WEBVTT
00:33:21.332 --> 00:33:22.500
GOOD AFTERNOON WE'RE GOING TO
00:33:22.567 --> 00:33:24.235
BEGIN TODAY'S HEARING OF A
00:33:24.302 --> 00:33:26.404
NATURAL RESOURCES COMMITTEE.
00:33:26.471 --> 00:33:29.107
UNTIL WE ESTABLISH A QUORUM ARE
00:33:29.173 --> 00:33:29.707
GOING TO BE OPERATING AS A SUB
00:33:29.774 --> 00:33:30.007
COMMITTEE.
00:33:30.074 --> 00:33:31.142
FIRST UP WE HAVE ASSEMBLY MEMBER
00:33:31.209 --> 00:33:35.113
AGUILAR CURRY. TO PRESENT AB ONE
00:33:35.179 --> 00:33:35.747
FORTY FOUR BEFORE WE DO THAT I
00:33:35.813 --> 00:33:36.381
JUST WANT TO ANNOUNCE THAT THE
00:33:36.447 --> 00:33:37.749
FOLLOWING BILLS ARE PROPOSED
00:33:37.815 --> 00:33:38.716
CONSENT.
00:33:38.783 --> 00:33:40.818
ITEM FOURTEEN AB NINE THIRTY
00:33:40.885 --> 00:33:42.587
THREE PETRIE-NORRIS I AM TWENTY
00:33:42.653 --> 00:33:43.988
AB TWELVE THIRTY SEVEN
00:33:44.055 --> 00:33:46.991
AGUIAR-CURRY ITEM TWENTY ONE AB
00:33:47.058 --> 00:33:48.292
TWELVE FIFTY TWO ROBERT RIVAS.
00:33:48.359 --> 00:33:50.862
ITEM TWENTY TWO A. B. THIRTEEN
00:33:50.928 --> 00:33:52.730
HUNDRED TO COME LONGER DOVE ITEM
00:33:52.797 --> 00:33:54.098
TWENTY FOUR A. B. THIRTEEN
00:33:54.165 --> 00:33:55.299
NINETY TWO MULLIN AND ITEM
00:33:55.366 --> 00:33:58.136
TWENTY EIGHT AB SEVENTEEN
00:33:58.202 --> 00:34:00.238
SEVENTY FRAZIER.
00:34:00.304 --> 00:34:01.339
THANK YOU AND THE HEARING WILL
00:34:01.406 --> 00:34:06.978
BE TELEVISED ON CAL CHANNEL.
00:34:07.044 --> 00:34:07.678
TWENTY ONE ASSEMBLYMEMBER
00:34:07.745 --> 00:34:10.081
AGUIAR-CURRY MAY BEGIN THANK YOU
00:34:10.148 --> 00:34:10.615
GOOD AFTERNOON MADAM CHAIR
00:34:10.681 --> 00:34:11.416
MEMBERS.
00:34:11.482 --> 00:34:13.451
AB ONE FORTY FOUR REQUIRES THE
00:34:13.518 --> 00:34:14.952
STRATEGIC GROWTH COUNCIL TO
00:34:15.019 --> 00:34:16.921
RECOMMEND A COORDINATED STRATEGY
00:34:16.988 --> 00:34:18.589
FOR REDUCING EMISSIONS.
00:34:18.656 --> 00:34:20.224
ASSOCIATED WITH FORESTRY
00:34:20.291 --> 00:34:22.326
AGRICULTURE AND URBAN WASTE
00:34:22.393 --> 00:34:24.061
ORGANIC WASTE.
00:34:24.128 --> 00:34:26.397
REDUCING WILDFIRE LANDFILL HAND
00:34:26.464 --> 00:34:28.099
HOW BURNING OF ORGANIC WASTE
00:34:28.166 --> 00:34:30.401
ACROSS THE SECTORS IS CRITICAL
00:34:30.468 --> 00:34:32.670
TO MEETING OUR EXISTING CLIMATE
00:34:32.737 --> 00:34:33.938
AND AIR QUALITY GOALS.
00:34:34.005 --> 00:34:35.373
HOWEVER THE STATE LACKS A
00:34:35.440 --> 00:34:37.408
COORDINATED STEP STRATEGY AND
00:34:37.475 --> 00:34:39.143
FUNDING PLANS TO MAXIMIZE THE
00:34:39.210 --> 00:34:40.912
BENEFICIAL REUSE OF THESE
00:34:40.978 --> 00:34:42.780
ORGANIC MATERIALS.
00:34:42.847 --> 00:34:45.216
BENEFICIAL REUSE SUCH AS COMPOST
00:34:45.283 --> 00:34:47.885
BIO ENERGY OR SOIL AMENDMENTS
00:34:47.952 --> 00:34:49.987
CAN SUPPORT NICK CARMINE CARBON
00:34:50.054 --> 00:34:51.255
EMISSION REDUCTIONS.
00:34:51.322 --> 00:34:53.124
APPROVED AIR QUALITY AND OTHER
00:34:53.191 --> 00:34:54.959
ENVIRONMENTAL AND ECONOMIC CO
00:34:55.026 --> 00:34:56.761
BENEFITS.
00:34:56.828 --> 00:34:58.463
AN AGORA AN ORGANIC SCOPING PLAN
00:34:58.529 --> 00:35:00.097
WILL PROVIDE LONG TERM
00:35:00.164 --> 00:35:01.999
TECHNOLOGY NEUTRAL AND DATE
00:35:02.066 --> 00:35:03.801
INFORM RECOMMENDATIONS ON HOW TO
00:35:03.868 --> 00:35:05.403
SUPPORT AND INCENTIVIZE THE
00:35:05.470 --> 00:35:06.971
BENEFICIAL REUSE OF ORGANIC
00:35:07.038 --> 00:35:08.439
WASTE.
00:35:08.506 --> 00:35:09.974
IT WILL BE DEVELOPED BY THE
00:35:10.041 --> 00:35:11.042
STRATEGIC GROWTH COUNSEL WITH
00:35:11.108 --> 00:35:12.677
INTER AGENCY SUPPORT.
00:35:12.743 --> 00:35:14.479
AND IT WILL CONSIDER AND BALANCE
00:35:14.545 --> 00:35:15.980
THE IMMEDIATE NEEDS OF LOCAL
00:35:16.047 --> 00:35:17.782
COMMUNITIES DISPROPORTIONATELY
00:35:17.849 --> 00:35:19.183
EXPOSED TO ENVIRONMENTAL
00:35:19.250 --> 00:35:21.152
POLLUTION.
00:35:21.219 --> 00:35:22.720
INCLUDING WILDFIRE SMOKE.
00:35:22.787 --> 00:35:25.456
I RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE VOTE.
00:35:25.523 --> 00:35:27.058
WITH ME TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT A
00:35:27.125 --> 00:35:27.992
REPRESENTATIVES FROM THE
00:35:28.059 --> 00:35:30.461
CALIFORNIA COMPOST COALITION.
00:35:30.528 --> 00:35:32.396
CALIFORNIANS AGAINST WASTE AND
00:35:32.463 --> 00:35:34.765
THE CALIFORNIA LOW CARBON FUEL
00:35:34.832 --> 00:35:36.367
AND ENERGY COALITION.
00:35:36.434 --> 00:35:37.235
THANK YOU BEFORE WE GO TO THE
00:35:37.301 --> 00:35:38.002
WITNESSES JUST FOR ALL THE
00:35:38.069 --> 00:35:39.604
WITNESSES AND AUTHORS WHO WERE
00:35:39.670 --> 00:35:40.705
PRESENT WE'RE GOING TO BE
00:35:40.771 --> 00:35:41.906
BECAUSE WE WERE VERY LONG AGENDA
00:35:41.973 --> 00:35:44.008
TODAY AND NEXT AT THE NEXT
00:35:44.075 --> 00:35:44.609
MEETING AND PROBABLY FOR THE
00:35:44.675 --> 00:35:45.576
REST OF TIME.
00:35:45.643 --> 00:35:46.744
WE'RE GOING TO ALLOW THREE
00:35:46.811 --> 00:35:48.246
WITNESSES WITH A MAXIMUM OF TWO
00:35:48.312 --> 00:35:49.747
MINUTES EACH AND WE ARE GOING TO
00:35:49.814 --> 00:35:50.581
BE USING.
00:35:50.648 --> 00:35:53.284
THE TIME KEEPER AND WE ARE GOING
00:35:53.351 --> 00:35:54.418
TO CUT YOU OFF SO PLEASE STAY
00:35:54.485 --> 00:35:55.820
WITH IN THOSE TWO MINUTES YOU
00:35:55.887 --> 00:35:56.854
WILL NOT BE ABLE TO FINISH HER
00:35:56.921 --> 00:35:59.357
TESTIMONY THANK YOU WITH THAT
00:35:59.423 --> 00:36:01.592
WELCOME AND YOU MAY PROCEED.
00:36:01.659 --> 00:36:03.027
MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS JUST MULLIN
00:36:03.094 --> 00:36:03.995
FOR THE CALIFORNIA COMPOST
00:36:04.061 --> 00:36:05.663
COALITION I CAN DO TO WILL AND
00:36:05.730 --> 00:36:06.797
TO TWO MINUTES I THINK THE THE
00:36:06.864 --> 00:36:07.765
CITADEL.
00:36:07.832 --> 00:36:09.534
WE KNOW THAT COMPOST IS PROBABLY
00:36:09.600 --> 00:36:11.402
THE BEST FROM MY PERSPECTIVE THE
00:36:11.469 --> 00:36:12.236
WAY TO ADDRESS SOME OF THESE
00:36:12.303 --> 00:36:13.538
ISSUES BUT WE'RE NOT THE ONLY
00:36:13.604 --> 00:36:15.206
GAME IN TOWN WE NEED A
00:36:15.273 --> 00:36:16.974
COMPREHENSIVE APPROACH AND
00:36:17.041 --> 00:36:19.377
REALLY A PULL TAB MOVING THIS
00:36:19.443 --> 00:36:20.778
FORWARD THANK YOU.
00:36:20.845 --> 00:36:25.616
THAT WAS A ROLE MODEL THANK YOU
00:36:25.683 --> 00:36:25.917
[inaudible]
00:36:25.983 --> 00:36:29.220
CALIFORNIA.
00:36:29.287 --> 00:36:30.788
WE WOULD AUTHOR THEORIES OF
00:36:30.855 --> 00:36:32.790
REALLY AGGRESSIVE POLLS NUMBER
00:36:32.857 --> 00:36:34.325
ORGANIC WAY.
00:36:34.392 --> 00:36:34.859
OVER THE LAST TEN YEARS.
00:36:34.926 --> 00:36:38.796
AND FRANKLY WE'RE NOT QUITE
00:36:38.863 --> 00:36:39.830
ENOUGH AN ORGANIC WAY SECTOR
00:36:39.897 --> 00:36:40.631
THAN OFFICE POINTS OUT THE FACT
00:36:40.698 --> 00:36:41.165
THAT THERE ARE CONFLICTING
00:36:41.232 --> 00:36:42.199
PERMITTING INSTRUCTIONS ARE
00:36:42.266 --> 00:36:43.401
REQUIREMENTS.
00:36:43.467 --> 00:36:45.369
FOR DIFFERENT FACILITIES
00:36:45.436 --> 00:36:48.940
OCCASIONALLY -- BUT OCCASIONALLY
00:36:49.006 --> 00:36:50.374
DURING THE MORE ENVIRONMENTALLY
00:36:50.441 --> 00:36:52.643
FRIENDLY THING IS THE MORE
00:36:52.710 --> 00:36:54.278
DIFFICULT APARTMENT REQUIREMENT.
00:36:54.345 --> 00:36:55.947
THAT HAPPENS BOTH BUT THE WATER
00:36:56.013 --> 00:36:56.447
BOARDS AND WHAT THEY ARE
00:36:56.514 --> 00:36:57.181
DISTRICTS.
00:36:57.248 --> 00:36:59.016
WE DON'T WANT TO DIS INCENTIVIZE
00:36:59.083 --> 00:37:00.318
ENVIRONMENTAL ACTION.
00:37:00.384 --> 00:37:02.820
AND THEN -- IT REALLY NO EFFORT
00:37:02.887 --> 00:37:05.590
HAS BEEN MADE -- TO COORDINATE
00:37:05.656 --> 00:37:07.592
THEIR AGRICULTURAL WASTE BEFORE
00:37:07.658 --> 00:37:09.994
SHE WAY SWEAT THAT STUFF COMING
00:37:10.061 --> 00:37:13.598
OUT OF URBAN FACTORS.
00:37:13.664 --> 00:37:17.335
THANK YOU.
00:37:17.401 --> 00:37:19.837
THANK YOU KELLY BOY WITH A
00:37:19.904 --> 00:37:21.372
CALIFORNIA.
00:37:21.439 --> 00:37:24.375
I WAS WITH MY THANK YOU.
00:37:24.442 --> 00:37:24.976
KELLY BOY THE CALIFORNIA LOW
00:37:25.042 --> 00:37:28.779
CARBON FUEL AND ENERGY COALITION --
00:37:28.846 --> 00:37:29.847
US SO HIT MYSELF WITH REMARKS TO
00:37:29.914 --> 00:37:30.414
THE OTHERS SPEAKERS BUT ALSO
00:37:30.481 --> 00:37:31.015
JUST POINT OUT WE DON'T HAVE A
00:37:31.082 --> 00:37:32.283
COMPREHENSIVE STRATEGY ACROSS
00:37:32.350 --> 00:37:33.784
AGENCY ACROSS SECTORS.
00:37:33.851 --> 00:37:35.286
THIS IS A KEY WAY TO GET A SENSE
00:37:35.353 --> 00:37:37.154
OF THE VOLUME -- IN EACH OF
00:37:37.221 --> 00:37:38.623
THOSE SECTORS APPROPRIATE
00:37:38.689 --> 00:37:40.591
INCENTIVES AND ALLOW EVERYTHING
00:37:40.658 --> 00:37:42.059
TO MOVE FORWARD.
00:37:42.126 --> 00:37:43.260
UNDER THE STRATEGIC GROWTH
00:37:43.327 --> 00:37:45.262
COUNCILS AGES WE WE THINK IT'S
00:37:45.329 --> 00:37:48.699
THE RIGHT MOVE AT THE RIGHT TIME
00:37:48.766 --> 00:37:49.166
THANK YOU FOR ENTRY AN
00:37:49.233 --> 00:37:49.867
INTRODUCTION.
00:37:49.934 --> 00:37:50.835
THANK YOU ARE THERE ANY OTHER
00:37:50.901 --> 00:37:51.469
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT AND WE'RE
00:37:51.535 --> 00:37:53.804
GONNA HAVE YOU MOVED TO THE SIDE
00:37:53.871 --> 00:37:56.040
ACTUALLY [inaudible]
00:37:56.107 --> 00:37:59.710
THANK YOU.
00:37:59.777 --> 00:38:01.278
NEED A GOOD FOR THE COALITION
00:38:01.345 --> 00:38:01.879
FOR RENEWABLE NATURAL GAS AND
00:38:01.946 --> 00:38:05.950
STRONG SUPPORT THANK YOU. TO
00:38:06.017 --> 00:38:07.385
CHECK OUR INTERACTIVE CULTURAL
00:38:07.451 --> 00:38:11.555
COUNCIL CALIFORNIA IN SUPPORT.
00:38:11.622 --> 00:38:13.024
JOHN CALDERON CALIFORNIA BY MEN
00:38:13.090 --> 00:38:14.392
ENERGY ENOUGH ALLIANCE IN
00:38:14.458 --> 00:38:17.595
SUPPORT.
00:38:17.662 --> 00:38:19.263
JOSIAH YOUNG WITH THE BIO ENERGY
00:38:19.330 --> 00:38:19.830
ASSOCIATION OF CALIFORNIANS
00:38:19.897 --> 00:38:23.768
SUPPORT. THREE IS A BROKERAGE ON
00:38:23.834 --> 00:38:25.436
BEHALF OF THE COMMUNITY ALLIANCE
00:38:25.503 --> 00:38:27.505
WITH FAMILY FARMERS AND SUPPORT.
00:38:27.571 --> 00:38:28.372
THANK YOU ANY OTHER WITNESSES
00:38:28.439 --> 00:38:30.274
SUPPORT TO HAVE ANY WITNESSES
00:38:30.341 --> 00:38:30.741
AND OFFICERS ANYONE IN
00:38:30.808 --> 00:38:33.210
OPPOSITION.
00:38:33.277 --> 00:38:35.046
SEEING NONE I WILL RETURN TO THE
00:38:35.112 --> 00:38:36.380
COMMITTEE TO SEE IF THERE'S ANY
00:38:36.447 --> 00:38:39.283
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS.
00:38:39.350 --> 00:38:40.051
THE MEMBER I WOULD JUST LIKE TO
00:38:40.117 --> 00:38:41.552
SAY I LOVE MAKING IT DECISIONS
00:38:41.619 --> 00:38:43.020
BASED ON DATA AND THANK YOU FOR
00:38:43.087 --> 00:38:44.288
BRINGING THIS BILL FORWARD TO WE
00:38:44.355 --> 00:38:45.456
CAN ACTUALLY GET A GOOD PICTURE
00:38:45.523 --> 00:38:47.625
AND A PLAN AND I LOVE TO BE AS A
00:38:47.692 --> 00:38:49.894
CO AUTHOR.
00:38:49.960 --> 00:38:51.629
OF THE HAVE TO HAVE A QUORUM.
00:38:51.696 --> 00:38:52.596
YOU'RE NOT OF A QUORUM.
00:38:52.663 --> 00:38:54.098
SO -- WITH THAT WE WILL -- WAIT
00:38:54.165 --> 00:38:55.833
UNTIL WE HAVE A QUORUM I WILL BE
00:38:55.900 --> 00:38:56.734
SUPPORTING THE BILL WHEN IT --
00:38:56.801 --> 00:38:57.902
WHEN WE OPEN THE ROLE FOR VOTE
00:38:57.968 --> 00:38:59.470
THANK YOU VERY MUCH THANK YOU
00:38:59.537 --> 00:39:01.572
VERY MUCH AND YOU ARE ALSO HERE
00:39:01.639 --> 00:39:04.442
FOR AB EIGHT FIFTEEN I AM?
00:39:04.508 --> 00:39:06.143
AGAIN GOOD AFTERNOON MADAM CHAIR
00:39:06.210 --> 00:39:08.145
AND MEMBERS ALL BEGINNING BY
00:39:08.212 --> 00:39:08.646
ACCEPTING THE COMMITTEE
00:39:08.713 --> 00:39:09.480
AMENDMENTS.
00:39:09.547 --> 00:39:11.849
WITH THESE AMENDMENTS AB EIGHT
00:39:11.916 --> 00:39:13.017
FIFTEEN WILL INCENTIVIZE LOCAL
00:39:13.084 --> 00:39:14.452
GOVERNMENTS TO INCREASE SIR
00:39:14.518 --> 00:39:16.120
CURBSIDE SEPARATION IN THE
00:39:16.187 --> 00:39:17.688
RECYCLING PROGRAMS.
00:39:17.755 --> 00:39:20.624
WHICH WILL REDUCE CONTAMINATION
00:39:20.691 --> 00:39:21.959
RATES IN THE RECYCLING STREAM.
00:39:22.026 --> 00:39:23.828
BY COMPARISON WHEN WE THROW OUT
00:39:23.894 --> 00:39:25.162
ALL OF OUR RECYCLABLES INTO THE
00:39:25.229 --> 00:39:27.498
SAME BIN GLASS BREAKS LEFT OVER
00:39:27.565 --> 00:39:29.533
SO TO SPILLS ON COPY PAPER.
00:39:29.600 --> 00:39:31.402
AND A RECYCLED MATERIALS BECOME
00:39:31.469 --> 00:39:32.770
CONTAMINATED.
00:39:32.837 --> 00:39:34.505
CONTAMINATION REDUCES THE
00:39:34.572 --> 00:39:36.040
QUALITY OF OUR RECYCLABLES
00:39:36.107 --> 00:39:37.708
MAKING THEM DIFFICULT OR IN PART
00:39:37.775 --> 00:39:40.611
BEEN POSSIBLE. TO MARKET FOR RE
00:39:40.678 --> 00:39:42.113
USE.
00:39:42.179 --> 00:39:43.314
WE USED TO SEND OVER HALF A
00:39:43.380 --> 00:39:45.049
WROTE CONTAMINATE RECYCLABLES TO
00:39:45.116 --> 00:39:46.717
CHINA WHERE THEY WERE FREQUENTLY
00:39:46.784 --> 00:39:48.185
LANDFILLS OR BURNED.
00:39:48.252 --> 00:39:49.653
BUT CHINA ISN'T TAKING ARE
00:39:49.720 --> 00:39:52.123
CONTAMINATED RECYCLABLES ANYMORE.
00:39:52.189 --> 00:39:53.657
WE NEED TO FIGURE OUT HOW TO BE
00:39:53.724 --> 00:39:55.760
MORE RESPONSIBLE CONSUMERS AND
00:39:55.826 --> 00:39:56.961
RECYCLERS.
00:39:57.027 --> 00:39:58.662
DUAL STREAM PROGRAMS KEEP
00:39:58.729 --> 00:40:01.065
RECYCLED MATERIAL SEPARATED AND
00:40:01.132 --> 00:40:02.266
CLEANER IN THE WASTE STREAM.
00:40:02.333 --> 00:40:03.701
CLEAN STREAMS INCREASE THE
00:40:03.768 --> 00:40:05.770
MARKETABILITY OF A RECYCLABLE SO
00:40:05.836 --> 00:40:07.037
THAT THEY ARE ACTUALLY TURNED
00:40:07.104 --> 00:40:08.672
INTONEW PRODUCTS.
00:40:08.739 --> 00:40:10.541
AB EIGHT FIFTEEN WORKERS LOCALS
00:40:10.608 --> 00:40:11.942
WITH EXISTING DUAL STREAM
00:40:12.009 --> 00:40:13.644
PROGRAMS TO CONTINUE OPERATING
00:40:13.711 --> 00:40:17.181
THOSE PROGRAMS AND INCENTIVIZE
00:40:17.248 --> 00:40:18.149
THOSE WHO WISH TO TO SWITCH.
00:40:18.215 --> 00:40:20.117
THIS WILL IMPROVE THE QUALITY
00:40:20.184 --> 00:40:21.819
AND MARKETABILITY OF RECYCLED
00:40:21.886 --> 00:40:24.288
MATERIALS AND REDUCE.
00:40:24.355 --> 00:40:25.990
THE AMOUNT OF THOSE MATERIALS
00:40:26.056 --> 00:40:28.192
THAT ARE STOCKPILED LANDFIELD OR
00:40:28.259 --> 00:40:31.128
BURNED AT HOME -- OVERSEAS.
00:40:31.195 --> 00:40:31.962
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR AYE
00:40:32.029 --> 00:40:32.997
VOTE.
00:40:33.063 --> 00:40:34.832
WITH ME TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT
00:40:34.899 --> 00:40:35.432
OUR REPRESENTATIVES FROM THE
00:40:35.499 --> 00:40:37.868
PENINSULA SANITARY SERVICE MILL
00:40:37.935 --> 00:40:39.737
VALLEY REFUSE SERVICE AND THE
00:40:39.804 --> 00:40:42.773
GLASS PACKING INSTITUTE THANK
00:40:42.840 --> 00:40:45.543
YOU THANK YOU.
00:40:45.609 --> 00:40:46.710
GOOD AFTERNOON MY NAME IS JIM MY
00:40:46.777 --> 00:40:48.112
PERONI I'M WITH MILL VALLEY
00:40:48.179 --> 00:40:50.748
REFUSE SERVICE -- HOLDER IN
00:40:50.815 --> 00:40:54.785
MARIN COUNTY -- COUPLE OF YEARS
00:40:54.852 --> 00:40:56.887
AGO WE WERE OPERATING A SINGLE
00:40:56.954 --> 00:41:01.025
STREAM -- RECYCLING -- OPERATION
00:41:01.091 --> 00:41:03.994
PICKING UP CURBSIDE AND WE BEGAN
00:41:04.061 --> 00:41:06.931
TO SUFFER THE AFFECTS OF THE
00:41:06.997 --> 00:41:09.366
CHINA NATIONAL SORT POLICY.
00:41:09.433 --> 00:41:12.636
SO WE WERE LOOKING AROUND FOR A
00:41:12.703 --> 00:41:14.004
DIFFERENT WAY TO COLLECT
00:41:14.071 --> 00:41:17.908
RECYCLING AND WE TESTED A DUAL
00:41:17.975 --> 00:41:20.077
STREAM PILOT PROJECT LAST YEAR
00:41:20.144 --> 00:41:22.580
WE FOUND IT WAS A A GOOD WAY TO
00:41:22.646 --> 00:41:25.015
CLEAN UP OUR MATERIAL.
00:41:25.082 --> 00:41:27.718
AND THAT WAS THE MAJOR GOAL TO
00:41:27.785 --> 00:41:30.621
REDUCE PROCESSING COSTS AND AND
00:41:30.688 --> 00:41:33.924
HELP -- MAKE OUR MATERIAL MORE
00:41:33.991 --> 00:41:36.493
MARKETABLE SO -- WE SUPPORT THIS
00:41:36.560 --> 00:41:38.429
BILL WE THINK DUAL STREAM SEEMS
00:41:38.495 --> 00:41:41.532
TO BE -- A GOOD WAY TO TACKLE
00:41:41.599 --> 00:41:45.603
THE PROBLEM OF CONTAMINATION IN --
00:41:45.669 --> 00:41:48.639
RECYCLING COLLECTION AT THE CURB.
00:41:48.706 --> 00:41:50.507
GOOD AFTERNOON MADAM CHAIRMAN IN
00:41:50.574 --> 00:41:52.943
A BOARD MY NAME'S LEE PELLEGRINI
00:41:53.010 --> 00:41:54.245
I'M A HOLLER IN THE SAN
00:41:54.311 --> 00:41:55.613
FRANCISCO BAY AREA INSOLENT
00:41:55.679 --> 00:41:56.747
SANITARY SERVICE.
00:41:56.814 --> 00:41:58.382
MY RELATED COMPANIES SERVICE
00:41:58.449 --> 00:42:00.384
OVER HALF A MILLION PEOPLE WE
00:42:00.451 --> 00:42:02.720
HAVE A BOTH SYSTEMS IN PLACE OF
00:42:02.786 --> 00:42:04.622
A SINGLE STREAM AND DOLE STREAM
00:42:04.688 --> 00:42:05.289
SYSTEM.
00:42:05.356 --> 00:42:06.690
THERE'S ROUGHLY TWENTY
00:42:06.757 --> 00:42:08.092
JURISDICTIONS AND AROUND THE SAN
00:42:08.158 --> 00:42:09.493
FRANCISCO BAY THAT HAVE DUAL
00:42:09.560 --> 00:42:11.295
SPRING COLLECTION SOME OF THOSE
00:42:11.362 --> 00:42:12.930
OF HAVE MOLLY BACK TO THE EARLY
00:42:12.997 --> 00:42:13.898
EIGHTIES.
00:42:13.964 --> 00:42:16.901
IT IS A BETTER CLEANER -- HIGHER
00:42:16.967 --> 00:42:21.138
AND BETTER USE OF MATERIAL
00:42:21.205 --> 00:42:21.906
COLLECTED FROM CURBSIDE.
00:42:21.972 --> 00:42:23.340
WE HAVE JUST RECENTLY TRANSITION
00:42:23.407 --> 00:42:23.908
TO CITIES THAT WERE SINGLE
00:42:23.974 --> 00:42:25.843
STREAM OVER TO DUAL STREAM THE
00:42:25.910 --> 00:42:27.878
CITY A MILPITAS IN THE CITY OF
00:42:27.945 --> 00:42:29.113
WINDSOR AND SONOMA COUNTY.
00:42:29.179 --> 00:42:29.980
ARE.
00:42:30.047 --> 00:42:32.283
A RESIDUAL PERCENTAGE ON A
00:42:32.349 --> 00:42:33.684
SINGLE STREAM COLLECTION PROGRAM
00:42:33.751 --> 00:42:36.253
HAS BEEN AVERAGING 25% WHICH IS
00:42:36.320 --> 00:42:37.922
GROWN WITH TO CHINA SOARED IN
00:42:37.988 --> 00:42:39.423
THE REQUIREMENTS OF A QUALITY
00:42:39.490 --> 00:42:39.990
PRODUCT.
00:42:40.057 --> 00:42:41.625
OUR DUAL STREAM SYSTEMS ARE
00:42:41.692 --> 00:42:44.628
ACHIEVING A 10% RESIDUAL FACTOR.
00:42:44.695 --> 00:42:47.531
WE NEED TOOLS. TO HELP OUR
00:42:47.598 --> 00:42:49.466
COMMUNITIES ARE OUR CUSTOMERS
00:42:49.533 --> 00:42:51.101
MEET THE MANDATES OF THE STATE
00:42:51.168 --> 00:42:52.603
AND THE GOALS THEY WANT TO DO
00:42:52.670 --> 00:42:53.938
BETTER WE ARE.
00:42:54.004 --> 00:42:55.406
LIKE THE IDEA OF THIS A PIECE OF
00:42:55.472 --> 00:42:56.573
LEGISLATION TO BRING SOME
00:42:56.640 --> 00:42:58.575
INCENTIVES SO WE CAN ALL DO OUR
00:42:58.642 --> 00:43:00.878
JOB TO SAVE THE ENVIRONMENT AND
00:43:00.945 --> 00:43:02.947
HAVE A CLEANER HIGHER BETTER USE
00:43:03.013 --> 00:43:04.415
PRODUCT TO BE REUSED.
00:43:04.481 --> 00:43:06.216
THANK YOU.
00:43:06.283 --> 00:43:06.951
A GOOD AFTERNOON THAT MICROBES
00:43:07.017 --> 00:43:07.985
IN HERE ON BEHALF OF THE GLASS
00:43:08.052 --> 00:43:10.120
PACKAGING IS TO WHICH IS THE
00:43:10.187 --> 00:43:11.455
TRADE ASSOCIATION OF GLASS
00:43:11.522 --> 00:43:13.023
BOTTLE MANUFACTURERS AND
00:43:13.090 --> 00:43:16.427
CALIFORNIAN IN THE NATION -- WE
00:43:16.493 --> 00:43:18.262
GPI HAS BEEN A LONG SUPPORTER OF
00:43:18.329 --> 00:43:20.097
A LONG TIME SUPPORTER OF OF OF
00:43:20.164 --> 00:43:21.532
TRYING TO GET MORE DUAL STREAM
00:43:21.598 --> 00:43:25.469
PROGRAMS -- IMPLEMENTED -- GLASS
00:43:25.536 --> 00:43:27.538
CONTAINERS ADDS AS AGAIN.
00:43:27.604 --> 00:43:28.372
AS HE NOW SAYS POINTS ON THE NOW
00:43:28.439 --> 00:43:30.240
SAYS DOESN'T EXCELLENT JOB ON
00:43:30.307 --> 00:43:31.508
THE WHOLE HISTORY OF OF A SINGLE
00:43:31.575 --> 00:43:32.977
STREAM DUAL STREAM AND WHAT'S
00:43:33.043 --> 00:43:34.678
GOING ON WITH -- CHINA NATIONAL
00:43:34.745 --> 00:43:35.980
SOARED SO IT'S A IT'S AN
00:43:36.046 --> 00:43:38.582
EXCELLENT DOCUMENT AND AND IN
00:43:38.649 --> 00:43:40.017
AND DOES EXPLAINED THE PROBLEM
00:43:40.084 --> 00:43:41.251
THAT THE GLASS INDUSTRY HAS THE
00:43:41.318 --> 00:43:43.320
GLASS INDUSTRY IS THE INITIATOR
00:43:43.387 --> 00:43:44.254
OF THE GLASS BOTTLE AND THEY'RE
00:43:44.321 --> 00:43:45.889
ALSO THE END USER OF THE GLASS
00:43:45.956 --> 00:43:47.191
BOTTLE IN ORDER
00:43:47.257 --> 00:43:48.759
TO IN ORDER TO CLOSE THE LOOP
00:43:48.826 --> 00:43:50.995
AND GET THAT GLASS BACK WE HAVE
00:43:51.061 --> 00:43:51.962
TO DO SOMETHING ABOUT REDUCING
00:43:52.029 --> 00:43:53.764
THE CONTAMINATION IN THE IN THE
00:43:53.831 --> 00:43:54.798
RECYCLING STREAM AND AND A
00:43:54.865 --> 00:43:56.567
DRAWSTRING PROGRAM DOES DO THAT
00:43:56.633 --> 00:43:58.202
AS THE GENTLEMAN OF HAVE POINTED
00:43:58.268 --> 00:44:00.237
OUT ON THE ALTERNATIVE FOR SOME
00:44:00.304 --> 00:44:02.039
COMMUNITIES AND FORTUNE LIKE.
00:44:02.106 --> 00:44:03.707
THE CITY OF MEAN PEAK AT THIS
00:44:03.774 --> 00:44:05.042
EVEN TAKE IT DECIDED THAT THEIR
00:44:05.109 --> 00:44:06.243
THEIR ANSWER TO CHINA NATIONAL
00:44:06.310 --> 00:44:07.945
SORT WAS JUST A CUT GLASS OUT OF
00:44:08.012 --> 00:44:09.847
THERE CURBSIDE PROGRAM IN AND
00:44:09.913 --> 00:44:10.881
AND THAT'S NOT THE ANSWER OF
00:44:10.948 --> 00:44:12.516
GLASS IS THE MOST RECYCLABLE
00:44:12.583 --> 00:44:14.184
PRODUCT IT'S A GLASS BOTTLE CAN
00:44:14.251 --> 00:44:14.618
BE A GLASS.
00:44:14.685 --> 00:44:16.520
BOTTLE AND WE NEED TO DO THINGS
00:44:16.587 --> 00:44:17.654
TO INCENTIVIZE DUAL STREAM
00:44:17.721 --> 00:44:18.822
PROGRAMS RATHER THAN WHAT THE
00:44:18.889 --> 00:44:19.990
COMMUNITIES COME UP WITH A
00:44:20.057 --> 00:44:21.392
SOLUTION THAT ACTUALLY.
00:44:21.458 --> 00:44:23.027
TAKE SOMETHING OUT OF THE
00:44:23.093 --> 00:44:24.928
RECYCLING STREAM ON IN PROJECT
00:44:24.995 --> 00:44:33.837
THE AUTHORS HELP HELP ON THIS IN
00:44:33.904 --> 00:44:34.838
THE FOR YOUR SUPPORT.
00:44:34.905 --> 00:44:35.439
THANK YOU ARE THERE ANY OTHER
00:44:35.506 --> 00:44:36.473
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT.
00:44:36.540 --> 00:44:37.041
ARE THERE ANY WITNESSES IN
00:44:37.107 --> 00:44:38.208
OPPOSITION.
00:44:38.275 --> 00:44:39.109
SIGNAL WILL TAKE IT BACK TO THE
00:44:39.176 --> 00:44:41.311
COMMITTEES FOR QUESTIONS AND I'M
00:44:41.378 --> 00:44:41.945
SORRY IS THERE ONE OR ACTUALLY A
00:44:42.012 --> 00:44:42.913
TWEENER -- AN ACCOMPLICE OF
00:44:42.980 --> 00:44:43.514
CALIFORNIANS AGAINST WASTE WE
00:44:43.580 --> 00:44:44.515
DON'T HAVE A POSITION ON THE
00:44:44.581 --> 00:44:46.116
BILL AS WRITTEN BUT WE
00:44:46.183 --> 00:44:47.584
DEFINITELY SHARE THE AUTHORS --
00:44:47.651 --> 00:44:49.186
MOTIVATION AND INTENT AND
00:44:49.253 --> 00:44:51.021
APPRECIATE THE STAFF FOR WORKING
00:44:51.088 --> 00:44:52.423
WITH US TO ADDRESS OUR CONCERNS
00:44:52.489 --> 00:44:53.057
THANK YOU.
00:44:53.123 --> 00:44:55.793
THANK YOU -- ANYBODY ELSE WHO
00:44:55.859 --> 00:44:57.227
WANTS TO TESTIFY.
00:44:57.294 --> 00:44:58.028
THANK YOU OKAY WE'LL TAKE IT
00:44:58.095 --> 00:44:59.430
BACK TO THE TWENTY FOR ANY
00:44:59.496 --> 00:45:01.331
QUESTIONS MISTER CHILD JUST A
00:45:01.398 --> 00:45:02.399
QUICK QUESTION FOR THE WITNESSES --
00:45:02.466 --> 00:45:03.467
THEY DID THE ONE ON EACH ITEM
00:45:03.534 --> 00:45:05.235
AND SAY THAT IT'S IT'S ACTUALLY
00:45:05.302 --> 00:45:07.938
COST LESS TO DO.
00:45:08.005 --> 00:45:09.907
A DOOR STREAM SYSTEMS.
00:45:09.973 --> 00:45:11.542
THIS IS A LESS COSTLY -- MORE
00:45:11.608 --> 00:45:13.444
MORE CAR ARE EXPERIENCED AT
00:45:13.510 --> 00:45:14.978
INCREMENTAL COST -- TO COLLECT
00:45:15.045 --> 00:45:16.113
MATERIAL SEPARATELY AS A DIVIDED
00:45:16.180 --> 00:45:20.184
CART -- ANNA SPLIT TRUCK.
00:45:20.250 --> 00:45:21.318
SO THAT WHEN YOU COLLECT
00:45:21.385 --> 00:45:22.619
MATERIALS KEPT SEPARATE ALL
00:45:22.686 --> 00:45:24.121
THROUGH THE COLLECTION PROCESS
00:45:24.188 --> 00:45:25.823
YOUR MATERIALS RECOVERY FACILITY
00:45:25.889 --> 00:45:27.558
TECHNOLOGY CAN HANDLE SINGLE
00:45:27.624 --> 00:45:28.692
STREAM OR DUAL STREAM.
00:45:28.759 --> 00:45:30.160
SO TO INCREMENTAL COSTS A SMALL
00:45:30.227 --> 00:45:33.130
PERCENTAGE THE RETURN IS REDUCED --
00:45:33.197 --> 00:45:34.998
RESIDUAL THAT COST YOU ENDS UP
00:45:35.065 --> 00:45:37.701
IN THE LANDFILL AND IT'S IT'S
00:45:37.768 --> 00:45:40.938
WORTH THE INVESTMENT STOP FOR
00:45:41.004 --> 00:45:44.208
THE LONG TERM IN MY OPINION.
00:45:44.274 --> 00:45:45.909
SEVEN ASSESSMENT YEAH I WOULD
00:45:45.976 --> 00:45:47.311
JUST LIKE TO STATE -- THIS
00:45:47.377 --> 00:45:47.978
NATIONAL SORT OF SOMETHING THAT
00:45:48.045 --> 00:45:48.745
WE ALL ARE STE TRYING TO
00:45:48.812 --> 00:45:50.214
STRUGGLE WITH AND AND TRYING TO
00:45:50.280 --> 00:45:51.615
FIND A WAY TO TO THREAD THE
00:45:51.682 --> 00:45:53.650
NEEDLE SO I APPRECIATE THEM.
00:45:53.717 --> 00:45:55.586
I APPRECIATE THE CARROT APPROACH
00:45:55.652 --> 00:45:58.889
THAT YOU'VE DECIDED UPON HERE --
00:45:58.956 --> 00:46:00.357
BUT TO IT.
00:46:00.424 --> 00:46:01.692
BUT THAT IT DOES COST MORE UNTIL
00:46:01.758 --> 00:46:03.160
WE HEAR FROM WITNESSES A WE
00:46:03.227 --> 00:46:04.261
RESPECT THEIR THAT THEY'RE ALL
00:46:04.328 --> 00:46:05.229
FROM BAY AREA.
00:46:05.295 --> 00:46:06.263
TYPE CITIES AND SO WHEN YOU
00:46:06.330 --> 00:46:07.397
MOVED FURTHER OUT INTO THE
00:46:07.464 --> 00:46:08.966
VALLEY IN DOWN THE STATE THINGS
00:46:09.032 --> 00:46:10.067
A LITTLE BIT MORE DIFFICULT AS
00:46:10.134 --> 00:46:11.535
YOU WELL KNOW REPRESENTING RURAL
00:46:11.602 --> 00:46:12.769
AREAS SO.
00:46:12.836 --> 00:46:14.004
I THINK THERE'S A WAY TO TRY TO
00:46:14.071 --> 00:46:15.205
GET IS THERE AND I THINK WE
00:46:15.272 --> 00:46:16.540
SHOULD ALL BE PAYING CAREFUL
00:46:16.607 --> 00:46:18.075
ATTENTION AS IT GOES FORWARD AND
00:46:18.142 --> 00:46:19.343
PAY ATTENTION THE COST ISSUES
00:46:19.409 --> 00:46:23.680
BUT ALSO THAT WE USE THE CARROT
00:46:23.747 --> 00:46:24.248
NOT A STICK. TO ADDRESS THIS
00:46:24.314 --> 00:46:25.749
ISSUE.
00:46:25.816 --> 00:46:28.118
THANK YOU ANY OTHER COMMENTS.
00:46:28.185 --> 00:46:30.220
OKAY -- WE STILL DON'T HAVE A
00:46:30.287 --> 00:46:31.054
QUORUM.
00:46:31.121 --> 00:46:32.489
OF DEALING WITH THE RECYCLING
00:46:32.556 --> 00:46:33.690
CRISIS IS GOING TO BE A TOP.
00:46:33.757 --> 00:46:35.025
PRIORITY FOR THIS COMMITTEE AND
00:46:35.092 --> 00:46:36.393
FOR MANY OF OUR MEMBERS AND I
00:46:36.460 --> 00:46:37.861
REALLY APPRECIATE YOUR I'M
00:46:37.928 --> 00:46:39.096
EFFORTS IN THIS AREA ALL THE
00:46:39.163 --> 00:46:40.664
SUPPORTING THE BILL -- WHEN WE
00:46:40.731 --> 00:46:43.033
HAVE A QUORUM?
00:46:43.100 --> 00:46:43.634
THANK YOU VERY MUCH THANK YOU
00:46:43.700 --> 00:46:48.005
VERY MUCH.
00:46:48.071 --> 00:47:05.923
NEXT UP WE HAVE MR HOLDEN WITH
00:47:14.097 --> 00:47:14.164
.
00:47:14.164 --> 00:47:14.698
THIRTEEN TWENTY EIGHT WELCOME
00:47:14.765 --> 00:47:15.899
YOU MAY BEGIN WHEN YOU'RE READY.
00:47:15.966 --> 00:47:17.534
THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR AND
00:47:17.601 --> 00:47:21.038
MEMBERS -- A. B..
00:47:21.104 --> 00:47:21.638
THIRTEEN TWENTY EIGHT AS NOTED
00:47:21.705 --> 00:47:22.973
IN THE COMMITTEE ANALYSIS IS
00:47:23.040 --> 00:47:25.742
VERY SIMILAR BILL. TO MY BILL A.
00:47:25.809 --> 00:47:28.912
B. THREE ONE FORTY SIX FROM LAST
00:47:28.979 --> 00:47:30.714
YEAR WHICH MANY OF YOU VOTED --
00:47:30.781 --> 00:47:32.416
TO SUPPORT.
00:47:32.482 --> 00:47:33.784
THERE ARE TENS OF THOUSANDS OF
00:47:33.850 --> 00:47:35.919
OLD AND POTENTIALLY LEAKING OIL
00:47:35.986 --> 00:47:38.822
AND GAS WELLS IN CALIFORNIA.
00:47:38.889 --> 00:47:40.190
SOME OF THESE SITES ARE IDLE
00:47:40.257 --> 00:47:41.258
DESERTED.
00:47:41.325 --> 00:47:42.025
HAZARDOUS.
00:47:42.092 --> 00:47:45.529
AND THOSE ARE THE FOCUS OF THIS
00:47:45.596 --> 00:47:47.231
BILL.
00:47:47.297 --> 00:47:49.066
LIKE ACTIVE PRODUCTION SITES
00:47:49.132 --> 00:47:50.867
IDLE DESERTED AND HAZARDOUS OIL
00:47:50.934 --> 00:47:53.937
AND GAS WELLS CAN LEAK POLLUTION.
00:47:54.004 --> 00:47:55.772
FOR EXAMPLE IN TWO THOUSAND
00:47:55.839 --> 00:47:57.107
SIXTEEN APPEAR OF IDLE OIL AND
00:47:57.174 --> 00:47:58.242
GAS WELLS WERE FOUND LEAKING
00:47:58.308 --> 00:47:59.910
HAZARDOUS LEVELS OF GAS IN THE
00:47:59.977 --> 00:48:01.778
ECHO PARK NEIGHBORHOOD OF LOS
00:48:01.845 --> 00:48:02.646
ANGELES.
00:48:02.713 --> 00:48:04.281
LESS THAN A HUNDRED FEET FROM
00:48:04.348 --> 00:48:05.649
NEARBY RESIDENTS.
00:48:05.716 --> 00:48:07.751
IN ADDITION EARLIER THIS YEAR
00:48:07.818 --> 00:48:08.619
AND OIL.
00:48:08.685 --> 00:48:10.854
OLD OIL WELL IN MARINA DEL REY
00:48:10.921 --> 00:48:12.889
EXPERIENCE RELEASE DURING
00:48:12.956 --> 00:48:14.424
REMEDIATION WORK.
00:48:14.491 --> 00:48:15.659
POTENTIAL EMISSIONS FROM IDA
00:48:15.726 --> 00:48:18.328
WELLS INCLUDE METHANE ADVANCING.
00:48:18.395 --> 00:48:20.397
METHANE IS A CLIMATE CHANGE GAS
00:48:20.464 --> 00:48:21.965
MANY TIMES MORE POWERFUL THAN
00:48:22.032 --> 00:48:23.900
CARBON DIOXIDE.
00:48:23.967 --> 00:48:25.902
WHILE OTHER CO ADMITTED YOUR
00:48:25.969 --> 00:48:27.537
POLLUTANTS LIKE BENZENE CAN
00:48:27.604 --> 00:48:29.239
CAUSE CANCER.
00:48:29.306 --> 00:48:31.041
AB THIRTEEN TWENTY EIGHT WOULD
00:48:31.108 --> 00:48:32.542
MAKE THIS INFORMATION ON LEAKS
00:48:32.609 --> 00:48:33.844
PUBLICLY AVAILABLE.
00:48:33.910 --> 00:48:35.412
CREATING A BODY OF INFORMATION
00:48:35.479 --> 00:48:37.314
THAT IS IMPORTANT. TO KNOW IN
00:48:37.381 --> 00:48:39.349
THE SIZE AND SCOPE OF THE
00:48:39.416 --> 00:48:41.018
EMISSIONS FROM IDLE AND DESERTED
00:48:41.084 --> 00:48:42.286
WELLS.
00:48:42.352 --> 00:48:43.687
INFORMATION COLLECTED UNDER A.
00:48:43.754 --> 00:48:45.289
B. THIRTEEN TWENTY EIGHT CAN BE
00:48:45.355 --> 00:48:46.123
USED TO CREATE A BETTER
00:48:46.189 --> 00:48:47.557
UNDERSTANDING OF THE EMISSIONS
00:48:47.624 --> 00:48:49.826
FROM ALL OF CALIFORNIA'S OIL AND
00:48:49.893 --> 00:48:51.028
GAS WELLS.
00:48:51.094 --> 00:48:53.764
LESLIE AB THIRTEEN TWENTY EIGHT
00:48:53.830 --> 00:48:54.798
WOULD ALSO REQUIRE DAGR TO
00:48:54.865 --> 00:48:56.366
PERFORMERS VIEW OF THE
00:48:56.433 --> 00:48:58.835
EFFECTIVENESS OF WELL PLUGIN
00:48:58.902 --> 00:49:00.437
OPERATIONS TO ELIMINATE ERA
00:49:00.504 --> 00:49:01.538
MISSIONS.
00:49:01.605 --> 00:49:03.640
AND CLOSING IDLE AND DESERTED
00:49:03.707 --> 00:49:05.909
WELLS CAN AND DO LEAK.
00:49:05.976 --> 00:49:08.111
AND WHEN THEY DO IT CAN RESULT
00:49:08.178 --> 00:49:09.813
IN EMISSIONS THAT CONTRIBUTE TO
00:49:09.880 --> 00:49:12.549
CLIMATE CHANGE.
00:49:12.616 --> 00:49:13.083
THAT ENDANGER THE PUBLIC'S
00:49:13.150 --> 00:49:13.617
HEALTH.
00:49:13.684 --> 00:49:15.118
AB THIRTEEN TWENTY EIGHT SIX TO
00:49:15.185 --> 00:49:16.920
ADDRESS THIS ISSUE AT A LOW COST
00:49:16.987 --> 00:49:19.723
BY REQUIRING THE DATA ALREADY
00:49:19.790 --> 00:49:21.224
COLLECTED BE MADE PUBLIC.
00:49:21.291 --> 00:49:23.527
I HAVE WITH ME LARA NAVARRO FROM
00:49:23.593 --> 00:49:24.895
ENVIRONMENTAL DEFENSE FUND TO
00:49:24.961 --> 00:49:25.996
DISCUSS THE IMPORTANCE OF THE
00:49:26.063 --> 00:49:28.031
LEGISLATION AND I RESPECTFULLY
00:49:28.098 --> 00:49:29.733
ASK FOR DR.
00:49:29.800 --> 00:49:30.901
I GOOD AFTERNOON MY NAME IS
00:49:30.967 --> 00:49:32.769
LAUREN OF OUR I'M HERE WITH
00:49:32.836 --> 00:49:34.938
ENVIRONMENTAL DEFENSE FUND -- I
00:49:35.005 --> 00:49:36.273
WOULD ECHO MANY OF THE ASSEMBLY
00:49:36.340 --> 00:49:38.275
MEN'S POINTS AT CALIFORNIA'S
00:49:38.342 --> 00:49:40.510
HOME TO TENS OF THOUSANDS OF
00:49:40.577 --> 00:49:42.212
ABANDONED AND IDA WELLS. FOR
00:49:42.279 --> 00:49:44.047
EXAMPLE THE LA BASIN IS HOME TO
00:49:44.114 --> 00:49:46.917
OVER SEVENTY OIL FIELDS ME THAT
00:49:46.983 --> 00:49:49.453
A BANDED WELLS UNDERLIE MANY
00:49:49.519 --> 00:49:50.921
HOMES AND BUSINESSES.
00:49:50.987 --> 00:49:52.122
WHEN THESE WELLS HAVE NOT BEEN
00:49:52.189 --> 00:49:54.024
PROPERLY SEALED THEY PRESENT A
00:49:54.091 --> 00:49:56.393
SERIES EXPLOSION HEALTH RISK TO
00:49:56.460 --> 00:49:58.295
BOTH HOME -- HOMEOWNERS AND
00:49:58.362 --> 00:50:00.664
RESIDENTS AND ALSO TO WORKERS IN
00:50:00.731 --> 00:50:01.631
THE BUSINESSES.
00:50:01.698 --> 00:50:03.333
SYSTEMATICALLY EXAMINING WHICH
00:50:03.400 --> 00:50:04.735
WELLS ARE LEAKING AND WHAT THE
00:50:04.801 --> 00:50:06.636
FACTORS ARE THAT ARE LIKELY TO
00:50:06.703 --> 00:50:08.638
MAKE THEM WEEK CAN HELP US AVOID
00:50:08.705 --> 00:50:10.774
HAZARDS LIKE EXPLOSIONS BEFORE
00:50:10.841 --> 00:50:12.008
THEY HAPPEN.
00:50:12.075 --> 00:50:13.443
ADDITIONALLY METHANE LEAKING
00:50:13.510 --> 00:50:14.411
FROM THESE WELLS IS A
00:50:14.478 --> 00:50:16.480
POTENTIALLY IMPORTANT SOURCE OF
00:50:16.546 --> 00:50:18.615
GLOBAL WARMING EMISSIONS AND CO
00:50:18.682 --> 00:50:20.250
POLLUTANTS LIKE BENZENE WHICH
00:50:20.317 --> 00:50:22.319
HARM AIR QUALITY IN AFFECT HUMAN
00:50:22.386 --> 00:50:24.588
HEALTH -- AND WITHOUT PROPER
00:50:24.654 --> 00:50:28.658
TESTING LIKE CONTEMPLATED IN.
00:50:28.725 --> 00:50:29.292
THIRTEEN TWENTY EIGHT ARE THESE
00:50:29.359 --> 00:50:30.527
LAWS CAN LEAK FOR SIGNIFICANT
00:50:30.594 --> 00:50:34.965
PERIOD OF TIME BEFORE IT'S
00:50:35.031 --> 00:50:36.032
DISCOVERED THAT THEY'RE LEAKING.
00:50:36.099 --> 00:50:37.167
SO WE BELIEVE THE BETTER
00:50:37.234 --> 00:50:38.201
UNDERSTANDING WHICH WELLS ARE
00:50:38.268 --> 00:50:39.269
LIKE ITALY WILL HELP US TRACK
00:50:39.336 --> 00:50:41.271
DOWN AND SEAL MORE LIKELY WELL
00:50:41.338 --> 00:50:42.773
AS IN CALIFORNIA.
00:50:42.839 --> 00:50:45.008
I AB THIRTEEN TWENTY EIGHT WILL
00:50:45.075 --> 00:50:46.777
MAKE THIS POSSIBLE ME VERY MUCH
00:50:46.843 --> 00:50:48.712
THANK ASSEMBLYMAN HOLD AND TO
00:50:48.779 --> 00:50:50.614
BRING IT FOR THE FOR FRONT --
00:50:50.680 --> 00:50:52.616
THE DATA THAT IS NECESSARY IS
00:50:52.682 --> 00:50:54.151
ALREADY BEING COLLECTED BY OIL
00:50:54.217 --> 00:50:56.186
AND GAS COMPANIES -- UNDER
00:50:56.253 --> 00:50:58.121
CURRENT REGULATIONS FOR WELLS
00:50:58.188 --> 00:50:59.222
THAT THEY ARE PLUGGING.
00:50:59.289 --> 00:51:00.557
THIS BILL WILL SIMPLY MAKE IT
00:51:00.624 --> 00:51:02.125
AVAILABLE MAKE THAT DATA
00:51:02.192 --> 00:51:04.060
AVAILABLE TO BOTH REGULATORS AND
00:51:04.127 --> 00:51:06.363
THE PUBLIC WHICH SURPRISINGLY IT
00:51:06.430 --> 00:51:08.999
ISN'T ALREADY -- SO WE ASK FOR
00:51:09.065 --> 00:51:10.967
YOUR AYE VOTE ON THIS BILL THANK
00:51:11.034 --> 00:51:11.768
YOU [inaudible]
00:51:11.835 --> 00:51:15.906
THANK YOU.
00:51:15.972 --> 00:51:16.540
ARE THERE ANY OTHER WITNESSES IN
00:51:16.606 --> 00:51:24.047
SUPPORT.
00:51:24.114 --> 00:51:24.948
GOOD AFTERNOON TURN MEMBERS
00:51:25.015 --> 00:51:26.349
MELISSA ROMERO ON BEHALF OF THE
00:51:26.416 --> 00:51:27.117
CALIFORNIA LEAGUE OF
00:51:27.184 --> 00:51:28.385
CONSERVATION VOTERS IN SUPPORT
00:51:28.452 --> 00:51:33.123
OF THE BILL.
00:51:33.190 --> 00:51:34.958
ROCKY RESCUED COALITION FOR
00:51:35.025 --> 00:51:35.592
CLEAN AIR IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL
00:51:35.659 --> 00:51:38.628
THANK YOU.
00:51:38.695 --> 00:51:40.430
QUITE A MEET ON A WITHOUT UPON
00:51:40.497 --> 00:51:42.933
CALIFORNIANS SUPPORT.
00:51:42.999 --> 00:51:43.934
THERESA PROHIBITS ON BEHALF OF
00:51:44.000 --> 00:51:45.535
THE CLEAN SEIZE LOVING COALITION
00:51:45.602 --> 00:51:48.004
IN SUPPORT.
00:51:48.071 --> 00:51:49.873
LAUREN COMMON BEHALF OF SIERRA
00:51:49.940 --> 00:51:52.042
CLUB CALIFORNIANS SUPPORT.
00:51:52.108 --> 00:51:53.510
I WILL BEAR WITH THE AMERICAN
00:51:53.577 --> 00:51:55.178
LUNG ASSOCIATION ALSO IN SUPPORT.
00:51:55.245 --> 00:51:56.813
THANK YOU WAS THERE ANYONE TO
00:51:56.880 --> 00:51:57.380
TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION TO THE
00:51:57.447 --> 00:52:08.859
BILL.
00:52:08.925 --> 00:52:09.893
GOOD AFTERNOON MADAM CHAIR
00:52:09.960 --> 00:52:10.760
MEMBERS THREE CENTERS WITH THE
00:52:10.827 --> 00:52:11.628
WESTERN STATES PETROLEUM
00:52:11.695 --> 00:52:13.363
ASSOCIATION WE CURRENTLY HAVE AN
00:52:13.430 --> 00:52:15.298
OPPOSE UNLESS AMENDED POSITION
00:52:15.365 --> 00:52:16.433
QUITE DIFFERENT THAN WHERE WE
00:52:16.500 --> 00:52:18.068
WERE HERE LAST YEAR APPRECIATE
00:52:18.134 --> 00:52:20.136
THE AUTHOR'S COMMITMENT.
00:52:20.203 --> 00:52:21.738
ON THIS ISSUE ALONG WITH STAFF --
00:52:21.805 --> 00:52:22.873
YOU KNOW WE CURRENTLY BELIEVE
00:52:22.939 --> 00:52:24.040
THAT THERE'S A ROBUST -- A
00:52:24.107 --> 00:52:26.109
RUBRIC FOR IN A LEAK DETECTION
00:52:26.176 --> 00:52:27.978
REPAIR PROGRAMS OUT WE ALSO
00:52:28.044 --> 00:52:29.479
BELIEVE THAT THE SNAP PROGRAM IS
00:52:29.546 --> 00:52:30.447
ALSO GOING TO PROVIDE A LOT OF
00:52:30.514 --> 00:52:32.048
SOME OF THE INFORMATION THAT THE
00:52:32.115 --> 00:52:33.383
AUTHOR IN THE SPONSOR SEEK.
00:52:33.450 --> 00:52:34.751
HOWEVER YOU KNOW WE ARE
00:52:34.818 --> 00:52:36.753
COMMITTED TO WORKING AGAIN WITH
00:52:36.820 --> 00:52:40.924
THE AUTHOR -- AND AND AND STAFF.
00:52:40.991 --> 00:52:41.958
TO TO OBVIOUSLY WE'VE SHARED
00:52:42.025 --> 00:52:43.193
LANGUAGE WE HOPE TO CONTINUE A
00:52:43.260 --> 00:52:45.028
DIALOGUE TO TRY TO YOU KNOW
00:52:45.095 --> 00:52:46.196
MAYBE REMEDIATE SO THE
00:52:46.263 --> 00:52:47.664
COMPLIANCE ISSUES THAT WE HAVE
00:52:47.731 --> 00:52:49.299
REDUCE COSTS BUT ALSO MAKE IT
00:52:49.366 --> 00:52:51.868
MORE EFFICIENT -- AS AND AS IT
00:52:51.935 --> 00:52:52.702
RELATES THE DATA THAT THE TRYING
00:52:52.769 --> 00:52:54.237
TO ACCOMPLISH SO FOR THESE
00:52:54.304 --> 00:52:55.505
REASONS YOU KNOW WE HAVE AN
00:52:55.572 --> 00:52:56.139
OPPOSEUNLESS SOMEBODY POSITION
00:52:56.206 --> 00:52:57.607
BY YOU KNOW WOULD LIKE TO
00:52:57.674 --> 00:53:01.244
CONTINUE THE DIALOGUE TO THANK
00:53:01.311 --> 00:53:01.411
YOU.
00:53:01.478 --> 00:53:03.914
THANK YOU.
00:53:03.980 --> 00:53:05.115
GOOD AFTERNOON MADAM CHAIR AND
00:53:05.181 --> 00:53:05.649
MEMBERS P. ANTHONY THOMAS
00:53:05.715 --> 00:53:06.182
WRITTEN IN THE CALIFORNIA
00:53:06.249 --> 00:53:07.384
INDEPENDENT PETROLEUM
00:53:07.450 --> 00:53:09.786
ASSOCIATION OR STEP UP -- JUST
00:53:09.853 --> 00:53:13.023
THE RESPONSE TO THE RESPOND TO
00:53:13.089 --> 00:53:14.090
THE BETTER UNDERSTANDING
00:53:14.157 --> 00:53:16.960
STATEMENT THAT THE PROPONENTS
00:53:17.027 --> 00:53:17.961
MAY.
00:53:18.028 --> 00:53:19.095
WE SHOULD WE SHOULD.
00:53:19.162 --> 00:53:20.597
KNOW THAT THERE IS A QUALITY
00:53:20.664 --> 00:53:23.300
INSPECTION REQUIREMENT BY A. R.
00:53:23.366 --> 00:53:26.803
B. TO QUANTIFY -- ANY LEAKS --
00:53:26.870 --> 00:53:28.505
BUT THE TESTING DEVICE CALLED AN
00:53:28.572 --> 00:53:30.473
EAGLE ON THAT DOES MEASURE TO
00:53:30.540 --> 00:53:33.009
FLOW THE PPM -- THE LAB GIVES
00:53:33.076 --> 00:53:35.679
YOU FULL CONCENTRATION SO LET'S
00:53:35.745 --> 00:53:37.547
BE CLEAR THAT THERE IS WORK
00:53:37.614 --> 00:53:39.049
BEING DONE IN THIS AREA.
00:53:39.115 --> 00:53:41.384
AND FOR THE STATEMENT TO AT
00:53:41.451 --> 00:53:43.153
LEAST BE SOMEONE INTERPRETED
00:53:43.219 --> 00:53:45.488
THAT IT ISN'T IT IS -- AGAIN WE
00:53:45.555 --> 00:53:47.023
FUNCTION ON THE SOME OF THE MOST
00:53:47.090 --> 00:53:47.924
STRICT.
00:53:47.991 --> 00:53:49.392
RULES AND REGULATIONS IN THE
00:53:49.459 --> 00:53:51.595
NATION IF NOT THE WORLD'S SOLE
00:53:51.661 --> 00:53:54.864
WHILE -- LEAKS ARE CONCERNED BOB
00:53:54.931 --> 00:53:56.666
IDLE AND BAND WELLS ARE
00:53:56.733 --> 00:53:58.835
CONCERNED THERE STILL ASSETS AND
00:53:58.902 --> 00:54:00.036
WE BELIEVE THAT THERE ARE
00:54:00.103 --> 00:54:02.272
FUNCTIONS AND POLICIES IN PLACE
00:54:02.339 --> 00:54:04.107
TO ADDRESS IT -- I WILL JOIN
00:54:04.174 --> 00:54:06.009
WITH MY COUNTERPART FROM WESTERN
00:54:06.076 --> 00:54:07.410
STATES TO SAY THAT WE TRYING TO
00:54:07.477 --> 00:54:08.278
DO OUR BEST TO BURKE WITH THE
00:54:08.345 --> 00:54:10.246
MEMBER -- BUT AT THE SAME TIME I
00:54:10.313 --> 00:54:12.182
AS WE GO FORWARD THAT SHOULD BE
00:54:12.248 --> 00:54:13.350
NOTED IN PLACE ON THE RECORD
00:54:13.416 --> 00:54:14.851
THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR.
00:54:14.918 --> 00:54:19.990
THANK YOU IS THERE ANYBODY ELSE
00:54:20.056 --> 00:54:20.624
TO TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION TO THE
00:54:20.690 --> 00:54:21.491
BILL.
00:54:21.558 --> 00:54:22.892
SEEING NONE IS THERE ANY
00:54:22.959 --> 00:54:23.493
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS FROM THE
00:54:23.560 --> 00:54:27.063
COMMITTEE.
00:54:27.130 --> 00:54:28.031
YES SOME MEMBER.
00:54:28.098 --> 00:54:29.332
ED IS IT YOUR INTENTION TO
00:54:29.399 --> 00:54:31.401
CONTINUE TO WORK WITH ALL
00:54:31.468 --> 00:54:33.603
PARTIES AS WE WE CAME THROUGH
00:54:33.670 --> 00:54:35.405
YOUR IT WILL LAST YEAR AS YOU
00:54:35.472 --> 00:54:36.773
CALL IN -- I DON'T THINK IT WAS
00:54:36.840 --> 00:54:38.041
OUTCOME YOU WANT WHEN WE FINALLY
00:54:38.108 --> 00:54:40.910
GOT TO THE FINISH LINE.
00:54:40.977 --> 00:54:42.712
SO I'M THINKING YOU'LL.
00:54:42.779 --> 00:54:45.482
WE WE WE WERE -- FULLY ENGAGED
00:54:45.548 --> 00:54:46.716
AT THE START OF THE PROCESS I
00:54:46.783 --> 00:54:48.084
THINK WE'VE BEEN INITIATED THE
00:54:48.151 --> 00:54:50.020
THE INITIAL CONTACT AS THEY COME
00:54:50.086 --> 00:54:51.888
ON AND LET'S TALK ABOUT THE BILL --
00:54:51.955 --> 00:54:53.690
WE'VE DONE THE SAME THIS YEAR --
00:54:53.757 --> 00:54:56.059
WILL CONTINUE -- TO WE'VE WE ARE
00:54:56.126 --> 00:54:58.962
IN RECEIPT OF OF THE PROPOSED
00:54:59.029 --> 00:55:00.330
AMENDMENTS WERE TAKE A LOOK AT
00:55:00.397 --> 00:55:01.731
THEM AND WILL WORK WITH THEM AS
00:55:01.798 --> 00:55:04.334
BEST WE CAN AND I THINK WE CAN
00:55:04.401 --> 00:55:06.469
PROBABLY GET THERE.
00:55:06.536 --> 00:55:07.404
THANK YOU -- I AM PLEASED TO BE
00:55:07.470 --> 00:55:09.172
SUPPORTING YOUR BILL TODAY WHEN
00:55:09.239 --> 00:55:10.640
WE HAVE FOR THE MEMBERS HERE.
00:55:10.707 --> 00:55:12.242
WE'LL TAKE UP FOR A VOTE TO ANY
00:55:12.308 --> 00:55:14.010
CLOSING STATEMENTS.
00:55:14.077 --> 00:55:15.412
ARE RESPECTED US.
00:55:15.478 --> 00:55:17.580
OKAY THANK YOU VERY MUCH THANK
00:55:17.647 --> 00:55:18.581
YOU.
00:55:18.648 --> 00:55:22.318
IS IT OKAY TO SAY AGAIN.
00:55:22.385 --> 00:55:25.055
BOB THIS IS A OKAY NEXT WE HAVE
00:55:25.121 --> 00:55:35.231
ASSEMBLY MEMBER WICKS WITH
00:55:35.298 --> 00:55:35.532
[inaudible]
00:55:35.598 --> 00:55:41.371
EIGHT THIRTY SIX OKAY.
00:55:41.438 --> 00:55:41.938
AND YOU CAN PROCEED WHENEVER
00:55:42.005 --> 00:55:45.008
YOU'RE READY.
00:55:45.075 --> 00:55:46.743
THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR AND
00:55:46.810 --> 00:55:48.411
MEMBERS I WANT TO THANK THE
00:55:48.478 --> 00:55:50.080
COMMITTEE FOR THEIR WORK AND
00:55:50.146 --> 00:55:51.414
ASSISTANCE AND I ACCEPT THE
00:55:51.481 --> 00:55:53.416
COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS.
00:55:53.483 --> 00:55:54.718
WILD FIRES IN RECENT YEARS HAVE
00:55:54.784 --> 00:55:57.353
BEEN DEVASTATING TO OUR STATE.
00:55:57.420 --> 00:55:59.289
IN ADDITION TO BURNING OVER ONE
00:55:59.355 --> 00:56:00.857
POINT FIVE MILLION ACRES OF LAND
00:56:00.924 --> 00:56:02.525
RECENT WILD FIRES IN TWENTY
00:56:02.592 --> 00:56:03.860
SEVENTEEN AND EIGHTEEN HAVE ALSO
00:56:03.927 --> 00:56:04.427
DEMONSTRATE HOW THEY HAVE
00:56:04.494 --> 00:56:05.361
IMPACTS.
00:56:05.428 --> 00:56:06.362
IN THE AIR QUALITY FOR RESIDENTS
00:56:06.429 --> 00:56:08.531
WHO LIVE HUNDREDS OF MILES AWAY
00:56:08.598 --> 00:56:10.266
FROM THE BURN AREAS.
00:56:10.333 --> 00:56:11.935
THE TOXIC AIR.
00:56:12.001 --> 00:56:13.369
CONTAINS ELEVATED LEVELS OF WOOD
00:56:13.436 --> 00:56:14.904
SMOKE AND CONTAMINANTS FROM BIRD
00:56:14.971 --> 00:56:16.473
STRUCTURES VEHICLES AND CONSUMER
00:56:16.539 --> 00:56:17.507
PRODUCTS.
00:56:17.574 --> 00:56:18.908
THIS CONTAMINATED AIR CAUSES
00:56:18.975 --> 00:56:20.710
PUBLIC HEALTH ISSUES AS A
00:56:20.777 --> 00:56:21.811
CONTROL THE LENGTH OF THE STATE
00:56:21.878 --> 00:56:22.812
IN BECAUSE NEGATIVE HEALTH
00:56:22.879 --> 00:56:24.047
IMPACTS TO ARE VULNERABLE
00:56:24.114 --> 00:56:26.015
POPULATIONS CHILDREN ELDERLY AND
00:56:26.082 --> 00:56:29.219
INDIVIDUALS WITH EXISTING ROBERT
00:56:29.285 --> 00:56:30.153
REST RESPIRATORY PROBLEMS. FOR
00:56:30.220 --> 00:56:31.721
EXAMPLE DURING LAST YEAR'S
00:56:31.788 --> 00:56:33.556
CAMPFIRE THE BAY AREA AND AREAS
00:56:33.623 --> 00:56:34.624
IN NORTHERN CALIFORNIA
00:56:34.691 --> 00:56:36.259
EXPERIENCED THE WORST AIR
00:56:36.326 --> 00:56:37.594
QUALITY.
00:56:37.660 --> 00:56:39.395
THE SMOKE FROM THE FIRE DROP THE
00:56:39.462 --> 00:56:41.297
AIR QUALITY IN CALIFORNIA TO THE
00:56:41.364 --> 00:56:42.732
WORST IN THE WORLD.
00:56:42.799 --> 00:56:43.600
AND PROMPTED MOST SCHOOL
00:56:43.666 --> 00:56:45.401
DISTRICTS AND UNIVERSITIES TO
00:56:45.468 --> 00:56:46.803
CLOSE THEIR CAMPUSES.
00:56:46.870 --> 00:56:47.904
DURING THAT TIME THE AIR QUALITY
00:56:47.971 --> 00:56:49.873
INDEX LEVELS WERE OVER TWO
00:56:49.939 --> 00:56:50.774
HUNDRED AND MANY REGIONS SUCH AS
00:56:50.840 --> 00:56:52.342
THE BEAR EXPERT EXPERIENCE POOR
00:56:52.408 --> 00:56:54.177
AIR QUALITY. FOR ALMOST TWO
00:56:54.244 --> 00:56:55.712
WEEKS.
00:56:55.779 --> 00:56:57.180
I THINK YOU KNOW MY DAD FIGHTS
00:56:57.247 --> 00:56:58.882
WILDFIRES IS ENOUGH FOR THIRTY
00:56:58.948 --> 00:56:59.783
FIVE YEARS SO IT'S SOMETHING I'M
00:56:59.849 --> 00:57:02.585
VERY USED -- TO IN OUR
00:57:02.652 --> 00:57:03.153
COMMUNITIES IN THIS HEARING
00:57:03.219 --> 00:57:04.521
ABOUT US BUT THE SAD REALITY IS
00:57:04.587 --> 00:57:05.755
I THINK THAT WE HAVE TO PREPARE
00:57:05.822 --> 00:57:07.690
THAT THIS IS OUR NEW NORMAL.
00:57:07.757 --> 00:57:08.324
GIVEN THE CHALLENGES THAT WERE
00:57:08.391 --> 00:57:10.193
SAYING -- WITH WILDFIRES AND I
00:57:10.260 --> 00:57:11.728
THINK WE HAVE TO MAKE SURE THAT
00:57:11.795 --> 00:57:13.296
WE ARE PREPARED TO HANDLE THIS.
00:57:13.363 --> 00:57:14.931
BEING OUR NEW NORMAL.
00:57:14.998 --> 00:57:16.733
AB EIGHT THREE SIX WILL CREATE A
00:57:16.800 --> 00:57:18.168
STATEWIDE PROGRAM THAT WOULD
00:57:18.234 --> 00:57:20.370
IDENTIFY VENTILATION SPACES
00:57:20.436 --> 00:57:20.904
WHICH WERE CALLING CLEANER
00:57:20.970 --> 00:57:22.172
CENTERS.
00:57:22.238 --> 00:57:23.807
THESE ARE PUBLIC OF PUBLIC
00:57:23.873 --> 00:57:25.141
CENTERS LIKE SCHOOLS SENIOR
00:57:25.208 --> 00:57:28.011
CENTERS -- LIBRARIES PLACES
00:57:28.077 --> 00:57:29.546
WHERE PEOPLE CONGREGATE -- THAT
00:57:29.612 --> 00:57:30.413
WOULD BE ACCESSIBLE TO THE
00:57:30.480 --> 00:57:31.714
PUBLIC AND STUBBLE XIN INCENTIVE
00:57:31.781 --> 00:57:33.116
PROGRAM.
00:57:33.183 --> 00:57:35.618
THAT PROVIDES FUNDING. FOR THESE
00:57:35.685 --> 00:57:37.453
FACILITIES TO IMPROVE THEIR L.
00:57:37.520 --> 00:57:39.189
AIR FILTRATION SYSTEM.
00:57:39.255 --> 00:57:40.290
AND LIVING IN THE BAY AREA IN
00:57:40.356 --> 00:57:41.591
THE EAST BAY MANY OF US DON'T
00:57:41.658 --> 00:57:43.193
HAVE AIR CONDITIONERS.
00:57:43.259 --> 00:57:44.727
SO IF YOU'RE AT HOME YOU HAVE NO
00:57:44.794 --> 00:57:46.095
AIR CONDITIONER A LOT OF THE
00:57:46.162 --> 00:57:47.163
BUILDINGS DON'T HAVE THAT YOU
00:57:47.230 --> 00:57:48.631
HAVE LITERALLY NO WHERE TO GO
00:57:48.698 --> 00:57:50.567
WHEN THESE -- TERRIBLE AIR
00:57:50.633 --> 00:57:51.668
QUALITY DAYS COME UP SO THAT'S
00:57:51.734 --> 00:57:53.937
THE PURPOSE OF THE BILL I WANT
00:57:54.003 --> 00:57:54.537
TO THANK THE SPONSORS THE BAY
00:57:54.604 --> 00:57:56.339
AREA AIR QUALITY MANAGEMENT
00:57:56.406 --> 00:57:57.440
DISTRICT FOR THEIR SUPPORT THIS
00:57:57.507 --> 00:57:59.108
LEGISLATION.
00:57:59.175 --> 00:58:00.410
AND INTRODUCE OUR WITNESSES
00:58:00.476 --> 00:58:04.080
ALLEN APES AND WILL BARNET.
00:58:04.147 --> 00:58:05.348
SORRY BARRETT.
00:58:05.415 --> 00:58:09.052
AND I RESPECT TO RESPECTFULLY
00:58:09.118 --> 00:58:11.387
ASK FOR A VOTE THANK YOU.
00:58:11.454 --> 00:58:12.021
THANK YOU CHAIR FREEMEN MEMBERS
00:58:12.088 --> 00:58:12.856
OF THE COMMITTEE MY NAME IS ALAN
00:58:12.922 --> 00:58:13.957
ABS I'M WITH THE BAY AREA AIR
00:58:14.023 --> 00:58:15.458
QUALITY MANAGEMENT DISTRICT I'D
00:58:15.525 --> 00:58:16.693
LIKE TO THANK ASSEMBLY MEMBER
00:58:16.759 --> 00:58:18.595
WICKS FOR INTRODUCING THIS BILL
00:58:18.661 --> 00:58:19.929
AND FOR OPENING COMMENTS.
00:58:19.996 --> 00:58:21.164
AT THE STATE HAS EMBARKED ON A
00:58:21.231 --> 00:58:22.765
LONG TERM PLAN TO IMPROVE FOREST
00:58:22.832 --> 00:58:23.933
HEALTH BUT WE KNOW THE LARGE
00:58:24.000 --> 00:58:25.902
FOREST FIRES WILL IMPACT US FOR
00:58:25.969 --> 00:58:27.770
THE FORESEEABLE FUTURE. SIXTEEN
00:58:27.837 --> 00:58:29.172
OF THE WORST TWENTY AIR QUALITY
00:58:29.239 --> 00:58:30.740
DAYS IN BAY AREA HISTORY OF
00:58:30.807 --> 00:58:32.408
OCCURRED IN THE LAST THREE YEARS
00:58:32.475 --> 00:58:34.444
TO THE WILDFIRES -- TO FILL A
00:58:34.510 --> 00:58:36.246
GAP IN OUR PUBLIC HEALTH
00:58:36.312 --> 00:58:37.747
RESPONSE TO THESE EVENTS --
00:58:37.814 --> 00:58:39.148
WE'VE PROPOSED THIS BILL TO
00:58:39.215 --> 00:58:40.717
IDENTIFY PUBLIC SPACES THAT
00:58:40.783 --> 00:58:42.318
CONNECT ACCOMMODATE OUR MOST
00:58:42.385 --> 00:58:44.354
VULNERABLE POPULATIONS CHILDREN
00:58:44.420 --> 00:58:46.289
ELDERLY SOCIO ECONOMICALLY
00:58:46.356 --> 00:58:48.558
DISADVANTAGED AND RESPIRATORY
00:58:48.625 --> 00:58:49.859
EARLY CHALLENGED -- DURING
00:58:49.926 --> 00:58:51.427
WILDFIRE SMOKE EVENTS OR OTHER
00:58:51.494 --> 00:58:52.862
HIGH PARTICULAR EVENTS THIS
00:58:52.929 --> 00:58:54.497
PROGRAM WILL NOT CONSTRUCT NEW
00:58:54.564 --> 00:58:56.199
FACILITIES BUT WOULD PROVIDE
00:58:56.266 --> 00:58:57.634
OPPORTUNITIES FOR EXISTING
00:58:57.700 --> 00:58:59.168
FACILITIES OPEN TO THE PUBLIC TO
00:58:59.235 --> 00:59:01.170
RECEIVE INFRASTRUCTURE UPGRADES
00:59:01.237 --> 00:59:02.906
TO PROVIDE INDOOR VENTILATION
00:59:02.972 --> 00:59:04.007
INFILTRATION.
00:59:04.073 --> 00:59:05.275
ELIGIBLE FACILITIES COULD
00:59:05.341 --> 00:59:06.676
INCLUDE SCHOOLS LIBRARIES
00:59:06.743 --> 00:59:07.877
COMMUNITY SAID SANDERS AND OTHER
00:59:07.944 --> 00:59:09.279
BUILDINGS OPEN TO THE PUBLIC
00:59:09.345 --> 00:59:11.247
USAGE SUBJECT TO THE GUIDELINE
00:59:11.314 --> 00:59:12.715
DEVELOPMENT AS A RESULT OF THIS
00:59:12.782 --> 00:59:13.182
BILL.
00:59:13.249 --> 00:59:14.817
WHEN WE FIRST INTRODUCED THIS
00:59:14.884 --> 00:59:16.819
BILL WE DID -- IT WAS A BAY AREA
00:59:16.886 --> 00:59:18.521
SPECIFIC BILL AND AND WE
00:59:18.588 --> 00:59:20.189
ACKNOWLEDGE THAT -- IN NOT ALL
00:59:20.256 --> 00:59:22.191
CASES OF A BAY AREA SOLUTIONS
00:59:22.258 --> 00:59:24.060
FOR APPLE TO THE REST OF THE
00:59:24.127 --> 00:59:24.861
STATE BUT WE HAVE HEARD THAT
00:59:24.928 --> 00:59:25.528
THERE IS.
00:59:25.595 --> 00:59:27.263
INTEREST IN EXPANSION OF THE
00:59:27.330 --> 00:59:29.098
BILL AND SO -- WITH THAT I WOULD --
00:59:29.165 --> 00:59:32.302
ENCOURAGE YOUR I. BUT WITH THOSE
00:59:32.368 --> 00:59:34.537
AMENDMENTS THANK YOU.
00:59:34.604 --> 00:59:35.405
GOOD AFTERNOON I'M WILL BEAR
00:59:35.471 --> 00:59:36.172
WITH THE AMERICAN LUNG
00:59:36.239 --> 00:59:37.540
ASSOCIATION CALIFORNIA WE
00:59:37.607 --> 00:59:38.741
STRONGLY SUPPORT THIS
00:59:38.808 --> 00:59:40.476
LEGISLATION AS A KEY TOOL TO
00:59:40.543 --> 00:59:41.411
PROTECT PEOPLE FROM GROWING
00:59:41.477 --> 00:59:42.879
IMPACTS OF WILD FIRE SMOKE THE
00:59:42.946 --> 00:59:43.546
CALIFORNIA.
00:59:43.613 --> 00:59:45.248
THE RECENT FIRES HIGHLIGHTED THE
00:59:45.315 --> 00:59:46.649
NEED FOR THESE CLEANER SPACES
00:59:46.716 --> 00:59:47.717
ESPECIALLY FOR THOSE MOST
00:59:47.784 --> 00:59:49.252
VULNERABLE AND UNABLE TO FIND
00:59:49.319 --> 00:59:50.887
RELIEF FROM ON HEALTHIER DURING
00:59:50.954 --> 00:59:52.188
THE WILDFIRES.
00:59:52.255 --> 00:59:53.690
ANYONE EXPOSED TO HIGH LEVELS OF
00:59:53.756 --> 00:59:54.590
PARTICLE POLLUTION IS AT REST
00:59:54.657 --> 00:59:56.159
BUT AS ALLEN NOTED SEVERAL
00:59:56.225 --> 00:59:57.393
GROUPS ARE AT HIGHER RISK
00:59:57.460 --> 00:59:58.561
INCLUDING OUR CHILDREN SENIOR
00:59:58.628 --> 01:00:00.463
CITIZENS THOSE LIVING WITH HEART
01:00:00.530 --> 01:00:01.664
AND LUNG DISEASE AND LOWER
01:00:01.731 --> 01:00:02.932
INCOME RESIDENTS.
01:00:02.999 --> 01:00:04.400
ACCORDING TO EXTENSIVE RESEARCH
01:00:04.467 --> 01:00:05.768
SHORT TERM INCREASES IN PARTICLE
01:00:05.835 --> 01:00:07.870
POLLUTION HAVE BEEN LINKED TO
01:00:07.937 --> 01:00:09.105
DEATH FROM RESPIRATORY AND
01:00:09.172 --> 01:00:10.573
CARDIOVASCULAR CAUSES INCREASED
01:00:10.640 --> 01:00:11.975
HOSPITALIZATIONS AND EMERGENCY
01:00:12.041 --> 01:00:13.042
ROOM VISITS.
01:00:13.109 --> 01:00:16.245
AND THE INCREASED SEVERITY OF
01:00:16.312 --> 01:00:17.480
ASTHMA ATTACKS FACING CHILDREN.
01:00:17.547 --> 01:00:18.047
THE FOURTH NATIONAL CLIMATE
01:00:18.114 --> 01:00:18.781
ASSESSMENT RELEASED LAST YEAR
01:00:18.848 --> 01:00:19.716
NOTED THE CALIFORNIA COULD
01:00:19.782 --> 01:00:21.818
EXPERIENCE A 74% INCREASE AND
01:00:21.884 --> 01:00:24.087
BURNED AREA -- BY THE END OF THE
01:00:24.153 --> 01:00:25.455
CENTURY AND THAT NORTHERN
01:00:25.521 --> 01:00:26.756
CALIFORNIA COULD POTENTIALLY
01:00:26.823 --> 01:00:27.991
FACE A DOUBLING OF THE BURNT
01:00:28.057 --> 01:00:28.891
AREA.
01:00:28.958 --> 01:00:29.792
SO WE KNOW THAT THERE'S A
01:00:29.859 --> 01:00:32.562
GROWING NEED FOR THIS TYPE OF
01:00:32.628 --> 01:00:34.030
RESPONSE TO WILDFIRES THE LUNG
01:00:34.097 --> 01:00:35.398
ASSOCIATION URGES YOU TO SUPPORT
01:00:35.465 --> 01:00:36.733
AB EIGHT THIRTY SIX AS AN
01:00:36.799 --> 01:00:37.900
IMPORTANT TOOL TO PROTECT.
01:00:37.967 --> 01:00:39.535
THE HEALTH OF THE PUBLIC DURING
01:00:39.602 --> 01:00:40.136
THIS GROWING THREAT THANK YOU
01:00:40.203 --> 01:00:41.137
VERY MUCH.
01:00:41.204 --> 01:00:43.606
THANK YOU ARE THERE ANY OTHER
01:00:43.673 --> 01:00:48.544
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL.
01:00:48.611 --> 01:00:49.479
LAUREN CALLING ON BEHALF OF
01:00:49.545 --> 01:00:50.980
SIERRA CLUB CALIFORNIANS SUPPORT
01:00:51.047 --> 01:00:51.781
THIS BILL.
01:00:51.848 --> 01:00:53.649
THANK YOU IS THERE ANYBODY TO
01:00:53.716 --> 01:00:55.718
SPEAK IN OPPOSITION TO THE BILL.
01:00:55.785 --> 01:00:57.253
THANK YOU WITHOUT WILL RETURN TO
01:00:57.320 --> 01:00:58.821
THE COMMITTEE FOR ANY QUESTIONS
01:00:58.888 --> 01:01:01.891
OR COMMENTS.
01:01:01.958 --> 01:01:04.093
SEEING NONE I'D BE HAPPY TO
01:01:04.160 --> 01:01:05.228
SUPPORT YOUR BILL TODAY AND WHEN
01:01:05.294 --> 01:01:07.163
WE GET A QUORUM WILL BE HAVING A
01:01:07.230 --> 01:01:07.663
VOTE ON IT.
01:01:07.730 --> 01:01:09.399
THANK YOU DO YOU WANT TO CLOSE
01:01:09.465 --> 01:01:11.801
OUT JUST ASK YOUR AYE VOTE OKAY
01:01:11.868 --> 01:01:14.003
THANK THEM VERY MUCH
01:01:14.070 --> 01:01:14.303
[inaudible]
01:01:14.370 --> 01:01:14.670
OKAY [inaudible]
01:01:14.737 --> 01:01:16.139
NEXT.
01:01:16.205 --> 01:01:21.277
IS MR TANG HERE.
01:01:21.344 --> 01:01:22.678
MR COOLEY.
01:01:22.745 --> 01:01:27.650
UP MR COOLEY IS COMING UP RIGHT.
01:01:27.717 --> 01:01:45.001
FOUR AB TWO AND
01:01:46.969 --> 01:01:47.203
NINETY SIX GOOD
01:01:47.270 --> 01:01:48.871
AFTERNOON COLLEAGUES.
01:01:48.938 --> 01:01:50.840
IT'S A PLEASURE TO INTRODUCE.
01:01:50.907 --> 01:01:54.177
SPEAKER TODAY BECAUSE FOR IN AB.
01:01:54.243 --> 01:01:56.646
TWO NINETY SIX AND THIS BILL
01:01:56.712 --> 01:01:58.448
ESTABLISHES THE CLIMB INNOVATION
01:01:58.514 --> 01:02:00.450
GRANT PROGRAM WITHIN THE
01:02:00.516 --> 01:02:01.784
STRATEGIC GROWTH COUNSEL.
01:02:01.851 --> 01:02:02.785
INVOLVED WAVE INTRODUCTION THE
01:02:02.852 --> 01:02:04.554
SUBJECT MATTER I WANT TO SAY
01:02:04.620 --> 01:02:06.122
THAT THE I'VE ACTUALLY HAD AN
01:02:06.189 --> 01:02:08.257
INTEREST IN INNOVATION ADVOCACY
01:02:08.324 --> 01:02:10.593
FOR LEAST FIFTEEN YEARS.
01:02:10.660 --> 01:02:12.128
BACK IN TWO THOUSAND THREE I WAS
01:02:12.195 --> 01:02:13.096
FOUNDER OF THE CITY OF RANCHO
01:02:13.162 --> 01:02:15.331
CORDOVA WHICH IS OF COURSE A
01:02:15.398 --> 01:02:16.899
TYPE OF INNOVATION.
01:02:16.966 --> 01:02:19.268
AND I PUT TOGETHER MY THOUGHTS
01:02:19.335 --> 01:02:22.038
ON THE IMPORTANCE OF INNOVATION.
01:02:22.105 --> 01:02:23.873
IN A SPEECH I DID BACK THEN
01:02:23.940 --> 01:02:26.342
WHICH I'VE OFTEN UPDATED.
01:02:26.409 --> 01:02:28.211
BUT SO KEY IDEAS IN THE REALM OF
01:02:28.277 --> 01:02:30.513
INNOVATION.
01:02:30.580 --> 01:02:31.881
A GREAT COMMENT BY HARVEY
01:02:31.948 --> 01:02:33.850
FIRESTONE WHO ONCE SAID.
01:02:33.916 --> 01:02:36.686
THOUGHT NOT MONEY IS THE REAL
01:02:36.752 --> 01:02:38.521
BUSINESS CAPITAL.
01:02:38.588 --> 01:02:39.589
THE ABILITY TO BRING FORWARD A
01:02:39.655 --> 01:02:42.058
NEW IDEA IS OFTEN THE MOST VITAL
01:02:42.125 --> 01:02:43.926
ELEMENT IN ANY.
01:02:43.993 --> 01:02:46.329
HUMAN ENTERPRISE [inaudible]
01:02:46.395 --> 01:02:49.165
MARK TWAIN.
01:02:49.232 --> 01:02:50.433
ALSO WAS A FAVORITE ON
01:02:50.500 --> 01:02:51.834
INNOVATION HE SAYS THE MAN WITH
01:02:51.901 --> 01:02:54.537
A NEW IDEA IS A CRANK.
01:02:54.604 --> 01:02:56.939
UNTIL IT SUCCEEDS.
01:02:57.006 --> 01:02:58.841
IDEAS TEST THE BOUNDARIES OF
01:02:58.908 --> 01:03:00.376
WHAT WE EXPECT.
01:03:00.443 --> 01:03:02.078
AND A LOT OF OUR FUTURE DEPENDS
01:03:02.145 --> 01:03:04.714
UPON IT.
01:03:04.780 --> 01:03:06.482
AND THEN THE LAST COMMENT ON
01:03:06.549 --> 01:03:08.284
INNOVATION JUST AS A PRELUDE TO
01:03:08.351 --> 01:03:09.452
THIS IS THAT.
01:03:09.519 --> 01:03:12.755
ALL GREAT HUMAN ENDEAVOR HAS TO
01:03:12.822 --> 01:03:14.757
EVOLVE THROUGH THREE WORDS
01:03:14.824 --> 01:03:15.057
[inaudible]
01:03:15.124 --> 01:03:16.659
IMPOSSIBLE [inaudible]
01:03:16.726 --> 01:03:17.994
IMPROBABLE [inaudible]
01:03:18.060 --> 01:03:20.796
INEVITABLE.
01:03:20.863 --> 01:03:23.099
AND I FEEL I I AGREE WITH OUR
01:03:23.166 --> 01:03:25.501
GOVERNOR FORMER GOVERNOR WHO.
01:03:25.568 --> 01:03:28.204
NOTICED THE CLIMATE CRISIS IS
01:03:28.271 --> 01:03:29.939
NEXT SUBSTANTIAL.
01:03:30.006 --> 01:03:31.874
ONE AND SO WE ARE IN NEED OF
01:03:31.941 --> 01:03:34.210
OUTSTANDING IDEAS TO PUSH BACK
01:03:34.277 --> 01:03:36.812
THE BOUNDARIES OF WHAT IS KNOWN.
01:03:36.879 --> 01:03:37.446
WHAT PEOPLE THINK IS POSSIBLE?
01:03:37.513 --> 01:03:41.751
ON AB TWO DONE A SEARCH FOR THE
01:03:41.817 --> 01:03:43.119
CLIMB RIVERS GRANT PROGRAM.
01:03:43.186 --> 01:03:44.587
WILL SEEK TO ACCELERATE AND
01:03:44.654 --> 01:03:46.422
SUPPORT THE RESEARCH INVOLVING
01:03:46.489 --> 01:03:47.757
NEW INNOVATIONS.
01:03:47.823 --> 01:03:48.791
THAT IMPROVE ADAPTABILITY
01:03:48.858 --> 01:03:50.793
RESILIENT TO THE IMPACTS OF
01:03:50.860 --> 01:03:51.794
CLIMATE CHANGE.
01:03:51.861 --> 01:03:53.429
I WANT TO SEE THE COMMITTEE HAS
01:03:53.496 --> 01:03:55.598
OFFERED TO SUGGEST A MUCH WHICH
01:03:55.665 --> 01:03:56.832
I AM PLEASED TO ACCEPT.
01:03:56.899 --> 01:03:58.267
I ACTUALLY FEEL THE CHANGE
01:03:58.334 --> 01:04:00.403
PROTECT HER FROM PROMOTE TO
01:04:00.469 --> 01:04:02.104
CONTRIBUTE IS VERY IMPORTANT.
01:04:02.171 --> 01:04:04.240
BECAUSE SOMETIMES THE ROLE OF
01:04:04.307 --> 01:04:05.408
SCIENCE IS NOT TO GIVE YOU A
01:04:05.474 --> 01:04:08.177
WHOLLY NEW IDEA.
01:04:08.244 --> 01:04:09.345
BUT ACTUALLY TO CONTRIBUTE TO
01:04:09.412 --> 01:04:11.080
THE IMPLEMENTATION IDEA BY
01:04:11.147 --> 01:04:12.215
MAKING IT'S A CHEAPER MORE
01:04:12.281 --> 01:04:13.849
FEASIBLE.
01:04:13.916 --> 01:04:18.487
WHAT I REFER TO IS AS OF?
01:04:18.554 --> 01:04:20.156
REDUCING THE RISK.
01:04:20.223 --> 01:04:22.124
OF CHANGE.
01:04:22.191 --> 01:04:24.060
AND SO WE ACTUALLY NEED IDEAS
01:04:24.126 --> 01:04:26.195
NOT JUST THE BIG IDEAS.
01:04:26.262 --> 01:04:27.129
BUT THE ONES THAT MAKE CHANGE
01:04:27.196 --> 01:04:28.698
TOOK LESS RISKY MORE MANAGEABLE
01:04:28.764 --> 01:04:30.333
MORE FEES WHEN I ACTUALLY THINK
01:04:30.399 --> 01:04:31.534
THAT THAT CHANGE.
01:04:31.601 --> 01:04:32.735
KIND OF MOVES MADE THAT
01:04:32.802 --> 01:04:34.604
DIRECTION SO I'M APPRECIATIVE OF
01:04:34.670 --> 01:04:36.239
THAT [inaudible]
01:04:36.305 --> 01:04:37.306
ARM.
01:04:37.373 --> 01:04:38.975
WE KNOW FOR THE FROM LAST
01:04:39.041 --> 01:04:40.309
OCTOBER'S UNITED NATIONS
01:04:40.376 --> 01:04:41.410
INTERGOVERNMENTAL PANEL CLIMATE
01:04:41.477 --> 01:04:43.212
CHANGE.
