WEBVTT
00:23:06.151 --> 00:23:07.819
ASSEMBLY JUDICIARY TODAY'S
00:23:07.886 --> 00:23:09.888
TUESDAY APRIL TWENTY THIRD WE DO
00:23:09.955 --> 00:23:11.523
NOT YET HAVE A QUORUM HOWEVER.
00:23:11.590 --> 00:23:13.125
WHICH WILL START AS A SUB
00:23:13.191 --> 00:23:14.392
COMMITTEE.
00:23:14.459 --> 00:23:15.694
WE DO HAVE A NUMBER OF AUTHORS
00:23:15.761 --> 00:23:19.531
PRESENCE AND WE WILL START WITH.
00:23:19.598 --> 00:23:20.132
I DON'T NUMBER THIRTEEN MISTER
00:23:20.198 --> 00:23:22.167
LOW.
00:23:22.234 --> 00:23:29.608
THIS IS AB.
00:23:29.674 --> 00:23:30.175
FIVE THIRTEEN FORTY TWO GOOD
00:23:30.242 --> 00:23:30.776
MORNING THANK YOU VERY MUCH
00:23:30.842 --> 00:23:32.344
MISTER CHAIR AND MEMBERS THIS IS
00:23:32.410 --> 00:23:34.312
ASSEMBLY BILL THIRTEEN FORTY TWO
00:23:34.379 --> 00:23:35.213
WITH RESPECT TO THE SALE OF
00:23:35.280 --> 00:23:36.414
NONPROFIT COLLEGES.
00:23:36.481 --> 00:23:39.718
AT THAT SIMPLY OF REQUIRES THAT
00:23:39.785 --> 00:23:42.420
WE HAVE THE TYPE OF OVERSIGHT OF
00:23:42.487 --> 00:23:44.623
FOR THE SALE OF NON PROFIT --
00:23:44.689 --> 00:23:46.024
I'M THE FOR PROFIT COLLEGES OF
00:23:46.091 --> 00:23:47.092
THIS ARE QUITE ATTORNEY GENERAL
00:23:47.159 --> 00:23:48.660
TO APPROVE WHATEVER A FOR PROFIT
00:23:48.727 --> 00:23:49.728
COLLEGE.
00:23:49.795 --> 00:23:52.430
SEEKS A TO BE SOLD AND WE LOOK
00:23:52.497 --> 00:23:53.632
FOR THE TYPE OF PROTECTIONS IN
00:23:53.698 --> 00:23:55.100
TRANSPARENCY FOR THE STUDENTS
00:23:55.167 --> 00:23:55.901
THAT MIGHT BE ASSOCIATED WITH
00:23:55.967 --> 00:23:56.735
THE IMPACT.
00:23:56.802 --> 00:24:00.038
OF THIS TYPE OF TRANSACTION WITH
00:24:00.105 --> 00:24:00.906
RESPECT ASK FOR AYE VOTE.
00:24:00.972 --> 00:24:04.209
THANK YOU AND YES THIS IS TO
00:24:04.276 --> 00:24:06.077
PASS OKAY PERFECT YOUR FIRST
00:24:06.144 --> 00:24:07.412
WITNESS PLACER HI I'M BOB
00:24:07.479 --> 00:24:09.181
SHERMAN I'M A SENIOR FELLOW AT
00:24:09.247 --> 00:24:10.949
THE CENTURY FOUNDATION.
00:24:11.016 --> 00:24:12.450
I'VE WORKED -- IN THE CLINTON
00:24:12.517 --> 00:24:13.685
ADMINISTRATION AND THE OBAMA
00:24:13.752 --> 00:24:16.488
ADMINISTRATION -- AND AND IT
00:24:16.555 --> 00:24:18.089
OTHER FEDERAL AND AT FEDERAL
00:24:18.156 --> 00:24:20.425
POSTS ON HIGHER EDUCATION.
00:24:20.492 --> 00:24:23.562
HAVE BEEN FOLLOWING THE ISSUE OF
00:24:23.628 --> 00:24:26.264
TORY FOR PROFIT COLLEGES -- FOR
00:24:26.331 --> 00:24:27.899
FOR ALMOST THIRTY YEARS.
00:24:27.966 --> 00:24:32.804
AND MANY OF THE WORST ABUSES
00:24:32.871 --> 00:24:36.141
THAT WE HAVE SEEN -- HAVE COME
00:24:36.208 --> 00:24:36.942
FROM.
00:24:37.008 --> 00:24:40.178
COLLEGES THAT HAD BEEN NONPROFIT
00:24:40.245 --> 00:24:42.380
HAD BUILT A POSITIVE REPUTATION
00:24:42.447 --> 00:24:44.149
AND THEN WERE PURCHASED BY A FOR
00:24:44.216 --> 00:24:45.317
PROFIT.
00:24:45.383 --> 00:24:49.254
COMPANY THAT USE THAT REPUTATION
00:24:49.321 --> 00:24:51.556
TO BRING IN STUDENTS BUT ENDED
00:24:51.623 --> 00:24:53.792
UP RUNNING THE RUNNING THE
00:24:53.859 --> 00:24:55.460
COMPANY INTO THE GROUND RUNNING
00:24:55.527 --> 00:24:56.628
THE COLLEGE INTO THE GROUND AND
00:24:56.695 --> 00:24:58.763
IN THAT ATTEMPT. TO PUMP UP THE
00:24:58.830 --> 00:25:00.131
STOCK PRICE.
00:25:00.198 --> 00:25:02.734
OR R. OR LARGE PROFITS SO IN THE
00:25:02.801 --> 00:25:05.937
CASE OF ASHFORD IT HAD BEEN A
00:25:06.004 --> 00:25:07.672
SMALL NONPROFIT RESIDENTIAL
00:25:07.739 --> 00:25:09.941
COLLEGE AND BECAME AN EIGHTY
00:25:10.008 --> 00:25:11.877
THOUSAND STUDENTS -- ONLINE
00:25:11.943 --> 00:25:13.912
COLLEGE THAT IS NOW BEING SUED
00:25:13.979 --> 00:25:14.479
BY THE CALIFORNIA ATTORNEY
00:25:14.546 --> 00:25:16.915
GENERAL -- IN THE CASE OF HEALED
00:25:16.982 --> 00:25:21.786
IN CALIFORNIA IT WAS A LONG TIME
00:25:21.853 --> 00:25:24.890
QUALITY -- NONPROFIT COLLEGE
00:25:24.956 --> 00:25:27.092
SURVEYING WORKING ADULTS WAS
00:25:27.158 --> 00:25:29.527
PURCHASED BY CORINTHIAN COLLEGES
00:25:29.594 --> 00:25:33.999
AND FAMOUSLY COLLAPSED --
00:25:34.065 --> 00:25:36.134
LEAVING MANY STUDENTS WHO HAD
00:25:36.201 --> 00:25:37.736
PORTENDING THOSE COLLEGES HIGH
00:25:37.802 --> 00:25:39.471
AND DRY LEAVING TAXPAYERS WITH
00:25:39.537 --> 00:25:41.439
THAT BILL SO THIS BILL WILL HELP
00:25:41.506 --> 00:25:42.440
TO ASSURE THAT WHEN THE WHEN
00:25:42.507 --> 00:25:44.743
COLLEGES GO FROM NONPROFIT TO
00:25:44.809 --> 00:25:46.077
FOR PROFIT THAT THOSE ASSETS ARE
00:25:46.144 --> 00:25:46.945
REATED.
00:25:47.012 --> 00:25:48.046
APPROPRIATELY THAT THERE AREN'T
00:25:48.113 --> 00:25:49.848
ANY PAY OFFS INVOLVED TO THE
00:25:49.915 --> 00:25:53.952
NONPROFIT OFFICIALS -- AND AND
00:25:54.019 --> 00:25:56.121
TO DO WHAT WE CAN ANY. TO HELP
00:25:56.187 --> 00:25:58.423
ENSURE THAT -- THAT THEN THEY
00:25:58.490 --> 00:26:03.061
OPERATE IN A NON PREDATORY WAY.
00:26:03.128 --> 00:26:06.498
THANK YOU ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT.
00:26:06.564 --> 00:26:08.900
RIGHT SEEING NONE IS THERE ANY
00:26:08.967 --> 00:26:16.241
OPPOSITE OF YES.
00:26:16.308 --> 00:26:17.842
HI ANGELA PERRY POLICY ANALYST
00:26:17.909 --> 00:26:19.077
WITH THE INSTITUTE FOR COLLEGE
00:26:19.144 --> 00:26:20.645
ACCESS AND SUCCESS IN SUPPORT OF
00:26:20.712 --> 00:26:21.179
THE BILL.
00:26:21.246 --> 00:26:22.681
THANK YOU.
00:26:22.747 --> 00:26:25.283
ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT.
00:26:25.350 --> 00:26:25.884
ALL RIGHT THING THEN IS THERE
00:26:25.951 --> 00:26:28.219
ANY OPPOSITION.
00:26:28.286 --> 00:26:29.955
I'D SAY NONE BRING BACK TO THE
00:26:30.021 --> 00:26:34.292
COMMITTEE QUESTIONS COMMENTS.
00:26:34.359 --> 00:26:35.760
MARKETING THEN MR THOUGH YOU MAY
00:26:35.827 --> 00:26:37.028
CLOSE THANK YOU VERY MUCH CHECK
00:26:37.095 --> 00:26:38.863
FAST BY ABOUT THANK YOU AND WE
00:26:38.930 --> 00:26:40.398
WILL TAKE IT UP BUT FORGET FOR
00:26:40.465 --> 00:26:42.634
WHICH HOPEFULLY SHOULD BE.
00:26:42.701 --> 00:26:44.569
IMMINENT ALRIGHT THANK YOU
00:26:44.636 --> 00:26:48.340
MISTER FRAZIER HEY.
00:26:48.406 --> 00:26:49.240
WE ARE.
00:26:49.307 --> 00:26:49.975
THAT MOVIE THE ITEM.
00:26:50.041 --> 00:26:54.279
NUMBER SEVEN WHICH IS AB.
00:26:54.346 --> 00:26:55.914
EIGHT THIRTEEN AND LET'S PAUSE
00:26:55.981 --> 00:26:57.482
FOR A MOMENT AND ESTABLISH A
00:26:57.549 --> 00:27:00.118
QUORUM.
00:27:00.185 --> 00:27:02.420
STONE HERE GALLAGHER.
00:27:02.487 --> 00:27:04.723
CHAO [inaudible]
00:27:04.789 --> 00:27:05.924
CHIU [inaudible]
00:27:05.991 --> 00:27:06.725
GONZALEZ [inaudible]
00:27:06.791 --> 00:27:07.792
HOLDEN [inaudible]
00:27:07.859 --> 00:27:11.229
KALRA [inaudible]
00:27:11.296 --> 00:27:12.931
KILEY MAIENSCHEIN [inaudible]
00:27:12.998 --> 00:27:14.466
OBERNOLTE [inaudible]
00:27:14.532 --> 00:27:16.034
NORRIS [inaudible]
00:27:16.101 --> 00:27:18.136
REYES.
00:27:18.203 --> 00:27:20.405
THANK YOU SO WE DO HAVE A QUORUM
00:27:20.472 --> 00:27:21.873
LET'S SEE IF WE COULD TAKE UP A
00:27:21.940 --> 00:27:24.709
MOTION ON ITEM NUMBER THIRTEEN
00:27:24.776 --> 00:27:26.811
A. B. THIRTEEN FORTY TWO LOW.
00:27:26.878 --> 00:27:28.913
THANK YOU THAT IS A MOTION TO
00:27:28.980 --> 00:27:30.849
PASS TO APPROPRIATIONS CALL THE
00:27:30.915 --> 00:27:33.485
MEMBERS PLEASE STONE BY STONE
00:27:33.551 --> 00:27:34.719
AYE GALLAGHER CHAU.
00:27:34.786 --> 00:27:36.621
CHAO I CHIU [inaudible]
00:27:36.688 --> 00:27:37.756
GONZALEZ.
00:27:37.822 --> 00:27:39.391
GONZALEZ I HOLDEN [inaudible]
00:27:39.457 --> 00:27:41.593
KALRA.
00:27:41.659 --> 00:27:43.128
KALRA AYE KILEY.
00:27:43.194 --> 00:27:45.030
MAIENSCHEIN.
00:27:45.096 --> 00:27:47.165
MAIENSCHEIN I OBERNOLTE.
00:27:47.232 --> 00:27:49.034
OBERNOLTE NO PETRIE-NORRIS.
00:27:49.100 --> 00:27:50.368
PETRIE-NORRIS ADDRESS.
00:27:50.435 --> 00:27:51.970
REYES AYE.
00:27:52.037 --> 00:27:53.938
THANK YOU AND I WILL ALSO
00:27:54.005 --> 00:27:56.741
ANNOUNCE THAT ITEM NUMBER ONE AB
00:27:56.808 --> 00:27:57.375
ONE NINETY NINE HAS BEEN PULLED
00:27:57.442 --> 00:27:59.411
FROM THE AGENDA SO A. B. ITEM
00:27:59.477 --> 00:28:01.813
NUMBER THIRTEEN AB.
00:28:01.880 --> 00:28:03.648
THIRTEEN FORTY TWO IS OUT THANK
00:28:03.715 --> 00:28:04.215
YOU.
00:28:04.282 --> 00:28:06.518
MISTER FRAZIER AB EIGHT THIRTEEN
00:28:06.584 --> 00:28:09.154
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR IN THE
00:28:09.220 --> 00:28:10.422
MORNING MEMBERS.
00:28:10.488 --> 00:28:11.089
FIRST I WOULD LIKE TO ACCEPT THE
00:28:11.156 --> 00:28:11.856
COULD A MEMBERS RECOMMENDED BY
00:28:11.923 --> 00:28:13.324
THE COMMITTEE AND THANK YOU VERY
00:28:13.391 --> 00:28:14.793
MUCH FOR WORKING WITH US ON
00:28:14.859 --> 00:28:15.794
THANK YOU ON THOSE.
00:28:15.860 --> 00:28:18.129
AB EIGHT THIRTEEN PROPOSES A
00:28:18.196 --> 00:28:20.165
ALTERNATIVE APPEALS PROCEDURE
00:28:20.231 --> 00:28:21.099
THAT WILL PLACE DISPUTE
00:28:21.166 --> 00:28:23.501
RESOLUTION RESOURCES.
00:28:23.568 --> 00:28:25.336
INSIDE THE REGIONAL CENTER.
00:28:25.403 --> 00:28:27.238
IT WILL OFFER EXHAUSTED PARENTS
00:28:27.305 --> 00:28:29.541
A MORE ACCESSIBLE RESOURCE WHEN
00:28:29.607 --> 00:28:31.443
DENIED SERVICES.
00:28:31.509 --> 00:28:32.710
WHAT PEOPLE DON'T REALIZE THAT
00:28:32.777 --> 00:28:35.647
OVER THE DECADES OF THE REGIONAL
00:28:35.713 --> 00:28:36.915
CENTER HAS BEEN IN SERVICE?
00:28:36.981 --> 00:28:39.751
THAT SINCE.
00:28:39.818 --> 00:28:40.351
NINETEEN SEVENTY SEVEN THEY'RE
00:28:40.418 --> 00:28:42.153
NOT EVEN NOW THAT NOW THESE ARE
00:28:42.220 --> 00:28:44.789
NOT EVEN SHOWING WHAT --
00:28:44.856 --> 00:28:46.491
SERVICES ARE EVEN OFFERED.
00:28:46.558 --> 00:28:47.559
WE HAD THE BIGGER REGIONAL
00:28:47.625 --> 00:28:49.160
SERVICE THEY'RE ACTUALLY PUT IT
00:28:49.227 --> 00:28:51.729
ON THEIR WEBSITE WHAT SERVICES
00:28:51.796 --> 00:28:54.199
THAT PARENTS MAY QUALIFY FOR
00:28:54.265 --> 00:28:56.768
THEIR CHILD -- AS THE CHAIR OF
00:28:56.835 --> 00:28:57.569
THE SELECT COMMITTEE ON
00:28:57.635 --> 00:28:58.937
INTELLECTUAL AND DEVELOPMENTAL
00:28:59.003 --> 00:28:59.838
DISABILITIES.
00:28:59.904 --> 00:29:01.840
I'VE HEARD FROM FAMILIES AROUND
00:29:01.906 --> 00:29:03.174
THE STATE AT OUR HEARINGS.
00:29:03.241 --> 00:29:04.476
TIME AND TIME AGAIN I HEAR FROM
00:29:04.542 --> 00:29:05.643
PARENTS EXPRESSING THEIR
00:29:05.710 --> 00:29:07.445
FRUSTRATION ABOUT.
00:29:07.512 --> 00:29:09.180
THE BROKEN SYSTEM. FOR THOSE
00:29:09.247 --> 00:29:11.282
WITH ADD WHO COME FROM SINGLE
00:29:11.349 --> 00:29:12.584
PARENT HOUSEHOLDS WHICH IS.
00:29:12.650 --> 00:29:14.519
A VERY PREVALENT THE MORTALITY
00:29:14.586 --> 00:29:16.221
RATE A MARRIAGES HE IS
00:29:16.287 --> 00:29:18.690
ABSOLUTELY DEVASTATING A WHEN
00:29:18.756 --> 00:29:21.593
YOU HAVE AN ID DE CHILD -- ON%
00:29:21.659 --> 00:29:23.495
SINGLE PARENT HOUSEHOLDS OR LOW
00:29:23.561 --> 00:29:25.296
INCOME FAMILIES APPEALS ARE
00:29:25.363 --> 00:29:27.966
VIRTUALLY IMPOSSIBLE.
00:29:28.032 --> 00:29:29.000
IF A PARENT DOESN'T HAVE A
00:29:29.067 --> 00:29:30.835
FLEXIBLE WORK SCHEDULE OR IF
00:29:30.902 --> 00:29:32.437
THEY HAVE A LANGUAGE BARRIER OR
00:29:32.504 --> 00:29:34.272
IF IRAQ -- LACK RELIABLE
00:29:34.339 --> 00:29:36.841
TRANSPORTATION THEY HAVE
00:29:36.908 --> 00:29:38.543
ABSOLUTELY NO CHANCE.
00:29:38.610 --> 00:29:40.378
AB THIRTEEN WILL GIVE EVERY
00:29:40.445 --> 00:29:41.579
CLIENT WITH I. DG A FIGHTING
00:29:41.646 --> 00:29:43.448
CHANCE TO GET THE SERVICES THEY
00:29:43.515 --> 00:29:44.616
NEED.
00:29:44.682 --> 00:29:47.318
WE HAD A WITNESS TODAY AND OUT.
00:29:47.385 --> 00:29:49.387
I APOLOGIZE SHE CAME DOWN WITH
00:29:49.454 --> 00:29:50.922
FOOD POISONING LAST NIGHT.
00:29:50.989 --> 00:29:53.992
AND SO -- I'M HERE BY MYSELF AND
00:29:54.058 --> 00:29:56.027
HOPEFULLY THERE'S THANK YOU WE
00:29:56.094 --> 00:30:01.266
DO HAVE A MOTION AND A SECOND.
00:30:01.332 --> 00:30:04.135
YOUR CARING IT VERY FINE BY
00:30:04.202 --> 00:30:05.136
YOURSELF RECOGNITION.
00:30:05.203 --> 00:30:07.272
SELF THANK YOU WOULD ANYONE ELSE
00:30:07.338 --> 00:30:19.918
LIKE TO SPEAK AND SUPPORTS
00:30:19.984 --> 00:30:20.218
[inaudible]
00:30:20.285 --> 00:30:23.521
GOOD MORNING.
00:30:23.588 --> 00:30:25.690
I'M DELFIN CATHCART REPRESENTING
00:30:25.757 --> 00:30:27.358
EMILY ALL OF CALIFORNIA.
00:30:27.425 --> 00:30:29.127
WE ARE FIVE FOR FIVE AFFILIATES
00:30:29.194 --> 00:30:31.029
IN CALIFORNIA'S SAN JOAQUIN
00:30:31.095 --> 00:30:32.597
COUNTY FORCES THE NEED IS.
00:30:32.664 --> 00:30:34.232
SAN DIEGO COUNTY JUSTICE
00:30:34.299 --> 00:30:36.267
OVERCOMING BOUNDARIES SACRAMENTO
00:30:36.334 --> 00:30:39.671
COUNTY -- CAPITAL REGION OCT
00:30:39.737 --> 00:30:41.940
ORGANISE ISAAC PROJECT CINEMA
00:30:42.006 --> 00:30:43.374
COUNTY.
00:30:43.441 --> 00:30:44.976
BAY AREA ORGANIZING PROJECT.
00:30:45.043 --> 00:30:47.512
ALAMEDA COUNTY GENESIS WE
00:30:47.579 --> 00:30:50.748
SUPPORT AB THIRTEEN AB EIGHT
00:30:50.815 --> 00:30:51.349
THIRTEEN THANK YOU VERY MUCH
00:30:51.416 --> 00:30:53.851
THANK YOU.
00:30:53.918 --> 00:30:56.788
NO ONE ELSE IN SUPPORT.
00:30:56.854 --> 00:30:58.656
ALRIGHT SING NUNS THAT -- I'M
00:30:58.723 --> 00:31:01.492
SORRY.
00:31:01.559 --> 00:31:02.060
THANK YOU.
00:31:02.126 --> 00:31:03.595
MY NAME IS MOHAMMED RASHID I'M
00:31:03.661 --> 00:31:04.562
FROM VALLEY MOUNTAIN REGIONAL
00:31:04.629 --> 00:31:09.033
CENTER AND WE SUPPORT THE BILL.
00:31:09.100 --> 00:31:09.634
THANK YOU THANK YOU FOR COMING
00:31:09.701 --> 00:31:10.635
OUT THIS MORNING.
00:31:10.702 --> 00:31:13.037
WHAT ELSE IN SUPPORT?
00:31:13.104 --> 00:31:17.709
CNN IS THEIR OPPOSITION.
00:31:17.775 --> 00:31:19.244
NOT OPPOSITION BUT DANIEL
00:31:19.310 --> 00:31:20.712
SAVANNAH ASSOCIATION OF REGIONAL
00:31:20.778 --> 00:31:22.213
CENTER AGENCIES WE LOOK FOR TO
00:31:22.280 --> 00:31:22.914
CONTINUING TO WORK WITH THE
00:31:22.981 --> 00:31:24.616
AUTHOR ON WAYS TO ENSURE THAT
00:31:24.682 --> 00:31:25.250
PEOPLE CAN ACCESS THE SERVICES
00:31:25.316 --> 00:31:26.150
THEY NEED.
00:31:26.217 --> 00:31:27.852
WITH AN EXISTING MECHANISMS AND
00:31:27.919 --> 00:31:29.187
WELL AS WELL AS LOOKING FOR
00:31:29.254 --> 00:31:30.521
OPPORTUNITIES.
00:31:30.588 --> 00:31:32.223
TO REFINE AND IMPROVE THOSE WERE
00:31:32.290 --> 00:31:33.057
NEEDED THANK YOU.
00:31:33.124 --> 00:31:34.993
THANK YOU ANYONE ELSE IN
00:31:35.059 --> 00:31:37.295
OPPOSITION OR OTHERWISE.
00:31:37.362 --> 00:31:39.330
ALRIGHT SIGNIN QUESTIONS
00:31:39.397 --> 00:31:42.767
COMMENTS FROM THE COMMITTEE.
00:31:42.834 --> 00:31:43.801
ALL RIGHT.
00:31:43.868 --> 00:31:45.036
SING NOT MISTER FRAZIER MAKE
00:31:45.103 --> 00:31:46.971
CLOTHES THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR
00:31:47.038 --> 00:31:48.172
JUST RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE
00:31:48.239 --> 00:31:49.707
VOTE THANK YOU AND GIVE OUR BEST
00:31:49.774 --> 00:31:53.645
YOUR WITNESS SORRY THAT THE I'M
00:31:53.711 --> 00:31:53.845
SORRY.
00:31:53.911 --> 00:31:54.545
CAME DOWN.
00:31:54.612 --> 00:31:55.413
THANK YOU WE DO HAVE A MOTION
00:31:55.480 --> 00:31:56.047
AND A SECOND MOTIONS TO PASS TO
00:31:56.114 --> 00:31:57.415
AS AMENDED TO APPROPRIATIONS
00:31:57.482 --> 00:31:59.584
CALL THE ROLL PLEASE STONE BY
00:31:59.651 --> 00:32:01.119
STONE AYE GALLAGHER CHOW.
00:32:01.185 --> 00:32:02.453
CHOW I CHIU.
00:32:02.520 --> 00:32:03.755
GONZALEZ.
00:32:03.821 --> 00:32:06.924
CONSULT AYE HOLDEN KALRA.
00:32:06.991 --> 00:32:10.595
KALRA AYE KILEY MAIENSCHEIN.
00:32:10.662 --> 00:32:12.697
MAIENSCHEIN I OBERNOLTE.
00:32:12.764 --> 00:32:14.299
OBERNOLTE I PETRIE-NORRIS
00:32:14.365 --> 00:32:17.568
PETRIE-NORRIS I RE AS REYES AYE.
00:32:17.635 --> 00:32:19.637
THAT BILLS OUT THANK YOU MISTER
00:32:19.704 --> 00:32:21.005
CHAIRMAN YOU VERY MUCH.
00:32:21.072 --> 00:32:23.341
ALL RIGHT MISTER LEVINE YOU HAVE
00:32:23.408 --> 00:32:26.144
ITEM NUMBER ELEVEN A. B.
00:32:26.210 --> 00:32:26.778
THIRTEEN TWENTY FOUR AND AS HE
00:32:26.844 --> 00:32:28.046
COMES UP I'LL TAKE A MOTION ON
00:32:28.112 --> 00:32:29.314
THE CONSENT AGENDA UNLESS
00:32:29.380 --> 00:32:31.382
SOMEONE WOULD LIKE TO REMOVE AN
00:32:31.449 --> 00:32:32.550
ITEM FROM THE SENATE.
00:32:32.617 --> 00:32:36.387
WE DO HAVE A MOTION AND A SECOND.
00:32:36.454 --> 00:32:37.955
CALL THE ROLL PLEASE STONE.
00:32:38.022 --> 00:32:40.491
BY STONE AYE GALLAGHER CHOW.
00:32:40.558 --> 00:32:42.660
CHOW I CHIU GONZALEZ.
00:32:42.727 --> 00:32:45.396
CONSULT AYE HOLDEN KALRA.
00:32:45.463 --> 00:32:49.367
KALRA AYE KILEY MAIENSCHEIN.
00:32:49.434 --> 00:32:52.303
HI MAIENSCHEIN I OBERNOLTE
00:32:52.370 --> 00:32:53.571
OBERNOLTE I'D PETRIE-NORRIS
00:32:53.638 --> 00:32:55.373
PETRIE-NORRIS AYE RADIUS.
00:32:55.440 --> 00:32:55.907
REYES AYE.
00:32:55.973 --> 00:32:58.042
THOSE BILLS ARE OUT THAT IS AB
00:32:58.109 --> 00:33:00.111
FORTY SIX CARILLO AB TWO EIGHTY
00:33:00.178 --> 00:33:01.512
NINE FONG A BEFORE FORTY SIX
00:33:01.579 --> 00:33:04.649
CHOI AB EIGHT NINETY TWO HOLDEN
00:33:04.716 --> 00:33:05.917
AB.
00:33:05.983 --> 00:33:07.452
TEN SIXTY EIGHT COOLEY AB ELEVEN
00:33:07.518 --> 00:33:09.420
SIXTEEN GRAYSON A LATE AB ELEVEN
00:33:09.487 --> 00:33:11.222
SEVENTEEN GRAYSON AB ELEVEN
00:33:11.289 --> 00:33:15.059
THIRTY TO GABRIEL AND AB
00:33:15.126 --> 00:33:15.727
SEVENTEEN THIRTY SEVEN OBERNOLTE.
00:33:15.793 --> 00:33:16.594
ALL RIGHT.
00:33:16.661 --> 00:33:17.362
THANKS YOUR PATIENCE MISTER
00:33:17.428 --> 00:33:18.730
LEVINE THANK YOU SO MUCH MR
00:33:18.796 --> 00:33:19.997
CHAIRMAN MEMBERS I WOULD LIKE TO
00:33:20.064 --> 00:33:21.432
BEGIN BY ACCEPTING THE COMMITTEE
00:33:21.499 --> 00:33:22.834
SUGGESTED AMENDMENTS SAYS
00:33:22.900 --> 00:33:24.235
AUTHORED AMENDMENTS AND THANK
00:33:24.302 --> 00:33:25.503
THE COMMITTEE FOR THEIR WORK ON
00:33:25.570 --> 00:33:26.671
THIS IMPORTANT ISSUE.
00:33:26.738 --> 00:33:28.606
AB THIRTEEN TWENTY FOUR REQUIRES
00:33:28.673 --> 00:33:29.640
THE CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF
00:33:29.707 --> 00:33:32.176
SOCIAL SERVICES TO CONTRACT WITH
00:33:32.243 --> 00:33:33.711
NONPROFIT LEGAL SERVICES
00:33:33.778 --> 00:33:35.413
ORGANIZATIONS TO PROVIDE
00:33:35.480 --> 00:33:37.115
IMMIGRANT LEGAL SERVICES TO
00:33:37.181 --> 00:33:39.384
UNDOCUMENTED MINORS AND NON
00:33:39.450 --> 00:33:40.752
MINERS CURRENTLY IN FOSTER CARE.
00:33:40.818 --> 00:33:42.453
WHAT CALIFORNIA ALREADY REQUIRES
00:33:42.520 --> 00:33:44.155
THE UNACCOMPANIED UNDOCUMENTED
00:33:44.222 --> 00:33:45.256
MINORS WHO ARE TRANSFERRED TO
00:33:45.323 --> 00:33:46.758
THE CARE AND CUSTODY OF THE
00:33:46.824 --> 00:33:48.559
OFFICE OF REFUGEE RESETTLEMENT
00:33:48.626 --> 00:33:50.228
BE PROVIDED WITH LEGAL SERVICES?
00:33:50.294 --> 00:33:51.996
THIS PROTECTION DOES NOT EXTEND
00:33:52.063 --> 00:33:53.598
TO UNDOCUMENTED MINORS OR NON
00:33:53.664 --> 00:33:55.566
MINORS IN CALIFORNIA'S FOSTER
00:33:55.633 --> 00:33:57.935
CARE SYSTEM AB THIRTEEN TWENTY
00:33:58.002 --> 00:33:58.436
FOUR WILL ENSURE THAT
00:33:58.503 --> 00:34:00.104
UNDOCUMENTED DEPENDENCE IN
00:34:00.171 --> 00:34:02.140
CALIFORNIA'S FOSTER CARE SYSTEM
00:34:02.206 --> 00:34:03.374
ARE PROVIDED WITH ESSENTIAL
00:34:03.441 --> 00:34:04.809
IMMIGRATION LEGAL SERVICES
00:34:04.876 --> 00:34:06.477
NECESSARY. TO SEEK LAWFUL
00:34:06.544 --> 00:34:08.679
RESIDENCY IN THE UNITED STATES
00:34:08.746 --> 00:34:10.114
THERE IS NO OPPOSITION TO THIS
00:34:10.181 --> 00:34:12.250
BILL I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR
00:34:12.316 --> 00:34:13.317
AYE VOTE.
00:34:13.384 --> 00:34:14.952
WITH ME TODAY IS SUSAN ABRAMS
00:34:15.019 --> 00:34:16.754
THE POLICY DIRECTOR. FOR THE
00:34:16.821 --> 00:34:18.089
CHILDREN'S LAWCENTER OF
00:34:18.156 --> 00:34:19.891
CALIFORNIA.
00:34:19.957 --> 00:34:20.525
THANK YOU FIRST WITH US PLEASE
00:34:20.591 --> 00:34:21.893
THE MORNING CHAIR AN HONORABLE
00:34:21.959 --> 00:34:23.628
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE.
00:34:23.694 --> 00:34:24.796
HI MY NAME IS SUSAN ABRAMS AND
00:34:24.862 --> 00:34:25.329
I'M WITH THE CHILDREN'S
00:34:25.396 --> 00:34:26.697
LAWCENTER OF CALIFORNIA WE
00:34:26.764 --> 00:34:28.666
REPRESENT THIRTY THREE THOUSAND
00:34:28.733 --> 00:34:29.634
CHILDREN IN THE FOSTER CARE
00:34:29.700 --> 00:34:32.703
SYSTEM IN SACRAMENTO PLASTER.
00:34:32.770 --> 00:34:34.505
IN LOS ANGELES COUNTY -- I WANT
00:34:34.572 --> 00:34:35.840
TO START BY THINKING ASSEMBLY
00:34:35.907 --> 00:34:38.042
MEMBER LEVINE. FOR AUTHORING
00:34:38.109 --> 00:34:39.777
THIS IMPORTANT LEGISLATION WHICH
00:34:39.844 --> 00:34:40.778
WILL SERVE TO PROTECT
00:34:40.845 --> 00:34:42.480
UNDOCUMENTED CHILDREN IN FOSTER
00:34:42.547 --> 00:34:45.149
CARE BY PROVIDING ACCESS TO
00:34:45.216 --> 00:34:46.551
LEGAL IMMIGRATION SERVICES.
00:34:46.617 --> 00:34:48.252
MOST UNDOCUMENTED CHILDREN IN
00:34:48.319 --> 00:34:49.887
FOSTER CARE QUALIFY FOR
00:34:49.954 --> 00:34:51.255
IMMIGRATION RELIEF THROUGH
00:34:51.322 --> 00:34:52.623
SPECIAL IMMIGRANT JUVENILE
00:34:52.690 --> 00:34:55.126
STATUS ALSO REFER TO ASSIDUOUS.
00:34:55.193 --> 00:34:56.828
THIS WAS ENACTED BY THE FEDERAL
00:34:56.894 --> 00:34:58.696
GOVERNMENT IN NINETEEN NINETY
00:34:58.763 --> 00:35:00.298
TWO ALLOW ABUSED ABANDONED AND
00:35:00.364 --> 00:35:02.366
NEGLECTED UNDOCUMENTED CHILDREN
00:35:02.433 --> 00:35:04.202
TO ATTAIN LAWFUL PERMANENT
00:35:04.268 --> 00:35:04.802
RESIDENCY.
00:35:04.869 --> 00:35:06.771
AND ENTERED PROVIDE GREATER
00:35:06.838 --> 00:35:08.306
STABILITY FOR THESE YOUNG PEOPLE
00:35:08.372 --> 00:35:09.907
HOWEVER IN TODAY'S POLITICAL
00:35:09.974 --> 00:35:12.276
CLIMATE THIS RELIEF IS DIFFICULT.
00:35:12.343 --> 00:35:14.145
TO OBTAIN WITHOUT LEGAL
00:35:14.212 --> 00:35:18.883
ASSISTANCE AND THERE'S NO
00:35:18.950 --> 00:35:19.951
MECHANISM RIGHT NOW TO ENSURE
00:35:20.017 --> 00:35:21.185
THAT CHILDREN IN FOSTER CARE
00:35:21.252 --> 00:35:22.153
RECEIVE THIS LEGAL RESEARCH.
00:35:22.220 --> 00:35:23.020
ASSISTANTS AND AS A RESULT SOME
00:35:23.087 --> 00:35:24.255
CHILDREN NEVER RECEIVED THE
00:35:24.322 --> 00:35:24.789
RELIEF TO WHICH THEY ARE
00:35:24.856 --> 00:35:25.590
ENTITLED.
00:35:25.656 --> 00:35:27.425
UNDOCUMENTED CHILDREN WHO EXIT
00:35:27.492 --> 00:35:28.993
FOSTER CARE WITHOUT APPLYING FOR
00:35:29.060 --> 00:35:31.195
SIEGES OR ANOTHER FORM OF RELIEF
00:35:31.262 --> 00:35:33.130
WILL BE UNABLE TO WORK AND
00:35:33.197 --> 00:35:34.365
TRANSITION TO SUCCESSFUL
00:35:34.432 --> 00:35:36.133
ADULTHOOD WE ARE SETTING THESE
00:35:36.200 --> 00:35:37.635
YOUTH UP FOR FAILURE.
00:35:37.702 --> 00:35:39.103
AB THIRTEEN TWENTY FOUR WILL
00:35:39.170 --> 00:35:40.271
ADDRESS THISSIGNIFICANT ISSUE
00:35:40.338 --> 00:35:41.639
IN TWO WAYS.
00:35:41.706 --> 00:35:43.641
FIRST IT WILL REQUIRE NOTICE TO
00:35:43.708 --> 00:35:45.009
MINORS COUNCIL.
00:35:45.076 --> 00:35:46.677
OF ANY IMMIGRATION ISSUES SO WE
00:35:46.744 --> 00:35:48.813
CAN WORK TO ENSURE OUR CLIENTS
00:35:48.880 --> 00:35:50.181
GET THE SUPPORT THEY NEED.
00:35:50.248 --> 00:35:51.449
AND SECOND IT WILL CREATE A
00:35:51.516 --> 00:35:52.717
FUNDING SOURCE WITHIN THE
00:35:52.783 --> 00:35:54.151
CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL
00:35:54.218 --> 00:35:56.120
SERVICES TO CONTRACT WITH
00:35:56.187 --> 00:35:57.188
NONPROFIT LEGAL SERVICE
00:35:57.255 --> 00:35:58.756
ORGANIZATIONS TO PROVIDE
00:35:58.823 --> 00:36:00.491
IMMIGRATION REPRESENTATION WE
00:36:00.558 --> 00:36:01.759
URGE YOUR SUPPORT OF THIS
00:36:01.826 --> 00:36:03.761
CRITICAL LEGISLATION THANK YOU.
00:36:03.828 --> 00:36:05.096
THANK YOU.
00:36:05.162 --> 00:36:05.696
RAIN OR ELSE LIKE TO SPEAK IN
00:36:05.763 --> 00:36:13.638
SUPPORT.
00:36:13.704 --> 00:36:14.639
REBEKAH GONZALEZ NATIONAL
00:36:14.705 --> 00:36:16.307
ASSOCIATION OF SOCIAL WORKERS
00:36:16.374 --> 00:36:17.375
CALIFORNIA CHAPTER IN SUPPORT
00:36:17.441 --> 00:36:19.710
THANK YOU.
00:36:19.777 --> 00:36:20.878
GOOD MORNING SEAN CHILDREN WITH
00:36:20.945 --> 00:36:21.679
THE ALLIANCE FOR CHILDREN'S
00:36:21.746 --> 00:36:23.915
RIGHTS FOR IN SUPPORT THANK YOU
00:36:23.981 --> 00:36:26.050
THANK YOU ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT.
00:36:26.117 --> 00:36:26.551
SEEING NONE IS THERE ANY
00:36:26.617 --> 00:36:28.619
OPPOSITION.
00:36:28.686 --> 00:36:29.854
I THINK NONE OF BRING BACK TO
00:36:29.921 --> 00:36:34.492
THE COMMITTEE QUESTIONS COMMENTS.
00:36:34.559 --> 00:36:35.960
SINGER MISCELLANY MAY CLOSE.
00:36:36.027 --> 00:36:37.094
THANK YOU VERY MUCH MR CHAIRMAN
00:36:37.161 --> 00:36:38.863
MEMBERS THIS IS -- APRIL IS
00:36:38.930 --> 00:36:40.464
CHILD ABUSE AWARENESS MONTH AND
00:36:40.531 --> 00:36:41.966
THIS IS A SMALL WAY THAT WE CAN
00:36:42.033 --> 00:36:43.968
HELP PROTECT CHILDREN WHO -- ARE
00:36:44.035 --> 00:36:45.069
VICTIMS OF ABUSE THAT ARE IN THE
00:36:45.136 --> 00:36:46.837
CARE IN CALIFORNIA AND THAT WE
00:36:46.904 --> 00:36:48.072
CAN PROTECT THANK YOU.
00:36:48.139 --> 00:36:48.873
THANK YOU.
00:36:48.940 --> 00:36:50.341
SO I STILL NEED A MOTION MOTIONS
00:36:50.408 --> 00:36:51.842
TO PASS AS AMENDED TO
00:36:51.909 --> 00:36:53.711
APPROPRIATIONS.
00:36:53.778 --> 00:36:55.746
THANK YOU WE HAVE A MOTION AND A
00:36:55.813 --> 00:36:56.981
SECOND CALL THE ROLL PLEASE
00:36:57.048 --> 00:36:59.584
STONE BY STONE AYE GALLAGHER
00:36:59.650 --> 00:36:59.784
CHOW.
00:36:59.850 --> 00:37:02.553
CHOW I CHIU GONZALEZ.
00:37:02.620 --> 00:37:05.423
GONZALEZ I HOLDEN KALRA.
00:37:05.489 --> 00:37:08.426
COVER AYE KILEY MAIENSCHEIN.
00:37:08.492 --> 00:37:10.628
MAIENSCHEIN I OBERNOLTE
00:37:10.695 --> 00:37:12.496
OBERNOLTE NO PETRIE-NORRIS.
00:37:12.563 --> 00:37:14.665
PETRIE-NORRIS AYE RADIUS.
00:37:14.732 --> 00:37:16.968
REYES AYE.
00:37:17.034 --> 00:37:18.936
THE BILL IS OUT THANK YOU MISTER
00:37:19.003 --> 00:37:20.304
NUMBERS THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:37:20.371 --> 00:37:22.039
MS COME UNDER DUFF THIS TAKES US
00:37:22.106 --> 00:37:33.284
TO ITEM NUMBER TWO A. B..
00:37:33.351 --> 00:37:34.485
TWO FORTY TWO THANK YOU WE DO A
00:37:34.552 --> 00:37:36.454
MOTION IS THEIR SECOND.
00:37:36.520 --> 00:37:39.557
AND THE SECOND THANK YOU.
00:37:39.624 --> 00:37:40.758
THANK YOU GOOD MORNING.
00:37:40.825 --> 00:37:44.962
MISTER CHAIR AND MEMBER.
00:37:45.029 --> 00:37:47.765
I AM HERE PRESENTING ASSEMBLY
00:37:47.832 --> 00:37:49.200
BILL TWO FOUR TWO WHICH WILL
00:37:49.266 --> 00:37:51.002
REQUIRE ATTORNEYS AND JUDGES TO
00:37:51.068 --> 00:37:52.870
PARTY PARTAKE IN CONTINUAL
00:37:52.937 --> 00:37:54.438
EDUCATION ON IMPLICIT BIAS.
00:37:54.505 --> 00:37:56.040
EVERY THREE YEARS AND COURT
00:37:56.107 --> 00:37:59.577
PERSONNEL EVERY TWO YEARS.
00:37:59.644 --> 00:38:01.512
THE BIAS IS THE UNCONSCIOUS AND
00:38:01.579 --> 00:38:03.214
UNINTENTIONAL MENTAL SHORT CUT
00:38:03.280 --> 00:38:05.616
THAT HUMAN BEINGS CAN DEVELOP
00:38:05.683 --> 00:38:07.151
AND IT AFFECTS US ALL.
00:38:07.218 --> 00:38:09.120
IT IS OFTEN SUBTLE ASSOCIATIONS
00:38:09.186 --> 00:38:11.055
WE MAKE BETWEEN GROUPS OF PEOPLE
00:38:11.122 --> 00:38:12.456
AND STEREO TYPES ABOUT THOSE
00:38:12.523 --> 00:38:13.758
GROUPS.
00:38:13.824 --> 00:38:15.726
WE KNOW THAT EXPLICIT BIAS
00:38:15.793 --> 00:38:18.729
PERSISTS LIKE RACISM SEXISM AND
00:38:18.796 --> 00:38:20.631
OTHER FORMS OF BIGOTRY AND AS A
00:38:20.698 --> 00:38:22.366
RESULT CLEAR ANTI DISCRIMINATION
00:38:22.433 --> 00:38:24.001
LAWS ARE IN PLACE TO HELP CHECK
00:38:24.068 --> 00:38:25.002
THOSE.
00:38:25.069 --> 00:38:26.937
MOST OF US WOULD LIKE TO BE FREE
00:38:27.004 --> 00:38:28.606
OF BIASES ATTITUDES AND
00:38:28.673 --> 00:38:31.075
STEREOTYPES THAT LEAD US TO
00:38:31.142 --> 00:38:31.976
JUDGE PEOPLE BASED ON THE SOCIAL
00:38:32.043 --> 00:38:34.311
CATEGORIES THEY BELONG TO SUCH
00:38:34.378 --> 00:38:36.580
AS RACE OR GENDER OR SEXUAL
00:38:36.647 --> 00:38:37.982
ORIENTATION.
00:38:38.049 --> 00:38:39.583
HOWEVER IT IS IMPORTANT THAT WE
00:38:39.650 --> 00:38:41.218
COME TO TERMS WITH THE FACT THAT
00:38:41.285 --> 00:38:42.787
EVERYONE HAS THEIR OWN
00:38:42.853 --> 00:38:44.755
UNCONSCIOUS AN IMPLICIT BIAS
00:38:44.822 --> 00:38:47.324
THESE AND THOSE ARE EQUALLY
00:38:47.391 --> 00:38:48.325
IMPACTFUL.
00:38:48.392 --> 00:38:50.494
DESPITE PEOPLE'S BEST INTENTIONS
00:38:50.561 --> 00:38:51.729
RESEARCHERS HAVE FOUND THAT
00:38:51.796 --> 00:38:54.131
SUBJECTS CAN CONSCIOUSLY EMBRACE
00:38:54.198 --> 00:38:56.000
IDEAS OF FAIRNESS AND EQUALITY
00:38:56.067 --> 00:38:58.436
AND YET ON TESTS THAT MEASURE
00:38:58.502 --> 00:39:00.438
SUBCONSCIOUS TENDENCIES STILL
00:39:00.504 --> 00:39:02.339
SHOW A STRONG PROPENSITY TO LEAN
00:39:02.406 --> 00:39:04.175
ON STEREO TYPES TO FILL IN THE
00:39:04.241 --> 00:39:06.077
BLANKS ABOUT PEOPLE THEY DON'T
00:39:06.143 --> 00:39:07.244
KNOW.
00:39:07.311 --> 00:39:09.413
IT IS CRITICAL THAT ATTORNEYS
00:39:09.480 --> 00:39:10.915
JUDGES AND COURT PERSONNEL
00:39:10.981 --> 00:39:12.750
RECEIVE TRAINING ON A ROUTINE
00:39:12.817 --> 00:39:14.385
BASIS TO RECOGNIZE THEIR
00:39:14.452 --> 00:39:16.153
IMPLICIT BIAS THESE AND TAKES
00:39:16.220 --> 00:39:18.389
STEPS TO COUNTER ACT THEIR
00:39:18.456 --> 00:39:19.790
UNCONSCIOUS INFLUENCES.
00:39:19.857 --> 00:39:21.559
WHEN PEOPLE ENTER INTO A COURT
00:39:21.625 --> 00:39:23.060
ROOM OR ENCOUNTER THE COURT
00:39:23.127 --> 00:39:24.195
SYSTEM?
00:39:24.261 --> 00:39:25.663
THEY'RE HOPEFUL FOR EQUAL
00:39:25.730 --> 00:39:28.099
EQUITABLE AND FAIR TREATMENT
00:39:28.165 --> 00:39:30.101
THEY ARE PUTTING THEIR LIVES
00:39:30.167 --> 00:39:32.103
THEIR FAMILIES AND THEIR FUTURES
00:39:32.169 --> 00:39:34.171
ON THE LINE IN IN THE TRUST OF
00:39:34.238 --> 00:39:35.673
THE COURT.
00:39:35.740 --> 00:39:37.408
AND YET UNCONSCIOUS AND IMPLICIT
00:39:37.475 --> 00:39:39.143
BIAS HE'S CAN AND DO AFFECT THE
00:39:39.210 --> 00:39:40.111
DAY TO DAY DECISION MAKING
00:39:40.177 --> 00:39:42.646
PROCESS THESE OF EVEN THE MOST
00:39:42.713 --> 00:39:44.181
AWARE COURT OFFICERS.
00:39:44.248 --> 00:39:45.483
YET CHANGE CAN COME THROUGH
00:39:45.549 --> 00:39:47.818
EDUCATION INTERACTION AND
00:39:47.885 --> 00:39:49.086
CONVERSATION.
00:39:49.153 --> 00:39:50.321
IN THE STATE OF JUDICIARY
00:39:50.387 --> 00:39:52.189
ADDRESS LAST MONTH SUPREME COURT
00:39:52.256 --> 00:39:53.624
CHIEF JUSTICE TANI CONCEAL
00:39:53.691 --> 00:39:55.659
SOCCER WAY RECOGNIZE THE
00:39:55.726 --> 00:39:57.561
IMPORTANCE AND EXPRESSED SUPPORT
00:39:57.628 --> 00:39:59.029
FOR IMPLICIT BIAS TRAINING FOR
00:39:59.096 --> 00:39:59.630
JUDGES.
00:39:59.697 --> 00:40:01.298
AN UNCONSCIOUS BIAS TRAINING
00:40:01.365 --> 00:40:03.334
MANDATORY FOR ALL COURT
00:40:03.400 --> 00:40:04.869
ADMINISTRATIVE EMPLOYEES.
00:40:04.935 --> 00:40:06.437
I WOULD LIKE TO BUILD A CULTURE
00:40:06.504 --> 00:40:08.139
THAT CONSTANTLY AND RESPECTFULLY
00:40:08.205 --> 00:40:10.141
ADDRESSES BIAS TO STRENGTHEN THE
00:40:10.207 --> 00:40:12.209
TRUST BETWEEN OFFICERS OF THE
00:40:12.276 --> 00:40:14.011
COURT IN OUR COMMUNITIES.
00:40:14.078 --> 00:40:16.914
AB TWO FOUR TWO SIX TO AMPLIFY
00:40:16.981 --> 00:40:18.482
THE SUPREME COURT.
00:40:18.549 --> 00:40:20.251
CHIEF JUSTICES WORK ON IMPLICIT
00:40:20.317 --> 00:40:22.219
BIAS AND MANDATE THAT JUDGES AND
00:40:22.286 --> 00:40:23.988
ATTORNEYS MUST BE TRAINED EVERY
00:40:24.054 --> 00:40:25.289
THREE YEARS AND COURT PERSONNEL
00:40:25.356 --> 00:40:27.224
EVERY TWO YEARS.
00:40:27.291 --> 00:40:27.858
TODAY WITH ME AND SUPPORT IS
00:40:27.925 --> 00:40:29.260
KIMBERLY PAPPY ON JUDICIAL
00:40:29.326 --> 00:40:31.729
PROFESSOR AND LISA HOLDER EQUAL
00:40:31.796 --> 00:40:33.764
JUSTICE SOCIETY LEGAL DIRECTOR
00:40:33.831 --> 00:40:35.266
THANK YOU THANK YOU AND IS
00:40:35.332 --> 00:40:37.001
COVERED OF THERE ARE AMENDMENTS
00:40:37.067 --> 00:40:40.437
LISTED IN THE IT ALSO SAVES WHO
00:40:40.504 --> 00:40:41.639
YOUR TAKING THOSE -- YES WE ARE
00:40:41.705 --> 00:40:43.474
THANK YOU VERY MUCH AND THANK
00:40:43.541 --> 00:40:45.109
YOU FOR THE WORK OF THE
00:40:45.176 --> 00:40:47.678
COMMITTEE ON ENERGY ABOUT.
00:40:47.745 --> 00:40:48.879
THE FIRST WITNESS PLEASE.
00:40:48.946 --> 00:40:49.947
GOOD MORNING I'M LISA HOLDER A
00:40:50.014 --> 00:40:52.082
CIVIL RIGHTS ATTORNEY AND UCLA
00:40:52.149 --> 00:40:55.920
LAW LECTURER UNCONSTITUTIONAL
00:40:55.986 --> 00:40:58.756
POLICING SKIP TO SPEAK.
00:40:58.823 --> 00:41:00.524
WE GET THIS IS A RECORD THANK
00:41:00.591 --> 00:41:00.825
YOU OKAY.
00:41:00.891 --> 00:41:01.458
I AM GRATEFUL TO BE HERE THIS
00:41:01.525 --> 00:41:03.928
MORNING ADDRESSING THIS AUGUST
00:41:03.994 --> 00:41:05.596
BODY OF LAWMAKERS.
00:41:05.663 --> 00:41:06.730
AND I ADDRESS YOU TODAY IN MY
00:41:06.797 --> 00:41:08.199
CAPACITY AS INTERIM LEGAL
00:41:08.265 --> 00:41:09.667
DIRECTOR OF THE EQUAL JUSTICE
00:41:09.733 --> 00:41:10.835
SOCIETY.
00:41:10.901 --> 00:41:13.604
AND OAKLAND BASED.
00:41:13.671 --> 00:41:15.105
RACIAL JUSTICE ADVOCACY GROUP.
00:41:15.172 --> 00:41:16.607
THE EQUAL JUSTICE SOCIETY IS
00:41:16.674 --> 00:41:18.309
TRANSFORMING THE NATION'S
00:41:18.375 --> 00:41:19.910
CONSCIOUSNESS ON RACE THROUGH
00:41:19.977 --> 00:41:22.246
LITIGATION SOCIAL SCIENCE AND
00:41:22.313 --> 00:41:23.514
THE ARTS.
00:41:23.581 --> 00:41:25.416
AND FOR TWENTY YEARS SINCE ITS
00:41:25.482 --> 00:41:26.550
INCEPTION.
00:41:26.617 --> 00:41:28.919
ALONG WITH ITS THOUGHT PARTNERS
00:41:28.986 --> 00:41:32.690
A NETWORK OF JUDGES ATTORNEYS
00:41:32.756 --> 00:41:34.725
SCIENTISTS.
00:41:34.792 --> 00:41:35.459
UP.
00:41:35.526 --> 00:41:38.128
SCIENTISTS AND ACADEMICS THE
00:41:38.195 --> 00:41:39.496
EAGLE JUST JUST THE SOCIETY HAS
00:41:39.563 --> 00:41:41.465
BEEN RESEARCHING AND ANALYZING
00:41:41.532 --> 00:41:43.634
IMPLICIT BIAS AND THE WAY THAT
00:41:43.701 --> 00:41:46.170
IT IMPACTS INDIVIDUALS.
00:41:46.237 --> 00:41:50.241
AND THE INSTITUTIONS OPERATED
00:41:50.307 --> 00:41:51.809
AND CREATED BY INDIVIDUALS.
