00:27:47.232 --> 00:27:50.702
BORROWERS. AND FINALLY AB TWO
00:27:50.769 --> 00:27:51.336
FOUR SIX THREE UNLIKELY TO HAVE
00:27:51.403 --> 00:27:53.004
ANY EFFECT AT ALL ON TO CHURCH
00:27:53.071 --> 00:27:54.539
MARKETS IS IN NO AFFECT ON
00:27:54.606 --> 00:27:55.807
INTEREST RATES NO AFFECT ON
00:27:55.874 --> 00:27:57.776
CLEVELAND SEIZE. UPPER HOUSING
00:27:57.842 --> 00:27:59.244
AUTOMOBILES AND OTHER CONSUMER
00:27:59.310 --> 00:28:01.813
DURABLES. UP FINALLY AS I
00:28:01.880 --> 00:28:03.181
MENTIONED BEFORE JUST BECAUSE
00:28:03.248 --> 00:28:04.783
THE NUMBER OF PORTS HOME SALES
00:28:04.849 --> 00:28:05.683
OUTSIDE A FORECLOSURE A
00:28:05.750 --> 00:28:07.786
BANKRUPTCY A SMALL ALL OF THE
00:28:07.852 --> 00:28:12.757
FACT. THAT THEY DO EXIST. ARE
00:28:12.824 --> 00:28:13.691
LIKELY TO BE VERY SMALL. THESE
00:28:13.758 --> 00:28:14.292
REASONS I BELIEVE. WE BETTER
00:28:14.359 --> 00:28:16.327
OFF AS A RESULT OF AB TO FORCE
00:28:16.394 --> 00:28:17.328
THREE. AND I. BECAUSE THAT YOU
00:28:17.395 --> 00:28:20.732
GO A THIS BILL. THANK YOU.
00:28:20.799 --> 00:28:22.133
BEFORE WE GO TO OTHER WITNESSES
00:28:22.200 --> 00:28:23.735
I'D LIKE TO STYLE SAPPORO. CALL
00:28:23.802 --> 00:28:31.910
THE ROLL PLEASE. STONE HERE
00:28:31.976 --> 00:28:38.049
STONE HERE GALLAGHER. CHAO CHOW
00:28:38.116 --> 00:28:43.588
HERE TO. GONZALEZ. GONZALEZ
00:28:43.655 --> 00:28:47.192
PRESENT HOLDEN. KALRA KALRA
00:28:47.258 --> 00:28:53.598
HERE KILEY. MAIENSCHEIN
00:28:53.665 --> 00:28:57.168
OBERNOLTE OBERNOLTE HERE YES.
00:28:57.235 --> 00:29:00.672
REYES PRESENT. THANK YOU WE DO
00:29:00.738 --> 00:29:03.308
HAVE A QUORUM. IS THERE ANYONE
00:29:03.374 --> 00:29:05.276
IN THE HEARING ROOM WOULD LIKE
00:29:05.343 --> 00:29:05.877
TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OF THIS
00:29:05.944 --> 00:29:08.847
BILL. ALL RIGHT SEE NINE
00:29:08.913 --> 00:29:11.015
OPERATOR. THEY'RE OPEN UP THE
00:29:11.082 --> 00:29:12.684
LINES FOR ANYONE ON THE PHONE
00:29:12.750 --> 00:29:14.352
WHO WOULD LIKE TO. GIVE US
00:29:14.419 --> 00:29:16.221
THEIR NAME THEIR AFFILIATION IN
00:29:16.287 --> 00:29:19.157
SUPPORT OF AB TWENTY FOUR SIXTY
00:29:19.224 --> 00:29:22.894
THREE. KILL IF YOU'RE INTO PART
00:29:22.961 --> 00:29:24.662
PLEASE PRESS ONE DIDN'T GIRL AT
00:29:24.729 --> 00:29:27.232
THE TIME WE'LL GO TO LINE
00:29:27.298 --> 00:29:29.901
TWENTY SIX PLEASE GO AHEAD.
00:29:29.968 --> 00:29:31.402
GOOD MORNING CHAIR MEMBERS CAN
00:29:31.469 --> 00:29:33.538
YELL CANDOR CARTER ON BEHALF OF
00:29:33.605 --> 00:29:34.906
THE NATIONAL CONSUMER LAW
00:29:34.973 --> 00:29:36.841
CLINIC IN STRONG SUPPORT. THANK
00:29:36.908 --> 00:29:41.679
YOU. BILL GO TO LINE TWENTY
00:29:41.746 --> 00:29:45.683
PLEASE I HAD. GOOD MORNING
00:29:45.750 --> 00:29:46.451
CHAIRMAN FOUND IN MEMBERS THIS
00:29:46.518 --> 00:29:47.619
IS LEE FERRAN THE DIRECTOR OF
00:29:47.685 --> 00:29:48.920
LITIGATION PRABANDHA WITH THE
00:29:48.987 --> 00:29:50.155
PUBLIC LAWCENTER IN ORANGE
00:29:50.221 --> 00:29:51.756
COUNTY AND WE ARE IN STRONG
00:29:51.823 --> 00:29:53.658
SUPPORT OF AB TWENTY FOUR FIFTY
00:29:53.725 --> 00:30:01.199
THREE. THANK YOU. LINE NINETEEN.
00:30:01.266 --> 00:30:02.433
THAT ARE LIKE ONCE IN A JACKET
00:30:02.500 --> 00:30:03.701
AND A RESCUE CENTER THE
00:30:03.768 --> 00:30:05.670
PARTICIPATION OF CAMPUS WITHOUT
00:30:05.737 --> 00:30:10.008
WE ARE INSTRUCTED OF AB. TWENTY
00:30:10.074 --> 00:30:12.577
FOUR SIXTY THREE. THANK YOU.
00:30:12.644 --> 00:30:16.247
THANK TWENTY ONE. JANUARY
00:30:16.314 --> 00:30:17.282
TERRACE ON BEHALF OF THE
00:30:17.348 --> 00:30:18.683
CONSUMER FEDERATION OF
00:30:18.750 --> 00:30:26.925
CALIFORNIA AND SUPPORT. NINE
00:30:26.991 --> 00:30:27.759
THIRTY TWO. GOOD MORNING ANNA
00:30:27.825 --> 00:30:28.693
BACK ON BEHALF OF THE
00:30:28.760 --> 00:30:29.994
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF BILL
00:30:30.061 --> 00:30:40.505
CLINTON OR. LINE THIRTY ONE.
00:30:40.572 --> 00:30:41.105
FOR NINE THIRTY WHEN YOUR LINE
00:30:41.172 --> 00:30:47.212
IS OPEN. BUT NOT THE LINE
00:30:47.278 --> 00:30:50.815
TWENTY FIVE YOUR MIND IS OPEN.
00:30:50.882 --> 00:30:54.018
WELL ACTUALLY PART CAN ONLY
00:30:54.085 --> 00:30:56.421
THAT DEREK LEGAL SERVICES. AND
00:30:56.487 --> 00:30:58.256
WE ARE IN STRONG SUPPORTER OF
00:30:58.323 --> 00:31:02.894
THE. EIGHTY TWENTY FOUR SIXTY
00:31:02.961 --> 00:31:03.494
THREE. IF THERE ARE ANY OTHER
00:31:03.561 --> 00:31:05.063
THAN SUPPORT PLEASE PRESS ONE
00:31:05.129 --> 00:31:11.536
TO ZERO AT THIS TIME. I KNOW
00:31:11.603 --> 00:31:12.870
OTHERS IN SUPPORT GREAT THANK
00:31:12.937 --> 00:31:15.006
YOU I DON'T HAVE ANY LISTED
00:31:15.073 --> 00:31:16.441
OPPOSITION BUT IS THERE ANYONE
00:31:16.507 --> 00:31:19.010
ON THE LINE. OR OTHERWISE WHO
00:31:19.077 --> 00:31:19.477
WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN
00:31:19.544 --> 00:31:34.959
OPPOSITION. OPERATOR YOU HAVE
00:31:35.026 --> 00:31:35.460
ANYONE IN THE QUEUE FOR
00:31:35.526 --> 00:31:38.997
OPPOSITION. YOU'RE IN
00:31:39.063 --> 00:31:40.932
OPPOSITION THE FIRST ONE DIDN'T
00:31:40.999 --> 00:31:42.767
ZERO AT THIS TIME WE DO HAVE
00:31:42.834 --> 00:31:43.334
PEOPLE QUEUING UP ONE MOMENT
00:31:43.401 --> 00:31:49.540
PLEASE. THANK THIRTY YOUR LINE
00:31:49.607 --> 00:31:52.777
IS OPEN. MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS
00:31:52.844 --> 00:31:54.445
ROBERT WILSON WITH A CALIFORNIA
00:31:54.512 --> 00:31:56.147
CREDIT UNION LEAGUE WE'RE NOT
00:31:56.214 --> 00:31:58.216
OFFICIAL POSITION ON THE BILL-
00:31:58.283 --> 00:31:59.550
BUT APPRECIATE THE WORK THAT
00:31:59.617 --> 00:32:00.685
THE AUTHORED THE SPONSORS HAVE
00:32:00.752 --> 00:32:02.553
BEEN DOING TO LEVY A
00:32:02.620 --> 00:32:03.154
TELEMARKETER EARNS THANK YOU.
00:32:03.221 --> 00:32:11.195
THANK YOU. AND TWENTY SEVEN.
00:32:11.262 --> 00:32:12.363
GOOD MORNING MISTER CHAIR AND
00:32:12.430 --> 00:32:13.031
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE
00:32:13.097 --> 00:32:13.998
MELANIE QUICK THAT THE
00:32:14.065 --> 00:32:15.700
CALIFORNIA THINKERS AT THE
00:32:15.767 --> 00:32:17.835
BEACH AND- ECHO THE COMMENTS
00:32:17.902 --> 00:32:19.804
BEFORE ME GREAT PUBLIC DIALOGUE
00:32:19.871 --> 00:32:20.872
THAT WE'VE HAD WITH THE AUTHOR
00:32:20.938 --> 00:32:22.607
AND FUN THIRD THIS IS AN
00:32:22.674 --> 00:32:24.208
INCREDIBLY RARELY USED TOOL
00:32:24.275 --> 00:32:25.743
HOWEVER WE LOOK FORWARD TO
00:32:25.810 --> 00:32:27.178
CONTINUING OUR DIALOGUE AND
00:32:27.245 --> 00:32:28.980
PERHAPS THE PUBLISHING FAMILY
00:32:29.047 --> 00:32:30.114
SOME REASONABLE PARAMETERS
00:32:30.181 --> 00:32:33.484
AROUND ABOUT. THANK YOU. THANK
00:32:33.551 --> 00:32:35.420
YOU. AND THERE ARE NO OTHERS
00:32:35.486 --> 00:32:39.057
ENOUGH OF THAT. GREAT THANK YOU
00:32:39.123 --> 00:32:39.624
I WILL THEN BRING IT BACK TO
00:32:39.691 --> 00:32:41.726
THE COMMITTEE. AUSTIN'S THROUGH
00:32:41.793 --> 00:32:45.129
COMMITTEE MEMBERS. RIGHT SEEING
00:32:45.196 --> 00:32:46.864
NONE THIS WITH YOU MAY CLOSE
00:32:46.931 --> 00:32:48.333
RESPECT FAST FOR AN AYE VOTE
00:32:48.399 --> 00:32:50.234
THANK YOU LOOKING FOR A MOTION
00:32:50.301 --> 00:32:52.337
THE MOTION IS TO PASS. THANK
00:32:52.403 --> 00:32:55.006
YOU WE DO HAVE A MOTION AND A
00:32:55.073 --> 00:32:58.676
SECOND KALRA PLEASE. STONE HI
00:32:58.743 --> 00:33:04.849
STERN AYE GALLAGHER. JO JO I TO
00:33:04.916 --> 00:33:08.019
CONSOLES HI GONZALEZ I HOLDEN
00:33:08.086 --> 00:33:13.491
KALRA KALRA AYE KILEY.
00:33:13.558 --> 00:33:23.234
MAIENSCHEIN OBERNOLTE. REYES HI.
00:33:23.301 --> 00:33:44.722
REZAI. KILEY. THAT HAS FIVE A
00:33:44.789 --> 00:33:45.723
FIVE ALREADY NEEDS ONE MORE
00:33:45.790 --> 00:33:47.358
SOMEONE PUT THIS FEDERAL CALL
00:33:47.425 --> 00:33:51.195
THANK YOU. THANK YOU ALL RIGHT
00:33:51.262 --> 00:33:52.797
THAT BRINGS US TO ITEM NUMBER
00:33:52.864 --> 00:33:54.499
TWO AB TWENTY THREE THIRTY
00:33:54.565 --> 00:33:56.567
EIGHT MS WEBER. OPERATOR WOULD
00:33:56.634 --> 00:33:59.804
YOU OPEN THE LINES FOR AB
00:33:59.871 --> 00:34:04.409
TWENTY THREE THIRTY EIGHT. MY
00:34:04.475 --> 00:34:12.250
JOB IN. THANK YOU. GOOD MORNING
00:34:12.316 --> 00:34:14.185
MISTER CHAIR AND MEMBERS- I'M
00:34:14.252 --> 00:34:17.255
HERE TO PRESENT TO YOU AB
00:34:17.321 --> 00:34:17.855
TWENTY THREE THIRTY EIGHT AND
00:34:17.922 --> 00:34:18.990
I'M ALWAYS EXCITED WHEN I GET A
00:34:19.056 --> 00:34:20.958
CHANCE TO PRESENT A BILL BACKED
00:34:21.025 --> 00:34:22.593
UP COMES OUT OF MY NEIGHBORHOOD
00:34:22.660 --> 00:34:24.929
OUT OF THE COMMUNITY THIS WAS A
00:34:24.996 --> 00:34:26.531
PART OF A THERE OUGHT TO BE A
00:34:26.597 --> 00:34:28.032
LAW ACTIVITY WE DO EVERY YEAR
00:34:28.099 --> 00:34:29.901
WE GET RECOMMENDATIONS AND IT'S
00:34:29.967 --> 00:34:31.269
GOOD TO SEE EVERY NOW AND THEN
00:34:31.335 --> 00:34:32.403
A RECOMMENDATION COMING FROM
00:34:32.470 --> 00:34:33.938
THE CONSTITUENTS. THAT MOVES
00:34:34.005 --> 00:34:35.039
ALL THE WAY THROUGH THE PROCESS
00:34:35.106 --> 00:34:36.741
OF ACTUALLY GET STATE-
00:34:36.808 --> 00:34:38.776
ORGANIZATIONAL SUPPORTS SO THIS
00:34:38.843 --> 00:34:41.212
AB TWENTY THREE THIRTY EIGHT
00:34:41.279 --> 00:34:43.481
COME FROM A AN ATTORNEY IN MY
00:34:43.548 --> 00:34:44.449
DISTRICT WHO DEALS WITH THIS
00:34:44.515 --> 00:34:47.118
ISSUE THIS BILL WOULD ADDRESS
00:34:47.185 --> 00:34:47.919
THE MISALIGNMENT AND
00:34:47.985 --> 00:34:49.687
CALIFORNIA'S PENAL AND CIVIL
00:34:49.754 --> 00:34:51.289
CODES AND IT'S AS IT RELATES TO
00:34:51.355 --> 00:34:53.257
FAMILY COURT THIS BILL WILL
00:34:53.324 --> 00:34:55.393
PROVIDE A PROBATION AND ALL AND
00:34:55.460 --> 00:34:56.828
AN ADDITIONAL AND ALTERNATIVE
00:34:56.894 --> 00:34:58.763
SENTENCING OPTION. WHEN AN
00:34:58.830 --> 00:35:00.131
INDIVIDUAL IS FOUND IN CONTEMPT
00:35:00.198 --> 00:35:01.632
OF THE FAMILY LAW COURT ORDER
00:35:01.699 --> 00:35:03.701
JUDGMENT UNDER CURRENT LAW
00:35:03.768 --> 00:35:05.236
FAMILY COURT JUDGES ARE ONLY
00:35:05.303 --> 00:35:06.971
ALLOWED TO IMPOSE COMMUNITY
00:35:07.038 --> 00:35:09.106
SERVICE AND OR IMPRISONMENT FOR
00:35:09.173 --> 00:35:11.008
NOT MORE THAN FIVE DAYS
00:35:11.075 --> 00:35:12.743
ALTHOUGH CONTENT MAY BE USEFUL
00:35:12.810 --> 00:35:14.445
TOOL FOR GAINING COMPLIANCE
00:35:14.512 --> 00:35:15.513
WITH A COURT ORDER ACTUAL
00:35:15.580 --> 00:35:17.315
CHRISTMAS OR COMMUNITY SERVICE
00:35:17.381 --> 00:35:18.883
IS NOT ASSIST IN GETTING A
00:35:18.950 --> 00:35:21.786
SUPPORT ORDER PAID. INDIVIDUALS
00:35:21.853 --> 00:35:24.489
CHARGE MULTIPLE OF CONTEMPT FOR
00:35:24.555 --> 00:35:26.424
FAILURE TO PAY CHILD SUPPORT AS
00:35:26.491 --> 00:35:29.327
UP OVER TIME THIS THIS THANKS
00:35:29.393 --> 00:35:36.200
OF PRIMARILY. THOSE WHO HAVE
00:35:36.267 --> 00:35:36.701
OUR LIVE FROM PAYCHECK.
00:35:36.767 --> 00:35:39.170
APPROVED BY IN THE- MASON ALOW
00:35:39.237 --> 00:35:39.770
THEM TO WORK IN COME UP WITH
00:35:39.837 --> 00:35:41.205
THE MONEY THEY OWE. THIS WAS
00:35:41.272 --> 00:35:42.139
THIS SOME EXT THE APPS
00:35:42.206 --> 00:35:43.941
AVAILABLE TO A JUDGE PURSUANT
00:35:44.008 --> 00:35:46.544
TO A CAP OF FAMILY COAT COAT
00:35:46.611 --> 00:35:48.112
PROBATION CAN OFTEN IS A BETTER
00:35:48.179 --> 00:35:49.847
ALTERNATIVE THAN IMPRISONMENT
00:35:49.914 --> 00:35:51.582
IN THESE CIRCUMSTANCES
00:35:51.649 --> 00:35:53.518
FURTHERMORE GRANTING PROBATION
00:35:53.584 --> 00:35:55.186
ON A CONDITIONAL SENTENCE WOULD
00:35:55.253 --> 00:35:56.854
IN MANY CASES HAVE THE
00:35:56.921 --> 00:35:59.156
ADVANTAGE OF INCREASING THE
00:35:59.223 --> 00:36:01.092
ODDS FOR OBTAINING COMPLIANCE
00:36:01.158 --> 00:36:02.593
WITH HIM WITH THE IMPOSITION OF
00:36:02.660 --> 00:36:03.761
PROBATION OR A CONDITIONAL
00:36:03.828 --> 00:36:05.730
SENTENCE THE PARTY WHO IS
00:36:05.796 --> 00:36:08.266
SUBJECT TO THE COLD ORDER HAS
00:36:08.332 --> 00:36:09.166
AN OPPORTUNITY TO GET BACK ON
00:36:09.233 --> 00:36:12.670
TRACK AND- I WITH A COURT ORDER.
00:36:12.737 --> 00:36:13.871
BILL IS SPONSORED THE LAWSUIT.
00:36:13.938 --> 00:36:15.740
ALL OF THE ALSO GIVES ME THE
00:36:15.806 --> 00:36:17.909
LAW OFFICE OF DON DEAL OF CLASS
00:36:17.975 --> 00:36:18.976
WHO'S THE INDIVIDUAL IN MY
00:36:19.043 --> 00:36:20.811
DISTRICT WHO WHO PROVIDED THIS
00:36:20.878 --> 00:36:22.580
WHO MAVIS IDEAS AND
00:36:22.647 --> 00:36:24.549
SUGGESTIONS- BUT SEVERAL OF THE
00:36:24.615 --> 00:36:25.917
ORGANIZATIONS HAVE LIVED THEIR
00:36:25.983 --> 00:36:27.151
SUPPORT TO THE CALIFORNIA.
00:36:27.218 --> 00:36:29.420
ATTORNEYS FOR CRIMINAL JUSTICE
00:36:29.487 --> 00:36:30.821
THE CALIFORNIA LAWYERS
00:36:30.888 --> 00:36:32.356
ASSOCIATION THEIR FAMILY LAW
00:36:32.423 --> 00:36:34.191
SECTION LOS ANGELES COUNTY BAR
00:36:34.258 --> 00:36:35.893
ASSOCIATION THEIR FAMILY LAW
00:36:35.960 --> 00:36:37.461
SECTION AND THE WESTERN CENTER
00:36:37.528 --> 00:36:39.263
ON LAW AND POVERTY. HERE TO
00:36:39.330 --> 00:36:41.332
SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF THIS SOME
00:36:41.399 --> 00:36:42.733
OF THIS BILL FOR TECHNICAL
00:36:42.800 --> 00:36:44.902
ASSISTANCE IS DON DELECOUR
00:36:44.969 --> 00:36:48.005
HERSELF- FROM DEAL OF QUIET LAW
00:36:48.072 --> 00:36:49.507
FIRM- THIS BILL HAS NO
00:36:49.574 --> 00:36:51.409
OPPOSITION AND- AND I
00:36:51.475 --> 00:36:53.511
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR AUTO.
00:36:53.578 --> 00:36:54.946
THANK YOU I HAVE ONE LISTED
00:36:55.012 --> 00:36:56.547
WITH THIS AND THAT IS DONE THE
00:36:56.614 --> 00:36:59.083
LACK WERE. ON THE TELEPHONE. GO
00:36:59.150 --> 00:37:02.720
AHEAD PLEASE. GOOD MORNING MY
00:37:02.787 --> 00:37:04.555
NAME IS DON BELL AQUA I AM A
00:37:04.622 --> 00:37:06.090
PRIVATE ATTORNEY IN SAN DIEGO
00:37:06.157 --> 00:37:08.459
COUNTY A CERTIFIED FAMILY LAW
00:37:08.526 --> 00:37:10.528
SPECIALIST FORMER PRESIDENT OF
00:37:10.595 --> 00:37:12.330
THE SAN DIEGO FAMILY LAW PART
00:37:12.396 --> 00:37:14.065
THOUGH SHE XIN. AND A COURT
00:37:14.131 --> 00:37:15.833
APPOINTED ATTORNEY FOR THE
00:37:15.900 --> 00:37:17.935
OFFICE OF ASSIGNED COUNSEL BOTH
00:37:18.002 --> 00:37:19.670
ORGANIZATIONS HAVE WRITTEN
00:37:19.737 --> 00:37:21.405
LETTERS OF STRONG SUPPORT FOR
00:37:21.472 --> 00:37:24.842
AT. TWENTY THREE THIRTY EIGHT.
00:37:24.909 --> 00:37:25.876
ONE MAN THE CODE OF CIVIL
00:37:25.943 --> 00:37:28.179
PROCEDURE SECTION TWELVE
00:37:28.245 --> 00:37:28.679
EIGHTEEN AND AUTHORIZED
00:37:28.746 --> 00:37:30.314
PROBATION AS A SENTENCING
00:37:30.381 --> 00:37:32.149
OPTION IN FAMILY COURT CONTEMPT
00:37:32.216 --> 00:37:35.953
CASES. AB TWENTY THREE THIRTY
00:37:36.020 --> 00:37:36.454
EIGHT OFFERED THE SAME
00:37:36.520 --> 00:37:38.122
SENTENCING OPTION OF PROBATION
00:37:38.189 --> 00:37:40.491
ADNAN MISDEMEANOR AND CRIMINAL
00:37:40.558 --> 00:37:42.026
CONTEMPT CASES UNDER THE PENAL
00:37:42.093 --> 00:37:45.196
CODE. IT WILL REDUCE COSTS FOR
00:37:45.262 --> 00:37:48.132
COURT STAFFING COUNSEL FEES AND
00:37:48.199 --> 00:37:50.468
COSTS OF INCARCERATION BY
00:37:50.534 --> 00:37:52.103
ALLOWING FOR PLEA AGREEMENTS TO
00:37:52.169 --> 00:37:54.605
OCCUR IN LIEU OF TRIAL THIS IS
00:37:54.672 --> 00:37:56.340
GOOD FOR BOTH THE PROSECUTION
00:37:56.407 --> 00:37:58.976
AND THE DEFENSE. A GIVE JUDGES
00:37:59.043 --> 00:38:00.277
THE DISCRETION TO LOOK AT THE
00:38:00.344 --> 00:38:02.446
REASONING WHY FOR EXAMPLE
00:38:02.513 --> 00:38:04.315
APPARENTLY UNABLE TO PAY
00:38:04.382 --> 00:38:06.350
SUPPORT PERHAPS BECAUSE OF THE
00:38:06.417 --> 00:38:08.419
LOSS OF A JOB. IT OFFERS THE
00:38:08.486 --> 00:38:10.554
GUILTY PARTY THE ABILITY TO
00:38:10.621 --> 00:38:12.323
CONFORM TO THE CORRECT BEHAVIOR
00:38:12.390 --> 00:38:14.158
SUCH AS CONDITIONING PROBATION
00:38:14.225 --> 00:38:15.726
ON COMPLIANCE WITH A COURT
00:38:15.793 --> 00:38:17.928
ORDER TO PAY SUPPORT. THAT'S A
00:38:17.995 --> 00:38:19.997
WIN WIN FOR BOTH SIDES THE
00:38:20.064 --> 00:38:21.766
PARTY PAINT SUPPORT WILL NOT
00:38:21.832 --> 00:38:23.834
LOSE THEIR JOBS MAY ACTUALLY
00:38:23.901 --> 00:38:25.469
GAIN EMPLOYMENT. WELL THE
00:38:25.536 --> 00:38:27.371
SUPPORTED PARTY RECEIVED A MUCH
00:38:27.438 --> 00:38:28.973
NEEDED SUPPORT TO TAKE CARE OF
00:38:29.040 --> 00:38:31.175
CHILDREN. FINALLY THIS BILL
00:38:31.242 --> 00:38:33.310
ALSO CLARIFIED A SORT OF
00:38:33.377 --> 00:38:34.679
AMBIGUITY IN THE CURRENT
00:38:34.745 --> 00:38:37.548
STATUTE BETWEEN SUBSECTION A
00:38:37.615 --> 00:38:39.116
AND THAT SECTION THREE.
00:38:39.183 --> 00:38:41.852
SUBSECTION SEAT IS WHAT APPLIES
00:38:41.919 --> 00:38:43.287
TO ALL CASES BROUGHT INTO THE
00:38:43.354 --> 00:38:46.724
FAMILY CODE SECTION SECTION HEY
00:38:46.791 --> 00:38:48.526
APPLY TO ALL OTHER CIVIL CASES.
00:38:48.592 --> 00:38:50.394
BUT THAT IS NOT CLEAR BECAUSE
00:38:50.461 --> 00:38:51.896
THERE IS NO LANGUAGE CURRENTLY
00:38:51.962 --> 00:38:53.931
IN THE STATUTE WHICH STATES
00:38:53.998 --> 00:38:55.299
THAT AND SO THERE IS A
00:38:55.366 --> 00:38:58.836
CORRECTION IN AB TWENTY THREE
00:38:58.903 --> 00:38:59.437
THIRTY EIGHT TO MAKE SURE THAT
00:38:59.503 --> 00:39:01.272
THIS IS CLEAR. I WANT TO THANK
00:39:01.338 --> 00:39:02.506
DOCTOR WEBER FOR ENERGY SEEN
00:39:02.573 --> 00:39:03.874
THIS BILL AND THE COMMITTEE FOR
00:39:03.941 --> 00:39:07.111
YOUR CONSIDERATION WE URGE AN
00:39:07.178 --> 00:39:10.181
AYE VOTE. THANK YOU. IS THERE
00:39:10.247 --> 00:39:12.283
ANYONE IN THE HEARING ROOM WHO
00:39:12.349 --> 00:39:12.883
WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT
00:39:12.950 --> 00:39:15.619
OF THIS BILL. ALL RIGHT SEE
00:39:15.686 --> 00:39:17.254
NONE OPERATOR IS THERE ANYONE
00:39:17.321 --> 00:39:18.689
ON THE LINE WHO WOULD LIKE TO
00:39:18.756 --> 00:39:20.725
SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF AB TWENTY
00:39:20.791 --> 00:39:23.427
THREE THIRTY EIGHT. Q. IF
00:39:23.494 --> 00:39:24.829
YOU'RE INTO PART PLEASE PRESS
00:39:24.895 --> 00:39:27.098
THE ONE BEEN ZERO AT THIS TIME.
00:39:27.164 --> 00:39:29.400
WE WILL GO TO LINE. THIRTY FIVE
00:39:29.467 --> 00:39:32.169
YOUR LINE IS OPEN. HELLO MISTER
00:39:32.236 --> 00:39:33.738
CHAIR THIS IS CAPITA BARTOLO
00:39:33.804 --> 00:39:36.240
WITH THE WESTERN CENTER ON LAW
00:39:36.307 --> 00:39:36.774
AND POVERTY AND WE ARE IN
00:39:36.841 --> 00:39:44.782
SUPPORT THANK YOU. NINE THIRTY
00:39:44.849 --> 00:39:45.382
EIGHT. NINE THIRTY EIGHT YOUR
00:39:45.449 --> 00:39:50.755
LINE IS OPEN. THE CHECK YOUR
00:39:50.821 --> 00:39:56.594
MUTE BUTTON. MOVING ON TO LINE
00:39:56.660 --> 00:39:57.228
TWENTY ONE TWENTY ONE YOUR LINE
00:39:57.294 --> 00:39:59.897
IS OPEN. CAN YOU COULD HEAR IT
00:39:59.964 --> 00:40:00.998
ON BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
00:40:01.065 --> 00:40:02.333
ATTORNEYS FOR CRIMINAL JUSTICE
00:40:02.399 --> 00:40:07.872
IN SUPPORT. THERE ANY FURTHER
00:40:07.938 --> 00:40:09.707
IN SUPPORT PLEASE PRESS ONE
00:40:09.774 --> 00:40:15.045
THEN ZERO AT THE TIME. THERE
00:40:15.112 --> 00:40:16.781
ARE NO OTHERS AT THE PORT.
00:40:16.847 --> 00:40:18.682
THANK YOU I'M GOING TO MOVE TO
00:40:18.749 --> 00:40:21.318
OPPOSITION I DON'T HAVE ANY
00:40:21.385 --> 00:40:21.852
OPPOSITION LISTED IS THERE
00:40:21.919 --> 00:40:23.854
ANYONE IN THE- HEARING ROOM
00:40:23.921 --> 00:40:24.321
WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN
00:40:24.388 --> 00:40:26.857
OPPOSITION. ALRIGHT SEE NONE
00:40:26.924 --> 00:40:29.160
OPERATOR IS THERE ANYONE ON THE
00:40:29.226 --> 00:40:33.230
LINE FOR OPPOSITION. PRESS ONE
00:40:33.297 --> 00:40:34.698
THEN ZERO IF YOU'RE IN
00:40:34.765 --> 00:40:36.300
OPPOSITION WE HAVE A LINE
00:40:36.367 --> 00:40:42.072
THIRTY EIGHT PLEASE GO AHEAD.
00:40:42.139 --> 00:40:42.673
NINE THIRTY EIGHT YOUR LINE IS
00:40:42.740 --> 00:40:49.680
OPEN. THIS IS STACEY TADD FROM
00:40:49.747 --> 00:40:51.482
UC IRVINE CONSUMER LAW CLINIC
00:40:51.549 --> 00:40:53.050
AND I WAS ACTUALLY CALLING IN
00:40:53.117 --> 00:40:55.319
SUPPORT OF AB TWENTY FOUR SIXTY
00:40:55.386 --> 00:40:55.986
THREE BUT WITH KICKED INTO THE
00:40:56.053 --> 00:40:57.888
OPPOSITION MINE BUT I'M CALLING
00:40:57.955 --> 00:41:00.925
IN SUPPORT. OKAY WE'RE ON AB
00:41:00.991 --> 00:41:05.029
TWENTY THREE THIRTY EIGHT.
00:41:05.095 --> 00:41:06.363
THERE IF ANYONE IN OPPOSITION
00:41:06.430 --> 00:41:08.098
PLEASE PRESS ONE BEEN ZERO AT
00:41:08.165 --> 00:41:15.773
THE TIME. AND NO ONE IS IN
00:41:15.840 --> 00:41:17.508
OPPOSITION RIGHT THANK YOU
00:41:17.575 --> 00:41:19.610
OPERATOR OF BRING BACK TO THE
00:41:19.677 --> 00:41:21.312
COMMITTEE ANY QUESTIONS
00:41:21.378 --> 00:41:23.547
COMMENTS FROM KANAME. THANK YOU
00:41:23.614 --> 00:41:25.516
WE DO HAVE A MOTION AND A
00:41:25.583 --> 00:41:29.587
SECOND THAT MOTION IS. TO PASS.
00:41:29.653 --> 00:41:31.622
SEE NO OTHER QUESTIONS OR
00:41:31.689 --> 00:41:33.490
COMMENTS THIS WILL REMAIN CLOSE
00:41:33.557 --> 00:41:35.559
IT'S ALL ON BEHALF OF THE
00:41:35.626 --> 00:41:37.228
ATTORNEY DEL LOCK LOCK AND
00:41:37.294 --> 00:41:38.996
MYSELF I RESPECTFULLY ASK WHEN
00:41:39.063 --> 00:41:43.067
I BILLS. THANK YOU. CALL THE
00:41:43.133 --> 00:41:46.003
ROLL PLEASE STONE BY STONE AYE
00:41:46.070 --> 00:41:51.709
GALLAGHER. JO JO I TWO GUNS ALL
00:41:51.775 --> 00:41:56.714
IS GONZALEZ I HOLDEN KALRA
00:41:56.780 --> 00:41:59.316
RIGHT KALRA AYE KILEY KILEY AYE
00:41:59.383 --> 00:42:02.219
MAIENSCHEIN. OBERNOLTE
00:42:02.286 --> 00:42:08.025
OBERNOLTE I REYES HI RES I. IT
00:42:08.092 --> 00:42:11.195
HAS SEVEN VOTE THAT BILL IS OUT
00:42:11.262 --> 00:42:13.464
THANK YOU THANK YOU. RIGHT WE
00:42:13.530 --> 00:42:15.599
WILL NOW- LET'S SEE MR CHOW ARE
00:42:15.666 --> 00:42:17.735
YOU READY ON AB TWENTY FOUR
00:42:17.801 --> 00:42:18.903
FORTY TWO SO WE OPERATOR OF THE
00:42:18.969 --> 00:42:21.372
LINES FOR AB TWENTY FOUR FORTY
00:42:21.438 --> 00:42:25.109
TWO PLEASE. GIVE THE LINE TO
00:42:25.175 --> 00:42:34.018
HELP WITH. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
00:42:34.084 --> 00:42:35.452
VERY MUCH MISTER CHAIR AND
00:42:35.519 --> 00:42:38.622
MEMBERS AB TWENTY FOUR FORTY
00:42:38.689 --> 00:42:39.790
TWO WOULD REQUIRE THAT SOCIAL
00:42:39.857 --> 00:42:41.759
MEDIA PLATFORMS THIS CLOSE
00:42:41.825 --> 00:42:43.060
WHETHER OR NOT THEY HAVE A
00:42:43.127 --> 00:42:45.329
POLICY TO ADDRESS THE SPREAD OF
00:42:45.396 --> 00:42:47.364
MISINFORMATION. CURRENTLY
00:42:47.431 --> 00:42:49.233
DEFINED TO INCLUDE INFORMATION
00:42:49.300 --> 00:42:50.467
WHICH IS INTENTIONALLY
00:42:50.534 --> 00:42:52.469
MISLEADING INACCURATE
00:42:52.536 --> 00:42:53.904
COORDINATED AND DECEPTIVE
00:42:53.971 --> 00:42:55.839
PROMOTION OR SUPPRESSION OF
00:42:55.906 --> 00:42:57.975
INFORMATION AND PRACTICES
00:42:58.042 --> 00:42:59.810
INTENDED TO MANIPULATE THE- OF
00:42:59.877 --> 00:43:02.613
USERS. SOCIAL MEDIA PLATFORMS
00:43:02.680 --> 00:43:03.847
THAT VIOLATE THIS LAW WOULD
00:43:03.914 --> 00:43:05.549
HAVE THIRTY DAYS TO REMEDY
00:43:05.616 --> 00:43:07.918
THEIR VIOLATION. ACCORDING TO
00:43:07.985 --> 00:43:11.355
THE PEW RESEARCH CENTER IN
00:43:11.422 --> 00:43:14.158
201955% OF US ADULTS GOT THEIR
00:43:14.224 --> 00:43:16.493
NEWS FROM SOCIAL MEDIA. IN YET
00:43:16.560 --> 00:43:17.828
ANOTHER REPORT THEY FOUND THAT
00:43:17.895 --> 00:43:19.697
DESPITE CONTROVERSY SURROUNDING
00:43:19.763 --> 00:43:22.666
FAKE NEWS 73% OF US ADULTS
00:43:22.733 --> 00:43:24.802
CONTINUE TO RELY ON GETTING
00:43:24.868 --> 00:43:26.870
NEWS FROM SOCIAL MEDIA SITES.
00:43:26.937 --> 00:43:28.038
WHAT IS MORE STE WHAT IS MORE
00:43:28.105 --> 00:43:30.074
TROUBLING IS THAT APPROXIMATELY
00:43:30.140 --> 00:43:32.009
50% OF THE PEOPLE SHARE A NEW
00:43:32.076 --> 00:43:34.778
STORY FOUND OUT LATER THAT THE
00:43:34.845 --> 00:43:36.413
NEWS STORY WAS FALSE. AS THE
00:43:36.480 --> 00:43:37.481
CLOVER NINETEEN CRISIS
00:43:37.548 --> 00:43:39.516
CONTINUES TO UNFOLD MANY
00:43:39.583 --> 00:43:40.584
INDIVIDUALS HAVE ALREADY BEEN
00:43:40.651 --> 00:43:42.753
HIT WITH IN- MISINFORMATION
00:43:42.820 --> 00:43:44.688
ABOUT HOW THE VIRUS IS SPREAD.
00:43:44.755 --> 00:43:47.458
ALL OFFERING TO SELL MEDICAL
00:43:47.524 --> 00:43:48.058
SUPPLIES TO FIGHT AGAINST THE
00:43:48.125 --> 00:43:50.327
VIRUS. MORE MORE PEOPLE ENGAGED
00:43:50.394 --> 00:43:51.895
IN SOCIAL MEDIA CAN SPREAD MORE
00:43:51.962 --> 00:43:53.530
MISINFORMATION BELIEVING IT TO
00:43:53.597 --> 00:43:54.965
BE TROUBLED. CREATING A VICIOUS
00:43:55.032 --> 00:43:57.568
CYCLE. ACCORDING TO ANALYSTS
00:43:57.634 --> 00:43:59.003
EARLY IN THE YEARINFORMATION
00:43:59.069 --> 00:44:00.504
ABOUT CLOVER NINETEEN WAS
00:44:00.571 --> 00:44:03.240
SCARCE LEADING TO A DATE AVOID
00:44:03.307 --> 00:44:04.475
UNFORTUNATELY DEVOID WAS
00:44:04.541 --> 00:44:06.143
QUICKLY FILL WOULD PROBLEMATIC
00:44:06.210 --> 00:44:08.779
CONTENT. BY BAD ACTORS EAGER TO
00:44:08.846 --> 00:44:11.548
EXPLOIT THE SITUATION. BY
00:44:11.615 --> 00:44:12.549
REQUIRING SOCIAL MEDIA
00:44:12.616 --> 00:44:14.318
PLATFORMS TO DISCLOSE WHAT THEY
00:44:14.385 --> 00:44:16.353
WHAT ARE THEY HOW SUCH A POLICY
00:44:16.420 --> 00:44:17.855
THE USERS AND THE PUBLIC WOULD
00:44:17.921 --> 00:44:19.490
HAVE THE ABILITY TO ASSESS THE
00:44:19.556 --> 00:44:21.225
INFORMATION THEY ARE CONSUMING.
00:44:21.291 --> 00:44:23.060
CURRENTLY MANY PLATFORM TO NOT
00:44:23.127 --> 00:44:24.828
HAVE SUCH A POLICY DEALING WITH
00:44:24.895 --> 00:44:27.464
MISINFORMATION. SINCE SOCIAL
00:44:27.531 --> 00:44:28.732
MEDIA PLATFORMS FORM AN
00:44:28.799 --> 00:44:30.067
INTEGRAL PART OF WHOLE ADULT
00:44:30.134 --> 00:44:32.002
CONSUME NEWS IT IS IMPORTANT TO
00:44:32.069 --> 00:44:33.337
KNOW WHICH OF THESE PLATFORMS
00:44:33.404 --> 00:44:35.339
ARE. TAKING STEPS TO ADDRESS
00:44:35.406 --> 00:44:38.175
THE SPREAD OF MISINFORMATION.
00:44:38.242 --> 00:44:38.776
EIGHTY FOUR TWENTY FOUR FORTY
00:44:38.842 --> 00:44:40.911
TWO DOES THAT. I HAVE PROFESSOR
00:44:40.978 --> 00:44:43.047
EMERITUS JOHN SIMS FROM THE
00:44:43.113 --> 00:44:45.249
GEORGE SCHOOL OF LAW AND EXPERT
00:44:45.315 --> 00:44:47.184
ON CONSTITUTIONAL LAW HERE TO
00:44:47.251 --> 00:44:49.253
PROVIDE TESTIMONY. AND ANSWER
00:44:49.319 --> 00:44:51.288
ANY QUESTIONS YES NO POSITION
00:44:51.355 --> 00:44:52.356
ON A BILL THAT CAN SPEAK
00:44:52.423 --> 00:44:53.323
SPECIFICALLY TO THE
00:44:53.390 --> 00:44:55.225
CONSTITUTIONAL ISSUES RAISED BY
00:44:55.292 --> 00:44:58.295
THE OPPOSITION. RIGHT THANK YOU
00:44:58.362 --> 00:45:00.397
WE WILL MOVE THEN TO PROFESSOR
00:45:00.464 --> 00:45:02.599
SINCE WHO IS WITH US AND OUR
00:45:02.666 --> 00:45:05.169
WITNESS VIDEO CONFERENCE ROOM.
00:45:05.235 --> 00:45:07.638
GOOD MORNING- THE FIRST
00:45:07.704 --> 00:45:08.939
AMENDMENT PROVIDE STRONG
00:45:09.006 --> 00:45:10.941
PROTECTION FOR THOSE WHO WISH
00:45:11.008 --> 00:45:13.243
TO EXPRESS THEMSELVES. AND TO A
00:45:13.310 --> 00:45:15.412
DEGREE IT ALSO. PROVIDES
00:45:15.479 --> 00:45:19.016
PROTECTION. TO THOSE WHEN THE
00:45:19.083 --> 00:45:19.750
GOVERNMENT'S TRYING TO COMPEL
00:45:19.817 --> 00:45:23.020
SPEECH- AB TWENTY FOUR FORTY
00:45:23.087 --> 00:45:24.788
TWO S. DESCRIBED WOULD REQUIRE
00:45:24.855 --> 00:45:26.490
EACH SOCIAL MEDIA PLATFORM TO
00:45:26.557 --> 00:45:28.292
DISCLOSE WHETHER IT HAS A
00:45:28.358 --> 00:45:32.029
POLICY TO DEAL WITH. SYSTEMATIC
00:45:32.096 --> 00:45:34.264
SPREAD OF MISINFORMATION. I IN
00:45:34.331 --> 00:45:36.133
MY VIEW NO SUBSTANTIAL
00:45:36.200 --> 00:45:38.535
CONSTITUTIONAL QUESTION CAN BE
00:45:38.602 --> 00:45:41.872
RAISED ABOUT THIS ASPECT OF AB
00:45:41.939 --> 00:45:44.141
TWENTY FOUR FORTY TWO. ARE
00:45:44.208 --> 00:45:45.309
THERE ARE MANY DISCLOSURE
00:45:45.375 --> 00:45:47.911
REQUIREMENTS AFTER A COUPLE TO
00:45:47.978 --> 00:45:48.679
THOSE PROVIDING GOODS AND
00:45:48.745 --> 00:45:50.814
SERVICES IN FIRST AMENDMENT LAW
00:45:50.881 --> 00:45:53.750
ACCEPTS IT DID THIS EVERY DAY
00:45:53.817 --> 00:45:55.285
PROCESS OF REGULATION WHICH
00:45:55.352 --> 00:45:57.054
PROTECTS AGAINST FLOP FRAUD
00:45:57.121 --> 00:46:00.324
EXPLOITATION AND OTHER INJURIES.
00:46:00.390 --> 00:46:03.293
FOR EXAMPLE I IN NINETEEN
00:46:03.360 --> 00:46:04.394
EIGHTY FIVE THE SUPREME COURT
00:46:04.461 --> 00:46:06.497
DECIDED A CASE CALLED SOUTER.