01:04:43.279 --> 01:04:45.815
THAT WE ARE SEEN CHANGES RELATED
01:04:45.881 --> 01:04:47.283
TO CLIMATE ALL ACROSS THE GLOBE
01:04:47.350 --> 01:04:49.118
THEY ARE LIFE THREATENING.
01:04:49.185 --> 01:04:50.653
AND HERE IN CALIFORNIA ON
01:04:50.720 --> 01:04:52.688
DECEMBER EIGHTEENTH ARE LA --
01:04:52.755 --> 01:04:54.423
ISSUE IN THEIR REPORT ON OUR
01:04:54.490 --> 01:04:55.358
CLIMATE POLICIES.
01:04:55.424 --> 01:04:57.126
SPECIFIC RECOMMENDED THAT THE
01:04:57.193 --> 01:04:59.295
STATE'S SUPPORT INNOVATION.
01:04:59.362 --> 01:05:00.963
AND ADDRESS OTHER IT.
01:05:01.030 --> 01:05:04.000
A MEANS OF SUPPORT ENVIRONMENTAL.
01:05:04.066 --> 01:05:05.701
IMPACTS AND WE KNOW THAT THERE'S
01:05:05.768 --> 01:05:07.470
A WIDE ARRAY OF POLICIES CAN
01:05:07.536 --> 01:05:08.371
AFFECT.
01:05:08.437 --> 01:05:10.006
CLIMATE POLICIES GREENHOUSE
01:05:10.072 --> 01:05:12.241
GRASS REDUCTIONS CO BENEFITS
01:05:12.308 --> 01:05:13.976
DIRECT COSTS INDIRECT BENEFITS
01:05:14.043 --> 01:05:15.278
ECONOMIC TRANSFERS.
01:05:15.344 --> 01:05:16.479
ENERGY THERE THE ROLE OF
01:05:16.545 --> 01:05:18.948
CALIFORNIA ON ALL THESE FRONTS.
01:05:19.015 --> 01:05:21.284
IS A LEADERSHIP ROLE IN ITSELF
01:05:21.350 --> 01:05:22.718
ONE OF INNOVATION.
01:05:22.785 --> 01:05:24.020
FROM TWO THOUSAND EIGHT WHEN
01:05:24.086 --> 01:05:25.254
CARP FIRST PRODUCED ITS
01:05:25.321 --> 01:05:28.090
RECOMMENDATIONS TO TWO THOUSAND
01:05:28.157 --> 01:05:29.392
FOURTEEN MORE RECENTLY AND TO
01:05:29.458 --> 01:05:30.693
TWENTY SEVENTEEN WE KEEP
01:05:30.760 --> 01:05:32.461
CHANGING THE CONVERSATION.
01:05:32.528 --> 01:05:33.996
AND GLOBALLY CALIFORNIA'S LEAD
01:05:34.063 --> 01:05:35.564
IN THAT CONVERSATION AND THIS
01:05:35.631 --> 01:05:37.233
WILL BE A PART OF THAT.
01:05:37.300 --> 01:05:38.467
PROCESS.
01:05:38.534 --> 01:05:39.302
ARM.
01:05:39.368 --> 01:05:40.670
THE BILL PROPOSED THE USE OF A
01:05:40.736 --> 01:05:42.838
COMPETITIVE GRANT PROCESS TOWARD
01:05:42.905 --> 01:05:44.473
MATCHING GRANT FUNDS. FOR
01:05:44.540 --> 01:05:46.075
INNOVATIONS IMPROVE ADAPTABILITY
01:05:46.142 --> 01:05:49.278
AND RESILIENT TO CLIMATE CHANGE.
01:05:49.345 --> 01:05:51.180
IT DOES OFFER A DIFFERENT
01:05:51.247 --> 01:05:53.683
ECONOMIC TOOL THEN JUST BARELY
01:05:53.749 --> 01:05:55.318
GRANTS A PUBLIC FUNDS.
01:05:55.384 --> 01:05:58.788
BUT INVITING PERSONS WHO WISH TO
01:05:58.854 --> 01:06:01.590
OF RESEARCH [inaudible] TO
01:06:01.657 --> 01:06:02.491
PARTNER WITH THE STATE OF
01:06:02.558 --> 01:06:04.460
CALIFORNIA AND THE STRATEGIC
01:06:04.527 --> 01:06:07.029
GROWTH COUNSEL TO FUND THESE
01:06:07.096 --> 01:06:08.631
PROGRAMS.
01:06:08.698 --> 01:06:12.368
AND I ACTUALLY THINK THIS IS.
01:06:12.435 --> 01:06:13.436
IT IS VERY APPROPRIATE FOR
01:06:13.502 --> 01:06:14.904
CALIFORNIA UTILIZE THIS TYPE OF
01:06:14.970 --> 01:06:17.373
TOOL. TO INVITE THE PARTNERSHIP
01:06:17.440 --> 01:06:18.874
OF OTHERS.
01:06:18.941 --> 01:06:21.577
I CAN QUOTE THE ANCIENT AND I
01:06:21.644 --> 01:06:23.679
GUESS WAS FROM THIRTY FOUR
01:06:23.746 --> 01:06:25.047
HUNDRED BC ANCIENT SANSKRIT.
01:06:25.114 --> 01:06:26.315
PROVERB [inaudible]
01:06:26.382 --> 01:06:28.551
THE ENEMY.
01:06:28.617 --> 01:06:31.620
OF MY ENEMY IS MY FRIEND.
01:06:31.687 --> 01:06:33.055
I THINK CALIFORNIA IS ALWAYS A
01:06:33.122 --> 01:06:34.657
STATUS IT IS THE ENEMY OF GLOBAL
01:06:34.724 --> 01:06:35.624
WARMING.
01:06:35.691 --> 01:06:37.493
THAT WANTS TO BE AGGRESSIVE IN
01:06:37.560 --> 01:06:38.661
BATTLING GLOBAL WARMING.
01:06:38.728 --> 01:06:40.863
AND IF THERE ARE.
01:06:40.930 --> 01:06:42.665
INSTITUTIONS OUT THERE THAT WILL
01:06:42.732 --> 01:06:44.367
ASSIST US IN THAT.
01:06:44.433 --> 01:06:45.935
AND ASSIST OUR STATE.
01:06:46.001 --> 01:06:48.137
THEN SURELY THEY ARE OUR FRIEND
01:06:48.204 --> 01:06:49.305
ON THIS TOPIC.
01:06:49.372 --> 01:06:50.740
IN THIS BILL AND BODIES THIS
01:06:50.806 --> 01:06:51.941
IDEA.
01:06:52.007 --> 01:06:53.642
THE PEOPLE WHO LIKE CALIFORNIA
01:06:53.709 --> 01:06:55.144
ONE ABOUT A GLOBAL WARM IF
01:06:55.211 --> 01:06:57.213
THEY'RE WILLING TO PARTNER.
01:06:57.279 --> 01:06:59.081
A WE SHOULD BE OPEN TO THAT.
01:06:59.148 --> 01:07:00.216
COM [inaudible]
01:07:00.282 --> 01:07:01.817
I AM.
01:07:01.884 --> 01:07:04.120
SO THIS BILL DOES NOT CONFLICT
01:07:04.186 --> 01:07:06.021
WITH THE ELECTRIC PROGRAM
01:07:06.088 --> 01:07:07.356
INVESTMENT CHARGE PROGRAM THE
01:07:07.423 --> 01:07:09.692
EPIC CHARGE OR THE GREENHOUSE
01:07:09.759 --> 01:07:11.660
GAS REDUCTION.
01:07:11.727 --> 01:07:13.095
FUND G. G. R. RAF.
01:07:13.162 --> 01:07:14.363
AND I'M DELIGHTED TODAY TO HAVE
01:07:14.430 --> 01:07:17.166
MERRY SELECCIONA AJ W. REPRESENT
01:07:17.233 --> 01:07:19.101
THE LARA INSTITUTE TO TALK ABOUT
01:07:19.168 --> 01:07:20.936
THE ROLE OF FUNDING FOR
01:07:21.003 --> 01:07:21.237
INNOVATION.
01:07:21.303 --> 01:07:23.105
SO MERRY.
01:07:23.172 --> 01:07:23.873
HI THERE CHAIR FRIEDMAN VICE
01:07:23.939 --> 01:07:24.740
CHAIR FULLER APPRECIATE YOUR
01:07:24.807 --> 01:07:26.008
TIME TODAY I JOIN YOU AS A
01:07:26.075 --> 01:07:27.910
REPRESENTATIVE MY NAME IS MERRY
01:07:27.977 --> 01:07:29.912
SO LACKEY HI -- IT AND
01:07:29.979 --> 01:07:31.113
REPRESENTING THE LAR TO
01:07:31.180 --> 01:07:34.583
INSTITUTE IN SUPPORT OF AB TWO
01:07:34.650 --> 01:07:36.051
NINETY SIX LARA IS A LOS ANGELES
01:07:36.118 --> 01:07:38.053
BASED NONPROFIT ORGANIZATION
01:07:38.120 --> 01:07:39.288
WITH THE CORE MISSION OF
01:07:39.355 --> 01:07:42.024
TRANSFORMING IDEAS AND RESEARCH
01:07:42.091 --> 01:07:43.592
INTO MARKET READY PRODUCTS.
01:07:43.659 --> 01:07:46.362
SINCE LURCHES FOUNDING IN
01:07:46.429 --> 01:07:46.929
NINETEEN NINETY THREE BY THE
01:07:46.996 --> 01:07:48.831
STATE OF CALIFORNIA HAS BEEN --
01:07:48.898 --> 01:07:50.866
COMMERCIALIZATION PARTNER TO TOP
01:07:50.933 --> 01:07:53.569
FEDERAL AGENCIES INCLUDING AND I
01:07:53.636 --> 01:07:56.472
H. ANISSA NEST NOAH AND U. S. T.
01:07:56.539 --> 01:07:57.206
A..
01:07:57.273 --> 01:07:59.675
AND HAS ASSISTED OVER SEVEN
01:07:59.742 --> 01:08:02.011
THOUSAND CALIFORNIA COMPANIES
01:08:02.077 --> 01:08:02.578
BRINGING THEIR RESEARCH TO
01:08:02.645 --> 01:08:03.479
MARKET.
01:08:03.546 --> 01:08:05.581
LOTUS WORK IS NASH ON A NATIONAL
01:08:05.648 --> 01:08:10.453
SCALE THE HAS PROFOUND IMPACTS
01:08:10.519 --> 01:08:12.188
ON THE CALIFORNIA ECONOMY.
01:08:12.254 --> 01:08:12.822
LIKE TO SUPPORTIVE OF THIS BILL
01:08:12.888 --> 01:08:14.023
BECAUSE ACROSS THE COUNTRY WE
01:08:14.089 --> 01:08:14.824
SEE IF THE ADDITIONAL PUBLIC
01:08:14.890 --> 01:08:16.992
DOLLARS INVESTED INTO RESEARCH
01:08:17.059 --> 01:08:18.360
YIELDS POSITIVE ECONOMIC
01:08:18.427 --> 01:08:19.695
OUTCOMES.
01:08:19.762 --> 01:08:21.230
WE RECOGNIZE THE BILL AUTHORS
01:08:21.297 --> 01:08:23.132
INTENTIONS TO ADDRESS CLIMATE
01:08:23.199 --> 01:08:25.367
CHANGE BY ALLOCATING RESOURCES
01:08:25.434 --> 01:08:27.603
FOR CLIMATE RELATED RESEARCH WE
01:08:27.670 --> 01:08:29.138
ARE PARTICULARLY EXCITED TO BE
01:08:29.205 --> 01:08:30.873
WORKINGWITH THE AUTHORS OFFICES
01:08:30.940 --> 01:08:32.942
ON THE OPPORTUNITY TO BRIDGE THE
01:08:33.008 --> 01:08:33.576
GAP.
01:08:33.642 --> 01:08:36.078
FROM RESEARCH TO MARKET READY
01:08:36.145 --> 01:08:37.847
PRODUCTS AND SERVICES.
01:08:37.913 --> 01:08:39.215
THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE CAP
01:08:39.281 --> 01:08:41.250
CLIMATE INNOVATION GRANT PROGRAM
01:08:41.317 --> 01:08:42.384
WOULD NOT ONLY ADVANCE
01:08:42.451 --> 01:08:44.053
CALIFORNIA'S CLIMATE GOALS BUT
01:08:44.119 --> 01:08:45.621
WILL BRING POSITIVE ECONOMIC
01:08:45.688 --> 01:08:47.223
GROWTH TO THE STATE TO
01:08:47.289 --> 01:08:48.691
FUNDAMENTAL ELEMENTS THAT
01:08:48.757 --> 01:08:49.959
PARALLEL LOWER TO THE CORE
01:08:50.025 --> 01:08:50.926
MISSION.
01:08:50.993 --> 01:08:52.194
BASED ON WHAT LOWER TO HAS SEEN
01:08:52.261 --> 01:08:53.796
ACROSS THE COUNTRY THIS GRANT
01:08:53.863 --> 01:08:55.965
PROGRAM UTILIZES THE SUCCESSFUL
01:08:56.031 --> 01:08:57.700
MODEL THAT WE SEE ELSEWHERE IN
01:08:57.766 --> 01:08:59.502
THE U. S. WHICH IS LEVERAGING
01:08:59.568 --> 01:09:00.836
MATCHING FUNDS.
01:09:00.903 --> 01:09:02.605
AND THUS COMBINING MANY FUNDING
01:09:02.671 --> 01:09:06.008
SOURCES FOR RESEARCH ESPECIALLY
01:09:06.075 --> 01:09:07.343
PLIED RESEARCH.
01:09:07.409 --> 01:09:08.878
BY WAY OF EXAMPLE COMPANIES LIKE
01:09:08.944 --> 01:09:11.046
MANGO MATERIALS CAN TURN THEIR
01:09:11.113 --> 01:09:12.715
RESEARCH AND TO MARKET READY
01:09:12.781 --> 01:09:14.350
PRODUCTS WITH THE HELP OF
01:09:14.416 --> 01:09:16.352
FEDERAL AND STATE FUNDING
01:09:16.418 --> 01:09:17.987
PROGRAMS AND ACCELERATORS.
01:09:18.053 --> 01:09:19.488
MAKE A MATERIALS IS BASED IN
01:09:19.555 --> 01:09:21.056
BERKELEY AND PRODUCES A BY A
01:09:21.123 --> 01:09:23.759
POLYMER FROM RECYCLED METHANE
01:09:23.826 --> 01:09:25.027
AND CREATES BIOPLASTICS.
01:09:25.094 --> 01:09:26.762
MAKE A MATERIALS WAS STARTED BY
01:09:26.829 --> 01:09:28.330
THREE WOMEN ENGINEERS AND WAS
01:09:28.397 --> 01:09:30.833
AWARDED RESEARCH UNDING BUT
01:09:30.900 --> 01:09:31.433
THEN UTILIZED FULLER TO THE
01:09:31.500 --> 01:09:34.336
TREES SERVICES TO HELP PROPEL
01:09:34.403 --> 01:09:35.170
THEIR PRODUCT INTO THE MARKET.
01:09:35.237 --> 01:09:37.239
LARGE WHO WOULD LIKE TO BE ABLE
01:09:37.306 --> 01:09:38.173
TO PROVIDE SIMILAR SERVICES YOUR
01:09:38.240 --> 01:09:39.074
TIME IS UP SO IF YOU CAN FINISH
01:09:39.141 --> 01:09:39.775
UP.
01:09:39.842 --> 01:09:41.310
ANY STATE FUNDED RESEARCH IN
01:09:41.377 --> 01:09:42.578
CALIFORNIA THANK YOU FOR THE
01:09:42.645 --> 01:09:44.780
OPPORTUNITY AND WE ASK FOR YOUR
01:09:44.847 --> 01:09:47.550
SUPPORT AND AB TWO NINETY SIX
01:09:47.616 --> 01:09:48.751
THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS.
01:09:48.817 --> 01:09:52.154
ANOTHER WHAT ANYONE ELSE WHO
01:09:52.221 --> 01:09:52.755
WANTS TO SPEAK IN FAVOR OF THE
01:09:52.821 --> 01:10:00.829
BILL. FOR CALLING ON BEHALF OF
01:10:00.896 --> 01:10:01.363
SIERRA CLUB CALIFORNIA AND
01:10:01.430 --> 01:10:03.766
SUPPORT.
01:10:03.832 --> 01:10:05.301
NATALIE NEXT ON BEHALF OF
01:10:05.367 --> 01:10:09.405
CALIFORNIA TROUT AND SUPPORT.
01:10:09.471 --> 01:10:10.639
HAVING DORKIN SOME BEHALF A
01:10:10.706 --> 01:10:12.575
SMART IN SUPPORT.
01:10:12.641 --> 01:10:14.109
ADAM ROBIN NORTHERN CALIFORNIA
01:10:14.176 --> 01:10:18.213
WATER ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT.
01:10:18.280 --> 01:10:19.648
IS THERE ANYONE TO SPEAK IN
01:10:19.715 --> 01:10:22.151
OPPOSITION TO THE BILL.
01:10:22.217 --> 01:10:23.352
SIGNAL BRING IT BACK TO THE
01:10:23.419 --> 01:10:23.919
COMMITTEE IF THERE ARE ANY
01:10:23.986 --> 01:10:24.987
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS FROM THE
01:10:25.054 --> 01:10:27.723
COMMITTEE MEMBERS.
01:10:27.790 --> 01:10:29.592
A SEEING YET NONE I WILL BE --
01:10:29.658 --> 01:10:30.626
SUPPORTING YOUR BILL WHEN WE
01:10:30.693 --> 01:10:31.927
HAVE A QUORUM I'M WOULD YOU LIKE
01:10:31.994 --> 01:10:33.495
TO CLOSE.
01:10:33.562 --> 01:10:35.598
AGAIN I WANT TO THANK THE WORK
01:10:35.664 --> 01:10:37.666
DONE BY YOUR COMMITTEE STAFF
01:10:37.733 --> 01:10:39.001
MADAM CHAIR.
01:10:39.068 --> 01:10:43.138
AND I I QUOTED BY OLD SANSKRIT
01:10:43.205 --> 01:10:44.573
PROVERB FULL QUOTE A MORE
01:10:44.640 --> 01:10:46.342
CONTEMPORARY.
01:10:46.408 --> 01:10:48.043
ONE FROM THAT RUSSIA.
01:10:48.110 --> 01:10:49.144
RELATIVELY RECENT LIVED
01:10:49.211 --> 01:10:51.080
INDIVIDUAL BEN FRANKLIN.
01:10:51.146 --> 01:10:52.414
ON THE IMPORTANCE OF NOT
01:10:52.481 --> 01:10:53.682
OVERLOOKING ANYTHING WHICH IS
01:10:53.749 --> 01:10:55.250
WHAT THIS BILL WILL HELP MAKE
01:10:55.317 --> 01:10:57.987
SURE WE DO NOT DO IN CALIFORNIA.
01:10:58.053 --> 01:10:59.254
FOR WANT OF A NAIL THE SHOE WAS
01:10:59.321 --> 01:11:00.990
LOST FOR ONE OF THE SHOE THE
01:11:01.056 --> 01:11:03.158
HORSE WAS LOST FOR WANT OF A
01:11:03.225 --> 01:11:05.294
HORSE THE WRITER WAS LOST. FOR
01:11:05.361 --> 01:11:05.894
ONE OF THE WRITER THE BATTLES
01:11:05.961 --> 01:11:07.830
LOSS FOR ONE OF THE BATTLE THE
01:11:07.896 --> 01:11:09.398
KINGDOM WAS LOST AND ALL FOR
01:11:09.465 --> 01:11:10.866
WANT OF A NAIL.
01:11:10.933 --> 01:11:14.269
I THINK THAT IN THIS ERA OF
01:11:14.336 --> 01:11:15.504
EXISTENTIAL THREATS.
01:11:15.571 --> 01:11:16.171
WHEN LEADERSHIP IS NEEDED AROUND
01:11:16.238 --> 01:11:17.473
THE GLOBE?
01:11:17.539 --> 01:11:18.941
AND OUR STATE IS PROVIDED THAT
01:11:19.008 --> 01:11:21.610
LEADERSHIP IN A DRAMATIC WAY.
01:11:21.677 --> 01:11:23.712
I THINK BEING OPEN TO ANYONE WHO
01:11:23.779 --> 01:11:25.748
HAS AN IDEA THAT THEY CAN MAKE
01:11:25.814 --> 01:11:28.217
THE CASE MAY HELP US DEAL WITH
01:11:28.283 --> 01:11:29.718
GREENHOUSE.
01:11:29.785 --> 01:11:31.253
THE HOUSE GAS PROBLEMS WRITTEN
01:11:31.320 --> 01:11:34.223
LARGE AS SOME RISE LA -- REPORT.
01:11:34.289 --> 01:11:36.191
INCLUDING THAT NEW WANTS OF
01:11:36.258 --> 01:11:38.127
CONTRIBUTING TO CHANGE BY MAKING
01:11:38.193 --> 01:11:39.995
A BIG ASPIRATION LOOK MORE
01:11:40.062 --> 01:11:41.697
MANAGEABLE TO DE RESPECT
01:11:41.764 --> 01:11:43.365
ASPIRATIONS.
01:11:43.432 --> 01:11:44.700
THIS IS A GREAT.
01:11:44.767 --> 01:11:46.001
PUBLIC SERVICE TO CALIFORNIA'S
01:11:46.068 --> 01:11:48.370
BUT INDEED TO THE GLOBE I THINK
01:11:48.437 --> 01:11:50.005
A. B. FITS OUR STATE CHOICES FOR
01:11:50.072 --> 01:11:52.007
QUESTION RIGHT VOTE AND THANK
01:11:52.074 --> 01:11:52.975
YOU FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION
01:11:53.042 --> 01:11:53.275
[inaudible]
01:11:53.342 --> 01:11:55.878
THANK YOU.
01:11:55.944 --> 01:11:59.281
OUR IS MISTER TAYLOR HERE.
01:11:59.348 --> 01:11:59.815
NOT WE'RE MOVING TO MISTER
01:11:59.882 --> 01:12:04.319
MULLIN WITH AB.
01:12:04.386 --> 01:12:04.953
EIGHT THIRTY NINE YOU MAY BEGIN
01:12:05.020 --> 01:12:12.261
WHENEVER YOU'RE READY.
01:12:12.327 --> 01:12:13.128
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
01:12:13.195 --> 01:12:15.631
MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS AB EIGHT
01:12:15.698 --> 01:12:16.465
THIRTY NINE IS A BILL TO MOVE
01:12:16.532 --> 01:12:17.933
CALIFORNIA FORWARD.
01:12:18.000 --> 01:12:19.401
IN OUR EFFORTS TO ADAPT TO THE
01:12:19.468 --> 01:12:21.270
INCREASING RISKS BROUGHT ON BY
01:12:21.336 --> 01:12:22.871
CLIMATE CHANGE.
01:12:22.938 --> 01:12:24.073
THE COURT IN CALIFORNIA'S FOURTH
01:12:24.139 --> 01:12:25.307
CLIMATE ESTIMATE THE ECONOMIC
01:12:25.374 --> 01:12:27.142
COST TO CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATED
01:12:27.209 --> 01:12:29.111
WITH DIRECT CLIMATE IMPACTS BY
01:12:29.178 --> 01:12:30.045
TWENTY FIFTY IS ESTIMATED AT
01:12:30.112 --> 01:12:32.147
OVER ONE HUNDRED BILLION DOLLARS
01:12:32.214 --> 01:12:33.148
EACH YEAR.
01:12:33.215 --> 01:12:34.450
THIS STAGGERING FIGURE IS
01:12:34.516 --> 01:12:36.652
ATTRIBUTABLE. TO DAMAGES TO
01:12:36.719 --> 01:12:38.620
COASTAL PROPERTIES THE POTENTIAL
01:12:38.687 --> 01:12:39.955
FOR DROUGHTS FIRES AND MAKE A
01:12:40.022 --> 01:12:41.690
FLOODS AND ALARMINGLY HUMAN
01:12:41.757 --> 01:12:42.925
MORTALITY.
01:12:42.991 --> 01:12:44.727
CALIFORNIA HAS DONE GREAT WORK
01:12:44.793 --> 01:12:46.428
TO DATE INVESTING IN RESEARCH
01:12:46.495 --> 01:12:47.162
AND DEVELOPING GUIDANCE IN
01:12:47.229 --> 01:12:48.897
PLANNING AS OUTLINED IN THE
01:12:48.964 --> 01:12:50.365
BILL'S ANALYSIS.
01:12:50.432 --> 01:12:52.167
I INTRODUCED AB EIGHT THIRTY
01:12:52.234 --> 01:12:53.068
NINE IN RESPONSE TO THE CALL THE
01:12:53.135 --> 01:12:54.603
MY OFFICE IS HEARD FROM THE
01:12:54.670 --> 01:12:55.938
NUMEROUS ORGANIZATIONS AROUND
01:12:56.004 --> 01:12:57.573
THE STATE THAT ARE IN SUPPORT OF
01:12:57.639 --> 01:12:58.440
THIS BILL.
01:12:58.507 --> 01:12:59.475
THAT WE NEED TO IMPLEMENT MORE
01:12:59.541 --> 01:13:01.910
TEETH TO OUR EXISTING EFFORTS
01:13:01.977 --> 01:13:03.779
SIR TO ACCOMPLISH THAT THE BILL
01:13:03.846 --> 01:13:05.481
DESIGNATES THE SECRETARY OF
01:13:05.547 --> 01:13:07.216
NATURAL RESOURCES. TO LEAD THE
01:13:07.282 --> 01:13:08.884
STATE'S CLIMATE ADAPTATION
01:13:08.951 --> 01:13:10.486
STRATEGY AND TO DEVELOP A
01:13:10.552 --> 01:13:12.688
STRATEGIC RESILIENCY FRAMEWORK
01:13:12.755 --> 01:13:14.323
THAT BILLS ON THE SAFEGUARDING
01:13:14.389 --> 01:13:15.457
CALIFORNIA PLAN.
01:13:15.524 --> 01:13:16.959
CRITICALLY THAT FRAMEWORK WILL
01:13:17.025 --> 01:13:19.528
INCLUDE RECOMMENDED ACTIONS WITH
01:13:19.595 --> 01:13:20.963
TIMETABLES AND METRICS TO
01:13:21.029 --> 01:13:22.431
MEASURE THE STATE'S PROGRESS IN
01:13:22.498 --> 01:13:23.899
BUILDING AND INVESTING IN
01:13:23.966 --> 01:13:25.267
ADAPTATION AND RESILIENCY
01:13:25.334 --> 01:13:27.536
PROJECTS EACH STATE AGENCY
01:13:27.603 --> 01:13:28.804
IDENTIFIED IN THE FRAMEWORK.
01:13:28.871 --> 01:13:30.806
REPORT TO THE SECRETARY ON ITS
01:13:30.873 --> 01:13:32.541
PROGRESS COMPLETELY THE
01:13:32.608 --> 01:13:33.909
RECOMMENDATIONS AND ACTIONS.
01:13:33.976 --> 01:13:35.477
ADDITIONALLY WE WOULD CREATE THE
01:13:35.544 --> 01:13:37.146
ADAPTATION THROUGH RESILIENCY
01:13:37.212 --> 01:13:39.248
ECONOMIC VITALITY IN EQUITY
01:13:39.314 --> 01:13:40.916
ACCOUNT WHERE FUNDS FOR
01:13:40.983 --> 01:13:41.984
ADAPTATION PROJECTS CAN BE
01:13:42.050 --> 01:13:45.554
CONSOLIDATED WE WANT THE NATURAL
01:13:45.621 --> 01:13:46.889
THE DIRECTOR OF STATE PLANNING
01:13:46.955 --> 01:13:48.924
AND RESEARCH. TO DEVELOP GRANTS
01:13:48.991 --> 01:13:50.225
AND INNOVATIVE FINANCING
01:13:50.292 --> 01:13:51.927
MECHANISM SUCH AS LOANS FOR
01:13:51.994 --> 01:13:53.495
EXAMPLE TO IMPLEMENTED THE
01:13:53.562 --> 01:13:55.197
RECOMMENDATIONS AND ACTIONS OF
01:13:55.264 --> 01:13:56.298
THE FRAMEWORK FUNDING THE
01:13:56.365 --> 01:13:58.066
ACCOUNT COULD BE FROM EXISTING
01:13:58.133 --> 01:13:59.568
OR FUTURE BOND DOLLARS.
01:13:59.635 --> 01:14:00.669
ALSO WE'RE NOT CURRENTLY
01:14:00.736 --> 01:14:02.905
ALLOCATING VERY MUCH MONEY FROM
01:14:02.971 --> 01:14:04.606
THE G. G. R. F. TO ADDRESS OUR
01:14:04.673 --> 01:14:06.408
CONSIDERABLE ADAPTATION NEEDS
01:14:06.475 --> 01:14:08.310
BUT PERHAPS IN THE FUTURE WILL
01:14:08.377 --> 01:14:09.344
CONSIDER THAT DIFFERENTLY.
01:14:09.411 --> 01:14:10.879
IN THIS ACCOUNT CAN SERVICE THE
01:14:10.946 --> 01:14:12.881
APPROPRIATE INSTRUMENT TO ENSURE
01:14:12.948 --> 01:14:13.382
THOSE DOLLARS ARE SPENT
01:14:13.448 --> 01:14:14.917
EFFECTIVELY WHERE THAT FUNDING
01:14:14.983 --> 01:14:16.351
WILL COME FROM IS SUBJECT TO
01:14:16.418 --> 01:14:18.587
FUTURE APPROPRIATIONS SO WE WILL
01:14:18.654 --> 01:14:20.122
BE ABLE TO REALLY PINPOINT THOSE
01:14:20.189 --> 01:14:24.126
SOURCES IN FUTURE BUDGET VOTES
01:14:24.193 --> 01:14:26.495
TO SOME RICE I'M CONFIDENT THAT
01:14:26.562 --> 01:14:27.462
THE BILL WILL ENACT A CLEAR.
01:14:27.529 --> 01:14:27.963
CLIMATE.
01:14:28.030 --> 01:14:28.564
ADAPTATION FRAMEWORK TO GUIDE
01:14:28.630 --> 01:14:29.932
THE STATE OVER THE COMING YEARS
01:14:29.998 --> 01:14:31.033
TO ENSURE WE HAVE A THOUGHTFUL
01:14:31.099 --> 01:14:32.701
SET OF GOALS COORDINATED
01:14:32.768 --> 01:14:33.936
GOVERNMENT ACTIONS AND
01:14:34.002 --> 01:14:35.637
INNOVATIVE FUNDING MECHANISMS IN
01:14:35.704 --> 01:14:36.538
PLACE.
01:14:36.605 --> 01:14:37.806
GIVEN THE BREATH COMPLEXITY
01:14:37.873 --> 01:14:39.341
PERVASIVENESS AND DANGER OF
01:14:39.408 --> 01:14:40.475
CLIMATE CHANGE THIS
01:14:40.542 --> 01:14:42.945
ACCOUNTABILITY IS NEEDED AND I
01:14:43.011 --> 01:14:44.713
ASKED FOR THE COMMITTEES SUPPORT.
01:14:44.780 --> 01:14:48.116
THANK YOU YOUR WITNESSES PLEASE.
01:14:48.183 --> 01:14:49.852
BOB GOOD AFTERNOON MADAM CHAIR
01:14:49.918 --> 01:14:50.919
COMMITTEE MEMBERS MY NAME IS
01:14:50.986 --> 01:14:51.687
GEORGE ON AND I'M CHIEF
01:14:51.753 --> 01:14:53.288
SCIENTIST WITH OCEAN CONSERVANCY.
01:14:53.355 --> 01:14:54.790
AND WE WORK FOR FORTY YEARS TO
01:14:54.857 --> 01:14:56.091
ADDRESS SOME OF THE BIGGEST
01:14:56.158 --> 01:14:57.226
THREATS TO OCEAN HEALTH.
01:14:57.292 --> 01:14:59.394
IN THE OCEAN AS ON LAND CLIMATE
01:14:59.461 --> 01:15:01.230
CHANGE IS NOW THE BIGGEST LONG
01:15:01.296 --> 01:15:02.531
TERM THREAT TO THE PLAN ITSELF.
01:15:02.598 --> 01:15:04.032
BUT CLIMATE CHANGE IS ALSO A
01:15:04.099 --> 01:15:06.468
MAJOR THREAT TODAY RIGHT NOW TO
01:15:06.535 --> 01:15:08.637
THE STATE'S PEOPLE PROPERTY
01:15:08.704 --> 01:15:10.072
ECONOMY IS A NATURAL RESOURCES.
01:15:10.138 --> 01:15:11.373
SINCE TWO THOUSAND TWELVE
01:15:11.440 --> 01:15:12.641
CALIFORNIA'S EXPERIENCE SOME OF
01:15:12.708 --> 01:15:14.776
THE MOST EXTREME NATURAL EVENTS
01:15:14.843 --> 01:15:16.378
IN A RECORDED HISTORY OF COURSE
01:15:16.445 --> 01:15:18.347
DROUGHT RAVAGING WILDFIRES BACK
01:15:18.413 --> 01:15:19.815
TO BACK YEARS.
01:15:19.882 --> 01:15:20.315
WITH THE WARMEST AVERAGE
01:15:20.382 --> 01:15:21.817
TEMPERATURES AND IF GREENHOUSE
01:15:21.884 --> 01:15:23.585
GASES AREN'T REDUCED AVERAGE
01:15:23.652 --> 01:15:24.753
TEMPERATURES ACROSS THE STRAIT
01:15:24.820 --> 01:15:26.021
WILL STE OF THE STATE WILL
01:15:26.088 --> 01:15:27.189
LIKELY BE NINE DEGREES
01:15:27.256 --> 01:15:28.790
FAHRENHEIT WARMER.
01:15:28.857 --> 01:15:30.592
IN JUST FIFTY YEARS WITH THE
01:15:30.659 --> 01:15:32.394
SNOW PACK REDUCED BY TWO THIRDS
01:15:32.461 --> 01:15:33.962
SEA LEVEL RISING BY
01:15:34.029 --> 01:15:35.497
APPROXIMATELY FIFTY FOUR INCHES.
01:15:35.564 --> 01:15:38.100
AND HIGH HEAT HEALTH EVENTS THE
01:15:38.166 --> 01:15:40.002
COULD LAST UP TO TWO WEEKS.
01:15:40.068 --> 01:15:41.570
CALIFORNIA'S CAUGHT A FOURTH
01:15:41.637 --> 01:15:42.271
CLIMATE ASSESSMENT AND THE
01:15:42.337 --> 01:15:43.372
STATE'S THEY'VE COURTING
01:15:43.438 --> 01:15:45.107
CALIFORNIA PLAN HAVE HELPED TO
01:15:45.173 --> 01:15:49.177
PREPARE THE STATE BUT MORE WORK
01:15:49.244 --> 01:15:50.379
AS WE'VE HEARD IS NEEDED.
01:15:50.445 --> 01:15:51.713
AB EIGHT THIRTY NINE IS REALLY A
01:15:51.780 --> 01:15:52.514
NEXT PHASE IN CLIMATE ADAPTATION
01:15:52.581 --> 01:15:53.248
FOR THE STATE.
01:15:53.315 --> 01:15:55.083
PROACTIVE ADAPTIVE PLANNING
01:15:55.150 --> 01:15:56.852
ESPECIALLY IN RESPONSE TO
01:15:56.919 --> 01:15:58.320
RAPIDLY DEVELOPED DEL VALLE
01:15:58.387 --> 01:16:00.422
UPPING SCIENCE IS CRITICAL TO
01:16:00.489 --> 01:16:01.690
ENSURE THAT THE STATE'S DAYS
01:16:01.757 --> 01:16:02.991
AHEAD OF THE CHANGES.
01:16:03.058 --> 01:16:06.094
THAT ARE UNDER WAY AB EIGHT
01:16:06.161 --> 01:16:06.595
THIRTY NINE WILL PROVIDE
01:16:06.662 --> 01:16:08.230
ACCOUNTABILITY. TO ENSURE THE
01:16:08.297 --> 01:16:10.065
STATE'S PRIORITY ACTIONS ARE
01:16:10.132 --> 01:16:12.034
BASED ON A CLEAR EYED ASSESSMENT
01:16:12.100 --> 01:16:12.968
OF THE THREATS OVER THE LONG
01:16:13.035 --> 01:16:13.602
TERM.
01:16:13.669 --> 01:16:15.504
IT WILL PUT TEETH BEHIND THE
01:16:15.570 --> 01:16:17.105
SAFEGUARDING PLAN TO ENSURE
01:16:17.172 --> 01:16:18.540
RECOMMENDATIONS ARE IMPLEMENTED
01:16:18.607 --> 01:16:20.275
IN A TIMELY MANNER.
01:16:20.342 --> 01:16:21.643
THAT THEY DELIVER THE ADAPTATION
01:16:21.710 --> 01:16:23.412
BENEFITS THAT WE DESIRE AND THAT
01:16:23.478 --> 01:16:25.847
WE DEVELOPED METRICS OF SUCCESS.
01:16:25.914 --> 01:16:27.249
TO ENSURE THAT WE HOLD OURSELVES
01:16:27.316 --> 01:16:28.450
ACCOUNTABLE.
01:16:28.517 --> 01:16:29.384
WHILE THE STATE HAS BEEN A REAL
01:16:29.451 --> 01:16:30.819
LEADER AN ADAPTATION PLANNING
01:16:30.886 --> 01:16:32.721
AND POLICY TO DATE IT IS NEVER
01:16:32.788 --> 01:16:33.455
REALLY EMBARKED ON A
01:16:33.522 --> 01:16:35.057
COMPREHENSIVE POLICY TO CREATE
01:16:35.123 --> 01:16:36.391
GOALS REQUIRE BETTER
01:16:36.458 --> 01:16:37.326
COORDINATION.
01:16:37.392 --> 01:16:40.028
AND PUSHED INNOVATIVE FINANCING
01:16:40.095 --> 01:16:42.230
A AB EIGHT THIRTY NINE GOES A
01:16:42.297 --> 01:16:43.498
LONG WAY IN DOING THAT AND
01:16:43.565 --> 01:16:45.567
THAT'S WHY WE ASK FOR YOUR
01:16:45.634 --> 01:16:47.169
SUPPORT TODAY.
01:16:47.235 --> 01:16:49.037
THANK YOU THE NEXT WITNESS.
01:16:49.104 --> 01:16:49.705
CHAIR AND MEMBERS READ AT US ON
01:16:49.771 --> 01:16:50.572
BEHALF OF LOCAL GOVERNMENT
01:16:50.639 --> 01:16:51.840
COMMISSION I HAVE HAD THE
01:16:51.907 --> 01:16:53.275
OPPORTUNITY TO WORK ON CLIMATE
01:16:53.342 --> 01:16:54.309
ADAPTATION HERE IN THE STATE OF
01:16:54.376 --> 01:16:56.511
CALIFORNIA OVER THE LAST SEVERAL
01:16:56.578 --> 01:16:56.945
YEARS.
01:16:57.012 --> 01:16:58.647
IN PARTICULAR -- WE'VE BEEN ABLE
01:16:58.714 --> 01:16:59.514
TO WORK ON REGIONAL
01:16:59.581 --> 01:17:01.183
COLLABORATIVE'S AND HAVE BEEN
01:17:01.249 --> 01:17:03.652
ABLE TO HOST THE ADAPTATION FORM
01:17:03.719 --> 01:17:04.953
THAT OCCURS -- HERE IN
01:17:05.020 --> 01:17:06.154
CALIFORNIA.
01:17:06.221 --> 01:17:08.056
BASED ON THAT WORK WE'RE REALLY
01:17:08.123 --> 01:17:09.424
INTERESTED IN THIS BILL IN
01:17:09.491 --> 01:17:10.726
PARTICULAR NOT ONLY BECAUSE THE
01:17:10.792 --> 01:17:12.394
ELEMENTS THAT FOCUS ON NATURAL
01:17:12.461 --> 01:17:13.562
RESOURCES.
01:17:13.628 --> 01:17:14.463
BUT THE ELEMENTS OF THE BILLS
01:17:14.529 --> 01:17:15.797
THAT THE FOCUS IS ON COMMUNITY
01:17:15.864 --> 01:17:17.265
RESILIENCY.
01:17:17.332 --> 01:17:18.667
WE'RE LOOKING AT AT PROVISIONS
01:17:18.734 --> 01:17:19.835
THAT ADDRESS ENVIRONMENTAL
01:17:19.901 --> 01:17:21.336
JUSTICE AND PEOPLE AS WELL AS
01:17:21.403 --> 01:17:23.338
NATURE AND SO WE WE REALLY LIKE
01:17:23.405 --> 01:17:25.407
THAT ABOUT THE MEASURE. TWO
01:17:25.474 --> 01:17:27.009
OTHER ITEMS WILL MENTION.
01:17:27.075 --> 01:17:28.477
BECAUSE MY COLLEAGUE FROM
01:17:28.543 --> 01:17:29.244
MACHINE CONSERVANCY COVERED ALL
01:17:29.311 --> 01:17:30.612
OF THE OTHER ONES BUT THE
01:17:30.679 --> 01:17:32.347
INNOVATIVE FINANCING ELEMENT OF
01:17:32.414 --> 01:17:33.415
THE BILL.
01:17:33.482 --> 01:17:34.916
WE THINK IT'S CRITICAL THE STATE
01:17:34.983 --> 01:17:35.851
OF CALIFORNIA IS GOING TO HAVE
01:17:35.917 --> 01:17:37.319
TO DEAL WITH A RED RATHER LARGE
01:17:37.386 --> 01:17:38.520
BILL TO DEAL WITH CLIMATE
01:17:38.587 --> 01:17:39.855
ADAPTATION.
01:17:39.921 --> 01:17:41.189
IT'S GOING TO TAKE A LOT OF
01:17:41.256 --> 01:17:42.524
INNOVATIVE FINANCING AND THE
01:17:42.591 --> 01:17:44.226
FINANCE THOUGHTFUL APPROACH TO
01:17:44.292 --> 01:17:45.093
DO THAT AND WE THINK THIS
01:17:45.160 --> 01:17:45.927
MEASURE.
01:17:45.994 --> 01:17:47.496
HELPS THE STATE YEAH GET GO A
01:17:47.562 --> 01:17:51.600
LONG WAY IN TRYING TO DO WITH
01:17:51.666 --> 01:17:52.701
THOSE FINANCIAL.
01:17:52.768 --> 01:17:53.068
NEEDS.
01:17:53.135 --> 01:17:53.602
AND THEN FINALLY THERE'S A
01:17:53.668 --> 01:17:54.536
POLICY IN HERE THAT WE THINK IS
01:17:54.603 --> 01:17:55.337
REALLY USEFUL MAKING SURE THAT
01:17:55.404 --> 01:17:55.937
WE'RE ALL ROWING IN THE SAME
01:17:56.004 --> 01:17:56.505
DIRECTION.
01:17:56.571 --> 01:17:57.739
MAKING SURE THAT THE NATURAL
01:17:57.806 --> 01:17:59.307
RESOURCE AGENCIES ALSO TALKING
01:17:59.374 --> 01:18:00.942
TO THEIR INSURANCE COMMISSIONER
01:18:01.009 --> 01:18:01.810
TO MAKE SURE THAT POLICIES ARE
01:18:01.877 --> 01:18:04.046
LINE FOR THOSE REASONS WERE IN
01:18:04.112 --> 01:18:05.781
STRONG SUPPORT TODAY THANK YOU.
01:18:05.847 --> 01:18:07.883
THANK YOU ARE THERE ANY OTHER
01:18:07.949 --> 01:18:13.321
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL.
01:18:13.388 --> 01:18:14.189
NATALIE LACKS ON BEHALF OF
01:18:14.256 --> 01:18:15.323
COMMUNITY NATURE CONNECTION
01:18:15.390 --> 01:18:16.658
FRIENDS OF THE LA RIVER LAND
01:18:16.725 --> 01:18:18.093
JUST A SANTA CRUZ COUNTY SAVE
01:18:18.160 --> 01:18:19.194
THE REDWOODS LEAGUE MIDLANDS
01:18:19.261 --> 01:18:20.695
NAME MID PENINSULA REGIONAL OPEN
01:18:20.762 --> 01:18:22.064
SPACE DISTRICT AND CALIFORNIA'S
01:18:22.130 --> 01:18:24.933
ISSUES ASSOCIATION OF LOCAL
01:18:25.000 --> 01:18:28.503
CONSERVATION COURSE AND CANCER
01:18:28.570 --> 01:18:29.671
NO DAY WOULD SAVE OUR SHORES IN
01:18:29.738 --> 01:18:31.106
SANTA CRUZ CALIFORNIA.
01:18:31.173 --> 01:18:33.875
IN SUPPORT.
01:18:33.942 --> 01:18:34.876
THROUGH THE WRECKAGE ON BEHALF
01:18:34.943 --> 01:18:36.378
OF THE CLEAN SEIZE LOBBYING
01:18:36.445 --> 01:18:38.613
COALITION IN SUPPORT.
01:18:38.680 --> 01:18:40.048
HI JENNIFER SAVAGE SURFRIDER IN
01:18:40.115 --> 01:18:42.217
SUPPORT.
01:18:42.284 --> 01:18:43.051
THANK YEARS OR ANYBODY WANTED TO
01:18:43.118 --> 01:18:44.786
TESTIFY ON IN OPPOSITION TO THE
01:18:44.853 --> 01:18:46.455
BILL.
01:18:46.521 --> 01:18:48.423
SEEING NONE OF IS ANYONE FROM
01:18:48.490 --> 01:18:49.524
THE COMMITTEE HAVE ANY QUESTIONS
01:18:49.591 --> 01:18:52.727
OR COMMENTS.
01:18:52.794 --> 01:18:54.463
SEEING NONE MISTER MOM WOULD YOU
01:18:54.529 --> 01:18:56.231
LIKE TO CLOSE.
01:18:56.298 --> 01:18:57.966
THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME MADAM
01:18:58.033 --> 01:18:59.134
CHAIR MEMBERS I RESPECTFULLY ASK
01:18:59.201 --> 01:19:00.969
MY VOTE THANK YOU I'M HAPPY TO
01:19:01.036 --> 01:19:02.270
SUPPORT YOUR BILL AND WILL DO SO
01:19:02.337 --> 01:19:03.972
LET ME HAVE A FORM.
01:19:04.039 --> 01:19:07.943
THANK YOU.
01:19:08.009 --> 01:19:09.111
AS MISTER KALRA HERE
01:19:09.177 --> 01:19:09.411
[inaudible]
01:19:09.478 --> 01:19:11.046
MS BURKE [inaudible]
01:19:11.113 --> 01:19:13.215
MR O'DONNELL [inaudible]
01:19:13.281 --> 01:19:14.816
MR GLORIA [inaudible]
01:19:14.883 --> 01:19:21.423
STIR GALLAGHER.
01:19:21.490 --> 01:19:23.992
AND SO THAT THE COMMITTEE -- IS
01:19:24.059 --> 01:19:25.527
CLEAR WE'RE GOING TO BE HEARING
01:19:25.594 --> 01:19:27.329
TESTIMONY ON THIS BILL TODAY BUT
01:19:27.395 --> 01:19:28.663
WE WILL NOT BE VOTING ON THIS
01:19:28.730 --> 01:19:30.632
BILL TODAY. TO GIVE THE AUTHOR
01:19:30.699 --> 01:19:33.034
MORE TIME TO WORK WITH MYSELF
01:19:33.101 --> 01:19:34.903
AND THE COMMITTEE -- ON
01:19:34.970 --> 01:19:38.740
AMENDMENTS -- THE THAT I BELIEVE
01:19:38.807 --> 01:19:40.942
THE THE BILL NEEDS -- BEFORE CAN
01:19:41.009 --> 01:19:43.145
BE VOTED ON SO WITH THAT MISTER
01:19:43.211 --> 01:19:43.812
GALLAGHER.
01:19:43.879 --> 01:19:44.546
YOU MAY OPEN.
01:19:44.613 --> 01:19:45.680
YEAH THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR
01:19:45.747 --> 01:19:46.948
MEMBERS -- APPRECIATE YOUR TIME
01:19:47.015 --> 01:19:51.753
THIS -- THIS AFTERNOON -- MANY
01:19:51.820 --> 01:19:53.588
PEN THAT I'M WORKING ON MY
01:19:53.655 --> 01:19:54.923
JACKET.
01:19:54.990 --> 01:19:56.558
OVER THE LAST FEW WEEKS AND THIS
01:19:56.625 --> 01:19:57.726
PEN RIGHT HERE ACTUALLY
01:19:57.792 --> 01:19:59.794
REPRESENTS THE FLAG OF THE TOWN
01:19:59.861 --> 01:20:02.330
OF PARADISE -- WRAPPED WITH THE
01:20:02.397 --> 01:20:03.865
AMERICAN FLAG IT WAS GIVEN TO ME
01:20:03.932 --> 01:20:07.002
BY -- FORMER MAYOR PARADISE
01:20:07.068 --> 01:20:08.737
SCOTT LAUDER.
01:20:08.803 --> 01:20:11.806
WHO'S HERE WITH US TODAY --
01:20:11.873 --> 01:20:14.042
INDIA AS MANY YOU KNOW THIS.
01:20:14.109 --> 01:20:15.510
YOU KNOW WHAT HAS HAPPENED UP IN
01:20:15.577 --> 01:20:17.078
THESE IN THESE COMMUNITIES -- IN
01:20:17.145 --> 01:20:18.747
BUTTE COUNTY WITH THE CAMP
01:20:18.813 --> 01:20:20.048
FIRE'S BEEN VERY CLOSE TO MY
01:20:20.115 --> 01:20:22.317
HEART IT'S BEEN A BIG PART OF MY
01:20:22.384 --> 01:20:25.253
LEGISLATIVE PACKAGE -- THIS YEAR --
01:20:25.320 --> 01:20:26.388
IN TRYING TO DO EVERYTHING THAT
01:20:26.454 --> 01:20:29.824
WE CAN TO HELP PEOPLE RECOVER.
01:20:29.891 --> 01:20:30.926
HIDE SO IN THAT LIGHT I'M I'M
01:20:30.992 --> 01:20:33.762
PROUD TO PRESENT AB FOUR THIRTY
01:20:33.828 --> 01:20:35.096
THE THE CAMPFIRE HOUSING
01:20:35.163 --> 01:20:36.731
ASSISTANCE ACT OF TWO THOUSAND
01:20:36.798 --> 01:20:40.101
AND NINETEEN AS YOU ALL KNOW --
01:20:40.168 --> 01:20:41.670
THE CAMPFIRE WAS THE DEADLIEST
01:20:41.736 --> 01:20:43.405
AND MOST DESTRUCTIVE WILDFIRE IN
01:20:43.471 --> 01:20:45.307
CALIFORNIA HISTORY.
01:20:45.373 --> 01:20:46.541
AND DEVASTATED THE COMMUNITIES
01:20:46.608 --> 01:20:48.944
OF MAY GALIA KHôNG CAL YANKEE
01:20:49.010 --> 01:20:50.145
HILL.
01:20:50.212 --> 01:20:51.813
AND PARADISE.
01:20:51.880 --> 01:20:53.181
THE FIREDISPLAYS FIFTY THOUSAND
01:20:53.248 --> 01:20:56.218
PEOPLE.
01:20:56.284 --> 01:20:57.319
IN THE DAYS SINCE NOVEMBER
01:20:57.385 --> 01:20:58.954
EIGHTH I'VE I'VE TALKED WITH
01:20:59.020 --> 01:20:59.955
COUNTLESS.
01:21:00.021 --> 01:21:02.224
COMMUNITY MEMBERS.
01:21:02.290 --> 01:21:04.226
WHO HAVE DETAILED THEIR HORROR
01:21:04.292 --> 01:21:06.728
STORIES OF?
01:21:06.795 --> 01:21:07.495
HAVE LITERALLY GOING THROUGH
01:21:07.562 --> 01:21:10.799
HELL -- AND MAKE IT OUT ALIVE IN
01:21:10.865 --> 01:21:11.399
THE TERROR THAT THAT WENT WITH
01:21:11.466 --> 01:21:13.168
THAT.
01:21:13.235 --> 01:21:14.569
BUT ALSO THE HELL OF THE
01:21:14.636 --> 01:21:16.037
AFTERMATH.
01:21:16.104 --> 01:21:17.939
OF THIS DISASTER OF NOT HAVING
01:21:18.006 --> 01:21:21.943
THE SAFETY SECURITY AND COMFORT.
01:21:22.010 --> 01:21:23.878
OF A HOME AND WE ALL KNOW THAT
01:21:23.945 --> 01:21:25.680
IT'S YOU KNOW WE WE HAVE TO DO
01:21:25.747 --> 01:21:27.482
IN THIS JOB WE WE TRAVEL A LOT
01:21:27.549 --> 01:21:30.085
AND HOW GREAT IT FEELS TO BE
01:21:30.151 --> 01:21:30.418
ABLE TO COME.
01:21:30.485 --> 01:21:32.988
HOME. TO BE IN YOUR HOME TO HAVE
01:21:33.054 --> 01:21:36.224
THAT -- YEAH BASICALLY THAT
01:21:36.291 --> 01:21:39.594
REFUGE -- THAT A HOME PROVIDES.
01:21:39.661 --> 01:21:41.796
SO MANY THESE FIFTY THOUSAND
01:21:41.863 --> 01:21:43.598
PEOPLE DON'T HAVE THAT -- WE
01:21:43.665 --> 01:21:46.601
HAVE -- WAY TOO MANY PEOPLE
01:21:46.668 --> 01:21:47.769
STILL LIVING IN RV'S AND
01:21:47.836 --> 01:21:49.838
TRAILERS [inaudible]
01:21:49.904 --> 01:21:51.473
EVEN TENSE.
01:21:51.539 --> 01:21:54.776
DURING THESE -- WINTER WEATHER --
01:21:54.843 --> 01:21:57.145
CONDITIONS AND ALSO FAR TOO MANY
01:21:57.212 --> 01:21:59.114
THAT ARE STILL HOMELESS.
01:21:59.180 --> 01:21:59.848
AND THERE WERE ALREADY WAS A
01:21:59.914 --> 01:22:01.916
HOMELESS ISSUE AND IN THE AREA
01:22:01.983 --> 01:22:03.551
BUT THIS HAS BEEN EXACERBATED BY
01:22:03.618 --> 01:22:05.420
THE FIRE.
01:22:05.487 --> 01:22:06.621
IT WILL TAKE YEARS FOR THESE
01:22:06.688 --> 01:22:08.957
COMMUNITIES TO REBUILD.
01:22:09.024 --> 01:22:10.825
AND IN THE MEANTIME EVACUEES
01:22:10.892 --> 01:22:12.560
NEED TO BE ABLE TO FIND.
01:22:12.627 --> 01:22:15.664
STABLE HOUSING -- WHILE MANY AND
01:22:15.730 --> 01:22:16.965
THERE'S A VERY STRONG CONTINGENT
01:22:17.032 --> 01:22:18.400
OF PEOPLE THAT WILL CHOOSE TO
01:22:18.466 --> 01:22:20.302
REBUILD IN PARADISE IN FACT I
01:22:20.368 --> 01:22:21.970
HAD A MEETING THIS MORNING.
01:22:22.037 --> 01:22:23.071
WITH MEMBERS OF THE TOWN OF
01:22:23.138 --> 01:22:25.373
PARADISE WORKING ON REBUILDING
01:22:25.440 --> 01:22:27.642
THE INFRASTRUCTURE IS GOING TO
01:22:27.709 --> 01:22:29.311
BE A VITAL CORNERSTONE OF THAT.
01:22:29.377 --> 01:22:31.246
BUT STILL OTHERS WILL HAVE TO
01:22:31.313 --> 01:22:32.781
TRY AND FIND PERMANENT HOUSING
01:22:32.847 --> 01:22:34.816
IN SURROUNDING AREAS OTHERS WILL
01:22:34.883 --> 01:22:36.651
NEED HOUSING IN THE INTERIM AS
01:22:36.718 --> 01:22:38.320
THEY START TO MAKE THOSE PLANS.
01:22:38.386 --> 01:22:39.621
FOR REBUILDING BUT HERE'S THE
01:22:39.688 --> 01:22:41.256
PROBLEM.
01:22:41.323 --> 01:22:42.691
THE CAMP FIRE DESTROYED FORT
01:22:42.757 --> 01:22:44.526
DESTROYED FOURTEEN THOUSAND
01:22:44.592 --> 01:22:47.395
HOMES. 14% OF BUTTE COUNTY'S
01:22:47.462 --> 01:22:49.130
HOUSING STOCK.
01:22:49.197 --> 01:22:50.999
AND THE COUNTY FELL SEVENTEEN
01:22:51.066 --> 01:22:52.100
PLACES MORE THAN ANY OTHER
01:22:52.167 --> 01:22:53.835
COUNTY IN THE STATE ON THE
01:22:53.902 --> 01:22:55.270
AFFORDABILITY INDEX.
01:22:55.337 --> 01:22:56.971
THE RENTAL MARKET VACANCY RATE
01:22:57.038 --> 01:22:59.708
ALSO FELL TO NEARLY 0%.
01:22:59.774 --> 01:23:01.443
AFTER THE FIRE THERE IS
01:23:01.509 --> 01:23:03.345
LITERALLY NO HOUSING. FOR PEOPLE
01:23:03.411 --> 01:23:05.347
WHO DESPERATELY WANT TO FIND
01:23:05.413 --> 01:23:06.915
HOUSING IN THIS AREA.
01:23:06.981 --> 01:23:08.183
THESE COMMUNITIES HAVE A STRONG
01:23:08.249 --> 01:23:09.551
SENSE OF PLACE AND THIS IS
01:23:09.617 --> 01:23:10.452
SOMETHING I REALLY WANT TO
01:23:10.518 --> 01:23:11.886
EMPHASIZE THIS IS WHERE THEY
01:23:11.953 --> 01:23:13.888
WANT TO LIVE. TO TO WORK TO
01:23:13.955 --> 01:23:16.791
RAISE A FAMILY.
01:23:16.858 --> 01:23:18.059
AND IT MAKES IT EXTREMELY
01:23:18.126 --> 01:23:19.661
DIFFICULT FOR CAMPFIRE VICTIMS
01:23:19.728 --> 01:23:21.196
AND OTHERS TO FIND THAT HOUSING
01:23:21.262 --> 01:23:22.364
IN THIS IN THIS REGION IN THIS
01:23:22.430 --> 01:23:25.200
PLACE -- THAT THEY WANT TO LIVE
01:23:25.266 --> 01:23:26.634
EVEN THOUGH MANY WANT TO STAY IN
01:23:26.701 --> 01:23:28.436
THE AREA WHERE THEY HAVE JOBS
01:23:28.503 --> 01:23:29.804
THEY STILL HAVE JOBS THEY HAVE.
01:23:29.871 --> 01:23:31.139
FAMILIES THEY HAVE KIDS THAT
01:23:31.206 --> 01:23:32.707
NEED TO GO TO SCHOOL.
01:23:32.774 --> 01:23:33.942
THEY HAVE MANY COMMUNITY
01:23:34.008 --> 01:23:35.276
CONNECTIONS SOCIAL CLUBS AT
01:23:35.343 --> 01:23:36.945
THEIR INVOLVED WHEN THEY WANT TO
01:23:37.011 --> 01:23:38.613
STAY IN THE AREA.
01:23:38.680 --> 01:23:40.248
NOT LONG AFTER THE FIRE AND THAT
01:23:40.315 --> 01:23:43.251
WITH MANY LOCAL STAKEHOLDERS --
01:23:43.318 --> 01:23:44.953
WITH LOCAL GOVERNMENT OFFICIALS
01:23:45.019 --> 01:23:46.388
WITH CITY MANAGERS WITH THE
01:23:46.454 --> 01:23:48.189
COUNTY GOVERNMENT.
01:23:48.256 --> 01:23:50.425
WITH HOUSING ADVOCATES.
01:23:50.492 --> 01:23:52.861
REALTORS -- THE WHOLE THE WHOLE
01:23:52.927 --> 01:23:54.863
RANGE ALL OF THEM IDENTIFIED
01:23:54.929 --> 01:23:56.064
SEEK WAS THE NUMBER ONE
01:23:56.131 --> 01:23:58.533
IMPEDIMENT. TO BUILDING MORE
01:23:58.600 --> 01:24:00.735
HOUSING IN THE IN THE IN IN THIS
01:24:00.802 --> 01:24:02.337
EMERGENCY SITUATION.
01:24:02.404 --> 01:24:04.406
AND SO WITH THAT IN MIND WE KNOW
01:24:04.472 --> 01:24:06.074
THAT CURRENT LAW ALLOWS SOME
01:24:06.141 --> 01:24:07.375
HOUSING PROJECTS TO BE PERMITTED
01:24:07.442 --> 01:24:09.344
BY CITY OR COUNTY PLANNING STAFF
01:24:09.411 --> 01:24:10.712
MINISTERIAL E..
01:24:10.779 --> 01:24:12.680
THERE BY STREAMLINING -- PROJECT
01:24:12.747 --> 01:24:14.482
APPROVAL ONLY SEEN SOME BILLS
01:24:14.549 --> 01:24:16.518
LIKE THAT BEFORE -- MOST
01:24:16.584 --> 01:24:18.253
RECENTLY SB THIRTY FIVE FROM
01:24:18.319 --> 01:24:21.489
SENATOR WIENER WHICH PASSED IN.
01:24:21.556 --> 01:24:22.123
TWENTY SEVENTEEN WHICH EXPANDED
01:24:22.190 --> 01:24:23.858
THIS MINISTERIAL PROCESS THAT
01:24:23.925 --> 01:24:25.193
HELPS IT AND ENSURE CERTAIN
01:24:25.260 --> 01:24:27.662
INFILL PROJECTS IN AREAS.
01:24:27.729 --> 01:24:28.730
THAT HAVE NOT MET THEIR HOUSING
01:24:28.797 --> 01:24:30.765
GOALS CAN BE DONE I AM TRYING TO
01:24:30.832 --> 01:24:32.700
TAILOR.
01:24:32.767 --> 01:24:34.636
THIS BILL AB. FOUR THIRTY TO DO
01:24:34.702 --> 01:24:36.070
EXACTLY JUST THAT BUT FOR THE
01:24:36.137 --> 01:24:38.239
BUTTE COUNTY REGION.
01:24:38.306 --> 01:24:39.941
THAT IS IT IS NARROWLY FOCUSED
01:24:40.008 --> 01:24:41.476
IN A PUT IN IT APPLIES THIS
01:24:41.543 --> 01:24:43.044
STREAMLINED MINISTERIAL APPROVAL
01:24:43.111 --> 01:24:44.846
PROCESS FOR THE REBUILDING OF
01:24:44.913 --> 01:24:47.015
HOMES IN URBAN AREAS OF THE CAP
01:24:47.081 --> 01:24:48.416
AND BUTTE COUNTY THIS IS NOT
01:24:48.483 --> 01:24:49.517
SPRAWL.
01:24:49.584 --> 01:24:51.119
THIS BILL ONLY APPLIES TO THE
01:24:51.186 --> 01:24:53.321
URBAN AREAS OF CHICO GRIDLEY IN
01:24:53.388 --> 01:24:54.289
ORVILLE.
01:24:54.355 --> 01:24:55.890
AND INCLUDES PROTECTIONS TO
01:24:55.957 --> 01:24:57.125
PREVENT DEVELOPMENTS FROM BEING
01:24:57.192 --> 01:24:58.092
BUILT.
01:24:58.159 --> 01:24:59.561
IN FLOOD PLAINS.
01:24:59.627 --> 01:25:01.963
IN PROTECTED AGRICULTURAL LANDS
01:25:02.030 --> 01:25:03.698
IN FACT IN BUTTE COUNTY WE HAVE
01:25:03.765 --> 01:25:05.500
A LONG STANDING ORDINANCE WHICH
01:25:05.567 --> 01:25:07.135
IS KNOWN AS THE GREEN LINE.
01:25:07.202 --> 01:25:09.103
THAT KEEPS -- PROJECTS FROM
01:25:09.170 --> 01:25:10.805
BEING BUILT -- IN PRIME
01:25:10.872 --> 01:25:12.941
AGRICULTURAL LANDS IN BUTTE
01:25:13.007 --> 01:25:13.741
COUNTY.
01:25:13.808 --> 01:25:14.943
IT ALSO PREVENTS IT FROM BEING
01:25:15.009 --> 01:25:16.044
BUILT ON ENVIRONMENTALLY
01:25:16.110 --> 01:25:18.046
SENSITIVE LANDS.
01:25:18.112 --> 01:25:19.814
THE DEVELOPMENT ALSO MUST BE
01:25:19.881 --> 01:25:21.950
CONSISTENT WITH LOCAL ZONING AND
01:25:22.016 --> 01:25:23.618
GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATIONS.
01:25:23.685 --> 01:25:25.353
IF THE LAND IS NOT CURRENTLY
01:25:25.420 --> 01:25:27.055
ZONED FOR RESIDENTIAL AND MULTI
01:25:27.121 --> 01:25:28.590
USE RESIDENTIAL.
01:25:28.656 --> 01:25:30.225
IT WILL NOT BE ABLE TO TAKE
01:25:30.291 --> 01:25:31.493
ADVANTAGE OF THIS PROCESS.
01:25:31.559 --> 01:25:33.228
SO IT IS A VERY LIMITED BUT IT'S
01:25:33.294 --> 01:25:34.596
A VERY SURGICAL.
01:25:34.662 --> 01:25:36.030
BILL THAT WILL ALLOW US TO BRING
01:25:36.097 --> 01:25:37.932
ONLINE HOUSING STOCK IN IN
01:25:37.999 --> 01:25:39.167
PLACES WHERE WE'VE ALREADY SAID
01:25:39.234 --> 01:25:42.437
AS LOCAL COMMUNITIES WE WANT --
01:25:42.504 --> 01:25:44.005
TO IT WILL PROVIDE A MUCH NEEDED
01:25:44.072 --> 01:25:46.341
INCENTIVE TO BRING THIS ONLINE
01:25:46.407 --> 01:25:49.143
AND SO -- AGAIN THIS BILL HAS A
01:25:49.210 --> 01:25:51.279
LOT OF VERY BROAD.
01:25:51.346 --> 01:25:52.814
LOCAL SUPPORT YOU SEE.
01:25:52.881 --> 01:25:54.716
AS VERY VERY MANY LOCAL
01:25:54.782 --> 01:25:56.417
ORGANIZATIONS WHO HAVE WHO HAVE
01:25:56.484 --> 01:25:58.620
COME ON BOARD IN SUPPORT OF THIS
01:25:58.686 --> 01:25:59.254
YOU'RE GONNA HEAR FROM MANY OF
01:25:59.320 --> 01:26:01.456
THEM TODAY -- SIERRA CLUB IS THE
01:26:01.523 --> 01:26:03.157
ONLY REGISTERED OPPOSITION. TO
01:26:03.224 --> 01:26:04.459
THIS BILL AT THIS POINT AND I
01:26:04.526 --> 01:26:05.527
HAVE COMMITTED TO MAKING
01:26:05.593 --> 01:26:07.362
AMENDMENTS TO ADDRESS THEIR
01:26:07.428 --> 01:26:08.796
CONCERNS ARE OUTLINED IN THEIR
01:26:08.863 --> 01:26:09.330
LETTER.
01:26:09.397 --> 01:26:11.533
AND THEY WILL TALK ABOUT THAT
01:26:11.599 --> 01:26:12.200
TODAY AS WELL.
01:26:12.267 --> 01:26:14.002
NOT SO WITH ME TODAY TO TESTIFY
01:26:14.068 --> 01:26:15.670
IN SUPPORT OF AB FOUR THIRTY I
01:26:15.737 --> 01:26:17.038
HAVE JENNIFER MORRIS -- THE
01:26:17.105 --> 01:26:18.439
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE NORTH
01:26:18.506 --> 01:26:21.276
VALLEY PROPERTY ASSOCIATION AND
01:26:21.342 --> 01:26:24.245
TOM LANDAU -- THE CITY MANAGER
01:26:24.312 --> 01:26:25.413
OF THE CITY OF OR BILL.
01:26:25.480 --> 01:26:26.381
HE'LL JUST GIVE US A MOMENT ONE
01:26:26.447 --> 01:26:28.650
OF SELFLESS A QUORUM BEFORE WE
01:26:28.716 --> 01:26:29.484
MOVE FORWARD.
01:26:29.551 --> 01:26:31.853
WE CAN HAVE A ROLL CALL.
01:26:31.920 --> 01:26:33.354
MEMBERS FRIEDMAN HERE FRIEDMAN
01:26:33.421 --> 01:26:35.323
HERE FLOOR FLOOR HERE CHAU
01:26:35.390 --> 01:26:35.623
[inaudible]
01:26:35.690 --> 01:26:37.258
EGGMAN.
01:26:37.325 --> 01:26:39.394
EGGMAN HERE GARCIA.
01:26:39.460 --> 01:26:41.162
GARCIA HERE LONG.
01:26:41.229 --> 01:26:42.063
MATHIS.
01:26:42.130 --> 01:26:43.731
MATHIS HERE MCCARTY.
01:26:43.798 --> 01:26:46.234
MCCARTY HERE MELINDA'S THE LAND
01:26:46.301 --> 01:26:48.002
IS HERE MURATSUCHI STONE
01:26:48.069 --> 01:26:48.303
[inaudible]
01:26:48.369 --> 01:26:49.737
OKAY.
01:26:49.804 --> 01:26:51.239
THE WITNESSES CAN PROCEED THANK
01:26:51.306 --> 01:26:52.840
THANK YOU.
01:26:52.907 --> 01:26:54.108
I'M TOM WINDOWS WITH MENTION ON
01:26:54.175 --> 01:26:56.578
THE INTERIM CITY ADMINISTRATORS
01:26:56.644 --> 01:26:58.212
IN YOUR BILL.
01:26:58.279 --> 01:26:59.247
HI I WAS WITH THE CITY OF CHICO
01:26:59.314 --> 01:27:00.682
FOR ABOUT TWENTY SIX YEARS MOST
01:27:00.748 --> 01:27:03.184
OF IT IS OUR CITY MANAGER -- I
01:27:03.251 --> 01:27:04.185
APPRECIATE THE OPPORTUNITY TO
01:27:04.252 --> 01:27:05.453
SPEAK THIS IS REALLY IMPORTANT
01:27:05.520 --> 01:27:07.088
ISSUE TO US.
01:27:07.155 --> 01:27:09.791
AS I SAT BACK I ALREADY HEARD.
01:27:09.857 --> 01:27:12.860
THE CAMPFIRE REFERENCED AT LEAST
01:27:12.927 --> 01:27:14.462
THREE TIMES IN IN WITH YOUR
01:27:14.529 --> 01:27:16.230
PREVIOUS SPEAKERS.
01:27:16.297 --> 01:27:18.766
THIS IS AN EMERGENCY OUR ECONOMY
01:27:18.833 --> 01:27:20.034
IN THE REGION IS AT RISK.
01:27:20.101 --> 01:27:21.202
YOU COUNTIES OF LOW INCOME
01:27:21.269 --> 01:27:24.005
COUNTY WITH A LITTLE MORE THAN
01:27:24.072 --> 01:27:25.139
TWO HUNDRED THOUSAND PEOPLE.
01:27:25.206 --> 01:27:27.642
AS YOU HEARD FIFTY THOUSAND HOME
01:27:27.709 --> 01:27:29.010
MORE BURN OUT OF THEIR HOMES.
01:27:29.077 --> 01:27:30.478
WHEN FOURTEEN THOUSAND OF THOSE
01:27:30.545 --> 01:27:32.180
WERE DESTROYED?
01:27:32.246 --> 01:27:34.415
UNFORTUNATELY THE RIDGE PROVIDED
01:27:34.482 --> 01:27:36.484
HOUSING FOR MANY OF THE REGION'S
01:27:36.551 --> 01:27:38.620
EMPLOYEES DUE TO ITS LOW COST.
01:27:38.686 --> 01:27:40.021
WITHOUT THESE WORKERS ARE
01:27:40.088 --> 01:27:40.855
REGION'S ECONOMY IS AT SERIOUS
01:27:40.922 --> 01:27:42.724
RISK.
01:27:42.790 --> 01:27:43.992
EMPLOYERS HAVE BEEN SURVEYED AND
01:27:44.058 --> 01:27:45.960
ON AVERAGE 10220% OF THEIR
01:27:46.027 --> 01:27:50.798
EMPLOYEES HOUSING EMPLOYERS ARE
01:27:50.865 --> 01:27:51.399
SAYING THEY'RE HAVING A HARD
01:27:51.466 --> 01:27:52.834
TIME RECRUITING.
01:27:52.900 --> 01:27:54.502
AND CONSIDERING OTHER LOCATIONS
01:27:54.569 --> 01:27:56.604
ALREADY ONE EMPLOYER.
01:27:56.671 --> 01:27:57.572
THE FEATHER RIVER HOSPITAL WITH
01:27:57.639 --> 01:27:59.607
ITS THIRTEEN HUNDRED EMPLOYEES
01:27:59.674 --> 01:28:00.875
IS CLOSE TO STORE.
01:28:00.942 --> 01:28:02.810
HOUSING IS CRITICAL AND FOR A
01:28:02.877 --> 01:28:05.246
HOST OF REASONS IS UNLIKELY TO
01:28:05.313 --> 01:28:08.316
BE BUILT IN A TIMELY FASHION ON
01:28:08.383 --> 01:28:09.651
THE RICH INCLUDING.
01:28:09.717 --> 01:28:12.253
NO SEWER VICTIM TRAUMA INSURANCE
01:28:12.320 --> 01:28:15.123
ISSUES AND COST TO BUILD.
01:28:15.189 --> 01:28:17.792
WE NEED A FIVE TO EIGHT THOUSAND
01:28:17.859 --> 01:28:19.060
HOUSING UNITS IMMEDIATELY.
01:28:19.127 --> 01:28:20.428
AND WE'RE TALKING PERMITTED
01:28:20.495 --> 01:28:21.729
EMPLOYEE HOUSING WE'RE NOT
01:28:21.796 --> 01:28:23.197
TALKING DOUBLING UP.
01:28:23.264 --> 01:28:24.932
WE'RE NOT TALKING FEMA TRAILERS
01:28:24.999 --> 01:28:26.134
WHICH WHICH INCIDENTALLY HAVE
01:28:26.200 --> 01:28:27.435
NOT YET BEEN PRODUCED.
01:28:27.502 --> 01:28:28.803
AGAIN AS WAS MENTIONED THERE
01:28:28.870 --> 01:28:30.471
VIRTUALLY NO VACANCIES OUR
01:28:30.538 --> 01:28:31.406
COMMUNITY NOW.
01:28:31.472 --> 01:28:33.074
UP THE COMMUNITY I'M WORKING IN
01:28:33.141 --> 01:28:34.275
WENT FROM.
01:28:34.342 --> 01:28:36.611
PROBABLY A 20% VACANCY TO A ZERO
01:28:36.678 --> 01:28:37.679
OVERNIGHT.
01:28:37.745 --> 01:28:39.547
INCLUDING TAKING OUR OLD
01:28:39.614 --> 01:28:40.415
STRUCTURES THE CITY HAD
01:28:40.481 --> 01:28:42.383
REPOSSESSED AND RE PURPOSING
01:28:42.450 --> 01:28:44.085
THEM AND HOUSING PEOPLE IN THOSE
01:28:44.152 --> 01:28:46.554
STRUCTURES.
01:28:46.621 --> 01:28:49.123
HOUSING PRICES HAVE SOARED DO A
01:28:49.190 --> 01:28:50.625
LOT TO A LACK OF THE SUPPLY.
01:28:50.692 --> 01:28:52.326
THIS BILL I BELIEVE IT IS A
01:28:52.393 --> 01:28:55.363
CRITICAL PIECE OF THE SOLUTION.
01:28:55.430 --> 01:28:57.231
IT'S GONNA TAKE AN INNOVATIVE
01:28:57.298 --> 01:29:00.168
APPROACH TO SOLVE THIS ISSUE.
01:29:00.234 --> 01:29:01.536
AS WAS MENTIONED.
01:29:01.602 --> 01:29:03.237
WE'RE TALKING ABOUT DEVELOPMENT
01:29:03.304 --> 01:29:04.605
IS CONSISTENT WITH THE
01:29:04.672 --> 01:29:06.574
JURISDICTIONS GENERAL PLANS AND
01:29:06.641 --> 01:29:08.176
SEVERE INFLUENCE.
01:29:08.242 --> 01:29:09.877
TIMING IS CRITICAL.
01:29:09.944 --> 01:29:11.846
WE ALREADY HAVE SEEN LITERALLY
01:29:11.913 --> 01:29:13.581
THOUSANDS OF PEOPLE MOVE OUT OF
01:29:13.648 --> 01:29:15.516
THE AREA -- FEMA'S PUT TOGETHER
01:29:15.583 --> 01:29:17.085
A MAP WHICH I BELIEVE IS
01:29:17.151 --> 01:29:18.352
AVAILABLE ONLINE.
01:29:18.419 --> 01:29:19.587
SHOWS WHERE THE REGS --
01:29:19.654 --> 01:29:23.891
RESIDENTS HAVE RELOCATED -- TO
01:29:23.958 --> 01:29:25.426
THERE ARE NUMBER OF PROJECTS
01:29:25.493 --> 01:29:27.528
THAT I BELIEVE WITH THIS BILL
01:29:27.595 --> 01:29:28.863
WOULD BE BROUGHT FORWARD.
01:29:28.930 --> 01:29:31.799
AGAIN CONSISTENT WITH EACH OF
01:29:31.866 --> 01:29:32.934
THE CITIES AND THE COUNTIES
01:29:33.000 --> 01:29:34.502
GENERAL PLAN.
01:29:34.569 --> 01:29:35.703
WE HAVE A DEVELOPING CALLED
01:29:35.770 --> 01:29:37.538
VALLEY VALLEY'S AGE WHICH WOULD
01:29:37.605 --> 01:29:39.307
HAVE THE ABILITY TO PROVIDE UP
01:29:39.373 --> 01:29:39.941
TO TWENTY THREE HUNDRED HOUSING
01:29:40.007 --> 01:29:40.742
UNITS.
01:29:40.808 --> 01:29:43.745
IN OUR AREA WE BUILD TWO TO FOUR
01:29:43.811 --> 01:29:45.079
HUNDRED A YEAR.
01:29:45.146 --> 01:29:46.347
HOPEFULLY WITH THESE
01:29:46.414 --> 01:29:47.782
DEVELOPMENTS COMING ON LINE WILL
01:29:47.849 --> 01:29:49.117
BE ABLE TO BUILD MAYBE THREE
01:29:49.183 --> 01:29:51.886
TIMES AT BUT IT'S GOING TO TAKE.
01:29:51.953 --> 01:29:53.855
A LARGER EFFORT TO GET THE
01:29:53.921 --> 01:29:55.423
REGION BACK ON TRACK.
01:29:55.490 --> 01:29:57.158
THERE'S A GATEWAY PROJECT WHICH
01:29:57.225 --> 01:29:58.493
IS TWO HUNDRED ACRES AGAIN.
01:29:58.559 --> 01:30:00.461
COMPLETELY CONSISTENT WITH THE
01:30:00.528 --> 01:30:03.064
CITY'S GENERAL PLAN THREE OR
01:30:03.131 --> 01:30:05.466
INFLUENCE IT HAS THE ABILITY TO
01:30:05.533 --> 01:30:07.702
HOUSE. TWELVE HUNDRED TWO
01:30:07.769 --> 01:30:08.636
THOUSAND UNITS AGAIN BILL OVER
01:30:08.703 --> 01:30:11.906
TIME YOU CAN FINISH UP CERTAINLY --
01:30:11.973 --> 01:30:13.875
PLEASE PASS THIS BILL IT'S ONE
01:30:13.941 --> 01:30:15.176
PIECE OF THE PUZZLE.
01:30:15.243 --> 01:30:16.544
I BELIEVE THIS BILL IS A
01:30:16.611 --> 01:30:18.713
CRITICAL PIECE OF THE RECOVERY.
01:30:18.780 --> 01:30:20.081
I WANT TO THANK THE ASSEMBLY
01:30:20.148 --> 01:30:21.115
ASSEMBLYMAN GALLAGHER FOR
01:30:21.182 --> 01:30:22.350
INTRODUCING IT.
01:30:22.416 --> 01:30:24.385
THE RECOVERY IT WAS IN CAN YOU
01:30:24.452 --> 01:30:25.753
NEEDS TO BE A TEAM EFFORT.
01:30:25.820 --> 01:30:27.655
I APPRECIATE ASSEMBLY FOR BEING
01:30:27.722 --> 01:30:30.758
PART OF THE TEAM THANK YOU.
01:30:30.825 --> 01:30:32.360
THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS.
01:30:32.426 --> 01:30:33.361
GOOD AFTERNOON MEMBERS OF THE
01:30:33.427 --> 01:30:34.862
ASSEMBLY THANK YOU FOR BEING
01:30:34.929 --> 01:30:36.230
HERE TODAY TO HEAR COMMENTS MY
01:30:36.297 --> 01:30:37.598
NAME IS JENNIFER MORRISON AND
01:30:37.665 --> 01:30:38.833
THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE
01:30:38.900 --> 01:30:39.967
NORTH VALLEY PROPERTY OWNERS
01:30:40.034 --> 01:30:41.135
ASSOCIATION.
01:30:41.202 --> 01:30:42.403
THE NORTH VALLEY PROPERTY OWNERS
01:30:42.470 --> 01:30:44.272
ASSOCIATION IS A NONPROFIT THAT
01:30:44.338 --> 01:30:45.807
PROVIDES SUPPORT EDUCATION AND
01:30:45.873 --> 01:30:47.175
ADVOCACY TO AREA HOUSING
01:30:47.241 --> 01:30:48.743
PROVIDERS LOCATED IN OUR TWELVE
01:30:48.810 --> 01:30:49.811
COUNTIES IN NORTHEASTERN
01:30:49.877 --> 01:30:51.045
CALIFORNIA.
01:30:51.112 --> 01:30:52.780
OUR OFFICES IN CHICO COUNTY VIEW
01:30:52.847 --> 01:30:54.682
AND WE REPRESENT THE OWNERS OF
01:30:54.749 --> 01:30:56.317
OVER TWENTY TWO THOUSAND RENTALS.
01:30:56.384 --> 01:30:57.618
SINCE THE DEVASTATING CAMPFIRE
01:30:57.685 --> 01:30:59.854
NOVEMBER EIGHTH TWO THOUSAND AND
01:30:59.921 --> 01:31:01.189
EIGHTEEN CHICO AND YOU COUNTY
01:31:01.255 --> 01:31:02.990
WILL NEVER BE THE SAME WE HAVE
01:31:03.057 --> 01:31:04.358
TAKEN IN A POPULATION OF
01:31:04.425 --> 01:31:05.693
SURVIVORS RECOVERY EFFORTS STAFF
01:31:05.760 --> 01:31:07.328
DURING THAT TIME WE HAD A PRE
01:31:07.395 --> 01:31:09.096
EXISTING VACANCY FACTOR OF LESS
01:31:09.163 --> 01:31:10.431
THAN 3%.
01:31:10.498 --> 01:31:12.233
THIS IS ABOUT FIVE TO SIX
01:31:12.300 --> 01:31:12.900
HUNDRED HOUSING UNITS THAT WERE
01:31:12.967 --> 01:31:13.734
AVAILABLE.
01:31:13.801 --> 01:31:15.336
THERE WAS OVER FOURTEEN THOUSAND
01:31:15.403 --> 01:31:16.404
HOMES THAT WERE DESTROYED IN THE
01:31:16.470 --> 01:31:18.639
CAMP FIRE YOU COUNTY NOW HAS
01:31:18.706 --> 01:31:20.775
LESS THAN 0% VACANCY OUR STREETS
01:31:20.842 --> 01:31:22.143
ARE LINED WITH DEBRIS REMOVAL
01:31:22.210 --> 01:31:23.411
TRUCKS.
01:31:23.477 --> 01:31:25.313
MOTORHOMES AND TRAILERS.
01:31:25.379 --> 01:31:26.914
AND AT TRAILERS WITH PEOPLE
01:31:26.981 --> 01:31:28.249
LIVING IN THEIR CARS ARE MENTAL
01:31:28.316 --> 01:31:29.817
HEALTH IS WEAKENING BY THE DAY
01:31:29.884 --> 01:31:31.385
MEMBERS OF OUR ORGANIZATION HAVE
01:31:31.452 --> 01:31:32.854
LED AND ATTENDED COUNTLESS
01:31:32.920 --> 01:31:33.955
MEETINGS TRYING TO SOLVE OUR
01:31:34.021 --> 01:31:35.389
HOUSING CRISIS.
01:31:35.456 --> 01:31:36.757
I AM HERE TODAY TO SUPPORT
01:31:36.824 --> 01:31:38.092
ASSEMBLYMAN GALLAGHER'S PROPOSED
01:31:38.159 --> 01:31:40.094
BILL OF AB FOR THIRTY TO
01:31:40.161 --> 01:31:41.462
STREAMLINED RECONSTRUCTION AND
01:31:41.529 --> 01:31:42.997
YOU HOUSING IN OUR COMMUNITY.
01:31:43.064 --> 01:31:44.432
AS I BELIEVE THIS IS ONE OF THE
01:31:44.498 --> 01:31:45.900
BEST SOLUTIONS WE CAN QUICKLY AN
01:31:45.967 --> 01:31:46.567
ACT.
01:31:46.634 --> 01:31:47.602
WHAT HAPPENED IN THE CAMP FIRE
01:31:47.668 --> 01:31:48.769
IS LIKE NOTHING ANYONE HAS
01:31:48.836 --> 01:31:50.471
EXPERIENCE BEFORE GENERATIONS
01:31:50.538 --> 01:31:51.939
UPON GENERATIONS HAVE BEEN
01:31:52.006 --> 01:31:53.541
DISPLACED WE HAVE EXPERIENCED
01:31:53.608 --> 01:31:55.209
WAYS OF HOUSING CHANGES AND WILL
01:31:55.276 --> 01:31:56.744
CONTINUE TO EXPERIENCE MORE?
01:31:56.811 --> 01:31:58.613
EVERY DAY THAT WE ARE UNABLE TO
01:31:58.679 --> 01:31:59.447
PROVIDE A SOLUTION TO OUR
01:31:59.513 --> 01:32:00.781
RESIDENTS IS ANOTHER DAY THAT
01:32:00.848 --> 01:32:01.983
THEY LOSE HOPE.
01:32:02.049 --> 01:32:03.284
AND LEAVE THE AREA.
01:32:03.351 --> 01:32:04.619
WE'RE MISSING OPPORTUNITIES TO
01:32:04.685 --> 01:32:05.887
MAINTAIN OUR WORK FORCE AT ALL
01:32:05.953 --> 01:32:06.954
LEVELS INCLUDING HEALTH
01:32:07.021 --> 01:32:08.356
PROFESSIONALS EDUCATORS AND SO
01:32:08.422 --> 01:32:09.757
MUCH MORE.
01:32:09.824 --> 01:32:11.425
WE NEED RELIEF AND SUPPORT OUR
01:32:11.492 --> 01:32:12.860
COMMUNITY IS STRONG AND WILL
01:32:12.927 --> 01:32:13.995
CONTINUE TO LIVE WITH THEIR NEW
01:32:14.061 --> 01:32:15.329
NORMAL BUT WITHOUT THE PASSAGE
01:32:15.396 --> 01:32:16.931
OF AB FOUR THIRTY WE WON'T BE
01:32:16.998 --> 01:32:18.399
ABLE TO BRING YOU HOUSING STOCK
01:32:18.466 --> 01:32:19.367
ON TO THE MARKET.
01:32:19.433 --> 01:32:20.935
IN A TIMELY MANNER WITHOUT YOUR
01:32:21.002 --> 01:32:22.703
ASSISTANCE PLEASE HELP US BY
01:32:22.770 --> 01:32:26.741
PASSING THIS IMPORTANT
01:32:26.807 --> 01:32:28.109
LEGISLATION FOR BUTTE COUNTY.
01:32:28.175 --> 01:32:28.643
THANK YOU ARE THERE OTHER
01:32:28.709 --> 01:32:29.277
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT MADAM CHAIR
01:32:29.343 --> 01:32:30.745
ANOTHER MEMBERS POLIO -- ON WE
01:32:30.811 --> 01:32:31.345
HAVE THE VIEW COUNTY BOARD OF
01:32:31.412 --> 01:32:31.946
SUPERVISORS IN SUPPORT OF THE
01:32:32.013 --> 01:32:32.413
BILL I'M TAKING EVERY
01:32:32.480 --> 01:32:33.447
OPPORTUNITY CAN THE THINK THE
01:32:33.514 --> 01:32:34.949
MEMBERS AGAIN WHO HAVE ACTUALLY
01:32:35.016 --> 01:32:36.417
GONE UP THERE PERSONALLY TOWARD
01:32:36.484 --> 01:32:38.019
THE AREA IT'S JUST NAME IN YOUR
01:32:38.085 --> 01:32:40.388
ORGANIZATION SO.
01:32:40.454 --> 01:32:41.689
I VOTE ON THE BILL THANK YOU.
01:32:41.756 --> 01:32:43.124
JOHN KENNEDY WORLD COUNTY
01:32:43.190 --> 01:32:43.925
REPRESENTATIVES OF CALIFORNIA
01:32:43.991 --> 01:32:46.761
THANK YOU.
01:32:46.827 --> 01:32:47.895
AT A RALLY ON BEHALF OF THE
01:32:47.962 --> 01:32:48.930
CALIFORNIA CHAMBER OF COMMERCE
01:32:48.996 --> 01:32:51.232
IN SUPPORT THANK YOU.
01:32:51.299 --> 01:32:52.900
SILVIO PURRING HAVE CALIFORNIA
01:32:52.967 --> 01:32:54.001
BUILDING INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION
01:32:54.068 --> 01:32:55.870
THE CIVIL JUSTICE CESSATION
01:32:55.937 --> 01:32:58.706
CALIFORNIA -- ADAM FINELLI FROM
01:32:58.773 --> 01:33:00.808
CHICO REALTOR REPRESENTS HERE
01:33:00.875 --> 01:33:02.877
NORTH VALLEY THE CESSATION OF
01:33:02.944 --> 01:33:06.113
REALTORS IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL.
01:33:06.180 --> 01:33:07.982
MARTY LE THE ROOM -- COLDWELL
01:33:08.049 --> 01:33:09.250
BANKER UP IN CHICO.
01:33:09.317 --> 01:33:11.252
POLICY ARE NORTH VALLEY REALTORS
01:33:11.319 --> 01:33:13.888
IN SUPPORT OF BILL.
01:33:13.955 --> 01:33:14.889
CASEY REYNOLDS MEMBER THE CHECK
01:33:14.956 --> 01:33:16.157
A CITY COUNCIL WHERE WE ARE
01:33:16.223 --> 01:33:17.191
STILL HAVE TWO PEOPLE SLEEPING
01:33:17.258 --> 01:33:18.859
IN CARS I STRONGLY SUPPORT THIS
01:33:18.926 --> 01:33:21.762
BILL.
01:33:21.829 --> 01:33:23.097
CAN YOU TELL ME PRESIDENT AND
01:33:23.164 --> 01:33:24.398
CEO OF THE CHECKER CHAMBER OF
01:33:24.465 --> 01:33:26.600
COMMERCE AND WE ARE IN SUPPORT
01:33:26.667 --> 01:33:29.804
OF AB FOUR THIRTY THANK YOU.
01:33:29.870 --> 01:33:31.205
WILLIAM SHARED IN I'M A MULTI
01:33:31.272 --> 01:33:32.940
FAMILY HOUSING PROVIDER IN CHICO
01:33:33.007 --> 01:33:35.309
AND I'M ALSO LEGISLATIVE REP FOR
01:33:35.376 --> 01:33:36.310
THE INSTITUTE REAL ESTATE
01:33:36.377 --> 01:33:37.979
MANAGEMENT SACRAMENTO VALLEY
01:33:38.045 --> 01:33:41.282
CHAPTER SUPPORT THE BILL.
01:33:41.349 --> 01:33:43.384
PAUL WEB A SMALL BUSINESS OWNER
01:33:43.451 --> 01:33:44.618
IN CHICO AND SUPPORT THE BILL
01:33:44.685 --> 01:33:48.155
THANK YOU -- LORETTA WEBER
01:33:48.222 --> 01:33:49.357
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF VALLEY
01:33:49.423 --> 01:33:51.492
CONTRACTORS EXCHANGE FROM CHICO
01:33:51.559 --> 01:33:54.729
IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL.
01:33:54.795 --> 01:33:56.530
DAMON CONKLIN WITH THE COALITION
01:33:56.597 --> 01:33:58.265
A BUILDER EXCHANGES AND
01:33:58.332 --> 01:33:58.833
CALIFORNIA'S FROM MY SUPPORT
01:33:58.899 --> 01:34:01.602
THANK YOU.
01:34:01.669 --> 01:34:03.437
HI I'M ANGELA KESSLER THE CEO OF
01:34:03.504 --> 01:34:04.638
SUSTAINABILITY MANAGEMENT
01:34:04.705 --> 01:34:07.441
ASSOCIATION WE REPRESENT TWENTY
01:34:07.508 --> 01:34:08.476
EIGHT HUNDRED PLUS MEMBERS IN
01:34:08.542 --> 01:34:09.377
EIGHTEEN COUNTRIES AROUND THE
01:34:09.443 --> 01:34:10.244
WORLD.
01:34:10.311 --> 01:34:11.946
WE DO SUPPORT THE BILL I'M A
01:34:12.013 --> 01:34:13.481
RESIDENT USED TO BE A RESIDENT
01:34:13.547 --> 01:34:15.549
OF PARADISE IS IT POSSIBLE I
01:34:15.616 --> 01:34:16.650
COULD TELL YOU A STORY I KNOW
01:34:16.717 --> 01:34:18.652
I'M SORRY WE'RE GRITTY FINISH
01:34:18.719 --> 01:34:19.253
TAKING TESTIMONY BUT THANK YOU
01:34:19.320 --> 01:34:22.056
FOR COMING.
01:34:22.123 --> 01:34:23.724
I AM CRISTINA TAFT AND I LOST MY
01:34:23.791 --> 01:34:25.426
MOTHER VICTORIA TOUGH IN THE
01:34:25.493 --> 01:34:28.329
FIRE AND I JUST THINK THAT A
01:34:28.396 --> 01:34:31.098
PERKY MEDIA OF THIS CANNOT
01:34:31.165 --> 01:34:32.666
AFFORD THEY USUALLY HUNDRED
01:34:32.733 --> 01:34:33.868
THOUSAND EXTRA SINCE THE
01:34:33.934 --> 01:34:36.270
REGULATIONS.
01:34:36.337 --> 01:34:36.570
TOOK PLACE.
01:34:36.637 --> 01:34:39.607
THANK YOU.
01:34:39.673 --> 01:34:41.642
SCOTT WATER OF FORMER COUNCIL
01:34:41.709 --> 01:34:43.144
MEMBER AND MAYOR PARADISE
01:34:43.210 --> 01:34:44.378
TRAILER DWELLER.
01:34:44.445 --> 01:34:49.016
IN SUPPORT.
01:34:49.083 --> 01:34:51.352
LINDA HORTON LIONS -- I'D LOST
01:34:51.419 --> 01:34:53.888
MY HOME MY HUSBAND SAVED HIS
01:34:53.954 --> 01:34:55.689
BUSINESS.