00:41:51.876 --> 00:41:53.477
WHEN I TALK TO PEOPLE ABOUT THE
00:41:53.544 --> 00:41:54.478
WORK THAT WE'VE DONE ON THIS
00:41:54.545 --> 00:41:56.247
BILL WHEN I TALK TO PEOPLE ABOUT
00:41:56.313 --> 00:41:57.147
THE WORK THAT I DO AN IMPLICIT
00:41:57.214 --> 00:41:58.015
BIAS?
00:41:58.082 --> 00:41:59.283
SO MANY OF THEM SAY OH THAT'S
00:41:59.350 --> 00:42:02.319
GREAT WORK ON I APPLAUD YOU BUT
00:42:02.386 --> 00:42:04.388
I DON'T HAVE BIAS.
00:42:04.455 --> 00:42:06.757
WELL ALL PEOPLE HAVE IMPLICIT
00:42:06.824 --> 00:42:08.792
BIAS.
00:42:08.859 --> 00:42:10.761
ALL PEOPLE HAVE UNCONSCIOUS
00:42:10.828 --> 00:42:13.130
BIASES.
00:42:13.197 --> 00:42:15.900
THAT THEY CANNOT CONTROL WITHOUT
00:42:15.966 --> 00:42:17.534
ASSISTANCE AND INTERVENTIONS.
00:42:17.601 --> 00:42:19.236
OUR BIASES DEVELOPED DURING THE
00:42:19.303 --> 00:42:21.205
COURSE OF A LIFETIME THROUGH
00:42:21.272 --> 00:42:25.075
EXPOSURE TO STEREOTYPES.
00:42:25.142 --> 00:42:27.511
AN IMPLICIT BIAS.
00:42:27.578 --> 00:42:28.445
INFLUENCES.
00:42:28.512 --> 00:42:29.980
NOT ONLY OUR BELIEFS BUT OUR
00:42:30.047 --> 00:42:32.349
ATTITUDES AND OUR ACTIONS TOWARD
00:42:32.416 --> 00:42:34.118
OTHER PEOPLE.
00:42:34.184 --> 00:42:36.120
AND THE WAY THAT WE CREATE AND
00:42:36.186 --> 00:42:38.188
OPERATE OUR SYSTEMS AND OUR
00:42:38.255 --> 00:42:39.757
INSTITUTIONS.
00:42:39.823 --> 00:42:42.159
IN A RESEARCH STUDY INVOLVING
00:42:42.226 --> 00:42:42.626
SEVEN HUNDRED THOUSAND
00:42:42.693 --> 00:42:43.761
PARTICIPANTS THE MOST FREQUENT
00:42:43.827 --> 00:42:45.362
ANSWER TO THE QUESTION WHO DO
00:42:45.429 --> 00:42:46.730
YOU PREFER BLACK PEOPLE OR WHITE
00:42:46.797 --> 00:42:49.934
PEOPLE WAS I HAVE NO PREFERENCE.
00:42:50.000 --> 00:42:52.469
YET IN THAT SAME STUDY WHEN
00:42:52.536 --> 00:42:53.938
GIVEN AND IMPERIL TEST THAT
00:42:54.004 --> 00:42:56.073
MEASURES ONE'S LEVEL OF IMPLICIT
00:42:56.140 --> 00:42:59.743
BIAS. 70% OF THOSE SEVEN HUNDRED
00:42:59.810 --> 00:43:00.544
THOUSAND PEOPLE SHOWED A
00:43:00.611 --> 00:43:01.679
PREFERENCE FOR WHITE PEOPLE OVER
00:43:01.745 --> 00:43:04.381
BLACK PEOPLE.
00:43:04.448 --> 00:43:06.617
JUDGES COURT PERSONNEL AND
00:43:06.684 --> 00:43:08.752
ATTORNEYS ARE NOT IMMUNE FROM
00:43:08.819 --> 00:43:11.789
BIAS THEIR PEOPLE.
00:43:11.855 --> 00:43:13.357
TO A TWO THOUSAND SEVENTEEN
00:43:13.424 --> 00:43:13.891
STUDY.
00:43:13.958 --> 00:43:15.359
DEMONSTRATED THAT JUDGES POSSESS
00:43:15.426 --> 00:43:16.961
THE SAME LEVEL OF IMPLICIT BIAS
00:43:17.027 --> 00:43:18.862
AGAINST AFRICAN AMERICANS AS DO
00:43:18.929 --> 00:43:20.831
MOSTLY PEOPLE.
00:43:20.898 --> 00:43:22.299
AT A TWO THOUSAND STEP SEVEN
00:43:22.366 --> 00:43:24.134
CHEVY STOW THAT JUDGES AND
00:43:24.201 --> 00:43:25.636
JURORS MAY UNINTENTIONALLY AND
00:43:25.703 --> 00:43:27.438
AUTOMATICALLY MISS REMEMBER
00:43:27.504 --> 00:43:29.940
FACTS IN A RACIALLY SKEWED
00:43:30.007 --> 00:43:33.477
MANNER DURING ALL FACETS OF THE
00:43:33.544 --> 00:43:34.511
LEGAL DECISION MAKING PROCESS.
00:43:34.578 --> 00:43:36.246
EMPIRICAL RESEARCH ALSO SHOWS
00:43:36.313 --> 00:43:38.382
THAT PROSECUTORS ARE MORE LIKELY
00:43:38.449 --> 00:43:40.050
TO CHARGE BLACK SUSPECTS THAN
00:43:40.117 --> 00:43:41.518
WHITE SUSPECTS IN SIMILAR
00:43:41.585 --> 00:43:43.187
CIRCUMSTANCES.
00:43:43.253 --> 00:43:44.621
SO WHEN LEFT UNADDRESSED THE
00:43:44.688 --> 00:43:47.524
IMPLICIT BIASES OF JUDGES CLERKS
00:43:47.591 --> 00:43:49.226
AND ATTORNEYS CONTRIBUTES TO AN
00:43:49.293 --> 00:43:52.296
UNACCEPTABLE RACIAL DISPARITY IN
00:43:52.363 --> 00:43:53.931
THE ADMINISTRATION OF JUSTICE.
00:43:53.998 --> 00:43:56.266
IN SAN FRANCISCO LOCALLY BLACK
00:43:56.333 --> 00:43:58.469
DEFENDANTS ARE HELD IN PRE TRIAL
00:43:58.535 --> 00:44:01.138
CUSTODY 62% LONGER THAN WHITE
00:44:01.205 --> 00:44:02.006
DEFENDANTS.
00:44:02.072 --> 00:44:04.375
AND BLACK DEFENDANTS RECEIVED
00:44:04.441 --> 00:44:06.443
28% LONGER SENTENCES THAN WHITE
00:44:06.510 --> 00:44:08.645
DEFENDANTS CONVICTED CONVICTED
00:44:08.712 --> 00:44:09.813
OF THE SAME CRIME.
00:44:09.880 --> 00:44:11.348
AND NATIONALLY JUDGES SET BAIL
00:44:11.415 --> 00:44:14.451
AMOUNTS OF BLACK MEN 35% HIGHER
00:44:14.518 --> 00:44:16.153
THAN FOR WHITE MEN AND FOR LET
00:44:16.220 --> 00:44:18.455
LATINO MEN 19% HIGHER THAN FOR
00:44:18.522 --> 00:44:19.390
WHITE MEN.
00:44:19.456 --> 00:44:21.725
SO SINCE BIAS IS LEARNED OVER
00:44:21.792 --> 00:44:22.793
THE COURSE OF A LIFETIME IT'S
00:44:22.860 --> 00:44:24.928
NOT EASILY -- LEARN BUT THE GOOD
00:44:24.995 --> 00:44:27.765
NEWS IS THAT THERE IS ROOM FOR
00:44:27.831 --> 00:44:31.402
CHANGE AND BIAS CAN BE MANAGED
00:44:31.468 --> 00:44:33.037
THROUGH COUNTER BIAS TRAINING.
00:44:33.103 --> 00:44:35.172
PRACTICAL TOOLS CAN HELP
00:44:35.239 --> 00:44:36.306
PARTICIPANTS UNLEARNED
00:44:36.373 --> 00:44:38.275
STEREOTYPES AND RETRAIN THEIR
00:44:38.342 --> 00:44:40.811
BRAIN TO DISRUPT STEREO TYPE
00:44:40.878 --> 00:44:43.113
BASS IMPLICIT ASSOCIATIONS.
00:44:43.180 --> 00:44:44.715
COUNTERBALANCED COUNTER BIAS
00:44:44.782 --> 00:44:46.517
TRAINING CAN BE MOST EFFECTIVE
00:44:46.583 --> 00:44:49.586
WHEN ITS ONGOING AND REOCCURRING.
00:44:49.653 --> 00:44:50.087
THE OTHER THING IS THAT
00:44:50.154 --> 00:44:52.022
STRESSFUL WORKING ENVIRONMENT
00:44:52.089 --> 00:44:53.290
STIMULATE BIAS.
00:44:53.357 --> 00:44:54.858
AND INDIVIDUALS HAVE TO DO THE
00:44:54.925 --> 00:44:56.427
HARD WORK OF DISRUPTING THEIR
00:44:56.493 --> 00:44:58.962
BIAS BUT INSTITUTIONS HAVE AN
00:44:59.029 --> 00:45:00.564
IMPORTANT ROLE TO PLAY AS WELL.
00:45:00.631 --> 00:45:01.865
INSTITUTIONS NEED TO CREATE
00:45:01.932 --> 00:45:03.667
POSITIVE BEHAVIORAL SUPPORT
00:45:03.734 --> 00:45:05.502
STRUCTURES.
00:45:05.569 --> 00:45:06.937
THAT DE STRESS THE WORK FORCE
00:45:07.004 --> 00:45:08.906
AND ALLOW PROFESSIONALS TIME TO
00:45:08.972 --> 00:45:10.374
MAKE CAREFUL AND DELIBERATE
00:45:10.441 --> 00:45:11.575
DECISIONS.
00:45:11.642 --> 00:45:13.510
DELIBERATE THOUGHTFUL DECISION
00:45:13.577 --> 00:45:18.615
MAKING IS THE KEY TO DISRUPTING.
00:45:18.682 --> 00:45:20.384
FIVE I'VE OBSERVED I DO NEED YOU
00:45:20.451 --> 00:45:22.052
TO WRAP UP OKAY.
00:45:22.119 --> 00:45:23.020
I KNOW THAT WE HAVE THE BODY
00:45:23.087 --> 00:45:24.788
POLITIC SHARE VALUES OF FAIRNESS
00:45:24.855 --> 00:45:27.024
EQUITY AND JUSTICE.
00:45:27.091 --> 00:45:27.991
AND I BELIEVE THAT THIS BILL
00:45:28.058 --> 00:45:30.694
THAT STRIVE TO ELIMINATE BIAS.
00:45:30.761 --> 00:45:32.463
IN INDIVIDUALS AND INSTITUTIONS
00:45:32.529 --> 00:45:34.231
TAKES US ONE GIANT LEAP TOWARD
00:45:34.298 --> 00:45:35.699
THAT MORE PERFECT UNION THANK
00:45:35.766 --> 00:45:37.568
YOU.
00:45:37.634 --> 00:45:39.970
THANK YOU NEXT WITH US PLEASE.
00:45:40.037 --> 00:45:41.538
GOOD MORNING.
00:45:41.605 --> 00:45:42.806
THANK YOU FOR INVITING ME TODAY
00:45:42.873 --> 00:45:45.008
MEDIAN CHAIR -- I'M PLEASED TO
00:45:45.075 --> 00:45:46.076
BE HERE.
00:45:46.143 --> 00:45:47.811
THE CONVERSATION THAT IF WE
00:45:47.878 --> 00:45:49.680
COULD JUST ASSUME ARGUENDO FOR
00:45:49.746 --> 00:45:50.914
THE PURPOSES OF CONVERSATION
00:45:50.981 --> 00:45:52.816
THAT BIAS EXISTS AND THAT IT
00:45:52.883 --> 00:45:54.651
AFFECTS DECISION MAKING -- ON
00:45:54.718 --> 00:45:57.054
THE BENCH AND BEYOND -- THEN WE
00:45:57.121 --> 00:45:58.822
GET TO EXPLORE THE QUESTION OF
00:45:58.889 --> 00:46:01.358
THE VALUE OF TRAINING.
00:46:01.425 --> 00:46:04.328
OF MAKE WILL IT SIMPLY BE A
00:46:04.394 --> 00:46:05.696
MOMENT OF COMMON UNDERSTANDING
00:46:05.762 --> 00:46:07.064
COMING TOGETHER NETWORKING OR
00:46:07.131 --> 00:46:08.398
WILL IT ACTUALLY MAKE A
00:46:08.465 --> 00:46:09.500
DIFFERENCE IN THE WAY THAT
00:46:09.566 --> 00:46:10.701
PEOPLE MAKE DECISIONS.
00:46:10.767 --> 00:46:12.269
BUCKLEY THE NEUROSCIENCE THAT IS
00:46:12.336 --> 00:46:14.538
AVAILABLE -- GIVES US INSIGHT
00:46:14.605 --> 00:46:15.539
INTO THAT.
00:46:15.606 --> 00:46:16.773
EFFECT WAS NEUROSCIENCE THE HELP
00:46:16.840 --> 00:46:18.442
THE FIRST OPEN THE DOOR. TO HELP
00:46:18.509 --> 00:46:19.977
US UNDERSTAND HOW BIAS ACTUALLY
00:46:20.043 --> 00:46:21.345
MANIFEST ITSELF.
00:46:21.411 --> 00:46:23.447
IF WE HAVE A DIFFERENT BRAIN
00:46:23.514 --> 00:46:26.116
REACTION TO A FACE A NAME A
00:46:26.183 --> 00:46:27.317
VOICE.
00:46:27.384 --> 00:46:28.185
WE WILL MAKE DECISIONS
00:46:28.252 --> 00:46:30.254
DIFFERENTLY ABOUT THOSE
00:46:30.320 --> 00:46:31.688
INDIVIDUALS IN A COURT OF LAW --
00:46:31.755 --> 00:46:32.756
THE WONDERFUL THING IS THAT THE
00:46:32.823 --> 00:46:33.790
TECHNOLOGY IN THE NATURAL
00:46:33.857 --> 00:46:35.259
SCIENCES ACTUALLY LET US KNOW
00:46:35.325 --> 00:46:36.793
HOW TO CHANGE THOSE BRING
00:46:36.860 --> 00:46:37.861
REACTIONS.
00:46:37.928 --> 00:46:39.596
CUES CAN BE UTILIZED THAT WILL
00:46:39.663 --> 00:46:41.732
LOWER OUR LEVEL OF THREAT
00:46:41.798 --> 00:46:43.767
REACTION WHEN WE SEE INDIVIDUALS
00:46:43.834 --> 00:46:46.470
WHO MIGHT OTHERWISE APPEAR FIGHT
00:46:46.537 --> 00:46:48.805
MEAN THREATENING PERHAPS JUST
00:46:48.872 --> 00:46:49.873
INDIVIDUALS WHO.
00:46:49.940 --> 00:46:51.108
WHEN CONSIDERING THE OPTION OF
00:46:51.175 --> 00:46:53.177
INCARCERATION WE SAY WE NEED TO
00:46:53.243 --> 00:46:54.144
PROTECT OURSELVES FROM THEM AND
00:46:54.211 --> 00:46:55.646
AND THEREFORE PERHAPS PLACE THEM
00:46:55.712 --> 00:46:58.081
IN INCARCERATION? FOR A LONGER
00:46:58.148 --> 00:46:59.516
PERIOD OF TIME [inaudible]
00:46:59.583 --> 00:47:00.784
ADDITIONALLY.
00:47:00.851 --> 00:47:02.419
NEUROSCIENCE HELPS US UNDERSTAND
00:47:02.486 --> 00:47:05.989
WHAT PRECISELY A JUDGE COULD DO.
00:47:06.056 --> 00:47:07.658
IN APPLYING LAW TO FACT. TO MAKE
00:47:07.724 --> 00:47:09.893
A FAIR DECISION EVEN IN THE FACE
00:47:09.960 --> 00:47:11.228
OF IMPLICIT BIAS.
00:47:11.295 --> 00:47:12.596
ASSUMING THAT IMPLICIT BIAS
00:47:12.663 --> 00:47:15.332
EXIST IN THE MIND OR THE BRAIN
00:47:15.399 --> 00:47:16.867
OF THAT JUDGE AT THAT TIME.
00:47:16.934 --> 00:47:18.669
CAN WE ACTUALLY TRAIN A JUDGE TO
00:47:18.735 --> 00:47:20.037
MAKE A FAIR DECISION BY
00:47:20.103 --> 00:47:21.939
ACTIVATING PARTICULAR PARTS OF
00:47:22.005 --> 00:47:23.507
THE NEUROANATOMY AND SUBSYSTEMS
00:47:23.574 --> 00:47:25.542
THAT WILL ALLOW THEM TO MAKE A
00:47:25.609 --> 00:47:27.578
DECISION THAT'S REALLY ABOUT THE
00:47:27.644 --> 00:47:28.212
FACTS AND THE LAW.
00:47:28.278 --> 00:47:30.247
AND THE ANSWER IS YES WE HAVE
00:47:30.314 --> 00:47:31.748
THAT AVAILABLE TO US AND THEY
00:47:31.815 --> 00:47:33.417
DON'T HAVE TO ACTUALLYHAVE
00:47:33.483 --> 00:47:35.085
THEIR BRAIN SCANNED IN THEY
00:47:35.152 --> 00:47:36.353
DON'T HAVE TO TAKE ANOTHER NEURO
00:47:36.420 --> 00:47:38.121
BIOLOGY CLASS OR THEIR FIRST ONE
00:47:38.188 --> 00:47:39.056
PERHAPS.
00:47:39.122 --> 00:47:40.457
IT ALL BECOMES A PART OF A
00:47:40.524 --> 00:47:42.259
PRACTICAL APPLICATION IN A
00:47:42.326 --> 00:47:43.827
CLASSROOM ENVIRONMENT.
00:47:43.894 --> 00:47:45.829
OF THE MORE THAT WE DO THE MORE
00:47:45.896 --> 00:47:48.332
CONTROL THE JUDGE HAS AND QUIRK
00:47:48.398 --> 00:47:49.566
STAFF HAVE OVER THEIR BRAINS.
00:47:49.633 --> 00:47:51.101
MANY OF CONTROL OF THEIR BRAINS
00:47:51.168 --> 00:47:54.338
ABOUT CONTROL THEIR COURT.
00:47:54.404 --> 00:47:56.039
AND THEN WE HAVE A FAIR.
00:47:56.106 --> 00:47:57.007
SHERRI AND IN THE JUDITH PROCESS
00:47:57.074 --> 00:47:58.642
THAT ACTUALLY LEADS TO THE
00:47:58.709 --> 00:48:00.544
OUTCOMES WERE HOPING.
00:48:00.611 --> 00:48:02.512
FOR SO I SUBMIT TO YOU THAT.
00:48:02.579 --> 00:48:04.448
TRAINING IS MORE THAN HOLDING
00:48:04.514 --> 00:48:06.683
HANDS SINGING KUMBAYA.
00:48:06.750 --> 00:48:09.653
BUT RATHER IMPLEMENTING SPECIFIC
00:48:09.720 --> 00:48:11.355
MECHANISMS THAT CAN ALLOW US TO
00:48:11.421 --> 00:48:12.856
ENSURE THE FAIRNESS AND EQUITY
00:48:12.923 --> 00:48:15.959
OF THE COURTS.
00:48:16.026 --> 00:48:17.661
THANK YOU THANK YOU BUT ALLOW
00:48:17.728 --> 00:48:21.898
ONE OTHER WITNESS HER TESTIMONY.
00:48:21.965 --> 00:48:23.300
THE COURT JESTERS ON BEHALF OF
00:48:23.367 --> 00:48:24.234
THE JUDICIAL COUNCIL MY MISTER
00:48:24.301 --> 00:48:25.602
CHAIR MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE
00:48:25.669 --> 00:48:26.470
WE DON'T HAVE AN OFFICIAL
00:48:26.536 --> 00:48:27.871
POSITION THAT STILL GOING TO
00:48:27.938 --> 00:48:29.172
ADVISORY COMMITTEE PROCESS BUT
00:48:29.239 --> 00:48:30.307
WE ARE DEFINITELY SUPPORT OF WE
00:48:30.374 --> 00:48:32.009
WELCOME THE ASSEMBLY MORMONS --
00:48:32.075 --> 00:48:33.310
INTEREST IN THIS ISSUE WITH A
00:48:33.377 --> 00:48:34.478
VERY IMPORTANT ISSUE WAS NOTED
00:48:34.544 --> 00:48:36.246
IN THE ANALYSIS -- THIS IS
00:48:36.313 --> 00:48:37.781
SOMETHING THAT THE JUDGES WERE
00:48:37.848 --> 00:48:39.316
COUNCIL HAS INTEGRATED INTO OUR
00:48:39.383 --> 00:48:40.584
QUALIFIED ETHICS COURSE FOR
00:48:40.651 --> 00:48:42.619
JUDGES I BELIEVE SINCE TWO
00:48:42.686 --> 00:48:43.553
THOUSAND THIRTEEN WE CONTINUE TO
00:48:43.620 --> 00:48:43.754
WORK.
00:48:43.820 --> 00:48:46.556
ON THAT -- ON THE SUBJECT THANK
00:48:46.623 --> 00:48:47.891
THE AUTHOR IN THE COMMITTEE FOR
00:48:47.958 --> 00:48:49.126
THE TECHNICAL AND CLARIFYING
00:48:49.192 --> 00:48:50.727
AMENDMENTS WE HAVE BEEN ENGAGED
00:48:50.794 --> 00:48:52.562
WITH OUR PRESIDING JUDGE
00:48:52.629 --> 00:48:53.930
LEADERSHIP IN COURT EXECUTIVE
00:48:53.997 --> 00:48:54.998
OFFICER LEADERSHIP.
00:48:55.065 --> 00:48:56.300
A WORKING ON SOME OF THE MOMENT
00:48:56.366 --> 00:48:58.068
SO THAT'S BEEN NOT REALLY GREAT
00:48:58.135 --> 00:48:59.036
AND I WOULD JUST INTRODUCE
00:48:59.102 --> 00:49:00.504
BRIEFLY KAREEM ALTERADO WHO'S
00:49:00.570 --> 00:49:01.638
JOINED US HERE SHE'S THE
00:49:01.705 --> 00:49:02.939
DIRECTOR OF OUR CENTER FOR
00:49:03.006 --> 00:49:04.541
JUDICIAL EDUCATION RESEARCH.
00:49:04.608 --> 00:49:05.575
AND SHE'S AVAILABLE IF YOU HAVE
00:49:05.642 --> 00:49:07.711
ANY QUESTIONS ABOUT THE WORK
00:49:07.778 --> 00:49:08.745
THAT THE JUDICIAL COUNCIL IS
00:49:08.812 --> 00:49:10.447
DOING IN THIS AREA THANK YOU.
00:49:10.514 --> 00:49:11.181
THANK YOU.
00:49:11.248 --> 00:49:12.516
ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT IF YOU
00:49:12.582 --> 00:49:13.784
COULD COME FOR JUST GIVE US YOUR
00:49:13.850 --> 00:49:21.191
NAME AND YOUR AFFILIATION PLEASE --
00:49:21.258 --> 00:49:22.092
CARES WITH DISABILITY RIGHTS
00:49:22.159 --> 00:49:23.093
CALIFORNIANS SUPPORT.
00:49:23.160 --> 00:49:27.831
THANK YOU.
00:49:27.898 --> 00:49:29.032
DANIEL SAVANNAH ASSOCIATION OF
00:49:29.099 --> 00:49:30.200
REGIONAL CENTER AGENCIES ALSO IN
00:49:30.267 --> 00:49:36.106
SUPPORT.
00:49:36.173 --> 00:49:37.107
CHRISTOPHER SONS THE CHAIR THAT
00:49:37.174 --> 00:49:38.975
WE JUST FROM THE POSITION LAST
00:49:39.042 --> 00:49:39.543
WEEK AND SUPPORT [inudible]
00:49:39.609 --> 00:49:41.078
THANK YOU.
00:49:41.144 --> 00:49:45.649
ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT.
00:49:45.716 --> 00:49:46.850
HELLO MY NAME IS YOU WANTED TO
00:49:46.917 --> 00:49:48.251
CLIMB A AM A RESIDENT OF OAKLAND
00:49:48.318 --> 00:49:49.886
CALIFORNIA AND I WORK FOR EQUAL
00:49:49.953 --> 00:49:51.355
JUSTICE SOCIETY AND ALSO HERE IN
00:49:51.421 --> 00:49:53.290
SUPPORT BECAUSE I THINK THIS
00:49:53.357 --> 00:49:54.291
BILL IS CRITICAL.
00:49:54.358 --> 00:49:56.159
I CAPACITY THEY DO ACTUALLY
00:49:56.226 --> 00:49:57.060
ADMINISTER JUSTICE IN THIS
00:49:57.127 --> 00:49:58.662
COUNTRY THANK YOU ANYONE ELSE IN
00:49:58.729 --> 00:50:03.734
SUPPORT.
00:50:03.800 --> 00:50:04.334
ALL RIGHT SIGNAL IS THERE ANY
00:50:04.401 --> 00:50:06.436
OPPOSITION.
00:50:06.503 --> 00:50:07.738
I SAY NONE BRING BACK TO
00:50:07.804 --> 00:50:10.574
COMMITTEE QUESTIONS COMMENTS
00:50:10.640 --> 00:50:12.743
REDRESS.
00:50:12.809 --> 00:50:14.244
THIS IS REALLY IMPORTANT I KNOW
00:50:14.311 --> 00:50:16.213
THAT -- WHEN I VOLUNTEERED AS A
00:50:16.279 --> 00:50:17.848
TEMPORARY JUDGE WE HAD TO GO
00:50:17.914 --> 00:50:19.216
THROUGH TRAINING?
00:50:19.282 --> 00:50:21.351
AND ONE OF THOSE WAS ON IMPLICIT
00:50:21.418 --> 00:50:22.452
BIAS.
00:50:22.519 --> 00:50:24.187
AND YOU'RE RIGHT EVEN THOUGH YOU
00:50:24.254 --> 00:50:26.890
THINK YOU DON'T HAVE THAT BIAS
00:50:26.957 --> 00:50:27.958
IT IS THERE.
00:50:28.024 --> 00:50:29.559
AND IT IS IMPORTANT TO
00:50:29.626 --> 00:50:31.061
ACKNOWLEDGE IT AND THEN TO
00:50:31.128 --> 00:50:32.496
FIGURE HOW YOU'RE GOING TO
00:50:32.562 --> 00:50:33.497
CHANGE IT.
00:50:33.563 --> 00:50:35.432
BECAUSE IF YOU JUST TO GLOSS
00:50:35.499 --> 00:50:37.634
OVER AND SAY I HAVE NO BIAS AYE.
00:50:37.701 --> 00:50:39.770
I GREW UP IN A SOCIETY WHERE I
00:50:39.836 --> 00:50:41.605
EVERYBODY IS EQUAL.
00:50:41.671 --> 00:50:43.640
IT THAT'S WONDERFUL BUT WHEN YOU
00:50:43.707 --> 00:50:45.108
TAKE THOSE LITTLE TESTS AND YOU
00:50:45.175 --> 00:50:47.043
FIND THAT THERE IS AN IMPLICIT
00:50:47.110 --> 00:50:48.612
BIAS YOU NEED TO BE ABLE TO
00:50:48.678 --> 00:50:49.646
ADDRESS THAT ESPECIALLY WHEN
00:50:49.713 --> 00:50:51.148
YOU'RE IN A POSITION. TO
00:50:51.214 --> 00:50:53.016
DETERMINE A SENTENCE OVER
00:50:53.083 --> 00:50:55.519
SOMEONE SO I ABSOLUTELY SUPPORT
00:50:55.585 --> 00:50:56.286
THIS BILL [inaudible]
00:50:56.353 --> 00:50:57.354
THANK YOU [inaudible]
00:50:57.421 --> 00:50:59.890
THANK YOU.
00:50:59.956 --> 00:51:02.392
THIS THE PETRIE-NORRIS.
00:51:02.459 --> 00:51:03.260
I JUST ECHO AT MY COLLEAGUES
00:51:03.326 --> 00:51:05.095
COMMENTS THIS IS SO IMPORTANT
00:51:05.162 --> 00:51:05.662
THANK YOU FOR BRINGING IT
00:51:05.729 --> 00:51:06.263
FORWARD.
00:51:06.329 --> 00:51:07.364
QUICK QUESTION FOR YOU AS YOU
00:51:07.431 --> 00:51:09.166
MENTIONED TRAINING IS NOT JUST
00:51:09.232 --> 00:51:11.034
HOLDING HANDS AND SING KUMBAYA
00:51:11.101 --> 00:51:13.236
WHAT ARE THE SPECIFIC ELEMENTS
00:51:13.303 --> 00:51:16.173
AS SUCCESSFUL TRAINING PROGRAMS
00:51:16.239 --> 00:51:17.941
AND SUCCESSFUL STRATEGIES IF YOU
00:51:18.008 --> 00:51:18.542
JUST.
00:51:18.608 --> 00:51:20.043
BRIEFLY TOUCH ON THAT VERY
00:51:20.110 --> 00:51:23.380
BRIEFLY CERTAINLY -- AND THANK
00:51:23.447 --> 00:51:26.082
YOU FOR THE QUESTION -- NUMBER.
00:51:26.149 --> 00:51:27.284
ONE AWARENESS.
00:51:27.350 --> 00:51:28.852
STEP ONE ADMIT YOU HAVE A
00:51:28.919 --> 00:51:30.821
PROBLEM BASICALLY SO IT IS
00:51:30.887 --> 00:51:32.322
IMPORTANT FOR A PERSON TO BE
00:51:32.389 --> 00:51:33.924
AWARE BUT THAT WHILE IS IT IS
00:51:33.990 --> 00:51:35.659
NECESSARY IS ABSOLUTELY
00:51:35.725 --> 00:51:36.827
INSUFFICIENT.
00:51:36.893 --> 00:51:38.995
IT'S PART ONE BUT YOU GOTTA GO
00:51:39.062 --> 00:51:40.297
TO THE NEXT STEP THEN ONCE
00:51:40.363 --> 00:51:41.398
EVERYONE GETS TO THE POINT OF
00:51:41.465 --> 00:51:43.533
SAYING YES INDEED WE HAVE A BIAS.
00:51:43.600 --> 00:51:44.835
NOW WE CAN MOVE FORWARD AND
00:51:44.901 --> 00:51:46.236
START UTILIZED TOOLS AND THE
00:51:46.303 --> 00:51:47.504
TOOL SHOULD COVER AT LEAST THREE
00:51:47.571 --> 00:51:49.573
CATEGORIES ONE REDUCING THE
00:51:49.639 --> 00:51:51.174
LEVEL OF IMPLICIT BIAS WHICH WE
00:51:51.241 --> 00:51:52.742
KNOW CAN BE DONE.
00:51:52.809 --> 00:51:54.177
THAT THERE IS OUR ACTUAL
00:51:54.244 --> 00:51:55.378
CURRICULA AVAILABLE THAT WILL
00:51:55.445 --> 00:51:56.980
ACTUALLY BRING DOWN YOUR LEVEL
00:51:57.047 --> 00:51:58.882
OF IMPLICIT BIAS ON THE I. A. T.
00:51:58.949 --> 00:52:00.650
IN ALMOST EVERY CATEGORY.
00:52:00.717 --> 00:52:02.419
SO THAT'S PART.
00:52:02.486 --> 00:52:04.254
ONE PART TWO PROVIDING THAT'S
00:52:04.321 --> 00:52:05.121
WHAT THAT'S LONG TERM
00:52:05.188 --> 00:52:06.656
MAINTENANCE PART TO PROVIDING
00:52:06.723 --> 00:52:09.226
PEOPLE WITH INSTANTANEOUS ACCESS
00:52:09.292 --> 00:52:10.594
TO BRING DOWN THE DIFFERENT
00:52:10.660 --> 00:52:12.929
NARAL PHYSIOLOGIC REACTIONS THAT
00:52:12.996 --> 00:52:14.631
CAN CREATE PROBLEMATIC DECISION
00:52:14.698 --> 00:52:15.332
MAKING.
00:52:15.398 --> 00:52:16.666
THE SPIDER SNAKE REACTION THAT
00:52:16.733 --> 00:52:18.168
WE HAVE IN OUR BRAIN WE CAN
00:52:18.235 --> 00:52:19.202
ACTUALLY ALSO HAVE TWO OTHER
00:52:19.269 --> 00:52:20.637
INDIVIDUALS WHO WE'VE BEEN TOLD
00:52:20.704 --> 00:52:21.938
OVER LIFE TIME OR THE SCARY
00:52:22.005 --> 00:52:23.340
PEOPLE WHO SHOULD BE
00:52:23.406 --> 00:52:24.608
INCARCERATED LONGER.
00:52:24.674 --> 00:52:25.675
FIRST A SHORT OF FOR SHORTER
00:52:25.742 --> 00:52:27.611
PERIODS OF TIME AND NUMBER THREE
00:52:27.677 --> 00:52:29.246
AND THIS IS IMPORTANT.
00:52:29.312 --> 00:52:30.881
TEACHING PEOPLE HOW TO ACTIVATE.
00:52:30.947 --> 00:52:32.115
THE SPECIFIC PARTS OF THEIR
00:52:32.182 --> 00:52:33.316
NEUROANATOMY THE ENTER YOUR
00:52:33.383 --> 00:52:35.452
SINGLE CORTEX TO BE SPECIFIC BUT
00:52:35.519 --> 00:52:36.486
NOT TO MAKE EVERYBODY'S EYES
00:52:36.553 --> 00:52:38.955
GLAZE OVER BUT TO PROTECT THE
00:52:39.022 --> 00:52:39.523
THE SPECIFIC PARTS OF THEIR
00:52:39.589 --> 00:52:40.657
NEUROANATOMY.
00:52:40.724 --> 00:52:41.758
THAT WILL ACTUALLY ALLOW THEM TO
00:52:41.825 --> 00:52:44.594
MAKE FAIR AND ACCURATE DECISIONS
00:52:44.661 --> 00:52:46.496
EVEN WALL BIAS IS EXT IS
00:52:46.563 --> 00:52:48.265
ACTUALLY ACTIVE IN THEIR BRAIN
00:52:48.331 --> 00:52:50.700
AND IN THEIR PSYCHE SO TO SPEAK.
00:52:50.767 --> 00:52:51.368
SO THOSE ARE THE THREE
00:52:51.434 --> 00:52:52.702
COMPONENTS FOR PART TO THE
00:52:52.769 --> 00:52:54.704
SOLUTION SECTION AND PART ONE IS
00:52:54.771 --> 00:52:56.339
JUST THE PROBLEM AND A LOT OF
00:52:56.406 --> 00:52:57.974
TRIMMING STOP AT PORT ONE NOW
00:52:58.041 --> 00:52:59.109
YOU'RE ALL WE ARE GOING TO GO
00:52:59.175 --> 00:53:00.911
OUT AND DO GOOD.
00:53:00.977 --> 00:53:02.445
AND YET THE PERSON SITS THERE
00:53:02.512 --> 00:53:03.346
CONFUSED.
00:53:03.413 --> 00:53:04.548
THANK THANK THANK YOU WE'RE NOT
00:53:04.614 --> 00:53:05.582
WE'RE NOT GONNA GO TO SOMEONE ON
00:53:05.649 --> 00:53:07.384
ALL THESE FASCINATING AS IT IS
00:53:07.450 --> 00:53:08.952
BUT WE'RE WE ARE TRYING TO MOVE
00:53:09.019 --> 00:53:13.823
THE POLICY.
00:53:13.890 --> 00:53:14.391
THANK YOU OTHER QUESTIONS OR
00:53:14.457 --> 00:53:14.958
COMMENTS.
00:53:15.025 --> 00:53:15.559
ALL RIGHT THANK YOU I I WILL
00:53:15.625 --> 00:53:16.126
GIVE A BRIEF PUBLIC SERVICE
00:53:16.192 --> 00:53:16.760
ANNOUNCEMENT ON MAY FOURTEENTH
00:53:16.826 --> 00:53:18.028
AT NINE O'CLOCK IN THIS ROOM
00:53:18.094 --> 00:53:19.062
THIS COMMITTEE.
00:53:19.129 --> 00:53:20.764
IN CONJUNCTION WITH THE NUMBER
00:53:20.830 --> 00:53:23.667
OF THE CAUCUSES IN THE ASSEMBLY
00:53:23.733 --> 00:53:25.502
ARE HOLDING HEARINGS ON
00:53:25.569 --> 00:53:26.536
DIVERSITY.
00:53:26.603 --> 00:53:28.104
IN THE ON THE BENCH DIVERSITY IN
00:53:28.171 --> 00:53:29.839
THE BARK IS ONE OF THE PROBLEMS
00:53:29.906 --> 00:53:31.875
THAT WE HAVE IS A LACK OF
00:53:31.942 --> 00:53:33.543
DIVERSITY BOTH ON THE BENCH TO
00:53:33.610 --> 00:53:35.579
THE BAR AND THE TRACK OF
00:53:35.645 --> 00:53:37.113
STUDENTS COMING INTO LAW
00:53:37.180 --> 00:53:38.515
PROFESSOR AND I THINK IT'S VERY
00:53:38.582 --> 00:53:41.051
DIFFICULT FOR US. TO OVERCOME
00:53:41.117 --> 00:53:42.485
THOSE BY SEES OR UNDERSTANDS.
00:53:42.552 --> 00:53:44.421
BREAK DOWN THE INTERNAL BY SEES
00:53:44.487 --> 00:53:46.856
IF WE DON'T HAVE A BENCH AT A
00:53:46.923 --> 00:53:48.491
BAR THAT LOOK LIKE CALIFORNIA
00:53:48.558 --> 00:53:49.993
IT'S MUCH EASIER TO SORT OF HIDE
00:53:50.060 --> 00:53:50.927
BEHIND.
00:53:50.994 --> 00:53:52.896
TRADITIONAL NOTIONS AND
00:53:52.963 --> 00:53:54.898
TRADITIONAL STANDARDS SO THAT'S
00:53:54.965 --> 00:53:56.533
GOING TO BE A VERY IMPORTANT
00:53:56.600 --> 00:53:58.802
PART OF CALIFORNIA MOVING
00:53:58.868 --> 00:53:59.636
FORWARD AND MAKING SURE THAT WE
00:53:59.703 --> 00:54:01.204
HAVE THE LEGAL PROFESSION THAT
00:54:01.271 --> 00:54:03.206
LOOKS AS MUCH LIKE CALIFORNIA AS
00:54:03.273 --> 00:54:05.742
WE CAN POSSIBLY GET IT.
00:54:05.809 --> 00:54:06.343
SO THANK YOU FOR BRINGING THIS
00:54:06.409 --> 00:54:08.211
FORWARD.
00:54:08.278 --> 00:54:08.845
OTHER QUESTIONS COMMENTS SEEING
00:54:08.912 --> 00:54:10.880
NONE.
00:54:10.947 --> 00:54:12.315
MS KAMARCK LOVE YOU MAY CLOSE.
00:54:12.382 --> 00:54:13.717
I WILL JUST SAY IN AN EFFORT TO
00:54:13.783 --> 00:54:15.352
DE STRESS THE WORKPLACE AND
00:54:15.418 --> 00:54:17.821
IMPACT IMPLICIT BIAS I
00:54:17.887 --> 00:54:18.421
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR AYE
00:54:18.488 --> 00:54:19.356
VOTE.
00:54:19.422 --> 00:54:20.423
WE DO HAVE A MOTION TO SECOND
00:54:20.490 --> 00:54:22.592
THE MOTION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED
00:54:22.659 --> 00:54:23.893
TO APPROPRIATIONS CALL THE ROLL
00:54:23.960 --> 00:54:25.662
PLEASE STONE BY STONE AYE
00:54:25.729 --> 00:54:27.063
GALLAGHER CHOW.
00:54:27.130 --> 00:54:29.265
CHOW I CHIU GONZALEZ.
00:54:29.332 --> 00:54:31.935
GONZALEZ I HOLDEN KALRA.
00:54:32.002 --> 00:54:35.972
KALRA AYE KILEY MAIENSCHEIN.
00:54:36.039 --> 00:54:37.841
MAIENSCHEIN I OBERNOLTE.
00:54:37.907 --> 00:54:39.376
PETRIE-NORRIS.
00:54:39.442 --> 00:54:40.710
PETRIE-NORRIS I REYES.
00:54:40.777 --> 00:54:42.479
REYES AYE.
00:54:42.545 --> 00:54:44.047
THAT BILLS OUT THANK YOU THANK
00:54:44.114 --> 00:54:45.181
YOU THANK YOU MEMBERS.
00:54:45.248 --> 00:54:46.750
THAT TAKES US TO ITEM NUMBER TEN
00:54:46.816 --> 00:54:49.219
A. B. ELEVEN EIGHTY FOUR MISTER
00:54:49.285 --> 00:54:54.958
GLORIA.
00:54:55.025 --> 00:55:11.307
YOU MADE YOUR BILL
00:55:12.609 --> 00:55:13.076
. TO LEARN
00:55:13.143 --> 00:55:14.544
MORE MISS CHAIRMAN I THANK YOU
00:55:14.611 --> 00:55:15.111
SO MUCH FOR ALLOWING ME TO
00:55:15.178 --> 00:55:17.080
PRESENT A. B. ELEVEN EIGHTY FOUR
00:55:17.147 --> 00:55:17.614
TODAY.
00:55:17.681 --> 00:55:18.982
I TO START BY THANKING THE CHAIR
00:55:19.049 --> 00:55:20.583
COMMITTEE STAFF AND STAKEHOLDERS
00:55:20.650 --> 00:55:22.252
FOR THEIR TIME ATTENTION. TO
00:55:22.318 --> 00:55:23.219
THIS BILL THE THOUGHTFUL
00:55:23.286 --> 00:55:24.554
COMMENTS THE CONSIDERATIONS
00:55:24.621 --> 00:55:26.089
BROUGHT BY MY OFFICE HAVE BEEN.
00:55:26.156 --> 00:55:27.390
BROUGHT TO MY OFFICE HAVE
00:55:27.457 --> 00:55:28.925
BENEFITTED THIS BILL IN THE
00:55:28.992 --> 00:55:29.693
TREMENDOUSLY THE MORNING THANK
00:55:29.759 --> 00:55:31.394
YOU HEY WE DO HAVE A MOTION AND
00:55:31.461 --> 00:55:33.063
A SECOND TEN TASTIC JUST VERY
00:55:33.129 --> 00:55:34.330
QUICKLY AB ELEVEN EIGHTY FOUR
00:55:34.397 --> 00:55:35.665
WILL REQUIRE PUBLIC AGENCIES TO
00:55:35.732 --> 00:55:36.566
RETAIN PUBLIC RECORDS.
00:55:36.633 --> 00:55:38.101
THAT ARE TRANSMITTED BY EMAIL
00:55:38.168 --> 00:55:39.469
FOR AT LEAST TWO YEARS THIS WILL
00:55:39.536 --> 00:55:40.937
CLARIFY EXISTING PUBLIC RECORD
00:55:41.004 --> 00:55:42.472
RETENTION Là AND BRING IT INTO
00:55:42.539 --> 00:55:43.673
THE TWENTY FIRST CENTURY.
00:55:43.740 --> 00:55:44.908
EMAILS OF COURSE AS YOU ON OUR
00:55:44.974 --> 00:55:46.276
CRITICAL CONDUCTING OUR DAILY
00:55:46.342 --> 00:55:47.510
BUSINESS I THINK IT'S
00:55:47.577 --> 00:55:48.845
APPROPRIATE TO SUGGEST THAT
00:55:48.912 --> 00:55:49.446
THEY'RE SOMEHOW DIFFERENT THE
00:55:49.512 --> 00:55:50.413
PAPER RECORDS.
00:55:50.480 --> 00:55:52.248
WE HAVE RECORDS WE HAVE --
00:55:52.315 --> 00:55:54.184
EXPERIENCES -- IN MY HOME COUNTY --
00:55:54.250 --> 00:55:56.619
OF LITIGATION AROUND THIS MATTER
00:55:56.686 --> 00:55:57.954
ARSENIO UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT
00:55:58.021 --> 00:55:59.389
RECENTLY A CELL TO EXPENSIVE
00:55:59.456 --> 00:56:00.590
LAWSUIT AFTER THEY APPROVED A
00:56:00.657 --> 00:56:02.258
POLICY WOULD ALLOW FOR THE
00:56:02.325 --> 00:56:03.827
DESTRUCTION OF EMAILS AFTER --
00:56:03.893 --> 00:56:05.729
IN MUCH LESS TIME THAN PROPOSED
00:56:05.795 --> 00:56:07.764
IN THIS BILL -- WITH ME THIS
00:56:07.831 --> 00:56:09.432
MORNING -- IS JIM YOUR COMPANY
00:56:09.499 --> 00:56:10.867
NEWSPAPER PUBLISHERS ASSOCIATION
00:56:10.934 --> 00:56:12.235
AS OUR WITNESS.
00:56:12.302 --> 00:56:13.403
THANK YOU AND THERE ARE
00:56:13.470 --> 00:56:14.404
AMENDMENTS THAT ARE LISTED IN
00:56:14.471 --> 00:56:15.705
THE ANALYSIS YOU'RE TAKING THOSE
00:56:15.772 --> 00:56:17.307
AUTHORS DISTRICTS THANK YOU SO
00:56:17.373 --> 00:56:18.475
MUCH.
00:56:18.541 --> 00:56:19.309
FIRST WITNESS PLEASE MISTER
00:56:19.375 --> 00:56:20.410
CHAIR MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE
00:56:20.477 --> 00:56:22.412
JIM YOU WORK FOR THE CALIFORNIA
00:56:22.479 --> 00:56:23.913
NEWS PUBLISHERS ASSOCIATION --
00:56:23.980 --> 00:56:28.151
WE STRONGLY SUPPORT THIS BILL --
00:56:28.218 --> 00:56:28.852
WE THINK THAT THERE IS A NEED TO
00:56:28.918 --> 00:56:30.520
CREATE MINIMUM STANDARDS THAT
00:56:30.587 --> 00:56:32.889
APPLY STATEWIDE AND DON'T LEAVE
00:56:32.956 --> 00:56:34.157
IT UP TO THE DISCRETION OF EACH
00:56:34.224 --> 00:56:36.126
AGENCY IN AN AREA THAT IS
00:56:36.192 --> 00:56:37.360
SOMEWHAT UNCLEAR.
00:56:37.427 --> 00:56:39.696
WITH REGARD TO THE INFORMATION
00:56:39.763 --> 00:56:40.930
THAT HAS TO BE RETAINED.
00:56:40.997 --> 00:56:42.198
AS THE SOME LIMóN POINTED OUT
00:56:42.265 --> 00:56:44.000
THERE HAVE BEEN INSTANCES WHEN
00:56:44.067 --> 00:56:50.507
RECORDS HAVE BEEN DESTROYED --
00:56:50.573 --> 00:56:53.109
THIRTY DAY PERIOD LET'S SAY --
00:56:53.176 --> 00:56:54.577
THAT'S INFORMATION THAT COULD BE
00:56:54.644 --> 00:56:56.813
USED BY THE PUBLIC TO LEARN
00:56:56.880 --> 00:56:59.249
ABOUT THE DEVELOPMENT OF POLICY
00:56:59.315 --> 00:57:00.650
ABOUT HOW.
00:57:00.717 --> 00:57:02.252
SOMETHING IS SHAPED IN A
00:57:02.318 --> 00:57:03.720
PARTICULAR COMMUNITY.
00:57:03.787 --> 00:57:06.089
WE THINK THIS IS A GOOD BILL AND
00:57:06.156 --> 00:57:07.490
WE STRONGLY YOUR DRIVER.
00:57:07.557 --> 00:57:14.230
THANK YOU.
00:57:14.297 --> 00:57:16.800
ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT.
00:57:16.866 --> 00:57:17.367
ALL RIGHT SEEN THAT IS THEIR
00:57:17.433 --> 00:57:33.817
OPPOSITION -- CHAIR MEMBERS OF
00:57:33.883 --> 00:57:35.185
THE COMMITTEE UNTIL GIVEN FOR
00:57:35.251 --> 00:57:36.286
THE CALIFORNIA SPECIAL DISTRICTS
00:57:36.352 --> 00:57:38.188
ASSOCIATION I'D LIKE TO THINK
00:57:38.254 --> 00:57:39.489
THE THE AUTHOR FOR WORKING WITH
00:57:39.556 --> 00:57:40.790
US IN AND TRYING TO NARROW THE
00:57:40.857 --> 00:57:42.959
SCOPE OF THE BILL -- AT THIS
00:57:43.026 --> 00:57:44.327
TIME WE STILL BELIEVE IT'S A
00:57:44.394 --> 00:57:45.695
LITTLE TOO BROAD AND WILL
00:57:45.762 --> 00:57:47.964
ULTIMATELY LEAD TO US KEEPING.
00:57:48.031 --> 00:57:50.366
EVERY EMAIL THAT WE HAVE -- FOR
00:57:50.433 --> 00:57:52.936
TWO YEARS AND AND AGAIN THIS IS
00:57:53.002 --> 00:57:56.272
IN A THAT THIS BILL DOES NOT
00:57:56.339 --> 00:57:58.141
REQUIRE ANY NEW DISCLOSURES.
00:57:58.208 --> 00:57:59.943
IT DOESN'T REQUIRE -- PROVIDE
00:58:00.009 --> 00:58:02.278
ANY NEW EXEMPTIONS -- THIS IS A
00:58:02.345 --> 00:58:04.480
DATA STORAGE BILL THIS IS A WE
00:58:04.547 --> 00:58:06.683
HAVE TO KEEP -- THESE EMAILS AND
00:58:06.749 --> 00:58:08.585
AND THAT WOULD BE -- MEN EMAIL
00:58:08.651 --> 00:58:11.287
CHAIN WHERE YOU'VE GOT IN A
00:58:11.354 --> 00:58:12.388
FIFTEEN PEOPLE RESPONDING TO AN
00:58:12.455 --> 00:58:14.557
EMAIL IT'S NOT THE LAST EMAIL
00:58:14.624 --> 00:58:16.125
THAT HAS THE RECORD OF ALL OF
00:58:16.192 --> 00:58:17.427
THE EMAILS THAT WE HAVE TO KEEP.
00:58:17.493 --> 00:58:19.128
IT ALL OF THE FIFTEEN RESPONSES
00:58:19.195 --> 00:58:20.029
AS WELL.
00:58:20.096 --> 00:58:21.598
AND SO WHAT THIS IS GOING TO DO
00:58:21.664 --> 00:58:23.700
IS COST ARE A PUBLIC AGENCIES
00:58:23.766 --> 00:58:25.268
MORE MONEY AS FAR AS THE THE
00:58:25.335 --> 00:58:26.603
DATA STORAGE NOW.
00:58:26.669 --> 00:58:27.971
HI I APPRECIATE WHAT THE
00:58:28.037 --> 00:58:29.239
ASSEMBLY MEMBER IS GETTING AT
00:58:29.305 --> 00:58:30.340
AND I THINK THAT WE CAN CONTINUE
00:58:30.406 --> 00:58:32.108
TO WORK TOGETHER TO TRY AND FIND
00:58:32.175 --> 00:58:34.143
SOME SORT OF RESOLUTION. ONE OF
00:58:34.210 --> 00:58:35.612
THE OTHER ISSUES IS THIS --
00:58:35.678 --> 00:58:37.714
RETENTION REQUIREMENT AS POINTED
00:58:37.780 --> 00:58:39.816
OUT THE ANALYSIS IS IN THE
00:58:39.883 --> 00:58:41.484
CALIFORNIA PUBLIC RECORDS ACT
00:58:41.551 --> 00:58:43.219
RATHER THAN ANOTHER SECTION THE
00:58:43.286 --> 00:58:43.887
GOVERNMENT CODE.
00:58:43.953 --> 00:58:45.321
AND ESSENTIALLY WHAT THAT DOES
00:58:45.388 --> 00:58:46.389
IS THAT CIRCUMVENTS THE
00:58:46.456 --> 00:58:48.157
REIMBURSEMENT PROCESS FOR PUBLIC
00:58:48.224 --> 00:58:49.659
AGENCIES THERE'S NO OTHER
00:58:49.726 --> 00:58:50.894
RETENTION REQUIREMENTS.
00:58:50.960 --> 00:58:52.395
IN THE CALIFORNIA PUBLIC RECORDS
00:58:52.462 --> 00:58:53.563
ACT THEIR OTHER PLACES IN THE
00:58:53.630 --> 00:58:55.265
GOVERNMENT CODE AND SO WE WOULD
00:58:55.331 --> 00:58:56.766
SUGGEST THAT THIS IF IF IT'S
00:58:56.833 --> 00:58:58.201
GOING TO MOVE FORWARD BE MOVED
00:58:58.268 --> 00:58:59.035
FROM THE CALIFORNIA PUBLIC
00:58:59.102 --> 00:59:00.036
RECORDS ACT.
00:59:00.103 --> 00:59:02.071
INTO THE GOVERNMENT COAT -- AND
00:59:02.138 --> 00:59:03.539
HOPEFULLY THAT THAT WILL ALLOW
00:59:03.606 --> 00:59:04.774
OUR AGENCIES THAT DO EXPERIENCE
00:59:04.841 --> 00:59:06.576
CERTAIN COSTS THAT ARE ELIGIBLE
00:59:06.643 --> 00:59:09.212
FOR YOUR REIMBURSEMENT WILL BE
00:59:09.279 --> 00:59:11.714
ABLE TO SEEK THOSE COSTS.
00:59:11.781 --> 00:59:14.050
AND WITH THAT -- THANK YOU.
00:59:14.117 --> 00:59:14.550
THANK YOU ANYONE ELSE IN
00:59:14.617 --> 00:59:16.486
OPPOSITION.
00:59:16.552 --> 00:59:17.287
THE MORNING ADJACENT BRIAN I'LL
00:59:17.353 --> 00:59:18.521
BE HAVE THE CALIFORNIA DOWNTOWN
00:59:18.588 --> 00:59:20.056
ASSOCIATION REPRESENTING
00:59:20.123 --> 00:59:20.757
CALIFORNIA'S BUSINESS
00:59:20.823 --> 00:59:21.891
IMPROVEMENT DISTRICTS APPRECIATE
00:59:21.958 --> 00:59:23.993
THE AUTHOR OR WORKING WITH US ON
00:59:24.060 --> 00:59:25.929
AMENDMENTS CONTINUES TO WORK
00:59:25.995 --> 00:59:27.497
WITH YOU OF MOVING FORWARD.