00:46:06.563 --> 00:46:09.399
OF WHICH CONCLUDED THAT AN
00:46:09.466 --> 00:46:11.768
ATTORNEY COULD BE REQUIRED TO
00:46:11.835 --> 00:46:13.804
MAKE CERTAIN DISCLOSURES
00:46:13.871 --> 00:46:15.405
RELATED TO HIS PROVISION OF
00:46:15.472 --> 00:46:17.541
SERVICES TO CLIENTS AND HE HAD
00:46:17.608 --> 00:46:19.243
TO MAKE THOSE DISCLOSURES TO
00:46:19.309 --> 00:46:22.846
PROSPECTIVE. CLIENTS SIMILARLY
00:46:22.913 --> 00:46:24.681
IN CALIFORNIA ATTORNEYS ARE
00:46:24.748 --> 00:46:26.717
REQUIRED IN AND IN NUMEROUS
00:46:26.783 --> 00:46:28.485
WAYS TO MAKE AFFIRMATIVE
00:46:28.552 --> 00:46:30.387
DISCLOSURES SO FOR EXAMPLE
00:46:30.454 --> 00:46:33.157
UNDER RULE ONE POINT FOUR POINT
00:46:33.223 --> 00:46:34.191
TWO CALIFORNIA ATTORNEYS ARE
00:46:34.258 --> 00:46:35.726
REQUIRED TO DISCLOSE TO
00:46:35.792 --> 00:46:37.161
PROSPECTIVE CLIENTS IN ALMOST
00:46:37.227 --> 00:46:39.062
ALL CIRCUMSTANCES WHETHER OR
00:46:39.129 --> 00:46:41.265
NOT THEY HAVE. MALPRACTICE
00:46:41.331 --> 00:46:43.767
INSURANCE. HI EVERYONE A
00:46:43.834 --> 00:46:45.936
CALIFORNIA'S FAMILIAR- WITH THE
00:46:46.003 --> 00:46:48.639
UBIQUITOUS STUFF PROP SIXTY
00:46:48.705 --> 00:46:50.641
FIVE WARNING SOME OF WHICH ARE
00:46:50.707 --> 00:46:55.312
REQUIRED. OF THOSE- SELLING
00:46:55.379 --> 00:46:58.749
SERVICES- AND GOODS WHEN THAT
00:46:58.815 --> 00:47:02.386
WOULD RESULT IN THE EXPOSURE-
00:47:02.452 --> 00:47:04.888
CONSUMERS TO DANGEROUS
00:47:04.955 --> 00:47:06.990
CHEMICALS. SO THE FIRST
00:47:07.057 --> 00:47:08.225
AMENDMENT DOES NOT PREVENT
00:47:08.292 --> 00:47:10.928
CONSUMER PROTECTION DISCARDED
00:47:10.994 --> 00:47:11.695
PROTECTION DISCLOSURES OF THESE
00:47:11.762 --> 00:47:15.666
TYPES. AND I'M CONFIDENT THAT
00:47:15.732 --> 00:47:17.668
IF ANY FIRST AMENDMENT.
00:47:17.734 --> 00:47:19.670
ARGUMENT WERE RAISED- ALONG THE
00:47:19.736 --> 00:47:21.038
LINES OF THE COMPELLED SPEECH
00:47:21.104 --> 00:47:24.575
DR AGAINST AB TWENTY FOUR FOUR
00:47:24.641 --> 00:47:26.310
TWO THAT THAT CLAIM WOULD BE
00:47:26.376 --> 00:47:28.712
REJECTED THANKS VERY MUCH.
00:47:28.779 --> 00:47:30.347
THANK YOU HAD MR TELL THE-
00:47:30.414 --> 00:47:32.216
ANALYSIS LISTS A NUMBER OF
00:47:32.282 --> 00:47:34.718
AMENDMENTS. HI THAT'S CORRECT
00:47:34.785 --> 00:47:37.287
UP. ARE THERE IS A SET OF
00:47:37.354 --> 00:47:38.922
AMENDMENTS ACT OUT I AM
00:47:38.989 --> 00:47:41.959
ACCEPTING A GRANDMA HERE AND-
00:47:42.025 --> 00:47:43.393
YEAH I'VE ALSO BEEN TALKING
00:47:43.460 --> 00:47:45.195
WITH THE ALL THE OPPOSITION AND
00:47:45.262 --> 00:47:46.597
STAKEHOLDERS ON FURTHER
00:47:46.663 --> 00:47:48.665
AMENDING THE LANGUAGE AND YOU
00:47:48.732 --> 00:47:50.100
KNOW TO TAKE A LOOK. THE
00:47:50.167 --> 00:47:51.268
DEFINITION OF SOCIAL MEDIA
00:47:51.335 --> 00:47:52.769
PLATFORM AS WELL AS THE
00:47:52.836 --> 00:47:54.438
DEFINITION OF MISINFORMATION SO
00:47:54.504 --> 00:47:55.405
THOSE AMENDMENTS WILL GO AND
00:47:55.472 --> 00:47:58.308
LATER. ON BUT THE MEMBERS ARE
00:47:58.375 --> 00:47:59.743
SUGGESTED IN THE ANALYSIS ARE
00:47:59.810 --> 00:48:00.877
YOU ALWAYS WILL BE ACCEPTED
00:48:00.944 --> 00:48:04.014
TODAY OKAY CORRECT. THANK YOU.
00:48:04.081 --> 00:48:06.516
ALL RIGHT THANK YOU IS THERE
00:48:06.583 --> 00:48:09.119
ANYONE IN THE HEARING ROOM
00:48:09.186 --> 00:48:09.720
WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT
00:48:09.786 --> 00:48:13.523
OF THIS BILL. ALL RIGHT CA
00:48:13.590 --> 00:48:14.524
NINETY MIGHT BE EDITION ALL
00:48:14.591 --> 00:48:17.661
CALLERS YEAH TO SUPPORT. YEAH I
00:48:17.728 --> 00:48:21.031
WOULD ANYONE ON THE LINES. LIKE
00:48:21.098 --> 00:48:23.600
TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF AB
00:48:23.667 --> 00:48:26.536
TWENTY FOUR FORTY TWO. IF
00:48:26.603 --> 00:48:28.071
YOU'RE INTO PART WITH FEDERAL
00:48:28.138 --> 00:48:31.008
ONE THEN ZERO AT THIS TIME LINE
00:48:31.074 --> 00:48:39.416
FORTY ONE YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
00:48:39.483 --> 00:48:40.017
AGAIN NINE FORTY ONE YOUR LINE
00:48:40.083 --> 00:48:48.225
IS OPEN. MOVING ON TO LINE
00:48:48.292 --> 00:48:52.562
THIRTY SIX YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
00:48:52.629 --> 00:48:54.131
LINE THIRTY SIX PLEASE GO AHEAD
00:48:54.197 --> 00:49:04.508
YOUR LINE IS OPEN. OKAY AT THE
00:49:04.574 --> 00:49:08.145
TIME IF YOU ARE IN. THE FACT
00:49:08.211 --> 00:49:08.745
ONE ZERO IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO
00:49:08.812 --> 00:49:14.084
SPEAK. THERE ARE NO OTHER
00:49:14.151 --> 00:49:20.190
SECURE. OKAY THANKYOU IS THERE
00:49:20.257 --> 00:49:22.459
OPPOSITION I HAVE ONE LISTED
00:49:22.526 --> 00:49:24.528
OPPOSITION SAMANTHA CORBIN FROM
00:49:24.594 --> 00:49:31.134
ELECTRONIC FRONTIER FOUNDATION.
00:49:31.201 --> 00:49:33.270
I'M ON THE LINE IF YOU CAN HEAR
00:49:33.337 --> 00:49:33.804
ME YES WE CAN HEAR PLEASE
00:49:33.870 --> 00:49:37.140
PROCEED. THANK YOU MISTER
00:49:37.207 --> 00:49:39.076
CHAIR. I'VE MET THE CORPORATE
00:49:39.142 --> 00:49:40.744
ON BEHALF OF THE ELECTRONIC
00:49:40.811 --> 00:49:42.179
FRONTIER FOUNDATION.
00:49:42.245 --> 00:49:45.649
RESPECTFULLY AND OPPOSITION AB.
00:49:45.716 --> 00:49:46.249
TWO FOUR FOUR TWO WE ARE
00:49:46.316 --> 00:49:48.251
CONCERNED ABOUT CUTS ON
00:49:48.318 --> 00:49:50.620
CONSTITUTIONALITY ISSUES- WITH
00:49:50.687 --> 00:49:52.756
THE LANGUAGE IN PARTICULAR-
00:49:52.823 --> 00:49:54.691
THAT THE DEFINITION OUR
00:49:54.758 --> 00:49:56.827
OBJECTIVE AND OVERLY BROAD. AND
00:49:56.893 --> 00:49:57.894
WE HAVE BEEN WORKING WITH THE
00:49:57.961 --> 00:49:59.396
AUTHORED OFFICE AND WILL
00:49:59.463 --> 00:50:00.597
CONTINUE TO DO SO AND
00:50:00.664 --> 00:50:01.598
APPRECIATE THE AMENDMENTS TO
00:50:01.665 --> 00:50:03.967
CONSIDER. ME THANK YOU. THANK
00:50:04.034 --> 00:50:06.436
YOU IS THERE ANYONE IN THE
00:50:06.503 --> 00:50:07.304
HEARING ROOM WOULD LIKE TO
00:50:07.371 --> 00:50:10.273
SPEAK IN OPPOSITION OF AB
00:50:10.340 --> 00:50:12.275
TWENTY FOUR FORTY TWO. SEEING
00:50:12.342 --> 00:50:13.577
NONE IS THERE ANYONE ON THE
00:50:13.643 --> 00:50:14.411
PHONE NINE TWO WOULD LIKE TO
00:50:14.478 --> 00:50:16.613
SPEAK IN OPPOSITION OF AB
00:50:16.680 --> 00:50:18.682
TWENTY FOUR FORTY TWO. IF
00:50:18.749 --> 00:50:19.850
YOU'RE IN OPPOSITION PLEASE
00:50:19.916 --> 00:50:21.651
PRESS ONE THEN ZERO AT THIS
00:50:21.718 --> 00:50:30.260
TIME. AND WE DO HAVE PEOPLE
00:50:30.327 --> 00:50:31.661
QUEUING UP IT'LL BE A MOMENT.
00:50:31.728 --> 00:50:33.864
THANK YOU. I WOULD PROVIDE THE
00:50:33.930 --> 00:50:52.482
LIGHT NUMBERS.
00:50:57.454 --> 00:50:58.555
MY NUMBER TWENTY
00:50:58.622 --> 00:51:01.491
NINE YOUR LINE IS OPEN. THANK
00:51:01.558 --> 00:51:02.793
YOU THIS IS ROBERT CAL AND WITH
00:51:02.859 --> 00:51:04.661
THE INTERNET ASSOCIATION- WE
00:51:04.728 --> 00:51:07.464
OPPOSE THE BILL. EIGHT NO THE
00:51:07.531 --> 00:51:09.266
AUTHOR'S EFFORTS TO WORK WITH
00:51:09.332 --> 00:51:11.468
US MOVING FORWARD- BUT IT PRINT
00:51:11.535 --> 00:51:13.437
WE DO BELIEVE AB TWENTY FOUR
00:51:13.503 --> 00:51:15.205
FORTY TWO IS UNNECESSARY- THE
00:51:15.272 --> 00:51:18.108
MOST WIDELY USED SOCIAL MEDIA.
00:51:18.175 --> 00:51:18.909
PLATFORMS A COMPANIES ALREADY
00:51:18.975 --> 00:51:21.378
HAVE STRICT RULES AND POLICIES
00:51:21.445 --> 00:51:22.712
ABOUT WHAT IS AND IS NOT
00:51:22.779 --> 00:51:24.247
ALLOWED ON THEIR PLATFORMS IN
00:51:24.314 --> 00:51:25.715
THESE ROLES ALREADY DRESSED
00:51:25.782 --> 00:51:27.417
WAYS PLATFORMS APPROACH-
00:51:27.484 --> 00:51:29.386
BERRIES FORMS OF MISINFORMATION
00:51:29.453 --> 00:51:31.388
AND MANIPULATION OF THE SITE-
00:51:31.455 --> 00:51:33.490
THAT AS FAR AS- BEING PUBLICLY
00:51:33.557 --> 00:51:34.991
AVAILABLE THEY ARE. NOT
00:51:35.058 --> 00:51:36.560
DISCUSSED AT LENGTH ON PAGES
00:51:36.626 --> 00:51:38.128
DEVOTED TO THESE RULES AND
00:51:38.195 --> 00:51:39.596
POLICIES AND ARE AVAILABLE TO
00:51:39.663 --> 00:51:42.265
BE VIEWED AT ANY TIME BY USERS-
00:51:42.332 --> 00:51:43.467
PERSPECTIVE USERS FOR THE
00:51:43.533 --> 00:51:46.169
GENERAL PUBLIC- SO- WE ARE
00:51:46.236 --> 00:51:47.971
BECAUSE OF THE BILL- AS WE
00:51:48.038 --> 00:51:49.072
BELIEVE IT'S NOT NECESSARY BUT
00:51:49.139 --> 00:51:52.375
IT SHOULD. OF THE AUTHOR THANK
00:51:52.442 --> 00:51:54.044
YOU. THANK YOU IS THERE ANYONE
00:51:54.110 --> 00:51:55.479
ELSE IN OFFICE. AND WE'RE NOT
00:51:55.545 --> 00:51:56.179
GOING TO TAKE ANY FURTHER
00:51:56.246 --> 00:51:57.447
TESTIMONY IF YOU COULD JUST
00:51:57.514 --> 00:51:58.882
GIVE US YOUR NAME AND YOUR
00:51:58.949 --> 00:52:02.052
AFFILIATION PLEASE. LINE FORTY
00:52:02.118 --> 00:52:06.556
FOR YOUR LINE IS OPEN. HELLO
00:52:06.623 --> 00:52:08.792
CAMERA DIMITRI WITH TECHNOLOGY
00:52:08.859 --> 00:52:10.026
WE ARE ALSO RESPECTFULLY
00:52:10.093 --> 00:52:15.432
BECAUSE THIS BILL. THANK YOU.
00:52:15.499 --> 00:52:17.400
THERE ARE NO OTHER CHEN Q.
00:52:17.467 --> 00:52:19.102
THANK YOU OPERATOR I'M GOING TO
00:52:19.169 --> 00:52:20.570
BRING IT BACK TO THE COMMITTEE
00:52:20.637 --> 00:52:24.508
THAT. THIS HIGHLY. I'M MISTER
00:52:24.574 --> 00:52:25.442
SHOW USED MENTIONED THAT
00:52:25.509 --> 00:52:26.543
THERE'S GOING TO BE A-
00:52:26.610 --> 00:52:27.511
AMENDMENT THE CHANGES THE
00:52:27.577 --> 00:52:28.745
DEFINITION OF MISINFORMATION
00:52:28.812 --> 00:52:30.814
WHAT IS ONE OF THEM TELL. ART
00:52:30.881 --> 00:52:32.282
WELL THE DETAILS ARE STILL
00:52:32.349 --> 00:52:34.351
BEING WORKED ON- BUT I'VE BEEN
00:52:34.417 --> 00:52:37.320
WORKING WITH YEAH- YEAH I
00:52:37.387 --> 00:52:38.788
INTERNET ASSOCIATION AND SO THE
00:52:38.855 --> 00:52:40.757
OPPOSITION DFL FIVE TO
00:52:40.824 --> 00:52:42.559
BASICALLY TRY TO REFINE THE
00:52:42.626 --> 00:52:44.561
DEFINITION. OF WE HAVEN'T
00:52:44.628 --> 00:52:46.429
DECIDED ON ONE PARTICULAR
00:52:46.496 --> 00:52:48.265
DEFINITION AS YET BUT THERE'S
00:52:48.331 --> 00:52:49.866
BEEN SEVERAL ITERATIONS OF THAT
00:52:49.933 --> 00:52:52.102
THE VERY THE- DEFINITION BEING
00:52:52.168 --> 00:52:54.371
CIRCULATED RIGHT NOW ALSO-
00:52:54.437 --> 00:52:57.040
CERTAIN PARTIES ARE. Y'ALL THEM
00:52:57.107 --> 00:52:58.742
THEY LIKE ONE VERSION NOT MORE
00:52:58.808 --> 00:53:00.343
THAN THE OTHERS SO WE JUST NEED
00:53:00.410 --> 00:53:02.712
AND SORTED OUT ALL OUT- BUT IT
00:53:02.779 --> 00:53:05.215
DEALT PRIMARILY IT DEALS WITH
00:53:05.282 --> 00:53:09.419
THE- THE FIRST THREE ITEMS OF
00:53:09.486 --> 00:53:13.790
THE DEFINITION. AND SO.
00:53:13.857 --> 00:53:14.958
SECIFIC EIGHT REGARDING THE
00:53:15.025 --> 00:53:17.327
WAY. OF AROUND INTENTIONALLY
00:53:17.394 --> 00:53:18.929
MISLEADING COORDINATING
00:53:18.995 --> 00:53:21.665
DECEPTIVE AND ALSO THE- THE
00:53:21.731 --> 00:53:25.101
BEHAVIOR PIECE ALSO SO I THINK-
00:53:25.168 --> 00:53:26.870
SO YOU KNOW THERE IS NO
00:53:26.937 --> 00:53:29.673
DEFINITIVE- OF VERSION AS YET
00:53:29.739 --> 00:53:31.875
THAT SO AGREED. AGREED TO BY
00:53:31.942 --> 00:53:33.977
EVERYBODY AT THIS POINT I SEE
00:53:34.044 --> 00:53:36.613
AND- I YEAH I GUESS QUESTION
00:53:36.680 --> 00:53:38.014
FOR EITHER FOR YOU OR FOR THE
00:53:38.081 --> 00:53:39.749
FOR YOUR WITNESS ON. THIS
00:53:39.816 --> 00:53:40.951
FIRST- PRONG ASKED
00:53:41.017 --> 00:53:43.420
INTENTIONALLY MISLEADING OR
00:53:43.486 --> 00:53:45.021
INACCURATE SO THERE'S AN INTENT
00:53:45.088 --> 00:53:47.090
REQUIREMENT WHICH- WAS AN
00:53:47.157 --> 00:53:47.924
IMPORTANT SAFEGUARD IN OTHER
00:53:47.991 --> 00:53:50.193
AREAS WERE PLAYING WITH- MAKING
00:53:50.260 --> 00:53:52.062
A JUDGMENT ABOUT. FALSENESS
00:53:52.128 --> 00:53:53.797
LIKE DEFAMATION THAT YOU KNOW
00:53:53.863 --> 00:53:55.599
YOU HAVE TO HAVE THAT. THIS
00:53:55.665 --> 00:53:56.499
INTENT REQUIREMENT IT'S
00:53:56.566 --> 00:53:58.501
IMPORTANT SAFEGUARD AGAINST A
00:53:58.568 --> 00:53:59.769
CHILLING EFFECT BUT I.
00:53:59.836 --> 00:54:03.907
WONDERING HOW THAT WORKS IN
00:54:03.974 --> 00:54:04.507
THIS CONTEXT I MEAN. BECAUSE
00:54:04.574 --> 00:54:05.075
YOU'RE GONNA HAVE TOHAVE A
00:54:05.141 --> 00:54:06.843
SOCIAL MEDIA PLATFORM MAKING A
00:54:06.910 --> 00:54:09.346
DETERMINATION IN REAL TIME-
00:54:09.412 --> 00:54:11.314
ABOUT WHAT WAS KNOWN WHAT THE
00:54:11.381 --> 00:54:12.983
INTENT OF THE CONTENT SHARE
00:54:13.049 --> 00:54:16.953
WISE- AND THEN YOU KNOW- DOES
00:54:17.020 --> 00:54:18.188
THE SAME STANDARD HAVE TO BE
00:54:18.254 --> 00:54:20.023
MET FOR EACH PERSON WHO SHARES
00:54:20.090 --> 00:54:21.992
THE CONTENT AFTER THAT- OR WHAT
00:54:22.058 --> 00:54:23.593
HAPPENS IF THEY TAKE A PIECE OF
00:54:23.660 --> 00:54:25.061
ORIGINAL CONTENT THAT MAY BE
00:54:25.128 --> 00:54:26.663
WHAT IS. I SHARED WITH WITH ILL
00:54:26.730 --> 00:54:29.099
INTENT- BUT THE SCHERER DOES
00:54:29.165 --> 00:54:31.034
NOT HAVE THAT SAME INTENT AND
00:54:31.101 --> 00:54:32.936
THEY HAD SOME COMMENTARY THAN
00:54:33.003 --> 00:54:35.071
THEIR OWN ORIGINAL CONTENT. SO
00:54:35.138 --> 00:54:35.839
HOW DO YOU HOW DO YOU SEE THESE
00:54:35.905 --> 00:54:38.475
QUESTIONS- THESE ISSUES BEING
00:54:38.541 --> 00:54:40.143
RESOLVED. BUT THE LAW
00:54:40.210 --> 00:54:42.212
ESSENTIALLY- PASSED THE TECH
00:54:42.278 --> 00:54:44.047
COMPANY ORDER FORM TO DISCLOSE
00:54:44.114 --> 00:54:45.915
WHETHER OR NOT THEY HOW SUCH A
00:54:45.982 --> 00:54:47.050
POLICY. SO IT DOESN'T REALLY
00:54:47.117 --> 00:54:49.552
MANDATE THE CONTENT. OF THE
00:54:49.619 --> 00:54:53.590
POLICY ITSELF- OR DOES IT. NEED
00:54:53.657 --> 00:54:55.091
A DOES IT COMPELS SPEECH SHELF
00:54:55.158 --> 00:54:57.494
EXAMPLE IT ALL DEPENDS ON THE
00:54:57.560 --> 00:55:00.864
DEFINITION OF- LET'S SAY- OF
00:55:00.930 --> 00:55:08.171
THIS PATIENT. YES. IT
00:55:08.238 --> 00:55:09.906
DEFINITION THAT'S OUT OF
00:55:09.973 --> 00:55:11.141
ACCEPTED BY ALL PARTIES THAT
00:55:11.207 --> 00:55:12.942
BUT- I DO UNDERSTAND YOUR
00:55:13.009 --> 00:55:14.678
CONCERN BUT YOU KNOW THE- THE
00:55:14.744 --> 00:55:17.113
INTENT HERE IS TO FIND. A TO
00:55:17.180 --> 00:55:18.982
FIND THE LOWEST- COMMON
00:55:19.049 --> 00:55:20.950
DENOMINATOR DOT WOULD BASICALLY
00:55:21.017 --> 00:55:22.919
FIT. ON THE DEFINITION OF THE
00:55:22.986 --> 00:55:24.087
DEFINITION OF MISINFORMATION
00:55:24.154 --> 00:55:26.489
ACROSS THE BOARD. ARE THERE ARE
00:55:26.556 --> 00:55:28.525
A LITTLE OVER TWO HUNDRED OR
00:55:28.591 --> 00:55:30.226
THERE ABOUT TWO HUNDRED SOCIAL
00:55:30.293 --> 00:55:31.594
MEDIA PLATFORMS OUT THERE. AND
00:55:31.661 --> 00:55:33.363
SOME OF THE PLATFORM STATE YOU
00:55:33.430 --> 00:55:35.532
HAVE POLICIES SOME DELL SO THAT
00:55:35.598 --> 00:55:36.566
YOUR INTENT IS TO BASICALLY
00:55:36.633 --> 00:55:38.468
CREATE ONE UNIFORM POLICY. I
00:55:38.535 --> 00:55:39.869
WOULD ALLOW ALL PLATFORMS TO
00:55:39.936 --> 00:55:42.739
COMPLY WITH. AND OF SO. SO
00:55:42.806 --> 00:55:44.908
TAXES EXACTLY WHAT WE WORKING
00:55:44.974 --> 00:55:47.444
ON THE DEFINITION OF. OKAY I
00:55:47.510 --> 00:55:48.678
MEAN I DON'T SEE LIKE HUGE
00:55:48.745 --> 00:55:51.247
PROBLEM I GUESS THE IDEA OF
00:55:51.314 --> 00:55:52.248
DISCLOSURE BUT IT IT KIND OF
00:55:52.315 --> 00:55:53.483
SEEMS LIKE THIS MIGHT BE THE
00:55:53.550 --> 00:55:54.718
FIRST STEP DOWN HE ROAD MAYBE.
00:55:54.784 --> 00:55:57.487
AT TRYING TO ADD MORE. CLOSELY
00:55:57.554 --> 00:55:59.923
MONITOR YEAH AND- AND YOU KNOW
00:55:59.989 --> 00:56:01.691
REQUIRE A SOCIAL MEDIA
00:56:01.758 --> 00:56:03.393
PLATFORMS TO MONITOR- THEIR
00:56:03.460 --> 00:56:06.463
CONTENT FOR. FOR FAKE NEWS- AND
00:56:06.529 --> 00:56:09.232
I SO I GUESS MY POINT IS THAT
00:56:09.299 --> 00:56:11.101
THE- SAFEGUARDS THAT WE'VE
00:56:11.167 --> 00:56:12.569
RECOGNIZED AS NECESSARY TO
00:56:12.635 --> 00:56:14.938
PREVENT- YOU CRIMINALIZING YOU
00:56:15.004 --> 00:56:17.807
KNOW FALSE STATEMENTS- FROM.
00:56:17.874 --> 00:56:20.643
UNDULY BURDENING SPEECH- IT.
00:56:20.710 --> 00:56:23.246
MIGHT NOT BE WORKABLE IN THE
00:56:23.313 --> 00:56:25.014
CONTEXT- THAT WE'RE DEALING
00:56:25.081 --> 00:56:27.217
WITH HERE. AND SO I JUST THINK
00:56:27.283 --> 00:56:29.385
THAT- THAT'S SOMETHING TO BE
00:56:29.452 --> 00:56:31.988
MINDFUL OF BEFORE WE GO TOO FAR
00:56:32.055 --> 00:56:34.057
DOWN THIS ROAD I DO GET IT. AND
00:56:34.124 --> 00:56:34.624
THE DEFINITION WAS ACTUALLY
00:56:34.691 --> 00:56:36.693
TAKEN FROM. OUT OF THE VERBIAGE
00:56:36.760 --> 00:56:38.228
THAT'S BEING USED BY OTHER-
00:56:38.294 --> 00:56:39.729
SOCIAL MEDIA PLATFORMS AS WELL
00:56:39.796 --> 00:56:40.697
SO THEY'RE PRETTY MUCH ALIGN
00:56:40.764 --> 00:56:42.699
WITH WHAT'S OUT THERE AS FAR AS
00:56:42.766 --> 00:56:43.166
THE DEFINITION ISN'T.
00:56:43.233 --> 00:56:44.968
DEFINITIONS CONCERT BUT I DON'T
00:56:45.034 --> 00:56:46.836
KNOW FOUGHT FOR SYSTEMS AS
00:56:46.903 --> 00:56:49.372
ANYTHING TO ADD TO THAT. SO
00:56:49.439 --> 00:56:51.808
JUST NINETY I COULD ASK SINCE
00:56:51.875 --> 00:56:53.777
ARE YOU STILL. THERE YES I. AT
00:56:53.843 --> 00:56:56.379
THAT YOU FOR THE UP. TO VOTE ON
00:56:56.446 --> 00:56:58.314
THIS I DO THINK IT'S REALLY.
00:56:58.381 --> 00:57:00.917
THAT THIS STATUTE IS NOT
00:57:00.984 --> 00:57:03.219
ATTEMPTING TO DO WHAT WILL GIVE
00:57:03.286 --> 00:57:05.989
A CALL. IT'S JUST A EXACT WHAT.
00:57:06.055 --> 00:57:14.097
A THE AFTER. WITH OF. FALSE
00:57:14.164 --> 00:57:14.798
INFORMATION THAT'S BEING
00:57:14.864 --> 00:57:15.765
DISSEMINATED BROUGHT SO THE
00:57:15.832 --> 00:57:17.167
ONLY THING THAT'S DAHLE WE IN
00:57:17.233 --> 00:57:19.369
THIS BILL IS TO REQUIRE THAT
00:57:19.435 --> 00:57:22.539
THE PLOT HAS TO INFORM ITS
00:57:22.605 --> 00:57:24.240
CUSTOMERS- IT WAS THEY'RE USING
00:57:24.307 --> 00:57:26.409
IT ALL WHETHER IT HAS A POLICY
00:57:26.476 --> 00:57:28.645
OR NOT I AND OF COURSE THE
00:57:28.711 --> 00:57:30.280
RIVER SENATE AND I CERTAINLY
00:57:30.346 --> 00:57:32.749
AGREE- THAT THE POTENTIAL
00:57:32.816 --> 00:57:34.517
CONSTITUTIONAL ISSUES THAT
00:57:34.584 --> 00:57:35.485
COULD COME UP WAY WAY DOWN THE
00:57:35.552 --> 00:57:38.188
ROAD COULD BE INVOLVED BECAUSE
00:57:38.254 --> 00:57:39.923
MOST FUNDAMENTALLY THE FIRST
00:57:39.989 --> 00:57:42.025
AMENDMENT DOESN'T RESTRICT. THE
00:57:42.091 --> 00:57:43.960
CONDUCT OF PRIVATE PARTIES ONLY
00:57:44.027 --> 00:57:46.629
DEALS WITH THE GOVERNMENT SO TO
00:57:46.696 --> 00:57:48.364
THE EXTENT THAT THERE'S A
00:57:48.431 --> 00:57:51.334
CONCERN HERE IT'S IN A WAY BACK
00:57:51.401 --> 00:57:53.436
GENERATED BY THE FACT THAT WE
00:57:53.503 --> 00:57:54.437
DON'T WE DON'T OF THE NORMAL
00:57:54.504 --> 00:57:56.506
REGULATORY PROCESS IS A PLACE
00:57:56.573 --> 00:57:58.775
BECAUSE PRIVATE COMPANIES THEN
00:57:58.842 --> 00:58:01.277
IF PRIVATE PUMP START ACTING
00:58:01.344 --> 00:58:03.046
ALMOST LIKE THE GUY AND THEY
00:58:03.112 --> 00:58:06.449
START CENSORING EACH AND REALLY
00:58:06.516 --> 00:58:07.917
EXPRESS WAY I THEN THAT RAY
00:58:07.984 --> 00:58:09.552
REALLY IMPORT POLICY. BUT BUT
00:58:09.619 --> 00:58:12.021
THIS BILL IS BACK ABOUT FOUR
00:58:12.088 --> 00:58:13.356
STEPS WE GET TO THE PROBLEM
00:58:13.423 --> 00:58:15.859
AREA BECAUSE ALWAYS REQUIRING
00:58:15.925 --> 00:58:18.962
IS THE NOT THE IT PLATFORM
00:58:19.028 --> 00:58:20.763
WOULD HAVE HAVE A POLICY THEY
00:58:20.830 --> 00:58:26.202
JUST HAVE TO INFORM. THOSE WHO.
00:58:26.269 --> 00:58:27.604
WITH EVERY STATE TO CARE ABOUT
00:58:27.670 --> 00:58:28.638
IT WHETHER THEY HAVE A POLICY
00:58:28.705 --> 00:58:31.241
HERE NOT. AND THE CON. AT LEAST
00:58:31.307 --> 00:58:35.044
NOW STONE UP TO THAT. THANK YOU
00:58:35.111 --> 00:58:39.515
CODE. OKAY THANK YOU DRESS.
00:58:39.582 --> 00:58:40.850
THANK YOU MR TRUMP THANK YOU
00:58:40.917 --> 00:58:42.085
FOR BRINGING THIS BILL I THINK
00:58:42.151 --> 00:58:43.753
THAT IS MISTER KILEY SAID THIS
00:58:43.820 --> 00:58:45.688
IS THE FIRST STEP AND WE DO
00:58:45.755 --> 00:58:47.156
HAVE TO MOVE IN THIS DIRECTION
00:58:47.223 --> 00:58:48.992
BECAUSE AS YOU MENTIONED IN THE
00:58:49.058 --> 00:58:50.927
STATISTICS THERE ARE SO MANY
00:58:50.994 --> 00:58:52.695
PEOPLE RELYING ON SOCIAL MEDIA
00:58:52.762 --> 00:58:54.397
TO GET THEIR NEWS AND
00:58:54.464 --> 00:58:56.799
OFTENTIMES THERE ON TROOPS
00:58:56.866 --> 00:58:58.501
THEIR FALSE STATEMENTS
00:58:58.568 --> 00:59:00.937
KNOWINGLY MADE FALSE STATEMENTS
00:59:01.004 --> 00:59:02.405
SO I THINK THIS IS AN IMPORTANT
00:59:02.472 --> 00:59:04.607
FIRST STEP AND I MOVE THE BILL.
00:59:04.674 --> 00:59:07.076
THANK YOU THANK YOU YOU HAVE A
00:59:07.143 --> 00:59:09.779
MOTION IS THEIR SECOND. THANK
00:59:09.846 --> 00:59:10.813
YOU YOU HAVE A MOTION AND A
00:59:10.880 --> 00:59:14.918
SECOND TO GALLAGHER. YEAH THANK
00:59:14.984 --> 00:59:17.287
YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN AND SO
00:59:17.353 --> 00:59:18.755
NUMBER CHAO I KNOW YOU AND I
00:59:18.821 --> 00:59:22.592
BOTH. CARE VERY MUCH ABOUT. THE
00:59:22.659 --> 00:59:25.561
PROBLEM OF MISINFORMATION BUT
00:59:25.628 --> 00:59:27.230
WE APPROACH THIS IN TWO
00:59:27.297 --> 00:59:29.599
DIFFERENT WAYS RIGHT SO. YOU
00:59:29.666 --> 00:59:31.401
KNOW FOR ME ONE OF MY BIG
00:59:31.467 --> 00:59:33.269
CONCERNS HAS BEEN THE ACTUAL
00:59:33.336 --> 00:59:34.504
CENSORSHIP THAT WE ALREADY
00:59:34.570 --> 00:59:37.840
SEEN. ON SOCIAL MEDIA AND THE
00:59:37.907 --> 00:59:39.108
WAY THAT I APPROACH THIS IS I
00:59:39.175 --> 00:59:41.477
THINK THAT ACTUALLY- MORE
00:59:41.544 --> 00:59:45.081
SPEECH. IS WHAT ENDS UP.
00:59:45.148 --> 00:59:51.254
EXPOSING THINGS FALSE AND
00:59:51.321 --> 00:59:54.090
THEORIES- AND SHOWING THAT
00:59:54.157 --> 00:59:55.825
THINGS ARE NOT ACCURATE MORE
00:59:55.892 --> 00:59:59.362
SPEECH HELPS. BRING THAT OUT-
00:59:59.429 --> 01:00:01.831
AND DISPEL THE MYTHS THAT ARE
01:00:01.898 --> 01:00:04.167
OUT THERE- RATHER THAN LAST
01:00:04.233 --> 01:00:06.970
SPEECH AND RATHER THAN AND
01:00:07.036 --> 01:00:12.342
SUPPRESSING SPEECH- AND I DO I
01:00:12.408 --> 01:00:15.511
WORRY THAT. NUMBER ONE I WORRY
01:00:15.578 --> 01:00:16.679
ABOUT THE TECH COMPANIES
01:00:16.746 --> 01:00:18.548
THEMSELVES THE SOCIAL MEDIA
01:00:18.614 --> 01:00:20.116
PLATFORMS THEMSELVES YOU KNOW I
01:00:20.183 --> 01:00:22.518
HAD LEGISLATION THAT WAS
01:00:22.585 --> 01:00:25.088
FOCUSED ON NOT ALLOWING THEM TO
01:00:25.154 --> 01:00:27.423
CENSOR SOMETHING. WE BASED ON
01:00:27.490 --> 01:00:29.459
THE POLITICAL NATURE OF THE
01:00:29.525 --> 01:00:32.795
SPEECH AND THERE HAVE BEEN
01:00:32.862 --> 01:00:33.896
SEVERAL INSTANCES WHERE THAT
01:00:33.963 --> 01:00:35.531
APPEARS TO BE THE CASE THAT IT
01:00:35.598 --> 01:00:38.267
WAS MORE ABOUT THE VIEWPOINT OF
01:00:38.334 --> 01:00:40.436
THE PERSON BRINGING THAT THEN
01:00:40.503 --> 01:00:42.538
WHETHER OR NOT AND- YOU KNOW IT
01:00:42.605 --> 01:00:46.275
WAS. ACCURATE OR OR OR
01:00:46.342 --> 01:00:47.744
CERTAINLY LIKE TO THE FORMS OF
01:00:47.810 --> 01:00:49.112
SPEECH THAT THE CONSTITUTION AS
01:00:49.178 --> 01:00:51.481
SET ARE LESS PROTECTED
01:00:51.547 --> 01:00:56.119
OBSCENITY. YOU KNOW CERTAINLY.
01:00:56.185 --> 01:00:58.554
CALLS TO VIOLENCE AGAINST
01:00:58.621 --> 01:01:00.156
PEOPLE THINGS LIKE THAT
01:01:00.223 --> 01:01:01.090
IMMEDIATE ACTS OF VIOLENCE
01:01:01.157 --> 01:01:04.127
AGAINST A PERSON'S IN GROUPS-
01:01:04.193 --> 01:01:05.895
BUT LARGELY I THINK WE NEED TO
01:01:05.962 --> 01:01:08.064
TRY AND KEEP A FREE MARKET OF
01:01:08.131 --> 01:01:09.866
SPEECH BECAUSE THAT SEEMS TO
01:01:09.932 --> 01:01:11.901
SUPPRESS ENOUGH AND I'LL I'LL
01:01:11.968 --> 01:01:13.369
GIVE AN EXAMPLE OF THEM. I
01:01:13.436 --> 01:01:15.772
THINK IT REALLY WE REALLY SEEN
01:01:15.838 --> 01:01:19.242
THAT IT WORKS WHEN IT COMES. TO
01:01:19.308 --> 01:01:20.943
MAJOR PUBLIC FIGURES FOR
01:01:21.010 --> 01:01:22.912
INSTANCE JUST YESTERDAY YOU
01:01:22.979 --> 01:01:24.147
KNOW PRESIDENT TRUMP WITH HAD
01:01:24.213 --> 01:01:27.050
TWEETED ABOUT JOE SCARBOROUGH.
01:01:27.116 --> 01:01:28.951
AND PERHAPS IN BEING INVOLVED
01:01:29.018 --> 01:01:30.153
WITH THE DEATH OF ONE OF HIS
01:01:30.219 --> 01:01:30.953
INSURANCE AND IT WAS
01:01:31.020 --> 01:01:32.889
IMMEDIATELY CALLED OUT BY
01:01:32.955 --> 01:01:34.624
ALMOST ALL THE NEWS AND- AND
01:01:34.690 --> 01:01:35.725
ALL DIFFERENT PEOPLE SAYING
01:01:35.792 --> 01:01:37.393
THAT AS A CONSPIRACY THEORY
01:01:37.460 --> 01:01:39.128
THAT HAS BEEN PROVEN FALSE.
01:01:39.195 --> 01:01:40.930
IT'S ALMOST IMMEDIATELY JUMPED
01:01:40.997 --> 01:01:42.432
ON AND THE MARKET OF FREE
01:01:42.498 --> 01:01:44.901
SPEECH. BASICALLY CALLED THAT
01:01:44.967 --> 01:01:46.636
OUT RIGHT AND I THINK WE CAN
01:01:46.702 --> 01:01:48.504
LOOK TO MANY DIFFERENT CASES
01:01:48.571 --> 01:01:52.341
WHERE THAT IS BEEN. THE CASE-
01:01:52.408 --> 01:01:54.110
WHERE WE WHERE WE SEEM TO HAVE
01:01:54.177 --> 01:01:57.980
SOME PROBLEM- IS REALLY AND
01:01:58.047 --> 01:02:03.119
EXAMPLE BOX THAT ARE OUT THERE-
01:02:03.186 --> 01:02:06.055
THIS WAS. MOST OF THE CALLED
01:02:06.122 --> 01:02:07.156
OUT THE MODEL REPORT FOR THE
01:02:07.223 --> 01:02:08.724
MOVE PART SAID THAT THESE
01:02:08.791 --> 01:02:10.426
RUSSIA BOUGHT. WHAT THEY WERE
01:02:10.493 --> 01:02:11.828
DOING IS THEY WERE ACTUALLY
01:02:11.894 --> 01:02:15.264
POSING AS FOR EXAMPLE A BLACK
01:02:15.331 --> 01:02:18.234
LIVES MATTER GROUP WHERE THEY
01:02:18.301 --> 01:02:20.069
WERE POSING AS A TEA PARTY.
01:02:20.136 --> 01:02:22.105
GROUP AND THEY WERE STILL KEEN
01:02:22.171 --> 01:02:24.774
REALLY THE FIRE. AND STOKING
01:02:24.841 --> 01:02:27.944
THE INDIVIDUAL- PASSIONS OF
01:02:28.010 --> 01:02:30.613
THESE GROUPS- USING FALSE
01:02:30.680 --> 01:02:31.948
NARRATIVES THAT WEREN'T EVEN
01:02:32.014 --> 01:02:33.916
ACTUALLY TRUE BUT THEY GOT THAT
01:02:33.983 --> 01:02:35.685
GROUP. TO BE ANIMATED
01:02:35.751 --> 01:02:38.287
IMMOBILIZED- THOSE ARE THOSE
01:02:38.354 --> 01:02:40.256
ARE THE AREAS WHERE IT'S MORE
01:02:40.323 --> 01:02:44.293
SURREPTITIOUS WHERE. YOU WANT
01:02:44.360 --> 01:02:45.928
SPEECH TO BE ABLE TO CALL THOSE
01:02:45.995 --> 01:02:48.164
THINGS OUT AND I GUESS TO MY
01:02:48.231 --> 01:02:49.899
COLLEAGUES POINT ABOUT. LOOK
01:02:49.966 --> 01:02:51.334
MANY MORE PEOPLE ARE LOOKING AT
01:02:51.400 --> 01:02:52.635
SOCIAL MEDIA AGAIN THEIR NEWS
01:02:52.702 --> 01:02:53.970
THERE BUT WHOSE RESPONSIBILITY
01:02:54.036 --> 01:02:57.373
IS IT. TO EDUCATE THEMSELVES.
01:02:57.440 --> 01:02:59.442
AND TO BE PUBLICLY INFORMED
01:02:59.509 --> 01:03:02.411
IT'S THE PER IS THE INDIVIDUAL
01:03:02.478 --> 01:03:04.480
AND- THAT YOU SHOULD BE LOOKING
01:03:04.547 --> 01:03:06.149
AT DIFFERENT VIEW POINT YOU
01:03:06.215 --> 01:03:09.819
SHOULD BE YOU SHOULD BE EXPOSED
01:03:09.886 --> 01:03:11.287
YOU SHOULD BE EXPOSED TO MANY
01:03:11.354 --> 01:03:13.623
DIFFERENT. YOU SHOULD JUST
01:03:13.689 --> 01:03:15.591
LISTEN TO FOX NEWS OR YOU
01:03:15.658 --> 01:03:17.393
SHOULD JUST LISTEN TO CNN.
01:03:17.460 --> 01:03:19.996
RIGHT SAID TO ME THE ANSWER IS
01:03:20.062 --> 01:03:22.532
MORE SPEECH IT'S AS AND NOT
01:03:22.598 --> 01:03:23.699
FINDING WAYS ACTUALLY SUPPRESS
01:03:23.766 --> 01:03:25.601
BEACH AND MY CONCERN WITH YOUR
01:03:25.668 --> 01:03:27.670
BILLS YEAH THE FIRST LEVEL IT'S
01:03:27.737 --> 01:03:29.605
JUST ASKING THEM TO SAY DO WE
01:03:29.672 --> 01:03:33.176
HAVE A POLICY. BUT WE ALREADY
01:03:33.242 --> 01:03:34.343
KNOW THAT THERE'S BILLS BY
01:03:34.410 --> 01:03:35.945
SENATOR PAN FOR EXIT FOR
01:03:36.012 --> 01:03:38.247
EXAMPLE THEY'RE LOOKING TO HAVE
01:03:38.314 --> 01:03:40.816
A PLAN TO TELL YOU KNOW PLAN A
01:03:40.883 --> 01:03:42.885
FRAMEWORK FOR HOW SPEECH SHOULD
01:03:42.952 --> 01:03:44.787
BE HANDLED ON THESE PLATFORMS
01:03:44.854 --> 01:03:45.421
AND I BELIEVE THAT'S GOING TO
01:03:45.488 --> 01:03:47.557
LEAD TO MORE SUPPRESSION WERE
01:03:47.623 --> 01:03:49.192
ALREADY SEEN IT ON THE
01:03:49.258 --> 01:03:51.494
PLATFORMS THEMSELVES. WHERE
01:03:51.561 --> 01:03:53.396
THEY'RE CENSORING SPEECH. AND
01:03:53.462 --> 01:03:55.097
THE MORE THE GOVERNMENT GETS
01:03:55.164 --> 01:03:56.933
INVOLVED I GET REALLY CONCERNED.
01:03:56.999 --> 01:03:58.334
BECAUSE IN GOVERNMENT STARTS
01:03:58.401 --> 01:03:59.669
DETERMINING BASED ON THEIR
01:03:59.735 --> 01:04:02.371
PLAN- BASED ON SOME DEFINITION
01:04:02.438 --> 01:04:04.173
THAT WE MIGHT COME UP WITH.
01:04:04.240 --> 01:04:07.210
WHAT CONSTITUTES TRUE NEWS AND
01:04:07.276 --> 01:04:08.711
FAKE NEWS AND IT'S NOT THE
01:04:08.778 --> 01:04:10.279
GOVERNMENT'S PLACE TO DO THAT
01:04:10.346 --> 01:04:14.684
IT REALLY IS NOT- AND THE
01:04:14.750 --> 01:04:17.053
PROBLEM WITH THAT IS THAT THE
01:04:17.119 --> 01:04:19.255
GOVERNMENT CAN BEGIN THE USE
01:04:19.322 --> 01:04:20.823
THAT POWER TO SUPPRESS
01:04:20.890 --> 01:04:23.859
LEGITIMATE VIEWPOINTS ONCE A
01:04:23.926 --> 01:04:25.861
DAY DON'T AGREE WITH SUB SUB
01:04:25.928 --> 01:04:29.599
SUPPRESS CRITICISM EVEN
01:04:29.665 --> 01:04:30.967
GOVERNMENT AND I'M A PROFESSOR
01:04:31.033 --> 01:04:32.802
SIMS YOU KNOW YOU BROUGHT THAT
01:04:32.868 --> 01:04:33.869
UP THAT. DOWN THE ROAD THIS
01:04:33.936 --> 01:04:35.371
COULD BECOME MORE OF A PROBLEM.