01:34:55.756 --> 01:34:57.992
ANDI'M PART OF THE LIONS --
01:34:58.059 --> 01:35:00.294
INTERNATIONAL AND WE HAD A
01:35:00.361 --> 01:35:02.696
CENTER AND WE SAW A LOT OF
01:35:02.763 --> 01:35:03.297
EVACUEES.
01:35:03.364 --> 01:35:05.699
LIVING.
01:35:05.766 --> 01:35:08.135
CATCH TO CALC SHOULD WE NEED THE
01:35:08.202 --> 01:35:10.204
HELP AND WERE WERE VERY MUCH IN
01:35:10.271 --> 01:35:11.572
SUPPORT.
01:35:11.639 --> 01:35:12.873
OF THE A. B. FOUR THIRTY THANK
01:35:12.940 --> 01:35:16.844
YOU.
01:35:16.911 --> 01:35:18.779
PHILLY ARISE THAT CAN'T FIRE EVE
01:35:18.846 --> 01:35:20.748
ACCU WE SURVIVOR SPENT THE LAST
01:35:20.815 --> 01:35:22.016
FIVE MONTHS LIVE IN RV IN A
01:35:22.083 --> 01:35:22.950
PARKING LOT.
01:35:23.017 --> 01:35:25.619
WITH OVER FIFTY OTHER TRAILERS --
01:35:25.686 --> 01:35:28.122
WITH FAMILIES AND CHILDREN WITH
01:35:28.189 --> 01:35:30.958
NO WHERE TO GO I'M IN SUPPORT.
01:35:31.025 --> 01:35:32.293
NATHAN WILKINSON THE MERS CITY
01:35:32.359 --> 01:35:33.761
BIGGS AND ALSO THE SON OF
01:35:33.828 --> 01:35:35.129
PARENTS ARE SIR CURRENTLY
01:35:35.196 --> 01:35:37.565
DISPLACED AND LIVING WITH ME SO
01:35:37.631 --> 01:35:38.132
I'M IN STRONG SUPPORT OF THE
01:35:38.199 --> 01:35:41.869
BILL.
01:35:41.936 --> 01:35:43.137
MELISSA SCHUSTER PARADISE TOWN
01:35:43.204 --> 01:35:45.606
COUNCIL SPEAKING FOR MYSELF.
01:35:45.673 --> 01:35:47.608
I LOST MY HOME I AM LIVING IN AN
01:35:47.675 --> 01:35:51.846
RV AND I ALSO SUPPORT THIS BILL.
01:35:51.912 --> 01:35:53.781
MARK SORENSON CITY OF THE BIG
01:35:53.848 --> 01:35:55.249
CITY ADMINISTRATOR AND FORMER
01:35:55.316 --> 01:35:57.351
PLANNING COMMISSIONER COUNCIL
01:35:57.418 --> 01:35:59.753
MEMBER MAYOR CITY A CHICO AND TO
01:35:59.820 --> 01:36:02.089
MY DAUGHTERS AND THEIR FAMILIES
01:36:02.156 --> 01:36:03.824
THREE MY TWO GRANDCHILDREN LOST
01:36:03.891 --> 01:36:05.960
THEIR HOMES IN PARADISE.
01:36:06.026 --> 01:36:07.194
STRONG SUPPORT.
01:36:07.261 --> 01:36:08.262
THANK YOU IS THERE ANYBODY
01:36:08.329 --> 01:36:09.430
WISHING TO TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION
01:36:09.497 --> 01:36:16.837
TO THE BILL.
01:36:16.904 --> 01:36:20.574
IF THERE ARE -- YEAH WE CAN HAVE
01:36:20.641 --> 01:36:22.109
THREE PEOPLE -- SET UP HERE AND
01:36:22.176 --> 01:36:23.377
IF ONE OF THE WITNESSES COULD
01:36:23.444 --> 01:36:24.545
MOVE PLEASE.
01:36:24.612 --> 01:36:26.547
AND THAT ANYONE ELSE WILL BE
01:36:26.614 --> 01:36:27.481
ABLE TO TESTIFY [inaudible]
01:36:27.548 --> 01:36:30.651
AFTERWARDS
01:36:30.718 --> 01:36:31.852
and the two minutes apiece
01:36:34.922 --> 01:36:36.724
I'm a resident I'm grace Marvin
01:36:36.790 --> 01:36:38.492
resident of Chico concerned
01:36:38.559 --> 01:36:40.694
about four thirty unnecessarily
01:36:40.761 --> 01:36:42.730
taking away the role of our
01:36:42.796 --> 01:36:44.565
local community and planning
01:36:44.632 --> 01:36:46.700
housing and parking and then
01:36:46.767 --> 01:36:48.569
removing the crucial role of
01:36:48.636 --> 01:36:50.471
the sequel -- in assessing
01:36:50.538 --> 01:36:52.873
future developments the bill
01:36:52.940 --> 01:36:54.875
states that it would it it's
01:36:54.942 --> 01:36:56.777
a matter of statewide concern
01:36:56.844 --> 01:36:58.179
rather than a municipal
01:36:58.245 --> 01:37:00.147
affair and it applies only to
01:37:00.214 --> 01:37:02.550
BiÃu six it also said that
01:37:02.616 --> 01:37:04.084
seek what does not apply to
01:37:04.151 --> 01:37:06.520
the approved projects and
01:37:06.587 --> 01:37:09.190
more over its says that --
01:37:09.890 --> 01:37:11.325
with respect to streamline
01:37:11.392 --> 01:37:14.695
ministerial approach the the
01:37:14.762 --> 01:37:16.497
county of Butte would in other
01:37:16.564 --> 01:37:18.165
words lose control to the
01:37:18.232 --> 01:37:20.367
state mandated local program
01:37:21.936 --> 01:37:23.737
we are concerned about the role
01:37:23.804 --> 01:37:25.906
of and mission of see cça and
01:37:25.973 --> 01:37:27.775
its review of people's physical
01:37:27.841 --> 01:37:29.476
health and safety and the need
01:37:29.543 --> 01:37:31.512
to protect plants trees water
01:37:31.579 --> 01:37:33.948
ways and critters in our natural
01:37:34.014 --> 01:37:35.649
environment and any proposed
01:37:35.716 --> 01:37:37.985
development why should we drop
01:37:38.052 --> 01:37:40.087
those concerns about people and
01:37:40.154 --> 01:37:42.223
nature in the nay in the name
01:37:42.289 --> 01:37:44.358
of supposedly helping people
01:37:44.825 --> 01:37:46.360
moreover I spoke with this
01:37:46.927 --> 01:37:49.163
the mayor of of of
01:37:50.731 --> 01:37:52.633
Chico and he sent you a
01:37:52.700 --> 01:37:55.202
letter today regarding his
01:37:55.269 --> 01:37:57.438
opposition to it and in that
01:37:57.504 --> 01:37:59.273
letter he wrote I am white
01:37:59.340 --> 01:38:01.342
writing his name is mayor
01:38:01.942 --> 01:38:03.644
Randall stone I am writing to
01:38:03.711 --> 01:38:05.813
convey my personal opposition
01:38:06.013 --> 01:38:08.415
unless amended to at AB four
01:38:08.482 --> 01:38:10.417
thirty I have communicated
01:38:10.484 --> 01:38:12.119
my opposition to the bill as
01:38:12.186 --> 01:38:13.587
currently written to author
01:38:13.654 --> 01:38:15.889
meant to author assemblyman
01:38:15.956 --> 01:38:17.958
member James Gallagher and
01:38:18.025 --> 01:38:19.426
look forward to working with
01:38:19.493 --> 01:38:21.195
the member once the preemption
01:38:21.262 --> 01:38:22.696
to conditional land use
01:38:22.763 --> 01:38:24.665
authority is redacted the
01:38:24.732 --> 01:38:26.834
Chico city council did not have
01:38:26.900 --> 01:38:28.435
an opportunity ahead of this
01:38:28.502 --> 01:38:30.771
hearing to discuss and or issue
01:38:30.838 --> 01:38:33.240
and oppose unless amended letter
01:38:33.507 --> 01:38:34.975
additionally the Butte County
01:38:35.042 --> 01:38:36.677
Board of supervisors letter of
01:38:36.744 --> 01:38:38.946
support did not seek approved
01:38:39.013 --> 01:38:40.447
the approval of either of the
01:38:40.514 --> 01:38:42.249
two suit supervisors in the
01:38:42.316 --> 01:38:44.785
Chico area overwhelmingly the
01:38:44.852 --> 01:38:46.954
most populated city pre and
01:38:47.021 --> 01:38:49.456
post campfire our community
01:38:49.523 --> 01:38:51.025
is concerned about lifting
01:38:51.091 --> 01:38:53.060
conditional land use authority
01:38:53.260 --> 01:38:54.428
ma'am your your two minutes are
01:38:54.495 --> 01:38:55.896
up -- if I would like one of
01:38:55.963 --> 01:38:57.731
your colleagues to finish okay
01:38:59.800 --> 01:39:00.968
and and we also have the letter
01:39:01.035 --> 01:39:02.269
so unless you want to read into
01:39:02.336 --> 01:39:03.270
the record we've lost we all
01:39:03.337 --> 01:39:05.606
have the letter read read
01:39:05.673 --> 01:39:07.174
this part that starting here
01:39:08.108 --> 01:39:09.643
the city of Chico currently
01:39:09.710 --> 01:39:11.245
has twenty five hundred single
01:39:11.312 --> 01:39:13.180
for family units and twenty
01:39:13.247 --> 01:39:14.548
eight hundred multi family
01:39:14.615 --> 01:39:16.216
units of housing in various
01:39:16.283 --> 01:39:18.152
stages of development that
01:39:18.218 --> 01:39:20.654
are overwhelmingly not pending
01:39:20.721 --> 01:39:22.956
city regulatory authority
01:39:23.257 --> 01:39:24.892
I see AB for thirty as a
01:39:24.958 --> 01:39:26.794
considerable over reach a
01:39:26.860 --> 01:39:28.862
potential state preemption under
01:39:28.929 --> 01:39:30.664
any circumstances let alone
01:39:30.731 --> 01:39:33.167
potentially that opposition to
01:39:33.233 --> 01:39:35.402
the most impacted jurisdictions
01:39:35.869 --> 01:39:37.504
I am urging a no vote to pass
01:39:37.571 --> 01:39:39.106
this bill to appropriations
01:39:39.173 --> 01:39:40.741
unless amended should you have
01:39:40.808 --> 01:39:42.343
any questions about my personal
01:39:42.409 --> 01:39:44.078
opposition of this bill please
01:39:44.144 --> 01:39:46.313
do not hesitate to contact me
01:39:47.748 --> 01:39:50.451
next okay I have something
01:39:50.517 --> 01:39:52.720
to -- I mean the main
01:39:53.320 --> 01:39:54.922
the thing is that I mean
01:39:55.356 --> 01:39:57.424
I have total sympathy and
01:39:57.491 --> 01:39:59.827
empathy for the survivors
01:39:59.893 --> 01:40:01.028
of the campfire in the fire
01:40:01.095 --> 01:40:02.629
came within ten feet of my
01:40:02.696 --> 01:40:04.798
own house and I was evacuated
01:40:05.232 --> 01:40:07.901
but I am I see this
01:40:07.968 --> 01:40:09.803
as a really stunning over
01:40:09.870 --> 01:40:12.306
reach of power into the locally
01:40:12.373 --> 01:40:13.941
elected representatives of Butte
01:40:14.007 --> 01:40:15.576
county local governments as
01:40:15.642 --> 01:40:17.878
the mayor said -- the locally
01:40:17.945 --> 01:40:19.279
elected officials should always
01:40:19.346 --> 01:40:20.814
have the decision making power
01:40:20.881 --> 01:40:22.750
over their development and
01:40:22.816 --> 01:40:23.884
since they're already fifty
01:40:23.951 --> 01:40:25.652
three hundred approved future
01:40:25.719 --> 01:40:28.188
residences in Chico many of us
01:40:28.255 --> 01:40:29.723
see the logical next step is
01:40:29.790 --> 01:40:31.892
building the opportunity sites
01:40:31.959 --> 01:40:33.527
already listed in the general
01:40:33.594 --> 01:40:36.196
plan which already has expensive
01:40:36.263 --> 01:40:38.098
infrastructure in place this
01:40:38.165 --> 01:40:39.333
would offer the possibility
01:40:39.400 --> 01:40:40.968
of efficient public transit
01:40:41.034 --> 01:40:42.703
walkability and particular
01:40:42.770 --> 01:40:44.705
affordable housing quickly in
01:40:44.772 --> 01:40:46.106
addition the sequel approval
01:40:46.173 --> 01:40:48.075
process is there to not only
01:40:48.142 --> 01:40:49.610
protect the environment and
01:40:49.676 --> 01:40:51.812
the last remaining five percent
01:40:52.045 --> 01:40:53.447
of our endangered species but
01:40:53.514 --> 01:40:54.748
also to protect the health and
01:40:54.815 --> 01:40:57.251
safety of the people large or
01:40:57.317 --> 01:40:58.685
small developments which are not
01:40:58.752 --> 01:41:00.521
able to pass carbon emissions
01:41:00.721 --> 01:41:02.890
worsen air quality and climate
01:41:02.956 --> 01:41:04.725
change and should not be allowed
01:41:05.025 --> 01:41:06.560
the irony would be to approve a
01:41:06.627 --> 01:41:08.896
bill like AB for thirty and
01:41:08.962 --> 01:41:11.432
streamline this process on the
01:41:11.498 --> 01:41:12.833
kinds of developments which
01:41:12.900 --> 01:41:14.802
actually would contribute to
01:41:14.868 --> 01:41:17.104
such disasters events disastrous
01:41:17.171 --> 01:41:19.373
events as the campfire emerging
01:41:19.440 --> 01:41:20.541
a no vote okay can you just
01:41:20.607 --> 01:41:21.775
identify yourself there was
01:41:21.842 --> 01:41:23.477
a Beth Devereaux from Chico
01:41:23.544 --> 01:41:25.212
thank you last witness please
01:41:26.046 --> 01:41:27.614
good afternoon madam chair and
01:41:27.681 --> 01:41:29.516
members of the committee my name
01:41:29.583 --> 01:41:31.452
is Molly Colton I'm an organizer
01:41:31.518 --> 01:41:32.953
an advocate for Sierra Club
01:41:33.020 --> 01:41:34.988
California I was also born and
01:41:35.055 --> 01:41:37.057
raised and paradise my family
01:41:37.124 --> 01:41:38.425
and friends lost everything in
01:41:38.492 --> 01:41:40.727
the camp fire being from Butte
01:41:40.794 --> 01:41:42.362
county I know first hand the
01:41:42.429 --> 01:41:44.565
impact this bill could have on
01:41:44.631 --> 01:41:46.166
the region and the necessity of
01:41:46.233 --> 01:41:48.001
housing for wild fire victims
01:41:48.068 --> 01:41:49.670
including my friends and family
01:41:50.370 --> 01:41:52.039
I also understand the need for
01:41:52.105 --> 01:41:54.341
environmental protection given
01:41:54.408 --> 01:41:55.809
that our official position
01:41:55.876 --> 01:41:57.544
on the bill is opposed unless
01:41:57.611 --> 01:41:59.346
amended as we believe sequel
01:41:59.413 --> 01:42:00.914
provides the opportunity
01:42:01.215 --> 01:42:02.349
for prudent environmental
01:42:02.416 --> 01:42:04.785
consideration we have provided
01:42:04.852 --> 01:42:06.653
the author with for specific
01:42:06.720 --> 01:42:08.455
amendments that we believe would
01:42:08.522 --> 01:42:09.957
provide greater environmental
01:42:10.023 --> 01:42:12.125
protection to the bill we've
01:42:12.192 --> 01:42:13.327
met with the author and are
01:42:13.393 --> 01:42:14.928
pleased that he has committed
01:42:14.995 --> 01:42:16.663
to adopting these amendments
01:42:17.397 --> 01:42:18.565
I am confident that we can
01:42:18.632 --> 01:42:20.200
work with the author to reach
01:42:20.267 --> 01:42:22.035
a neutral position and craft
01:42:22.102 --> 01:42:23.704
a bill that would best strike
01:42:23.770 --> 01:42:25.339
a balance between providing
01:42:25.405 --> 01:42:27.407
affordable infill housing for
01:42:27.474 --> 01:42:29.576
wild fire victims that best
01:42:29.643 --> 01:42:31.078
coincides with environmental
01:42:31.144 --> 01:42:33.046
preservation we look forward
01:42:33.113 --> 01:42:34.648
to removing our opposition
01:42:34.715 --> 01:42:36.116
upon seeing upon seeing the
01:42:36.183 --> 01:42:37.684
amendments and print thank you
01:42:38.452 --> 01:42:39.553
thank you is running body else
01:42:39.620 --> 01:42:41.054
wishing to testify in opposition
01:42:41.121 --> 01:42:43.423
to the bill Melissa Romero
01:42:43.490 --> 01:42:44.491
on behalf of the California
01:42:44.558 --> 01:42:45.826
league of conservation voters
01:42:45.893 --> 01:42:47.194
and I line our comments with
01:42:47.261 --> 01:42:49.062
those of Sierra Club California
01:42:49.363 --> 01:42:50.964
thank you thank you all bring
01:42:51.031 --> 01:42:51.965
it back now to the committee
01:42:52.032 --> 01:42:54.067
for for comments or questions
01:42:55.536 --> 01:42:56.770
assemblymember Melinda's
01:42:58.839 --> 01:43:00.107
thank you madam chair I'm I'm
01:43:00.173 --> 01:43:02.242
sorry the witnesses already
01:43:02.543 --> 01:43:04.077
left the table of your rate
01:43:04.144 --> 01:43:05.812
here so of the three you
01:43:05.879 --> 01:43:06.580
don't have to come back at
01:43:06.647 --> 01:43:07.948
me and you may sit down I'm
01:43:08.015 --> 01:43:10.183
just of the three of you
01:43:10.517 --> 01:43:12.419
who how many of you lost
01:43:12.486 --> 01:43:14.655
your your home the three
01:43:14.721 --> 01:43:15.989
to testify in opposition
01:43:19.126 --> 01:43:20.360
seven nine if you lost your
01:43:20.427 --> 01:43:23.096
home in the fire thank you so
01:43:24.331 --> 01:43:26.466
here's my concern is that
01:43:26.533 --> 01:43:27.734
from what I understand Mister
01:43:27.801 --> 01:43:29.603
Gallagher there's some issue
01:43:29.670 --> 01:43:31.204
with the conditional use
01:43:31.271 --> 01:43:32.773
land permit is that correct
01:43:34.841 --> 01:43:36.777
I think what has been brought
01:43:36.843 --> 01:43:38.178
up is it somehow this would
01:43:38.245 --> 01:43:40.480
take away local control -- I
01:43:40.547 --> 01:43:42.149
I disagree with that contention
01:43:42.215 --> 01:43:43.483
if you read the terms of the
01:43:43.550 --> 01:43:46.486
bill -- first of all it requires
01:43:46.553 --> 01:43:48.055
-- that these would have to go
01:43:48.121 --> 01:43:49.156
through the planning commission
01:43:49.222 --> 01:43:50.457
process that have to go to
01:43:50.524 --> 01:43:51.858
this to the city council or the
01:43:51.925 --> 01:43:53.093
board of supervisors whatever
01:43:53.160 --> 01:43:55.062
the case may be -- it would
01:43:55.128 --> 01:43:56.330
have to be consistent with
01:43:56.396 --> 01:43:57.798
the general plan and zoning
01:43:58.332 --> 01:43:59.533
so as we all know many of us
01:43:59.600 --> 01:44:00.934
are and local government you
01:44:01.001 --> 01:44:03.103
you do a plan the do a general
01:44:03.170 --> 01:44:04.771
plan that you establish where
01:44:04.838 --> 01:44:06.173
where residential is going to
01:44:06.239 --> 01:44:07.908
be what zoned residential so
01:44:07.975 --> 01:44:09.309
you've already planned and said
01:44:09.376 --> 01:44:11.111
this is okay for a committee
01:44:11.178 --> 01:44:12.412
that's worry what the building
01:44:12.479 --> 01:44:14.281
taking place would presumably
01:44:14.348 --> 01:44:16.450
have to coincide with whatever
01:44:16.516 --> 01:44:17.951
the city's general plan AB
01:44:18.018 --> 01:44:19.586
radio right hundred there's no
01:44:19.653 --> 01:44:21.421
changing of zoning no change
01:44:21.488 --> 01:44:23.490
in accounting the the change
01:44:23.557 --> 01:44:25.258
would be that we're trying to
01:44:25.626 --> 01:44:27.461
-- speed up the process by
01:44:27.527 --> 01:44:28.996
which people could rebuild their
01:44:29.062 --> 01:44:31.331
lives is that a fair way of
01:44:31.398 --> 01:44:33.200
explaining it exactly bill
01:44:33.266 --> 01:44:34.868
bring on more housing that we've
01:44:34.935 --> 01:44:36.136
already planned for as soon as
01:44:36.203 --> 01:44:38.138
possible so that we can house
01:44:38.205 --> 01:44:39.940
fire victims okay thank you
01:44:41.842 --> 01:44:43.510
thank you some of the real
01:44:43.577 --> 01:44:45.846
amount I think you
01:44:45.912 --> 01:44:46.980
as a member Gallagher for
01:44:47.047 --> 01:44:48.649
bringing this forward and
01:44:49.049 --> 01:44:50.350
certainly as someone who is
01:44:50.417 --> 01:44:52.552
impacted whose district was
01:44:52.619 --> 01:44:54.321
impacted by the Thomas fire in
01:44:54.388 --> 01:44:56.423
the a subsequent debris flows
01:44:56.490 --> 01:44:58.025
I understand how important
01:44:58.091 --> 01:44:59.993
it is to rebuild and to get
01:45:00.060 --> 01:45:02.696
our community -- functioning
01:45:02.763 --> 01:45:04.965
and moving in as normal
01:45:05.999 --> 01:45:07.534
as a way possible in the most
01:45:07.601 --> 01:45:09.069
a normal circumstances and
01:45:09.136 --> 01:45:11.405
it is very difficult -- one
01:45:11.471 --> 01:45:12.939
of the elements that I I've
01:45:13.006 --> 01:45:14.107
been kind of you and I had
01:45:14.174 --> 01:45:15.308
a conversation about it that
01:45:15.375 --> 01:45:16.476
we've been trying to figure out
01:45:16.543 --> 01:45:18.679
is AB you know the removing of
01:45:18.745 --> 01:45:20.547
the sea quest -- piece of it
01:45:20.614 --> 01:45:23.450
and I the conversations
01:45:23.517 --> 01:45:25.485
in my district still --
01:45:25.552 --> 01:45:28.255
happening and -- I have
01:45:28.321 --> 01:45:31.091
not felt the positive impact
01:45:31.158 --> 01:45:33.393
of public input and through
01:45:33.460 --> 01:45:35.062
the review process as much
01:45:35.762 --> 01:45:37.664
-- for any other issue I've
01:45:37.731 --> 01:45:38.699
had to deal with than with
01:45:38.765 --> 01:45:41.168
rebuilding our community -- and
01:45:41.234 --> 01:45:44.271
so seen that it would be removed
01:45:44.337 --> 01:45:46.139
-- because it's you know seek
01:45:46.206 --> 01:45:47.674
was a much thorough is something
01:45:47.741 --> 01:45:48.875
that you know I just throw
01:45:48.942 --> 01:45:50.744
out there -- our community
01:45:50.811 --> 01:45:52.946
has been very involved in what
01:45:53.013 --> 01:45:55.115
rebuilding looks like -- there
01:45:55.182 --> 01:45:57.317
have been really tough not just
01:45:57.384 --> 01:45:59.119
individual owner conversations
01:45:59.186 --> 01:46:00.454
but community conversations
01:46:00.520 --> 01:46:02.823
about area that can no longer be
01:46:02.889 --> 01:46:04.357
rebuilt because the topography
01:46:04.424 --> 01:46:06.827
itself change and you know
01:46:06.893 --> 01:46:08.729
watching a community go through
01:46:08.795 --> 01:46:10.630
a process to have to decide
01:46:10.931 --> 01:46:12.799
that ex number of homes won't
01:46:12.866 --> 01:46:13.867
be rebuilt and now we're
01:46:13.934 --> 01:46:14.968
going to service the debris
01:46:15.035 --> 01:46:17.871
basin -- was very difficult
01:46:18.271 --> 01:46:19.573
-- individuals had to make a
01:46:19.639 --> 01:46:21.174
decision but also community
01:46:21.241 --> 01:46:22.442
had to come around and support
01:46:22.509 --> 01:46:24.778
some of these decisions a throw
01:46:24.845 --> 01:46:26.646
that out there because I know
01:46:26.713 --> 01:46:28.715
sometimes we feel that seek when
01:46:28.782 --> 01:46:30.650
the public input process can
01:46:31.518 --> 01:46:32.119
THE DISTRICT HAVE
01:46:32.185 --> 01:46:33.520
ALSO SEEN IT UNDER THIS
01:46:33.587 --> 01:46:35.388
CIRCUMSTANCE ALSO BE PART OF THE
01:46:35.455 --> 01:46:35.655
CEILING.
01:46:35.722 --> 01:46:37.691
IN TERMS OF THIS IS HOW WE
01:46:37.758 --> 01:46:40.127
REBUILD -- INDIVIDUAL DECISIONS
01:46:40.193 --> 01:46:42.329
HAVE HAD TO BE MADE AS WELL AS
01:46:42.395 --> 01:46:44.064
COLLECTIVE DECISIONS FOR THE
01:46:44.131 --> 01:46:45.432
COMMUNITY AND I JUST.
01:46:45.499 --> 01:46:46.967
AS THIS DISCUSSION CONTINUES I
01:46:47.033 --> 01:46:48.168
UNDERSTAND WE'RE NOT VOTING ON
01:46:48.235 --> 01:46:50.670
THIS TODAY BUT YOU KNOW THERE.
01:46:50.737 --> 01:46:52.172
THERE HAS BEEN GREAT VALUE TO
01:46:52.239 --> 01:46:54.141
THE PUBLIC.
01:46:54.207 --> 01:46:56.143
IN DEATH PROCESS -- IN THIS
01:46:56.209 --> 01:46:57.511
PARTICULAR CASE IT'S BEEN VERY
01:46:57.577 --> 01:46:59.446
DIFFICULT AND I CERTAINLY
01:46:59.513 --> 01:47:01.882
UNDERSTAND -- WHERE YOU AND THE
01:47:01.948 --> 01:47:03.250
COMMUNITY ARE COMING FROM LIKE
01:47:03.316 --> 01:47:04.951
EIGHT IS IMPORTANT? TO HELP OUR
01:47:05.018 --> 01:47:06.720
COMMUNITY REBUILT AND IT WILL BE
01:47:06.787 --> 01:47:09.689
YEARS -- BUT BUT I WANTED TO US
01:47:09.756 --> 01:47:11.358
TO ALSO THINK ABOUT THAT AND
01:47:11.424 --> 01:47:12.726
THERE'S JUST.
01:47:12.793 --> 01:47:14.227
A FEW INSTANCES OF IN OUR
01:47:14.294 --> 01:47:15.695
COMMUNITY WHERE IT REALLY HAS
01:47:15.762 --> 01:47:17.998
HELPED.
01:47:18.064 --> 01:47:19.900
THANK YOU A SUMMER MATHIS.
01:47:19.966 --> 01:47:21.268
THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR.
01:47:21.334 --> 01:47:22.936
SO I JUST WANNA MAKE SURE I'M
01:47:23.003 --> 01:47:26.940
HEARING EVERYTHING A RIGHT SO.
01:47:27.007 --> 01:47:28.308
WE'RE NOT TAKING AWAY LOCAL
01:47:28.375 --> 01:47:30.510
CONTROL FROM SAY THE CITY OF
01:47:30.577 --> 01:47:32.212
CHICO FOR ISSUE IN A BUILDING
01:47:32.279 --> 01:47:34.781
PERMIT WE'RE DECIDING NOT. TO
01:47:34.848 --> 01:47:36.082
ISSUE A BUILDING PERMIT IS THAT
01:47:36.149 --> 01:47:37.784
CORRECT.
01:47:37.851 --> 01:47:39.252
NO I MEAN WHAT WOULD HAPPEN IS
01:47:39.319 --> 01:47:41.688
SIMILAR TO SB -- THIRTY FIVE
01:47:41.755 --> 01:47:42.956
WHICH WAS PASSED A COUPLE YEARS
01:47:43.023 --> 01:47:43.690
AGO.
01:47:43.757 --> 01:47:46.426
IS IT THESE ARE VERY LIMITED
01:47:46.493 --> 01:47:48.161
TYPES OF PROJECTS NUMBER ONE
01:47:48.228 --> 01:47:49.296
THEY HAVE TO BE CONSISTENT WITH
01:47:49.362 --> 01:47:51.097
THE GENERAL PLAN AND ZONING SO
01:47:51.164 --> 01:47:52.499
THAT ALREADY HAVE TO BE.
01:47:52.566 --> 01:47:54.134
A PLACE IT'S ZONED RESIDENTIAL
01:47:54.201 --> 01:47:55.335
THAT'S ALREADY BEEN AYE ZONE AND
01:47:55.402 --> 01:47:56.336
GONE THROUGH AND NOT EASILY CORE
01:47:56.403 --> 01:47:58.038
PROCESS AND EVERYTHING LOOKING
01:47:58.104 --> 01:47:59.339
AT THE ZONING CURRENT EXACTLY
01:47:59.406 --> 01:48:00.540
AND THEN IT HAD CAN'T.
01:48:00.607 --> 01:48:03.109
INVOLVE -- YOU KNOW ON A FLOOD
01:48:03.176 --> 01:48:05.212
PLAIN AGRICULTURALLY PROTECTED
01:48:05.278 --> 01:48:08.081
AREA OR OTHER BUYER MENTALLY
01:48:08.148 --> 01:48:10.250
SENSITIVE AREA -- SO IT'S IT'S
01:48:10.317 --> 01:48:11.618
THERE'S GONNA BE A LIMITED
01:48:11.685 --> 01:48:12.819
AMOUNT OF PROJECTS HERE BUT IT'S
01:48:12.886 --> 01:48:14.821
IMPORTANT TOOL AND WHAT IT WOULD
01:48:14.888 --> 01:48:16.423
DO FOR THE SO IN THOSE LIMITED
01:48:16.489 --> 01:48:20.060
CIRCUMSTANCES IT WOULD BE A
01:48:20.126 --> 01:48:21.928
MINISTERIAL PROCESS.
01:48:21.995 --> 01:48:22.596
THE SO AS LONG AS YOU MET THAT
01:48:22.662 --> 01:48:24.164
CRITERIA YOU GET APPROVED BUT
01:48:24.231 --> 01:48:24.698
YOU WOULD STILL HAVE TO GO
01:48:24.764 --> 01:48:26.299
THROUGH.
01:48:26.366 --> 01:48:27.868
THE THE PLANNING COMMISSION
01:48:27.934 --> 01:48:29.836
YOU'D STILL HAVE TO GO TO THE
01:48:29.903 --> 01:48:30.971
THE BOARD.
01:48:31.037 --> 01:48:32.505
IT WOULD BE PUBLIC INPUT
01:48:32.572 --> 01:48:34.074
THROUGHOUT THAT PROCESS.
01:48:34.140 --> 01:48:35.642
AND AS LONG AS IT MET THE
01:48:35.709 --> 01:48:37.544
CRITERIA AND MEETS THE OBJECT
01:48:37.611 --> 01:48:38.712
YOU COULD ALSO HAVE DESIGN
01:48:38.778 --> 01:48:39.880
CRITERIA.
01:48:39.946 --> 01:48:42.449
IN PLACES MANY COMMUNITIES DO.
01:48:42.515 --> 01:48:43.583
AND AS LONG AS A MET THAT
01:48:43.650 --> 01:48:45.252
CRITERIA IT WOULD IT WOULD BE
01:48:45.318 --> 01:48:47.587
MINISTERIAL E. APPROVED BY THE
01:48:47.654 --> 01:48:48.655
LOCAL GOVERNMENT.
01:48:48.722 --> 01:48:49.789
NOW SOME MIGHT TAKE THAT IS
01:48:49.856 --> 01:48:51.424
TAKING AWAY THEIR THEIR
01:48:51.491 --> 01:48:53.326
CONTROLLER DISCRETION BECAUSE OF
01:48:53.393 --> 01:48:55.061
THAT FACT THERE.
01:48:55.128 --> 01:48:56.496
BUT AGAIN THERE'S A LOT.
01:48:56.563 --> 01:48:57.664
THAT GOES INTO THAT THIS IS A
01:48:57.731 --> 01:48:59.599
VERY LIMITED AMOUNT OF PROJECTS
01:48:59.666 --> 01:49:02.068
AND IT'S AN IMPORTANT TOOL.
01:49:02.135 --> 01:49:02.669
BECAUSE ULTIMATELY WHAT WE'RE
01:49:02.736 --> 01:49:04.938
LOOKING AT IS WE HAVE A LOT OF
01:49:05.005 --> 01:49:05.705
PEOPLE THAT ARE OUT OF THEIR
01:49:05.772 --> 01:49:07.340
HOMES AND SO I NEED TO TRY AND
01:49:07.407 --> 01:49:09.309
BRING ONLINE HOUSING AS FAST AS
01:49:09.376 --> 01:49:10.176
POSSIBLE.
01:49:10.243 --> 01:49:11.878
AND WE'RE SAYING HEY WE'RE WE'RE
01:49:11.945 --> 01:49:13.313
COMMUNITIES OF ALREADY DECIDED.
01:49:13.380 --> 01:49:15.315
IT MAKES SENSE TO HAVE GROWTH
01:49:15.382 --> 01:49:16.716
AND BUILDING LET'S GET IT DONE.
01:49:16.783 --> 01:49:17.918
IS ESSENTIALLY WHAT WE'RE DOING
01:49:17.984 --> 01:49:19.386
FOR EXAMPLE THE THE MAYOR OF
01:49:19.452 --> 01:49:23.223
CHICO AS THESE CONCERNS THROUGH
01:49:23.290 --> 01:49:24.090
THE PLANNING PROCESS COULD.
01:49:24.157 --> 01:49:25.659
HOLD PUBLIC EVENT TO GET PUBLIC
01:49:25.725 --> 01:49:28.395
COMMENT ON ANY PUBLIC CONCERNS
01:49:28.461 --> 01:49:30.463
REGARDING.
01:49:30.530 --> 01:49:32.065
THE THE PLANNING OF A SAY THE
01:49:32.132 --> 01:49:33.900
HOMES THAT THE IS ALREADY ZONED
01:49:33.967 --> 01:49:36.770
FOR CORRECT.
01:49:36.836 --> 01:49:38.171
I'VE JUST HEARD ABOUT THIS
01:49:38.238 --> 01:49:39.940
LETTER TODAY MYSELF I HAVEN'T
01:49:40.006 --> 01:49:41.508
HAD A CHANCE EVEN READ THERE'S A
01:49:41.574 --> 01:49:42.375
LIMIT IS MAYOR I COULD
01:49:42.442 --> 01:49:43.810
DEFINITELY HAVE PUBLIC COMMENT
01:49:43.877 --> 01:49:44.678
TIME IT.
01:49:44.744 --> 01:49:47.747
THROUGH THE PLANNING PROCESS
01:49:47.814 --> 01:49:48.882
IRONY I IS I AM A OR IF YOU
01:49:48.949 --> 01:49:49.983
WANTED.
01:49:50.050 --> 01:49:51.351
TO I FEEL VERY CONFIDENT THAT
01:49:51.418 --> 01:49:52.519
THERE WILL BE A LOT OF PUBLIC
01:49:52.585 --> 01:49:54.821
INPUT INTO THESE PROJECTS IF
01:49:54.888 --> 01:49:57.390
THIS BILL WERE TO PASS YES.
01:49:57.457 --> 01:49:58.591
BUT SOME PEOPLE WOULD ARGUE BUT
01:49:58.658 --> 01:50:00.627
SEQUEL WOULD BE BYPASSED YEAH SO
01:50:00.694 --> 01:50:02.329
YOU'RE NOT TYING HIS HANDS ON
01:50:02.395 --> 01:50:05.098
THE PUBLIC PROCESS OR OR AS OUR
01:50:05.165 --> 01:50:06.366
COLLEAGUE HAS SAID YOU KNOW
01:50:06.433 --> 01:50:07.767
MAKING SURE THE COMMUNITY.
01:50:07.834 --> 01:50:09.069
CAN COME TOGETHER AND HILL IN
01:50:09.135 --> 01:50:10.570
THE DIFFERENT AREAS THEY THEY
01:50:10.637 --> 01:50:11.504
COULD ALL.
01:50:11.571 --> 01:50:13.506
MEET IN AND TALK ABOUT IT
01:50:13.573 --> 01:50:15.275
PUBLICLY THERE IN CHICO JUST
01:50:15.342 --> 01:50:17.644
LIKE IS THE THE PEOPLE AND
01:50:17.711 --> 01:50:18.912
PARADISE TO BE ABLE TO GET
01:50:18.979 --> 01:50:22.782
TOGETHER AND TALK.
01:50:22.849 --> 01:50:23.917
CORRECT.
01:50:23.984 --> 01:50:24.584
THAT'S MY UNDERSTANDING YES OKAY
01:50:24.651 --> 01:50:25.852
SIDE.
01:50:25.919 --> 01:50:26.686
HE STILL HAS THE OPPORTUNITY TO
01:50:26.753 --> 01:50:28.088
BE MAYOR SO I THINK YOU'RE BILLS
01:50:28.154 --> 01:50:33.293
GREAT.
01:50:33.360 --> 01:50:33.827
THANK YOU ASSEMBLY MEMBER
01:50:33.893 --> 01:50:35.295
MCCARTY.
01:50:35.362 --> 01:50:36.796
THANK YOU A MANAGER AT THANK YOU
01:50:36.863 --> 01:50:39.199
MISTER GALLAGHER -- FOR FOR FOR
01:50:39.265 --> 01:50:40.867
THEY HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO ONE
01:50:40.934 --> 01:50:41.534
TALK ABOUT TODAY AND YOUR
01:50:41.601 --> 01:50:42.869
CONSTITUENTS DROVE ALL THE WAY
01:50:42.936 --> 01:50:43.970
HERE BUT FOR ALSO.
01:50:44.037 --> 01:50:46.339
SAYING TO WORK WITH THE AT
01:50:46.406 --> 01:50:47.507
COMMITTEE STAFF.
01:50:47.574 --> 01:50:49.175
AND THE CHAIR TO TRY TO COME TO
01:50:49.242 --> 01:50:50.210
A CONCLUSION HERE BECAUSE I
01:50:50.276 --> 01:50:51.344
THINK WE'RE ALL.
01:50:51.411 --> 01:50:53.980
VERY SYMPATHETIC -- TO TO THE
01:50:54.047 --> 01:50:55.582
CONCERNS OF DEALING WITH THE
01:50:55.648 --> 01:50:57.384
COMMUNITY THAT SUFFERED A GREAT
01:50:57.450 --> 01:50:58.818
TRAGEDY IN TRYING TO REBUILD
01:50:58.885 --> 01:50:59.986
UNFATHOMABLE.
01:51:00.053 --> 01:51:01.588
WITH THAT THE MAGNITUDE OF OF
01:51:01.654 --> 01:51:03.390
ALL THAT IS NOT MY DISTRICT I
01:51:03.456 --> 01:51:05.425
DON'T SO I DON'T SEE IT -- BUT
01:51:05.492 --> 01:51:06.593
ALSO TRYING TO IT HERE TO OUR
01:51:06.659 --> 01:51:08.294
CALIFORNIA POLICIES AND OUR
01:51:08.361 --> 01:51:10.163
VALUES SO I DO WANNA TO HAVE TO
01:51:10.230 --> 01:51:11.998
ASK A QUESTION FOLLOW UP WITH
01:51:12.065 --> 01:51:13.433
MISTER MATHIS ITSELF I WAS A
01:51:13.500 --> 01:51:14.034
FORMER.
01:51:14.100 --> 01:51:16.069
LOCAL GOVERNMENT OFFICIAL JUST
01:51:16.136 --> 01:51:16.836
LIKE YOU.
01:51:16.903 --> 01:51:19.139
AND I UNDERSTANDING IS THAT.
01:51:19.205 --> 01:51:21.741
THAT ONCE THE PROPERTY IS IS --
01:51:21.808 --> 01:51:23.143
PROPERLY ZONE.
01:51:23.209 --> 01:51:25.979
IN RESIDENTIAL AND SINGLE FAMILY.
01:51:26.046 --> 01:51:28.648
YOU GO IN AND GET YOUR APPROVAL
01:51:28.715 --> 01:51:30.283
FROM THE CITY AND IT IS A
01:51:30.350 --> 01:51:32.452
MINISTERIAL DECISION SO.
01:51:32.519 --> 01:51:34.120
RIGHT BUT YOU SAY THERE'S SOME
01:51:34.187 --> 01:51:35.889
TYPE OF DEVELOPMENTS THAT WOULD
01:51:35.955 --> 01:51:38.324
BE DIFFERENT CAN YOU EXPAND.
01:51:38.391 --> 01:51:40.126
WHAT WHAT THE SITUATION CIRCUS
01:51:40.193 --> 01:51:41.361
HARD FOR ME TO KIND UNDERSTAND?
01:51:41.428 --> 01:51:43.029
I'LL TURN IT OVER TO MY WITNESS
01:51:43.096 --> 01:51:45.865
BUT JUST JUST IN ADVANCE OF THAT --
01:51:45.932 --> 01:51:47.500
YES IT WOULD BE A MINISTERIAL
01:51:47.567 --> 01:51:52.038
PROCESS BUT NONE THE LESS.
01:51:52.105 --> 01:51:52.839
AGAIN THIS IS ONLY FOR PROJECTS
01:51:52.906 --> 01:51:53.306
THAT ARE ALREADY ZONED
01:51:53.373 --> 01:51:54.107
RESIDENTIAL THEY CAN INVOLVE ANY
01:51:54.174 --> 01:51:56.076
AGRICULTURALLY PROTECTED LAND
01:51:56.142 --> 01:51:58.211
ECCENTRIC RIGHT.
01:51:58.278 --> 01:51:59.279
THEY WOULD STILL NEED TO GO
01:51:59.345 --> 01:52:00.313
THROUGH THE PUB THEY GO TO THE
01:52:00.380 --> 01:52:01.448
PLANNING COMMISSION EVEN THOUGH
01:52:01.514 --> 01:52:02.749
THE MINISTERIAL THEY GO TO THE
01:52:02.816 --> 01:52:04.384
PLANNING COMMISSION PROCESS THEY
01:52:04.451 --> 01:52:05.985
GO TO THE BOARD.
01:52:06.052 --> 01:52:06.986
WHERE THERE WILL BE PUBLIC INPUT
01:52:07.053 --> 01:52:08.521
BUT ALL TURNED OVER TO THE CITY
01:52:08.588 --> 01:52:10.423
MANAGER FOR A BILL WHO KNOWS
01:52:10.490 --> 01:52:12.492
THIS ALL TOO WELL?
01:52:12.559 --> 01:52:13.993
I JUST WANT TO EMPHASIZE THAT SO.
01:52:14.060 --> 01:52:15.228
CONSISTENT WITH THE GENERAL PLAN
01:52:15.295 --> 01:52:17.230
CONSISTS WHO WAS OWNING IT STILL
01:52:17.297 --> 01:52:19.099
TAKES SUBDIVISION APPROVAL THERE
01:52:19.165 --> 01:52:20.400
STILL IS A PUBLIC HEARING THERE
01:52:20.467 --> 01:52:21.701
STILL PROCESS.
01:52:21.768 --> 01:52:23.169
PLANNING STAFF TO ADDRESS IS THE
01:52:23.236 --> 01:52:25.138
SAME ISSUES WHETHER IN DANGER
01:52:25.205 --> 01:52:26.739
SPECIES OR TRAFFIC AND I
01:52:26.806 --> 01:52:27.807
GUARANTEE ' COMMUNITIES
01:52:27.874 --> 01:52:29.142
INVOLVED ALLOWED DISCUSSION
01:52:29.209 --> 01:52:30.376
ABOUT BOTH OF THOSE.
01:52:30.443 --> 01:52:31.578
YEAH SO THOSE ITEMS ARE STILL
01:52:31.644 --> 01:52:33.313
DRESSED IN A PUBLIC HEARING
01:52:33.379 --> 01:52:35.849
PROCESS IN IN A COMMON PROCESS.
01:52:35.915 --> 01:52:37.217
SO GIVE US AN EXAMPLE OF OF A
01:52:37.283 --> 01:52:38.785
PROJECT THAT WOULD BE ABLE TO BE
01:52:38.852 --> 01:52:40.320
APPROVED AND YOUR CURRENT
01:52:40.386 --> 01:52:41.221
PROCESS ONE THAT WOULD BE
01:52:41.287 --> 01:52:44.891
TRIPPED UP WHICH SHE WOULD SHE
01:52:44.958 --> 01:52:46.392
WOULD NEED THIS BILL TO ADDRESS
01:52:46.459 --> 01:52:46.693
[inaudible]
01:52:46.759 --> 01:52:47.360
OUR COMMUNITY.
01:52:47.427 --> 01:52:48.595
IS A VERY DIVIDED COMMUNITY AND
01:52:48.661 --> 01:52:49.829
IN THIS CASE AND TALK ABOUT THE
01:52:49.896 --> 01:52:51.030
CITY OF CHICO.
01:52:51.097 --> 01:52:54.134
AND THE COMMUNITY.
01:52:54.200 --> 01:52:55.335
THERE'S A PORTION THE COMMUNITY
01:52:55.401 --> 01:52:56.369
THAT GREATLY OPPOSES ANY
01:52:56.436 --> 01:52:58.037
DEVELOPMENT.
01:52:58.104 --> 01:52:59.906
AND WITH SEEK WERE IT'S
01:52:59.973 --> 01:53:02.709
PRIMARILY PROCEDURAL TOOL AND
01:53:02.775 --> 01:53:04.477
THEREFORE THE PROJECTS ARE
01:53:04.544 --> 01:53:05.979
DRAGGED OUT.
01:53:06.045 --> 01:53:06.913
NOT BECAUSE HAVING GONE THROUGH
01:53:06.980 --> 01:53:08.848
A LENGTHY LENGTHY PUBLIC HEARING
01:53:08.915 --> 01:53:11.417
PROCESS BUT BECAUSE THERE'S A
01:53:11.484 --> 01:53:13.019
WAITED TO DETERMINE.
01:53:13.086 --> 01:53:16.222
THE TO SLOW THE PROJECT DOWN
01:53:16.289 --> 01:53:18.391
BASICALLY MAYBE MAYBE STOP IT.
01:53:18.458 --> 01:53:21.161
OKAY AND THEN -- CAN YOU REMIND
01:53:21.227 --> 01:53:22.729
US AGAIN WHAT WHAT THE SIERRA
01:53:22.795 --> 01:53:24.964
CLUB IS IS ASKING OF YOU.
01:53:25.031 --> 01:53:27.167
AND WHAT YOU'RE WILLING TO TO
01:53:27.233 --> 01:53:28.168
PUT ON THE TABLE TO ADDRESS
01:53:28.234 --> 01:53:32.705
THOSE CONCERNS [inaudible]
01:53:32.772 --> 01:53:33.773
SO [inaudible]
01:53:33.840 --> 01:53:35.909
I DON'T.
01:53:35.975 --> 01:53:37.510
I THINK I CAN SPEAK FOR THEM BUT
01:53:37.577 --> 01:53:40.079
ESSENTIALLY. ONE THEY WOULD LIKE
01:53:40.146 --> 01:53:41.814
SOME LANGUAGE THAT DEALS WITH
01:53:41.881 --> 01:53:44.317
WETLANDS -- AND ENSURING THAT
01:53:44.384 --> 01:53:47.086
THOSE ARE PROTECTED -- THEY ALSO
01:53:47.153 --> 01:53:48.288
WOULD LIKE TO CHANGE THE
01:53:48.354 --> 01:53:50.523
REQUIREMENT ON WHETHER NOT YOU
01:53:50.590 --> 01:53:54.160
CAN REQUIRE PARKING -- RIGHT NOW
01:53:54.227 --> 01:53:56.129
THE LANGUAGE READS IT AS LONG AS
01:53:56.196 --> 01:53:58.565
IT'S WITHIN A MILE OF PUBLIC
01:53:58.631 --> 01:54:00.967
TRANSIT -- THAT THERE CAN'T BE A
01:54:01.034 --> 01:54:02.535
PARKING REQUIREMENT ON IT --
01:54:02.602 --> 01:54:05.605
THEY'VE ACID BE HALF A MILE.
01:54:05.672 --> 01:54:10.610
SO HAVE AGREED TO DO THAT -- THE
01:54:10.677 --> 01:54:11.844
LET'S SEE HERE THERE'S THERE'S
01:54:11.911 --> 01:54:13.813
SOME LANGUAGE ABOUT WHAT IF
01:54:13.880 --> 01:54:15.415
THERE'S A DISCREPANCY BETWEEN.
01:54:15.481 --> 01:54:18.751
GENERAL PLAN AND AND SONY AND
01:54:18.818 --> 01:54:20.119
HOW THAT WOULD BE HAMMERED OUT.
01:54:20.186 --> 01:54:23.890
THAT COMES FROM SB THIRTY FIVE
01:54:23.957 --> 01:54:24.524
THEY'VE ASKED THAT THAT BE TAKEN
01:54:24.591 --> 01:54:25.525
OUT.
01:54:25.592 --> 01:54:27.827
I'M AGREEABLE TO TAKING THAT OUT --
01:54:27.894 --> 01:54:29.529
AND THEN RIGHT NOW WE HAVE THIS
01:54:29.596 --> 01:54:31.397
AS A FIVE YEAR OR SORRY A TEN
01:54:31.464 --> 01:54:32.332
YEAR.
01:54:32.398 --> 01:54:35.335
IT HAS A TEN YEAR SUNSET ON IT --
01:54:35.401 --> 01:54:36.836
BECAUSE I WAS THINKING WILL
01:54:36.903 --> 01:54:39.172
REALLY WERE THINKING IT.
01:54:39.239 --> 01:54:40.340
ABOUT TEN YEARS TO RELEASE.
01:54:40.406 --> 01:54:43.009
AB GET BACK UP ON THE RIDGE IN
01:54:43.076 --> 01:54:46.679
REBUILDING -- ALSO MANY GENERAL
01:54:46.746 --> 01:54:48.248
PLANS ARE TEN YEARS USUALLY --
01:54:48.314 --> 01:54:49.215
SO.
01:54:49.282 --> 01:54:50.016
THAT THAT WAS THE THINKING
01:54:50.083 --> 01:54:51.184
BEHIND THAT THEY'VE ASKED FOR IT
01:54:51.251 --> 01:54:52.719
TO BE FIVE IN THE INTEREST OF
01:54:52.785 --> 01:54:53.920
TRYING TO COMPROMISE A MOVE
01:54:53.987 --> 01:54:55.388
SOMETHING ALONG HERE I'M WILLING
01:54:55.455 --> 01:54:56.923
TO DO THAT AS WELL DOES THAT
01:54:56.990 --> 01:54:58.224
COVER EVERYTHING HERE.
01:54:58.291 --> 01:54:59.726
YES PRINT AWESOME B. OFFICE HERE
01:54:59.792 --> 01:55:01.394
THE CALIFORNIA -- FIRST OFF
01:55:01.461 --> 01:55:02.528
THANK YOU ALL FOR HEARING THIS
01:55:02.595 --> 01:55:04.797
BILL -- HE BASICALLY HAD ALL THE
01:55:04.864 --> 01:55:05.598
NET IN THE NOTES ON THE HEAD AND
01:55:05.665 --> 01:55:07.867
THAT OF OUR REQUESTS -- WE'VE
01:55:07.934 --> 01:55:10.236
TALKED ALSO ABOUT HOW BECAUSE OF
01:55:10.303 --> 01:55:11.504
THE LIMITATIONS THAT I PROVIDED
01:55:11.571 --> 01:55:12.839
AND ALSO SOME OF IMITATION THAT
01:55:12.905 --> 01:55:13.806
THE COMMITTEE HAS BEEN TALKING
01:55:13.873 --> 01:55:15.575
TO A LOT OF THIS WOULD BE
01:55:15.642 --> 01:55:16.743
SUBJUGATED -- TO INFILL
01:55:16.809 --> 01:55:18.111
DEVELOPMENT WHICH WE OBVIOUSLY
01:55:18.177 --> 01:55:19.746
WOULD LIKE AS WELL -- AND SO
01:55:19.812 --> 01:55:20.913
THAT'S NOT A NEED THAT IN OUR
01:55:20.980 --> 01:55:23.516
LETTER PER SE BUT WE WOULD ALSO
01:55:23.583 --> 01:55:24.784
LIKE TO TALK TO MORE ABOUT HOW
01:55:24.851 --> 01:55:25.918
WE CAN DO IT LIKE LIMIT THIS TO
01:55:25.985 --> 01:55:27.053
INFILL DEVELOPMENT.
01:55:27.120 --> 01:55:33.059
WHICH WE OBVIOUSLY ADVOCATE MORE --
01:55:33.126 --> 01:55:34.661
FOR LONG TERM WHAT NOT SURE OF
01:55:34.727 --> 01:55:35.295
THANK YOU IN IN THE MAYBE THAT
01:55:35.361 --> 01:55:36.429
THANK YOU THOUGHT YOUR WELL YOUR
01:55:36.496 --> 01:55:37.764
WORKING WITH THE SIERRA CLUB AND
01:55:37.830 --> 01:55:38.765
HOPEFULLY BUT TIME IS A BILL.
01:55:38.831 --> 01:55:39.432
YOU'LL HAVE WORKED WORKED IT OUT
01:55:39.499 --> 01:55:39.966
WITH THEM TO REMOVE THEIR
01:55:40.033 --> 01:55:41.334
OPPOSITION BUT ONE THING THAT
01:55:41.401 --> 01:55:43.269
THEY DID NOTE THERE WHICH I WANT
01:55:43.336 --> 01:55:44.404
TO ASK YOU IS THAT IS AYE AYE.
01:55:44.470 --> 01:55:45.471
I KNOW YOU'RE TRYING TO BE
01:55:45.538 --> 01:55:47.740
CREATIVE AND MODEL THIS AFTER.
01:55:47.807 --> 01:55:49.809
SB THIRTY FIVE WHICH WAS IS THE
01:55:49.876 --> 01:55:53.379
LIE SUPPORT DEVOTED -- BUT IT'S
01:55:53.446 --> 01:55:54.914
YOU KNOW APPLES AND ORANGES I
01:55:54.981 --> 01:55:56.516
THINK THAT THE GOAL THAT MISTER
01:55:56.582 --> 01:55:57.850
WINNER PUT FORTH WAS.
01:55:57.917 --> 01:55:59.952
IN THESE URBAN LOCATIONS WERE
01:56:00.019 --> 01:56:00.953
THERE YOU KNOW MANY TIMES CLOSE
01:56:01.020 --> 01:56:03.289
OUR CLUSTER RAIL AND TRANSIT AND
01:56:03.356 --> 01:56:04.957
OBVIOUSLY PARADISE IS NOT.
01:56:05.024 --> 01:56:07.794
NECESSARILY -- THAT CITY MAYBE
01:56:07.860 --> 01:56:08.928
CHICO'S A LITTLE BIT SINCE SOME
01:56:08.995 --> 01:56:10.663
OF THE DENSE AREAS AND SO AND
01:56:10.730 --> 01:56:11.964
THEN ALSO TALK ABOUT HOW.
01:56:12.031 --> 01:56:15.335
WELL YOU FOCUS ON THIS IS SB
01:56:15.401 --> 01:56:16.002
THIRTY FIVE LIKE IT'S IT'S GOOD
01:56:16.069 --> 01:56:17.603
AS A LIGHT IN MANY AREAS
01:56:17.670 --> 01:56:19.105
INCLUDING.
01:56:19.172 --> 01:56:21.574
THIS INFILL -- YOU KNOW --
01:56:21.641 --> 01:56:23.343
PRINCIPLE THAT OBVIOUSLY IS NOT
01:56:23.409 --> 01:56:26.079
THERE IN YOUR COMMUNITY SO. ONE
01:56:26.145 --> 01:56:28.214
IF YOU CAN ADDRESS THAT IN SOME
01:56:28.281 --> 01:56:30.516
OF THE OTHER ISSUES THAT WERE IN.
01:56:30.583 --> 01:56:35.021
THIRTY FIVE SB THIRTY FIVE WHICH
01:56:35.088 --> 01:56:35.688
ARE NOT IN YOUR PROPOSAL.
01:56:35.755 --> 01:56:36.356
I MEAN I THINK THAT'S EXACTLY IT
01:56:36.422 --> 01:56:37.824
LIKE I I MEAN I I I KIND OF JOKE
01:56:37.890 --> 01:56:39.125
TO AN SB THIRTY FIVE WAS UP THAT
01:56:39.192 --> 01:56:40.059
IT WAS IT WAS.
01:56:40.126 --> 01:56:41.928
NO SECRET STREAMLINING FOR SAN
01:56:41.994 --> 01:56:43.396
FRANCISCO RIGHT BECAUSE IT WAS
01:56:43.463 --> 01:56:44.864
ALMOST LIKE THAT WAS KIND OF THE
01:56:44.931 --> 01:56:46.466
ONLY AREAS IT WOULD REALLY WORK
01:56:46.532 --> 01:56:50.670
IN -- SO I'VE I'VE MODELED. FOUR
01:56:50.737 --> 01:56:52.171
THIRTY OFF OF THIRTY FIVE THAT I
01:56:52.238 --> 01:56:53.106
WOULD CALL IT.
01:56:53.172 --> 01:56:54.340
SICK WITH STREAMLINING FOR BUTTE
01:56:54.407 --> 01:56:55.942
COUNTY HERE AND SO I'VE I'VE
01:56:56.008 --> 01:56:57.276
DEFINITELY IN TRYING TO TAKE
01:56:57.343 --> 01:56:58.277
INTO ACCOUNT.
01:56:58.344 --> 01:56:59.579
THAT THERE YOU KNOW IT IS IT IS
01:56:59.645 --> 01:57:02.782
DIFFERENT AS I THINK MANY OF YOU
01:57:02.849 --> 01:57:05.985
KNOW -- AND MANY AB THE VISITED.
01:57:06.052 --> 01:57:07.253
YOU KNOW WE DON'T NECESSARILY
01:57:07.320 --> 01:57:07.987
HAVE [inaudible]
01:57:08.054 --> 01:57:10.123
YOU KNOW.
01:57:10.189 --> 01:57:11.491
VERY URBAN ENVIRONMENTS WE DO
01:57:11.557 --> 01:57:13.359
HAVE URBAN AREAS -- WE DO HAVE A
01:57:13.426 --> 01:57:16.562
LOT OF SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENCES.
01:57:16.629 --> 01:57:18.030
BUT THIS WOULD ENABLE INFILL
01:57:18.097 --> 01:57:20.032
PROJECTS IT WOULD ENABLE A MULTI
01:57:20.099 --> 01:57:22.101
FAMILY PROJECTS APARTMENTS
01:57:22.168 --> 01:57:23.202
THERE'S A LACKS THE A LOT OF
01:57:23.269 --> 01:57:24.570
APARTMENT HOUSING IN CHICO
01:57:24.637 --> 01:57:27.073
PROBABLY NEEDS TO BE MORE -- IN
01:57:27.140 --> 01:57:28.441
IN OTHER IN OTHER JURISDICTIONS
01:57:28.508 --> 01:57:29.342
AS WELL.
01:57:29.409 --> 01:57:31.277
BUT ALSO SINGLE FAMILY HOMES
01:57:31.344 --> 01:57:33.079
BECAUSE THAT'S THAT'S KIND OF
01:57:33.146 --> 01:57:34.447
PART OF HOW PEOPLE LIVE UP IN
01:57:34.514 --> 01:57:35.982
THIS IN THIS AREA THAT'S WHAT
01:57:36.048 --> 01:57:37.884
PEOPLE A LOT OF PEOPLE THAT WERE
01:57:37.950 --> 01:57:39.552
ON THE RICH ARE USED -- TO BUT
01:57:39.619 --> 01:57:40.953
WE NEED IT ALL RIGHT WE NEED WE
01:57:41.020 --> 01:57:42.488
DON'T JUST NEED ONE TYPE OF
01:57:42.555 --> 01:57:44.924
HOUSING THAT'S WHY THIS ALLOWS.
01:57:44.991 --> 01:57:48.361
FOR THE WHOLE GAMUT -- AND BUT
01:57:48.428 --> 01:57:50.363
ONLY IN THOSE LIMITED AREAS
01:57:50.430 --> 01:57:51.864
WHERE IT MEETS THE CRITERIA
01:57:51.931 --> 01:57:52.432
BASICALLY.
01:57:52.498 --> 01:57:54.033
YES MA'AM I HAVE TO INTERRUPT
01:57:54.100 --> 01:57:54.834
BECAUSE I HAVE TO GO ON PRESENT
01:57:54.901 --> 01:57:56.602
A BILL I'M GONNA TURN IT OVER TO
01:57:56.669 --> 01:57:58.671
MY CODE MY VICE CHAIR TO
01:57:58.738 --> 01:57:59.906
CONTINUE TAKING YOUR QUESTIONS
01:57:59.972 --> 01:58:01.674
BEFORE I GO I I DO WANT TO THANK
01:58:01.741 --> 01:58:03.009
THE AUTHOR FOR BRINGING THIS
01:58:03.075 --> 01:58:03.876
FORWARD IN.
01:58:03.943 --> 01:58:04.944
AN ATTEMPT TO DEAL WITH WHAT'S
01:58:05.011 --> 01:58:07.079
CLEARLY A CRISIS AND I DO --
01:58:07.146 --> 01:58:08.281
ALSO APPRECIATE YOUR BEING
01:58:08.347 --> 01:58:09.916
WILLING TO CONTINUE TO WORK WITH
01:58:09.982 --> 01:58:11.317
US BEFORE WE BRING ABOUT GO BACK
01:58:11.384 --> 01:58:12.084
FOR A VOTE I THINK YOU ARE
01:58:12.151 --> 01:58:12.685
HEARING.
01:58:12.752 --> 01:58:14.153
CONCERNS AND THERE'S SOME WORK
01:58:14.220 --> 01:58:15.588
TO BE DONE WITH THIS BILL --
01:58:15.655 --> 01:58:16.889
FRIEND SINCE SB THIRTY FIVE WAS
01:58:16.956 --> 01:58:20.226
REALLY A BILL THAT WAS MEANT --
01:58:20.293 --> 01:58:22.595
TO FORCE ARE RETICENT -- CITY
01:58:22.662 --> 01:58:23.963
COUNCILS IN URBAN AREAS I'VE TO
01:58:24.030 --> 01:58:25.465
FORCE THEM TO ALLOW PROJECTS
01:58:25.531 --> 01:58:27.533
WHEN THEY DIDN'T WANT TO SO IT'S
01:58:27.600 --> 01:58:28.134
STILL UNCLEAR TO ME WITH THIS
01:58:28.201 --> 01:58:29.035
BILL.
01:58:29.101 --> 01:58:30.937
IF A PROJECT COMES IN IT MEETS
01:58:31.003 --> 01:58:33.039
THE CRITERIA OF BEINGS UP KIND
01:58:33.105 --> 01:58:34.707
OF THE RIGHT KIND OF PROJECT FOR
01:58:34.774 --> 01:58:36.008
THE ZONING AND OTHERS WHETHER
01:58:36.075 --> 01:58:37.643
CITY COUNCIL COULD STILL DENY IT
01:58:37.710 --> 01:58:38.878
THAT STILL UNCLEAR TO ME.
01:58:38.945 --> 01:58:39.679
IT SEEMS LIKE IT'S YOUR
01:58:39.745 --> 01:58:41.314
INDICATION TO ALLOW THAT LEVEL
01:58:41.380 --> 01:58:42.815
OF REVIEW BUT THAT'S NOT ALL
01:58:42.882 --> 01:58:45.818
WITH SB -- THIRTY FIVE DID AND I
01:58:45.885 --> 01:58:46.786
I THINK BECAUSE YOUR BILL MAHER
01:58:46.853 --> 01:58:48.387
MIRRORS THAT BILL SO CLOSELY
01:58:48.454 --> 01:58:49.889
THAT WE REALLY DO NEED.
01:58:49.956 --> 01:58:51.290
TO YOU KNOW YOU'RE IT IS THAT
01:58:51.357 --> 01:58:53.392
ROUND PEG SQUARE HOLE OR
01:58:53.459 --> 01:58:54.393
WHATEVER THE EXPRESSION IS
01:58:54.460 --> 01:58:59.365
BASICALLY TO GIVE COME BACK WITH
01:58:59.432 --> 01:58:59.665
THE CLOTHES.
01:58:59.732 --> 01:59:04.003
ON RIGHT [inaudible]
01:59:04.070 --> 01:59:04.370
SENS [inaudible]
01:59:04.437 --> 01:59:05.638
YEAH -- BUT YOU KNOW TO BETTER
01:59:05.705 --> 01:59:06.239
DEFINE WHAT IT WHAT YOU KNOW
01:59:06.305 --> 01:59:07.039
WHAT SORT OF URBAN MEANS TO
01:59:07.106 --> 01:59:08.140
NARROW THIS SO THAT IT'S NOT.
01:59:08.207 --> 01:59:12.512
USED FOR FOR SPRAWL THAT THE THE
01:59:12.578 --> 01:59:14.514
COMMUNITY HAS A CHANCE TO REALLY
01:59:14.580 --> 01:59:16.115
HAVE A VOICE AND INPUT.
01:59:16.182 --> 01:59:17.116
AND I ALSO WILL SAY THAT AS
01:59:17.183 --> 01:59:18.050
WE'VE DISCUSSED THERE'S A LOT OF
01:59:18.117 --> 01:59:19.352
OTHER MEASURES THAT COMMUNITIES
01:59:19.418 --> 01:59:20.920
CAN BE TAKING RIGHT NOW IF THEY
01:59:20.987 --> 01:59:22.421
WANT TO HELP DEVELOPERS AND HELP
01:59:22.488 --> 01:59:23.322
DEVELOPMENTS SUCH AS
01:59:23.389 --> 01:59:25.057
PROGRAMMATIC YARIS -- WITH THEIR
01:59:25.124 --> 01:59:26.459
DOWNTOWN SPECIFIC YOU KNOW WITH
01:59:26.526 --> 01:59:28.494
THEIR PLAN SO THAT THAT WORK IS
01:59:28.561 --> 01:59:29.996
DONE IN ADVANCE -- FOR THE
01:59:30.062 --> 01:59:31.631
DEVELOPERS THAT'S USE VERY
01:59:31.697 --> 01:59:32.632
SUCCESSFUL IN A LOT OF
01:59:32.698 --> 01:59:34.100
COMMUNITIES AND THERE'S MONEY IN
01:59:34.166 --> 01:59:35.835
SB TWO FROM LAST YEAR TO HELP
01:59:35.902 --> 01:59:37.870
SMALLER COMMUNITIES -- HAVE THE
01:59:37.937 --> 01:59:39.872
ABILITY TO DO THAT SO RATHER
01:59:39.939 --> 01:59:41.707
THAN WAIT UNTIL THIS BILL MAHER
01:59:41.774 --> 01:59:42.808
MAY NOT GO THROUGH AN UNTIL
01:59:42.875 --> 01:59:44.176
JANUARY COMMUNITIES SHOULD BE
01:59:44.243 --> 01:59:45.778
WORKING RIGHT NOW I THINK
01:59:45.845 --> 01:59:46.846
TOWARDS THAT END.
01:59:46.913 --> 01:59:48.514
SO I LOOK FOR TO WORKING WITH
01:59:48.581 --> 01:59:49.415
YOU OVER THE NEXT COUPLE OF
01:59:49.482 --> 01:59:51.984
WEEKS AND YOU KNOW WE'LL WE'LL
01:59:52.051 --> 01:59:52.985
SEE WHAT WE GET WITH THIS.
01:59:53.052 --> 01:59:54.186
WITHOUT IT OVER MISTER I DO JUST
01:59:54.253 --> 01:59:55.421
WANT TO SAY IT THANK YOU MADAM
01:59:55.488 --> 01:59:57.290
CHAIR OF APPRECIATE THE INPUT
01:59:57.356 --> 01:59:58.524
AND DIALOGUE THAT WE'VE HAD AND
01:59:58.591 --> 01:59:59.792
I AND I DO BELIEVE THAT WILL BE
01:59:59.859 --> 02:00:00.826
ABLE.
02:00:00.893 --> 02:00:02.528
TO YOU KNOW GET TO THAT PLACE --
02:00:02.595 --> 02:00:04.297
BUT IT'S IT'S DEFINITELY A GREAT
02:00:04.363 --> 02:00:05.731
TO HAVE AND COMMITTEE STAFF
02:00:05.798 --> 02:00:09.502
WHO'S BEEN VERY ATTENTIVE TO
02:00:09.569 --> 02:00:11.103
THIS ISSUE.
02:00:11.170 --> 02:00:12.038
YOU KNOW I THINK AS WE AS WE AS
02:00:12.104 --> 02:00:13.406
WE SAID THERE'S NO I THINK ALL
02:00:13.472 --> 02:00:15.107
THE ISSUES THAT HAVE BEEN RAISED
02:00:15.174 --> 02:00:16.809
OR THINGS THAT WE CAN ADDRESS --
02:00:16.876 --> 02:00:18.811
AND I'M HOPEFUL THAT WE'LL GET
02:00:18.878 --> 02:00:20.913
TO A PRODUCT HERE AT THE END.
02:00:20.980 --> 02:00:22.548
HOW RIGHT THANK YOU MISTER SOME
02:00:22.615 --> 02:00:22.982
WOMAN?
02:00:23.049 --> 02:00:24.684
WAS EGGMAN THANK YOU THANK YOU
02:00:24.750 --> 02:00:25.985
MISTER GALLAGHER IN.
02:00:26.052 --> 02:00:27.153
THANK YOU FOR THIS.
02:00:27.219 --> 02:00:30.856
YOUR WORK ON THIS -- I I I WOULD.
02:00:30.923 --> 02:00:32.592
AND THEN TOUR THE AREA AND AS
02:00:32.658 --> 02:00:33.859
YOU WELL KNOW I HAVE FAMILY THAT
02:00:33.926 --> 02:00:37.163
LIVE IN THE AREAS IMPACTED -- SO
02:00:37.229 --> 02:00:39.031
I APPRECIATE YOU BRINGING THIS
02:00:39.098 --> 02:00:40.166
FORWARD AND AYE AYE.
02:00:40.232 --> 02:00:40.933
AYE AYE DIFFER FROM MY
02:00:41.000 --> 02:00:42.034
COLLEAGUES A LITTLE BIT BECAUSE
02:00:42.101 --> 02:00:43.803
I SEE SB THIRTY FIVE WAS
02:00:43.869 --> 02:00:45.838
ADDRESSING A CRISIS -- AND I AND
02:00:45.905 --> 02:00:47.239
I THINK YOUR ROUND HOLE IS A
02:00:47.306 --> 02:00:49.542
CRISIS AS WELL -- IT MAY NOT FIT
02:00:49.609 --> 02:00:51.277
IN THE EXACT SAME WAYS BUT I
02:00:51.344 --> 02:00:54.146
THINK IT IS VERY CLEAR -- THAT
02:00:54.213 --> 02:00:54.780
WE NEED TO GET PEOPLE BACK IN
02:00:54.847 --> 02:00:55.481
HOUSING.
02:00:55.548 --> 02:00:56.582
I GUESS ONE OF MY QUESTIONS I
02:00:56.649 --> 02:00:57.450
WOULD ASK FOR THE CITY MANAGER
02:00:57.516 --> 02:00:59.051
IS IT EVERYBODY HAS A GENERAL
02:00:59.118 --> 02:01:00.119
PLAN ALREADY IN PLACE AND
02:01:00.186 --> 02:01:02.955
THERE'S THERE'S NOTHING UP --
02:01:03.022 --> 02:01:04.223
FOR LAND USE EXTENSION AT THIS
02:01:04.290 --> 02:01:04.457
POINT.
02:01:04.523 --> 02:01:05.524
IN.
02:01:05.591 --> 02:01:07.493
THE CITY OF CHICO AND SO YOUR
02:01:07.560 --> 02:01:08.894
BILL YES PARADISE APPOINT
02:01:08.961 --> 02:01:10.262
THROUGH AN EXTENSIVE LAND USE
02:01:10.329 --> 02:01:11.664
PROCESS RIGHT NOW.
02:01:11.731 --> 02:01:13.532
AS YOU MIGHT EXPECT IN TERMS OF
02:01:13.599 --> 02:01:14.166
HOW WHAT WE WANT TO LOOK LIKE
02:01:14.233 --> 02:01:15.201
SINCE.
02:01:15.267 --> 02:01:16.702
THEY BASICALLY WIPED OUT BUT THE
02:01:16.769 --> 02:01:18.404
ANSWER TO YOUR QUESTION IS YES.
02:01:18.471 --> 02:01:19.905
RECENTLY ADOPTED A LONG TERM
02:01:19.972 --> 02:01:24.977
GENERAL PLANS IN THE COMMUNITIES.
02:01:25.044 --> 02:01:25.778
OKAY SO THAT SO THIS WOULDN'T BE
02:01:25.845 --> 02:01:26.779
CHANGING ANYTHING BUT ALTHOUGH
02:01:26.846 --> 02:01:27.913
CHICO IS IS LOOKING AT THEIR
02:01:27.980 --> 02:01:30.149
LAND USE RIGHT NOW.
02:01:30.216 --> 02:01:31.751
I'M PREPARED AYE SOMETHING
02:01:31.817 --> 02:01:33.319
PARADISE IS.
02:01:33.386 --> 02:01:34.320
NOT YOUR ENTRY POINT.
02:01:34.387 --> 02:01:35.388
OKAY ALRIGHT BUT YOU GO IN
02:01:35.454 --> 02:01:37.289
ORVILLE HAVE DENTAL PLANS IN
02:01:37.356 --> 02:01:39.025
PLACE THAT IS CORRECT OKAY --
02:01:39.091 --> 02:01:40.559
BECAUSE IT CERTAINLY LIKE LIKE
02:01:40.626 --> 02:01:42.328
SAN FRANCISCO I THINK ONE OF THE
02:01:42.395 --> 02:01:43.329
THINGS THAT I'M HEARING EVEN
02:01:43.396 --> 02:01:45.264
MORE CLEARLY TODAY IS SIMPLY BE
02:01:45.331 --> 02:01:45.464
ISM.
02:01:45.531 --> 02:01:47.166
RIGHT ABOUT THEN PICKING WINNERS
02:01:47.233 --> 02:01:49.435
AND LOSERS -- AND I THINK YOU
02:01:49.502 --> 02:01:53.639
KNOW BUT IT THE FIRE HAS ALREADY
02:01:53.706 --> 02:01:55.474
ESTABLISHED A BUNCH OF SORRY
02:01:55.541 --> 02:01:56.275
PICK SOME WINNERS AND LOSERS.
02:01:56.342 --> 02:01:56.909
AND I THINK IT'S UP TO US AS A
02:01:56.976 --> 02:01:58.310
AS A STATE AS A COMMUNITY TO BE
02:01:58.377 --> 02:02:00.079
ABLE TO HELP PEOPLE GET BACK ON
02:02:00.146 --> 02:02:02.682
THEIR FEET SO -- I'D BUY I AM
02:02:02.748 --> 02:02:04.183
ENCOURAGED.
02:02:04.250 --> 02:02:05.584
YOU KNOW AND THE THE HOPEFULLY
02:02:05.651 --> 02:02:06.986
THE COMMITTEE WILL DO GOOD WORK
02:02:07.053 --> 02:02:07.953
AND WILL BE ABLE TO THREAD THE
02:02:08.020 --> 02:02:09.488
NEEDLE IN A WAY THAT PROVIDES.
02:02:09.555 --> 02:02:12.091
YOU TOOLS -- AND CONTINUES TO A
02:02:12.158 --> 02:02:13.626
PULLED CALIFORNIA VALUES.
02:02:13.693 --> 02:02:16.328
BUT THERE THERE IS A CRISIS IN
02:02:16.395 --> 02:02:16.829
IN THE AREA THAT MUST BE
02:02:16.896 --> 02:02:19.098
ADDRESSED.
02:02:19.165 --> 02:02:20.566
THANK YOU VERY MUCH ANY OTHER
02:02:20.633 --> 02:02:22.768
QUESTIONS FROM THE COMMITTEE.
02:02:22.835 --> 02:02:25.604
SEE A NINE TO GALLAGHER ALICE'S
02:02:25.671 --> 02:02:27.239
TESTIMONY ONLY SO.
02:02:27.306 --> 02:02:28.607
IF YOU'D LIKE TO CLOSE.
02:02:28.674 --> 02:02:29.608
AND I APPRECIATE THE COMMITTEE I
02:02:29.675 --> 02:02:30.743
MEET AS YOU KNOW THIS IS AN
02:02:30.810 --> 02:02:32.645
IMPORTANT ISSUE FOR ME I WANTED
02:02:32.712 --> 02:02:34.513
TO JUST CLARIFY A COUPLE THINGS
02:02:34.580 --> 02:02:36.649
IN IN IN CLOSING -- AND I DO
02:02:36.716 --> 02:02:37.583
LOOK FORWARD IN TWO WEEKS TO
02:02:37.650 --> 02:02:38.784
BRING IT BACK SOMETHING THAT WE
02:02:38.851 --> 02:02:42.621
CAN ALL GET BEHIND AND PASS OUT --
02:02:42.688 --> 02:02:44.724
NUMBER ONE LOCAL CONTROL IS
02:02:44.790 --> 02:02:46.926
PRESERVED -- THEY AGAIN IF YOU
02:02:46.992 --> 02:02:48.461
LOOK AT THE CLEAR TERMS OF THE
02:02:48.527 --> 02:02:49.729
LEGISLATION.
02:02:49.795 --> 02:02:50.696
I WOULD HAVE TO BE CONSISTENT
02:02:50.763 --> 02:02:52.298
WITH THE PLANNING THE CITY
02:02:52.364 --> 02:02:54.033
COUNCILS AND COUNTY GOVERNMENTS
02:02:54.100 --> 02:02:55.201
HAVE ALREADY DONE.
02:02:55.267 --> 02:02:56.569
AND SAID THIS IS WHERE WE WANT
02:02:56.635 --> 02:02:57.636
TO GROW THIS IS WHERE I WANT TO
02:02:57.703 --> 02:02:58.738
HAVE RESIDENTIAL THERE WOULD
02:02:58.804 --> 02:03:00.106
STILL BE A PUBLIC.
02:03:00.172 --> 02:03:02.708
REVIEW PROCESS FOR THESE
02:03:02.775 --> 02:03:04.043
PROJECTS.
02:03:04.110 --> 02:03:06.078
SO LOCAL CONTROL IS PRESERVED IF
02:03:06.145 --> 02:03:07.813
YOU MEAN THAT AND THEN BE ISM.
02:03:07.880 --> 02:03:09.648
WILL BE LESS LIKELY YEAH THAT'S
02:03:09.715 --> 02:03:10.549
TRUE.
02:03:10.616 --> 02:03:11.784
YOU KNOW THAT SOMEBODY COMES IN
02:03:11.851 --> 02:03:12.952
A PROJECT WHERE EVERYBODY'S
02:03:13.018 --> 02:03:14.420
ALREADY DECIDED THIS MAKES A LOT
02:03:14.487 --> 02:03:16.455
OF SENSE AS WAS HAPPENING IN SAN
02:03:16.522 --> 02:03:18.858
FRANCISCO -- AND THE PROJECTS
02:03:18.924 --> 02:03:20.493
WERE GETTING BUILT YEAH OF THIS
02:03:20.559 --> 02:03:21.927
WOULD PROVIDE A MINISTRY --
02:03:21.994 --> 02:03:24.230
PROCESS THAT HELPS ENSURE.
02:03:24.296 --> 02:03:26.198
THAT HAPPENS -- BUT IT WOULD
02:03:26.265 --> 02:03:28.234
PROVIDE FULL PUBLIC VETTING OF
02:03:28.300 --> 02:03:29.468
THOSE PROJECTS AND IT WOULD HAVE
02:03:29.535 --> 02:03:31.203
TO MEET CRITERIA VERY LIMITED
02:03:31.270 --> 02:03:32.471
CRITERIA AS WE'VE BEEN TALKING
02:03:32.538 --> 02:03:33.672
ABOUT.
02:03:33.739 --> 02:03:34.874
AND WE WILL CONTINUE TO WORK ON
02:03:34.940 --> 02:03:38.244
ON THAT CRITERIA SO THAT PEOPLE
02:03:38.310 --> 02:03:39.245
FEEL FEEL COMFORTABLE WITH THAT.
02:03:39.311 --> 02:03:41.213
SECOND POINT IS LOCALS HAVE BEEN
02:03:41.280 --> 02:03:42.648
INVOLVED THIS WHOLE PROCESS I
02:03:42.715 --> 02:03:44.283
STARTED THIS RIDE IN THE
02:03:44.350 --> 02:03:45.718
AFTERMATH OF THE FIRE.
02:03:45.785 --> 02:03:46.986
WE MET WITH ALL THE LOCAL
02:03:47.052 --> 02:03:49.155
GOVERNMENTS WE MET WITH LOCAL
02:03:49.221 --> 02:03:51.090
ELECTED IF OFFICIALS.
02:03:51.157 --> 02:03:52.591
WE'VE BEEN IN CONVERSATIONS WITH
02:03:52.658 --> 02:03:54.393
LOCAL ELECTED OFFICIALS
02:03:54.460 --> 02:03:55.895
INCLUDING THE MAYOR OF CHICO.
02:03:55.961 --> 02:03:58.197
WHO IS WHO IS WELL AWARE OF WHAT
02:03:58.264 --> 02:03:58.964
WE'VE BEEN PROPOSING?
02:03:59.031 --> 02:04:00.866
AND HE HAS A LETTER APPARENTLY
02:04:00.933 --> 02:04:03.936
THERE'S BEEN SUBMITTED -- THAT
02:04:04.003 --> 02:04:04.537
HASN'T BEEN SHARED WITH ME AT
02:04:04.603 --> 02:04:07.373
THIS POINT -- BUT WE HAVE BEEN
02:04:07.439 --> 02:04:08.841
AND AS YOU'VE HEARD ME IN.
02:04:08.908 --> 02:04:10.176
IF ANYBODY SAYS THAT LOCALS
02:04:10.242 --> 02:04:11.777
DON'T SUPPORT THIS I HAVE A
02:04:11.844 --> 02:04:13.245
LETTER CITY OF OROVILLE.
02:04:13.312 --> 02:04:15.414
VALLEY CONTRACTORS EXCHANGE
02:04:15.481 --> 02:04:17.883
SIERRA NORTH VALLEY REALTORS.
02:04:17.950 --> 02:04:19.218
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
02:04:19.285 --> 02:04:21.020
REALTORS RURAL COUNTY
02:04:21.086 --> 02:04:22.922
REPRESENTATIVES A CALIFORNIA
02:04:22.988 --> 02:04:23.222
[inaudible]
02:04:23.289 --> 02:04:24.957
BUTTE COUNTY.
02:04:25.024 --> 02:04:27.426
AND THE P. O. A THE NORTH VALLEY
02:04:27.493 --> 02:04:28.928
PROPERTY OWNERS ASSOCIATION THAT
02:04:28.994 --> 02:04:30.095
YOU HEARD FROM THE CHICO CHAMBER
02:04:30.162 --> 02:04:33.799
OF COMMERCE -- THE CHICO
02:04:33.866 --> 02:04:36.902
BUILDERS ASSOCIATION.
02:04:36.969 --> 02:04:38.871
THE VALLEY CONTRACTORS EXCHANGE
02:04:38.938 --> 02:04:41.073
ALL THE BUILDERS IN THAT REGION.
02:04:41.140 --> 02:04:42.508
AND PEOPLE AND VENDORS INVOLVED
02:04:42.575 --> 02:04:44.710
IN BUILDING I MEAN ALL THE
02:04:44.777 --> 02:04:46.512
STAKEHOLDERS AND LOCAL.
02:04:46.579 --> 02:04:47.580
PEOPLE THAT HAVE BEEN INVOLVED
02:04:47.646 --> 02:04:48.614
IN TRYING TO MAKE SURE THAT WE
02:04:48.681 --> 02:04:50.349
BUILD HOUSING AND THAT WE TREAT
02:04:50.416 --> 02:04:53.319
THIS AS THE EMERGENCY THAT IT IS.
02:04:53.385 --> 02:04:55.955
ARE BEHIND THIS AND SO THOSE
02:04:56.021 --> 02:04:58.023
THAT MAYBE -- OPPOSE THIS ARE A
02:04:58.090 --> 02:04:59.892
VERY SMALL MINORITY.
02:04:59.959 --> 02:05:02.127
AND I CAN SAY VERY EMPHATICALLY
02:05:02.194 --> 02:05:03.929
THAT THERE HAS BEEN NO NO ONE
02:05:03.996 --> 02:05:05.130
WHO REPRESENTS AN OFFICIAL
02:05:05.197 --> 02:05:06.065
ENTITY.
02:05:06.131 --> 02:05:07.433
THERE'S BEEN ANY OFFICIAL VOTE
02:05:07.499 --> 02:05:09.235
INCLUDING THE CITY OF CHICO FOR
02:05:09.301 --> 02:05:10.269
THAT MATTER.
02:05:10.336 --> 02:05:12.071
THAT IS SAID THEY OPPOSE THIS
02:05:12.137 --> 02:05:15.074
BILL -- BUT IF THIS YEAR THE
02:05:15.140 --> 02:05:16.642
CITY OF CHICO RIGHT NOW.
02:05:16.709 --> 02:05:17.476
LET'S TALK ABOUT ANOTHER
02:05:17.543 --> 02:05:20.045
EMERGENCY TWENTY THOUSAND PEOPLE.
02:05:20.112 --> 02:05:21.213
AN ESTIMATED THAT ARE IN THE
02:05:21.280 --> 02:05:22.748
CITY OF CHICO RIGHT NOW
02:05:22.815 --> 02:05:24.316
PRECARIOUSLY HOUSE STE.
02:05:24.383 --> 02:05:26.151
EITHER LIVING WITH WITH A FAMILY
02:05:26.218 --> 02:05:28.020
MEMBER LIVING WITH FRIENDS
02:05:28.087 --> 02:05:30.089
LIVING IN TRAILERS ON THE STREET.
02:05:30.155 --> 02:05:31.624
LIVING IN TENTS.
02:05:31.690 --> 02:05:33.325
HOMELESS THE IMPACTS ARE GOING
02:05:33.392 --> 02:05:35.194
ON IN THAT CITY WE'RE TRYING TO
02:05:35.261 --> 02:05:36.228
DO SOMETHING TO HELP ADDRESS
02:05:36.295 --> 02:05:37.930
THOSE IMPACTS BY FINDING PEOPLE
02:05:37.997 --> 02:05:39.598
STABLE HOUSING.
02:05:39.665 --> 02:05:40.366
AND THAT'S WHAT THIS BILL WOULD
02:05:40.432 --> 02:05:41.133
DO.
02:05:41.200 --> 02:05:43.836
BUT AT THE CITY OF CHICO REALLY
02:05:43.903 --> 02:05:45.070
DOESN'T WANT THIS HELP OF THIS
02:05:45.137 --> 02:05:45.271
BILL.
02:05:45.337 --> 02:05:47.573
FROM THIS BILL WILL BE HAPPY TO
02:05:47.640 --> 02:05:48.574
TAKE THEM OUT.
02:05:48.641 --> 02:05:49.842
IF THAT'S THE KIND OF STATEMENT
02:05:49.909 --> 02:05:51.610
THAT THEY WANT TO MAKE.
02:05:51.677 --> 02:05:52.611
THEY WILL BE HAPPY TO TAKE THEM
02:05:52.678 --> 02:05:54.280
OUT AND OTHER COMMUNITIES THAT
02:05:54.346 --> 02:05:55.981
WANT TO STEP UP AND HELP.
02:05:56.048 --> 02:05:57.283
AND WHO HAVE ALREADY PUT OUT
02:05:57.349 --> 02:06:03.956
PUBLIC DO -- BUT I JUST WANT TO
02:06:04.023 --> 02:06:06.158
FIND SOLUTIONS FOR MY COMMUNITY
02:06:06.225 --> 02:06:08.727
FOR THE PEOPLE.
02:06:08.794 --> 02:06:09.962
THEY GOT UP HERE TODAY PEOPLE
02:06:10.029 --> 02:06:11.764
THAT HAVE LOST LOVED ONES PEOPLE
02:06:11.830 --> 02:06:13.299
THAT HAVE BEEN LIVING IN RV'S
02:06:13.365 --> 02:06:14.366
THAT YOU HEARD FROM.
02:06:14.433 --> 02:06:16.135
TODAY RIGHT THAT'S WHAT I DO
02:06:16.201 --> 02:06:17.336
THIS FOR AND THAT'S WHY WE'RE
02:06:17.403 --> 02:06:18.570
TRYING TO FIND A SOLUTION FOR
02:06:18.637 --> 02:06:19.772
THEM AND I'M.
02:06:19.838 --> 02:06:20.973
AND I WANT TO THANK.
02:06:21.040 --> 02:06:22.942
I JUST WANT TO BE VERY CLEAR
02:06:23.008 --> 02:06:23.475
ABOUT I WANT TO THANK THE
02:06:23.542 --> 02:06:25.044
COMMITTEE AND I WANT TO THANK
02:06:25.110 --> 02:06:26.812
THE MEMBERS.
02:06:26.879 --> 02:06:27.813
THE SERVER Là M<c.cyan> ONLY BEEN</c>
02:06:27.880 --> 02:06:28.881
WORKING A LOT OF THE EMERGENCY
02:06:28.948 --> 02:06:30.616
RESPONSE ISSUES ASSEMBLY MEMBER
02:06:30.683 --> 02:06:32.251
EGGMAN.
02:06:32.318 --> 02:06:33.786
CAME UP TO PARADISE.
02:06:33.852 --> 02:06:35.220
THE VERY ATTENTIVE TO THIS ISSUE
02:06:35.287 --> 02:06:36.588
INTO THE ISSUES THAT ARE
02:06:36.655 --> 02:06:38.190
AFFECTING THE PEOPLE UP THERE.
02:06:38.257 --> 02:06:40.426
AND MANY OTHERS THE SERVER
02:06:40.492 --> 02:06:42.928
MATHIS -- THAT HAVE COME UP AND
02:06:42.995 --> 02:06:45.264
SIT AND AND SEEN THE DEVASTATION
02:06:45.331 --> 02:06:47.366
UP THERE IN THAT WANT TO HELP --
02:06:47.433 --> 02:06:48.200
I AM VERY APPRECIATED ALL OF THE
02:06:48.267 --> 02:06:49.301
APPRECIATED THE CHAIR WHO'S
02:06:49.368 --> 02:06:50.836
TRYING TO FIND.
02:06:50.903 --> 02:06:52.338
A SOLUTION HERE WE WANT TO
02:06:52.404 --> 02:06:53.472
THAT'S THE BOTTOM LINE WE'RE
02:06:53.539 --> 02:06:55.107
TRYING TO FIND A SOLUTION. FOR
02:06:55.174 --> 02:06:56.475
PEOPLE WHO DESPERATELY NEED IT
02:06:56.542 --> 02:06:58.777
RIGHT NOW -- I THINK WE CAN FIND
02:06:58.844 --> 02:07:00.112
A WAY AND HOPEFULLY IN TWO WEEKS
02:07:00.179 --> 02:07:01.847
WE'LL COME BACK HERE WITH THE
02:07:01.914 --> 02:07:02.948
LANGUAGE WILL GET THE SAME WITH
02:07:03.015 --> 02:07:06.118
THE FORD SO THANK YOU FOR YOUR
02:07:06.185 --> 02:07:07.586
TIME TODAY.
02:07:07.653 --> 02:07:09.555
I RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR AYE
02:07:09.621 --> 02:07:10.789
VOTE -- WHEN WE HAVE THIS
02:07:10.856 --> 02:07:11.357
AMENDED MEASURE BEFORE YOU?
02:07:11.423 --> 02:07:12.958
IN A COUPLE WEEKS AND HELP YOU
02:07:13.025 --> 02:07:13.926
COUNTY RECOVER FROM ONE OF THE
02:07:13.993 --> 02:07:16.261
MOST DEVASTATING DISASTERS IN
02:07:16.328 --> 02:07:18.497
CALIFORNIA HISTORY.
02:07:18.564 --> 02:07:20.232
THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME.
02:07:20.299 --> 02:07:23.602
THE US TO GALLAGHER.
02:07:23.669 --> 02:07:26.972
ALL RIGHT NEXT UP SOMEONE NUMBER.
02:07:27.039 --> 02:07:43.222
THIRTEEN AB
02:07:53.265 --> 02:07:53.332
.
02:07:53.332 --> 02:07:53.766
SEVEN NINETY TWO SO EVER
02:07:53.832 --> 02:07:54.400
WHATEVER YOU'RE READY PLEASE.
02:07:54.466 --> 02:07:56.402
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR --
02:07:56.468 --> 02:07:58.971
FIRSTLY JUST THANK THE CHAIR AND
02:07:59.038 --> 02:07:59.872
THE CONSULTANT FOR THE
02:07:59.938 --> 02:08:01.206
AMENDMENTS WILL BE HAPPY --
02:08:01.273 --> 02:08:03.108
ACCEPTING THE MEMBERS THAT APPLY
02:08:03.175 --> 02:08:04.676
THESE STANDARDS TO ONLY I
02:08:04.743 --> 02:08:05.944
CALIFORNIA REDEMPTION VALUE
02:08:06.011 --> 02:08:07.746
BOTTLES AND BASES THAT ON THE
02:08:07.813 --> 02:08:10.482
MANUFACTURER'S AVERAGE -- A. B.
02:08:10.549 --> 02:08:12.017
SEVEN ID TO ESTABLISH IS A TIME
02:08:12.084 --> 02:08:14.153
LINE FOR PLASTIC BOTTLED
02:08:14.219 --> 02:08:15.320
BEVERAGE MANY FACTORS TO USE
02:08:15.387 --> 02:08:17.356
MINIMUM RECYCLED CONTENT IN
02:08:17.423 --> 02:08:18.891
THEIR PLASTIC BOTTLES.
02:08:18.957 --> 02:08:21.126
WITH THE GOAL OF GETTING 21100%
02:08:21.193 --> 02:08:23.929
RECYCLED CONTENT BY.
02:08:23.996 --> 02:08:25.097
TWENTY THIRTY FIVE AS YOU KNOW A
02:08:25.164 --> 02:08:25.964
SIGNIFICANT PORTION OF
02:08:26.031 --> 02:08:28.767
CALIFORNIA'S RECYCLE PLASTICS.
02:08:28.834 --> 02:08:30.369
WERE SHIPPED OVERSEAS TO CHINA
02:08:30.436 --> 02:08:32.137
INTEL LAST YEAR WITH CHINA
02:08:32.204 --> 02:08:33.839
STOPPED TAKING AND PURCHASING
02:08:33.906 --> 02:08:36.575
MOST OF OUR RECYCLED CONTENT.
02:08:36.642 --> 02:08:38.310
NOW THAT CALIFORNIA'S FACING
02:08:38.377 --> 02:08:39.578
THIS CRISIS I THINK WE HAVE TO
02:08:39.645 --> 02:08:41.513
LOOK INTERNALLY TO FIGURE OUT
02:08:41.580 --> 02:08:44.283
HOW BEST TO CAN REALLY HAVE
02:08:44.349 --> 02:08:45.818
RECYCLED CONTENT IN OUR VARIOUS
02:08:45.884 --> 02:08:47.419
PLASTIC BOTTLES.