00:59:27.563 --> 00:59:29.732
WE ARE CONCERNED ABOUT COSTS AND
00:59:29.799 --> 00:59:33.736
BEFORE NEXT UPS THANK YOU.
00:59:33.803 --> 00:59:35.505
I GIVE ANYONE ELSE IN OPPOSITION.
00:59:35.571 --> 00:59:36.439
GOOD MORNING CARA CROSS ON
00:59:36.506 --> 00:59:37.840
BEHALF OF DOWNTOWN CENTER
00:59:37.907 --> 00:59:39.409
BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT
00:59:39.475 --> 00:59:41.244
WHICH YOU'RE LOOKING FORWARD --
00:59:41.311 --> 00:59:42.245
TO WORKING WITH AUTHOR OF
00:59:42.312 --> 00:59:44.414
CURRENTLY WE OPPOSE BUT WE'RE
00:59:44.480 --> 00:59:44.981
OPTIMISTIC THANK YOU
00:59:45.048 --> 00:59:45.281
[inaudible]
00:59:45.348 --> 00:59:47.317
THANK YOU.
00:59:47.383 --> 00:59:48.451
ANYONE ELSE IN OPPOSITION SEEING
00:59:48.518 --> 00:59:50.219
NONE BRING BACK TO THE COMMITTEE
00:59:50.286 --> 00:59:52.689
QUESTIONS COMMENTS.
00:59:52.755 --> 00:59:55.692
RIGHT SIGNAL. TO GLORY MIKLOS.
00:59:55.758 --> 00:59:56.459
TWENTY NINETEEN MISTER IT'S TIME
00:59:56.526 --> 00:59:58.161
TO UPDATE THIS AND CLARIFY -- I
00:59:58.227 --> 00:59:59.295
WOULD SAID ASSEMBLY SUGGESTS
00:59:59.362 --> 01:00:00.663
THAT THE REDUCTION LITIGATION
01:00:00.730 --> 01:00:02.432
MAY ACTUALLY MORE THAN MAKE UP
01:00:02.498 --> 01:00:04.500
FOR THE DIFFERENCE IN STORAGE.
01:00:04.567 --> 01:00:05.668
AND I PERCENT GAS FOR EITHER.
01:00:05.735 --> 01:00:06.602
THANK YOU.
01:00:06.669 --> 01:00:07.804
WE DO HAVE A MOTION AND A SECOND
01:00:07.870 --> 01:00:09.539
MOTION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED TO
01:00:09.605 --> 01:00:10.440
APPROPRIATIONS CALL THE ROLL
01:00:10.506 --> 01:00:12.308
PLEASE STONE BY STONE AYE
01:00:12.375 --> 01:00:13.810
GALLAGHER CHOW.
01:00:13.876 --> 01:00:16.179
CHOW I CHIU GONZALEZ.
01:00:16.245 --> 01:00:18.948
GONZALEZ I HOLDEN KALRA.
01:00:19.015 --> 01:00:21.217
KALRA AYE KILEY.
01:00:21.284 --> 01:00:23.219
MAIENSCHEIN.
01:00:23.286 --> 01:00:25.021
MAIENSCHEIN I OBERNOLTE
01:00:25.088 --> 01:00:27.457
OBERNOLTE NO PETRIE-NORRIS.
01:00:27.523 --> 01:00:29.559
PETRIE-NORRIS I RATE THIS.
01:00:29.625 --> 01:00:34.163
RACE I BUT I WAS OUT BIG CHEVY
01:00:34.230 --> 01:00:34.964
SO MUCH.
01:00:35.031 --> 01:00:37.600
RIGHT MR SANTIAGO THAT NOW TAKE
01:00:37.667 --> 01:00:38.634
SAYS.
01:00:38.701 --> 01:00:49.212
ITEM NUMBER NINETEEN AB.
01:00:49.278 --> 01:00:49.746
SIXTEEN SIXTY SEVEN OF THE
01:00:49.812 --> 01:00:50.847
ELECTRONIC RECORD.
01:00:50.913 --> 01:00:52.548
THAT IS ITEM TWENTY SIX THANK
01:00:52.615 --> 01:00:53.182
YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN OF YOU'VE
01:00:53.249 --> 01:00:54.250
WORKED ON THIS WITH US FOR A
01:00:54.317 --> 01:00:58.054
COUPLE OF YEARS AND WERE --
01:00:58.121 --> 01:00:58.821
APPRECIATIVE OF THAT.
01:00:58.888 --> 01:00:59.756
WE ACCEPT THE COMMITTEE
01:00:59.822 --> 01:01:01.758
AMENDMENTS AND IN SHORT AS YOU
01:01:01.824 --> 01:01:03.960
KNOW AB SIXTEEN SIXTY SEVEN
01:01:04.027 --> 01:01:04.994
WOULD RECOGNIZE OUT OF STATE
01:01:05.061 --> 01:01:06.729
ELECTRONIC WILL WILLS THAT MEET
01:01:06.796 --> 01:01:09.365
SPECIFIC CRITERIA WILL CONTINUE
01:01:09.432 --> 01:01:11.200
TO WORK WITH YOU.
01:01:11.267 --> 01:01:11.601
HI IN THE SESSION.
01:01:11.667 --> 01:01:13.369
THANK YOU.
01:01:13.436 --> 01:01:14.604
THANK YOU WE DO HAVE A MOTION
01:01:14.670 --> 01:01:16.139
AND A SECOND.
01:01:16.205 --> 01:01:17.273
WAS WITH US PLEASE I MISSED
01:01:17.340 --> 01:01:18.141
CHAIR -- MEMBERS OF THE
01:01:18.207 --> 01:01:19.976
COMMITTEE MARKUP PRAY I'M HERE
01:01:20.043 --> 01:01:22.045
ON BEHALF OF LEGALZOOM WE WANT
01:01:22.111 --> 01:01:23.846
TO THANK THE AUTHOR FOR
01:01:23.913 --> 01:01:25.848
INTRODUCING THIS MEASURE -- THE
01:01:25.915 --> 01:01:29.218
STAFF FOR WORKING WITH US -- AND
01:01:29.285 --> 01:01:32.822
AS THE AS THEY BUILD AS PROPOSED
01:01:32.889 --> 01:01:34.957
TO BE AMENDED BY THE BY THE
01:01:35.024 --> 01:01:38.895
COMMITTEE -- WOULD -- RECOGNIZE
01:01:38.961 --> 01:01:40.596
OUT OF STATE ELECTRONIC WILLS
01:01:40.663 --> 01:01:42.165
I'LL JUST POINT OUT THAT.
01:01:42.231 --> 01:01:44.801
THIS WEEKEND -- THE UNIFORM WALK
01:01:44.867 --> 01:01:47.003
COMMISSION WILL BE MEETING FOR
01:01:47.070 --> 01:01:49.072
THE FINAL TIME -- TO REVIEW
01:01:49.138 --> 01:01:51.441
THEIR PROPOSAL -- WE ALSO ARE
01:01:51.507 --> 01:01:53.309
ARE WELL AWARE THAT OTHER STATES
01:01:53.376 --> 01:01:55.878
HAVE ADOPTED ELECTRONIC WILLS
01:01:55.945 --> 01:01:57.847
AND THAT PEOPLE ARE UTILIZING --
01:01:57.914 --> 01:01:59.148
ELECTRONIC MEANS OF CREATING
01:01:59.215 --> 01:02:00.616
WILLS AND WE LOOK FORWARD TO
01:02:00.683 --> 01:02:01.951
WORKING WITH THE COMMITTEE TO
01:02:02.018 --> 01:02:03.920
DEVISING A STANDARD THAT CAN BE
01:02:03.986 --> 01:02:06.789
APPLICABLE IN CALIFORNIA WE URGE
01:02:06.856 --> 01:02:07.390
AYE VOTE THANK YOU.
01:02:07.457 --> 01:02:13.196
THANK YOU ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT.
01:02:13.262 --> 01:02:13.729
I'D SING NONE IS THERE ANY
01:02:13.796 --> 01:02:17.366
OPPOSITION.
01:02:17.433 --> 01:02:19.001
AT NOT OPPOSITE TO TURN MEMBERS
01:02:19.068 --> 01:02:20.336
CAN PLAN FOR THE JUDICIAL
01:02:20.403 --> 01:02:21.337
COUNCIL.
01:02:21.404 --> 01:02:22.472
WE'VE HAD GOOD PRODUCTIVE
01:02:22.538 --> 01:02:23.773
CONVERSATIONS WITH THE OTHER
01:02:23.840 --> 01:02:25.408
STAFF AND COMMITTEE STAFF ON
01:02:25.475 --> 01:02:27.543
THIS ISSUE -- THE ISSUE OF
01:02:27.610 --> 01:02:28.711
ELECTRONIC WILL THIS VERY
01:02:28.778 --> 01:02:30.980
COMPLEX AS WAS MENTIONED THE
01:02:31.047 --> 01:02:31.781
UNIFORM Là COMMISSION IS
01:02:31.848 --> 01:02:32.982
STUDYING AT THERE'S A VARIETY OF
01:02:33.049 --> 01:02:34.517
DIFFERENT VIEWS OUT THERE.
01:02:34.584 --> 01:02:35.618
WE LOOK FORWARD TO CONTINUING TO
01:02:35.685 --> 01:02:37.487
WORK COOPERATIVELY WITH AUTHOR
01:02:37.553 --> 01:02:39.322
SPONSOR COMMITTEE STAFF AND ALL
01:02:39.388 --> 01:02:41.557
THE OTHER STAKEHOLDERS MOVING
01:02:41.624 --> 01:02:42.158
FORWARD THANK YOU [inaudible]
01:02:42.225 --> 01:02:44.026
THANK YOU.
01:02:44.093 --> 01:02:45.027
ANYONE ELSE ERIN RUBBER ON
01:02:45.094 --> 01:02:46.395
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA JUDGES
01:02:46.462 --> 01:02:47.997
ASSOCIATION AND JUST NEAR THE
01:02:48.064 --> 01:02:49.499
SAME COMMENTS AS THE JUDICIAL
01:02:49.565 --> 01:02:50.833
COUNCIL AND THANK THE AUTHOR AND
01:02:50.900 --> 01:02:52.368
THE COMMITTEE FOR INCLUDING US
01:02:52.435 --> 01:02:53.369
IN THE DISCUSSIONS.
01:02:53.436 --> 01:02:54.904
THANK YOU THANK YOU ANYONE ELSE
01:02:54.971 --> 01:02:59.275
IN OPPOSITION OR TO YOU IN
01:02:59.342 --> 01:03:00.676
DISCUSSION SO ALL RIGHT SEE NONE
01:03:00.743 --> 01:03:02.111
BRING BACK TO THE COMMITTEE.
01:03:02.178 --> 01:03:03.713
THANK YOU MISTER SANTIAGO FOR
01:03:03.779 --> 01:03:04.514
WORKING WITH US.
01:03:04.580 --> 01:03:06.048
THAT ONE OF THE CHALLENGES
01:03:06.115 --> 01:03:06.916
THERE'S THERE'S THIS GREAT
01:03:06.983 --> 01:03:09.685
NOTION OF OF WANTING TO USE
01:03:09.752 --> 01:03:11.854
TECHNOLOGY TO REPLACE.
01:03:11.921 --> 01:03:12.989
TRADITIONS AND AND LEGAL
01:03:13.055 --> 01:03:14.223
STRUCTURE THEY'VE BEEN BUILT UP
01:03:14.290 --> 01:03:15.825
OVER THE YEARS IN PAPER AND I'LL
01:03:15.892 --> 01:03:17.393
TELL YOU FOR ONE I AM VERY
01:03:17.460 --> 01:03:19.462
SUPPORTIVE OF THAT.
01:03:19.529 --> 01:03:20.296
BUT IT DOESN'T ALWAYS TRANSLATE
01:03:20.363 --> 01:03:20.596
[inaudible]
01:03:20.663 --> 01:03:22.098
PAPER.
01:03:22.165 --> 01:03:24.233
INTO ELECTRONICS AND AS WE DO
01:03:24.300 --> 01:03:25.568
THAT MAKING SURE THAT WE ARE
01:03:25.635 --> 01:03:26.502
PROTECTING.
01:03:26.569 --> 01:03:28.871
THE IN THIS CASE THE INTENT OF
01:03:28.938 --> 01:03:31.207
THE THE CREATOR OF THE WILL AND
01:03:31.274 --> 01:03:32.742
THOSE PROCESS IS WHAT WE NEED TO
01:03:32.808 --> 01:03:34.277
DO TO MAKE SURE WE DO.
01:03:34.343 --> 01:03:36.078
SO THAT THE SYSTEM HAS A WAY TO
01:03:36.145 --> 01:03:38.114
TO MANAGE SO I I THINK THIS IS A
01:03:38.181 --> 01:03:39.482
VERY GOOD ISSUE I WANNA MAKE
01:03:39.549 --> 01:03:41.050
SURE WE FIND A WAY. TO
01:03:41.117 --> 01:03:42.485
ACCOMPLISH IS BECAUSE THIS IS
01:03:42.552 --> 01:03:44.086
WHERE WE'RE GOING -- BUT MAKE
01:03:44.153 --> 01:03:46.322
SURE THAT THAT WE'RE DOING IT IN
01:03:46.389 --> 01:03:47.823
A WAY THAT THAT WE ARE
01:03:47.890 --> 01:03:49.859
PRESERVING THE EVIDENCE
01:03:49.926 --> 01:03:51.394
PRESERVING THE STRUCTURE.
01:03:51.460 --> 01:03:53.296
THAT'S REALLY WHAT THE CONCERN
01:03:53.362 --> 01:03:54.897
IS SO WE WE WILL GET THERE.
01:03:54.964 --> 01:03:58.868
THIS RACE. TO SHARE -- THAT
01:03:58.935 --> 01:04:01.737
CONCERNED -- MISTER CHAIR RIGHT
01:04:01.804 --> 01:04:04.941
BY I DON'T KNOW IF THERE WILL BE
01:04:05.007 --> 01:04:07.143
LIMITATIONS ON THIS AT A FUTURE
01:04:07.210 --> 01:04:08.911
DATE FOUR WHEELS OF PARTICULAR
01:04:08.978 --> 01:04:10.146
VALUE.
01:04:10.213 --> 01:04:11.981
A SIMPLE WILLS AS OPPOSED TO
01:04:12.048 --> 01:04:13.449
VERY COMPLICATED WILLS.
01:04:13.516 --> 01:04:15.585
I THINK BEING ABLE TO TALK TO
01:04:15.651 --> 01:04:17.520
THE PERSON.
01:04:17.587 --> 01:04:18.888
BEING ABLE.
01:04:18.955 --> 01:04:20.289
TO TO CONFIRM THEIR THEIR
01:04:20.356 --> 01:04:23.759
INTENTIONS BUT I I AM.
01:04:23.826 --> 01:04:25.661
CERTAIN THAT THAT TO THE AUTHOR
01:04:25.728 --> 01:04:27.597
WILL BE LOOKING AT THE
01:04:27.663 --> 01:04:29.265
PROTECTIONS OF ALL OF THOSE.
01:04:29.332 --> 01:04:31.133
WHO WILL BE INVOLVED IN SUCH A
01:04:31.200 --> 01:04:33.502
WILL?
01:04:33.569 --> 01:04:33.936
THAT WILL BE SIGNED
01:04:34.003 --> 01:04:35.738
ELECTRONICALLY.
01:04:35.805 --> 01:04:36.672
MISTER CHAIRMAN I RESPOND.
01:04:36.739 --> 01:04:38.074
PLACE YEAH BUT WE'RE ALSO
01:04:38.140 --> 01:04:39.742
CONCERNED ABOUT THOSE ARE THOSE --
01:04:39.809 --> 01:04:41.244
ISSUES AND COMMENTS AND WE WOULD
01:04:41.310 --> 01:04:42.211
AGREE WITH THE CHAIR THIS IS WHY
01:04:42.278 --> 01:04:43.512
WE'VE TAKEN OUR TIME OVER THE
01:04:43.579 --> 01:04:46.148
LAST COUPE OF YEARS AND YEAH
01:04:46.215 --> 01:04:47.416
THIS IS A PLACE THAT MOVES VERY
01:04:47.483 --> 01:04:48.718
QUICKLY IN IN EVEN IN THIS%
01:04:48.784 --> 01:04:50.853
SITUATION WE DECIDED TO TAKE THE
01:04:50.920 --> 01:04:51.854
LONG ROAD IN.
01:04:51.921 --> 01:04:53.856
AND EVEN TABLE BILLS IN THE PAST
01:04:53.923 --> 01:04:55.424
WE CAN GET IT RIGHT I MEAN THIS
01:04:55.491 --> 01:04:56.626
IS IMPORTANT AND WE IN A WEEK
01:04:56.692 --> 01:04:58.594
KNOWLEDGE -- POTENTIAL ABUSES
01:04:58.661 --> 01:04:59.829
WHICH IS WHY WE'RE TAKING OUR
01:04:59.895 --> 01:05:01.063
TIME WILL CONTINUE TO WORK WITH
01:05:01.130 --> 01:05:02.164
THE CHAIR HOPEFULLY WE GET DONE
01:05:02.231 --> 01:05:04.300
THIS YEAR I'M OPTIMISTIC -- BUT
01:05:04.367 --> 01:05:05.868
IF NOT WE'RE NOT LOOKING -- FOR
01:05:05.935 --> 01:05:09.305
SOME SORT OF RAM JOB ON THIS
01:05:09.372 --> 01:05:09.939
EITHER I MEAN WE WANT TO GET IT
01:05:10.006 --> 01:05:11.140
DONE RIGHT.
01:05:11.207 --> 01:05:12.141
THANK YOU OTHER QUESTIONS
01:05:12.208 --> 01:05:13.776
COMMENTS IT'S AN EVERYDAY THAT
01:05:13.843 --> 01:05:15.144
MISTER SANTIAGO YES WE I THINK
01:05:15.211 --> 01:05:16.579
WE WE WILL DEFINITELY BE ABLE TO
01:05:16.646 --> 01:05:18.147
GET THIS SORTED OUT BUT IT'S
01:05:18.214 --> 01:05:19.181
GOOD.
01:05:19.248 --> 01:05:19.782
I THINK TAKE A LITTLE BIT OF
01:05:19.849 --> 01:05:20.850
EVERY SHAPE YOUR YOUR PATIENCE
01:05:20.916 --> 01:05:21.717
YOU'VE BEEN WORKING ON THIS BUT
01:05:21.784 --> 01:05:22.752
IN THE END I THINK YOU'RE GONNA
01:05:22.818 --> 01:05:25.054
HAVE A GREAT WORK PRODUCT.
01:05:25.121 --> 01:05:25.488
THAT REALLY SUPPORTS
01:05:25.554 --> 01:05:27.023
CALIFORNIANS.
01:05:27.089 --> 01:05:28.291
ALL RIGHT SEE NOTHING ELSE WAS
01:05:28.357 --> 01:05:30.526
UNDERGOING A CLOSE NOT RESPECT
01:05:30.593 --> 01:05:31.661
WESTERN AYE VOTE.
01:05:31.727 --> 01:05:32.561
THANK YOU WE DO HAVE A MOTION A
01:05:32.628 --> 01:05:34.030
SECOND MOTIONS TO PASS AS
01:05:34.096 --> 01:05:35.431
AMENDED TO APPROPRIATIONS CALL
01:05:35.498 --> 01:05:36.832
THE ROLL PLEASE STONE BY STONE
01:05:36.899 --> 01:05:38.467
AYE GALLAGHER.
01:05:38.534 --> 01:05:39.835
GALLAGHER I CHAU.
01:05:39.902 --> 01:05:41.070
CHIU.
01:05:41.137 --> 01:05:44.507
GONZALEZ GONZALEZ I HOLDEN KALRA.
01:05:44.573 --> 01:05:48.678
KALRA AYE KILEY MAIENSCHEIN.
01:05:48.744 --> 01:05:50.246
MAIENSCHEIN I OBERNOLTE
01:05:50.313 --> 01:05:51.681
OBERNOLTE I PETRIE-NORRIS.
01:05:51.747 --> 01:05:54.216
PETRIE-NORRIS I REYES HI RES
01:05:54.283 --> 01:05:55.851
SIDE.
01:05:55.918 --> 01:05:56.485
THE BILL IS OUT SICK THANK YOU
01:05:56.552 --> 01:05:57.520
SO MUCH MISTER BLOOM THANK YOU
01:05:57.586 --> 01:05:58.754
FOR BEING PATIENT.
01:05:58.821 --> 01:06:09.398
ITEM NUMBER TWENTY AB -- SIXTEEN
01:06:09.465 --> 01:06:16.772
SEVENTY TWO ITEM.
01:06:16.839 --> 01:06:17.440
TWENTY SEVEN GOOD MORNING MISTER
01:06:17.506 --> 01:06:19.642
CHAIR AND MEMBERS AND NOW FOR
01:06:19.709 --> 01:06:22.044
SOMETHING A LITTLE DIFFERENT.
01:06:22.111 --> 01:06:25.581
AB -- SIXTEEN SEVENTY TWO IS A
01:06:25.648 --> 01:06:27.049
BILL THAT IS INTENDED TO PROVIDE
01:06:27.116 --> 01:06:28.684
CLEAR CONSUMER INFORMATION ABOUT
01:06:28.751 --> 01:06:30.152
HOW CONSUMERS SHOULD PROPERLY
01:06:30.219 --> 01:06:33.189
DISPOSE OF SINGLE USE WET WIPES.
01:06:33.255 --> 01:06:34.657
PRODUCTS WITH THE ATTENTIVE
01:06:34.724 --> 01:06:36.826
KEEPING NON DISPERSIBLE WIPES
01:06:36.892 --> 01:06:38.327
OUT OF THE SEWER SYSTEM.
01:06:38.394 --> 01:06:39.061
BOB.
01:06:39.128 --> 01:06:40.963
THIS IS TOILET PAPER THAT WAS
01:06:41.030 --> 01:06:42.732
PLACED IN THIS JAR THIS MORNING
01:06:42.798 --> 01:06:45.134
AND YOU CAN SEE HOW IT'S ALREADY
01:06:45.201 --> 01:06:46.836
DISSOLVED INTO SMALL PIECES.
01:06:46.902 --> 01:06:50.005
THIS IS -- PERMISSION TO USE
01:06:50.072 --> 01:06:52.274
PROPS GRANTED.
01:06:52.341 --> 01:06:52.842
WITH YOUR PERMISSION MISTER
01:06:52.908 --> 01:06:54.810
CHAIR.
01:06:54.877 --> 01:06:55.878
YOU'RE JUST GONNA WANT TO HEAR
01:06:55.945 --> 01:06:57.646
THIS MISTER CHAIR -- THIS THIS
01:06:57.713 --> 01:07:01.183
IS -- TUG OF BOOZE KIDS WIPES --
01:07:01.250 --> 01:07:03.185
YOU CAN SEE IT'S STILL IN ONE
01:07:03.252 --> 01:07:03.986
PIECE THIS WOULD PLACE THE JAR
01:07:04.053 --> 01:07:05.921
BACK IN FEBRUARY THE BEGINNING
01:07:05.988 --> 01:07:08.224
OF FEBRUARY OF OF OF THIS YEAR
01:07:08.290 --> 01:07:10.226
AND THAT IN CAPSULE IT'S THE
01:07:10.292 --> 01:07:12.228
PROBLEM THAT WE'RE TRYING TO
01:07:12.294 --> 01:07:12.661
ADDRESS HERE WITH.
01:07:12.728 --> 01:07:14.029
WITH THIS BILL.
01:07:14.096 --> 01:07:15.097
THE FACT OF THE MATTER IS RIGHT
01:07:15.164 --> 01:07:16.966
NOW ANY COMPANY CAN CALL THEIR
01:07:17.032 --> 01:07:19.268
PRODUCT FLUSHABLE REGARDLESS OF
01:07:19.335 --> 01:07:21.003
THE POTENTIAL HARM TO THE SEWER
01:07:21.070 --> 01:07:22.805
SYSTEM OR WHETHER IT.
01:07:22.872 --> 01:07:26.108
TRULY BREAKS APART -- OF LIKE
01:07:26.175 --> 01:07:26.876
TOILET PAPER DOES.
01:07:26.942 --> 01:07:29.145
WHEN AND WHAT WHITE PRODUCTS ARE
01:07:29.211 --> 01:07:30.479
FLUSHED INTO THE SEWER SYSTEM
01:07:30.546 --> 01:07:31.847
THAT CAN CAUSE SIGNIFICANT
01:07:31.914 --> 01:07:33.716
ISSUES FOR PRIVATE PROPERTY
01:07:33.783 --> 01:07:35.050
OWNERS SEWER COLLECTIONS AND
01:07:35.117 --> 01:07:36.819
WASTE TREATMENT PLANTS AND IN
01:07:36.886 --> 01:07:39.188
FACT THAT'S EXACTLY WHAT WE'RE
01:07:39.255 --> 01:07:39.422
SEEING?
01:07:39.488 --> 01:07:41.457
OUT IN THE FIELD A SINGLE USE
01:07:41.524 --> 01:07:43.259
WET WIPES ARE HEAVIER THICKER
01:07:43.325 --> 01:07:44.326
AND HAVE LARGER SURFACE AREAS
01:07:44.393 --> 01:07:45.861
THAN TOILET PAPER AND
01:07:45.928 --> 01:07:47.196
RESEARCHERS HAVE FOUND THAT
01:07:47.263 --> 01:07:49.465
UNDER WHAT CONDITIONS WHITE.
01:07:49.532 --> 01:07:50.900
MAINTAIN MOST OF THEIR STRENGTH
01:07:50.966 --> 01:07:52.034
AS THEY ARE COMPOSED OF
01:07:52.101 --> 01:07:54.370
SYNTHETIC FIBERS THAT RETAIN
01:07:54.437 --> 01:07:55.571
THEIR SHAPE AND STRENGTH.
01:07:55.638 --> 01:07:58.474
THEY OFTEN DO NOT BREAK DOWN --
01:07:58.541 --> 01:07:59.875
FOR A LONG LONG TIME AFTER BEING
01:07:59.942 --> 01:08:02.611
FLUSHED AND CAN ACCUMULATE WITH
01:08:02.678 --> 01:08:04.180
FATS OILS AND GREASE.
01:08:04.246 --> 01:08:06.048
THAT BECOME LARGE OBSTRUCTIONS
01:08:06.115 --> 01:08:07.683
IN OUR PIPES AND TO HAVE EARNED
01:08:07.750 --> 01:08:11.687
THE DISGUSTING NAME OF FAT BERKS --
01:08:11.754 --> 01:08:13.355
FURTHER DOWN THE LINE THEY WEAVE
01:08:13.422 --> 01:08:15.291
TOGETHER AND THEY CAN CREATE
01:08:15.357 --> 01:08:20.329
GIANT RAGS -- THAT -- THEN CAN'T
01:08:20.396 --> 01:08:21.897
CATCH IN OUR PUMP SYSTEMS
01:08:21.964 --> 01:08:23.899
COLLECTION SYSTEMS AND MOTORS
01:08:23.966 --> 01:08:25.434
CAUSING BACKUPS AND EQUIPMENT
01:08:25.501 --> 01:08:27.670
FAILURES AND THIS IN FACT IS A
01:08:27.736 --> 01:08:28.871
PROBLEM THAT HAS BEEN
01:08:28.938 --> 01:08:30.940
EXPERIENCED ACROSS THE STATE.
01:08:31.006 --> 01:08:32.808
I COULD GIVE YOU EXAMPLES IN
01:08:32.875 --> 01:08:35.144
PETALUMA AN ORANGE COUNTY -- IN
01:08:35.211 --> 01:08:36.545
THE ORANGE COUNTY SANITATION
01:08:36.612 --> 01:08:39.615
DISTRICT OF THE CITY OF CAMERI --
01:08:39.682 --> 01:08:40.916
A WASTE WATER TREATMENT PLANT IT
01:08:40.983 --> 01:08:42.818
HAS INVESTED A HALF MILLION
01:08:42.885 --> 01:08:44.153
DOLLARS TO UPGRADE ITS WASTE
01:08:44.220 --> 01:08:49.492
WATER TREATMENT PLANT JUST TO
01:08:49.558 --> 01:08:50.693
DEAL WITH THIS ISSUE.
01:08:50.759 --> 01:08:51.894
IN EACH OF THESE CASES THE COST
01:08:51.961 --> 01:08:53.362
GETS PASSED ON TO RATE PAYERS
01:08:53.429 --> 01:08:54.296
NOT THE MANUFACTURERS OF THE
01:08:54.363 --> 01:08:55.698
WHITES THAT ARE ACTUALLY
01:08:55.764 --> 01:08:57.733
DAMAGING THE SYSTEMS AND SO THIS
01:08:57.800 --> 01:09:00.202
BILL SIMPLY PRESCRIBES CLEAR AND
01:09:00.269 --> 01:09:02.638
CONSISTENT CONSUMER MESSAGING.
01:09:02.705 --> 01:09:04.406
FOR THESE PRODUCTS SO THAT
01:09:04.473 --> 01:09:07.042
CONSUMERS LEARN WHAT GOES DOWN
01:09:07.109 --> 01:09:10.012
THE TOILET AND WHAT DOESN'T --
01:09:10.079 --> 01:09:12.815
AND THESE SHOULD NOT BE FLUSHED
01:09:12.882 --> 01:09:14.583
DOWN THE TOILET IT'S IT'S THAT
01:09:14.650 --> 01:09:16.218
SIMPLE SO UNDER THE PROVISIONS
01:09:16.285 --> 01:09:17.920
OF THE BILL WIFE CAN BE LABELED
01:09:17.987 --> 01:09:19.989
AS FLUSHABLE IF THE IF THEY DO
01:09:20.055 --> 01:09:21.857
NOT CAUSE HARM TO THE SEWER
01:09:21.924 --> 01:09:22.224
SYSTEM.
01:09:22.291 --> 01:09:24.460
MEANING THAT MANUFACTURERS WILL
01:09:24.527 --> 01:09:25.594
NEED TO DEMONSTRATE THAT THEIR
01:09:25.661 --> 01:09:27.062
WIVES CAN BREAK DOWN OF THE
01:09:27.129 --> 01:09:28.163
SEWER SYSTEM MUCH LIKE TRY
01:09:28.230 --> 01:09:31.600
TOILET PAPER FOR ALL OTHER WIPES
01:09:31.667 --> 01:09:32.368
THAT ARE NOT INTENDED TO BE
01:09:32.434 --> 01:09:33.035
FLUSHED.
01:09:33.102 --> 01:09:35.504
FELT BE MARKED DO NOT FLUSH IT'S
01:09:35.571 --> 01:09:37.873
VERY SIMPLE IT'S VERY LOGICAL.
01:09:37.940 --> 01:09:39.408
AND TESTIFYING IN SUPPORT OF THE
01:09:39.475 --> 01:09:41.610
BILL IS JESSICA GALLAGHER WITH
01:09:41.677 --> 01:09:44.680
THE CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
01:09:44.747 --> 01:09:46.549
SANITATION.
01:09:46.615 --> 01:09:47.349
THANK YOU FIRST WITNESS PLEASE
01:09:47.416 --> 01:09:48.317
GOOD MORNING CHAIRMAN STONE AND
01:09:48.384 --> 01:09:49.552
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE HOW I'M
01:09:49.618 --> 01:09:50.819
JUST C<c.cyan> AUGER WITH CALIFORNIA</c>
01:09:50.886 --> 01:09:52.154
ASSOCIATION OF SANITATION
01:09:52.221 --> 01:09:55.024
AGENCIES WERE THE SPONSOR BABY
01:09:55.090 --> 01:09:55.624
SIXTEEN SEVENTY TWO HERE TODAY
01:09:55.691 --> 01:09:56.559
AND STRONG SUPPORT.
01:09:56.625 --> 01:09:58.060
SINGLE USE WET WIPES THE BECOME
01:09:58.127 --> 01:09:59.395
WIDELY AVAILABLE TO CONSUMERS
01:09:59.461 --> 01:10:00.796
OVER THE LAST FIFTEEN OR TWENTY
01:10:00.863 --> 01:10:02.164
YEARS AND THERE'S A DIRECT
01:10:02.231 --> 01:10:03.299
CORRELATION WITH THE INCREASING
01:10:03.365 --> 01:10:05.000
POPULARITY.
01:10:05.067 --> 01:10:06.101
OF SINGLE USE WIPES PRODUCTS IN
01:10:06.168 --> 01:10:07.236
THE SIGNIFICANT PROBLEMS WE'RE
01:10:07.303 --> 01:10:08.804
SEEING IN THE SEWER SYSTEM WITH
01:10:08.871 --> 01:10:09.572
RAGGING.
01:10:09.638 --> 01:10:11.373
SOME MORE -- WIPES ARE MARKETED
01:10:11.440 --> 01:10:12.841
AS FLUSHABLE OTHERS ARE LABELED
01:10:12.908 --> 01:10:14.843
WITH DO NOT FLUSH DIRECTIONS OR
01:10:14.910 --> 01:10:16.412
NOT LABELED WITH ANY DISPOSAL
01:10:16.478 --> 01:10:17.947
INDICATIONS AT ALL.
01:10:18.013 --> 01:10:19.415
BECAUSE OF THIS INCONSISTENCY IN
01:10:19.481 --> 01:10:20.883
LABELING PRACTICES AND BECAUSE
01:10:20.950 --> 01:10:22.451
MOST OF THESE WIPES LOOK AND
01:10:22.518 --> 01:10:24.119
FEEL THE SAME.
01:10:24.186 --> 01:10:25.354
THE RESULT IS AN ONSLAUGHT OF
01:10:25.421 --> 01:10:26.322
WHITE SEEING FLUSHED DOWN THE
01:10:26.388 --> 01:10:28.023
DRAIN -- BOTH WIPES THAT ARE
01:10:28.090 --> 01:10:29.959
LABELED AS POSSIBLE IN THE ART
01:10:30.025 --> 01:10:31.493
AND THE CAUSING MAJOR ISSUES.
01:10:31.560 --> 01:10:33.295
FOR SEWER SERVICE PROVIDERS --
01:10:33.362 --> 01:10:35.130
ONE WIPES GET INTO THE SYSTEM
01:10:35.197 --> 01:10:37.466
THEY WEAVE TOGETHER -- INFORMED
01:10:37.533 --> 01:10:38.934
LARGE BLANKETS AND WHEN THEY
01:10:39.001 --> 01:10:41.270
CATCH ON TO OTHER DEBRIS AND
01:10:41.337 --> 01:10:43.172
GREECE THEY FORM FAT BERKS.
01:10:43.238 --> 01:10:45.140
AND THESE ARE GIANT OBSTRUCTIONS
01:10:45.207 --> 01:10:46.775
THAT ARE MAJORLY DESTRUCTIVE FOR
01:10:46.842 --> 01:10:47.810
THE SYSTEM THINKING COST
01:10:47.876 --> 01:10:50.079
SANITARY SEWER OVERFLOWS.
01:10:50.145 --> 01:10:55.517
A SEWER SPILL OF ANY AMOUNT --
01:10:55.584 --> 01:10:56.118
IS A PUBLIC AN ENVIRONMENTAL
01:10:56.185 --> 01:10:57.453
HAZARD AND THE WATER BOARD HAS A
01:10:57.519 --> 01:10:58.020
ZERO TOLERANCE POLICY FIRST
01:10:58.087 --> 01:10:58.854
BILLS.
01:10:58.921 --> 01:11:00.656
SO FAR IN TWENTY NINETEEN THE
01:11:00.723 --> 01:11:01.690
WATER BOARD'S BILL DATABASE
01:11:01.757 --> 01:11:03.692
INDICATES THAT THERE BEEN AT
01:11:03.759 --> 01:11:05.194
EIGHTY SANITARY SEWER OVERFLOWS
01:11:05.260 --> 01:11:06.895
ATTRIBUTED TO RAGGING AND NON
01:11:06.962 --> 01:11:07.896
DISPERSIBLE.
01:11:07.963 --> 01:11:09.732
THAT'S FIFTY THOUSAND GALLONS --
01:11:09.798 --> 01:11:11.800
IN THIS YEAR ALONE THIRTY FIVE
01:11:11.867 --> 01:11:12.835
THOUSAND OF WHICH REACH SURFACE
01:11:12.901 --> 01:11:14.903
WATERS AND WERE SUBJECT TO
01:11:14.970 --> 01:11:16.238
ADMINISTRATIVE PENALTIES.
01:11:16.305 --> 01:11:17.506
AND THAT NUMBER DOESN'T ACCOUNT
01:11:17.573 --> 01:11:18.641
FOR THE OVERFLOW THAT PRIVATE
01:11:18.707 --> 01:11:20.409
RESIDENCES OR BUSINESSES THAT GO
01:11:20.476 --> 01:11:22.411
UNREPORTED.
01:11:22.478 --> 01:11:23.646
IN ADDITION TO OVERFLOWS ONE
01:11:23.712 --> 01:11:24.446
WIFE GET FURTHER DOWN IN THE
01:11:24.513 --> 01:11:26.281
SYSTEMS LARGE RAGS GET WRAPPED
01:11:26.348 --> 01:11:28.017
UP IN HEAVY MECHANICAL FEATURES
01:11:28.083 --> 01:11:29.418
OF THE SYSTEMS LIKE PUMPS.
01:11:29.485 --> 01:11:31.220
MOTORS AND SCREENS REQUIRING
01:11:31.286 --> 01:11:32.888
MANUAL REMOVAL OF DEBRIS AND
01:11:32.955 --> 01:11:34.156
ADDITIONAL MAINTENANCE OR
01:11:34.223 --> 01:11:35.758
REPLACEMENT OF THE STRUCTURES.
01:11:35.824 --> 01:11:37.092
ON THE CONSTANT REMEDIATION
01:11:37.159 --> 01:11:39.261
EFFORTS TO DISRUPT ALL STAGES OF
01:11:39.328 --> 01:11:41.163
TREATMENT THE TREATMENT PROCESS
01:11:41.230 --> 01:11:43.432
AND AS A RESULT -- AT RESULTING
01:11:43.499 --> 01:11:45.334
COSTS ON MANY LEVELS FOR PUBLIC
01:11:45.401 --> 01:11:47.102
AGENCIES AND ULTIMATELY ON
01:11:47.169 --> 01:11:48.971
REPAIRS -- ALSO WANT TO POINT
01:11:49.038 --> 01:11:50.539
OUT MANY WIPES LIKE BABY WIPES
01:11:50.606 --> 01:11:51.674
AND CLEANING WIPES ARE MADE OF
01:11:51.740 --> 01:11:53.075
PLASTIC AND WHEN THEIR FLESH
01:11:53.142 --> 01:11:55.444
IMPROPERLY THEY CAN CONTRIBUTE.
01:11:55.511 --> 01:11:57.813
TO LOADING MY IN WASTEWATER
01:11:57.880 --> 01:11:59.515
EFFLUENT -- THERE SIGNIFICANT
01:11:59.581 --> 01:12:01.283
TIME ENERGY ND PUBLIC MONEY
01:12:01.350 --> 01:12:02.751
BEING SPENT ON MASSIVE PUBLIC
01:12:02.818 --> 01:12:04.319
EDUCATION EFFORTS ABOUT THE
01:12:04.386 --> 01:12:05.754
PROBLEMS WITH FLUSHING WIPES.
01:12:05.821 --> 01:12:06.989
PRETTY MUCH EVERY AGENCY HAS
01:12:07.056 --> 01:12:08.590
DONE OUT REACH ABOUT WIPES FOR
01:12:08.657 --> 01:12:09.858
MANY YEARS AND WE'RE HERE TODAY
01:12:09.925 --> 01:12:11.460
BECAUSE EDUCATIONAL CAMPAIGN
01:12:11.527 --> 01:12:13.095
SIMPLY AREN'T EFFECTIVE ENOUGH
01:12:13.162 --> 01:12:14.496
AND MANAGING THIS PROBLEM.
01:12:14.563 --> 01:12:15.931
WE RECENTLY DID SOME POLLING ON
01:12:15.998 --> 01:12:17.332
THIS ISSUE IN THE BAY AREA AND
01:12:17.399 --> 01:12:18.934
BY A LARGE MARGIN IT WAS EVIDENT
01:12:19.001 --> 01:12:20.469
THAT CONSUMERS TRUST THE
01:12:20.536 --> 01:12:21.937
LABELING ON PACKAGES.
01:12:22.004 --> 01:12:23.305
AND THAT'S THE PREFERRED METHOD
01:12:23.372 --> 01:12:25.107
FOR RECEIVING INFORMATION ABOUT
01:12:25.174 --> 01:12:25.641
PROPER DISPOSAL OF THESE
01:12:25.708 --> 01:12:26.408
PRODUCTS.
01:12:26.475 --> 01:12:28.310
FAR AND ABOVE HEARING ABOUT IT
01:12:28.377 --> 01:12:30.145
FROM THEIR LOCAL SEWER UTILITY.
01:12:30.212 --> 01:12:31.213
ON THE PERFORMANCE METRICS FOR
01:12:31.280 --> 01:12:32.347
FLEXIBILITY IN THE BILL ARE
01:12:32.414 --> 01:12:33.649
BASED ON SCIENCE AND ACCURATELY
01:12:33.716 --> 01:12:35.517
REFLECT THE CONDITIONS IN THE
01:12:35.584 --> 01:12:36.952
SEWER ESPECIALLY THE SYSTEMS
01:12:37.019 --> 01:12:38.387
HERE IN CALIFORNIA WHERE THERE'S
01:12:38.454 --> 01:12:39.788
LESS TURBULENCE BECAUSE THE
01:12:39.855 --> 01:12:41.457
SUCCESSFUL WATER CONSERVATION
01:12:41.523 --> 01:12:42.024
EFFORTS.
01:12:42.091 --> 01:12:43.158
THE MEASURES WERE DEVELOPED BY
01:12:43.225 --> 01:12:44.727
AN INTERNATIONAL GROUP OF MORE
01:12:44.793 --> 01:12:46.028
THAN TWO HUNDRED PUBLIC WASTE
01:12:46.095 --> 01:12:46.929
WATER ENTITIES USING A
01:12:46.995 --> 01:12:48.630
SCIENTIFIC AN EVIDENCE BASED
01:12:48.697 --> 01:12:50.099
PROCESS WITH FEEDBACK FROM THE
01:12:50.165 --> 01:12:51.934
NON WOVEN FABRICS INDUSTRY.
01:12:52.000 --> 01:12:53.001
THE DO NOT FLESHLY BAND LABELING
01:12:53.068 --> 01:12:54.303
REQUIREMENT IS IN ACCORDANCE
01:12:54.369 --> 01:12:55.404
WITH THE VOLUNTARY INDUSTRY
01:12:55.471 --> 01:12:57.172
GUIDELINES THAT MANY OF THESE
01:12:57.239 --> 01:12:58.774
PRODUCTS ALREADY ABIDE BY.
01:12:58.841 --> 01:12:59.875
THE ENFORCEMENT PROVISIONS ARE
01:12:59.942 --> 01:13:00.909
REFLECTIVE OF OTHER SOURCE
01:13:00.976 --> 01:13:07.683
CONTROL LEGISLATION AND WE SHEET
01:13:07.750 --> 01:13:08.283
THE AMENDMENTS BEING DISCUSSED
01:13:08.350 --> 01:13:09.284
IN THE ANALYSIS THAT EXTEND OUT
01:13:09.351 --> 01:13:10.486
THE IMPLEMENTATION PERIOD TO
01:13:10.552 --> 01:13:11.987
GIVE MANUFACTURERS TIME TO COME
01:13:12.054 --> 01:13:14.456
INTO COMPLIANCE -- BOTTOM LINE
01:13:14.523 --> 01:13:16.525
WE'VE SPENT MANY YEARS --
01:13:16.592 --> 01:13:17.526
PROVIDING FEEDBACK TO THE
01:13:17.593 --> 01:13:19.661
MANUFACTURERS OF WET WIPES ABOUT
01:13:19.728 --> 01:13:20.162
THE PROBLEMS WE'VE BEEN
01:13:20.229 --> 01:13:21.497
EXPERIENCING.
01:13:21.563 --> 01:13:22.765
AND SUGGESTING CHANGES TO
01:13:22.831 --> 01:13:24.032
LABELING GUIDELINES WITH LITTLE
01:13:24.099 --> 01:13:26.135
SUCCESS SO WE FEEL IT'S TIME TO
01:13:26.201 --> 01:13:27.703
ADDRESS THIS PROBLEM AND THAT
01:13:27.770 --> 01:13:29.071
REQUIRING MANUFACTURERS TO
01:13:29.138 --> 01:13:30.105
PROVIDE CLEAR CONSUMER
01:13:30.172 --> 01:13:30.839
INFORMATION ABOUT THE
01:13:30.906 --> 01:13:32.474
APPROPRIATE DISPOSAL OF THESE
01:13:32.541 --> 01:13:33.442
PRODUCTS.
01:13:33.509 --> 01:13:34.343
IS A SENSIBLE AND MODERATE
01:13:34.409 --> 01:13:35.644
APPROACH SO FOR THESE REASONS
01:13:35.711 --> 01:13:36.845
WERE IN STRONG SUPPORT OF THE
01:13:36.912 --> 01:13:38.347
BILL AND WOULD URGE THE
01:13:38.413 --> 01:13:39.448
COMMITTEES I BUT WE HAVE CHAIRED
01:13:39.515 --> 01:13:41.049
BOSS GOAL OF A KATHY HERE TODAY
01:13:41.116 --> 01:13:42.751
TO PROVIDE TECHNICAL FEEDBACK IF
01:13:42.818 --> 01:13:43.519
NECESSARY AS WELL.
01:13:43.585 --> 01:13:46.622
AND A MISTER CHAIR I NEGLECTED
01:13:46.688 --> 01:13:47.523
TO OF ACTION OF THE TOTAL EXCEPT
01:13:47.589 --> 01:13:48.824
OF THE AMENDMENT SAID THAT THE
01:13:48.891 --> 01:13:51.460
COMMITTEE HAS RECOMMENDED.
01:13:51.527 --> 01:13:52.594
THANK YOU.
01:13:52.661 --> 01:13:53.695
THANK YOU RIGHT ANYONE ELSE IN
01:13:53.762 --> 01:13:56.965
SUPPORT.
01:13:57.032 --> 01:13:58.600
IF YOU COULD GIVE US YOUR NAME
01:13:58.667 --> 01:14:00.202
AND YOUR AFFILIATION PLEASE.
01:14:00.269 --> 01:14:01.403
SCHERING GREEN SANITATION
01:14:01.470 --> 01:14:03.138
DISTRICTS OF LOS ANGELES COUNTY
01:14:03.205 --> 01:14:05.340
HERE IN STRONG SUPPORT.
01:14:05.407 --> 01:14:06.875
JOHN LANDED ON BEHALF OF THE
01:14:06.942 --> 01:14:07.409
CITY OF WEST HOLLYWOOD IN
01:14:07.476 --> 01:14:10.279
SUPPORT.
01:14:10.345 --> 01:14:12.181
KILLER ROBINSON ON BEHALF
01:14:12.247 --> 01:14:14.383
EVERYTHING WASTE IN SUPPORT.
01:14:14.449 --> 01:14:16.051
ERIC O'DONNELL BEHALF THE ORANGE
01:14:16.118 --> 01:14:16.652
COUNTY SANITATION DISTRICT IN
01:14:16.718 --> 01:14:18.353
SUPPORT.
01:14:18.420 --> 01:14:19.855
STARSKY WAS ON BEHALF THE LESS
01:14:19.922 --> 01:14:21.056
BURGESS AND DEPUTY IN TRIUMPH
01:14:21.123 --> 01:14:22.524
WAS SANITATION DISTRICT IN
01:14:22.591 --> 01:14:25.260
SUPPORT AND ELSEWHERE VALLEY
01:14:25.327 --> 01:14:25.828
MUNICIPAL WATER DISTRICT IN
01:14:25.894 --> 01:14:27.529
SUPPORT.
01:14:27.596 --> 01:14:28.397
JASON OCCURRED WITH THAT'LL
01:14:28.463 --> 01:14:29.031
STAND GILBERT ROBESON SMITH ON
01:14:29.097 --> 01:14:30.065
BEHALF OF THE SAN FRANCISCO
01:14:30.132 --> 01:14:31.433
PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION ALSO
01:14:31.500 --> 01:14:34.002
IN SUPPORT.
01:14:34.069 --> 01:14:35.437
THE TICKETS WITH THE CITY OF
01:14:35.504 --> 01:14:38.807
ROSEVILLE ALSO IN SUPPORT.
01:14:38.874 --> 01:14:40.075
MY NAME IS LOUIS SQUARE FOR MY
01:14:40.142 --> 01:14:41.343
CALIFORNIA I'M A WATER TREATMENT
01:14:41.410 --> 01:14:43.345
PLANT OPERATOR AND I UNDERSTAND
01:14:43.412 --> 01:14:44.279
EVERYTHING THAT THEY'RE TALKING
01:14:44.346 --> 01:14:45.614
ABOUT. ONE OF THE THINGS I
01:14:45.681 --> 01:14:47.182
LEARNED WE'RE NOT TAKING FOR THE
01:14:47.249 --> 01:14:49.117
TESTIMONY I JUST EDUCATION I
01:14:49.184 --> 01:14:51.553
SUPPORT YES I SUPPORT THIS BILL
01:14:51.620 --> 01:14:53.355
THANK YOU.
01:14:53.422 --> 01:14:55.324
EMILY BARNETT STRONG SUPPORT FOR
01:14:55.390 --> 01:14:56.825
THE CENTRAL CONTRA COSTA
01:14:56.892 --> 01:14:59.294
SANITARY DISTRICT.
01:14:59.361 --> 01:15:00.729
ANGELA LARA DEL TO DOUBLE STRONG
01:15:00.796 --> 01:15:03.332
SUPPORT THANK YOU.
01:15:03.398 --> 01:15:04.766
JENNIFER WILLIAMS WITH THE EAST
01:15:04.833 --> 01:15:05.801
BAY MUNICIPAL UTILITY DISTRICT
01:15:05.868 --> 01:15:08.403
IN SUPPORT.
01:15:08.470 --> 01:15:09.972
DON'T GIVEN FOR THE CALIFORNIA
01:15:10.038 --> 01:15:10.606
SPECIAL DISTRICTS ASSOCIATION IN
01:15:10.672 --> 01:15:12.975
SUPPORT.
01:15:13.041 --> 01:15:13.876
GOOD MORNING BATH A LOSS ON
01:15:13.942 --> 01:15:15.244
BEHALF OF THE INLAND EMPIRE
01:15:15.310 --> 01:15:16.845
UTILITIES AGENCY ARE UP OR
01:15:16.912 --> 01:15:18.146
DIDN'T TAKE A POSITION TO AFTER
01:15:18.213 --> 01:15:20.282
YOUR LETTER DEADLINE SO WE'RE
01:15:20.349 --> 01:15:22.317
NOT ON YOUR HOUSES BUT IN STRONG
01:15:22.384 --> 01:15:24.486
SUPPORT THANK YOU.
01:15:24.553 --> 01:15:25.687
BORN COMMON SIERRA CLUB
01:15:25.754 --> 01:15:27.689
CALIFORNIANS STRONG SUPPORT.
01:15:27.756 --> 01:15:29.725
THANK YOU ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT.
01:15:29.791 --> 01:15:46.308
SEEING NONE IS THERE OPPOSITION
01:15:48.377 --> 01:15:48.443
.
01:15:48.443 --> 01:15:49.878
GOOD MORNING A CHAIR STONE IN
01:15:49.945 --> 01:15:51.280
MEMBERS CURSOR IS ON BEHALF OF
01:15:51.346 --> 01:15:53.081
INTO THE ASSOCIATION FOR NON
01:15:53.148 --> 01:15:54.783
WOVEN FABRICS INDUSTRY THANK YOU
01:15:54.850 --> 01:15:55.550
FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO PROVIDE
01:15:55.617 --> 01:15:58.353
TESTIMONY ON SIXTEEN SEVENTY TWO
01:15:58.420 --> 01:15:59.154
OUR INDUSTRY IS COMMITTED TO
01:15:59.221 --> 01:16:00.389
CONTINUE IMPROVING OUR WIPES
01:16:00.455 --> 01:16:01.623
PRODUCTS TO MEET THE
01:16:01.690 --> 01:16:03.325
EXPECTATIONS OF CONSUMERS WHILE
01:16:03.392 --> 01:16:04.626
MINIMIZING THE IMPACTS.
01:16:04.693 --> 01:16:06.662
OF WASTE WATER INFRASTRUCTURE IN
01:16:06.728 --> 01:16:08.330
THE ENVIRONMENT AND TO THAT END
01:16:08.397 --> 01:16:09.798
THE ONLY VIABLE SOLUTIONS TO THE
01:16:09.865 --> 01:16:11.667
PERSISTENT ISSUE OF WASTE WATER
01:16:11.733 --> 01:16:12.668
SYSTEM CLOGS.
01:16:12.734 --> 01:16:13.969
COME FROM SYSTEM STUDIES AND
01:16:14.036 --> 01:16:15.570
WHAT TRIBES CONSUMER DISPOSABLE
01:16:15.637 --> 01:16:17.005
BEHAVIOR WE'VE ALL SEEN THE
01:16:17.072 --> 01:16:19.074
PICTURES OF THE BIG UGLY CLOGS
01:16:19.141 --> 01:16:20.475
PULLED OUT OF SYSTEMS.
01:16:20.542 --> 01:16:22.210
MANY SUCH PICTURES APPEAR TO
01:16:22.277 --> 01:16:23.745
INVOLVE WIPES OR RACKING
01:16:23.812 --> 01:16:24.846
MATERIAL THAT ARE WIDELY
01:16:24.913 --> 01:16:27.549
REPORTED AS FLUSHABLE WIPES.
01:16:27.616 --> 01:16:28.817
HOWEVER AFTER SEVERAL FORENSIC
01:16:28.884 --> 01:16:30.419
ANALYSES OF ACCUMULATIONS AND
01:16:30.485 --> 01:16:32.187
CLOGS IN THE UNITED STATES AND
01:16:32.254 --> 01:16:34.089
U. K. MUNICIPAL SYSTEMS WE KNOW
01:16:34.156 --> 01:16:35.791
THAT MOSTLY THIS IS.