01:04:35.438 --> 01:04:37.773
I BELIEVE THAT. THE SOCIAL
01:04:37.840 --> 01:04:39.542
MEDIA PLATFORMS HAVE BECOME
01:04:39.609 --> 01:04:40.543
MUCH MORE LIKE A LIMITED PUBLIC
01:04:40.610 --> 01:04:43.879
FORUM WHICH THERE HAS BEEN CASE
01:04:43.946 --> 01:04:45.948
LAW SAYING LOOK IN LIMIT PUBLIC
01:04:46.015 --> 01:04:48.117
FORMS YOU HAVE TO ALLOW FOR
01:04:48.184 --> 01:04:49.719
FREE SPEECH AND THE EVEN THOUGH
01:04:49.785 --> 01:04:51.554
THESE ARE PRIVATE AREAS. THESE
01:04:51.621 --> 01:04:54.090
ARE PRIVATE COMPANIES BECAUSE
01:04:54.156 --> 01:04:55.891
THESE NOW HAVE BECOME A FORM
01:04:55.958 --> 01:04:57.226
I'LL GIVE AN EXAMPLE WHEN I WAS
01:04:57.293 --> 01:04:58.761
ON THE BERKELEY CAMPUS AS AN
01:04:58.828 --> 01:05:02.164
UNDERGRADUATE. THERE WAS NOT IT
01:05:02.231 --> 01:05:04.100
IN SPROUT PLAZA THERE WAS ALL
01:05:04.166 --> 01:05:05.801
KINDS OF YOU POINTS. BEING
01:05:05.868 --> 01:05:08.571
EXPRESSED OUT THERE AND I WOULD
01:05:08.638 --> 01:05:09.171
SAY THERE'S EVEN THINGS THAT I
01:05:09.238 --> 01:05:10.439
WOULD SAY THAT IS. THAT'S FALSE
01:05:10.506 --> 01:05:12.775
IS NOT EVEN TRUE RIGHT. AND
01:05:12.842 --> 01:05:15.278
YET. BECAUSE THAT WAS A PUBLIC
01:05:15.344 --> 01:05:16.012
FORUM WHERE PEOPLE HAVE THE
01:05:16.078 --> 01:05:18.381
RIGHT TO SAY YOU KNOW THE BIRTH
01:05:18.447 --> 01:05:20.650
OF THE FREE SPEECH MOVEMENT. WE
01:05:20.716 --> 01:05:22.685
DIDN'T TRY TO SUPPRESS. PEOPLE
01:05:22.752 --> 01:05:26.222
SPEECH- WE USED OUR SPEECH TO
01:05:26.289 --> 01:05:28.291
SAY HEY HERE'S WHAT WE BELIEVE
01:05:28.357 --> 01:05:29.959
IN HERE'S WHAT WE THINK IS TRUE.
01:05:30.026 --> 01:05:31.661
AND I BELIEVE THAT FOR IS THE
01:05:31.727 --> 01:05:33.362
ULTIMATE DISINFECTANT IS THE
01:05:33.429 --> 01:05:36.365
ULTIMATE. TRUTH TELLER BECAUSE-
01:05:36.432 --> 01:05:37.600
TRUTH WILL OF TRUTH WILL
01:05:37.667 --> 01:05:40.670
EVENTUALLY RISE. TO THE TOP IT
01:05:40.736 --> 01:05:41.971
AMONG SAYS IT WILL IT WILL CALL
01:05:42.038 --> 01:05:44.974
OUT THINGS ARE FALSE AND SO
01:05:45.041 --> 01:05:47.510
THAT I MEAN ALL THAT TO SAY. I
01:05:47.576 --> 01:05:48.611
DID I DID I GET CONCERNED WERE
01:05:48.678 --> 01:05:51.414
MOVING TOO FAR INTO THE SPACE
01:05:51.480 --> 01:05:52.014
FOR ACTUALLY GONNA ALTERNATELY
01:05:52.081 --> 01:05:55.351
SUPPRESS LEGITIMATE VIEW POINTS
01:05:55.418 --> 01:05:57.420
WE'RE GOING TO WEAR THIS COULD
01:05:57.486 --> 01:06:00.690
BE THE FOCUS OF. SUPPRESSING
01:06:00.756 --> 01:06:04.226
SPEECH- I NECESSARILY I THINK
01:06:04.293 --> 01:06:05.594
WE'RE ALL WORRIED ABOUT YOU
01:06:05.661 --> 01:06:08.397
KNOW PEOPLE. LOOK I MEAN PEOPLE
01:06:08.464 --> 01:06:10.132
LISTEN TO A VARIETY OF
01:06:10.199 --> 01:06:10.666
VIEWPOINTS AND PEOPLE ARE
01:06:10.733 --> 01:06:12.635
ENTITLED TO BE WRONG. PEOPLE
01:06:12.702 --> 01:06:15.438
ARE ENTITLED TO. YOU KNOW
01:06:15.504 --> 01:06:17.239
BELIEVE THE THINGS THAT THEY
01:06:17.306 --> 01:06:17.873
WANT TO BELIEVE THAT'S KIND OF
01:06:17.940 --> 01:06:20.776
A FUNDAMENTAL CORNERSTONE OF
01:06:20.843 --> 01:06:22.011
THIS COUNTRY AND IF THE
01:06:22.078 --> 01:06:23.245
GOVERNMENT STARTS GETTING TOO
01:06:23.312 --> 01:06:24.180
FAR INTO THAT WILL WE'RE GOING
01:06:24.246 --> 01:06:25.648
TO TEACH PEOPLE WHAT THEY
01:06:25.715 --> 01:06:27.650
BELIEVE THEM NO MORE NOT. THE
01:06:27.717 --> 01:06:29.485
AMERICA THAT I KNOW. AT THE END
01:06:29.552 --> 01:06:31.520
OF THAT THIS IS WHAT YOU NEED
01:06:31.587 --> 01:06:32.021
TO KNOW AND IF YOU DON'T
01:06:32.088 --> 01:06:32.555
BELIEVE THIS AND YOU'RE
01:06:32.621 --> 01:06:34.857
SOMEHOW. WRONG AND I'VE BUT I
01:06:34.924 --> 01:06:37.393
WORRY ABOUT GOING DOWN. A PAST
01:06:37.460 --> 01:06:38.928
LIKE THAT SO I MEAN. HAPPY TO
01:06:38.994 --> 01:06:40.529
HAVE YOU RESPOND TO THAT AND
01:06:40.596 --> 01:06:42.298
GIVE ME YOUR THOUGHTS BUT-
01:06:42.365 --> 01:06:43.599
THAT'S MY CONCERN. THANK YOU
01:06:43.666 --> 01:06:45.201
VERY MUCH MISTER GALLAGHER FOR
01:06:45.267 --> 01:06:48.838
COMMENTS- LET LET ME SAY THIS I
01:06:48.904 --> 01:06:50.206
DO AGREE WITH YOU THAT WE
01:06:50.272 --> 01:06:52.041
SHOULD NOT SUPPRESS. A SPEECH
01:06:52.108 --> 01:06:53.709
WHATSOEVER BECAUSE WE THAT'S
01:06:53.776 --> 01:06:54.877
WHAT THE FIRST AMENDMENT IS ALL
01:06:54.944 --> 01:06:58.714
ABOUT THAT. AND THIS PARTICULAR
01:06:58.781 --> 01:06:59.815
MEASURE DOES NOT SUPPRESS
01:06:59.882 --> 01:07:01.684
SPEECH- AS MENTIONED BY
01:07:01.751 --> 01:07:04.720
PROFESSOR SAM AND- AND IT DOES
01:07:04.787 --> 01:07:07.022
NOT. EITHER ENCOURAGE OR
01:07:07.089 --> 01:07:10.526
DISCOURAGE SPEECH. IT DOES NOT-
01:07:10.593 --> 01:07:12.695
COMPELS SPEECH. ARE WE DID
01:07:12.762 --> 01:07:14.363
MENTION A WORD I THINK ON A
01:07:14.430 --> 01:07:15.998
KIND OF. PIGGY BACK ON THAT AND
01:07:16.065 --> 01:07:19.668
THAT IS SO I THINK. OFTENTIMES
01:07:19.735 --> 01:07:21.637
WE NEED TO KIND OF. A SEEK A
01:07:21.704 --> 01:07:23.939
BALANCE BETWEEN. OF CORPORATE
01:07:24.006 --> 01:07:25.207
RESPONSIBLE FOR COMPANY
01:07:25.274 --> 01:07:26.609
RESPONSIBILITY SOCIAL
01:07:26.675 --> 01:07:29.879
RESPONSIBILITY. WHAT LET'S SEE
01:07:29.945 --> 01:07:30.946
WHAT THE USERS OUT THERE NEED.
01:07:31.013 --> 01:07:33.582
AT THIS DAY AND AGE I THINK
01:07:33.649 --> 01:07:36.452
PEOPLE UP THERE ARE HUNGRY FOR
01:07:36.519 --> 01:07:37.620
INFORMATION AND THAT'S WHAT
01:07:37.686 --> 01:07:41.724
SOCIAL MEDIA IS PROVIDING. THE
01:07:41.791 --> 01:07:44.326
PROBLEM IS A LOT OF SENSE TIONS
01:07:44.393 --> 01:07:46.896
SIR RATED. NOW WHAT JUST ONE.
01:07:46.962 --> 01:07:48.164
THIS DOES IS ESSENTIALLY AS
01:07:48.230 --> 01:07:49.832
MENTIONED EARLIER ONLY TO WE-
01:07:49.899 --> 01:07:50.933
DOT PLOT FOR TO DISCLOSE
01:07:51.000 --> 01:07:52.868
WHETHER THEY- ARE THEY HAVE
01:07:52.935 --> 01:07:54.670
SUCH A POLICY. TO ADDRESS THE
01:07:54.737 --> 01:07:56.839
ISSUE OF MISINFORMATION. DOES
01:07:56.906 --> 01:07:58.974
NOT IS CONTENT NEUTRAL IT IS
01:07:59.041 --> 01:08:01.510
SAW TECHNOLOGY NEUTRAL. SO
01:08:01.577 --> 01:08:02.812
THAT'S WHY WE DON'T HAVE ANY
01:08:02.878 --> 01:08:05.247
FIRST DIMINISH IT NOW. AS TO
01:08:05.314 --> 01:08:06.549
YOUR FEAR ABOUT YOU KNOW GOING
01:08:06.615 --> 01:08:08.284
TO STEP TO STEP FORWARD I MEAN
01:08:08.350 --> 01:08:09.852
THAT'S IN THE FUTURE I MEAN. I
01:08:09.919 --> 01:08:11.821
DO NOT INTEND TO GO ANY FURTHER
01:08:11.887 --> 01:08:13.088
THAN THIS AT LEAST FOR THE
01:08:13.155 --> 01:08:15.424
MOMENT. SO I THINK IT'S A
01:08:15.491 --> 01:08:17.993
BALANCING ACT BETWEEN LET'S SAY
01:08:18.060 --> 01:08:19.695
OF. CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY TO
01:08:19.762 --> 01:08:22.331
OUR SOCIETY AND WHAT THE USERS.
01:08:22.398 --> 01:08:23.999
NEED TO KNOW BECAUSE THESE
01:08:24.066 --> 01:08:25.801
USERS OF JUST LAY PEOPLE STATE
01:08:25.868 --> 01:08:27.169
THEY DON'T KNOW ANY DIDN'T THEY
01:08:27.236 --> 01:08:28.571
DON'T HAVE A LOT OF A LOT OF
01:08:28.637 --> 01:08:30.206
SOPHISTICATION WHEN IT COMES TO
01:08:30.272 --> 01:08:32.174
FAKE NEWS FOR EXAMPLE. SO HOW
01:08:32.241 --> 01:08:34.009
WOULD THEY DISCERN WHAT IS TRUE
01:08:34.076 --> 01:08:36.345
AND WHAT IS NOT TRUE. SO THAT
01:08:36.412 --> 01:08:38.347
HAS TO BE DOLLARS WHICH- THE
01:08:38.414 --> 01:08:40.282
PLATFORMS SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY
01:08:40.349 --> 01:08:42.451
HOW MUCH DID THEY DO. YOU KNOW
01:08:42.518 --> 01:08:45.287
IN THIS EQUATION. TO DATE FACT
01:08:45.354 --> 01:08:46.188
CHECK SHOULD THEY REMOVE THE
01:08:46.255 --> 01:08:47.590
CONTENT WELL SHOULD THEY JUST
01:08:47.656 --> 01:08:49.525
DO A DISCLOSURE AND THAT'S WHAT
01:08:49.592 --> 01:08:51.560
THIS BILL DOES IT'S A SIMPLE
01:08:51.627 --> 01:08:53.095
DISCLOSURE BILL. SO I DON'T
01:08:53.162 --> 01:08:53.963
KNOW PROFESSOR SINCE YOU YOU
01:08:54.029 --> 01:08:55.431
LIKE TO RESPOND TO THAT AS I
01:08:55.498 --> 01:08:57.366
THINK WE'RE- WE GET. THE AD
01:08:57.433 --> 01:08:59.201
THEY WERE GOOD AT THIS POINT I
01:08:59.268 --> 01:08:59.935
WAS MORE OF A STATEMENT BY
01:09:00.002 --> 01:09:03.038
MISTER GALLAGHER THAN. A
01:09:03.105 --> 01:09:03.572
QUESTION ULTIMATELY MISTER
01:09:03.639 --> 01:09:05.574
OBERNOLTE. THANK YOU MISTER
01:09:05.641 --> 01:09:07.510
CHAIR OF. MR CHOW I PRECIADO
01:09:07.576 --> 01:09:08.744
WHAT YOU'RE TRYING TO DO HERE I
01:09:08.811 --> 01:09:11.046
HAVE SOME CONCERNS WITH. THE
01:09:11.113 --> 01:09:13.148
LANGUAGE. THAT WE'RE TALKING
01:09:13.215 --> 01:09:14.517
ABOUT BECAUSE- YOU KNOW WE
01:09:14.583 --> 01:09:15.718
COULD HAVE A PHILOSOPHICAL
01:09:15.784 --> 01:09:17.386
AGREEMENT THAT SOMETHING IS BAD
01:09:17.453 --> 01:09:18.854
AND WE WANT TO STOP THE SPREAD
01:09:18.921 --> 01:09:20.356
OF THIS INFORMATION ON SOCIAL
01:09:20.422 --> 01:09:23.092
MEDIA. BUT THE LANGUAGE THAT WE
01:09:23.158 --> 01:09:25.694
CHOOSE TO USE MATTERS BECAUSE
01:09:25.761 --> 01:09:27.963
WE'RE WRITING THE WALKING. SO
01:09:28.030 --> 01:09:30.432
THE U. YOU'VE- BEEN VERY CLEAR
01:09:30.499 --> 01:09:31.800
THAT YOU'RE NOT ATTEMPTING TO
01:09:31.867 --> 01:09:34.336
REQUIRE CERTAIN CONTENT OF THE
01:09:34.403 --> 01:09:35.938
POLICY YOU JUST WANT TO-
01:09:36.005 --> 01:09:38.140
REQUIRE THAT A DISCLOSURE ABOUT
01:09:38.207 --> 01:09:40.409
WHETHER OR NOT HE POLICY EXISTS
01:09:40.476 --> 01:09:41.176
IS THAT RIGHT THAT'S CORRECT
01:09:41.243 --> 01:09:45.581
OKAY SO- IF THE POLICY WAS-WE
01:09:45.648 --> 01:09:47.082
THINK WE DON'T CURATE THIS
01:09:47.149 --> 01:09:49.084
PLATFORM USE IT AT YOUR OWN
01:09:49.151 --> 01:09:51.654
RISK BUT IS THAT. IT AND YOU
01:09:51.720 --> 01:09:52.488
JUST CLOSE THAT THERE IS A
01:09:52.555 --> 01:09:54.623
POLICY IS THAT IMPLANTS OF WITH
01:09:54.690 --> 01:09:56.158
THIS BILL THAT'S OF ISIS WHAT
01:09:56.225 --> 01:09:58.160
FOR THE SAKE OF THIS LAW OKAY
01:09:58.227 --> 01:09:59.328
BUT SO WHAT IF YOUR CAR IF
01:09:59.395 --> 01:10:02.698
THAT'S CASE WHAT THE OUR
01:10:02.765 --> 01:10:05.000
PURPOSE FOR THE U. OUT THERE TO
01:10:05.067 --> 01:10:07.970
THIS. WHICH OF THESE PLATFORMS
01:10:08.037 --> 01:10:10.105
I DO HAVE A POLICY WE FATE NEW
01:10:10.172 --> 01:10:13.008
OR VISIT SO DATE COULD BE THE
01:10:13.075 --> 01:10:15.544
ARE THE YOU KNOW THE COULD PICK
01:10:15.611 --> 01:10:18.013
AND CHOOSE WHICH HAVE A FIVE
01:10:18.080 --> 01:10:22.117
THE RIGHT TO GET ON LOOK AT THE
01:10:22.184 --> 01:10:23.218
PHARMACY I JUST JUST IS JUST NO
01:10:23.285 --> 01:10:25.020
BECAUSE IT'S PLATFORM A
01:10:25.087 --> 01:10:26.388
SPECIFICALLY. THE WE DON'T
01:10:26.455 --> 01:10:28.824
THINK APOLLO TO SIR THAT'S UP
01:10:28.891 --> 01:10:34.630
TO THE PLATFORM ITSELF. THE
01:10:34.697 --> 01:10:37.166
BUTTON. IS SO I MEAN IT IS A
01:10:37.232 --> 01:10:38.167
USER OF THE- I SEE THAT HAVE
01:10:38.233 --> 01:10:39.635
THE POWER. TO THE- SPREAD OF IN
01:10:39.702 --> 01:10:40.970
A- AND BUT THE POLICIES
01:10:41.036 --> 01:10:41.604
ACTUALLY SAYING THAT THEY DON'T
01:10:41.670 --> 01:10:43.939
HAVE A- SO OFTEN ABOUT IS THAT
01:10:44.006 --> 01:10:47.042
HOW HOW GAME TO A USER OF THE-
01:10:47.109 --> 01:10:48.477
WELL IT. IF THEY DON'T HAVE A-
01:10:48.544 --> 01:10:50.679
TO YOU KNOW. THAT THE- LETTER
01:10:50.746 --> 01:10:52.548
DOUBLE BEWARE I GUESS THE
01:10:52.615 --> 01:10:54.783
CUSTOMER. THAT I MEAN IF THE
01:10:54.850 --> 01:10:56.885
USER. STILL WANTS TO USE OUR
01:10:56.952 --> 01:10:58.220
PLATFORM THAT'S UP ON KNOW THAT
01:10:58.287 --> 01:11:04.093
THEIR OWN FOR OUR- WE NOT SEE.
01:11:04.159 --> 01:11:06.562
THIS PART ON THE NUMBER POLICY.
01:11:06.629 --> 01:11:08.097
USE THAT WE'RE NOT SAYING I
01:11:08.163 --> 01:11:09.932
WHATSOEVER. SO THIS IS TO HELP
01:11:09.999 --> 01:11:11.000
THE- TO BASIC GIVE US A
01:11:11.066 --> 01:11:12.434
GUIDANCE AS TO WHICH- DOES.
01:11:12.501 --> 01:11:14.303
HAVE A POP. FOR JUST ISSUE
01:11:14.370 --> 01:11:17.306
WHICH- PROVIDES. BUT WE DO WILL
01:11:17.373 --> 01:11:18.574
GIVE THEM NO GUIDE SOMETIMES I
01:11:18.641 --> 01:11:21.810
DON'T TO GET A- CALL IF WE HEAR.
01:11:21.877 --> 01:11:23.345
SEC BUT I MEAN IF YOU SEE MY-
01:11:23.412 --> 01:11:27.383
RIGHT. WELL IF THE POLICY.
01:11:27.449 --> 01:11:28.851
AMOUNT THIS WE DON'T THINK NEED
01:11:28.917 --> 01:11:29.785
A POLL. IN WE'RE SAYING THE
01:11:29.852 --> 01:11:30.919
THAT'S UP. AND THEN I'M JUST
01:11:30.986 --> 01:11:33.355
AND PEOPLE YES WE HAVE A POT.
01:11:33.422 --> 01:11:34.256
HOW IS THAT GIVING ME ANY
01:11:34.323 --> 01:11:35.624
USEFUL INFORMATION A USER
01:11:35.691 --> 01:11:37.993
PLATFORM. THAT WOULD PROBABLY
01:11:38.060 --> 01:11:39.595
WHAT JUST HAPPENED. DOWN GIVE
01:11:39.662 --> 01:11:42.431
TO YOU. NO MORE SURE AND SAYS
01:11:42.498 --> 01:11:45.834
TO THE COME. YOU DOING.
01:11:45.901 --> 01:11:48.404
BUSINESS OKAY I DON'T SEE THAT
01:11:48.470 --> 01:11:50.272
IT DOES. MEAN THAT THAT'S WHAT
01:11:50.339 --> 01:11:53.676
THAT'S- I DO THINK THAT THE-
01:11:53.742 --> 01:11:54.777
YOU KNOW IN THIS WHOLE DEBATE.
01:11:54.843 --> 01:12:06.055
THERE THERE MERIT. TO BE
01:12:06.121 --> 01:12:07.890
INACCURATE. YOU KNOW IF I PUT A
01:12:07.956 --> 01:12:09.992
STATE WITH ITS- I CAN SAY MAN
01:12:10.059 --> 01:12:11.760
IS GOOD. ON MY FACEBOOK PAGE IS
01:12:11.827 --> 01:12:12.795
THAT AN ACCURATE WELL SOME
01:12:12.861 --> 01:12:14.963
PEOPLE WOULD ARGUE THAT IT IS.
01:12:15.030 --> 01:12:15.931
IT ALL IT'S ACTUALLY VERY
01:12:15.998 --> 01:12:18.967
DIFFICULT THING. TO PROVE
01:12:19.034 --> 01:12:20.169
DEFINITIVELY THAT'S ACCURATE OR
01:12:20.235 --> 01:12:21.904
INACCURATE. I MEAN WHAT ONCE
01:12:21.970 --> 01:12:23.138
YOU GET ONCE YOU START TO SLICE
01:12:23.205 --> 01:12:24.807
DOWN ON IT JUST ENDS UP BEING.
01:12:24.873 --> 01:12:26.742
THE THIS HUGE PROBLEM. AND WE
01:12:26.809 --> 01:12:28.077
END UP HAVING TO COME BACK DOWN
01:12:28.143 --> 01:12:29.011
THE SIDE OF FREE SPEECH AND
01:12:29.078 --> 01:12:30.746
SAYING OKAY LOOK. WE UNDERSTAND
01:12:30.813 --> 01:12:31.680
THAT WHEN PEOPLE POST
01:12:31.747 --> 01:12:34.283
SOMETHING. IT IS THEIR OPINION.
01:12:34.349 --> 01:12:35.117
AND YOU KNOW IF YOU'RE GOING TO
01:12:35.184 --> 01:12:36.585
RELY ON IT IS FACT IT'S YOUR
01:12:36.652 --> 01:12:38.120
RESPONSIBILITY TO GO FACT CHECK
01:12:38.187 --> 01:12:39.021
AND THAT THEN THAT'S WHERE WE
01:12:39.088 --> 01:12:41.023
ARE NOW. WITH WITH I'M HERE FOR
01:12:41.090 --> 01:12:43.325
VERY GOOD REASON. SO THOSE ARE
01:12:43.392 --> 01:12:43.892
MY CONCERNS WITH THE BILL I
01:12:43.959 --> 01:12:45.894
JUST. I DON'T SEE THAT. THAT
01:12:45.961 --> 01:12:47.763
THIS IS MAKING MEANINGFUL STEPS
01:12:47.830 --> 01:12:48.764
IN THE DIRECTION IS GOING TO
01:12:48.831 --> 01:12:50.666
SOLVE THE ACTUAL PRODUCT. HI
01:12:50.733 --> 01:12:52.534
WHAT YOU'RE COMING FROM BUT I
01:12:52.601 --> 01:12:55.104
DO DISAGREE. BUT I THINK THAT'S
01:12:55.170 --> 01:12:55.637
WHAT THEY'RE- IN A MINUTE.
01:12:55.704 --> 01:12:58.373
FOREST HELP AS WELL. OFFERS HOW
01:12:58.440 --> 01:12:59.842
DO YOU INTERPRET CASE LAW AND-
01:12:59.908 --> 01:13:04.613
SO FORTH. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
01:13:04.680 --> 01:13:09.384
FOR MORE I AM THREE HOUR. SO I
01:13:09.451 --> 01:13:10.285
WAS JUST READING AND I KNOW
01:13:10.352 --> 01:13:12.354
YOU'RE CHANGE THE DEFINITION
01:13:12.421 --> 01:13:12.955
BUT YOU KNOW AS AS THINGS ARE
01:13:13.021 --> 01:13:15.858
NOW. WE'RE ASKING THEM TO WHAT
01:13:15.924 --> 01:13:17.392
IS OUR POLICY TO ADDRESS THE
01:13:17.459 --> 01:13:19.995
SPREAD OF MISINFORMATION
01:13:20.062 --> 01:13:22.564
INCLUDING INACCURATE CONTENT
01:13:22.631 --> 01:13:26.735
REPORTED AS FACT. DECEPTICON
01:13:26.802 --> 01:13:28.370
UNAIDED AND DECEPTIVE PROMOTION
01:13:28.437 --> 01:13:33.075
OR SUPPRESSION OF INFORMATION.
01:13:33.142 --> 01:13:34.376
AND PRACTICES INTENDED TO
01:13:34.443 --> 01:13:36.044
MANIPULATE OR DESTRUCTIVE
01:13:36.111 --> 01:13:39.248
BEHAVIOR OF USERS. ON SOCIAL
01:13:39.314 --> 01:13:40.449
MEDIA PRO WHAT DO WE GET DO
01:13:40.516 --> 01:13:44.553
WITH CAMPAIGNS. THIS GOT YOUR
01:13:44.620 --> 01:13:45.854
MASK IN ORDER TO MAKE IT AND
01:13:45.921 --> 01:13:50.726
SORRY NEEDLE THERE. WHAT ARE WE
01:13:50.793 --> 01:13:51.994
GOING TO DO WITH POLITICAL
01:13:52.060 --> 01:13:53.996
CAMPAIGNS AND POLITICAL SPEECH
01:13:54.062 --> 01:13:56.165
RIGHT BECAUSE I THINK A LOT OF
01:13:56.231 --> 01:13:57.232
PEOPLE SAY AND THE COURSE OF
01:13:57.299 --> 01:13:58.233
THE CAMPAIGN THERE'S THINGS
01:13:58.300 --> 01:14:00.903
THAT ARE- THAT MAKE A LOT OF
01:14:00.969 --> 01:14:02.671
DEPEND ON WHAT SIDE YOU'RE ON
01:14:02.738 --> 01:14:05.374
HE WOULD SAY. HEY THOSE ARE-
01:14:05.440 --> 01:14:06.742
NOT QUITE ACCURATE THERE YOU
01:14:06.809 --> 01:14:08.644
BEING USED TO MANIPULATE THEIR
01:14:08.710 --> 01:14:11.079
BEING USED TO PROMOTE. ARE
01:14:11.146 --> 01:14:11.547
BEING USED TO SUPPRESS
01:14:11.613 --> 01:14:14.216
SOMETHING ELSE. HOW CERTAINLY
01:14:14.283 --> 01:14:15.851
POLITICAL SPEECH IS PROTECTED
01:14:15.918 --> 01:14:17.920
SPEECH RIGHT HOW WE GONNA DO
01:14:17.986 --> 01:14:19.988
WITH THAT OR HOW DO YOU PROPOSE
01:14:20.055 --> 01:14:22.658
THE SOCIAL MEDIA. PLATFORM TO
01:14:22.724 --> 01:14:23.525
DEAL WITH THAT I'M GONNA GIVE
01:14:23.592 --> 01:14:24.459
YOU A SHORT ANSWER AND THEN I
01:14:24.526 --> 01:14:26.528
WANTED TO FOR TO- PROFESSOR THE
01:14:26.595 --> 01:14:29.965
SHORT ANSWER IS OUT THAT PART
01:14:30.032 --> 01:14:30.566
OF THE DEFINITION IS STILL BE
01:14:30.632 --> 01:14:32.768
PARKED ON. SO WITH THAT- CAN I
01:14:32.835 --> 01:14:35.537
REFER TO AS- PROFESSOR SAM JUST
01:14:35.604 --> 01:14:37.139
FOR QUICK YES PROFESSOR SIMPLY
01:14:37.206 --> 01:14:38.907
VERY OF SOMETHING TO ADD TO
01:14:38.974 --> 01:14:40.075
THAT BRIEFLY HAVE ANYTHING
01:14:40.142 --> 01:14:42.044
SURE I WOULD JUST OKAY IN TERMS
01:14:42.110 --> 01:14:43.912
OF THE FIRST MANY CATEGORIES.
01:14:43.979 --> 01:14:45.013
THE MOST TROUBLING OR IS OUR
01:14:45.080 --> 01:14:47.149
CONTENT BASED REGULATION AND OF
01:14:47.216 --> 01:14:48.217
COURSE WE KNOW EVEN THERE ARE
01:14:48.283 --> 01:14:50.385
SOME CONTENT PASTE REGULATIONS
01:14:50.452 --> 01:14:51.353
OKAY IF YOU'RE DEALING WITH
01:14:51.420 --> 01:14:52.487
LIFE ALERT YOU'RE DEALING WITH
01:14:52.554 --> 01:14:57.559
OBSCENITY. CHILD **** THIS BILL
01:14:57.626 --> 01:15:00.128
IS WAY BACK FROM THAT BOUNDARY
01:15:00.195 --> 01:15:02.264
BECAUSE IT'S NOT DEALING WITH
01:15:02.331 --> 01:15:04.132
THE CONTENT AT ALL IT'S
01:15:04.199 --> 01:15:06.702
REQUIRING. PROVIDER OF A
01:15:06.768 --> 01:15:08.170
CERTAIN SERVICE TO MAKE CERTAIN
01:15:08.237 --> 01:15:10.439
DISCLOSURE THOSE USING THE
01:15:10.505 --> 01:15:14.843
PLATFORM. AND IT'S I BELIEVE
01:15:14.910 --> 01:15:16.912
WELL DESIGNED TO LET PEOPLE
01:15:16.979 --> 01:15:19.848
FIGURE OUT. TO SOME DEGREE HOW
01:15:19.915 --> 01:15:21.350
MUCH RELIANCE TAKING PLACE AND
01:15:21.416 --> 01:15:23.151
WHAT THEY SEE YOU KNOW IF THEY
01:15:23.218 --> 01:15:24.353
KNOW THAT THERE'S NO POLICY WE
01:15:24.419 --> 01:15:27.222
DON'T CENSOR THIS MATURE WE
01:15:27.289 --> 01:15:27.723
DON'T LOOK AT IT AT ALL
01:15:27.789 --> 01:15:30.025
ANYTHING GO WELL THEN. MOST
01:15:30.092 --> 01:15:31.393
PEOPLE WOULD BE MORE CAUTIOUS
01:15:31.460 --> 01:15:33.962
IN. LOOKING AT THE JOB THEY'RE
01:15:34.029 --> 01:15:38.967
DECIDING WHETHER IT'S CREDIT.
01:15:39.034 --> 01:15:43.205
RIGHT THANK YOU MISTER JOHN
01:15:43.272 --> 01:15:44.273
HAPPY TO SUPPORT YOUR BILL
01:15:44.339 --> 01:15:46.441
TODAY BECAUSE OF WHAT IT
01:15:46.508 --> 01:15:48.710
ACTUALLY SAYS NOT WHAT. FEARFUL
01:15:48.777 --> 01:15:50.212
IT IT MIGHT SAY DOWN THE LINE
01:15:50.279 --> 01:15:52.247
AND I AGREE IT'S JUST A NOTICE
01:15:52.314 --> 01:15:56.418
BILL. AND WHETHER A PLATFORM
01:15:56.485 --> 01:15:59.454
HAS A POLICY EXPLICITLY OF NOT
01:15:59.521 --> 01:16:01.623
TOUCHING ANY OF THIS WAR HAS A
01:16:01.690 --> 01:16:03.992
MORE NUANCED POLICY THAT IS
01:16:04.059 --> 01:16:05.727
INFORMATION TO THE END USER
01:16:05.794 --> 01:16:07.362
BECAUSE IT END USER ESPECIALLY
01:16:07.429 --> 01:16:09.131
THINK OF IT IN THE CONTEXT OF.
01:16:09.197 --> 01:16:10.198
THE PARENTS HELPING A CHILD
01:16:10.265 --> 01:16:13.802
DECIDE. HOW TO FILTER. WHAT IS
01:16:13.869 --> 01:16:15.771
COMING OFF OF A OF A WEBSITE
01:16:15.837 --> 01:16:17.506
WELL WORLD OF A SOCIAL MEDIA
01:16:17.572 --> 01:16:20.075
PLATFORM THE INFORMATION THAT
01:16:20.142 --> 01:16:22.844
THERE IS. NO CONCERN FOR
01:16:22.911 --> 01:16:24.913
FILTERING AT ALL ON THAT. TOP
01:16:24.980 --> 01:16:27.282
PLATFORM OR THAT THERE IS SOME
01:16:27.349 --> 01:16:29.451
I THINK IS VERY USEFUL. THE
01:16:29.518 --> 01:16:34.289
BECAUSE- THE INFORMATION COMING
01:16:34.356 --> 01:16:35.757
OUT OF THIS BROAD THING THAT WE
01:16:35.824 --> 01:16:37.859
CALL THE INTERNET IS SO
01:16:37.926 --> 01:16:39.394
PROLIFIC IT IS SO RIGHT ONE OF
01:16:39.461 --> 01:16:40.762
THE BIGGEST CHALLENGES I THINK
01:16:40.829 --> 01:16:42.898
WE HAVE AS A SOCIETY IS
01:16:42.965 --> 01:16:45.200
FILTERING INFORMATION WE HAVE.
01:16:45.267 --> 01:16:47.869
AND I ACTUALLY WISH THAT. THE
01:16:47.936 --> 01:16:49.638
INDUSTRY WOULD COME UP WITH.
01:16:49.705 --> 01:16:53.208
DISCLOSURE THE BULLS THAT MAKE
01:16:53.275 --> 01:16:56.311
IT EASIER FOR A USER TO
01:16:56.378 --> 01:16:58.613
UNDERSTAND WHAT THE RISK MAY OR
01:16:58.680 --> 01:17:00.315
MAY NOT BE WITH RESPECT TO THAT
01:17:00.382 --> 01:17:02.651
SITE AND THAT'S WHAT I THINK
01:17:02.718 --> 01:17:03.885
YOU WERE ATTEMPTING TO DO AND I
01:17:03.952 --> 01:17:05.153
APPRECIATE THAT YOU WORKING OUT
01:17:05.220 --> 01:17:06.054
BECAUSE THE DEFINITIONS OR
01:17:06.121 --> 01:17:07.990
REALLY GOING TO MATTER IN HERE
01:17:08.056 --> 01:17:09.725
AND I THINK IF THIS WAS GOING
01:17:09.791 --> 01:17:11.760
TO IN FACT REGULATORS STEP INTO
01:17:11.827 --> 01:17:13.395
REGULATIONS BECAUSE I AGREE
01:17:13.462 --> 01:17:15.364
THAT THAT IS A KIND OF A
01:17:15.430 --> 01:17:16.431
DANGEROUS PLACE TO GO BUT I
01:17:16.498 --> 01:17:20.068
THINK IT'S VERY USEFUL FOR A
01:17:20.135 --> 01:17:22.571
USER OF. ANY PLATFORM. TO HAVE
01:17:22.637 --> 01:17:24.873
A COMMUNICATION FROM WHOEVER'S
01:17:24.940 --> 01:17:27.342
RUNNING THAT PLATFORM TO SAY
01:17:27.409 --> 01:17:29.344
OUR POLICY IS NO POLICY WHICH
01:17:29.411 --> 01:17:31.780
IS A POLICY OR OUR POLICY IS
01:17:31.847 --> 01:17:33.315
THESE GUIDELINES WHICH IS A
01:17:33.382 --> 01:17:36.985
MORE. ENUMERATED POLICY THAT'S
01:17:37.052 --> 01:17:38.687
INFORMATION THAT THAT A USER
01:17:38.754 --> 01:17:40.222
CAN BE USED TO DECIDE WHETHER
01:17:40.288 --> 01:17:41.957
OR NOT THEY WANT TO INTERACT OR
01:17:42.024 --> 01:17:44.159
HOPEFULLY. TO FILTER THE
01:17:44.226 --> 01:17:45.193
INFORMATION THAT THEY'RE
01:17:45.260 --> 01:17:46.795
GETTING SO THAT BECAUSE THE
01:17:46.862 --> 01:17:47.863
USER DOES NEED TO TAKE
01:17:47.929 --> 01:17:49.398
RESPONSIBILITY FOR WHAT THEY DO
01:17:49.464 --> 01:17:51.199
WITH THAT INFORMATION. THE MORE
01:17:51.266 --> 01:17:52.934
THEY UNDERSTAND ABOUT THE
01:17:53.001 --> 01:17:55.937
VERACITY FOR THE CONTROLS THAT
01:17:56.004 --> 01:17:57.172
MAY OR MAY NOT BE THERE ARE NOT
01:17:57.239 --> 01:17:58.407
THAT I'M SUGGESTING WE PUT
01:17:58.473 --> 01:18:00.008
CONTROLS ON THERE BECAUSE I
01:18:00.075 --> 01:18:00.742
THINK THAT THAT BECOMES
01:18:00.809 --> 01:18:02.477
TROUBLING. BUT AT LEAST A
01:18:02.544 --> 01:18:05.047
STATEMENT. THAT IS COMMON
01:18:05.113 --> 01:18:08.116
ACROSS PLATFORMS SO THAT TE
01:18:08.183 --> 01:18:09.751
USER HAS AN ABILITY TO SAY.
01:18:09.818 --> 01:18:11.453
OKAY I'M GONNA BE GETTING
01:18:11.520 --> 01:18:12.587
ANYTHING AND EVERYTHING HERE
01:18:12.654 --> 01:18:13.955
BECAUSE THERE ARE NO CONTROLS
01:18:14.022 --> 01:18:15.791
OVER FALSE INFORMATION OR
01:18:15.857 --> 01:18:17.859
THERE'S AT LEAST AN ATTEMPT. TO
01:18:17.926 --> 01:18:19.728
CONTROL FALSE INFORMATION THIS
01:18:19.795 --> 01:18:22.464
IS WHAT IT IS. THEN THE USER
01:18:22.531 --> 01:18:23.598
COULD DECIDE I AGREE WITH THAT
01:18:23.665 --> 01:18:25.700
OR AYE THOSE CONTROLS OR I
01:18:25.767 --> 01:18:26.468
DISAGREE WITH THOSE CONTROLS
01:18:26.535 --> 01:18:28.637
AND MAKE A DECISION AND THAT'S
01:18:28.703 --> 01:18:29.704
WHAT I THINK IS IMPORTANT AND
01:18:29.771 --> 01:18:31.773
THAT'S WHY THIS IS APPROPRIATE
01:18:31.840 --> 01:18:33.275
AT THIS POINT BECAUSE IT IS
01:18:33.341 --> 01:18:34.643
JUST A NOTIFICATION WE'RE
01:18:34.709 --> 01:18:36.878
ASKING. THE PLATFORMS TO SAY
01:18:36.945 --> 01:18:38.680
WHAT IT IS YOU DO SO THAT THE
01:18:38.747 --> 01:18:42.184
END USER HAS BETTER INFORMATION.
01:18:42.250 --> 01:18:43.385
TO MAKE A DECISION ON WHETHER
01:18:43.452 --> 01:18:44.019
OR NOT THEY'RE GOING TO RELY ON
01:18:44.086 --> 01:18:45.353
THAT INFORMATION OR WHAT
01:18:45.420 --> 01:18:47.923
THEY'RE GOING TO DO. WITH THAT
01:18:47.989 --> 01:18:48.723
THAT SITE WERE THAT PLATFORM.
01:18:48.790 --> 01:18:52.461
SO I THINK THIS IS APPROPRIATE
01:18:52.527 --> 01:18:54.296
AT THIS POINT THIS WOULD BE
01:18:54.362 --> 01:18:57.599
USEFUL INFORMATION. AND THERE
01:18:57.666 --> 01:18:58.967
ARE OTHER AREAS I THINK THAT
01:18:59.034 --> 01:19:00.569
THE INDUSTRY COULD DO A BETTER
01:19:00.635 --> 01:19:01.937
JOB OF INFORMING CONSUMERS
01:19:02.003 --> 01:19:03.505
ABOUT WHAT THEY DO WITH
01:19:03.572 --> 01:19:05.006
INFORMATION THAT WOULD LEAD TO
01:19:05.073 --> 01:19:06.308
CONSUMERS MAKING BETTER
01:19:06.374 --> 01:19:08.176
DECISIONS THAT MAYBE AYBE NOT.
01:19:08.243 --> 01:19:09.411
BUT I WOULD HOPE THAT THEY
01:19:09.478 --> 01:19:11.346
WOULD IT WOULD BE USEFUL IN
01:19:11.413 --> 01:19:12.814
THAT CONTEXT SO I THAT I
01:19:12.881 --> 01:19:14.015
APPRECIATE WHAT YOU'RE DOING
01:19:14.082 --> 01:19:15.383
HERE I ALSO APPRECIATE THAT
01:19:15.450 --> 01:19:16.051
YOURE WORKING WITH THE
01:19:16.118 --> 01:19:17.419
OPPOSITION BECAUSE THOSE
01:19:17.486 --> 01:19:18.787
DEFINITIONS ULTIMATELY ARE
01:19:18.854 --> 01:19:20.956
GOING TO BE IMPORTANT. IN HOW A
01:19:21.022 --> 01:19:23.625
USER DECIDES. HOW TO FILTER
01:19:23.692 --> 01:19:24.726
WHAT THEY'RE GETTING BASED ON
01:19:24.793 --> 01:19:25.861
THE INFORMATION THAT THIS IS
01:19:25.927 --> 01:19:27.129
GOING TO ASK. FOLKS TO PUT
01:19:27.195 --> 01:19:28.463
FORWARD AND WE ARE SO FAR I
01:19:28.530 --> 01:19:30.398
THINK WE'RE SO FAR AWAY FROM.
01:19:30.465 --> 01:19:32.467
ANY CONSTITUTIONAL QUESTION.
01:19:32.534 --> 01:19:33.702
THAT THIS IS PERFECTLY
01:19:33.768 --> 01:19:35.537
APPROPRIATE FOR. OUR COMMITTEE.
01:19:35.604 --> 01:19:37.506
SO WITH THAT THE STRAP. YOU MAY
01:19:37.572 --> 01:19:38.673
CLOSE THANK YOU VERY MUCH I
01:19:38.740 --> 01:19:40.041
JUST I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
01:19:40.108 --> 01:19:41.443
WE'RE I'VE OFTEN THANKS FOR THE
01:19:41.510 --> 01:19:43.512
COMMENTS AS WELL. THANK YOU WE
01:19:43.578 --> 01:19:44.880
DO HAVE A MOTION TO SECOND.
01:19:44.946 --> 01:19:46.214
THAT MOTION IS TO PASS AS
01:19:46.281 --> 01:19:47.949
AMENDED CALL THE ROLL PLEASE.
01:19:48.016 --> 01:19:52.988
STONE BY STONE AYE GALLAGHER.
01:19:53.054 --> 01:19:57.559
GALLAGHER NOT VOTING. CHAU HI
01:19:57.626 --> 01:20:03.932
SO I TO AND SALAS HOLDEN KALRA
01:20:03.999 --> 01:20:08.937
KALRA AYE KILEY. KILEY NO
01:20:09.004 --> 01:20:11.806
MAIENSCHEIN OBERNOLTE OBERNOLTE
01:20:11.873 --> 01:20:16.611
NO REYES AS I. THAT HAS FOUR
01:20:16.678 --> 01:20:18.647
VOTES OKAY I WILL PUT THE BILL
01:20:18.713 --> 01:20:21.249
ON CALL THEN WITH FOUR VOTES
01:20:21.316 --> 01:20:22.951
THANK YOU MISTER THOMAS REYES
01:20:23.018 --> 01:20:24.819
WE WILL NOW MOVE TO ITEM NUMBER
01:20:24.886 --> 01:20:28.723
FOUR AB. TWENTY FOUR FORTY FIVE
01:20:28.790 --> 01:20:30.025
OPERATOR YOU CAN OPEN THE LINES
01:20:30.091 --> 01:20:35.063
FOR AB. TWENTY FOUR FORTY FIVE.
01:20:35.130 --> 01:20:42.470
THE LINES ARE OPEN THANK YOU.
01:20:42.537 --> 01:20:44.072
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS%
01:20:44.139 --> 01:20:48.310
ARE TODAY PRESENT AB TWENTY
01:20:48.376 --> 01:20:48.877
FOUR FORTY FIVE WHICH WILL
01:20:48.944 --> 01:20:50.278
EXTEND THAT TO LEGAL GUARDIANS
01:20:50.345 --> 01:20:52.514
THE RIGHT TO BRING A CLAIM ON
01:20:52.581 --> 01:20:54.149
BEHALF OF THEIR CHILD IF THE
01:20:54.216 --> 01:20:55.650
CHILD PASSES AWAY TO THE WRONG
01:20:55.717 --> 01:20:57.686
DUE TO THE WRONGFUL CONDUCT OF
01:20:57.752 --> 01:21:01.089
ANOTHER STAND AT THE ASSUMING
01:21:01.156 --> 01:21:02.958
THE CHILD HAS NO LIVING PARENTS.
01:21:03.024 --> 01:21:04.426
CURRENT LAW SPECIFIES THE
01:21:04.492 --> 01:21:06.027
INDIVIDUALS WHO MAY BRING A
01:21:06.094 --> 01:21:06.861
CAUSE OF ACTION FOR THE DEATH
01:21:06.928 --> 01:21:08.797
OF A PERSON. COST BY THE
01:21:08.863 --> 01:21:10.532
WRONGFUL ACT OR NEGLECT OF
01:21:10.599 --> 01:21:13.501
ANOTHER. THESE INDIVIDUALS ARE
01:21:13.568 --> 01:21:14.369
LIMITED TO THE DECEDENT'S
01:21:14.436 --> 01:21:17.038
SPOUSE. CHILDREN AND IN THE
01:21:17.105 --> 01:21:18.440
ABSENCE OF THESE INDIVIDUALS
01:21:18.506 --> 01:21:19.908
THOSE WHO WOULD BE ENTITLED TO
01:21:19.975 --> 01:21:21.176
THE PROPERTY OF DECEDENT
01:21:21.243 --> 01:21:22.944
INCLUDING THE PARENTS.