02:08:47.486 --> 02:08:48.220
IT JUST.
02:08:48.287 --> 02:08:50.422
TO SET THE SET THE RECORD SO YOU
02:08:50.489 --> 02:08:51.690
UNDERSTAND WHAT'S AT STAKE.
02:08:51.757 --> 02:08:55.694
IS IF NOTHING ELSE IS DONE. TO
02:08:55.761 --> 02:08:58.664
DEAL WITH THE RECYCLED PLASTICS
02:08:58.730 --> 02:09:00.099
BY.
02:09:00.165 --> 02:09:00.933
TWENTY FIFTY THERE WILL BE MORE
02:09:00.999 --> 02:09:07.406
PLASTIC IN THE OCEAN THAT FISH.
02:09:07.473 --> 02:09:08.040
SO IF YOU COULD THINK ABOUT THE
02:09:08.107 --> 02:09:08.574
FACT THAT IF WE DON'T DO
02:09:08.640 --> 02:09:10.075
ANYTHING BY TWENTY FIFTY WALK TO
02:09:10.142 --> 02:09:11.310
HAVE MORE PLASTIC IN THE OCEAN
02:09:11.376 --> 02:09:12.111
THAN FISH.
02:09:12.177 --> 02:09:13.278
A NUMBER OF LEADING COMPANIES
02:09:13.345 --> 02:09:13.612
HAVE ALREADY.
02:09:13.679 --> 02:09:15.714
STARTED AND LEAD BY EXAMPLE WE
02:09:15.781 --> 02:09:16.849
HAVE THE NAKED JUICE COMPANY
02:09:16.915 --> 02:09:17.950
THEY HAVE BEEN USING BOTTLES
02:09:18.016 --> 02:09:20.085
WITH 1100% POST RECYCLED
02:09:20.152 --> 02:09:20.853
CONSUMER.
02:09:20.919 --> 02:09:22.588
CONTENT IN EUROPE COCA COLA HAS
02:09:22.654 --> 02:09:24.790
COMMITTED. TO HAS ALREADY BEEN
02:09:24.857 --> 02:09:27.559
USING 25% RECYCLED PLASTIC AND
02:09:27.626 --> 02:09:32.898
THEY'VE COMMITTED TO THE 50% BY --
02:09:32.965 --> 02:09:33.465
TWENTY TWENTY FIVE RECYCLED
02:09:33.532 --> 02:09:36.034
PLASTIC THE PROPOSAL IN EUROPE.
02:09:36.101 --> 02:09:38.003
SO AGAIN IF WE CAN SET UP
02:09:38.070 --> 02:09:39.371
MINIMUM CONTENT TO PLASTIC
02:09:39.438 --> 02:09:40.672
BOTTLES IN CALIFORNIA TO HAVE
02:09:40.739 --> 02:09:42.341
HUGE ENVIRONMENTAL BENEFITS WE
02:09:42.407 --> 02:09:43.575
HAVE A COUPLE WITNESSES THROUGH
02:09:43.642 --> 02:09:43.976
WILLING.
02:09:44.042 --> 02:09:47.479
TO JUST BE VERY QUICKLY ON THE
02:09:47.546 --> 02:09:48.580
ISSUE THANK.
02:09:48.647 --> 02:09:49.882
MY APOLOGIES ON BEHALF OF THE
02:09:49.948 --> 02:09:50.682
RECLAIMER IS IN THE RECYCLERS
02:09:50.749 --> 02:09:52.951
THE PROCESSORS AND ON I HAVE ONE
02:09:53.018 --> 02:09:54.119
WITH ME HERE FROM CARBON LIGHT
02:09:54.186 --> 02:09:56.121
BUT VERY QUICKLY I JUST PASSED
02:09:56.188 --> 02:09:58.557
OUT A A HAND OUT.
02:09:58.624 --> 02:10:00.492
IT TALKS ABOUT WHAT MY CLIENTS
02:10:00.559 --> 02:10:02.094
HAVE BEEN DOING AS FAR AS THEIR
02:10:02.161 --> 02:10:05.497
CONTRIBUTIONS TO TO TRYING TO
02:10:05.564 --> 02:10:07.332
HELP WITH BOTH THE BOTTLES OUT
02:10:07.399 --> 02:10:09.735
OF LANDFILL AND GREENHOUSE GASES --
02:10:09.801 --> 02:10:11.470
BUT IF YOU LOOK THROUGH YOU CAN
02:10:11.537 --> 02:10:13.005
SEE SOME OF THE BOTTLES
02:10:13.071 --> 02:10:14.640
EXPLAINING A 100%.
02:10:14.706 --> 02:10:18.577
A 100% -- NAKED CHOOSE A 100% --
02:10:18.644 --> 02:10:20.412
WE WERE TOLD YEARS AGO THAT IT
02:10:20.479 --> 02:10:22.247
COULDN'T BE DONE NAKED USED AS A
02:10:22.314 --> 02:10:24.550
100% ERRO HEAD DOES 50%.
02:10:24.616 --> 02:10:26.718
EVERY ON DOES A 100% NESTLE PURE
02:10:26.785 --> 02:10:28.820
LIFE DOES A 100% KIRKLIN WATER
02:10:28.887 --> 02:10:30.455
DOES BOTH A HUNDRED AND FIFTY I
02:10:30.522 --> 02:10:33.091
MEAN A HUNDRED AND 50% RECYCLED
02:10:33.158 --> 02:10:33.992
CONTENT.
02:10:34.059 --> 02:10:35.093
SO I THINK WE'VE COME TO THE
02:10:35.160 --> 02:10:37.129
POINT WHERE I'LL JUST SAY THAT
02:10:37.196 --> 02:10:39.298
IT'S IT'S REALLY NOT OK ANYMORE
02:10:39.364 --> 02:10:40.766
TO JUST BE ABLE TO HAVE
02:10:40.832 --> 02:10:42.100
SOMETHING RECYCLED.
02:10:42.167 --> 02:10:43.268
BUT IT NEEDS TO ACTUALLY BE
02:10:43.335 --> 02:10:45.237
RECYCLED IN THE STATE TO HELP
02:10:45.304 --> 02:10:50.008
KEEP THIS OUT OF YOUR LANDFILL
02:10:50.075 --> 02:10:59.151
AND AND OF WATER WAYS.
02:10:59.218 --> 02:11:00.786
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR COMMITTEE
02:11:00.852 --> 02:11:03.722
MEMBERS FOR TAKE UNDER
02:11:03.789 --> 02:11:06.091
CONSIDERATION APOLOGIZE SIR.
02:11:06.158 --> 02:11:06.959
REYES RICH COST ON THE DIRECTOR
02:11:07.025 --> 02:11:08.527
PROCUREMENT SUSTAINABILITY IT
02:11:08.594 --> 02:11:09.661
CORRELATE INDUSTRIES LONGER
02:11:09.728 --> 02:11:10.562
COALITION A CALIFORNIA GROUP
02:11:10.629 --> 02:11:12.898
REQUIREMENTS THAT CONSIST OF ALL
02:11:12.965 --> 02:11:13.899
REQUIRES THE STATE EXCEPT.
02:11:13.966 --> 02:11:14.700
FOR ONE WE PURCHASED THE BOTTLES
02:11:14.766 --> 02:11:15.667
PIPE TRUCKLOAD FROM STATE
02:11:15.734 --> 02:11:16.568
PROCESSORS AND RECYCLERS IN
02:11:16.635 --> 02:11:17.569
EXCESS OF A HUNDRED MILLION
02:11:17.636 --> 02:11:18.370
POUNDS OR TWO BILLION BOTTLES
02:11:18.437 --> 02:11:20.105
ANNUALLY AND PROCESS MATERIAL.
02:11:20.172 --> 02:11:21.807
THROUGH OUR PLANT RIVERSIDE BACK
02:11:21.873 --> 02:11:24.042
IN A NEW PT PELLETS WHICH IS FDA
02:11:24.109 --> 02:11:25.444
CERTIFIED FOR FOOD GRADE CONTACT
02:11:25.510 --> 02:11:26.745
UP TO A 100%.
02:11:26.812 --> 02:11:27.279
WE HAVE BEEN SUCCESSFULLY
02:11:27.346 --> 02:11:32.184
PERFORMING THE SERVICES.
02:11:32.251 --> 02:11:32.784
TWO THOUSAND TWELVE WE'VE BEEN
02:11:32.851 --> 02:11:33.585
DOWN THIS MINIMUM PATH GOING ON
02:11:33.652 --> 02:11:34.186
FOR FOUR YEARS NOW AND GETTING
02:11:34.253 --> 02:11:34.853
NEW GROUND EACH TIME.
02:11:34.920 --> 02:11:36.488
WE EDUCATE.
02:11:36.555 --> 02:11:38.257
THE WILLING OF THE FACTS ABOUT
02:11:38.323 --> 02:11:38.991
INDUSTRIES CAPABILITY AND NOT
02:11:39.057 --> 02:11:40.359
THE SECTIONAL HAVE TREES PUT OUT
02:11:40.425 --> 02:11:41.994
BY SOME WHO SAY IT'S NOT SAFE
02:11:42.060 --> 02:11:43.128
FOR FOR CONTACT BUT THERE'S NOT
02:11:43.195 --> 02:11:45.397
ENOUGH GOOD MATERIAL.
02:11:45.464 --> 02:11:45.897
OR RECYCLING IS FINDING
02:11:45.964 --> 02:11:47.532
CALIFORNIA.
02:11:47.599 --> 02:11:48.300
NGUYEN RECYCLE P. TWO BOTTLES
02:11:48.367 --> 02:11:49.268
ARE DOWN CYCLE THAT TO OTHER
02:11:49.334 --> 02:11:50.135
PRODUCTS AND SET UP SHORE THE
02:11:50.202 --> 02:11:51.536
CHAIN IS BROKEN AND WE LOSE
02:11:51.603 --> 02:11:52.971
ABILITY TO CLOSE THE LOOP.
02:11:53.038 --> 02:11:55.307
AND LIMIT NEW FOSSIL FUELS LIVE
02:11:55.374 --> 02:11:57.709
IT.
02:11:57.776 --> 02:12:00.379
X. WITH THE LIMITED.
02:12:00.445 --> 02:12:01.847
THAT'S WE LIMIT THAN DO.
02:12:01.913 --> 02:12:02.848
OF SIDE THE NEW FOSSIL FUELS A
02:12:02.914 --> 02:12:04.750
VIRGIN PT BADAK COULD BE PROCESS
02:12:04.816 --> 02:12:06.084
BACK INTO A BOTTLE OVER AND OVER
02:12:06.151 --> 02:12:06.918
AGAIN AND TELL US BANKS DOWN
02:12:06.985 --> 02:12:09.054
CYCLE INTO ANOTHER PRODUCT OR
02:12:09.121 --> 02:12:09.921
OFF SHORT.
02:12:09.988 --> 02:12:11.323
IT'S A CHICKEN OR EGG ARGUMENT
02:12:11.390 --> 02:12:12.557
THAT COMES TO MIND WE DISCUSS TO
02:12:12.624 --> 02:12:13.592
DEBATE THIS TOPIC.
02:12:13.659 --> 02:12:15.260
IT'S TRUE WE DO HAVE THE MOST
02:12:15.327 --> 02:12:16.061
FOR BUS RECYCLING INFRASTRUCTURE
02:12:16.128 --> 02:12:17.396
IN THE NATION WITH THE RECYCLING
02:12:17.462 --> 02:12:19.131
RATE THAT HOVERS AROUND 70% YEAR
02:12:19.197 --> 02:12:20.165
AFTER YEAR.
02:12:20.232 --> 02:12:21.500
BUT WE MUST SET NEW STANDARDS TO
02:12:21.566 --> 02:12:23.001
PUSH INDUSTRY TO REALIZE MORE
02:12:23.068 --> 02:12:24.336
THE RECYCLE MATERIALS THAT THEY
02:12:24.403 --> 02:12:25.370
SELL TO THE PUBLIC.
02:12:25.437 --> 02:12:27.105
THE REALIZATION RATE FOR OUR PET
02:12:27.172 --> 02:12:29.941
BACKING ABOLISHED EVER 007%.
02:12:30.008 --> 02:12:31.476
YOU HAVE A GREAT RECYCLING STORY
02:12:31.543 --> 02:12:32.678
WE NOW NEED WE'RE GREAT
02:12:32.744 --> 02:12:33.478
RECYCLING THAT WE NEED
02:12:33.545 --> 02:12:35.380
REALIZATION AND PRACTICE TO
02:12:35.447 --> 02:12:36.682
CLOSE THE LOOP AT CIRCA CONNERY
02:12:36.748 --> 02:12:38.383
WE MUST DO BETTER.
02:12:38.450 --> 02:12:39.351
I UNDERSTAND OUR FRIENDS ON THE
02:12:39.418 --> 02:12:41.320
OTHER SIDE WHO OPPOSE A MANDATE
02:12:41.386 --> 02:12:42.120
MANY OF WHOM ARE OUR CUSTOMERS
02:12:42.187 --> 02:12:42.888
BY THE WAY.
02:12:42.954 --> 02:12:44.222
NO ONE WANTS GOVERNMENT TELLING
02:12:44.289 --> 02:12:45.357
THEM HOW TO RUN THEIR BUSINESS.
02:12:45.424 --> 02:12:46.692
BUT THEY HAVE THE OPTION BE A
02:12:46.758 --> 02:12:48.060
VIRGIN WE DO NOT.
02:12:48.126 --> 02:12:49.428
IT'S IF IT'S AT A COST SAVINGS
02:12:49.494 --> 02:12:54.466
TO THEM THE MATTEL YES WE USE IT
02:12:54.533 --> 02:12:55.867
BUT ONLY IF IT'S CHEAPER.
02:12:55.934 --> 02:12:56.735
UNFORTUNATELY COSTS ASSOCIATED
02:12:56.802 --> 02:12:57.369
WITH RECYCLING FOR STRUCTURE THE
02:12:57.436 --> 02:12:58.503
STATE HAS NO BEARING ON DOMESTIC
02:12:58.570 --> 02:12:59.404
OR INTERNATIONAL VERGE OF
02:12:59.471 --> 02:13:00.472
PRICING AT ALL THAT PUTS OUR
02:13:00.539 --> 02:13:01.106
INDUSTRY IN A NO WIN SITUATION.
02:13:01.173 --> 02:13:02.040
TAKE ORDERS A LOSS OF HOPE
02:13:02.107 --> 02:13:03.508
VIRGIN RESIN GOES UP AT SOME
02:13:03.575 --> 02:13:04.409
POINT OR SHUT DOWN A HUNDRED
02:13:04.476 --> 02:13:05.711
MILLION DOLLAR PLAN THAT'S JUST
02:13:05.777 --> 02:13:06.978
ONE COMPANY.
02:13:07.045 --> 02:13:07.879
WE NEED ONGOING GUARANTEE FOR
02:13:07.946 --> 02:13:08.814
THE BALLING THE STREET TO SECURE
02:13:08.880 --> 02:13:10.248
CAPITAL INVESTMENTS FOR FUTURE
02:13:10.315 --> 02:13:11.683
GROWTH EXPANSIONS WITHIN THE
02:13:11.750 --> 02:13:12.751
STATE AND WITHOUT IT WE COULD
02:13:12.818 --> 02:13:15.253
LOSE A GREAT SUCCESS STORY WE
02:13:15.320 --> 02:13:16.588
HAVE A CALIFORNIA RECYCLING.
02:13:16.655 --> 02:13:18.290
A CLOSE WITH THAT I'M HAPPY TO
02:13:18.357 --> 02:13:21.293
TAKE ANY QUESTIONS THE MAP.
02:13:21.360 --> 02:13:21.560
THANK YOU.
02:13:21.626 --> 02:13:23.428
WITH US.
02:13:23.495 --> 02:13:24.329
CHAIRMAN MEMBERS MARK VERY WITH
02:13:24.396 --> 02:13:25.797
THE ENVIRONMENT OF CALIFORNIANS
02:13:25.864 --> 02:13:26.598
AGAINST WASTE.
02:13:26.665 --> 02:13:28.567
ASSEMBLYMEMBER TINGS MEASURE
02:13:28.633 --> 02:13:30.202
WILL ENHANCE AND EXPAND THE
02:13:30.268 --> 02:13:32.237
MARKETS FOR THE NINE BILLION
02:13:32.304 --> 02:13:34.973
PLASTIC BEVERAGE CONTAINERS THAT
02:13:35.040 --> 02:13:36.375
CONSUMERS ARE ALREADY RECOVERED.
02:13:36.441 --> 02:13:37.676
AND IT ALSO CREATE NEW
02:13:37.743 --> 02:13:39.578
INCENTIVES FOR THE THREE AND A
02:13:39.644 --> 02:13:41.747
HALF BILLION PLASTIC BOTTLES
02:13:41.813 --> 02:13:43.882
THAT WE AREN'T RECYCLING THAT
02:13:43.949 --> 02:13:45.617
ARE GETTING LITERATURE LANDFILLS.
02:13:45.684 --> 02:13:46.952
THE EXPERIENCE THIS WHOLE CHINA
02:13:47.018 --> 02:13:48.286
NATIONAL SOARED.
02:13:48.353 --> 02:13:50.255
EPISODE HAS TOLD US THAT WE'RE
02:13:50.322 --> 02:13:52.324
NOT REALLY RECYCLING UNLESS
02:13:52.391 --> 02:13:54.359
SOMEBODY IS BUYING THAT MATERIAL
02:13:54.426 --> 02:13:55.727
IF THEY'RE NOT BUYING THE
02:13:55.794 --> 02:13:57.429
PLASTIC AND PUTTING IT INTO A
02:13:57.496 --> 02:13:59.364
NEW PRODUCT THAT WE'RE NOT
02:13:59.431 --> 02:14:00.232
REALLY RECYCLING.
02:14:00.298 --> 02:14:02.401
OUGHT THE RECYCLE CONTENT THE
02:14:02.467 --> 02:14:04.136
IDEA OF MANDATING RECYCLE
02:14:04.202 --> 02:14:05.937
CONTENT IS SOMETHING THAT THIS
02:14:06.004 --> 02:14:08.206
STATE PIONEERED TWENTY FIVE
02:14:08.273 --> 02:14:09.107
YEARS AGO.
02:14:09.174 --> 02:14:10.642
YOUR PREDECESSORS SET MINIMUM
02:14:10.709 --> 02:14:12.644
RECYCLE CONTENT REQUIREMENTS FOR
02:14:12.711 --> 02:14:14.579
NEWSPRINT FOR NON FOOD PLASTIC
02:14:14.646 --> 02:14:16.615
CONTAINERS ALL AND FOR GLASS
02:14:16.681 --> 02:14:17.282
CONTAINERS.
02:14:17.349 --> 02:14:19.651
TODAY WE HAVE A 35% RECYCLED
02:14:19.718 --> 02:14:21.553
CONTENT MANDATE FOR GLASS
02:14:21.620 --> 02:14:23.121
CONTAINERS BUT THE MARKET.
02:14:23.188 --> 02:14:24.923
THAT WE HELP BUILD IS ACHIEVING
02:14:24.990 --> 02:14:27.159
MORE THAN 50% RECYCLED CONTENT
02:14:27.225 --> 02:14:29.428
AND THE RECOVERY RATE FOR THE PT
02:14:29.494 --> 02:14:31.630
BOTTLE IS HIGHER THAN THE
02:14:31.696 --> 02:14:33.565
RECOVERY RATE FOR GLASS BOTTLES.
02:14:33.632 --> 02:14:35.534
AND WE ONLY HAVE ONE PROCESSOR
02:14:35.600 --> 02:14:36.535
FOR GLASS IN THE STATE OF
02:14:36.601 --> 02:14:41.640
CALIFORNIA AND YET WE'RE USING
02:14:41.706 --> 02:14:42.641
50% RECYCLED CONTENT.
02:14:42.707 --> 02:14:43.608
WE HAVE MORE THAN A HALF A DOZEN
02:14:43.675 --> 02:14:44.409
PROCESSORS OF RECYCLED PLASTIC
02:14:44.476 --> 02:14:45.911
IN THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA.
02:14:45.977 --> 02:14:47.212
AND THE REASON THAT WE HAVE A
02:14:47.279 --> 02:14:49.080
HALF A DOZEN PROCESSORS FOR THAT
02:14:49.147 --> 02:14:51.082
MATERIAL IS BECAUSE PRIVATE
02:14:51.149 --> 02:14:52.184
INVESTORS IN THE STATE OF
02:14:52.250 --> 02:14:54.753
CALIFORNIA HAVE INVESTED IN THAT.
02:14:54.820 --> 02:14:56.121
WE'VE USED TAX CREDITS WE'VE
02:14:56.188 --> 02:14:57.823
USED MORE THAN A HUNDRED MILLION
02:14:57.889 --> 02:14:58.757
DOLLARS.
02:14:58.824 --> 02:15:01.393
IN TAX CREDITS IN ON RUDY MONEY
02:15:01.460 --> 02:15:02.461
FROM THE BEVERAGE CONTAINER
02:15:02.527 --> 02:15:04.896
RECYCLING PROGRAM TO DEVELOP
02:15:04.963 --> 02:15:06.998
THESE FACILITIES.
02:15:07.065 --> 02:15:08.467
AND WE NOW HAVE CAPACITY IN
02:15:08.533 --> 02:15:11.303
CALIFORNIA FOR PROCESSING AND
02:15:11.369 --> 02:15:12.904
TURNING INTO FOOD GRADE
02:15:12.971 --> 02:15:14.072
PACKAGING.
02:15:14.139 --> 02:15:15.440
ANOTHER PLASTIC.
02:15:15.507 --> 02:15:17.576
BUT ENOUGH PLASTIC TO RECYCLE
02:15:17.642 --> 02:15:19.044
EVERYTHING THAT'S COLLECTED IN
02:15:19.110 --> 02:15:20.312
THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA BUT THAT
02:15:20.378 --> 02:15:22.347
SYSTEM IS BEING UNDER UTILIZED
02:15:22.414 --> 02:15:23.815
BECAUSE THE BEVERAGE CONTAINER
02:15:23.882 --> 02:15:25.183
MANUFACTURERS ARE NOT BUYING
02:15:25.250 --> 02:15:26.384
THAT MATERIAL BACK.
02:15:26.451 --> 02:15:28.253
THIS MEASURE WILL REQUIRE THAT
02:15:28.320 --> 02:15:31.156
THEY BY THE MATERIAL BACK WE ARE
02:15:31.223 --> 02:15:31.857
CHEN AYE VOTE.
02:15:31.923 --> 02:15:32.390
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR YOUR
02:15:32.457 --> 02:15:36.428
TESTIMONY ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT.
02:15:36.495 --> 02:15:37.863
MELISSA ROMERO ON BEHALF OF THE
02:15:37.929 --> 02:15:39.064
CALIFORNIA LEAGUE OF
02:15:39.130 --> 02:15:42.033
CONSERVATION VOTERS IN SUPPORT.
02:15:42.100 --> 02:15:43.335
NATALIE KNOCKS ON BEHALF OF
02:15:43.401 --> 02:15:46.605
RETHINK WASTE IN SUPPORT.
02:15:46.671 --> 02:15:47.639
OR FRONT TEND TO HAVE THE
02:15:47.706 --> 02:15:48.974
CALIFORNIA REFUSE RECYCLING
02:15:49.040 --> 02:15:50.509
COUNCIL NORTHERN DISTRICT IN
02:15:50.575 --> 02:15:53.111
SUPPORT.
02:15:53.178 --> 02:15:54.379
STEPHANIE MORE ON BEHALF OF
02:15:54.446 --> 02:15:57.382
APOLOGY AND SUPPORT.
02:15:57.449 --> 02:15:59.084
HELLO VICTORIA ROOM WITH NATURAL
02:15:59.150 --> 02:16:00.385
RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL IN
02:16:00.452 --> 02:16:02.888
SUPPORT.
02:16:02.954 --> 02:16:04.055
AND ONLY ZERO DEFENDERS OF
02:16:04.122 --> 02:16:07.192
WILDLIFE IN SUPPORT.
02:16:07.259 --> 02:16:08.560
PERSONAL GET US ON BEHALF OF
02:16:08.627 --> 02:16:10.829
SOLOWAY CESSATION NORTH AMERICA
02:16:10.896 --> 02:16:13.899
AND STOP WASTE IN SUPPORT.
02:16:13.965 --> 02:16:15.300
A GOOD EVENING TONY GONZALEZ ON
02:16:15.367 --> 02:16:17.068
BEHALF OF TOM AND WITH AMERICA
02:16:17.135 --> 02:16:19.337
IN SUPPORT.
02:16:19.404 --> 02:16:20.539
THERESA BROKERAGE ON BEHALF OF
02:16:20.605 --> 02:16:21.773
HILL THE BASE SEVENTH GENERATION
02:16:21.840 --> 02:16:23.408
ADVISORS AND THE OTHER MEMBERS
02:16:23.475 --> 02:16:24.976
OF THE CLEAN SEIZE LOVING
02:16:25.043 --> 02:16:26.912
COALITION IN SUPPORT.
02:16:26.978 --> 02:16:28.680
LAUREN COMMON BEHALF OF SIERRA
02:16:28.747 --> 02:16:31.216
CLUB CALIFORNIA IN SUPPORT.
02:16:31.283 --> 02:16:32.584
JENNIFER SAVAGE SURFRIDER
02:16:32.651 --> 02:16:36.755
FOUNDATION IN SUPPORT.
02:16:36.821 --> 02:16:38.790
THEN I CAN BURKE ON BEHALF OF
02:16:38.857 --> 02:16:39.357
SAN FRANCISCO BAY KEEPER AND
02:16:39.424 --> 02:16:40.258
SUPPORT.
02:16:40.325 --> 02:16:41.893
THANK YOU VERY MUCH ANYONE ELSE
02:16:41.960 --> 02:16:43.695
IN SUPPORT.
02:16:43.762 --> 02:16:57.676
SEE AN NINE ANY OPPOSITION.
02:16:57.742 --> 02:16:59.377
GOOD AFTERNOON.
02:16:59.444 --> 02:17:01.580
COMMITTEE MEMBERS CHAIR.
02:17:01.646 --> 02:17:05.984
I'M SORRY ABOUT THAT AB THERE.
02:17:06.051 --> 02:17:06.618
FEDERICA MCGEE ON BEHALF OF THE
02:17:06.685 --> 02:17:08.453
AMERICAN BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION --
02:17:08.520 --> 02:17:09.921
UNFORTUNATELY OPPOSE UNLESS
02:17:09.988 --> 02:17:12.123
AMENDED COUPLE OF CONCERNS WE
02:17:12.190 --> 02:17:14.292
HAVE MOSTLY WE WANT TO SEE
02:17:14.359 --> 02:17:15.961
RECYCLE CONTENT NOT OPPOSED TO
02:17:16.027 --> 02:17:17.395
THAT THE NUMBERS THAT ARE
02:17:17.462 --> 02:17:19.631
OUTLINED IN EIGHTY SEVEN NINETY
02:17:19.698 --> 02:17:21.132
TWO OR SIMPLY NOT REACHABLE --
02:17:21.199 --> 02:17:22.534
WHEN WE TALK ABOUT OUR
02:17:22.601 --> 02:17:25.437
COLLECTION RATE IN CALIFORNIA WE
02:17:25.503 --> 02:17:26.905
HAVE A SEVENTY FIVE OR 80%
02:17:26.972 --> 02:17:30.008
COLLECTION RIGHT SO IF YOU GET
02:17:30.075 --> 02:17:32.143
275% OR A 100% WHICH ARE
02:17:32.210 --> 02:17:34.412
OUTLINED IN AB?
02:17:34.479 --> 02:17:35.280
SEVEN NINETY TWO IT DOESN'T
02:17:35.347 --> 02:17:36.815
RECOGNIZE THE FACT THAT WE'RE
02:17:36.881 --> 02:17:38.717
NOT GETTING A 100% EVENING
02:17:38.783 --> 02:17:41.019
COLLECTED BACK -- LET ALONE THE
02:17:41.086 --> 02:17:42.854
CONTAMINATION THAT WE TALKED
02:17:42.921 --> 02:17:45.223
ABOUT EVEN IN -- AGUILAR CARRIES
02:17:45.290 --> 02:17:47.759
BILL EARLIER TODAY SO WE ARE
02:17:47.826 --> 02:17:50.762
ALREADY DOWN FROM 1100% ACTUALLY
02:17:50.829 --> 02:17:52.430
DOWN THE 75% IF THAT'S THE
02:17:52.497 --> 02:17:53.698
COLLECTION RATE AT THAT
02:17:53.765 --> 02:17:55.200
PARTICULAR TIME.
02:17:55.266 --> 02:17:57.002
THE SECOND THING THERE'S YIELD
02:17:57.068 --> 02:17:59.237
LOSS OUR P. R. C. C. DID A STUDY
02:17:59.304 --> 02:18:02.540
IN THE FALL WITH OUR RECLAIMER
02:18:02.607 --> 02:18:04.776
IS AND AND AND LOOKED AT ABOUT.
02:18:04.843 --> 02:18:06.578
THIRTY THREE AT THREE THOUSAND
02:18:06.645 --> 02:18:07.178
THREE HUNDRED AND FIFTY EIGHT
02:18:07.245 --> 02:18:09.047
POUNDS OF SORTED BAIL SO WHEN
02:18:09.114 --> 02:18:10.248
YOU GET THE BALES A COME BACK.
02:18:10.315 --> 02:18:12.317
EVEN THE RECLAIMER IS HAD A TEN
02:18:12.384 --> 02:18:14.185
AND A HALF PERCENT YIELD LOSS
02:18:14.252 --> 02:18:16.721
FROM THE BAIL THAT CAME BACK SO
02:18:16.788 --> 02:18:18.857
NOW YOU'RE ALREADY DOWN FROM
02:18:18.923 --> 02:18:20.392
WHATEVER THE 75%.
02:18:20.458 --> 02:18:22.727
OF OUR COLLECTION RADIUS FROM
02:18:22.794 --> 02:18:24.429
WHAT YOU GET BACK FROM WHAT THEY
02:18:24.496 --> 02:18:26.331
GET BACK TO THAT TO THE BAIL SO
02:18:26.398 --> 02:18:28.933
YOU'RE NEVER GOING TO GET TO A
02:18:29.000 --> 02:18:31.369
75% OR A 100% RATE.
02:18:31.436 --> 02:18:32.771
TURNING AROUND INTO ANOTHER
02:18:32.837 --> 02:18:36.074
BOTTLE -- WE TALK ABOUT THE FDA
02:18:36.141 --> 02:18:39.644
STANDARDS THAT IS IMPORTANT AND
02:18:39.711 --> 02:18:41.513
OUR OTHER OUR OTHER PRODUCTS
02:18:41.579 --> 02:18:43.481
SUCH AS THAT THEY TALKED ABOUT
02:18:43.548 --> 02:18:44.616
WHAT A 100%.
02:18:44.683 --> 02:18:46.484
RECYCLED CONTENT RATE THAT'S
02:18:46.551 --> 02:18:47.886
RIGHT THERE ARE SOME BEVERAGES
02:18:47.952 --> 02:18:51.122
THAT THAT BOTTLE CAN HAVE 1100%
02:18:51.189 --> 02:18:52.824
RECYCLED CONTENT BUT THERE ARE
02:18:52.891 --> 02:18:55.593
CARBONATED DRINKS WHERE THE THAT --
02:18:55.660 --> 02:18:57.662
CONSISTENCY OF THAT BOTTLE MUST
02:18:57.729 --> 02:18:59.431
BE DIFFERENT BASED ON THE FDA
02:18:59.497 --> 02:19:05.036
STANDARDS AND SO ALL BEVERAGES
02:19:05.103 --> 02:19:06.471
ARE NOT COULD CREATED THE COOL
02:19:06.538 --> 02:19:07.906
THE EXAMPLES WERE YOU KNOW SOME
02:19:07.972 --> 02:19:09.474
OF OUR OUR OUR DRINKS THAT KIND
02:19:09.541 --> 02:19:10.942
OF OUR WATER OR OTHER PRODUCTS
02:19:11.009 --> 02:19:13.211
AND SO WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE TYPE
02:19:13.278 --> 02:19:13.511
OF PRODUCT.
02:19:13.578 --> 02:19:15.513
IT IS VERY IMPORTANT TIME LINES
02:19:15.580 --> 02:19:18.183
ARE CONCERNING HERE SOME OF THE
02:19:18.249 --> 02:19:20.051
CONTRACTS ARE. TWO IN THREE
02:19:20.118 --> 02:19:21.319
YEARS OUT WE DON'T HAVE AN
02:19:21.386 --> 02:19:23.021
OPPORTUNITY TO GET THERE AND SO
02:19:23.088 --> 02:19:24.789
EVEN IF WE CAN LAND ON A NUMBER
02:19:24.856 --> 02:19:26.591
OR A TIME MIND WE ALSO THINK
02:19:26.658 --> 02:19:27.025
THAT.
02:19:27.092 --> 02:19:28.693
PRICE GOUGING CONCERN SHOULD BE
02:19:28.760 --> 02:19:30.495
CONSENT LAID OUT IN THE BILL AND
02:19:30.562 --> 02:19:32.063
THOSE PROTECTION SHOULD BE IN
02:19:32.130 --> 02:19:32.964
THERE THERE SHOULD BE --
02:19:33.031 --> 02:19:34.966
CONSPIRE AS CONCESSIONS FOR
02:19:35.033 --> 02:19:37.068
COMPANIES LIKE COCA COLA WHO
02:19:37.135 --> 02:19:38.770
HAVE PLANT BASED PRODUCTS THAT
02:19:38.837 --> 02:19:40.205
ARE NOT PUTTING AS MUCH VIRGIN
02:19:40.271 --> 02:19:42.006
INTO THE TO THE SYSTEM AND THAT
02:19:42.073 --> 02:19:43.775
SHOULD BE CONSIDERED AN ART LAID
02:19:43.842 --> 02:19:43.975
OUT.
02:19:44.042 --> 02:19:46.044
IN HERE AS WELL AND SO AND
02:19:46.111 --> 02:19:48.113
LASTLY -- THERE SHOULD BE AN
02:19:48.179 --> 02:19:50.081
OPPORTUNITY TO AVERAGE IT ACROSS
02:19:50.148 --> 02:19:51.182
THE PORTFOLIO BECAUSE ALL
02:19:51.249 --> 02:19:52.650
BEVERAGES ARE NOT THE SAME.
02:19:52.717 --> 02:19:55.353
THANK YOU VERY MUCH ANYONE ELSE
02:19:55.420 --> 02:20:00.792
IN OPPOSITION.
02:20:00.859 --> 02:20:02.026
DENNIS I'LL BE ON A ON A BEHALF
02:20:02.093 --> 02:20:03.828
THE GROCERY MANUFACTURERS BUT
02:20:03.895 --> 02:20:05.330
THE ABA REPRESENT OF LAID OUT A
02:20:05.396 --> 02:20:07.832
VERY GOOD -- SET THAT THIS IS
02:20:07.899 --> 02:20:10.568
JUST COMPLETELY IN FEASIBLE THE
02:20:10.635 --> 02:20:12.103
TIME LINES ARE NOT -- COULD NOT
02:20:12.170 --> 02:20:13.404
BE MAD AND IT'S NOT ONLY ABOUT
02:20:13.471 --> 02:20:16.207
THE BIG LARGE MANUFACTURERS
02:20:16.274 --> 02:20:18.076
THERE'S ALSO -- YOU THINK ABOUT
02:20:18.143 --> 02:20:19.544
ALL THE STORE BRANDS THE BELL
02:20:19.611 --> 02:20:21.079
THE PRIVATE MANUFACTURES BE ABLE
02:20:21.146 --> 02:20:22.680
TO GET TO THAT FIRST STEP --
02:20:22.747 --> 02:20:24.582
WHICH IN THIS BILL IS NEXT YEAR
02:20:24.649 --> 02:20:26.851
REQUIRE ONE YEAR FOR COMPLIANCE
02:20:26.918 --> 02:20:28.286
SO THOSE ARE AREAS THAT THAT
02:20:28.353 --> 02:20:29.788
THAT NEED TO BE ADDRESSED.
02:20:29.854 --> 02:20:30.588
I THINK ALSO THERE'S ALSO
02:20:30.655 --> 02:20:32.824
REGRETTABLE SUBSTITUTION THESE
02:20:32.891 --> 02:20:34.492
BOTTLES THE PT THAT.
02:20:34.559 --> 02:20:35.393
THAT THE PROPONENTS BROUGHT
02:20:35.460 --> 02:20:38.930
FORWARD IS A 1100% RECYCLABLE
02:20:38.997 --> 02:20:39.464
BOTTLE.
02:20:39.531 --> 02:20:40.999
AND BY THE WAY THAT THE NATIONAL
02:20:41.065 --> 02:20:41.399
SORT.
02:20:41.466 --> 02:20:43.868
WITH A VERY SIGNIFICANT ISSUE
02:20:43.935 --> 02:20:45.203
BUT FOR OUR PET.
02:20:45.270 --> 02:20:46.671
OUR PET ACTUALLY THE PRICEY
02:20:46.738 --> 02:20:48.907
RETAINED VERY STRONG VALUE
02:20:48.973 --> 02:20:50.875
THROUGHOUT THAT TIME WOULD DUMP
02:20:50.942 --> 02:20:53.011
A FEW MONTHS AND BOUNCE BACK UP
02:20:53.077 --> 02:20:53.912
TO EQUILIBRIUM.
02:20:53.978 --> 02:20:55.747
SO OUR PET IS A DIFFERENT
02:20:55.814 --> 02:20:57.182
MATERIAL BASED ON DIFFERENT.
02:20:57.248 --> 02:20:58.950
AND NATIONAL INTERNATIONAL
02:20:59.017 --> 02:21:00.718
MARKETS.
02:21:00.785 --> 02:21:02.187
AND SO.
02:21:02.253 --> 02:21:03.221
WELL WE DON'T WANT TO DO IS TO
02:21:03.288 --> 02:21:05.757
DRIVE TO A REGRETTABLE
02:21:05.824 --> 02:21:07.492
SUBSTITUTION SITUATION WE HAVE
02:21:07.559 --> 02:21:09.093
THINGS LIKE THIS THIS CAME OUT
02:21:09.160 --> 02:21:11.429
OF THE SIX OF FLOOR CAFETERIA.
02:21:11.496 --> 02:21:13.765
THIS IS NOT A WILD IS PAPER IT
02:21:13.832 --> 02:21:15.834
IS LINED WITH A WITH A LINER
02:21:15.900 --> 02:21:17.302
THAT IS NOT RECYCLABLE IT HAS A
02:21:17.368 --> 02:21:19.037
SECOND MATERIAL IN HERE WHICH IS
02:21:19.103 --> 02:21:20.271
A PLASTIC PRODUCT.
02:21:20.338 --> 02:21:21.773
AND SO THIS IS A VERY ON
02:21:21.840 --> 02:21:23.875
RECYCLABLE UP.
02:21:23.942 --> 02:21:26.077
OF A PACKAGE IT'S A WE DON'T
02:21:26.144 --> 02:21:27.278
WANT TO DRY THINGS OUT OF OUR
02:21:27.345 --> 02:21:29.547
PETS ARE PET IS A IS A ISA GOOD
02:21:29.614 --> 02:21:34.552
MATERIAL AND WE CAN GET BEHIND.
02:21:34.619 --> 02:21:35.520
RECYCLED CONTENT AS THE MOST OF
02:21:35.587 --> 02:21:36.654
THE THE THE MANUFACTURERS HAVE
02:21:36.721 --> 02:21:37.555
ALREADY.
02:21:37.622 --> 02:21:38.690
IT'S JUST A MATTER OF
02:21:38.756 --> 02:21:40.758
FEASIBILITY TIMING LIKE SAY ONE
02:21:40.825 --> 02:21:42.160
MORE THING SO MARCH TWENTY
02:21:42.227 --> 02:21:43.461
SEVENTH THE THE E. U..
02:21:43.528 --> 02:21:45.730
LAID OUT THEIR STANDARDS AND
02:21:45.797 --> 02:21:46.631
THEY STUDY THIS FOR SEVERAL
02:21:46.698 --> 02:21:48.299
YEARS THEY LOOKED AT IT VERY
02:21:48.366 --> 02:21:51.035
INTENTLY AND THEIR STANDARDS ARE
02:21:51.102 --> 02:21:52.837
25% BY.
02:21:52.904 --> 02:21:53.471
TWENTY TWENTY FIVE SO THEY GIVE%
02:21:53.538 --> 02:21:55.139
A FIVE SIX YEAR A GLIDE PATH ON
02:21:55.206 --> 02:21:55.740
THAT.
02:21:55.807 --> 02:21:58.643
AND THEN THEY ARE 30% BY.
02:21:58.710 --> 02:21:59.878
TWENTY THIRTY THEY ALSO HAVE A
02:21:59.944 --> 02:22:03.081
GOAL -- REQUIREMENT OF OF 90% OF
02:22:03.147 --> 02:22:04.182
RECYCLING.
02:22:04.249 --> 02:22:05.617
AND SO THEY HAVE A MUCH BETTER
02:22:05.683 --> 02:22:07.352
RECLAIMING SYSTEM THAT WE HAVE
02:22:07.418 --> 02:22:08.319
AND THEY'RE STILL AT THOSE
02:22:08.386 --> 02:22:10.054
NUMBERS SO THAT THAT'S CLEARLY A
02:22:10.121 --> 02:22:11.456
DEMONSTRATION THAT THAT'S NOT
02:22:11.522 --> 02:22:12.824
FEASIBLE TO MEET THE
02:22:12.891 --> 02:22:13.591
REQUIREMENTS OF THIS BILL THANK
02:22:13.658 --> 02:22:14.359
YOU.
02:22:14.425 --> 02:22:16.060
THANK YOU SO MUCH ANYONE ELSE IN
02:22:16.127 --> 02:22:18.963
OPPOSITION NAME AN ORGANIZATION
02:22:19.030 --> 02:22:20.164
PLEASE.
02:22:20.231 --> 02:22:22.267
GOOD AFTERNOON MEMBERS OF THE
02:22:22.333 --> 02:22:23.101
COMMITTEE IN SOME THE NUMBER
02:22:23.167 --> 02:22:24.202
TING MY NAME'S THEIR THOMAS ON
02:22:24.269 --> 02:22:25.236
BEHALF OF NIAGARA BOTTLING WITH
02:22:25.303 --> 02:22:26.537
THE LARGEST PRIVATE LABEL.
02:22:26.604 --> 02:22:27.906
BOTTLED WATER COMPANY IN THE
02:22:27.972 --> 02:22:30.341
COUNTRY AND THE LARGEST USER OUR
02:22:30.408 --> 02:22:32.277
PET IN CALIFORNIA WERE IN
02:22:32.343 --> 02:22:33.912
OPPOSITION MEMBER PROPOSAL WE
02:22:33.978 --> 02:22:34.312
WILL.
02:22:34.379 --> 02:22:36.180
LOOK FOR THE WORKING WITH
02:22:36.247 --> 02:22:38.182
STAKEHOLDERS AND WE'RE VERY
02:22:38.249 --> 02:22:40.118
OPTIMISTIC WE CAN CHANGE
02:22:40.184 --> 02:22:41.519
SOMETHING THANK YOU SO MUCH.
02:22:41.586 --> 02:22:43.187
MY CORPORATE BEHALF OF NESTLE
02:22:43.254 --> 02:22:44.956
WATERS NORTH AMERICA ALSO IN
02:22:45.023 --> 02:22:47.025
OPPOSITION BUT I DO JUST WANT TO
02:22:47.091 --> 02:22:49.060
SAY WE'RE WALKING THE WALK AS
02:22:49.127 --> 02:22:50.361
MYSTERY JUST.
02:22:50.428 --> 02:22:52.830
POINTED OUT AT 50% ON ARROWHEAD.
02:22:52.897 --> 02:22:56.467
AND WE DO INTEND TO COLLECTIVE
02:22:56.534 --> 02:22:58.403
WERE COMMITTED TO COLLECTIVELY --
02:22:58.469 --> 02:23:00.338
TO CONSTRUCTIVELY ENGAGING WITH
02:23:00.405 --> 02:23:02.607
MR MURRAY OUR BUSINESS PARTNERS
02:23:02.674 --> 02:23:04.709
THE RECLAIMER IS TO GET A
02:23:04.776 --> 02:23:06.577
SOLUTION THANK YOU SO MUCH.
02:23:06.644 --> 02:23:07.645
ALL RIGHT.
02:23:07.712 --> 02:23:09.580
ANYONE ELSE OPPOSITION SEE AN
02:23:09.647 --> 02:23:11.349
NINE ANY QUESTION COMMITTEE.
02:23:11.416 --> 02:23:13.084
THE SEGMENT.
02:23:13.151 --> 02:23:14.352
I THINK YOU AB.
02:23:14.419 --> 02:23:15.553
THANK YOU MISTER KING FOR
02:23:15.620 --> 02:23:18.356
WORKING ON THIS ISSUE -- AND I
02:23:18.423 --> 02:23:20.391
GUESS MY QUESTION WAS ABOUT.
02:23:20.458 --> 02:23:21.025
TWENTY TWENTY ONE THAT'S THAT'S
02:23:21.092 --> 02:23:22.460
A PRETTY FAST TURN AROUND TIME
02:23:22.527 --> 02:23:25.096
AND ALSO ABOUT THE U. RIGHT TO
02:23:25.163 --> 02:23:26.631
THE YOU HAVE STUDIED THIS.
02:23:26.698 --> 02:23:27.765
AND SO I GUESS.
02:23:27.832 --> 02:23:29.300
HAVE YOU CONSIDERED THAT AND
02:23:29.367 --> 02:23:31.536
THEN TO THE OPPOSITION WITH THE
02:23:31.602 --> 02:23:33.671
E. U. MODEL B. DO YOU THINK
02:23:33.738 --> 02:23:34.939
THAT'S MORE FEASIBLE.
02:23:35.006 --> 02:23:38.409
SO SO HOT HAPPY -- TO WE DON'T
02:23:38.476 --> 02:23:39.243
HAVE HAD THAT INITIAL MEETINGS
02:23:39.310 --> 02:23:40.945
WITH THE OPPOSITION IN TERMS OF
02:23:41.012 --> 02:23:42.347
IMPLEMENTATION PERIOD WHAT WERE
02:23:42.413 --> 02:23:45.583
HAPPY AND OPEN -- TO BOTH
02:23:45.650 --> 02:23:46.884
DIFFERENT PERCENTAGES AS WELL
02:23:46.951 --> 02:23:47.919
DIFFERENT TIMELINE.
02:23:47.986 --> 02:23:50.822
WE LOOKED AT THE KEY YOU MODEL --
02:23:50.888 --> 02:23:53.291
WE THINK IT'S IT'S WORTH TAKING
02:23:53.358 --> 02:23:54.993
A LOOK AT BUT I DON'T KNOW THAT
02:23:55.059 --> 02:23:56.961
WE YOU KNOW WE ALWAYS LOOK AT
02:23:57.028 --> 02:23:58.162
OURSELVES A SORT OF LEADING NOT
02:23:58.229 --> 02:23:59.764
NECESSARILY FOLLOWING.
02:23:59.831 --> 02:24:01.666
SO THE FACT THAT THE E. U. --
02:24:01.733 --> 02:24:03.735
HAS SET A BENCHMARK I THINK IS
02:24:03.801 --> 02:24:04.736
GOOD BUT I DON'T KNOW THAT YOU
02:24:04.802 --> 02:24:06.437
DON'T NECESSARILY HAVE TO JUST
02:24:06.504 --> 02:24:07.739
ACCEPT.
02:24:07.805 --> 02:24:09.707
THE 30% BY TWENTY THIRD I MEAN
02:24:09.774 --> 02:24:12.310
TO THE 25% BY TWENTY TWENTY FIVE
02:24:12.377 --> 02:24:12.677
AS WELL ROUTE.
02:24:12.744 --> 02:24:14.178
THAT WE THOUGHT WE COULD BE MORE
02:24:14.245 --> 02:24:15.713
AGGRESSIVE IN THE HOPE IS THAT
02:24:15.780 --> 02:24:17.415
ONCE YOU GET INTO THIS.
02:24:17.482 --> 02:24:19.584
PRACTICE OF RECYCLING BIN I
02:24:19.650 --> 02:24:21.019
THINK IT COULD REALLY PICKS UP A
02:24:21.085 --> 02:24:21.719
LOT OF STEAM.
02:24:21.786 --> 02:24:24.322
I THINK THE OTHER PIECE -- JUST
02:24:24.389 --> 02:24:25.556
JUST TO GO FOR A COUPLE COUPLE
02:24:25.623 --> 02:24:26.524
DIFFERENT PIECES.
02:24:26.591 --> 02:24:27.325
IN TERMS OF NESTLE NESTE IS
02:24:27.392 --> 02:24:34.665
ALREADY COMMITTED TO I BELIEVE
02:24:34.732 --> 02:24:36.501
50% BUT BY.
02:24:36.567 --> 02:24:37.301
TWENTY TWENTY FIVE WE ALSO MR
02:24:37.368 --> 02:24:39.203
BIONDI I'LL BE ON A HAD THE HERE
02:24:39.270 --> 02:24:40.204
WILL LOOKS LIKE A SMALL MILK
02:24:40.271 --> 02:24:41.672
CARTON -- IN IN CERTAIN PLACES
02:24:41.739 --> 02:24:42.840
THAT IS COMPOSTABLE AT FAULT YOU
02:24:42.907 --> 02:24:43.741
CUT OUT THE PLASTIC PIECE OF IT
02:24:43.808 --> 02:24:44.008
SO AGAIN.
02:24:44.075 --> 02:24:45.076
THAT ACTUALLY IS COMPOSTABLE IS
02:24:45.143 --> 02:24:47.678
NOT NOT JUST NOT IT'S NOT JUST --
02:24:47.745 --> 02:24:49.747
RECYCLABLE IS COMPOSTABLE SO --
02:24:49.814 --> 02:24:52.050
IT ALSO WITH THE THE OGIC OF
02:24:52.116 --> 02:24:54.252
THE BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION IS SORT
02:24:54.318 --> 02:24:56.287
OF LIKE -- A VERY ODD TYPE OF
02:24:56.354 --> 02:24:57.822
MATH THAT WAS SORT OF BEING USED
02:24:57.889 --> 02:24:59.524
IN TERMS OF WELL BECAUSE YOU
02:24:59.590 --> 02:25:00.625
CAN'T.
02:25:00.691 --> 02:25:02.360
GET BACK EVERY SINGLE BOTTLE
02:25:02.427 --> 02:25:04.495
THEN YOU CAN ACTUALLY.
02:25:04.562 --> 02:25:06.297
RECEIVE GET A 100% WELL WHAT'S
02:25:06.364 --> 02:25:07.832
ACTUALLY HAPPENING IS IN DOUBT
02:25:07.899 --> 02:25:09.133
NOT ONLY ARE WE NOT GETTING BACK
02:25:09.200 --> 02:25:10.735
IN THE BOTTLE FOR ACTUALLY USING
02:25:10.802 --> 02:25:12.703
MORE AND MORE AND MORE PLASTIC
02:25:12.770 --> 02:25:14.072
BOTTLES OUT THERE.
02:25:14.138 --> 02:25:15.273
THAT THAT'S A BIGGER ISSUE THE
02:25:15.339 --> 02:25:16.474
BIGGER ISSUE IS IS.
02:25:16.541 --> 02:25:18.443
THE USE OF PLASTIC BOTTLES IS
02:25:18.509 --> 02:25:20.244
FRANKLY NOT SUSTAINABLE NOTHING
02:25:20.311 --> 02:25:22.113
BEFORE LANDFILLS NOT SUSTAINABLE
02:25:22.180 --> 02:25:23.981
FOR OUR OCEANS NOT SUSTAINABLE
02:25:24.048 --> 02:25:24.615
FOR OUR STATE I THINK.
02:25:24.682 --> 02:25:25.983
IT'S REALLY TRYING TO FIGURE OUT
02:25:26.050 --> 02:25:29.387
HOW DO WE GET THOSE -- GET THAT
02:25:29.454 --> 02:25:36.060
QATAR RECYCLED AND RE USE IN IT
02:25:36.127 --> 02:25:36.661
TO TRY TO BE PRETTY AGGRESSIVE
02:25:36.727 --> 02:25:39.230
ABOUT.
02:25:39.297 --> 02:25:40.231
IF I COULD JUST CLARIFY THE
02:25:40.298 --> 02:25:42.366
YIELD.
02:25:42.433 --> 02:25:45.203
PERSPECTIVES I'M SORRY.
02:25:45.269 --> 02:25:46.971
YEAH RIGHT WHEN WE MIND THAT WAS
02:25:47.038 --> 02:25:47.438
A PROJECT.
02:25:47.505 --> 02:25:48.372
WELL I I WAS JUST ASKING IF THE
02:25:48.439 --> 02:25:49.907
OPPONENTS.
02:25:49.974 --> 02:25:50.708
ARE OKAY WITH THE WHAT.
02:25:50.775 --> 02:25:53.511
IF THEY THINK THAT IS A MORE
02:25:53.578 --> 02:25:55.513
REASONABLE.
02:25:55.580 --> 02:26:02.820
BUT IT LOOKS LIKE THEY'VE LEFT.
02:26:02.887 --> 02:26:03.688
SO WE HAVE A GROCERY
02:26:03.754 --> 02:26:04.989
MANUFACTURERS WITH THE BRANDED
02:26:05.056 --> 02:26:06.090
FOOD COMPANIES -- WE THINK THE
02:26:06.157 --> 02:26:08.593
25% BY TWENTY TWENTY FIVE IS IS
02:26:08.659 --> 02:26:10.761
A LIVE IS A YEAH A GOOD WRAP UP
02:26:10.828 --> 02:26:11.362
WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE CONTRACT
02:26:11.429 --> 02:26:12.029
WOULD LOOK AT THE PHASE WHEN YOU
02:26:12.096 --> 02:26:13.164
LOOK AT THE AMOUNT OF MATERIAL.
02:26:13.231 --> 02:26:14.532
AND I IN THAT 30% BY TWENTY BY
02:26:14.599 --> 02:26:17.235
TWENTY THIRTY IS IS ABSOLUTELY
02:26:17.301 --> 02:26:19.370
MAYBE WE COULD EVEN DO BETTER.
02:26:19.437 --> 02:26:20.171
THANK YOU MAY HAVE PERMISSION
02:26:20.238 --> 02:26:21.439
JUST TO GO INTO THAT TOO WE WILL
02:26:21.506 --> 02:26:23.307
BE A BUSINESS BY THEN.
02:26:23.374 --> 02:26:26.077
LITERALLY WE'VE ALREADY LOST.
02:26:26.144 --> 02:26:28.312
ONE I'M SORRY I'M SORRY I JUST
02:26:28.379 --> 02:26:31.215
WALKED IN I WHAT WHAT DOES YOUR
02:26:31.282 --> 02:26:32.583
INTO YOU AND THREE TO TWO OF THE
02:26:32.650 --> 02:26:33.284
ASSEMBLY WOMAN.
02:26:33.351 --> 02:26:34.852
ON THE QUESTION OF WAITING I WAS
02:26:34.919 --> 02:26:37.855
ALSO ANYBODY YOU AND THE AND THE
02:26:37.922 --> 02:26:40.324
OPPONENTS -- TO TO TO THAT
02:26:40.391 --> 02:26:41.993
QUESTION ASSEMBLY MEMBER EGGMAN --
02:26:42.059 --> 02:26:42.927
YOU KNOW NIAGARA LIKE AS I WAS
02:26:42.994 --> 02:26:44.295
SAYING IS THE LARGEST PRODUCED --
02:26:44.362 --> 02:26:46.330
BUYER OF OUR PAY IN THE STATE IT
02:26:46.397 --> 02:26:47.999
WAS REFLECTED IN LAST WEEK'S CAR
02:26:48.065 --> 02:26:50.067
CYCLE REPORT -- WE YOU KNOW
02:26:50.134 --> 02:26:51.602
WE'RE CLOSE 240% WE USE THE
02:26:51.669 --> 02:26:54.505
STUFF WE LIKE IT WE ENCOURAGE IT.
02:26:54.572 --> 02:26:57.108
WE DON'T EMBRACE THE U. MODEL
02:26:57.175 --> 02:26:57.975
WITH THE GUYS WERE STUDYING.
02:26:58.042 --> 02:26:59.076
I MEAN THERE'S THERE'S THERE'S A
02:26:59.143 --> 02:27:00.311
LOT OF ELEMENTS TO THAT PROPOSAL
02:27:00.378 --> 02:27:02.847
THAT'S WORTHY OF FURTHER REVIEW --
02:27:02.914 --> 02:27:04.682
WE LOOK FORWARD TO WORKING WITH
02:27:04.749 --> 02:27:05.750
RECLAIMER IS WITH THE
02:27:05.816 --> 02:27:06.784
ENVIRONMENTAL COMMUNITY WITH
02:27:06.851 --> 02:27:08.252
MEMBERS OF THIS COMMITTEE.
02:27:08.319 --> 02:27:09.654
AND OTHER STAKEHOLDERS AMOUNTS
02:27:09.720 --> 02:27:11.189
IN THE BEVERAGE COMMUNITY TO
02:27:11.255 --> 02:27:12.290
WORK ON SOMETHING THAT'S
02:27:12.356 --> 02:27:14.792
ACHIEVABLE AND REALISTIC THIS
02:27:14.859 --> 02:27:15.426
BILL.
02:27:15.493 --> 02:27:17.094
REGRETTABLY I I YOU KNOW ARTS
02:27:17.161 --> 02:27:18.496
ARE OPINION IT'S IT'S NOT THAT
02:27:18.563 --> 02:27:20.198
BUT IT CAN BE AND WE HOPE TO GET
02:27:20.264 --> 02:27:22.833
THERE SO WITH YOUR SUPPORT AND
02:27:22.900 --> 02:27:24.035
GUIDANCE.
02:27:24.101 --> 02:27:25.269
WE THINK WE CAN WE CAN GET THERE
02:27:25.336 --> 02:27:26.270
SO SOUNDS LIKE EVERYBODY'S
02:27:26.337 --> 02:27:28.439
WORKING LOOKING IS EVERYONE IS
02:27:28.506 --> 02:27:30.074
EAGER TO TERRY HARD I'M KIND OF
02:27:30.141 --> 02:27:34.779
AGREEMENT -- AND I WOULD.
02:27:34.845 --> 02:27:36.180
AND I WOULD JUST SAY TO TO MR
02:27:36.247 --> 02:27:36.514
TANG.
02:27:36.581 --> 02:27:38.783
WITH THE THE THE LITTLE CARTON
02:27:38.849 --> 02:27:41.652
I'M UP I AM A SERIOUS RECYCLE
02:27:41.719 --> 02:27:43.654
SEC RECYCLER CYCLER -- PERSON
02:27:43.721 --> 02:27:44.288
WHO RECYCLES.
02:27:44.355 --> 02:27:45.790
BUT I WILL SAY THAT THAT IS VERY
02:27:45.856 --> 02:27:46.424
DIFFICULT TO DO AND OUR AVERAGE
02:27:46.490 --> 02:27:47.992
PERSON WHO RECYCLES IS NOT GOING
02:27:48.059 --> 02:27:50.328
TO TAKE A PART THAT THAT CARTON
02:27:50.394 --> 02:27:52.096
I MEAN I I DO IT SOMETIMES AND I
02:27:52.163 --> 02:27:53.664
HAVE TO ADMIT SOMETIMES I DON'T
02:27:53.731 --> 02:27:54.799
ALWAYS PULL IT ALL APART AND
02:27:54.865 --> 02:27:55.233
THEN.
02:27:55.299 --> 02:27:57.568
AND THEN WE HAVE THE PROBLEM
02:27:57.635 --> 02:27:59.136
THAT LED TO THE NATIONAL SORT.
02:27:59.203 --> 02:28:01.172
TO BRING THIS FORWARD AND IT'S A
02:28:01.239 --> 02:28:01.806
COMPLICATED ISSUE THAT WE'RE ARE
02:28:01.872 --> 02:28:04.208
GRAPPLING WITH.
02:28:04.275 --> 02:28:06.477
MS EGGMAN I'M SORRY MISS GARCIA
02:28:06.544 --> 02:28:06.777
[inaudible]
02:28:06.844 --> 02:28:10.548
OKAY -- WE SAW -- ASSEMBLY
02:28:10.615 --> 02:28:12.817
MEMBER GONZALEZ HERE RECENTLY
02:28:12.884 --> 02:28:15.519
PRESENTING HER BILL DEALING WITH
02:28:15.586 --> 02:28:17.388
WITH PLASTICS AND I I TOLD HER
02:28:17.455 --> 02:28:18.823
AND HER SPONSORS THAT IF THIS IS
02:28:18.889 --> 02:28:19.457
THE APPROACH WE'RE GOING TO BE
02:28:19.523 --> 02:28:21.025
DEALING WITH PLASTIC THAT WE
02:28:21.092 --> 02:28:24.929
NEEDED TO HAVE -- A BILL SIMILAR
02:28:24.996 --> 02:28:26.964
TO WHAT YOU'RE DOING I WILL SAY
02:28:27.031 --> 02:28:29.800
THOUGH I HAVE CONCERNS WITH THE
02:28:29.867 --> 02:28:32.136
WHETHER OR NOT THE TARGET OF A
02:28:32.203 --> 02:28:33.671
100% IS FEASIBLE.
02:28:33.738 --> 02:28:35.473
IN IN THIS BILL.
02:28:35.539 --> 02:28:37.074
AND SO I WOULD URGE YOU TO
02:28:37.141 --> 02:28:39.110
CONTINUE TO WORK WITH THE
02:28:39.176 --> 02:28:40.144
STAKEHOLDERS.
02:28:40.211 --> 02:28:41.612
BEFORE THIS COMES TO THE FLOOR
02:28:41.679 --> 02:28:43.180
TO COME UP WITH SOMETHING THAT'S
02:28:43.247 --> 02:28:45.416
THAT'S FEASIBLE.
02:28:45.483 --> 02:28:47.818
IN GENERAL PRACTICALITY SPEAKING
02:28:47.885 --> 02:28:49.220
ONCE WE START TO GET PAST THE
02:28:49.287 --> 02:28:51.122
THIRD NUMBER FINISHINGS BECOME
02:28:51.188 --> 02:28:54.158
EITHER TOO EXPENSIVE -- AND AND
02:28:54.225 --> 02:28:55.626
I THINK YOU CAN GET A PRETTY
02:28:55.693 --> 02:28:56.594
HIGH NUMBER.
02:28:56.661 --> 02:28:57.662
WE'VE BEEN TALKING ABOUT THE E.
02:28:57.728 --> 02:28:59.797
U. MODEL AND I DON'T KNOW THAT
02:28:59.864 --> 02:29:00.564
30% IS HIGH ENOUGH IN ALL
02:29:00.631 --> 02:29:01.032
HONESTY.
02:29:01.098 --> 02:29:03.034
ON AND SO YOU KNOW BUT I DO
02:29:03.100 --> 02:29:05.636
QUESTION WHETHER 1100% IS USABLE
02:29:05.703 --> 02:29:06.771
FOR ALL THESE PRODUCTS AND WE
02:29:06.837 --> 02:29:08.072
HAVE PRODUCTS OUT THERE THAT ARE
02:29:08.139 --> 02:29:11.309
AN EXAMPLE ARE READY 290%.
02:29:11.375 --> 02:29:12.076
BUT I DO THINK WE NEED TO BE
02:29:12.143 --> 02:29:13.477
THINKING ABOUT.
02:29:13.544 --> 02:29:15.179
ABOUT IT -- AND I DON'T KNOW IF
02:29:15.246 --> 02:29:16.447
IT'S TIED TO OUR RECYCLE
02:29:16.514 --> 02:29:18.049
CONTINENT WHERE WAS TO PRODUCE
02:29:18.115 --> 02:29:19.550
OR SOMETHING ELSE AND HOW YOU
02:29:19.617 --> 02:29:21.352
GET TO THAT NUMBER I I APOLOGIZE
02:29:21.419 --> 02:29:21.886
THAT I'M NOT GIVING YOU A
02:29:21.952 --> 02:29:23.387
SOLUTION.
02:29:23.454 --> 02:29:24.622
THAT THE CONCERN THAT I HAVE
02:29:24.689 --> 02:29:25.856
MOVING FORWARD BUT FOR TODAY I
02:29:25.923 --> 02:29:26.791
AM.
02:29:26.857 --> 02:29:28.426
READY TO SUPPORT THE BILL TO
02:29:28.492 --> 02:29:29.560
KEEP THE DISCUSSION GOING AND
02:29:29.627 --> 02:29:31.762
NEVER GOING TO BE HAVING AB TEN
02:29:31.829 --> 02:29:32.430
EIGHTY AND ITS COMPANION BILL IN
02:29:32.496 --> 02:29:33.364
THE SENATE.
02:29:33.431 --> 02:29:37.368
WE NEED TO HAVE -- SOME SORT OF
02:29:37.435 --> 02:29:38.803
CONTENT BILL SPELL THANK YOU.
02:29:38.869 --> 02:29:39.704
SO HAPPY TO WE'VE WE'VE HAD SOME
02:29:39.770 --> 02:29:40.304
INITIAL DISCUSSIONS WITH THE
02:29:40.371 --> 02:29:42.006
BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION AND THEY
02:29:42.073 --> 02:29:44.141
DID -- POINT OUT CERTAIN TYPES
02:29:44.208 --> 02:29:46.877
OF BOTTLES THAT PERHAPS COULD
02:29:46.944 --> 02:29:47.978
COULD EVENTUALLY GET THERE IS
02:29:48.045 --> 02:29:49.347
SOMEONE THAT WOULD ACTUALLY
02:29:49.413 --> 02:29:50.281
NEVER GET THERE SO I THINK.
02:29:50.348 --> 02:29:51.916
THE OPEN TO DIFFERENT IN THAT
02:29:51.982 --> 02:29:53.551
DISCUSSION -- THE THE THE GERMAN
02:29:53.617 --> 02:29:55.519
FROM NIAGARA HAS NOT COME INTO
02:29:55.586 --> 02:29:56.721
THE OFFICE OF WHERE THE HAPPY TO
02:29:56.787 --> 02:29:58.155
BE INTERESTED IN HEARING WHAT
02:29:58.222 --> 02:29:59.824
HAS PROPOSAL WOULD BE. TO TO SEE
02:29:59.890 --> 02:30:00.658
HOW IT MATCHES WITH OURS BUT
02:30:00.725 --> 02:30:04.662
WHAT WE'RE MORE THAN HAPPY TO
02:30:04.729 --> 02:30:05.696
CONTINUE THESE DISCUSSIONS.
02:30:05.763 --> 02:30:06.997
THANK YOU MISTER STONE
02:30:07.064 --> 02:30:07.298
[inaudible]
02:30:07.365 --> 02:30:08.432
THANK YOU.
02:30:08.499 --> 02:30:10.368
THIS IS TECH.
02:30:10.434 --> 02:30:11.502
THE BIGGEST SERVICE I THINK I
02:30:11.569 --> 02:30:13.904
COULD HAVE DONE YOU THIS YEAR'S
02:30:13.971 --> 02:30:14.739
RUN THE LEAST THE LID BOTTLE
02:30:14.805 --> 02:30:15.039
[inaudible]
02:30:15.106 --> 02:30:17.742
AGAIN BECAUSE AS WE TRIED TO DO
02:30:17.808 --> 02:30:18.943
THAT AND HAD LOTS AND LOTS OF
02:30:19.009 --> 02:30:20.511
CONVERSATIONS WITH THE MAJOR
02:30:20.578 --> 02:30:22.113
FILERS THEY SAID DON'T DO THIS
02:30:22.179 --> 02:30:23.681
TO US DON'T DO THIS TO US.
02:30:23.748 --> 02:30:25.516
WE'LL SHOW YOU HOW GREAT WE ARE
02:30:25.583 --> 02:30:28.252
DOING -- AND RECYCLE CONTENT IN
02:30:28.319 --> 02:30:29.687
OUR BOTTLES AND SO THEY LAID OUT
02:30:29.754 --> 02:30:31.856
THESE GREAT NUMBERS AND I THINK
02:30:31.922 --> 02:30:33.758
YOUR YOUR PATH IS REALLY WHAT
02:30:33.824 --> 02:30:34.859
THEY WERE TRYING.
02:30:34.925 --> 02:30:37.962
TO USE TO CONVINCE US TO NOT DO
02:30:38.028 --> 02:30:39.296
THE LEAST THE LEAD SO IT'S IT'S
02:30:39.363 --> 02:30:41.132
INTERESTING THIS YEAR NOW ALL
02:30:41.198 --> 02:30:43.200
SAID THIS IS THE BIG BUGABOO AND
02:30:43.267 --> 02:30:44.468
WE CAN'T GET THERE.
02:30:44.535 --> 02:30:46.570
THAT'S THE REFRAIN WE CONSTANTLY
02:30:46.637 --> 02:30:47.738
HEAR OH CAN'T DO THIS INVISIBLE
02:30:47.805 --> 02:30:49.874
INVISIBLE VISIBLE AND THEN TURNS
02:30:49.940 --> 02:30:51.342
OUT THINGS ARE VISIBLE.
02:30:51.409 --> 02:30:54.278
SO I I WISH YOU LUCK DO YOU HAVE
02:30:54.345 --> 02:30:55.379
A MOTION ON THIS YET.
02:30:55.446 --> 02:30:57.114
HAVE YOU SOCIAL QUORUM.
02:30:57.181 --> 02:30:58.816
WE DO HAVE A QUORUM THAT ARTICLE
02:30:58.883 --> 02:31:00.284
MOTION ON THIS BILL.
02:31:00.351 --> 02:31:01.786
OKAY WITH EMOTION THE SECOND ANY
02:31:01.852 --> 02:31:02.286
OTHER COMMENTS FROM THE
02:31:02.353 --> 02:31:04.021
COMMITTEE.
02:31:04.088 --> 02:31:04.989
AND I'LL BE SUPPORTING YOUR BILL
02:31:05.055 --> 02:31:06.157
TODAY AND I DO A REALLY
02:31:06.223 --> 02:31:07.558
APPRECIATE YOU BRING IT FOR THIS
02:31:07.625 --> 02:31:09.226
IS ONE OF THE BIGGEST CRISIS IS
02:31:09.293 --> 02:31:10.761
WE HAVE IN THE STATE RIGHT NOW
02:31:10.828 --> 02:31:11.362
IN FRONT OF THIS COMMITTEE SO
02:31:11.429 --> 02:31:12.229
THANK YOU.
02:31:12.296 --> 02:31:13.831
I DO YOU HAVE ANY YOU WANT TO
02:31:13.898 --> 02:31:15.699
CLOSE TO DO JUST VERY QUICKLY
02:31:15.766 --> 02:31:16.834
CLOSING WITH THE YOU KNOW YOU'RE
02:31:16.901 --> 02:31:17.868
YOU'RE YOU'RE GONE MADAM CHAIR
02:31:17.935 --> 02:31:19.603
BUT REALLY APPRECIATE YOUR WORK
02:31:19.670 --> 02:31:20.237
THE CONSULTANTS WORKING WORKING
02:31:20.304 --> 02:31:22.673
WITH AS I HEAR AT THE FEEDBACK
02:31:22.740 --> 02:31:24.241
FROM MY COLLEAGUES I VERY MUCH
02:31:24.308 --> 02:31:25.943
APPRECIATE IT WE KNOW.
02:31:26.010 --> 02:31:27.144
THIS ISSUE IS A CHALLENGING
02:31:27.211 --> 02:31:29.046
ISSUE WE WERE WERE UP TO I KNOW
02:31:29.113 --> 02:31:30.948
THAT THE STATE DOES BODIES UP TO
02:31:31.015 --> 02:31:31.315
THE CHALLENGE.
02:31:31.382 --> 02:31:34.185
AND WE'RE GOING TO KEEP WORKING
02:31:34.251 --> 02:31:35.319
TO MAKE SURE THAT WE ARE GOING
02:31:35.386 --> 02:31:40.458
TO GET -- A MINIMUM CONTENT
02:31:40.524 --> 02:31:42.259
BUILT ON THE SHORES THANK YOU.
02:31:42.326 --> 02:31:43.227
THANK YOU WITHOUT WE HAVE A ROLL
02:31:43.294 --> 02:31:44.628
CALL A SECOND WE HAVE A VOTE A
02:31:44.695 --> 02:31:45.362
ROLL CALL VOTE PLEASE.
02:31:45.429 --> 02:31:46.897
ITEM TEN A. B. SEVEN NINETY TWO
02:31:46.964 --> 02:31:47.465
BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER TEAM THE
02:31:47.531 --> 02:31:48.566
MOTION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED TO
02:31:48.632 --> 02:31:49.066
REFER TO APPROPRIATIONS
02:31:49.133 --> 02:31:49.767
COMMITTEE.
02:31:49.834 --> 02:31:52.536
MEMBERS FRIEDMAN HI FRIEDMAN I
02:31:52.603 --> 02:31:52.736
FLORA.
02:31:52.803 --> 02:31:53.737
CHAU [inaudible]
02:31:53.804 --> 02:31:55.506
EGGMAN.
02:31:55.573 --> 02:31:57.975
EGGMAN AYE GARCIA AYE GARCIA AYE
02:31:58.042 --> 02:31:59.443
LIMóN.
02:31:59.510 --> 02:32:00.544
MATHIS.
02:32:00.611 --> 02:32:03.013
MATHIS NO MCCARTY [inaudible]
02:32:03.080 --> 02:32:04.415
MELENDEZ.
02:32:04.482 --> 02:32:07.952
MELENDEZ NOT VOTING.
02:32:08.018 --> 02:32:08.853
RIGHT TO TREAT STONE
02:32:08.919 --> 02:32:09.153
[inaudible]
02:32:09.220 --> 02:32:12.923
SO [inaudible] NINE FOR ONE THE
02:32:12.990 --> 02:32:13.491
VOTERS FORTY ONE BELIEVE THE
02:32:13.557 --> 02:32:14.959
REAL OPEN FOR ABSENT MEMBERS
02:32:15.025 --> 02:32:17.695
THANK YOU VERY MUCH [inaudible]
02:32:17.761 --> 02:32:18.796
MISTER KALRA [inaudible]
02:32:18.863 --> 02:32:20.598
YOUR NEXT.
02:32:20.664 --> 02:32:23.467
WITH ELEVEN SIXTY TWO YOU MAY
02:32:23.534 --> 02:32:39.950
PROCEED WHEN YOU ARE READY
02:32:55.466 --> 02:32:55.533
.
02:32:55.533 --> 02:32:56.000
THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR AND
02:32:56.066 --> 02:32:57.835
MEMBERS.
02:32:57.902 --> 02:32:59.436
THE SENATE BILL ELEVEN SIXTY TWO
02:32:59.503 --> 02:33:00.070
WILL TAKE ME FOR ACTION TO CURB
02:33:00.137 --> 02:33:02.907
SINGLE HOUSE ON THE BILL'S
02:33:02.973 --> 02:33:04.542
DELAYED IMPLEMENTATION DATE AND
02:33:04.608 --> 02:33:06.210
COUNTY AMOUNTS.
02:33:06.277 --> 02:33:07.711
PROVISIONAL PLASTIC WASTE AS WE
02:33:07.778 --> 02:33:09.647
WERE JUST DISCUSSING AND AND
02:33:09.713 --> 02:33:11.549
THIS COMMITTEE IS AS COST REALLY
02:33:11.615 --> 02:33:13.450
OVER MANY YEARS -- IS HAVING
02:33:13.517 --> 02:33:14.585
DEVASTATING IMPACT OUR
02:33:14.652 --> 02:33:16.186
ENVIRONMENT AND AS IN DALLAS IS
02:33:16.253 --> 02:33:17.855
RIGHTLY POINTS OUT ITS POLICING
02:33:17.922 --> 02:33:18.455
OUR OCEANS.
02:33:18.522 --> 02:33:21.825
SINGLE USE PLASTIC IS ALSO
02:33:21.892 --> 02:33:22.993
ADDING TO OUR LANDFILLS.
02:33:23.060 --> 02:33:24.094
THOSE TINY PLASTIC SHAMPOO
02:33:24.161 --> 02:33:24.728
SHAMPOO BOTTLES OTHER PERSONAL
02:33:24.795 --> 02:33:26.163
CARE PRODUCTS REPRESENT A
02:33:26.230 --> 02:33:27.665
SIZEABLE AMOUNT OF WASTE I CAN
02:33:27.731 --> 02:33:29.433
EASILY BE ELIMINATED. TWO MORE
02:33:29.500 --> 02:33:30.434
COST EFFECTIVE AND
02:33:30.501 --> 02:33:31.802
ENVIRONMENTALLY FRIENDLY
02:33:31.869 --> 02:33:33.437
ALTERNATIVES.
02:33:33.504 --> 02:33:34.371
THINK ABOUT IT WHEN YOU STAY IN
02:33:34.438 --> 02:33:36.173
A HOTEL EVERY DAY WORKERS MUST
02:33:36.240 --> 02:33:37.775
RESTOCK POSSIBLE THE NEW ONES
02:33:37.841 --> 02:33:39.076
OFTENTIMES REGARDLESS OF FULL
02:33:39.143 --> 02:33:41.812
USED BY THE GAS OR JUST USING A
02:33:41.879 --> 02:33:43.047
SMALL FRACTION OF IT.
02:33:43.113 --> 02:33:44.582
WITH OVER NINETY FIVE HUNDRED
02:33:44.648 --> 02:33:45.849
TRAVEL ACCOMMODATION EMPLOYERS
02:33:45.916 --> 02:33:47.451
IN THE STATE AND HUNDREDS OF
02:33:47.518 --> 02:33:48.519
THOUSANDS OF HOTEL ROOMS A
02:33:48.586 --> 02:33:50.454
PLASTIC WASTE STREAM QUICKLY
02:33:50.521 --> 02:33:50.988
ADDS UP.
02:33:51.055 --> 02:33:52.957
BACK ORDER THE AMERICAN HOTEL
02:33:53.023 --> 02:33:54.992
LODGING ASSOCIATION AS PACOLLI A
02:33:55.059 --> 02:33:56.160
APPROXIMATELY HALF A MILLION
02:33:56.226 --> 02:33:57.661
HOTEL ROOMS IN CALIFORNIA AND
02:33:57.728 --> 02:33:58.529
THOSE ARE JUST THOSE THEIR
02:33:58.596 --> 02:33:59.563
ACCOUNT ABOUT THAT PARTICULAR
02:33:59.630 --> 02:34:00.931
ASSOCIATION.
02:34:00.998 --> 02:34:03.200
SO LIKELY MANY MORE.
02:34:03.267 --> 02:34:05.936
BOB IF YOU OF COUNT FOR A
02:34:06.003 --> 02:34:06.770
THOUSAND BOTTLES PER ROOM PER
02:34:06.837 --> 02:34:07.905
YEAR SUGGEST BY THE WALL STREET
02:34:07.972 --> 02:34:08.872
JOURNAL.
02:34:08.939 --> 02:34:10.107
THAT AMOUNTS TO APPROXIMATELY
02:34:10.174 --> 02:34:12.710
HALF A BILLION PLASTIC BOTTLES
02:34:12.776 --> 02:34:14.511
IN CALIFORNIA ALONE EVERY YEAR
02:34:14.578 --> 02:34:16.246
AND AGAIN THAT'S A CONSERVATIVE
02:34:16.313 --> 02:34:17.047
ESTIMATE.
02:34:17.114 --> 02:34:18.749
BASED UPON THE NUMBER OF ROOMS --
02:34:18.816 --> 02:34:20.084
THAT WE HAVE.
02:34:20.150 --> 02:34:21.652
AB ELEVEN SIXTY TWO PROHIBITS A
02:34:21.719 --> 02:34:23.020
LODGING ESTABLISHMENT PROVIDING
02:34:23.087 --> 02:34:24.788
SMALL PLASTIC BOTTLES CONTAINING
02:34:24.855 --> 02:34:27.024
A PERSONAL CARE PRODUCTS. TO A
02:34:27.091 --> 02:34:27.458
GAS AND THE SLEEPING
02:34:27.524 --> 02:34:28.192
ACCOMMODATION.
02:34:28.258 --> 02:34:30.227
FORTUNATELY MANY BUSINESSES AND
02:34:30.294 --> 02:34:31.996
BRANDS IN THE HOTEL INDUSTRY ARE
02:34:32.062 --> 02:34:34.198
ALREADY FACING OUT THE SMALL
02:34:34.264 --> 02:34:36.000
PLASTIC BOTTLES AND PAPER PAPER --
02:34:36.066 --> 02:34:38.836
FOR REFILLABLE DISPENSERS OR IN
02:34:38.902 --> 02:34:45.009
THE CASE OF SOAPS USING A PAPER.
02:34:45.075 --> 02:34:45.843
OF A BY NOT OFFERING SMALL
02:34:45.909 --> 02:34:46.510
PLASTIC BOTTLES OF PERSONAL CARE
02:34:46.577 --> 02:34:48.312
PRODUCTS HOTELS MOTELS AND OTHER
02:34:48.379 --> 02:34:49.279
LODGING ESTABLISHMENTS.
02:34:49.346 --> 02:34:50.080
WE SB CAN REDUCE SINGLE USE
02:34:50.147 --> 02:34:50.814
PLASTIC CONSUMPTION AND
02:34:50.881 --> 02:34:52.783
INCREASED CONSUMER AWARENESS OF
02:34:52.850 --> 02:34:54.985
OUR USE OF PLASTIC IN FACT A LOT
02:34:55.052 --> 02:34:56.520
OF WHAT THE HOTEL INDUSTRY IS
02:34:56.587 --> 02:34:57.921
DOING IS BEING DRIVEN BY
02:34:57.988 --> 02:35:00.257
CONSUMER CHOICE AND PREFERENCE
02:35:00.324 --> 02:35:01.291
AS WELL.
02:35:01.358 --> 02:35:02.026
I'VE BEEN A PRODUCTIVE
02:35:02.092 --> 02:35:02.693
CONVERSATIONS WITH THE
02:35:02.760 --> 02:35:03.927
CALIFORNIA HOTEL AND LODGING
02:35:03.994 --> 02:35:05.329
ASSOCIATION AS WELL AS
02:35:05.396 --> 02:35:07.264
ASSOCIATION AMERICAN ASIAN
02:35:07.331 --> 02:35:07.731
AMERICAN HOTEL OWNERS
02:35:07.798 --> 02:35:10.868
ASSOCIATION -- AND YOU KNOW WE
02:35:10.934 --> 02:35:12.336
ACTUALLY HAD MET WITH THEM
02:35:12.403 --> 02:35:13.771
BEFORE THIS BILL WAS EVEN
02:35:13.837 --> 02:35:15.806
INTRODUCED AS A SIGN OF GOOD
02:35:15.873 --> 02:35:17.141
FAITH THAT WE REALLY WANT TO
02:35:17.207 --> 02:35:20.077
WORK WITH THE WITH THE INDUSTRY.
02:35:20.144 --> 02:35:20.678
AND MAKING SURE THIS IS DONE
02:35:20.744 --> 02:35:23.080
AWAY DONE IN A WAY THAT'S
02:35:23.147 --> 02:35:24.815
RESPECTFUL OF ALL STAKEHOLDERS --
02:35:24.882 --> 02:35:26.717
AND JUST RECENTLY -- THE IT
02:35:26.784 --> 02:35:28.552
INDUSTRY TOOK A SUPPORT OF A MAN
02:35:28.619 --> 02:35:29.787
A POSITION ON A. B. ELEVEN SIXTY
02:35:29.853 --> 02:35:30.854
TWO AND I'M VERY GRATEFUL FOR
02:35:30.921 --> 02:35:31.321
THAT.
02:35:31.388 --> 02:35:32.356
MY HOPE.
02:35:32.423 --> 02:35:34.458
AND INTENTION IS TO KEEP WORKING
02:35:34.525 --> 02:35:35.926
WITH INDUSTRY AND COME TO AN
02:35:35.993 --> 02:35:37.061
AGREEMENT ON THE BILL'S TIME
02:35:37.127 --> 02:35:38.662
FRAME AND SCOPE OF ALREADY
02:35:38.729 --> 02:35:41.598
RECOGNIZE THE NEED. TO DELAY --
02:35:41.665 --> 02:35:43.333
THE BILL BUT BEFORE A THREE YEAR
02:35:43.400 --> 02:35:45.169
TIME LINE TO GET BUSINESSES TIME.
02:35:45.235 --> 02:35:46.437
TO DEPLETE THE CURRENT STOCK IS
02:35:46.503 --> 02:35:48.038
DAHLE DISPENSERS AND ENSURE THEY
02:35:48.105 --> 02:35:53.444
HAVE DISTRIBUTION OF SUPPLY.
02:35:53.510 --> 02:35:54.545
SO MANY VIABLE ALTERNATIVES TO
02:35:54.611 --> 02:35:55.179
PROVIDING SMALL PLASTIC BOTTLES
02:35:55.245 --> 02:35:56.747
OF PERSONAL CARE PRODUCTS LIKE
02:35:56.814 --> 02:35:57.915
SHAMPOO THE LOGIC IN IT
02:35:57.981 --> 02:35:58.949
INDUSTRIES IN A PRIME POSITION
02:35:59.016 --> 02:35:59.516
TO PHASE OUT THE PRACTICE.
02:35:59.583 --> 02:36:01.452
AND CONTINUE THEIR COMMITMENT AS
02:36:01.518 --> 02:36:02.820
AN INDUSTRY THAT'S VERY FOUR
02:36:02.886 --> 02:36:04.455
FOUR THINK ON THESE ISSUES -- TO
02:36:04.521 --> 02:36:05.622
ENVIRONMENTAL STEWARDSHIP OF
02:36:05.689 --> 02:36:07.758
REDUCING PLASTIC WASTE WASTE.
02:36:07.825 --> 02:36:08.959
WOULD BE TO PROVIDE SUPPORTING
02:36:09.026 --> 02:36:10.527
TESTIMONY IS KATHERINE -- DAY
02:36:10.594 --> 02:36:14.331
EXACTED DIRECTORS SAVE UP FOR
02:36:14.398 --> 02:36:17.301
SAVE OUR SHORES.
02:36:17.367 --> 02:36:18.402
GOOD AFTERNOON COMMITTEE MEMBERS --
02:36:18.469 --> 02:36:19.436
AS JUST SAID MY NAME IS
02:36:19.503 --> 02:36:20.370
KATHERINE -- DAY AND AS THE
02:36:20.437 --> 02:36:21.839
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR.
02:36:21.905 --> 02:36:23.774
OF THE SAVE OUR SHORES AND ARE
02:36:23.841 --> 02:36:26.810
TENS OF THOUSANDS OF CALIFORNIAN
02:36:26.877 --> 02:36:29.413
CONSTITUENTS -- WE ARE HERE TO
02:36:29.480 --> 02:36:32.349
SUPPORT AB ELEVEN SIXTY TWO SAVE
02:36:32.416 --> 02:36:33.917
OUR SHORES AS A NONPROFIT BASED
02:36:33.984 --> 02:36:35.452
IN SANTA CRUZ CALIFORNIA WHOSE
02:36:35.519 --> 02:36:36.754
MISSION IS TO STEWART CLEAN
02:36:36.820 --> 02:36:38.689
SHORES HEALTHY HABITATS AND
02:36:38.756 --> 02:36:39.823
LIVING WATERS.
02:36:39.890 --> 02:36:41.358
WHICH FOSTER THRIVING MARINE
02:36:41.425 --> 02:36:43.894
SYSTEMS ALONG THE CENTRAL COAST.
02:36:43.961 --> 02:36:45.596
PLASTIC POLLUTION AS EVIDENCED
02:36:45.662 --> 02:36:47.397
BY THE EXPLOSION OF MAINSTREAM
02:36:47.464 --> 02:36:49.533
NEWS COVERAGE HAS REACHED A
02:36:49.600 --> 02:36:50.501
CRISIS STAGE.
02:36:50.567 --> 02:36:52.770
SERIOUS ACTION IS REQUIRED TO
02:36:52.836 --> 02:36:54.371
STEM THE TALKS A VACATION NUMBER
02:36:54.438 --> 02:36:56.373
OCEAN THE DEATH OF SEA LIFE AND
02:36:56.440 --> 02:36:58.342
SEE BIRDS IN THE VERY HEALTH AND
02:36:58.408 --> 02:36:59.777
WELL BEING OF HUMANS.
02:36:59.843 --> 02:37:01.044
TRACES THE PLASTICS ARE NOW
02:37:01.111 --> 02:37:03.247
FOUND IN FOODS AND BEVERAGES WE
02:37:03.313 --> 02:37:05.649
CONSUME INCLUDING FISH SEA SALT
02:37:05.716 --> 02:37:08.719
HONEY TAP WATER AND WATER.
02:37:08.786 --> 02:37:10.521
PLASTICS AND THEIR TOXIC AND
02:37:10.587 --> 02:37:12.289
CARCINOGENIC ADDITIVES HAVE ALSO
02:37:12.356 --> 02:37:15.926
BEEN FOUND IN HUMAN BLOOD IN
02:37:15.993 --> 02:37:16.794
STOOL.
02:37:16.860 --> 02:37:18.228
MANY HOTEL CHAINS INCLUDING MARY
02:37:18.295 --> 02:37:19.096
ON HILTON HAVE ALREADY BEGUN
02:37:19.163 --> 02:37:20.197
SWITCHING TO WALL MOUNTED
02:37:20.264 --> 02:37:22.633
DISPENSER STIRRED REDUCE WASTE.
02:37:22.699 --> 02:37:25.068
PER STUDY RELEASED BY MARRIOTT
02:37:25.135 --> 02:37:27.004
AN AVERAGE SIZE HOTEL WHICH THEY
02:37:27.070 --> 02:37:28.806
DEFINE AS ONE HUNDRED AND FORTY
02:37:28.872 --> 02:37:30.073
ROOM PROPERTY.
02:37:30.140 --> 02:37:32.376
CAN ELIMINATE TWENTY SEVEN
02:37:32.442 --> 02:37:33.544
THOUSAND BOTTLES PER YEAR
02:37:33.610 --> 02:37:35.979
YIELDING TWO THOUSAND IN ANNUAL
02:37:36.046 --> 02:37:38.649
SAVINGS WHILE ALSO YOU ALSO.
02:37:38.715 --> 02:37:40.784
KEEPING ROUGHLY TWO HUNDRED AND
02:37:40.851 --> 02:37:42.219
FIFTY THREE POUNDS OF PLASTIC
02:37:42.286 --> 02:37:43.620
CONSUMING EACH BOTTLE WEIGHS
02:37:43.687 --> 02:37:45.889
ONLY ONE POINT FIVE OUNCES OUT
02:37:45.956 --> 02:37:47.457
OF THE LANDFILL EVERY YEAR.
02:37:47.524 --> 02:37:50.060
THAT'S WHAT WE CALL A WIN WIN
02:37:50.127 --> 02:37:51.328
SCENARIO.
02:37:51.395 --> 02:37:53.030
LIMITING SINGLE USE PLASTIC
02:37:53.096 --> 02:37:55.465
TOILETRY BOTTLES ALSO RESULTS IN
02:37:55.532 --> 02:37:56.767
GREENHOUSE GAS REDUCTION.
02:37:56.834 --> 02:37:59.436
GHGS ARE RELEASED DURING EVERY
02:37:59.503 --> 02:38:01.538
PHASE OF EVERY YEAH EACH PLASTIC
02:38:01.605 --> 02:38:03.407
BOTTLES LIFECYCLE FROM FOSSIL
02:38:03.473 --> 02:38:05.309
FUEL EXTRACTION THROUGH PLASTIC
02:38:05.375 --> 02:38:07.444
RESIN PRODUCTION TO PACKAGING
02:38:07.511 --> 02:38:10.214
MANUFACTURING LANDFILL DISPOSAL.
02:38:10.280 --> 02:38:11.915
USING THESE ARGUMENTS WE WERE
02:38:11.982 --> 02:38:13.650
SUCCESSFUL IN URGING THE SANTA
02:38:13.717 --> 02:38:15.452
CRUZ COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
02:38:15.519 --> 02:38:16.854
TO TAKE ACTION.
02:38:16.920 --> 02:38:20.257
IN NOVEMBER TWO IN NOVEMBER OF
02:38:20.324 --> 02:38:20.791
TWENTY EIGHTEEN IF YOU CAN
02:38:20.858 --> 02:38:21.692
FINISH UP PLEASE YOUR TIME IS
02:38:21.758 --> 02:38:22.059
YET.
02:38:22.125 --> 02:38:23.660
SANTA CRUZ BECAME THE FIRST
02:38:23.727 --> 02:38:25.295
COUNTY AND MAYBE A IN THE
02:38:25.362 --> 02:38:26.830
CALIFORNIA AND POSSIBLY IN THE
02:38:26.897 --> 02:38:29.333
U. S. TO PASS SUCH IN A MEASURE.
02:38:29.399 --> 02:38:31.401
WE'RE ALSO WORKING IN HAVE
02:38:31.468 --> 02:38:33.637
ACTIVE -- AN INDICATION OF
02:38:33.704 --> 02:38:35.973
ACTION FROM SIT CITY OF SANTA
02:38:36.039 --> 02:38:38.342
CRUZ SCOTTS VALLEY CAPITAL LACKS
02:38:38.408 --> 02:38:46.884
THANK YOU FOR YOUR SUPPORT.
02:38:46.950 --> 02:38:47.384
MADAM CHAIRMAN.
02:38:47.451 --> 02:38:48.018
JOHN CALDWELL ON BEHALF OF THE
02:38:48.085 --> 02:38:48.518
CALIFORNIA HOTEL LODGING
02:38:48.585 --> 02:38:49.386
ASSOCIATION WE APPRECIATE THE
02:38:49.453 --> 02:38:50.153
AUTHOR REACHING OUT TO US -- WE
02:38:50.220 --> 02:38:51.054
ARE NOT OPPOSED TO THE BILL AS
02:38:51.121 --> 02:38:53.357
HE SAID WE WE I HAVE ASKED --
02:38:53.423 --> 02:38:54.691
FIRST AMENDMENTS AND WE WOULD
02:38:54.758 --> 02:38:56.193
SUPPORT IT IF THOSE AMENDMENTS
02:38:56.260 --> 02:38:56.927
ARE TAKEN OUR INDUSTRIES A
02:38:56.994 --> 02:38:58.362
LEADER IT'S BEEN POINTED OUT AND
02:38:58.428 --> 02:38:59.963
SUSTAINABILITY AND DEMONSTRATED
02:39:00.030 --> 02:39:01.632
TANGIBLE COMMITMENT. TO
02:39:01.698 --> 02:39:03.200
ENVIRONMENTAL STEWARDSHIP.
02:39:03.267 --> 02:39:04.434
INTER CONTINENTAL HOTEL GROUP
02:39:04.501 --> 02:39:05.736
HAS RECEIVED THE HIGHEST SCORE
02:39:05.802 --> 02:39:06.737
FOR THE INDUSTRY ON THE
02:39:06.803 --> 02:39:07.971
CORPORATE SUSTAINABILITY
02:39:08.038 --> 02:39:09.273
ASSESSMENT HEALTH IN AS REDUCE
02:39:09.339 --> 02:39:11.475
LANDFILL WASTE BY 41%.
02:39:11.541 --> 02:39:13.343
HI IT IS COMMITTED TO DIVERTING
02:39:13.410 --> 02:39:15.112
40% OF ITS WASTE FROM LANDFILLS
02:39:15.178 --> 02:39:16.380
BY THE END OF TWENTY TWENTY
02:39:16.446 --> 02:39:19.283
MARRIOTT HAS -- RECYCLED OVER A
02:39:19.349 --> 02:39:20.050
HUNDRED THOUSAND POUNDS.