01:16:35.857 --> 01:16:37.426
A CASE OF MISTAKEN IDENTITY.
01:16:37.492 --> 01:16:38.493
THESE WASTEWATER COLLECTION
01:16:38.560 --> 01:16:39.628
STUDIES INDICATE THAT THE
01:16:39.695 --> 01:16:42.397
FLASHING OF NON FLUSHABLE SUCH
01:16:42.464 --> 01:16:44.199
AS BABY WIPES SURFACE WIPES AND
01:16:44.266 --> 01:16:46.668
SANITARY PIPES ARE THE PRIMARY
01:16:46.735 --> 01:16:48.437
CAUSE OF THE OF THE CLOGS IN THE
01:16:48.503 --> 01:16:51.807
SEWER SYSTEMS NOT FLUSHABLE
01:16:51.873 --> 01:16:52.641
WIPES FOR EXAMPLE.
01:16:52.708 --> 01:16:54.209
A COMPREHENSIVE STUDY IN TWENTY
01:16:54.276 --> 01:16:54.743
SIXTEEN IN NEW YORK CITY
01:16:54.810 --> 01:16:55.844
ADMINISTERED BY AN INDEPENDENT
01:16:55.911 --> 01:16:57.646
ENGINEERING FIRM AT THE REQUEST
01:16:57.713 --> 01:16:59.281
OF NEW YORK CITY LAW DEPARTMENT
01:16:59.348 --> 01:17:01.116
FOUND FLUSHABLE WIPES WHERE THE
01:17:01.183 --> 01:17:02.784
SMALLEST CATEGORY OF MATERIALS
01:17:02.851 --> 01:17:04.619
COLLECTED AT 2%.
01:17:04.686 --> 01:17:05.754
THIS SHOWS THAT THE IN THE FLESH
01:17:05.821 --> 01:17:07.255
ABILITY GUIDELINES FOR FLUSHABLE
01:17:07.322 --> 01:17:09.491
WIPES ACTUALLY WORK AS INTENDED
01:17:09.558 --> 01:17:11.059
AND THAT FLUSHABLE WIPES ARE NOT
01:17:11.126 --> 01:17:12.394
THE SOURCE OF THE PROBLEM
01:17:12.461 --> 01:17:14.196
CONTRARY TO THE STATED PURPOSE
01:17:14.262 --> 01:17:15.931
OF AB.
01:17:15.998 --> 01:17:16.732
SIXTEEN SEVENTY TWO THE UNITED
01:17:16.798 --> 01:17:19.267
KINGDOM STUDY OF TWENTY
01:17:19.334 --> 01:17:20.302
SEVENTEEN BY WATER U. K..
01:17:20.369 --> 01:17:22.104
HOW YOU SIMILAR PROTOCOLS AND
01:17:22.170 --> 01:17:23.705
COLLECTED AND ANALYZED MORE THAN
01:17:23.772 --> 01:17:25.240
FIFTY CLOGS IN PUMPS SEWER
01:17:25.307 --> 01:17:26.508
BLOCKAGES AND WASTE WATER
01:17:26.575 --> 01:17:28.076
TREATMENT IN LET SAMPLES OVER A
01:17:28.143 --> 01:17:29.811
PERIOD OF MORE THAN TWO MONTHS?
01:17:29.878 --> 01:17:31.513
UPON COMPLETION RESEARCHERS
01:17:31.580 --> 01:17:33.315
FOUND THAT FLUSHABLE WIPES
01:17:33.382 --> 01:17:34.149
ACCOUNTED FOR A NEGLIGIBLE
01:17:34.216 --> 01:17:42.657
AMOUNT OF IDENTIFY MATERIAL
01:17:42.724 --> 01:17:44.326
MACHINE LABEL OF BABYSURFACE
01:17:44.393 --> 01:17:45.927
AND OTHER WIPES IDENTIFIED AS
01:17:45.994 --> 01:17:47.396
THE PROBLEM IN PRIMARY STUDIES.
01:17:47.462 --> 01:17:49.398
THE BILL'S PRIMARY FOCUS ON ONE
01:17:49.464 --> 01:17:51.633
CATEGORY OF FLUSHABLE WIPES
01:17:51.700 --> 01:17:53.568
ACTUALLY DESIGNED AND ENGINEERED
01:17:53.635 --> 01:17:55.170
TO BE SAFE THE FLASH IS A
01:17:55.237 --> 01:17:56.271
QUESTIONABLE APPROACH TO THE
01:17:56.338 --> 01:17:58.640
PROBLEM. FOR THIS REASON WE
01:17:58.707 --> 01:17:59.207
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR NO
01:17:59.274 --> 01:18:00.475
VOTE.
01:18:00.542 --> 01:18:01.710
THANK YOU.
01:18:01.777 --> 01:18:02.811
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS
01:18:02.878 --> 01:18:04.046
DON CAP KEEP Q. CAP CAN
01:18:04.112 --> 01:18:05.147
ASSOCIATES ON BEHALF OF THE
01:18:05.213 --> 01:18:06.314
CALIFORNIA MANUFACTURERS AND
01:18:06.381 --> 01:18:08.950
TECHNOLOGY ASSOCIATION ALSO WITH
01:18:09.017 --> 01:18:09.885
RESPECTFUL OPPOSITION.
01:18:09.951 --> 01:18:11.553
OUR OPPOSITION IS BASED AS WELL
01:18:11.620 --> 01:18:14.990
ON THE FORENSIC ANALYSES AS
01:18:15.057 --> 01:18:16.858
REFERENCED -- BY AND THEY CHAU
01:18:16.925 --> 01:18:18.693
FLUSHABLE WIPES OR NOT INDEED
01:18:18.760 --> 01:18:19.995
THE CHIEF CONTRIBUTORS TO THESE
01:18:20.062 --> 01:18:22.197
CLOGS -- AND THEREFORE WE DON'T
01:18:22.264 --> 01:18:24.966
BELIEVE THAT THIS BILL AB
01:18:25.033 --> 01:18:25.567
SIXTEEN SEVENTY TWO ADDRESSES
01:18:25.634 --> 01:18:26.368
ARE THE PROBLEM.
01:18:26.435 --> 01:18:27.769
A RECENT COLLABORATION BETWEEN
01:18:27.836 --> 01:18:28.837
INDUSTRY IN THE JACKSONVILLE
01:18:28.904 --> 01:18:30.705
ELECTRIC AUTHORITY WASTE WATER
01:18:30.772 --> 01:18:32.808
SYSTEM IN JACKSONVILLE FLORIDA
01:18:32.874 --> 01:18:34.643
IN MARCH OF JUST THIS YEAR FOUND
01:18:34.709 --> 01:18:35.610
THAT BOTH WASTE WATER AND
01:18:35.677 --> 01:18:37.012
INDUSTRY REPRESENTATIVES WORK
01:18:37.079 --> 01:18:38.447
TOGETHER TO COLLECT AND ANALYZE
01:18:38.513 --> 01:18:39.681
MATERIALS.
01:18:39.748 --> 01:18:41.516
FROM THREE SEPARATE SETS OF BAR
01:18:41.583 --> 01:18:42.884
SCREEN SAMPLES OVER A TWO DAY
01:18:42.951 --> 01:18:43.785
PERIOD.
01:18:43.852 --> 01:18:45.654
ONCE AGAIN FLUSHABLE WIPES AND
01:18:45.720 --> 01:18:47.989
NOT STUDY FOUND TO OUGHT TO BE
01:18:48.056 --> 01:18:49.858
LESS THAN 1% OF THE MATERIAL
01:18:49.925 --> 01:18:51.326
COLLECTED AND ANALYZED.
01:18:51.393 --> 01:18:52.360
COLLECTION STUDIES USING
01:18:52.427 --> 01:18:54.096
FORENSIC ANALYSES IN PORTLAND
01:18:54.162 --> 01:18:56.298
MAINE AND WE'RE A CALIFORNIA
01:18:56.364 --> 01:18:58.233
SIMILARLY SHOWED FLUSHABLE WIPES
01:18:58.300 --> 01:19:00.669
REPRESENT ONLY A SMALL PORTION.
01:19:00.735 --> 01:19:02.537
OF MATERIALS COLLECTED AND
01:19:02.604 --> 01:19:03.405
IDENTIFIED.
01:19:03.472 --> 01:19:06.608
AND NOTED -- BY THE PROPONENTS I
01:19:06.675 --> 01:19:08.577
DOUBT IT WAS REFERENCE -- TO
01:19:08.643 --> 01:19:09.945
FROM THE CALIFORNIA STATE WATER.
01:19:10.011 --> 01:19:12.180
RESOURCES CONTROL BOARD SANITARY
01:19:12.247 --> 01:19:14.116
SEWER OVERFLOW REDUCTION PROGRAM
01:19:14.182 --> 01:19:15.750
WHICH ALSO NOTABLY DESPITE THE
01:19:15.817 --> 01:19:17.686
NUMBERS MENTIONED IS JUST
01:19:17.752 --> 01:19:18.920
REPRESENTS JUST A DE MINIMUS
01:19:18.987 --> 01:19:20.355
AMOUNT OF THE KIND OF THOSE
01:19:20.422 --> 01:19:22.624
ISSUES AS REPORTED BY THE STATE
01:19:22.691 --> 01:19:24.292
WATER BOARD'S OWN DATA.
01:19:24.359 --> 01:19:25.627
AND ILLUSTRATES AT THE END OF
01:19:25.694 --> 01:19:27.829
FLEXIBILITY STANDARDS ARE INDEED
01:19:27.896 --> 01:19:29.030
WORKING WELL.
01:19:29.097 --> 01:19:30.932
NOT DOT APPEARS THAT OUT. FOR
01:19:30.999 --> 01:19:32.033
THE COMPREHENSIVE FIELD STUDIES
01:19:32.100 --> 01:19:33.602
IN FORENSIC ANALYSES AS WELL AS
01:19:33.668 --> 01:19:34.970
THE STATE'S DATA COMBINED SHOW
01:19:35.036 --> 01:19:35.904
THE END OF FLEXIBILITY
01:19:35.971 --> 01:19:37.506
GUIDELINES TO BE SUFFICIENT FOR
01:19:37.572 --> 01:19:39.040
PROTECTING MUNICIPAL WASTE WATER
01:19:39.107 --> 01:19:39.908
SYSTEMS.
01:19:39.975 --> 01:19:41.510
THIS IS WHY COUNTRIES SUCH AS
01:19:41.576 --> 01:19:43.578
SPAIN BELGIUM NETHERLANDS AND
01:19:43.645 --> 01:19:45.614
GERMANY ARE STEADILY INCREASING
01:19:45.680 --> 01:19:47.182
KEY STANDARDS RATHER THAN THE
01:19:47.249 --> 01:19:49.117
FAULTY STANDARDS THAT WE ARE
01:19:49.184 --> 01:19:50.585
CONCERNED -- IN THIS BILL.
01:19:50.652 --> 01:19:51.686
THE BILL STANDARDS OF FASHION
01:19:51.753 --> 01:19:53.288
EFFECTIVELY BANNED FLUSHABLE
01:19:53.355 --> 01:19:56.191
WIPES IN CALIFORNIA BASICALLY
01:19:56.258 --> 01:20:04.266
ALL FLUSHABLE WIPES CURRENTLY ON
01:20:04.332 --> 01:20:06.868
THE U. S. MARKET A PRODUCT WHEN
01:20:06.935 --> 01:20:08.837
WE SPUR SYSTEMS STUDIES AND
01:20:08.904 --> 01:20:11.106
STATES DATA TO NOT BE A PROBLEM.
01:20:11.173 --> 01:20:12.207
WE WOULD ASK THE PROPONENTS WHY
01:20:12.274 --> 01:20:12.807
CHOOSING A BAND OF WHAT IS NO
01:20:12.874 --> 01:20:13.642
MORE THAN 2% OF THE PROBLEM
01:20:13.708 --> 01:20:14.209
RATHER THAN COMMITTING TO A
01:20:14.276 --> 01:20:15.143
TARGETED STRATEGY ON 98% OF THE
01:20:15.210 --> 01:20:16.344
PROBLEM.
01:20:16.411 --> 01:20:17.012
IS THE DIRECTION WE'RE HEADED UP
01:20:17.078 --> 01:20:19.814
WITH THE FOR THESE REASONS THAT
01:20:19.881 --> 01:20:20.448
WE RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR NEW
01:20:20.515 --> 01:20:21.783
VOTE.
01:20:21.850 --> 01:20:22.284
THANK YOU ANYONE ELSE IN
01:20:22.350 --> 01:20:24.286
OPPOSITION.
01:20:24.352 --> 01:20:24.953
THE SEARCH AREA THREE MILLION ON
01:20:25.020 --> 01:20:25.420
BEHALF OF THE GROCERY
01:20:25.487 --> 01:20:27.822
MANUFACTURERS ASSOCIATION IN
01:20:27.889 --> 01:20:30.125
OPPOSITION THANK YOU.
01:20:30.192 --> 01:20:30.959
MORNING SHARING COMMITTEE ADAM
01:20:31.026 --> 01:20:32.194
REGULAR AND AFTER THE CALIFORNIA
01:20:32.260 --> 01:20:33.061
CHAMBER OF COMMERCE WE ALIGN
01:20:33.128 --> 01:20:35.497
WITH SEEM TA AND I NDA WERE
01:20:35.564 --> 01:20:37.699
OPPOSED THANKS THANK YOU ANYONE
01:20:37.766 --> 01:20:38.867
ELSE IN OPPOSITION.
01:20:38.934 --> 01:20:39.968
RIGHT SEE NONE OF BRING IT BACK
01:20:40.035 --> 01:20:45.073
TO THE COMMITTEE QUESTIONS -- ON
01:20:45.140 --> 01:20:46.174
MY VERY MANY LEE ON BEHALF OF
01:20:46.241 --> 01:20:47.242
THE PERSONAL CARE PRODUCTS
01:20:47.309 --> 01:20:49.244
CANCEL ANY OUR COMMENTS.
01:20:49.311 --> 01:20:49.978
THANK YOU.
01:20:50.045 --> 01:20:51.846
ALL RIGHT BACK TO COMMITTEE
01:20:51.913 --> 01:20:53.882
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS.
01:20:53.949 --> 01:20:55.350
PRICING THAT MISTER BLOOM --
01:20:55.417 --> 01:20:57.752
PROPS YOU CAN ADDRESS THE
01:20:57.819 --> 01:20:59.421
SERVICE THEY MISS THE OPPOSITION.
01:20:59.487 --> 01:21:00.488
SMITH GOVERNOR TO DO THAT OF
01:21:00.555 --> 01:21:02.357
COURSE SO -- I THINK THERE'S
01:21:02.424 --> 01:21:04.092
JUST A FUNDAMENTAL DISAGREEMENT
01:21:04.159 --> 01:21:06.761
ON THE RESEARCH -- HERE -- THAT
01:21:06.828 --> 01:21:08.363
WE FEEL THAT THE RESEARCH THAT
01:21:08.430 --> 01:21:09.764
THE INDUSTRY PRESENTS AS
01:21:09.831 --> 01:21:12.200
SOMEWHAT FLAWED AND WE OBJECT TO
01:21:12.267 --> 01:21:16.104
MANY OF THE KLUTE CONCLUSIONS
01:21:16.171 --> 01:21:17.973
IT IS BOTH THE FLUSHABLE.
01:21:18.039 --> 01:21:19.374
AND NON FLUSHABLE WIPES THAT
01:21:19.441 --> 01:21:21.243
CONTRIBUTE TO THE PROBLEMS -- IN
01:21:21.309 --> 01:21:22.644
THE SYSTEMS AND FOR PUBLIC
01:21:22.711 --> 01:21:24.579
AGENCIES AND WE ALSO KNOW BASED
01:21:24.646 --> 01:21:26.081
ON SOME FIELD STUDIES THAT HAVE
01:21:26.147 --> 01:21:27.849
BEEN DONE SPECIFIC TO THE
01:21:27.916 --> 01:21:31.119
FLUSHABLE WIPES CATEGORY -- THAT
01:21:31.186 --> 01:21:33.221
WHEN WE DROP -- A VARIETY OF
01:21:33.288 --> 01:21:35.657
FLUSHABLE WIPES INTO THE SYSTEM
01:21:35.724 --> 01:21:37.559
THEY DO COME THROUGH INTACT SOME
01:21:37.626 --> 01:21:39.828
OF THE WIPES ARE HIGH PERFORMERS
01:21:39.894 --> 01:21:41.830
AND THEY COME THROUGH AND
01:21:41.896 --> 01:21:44.366
DISPERSE BUT OF A LARGE AMOUNT
01:21:44.432 --> 01:21:46.101
DO COME THROUGH AND TAX SO THAT
01:21:46.167 --> 01:21:48.336
TELLS US THAT AND THEY ARE NOT
01:21:48.403 --> 01:21:50.372
PERFORMING -- THE WAY THAT THEIR
01:21:50.438 --> 01:21:51.873
INTENDED TO PERFORM AND THAT'S A
01:21:51.940 --> 01:21:53.408
STUDY DONE IN A FIELD OUTSIDE OF
01:21:53.475 --> 01:21:54.676
THE LABORATORY SETTING SO WE
01:21:54.743 --> 01:21:57.912
KNOW THAT -- THEY ARE MAKING IT --
01:21:57.979 --> 01:21:59.714
THROUGH THE SYSTEM SO -- THAT'S
01:21:59.781 --> 01:22:02.250
WHY WE HAVE INTENDED TO ADDRESS
01:22:02.317 --> 01:22:05.820
THE WHOLE SUITE OF PRODUCTS BY
01:22:05.887 --> 01:22:08.223
ADDRESSING LABELING OF BOTH THE
01:22:08.290 --> 01:22:09.157
NON FLUSHABLE.
01:22:09.224 --> 01:22:13.762
AND FLUSHABLE MARKETED -- WHAT
01:22:13.828 --> 01:22:14.596
WHITE [inaudible]
01:22:14.663 --> 01:22:15.930
THANK YOU.
01:22:15.997 --> 01:22:16.564
THE QUESTIONS COMMENTS FROM THE
01:22:16.631 --> 01:22:18.166
COMMITTEE.
01:22:18.233 --> 01:22:19.501
ALRIGHT THIS WILL BE MY CLOSE.
01:22:19.567 --> 01:22:21.336
THANK YOU I RESPECTFULLY ASK
01:22:21.403 --> 01:22:21.636
YOUR RIVAL.
01:22:21.703 --> 01:22:23.204
THANK YOU.
01:22:23.271 --> 01:22:24.606
WE DO HAVE THE MOST -- NOW
01:22:24.673 --> 01:22:27.809
LOOKING FOR A MOTION.
01:22:27.876 --> 01:22:29.911
THANK YOU AND THE SECOND MOTION
01:22:29.978 --> 01:22:31.980
IS TO PASS AS AMENDED TO
01:22:32.047 --> 01:22:32.580
APPROPRIATIONS CALL THE ROLL
01:22:32.647 --> 01:22:33.048
PLEASE.
01:22:33.114 --> 01:22:35.583
STONE BY STONE AYE GALLAGHER.
01:22:35.650 --> 01:22:36.985
GALLAGHER NO CHAU.
01:22:37.052 --> 01:22:37.986
CHIU.
01:22:38.053 --> 01:22:39.888
GONZALEZ.
01:22:39.954 --> 01:22:41.823
AND SALAS AYE HOLDEN.
01:22:41.890 --> 01:22:43.491
IN AYE KALRA.
01:22:43.558 --> 01:22:44.392
KALRA AYE KILEY.
01:22:44.459 --> 01:22:47.128
MAIENSCHEIN.
01:22:47.195 --> 01:22:49.397
MAIENSCHEIN I OBERNOLTE
01:22:49.464 --> 01:22:51.132
OBERNOLTE NO PETRIE-NORRIS
01:22:51.199 --> 01:22:53.468
PETRIE-NORRIS AYE REYES.
01:22:53.535 --> 01:22:56.371
AYE REYES AYE.
01:22:56.438 --> 01:22:58.106
THE BILL IS OUT THANK YOU THANK
01:22:58.173 --> 01:22:59.641
YOU MISTER BILL OF RIGHTS MS
01:22:59.708 --> 01:23:15.256
CARILLO YOU HAVE TO BILLS WORTH.
01:23:15.323 --> 01:23:17.992
YEAH GIVE A PREFERENCE FOR WHICH
01:23:18.059 --> 01:23:18.893
YOU'D LIKE TO TAKE UP FIRST.
01:23:18.960 --> 01:23:19.461
RIGHT LET'S START WITH ITEM
01:23:19.527 --> 01:23:41.282
NUMBER SIX THEN AB.
01:23:54.829 --> 01:23:54.996
SEVEN FIFTY
01:23:55.063 --> 01:23:55.630
EIGHT SEVEN FIFTY EIGHT MORNING
01:23:55.697 --> 01:23:55.964
GOOD MORNING.
01:23:56.030 --> 01:23:57.065
HELLO GOOD MORNING MISTER CHAIR
01:23:57.132 --> 01:23:58.333
AND MEMBERS I'M HERE TO PRESENT
01:23:58.400 --> 01:24:00.201
ASSEMBLY BILL SEVEN FIFTY EIGHT
01:24:00.268 --> 01:24:00.869
A BILL THAT ADDRESSES THE
01:24:00.935 --> 01:24:02.437
UNLAWFUL WORKPLACE PAID
01:24:02.504 --> 01:24:04.406
DIFFERENCES. FOR EMPLOYEES OF
01:24:04.472 --> 01:24:06.341
ALL GENDERS OUR CURRENT EQUAL
01:24:06.408 --> 01:24:08.309
PAY INSURERS THAT EMPLOYEES OF
01:24:08.376 --> 01:24:09.577
DIFFERENT GENDER RACE AND
01:24:09.644 --> 01:24:11.179
ETHNICITY THROUGH PERFORM
01:24:11.246 --> 01:24:13.615
SIMILAR WORK ARE PAID FAIRLY.
01:24:13.681 --> 01:24:15.283
THE LAW ALSO DISCOURAGES PAY
01:24:15.350 --> 01:24:16.851
SECRECY BY PROHIBITING
01:24:16.918 --> 01:24:18.386
RETALIATION OR DISCRIMINATION
01:24:18.453 --> 01:24:20.321
AGAINST EMPLOYEES WHO DISCUSS
01:24:20.388 --> 01:24:21.623
THEIR INCOME.
01:24:21.689 --> 01:24:23.191
AB SEVEN FIFTY EIGHT THREATENS
01:24:23.258 --> 01:24:25.226
OUR FAIR PAY ACT BY REMOVING THE
01:24:25.293 --> 01:24:27.028
GENDER BINARY TERMINOLOGY THE US
01:24:27.095 --> 01:24:28.329
INCORPORATING.
01:24:28.396 --> 01:24:30.064
NON BINARY PEOPLE INTO THESE
01:24:30.131 --> 01:24:31.566
PROTECTIONS AND CLARIFYING THAT
01:24:31.633 --> 01:24:33.134
TRANSGENDER PEOPLE HAVE ALWAYS
01:24:33.201 --> 01:24:34.903
BEEN AND WILL CONTINUE TO BE
01:24:34.969 --> 01:24:36.271
PROTECTED.
01:24:36.337 --> 01:24:38.807
THIS BILL ALSO SPECIFIES THAT
01:24:38.873 --> 01:24:40.008
ONE THE WORKER FILING A CLAIM AS
01:24:40.074 --> 01:24:41.276
ONLY ESTABLISHED THAT THEY WERE
01:24:41.342 --> 01:24:43.611
PAID LESS THAN A SINGLE EMPLOYEE
01:24:43.678 --> 01:24:45.246
OF ANOTHER SEX OR RACE.
01:24:45.313 --> 01:24:47.649
AND TO WORKERS HAVE A ONE YEAR
01:24:47.715 --> 01:24:49.350
OF A FILING DEADLINE FOR
01:24:49.417 --> 01:24:50.084
ADMINISTRATIVE RETALIATION
01:24:50.151 --> 01:24:52.287
CLAIMS LIKE THEY DO FOR CIVIL
01:24:52.353 --> 01:24:53.655
RETALIATION CLAIMS.
01:24:53.721 --> 01:24:55.323
WHILE GENDER NON CONFORMING AND
01:24:55.390 --> 01:24:57.025
TRANSGENDER PEOPLE HAVE ALWAYS
01:24:57.091 --> 01:24:59.527
OCCUPIED OUR WORKPLACE THEY HAVE
01:24:59.594 --> 01:25:00.628
NOT ALWAYS BEEN LEGALLY
01:25:00.695 --> 01:25:04.532
RECOGNIZED OR PROTECTED.
01:25:04.599 --> 01:25:05.166
THESE PROTECTIONS ARE NECESSARY
01:25:05.233 --> 01:25:06.801
AS SHOWN IN THE NATIONAL CENTER
01:25:06.868 --> 01:25:08.536
FOR TRANSGENDER EQUALITY SURVEY
01:25:08.603 --> 01:25:10.071
WHICH REPORTED THAT ONE OUT OF
01:25:10.138 --> 01:25:11.105
EVERY THREE TRANS GENDER
01:25:11.172 --> 01:25:13.641
RESPONDENTS REPORTED BEING FIRED.
01:25:13.708 --> 01:25:15.810
DENIED A PROMOTION OR MISTREATED
01:25:15.877 --> 01:25:17.145
BECAUSE OF THEIR GENDER.
01:25:17.212 --> 01:25:18.913
ADDITIONALLY WORKERS HAVE ONE
01:25:18.980 --> 01:25:20.849
YEAR TO FILE A CIVIL RETALIATION
01:25:20.915 --> 01:25:22.183
COMPLAINING PORTS UNDER THE
01:25:22.250 --> 01:25:23.518
EQUAL PAY ACT.
01:25:23.585 --> 01:25:25.253
BUT SIX MONTHS TO FILE
01:25:25.320 --> 01:25:26.821
ADMINISTRATIVE RETALIATION
01:25:26.888 --> 01:25:28.857
CLAIMS WE MUST PROVIDE THE SAME
01:25:28.923 --> 01:25:31.426
FILING DEADLINES REGARDLESS OF
01:25:31.493 --> 01:25:33.695
WHICH ROUTE A WORKER CHOOSES TO
01:25:33.761 --> 01:25:35.029
PURSUE.
01:25:35.096 --> 01:25:37.098
HERE TO TESTIFY IS TAMMY MARTIN
01:25:37.165 --> 01:25:38.600
LEGISLATIVE MANAGER OF EQUALITY
01:25:38.666 --> 01:25:40.735
CALIFORNIA JESSICA STERN -- WHO
01:25:40.802 --> 01:25:42.537
IS A SENIOR STAFF ATTORNEY AT
01:25:42.604 --> 01:25:44.072
EQUAL RIGHTS ADVOCATES?
01:25:44.138 --> 01:25:47.942
AND HER CLIENT CAROL HANDED.
01:25:48.009 --> 01:25:48.543
THANK YOU THANK WORST WITNESS
01:25:48.610 --> 01:25:49.911
PLEASE.
01:25:49.978 --> 01:25:50.445
MISTER CHAIR AND COMMITTEE
01:25:50.512 --> 01:25:52.080
MEMBERS TAMMY MARTIN ON BEHALF
01:25:52.146 --> 01:25:53.848
OF EQUALITY CALIFORNIA THE STATE
01:25:53.915 --> 01:25:55.450
WIDE LGBTQ CIVIL RIGHTS
01:25:55.517 --> 01:25:57.218
ORGANIZATION AND PROUD CO
01:25:57.285 --> 01:25:59.654
SPONSOR OF AB SEVEN FIFTY EIGHT
01:25:59.721 --> 01:26:00.688
WHICH REFLECTS CALIFORNIA'S
01:26:00.755 --> 01:26:01.923
RESPECT FOR ITS DIVERSE
01:26:01.990 --> 01:26:03.091
POPULATION.
01:26:03.157 --> 01:26:04.692
AND UPDATES THE OUTDATED IT
01:26:04.759 --> 01:26:06.561
GENDER BINARY LANGUAGE IN THE
01:26:06.628 --> 01:26:07.996
STATE'S EQUAL PAY ACT.
01:26:08.062 --> 01:26:09.697
IN TWO THOUSAND SEVENTEEN WE
01:26:09.764 --> 01:26:10.999
SPONSORED THE GENDER RECOGNITION
01:26:11.065 --> 01:26:13.167
ACT WHICH ENABLED MORE PEOPLE TO
01:26:13.234 --> 01:26:15.436
OBTAIN A STATE ISSUED IDENTITY
01:26:15.503 --> 01:26:16.971
DOCUMENTS THAT ACCURATELY.
01:26:17.038 --> 01:26:18.506
REFLECT THEIR GENDER IDENTITY BY
01:26:18.573 --> 01:26:20.608
CREATING A THIRD NON BINARY
01:26:20.675 --> 01:26:22.043
GENDER MARKER.
01:26:22.110 --> 01:26:23.912
AND THE CURRENT LANGUAGE OF THE
01:26:23.978 --> 01:26:25.346
CALIFORNIA'S EQUAL PAY ACT.
01:26:25.413 --> 01:26:26.648
PROHIBITS EMPLOYERS FROM PAYING
01:26:26.714 --> 01:26:28.216
AN EMPLOYEE LESS THAN AN
01:26:28.283 --> 01:26:30.351
EMPLOYEE OF THE OPPOSITE SEX FOR
01:26:30.418 --> 01:26:33.254
SUBSTANTIALLY SIMILAR WORK SO AB
01:26:33.321 --> 01:26:33.855
SEVEN FIFTY EIGHT WILL UPDATE
01:26:33.922 --> 01:26:36.224
THIS OUTDATED BINARY LANGUAGE TO
01:26:36.291 --> 01:26:37.725
ENSURE THAT EMPLOYEES OF ALL.
01:26:37.792 --> 01:26:39.561
GENDERS AND GENDER EXPRESSIONS
01:26:39.627 --> 01:26:41.195
ARE PAID EQUITABLY.
01:26:41.262 --> 01:26:42.897
AND WE KNOW THAT LGBT Q. PEOPLE
01:26:42.964 --> 01:26:44.599
AND TRANS GENDER AND NON BINARY
01:26:44.666 --> 01:26:46.200
PEOPLE IN PARTICULAR HAVE
01:26:46.267 --> 01:26:47.502
HISTORICALLY FACED HIGH LEVELS
01:26:47.569 --> 01:26:49.003
OF SOCIETAL STIGMA AND
01:26:49.070 --> 01:26:50.471
DISCRIMINATION.
01:26:50.538 --> 01:26:52.140
A RECENT STUDY REVEALED PATTERNS
01:26:52.206 --> 01:26:53.641
OF DISCRIMINATION AGAINST
01:26:53.708 --> 01:26:55.076
TRANSGENDER NON BINARY PEOPLE IN
01:26:55.143 --> 01:26:57.345
A VARIETY OF SETTINGS INCLUDING
01:26:57.412 --> 01:26:58.980
WORK PLACES. ONE OUT OF EVERY
01:26:59.047 --> 01:27:01.115
THREE RESPONDENTS REPORTED BEING
01:27:01.182 --> 01:27:02.784
FIRED TONIGHT A PROMOTION OR
01:27:02.850 --> 01:27:04.052
OTHERWISE BEING MISTREATED AT
01:27:04.118 --> 01:27:05.820
WORK BECAUSE OF THEIR GENDER
01:27:05.887 --> 01:27:07.589
IDENTITY OR EXPRESSION.
01:27:07.655 --> 01:27:09.057
AND THIS PERPETUATES THE CYCLE
01:27:09.123 --> 01:27:10.692
OF ECONOMIC INSTABILITY FOR
01:27:10.758 --> 01:27:12.193
TRANSGENDER AND NON BINARY
01:27:12.260 --> 01:27:13.695
CALIFORNIANS ONE THIRD OF WHOM
01:27:13.761 --> 01:27:16.764
LIVE IN POVERTY. EIGHTY SEVEN
01:27:16.831 --> 01:27:17.332
FIFTY EIGHT IS A THOUGHTFUL
01:27:17.398 --> 01:27:18.933
UNNECESSARY UPDATE TO EQUAL PAY
01:27:19.000 --> 01:27:20.335
LAWS AND WE THANK ASSEMBLY
01:27:20.401 --> 01:27:21.636
MEMBER CARILLO FOR ADVANCING
01:27:21.703 --> 01:27:23.204
THIS CRITICAL LEGISLATION.
01:27:23.271 --> 01:27:24.806
AND WE URGE THE COMMITTEE TO
01:27:24.872 --> 01:27:27.308
SUPPORT AS WELL THANK YOU THANK
01:27:27.375 --> 01:27:27.508
YOU.
01:27:27.575 --> 01:27:28.443
THAT'S WHAT THIS PLACE GOOD
01:27:28.509 --> 01:27:29.243
MORNING MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS OF
01:27:29.310 --> 01:27:30.645
THE COMMITTEE MY NAME IS JESSICA
01:27:30.712 --> 01:27:32.113
CENTER AND I'M AN ATTORNEY EQUAL
01:27:32.180 --> 01:27:34.015
RIGHTS ADVOCATES -- WE EMPHASIZE
01:27:34.082 --> 01:27:35.717
THE NEED TO MAKE THE FILING TIME
01:27:35.783 --> 01:27:37.118
LINES CONSISTENT FOR FILING A
01:27:37.185 --> 01:27:39.287
RETALIATION CLAIM IN COURT -- OR
01:27:39.354 --> 01:27:41.889
pTO THE LIMITATIONS THAT MANY
01:27:41.956 --> 01:27:43.391
PEOPLE HAVE IN FINDING A LAWYER
01:27:43.458 --> 01:27:44.559
TO ACTUALLY BRING UP RETALIATION
01:27:44.626 --> 01:27:46.628
CLAIM IN COURT WITHOUT ALTERNATE
01:27:46.694 --> 01:27:51.032
TO OUR CLIENT CORAL HAND IN --
01:27:51.099 --> 01:27:53.167
TO SPEAK ABOUT THE ISSUE THE
01:27:53.234 --> 01:27:54.469
THANKS WITH THIS PLEASE.
01:27:54.535 --> 01:27:55.103
A GOOD AFTERNOON MEMBERS OF THE
01:27:55.169 --> 01:27:55.403
COMMITTEE.
01:27:55.470 --> 01:27:56.070
THANK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO
01:27:56.137 --> 01:27:57.071
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OF AB.
01:27:57.138 --> 01:27:57.672
SEVEN FIFTY EIGHT WHICH WAS A
01:27:57.739 --> 01:27:59.073
PROVIDE IMPORTANT UPDATES AND
01:27:59.140 --> 01:28:00.775
CLARIFICATIONS TO OUR STATE
01:28:00.842 --> 01:28:02.176
EQUAL PAY LAW.
01:28:02.243 --> 01:28:03.911
I WORKED FOR A MAJOR GOLF COURSE
01:28:03.978 --> 01:28:06.114
BEACH RESORT FOR A YEAR AND A
01:28:06.180 --> 01:28:07.649
HALF AS A ROTATIONAL MANAGER.
01:28:07.715 --> 01:28:08.750
IN THAT POSITION I WORKED AT
01:28:08.816 --> 01:28:09.851
SEVERAL DIFFERENT RESTAURANTS AT
01:28:09.917 --> 01:28:12.620
THE RESORT ON A ROTATIONAL BASIS.
01:28:12.687 --> 01:28:13.421
THE TIME THAT I WORKED THERE I
01:28:13.488 --> 01:28:15.189
WORKED HARD I DID MY JOB WELL
01:28:15.256 --> 01:28:16.391
AND I RECEIVED POSITIVE FEEDBACK
01:28:16.457 --> 01:28:18.026
AND EVALUATIONS FOR MY
01:28:18.092 --> 01:28:20.294
SUPERVISORS.
01:28:20.361 --> 01:28:21.329
AFTER A LITTLE OVER A YEAR
01:28:21.396 --> 01:28:22.397
WORKING THERE.
01:28:22.463 --> 01:28:23.498
I CAME ACROSS A DOCUMENT A
01:28:23.564 --> 01:28:25.400
SHARED SERVER THAT LISTED THE
01:28:25.466 --> 01:28:26.801
SALARIES OF ALL THE MANAGERS.
01:28:26.868 --> 01:28:28.369
AND REFLECTED DISPARITIES
01:28:28.436 --> 01:28:29.837
BETWEEN MALE AND FEMALE MANAGERS
01:28:29.904 --> 01:28:31.806
WITH THE MEN RECEIVING HIGHER
01:28:31.873 --> 01:28:32.940
WAGES.
01:28:33.007 --> 01:28:34.242
I IMMEDIATELY INFORM MY
01:28:34.308 --> 01:28:35.643
SUPERVISOR THAT IT COME ACROSS
01:28:35.710 --> 01:28:37.612
THE DOCUMENT IN THE OFFICES
01:28:37.679 --> 01:28:39.380
DIGITAL FILES AND GIVEN.
01:28:39.447 --> 01:28:40.415
THAT IT HAD SENSE OF WAGE
01:28:40.481 --> 01:28:42.050
INFORMATION I THOUGHT IT SHOULD
01:28:42.116 --> 01:28:43.818
PROBABLY BE PASSWORD PROTECTED.
01:28:43.885 --> 01:28:45.853
I ALSO RAISE THE GENDER GENDER
01:28:45.920 --> 01:28:47.221
WAGE DISPARITIES THAT REFLECTED
01:28:47.288 --> 01:28:50.391
IN THE DOCUMENT WITH HR.
01:28:50.458 --> 01:28:52.060
AS FAR AS I KNOW NO CHANGES IN
01:28:52.126 --> 01:28:54.128
PAY WERE MADE AFTER A REPORTED
01:28:54.195 --> 01:28:54.395
THE PAY.
01:28:54.462 --> 01:28:56.397
DISPARITIES A FEW MONTHS LATER I
01:28:56.464 --> 01:28:58.166
DECIDED TO TAKE ANOTHER JOB
01:28:58.232 --> 01:28:59.567
BECAUSE IT PAID MORE.
01:28:59.634 --> 01:29:02.437
DURING MY EXIT INTERVIEW THE H.
01:29:02.503 --> 01:29:04.172
WAS LEAVING I TOLD HER THAT I
01:29:04.238 --> 01:29:05.306
LOVE MY JOB.
01:29:05.373 --> 01:29:06.474
AND THAT THE REASON I WAS
01:29:06.541 --> 01:29:07.709
LEAVING WAS THAT I WAS BEING
01:29:07.775 --> 01:29:09.644
PAID TOO LITTLE AND BECAUSE OF
01:29:09.711 --> 01:29:11.546
THE PAY DISPARITIES THAT I HAD
01:29:11.612 --> 01:29:13.214
SEEN IN THE DOCUMENT.
01:29:13.281 --> 01:29:14.782
NATURE REPRESENTATIVE THEN TOLD
01:29:14.849 --> 01:29:16.284
ME THAT MY SUPERVISOR WAS NO
01:29:16.350 --> 01:29:18.186
VERY UPSET WITH ME FOR HAVING
01:29:18.252 --> 01:29:19.921
RAISE THE ISSUE OF PAY.
01:29:19.987 --> 01:29:21.389
I EXPLAINED THAT I HADN'T ACTED
01:29:21.456 --> 01:29:22.623
WITH ANY MALICE.
01:29:22.690 --> 01:29:24.025
I'D SIMPLY REPORTED THE ISSUE TO
01:29:24.092 --> 01:29:25.526
HR BECAUSE THEY FELT IT WAS THE
01:29:25.593 --> 01:29:28.296
RIGHT THING TO DO.
01:29:28.362 --> 01:29:29.530
THE NEW JOB DIDN'T WORK OUT AS I
01:29:29.597 --> 01:29:30.698
HAD HOPED SO AFTER A FEW MONTHS
01:29:30.765 --> 01:29:31.833
I'VE APPLIED FOR SEVERAL OPEN
01:29:31.899 --> 01:29:33.401
POSITIONS WITH MY FORMER
01:29:33.468 --> 01:29:35.169
EMPLOYER I WAS ALREADY TRAINED
01:29:35.236 --> 01:29:37.171
AND HAD EXPERIENCE IN ALL OF THE
01:29:37.238 --> 01:29:38.539
POSITIONS THAT I APPLIED.
01:29:38.606 --> 01:29:40.541
HOWEVER AFTER MONTHS OF WAITING
01:29:40.608 --> 01:29:41.342
AND THE POSITIONS STILL BEING
01:29:41.409 --> 01:29:42.310
OPEN.
01:29:42.376 --> 01:29:44.378
I DID NOT HEAR BACK ABOUT ANY OF
01:29:44.445 --> 01:29:46.481
MY APPLICATIONS.
01:29:46.547 --> 01:29:47.348
I WAS CONFUSED AND UPSET BECAUSE
01:29:47.415 --> 01:29:48.750
I HAD BEEN A GREAT EMPLOYEE I
01:29:48.816 --> 01:29:50.251
FELT A TO HANDLE THE SITUATION
01:29:50.318 --> 01:29:51.252
PROFESSIONALLY.
01:29:51.319 --> 01:29:52.720
BY REPORTING TO PAY PROBLEM THAT
01:29:52.787 --> 01:29:54.155
I DISCOVERED.
01:29:54.222 --> 01:29:55.389
MY FORMER SUPERVISOR HAD EMAILED
01:29:55.456 --> 01:29:56.958
ME PRIOR TO MY DEPARTURE SAYING
01:29:57.024 --> 01:29:58.059
THAT HE WOULD CERTAINLY WELCOME
01:29:58.126 --> 01:30:00.461
ME BACK IF THIS NEW OPPORTUNITY
01:30:00.528 --> 01:30:01.429
DIDN'T WORK OUT.
01:30:01.496 --> 01:30:02.930
IT WAS CLEAR TO ME EVENTUALLY
01:30:02.997 --> 01:30:04.632
BUT THEY WERE NOT CONTACTED ME
01:30:04.699 --> 01:30:05.800
ABOUT THE OPEN POSITIONS BECAUSE
01:30:05.867 --> 01:30:07.401
I HAD RATES RAISE THE ISSUE OF
01:30:07.468 --> 01:30:08.636
EQUAL PAY.
01:30:08.703 --> 01:30:09.904
APPROXIMATELY FIVE MONTHS AFTER
01:30:09.971 --> 01:30:11.005
I FIRST RE APPLIED TO WORK FOR
01:30:11.072 --> 01:30:12.840
THE COMPANY.
01:30:12.907 --> 01:30:14.542
I FILED A WAGE CLAIM AND
01:30:14.609 --> 01:30:15.910
RETALIATION CLAIM UNDER THE
01:30:15.977 --> 01:30:17.879
EQUAL PAY ACT WITH THE LABOR
01:30:17.945 --> 01:30:18.980
COMMISSIONER.
01:30:19.046 --> 01:30:20.314
AN INVESTIGATOR CONTACTED ME
01:30:20.381 --> 01:30:22.016
ABOUT THE EQUAL PAY CLAIM BUT I
01:30:22.083 --> 01:30:23.384
WAS NOT CONTACTED ABOUT THE
01:30:23.451 --> 01:30:24.752
RETALIATION CLAIM.
01:30:24.819 --> 01:30:26.020
DESPITE MAKING REPEATED
01:30:26.087 --> 01:30:27.221
INQUIRIES.
01:30:27.288 --> 01:30:29.557
I FINALLY LEARNED THAT THE LABOR
01:30:29.624 --> 01:30:30.491
COMMISSIONER HAD DISMISSED MY
01:30:30.558 --> 01:30:31.726
RETALIATION CLAIM.
01:30:31.793 --> 01:30:32.794
ON THE GROUNDS THAT WAS FILED
01:30:32.860 --> 01:30:34.695
MORE THAN SIX MONTHS AFTER THE
01:30:34.762 --> 01:30:37.064
END OF MY EMPLOYMENT.
01:30:37.131 --> 01:30:38.366
I FILED AN APPEAL ON THE GROUNDS
01:30:38.432 --> 01:30:39.500
OF THE DEADLINE FOR THE
01:30:39.567 --> 01:30:41.102
RETALIATION CLAIM IS ONE YEAR AS
01:30:41.169 --> 01:30:42.103
MY STATS AS STATED IN THE
01:30:42.170 --> 01:30:43.905
STATUTE I DID NOT RECEIVE ANY
01:30:43.971 --> 01:30:44.405
RESPONSE FROM THE LABOR
01:30:44.472 --> 01:30:45.373
COMMISSIONER.
01:30:45.439 --> 01:30:46.707
ABOUT MY APPEAL OF THE
01:30:46.774 --> 01:30:49.043
RETALIATION DISMISSAL DESPITE
01:30:49.110 --> 01:30:50.211
REACHING OUT MULTIPLE TIMES.
01:30:50.278 --> 01:30:51.612
FINALLY THE INVESTIGATOR WHO IS
01:30:51.679 --> 01:30:53.214
INVESTIGATING MY EQUAL PAY CLAIM
01:30:53.281 --> 01:30:53.948
TOLD ME THAT THE LABOR
01:30:54.015 --> 01:30:55.249
COMMISSIONER WAS UNABLE TO RE
01:30:55.316 --> 01:30:56.584
OPEN THE CLAIM AND THEN I COULD
01:30:56.651 --> 01:30:58.252
REACH OUT TO THE RETALIATION
01:30:58.319 --> 01:30:59.954
PUBLIC LINE FOR MORE INFORMATION.
01:31:00.021 --> 01:31:01.189
I SENT MULTIPLE REQUESTS AND
01:31:01.255 --> 01:31:03.457
RETALIATION PUBLIC LINE BUT I
01:31:03.524 --> 01:31:05.593
HAVE NOT HEARD BACK ONCE.
01:31:05.660 --> 01:31:06.394
I FILE MAKE IT WILL PLAY AND
01:31:06.460 --> 01:31:07.195
RETALIATION CLAIMS WITH THE
01:31:07.261 --> 01:31:08.162
LABOR COMMISSIONER BECAUSE I
01:31:08.229 --> 01:31:09.430
COULDN'T FIND A LAWYER.
01:31:09.497 --> 01:31:11.032
AND WOULD NOT HAVE BEEN ABLE TO
01:31:11.098 --> 01:31:12.200
FILE A LAWSUIT ON MY OWN.
01:31:12.266 --> 01:31:13.401
I THINK WORKERS SHOULD HAVE THE
01:31:13.467 --> 01:31:14.635
SAME AMOUNT OF TIME TO FILE A
01:31:14.702 --> 01:31:16.037
RETALIATION CLAIM WITH THE LABOR
01:31:16.103 --> 01:31:18.105
COMMISSIONER.
01:31:18.172 --> 01:31:19.307
AS THEY HAVE TO FILE IN COURT.
01:31:19.373 --> 01:31:20.308
IT WORKERS ABILITY TO FIND A
01:31:20.374 --> 01:31:21.876
LAWYER AND FILE A LAWSUIT SHOULD
01:31:21.943 --> 01:31:23.177
NOT DICTATE THE AMOUNT OF TIME
01:31:23.244 --> 01:31:25.813
THAT SHE HAS TO SEEK JUSTICE FOR
01:31:25.880 --> 01:31:27.882
BEING RETALIATED AGAINST.
01:31:27.949 --> 01:31:29.317
AB SEVEN FIFTY EIGHT WOULD
01:31:29.383 --> 01:31:30.885
CLARIFY THAT THE FILING DEADLINE
01:31:30.952 --> 01:31:32.286
FOR THESE CLAIMS IS THE SAME
01:31:32.353 --> 01:31:33.788
REGARDLESS OF THE FORM AND I
01:31:33.855 --> 01:31:35.122
URGE YOUR AYE VOTE.
01:31:35.189 --> 01:31:36.023
THANK YOU FOR GIVING ME THE
01:31:36.090 --> 01:31:37.725
OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK WITH YOU
01:31:37.792 --> 01:31:39.026
ABOUT MY SITUATION [inaudible]
01:31:39.093 --> 01:31:41.095
THANK YOU.
01:31:41.162 --> 01:31:42.530
ANYONE ELSE LIKE TO SPEAK IN
01:31:42.597 --> 01:31:47.501
SUPPORT.
01:31:47.568 --> 01:31:49.403
IF YOU ARE ON THE TOP OF THE
01:31:49.470 --> 01:31:50.838
THERE'S ASSOCIATION PART BECAUSE
01:31:50.905 --> 01:31:51.405
ONCE AS OF THIS BILL ARCHER
01:31:51.472 --> 01:31:53.608
SUPPORT.
01:31:53.674 --> 01:31:54.242
THE MORNING CHANCES CALLING ON
01:31:54.308 --> 01:31:55.076
BEHALF OF THE AMERICAN
01:31:55.142 --> 01:31:56.544
ASSOCIATION OF UNIVERSITY WOMEN
01:31:56.611 --> 01:31:58.412
FOR CALIFORNIA IN SUPPORT ALSO A
01:31:58.479 --> 01:32:00.348
CO SPONSOR.
01:32:00.414 --> 01:32:02.149
THANK YOU ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT.
01:32:02.216 --> 01:32:03.451
RISKS OVER TOLD SANTA CLARA
01:32:03.517 --> 01:32:05.219
COUNTY WHICH HAVE COALITION AND
01:32:05.286 --> 01:32:06.721
CATHERINE AND GEORGE ALEXANDER
01:32:06.787 --> 01:32:10.191
COMMUNITY LAW CENTER IN SUPPORT.
01:32:10.258 --> 01:32:11.659
THANK YOU NO ONE ELSE IN SUPPORT.
01:32:11.726 --> 01:32:15.630
SEEING NONE IS THERE OPPOSITION.
01:32:15.696 --> 01:32:17.298
RIGHT SIGNAL BRING IT BACK TO
01:32:17.365 --> 01:32:19.400
THE COMMITTEE QUESTIONS COMMENTS
01:32:19.467 --> 01:32:20.935
MISTER OBERNOLTE.
01:32:21.002 --> 01:32:22.803
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR SO -- IN
01:32:22.870 --> 01:32:24.205
ADDITION TO THE GENDER IDENTITY
01:32:24.272 --> 01:32:26.073
CHANGES TO STATE LAWYER ALSO
01:32:26.140 --> 01:32:27.775
PROPOSING TO CHANGE THE BURDEN
01:32:27.842 --> 01:32:30.578
OF PROOF ON EMPLOYER FROM A
01:32:30.645 --> 01:32:33.047
GROUP OF EMPLOYEES TO A SINGLE
01:32:33.114 --> 01:32:33.447
EMPLOYEE.
01:32:33.514 --> 01:32:37.151
CAN YOU TALK ABOUT WHY YOU'RE
01:32:37.218 --> 01:32:37.785
TRYING TO DO THAT AND WHY THAT'S
01:32:37.852 --> 01:32:39.120
NECESSARY [inaudible]
01:32:39.186 --> 01:32:40.588
HI.
01:32:40.655 --> 01:32:42.423
SO -- THE LONGSTANDING
01:32:42.490 --> 01:32:44.091
INTERPRETATION OF THE BOTH
01:32:44.158 --> 01:32:45.159
FEDERAL EQUAL PAY ACT AND THE
01:32:45.226 --> 01:32:46.460
CALIFORNIA EAGLE PACK WHICH HAS
01:32:46.527 --> 01:32:47.395
BEEN MODELED AFTER THE FEDERAL
01:32:47.461 --> 01:32:49.597
EQUAL PAY ACT IS THAT A SINGLE
01:32:49.664 --> 01:32:51.232
EMPLOYEE USE BRING ANY CO PACK
01:32:51.299 --> 01:32:52.767
LAID NEEDS ONLY TO FIND.
01:32:52.833 --> 01:32:54.735
ONE COMPARATOR -- I BELIEVE THAT
01:32:54.802 --> 01:32:55.937
THAT'S REFLECTED THE COMMITTEE
01:32:56.003 --> 01:32:57.738
ANALYSIS THE CASE LAW THAT THAT
01:32:57.805 --> 01:32:59.407
THAT SUPPORTS THAT THE
01:32:59.473 --> 01:33:01.108
INTERPRETATION OF NEED ONLY --
01:33:01.175 --> 01:33:03.210
ONE COMPARED OR EMPLOYEE -- THE
01:33:03.277 --> 01:33:05.046
STATUTE ITSELF HAS A SEVEN
01:33:05.112 --> 01:33:06.914
POISONS OR MERELY CLARIFYING IT
01:33:06.981 --> 01:33:08.849
TO SAY NGUYEN PLEASE SINGULAR TO
01:33:08.916 --> 01:33:12.620
REFLECT WHAT THE CASE LAWS WERE
01:33:12.687 --> 01:33:14.088
HAS HAS HELD FOR MANY YEARS.
01:33:14.155 --> 01:33:14.922
OKAY THANK YOU SO I ACTUALLY
01:33:14.989 --> 01:33:16.090
DON'T HAVE A PROBLEM WITH THE
01:33:16.157 --> 01:33:17.725
GENDER IDENTITY PORTIONS OF THAT
01:33:17.792 --> 01:33:19.360
WATER IDEA IN SUPPORT IF THAT
01:33:19.427 --> 01:33:20.294
WAS IN THERE.
01:33:20.361 --> 01:33:22.229
I DISAGREE WITH YOUR ANALYSIS OF
01:33:22.296 --> 01:33:24.365
OUR CURRENT CASE LAW -- THERE
01:33:24.432 --> 01:33:25.199
FOR ABOUT TO BE RESPECTFUL
01:33:25.266 --> 01:33:26.567
OPPOSITION BUT IT'S A SHAME
01:33:26.634 --> 01:33:27.768
BECAUSE I WOULD LIKE TO BEEN
01:33:27.835 --> 01:33:28.669
WITH WITH YOU ON THIS BECAUSE I
01:33:28.736 --> 01:33:31.605
AGREE WITH 90% OF WHAT YOU'RE
01:33:31.672 --> 01:33:33.708
TRYING TO DO.
01:33:33.774 --> 01:33:34.241
THANK YOU OTHER QUESTIONS
01:33:34.308 --> 01:33:35.776
COMMENTS.
01:33:35.843 --> 01:33:36.811
RIGHT SEE NONE THIS CAREER YOU
01:33:36.877 --> 01:33:38.145
MAY CLOSE THANK YOU AND THANK
01:33:38.212 --> 01:33:39.347
YOU MISTER OBERNOLTE FOR THAT
01:33:39.413 --> 01:33:40.681
THAT'S CERTAINLY SOMETHING THAT
01:33:40.748 --> 01:33:41.282
WE'RE WILLING TO LOOK AT AS A
01:33:41.349 --> 01:33:42.550
SMALL MOVES FORWARD.