01:21:23.011 --> 01:21:24.613
SPECIFICALLY A MINOR PASSES
01:21:24.679 --> 01:21:25.847
AWAY DUE TO THE WRONGFUL
01:21:25.914 --> 01:21:27.582
CONDUCT OF OTHERS AND THE
01:21:27.649 --> 01:21:28.984
MINERS ON MARRIED AND DOES NOT
01:21:29.050 --> 01:21:30.885
HAVE CHILDREN. THAN THOSE WHO
01:21:30.952 --> 01:21:32.754
CAN BRING FORTH THE CASE OR THE
01:21:32.821 --> 01:21:35.023
MINERS BIOLOGICAL OR ADOPTIVE
01:21:35.090 --> 01:21:38.059
PARENTS. BUT NOT EVERY CHILD IS
01:21:38.126 --> 01:21:40.528
RAISED BY THEIR PARENTS. IF THE
01:21:40.595 --> 01:21:42.364
MINERS REYES BY LEGAL GUARDIANS
01:21:42.430 --> 01:21:43.832
WHO HAVE NOT OFFICIALLY ADOPTD
01:21:43.898 --> 01:21:46.134
THE MINOR THESE LEGAL GUARDIANS
01:21:46.201 --> 01:21:48.236
DO NOT HAVE LEGAL STANDING TO
01:21:48.303 --> 01:21:49.537
BRING A CLAIM IN THE EVENT OF A
01:21:49.604 --> 01:21:51.740
WRONGFUL DEATH. EVEN THOUGH
01:21:51.806 --> 01:21:53.275
BOTH OF THE CHILD'S BIOLOGICAL
01:21:53.341 --> 01:21:54.376
OR ADOPTIVE PARENTS ARE
01:21:54.442 --> 01:21:58.046
DECEASED. AB TWENTY FOUR FORTY
01:21:58.113 --> 01:21:59.914
FIVE CORRECT THIS OVERSIGHT IN
01:21:59.981 --> 01:22:02.083
LAW BY ALLOWING LEGAL GUARDIANS
01:22:02.150 --> 01:22:03.251
TO BRING FORTH A WRONGFUL DEATH
01:22:03.318 --> 01:22:05.820
CASE UNDER THE SAME CONDITIONS
01:22:05.887 --> 01:22:08.290
WHICH A PARENT CAN BRING. UNDER
01:22:08.356 --> 01:22:09.524
THE SAME CONDITIONS- WHICH
01:22:09.591 --> 01:22:10.792
APPEARED CAN BRING FORTH THE
01:22:10.859 --> 01:22:13.495
CASE FOR THEIR CHILD. BUT ONLY
01:22:13.561 --> 01:22:15.830
WHEN THE DECEASED DECEASED
01:22:15.897 --> 01:22:17.866
CHILD'S PARENTS HAVE ALSO
01:22:17.932 --> 01:22:21.202
PASSED AWAY. CONTRARY TO THE
01:22:21.269 --> 01:22:23.238
OPPOSITION'S CLAIM BECAUSE
01:22:23.305 --> 01:22:24.639
LEGAL GUARDIANS WOULD BE ACTING
01:22:24.706 --> 01:22:26.574
AS A CHILD'S PARENT AND
01:22:26.641 --> 01:22:28.777
BRINGING FORTH THE CASE INSTEAD
01:22:28.843 --> 01:22:30.178
OF THE TILES DECEASED
01:22:30.245 --> 01:22:32.480
BIOLOGICAL OR ADOPTIVE PARENT.
01:22:32.547 --> 01:22:33.648
THIS BILL DOES NOT INCREASE THE
01:22:33.715 --> 01:22:35.016
NUMBER OF PEOPLE WHO MAY BRING
01:22:35.083 --> 01:22:38.320
A CASE. AB TWENTY FOUR FORTY
01:22:38.386 --> 01:22:39.454
FIVE ALLOWS A LEGAL GUARDIAN TO
01:22:39.521 --> 01:22:41.656
SEEK JUSTICE FOR CHILD WAS
01:22:41.723 --> 01:22:43.258
PASSED AWAY DUE TO THE WRONGFUL
01:22:43.325 --> 01:22:44.893
CONDUCT OF ANOTHER WHEN THE
01:22:44.959 --> 01:22:47.929
CHILD'S PARENTS CANNOT DO SO
01:22:47.996 --> 01:22:49.864
BECAUSE THEY ARE DECEASED. TO
01:22:49.931 --> 01:22:52.300
QUOTE THE ANALYSIS PREPARED BY
01:22:52.367 --> 01:22:54.235
THIS COMMITTEE. ALLOWING THE
01:22:54.302 --> 01:22:56.438
LEGAL GUARDIAN TO BRING ACTION
01:22:56.504 --> 01:22:57.939
IN THE SAME MANNER AS ANY OTHER
01:22:58.006 --> 01:22:59.207
PARENT WILL UPDATE THE WRONGFUL
01:22:59.274 --> 01:23:00.709
DEATH STATUTE. TO BETTER
01:23:00.775 --> 01:23:02.811
REFLECT THE CURRENT REALITIES
01:23:02.877 --> 01:23:05.647
OF LIFE. FOR THESE REASONS I
01:23:05.714 --> 01:23:07.782
RESPECTFULLY RESPECTFULLY WILL
01:23:07.849 --> 01:23:10.018
BE ASKING FOR AN AYE VOTE. NOT
01:23:10.085 --> 01:23:11.786
TO TESTIFY TESTIFIED VIA
01:23:11.853 --> 01:23:15.056
TELEPHONE TODAY. WE HAVE NEIL
01:23:15.123 --> 01:23:17.592
GALLO OCT TURNING IT PRIVATE
01:23:17.659 --> 01:23:19.361
ATTORNEY WITH TAYLOR IN RING.
01:23:19.427 --> 01:23:21.329
AND CAP THE SAKE MORE ON WHO IS
01:23:21.396 --> 01:23:23.298
A FAMILY LAW DIRECTOR FOR THE
01:23:23.365 --> 01:23:24.499
NATIONAL CENTER FOR LESBIAN
01:23:24.566 --> 01:23:27.669
RIGHTS I WOULD LIKE TO KNOW TO
01:23:27.736 --> 01:23:29.671
THE MEMBERS THAT. THIS IS NOT A
01:23:29.738 --> 01:23:32.240
SPONSORED BILL THIS WAS BROUGHT
01:23:32.307 --> 01:23:34.008
ABOUT AS A RESULT OF THE CHILD
01:23:34.075 --> 01:23:37.312
DIEGO WHO DIED WITH NO PARENTS
01:23:37.379 --> 01:23:39.547
LIVING AND TO THE LEGAL
01:23:39.614 --> 01:23:40.849
GUARDIANS WERE PRECLUDED FROM
01:23:40.915 --> 01:23:43.084
FILING A CLAIM. AND MISTER
01:23:43.151 --> 01:23:45.553
GALLO UP WILL YOU MORE ABOUT
01:23:45.620 --> 01:23:48.690
THAT. THANK YOU WHERE DO YOU.
01:23:48.757 --> 01:23:50.759
START SO WE DO HAVE A MOTION AS
01:23:50.825 --> 01:23:53.328
THEIR SECOND. AND A SECOND
01:23:53.395 --> 01:23:54.896
THANK YOU THEY DO HAVE TWO
01:23:54.963 --> 01:23:56.798
LISTED FOLKS FOR SUPPORT NEW
01:23:56.865 --> 01:23:59.768
YORK A LOT AND KATHY SYCAMORE
01:23:59.834 --> 01:24:03.738
ARE. YOU ON THE LINE PLEASE.
01:24:03.805 --> 01:24:06.274
NEIL KILOWATT CAN EVERYONE HEAR
01:24:06.341 --> 01:24:06.841
ME YES WE CAN HERE GO AHEAD
01:24:06.908 --> 01:24:10.712
PLEASE. GOOD MORNING MEMBERS OF
01:24:10.779 --> 01:24:12.180
THE ASSEMBLY THANK YOU FOR
01:24:12.247 --> 01:24:14.315
GIVING ME THE OPPORTUNITY TO
01:24:14.382 --> 01:24:15.316
SPEAK TO ALL OF YOU ABOUT THIS
01:24:15.383 --> 01:24:17.619
BILL BY WAY OF INTRODUCTION MY
01:24:17.685 --> 01:24:19.320
NAME IS NEIL CAL A LOT AND I AM
01:24:19.387 --> 01:24:20.388
A MEMBER OF THE CONSUMER
01:24:20.455 --> 01:24:21.956
ATTORNEYS OF CALIFORNIA IN
01:24:22.023 --> 01:24:24.759
SUPPORT OF AB TWO FOUR. FOUR
01:24:24.826 --> 01:24:27.028
FIVE. I AM AN ATTORNEY AT
01:24:27.095 --> 01:24:28.163
TAYLOR AND RING IN MANHATTAN
01:24:28.229 --> 01:24:29.998
BEACH. WHERE I CONCENTRATE MY
01:24:30.064 --> 01:24:31.433
PRACTICE IN THE AREAS OF
01:24:31.499 --> 01:24:33.001
SERIOUS PERSONAL INJURY
01:24:33.067 --> 01:24:35.637
WRONGFUL DEATH AND SEXUAL ABUSE.
01:24:35.703 --> 01:24:39.007
ABOVE ALL AB TWO FOUR FOUR FIVE
01:24:39.073 --> 01:24:41.242
IS ABOUT FAIRNESS THIS BILL
01:24:41.309 --> 01:24:43.077
AIMS TO CORRECT INEQUITIES IN
01:24:43.144 --> 01:24:44.746
THE LAW UNDER CIRCUMSTANCES
01:24:44.813 --> 01:24:47.015
WHERE A MINOR DIES DUE TO THE
01:24:47.081 --> 01:24:48.850
WRONGFUL CONDUCT OF OTHERS.
01:24:48.917 --> 01:24:50.819
UNDER SUCH CIRCUMSTANCES THE
01:24:50.885 --> 01:24:52.420
RIGHTFUL HEIRS IN A WRONGFUL
01:24:52.487 --> 01:24:54.556
DEATH ACTION ASSUMING THE MINOR
01:24:54.622 --> 01:24:56.357
WAS UNMARRIED AND DID NOT HAVE
01:24:56.424 --> 01:24:57.759
CHILDREN ARE THE MINERS
01:24:57.826 --> 01:25:00.528
PARENTS. HOWEVER IF THE MINERS
01:25:00.595 --> 01:25:03.298
PARENTS PREDECEASED HIM OR HER
01:25:03.364 --> 01:25:05.099
THIS BILL WOULD ALLOW FOR THE
01:25:05.166 --> 01:25:07.469
MINERS LEGAL GUARDIANS TO WRITE
01:25:07.535 --> 01:25:09.204
POLICE STEP INTO THE SHOES OF
01:25:09.270 --> 01:25:11.139
THE MINERS PARENTS. AND PURSUE
01:25:11.206 --> 01:25:12.941
WRONGFUL DEATH CLAIMS ON HIS
01:25:13.007 --> 01:25:17.078
BEHALF. AS IT CURRENTLY STANDS.
01:25:17.145 --> 01:25:20.148
THE LAW SAYS LEGAL GUARDIANSHIP
01:25:20.215 --> 01:25:22.984
IS NOT ENOUGH. THE LAW REQUIRES
01:25:23.051 --> 01:25:24.118
THE MINERS LEGAL GUARDIANS TO
01:25:24.185 --> 01:25:26.788
HAVE FORMALLY ADOPTED THE MINOR
01:25:26.855 --> 01:25:28.890
IN ORDER TO BRING A LAWSUIT ON
01:25:28.957 --> 01:25:31.025
THE MINOR'S BEHALF. THIS IS A
01:25:31.092 --> 01:25:32.627
COLORIST AND ANTIQUATED
01:25:32.694 --> 01:25:33.962
REQUIREMENT THAT SHOULD BE
01:25:34.028 --> 01:25:36.030
ELIMINATED AS THE LAW SHOULD
01:25:36.097 --> 01:25:38.032
RECOGNIZE THE CHANGING NATURE
01:25:38.099 --> 01:25:39.934
FAMILY. THIS BILL WOULD STILL
01:25:40.001 --> 01:25:42.370
REQUIRE THESE LEGAL GUARDIANS
01:25:42.437 --> 01:25:44.138
TO BE FORMALLY APPOINTED AT
01:25:44.205 --> 01:25:46.174
SUCH BY THE COURT PRIOR TO THE
01:25:46.241 --> 01:25:48.443
MINORS DEBT. THIS IS IMPORTANT
01:25:48.510 --> 01:25:49.644
BECAUSE IT WOULD REQUIRE A
01:25:49.711 --> 01:25:51.946
JUDICIAL OFFICER TO EVALUATE
01:25:52.013 --> 01:25:53.781
THE CIRCUMSTANCES UNDERLYING
01:25:53.848 --> 01:25:55.617
THE APPOINTMENT AND CONCLUDE
01:25:55.683 --> 01:25:56.885
THAT THE PARTIES BRINGING THE
01:25:56.951 --> 01:25:59.687
APPLICATION SHOULD IN FACT BE
01:25:59.754 --> 01:26:00.221
APPOINTED THE MINERS LEGAL
01:26:00.288 --> 01:26:02.156
GUARDIANS. IT SHOULD ALSO BE
01:26:02.223 --> 01:26:04.092
NOTED THAT THIS BILL WILL NOT
01:26:04.158 --> 01:26:05.693
EXPAND THE UNIVERSE OF
01:26:05.760 --> 01:26:07.262
PLAINTIFFS THAT MAY PURSUE A
01:26:07.328 --> 01:26:09.063
WRONGFUL DEATH ACTION ON BEHALF
01:26:09.130 --> 01:26:11.332
OF A MINOR. RATHER IT MERELY
01:26:11.399 --> 01:26:13.535
ALLOWS LEGAL GUARDIANS TO STEP
01:26:13.601 --> 01:26:15.403
INTO THE SHOES OF THE MINERS
01:26:15.470 --> 01:26:18.006
PARENTS WANT BOTH PARENTS HAVE
01:26:18.072 --> 01:26:21.809
PASSED AWAY. IN SOME AB TWO
01:26:21.876 --> 01:26:22.844
FOUR FOUR FIVE NARROWLY A MEN'S
01:26:22.911 --> 01:26:24.979
EXISTING LAW TO ALLOW FOR THE
01:26:25.046 --> 01:26:27.048
RIGHTFUL PROSECUTION OF
01:26:27.115 --> 01:26:29.050
WRONGFUL DEATH ACTION. STEPPING
01:26:29.117 --> 01:26:31.119
INTO THE SHOES OF A PARENT IS
01:26:31.185 --> 01:26:33.655
NO EASY TASK WHEN INDIVIDUALS
01:26:33.721 --> 01:26:35.823
TAKE ON THIS NOBLE VENTURE THEY
01:26:35.890 --> 01:26:37.392
SHOULD BE AFFORDED THE SAME
01:26:37.458 --> 01:26:38.793
RIGHTS AFFORDED TO THE MINORS
01:26:38.860 --> 01:26:41.396
PARENTS. THAT JUST BRIEFLY
01:26:41.462 --> 01:26:43.998
ABOUT THE DIEGO CASE THAT MISS
01:26:44.065 --> 01:26:45.700
RATES MENTION THIS CASE
01:26:45.767 --> 01:26:47.835
INVOLVES A THIRTEEN YEAR OLD
01:26:47.902 --> 01:26:50.305
BOY WHO WAS WHO WAS BULLIED
01:26:50.371 --> 01:26:52.307
PHYSICALLY ASSAULTED AND KILLED
01:26:52.373 --> 01:26:55.577
AT SCHOOL. IN THE MARINO VALLEY
01:26:55.643 --> 01:26:56.644
UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT.
01:26:56.711 --> 01:26:59.013
DIEGO'S PARENTS BOTH
01:26:59.080 --> 01:27:00.782
PREDECEASED IN HIS MOTHER
01:27:00.848 --> 01:27:02.450
PASSED AWAY WHEN HE WAS ONE
01:27:02.517 --> 01:27:05.253
YEAR OLD. AT ITS FATHER PASSED
01:27:05.320 --> 01:27:07.589
AWAY IN TWO THOUSAND FOURTEEN.
01:27:07.655 --> 01:27:10.358
DIEGO WAS RAISED BY HIS AUNT
01:27:10.425 --> 01:27:11.893
AND UNCLE HIS MATERNAL AUNT AND
01:27:11.960 --> 01:27:13.094
UNCLES IN PEOPLE'S ONE YOUR
01:27:13.161 --> 01:27:15.697
SOUL. HE LIVES IN THE HOUSE
01:27:15.763 --> 01:27:17.332
WITH THEM THEY TOOK CARE OF
01:27:17.398 --> 01:27:18.566
THEM AND THEY FINANCIALLY
01:27:18.633 --> 01:27:20.802
SUPPORTED HIM AND SO IT SEEMS
01:27:20.868 --> 01:27:23.071
ONLY FAIR THAT GIVEN THAT THEY
01:27:23.137 --> 01:27:25.473
WERE APPOINTED LEGAL GUARDIANS
01:27:25.540 --> 01:27:27.442
FOR DIEGO THAT THEY ALSO BE
01:27:27.508 --> 01:27:29.243
AFFORDED HE SAME RIGHTS THAT
01:27:29.310 --> 01:27:31.312
DIEGO'S PARENTS WOULD HAVE BEEN
01:27:31.379 --> 01:27:33.715
AFFORDED. AN EAGLES PARENTS
01:27:33.781 --> 01:27:37.452
BOTH PREDECEASED. THANK YOU.
01:27:37.518 --> 01:27:41.789
THANK YOU MISTER CAMARA. THANK
01:27:41.856 --> 01:27:43.291
YOU GOOD MORNING MY NAME IS
01:27:43.358 --> 01:27:44.525
KATHY SAKE MORA AND I'M
01:27:44.592 --> 01:27:46.961
TESTIFYING IN SUPPORT ON BEHALF
01:27:47.028 --> 01:27:47.495
OF THE NATIONAL CENTER FOR
01:27:47.562 --> 01:27:49.697
LESBIAN RIGHTS. NATIONAL CENTER
01:27:49.764 --> 01:27:50.798
FOR LESBIAN RIGHTS TO THE NASH
01:27:50.865 --> 01:27:52.166
IN A LEGAL ORGANIZATION
01:27:52.233 --> 01:27:53.568
COMMITTED TO ADVANCING THE
01:27:53.635 --> 01:27:54.969
CIVIL AND HUMAN RIGHTS. OF
01:27:55.036 --> 01:27:56.404
LESBIAN GAY BISEXUAL AND
01:27:56.471 --> 01:27:57.672
TRANSGENDER PEOPLE AND THEIR
01:27:57.739 --> 01:28:00.041
FAMILIES. AS A PART OF OUR
01:28:00.108 --> 01:28:01.376
MISSION WE STRONGLY SUPPORT THE
01:28:01.442 --> 01:28:02.577
RIGHT TO ALL FAMILIES
01:28:02.644 --> 01:28:03.578
REGARDLESS OF HOW THEY ARE
01:28:03.645 --> 01:28:05.613
FORMED AND WHETHER THERE ARE
01:28:05.680 --> 01:28:07.181
BIOLOGICAL OR ADOPTIVE FOR
01:28:07.248 --> 01:28:09.250
LEGAL TIES. WE BELIEVE THE
01:28:09.317 --> 01:28:10.218
LEGAL GUARDIAN SHOULD BE
01:28:10.284 --> 01:28:11.619
INCLUDED IN WRONGFUL DEATH
01:28:11.686 --> 01:28:13.788
ACTION BEEN ALLOWED TO PURSUE-
01:28:13.855 --> 01:28:15.223
THESE ACTIONS IN THE CASE OF A
01:28:15.289 --> 01:28:16.924
WRONGFUL DEATH OF THEIR CHILD
01:28:16.991 --> 01:28:18.626
BECAUSE IN EVERY WAY THE ACTIVE
01:28:18.693 --> 01:28:20.028
PARENTS FOR THE CHILDREN THAT
01:28:20.094 --> 01:28:21.696
ARE IN THEIR CARE. ADDITIONALLY
01:28:21.763 --> 01:28:22.830
WHEN CHILDREN WITH LEGAL
01:28:22.897 --> 01:28:24.298
GUARDIANS DO NOT HAVE LEGAL
01:28:24.365 --> 01:28:26.501
PARENTS. IN THE PICTURE AT ALL
01:28:26.567 --> 01:28:28.403
ALL THOSE GUARDIAN SHOULD BE
01:28:28.469 --> 01:28:29.837
PERMITTED TO PROTECTING THE
01:28:29.904 --> 01:28:32.473
START THE RIGHTS OF THE CHILD
01:28:32.540 --> 01:28:33.041
IF THE CHILD. IS WRONGFULLY
01:28:33.107 --> 01:28:34.342
KILLED. LEGAL GUARDIAN ARTIST
01:28:34.409 --> 01:28:35.677
IS AFFECTED BY THE TRAGIC DEATH
01:28:35.743 --> 01:28:36.944
OF THE CHILD. AND THE PARENT
01:28:37.011 --> 01:28:38.579
WOULD BE. AND FOR THESE REASONS
01:28:38.646 --> 01:28:41.549
WE ORDER AYE VOTE. ON AB TWENTY
01:28:41.616 --> 01:28:44.152
FOUR FOUR FIVE THANK YOU. THANK
01:28:44.218 --> 01:28:46.888
YOU ALL RIGHT IS THERE ANYONE.
01:28:46.954 --> 01:28:47.655
HERE THE HEARING ROOM WOULD
01:28:47.722 --> 01:28:50.024
LIKE TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF AB
01:28:50.091 --> 01:28:51.192
TWENTY FOUR FORTY FIVE. SEEING
01:28:51.259 --> 01:28:53.895
NONE OPERATOR OPEN UP THE LINES
01:28:53.961 --> 01:28:55.063
FOR ANYONE WHO LIKE SPEAK IN
01:28:55.129 --> 01:28:57.065
SUPPORT OF AB TWENTY FOUR FORTY
01:28:57.131 --> 01:28:59.467
FIVE. THANK YOU IF YOU'RE IN
01:28:59.534 --> 01:29:01.135
SUPPORT PRESSED ONE ZERO AT
01:29:01.202 --> 01:29:19.787
THIS TIME.
01:29:21.255 --> 01:29:21.556
AT NINE TWENTY ONE
01:29:21.622 --> 01:29:25.460
YOUR LINE IS OPEN. JANUARY
01:29:25.526 --> 01:29:26.594
TERRACE ON BEHALF OF THE
01:29:26.661 --> 01:29:28.129
CONSUMER FEDERATION OF
01:29:28.196 --> 01:29:29.464
CALIFORNIA IN SUPPORT. THANK
01:29:29.530 --> 01:29:32.700
YOU IS THERE ANY OTHER THAN
01:29:32.767 --> 01:29:34.836
SUPPORT LEAVE AT ONE THEN ZERO
01:29:34.902 --> 01:29:40.541
AT THE TIME. THERE ARE NO
01:29:40.608 --> 01:29:43.277
OTHERS AT THE PORT. THANK YOU I
01:29:43.344 --> 01:29:45.580
HAVE NO OPPOSITION LISTED IS
01:29:45.646 --> 01:29:46.781
THERE ANYONE IN THE HEARING
01:29:46.848 --> 01:29:48.382
ROOMWOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN
01:29:48.449 --> 01:29:49.517
OPPOSITION OF AB TWENTY FOUR
01:29:49.584 --> 01:29:50.918
FORTY FIVE. SEEING NONE IS
01:29:50.985 --> 01:29:52.453
THERE ANYONE ON THE PHONE WHO
01:29:52.520 --> 01:29:53.821
WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN
01:29:53.888 --> 01:29:54.989
OPPOSITION OF AB TWENTY FOUR
01:29:55.056 --> 01:29:58.192
FORTY FIVE. THERE IS ANYONE IN
01:29:58.259 --> 01:30:00.461
OPPOSITION THE PERFECT ONE THEN
01:30:00.528 --> 01:30:08.136
ZERO AT THE TIME. THERE'S NO
01:30:08.202 --> 01:30:09.704
ONE IN OPPOSITION I THANK YOU
01:30:09.771 --> 01:30:11.038
BRING BACK TO THE COMMITTEE
01:30:11.105 --> 01:30:12.507
QUESTIONS COMMENTS WAS TO
01:30:12.573 --> 01:30:16.277
GALLAGHER. YEAH JUST A COUPLE
01:30:16.344 --> 01:30:18.546
QUESTIONS FOR THE AUTHOR. UNDER
01:30:18.613 --> 01:30:21.315
UNDER YOUR BILL AS PROPOSED
01:30:21.382 --> 01:30:22.650
WITH THE LEGAL GUARDIAN STILL
01:30:22.717 --> 01:30:24.185
HAVE TO PROVE THAT THEY WERE
01:30:24.252 --> 01:30:26.754
DEPENDENT ON THE DECEIT NO OKAY
01:30:26.821 --> 01:30:28.823
SO HOW HOW DOES THAT WORK. THEY
01:30:28.890 --> 01:30:30.124
ARE JUST THE LEGAL GUARDIAN
01:30:30.191 --> 01:30:32.360
JUST AS THE PARENT WOULD NOT
01:30:32.426 --> 01:30:32.894
HAVE TO PROVE THAT IS A
01:30:32.960 --> 01:30:34.862
DIFFERENT SECTION OKAY- THAT
01:30:34.929 --> 01:30:37.031
WAS- STATED JUST SO THAT YOU
01:30:37.098 --> 01:30:38.332
KNOW THAT'S THE ONLY OTHER WAY
01:30:38.399 --> 01:30:39.267
THAT THE PARENT WOULD BE ABLE
01:30:39.333 --> 01:30:43.004
TO. TO FILE A CLAIM BUT HERE
01:30:43.070 --> 01:30:45.473
SIMPLY BEING A PARENT ALLOWS IN
01:30:45.540 --> 01:30:47.542
THE OPPORTUNITY AND THE RIGHT
01:30:47.608 --> 01:30:49.977
TO FILE THE CLAIM OKAY IS THERE
01:30:50.044 --> 01:30:53.214
ANY RESTRICTION ON DO ALL THE
01:30:53.281 --> 01:30:57.418
OTHER. HEIRS AND- SORRY THE-
01:30:57.485 --> 01:31:00.388
DOES THE DECEDENT STILL HAVE TO.
01:31:00.454 --> 01:31:02.256
NOT HAVE ANY OTHER SURVIVING
01:31:02.323 --> 01:31:05.660
PARENTS OR OTHER HEIRS. THE
01:31:05.726 --> 01:31:08.296
DECEDENT THE DECEDENT'S LEGAL
01:31:08.362 --> 01:31:10.264
GUARDIAN WOULD TAKE THE PLACE
01:31:10.331 --> 01:31:11.365
OF THE PARENTS OR WHATEVER
01:31:11.432 --> 01:31:13.835
RIGHT THE PARENTS WOULD HAVE IN
01:31:13.901 --> 01:31:15.903
BRINGING FORTH THE LAWSUIT THAT
01:31:15.970 --> 01:31:18.272
LEGAL GUARDIAN WOULD STEP IN
01:31:18.339 --> 01:31:22.076
THEIR SHOES. OKAY. ARE THERE
01:31:22.143 --> 01:31:24.212
SOME AND MAYBE SOME OF ONE OF
01:31:24.278 --> 01:31:27.148
THE WITNESSES COULD. WHAT ARE
01:31:27.215 --> 01:31:28.516
SOME OF THE REASONS WHY A LEGAL
01:31:28.583 --> 01:31:30.651
GUARDIAN MIGHT NOT PROCEED WITH
01:31:30.718 --> 01:31:34.755
ADOPTION I'M THINKING IN MOST
01:31:34.822 --> 01:31:35.323
OF THESE CASES IS USUALLY A
01:31:35.389 --> 01:31:38.593
CHILD INVOLVED. WHAT ARE SOME
01:31:38.659 --> 01:31:39.727
REASONS LEGAL GUARDIAN MIGHT
01:31:39.794 --> 01:31:40.928
NOT MOVE TOWARDS ADOPTION
01:31:40.995 --> 01:31:42.330
BECAUSE UNDER THE CURRENT LAW
01:31:42.396 --> 01:31:44.932
DOESN'T A DOCTOR IF. YOU CAN
01:31:44.999 --> 01:31:47.068
BRING ROB WRONGFUL DEATH CLAIM
01:31:47.134 --> 01:31:49.770
RIGHT. I'M SURE THERE ARE A
01:31:49.837 --> 01:31:52.607
MYRIAD OF REASON IT MAY JUST
01:31:52.673 --> 01:31:55.543
BE TIMING- IF- NEIL GULLIBLE
01:31:55.610 --> 01:31:58.212
OUGHT TO IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO
01:31:58.279 --> 01:32:02.783
PROVIDE A RESPONSE IF YOU KNOW.
01:32:02.850 --> 01:32:03.885
EIGHT AND MISTER GALLAGHER LET
01:32:03.951 --> 01:32:05.419
ME ALSO RESPOND TO YOUR FIRST
01:32:05.486 --> 01:32:07.021
QUESTION JUST BRIEFLY SO THE
01:32:07.088 --> 01:32:08.890
LEGAL GUARDIAN STEP INTO THE
01:32:08.956 --> 01:32:10.725
SHOES OF THE PARENTS THAT HAVE
01:32:10.791 --> 01:32:13.094
THE SAME RIGHT TO SAY WHAT. IF
01:32:13.160 --> 01:32:16.564
THE MINER WHO PASSED AWAY HAD A
01:32:16.631 --> 01:32:20.067
SURVIVING SPOUSE OR A CHILD.
01:32:20.134 --> 01:32:22.603
THEN UNDER THOSE CIRCUMSTANCES
01:32:22.670 --> 01:32:24.438
THE LAW SAYS THE PARENTS COULD
01:32:24.505 --> 01:32:26.941
ONLY BRING A CLAIM IF THEY WERE
01:32:27.008 --> 01:32:28.876
FINANCIALLY DEPENDENT TO SOME
01:32:28.943 --> 01:32:34.148
EXTENT. ON THE MIND. SO UNDER
01:32:34.215 --> 01:32:36.317
THOSE CIRCUMSTANCES A LEGAL
01:32:36.384 --> 01:32:38.152
GUARDIAN WOULD HAVE TO PROVE
01:32:38.219 --> 01:32:40.955
FINANCIAL DEPENDENCY BUT ABSENT
01:32:41.022 --> 01:32:44.258
A SPOUSE. OR CHILD OF THE
01:32:44.325 --> 01:32:46.694
DECEASED MINOR THEN THE LEGAL
01:32:46.761 --> 01:32:49.664
GUARDIANS WOULD HAVE A RIGHT TO
01:32:49.730 --> 01:32:51.465
BRING A CLAIM JUST AS THE
01:32:51.532 --> 01:32:52.900
PARENTS WOULD WITHOUT HAVING TO
01:32:52.967 --> 01:32:54.769
PROVE FINANCIAL DEPEND SO IN
01:32:54.835 --> 01:32:56.637
OTHER WORDS. THE LOFTY AND DOES
01:32:56.704 --> 01:32:58.973
IT IS THE LEGAL GUARDIANS JUST
01:32:59.040 --> 01:33:00.541
STEP INTO THE SHOES OF THE PAIR.
01:33:00.608 --> 01:33:02.276
WITH RESPECT TO YOUR SECOND
01:33:02.343 --> 01:33:04.178
QUESTION ABOUT ADOPTION I CAN
01:33:04.245 --> 01:33:06.113
SAY THAT THERE'S AT LEAST TWO
01:33:06.180 --> 01:33:07.882
THINGS THAT COME TO MIND ONE IS
01:33:07.949 --> 01:33:09.917
THAT THE PROCESS CAN BE LENGTHY
01:33:09.984 --> 01:33:12.553
AND IT CAN ALSO BE EXPENSIVE-
01:33:12.620 --> 01:33:14.588
THERE'S A NUMBER OF PEOPLE WHO.
01:33:14.655 --> 01:33:15.790
HAVE TO GO THROUGH THAT POP
01:33:15.856 --> 01:33:17.525
PROCESS HIGHER FAMILY LAW
01:33:17.591 --> 01:33:19.226
ATTORNEYS- AND GO THROUGH A
01:33:19.293 --> 01:33:21.162
LINK TO YOUR PROCESS TO HAVE
01:33:21.228 --> 01:33:23.331
THAT HAPPEN. AND IT'S MUCH LESS
01:33:23.397 --> 01:33:25.599
EXPENSIVE AND MUCH LESS ONEROUS
01:33:25.666 --> 01:33:26.701
FOR THEM TO GO THROUGH THE
01:33:26.767 --> 01:33:28.169
PROCESS OF BECOMING A LEGAL
01:33:28.235 --> 01:33:31.372
GUARDIAN- WHICH IS SHORTER LESS
01:33:31.439 --> 01:33:33.240
EXPENSIVE AND SO THAT IS A LOT
01:33:33.307 --> 01:33:35.009
OF THE REASON WHY THEY TEND TO
01:33:35.076 --> 01:33:37.078
BECOME PART INCIDENT AND- HOLD
01:33:37.144 --> 01:33:38.846
OFF ON. FORMALLY ADOPTED THE
01:33:38.913 --> 01:33:45.553
CHILD. ALL I HAD OKAY THE
01:33:45.619 --> 01:33:48.856
QUESTIONS COMMON. SEEING NONE
01:33:48.923 --> 01:33:50.992
WAS REYES WHO MAKE CLOTHES. FOR
01:33:51.058 --> 01:33:52.326
DIEGO AND FOR THE PARENTS WHO
01:33:52.393 --> 01:33:54.095
RAISED HIM I RESPECTFULLY ASK
01:33:54.161 --> 01:33:55.563
FOR AN AYE VOTE THANK YOU WE DO
01:33:55.629 --> 01:33:57.298
HAVE A MOTIONAND A SECOND THAT
01:33:57.365 --> 01:33:58.666
MOTION IS DO PASS CALL THE ROLL
01:33:58.733 --> 01:34:01.335
PLEASE. STONE BY STONE AYE
01:34:01.402 --> 01:34:05.139
GALLAGHER. THE OLDER I SHOW. SO
01:34:05.206 --> 01:34:09.377
I CHIU. GONZALEZ AND SALAS AYE
01:34:09.443 --> 01:34:14.281
HOLDEN KALRA KALRA AYE KILEY
01:34:14.348 --> 01:34:16.951
AYE AYE KILEY AYE MAIENSCHEIN.
01:34:17.018 --> 01:34:22.356
OBERNOLTE RAY IS FIVE.
01:34:22.423 --> 01:34:26.227
OBERNOLTE AYE REYES AYE. THE
01:34:26.293 --> 01:34:30.398
BILL HAS. EIGHT VOTES GRIP THE
01:34:30.464 --> 01:34:32.933
BILL IS OUT THANK YOU. SO OUR
01:34:33.000 --> 01:34:35.603
NUMBER FIVE AB TWENTY FOUR
01:34:35.669 --> 01:34:36.237
SEVENTY ONE MISTER MAY TIES NOT
01:34:36.303 --> 01:34:37.204
WITH TIS I WILL BE PRESENTING
01:34:37.271 --> 01:34:39.340
THAT LATER ON IT ON THE AGENDA
01:34:39.407 --> 01:34:39.940
SO WE'RE GOING TO MOVE TO ITEM
01:34:40.007 --> 01:34:44.478
NUMBER SIX. AB THIRTY TWENTY.
01:34:44.545 --> 01:34:45.546
OPERATOR IF YOU COULD OPEN THE
01:34:45.613 --> 01:34:49.950
LINES FOR AB THIRTY TWENTY.
01:34:50.017 --> 01:34:52.520
THEY GIVE A LINE FOR OPEN.
01:34:52.586 --> 01:34:54.989
THANK YOU THIS GLORIA. GOOD
01:34:55.056 --> 01:34:56.123
MORNING MISTER CHAIRMAN- THANK
01:34:56.190 --> 01:34:56.791
YOU SO MUCH FOR THIS
01:34:56.857 --> 01:34:58.225
OPPORTUNITY TO PRESENT THAT
01:34:58.292 --> 01:35:00.227
COMMITTEE WITH ASSEMBLY BILL
01:35:00.294 --> 01:35:01.595
THIRTY TWENTY TODAY MEMBERS
01:35:01.662 --> 01:35:03.597
UNDER EXISTING LAW ONLY PUBLIC
01:35:03.664 --> 01:35:05.766
PROSECUTORS MAY FILE LAWSUITS
01:35:05.833 --> 01:35:06.767
CHARGING UNFAIR BUSINESS
01:35:06.834 --> 01:35:08.936
PRACTICES THESE ACTIONS MAY BE
01:35:09.003 --> 01:35:10.237
BROUGHT FORWARD BY THE ATTORNEY
01:35:10.304 --> 01:35:12.039
GENERAL THE DISTRICT ATTORNEY
01:35:12.106 --> 01:35:13.374
FOR CITY ATTORNEY IN A CITY
01:35:13.441 --> 01:35:15.309
WITH A POPULATION GREATER THAN
01:35:15.376 --> 01:35:16.210
SEVEN HUNDRED AND FIFTY
01:35:16.277 --> 01:35:17.645
THOUSAND PEOPLE. WHEN THE
01:35:17.711 --> 01:35:18.846
ATTORNEY GENERAL OR DISTRICT
01:35:18.913 --> 01:35:20.347
ATTORNEY BRINGS FOR AN ACTION
01:35:20.414 --> 01:35:21.582
UNDER THE UNFAIR COMPETITION
01:35:21.649 --> 01:35:24.418
ACT- DOT OFFICE RECEIVES ALL OF
01:35:24.485 --> 01:35:25.853
THE CIVIL PENALTIES AWARDED BY
01:35:25.920 --> 01:35:28.189
THE COURT HOWEVER WITH THE CITY
01:35:28.255 --> 01:35:29.790
ATTORNEY BRING SUCH AN ACTION
01:35:29.857 --> 01:35:31.525
THE CIVIL PENALTIES MUST BE
01:35:31.592 --> 01:35:33.461
SPLIT EVENLY WITH THE DISTRICT
01:35:33.527 --> 01:35:35.296
ATTORNEY OF THAT COUNTY. THIS
01:35:35.362 --> 01:35:37.264
DISCREPANCY HAS LEFT THOSE SAID
01:35:37.331 --> 01:35:38.399
ELIGIBLE CITY ATTORNEY'S WITH A
01:35:38.466 --> 01:35:40.401
DIFFICULT CHOICE OF BALANCING
01:35:40.468 --> 01:35:41.802
THE PURSUIT OF LEGAL RECOURSE
01:35:41.869 --> 01:35:43.838
AGAINST UNSCRUPULOUS ACTORS
01:35:43.904 --> 01:35:45.639
WITH THE REALITY OF FIVE PUBLIC
01:35:45.706 --> 01:35:48.175
RESOURCES AB THIRTY TWENTY
01:35:48.242 --> 01:35:50.177
REQUIRES- PENALTIES BECAUSE
01:35:50.244 --> 01:35:51.645
WHAT COLLECTED BY THE SAN DIEGO
01:35:51.712 --> 01:35:53.414
CITY ATTORNEY FROM AN ACTION
01:35:53.481 --> 01:35:54.715
UNDER THE UNFAIR COMPETITION
01:35:54.782 --> 01:35:56.851
ACT TO BE PAID TO THE CITY OF
01:35:56.917 --> 01:35:58.385
SAN DIEGO ENTIRELY. BY
01:35:58.452 --> 01:35:59.353
ANSWERING AN EQUITABLE
01:35:59.420 --> 01:36:00.921
DISTRIBUTION OF PENALTIES UNDER
01:36:00.988 --> 01:36:02.690
THE UNFAIR COMPETITION ACT THIS
01:36:02.756 --> 01:36:04.291
BILL WILL EMPOWER THE SAN DIEGO
01:36:04.358 --> 01:36:06.060
CITY ATTORNEY TO PROSECUTE
01:36:06.127 --> 01:36:08.295
AGAINST UNFAIR BUSINESSES IN
01:36:08.362 --> 01:36:09.897
THE INTEREST OF CONSUMERS AND
01:36:09.964 --> 01:36:11.765
OF OUR ENVIRONMENT THIS CHERRY
01:36:11.832 --> 01:36:13.067
WITH ME THIS MORNING BY PHONE
01:36:13.134 --> 01:36:14.635
IS SAN DIEGO CITY ATTORNEY MARK
01:36:14.702 --> 01:36:16.604
ELLIOTT AND ALSO BY PHONE HERE
01:36:16.670 --> 01:36:18.105
TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS AND
01:36:18.172 --> 01:36:19.540
QUESTIONS COMMITTEE MEMBERS MAY
01:36:19.607 --> 01:36:22.943
HAVE IS MARKET ACCOUNT OF THE
01:36:23.010 --> 01:36:24.912
OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY MARK
01:36:24.979 --> 01:36:30.618
MARK IT. UP RESPECT THE. YOU
01:36:30.684 --> 01:36:32.019
THAT YOU MISTER FOR THE WITNESS.
01:36:32.086 --> 01:36:33.420
THANK YOU MISTER GLORIA HAVE
01:36:33.487 --> 01:36:34.955
THE TWO MARK ANGKOR AND MAHER
01:36:35.022 --> 01:36:37.024
EL LISTA AS- TO. BY PHONE ARE
01:36:37.091 --> 01:36:40.494
YOU ON THE PLEASE. YEAH COULD
01:36:40.561 --> 01:36:41.896
THAT THE BAND ERA CREATE MARK
01:36:41.962 --> 01:36:43.364
ALLIA. AND I COMING THROUGH
01:36:43.430 --> 01:36:43.898
OKAY YES WE CAN YOU GOOD
01:36:43.964 --> 01:36:47.101
MORNING. PERFECT ALRIGHT THANK
01:36:47.168 --> 01:36:49.403
YOU FROM THE MEMBER GLORIA. I
01:36:49.470 --> 01:36:50.437
AM STANDING AT THE ATTORNEY
01:36:50.504 --> 01:36:52.373
MARA ALLIOT THANK YOU FOR THE
01:36:52.439 --> 01:36:54.175
OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK TO YOU
01:36:54.241 --> 01:36:55.976
ABOUT THIS IMPORTANT BELL. AND
01:36:56.043 --> 01:36:59.113
HE JUST HEARD UNDER STATE LAW.
01:36:59.180 --> 01:37:00.447
ERNIE PAPER BUT CITY OF MORE
01:37:00.514 --> 01:37:02.349
THAN SEVEN HUNDRED FIFTY
01:37:02.416 --> 01:37:03.250
THOUSAND HAVE AUTHORITY TO
01:37:03.317 --> 01:37:05.252
BRING ENFORCEMENT ACTIONS BASED
01:37:05.319 --> 01:37:07.555
ON UNFAIR COMPETITION LAWS. ON
01:37:07.621 --> 01:37:08.856
BEHALF OF THE PEOPLE OF THE
01:37:08.923 --> 01:37:10.925
STATE OF CALIFORNIA. WHEN
01:37:10.991 --> 01:37:13.093
SHOOTING WHICH CASES TO PURSUE
01:37:13.160 --> 01:37:15.629
I LOOK FOR EGREGIOUS CASES
01:37:15.696 --> 01:37:16.430
WHERE OUR ENVIRONMENT AND BEING
01:37:16.497 --> 01:37:19.767
HARMED CONSUMERS ARE BEING
01:37:19.833 --> 01:37:20.801
DEFRAUDED BY BUSINESS. WORKERS
01:37:20.868 --> 01:37:22.536
ARE BEING SHORT CHANGED BY AN
01:37:22.603 --> 01:37:24.572
UNSCRUPULOUS EMPLOYER OR THE
01:37:24.638 --> 01:37:26.307
HEALTH AND WELFARE OF OUR
01:37:26.373 --> 01:37:28.108
PEOPLE IS JEOPARDIZED. WE
01:37:28.175 --> 01:37:29.910
TYPICALLY GIVE THE BUSINESS AN
01:37:29.977 --> 01:37:32.046
OPPORTUNITY TO COMPLY AND THEN
01:37:32.112 --> 01:37:33.314
BRING LITIGATION WHEN OUR
01:37:33.380 --> 01:37:35.115
EFFORTS TO EDUCATE AND GAIN
01:37:35.182 --> 01:37:37.551
COMPLIANCE TRAIL. WE'VE BROUGHT
01:37:37.618 --> 01:37:39.653
CASES THAT ALLOW US TO ENSURE
01:37:39.720 --> 01:37:41.155
HARD WORKING SAN DIEGANS THEIR
01:37:41.222 --> 01:37:42.623
PAYS WHAT THEY'RE LOOKING FOR
01:37:42.690 --> 01:37:44.858
WORK THEY PERFORMED CONSUMERS
01:37:44.925 --> 01:37:47.261
ARE NOT CHARGED HIDDEN FEES OR
01:37:47.328 --> 01:37:49.730
OTHERWISE EXPLOITED. POLLUTANTS
01:37:49.797 --> 01:37:51.865
ARE REMOVED FROM OUR WATER WAYS
01:37:51.932 --> 01:37:52.967
AND THOSE WHO ARE ADDICTED TO
01:37:53.033 --> 01:37:55.102
OPIOIDS CAN ACCESS THE THIRD
01:37:55.169 --> 01:37:58.739
THAT THEY NEED TO RECOVER FROM
01:37:58.806 --> 01:38:00.441
THEIR ADDICTION. EIGHT AND SURE.
01:38:00.507 --> 01:38:01.809
AND ARE IMPORTANT TO THE PEOPLE
01:38:01.875 --> 01:38:04.245
OF SAN DIEGO. UNDER EXISTING
01:38:04.311 --> 01:38:05.946
LAW THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO NOT
01:38:06.013 --> 01:38:08.449
SHARE THE CIVIL PENALTIES IT
01:38:08.515 --> 01:38:09.817
RECOVERED FROM THESE CASES WITH
01:38:09.883 --> 01:38:12.119
THE COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO. EVEN
01:38:12.186 --> 01:38:14.388
IF THE COUNTY DOES NOT STAND
01:38:14.455 --> 01:38:17.191
SINGLE SECOND THE FIFTEENTH
01:38:17.258 --> 01:38:18.659
WITH THE CASE. IF HOWEVER THE
01:38:18.726 --> 01:38:19.960
COUNTY BRINGS THE CASE UNDER
01:38:20.027 --> 01:38:22.963
THE LONG AND RECOVERY PENALTIES
01:38:23.030 --> 01:38:24.331
THE LAW DOES NOT REQUIRE THE
01:38:24.398 --> 01:38:26.367
COUNTY TO SHARE THE PROCEEDS IT
01:38:26.433 --> 01:38:28.168
RECOVERS WITH THE CITY. THE
01:38:28.235 --> 01:38:30.070
DISTRIBUTION IS NOT FAIR AND IT
01:38:30.137 --> 01:38:31.839
DOESN'T MAKE SENSE. WE'RE
01:38:31.905 --> 01:38:33.874
COVERING THE PENALTIES FOR THE
01:38:33.941 --> 01:38:36.176
WORK WE DO IS VERY IMPORTANT.