02:39:20.117 --> 02:39:22.452
OF PLASTIC JUST IN TWENTY
02:39:22.519 --> 02:39:23.387
SEVENTEEN ALONE.
02:39:23.453 --> 02:39:24.888
OUR INDUSTRY IS ALREADY TAKING
02:39:24.955 --> 02:39:27.190
RECOGNIZED INNOVATIVE STEPS TO
02:39:27.257 --> 02:39:28.659
CREATE A MORE SUSTAINABLE FUTURE
02:39:28.725 --> 02:39:29.826
SO WHAT WE'RE ASKING.
02:39:29.893 --> 02:39:30.994
IS THAT THE COMMITTEE TO
02:39:31.061 --> 02:39:31.862
CONSIDER AMENDMENTS THAT WOULD
02:39:31.929 --> 02:39:33.897
HELP SB ELEVEN SIXTY TO MELD
02:39:33.964 --> 02:39:35.365
WITH THESE EXISTING
02:39:35.432 --> 02:39:37.601
ENVIRONMENTAL INITIATIVES AND SO
02:39:37.668 --> 02:39:39.336
WE WERE WE TALK TO THE THE
02:39:39.403 --> 02:39:43.273
AUTHOR ABOUT THIS -- WE WE WOULD
02:39:43.340 --> 02:39:44.041
LIKE TO MAKE SO SURE THAT
02:39:44.107 --> 02:39:45.142
CLARIFY THE SCOPE OF THE BILL BE
02:39:45.208 --> 02:39:46.243
LIMITED THE SHOWER BATH
02:39:46.310 --> 02:39:47.477
ACCESSORIES.
02:39:47.544 --> 02:39:48.612
WHICH THE INDUSTRY HAS ALREADY
02:39:48.679 --> 02:39:50.180
BEGUN IN EARNEST OVER THE PAST
02:39:50.247 --> 02:39:52.249
DECADE WITH SEVERAL HOTEL BRANDS
02:39:52.316 --> 02:39:53.917
ALREADY MOVING AWAY FROM SINGLE
02:39:53.984 --> 02:39:55.252
USE SHAMPOO CONDITIONER LIKE
02:39:55.319 --> 02:39:55.953
WHICH SHALL.
02:39:56.019 --> 02:39:58.655
WE BELIEVE THIS FOCUSED APPROACH --
02:39:58.722 --> 02:39:59.723
MEETS THE INTENT OF THE AUTHOR
02:39:59.790 --> 02:40:05.529
AND WILL PREVENT LATER DISPUTES.
02:40:05.595 --> 02:40:06.163
SECONDLY WE REQUEST A RIGHT TO
02:40:06.229 --> 02:40:06.797
CURE PROVISIONS SIMILAR TO WHAT
02:40:06.863 --> 02:40:07.297
IS REQUIRED OF ON HUMAN
02:40:07.364 --> 02:40:09.066
TRAFFICKING SIGNAGE THAT HOTELS
02:40:09.132 --> 02:40:10.767
AND OTHER BUSINESSES ARE SUBJECT.
02:40:10.834 --> 02:40:11.868
TO LASTLY REQUEST AN
02:40:11.935 --> 02:40:14.171
IMPLEMENTATION DATE OF JANUARY
02:40:14.237 --> 02:40:15.839
FIRST TWENTY TWENTY FIVE FOR ALL
02:40:15.906 --> 02:40:16.907
LODGING ESTABLISHMENTS WITH
02:40:16.974 --> 02:40:18.475
FIFTY ROOMS ARE MORE.
02:40:18.542 --> 02:40:20.110
THAN A YEAR LATER FOR THOSE.
02:40:20.177 --> 02:40:21.878
WITH FIFTY ROOMS ARE LAST.
02:40:21.945 --> 02:40:23.447
ON THAT THIS OUR PRIDE THIS WILL
02:40:23.513 --> 02:40:24.948
PROVIDE HOTELS WITH ENOUGH TIME
02:40:25.015 --> 02:40:26.917
TO EXHAUST OUR CURRENT SUPPLY OF
02:40:26.984 --> 02:40:28.352
SHAMPOO CONDITIONER LIQUID SOAP
02:40:28.418 --> 02:40:29.419
SO AS NOT TO ENCOURAGE
02:40:29.486 --> 02:40:30.754
UNNECESSARY WASTE.
02:40:30.821 --> 02:40:31.955
ADDITIONALLY THE REALITY IS A
02:40:32.022 --> 02:40:33.357
MANDATE LIKE THIS ON A STATE
02:40:33.423 --> 02:40:34.691
WITH MORE THAN HALF A MILLION
02:40:34.758 --> 02:40:35.993
HOTEL LODGING ROOMS MAY CAUSE
02:40:36.059 --> 02:40:37.627
BACKLOGS AND SHORTAGES.
02:40:37.694 --> 02:40:39.062
ON THE REPLACEMENT TECHNOLOGY
02:40:39.129 --> 02:40:41.098
AGAIN OUR APPRECIATION TO THE
02:40:41.164 --> 02:40:42.933
AUTHOR FOR REACHING OUT TO US IN
02:40:43.000 --> 02:40:46.370
HIS WILLINGNESS TO MAKE THIS WAS
02:40:46.436 --> 02:40:47.471
LOWER.
02:40:47.537 --> 02:40:48.105
YOU ARE THERE ARE ANY WITNESSES
02:40:48.171 --> 02:40:52.342
IN SUPPORT.
02:40:52.409 --> 02:40:53.577
MELISSA ROMERO ON BEHALF OF THE
02:40:53.643 --> 02:40:55.445
CALIFORNIA LEAGUE OF
02:40:55.512 --> 02:40:59.850
CONSERVATION VOTERS IN SUPPORT.
02:40:59.916 --> 02:41:01.151
BOTTOM ANYONE FROM CALIFORNIANS
02:41:01.218 --> 02:41:04.554
AGAINST WASTE IN SUPPORT.
02:41:04.621 --> 02:41:05.756
THERESA RIGOROUS ON BEHALF OF
02:41:05.822 --> 02:41:06.857
THE CLEAN SEIZE LOBBYING
02:41:06.923 --> 02:41:08.258
COALITION IN STRONG SUPPORT
02:41:08.325 --> 02:41:09.292
THANK YOU ARE THERE ANY
02:41:09.359 --> 02:41:10.660
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION TO THE
02:41:10.727 --> 02:41:18.001
BILL.
02:41:18.068 --> 02:41:19.503
HEY GOOD AFTERNOON MEMBERS SORRY
02:41:19.569 --> 02:41:21.138
LITTLE OUT THERE MEMBERS OF THE
02:41:21.204 --> 02:41:22.406
COMMITTEE MY NAME IS KAREN ROSS
02:41:22.472 --> 02:41:23.273
AND WITH THE PERSONAL CARE
02:41:23.340 --> 02:41:25.208
PRODUCTS COUNCIL WHERE THE
02:41:25.275 --> 02:41:26.710
INDUSTRY TRADE ASSOCIATION.
02:41:26.777 --> 02:41:28.045
REPRESENTING THE FRAGRANCE
02:41:28.111 --> 02:41:29.713
PERSONAL CARE -- AND BECAUSE
02:41:29.780 --> 02:41:32.716
MEDICS ASSOCIATION WITH OVER
02:41:32.783 --> 02:41:33.350
FIVE HUNDRED THOUSAND EMPLOYEES
02:41:33.417 --> 02:41:35.385
IN STATE AND WE ARE HERE TO
02:41:35.452 --> 02:41:36.853
OPPOSE THE BILL AS CURRENTLY
02:41:36.920 --> 02:41:38.221
DRAFTED HAVEN'T HAD AN
02:41:38.288 --> 02:41:39.589
OPPORTUNITY TO SEE THE RECENT
02:41:39.656 --> 02:41:40.957
AMENDMENTS BUT LOOK FORWARD TO
02:41:41.024 --> 02:41:42.626
SEEING THEM -- WE THINK THIS
02:41:42.692 --> 02:41:44.661
BILL IS WELL INTENDED WE SHARE
02:41:44.728 --> 02:41:47.197
THE SAME GOAL AS FAR AS REDUCING
02:41:47.264 --> 02:41:48.865
PLASTIC PACKAGING.
02:41:48.932 --> 02:41:50.133
OUR MEMBER COMPANIES HAVE SET
02:41:50.200 --> 02:41:52.069
AGGRESSIVE COMMITMENTS ON THAT
02:41:52.135 --> 02:41:54.037
FRONT -- WE DO THINK THERE ARE
02:41:54.104 --> 02:41:55.972
SOME ISSUES -- WITH THE SCOPE OF
02:41:56.039 --> 02:41:58.875
THE BILL -- WITH THE SIZE OF THE
02:41:58.942 --> 02:42:00.277
TWELVE OUNCES OR LESS WE THINK
02:42:00.343 --> 02:42:02.746
THAT COULD ON IN A FOR ONLY BàN
02:42:02.813 --> 02:42:04.581
A TREMENDOUS AMOUNT OF PRODUCT.
02:42:04.648 --> 02:42:07.184
AND WE ALSO HAVE -- YOU KNOW
02:42:07.250 --> 02:42:09.052
THERE ARE A LOT OF MY MEDIUM AND
02:42:09.119 --> 02:42:12.089
SMALL COMPANIES THAT ARE IN
02:42:12.155 --> 02:42:15.392
STATE THAT COULD BE READ READ --
02:42:15.459 --> 02:42:16.960
PACKAGING THE PRODUCT OF
02:42:17.027 --> 02:42:18.528
DISTRIBUTING THE PRODUCT UNDER
02:42:18.595 --> 02:42:20.730
BRAND NAMES TO HOTELS AND WE DO
02:42:20.797 --> 02:42:21.998
THINK THAT WE HAVE TO BRING THEM
02:42:22.065 --> 02:42:23.533
INTO THE CONVERSATION TO MAKE
02:42:23.600 --> 02:42:25.602
SURE THAT COMPANIES OF ALL SIZES.
02:42:25.669 --> 02:42:27.270
CAN COMPLY WITH US BUT WE LOOK
02:42:27.337 --> 02:42:28.004
FORWARD TO WORKING WITH THE
02:42:28.071 --> 02:42:30.640
AUTHOR -- BUT REGRETFULLY OPPOSE
02:42:30.707 --> 02:42:34.611
AS CURRENTLY DRAFTED THANK YOU
02:42:34.678 --> 02:42:37.914
THANK YOU ANYONE ELSE OPPOSE.
02:42:37.981 --> 02:42:38.949
GOOD AFTERNOON ADAM REQUIEM
02:42:39.015 --> 02:42:40.217
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA CHAMBER
02:42:40.283 --> 02:42:41.451
OF COMMERCE WE HAVE A OPPOSE
02:42:41.518 --> 02:42:43.353
UNLESS AMENDED POSITION AND WE
02:42:43.420 --> 02:42:44.020
LOOK FORWARD TO WORKING WITH THE
02:42:44.087 --> 02:42:45.322
AUTHOR -- TO GO TO NEUTRAL THANK
02:42:45.388 --> 02:42:46.456
YOU.
02:42:46.523 --> 02:42:48.058
THANK YOU NUMBER GET BACK TO THE
02:42:48.125 --> 02:42:49.326
COMMITTEE.
02:42:49.392 --> 02:42:52.129
ASSEMBLYMEMBER MELINDA'S.
02:42:52.195 --> 02:42:54.097
THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR -- SO
02:42:54.164 --> 02:42:58.301
MISTER KALRA -- MANY OF THESE
02:42:58.368 --> 02:43:00.837
BOTTLES ARE RECYCLABLE.
02:43:00.904 --> 02:43:02.038
YES THEY ARE [inaudible]
02:43:02.105 --> 02:43:05.342
SURE THERE.
02:43:05.408 --> 02:43:07.110
MISTER KALRA MANY OF THESE
02:43:07.177 --> 02:43:08.578
BOTTLES ARE RECYCLABLE IF
02:43:08.645 --> 02:43:10.013
THEY'VE IF THEY'VE GOT THE
02:43:10.080 --> 02:43:11.281
SYMBOL UNDER NEED THAT SHOWS
02:43:11.348 --> 02:43:11.948
THAT THERE IS LIKE WHAT THEY CAN
02:43:12.015 --> 02:43:13.350
BE REACHED THAT CAN BE PUT IN
02:43:13.416 --> 02:43:14.484
THE RECYCLE.
02:43:14.551 --> 02:43:16.920
BIN IN THE ROOM ON THAT DOT THE
02:43:16.987 --> 02:43:19.055
HOTELS CAN THEN YOU KNOW SEND
02:43:19.122 --> 02:43:20.490
THEM OUT FOR READ FOR RECYCLING
02:43:20.557 --> 02:43:22.392
SO I'M JUST CURIOUS.
02:43:22.459 --> 02:43:24.594
RATHER THAN A BAN WHY NOT MORE
02:43:24.661 --> 02:43:28.064
OF A FOCUS ON AN EDUCATION.
02:43:28.131 --> 02:43:29.799
CAMPAIGN.
02:43:29.866 --> 02:43:30.767
WELL.
02:43:30.834 --> 02:43:31.768
THANK YOU FOR THE QUESTION A
02:43:31.835 --> 02:43:33.737
COUPLE OF THE THINGS THAT POINT.
02:43:33.803 --> 02:43:35.472
ONE IS THAT WE KNOW ESPECIALLY
02:43:35.539 --> 02:43:37.908
THE SMALLER A PIECE OF PLASTIC
02:43:37.974 --> 02:43:38.909
GETS THE LESS LIKELY THAT IT
02:43:38.975 --> 02:43:41.378
DOES ACTUALLY GET RECYCLED AND
02:43:41.444 --> 02:43:41.611
BACKED.
02:43:41.678 --> 02:43:43.380
UP AND AND A SUMMER STYLE HE'S
02:43:43.446 --> 02:43:44.548
OVER THERE THAT.
02:43:44.614 --> 02:43:46.249
THIS BILL IDEA CAME BECAUSE IT
02:43:46.316 --> 02:43:47.050
WAS A SELECT COMMITTEE HEARING
02:43:47.117 --> 02:43:49.452
THAT A SIMILAR STONE WAS --
02:43:49.519 --> 02:43:50.620
HOLDER THE HELD IN SANTA CRUZ
02:43:50.687 --> 02:43:52.856
NEVER DIFFERENT -- IDEAS AS TO
02:43:52.923 --> 02:43:53.890
WHAT KINDS OF THINGS COULD
02:43:53.957 --> 02:43:55.659
REDUCE SINGLE USE PLASTIC USAGE
02:43:55.725 --> 02:43:57.060
THAT ENDS UP IN THE WASTE STREAM
02:43:57.127 --> 02:43:58.528
AND IN THE OCEANS.
02:43:58.595 --> 02:44:00.163
AND THIS WAS IDENTIFIED AS ONE
02:44:00.230 --> 02:44:01.731
MOST MORSE BUT MOST POSSIBLY
02:44:01.798 --> 02:44:03.400
BECAUSE NOT JUST THE SIZE BUT
02:44:03.466 --> 02:44:05.869
THE VOLUME OF THE AMOUNT OF THEM.
02:44:05.936 --> 02:44:07.837
IS SO LARGE THE DAD A NOTE IN AN
02:44:07.904 --> 02:44:09.472
INORDINATE INORDINATE A NUMBER
02:44:09.539 --> 02:44:11.441
OF THEM ARE ENDING UP IN THE WAY
02:44:11.508 --> 02:44:12.642
STE NOT IN THE WAIST PROPER
02:44:12.709 --> 02:44:14.377
WASTE AND RECYCLING STREAM.
02:44:14.444 --> 02:44:16.012
BUT ENDING UP IN OUR RIVER WAYS
02:44:16.079 --> 02:44:17.981
AND OUR WATERWAYS AND INTO THE
02:44:18.048 --> 02:44:18.748
OCEAN.
02:44:18.815 --> 02:44:21.885
SECONDLY OF THE WE HAVE THIS
02:44:21.952 --> 02:44:23.019
LARGER CONVERSATION -- SUMMER
02:44:23.086 --> 02:44:24.654
GONZALEZ AND OTHERS HAVE BILLS
02:44:24.721 --> 02:44:26.556
REGARDING SINGLE USE PLASTICS IF
02:44:26.623 --> 02:44:27.891
WE'RE REALLY GOING TO TACKLE THE
02:44:27.958 --> 02:44:29.292
ISSUES IN THESE PLASTICS WE HAVE
02:44:29.359 --> 02:44:29.559
TO FIND.
02:44:29.626 --> 02:44:31.328
AREAS WHERE WE CAN REDUCE THEIR
02:44:31.394 --> 02:44:34.297
USE AND I BELIEVE THAT HOTELS UP
02:44:34.364 --> 02:44:35.699
ESPECIALLY GIVEN THE FACT THE
02:44:35.765 --> 02:44:37.200
INDUSTRY ON ITS OWN WITHOUT ANY
02:44:37.267 --> 02:44:38.335
LEGISLATION.
02:44:38.401 --> 02:44:40.370
IS MOVING IN THAT DIRECTION IS
02:44:40.437 --> 02:44:41.905
ABSOLUTELY LOW HANGING FRUIT TO
02:44:41.972 --> 02:44:45.542
REDUCE SINGLE USE PLASTICS IN
02:44:45.609 --> 02:44:48.678
OUR IN -- IN OUR STATE -- AGAIN
02:44:48.745 --> 02:44:49.746
YOU KNOW MERRY OUT BY ITSELF BY
02:44:49.813 --> 02:44:50.714
THE END OF THIS YEAR AND IN
02:44:50.780 --> 02:44:51.715
NORTH AMERICA WILL HAVE WELL
02:44:51.781 --> 02:44:53.316
OVER FIFTEEN HUNDRED PROPERTIES --
02:44:53.383 --> 02:44:55.185
BUT ENDED THIS YEAR -- WELL
02:44:55.252 --> 02:44:56.886
BEFORE ANYTHING OF THIS NATURE
02:44:56.953 --> 02:44:59.489
WOULD BE PUT INTO PLACE OF OF OF
02:44:59.556 --> 02:45:01.291
OF REMOVING SO THEY USE PLASTICS
02:45:01.358 --> 02:45:02.525
AND THEIR TOILETRIES.
02:45:02.592 --> 02:45:04.628
AND SO IT'S NOT JUST SIMPLY A
02:45:04.694 --> 02:45:07.430
MATTER OF WHETHER SOMETHING CAN
02:45:07.497 --> 02:45:09.165
BE RECYCLED OR NOT.
02:45:09.232 --> 02:45:10.533
IT'S A MATTER OF HOW DO WE
02:45:10.600 --> 02:45:11.668
ULTIMATELY BECAUSE THERE'S A
02:45:11.735 --> 02:45:13.703
THERE'S A PRODUCTION COSTS AS
02:45:13.770 --> 02:45:15.038
WELL TO CREATING PLASTIC THAT AB
02:45:15.105 --> 02:45:16.439
HAD TO CONTRIBUTE TO GREENHOUSE
02:45:16.506 --> 02:45:18.074
GAS EMISSIONS AND CRUDE JOBS TO
02:45:18.141 --> 02:45:18.508
WASTE.
02:45:18.575 --> 02:45:20.277
AND SO IF WE CAN REDUCE THE
02:45:20.343 --> 02:45:22.245
OVERALL AMOUNT OF PLASTIC IS
02:45:22.312 --> 02:45:23.747
PARTICULARLY SINGLE USE.
02:45:23.813 --> 02:45:25.749
I THINK THAT IT IT HITS A LOT OF
02:45:25.815 --> 02:45:35.292
DIFFERENT GOALS WE HAVE OKAY BUT
02:45:35.358 --> 02:45:35.925
YOU SAID SOMETHING THAT KIND OF
02:45:35.992 --> 02:45:37.594
STAND ABOUT WHICH IS THAT THE
02:45:37.661 --> 02:45:38.695
INDUSTRY IS REALLY ALREADY
02:45:38.762 --> 02:45:39.329
TAKING THIS UPON THEMSELVES. TO
02:45:39.396 --> 02:45:39.929
MOVE FORWARD WITH THIS SO WHY
02:45:39.996 --> 02:45:40.497
THEN DO WE NEED GOVERNMENT
02:45:40.563 --> 02:45:40.830
INTERVENTION.
02:45:40.897 --> 02:45:41.998
IF IT'S WORKING.
02:45:42.065 --> 02:45:43.400
WELL IT'S A COUPLE REASONS ONE
02:45:43.466 --> 02:45:44.701
IS GAS INDUSTRY IS MOVING IN
02:45:44.768 --> 02:45:46.102
THAT DIRECTION IN TERMS OF SOME
02:45:46.169 --> 02:45:46.836
OF THE BRANDS.
02:45:46.903 --> 02:45:48.672
I THINK THAT WITH LEGISLATION
02:45:48.738 --> 02:45:50.573
NOT ONLY CAN WE PAYS IT OUT ALL
02:45:50.640 --> 02:45:51.875
TOGETHER WHICH I THINK IS A A
02:45:51.941 --> 02:45:53.777
NOBLE COLIN OF OF APPROPRIATE
02:45:53.843 --> 02:45:55.278
GOAL IN TERMS OF PUBLIC POLICY.
02:45:55.345 --> 02:45:57.213
BUT BY HAVING LEGISLATION WE CAN
02:45:57.280 --> 02:45:58.214
ALSO.
02:45:58.281 --> 02:45:59.816
HELP IN WORKING WITH THE LODGING
02:45:59.883 --> 02:46:01.051
ASSOCIATE HOW AND ACTIVELY WITH
02:46:01.117 --> 02:46:02.552
THOSE INDEPENDENT HOTELS THAT
02:46:02.619 --> 02:46:03.887
AREN'T PART OF THE MARRIOTT
02:46:03.953 --> 02:46:05.422
BRAND WHAT HAVE YOU MOVE IN THE
02:46:05.488 --> 02:46:06.890
RIGHT DIRECTION MANY OF THEM
02:46:06.956 --> 02:46:08.792
WANT TO I'VE MET WITH I MET WITH
02:46:08.858 --> 02:46:09.192
SO MANY OF THEM.
02:46:09.259 --> 02:46:10.894
THEY WANT TO THEY DON'T HAVE THE
02:46:10.960 --> 02:46:15.899
SUPPORT SYSTEM TO DO IT WITH THE
02:46:15.965 --> 02:46:18.601
BILL NOT ONLY CAN WE IT'S NOT
02:46:18.668 --> 02:46:19.235
JUST ABOUT MANDATING IT'S ALSO
02:46:19.302 --> 02:46:19.469
ABOUT.
02:46:19.536 --> 02:46:20.437
CREATING A TIE MINOR SUPPORT
02:46:20.503 --> 02:46:22.205
SYSTEM TO HELP ALL OF THE HOTEL
02:46:22.272 --> 02:46:24.407
YEARS A MOTEL YEARS -- PAYS US
02:46:24.474 --> 02:46:25.475
IN THESE PLASTIC BECAUSE THAT
02:46:25.542 --> 02:46:26.409
GOAL IN ITSELF IS A GOOD GOAL SO
02:46:26.476 --> 02:46:27.811
WHAT IN THE WHICH PART IN THE
02:46:27.877 --> 02:46:29.612
BILL OFFER SUPPORT TO THEIR
02:46:29.679 --> 02:46:30.613
SMALLER HOTEL.
02:46:30.680 --> 02:46:32.816
WELL FOR ONE OF THE AREAS THAT.
02:46:32.882 --> 02:46:34.784
WERE ONE OF THE AMENDMENTS THAT
02:46:34.851 --> 02:46:35.652
WILL BE.
02:46:35.719 --> 02:46:37.554
OF THAT WE DISCUSSED AND I I
02:46:37.620 --> 02:46:38.955
KNOW WELL A REPRESENTATIVE HERE
02:46:39.022 --> 02:46:40.557
FROM THE HOTEL LODGING
02:46:40.623 --> 02:46:43.393
ASSOCIATION A REFERENCE -- TO
02:46:43.460 --> 02:46:43.893
AND IT'S SOMETHING I'VE
02:46:43.960 --> 02:46:44.194
DISCUSSED.
02:46:44.260 --> 02:46:45.729
EVEN WITH OF THE ORGANIZATION IS
02:46:45.795 --> 02:46:48.264
THAT ADDITIONAL TIME LINE OF ONE
02:46:48.331 --> 02:46:49.799
YEAR FOR SMALLER HOTELS.
02:46:49.866 --> 02:46:51.601
I THINK THAT ADDITIONAL YEAR
02:46:51.668 --> 02:46:53.937
ALLOWS THE ASSOCIATION -- AND
02:46:54.003 --> 02:46:55.105
ALLOWS.
02:46:55.171 --> 02:46:57.240
US AS A STATE TO EDUCATE AND GET
02:46:57.307 --> 02:46:58.541
THE WORD OUT THERE ABOUT IT AND
02:46:58.608 --> 02:47:00.810
TO HELP OFFER ASSISTANCE AND
02:47:00.877 --> 02:47:02.846
CONNECT WITH SAYS ABSOLUTELY --
02:47:02.912 --> 02:47:04.414
SOMETHING THAT -- I'M I'M
02:47:04.481 --> 02:47:06.216
ABSOLUTELY INTERESTED IN DOING
02:47:06.282 --> 02:47:08.918
IS ENSURING THAT -- AND THAT'S
02:47:08.985 --> 02:47:09.652
PART OF THESE I MET WITH THE
02:47:09.719 --> 02:47:12.188
BILL DISSOCIATION WAS A HOA --
02:47:12.255 --> 02:47:13.623
BEFORE I EVEN REDUCE THE BILL
02:47:13.690 --> 02:47:14.457
BECAUSE I DIDN'T WANT TO BE A
02:47:14.524 --> 02:47:15.925
HEAVY HANDED ABLE COMING AT YOU --
02:47:15.992 --> 02:47:17.127
COMING AT YOUR INDUSTRY IT WAS
02:47:17.193 --> 02:47:18.428
QUITE THE OPPOSITE IT WAS A
02:47:18.495 --> 02:47:20.130
LET'S MEET NOW BEFORE I EVEN
02:47:20.196 --> 02:47:21.731
KNEW DISABILITY AND THAT'S WHY
02:47:21.798 --> 02:47:22.599
THEY'RE AMENDMENTS ARE BEING
02:47:22.665 --> 02:47:24.033
OFFERED THE CONVERSATIONS GOING
02:47:24.100 --> 02:47:25.602
TO CONTINUE. TO MAKE IT AS EASY
02:47:25.668 --> 02:47:27.137
AS POSSIBLE BUT ABSOLUTELY
02:47:27.203 --> 02:47:28.905
THERE'S AN INTEREST TO HELP WITH
02:47:28.972 --> 02:47:35.779
THE INDEPENDENT SMALLER HOTELS
02:47:35.845 --> 02:47:36.946
HELP FACILITATE THANK YOU.
02:47:37.013 --> 02:47:38.014
THANK YOU ANY OTHER COMMITTEE
02:47:38.081 --> 02:47:40.150
MEMBERS WITH COMMENTS.
02:47:40.216 --> 02:47:43.286
SOME MEMBER MATHIS JUST.
02:47:43.353 --> 02:47:44.087
YOU KNOW AND I KNOW THERE'S
02:47:44.154 --> 02:47:45.188
OTHER BILLS FLOATING AROUND THE
02:47:45.255 --> 02:47:48.024
LEGISLATURE THAT MORE TOWARDS --
02:47:48.091 --> 02:47:49.459
YOU KNOW KINDA INFORMING THE
02:47:49.526 --> 02:47:52.695
PUBLIC ON RECYCLING -- HAVING
02:47:52.762 --> 02:47:54.164
DIFFERENT GROUPS ACTUALLY SET UP
02:47:54.230 --> 02:47:56.065
RECYCLING BINS I MEAN I'VE NEVER
02:47:56.132 --> 02:47:58.067
WALKED INTO A HOTEL ROOM.
02:47:58.134 --> 02:47:59.436
IT'S IN A BLUE.
02:47:59.502 --> 02:48:02.572
RECYCLING BAND -- MALIK I'VE
02:48:02.639 --> 02:48:04.607
SEEN A FEW BUT IT'S YOU KNOW YOU
02:48:04.674 --> 02:48:05.975
YOU GOT A LITTLE TRASH CANS
02:48:06.042 --> 02:48:07.210
THERE ARE THEY OFFERING
02:48:07.277 --> 02:48:08.645
RECYCLING BINS I MEAN WHAT WOULD
02:48:08.711 --> 02:48:13.416
IT BE A MUCH EASIER PUSH -- FOR
02:48:13.483 --> 02:48:14.717
HOTELS JUST.
02:48:14.784 --> 02:48:16.586
TO HAVE THEM OFFER RECYCLING
02:48:16.653 --> 02:48:17.353
BINS THAT WE WE KNOW WE'RE
02:48:17.420 --> 02:48:18.421
GETTING THIS.
02:48:18.488 --> 02:48:20.590
AND IT GOES INTO TO THE PLASTIC --
02:48:20.657 --> 02:48:23.293
RECYCLING IN A GOES AND MISTER
02:48:23.359 --> 02:48:25.261
TEAMS BILL I'M A GOES IN AND ALL
02:48:25.328 --> 02:48:25.862
THESE OTHER THINGS THAT WE'RE
02:48:25.929 --> 02:48:29.466
TRYING TO DO -- NO IT WE A LOT
02:48:29.532 --> 02:48:31.234
OF US GREW UP WITH THIS -- YOU
02:48:31.301 --> 02:48:34.103
KNOW RECYCLE REDUCE REUSE.
02:48:34.170 --> 02:48:35.438
BIND SCHOOLS AND NOW IT JUST
02:48:35.505 --> 02:48:36.673
SEEMS LIKE WE JUST WANT TO GET
02:48:36.739 --> 02:48:39.075
RID OF ANYTHING THAT COULD BE A
02:48:39.142 --> 02:48:41.211
RECYCLED PRODUCT ON JUST BECAUSE
02:48:41.277 --> 02:48:46.850
IT'S BAD -- OR OR SOMEBODY DEEMS
02:48:46.916 --> 02:48:48.651
THAT BAD -- YOU KNOW I THOUGHT
02:48:48.718 --> 02:48:50.854
THE THE WHOLE PURPOSE -- THE
02:48:50.920 --> 02:48:52.455
EARLIEST -- FOR FOR THE
02:48:52.522 --> 02:48:54.190
MILLENNIALS ON MY GENERATION
02:48:54.257 --> 02:48:56.593
THAT WE GOT -- INSTITUTIONALIZED
02:48:56.659 --> 02:48:59.496
IN IN -- SCHOOL WAS TO RECYCLE
02:48:59.562 --> 02:49:01.364
ON NOT TO GET RID OF SO WHY
02:49:01.431 --> 02:49:03.733
AREN'T WE FOCUSING ON RECYCLING
02:49:03.800 --> 02:49:05.969
THESE PRODUCTS AND SAY HAVE THE
02:49:06.035 --> 02:49:08.371
HOTELS -- HAVE RECYCLE BINS
02:49:08.438 --> 02:49:11.808
THERE IN THE ROOMS TO CAPTURE
02:49:11.875 --> 02:49:14.477
THAT OR THE YOU KNOW ON SPENT
02:49:14.544 --> 02:49:16.079
SHAMPOOS CAN GO TO HOMELESS
02:49:16.145 --> 02:49:17.814
SHELTERS WERE HAVING AN ISSUE
02:49:17.881 --> 02:49:19.983
GETTING PRODUCTS THERE I MEAN
02:49:20.049 --> 02:49:20.617
THERE'S A HUNDRED ONE THINGS WE
02:49:20.683 --> 02:49:21.484
CAN DO.
02:49:21.551 --> 02:49:24.087
BUT I I FEEL LIKE WE'RE JUST
02:49:24.153 --> 02:49:25.622
TRYING TO SAY OKAY THIS IS BAD.
02:49:25.688 --> 02:49:27.757
LET'S GET RID OF IT YOU KNOW IN
02:49:27.824 --> 02:49:29.058
THE I THINK THERE'S TOO MUCH OF
02:49:29.125 --> 02:49:30.360
THAT FLOW AROUND UP HERE I I
02:49:30.426 --> 02:49:31.661
APPRECIATE YOUR PERSPECTIVE LOOK
02:49:31.728 --> 02:49:33.296
YOU KNOW I GREW UP JUST LIKE YOU
02:49:33.363 --> 02:49:34.397
DID LEARNING ABOUT RECYCLING WE
02:49:34.464 --> 02:49:35.465
TAUGHT OUR PARENTS HOW TO DO IT
02:49:35.532 --> 02:49:36.065
BECAUSE THEY DIDN'T GROW UP.
02:49:36.132 --> 02:49:37.500
WITH THAT AND THE PART OF THE
02:49:37.567 --> 02:49:39.135
REASON IS THAT POSSIBLE
02:49:39.202 --> 02:49:40.503
LIBERATED DURING OUR UPBRINGING
02:49:40.570 --> 02:49:42.071
IN A WAY THAT WE HAD NEVER SEEN
02:49:42.138 --> 02:49:43.273
BEFORE NOW WE KNOW WHAT THOSE
02:49:43.339 --> 02:49:44.374
IMPACTS ARE.
02:49:44.440 --> 02:49:45.542
THIS IS AN EVOLUTION IT'S AN
02:49:45.608 --> 02:49:47.210
EVOLUTION RECOGNIZING IS NOT
02:49:47.277 --> 02:49:48.811
JUST ABOUT ABOUT RECYCLING
02:49:48.878 --> 02:49:50.947
PLASTICS BUT WE HAVE TO START
02:49:51.014 --> 02:49:52.582
ARE WE AT THE START TO PHASE AS
02:49:52.649 --> 02:49:53.383
MUCH THE MOTHER THAT'S PACKED
02:49:53.449 --> 02:49:54.851
THAT'S PRACTICAL.
02:49:54.918 --> 02:49:57.053
THAT MAKES SENSE -- SECONDLY AND
02:49:57.120 --> 02:49:58.354
THIS IS SOMETHING I LEARNED A
02:49:58.421 --> 02:50:00.056
LOT ABOUT WHEN I WAS IN THIS
02:50:00.123 --> 02:50:00.857
HOUSE A CITY COUNCIL IN A MANY
02:50:00.924 --> 02:50:02.225
OF YOUR FROM LOCAL GOVERNMENT.
02:50:02.292 --> 02:50:02.759
AND WHEN I VISIT RECYCLING
02:50:02.825 --> 02:50:05.395
PLANTS IF THERE ARE CONTAMINANTS --
02:50:05.461 --> 02:50:06.963
THAT THEIR OF THEIR CONTAMINANTS
02:50:07.030 --> 02:50:07.597
WHICH A LOT OF THESE PRODUCTS
02:50:07.664 --> 02:50:10.199
WOULD HAVE AS FAR AS RECYCLING
02:50:10.266 --> 02:50:10.867
IS CONSIDERED.
02:50:10.934 --> 02:50:12.569
THE END OF THE PRODUCT IS NOT
02:50:12.635 --> 02:50:13.836
RECYCLE THEY ACTUALLY JUST PUT
02:50:13.903 --> 02:50:15.171
INTO LANDFILL AND SO THAT'S
02:50:15.238 --> 02:50:16.205
ANOTHER ISSUE NOT AND I'LL GIVE
02:50:16.272 --> 02:50:23.546
YOU AN EXAMPLE ABOUT IS
02:50:23.613 --> 02:50:25.014
EDUCATION ENOUGH.
02:50:25.081 --> 02:50:25.915
PLASTIC.
02:50:25.982 --> 02:50:26.649
BAGS AT THE GROCERY STORES I
02:50:26.716 --> 02:50:27.150
KNOW I'M SURE WE HAVE A
02:50:27.216 --> 02:50:27.784
DIFFERENT OPINION ON ON WHETHER
02:50:27.850 --> 02:50:28.585
THAT WAS A GOOD PUBLIC POLICY
02:50:28.651 --> 02:50:29.519
BUT I'LL TELL YOU THAT PRO. TWO
02:50:29.586 --> 02:50:30.086
TO THREE DECADES THERE WAS A
02:50:30.153 --> 02:50:31.187
EDUCATION PROGRAM THAT YOU WERE
02:50:31.254 --> 02:50:32.088
ABLE TO TAKE YOUR PLASTIC BAGS
02:50:32.155 --> 02:50:32.889
BACK THE GROCERY STORE THEY
02:50:32.956 --> 02:50:34.290
WOULD TAKE IT BACK.
02:50:34.357 --> 02:50:35.391
THE REALITY IS THAT PEOPLE JUST
02:50:35.458 --> 02:50:38.494
DIDN'T DO IT AND SO THE THOUGH
02:50:38.561 --> 02:50:40.063
OF THE REAL THE REAL.
02:50:40.129 --> 02:50:41.898
OF THE THE REAL MOVE THAT HAD TO
02:50:41.965 --> 02:50:43.232
BE MADE WAS JUST ABANDONED
02:50:43.299 --> 02:50:44.300
BECAUSE THEY WERE NOT GETTING IN
02:50:44.367 --> 02:50:45.868
THE RECYCLING STREAM THERE ARE
02:50:45.935 --> 02:50:47.136
GETTING IN THE WAY STREAM.
02:50:47.203 --> 02:50:48.738
NOW AGAIN I KNOW YOU MAY NOT
02:50:48.805 --> 02:50:49.839
AGREE WITH THAT.
02:50:49.906 --> 02:50:51.407
THAT CONCLUSION BUT THAT'S AN
02:50:51.474 --> 02:50:52.942
EXAMPLE OF HOW IT'S NOT JUST
02:50:53.009 --> 02:50:54.477
ENOUGH TO HAVE A RECYCLING BIN
02:50:54.544 --> 02:50:56.846
OR HAVE A PROGRAM THAT ACCEPTS
02:50:56.913 --> 02:51:00.717
BACK TO THE RECYCLING SO THAT IS.
02:51:00.783 --> 02:51:02.552
SO YEAH SO.
02:51:02.619 --> 02:51:03.853
WANT ONE MORE QUESTION MANAGERS
02:51:03.920 --> 02:51:05.622
IF.
02:51:05.688 --> 02:51:06.556
WE'RE WE'RE SO FOCUSED ON SINGLE
02:51:06.623 --> 02:51:07.690
USE SMALL PLASTICS AND WHAT
02:51:07.757 --> 02:51:09.626
ABOUT LIKE THE INK PEN THAT
02:51:09.692 --> 02:51:11.294
YOU'RE HOLDING IN YOUR HAND.
02:51:11.361 --> 02:51:13.496
NO I MEAN IS THAT IS THAT NEXT
02:51:13.563 --> 02:51:14.297
ON THE CHOPPING THIS WAS CARE AT
02:51:14.364 --> 02:51:17.867
ALL SINGLE USING PENS AND WELL%
02:51:17.934 --> 02:51:19.602
OF AT THE LOOK THE REALITY IS
02:51:19.669 --> 02:51:21.571
THIS AND I I UNDERSTAND I MEAN I
02:51:21.638 --> 02:51:22.939
AM I MEAN A LITTLE FACETIOUS.
02:51:23.006 --> 02:51:24.273
I GET IT I I'VE IT BUT I MEAN WE
02:51:24.340 --> 02:51:25.875
WE KEEP GOING AFTER.
02:51:25.942 --> 02:51:27.844
YOU KNOW ONE SMALL PLASTIC AFTER
02:51:27.910 --> 02:51:30.213
ANOTHER AFTER ANOTHER AFTER
02:51:30.279 --> 02:51:33.182
ANOTHER. ONE IS IN STOCK WELL
02:51:33.249 --> 02:51:34.083
ABOVE WHAT WE DO THIS AND GET
02:51:34.150 --> 02:51:35.284
RID OF HALF A BILLION A YEAR.
02:51:35.351 --> 02:51:36.753
THAT'S NOT HOW MUCH OF THAT IS
02:51:36.819 --> 02:51:38.121
ACTUALLY COMING FROM CALIFORNIA
02:51:38.187 --> 02:51:39.455
VERSUS OTHER PLAYER THAT'S
02:51:39.522 --> 02:51:41.424
CALIFORNIA ALONE THAT THAT'S CAL.
02:51:41.491 --> 02:51:42.792
IT'S A VERY ROUGH LIKE NAPKIN
02:51:42.859 --> 02:51:44.193
CALCULATION BUT BASED UPON THE
02:51:44.260 --> 02:51:46.462
DATA OF THE HOW MANY ROOMS AND
02:51:46.529 --> 02:51:47.864
HOW MANY PLASTIC BOTTLES OF THE
02:51:47.930 --> 02:51:48.631
ROOMS.
02:51:48.698 --> 02:51:51.768
AND SO -- BUT IT DOES MATTER IT
02:51:51.834 --> 02:51:52.835
DOES ADD UP I MEAN WE DON'T.
02:51:52.902 --> 02:51:54.871
WE'RE IN THE WERE IN THE PROBLEM
02:51:54.937 --> 02:51:56.305
THAT WERE IT WE WERE HAVING A
02:51:56.372 --> 02:51:57.440
PROBLEM IN THE CRISIS RIGHT NOW
02:51:57.507 --> 02:51:58.608
WITH THE PLASTICS.
02:51:58.675 --> 02:52:00.009
BECAUSE IT'S CONSERVATIVE AND SO
02:52:00.076 --> 02:52:01.310
YES YOU'RE ABSOLUTELY RIGHT WE
02:52:01.377 --> 02:52:03.112
DO ONE THING OVER JUST TO THAT
02:52:03.179 --> 02:52:03.746
ONE THING WHICH IS IN THE OTHER
02:52:03.813 --> 02:52:04.847
THING AHLERS SANTA SOUNDS LIKE A
02:52:04.914 --> 02:52:09.318
LOT OF OF ABILITY TO RECYCLE AND
02:52:09.385 --> 02:52:10.586
AND REVIEWS.
02:52:10.653 --> 02:52:12.055
ARE WE WE ARE YOUR YOUR I HATE
02:52:12.121 --> 02:52:13.156
YOU YEAH WELL RIGHT NOW WE'RE
02:52:13.222 --> 02:52:13.756
HAVING A BILL WE'RE HAVING A
02:52:13.823 --> 02:52:14.824
PROBLEM WITH RECYCLING PLASTIC
02:52:14.891 --> 02:52:16.626
BECAUSE CHINA'S DECIDED TO STOP
02:52:16.693 --> 02:52:18.261
TAKING OUR RECYCLABLES.
02:52:18.327 --> 02:52:20.396
AND SO PART OF IT IS YES HAVING
02:52:20.463 --> 02:52:21.898
OUR OWN HOME GROWN ABILITY TO
02:52:21.964 --> 02:52:23.966
RECYCLE AND PART OF IT IS
02:52:24.033 --> 02:52:25.301
REDUCING THE CONSUMPTION OF
02:52:25.368 --> 02:52:26.502
SIMPLY IS PLASTICS.
02:52:26.569 --> 02:52:34.010
AND SO WE HAVE TO DO IT ALL IS
02:52:34.077 --> 02:52:34.610
THAT THERE'S NOT ONE ANSWER TO
02:52:34.677 --> 02:52:36.412
IT.
02:52:36.479 --> 02:52:37.146
A SIGNAL MORE COMMON SIDE ARE
02:52:37.213 --> 02:52:37.814
VERY SUPPORTIVE OF YOUR BILL --
02:52:37.880 --> 02:52:38.448
THE IDEA THAT BECAUSE SOMETHING
02:52:38.514 --> 02:52:39.382
IS RECYCLABLE THAT IT'S OFF THE
02:52:39.449 --> 02:52:40.049
HOOK WHEN WE KNOW BECAUSE WE SIT
02:52:40.116 --> 02:52:40.717
ON THIS COMMITTEE AND WE HEAR IT
02:52:40.783 --> 02:52:41.684
OVER AND OVER AGAIN THAT THESE
02:52:41.751 --> 02:52:44.387
PRODUCTS ARE NOT BEING RECYCLED.
02:52:44.454 --> 02:52:45.755
THEY'RE EITHER BEING LAND FILLED
02:52:45.822 --> 02:52:46.989
OR IF THEY GO OVERSEAS SOMETIMES
02:52:47.056 --> 02:52:48.357
ARE BEING BURNED.
02:52:48.424 --> 02:52:49.592
AND A LOT OF TIMES THEY END UP
02:52:49.659 --> 02:52:50.626
IN THE OCEAN AND WHEN DOES IT
02:52:50.693 --> 02:52:52.161
END ENDS WHEN WE STOP PULLING
02:52:52.228 --> 02:52:53.296
WELLS OUT OF THE OCEAN.
02:52:53.362 --> 02:52:54.263
WHO ARE DEAD BECAUSE OUR
02:52:54.330 --> 02:52:55.665
STOMACHS ARE FILLED WITH PLASTIC
02:52:55.732 --> 02:52:58.267
THAT THEY CAN'T DIGEST SO?
02:52:58.334 --> 02:53:00.603
REDUCING THE SOURCE OF ALL OF
02:53:00.670 --> 02:53:01.938
THIS POLLUTION IS GOING TO BE A
02:53:02.004 --> 02:53:03.072
HUGE PART OF THE EQUATION AND
02:53:03.139 --> 02:53:04.173
THIS SEEMS TO ME LIKE LOW
02:53:04.240 --> 02:53:05.441
HANGING FRUIT.
02:53:05.508 --> 02:53:06.175
I THANK YOU FOR BRINGING IT
02:53:06.242 --> 02:53:08.277
FORWARD I DO HAVE ONE QUESTION
02:53:08.344 --> 02:53:09.378
IS YOU HAVE TO ANSWER BUT I
02:53:09.445 --> 02:53:09.879
DON'T KNOW.
02:53:09.946 --> 02:53:11.247
HOW TO THE PACE CONTAINERS
02:53:11.314 --> 02:53:12.582
FIGURE INTO THIS GIVEN THAT
02:53:12.648 --> 02:53:13.850
THERE MIGHT BE SOME SANITARY
02:53:13.916 --> 02:53:15.251
ISSUES SO JUST THINK ABOUT ALL
02:53:15.318 --> 02:53:16.152
THE RANGE OF PRODUCTS AS YOU
02:53:16.219 --> 02:53:17.086
MOVE FORWARD?
02:53:17.153 --> 02:53:18.688
BUT I'M VERY HAPPY TO SUPPORT
02:53:18.755 --> 02:53:20.690
YOUR BILL TODAY.
02:53:20.757 --> 02:53:21.591
AND WITH THAT WOULD YOU LIKE TO
02:53:21.657 --> 02:53:22.291
CLOSE.
02:53:22.358 --> 02:53:24.093
YES THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR FOR
02:53:24.160 --> 02:53:26.095
THE SUPPORT -- AND I'LL JUST DO
02:53:26.162 --> 02:53:27.997
A QUICK ON WE'RE NOT CUTTING TO
02:53:28.064 --> 02:53:28.931
PLEASE BECAUSE NOT IT'S NOT AS
02:53:28.998 --> 02:53:30.867
STANDARD YOU WALK IN EVERY HOTEL
02:53:30.933 --> 02:53:31.434
ROOM YOU DON'T SEC TWO BASE
02:53:31.501 --> 02:53:32.301
THERE.
02:53:32.368 --> 02:53:33.269
AND IT IS A DIFFERENT KIND OF
02:53:33.336 --> 02:53:35.037
POSITIVE A KIND OF ISSUE WITH
02:53:35.104 --> 02:53:36.672
CONTAMINANTS RAPID.
02:53:36.739 --> 02:53:38.007
PROCESS I BELIEVE THAT THIS BILL
02:53:38.074 --> 02:53:40.243
DOES NOT INTEND TO COVER TO PAY
02:53:40.309 --> 02:53:41.210
JUST JUST TO MAKE IT CLEAR TO
02:53:41.277 --> 02:53:42.779
EVERYONE BUT I DO APPRECIATE THE
02:53:42.845 --> 02:53:44.380
QUESTION BECAUSE THOSE ARE THE
02:53:44.447 --> 02:53:45.715
KINDS OF QUESTIONS THAT COME UP
02:53:45.782 --> 02:53:46.549
THAT WE TALK ABOUT WITH THE
02:53:46.616 --> 02:53:47.416
INDUSTRY.
02:53:47.483 --> 02:53:48.718
ARE THOSE DETAILS BECAUSE THE
02:53:48.785 --> 02:53:50.620
THE DEVIL'S IN THE DETAILS WHEN
02:53:50.686 --> 02:53:52.121
IT COMES TO A BILL LIKE THIS IS
02:53:52.188 --> 02:53:52.622
GOOD IMPACT SO MANY.
02:53:52.688 --> 02:53:54.390
HOTEL ROOMS AND HOTELS THAT WANT
02:53:54.457 --> 02:53:55.725
TO DO THE RIGHT THING THE
02:53:55.792 --> 02:53:57.026
INDUSTRY HAS PROVEN THAT YOU'VE
02:53:57.093 --> 02:53:58.561
SEEN IT WITH THE BUT THE TOWEL
02:53:58.628 --> 02:54:00.296
ON THE BED SHE CLEANING WHEN
02:54:00.363 --> 02:54:02.365
THEY HAVE SIGNS ALL BUT IT SEEMS
02:54:02.431 --> 02:54:02.999
THE MONEY IT'S ALSO WRITING TO
02:54:03.065 --> 02:54:03.900
DO.
02:54:03.966 --> 02:54:05.067
THIS IS AN EXAMPLE OF SOMETHING
02:54:05.134 --> 02:54:05.935
THAT WILL SAVE INDUSTRY MONEY
02:54:06.002 --> 02:54:06.736
AND IT'S ALSO THE RIGHT THING TO
02:54:06.803 --> 02:54:09.338
DO AND SO I REALLY BELIEVE THAT
02:54:09.405 --> 02:54:10.873
WE'RE GONNA BECAUSE OF THE
02:54:10.940 --> 02:54:11.507
WILLINGNESS OF THE INDUSTRY TO
02:54:11.574 --> 02:54:12.475
WORK WITH US.
02:54:12.542 --> 02:54:14.010
THAT WE'RE GOING TO FIND UP OF
02:54:14.076 --> 02:54:15.011
PUT COMPROMISED POSITIONS OF
02:54:15.077 --> 02:54:15.678
YOU'VE BEEN WORKING REALLY WELL
02:54:15.745 --> 02:54:17.280
TOGETHER ALREADY AND I'M VERY
02:54:17.346 --> 02:54:18.614
GRATEFUL TO THE CHAIR VERY
02:54:18.681 --> 02:54:20.850
GRATEFUL AS WELL A TO SUMMER
02:54:20.917 --> 02:54:22.618
STONE -- FOR HAVING A SELECT
02:54:22.685 --> 02:54:23.352
COMMITTEE THAT REALLY SPREAD
02:54:23.419 --> 02:54:24.987
THIS IDEA HAS WITHOUT A
02:54:25.054 --> 02:54:25.788
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR MY BOAT.
02:54:25.855 --> 02:54:26.622
AND IF YOU REALLY WANT TO BORROW
02:54:26.689 --> 02:54:35.198
THE SHAMPOO YOU CAN BRING YOUR
02:54:35.264 --> 02:54:36.933
OWN BOTTLE.
02:54:36.999 --> 02:54:38.734
OKAY WITH THAT WE HAVE A WE NEED
02:54:38.801 --> 02:54:41.370
A MOTION A SECOND.
02:54:41.437 --> 02:54:42.238
OKAY.
02:54:42.305 --> 02:54:43.940
OUR CAN I MAKE.
02:54:44.006 --> 02:54:46.042
A MOVE IT WE HAVE A SECOND.
02:54:46.108 --> 02:54:47.543
OKAY ABOVE IT AND ALSO I THINK
02:54:47.610 --> 02:54:48.978
THAT.
02:54:49.045 --> 02:54:49.579
WITH ACT MAY HAVE A ROLL CALL
02:54:49.645 --> 02:54:51.314
PLEASE.
02:54:51.380 --> 02:54:52.748
ITEM EIGHTEEN A. B. ELEVEN SIXTY
02:54:52.815 --> 02:54:53.416
TWO BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER KALRA THE
02:54:53.482 --> 02:54:54.450
MOTION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED AND
02:54:54.517 --> 02:54:55.551
REFER TO JUDICIARY COMMITTEE.
02:54:55.618 --> 02:54:57.353
MEMBERS FRIEDMAN AYE FRIEDMAN
02:54:57.420 --> 02:54:57.954
AYE FLORA.
02:54:58.020 --> 02:54:59.222
FLORA NO CHAU.
02:54:59.288 --> 02:55:00.756
EGGMAN GARCIA LIMON.
02:55:00.823 --> 02:55:02.358
MATHIS.
02:55:02.425 --> 02:55:04.961
NO MATHIS NO MCCARTY.
02:55:05.027 --> 02:55:06.429
MELENDEZ.
02:55:06.495 --> 02:55:09.732
MELENDEZ NUMBER THREE TREE STONE.
02:55:09.799 --> 02:55:12.001
STONE. NINE TWO THREE TWO THREE
02:55:12.068 --> 02:55:13.669
WILL BE THE ROLE OF AN THANK YOU
02:55:13.736 --> 02:55:14.637
VERY MUCH.
02:55:14.704 --> 02:55:15.238
NEXT WE HAVE ASSEMBLY MEMBER
02:55:15.304 --> 02:55:18.007
BURKE WITH A. B..
02:55:18.074 --> 02:55:19.675
FOURTEEN EIGHTY EIGHT THIS BURKE
02:55:19.742 --> 02:55:20.209
YOU MAY BE SEATED WHENEVER
02:55:20.276 --> 02:55:24.513
YOU'RE READY.
02:55:24.580 --> 02:55:26.115
THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS.
02:55:26.182 --> 02:55:27.350
THANK YOU ALTHOUGH NOT REFLECTED
02:55:27.416 --> 02:55:28.751
IN THE ANALYSIS I WOULD LIKE TO
02:55:28.818 --> 02:55:29.852
BEGIN BY ACCEPTING THE COMMITTEE
02:55:29.919 --> 02:55:31.621
AMENDMENTS THAT WOULD REQUIRE RE
02:55:31.687 --> 02:55:33.222
CLEAN OR IS TO REPORT TO CAL
02:55:33.289 --> 02:55:34.790
RECYCLE ON THE TOTAL NET AMOUNT
02:55:34.857 --> 02:55:35.725
OF RECYCLED MATERIAL THEY
02:55:35.791 --> 02:55:37.260
PRODUCE AND THE AMOUNT OF FOOD
02:55:37.326 --> 02:55:39.128
GRADE MATERIAL THEY PRODUCE --
02:55:39.195 --> 02:55:40.263
THE PROPOSED DEFINITION APOLLO
02:55:40.329 --> 02:55:41.764
GREAT WILL BE REMOVED I WANNA
02:55:41.831 --> 02:55:42.832
MAKE SURE EVERYONE HERE IS THAT
02:55:42.899 --> 02:55:44.500
THE PROPOSED DEFINITION OF OUR
02:55:44.567 --> 02:55:45.968
GREAT WILL ALSO BE REMOVED.
02:55:46.035 --> 02:55:47.403
AB FOURTEEN EIGHTY EIGHT
02:55:47.470 --> 02:55:48.638
REQUIRES CALORIE CYCLE TO
02:55:48.704 --> 02:55:50.239
STANDARDIZE AN EXISTING FORM
02:55:50.306 --> 02:55:51.741
USED TO COLLECT DATA ON THE
02:55:51.807 --> 02:55:53.342
AMOUNT OF VIRGIN PLASTIC IN POST
02:55:53.409 --> 02:55:54.543
CONSUMER RECYCLED PLASTIC USED
02:55:54.610 --> 02:55:55.978
BY MANUFACTURERS THE CURRENT
02:55:56.045 --> 02:55:57.680
CARRIED CYCLE REPORT DOES NOT
02:55:57.747 --> 02:55:58.447
SPECIFY.
02:55:58.514 --> 02:55:59.949
WHAT TYPE OF METRIC THEY WANTED
02:56:00.016 --> 02:56:02.018
MANUFACTURES USE WHEN REPORTING
02:56:02.084 --> 02:56:02.551
AND AS A RESULT THE DATA
02:56:02.618 --> 02:56:03.319
REPORTED?
02:56:03.386 --> 02:56:04.720
CAME IN PERCENTAGES POUNDS
02:56:04.787 --> 02:56:05.922
KILOGRAMS AND A NUMBER OF
02:56:05.988 --> 02:56:07.356
BOTTLES USED AS A RESULT THE
02:56:07.423 --> 02:56:08.624
INFORMATION DOES NOT ACCOMPLISH
02:56:08.691 --> 02:56:09.458
THE GOAL OF EFFECTIVELY
02:56:09.525 --> 02:56:11.160
IDENTIFYING THE AMOUNT OF VIRGIN
02:56:11.227 --> 02:56:12.762
PLASTIC AND RECYCLE PLASTIC USED.
02:56:12.828 --> 02:56:14.230
IN PLASTIC BEVERAGE CONTAINERS
02:56:14.297 --> 02:56:15.631
FROM THE PREVIOUS YEAR AS
02:56:15.698 --> 02:56:17.433
OPPOSED TO BE AMENDED THIS BILL
02:56:17.500 --> 02:56:19.669
WILL ALSO REQUIRE CLIMBERS TO
02:56:19.735 --> 02:56:21.570
REPORT DATA I'M RECYCLE MATERIAL
02:56:21.637 --> 02:56:21.871
INCLUDING.
02:56:21.938 --> 02:56:23.506
GRADE MATERIAL THEY PRODUCE IN
02:56:23.572 --> 02:56:25.041
THE PREVIOUS CALENDAR YEAR THE
02:56:25.107 --> 02:56:26.309
GOAL IS TO SET UP AN ANNUAL
02:56:26.375 --> 02:56:28.210
SNAPSHOT OF THE FOOD GRADE PELA
02:56:28.277 --> 02:56:29.211
TIES MATERIAL THAT IS BEING
02:56:29.278 --> 02:56:30.680
PRODUCED IN.
02:56:30.746 --> 02:56:31.914
THE STATE TO SEE IF THEY CAN
02:56:31.981 --> 02:56:33.282
SUPPLY THE NECESSARY FEEDSTOCK
02:56:33.349 --> 02:56:34.116
FOR THE VARIOUS PROPOSED MINIMUM
02:56:34.183 --> 02:56:35.451
CONTENT LEVELS FOR BEVERAGE
02:56:35.518 --> 02:56:36.953
BOTTLES UNDER THE C. R. V.
02:56:37.019 --> 02:56:37.820
PROGRAM.
02:56:37.887 --> 02:56:39.388
AT NEW POLICIES PROMOTING
02:56:39.455 --> 02:56:41.223
RECYCLE CONTENT ARE CONSIDERED
02:56:41.290 --> 02:56:41.991
IT IS IMPORTANT FOR THE
02:56:42.058 --> 02:56:43.359
LEGISLATURE AND CAL RECYCLE TO
02:56:43.426 --> 02:56:44.660
NOT ONLY KNOW HOW MUCH RECYCLED
02:56:44.727 --> 02:56:46.195
MATERIAL IS IN THE STATE BUT
02:56:46.262 --> 02:56:47.964
ALSO HAVE USEFUL STANDARDIZED
02:56:48.030 --> 02:56:49.398
INFORMATION TO BETTER INFORM THE
02:56:49.465 --> 02:56:50.933
DECISION MAKING PROCESS.
02:56:51.000 --> 02:56:52.802
WITH ME TODAY IN SUPPORT IS A
02:56:52.868 --> 02:56:54.670
FEDERICA MCGREEVEY MIKEY WITH
02:56:54.737 --> 02:56:55.671
THE AMERICAN BEVERAGE
02:56:55.738 --> 02:57:00.576
ASSOCIATION I RESPECTFULLY
02:57:00.643 --> 02:57:01.344
REQUEST AN ITEM.
02:57:01.410 --> 02:57:02.912
GOOD AFTERNOON MADAM CHAIR AND
02:57:02.979 --> 02:57:04.180
MEMBERS -- PATRICK MAGEE ON
02:57:04.246 --> 02:57:05.815
BEHALF ABA AND JUST CONSIDERING
02:57:05.881 --> 02:57:07.216
YOUR TIME IN THE LIFT THE THINGS
02:57:07.283 --> 02:57:09.318
YOU HAVE.
02:57:09.385 --> 02:57:11.087
DO YOU KNOW WHAT.
02:57:11.153 --> 02:57:12.655
IT IS SUPPORT [inaudible]
02:57:12.722 --> 02:57:13.856
YEAH.
02:57:13.923 --> 02:57:14.490
THANK YOU IS THERE ANYONE ELSE
02:57:14.557 --> 02:57:16.125
WHO WISHES TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT
02:57:16.192 --> 02:57:18.561
OF THE BILL.
02:57:18.627 --> 02:57:20.129
IS THERE ANYBODY WHO WISHES TO
02:57:20.196 --> 02:57:20.696
TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION TO THE
02:57:20.763 --> 02:57:23.833
BILL.
02:57:23.899 --> 02:57:25.434
SIGNAL BRING IT TO THE COMMITTEE
02:57:25.501 --> 02:57:27.336
DOES ANYBODY HAVE ANY COMMENTS
02:57:27.403 --> 02:57:27.636
[inaudible]
02:57:27.703 --> 02:57:29.238
OKAY.
02:57:29.305 --> 02:57:30.840
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE I
02:57:30.906 --> 02:57:31.974
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST AN AYE VOTE
02:57:32.041 --> 02:57:33.042
THANK YOU AND I I REALLY
02:57:33.109 --> 02:57:34.076
APPRECIATE YOUR WORKING WITH OUR
02:57:34.143 --> 02:57:35.244
COMMITTEE ON THE AMENDMENTS AND
02:57:35.311 --> 02:57:36.145
I'M HAPPY TO SUPPORT THE BILL
02:57:36.212 --> 02:57:37.713
TODAY THANK YOU VERY THOUGHT TO
02:57:37.780 --> 02:57:38.848
WE HAVE A MOTION.
02:57:38.914 --> 02:57:39.782
MOVED AND SECONDED WE HAVE A
02:57:39.849 --> 02:57:41.050
MOTION AND A SECOND CLEAVER ALL
02:57:41.117 --> 02:57:42.918
CALL PLEASE THANKS I DON'T
02:57:42.985 --> 02:57:44.086
TWENTY FIVE A. B. FOURTEEN
02:57:44.153 --> 02:57:45.021
EIGHTY AYE BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER
02:57:45.087 --> 02:57:46.522
BURKE THE MOTIONS TO PASS AS
02:57:46.589 --> 02:57:47.523
AMENDED AND REFER TO
02:57:47.590 --> 02:57:49.025
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE.
02:57:49.091 --> 02:57:51.360
MEMBERS FRIEDMAN HI FRIEDMAN I
02:57:51.427 --> 02:57:52.261
FLORA.
02:57:52.328 --> 02:57:53.796
LARA AYE CHAU.
02:57:53.863 --> 02:57:56.599
EGGMAN GARCIA LIMóN.
02:57:56.665 --> 02:57:57.833
MATHIS.
02:57:57.900 --> 02:58:00.036
MATHIS I MCCARTY MELENDEZ
02:58:00.102 --> 02:58:04.040
MELENDEZ AYE MURATSUCHI STONE.
02:58:04.106 --> 02:58:07.143
STONE I FIVE ZERO FIVE ZERO
02:58:07.209 --> 02:58:08.911
THANK YOU VERY MUCH -- NEXT WE
02:58:08.978 --> 02:58:24.226
HAVE MISTER O'DONNELL WITH.
02:58:24.293 --> 02:58:26.095
ELEVEN NINETY FIVE WEBER SECOND
02:58:26.162 --> 02:58:26.996
FULL PLEASE PLEASE CONTINUE.
02:58:27.063 --> 02:58:28.097
THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR AND
02:58:28.164 --> 02:58:29.665
COMMITTEE MEMBERS I'D LIKE TO
02:58:29.732 --> 02:58:30.599
START OFF BY ACCEPTING THE
02:58:30.666 --> 02:58:31.767
COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS AND THANK
02:58:31.834 --> 02:58:32.835
THE CHAIR AND THE STAFF FOR
02:58:32.902 --> 02:58:34.236
THEIR WORK ON THE BILL.
02:58:34.303 --> 02:58:36.572
I AM PLEASED TO PRESENT AT
02:58:36.639 --> 02:58:37.173
ELEVEN NINETY FIVE WHICH CARS
02:58:37.239 --> 02:58:38.441
CARP TO ALLOW OIL AND GAS
02:58:38.507 --> 02:58:40.176
COMPANIES TO GENERATE AN
02:58:40.242 --> 02:58:41.544
INNOVATIVE PRODUCTION METHOD
02:58:41.610 --> 02:58:42.578
CREDIT.
02:58:42.645 --> 02:58:43.846
UNDER THE LOW CARBON FUEL
02:58:43.913 --> 02:58:45.581
STANDARD FOR USING RENEWABLE
02:58:45.648 --> 02:58:47.783
NATURAL GAS TO DISPLACE THEIR
02:58:47.850 --> 02:58:49.185
EXISTING USE OF TRADITIONAL.
02:58:49.251 --> 02:58:50.519
NATURAL GAS.
02:58:50.586 --> 02:58:52.088
THE LOW CARBON FUEL STANDARD OR
02:58:52.154 --> 02:58:54.557
ELSE CFS IS PRIMARILY DESIGNED
02:58:54.623 --> 02:58:55.991
TO ENCOURAGE THE USE OF CLEAN.
02:58:56.058 --> 02:58:57.960
LOW CARBON TRANSPORTATION FUELS
02:58:58.027 --> 02:58:59.128
IN CALIFORNIA.
02:58:59.195 --> 02:59:00.663
THIS PROGRAM IS ALSO INTENDED TO
02:59:00.729 --> 02:59:02.064
REDUCE EMISSIONS DURING THE
02:59:02.131 --> 02:59:04.133
ACTUAL PROCESS OF PRODUCING
02:59:04.200 --> 02:59:05.534
TRANSPORTATION FUELS.
02:59:05.601 --> 02:59:07.203
AS SUCH THE PROGRAM ALLOWS OIL
02:59:07.269 --> 02:59:09.171
REFINING OPERATIONS TO GENERATE%
02:59:09.238 --> 02:59:11.407
LC OF AS CREDITS WHEN SWITCHING
02:59:11.474 --> 02:59:13.209
FROM FOR TRADITIONAL NATURAL GAS
02:59:13.275 --> 02:59:14.910
TO RENEWABLE NATURAL GAS.
02:59:14.977 --> 02:59:16.712
AB ELEVEN NINETY FIVE SEEKS TO
02:59:16.779 --> 02:59:17.613
EXPAND THIS OPTION TO OIL AND
02:59:17.680 --> 02:59:19.648
GAS PRODUCERS GIVEN THE LARGE
02:59:19.715 --> 02:59:21.083
AMOUNT OF NATURAL GAS REQUIRED
02:59:21.150 --> 02:59:24.420
BY ENHANCED OIL RECOVERY METHODS.
02:59:24.487 --> 02:59:25.754
THIS MAKES THE PROCESS LESS
02:59:25.821 --> 02:59:26.856
CARBON INTENSIVE WHICH IS
02:59:26.922 --> 02:59:28.491
CONSISTENT WITH THE GOALS OF THE
02:59:28.557 --> 02:59:29.758
LC OF US.
02:59:29.825 --> 02:59:30.960
THIS BILL ALSO ASSIST IN
02:59:31.026 --> 02:59:32.294
CREATING ADDITIONAL BENEFICIAL
02:59:32.361 --> 02:59:35.231
USES FOR RENEWABLE NATURAL GAS.
02:59:35.297 --> 02:59:36.665
THE ABSENCE OF A HAVE A HEALTHY
02:59:36.732 --> 02:59:38.200
RENEWABLE GAS MARKET HAS MADE IT
02:59:38.267 --> 02:59:41.137
DIFFICULT TO FIND INVESTMENT. TO
02:59:41.203 --> 02:59:42.037
CAPTURE THE LARGE AMOUNT OF
02:59:42.104 --> 02:59:43.772
METHANE DERIVED FROM ORGANIC
02:59:43.839 --> 02:59:45.908
WASTE AS REMINDER METHANE IS A
02:59:45.975 --> 02:59:48.144
POTENT GLOBAL WARMING GAS THAT
02:59:48.210 --> 02:59:49.879
IS THIRTY FOUR TIMES THIRTY FOUR
02:59:49.945 --> 02:59:50.546
TIMES.
02:59:50.613 --> 02:59:51.981
MORE POWERFUL THAN CARBON
02:59:52.047 --> 02:59:53.616
DIOXIDE AT TRAPPING THE EARNERS
02:59:53.682 --> 02:59:55.117
HEAT OVER A ONE HUNDRED YEAR
02:59:55.184 --> 02:59:55.851
PERIOD.
02:59:55.918 --> 02:59:57.186
WELL THIS BILL REPRESENTS A
02:59:57.253 --> 02:59:58.888
MODEST USE OF RENEWABLE NATURAL
02:59:58.954 --> 03:00:00.756
GAS IT IS IMPERATIVE THAT THE
03:00:00.823 --> 03:00:03.292
STATE FINDS ADDITIONAL END USERS
03:00:03.359 --> 03:00:04.860
FOR WHAT FOR FOR WHATEVER IS
03:00:04.927 --> 03:00:05.794
POSSIBLE.
03:00:05.861 --> 03:00:07.863
AB ELEVEN NINETY FIVE ASSISTS IN
03:00:07.930 --> 03:00:09.532
CREATING A MARKET FOR MATH THING
03:00:09.598 --> 03:00:11.000
THAT WOULD OTHERWISE DISSIPATE
03:00:11.066 --> 03:00:13.302
INTO THE ATMOSPHERE WHILE ALSO
03:00:13.369 --> 03:00:15.271
REDUCING THE GHQ FOOT PRINT OF
03:00:15.337 --> 03:00:17.106
ALL OIL AND GAS OPERATIONS
03:00:17.173 --> 03:00:17.840
INTERSTATE.
03:00:17.907 --> 03:00:20.176
IN HERE TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT IS
03:00:20.242 --> 03:00:23.612
THE CALIFORNIA.
03:00:23.679 --> 03:00:25.814
STATE PIPE TRADES COUNCIL.
03:00:25.881 --> 03:00:27.149
MADAM CHAIRMAN MEMBERS.
03:00:27.216 --> 03:00:27.750
SCOTT WHICH ON BEHALF OF THE
03:00:27.816 --> 03:00:28.284
CALIFORNIA STATE PATRIOTS
03:00:28.350 --> 03:00:29.351
COUNCIL ALSO ON BEHALF OF THE
03:00:29.418 --> 03:00:30.853
CALIFORNIA COALITION OF UTILITY
03:00:30.920 --> 03:00:31.554
EMPLOYEES.
03:00:31.620 --> 03:00:32.855
IN THE STATUS OF SEASON
03:00:32.922 --> 03:00:35.624
ELECTRICAL WORKERS -- WE'RE HERE
03:00:35.691 --> 03:00:36.192
TO URGE YOUR SUPPORT OF THIS
03:00:36.258 --> 03:00:38.894
BILL -- IT TODAY YOU KNOW MY
03:00:38.961 --> 03:00:43.132
MEMBERS -- BOTH WORK AT MANY OF
03:00:43.199 --> 03:00:43.832
THESE.
03:00:43.899 --> 03:00:46.001
OIL REFINERIES AND IN THE IN THE
03:00:46.068 --> 03:00:47.636
OIL PATCH.
03:00:47.703 --> 03:00:50.639
AS WELL AS IN THIS NEW EMERGING
03:00:50.706 --> 03:00:54.043
INDUSTRY OF BIO GAS AND WE
03:00:54.109 --> 03:00:55.644
BELIEVE THIS IS -- COMMONSENSE
03:00:55.711 --> 03:00:56.745
MEASURE.
03:00:56.812 --> 03:01:00.216
CURRENTLY -- INDUSTRIAL USERS --
03:01:00.282 --> 03:01:02.184
YOU KNOW -- OIL AND GAS
03:01:02.251 --> 03:01:03.485
PRODUCERS.
03:01:03.552 --> 03:01:06.956
IF THEY PURCHASE SOLAR POWER.
03:01:07.022 --> 03:01:09.458
THEY CAN GET OFFSETS FOR THE
03:01:09.525 --> 03:01:10.859
PURCHASE OF THAT SOLAR POWER
03:01:10.926 --> 03:01:12.695
REGARDLESS OF OF WHERE THAT
03:01:12.761 --> 03:01:14.063
POWER IS GENERATED AND PUT ON TO
03:01:14.129 --> 03:01:16.165
THE GRID.
03:01:16.232 --> 03:01:18.634
BUT IN IN ORDER TO GET CREDIT
03:01:18.701 --> 03:01:20.135
FOR THE BIO GAS.
03:01:20.202 --> 03:01:22.171
IT HAVE TO BE PIPED DIRECTLY TO
03:01:22.238 --> 03:01:23.539
THE FACILITY.
03:01:23.606 --> 03:01:24.907
WE WE SIMPLY BELIEVE THE
03:01:24.974 --> 03:01:27.476
MOLECULES AND ELECTRONS IN THIS
03:01:27.543 --> 03:01:29.011
INSTANCE SHOULD BOTH.
03:01:29.078 --> 03:01:30.246
BE TREATED EQUALLY.
03:01:30.312 --> 03:01:31.880
WE THINK THAT THIS WAS A HUGE
03:01:31.947 --> 03:01:33.549
BENEFIT TO THE ENVIRONMENT TO
03:01:33.616 --> 03:01:35.084
THEIR BURGEONING BIO GAS
03:01:35.150 --> 03:01:39.154
INDUSTRY AND TO THE FOLKS.
03:01:39.221 --> 03:01:41.056
MY MEMBERS WHO WORK IN LABOR
03:01:41.123 --> 03:01:43.025
EVERY DAY IN THE OIL PATCH SO
03:01:43.092 --> 03:01:45.394
FOR ALL THOSE REASONS WE WOULD --
03:01:45.461 --> 03:01:48.330
DRIVE OUT THANK YOU.
03:01:48.397 --> 03:01:49.965
MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS THE PAY US
03:01:50.032 --> 03:01:51.166
OVER THE CALIFORNIA BEEN
03:01:51.233 --> 03:01:52.568
PATROLMEN'S ASSOCIATION.
03:01:52.635 --> 03:01:54.136
SOME MODEST BILL IT JUST GIVES
03:01:54.203 --> 03:01:56.338
US ANOTHER INCENTIVE TO BUILD TO
03:01:56.405 --> 03:01:57.840
PRODUCE OIL AND GAS.
03:01:57.906 --> 03:01:59.908
IN A WAY THAT REDUCES RGH TWO
03:01:59.975 --> 03:02:02.077
FOOT PRINT -- AGAIN WE THINK
03:02:02.144 --> 03:02:03.279
IT'S VERY MODEST THERE'S NOTHING
03:02:03.345 --> 03:02:04.747
IN THE BILL.
03:02:04.813 --> 03:02:07.082
THAT IS GOOD NO -- BECAUSE US TO
03:02:07.149 --> 03:02:09.351
TRY TO PRODUCE MORE GASOLINE OR
03:02:09.418 --> 03:02:11.020
CRUDE OIL FROM CALIFORNIA THAT'S
03:02:11.086 --> 03:02:12.788
SIMPLY A DEMAND QUESTION THIS
03:02:12.855 --> 03:02:14.256
HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH THIS THIS
03:02:14.323 --> 03:02:15.524
JUST SAYS AS LONG AS WE'RE
03:02:15.591 --> 03:02:16.925
PRODUCING.
03:02:16.992 --> 03:02:19.328
OIL IN CALIFORNIA WE CAN AVAIL
03:02:19.395 --> 03:02:20.863
OURSELVES TO THIS INCENTIVE TO
03:02:20.929 --> 03:02:22.398
DO SO IN A MORE ENVIRONMENTALLY
03:02:22.464 --> 03:02:23.866
RESPONSIBLE MANNER.
03:02:23.932 --> 03:02:25.534
I JUST WANT ONCE AGAIN REALLY
03:02:25.601 --> 03:02:26.568
QUICKLY THE BENEFITS OF METHANE
03:02:26.635 --> 03:02:27.836
ARE HUGE.
03:02:27.903 --> 03:02:29.938
IF WE CAN USE MECHANIC METHANE
03:02:30.005 --> 03:02:31.573
STREAM INSTEAD OF USING A FOSSIL
03:02:31.640 --> 03:02:34.510
FUEL BASED NATURAL GAS TO TO
03:02:34.576 --> 03:02:36.378
HEAT OUR WATER TO MAKE THIS TEAM
03:02:36.445 --> 03:02:37.246
TO DO THE IN FINANCE OR RECOVERY.
03:02:37.313 --> 03:02:38.847
I THINK THAT'S A BIG BENEFIT
03:02:38.914 --> 03:02:40.182
RECENTLY -- WE'VE TAKEN
03:02:40.249 --> 03:02:41.650
AMENDMENTS SUCH AS BY THE
03:02:41.717 --> 03:02:43.852
COMMITTEE TO ENSURE THAT THAT
03:02:43.919 --> 03:02:45.788
AVENUE WILL NATURAL GAS COME
03:02:45.854 --> 03:02:47.489
FROM CALIFORNIA SOURCES.
03:02:47.556 --> 03:02:48.557
THUS THE METHANE REDUCTION IS IN
03:02:48.624 --> 03:02:51.260
CALIFORNIA FOR THOSE OF YOU WITH
03:02:51.327 --> 03:02:52.795
A METHANE SOURCES BE A DAIRY
03:02:52.861 --> 03:02:55.597
ORGANIC -- LANDFILL WASTE IN
03:02:55.664 --> 03:02:56.265
YOUR DISTRICT THIS IS SOMETHING
03:02:56.332 --> 03:03:02.171
THAT'S GOOD FOR YOUR DISTRICTS
03:03:02.237 --> 03:03:02.771
SO WE APPRECIATE YOUR SUPPORT
03:03:02.838 --> 03:03:04.707
THANK YOU.
03:03:04.773 --> 03:03:05.841
GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIR FRIEDMAN
03:03:05.908 --> 03:03:06.709
MEMBERS NEED TO COOK FOR THE
03:03:06.775 --> 03:03:07.343
COALITION FOR RENEWABLE NATURAL
03:03:07.409 --> 03:03:08.010
GAS WE REPRESENT OVER A HUNDRED
03:03:08.077 --> 03:03:09.144
AND EIGHTY MEMBERS -- FROM EVERY
03:03:09.211 --> 03:03:10.112
SECTOR OF THE R. G. INDUSTRY
03:03:10.179 --> 03:03:11.280
INCLUDING ORGANIZED LABOR
03:03:11.347 --> 03:03:13.515
UTILITIES AND PRODUCERS OF OVER
03:03:13.582 --> 03:03:15.150
90% OF THE ARE IN G. PRODUCED IN
03:03:15.217 --> 03:03:16.318
NORTH AMERICA.
03:03:16.385 --> 03:03:17.786
WE SUPPORT ALL SUSTAINABLE AND
03:03:17.853 --> 03:03:19.154
USES OF OUR ENERGY AND THAT
03:03:19.221 --> 03:03:20.856
INCLUDES WHEN IT IS USED AS A
03:03:20.923 --> 03:03:22.157
PROCESS YOU'LL TO LOWER THE
03:03:22.224 --> 03:03:23.926
CARBON INTENSITY OF OTHER FUELS
03:03:23.992 --> 03:03:24.893
OF IN PROGRAMS LIKE THE LOW
03:03:24.960 --> 03:03:26.795
CARBON FUEL STANDARD.
03:03:26.862 --> 03:03:28.163
AND WE THINK THIS IS A REALLY --
03:03:28.230 --> 03:03:30.366
MODEST AND APPROPRIATE BILL AND
03:03:30.432 --> 03:03:31.500
WE RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE
03:03:31.567 --> 03:03:35.204
VOTE AND FOR AB ELEVEN NINETY
03:03:35.270 --> 03:03:36.305
FIVE AS AMENDED THANK YOU.
03:03:36.372 --> 03:03:36.939
THANK YOU IS THERE ANYONE ELSE
03:03:37.005 --> 03:03:38.073
WISHING TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF
03:03:38.140 --> 03:03:42.010
THIS BILL.
03:03:42.077 --> 03:03:43.045
GOOD AFTERNOON MADAM CHAIR
03:03:43.112 --> 03:03:44.179
MEMBERS P. ANTHONY THOMAS RIP IN
03:03:44.246 --> 03:03:45.781
THE CALIFORNIAN GAS PRODUCERS
03:03:45.848 --> 03:03:47.249
ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT OF THE
03:03:47.316 --> 03:03:51.687
BILL.
03:03:51.754 --> 03:03:53.055
NATALIE MAX ON BEHALF OF SEE OUR
03:03:53.122 --> 03:03:54.390
IN OUR ENVIRONMENTAL
03:03:54.456 --> 03:03:54.923
ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES AND
03:03:54.990 --> 03:03:58.527
SUPPORT.
03:03:58.594 --> 03:04:00.129
THANK YOU IS THERE ANYONE
03:04:00.195 --> 03:04:00.729
WISHING TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION
03:04:00.796 --> 03:04:06.301
TO THE BILL.
03:04:06.368 --> 03:04:08.003
HI LAUREN COLEMAN BE ALPHA
03:04:08.070 --> 03:04:09.104
SIERRA CLUB CALIFORNIA.
03:04:09.171 --> 03:04:12.141
CIRCLE CALIFORNIA POSES AB ONE
03:04:12.207 --> 03:04:12.741
ONE NINE FIVE THIS BILL WOULD
03:04:12.808 --> 03:04:13.909
OPEN UP THE NATURAL GAS PIPELINE
03:04:13.976 --> 03:04:15.210
INFRASTRUCTURE TO RENEWABLE
03:04:15.277 --> 03:04:17.212
NATURAL GAS ND BY DOING SO
03:04:17.279 --> 03:04:18.514
WOULD UNDERMINE CALIFORNIA'S
03:04:18.580 --> 03:04:21.216
PROGRESS ON CLEAN ENERGY POLICY.
03:04:21.283 --> 03:04:23.085
AND DELAY OUR SHIFT TO CLEAN
03:04:23.152 --> 03:04:24.720
RENEWABLE ENERGY SOLUTIONS.
03:04:24.787 --> 03:04:26.155
IN ADDITION TO THE INFORMATION
03:04:26.221 --> 03:04:27.089
THAT WE PUT FORWARD IN OUR
03:04:27.156 --> 03:04:28.724
OPPOSITION LETTER THIS BILL
03:04:28.791 --> 03:04:30.225
WOULD ALSO UNDER CUT THE NON
03:04:30.292 --> 03:04:31.927
COMBUSTION CLEAN TECHNOLOGIES
03:04:31.994 --> 03:04:33.562
THAT SOME FIELDS ARE DEVELOPING.
03:04:33.629 --> 03:04:35.097
SUCH AS USING SOLAR STEAM TO
03:04:35.164 --> 03:04:37.032
EXTRACT AND NOT ONLY THAT BUT IT
03:04:37.099 --> 03:04:38.000
WOULD END UP PRESERVING
03:04:38.066 --> 03:04:39.468
COMBUSTION TECHNOLOGY AND
03:04:39.535 --> 03:04:41.003
DISCOURAGE THE TRANSITION TO NON
03:04:41.069 --> 03:04:42.070
COMBUSTION TACK.
03:04:42.137 --> 03:04:43.505
IN AREAS THAT NEED THAT
03:04:43.572 --> 03:04:45.407
TRANSITION. FOR EXAMPLE MANY
03:04:45.474 --> 03:04:47.242
FIELDS IN CALIFORNIA ESPECIALLY
03:04:47.309 --> 03:04:48.744
IN THE CENTRAL VALLEY RELY ON
03:04:48.811 --> 03:04:50.179
USING THERMAL ENHANCEMENT
03:04:50.245 --> 03:04:51.747
RECOVERY HE'S AREAS COULD
03:04:51.814 --> 03:04:52.848
GREATLY BENEFIT FROM NON
03:04:52.915 --> 03:04:54.116
COMBUSTION TECHNOLOGY TO HELP
03:04:54.183 --> 03:04:55.784
MINIMIZE THE ENVIRONMENTAL
03:04:55.851 --> 03:04:58.754
IMPACTS THEIR SUFFERING FROM
03:04:58.821 --> 03:05:00.022
SUCH AS AIR POLLUTION.
03:05:00.088 --> 03:05:01.056
INSTEAD THIS BILL WOULD LOCK
03:05:01.123 --> 03:05:01.857
THOSE AREAS AND RELYING ON DIRTY
03:05:01.924 --> 03:05:03.225
COMBUSTION TECHNOLOGIES.
03:05:03.292 --> 03:05:04.726
THE STATE NEEDS TO WEAN ITSELF
03:05:04.793 --> 03:05:06.462
OFF OF ITS DEPENDENCE ON GAS AND
03:05:06.528 --> 03:05:08.897
THIS BILL WOULD WORK IN
03:05:08.964 --> 03:05:10.532
OPPOSITION TO THAT THANK YOU.
03:05:10.599 --> 03:05:11.200
THANK YOU IS THERE ANYONE ELSE
03:05:11.266 --> 03:05:13.368
WISHING TO TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION
03:05:13.435 --> 03:05:15.103
TO THE BILL.
03:05:15.170 --> 03:05:15.671
SEEING NONE I BRING TO THE
03:05:15.737 --> 03:05:17.039
COMMITTEE.
03:05:17.105 --> 03:05:18.907
MISTER MATHIS.
03:05:18.974 --> 03:05:21.043
YOU KNOW I I ALWAYS FIND IT
03:05:21.109 --> 03:05:22.177
INTERESTING SO TALK ABOUT
03:05:22.244 --> 03:05:23.846
WINNING PEOPLE OF A GAS EVEN
03:05:23.912 --> 03:05:25.180
THOUGH WE HAVE ALL THIS NATURAL
03:05:25.247 --> 03:05:26.982
NATURAL GAS OCCURRING IN THE
03:05:27.049 --> 03:05:29.151
ABILITY TO CAPTURE IT AND USE IT
03:05:29.218 --> 03:05:32.287
AND GET IN THE PIPELINE -- YEAH
03:05:32.354 --> 03:05:34.223
I'VE GOT A VERY DISADVANTAGED
03:05:34.289 --> 03:05:37.259
DISTRICT IN WE WE HAVE A AREA
03:05:37.326 --> 03:05:39.261
AND I I WON'T CALL THE THE TOWN
03:05:39.328 --> 03:05:43.232
OUT BY NAME -- BUT THE RESIDENTS
03:05:43.298 --> 03:05:46.235
ACTUALLY HAVE THE OPTION. TO GET
03:05:46.301 --> 03:05:48.136
FREE SOLAR.
03:05:48.203 --> 03:05:49.805
AND SWITCH ALL OF THEIR
03:05:49.872 --> 03:05:53.208
APPLIANCES OVER TO ELECTRIC.
03:05:53.275 --> 03:05:56.411
THEY REFUSED THE FREE OFFER OF
03:05:56.478 --> 03:05:59.014
SOLAR ELECTRIC APPLIANCES.
03:05:59.081 --> 03:06:01.517
BECAUSE THEY PREFER THE ABILITY
03:06:01.583 --> 03:06:04.853
TO USE GAS STOVES.
03:06:04.920 --> 03:06:06.121
AND INSTEAD HAVE BEEN
03:06:06.188 --> 03:06:09.024
ENCOURAGING THE LOCAL AREA -- TO
03:06:09.091 --> 03:06:12.661
TEAM UP WITH OUR GAS COMPANIES
03:06:12.728 --> 03:06:15.664
AND OUR RENEWABLE ENERGY PLANT
03:06:15.731 --> 03:06:17.165
THAT'S ACTUALLY CAPTURING
03:06:17.232 --> 03:06:19.034
METHANE FROM DERRY DIGEST
03:06:19.101 --> 03:06:22.671
STATION -- TO USE THAT NATURAL
03:06:22.738 --> 03:06:25.073
NATURAL GAS -- AS A MATTER.
03:06:25.140 --> 03:06:26.808
ID AND I BELIEVE THIS WOULD
03:06:26.875 --> 03:06:29.511
ACTUALLY LOWER THE COST -- QUITE
03:06:29.578 --> 03:06:31.013
SIGNIFICANTLY.
03:06:31.079 --> 03:06:32.581
OF THAT NATURAL NATURAL GAS AND
03:06:32.648 --> 03:06:34.349
HELP AND MOVE FORWARD TO CREATE
03:06:34.416 --> 03:06:36.919
A MARKET -- FOR THAT MAKE IT
03:06:36.985 --> 03:06:39.221
MORE AFFORDABLE FOR THE MOST
03:06:39.288 --> 03:06:40.789
DISADVANTAGED IN OUR STATE.
03:06:40.856 --> 03:06:42.357
I REALLY APPRECIATE WHAT YOU'RE
03:06:42.424 --> 03:06:44.993
DOING THIS ROAD ON ALL -- TO TO
03:06:45.060 --> 03:06:46.395
DO THIS AND REALLY HELP DRIVE
03:06:46.461 --> 03:06:48.230
DOWN THOSE COST AND MAKE NATURAL
03:06:48.297 --> 03:06:50.265
NATURAL GAS MORE AFFORDABLE ON
03:06:50.332 --> 03:06:51.934
TO THE CALIFORNIA NEEDED THE
03:06:52.000 --> 03:06:53.535
MOST THANK YOU.
03:06:53.602 --> 03:06:55.604
THANK YOU MS EGGMAN.
03:06:55.671 --> 03:06:57.472
THE GAME IS PARTY PRESENTATION
03:06:57.539 --> 03:06:58.507
BUT MY MY ESTIMATE WHAT A LOT OF
03:06:58.574 --> 03:07:00.609
TEARS IN MY DISTRICT IT IT IS.
03:07:00.676 --> 03:07:03.011
ONLY CALIFORNIA NATURAL GAS ONLY
03:07:03.078 --> 03:07:05.480
TO BE RECEIVE THE CREDITS IN
03:07:05.547 --> 03:07:07.816
CALIFORNIA ALL CALIFORNIA.
03:07:07.883 --> 03:07:09.551
ALL CALIFORNIANS ARE. FOR THE
03:07:09.618 --> 03:07:11.320
COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS THAT THE
03:07:11.386 --> 03:07:12.554
THE METHANE HAS TO COME THAT
03:07:12.621 --> 03:07:14.122
DISPLACEMENT HAS TO BE FROM
03:07:14.189 --> 03:07:17.359
CALIFORNIA SO AS TO BE ACCEPTED
03:07:17.426 --> 03:07:20.429
YEAH EXCEPT YEAH THE COUPLE.
03:07:20.495 --> 03:07:20.996
ANY OTHER COMMENTS FROM THE
03:07:21.063 --> 03:07:24.933
COMMITTEE -- I DO THINK WANT TO
03:07:25.000 --> 03:07:26.101
THANK THE AUTHOR FOR WORKING
03:07:26.168 --> 03:07:26.935
WITH US AND ACCEPTING THE
03:07:27.002 --> 03:07:28.604
AMENDMENTS I AM GOING TO SUPPORT
03:07:28.670 --> 03:07:30.672
THE BILL TODAY I WILL SAY THAT I
03:07:30.739 --> 03:07:33.642
DO -- WANT TO JUST PUT OUT THERE
03:07:33.709 --> 03:07:35.677
THAT THE LC ABOUT L. L. C. F. F.
03:07:35.744 --> 03:07:36.545
IS VERY.
03:07:36.612 --> 03:07:37.879
IS A VERY COMPLICATED SET OF
03:07:37.946 --> 03:07:41.216
REGULATIONS AND I DO THINK THAT.
03:07:41.283 --> 03:07:42.250
WE'RE GOING TO HAVE TO MAKE SURE
03:07:42.317 --> 03:07:44.653
THAT THAT THE AIR RESOURCE BOARD --
03:07:44.720 --> 03:07:45.988
CAN REALLY MAKE SURE THAT THIS
03:07:46.054 --> 03:07:47.956
BILL IS WORKABLE AND SUPPORTS
03:07:48.023 --> 03:07:50.192
OUR COMMON OBJECTIVE OF NEW
03:07:50.258 --> 03:07:51.960
NOTHING CAPTURE PROJECTS MY ONE
03:07:52.027 --> 03:07:53.495
CONCERN IS THAT.
03:07:53.562 --> 03:07:55.731
THIS ISN'T WORK SOMEHOW SO THAT
03:07:55.797 --> 03:07:56.965
YOU CAN PURCHASE EXISTING
03:07:57.032 --> 03:07:58.867
PROJECTS SO THAT YOU MOVE THOSE
03:07:58.934 --> 03:08:00.302
CREDITS OVER IT HAS TO IT FOR
03:08:00.369 --> 03:08:02.838
THIS TO WORK AS AS ADVERTISED.
03:08:02.904 --> 03:08:04.773
THESE HAVE TO BE NEW PROJECTS SO
03:08:04.840 --> 03:08:06.041
THAT WE'RE GETTING -- NEW
03:08:06.108 --> 03:08:07.676
REDUCTIONS SO I JUST WANTED TO
03:08:07.743 --> 03:08:08.243
PUT THAT OUT THERE FOR THE
03:08:08.310 --> 03:08:09.578
RECORD THAT THAT'S OUR INTENTION
03:08:09.645 --> 03:08:10.812
AS WE MOVE FORWARD AND I HOPE
03:08:10.879 --> 03:08:12.014
THAT THERE RESOURCE BOARD IS.
03:08:12.080 --> 03:08:13.515
UP TO THE TASK OF BEING ABLE TO
03:08:13.582 --> 03:08:14.650
IMPLEMENT THAT.
03:08:14.716 --> 03:08:17.119
WITH THAT WE DO HAVE A MOTION I
03:08:17.185 --> 03:08:17.352
BELIEVE.
03:08:17.419 --> 03:08:18.353
WE HAVE A SECOND.
03:08:18.420 --> 03:08:21.623
WE HAVE A MOTION A SECOND CAN WE
03:08:21.690 --> 03:08:23.925
HAVE A ROLL CALL PLEASE -- AND I
03:08:23.992 --> 03:08:24.459
DO HAVE A QUESTION SO.
03:08:24.526 --> 03:08:25.927
MY MY ONE QUESTION IS WILL THE
03:08:25.994 --> 03:08:28.063
BILL SUPPORT NEW METHANE CAPTURE
03:08:28.130 --> 03:08:31.366
PROJECTS.
03:08:31.433 --> 03:08:32.934
IS THAT YOUR YOUR COMMITMENT
03:08:33.001 --> 03:08:33.769
RATHER THAN TRYING TO PERCH ON
03:08:33.835 --> 03:08:35.437
TEXTING PRICE SO I MEAN I I
03:08:35.504 --> 03:08:37.639
CAN'T SPEAK TO EVERY PARTICULAR
03:08:37.706 --> 03:08:38.840
TRANSACTION BUT I CAN I CAN'T
03:08:38.907 --> 03:08:40.175
SAY A COUPLE THINGS.
03:08:40.242 --> 03:08:41.209
ONE WE DON'T HAVE AS MUCH
03:08:41.276 --> 03:08:43.178
METHANE CAPTURE IN THE STATE IS
03:08:43.245 --> 03:08:45.380
AS WE THINK WE DO RIGHT AND SO
03:08:45.447 --> 03:08:47.149
AS WITH SAN DIEGO GAS ELECTRIC
03:08:47.215 --> 03:08:48.984
SO CAL GAS IS COMMITMENT TO
03:08:49.051 --> 03:08:50.185
START.