01:33:42.616 --> 01:33:44.051
BECAUSE WE ARE TRYING TO UPDATE
01:33:44.118 --> 01:33:45.786
THE LAW TO MAKE SURE THAT EVERY
01:33:45.853 --> 01:33:47.388
WORKER IN CALIFORNIA REGARDLESS
01:33:47.455 --> 01:33:49.857
OF GENDER ETHNICITY RACE CREED
01:33:49.924 --> 01:33:51.092
IS PROTECTED EQUALLY UNDER THE
01:33:51.158 --> 01:33:52.426
LAW SO THANK YOU FOR THAT.
01:33:52.493 --> 01:33:53.461
THANK YOU TO THE COMMITTEE
01:33:53.527 --> 01:33:55.062
STAFFER WORKING WITH MY TEAM ON
01:33:55.129 --> 01:33:56.297
THIS AS WELL AND THANK YOU
01:33:56.364 --> 01:33:58.132
MISTER CHAIR AND I RESPECTFULLY
01:33:58.199 --> 01:33:59.200
ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE.
01:33:59.266 --> 01:34:00.334
THANK YOU WE DO NEED A MOTION
01:34:00.401 --> 01:34:03.070
THE MOTIONS TO PASS TO
01:34:03.137 --> 01:34:04.005
APPROPRIATIONS.
01:34:04.071 --> 01:34:05.406
THANK YOU WE DO HAVE A MOTION
01:34:05.473 --> 01:34:06.874
AND A SECOND.
01:34:06.941 --> 01:34:09.110
CALL THE ROLL PLEASE STONE BY
01:34:09.176 --> 01:34:11.746
STONE AYE GALLAGHER -- NO CHAU
01:34:11.812 --> 01:34:12.046
[inaudible]
01:34:12.113 --> 01:34:13.748
CHIU [inaudible]
01:34:13.814 --> 01:34:15.649
GONZALEZ.
01:34:15.716 --> 01:34:17.451
GONZALEZ I HOLDEN.
01:34:17.518 --> 01:34:18.986
HOLDEN AYE KALRA.
01:34:19.053 --> 01:34:20.755
KALRA AYE KILEY.
01:34:20.821 --> 01:34:22.223
MAIENSCHEIN.
01:34:22.289 --> 01:34:24.792
MAIENSCHEIN AYE OBERNOLTE.
01:34:24.859 --> 01:34:27.261
OBERNOLTE NO PETRIE-NORRIS.
01:34:27.328 --> 01:34:28.362
NORTH AYE RADIUS.
01:34:28.429 --> 01:34:31.832
REYES I AS SEVEN DOES IT IS OUT
01:34:31.899 --> 01:34:33.167
THANK YOU THANK YOU VERY MUCH SO
01:34:33.234 --> 01:34:35.936
WE WILL NOW MOVE TO ITEM NUMBER
01:34:36.003 --> 01:34:38.406
TWENTY TWO AB.
01:34:38.472 --> 01:34:54.955
SEVENTEEN FIFTY THREE EVERYONE
01:34:58.793 --> 01:34:58.859
.
01:34:58.859 --> 01:35:08.302
YOUR LAST NAME.
01:35:08.369 --> 01:35:09.336
WELL GOOD MORNING AGAIN CHAIR
01:35:09.403 --> 01:35:12.807
AND MEMBERS I'M HERE 2% AB.
01:35:12.873 --> 01:35:13.407
SEVENTEEN FIFTY THREE A BILL
01:35:13.474 --> 01:35:14.575
THAT INSURANCE IMMIGRANTS ONLY
01:35:14.642 --> 01:35:16.377
RECEIVE A HIGHLY IMPORTANT LEGAL
01:35:16.444 --> 01:35:18.379
ADVICE FROM INDIVIDUALS WHO HAVE
01:35:18.446 --> 01:35:19.580
THE LEGAL EDUCATION AND
01:35:19.647 --> 01:35:21.248
EXPERTISE TO PROVIDE SUCH
01:35:21.315 --> 01:35:22.416
ASSISTANCE.
01:35:22.483 --> 01:35:22.983
I WOULD LIKE TO BEGIN BY
01:35:23.050 --> 01:35:24.318
THANKING THE COMMITTEE STAFF
01:35:24.385 --> 01:35:25.719
AGAIN FOR THEIR WORK ON THIS
01:35:25.786 --> 01:35:27.855
ANALYSIS I WILL BE ACCEPTING THE
01:35:27.922 --> 01:35:30.291
AMENDMENTS AS OUTLINED ON PAGE
01:35:30.357 --> 01:35:31.826
TWELVE OF THE ANALYSIS THANK YOU.
01:35:31.892 --> 01:35:33.360
THANK YOU THE IMMIGRATION
01:35:33.427 --> 01:35:35.129
CONSULTANTS AT OTHERWISE KNOWN
01:35:35.196 --> 01:35:36.664
AS THE I. C. A. REGULATES
01:35:36.730 --> 01:35:38.532
INDIVIDUALS WHO HAVE PROVIDE WHO
01:35:38.599 --> 01:35:40.301
PROVIDE IMMIGRATION ASSISTANCE.
01:35:40.367 --> 01:35:42.703
AND ARE NEITHER ATTORNEYS NOR
01:35:42.770 --> 01:35:43.704
ACCREDITED BY THE FEDERAL
01:35:43.771 --> 01:35:44.505
GOVERNMENT.
01:35:44.572 --> 01:35:45.739
THE I EE A AUTHORIZES
01:35:45.806 --> 01:35:46.907
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS TO
01:35:46.974 --> 01:35:48.476
COMPLETE IMMIGRATION FORMS UNDER
01:35:48.542 --> 01:35:50.878
CERTAIN CONDITIONS BUT PROHIBITS
01:35:50.945 --> 01:35:52.513
THEM PROVIDE FROM PROVIDING
01:35:52.580 --> 01:35:53.881
LEGAL ADVICE OR REPRESENTING
01:35:53.948 --> 01:35:54.815
CLIENTS.
01:35:54.882 --> 01:35:56.684
IN AN IMMIGRATION COURT IN JUNE
01:35:56.750 --> 01:35:58.252
OF TWENTY EIGHTEEN FEDERAL
01:35:58.319 --> 01:35:59.753
POLICY WAS MODIFIED THAT PUTS
01:35:59.820 --> 01:36:01.222
IMMIGRANTS AT A GREATER RISK OF
01:36:01.288 --> 01:36:02.623
DEPORTATION BY ALLOWING
01:36:02.690 --> 01:36:04.058
OFFICIALS TO START THE
01:36:04.125 --> 01:36:05.826
DEPORTATION PROCESS. FOR TO
01:36:05.893 --> 01:36:07.695
NIGHT IMMIGRATION PETITIONS AND
01:36:07.761 --> 01:36:08.729
TO REFER CASES TO THE
01:36:08.796 --> 01:36:09.964
IMMIGRATIONS.
01:36:10.030 --> 01:36:12.032
AND CUSTOMS ENFORCEMENT AGENCY
01:36:12.099 --> 01:36:13.767
OTHERWISE KNOWN AS ICE NO
01:36:13.834 --> 01:36:15.236
CRIMINAL OR SECURITY GROUNDS.
01:36:15.302 --> 01:36:16.804
THIS IS IMPORTANT TO MY DISTRICT
01:36:16.871 --> 01:36:18.038
BECAUSE ACCORDING TO THE US
01:36:18.105 --> 01:36:21.542
CENSUS NEARLY 35% OF LA COUNTY.
01:36:21.609 --> 01:36:23.077
TEN MILLION RESIDENTS WERE BORN
01:36:23.144 --> 01:36:25.146
IN ANOTHER COUNTRY MYSELF
01:36:25.212 --> 01:36:26.046
INCLUDED.
01:36:26.113 --> 01:36:27.781
ESTIMATES FURTHER INDICATE THAT
01:36:27.848 --> 01:36:29.817
APPROXIMATELY NINE HUNDRED AND
01:36:29.884 --> 01:36:30.417
SEVENTY THOUSAND UNDOCUMENTED
01:36:30.484 --> 01:36:31.585
IMMIGRANTS IMMIGRANTS LIVE IN LA
01:36:31.652 --> 01:36:32.653
COUNTY.
01:36:32.720 --> 01:36:34.822
MORE THAN ANY OTHER COUNTY IN
01:36:34.889 --> 01:36:36.524
OUR STATE. FOR THESE VULNERABLE
01:36:36.590 --> 01:36:38.092
COMMUNITIES HIRING AND
01:36:38.159 --> 01:36:39.527
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS OFTEN
01:36:39.593 --> 01:36:41.095
COST LESS THAN HIRING AND AN
01:36:41.162 --> 01:36:41.929
ATTORNEY.
01:36:41.996 --> 01:36:43.364
BUT THE RISK OF POTENTIAL
01:36:43.430 --> 01:36:45.099
DEPORTATION AND THE DENIAL OF
01:36:45.166 --> 01:36:46.433
CITIZENSHIP OR RESIDENCY
01:36:46.500 --> 01:36:48.702
INVOLVING HIRING A LOWER COST
01:36:48.769 --> 01:36:49.970
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANT.
01:36:50.037 --> 01:36:52.873
FAR OUTWEIGHS THE COST BENEFIT.
01:36:52.940 --> 01:36:54.542
THE CURRENT EXPANDED DISCRETION
01:36:54.608 --> 01:36:56.010
OF FEDERAL OFFICIALS TO DENY
01:36:56.076 --> 01:36:57.978
IMMIGRATION APPLICATIONS LEAVES
01:36:58.045 --> 01:36:59.747
NO ROOM FOR ERROR.
01:36:59.813 --> 01:37:01.582
IN THE ACCURACY SUBMISSION AND
01:37:01.649 --> 01:37:06.020
COMPLETENESS OF IMMIGRATION
01:37:06.086 --> 01:37:06.353
APPLICATIONS.
01:37:06.420 --> 01:37:08.389
AND E. IN OF ERRORS CAN BE
01:37:08.455 --> 01:37:09.023
RECTIFIED.
01:37:09.089 --> 01:37:09.657
AFFECTED IMMIGRANT VICTIMS OFTEN
01:37:09.723 --> 01:37:10.925
LACK THE ABILITY TO CORRECT
01:37:10.991 --> 01:37:12.493
THESE MISTAKES.
01:37:12.560 --> 01:37:14.461
BE IT FOR LACK OF RESOURCES FEAR
01:37:14.528 --> 01:37:16.931
OF RETALIATION OR A VERY REAL
01:37:16.997 --> 01:37:18.332
DISTRUST OF OUR FEDERAL
01:37:18.399 --> 01:37:19.900
GOVERNMENT AT THIS MOMENT.
01:37:19.967 --> 01:37:21.569
AB SEVENTEEN FIFTY THREE
01:37:21.635 --> 01:37:23.003
ADDRESSES THIS ISSUE BY MAKING
01:37:23.070 --> 01:37:25.005
IT UNLAWFUL FOR A PERSON OTHER
01:37:25.072 --> 01:37:26.640
THAN A LICENSED ATTORNEY OR A
01:37:26.707 --> 01:37:27.808
PERSON.
01:37:27.875 --> 01:37:29.310
OR ORGANIZATION FEDERALLY
01:37:29.376 --> 01:37:30.644
AUTHORIZED TO REPRESENT
01:37:30.711 --> 01:37:31.946
INDIVIDUALS IN IMMIGRATION
01:37:32.012 --> 01:37:33.547
MATTERS TO PROVIDE IMMIGRATION
01:37:33.614 --> 01:37:35.516
RELATED SERVICES FOR A FEE AND
01:37:35.583 --> 01:37:36.417
CALIFORNIA.
01:37:36.483 --> 01:37:38.419
HERE TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT IS
01:37:38.485 --> 01:37:39.987
CHASE OF NIKITA DIRECTOR OF THE
01:37:40.054 --> 01:37:42.690
LA COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF CONSUMER
01:37:42.756 --> 01:37:44.291
AND BUSINESS AFFAIRS.
01:37:44.358 --> 01:37:44.892
WHO HAVE ASK IS PROFESSOR OF
01:37:44.959 --> 01:37:46.260
SOUTHWESTERN SCHOOL OF LAW AND
01:37:46.327 --> 01:37:47.561
DANIEL SHARP THE LEGAL DIRECTOR
01:37:47.628 --> 01:37:49.263
OF THE CENTRAL AMERICAN RESOURCE
01:37:49.330 --> 01:37:50.197
CENTER TO PROVIDE TECHNICAL
01:37:50.264 --> 01:37:51.632
ASSISTANCE?
01:37:51.699 --> 01:37:52.866
I THANK YOU FIRST WITH US PLEASE.
01:37:52.933 --> 01:37:54.535
GOOD MORNING MISTER CHAIR AND
01:37:54.602 --> 01:37:56.503
MEMBERS I'M WE HAVE THAT FAITH
01:37:56.570 --> 01:37:58.439
ASSOCIATE CLINICAL PROFESSOR OF
01:37:58.505 --> 01:38:00.274
LAW AT SOUTHWESTERN LAW SCHOOL.
01:38:00.341 --> 01:38:01.809
I'VE DEDICATED MY CAREER TO
01:38:01.875 --> 01:38:03.611
TEACHING IMMIGRATION LAW AND
01:38:03.677 --> 01:38:05.246
PRACTICING IMMIGRATION LAW ONE
01:38:05.312 --> 01:38:07.581
OF THE MOST COMPLEX AREAS OF US
01:38:07.648 --> 01:38:08.515
LAW.
01:38:08.582 --> 01:38:10.451
THE TIME HAS COME TO OVERHAUL
01:38:10.517 --> 01:38:11.752
THE CALIFORNIA IMMIGRATION
01:38:11.819 --> 01:38:13.887
CONSULTANTS ACT WHICH WAS PASSED
01:38:13.954 --> 01:38:15.823
OVER THIRTY YEARS AGO UNDER A
01:38:15.889 --> 01:38:17.524
VERY DIFFERENT IMMIGRATION
01:38:17.591 --> 01:38:18.959
SYSTEM.
01:38:19.026 --> 01:38:20.361
UNDER TODAY'S IMMIGRATION LAWS
01:38:20.427 --> 01:38:22.396
MOST UNDOCUMENTED IMMIGRANTS DO
01:38:22.463 --> 01:38:25.232
NOT QUALIFY FOR RELIEF.
01:38:25.299 --> 01:38:26.333
I OFTEN IS THIS IMMIGRANTS
01:38:26.400 --> 01:38:28.369
WHO'VE ALREADY FALLEN VICTIM TO
01:38:28.435 --> 01:38:29.603
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS
01:38:29.670 --> 01:38:33.807
DECEPTIVE AN UNSCRUPULOUS
01:38:33.874 --> 01:38:34.541
PRACTICES.
01:38:34.608 --> 01:38:35.309
IMMIGRANTS ARE OFTEN AN
01:38:35.376 --> 01:38:36.443
UNDERSTANDABLY CONFUSED BY THE
01:38:36.510 --> 01:38:39.079
TERM IMMIGRATION CONSULTANT.
01:38:39.146 --> 01:38:40.848
AND THEY'RE OFTEN LED TO BELIEVE
01:38:40.914 --> 01:38:42.883
THAT THE TERM DENOTES A FORM OF
01:38:42.950 --> 01:38:45.719
EXPERTISE IN IMMIGRATION LAW.
01:38:45.786 --> 01:38:48.155
CONSEQUENCES OF IT IMMIGRATION
01:38:48.222 --> 01:38:50.257
CONSULTANT FILING A BOTCHED OR
01:38:50.324 --> 01:38:52.192
ILL ADVISED APPLICATION ARE
01:38:52.259 --> 01:38:53.694
DEVASTATING.
01:38:53.761 --> 01:38:54.995
THEY CAN INCLUDE IMMIGRANTS
01:38:55.062 --> 01:38:55.963
BEING PLACED IN REMOVAL
01:38:56.030 --> 01:38:57.364
PROCEEDINGS DEPORTATION
01:38:57.431 --> 01:38:59.400
PROCEEDINGS AND POSSIBLY
01:38:59.466 --> 01:39:00.934
DETENTION.
01:39:01.001 --> 01:39:03.570
SURELY BE SIX ARE TOO HIGH. FOR
01:39:03.637 --> 01:39:05.539
MERELY A BONDS AND A BACKGROUND
01:39:05.606 --> 01:39:08.075
CHECK WHICH IS THE LOW BAR UNDER
01:39:08.142 --> 01:39:09.410
THE CURRENT ACT.
01:39:09.476 --> 01:39:11.545
IMMIGRATION FORM PREPARATION IS
01:39:11.612 --> 01:39:14.315
NO LONGER A SIMPLE SERVICE AND
01:39:14.381 --> 01:39:17.117
IT REQUIRES LEGAL ADVICE.
01:39:17.184 --> 01:39:19.086
I RECENTLY CONDUCTED A THOROUGH
01:39:19.153 --> 01:39:21.822
ANALYSIS OF THE CURRENT US
01:39:21.889 --> 01:39:24.191
IMMIGRATION FORMS COMMONLY FILED
01:39:24.258 --> 01:39:26.293
BY IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS I
01:39:26.360 --> 01:39:28.329
FOUND THAT ONLY ONE FORM A SHORT
01:39:28.395 --> 01:39:30.998
HALF PAGE CHANGE OF ADDRESS FORM.
01:39:31.065 --> 01:39:33.634
CAN ACCURATELY BE COMPLETED WITH
01:39:33.701 --> 01:39:35.035
OUT THE PROVISION OF LEGAL
01:39:35.102 --> 01:39:36.070
ADVICE.
01:39:36.136 --> 01:39:37.571
SOMETHING WHICH IMMIGRATION
01:39:37.638 --> 01:39:39.506
CONSULTANTS CAN NOT STATUTORILY
01:39:39.573 --> 01:39:41.141
PROVIDE.
01:39:41.208 --> 01:39:42.509
YES IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS
01:39:42.576 --> 01:39:45.112
ROUTINELY IGNORE THESE LIMITS
01:39:45.179 --> 01:39:47.748
AND PLACE IMMIGRANTS AT RISK.
01:39:47.815 --> 01:39:49.650
IT IS IMPOSSIBLE TO DIVORCE
01:39:49.717 --> 01:39:51.652
IMMIGRATION FORM PREPARATION
01:39:51.719 --> 01:39:53.187
FROM THE PROVISION OF LEGAL
01:39:53.253 --> 01:39:54.188
ADVICE.
01:39:54.254 --> 01:39:56.023
AND CALIFORNIA'S SHOULD NO
01:39:56.090 --> 01:39:58.225
LONGER SANCTION A SYSTEM THAT
01:39:58.292 --> 01:39:59.860
IGNORES THIS REALITY.
01:39:59.927 --> 01:40:01.662
THE IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS ACT
01:40:01.729 --> 01:40:03.864
IT'S OUTDATED AND PLACES
01:40:03.931 --> 01:40:06.467
IMMIGRANTS AT E. WEBER BOWL RISK.
01:40:06.533 --> 01:40:10.471
I ENCOURAGE YOU TO SUPPORT AB
01:40:10.537 --> 01:40:11.004
SEVENTEEN FIFTY THREE AND
01:40:11.071 --> 01:40:12.906
CONTINUE CALIFORNIA'S ADMIRABLE
01:40:12.973 --> 01:40:15.275
PATH OF PROTECTING ITS IMMIGRANT
01:40:15.342 --> 01:40:17.578
COMMUNITIES THANK YOU.
01:40:17.644 --> 01:40:18.946
THANK YOU THAT'S WHAT THIS PLACE
01:40:19.012 --> 01:40:19.713
GOOD MORNING MR CHEN MEMBERS
01:40:19.780 --> 01:40:21.248
JONI KEYED ON BEHALF OF THE LA
01:40:21.315 --> 01:40:22.483
COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS AS
01:40:22.549 --> 01:40:24.585
CO SPONSOR.
01:40:24.651 --> 01:40:25.986
OF AB.
01:40:26.053 --> 01:40:26.587
SEVENTEEN FIFTY THREE I'M THE
01:40:26.653 --> 01:40:27.287
DIRECTOR OF THE LA COUNTY
01:40:27.354 --> 01:40:28.655
DEPARTMENT OF CONSUMER AND
01:40:28.722 --> 01:40:29.957
BUSINESS AFFAIRS MY DEPARTMENT
01:40:30.023 --> 01:40:31.492
IS RESPONSIBLE FOR PROTECTING
01:40:31.558 --> 01:40:32.893
OVER TEN MILLION CONSUMERS IN LA
01:40:32.960 --> 01:40:33.727
COUNTY.
01:40:33.794 --> 01:40:34.862
AND SUPPORTING BUSINESSES TO
01:40:34.928 --> 01:40:36.663
CREATE A FAIR AND THRIVING
01:40:36.730 --> 01:40:37.564
MARKET PLACE I WANT TO THANK
01:40:37.631 --> 01:40:38.966
MEMBER CREEL FOR ADVANCING THIS
01:40:39.032 --> 01:40:40.200
IMPORTANT BILL.
01:40:40.267 --> 01:40:41.502
AND THINK PROFESSOR VASQUEZ FOR
01:40:41.568 --> 01:40:42.836
HER TESTIMONY IN AS THE CHILD OF
01:40:42.903 --> 01:40:47.508
IMMIGRANTS THIS IS ALSO
01:40:47.574 --> 01:40:48.509
PERSONALLY IMPORT FOR ME AS WELL.
01:40:48.575 --> 01:40:49.643
YOU'VE JUST HEARD HOW DIFFICULT
01:40:49.710 --> 01:40:50.310
IT IS FOR IMMIGRANTS TO NAVIGATE
01:40:50.377 --> 01:40:50.878
OUR IMMIGRATION SYSTEM AND
01:40:50.944 --> 01:40:52.179
AGAINST THIS BACKDROP.
01:40:52.246 --> 01:40:53.514
AND BASED ON OUR EXPERIENCE IN
01:40:53.580 --> 01:40:55.015
LA COUNTY THE IMMIGRATION
01:40:55.082 --> 01:40:57.050
CONSULTANT ACT IS BAD FOR
01:40:57.117 --> 01:40:58.419
CONSUMERS.
01:40:58.485 --> 01:40:59.486
MOST CONSUMERS ENGAGE IN
01:40:59.553 --> 01:41:01.054
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANT BECAUSE
01:41:01.121 --> 01:41:02.790
THEY NEED SUBSTANTIVE HELP THEY
01:41:02.856 --> 01:41:03.991
MAY HAVE A GENERAL UNDERSTANDING
01:41:04.057 --> 01:41:04.625
OF WHAT OF WHAT THEY WANT TO
01:41:04.691 --> 01:41:05.659
ACHIEVE.
01:41:05.726 --> 01:41:07.361
LIKE GETTING A GREEN CARD BUT
01:41:07.428 --> 01:41:08.395
THEY WON'T KNOW HOW TO HAD IT
01:41:08.462 --> 01:41:09.897
THEY ONE OF THE QUALIFY THEY
01:41:09.963 --> 01:41:10.431
WON'T KNOW HOW TO GO ABOUT
01:41:10.497 --> 01:41:12.232
APPLYING -- WHAT FORMS TO FILL
01:41:12.299 --> 01:41:15.035
OUT A WHAT PROCEDURES TO FOLLOW?
01:41:15.102 --> 01:41:16.870
UP BUT FOR GOOD REASON THE I. C.
01:41:16.937 --> 01:41:17.971
FOR BIDS A CONSULTANT FROM
01:41:18.038 --> 01:41:19.840
PROVIDING THAT SUBSTANTIVE HELP
01:41:19.907 --> 01:41:21.375
AND THIS PUTS THE CONSULTANT.
01:41:21.442 --> 01:41:22.676
IN THE UNTENABLE POSITION OF
01:41:22.743 --> 01:41:24.344
LETTING CONSUMERS GAS AND HOW TO
01:41:24.411 --> 01:41:26.346
PROCEED OR ATTEMPTING TO GUIDE
01:41:26.413 --> 01:41:28.749
WERE ADVISED THE CONSUMER IN
01:41:28.816 --> 01:41:30.484
VIOLATION OF THE I SEE A BOTH OF
01:41:30.551 --> 01:41:32.319
WHICH COULD HAVE CATASTROPHIC
01:41:32.386 --> 01:41:34.354
OUTCOMES FOR THE CONSUMER.
01:41:34.421 --> 01:41:35.756
SOME OF OUR DATA FROM LA COUNTY
01:41:35.823 --> 01:41:36.957
BEARS THIS OUT.
01:41:37.024 --> 01:41:38.091
SINCE TWENTY TWELVE MY
01:41:38.158 --> 01:41:39.793
DEPARTMENT HAS LOGGED OVER EIGHT
01:41:39.860 --> 01:41:40.794
HUNDRED COMPLAINTS INVOLVING
01:41:40.861 --> 01:41:42.062
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS MORE
01:41:42.129 --> 01:41:44.064
THAN TWO HUNDRD AND SEVENTY
01:41:44.131 --> 01:41:45.365
LAST YEAR ALONE.
01:41:45.432 --> 01:41:46.066
I'VE HEARD IT SAID THE
01:41:46.133 --> 01:41:46.934
COMPLAINTS TYPICALLY INVOLVE
01:41:47.000 --> 01:41:48.502
CONSULTANTS WHO ARE NOT BONDED
01:41:48.569 --> 01:41:49.903
UNDER THE ICY BUT THAT DOES NOT
01:41:49.970 --> 01:41:51.104
REFLECT.
01:41:51.171 --> 01:41:52.539
OUR EXPERIENCE IN THE COUNTY.
01:41:52.606 --> 01:41:53.607
OUR DATA SHOWS UP FOR
01:41:53.674 --> 01:41:55.242
CONSULTANTS WHO HAD FOUR OR MORE
01:41:55.309 --> 01:41:56.276
COMPLAINTS AGAINST THEM INTO A
01:41:56.343 --> 01:41:58.545
SINCE TWENTY TWELVE IN OTHER
01:41:58.612 --> 01:41:59.813
WORDS THE REPEAT OFFENDERS.
01:41:59.880 --> 01:42:02.950
UP 55% OF THOSE WERE OR ARE
01:42:03.016 --> 01:42:04.751
BONDED AT IN COMPLIANCE WITH THE
01:42:04.818 --> 01:42:06.620
I. CA ONE SUCH CONSULTANT HAD
01:42:06.687 --> 01:42:07.554
OVER EIGHTY THREE COMPLAINTS
01:42:07.621 --> 01:42:08.188
HIMSELF ALONG WITH OUR
01:42:08.255 --> 01:42:09.790
DEPARTMENT BUT HE HAD HUNDREDS
01:42:09.857 --> 01:42:11.658
OF VICTIMS COME FORWARD -- WHEN
01:42:11.725 --> 01:42:13.360
IT CASES BROUGHT AGAINST THEM?
01:42:13.427 --> 01:42:14.561
SINCE TWENTY FIFTEEN THE LA
01:42:14.628 --> 01:42:15.896
COUNTY DA HAS CHARGED NUMEROUS
01:42:15.963 --> 01:42:17.231
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS OF
01:42:17.297 --> 01:42:19.032
VARIOUS CRIMES THEY VICTIMIZE
01:42:19.099 --> 01:42:20.400
MORE THAN THREE HUNDRED PEOPLE
01:42:20.467 --> 01:42:21.869
WHO COLLECTIVELY LOST OVER THREE
01:42:21.935 --> 01:42:22.970
MILLION DOLLARS AND THAT'S JUST
01:42:23.036 --> 01:42:28.375
THE LA COUNTY DA DOES REFLECT
01:42:28.442 --> 01:42:28.575
OTHER.
01:42:28.642 --> 01:42:30.777
PROSECUTING.
01:42:30.844 --> 01:42:31.411
LOOK WE'VE TRIED TO AMENDED THE
01:42:31.478 --> 01:42:32.045
I SEE A AT LEAST ELEVEN TIMES
01:42:32.112 --> 01:42:32.679
SINCE NINETEEN EIGHTY SIX WITH
01:42:32.746 --> 01:42:34.248
OVER THIRTY SUBSTANTIVE CHANGES
01:42:34.314 --> 01:42:34.715
TO STRENGTHEN CONSUMER
01:42:34.781 --> 01:42:35.849
PROTECTIONS.
01:42:35.916 --> 01:42:37.017
GET COMPLAINTS CONTINUE TO
01:42:37.084 --> 01:42:38.151
INCREASE.
01:42:38.218 --> 01:42:39.319
THERE ARE OTHER OPTIONS OUT
01:42:39.386 --> 01:42:40.754
THERE FOR IMMIGRANTS ATTORNEYS
01:42:40.821 --> 01:42:41.788
AND FEDERALLY ACCREDITED
01:42:41.855 --> 01:42:43.390
NONPROFITS WHO CAN HELP.
01:42:43.457 --> 01:42:45.025
AND I ALSO IN CLOSING WOULD LIKE
01:42:45.092 --> 01:42:46.326
TO CHALLENGE THE NOTION THAT
01:42:46.393 --> 01:42:47.895
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS PROVIDE
01:42:47.961 --> 01:42:49.263
LOW COST ALTERNATIVES TO
01:42:49.329 --> 01:42:50.564
ATTORNEYS.
01:42:50.631 --> 01:42:51.131
THAT'S REALLY AN APPLES TO
01:42:51.198 --> 01:42:53.400
ORANGES COMPARISON IMMIGRATION
01:42:53.467 --> 01:42:54.935
CONSULTANTS CANNOT PROVIDE.
01:42:55.002 --> 01:42:56.403
THE LEGAL ADVICE NEEDED TO HELP
01:42:56.470 --> 01:42:58.305
CONSUMERS IN TODAY'S IMMIGRATION
01:42:58.372 --> 01:43:00.741
LANDSCAPE EVEN SMALL ERRORS ON
01:43:00.807 --> 01:43:01.275
WAS PERCEIVED AS A ROUTINE
01:43:01.341 --> 01:43:02.242
MATTER.
01:43:02.309 --> 01:43:03.510
COULD HAVE SOME SERIOUS ADVERSE
01:43:03.577 --> 01:43:05.012
OUTCOMES AS REFLECTED IN THE
01:43:05.078 --> 01:43:07.781
BILL ANALYSIS OF WHAT THAT I
01:43:07.848 --> 01:43:08.382
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR YES
01:43:08.448 --> 01:43:10.050
VOTE.
01:43:10.117 --> 01:43:12.586
THANK YOU THAT'S WITH US WITH.
01:43:12.653 --> 01:43:14.187
I'M HERE FOR TECHNICAL
01:43:14.254 --> 01:43:15.789
ASSISTANCE ONLY SO RIGHT THANK
01:43:15.856 --> 01:43:16.323
YOU.
01:43:16.390 --> 01:43:17.591
NO ONE ELSE LIKE TO SPEAK IN
01:43:17.658 --> 01:43:20.561
SUPPORT IF YOU GIVE US YOUR NAME
01:43:20.627 --> 01:43:23.297
AND YOUR AFFILIATION PLEASE.
01:43:23.363 --> 01:43:25.632
GOOD MORNING MY NAME IS MADELINE
01:43:25.699 --> 01:43:28.302
AND I'M FROM SAN FERNANDO VALLEY
01:43:28.368 --> 01:43:31.171
AND I'M FROM THE G. Là AN I'M
01:43:31.238 --> 01:43:34.308
HERE TO SUPPORT AB. SEVENTY
01:43:34.374 --> 01:43:37.444
FIFTY THREE THANK YOU.
01:43:37.511 --> 01:43:39.980
GOOD MORNING MY NAME IS NORMAN
01:43:40.047 --> 01:43:41.982
WITH ONLINE SO.
01:43:42.049 --> 01:43:43.317
MANY THROUGH SHOWN AS FORTY TWO
01:43:43.383 --> 01:43:45.619
LEARNING HI SUPPORT LARA.
01:43:45.686 --> 01:43:50.357
AB SEVENTEEN SEP FIFTY THREE
01:43:50.424 --> 01:43:50.624
THANK YOU.
01:43:50.691 --> 01:43:53.093
THANK YOU.
01:43:53.160 --> 01:43:55.529
WHEN OF THEIR MINIMUM MILLION
01:43:55.596 --> 01:43:56.129
UNDER THING LESS OPEN ON THE
01:43:56.196 --> 01:43:58.865
WIDELY -- GOING CHILDREN.
01:43:58.932 --> 01:44:01.134
HE YOUR BY A STEP FOR YOUR UPPER
01:44:01.201 --> 01:44:06.907
BUT THE YES HE ADMITTED AS HE
01:44:06.974 --> 01:44:07.541
SHOULD THE SINK WHEN THEY THREE
01:44:07.608 --> 01:44:08.709
THANK YOU.
01:44:08.775 --> 01:44:09.276
REBEKAH GONZALEZ NATIONAL
01:44:09.343 --> 01:44:09.876
ASSOCIATION OF SOCIAL WORKERS
01:44:09.943 --> 01:44:12.379
CALIFORNIA CHAPTER IN SUPPORT.
01:44:12.446 --> 01:44:13.146
JIM LIMBURG ON BEHALF OF THE
01:44:13.213 --> 01:44:15.215
FRIENDS COMMITTEE ON LEGISLATION
01:44:15.282 --> 01:44:19.453
TO CALIFORNIA IN SUPPORT.
01:44:19.519 --> 01:44:20.887
HELLO MY NAME IS BUT THAT IS A
01:44:20.954 --> 01:44:23.023
FELLOW SIDE A FROM PALM THEN M.
01:44:23.090 --> 01:44:25.025
FROM TO LET TOLL IN A TO PUT IT
01:44:25.092 --> 01:44:31.331
THE A. B.. SEVENTEEN FIFTY THREE
01:44:31.398 --> 01:44:32.065
ONE OF THE ASK ME NUMBER SEVEN
01:44:32.132 --> 01:44:35.669
MIGHT BE AN ISSUE IN THE BAND
01:44:35.736 --> 01:44:38.538
WHILE I CENTERS.
01:44:38.605 --> 01:44:39.806
BUT A LOT OF IT.
01:44:39.873 --> 01:44:41.274
THIS IS IT THIS HE WENT BACK THE
01:44:41.341 --> 01:44:44.277
BEST THING WAS A THREAT OR
01:44:44.344 --> 01:44:48.115
SOMETHING IS GOING.
01:44:48.181 --> 01:44:48.715
TO WELL I MEAN NUMBER IT'S A
01:44:48.782 --> 01:44:51.251
MATTER OF THE PLAN FOR YOU THINK
01:44:51.318 --> 01:44:52.252
WHAT FOR YOUNGER THAT.
01:44:52.319 --> 01:44:56.089
I HAVE A THE A CITIZEN WHEN THEY
01:44:56.156 --> 01:44:58.125
THOUGHT IF THEY LAWCENTER.
01:44:58.191 --> 01:44:59.059
HELLO MY NAME IS BRIAN WHO STILL
01:44:59.126 --> 01:45:00.727
I'M FROM LOS ANGELES I'M PART OF
01:45:00.794 --> 01:45:02.029
WISE OF WHICH WORKS IT'S YOUR
01:45:02.095 --> 01:45:05.332
AND I SUPPORT THE SEVENTEEN
01:45:05.399 --> 01:45:05.932
FIFTY THREE HI MY NAME IS RICK
01:45:05.999 --> 01:45:06.900
HELDER FULLER I AM FROM PALMDALE
01:45:06.967 --> 01:45:07.534
AND I'M A MEMBER OF CHIRLA AND I
01:45:07.601 --> 01:45:11.972
SUPPORT -- AB.
01:45:12.039 --> 01:45:12.539
SEVENTEEN FIFTY THREE I ALSO
01:45:12.606 --> 01:45:13.507
FEEL THE FLOW FROM PALMDALE I'M
01:45:13.573 --> 01:45:15.642
MITCHELL ND I SUPPORT AB
01:45:15.709 --> 01:45:17.878
SEVENTEEN FIFTY THREE THANK YOU.
01:45:17.944 --> 01:45:20.213
HI MY NAME IS ME THEY YEAH --
01:45:20.280 --> 01:45:21.415
COMING YOU KNOW THEN THEY SAID
01:45:21.481 --> 01:45:21.948
WITH CHILLING SOME BUT NOT
01:45:22.015 --> 01:45:26.920
ENOUGH AND I'M SUPPORT AB.
01:45:26.987 --> 01:45:27.554
FIFTY SEVENTEEN FIFTY THREE MON
01:45:27.621 --> 01:45:28.955
MAR AND THE NUMBER THE MORE
01:45:29.022 --> 01:45:30.757
BECAUSE I WANNA.
01:45:30.824 --> 01:45:33.060
EVEN WORSE [inaudible]
01:45:33.126 --> 01:45:36.396
EARN.
01:45:36.463 --> 01:45:37.831
WERE YOU ALONE HE SAID THIS WITH
01:45:37.898 --> 01:45:39.499
IT THIS.
01:45:39.566 --> 01:45:41.835
HI MY NAME IS CAROLINE I'M WHAT
01:45:41.902 --> 01:45:44.337
I AM FROM CHILE AND NINE SUPPORT
01:45:44.404 --> 01:45:51.912
LET SEVEN THE FIFTY THREE WHAT
01:45:51.978 --> 01:45:53.213
ARE THE YES WE NOTICED THAT
01:45:53.280 --> 01:45:55.282
MICROWAVING GO UP WE AND THE
01:45:55.348 --> 01:45:55.916
LAST.
01:45:55.982 --> 01:45:58.385
HAVE RAISED THE CITY WITH A
01:45:58.452 --> 01:46:02.355
VAGUELY BUT THE CHEESE Là.
01:46:02.422 --> 01:46:05.726
CHECK IT OUT.
01:46:05.792 --> 01:46:07.961
WHEN OF FAMINE NUMBER SOUND THAT
01:46:08.028 --> 01:46:10.564
CLOSE THEN GO UP I AM GOING TO
01:46:10.630 --> 01:46:12.632
HAVE A SAY THIS IS YET THE THING
01:46:12.699 --> 01:46:14.801
WENT BY IT THAT IS?
01:46:14.868 --> 01:46:18.472
THEY'RE SO THEY'LL ORANGE.
01:46:18.538 --> 01:46:21.475
GOING TO LETTING GO -- HI GOOD
01:46:21.541 --> 01:46:22.075
MORNING MY NAME IS GOT THEIR
01:46:22.142 --> 01:46:24.377
GARCIA YOUTH ORGANIZER WHICH YOU
01:46:24.444 --> 01:46:25.011
LIE AND I STRONGLY SUPPORT THIS
01:46:25.078 --> 01:46:26.680
BILL.
01:46:26.747 --> 01:46:28.548
JAZZY GIRL WITH THE S. E. W.
01:46:28.615 --> 01:46:29.182
ESSENCES COUNTS ON SUPPORT THANK
01:46:29.249 --> 01:46:30.550
YOU.
01:46:30.617 --> 01:46:32.152
HI MORNING UNIVERSE OF THE
01:46:32.219 --> 01:46:34.020
CALIFORNIA ROOM TO SELLING IS
01:46:34.087 --> 01:46:35.789
OFTEN SUPPORT.
01:46:35.856 --> 01:46:36.556
CHRIS RESPONSE WHICH ARE THE
01:46:36.623 --> 01:46:38.592
PROUD TO BE A SPONSOR.
01:46:38.658 --> 01:46:39.226
MR CHAIRMAN MEMBERS DâN FULL
01:46:39.292 --> 01:46:39.760
ASSAULT ON BEHALF THE LOS
01:46:39.826 --> 01:46:40.560
ANGELES COUNTY DISTRICT
01:46:40.627 --> 01:46:41.161
ATTORNEY'S OFFICE PLEASE TO CO
01:46:41.228 --> 01:46:42.162
SPONSOR.
01:46:42.229 --> 01:46:42.763
NO I BOTTOM ALL REPRESENTING
01:46:42.829 --> 01:46:43.230
CALIFORNIA RURAL LEGAL
01:46:43.296 --> 01:46:44.064
ASSISTANCE FOUNDATION PROUD CO
01:46:44.131 --> 01:46:45.832
SPONSOR IN STRONG SUPPORT.
01:46:45.899 --> 01:46:46.700
ACTUALLY ARE THE CALIFORNIA
01:46:46.767 --> 01:46:48.001
DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ON BEHALF
01:46:48.068 --> 01:46:49.035
OF JOURNEY GENERAL HOBBY OF THE
01:46:49.102 --> 01:46:50.737
SENATE IN SUPPORT OF THE
01:46:50.804 --> 01:46:53.640
OUTRIGHT BAN.
01:46:53.707 --> 01:46:55.509
MY ANGER MAYES FAILURE OF
01:46:55.575 --> 01:46:58.411
CALIFORNIANS SUPPORT.
01:46:58.478 --> 01:46:59.379
VERY COURTEOUS HARLEM HALF OF
01:46:59.446 --> 01:47:01.681
THE CALIFORNIA PLAN MILLERS
01:47:01.748 --> 01:47:04.251
ASSOCIATION SUPPORT.
01:47:04.317 --> 01:47:05.752
DOES THE CENTER ON BEHALF OF
01:47:05.819 --> 01:47:06.286
EQUAL RIGHTS ADVOCATES IN
01:47:06.353 --> 01:47:07.721
SUPPORT.
01:47:07.788 --> 01:47:08.655
CAN REALLY ROSENBERGER WITH
01:47:08.722 --> 01:47:09.689
SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTERNATIONAL
01:47:09.756 --> 01:47:14.161
UNION SUPPORT.
01:47:14.227 --> 01:47:15.629
RUTH'S OVER TOBE -- CATHERINE
01:47:15.695 --> 01:47:16.630
AND GEORGE ALEXANDER COMMUNITY
01:47:16.696 --> 01:47:18.331
LAWCENTER AT SANTA CLARA
01:47:18.398 --> 01:47:21.034
UNIVERSITY LAW SCHOOL AND SANTA
01:47:21.101 --> 01:47:22.803
CLARA COUNTY WHICH THE COALITION
01:47:22.869 --> 01:47:25.739
IN SUPPORT.
01:47:25.806 --> 01:47:28.542
THANK YOU ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT.
01:47:28.608 --> 01:47:29.042
RIGHT SEEN THAT IS THEIR
01:47:29.109 --> 01:47:41.087
OPPOSITION.
01:47:41.154 --> 01:47:42.722
YOU'RE WELCOME TO COME UP TO THE
01:47:42.789 --> 01:47:56.870
TABLE COULD YOU MAKE SOME ROOM.
01:47:56.937 --> 01:47:58.305
HI MY NAME IS ERIN RAY BURKE AND
01:47:58.371 --> 01:47:59.906
I REPRESENT THE NATIONAL NOTARY
01:47:59.973 --> 01:48:01.975
ASSOCIATION AND A PORTION OF
01:48:02.042 --> 01:48:03.944
WHICH WE'VE -- WORK WITH THE
01:48:04.010 --> 01:48:05.612
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS AND WE
01:48:05.679 --> 01:48:07.080
HAVE A LOT IN THE ROOM TODAY
01:48:07.147 --> 01:48:11.184
INCLUDING TWO AT THE TABLE -- IN
01:48:11.251 --> 01:48:13.653
FRONT AND I MOSTLY HERE FOR
01:48:13.720 --> 01:48:14.721
TECHNICAL QUESTIONS AND
01:48:14.788 --> 01:48:16.556
ASSISTANCE BUT IT BEFORE I TURN
01:48:16.623 --> 01:48:17.457
IT OVER.
01:48:17.524 --> 01:48:20.126
I JUST WANT TO ADD THAT
01:48:20.193 --> 01:48:20.727
SEVENTEEN FIFTY THREE LIKE ITS
01:48:20.794 --> 01:48:23.029
PREDECESSOR AB SIX THIRTY EIGHT
01:48:23.096 --> 01:48:24.764
IS ANTI IMMIGRANT AND THAT'S WHY
01:48:24.831 --> 01:48:25.365
WE WERE.
01:48:25.432 --> 01:48:27.334
FIRST SIX THIRTY EIGHT WE HAD
01:48:27.400 --> 01:48:28.568
IMMIGRANT RIGHTS GROUPS ON BOTH
01:48:28.635 --> 01:48:30.637
SIDES OF THE BILL AND THAT'S WHY
01:48:30.704 --> 01:48:32.372
IT DIED SUCH A PAINFUL DEATH ON
01:48:32.439 --> 01:48:33.540
THE SENATE FLOOR.
01:48:33.607 --> 01:48:36.042
BECAUSE WE HAD GROUPS AND STRONG
01:48:36.109 --> 01:48:37.644
OPPOSITION TO IT AND THEY'RE
01:48:37.711 --> 01:48:39.446
SIMPLY ASKING THE PROPONENTS AND
01:48:39.512 --> 01:48:42.148
THE AUTHOR TO WORK WITH US TO
01:48:42.215 --> 01:48:43.950
ADD TRAINING STANDARDS IN
01:48:44.017 --> 01:48:45.385
EDUCATION STANDARDS.
01:48:45.452 --> 01:48:47.387
WHICH WE HAVE BEEN WILLING TO DO
01:48:47.454 --> 01:48:49.022
RATHER THAN GETTING THROWING
01:48:49.089 --> 01:48:50.957
AWAY AN ENTIRE INDUSTRY THAT DID
01:48:51.024 --> 01:48:52.692
HELP TWO HUNDRED THOUSAND
01:48:52.759 --> 01:48:53.960
IMMIGRANTS LAST YEAR.
01:48:54.027 --> 01:48:57.264
AND WITH THAT I'LL TURN IT OVER.
01:48:57.330 --> 01:48:59.199
THANK YOU SIX WITNESS PLEASE.
01:48:59.266 --> 01:49:00.400
GOOD MORNING.
01:49:00.467 --> 01:49:01.768
MY NAME IS SALLY I TRY THIS AND
01:49:01.835 --> 01:49:02.736
I HAVE BEEN IN IMMIGRATION
01:49:02.802 --> 01:49:04.938
CONSULTANT FOR THE PAST TWENTY
01:49:05.005 --> 01:49:06.506
FIVE YEARS.
01:49:06.573 --> 01:49:08.074
I WORKED AS A LIAISON CONSULAR
01:49:08.141 --> 01:49:09.643
THE DAVIS SCHOOL DISTRICT FOR
01:49:09.709 --> 01:49:11.978
MANY YEARS IN MY INVOLVEMENT
01:49:12.045 --> 01:49:12.946
WITH THE SPANISH SPEAKING
01:49:13.013 --> 01:49:14.981
PARENTS I REALIZE THE NEED FOR
01:49:15.048 --> 01:49:16.650
SERVICE PROVIDERS IN THE
01:49:16.716 --> 01:49:18.285
IMMIGRANT COMMUNITY.
01:49:18.351 --> 01:49:19.519
I WENT TO SAN FRANCISCO CITY
01:49:19.586 --> 01:49:21.221
COLLEGE TO EDUCATE MYSELF
01:49:21.288 --> 01:49:22.322
THROUGH IMMIGRATION LEGAL
01:49:22.389 --> 01:49:23.823
RESOURCE CENTER.
01:49:23.890 --> 01:49:25.191
I STARTED TEACHING CITIZENSHIP
01:49:25.258 --> 01:49:29.062
CLASSES FOR PARENTS WHO AFTER
01:49:29.129 --> 01:49:30.363
BECOMING CITIZENS.
01:49:30.430 --> 01:49:31.231
I COMPANIES THE LEGALIZATION OF
01:49:31.298 --> 01:49:33.300
THEIR OWN CHILDREN WHO WERE MY
01:49:33.366 --> 01:49:34.634
STUDENTS AND EVENTUALLY
01:49:34.701 --> 01:49:37.537
GRADUATED AND WENT ON TO COLLEGE.
01:49:37.604 --> 01:49:39.172
THERE ARE THOUSAND SIXTEEN
01:49:39.239 --> 01:49:40.273
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS WHO ARE
01:49:40.340 --> 01:49:42.008
BONDED AND REGISTER WITH THE
01:49:42.075 --> 01:49:43.143
CALIFORNIA SECRETARY OF STATE.
01:49:43.209 --> 01:49:44.945
THEN.
01:49:45.011 --> 01:49:46.112
THERE ARE THE BAD ACTORS WHO ARE
01:49:46.179 --> 01:49:47.914
NOT LAWFULLY REGISTER WHO ARE
01:49:47.981 --> 01:49:50.083
NOT BONDED TO PROTECT THE PUBLIC
01:49:50.150 --> 01:49:51.952
NOR HAVE THEY BEEN FINGERPRINTED.
01:49:52.018 --> 01:49:53.853
AB SEVENTEEN FIFTY THREE WILL
01:49:53.920 --> 01:49:55.655
NOT STOP THEM IT COULD END UP
01:49:55.722 --> 01:49:57.123
CREATING MORE FRAUD.
01:49:57.190 --> 01:49:59.492
AB SEVENTEEN FIFTY THREE WILL
01:49:59.559 --> 01:50:01.261
LEAVE MANY OF US UNJUSTLY
01:50:01.328 --> 01:50:02.595
UNEMPLOYED AND FINANCIALLY
01:50:02.662 --> 01:50:04.798
STRESS WE BELIEVE THAT WE HELP
01:50:04.864 --> 01:50:06.933
THE STATE'S ECONOMY AS WELL AS
01:50:07.000 --> 01:50:08.368
THE EMPLOYMENT INDUSTRY.
01:50:08.435 --> 01:50:10.470
THE STATE WILL NOT BENEFIT FROM
01:50:10.537 --> 01:50:11.805
THERE FROM THE AND BONDED BAD
01:50:11.871 --> 01:50:14.140
ACTORS WE NEED IMMIGRATION
01:50:14.207 --> 01:50:15.675
LAWYERS I ATTEND A YEAR YOU
01:50:15.742 --> 01:50:17.410
SEMINAR TAUGHT BY IMMIGRATION
01:50:17.477 --> 01:50:19.212
LAWYERS.
01:50:19.279 --> 01:50:21.281
WE NEED NONPROFIT ORGANIZATIONS
01:50:21.348 --> 01:50:22.882
BUT WE ALSO NEED EXPERIENCE
01:50:22.949 --> 01:50:24.417
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS IN GOOD
01:50:24.484 --> 01:50:25.986
STANDINGS.
01:50:26.052 --> 01:50:28.154
AB SEVENTEEN FIFTY THREE WELL
01:50:28.221 --> 01:50:29.856
HEARD IMMIGRANTS IF AFFORDABLE
01:50:29.923 --> 01:50:33.259
NON LEGAL IMMIGRATION HELP IS
01:50:33.326 --> 01:50:34.561
ELIMINATED.
01:50:34.627 --> 01:50:35.428
IN AN IMMIGRATION CONSULTANT IS
01:50:35.495 --> 01:50:38.231
NOT THE BUSINESS OF COMPETITION
01:50:38.298 --> 01:50:41.634
BUT A BUSINESS OF COMPASSION.
01:50:41.701 --> 01:50:43.370
I HAVE HELPED THOUSANDS AND
01:50:43.436 --> 01:50:45.171
THOUSANDS OF IMMIGRANTS
01:50:45.238 --> 01:50:46.639
ACCOMPLISH THEIR IMMIGRATION
01:50:46.706 --> 01:50:48.341
DREAM.
01:50:48.408 --> 01:50:50.076
SO AGAIN ON BEHALF.
01:50:50.143 --> 01:50:51.978
OF THE THOUSAND SIXTEEN REGISTER
01:50:52.045 --> 01:50:53.513
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS IN
01:50:53.580 --> 01:50:57.217
CALIFORNIA I RESPECTFULLY ASK.%
01:50:57.283 --> 01:51:01.121
FOR YOUR NO VOTE ON AB.
01:51:01.187 --> 01:51:03.256
SEVENTEEN THANK YOU.
01:51:03.323 --> 01:51:05.825
THANK YOU THAT'S WITH US PLEASE.
01:51:05.892 --> 01:51:06.860
THANK YOU VERY MUCH -- FOR
01:51:06.926 --> 01:51:07.727
ALLOWING ME TO VOICE MY
01:51:07.794 --> 01:51:11.531
OPPOSITION TO A. B. ONE SEVEN
01:51:11.598 --> 01:51:12.198
FIVE THREE MY NAME IS NELLIE OF
01:51:12.265 --> 01:51:13.133
A YES.
01:51:13.199 --> 01:51:14.667
AND I AM I CONCEDE TO AND
01:51:14.734 --> 01:51:16.736
TELEPHONE WILL NOT I WILL THEY
01:51:16.803 --> 01:51:18.304
BE CHIU FROM SAN FRANCISCO.
01:51:18.371 --> 01:51:19.572
I HAD BEING IT RAISED THEIR
01:51:19.639 --> 01:51:21.674
IMMIGRATION CONSULT THEM FOR
01:51:21.741 --> 01:51:22.742
TWENTY SIX YEARS IN THE SAN
01:51:22.809 --> 01:51:24.611
FRANCISCO BAY AREA.
01:51:24.677 --> 01:51:26.179
I WAS TRAINED BY THE IN WE GET A
01:51:26.246 --> 01:51:27.847
LEGALLY SUBSTANTIVE TO PROVIDE
01:51:27.914 --> 01:51:29.582
LOW INCOME IMMIGRANTS WITH
01:51:29.649 --> 01:51:30.650
IMMIGRATION SERVICES THAT DO NOT
01:51:30.717 --> 01:51:32.385
REQUIRE AN ATTORNEY.
01:51:32.452 --> 01:51:33.820
I WAS AN ACCREDITED
01:51:33.887 --> 01:51:35.388
REPRESENTATIVE AND WHAT CAN
01:51:35.455 --> 01:51:37.157
PARTNERSHIP WITH CARY SENT TO
01:51:37.223 --> 01:51:39.159
PROMOTE CITIZENSHIP THROUGH
01:51:39.225 --> 01:51:40.326
CITIZENSHIP FAIRS.
01:51:40.393 --> 01:51:42.896
I CONTINUED TO BE IN BUSINESS
01:51:42.962 --> 01:51:44.531
THANKS TO PERSONALLY FERRIS.
01:51:44.597 --> 01:51:47.000
THE CITY OF OAKLAND NAME AUGUST
01:51:47.067 --> 01:51:48.802
ELEVEN THEN THE LATEST THEY AND
01:51:48.868 --> 01:51:50.437
I RECEIVED THE PHILIP BARTON
01:51:50.503 --> 01:51:52.138
IMMIGRATION AND CIVIL RIGHTS I
01:51:52.205 --> 01:51:52.372
WORKED.