01:38:36.243 --> 01:38:38.345
WE INVEST THE PENALTIES LEAVE
01:38:38.412 --> 01:38:40.247
THE COVER INTO DOING MORE WORK
01:38:40.314 --> 01:38:43.417
THAT PROTECTS CONSUMERS WORKERS
01:38:43.484 --> 01:38:44.084
AND OUR ENVIRONMENT. IF
01:38:44.151 --> 01:38:46.220
UNFORTUNATE WHEN WE MUST REJECT
01:38:46.287 --> 01:38:47.721
THE CASE BECAUSE THE COCKPIT
01:38:47.788 --> 01:38:49.823
PURSUING IT IS OUTWEIGHED BY
01:38:49.890 --> 01:38:51.892
THE PANEL PEOPLE WHATEVER.
01:38:51.959 --> 01:38:54.261
UNDER EIGHTY THIRTY TWENTY THE
01:38:54.328 --> 01:38:55.462
CITY OF SAN DIEGO WOULD KEEP
01:38:55.529 --> 01:38:56.697
ALL THE PENALTY THEY WERE
01:38:56.764 --> 01:38:57.998
COVERED WHEN THE RECOVERY IS
01:38:58.065 --> 01:39:00.934
DUE SOLELY TO ITS OWN EFFORT.
01:39:01.001 --> 01:39:02.736
THIS ENABLES US TO CONTINUE THE
01:39:02.803 --> 01:39:04.238
GOOD WORK THAT WE DO ON BEHALF
01:39:04.305 --> 01:39:05.372
OF THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF
01:39:05.439 --> 01:39:08.475
CALIFORNIA. I URGE YOU TO
01:39:08.542 --> 01:39:10.878
SUPPORT AB THIRTY TWENTY. ALSO
01:39:10.944 --> 01:39:12.780
ON THE LINE IS CHIEF DEPUTY
01:39:12.846 --> 01:39:14.748
CITY ATTORNEY MARK AND CORN HE
01:39:14.815 --> 01:39:16.583
OVERSEES ARE A PERMANENT CIVIL
01:39:16.650 --> 01:39:17.951
ENFORCEMENT UNIT WHICH IS
01:39:18.018 --> 01:39:19.887
PRIMARILY RESPONSIBLE FOR.
01:39:19.953 --> 01:39:21.855
PROSECUTING SEVENTEEN TWO
01:39:21.922 --> 01:39:23.490
HUNDRED CASES MARKET ALSO
01:39:23.557 --> 01:39:24.792
AVAILABLE TO ANSWER YOUR
01:39:24.858 --> 01:39:28.996
QUESTION. AGAIN THANK YOU FOR
01:39:29.063 --> 01:39:29.763
THIS OPPORTUNITY. THANK YOU. MR
01:39:29.830 --> 01:39:31.231
ACCORDING TESTIMONY THAT YOU'D
01:39:31.298 --> 01:39:32.266
LIKE TO GIVE FOR YOU JUST
01:39:32.333 --> 01:39:35.803
AVAILABLE FOR QUESTIONS. NO
01:39:35.869 --> 01:39:36.937
MISTER CHAIRMAN I'M AVAILABLE
01:39:37.004 --> 01:39:38.672
FOR QUESTIONS THANK YOU OKAY.
01:39:38.739 --> 01:39:40.174
THANK YOU. IS THERE ANYONE IN
01:39:40.240 --> 01:39:42.209
THE HEARING ROOM WOULD LIKE TO
01:39:42.276 --> 01:39:43.310
SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF AB THIRTY
01:39:43.377 --> 01:39:45.612
TWENTY. SEEING NONE IS THERE
01:39:45.679 --> 01:39:47.481
ANYONE ON THE PHONE WHO WOULD
01:39:47.548 --> 01:39:49.616
LIKE TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF AB
01:39:49.683 --> 01:39:52.219
THIRTY TWENTY. IF YOU'RE A
01:39:52.286 --> 01:39:54.421
REPORT PLEASE PRESS ONE THEN
01:39:54.488 --> 01:40:01.628
ZERO AT THE TIME. AGAIN THE
01:40:01.695 --> 01:40:03.130
PROMPTER ONE AND THEN ZERO IF
01:40:03.197 --> 01:40:08.001
YOU'RE IN SUPPORT. THERE'S NO
01:40:08.068 --> 01:40:08.836
ONE IN SUPPORT AT THE TIME.
01:40:08.902 --> 01:40:11.805
THANK YOU IS THERE I HAVE NO
01:40:11.872 --> 01:40:13.474
OPPOSITION LISTED IS THERE
01:40:13.540 --> 01:40:16.777
ANYONE IN THE- ROOM WOULD LIKE
01:40:16.844 --> 01:40:17.778
TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION OF AB
01:40:17.845 --> 01:40:19.346
THIRTY TWENTY. SEEING NONE IS
01:40:19.413 --> 01:40:21.148
THERE ANYBODY ON THE PHONE WHO
01:40:21.215 --> 01:40:22.216
WOULDLIKE TO SPEAK IN
01:40:22.282 --> 01:40:25.686
OPPOSITION OF THIRTY TWENTY. IF
01:40:25.753 --> 01:40:27.988
YOU'RE IN OPPOSITION PLEASE
01:40:28.055 --> 01:40:28.555
PRESS ONE IF THEY'RE ALL AT
01:40:28.622 --> 01:40:35.529
THIS TIME. BUT NO ONE IN
01:40:35.596 --> 01:40:37.464
OPPOSITION THANK YOU I'M GONNA
01:40:37.531 --> 01:40:38.298
BRING IT BACK TO THE COMMITTEE
01:40:38.365 --> 01:40:39.800
QUESTIONS COMMENTS THIS
01:40:39.867 --> 01:40:49.410
GALLAGHER. YEAH SO. I THINK THE
01:40:49.476 --> 01:40:51.345
LARGEST CONCERN IS THAT THIS
01:40:51.412 --> 01:40:54.281
MAY BE UNCONSTITUTIONAL- AS A
01:40:54.348 --> 01:40:56.683
VIOLATE ARTICLE FOUR SECTION
01:40:56.750 --> 01:40:58.952
SIXTEEN. WHICH REQUIRES THAT A
01:40:59.019 --> 01:41:01.054
LOCAL OR SPECIAL STATUTE IS
01:41:01.121 --> 01:41:06.460
pCAN BE MADE APPLICABLE- SO THE
01:41:06.527 --> 01:41:09.029
QUESTION BECOMES- AND THE
01:41:09.096 --> 01:41:10.130
REASON THAT'S IN THERE IS WHY
01:41:10.197 --> 01:41:11.732
NOT DO IT GENERAL STATUTE THAT
01:41:11.799 --> 01:41:15.302
SAYS ALL CITIES- COULD IN FACT
01:41:15.369 --> 01:41:18.806
COLLECT. ALL THE PENALTIES- AND
01:41:18.872 --> 01:41:19.907
NOT SHARE THEM WITH THE
01:41:19.973 --> 01:41:22.543
COUNTIES WHY WE DO THIS ONLY
01:41:22.609 --> 01:41:24.511
FOR ONE. JURISDICTION SO I
01:41:24.578 --> 01:41:27.481
THINK THERE IS A- YOU'RE VERY
01:41:27.548 --> 01:41:28.182
FUNDAMENTAL CONSTITUTIONAL
01:41:28.248 --> 01:41:30.284
ISSUE THERE THAT WE WOULD BE
01:41:30.350 --> 01:41:34.388
CONCERNED ABOUT. BUT MAYBE I
01:41:34.455 --> 01:41:35.622
JUST GOT I MEAN AND I'M HEARING
01:41:35.689 --> 01:41:38.025
I HEARD SOME OF THE TESTIMONY
01:41:38.091 --> 01:41:39.026
OTHER THINGS BEING HIGHLIGHTED
01:41:39.092 --> 01:41:41.495
AS- THINGS THAT THE CITY
01:41:41.562 --> 01:41:42.763
ATTORNEY WOULD WANT TO GO AFTER
01:41:42.830 --> 01:41:45.132
PROBABLY THINGS THAT EVERY CITY
01:41:45.199 --> 01:41:46.967
AND CALIFORNIA PROBABLY DEALS
01:41:47.034 --> 01:41:49.269
WITH IN SOME ASPECT AND YET
01:41:49.336 --> 01:41:51.538
THEY ALSO HAVE THE SAME
01:41:51.605 --> 01:41:52.673
PROVISION THAT THEY HAVE TO
01:41:52.739 --> 01:41:57.478
SHARE- WITH THE COUNTIES. SO I
01:41:57.544 --> 01:41:58.045
GUESS I'M TRYING TO SEE LIKE
01:41:58.111 --> 01:42:00.314
WHAT IS. WHAT IS MAYBE SO
01:42:00.380 --> 01:42:02.783
FUNDAMENTALLY GOING ON IN SAN
01:42:02.850 --> 01:42:04.518
DIEGO THAT ISN'T PRESENT. IN
01:42:04.585 --> 01:42:08.755
OTHER AREAS. AND THEN I'LL GO
01:42:08.822 --> 01:42:10.724
TO THIS LIKE IS NOW THE BEST
01:42:10.791 --> 01:42:12.259
TIME TO BE REALLY GOING AFTER A
01:42:12.326 --> 01:42:15.863
LOT OF BUSINESSES- WHEN PEOPLE
01:42:15.929 --> 01:42:16.463
ARE STRUGGLING CERTAINLY THERE
01:42:16.530 --> 01:42:21.134
ARE. LEGITIMATE VIOLATIONS. BUT
01:42:21.201 --> 01:42:24.771
YOU KNOW. THE OPPOSITE COULD BE
01:42:24.838 --> 01:42:26.206
TRUE AS WELL THAT YOU KNOW
01:42:26.273 --> 01:42:28.442
WE'RE GOING AFTER BUSINESSES AT
01:42:28.509 --> 01:42:30.177
A TIME WHEN- A LOT OF PEOPLE
01:42:30.244 --> 01:42:34.548
ARE STRUGGLING JUST TO SURVIVE-
01:42:34.615 --> 01:42:36.850
ESPECIALLY IN THE YOU KNOW IN
01:42:36.917 --> 01:42:40.487
OUR LARGE CITIES. HAPPY TRYING
01:42:40.554 --> 01:42:41.722
FIELD- THINK THERE'S A COUPLE
01:42:41.788 --> 01:42:42.956
QUESTIONS IN THERE WITH REGARD
01:42:43.023 --> 01:42:44.091
TO THE FIRST MATTER THERE IS A
01:42:44.157 --> 01:42:46.460
DECLARATION OF SPECIAL STATUTE
01:42:46.527 --> 01:42:47.060
IN SECTION TWO OF THE BILL HAS
01:42:47.127 --> 01:42:49.096
PROPOSED TO YOUR OBSERVATION
01:42:49.162 --> 01:42:50.931
THAT THIS IS LIMITED TO THE
01:42:50.998 --> 01:42:52.699
CITY OF SAN DIEGO- THE-
01:42:52.766 --> 01:42:54.601
COMMITTEE ANALYSIS OR SYNOPSIS
01:42:54.668 --> 01:42:55.602
POINTS OUT THE LAST YEAR IN A
01:42:55.669 --> 01:42:57.237
VERY SIMILAR BILL WITH A
01:42:57.304 --> 01:43:00.173
BROADER- HEATING EIGHTY COMPASS
01:43:00.240 --> 01:43:02.042
MORE COMMUNITIES. HOWEVER THAT
01:43:02.109 --> 01:43:03.710
BILL WAS VETOED BY GOVERNOR DO
01:43:03.777 --> 01:43:05.546
SOME- YOU KNOW THIS IS
01:43:05.612 --> 01:43:07.214
BASICALLY A FIVE TO THREE
01:43:07.281 --> 01:43:09.216
CITIES- CITIES OF SAN DIEGO SAN
01:43:09.283 --> 01:43:12.185
JOSE AND LOS ANGELES- BECAUSE
01:43:12.252 --> 01:43:14.655
THAT BROADER BILL- WAS NOT
01:43:14.721 --> 01:43:15.923
SIGNED INTO LAW WE'RE BACK HERE
01:43:15.989 --> 01:43:17.991
TODAY ON BEHALF OF THE CITY
01:43:18.058 --> 01:43:19.860
CITY A GO WITH THIS IS NOT
01:43:19.927 --> 01:43:20.961
CONTROVERSIAL THERE'S NOT A
01:43:21.028 --> 01:43:22.162
FIGHT BETWEEN THE COUNTY IN THE
01:43:22.229 --> 01:43:25.866
STATE ASSEMBLY ASKING FOR THE-
01:43:25.933 --> 01:43:26.567
YOUR LAST POINT YEAH. IRAQI
01:43:26.633 --> 01:43:27.034
THERE DIDN'T TIMES FOR
01:43:27.100 --> 01:43:28.468
BUSINESSES BUT THIS TOGETHER
01:43:28.535 --> 01:43:30.103
I'M SURE- YOU ARE FAMILIAR WITH
01:43:30.170 --> 01:43:31.271
THE FACT THAT THERE ARE MANY
01:43:31.338 --> 01:43:32.706
BUSINESSES ARE STRUGGLING. BUT
01:43:32.773 --> 01:43:33.874
THERE ARE ALSO MANY BUSINESSES
01:43:33.941 --> 01:43:34.808
THAT ARE ENGAGING IN ILLEGAL
01:43:34.875 --> 01:43:35.809
BEHAVIOR EXPORTING THE
01:43:35.876 --> 01:43:37.277
PANDEMIC. AND WENT TO THE
01:43:37.344 --> 01:43:38.812
EXTENT THAT WE CAN AUTHORIZE
01:43:38.879 --> 01:43:40.480
THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO TO GO
01:43:40.547 --> 01:43:42.015
AFTER THAT. THANK YOU RECOGNIZE
01:43:42.082 --> 01:43:43.216
HOW YOUR COUNTY YOUR DA'S
01:43:43.283 --> 01:43:44.985
OVERWHELMED BY WORK HI THIS
01:43:45.052 --> 01:43:47.020
WOULD ALLOW. THE CITY ATTORNEY
01:43:47.087 --> 01:43:48.589
TO ALSO GO AFTER THIS THING
01:43:48.655 --> 01:43:50.691
WITHOUT HAVING TO- CONSIDER THE
01:43:50.757 --> 01:43:52.292
FACT THAT THIS WOULD BE NEXT.
01:43:52.359 --> 01:43:54.261
X. BUT- EXPENDING. A FINITE
01:43:54.328 --> 01:43:56.229
PUBLIC RESOURCES- WITHOUT BEING
01:43:56.296 --> 01:43:58.498
ABLE TO PROPERLY- REIMBURSE
01:43:58.565 --> 01:44:00.100
THOSE EFFORTS INSTEAD HAVE A
01:44:00.167 --> 01:44:02.102
SHARE THAT- THOSE PROCEEDS BUT
01:44:02.169 --> 01:44:03.337
WITH THE COUNTY SAN DIEGO WHO.
01:44:03.403 --> 01:44:04.671
AS OUR CITY ATTORNEY MENTION
01:44:04.738 --> 01:44:06.406
MADE DONE NOTHING- WITH REGARD
01:44:06.473 --> 01:44:07.407
TO LEGAL PROCEEDING BUT IT'S
01:44:07.474 --> 01:44:10.243
STILL ENTITLED TO HALF. OF THE
01:44:10.310 --> 01:44:13.947
WAR. MORE JUST. A QUICK
01:44:14.014 --> 01:44:16.316
RESPONSE YOU KNOW. YES LAST
01:44:16.383 --> 01:44:17.317
YEAR'S LEGISLATION WAS VETOED
01:44:17.384 --> 01:44:18.785
BY THE GOVERNOR I'M CONCERNED
01:44:18.852 --> 01:44:20.253
THIS ONE'S GONNA GET VETOED BY
01:44:20.320 --> 01:44:22.322
THE CALIFORNIA SUPREME COURT-
01:44:22.389 --> 01:44:24.024
BECAUSE IT IS A SPECIAL STATUTE
01:44:24.091 --> 01:44:27.194
WHERE YOU COULD DO A GENERAL. A
01:44:27.260 --> 01:44:27.594
STATUTE OF GENERAL
01:44:27.661 --> 01:44:31.431
APPLICABILITY. AND THEN LOOK
01:44:31.498 --> 01:44:33.033
I'D THERE'S NOTHING THAT
01:44:33.100 --> 01:44:35.535
PRECLUDES RIGHT NOW CITY
01:44:35.602 --> 01:44:37.704
OFFICES IN CITY ATTORNEYS FROM
01:44:37.771 --> 01:44:39.940
GOING AFTER ABOUT ACTORS AND
01:44:40.007 --> 01:44:42.109
THEY CAN AND SHOULD DO THAT. IT
01:44:42.175 --> 01:44:43.710
SEEMS TO ME THAT THIS IS GOING
01:44:43.777 --> 01:44:45.112
TO GREATER INCENTIVIZE BECAUSE
01:44:45.178 --> 01:44:47.214
NOW IT'S A REVENUE SOURCE IS
01:44:47.280 --> 01:44:48.248
EVEN MORE OF A GRADE A REVENUE
01:44:48.315 --> 01:44:51.418
SOURCE AND I'VE SEEN INSTANCES.
01:44:51.485 --> 01:44:53.854
WHERE WHEN THAT'S THE CASE- I
01:44:53.920 --> 01:44:55.656
WOULD ARGUE FRIVOLOUS SUITS GET
01:44:55.722 --> 01:44:56.623
BROUGHT AGAINST SMALL
01:44:56.690 --> 01:44:57.991
BUSINESSES BECAUSE HEY THEY
01:44:58.058 --> 01:44:59.926
THEY'RE GONNA GET. YOU HAVE TO
01:44:59.993 --> 01:45:02.896
SETTLE. OR RISK LOSING THEIR
01:45:02.963 --> 01:45:04.898
ENTIRE BUSINESS AND SO. YOU
01:45:04.965 --> 01:45:07.467
KNOW IT BECOMES A MONEY MAKER-
01:45:07.534 --> 01:45:08.769
IN A WAY THAT I THINK IS NOT
01:45:08.835 --> 01:45:11.638
VERY JUST YOU KNOW FOR THE
01:45:11.705 --> 01:45:12.773
BUSINESSES AND FOR PEOPLE THAT
01:45:12.839 --> 01:45:14.508
ARE JUST TRYING AGAIN AT THAT
01:45:14.574 --> 01:45:15.676
ARE GOING TO SOME REALLY
01:45:15.742 --> 01:45:17.110
DIFFICULT CIRCUMSTANCES RIGHT
01:45:17.177 --> 01:45:17.844
NOW SO THAT WOULD BE MY
01:45:17.911 --> 01:45:20.213
CONCERN. AND JUST TO MAKE SURE
01:45:20.280 --> 01:45:20.847
IT'S ON THE RECORD MISTER
01:45:20.914 --> 01:45:22.516
CHAIRMAN I HERE WITH MISTER
01:45:22.582 --> 01:45:23.684
GALLAGHER ST I WOULD JUST POINT
01:45:23.750 --> 01:45:25.819
OUT THAT- THERE ARE FEW THAT
01:45:25.886 --> 01:45:27.054
JUST LET AGAINST THAT ARE GOING
01:45:27.120 --> 01:45:27.988
TO BE HELD ACCOUNTABLE AT THE
01:45:28.055 --> 01:45:29.356
BALLOT BOX IN THE CASE OF THE
01:45:29.423 --> 01:45:31.291
CITY ATTORNEY- THIS INDIVIDUAL
01:45:31.358 --> 01:45:32.926
MUST GO BEFORE THE VOTERS OF
01:45:32.993 --> 01:45:34.394
SAN DIEGO EVERY FOUR YEARS. IF
01:45:34.461 --> 01:45:35.395
THEY'RE IN THIS USING THIS
01:45:35.462 --> 01:45:36.697
AUTHORITY I SUSPECT THE PUBLIC
01:45:36.763 --> 01:45:38.098
HOLD THEM ACCOUNTABLE I THINK
01:45:38.165 --> 01:45:39.366
WHAT WE'RE TRYING TO DO IS TO
01:45:39.433 --> 01:45:41.101
TAKE TO ALLOW THEM TO ACTUALLY
01:45:41.168 --> 01:45:42.836
MAKE THE DECISION TO BE ABLE TO
01:45:42.903 --> 01:45:44.538
PURSUE THIS WITH THEIR FINITE
01:45:44.604 --> 01:45:45.806
RESOURCES. YOU'RE BOTH KNOW
01:45:45.872 --> 01:45:47.174
WHAT WE'LL GET OUR BUDGET YOU
01:45:47.240 --> 01:45:47.841
CAN IMAGINE WHAT THEY'RE HAVING
01:45:47.908 --> 01:45:48.975
TO DO DOWN THERE AND THAT
01:45:49.042 --> 01:45:50.110
SHOULD NOT BE AN EXCUSE TO OUT
01:45:50.177 --> 01:45:51.578
BAD ACTORS TO BE HELD ON
01:45:51.645 --> 01:45:53.280
ACCOUNTABLE. THIS AT LEAST IT
01:45:53.346 --> 01:45:54.848
GIVES MORE OF A CHANCE THAT
01:45:54.915 --> 01:45:55.348
SOME OF THESE FOLKS ARE
01:45:55.415 --> 01:45:57.117
ENGAGING BAD BEHAVIOR HAS SOME
01:45:57.184 --> 01:45:58.819
RISK OF BEING HELD ACCOUNTABLE
01:45:58.885 --> 01:46:00.120
NOT NECESSARY CARP WANTED
01:46:00.187 --> 01:46:01.588
RESOURCE THEY'RE STILL LIMITED.
01:46:01.655 --> 01:46:02.556
BUT THEY WOULD NOT HAVE TO
01:46:02.622 --> 01:46:03.957
SHARE THE PROCEEDS OF THIS
01:46:04.024 --> 01:46:05.625
STUFF TO PICK ME A BURST OF
01:46:05.692 --> 01:46:06.760
WORKED ON BEHALF OF THE PUBLIC
01:46:06.827 --> 01:46:08.929
WITH AN AGENCY DID NOTHING TO
01:46:08.995 --> 01:46:12.532
ACTUALLY EFFECTUATE THAT
01:46:12.599 --> 01:46:15.836
POSITIVE OUTCOME. IF YOU MISSED.
01:46:15.902 --> 01:46:18.004
I'M IS THERE MOTION KNOW
01:46:18.071 --> 01:46:19.139
THERE'S AN ALL MAKE A MOTION I
01:46:19.206 --> 01:46:20.640
WANT TO THANK YIELD MISS CORY
01:46:20.707 --> 01:46:21.708
LIKE HEY WE HAVE A MOST IS
01:46:21.775 --> 01:46:23.443
THEIR SECOND AND SECOND THANK
01:46:23.510 --> 01:46:25.011
YOU I'D LIKE TO CO AUTHOR IF
01:46:25.078 --> 01:46:27.514
POSSIBLE THIS BILL- JUST SO
01:46:27.581 --> 01:46:29.416
PEOPLE ARE WHERE THE THIS ISN'T
01:46:29.483 --> 01:46:31.485
A RANDOM DESIGNATION THE SEVEN
01:46:31.551 --> 01:46:32.486
HUNDRED FIFTY THOUSAND IS IN
01:46:32.552 --> 01:46:34.588
THE BNP CODE IT'S ALSO- AND THE
01:46:34.654 --> 01:46:36.690
LABOR CODE WHICH ALLOWS. ADD
01:46:36.757 --> 01:46:38.058
THESE LARGER CITIES INCLUDING
01:46:38.125 --> 01:46:39.192
THE SAN FRANCISCO BUT THAT'S
01:46:39.259 --> 01:46:40.293
DIFFERENT HAS ALSO THE COUNTY I
01:46:40.360 --> 01:46:41.595
GUESS THEY DON'T HAVE THE SAME
01:46:41.661 --> 01:46:45.132
I'M REVENUE ISSUE BUT IT WE
01:46:45.198 --> 01:46:46.633
PROVIDE THE CITIES THE
01:46:46.700 --> 01:46:48.902
OPPORTUNITY TO UTILIZE THE LOT
01:46:48.969 --> 01:46:49.803
IN A DIFFERENT WAY THAT OTHER
01:46:49.870 --> 01:46:51.438
CITY ATTORNEY STOPPED- THEY
01:46:51.505 --> 01:46:53.073
CAN'T BRING THESE ACTIONS AND
01:46:53.140 --> 01:46:55.108
SO IT SEEMS FAIR THAT WHEN
01:46:55.175 --> 01:46:57.210
THEY- PUT CONSIDERABLE
01:46:57.277 --> 01:46:59.279
RESOURCES. IN MOST THESE
01:46:59.346 --> 01:47:00.347
ACTIONS ARE AGAINST BIG
01:47:00.413 --> 01:47:01.848
CORPORATIONS AND THEY HAVE TO
01:47:01.915 --> 01:47:03.483
USE CONSIDERABLE RESOURCES IN
01:47:03.550 --> 01:47:05.986
ORDER TO EVEN LITIGATE IT THAT
01:47:06.052 --> 01:47:08.088
WHEN THEY WHEN THEY SHOULD GET
01:47:08.155 --> 01:47:09.556
THE FRUITS OF THAT LABOR ON
01:47:09.623 --> 01:47:12.492
BACK SO I ABSOLUTELY-
01:47:12.559 --> 01:47:14.628
APPRECIATED AND APPRECIATE THE
01:47:14.694 --> 01:47:16.129
WORK THAT THE SAN DIEGO CITY
01:47:16.196 --> 01:47:19.065
ATTORNEY HAS DONE AND THAT ENDS
01:47:19.132 --> 01:47:19.599
UP BEING AND WHEN HE WON'T
01:47:19.666 --> 01:47:21.768
THESE SORT OF FOR SOME ACTION
01:47:21.835 --> 01:47:25.705
SAM THANK YOU. THANK YOU FOR
01:47:25.772 --> 01:47:28.742
THE QUESTION COMMENTS. ALRIGHT
01:47:28.809 --> 01:47:29.376
THIS IS LAURIE I'D I THINK IT'S
01:47:29.442 --> 01:47:31.011
A IT'S A FIVE BILL AND I FOR
01:47:31.077 --> 01:47:34.581
ONE DO NOT SEE A CUTS TO PROP.
01:47:34.648 --> 01:47:36.249
THIS IS. AT A GROUP THAT.
01:47:36.316 --> 01:47:38.485
COUNTY SAN DIEGO LEASE. DON'T
01:47:38.552 --> 01:47:39.920
HAVE A QUALM ABOUT MOVING THIS
01:47:39.986 --> 01:47:42.122
FORWARD AND ABSOLUTELY SUPPORT
01:47:42.189 --> 01:47:44.191
YOUR- YOUR BILL SO WITH THAT
01:47:44.257 --> 01:47:46.159
YOU MAY CLOSE THANK YOU SIR I
01:47:46.226 --> 01:47:46.793
JUST WANT EXPRESS MY
01:47:46.860 --> 01:47:47.928
APPRECIATION TO SERIOUSLY
01:47:47.994 --> 01:47:49.629
TURNING OUR ELLIOT CAR
01:47:49.696 --> 01:47:50.664
PARTNERSHIP IN THIS LEGISLATION
01:47:50.730 --> 01:47:52.432
THANK- MY COLLEAGUE FROM SAN
01:47:52.499 --> 01:47:54.034
DIEGO FOR HER KIND WORDS AND
01:47:54.100 --> 01:47:55.468
HAPPY TO ADD YOU AND I JUST FOR
01:47:55.535 --> 01:47:57.003
THE RECORD WOULD POINT OUT THAT
01:47:57.070 --> 01:47:58.138
AND I SHOULD HAVE. SAID THIS AN
01:47:58.205 --> 01:47:59.372
ANSWERING MISTER GALLAGHER THE
01:47:59.439 --> 01:48:00.640
PROCEEDS THAT WOULD COME FROM
01:48:00.707 --> 01:48:02.676
JUSTIFICATION MUST BE SPENT BY
01:48:02.742 --> 01:48:03.476
THE CITY ATTORNEY ON
01:48:03.543 --> 01:48:05.278
ADDITIONAL- THE BUSINESS
01:48:05.345 --> 01:48:06.413
PRACTICE UNFAIR BUSINESS
01:48:06.479 --> 01:48:08.014
PRACTICES FOR SMITH SO THIS IS
01:48:08.081 --> 01:48:09.783
NOT INTENDED TO BE- A
01:48:09.850 --> 01:48:11.384
SWEEPSTAKES- FOR THE CITY
01:48:11.451 --> 01:48:12.886
ATTORNEY'S OFFICE ASSEMBLY
01:48:12.953 --> 01:48:14.521
MEANT TO HELP HER DEVELOP HER
01:48:14.588 --> 01:48:16.823
AND SUCCESSORS DO THEIR JOB- AS
01:48:16.890 --> 01:48:18.124
EFFECTIVELY AS POSSIBLE
01:48:18.191 --> 01:48:19.492
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR IDOL
01:48:19.559 --> 01:48:20.727
TODAY. THANK YOU WE DO HAVE A
01:48:20.794 --> 01:48:22.095
MOTION AND A SECOND THE MOST
01:48:22.162 --> 01:48:24.497
ASTUTE CALL THE ROLL PLEASE
01:48:24.564 --> 01:48:29.736
STONE BY. STONE I GALLAGHER. GO
01:48:29.803 --> 01:48:33.139
NO CHAO. CHAO I TO. FROM
01:48:33.206 --> 01:48:37.811
DOLLARS. CONSOLES I HOLDEN. ALL
01:48:37.878 --> 01:48:41.114
KALRA I KILEY. I'M SORRY WAS
01:48:41.181 --> 01:48:44.217
THAT NO KILEY NO. MAIENSCHEIN
01:48:44.284 --> 01:48:47.854
OBERNOLTE. OBERNOLTE NO REYES
01:48:47.921 --> 01:48:53.526
REYES AYE. THAT HAS FIVE VOTE
01:48:53.593 --> 01:48:55.428
CHECK THE BILL HAS FIVE ALSO
01:48:55.495 --> 01:48:57.464
PUT ON CALL TECHNICIAN THANK
01:48:57.530 --> 01:49:00.567
YOU ALL RIGHT MISS AGUIAR-CURRY.
01:49:00.634 --> 01:49:02.903
THIS TAKES US TO ITEM NUMBER
01:49:02.969 --> 01:49:05.071
SEVEN AB THIRTY ONE THIRTY
01:49:05.138 --> 01:49:05.872
THREE OPERATOR IF YOU COULD
01:49:05.939 --> 01:49:09.042
OPEN THE LINES FOR A. B. THIRTY
01:49:09.109 --> 01:49:14.381
ONE THIRTY THREE. AND OPEN
01:49:14.447 --> 01:49:17.417
THANK YOU. GOOD MORNING
01:49:17.484 --> 01:49:20.987
CHAIRMAN STONE AND REMEMBERS-
01:49:21.054 --> 01:49:23.456
AB THIRTY ONE THIRTY THREE
01:49:23.523 --> 01:49:24.457
CODIFIES CALIFORNIA'S
01:49:24.524 --> 01:49:25.992
COMMITMENT TO RESETTLING
01:49:26.059 --> 01:49:27.594
REFUGEES WITHOUT DISCRIMINATION
01:49:27.661 --> 01:49:29.396
AS PART OF THE UNITED STATES
01:49:29.462 --> 01:49:31.197
RECEPTION AND PLACEMENT PROGRAM
01:49:31.264 --> 01:49:33.900
REFUGEES ARE MEN WOMEN AND
01:49:33.967 --> 01:49:35.235
CHILDREN WHO ARE FORCED TO FLEE
01:49:35.302 --> 01:49:36.770
THEIR COUNTRY OF ORIGIN TO SEEK
01:49:36.836 --> 01:49:39.272
ANOTHER COUNTRY DUE TO WAR.
01:49:39.339 --> 01:49:40.640
GOVERNMENTAL OF PEOPLE OR
01:49:40.707 --> 01:49:42.342
PERSECUTION BASED UPON THE
01:49:42.409 --> 01:49:44.744
RELIGION NATIONALITY OR
01:49:44.811 --> 01:49:46.513
MEMBERSHIP IN A PARTICULAR
01:49:46.579 --> 01:49:48.348
SOCIAL OR POLITICAL GROUP.
01:49:48.415 --> 01:49:51.318
CALIFORNIA HAS HAD A LONG LONG
01:49:51.384 --> 01:49:53.119
TRADITION OF OFFERING REFUGEES
01:49:53.186 --> 01:49:54.788
ARE HAVING RECEIVED NEWLY
01:49:54.854 --> 01:49:56.489
ARRIVED REFUGEES SINCE NINETEEN
01:49:56.556 --> 01:49:58.358
EIGHTY. THESE REFUGEES THEN
01:49:58.425 --> 01:49:59.559
TURN AROUND A CONTRIBUTE
01:49:59.626 --> 01:50:01.561
SIGNIFICANT ECONOMIC AND
01:50:01.628 --> 01:50:02.629
CULTURAL CONTRIBUTIONS TO OUR
01:50:02.696 --> 01:50:04.831
STATE INCLUDING SEVENTEEN
01:50:04.898 --> 01:50:06.866
BILLION IN SPENDING POWER AND
01:50:06.933 --> 01:50:07.467
THE DIVERSITY WE ARE SO PROUD
01:50:07.534 --> 01:50:09.636
OF. WITH FEDERAL FUNDING
01:50:09.703 --> 01:50:11.271
SUPPORT RESETTLEMENT AGENCIES
01:50:11.338 --> 01:50:13.673
PROVIDE DIRECT SUPPORT TO NEWLY
01:50:13.740 --> 01:50:15.775
ARRIVED REFUGEES PLUS
01:50:15.842 --> 01:50:17.410
ASSISTANCE TO ASYLUM SEEKERS.
01:50:17.477 --> 01:50:19.579
DOCTOR RECEPTIVE RECIPIENTS AND
01:50:19.646 --> 01:50:20.480
UNDOCUMENTED PEOPLE IN
01:50:20.547 --> 01:50:22.649
CALIFORNIA. THIS BILL SIMPLY
01:50:22.716 --> 01:50:25.552
CODIFIES IN A LOCKED IN OUR LAW
01:50:25.618 --> 01:50:26.953
THAT WE WILL CONTINUE TO UPHOLD
01:50:27.020 --> 01:50:28.288
OUR COMMITMENT TO ASSISTING
01:50:28.355 --> 01:50:30.490
THOSE SEEKING REFUGEE IN OUR
01:50:30.557 --> 01:50:32.592
COUNTRY AND STATE. I ASK FOR
01:50:32.659 --> 01:50:33.960
YOUR AYE VOTE AND I HAVE A
01:50:34.027 --> 01:50:35.428
SPEAKER KAREN FERGUSON FROM THE
01:50:35.495 --> 01:50:37.530
INTERNATIONAL RESCUE COMMITTEE
01:50:37.597 --> 01:50:39.366
TO SUPPORT ME ON THE PHONE.
01:50:39.432 --> 01:50:42.635
THANK YOU I DO HAVE ONE SUPPORT
01:50:42.702 --> 01:50:45.438
WITNESS LISTED AND THAT IS DR
01:50:45.505 --> 01:50:46.072
FERGUSON DUTCH FERGUSON ARE YOU
01:50:46.139 --> 01:50:50.477
WITH US. I AM YES GREAT WE CAN
01:50:50.543 --> 01:50:51.077
HEAR YOU PLEASE GO AHEAD YOU
01:50:51.144 --> 01:50:53.880
CAN HEAR ME OKAY GREAT ALREADY
01:50:53.947 --> 01:50:55.048
SO THIS IS KAREN FERGUSON I'M
01:50:55.115 --> 01:50:56.850
THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE
01:50:56.916 --> 01:50:58.651
INTERNATIONAL RESCUE COMMITTEE
01:50:58.718 --> 01:51:01.121
IN NORTHERN CALIFORNIA THE I RC
01:51:01.187 --> 01:51:02.522
THE IDEA OF THE REFUGEE
01:51:02.589 --> 01:51:04.357
RESETTLEMENT AGENCY WITH TWENTY
01:51:04.424 --> 01:51:06.559
FIVE OFFICES SPREAD ACROSS
01:51:06.626 --> 01:51:07.794
FIFTEEN STATES IN THE U. S. AND
01:51:07.861 --> 01:51:09.629
HERE IN CALIFORNIA WE HAVE
01:51:09.696 --> 01:51:11.297
SEVEN WEEKS SETTLEMENT SITE. WE
01:51:11.364 --> 01:51:13.166
ARE ONE OF THE NINE WITH
01:51:13.233 --> 01:51:16.403
SETTLEMENT AGENCIES THAT THE
01:51:16.469 --> 01:51:17.437
THING REFUGEES. YOUR IDEA OF
01:51:17.504 --> 01:51:19.572
HOME CAL. THIRD ALONG SIDE YOU
01:51:19.639 --> 01:51:23.143
MILLER. ENACT FOR OUR REFUGEES
01:51:23.209 --> 01:51:25.745
REUNITING WITH FAMILY AFTER
01:51:25.812 --> 01:51:27.347
CLEAN WAR AND COMPLEX. I'M
01:51:27.414 --> 01:51:28.948
PARTICIPATING TODAY TO
01:51:29.015 --> 01:51:30.583
REPRESENT I A SEAT THE PART FOR
01:51:30.650 --> 01:51:32.585
AB THREE ONE THREE THREE
01:51:32.652 --> 01:51:33.920
REFUGEES FROM THIRD BY
01:51:33.987 --> 01:51:36.322
ASSEMBLYMEMBER AGUIAR-CURRY AND
01:51:36.389 --> 01:51:38.558
MY AT. WHAT DID YOU RETIREMENT
01:51:38.625 --> 01:51:41.027
IS A PROCESS THAT IS DESIGNED
01:51:41.094 --> 01:51:42.962
AS A PUBLIC PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP
01:51:43.029 --> 01:51:44.230
BUILT UP OVER THE LAST FORTY
01:51:44.297 --> 01:51:46.666
YEARS AND INCORPORATING FEDERAL
01:51:46.733 --> 01:51:48.301
AND STATE GOVERNMENT COMMUNITY
01:51:48.368 --> 01:51:50.603
PARTNERS AND RETIREMENT AGENCY
01:51:50.670 --> 01:51:52.338
INPUT. TO FACILITATE A
01:51:52.405 --> 01:51:55.642
SUCCESSFUL TRANSITION FOR CLIMB.
01:51:55.708 --> 01:51:57.143
I'D RETIREMENT AGENCIES WE WORK
01:51:57.210 --> 01:51:59.079
CLOSELY WITH A WIDE RANGE OF
01:51:59.145 --> 01:52:01.214
LOCAL AGENCIES AND WE PROVIDE
01:52:01.281 --> 01:52:02.949
FEDERALLY FUNDED SUPPORT TO
01:52:03.016 --> 01:52:05.885
HELP NEWLY ARRIVED REFUGEES AND
01:52:05.952 --> 01:52:06.619
OTHER VIOLENT VULNERABLE
01:52:06.686 --> 01:52:08.621
GROUPS. SUCH AS VICTIMS OF
01:52:08.688 --> 01:52:10.723
TRAFFICKING INTEGRATE AND
01:52:10.790 --> 01:52:12.559
THRIVE IN THE COMMUNITY. THIS
01:52:12.625 --> 01:52:14.427
WORK BENEFITS THE REFUGEES AND
01:52:14.494 --> 01:52:15.628
THE COMMUNITIES THAT ARE THEIR
01:52:15.695 --> 01:52:18.498
NEW HOME. DESPITE ALL OF THIS
01:52:18.565 --> 01:52:20.567
COORDINATION THE RELATIONSHIP
01:52:20.633 --> 01:52:22.168
THAT MANIFEST IN A BIG CIRCLE
01:52:22.235 --> 01:52:24.471
WITH THE ELEMENT PROGRAM CAN BE
01:52:24.537 --> 01:52:28.441
ELIMINATED IN AN ACTION AS WITH
01:52:28.508 --> 01:52:30.443
AS AN EXECUTIVE ORDER. IN THE
01:52:30.510 --> 01:52:32.645
LAST THREE YEARS DIRECTED YOU
01:52:32.712 --> 01:52:34.013
WOULD SETTLEMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
01:52:34.080 --> 01:52:36.850
HASFACED UNPRECEDENTED ATTACK
01:52:36.916 --> 01:52:38.184
AGAINST WHAT WAS ONCE THE
01:52:38.251 --> 01:52:40.386
SYSTEMS THAT ENJOYED BIPARTISAN
01:52:40.453 --> 01:52:43.556
SUPPORT. IN THE FEW YEARS WE
01:52:43.623 --> 01:52:45.158
HAVE WITNESSED STATE OPT TO
01:52:45.225 --> 01:52:46.960
WITHDRAW FROM THE RESETTLEMENT
01:52:47.026 --> 01:52:49.796
PROGRAM AND IN A MINUTE AND AN
01:52:49.863 --> 01:52:51.764
ADMINISTRATION THAT JEFF THIS
01:52:51.831 --> 01:52:54.701
PAST WINTER REQUIRED GOVERNORS
01:52:54.767 --> 01:52:56.569
AND LOCAL COUNTY AND CITY BOARD
01:52:56.636 --> 01:52:58.705
TO PUBLICLY CERTIFIED THEIR
01:52:58.771 --> 01:53:00.607
CONSENT IF THEY WISHED FIFTY
01:53:00.673 --> 01:53:02.976
RETIREMENT CONTINUE IN OUR
01:53:03.042 --> 01:53:05.678
STATE AS ASSEMBLYMEMBER
01:53:05.745 --> 01:53:08.014
AGUIAR-CURRY JUST MENTIONED
01:53:08.081 --> 01:53:09.849
CALIFORNIA HAS ALWAYS BEEN A
01:53:09.916 --> 01:53:11.351
WELCOMING HOME TO THE WORLD'S.
01:53:11.417 --> 01:53:13.486
MOST AT RISK. IT IS THE STATE
01:53:13.553 --> 01:53:15.321
WHERE THE RETIREMENT PROGRAM AS
01:53:15.388 --> 01:53:17.457
WE KNOW IT TODAY WAS BORN WHEN
01:53:17.524 --> 01:53:19.192
THE FIRST WAVE OF SOUTHEAST
01:53:19.259 --> 01:53:21.728
ASIAN REFUGEES ARRIVED QUICKLY
01:53:21.794 --> 01:53:24.931
BECAME SAFETY AND SHELTER. I
01:53:24.998 --> 01:53:26.266
THINK IT'S A MAJOR MARK ON
01:53:26.332 --> 01:53:28.334
CALIFORNIA CONTRIBUTING MAJOR
01:53:28.401 --> 01:53:30.170
INDUSTRY STARTING A BUSINESS IS
01:53:30.236 --> 01:53:32.005
BOTH SMALL AND LARGE AND
01:53:32.071 --> 01:53:33.640
REVITALIZED TO COMMUNICATE
01:53:33.706 --> 01:53:35.708
COMMUNITIES AS THEY BUY HOMES
01:53:35.775 --> 01:53:37.443
AND RAISE THEIR FAMILIES HERE.
01:53:37.510 --> 01:53:39.846
IN FACT IN THIS LATEST PANDEMIC
01:53:39.913 --> 01:53:41.014
REFUGEES WITH HEALTHCARE
01:53:41.080 --> 01:53:44.317
TRAINING ARE STEPPING UP TO
01:53:44.384 --> 01:53:45.585
HELP ON THE FRONTLINE. OUR
01:53:45.652 --> 01:53:47.253
STATE AND LOCAL COMMUNITY
01:53:47.320 --> 01:53:49.389
BENEFIT FROM THEIR REBELLION.
01:53:49.455 --> 01:53:52.358
WE ASK YOU TO PASS AB THREE ONE
01:53:52.425 --> 01:53:53.159
THREE THREE AND PROTECT THE
01:53:53.226 --> 01:53:55.695
INFRASTRUCTURE OF THE U. S.
01:53:55.762 --> 01:53:56.296
RESETTLEMENT PROGRAM HERE IN
01:53:56.362 --> 01:53:58.264
CALIFORNIA FOR FUTURE REFUGEES
01:53:58.331 --> 01:54:00.200
THAT WILL ARISE AND CALL THE
01:54:00.266 --> 01:54:05.538
STATE HOME. THANK YOU THANK YOU.
01:54:05.605 --> 01:54:07.307
I DON'T HAVE ANY WELL AS LISTED
01:54:07.373 --> 01:54:09.008
IS THERE ANYONE IN THE HEARING
01:54:09.075 --> 01:54:11.311
ROOM WHO WOULD LIKE TO USE
01:54:11.377 --> 01:54:12.512
BEACON SUPPORT OF AB THIRTY ONE
01:54:12.579 --> 01:54:14.581
THIRTY THREE. SEEING NONE IS
01:54:14.647 --> 01:54:16.249
THERE ANYONE ON THE PHONE WHO
01:54:16.316 --> 01:54:18.051
WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT
01:54:18.117 --> 01:54:20.653
OF AB THIRTY ONE THIRTY THREE.
01:54:20.720 --> 01:54:21.688
LADIES AND GENTLEMEN TO SHOW
01:54:21.754 --> 01:54:23.723
SUPPORT FOR AB THREE ONE THREE
01:54:23.790 --> 01:54:25.658
THREE. PLEASE PRESS ONE AND
01:54:25.725 --> 01:54:28.561
ZERO. ONCE AGAIN TO SHOW
01:54:28.628 --> 01:54:30.330
SUPPORT PLEASE PRESS ONE DIDN'T
01:54:30.396 --> 01:54:35.802
ZERO AT THIS TIME. AND LOCAL
01:54:35.868 --> 01:54:38.171
THE LINE NUMBER FIFTY LINE FIVE
01:54:38.238 --> 01:54:41.874
ZERO YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
01:54:41.941 --> 01:54:43.243
NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF SOCIAL
01:54:43.309 --> 01:54:44.510
WORKERS CALIFORNIA CHAPTER IN
01:54:44.577 --> 01:54:52.986
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. WE DO HAVE
01:54:53.052 --> 01:54:54.654
ONE MORE TO BE JUST A MOMENT TO
01:54:54.721 --> 01:55:03.630
GET THEIR LINE NUMBER PLEASE.