03:08:50.252 --> 03:08:51.820
OFTEN INVOLUNTARY WINNABLE
03:08:51.887 --> 03:08:53.789
NATURAL GAS IN THEIR PIPELINE
03:08:53.855 --> 03:08:55.924
AND FOR ALL THE OTHER VARIOUS
03:08:55.991 --> 03:08:57.993
INCENTIVE PROGRAMS THAT WE HAVE --
03:08:58.060 --> 03:08:59.394
ACROSS THE STATE WE THERE'S NOT
03:08:59.461 --> 03:09:01.129
ENOUGH RIGHT NOW TO FILL THE
03:09:01.196 --> 03:09:01.863
DEMAND THAT'S RIGHT THERE IN
03:09:01.930 --> 03:09:04.733
FACT WE HAVE ASKED.
03:09:04.800 --> 03:09:06.101
FOR RENEWABLE NATURAL GAS
03:09:06.168 --> 03:09:07.803
CONTRACTS AND WE HAVEN'T REALLY
03:09:07.869 --> 03:09:09.471
GOTTEN A RETURN PHONE CALL IT IS
03:09:09.538 --> 03:09:11.440
MY UNDERSTANDING THAT THIS IS
03:09:11.506 --> 03:09:12.307
GONNA TAKE THERE'S GONNA BE
03:09:12.374 --> 03:09:14.676
COMPETITION FOR NEW PROJECTS.
03:09:14.743 --> 03:09:16.611
RIGHT NOW WE ACTUALLY COULDN'T
03:09:16.678 --> 03:09:18.246
DO WHAT'S IN THE BILL BECAUSE
03:09:18.313 --> 03:09:19.848
IT'S JUST NOT THE SUPPLY SO IT
03:09:19.915 --> 03:09:21.283
IS GOING TO HAVE TO BE.
03:09:21.349 --> 03:09:23.885
NEW PRODUCTS NEW PROJECTS BUILT
03:09:23.952 --> 03:09:26.688
OUT IN ORDER TO GET THE GET THE
03:09:26.755 --> 03:09:28.824
SUPPLY IN THE PIPELINE AND DRIVE
03:09:28.890 --> 03:09:30.192
THE PRICE DOWN SO WE CAN DO
03:09:30.258 --> 03:09:31.493
THAT'S WEIRD MY UNDERSTAND IS
03:09:31.560 --> 03:09:32.494
WE'RE NOT THERE YET.
03:09:32.561 --> 03:09:33.762
SO MY ASSUMPTION IS BANNED FROM
03:09:33.829 --> 03:09:35.297
THE BEGINNING ONCE THAT
03:09:35.363 --> 03:09:36.998
AMENDMENT WAS PROFFERED THAT
03:09:37.065 --> 03:09:37.699
WOULD BE TALKING ABOUT NEW
03:09:37.766 --> 03:09:40.035
PROJECTS OKAY THANK YOU WITHOUT
03:09:40.102 --> 03:09:41.803
MISTER DONNA WOULD YOU LIKE TO
03:09:41.870 --> 03:09:42.003
CLOSE.
03:09:42.070 --> 03:09:43.071
THAT'S WHEN I VOTE.
03:09:43.138 --> 03:09:44.473
THANK YOU WE HAVE A MOTION A
03:09:44.539 --> 03:09:45.440
SECOND WAVE A ROLL CALL PLEASE.
03:09:45.507 --> 03:09:47.476
I AM NINETEEN AB ELEVEN NINETY
03:09:47.542 --> 03:09:47.976
FIVE BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER
03:09:48.043 --> 03:09:49.211
O'DONNELL THE MOTION IS TO PASS
03:09:49.277 --> 03:09:50.779
AS AMENDED AND REFER TO
03:09:50.846 --> 03:09:52.547
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE.
03:09:52.614 --> 03:09:53.782
MEMBERS FRIEDMAN AYE FRIEDMAN
03:09:53.849 --> 03:09:58.086
AYE FLORA.
03:09:58.153 --> 03:09:59.521
CHAU.
03:09:59.588 --> 03:10:00.288
EGGMAN.
03:10:00.355 --> 03:10:02.190
EGGMAN AYE GARCIA AYE GARCIA AYE
03:10:02.257 --> 03:10:03.558
LOW MOAN.
03:10:03.625 --> 03:10:04.960
MATHIS -- MATHIS AYE MCCARTY.
03:10:05.026 --> 03:10:06.361
MELENDEZ [inaudible]
03:10:06.428 --> 03:10:07.629
WROTE SURGERY [inaudible]
03:10:07.696 --> 03:10:09.464
STONE.
03:10:09.531 --> 03:10:12.033
STONE NO FOUR ONE THANK YOU FOR
03:10:12.100 --> 03:10:12.601
ONE LEAVE THE ROLL OPEN FOR
03:10:12.667 --> 03:10:14.436
ABSENT MEMBERS THANK YOU NEXT WE
03:10:14.503 --> 03:10:30.786
HAVE MISTER GLORIA WITH.
03:10:30.852 --> 03:10:31.286
FOR TWENTY THREE A GOOD
03:10:31.353 --> 03:10:32.154
AFTERNOON MADAM CHAIR AND
03:10:32.220 --> 03:10:34.756
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE --
03:10:34.823 --> 03:10:35.357
EIGHTY FOUR TWENTY THREE WE'RE
03:10:35.423 --> 03:10:36.458
STRUCTURE SAID THE EAGLES AIR
03:10:36.525 --> 03:10:37.826
POLLUTION CONTROL DISTRICT AND
03:10:37.893 --> 03:10:39.094
DIRECT THEM TO INCREASE THEIR
03:10:39.161 --> 03:10:40.762
PROGRAM TRANSPARENCY.
03:10:40.829 --> 03:10:41.429
THE BOARD INCLUDES
03:10:41.496 --> 03:10:42.731
REPRESENTATION FROM ADDITIONAL
03:10:42.798 --> 03:10:44.399
SAN DIEGO AREA CITIES AND OTHER
03:10:44.466 --> 03:10:46.201
KEY STAKEHOLDERS IF PASSED A
03:10:46.268 --> 03:10:47.469
BEFORE TWENTY THREE WILL TAKE
03:10:47.536 --> 03:10:49.971
EFFECT ON MARCH FIRST.
03:10:50.038 --> 03:10:50.572
TWENTY TWENTY ONE QUICKLY --
03:10:50.639 --> 03:10:53.775
MADAM CHAIR I KNOW YOU'VE HAD A
03:10:53.842 --> 03:10:55.377
LONG DAY OF THE BILL.
03:10:55.443 --> 03:10:56.578
THIS BILL CORRECT ANOMALY -- IS
03:10:56.645 --> 03:10:57.913
CREATED BY THIS LEGISLATURE MANY
03:10:57.979 --> 03:10:59.548
MANY YEARS AGO -- BASICALLY
03:10:59.614 --> 03:11:00.916
INCREASING TRANSPARENCY AND
03:11:00.982 --> 03:11:01.883
REPRESENTATION THIS BOARD I
03:11:01.950 --> 03:11:03.318
BELIEVE WILL HELP US TO REACH A
03:11:03.385 --> 03:11:04.719
CLIMATE GOALS I AM REDUCE AIR
03:11:04.786 --> 03:11:06.188
POLLUTION OUR COMMUNITY I HAVE
03:11:06.254 --> 03:11:07.789
TWO WITNESSES I'D LIKE TO HAVE.
03:11:07.856 --> 03:11:09.558
THE OPPORTUNITY TESTIFIED TRAVEL
03:11:09.624 --> 03:11:11.159
FROM SAN DIEGO DâN TALK VOID
03:11:11.226 --> 03:11:11.860
WITH THE ENVIRONMENT HEALTH
03:11:11.927 --> 03:11:16.298
COALITION AND THERE ARE HUNDREDS
03:11:16.364 --> 03:11:16.865
TO TELL US OF THESE FROM THE
03:11:16.932 --> 03:11:17.365
CITY OF NATIONAL CITY.
03:11:17.432 --> 03:11:18.033
WE CAN MAKE IT REALLY WORTHWHILE
03:11:18.099 --> 03:11:18.567
AND ASK A LOT OF REALLY
03:11:18.633 --> 03:11:19.501
DIFFICULT QUESTIONS IF YOU
03:11:19.568 --> 03:11:21.336
PREFER AS WELL.
03:11:21.403 --> 03:11:23.939
YOU CAN ASK THEM TO BE PUT ON
03:11:24.005 --> 03:11:25.941
THE WITNESS OKAY.
03:11:26.007 --> 03:11:27.242
GOOD AFTERNOON -- DIANE TECH FOR
03:11:27.309 --> 03:11:28.343
IN DIRECTOR OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL
03:11:28.410 --> 03:11:29.344
HEALTH COALITION WE'RE A FORTY
03:11:29.411 --> 03:11:30.378
YEAR OLD ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE
03:11:30.445 --> 03:11:32.247
ORGANIZATION THAT WORKS IN LOW
03:11:32.314 --> 03:11:33.915
INCOME COMMUNITIES OF COLOR --
03:11:33.982 --> 03:11:34.983
TO CONFRONT THE UNJUST
03:11:35.050 --> 03:11:36.985
CONSEQUENCES OF POOR AIR QUALITY
03:11:37.052 --> 03:11:38.320
AND OUR COMMUNITIES HAVE A VERY
03:11:38.386 --> 03:11:40.522
LONG HISTORY OF WORKING FOR AIR
03:11:40.589 --> 03:11:42.724
QUALITY IN OUR COMMUNITIES AND
03:11:42.791 --> 03:11:43.925
WE HAVE BEEN MET WITH AN
03:11:43.992 --> 03:11:45.527
UNRESPONSIVE BOARD.
03:11:45.594 --> 03:11:46.361
THE HEALTH IMPACTS IN THE
03:11:46.428 --> 03:11:48.029
CONTINUED HIGH RATES OF CANCER
03:11:48.096 --> 03:11:49.598
AND ASTHMA HOSPITALIZATIONS
03:11:49.664 --> 03:11:52.400
AMONG CHILDREN ARE UNACCEPTABLE
03:11:52.467 --> 03:11:52.968
AND DEMONSTRATE THE NEED FOR
03:11:53.034 --> 03:11:53.435
ACTION.
03:11:53.501 --> 03:11:55.470
THE NEED FOR A DIVERSE
03:11:55.537 --> 03:11:57.239
REPRESENTATION ON THIS BOARD IS
03:11:57.305 --> 03:11:58.340
CLEAR.
03:11:58.406 --> 03:11:59.507
THE SAN DIEGO AIR POLLUTION
03:11:59.574 --> 03:12:00.876
CONTROL DISTRICT BOARD IS AN
03:12:00.942 --> 03:12:02.510
ANOMALY AMONG THE LARGE
03:12:02.577 --> 03:12:04.312
DISTRICTS IN THE STATE THE
03:12:04.379 --> 03:12:05.447
PRODUCT OF A TWENTY FIVE YEAR
03:12:05.513 --> 03:12:06.681
OLD PROVISIONS SPECIFICALLY
03:12:06.748 --> 03:12:08.216
DESIGNED TO EXAM SAN DIEGO
03:12:08.283 --> 03:12:10.085
COUNTY FROM HAVING A DIVERSE AND
03:12:10.151 --> 03:12:11.319
REPRESENTATIVE FORD.
03:12:11.386 --> 03:12:12.487
AND WE ALSO BELIEVE THAT THE
03:12:12.554 --> 03:12:14.589
NEED FOR DIRECTED ACTION THROUGH
03:12:14.656 --> 03:12:15.924
CLEAR REQUIREMENTS IS EVIDENT
03:12:15.991 --> 03:12:18.360
FOR EXAMPLE BASIC TRANSPARENCY
03:12:18.426 --> 03:12:20.295
IN LACKEY IS LACKING IN AREAS
03:12:20.362 --> 03:12:21.463
WHICH WOULD ENABLE THE PUBLIC TO
03:12:21.529 --> 03:12:23.865
PARTICIPATE IN THEIR ACTIVITIES
03:12:23.932 --> 03:12:24.733
FOR EXAMPLE.
03:12:24.799 --> 03:12:26.301
VERY SIMPLY THE SAN DIEGO AIR
03:12:26.368 --> 03:12:27.602
POLLUTION CONTROL DISTRICT
03:12:27.669 --> 03:12:29.104
MINUTES AND AGENDAS ARE NOT
03:12:29.170 --> 03:12:31.072
POSTED ON THEIR WEBSITE --
03:12:31.139 --> 03:12:32.173
THEY'RE BURIED IN THE COUNTY
03:12:32.240 --> 03:12:33.541
BOARD OF SUPERVISORS --
03:12:33.608 --> 03:12:35.477
INFORMATION THERE IS LITTLE
03:12:35.543 --> 03:12:38.013
INFORMATION AVAILABLE ABOUT --
03:12:38.079 --> 03:12:40.282
BASIC PERMITTING WHEN WE FOLLOW
03:12:40.348 --> 03:12:42.517
THEIR INSTRUCTIONS AND SIGNED UP
03:12:42.584 --> 03:12:44.953
TO RECEIVE DATA -- WE RECEIVED
03:12:45.020 --> 03:12:46.321
ZERO DATE AND NONE OF THE DATA
03:12:46.388 --> 03:12:49.257
REQUEST MATCH THEIR CRITERIA--
03:12:49.324 --> 03:12:51.559
WHEN WE DID THAT ON THE -- BAY
03:12:51.626 --> 03:12:54.095
AREA'S WEBSITE WE GOT TWENTY
03:12:54.162 --> 03:12:55.263
FIVE HUNDRED HITS SO THERE'S A
03:12:55.330 --> 03:12:56.498
BIG DIFFERENCE.
03:12:56.564 --> 03:12:57.933
AIR POLLUTION CONTROL DISTRICT
03:12:57.999 --> 03:12:59.100
FOUR DOES NOT PROVIDE BUDGET
03:12:59.167 --> 03:13:00.835
INFORMATION THERE'S NO DETAILED
03:13:00.902 --> 03:13:01.970
INFORMATION AND NOT AN
03:13:02.037 --> 03:13:03.338
OPPORTUNITY FOR THE PUBLIC TO
03:13:03.405 --> 03:13:04.372
PARTICIPATE.
03:13:04.439 --> 03:13:06.308
AND LASTLY MONITORING DATA FROM
03:13:06.374 --> 03:13:08.410
EXISTING MONITORS TAKES YEARS TO
03:13:08.476 --> 03:13:10.078
BE PROCESS JUST LAST WEEK WE
03:13:10.145 --> 03:13:12.647
RECEIVE DATA FROM.
03:13:12.714 --> 03:13:13.615
TWENTY SIXTEEN SO IN CLOSING
03:13:13.682 --> 03:13:14.883
OTHER LARGE DISTRICTS HAVE
03:13:14.950 --> 03:13:16.418
ROBUST PUBLIC INFORMATION
03:13:16.484 --> 03:13:17.652
AUTHENTIC COMMUNITY
03:13:17.719 --> 03:13:19.354
PARTICIPATION OPPORTUNITIES AN
03:13:19.421 --> 03:13:20.956
AMBITIOUS EMISSION REDUCTION
03:13:21.022 --> 03:13:23.191
PROGRAMS SAN DIEGO DESERVES AIR
03:13:23.258 --> 03:13:24.659
POLLUTION CONTROL DISTRICT.
03:13:24.726 --> 03:13:26.394
THAT ENCOURAGES AND SUPPORTS ITS
03:13:26.461 --> 03:13:28.596
KATE CAPABLE AND COMMITTED STAFF
03:13:28.663 --> 03:13:30.031
TO TAKE BOLD AND EFFECTIVE
03:13:30.098 --> 03:13:31.466
ACTION TO PROTECT PUBLIC HEALTH
03:13:31.533 --> 03:13:33.101
AND OUR MOST VULNERABLE
03:13:33.168 --> 03:13:34.769
COMMUNITIES THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
03:13:34.836 --> 03:13:36.137
THANK YOU NEXT WITH THIS.
03:13:36.204 --> 03:13:38.273
THANK YOU SO MUCH -- MADAM CHAIR
03:13:38.340 --> 03:13:40.608
AND MEMBERS -- I KNOW THAT HOW
03:13:40.675 --> 03:13:41.276
THAT'S WHAT THE LAW SO LEASE AND
03:13:41.343 --> 03:13:42.477
I AM THE MAYOR OF THE CITY OF
03:13:42.544 --> 03:13:45.947
NATIONAL CITY AND IT'S A CITY OF
03:13:46.014 --> 03:13:47.282
SIXTY THOUSAND PEOPLE IN
03:13:47.349 --> 03:13:48.984
SOUTHERN **** ANY ACCOUNTING.
03:13:49.050 --> 03:13:50.585
NATIONAL CITY SUFFERS FROM SOME
03:13:50.652 --> 03:13:52.020
OF THE WORST AIR POLLUTION IN
03:13:52.087 --> 03:13:53.221
SAN DIEGO COUNTY.
03:13:53.288 --> 03:13:54.055
AND AS A RESULT OF THESE
03:13:54.122 --> 03:13:55.357
CHALLENGES NATIONAL CITY HAS
03:13:55.423 --> 03:13:57.726
RECENTLY BEEN SELECTED TO BE
03:13:57.792 --> 03:13:59.160
PART OF THE CALIFORNIA COMMUNITY
03:13:59.227 --> 03:14:00.562
AIR PROTECTION PROGRAM.
03:14:00.628 --> 03:14:04.265
UNDER AB SIX ONE SEVEN OR SIX
03:14:04.332 --> 03:14:05.066
SEVENTEEN THE CITY OF NATIONAL
03:14:05.133 --> 03:14:06.601
CITY HAS RECOGNIZED THE SERIOUS
03:14:06.668 --> 03:14:08.036
PROBLEM OF AIR POLLUTION IN OUR
03:14:08.103 --> 03:14:13.174
COMMUNITY FOR NEARLY TWO DECADES.
03:14:13.241 --> 03:14:14.609
AND WE'RE DOING WHAT WE CAN AND
03:14:14.676 --> 03:14:15.744
AT THE LOCAL LEVEL TO IMPROVE
03:14:15.810 --> 03:14:16.144
OUR AIR QUALITY.
03:14:16.211 --> 03:14:16.745
AND WHAT DOES THAT MEAN THAT
03:14:16.811 --> 03:14:17.312
INCLUDE THE NEW WEST SIDE
03:14:17.379 --> 03:14:17.946
COMMUNITY PLAN THAT RESOUNDS THE
03:14:18.013 --> 03:14:19.614
COMMUNITY TO CORRECT
03:14:19.681 --> 03:14:21.483
INCOMPATIBLE LAND USES.
03:14:21.549 --> 03:14:23.151
NATIONAL CITY ADOPTED THE FIRST
03:14:23.218 --> 03:14:24.919
ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE ELEMENT IN
03:14:24.986 --> 03:14:27.555
A GENERAL PLAN AND IN THE STATE
03:14:27.622 --> 03:14:29.057
AND WHICH WAS THE INSPIRATION
03:14:29.124 --> 03:14:32.427
FOR SB ONE THOUSAND ADOPTED IN.
03:14:32.494 --> 03:14:33.028
TWO THOUSAND SIXTEEN WE JUST
03:14:33.094 --> 03:14:34.529
COMPLETED THE CONSTRUCTION OF
03:14:34.596 --> 03:14:35.330
TWO HUNDRED ONE AFFORDABLE
03:14:35.397 --> 03:14:36.931
HOUSING UNITS RIGHT NEXT TO OUR
03:14:36.998 --> 03:14:38.833
A TRANSIT CENTER WITH THE HELP
03:14:38.900 --> 03:14:40.535
OF NINE MILLION DOLLARS.
03:14:40.602 --> 03:14:44.906
IN CAPITAL FUND TRADES.
03:14:44.973 --> 03:14:45.540
CAPITA RATE BUTTONS.
03:14:45.607 --> 03:14:46.408
WE NEED YOUR HELP TO ENABLE
03:14:46.474 --> 03:14:48.376
NATIONAL CITY IN ALL OF THE
03:14:48.443 --> 03:14:49.177
EIGHTEEN CITIES IN SAN DIEGO
03:14:49.244 --> 03:14:50.412
COUNTY TO PARTICIPATE IN
03:14:50.478 --> 03:14:52.414
IMPROVING AIR QUALITY WE WANT
03:14:52.480 --> 03:14:54.282
OUR SEAT AT THE TABLE.
03:14:54.349 --> 03:14:55.683
OUR PERSPECTIVES AN INSIGHT INTO
03:14:55.750 --> 03:14:57.752
LOCAL AIR POLLUTION SOURCES OUR
03:14:57.819 --> 03:14:59.487
UNIQUE INVALUABLE INSIGHTS THAT
03:14:59.554 --> 03:15:00.789
ARE REPRESENT.
03:15:00.855 --> 03:15:02.223
OF REPRESENTATION WILL PROVIDE
03:15:02.290 --> 03:15:06.461
WE URGE YOU TO SUPPORT AB.
03:15:06.528 --> 03:15:07.062
FOR TWENTY THREE THANK YOU ARE
03:15:07.128 --> 03:15:08.263
THERE ANY OTHER MEMBERS OF THE
03:15:08.329 --> 03:15:09.531
PUBLIC WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN
03:15:09.597 --> 03:15:13.234
FAVOR OF THE BILL.
03:15:13.301 --> 03:15:14.969
YEAH GOOD EVENING IN A BASKET ON
03:15:15.036 --> 03:15:17.205
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA ROOM TO
03:15:17.272 --> 03:15:17.772
SCIENCE IN STRONG SUPPORT OF
03:15:17.839 --> 03:15:20.375
THIS BILL.
03:15:20.442 --> 03:15:21.810
LAUREN CALLING ON BEHALF OF
03:15:21.876 --> 03:15:25.313
SIERRA CLUB CALIFORNIANS SUPPORT.
03:15:25.380 --> 03:15:27.082
ROCKY RUSSIAN COALITION FOR
03:15:27.148 --> 03:15:30.418
CLEAN AIR HAPPY TO SUPPORT.
03:15:30.485 --> 03:15:31.753
I WILL BEAR AMERICAN LUNG
03:15:31.820 --> 03:15:35.757
ASSOCIATION ALSO IN SUPPORT.
03:15:35.824 --> 03:15:38.593
THANK YOU IS THERE ANYBODY IN
03:15:38.660 --> 03:15:39.227
OPPOSITION TO THE BILL THAT LIKE
03:15:39.294 --> 03:15:39.894
TO SPEAK.
03:15:39.961 --> 03:15:49.704
COUPLE OF TWEETERS.
03:15:49.771 --> 03:15:50.738
GOOD EVENING MADAM CHAIR
03:15:50.805 --> 03:15:51.973
COMMITTEE MEMBERS JONATHAN CLAY
03:15:52.040 --> 03:15:53.074
HERE ABOUT FOR THE COUNTY SAN
03:15:53.141 --> 03:15:55.076
DIEGO TO VOICE CONCERNS WITH THE
03:15:55.143 --> 03:15:56.911
MOST RECENT AMENDED VERSION OF
03:15:56.978 --> 03:15:58.746
AB -- FOR TWENTY THREE IN ITS
03:15:58.813 --> 03:16:00.482
PREVIOUS ITERATION WHEN THE BILL
03:16:00.548 --> 03:16:02.016
JUST DEALT WITH GOVERNANCE THE
03:16:02.083 --> 03:16:03.351
COUNTY AND CHOSEN TO REMAIN
03:16:03.418 --> 03:16:04.319
SILENT ON THAT.
03:16:04.385 --> 03:16:05.453
BUT WITH THE RECENT SET OF
03:16:05.520 --> 03:16:07.055
AMENDMENTS -- WE FELT WE NEEDED
03:16:07.122 --> 03:16:08.490
TO RAISE SOME CONCERNS.
03:16:08.556 --> 03:16:10.024
THIS CONCERNS REVOLVE AROUND A
03:16:10.091 --> 03:16:11.759
COUPLE DIFFERENT -- ISSUE AREAS
03:16:11.826 --> 03:16:13.761
FIRST OFF WE BELIEVE THAT
03:16:13.828 --> 03:16:15.830
IMPLEMENTATION FOR THOSE NEW SET
03:16:15.897 --> 03:16:16.764
OF AMENDMENTS REQUIREMENTS FOR
03:16:16.831 --> 03:16:18.433
THE DISTRICT -- THE MANDATES TO
03:16:18.500 --> 03:16:19.901
DO WOULD BE SOMEWHERE IN THE
03:16:19.968 --> 03:16:21.336
RANGE OF ABOUT THREE TO FIVE
03:16:21.402 --> 03:16:22.137
MILLION DOLLARS.
03:16:22.203 --> 03:16:23.338
WE ALSO THINK THERE'S A NUMBER
03:16:23.404 --> 03:16:24.839
REQUIREMENTS THAT HAVE
03:16:24.906 --> 03:16:26.774
UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES --
03:16:26.841 --> 03:16:28.376
WEATHER RELATED TO PENDING
03:16:28.443 --> 03:16:30.044
INVESTIGATIONS AND HAVING TO
03:16:30.111 --> 03:16:31.579
MAKE THOSE PUBLIC WITHOUT HAVING
03:16:31.646 --> 03:16:33.248
THE FULL FACTS OF THE MATTER
03:16:33.314 --> 03:16:35.650
BEING DETERMINED -- WE ALSO FEEL
03:16:35.717 --> 03:16:37.986
THAT THERE'S WAYS INTERPRET THE
03:16:38.052 --> 03:16:39.521
LANGUAGE OF REQUIRE TIPSTERS AND
03:16:39.587 --> 03:16:40.955
OTHER TYPES OF COMMENTS HAVE TO
03:16:41.022 --> 03:16:42.090
BE MADE PUBLIC.
03:16:42.157 --> 03:16:43.224
THERE'S JUST SOME MECHANICAL
03:16:43.291 --> 03:16:44.726
PROBLEMS WITH THE LANGUAGE WE
03:16:44.792 --> 03:16:46.761
ALSO FEEL THAT -- THERE'S SOME
03:16:46.828 --> 03:16:47.562
OTHER THINGS THAT THE BILL
03:16:47.629 --> 03:16:49.531
REQUIRES THAT WOULD BE NICE TO
03:16:49.597 --> 03:16:53.601
HAVE BETTER -- HUGE WORKLOAD FOR
03:16:53.668 --> 03:16:55.136
THE DISTRICT IN VERY EXPENSIVE.
03:16:55.203 --> 03:16:55.970
FINALLY WE ALSO THINK -- THERE'S
03:16:56.037 --> 03:16:57.238
SOME -- MISSING CROSS REFERENCES
03:16:57.305 --> 03:16:58.973
FOR FEAR FORTY AND THAT OF THEIR
03:16:59.040 --> 03:17:00.775
OTHER ITEMS IN THE BILL RIGHT
03:17:00.842 --> 03:17:01.976
NOW THAT ARE CURRENTLY BEING
03:17:02.043 --> 03:17:03.511
DONE OR IN PROCESS OF BEING DONE
03:17:03.578 --> 03:17:04.913
AND DON'T NEED TO ACTUALLY BE
03:17:04.979 --> 03:17:06.247
MANDATE AND STATUTES.
03:17:06.314 --> 03:17:08.449
WITHOUT THOSE ARE CONCERNS.
03:17:08.516 --> 03:17:10.718
THANK YOU.
03:17:10.785 --> 03:17:12.620
CHAIR FREEDMAN RANDALL FRIEDMAN
03:17:12.687 --> 03:17:13.421
REPRESENTING THE NAVY AND MARINE
03:17:13.488 --> 03:17:16.224
CORPS ALSO VOICING CONCERNS.
03:17:16.291 --> 03:17:17.659
WITH SIX MAJOR INSTALLATIONS IN
03:17:17.725 --> 03:17:19.327
SAN DIEGO COUNTY DEPENDENT ON A
03:17:19.394 --> 03:17:21.696
WIDE RANGE OF EQUIPMENT SUBJECT
03:17:21.763 --> 03:17:23.498
TO REGULATION BY THE A. P. C. D..
03:17:23.565 --> 03:17:24.766
THIS BILL IS.
03:17:24.832 --> 03:17:26.301
A HIGH PRIORITY FOR US.
03:17:26.367 --> 03:17:27.635
WE ARE WORKING IN GOOD FAITH
03:17:27.702 --> 03:17:28.736
WITH THE AUTHOR ON REQUESTED
03:17:28.803 --> 03:17:30.238
AMENDMENTS TO ENSURE THE
03:17:30.305 --> 03:17:31.573
MILITARY'S UNIQUE MISSION NEEDS
03:17:31.639 --> 03:17:33.107
ARE FULLY CONSIDERED BY THIS NEW
03:17:33.174 --> 03:17:34.075
BOARD.
03:17:34.142 --> 03:17:36.044
WE ARE STILL ANALYZING POTENTIAL
03:17:36.110 --> 03:17:36.711
IMPACTS FROM THE LATEST
03:17:36.778 --> 03:17:37.712
AMENDMENT.
03:17:37.779 --> 03:17:40.048
AND WILL CONTINUE OUR
03:17:40.114 --> 03:17:40.615
DISCUSSIONS WITH THE AUTHOR
03:17:40.682 --> 03:17:41.149
THANK YOU.
03:17:41.216 --> 03:17:41.783
THANK YOU VERY MUCH IS THERE
03:17:41.849 --> 03:17:43.585
ANYBODY WHO WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK
03:17:43.651 --> 03:17:46.087
IN OPPOSITION TO THE BILL.
03:17:46.154 --> 03:17:48.156
OKAY WITH THAT TO WILL GO TO THE
03:17:48.223 --> 03:17:49.023
COMMITTEE IS ANY COMMITTEE
03:17:49.090 --> 03:17:50.058
MEMBER OF ANY QUESTIONS OR
03:17:50.124 --> 03:17:53.461
COMMENTS.
03:17:53.528 --> 03:17:54.362
MR GLORIA WOULD YOU LIKE TO
03:17:54.429 --> 03:17:55.730
CLOSE I JUST WANNA STATE FOR THE
03:17:55.797 --> 03:17:57.165
RECORD MEN SHARE THAT WITH MY MY
03:17:57.232 --> 03:17:58.233
OFFICE AND I WILL CONTINUE TO
03:17:58.299 --> 03:17:59.300
WORK WITH THE OPPONENTS ON THE
03:17:59.367 --> 03:18:00.935
CONCERNS THAT WERE RAISED --
03:18:01.002 --> 03:18:02.570
TODAY IN IN IN DAYS UP PRIOR TO
03:18:02.637 --> 03:18:04.973
THIS -- INITIAL SPECS WE ASK
03:18:05.039 --> 03:18:06.074
YOUR AYE VOTE.
03:18:06.140 --> 03:18:07.275
THANK YOU -- I AM HAPPY TO
03:18:07.342 --> 03:18:09.444
SUPPORT YOUR BILL TODAY -- DID
03:18:09.510 --> 03:18:11.246
WE HAVE A MOTION AND A SECOND.
03:18:11.312 --> 03:18:11.779
YES WE DO HAVE A ROLL CALL
03:18:11.846 --> 03:18:13.181
PLEASE.
03:18:13.248 --> 03:18:14.949
I DON'T FIVE AB FOR TWENTY THREE
03:18:15.016 --> 03:18:15.750
BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER GLORIA THE
03:18:15.817 --> 03:18:17.518
MOTION IS TO PASS AND REFER TO
03:18:17.585 --> 03:18:18.953
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE.
03:18:19.020 --> 03:18:20.355
MEMBERS FRIEDMAN HI FRIEDMAN
03:18:20.421 --> 03:18:21.589
I'VE FLORA [inaudible]
03:18:21.656 --> 03:18:23.091
CHAU.
03:18:23.157 --> 03:18:24.158
EGGMAN.
03:18:24.225 --> 03:18:26.060
EGGMAN AYE GARCIA AYE GARCIA AYE
03:18:26.127 --> 03:18:27.729
LIMóN.
03:18:27.795 --> 03:18:30.898
MATHIS NO MATHIS NO MCCARTY.
03:18:30.965 --> 03:18:31.532
MELENDEZ.
03:18:31.599 --> 03:18:33.568
WROTE SURGERY.
03:18:33.635 --> 03:18:34.369
STONE.
03:18:34.435 --> 03:18:37.071
BUT SOON I FOR ONE FORTY ONE
03:18:37.138 --> 03:18:38.373
BELIEVE THE REAL OPEN CRAFTED
03:18:38.439 --> 03:18:39.741
MEMBERS THANK YOU VERY MUCH
03:18:39.807 --> 03:18:40.742
THANK YOU THANK YOU.
03:18:40.808 --> 03:18:44.512
AND NOW -- MISTER REAVIS WITH
03:18:44.579 --> 03:18:55.390
NINE THIRTY SIX AND SIXTEEN
03:18:55.456 --> 03:18:55.957
TWENTY EIGHT THANK YOU MADAM
03:18:56.024 --> 03:18:57.358
CHAIR.
03:18:57.425 --> 03:18:59.694
IS PREPARED TO SAY I'M HAPPY
03:18:59.761 --> 03:19:01.195
WITH WHO I AM HAPPY TO BE HERE
03:19:01.262 --> 03:19:03.398
WITH YOU THIS AFTERNOON BUT IT'S
03:19:03.464 --> 03:19:04.699
SEEMS TO BE EVENING TIME.
03:19:04.766 --> 03:19:05.633
BUT IT'S A IT'S IT'S ALWAYS
03:19:05.700 --> 03:19:07.835
GREAT TO BE HERE -- MEMBERS OF
03:19:07.902 --> 03:19:09.137
THE COMMITTEE I ALSO WANT TO
03:19:09.203 --> 03:19:11.606
THANK -- STAFF FOR NATURAL
03:19:11.673 --> 03:19:12.607
RESOURCES COMMITTEE FOR A WORK
03:19:12.674 --> 03:19:14.809
ON THE ANALYSIS AND I ALSO
03:19:14.876 --> 03:19:16.210
GLADLY ACCEPTED THE COMMITTEE
03:19:16.277 --> 03:19:19.247
AMENDMENTS BUT I AM HAPPY HERE
03:19:19.314 --> 03:19:21.382
TO PRESENT A. B. -- NINE THREE
03:19:21.449 --> 03:19:23.384
SIX A BILL RELATED TO OIL SPILL
03:19:23.451 --> 03:19:24.952
RESPONSE A CONTINGENCY PLANNING.
03:19:25.019 --> 03:19:26.521
AND SO LET ME BE ABSOLUTELY
03:19:26.587 --> 03:19:29.090
CLEAR THAT THIS BILL.
03:19:29.157 --> 03:19:30.224
THAT IS BILLS INTENT.
03:19:30.291 --> 03:19:31.626
YOU KNOW IT'S A BILL ABOUT
03:19:31.693 --> 03:19:33.494
SAFETY AND PREPAREDNESS -- AND
03:19:33.561 --> 03:19:35.463
SO CERTAINLY SEE THE THE
03:19:35.530 --> 03:19:37.398
KALAMAZOO RIVER OIL SPILL IN
03:19:37.465 --> 03:19:39.834
SOUTH CENTRAL MICHIGAN HAS BEEN
03:19:39.901 --> 03:19:41.502
CALLED THE BIGGEST OIL SPILL
03:19:41.569 --> 03:19:43.171
THAT YOU'VE NEVER HEARD ABOUT.
03:19:43.237 --> 03:19:44.872
IN TWO THOUSAND TEN ACCORDING TO
03:19:44.939 --> 03:19:46.908
FEDERAL AGENCIES A RUPTURED
03:19:46.974 --> 03:19:48.943
THIRTY INCH PIPELINE RESULTED IN
03:19:49.010 --> 03:19:50.912
A SPILL OF MORE THAN ONE MILLION
03:19:50.978 --> 03:19:52.814
GALLONS OF TAR SANDS OIL FROM
03:19:52.880 --> 03:19:54.315
ALBERTA CANADA.
03:19:54.382 --> 03:19:56.284
INTO THE KALAMAZOO.
03:19:56.351 --> 03:19:58.619
THE IMPACT OF THIS BILL WAS
03:19:58.686 --> 03:19:59.921
SEVERE.
03:19:59.987 --> 03:20:02.190
NEARLY FORTY MILES OF RIVER AND
03:20:02.256 --> 03:20:03.591
SHORELINES ARE POLLUTED MORE
03:20:03.658 --> 03:20:04.726
THAN ONE HUNDRED FAMILIES
03:20:04.792 --> 03:20:06.994
VOLUNTARILY LEFT THEIR HOMES.
03:20:07.061 --> 03:20:10.398
MOSTLY -- MOSTLY BECAUSE OF THE
03:20:10.465 --> 03:20:12.533
HIGH LEVELS OF OF OF BENZENE
03:20:12.600 --> 03:20:14.302
THAT HAD EVAPORATED FROM THE OIL
03:20:14.369 --> 03:20:15.136
INTO THE AIR.
03:20:15.203 --> 03:20:16.871
IT WAS -- BENZENE THAT HAD BEEN
03:20:16.938 --> 03:20:20.575
USED TO DILUTE THE HEAVY CRUDE.
03:20:20.641 --> 03:20:21.909
AND THIS EVENT TO THIS OIL SPILL.
03:20:21.976 --> 03:20:23.444
WITH SIGNIFICANT IT WAS
03:20:23.511 --> 03:20:24.846
SIGNIFICANT BECAUSE IT WAS THE
03:20:24.912 --> 03:20:27.915
FIRST SPILL OF TAR SANDS OIL.
03:20:27.982 --> 03:20:29.717
A TYPE OF NON FLOATING OIL THAT
03:20:29.784 --> 03:20:31.886
US AGENCIES WERE FORCED TO DEAL
03:20:31.953 --> 03:20:32.920
WITH.
03:20:32.987 --> 03:20:34.355
AND TO DATE THIS BILL REMAINS
03:20:34.422 --> 03:20:36.424
ONE OF THE BIGGEST AND COSTLIEST
03:20:36.491 --> 03:20:38.659
INLAND OIL SPILLS EVER
03:20:38.726 --> 03:20:40.461
REGISTERED IN THE UNITED STATES.
03:20:40.528 --> 03:20:41.529
THE BIGGEST AND COSTLIEST
03:20:41.596 --> 03:20:44.465
BECAUSE THE TYPICAL OIL SPILL
03:20:44.532 --> 03:20:48.069
CLEANUP METHODS DID NOT WORK
03:20:48.136 --> 03:20:48.369
[inaudible]
03:20:48.436 --> 03:20:50.438
THIS.
03:20:50.505 --> 03:20:52.273
THIS PARTICULAR HEAVY OIL IT DID
03:20:52.340 --> 03:20:54.208
NOT FLOAT ON WATER LIKE MOST
03:20:54.275 --> 03:20:55.443
OILS.
03:20:55.510 --> 03:20:57.145
TO EVERY ACTED VERY DIFFERENTLY.
03:20:57.211 --> 03:20:58.846
ONCE THIS BILL OCCURRED OVER
03:20:58.913 --> 03:21:00.515
TIME AS IT SAT IN THE WATER IT
03:21:00.581 --> 03:21:02.717
BECAME SUSPENDED IN THE WATER
03:21:02.784 --> 03:21:04.886
COLUMN EVENTUALLY THINKING.
03:21:04.952 --> 03:21:07.755
THE CALVET THE THE RIVER CLEANUP
03:21:07.822 --> 03:21:09.657
TOOK FIVE YEARS TO COMPLETE.
03:21:09.724 --> 03:21:13.895
AND COST OVER ONE POINT -- TWO
03:21:13.961 --> 03:21:15.630
BILLION DOLLARS NOT INCLUDING
03:21:15.696 --> 03:21:17.899
THE MULTI BILLION DOLLAR SPENT
03:21:17.965 --> 03:21:19.367
IN COMPANY FIGHT TO
03:21:19.434 --> 03:21:20.902
INFRASTRUCTURE IMPROVEMENTS.
03:21:20.968 --> 03:21:22.470
CALIFORNIA IS ONE OF ONLY THREE
03:21:22.537 --> 03:21:23.971
MAJOR REGIONS IN THE UNITED
03:21:24.038 --> 03:21:25.606
STATES THAT CAN REFINE THIS TYPE
03:21:25.673 --> 03:21:27.008
OF HEAVY CRUDE.
03:21:27.074 --> 03:21:28.609
TAR SANDS OIL HAS BEEN IN
03:21:28.676 --> 03:21:29.877
PRODUCTION SINCE THE LATE
03:21:29.944 --> 03:21:31.212
NINETEEN SIXTIES.
03:21:31.279 --> 03:21:33.314
AND CURRENTLY ACCOUNTS FOR ABOUT
03:21:33.381 --> 03:21:34.949
5% OF ALL US GAS.
03:21:35.016 --> 03:21:36.417
HOWEVER PRODUCTION HAS BEEN
03:21:36.484 --> 03:21:38.519
SCALING UP.
03:21:38.586 --> 03:21:40.254
IN FACT ACCORDING TO THE US
03:21:40.321 --> 03:21:40.655
ENERGY INFORMATION
03:21:40.721 --> 03:21:42.623
ADMINISTRATION LAST YEAR CANADA
03:21:42.690 --> 03:21:45.326
EXPORTED A RECORD AMOUNT OF TAR
03:21:45.393 --> 03:21:47.328
SANDS OIL TO THE UNITED STATES.
03:21:47.395 --> 03:21:48.196
EXPORTS ARE TRANSPORTED
03:21:48.262 --> 03:21:49.764
THROUGHOUT OUR STATE USING
03:21:49.831 --> 03:21:51.933
VARIOUS METHODS INCLUDING BY C.
03:21:51.999 --> 03:21:53.034
ALONG OUR PACIFIC OCEAN
03:21:53.100 --> 03:21:55.203
COASTLINE.
03:21:55.269 --> 03:21:56.304
AND IN LIGHT OF THIS THIS
03:21:56.370 --> 03:21:57.605
LEGISLATION.
03:21:57.672 --> 03:21:59.807
AB NINE THIRTY SIX AGAIN IS
03:21:59.874 --> 03:22:03.110
ABOUT SAFETY AND PREPAREDNESS.
03:22:03.177 --> 03:22:04.212
IT'S SIX THIS IS A BILL THAT
03:22:04.278 --> 03:22:05.546
SEEKS TO ENHANCE OIL
03:22:05.613 --> 03:22:06.914
TRANSPORTATION SAFETY IN
03:22:06.981 --> 03:22:08.416
CALIFORNIA BY PROVIDING
03:22:08.483 --> 03:22:10.585
INFORMATION ON NON FLOATING OIL
03:22:10.651 --> 03:22:12.153
MOVEMENTS WITHIN THE STATE TO
03:22:12.220 --> 03:22:14.589
EMERGENCY RESPONDERS.
03:22:14.655 --> 03:22:16.791
AND IT RESPONSIBLY SEEKS TO
03:22:16.858 --> 03:22:17.625
UPDATE AND STRAIGHTENING
03:22:17.692 --> 03:22:19.227
CALIFORNIA'S TOOLS FOR PLANNING
03:22:19.293 --> 03:22:20.962
AND PREPARING FOR UNANTICIPATED
03:22:21.028 --> 03:22:22.530
FUTURE OIL SPILLS.
03:22:22.597 --> 03:22:24.499
OF NON FOR AN OIL.
03:22:24.565 --> 03:22:26.767
THE CALIFORNIA COAST ALL TWELVE
03:22:26.834 --> 03:22:28.336
HUNDRED MILES ALONG THE PACIFIC
03:22:28.402 --> 03:22:29.904
OCEAN IS ONE OF OUR STATE
03:22:29.971 --> 03:22:31.772
NATURAL TREASURES.
03:22:31.839 --> 03:22:33.307
AND IT'S CLEARLY A MAJOR
03:22:33.374 --> 03:22:36.143
ECONOMIC RESOURCE FOR OUR STATE.
03:22:36.210 --> 03:22:37.445
NON FOR THE OIL PRESENTS A
03:22:37.512 --> 03:22:38.880
UNIQUE AND SERVICE RISK TO OUR
03:22:38.946 --> 03:22:40.281
COAST.
03:22:40.348 --> 03:22:41.716
HERE CALIFORNIA IF YOU TAKE THE
03:22:41.782 --> 03:22:43.784
TIME AND REVIEW CALIFORNIA'S OIL
03:22:43.851 --> 03:22:46.554
SPILL -- THE CONTINGENCY PLAN IT
03:22:46.621 --> 03:22:48.189
IS ABSOLUTELY CLEAR.
03:22:48.256 --> 03:22:49.891
THAT OUR STATE OIL RESPONSE
03:22:49.957 --> 03:22:51.592
CAPABILITIES ASSUME.
03:22:51.659 --> 03:22:54.095
THE OIL FLOATS.
03:22:54.161 --> 03:22:55.930
WHEN IT COMES TO NON FORTY OILS
03:22:55.997 --> 03:22:58.065
HEAVIER OILS LIKE TAR SANDS THE
03:22:58.132 --> 03:22:59.534
TRUTH IS WE KNOW VERY LITTLE
03:22:59.600 --> 03:23:01.035
ABOUT IT?
03:23:01.102 --> 03:23:03.304
WE KNOW VERY LITTLE ABOUT THIS
03:23:03.371 --> 03:23:04.672
WILL IMPACT IN BEHAVIOR.
03:23:04.739 --> 03:23:07.575
ESPECIALLY WHEN THIS BILL OCCURS.
03:23:07.642 --> 03:23:08.809
WE CAN HAVE A POINT TO THE
03:23:08.876 --> 03:23:10.378
KALAMAZOO RIVER INCIDENT THE
03:23:10.444 --> 03:23:11.846
EFFECTS THAT NON UT -- HAD ON
03:23:11.913 --> 03:23:13.548
THE RIVER AND ON THE OVERALL
03:23:13.614 --> 03:23:14.615
ENVIRONMENT.
03:23:14.682 --> 03:23:16.083
THAT INCIDENT MADE IT QUITE
03:23:16.150 --> 03:23:17.785
CLEAR THAT ONCE ALL THE OIL
03:23:17.852 --> 03:23:19.620
STARTED TO SINK IT MADE THINGS A
03:23:19.687 --> 03:23:22.390
LOT MORE DIFFICULT AND VERY VERY
03:23:22.456 --> 03:23:24.025
CHALLENGING TO CLEAN UP.
03:23:24.091 --> 03:23:25.493
RESPOND AS WERE CLEARLY NOT AS
03:23:25.560 --> 03:23:26.527
PREPARED TO ADDRESS THE
03:23:26.594 --> 03:23:28.429
SITUATION AND CLEAN IT UP AS
03:23:28.496 --> 03:23:30.231
THEY SHOULD HAVE BEEN -- IT'S
03:23:30.298 --> 03:23:31.666
AGAIN THIS BILL IS ABOUT SAFETY
03:23:31.732 --> 03:23:33.634
AND PREPAREDNESS -- FOR OUR
03:23:33.701 --> 03:23:35.536
STATE AND ALONG OUR COAST I HAVE
03:23:35.603 --> 03:23:36.737
HERE SOME WITNESSES AND I WILL
03:23:36.804 --> 03:23:39.507
ALLOW THEM TO INTRODUCE
03:23:39.574 --> 03:23:42.310
THEMSELVES THANK MANAGER.
03:23:42.376 --> 03:23:44.111
GOOD AFTERNOON MADAM CHAIR AND
03:23:44.178 --> 03:23:46.847
MEMBERS I AM -- JOSHUA AXELROD
03:23:46.914 --> 03:23:47.615
FOR WITH THE INTERNATIONAL
03:23:47.682 --> 03:23:49.150
FOSSIL FUELS PROGRAM AT THE
03:23:49.216 --> 03:23:50.484
NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE
03:23:50.551 --> 03:23:52.253
COUNCIL HERE IN SUPPORT OF THIS
03:23:52.320 --> 03:23:53.287
BILL.
03:23:53.354 --> 03:23:54.622
WE APPRECIATE MISTER REVERSES
03:23:54.689 --> 03:23:57.925
LEADERSHIP IN INTRODUCING AB
03:23:57.992 --> 03:23:58.526
NINE THIRTY SIX TO ADDRESS THE
03:23:58.593 --> 03:24:00.561
THREATS THAT NON PUTTING AYEOPPOSED TO CALIFORNIA
03:24:00.628 --> 03:24:01.696
COMMUNITIES.
03:24:01.762 --> 03:24:03.197
AND NATURAL RESOURCES ACROSS THE
03:24:03.264 --> 03:24:04.231
STATE.
03:24:04.298 --> 03:24:05.900
THE BILL PROVIDES FOR PRUDENT
03:24:05.967 --> 03:24:07.702
AND NECESSARY REQUIREMENTS TO
03:24:07.768 --> 03:24:08.836
CONFRONT THESE THREATS
03:24:08.903 --> 03:24:10.705
SPECIFICALLY -- I'LL HAVE IT
03:24:10.771 --> 03:24:12.039
THREE THINGS -- PROPOSED NEW
03:24:12.106 --> 03:24:13.541
INFRASTRUCTURE OUTSIDE OF THE
03:24:13.608 --> 03:24:14.809
STATE IS POISED TO OPEN
03:24:14.875 --> 03:24:17.144
CALIFORNIA'S REFINING MARKETS TO
03:24:17.211 --> 03:24:19.046
AN INFLUX OF NON FLOATING AROUND.
03:24:19.113 --> 03:24:20.081
CARRIED MOSTLY BY OCEAN TANKERS
03:24:20.147 --> 03:24:21.082
TO THE SAN FRANCISCO SAN
03:24:21.148 --> 03:24:24.819
FRANCISCO AND LOS ANGELES AREAS.
03:24:24.885 --> 03:24:26.020
IN LIGHT OF THIS POTENTIALITY
03:24:26.087 --> 03:24:26.887
AND TO COPE WITH NON VOTING ARE
03:24:26.954 --> 03:24:28.789
BEING TRANSPORTED INTO OUR STATE
03:24:28.856 --> 03:24:30.825
NOW AB NINE THIRTY SIX PROVIDE
03:24:30.891 --> 03:24:33.561
STATE AGENCIES AND SPELL RESPOND
03:24:33.628 --> 03:24:35.062
AS WITH INCREASED INFORMATION.
03:24:35.129 --> 03:24:36.297
REGARDING CHARACTERISTICS OF
03:24:36.364 --> 03:24:37.832
OILS ENTERING THE STATE AND
03:24:37.898 --> 03:24:39.734
CLARITY AS TO THE TIMING AND
03:24:39.800 --> 03:24:40.868
TYPES OF RESPONSE THAT MIGHT BE
03:24:40.935 --> 03:24:42.570
NECESSARY IN THE EVENT OF A
03:24:42.637 --> 03:24:44.238
LARGE WATER BORNE SPELL OF NON
03:24:44.305 --> 03:24:45.306
FLOATING AROUND.
03:24:45.373 --> 03:24:47.041
AB NINE THIRTY SIX EXPANDS THE
03:24:47.108 --> 03:24:48.609
FINANCIAL RESPONSIBILITY OF
03:24:48.676 --> 03:24:50.077
OPERATORS MOVING NON PUTTING OIL
03:24:50.144 --> 03:24:51.545
INTO THE STATE TO ENSURE THAT
03:24:51.612 --> 03:24:52.980
THE POTENTIALLY SIGNIFICANT
03:24:53.047 --> 03:24:54.181
COSTS OF CLEAN UP.
03:24:54.248 --> 03:24:57.318
SHOULD THEY ARISE ARE NOT BORN
03:24:57.385 --> 03:24:58.919
BY THE CITIZENS OF CALIFORNIA.
03:24:58.986 --> 03:25:00.488
AB NINE THIRTY SIX OF THE
03:25:00.554 --> 03:25:01.589
COMMONSENSE BELT THAT WILL
03:25:01.656 --> 03:25:02.890
BENEFIT FIRST RESPONDERS
03:25:02.957 --> 03:25:04.959
COMMUNITIES AND CALIFORNIA'S
03:25:05.026 --> 03:25:06.394
PRECIOUS NATURAL RESOURCES.
03:25:06.460 --> 03:25:08.295
BY IMPROVING OUR PREPAREDNESS
03:25:08.362 --> 03:25:09.797
FOR A POTENTIALLY DEVASTATING
03:25:09.864 --> 03:25:12.099
ACCIDENT INVOLVING NON PUTTING
03:25:12.166 --> 03:25:13.367
OILS WE ARE QUITE BE I
03:25:13.434 --> 03:25:16.337
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR AYE
03:25:16.404 --> 03:25:16.871
VOTE THANK YOU [inaudible]
03:25:16.937 --> 03:25:19.507
THANK YOU.
03:25:19.573 --> 03:25:21.909
THAT THEIR MEDICARE.
03:25:21.976 --> 03:25:23.511
MEMBERS TIME I'M THEN I CAN
03:25:23.577 --> 03:25:24.412
BURKE STAFF ATTORNEY PERCENT
03:25:24.478 --> 03:25:25.212
DISCO BAY KEEPER I'M HERE IN
03:25:25.279 --> 03:25:26.313
SUPPORT OF THIS IMPORTANT BILL --
03:25:26.380 --> 03:25:27.481
I WOULD ALSO LIKE TO THANK
03:25:27.548 --> 03:25:29.050
ASSEMBLY MEMBER REAVIS FOR HIS
03:25:29.116 --> 03:25:30.918
LEADERSHIP ON THIS IMPORTANT
03:25:30.985 --> 03:25:32.186
ISSUE AS WELL AS MANY STAFF.
03:25:32.253 --> 03:25:33.320
ALSO LIKE TO THANK MY COLLEAGUE
03:25:33.387 --> 03:25:34.689
MINORITY SEE FOR TAKING TIME OUT
03:25:34.755 --> 03:25:38.926
FROM HIS PATERNITY LEAVE AND HIS
03:25:38.993 --> 03:25:40.895
HIS NEW BABY.
03:25:40.961 --> 03:25:41.462
AS IT'S BEEN MADE CLEAR BY
03:25:41.529 --> 03:25:42.229
ASSEMBLYMEMBER REAVIS CALIFORNIA
03:25:42.296 --> 03:25:43.998
NEEDS THIS ADDITIONAL PROTECTION
03:25:44.065 --> 03:25:44.632
IN THE EVENT OF A NON POLLUTING
03:25:44.699 --> 03:25:46.634
SPELL. TO SUMMARIZE -- THERE'S
03:25:46.701 --> 03:25:48.069
AN IMMINENT THREAT OF MORE OF
03:25:48.135 --> 03:25:49.503
THIS TYPE WELCOME TO CALIFORNIA
03:25:49.570 --> 03:25:51.038
THE RISK OF THIS BILL IS
03:25:51.105 --> 03:25:53.074
CATASTROPHIC.
03:25:53.140 --> 03:25:53.641
OUR SOLUTION IS THREE PARTS
03:25:53.708 --> 03:25:54.408
FIRST.
03:25:54.475 --> 03:25:55.976
FIRST OF ALL FIRST RESPONDERS
03:25:56.043 --> 03:25:57.111
HAVE A RIGHT TO KNOW WHAT
03:25:57.178 --> 03:25:57.912
THEY'RE DEALING WITH SECOND OF
03:25:57.978 --> 03:25:59.346
ALL WE MUST PREPARE FOR THIS
03:25:59.413 --> 03:26:01.315
THREAT USING THE BEST TECHNOLOGY
03:26:01.382 --> 03:26:01.882
WE CAN GET.
03:26:01.949 --> 03:26:02.983
AND THIRD THE PEOPLE OF
03:26:03.050 --> 03:26:05.519
CALIFORNIA SHOULDN'T BE SADDLED
03:26:05.586 --> 03:26:07.221
WITH THIS THE COST OF A SPELL.
03:26:07.288 --> 03:26:08.322
THE NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES
03:26:08.389 --> 03:26:09.990
IS THE STUDY THIS ISSUE TWICE
03:26:10.057 --> 03:26:11.459
FIRST IN NINETEEN NINETY NINE
03:26:11.525 --> 03:26:12.393
AND THEN WHAT MORE RECENTLY.
03:26:12.460 --> 03:26:14.261
FOUND THIS THREAD TO BE SEVERE
03:26:14.328 --> 03:26:14.829
AND FOUND THAT WE ARE UNDER
03:26:14.895 --> 03:26:15.596
PREPARED.
03:26:15.663 --> 03:26:16.831
SAN FRANCISCO BAY IS
03:26:16.897 --> 03:26:19.166
SPECIFICALLY UNDER THREAT --
03:26:19.233 --> 03:26:20.367
THERE'S GONNA BE MORE THERE
03:26:20.434 --> 03:26:21.669
COULD BE MORE THAN THREE HUNDRED
03:26:21.736 --> 03:26:22.236
IT'S NOT BARGES AND TANKERS
03:26:22.303 --> 03:26:23.471
CARRYING ON PUTTING OIL ON THE
03:26:23.537 --> 03:26:25.439
WEST COAST IF CURRENTLY PLANNED
03:26:25.506 --> 03:26:26.674
PROJECTS ARE COMPLETED.
03:26:26.741 --> 03:26:28.275
FIRST RESPONDERS MUST KNOW WHAT
03:26:28.342 --> 03:26:29.910
IS COMING.
03:26:29.977 --> 03:26:31.278
EACH TANKER CARRIES AN ADDED
03:26:31.345 --> 03:26:33.047
RISK OF SPELL AND SPILLS IMPORT
03:26:33.114 --> 03:26:34.548
MEAN ECONOMICALLY DISADVANTAGED
03:26:34.615 --> 03:26:36.117
COMMUNITIES COULD BE HIT
03:26:36.183 --> 03:26:37.451
PARTICULARLY HARD.
03:26:37.518 --> 03:26:38.619
CALIFORNIA'S FORTY SIX BILLION
03:26:38.686 --> 03:26:40.588
DOLLAR COASTAL ECONOMY HAS A LOT
03:26:40.654 --> 03:26:42.056
TO LOSE FROM A SPELL.
03:26:42.123 --> 03:26:43.090
EVER GONNA SHIP THIS THAT STUFF
03:26:43.157 --> 03:26:44.558
THROUGH SEPARATIST KOBE AND ALL
03:26:44.625 --> 03:26:46.093
OVER CALIFORNIA WE NEED TO
03:26:46.160 --> 03:26:47.695
IMAGINE THE SCENARIO TO FIGURE
03:26:47.762 --> 03:26:48.896
OUT A PLAN TO REDUCE
03:26:48.963 --> 03:26:51.665
CATASTROPHIC DAMAGE.
03:26:51.732 --> 03:26:52.266
ALSO RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE
03:26:52.333 --> 03:26:52.767
VOTE.
03:26:52.833 --> 03:26:53.400
THANK YOU VERY MUCH IS THERE
03:26:53.467 --> 03:26:54.568
ANYONE ELSE WANTING TO TESTIFY
03:26:54.635 --> 03:26:58.606
IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL.
03:26:58.672 --> 03:26:59.874
MELISSA ROMERO CALIFORNIA LEAGUE
03:26:59.940 --> 03:27:01.542
OF CONSERVATION VOTERS IN
03:27:01.609 --> 03:27:04.345
SUPPORT.
03:27:04.411 --> 03:27:05.880
I FURTHER THAN ON BEHALF OF
03:27:05.946 --> 03:27:08.682
BOTTLING CALIFORNIANS SUPPORT.
03:27:08.749 --> 03:27:09.984
VICTORIA AROUND YOU KNOW ME AS
03:27:10.050 --> 03:27:13.387
IN OUR DC BUT I'M SPEAKING TODAY
03:27:13.454 --> 03:27:14.922
FOR THREE FIFTY BAY AREA ACTION
03:27:14.989 --> 03:27:17.491
IN SUPPORT THANK YOU.
03:27:17.558 --> 03:27:19.226
JENNIFER SAVAGE SURFRIDER IN
03:27:19.293 --> 03:27:21.762
SUPPORT THANK YOU.
03:27:21.829 --> 03:27:22.963
LAUREN COM SIERRA CLUB
03:27:23.030 --> 03:27:25.533
CALIFORNIA IN SUPPORT.
03:27:25.599 --> 03:27:27.601
TREES A BROKERAGE ON BEHALF OF
03:27:27.668 --> 03:27:28.702
HILL THE BAY IN THE CLEAN SEIZE
03:27:28.769 --> 03:27:30.037
LOBBYING COALITION IN SUPPORT.
03:27:30.104 --> 03:27:32.173
THANK YOU ANYBODY WISHING TO
03:27:32.239 --> 03:27:43.350
SPEAK IN OPPOSITION TO THE BILL.
03:27:43.417 --> 03:27:45.219
IF ONE OF THE WITNESSES COULD
03:27:45.286 --> 03:27:47.288
PLEASE GIVE THEIR SEAT TO THE
03:27:47.354 --> 03:27:49.523
OPPOSING WITNESS THANK YOU.
03:27:49.590 --> 03:27:50.691
A GOOD AFTERNOON MADAM CHAIR P.
03:27:50.758 --> 03:27:52.092
ANTHONY THOMAS WITH THE
03:27:52.159 --> 03:27:53.460
CALIFORNIA INDEPENDENT PETROLEUM
03:27:53.527 --> 03:27:57.731
ASSOCIATION -- WE'RE WE'RE IN
03:27:57.798 --> 03:28:01.802
WE'RE IN OPPOSITION -- TO AB
03:28:01.869 --> 03:28:02.570
NINE THIRTY SIX FIRST OF ALL LET
03:28:02.636 --> 03:28:05.306
ME SAY THIS -- MADAM CHAIR THAT
03:28:05.372 --> 03:28:07.041
I WANT TO THANK MISTER REAVIS WE
03:28:07.107 --> 03:28:09.577
WORKED WE'VE WORKED ON TO OTHER
03:28:09.643 --> 03:28:10.711
BUILT ASIDE FROM THIS WOMAN.
03:28:10.778 --> 03:28:11.879
AND I HE IS A MAN OF HIS WORD
03:28:11.946 --> 03:28:14.915
AND A PERSON WHO I AM GLAD TO
03:28:14.982 --> 03:28:16.050
HAVE KNOWN HOW TO NOTE.
03:28:16.116 --> 03:28:17.184
AND WE LOOK FORWARD TO WORKING
03:28:17.251 --> 03:28:18.619
IN THE FUTURE.
03:28:18.686 --> 03:28:22.990
BUT IN SO FAR AS A. B. -- NINE
03:28:23.057 --> 03:28:24.658
THIRTY SIX IS CONCERNED.
03:28:24.725 --> 03:28:26.994
THERE'S NO ARGUMENT ON HOW
03:28:27.061 --> 03:28:27.561
DAMAGING ANY OIL SPILL IS.
03:28:27.628 --> 03:28:28.095
BUT IF YOU LISTEN TO THE
03:28:28.162 --> 03:28:30.197
TESTIMONY VERY CLEARLY WE'RE
03:28:30.264 --> 03:28:32.299
TALKING ABOUT IMPORT.
03:28:32.366 --> 03:28:34.201
WE'RE TALKING ABOUT THE ISSUE
03:28:34.268 --> 03:28:35.269
WITH THE IMPORT SOLD WHEN
03:28:35.336 --> 03:28:37.238
PRODUCTION IN A STATE GOALS DOWN
03:28:37.304 --> 03:28:38.239
THE DEMAND IS STILL THERE SO WE
03:28:38.305 --> 03:28:40.441
HAVE TO DEPEND ON IMPORTS.
03:28:40.507 --> 03:28:41.976
ENTERS TALKING ABOUT THE DAMAGE
03:28:42.042 --> 03:28:43.143
OF IMPORTS WE'VE SAID THAT ALL
03:28:43.210 --> 03:28:45.479
THE TIME THAT MORE IN STATE
03:28:45.546 --> 03:28:47.882
PRODUCTION IS ACTUALLY BETTER
03:28:47.948 --> 03:28:49.383
CONSIDERING THE ROUTE THE
03:28:49.450 --> 03:28:50.150
REGULATION THAT WE FUNCTION
03:28:50.217 --> 03:28:51.619
UNDER.
03:28:51.685 --> 03:28:54.822
THE TO PROPONENTS MENTION THE
03:28:54.889 --> 03:28:56.323
ISSUES WITH IMPORTS OF OIL SO WE
03:28:56.390 --> 03:28:57.491
SHOULD TAKE INTO CONSIDERATION
03:28:57.558 --> 03:29:00.027
MAYBE WE NEED TO IN FACT
03:29:00.094 --> 03:29:01.328
INCREASE PRODUCTION STATE OF
03:29:01.395 --> 03:29:02.096
CALIFORNIA.
03:29:02.162 --> 03:29:03.831
BECAUSE OF THE RULES AND
03:29:03.898 --> 03:29:05.666
REGULATIONS THAT ARE THAT ARE
03:29:05.733 --> 03:29:07.868
GOVERNED AND BECAUSE OF OUR ORAL
03:29:07.935 --> 03:29:09.803
BEING THE BEST IN THE CLEANEST
03:29:09.870 --> 03:29:10.971
IN THE NATION.
03:29:11.038 --> 03:29:12.439
AS THE BILL READS MADAM CHAIR
03:29:12.506 --> 03:29:13.874
THE GOAL IS TO HAVE THE OFFICE
03:29:13.941 --> 03:29:15.509
OF SPILL RESPONSE ADMINISTRATOR
03:29:15.576 --> 03:29:17.745
TO ESTABLISH A CRITERION FOR
03:29:17.811 --> 03:29:18.879
SEPARATE RATING.
03:29:18.946 --> 03:29:20.614
OUR RATING LEVEL FOR THE
03:29:20.681 --> 03:29:25.686
ORGANIZATION TO ADDRESS NON
03:29:25.753 --> 03:29:28.155
FLOATING.
03:29:28.222 --> 03:29:29.890
OIL INDUSTRY HAS ADDRESSED THIS
03:29:29.957 --> 03:29:31.659
ISSUE OF WORLD BILL DATING BACK
03:29:31.725 --> 03:29:34.395
TO AB -- ELEVEN NINETY SEVEN
03:29:34.461 --> 03:29:35.796
MEMBER LAMONT CHAPTER IN TWENTY
03:29:35.863 --> 03:29:37.197
FOURTEEN AS WELL AS SB EIGHT
03:29:37.264 --> 03:29:37.831
SIXTY ONE WHICH IS ALSO CHAPTER
03:29:37.898 --> 03:29:37.998
IN.
03:29:38.065 --> 03:29:38.632
TWENTY FOURTEEN THE LEGISLATURE
03:29:38.699 --> 03:29:39.700
HAS INVESTED SIGNIFICANT
03:29:39.767 --> 03:29:42.036
RESOURCES AND TIMING CRAFTING
03:29:42.102 --> 03:29:44.538
THESE TO COMPREHENSIVE LOSS. TO
03:29:44.605 --> 03:29:47.041
SUPPLEMENT SB FOUR CHAPTER IN
03:29:47.107 --> 03:29:47.508
TWENTY THIRTEEN WHICH
03:29:47.574 --> 03:29:49.043
INCIDENTALLY IS NOW UNDERGOING
03:29:49.109 --> 03:29:52.012
STATUTORY REVIEW FOR A TWENTY
03:29:52.079 --> 03:29:53.881
TWENTY REPORT TO THE LEGISLATURE
03:29:53.948 --> 03:29:55.249
WHICH WILL INCLUDE.
03:29:55.316 --> 03:29:58.218
OIL SPILLS YOUR TIME IS UP YOU
03:29:58.285 --> 03:30:00.454
CAN JUST FINISH UP IN LATE
03:30:00.521 --> 03:30:01.522
WITNESSES MAY HAVE MADAM CHAIR I
03:30:01.588 --> 03:30:02.990
I I UNDERSTAND WE'RE ALWAYS ON
03:30:03.057 --> 03:30:04.825
TIME LINES BUT BUT I WERE.
03:30:04.892 --> 03:30:07.261
OKAY LET ME JUST SAY THIS.
03:30:07.328 --> 03:30:08.762
THERE ARE CHAPTER BILL THAT
03:30:08.829 --> 03:30:09.763
ADDRESSED THIS ISSUE THERE WAS A
03:30:09.830 --> 03:30:11.832
REPORT COMING OUT THAT WILL
03:30:11.899 --> 03:30:13.500
ADDRESS OR THIS BILL DOUBLE
03:30:13.567 --> 03:30:14.935
INCLUDE NON FLOATING.
03:30:15.002 --> 03:30:16.303
IF IN FACT NON FLOATING IS NOT
03:30:16.370 --> 03:30:18.372
INCLUDED I AM SURE THAT THIS
03:30:18.439 --> 03:30:21.508
BODY WILL GO BACK AND READ AND
03:30:21.575 --> 03:30:23.444
READ AND READ KINDLE AND RE
03:30:23.510 --> 03:30:29.416
SURFACED AND DEAL WITH THAT
03:30:29.483 --> 03:30:34.521
ISSUE THANK YOU.
03:30:34.588 --> 03:30:36.256
EARLY EVENING MADAM CHAIR
03:30:36.323 --> 03:30:37.424
MEMBERS RESENTED WITH THE
03:30:37.491 --> 03:30:39.493
WESTERN PETROLEUM ASSOCIATION BE
03:30:39.560 --> 03:30:40.361
VERY BRIEF.
03:30:40.427 --> 03:30:40.794
ENCOURAGED THAT THE
03:30:40.861 --> 03:30:41.462
CONVERSATIONS WE'VE HAD WITH THE
03:30:41.528 --> 03:30:42.196
AUTHOR STAFF AND PROVIDING
03:30:42.262 --> 03:30:43.464
INFORMATION AS TO YOU KNOW HOW
03:30:43.530 --> 03:30:46.233
WE CURRENTLY OPERATE AND TAKE
03:30:46.300 --> 03:30:48.302
THIS ISSUE VERY SERIOUSLY.
03:30:48.369 --> 03:30:49.169
WE JUST WANNA HIGHLIGHT THE THE
03:30:49.236 --> 03:30:49.770
THE BIG MAJOR CONCERN THAT WE
03:30:49.837 --> 03:30:50.971
HAVE WITH WITH THE BILL IS THE
03:30:51.038 --> 03:30:53.007
FINANCIAL ASSURANCE IS PEACE WE
03:30:53.073 --> 03:30:53.774
BASICALLY SEE IT AS IMPOSSIBLE
03:30:53.841 --> 03:30:54.742
OR VIRTUALLY IMPOSSIBLE TO ME
03:30:54.808 --> 03:30:55.042
GENERALLY.
03:30:55.109 --> 03:30:55.843
AS WE ARE CURRENTLY -- IMPORT
03:30:55.909 --> 03:30:57.344
OVER 70% OF OUR ENERGY NEEDS --
03:30:57.411 --> 03:30:58.545
IN ORDER TO PROVIDE
03:30:58.612 --> 03:31:00.114
TRANSPORTATION FIELD AND TO
03:31:00.180 --> 03:31:00.914
DRIVE CALIFORNIA'S ECONOMY --
03:31:00.981 --> 03:31:03.250
THIS COULD HAVE VERY VERY HUGE
03:31:03.317 --> 03:31:05.352
IMPLICATIONS AS TO YOU KNOW THE
03:31:05.419 --> 03:31:06.854
THE ABILITY FOR THESE VESSELS TO
03:31:06.920 --> 03:31:08.522
COME INTO OUR MARINE TERMINALS
03:31:08.589 --> 03:31:09.690
AND PROVIDE THAT FEES TALK FOR
03:31:09.757 --> 03:31:10.391
REFINERY SO.
03:31:10.457 --> 03:31:12.359
YOU KNOW TOP OF THE MARKET IS
03:31:12.426 --> 03:31:13.794
THE FINANCIAL ASSURANCE IS PEACE
03:31:13.861 --> 03:31:16.263
AFTER SOME OF THE THE PROVISIONS
03:31:16.330 --> 03:31:17.898
UNDER SECTION FIVE IN SECTION
03:31:17.965 --> 03:31:18.465
SIX THERE'S A WHOLE HOST OF
03:31:18.532 --> 03:31:20.901
ISSUES OR CURRENTLY WORKING --
03:31:20.968 --> 03:31:22.436
IT WHETHER IT'S A P. I. OR THE
03:31:22.503 --> 03:31:24.004
U. S. COAST GUARD TO PROVIDE
03:31:24.071 --> 03:31:25.172
SOME OF THIS INFORMATION THIS
03:31:25.239 --> 03:31:27.041
DATA THE STUDY SO -- WILL LOOK
03:31:27.107 --> 03:31:28.142
FOR TO CONTINUE THE CONVERSATION
03:31:28.208 --> 03:31:30.477
WITH THE AUTHOR AND HIS STAFF TO
03:31:30.544 --> 03:31:31.912
SEE WE CAN COME -- WHAT WAS SOME
03:31:31.979 --> 03:31:33.847
SORT OF SOLUTION TO BASICALLY
03:31:33.914 --> 03:31:35.649
YOU KNOW GET OUT TO WHAT HE'S
03:31:35.716 --> 03:31:36.917
TRYING TO DO WHICH IS?
03:31:36.984 --> 03:31:40.421
YOU KNOW A LOT OF LOCAL SO WE
03:31:40.487 --> 03:31:43.590
OPPOSE AT THIS TIME THANK YOU.
03:31:43.657 --> 03:31:44.725
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN
03:31:44.792 --> 03:31:45.392
COMMITTEE MEMBERS -- MY NAME IS
03:31:45.459 --> 03:31:46.393
JOHN BURKE I REPRESENT THE
03:31:46.460 --> 03:31:47.061
PACIFIC MERCHANT SHIPPING
03:31:47.127 --> 03:31:48.862
ASSOCIATION OUR MEMBERS ARE NON
03:31:48.929 --> 03:31:50.831
TANKER SHIPPING LINE SERVING
03:31:50.898 --> 03:31:53.000
CALIFORNIA -- WE HAVE BEEN
03:31:53.067 --> 03:31:54.435
OPPOSE UNLESS AMENDED POSITION
03:31:54.501 --> 03:31:56.703
ON THIS BILL -- SPECIFICALLY WE
03:31:56.770 --> 03:31:59.239
HAVE ONE ISSUE AND THAT IS WOULD
03:31:59.306 --> 03:32:02.042
BE WE VIEW IS THE OVERLY BROAD
03:32:02.109 --> 03:32:04.945
DEFINITION OF NONVOTING OILS TO
03:32:05.012 --> 03:32:07.414
INCLUDE -- MARINE FUEL OILS USED
03:32:07.481 --> 03:32:08.782
FOR PROPULSION WHICH ESSENTIALLY
03:32:08.849 --> 03:32:09.983
CAPTURES EVERY SHIP THAT COMES
03:32:10.050 --> 03:32:11.585
IN THE CALIFORNIA AND THIS IS
03:32:11.652 --> 03:32:13.187
DESPITE THE FACT THAT THESE
03:32:13.253 --> 03:32:16.090
FUELS ARE PROPERLY RESPONDED TO
03:32:16.156 --> 03:32:17.991
AS FLOATING OILS.
03:32:18.058 --> 03:32:19.693
IN THE EVENT OF A SPILL -- WE
03:32:19.760 --> 03:32:21.361
ACTUALLY FEEL CONFIDENT THAT WE
03:32:21.428 --> 03:32:22.763
CAN WORK WITH THE AUTHOR AND THE
03:32:22.830 --> 03:32:25.032
SPONSORS TO MORE NARROWLY
03:32:25.099 --> 03:32:26.433
ADDRESS THIS DEFINITION A WE
03:32:26.500 --> 03:32:28.635
NOTE THAT THE COMMITTEE ANALYSIS
03:32:28.702 --> 03:32:30.170
DID BRING UP THIS ISSUE AS WELL
03:32:30.237 --> 03:32:33.674
SO -- HOPEFULLY WE CAN RESOLVE
03:32:33.740 --> 03:32:35.843
THIS ISSUE.
03:32:35.909 --> 03:32:36.410
IN THE NEAR FUTURE.
03:32:36.477 --> 03:32:37.044
THANK YOU IS THERE ANYONE ELSE
03:32:37.111 --> 03:32:38.345
WISHING TO TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION
03:32:38.412 --> 03:32:41.315
TO THE BILL.
03:32:41.381 --> 03:32:41.515
OKAY.
03:32:41.582 --> 03:32:43.183
I ANY COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS FROM
03:32:43.250 --> 03:32:47.020
THE COMMITTEE MEMBERS.
03:32:47.087 --> 03:32:47.855
FACING THE MISTER RIVERS WOULD
03:32:47.921 --> 03:32:50.157
YOU LIKE TO CLOSE NO -- YOU KNOW
03:32:50.224 --> 03:32:52.626
AGAIN -- YOU KNOW MYSELF AND
03:32:52.693 --> 03:32:53.827
STAFF -- WILL CONTINUE TO WORK
03:32:53.894 --> 03:32:55.195
WITH THE OPPONENTS YOU KNOW TO
03:32:55.262 --> 03:32:56.763
ADDRESS THEIR CONCERNS ABOUT THE
03:32:56.830 --> 03:32:58.398
FINANCE ASSURANCES AND CERTAINLY
03:32:58.465 --> 03:33:00.167
THE DEFINITION OF NON FLOOD OIL
03:33:00.234 --> 03:33:01.568
BUT CERTAINLY THIS IS A BILL YOU
03:33:01.635 --> 03:33:02.236
KNOW IT'S A GOOD BILL WAS ABOUT
03:33:02.302 --> 03:33:04.571
SAFETY IT'S ABOUT PREPAREDNESS
03:33:04.638 --> 03:33:06.106
FOR OUR STATE FAR COAST. FOR OUR
03:33:06.173 --> 03:33:07.875
PRECIOUS RESOURCES ARE NATURAL
03:33:07.941 --> 03:33:09.743
RESOURCES YOU KNOW IT'S THAT WAS
03:33:09.810 --> 03:33:11.578
SEEN -- YOU KNOW A DEFINITION OF
03:33:11.645 --> 03:33:13.380
NOT FOR OIL MAKE USE THAT WE
03:33:13.447 --> 03:33:14.848
OFFER THE NOTIFICATION FOR
03:33:14.915 --> 03:33:16.016
EMERGENCY RESPONDERS BIGGEST AT
03:33:16.083 --> 03:33:16.617
WERE PLANNING YOU KNOW IN THE
03:33:16.683 --> 03:33:18.785
WAY OF OF WHAT TO EXPECT TO IF
03:33:18.852 --> 03:33:20.721
IF IF IF WE DO HAVE THIS BILL OF
03:33:20.787 --> 03:33:21.455
NOT FOR OIL.
03:33:21.522 --> 03:33:22.589
AND THEN FINALLY MAKING SURE
03:33:22.656 --> 03:33:24.358
THAT THOSE THAT ARE TRANSPORT IT
03:33:24.424 --> 03:33:24.892
DO HAVE THE FIND AT THE
03:33:24.958 --> 03:33:27.361
APPROPRIATE FINANCIAL ASSURANCES
03:33:27.427 --> 03:33:32.666
TO MAKE SURE THAT ANY SPILL THE
03:33:32.733 --> 03:33:36.937
FUTURE -- THAT -- IT'S COVERED
03:33:37.004 --> 03:33:38.972
SO HOW YOU KNOW WHAT THAT I
03:33:39.039 --> 03:33:39.540
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR EITHER
03:33:39.606 --> 03:33:40.674
THANK YOU VERY MUCH WE HAVE A
03:33:40.741 --> 03:33:42.442
MOTION AND A SECOND AND WE HAVE
03:33:42.509 --> 03:33:43.043
A ROLL CALL PLEASE.
03:33:43.110 --> 03:33:45.479
I'D IN FIFTEEN EIGHTY NINE
03:33:45.546 --> 03:33:46.113
THIRTY SIX FOR ASSEMBLY MEMBER
03:33:46.180 --> 03:33:47.581
ROBERT REVERSED MOTION IS TO
03:33:47.648 --> 03:33:49.216
PASS AS AMENDED AND REFER TO
03:33:49.283 --> 03:33:51.018
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE MEMBERS
03:33:51.084 --> 03:33:55.422
FRIEDMAN YES FRIEDMAN AYE FLORA.
03:33:55.489 --> 03:33:55.622
CHAU.
03:33:55.689 --> 03:33:57.457
EGGMAN.
03:33:57.524 --> 03:34:00.060
EGGMAN AYE GARCIA.
03:34:00.127 --> 03:34:02.496
GARCIA ISLA MON.
03:34:02.563 --> 03:34:03.964
Là MON I MATHIS.
03:34:04.031 --> 03:34:08.035
MATHIS NO MCCARTY.
03:34:08.101 --> 03:34:12.706
MELENDEZ MURATSUCHI STONE
03:34:12.773 --> 03:34:13.006
[inaudible]
03:34:13.073 --> 03:34:17.277
STONE I FIVE ONE YOU HAVE FIVE
03:34:17.344 --> 03:34:18.912
VOTES WILL LEAVE THE ROLE OPEN
03:34:18.979 --> 03:34:20.214
FOR ABSENT MEMBERS.
03:34:20.280 --> 03:34:21.882
YOU HAVE SIXTEEN TWENTY EIGHT
03:34:21.949 --> 03:34:23.550
YES SO -- THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR
03:34:23.617 --> 03:34:25.953
LAST YEAR OUR ATTORNEY GENERAL
03:34:26.019 --> 03:34:26.753
HOBBY OF THE SERRA ESTABLISHED
03:34:26.820 --> 03:34:27.821
THE BUREAU OF ENVIRONMENTAL
03:34:27.888 --> 03:34:29.923
JUSTICE. TO PROTECT PEOPLE AND
03:34:29.990 --> 03:34:31.225
OUR COMMUNITIES THAT INDOOR A
03:34:31.291 --> 03:34:33.026
DISPROPORTIONATE SHARE OF
03:34:33.093 --> 03:34:34.094
ENVIRONMENTAL POLLUTION.
03:34:34.161 --> 03:34:35.662
THROUGH OVERSIGHT INVESTIGATION
03:34:35.729 --> 03:34:36.396
AND ENFORCEMENT OF THE LAW.
03:34:36.463 --> 03:34:37.898
AB SIXTY TWENTY EIGHT WOULD
03:34:37.965 --> 03:34:39.800
RECOGNIZE THE BUREAU IN STATUTE
03:34:39.866 --> 03:34:40.300
AS A PERMANENT ENTITY.
03:34:40.367 --> 03:34:41.401
AND WHAT STATE THE INTENT OF THE
03:34:41.468 --> 03:34:42.236
LEGISLATURE TO SUPPORT THE
03:34:42.302 --> 03:34:42.869
ATTORNEY GENERAL IN SECURING THE
03:34:42.936 --> 03:34:44.004
RESOURCES NECESSARY TO SUPPORT
03:34:44.071 --> 03:34:44.871
THE BUREAU.
03:34:44.938 --> 03:34:46.006
RESEARCH RESEARCH SHOWS THAT
03:34:46.073 --> 03:34:47.641
POOR PEOPLE AND PEOPLE OF COLOR
03:34:47.708 --> 03:34:48.508
INDOOR A DISPROPORTIONATE SHARE
03:34:48.575 --> 03:34:49.977
OF ENVIRONMENTAL POLLUTION AND
03:34:50.043 --> 03:34:51.945
PUBLIC HEALTH HAZARDS WHERE THEY
03:34:52.012 --> 03:34:53.513
LIVE WHERE THEY WORK.
03:34:53.580 --> 03:34:55.749
AND WHERE THEY GO TO SCHOOL.
03:34:55.816 --> 03:34:57.217
THESE FRONTLINE -- THESE
03:34:57.284 --> 03:34:59.286
COMMUNITIES OFTEN LACK RESOURCES
03:34:59.353 --> 03:35:00.954
AND OPPORTUNITIES TO COMBAT
03:35:01.021 --> 03:35:03.056
ENVIRONMENTAL HARMS AND ARE
03:35:03.123 --> 03:35:05.492
DENIED A VOICE IN KEY DECISIONS
03:35:05.559 --> 03:35:07.227
THAT IMPACT THEIR HEALTH.
03:35:07.294 --> 03:35:09.096
THIS BILL ALSO AS THE TERM
03:35:09.162 --> 03:35:10.864
MEANINGFUL ENGAGEMENT TO THE
03:35:10.931 --> 03:35:12.532
DEFINITION OF ENVIRONMENTAL
03:35:12.599 --> 03:35:13.900
JUSTICE TO SURE THAT FAIR
03:35:13.967 --> 03:35:15.402
TREATMENT AND MEANINGFUL
03:35:15.469 --> 03:35:16.603
ENGAGEMENT OF PEOPLE.
03:35:16.670 --> 03:35:18.905
OF ALL RACES CULTURES AND
03:35:18.972 --> 03:35:20.274
INCOMES WITH RESPECT TO THE
03:35:20.340 --> 03:35:21.875
DEVELOPMENT ADOPTION
03:35:21.942 --> 03:35:23.644
IMPLEMENTATION AND ENFORCEMENT
03:35:23.710 --> 03:35:25.946
OF ENVIRONMENTAL LAWS
03:35:26.013 --> 03:35:27.981
REGULATIONS AND POLICIES -- MY
03:35:28.048 --> 03:35:29.216
WITNESS HERE TODAY I CAN
03:35:29.283 --> 03:35:33.453
INTRODUCE THEMSELVES BUT AGAIN.
03:35:33.520 --> 03:35:36.690
THIS IS AB SIXTY TWENTY THANK
03:35:36.757 --> 03:35:36.857
YOU.
03:35:36.923 --> 03:35:38.058
THANK YOU.
03:35:38.125 --> 03:35:39.192
HI GOOD EVENING MADAM CHAIR
03:35:39.259 --> 03:35:40.927
MEMBERS -- MY NAME IS TIFFANY
03:35:40.994 --> 03:35:43.497
ING AND WITH THE CALIFORNIA
03:35:43.563 --> 03:35:44.131
ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE LANCER SO
03:35:44.197 --> 03:35:44.531
HOT.
03:35:44.598 --> 03:35:45.098
I'M HERE TODAY TO SHARE OUR
03:35:45.165 --> 03:35:48.702
STRONG SUPPORT FOR A BI.
03:35:48.769 --> 03:35:49.503
SIXTEEN TWENTY EIGHT AS A KAMALA
03:35:49.569 --> 03:35:51.605
ALLIANCE A BILL TO POWER OF
03:35:51.672 --> 03:35:52.472
VARIOUS ORGANIZATIONS TO CHEER
03:35:52.539 --> 03:35:53.507
VINYL JUSTICE SOLUTIONS ACROSS
03:35:53.573 --> 03:35:55.008
CALIFORNIA.
03:35:55.075 --> 03:35:56.743
WE DEEPLY UNDERSTAND HOW
03:35:56.810 --> 03:35:57.878
IMPORTANT THE EASIER IT IS TO
03:35:57.944 --> 03:36:00.681
THE PEOPLE AND NEIGHBORHOODS
03:36:00.747 --> 03:36:02.449
THAT WE WORK WITH.
03:36:02.516 --> 03:36:03.550
FROM ENSURING THAT LAND USE
03:36:03.617 --> 03:36:06.553
DECISIONS CONSIDER VINYL JUSTICE.
03:36:06.620 --> 03:36:07.854
TO HOLDING BIG PUSH ACCOUNTABLE
03:36:07.921 --> 03:36:08.455
FOR THE HARM THEY FLIPPED ON
03:36:08.522 --> 03:36:10.157
MANY LOW INCOME RESIDENTS AND
03:36:10.223 --> 03:36:10.590
COMMITTEES A COLOR.
03:36:10.657 --> 03:36:12.859
WE HAVE SEEN FIRST HAND HOW THE
03:36:12.926 --> 03:36:13.593
EGYPTAIR HAS MADE A DIFFERENCE
03:36:13.660 --> 03:36:15.729
AND SHOULD BE ABLE TO CONSULT
03:36:15.796 --> 03:36:17.998
WITH OTHER STATE AGENCIES AND
03:36:18.065 --> 03:36:21.702
OFFICES SUCH AS OPR. TO
03:36:21.768 --> 03:36:24.471
COORDINATE PROGRAMS AND EFFORTS.
03:36:24.538 --> 03:36:25.772
SECOND MABEL COMMUNICATION IS
03:36:25.839 --> 03:36:26.940
OBVIOUSLY CRITICAL TO THE
03:36:27.007 --> 03:36:27.874
DEFINITION OF ENVIRONMENTAL
03:36:27.941 --> 03:36:30.944
JUSTICE WE STRONGLY BELIEVE THAT
03:36:31.011 --> 03:36:33.080
ATTY MEANINGFUL GAUGE WENT TO
03:36:33.146 --> 03:36:33.647
THE STATE'S DEFINITION VIRAL
03:36:33.714 --> 03:36:33.914
JUSTICE.
03:36:33.980 --> 03:36:34.848
WOULD SEND A CLEAR MESSAGE TO
03:36:34.915 --> 03:36:36.883
THIS TO OTHERS THAT FRONTLINE OR
03:36:36.950 --> 03:36:37.818
FENCE LIKE COMMUNITIES SHOULD
03:36:37.884 --> 03:36:40.253
HAVE A RIGHT TO BE NOTIFIED AND
03:36:40.320 --> 03:36:41.021
HAVE A VOICE THESE APPOINT
03:36:41.088 --> 03:36:42.489
SURGEONS -- FOR THESE REASONS WE
03:36:42.556 --> 03:36:43.990
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR AYE
03:36:44.057 --> 03:36:45.692
VOTE AND LOOK FOR TO WORK WITH
03:36:45.759 --> 03:36:46.493
SOME REMEMBER REAVIS AS THE BILL
03:36:46.560 --> 03:36:47.694
MOVES FORWARD TO THE PROCESS
03:36:47.761 --> 03:36:47.994
THANK YOU.
03:36:48.061 --> 03:36:49.229
THANK YOU VERY MUCH IS THERE
03:36:49.296 --> 03:36:49.763
ANYONE ELSE WHO WISHES TO
03:36:49.830 --> 03:36:57.437
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL.
03:36:57.504 --> 03:36:59.005
LARA GONNA BE ALPHA SIERRA CLUB
03:36:59.072 --> 03:37:00.340
CALIFORNIANS SUPPORT.
03:37:00.407 --> 03:37:03.243
THANK YOU IS THERE ANY MEMBER OF
03:37:03.310 --> 03:37:03.877
THE PUBLIC IN OPPOSITION TO THE
03:37:03.944 --> 03:37:05.912
BILL.
03:37:05.979 --> 03:37:08.548
OKAY.
03:37:08.615 --> 03:37:09.149
THANK YOU MISTER RIVERS WOULD
03:37:09.216 --> 03:37:09.583
YOU LIKE TO CLOSE.
03:37:09.649 --> 03:37:10.717
OR FAR IS ANY COMMITTEE MEMBER
03:37:10.784 --> 03:37:13.053
HAVE ANY COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS
03:37:13.120 --> 03:37:14.454
OKAY WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE.
03:37:14.521 --> 03:37:17.023
SURE AND YOU KNOW AGAIN.
03:37:17.090 --> 03:37:18.191
THIS BILL SUPPORTED TO JONES
03:37:18.258 --> 03:37:22.329
MISSION TO PROTECT VULNERABLE --
03:37:22.396 --> 03:37:23.630
SOME COMMUNITIES IN OUR STATE
03:37:23.697 --> 03:37:24.664
AND TO FURTHER MEANINGFUL
03:37:24.731 --> 03:37:27.334
ENGAGEMENT EFFORTS TO COMBAT BY
03:37:27.401 --> 03:37:29.269
MIDDLE HAZARDS I RESPECT THAT.
03:37:29.336 --> 03:37:30.070
THANK YOU VERY MUCH OF A MOTION
03:37:30.137 --> 03:37:31.338
AND SECOND CAN WE HAVE A ROLL
03:37:31.405 --> 03:37:31.872
CALL PLEASE.
03:37:31.938 --> 03:37:34.741
ITEM TWENTY SEVEN A. B. SIXTEEN
03:37:34.808 --> 03:37:35.375
TWENTY EIGHT BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER
03:37:35.442 --> 03:37:36.343
ROBERT RIVAS THE MOTION IS TO
03:37:36.410 --> 03:37:38.512
PASS AND REFER TO JUDICIARY
03:37:38.578 --> 03:37:39.613
COMMITTEE.
03:37:39.679 --> 03:37:41.782
MEMBERS FRIEDMAN AYE FRIEDMAN
03:37:41.848 --> 03:37:45.685
AYE FLORA CHAU EGGMAN.
03:37:45.752 --> 03:37:47.921
EGGMAN AYE GARCIA.
03:37:47.988 --> 03:37:54.094
GARCIA I LOW MOAN.
03:37:54.161 --> 03:37:56.163
LIMON AYE MATHIS.
03:37:56.229 --> 03:37:59.232
MATHIS NO MCCARTY.
03:37:59.299 --> 03:38:02.969
MELENDEZ WHERE THIRTY STONE
03:38:03.036 --> 03:38:03.270
[inaudible]
03:38:03.336 --> 03:38:09.843
STONE I I WANT TO GIVE I FOR ONE
03:38:09.910 --> 03:38:12.712
BELIEVE THE ROLE OPEN.
03:38:12.779 --> 03:38:19.886
SOMEONE ARE CALDERON.
03:38:19.953 --> 03:38:20.620
GOOD.
03:38:20.687 --> 03:38:22.122
EVENING MADAM CHAIR [inaudible]
03:38:22.189 --> 03:38:24.124
AND MEMBERS.
03:38:24.191 --> 03:38:25.792
YOUR TIME THIS EVENING -- I'M
03:38:25.859 --> 03:38:26.393
HERE TODAY TO PRESENT AB NINE
03:38:26.460 --> 03:38:29.162
SEVEN FIVE CAL ADAPTATION
03:38:29.229 --> 03:38:31.131
LEADERSHIP AND COORDINATION ACT
03:38:31.198 --> 03:38:31.698
TWENTY NINETEEN AND IT WILL
03:38:31.765 --> 03:38:33.033
REQUIRE THE SECRETARY OF NATURAL
03:38:33.099 --> 03:38:34.568
RESOURCES AGENCY TO COLLABORATE
03:38:34.634 --> 03:38:36.336
WITH OUTSIDE NATIONS. TO SUPPORT
03:38:36.403 --> 03:38:37.971
AND PROMOTE THE GOALS POLICIES
03:38:38.038 --> 03:38:39.506
INVEST MANAGER PROCESS PRACTICES
03:38:39.573 --> 03:38:40.941
RELATING TO OUR GLOBALLY SHARED
03:38:41.007 --> 03:38:42.342
OCEAN ESSENTIALLY WE JUST WANT
03:38:42.409 --> 03:38:44.010
MORE COMMUNICATION BETWEEN NOT
03:38:44.077 --> 03:38:44.878
JUST OURSELVES WE'RE NOT ONLY
03:38:44.945 --> 03:38:45.879
TALKING WITH OURSELVES BUT THAT
03:38:45.946 --> 03:38:47.214
WE HAVE A MORE GLOBAL APPROACH
03:38:47.280 --> 03:38:48.482
WHEN IT COMES.
03:38:48.548 --> 03:38:49.449
TO OUR ENVIRONMENT AND WHAT
03:38:49.516 --> 03:38:50.650
WE'RE DOING WHEN IT COMES TO
03:38:50.717 --> 03:38:52.319
POLICIES ARE THERE TO PROTECT
03:38:52.385 --> 03:38:53.720
OUR OCEAN BECAUSE IT'S MAJORITY
03:38:53.787 --> 03:38:54.621
OF THE WORLD.
03:38:54.688 --> 03:38:55.722
GET THE FOOD FROM THE OCEAN AND
03:38:55.789 --> 03:38:56.623
SO WE ALL NEED TO BE TALKING TO
03:38:56.690 --> 03:38:58.024
EACH OTHER SO THAT A PARENT
03:38:58.091 --> 03:38:59.426
POLICIES RUN CONGRUENT WITH ONE
03:38:59.493 --> 03:39:00.227
ANOTHER.