01:51:52.439 --> 01:52:01.247
HOWEVER YOU HAVE NEVER HEARD OF
01:52:01.314 --> 01:52:02.749
ME QUITE.
01:52:02.816 --> 01:52:04.217
BECAUSE I AM A GOOD HONEST
01:52:04.284 --> 01:52:05.618
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANT.
01:52:05.685 --> 01:52:06.219
YOU HEAR ABOUT THE BAD ONES.
01:52:06.286 --> 01:52:07.520
BUT YOU DON'T HEAR ABOUT THE
01:52:07.587 --> 01:52:10.924
WATER THAT THE OVER ONE THOUSAND
01:52:10.990 --> 01:52:11.524
THREE YOU STUDY CONSULTANTS.
01:52:11.591 --> 01:52:13.293
TO AND YOU WILL NEVER HEAR ABOUT
01:52:13.359 --> 01:52:15.395
US IS THIS TO BE THE PROCESS.
01:52:15.462 --> 01:52:17.130
BECAUSE WE WILL CLOSE OF
01:52:17.197 --> 01:52:17.897
BUSINESS WEEK.
01:52:17.964 --> 01:52:20.400
BUT YOU WILL CONTINUE TO HEAR
01:52:20.467 --> 01:52:22.302
ABOUT THE BAD ONES.
01:52:22.368 --> 01:52:23.736
THIS IS THE WRONG B. L. AT THE
01:52:23.803 --> 01:52:24.971
WRONG TIME.
01:52:25.038 --> 01:52:25.839
WHEN I A STEP THAT CALLING MY
01:52:25.905 --> 01:52:28.308
CLIENT SERVER AB?
01:52:28.374 --> 01:52:28.842
ONE SEVEN FIVE THREE THEY
01:52:28.908 --> 01:52:29.375
IMMEDIATELY ASKED ME IF
01:52:29.442 --> 01:52:30.844
PRESIDENT TRUMP WAS BEHIND.
01:52:30.910 --> 01:52:33.079
THERE IS ALREADY A LOT OF FEAR
01:52:33.146 --> 01:52:34.781
IN THE IMMIGRANT COMMUNITY.
01:52:34.848 --> 01:52:36.216
AND THIS BILL WILL ELIMINATE
01:52:36.282 --> 01:52:37.450
DUST A HOST WHO HAVE MADE A
01:52:37.517 --> 01:52:39.486
DIFFERENCE.
01:52:39.552 --> 01:52:41.421
I URGE YOU TO AMEND THE BILL.
01:52:41.488 --> 01:52:43.156
DON'T THEY LEAVE ME LATER IN
01:52:43.223 --> 01:52:44.357
STATE WATER WITH US TO FIND THE
01:52:44.424 --> 01:52:45.391
SOLUTION.
01:52:45.458 --> 01:52:47.260
WE HAVE OFFERED AMENDMENTS BUT
01:52:47.327 --> 01:52:48.695
NO ONE WOULD LISTEN.
01:52:48.761 --> 01:52:53.133
AB SEVEN WHAT. SEVENTEEN FIFTY
01:52:53.199 --> 01:52:54.667
FIFTY THREE WILL HELP IMMIGRANTS.
01:52:54.734 --> 01:52:57.203
AND THE GOOD THING TO GET ACTUAL
01:52:57.270 --> 01:53:00.140
BUSINESS CUSSING FINANCIAL
01:53:00.206 --> 01:53:00.707
HARDSHIP TO SINGLE MOTHERS.
01:53:00.773 --> 01:53:02.242
PAYING PENALTIES FOR BREAKING A
01:53:02.308 --> 01:53:04.310
LEASE NOT BEING ABLE TO PAY THE
01:53:04.377 --> 01:53:07.213
RENT OR MORTGAGE.
01:53:07.280 --> 01:53:08.414
WE WILL DISAPPEAR.
01:53:08.481 --> 01:53:09.816
BUT YOU WILL CONTINUE TO HEAR
01:53:09.883 --> 01:53:11.151
ABOUT THE FRAUD COMMITTED
01:53:11.217 --> 01:53:12.685
AGAINST SENIOR.
01:53:12.752 --> 01:53:14.721
I ASSURE YOU THAT.
01:53:14.787 --> 01:53:15.722
THANK YOU FOR LISTENING.
01:53:15.788 --> 01:53:17.390
THANK YOU.
01:53:17.457 --> 01:53:19.025
ANYONE ELSE IN OPPOSITION IF YOU
01:53:19.092 --> 01:53:20.160
COULD GIVE US YOUR NAME AND YOUR
01:53:20.226 --> 01:53:23.129
AFFILIATION PLEASE.
01:53:23.196 --> 01:53:23.696
YEAH I KNOW I'M FROM ORANGE
01:53:23.763 --> 01:53:24.764
COUNTY.
01:53:24.831 --> 01:53:26.966
OF I HAVE BEEN IN IMMIGRATION
01:53:27.033 --> 01:53:29.302
CONSULTANT FOR TWENTY FIVE YEARS
01:53:29.369 --> 01:53:30.470
WE'RE NOT ABLE TO TAKE YOUR
01:53:30.537 --> 01:53:32.172
TESTIMONY WAS TAKING AIM
01:53:32.238 --> 01:53:33.773
AFFILIATION OKAY SAW THREE STUDY
01:53:33.840 --> 01:53:35.909
ON A FROM ORANGE COUNTY AND I AM
01:53:35.975 --> 01:53:37.010
AGAINST IT.
01:53:37.076 --> 01:53:40.713
I WISH I COULD MAKE A FEW POINTS
01:53:40.780 --> 01:53:41.648
BUT I'M NOT ALLOWED.
01:53:41.714 --> 01:53:45.752
NO NOT AT THIS POINT OKAY.
01:53:45.818 --> 01:53:46.419
GOOD MORNING TO KIND OF
01:53:46.486 --> 01:53:47.520
AMERICA'S THE NATIONAL
01:53:47.587 --> 01:53:48.988
ASSOCIATION OF IMMIGRATION
01:53:49.055 --> 01:53:50.323
CONSULTANTS ARE NONPROFIT
01:53:50.390 --> 01:53:52.692
ORGANIZATION WE STRONGLY OPPOSE
01:53:52.759 --> 01:53:55.261
THIS BILL.
01:53:55.328 --> 01:53:56.596
MY NAME IS THEIR MOTHER
01:53:56.663 --> 01:53:57.997
GUIDELINE BEING A GONG A MISSION
01:53:58.064 --> 01:53:59.032
CONSULTANT FOR THIRTY YEARS AND
01:53:59.098 --> 01:54:00.733
I OPPOSE THE BILL.
01:54:00.800 --> 01:54:02.101
EVERYTHING ABOUT CHAIR LANDING
01:54:02.168 --> 01:54:03.136
OUT INTO THE BECAUSE SOME MONEY
01:54:03.203 --> 01:54:06.239
THEY MADE SEVEN MILLION DOLLARS
01:54:06.306 --> 01:54:09.209
A YEAR [inaudible]
01:54:09.275 --> 01:54:11.444
GOOD MORNING.
01:54:11.511 --> 01:54:13.479
MY NAME IS A WITH A YES AND I'M
01:54:13.546 --> 01:54:15.648
HERE ON BEHALF OF THE HOPS.
01:54:15.715 --> 01:54:17.217
THE SPAWNING ASSOCIATION THE
01:54:17.283 --> 01:54:19.352
PROFESSIONAL SERVICE HEY WE
01:54:19.419 --> 01:54:23.656
DELIVER EDUCATION SINCE.
01:54:23.723 --> 01:54:24.290
NINETEEN NINETY SIX SAY I HAVE
01:54:24.357 --> 01:54:26.459
THE CERTIFICATION Và WE DO HAVE
01:54:26.526 --> 01:54:27.260
CONTINUED EDUCATION.
01:54:27.327 --> 01:54:28.595
I'M SORRY WE CANNOT TAKE MORE
01:54:28.661 --> 01:54:30.964
TESTIMONY IS YOUR NAME YOUR
01:54:31.030 --> 01:54:32.432
ANGER LEAVES AND AND THAT YOU'RE
01:54:32.498 --> 01:54:36.936
THANK YOU I OPPOSE OKAY.
01:54:37.003 --> 01:54:37.804
MY NAME'S ABIGAIL MARIA HERRERA
01:54:37.870 --> 01:54:38.605
I AM THE DAUGHTER OF AN
01:54:38.671 --> 01:54:40.106
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANT AND I
01:54:40.173 --> 01:54:44.143
OPPOSE THIS BILL.
01:54:44.210 --> 01:54:45.345
MY NAME IS BETTER ESPINOZA
01:54:45.411 --> 01:54:46.312
PERSONAL FIVE HOPS HISPANIC
01:54:46.379 --> 01:54:47.914
ASSOCIATION OF PROFESSIONAL
01:54:47.981 --> 01:54:52.552
SERVICES MY POSTED THANK YOU.
01:54:52.619 --> 01:54:53.519
MY NAME IS ROSE THAT ARE THE
01:54:53.586 --> 01:54:54.454
BIGGEST FROM SAN DIEGO
01:54:54.520 --> 01:54:56.889
CALIFORNIA ON BEHALF OF HISPANIC
01:54:56.956 --> 01:54:58.825
ASSOCIATION OF PROFESSIONAL
01:54:58.891 --> 01:55:02.395
SERVICES AND I OPPOSE THE BILL.
01:55:02.462 --> 01:55:04.497
MY NAME IS SOPHIE NORMAL FROM
01:55:04.564 --> 01:55:09.836
SAN DIEGO AND AYE OPPOSED TO THE
01:55:09.902 --> 01:55:10.470
SEVENTEEN FIFTY THREE MY NAME IS
01:55:10.536 --> 01:55:11.771
MONICA TAPIA FROM.
01:55:11.838 --> 01:55:14.073
THE SAN GABRIEL VALLEY A UP A MY
01:55:14.140 --> 01:55:16.309
ENGLISH IMMIGRATION CONSULTED
01:55:16.376 --> 01:55:19.178
AND OPPOSE THE BILL THANK YOU.
01:55:19.245 --> 01:55:20.747
IT MIGHT BE ANOTHER FROM ON
01:55:20.813 --> 01:55:22.849
MONNING AYE OPPOSED TO THE BILL.
01:55:22.915 --> 01:55:24.350
JUGGLING BARRIOS FROM ORANGE
01:55:24.417 --> 01:55:26.119
COUNTY AND I STRONGLY OPPOSE
01:55:26.185 --> 01:55:28.588
THANK YOU.
01:55:28.655 --> 01:55:30.690
GREG MCEWEN -- ON BEHALF OF THE
01:55:30.757 --> 01:55:31.958
LATIN AMERICAN IMMIGRATION
01:55:32.025 --> 01:55:33.426
ASSOCIATION IN OPPOSITION OF THE
01:55:33.493 --> 01:55:37.997
BILL.
01:55:38.064 --> 01:55:39.999
MINE IS CARLOS SO DO I YOUR ON A
01:55:40.066 --> 01:55:42.969
STRONG POSITION OF THE BILL.
01:55:43.036 --> 01:55:43.603
TWENTY SEVEN YEARS ASSIMILATION
01:55:43.670 --> 01:55:45.638
SOLD.
01:55:45.705 --> 01:55:47.140
MY NAME IS GLENDA SILVA AND I'M
01:55:47.206 --> 01:55:49.876
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANT FOR
01:55:49.942 --> 01:55:50.476
NINETEEN YEARS AND AYE OPPOSED
01:55:50.543 --> 01:55:54.280
TO THE BILL.
01:55:54.347 --> 01:55:56.349
MY NAME IS JOSEPHINE A RUN FROM
01:55:56.416 --> 01:55:58.251
ORANGE COUNTY AND I OPPOSE THIS
01:55:58.318 --> 01:56:03.856
BILL.
01:56:03.923 --> 01:56:04.390
GOOD MORNING MY NAME IS --
01:56:04.457 --> 01:56:06.059
ACOSTA WITH HISPANIC COMMUNITY
01:56:06.125 --> 01:56:07.126
SERVICES HAVE BEEN TEACHING
01:56:07.193 --> 01:56:08.895
HISTORY CIVICS CLASS OF THE PAST
01:56:08.961 --> 01:56:09.962
TEN YEARS.
01:56:10.029 --> 01:56:11.731
I STRONGLY OPPOSE THIS BILL SOON
01:56:11.798 --> 01:56:15.368
HEARD IMMIGRANTS.
01:56:15.435 --> 01:56:16.936
GOOD MORNING GOOD MORNING AND I
01:56:17.003 --> 01:56:19.739
WILL BUT I BECAUSE MIX -- SO I'M
01:56:19.806 --> 01:56:22.475
I STRONGLY OPPOSED TO THIS BILL.
01:56:22.542 --> 01:56:23.443
MY NAME IS RISK WAY OUT FROM
01:56:23.509 --> 01:56:25.478
FROM MY CALIFORNIA AND I
01:56:25.545 --> 01:56:28.514
STRONGLY OPPOSE THIS BILL.
01:56:28.581 --> 01:56:29.782
GOOD MORNING MY NAME IS CAROLYN
01:56:29.849 --> 01:56:31.584
ARABIA IMMIGRATION CONSULTANT
01:56:31.651 --> 01:56:33.219
FOR NEARLY TEN YEARS.
01:56:33.286 --> 01:56:34.821
IN BEHALF OF MY CLIENTS IN
01:56:34.887 --> 01:56:36.656
BEHALF OF MY FAMILY AND MINE I
01:56:36.723 --> 01:56:39.792
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR KNOW WHAT
01:56:39.859 --> 01:56:41.694
FROM SANTA CLARA COUNTY.
01:56:41.761 --> 01:56:42.795
GOOD MORNING BILL ANDERSON
01:56:42.862 --> 01:56:44.230
NATIONAL NOTARY ASSOCIATION IN
01:56:44.297 --> 01:56:46.632
OPPOSITION THANK YOU.
01:56:46.699 --> 01:56:49.302
THANK YOU ANYONE ELSE OPPOSE.
01:56:49.369 --> 01:56:51.170
RIGHT SIGNAL BRING BACK THE
01:56:51.237 --> 01:56:55.041
COMMITTEE WAS OUT -- HAVING.
01:56:55.108 --> 01:56:56.676
TRY TO PREVIOUSLY DO BILLS IN
01:56:56.743 --> 01:56:59.545
THE SPACE TO TIGHTEN THINGS UP.
01:56:59.612 --> 01:57:02.215
I'M JUST KIND OF A DISTURBED
01:57:02.281 --> 01:57:03.249
OKAY CURIOUS WHY THE NATIONAL
01:57:03.316 --> 01:57:05.718
NOTARY ASSOCIATION IS INVOLVED
01:57:05.785 --> 01:57:08.054
IN THIS DISCUSSION.
01:57:08.121 --> 01:57:10.623
SO A PORTION OF OUR NOTARIES ARE
01:57:10.690 --> 01:57:12.458
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS AND IN
01:57:12.525 --> 01:57:14.394
THERE IN LIES THE PROBLEM IS
01:57:14.460 --> 01:57:15.661
THAT WE HAVE BEEN TRYING TO
01:57:15.728 --> 01:57:18.030
BATTLE FOR DECADES.
01:57:18.097 --> 01:57:20.633
I I REPRESENT A BORDER COMMUNITY
01:57:20.700 --> 01:57:22.368
AND THE TERM NOBODY ALL.
01:57:22.435 --> 01:57:24.971
IN SPANISH IS VERY IT MEANS VERY
01:57:25.037 --> 01:57:26.572
DIFFERENT THINGS I I DON'T
01:57:26.639 --> 01:57:28.107
UNDERSTAND AND WE HAVE BEEN
01:57:28.174 --> 01:57:29.742
TRYING TO GET THE BUSINESS OF
01:57:29.809 --> 01:57:32.845
NOTARIES OUT OF THE IMMIGRATION
01:57:32.912 --> 01:57:35.448
BUSINESS BECAUSE THE CONFUSION
01:57:35.515 --> 01:57:37.016
THAT HAS CAUSED IN THE COMMUNITY
01:57:37.083 --> 01:57:38.851
OVERT THAT SIMPLE WORD AND WE
01:57:38.918 --> 01:57:40.686
HAVE TRIED TO LEGISLATE THIS --
01:57:40.753 --> 01:57:42.121
IS SHOCKING AND WE'VE ALWAYS
01:57:42.188 --> 01:57:43.856
BEEN TOLD NO WE'RE NOT TRYING TO
01:57:43.923 --> 01:57:45.158
SUGGEST WERE ANYTHING BUT
01:57:45.224 --> 01:57:46.259
NOTARIES AND YET HERE THE
01:57:46.325 --> 01:57:48.628
NATIONAL ASSOCIATION IS HIGHLY.
01:57:48.694 --> 01:57:51.030
INVOLVED IN OPPOSING THIS BILL
01:57:51.097 --> 01:57:53.599
WHEN -- AS I UNDERSTAND THAT A
01:57:53.666 --> 01:57:55.501
LOT OF NOTARIES ARE IMMIGRATION
01:57:55.568 --> 01:57:57.103
CONSULTANTS BUT THERE'S A REASON
01:57:57.170 --> 01:57:59.238
WHY IT AND WE'RE NOT -- I'M
01:57:59.305 --> 01:58:00.640
AWARE OF THAT REASON I THINK
01:58:00.706 --> 01:58:02.708
EVERYBODY HERE I KNOW I KNOW YOU
01:58:02.775 --> 01:58:04.610
HAVE TO GET PAPERS NOTARIZED BUT
01:58:04.677 --> 01:58:06.112
WE ALSO KNOW THAT THE TERM
01:58:06.179 --> 01:58:08.014
NOBODY -- HISTORICALLY IN OUR
01:58:08.080 --> 01:58:10.583
COMMUNITY HAS BEEN USED TO PULL
01:58:10.650 --> 01:58:11.617
PEOPLE.
01:58:11.684 --> 01:58:13.219
INTO BELIEVING THAT THE HELP
01:58:13.286 --> 01:58:14.654
THAT THEY'RE GETTING IS A
01:58:14.720 --> 01:58:16.022
DIFFERENT LEVEL OF HEALTH I'M
01:58:16.088 --> 01:58:19.992
SORRY WE WILL NOT TAKE.
01:58:20.059 --> 01:58:20.993
I COMMENTS FROM THE AUDIENCE AT
01:58:21.060 --> 01:58:22.895
THIS POINT PLEASE RESPECT MS
01:58:22.962 --> 01:58:24.063
GONZALEZ AND QUITE READY.
01:58:24.130 --> 01:58:25.298
I LIVE IN THIS COMMUNITY AND
01:58:25.364 --> 01:58:27.433
AFTER BILL AFTER BILL AFTER BILL
01:58:27.500 --> 01:58:28.835
WHEN WE HAVE TRIED TO TIGHTEN
01:58:28.901 --> 01:58:31.504
THIS UP YOU CAN GO DOWN DOWN THE
01:58:31.571 --> 01:58:33.406
STREET AND SEE YOU CAN SEE THE
01:58:33.473 --> 01:58:35.107
ADS IN THE NEWSPAPER YOU CAN SEE.
01:58:35.174 --> 01:58:36.676
THE CROSS BORDER ADDS THAT WE
01:58:36.742 --> 01:58:40.346
CAN'T CONTROL SO.
01:58:40.413 --> 01:58:41.814
SO I AM SORRY PLEASE WE WILL NOT
01:58:41.881 --> 01:58:44.684
TAKE OUTBURST FROM THE AUDIENCE.
01:58:44.750 --> 01:58:45.751
I WOULD LIKE TO SEE MOVING
01:58:45.818 --> 01:58:48.154
FORWARD THE UTILIZATION OF
01:58:48.221 --> 01:58:49.622
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS UNDER AN
01:58:49.689 --> 01:58:51.924
ATTORNEY TO PROVIDE HELP TO AN
01:58:51.991 --> 01:58:53.793
ATTORNEY IN IN A KIND OF PARA
01:58:53.860 --> 01:58:54.861
LEGAL SENSE.
01:58:54.927 --> 01:58:56.262
BUT NOT ACTING ON THEIR OWN
01:58:56.329 --> 01:58:57.964
BECAUSE WE HAVE SEEN WITH WHEN I
01:58:58.030 --> 01:59:00.032
INITIALLY DID A BILL ON THIS AND
01:59:00.099 --> 01:59:01.434
AND MISC CARILLO I KNOW YOU KNOW
01:59:01.501 --> 01:59:02.101
THIS.
01:59:02.168 --> 01:59:04.337
IN MY OWN OFFICE IN MY OWN
01:59:04.403 --> 01:59:06.239
ASSEMBLY OFFICE WE HAVE EVERY
01:59:06.305 --> 01:59:07.807
SINGLE MEMBER OF MY DISTRICT
01:59:07.874 --> 01:59:09.642
OFFICE HAD A STORY ABOUT THEIR
01:59:09.709 --> 01:59:11.978
OWN FAMILIES PROBLEMS WITHIN
01:59:12.044 --> 01:59:14.614
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANT.
01:59:14.680 --> 01:59:15.948
THIS IS NOTHING THAT IS NEW. TO
01:59:16.015 --> 01:59:17.917
OUR COMMUNITY AND I UNDERSTAND
01:59:17.984 --> 01:59:19.352
THAT ALL THE PEOPLE WHO
01:59:19.418 --> 01:59:20.553
TESTIFIED TODAY AYE AYE.
01:59:20.620 --> 01:59:21.854
I THINK YOU'RE PROBABLY GOOD
01:59:21.921 --> 01:59:23.890
PEOPLE WHO ARE TRYING TO DO A
01:59:23.956 --> 01:59:25.625
GOOD SERVICE FOR COMMUNITY I
01:59:25.691 --> 01:59:27.326
DON'T THINK YOU CAME ALL THE WAY
01:59:27.393 --> 01:59:29.028
UP HERE BECAUSE YOUR HI JACKING
01:59:29.095 --> 01:59:30.363
OUR COMMUNITY BUT THERE ARE
01:59:30.429 --> 01:59:31.764
PEOPLE WHO ARE MAKING.
01:59:31.831 --> 01:59:33.132
MONEY OFF OF OUR COMMUNITY
01:59:33.199 --> 01:59:35.501
PROVIDING A BAD SERVICE AND
01:59:35.568 --> 01:59:36.936
ACTUALLY HAVE GETTING PEOPLE
01:59:37.003 --> 01:59:38.871
DEPORTED OR NOT ALLOWING THEM TO
01:59:38.938 --> 01:59:40.106
IT TO WRITE THEIR PAPERWORK
01:59:40.172 --> 01:59:41.974
BECAUSE IT'S DONE WRONG THE
01:59:42.041 --> 01:59:42.308
FIRST TIME.
01:59:42.375 --> 01:59:44.277
AND ALL OF US THERE IS NOT A
01:59:44.343 --> 01:59:45.878
SINGLE PERSON WHO I THINK
01:59:45.945 --> 01:59:47.613
TESTIFIED TODAY WHO IS NOT HEARD
01:59:47.680 --> 01:59:48.781
THOSE STORIES.
01:59:48.848 --> 01:59:50.750
SO UNTIL WE CAN FIGURE OUT HOW
01:59:50.816 --> 01:59:53.419
TO PROVIDE -- A TRUE
01:59:53.486 --> 01:59:55.354
UNDERSTANDING OF WHO THE THE THE
01:59:55.421 --> 01:59:57.790
QUALIFIED.
01:59:57.857 --> 01:59:58.824
WELL ESTABLISHED.
01:59:58.891 --> 02:00:00.693
TESTED WORKING UNDER AN ATTORNEY
02:00:00.760 --> 02:00:02.728
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANT HAS I I
02:00:02.795 --> 02:00:04.931
HAVE NO ABILITY TO DO ANYTHING
02:00:04.997 --> 02:00:06.232
BUT SUPPORT THIS BILL.
02:00:06.299 --> 02:00:08.367
AND I I WANT TO THANK YOU I KNOW
02:00:08.434 --> 02:00:08.935
IT'S A TOUGH BILL TO BRING
02:00:09.001 --> 02:00:11.404
FORWARD I KNOW I'M GOING TO GET
02:00:11.470 --> 02:00:12.605
A LOT OF A LOT OF LETTERS IN MY
02:00:12.672 --> 02:00:14.140
COMMUNITY A LOT OF VISITS FROM
02:00:14.206 --> 02:00:15.374
FOLKS WHO.
02:00:15.441 --> 02:00:16.642
OPERATE SMALL BUSINESSES MY
02:00:16.709 --> 02:00:18.044
COMMUNITY BUT THERE'S A POINT
02:00:18.110 --> 02:00:19.378
WHERE WE HAVE TO SAY THAT THE
02:00:19.445 --> 02:00:22.481
CONSEQUENCES OF THE BAD ACTORS.
02:00:22.548 --> 02:00:24.216
ON PEOPLE'S LIVELIHOODS IS TOO
02:00:24.283 --> 02:00:26.519
GREAT TO ALLOW THIS TO CONTINUE
02:00:26.586 --> 02:00:27.119
SO THANK YOU FOR THE RING AS
02:00:27.186 --> 02:00:28.020
BILL AND I MOVE.
02:00:28.087 --> 02:00:29.789
AND I'M THINKING IF YOU HAVE A
02:00:29.855 --> 02:00:30.256
I'M SORRY.
02:00:30.323 --> 02:00:31.457
WE DO HAVE A MOTION IS THERE A
02:00:31.524 --> 02:00:33.125
SECOND.
02:00:33.192 --> 02:00:36.429
AND A SECOND THANK YOU -- NO YOU
02:00:36.495 --> 02:00:37.063
CAN ONLY RESPOND IF YOU ASK THE
02:00:37.129 --> 02:00:38.130
QUESTION [inaudible]
02:00:38.197 --> 02:00:40.933
GALLAGHER.
02:00:41.000 --> 02:00:42.368
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN AND
02:00:42.435 --> 02:00:44.337
I'VE I SHARE THE CONCERN FOR MY
02:00:44.403 --> 02:00:45.504
COLLEAGUE FROM SAN DIEGO AND
02:00:45.571 --> 02:00:46.539
I'VE ACTUALLY SUPPORTED
02:00:46.606 --> 02:00:48.074
LEGISLATION THAT YOU PASS A FEW
02:00:48.140 --> 02:00:49.675
YEARS AGO.
02:00:49.742 --> 02:00:52.244
TRYING TO REGULATE THE ABUSIVE
02:00:52.311 --> 02:00:54.113
PRACTICES OF NOTORIOUS.
02:00:54.180 --> 02:00:55.615
I ACTUALLY SUPPORTED A VERY
02:00:55.681 --> 02:00:58.551
SIMILAR BILL LAST YEAR.
02:00:58.618 --> 02:01:00.419
IN IN REVIEWING THIS AGAIN AND
02:01:00.486 --> 02:01:02.888
LISTEN TO THE TESTIMONY I DO
02:01:02.955 --> 02:01:05.157
THINK THAT THAT BILL -- IT AND
02:01:05.224 --> 02:01:06.726
THIS BILL IS IS OVER BROAD I
02:01:06.792 --> 02:01:08.728
MEAN I I THINK WHAT WE'VE HIT ON
02:01:08.794 --> 02:01:09.695
IS HEY WE DO NEED.
02:01:09.762 --> 02:01:11.964
YOU KNOW BETTER TRAINING WE DO
02:01:12.031 --> 02:01:13.766
NEED TO HAVE -- YOU BETTER
02:01:13.833 --> 02:01:15.501
PRACTICES BUT TO WHAT THIS BILL
02:01:15.568 --> 02:01:17.136
SEEMS TO DO IS JUST COMPLETELY
02:01:17.203 --> 02:01:19.372
GET RID OF THE IMMIGRATION
02:01:19.438 --> 02:01:20.906
CONSULTANT.
02:01:20.973 --> 02:01:22.108
THE INDUSTRY WILL ALL TOGETHER
02:01:22.174 --> 02:01:23.075
AND I AND I THINK AS WE'VE SAID
02:01:23.142 --> 02:01:25.044
HERE NOT NOT EVERYBODY IN THAT
02:01:25.111 --> 02:01:26.412
INDUSTRY IS A BAD ACTOR IN FACT
02:01:26.479 --> 02:01:27.780
THERE'S A LOT OF GOOD ACTORS WHO
02:01:27.847 --> 02:01:29.482
ARE HELPING PEOPLE.
02:01:29.548 --> 02:01:32.018
EVERY DAY -- IN IN THIS SPACE
02:01:32.084 --> 02:01:33.786
AND SO I THINK THIS IS JUST IS
02:01:33.853 --> 02:01:37.189
JUST TOO DRASTIC OF A MOVE --
02:01:37.256 --> 02:01:38.691
AND I'M ALSO REALLY HESITANT
02:01:38.758 --> 02:01:40.326
ANYTIME THAT WE YOU KNOW AND
02:01:40.393 --> 02:01:42.328
GOVERNMENT SORT OF I MEAN
02:01:42.395 --> 02:01:44.530
ESSENTIALLY ELIMINATE AN ENTIRE --
02:01:44.597 --> 02:01:46.399
INDUSTRY YOU KNOW WITH A PIECE
02:01:46.465 --> 02:01:48.267
OF LEGISLATION I THINK BEFORE
02:01:48.334 --> 02:01:49.368
YOU TRY TO DO IS.
02:01:49.435 --> 02:01:50.803
GO TO SOMETHING THAT DRASTIC
02:01:50.870 --> 02:01:52.204
MAYBE WE SHOULD BE LOOKING AT
02:01:52.271 --> 02:01:53.773
OTHER THINGS THAT COULD HELP.
02:01:53.839 --> 02:01:54.507
ENSURE THAT THERE ARE
02:01:54.573 --> 02:01:55.975
PROTECTIONS BECAUSE I THINK
02:01:56.042 --> 02:01:57.343
EVERYBODY IN HERE CARES ABOUT
02:01:57.410 --> 02:01:58.577
ENSURING THAT.
02:01:58.644 --> 02:02:00.846
PEOPLE DO GET GOOD ADVICE THAT
02:02:00.913 --> 02:02:02.682
THINGS ARE FALL THROUGH ON WITH
02:02:02.748 --> 02:02:03.983
REGARD TO THEIR IMPORTANT
02:02:04.050 --> 02:02:06.385
IMMIGRATION -- ISSUES AND
02:02:06.452 --> 02:02:08.421
DOCUMENT SO -- NO I CAN'T
02:02:08.487 --> 02:02:11.624
SUPPORT THE BILL IN THIS FORM --
02:02:11.691 --> 02:02:13.292
AND YOU KNOW WOULD WOULD LIKE TO
02:02:13.359 --> 02:02:14.593
SEE THIS MAY BE MORE FROM THE
02:02:14.660 --> 02:02:15.594
SOMETHING THAT.
02:02:15.661 --> 02:02:17.463
YOU KNOW MAYBE IT MAYBE THERE IS.
02:02:17.530 --> 02:02:18.731
SOME COMMON GROUND THAT WE COULD
02:02:18.798 --> 02:02:20.166
THAT COULD BE REACHED WITH THE
02:02:20.232 --> 02:02:22.034
OPPOSITION -- YOU KNOW WHETHER
02:02:22.101 --> 02:02:24.437
IT'S ON TRAINING OR FURTHER
02:02:24.503 --> 02:02:27.373
PROTECTIONS OR REQUIREMENTS FOR
02:02:27.440 --> 02:02:29.375
THE CERTIFICATION.
02:02:29.442 --> 02:02:31.610
NOW I THINK THERE'S MAYBE
02:02:31.677 --> 02:02:32.878
SOMEWHERE WE CAN GET THERE SO.
02:02:32.945 --> 02:02:34.413
THAT I WOULD JUST ASK IF MAYBE
02:02:34.480 --> 02:02:35.381
YOU COULD WORK ON THAT YOU KNOW
02:02:35.448 --> 02:02:39.819
AS YOU AS YOU MOVE MOVE THE BILL.
02:02:39.885 --> 02:02:40.986
FOR THANK.
02:02:41.053 --> 02:02:41.554
THANK YOU OTHER QUESTIONS OR
02:02:41.620 --> 02:02:43.322
COMMENTS.
02:02:43.389 --> 02:02:43.889
THANK YOU FOR BRINGING THIS
02:02:43.956 --> 02:02:45.291
FORWARD JUST FROM.
02:02:45.357 --> 02:02:46.859
AND THIS COMMITTEE STANDPOINT
02:02:46.926 --> 02:02:47.593
ONE OF THE THINGS WERE VERY
02:02:47.660 --> 02:02:48.327
CONCERNED ABOUT IS UNLESS
02:02:48.394 --> 02:02:49.929
PRACTICE OF LAW AND IN THESE
02:02:49.995 --> 02:02:51.597
IMMIGRATION CASES THAT SEEMS TO
02:02:51.664 --> 02:02:54.800
BE ONE OF THE TOP AREAS THAT THE
02:02:54.867 --> 02:02:55.801
BAR.
02:02:55.868 --> 02:02:57.136
HAD NECESSARILY GONE AFTER WERE
02:02:57.203 --> 02:02:58.804
TRYING TO MAKE SURE THAT THE BAR
02:02:58.871 --> 02:02:59.171
DOES.
02:02:59.238 --> 02:03:00.806
MEET ITS PUBLIC PROTECTION
02:03:00.873 --> 02:03:02.975
OBLIGATIONS BY GOING AFTER A
02:03:03.042 --> 02:03:03.843
LICENSE PRACTICE OF LAW WITH
02:03:03.909 --> 02:03:06.412
THIS CONSTANTLY CROPS UP AS ONE
02:03:06.479 --> 02:03:07.847
OF THE MOST SIGNIFICANT ISSUES.
02:03:07.913 --> 02:03:09.782
SO IT'S STATE IT IS A DIFFICULT
02:03:09.849 --> 02:03:11.150
ISSUE I UNDERSTAND IT'S A VERY
02:03:11.217 --> 02:03:13.152
EMOTIONAL ISSUE. FOR THOSE
02:03:13.219 --> 02:03:14.487
CONSULTANTS WHO ARE.
02:03:14.553 --> 02:03:16.155
WORKING TRYING TO MAKE A LIVING
02:03:16.222 --> 02:03:17.823
IN VARIOUS AREAS THERE BUT A
02:03:17.890 --> 02:03:20.493
NUMBER OF TABS TO TRY AND
02:03:20.559 --> 02:03:22.995
ADDRESS THIS AND AND THE FACT OF
02:03:23.062 --> 02:03:23.729
THE MATTER IS A LOT OF PEOPLE
02:03:23.796 --> 02:03:24.497
GET HURT.
02:03:24.563 --> 02:03:26.632
A LOT OF OF EXAMPLES OF UNLESS
02:03:26.699 --> 02:03:28.734
HIS PRACTICE OF LAW WHICH DOES
02:03:28.801 --> 02:03:32.538
HARM THE PUBLIC AND THAT'S WHY
02:03:32.605 --> 02:03:33.806
VERY SERIOUSLY.
02:03:33.873 --> 02:03:35.007
SO THAT WAS MISS CAREER YOU MAY
02:03:35.074 --> 02:03:35.541
CLOSE.
02:03:35.608 --> 02:03:38.277
THANK YOU I'D LIKE TO THANK THE
02:03:38.344 --> 02:03:39.912
SUPPORTERS I CAME TO TESTIFY AS
02:03:39.979 --> 02:03:41.480
WELL AS THE OPPOSITION WHO IS
02:03:41.547 --> 02:03:43.282
HERE TO TESTIFY YOU HAVE A
02:03:43.349 --> 02:03:45.518
MISTER GALLAGHER TO YOUR POINT.
02:03:45.584 --> 02:03:47.219
IS CONSOLIDATING HER -- ADVOCACY
02:03:47.286 --> 02:03:49.388
AS WELL YOU DO HAVE A COMMITMENT
02:03:49.455 --> 02:03:50.756
FROM MYSELF AND FOR MY OFFICE TO
02:03:50.823 --> 02:03:52.291
CONTINUE TO WORK ON THIS BILL TO
02:03:52.358 --> 02:03:54.026
MAKE SURE THAT WE COME TO A
02:03:54.093 --> 02:03:55.561
RESOLUTION.
02:03:55.628 --> 02:03:56.195
THE DOESN'T PUT PEOPLE OUT OF
02:03:56.262 --> 02:03:57.329
BUSINESS.
02:03:57.396 --> 02:03:58.564
BUT AT THE SAME TIME AND CHORES
02:03:58.631 --> 02:03:59.965
THAT ANYONE THAT'S SEEKING
02:04:00.032 --> 02:04:01.734
IMMIGRATION HELP IN THIS MOMENT
02:04:01.801 --> 02:04:03.302
IN TIME WHEN THERE'S SO MUCH AT
02:04:03.369 --> 02:04:04.203
STAKE.
02:04:04.270 --> 02:04:06.272
HAS THE OPPORTUNITY TO RECEIVE
02:04:06.338 --> 02:04:08.073
LEGAL SERVICES FROM ANY
02:04:08.140 --> 02:04:10.309
CERTIFIED LEGAL PROVIDER
02:04:10.376 --> 02:04:11.877
FEDERALLY RECOGNIZED OR AN
02:04:11.944 --> 02:04:13.279
ATTORNEY WHEN IT COMES TO
02:04:13.345 --> 02:04:14.513
IMMIGRATION CASES.
02:04:14.580 --> 02:04:16.015
THAT'S A FORMALLY UNDOCUMENTED
02:04:16.081 --> 02:04:18.684
PERSON MYSELF I TAKE OFFENSE TO
02:04:18.751 --> 02:04:20.152
THAT I WOULD PERSONALLY DO
02:04:20.219 --> 02:04:21.954
ANYTHING THAT'S EVEN SLIGHTLY
02:04:22.021 --> 02:04:23.055
ASSOCIATED.
02:04:23.122 --> 02:04:24.190
WITH THE CURRENT PRESIDENT OF
02:04:24.256 --> 02:04:26.258
THE UNITED STATES I WOULD NEVER
02:04:26.325 --> 02:04:28.828
PUT MY COMMUNITY AT HARM'S WAY.
02:04:28.894 --> 02:04:30.863
AND THIS IS IN FACT AN EFFORT TO
02:04:30.930 --> 02:04:35.868
PROTECT THAT VERY COMMUNITY AND
02:04:35.935 --> 02:04:37.069
I RESPECTFULLY ASK.
02:04:37.136 --> 02:04:37.937
FOR NINE THANK YOU WE DO HAVE A
02:04:38.003 --> 02:04:38.971
MOTION AND A SECOND THE MOTION
02:04:39.038 --> 02:04:39.505
IS TO PASS AS AMENDED. TO
02:04:39.572 --> 02:04:40.673
APPROPRIATIONS CALL THE ROLL
02:04:40.739 --> 02:04:42.608
PLEASE STONE BY STONE AYE
02:04:42.675 --> 02:04:43.809
GALLAGHER.
02:04:43.876 --> 02:04:46.412
GALLAGHER NO CHAU CHIU.
02:04:46.478 --> 02:04:49.849
GONZALEZ GONZALEZ I HOLDEN.
02:04:49.915 --> 02:04:53.319
HOLDEN AYE KALRA.
02:04:53.385 --> 02:04:55.387
KALRA AYE KILEY MAIENSCHEIN
02:04:55.454 --> 02:04:55.688
[inaudible]
02:04:55.754 --> 02:04:58.057
OBERNOLTE [inaudible]
02:04:58.123 --> 02:04:59.658
PETRIE-NORRIS.
02:04:59.725 --> 02:05:02.561
AS I REYES.
02:05:02.628 --> 02:05:04.029
THAT NEEDS TO MORE OF THE PLACE
02:05:04.096 --> 02:05:05.164
THAT THE LAW CALL.
02:05:05.231 --> 02:05:07.299
THANK YOU.
02:05:07.366 --> 02:05:10.169
THAT TAKES US TO ITEM NUMBER
02:05:10.236 --> 02:05:12.738
SEVENTEEN AB SIXTEEN OH SEVEN MS
02:05:12.805 --> 02:05:24.183
BARNHART [inaudible]
02:05:24.250 --> 02:05:40.332
FIVE I
02:05:42.568 --> 02:05:43.836
GOOD MORNING EVERYONE
02:05:43.903 --> 02:05:45.204
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR HAVING ME.
02:05:45.271 --> 02:05:47.039
SO COULD WE PLEASE HAVE A QUITE
02:05:47.106 --> 02:05:47.640
SO WE CAN CONTINUE OUR HEARING
02:05:47.706 --> 02:05:53.712
PLEASE -- MISTER CHAIR AND
02:05:53.779 --> 02:05:55.481
MEMBERS THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR
02:05:55.547 --> 02:05:57.917
HEARING THE SPELL SIXTEEN OH
02:05:57.983 --> 02:05:58.951
SEVEN IT WOULD REQUIRE CITIES
02:05:59.018 --> 02:06:00.219
AND COUNTIES THE ISSUE LOCAL
02:06:00.286 --> 02:06:01.754
BUSINESS LICENSES TO ISSUE A
02:06:01.820 --> 02:06:03.422
NOTE NOTICE TO A BUSINESS.
02:06:03.489 --> 02:06:04.957
WITH INFORMATION ABOUT THE
02:06:05.024 --> 02:06:06.692
GENDER TAX REPEAL ACT AT THE
02:06:06.759 --> 02:06:07.993
TIME THE BUSINESS RECEIVES ITS
02:06:08.060 --> 02:06:09.128
BUSINESS LICENSE.
02:06:09.194 --> 02:06:11.330
UNDER CURRENT LAW THE GENDER TAX
02:06:11.397 --> 02:06:12.831
REPEAL ACT PROHIBITS BUSINESSES
02:06:12.898 --> 02:06:15.434
FROM CHARGING DIFFERENT PRICES
02:06:15.501 --> 02:06:17.369
FOR SERVICES BASED ON GENDER.
02:06:17.436 --> 02:06:18.070
VIOLATION OF THE FAULT RESULT IN
02:06:18.137 --> 02:06:20.172
AN AUTOMATIC FOUR THOUSAND
02:06:20.239 --> 02:06:21.907
DOLLAR STATUTORY PENALTY OR
02:06:21.974 --> 02:06:23.409
THREE TIMES THE ACTUAL DAMAGES
02:06:23.475 --> 02:06:25.444
SUFFERED WHICHEVER IS HIGHER.
02:06:25.511 --> 02:06:26.845
THE ACT ALSO REQUIRES CERTAIN
02:06:26.912 --> 02:06:29.048
BUSINESSES TO POST A NOTICE AND
02:06:29.114 --> 02:06:30.582
TWENTY FOUR POINT FONT OF THE
02:06:30.649 --> 02:06:32.618
GENDER TAX REPEAL A VIOLATION OF
02:06:32.685 --> 02:06:34.520
THIS POSTING REQUIREMENT RESULT
02:06:34.586 --> 02:06:36.255
IN A THOUSAND DOLLAR STATUTORY
02:06:36.322 --> 02:06:37.523
PENALTY.
02:06:37.589 --> 02:06:38.223
THE CHALLENGES THAT MANY
02:06:38.290 --> 02:06:39.458
BUSINESSES ESPECIALLY SMALL
02:06:39.525 --> 02:06:41.727
BUSINESSES ARE NOT AWARE THAT
02:06:41.794 --> 02:06:43.095
THIS LAW EVEN EXISTS.
02:06:43.162 --> 02:06:44.763
SOME SMALL BUSINESSES HAVE
02:06:44.830 --> 02:06:46.932
CHARGE DIFFERENT PRICES FOR
02:06:46.999 --> 02:06:47.466
SERVICES BASED ON TIME AND
02:06:47.533 --> 02:06:48.701
EFFORT.
02:06:48.767 --> 02:06:49.902
BUT THERE HAVE BEEN TARGETED
02:06:49.969 --> 02:06:51.103
WITH FRIVOLOUS LAWSUITS
02:06:51.170 --> 02:06:52.304
DEMANDING THE MINIMUM STATUTORY
02:06:52.371 --> 02:06:55.307
PAMPHLET PENALTY AND MORE.
02:06:55.374 --> 02:06:56.075
PERSONALLY THIS IS THAT
02:06:56.141 --> 02:06:57.476
IMPORTANT TO ME BECAUSE MANY OF
02:06:57.543 --> 02:06:58.544
YOU KNOW I HAVE A SMALL BUSINESS
02:06:58.610 --> 02:06:59.712
I DESIGNED SENSORY FAMILY
02:06:59.778 --> 02:07:01.113
CLOTHING FOR LITTLE GIRLS.
02:07:01.180 --> 02:07:02.648
AND THE REASON I CHOSE LITTLE
02:07:02.715 --> 02:07:03.983
GIRLS AND LITTLE BOYS IS BECAUSE
02:07:04.049 --> 02:07:05.584
IT'S MORE FUN TO DESIGN FOR
02:07:05.651 --> 02:07:08.387
LITTLE GIRLS -- BUT HAD I DONE
02:07:08.454 --> 02:07:10.990
THIS ALSO FOR BOYS I WOULD HAVE
02:07:11.056 --> 02:07:12.524
NOT KNOWN ABOUT THIS LAW AND I
02:07:12.591 --> 02:07:13.792
THINK I WOULD HAVE VIOLATED IT.
02:07:13.859 --> 02:07:15.260
AND SO THIS IS ONE OF THE SMALL
02:07:15.327 --> 02:07:17.329
THINGS WE CAN DO TO REALLY MAKE
02:07:17.396 --> 02:07:19.832
SURE SMALL BUSINESSES ARE AWARE
02:07:19.898 --> 02:07:21.433
AND THEY ARE FOLLOWING THE LAW.
02:07:21.500 --> 02:07:24.136
SO AB SIXTEEN OH SEVEN WOULD
02:07:24.203 --> 02:07:25.604
REQUIRE CITY OR COUNTY.
02:07:25.671 --> 02:07:26.505
WHO ISSUES ISSUES THE BUSINESS
02:07:26.572 --> 02:07:27.606
LICENSE TO NOTICE?
02:07:27.673 --> 02:07:29.208
GIVE NOTICE OF THE GENDER TAX
02:07:29.274 --> 02:07:31.643
REPEAL ACT OF THE TIME THE
02:07:31.710 --> 02:07:32.277
BUSINESS RECEIVES ITS BUSINESS
02:07:32.344 --> 02:07:32.978
LIFE.
02:07:33.045 --> 02:07:34.880
IN ADDITION AB SIXTEEN OH SEVEN
02:07:34.947 --> 02:07:35.481
WHAT AUTHORIZED THE CITY OR
02:07:35.547 --> 02:07:37.049
COUNTY TO INCREASE THE FEES FOR
02:07:37.116 --> 02:07:38.283
A BUSINESS LICENSE TO RECOVER
02:07:38.350 --> 02:07:40.019
THE ACTUAL COSTS ASSOCIATED WITH
02:07:40.085 --> 02:07:41.186
THE ISSUING THIS NOTICE.
02:07:41.253 --> 02:07:42.955
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR AYE
02:07:43.022 --> 02:07:44.390
VOTE AND WITH ME HERE TODAY IS
02:07:44.456 --> 02:07:47.126
JENNIFER BARRERA FROM THE CAL
02:07:47.192 --> 02:07:48.494
CHAMBER TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OF
02:07:48.560 --> 02:07:48.994
THIS BILL.
02:07:49.061 --> 02:07:49.595
THANK YOU THE MORNING MISTER
02:07:49.661 --> 02:07:50.763
CHAIR AND MEMBERS OF THE
02:07:50.829 --> 02:07:51.463
COMMITTEE JENNIFER BROWN WE HAVE
02:07:51.530 --> 02:07:52.631
THE CALIFORNIA CHAMBER OF
02:07:52.698 --> 02:07:53.832
COMMERCE AND WE ARE IN SUPPORT
02:07:53.899 --> 02:07:54.933
AND PLEASE TO SPONSOR THIS BILL
02:07:55.000 --> 02:07:56.035
WE HAVE SEEN.
02:07:56.101 --> 02:07:58.337
INSTANCES IN WHICH SMALL
02:07:58.404 --> 02:07:59.638
BUSINESSES HAVE BEEN.
02:07:59.705 --> 02:08:01.206
BASICALLY SUBJECT TO FRIVOLOUS
02:08:01.273 --> 02:08:02.875
LAWSUITS -- FOR PRICE
02:08:02.941 --> 02:08:04.510
DIFFERENTIALS THAT THEY'RE ABLE
02:08:04.576 --> 02:08:06.245
TO JUSTIFY BUT THE COST OF THE
02:08:06.311 --> 02:08:07.746
FENCE IS JUST SIMPLY TOO HIGH
02:08:07.813 --> 02:08:10.082
FOR THEM TO ENGAGE IN -- AND
02:08:10.149 --> 02:08:11.050
THEY'VE BEEN LEVERAGED BY SOME
02:08:11.116 --> 02:08:12.351
UNSCRUPULOUS I WOULD SAY
02:08:12.418 --> 02:08:14.119
PLAINTIFFS ATTORNEYS -- FOR THE
02:08:14.186 --> 02:08:15.754
AUTOMATIC FOUR THOUSAND DOLLARS
02:08:15.821 --> 02:08:17.856
IN STATUTORY DAMAGES EVEN THOUGH
02:08:17.923 --> 02:08:19.158
THE DIFFERENCE IN PRICING IS NOT
02:08:19.224 --> 02:08:20.726
A NOMINAL LIKE TWENTY CENTS I
02:08:20.793 --> 02:08:22.027
THINK ON A DRY CLEANING AND IT
02:08:22.094 --> 02:08:23.362
WAS JUSTIFIED BY THE TIME AND
02:08:23.429 --> 02:08:24.663
EFFORT ENGAGED IN SO.
02:08:24.730 --> 02:08:26.098
WE'RE JUST HOPING TO PROTECT
02:08:26.165 --> 02:08:27.466
SMALL BUSINESSES BY GIVING THEM
02:08:27.533 --> 02:08:29.201
NOTICE UP FRONT OF WHAT THIS LAW
02:08:29.268 --> 02:08:30.836
REQUIRES SO THAT ONE THEY CAN
02:08:30.903 --> 02:08:32.337
SATISFY THE POSTING REQUIREMENT
02:08:32.404 --> 02:08:33.672
AND NOT BE SUBJECT TO THE
02:08:33.739 --> 02:08:34.873
THOUSAND DOLLAR PENALTY AND TWO
02:08:34.940 --> 02:08:36.341
IF THEY ARE GOING TO HAVE PRICE
02:08:36.408 --> 02:08:37.443
DIFFERENTIALS.
02:08:37.509 --> 02:08:38.844
THAT THAT PRICE DIFFERENTIAL IS
02:08:38.911 --> 02:08:40.279
OBJECTIVE AND THEY ARE INFORMED
02:08:40.345 --> 02:08:41.680
AND THE CONSUMERS INFORMED ON
02:08:41.747 --> 02:08:42.781
WHAT THE DIFFERENCES SO THAT
02:08:42.848 --> 02:08:44.383
THEY CAN AVOID A POTENTIALLY
02:08:44.450 --> 02:08:45.517
THESE FRIVOLOUS LAWSUITS THAT
02:08:45.584 --> 02:08:46.752
THEY'VE BEEN SUBJECTED TO AND SO
02:08:46.819 --> 02:08:49.788
WE AGAIN -- PLEASE TO SPONSOR
02:08:49.855 --> 02:08:50.422
AND SUPPORT AND ASK FOR YOUR AYE
02:08:50.489 --> 02:08:56.261
VOTE.
02:08:56.328 --> 02:08:57.796
THANK YOU ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT.
02:08:57.863 --> 02:08:58.931
I THINK THAT IS THEIR OPPOSITION.
02:08:58.997 --> 02:08:59.531
SEEING NONE BRING BACK TO THE
02:08:59.598 --> 02:09:02.401
COMMITTEE QUESTIONS COMMENTS.
02:09:02.468 --> 02:09:03.602
SEEING NONE YOU MAY CLOSE.
02:09:03.669 --> 02:09:05.337
THANK YOU SO MUCH I RESPECTFULLY
02:09:05.404 --> 02:09:07.106
ASK FOR YOUR AYE VOTE I VOTE ON
02:09:07.172 --> 02:09:09.241
AB SIXTEEN OF SEVEN THANK YOU I
02:09:09.308 --> 02:09:11.443
DO NEED A MOTION.
02:09:11.510 --> 02:09:12.544
THANK YOU WE DO HAVE A MOTION A
02:09:12.611 --> 02:09:14.546
SECOND THE MOTION IS TO PASS TO
02:09:14.613 --> 02:09:15.314
APPROPRIATIONS CALL THE ROLL
02:09:15.380 --> 02:09:17.282
PLEASE STONE BY STONE AYE
02:09:17.349 --> 02:09:18.350
GALLAGHER.
02:09:18.417 --> 02:09:22.020
GALLAGHER I CHAU CHIU AND SALAS.
02:09:22.087 --> 02:09:23.722
CONSULT AYE HOLDEN.
02:09:23.789 --> 02:09:25.157
HOLDEN AYE KALRA.
02:09:25.224 --> 02:09:27.593
KALRA AYE KILEY MAIENSCHEIN
02:09:27.659 --> 02:09:31.463
OBERNOLTE PETRIE-NORRIS.
02:09:31.530 --> 02:09:34.733
PETRIE-NORRIS I REYES.
02:09:34.800 --> 02:09:35.501
THAT NEEDS ONE MORE -- PLACE IT
02:09:35.567 --> 02:09:37.369
ON CALL THANK YOU.
02:09:37.436 --> 02:09:38.370
MR TANG.
02:09:38.437 --> 02:09:40.873
SPRING THIS TO ITEM NUMBER
02:09:40.939 --> 02:09:51.950
FOURTEEN A. B..
02:09:52.017 --> 02:09:53.118
THIRTEEN SIXTY MORNING -- MISTER
02:09:53.185 --> 02:09:56.188
MEMBERS -- AB THIRTEEN SIXTY
02:09:56.255 --> 02:09:57.356
ESTABLISHES JUST BASIC HEALTH
02:09:57.422 --> 02:09:59.758
AND SAFETY STANDARDS FOR GROCERY
02:09:59.825 --> 02:10:01.360
DELIVERY THROUGH ONLINE
02:10:01.426 --> 02:10:02.294
PLATFORMS.
02:10:02.361 --> 02:10:03.929
IT JUST GIVE EXAMPLE THE BILL
02:10:03.996 --> 02:10:05.631
REQUIRES DELIVERY PERSON OF A
02:10:05.697 --> 02:10:07.132
FOOD HANDLER CARD.