01:55:03.696 --> 01:55:05.698
I'D LIKE TO GO TO MY NUMBER
01:55:05.765 --> 01:55:06.299
TWELVE LINE NUMBER TWELVE YOUR
01:55:06.366 --> 01:55:13.573
LINE IS OPEN. YES GOOD MORNING
01:55:13.640 --> 01:55:19.279
THIS IS THAT. THANK YOU. WHAT
01:55:19.345 --> 01:55:21.381
THE INITIAL SUPPORT FOR A BI
01:55:21.447 --> 01:55:22.849
THREE ONE THREE THREE CLASS
01:55:22.915 --> 01:55:23.416
PLEASE PRESS ONE TO ZERO AT
01:55:23.483 --> 01:55:26.919
THIS TIME. WE HAVE NO ONE ALSO
01:55:26.986 --> 01:55:28.988
IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU OPERATOR
01:55:29.055 --> 01:55:30.857
I. HAVE NO ONE LISTED IN
01:55:30.923 --> 01:55:32.659
OPPOSITION IS THERE ANYONE IN
01:55:32.725 --> 01:55:34.661
THE HEARING ROOM WHO WOULD LIKE
01:55:34.727 --> 01:55:35.662
TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION OF AB
01:55:35.728 --> 01:55:38.164
THIRTY ONE THIRTY THREE. SEEING
01:55:38.231 --> 01:55:39.699
NONE IS THERE ANYONE ON THE
01:55:39.766 --> 01:55:41.701
PHONE WHO WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK
01:55:41.768 --> 01:55:42.935
IN OPPOSITION OF AB THIRTY ONE
01:55:43.002 --> 01:55:45.471
THIRTY THREE. HELLO MANISHA
01:55:45.538 --> 01:55:48.975
OPPOSITION FOR EIGHTY THREE ONE
01:55:49.042 --> 01:55:49.575
THIRTY THREE PLEASE PRESS ONE
01:55:49.642 --> 01:55:56.349
TO ZERO AT THIS TIME. NO ONE IN
01:55:56.416 --> 01:55:57.817
OPPOSITION PLEASE CONTINUE SIR
01:55:57.884 --> 01:55:59.185
ALL RIGHT THANK YOU OPERATOR.
01:55:59.252 --> 01:56:00.787
WILL BRING IT BACK TO COMMITTEE
01:56:00.853 --> 01:56:05.058
QUESTIONS COMMENTS. SECOND TO
01:56:05.124 --> 01:56:06.993
HAVE A MOTION AND A SECOND
01:56:07.060 --> 01:56:08.394
THANK YOU ALRIGHT MS
01:56:08.461 --> 01:56:11.030
AGUIAR-CURRY MAY CLOSE- I JUST
01:56:11.097 --> 01:56:12.365
ASK FOR YOUR AYE VOTE THANK YOU
01:56:12.432 --> 01:56:13.633
VERY MUCH FOR YOUR TIME AND
01:56:13.700 --> 01:56:14.701
YOUR WORKING WITH US ON THIS.
01:56:14.767 --> 01:56:16.069
BILLTHANK YOU WE DO HAVE THE
01:56:16.135 --> 01:56:17.470
MOST IN A SECOND THAT MOTION IS
01:56:17.537 --> 01:56:19.906
DO PASCHAL ROLE PLEASE. STONE
01:56:19.972 --> 01:56:23.576
BY STONE HI GALLAGHER.
01:56:23.643 --> 01:56:28.281
GALLAGHER AYE CHAU. CHOW I. TO
01:56:28.348 --> 01:56:31.317
GONZALEZ. CONTROLS AYE HOLDEN
01:56:31.384 --> 01:56:36.322
KALRA OUR AYE KILEY KILEY AYE
01:56:36.389 --> 01:56:38.991
THANK YOU MAIENSCHEIN OBERNOLTE
01:56:39.058 --> 01:56:45.698
OBERNOLTE AYE RIAS. RIOS I.
01:56:45.765 --> 01:56:47.233
THAT HAS EIGHT VOTE EIGHT BOOKS
01:56:47.300 --> 01:56:49.168
OF BILLS THAT THANK YOU VERY
01:56:49.235 --> 01:56:50.970
MUCH CHAIRMAN MEMBERS. RIGHT
01:56:51.037 --> 01:56:53.139
THAT BRINGS US TO THE NUMBER
01:56:53.206 --> 01:56:54.807
EIGHT AB THIRTY TO FIFTY FORM
01:56:54.874 --> 01:56:58.911
IS THE MOST. OPERATOR PLEASE
01:56:58.978 --> 01:57:01.414
OPEN THE LINES FOR AB THIRTY TO
01:57:01.481 --> 01:57:03.883
FIFTY FOUR. WHEN THEY'RE OPEN
01:57:03.950 --> 01:57:09.255
THANK YOU. THANK YOU CHAIR AND
01:57:09.322 --> 01:57:13.092
MEMBERS AB THIRTY TO FIFTY FOUR
01:57:13.159 --> 01:57:13.559
SIX TO CLARIFY CURRENT
01:57:13.626 --> 01:57:15.762
CALIFORNIA LAW. WHEN A CONTRACT
01:57:15.828 --> 01:57:17.363
IS NEGOTIATED AND WON A FIVE
01:57:17.430 --> 01:57:19.232
LANGUAGE OTHER THAN ENGLISH A
01:57:19.298 --> 01:57:20.800
PHYSICAL CONTRACT MUST BE
01:57:20.867 --> 01:57:22.101
PROVIDED IN THAT LANGUAGE BUT
01:57:22.168 --> 01:57:23.803
THIS PROVISION DOES NOT APPLY
01:57:23.870 --> 01:57:25.872
TO MONOLINGUAL CLOSE SIGNERS
01:57:25.938 --> 01:57:27.073
THIS BILL WOULD ENSURE CO
01:57:27.140 --> 01:57:28.174
SIGNERS HAVE THE SAME
01:57:28.241 --> 01:57:29.876
PROTECTIONS. FOR EXAMPLE WHEN A
01:57:29.942 --> 01:57:31.344
SPANISH SPEAKING COSIGNER SIGNS
01:57:31.411 --> 01:57:34.380
IN ENGLISH CONTRACT THERE HELL
01:57:34.447 --> 01:57:34.947
TO THE TERMS OF THE ENGLISH
01:57:35.014 --> 01:57:35.982
CONTRACT WITHOUT THESE
01:57:36.048 --> 01:57:37.083
PROTECTIONS CO SIGNERS ARE
01:57:37.150 --> 01:57:38.985
EXTREMELY SUSCEPTIBLE TO FRAUD
01:57:39.051 --> 01:57:40.219
BECAUSE THEY MAY NOT UNDERSTAND
01:57:40.286 --> 01:57:41.587
THE TERMS OF THE CONTRACT AND
01:57:41.654 --> 01:57:43.389
ARE TAKING ON ALL THE RISK IN
01:57:43.456 --> 01:57:44.957
ALONE WITHOUT RECEIVING. ANY OF
01:57:45.024 --> 01:57:46.592
THE BENEFITS IF A CO SIGNER
01:57:46.659 --> 01:57:48.628
SPEAKS TO ONE OF FIVE LANGUAGES
01:57:48.694 --> 01:57:49.495
OTHER THAN ENGLISH THEY WOULD
01:57:49.562 --> 01:57:51.063
NEED TO RECEIVE AN IN LANGUAGE
01:57:51.130 --> 01:57:52.131
CONTRACT UNLESS THEY PROVIDE
01:57:52.198 --> 01:57:53.866
THEIR OWN TRANSLATOR LIKE A
01:57:53.933 --> 01:57:55.401
FAMILY MEMBER. DUE TO THE
01:57:55.468 --> 01:57:57.336
CENSUS NEARLY 45% OF CALIFORNIA
01:57:57.403 --> 01:57:59.138
HOUSEHOLDS. SPEAK A LANGUAGE
01:57:59.205 --> 01:58:01.073
OTHER THAN ENGLISH. THIS BILL
01:58:01.140 --> 01:58:01.908
IS ESPECIALLY IMPORTANT IN
01:58:01.974 --> 01:58:03.075
LIGHT OF THE I'M PRESIDENT.
01:58:03.142 --> 01:58:04.310
UNPRECEDENTED RISE IN
01:58:04.377 --> 01:58:05.044
UNEMPLOYMENT THROUGHOUT THE
01:58:05.111 --> 01:58:06.512
STATE AND COUNTRY. IT IS
01:58:06.579 --> 01:58:07.780
FORESEEABLE THAT MANY PEOPLE
01:58:07.847 --> 01:58:08.981
TURN TO PERSONAL LOANS AND
01:58:09.048 --> 01:58:10.483
CREDIT CARDS WHICH MAY REQUIRE
01:58:10.550 --> 01:58:12.418
CO SIGNERS TO ADDRESS THE
01:58:12.485 --> 01:58:13.419
RISING DEBT AND PAY FOR BASIC
01:58:13.486 --> 01:58:15.888
NEEDS- TODAY ON THE PHONE TO
01:58:15.955 --> 01:58:17.123
SUPPORT THIS BILL IS DANNY
01:58:17.190 --> 01:58:18.357
CONDO KAISER REPRESENTING THE
01:58:18.424 --> 01:58:20.326
CALIFORNIA LOW INCOME CONSUMER
01:58:20.393 --> 01:58:22.895
COALITION. AND DOES RAINY AND-
01:58:22.962 --> 01:58:26.132
FROM. THE JUSTICE AND DIVERSITY
01:58:26.199 --> 01:58:28.835
CENTER OF THE BAR ASSOCIATION
01:58:28.901 --> 01:58:30.670
OF SAN FRANCISCO. THANK YOU I
01:58:30.736 --> 01:58:32.538
DO HAVE TO SUPPORT WITNESSES
01:58:32.605 --> 01:58:34.507
THIS KIND OF KAISER AND MS
01:58:34.574 --> 01:58:36.242
MILLION NORTH. ARE YOU ON THE
01:58:36.309 --> 01:58:42.215
LINE PLEASE. YES YES OKAY- THIS
01:58:42.281 --> 01:58:46.319
KIND OF CLOSER THE- GOOD GOOD
01:58:46.385 --> 01:58:47.887
AFTERNOON CHAIR AND MEMBERS
01:58:47.954 --> 01:58:49.455
JENNY CANDOR CARTER ON BEHALF
01:58:49.522 --> 01:58:50.723
OF THE SPONSORS OF THE STILL
01:58:50.790 --> 01:58:51.757
THE CALIFORNIA LOW INCOME
01:58:51.824 --> 01:58:53.960
CONSUMER COALITION CLICK OF THE
01:58:54.026 --> 01:58:55.995
STATEWIDE COALITION OF FOURTEEN
01:58:56.062 --> 01:58:57.396
LEGALLY PROVIDERS THAT SIR
01:58:57.463 --> 01:58:58.965
STRIVE TO ENSURE THE ALL
01:58:59.031 --> 01:59:01.000
CONSUMERS IN CALIFORNIA HOW
01:59:01.067 --> 01:59:01.968
THEIR VOICES HEARD BY THE
01:59:02.034 --> 01:59:04.103
LEGISLATURE WE PART OF FAMILY
01:59:04.170 --> 01:59:07.373
MEMBER WOMEN'S AUTHORSHIP OF AB
01:59:07.440 --> 01:59:08.007
THIRTY TO FIFTY FOUR WHICH WILL
01:59:08.074 --> 01:59:10.309
PROVIDE SIGNIFICANT ANTI FRAUD
01:59:10.376 --> 01:59:11.410
CONSUMER PROTECTIONS BY
01:59:11.477 --> 01:59:12.812
REQUIRING THAT NON ENGLISH
01:59:12.879 --> 01:59:14.680
SPEAKING CO SIGNERS WHO DO NOT
01:59:14.747 --> 01:59:17.016
HAVE A DISINTEREST. INTERPRETER
01:59:17.083 --> 01:59:17.950
BE GIVEN A COPY OF THEIR
01:59:18.017 --> 01:59:20.720
CONTRACT IN THE LANGUAGE THEY
01:59:20.786 --> 01:59:21.787
SPEAK. CODE SIGNING OF OFTEN
01:59:21.854 --> 01:59:23.589
LOOK WHEN THE PRIMARY BORROWERS
01:59:23.656 --> 01:59:25.024
CREDIT IS POOR OR UNDER
01:59:25.091 --> 01:59:27.026
ESTABLISHED. THE BORROWER IS
01:59:27.093 --> 01:59:28.561
INCENTIVIZE YOU BRING ON A CO
01:59:28.628 --> 01:59:30.096
SIGNER IN ORDER TO OBTAIN WHAT
01:59:30.162 --> 01:59:32.031
HE NEEDS OR WANTS. THE VERY
01:59:32.098 --> 01:59:33.232
NATURE OF CODE FINDING IS A
01:59:33.299 --> 01:59:34.400
RELATIONSHIP WHERE IN THE
01:59:34.467 --> 01:59:36.836
COSIGNER HAVE BETTER CREDIT
01:59:36.903 --> 01:59:38.137
THAN THE BORROWER. A TAKE ON
01:59:38.204 --> 01:59:39.372
EQUAL RISK FOR ANOTHER THE
01:59:39.438 --> 01:59:40.373
BENEFITS AND THEY WILL SUFFER
01:59:40.439 --> 01:59:42.775
GREATER HARM TO THEIR CREDIT IN
01:59:42.842 --> 01:59:44.877
THE EVENT OF DEFAULT. DAMAGE TO
01:59:44.944 --> 01:59:45.778
ONE CREDIT MAY RESULT IN
01:59:45.845 --> 01:59:47.280
DIFFICULTY IN FINDING HOUSING
01:59:47.346 --> 01:59:48.414
AND SAFE NEIGHBORHOODS
01:59:48.481 --> 01:59:50.216
ATTAINING GOOD PAYING JOBS. AND
01:59:50.283 --> 01:59:51.918
HIGHER INTEREST RATE COMPUTER
01:59:51.984 --> 01:59:53.619
LUNCH OR FINANCING. THE
01:59:53.686 --> 01:59:54.687
COSIGNER MUST CARRY THE
01:59:54.754 --> 01:59:56.155
FINANCIAL BURDEN IF THE
01:59:56.222 --> 01:59:57.924
BORROWER DROPS OR SUFFERS THE
01:59:57.990 --> 01:59:59.392
CONSEQUENCES IF SHE CANNOT
01:59:59.458 --> 02:00:01.260
AFFORD IT. WITH MANY
02:00:01.327 --> 02:00:02.728
CALIFORNIANS LIVING PAYCHECK TO
02:00:02.795 --> 02:00:05.064
PAYCHECK THE LATTER SCENARIO IS
02:00:05.131 --> 02:00:06.866
OFTEN THE CASE. THIS BILL WOULD
02:00:06.933 --> 02:00:08.634
PROVIDE FOR A MUCH NEEDED YET
02:00:08.701 --> 02:00:10.703
MODEST EXPANSION OF EXISTING
02:00:10.770 --> 02:00:12.605
LAW CIVIL CODE SIXTEEN THIRTY
02:00:12.672 --> 02:00:14.373
TWO WHICH WAS ENACTED IN
02:00:14.440 --> 02:00:14.874
NINETEEN SEVENTY SIX TO
02:00:14.941 --> 02:00:16.008
INCREASE PROTECTIONS FOR NON
02:00:16.075 --> 02:00:18.077
ENGLISH SPEAKING CONSUMERS.
02:00:18.144 --> 02:00:19.712
UNDER AB THIRTY TO FIFTY FOUR
02:00:19.779 --> 02:00:21.080
AT THE COSIGNER SPEAKS ONE OF
02:00:21.147 --> 02:00:22.882
THE FIVE INDICATED LANGUAGES
02:00:22.949 --> 02:00:24.317
THEY WILL BE GIVEN A CONTRACT
02:00:24.383 --> 02:00:25.618
IN THAT LANGUAGE UNLESS THEY
02:00:25.685 --> 02:00:27.887
SUPPLY THEIR OWN DISINTERESTED
02:00:27.954 --> 02:00:29.822
INTERPRETER. LEAVE PROTECTIONS
02:00:29.889 --> 02:00:31.557
ARE INTEGRAL TO PROTECTING NON
02:00:31.624 --> 02:00:33.092
ENGLISH SPEAKERS FROM FRAUD
02:00:33.159 --> 02:00:34.827
MISREPRESENTATION AND LASTING
02:00:34.894 --> 02:00:36.596
HARM TO THEIR CREDIT. IN OUR
02:00:36.662 --> 02:00:38.631
NEW ECONOMIC CLIMB AND WE FOR
02:00:38.698 --> 02:00:39.899
SEE MORE PEOPLE TAKING UP
02:00:39.966 --> 02:00:41.233
PERSONAL LOANS AND LINES OF
02:00:41.300 --> 02:00:42.501
CREDIT. AND WE FEEL THAT THE
02:00:42.568 --> 02:00:43.936
PROTECTIONS INCLUDING IN THE
02:00:44.003 --> 02:00:45.838
INCLUDED IN THIS BILL ARE MORE
02:00:45.905 --> 02:00:47.340
IMPORTANT THAN EVER WE THANK
02:00:47.406 --> 02:00:49.976
YOU FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION. AND
02:00:50.042 --> 02:00:50.576
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR AYE
02:00:50.643 --> 02:00:52.345
THAT. THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS
02:00:52.411 --> 02:00:57.617
PLEASE. NUMBER THAT THE
02:00:57.683 --> 02:00:59.785
COMMITTEE MY NAME IS DESIREE
02:00:59.852 --> 02:01:00.920
ONE OF THE INTEGRITY CENTER OF
02:01:00.987 --> 02:01:02.421
THE PARTICIPATION OF CAMPING
02:01:02.488 --> 02:01:03.856
DISCOUNTS ARE THE PROVIDER
02:01:03.923 --> 02:01:05.057
DIRECTLY WILL SERVICE HELLO
02:01:05.124 --> 02:01:06.425
INCOMPLETE CAMERAS I'VE
02:01:06.492 --> 02:01:07.526
EXPERIENCED YOU MOMENT WORSE
02:01:07.593 --> 02:01:09.562
THAN TELLING A CLIENT I'M SORRY
02:01:09.629 --> 02:01:10.863
I CAN'T HELP YOU BECAUSE YOU
02:01:10.930 --> 02:01:12.231
CAN'T SPEAK ENGLISH BUT A LOT
02:01:12.298 --> 02:01:13.833
OF NOT YOU NEED FOR PROTECTION
02:01:13.899 --> 02:01:17.637
ALL RIGHT THE DOES. THAT
02:01:17.703 --> 02:01:18.371
SOMEONE WHO CAN. MY CLIENT
02:01:18.437 --> 02:01:20.172
LOCAL. AND ACTUALLY MODELING
02:01:20.239 --> 02:01:23.242
OKAY. OKAY LIKE. BUT THE CAR
02:01:23.309 --> 02:01:24.977
DEALERSHIP IN NOT HURT YOU NEED
02:01:25.044 --> 02:01:28.447
MY PAPER. THE EMPLOYER HIS WIFE
02:01:28.514 --> 02:01:29.382
AND DEALERSHIP REPRESENT A
02:01:29.448 --> 02:01:31.083
DISCUSS TURNED AND HIGHER LEE
02:01:31.150 --> 02:01:33.619
ENGLISH. WHAT YOU AFTER WHERE
02:01:33.686 --> 02:01:34.286
SHE WOULD HAVE TO PAY A THE
02:01:34.353 --> 02:01:37.223
CARD. THEY NO. AND IN ADDITION
02:01:37.289 --> 02:01:38.724
A HOLDER SIX MONTHS CONTRACT
02:01:38.791 --> 02:01:45.531
THE CONTRACT ENTIRELY TO THAT.
02:01:45.598 --> 02:01:47.533
WHERE THE LARGEST ETHNIC AND
02:01:47.600 --> 02:01:50.036
ALRIGHT. THE CLASS CLOUT CALL
02:01:50.102 --> 02:01:52.438
MEDICAL THIRTY. AND THAT WAS
02:01:52.505 --> 02:01:54.173
HOW SHE FIRST LEARNED THAT YOU
02:01:54.240 --> 02:02:01.681
THE TOP OF THE CAR. ONE ECOTEX
02:02:01.747 --> 02:02:02.815
ARE EQUALLY FINANCIALLY
02:02:02.882 --> 02:02:04.350
RESPONSIBLE FOR DEBT ON WHICH
02:02:04.417 --> 02:02:05.985
THEY CO SIGN. ALONG THE
02:02:06.052 --> 02:02:07.319
QUESTION WILL BE LEGALLY BOUND
02:02:07.386 --> 02:02:09.188
TO CONTRACT THE OPPORTUNITY
02:02:09.255 --> 02:02:10.856
OPPORTUNITY TO READ AND
02:02:10.923 --> 02:02:13.526
UNDERSTAND THE TERMS ASSEMBLY
02:02:13.592 --> 02:02:14.160
AND THE FACT THAT HE- THIS IS A
02:02:14.226 --> 02:02:15.428
BIPARTISAN ISSUE A BASIC
02:02:15.494 --> 02:02:17.630
CONTRACT REQUIREMENTS. IT IS IN
02:02:17.697 --> 02:02:18.364
THE BEST INTEREST OF BOTH
02:02:18.431 --> 02:02:20.032
CONSUMERS AND BUSINESSES THAT
02:02:20.099 --> 02:02:21.500
ALL PARTIES WILL BE RESPONSIBLE
02:02:21.567 --> 02:02:23.035
UNDER THE CONTACT. UNDERSTAND
02:02:23.102 --> 02:02:23.803
WHAT YOU'VE GIVEN THE
02:02:23.869 --> 02:02:26.005
OPPORTUNITY TO UNDERSTAND THE
02:02:26.072 --> 02:02:26.772
TERMS UNDER WHICH THEY WILL BE
02:02:26.839 --> 02:02:28.407
BALANCED. I JUST DON'T HAVE OT
02:02:28.474 --> 02:02:29.408
CHANGED THE CATEGORY THE
02:02:29.475 --> 02:02:31.010
BUSINESSES THAT ARE OBLIGATED
02:02:31.077 --> 02:02:32.645
TO FIND AND WHEN THAT CONTRACT
02:02:32.712 --> 02:02:33.679
THERE'S VERY LITTLE BURDEN FOR
02:02:33.746 --> 02:02:35.381
THE DEFENSE WOEFULLY MONOLOGUE
02:02:35.448 --> 02:02:36.882
BUT NOT AT THE GREAT BENEFIT OF
02:02:36.949 --> 02:02:37.950
UNDERSTANDING I LEGAL AND
02:02:38.017 --> 02:02:40.052
FINANCIAL OBLIGATIONS AS LONG.
02:02:40.119 --> 02:02:41.821
THE BENEFITS THAT ALL QUITE BUT
02:02:41.887 --> 02:02:44.156
I'M CONTACT ACTUALLY THANKED
02:02:44.223 --> 02:02:45.624
THE TURN. THANK YOU FOR YOUR
02:02:45.691 --> 02:02:49.929
CONSIDERATION. EXACTLY DRIED UP.
02:02:49.995 --> 02:02:52.198
THANK YOU. RIGHT IS THERE
02:02:52.264 --> 02:02:53.833
ANYONE IN THE HEARING ROOM
02:02:53.899 --> 02:02:54.967
WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT
02:02:55.034 --> 02:02:58.270
OF AB THIRTY TO FIFTY FOUR.
02:02:58.337 --> 02:02:59.638
SEEING NONE IS THERE ANYONE ON
02:02:59.705 --> 02:03:00.973
THE TELEPHONE WHO WOULD LIKE TO
02:03:01.040 --> 02:03:03.576
SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF AB THIRTY
02:03:03.642 --> 02:03:06.545
TO FIFTY FOUR. THE GENTLEMAN ON
02:03:06.612 --> 02:03:07.913
THE PHONE LINE TO SHOW SUPPORT
02:03:07.980 --> 02:03:10.015
OF AB THIRTY TO FIFTY FOUR
02:03:10.082 --> 02:03:11.650
PLEASE PRESS ONE THEN ZERO AT
02:03:11.717 --> 02:03:18.224
THIS TIME. AND LOCAL TO LINE
02:03:18.290 --> 02:03:19.959
NUMBER FORTY NINE NINE FORTY
02:03:20.025 --> 02:03:23.262
NINE YOUR LINE IS OPEN. SOME OF
02:03:23.329 --> 02:03:23.963
THE TERM MEMBERS CATALINA
02:03:24.029 --> 02:03:26.098
SANCHEZ THE CARBON IN KINDER ON
02:03:26.165 --> 02:03:27.266
BEHALF OF THE NATIONAL CONSUMER
02:03:27.333 --> 02:03:29.168
LAW CENTER IN SUPPORT. THANK
02:03:29.235 --> 02:03:35.508
YOU. THE BOTTOM LINE NUMBER
02:03:35.574 --> 02:03:38.344
FIFTY THREE YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
02:03:38.410 --> 02:03:39.578
CHAIRMAN DON AND NUMBER THE
02:03:39.645 --> 02:03:41.180
RETIRING UP THE PUBLIC
02:03:41.247 --> 02:03:43.015
LAWCENTER IN ORANGE COUNTY AND
02:03:43.082 --> 02:03:46.218
WE ARE IN STRONG SUPPORT AT
02:03:46.285 --> 02:03:46.786
EIGHTY THIRTY TO FIFTY FOUR.
02:03:46.852 --> 02:03:51.891
THANK YOU. TEXACO TO LINE
02:03:51.957 --> 02:03:52.491
NUMBER FIFTY FIVE YOUR LINE IS
02:03:52.558 --> 02:03:58.864
OPEN. THE FIVE YEAR LINE NUMBER
02:03:58.931 --> 02:04:03.335
TO OPEN. HELLO CHAIRMAN DOWN
02:04:03.402 --> 02:04:04.336
THE NUMBER MY NAME AT THE END
02:04:04.403 --> 02:04:06.071
OF THE CALDWELL AND I LOCAL
02:04:06.138 --> 02:04:12.211
ROUTE THAT THE TRIP. WE SEEM TO
02:04:12.278 --> 02:04:13.412
GET THE CAR THAT I MET BUT
02:04:13.479 --> 02:04:14.847
ROUTE THE VENTURE THE GAL WE'RE
02:04:14.914 --> 02:04:17.516
IN JUNK THE PORT EIGHTY THREE
02:04:17.583 --> 02:04:21.787
TWO FIVE FOUR. THANK YOU. THE
02:04:21.854 --> 02:04:24.890
REMINDER TO SHOW SUPPORT FOR
02:04:24.957 --> 02:04:25.524
THREE TO FIVE FOUR PLEASE PRESS
02:04:25.591 --> 02:04:29.662
ONE AND ZERO AT THIS TIME. WE
02:04:29.728 --> 02:04:31.230
HAVE NO ONE ELSE ONE SUPPORT.
02:04:31.297 --> 02:04:32.832
THANK YOU I DO NOT HAVE ANY
02:04:32.898 --> 02:04:34.900
LISTED OPPOSITION THIRTY ONE
02:04:34.967 --> 02:04:36.068
HERE IN THE HEARING ROOM WOULD
02:04:36.135 --> 02:04:38.170
LIKE TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION OF
02:04:38.237 --> 02:04:40.272
AB THIRTY TO FIFTY FOUR. SEEING
02:04:40.339 --> 02:04:41.574
NONE IS THERE ANYONE ON THE
02:04:41.640 --> 02:04:42.741
PHONE LINES WHO WOULD LIKE TO
02:04:42.808 --> 02:04:45.644
SPEAK. IN OPPOSITION TO AB
02:04:45.711 --> 02:04:48.047
THIRTY TO FIFTY FOUR. GENTLEMAN
02:04:48.113 --> 02:04:49.014
ON THE PHONE LINE TO SHOW
02:04:49.081 --> 02:04:51.283
OPPOSITION TO THIRTY TO FIFTY
02:04:51.350 --> 02:04:53.118
FOUR PLEASE PRESS ONE THEN ZERO
02:04:53.185 --> 02:04:59.859
AT THIS TIME. O ONE IN
02:04:59.925 --> 02:05:01.560
OPPOSITION SIR PLEASE CONTINUE
02:05:01.627 --> 02:05:02.394
ALRIGHT THANK YOU OPERATOR FOR
02:05:02.461 --> 02:05:04.096
YOU BACK TO THE COMMITTEE
02:05:04.163 --> 02:05:07.600
QUESTIONS COME AT. RIGHT SIGNAL
02:05:07.666 --> 02:05:09.068
IS THE MORNING MAY CLOSED I
02:05:09.134 --> 02:05:09.902
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AND I HAVE
02:05:09.969 --> 02:05:12.238
A- THANK YOU LOOKING FOR A
02:05:12.304 --> 02:05:14.406
MOTION ON AB THIRTY. THANK YOU
02:05:14.473 --> 02:05:18.644
pSECOND THAT MOTION IS TO PASS
02:05:18.711 --> 02:05:21.513
CALL THE ROLL PLEASE. STONE BY
02:05:21.580 --> 02:05:24.483
STONE AYE GALLAGHER GALLAGHER I
02:05:24.550 --> 02:05:29.555
CHAO SO ALL RIGHT TO GONZALEZ
02:05:29.622 --> 02:05:34.260
HI CONSOLES I HOLDEN KALRA.
02:05:34.326 --> 02:05:36.996
KALRA AYE KILEY KILEY AYE
02:05:37.062 --> 02:05:41.867
MAIENSCHEIN. OBERNOLTE.
02:05:41.934 --> 02:05:47.373
OBERNOLTE AYE RAY IS REYES AYE.
02:05:47.439 --> 02:05:49.241
THAT HAS EIGHT VOTE THANK YOU
02:05:49.308 --> 02:05:50.943
THE BILL IS OUT THANK YOU. IT
02:05:51.010 --> 02:05:54.146
WAS KILEY. THANKS AS TO ITEM
02:05:54.213 --> 02:05:57.483
NUMBER NINE AB THIRTY TWO
02:05:57.549 --> 02:05:58.083
SEVENTY ONE OPERATOR WOULD YOU
02:05:58.150 --> 02:06:00.719
PLEASE OPEN THE LINES FOR AB
02:06:00.786 --> 02:06:02.288
THIRTY TWO SEVENTY ONE.
02:06:02.354 --> 02:06:21.807
CAROLINE OPEN. MORNING ARE
02:06:21.874 --> 02:06:23.642
STILL MORE TIMES THE MORNING
02:06:23.709 --> 02:06:25.377
TOMORROW IF ALL RIGHT IS LEFT.
02:06:25.444 --> 02:06:27.313
AB THIRTY TWO SEVENTY ONE
02:06:27.379 --> 02:06:28.247
INSURERS THAT A VICTIM OF
02:06:28.314 --> 02:06:30.149
CHILDHOOD SEXUAL ASSAULT CAN
02:06:30.215 --> 02:06:31.350
PURSUE A CIVIL ACTION AGAINST
02:06:31.417 --> 02:06:33.118
THE PERPETRATOR AND OTHER
02:06:33.185 --> 02:06:35.054
RELEVANT PARTIES. THE BILL
02:06:35.120 --> 02:06:36.855
WOULD GIVE A MINOR THE ABILITY
02:06:36.922 --> 02:06:38.257
TO OPT OUT OR JUST A FORM OF
02:06:38.324 --> 02:06:39.558
THE PROVISION IN IN A ROMAN
02:06:39.625 --> 02:06:41.260
AGREEMENT FOR THEIR SCHOOL THE
02:06:41.327 --> 02:06:43.028
DENIES THEM ANY LEGAL RIGHT
02:06:43.095 --> 02:06:44.763
REMEDY FOR- PROCEEDING OR
02:06:44.830 --> 02:06:46.966
PROCEDURE FOR A SPECIFIC TYPE
02:06:47.032 --> 02:06:48.801
OF CLAIM ONE ARISING OUT OF A
02:06:48.867 --> 02:06:50.436
CRIMINAL SEXUAL ASSAULT OR
02:06:50.502 --> 02:06:53.205
BATTERY. IN OUR CIVIL JUSTICE
02:06:53.272 --> 02:06:55.407
SYSTEM. COURTS ARE THE DEFAULT
02:06:55.474 --> 02:06:57.076
FORUM FOR EDUCATING LEGAL
02:06:57.142 --> 02:07:00.045
CLAIMS. YET PARTIES CAN OFFICE
02:07:00.112 --> 02:07:01.280
TO CHANGE THAT TO FALL AND MANY
02:07:01.347 --> 02:07:03.082
DO. WHEN ENTERING A CONTRACTOR
02:07:03.148 --> 02:07:04.416
THE AGREED TO RESOLVE ANY
02:07:04.483 --> 02:07:06.151
DISPUTES THAT MAY ARISE IN THE
02:07:06.218 --> 02:07:07.186
COURSE OF THEIR CONTRACTUAL
02:07:07.252 --> 02:07:08.387
RELATIONSHIP. THROUGH AN
02:07:08.454 --> 02:07:10.022
ALTERNATIVE FORUM SUCH AS
02:07:10.089 --> 02:07:12.658
ARBITRATION. ARBITRATION OFFERS
02:07:12.725 --> 02:07:13.826
A NUMBER OF ADVANTAGES OVER
02:07:13.892 --> 02:07:15.661
LITIGATION INCLUDING COSTS
02:07:15.728 --> 02:07:18.030
SPEED ND PRIVACY. THAT'S WHY
02:07:18.097 --> 02:07:19.631
IT'S FAVORED UNDER BOTH FEDERAL
02:07:19.698 --> 02:07:21.567
AND STATE LAW. WE GENERALLY
02:07:21.633 --> 02:07:22.601
RESPECT THE RIGHT OF
02:07:22.668 --> 02:07:23.802
CONTRACTING PARTIES TO INCLUDE
02:07:23.869 --> 02:07:25.404
AN ARBITRATION CLAUSE IN THEIR
02:07:25.471 --> 02:07:27.306
AGREEMENT WHICH BINDS THEM TO A
02:07:27.373 --> 02:07:29.508
CHANGE IN THE DEFAULT FORUM FOR
02:07:29.575 --> 02:07:30.976
RESOLVING CLAIMS IN ADVANCE OF
02:07:31.043 --> 02:07:33.312
ANY DISPUTE. BUT THIS PRINCIPLE
02:07:33.379 --> 02:07:35.314
IS POORLY ADAPTED TO THE NARROW
02:07:35.381 --> 02:07:36.482
AND UNIQUE CIRCUMSTANCE
02:07:36.548 --> 02:07:38.617
PRESENTED HERE. WHERE THE AGENT
02:07:38.684 --> 02:07:40.152
OF AN EDUCATION ESTABLISHMENT
02:07:40.219 --> 02:07:41.720
HAS COMMITTED A HEINOUS ACT OF
02:07:41.787 --> 02:07:44.089
SEXUAL VIOLENCE AGAINST A MINOR
02:07:44.156 --> 02:07:46.725
ENTRUSTED TO ITS CARE. AS AN
02:07:46.792 --> 02:07:48.794
INITIAL MATTER SCHOOLING IS
02:07:48.861 --> 02:07:50.429
COMPULSORY FOR A MINOR THERE
02:07:50.496 --> 02:07:51.697
MAY BE A CHOICE OF WHICH SCHOOL
02:07:51.764 --> 02:07:52.698
TO ATTEND BUT THERE'S NO CHOICE
02:07:52.765 --> 02:07:53.766
WHETHER TO ATTEND SCHOOL ALL
02:07:53.832 --> 02:07:56.602
TOGETHER. SECOND IF THE SCHOOL
02:07:56.668 --> 02:07:58.370
SELECTED REQUIRES AN ORAL
02:07:58.437 --> 02:07:59.471
AGREEMENT THE MINOR DOES NOT
02:07:59.538 --> 02:08:00.672
SIGN ANY CONTRACT HIM OR
02:08:00.739 --> 02:08:02.608
HERSELF BUT IS BOUND BY THE
02:08:02.674 --> 02:08:04.676
SIGNATURE OF THE PARENT. THIRD
02:08:04.743 --> 02:08:06.211
A CRIMINAL SEXUAL ASSAULT IS
02:08:06.278 --> 02:08:07.880
NOT AMONG THE REASONABLY
02:08:07.946 --> 02:08:09.048
FORESEEABLE RISKS OF
02:08:09.114 --> 02:08:10.482
ENROLLMENT. TERMS AND
02:08:10.549 --> 02:08:12.251
CONDITIONS LIKE SCHOOL HOURS
02:08:12.317 --> 02:08:13.452
TUITION DRESS CODES GRADING
02:08:13.519 --> 02:08:14.920
STANDARDS REQUIREMENTS LIKE
02:08:14.987 --> 02:08:16.455
TUITION ATTENDANCE THESE OF THE
02:08:16.522 --> 02:08:18.357
SUBSTANCE OF THE AGREEMENT. THE
02:08:18.424 --> 02:08:20.259
ONE COULD REASONABLY ANTICIPATE
02:08:20.325 --> 02:08:22.261
AS THE BASIS FOR ANY DISPUTE.
02:08:22.327 --> 02:08:23.662
MIDDLE SEXUAL ASSAULT IS AN
02:08:23.729 --> 02:08:24.897
INJURY OF AN ALTOGETHER
02:08:24.963 --> 02:08:26.165
DIFFERENT KIND THAT WOULD NOT
02:08:26.231 --> 02:08:27.900
BE UNDERSTOOD AS SUBJECT TO
02:08:27.966 --> 02:08:29.234
ARBITRATION BY A REASONABLE
02:08:29.301 --> 02:08:31.270
PARENT MUCH LESS BY A MINOR
02:08:31.336 --> 02:08:32.838
STUDENT WHO LIKELY WAS NOT
02:08:32.905 --> 02:08:34.706
AWARE OF THE CAUSE OR THE
02:08:34.773 --> 02:08:36.708
CONCEPT OF ARBITRATION AT ALL.
02:08:36.775 --> 02:08:38.077
IT IS TRUE THAT THE FEDERAL
02:08:38.143 --> 02:08:39.745
ARBITRATION ACT HAS A BROADLY
02:08:39.812 --> 02:08:42.181
PREEMPTIVE THE FACT. ON STATE
02:08:42.247 --> 02:08:44.283
LAWS LIMITING ARBITRATION. BUT
02:08:44.349 --> 02:08:45.651
THE CIRCUMSTANCES UNDER WHICH A
02:08:45.717 --> 02:08:48.020
MINOR CAN DECIPHER MY CONTRACT
02:08:48.087 --> 02:08:49.488
THAT'S A DISTINCT QUESTION OF
02:08:49.555 --> 02:08:51.590
STATE LAW AND NOT GOVERNED BY
02:08:51.657 --> 02:08:53.859
THE FAA ITSELF. CALIFORNIA LAW
02:08:53.926 --> 02:08:55.427
IN FACT ALREADY ALLOWS JUST
02:08:55.494 --> 02:08:56.962
AFFIRMING CONTRACTS AND SEVERAL
02:08:57.029 --> 02:09:00.032
CONTACTS. WELL IT'S POSSIBLE
02:09:00.099 --> 02:09:01.400
THAT A COURT WOULDFIND NEVER
02:09:01.467 --> 02:09:05.170
THE LESS THAT AB EIGHT THREE
02:09:05.237 --> 02:09:05.737
TWO SEVEN ONE IMPERMISSIBLY
02:09:05.804 --> 02:09:06.939
FAVORS ARBITRATION THIS FAVORS
02:09:07.005 --> 02:09:08.740
ARBITRATION IN A WAYTHAT
02:09:08.807 --> 02:09:11.043
TRIGGERS FAA PREVENT PREEMPTION
02:09:11.110 --> 02:09:13.645
I AM. NOT AWARE OF ANY EXISTING
02:09:13.712 --> 02:09:15.080
PRECEDENT TO THAT EFFECT AND I
02:09:15.147 --> 02:09:16.548
BELIEVE THE ARGUMENT FOR A
02:09:16.615 --> 02:09:19.318
CONTRARY HOLDING IS COMPELLING
02:09:19.384 --> 02:09:21.520
GIVEN THE BILL'S NARROW SCOPE
02:09:21.587 --> 02:09:23.021
AND THE UNIQUE CIRCUMSTANCES IT
02:09:23.088 --> 02:09:25.023
ADDRESSES NAMELY- THE BILL
02:09:25.090 --> 02:09:27.259
CREATES A RIGHTS INTO JUST A
02:09:27.326 --> 02:09:29.394
FIRM. THAT IS NOT TARGETED AT
02:09:29.461 --> 02:09:32.531
ARBITRATION AS SUCH BUT IS
02:09:32.598 --> 02:09:34.166
LIMITED TO THAT PORTION OF AN
02:09:34.233 --> 02:09:37.169
ENROLLMENT AGREEMENT- WHERE
02:09:37.236 --> 02:09:39.238
JUST AFFIRMING- THE CONTRACT
02:09:39.304 --> 02:09:42.040
IS- WORKABLE AND REASONABLE IN
02:09:42.107 --> 02:09:44.042
OTHER WORDS- WE I WOULDN'T BE
02:09:44.109 --> 02:09:46.245
REASONABLE TO HAVE A STUDENT BE
02:09:46.311 --> 02:09:48.413
ABLE TO SIMPLY- DISA FIRM THEIR
02:09:48.480 --> 02:09:49.281
ENROLLMENT AGREEMENT AT ANY
02:09:49.348 --> 02:09:50.382
POINT BECAUSE THEY COULD JUST
02:09:50.449 --> 02:09:51.316
YOU COULD JUMP BUT DROPPED OUT
02:09:51.383 --> 02:09:53.051
OF SCHOOL WHATEVER THEY WANTED-
02:09:53.118 --> 02:09:55.721
BUT IN THE- I HIGHLY UNUSUAL
02:09:55.787 --> 02:09:58.157
AND HIGHLY. INJURIOUS
02:09:58.223 --> 02:10:00.259
CIRCUMSTANCES PRESENTED BY THIS
02:10:00.325 --> 02:10:02.928
BILL IT DOESN'T MAKE SENSE FOR
02:10:02.995 --> 02:10:05.430
THEM TO BE ABLE TO DECIPHER THE
02:10:05.497 --> 02:10:07.299
PART OF THE CONTRACT THAT IS
02:10:07.366 --> 02:10:08.934
DIRECTLY RELATED TO BE DRESSING
02:10:09.001 --> 02:10:11.870
THAT INJURY- SO- WITH THAT SAID
02:10:11.937 --> 02:10:14.006
I RESPECT RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
02:10:14.072 --> 02:10:17.876
AN AYE VOTE AND I HAVE TWO
02:10:17.943 --> 02:10:18.510
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT WHO ARE ON
02:10:18.577 --> 02:10:19.611
THE LINE. THANK YOU I DO HAVE
02:10:19.678 --> 02:10:21.146
TWO WITNESSES RICHARDS WORDS
02:10:21.213 --> 02:10:22.948
AND STEPHEN SCHWARTZ. ONLINE
02:10:23.015 --> 02:10:27.352
ARE YOU WITH US. YES MISTER
02:10:27.419 --> 02:10:28.687
CHAIRMAN THIS IS RICHARD
02:10:28.754 --> 02:10:34.760
SCHWARTZ. FOR I'M HERE- I
02:10:34.826 --> 02:10:36.828
REBEKAH SCHWARTZ SEEKING UP OR-
02:10:36.895 --> 02:10:39.998
EVEN SHORT OKAY- MISTER RICHARD
02:10:40.065 --> 02:10:42.801
SCHWARTZ FIRST PLEASE. THANK
02:10:42.868 --> 02:10:45.170
YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN AND MEMBERS
02:10:45.237 --> 02:10:45.971
THANK YOU ASSEMBLYMEMBERS KILEY
02:10:46.038 --> 02:10:47.472
IN PARTICULAR MY NAME IS
02:10:47.539 --> 02:10:48.907
RICHARD SCHWARTZ A PARTNER AT
02:10:48.974 --> 02:10:50.709
THE LAW FIRM BROWN GEORGE ROCK
02:10:50.776 --> 02:10:52.211
L. L. P. AND I HEARD YOU ALL
02:10:52.277 --> 02:10:54.413
CANNELLA AYE ON A. B. THIRTY
02:10:54.479 --> 02:10:57.049
TWO SEVENTY ONE. AB THIRTY TWO
02:10:57.115 --> 02:10:57.549
SEVENTY ONE WOULD ALLOW
02:10:57.616 --> 02:10:58.984
INDIVIDUALS WHO ARE THE VICTIMS
02:10:59.051 --> 02:11:00.852
AND CRIMINAL SEXUAL ASSAULT OR
02:11:00.919 --> 02:11:02.287
SEXUAL BATTERY IN A SCHOOL
02:11:02.354 --> 02:11:03.889
CONTACT EACH OTHER THROUGH THE
02:11:03.956 --> 02:11:05.824
COURT SYSTEM EVEN IF THE SCHOOL
02:11:05.891 --> 02:11:06.725
ENROLLMENT AGREEMENT WOULD
02:11:06.792 --> 02:11:08.360
OTHERWISE SEND THAT STUDENT
02:11:08.427 --> 02:11:09.895
ARBITRATION. RIGHT NOW
02:11:09.962 --> 02:11:11.496
CALIFORNIA LAW AUTHORIZES
02:11:11.563 --> 02:11:12.931
SCHOOL TOOK FOR STUDENTS AND
02:11:12.998 --> 02:11:16.802
PARENTS TO SIGN. NON NEGOTIABLE
02:11:16.868 --> 02:11:17.803
ENROLLMENT AGREEMENT. STOP AND
02:11:17.869 --> 02:11:19.104
HAVE. THAT AMONG OTHER THINGS
02:11:19.171 --> 02:11:21.673
ALLOW THOSE TO HIDE IT. BEHIND
02:11:21.740 --> 02:11:24.276
THE VEIL CONFIDENTIAL. EVEN
02:11:24.343 --> 02:11:25.944
WHEN A STUDENT HAS CLAIMS BASED
02:11:26.011 --> 02:11:27.546
ON PROVEN CRIMINAL SEXUAL
02:11:27.613 --> 02:11:29.781
MISCONDUCT. THE SECRECY THAT
02:11:29.848 --> 02:11:31.116
SCHOOLS CAN REQUIRE THROUGH
02:11:31.183 --> 02:11:32.351
FORCED ARBITRATION IS THAT
02:11:32.417 --> 02:11:33.719
SPECIALLY PROBLEMATIC FOR
02:11:33.785 --> 02:11:35.187
SCHOOL COMMUNITY. WHO
02:11:35.254 --> 02:11:36.588
DESPERATELY NEED INFORMATION
02:11:36.655 --> 02:11:38.056
ABOUT WHAT PROCEDURES THEIR
02:11:38.123 --> 02:11:39.725
SCHOOLS ARE TAKING FOR FAILING
02:11:39.791 --> 02:11:41.426
TO TAKE TO PREVENT CRIMINAL
02:11:41.493 --> 02:11:42.928
SEXUAL MISCONDUCT ON THEIR
02:11:42.995 --> 02:11:45.631
PREMISES. EVEN MORE PROBLEMATIC
02:11:45.697 --> 02:11:49.601
IS THE IMPACT OF ARBITRATION ON
02:11:49.668 --> 02:11:50.168
A VICTIM OF CRIMINAL SEXUAL
02:11:50.235 --> 02:11:50.969
ASSAULT. CALIFORNIA LAW MAKES
02:11:51.036 --> 02:11:52.704
IT CLEAR THAT AN ARBITRATOR CAN
02:11:52.771 --> 02:11:54.740
DECIDE A MATTER BEFORE THEM NOT
02:11:54.806 --> 02:11:56.341
ON THE BASIS OF THE RULE OF LAW
02:11:56.408 --> 02:11:58.010
OR THE RULES OF EVIDENCE.