03:39:00.293 --> 03:39:01.795
AND WE'RE NOT MISSING EACH OTHER
03:39:01.862 --> 03:39:02.562
BECAUSE WE'RE NOT COMMUNICATING
03:39:02.629 --> 03:39:03.096
AND SO THIS IS JUST GONNA
03:39:03.163 --> 03:39:04.598
MANDATE THAT COMMUNICATION AND
03:39:04.664 --> 03:39:09.035
SO WITH THAT I RESPECTFULLY ASK --
03:39:09.102 --> 03:39:11.238
FOR A YEAR I VOTE ON THE SUPPORT
03:39:11.304 --> 03:39:12.939
BILL.
03:39:13.006 --> 03:39:13.573
THANK YOU AND YOU HAVE WITNESSES
03:39:13.640 --> 03:39:13.874
IN SUPPORT.
03:39:13.940 --> 03:39:16.510
YES GOOD AFTERNOON OR GOOD
03:39:16.576 --> 03:39:18.378
EVENING I GUESS MADAM CHAIR AND
03:39:18.445 --> 03:39:18.945
COMMITTEE MEMBERS MY NAME'S
03:39:19.012 --> 03:39:19.846
GEORGE CENTER FOR MOTION
03:39:19.913 --> 03:39:20.447
CONSERVANCY -- AS I MENTIONED
03:39:20.514 --> 03:39:21.581
EARLIER THIS AFTERNOON FOR FORTY
03:39:21.648 --> 03:39:22.516
YEARS WE'VE WORKED ON CONFRONTED
03:39:22.582 --> 03:39:24.684
SOME OF THE BIGGEST HALLENGES
03:39:24.751 --> 03:39:26.419
TO HEALTHY OCEANS AND VIBRANT
03:39:26.486 --> 03:39:27.420
COASTAL COMMUNITIES.
03:39:27.487 --> 03:39:28.555
A DECADE AGO CLIMATE CHANGE IS
03:39:28.622 --> 03:39:30.357
REALLY A FUTURE THREAT BUT TODAY
03:39:30.423 --> 03:39:31.858
IT IS HERE IN FULL FORCE BOTH ON
03:39:31.925 --> 03:39:33.293
LAND AND IN THE OCEAN -- AND
03:39:33.360 --> 03:39:34.461
WHILE MITIGATION OF CARBON
03:39:34.528 --> 03:39:35.695
EMISSIONS IS CRITICAL TO A
03:39:35.762 --> 03:39:37.597
STABLE CLIMATE IN THE LONG TERM
03:39:37.664 --> 03:39:39.266
WE NEED TO EXPAND OUR EFFORTS.
03:39:39.332 --> 03:39:40.667
TO ADAPT TO THE CHANGES THAT ARE
03:39:40.734 --> 03:39:42.702
ALREADY UPON US -- AND THAT ARE
03:39:42.769 --> 03:39:44.437
PREDICTED TO CERTAINLY GET WORSE
03:39:44.504 --> 03:39:46.806
IN THE NEAR FUTURE AND THAT'S
03:39:46.873 --> 03:39:48.408
WHY I AM PLEASED TO SUPPORT A.
03:39:48.475 --> 03:39:49.743
B. AT NINE SEVENTY FIVE
03:39:49.809 --> 03:39:50.510
CONFRONTING CLIMATE CHANGE IS
03:39:50.577 --> 03:39:51.545
GOING TO REQUIRE ALL OF US TO
03:39:51.611 --> 03:39:53.146
WORK TOGETHER INCLUDING THOSE OF
03:39:53.213 --> 03:39:55.282
US IN CALIFORNIA -- BUT ALSO OUR
03:39:55.348 --> 03:39:55.849
FRIENDS AND OUR NEIGHBORING
03:39:55.916 --> 03:39:57.784
STATES -- AND OTHER COUNTRIES
03:39:57.851 --> 03:39:59.019
AROUND THE PACIFIC OR
03:39:59.085 --> 03:40:00.587
CONFRONTING SIMILAR CHALLENGES
03:40:00.654 --> 03:40:03.723
TIME IS NOT ON OUR SIDE AND
03:40:03.790 --> 03:40:05.158
MAXIMIZING KNOWLEDGE GENERATION.
03:40:05.225 --> 03:40:07.294
AND KNOWLEDGE TRANSFER IS REALLY
03:40:07.360 --> 03:40:08.795
CRITICAL TO SOLUTIONS.
03:40:08.862 --> 03:40:09.963
AT OCEAN CONSERVANCY WE'VE LONG
03:40:10.030 --> 03:40:11.064
SUPPORTED EFFORTS TO ENHANCE
03:40:11.131 --> 03:40:12.265
KNOWLEDGE DEVELOPMENT AND
03:40:12.332 --> 03:40:14.134
KNOWLEDGE TRANSFER AMONG
03:40:14.200 --> 03:40:15.869
OTHERWISE INDEPENDENT BODIES
03:40:15.936 --> 03:40:16.670
ESPECIALLY AROUND OCEAN CLIMATE
03:40:16.736 --> 03:40:17.404
CHANGE.
03:40:17.470 --> 03:40:19.306
WE ONE OF THE FOUNDING MEMBERS
03:40:19.372 --> 03:40:21.508
OF THE INTERNATIONAL ALLIANCE TO
03:40:21.575 --> 03:40:22.976
COMBAT OCEAN ACIDIFICATION.
03:40:23.043 --> 03:40:24.844
AND WE HAVE ACTIVELY SUPPORTED
03:40:24.911 --> 03:40:25.912
THAT WORK EVER SINCE AND
03:40:25.979 --> 03:40:31.685
CALIFORNIA HAS BEEN A MAJOR
03:40:31.751 --> 03:40:33.520
CONTRIBUTOR TO THIS EFFORT --
03:40:33.587 --> 03:40:35.155
AND AS A RESULT THE ALLIANCE'S
03:40:35.221 --> 03:40:36.423
REALLY ACCELERATING ACTION AMONG
03:40:36.489 --> 03:40:37.958
GUN -- GOVERNMENTS AND OTHER
03:40:38.024 --> 03:40:38.992
ENTITIES SO AS CLIMATE CHANGE
03:40:39.059 --> 03:40:39.859
CONTINUES TO ACCELERATE
03:40:39.926 --> 03:40:41.194
CALIFORNIA MUST CONTINUE TO BE A
03:40:41.261 --> 03:40:42.028
CRITICAL VOICE ON ADAPTATION
03:40:42.095 --> 03:40:42.796
POLICY.
03:40:42.862 --> 03:40:43.563
APPLIED RESEARCH AND RENEWABLE
03:40:43.630 --> 03:40:44.664
ENERGY THE WORLD HAS A LOT TO
03:40:44.731 --> 03:40:45.932
LEARN FROM OUR EFFORTS AND OUR
03:40:45.999 --> 03:40:47.834
LEADERSHIP AND SIMILARLY WE CAN
03:40:47.901 --> 03:40:49.903
BENEFIT FROM THE EXPERIENCE THAT
03:40:49.970 --> 03:40:51.571
MINIS -- OTHER ENTITIES ALSO
03:40:51.638 --> 03:40:53.707
ALSO GOING THROUGH SO WE ASK FOR
03:40:53.773 --> 03:40:55.208
YOUR SUPPORT A NINE SEVENTY FIVE
03:40:55.275 --> 03:40:57.377
TODAY THANK YOU.
03:40:57.444 --> 03:41:00.046
THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS.
03:41:00.113 --> 03:41:01.615
GOOD EVENING MADAM CHAIR
03:41:01.681 --> 03:41:02.215
COMMITTEE MEMBERS MY NAME IS
03:41:02.282 --> 03:41:02.716
JENNIFER SAVAGE ON THE
03:41:02.782 --> 03:41:04.317
CALIFORNIA POLICY MANAGER FOR
03:41:04.384 --> 03:41:05.752
SURFRIDER FOUNDATION.
03:41:05.819 --> 03:41:07.420
SURFRIDER WAS FOUNDED IN
03:41:07.487 --> 03:41:08.054
NINETEEN EIGHTY FOUR BY A SMALL
03:41:08.121 --> 03:41:09.656
GROUP OF SURFERS DETERMINED TO
03:41:09.723 --> 03:41:11.057
PROTECT THE WORLD'S OCEAN
03:41:11.124 --> 03:41:11.758
BEACHES IN WAVES.
03:41:11.825 --> 03:41:13.793
AT LAST COUNT WE HAD ONE HUNDRED
03:41:13.860 --> 03:41:15.061
AND SEVENTY VOLUNTEER LE
03:41:15.128 --> 03:41:16.329
CHAPTERS AT STUDENT CLUBS IN THE
03:41:16.396 --> 03:41:18.465
US INCLUDING TWENTY CHAPTERS
03:41:18.531 --> 03:41:19.432
HERE IN CALIFORNIA.
03:41:19.499 --> 03:41:20.500
I'M VERY PLEASED TO EXPRESS OUR
03:41:20.567 --> 03:41:22.469
STRONG SUPPORT FOR A BI NINE
03:41:22.535 --> 03:41:23.303
SEVEN FIVE TODAY.
03:41:23.370 --> 03:41:25.271
AND WILL NOT EVERYONE WHO IS
03:41:25.338 --> 03:41:26.773
PART OF SURFRIDER SERVICE I
03:41:26.840 --> 03:41:27.407
THINK IT'S FAIR TO SAY MOST OF
03:41:27.474 --> 03:41:28.842
US DO AND WHEN IT COMES TO THE
03:41:28.908 --> 03:41:30.410
IMPACTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON OUR
03:41:30.477 --> 03:41:31.745
CO SURFERS ARE AMONG THOSE ON
03:41:31.811 --> 03:41:32.612
THE FRONT LINES.
03:41:32.679 --> 03:41:34.214
READ THE BEACH IN THE WATER IN
03:41:34.280 --> 03:41:37.050
THE WATER EVERY DAY COLLECTIVELY.
03:41:37.117 --> 03:41:37.817
A MANY OF CALIFORNIA'S BEACHES
03:41:37.884 --> 03:41:38.351
AS YOU PROBABLY KNOW ARE
03:41:38.418 --> 03:41:40.854
EXPECTED TO DISAPPEAR IN THE
03:41:40.920 --> 03:41:42.288
NEXT EIGHTY YEARS DO YOU SEE
03:41:42.355 --> 03:41:43.256
LEVEL RISE.
03:41:43.323 --> 03:41:44.724
IT'S ALSO LIKELY TO DO MANY IF
03:41:44.791 --> 03:41:46.493
NOT MOST OF CALIFORNIA'S ICONIC
03:41:46.559 --> 03:41:47.827
SURF BREAKS WHICH IS A RATHER
03:41:47.894 --> 03:41:51.131
SAD FOLLOW UP TO AN ACTIVITY
03:41:51.197 --> 03:41:51.731
THAT WE JUST MADE THE STATE'S
03:41:51.798 --> 03:41:52.699
SPORT.
03:41:52.766 --> 03:41:54.000
AND WHETHER OR NOT PEOPLE GET TO
03:41:54.067 --> 03:41:54.968
PLAY THE COAST MIGHT NOT SEEM
03:41:55.035 --> 03:41:56.269
LIKE A PRIORITY ISSUE BUT SEA
03:41:56.336 --> 03:41:56.803
LEVEL RISE IS ONE OF THE
03:41:56.870 --> 03:41:58.638
GREATEST THREATS TO CALIFORNIA'S
03:41:58.705 --> 03:42:00.974
ECONOMY OUT WAIT EVEN WILD FIRES
03:42:01.041 --> 03:42:01.875
AND EARTHQUAKES.
03:42:01.941 --> 03:42:03.410
ACCORDING TO A MAJOR NEW STUDY
03:42:03.476 --> 03:42:05.245
BY USGS RESEARCHERS AND OTHER
03:42:05.311 --> 03:42:07.547
SCIENTIST THEY FOUND THAT RISING
03:42:07.614 --> 03:42:08.815
SEAS AND STORMS WILL DEVASTATE
03:42:08.882 --> 03:42:10.417
CALIFORNIA AT THE TURN OF THE
03:42:10.483 --> 03:42:11.785
CENTURY WITH IMPACTS OCCURRING
03:42:11.851 --> 03:42:13.586
AS EARLY AS TWENTY FORTY AND AS
03:42:13.653 --> 03:42:14.587
YOU KNOW THE FISCAL IMPACTS OUR
03:42:14.654 --> 03:42:16.122
ENVIRONMENT TRANSLATE INTO SOCIO
03:42:16.189 --> 03:42:17.090
ECONOMIC ONCE BOTH.
03:42:17.157 --> 03:42:19.459
THE COAST AND INLAND AREAS WILL
03:42:19.526 --> 03:42:21.294
FACE MAJOR FINANCIAL LOSSES.
03:42:21.361 --> 03:42:22.929
WITH ALL THIS AT RISK CLIMATE
03:42:22.996 --> 03:42:24.130
CHANGE MUST BE ADDRESSED IN
03:42:24.197 --> 03:42:26.566
COORDINATION WITH AT A MINIMUM
03:42:26.633 --> 03:42:28.468
OUR NEAREST NEIGHBORS WHICH THE
03:42:28.535 --> 03:42:29.602
STATE HAS BEEN DOING THAT ALMOST
03:42:29.669 --> 03:42:30.570
WHOLLY THROUGH UNILATERAL
03:42:30.637 --> 03:42:33.473
ACTIONS BY PAST GOVERNORS.
03:42:33.540 --> 03:42:35.175
AB NINE SEVEN FIVE AND IT'S FOR
03:42:35.241 --> 03:42:36.342
ENGAGEMENT IN MULTI STATE IN
03:42:36.409 --> 03:42:37.610
INTERNATIONAL ACTIVITIES.
03:42:37.677 --> 03:42:38.244
AND ENSURE THAT CLIMATE CHANGE
03:42:38.311 --> 03:42:39.612
ADAPTATION EFFORTS CONTINUE INTO
03:42:39.679 --> 03:42:41.781
THE FUTURE STRENGTHENING THE
03:42:41.848 --> 03:42:42.348
STATE'S COMMITMENT TO THESE
03:42:42.415 --> 03:42:43.750
EFFORTS GIVEN THE LEGISLATURE
03:42:43.817 --> 03:42:45.618
AND THE NATURAL RESOURCES AGENCY
03:42:45.685 --> 03:42:47.087
AN OVERDUE AND NECESSARY
03:42:47.153 --> 03:42:48.855
LEADERSHIP ROLE.
03:42:48.922 --> 03:42:52.192
WE THEREFORE EXPECT PLEA ASPIRIN
03:42:52.258 --> 03:42:53.693
AYE VOTE ON EIGHTY NINE SEVEN
03:42:53.760 --> 03:43:01.901
FIVE THANK YOU IF ANYONE ELSE
03:43:01.968 --> 03:43:02.502
WISHING TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF
03:43:02.569 --> 03:43:05.271
THE BILL.
03:43:05.338 --> 03:43:06.272
NATALIE KNOCKS ON BEHALF OF SAVE
03:43:06.339 --> 03:43:09.042
THE REDWOODS LEAGUE IN SUPPORT.
03:43:09.109 --> 03:43:09.676
FOR CALLING ON BEHALF OF SIERRA
03:43:09.743 --> 03:43:11.911
CLUB CALIFORNIANS SUPPORT.
03:43:11.978 --> 03:43:14.080
THERESA BROKERAGE ON BEHALF FEEL
03:43:14.147 --> 03:43:14.647
THE BAY IN THE CLEAN SEIZE
03:43:14.714 --> 03:43:15.248
LOBBYING COALITION IN SUPPORT
03:43:15.315 --> 03:43:15.882
I'VE ALSO BEEN ASKED TO REGISTER
03:43:15.949 --> 03:43:17.717
SUPPORT FOR THREE SIXTY BAY AREA
03:43:17.784 --> 03:43:18.351
ACTION THANK YOU.
03:43:18.418 --> 03:43:19.486
THANK YOU IS THERE ANYBODY IN
03:43:19.552 --> 03:43:21.988
OPPOSITION TO THE BILL WOULD
03:43:22.055 --> 03:43:24.157
LIKE TO SPEAK.
03:43:24.224 --> 03:43:25.825
OKAY ANY COMMENTS FROM COMMITTEE
03:43:25.892 --> 03:43:28.161
MEMBERS.
03:43:28.228 --> 03:43:29.329
OKAY YOU HAVE A MOTION IT UP
03:43:29.395 --> 03:43:31.264
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE.
03:43:31.331 --> 03:43:33.800
THANK YOU MEMBERS ARE TIME
03:43:33.867 --> 03:43:35.435
RESPECTFULLY ASK FROM ABOUT.
03:43:35.502 --> 03:43:38.171
THE CLOTHES OKAY EVEN MOTION THE
03:43:38.238 --> 03:43:39.839
SECOND MOVE A ROLL CALL PLEASE.
03:43:39.906 --> 03:43:42.075
I'D IN SIXTEEN EIGHTY NINE
03:43:42.142 --> 03:43:42.642
SEVENTY FIVE ASSEMBLY MEMBER
03:43:42.709 --> 03:43:43.409
CALDERON THE MOTION IS TO PASS
03:43:43.476 --> 03:43:44.444
REFER TO APPROPRIATIONS
03:43:44.511 --> 03:43:46.746
COMMITTEE MEMBERS FRIEDMAN HI
03:43:46.813 --> 03:43:49.549
FRIEDMAN I FLORA.
03:43:49.616 --> 03:43:51.618
CHAU.
03:43:51.684 --> 03:43:52.786
EGGMAN.
03:43:52.852 --> 03:43:56.256
EGGMAN AYE GARCIA GARCIA I
03:43:56.322 --> 03:43:58.458
LIMóN.
03:43:58.525 --> 03:43:59.793
LIMON AYE MATHIS.
03:43:59.859 --> 03:44:00.894
MATHIS NOT VOTING [inaudible]
03:44:00.960 --> 03:44:01.861
MCCARTY [inaudible]
03:44:01.928 --> 03:44:03.062
MELENDEZ.
03:44:03.129 --> 03:44:05.565
RIGHT TO CHOOSE [inaudible]
03:44:05.632 --> 03:44:07.066
STONE [inaudible]
03:44:07.133 --> 03:44:21.214
STONE I FLORA.
03:44:21.281 --> 03:44:29.789
FIVE ALL RIGHT FLORA I SIX ZERO
03:44:29.856 --> 03:44:30.690
SIX ZERO THE BILL IS OUT WILL
03:44:30.757 --> 03:44:31.424
LEAVE THE ROLE OKAY THANK YOU
03:44:31.491 --> 03:44:32.592
MEMBERS.
03:44:32.659 --> 03:44:34.861
THANK YOU WILL NOW MOVE TO BILLS
03:44:34.928 --> 03:44:38.731
AND COMMITTEE MEMBERS IN THIS
03:44:38.798 --> 03:44:53.279
LIMóN MISSION TO SPEAK IN
03:44:53.346 --> 03:44:54.714
SUPPORT OF THE BILL THANK YOU.
03:44:54.781 --> 03:44:56.549
THANK YOU ARE MADAM CHAIR AND
03:44:56.616 --> 03:44:58.084
MEMBERS SHERRY PEMBERTON ON
03:44:58.151 --> 03:44:58.985
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA STATE
03:44:59.052 --> 03:45:00.320
LANDS COMMISSION OR THE SPONSOR
03:45:00.386 --> 03:45:02.889
OF AB.
03:45:02.956 --> 03:45:03.489
FIVE EIGHTY FIVE WE THINK IT
03:45:03.556 --> 03:45:04.324
WILL GIVE THE COMMISSION MORE
03:45:04.390 --> 03:45:06.059
TOOLS TO PREVENT AN OIL AND GAS
03:45:06.125 --> 03:45:08.194
OPERATOR WHEN THEY MAY TRANSFER
03:45:08.261 --> 03:45:09.629
A LEASE TO ANOTHER ENTITY.
03:45:09.696 --> 03:45:10.396
FROM LEAVING THE STATE
03:45:10.463 --> 03:45:11.631
RESPONSIBLE FOR THE DE
03:45:11.698 --> 03:45:14.033
COMMISSIONING AND FINANCIAL
03:45:14.100 --> 03:45:16.569
LIABILITY -- WE HAVE HEARD THERE
03:45:16.636 --> 03:45:18.037
MIGHT BE SOME CONCERNED THAT IT
03:45:18.104 --> 03:45:19.038
MADE THIS INCENTIVIZE THE
03:45:19.105 --> 03:45:21.107
TRANSFER -- BUT THE THINGS THAT
03:45:21.174 --> 03:45:23.509
IT CODIFIES OUR OUR CONDITIONS
03:45:23.576 --> 03:45:25.311
OF THE COMMISSION ALREADY HAS TO
03:45:25.378 --> 03:45:26.446
ENSURE WHEN IT CONSIDERS A LEASE
03:45:26.512 --> 03:45:28.047
ASSIGNMENT OR TRANSFER SO IT'S
03:45:28.114 --> 03:45:29.582
VERY CONSISTENT WITH CURRENT LAN
03:45:29.649 --> 03:45:30.516
PRACTICE.
03:45:30.583 --> 03:45:31.517
AND IT WILL BETTER PROTECT THE
03:45:31.584 --> 03:45:33.119
STATE IN THE FUTURE WHEN THERE'S
03:45:33.186 --> 03:45:35.521
A POTENTIAL LEASE ASSIGNMENT OR
03:45:35.588 --> 03:45:37.357
TRANSFER.
03:45:37.423 --> 03:45:38.391
OKAY THANK YOU IS THERE ANYBODY
03:45:38.458 --> 03:45:39.025
ELSE WISHING TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT
03:45:39.092 --> 03:45:41.060
OF THE BILL.
03:45:41.127 --> 03:45:42.462
IS THERE ANYBODY HERE TO SPEAK
03:45:42.528 --> 03:45:46.032
IN OPPOSITION OF THE BILL.
03:45:46.099 --> 03:45:46.900
MANAGER MEMBERS WE CENTERS WITH
03:45:46.966 --> 03:45:47.634
THE WESTERN STATES PETROLEUM
03:45:47.700 --> 03:45:50.570
ASSOCIATION NO POSITION JUST ONE
03:45:50.637 --> 03:45:51.004
OF CONCERN.
03:45:51.070 --> 03:45:52.839
WE DID HAVE A QUICK CONVERSATION
03:45:52.906 --> 03:45:54.140
WITH THE STATE LANDS COMMISSION
03:45:54.207 --> 03:45:55.108
AND THE AUTHORS OFFICE.
03:45:55.174 --> 03:45:57.577
HOPE TO CONTINUE THAT DIALOGUE
03:45:57.644 --> 03:45:59.178
ARE ISSUES -- STEM WITH THE TWO
03:45:59.245 --> 03:46:01.080
YEAR REQUIREMENT FOR COMPLETE
03:46:01.147 --> 03:46:02.548
THE COMMISSIONING WE BELIEVE
03:46:02.615 --> 03:46:04.050
THAT THAT MIGHT BE PROBLEMATIC --
03:46:04.117 --> 03:46:05.885
IN CERTAIN INSTANCES THE SEEKER
03:46:05.952 --> 03:46:06.753
PROCESS TAKES OVER TWENTY FOUR
03:46:06.819 --> 03:46:08.254
MONTHS -- SO WOULD LIKE TO
03:46:08.321 --> 03:46:10.156
DISCUSS -- YOU KNOW HOW TO GET
03:46:10.223 --> 03:46:12.692
HOW TO APPROACH THAT ALSO THE
03:46:12.759 --> 03:46:14.427
THE LANGUAGE MAY BE.
03:46:14.494 --> 03:46:16.896
AMBIGUOUS OR OR CONFUSING AS IT
03:46:16.963 --> 03:46:19.832
RELATES TO THE TYPES OF
03:46:19.899 --> 03:46:20.833
FACILITIES SO AGAIN.
03:46:20.900 --> 03:46:22.068
JUST SOME AREAS OF CONCERNS AND
03:46:22.135 --> 03:46:22.702
WE LOOK FORWARD TO CONTINUE THE
03:46:22.769 --> 03:46:24.203
DIALOGUE WITH THE SPONSORS AND
03:46:24.270 --> 03:46:24.804
AND THE OTHERS OFFICE OF THANK
03:46:24.871 --> 03:46:26.105
YOU.
03:46:26.172 --> 03:46:27.473
THANK YOU VERY MUCH AS ANYBODY
03:46:27.540 --> 03:46:27.974
ELSE WISHING TO SPEAK IN
03:46:28.041 --> 03:46:31.311
OPPOSITION.
03:46:31.377 --> 03:46:32.845
OKAY ANY COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS
03:46:32.912 --> 03:46:37.483
FROM THE TWENTY FACING -- THIS
03:46:37.550 --> 03:46:38.084
ONE WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE I
03:46:38.151 --> 03:46:38.885
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE
03:46:38.952 --> 03:46:40.286
THANK YOU THERE'S A MOTION AND A
03:46:40.353 --> 03:46:41.187
SECOND WE HAVE A ROLL CALL
03:46:41.254 --> 03:46:41.888
PLEASE.
03:46:41.955 --> 03:46:44.123
I TO MATE AB FIVE EIGHTY FIVE BY
03:46:44.190 --> 03:46:44.857
ASSEMBLY MEMBER LIMóN THE
03:46:44.924 --> 03:46:46.526
MOTION IS TO PASS AND REFER TO
03:46:46.592 --> 03:46:48.294
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE MEMBERS
03:46:48.361 --> 03:46:53.333
FRIEDMAN HI FRIEDMAN I FLORA.
03:46:53.399 --> 03:46:54.834
OR NOT VOTING CHAU.
03:46:54.901 --> 03:46:55.868
EGGMAN.
03:46:55.935 --> 03:46:58.638
EGGMAN AYE GARCIA AYE GARCIA AYE
03:46:58.705 --> 03:47:01.808
LIMóN AYE LOW MOAN AYE MATHIS.
03:47:01.874 --> 03:47:04.243
MATHIS NOT VOTING MCCARTY.
03:47:04.310 --> 03:47:09.148
MCCARTY AYE MELENDEZ. TO TREAT.
03:47:09.215 --> 03:47:10.950
BREAST SURGERY AYE STONE
03:47:11.017 --> 03:47:11.250
[inaudible]
03:47:11.317 --> 03:47:14.387
OWN AYE. SEVEN ZERO SEVEN ZERO
03:47:14.454 --> 03:47:15.021
THE BILL IS OUT LEAVE THE ROLE
03:47:15.088 --> 03:47:15.822
OPEN AND YOUR NEXT BILL PLEASE
03:47:15.888 --> 03:47:16.122
THANK YOU.
03:47:16.189 --> 03:47:17.256
I WANTED TO START BY ACCEPTING
03:47:17.323 --> 03:47:18.558
THE COMMITTEES AMENDMENTS.
03:47:18.624 --> 03:47:20.093
AS OIL PRODUCTION CONTINUES TO
03:47:20.159 --> 03:47:21.361
DECLINE IN CALIFORNIA THERE IS
03:47:21.427 --> 03:47:22.261
GROWING CONCERN FROM OUR
03:47:22.328 --> 03:47:23.429
ENVIRONMENTAL GROUPS AND STATE
03:47:23.496 --> 03:47:24.964
REGULATORS THE OIL AND GAS
03:47:25.031 --> 03:47:27.867
INFRASTRUCTURE COULD BE DESERTED
03:47:27.934 --> 03:47:30.269
LEAVING THE TAX [inaudible]
03:47:30.336 --> 03:47:38.378
THE LEAVING TAXPAYERS TO ADDRESS
03:47:38.444 --> 03:47:39.278
THE RISK AND COVER THE COST OF
03:47:39.345 --> 03:47:40.446
OIL AND GAS PRODUCERS ACCEPT
03:47:40.513 --> 03:47:41.614
RESPONSIBILITY.%
03:47:41.681 --> 03:47:43.416
AT TO PLUG WELLS WHEN THEY ENTER
03:47:43.483 --> 03:47:45.451
INTO LEASES WITH THE STATE TO
03:47:45.518 --> 03:47:47.353
DRILL TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE OIL
03:47:47.420 --> 03:47:49.555
AND GAS -- BONDS ARE REQUIRED
03:47:49.622 --> 03:47:51.524
FROM OPERATORS AS PREREQUISITES
03:47:51.591 --> 03:47:52.592
TO OBTAIN PERMISSION TO DRILL
03:47:52.658 --> 03:47:54.360
WELLS IN THE EVENT A COMPANY
03:47:54.427 --> 03:47:56.129
WHETHER THROUGH BANKRUPTCY OR
03:47:56.195 --> 03:47:56.963
OTHER.
03:47:57.030 --> 03:47:58.765
EVENT CANNOT TO FILL THE STATURE
03:47:58.831 --> 03:48:00.500
IT THE STATUTORY OBLIGATION TO
03:48:00.566 --> 03:48:01.667
PLUG IN A BAND IN THE WELLS THE
03:48:01.734 --> 03:48:04.003
STATE CAN COLLECT IN OIL AND GAS.
03:48:04.070 --> 03:48:06.039
SURETY BOND TO PAY FOR THE
03:48:06.105 --> 03:48:08.007
CLEANUP THE CURRENT BOND LEVELS
03:48:08.074 --> 03:48:09.709
ARE WOEFULLY INADEQUATE TO COVER
03:48:09.776 --> 03:48:11.911
ME MEDIATION AND THE STATE MUST
03:48:11.978 --> 03:48:13.246
STEP UP TO PROTECT THE PUBLIC
03:48:13.312 --> 03:48:14.580
FROM BEARING THE COST OF
03:48:14.647 --> 03:48:17.016
DESERTED OIL AND GAS OPERATIONS.
03:48:17.083 --> 03:48:19.485
BASED ON CONSERVATIVE ESTIMATES
03:48:19.552 --> 03:48:22.088
COSTS PAYERS COSTS TO TAXPAYERS
03:48:22.155 --> 03:48:24.323
COULD BE AS HIGH AS TWO HUNDRED
03:48:24.390 --> 03:48:26.359
AND NINETY EIGHT MILLION PER TEN
03:48:26.426 --> 03:48:27.693
THOUSAND OIL WELLS.
03:48:27.760 --> 03:48:29.562
ASSEMBLY BILL TEN FIFTY SEVEN
03:48:29.629 --> 03:48:30.063
DOUBLES MINIMUM BONDING
03:48:30.129 --> 03:48:31.798
REQUIRING REQUIREMENTS FOR ON
03:48:31.864 --> 03:48:33.833
SHORE OIL AND GAS WELLS TO
03:48:33.900 --> 03:48:35.568
ENSURE THAT THE PUBLIC IS
03:48:35.635 --> 03:48:37.070
PROTECTED FROM ENVIRONMENTAL AND
03:48:37.136 --> 03:48:38.571
FINANCIAL LIABILITIES IN THE
03:48:38.638 --> 03:48:40.573
EVENT A COMPANY FAILS TO FILL
03:48:40.640 --> 03:48:41.774
THEIR LEGAL OBLIGATION TO
03:48:41.841 --> 03:48:42.842
DECOMMISSION.
03:48:42.909 --> 03:48:44.310
AND REMEDIATE OIL PRODUCTION
03:48:44.377 --> 03:48:46.112
SITES THIS BILL ALSO
03:48:46.179 --> 03:48:47.613
STRENGTHENED THE DIVISION OF OIL
03:48:47.680 --> 03:48:49.649
GAS AND GEOTHERMAL RESOURCES
03:48:49.715 --> 03:48:51.784
DAGR AUTHORITY TO REQUIRE
03:48:51.851 --> 03:48:54.020
ADDITIONAL BONDING REQUIREMENTS
03:48:54.087 --> 03:48:56.089
BASED ON THE LIKELY COST FOR
03:48:56.155 --> 03:48:58.357
FULL REMEDIATION AB TEN FIFTY
03:48:58.424 --> 03:48:59.092
SEVEN IS A BALANCED APPROACH
03:48:59.158 --> 03:49:00.426
THAT WILL PROTECT TAXPAYERS BY
03:49:00.493 --> 03:49:02.462
ENSURING THE STATE IS NOT LIABLE.
03:49:02.528 --> 03:49:03.930
IN THE EVENT AN OPERATOR FAILS
03:49:03.996 --> 03:49:05.531
TO FILL THEIR DUTY I HAVE WITH
03:49:05.598 --> 03:49:06.833
ME TODAY MELISSA FROM METAL FROM
03:49:06.899 --> 03:49:07.600
THE CALIFORNIA LEGAL
03:49:07.667 --> 03:49:10.203
CONSERVATION VOTERS AND UNFIT
03:49:10.269 --> 03:49:14.507
THOUGHT IT ON THOUGH WITH OB ON
03:49:14.574 --> 03:49:15.141
A LOT OF ON TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT
03:49:15.208 --> 03:49:16.943
OF THE BILL.
03:49:17.009 --> 03:49:17.810
THANK YOU SO EVER LIMóN -- GOOD
03:49:17.877 --> 03:49:19.245
EVENING CHAIR AND MEMBERS OF THE
03:49:19.312 --> 03:49:19.946
COMMITTEE -- MELISSA ROMERO WITH
03:49:20.012 --> 03:49:20.446
THE CALIFORNIA LEAGUE OF
03:49:20.513 --> 03:49:21.848
CONSERVATION VOTERS THERE ARE
03:49:21.914 --> 03:49:23.416
CURRENTLY THIRTY THOUSAND IDLE
03:49:23.483 --> 03:49:24.917
OIL WELLS IN THE STATE WITH
03:49:24.984 --> 03:49:26.619
NEARLY A QUARTER OF WHICH HAVE
03:49:26.686 --> 03:49:28.721
NOT PRODUCED OIL IN THE PAST
03:49:28.788 --> 03:49:29.555
TWENTY FIVE YEARS.
03:49:29.622 --> 03:49:30.923
IF THOSE THIRTY THOUSAND IDA
03:49:30.990 --> 03:49:31.891
WELLS IN THE STATE BECOME
03:49:31.958 --> 03:49:33.426
ORPHANED OR ABANDONED IT COULD
03:49:33.493 --> 03:49:35.128
EXPOSE TAXPAYERS TO SIGNIFICANT
03:49:35.194 --> 03:49:36.229
LIABILITY.
03:49:36.295 --> 03:49:37.396
IN ADDITION TO THE STATE'S
03:49:37.463 --> 03:49:38.898
EFFORTS TO INCREASE BOND LEVELS
03:49:38.965 --> 03:49:40.867
FOR OFFSHORE OIL AND GAS WE MUST
03:49:40.933 --> 03:49:42.368
ALSO ENSURE THAT FOR ON SHORE
03:49:42.435 --> 03:49:44.904
WELLS WHICH MAKE UP 97% OF ALL
03:49:44.971 --> 03:49:46.272
OF THE WELLS IN THE STATE.
03:49:46.339 --> 03:49:47.807
BOND LEVELS ARE ADEQUATE AND
03:49:47.874 --> 03:49:48.908
THAT THE STATE HAS THE TOOLS TO
03:49:48.975 --> 03:49:50.443
INCREASE THOSE BOND RATES IF
03:49:50.510 --> 03:49:51.944
NEEDED TO COVER THE FULL COST OF
03:49:52.011 --> 03:49:53.412
REMEDIATION AND THAT SECOND
03:49:53.479 --> 03:49:55.181
PIECE IS REALLY KEY BECAUSE THE
03:49:55.248 --> 03:49:56.182
COST TO PLUG.
03:49:56.249 --> 03:49:57.950
IN A BAND AN ON SHORE OIL WELLS
03:49:58.017 --> 03:49:59.619
VARIES GREATLY DEPENDING ON A
03:49:59.685 --> 03:50:01.454
NUMBER OF FACTORS INCLUDING WELL
03:50:01.521 --> 03:50:04.724
DEPTH AND PROXIMITY TO SENSITIVE
03:50:04.790 --> 03:50:05.324
COMMUNITIES.
03:50:05.391 --> 03:50:06.125
CALIFORNIA'S LEADING THE GLOBAL
03:50:06.192 --> 03:50:07.860
FIGHT AGAINSTCLIMATE CHANGE AND
03:50:07.927 --> 03:50:09.395
PART OF THAT FIGHT IS TO
03:50:09.462 --> 03:50:11.197
THOUGHTFULLY PLANNED AND MANAGED.
03:50:11.264 --> 03:50:13.666
FOR THE MANAGE DECLINE AND OUR
03:50:13.733 --> 03:50:17.170
RELIANCE ON ALL ON FOSSIL FUELS.
03:50:17.236 --> 03:50:18.671
IN TO MAKE SURE THAT LIABILITY
03:50:18.738 --> 03:50:20.239
FOR MEDIATION COSTS ARE PLACED
03:50:20.306 --> 03:50:21.874
ON THE PUBLIC THE VERY PEOPLE
03:50:21.941 --> 03:50:23.643
WHO ALREADY BEEN HARMED.
03:50:23.709 --> 03:50:24.343
BY THE POLLUTION AND
03:50:24.410 --> 03:50:25.811
ENVIRONMENTAL BURDENS BECAUSE BY
03:50:25.878 --> 03:50:26.846
THIS INDUSTRY.
03:50:26.913 --> 03:50:28.548
AB TEN FIFTY SEVEN IS A CRITICAL
03:50:28.614 --> 03:50:29.815
STEP THAT THE STATE MUST TAKE IN
03:50:29.882 --> 03:50:31.551
ORDER TO PROTECT TAXPAYERS AND
03:50:31.617 --> 03:50:33.486
IT'S PART OF AN OVERALL STRATEGY.
03:50:33.553 --> 03:50:34.787
TO THE FOR THE MANAGE DECLINE OF
03:50:34.854 --> 03:50:37.256
OIL PRODUCTION IN CALIFORNIA AND
03:50:37.323 --> 03:50:38.991
WE URGE YOUR SUPPORT OF THE BILL.
03:50:39.058 --> 03:50:41.060
THANK YOU IS ANYBODY ELSE WHICH
03:50:41.127 --> 03:50:42.461
SPEAK SUPPORT OF THE BILL.
03:50:42.528 --> 03:50:44.197
GOOD AFTERNOON MADAM CHAIR AND
03:50:44.263 --> 03:50:45.264
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE OF THE
03:50:45.331 --> 03:50:46.299
FEDERAL NAM BEHALF OF BOTTOM
03:50:46.365 --> 03:50:48.000
LINE CALIFORNIA I'LL BE BRIEF
03:50:48.067 --> 03:50:49.068
AND JUST OFFER TWO EXAMPLES I
03:50:49.135 --> 03:50:50.469
THINK THAT I THINK REALLY
03:50:50.536 --> 03:50:51.270
EMPHASIZE THE NEED FOR IT FOR
03:50:51.337 --> 03:50:53.472
THIS BILL -- YOU KNOW JUST LAST
03:50:53.539 --> 03:50:55.675
YEAR WE HAD A IN THE BUDGET --
03:50:55.741 --> 03:50:56.876
OVER A HUNDRED MILLION DOLLARS
03:50:56.943 --> 03:50:58.711
BEING YOUR MARKED -- TO DO THE
03:50:58.778 --> 03:51:00.546
REMEDIATION FOR PLATFORM HOLLY
03:51:00.613 --> 03:51:03.783
AND RINCON ISLAND.
03:51:03.849 --> 03:51:05.351
ALTHOUGH THOSE WERE OFF SHORE --
03:51:05.418 --> 03:51:07.253
I THINK IT EMPHASIZES THE NEED
03:51:07.320 --> 03:51:07.887
TO TO REALLY BE ABLE TO ADDRESS
03:51:07.954 --> 03:51:10.456
THIS -- HEAD ON BEFORE WE WE
03:51:10.523 --> 03:51:11.724
FIND OURSELVES IN ADDITIONAL
03:51:11.791 --> 03:51:13.259
SITUATIONS WHERE THE STATE OF
03:51:13.326 --> 03:51:15.094
CALIFORNIA HAS TO FOOT THE BILL --
03:51:15.161 --> 03:51:16.596
FOR THOSE REMEDIATION EFFORTS
03:51:16.662 --> 03:51:17.430
AND THE OTHER THING I WOULD
03:51:17.496 --> 03:51:20.099
MENTION TO IS THAT SINCE TWENTY
03:51:20.166 --> 03:51:20.733
SIXTEEN WHEN YOU HANDLE -- THE
03:51:20.800 --> 03:51:21.901
LAST UPDATE OF THESE --
03:51:21.968 --> 03:51:26.906
INDEMNITY BONDS -- WE'VE SEEN A
03:51:26.973 --> 03:51:28.674
LOT OF NEW ACTIONS AT THE
03:51:28.741 --> 03:51:29.342
FEDERAL LEVEL THAT ACTUALLY ROLL
03:51:29.408 --> 03:51:30.309
BACK PROTECTIONS VOTE FOR THE
03:51:30.376 --> 03:51:31.777
WAY THAT WE CAN PROTECT OUR ARE.
03:51:31.844 --> 03:51:32.712
SENSITIVE ECOSYSTEMS AND
03:51:32.778 --> 03:51:35.047
WILDLIFE -- WITH THE THE CASE IN
03:51:35.114 --> 03:51:36.482
POINT BEING THE ROLL BACKS RUN
03:51:36.549 --> 03:51:38.251
THE MIGRATORY BIRD TREATY ACT --
03:51:38.317 --> 03:51:39.986
BY THE CURRENT TO ACTING I
03:51:40.052 --> 03:51:41.454
INTERIOR SECRETARY MISTER BURN
03:51:41.520 --> 03:51:44.957
HARD -- AND THE CONTINUED A PUSH.
03:51:45.024 --> 03:51:46.525
TO TO REMOVE THOSE PROTECTIONS
03:51:46.592 --> 03:51:49.528
SO IT REALLY JUST ELEVATES FOR
03:51:49.595 --> 03:51:51.631
THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA THE AND
03:51:51.697 --> 03:51:52.365
THE NEED AND THAT.
03:51:52.431 --> 03:51:53.499
ULTIMATELY THE DESIRE OF
03:51:53.566 --> 03:51:54.467
LEGISLATORS -- LIKE SOMEONE FROM
03:51:54.533 --> 03:51:56.569
THE MON TO CONTINUE TO EMPHASIZE
03:51:56.636 --> 03:51:58.304
THOSE PROTECTIONS FOR CALIFORNIA
03:51:58.371 --> 03:51:59.939
SO WITH THAT -- RESPECTFULLY ASK
03:52:00.006 --> 03:52:01.073
FOR YOUR VOTE.
03:52:01.140 --> 03:52:01.807
THANK YOU OTHER MEMBERS OTHER
03:52:01.874 --> 03:52:04.577
PEOPLE IN SUPPORT VICTORIA ROME
03:52:04.644 --> 03:52:08.114
WITH ENERGY SEE IN SUPPORT.
03:52:08.180 --> 03:52:09.382
LAUREN COMMA SIERRA CLUB
03:52:09.448 --> 03:52:11.851
CALIFORNIANS SUPPORT.
03:52:11.917 --> 03:52:13.886
JAMIE GO ON BEHALF OF A SOUL IN
03:52:13.953 --> 03:52:14.320
SUPPORT.
03:52:14.387 --> 03:52:15.288
THANK YOU.
03:52:15.354 --> 03:52:16.956
IS THERE ANYBODY WISHING TO
03:52:17.023 --> 03:52:32.805
TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION.
03:52:32.872 --> 03:52:33.806
A GOOD EVENING GOOD EVENING
03:52:33.873 --> 03:52:35.041
MADAM CHAIR P. ANTHONY THOMAS
03:52:35.107 --> 03:52:36.876
REPRESENT CALIFORNIA INDEPENDENT
03:52:36.942 --> 03:52:39.278
PETROLEUM ASSOCIATION -- GIVEN
03:52:39.345 --> 03:52:40.980
THE OUR LET ME BE BRIEF AND JUST
03:52:41.047 --> 03:52:42.748
GET TO THE POINT.
03:52:42.815 --> 03:52:45.685
AND THAT IS -- AS COMPELLING.
03:52:45.751 --> 03:52:49.155
AS THE THE TESTIMONY WAS --
03:52:49.221 --> 03:52:50.489
WE'VE BEEN DOWN THIS ROADJUST
03:52:50.556 --> 03:52:53.626
RECENTLY AB TWENTY SEVEN TWENTY
03:52:53.693 --> 03:52:54.960
NINE CHAPLAIN IN TWENTY SIXTEEN
03:52:55.027 --> 03:52:55.561
MISTER WILLIAMS.
03:52:55.628 --> 03:52:58.497
DID EXACTLY WHAT FIVE EIGHTY
03:52:58.564 --> 03:53:00.032
FIVE IS ATTEMPTING TO DO.
03:53:00.099 --> 03:53:00.966
THERE'S A SECTION FIVE THAT BILL
03:53:01.033 --> 03:53:02.601
IT TALKED ABOUT THE DOLLAR
03:53:02.668 --> 03:53:04.537
AMOUNTS TO TWENTY FIVE DOLLARS
03:53:04.603 --> 03:53:06.639
FOR EACH WELL THAT IS LESS THAN
03:53:06.706 --> 03:53:08.274
TEN THOUSAND FEET. FORTY DOLLARS
03:53:08.341 --> 03:53:09.875
FOR EACH WELL THAT IS TEN
03:53:09.942 --> 03:53:11.510
THOUSAND OR MORE DEEP AND THEN
03:53:11.577 --> 03:53:12.912
OF COURSE WE GO TO THE INDEMNITY
03:53:12.978 --> 03:53:14.647
BONDS OF WHICH THE AUTHOR
03:53:14.714 --> 03:53:15.648
SPEAKING ABOUT.
03:53:15.715 --> 03:53:16.782
HIS WAS SET UP ON A TIERED
03:53:16.849 --> 03:53:19.318
SYSTEM I PERSONALLY WITH MY CEO
03:53:19.385 --> 03:53:21.153
HELP NEGOTIATE THIS PARTICULAR
03:53:21.220 --> 03:53:22.988
DEAL. TWO HUNDRED THOUSAND
03:53:23.055 --> 03:53:24.190
FOREIGN OPERATE HAVING FIFTY OR
03:53:24.256 --> 03:53:26.192
FEWER WELLS IN THE STATE FOUR
03:53:26.258 --> 03:53:27.159
HUNDRED DOLLARS FOR ANY OPERATOR
03:53:27.226 --> 03:53:29.061
HAVING MORE THAN FIFTY BUT NO
03:53:29.128 --> 03:53:30.896
MORE THAN FIVE HUNDRED WELLS.
03:53:30.963 --> 03:53:32.264
TWO MILLION DOLLAR BOND THERE'S
03:53:32.331 --> 03:53:33.799
A THREE MILLION DOLLAR BOND AND
03:53:33.866 --> 03:53:34.900
OF COURSE THERE ARE PENALTIES
03:53:34.967 --> 03:53:37.870
FOR NON COMPLIANCE RANGING FROM.
03:53:37.937 --> 03:53:38.504
ONE TO FIVE HUNDRED DOLLARS PER
03:53:38.571 --> 03:53:39.472
WELL.
03:53:39.538 --> 03:53:41.307
NOW IF IF IF IT'S THIS IF IT'S
03:53:41.374 --> 03:53:43.476
THE GOAL OF JETS TO INCREASE
03:53:43.542 --> 03:53:45.611
ANOTHER BOND AND AND ASSURE
03:53:45.678 --> 03:53:47.113
DIMOND AND THEN SO BE IT.
03:53:47.179 --> 03:53:49.014
BUT IF YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT REAL
03:53:49.081 --> 03:53:51.584
POLICY MADAM CHAIR TRUE POLICY
03:53:51.650 --> 03:53:57.523
AND THAT HAS TO DO WITH.
03:53:57.590 --> 03:53:59.325
IS THIS BEING APPLIED.
03:53:59.392 --> 03:54:00.693
FAIRLY AND ADEQUATELY TO PROTECT
03:54:00.760 --> 03:54:01.627
WHEN SHE REGARDLESS OF WHAT YOU
03:54:01.694 --> 03:54:02.428
THINK ABOUT IT THEN I THINK
03:54:02.495 --> 03:54:03.662
THAT'S THE QUESTION THAT YOU
03:54:03.729 --> 03:54:04.163
HAVE TO ASK YOURSELF AND
03:54:04.230 --> 03:54:04.463
HOPEFULLY.
03:54:04.530 --> 03:54:05.631
ANSWER IT ACCORDINGLY THIS
03:54:05.698 --> 03:54:07.199
INDUSTRY HAS IN FACT HAD THOSE
03:54:07.266 --> 03:54:08.934
BONDS TAKEN CARE OF THERE WAS
03:54:09.001 --> 03:54:11.771
ALSO A BILL BY FORMER MEMBER LOS
03:54:11.837 --> 03:54:14.540
WILK SB -- SIX SIX FIVE IN
03:54:14.607 --> 03:54:16.675
TWENTY FOURTEEN IT DID THE SAME
03:54:16.742 --> 03:54:17.943
THING SO ARBITRARILY.
03:54:18.010 --> 03:54:19.245
OR SPECIFICALLY RAISING BOND
03:54:19.311 --> 03:54:21.113
EVERY TWO OR THREE YEARS BECAUSE
03:54:21.180 --> 03:54:23.582
OF THE THOUGHT.
03:54:23.649 --> 03:54:24.650
BECAUSE OF THE THOUGHT THERE'S
03:54:24.717 --> 03:54:26.619
GOING TO BE DESERTED WELLS.
03:54:26.685 --> 03:54:28.354
IT IS INCONCEIVABLE ESPECIALLY
03:54:28.421 --> 03:54:29.655
AGAIN WHEN I SAY THAT WE ARE
03:54:29.722 --> 03:54:31.257
REGULATED UNDER THE MOST STRICT
03:54:31.323 --> 03:54:32.558
REGULATIONS IN THE COUNTRY IF
03:54:32.625 --> 03:54:33.859
NOT THE WORLD I THINK THE BILL
03:54:33.926 --> 03:54:35.494
SHOULD BE HELPED -- I THINK THAT
03:54:35.561 --> 03:54:36.862
WE SHOULD HAVE A LITTLE MORE
03:54:36.929 --> 03:54:38.330
CONVERSATION ABOUT WHAT IS BEING
03:54:38.397 --> 03:54:41.500
CURRENTLY PAID -- BY INDUSTRY
03:54:41.567 --> 03:54:43.369
AND I BELIEVE THAT -- HAVING
03:54:43.436 --> 03:54:44.537
THAT CONVERSATION -- COME OUT
03:54:44.603 --> 03:54:46.105
AND SHOW THAT WE ARE IN FACT
03:54:46.172 --> 03:54:48.741
PAYING ENOUGH I STAND AGAINST A
03:54:48.808 --> 03:54:49.875
STAND IN OPPOSITION TO THE BILL
03:54:49.942 --> 03:54:51.277
THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR FOR YOUR
03:54:51.343 --> 03:54:51.477
TIME.
03:54:51.544 --> 03:54:54.013
THANK YOU IS THERE ANYBODY ELSE
03:54:54.079 --> 03:54:56.015
IN OPPOSITION.
03:54:56.081 --> 03:54:57.283
HEY SEEING NONE ALL BRING IT
03:54:57.349 --> 03:54:58.350
BACK TO THE COMMITTEE.
03:54:58.417 --> 03:55:00.886
ARE THERE ANY QUESTIONS OR
03:55:00.953 --> 03:55:04.190
COMMENTS MANY MANY MEMBERS.
03:55:04.256 --> 03:55:05.391
OKAY WITH THAT MISSILE MOMENT TO
03:55:05.458 --> 03:55:06.325
LIKE TO CLOSE.
03:55:06.392 --> 03:55:08.627
YES THANK YOU AT THIS IS SIMPLY
03:55:08.694 --> 03:55:10.629
ABOUT ENSURING THAT TAXPAYERS
03:55:10.696 --> 03:55:12.364
DON'T HAVE TO PICK UP THE COST
03:55:12.431 --> 03:55:15.100
OF VITAL WELLS THE COST IS FAR
03:55:15.167 --> 03:55:17.436
MORE THAN WHAT THE CURRENT BONDS
03:55:17.503 --> 03:55:20.272
ARE -- TO BUY IDLE WELLS IN ECHO
03:55:20.339 --> 03:55:22.475
PARK NEAR TO MILLION DOLLARS
03:55:22.541 --> 03:55:25.077
THAT'S WAY MORE THAN THE THIRTY
03:55:25.144 --> 03:55:26.212
THOUSAND AND THAT IS EXPECTED
03:55:26.278 --> 03:55:27.713
FOR THEM SO I THINK.
03:55:27.780 --> 03:55:28.647
THIS IS REALLY ABOUT PROTECTING
03:55:28.714 --> 03:55:29.748
TAXPAYERS DOLLARS AND MAKING
03:55:29.815 --> 03:55:32.218
SURE THEY DON'T PICK UP THE COST
03:55:32.284 --> 03:55:33.385
OF THESE ABANDONED WELLS.
03:55:33.452 --> 03:55:36.755
OKAY THANK YOU WE HAVE A MOTION.
03:55:36.822 --> 03:55:38.023
OKAY WE HAVE A MOTION AND SECOND
03:55:38.090 --> 03:55:41.827
ROLL CALL PLEASE.
03:55:41.894 --> 03:55:44.763
YES SHE DID.
03:55:44.830 --> 03:55:46.165
YOUR SEVENTY MM I DID YES AT THE
03:55:46.232 --> 03:55:46.899
BEGINNING.
03:55:46.966 --> 03:55:49.034
ITEM SEVENTEEN A. B. TEN FIFTY
03:55:49.101 --> 03:55:49.668
SEVEN BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER LEMOND
03:55:49.735 --> 03:55:51.337
THE MOTION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED
03:55:51.403 --> 03:55:52.738
AND REFER TO APPROPRIATIONS
03:55:52.805 --> 03:55:53.606
COMMITTEE.
03:55:53.672 --> 03:55:55.574
MEMBERS FRIEDMAN HI FRIEDMAN
03:55:55.641 --> 03:55:56.709
I'VE FLORA.
03:55:56.775 --> 03:55:58.177
FLORA NO CHAU [inaudible]
03:55:58.244 --> 03:56:00.379
EGGMAN.
03:56:00.446 --> 03:56:02.848
EGGMAN AYE GARCIA.
03:56:02.915 --> 03:56:04.650
THE AYE LIMóN AYE LOW MOAN AYE
03:56:04.717 --> 03:56:06.619
MATHIS.
03:56:06.685 --> 03:56:08.554
MATHIS NO MCCARTY.
03:56:08.621 --> 03:56:11.790
MCCARTY AYE MELENDEZ EL MELENDEZ
03:56:11.857 --> 03:56:14.693
NO RIGHT TO CHEAT.
03:56:14.760 --> 03:56:15.794
RESEARCH THE AYE STONE
03:56:15.861 --> 03:56:16.095
[inaudible]
03:56:16.161 --> 03:56:20.399
JOHN I SEVEN THREE SEVEN TO
03:56:20.466 --> 03:56:21.233
THREE THANK YOU THE BILL WAS OUT
03:56:21.300 --> 03:56:22.701
MR STONE WOULD YOU LIKE TO
03:56:22.768 --> 03:56:30.910
PRESENT.
03:56:30.976 --> 03:56:34.547
THAT -- I'M SORRY.
03:56:34.613 --> 03:56:39.985
I MEAN JUST LIKE THEM YEAH.
03:56:40.052 --> 03:56:48.060
YEAH RIGHT OKAY.
03:56:48.127 --> 03:56:53.065
I HAVE BEEN MANY [inaudible]
03:56:53.132 --> 03:56:54.633
CONNECTION.
03:56:54.700 --> 03:57:01.974
I REMEMBER YEAH.
03:57:02.041 --> 03:57:02.541
MISTER SOME WHENEVER YOU'RE
03:57:02.608 --> 03:57:03.108
READY THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR
03:57:03.175 --> 03:57:05.010
MEMBERS FIRST OF ALL I'D LIKE TO
03:57:05.077 --> 03:57:05.578
THANK YOU COMMITTEE STAFFER
03:57:05.644 --> 03:57:06.211
WORKING WITH THIS AND I'M HAPPY
03:57:06.278 --> 03:57:06.779
TO ACCEPT THE AMENDMENTS.
03:57:06.845 --> 03:57:07.980
THAT ARE LISTED IN THE ANALYSIS
03:57:08.047 --> 03:57:08.647
THERE ON PAGE.
03:57:08.714 --> 03:57:09.848
FIVE AB FIVE FIFTY TO CREATE
03:57:09.915 --> 03:57:11.750
SAID COASTAL ADAPTATION ACCESS
03:57:11.817 --> 03:57:12.618
AND RESILIENCE PROGRAM.
03:57:12.685 --> 03:57:13.152
IN ORDER TO FUNDS CLIMATE
03:57:13.218 --> 03:57:14.553
ADAPTATION THAT WE SEE ALONG THE
03:57:14.620 --> 03:57:15.988
COAST [inaudible]
03:57:16.055 --> 03:57:17.323
CURRENTLY.
03:57:17.389 --> 03:57:19.091
THE STATE COLLECTS THAILAND'S
03:57:19.158 --> 03:57:22.194
REVENUES FROM OIL EXTRACTORS AND
03:57:22.261 --> 03:57:24.096
PRIOR TO TWO THOUSAND AND SIX
03:57:24.163 --> 03:57:26.599
THIS MONEY WAS AVAILABLE. TO GO
03:57:26.665 --> 03:57:27.666
TO FUND TO PROTECT NATURAL
03:57:27.733 --> 03:57:29.902
RESOURCES BUT AFTER TWO THOUSAND
03:57:29.969 --> 03:57:31.003
SIX THIS MONEY WAS SWEPT INTO
03:57:31.070 --> 03:57:32.137
THE STATE'S GENERAL FUND.
03:57:32.204 --> 03:57:34.039
IT'S PROBABLY ABOUT CURRENTLY
03:57:34.106 --> 03:57:35.574
TWENTY FIVE MILLION DOLLARS OR
03:57:35.641 --> 03:57:37.142
SO AND IT'S A BIT IT'S DECLINING
03:57:37.209 --> 03:57:39.144
BUT WHAT THIS BILL DOES IS TAKE
03:57:39.211 --> 03:57:40.079
30% OF THOSE REVENUES SAID JUST
03:57:40.145 --> 03:57:41.747
PART OF THE GENERAL FUND TO GO
03:57:41.814 --> 03:57:43.582
TO A PROGRAM. TO HELP TO CREATE
03:57:43.649 --> 03:57:44.783
GRANTS TO HELP LOCAL
03:57:44.850 --> 03:57:46.685
JURISDICTIONS ANOTHER'S ADAPT TO
03:57:46.752 --> 03:57:48.787
RISING SEAS AND OTHER CLIMATE
03:57:48.854 --> 03:57:49.989
RELATED IMPACTS.
03:57:50.055 --> 03:57:51.156
THIS IS MONEY THAT'S ALREADY
03:57:51.223 --> 03:57:53.192
BEING COLLECTED INSTEAD OF GOING
03:57:53.258 --> 03:57:53.859
TO THE GENERAL FUND LET'S PUT IT
03:57:53.926 --> 03:57:54.693
TO GOOD USE.
03:57:54.760 --> 03:57:57.062
AND START TO FUND SOME OF THE
03:57:57.129 --> 03:57:58.998
CLIMATE ADAPTATION NEEDS ACROSS
03:57:59.064 --> 03:58:00.332
THE STATE ESPECIALLY IN THE
03:58:00.399 --> 03:58:02.401
COASTAL ZONE SINCE THAT'S WHERE
03:58:02.468 --> 03:58:03.302
THIS MONEY IS -- THAT I DON'T.
03:58:03.369 --> 03:58:06.939
THAT'S WHERE IT GOES AND I
03:58:07.006 --> 03:58:09.775
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR EITHER.
03:58:09.842 --> 03:58:11.010
ONE OF THE MEAT ON A WITH AUTUMN
03:58:11.076 --> 03:58:12.244
ON CALIFORNIA WE WANT TO THANK
03:58:12.311 --> 03:58:13.345
THE AUTHOR FOR AUTHORING THIS
03:58:13.412 --> 03:58:13.879
IMPORTANT BILL.
03:58:13.946 --> 03:58:16.615
AS WE WE KNOW THAT RESIDENTS --
03:58:16.682 --> 03:58:17.950
IN CALIFORNIA WOULD NEED TO HAVE
03:58:18.017 --> 03:58:20.119
A RESILIENT FUTURE -- A. B. AS
03:58:20.185 --> 03:58:22.554
THE ASSEMBLY MEMBER SAID AB FIVE
03:58:22.621 --> 03:58:23.589
FIFTY TO MAKE SAID NECESSARY
03:58:23.656 --> 03:58:24.723
INVESTMENTS TO HELP.
03:58:24.790 --> 03:58:26.392
ENHANCE LOCAL RESILIENCE AGAINST
03:58:26.458 --> 03:58:28.127
CLIMATE CHANGE OUR DISASTER BY
03:58:28.193 --> 03:58:29.628
ENSURING THAT AGENCIES HAVE THE
03:58:29.695 --> 03:58:31.797
ADEQUATE FUNDING NECESSARY. TO
03:58:31.864 --> 03:58:33.599
REDUCE THE IMPACTS OF SEA LEVEL
03:58:33.666 --> 03:58:36.402
RISE AND FOR THAT REASON -- WE
03:58:36.468 --> 03:58:40.439
ASK FOR RE RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
03:58:40.506 --> 03:58:42.041
AN AYE VOTE.
03:58:42.107 --> 03:58:43.475
THANK YOU IS ANYBODY ELSE WOULD
03:58:43.542 --> 03:58:44.376
LIKE TO SPEAK IN FAVOR OF THE
03:58:44.443 --> 03:58:44.977
BILL.
03:58:45.044 --> 03:58:45.544
MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS THE
03:58:45.611 --> 03:58:47.012
SILENCE ALICE WITH THE NATURE
03:58:47.079 --> 03:58:49.081
CONSERVANCY IN SUPPORT.
03:58:49.148 --> 03:58:50.315
THERESA BROKERAGE ON BEHALF OF
03:58:50.382 --> 03:58:51.350
THE CLEAN SEIZE LOBBYING
03:58:51.417 --> 03:58:53.652
COALITION IN SUPPORT.
03:58:53.719 --> 03:58:54.720
LAUREN COMMISSAIRE CLUB
03:58:54.787 --> 03:58:58.590
CALIFORNIANS SUPPORT -- GEORGE
03:58:58.657 --> 03:58:59.158
WANTED OCEAN CONSERVANCY IN
03:58:59.224 --> 03:59:03.829
SUPPORT. FOR THAT ALONE ON
03:59:03.896 --> 03:59:04.463
BEHALF OF DEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE
03:59:04.530 --> 03:59:06.665
IN SUPPORT.
03:59:06.732 --> 03:59:08.000
JAMIE GO ON BEHALF OF A SOUL IN
03:59:08.067 --> 03:59:09.301
SUPPORT.
03:59:09.368 --> 03:59:11.003
THANK YOU IS FOR ANYBODY WHO
03:59:11.070 --> 03:59:11.637
WISHES TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION TO
03:59:11.704 --> 03:59:13.372
THE BILL.
03:59:13.439 --> 03:59:14.640
OKAY SING NOT OVER GO BACK TO
03:59:14.707 --> 03:59:18.944
THE COMMITTEE.
03:59:19.011 --> 03:59:23.048
NO REQUEST TO SPEAK AT THE I
03:59:23.115 --> 03:59:23.916
THINK IT'S AN EXCELLENT BILL
03:59:23.982 --> 03:59:24.983
THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR BRINGING
03:59:25.050 --> 03:59:27.086
FOR WE HAVE A MOTION THE SECOND
03:59:27.152 --> 03:59:28.287
CAN WE HAVE A ROLL CALL PLEASE.
03:59:28.353 --> 03:59:30.155
ITEM SEVEN A. B. FIVE FIFTY TWO
03:59:30.222 --> 03:59:31.457
BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER MARK STONE THE
03:59:31.523 --> 03:59:33.592
MOTION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED AND
03:59:33.659 --> 03:59:34.493
REFERRED APPROPRIATIONS
03:59:34.560 --> 03:59:35.461
COMMITTEE.
03:59:35.527 --> 03:59:36.729
MEMBERS FRIEDMAN AYE FRIEDMAN
03:59:36.795 --> 03:59:38.497
AYE FLORA.
03:59:38.564 --> 03:59:40.265
FLORA NO CHILD.
03:59:40.332 --> 03:59:41.033
EGGMAN.
03:59:41.100 --> 03:59:43.302
EGGMAN AYE GARCIA GARCIA I
03:59:43.368 --> 03:59:45.537
LIMóN.
03:59:45.604 --> 03:59:47.506
LIMON AYE MATHIS.
03:59:47.573 --> 03:59:48.307
MATHIS NO.
03:59:48.373 --> 03:59:53.445
MCCARTY. THIRTY AYE MELENDEZ.
03:59:53.512 --> 03:59:55.781
MELENDEZ NO MURATSUCHI.
03:59:55.848 --> 03:59:57.750
WROTE TO GI STONE.
03:59:57.816 --> 04:00:00.919
STONE I SEVEN THREE SEVEN THREE
04:00:00.986 --> 04:00:01.553
THE BILL IS OUT MISTER MCCARTY
04:00:01.620 --> 04:00:15.167
WOULD YOU LIKE TO PRESENT
04:00:15.234 --> 04:00:15.467
[inaudible]
04:00:15.534 --> 04:00:18.904
RIGHT [inaudible]
04:00:18.971 --> 04:00:26.979
YEAH.
04:00:27.045 --> 04:00:31.250
BUT IT'S GOOD.
04:00:31.316 --> 04:00:34.086
OKAY.
04:00:34.153 --> 04:00:35.087
SIX SIX ONE OKAY REAL QUICK HAVE
04:00:35.154 --> 04:00:36.088
A FEW AYE IMPORTANT WITNESSES
04:00:36.155 --> 04:00:36.889
WENT TO INTRODUCE BUT THIS IS A
04:00:36.955 --> 04:00:37.823
DISTRICT BILL BUT RELATE TO THE
04:00:37.890 --> 04:00:38.924
FIRES THAT WE ALL EXPERIENCE
04:00:38.991 --> 04:00:40.459
BELIEVE IT OR NOT AFTER THE CART.
04:00:40.526 --> 04:00:42.594
CAMPFIRE MY DISTRICT DURING A
04:00:42.661 --> 04:00:44.263
FEW DAYS HAD THE DISTINCTION OF
04:00:44.329 --> 04:00:46.064
HAVING THE WORST AIR QUALITY IN
04:00:46.131 --> 04:00:47.099
THE WORLD.
04:00:47.166 --> 04:00:48.367
AND THE WORLD THE FIRE WAS
04:00:48.433 --> 04:00:49.802
NINETY MILES FROM HERE BUT THE
04:00:49.868 --> 04:00:51.503
WORST AIR QUALITY IN THE WORLD
04:00:51.570 --> 04:00:52.871
IS RIGHT HERE IN SACRAMENTO.
04:00:52.938 --> 04:00:54.973
MANY QUESTIONS LINGER IN OUR
04:00:55.040 --> 04:00:56.708
COMMUNITY NOT TO SMOKE WHAT YOU
04:00:56.775 --> 04:00:57.976
DO WITH OUR SCHOOLS SHOULD
04:00:58.043 --> 04:00:59.211
PARENTS KEEP THEIR KIDS AT HOME
04:00:59.278 --> 04:01:00.612
SHE TO GO TO WORK.
04:01:00.679 --> 04:01:01.980
WHAT SHOULD YOU DO IF YOU GO
04:01:02.047 --> 04:01:04.016
OUTSIDE TO TO WEAR A MASK WHAT
04:01:04.082 --> 04:01:06.485
THE HECK IS THAT? THREE THREE
04:01:06.552 --> 04:01:08.854
HUNDRED PM TWO POINT FIVE RATING
04:01:08.921 --> 04:01:09.621
WHAT'S THAT MEAN INTERNET IN
04:01:09.688 --> 04:01:09.988
PLAIN ENGLISH.
04:01:10.055 --> 04:01:11.223
Là EVENTS UNANSWERED QUESTIONS
04:01:11.290 --> 04:01:13.458
WE HAVE OUR AIR QUALITY EXPERTS.
04:01:13.525 --> 04:01:14.960
IN OUR COMMUNITY SAID THIS
04:01:15.027 --> 04:01:16.995
MEASURE ASK THEM TO HELP A
04:01:17.062 --> 04:01:18.564
BETTER FOR LOCAL GOVERNMENTS AND
04:01:18.630 --> 04:01:20.566
RESIDENTS OF WHAT TO DO DURING
04:01:20.632 --> 04:01:22.434
AN AIR EMERGENCY.
04:01:22.501 --> 04:01:24.636
WITH ME IS MR ALBERTO AYALA
04:01:24.703 --> 04:01:25.904
ARCHIE FOR THE SACRAMENTO AIR
04:01:25.971 --> 04:01:27.806
QUALITY DISTRICT OUR LOCAL
04:01:27.873 --> 04:01:28.841
COUNCIL MEMBER STEVE HANSEN I
04:01:28.907 --> 04:01:29.675
CAN I ALSO ASK IF YOU'RE
04:01:29.741 --> 04:01:31.677
ACCEPTING THE AMENDMENTS THE
04:01:31.743 --> 04:01:33.278
COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS YES THANK
04:01:33.345 --> 04:01:34.079
YOU.
04:01:34.146 --> 04:01:34.713
THAT'S WHAT I LOVE WITH ALL OF
04:01:34.780 --> 04:01:36.548
THAT YES THANK YOU AND THANK YOU
04:01:36.615 --> 04:01:41.720
FOR YOUR YOUR TEAM. FOR WORKING
04:01:41.787 --> 04:01:43.622
WITH US.
04:01:43.689 --> 04:01:44.289
MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS CUTS MEMBER
04:01:44.356 --> 04:01:44.857
STEVE HANSEN I AM ALSO THE
04:01:44.923 --> 04:01:45.457
FORMER CHAIR OF THEIR QUALITY
04:01:45.524 --> 04:01:46.091
MANAGEMENT DISTRICT AND MEMBER
04:01:46.158 --> 04:01:47.860
OF THE BOARD AS WELL AS AN R. T.
04:01:47.926 --> 04:01:49.228
BOARD MEMBER -- WHEN THIS AIR
04:01:49.294 --> 04:01:50.662
QUALITY OF IT HAPPENED LAST YEAR
04:01:50.729 --> 04:01:52.231
CONSTITUENTS WERE CONCERNED
04:01:52.297 --> 04:01:53.932
ABOUT WAS GOING ON BUT OUR TOOLS
04:01:53.999 --> 04:01:55.834
THAT WE HAVE DON'T WORK FOR A
04:01:55.901 --> 04:01:57.236
WILDFIRE INUNDATION?
04:01:57.302 --> 04:01:58.904
THEY'RE MEANT TO GET PEOPLE OUT
04:01:58.971 --> 04:02:00.205
OF THEIR CARS AND RIGHT TRANSIT
04:02:00.272 --> 04:02:01.907
BUT SPARE THE AIR DAY DOESN'T
04:02:01.974 --> 04:02:05.444
WORK WHEN IT'S A WILDFIRE AND
04:02:05.510 --> 04:02:06.044
YOUR CARD THE BASIN AND SO.
04:02:06.111 --> 04:02:07.746
WHAT WE NEED IS SOME AUTHORITY
04:02:07.813 --> 04:02:08.914
FOR THE -- DISTRICT COURT NAY
04:02:08.981 --> 04:02:10.415
BETTER WITH THE OTHER LOCAL
04:02:10.482 --> 04:02:11.917
AGENCIES AND WE BELIEVE THIS
04:02:11.984 --> 04:02:15.320
BILL -- THANK YOU MISTER MCCARTY
04:02:15.387 --> 04:02:15.721
FOR AUTHORING IT.
04:02:15.787 --> 04:02:17.089
IS IT A PILOT OF SORTS BUT WILL
04:02:17.155 --> 04:02:18.257
COME A MODEL FOR OTHER AIR
04:02:18.323 --> 04:02:19.691
DISTRICTS IN THE STATE.
04:02:19.758 --> 04:02:20.425
SO THAT WE CAN BE BETTER
04:02:20.492 --> 04:02:22.094
PREPARED THE NEXT TIME THIS
04:02:22.160 --> 04:02:22.828
GONNA HAPPEN BECAUSE WITH
04:02:22.895 --> 04:02:24.696
CLIMATE CHANGE WE KNOW THERE
04:02:24.763 --> 04:02:26.064
WILL BE ANOTHER FIRE AND THERE
04:02:26.131 --> 04:02:27.532
BE ANOTHER INCIDENT WERE
04:02:27.599 --> 04:02:28.100
PEOPLE'S PUBLIC HEALTH IS AT
04:02:28.166 --> 04:02:28.634
RISK [inaudible]
04:02:28.700 --> 04:02:32.337
THANK YOU.
04:02:32.404 --> 04:02:36.174
THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR AND
04:02:36.241 --> 04:02:36.842
MEMBERS OTHER TOYOTA AND
04:02:36.909 --> 04:02:38.076
POLLUTION CONTROL OFFICER FOR
04:02:38.143 --> 04:02:39.311
THE SACRAMENTO MATCH OUR QUALITY
04:02:39.378 --> 04:02:40.112
MANAGEMENT DISTRICT.
04:02:40.178 --> 04:02:43.282
SO AGAIN AS A COUNCIL MEMBER --
04:02:43.348 --> 04:02:44.349
HANSEN SAID -- THIS IS
04:02:44.416 --> 04:02:46.118
ESSENTIALLY AN OPPORTUNITY FOR
04:02:46.184 --> 04:02:48.520
US TO HAVE BETTER COORDINATION
04:02:48.587 --> 04:02:51.256
AND INTEGRATION REGIONALLY AND
04:02:51.323 --> 04:02:52.791
WE ARE WORKING WITH THAT -- ARE
04:02:52.858 --> 04:02:55.027
HEALTH OFFICERS -- AS WELL AS
04:02:55.093 --> 04:02:56.828
OTHER PARTNERS TO MAKE SURE THAT
04:02:56.895 --> 04:02:58.997
WE ARE PREPARE WHEN -- THE NEXT
04:02:59.064 --> 04:03:01.633
FIRE WILL HIT US WE SET RECORDS
04:03:01.700 --> 04:03:03.035
IN TERMS OF AIR POLLUTION IN
04:03:03.101 --> 04:03:04.169
CALIFORNIA.
04:03:04.236 --> 04:03:05.337
THAT WE HAVE NEVER SEEN IN THE
04:03:05.404 --> 04:03:07.773
PAST AND FOR THOSE FEW DAYS WE
04:03:07.839 --> 04:03:09.308
HAVE THE WORST AIR POLLUTION --
04:03:09.374 --> 04:03:12.911
IN THE WORLD.
04:03:12.978 --> 04:03:15.347
AND AS YOU CAN IMAGINE THERE'S A
04:03:15.414 --> 04:03:15.948
LOT OF CONFUSION AND I I NEED
04:03:16.014 --> 04:03:16.515
FOR BETTER COORDINATION AND
04:03:16.581 --> 04:03:17.115
COMMUNICATION AND THAT'S WHAT
04:03:17.182 --> 04:03:17.950
THIS BILL IS.
04:03:18.016 --> 04:03:19.184
IS GOING TO ALLOW US TO DO SO
04:03:19.251 --> 04:03:21.286
THANK YOU.
04:03:21.353 --> 04:03:22.454
THANK YOU VERY MUCH IS THERE ANY
04:03:22.521 --> 04:03:23.522
MEMBER OF THE PUBLIC WHO WOULD
04:03:23.588 --> 04:03:25.424
LIKE TO TESTIFY ON BEHALF OF THE
04:03:25.490 --> 04:03:25.824
BILL OR ANYBODY.
04:03:25.891 --> 04:03:27.359
AT ALL IS THERE ANYBODY WHO
04:03:27.426 --> 04:03:28.894
WOULD LIKE TO VOICE THEIR
04:03:28.961 --> 04:03:31.163
OPPOSITION TO THE BILL.
04:03:31.229 --> 04:03:36.268
CALIFORNIA BACK TO THE COMMITTEE.
04:03:36.335 --> 04:03:37.269
NO COMMENT THREE COMMITTEE
04:03:37.336 --> 04:03:38.337
MEMBERS MR MCCARTY WOULD YOU
04:03:38.403 --> 04:03:39.738
LIKE TO CLOSE THANK YOU AGAIN
04:03:39.805 --> 04:03:41.106
THIS IS THE NEW NORMAL AND
04:03:41.173 --> 04:03:42.741
FORTUNATELY WE NEED TO PREPARE
04:03:42.808 --> 04:03:44.109
AND THIS IS A SMART MEASURE
04:03:44.176 --> 04:03:44.476
ASKING PRIVATE.
04:03:44.543 --> 04:03:46.345
THANK YOU THANK YOU VERY MUCH
04:03:46.411 --> 04:03:46.912
THANKS FOR WORKING WITH THE
04:03:46.979 --> 04:03:48.447
COMMITTEE -- WE HAVE A MOTION
04:03:48.513 --> 04:03:49.915
AND A SECOND I THINK MULTIPLE
04:03:49.982 --> 04:03:51.416
MOTIONS MULTIPLE SECONDS WE HAVE
04:03:51.483 --> 04:03:52.451
A ROLL CALL PLEASE.
04:03:52.517 --> 04:03:54.286
ITEM NINE A. B. SIX SIXTY ONE BY
04:03:54.353 --> 04:03:55.120
ASSEMBLY MEMBER MCCARTY THE
04:03:55.187 --> 04:03:57.222
MOTION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED
04:03:57.289 --> 04:03:57.789
EVERY FOR TO APPROPRIATIONS
04:03:57.856 --> 04:03:58.924
COMMITTEE.
04:03:58.991 --> 04:04:00.859
MEMBERS FRIEDMAN HI FRIEDMAN I
04:04:00.926 --> 04:04:03.996
FLORA.
04:04:04.062 --> 04:04:05.630
FLORA AYE CHAU [inaudible]
04:04:05.697 --> 04:04:08.200
EGGMAN.
04:04:08.266 --> 04:04:09.901
I GARCIA.
04:04:09.968 --> 04:04:11.770
GARCIA I LIMóN.
04:04:11.837 --> 04:04:13.939
LIMON AYE MATHIS.
04:04:14.006 --> 04:04:15.240
MATHIS I MCCARTY.
04:04:15.307 --> 04:04:17.175
MCCARTY AYE MELENDEZ.
04:04:17.242 --> 04:04:19.911
MULLIN DOES NOT VOTING.
04:04:19.978 --> 04:04:21.847
MURATSUCHI.
04:04:21.913 --> 04:04:23.081
MURATSUCHI AYE STONE
04:04:23.148 --> 04:04:23.382
[inaudible]
04:04:23.448 --> 04:04:27.719
STONE I NINE ZERO NINE ZERO THE
04:04:27.786 --> 04:04:30.155
BILL IS OUT -- MISTER AMERICA TO
04:04:30.222 --> 04:04:39.564
CHEAT WOULD YOU LIKE TO PRESENT.
04:04:39.631 --> 04:04:41.033
THANK YOU VERY MUCH MADAM CHAIR
04:04:41.099 --> 04:04:42.234
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE I AM
04:04:42.300 --> 04:04:44.536
HERE TO PRESENT AB THREE FOUR
04:04:44.603 --> 04:04:45.470
TWO AND I'D LIKE TO START BY
04:04:45.537 --> 04:04:46.838
ACCEPTING THE COMMITTEE
04:04:46.905 --> 04:04:48.206
AMENDMENTS.
04:04:48.273 --> 04:04:50.442
AB THREE FOUR TWO WILL HELP
04:04:50.509 --> 04:04:51.510
CALIFORNIA PROTECT.
04:04:51.576 --> 04:04:52.944
FEDERALLY PROTECTED LAND AND
04:04:53.011 --> 04:04:54.479
NATIONAL MONUMENTS WITHIN OUR
04:04:54.546 --> 04:04:56.348
STATE BY PROHIBITING ANY STATE
04:04:56.415 --> 04:04:58.350
ENTITY WITH POLICING AUTHORITY
04:04:58.417 --> 04:05:00.018
OVER STATE LANDS FROM ENTERING
04:05:00.085 --> 04:05:01.620
INTO ANY LEASE AUTHORIZING THE
04:05:01.686 --> 04:05:03.688
CONSTRUCTION OF OIL AND GAS
04:05:03.755 --> 04:05:04.756
RELATED INFRASTRUCTURE.
04:05:04.823 --> 04:05:06.425
ON STATE LANDS TO SUPPORT OIL
04:05:06.491 --> 04:05:08.126
AND GAS PRODUCTION ON FEDERALLY
04:05:08.193 --> 04:05:09.094
PROTECTED LANCE.
04:05:09.161 --> 04:05:10.195
THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION IS
04:05:10.262 --> 04:05:11.663
PURSUING AGGRESSIVE ENERGY
04:05:11.730 --> 04:05:13.832
POLICY TO OPEN UP MORE MORE
04:05:13.899 --> 04:05:15.067
FEDERAL LAND TO OIL AND GAS
04:05:15.133 --> 04:05:16.935
EXPLORATION WITH LITTLE REGARD
04:05:17.002 --> 04:05:18.303
FOR THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS.
04:05:18.370 --> 04:05:19.805
AB THREE FOUR TWO WILL HELP
04:05:19.871 --> 04:05:21.006
PROTECT SOME OF OUR MOST
04:05:21.073 --> 04:05:22.641
BEAUTIFUL LANDS BY PROHIBITING
04:05:22.707 --> 04:05:24.009
THE ISSUANCE OF INFRASTRUCTURE
04:05:24.076 --> 04:05:26.278
NEEDED TO SUPPORT SUCH OIL AND
04:05:26.344 --> 04:05:27.479
GAS DEVELOPMENT.
04:05:27.546 --> 04:05:28.580
I AM PLEASED TO BE JOINED BY
04:05:28.647 --> 04:05:29.948
BRIAN WIKI WITH THE CENTER FOR
04:05:30.015 --> 04:05:31.750
BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY WILL BE
04:05:31.817 --> 04:05:33.552
TESTIFYING SUPPORT THE BILL.
04:05:33.618 --> 04:05:34.419
THANK YOU.
04:05:34.486 --> 04:05:36.321
GOOD EVENING MADAM CHAIR AND
04:05:36.388 --> 04:05:37.823
MEMBERS A COMMITTEE.
04:05:37.889 --> 04:05:39.157
MEMBER I KNOW WE GIVE THE CENTER
04:05:39.224 --> 04:05:39.658
FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY
04:05:39.724 --> 04:05:41.293
ENVIRONMENTAL ORGANIZATION
04:05:41.359 --> 04:05:43.829
ACTIVELY ENGAGED IN PROTECTING
04:05:43.895 --> 04:05:45.297
OUR PUBLIC LANDS FROM OIL AND
04:05:45.363 --> 04:05:46.198
GAS DEVELOPMENT.
04:05:46.264 --> 04:05:47.732
THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION IS
04:05:47.799 --> 04:05:49.067
CURRENTLY PROPOSING TO OPEN MORE
04:05:49.134 --> 04:05:50.836
THAN A MILLION ACRES OF PUBLIC
04:05:50.902 --> 04:05:52.137
LAND AND MINERALS STATE
04:05:52.204 --> 04:05:53.872
ADMINISTERED BY THE FEDERAL
04:05:53.939 --> 04:05:55.340
BUREAU OF LAND MANAGEMENT IN
04:05:55.407 --> 04:05:57.476
CALIFORNIA TO OIL DRILLING AND
04:05:57.542 --> 04:05:59.177
FRACKING ENDING THE FEDERAL
04:05:59.244 --> 04:06:00.645
MORATORIUM ON LEASING
04:06:00.712 --> 04:06:01.980
CALIFORNIA'S FEDERAL PUBLIC
04:06:02.047 --> 04:06:03.415
LANDS TO OIL COMPANIES.
04:06:03.482 --> 04:06:05.117
THAT HAS BEEN IN EFFECT FOR OVER
04:06:05.183 --> 04:06:06.184
FIVE YEARS.
04:06:06.251 --> 04:06:07.519
THE BUREAU OF LAND MANAGEMENT
04:06:07.586 --> 04:06:10.055
ESTIMATES THAT UP 290% OF NEW
04:06:10.122 --> 04:06:11.723
WELLS ON FEDERAL LANDS ARE
04:06:11.790 --> 04:06:12.591
CRACKED.
04:06:12.657 --> 04:06:13.992
WHICH OCCURS LARGELY AT SHALLOW
04:06:14.059 --> 04:06:15.794
DEPTHS DANGEROUSLY CLOSE TO
04:06:15.861 --> 04:06:17.329
UNDERGROUND DRINKING WATER
04:06:17.395 --> 04:06:18.430
SUPPLIES WITH HIGH
04:06:18.497 --> 04:06:19.865
CONCENTRATIONS OF CHEMICALS
04:06:19.931 --> 04:06:21.399
DANGEROUS TO HUMAN HEALTH AND
04:06:21.466 --> 04:06:22.100
THE ENVIRONMENT.
04:06:22.167 --> 04:06:23.435
MOREOVER NEW DRILLING AND
04:06:23.502 --> 04:06:25.570
FRACKING WOULD DO FURTHER DAMAGE
04:06:25.637 --> 04:06:27.005
TO THE AIR QUALITY OF CENTRAL
04:06:27.072 --> 04:06:28.874
CALIFORNIA PARTICULARLY IN THE
04:06:28.940 --> 04:06:31.109
SAN JOAQUIN VALLEY AIR BASIN
04:06:31.176 --> 04:06:34.179
WHICH HAS SOME OF THE WORST AIR
04:06:34.246 --> 04:06:35.147
POLLUTION IN THE NATION.
04:06:35.213 --> 04:06:35.680
OIL AND GAS DRILLING AND
04:06:35.747 --> 04:06:37.149
FRACKING OPERATIONS CONTRIBUTE
04:06:37.215 --> 04:06:38.216
TO THIS POLLUTION WHICH CAN
04:06:38.283 --> 04:06:40.085
TRIGGER ASTHMA WORSE AND OTHER
04:06:40.152 --> 04:06:41.620
RESPIRATORY CONDITIONS AND ARE
04:06:41.686 --> 04:06:42.888
LINKED WITH HEART DISEASE AND
04:06:42.954 --> 04:06:44.089
CHRONIC ILLNESSES.
04:06:44.156 --> 04:06:46.158
LIKE HOUSEHOLD BUDGET THE PLANET
04:06:46.224 --> 04:06:47.592
HAS A FOSSIL FUEL BUDGET AND
04:06:47.659 --> 04:06:50.162
THERE IS ENOUGH OIL GAS AND COAL
04:06:50.228 --> 04:06:52.063
AND ALREADY OPENED PRODUCING
04:06:52.130 --> 04:06:54.166
FIELDS GLOBALLY TO TAKE US FAR
04:06:54.232 --> 04:06:56.701
BEYOND THE PARIS CLIMATE TARGETS.
04:06:56.768 --> 04:06:58.436
IT DEFIES REASON THAT THE
04:06:58.503 --> 04:06:59.671
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT WILL CONTINUE
04:06:59.738 --> 04:07:01.840
SELLING OFF PUBLICLY OWNED LANDS
04:07:01.907 --> 04:07:03.875
AND FOSSIL FUELS FOR DEVELOPMENT
04:07:03.942 --> 04:07:06.077
NOW MORE THAN EVER WE MUST KEEP
04:07:06.144 --> 04:07:07.646
FOSSIL FUELS IN THE GROUND.
04:07:07.712 --> 04:07:09.548
THE TRUMP PLAN WOULD PUT THE
04:07:09.614 --> 04:07:11.783
STATE'S MOST ICONIC LANDSCAPES
04:07:11.850 --> 04:07:13.385
AT RISK AS WELL.
04:07:13.451 --> 04:07:15.120
IT THREATENS NOT ONLY LANCE
04:07:15.187 --> 04:07:15.754
MANAGED BY THE BUREAU OF LAND
04:07:15.820 --> 04:07:17.489
MANAGEMENT BUT RISKS POLLUTING
04:07:17.556 --> 04:07:19.257
THE AIR AND WATER OF OTHER
04:07:19.324 --> 04:07:20.525
FEDERAL AND PRIVATE LANDS IN THE
04:07:20.592 --> 04:07:22.227
REGION INCLUDING THE ICONIC
04:07:22.294 --> 04:07:23.895
SEQUOIA NATIONAL FOREST.
04:07:23.962 --> 04:07:25.297
LOS PADRES NATIONAL FOREST
04:07:25.363 --> 04:07:26.731
GREASE A PLANE NATIONAL MONUMENT
04:07:26.798 --> 04:07:28.099
AND CALIFORNIA'S BEAUTIFUL
04:07:28.166 --> 04:07:29.000
COASTLINES.
04:07:29.067 --> 04:07:30.435
WHILE THE STATE MAY HAVE LIMITED
04:07:30.502 --> 04:07:32.103
AUTHORITY TO STOP THE TRUMP
04:07:32.170 --> 04:07:34.306
ADMINISTRATION PLAN. TO OPEN OUR
04:07:34.372 --> 04:07:35.407
PUBLIC LANDS TO EXPANDED FOSSIL
04:07:35.473 --> 04:07:36.575
FUEL DRILLING.
04:07:36.641 --> 04:07:37.642
THE STATE SHOULD CERTAINLY NOT
04:07:37.709 --> 04:07:39.377
BE WORKING TO FACILITATE THEIR
04:07:39.444 --> 04:07:41.346
EXPANSION FOR ALL THESE REASONS
04:07:41.413 --> 04:07:41.880
THE CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL
04:07:41.947 --> 04:07:44.549
DIVERSITY IS PLEASED TO SUPPORT
04:07:44.616 --> 04:07:45.717
AB.
04:07:45.784 --> 04:07:46.351
THREE FOUR TWO AND RESPECTFULLY
04:07:46.418 --> 04:07:47.986
ASK THE COMMITTEE TO SUPPORT
04:07:48.053 --> 04:07:50.956
THIS BILL THANK YOU.
04:07:51.022 --> 04:07:51.556
THANK YOU ANY OTHER MEMBERS OF
04:07:51.623 --> 04:07:52.524
THE PUBLIC.
04:07:52.591 --> 04:07:53.625
OR ANYBODY WISHING TO TESTIFY IN
04:07:53.692 --> 04:07:56.728
SUPPORT.
04:07:56.795 --> 04:07:57.729
DEVICE CAR FOR NEXT GEN
04:07:57.796 --> 04:08:01.766
CALIFORNIANS SUPPORT OF THE BILL.
04:08:01.833 --> 04:08:02.834
MELISSA ROMERO ON BEHALF OF THE
04:08:02.901 --> 04:08:04.669
CALIFORNIA LEAGUE OF
04:08:04.736 --> 04:08:07.505
CONSERVATION VOTERS AND SUPPORT.
04:08:07.572 --> 04:08:09.541
VICTORIA AROUND WITHIN OUR DC IN
04:08:09.608 --> 04:08:12.611
SUPPORT.
04:08:12.677 --> 04:08:14.246
LOW INCOME ON BEHALF OF SIERRA
04:08:14.312 --> 04:08:16.548
CLUB CALIFORNIANS SUPPORT.
04:08:16.615 --> 04:08:17.549
THANK YOU ANYONE WISHING TEST TO
04:08:17.616 --> 04:08:20.485
TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION.
04:08:20.552 --> 04:08:21.853
OKAY ANY MEASURE -- ANY
04:08:21.920 --> 04:08:23.688
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS FROM
04:08:23.755 --> 04:08:25.390
COMMITTEE MEMBERS MISTER MATHIS.
04:08:25.457 --> 04:08:26.758
JUST A OUT.
04:08:26.825 --> 04:08:28.994
SO YOU WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT.
04:08:29.060 --> 04:08:32.163
WE'RE NOT GONNA RUN PIPE THROUGH.
04:08:32.230 --> 04:08:33.431
AND ANY OF THE STATE LANDS
04:08:33.498 --> 04:08:37.035
CRACKED THAT'S CORRECT SO YOU.
04:08:37.102 --> 04:08:39.404
PROPOSING OUT THEY JUST RUN PIPE
04:08:39.471 --> 04:08:41.139
ALL THE WAY AROUND THEM.
04:08:41.206 --> 04:08:42.140
WHICH WOULD INCREASE THE
04:08:42.207 --> 04:08:43.575
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT.
04:08:43.642 --> 04:08:47.045
THIS BUT THIS IS SIMILAR.
04:08:47.112 --> 04:08:49.180
TO WHAT -- YET LESS LATE
04:08:49.247 --> 04:08:50.615
YESTERDAY ON OFFER AFTER.
04:08:50.682 --> 04:08:51.883
IT IF WE'RE GONNA BLOCKING FROM
04:08:51.950 --> 04:08:52.417
GOING.
04:08:52.484 --> 04:08:53.918
THROUGH STATE LANDS ARE GONNA GO
04:08:53.985 --> 04:08:59.024
AROUND THEM WELL -- THAT.
04:08:59.090 --> 04:09:00.258
MAY BE AN OPTION THAT -- OIL
04:09:00.325 --> 04:09:00.925
COMPANIES MAY CHOOSE.
04:09:00.992 --> 04:09:03.261
TO PURSUE BUT THE THE THE THE
04:09:03.328 --> 04:09:04.896
BASIC OBJECTIVE IS.
04:09:04.963 --> 04:09:05.964
TO TRY TO MAKE IT AS DIFFICULT
04:09:06.031 --> 04:09:08.600
AS POSSIBLE -- TO DRILL AND SOME
04:09:08.667 --> 04:09:11.102
OF OUR MOST BEAUTIFUL -- LANCE
04:09:11.169 --> 04:09:13.538
THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA.
04:09:13.605 --> 04:09:14.906
ALRIGHT.
04:09:14.973 --> 04:09:16.775
LOOKS LIKE THE GO AROUND.
04:09:16.841 --> 04:09:19.210
THANK YOU ANY OTHER QUESTIONS.
04:09:19.277 --> 04:09:20.412
ARE WE HAVE A MOTION AND A
04:09:20.478 --> 04:09:21.946
SECOND TO YOU DID YOU WANT TO
04:09:22.013 --> 04:09:23.682
CLOSE I ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE.
04:09:23.748 --> 04:09:27.052
THANK YOU.
04:09:27.118 --> 04:09:28.219
WE WERE ROLL CALL.
04:09:28.286 --> 04:09:29.654
ITEM FOR AB THREE FORTY TWO BY
04:09:29.721 --> 04:09:30.455
ASSEMBLYMEMBER MOUNT FUJI THE
04:09:30.522 --> 04:09:31.690
MOTION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED AND
04:09:31.756 --> 04:09:32.924
REFER TO APPROPRIATIONS
04:09:32.991 --> 04:09:34.559
COMMITTEE.
04:09:34.626 --> 04:09:37.128
MEMBERS FRIEDMAN YES FRIEDMAN I
04:09:37.195 --> 04:09:37.929
FLORA.
04:09:37.996 --> 04:09:39.864
FLORA NOTE CHAU.
04:09:39.931 --> 04:09:41.366
EGGMAN.
04:09:41.433 --> 04:09:42.967
EGGMAN AYE GARCIA.
04:09:43.034 --> 04:09:45.403
GARCIA AYE LIMóN.
04:09:45.470 --> 04:09:47.806
LOW MOAN AYE MATHIS.
04:09:47.872 --> 04:09:50.375
MATHIS NO MCCARTY.
04:09:50.442 --> 04:09:52.811
THE AYE MELENDEZ THE LENDERS
04:09:52.877 --> 04:09:54.946
KNOW MURATSUCHI I READ THROUGH
04:09:55.013 --> 04:09:56.281
G. AYE STONE.
04:09:56.348 --> 04:09:58.483
STONE AYE SEVEN THREE SEVEN
04:09:58.550 --> 04:09:59.150
THREE THE BILL IS OUT THANK YOU.