02:10:07.199 --> 02:10:08.300
THAT ASKED DELIVERY VEHICLE TO
02:10:08.367 --> 02:10:11.203
ME VEHICLE CODE STANDARDS.
02:10:11.270 --> 02:10:12.404
HOUSE THAT THE ONLINE PLATFORM
02:10:12.471 --> 02:10:13.539
DRIVER TO ENSURE FOOD IS
02:10:13.605 --> 02:10:15.641
TRANSPORTED MEETING SPECIFIED
02:10:15.707 --> 02:10:17.910
HEALTH AND SAFETY STANDARDS.
02:10:17.976 --> 02:10:18.443
THE AND AGAIN.
02:10:18.510 --> 02:10:19.444
WHEN WE GO TO THE GROCERY STORE
02:10:19.511 --> 02:10:20.579
THE FOOD IS HANDLED IN A
02:10:20.646 --> 02:10:21.947
PARTICULAR WAY WE JUST WANT TO
02:10:22.014 --> 02:10:22.681
MAKE SURE?
02:10:22.748 --> 02:10:25.217
THAT AS IT'S DELIVERED THAT WE
02:10:25.284 --> 02:10:26.852
CONTINUE TO MAINTAIN THAT SAME --
02:10:26.919 --> 02:10:29.054
CONSUMER SAFETY AND THAT HEALTH
02:10:29.121 --> 02:10:30.556
SAME HEALTH STANDARDS.
02:10:30.622 --> 02:10:32.191
WITHOUT A RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
02:10:32.257 --> 02:10:34.560
IDLE FOR A. B. THIRTEEN SIXTEEN
02:10:34.626 --> 02:10:35.794
HAVE WITNESSED.
02:10:35.861 --> 02:10:36.962
THANK YOU FIRST WHAT IS PLEASE
02:10:37.029 --> 02:10:38.096
GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIR NUMBERS.
02:10:38.163 --> 02:10:39.565
MY NAME IS DANIEL CURRY AND I
02:10:39.631 --> 02:10:41.033
REPRESENT THE UNITED FOOD AND
02:10:41.099 --> 02:10:42.501
COMMERCIAL WORKERS UNION WESTERN
02:10:42.568 --> 02:10:43.902
STATES COUNCIL.
02:10:43.969 --> 02:10:45.037
I'M HERE TODAY SPEAKING ON
02:10:45.103 --> 02:10:47.372
BEHALF OF OVER ONE HUNDRED
02:10:47.439 --> 02:10:51.543
SEVENTY THOUSAND UNION MEMBERS
02:10:51.610 --> 02:10:53.111
TO SUPPORT.
02:10:53.178 --> 02:10:53.745
THIRTEEN SIXTY THIS BILL CLOSES
02:10:53.812 --> 02:10:54.513
THE GAP IN LIABILITY COVERAGE
02:10:54.580 --> 02:10:55.547
THAT EXISTS FOR CONSUMERS TO USE
02:10:55.614 --> 02:10:56.782
FOOD DELIVERY PLATFORMS AND FOR
02:10:56.848 --> 02:10:57.316
WORKERS OF THOSE DELIVERY
02:10:57.382 --> 02:10:58.183
PLATFORMS.
02:10:58.250 --> 02:11:00.819
AB THIRTEEN SIXTEEN SURE IS THAT
02:11:00.886 --> 02:11:01.587
OF CONSUMER WORKER.
02:11:01.653 --> 02:11:03.455
SUFFERS HARM AS A RESULT THE
02:11:03.522 --> 02:11:04.856
FOOD DELIVERY PLATFORM THAT
02:11:04.923 --> 02:11:06.458
VICTIM IS NOT LEFT BEAR THE
02:11:06.525 --> 02:11:07.526
COSTS.
02:11:07.593 --> 02:11:09.161
I WELCOME ANY QUESTIONS YOU HAVE
02:11:09.228 --> 02:11:10.696
THANK YOU.
02:11:10.762 --> 02:11:13.432
THANK YOU ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT.
02:11:13.498 --> 02:11:26.979
I'D SEEN THAT IS OUR OPPOSITION.
02:11:27.045 --> 02:11:28.146
MR CHAN MEMBERS COURT IN JENSEN
02:11:28.213 --> 02:11:29.181
WITH TECH MATT HERE TODAY IN
02:11:29.248 --> 02:11:32.217
OPPOSITION TO AB -- THIRTEEN
02:11:32.284 --> 02:11:33.619
SIXTY WE DO NOT BELIEVE THIS
02:11:33.685 --> 02:11:35.187
BILL WILL MITIGATE ANY POTENTIAL
02:11:35.254 --> 02:11:36.788
FOOD SAFETY CONCERNS RELATED TO
02:11:36.855 --> 02:11:38.056
THE DELIVERY OF FOOD.
02:11:38.123 --> 02:11:40.025
FOOD SAFETY AND CONSUMER TRUST
02:11:40.092 --> 02:11:41.593
IS A TOP PRIORITY FOR TECHNICS
02:11:41.660 --> 02:11:43.228
MEMBER COMPANIES AND WE HAVE
02:11:43.295 --> 02:11:44.630
DONE MUCH TO WORK WITH OUR
02:11:44.696 --> 02:11:46.865
RETAIL AND GROCERY PARTNERS TO
02:11:46.932 --> 02:11:47.666
DELIVER FOOD.
02:11:47.733 --> 02:11:49.534
AND AND HAVE IMPLEMENTED RACE
02:11:49.601 --> 02:11:50.969
BASED FOOD SAFETY MEASURES
02:11:51.036 --> 02:11:52.471
APPROPRIATE FOR THE POTENTIAL
02:11:52.537 --> 02:11:54.039
FOOD SAFETY RISKS.
02:11:54.106 --> 02:11:55.607
BUT SIMPLY THIS BILL IS TRYING
02:11:55.674 --> 02:11:56.708
TO FIT THE THIRD PARTY FOOD
02:11:56.775 --> 02:11:58.477
DELIVERY INDUSTRY INTO A BOX
02:11:58.543 --> 02:12:00.012
THEY DON'T FIT IN THIS WILL
02:12:00.078 --> 02:12:01.546
STIFLE THIS INNOVATION AND HARM
02:12:01.613 --> 02:12:03.148
CONSUMERS AND BUSINESSES IN THE
02:12:03.215 --> 02:12:03.715
STATE.
02:12:03.782 --> 02:12:05.484
NOT TO MENTION THE ELIMINATION
02:12:05.550 --> 02:12:07.152
OF EARNING POTENTIAL OF TENS OF
02:12:07.219 --> 02:12:08.787
THOUSANDS OF CALIFORNIANS WHO
02:12:08.854 --> 02:12:10.789
MAKE MONEY ON THESE PLATFORMS.
02:12:10.856 --> 02:12:13.392
AB THIRTEEN SIXTY SINGLES OUT
02:12:13.458 --> 02:12:15.527
COMPANIES THAT SERVE CONSUMERS
02:12:15.594 --> 02:12:16.728
BY PROVIDING CONVENIENCE AND
02:12:16.795 --> 02:12:21.099
CHOICE TO HAVE FOOD STORE WHICH
02:12:21.166 --> 02:12:22.801
INCREASES THE MARKET RESEARCH OF
02:12:22.868 --> 02:12:24.503
THOSE MARKET REACH OF THOSE
02:12:24.569 --> 02:12:26.138
BUSINESSES.
02:12:26.204 --> 02:12:28.073
THERE'S TWO BASIC MODELS JUST TO
02:12:28.140 --> 02:12:29.541
GIVE YOU A LITTLE IDEA OF THESE
02:12:29.608 --> 02:12:31.610
PLATFORMS -- FIRST FOR MANY
02:12:31.677 --> 02:12:33.378
GROCERY FOOD DELIVERY ORDERS A
02:12:33.445 --> 02:12:35.213
CUSTOMER SUBMITS IN ORDER TO THE
02:12:35.280 --> 02:12:36.181
GROCERY STORE AND A GROCERY
02:12:36.248 --> 02:12:38.016
STORE EMPLOYEE ASSEMBLES THE
02:12:38.083 --> 02:12:39.017
ORDER.
02:12:39.084 --> 02:12:40.419
AND THEN THE DRIVER WORKING ON
02:12:40.485 --> 02:12:41.887
THE DELIVERY PLATFORM PICKS UP
02:12:41.953 --> 02:12:43.255
THE ORDER AND DELIVERS THAT TO
02:12:43.322 --> 02:12:45.924
THE CUSTOMER. FOR OTHER ORDERS A
02:12:45.991 --> 02:12:47.059
SHOPPER GOES TO THE GROCERY
02:12:47.125 --> 02:12:49.061
STORE PICKS UP THE GROCERIES IN
02:12:49.127 --> 02:12:50.595
THE SAME WAY THE CONSUMER WOULD
02:12:50.662 --> 02:12:52.431
AND THEN THE SHOPPER ACTS LIKE
02:12:52.497 --> 02:12:53.432
THIS CONSUMER.
02:12:53.498 --> 02:12:55.100
THAT PAYS FOR THE GROCERIES AND
02:12:55.167 --> 02:12:56.468
TRANSPORTS THEM TO THE CONSUMERS
02:12:56.535 --> 02:12:57.803
HOME.
02:12:57.869 --> 02:12:59.304
SO FOR THE BILL IT BY ONE OF THE
02:12:59.371 --> 02:13:00.872
PROVISIONS THE BILL REQUIRES ADD
02:13:00.939 --> 02:13:02.374
THESE DRIVERS HAVE FOOD HANDLER
02:13:02.441 --> 02:13:04.376
CARDS NOT EVEN GROCERY STORE
02:13:04.443 --> 02:13:07.446
pSAME THING AS THE SHOPPERS WOULD
02:13:07.512 --> 02:13:08.013
DO.
02:13:08.080 --> 02:13:09.014
ARE REQUIRED TO HAVE FOOD
02:13:09.081 --> 02:13:11.116
HANDLER CARDS ONLY THOSE
02:13:11.183 --> 02:13:12.751
EMPLOYEES THAT PREPARE AND SERVE
02:13:12.818 --> 02:13:14.820
FOOD ARE REQUIRED TO HAVE FOOD
02:13:14.886 --> 02:13:15.620
HANDLER CARDS.
02:13:15.687 --> 02:13:16.855
DIFFERENT FOOD HANDLER CARD
02:13:16.922 --> 02:13:19.024
PROGRAM REQUIRES A NINETY MINUTE
02:13:19.091 --> 02:13:20.992
COURSE AND THEN PASSING A FORTY
02:13:21.059 --> 02:13:23.295
QUESTION TEST FOCUS ON HOW FOOD
02:13:23.362 --> 02:13:26.131
IS PREPARED AND SERVED NOTHOW
02:13:26.198 --> 02:13:27.699
FOOD IS GONNA PICKED UP FROM THE
02:13:27.766 --> 02:13:29.134
GROCERY STORE AND THEN DELIVERED
02:13:29.201 --> 02:13:30.268
TO A CONSUMER.
02:13:30.335 --> 02:13:31.436
SO THE INTENT OF THE FOOD
02:13:31.503 --> 02:13:33.171
HANDLER CARD HAS ALWAYS BEEN FOR
02:13:33.238 --> 02:13:34.473
WORKERS AT RESTAURANTS AND OTHER
02:13:34.539 --> 02:13:35.841
ESTABLISHMENTS WHERE FOOD IS
02:13:35.907 --> 02:13:37.142
BEING PREPARED AND SERVE WHICH
02:13:37.209 --> 02:13:38.543
IS NOT THE CASE FOR THESE
02:13:38.610 --> 02:13:39.945
DRIVERS SIMPLY COLLECTING.
02:13:40.011 --> 02:13:41.813
AND DELIVERING PACKAGE PRODUCTS
02:13:41.880 --> 02:13:43.148
TO A CONSUMER.
02:13:43.215 --> 02:13:44.416
THEY DID SOME HURDLE OF THIS
02:13:44.483 --> 02:13:45.884
WOULD REQUIRE THAT DELIVERY
02:13:45.951 --> 02:13:47.185
DRIVERS WOULD HAVE TO HAVE THIS
02:13:47.252 --> 02:13:48.520
FOOD HANDLER CARD WHICH WOULD BE
02:13:48.587 --> 02:13:50.021
A ROAD BLOCK FOR MANY OF THESE
02:13:50.088 --> 02:13:52.023
DRIVERS WHO JUST DO THIS -- TO
02:13:52.090 --> 02:13:53.525
MAKE A LITTLE BIT OF EXTRA MONEY --
02:13:53.592 --> 02:13:55.127
WHILE DOING OTHER JOBS OR
02:13:55.193 --> 02:13:57.763
RAISING AT CHILD OR BEING A
02:13:57.829 --> 02:13:59.398
STUDENT -- THERE'S MANY OTHER
02:13:59.464 --> 02:14:00.732
PROVISIONS IN THIS BILL THAT WE
02:14:00.799 --> 02:14:03.602
HAVE CONCERNS WITH THE FINAL ONE
02:14:03.668 --> 02:14:05.170
I'LL MENTION IS THAT.
02:14:05.237 --> 02:14:05.637
THE BILL WOULD REQUIRE
02:14:05.704 --> 02:14:06.905
CALIFORNIA WOULD SUPPLANT
02:14:06.972 --> 02:14:09.207
CALIFORNIA'S LEADING REGULATORY
02:14:09.274 --> 02:14:10.876
GUIDANCE ON I'LL CALL DELIVERY --
02:14:10.942 --> 02:14:12.344
UNDERSTANDING THIS NOT THE GEO
02:14:12.411 --> 02:14:14.312
COMMITTEE BUT AND FOR THAT I'LL
02:14:14.379 --> 02:14:15.313
CALL DELIVERY SECTION THE
02:14:15.380 --> 02:14:18.283
CALIFORNIA ABC IS OCTOBER TWO
02:14:18.350 --> 02:14:18.917
THOUSAND ELEVEN GUIDANCE ON THE
02:14:18.984 --> 02:14:21.353
THIRD PARTY PROVIDERS -- CREATED
02:14:21.420 --> 02:14:24.055
INEFFECTIVE REGULATORY REGIME
02:14:24.122 --> 02:14:28.059
FOR THIRD PARTY DELIVERY DRIVER
02:14:28.126 --> 02:14:30.195
A DELIVERY OF OUT HALL AND THEN
02:14:30.262 --> 02:14:30.796
A NUMBER OF OTHER STATES HAVE
02:14:30.862 --> 02:14:31.363
ACTUALLY TAKEN AND USED AS A
02:14:31.430 --> 02:14:32.297
MODEL THERE'S NO REASON THAT
02:14:32.364 --> 02:14:32.931
THIS BILL IS NEEDED TO SUPPLANT
02:14:32.998 --> 02:14:34.499
THAT REGULATORY SCHEME.
02:14:34.566 --> 02:14:35.901
I'LL WRAP UP BY SAYING THAT ARE
02:14:35.967 --> 02:14:37.569
MET MEMBER COMPANIES PROVIDE TO
02:14:37.636 --> 02:14:39.304
THEIR SHOPPERS INFORMATION THEY
02:14:39.371 --> 02:14:41.173
NEED TO SAFELY PERFORM THE WORK
02:14:41.239 --> 02:14:42.240
THAT THEY DO WHICH IS SIMPLY
02:14:42.307 --> 02:14:44.309
GOING AND PICKING UP GROCERIES
02:14:44.376 --> 02:14:45.544
AND DELIVERING IT.
02:14:45.610 --> 02:14:46.711
AND WE DO NOT THINK THAT SIT
02:14:46.778 --> 02:14:48.046
BIDDING THIS INNOVATIVE INDUSTRY
02:14:48.113 --> 02:14:49.981
INTO A PRE EXISTING ON RELATED
02:14:50.048 --> 02:14:51.416
REGULATORY FRAMEWORK IS IT
02:14:51.483 --> 02:14:53.819
APPROPRIATE AND I THINK YOU AND
02:14:53.885 --> 02:14:56.621
ASK FOR KNOW ABOUT THANK YOU.
02:14:56.688 --> 02:14:57.122
THANK YOU ANYONE ELSE IN
02:14:57.189 --> 02:15:00.459
OPPOSITION.
02:15:00.525 --> 02:15:04.095
BOB MARTIN HERE ON BEHALF OF
02:15:04.162 --> 02:15:04.463
GROUP.
02:15:04.529 --> 02:15:06.398
OF ALBERTSON'S SAFEWAY -- WE ARE
02:15:06.465 --> 02:15:07.299
HERE WAS A LITTLE LATE
02:15:07.365 --> 02:15:09.100
OPPOSITION AND WE'RE NOT A 100%
02:15:09.167 --> 02:15:10.135
SURE IT'S OPPOSITION MY CLIENT
02:15:10.202 --> 02:15:11.369
HAS REVIEWED THE BILL AND HAS
02:15:11.436 --> 02:15:12.838
IDENTIFIED SOME CONCERNS
02:15:12.904 --> 02:15:15.407
RELATIVE TO THE BUSINESS MODEL.
02:15:15.474 --> 02:15:16.908
THAT THEY USE FOR HOME DELIVERY
02:15:16.975 --> 02:15:18.176
WE LOOK FORWARD TO WORKING WITH
02:15:18.243 --> 02:15:20.245
MR TANG THE SPONSORS AND HIS
02:15:20.312 --> 02:15:22.113
STAFF TO GET SOME CLARIFICATION
02:15:22.180 --> 02:15:24.683
BUT AS WRITTEN THEY DO HAVE SOME
02:15:24.749 --> 02:15:26.418
SERIOUS CONCERNS SO WE WANTED TO
02:15:26.485 --> 02:15:29.621
GET ON THE RECORD SO THANK YOU.
02:15:29.688 --> 02:15:34.059
THANK YOU.
02:15:34.125 --> 02:15:34.659
GOOD MORNING LOWER CURTIS ON
02:15:34.726 --> 02:15:35.327
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA CHAMBER
02:15:35.393 --> 02:15:36.628
OF COMMERCE ALSO IN OPPOSITION
02:15:36.695 --> 02:15:38.330
FOR THE REASONS PREVIOUSLY
02:15:38.396 --> 02:15:40.198
STATED THANK YOU.
02:15:40.265 --> 02:15:40.699
THANK YOU ANYONE ELSE IN
02:15:40.765 --> 02:15:41.466
OPPOSITION.
02:15:41.533 --> 02:15:42.567
RIGHT SIGNAL BRING IT BACK TO
02:15:42.634 --> 02:15:44.970
THE COMMITTEE [inaudible]
02:15:45.036 --> 02:15:48.707
QUESTIONS COMMENTS.
02:15:48.773 --> 02:15:49.341
RIGHT SIGNALED VISITING YOU MAY
02:15:49.407 --> 02:15:50.141
CLOSE.
02:15:50.208 --> 02:15:51.042
AGAIN THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR I
02:15:51.109 --> 02:15:53.378
WE VERY MUCH APPRECIATE THE
02:15:53.445 --> 02:15:55.313
OPPOSITIONS -- FEEDBACK AND
02:15:55.380 --> 02:15:56.481
COMMENTS.
02:15:56.548 --> 02:15:58.216
AGAIN THIS IS AN INDUSTRY THAT
02:15:58.283 --> 02:15:59.818
I'VE USED -- TO PERSONALLY AS A
02:15:59.885 --> 02:16:01.720
CONSUMER AND I'M A BIG FAN OF
02:16:01.786 --> 02:16:03.355
HOWEVER WE DO WANT TO MAKE SURE
02:16:03.421 --> 02:16:06.625
THAT THERE ARE -- FOOD IN SAFETY --
02:16:06.691 --> 02:16:08.527
HANDLING STANDARDS ESPECIALLY AS
02:16:08.593 --> 02:16:10.295
THIS INDUSTRY EXPANDS AND MORE
02:16:10.362 --> 02:16:12.731
MORE PEOPLE USE THEM WE SEE THIS
02:16:12.797 --> 02:16:15.000
INDUSTRY AS A CONTINUUM OF
02:16:15.066 --> 02:16:16.468
WHAT'S HAPPENING IN THE GROCERY
02:16:16.535 --> 02:16:17.502
STORES AND AGAIN.
02:16:17.569 --> 02:16:19.571
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FIVE OH FOR
02:16:19.638 --> 02:16:22.541
A. B..
02:16:22.607 --> 02:16:23.875
THIRTEEN SIXTY THANK YOU.
02:16:23.942 --> 02:16:24.609
LOOKING FOR A MOTION.
02:16:24.676 --> 02:16:25.677
WE HAVE A MOTION AND A SECOND
02:16:25.744 --> 02:16:27.178
THANK YOU MOTIONS TO PASS TO
02:16:27.245 --> 02:16:28.747
APPROPRIATIONS CULTURAL PLEASE
02:16:28.813 --> 02:16:31.650
STONE BY STONE AYE GALLAGHER
02:16:31.716 --> 02:16:32.617
CHAU.
02:16:32.684 --> 02:16:36.655
CHIU GONZALEZ CONSULT BY HOLDEN.
02:16:36.721 --> 02:16:38.790
HOLDEN AYE KALRA.
02:16:38.857 --> 02:16:41.426
KALRA AYE KILEY MAIENSCHEIN.
02:16:41.493 --> 02:16:44.930
OBERNOLTE PETRIE-NORRIS
02:16:44.996 --> 02:16:45.230
[inaudible]
02:16:45.297 --> 02:16:50.068
I REYES.
02:16:50.135 --> 02:16:53.371
THE BILL NEEDS TO MORE -- PLACE
02:16:53.438 --> 02:16:55.607
IT ON CALL THANK YOU MISTER TECH.
02:16:55.674 --> 02:17:00.645
THAT BRINGS US TO MISTER REAVIS.
02:17:00.712 --> 02:17:13.491
ITEM NUMBER EIGHTEEN A. B..
02:17:13.558 --> 02:17:14.092
SIXTEEN TWENTY EIGHT AS CHAIR
02:17:14.159 --> 02:17:16.795
OUR GOOD MORNING COMMITTEE
02:17:16.861 --> 02:17:17.662
MEMBERS AND COLLEAGUES OKAY WE
02:17:17.729 --> 02:17:23.468
DO HAVE A MOTION AND A SECOND.
02:17:23.535 --> 02:17:24.803
HOW DOES IT WELL I -- FIRST ONE
02:17:24.869 --> 02:17:26.671
TO SAY GOOD MORNING -- AND TO
02:17:26.738 --> 02:17:27.706
THE COMMITTEE STAFF I REALLY
02:17:27.772 --> 02:17:29.341
APPRECIATE THE WORK ON THE
02:17:29.407 --> 02:17:30.842
ANALYSIS SO I KNOW I HAVEN'T
02:17:30.909 --> 02:17:32.243
BEEN HERE VERY LONG BUT THE
02:17:32.310 --> 02:17:32.777
ANALYSIS WAS GLOWING SO I
02:17:32.844 --> 02:17:35.447
APPRECIATE IT -- BUT NOT LAST
02:17:35.513 --> 02:17:37.148
YEAR ATTORNEY GENERAL HABIA BUT
02:17:37.215 --> 02:17:38.583
SERRA HIS THAT WAS THE BUREAU OF
02:17:38.650 --> 02:17:40.318
ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE -- ANY DID
02:17:40.385 --> 02:17:42.020
SO TO PROTECT PEOPLE AND
02:17:42.087 --> 02:17:43.455
COMMUNITIES.
02:17:43.521 --> 02:17:44.656
PEOPLE COMMUNITIES IN OUR STATE
02:17:44.723 --> 02:17:46.524
THAT INDOOR A DISPROPORTIONATE
02:17:46.591 --> 02:17:48.727
SHARE OF ENVIRONMENTAL POLLUTION
02:17:48.793 --> 02:17:50.261
AND PUBLIC HEALTH HAZARDS.
02:17:50.328 --> 02:17:51.763
SO AS THE COMMITTEE ANALYSIS
02:17:51.830 --> 02:17:53.765
STATES TOO FREQUENTLY ARE STATES
02:17:53.832 --> 02:17:56.301
LOWER INCOME -- THE COMMUNITIES
02:17:56.368 --> 02:17:58.136
OF COLOR EXPERIENCE FAR GREATER
02:17:58.203 --> 02:17:59.738
IMPACTS FROM POLLUTION FROM
02:17:59.804 --> 02:18:02.874
TOXICS.
02:18:02.941 --> 02:18:04.175
FROM THE TOXIC -- CONTAMINATION
02:18:04.242 --> 02:18:04.943
AND THE EFFECTS OF GLOBAL
02:18:05.010 --> 02:18:06.444
WARMING THAN RICHER AREAS OF THE
02:18:06.511 --> 02:18:07.579
STATE.
02:18:07.646 --> 02:18:08.613
UNFORTUNATELY THESE THESE
02:18:08.680 --> 02:18:13.251
IMPACTED AREAS AND THE CAT THAT
02:18:13.318 --> 02:18:15.220
COMMUNITIES OFTEN LACK RESOURCES
02:18:15.286 --> 02:18:17.288
AND OPPORTUNITIES. TO MAKE SURE
02:18:17.355 --> 02:18:19.724
THAT WE THAT WE COMBAT SUCH
02:18:19.791 --> 02:18:21.226
ENVIRONMENTAL HARMS.
02:18:21.292 --> 02:18:23.595
AND RARELY RARELY THEY POSSESS
02:18:23.662 --> 02:18:24.195
THE MEANS TO REPRESENT THEIR
02:18:24.262 --> 02:18:26.131
INTERESTS THEIR CONCERNS IN
02:18:26.197 --> 02:18:28.500
COURT OR BEFORE THE APPROPRIATE
02:18:28.566 --> 02:18:29.868
STATE AGENCY OR REGULATORS.
02:18:29.934 --> 02:18:32.637
THUS THEY HAVE BEEN DENIED A KEY
02:18:32.704 --> 02:18:34.406
ROLE OR A VOICE IN DECISIONS
02:18:34.472 --> 02:18:36.107
THAT AFFECT THE QUALITY OF THEIR
02:18:36.174 --> 02:18:37.108
LIVES.
02:18:37.175 --> 02:18:39.210
SO AS A RESULT THIS BILL AB
02:18:39.277 --> 02:18:39.844
SIXTY TWENTY EIGHT IT DOES TWO
02:18:39.911 --> 02:18:41.179
THINGS FIRST IT WOULD INCLUDE
02:18:41.246 --> 02:18:42.681
THE ATTORNEY GENERAL AND THE
02:18:42.747 --> 02:18:44.582
NEWLY ESTABLISHED DOJ'S BUREAU
02:18:44.649 --> 02:18:46.384
ENVIRONMENTAL.
02:18:46.451 --> 02:18:48.119
JUSTICE -- TO TO THE LIST OF
02:18:48.186 --> 02:18:49.120
AGENCIES THAT THE GOVERNOR'S
02:18:49.187 --> 02:18:50.555
OFFICE OF PLANNING RESEARCH MUST
02:18:50.622 --> 02:18:52.424
COORDINATE WITH REGARDING
02:18:52.490 --> 02:18:53.658
CALIFORNIA'S ENVIRONMENTAL
02:18:53.725 --> 02:18:54.893
JUSTICE PROGRAMS.
02:18:54.959 --> 02:18:57.762
AND SECOND RECOGNIZING THE NEED
02:18:57.829 --> 02:18:59.531
FOR ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE --
02:18:59.597 --> 02:19:01.966
THESE COMMUNITIES TO BE INVOLVED
02:19:02.033 --> 02:19:03.001
TO BE ENGAGED WITH STATE
02:19:03.068 --> 02:19:04.636
GOVERNMENT AND TO TRULY HAVE
02:19:04.703 --> 02:19:06.271
AGENCY IN THE DECISIONS THAT
02:19:06.337 --> 02:19:07.072
IMPACT THEM.
02:19:07.138 --> 02:19:08.173
AT THIS BILL EXPANDS THE
02:19:08.239 --> 02:19:09.140
DEFINITION OF ENVIRONMENTAL
02:19:09.207 --> 02:19:10.975
JUSTICE TO INCLUDE MEANINGFUL
02:19:11.042 --> 02:19:12.477
ENGAGEMENT. TO ENSURE THAT OUR
02:19:12.544 --> 02:19:14.412
STATE IS MEANING FULLY ENGAGING
02:19:14.479 --> 02:19:16.715
PEOPLE OF ALL RACES CULTURES AND
02:19:16.781 --> 02:19:17.615
INCOMES.
02:19:17.682 --> 02:19:19.117
WHEN MAKING THESE DECISIONS
02:19:19.184 --> 02:19:20.819
ABOUT ENVIRONMENTAL PROGRAMS AND
02:19:20.885 --> 02:19:21.986
SO WITH THAT MISTER CHAIR I DO
02:19:22.053 --> 02:19:24.122
HAVE THE BILL'S SPONSOR WITH US
02:19:24.189 --> 02:19:26.024
HERE TODAY FROM THE CALIFORNIA
02:19:26.091 --> 02:19:29.427
JUSTICE ALLIANCE AND ALLOW THEM
02:19:29.494 --> 02:19:32.397
TO TO DO SOME SELF?
02:19:32.464 --> 02:19:33.531
THANK YOU CHRIS WITNESS PLEASE
02:19:33.598 --> 02:19:36.735
[inaudible] ONE OF OKAY.
02:19:36.801 --> 02:19:37.869
A GOOD MORNING CHAIR MEMBERS MY
02:19:37.936 --> 02:19:38.536
NAME IS TIFFANY AND I'M WITH THE
02:19:38.603 --> 02:19:39.304
CALIFORNIA ENVIRONMENTAL JUST
02:19:39.370 --> 02:19:40.004
ALLIANCE.
02:19:40.071 --> 02:19:43.675
A SALES A PROUD SPONSOR OF AB
02:19:43.742 --> 02:19:44.209
SIXTEEN TWENTY EIGHT WHICH
02:19:44.275 --> 02:19:44.876
ADVANCE IN THE FORMAL JUSTICE ON
02:19:44.943 --> 02:19:46.211
THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA IN TWO
02:19:46.277 --> 02:19:47.846
IMPORTANT WAYS.
02:19:47.912 --> 02:19:49.647
FIRST BY REQUIRING THE OFF TO
02:19:49.714 --> 02:19:51.916
PLAY RESEARCH TO CONSULTS WITH
02:19:51.983 --> 02:19:52.751
ATTORNEY GENERAL'S BUREAU VJ ON
02:19:52.817 --> 02:19:54.552
EASY PROGRAMS WE BELIEVE THAT
02:19:54.619 --> 02:19:55.720
THE STRESS AND COORDINATION
02:19:55.787 --> 02:19:57.322
WOULD HELP TO ENSURE THAT MORE
02:19:57.388 --> 02:19:58.423
EASY COMMITTEES.
02:19:58.490 --> 02:19:59.557
THAT PREDOMINATE LOW INCOME
02:19:59.624 --> 02:20:00.892
COMMUNITIES OF COLOR WOULD
02:20:00.959 --> 02:20:02.961
RECEIVE GREATER PROTECTIONS
02:20:03.027 --> 02:20:03.528
INCREASE RESOURCES AND MORE
02:20:03.595 --> 02:20:06.064
SUPPORT WHEN IT COMES TO THE
02:20:06.131 --> 02:20:07.132
NEED TO PROTECT THEIR HEALTH AND
02:20:07.198 --> 02:20:08.466
LIVELIHOODS.
02:20:08.533 --> 02:20:09.734
WE'VE ALREADY SEEN THE
02:20:09.801 --> 02:20:10.335
DIFFERENCE AT THE AGE OF YOUR
02:20:10.402 --> 02:20:11.936
HAS MADE IN SEASON COMMUTES
02:20:12.003 --> 02:20:13.037
ACROSS CALIFORNIA.
02:20:13.104 --> 02:20:17.776
I LOOK FORWARD TO THEIR ENHANCE
02:20:17.842 --> 02:20:18.810
COORDINATION WITH OPR.
02:20:18.877 --> 02:20:19.878
SECOND WE ARE EXCITED ABOUT THE
02:20:19.944 --> 02:20:20.645
BILL'S INCLUSION OF MEANINGFUL
02:20:20.712 --> 02:20:21.212
ENGAGEMENTS AND THE STATE'S
02:20:21.279 --> 02:20:23.114
DEFINITION OF ENVIRONMENTAL
02:20:23.181 --> 02:20:23.515
JUSTICE.
02:20:23.581 --> 02:20:24.115
I DID THIS CONCERT WITH A LINE
02:20:24.182 --> 02:20:25.750
CALIFORNIA DEFINITION MORE WITH
02:20:25.817 --> 02:20:27.218
THE FEDERAL DEFINITION OF VJ.
02:20:27.285 --> 02:20:28.553
I WOULD IN ADVANCE PROCEDURAL
02:20:28.620 --> 02:20:30.155
JUSTICE NOT JUST DISTRIBUTIVE
02:20:30.221 --> 02:20:33.057
JUSTICE WHEN IT COMES -- TO
02:20:33.124 --> 02:20:34.058
INFORMAL JUSTICE.
02:20:34.125 --> 02:20:35.493
WHILE WE THE CURRENT DEFINITION
02:20:35.560 --> 02:20:36.761
DOES DISCUSS THE NEED TO
02:20:36.828 --> 02:20:37.529
EQUITABLY DISTRIBUTE
02:20:37.595 --> 02:20:39.230
ENVIRONMENTAL BENEFITS AND
02:20:39.297 --> 02:20:40.732
PROTECTIONS TO ALL PEOPLE
02:20:40.799 --> 02:20:43.568
REGARDLESS OF RACE CLASS GENDER
02:20:43.635 --> 02:20:45.270
ECCENTRIC THEIR BACKGROUNDS.
02:20:45.336 --> 02:20:45.937
ATTY MEANINGFUL ENGAGEMENT WOULD
02:20:46.004 --> 02:20:47.505
SET A CLEAR MESSAGE TO DECISION
02:20:47.572 --> 02:20:49.240
MAKERS FROM THE STATE LEVEL TO
02:20:49.307 --> 02:20:50.942
THE LOCAL LEVEL THAT FRONT LINE
02:20:51.009 --> 02:20:51.976
AFFECTED COMMITTEES A RESIDENTS
02:20:52.043 --> 02:20:53.778
DESERVE TO BE AT THE TABLE WHEN
02:20:53.845 --> 02:20:55.380
IMPORT DECISIONS ARE BEING MADE
02:20:55.446 --> 02:20:56.815
THAT AFFECT THEIR ENVIRONMENTAL
02:20:56.881 --> 02:20:58.183
HEALTH AND OUTCOMES.
02:20:58.249 --> 02:20:58.850
AND WE ALSO WANT RECOGNIZE THAT
02:20:58.917 --> 02:21:02.887
THEY ALSO HAVE LOCAL EXPERTISE
02:21:02.954 --> 02:21:04.889
ON EACH ISSUES.
02:21:04.956 --> 02:21:06.090
LASTLY SO HOW WOULD LIKE TO
02:21:06.157 --> 02:21:06.658
APPRECIATE IT SO THE MEMBER
02:21:06.724 --> 02:21:07.325
REVERSE WAS LEADERSHIP ON THESE
02:21:07.392 --> 02:21:08.226
IMPORTANT ISSUES.
02:21:08.293 --> 02:21:09.127
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR AYE
02:21:09.194 --> 02:21:11.196
VOTE THANK YOU SO MUCH THANK YOU
02:21:11.262 --> 02:21:13.398
THANK GOODNESS PLEASE.
02:21:13.464 --> 02:21:14.766
<c.red>I -- GOOD MORNING CHAIRMAN AND</c>
02:21:14.833 --> 02:21:15.867
MEMBERS THAT MY NAME IS JASIM
02:21:15.934 --> 02:21:17.001
JOHNSON AND I'M WITH PHYSICIANS
02:21:17.068 --> 02:21:18.102
FOR SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY LOS
02:21:18.169 --> 02:21:19.871
ANGELES AND WE ARE -- A MEMBER
02:21:19.938 --> 02:21:21.973
OF SAY HI AND WE STRONGLY
02:21:22.040 --> 02:21:24.843
SUPPORT THIS BILL -- AS GOING
02:21:24.909 --> 02:21:25.944
USING HEALTH BERMAN SOCIOPATHS
02:21:26.010 --> 02:21:27.145
ARE AWAY I EXAMINE THE CRITICAL
02:21:27.212 --> 02:21:28.112
ROLE THAT LAND USE AND PLANNING
02:21:28.179 --> 02:21:29.814
PLAY IN THE HEALTH AND SAFETY
02:21:29.881 --> 02:21:31.516
AND WELL BEING OF COMMUNITY
02:21:31.583 --> 02:21:32.450
RESIDENTS.
02:21:32.517 --> 02:21:33.718
AND REQUIRED FOR NATION BETWEEN --
02:21:33.785 --> 02:21:35.320
OPR AS WELL AS ALL OTHER
02:21:35.386 --> 02:21:38.790
OVERSIGHT AGENCIES AND THE AG'S --
02:21:38.857 --> 02:21:40.091
BIERMAN RAMIL JUSTICE WILL ONLY
02:21:40.158 --> 02:21:41.092
FURTHER STRENGTHEN POLICIES PUT
02:21:41.159 --> 02:21:43.528
IN PLACE TO UP LIFT AND I'M
02:21:43.595 --> 02:21:45.163
PROTECT OVER BRING COMMUNITIES.
02:21:45.230 --> 02:21:47.031
IN IN CALIFORNIA EVEN MORE
02:21:47.098 --> 02:21:48.433
IMPORTANTLY THIS FEAR WILL BE
02:21:48.500 --> 02:21:49.467
ABLE TO REMEDY INSTANCES
02:21:49.534 --> 02:21:50.602
ENVIRONMENT AND JUSTICE WHERE
02:21:50.668 --> 02:21:52.237
IT'S NOT BEING PROPERLY ADDRESS
02:21:52.303 --> 02:21:54.005
SUCH AS MANY INSTANCES OF
02:21:54.072 --> 02:21:55.740
INCOMPATIBLE AND USE AND SOUTH
02:21:55.807 --> 02:21:58.109
AND SOUTHEAST LA -- ADDITIONALLY
02:21:58.176 --> 02:22:00.545
SIXTEEN SB SIX AND TWENTY EIGHT
02:22:00.612 --> 02:22:01.980
BY FORMALLY ESTABLISHING AGES
02:22:02.046 --> 02:22:03.348
BUILT ON EACH DAY ENSURE THAT
02:22:03.414 --> 02:22:03.915
THERE'S A PERMANENT BODY IN
02:22:03.982 --> 02:22:04.849
PLACE TO IMPROVE ENFORCEMENT OF
02:22:04.916 --> 02:22:08.286
ENVIRONMENTAL LAWS AND BEHALF OF
02:22:08.353 --> 02:22:08.753
ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE
02:22:08.820 --> 02:22:09.320
COMMUNITIES.
02:22:09.387 --> 02:22:10.054
AND IS ESPECIALLY IMPORTANT
02:22:10.121 --> 02:22:11.289
PLACES WHERE THE LITTLE VERY
02:22:11.356 --> 02:22:13.224
LITTLE RESOURCES ON OR INTEREST
02:22:13.291 --> 02:22:14.225
FOR LOCAL ENFORCEMENT OR EVEN
02:22:14.292 --> 02:22:15.927
REGULATORY FAILURE.
02:22:15.994 --> 02:22:17.028
ENVIRONMENT JUSTICE HAS STRONG
02:22:17.095 --> 02:22:18.897
ROOTS IN THE CIVIL RIGHTS
02:22:18.963 --> 02:22:20.598
MOVEMENT YET IS OFTEN CARPETED
02:22:20.665 --> 02:22:22.533
BY INDUSTRY AND OTHERS WHO CARE
02:22:22.600 --> 02:22:25.136
LITTLE FOR THE HEALTH AND WELL
02:22:25.203 --> 02:22:25.770
BEING A FRONT LINE COMMITTEES.
02:22:25.837 --> 02:22:28.106
LASTLY BUT OF GREAT IMPORTANCE
02:22:28.172 --> 02:22:29.474
AND CLICK WITH GREAT INSIGHT
02:22:29.540 --> 02:22:30.375
EXCITEMENT -- IS THE BILL'S
02:22:30.441 --> 02:22:32.143
EXPANSION OF THE DEFINITION OF
02:22:32.210 --> 02:22:33.811
ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE.
02:22:33.878 --> 02:22:34.445
LOW INCOME COMMUNITIES
02:22:34.512 --> 02:22:35.980
COMMUNITIES OF COLOR AS WELL AS
02:22:36.047 --> 02:22:37.048
UNINCORPORATED COMMUNITIES
02:22:37.115 --> 02:22:38.516
DISPROPORTIONATELY BY THE BURDEN
02:22:38.583 --> 02:22:40.051
OF POLLUTION AND OF OUR MELINDA
02:22:40.118 --> 02:22:41.085
COLLECT.
02:22:41.152 --> 02:22:42.720
YET THEY OFTEN -- AS ASSEMBLY
02:22:42.787 --> 02:22:43.922
MEMBER MENTIONED HAVE LITTLE
02:22:43.988 --> 02:22:45.223
RESOURCES AT THEIR DISPOSAL TO
02:22:45.290 --> 02:22:46.457
BE ABLE TO ENGAGE -- WITH
02:22:46.524 --> 02:22:48.092
REGULATORY AGENCIES TO ADDRESS
02:22:48.159 --> 02:22:51.062
THESE ISSUES -- RESIDENTS OFTEN
02:22:51.129 --> 02:22:53.298
HAVE TO FIGHT TO SIMPLY HAVE AND
02:22:53.364 --> 02:22:56.134
PUT ABOUT A POTENTIALLY HAS THIS
02:22:56.200 --> 02:22:56.701
WAS SO HE'S MOVING TO THEIR
02:22:56.768 --> 02:22:57.835
NEIGHBORHOODS AND MOREOVER IT IS
02:22:57.902 --> 02:22:59.237
THE HISTORICAL LACK OF
02:22:59.304 --> 02:22:59.837
COMMUNICATION THAT IS PLACES
02:22:59.904 --> 02:23:01.272
COMMUNITIES IN THE CONDITIONS
02:23:01.339 --> 02:23:02.840
THAT THEY'RE CURRENTLY ENTERING.
02:23:02.907 --> 02:23:03.908
ESSENTIALLY ENVIRONMENTAL
02:23:03.975 --> 02:23:05.710
JUSTICE WITHOUT MANY BOOKING
02:23:05.777 --> 02:23:08.179
ENGAGEMENT IS SIMPLY NOT JUSTICE.
02:23:08.246 --> 02:23:19.857
WE GREATLY APPRECIATE SOMEONE
02:23:19.924 --> 02:23:21.659
ASSEMBLY MEMBER REDUCES LEADER
02:23:21.726 --> 02:23:22.627
SHIP AND PRIORITIZING
02:23:22.694 --> 02:23:23.928
PRACTICALLY ADDRESSING A FAMILY
02:23:23.995 --> 02:23:26.631
JUSTICE AND ENSURING CLEAN SAFE
02:23:26.698 --> 02:23:27.198
AND HEALTHY NEIGHBORHOODS IN
02:23:27.265 --> 02:23:28.166
CALIFORNIA.
02:23:28.232 --> 02:23:29.634
AND RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE
02:23:29.701 --> 02:23:31.569
VOTES THANK YOU.
02:23:31.636 --> 02:23:34.839
OTHERS IN SUPPORT. FOR CALLING
02:23:34.906 --> 02:23:35.573
ON BEHALF OF SIERRA CLUB
02:23:35.640 --> 02:23:36.441
CALIFORNIANS SUPPORT.
02:23:36.507 --> 02:23:38.943
THANK YOU ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT.
02:23:39.010 --> 02:23:39.544
RIGHT SEEING NONE IS THERE ANY
02:23:39.610 --> 02:23:40.411
OPPOSITION.
02:23:40.478 --> 02:23:41.212
SEEING NONE OF BRING BACK TO THE
02:23:41.279 --> 02:23:43.948
COMMITTEE QUESTIONS COMMENTS.
02:23:44.015 --> 02:23:44.849
SIGNALED THE SERVICE YOU MAY
02:23:44.916 --> 02:23:46.985
CLOSE -- MISTER CHAIR AGAIN -- I
02:23:47.051 --> 02:23:47.452
REALLY APPRECIATE THE
02:23:47.518 --> 02:23:48.252
OPPORTUNITY HERE THIS MORNING
02:23:48.319 --> 02:23:49.287
AND CERTAINLY THIS BILL SUPPORT
02:23:49.354 --> 02:23:49.887
THE ATTORNEY GENERAL'S MISSION
02:23:49.954 --> 02:23:51.990
TO PROTECT OUR MOST VULNERABLE --
02:23:52.056 --> 02:23:54.625
BUT COMMUNITIES -- AND AND AND
02:23:54.692 --> 02:23:55.126
AND WHEN YOU SHARE THEIR
02:23:55.193 --> 02:23:56.527
MEANINGFUL ENGAGEMENT IN EFFORTS
02:23:56.594 --> 02:24:00.431
TO COMBAT BY MIDDLE HAZARDS --
02:24:00.498 --> 02:24:00.999
IT'S R. SPEC WE ASK FOR YOUR
02:24:01.065 --> 02:24:02.100
I'VE.
02:24:02.166 --> 02:24:03.034
THANK YOU WE DO HAVE A MOTION
02:24:03.101 --> 02:24:04.402
AND A SECOND MOTION IS TO PASS
02:24:04.469 --> 02:24:05.570
TO APPROPRIATIONS CALL THE ROLL
02:24:05.636 --> 02:24:07.238
PLEASE STONE BY STONE AYE
02:24:07.305 --> 02:24:09.374
GALLAGHER.
02:24:09.440 --> 02:24:13.811
CHAU CHIU GONZALEZ.
02:24:13.878 --> 02:24:15.446
SALAS I HOLDEN.
02:24:15.513 --> 02:24:16.481
OLD AND I KALRA KILEY
02:24:16.547 --> 02:24:19.117
MAIENSCHEIN.
02:24:19.183 --> 02:24:21.185
I MAIENSCHEIN I OBERNOLTE
02:24:21.252 --> 02:24:22.854
PETRIE-NORRIS.
02:24:22.920 --> 02:24:25.556
PETRIE-NORRIS I REYES.
02:24:25.623 --> 02:24:26.924
THE BILL NEEDS TO MORE SO PLACE
02:24:26.991 --> 02:24:33.498
AT ALL CALL THANK YOU.
02:24:33.564 --> 02:24:35.333
THIS IS THE MOST.
02:24:35.400 --> 02:24:36.601
WELCOME THIS WILL TAKE US TO
02:24:36.667 --> 02:24:40.538
ITEM NUMBER THREE AB.
02:24:40.605 --> 02:24:41.139
THREE SEVENTY EIGHT THANK YOU
02:24:41.205 --> 02:24:45.143
THERE IS A MOTION AND A SECOND.
02:24:45.209 --> 02:24:46.744
SO AT WITH THE MOTION AND A
02:24:46.811 --> 02:24:48.479
SECOND I WOULD JUST SAY ADD THAT
02:24:48.546 --> 02:24:50.214
AT EIGHT A. B. THREE SEVENTY
02:24:50.281 --> 02:24:51.549
EIGHT WAS HEARD EARLIER I'M IN
02:24:51.616 --> 02:24:53.451
THE LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT AND IT
02:24:53.518 --> 02:24:54.819
PASSED A UNANIMOUSLY.
02:24:54.886 --> 02:24:56.587
FROM THE ASSEMBLY LABOR AND
02:24:56.654 --> 02:24:58.656
EMPLOYMENT AT COMMITTEE THIS IS
02:24:58.723 --> 02:25:00.358
ABOUT ALLOWING CHILD CARE
02:25:00.425 --> 02:25:03.728
WORKERS A SEAT AT THE TABLE
02:25:03.795 --> 02:25:04.996
THROUGH -- BARGAINING.
02:25:05.063 --> 02:25:06.030
AND I DO HAVE SOME FOLKS I HERE
02:25:06.097 --> 02:25:07.865
TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL
02:25:07.932 --> 02:25:09.167
AND I WILL LET THEM INTRODUCE
02:25:09.233 --> 02:25:12.437
THEMSELVES AND IS THE ONE YOU.
02:25:12.503 --> 02:25:13.237
THE COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS YES
02:25:13.304 --> 02:25:14.672
THANK YOU SO MUCH ALL RIGHT
02:25:14.739 --> 02:25:15.606
FIRST WITNESS PLEASE GOOD
02:25:15.673 --> 02:25:18.676
MORNING.
02:25:18.743 --> 02:25:19.811
MY NAME IS LIZ THAT REINA.
02:25:19.877 --> 02:25:21.245
I LIVE IN LOS BANOS AND I HAVE
02:25:21.312 --> 02:25:23.681
BEEN A FAMILY CHILDCARE PROVIDER
02:25:23.748 --> 02:25:25.450
FOR TWENTY FIVE YEARS.
02:25:25.516 --> 02:25:26.884
LICENSE LARGE FAMILY CHILD CARE
02:25:26.951 --> 02:25:28.820
AND CURRENTLY CARE FOR SIXTEEN
02:25:28.886 --> 02:25:30.788
CHILDREN. TEN WHICH ARE ON STATE
02:25:30.855 --> 02:25:32.423
SUBSIDIZED.
02:25:32.490 --> 02:25:33.825
I ALSO HAVE TWO CHILDREN OF MY
02:25:33.891 --> 02:25:35.626
OWN AN EIGHTEEN YEAR OLD
02:25:35.693 --> 02:25:37.295
GRADUATING FROM HIGH SCHOOL THIS
02:25:37.361 --> 02:25:38.329
YEAR AND A CUTE SIX YEAR OLD
02:25:38.396 --> 02:25:40.131
LITTLE GIRL.
02:25:40.198 --> 02:25:41.899
I'M ALSO A PROUD.
02:25:41.966 --> 02:25:43.201
MEMBER OF CHILD CARE PROVIDERS
02:25:43.267 --> 02:25:46.204
UNITED A PARTNERSHIP BETWEEN D.
02:25:46.270 --> 02:25:48.206
U. D. W. AS FOR ME.
02:25:48.272 --> 02:25:51.075
LOCAL THREE THIRTY NINE THIRTY
02:25:51.142 --> 02:25:54.212
AN SD I YOU LOCALS NINETY NINE
02:25:54.278 --> 02:25:55.947
AND FIVE TWENTY ONE I'D LIKE
02:25:56.013 --> 02:25:57.949
THOUSANDS OF FAMILY CHILD CARE
02:25:58.015 --> 02:25:59.117
PROVIDERS THROUGHOUT THE STATE.
02:25:59.183 --> 02:26:01.452
DEDICATE MY LIFE TO NURTURING
02:26:01.519 --> 02:26:04.522
EDUCATING INFANTS TODDLERS AND
02:26:04.589 --> 02:26:05.890
SCHOOL AGE CHILDREN IN MY HOME.
02:26:05.957 --> 02:26:07.859
I LOVE WHAT I DO AND TAKE MY
02:26:07.925 --> 02:26:09.660
WORK VERY SERIOUSLY BECAUSE I
02:26:09.727 --> 02:26:11.596
KNOW THAT IN MY HANDS IS THE
02:26:11.662 --> 02:26:13.131
EDUCATIONAL EMOTIONAL.
02:26:13.197 --> 02:26:14.532
SOCIAL WELL BEING OF THESE
02:26:14.599 --> 02:26:15.666
CHILDREN.
02:26:15.733 --> 02:26:17.835
AND JUST AS IMPORTANTLY I AM I
02:26:17.902 --> 02:26:20.771
AM THEIR PARENTS PEACE OF MIND.
02:26:20.838 --> 02:26:22.440
WHEN THEY GO TO WORK?
02:26:22.507 --> 02:26:24.242
IN MY CARE THEY KNOW THAT THEIR
02:26:24.308 --> 02:26:26.043
CHILDREN ARE BEING EDUCATED
02:26:26.110 --> 02:26:28.279
NURTURED AND KEPT SAFE.
02:26:28.346 --> 02:26:29.714
THE WAY I SEE IT THERE IS NO
02:26:29.780 --> 02:26:30.982
GREATER RESPONSIBILITY THAN
02:26:31.048 --> 02:26:32.383
TAKING CARE OF SOMEONE'S ELSE
02:26:32.450 --> 02:26:33.551
CHILD.
02:26:33.618 --> 02:26:35.052
AND YET FOR FAMILY CHILD CARE
02:26:35.119 --> 02:26:36.988
PROVIDERS LIKE ME WE CAN BARELY
02:26:37.054 --> 02:26:39.190
TAKE CARE OF OUR OWN MUCH LESS
02:26:39.257 --> 02:26:40.591
FORD.
02:26:40.658 --> 02:26:42.393
A FORD.
02:26:42.460 --> 02:26:44.896
ANY ADDITIONAL EDUCATION AND
02:26:44.962 --> 02:26:46.097
TRAINING TO PROVIDE THE BEST
02:26:46.164 --> 02:26:47.765
EARLY CARE AND EDUCATION
02:26:47.832 --> 02:26:49.100
POSSIBLE.
02:26:49.167 --> 02:26:50.568
WE DON'T EARN A MINIMUM WAGE
02:26:50.635 --> 02:26:52.203
MUCH LESS COVERED BY MINIMUM
02:26:52.270 --> 02:26:54.839
WAGE LOSS IF WE GET INJURED ON
02:26:54.906 --> 02:26:56.707
THE JOB WE ARE ON OUR OWN AS WE
02:26:56.774 --> 02:26:57.842
ARE NOT COVERED BY WORKERS
02:26:57.909 --> 02:26:59.377
COMPENSATION LAWS.
02:26:59.443 --> 02:27:00.711
AND MANY OF US STILL STRUGGLE TO
02:27:00.778 --> 02:27:02.680
PAY FOR HEALTHCARE DESPITE THE
02:27:02.747 --> 02:27:05.016
SUBSIDIZED.
02:27:05.082 --> 02:27:07.685
IN FACT WE QUALIFY FOR THE SAME
02:27:07.752 --> 02:27:09.554
CHILD CARE SURVEYS THAT WE
02:27:09.620 --> 02:27:10.521
PROVIDE.
02:27:10.588 --> 02:27:12.757
JUST LET THAT SINK IN FOR A
02:27:12.823 --> 02:27:15.259
MOMENT WE QUALIFY FOR THE SAME
02:27:15.326 --> 02:27:18.796
STAES OF SURVEYS WE PROVIDE.