02:11:58.076 --> 02:11:59.544
RATHER SOLELY ON AMBIGUOUS
02:11:59.611 --> 02:12:01.913
NOTIONS OF EQUITY AS PERCEIVED
02:12:01.980 --> 02:12:03.715
BY THAT ARBITRATOR OFTEN A
02:12:03.782 --> 02:12:05.284
SINGLE PERSON WITH HIS OR HER
02:12:05.350 --> 02:12:07.953
OWN BIASES AND PRECONCEPTIONS.
02:12:08.020 --> 02:12:09.187
THAT MEANS THAT AN ARBITRATOR
02:12:09.254 --> 02:12:10.756
CAN BLATANTLY IGNORE THE LAW
02:12:10.822 --> 02:12:12.257
AND PREVENT IT STUDENT WHO IS
02:12:12.324 --> 02:12:13.258
SEXUALLY ASSAULTED FROM
02:12:13.325 --> 02:12:14.926
OBTAINING THE JUSTICE THEY
02:12:14.993 --> 02:12:15.427
COULD OBTAIN THROUGH THE
02:12:15.494 --> 02:12:18.664
COURTS. AB THIRTY TWO SEVENTY
02:12:18.730 --> 02:12:19.665
ONE WOULD FIX THAT PROBLEM BY
02:12:19.731 --> 02:12:21.033
ALLOWING STUDENTS TO DEATH THE
02:12:21.099 --> 02:12:22.501
FIRM THOSE ENROLLMENT AGREEMENT
02:12:22.567 --> 02:12:23.769
AFTER BEING THE VICTIM OF A
02:12:23.835 --> 02:12:25.704
SEXUAL ASSAULT. I SHOULD
02:12:25.771 --> 02:12:28.106
EMPHASIZE THAT AB THIRTY TWO
02:12:28.173 --> 02:12:28.707
SEVENTY ONE HAS A VERY NARROW
02:12:28.774 --> 02:12:30.442
SCOPE AND PROVISIONS ARE ONLY
02:12:30.509 --> 02:12:31.376
TRIGGERED WHEN THERE IS
02:12:31.443 --> 02:12:33.078
CRIMINAL SEXUAL MISCONDUCT THAT
02:12:33.145 --> 02:12:35.614
FORM THE BASIS OF DISPUTED
02:12:35.681 --> 02:12:36.915
CLAIM. CALIFORNIA CONVICTED
02:12:36.982 --> 02:12:38.784
WILL ALL THAT ALLOW SCHOOLS TO
02:12:38.850 --> 02:12:39.751
ESCAPE THE COURT SYSTEM AND
02:12:39.818 --> 02:12:41.753
AVOID THE PUBLIC RECONCILIATION
02:12:41.820 --> 02:12:43.522
PROCESS THAT THESE COMMUNITIES
02:12:43.588 --> 02:12:45.624
NEED TO HEAL AND MOVE ON. THANK
02:12:45.691 --> 02:12:46.291
YOU FOR YOUR TIME AND
02:12:46.358 --> 02:12:47.726
CONSIDERATION AND THE IMPORTANT
02:12:47.793 --> 02:12:49.194
BILL WHICH WOULD GO A LONG WAY
02:12:49.261 --> 02:12:50.495
TO SECURING JUSTICE FOR THE
02:12:50.562 --> 02:12:51.697
VICTIMS OF CRIMINAL OF
02:12:51.763 --> 02:12:53.699
CHILDHOOD SEXUAL ASSAULT. I ASK
02:12:53.765 --> 02:12:56.268
YOU TO THE MEMBERS ABOUT AYE IN
02:12:56.335 --> 02:12:56.802
SUPPORT OF THIS IMPORTANT
02:12:56.868 --> 02:12:58.403
MEASURE. THANK YOU THE WITNESS
02:12:58.470 --> 02:13:03.041
PLEASE. THANK YOU FOR THE
02:13:03.108 --> 02:13:04.509
OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK BEFORE YOU
02:13:04.576 --> 02:13:06.378
TODAY FOR HEARING THE VICTIM'S
02:13:06.445 --> 02:13:07.379
PERSPECTIVE ON A SUBJECT
02:13:07.446 --> 02:13:09.614
IMPORTANT TO PUBLIC SAFETY IT
02:13:09.681 --> 02:13:11.450
IS AN HONOR BY COMING FORWARD
02:13:11.516 --> 02:13:12.617
WE CHOOSE TO STAND UP FOR THE
02:13:12.684 --> 02:13:14.419
SAFETY OF OUR COMMUNITY TO
02:13:14.486 --> 02:13:15.687
LOWER THE RISK OF CALIFORNIA'S
02:13:15.754 --> 02:13:18.056
CHILDREN BEING EXPOSED TO
02:13:18.123 --> 02:13:19.491
SEXUAL PREDATORS IN OUR SCHOOL.
02:13:19.558 --> 02:13:20.559
THIS IS NOT BEEN THE PATH OF
02:13:20.625 --> 02:13:22.294
LEAST RESISTANCE AMONG THE MANY
02:13:22.361 --> 02:13:23.695
UGLY TRUTH WE HAVE LEARNED ON
02:13:23.762 --> 02:13:25.997
THIS JOURNEY IS THAT MANY WOULD
02:13:26.064 --> 02:13:26.631
PREFER THIS ISSUE NEVER SEE THE
02:13:26.698 --> 02:13:29.234
LIGHT OF DAY. THERE ARE FEW
02:13:29.301 --> 02:13:29.801
THINGS WORSE THAN HARMING A
02:13:29.868 --> 02:13:32.204
CHILD. ONE MIGHT BE PREVENTING
02:13:32.270 --> 02:13:33.905
THAT SHOCKING SEEKING JUSTICE
02:13:33.972 --> 02:13:35.507
FOR THAT HARM IGNORING THAT IT
02:13:35.574 --> 02:13:38.043
EVER HAPPENED. FOUR YEARS AGO
02:13:38.110 --> 02:13:39.611
OUR CHILD WAS REPEATEDLY AND
02:13:39.678 --> 02:13:41.480
BRUTALLY RAPED BY A TEACHER AT
02:13:41.546 --> 02:13:43.615
REDWOOD SCHOOL IN LOS ANGELES
02:13:43.682 --> 02:13:44.983
NEARLY EVERY DAY FOR SEVERAL
02:13:45.050 --> 02:13:48.220
MONTHS BOTH ON AND OFF CAMPUS.
02:13:48.286 --> 02:13:50.088
RVTRADER REMOTELY CONVICTED AND
02:13:50.155 --> 02:13:52.190
SERVING TIME. OUR CHILD HAS
02:13:52.257 --> 02:13:53.392
BEEN PERMANENTLY CHANGED
02:13:53.458 --> 02:13:55.127
DAMAGED AND SCARRED BY THE
02:13:55.193 --> 02:13:56.495
THEORIES OF A FAULT. THE
02:13:56.561 --> 02:13:58.363
ANGUISH PAIN AND MISERY COUPLED
02:13:58.430 --> 02:14:00.332
WITH THE LOSS OF INNOCENCE HAVE
02:14:00.399 --> 02:14:01.032
BEEN AND CONTINUE TO BE
02:14:01.099 --> 02:14:03.402
CHALLENGING. HEIGHTENED BY THE
02:14:03.468 --> 02:14:05.570
FACT THAT OUR CHARLES NEVER GOT
02:14:05.637 --> 02:14:07.839
THE PROVERBIAL DAY IN COURT. A
02:14:07.906 --> 02:14:09.307
JURY TRIAL WOULD BE IN ONE WAY
02:14:09.374 --> 02:14:09.975
TO BRING ABOUT A FULL
02:14:10.041 --> 02:14:11.743
INVESTIGATION OF THE CRIME AND
02:14:11.810 --> 02:14:13.512
SCHOOLED POLICIES PROCEDURES
02:14:13.578 --> 02:14:14.813
GUIDELINES GOVERNANCE AND
02:14:14.880 --> 02:14:17.449
CULTURE WHICH MAY HAVE
02:14:17.516 --> 02:14:18.183
CONTRIBUTED TO THE CRIME.
02:14:18.250 --> 02:14:19.117
INSTEAD THE CIVIL JUSTICE
02:14:19.184 --> 02:14:20.419
SYSTEM DID NOT A TRIAL THE JURY
02:14:20.485 --> 02:14:22.087
TRIAL BECAUSE OF A MANDATORY
02:14:22.154 --> 02:14:23.789
CONFIDENTIAL ARBITRATION CLAUSE
02:14:23.855 --> 02:14:25.390
IN BRENTWOOD SCHOOL INVOLVEMENT
02:14:25.457 --> 02:14:27.359
IN GREEN MINT. ARE TWELVE NOT
02:14:27.426 --> 02:14:28.393
SIGNED AN AGREEMENT AND YET
02:14:28.460 --> 02:14:30.495
WHAT HELP TO IT. MY HUSBAND AND
02:14:30.562 --> 02:14:31.730
I FIND THAT AGREEMENT BELIEVING
02:14:31.797 --> 02:14:33.365
THAT MOST ARBITRATION WOULD
02:14:33.432 --> 02:14:34.833
COVER GRIEVANCES WE MIGHT HAVE
02:14:34.900 --> 02:14:36.368
WITH THE SCHOOL REGARDING OUR
02:14:36.435 --> 02:14:38.403
TRIAL EDUCATION. WE NEVER
02:14:38.470 --> 02:14:39.571
ENVISIONED IT WOULD COVER A
02:14:39.638 --> 02:14:40.972
FELONY CRIME AND WE CERTAINLY
02:14:41.039 --> 02:14:42.407
NEVER ENVISIONED THAT WE WERE
02:14:42.474 --> 02:14:43.475
SIGNING AWAY ARE TWELFTH RIGHT
02:14:43.542 --> 02:14:44.910
TO CHOOSE THEIR OWN PATH TO
02:14:44.976 --> 02:14:47.045
JUSTICE. NO PARENT DOES OR
02:14:47.112 --> 02:14:49.614
SHOULD. THE CONTENT THE PARENT
02:14:49.681 --> 02:14:50.916
TO FIND YOU THE PREMIUM IS THAT
02:14:50.982 --> 02:14:52.284
ARBITRATION IS INTENDED TO
02:14:52.350 --> 02:14:53.752
RESOLVE DISPUTES RELATED TO
02:14:53.819 --> 02:14:57.656
ATTENDING A SCHOOL LIKE THIS
02:14:57.722 --> 02:14:58.256
AGREEMENT ABOUT A GREAT ORANGE
02:14:58.323 --> 02:14:59.224
ON. ARBITRATION CERTAINLY HAS
02:14:59.291 --> 02:15:00.859
PLACE TO DOUBLE CHECK SYSTEM
02:15:00.926 --> 02:15:01.793
BUT WAIT FIFTEEN SHOULD HAVE
02:15:01.860 --> 02:15:03.428
THE RIGHT TO CHOOSE ARBITRATION
02:15:03.495 --> 02:15:05.230
OR COURT. APPLYING THE
02:15:05.297 --> 02:15:06.765
ARBITRATION QUALITY EDUCATORS
02:15:06.832 --> 02:15:08.333
SEXUAL ABUSE OF A CHILD AT THE
02:15:08.400 --> 02:15:09.701
POTENTIAL TO UNDERMINE ANY
02:15:09.768 --> 02:15:11.169
CHANCE OF TRUE TRANSPARENCY AND
02:15:11.236 --> 02:15:13.238
ACCOUNTABILITY. ARBITRATION
02:15:13.305 --> 02:15:14.840
THAT IMPORTANT CONFIDENTIAL AND
02:15:14.906 --> 02:15:16.675
REPORTEDLY LIMIT DISCOVERY IN
02:15:16.741 --> 02:15:18.944
DISCLOSURE IS NOT ONLY BAD FOR
02:15:19.010 --> 02:15:20.579
THE SEXUAL FALL VICTIM BUT ALSO
02:15:20.645 --> 02:15:22.681
FOR SOCIETY. IT INSULATES THE
02:15:22.747 --> 02:15:25.016
INVITATION FROM PUBLIC SCRUTINY
02:15:25.083 --> 02:15:26.251
LEADING SCHOOLS COMPELLED TO
02:15:26.318 --> 02:15:27.619
TRULY SELF REFLECTING MAKE THE
02:15:27.686 --> 02:15:32.190
NECESSARY REFORMS TO PREVENT.
02:15:32.257 --> 02:15:32.824
THE CRIMES THAT PROTECT YOU FOR
02:15:32.891 --> 02:15:33.625
VICTIMS. ALL OF THOSE WHO WORK
02:15:33.692 --> 02:15:35.327
A SCHOOL A SACRED AND WIDE
02:15:35.393 --> 02:15:37.062
LEGAL DUTY TO PROTECT OUR TO.
02:15:37.128 --> 02:15:38.363
WHEN CRIME TAKE PLACE IN THE
02:15:38.430 --> 02:15:39.898
SCHOOL CONTEXT EVERYONE AGREES
02:15:39.965 --> 02:15:41.299
THAT SOMETHING HAS GONE
02:15:41.366 --> 02:15:42.767
HORRIBLY WRONG. BUT SHOULD
02:15:42.834 --> 02:15:43.802
BILLS WON'T GO UNDER
02:15:43.869 --> 02:15:45.270
INVESTIGATIVE ACOSTA WHEN THE
02:15:45.337 --> 02:15:46.605
PARENTS AGREEING NOT TO SPEAK
02:15:46.671 --> 02:15:48.874
OF THE SCHOOL OF A GRADE OR
02:15:48.940 --> 02:15:50.242
PARKING. REGARDLESS OF THE
02:15:50.308 --> 02:15:52.277
AMERICAN ARBITRATION UNPLUGGING
02:15:52.344 --> 02:15:53.778
THE COURT SHOULD EXPECT TO GET
02:15:53.845 --> 02:15:55.180
FULL CHILDREN BE AUTOMATICALLY
02:15:55.247 --> 02:15:57.148
COVERED BEHIND THE CLOAK OF
02:15:57.215 --> 02:15:58.783
CONFIDENTIAL ARBITRATION. I'D
02:15:58.850 --> 02:16:00.285
LIKE MONTH IN THE STATE OF
02:16:00.352 --> 02:16:01.686
CALIFORNIA WE ARE BAFFLED AND
02:16:01.753 --> 02:16:03.588
BOTHERED THAT UNDER CURRENT LAW
02:16:03.655 --> 02:16:04.689
AN AGREEMENT SIGNED BY PARENTS
02:16:04.756 --> 02:16:05.957
WITH THE CONDITION TO ATTEND A
02:16:06.024 --> 02:16:07.459
SCHOOL IN CALIFORNIA PUT
02:16:07.526 --> 02:16:09.160
OPERATE THE HIGH TECHS FIND
02:16:09.227 --> 02:16:10.529
OTHER HIGH FELONIES BEHIND
02:16:10.595 --> 02:16:12.130
CONFIDENTIAL ARBITRATION WE
02:16:12.197 --> 02:16:13.698
IMPLORE YOU. TO CLOSE A
02:16:13.765 --> 02:16:17.135
LOOPHOLE BY PASSING AB THREE
02:16:17.202 --> 02:16:17.869
TWO SEVEN ONE INTO LAW. IN
02:16:17.936 --> 02:16:19.638
SCHOOL FROM FORTY WEIGHT BUT-
02:16:19.704 --> 02:16:21.640
ARBITER. BASED ON DECEPTIVE AND
02:16:21.706 --> 02:16:25.377
WARM AGREEMENT. HAVING EIGHTY
02:16:25.443 --> 02:16:25.911
THREE TWO SEVEN ONE OF THE
02:16:25.977 --> 02:16:26.811
BOOKS WILL GO A LONG WAY TOWARD
02:16:26.878 --> 02:16:28.013
HELPING OUR CHILD FEEL BY
02:16:28.079 --> 02:16:29.447
KNOWING OTHER CHILDREN WILL NOT
02:16:29.514 --> 02:16:30.582
BE IN A LONELY PAINFUL
02:16:30.649 --> 02:16:32.951
PREDICAMENT AGAIN THANK YOU
02:16:33.018 --> 02:16:34.019
VERY MUCH FOR LISTENING. THANK
02:16:34.085 --> 02:16:39.758
YOU. SO IS THERE ANYONE IN THE
02:16:39.824 --> 02:16:41.126
ROOM WHO WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN
02:16:41.192 --> 02:16:42.260
SUPPORT OF AB THIRTY TWO
02:16:42.327 --> 02:16:45.430
SEVENTY ONE. SEEING NONE- THERE
02:16:45.497 --> 02:16:46.831
ANYONE ON THE PHONE LINES WHO
02:16:46.898 --> 02:16:48.500
WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT
02:16:48.567 --> 02:16:51.803
OF AB THIRTY TWO SEVENTY ONE.
02:16:51.870 --> 02:16:52.671
LADIES AND GENTLEMAN ON THE
02:16:52.737 --> 02:16:54.139
PHONE LINE TO SHOW SUPPORT OF
02:16:54.205 --> 02:16:56.041
AB THIRTY TWO SEVENTY ONE
02:16:56.107 --> 02:16:57.509
PLEASE PRESS ONE THEN HERO AT
02:16:57.576 --> 02:17:07.052
THIS TIME. AND I SAW NO ONE IN
02:17:07.118 --> 02:17:10.155
SUPPORT. THANK YOU MOVED TO
02:17:10.221 --> 02:17:11.456
OPPOSITION I HAVE ONE
02:17:11.523 --> 02:17:13.291
OPPOSITION WITNESS LISTED ROB
02:17:13.358 --> 02:17:19.898
MUTRIE OUR ALLY. YES THANK YOU-
02:17:19.965 --> 02:17:23.468
GOOD- GOOD MORNING JUST FIVE
02:17:23.535 --> 02:17:26.538
MINUTES EVERYONE I'M ROBERT YOU
02:17:26.605 --> 02:17:27.439
COULD HELP CHAMBER WHERE
02:17:27.505 --> 02:17:29.341
BECAUSE THEY BE THIRTY TO
02:17:29.407 --> 02:17:31.876
THIRTY ONE- BUT FIRST. AND
02:17:31.943 --> 02:17:33.144
FOREMOST LET ME CLEAR OUR
02:17:33.211 --> 02:17:35.280
POSITION I HAVE NOTHING TO DO
02:17:35.347 --> 02:17:38.016
WITH- IS SEXUAL ASSAULT OR ANY
02:17:38.083 --> 02:17:40.151
LACK OF CONCERN OVER WHAT WAS
02:17:40.218 --> 02:17:41.086
JUST EXPRESSED THROUGH THE
02:17:41.152 --> 02:17:42.954
TERRIBLE ACT WE KNOW WE CAN
02:17:43.021 --> 02:17:44.055
DOWN SEXUAL WHILE THE MOST
02:17:44.122 --> 02:17:45.290
CERTAINLY CONDEMN IT HOPE.
02:17:45.357 --> 02:17:47.259
EVERYONE TO COMMIT SUCH ACT THE
02:17:47.325 --> 02:17:49.628
PROP YOU TO HOLD AND THE LAW-
02:17:49.694 --> 02:17:50.862
ALSO NOT OF ANY ISSUES REYES
02:17:50.929 --> 02:17:52.330
RIGHT DECEPTION THANK SCHOOL TO
02:17:52.397 --> 02:17:54.399
NEGOTIATE BILLION CONTRACT BUT
02:17:54.466 --> 02:17:56.601
THEY'RE SEPARATE ISSUES- OUR
02:17:56.668 --> 02:17:58.436
OUR ISSUE POLKA DOT THAT
02:17:58.503 --> 02:17:59.904
CORRECTLYNOTED THE ISSUE OF
02:17:59.971 --> 02:18:01.139
THE ARBITRATION AGREEMENT AND I
02:18:01.206 --> 02:18:02.440
APPRECIATE THE AUTHOR IS THAT
02:18:02.507 --> 02:18:03.775
HAVING MULTIPLE LINK P.
02:18:03.842 --> 02:18:04.676
DISCUSSIONS WITH US ON THIS
02:18:04.743 --> 02:18:07.312
POINT- I WOULD AGREE WITH THAT.
02:18:07.379 --> 02:18:11.483
AND BUT BECAUSE I THINK THATFOR THE THROWN OUT THAT AGREE
02:18:11.549 --> 02:18:13.018
WITH THAT THE MAJORITY AT THE
02:18:13.084 --> 02:18:15.620
K. POP CITED- AND STAFF POINT
02:18:15.687 --> 02:18:16.621
TO THE ISSUE AT ALL ON A LOT OF
02:18:16.688 --> 02:18:17.789
FOR YOU SIMPLY PUT OUR CONCERN
02:18:17.856 --> 02:18:20.358
IS THAT- THIS BILL IS TOTALLY
02:18:20.425 --> 02:18:22.260
PREEMPTED. SEVEN OKAY MATTER
02:18:22.327 --> 02:18:23.928
HAD THAT- I THINK THE LINE THAT
02:18:23.995 --> 02:18:26.564
THE THUMBS UP ARE CONCERNED-
02:18:26.631 --> 02:18:28.466
THREE COURTS TWENTY ELEVEN KT
02:18:28.533 --> 02:18:29.868
EIGHTY ANTI MOBILITY BECAUSE
02:18:29.934 --> 02:18:38.076
THAT THE ON. THE COURT SAID.
02:18:38.143 --> 02:18:39.711
QUOTE PERMIT. PERMIT THE
02:18:39.778 --> 02:18:40.311
GREENEST ARE. TO BE VALIDATED
02:18:40.378 --> 02:18:42.247
BY C<c.cyan>. GENERALLY APPLICABLE</c>
02:18:42.313 --> 02:18:43.748
CONTRA DEFENSIVE BUT JUST FOR.
02:18:43.815 --> 02:18:45.116
TO RESTAURANT BECAUSE- CLOSE
02:18:45.183 --> 02:18:46.751
QUOTE. BUT NOT BY THE THAT THE
02:18:46.818 --> 02:18:48.153
PLIGHT ONLY. ARBITER OR THE
02:18:48.219 --> 02:18:49.320
DRIVE THEY MEETING THE FACT
02:18:49.387 --> 02:18:50.555
THAT AGREE TO ARBITRATE IS THAT
02:18:50.622 --> 02:18:53.625
EACH. IT READ THIS BILL ALL THE
02:18:53.692 --> 02:18:56.394
FACT THERE THIS CREATE STABLE
02:18:56.461 --> 02:18:58.930
CONTRACTED. UP BY. ONLY TO OUR-
02:18:58.997 --> 02:19:00.999
FACULTY. EXIT THE GRIEVANCE
02:19:01.066 --> 02:19:06.638
ARCH. THAT THE HEART OF OUR
02:19:06.705 --> 02:19:08.006
CONCERNS THIS WILL DELETE IT
02:19:08.073 --> 02:19:08.740
PREEMPTIVELY BELIEVE IT WILL BE
02:19:08.807 --> 02:19:10.909
STRUCK DOWN COURT. AND VERIFY
02:19:10.975 --> 02:19:11.676
THAT THE WAY PUBLIC AND PRIVATE
02:19:11.743 --> 02:19:14.012
RESOURCE THEIR- WE THINK THIS
02:19:14.079 --> 02:19:15.413
IS THAT THE GRANDFATHER BILL ON
02:19:15.480 --> 02:19:17.615
THE POINT WITHOUT NOW THE- IT
02:19:17.682 --> 02:19:19.084
IN THE RIGHT ROLE OF CASE LAW
02:19:19.150 --> 02:19:21.853
WHICH SHOW THE- EIGHT. CULTURE
02:19:21.920 --> 02:19:22.987
HERE THE WAY OTHER POINT I WILL
02:19:23.054 --> 02:19:25.023
RAISE BRIEFLY THAT I THINK THE
02:19:25.090 --> 02:19:27.959
AUTHOR AND- AND SUPPORTING
02:19:28.026 --> 02:19:29.861
WITNESSES MENTION WITHIN NEXT
02:19:29.928 --> 02:19:31.396
YEAR. THAT POINT I'M NOT AWARE
02:19:31.463 --> 02:19:32.530
WE SPOKE TO THE AUTHOR AT
02:19:32.597 --> 02:19:34.399
LENGTH OF ANY JURISPRUDENCE
02:19:34.466 --> 02:19:37.001
FEDERALLY OR STATE WHICH-
02:19:37.068 --> 02:19:40.472
CHANGES- THE CREATION OF A OF
02:19:40.538 --> 02:19:41.840
AN ARBITRATION IF YOU'RE
02:19:41.906 --> 02:19:43.708
PICKING BILL. BASED ON WHETHER
02:19:43.775 --> 02:19:46.444
IT WAS INDEED. THAT JUST YOU
02:19:46.511 --> 02:19:48.513
KNOW HOW TO SPEAK LIMIT.
02:19:48.580 --> 02:19:50.148
OTHERWISE YOU HAVE A DEATH BY A
02:19:50.215 --> 02:19:51.883
THOUSAND CUTS METHOD AROUND THE
02:19:51.950 --> 02:19:55.186
FAM. SO WHAT WHAT TO TALK ABOUT
02:19:55.253 --> 02:19:57.489
THAT CASE LAW AT ANY BUT WE DID
02:19:57.555 --> 02:20:04.229
IT IS CLEARLY. PREEMPTED AND
02:20:04.295 --> 02:20:05.730
THANK YOU. THANK YOU SIR ANYONE
02:20:05.797 --> 02:20:06.331
IN THE HEARING ROOM WITH A TO
02:20:06.397 --> 02:20:08.099
SPEAK OPPOSITION OF THE THIRTY
02:20:08.166 --> 02:20:08.800
TWO SEVENTY ONE. SO NONE IS
02:20:08.867 --> 02:20:09.367
THERE ANY ESE ON THE PHONE
02:20:09.434 --> 02:20:10.568
LINES WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN
02:20:10.635 --> 02:20:14.139
OPPOSITION OF AB. THIRTY TWO
02:20:14.205 --> 02:20:14.706
SEVENTY ONE. ANYTHING GERAN
02:20:14.773 --> 02:20:16.107
METAL MIND TO SHOW OPPOSITION
02:20:16.174 --> 02:20:17.909
FOR AB THIRTY TWO SEVENTY ONE
02:20:17.976 --> 02:20:19.911
PLEASE PRESS ONE THEN ZERO AT
02:20:19.978 --> 02:20:29.220
THE TIME. AND I SHOW NO ONE
02:20:29.287 --> 02:20:30.955
SHOWING OPPOSITION. ALL RIGHT
02:20:31.022 --> 02:20:32.557
THANK YOU OPERATOR I'M GONNA
02:20:32.624 --> 02:20:33.591
BRING IT BACK TO THE COMMITTEE
02:20:33.658 --> 02:20:35.093
THIS COMES OUT. I'D LIKE TO
02:20:35.160 --> 02:20:36.461
MOVE THE BILL I WANT TO THANK
02:20:36.528 --> 02:20:39.597
YOU THIS IS A- WONDERFUL BILL I
02:20:39.664 --> 02:20:41.032
FEAR THAT THE OPPOSITION'S
02:20:41.099 --> 02:20:44.469
CRACKED- HAVING. DONE ARE.
02:20:44.536 --> 02:20:45.737
FORCED ARBITRATION BILLS THAT
02:20:45.804 --> 02:20:48.473
HAVE BEEN A NOT EVEN GIVEN A
02:20:48.540 --> 02:20:50.074
HEARING AND IN FEDERAL COURT
02:20:50.141 --> 02:20:52.777
BASICALLY WITH WITH BEING- AN
02:20:52.844 --> 02:20:53.745
INJUNCTION BUT I THINK IT'S A
02:20:53.812 --> 02:20:55.513
START AND I THINK EVERY TIME WE
02:20:55.580 --> 02:20:56.347
CAN PASS A BILL THAT MAKES
02:20:56.414 --> 02:20:58.983
SENSE- WE CAN TACKLE. THE USE
02:20:59.050 --> 02:21:00.518
OF FORCED ARBITRATION AND SOME
02:21:00.585 --> 02:21:01.352
I'M HAPPY THAT YOU'RE DOING
02:21:01.419 --> 02:21:04.389
THAT- AYE AYE IT AMAZES ME
02:21:04.455 --> 02:21:05.690
YOU'RE DOING THIS BILL GIVEN
02:21:05.757 --> 02:21:06.858
THAT YOU VOTED AGAINST MY
02:21:06.925 --> 02:21:08.827
CHILDHOOD SEXUAL ASSAULT BILL-
02:21:08.893 --> 02:21:10.962
LAST YEAR BUT YOU KNOW IT.
02:21:11.029 --> 02:21:14.465
RIGHT I EMBRACE THE CHANGE BOTH
02:21:14.532 --> 02:21:15.867
ON FORCED ARBITRATION AND ON
02:21:15.934 --> 02:21:18.303
CHILDHOOD- SEXUAL MISCONDUCT IN
02:21:18.369 --> 02:21:20.738
SCHOOL SO. I ABSOLUTELY- I'M
02:21:20.805 --> 02:21:21.739
GRATEFUL THAT YOU'RE BRINGING
02:21:21.806 --> 02:21:23.041
THIS BILL FORWARD AND I THANK
02:21:23.107 --> 02:21:23.842
YOU FOR LOOKING OUT FOR
02:21:23.908 --> 02:21:26.244
VICTIMS. THANK YOU THERE'S A
02:21:26.311 --> 02:21:27.645
MOST IS THEIR SECOND. AND THE
02:21:27.712 --> 02:21:29.581
SECOND THANK YOU. FOR THE
02:21:29.647 --> 02:21:32.250
COMMENTS WAS TOGETHER. YEAH
02:21:32.317 --> 02:21:33.218
THANK YOU FOR BRINGING THIS
02:21:33.284 --> 02:21:34.986
BILL IT AND THIS GOES TO- WE
02:21:35.053 --> 02:21:38.223
HAD A SIMILAR- BILL A COUPLE
02:21:38.289 --> 02:21:40.592
WEEKS AGO. DEALING WITH THIS
02:21:40.658 --> 02:21:42.594
ISSUE- BUT WE YOU KNOW WE PUT A
02:21:42.660 --> 02:21:44.729
LOT OF FOCUS ON. PRIVATE
02:21:44.796 --> 02:21:45.864
ENTITIES SOME PRIVATE
02:21:45.930 --> 02:21:48.800
INSTITUTIONS- YOU KNOW I CAN
02:21:48.867 --> 02:21:49.400
THINK OF IS THAT THE CATHOLIC
02:21:49.467 --> 02:21:51.469
CHURCH. ONE OF THEM AND THE
02:21:51.536 --> 02:21:53.805
THINGS THAT THEY HAD DONE TO.
02:21:53.872 --> 02:21:55.907
COVER UP TO MOVE PEOPLE AROUND-
02:21:55.974 --> 02:21:59.944
TO AVOID DISCOVERY OF THESE
02:22:00.011 --> 02:22:01.980
EGREGIOUS INJURIOUS SEXUAL
02:22:02.046 --> 02:22:04.382
ASSAULTS- THAT WORKER ON PEOPLE
02:22:04.449 --> 02:22:06.551
AND WHAT WE WILL WE HAVE NOT
02:22:06.618 --> 02:22:07.151
PUT ENOUGH FOCUSING ATTENTION
02:22:07.218 --> 02:22:10.054
ON. IS THE PUBLIC ENTITIES THAT
02:22:10.121 --> 02:22:12.290
HAVE DONE VERY SIMILAR THINGS
02:22:12.357 --> 02:22:14.225
AND THERE HAVE BEEN COUNTLESS.
02:22:14.292 --> 02:22:15.894
THERE HAVE BEEN COUNTLESS
02:22:15.960 --> 02:22:18.630
INCIDENTS OF TEACHERS WHO HAVE
02:22:18.696 --> 02:22:20.331
COMMITTED THESE TYPES OF ACTS
02:22:20.398 --> 02:22:21.499
AND THINGS HAVE NOT BEEN DONE
02:22:21.566 --> 02:22:22.667
THINGS HAVE BEEN COVERED UP
02:22:22.734 --> 02:22:26.504
THINGS HAVE BEEN- YOU KNOW NOT
02:22:26.571 --> 02:22:28.273
DONE PROPERLY- TO THE INSURED
02:22:28.339 --> 02:22:30.708
ESTES AN- AND A SAFE LEARNING
02:22:30.775 --> 02:22:32.810
ENVIRONMENT FOR STUDENTS. AND
02:22:32.877 --> 02:22:35.046
SO WE NEED TO HAVE WE CANNOT
02:22:35.113 --> 02:22:37.649
ALLOW SOMETHING TO BE PUT UP
02:22:37.715 --> 02:22:38.583
YOUR BECAUSE SOMETHING'S A
02:22:38.650 --> 02:22:41.419
PUBLIC ENTITY- A WALL TO BE PUT
02:22:41.486 --> 02:22:44.455
UP- TO JUSTICE AND SO I THINK
02:22:44.522 --> 02:22:45.723
THIS IS VERY MUCH IN LINE WITH
02:22:45.790 --> 02:22:48.126
THAT- SEVEN MEMBER WICKS IS
02:22:48.192 --> 02:22:49.694
BILL- THAT MOVED OUT OF THIS
02:22:49.761 --> 02:22:51.162
COMMITTEE TWO WEEKS TWO WEEKS
02:22:51.229 --> 02:22:54.365
AGO IS VERYMUCH AND- IN LINE
02:22:54.432 --> 02:22:56.868
WITH THAT DEALING WITH UCLA-
02:22:56.935 --> 02:22:58.703
SO. WE DO NEED TO REALLY START
02:22:58.770 --> 02:23:00.071
PUTTING THE FOCUS ON THAT THERE
02:23:00.138 --> 02:23:03.508
SHOULD BE IT SHOULD NOT MATTER
02:23:03.574 --> 02:23:04.075
WHETHER YOU ARE A PUBLIC OR
02:23:04.142 --> 02:23:06.511
PRIVATE AND IT IT YOU DID THESE
02:23:06.577 --> 02:23:07.312
KINDS OF. IS IF YOU ALLOW
02:23:07.378 --> 02:23:08.212
SOMETHING LIKE THIS TO HAPPEN
02:23:08.279 --> 02:23:09.681
WHERE YOU KNOW WITH THIS YOUNG.
02:23:09.747 --> 02:23:13.284
YOUNG MAN. THERE SHOULD NOT BE
02:23:13.351 --> 02:23:15.887
A PET IMMENSE- TO JUSTICE AND I
02:23:15.954 --> 02:23:16.487
AND I ALSO AGREE WITH THE WITH
02:23:16.554 --> 02:23:19.123
YOUR- VIEW POINT- MISTER KILEY
02:23:19.190 --> 02:23:22.393
THAT. THIS IS NOT A CONTRACTUAL
02:23:22.460 --> 02:23:24.595
SITUATION YOU KNOW SCHOOL IS
02:23:24.662 --> 02:23:27.332
COMPULSORY NOW THERE'S NOT
02:23:27.398 --> 02:23:27.899
THERE'S NOT REALLY A THIS IS
02:23:27.966 --> 02:23:29.968
NOT A- BE A WILLING VOLUNTARY
02:23:30.034 --> 02:23:31.202
TRANSACTION BETWEEN THE
02:23:31.269 --> 02:23:32.603
STUDENTS SCHOOL WE WANT ALL OF
02:23:32.670 --> 02:23:34.872
OUR KIDS IN SCHOOL. AND SO CAN
02:23:34.939 --> 02:23:36.307
WE REALLY ALLOW THESE AND
02:23:36.374 --> 02:23:38.943
ROAMING AGREEMENTS- THAT THE
02:23:39.010 --> 02:23:40.878
KID LIKELY NEVER EVEN SIGNED
02:23:40.945 --> 02:23:43.281
HIS PARENTS SIGNED- BE THE
02:23:43.348 --> 02:23:45.416
THING THAT KEEPS. JUSTICE FROM
02:23:45.483 --> 02:23:48.119
BEING PERFORMED OF COURSE NOT-
02:23:48.186 --> 02:23:49.887
AND SO THAT'S WHY I AM. I TO
02:23:49.954 --> 02:23:51.389
SUPPORT THIS BILL TODAY AND
02:23:51.456 --> 02:23:53.825
CONTINUE. ENSURING THAT THAT
02:23:53.891 --> 02:23:54.959
JUSTICE HAPPENS IN THE PUBLIC
02:23:55.026 --> 02:23:57.095
SECTOR- AS WELL AS IN THE
02:23:57.161 --> 02:23:58.696
PRIVATE SECTOR THANK YOU. THANK
02:23:58.763 --> 02:24:02.867
YOU ISRAEL. THANK YOU- I TO
02:24:02.934 --> 02:24:04.869
WANT TO THANK YOU FOR BRINGING
02:24:04.936 --> 02:24:07.005
THIS BILL. I THINK THIS BRINGS
02:24:07.071 --> 02:24:08.906
US A STEP CLOSER TO REALLY
02:24:08.973 --> 02:24:12.143
LOOKING OUT. FORCED ARBITRATION
02:24:12.210 --> 02:24:13.378
WE HAVE PEOPLE ENTERING INTO
02:24:13.444 --> 02:24:15.813
CONTRACTS- THAT SIGN AWAY
02:24:15.880 --> 02:24:17.782
RIGHTS BECAUSE THAT'S THE ONLY
02:24:17.849 --> 02:24:19.050
WAY THEY CAN GET INTO THIS
02:24:19.117 --> 02:24:21.986
PRIVATE SCHOOL OR GET THIS JOB.
02:24:22.053 --> 02:24:23.588
THIS IS THE FIRST STEP BUT I
02:24:23.654 --> 02:24:25.790
THINK THAT WE NEED TO LOOK AT
02:24:25.857 --> 02:24:27.725
IT AS MUCH GONZALEZ SAID THAT
02:24:27.792 --> 02:24:28.526
THIS IS A THIS IS SOMETHING
02:24:28.593 --> 02:24:31.229
BIGGER. I RECOGNIZE THAT HERE
02:24:31.295 --> 02:24:33.197
WE'RE TALKING ABOUT A MINOR. A
02:24:33.264 --> 02:24:34.799
MINOR AS WE ALL KNOW CANNOT
02:24:34.866 --> 02:24:36.934
ENTER INTO A CONTRACT. SO WE
02:24:37.001 --> 02:24:40.338
HAVE PERRANCE. SIGNING WARY A
02:24:40.405 --> 02:24:42.907
MINOR'S RIGHT. AND THEY SHOULD.
02:24:42.974 --> 02:24:44.342
THEY SHOULD NOT BE ALLOWED IN
02:24:44.409 --> 02:24:46.444
LOSS I DO APPRECIATE. THAT
02:24:46.511 --> 02:24:48.846
YOU'RE DOING THIS. I ALSO HAD
02:24:48.913 --> 02:24:51.716
THE BILL AS YOU MIGHT RECALL.
02:24:51.783 --> 02:24:53.885
OF FOR YOU R. C. U. S. C. HAD
02:24:53.951 --> 02:24:57.221
ALSO- THE THIRD THEIR DOCTOR
02:24:57.288 --> 02:25:01.192
HAD. MOLESTED HAS SO MANY
02:25:01.259 --> 02:25:02.126
FOURTEEN THOUSAND WOMEN THAT
02:25:02.193 --> 02:25:04.262
CAME THROUGH THE DOORS WE HAVE
02:25:04.328 --> 02:25:05.930
TO DO EVERYTHING THAT WE CAN TO
02:25:05.997 --> 02:25:08.032
PROTECT. THOSE VULNERABLE
02:25:08.099 --> 02:25:10.301
PEOPLE IN OUR COMMUNITY THE
02:25:10.368 --> 02:25:11.569
FACT THAT WE ARE TALKING ABOUT
02:25:11.636 --> 02:25:15.339
A MINOR IS MOST EGREGIOUS. SO I
02:25:15.406 --> 02:25:18.643
AM HAPPY TO SUPPORT THIS AND I
02:25:18.709 --> 02:25:19.210
DO THANK YOU FOR BRINGING IT
02:25:19.277 --> 02:25:21.946
FORWARD. THANK YOU FOR THE
02:25:22.013 --> 02:25:24.248
QUESTIONS COMMON. SIGNALS TO
02:25:24.315 --> 02:25:26.117
KILEY MAY CLOSE I THINK THE
02:25:26.184 --> 02:25:27.151
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE FOR
02:25:27.218 --> 02:25:28.820
YOUR CONSIDERATION AND I ASPEN
02:25:28.886 --> 02:25:30.455
OF IT. THANK YOU WE DO HAVE A
02:25:30.521 --> 02:25:32.190
MOTION AND A SECOND THE MOTION
02:25:32.256 --> 02:25:33.124
IS TO PASS CALL THE ROLL
02:25:33.191 --> 02:25:35.927
PLEASE. STONE BY STONE AYE
02:25:35.993 --> 02:25:39.097
GALLAGHER. GALLAGHER I'D SHOW
02:25:39.163 --> 02:25:44.202
SO I. TO GONZALEZ CONSOLES I
02:25:44.268 --> 02:25:47.472
HOLDEN. HOLDEN AYE KALRA. ALL
02:25:47.538 --> 02:25:50.241
RIGHT I KILEY HI KILEY AYE
02:25:50.308 --> 02:25:52.777
MAIENSCHEIN. OBERNOLTE
02:25:52.844 --> 02:25:55.513
OBERNOLTE AYE RIVAS I'M SERIOUS
02:25:55.580 --> 02:26:02.320
I. THAT HAS NINE VOTE HAS NINE
02:26:02.386 --> 02:26:04.755
VOTES THAT BILL IS OUT. THANK
02:26:04.822 --> 02:26:07.525
YOU ALL RIGHT WE WILL NOW DO.
02:26:07.592 --> 02:26:08.960
TWO BILLS WILL WILL MOVE TO
02:26:09.026 --> 02:26:10.862
ITEM NUMBER FIVE AB TWENTY FOUR
02:26:10.928 --> 02:26:11.629
SEVENTY ONE AND AFTER THAT
02:26:11.696 --> 02:26:14.532
WE'LL DO ITEM NUMBER TEN A. B.
02:26:14.599 --> 02:26:15.066
THIRTY THREE SIXTY SIX MR
02:26:15.133 --> 02:26:29.914
GALLAGHER. YEAH OKAY. I THINK
02:26:29.981 --> 02:26:33.284
YOU CAN DO IT FROM YOUR CHANNEL.
02:26:33.351 --> 02:26:46.764
THANK YOU. YEAH. YES MISTER
02:26:46.831 --> 02:26:48.666
CHAIRMAN- GO ARE YOU PROCEEDING
02:26:48.733 --> 02:26:50.101
ON THE MISTER MAIN CHAINS BILL
02:26:50.168 --> 02:26:52.837
YES YOU DID OKAY- LIKE TO MOVE
02:26:52.904 --> 02:26:55.973
FORWARD WITH AB TWENTY FOUR
02:26:56.040 --> 02:26:56.741
SEVENTY ONE OF THE BILL GO
02:26:56.807 --> 02:26:59.777
AHEAD PROCEED THANK YOU MEMBERS
02:26:59.844 --> 02:27:01.112
EXISTING LAW CALIFORNIA LAW
02:27:01.179 --> 02:27:02.680
PROVIDES CONSUMERS A THREE DAY
02:27:02.747 --> 02:27:03.848
RIGHT TO CANCEL CERTAIN
02:27:03.915 --> 02:27:05.583
CONTRACTS AFTER SIGNING AND
02:27:05.650 --> 02:27:06.817
THESE ARE CONTRACTS RECOGNIZES
02:27:06.884 --> 02:27:08.486
INVOLVING HIGH PRESSURE SALES
02:27:08.553 --> 02:27:09.687
TACTICS SUCH AS HOME
02:27:09.754 --> 02:27:11.222
SOLICITATION CONTRACTORS
02:27:11.289 --> 02:27:13.758
SEMINAR SALES CONTRACTS AND
02:27:13.824 --> 02:27:15.660
PASTE FINANCING AGREEMENTS HIGH
02:27:15.726 --> 02:27:17.328
PRESSURE SALES TACTICS CAN
02:27:17.395 --> 02:27:18.462
MISLEAD CONSUMERS WHO MAY NOT
02:27:18.529 --> 02:27:19.697
FULLY COMPREHEND THE DIFFERENCE
02:27:19.764 --> 02:27:20.932
BETWEEN FOR WILL PRESENT THE
02:27:20.998 --> 02:27:22.833
VERBAL PRESENTATION AN ACTUAL
02:27:22.900 --> 02:27:24.435
TERMS OF THE WRITTEN CONTRACT.