04:09:59.217 --> 04:10:00.251
AND WITH THAT I WILL PASSED THE
04:10:00.318 --> 04:10:04.856
GAVEL TO MY BUT VICE CHAIR AND
04:10:04.923 --> 04:10:11.596
BRING US ALL HOME.
04:10:11.663 --> 04:10:12.197
HER I. MADAM CHAIR WHENEVER
04:10:12.263 --> 04:10:19.170
YOU'RE READY AB.
04:10:19.237 --> 04:10:19.838
TWO EIGHTY FIVE THANK YOU MISTER
04:10:19.904 --> 04:10:20.972
VICE CHAIR AND MEMBERS A
04:10:21.039 --> 04:10:22.173
TRANSPORTATION CONTINUES TO BE
04:10:22.240 --> 04:10:23.174
CALIFORNIA'S GREATEST
04:10:23.241 --> 04:10:24.509
CONTRIBUTOR TO GREENHOUSE GAS
04:10:24.576 --> 04:10:25.443
EMISSIONS.
04:10:25.510 --> 04:10:26.711
DIRECT EMISSIONS FROM THE TAIL
04:10:26.778 --> 04:10:28.880
PIPE OF CARS TRUCKS OFF ROAD
04:10:28.947 --> 04:10:30.014
TRANSPORTATION SOURCES AND MORE
04:10:30.081 --> 04:10:31.750
ACCOUNT FOR ALMOST 40% OF THE
04:10:31.816 --> 04:10:34.419
GHG INVENTORY IN.
04:10:34.486 --> 04:10:35.387
TWO THOUSAND SIXTEEN A 2%
04:10:35.453 --> 04:10:36.888
INCREASE FROM.
04:10:36.955 --> 04:10:38.423
TWO THOUSAND FIFTEEN AB TWO
04:10:38.490 --> 04:10:38.923
EIGHTY FIVE REQUIRES THE
04:10:38.990 --> 04:10:39.457
CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF
04:10:39.524 --> 04:10:40.992
TRANSPORTATION TO INCORPORATE
04:10:41.059 --> 04:10:42.827
CURRENT GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSION
04:10:42.894 --> 04:10:45.630
REDUCTION GOALS SUCH AS SB
04:10:45.697 --> 04:10:46.398
THIRTY TWO AND THE STATE'S AIR
04:10:46.464 --> 04:10:48.066
QUALITY PLANS INTO THE
04:10:48.133 --> 04:10:49.701
CALIFORNIA TRANSPORTATION PLAN.
04:10:49.768 --> 04:10:51.569
THIS UPDATE TO CALIFORNIA'S LONG
04:10:51.636 --> 04:10:52.871
TERM TRANSPORTATION PLANNING
04:10:52.937 --> 04:10:54.439
WILL IMPROVE THE EFFECTIVENESS
04:10:54.506 --> 04:10:55.673
OF TRANSPORTATION EMISSION
04:10:55.740 --> 04:10:56.841
REDUCTION PROGRAMS.
04:10:56.908 --> 04:10:58.410
WITH ME TODAY TO TESTIFY IN
04:10:58.476 --> 04:10:59.844
SUPPORT IS ROCKY RUSSIAN WITH
04:10:59.911 --> 04:11:01.746
THE COALITION FOR CLEAN AIR AND
04:11:01.813 --> 04:11:02.781
WILL BEAR WITH THE AMERICAN LUNG
04:11:02.847 --> 04:11:05.216
ASSOCIATION I RESPECTFULLY
04:11:05.283 --> 04:11:05.950
REQUEST AN AYE VOTE.
04:11:06.017 --> 04:11:07.419
COMMITTEE MEMBERS THANK YOU GOOD
04:11:07.485 --> 04:11:08.887
EVENING MY NAME IS ROCKY RUSSIAN
04:11:08.953 --> 04:11:10.288
WITH COLLEGE FOR CLEAN AIR.
04:11:10.355 --> 04:11:11.956
THE HARMFUL ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH
04:11:12.023 --> 04:11:14.392
IMPACTS OF HELP LET ME --
04:11:14.459 --> 04:11:15.393
TAILPIPE EMISSIONS ARE
04:11:15.460 --> 04:11:16.461
IRREFUTABLE.
04:11:16.528 --> 04:11:18.730
WE ARE HEATING UP OUR CLIMATE
04:11:18.797 --> 04:11:20.064
MAKING PEOPLE SICK.
04:11:20.131 --> 04:11:21.900
TRANSPORTATION SOURCES ACCOUNT
04:11:21.966 --> 04:11:23.802
FOR APPROXIMATELY 80% OF SMOG
04:11:23.868 --> 04:11:25.837
FORMING KNOCKS EMISSIONS 90% OF
04:11:25.904 --> 04:11:28.506
DIESEL PM AT APPROXIMATELY HALF
04:11:28.573 --> 04:11:29.774
OF OUR GREENHOUSE GASES.
04:11:29.841 --> 04:11:31.042
THESE POLLUTANTS FILE THE AIR WE
04:11:31.109 --> 04:11:33.178
BREATHE AND CONTRIBUTE TO A WIDE
04:11:33.244 --> 04:11:34.345
RANGE OF NEGATIVE HEALTH
04:11:34.412 --> 04:11:35.380
OUTCOMES.
04:11:35.447 --> 04:11:36.448
CARBON POLLUTION FROM OUR
04:11:36.514 --> 04:11:37.916
TRANSPORTATION SYSTEM DRIVES
04:11:37.982 --> 04:11:39.484
CLIMATE CHANGE RELATED
04:11:39.551 --> 04:11:40.618
CONDITIONS.
04:11:40.685 --> 04:11:43.121
SUCH AS EXTREME HEAT DROUGHT AND
04:11:43.188 --> 04:11:44.856
WILDFIRES YET THERE'S A SERIOUS
04:11:44.923 --> 04:11:47.091
DISCONNECT WITH OUR AIR QUALITY
04:11:47.158 --> 04:11:51.696
IN CLIMB A GOLD AND ARE
04:11:51.763 --> 04:11:52.564
TRANSPORTATION PLANNING.
04:11:52.630 --> 04:11:54.199
THE RECENT SB ONE FIFTY REPORT
04:11:54.265 --> 04:11:54.799
COULD NOT HAVE BEEN MORE CLEAR
04:11:54.866 --> 04:11:55.934
WE ARE ON THE ROAD TO FAILURE IN
04:11:56.000 --> 04:11:58.169
MEETING OUR FUTURE GHG
04:11:58.236 --> 04:11:59.337
REDUCTIONS.
04:11:59.404 --> 04:12:00.772
AND CLIMATE MANDATES.
04:12:00.839 --> 04:12:02.040
UNLESS WE SOLVE THE
04:12:02.106 --> 04:12:04.442
TRANSPORTATION HOUSING PLANNING
04:12:04.509 --> 04:12:06.444
CONUNDRUM THAT WE FACE.
04:12:06.511 --> 04:12:08.847
COLLEGE CLEAN AIR SPORTS AB TWO
04:12:08.913 --> 04:12:09.481
EIGHTY FIVE BECAUSE IT WOULDN'T
04:12:09.547 --> 04:12:10.949
SURE THAT THE CURRENT CLEAN AIR
04:12:11.015 --> 04:12:12.450
AND CLIMATE STANDARDS ARE
04:12:12.517 --> 04:12:13.651
ACCOUNTED FOR WITHIN THE
04:12:13.718 --> 04:12:17.288
CALIFORNIA TRANSPORTATION PLAN.
04:12:17.355 --> 04:12:18.356
THERE'S CRITICAL NEED TO ENSURE
04:12:18.423 --> 04:12:19.891
THE CALIFORNIA'S TRANSPORTATION
04:12:19.958 --> 04:12:21.559
DECISIONS AND INVESTMENT SUPPORT
04:12:21.626 --> 04:12:22.894
REDUCTIONS IN THE POLLUTANTS
04:12:22.961 --> 04:12:24.596
THAT THREATEN THE HEALTH OF TOO
04:12:24.662 --> 04:12:26.164
MANY CALIFORNIANS.
04:12:26.231 --> 04:12:27.699
AB TWO EIGHTY FIVE WOULD PLAY AN
04:12:27.765 --> 04:12:28.967
IMPORTANT ROLE IN MEETING THIS
04:12:29.033 --> 04:12:31.703
NEED AND COALITION FOR CLEAN AIR.
04:12:31.769 --> 04:12:34.339
ASKS FOR YOUR SUPPORT THANK YOU
04:12:34.405 --> 04:12:36.474
SO MUCH.
04:12:36.541 --> 04:12:38.076
HI GOOD EVENING WILL BEAR AT THE
04:12:38.142 --> 04:12:39.177
AMERICAN LUNG ASSOCIATION
04:12:39.244 --> 04:12:41.212
CALIFORNIA WE SUPPORT AB TWO
04:12:41.279 --> 04:12:42.146
EIGHTY FIVE IS A STRAIGHTFORWARD
04:12:42.213 --> 04:12:44.983
MEASURE TO UPDATES THE ESCAPEES --
04:12:45.049 --> 04:12:46.618
CONTENTS THE BILL INSURERS THE
04:12:46.684 --> 04:12:47.752
STATE'S TRANSPORTATION PLAN
04:12:47.819 --> 04:12:48.953
ACCOUNTS FOR TREATMENT OF OUR
04:12:49.020 --> 04:12:50.588
FEDERAL CLEAN AIR STANDARDS IN
04:12:50.655 --> 04:12:51.923
OUR STATE GREENHOUSE GAS
04:12:51.990 --> 04:12:53.258
REDUCTION RESPONSIBILITIES.
04:12:53.324 --> 04:12:54.125
WILL ALSO IDENTIFYING
04:12:54.192 --> 04:12:56.327
OPPORTUNITIES TO IMPROVE
04:12:56.394 --> 04:12:58.396
CRITICAL GRANT PROGRAM ALIGNMENT.
04:12:58.463 --> 04:12:59.230
IN PORTLAND AB TWO EIGHTY FIVE
04:12:59.297 --> 04:12:59.664
CREATE SPACE FOR THE
04:12:59.731 --> 04:13:00.932
CONSIDERATION OF ENVIRONMENTAL
04:13:00.999 --> 04:13:03.268
JUSTICE CONCERNS WITHIN THE PLAN.
04:13:03.334 --> 04:13:04.502
RECOGNITION THAT MANY CAN
04:13:04.569 --> 04:13:05.203
COMMUNITIES ARE
04:13:05.270 --> 04:13:05.970
DISPROPORTIONATELY AND
04:13:06.037 --> 04:13:07.238
NEGATIVELY IMPACTED BY
04:13:07.305 --> 04:13:09.374
TRANSPORTATION DECISIONS AND
04:13:09.440 --> 04:13:10.875
ASSOCIATED POLLUTION BURDENS
04:13:10.942 --> 04:13:12.510
TRAFFIC POLLUTION IS ASSOCIATED
04:13:12.577 --> 04:13:13.244
WITH CAUSING ASTHMA TEXAN
04:13:13.311 --> 04:13:14.012
CHILDREN.
04:13:14.078 --> 04:13:15.246
IN A WIDE RANGE OF OTHER HEALTH
04:13:15.313 --> 04:13:16.714
IMPACTS THAT NEGATIVELY AFFECT
04:13:16.781 --> 04:13:17.782
CALIFORNIANS.
04:13:17.849 --> 04:13:19.050
GIVEN THE URGENCY OF ACHIEVING
04:13:19.117 --> 04:13:20.151
OUR HEALTH PROTECTIVE AIR
04:13:20.218 --> 04:13:21.553
QUALITY CLIMATE STANDARDS IN A
04:13:21.619 --> 04:13:22.520
TIME WHEN TRANSPORTATION
04:13:22.587 --> 04:13:23.988
EMISSIONS ARE INCREASING IN OUR
04:13:24.055 --> 04:13:25.223
TRANSPORTATION INVESTMENTS ARE
04:13:25.290 --> 04:13:27.091
NOT WELL ALIGNED WITH OUR HEALTH
04:13:27.158 --> 04:13:28.059
EQUITY IN CLIMATE GOALS.
04:13:28.126 --> 04:13:30.395
AB TWO EIGHTY FIVE PROVIDES A
04:13:30.461 --> 04:13:31.930
POSITIVE STEP FORWARD PLANNING.
04:13:31.996 --> 04:13:32.564
TOWARDS PLANNING ASSISTANT WILL
04:13:32.630 --> 04:13:33.998
TRANSPORTATION SYSTEM FOR
04:13:34.065 --> 04:13:35.500
CALIFORNIA SO WE URGE YOUR
04:13:35.567 --> 04:13:36.601
SUPPORT THANK YOU VERY MUCH
04:13:36.668 --> 04:13:37.936
THANK YOU VERY MUCH ANYONE ELSE
04:13:38.002 --> 04:13:39.070
IN SUPPORT.
04:13:39.137 --> 04:13:41.005
YES VICTORIA ROOM WITH AN RTC IN
04:13:41.072 --> 04:13:45.777
SUPPORT THANK YOU THANK YOU.
04:13:45.843 --> 04:13:46.444
RIGHT NOW WITH YOU AT THE CENTER
04:13:46.511 --> 04:13:47.545
FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY IN
04:13:47.612 --> 04:13:48.246
SUPPORT.
04:13:48.313 --> 04:13:49.647
THANK YOU VERY MUCH ANYONE IN
04:13:49.714 --> 04:13:51.549
OPPOSITION.
04:13:51.616 --> 04:13:52.617
CNN ANY QUESTIONS FROM THE
04:13:52.684 --> 04:13:56.054
COMMITTEE.
04:13:56.120 --> 04:13:59.891
THIS ONE THIS -- IF I'M READING
04:13:59.958 --> 04:14:01.893
THIS CORRECTLY THERE IS ALREADY
04:14:01.960 --> 04:14:05.463
PENALTIES -- FOR VIOLATIONS OF
04:14:05.530 --> 04:14:07.832
DEFENSIBLE SPACE SORRY THAT'S
04:14:07.899 --> 04:14:09.667
THE OTHER OIL SORRY OKAY SORRY.
04:14:09.734 --> 04:14:16.140
HOLD MY POWDER TILL THE NEXT.
04:14:16.207 --> 04:14:17.542
ALL RIGHT ANYONE ELSE.
04:14:17.609 --> 04:14:19.611
PERFECT MANAGER WOULD YOU LIKE
04:14:19.677 --> 04:14:20.912
TO CLOSE I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
04:14:20.979 --> 04:14:22.580
AN AYE VOTE THANK YOU VERY MUCH
04:14:22.647 --> 04:14:24.315
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
04:14:24.382 --> 04:14:26.584
ITEM TWO AB TWO EIGHTY FIVE BY
04:14:26.651 --> 04:14:27.352
ASSEMBLYMEMBER FRIEDMAN THE
04:14:27.418 --> 04:14:29.187
MOTION IS TO PASS AND REFER TO
04:14:29.253 --> 04:14:30.722
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE.
04:14:30.788 --> 04:14:32.857
MEMBERS FRIEDMAN HI FRIEDMAN I
04:14:32.924 --> 04:14:35.627
FLORA NO FLORA NO CHAU.
04:14:35.693 --> 04:14:36.628
EGGMAN.
04:14:36.694 --> 04:14:38.363
EGGMAN AYE GARCIA.
04:14:38.429 --> 04:14:40.498
GARCIA I LIMóN.
04:14:40.565 --> 04:14:42.634
LIMON AYE MATHIS.
04:14:42.700 --> 04:14:44.936
MATHIS NO MCCARTY.
04:14:45.003 --> 04:14:47.672
MCCARTY AYE MELENDEZ.
04:14:47.739 --> 04:14:50.241
MELENDEZ NO WAY OUT.
04:14:50.308 --> 04:14:51.776
MURATSUCHI AYE STONE.
04:14:51.843 --> 04:14:54.145
STONE AYE.
04:14:54.212 --> 04:14:54.779
SEVEN THREE ALL RIGHT OKAY I'M
04:14:54.846 --> 04:14:56.447
SURE THE GO ONE MORE A. B.
04:14:56.514 --> 04:14:57.682
FIFTEEN SIXTEEN YES I THANK YOU
04:14:57.749 --> 04:14:59.050
MEMBERS I'D LIKE TO START BY
04:14:59.117 --> 04:14:59.584
ACCEPTING THE COMMITTEES
04:14:59.651 --> 04:15:00.418
AMENDMENTS.
04:15:00.485 --> 04:15:02.420
IN TWO THOUSAND SEVENTEEN AND
04:15:02.487 --> 04:15:04.255
EIGHTEEN AS WE KNOW WE'VE HAD
04:15:04.322 --> 04:15:06.157
HORRIBLE WILDFIRES IN THE STATE
04:15:06.224 --> 04:15:08.826
WILL MOVE THE BILL.
04:15:08.893 --> 04:15:10.028
OKAY I'M AT Là JUST FOR THE
04:15:10.094 --> 04:15:11.329
RECORD SAY THAT -- THIS IS
04:15:11.396 --> 04:15:13.164
REALLY TO BEEF UP THE DEFENSIBLE
04:15:13.231 --> 04:15:15.366
SPACE REQUIREMENTS -- WHOLE --
04:15:15.433 --> 04:15:17.101
HOMES OF REQUIRING THE NEW IS
04:15:17.168 --> 04:15:18.002
BUILDING CENTERS ARE OFTEN
04:15:18.069 --> 04:15:19.971
IGNITION RESISTANT BUT ONLY IF
04:15:20.038 --> 04:15:21.205
THE DEFENSIBLE SPACE
04:15:21.272 --> 04:15:22.640
REQUIREMENTS ARE MET.
04:15:22.707 --> 04:15:24.676
AND WHAT'S NEW ABOUT THOSE FIRES
04:15:24.742 --> 04:15:25.777
WITH A LOT OF THE HOUSES THAT
04:15:25.843 --> 04:15:27.211
BURNED WERE NEWER HOUSES THAT
04:15:27.278 --> 04:15:28.746
DID HAVE A LOT OF THE MORE
04:15:28.813 --> 04:15:30.415
RESILIENT A FIRE CODES BUILT
04:15:30.481 --> 04:15:31.716
INTO THEM BUT WHAT WE LEARNED
04:15:31.783 --> 04:15:33.184
WAS THAT THE VEGETATION THAT WAS
04:15:33.251 --> 04:15:35.019
RIGHT WITHIN THE FIVE FOOT.
04:15:35.086 --> 04:15:36.287
THIS FIVE FOOT BUFFER WAS WHAT
04:15:36.354 --> 04:15:38.523
IGNITED THE HOUSES AND THAT WAS
04:15:38.589 --> 04:15:40.925
NOT IN THE CURRENT -- DEFENSIBLE
04:15:40.992 --> 04:15:42.393
SPACE REQUIREMENTS SO THIS
04:15:42.460 --> 04:15:43.594
NARROWS IT DOWN TO REALLY TRY TO
04:15:43.661 --> 04:15:45.396
GUIDE PEOPLE TO LOOKING AT THE
04:15:45.463 --> 04:15:46.798
SPACE BETWEEN ZERO AND FIVE FEET
04:15:46.864 --> 04:15:48.466
OF YOUR HOUSE BECAUSE EVEN IF
04:15:48.533 --> 04:15:49.934
YOUR YARD DOESN'T BURN YOUR TREE
04:15:50.001 --> 04:15:51.035
DECEMBER AND IF IT AMBER BLOWS
04:15:51.102 --> 04:15:52.136
INTO A BUSH SITS RIGHT IN FRONT
04:15:52.203 --> 04:15:53.004
OF YOUR WINDOW.
04:15:53.071 --> 04:15:54.272
THAT COULD BE ENOUGH TO BLOW THE
04:15:54.338 --> 04:15:55.873
WINDOW OUT AND ALLOW FIRE TO
04:15:55.940 --> 04:15:57.775
MOVE INTO A HOME SO WE'VE BEEN
04:15:57.842 --> 04:15:59.577
WORKING WITH CAL FIRE.
04:15:59.644 --> 04:16:01.779
WITH THE ALL OF THE DIFFERENT
04:16:01.846 --> 04:16:03.481
STAKEHOLDERS AND YOU KNOW THESE
04:16:03.548 --> 04:16:06.284
ARE OURS ARE MEASURES THAT -- A
04:16:06.350 --> 04:16:08.319
LOT OF THE EXPERTS BELIEVE ARE
04:16:08.386 --> 04:16:09.487
REALLY NECESSARY TO START
04:16:09.554 --> 04:16:11.289
INSTITUTING TO MAKE OUR HOMES
04:16:11.355 --> 04:16:12.623
MORE FIRE RESILIENT.
04:16:12.690 --> 04:16:14.492
WITH ME TODAY TO SUPPORT IN IT
04:16:14.559 --> 04:16:15.927
TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT IS LIZ FOR
04:16:15.993 --> 04:16:17.261
FOSS BURKE FOR THE NATURE
04:16:17.328 --> 04:16:19.864
CONSERVANCY AND RICK SAID TOLD
04:16:19.931 --> 04:16:20.898
ME A FARCE ADVISER FROM UC
04:16:20.965 --> 04:16:22.100
COOPERATIVE EXTENSION TO ANSWER
04:16:22.166 --> 04:16:27.438
ANY QUESTIONS.
04:16:27.505 --> 04:16:28.973
THANK YOU BOTH FOR COMING GREAT.
04:16:29.040 --> 04:16:29.507
CHAIR AND MEMBERS OF THE
04:16:29.574 --> 04:16:30.141
COMMITTEE MY NAME IS LIZ FORCE
04:16:30.208 --> 04:16:31.409
BURKE AND I'M HERE ON BEHALF OF
04:16:31.476 --> 04:16:32.043
THE NATURE CONSERVANCY WE ARE IN
04:16:32.110 --> 04:16:33.644
STRONG SUPPORT OF AB.
04:16:33.711 --> 04:16:34.178
FIFTEEN SIXTEEN LAST YEAR
04:16:34.245 --> 04:16:34.712
CALIFORNIA'S OF THE WORST
04:16:34.779 --> 04:16:35.880
WILDFIRES IN HISTORY SETTING NEW
04:16:35.947 --> 04:16:37.682
RECORDS FOR THE LARGEST MOST
04:16:37.749 --> 04:16:39.317
DESTRUCTIVE AND DEADLY US.
04:16:39.383 --> 04:16:40.318
IN THE FACE OF MAKE THE FIRES WE
04:16:40.384 --> 04:16:41.786
HAVE A RESPONSIBILITY TO INVEST
04:16:41.853 --> 04:16:43.688
IN AND CREATE FIRE RESILIENT
04:16:43.755 --> 04:16:44.455
COMMUNITIES.
04:16:44.522 --> 04:16:45.623
BUT IF YOU'RE CONSERVANCY IS AN
04:16:45.690 --> 04:16:46.624
ACTIVE MEMBER OF THE FIRE
04:16:46.691 --> 04:16:47.992
ADOPTED COMMUNITIES LEARNING
04:16:48.059 --> 04:16:49.861
NETWORK A NATIONAL GROUP WORKING
04:16:49.927 --> 04:16:51.095
TO BUILD SUSTAINABLE WILDFIRE
04:16:51.162 --> 04:16:52.597
RESILIENCE CAPACITY IN FIRE
04:16:52.663 --> 04:16:53.698
PRONE COMMUNITIES.
04:16:53.765 --> 04:16:55.133
THE COALITION IS COMMITTED TO
04:16:55.199 --> 04:16:56.300
HELPING PEOPLE IN THE WILD AND
04:16:56.367 --> 04:16:57.602
URBAN INTERFACE ADAPTOR LIVING
04:16:57.668 --> 04:16:59.370
WITH WILD FIRE.
04:16:59.437 --> 04:17:01.038
AND REDUCE THEIR RISK FOR DAMAGE.
04:17:01.105 --> 04:17:02.039
FOR COMMUNITIES THAT ARE STOP
04:17:02.106 --> 04:17:03.775
MOTION HIGH FIRE RISK AREAS WE
04:17:03.841 --> 04:17:05.276
MUST MAKE THE MORE RESILIENT TO
04:17:05.343 --> 04:17:07.011
FIRE SAFE BUILDING STANDARDS
04:17:07.078 --> 04:17:08.746
DEFENSIBLE SPACE PROGRAMS.
04:17:08.813 --> 04:17:09.981
EVACUATION PLANNING AND
04:17:10.047 --> 04:17:11.315
PREVENTION OF HUMAN CAUSED
04:17:11.382 --> 04:17:14.051
IGNITIONS AB FIFTEEN SIXTEEN
04:17:14.118 --> 04:17:15.019
MAKES IMPORTANT CHANGES TO
04:17:15.086 --> 04:17:15.787
IMPROVE DEFENSIBLE SPACE
04:17:15.853 --> 04:17:17.555
REQUIREMENTS AND COMPLIANCE
04:17:17.622 --> 04:17:18.623
ENSURING WE ARE ADOPTING
04:17:18.689 --> 04:17:20.458
CALIFORNIA TO DEAL WITH THE
04:17:20.525 --> 04:17:21.192
ESCALATING FOR A FIRE.
04:17:21.259 --> 04:17:22.693
WE ALSO BE MORE RESOURCES AN
04:17:22.760 --> 04:17:24.362
EXPERT TO COULD HELP WITH FIRE
04:17:24.428 --> 04:17:25.463
PREVENTION ACTIVITIES.
04:17:25.530 --> 04:17:27.165
AB FIFTEEN SIXTEEN IMPROVE THE
04:17:27.231 --> 04:17:28.332
TRAINING OF LOCAL DEFENSIBLE
04:17:28.399 --> 04:17:30.601
SPACE INSPECTORS AND PROVIDES
04:17:30.668 --> 04:17:31.836
OPTIONS FOR CONSERVATION CORES.
04:17:31.903 --> 04:17:33.504
RESOURCE CONSERVATION DISTRICTS
04:17:33.571 --> 04:17:37.975
AND FIRE CITY COUNCIL TO CONDUCT
04:17:38.042 --> 04:17:39.777
DEFENSIBLE SPACE FOR HOMEOWNERS.
04:17:39.844 --> 04:17:40.878
LET'S STOP MAKING HISTORY AND
04:17:40.945 --> 04:17:41.445
START MAKING OUR COMMUNITIES
04:17:41.512 --> 04:17:42.013
MORE FIRE RESILIENT THROUGH
04:17:42.079 --> 04:17:44.048
IMPORTANT MEASURES LIKE AB.
04:17:44.115 --> 04:17:44.649
FIFTEEN SIXTEEN THANK YOU TO
04:17:44.715 --> 04:17:45.616
ASSEMBLYMEMBER FRIEDMAN FOR HER
04:17:45.683 --> 04:17:46.984
LEADERSHIP ON THIS ISSUE AND WE
04:17:47.051 --> 04:17:48.352
ARE RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR
04:17:48.419 --> 04:17:49.387
SUPPORT.
04:17:49.453 --> 04:17:53.925
THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS.
04:17:53.991 --> 04:17:55.893
MY NAME IS RICK IS TELL ME I AM
04:17:55.960 --> 04:17:57.461
FORCE VISOR OF PC DIVISION OF
04:17:57.528 --> 04:17:58.896
AGRICULTURE NATURAL RESOURCES
04:17:58.963 --> 04:18:01.599
BASED ON A SHASTA TRINITY AND
04:18:01.666 --> 04:18:02.433
SISKIYOU COUNTY.
04:18:02.500 --> 04:18:03.367
YOU SEE SUPPORTS EFFORTS TO
04:18:03.434 --> 04:18:05.269
ESTABLISH A NON COMBUSTIBLE ZONE
04:18:05.336 --> 04:18:06.771
AROUND STRUCTURES IN HIGH FIRE
04:18:06.838 --> 04:18:07.672
HAZARD.
04:18:07.738 --> 04:18:09.040
DANGER AREAS.
04:18:09.106 --> 04:18:10.007
OUR RESEARCH AND MY OWN
04:18:10.074 --> 04:18:11.876
EXPERIENCE DURING THE CAR FIRE
04:18:11.943 --> 04:18:13.144
HAVE SHOWN THAT THE THREE TO
04:18:13.211 --> 04:18:15.847
FIVE FOOT ZONE IS A CRITICAL
04:18:15.913 --> 04:18:18.349
AREA TO PROTECT -- WENT WHEN
04:18:18.416 --> 04:18:18.950
WE'RE TRYING TO REDUCE HUMMING
04:18:19.016 --> 04:18:21.185
MISSION POTENTIAL.
04:18:21.252 --> 04:18:22.787
BY ADDRESSING THIS CRITICAL
04:18:22.854 --> 04:18:24.655
VULNERABILITY IN OUR HOME OUR
04:18:24.722 --> 04:18:26.624
KERN FIRE DEFENSE STRATEGY WE
04:18:26.691 --> 04:18:28.459
WILL REINFORCE OUR EFFORTS.
04:18:28.526 --> 04:18:29.727
OF OUR AGENCY COLLEAGUES WHEN
04:18:29.794 --> 04:18:31.495
THEY GO ABOUT PROTECTING HOME
04:18:31.562 --> 04:18:34.098
STRING WILDFIRE.
04:18:34.165 --> 04:18:34.732
AT THIS POINT IF THE COMMITTEE
04:18:34.799 --> 04:18:35.867
HAS ANY QUESTIONS ABOUT YOU SEE
04:18:35.933 --> 04:18:37.368
AN ARTS ONGOING EFFORTS
04:18:37.435 --> 04:18:39.704
SURROUNDING -- NEAR HOME FIRE
04:18:39.770 --> 04:18:43.207
DEFENSE OR OUR CURRENT RESEARCH.
04:18:43.274 --> 04:18:44.542
I AM HAPPY TO HELP.
04:18:44.609 --> 04:18:46.110
ANSWER I CAN THANK YOU.
04:18:46.177 --> 04:18:47.211
THANK YOU VERY MUCH ANYONE ELSE
04:18:47.278 --> 04:18:53.017
IN SUPPORT.
04:18:53.084 --> 04:18:53.951
KRISTIN MURPHY WITH THE
04:18:54.018 --> 04:18:54.986
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
04:18:55.052 --> 04:18:56.520
RESOURCE CONSERVATION DISTRICTS
04:18:56.587 --> 04:19:01.092
IN SUPPORT.
04:19:01.158 --> 04:19:03.160
BRIAN -- ACUTE THE CENTER FOR
04:19:03.227 --> 04:19:07.064
BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY IN SUPPORT.
04:19:07.131 --> 04:19:08.966
SYLVIA SO LEASE SHAUN BEHALF OF
04:19:09.033 --> 04:19:10.401
ALL STATE INSURANCE AND SUPPORT.
04:19:10.468 --> 04:19:11.636
THANK YOU VERY MUCH ANYONE ELSE
04:19:11.702 --> 04:19:13.905
IN SUPPORT CNN ANY OPPOSITION TO
04:19:13.971 --> 04:19:15.172
THIS BILL.
04:19:15.239 --> 04:19:17.541
SEE AN NINE BRING IT BACK TO THE
04:19:17.608 --> 04:19:19.277
COMMITTEE FOR QUESTIONS THE CARD.
04:19:19.343 --> 04:19:21.279
THANK YOU THANK YOU ASSEMBLY
04:19:21.345 --> 04:19:21.712
MEMBER.
04:19:21.779 --> 04:19:23.581
AT DEJA VU I I KNOW WE TALKED
04:19:23.648 --> 04:19:25.349
ABOUT THIS WEATHER IS THAT AT
04:19:25.416 --> 04:19:26.350
INFORMATIONAL HEARING OR WHEN
04:19:26.417 --> 04:19:28.853
YOU'RE HIGHER BILLS ARE ARE ALL
04:19:28.920 --> 04:19:30.421
THE ABOUT.
04:19:30.488 --> 04:19:30.655
A SOON.
04:19:30.721 --> 04:19:31.622
THE BILL THAT WE SPOKE ABOUT
04:19:31.689 --> 04:19:33.357
BEFORE I RECALL AT THIS MAKES
04:19:33.424 --> 04:19:34.558
SENSE IS JUST WONDERING.
04:19:34.625 --> 04:19:36.093
WHO WOULD BE AGAINST THIS AND
04:19:36.160 --> 04:19:37.028
WHAT WHAT WITH THE PUSH BACK IF
04:19:37.094 --> 04:19:37.495
ANY?
04:19:37.561 --> 04:19:40.464
IF ANY BE AGAINST THIS WOULD IT
04:19:40.531 --> 04:19:42.233
BE I GUESS I PROPERTY OWNERS
04:19:42.300 --> 04:19:42.800
WOULD LIKE IT BUT THERE ARE
04:19:42.867 --> 04:19:43.334
OTHER ANY ORGANIZED GROUP
04:19:43.401 --> 04:19:44.368
SERVING ORGANIZATIONS WOULD
04:19:44.435 --> 04:19:45.303
OBJECT TO THIS.
04:19:45.369 --> 04:19:46.671
WE'RE NOT AWARE OF ANY ORGANIZED
04:19:46.737 --> 04:19:48.739
OPPOSITION BUT THIS THIS BILL IS
04:19:48.806 --> 04:19:50.541
REALLY INTENDED TO ALSO WORK
04:19:50.608 --> 04:19:51.742
WITH COMMUNITIES TO EDUCATE THE
04:19:51.809 --> 04:19:53.344
PUBLIC ABOUT THE DANGERS OF
04:19:53.411 --> 04:19:55.513
HAVING -- THIS COMBUSTIBLE
04:19:55.579 --> 04:19:56.681
MATERIALS AROUND THEIR HOMES AND
04:19:56.747 --> 04:19:57.481
CERTAINLY THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN
04:19:57.548 --> 04:19:58.683
SOMEONE WHO HAS YOU KNOW ONE
04:19:58.749 --> 04:20:00.084
SMALL PLANNED AND THEN.
04:20:00.151 --> 04:20:00.751
I'VE BEEN JUST DOING WINDSHIELD
04:20:00.818 --> 04:20:02.086
SURVEYS AND DRIVING AROUND MY
04:20:02.153 --> 04:20:03.220
NEIGHBORHOOD WHICH IS A HIGH
04:20:03.287 --> 04:20:04.522
FIRE SEVERITY ZONE AND THE
04:20:04.588 --> 04:20:05.423
NUMBER OF HOUSES THAT ARE
04:20:05.489 --> 04:20:06.958
LITERALLY WRAPPED.
04:20:07.024 --> 04:20:10.361
IN FOLIAGE -- YOU KNOW IS A IS
04:20:10.428 --> 04:20:11.595
REALLY ASTOUNDING AND WHEN I
04:20:11.662 --> 04:20:13.097
TALK TO HOMEOWNERS AND YOU KNOW
04:20:13.164 --> 04:20:14.465
I I PUT MYSELF IN THAT CATEGORY
04:20:14.532 --> 04:20:15.666
PEOPLE DON'T REALIZE WHAT THE
04:20:15.733 --> 04:20:16.767
DANGERS THEY JUST DON'T
04:20:16.834 --> 04:20:17.902
UNDERSTAND.
04:20:17.969 --> 04:20:18.536
THAT IT'S REALLY DIFFERENT TO
04:20:18.602 --> 04:20:20.571
HAVE A PLANT TEN FEET AWAY FOR
04:20:20.638 --> 04:20:21.238
YOUR HOUSE IS TO HAVE ONE THAT'S
04:20:21.305 --> 04:20:22.206
LITERALLY.
04:20:22.273 --> 04:20:23.641
RIGHT UP AGAINST YOUR YOUR HOUSE
04:20:23.708 --> 04:20:24.508
SO WE'RE HOPING THAT THE
04:20:24.575 --> 04:20:26.544
COMMUNITIES USE THIS TO TO GO
04:20:26.610 --> 04:20:27.778
OUT AND EDUCATE THE PUBLIC.
04:20:27.845 --> 04:20:29.680
AND START TO SORT OF IDENTIFY
04:20:29.747 --> 04:20:31.115
THOSE HOMES ARE MOST AT RISK AND
04:20:31.182 --> 04:20:32.516
SEND THEM NOTICES THE WAY THEY
04:20:32.583 --> 04:20:33.818
DO WITH OTHER TYPES OF HAZARD
04:20:33.884 --> 04:20:39.657
AND BRUSH CLEARANCE ISN'T AND
04:20:39.724 --> 04:20:42.526
GET THE WORD OUT.
04:20:42.593 --> 04:20:43.995
THIS ONE IS.
04:20:44.061 --> 04:20:45.830
THANK YOU OKAY SO NIGHT TWO
04:20:45.896 --> 04:20:48.065
QUESTIONS -- ONE IS.
04:20:48.132 --> 04:20:48.699
I I THINK YOU ALLUDED TO IT IN
04:20:48.766 --> 04:20:49.567
YOUR COMMENTS BUT THERE IS
04:20:49.633 --> 04:20:51.569
ALREADY -- A PENALTY ASSOCIATED
04:20:51.635 --> 04:20:53.170
WITH NOT HAVING THIS DEFENSIBLE
04:20:53.237 --> 04:20:55.606
SPACE YOU'RE SAYING -- IT'S
04:20:55.673 --> 04:20:56.941
DIFFERENT BECAUSE YOU'RE.
04:20:57.008 --> 04:20:58.242
YOUR SHORTENING.
04:20:58.309 --> 04:21:00.077
THEAMOUNT OF SPACE IN BETWEEN
04:21:00.144 --> 04:21:01.846
THE HOME AND AND FOLIAGE CORRECT
04:21:01.912 --> 04:21:03.347
WELL THERE'S TWO DIFFERENCES THE
04:21:03.414 --> 04:21:04.715
FIRST IS THAT THERE IS NO THE
04:21:04.782 --> 04:21:06.751
CURRENTLY IS ZERO TO FIVE
04:21:06.817 --> 04:21:08.219
DEFENSIBLE SPACE ZONE.
04:21:08.285 --> 04:21:09.754
SO THIS DOES CREATE A NEWS ON
04:21:09.820 --> 04:21:11.989
BASED ON WHAT WE SAW IN THE LAST
04:21:12.056 --> 04:21:13.991
COUPLE OF FIRES AND SECONDLY
04:21:14.058 --> 04:21:14.658
RIGHT NOW THERE'S A CIVIL
04:21:14.725 --> 04:21:16.394
PENALTY AND LEAN AUTHORITY BUT
04:21:16.460 --> 04:21:18.095
HELL FIRES NEVER USED IT HOWEVER.
04:21:18.162 --> 04:21:19.663
BECAUSE THEY HAVE TO GO TO COURT
04:21:19.730 --> 04:21:20.798
SO THIS CREATES AN
04:21:20.865 --> 04:21:22.867
ADMINISTRATIVE -- REMEDY FOR
04:21:22.933 --> 04:21:24.468
THEM BUT AGAIN WITH THE GOAL
04:21:24.535 --> 04:21:26.737
TOWARDS GETTING COMPLIANCE --
04:21:26.804 --> 04:21:28.506
YOU KNOW NOT TO WHAT DO YOU MEAN
04:21:28.572 --> 04:21:30.875
BY THE MINISTRY OF ROMANI AND I
04:21:30.941 --> 04:21:36.514
UNDERSTAND.
04:21:36.580 --> 04:21:40.384
ADMINISTRATIVE PENALTY THROUGH
04:21:40.451 --> 04:21:42.319
AN ALLERGY PROCESS.
04:21:42.386 --> 04:21:43.120
RIGHT SO IT'S IT'S A IT'S A
04:21:43.187 --> 04:21:43.721
PROCESS WHERE THEY CAN HAVE
04:21:43.788 --> 04:21:44.588
ADMINISTRATIVE CIVIL PENALTY
04:21:44.655 --> 04:21:45.189
WHERE THEY DON'T HAVE TO GO TO
04:21:45.256 --> 04:21:45.823
COURT TO DO IT THEY'RE STILL A
04:21:45.890 --> 04:21:46.457
PROCESS AND THEY'RE STILL AWAY
04:21:46.524 --> 04:21:47.124
FOR THE HOMEOWNER TO RESPOND BUT
04:21:47.191 --> 04:21:48.325
IT'S THAT DOESN'T INVOLVE THE
04:21:48.392 --> 04:21:51.996
COURT SYSTEM TO DO IT.
04:21:52.063 --> 04:21:53.831
OKAY SO YOU'RE SAYING THAT
04:21:53.898 --> 04:21:55.933
THEY'VE HAD THIS ABILITY TO
04:21:56.000 --> 04:21:57.535
PLACE A LIEN ON THE HOME THEY
04:21:57.601 --> 04:21:58.602
HAVE THAT NOW.
04:21:58.669 --> 04:22:00.271
THEY JUST NEVER USE IT AND SO
04:22:00.337 --> 04:22:02.106
YOUR OBJECTIVE LEAST PARTIALLY
04:22:02.173 --> 04:22:03.307
IN THIS BILL IS TO MAKE IT
04:22:03.374 --> 04:22:06.343
EASIER. TO HAVE A LIEN PLACED ON
04:22:06.410 --> 04:22:08.946
HOMEOWNERS PROPERTY IT'S NOT FOR
04:22:09.013 --> 04:22:10.848
A LEAN IT'S FOR THE FINE.
04:22:10.915 --> 04:22:12.016
CORRECT.
04:22:12.083 --> 04:22:13.317
YEAH AND IT'S FOR THE FINES AND
04:22:13.384 --> 04:22:14.785
TO GET COMPLIANCE WHEN PEOPLE
04:22:14.852 --> 04:22:18.722
ARE OUT OF COMPLIANCE OKAY IN --
04:22:18.789 --> 04:22:20.357
SO WHEN YOU WERE TALKING MUCH
04:22:20.424 --> 04:22:21.525
DRIVING TO YOUR NEIGHBORHOOD
04:22:21.592 --> 04:22:22.893
NOTICING A LOT OF PEOPLE HAVE
04:22:22.960 --> 04:22:24.095
YOU KNOW DIFFERENT TYPES OF
04:22:24.161 --> 04:22:26.097
PLANTS AROUND THEIR HOMES -- I'M
04:22:26.163 --> 04:22:27.631
JUST HOW ARE YOU HOW ARE PEOPLE
04:22:27.698 --> 04:22:29.467
GOING TO KNOW THAT THEIR OUT OF
04:22:29.533 --> 04:22:30.768
COMPLIANCE WELL THEY WOULD BE
04:22:30.835 --> 04:22:32.870
NOTIFIED THE SAME WAY THAT RIGHT
04:22:32.937 --> 04:22:34.004
NOW I I I I'LL JUST USE MY OWN
04:22:34.071 --> 04:22:35.306
EXPERIENCE.
04:22:35.372 --> 04:22:36.373
EVERY YEAR THE CITY OF GLENDALE
04:22:36.440 --> 04:22:38.342
DOES HAVE THE FIRE DEPARTMENT DO
04:22:38.409 --> 04:22:39.610
THEY DRIVE AROUND THE HIGH FIRED
04:22:39.677 --> 04:22:40.678
JONES THEY START SENDING OUT
04:22:40.744 --> 04:22:41.979
NOTICES PEOPLE SAYING.
04:22:42.046 --> 04:22:43.414
YOU KNOW FROM WHAT WE SAW YOUR
04:22:43.481 --> 04:22:44.882
OUT OF COMPLIANCE YOU'RE NOT
04:22:44.949 --> 04:22:46.684
THAT I WOULD KNOW PERSONALLY BUT
04:22:46.750 --> 04:22:47.852
YOU'RE A YOU KNOW WE THINK THAT
04:22:47.918 --> 04:22:49.019
YOU NEED TO REMOVE SOME OF THE
04:22:49.086 --> 04:22:50.321
BRUSH IN YOUR LANDSCAPE.
04:22:50.387 --> 04:22:53.491
AND SO THEY DO ACTUALLY NOTIFY
04:22:53.557 --> 04:22:54.058
PEOPLE.
04:22:54.125 --> 04:22:55.126
AND CAL FIRE DOES NOTIFY PEOPLE
04:22:55.192 --> 04:22:56.861
IN THEIR RESPONSIBILITIES OWN SO
04:22:56.927 --> 04:22:59.330
THERE IS NOTICING THAT GOES OUT.
04:22:59.396 --> 04:23:02.533
OKAY SO THEN -- EVERYONE IS A
04:23:02.600 --> 04:23:04.368
GUARANTEED BEING NOTIFIED IF
04:23:04.435 --> 04:23:05.503
THEY'RE OUT OF COMPLIANCE BUT
04:23:05.569 --> 04:23:07.037
WHEN AN OPPORTUNITY TO REMEDY
04:23:07.104 --> 04:23:08.305
THE SITUATION BEFORE THEY GET
04:23:08.372 --> 04:23:10.107
FINED ABSOLUTELY AND WHAT IS
04:23:10.174 --> 04:23:13.544
THAT TIME FRAME.
04:23:13.611 --> 04:23:14.812
LET'S NOT I GUESS IT'S WHATEVER
04:23:14.879 --> 04:23:15.846
IT IS NOW RATED YOU'RE NOT
04:23:15.913 --> 04:23:17.281
CHANGING THAT IT MIGHT CHANGE BY
04:23:17.348 --> 04:23:18.816
DIFFERENT MUNICIPALITY OR WHO'S
04:23:18.883 --> 04:23:21.118
THE RESPONSIBLE AGENCIES SO CAL
04:23:21.185 --> 04:23:22.720
FIRE FOR THEIR RESPONSIBILITY
04:23:22.786 --> 04:23:24.054
THEY DO THAT IN THEIR
04:23:24.121 --> 04:23:25.456
RESPONSIBILITIES ON A LOT OF
04:23:25.523 --> 04:23:26.257
MUNICIPALITIES.
04:23:26.323 --> 04:23:27.825
DO IT THEMSELVES BECAUSE THERE
04:23:27.892 --> 04:23:29.894
HAVE THEIR OWN YOU KNOW THEIR
04:23:29.960 --> 04:23:32.029
OWN A PROCESS.
04:23:32.096 --> 04:23:33.531
OKAY -- THANK YOU.
04:23:33.597 --> 04:23:35.166
WELCOME.
04:23:35.232 --> 04:23:41.172
YES THIS MATHIS SO.
04:23:41.238 --> 04:23:42.506
WE WE YOU SAY YOU GET A
04:23:42.573 --> 04:23:45.309
NOTIFICATION.
04:23:45.376 --> 04:23:47.778
I ON A HOUSE YOU'VE HAD FOR
04:23:47.845 --> 04:23:49.480
TWENTY YEARS YOU SPENT.
04:23:49.547 --> 04:23:52.149
A TON OF INVESTMENT.
04:23:52.216 --> 04:23:53.884
NOT ON THIS LANDSCAPE NET
04:23:53.951 --> 04:23:56.187
NAGGING NOTIFICATION THAT YOU'VE
04:23:56.253 --> 04:23:57.988
GOT TO GET RID OF IT
04:23:58.055 --> 04:23:58.289
[inaudible]
04:23:58.355 --> 04:23:59.890
SEOUL.
04:23:59.957 --> 04:24:01.225
WHAT IS THE FINANCIAL
04:24:01.292 --> 04:24:02.726
RECUPERATION FOR HAVING TO
04:24:02.793 --> 04:24:04.428
REMOVE THAT?
04:24:04.495 --> 04:24:06.096
BE BECAUSE NOW NOW WE'RE WE'RE
04:24:06.163 --> 04:24:07.031
TELLING PEOPLE THAT I'VE HAD
04:24:07.097 --> 04:24:09.033
THIS LANDSCAPE FOR WHO KNOWS HOW
04:24:09.099 --> 04:24:10.935
LONG HEY GUESS WHAT YOU NEED
04:24:11.001 --> 04:24:12.269
PULL ALL THAT OUT.
04:24:12.336 --> 04:24:15.206
SO WE WITHOUT.
04:24:15.272 --> 04:24:16.407
THE ANY ABILITY TO PULL NOW SO
04:24:16.473 --> 04:24:17.808
NOW WE'RE JUST EXPECTING PEOPLE
04:24:17.875 --> 04:24:20.144
TO GO READ ABOUT SOMETHING AND
04:24:20.211 --> 04:24:21.645
INVESTMENT THAT THEY'VE MADE.
04:24:21.712 --> 04:24:22.913
THAT THEY'VE BEEN TOLD FOR
04:24:22.980 --> 04:24:25.583
DECADES IS IS AN INVESTMENT TO
04:24:25.649 --> 04:24:27.718
INCREASE OUR HOME VALUE.
04:24:27.785 --> 04:24:28.185
AND SO.
04:24:28.252 --> 04:24:29.119
I MEAN IS THERE FINANCIAL
04:24:29.186 --> 04:24:31.288
INCENTIVE IN YOUR BILL THAT'S
04:24:31.355 --> 04:24:32.623
GOING TO HELP PAY FOR THIS.
04:24:32.690 --> 04:24:34.625
ORDER IF IT'S AN OLD TREE THAT'S
04:24:34.692 --> 04:24:36.060
BEEN THERE.
04:24:36.126 --> 04:24:37.394
I MEAN TO SOMETIMES TAKE A SOME
04:24:37.461 --> 04:24:39.129
OF THE STUFF OUT IS EXTREMELY
04:24:39.196 --> 04:24:41.565
COSTLY ESPECIALLY IF IT'S RIGHT
04:24:41.632 --> 04:24:42.233
NEXT TO THE HOUSE.
04:24:42.299 --> 04:24:43.000
THEN YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT ROOT
04:24:43.067 --> 04:24:44.635
SYSTEMS THAT ARE GOING.
04:24:44.702 --> 04:24:50.341
UNDERNEATH THE FOUNDATION -- SO
04:24:50.407 --> 04:24:51.375
I MEAN IT IT THESE THIS CAN GIVE
04:24:51.442 --> 04:24:53.711
VERY VERY COSTLY VERY QUICKLY --
04:24:53.777 --> 04:24:56.080
A ADDED RE CONSTRUCTION AND
04:24:56.146 --> 04:24:58.082
REMODELING HOMES AND FLIPPING
04:24:58.148 --> 04:25:00.050
HOUSES AND BETWEEN DEPLOYMENTS.
04:25:00.117 --> 04:25:01.986
IN.
04:25:02.052 --> 04:25:03.287
I MEAN FIXING A FOUNDATION IS A
04:25:03.354 --> 04:25:04.688
NIGHTMARE.
04:25:04.755 --> 04:25:05.456
SO IF YOU'RE GONNA GO START
04:25:05.522 --> 04:25:06.991
PULLING STUFF OUT.
04:25:07.057 --> 04:25:08.959
I MEAN IS THIS CAN QUICKLY GOING
04:25:09.026 --> 04:25:11.161
TO THE THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS THAT
04:25:11.228 --> 04:25:12.896
WE'RE ASKING PEOPLE TO DO.
04:25:12.963 --> 04:25:14.965
OKAY SO FIRST OF ALL -- WE ARE
04:25:15.032 --> 04:25:17.401
NOT -- IT RIGHT NOW SAYING THAT
04:25:17.468 --> 04:25:18.569
YOU CAN'T HAVE ANYTHING WITHIN
04:25:18.636 --> 04:25:20.571
THE FIVE FEET WE THE BILL
04:25:20.638 --> 04:25:23.741
DIRECTS -- THE VARIOUS YOU KNOW
04:25:23.807 --> 04:25:25.242
EXPERTS SORT OF COTTON SORT OF
04:25:25.309 --> 04:25:26.944
WELL I'M A LOOK AT WHAT EXACTLY
04:25:27.011 --> 04:25:28.045
WE SHOULD BE RECOMMENDING BUT
04:25:28.112 --> 04:25:30.581
ALSO TO FOCUS ON SORT OF THE
04:25:30.648 --> 04:25:31.982
MOST FLAMMABLE MOST DANGEROUS
04:25:32.049 --> 04:25:33.350
MATERIALS.
04:25:33.417 --> 04:25:34.418
BUT I WOULD SAY THAT IS
04:25:34.485 --> 04:25:36.020
EXPENSIVE IS REMOVING THIS
04:25:36.086 --> 04:25:37.354
MATERIAL WITHIN FIVE FEET FOR
04:25:37.421 --> 04:25:38.555
YOUR HOUSES IT'S NOT GONNA BE
04:25:38.622 --> 04:25:40.190
NEARLY AS EXPENSIVE AS REPLACING
04:25:40.257 --> 04:25:41.425
YOUR HOUSE IF IT BURNS DOWN IN A
04:25:41.492 --> 04:25:42.159
FIRE.
04:25:42.226 --> 04:25:44.094
SO THERE IS A YOU KNOW KIND OF A
04:25:44.161 --> 04:25:45.829
RISK ANALYSIS THAT HOMEOWNERS
04:25:45.896 --> 04:25:46.930
NEED TO BE DOING WHEN THEY LOOK
04:25:46.997 --> 04:25:47.898
AT THIS AND IF YOU.
04:25:47.965 --> 04:25:49.767
GET A NOTICE FROM ONE OF YOUR
04:25:49.833 --> 04:25:51.568
AGENCY SAYING THAT YOU HAVE A
04:25:51.635 --> 04:25:53.737
REAL A HAZARDOUS CONDITION AND
04:25:53.804 --> 04:25:54.405
YOU'RE ALREADY LIVING AT A HIGH
04:25:54.471 --> 04:25:55.339
FIRE.
04:25:55.406 --> 04:25:56.874
SEVERITY ZONE WHICH THIS BILL
04:25:56.940 --> 04:25:58.309
ONLY IMPACTS.
04:25:58.375 --> 04:25:59.977
YOU REALLY NEED TO DO THAT COST
04:26:00.044 --> 04:26:01.645
BENEFIT US AND BENEFIT ANALYSIS
04:26:01.712 --> 04:26:03.380
AND CERTAINLY YOU KNOW SOMEONE
04:26:03.447 --> 04:26:04.682
WHO GETS NOTICE WAS A COUPLE OF
04:26:04.748 --> 04:26:06.116
PLANTS IS NOT A BIG DEAL BUT IF
04:26:06.183 --> 04:26:06.950
YOU'VE GOT.
04:26:07.017 --> 04:26:08.886
A REALLY FLAMMABLE TREE RIGHT UP
04:26:08.952 --> 04:26:09.687
AGAINST YOUR HOUSE.
04:26:09.753 --> 04:26:10.921
PEOPLE REALLY DO NEED TO BE PUT
04:26:10.988 --> 04:26:12.856
ON NOTICE BECAUSE PEOPLE DO NOT
04:26:12.923 --> 04:26:14.591
REALIZE HOW HAZARDOUS THAT IS
04:26:14.658 --> 04:26:16.327
THEY JUST DON'T NOW SO A LOT OF
04:26:16.393 --> 04:26:18.062
THIS IS ABOUT EDUCATING PEOPLE
04:26:18.128 --> 04:26:19.463
SO THAT THEY CAN NO AYE THOSE
04:26:19.530 --> 04:26:21.031
KINDS OF ANALYSIS YOU TO DO THAT
04:26:21.098 --> 04:26:22.533
DO THAT ANALYSIS AND SELF.
04:26:22.599 --> 04:26:24.868
ABSOLUTELY BUT THE MEN WERE ALSO
04:26:24.935 --> 04:26:28.472
IN THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA WHERE
04:26:28.539 --> 04:26:29.940
WERE YOU KNOW.
04:26:30.007 --> 04:26:31.141
SAYING THAT PEOPLE CAN'T AFFORD
04:26:31.208 --> 04:26:32.242
TO PAY THEIR OWN TRAFFIC TICKETS.
04:26:32.309 --> 04:26:33.110
SO HOW SHOULD WE EXPECT THEM TO
04:26:33.177 --> 04:26:37.181
REMOVE TREES THERE ARE -- FIRE --
04:26:37.247 --> 04:26:39.350
RESPONSIBILITY -- AREAS THAT
04:26:39.416 --> 04:26:41.585
HAVE COME UP WITH WAYS OF
04:26:41.652 --> 04:26:43.220
INCENTIVIZING AND FINANCING LOW
04:26:43.287 --> 04:26:45.089
INCOME HOMEOWNERS TO REMOVE
04:26:45.155 --> 04:26:46.990
HAZARDOUS MATERIALS AND THERE
04:26:47.057 --> 04:26:48.492
ARE CITIES THAT DO THAT AS WELL
04:26:48.559 --> 04:26:50.494
WHERE THEY HAVE FOR LOW INCOMES --
04:26:50.561 --> 04:26:53.364
HOMEOWNERS AND SENIORS -- ALL
04:26:53.430 --> 04:26:54.698
KINDS OF HAZARD ABATEMENT
04:26:54.765 --> 04:26:56.734
PROGRAMS THAT ARE AVAILABLE SO
04:26:56.800 --> 04:26:58.235
THERE ARE LOCAL INCENTIVE
04:26:58.302 --> 04:27:00.404
PROGRAMS IN PLACE IN MANY PLACES
04:27:00.471 --> 04:27:01.972
AND I CERTAINLY WOULD SUPPORT.
04:27:02.039 --> 04:27:03.173
MEASURES TO INCREASE THE
04:27:03.240 --> 04:27:05.542
AVAILABILITY OF PEOPLE TO DO ALL
04:27:05.609 --> 04:27:07.211
KINDS OF HOME HARDENING --
04:27:07.277 --> 04:27:08.379
BECAUSE THIS IS GOING TO BE A
04:27:08.445 --> 04:27:09.513
PROBLEM ALL ACROSS THE STATE AS
04:27:09.580 --> 04:27:11.582
WILD FIRE RISK INCREASES I MEAN
04:27:11.648 --> 04:27:13.183
WILL HAVE THE SAME CONVERSATION
04:27:13.250 --> 04:27:14.651
ABOUT HOME HARDENING ABOUT
04:27:14.718 --> 04:27:16.019
REPLACING ROOFS ABOUT.
04:27:16.086 --> 04:27:17.287
YOU KNOW ALL OF THESE DIFFERENT
04:27:17.354 --> 04:27:18.689
MEASURES YOU KNOW I THINK IS AS
04:27:18.756 --> 04:27:19.723
HIGHLIGHTED.
04:27:19.790 --> 04:27:20.991
ABSOLUTELY UNDERSTAND DEFENSE
04:27:21.058 --> 04:27:21.959
YEAH SPACE EIGHT MY FIRST JOB
04:27:22.025 --> 04:27:23.360
WAS DRIVING A THREE WHEELER WITH
04:27:23.427 --> 04:27:25.262
THE TRAILER CLEARING DEFENSIBLE
04:27:25.329 --> 04:27:28.298
SPACE ON THE COUNTRY -- IN IN MY
04:27:28.365 --> 04:27:29.767
ROLE COMMUNITY WHERE I GREW UP
04:27:29.833 --> 04:27:31.735
SO I I KNOW ALL ABOUT IT VERY
04:27:31.802 --> 04:27:34.838
WELL -- BUT I ALSO ONE OF THE BY
04:27:34.905 --> 04:27:37.074
I ALSO KNOWS VERY COSTLY IN
04:27:37.141 --> 04:27:38.242
WITHOUT HAVING A FUNDING.
04:27:38.308 --> 04:27:39.743
TASKED WITH IN THE BILL TO
04:27:39.810 --> 04:27:41.979
REALLY HAVE A MECHANISM THERE.
04:27:42.045 --> 04:27:44.114
TO HELP THESE FAMILIES OUT TO DO
04:27:44.181 --> 04:27:46.283
THIS I I CAN'T SUPPORT IT INTO A
04:27:46.350 --> 04:27:47.351
SALE ALSO SAID THAT A BIG PART
04:27:47.418 --> 04:27:49.186
OF THIS IS TO CHANGE THE CODES
04:27:49.253 --> 04:27:49.887
FOR NEW CONSTRUCTION A NEW
04:27:49.953 --> 04:27:51.255
LANDSCAPES THAT ARE PUT IN AND
04:27:51.321 --> 04:27:52.489
YOU KNOW THAT'S NOT SOMETHING TO
04:27:52.556 --> 04:27:54.024
BE IGNORED BECAUSE LANDSCAPE
04:27:54.091 --> 04:27:54.458
DESIGNERS.
04:27:54.525 --> 04:27:55.993
ARE STILL DESIGNING NEW NEW
04:27:56.059 --> 04:27:57.227
LANDSCAPES TODAY IN THESE ZONES
04:27:57.294 --> 04:28:00.030
WITH PLANTING RIGHT IN THAT FIVE
04:28:00.097 --> 04:28:06.136
FOOT -- AREA.
04:28:06.203 --> 04:28:06.737
THANK YOU ANY OTHER QUESTIONS
04:28:06.804 --> 04:28:09.273
FROM THE COMMITTEE.
04:28:09.339 --> 04:28:10.641
FROM A FIREFIGHTER -- SORRY MR
04:28:10.707 --> 04:28:11.508
SOME GOOD WE JUST ADD IN THIS IS
04:28:11.575 --> 04:28:12.810
SOMETHING THAT I'VE ACTUALLY
04:28:12.876 --> 04:28:13.677
WORKED PRETTY CLOSELY WITH MILES
04:28:13.744 --> 04:28:15.913
WHO WAS OR THE SECOND I'LL TELL
04:28:15.979 --> 04:28:16.880
YOU HOW IT'S GOING TO GET USE.
04:28:16.947 --> 04:28:18.048
EVERY NEIGHBORHOOD KNOWS THE
04:28:18.115 --> 04:28:18.582
HOUSE.
04:28:18.649 --> 04:28:20.284
LOCAL FIRE AGENCIES NO THE HOUSE.
04:28:20.350 --> 04:28:21.919
THAT FIRE SAFE COUNCILS NO THE
04:28:21.985 --> 04:28:23.053
HOUSE THAT THEY'VE BEEN TRYING
04:28:23.120 --> 04:28:24.588
TO GET CLEANED UP AND THAT ONE
04:28:24.655 --> 04:28:26.223
HOUSE WHO REFUSES TO CLEAN UP.
04:28:26.290 --> 04:28:27.791
AND ADDRESS OF THE THE
04:28:27.858 --> 04:28:29.393
DEFENSIBLE SPACE IS A THREAT TO
04:28:29.460 --> 04:28:31.328
THE ENTIRE NEIGHBORHOOD SO YEAH
04:28:31.395 --> 04:28:32.830
IT'S A COST TO THAT HOUSE BUT
04:28:32.896 --> 04:28:34.131
IT'S A COST TO THE ENTIRE
04:28:34.198 --> 04:28:35.966
NEIGHBORHOOD IN THESE FIRE.
04:28:36.033 --> 04:28:37.835
RISK AREAS WHEN THEY GO UP SO I
04:28:37.901 --> 04:28:39.736
DON'T SEE LOCAL AGENCIES ARE CAL
04:28:39.803 --> 04:28:40.604
FIRE.
04:28:40.671 --> 04:28:42.973
USING THIS IRRESPONSIBLY THEY'RE
04:28:43.040 --> 04:28:43.974
GOING TO THEY CONSTANTLY ARE
04:28:44.041 --> 04:28:45.409
WORKING WITH HOMEOWNERS THEIR
04:28:45.476 --> 04:28:45.843
COSTLY WORKING WITH
04:28:45.909 --> 04:28:47.277
NEIGHBORHOODS TO GET THEM TO
04:28:47.344 --> 04:28:49.513
CLEAN UP THE RISKIEST AREAS AND
04:28:49.580 --> 04:28:51.415
THOSE LAST FEW HOMES THAT
04:28:51.482 --> 04:28:52.983
REFUSED TO PARTICIPATE.
04:28:53.050 --> 04:28:55.052
AND THAT PUT ITS THREAT THE REST
04:28:55.118 --> 04:28:55.853
OF THAT NEIGHBORHOOD ARE THE
04:28:55.919 --> 04:28:58.922
ONES WHO ARE GOING TO BE.
04:28:58.989 --> 04:29:00.924
THIS TOOL WILL BE USED. TO TRY
04:29:00.991 --> 04:29:02.059
AND MAKE SURE THAT THEY ARE
04:29:02.125 --> 04:29:03.760
BEING RESPONSIBLE THAT'S THE
04:29:03.827 --> 04:29:05.529
LEVEL OF RISK THAT THAT WE'RE
04:29:05.596 --> 04:29:07.564
TALKING ABOUT I DON'T SEE IT
04:29:07.631 --> 04:29:08.398
BEING USED.
04:29:08.465 --> 04:29:10.334
SORT OF **** NILLY AND JUST FOR
04:29:10.400 --> 04:29:11.668
FOR EVERYONE AND IT'S
04:29:11.735 --> 04:29:14.471
ASTONISHING WHAT SOME HOMEOWNERS
04:29:14.538 --> 04:29:16.373
ARE ARE REALLY NOT WILLING TO DO
04:29:16.440 --> 04:29:17.140
THAT BUT THEMSELVES AND OTHERS
04:29:17.207 --> 04:29:20.310
AT RISK AND THIS IS HOW THIS WAS
04:29:20.377 --> 04:29:20.878
GOING TO BE USED AND I THINK
04:29:20.944 --> 04:29:21.912
IT'S GOING TO BE VERY EFFECTIVE.
04:29:21.979 --> 04:29:24.982
THANK YOU VERY MUCH ANYONE ELSE.
04:29:25.048 --> 04:29:26.850
CNN MANAGER WOULD LIKE TO CLOSE.
04:29:26.917 --> 04:29:27.951
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST AN AYE VOTE
04:29:28.018 --> 04:29:29.987
AND THANK YOU FOR THE ROBUST
04:29:30.053 --> 04:29:31.889
CONVERSATION AT THE END OF THE
04:29:31.955 --> 04:29:32.122
HEARING.
04:29:32.189 --> 04:29:34.091
THIS.
04:29:34.157 --> 04:29:35.359
AS SECOND PLEASE CALL THE ROLL I
04:29:35.425 --> 04:29:36.527
AM TWENTY SIX A. B. FIFTEEN
04:29:36.593 --> 04:29:37.060
SIXTEEN BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER
04:29:37.127 --> 04:29:38.028
FRIEDMAN THE MOTION IS TO PASS
04:29:38.095 --> 04:29:39.496
AS AMENDED AND REFER TO
04:29:39.563 --> 04:29:41.632
UTILITIES AND ENERGY COMMITTEE.
04:29:41.698 --> 04:29:43.667
MEMBERS FRIEDMAN HI FRIEDMAN I
04:29:43.734 --> 04:29:47.804
FLORA FLORA I'D CHAU CHAU AYE
04:29:47.871 --> 04:29:50.040
EGGMAN.
04:29:50.107 --> 04:29:53.677
EGGMAN AYE GARCIA GARCIA ITEM ON
04:29:53.744 --> 04:29:55.479
THE MOON I MATHIS.
04:29:55.546 --> 04:29:57.414
MATHIS NOT VOTING MCCARTY.
04:29:57.481 --> 04:30:01.218
HI MCCARTY AYE MELINDA'S.
04:30:01.285 --> 04:30:03.453
DILLON DOES NOT VOTING.
04:30:03.520 --> 04:30:06.924
WE'RE OUT TO CHANGE.
04:30:06.990 --> 04:30:07.691
ROUTE SIXTY AYE STONE.
04:30:07.758 --> 04:30:15.265
STONE AYE. NINE ZERO I AM SURE
04:30:15.332 --> 04:30:21.838
THAT BILLS OUT.
04:30:21.905 --> 04:30:22.406
HEY WITH THAT.
04:30:22.472 --> 04:30:25.108
WE ARE GOING -- TO CALL FOR A
04:30:25.175 --> 04:30:28.478
MOTION ON THE CONSENT CALENDAR.
04:30:28.545 --> 04:30:30.013
WE HAVE A MOTION ON THE CONSENT
04:30:30.080 --> 04:30:30.581
CALENDAR COMING OF ROLL CALL
04:30:30.647 --> 04:30:33.250
PLEASE.
04:30:33.317 --> 04:30:34.785
ON THE CONSENT CALENDAR. TO PASS
04:30:34.851 --> 04:30:35.586
AND REFERRED APPROPRIATIONS
04:30:35.652 --> 04:30:36.386
COMMITTEE WITH CONSENT
04:30:36.453 --> 04:30:40.290
RECOMMENDATION MEMBERS FRIEDMAN
04:30:40.357 --> 04:30:42.793
HI FRIEDMAN I FLORA.
04:30:42.859 --> 04:30:45.562
FLORA I CHILD CHAU AYE EGGMAN.
04:30:45.629 --> 04:30:49.766
EGGMAN AYE GARCIA GARCIA ISLANDS.
04:30:49.833 --> 04:30:52.102
Là MON I MATHIS MATHIS AYE
04:30:52.169 --> 04:30:54.271
MCCARTY AYE MCCARTY AYE
04:30:54.338 --> 04:30:56.473
MELINDA'S MELENDEZ AYE
04:30:56.540 --> 04:30:58.475
MURATSUCHI.
04:30:58.542 --> 04:30:59.543
WROTE TO GI STONE.
04:30:59.610 --> 04:31:01.378
STONE NINE ELEVEN ZERO OKAY CAN
04:31:01.445 --> 04:31:02.012
WE START AT THE TOP BECAUSE WE
04:31:02.079 --> 04:31:03.513
HAVE BILLS IN THE BEGINNING THEY
04:31:03.580 --> 04:31:06.850
DON'T HAVE MOTIONS OR SECONDS AS
04:31:06.917 --> 04:31:07.050
WELL.
04:31:07.117 --> 04:31:08.151
WE HAVE A LIST OF THOSE.
04:31:08.218 --> 04:31:11.321
ITEM ONE AB ONE FORTY FOUR BY
04:31:11.388 --> 04:31:12.789
TWO SECOND.
04:31:12.856 --> 04:31:15.058
OKAY COULD WE HAVE A ROLL CALL.
04:31:15.125 --> 04:31:16.627
AB ONE FORTY FOUR AGUIAR-CURRY
04:31:16.693 --> 04:31:18.095
DO PASS AND REFERRED
04:31:18.161 --> 04:31:19.429
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE MEMBERS
04:31:19.496 --> 04:31:22.265
FRIEDMAN HI FRIEDMAN I FLORA
04:31:22.332 --> 04:31:24.434
FLORA AYE CHAU.
04:31:24.501 --> 04:31:26.570
CHAU AYE EGGMAN.
04:31:26.637 --> 04:31:29.706
EGGMAN AYE GARCIA AYE GARCIA AYE
04:31:29.773 --> 04:31:30.974
LOW MOAN.
04:31:31.041 --> 04:31:33.543
LIMON AYE MATHIS MATHIS AYE
04:31:33.610 --> 04:31:37.214
MCCARTY AYE MCCARTY AYE MELENDEZ
04:31:37.280 --> 04:31:40.283
MELENDEZ AYE MURATSUCHI
04:31:40.350 --> 04:31:41.251
MURATSUCHI AYE STONE.
04:31:41.318 --> 04:31:46.089
STONE AYE ELEVEN ZERO ELEVEN
04:31:46.156 --> 04:31:47.991
ZERO THAT THOSE OUT.
04:31:48.058 --> 04:31:49.459
ITEM TO AB TWO EIGHTY FIVE BY
04:31:49.526 --> 04:31:50.594
FRIEDMAN DO PASSED REFER TO
04:31:50.661 --> 04:31:51.561
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE CURRENT --
04:31:51.628 --> 04:31:53.030
IS SEVEN TO THREE WITH THE CHORE
04:31:53.096 --> 04:31:55.198
VOTING I ABSENT MEMBERS CHAU
04:31:55.265 --> 04:31:55.499
[inaudible]
04:31:55.565 --> 04:31:59.436
SHALL I EIGHT THREE EIGHT THREE
04:31:59.503 --> 04:32:01.338
THAT BILL IS OUT.
04:32:01.405 --> 04:32:02.606
ITEM THREE AB TWO NINETY SIX I
04:32:02.673 --> 04:32:04.574
NEED A MOTION AND A SECOND.
04:32:04.641 --> 04:32:06.410
ROLL CALL PLEASE.
04:32:06.476 --> 04:32:07.244
AB TWO NINETY SIX BY MEMBER
04:32:07.310 --> 04:32:07.778
COOLEY TO PASS AS AMENDED
04:32:07.844 --> 04:32:08.979
REFERRED APPROPRIATIONS
04:32:09.046 --> 04:32:10.914
COMMITTEE MEMBERS FRIEDMAN AYE
04:32:10.981 --> 04:32:12.115
FRIEDMAN AYE FLORA.
04:32:12.182 --> 04:32:15.218
FLORA AYE CHAU CHAU AYE EGGMAN.
04:32:15.285 --> 04:32:17.154
EGGMAN AYE GARCIA AYE GARCIA AYE
04:32:17.220 --> 04:32:18.355
LOW MOAN.
04:32:18.422 --> 04:32:20.057
THE LOAN I MATHIS.
04:32:20.123 --> 04:32:22.059
MATHIS I MCCARTY AYE MCCARTY AYE
04:32:22.125 --> 04:32:23.660
MELENDEZ.
04:32:23.727 --> 04:32:27.597
MELENDEZ NO RIGHT TO CHEAT.
04:32:27.664 --> 04:32:29.700
MURATSUCHI AYE STONE.
04:32:29.766 --> 04:32:31.401
ON I TEN ONE TEN ONE THAT THOSE
04:32:31.468 --> 04:32:33.870
UP.
04:32:33.937 --> 04:32:34.805
MAYBE THREE FORTY TWO ITEM FOR
04:32:34.871 --> 04:32:36.273
MURATSUCHI DO PASS AS AMENDED
04:32:36.339 --> 04:32:37.107
REFERRED APPROPRIATIONS
04:32:37.174 --> 04:32:39.209
COMMITTEE CURRENT VOTE THIS
04:32:39.276 --> 04:32:39.810
SEVEN TO THREE ABSENT MEMBERS
04:32:39.876 --> 04:32:40.010
CHAU.
04:32:40.077 --> 04:32:43.280
CHOW AYE EIGHT THREE EIGHT THREE
04:32:43.346 --> 04:32:44.781
THAT BILL IS OUT.
04:32:44.848 --> 04:32:46.416
I DON'T FIVE AB FOR TWENTY THREE
04:32:46.483 --> 04:32:47.250
GLORIA DO PASSED REFERRED
04:32:47.317 --> 04:32:49.352
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE CURRENT
04:32:49.419 --> 04:32:49.986
VOTE FOR THE ONE WITH THE CHORE
04:32:50.053 --> 04:32:54.591
VOTING I ABSENT MEMBERS FLORA.
04:32:54.658 --> 04:32:56.760
FLORA NOT VOTING CHAU.
04:32:56.827 --> 04:32:58.895
TROUT I LIMóN.
04:32:58.962 --> 04:33:02.099
LOW MOAN I MCCARTY HI MCCARTY
04:33:02.165 --> 04:33:04.067
AYE MELINDA'S.
04:33:04.134 --> 04:33:07.771
LENDERS NO ROUTE SEARCHES.
04:33:07.838 --> 04:33:13.110
READ THROUGH GI. EIGHT TO EIGHTY
04:33:13.176 --> 04:33:14.511
TWO THAT DOLLARS OUT.
04:33:14.578 --> 04:33:15.812
ITEM SIX A BEFORE THIRTY WAS
04:33:15.879 --> 04:33:18.782
TESTIMONY ONLY.
04:33:18.849 --> 04:33:19.583
ITEM SEVEN AB FIVE FIFTY TWO BY
04:33:19.649 --> 04:33:21.118
MARK STONE.
04:33:21.184 --> 04:33:21.985
DO PASS AS AMENDED REFERRED
04:33:22.052 --> 04:33:23.220
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE CURRENT
04:33:23.286 --> 04:33:24.521
VOTE SEVEN TO THREE WITH THE
04:33:24.588 --> 04:33:25.756
CHORE VOTING I ABSENT MEMBER
04:33:25.822 --> 04:33:26.690
CHAU.
04:33:26.757 --> 04:33:29.192
CHOW AYE.
04:33:29.259 --> 04:33:29.793
EIGHT THREE A THROUGH THE BILL
04:33:29.860 --> 04:33:30.927
ITSELF.
04:33:30.994 --> 04:33:32.295
I AM A AB FIVE EIGHTY FIVE BY
04:33:32.362 --> 04:33:33.096
THE MOM TO PASS REFERRED
04:33:33.163 --> 04:33:34.331
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE CURRENT
04:33:34.397 --> 04:33:35.899
GOAL IS.
04:33:35.966 --> 04:33:37.901
SEVEN ZERO ABSENT MEMBERS CHILD.
04:33:37.968 --> 04:33:39.703
CHAU I MELENDEZ.
04:33:39.770 --> 04:33:41.271
THE LENDERS KNOW. EIGHT ONE
04:33:41.338 --> 04:33:43.006
EIGHT ONE THAT BILL IS OUT.
04:33:43.073 --> 04:33:44.808
I DO NINE A. B. SIX SIXTY ONE
04:33:44.875 --> 04:33:45.375
MCCARTY DO PASS AS AMENDED
04:33:45.442 --> 04:33:46.176
REFERRED APPROPRIATIONS
04:33:46.243 --> 04:33:46.610
COMMITTEE.
04:33:46.676 --> 04:33:48.645
CURRENT VOTE.
04:33:48.712 --> 04:33:49.613
NINE ZERO ABSENT MEMBERS CHOW.
04:33:49.679 --> 04:33:52.682
CHOW I TEND ZERO TEN TO ZERO
04:33:52.749 --> 04:33:53.917
THAT GOES OUT.
04:33:53.984 --> 04:33:55.819
ITEM TEN EIGHTY SEVEN NINETY TWO
04:33:55.886 --> 04:33:57.220
BY TEEN TO PASS AS AMENDED
04:33:57.287 --> 04:33:57.954
REFERRED APPROPRIATIONS
04:33:58.021 --> 04:33:59.322
COMMITTEE CURRENT VOTE FOR THE
04:33:59.389 --> 04:34:00.390
ONE WITH THE CHAIR VOTING I
04:34:00.457 --> 04:34:02.993
ABSENT MEMBERS FLORA.
04:34:03.059 --> 04:34:06.730
THE VOTING FLORA NOT VOTING CHAU.
04:34:06.797 --> 04:34:09.399
CHAU II LIMóN.
04:34:09.466 --> 04:34:13.670
LIMON I MCCARTY BY THE CARTY I
04:34:13.737 --> 04:34:14.838
FOR A TO G..
04:34:14.905 --> 04:34:18.108
ROTH TO GI. EIGHT ONE EIGHT TO
04:34:18.175 --> 04:34:19.776
ONE THAT BILL IS OUT.
04:34:19.843 --> 04:34:21.378
ITEM ELEVEN I NEED A MOTION AND
04:34:21.444 --> 04:34:28.018
A SECOND.
04:34:28.084 --> 04:34:31.788
WHO WAS THE SECOND?
04:34:31.855 --> 04:34:34.357
RESEARCHING OKAY THANK YOU THE
04:34:34.424 --> 04:34:36.226
VIETNAMESE.
04:34:36.293 --> 04:34:38.195
YEAH ITEM ELEVEN AB EIGHT
04:34:38.261 --> 04:34:38.929
FIFTEEN IGOR CURRY DO PASS AS
04:34:38.995 --> 04:34:40.430
AMENDED REFERRED APPROPRIATIONS
04:34:40.497 --> 04:34:40.931
COMMITTEE.
04:34:40.997 --> 04:34:43.066
MEMBERS FRIEDMAN HI FRIEDMAN I
04:34:43.133 --> 04:34:46.369
FLORA FLORA AYE CHAU.
04:34:46.436 --> 04:34:49.139
CHAU AYE EGGMAN.
04:34:49.206 --> 04:34:53.143
EGGMAN AYE GARCIA. THIRTY AYE
04:34:53.210 --> 04:34:57.080
LOW MOAN HI Là MON I MATHIS.
04:34:57.147 --> 04:34:58.215
MATHIS AYE MCCARTY AYE MCCARTY
04:34:58.281 --> 04:35:01.151
AYE MELINDA'S MELENDEZ AYE
04:35:01.218 --> 04:35:02.619
MURATSUCHI.
04:35:02.686 --> 04:35:05.622
MURATSUCHI AYE STONE.
04:35:05.689 --> 04:35:09.326
STONE I ELEVEN ZERO I AM YOUR
04:35:09.392 --> 04:35:09.893
LEVEL IS OUT.
04:35:09.960 --> 04:35:11.728
ITEM TWELVE AB EIGHT THIRTY SIX
04:35:11.795 --> 04:35:11.995
BY WICKS.
04:35:12.062 --> 04:35:14.397
THANK YOU.
04:35:14.464 --> 04:35:16.199
ITEM TWELVE AB EIGHT THIRTY SIX
04:35:16.266 --> 04:35:16.733
WEEKS TO PASS AS AMENDED
04:35:16.800 --> 04:35:17.234
REFERRED APPROPRIATIONS
04:35:17.300 --> 04:35:19.269
COMMITTEE MEMBERS FRIEDMAN AYE
04:35:19.336 --> 04:35:20.904
AYE FRIEDMAN AYE FLORA.
04:35:20.971 --> 04:35:23.940
FLORA AYE CHAU CHAU AYE EGGMAN.
04:35:24.007 --> 04:35:26.209
EGGMAN AYE GARCIA.
04:35:26.276 --> 04:35:27.844
GARCIA I LIMóN.
04:35:27.911 --> 04:35:29.012
LOW MOAN AYE MATHIS.
04:35:29.079 --> 04:35:30.780
MATHIS I MCCARTY.
04:35:30.847 --> 04:35:32.716
MCCARTY AYE MELENDEZ MELENDEZ
04:35:32.782 --> 04:35:34.851
AYE MURATSUCHI MURATSUCHI AYE
04:35:34.918 --> 04:35:35.518
STONE.
04:35:35.585 --> 04:35:39.923
STONE I ELEVEN ZERO BILL IS OUT.
04:35:39.990 --> 04:35:42.893
ELEVEN ZERO ITEM THIRTEEN EIGHTY
04:35:42.959 --> 04:35:43.493
EIGHT THIRTY NINE MULLIN I DO
04:35:43.560 --> 04:35:47.597
NEED A MOTION AND A SECOND.
04:35:47.664 --> 04:35:49.699
HELLO EGGMAN ARE SWITCHING THANK
04:35:49.766 --> 04:35:51.568
YOU.
04:35:51.635 --> 04:35:52.769
I AM THIRTEEN AB EIGHT THIRTY
04:35:52.836 --> 04:35:53.336
NINE MULLIN DO PAST REFERRED
04:35:53.403 --> 04:35:55.238
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE MEMBERS
04:35:55.305 --> 04:35:57.340
FRIEDMAN AYE FRIEDMAN AYE FLORA.
04:35:57.407 --> 04:36:01.378
FLORA I'D CHAU CHAU AYE EGGMAN.
04:36:01.444 --> 04:36:03.914
EGGMAN AYE GARCIA.
04:36:03.980 --> 04:36:05.649
GARCIA I LIMóN.
04:36:05.715 --> 04:36:08.585
THE LOAN I MATH MATHIS.
04:36:08.652 --> 04:36:10.787
MATHIS NOT VOTING MCCARTY.
04:36:10.854 --> 04:36:13.657
MCCARTY AYE MELENDEZ.
04:36:13.723 --> 04:36:15.659
LENDERS KNOW MURATSUCHI.
04:36:15.725 --> 04:36:16.526
MURATSUCHI AYE STONE.
04:36:16.593 --> 04:36:17.093
STONE [inaudible]
04:36:17.160 --> 04:36:20.630
I TEN ONE THEN WHEN THE
04:36:20.697 --> 04:36:21.731
BUILDINGS ARE NINE ONE NINE ONE
04:36:21.798 --> 04:36:22.999
BILLS UP.
04:36:23.066 --> 04:36:25.302
ITEM FIFTEEN EIGHTY NINE THIRTY
04:36:25.368 --> 04:36:25.869
SIX ROBERT RIVAS TWO PASSES
04:36:25.936 --> 04:36:26.503
AMANDA REFERRED APPROPRIATIONS
04:36:26.569 --> 04:36:29.205
COMMITTEE CURRENT -- IS FIVE TO
04:36:29.272 --> 04:36:32.208
ONE WITH THE CHAIR VOTING I WITH
04:36:32.275 --> 04:36:34.477
THE CONSENT.
04:36:34.544 --> 04:36:34.945
ABSENT MEMBER FLORA.
04:36:35.011 --> 04:36:36.379
NO.
04:36:36.446 --> 04:36:37.480
FLORA NO CHILD [inaudible]
04:36:37.547 --> 04:36:43.153
CHAU I MCCARTY.
04:36:43.219 --> 04:36:45.288
THIS IS AB.
04:36:45.355 --> 04:36:45.855
NINE THIRTY SIX MCCARTY AYE
04:36:45.922 --> 04:36:51.227
MELINDA'S.
04:36:51.294 --> 04:36:52.329
WHAT MADE?
04:36:52.395 --> 04:36:52.762
YOU.
04:36:52.829 --> 04:36:56.566
ARE IN THE SIXTEEN ITEM FIFTEEN
04:36:56.633 --> 04:36:58.535
A. B. [inaudible]
04:36:58.601 --> 04:37:00.370
NINE THIRTY SIX MELENDEZ NO
04:37:00.437 --> 04:37:00.670
[inaudible]
04:37:00.737 --> 04:37:04.474
MURATSUCHI MURATSUCHI I EIGHT
04:37:04.541 --> 04:37:05.108
THREE EIGHTY THREE THAT BILL IS
04:37:05.175 --> 04:37:10.513
OUT. TWENTY SIX ITEM SIXTEEN AB
04:37:10.580 --> 04:37:11.114
NINE SEVENTY FIVE CALDERON TO
04:37:11.181 --> 04:37:12.916
PASS REFERRED APPROPRIATIONS
04:37:12.983 --> 04:37:15.118
COMMITTEE CURRENT -- IS SIX TO
04:37:15.185 --> 04:37:16.820
ZERO WITH THE CHORE VOTING I AS
04:37:16.886 --> 04:37:18.188
A MEMBER CHAU.
04:37:18.254 --> 04:37:21.891
TROUT I MCCARTY.
04:37:21.958 --> 04:37:24.761
MCCARTY AYE MELENDEZ.
04:37:24.828 --> 04:37:25.562
MELENDEZ NOW MURATSUCHI.
04:37:25.628 --> 04:37:28.498
RESEARCH THE I NINE ONE THE BILL
04:37:28.565 --> 04:37:32.102
IS OUT. NINETY ONE I DON'T
04:37:32.168 --> 04:37:33.870
SEVENTEEN AB TEN FIFTY SEVEN BYE
04:37:33.937 --> 04:37:34.604
LE MONDE TO PASS AS AMENDED
04:37:34.671 --> 04:37:35.739
REFERRED APPROPRIATIONS
04:37:35.805 --> 04:37:37.807
COMMITTEE CURRENT VOTE. SEVENTY
04:37:37.874 --> 04:37:39.009
THREE WITH THE TRIBE VOTING I
04:37:39.075 --> 04:37:40.877
ABSENT MEMBER CHILD.
04:37:40.944 --> 04:37:43.046
SHALL I EIGHT THREE EIGHTY THREE
04:37:43.113 --> 04:37:44.647
THE PHYLLIS OUT.
04:37:44.714 --> 04:37:46.850
ITEM EIGHTEEN AB ELEVEN SIXTY
04:37:46.916 --> 04:37:47.751
TWO KALRA TO PASS AS AMENDED
04:37:47.817 --> 04:37:49.452
REFER TO JUDICIARY COMMITTEE CAR
04:37:49.519 --> 04:37:51.187
ABOUT TWO TO THREE WITH THE
04:37:51.254 --> 04:37:53.390
CHAIR VOTING I ABSENT MEMBERS
04:37:53.456 --> 04:37:54.991
CHAU.
04:37:55.058 --> 04:37:57.193
SHALL I EGGMAN.
04:37:57.260 --> 04:37:59.262
EGGMAN NOT VOTING GARCIA.
04:37:59.329 --> 04:38:01.531
GARCIA NOT VOTING LAMONT
04:38:01.598 --> 04:38:01.831
[inaudible]
04:38:01.898 --> 04:38:12.308
LIMON I THE MONA.
04:38:12.375 --> 04:38:13.176
MCCARTY.
04:38:13.243 --> 04:38:16.446
MCCARTY AYE MURATSUCHI.
04:38:16.513 --> 04:38:18.381
RED TO GI [inaudible] SIX THREE
04:38:18.448 --> 04:38:22.986
SET UP. SIX THREE SIX THREE THE
04:38:23.053 --> 04:38:25.088
BILL IS OUT.
04:38:25.155 --> 04:38:27.624
I DON'T NINETEEN A. B. ELEVEN
04:38:27.690 --> 04:38:28.324
NINETY FIVE O'DONNELL DO PASS AS
04:38:28.391 --> 04:38:29.793
AMENDED REFERRED APPROPRIATIONS
04:38:29.859 --> 04:38:31.561
COMMITTEE CURRENT GOAL IS FORTY
04:38:31.628 --> 04:38:33.763
ONE WITH THE CHAIR VOTING I
04:38:33.830 --> 04:38:36.399
ABSENT MEMBER FLORA.
04:38:36.466 --> 04:38:39.502
FLORA I'D CHAU [inaudible]
04:38:39.569 --> 04:38:41.137
I LIMóN.
04:38:41.204 --> 04:38:41.704
Là M<c.cyan> NO.</c>
04:38:41.771 --> 04:38:42.505
MCCARTY.
04:38:42.572 --> 04:38:44.674
MCCARTY NOT VOTING [inaudible]
04:38:44.741 --> 04:38:48.044
MELENDEZ.
04:38:48.111 --> 04:38:50.313
AND AS I MURATSUCHI.
04:38:50.380 --> 04:38:52.515
RIGHT TO CHIU NOT VOTING. SEVEN
04:38:52.582 --> 04:38:55.885
TWO SEVEN TWO THE BILL IS OUT.
04:38:55.952 --> 04:38:58.054
ITEM TWENTY THREE A. B. THIRTEEN
04:38:58.121 --> 04:38:59.589
TWENTY EIGHT HOLDEN I DO NEED
04:38:59.656 --> 04:39:03.960
MOTION A SECOND PLEASE.
04:39:04.027 --> 04:39:06.396
I DON'T KNOW.
04:39:06.463 --> 04:39:07.997
SOMEBODY I'LL JUST.
04:39:08.064 --> 04:39:10.100
ITEM TWENTY THREE A. B. THIRTEEN
04:39:10.166 --> 04:39:10.667
TWENTY EIGHT HOLDEN TO PASS
04:39:10.733 --> 04:39:12.202
REFERRED APPROPRIATIONS
04:39:12.268 --> 04:39:14.370
COMMITTEE MEMBERS FRIEDMAN HI
04:39:14.437 --> 04:39:15.872
FRIEDMAN I FLORA.
04:39:15.939 --> 04:39:17.807
FLORA NO CHAU.
04:39:17.874 --> 04:39:19.476
CHAU AYE EGGMAN.
04:39:19.542 --> 04:39:21.911
EGGMAN AYE GARCIA.
04:39:21.978 --> 04:39:24.047
GARCIA I LIMóN.
04:39:24.114 --> 04:39:25.348
LIMON AYE MATHIS [inaudible]
04:39:25.415 --> 04:39:32.088
MATHIS NO THE I. MELINDA'S.
04:39:32.155 --> 04:39:34.357
LENDERS NO.
04:39:34.424 --> 04:39:35.658
RIGHT TO CHOOSE.
04:39:35.725 --> 04:39:36.559
RED SURGERY AYE STONE.
04:39:36.626 --> 04:39:38.962
STONE AYE EIGHT THREE EIGHT
04:39:39.028 --> 04:39:40.864
THREE THAT BILL IS OUT.
04:39:40.930 --> 04:39:43.066
I DON'T TWENTY FIVE A. B.
04:39:43.133 --> 04:39:43.666
FOURTEEN EIGHTY EIGHT BY BURKE
04:39:43.733 --> 04:39:45.068
TO PASS AS AMENDED REFERRED
04:39:45.135 --> 04:39:46.836
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE.
04:39:46.903 --> 04:39:48.805
CURRENT VOTE.
04:39:48.872 --> 04:39:49.372
FIVE TO ZERO ABSENT MEMBERS
04:39:49.439 --> 04:39:50.840
CHILD.
04:39:50.907 --> 04:39:52.542
CHAU AYE EGGMAN.
04:39:52.609 --> 04:39:54.377
EGGMAN AYE GARCIA.
04:39:54.444 --> 04:39:56.946
GARCIA AYE LAMONT.
04:39:57.013 --> 04:39:58.681
LOW MOAN AYE MCCARTY.
04:39:58.748 --> 04:40:01.718
MCCARTY I MURATSUCHI MURATSUCHI
04:40:01.784 --> 04:40:13.229
I 11-3. TWENTY EIGHT CONSENT.
04:40:13.296 --> 04:40:18.835
AFTER SEVEN MINUTES.
04:40:18.902 --> 04:40:19.536
OKAY SO I CAN RUN.
04:40:19.602 --> 04:40:21.738
THEM WITH ITEM TWENTY THREE
04:40:21.804 --> 04:40:24.407
THERE ARE TWO DIFFERENT SHEETS
04:40:24.474 --> 04:40:30.280
THAT MIGHT THE CONFUSION. ONE OF
04:40:30.346 --> 04:40:34.350
THE COOLEST PART OF SEVEN OFF OF
04:40:34.417 --> 04:40:38.588
WEST EXAMPLE SATURDAY.
04:40:38.655 --> 04:40:40.156
WHICH IS THAT WHEN YOU TO
04:40:40.223 --> 04:40:41.391
DEVELOP.
04:40:41.457 --> 04:40:42.692
OKAY WHAT WOULD LET'S FINISH THE
04:40:42.759 --> 04:40:45.428
ONE WE'RE ON WHAT WE'RE WAITING
04:40:45.495 --> 04:40:47.397
ON THE WHEN WE RUN.
04:40:47.463 --> 04:40:47.997
HE WAS.
04:40:48.064 --> 04:40:49.432
YEAH WE'RE READY TO DO BURKE DO
04:40:49.499 --> 04:40:51.067
WE JUST FINISH THE OTHER.
04:40:51.134 --> 04:40:52.902
ONE OKAY YEAH.
04:40:52.969 --> 04:40:55.505
WE JUST SAID BURKE BURKE OUT OUT
04:40:55.572 --> 04:40:56.406
ELEVEN ZERO QUE QUE NOW WE'RE ON
04:40:56.472 --> 04:40:58.041
ITEM. TWENTY SEVEN EIGHTY
04:40:58.107 --> 04:40:58.608
SIXTEEN TWENTY EIGHT ROBERT
04:40:58.675 --> 04:40:59.409
RIVAS TO PASS REFER TO JUDICIARY
04:40:59.475 --> 04:41:01.010
COMMITTEE CURRENT BEAU IS FIVE
04:41:01.077 --> 04:41:03.079
TO ONE WITH THE CHAIR VOTING I
04:41:03.146 --> 04:41:05.215
HAVE SOME MEMBER FLORA.
04:41:05.281 --> 04:41:06.816
FLORA NO CHILD.
04:41:06.883 --> 04:41:09.586
CHAU AYE MCCARTY.
04:41:09.652 --> 04:41:12.755
MCCARTY AYE MELENDEZ.
04:41:12.822 --> 04:41:13.823
MELENDEZ NO MURATSUCHI.
04:41:13.890 --> 04:41:17.994
RED TO GI.
04:41:18.061 --> 04:41:21.231
EIGHT THREE AND IF THOSE OUT.
04:41:21.297 --> 04:41:22.966
YEAH THAT'S GOOD UNLESS YOU WANT
04:41:23.032 --> 04:41:23.600
TO GO BACK TO ITEM TWENTY THREE
04:41:23.666 --> 04:41:33.109
BUT FOURTEEN TO LEARN.
04:41:33.176 --> 04:41:41.517
THANK YOU. FOR EXAMPLE
04:41:41.584 --> 04:41:56.599
[inaudible]