02:27:24.502 --> 02:27:25.803
SENIOR CITIZENS ARE OFTEN THE
02:27:25.870 --> 02:27:26.771
VICTIMS OF THESE HIGH PRESSURE
02:27:26.837 --> 02:27:28.005
SALES TACTICS PUTTING THEIR
02:27:28.072 --> 02:27:30.241
RETIREMENT SAVINGS AND ASSETS
02:27:30.308 --> 02:27:33.144
AT RISK WE HAVE OF MR
02:27:33.211 --> 02:27:36.047
MAIENSCHEIN. I AM PRESENTING AB
02:27:36.113 --> 02:27:36.647
TWENTY FOUR SEVENTY ONE WHICH
02:27:36.714 --> 02:27:37.281
PROVIDED DIGITAL PROTECTION TO
02:27:37.348 --> 02:27:39.517
SENIORS DEVICE THAT'S TRULY EXT
02:27:39.584 --> 02:27:41.085
TENDING THE RIGHT T CANCEL
02:27:41.152 --> 02:27:42.520
FROM THREE BUSINESS DAYS TO
02:27:42.587 --> 02:27:44.021
FIVE BUSINESS DAYS. FOR THESE
02:27:44.088 --> 02:27:46.157
TYPES OF CONTRACTS THERE ARE
02:27:46.224 --> 02:27:47.592
TWO WITNESSES SPEAKING IN
02:27:47.658 --> 02:27:49.860
SUPPORT COLLEEN WHO'S GOT. THE
02:27:49.927 --> 02:27:51.729
DEPUTY DA FROM SAN DIEGO COUNTY%
02:27:51.796 --> 02:27:53.497
AND LARRY MORSE THE LEGISLATIVE
02:27:53.564 --> 02:27:55.032
DIRECTOR OF THE CALIFORNIA
02:27:55.099 --> 02:27:56.467
DISTRICT ATTORNEYS ASSOCIATION
02:27:56.534 --> 02:27:57.501
AND WITH THAT I RESPECTFULLY
02:27:57.568 --> 02:28:00.338
ASK ON BEHALF OF MR BEACH I'D-
02:28:00.404 --> 02:28:02.974
FOR YOUR ITEMS. ALL RIGHT- WILL
02:28:03.040 --> 02:28:03.841
PROCEED WITH WITNESSES IN
02:28:03.908 --> 02:28:05.676
SUPPORT. TO WE HAVE A LOT OF
02:28:05.743 --> 02:28:11.816
SAN DIEGANS WITH US TODAY.
02:28:11.882 --> 02:28:13.884
CIGARETTE NOON VIDEO THE MOUSE
02:28:13.951 --> 02:28:20.992
TO WORK THANK YOU. ATTORNEY
02:28:21.058 --> 02:28:22.860
KHALID SHOW OF THE CONSUMER
02:28:22.927 --> 02:28:24.462
PROTECTION UNIT OF THE SAN
02:28:24.528 --> 02:28:26.464
DIEGO COUNTY THIS IS TURNING
02:28:26.530 --> 02:28:27.965
OFFICE REPRESENTING. ERNIE
02:28:28.032 --> 02:28:30.134
SUMMER STAFF IN SAN DIEGO
02:28:30.201 --> 02:28:31.402
DISTRICT ATTORNEY IS CO
02:28:31.469 --> 02:28:34.272
SPONSORING AB TWENTY FOUR
02:28:34.338 --> 02:28:34.839
SEVENTY ONE ALONG WITH THE
02:28:34.905 --> 02:28:36.741
CALIFORNIA DISTRICT ATTORNEYS
02:28:36.807 --> 02:28:40.444
ASSOCIATION. AB TWENTY FOUR
02:28:40.511 --> 02:28:40.811
SEVENTY ONE IS A
02:28:40.878 --> 02:28:42.213
STRAIGHTFORWARD PROPOSAL TO
02:28:42.280 --> 02:28:43.748
EXTEND THE RIGHT TO CANCEL FOR
02:28:43.814 --> 02:28:45.383
INDIVIDUALS SIXTY FIVE YEARS
02:28:45.449 --> 02:28:48.119
OLD AND OVER FROM THREE
02:28:48.185 --> 02:28:49.086
BUSINESS DAYS TO FIVE BUSINESS
02:28:49.153 --> 02:28:51.422
DAYS. THE NATIONAL TWO DAYS ARE
02:28:51.489 --> 02:28:53.658
DESIGNED TO PROACTIVELY PROTECT
02:28:53.724 --> 02:28:55.559
SENIOR FROM ENTERING INTO
02:28:55.626 --> 02:28:58.296
CONTRACTS WHICHUPON REFLECTION
02:28:58.362 --> 02:29:00.331
DO NOT SUIT THEIR NEEDS- WHICH
02:29:00.398 --> 02:29:03.100
HAVE BEEN MISREPRESENTED OR
02:29:03.167 --> 02:29:04.502
MISUNDERSTOOD. THE FIVE
02:29:04.568 --> 02:29:06.404
CATEGORIES OF CONTRACT
02:29:06.470 --> 02:29:08.172
INCUMBENTS BY THESE AMENDMENTS
02:29:08.239 --> 02:29:10.908
ARE COLD SO WHAT CONTRACT. HOME
02:29:10.975 --> 02:29:12.910
IMPROVEMENT CONTRACTOR PROPERTY
02:29:12.977 --> 02:29:15.579
AFFECT CLEAN ENERGY OR PACE
02:29:15.646 --> 02:29:17.248
ASSESSMENT CONTRACT. THERE IS A
02:29:17.315 --> 02:29:18.916
REPAIR CONTRACTS AND SEMINARS
02:29:18.983 --> 02:29:21.719
FAILED CONTRACT. AS NOTED IN
02:29:21.786 --> 02:29:24.322
THE PREAMBLE. CONTRACT ARE
02:29:24.388 --> 02:29:26.390
OFTEN ENTERED INTO AFTER HIGH
02:29:26.457 --> 02:29:28.392
PRESSURE SALES TACTICS AND
02:29:28.459 --> 02:29:30.661
OFTEN RESULT IN LARGE FINANCIAL
02:29:30.728 --> 02:29:34.932
OBLIGATIONS. ORACLE ENTERING
02:29:34.999 --> 02:29:35.466
INTO THESE CATEGORIES THE
02:29:35.533 --> 02:29:37.234
CONTRACT CAN BE AVOIDED OR
02:29:37.301 --> 02:29:38.903
MITIGATED THE SAFEGUARDS
02:29:38.969 --> 02:29:40.538
ALLOWING ADDITIONAL TIME TO
02:29:40.604 --> 02:29:42.606
CONSIDER THE BENEFIT OF THE
02:29:42.673 --> 02:29:44.141
CONTEMPLATED PURCHASE. COMPARE
02:29:44.208 --> 02:29:45.676
THE WRITTEN CONTRACT TERMS TO
02:29:45.743 --> 02:29:47.411
THE VERBAL PROMISES. AND
02:29:47.478 --> 02:29:49.313
CONSULT WITH FAMILY MEMBERS OR
02:29:49.380 --> 02:29:51.048
OTHER TRUSTED ADVISER BEFORE
02:29:51.115 --> 02:29:52.750
UNDERTAKING THE FINANCIAL
02:29:52.817 --> 02:29:56.454
OBLIGATIONS. HOME IMPROVEMENT
02:29:56.520 --> 02:29:58.089
AND PACE ASSESSMENT CONTRACT IN
02:29:58.155 --> 02:30:00.257
PARTICULAR INVOLVED THE LARGEST
02:30:00.324 --> 02:30:02.426
FINANCIAL ASSET MANY SENIOR
02:30:02.493 --> 02:30:05.529
CITIZENS HAVE THEIR HOME WHAT
02:30:05.596 --> 02:30:07.064
CAN BE PLACED AT RISK OR EVEN
02:30:07.131 --> 02:30:09.300
LAW TO FORECLOSURE AS A RESULT
02:30:09.367 --> 02:30:11.001
THE CONTRACT. WHICH ARE
02:30:11.068 --> 02:30:13.604
MISREPRESENTED OR MISS
02:30:13.671 --> 02:30:16.040
UNDERSTOOD. LAST YEAR OUR
02:30:16.107 --> 02:30:19.243
OFFICE AS A MEMBER OF A STATE
02:30:19.310 --> 02:30:20.745
WIDE PATH TOWARDS. ELEVATE
02:30:20.811 --> 02:30:22.680
AMERICA ONE OF CALIFORNIA'S
02:30:22.747 --> 02:30:25.349
LARGEST PASTED MINISTRY- UNFIR
02:30:25.416 --> 02:30:27.451
BUSINESS PRACTICES AND FALSE
02:30:27.518 --> 02:30:29.620
ADVERTISING. AS PART OF THE
02:30:29.687 --> 02:30:30.988
SETTLEMENT OF THAT CIVIL LAW
02:30:31.055 --> 02:30:33.057
ENFORCEMENT ACTION RENOVATE
02:30:33.124 --> 02:30:34.458
AMERICA AGREED TO CERTAIN
02:30:34.525 --> 02:30:36.494
JUMPED INFORMATION BUT WE
02:30:36.560 --> 02:30:38.529
DESIGNED TO PROTECT SENIOR
02:30:38.596 --> 02:30:40.264
INCLUDED EXTENDED RIGHT TO
02:30:40.331 --> 02:30:42.433
CANCEL FOR A NUMBER OF ENERGY
02:30:42.500 --> 02:30:43.367
EFFICIENT HOME IMPROVEMENT
02:30:43.434 --> 02:30:45.970
PROJECTS THE THREE TO FIVE
02:30:46.036 --> 02:30:49.407
BUSINESS DAYS. AB TWENTY FOUR
02:30:49.473 --> 02:30:50.741
SEVENTY ONE CODIFIED WHAT HAD
02:30:50.808 --> 02:30:51.675
BEEN NEGOTIATED IN THAT
02:30:51.742 --> 02:30:53.677
AGREEMENT TO PROTECT SENIORS
02:30:53.744 --> 02:30:55.346
WHO AGGRESSIVE SALES TACTICS.
02:30:55.413 --> 02:30:57.815
AND HARMONIZES THE FIVE DAY
02:30:57.882 --> 02:30:59.917
EXTENSION THIRTEEN YEARS ACROSS
02:30:59.984 --> 02:31:01.619
THE OTHER CATEGORIES. WE HAVE
02:31:01.685 --> 02:31:05.356
THE SAME UNDERLYING PRESSURES.
02:31:05.423 --> 02:31:07.491
WE ALSO ANTICIPATE THAT SENIORS
02:31:07.558 --> 02:31:08.659
WILL ENTER INTO MORE OF THE
02:31:08.726 --> 02:31:10.394
TYPE OF CONTRACT COVERED BY
02:31:10.461 --> 02:31:11.495
THESE AMENDMENTS IN THE COMING
02:31:11.562 --> 02:31:14.398
MONTHS AND YEARS. AS A RESULT
02:31:14.465 --> 02:31:16.233
OF THE COLD NINETEEN CRISIS. AS
02:31:16.300 --> 02:31:19.470
A SCIENTIST CLARIFYING EACH DAY.
02:31:19.537 --> 02:31:21.305
ARE MORE AT RISK THE NEGATIVE
02:31:21.372 --> 02:31:23.941
EFFECTS OF CONTRACTING KOBE
02:31:24.008 --> 02:31:26.444
NINETEEN. AS A RESULT WHETHER
02:31:26.510 --> 02:31:28.045
FROM GOVERNMENT HELP DIRECTED
02:31:28.112 --> 02:31:30.381
OR TO PERSONAL CHOICE WE
02:31:30.448 --> 02:31:32.049
ANTICIPATE SENIOR TO BE
02:31:32.116 --> 02:31:33.217
ENTERING INTO THE SORT OF
02:31:33.284 --> 02:31:35.219
CONTRACT COVERED. THEY MAY WISH
02:31:35.286 --> 02:31:36.620
TO UPGRADE OR RENOVATE THEIR
02:31:36.687 --> 02:31:39.023
HOME THEY MAY ALSO BE APPROACH
02:31:39.089 --> 02:31:41.091
TO HOLD SOLICITATION OR DURING
02:31:41.158 --> 02:31:43.093
SEMINAR FAILED ABOUT VARIOUS
02:31:43.160 --> 02:31:45.062
SERVICES THAT IS DESIGNED TO
02:31:45.129 --> 02:31:47.131
PERHAPS CLEAN SANITIZED AND
02:31:47.198 --> 02:31:48.899
PROTECT THEMSELVES AND THEIR
02:31:48.966 --> 02:31:52.203
LIVING SPACE. FROM THE VIRUS.
02:31:52.269 --> 02:31:53.270
WE HAVE ALL THE INFORMATION
02:31:53.337 --> 02:31:55.339
ABOUT KOBE NINETEEN AND THE
02:31:55.406 --> 02:31:56.707
NEED TO REVIEW CREDIBLE
02:31:56.774 --> 02:31:58.776
INFORMATION ABOUT WHAT SERVICE
02:31:58.843 --> 02:31:59.243
IS THE PRODUCT THEY'RE
02:31:59.310 --> 02:32:01.212
EFFICACIOUS. AND WHICH PROVIDER
02:32:01.278 --> 02:32:03.080
THE COMPANIES ARE REPUTABLE
02:32:03.147 --> 02:32:04.748
WILL REQUIRE ADDITIONAL TIME TO
02:32:04.815 --> 02:32:08.052
REVIEW WOULD DISCUSS. WITH
02:32:08.118 --> 02:32:09.053
TRUSTED BY THE FAMILY MEMBERS.
02:32:09.119 --> 02:32:09.987
I WILL REMAIN ON THE LINE IF
02:32:10.054 --> 02:32:11.789
YOU HAVE ANY FURTHER QUESTIONS
02:32:11.856 --> 02:32:13.357
AND RESPECTFULLY REQUEST AN AYE
02:32:13.424 --> 02:32:17.161
VOTE. ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU
02:32:17.228 --> 02:32:19.230
DEBBIE DISTRICT ATTORNEY HESKEY
02:32:19.296 --> 02:32:20.731
HAVE MISTER MOORE ST I WILL
02:32:20.798 --> 02:32:22.433
REMIND YOU WE HAVE A SUPPORT
02:32:22.500 --> 02:32:35.980
SUPPORT ON THIS- SO. PROCEED.
02:32:36.046 --> 02:32:36.580
OKAY DO WE HAVE MISTER MORRIS
02:32:36.647 --> 02:32:40.084
THEIR- I DO NOT SENATOR MARK ON
02:32:40.150 --> 02:32:42.086
THE PHONE LINE. ALL RIGHT DO
02:32:42.152 --> 02:32:44.755
ANYBODY ANY OTHER. THIS IS IN
02:32:44.822 --> 02:32:47.291
SUPPORT IN THE AUDIENCE. SEEN
02:32:47.358 --> 02:32:50.561
NONE- WILL- ANYONE ON THE PHONE
02:32:50.628 --> 02:32:54.999
LINES TWENTY TWO. GIVE SUPPORT.
02:32:55.065 --> 02:32:58.402
TO AB TWENTY FOUR SEVEN YOU.
02:32:58.469 --> 02:32:59.370
LADIES AND GENTLEMAN ON THE
02:32:59.436 --> 02:33:00.638
PHONE LINE TO SHOW SUPPORT OF
02:33:00.704 --> 02:33:02.573
AB TWENTY FOUR SEVENTY ONE
02:33:02.640 --> 02:33:04.074
PLEASE PRESS ONE THEN ZERO AT
02:33:04.141 --> 02:33:09.613
THIS TIME. LOCAL TO LINE NUMBER
02:33:09.680 --> 02:33:10.214
SIXTY THREE LINES SIXTY THREE
02:33:10.281 --> 02:33:12.349
YOUR LINE IS OPEN. GOOD
02:33:12.416 --> 02:33:14.151
AFTERNOON PERSONAL GET OFF ON
02:33:14.218 --> 02:33:15.352
BEHALF OF LOS ANGELES CITY
02:33:15.419 --> 02:33:17.221
ATTORNEY MIKE HERE IN SUPPORT
02:33:17.288 --> 02:33:21.625
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. AT THE
02:33:21.692 --> 02:33:23.627
BOTTOM LINE NUMBER FORTY NINE
02:33:23.694 --> 02:33:24.194
ONE FORTY NINE YOUR LINE IS
02:33:24.261 --> 02:33:27.398
OPEN. HELLO CATALINA SAYS
02:33:27.464 --> 02:33:28.966
ACCORDING HI THERE ON BEHALF OF
02:33:29.033 --> 02:33:30.401
THE CALIFORNIA LOW INCOME
02:33:30.467 --> 02:33:32.469
CONSUMER COALITION AND SUPPORT
02:33:32.536 --> 02:33:37.808
THANK YOU. BOTTOM LINE NUMBER
02:33:37.875 --> 02:33:38.409
SIXTY FIVE ONE SIXTY FIVE YOUR
02:33:38.475 --> 02:33:42.580
LINE IS OPEN. HI LARRY MORSE-
02:33:42.646 --> 02:33:43.914
ON BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
02:33:43.981 --> 02:33:45.583
DISTRICT ATTORNEYS ASSOCIATION
02:33:45.649 --> 02:33:47.651
WE'RE PROUD TO BE A CO SPONSOR
02:33:47.718 --> 02:33:48.953
OF THE SUPPORT CONSUMER
02:33:49.019 --> 02:33:50.588
LEGISLATION WE ARE JULY BOAT
02:33:50.654 --> 02:33:52.556
THANK YOU. THANK YOU MISTER
02:33:52.623 --> 02:33:57.695
MARS. NEXT PHOTO MY NUMBER
02:33:57.761 --> 02:34:00.564
SIXTY SIX IN YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
02:34:00.631 --> 02:34:01.966
BACK IN MARKET ON BEHALF OF THE
02:34:02.032 --> 02:34:03.567
CENTER FOR PUBLIC INTEREST LAW
02:34:03.634 --> 02:34:07.938
IN SUPPORT. AND LOCAL TO MY
02:34:08.005 --> 02:34:09.440
NUMBER THIRTY TO ONE THIRTY TO
02:34:09.506 --> 02:34:12.142
YOUR LINE IS OPEN. ANNA BACK ON
02:34:12.209 --> 02:34:13.711
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
02:34:13.777 --> 02:34:14.244
ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS IN
02:34:14.311 --> 02:34:18.616
SUPPORT. AND AS A REMINDER TO
02:34:18.682 --> 02:34:22.019
SHOW SUPPORT TO AB TWENTY FOUR
02:34:22.086 --> 02:34:22.586
SEVENTY ONE PLEASE PRESS ONE
02:34:22.653 --> 02:34:27.424
AND ZERO AT THIS TIME. I SURE
02:34:27.491 --> 02:34:33.497
NO ONE ELSE PART. OKAY ANY
02:34:33.564 --> 02:34:37.167
OPPOSITION. I DON'T HAVE ANY
02:34:37.234 --> 02:34:38.936
WITNESSES ARE THERE ANY
02:34:39.003 --> 02:34:43.607
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION. SCENE
02:34:43.674 --> 02:34:47.177
NINE- ANY OPPOSITION. IN THE
02:34:47.244 --> 02:34:50.147
AUDIENCE SCENE NINE ANY
02:34:50.214 --> 02:34:53.651
OPPOSITION ON THE PHONE LINES.
02:34:53.717 --> 02:34:54.852
TO SHOW OPPOSITION ON THE OVER
02:34:54.918 --> 02:34:57.454
THE PHONE LINE FOR BILL AB
02:34:57.521 --> 02:34:58.689
TWENTY FOUR SEVENTY ONE PLEASE
02:34:58.756 --> 02:35:07.498
PRESS ONE ZERO AT THIS TIME.
02:35:07.564 --> 02:35:08.032
THANK CHAU NO ONE SHOWING
02:35:08.098 --> 02:35:11.035
OPPOSITION. OKAY WITHOUT BRING
02:35:11.101 --> 02:35:12.302
IT BACK TO THE COMMITTEE WAS
02:35:12.369 --> 02:35:13.871
MISTER MAIN SHINES NON
02:35:13.937 --> 02:35:15.839
CONTROVERSIAL BILL. WHAT'S YOUR
02:35:15.906 --> 02:35:17.908
PLEASURE. AT THE GARY HEARD OF
02:35:17.975 --> 02:35:20.310
FOR THE- MOTION AND THE SECOND
02:35:20.377 --> 02:35:22.479
IS THAT CORRECT THE- OKAY IS
02:35:22.546 --> 02:35:24.148
THERE A MOTION. MOVED BY MISS
02:35:24.214 --> 02:35:29.787
REYES SECOND ABOUT MR HOLDEN.
02:35:29.853 --> 02:35:31.321
THAT ROLL ROLL CALL THE PLEASE
02:35:31.388 --> 02:35:33.991
CALL THE ROLL. AND FOR CLEARLY
02:35:34.058 --> 02:35:37.394
THE MOTION IS TO PASS. STONE
02:35:37.461 --> 02:35:40.130
AYE STONE AYE GALLAGHER HI
02:35:40.197 --> 02:35:43.667
FELDER I JOE SO I CHIU.
02:35:43.734 --> 02:35:48.305
GONZALEZ CONSOLES I HOLDEN.
02:35:48.372 --> 02:35:50.974
HOLDEN AYE KALRA KALRA AYE
02:35:51.041 --> 02:35:55.813
KILEY KILEY AYE MAIENSCHEIN.
02:35:55.879 --> 02:35:58.982
OBERNOLTE OBERNOLTE I REYES
02:35:59.049 --> 02:36:07.224
REZAI. THE BILL HAS NINE VOTES
02:36:07.291 --> 02:36:10.627
NUMBER SEVEN BILLS OUT. AND
02:36:10.694 --> 02:36:11.929
MISTER CHAIRMAN WOULD YOU LIKE
02:36:11.995 --> 02:36:14.031
TO PROCEED WITH YOUR NEXT BILL
02:36:14.098 --> 02:36:17.468
THANK YOU AB THIRTY THREE SIXTY
02:36:17.534 --> 02:36:18.102
SIX DEALS WITH JUDICIAL
02:36:18.168 --> 02:36:20.571
EMERGENCIES IN CALIFORNIA UNDER
02:36:20.637 --> 02:36:22.506
CURRENT LAW THE CHIEF JUSTICE
02:36:22.573 --> 02:36:23.807
MAY ISSUE ORDERS TO MODIFY
02:36:23.874 --> 02:36:25.509
COURT RULES AND PROCEDURES
02:36:25.576 --> 02:36:27.444
DURING A DECLARED EMERGENCY.
02:36:27.511 --> 02:36:29.213
BUT UNDER GOVERNMENT CODE
02:36:29.279 --> 02:36:31.448
SECTION SIXTY EIGHT ONE ONE
02:36:31.515 --> 02:36:32.015
FIVE IT ONLY ALLOWS CHIEF
02:36:32.082 --> 02:36:33.217
JUSTICE TO ISSUE ORDERS
02:36:33.283 --> 02:36:34.885
AFFECTING A SINGLE COUNTY UPON
02:36:34.952 --> 02:36:36.086
THE REQUEST OF THE PRESIDING
02:36:36.153 --> 02:36:37.921
JUDGE OF THE SUPERIOR COURT FOR
02:36:37.988 --> 02:36:40.724
THAT COUNTY AND AS WE SAW WITH
02:36:40.791 --> 02:36:42.426
THE STATE WIDE EPIDEMIC OR-
02:36:42.493 --> 02:36:43.393
THAT WITH THIS STATEWIDE
02:36:43.460 --> 02:36:44.795
EPIDEMIC WERE WITH A DISASTER
02:36:44.862 --> 02:36:46.764
THAT COVERS MULTIPLE COUNTIES
02:36:46.830 --> 02:36:48.565
THAT LAW IS ENOUGH REALLY
02:36:48.632 --> 02:36:50.534
WORKABLE AND IN FACT FOR THEIR
02:36:50.601 --> 02:36:52.936
CURRENT PANDEMIC. THE GOVERNOR
02:36:53.003 --> 02:36:55.973
HAD TO ISSUE AN EXECUTIVE ORDER
02:36:56.039 --> 02:36:57.207
IN ORDER TO GIVE THESE.
02:36:57.274 --> 02:36:59.009
ABILITIES TO THE CHIEF JUSTIC
02:36:59.076 --> 02:37:01.912
THIS BILL MERELY PROVIDES FOR A
02:37:01.979 --> 02:37:03.313
STATEWIDE WHERE YOU MULTI
02:37:03.380 --> 02:37:05.516
COUNTY ABILITY FOR THE CHIEF
02:37:05.582 --> 02:37:08.519
JUSTICE. TO BE ABLE TO DO.
02:37:08.585 --> 02:37:10.120
MODIFY PROCEDURES IN ORDER TO
02:37:10.187 --> 02:37:11.622
ENSURE THAT JUSTICE HAPPENS
02:37:11.688 --> 02:37:14.124
THROUGHOUT ALL OF OUR COURTS
02:37:14.191 --> 02:37:14.691
THIS IS A SIMPLE BUT PRETTY
02:37:14.758 --> 02:37:17.294
IMPORTANT MEASURE. AND YOU'LL
02:37:17.361 --> 02:37:18.629
NOTICE THIS THIS BILL WITH HAD
02:37:18.695 --> 02:37:21.431
WAS HAS BEEN HEAVILY AMENDED SO
02:37:21.498 --> 02:37:22.533
THE BECAUSE WE HAVE BEEN
02:37:22.599 --> 02:37:24.434
WORKING WITH BOTH SIDES AND IN
02:37:24.501 --> 02:37:25.936
SUPPORT WE HAVE WITNESSES FROM
02:37:26.003 --> 02:37:27.437
BOTH THE CONSUMER TOURNEY'S AND
02:37:27.504 --> 02:37:29.406
THE CALIFORNIA DEFENSE COUNSEL.
02:37:29.473 --> 02:37:31.975
AND BOTH OF THEM BEING ON THIS
02:37:32.042 --> 02:37:33.577
BILL SHOWS THE AMOUNT OF
02:37:33.644 --> 02:37:35.045
AMENDMENTS WE'VE TAKEN TRYING
02:37:35.112 --> 02:37:36.013
TO MAKE SURE THAT WE'RE GIVING
02:37:36.079 --> 02:37:38.115
APPROPRIATE LEVELS. OF
02:37:38.182 --> 02:37:39.950
AUTHORITY TO THE CHIEF JUSTICE
02:37:40.017 --> 02:37:42.219
IN SITUATIONS LIKE THESE SO
02:37:42.286 --> 02:37:43.654
THAT JUSTICE CAN HAPPEN AND
02:37:43.720 --> 02:37:45.823
WITH THAT REYES RESPECTFULLY
02:37:45.889 --> 02:37:48.225
ASK YOUR I'VE LIVED. MOVE THEM
02:37:48.292 --> 02:37:49.626
AS REYES SECONDED BY MISS
02:37:49.693 --> 02:37:52.563
GONZALEZ- ANY WITNESSES IN
02:37:52.629 --> 02:37:53.831
SUPPORT I HAVE TO ON FILE HERE
02:37:53.897 --> 02:38:00.971
MIKE HELLO. AND NANCY DRABBLE.
02:38:01.038 --> 02:38:02.539
YES MISTER CHAIR THIS IS NANCY
02:38:02.606 --> 02:38:04.241
TRAVEL WITH CONSUMER ATTORNEYS
02:38:04.308 --> 02:38:07.878
OF CALIFORNIA WE ARE VERY HAPPY
02:38:07.945 --> 02:38:09.246
TO SUPPORT THIS BILL IT IS
02:38:09.313 --> 02:38:12.182
ABSOLUTELY ESSENTIAL AS MR
02:38:12.249 --> 02:38:14.751
STONE MENTIONED WE THOUGHT HOW.
02:38:14.818 --> 02:38:16.587
UNFORTUNATELY DYSFUNCTIONAL THE
02:38:16.653 --> 02:38:18.989
CURRENT STATUTE IS BECAUSE IT
02:38:19.056 --> 02:38:20.891
REALLY DID NOT ANTICIPATE A
02:38:20.958 --> 02:38:24.228
PANDEMIC- AND FOR THE THOSE OF
02:38:24.294 --> 02:38:25.829
OUR MEMBERS AND ALSO FOR
02:38:25.896 --> 02:38:27.631
DEFENSE COUNSEL DEALING WITH
02:38:27.698 --> 02:38:30.467
CIVIL CASES WE SAW THAT THE
02:38:30.534 --> 02:38:32.636
CHIEF JUSTICE DID NOT HAVE.
02:38:32.703 --> 02:38:34.771
ADEQUATE AUTHORITY AND WOULD
02:38:34.838 --> 02:38:36.240
THAT FORCE TO WAIT FOR VARIOUS
02:38:36.306 --> 02:38:39.409
REQUEST AN INDIVIDUAL COURT IN
02:38:39.476 --> 02:38:42.079
FACT I BELIEVE SHE RESPONDED.
02:38:42.145 --> 02:38:44.147
TO OVER A HUNDRED REQUIRED HIM
02:38:44.214 --> 02:38:48.018
INDIVIDUAL COURT AND THEN- SHE
02:38:48.085 --> 02:38:50.320
HAD TO WAIT FOR AN EXECUTIVE
02:38:50.387 --> 02:38:51.955
ORDER AUTHORITY FROM THE
02:38:52.022 --> 02:38:54.691
GOVERNOR- THAT MEANT THAT THE
02:38:54.758 --> 02:38:58.528
COURT LOST SOME TIME. THE FIRST
02:38:58.595 --> 02:38:59.763
THE CASES AND IS A RESULT OF
02:38:59.830 --> 02:39:01.598
THIS OF CLEAR AUTHORITY FOR A
02:39:01.665 --> 02:39:04.701
PANDEMIC SOME OF THE BACKLOG-
02:39:04.768 --> 02:39:06.870
THAT WE ARE NOW FACING FOR
02:39:06.937 --> 02:39:09.139
ACCESS TO JOB TO HAVE INCREASED
02:39:09.206 --> 02:39:11.308
SO GOING FORWARD WE THINK IT IS
02:39:11.375 --> 02:39:12.776
ESSENTIAL THAT THE CHIEF
02:39:12.843 --> 02:39:15.012
JUSTICE HAVE. STATEWIDE
02:39:15.078 --> 02:39:16.146
AUTHORITY TO DEAL WITH THE
02:39:16.213 --> 02:39:20.450
STATEWIDE EMERGENCY. THANK YOU.
02:39:20.517 --> 02:39:22.786
AND MISTER KERIK MIKE BELOW
02:39:22.853 --> 02:39:23.287
TWENTY OF THE CALIFORNIA
02:39:23.353 --> 02:39:26.790
DEFENSE COUNSEL. FOLLOWING UP
02:39:26.857 --> 02:39:28.525
ON MS GRAVELS COMMENTS THIS WAS
02:39:28.592 --> 02:39:30.627
A LESSON FROM THE PANDEMIC AND
02:39:30.694 --> 02:39:32.629
WE'RE LEARNING LOTS OF LESSONS-
02:39:32.696 --> 02:39:34.431
THIS IS NOT INTERROGATION OF A
02:39:34.498 --> 02:39:37.000
PRESIDING JUDGES ABILITY TO
02:39:37.067 --> 02:39:39.670
TAILOR. PROCEDURES BASED ON
02:39:39.736 --> 02:39:42.873
THE- ISSUES FACING LOCAL COURTS
02:39:42.940 --> 02:39:45.175
BUT RATHER A RECOGNITION THAT
02:39:45.242 --> 02:39:46.743
WE HAVE A STATE COURT SYSTEM
02:39:46.810 --> 02:39:49.212
THAT OUR MEMBERS PRACTICE IN
02:39:49.279 --> 02:39:51.315
MULTIPLE JURISDICTIONS AND IT'S
02:39:51.381 --> 02:39:53.250
CRITICAL TO KNOW WHAT THE
02:39:53.317 --> 02:39:55.552
STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS RULES
02:39:55.619 --> 02:39:59.056
WILL BE IN EFFECT- WHAT-
02:39:59.122 --> 02:40:01.158
HEARING DEADLINE RULES WILL BE
02:40:01.224 --> 02:40:02.759
IN EFFECT PEOPLE PRACTICE MULTI
02:40:02.826 --> 02:40:05.362
JURISDICTIONAL A AND- THE MORE
02:40:05.429 --> 02:40:06.830
UNIFORMITY WE CAN HAVE AROUND
02:40:06.897 --> 02:40:09.232
THE STATE- SUBJECT TO LOCAL
02:40:09.299 --> 02:40:11.435
CONDITIONS THE BETTER OFF WE
02:40:11.501 --> 02:40:13.570
ARE. AND SO WE'RE PROUD TO
02:40:13.637 --> 02:40:15.672
JOIN- THE CONSUMER ATTORNEYS IN
02:40:15.739 --> 02:40:18.475
ASKING FOR AN AYE VOTE ON THE
02:40:18.542 --> 02:40:21.712
BILL THANK YOU. THANK YOU- ANY
02:40:21.778 --> 02:40:23.413
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT IN THE
02:40:23.480 --> 02:40:27.617
AUDIENCE TODAY. ANY FURTHER
02:40:27.684 --> 02:40:29.119
WITNESSES SUPPORT ON THE PHONE
02:40:29.186 --> 02:40:34.224
LINES. ID ONE ZERO IF YOU'RE IN
02:40:34.291 --> 02:40:40.564
SUPPORT. AND THERE'S NO ONE IN
02:40:40.630 --> 02:40:44.801
SUPPORT. OKAY ANY OPPOSITION
02:40:44.868 --> 02:40:51.575
WITNESSES. CNN WE HAVE ANY A
02:40:51.641 --> 02:40:53.844
BUDDY OF MINE TO EXPRESS
02:40:53.910 --> 02:40:57.781
OPPOSITION IN THE AUDIENCE. AND
02:40:57.848 --> 02:40:59.049
ANY OPPOSITION ON THE PHONE
02:40:59.116 --> 02:41:03.687
LINES. IF YOU'RE IN OPPOSITION
02:41:03.754 --> 02:41:05.355
PLEASE PRESS ONE ZERO AT THE
02:41:05.422 --> 02:41:10.660
TIME. WE DO HAVE ONE GIVING UP.
02:41:10.727 --> 02:41:20.470
THERE'S AT THE MOMENT. IN
02:41:20.537 --> 02:41:21.071
NINETEEN SIXTY FOUR YOUR LIGHT
02:41:21.138 --> 02:41:23.407
AND BUT- GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIR
02:41:23.473 --> 02:41:25.108
COMMITTEE MEMBERS OUT OF
02:41:25.175 --> 02:41:25.675
REGULAR WITH THE CALIFORNIA
02:41:25.742 --> 02:41:27.444
CHAMBER OF COMMERCE. ONE OF THE
02:41:27.511 --> 02:41:29.713
EXPRESS OUR GRATITUDE TO THE
02:41:29.780 --> 02:41:31.515
COMMITTEE CONSULTANT AND STAFF
02:41:31.581 --> 02:41:34.117
WORKING ON THE AMENDMENTS WE
02:41:34.184 --> 02:41:36.987
WERE INITIALLY OPPOSED TO THE-
02:41:37.054 --> 02:41:39.256
INTRODUCED LANGUAGE AND WITH
02:41:39.322 --> 02:41:41.191
THE AMENDMENT THAT THE
02:41:41.258 --> 02:41:43.260
COMMITTEE PLANS TO TAKE. THE
02:41:43.326 --> 02:41:45.062
CHAMBER WILL BE GOING TO A NO
02:41:45.128 --> 02:41:46.830
POSITION AND THERE'LL BE A
02:41:46.897 --> 02:41:49.633
NUMBER OF- ENTITY THAT SIGNED
02:41:49.699 --> 02:41:50.901
ON TO OUR OPPOSITION COALITION
02:41:50.967 --> 02:41:52.836
WILL ALSO BE CHANGING TO A
02:41:52.903 --> 02:41:55.472
NEUTRAL OR NO POSITION. AND WE
02:41:55.539 --> 02:41:56.973
WILL ONCE REFLECTED IN PRINT
02:41:57.040 --> 02:41:59.276
THE MINUTE CHANGE OF POSITION
02:41:59.342 --> 02:41:59.876
REFLECTING THAT THANK YOU VERY
02:41:59.943 --> 02:42:04.948
MUCH. IF THERE ANY OTHER THAN
02:42:05.015 --> 02:42:06.283
OPPOSITION PLEASE PRESS ONE
02:42:06.349 --> 02:42:12.856
THEN ZERO AT THIS TIME. THERE'S
02:42:12.923 --> 02:42:15.592
NO ONE ELSE IN THE QUEUE. OKAY
02:42:15.659 --> 02:42:16.860
BRING IT BACK TO THE COMMITTEE
02:42:16.927 --> 02:42:18.128
WE ALREADY HAVE A MOTION AND A
02:42:18.195 --> 02:42:20.630
SECOND- ANY QUESTIONS OR
02:42:20.697 --> 02:42:26.269
COMMENTS. SCENE NINE WILL CALL
02:42:26.336 --> 02:42:27.571
YEAH I DID HAVE ONE QUESTION
02:42:27.637 --> 02:42:29.206
HAVE WE HEARD FROM THE
02:42:29.272 --> 02:42:30.107
PRESIDING JUDGES AT ALL IS
02:42:30.173 --> 02:42:31.942
THERE ANY DISCUSSION WE'VE
02:42:32.008 --> 02:42:33.009
GOTTEN BACK FROM THE MISTER
02:42:33.076 --> 02:42:35.245
TURNER WE'VE NOT HAD ANY ISSUES
02:42:35.312 --> 02:42:37.814
WITH. FOR THE PRESIDING JUDGES.
02:42:37.881 --> 02:42:40.417
OKAY MEDICAL CLOUT CALL THE
02:42:40.484 --> 02:42:43.253
ROLL OF A CLOSE. YES GET AN
02:42:43.320 --> 02:42:44.855
EMOTIONAL IF YOU PASS AS
02:42:44.921 --> 02:42:46.156
AMENDED BECAUSE THIS BILL HAS
02:42:46.223 --> 02:42:48.391
BEEN. AMENDED QUITE A BIT OVER
02:42:48.458 --> 02:42:49.526
THE COURSE OF IT AND THE
02:42:49.593 --> 02:42:51.027
ANALYSIS REFLECTS THE AMENDED
02:42:51.094 --> 02:42:52.496
BILL SO I JUST WANT TO MAKE IT.
02:42:52.562 --> 02:42:53.396
CLEAR ON THE RECORD THEM
02:42:53.463 --> 02:42:56.299
ACCEPTING THOSE AMENDMENTS AND
02:42:56.366 --> 02:42:56.867
I ASKED WE WRITE ABOUT THANK
02:42:56.933 --> 02:42:58.668
YOU. THANK YOU I'M SORRY- I
02:42:58.735 --> 02:43:00.537
DON'T BELIEVE I HAVE A MOTION
02:43:00.604 --> 02:43:04.508
AND SECOND. THE MOTION- MUST
02:43:04.574 --> 02:43:05.876
READ AND SECONDED BY MISTER
02:43:05.942 --> 02:43:10.547
HOLDEN. A STONE FIVE STONE AYE
02:43:10.614 --> 02:43:14.084
GALLAGHER AYE FELDER I SHOW SO
02:43:14.151 --> 02:43:18.555
I CHU CHU AYE GONZALEZ AND
02:43:18.622 --> 02:43:20.657
THOSE AYE HOLDEN. HOLDEN AYE
02:43:20.724 --> 02:43:28.899
KALRA. KALRA BY. KILEY NON.
02:43:28.965 --> 02:43:31.001
KELLY NOT VOTING MAIENSCHEIN
02:43:31.067 --> 02:43:35.172
OBERNOLTE. OBERNOLTE NOT VOTING
02:43:35.238 --> 02:43:45.682
REYES. HI RES I. SHE'S THAT HAS
02:43:45.749 --> 02:43:49.052
EIGHT BUT- WHAT ABLE TO DOUBLE
02:43:49.119 --> 02:43:53.490
THE BILLS OUT. YEP THANK YOU.
02:43:53.557 --> 02:43:56.960
OKAY LET'S NOW ROLL BACK
02:43:57.027 --> 02:43:59.930
THROUGH ALL OF THE ITEMS WE
02:43:59.996 --> 02:44:01.331
HAVE SEVERAL BILLS ARE CALL
02:44:01.398 --> 02:44:02.999
MOST OF THE BILLS HAVE PASSED
02:44:03.066 --> 02:44:04.935
OUT OF THE COMMITTEE SO LET'S
02:44:05.001 --> 02:44:08.038
RUN THROUGH FROM THE TOP ITEM
02:44:08.104 --> 02:44:11.975
NUMBER ONE IS AB TWENTY FOUR
02:44:12.042 --> 02:44:12.609
SIXTY THREE WHICH IS ON CALL IN
02:44:12.676 --> 02:44:15.111
THE LIFT THE CALL. COMING UP TO
02:44:15.178 --> 02:44:17.380
MEMBERS PLEASE GALLAGHER.
02:44:17.447 --> 02:44:22.953
GALLAGHER NOT VOTING. TO AYE
02:44:23.019 --> 02:44:27.524
HOLDEN HOLDEN AYE KILEY. KILEY
02:44:27.591 --> 02:44:34.030
AYE OBERNOLTE NOT VOTING. THE
02:44:34.097 --> 02:44:37.334
BILL HAS EIGHT FOLKS SO AB
02:44:37.400 --> 02:44:37.934
TWENTY FOUR SIXTY THREE IS OUT
02:44:38.001 --> 02:44:41.204
THANK YOU. ITEM NUMBER TWO IS
02:44:41.271 --> 02:44:43.373
AB TWENTY THREE THIRTY EIGHT BY
02:44:43.440 --> 02:44:45.075
WHATEVER IT IS OUT OF THE
02:44:45.141 --> 02:44:45.642
COMMITTEE BUT WOULD YOU CALL
02:44:45.709 --> 02:44:50.013
THE ABSENT MEMBERS. GALLAGHER.
02:44:50.080 --> 02:44:56.419
GALLAGHER NOT VOTING. CHU CHU I.
02:44:56.486 --> 02:45:02.092
HOLDEN HOLDEN I. AND
02:45:02.158 --> 02:45:13.336
MAIENSCHEIN. GALLAGHER I. THAT
02:45:13.403 --> 02:45:15.105
HAS TEN VOTES OKAY THAT WAS
02:45:15.171 --> 02:45:16.940
ALREADY OUT SO ITEM NUMBER
02:45:17.007 --> 02:45:19.009
THREE IS AB TWENTY FOUR FORTY
02:45:19.075 --> 02:45:21.278
TWO BY MR CHALLENGES ON CALL.
02:45:21.344 --> 02:45:28.718
MIDDLE IF THE CALL. TWO FIVE TO
02:45:28.785 --> 02:45:32.689
BUY GONZALEZ AND SALAS I HOLDEN.
02:45:32.756 --> 02:45:39.863
HOLDEN I. AND MAIENSCHEIN. AND
02:45:39.929 --> 02:45:42.232
THAT HAS SEVEN VOTES THANK YOU
02:45:42.299 --> 02:45:45.035
THE BILL IS OUT. I REMEMBER FOR
02:45:45.101 --> 02:45:47.037
AB TWENTY FOUR FORTY FIVE I
02:45:47.103 --> 02:45:49.539
MISS REYES IS ALREADY OUT BUT
02:45:49.606 --> 02:45:50.140
LOW ADD ONS A CALL THE ABSENT
02:45:50.206 --> 02:45:55.312
MEMBERS. TWO FIVE CHU I HOLDEN
02:45:55.378 --> 02:46:01.818
HOLDEN HI. AND MAIENSCHEIN.
02:46:01.885 --> 02:46:03.853
THANK YOU ITEM NUMBER FIVE IS
02:46:03.920 --> 02:46:05.789
AB TWENTY FOUR SEVENTY ONE BY
02:46:05.855 --> 02:46:07.123
MR MAIENSCHEIN THE BILL IS
02:46:07.190 --> 02:46:08.758
ALREADY OUT I'M NOT SURE WE
02:46:08.825 --> 02:46:10.360
HAVE EVERYBODY LISTED BUT IF
02:46:10.427 --> 02:46:12.629
YOU CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS TWO
02:46:12.696 --> 02:46:17.567
FIVE TWO I. OKAY THAT'S IT.
02:46:17.634 --> 02:46:20.070
ITEM NUMBER SIX AB THIRTY
02:46:20.136 --> 02:46:21.671
TWENTY BY MR GLORIA IS ON CALL
02:46:21.738 --> 02:46:25.075
I'M GOING TO LIFT THE CALL. TWO
02:46:25.141 --> 02:46:29.779
HI CHIU AYE HOLDEN. HOLDEN I.
02:46:29.846 --> 02:46:33.016
IT HAS SEVEN. GREAT THE BILL IS
02:46:33.083 --> 02:46:35.485
OUT THANK YOU I REMEMBER SEVEN
02:46:35.552 --> 02:46:37.087
AB THIRTY ONE THIRTY THREE BY
02:46:37.153 --> 02:46:39.389
MS AGUIAR-CURRY IS OUT BUT CALL
02:46:39.456 --> 02:46:42.292
THE UP TO MEMBERS THAT ARE TOO
02:46:42.359 --> 02:46:48.732
HIGH. TWO I. HOLDEN HOLDEN I.
02:46:48.798 --> 02:46:51.234
ORANGE LINE THANK YOU NUMBER
02:46:51.301 --> 02:46:52.736
EIGHT IS AB THIRTY TO FIFTY
02:46:52.802 --> 02:46:54.204
FOUR BY MS LOW MOAN IT IS
02:46:54.270 --> 02:46:55.872
ALREADY OUT OF THE COMMITTEE
02:46:55.939 --> 02:46:57.340
BUT IF MEMBERS WISH THAT ON
02:46:57.407 --> 02:47:00.910
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS TO HI
02:47:00.977 --> 02:47:03.780
CHU I. HOLDEN HOLDEN I
02:47:03.847 --> 02:47:07.350
MAIENSCHEIN. OKAY AN ITEM
02:47:07.417 --> 02:47:09.285
NUMBER NINE AB THIRTY TWO
02:47:09.352 --> 02:47:11.354
SEVENTY ONE BY MR KILEY IS OUT
02:47:11.421 --> 02:47:13.089
OF THE COMMITTEE BUT IF YOU YOU
02:47:13.156 --> 02:47:14.991
COULD CALL THE AS A MEMBER STAT
02:47:15.058 --> 02:47:20.597
ON TWO FIVE. TWO I. MAIENSCHEIN
02:47:20.663 --> 02:47:22.599
OKAY AND DO WE HAVE EVERYBODY
02:47:22.665 --> 02:47:25.769
ON ITEM NUMBER TEN A. B. THIRTY
02:47:25.835 --> 02:47:26.903
THREE SIXTY SIX YES WE DO ALL
02:47:26.970 --> 02:47:29.606
RIGHT THAT'S IT THANK YOU ALL
02:47:29.672 --> 02:47:44.687
VERY MUCH WE ARE A JERK.