02:27:18.863 --> 02:27:21.566
THIS LOOK AT THINGS LIKE.
02:27:21.632 --> 02:27:23.634
SAVINGS SIX DAYS OF WORK
02:27:23.701 --> 02:27:24.902
VACATION TIME ARE JUST A PIPE
02:27:24.969 --> 02:27:27.438
DREAM I FACE CHALLENGES ON A
02:27:27.505 --> 02:27:29.140
DAILY BASIS.
02:27:29.207 --> 02:27:30.808
JUST RECENTLY AN ERROR IN A WORK
02:27:30.875 --> 02:27:32.210
PAPERWORK BY THE AGENCY I
02:27:32.276 --> 02:27:35.813
CONTRACT WITH MEANT THAT I WENT
02:27:35.880 --> 02:27:37.148
OVER A MONTH WITHOUT PAY.
02:27:37.215 --> 02:27:39.417
SALLY THIS IS NOT THE FIRST TIME
02:27:39.483 --> 02:27:41.352
THAT THIS HAS HAPPENED TO ME.
02:27:41.419 --> 02:27:43.988
AND I DOUBT IT WILL BE THE LAST
02:27:44.055 --> 02:27:45.523
BECAUSE OF THE LOW WAGES I EARN
02:27:45.590 --> 02:27:47.024
WHEN I DON'T GET PAID ON TIME
02:27:47.091 --> 02:27:48.459
THAT MEANS THAT I CAN'T PAY MY
02:27:48.526 --> 02:27:50.561
MORTGAGE MY BILLS OR PUT FOOD ON
02:27:50.628 --> 02:27:53.231
THE TABLE. FOR MY FAMILY AND I
02:27:53.297 --> 02:27:54.765
IT IT ALSO MEANS THAT I CANNOT
02:27:54.832 --> 02:27:56.734
CONTINUE TO AFFORD TO TAKE THE
02:27:56.801 --> 02:27:59.570
CHILDREN TO IN MY CARE ON
02:27:59.637 --> 02:28:01.005
EDUCATIONAL FIELD TRIPS.
02:28:01.072 --> 02:28:01.239
BY ART.
02:28:01.305 --> 02:28:02.807
ART SUPPLIES OR TOYS THAT WILL
02:28:02.873 --> 02:28:04.642
HELP THEM LEARN ALL OF THIS
02:28:04.709 --> 02:28:06.644
CONTRIBUTES TO OVER ALL EXCITING
02:28:06.711 --> 02:28:07.845
I FEEL.
02:28:07.912 --> 02:28:09.847
THAT MAYBE THAT NEXT TIME I
02:28:09.914 --> 02:28:11.649
WON'T BE ABLE TO STRETCH WHAT
02:28:11.716 --> 02:28:13.651
LITTLE FUNDS I HAVE AND WILL
02:28:13.718 --> 02:28:15.319
HAVE TO BE FORCED TO CLOSE MY
02:28:15.386 --> 02:28:16.187
DOORS.
02:28:16.254 --> 02:28:18.422
UNFORTUNATELY MEANT MY STORY IS
02:28:18.489 --> 02:28:20.291
ONE OF MANY AND A GLARING
02:28:20.358 --> 02:28:22.193
EXAMPLE OF THE DEEP CRACKS IN
02:28:22.260 --> 02:28:23.694
CALIFORNIA'S CHILD CARE SYSTEM.
02:28:23.761 --> 02:28:25.630
THAT NOT ONLY IMPACTS PROVIDERS
02:28:25.696 --> 02:28:28.799
LIKE ME BUT OUR CHILDREN AND
02:28:28.866 --> 02:28:29.700
PARENTS WHO RELY ON US.
02:28:29.767 --> 02:28:31.102
THAT'S WHY I'M HERE TODAY
02:28:31.168 --> 02:28:32.770
BECAUSE AFTER FIFTEEN YEARS OF
02:28:32.837 --> 02:28:35.606
FIGHTING FOR THE RIGHTS TO FORM
02:28:35.673 --> 02:28:38.442
A UNION AND AND NEGOTIATE WITH
02:28:38.509 --> 02:28:39.877
THE STATE WE KNOW THAT.
02:28:39.944 --> 02:28:41.545
IF WE ARE GOING TO CHANGE THE IN
02:28:41.612 --> 02:28:43.981
QUALITY AROUND AS WE NEED TO BE
02:28:44.048 --> 02:28:45.383
TREATED AS REAL PARTNERS.
02:28:45.449 --> 02:28:47.084
THE MOST MEANINGFUL WAY TO DO
02:28:47.151 --> 02:28:49.120
THAT IS BY GIVING AS THE RIGHT
02:28:49.186 --> 02:28:50.921
TO COLLECTIVELY BARGAIN WITH THE
02:28:50.988 --> 02:28:52.823
STATE AS IT IS THE MOST
02:28:52.890 --> 02:28:55.092
EFFECTIVE TOOL FOR EPIC SEE FOR
02:28:55.159 --> 02:28:55.993
PROVIDERS LIKE ME.
02:28:56.060 --> 02:28:58.729
THEREFORE I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
02:28:58.796 --> 02:29:02.900
YOUR HI BO FOR A. B..
02:29:02.967 --> 02:29:03.467
THREE SEVEN EIGHT THANK YOU
02:29:03.534 --> 02:29:05.703
THANK YOU.
02:29:05.770 --> 02:29:08.372
THAT'S WHAT THIS BOOK. TWENTY ON
02:29:08.439 --> 02:29:09.106
AIRING ON BEHALF OF BOTH THE
02:29:09.173 --> 02:29:10.308
UNIONS AND I'M HERE JUST TO
02:29:10.374 --> 02:29:10.908
PROVIDE TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE.
02:29:10.975 --> 02:29:11.208
THANK YOU.
02:29:11.275 --> 02:29:16.113
ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT.
02:29:16.180 --> 02:29:16.681
HE GIVES YOUR NAME AND YOUR
02:29:16.747 --> 02:29:17.848
AFFILIATION.
02:29:17.915 --> 02:29:18.849
LATER IS THAT THE WITH THE
02:29:18.916 --> 02:29:20.985
CALIFORNIA IMMIGRANT POLICY
02:29:21.052 --> 02:29:23.020
CENTER IN STRONG SUPPORT.
02:29:23.087 --> 02:29:24.188
CAN REALLY ROSENBERGER WITH
02:29:24.255 --> 02:29:25.323
SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTERNATIONAL
02:29:25.389 --> 02:29:27.024
UNION SUPPORT AND I ALSO HAVE A
02:29:27.091 --> 02:29:29.360
DO YOU DO A PORTAL ISSUE THIRTY
02:29:29.427 --> 02:29:30.161
LETTERS THAT WE SUBMITTED LAST
02:29:30.227 --> 02:29:32.129
WEEK THAT IT BEGINS ANALYSIS AND
02:29:32.196 --> 02:29:33.264
BECAUSE I ALSO AN ATTORNEY AND A
02:29:33.331 --> 02:29:35.266
PAPER TRAIL MATTERS SO.
02:29:35.333 --> 02:29:37.134
I HAVE THIS TO GIVE.
02:29:37.201 --> 02:29:38.836
TO YOU JUST TO PUT ON THE RECORD
02:29:38.903 --> 02:29:40.838
THAT A LOT OF LOCAL ORGANIZATION
02:29:40.905 --> 02:29:44.675
ACTIVE SUPPORT.
02:29:44.742 --> 02:29:46.110
HI MY NAME IS A RESERVE ARMY
02:29:46.177 --> 02:29:48.145
THIS AND I AM A CHUNK OF FOR WHY
02:29:48.212 --> 02:29:51.682
THERE IS JOSE FOR THREE YEARS.
02:29:51.749 --> 02:29:54.919
AND ALSO A MEMBER OF THE AS YOU
02:29:54.985 --> 02:29:56.420
FIVE TO ONE AND NOW -- I AM I AS
02:29:56.487 --> 02:30:02.226
FAR HERE IS A PART OF IT AB
02:30:02.293 --> 02:30:02.593
THREE SEVEN IT.
02:30:02.660 --> 02:30:04.662
THANK YOU.
02:30:04.729 --> 02:30:07.098
HI MY NAME IS STILL UP ON THEM
02:30:07.164 --> 02:30:09.266
PROVIDER WOULD BE TOTALLY FOR
02:30:09.333 --> 02:30:12.903
NOW I SUPPORT THEM AB THREE
02:30:12.970 --> 02:30:15.840
SEVEN EIGHT THANK YOU.
02:30:15.906 --> 02:30:17.408
MY NAME IS GERALDINE SAY I AM
02:30:17.475 --> 02:30:18.542
FROM STOCKTON CALIFORNIA I'VE
02:30:18.609 --> 02:30:19.477
BEEN A CHILD CARE PROVIDER FOR
02:30:19.543 --> 02:30:20.678
SEVENTEEN YEARS.
02:30:20.745 --> 02:30:24.448
I AM WITH -- SEIU LOCAL.
02:30:24.515 --> 02:30:25.649
FIVE TWENTY ONE AND I AM IN
02:30:25.716 --> 02:30:28.119
SUPPORT OF A. B..
02:30:28.185 --> 02:30:30.588
THREE SEVEN EIGHT THANK.
02:30:30.654 --> 02:30:33.023
HELLO MY NAME IS JULIE APONTE
02:30:33.090 --> 02:30:34.925
PROVIDERS WHO DEAL DOWNEY FOR
02:30:34.992 --> 02:30:36.026
SIXTEEN YEARS.
02:30:36.093 --> 02:30:37.294
AND I'M REMEMBER AS HE A YOU
02:30:37.361 --> 02:30:38.929
LOOK ON NINETY NINE AND I'M
02:30:38.996 --> 02:30:41.532
SUPPORT A THREE SEVEN EIGHT AND
02:30:41.599 --> 02:30:44.034
I ASK.
02:30:44.101 --> 02:30:44.402
FOR YOUR ALBUM.
02:30:44.468 --> 02:30:47.071
THANK YOU.
02:30:47.138 --> 02:30:48.372
HI AM THE NETTING CNCEITO FROM
02:30:48.439 --> 02:30:52.743
LA COUNTY I TO SUPPORT AB.
02:30:52.810 --> 02:30:53.344
THREE SEVENTY EIGHT THE THING
02:30:53.411 --> 02:30:53.978
THAT I MEAN IS NOT TO KNOW WHAT
02:30:54.044 --> 02:30:55.112
CHILDREN NOW IN STRONG SUPPORT
02:30:55.179 --> 02:30:57.181
OF THIS MEASURE.
02:30:57.248 --> 02:30:58.282
CHARLOTTE NAILS SACRAMENTO
02:30:58.349 --> 02:30:59.750
CALIFORNIA -- PROVIDER EIGHTEEN
02:30:59.817 --> 02:31:04.155
YEARS AND I SUPPORT.
02:31:04.221 --> 02:31:04.822
THREE SEVENTY EIGHT VERY GOOD --
02:31:04.889 --> 02:31:05.723
SHE HARM TO HAVE THE CALIFORNIA
02:31:05.790 --> 02:31:07.158
EMPLOYMENT LAWYERS ASSOCIATION
02:31:07.224 --> 02:31:10.060
IN SUPPORT.
02:31:10.127 --> 02:31:11.996
MY NAME IS NORA ALLEN SWAY LE IN
02:31:12.062 --> 02:31:14.198
I SUPPORT AB.
02:31:14.265 --> 02:31:18.002
THREE SEVENTY EIGHT THANK YOU.
02:31:18.068 --> 02:31:19.804
MEDI GRATEFUL FOR THIS
02:31:19.870 --> 02:31:21.338
OPPORTUNITY MY NAME IS C.
02:31:21.405 --> 02:31:22.473
BEETHOVEN.
02:31:22.540 --> 02:31:25.109
AND I'M A BEING CHILD CARE
02:31:25.176 --> 02:31:30.347
PROVIDER. FOR FIFTEEN YEARS AND
02:31:30.414 --> 02:31:33.617
I YOU STRONGLY SUPPORT THIS.
02:31:33.684 --> 02:31:34.251
BUT HE GOT A FOUR FOUR TWO THANK
02:31:34.318 --> 02:31:36.587
YOU.
02:31:36.654 --> 02:31:37.421
ALEX TO CAPRI ON BEHALF OF FIRST
02:31:37.488 --> 02:31:38.389
FIVE CALIFORNIA WE DON'T YET
02:31:38.456 --> 02:31:39.356
HAVE A POSITION ON THE BILL OR
02:31:39.423 --> 02:31:40.591
WORKING WITH THE AUTHOR AND
02:31:40.658 --> 02:31:41.792
SPONSOR TOWARD SUPPORT THANK YOU.
02:31:41.859 --> 02:31:42.593
MICHAEL YOUNG WITH THE
02:31:42.660 --> 02:31:43.828
CALIFORNIA LABOR FEDERATION LOS
02:31:43.894 --> 02:31:46.997
WERE ALSO YOUR SUPPORT.
02:31:47.064 --> 02:31:48.199
GOOD MORNING MY SHOULD CALL FROM
02:31:48.265 --> 02:31:49.867
THE CHILD CARE LAWCENTER AND WE
02:31:49.934 --> 02:31:52.203
ARE IN STRONG SUPPORT OF THIS
02:31:52.269 --> 02:31:56.574
LEGISLATION HAVE A GOOD DAY.
02:31:56.640 --> 02:31:58.142
LEAGUE BYNUM YOU W. ASKED ME
02:31:58.209 --> 02:31:59.543
THEIR NINE THIRTY HOW CLOSE
02:31:59.610 --> 02:32:00.778
SPONSORS ON THE BILL AND WE URGE
02:32:00.845 --> 02:32:02.213
YOUR SUPPORT THANK YOU.
02:32:02.279 --> 02:32:04.548
THANK YOU ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT.
02:32:04.615 --> 02:32:05.049
SEEING NONE IS THERE ANY
02:32:05.115 --> 02:32:12.590
OPPOSITION.
02:32:12.656 --> 02:32:13.157
THE MORNING WHEN YOU PROUD
02:32:13.224 --> 02:32:14.325
CALIFORNIA NEWS PUBLISHERS
02:32:14.391 --> 02:32:16.126
ASSOCIATION WEIRD NEUTRAL ON THE
02:32:16.193 --> 02:32:17.761
BILL -- I JUST WANTED TO THANK
02:32:17.828 --> 02:32:18.963
THE AUTHOR WE EXPRESSED A
02:32:19.029 --> 02:32:20.464
CONCERN ABOUT THE PUBLIC RECORDS
02:32:20.531 --> 02:32:21.899
PROVISION IN THE BILL.
02:32:21.966 --> 02:32:23.767
AND WE APPRECIATE HER TAKING THE
02:32:23.834 --> 02:32:24.535
AMENDMENT TO ADDRESS THAT
02:32:24.602 --> 02:32:25.102
SOMETHING KILL.
02:32:25.169 --> 02:32:26.470
THANK YOU ANYONE ELSE IN
02:32:26.537 --> 02:32:28.606
OPPOSITION OR NEUTRAL OR
02:32:28.672 --> 02:32:29.974
OTHERWISE ALL RIGHT.
02:32:30.040 --> 02:32:31.375
SEEING NONE OF BRING IT BACK TO
02:32:31.442 --> 02:32:36.447
THE COMMITTEE QUESTIONS COMMENTS
02:32:36.514 --> 02:32:36.747
[inaudible]
02:32:36.814 --> 02:32:38.215
WAS GALLAGHER.
02:32:38.282 --> 02:32:39.884
YES SO I MY CONCERN AT THIS BILL
02:32:39.950 --> 02:32:41.218
IS THAT YOU KNOW I THINK
02:32:41.285 --> 02:32:42.386
ULTIMATELY YOU KNOW ALLOWING THE
02:32:42.453 --> 02:32:42.987
COLLECTIVE BARGAINING IS GONNA
02:32:43.053 --> 02:32:44.955
MAKE CHILD CARE MORE EXPENSIVE
02:32:45.022 --> 02:32:46.557
AND I THINK THAT'S GOING TO BE.
02:32:46.624 --> 02:32:47.591
REALLY DIFFICULT ESPECIALLY IN
02:32:47.658 --> 02:32:49.760
IN MY DISTRICT WHERE YOU KNOW
02:32:49.827 --> 02:32:51.262
PEOPLE ARE MIA.
02:32:51.328 --> 02:32:52.930
DON'T MAKE AS MUCH MONEY.
02:32:52.997 --> 02:32:54.632
AND YOU KNOW THE COST OF LIVING
02:32:54.698 --> 02:32:55.766
IN THE THINGS ARE GOING UP
02:32:55.833 --> 02:32:58.502
CONSTANTLY IN THE STATE IT MAKES
02:32:58.569 --> 02:33:00.571
IT VERY TOUGH YOU KNOW AND SO --
02:33:00.638 --> 02:33:02.072
I BY NO A LOT OF PEOPLE TO
02:33:02.139 --> 02:33:03.607
PROVIDE CHILDCARE.
02:33:03.674 --> 02:33:04.608
BEYOND THE ONES OF MY DISTRICT
02:33:04.675 --> 02:33:08.012
THEY'RE REALLY NOT INTERESTED IN
02:33:08.078 --> 02:33:09.446
UNION UNIONIZE IN.
02:33:09.513 --> 02:33:11.115
AND YET THAT'S THE OTHER PROBLEM
02:33:11.181 --> 02:33:11.715
I HAVE WITH THIS BILL IS THAT
02:33:11.782 --> 02:33:13.817
YEAH FOR THOSE THAT WANT.
02:33:13.884 --> 02:33:15.419
TO YOU KNOW THAT'S I MEAN THAT'S
02:33:15.486 --> 02:33:18.455
HOW THIS YEAR PRAGUE IF -- BUT
02:33:18.522 --> 02:33:19.790
SHARING THEIR INFORMATION
02:33:19.857 --> 02:33:22.192
PRIVATE INFORMATION AND THEIR
02:33:22.259 --> 02:33:23.894
HOME ADDRESSES AND AND THEIR
02:33:23.961 --> 02:33:25.396
INFO ABOUT YOU KNOW THEIR CHILD
02:33:25.462 --> 02:33:27.765
CARE BUSINESS WITH THE UNION IS
02:33:27.831 --> 02:33:28.766
SOMETHING THAT THEY DON'T WANT
02:33:28.832 --> 02:33:31.302
TO SEE DONE YOU KNOW AND SO.
02:33:31.368 --> 02:33:32.102
AND I AND I THINK IT GOES THE
02:33:32.169 --> 02:33:33.637
OTHER IS KIND OF A CONSTANT
02:33:33.704 --> 02:33:35.105
THEME HERE THIS YEAR WAS PRIVATE
02:33:35.172 --> 02:33:36.240
AND HE GOES TO OUR PRIVACY
02:33:36.307 --> 02:33:37.474
ISSUES LIKE.
02:33:37.541 --> 02:33:38.976
WHY SHOULD?
02:33:39.043 --> 02:33:40.578
THIS INFORMATION BE SHARED THIS
02:33:40.644 --> 02:33:42.813
PRIVATE INFORMATION ABOUT YOUR
02:33:42.880 --> 02:33:44.815
BUSINESS WE SHARED WITH SOME
02:33:44.882 --> 02:33:46.917
THIRD PARTY GROUP -- THAT MAY
02:33:46.984 --> 02:33:48.285
HAVE AN INTENT THAT YOU JUST
02:33:48.352 --> 02:33:50.187
THAT YOU DON'T PARTICULARLY
02:33:50.254 --> 02:33:52.189
AGREE WITH -- SO I THINK WE
02:33:52.256 --> 02:33:52.923
SHOULD YOU KNOW HELP PROTECT
02:33:52.990 --> 02:33:55.326
THAT AND SO FOR THOSE REASONS
02:33:55.392 --> 02:33:56.126
THAT'S WHY.
02:33:56.193 --> 02:33:57.528
I UNDERSTAND YOU KNOW YOUR
02:33:57.595 --> 02:33:58.929
INTENT BEHIND IT AND WHAT YOU'RE
02:33:58.996 --> 02:34:02.533
TRYING TO DO AND AND AND
02:34:02.600 --> 02:34:04.702
CERTAINLY.
02:34:04.768 --> 02:34:05.669
YOUNG SYMPATHIZE WITH THAT BUT I
02:34:05.736 --> 02:34:06.503
JUST THINK THAT YOU KNOW IT'S
02:34:06.570 --> 02:34:08.372
NOT IT'S NOT FOR EVERYBODY AND
02:34:08.439 --> 02:34:10.107
WE NEED A LOT OF CHILD CARE
02:34:10.174 --> 02:34:11.408
PROVIDERS OBVIOUSLY IT.
02:34:11.475 --> 02:34:12.643
IN THE STATE IS SOMETHING THAT
02:34:12.710 --> 02:34:14.078
WE'RE WORKING ON A MANY
02:34:14.144 --> 02:34:17.715
DIFFERENT ASPECTS -- AND SO
02:34:17.781 --> 02:34:18.315
THAT'S WHY I CAN'T SUPPORT THE
02:34:18.382 --> 02:34:19.416
BILL.
02:34:19.483 --> 02:34:20.651
CAN I JUST RESPOND I THINK THAT
02:34:20.718 --> 02:34:22.219
THAT'S ONE OF THE THE ELEMENTS
02:34:22.286 --> 02:34:24.955
THAT THAT COME UP -- IN TERMS OF
02:34:25.022 --> 02:34:26.223
THE COST BUT EIGHT EIGHT THINK
02:34:26.290 --> 02:34:26.957
THAT.
02:34:27.024 --> 02:34:29.893
THE REAL COST IS OUR FUTURE AND
02:34:29.960 --> 02:34:31.895
IF WE DON'T HAVE CHILD CARE
02:34:31.962 --> 02:34:32.796
WORKERS.
02:34:32.863 --> 02:34:34.398
THAT HAS A HUGE COST TO THE
02:34:34.465 --> 02:34:36.166
STATE TO THE EDUCATION AND
02:34:36.233 --> 02:34:38.569
PREPARATION OF OUR KIDS AND I
02:34:38.636 --> 02:34:39.970
THINK THAT THAT'S WHERE WE'RE AT
02:34:40.037 --> 02:34:41.672
WE'VE HEARD TESTIMONY FROM
02:34:41.739 --> 02:34:43.107
ACROSS ALL THE STATE.
02:34:43.173 --> 02:34:46.210
ABOUT A CHILD CARE WORKERS WHO
02:34:46.276 --> 02:34:48.078
ARE QUALIFY FOR THE SAME
02:34:48.145 --> 02:34:49.747
SUBSIDIES.
02:34:49.813 --> 02:34:52.082
THAT THE FAMILIES THAT THEY
02:34:52.149 --> 02:34:54.918
SERVE QUALIFY FOR US SO WE PAY
02:34:54.985 --> 02:34:56.687
FOR IT LET'S JUST BE VERY CLEAR --
02:34:56.754 --> 02:34:58.255
A AND IT'S THROUGH ITS STATE
02:34:58.322 --> 02:34:59.890
SUBSIDIES SO I THINK THAT THAT'S
02:34:59.957 --> 02:35:02.660
BIGGER -- ISSUE AND I YOU KNOW I
02:35:02.726 --> 02:35:04.595
I THINK RESPECTFULLY ANYONEWHO
02:35:04.662 --> 02:35:05.596
DOESN'T WANT TO BE PART OF
02:35:05.663 --> 02:35:07.297
SOMETHING HAS THE ABILITY TO SAY
02:35:07.364 --> 02:35:09.233
NO -- BUT IT'S EIGHT THAT NEVER
02:35:09.299 --> 02:35:12.136
GOES AWAY -- INDEPENDENT OF
02:35:12.202 --> 02:35:13.904
SOMEONE MAKING SURE THAT THEY
02:35:13.971 --> 02:35:17.875
HAVE ACCURATE INFORMATION.
02:35:17.941 --> 02:35:19.643
THAT COULD HELP THEM.
02:35:19.710 --> 02:35:20.711
JUST A FOLLOW UP REALLY QUICK IS
02:35:20.778 --> 02:35:22.012
WHAT IF IT BECOMES A CLOTHES
02:35:22.079 --> 02:35:22.680
SHOP THEN THEY DON'T HAVE A SUCH
02:35:22.746 --> 02:35:24.381
THAN THEY DON'T HAVE A CHOICE
02:35:24.448 --> 02:35:25.983
CORRECT I MEAN IT WHEN YOU CAN
02:35:26.050 --> 02:35:26.617
RESPOND TO IT THAT'S FINE BUT I
02:35:26.684 --> 02:35:27.317
MEAN.
02:35:27.384 --> 02:35:29.319
ULTIMATELY AS YOU GAIN MORE
02:35:29.386 --> 02:35:31.822
BARGAINING POWER RIGHT. FOR
02:35:31.889 --> 02:35:34.024
EXAMPLESTATE WORKERS RIGHT NOW
02:35:34.091 --> 02:35:36.160
YOU DON'T HAVE A CHOICE.
02:35:36.226 --> 02:35:38.762
RIGHT -- YOU YOU AND IF YOU GET.
02:35:38.829 --> 02:35:42.166
INTO THAT SITUATION RIGHT.
02:35:42.232 --> 02:35:44.435
THEN AND ALSO I AGAIN I I I I GO
02:35:44.501 --> 02:35:45.869
BACK TO THE ISSUE OF ARE WE
02:35:45.936 --> 02:35:47.805
GONNA GET MORE CHILD CARE
02:35:47.871 --> 02:35:49.206
WORKERS OUT OF UNIONIZATION.
02:35:49.273 --> 02:35:50.441
WE'RE GONNA GET MORE CHILD CARE
02:35:50.507 --> 02:35:52.342
WORKERS WHEN WE PAY THEM WELL
02:35:52.409 --> 02:35:53.477
WHAT'S YOUR EVIDENCE FOR THAT.
02:35:53.544 --> 02:35:55.746
IF THE EVIDENCE WITH ANY OTHER
02:35:55.813 --> 02:35:57.648
INDUSTRY WHEN PAY SUPPORTS THE
02:35:57.715 --> 02:35:59.817
WORK OF SOMEONE DOING THAT WORK
02:35:59.883 --> 02:36:01.652
WE GET BETTER WORKERS WE GET
02:36:01.719 --> 02:36:04.755
MORE WORKERS WE HAVE.
02:36:04.822 --> 02:36:05.823
CHILD CARE WORKERS.
02:36:05.889 --> 02:36:08.459
WHO CANNOT AFFORD TO BE IN THAT
02:36:08.525 --> 02:36:10.728
SPACE WHO WILL GO WORK FOR A
02:36:10.794 --> 02:36:12.162
FAST FOOD RESTAURANT BECAUSE THE
02:36:12.229 --> 02:36:13.897
FAST FOOD RESTAURANT PAYS MORE
02:36:13.964 --> 02:36:16.300
THAN WHAT THEY GET PAID?
02:36:16.366 --> 02:36:18.335
IT'S DRIVING IT'S SIMPLE IT'S
02:36:18.402 --> 02:36:19.703
SIMPLE ECONOMICS IT'S DRIVING
02:36:19.770 --> 02:36:22.539
PEOPLE OUT OF AN INDUSTRY
02:36:22.606 --> 02:36:24.108
BECAUSE THEY CANNOT AFFORD.
02:36:24.174 --> 02:36:25.275
AN UP ALL THE SAID I THINK
02:36:25.342 --> 02:36:27.678
THAT'S YOUR PERSPECTIVE I HAVE
02:36:27.745 --> 02:36:29.379
HAD HAPPY INVITE ANY EVIDENCE
02:36:29.446 --> 02:36:30.514
HAVE RESEARCH YOU TELL ME WHO
02:36:30.581 --> 02:36:31.315
YOU LIKE IF I HAVEN'T SEEN ANY
02:36:31.381 --> 02:36:33.217
EVIDENCE OF THAT AND I HAVE HAD
02:36:33.283 --> 02:36:33.951
MY OWN.
02:36:34.017 --> 02:36:36.019
MY OWN SUBJECTIVE EXPERIENCES
02:36:36.086 --> 02:36:38.422
WITH CHILD CARE WORKERS HE SAID
02:36:38.489 --> 02:36:41.291
THIS IS NOT WHAT THEY WANT YEAH --
02:36:41.358 --> 02:36:42.860
AND SO WE IS HIS WE CAN ALL TALK
02:36:42.926 --> 02:36:44.628
ABOUT OUR OWN SUBJECTIVE STORIES
02:36:44.695 --> 02:36:46.396
BUT YOU KNOW ABSENT SOME REAL
02:36:46.463 --> 02:36:47.765
EVIDENCE THAT THAT'S THE CASE
02:36:47.831 --> 02:36:49.099
I'M CONCERNED WITH SOMETHING
02:36:49.166 --> 02:36:50.267
THAT COULD ACTUALLY.
02:36:50.334 --> 02:36:56.507
LEAD TO LESS JOKER WORKERS.
02:36:56.573 --> 02:36:57.641
MISTER KALRA THE MS GONZALEZ.
02:36:57.708 --> 02:36:58.942
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN I
02:36:59.009 --> 02:37:00.144
THINK THE AUTHOR I'M A PROUD
02:37:00.210 --> 02:37:00.811
PRINCIPLE CO AUTHOR OF THIS BILL
02:37:00.878 --> 02:37:02.412
I THINK IS INCREDIBLY IMPORTANT.
02:37:02.479 --> 02:37:05.115
AND I THINK THAT IF YOU TALK TO
02:37:05.182 --> 02:37:06.083
ANY WORKER.
02:37:06.150 --> 02:37:08.485
AND JUST KEEP THE WORD UNION ON
02:37:08.552 --> 02:37:09.686
UNIT OUT OF IT JUST LIKE YOU
02:37:09.753 --> 02:37:10.654
WOULD YOU LIKE BETTER PAY
02:37:10.721 --> 02:37:11.488
BENEFITS AND A VOICE.
02:37:11.555 --> 02:37:12.556
I THINK PRETTY MUCH EVERYONE
02:37:12.623 --> 02:37:13.590
WOULD SAY YES TO THAT.
02:37:13.657 --> 02:37:15.292
AND THE REALITY IS THAT THOSE
02:37:15.359 --> 02:37:17.928
ARE WORKING IN CHILD CARE -- OUR
02:37:17.995 --> 02:37:20.531
OFTENTIMES WORKING IN ISOLATION
02:37:20.597 --> 02:37:22.432
OFTENTIMES THEIR VICTIMS A WAGE
02:37:22.499 --> 02:37:23.567
THEFT OFTENTIMES OF VICTIMS OF
02:37:23.634 --> 02:37:25.502
HARASSMENT AND THEY CERTAINLY
02:37:25.569 --> 02:37:26.103
DON'T HAVE THE BOYS THAT THEY
02:37:26.170 --> 02:37:26.770
DESERVE.
02:37:26.837 --> 02:37:28.338
CONSIDERING THE IMPORTANT JOB
02:37:28.405 --> 02:37:29.940
THAT THEY PROVIDE FOR ALL OF US
02:37:30.007 --> 02:37:31.842
AND SIMPLY JUST SAYING WELL.
02:37:31.909 --> 02:37:34.077
IF WE CAN IF IF FAMILIES PAVE
02:37:34.144 --> 02:37:34.678
THEIR CHILD CARE WORKERS THAT
02:37:34.745 --> 02:37:35.846
HAS MORE MONEY IN THEIR POCKET
02:37:35.913 --> 02:37:37.548
IS REALLY AB I DISRESPECTED
02:37:37.614 --> 02:37:39.116
THOSE THEY'RE DOING THE WORK --
02:37:39.183 --> 02:37:40.751
BECAUSE REALLY WHAT WE'RE ASKING
02:37:40.818 --> 02:37:43.020
THE THE THOSE THAT.
02:37:43.086 --> 02:37:44.555
ARE IN THE THE THE HAD THE LEAST
02:37:44.621 --> 02:37:45.823
AMOUNT OF POWER.
02:37:45.889 --> 02:37:47.691
UP TO STAND UP TO ASK FOR A
02:37:47.758 --> 02:37:49.193
BETTER WAGES AND TREATMENT AND
02:37:49.259 --> 02:37:51.195
BENEFITS TO BEAR THE BRUNT OF
02:37:51.261 --> 02:37:53.230
THE BURDEN OF HAVING LOWER
02:37:53.297 --> 02:37:54.398
CHILDCARE COSTS.
02:37:54.464 --> 02:37:56.166
AS AS THE AUTHOR CORRECTLY SAID
02:37:56.233 --> 02:37:58.402
THE MONEY COMES FROM SOMEWHERE
02:37:58.468 --> 02:37:59.503
IT'S NOT LIKE -- BALLS WITH A
02:37:59.570 --> 02:38:00.704
FAMILY GOING TO SAVE A FEW BUCKS
02:38:00.771 --> 02:38:02.806
ON CHILD CARE AND THEN THAT THAT
02:38:02.873 --> 02:38:04.608
MONEY JUST RECKLESS APPEARS SOME
02:38:04.675 --> 02:38:05.142
SOMEWHERE.
02:38:05.209 --> 02:38:06.076
NO WE'RE EITHER PAYING IT
02:38:06.143 --> 02:38:07.511
BECAUSE ARE SUBSIDIZING OTHER.
02:38:07.578 --> 02:38:09.746
BENEFITS THAT THESE WORKERS ARE
02:38:09.813 --> 02:38:10.347
NOT.
02:38:10.414 --> 02:38:13.116
A DON'T HAVE THAT DON'T HAVE OR
02:38:13.183 --> 02:38:14.651
THEY'RE STRUGGLING AND SUFFERING --
02:38:14.718 --> 02:38:16.086
IN POVERTY.
02:38:16.153 --> 02:38:18.622
AND SO IT'S AN EITHER OR AND I
02:38:18.689 --> 02:38:19.957
THINK THAT THEY'RE ALL ALWAYS WE
02:38:20.023 --> 02:38:21.291
ALWAYS A BALANCING TEST ON ALL
02:38:21.358 --> 02:38:22.259
THESE ISSUES.
02:38:22.326 --> 02:38:22.759
BUT I THINK THERE'S AN
02:38:22.826 --> 02:38:23.994
OVERRIDING PUBLIC POLICY
02:38:24.061 --> 02:38:25.996
INTERESTS FOR US TO ENSURE THAT
02:38:26.063 --> 02:38:27.364
NOT JUST THE CURRENT WORK FORCE
02:38:27.431 --> 02:38:28.699
WHAT WE KNOW IS GOING TO BE A
02:38:28.765 --> 02:38:29.967
GROWING WORK FORCE A CHILD CARE
02:38:30.033 --> 02:38:31.034
WORKERS WHO ARE.
02:38:31.101 --> 02:38:33.136
IN MOST CASES THE VERY FIRST
02:38:33.203 --> 02:38:35.105
EDUCATOR THAT A CHILD HAS -- WE
02:38:35.172 --> 02:38:36.840
NEED TO TREAT THEM AS SUCH AND
02:38:36.907 --> 02:38:37.407
TREAT THEM WITH RESPECT AND
02:38:37.474 --> 02:38:38.242
DIGNITY.
02:38:38.308 --> 02:38:39.843
AND I THINK THAT THIS HAS BEEN
02:38:39.910 --> 02:38:43.247
THIS INDUSTRY IS -- ONE THAT IS --
02:38:43.313 --> 02:38:44.481
WILLIAM BECAUSE SEE PARALLELS TO
02:38:44.548 --> 02:38:45.649
MANY OTHER INDUSTRY THERE ARE
02:38:45.716 --> 02:38:46.683
DOMINATED BY A WOMAN A FEMALE
02:38:46.750 --> 02:38:49.920
WORK FORCE FOR THE MOST PART --
02:38:49.987 --> 02:38:51.655
THAT GET PAID LESS THAN HALF
02:38:51.722 --> 02:39:01.565
LESS BENEFITS AGAIN BLOOD THAT'S
02:39:01.632 --> 02:39:02.099
RESPECT I THINK WE HAVE TO
02:39:02.165 --> 02:39:04.635
CHANGE THAT AND THAT'S WHY I
02:39:04.701 --> 02:39:06.603
STRONGLY SUPPORT THIS BILL.
02:39:06.670 --> 02:39:07.170
THANK YOU -- BUT SOME OF THE
02:39:07.237 --> 02:39:08.405
MONTH [inaudible]
02:39:08.472 --> 02:39:09.640
GONZALEZ.
02:39:09.706 --> 02:39:10.841
I JUST WANT TO CLARIFY -- FOR MY
02:39:10.908 --> 02:39:13.143
COLLEAGUE FROM.
02:39:13.210 --> 02:39:17.481
HE IS NICHOLAS THANK YOU.
02:39:17.547 --> 02:39:19.850
CHICO -- THAT -- THERE IS NO.
02:39:19.917 --> 02:39:20.951
SUCH THING AS A CLOSED SHOP AND
02:39:21.018 --> 02:39:21.518
PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT -- THAT
02:39:21.585 --> 02:39:22.653
ANYBODY WHO DOESN'T WANT TO BE A
02:39:22.719 --> 02:39:23.086
MEMBER OF A UNION.
02:39:23.153 --> 02:39:23.754
IS NOT FORCED TO BE A MEMBER OF
02:39:23.820 --> 02:39:24.655
UNION AND NOW THANKS TO A
02:39:24.721 --> 02:39:25.389
SUPREME COURT DECISION THEY
02:39:25.455 --> 02:39:27.724
ACTUALLY GET ALL THE BENEFITS OF
02:39:27.791 --> 02:39:29.192
THE UNION WITHOUT PAYING A
02:39:29.259 --> 02:39:30.627
SINGLE CENT.
02:39:30.694 --> 02:39:32.262
SO -- TO SUGGEST THAT BECAUSE
02:39:32.329 --> 02:39:34.231
SOMEBODY DOESN'T WANT TO BE PART
02:39:34.298 --> 02:39:35.999
OF A UNION -- I'D ASK OUR
02:39:36.066 --> 02:39:37.334
CONSTITUENTS IN A ANY
02:39:37.401 --> 02:39:39.369
CONSTITUENT -- WOULD YOU LIKE IN
02:39:39.436 --> 02:39:42.072
FACT THE BENEFITS OF OF HIGHER
02:39:42.139 --> 02:39:44.708
PAY -- WORKFORCE TRAINING
02:39:44.775 --> 02:39:47.110
BENEFITS -- AND BY THE WAY NOT
02:39:47.177 --> 02:39:48.512
HAVE TO PAY A SINGLE CENT
02:39:48.578 --> 02:39:50.013
BECAUSE WE ALLOW FREE RIDERS NOW
02:39:50.080 --> 02:39:52.683
AND I I WOULD ASSUME -- THAT THE
02:39:52.749 --> 02:39:54.284
ANSWER WOULD BE YES BECAUSE EVEN
02:39:54.351 --> 02:39:55.085
THOSE PLAINTIFFS IN THE JANICE
02:39:55.152 --> 02:39:56.320
DECISION DID NOT GIVE UP THEIR
02:39:56.386 --> 02:39:58.588
RIGHT TO PENSIONS AND HIGHER PAY
02:39:58.655 --> 02:40:03.226
THEY SIMPLY -- DID NOT WANT TO
02:40:03.293 --> 02:40:05.929
AT SPEND ANY MONEY TO ACHIEVE
02:40:05.996 --> 02:40:06.997
ADD THAT THE COLLECTIVE GOALS OF
02:40:07.064 --> 02:40:07.731
THE INDUSTRY SO.
02:40:07.798 --> 02:40:08.865
I I JUST WANNA MAKE SURE THAT'S
02:40:08.932 --> 02:40:10.367
CLEAR AND I'D BE HAPPY TO SIT
02:40:10.434 --> 02:40:11.735
DOWN WITH YOU NOT ONLY ON THE
02:40:11.802 --> 02:40:13.503
UNIONIZATION QUESTION BUT ALSO
02:40:13.570 --> 02:40:15.772
THE DATA THAT -- YOU ARE
02:40:15.839 --> 02:40:18.241
ATTRIBUTING TO THE AUTHOR AS AN
02:40:18.308 --> 02:40:20.410
OPINION THE PEOPLE ARE LEAVING
02:40:20.477 --> 02:40:22.112
THE CHILD CARE -- WILL LEAVE THE
02:40:22.179 --> 02:40:24.047
CHILD CARE PROFESSION BECAUSE
02:40:24.114 --> 02:40:25.782
THEY WILL HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY
02:40:25.849 --> 02:40:26.616
HAVE MORE TRAINING AND HIGHER
02:40:26.683 --> 02:40:28.785
PAY -- I THINK NOT ONLY IS THAT
02:40:28.852 --> 02:40:30.020
NOT COMMONSENSE THERE'S ACTUALLY
02:40:30.087 --> 02:40:31.588
THERE'S ACTUALLY STUDIES ABOUT
02:40:31.655 --> 02:40:33.323
WHY PEOPLE LEAVE HEALTHCARE SO
02:40:33.390 --> 02:40:34.691
IT WOULD IT WOULD BE GREAT TO
02:40:34.758 --> 02:40:36.460
HAVE THAT DISCUSSION I WOULD
02:40:36.526 --> 02:40:37.294
THINK THE AUTHOR FOR BRINGING
02:40:37.361 --> 02:40:38.428
THIS FORWARD I THINK WE ARE MADE
02:40:38.495 --> 02:40:39.663
A MOTION BUT I'M I'M SAID BEFORE
02:40:39.730 --> 02:40:39.863
THERE.
02:40:39.930 --> 02:40:41.631
IS NO MORE IMPORTANT BILL I
02:40:41.698 --> 02:40:43.433
THINK THIS LEGISLATIVE SESSION
02:40:43.500 --> 02:40:44.534
ON THIS -- ONE WE HAVE THE
02:40:44.601 --> 02:40:46.970
OPPORTUNITY TO TAKE WORKERS WHO
02:40:47.037 --> 02:40:49.740
FOR FAR TOO LONG ARE UNDERPAID --
02:40:49.806 --> 02:40:52.042
THAT WE RELY ON TO IT TO DO THE
02:40:52.109 --> 02:40:56.680
MOST BASIC -- FUNDAMENTAL.
02:40:56.747 --> 02:40:57.214
CARING FOR OUR CHILDREN.
02:40:57.280 --> 02:40:57.881
THE THINGS WE ALL AGREE IS VERY
02:40:57.948 --> 02:40:59.750
IMPORTANT AND THEY HAVE
02:40:59.816 --> 02:41:00.951
UNFORTUNATELY JUST SLIP THE
02:41:01.018 --> 02:41:02.452
LOWER THE RATE ARE AND WAY TOO
02:41:02.519 --> 02:41:03.987
MANY THINGS THEY ARE WORKERS WHO
02:41:04.054 --> 02:41:05.322
CANNOT BE OUTSOURCED THEIR
02:41:05.389 --> 02:41:06.356
WORKERS THAT WILL NEVER BE
02:41:06.423 --> 02:41:08.125
AUTOMATED AND SO IT IS.
02:41:08.191 --> 02:41:09.493
ABOUT TIME THAT WE'RE MOVING
02:41:09.559 --> 02:41:10.594
FORWARD ON THIS THANK YOU FOR
02:41:10.660 --> 02:41:12.963
BRINGING FOR IT AND I IT WILL
02:41:13.030 --> 02:41:15.332
VOTE YES TODAY.
02:41:15.399 --> 02:41:15.966
THE U. S. M. THE SOMEBODY WHAT
02:41:16.033 --> 02:41:16.533
THANK YOU FOR BRINGING THIS
02:41:16.600 --> 02:41:17.934
FORWARD WERE HAVING A PRETTY
02:41:18.001 --> 02:41:19.770
PERSPECTIVE CONVERSATION I THINK
02:41:19.836 --> 02:41:21.104
ACROSS THE ADMINISTRATION AND
02:41:21.171 --> 02:41:23.240
THE LEGISLATURE NOW ABOUT THE
02:41:23.306 --> 02:41:24.674
FUTURE THE EDUCATION SYSTEM AN
02:41:24.741 --> 02:41:26.143
EARLY CHILDHOOD EDUCATION IS ONE
02:41:26.209 --> 02:41:27.210
OF THOSE CRITICAL COMPONENTS AND
02:41:27.277 --> 02:41:29.079
SO FOR CHILD.
02:41:29.146 --> 02:41:30.080
CARE WORKERS WHO ARE.
02:41:30.147 --> 02:41:32.049
THE FIRST OPPORTUNITY TO START
02:41:32.115 --> 02:41:34.017
THAT EDUCATION.
02:41:34.084 --> 02:41:35.452
THE STEP WE NEED TO TAKE IS TO
02:41:35.519 --> 02:41:37.087
PROFESSIONALISM IS TO BRING THEM
02:41:37.154 --> 02:41:38.789
INTO THE WORK FORCE IN AN
02:41:38.855 --> 02:41:40.757
APPROPRIATE WAY HAVE THEM PAID
02:41:40.824 --> 02:41:42.359
WELL GIVE THEM BENEFITS.
02:41:42.426 --> 02:41:43.894
GIVE THEM RESPECT FOR THE THE
02:41:43.960 --> 02:41:45.529
POSITION THAT THEY THAT THEY
02:41:45.595 --> 02:41:47.531
HAVE IN OUR COMMUNITY AND OUR
02:41:47.597 --> 02:41:49.866
SOCIETY AND INTEGRATE THAT INTO
02:41:49.933 --> 02:41:51.234
THE EDUCATION SYSTEM THAT'S
02:41:51.301 --> 02:41:53.136
ULTIMATELY THE GOAL THAT'S WHY
02:41:53.203 --> 02:41:54.571
THIS BILL IS VERY APPROPRIATE.
02:41:54.638 --> 02:41:55.939
AND I THANK YOU FOR BRINGING IT
02:41:56.006 --> 02:41:56.807
FORWARD THANK YOU.
02:41:56.873 --> 02:41:57.974
AND WITH THAT YOU MAY CLOSE
02:41:58.041 --> 02:41:59.709
THANK YOU AND I WANT TO ADD THAT
02:41:59.776 --> 02:42:00.610
YOU YOU KNOW IN THIS
02:42:00.677 --> 02:42:02.045
CONVERSATION.
02:42:02.112 --> 02:42:03.747
THAT UNIONIZING AND COLLECTIVE
02:42:03.814 --> 02:42:05.682
BARGAINING IS A MEANS TO A
02:42:05.749 --> 02:42:07.684
GREATER GOOD WHEN I THINK OF
02:42:07.751 --> 02:42:09.019
WHAT IT WOULD MEAN TO HAVE
02:42:09.086 --> 02:42:11.188
TRAINING FOR THE INDIVIDUALS
02:42:11.254 --> 02:42:12.756
THAT TAKE CARE.
02:42:12.823 --> 02:42:16.827
OF THE KIDS -- BELOW FIVE TO BE
02:42:16.893 --> 02:42:18.161
ABLE TO DENNIS ACT IN A FIGHT
02:42:18.228 --> 02:42:20.730
COGNITIVE CHALLENGES TO BE ABLE
02:42:20.797 --> 02:42:22.432
TO IDENTIFY WHAT REALLY IS IN
02:42:22.499 --> 02:42:24.568
THEIR BEST INTEREST IN TERMS OF
02:42:24.634 --> 02:42:26.336
HEALTH DECISIONS EDUCATION
02:42:26.403 --> 02:42:28.605
DECISIONS -- THIS IS BIGGER THIS
02:42:28.672 --> 02:42:32.709
IS JUST A MEANS TO CREATE
02:42:32.776 --> 02:42:35.178
HEALTHIER.
02:42:35.245 --> 02:42:35.812
KIDS OF THAT OUR OUR FUTURE TOO
02:42:35.879 --> 02:42:36.613
REALLY PREPARE STUDENTS FOR A K.
02:42:36.680 --> 02:42:37.814
THROUGH TWELVE SYSTEM IN THE
02:42:37.881 --> 02:42:39.916
BEST WAY POSSIBLE -- ANYTHING
02:42:39.983 --> 02:42:41.685
SOMETIMES WE GET LOST THAT THIS
02:42:41.751 --> 02:42:43.587
IS ABOUT THE GREATER GOOD OF OUR
02:42:43.653 --> 02:42:45.455
FUTURE THIS IS GOING TO BE WHO
02:42:45.522 --> 02:42:47.324
LEADS THE STATE -- THIS IS THE
02:42:47.390 --> 02:42:49.726
MEANS TO ENSURE THAT THE WORKERS
02:42:49.793 --> 02:42:51.361
HAVE ALL THE TOOLS THAT THERE HE
02:42:51.428 --> 02:42:52.829
QUIPPED THAT WE PROFESSIONAL
02:42:52.896 --> 02:42:53.463
EYES.
02:42:53.530 --> 02:42:55.632
THE INDUSTRY IN SUCH A WAY THAT
02:42:55.699 --> 02:42:57.868
WE HAVE MORE INDIVIDUALS THAT
02:42:57.934 --> 02:43:01.738
WANT TO AND CAN STEP UP TO BE
02:43:01.805 --> 02:43:04.207
ABLE TO DO THIS NEEDED WORK.
02:43:04.274 --> 02:43:04.774
WITH THAT I RESPECTFULLY ASK
02:43:04.841 --> 02:43:05.442
PRIVATE.
02:43:05.509 --> 02:43:06.676
THANK YOU WE DO HAVE A MOTION TO
02:43:06.743 --> 02:43:08.111
SECOND THE MOTION IS TO PASS AS
02:43:08.178 --> 02:43:09.846
AMENDED TO APPROPRIATIONS CALL
02:43:09.913 --> 02:43:12.282
THE ROLL PLEASE STONE BY STONE
02:43:12.349 --> 02:43:13.950
AYE GALLAGHER.
02:43:14.017 --> 02:43:16.586
GALLAGHER NO CHAU CHIU.
02:43:16.653 --> 02:43:17.921
AND SALAS.
02:43:17.988 --> 02:43:18.655
GONZALEZ I HOLDEN.
02:43:18.722 --> 02:43:20.457
HOLDEN AYE KALRA.
02:43:20.524 --> 02:43:23.660
KALRA AYE KILEY MAIENSCHEIN.
02:43:23.727 --> 02:43:25.128
MAIENSCHEIN I OBERNOLTE
02:43:25.195 --> 02:43:26.530
PETRIE-NORRIS.
02:43:26.596 --> 02:43:30.066
NORTH AYE REYES.
02:43:30.133 --> 02:43:32.636
THE BILL IS ONE MORE OF A SAID
02:43:32.702 --> 02:43:41.278
ON CALL THANK YOU THANK YOU.
02:43:41.344 --> 02:43:45.215
THIS WORKS THAT TAKES US. TO
02:43:45.282 --> 02:43:52.923
ITEM NUMBER FIVE ON OUR LIST AB
02:43:52.989 --> 02:43:53.223
[inaudible]
02:43:53.290 --> 02:43:54.224
SEVEN TWO FOUR WHERE HI.
02:43:54.291 --> 02:43:56.793
MEMBERS I THANK YOU FOR HAVING
02:43:56.860 --> 02:43:58.795
ME TODAY -- YOU KNOW I THINK ALL
02:43:58.862 --> 02:44:00.630
OF US KNOW THE ISSUES THAT WE'RE
02:44:00.697 --> 02:44:01.932
FACING IN TERMS OF HOMELESSNESS
02:44:01.998 --> 02:44:03.200
IN OUR COMMUNITIES WHETHER IT'S
02:44:03.266 --> 02:44:06.369
WILDFIRES -- THE COST OF LIVING
02:44:06.436 --> 02:44:08.238
FINANCIAL SECURITY -- WE HEAR
02:44:08.305 --> 02:44:10.440
AND SEE THE STORIES IN THE PRESS
02:44:10.507 --> 02:44:11.041
YOU KNOW IN MY DISTRICT ALONG
02:44:11.107 --> 02:44:12.375
WE'VE HAD ABOUT A 40% INCREASE
02:44:12.442 --> 02:44:14.511
IN HOMELESSNESS IN THE LAST TWO
02:44:14.578 --> 02:44:15.812
TO THREE YEARS -- ANYTHING THOSE
02:44:15.879 --> 02:44:17.714
TRENDS ARE ARE GROWING AND AND
02:44:17.781 --> 02:44:19.516
CONTINUING -- WHAT WE DON'T
02:44:19.583 --> 02:44:20.584
ACTUALLY HAVE AS A STATEWIDE
02:44:20.650 --> 02:44:22.385
RENTAL REGISTRY DATABASE THAT
02:44:22.452 --> 02:44:22.852
WOULD HELP US COLLECT
02:44:22.919 --> 02:44:24.654
INFORMATION SO WE CAN UNDERSTAND
02:44:24.721 --> 02:44:25.422
TRENDS OF?
02:44:25.488 --> 02:44:27.090
EVICTIONS AND RENT INCREASES AND
02:44:27.157 --> 02:44:28.491
THINGS OF THIS NATURE -- I'M A
02:44:28.558 --> 02:44:29.526
BIG BELIEVER IN EVIDENCE BASED
02:44:29.593 --> 02:44:30.961
POLICY MAKING AND HAVING THE
02:44:31.027 --> 02:44:33.330
DATA TO CREATE THE POLICIES THAT
02:44:33.396 --> 02:44:35.232
WE NEED. TO TO ADDRESS OUR
02:44:35.298 --> 02:44:37.100
HOUSING CRISIS YOU KNOW PROTECT
02:44:37.167 --> 02:44:38.068
THE TENANTS THAT WE NEED.
02:44:38.134 --> 02:44:38.902
TO WE CURRENTLY DON'T HAVE THIS
02:44:38.969 --> 02:44:40.203
READ THIS INFORMATION SOME
02:44:40.270 --> 02:44:41.705
CITIES HAVE.
02:44:41.771 --> 02:44:44.040
RENTAL REGISTRIES A MOST DON'T
02:44:44.107 --> 02:44:45.408
I'M SO THIS BILL IS VERY SIMPLE
02:44:45.475 --> 02:44:46.743
IT WOULD JUST SEEK TO CREATE A
02:44:46.810 --> 02:44:47.811
RENTAL REGISTRY SO WE CAN GATHER
02:44:47.877 --> 02:44:49.212
THAT INFORMATION AND FROM THAT
02:44:49.279 --> 02:44:50.580
INFORMATION THEN.
02:44:50.647 --> 02:44:51.314
FIGURE OUT WHAT ARE THE BEST
02:44:51.381 --> 02:44:52.549
POLICIES TO HAVE SOLUTIONS TO
02:44:52.616 --> 02:44:53.650
THESE PROBLEMS SO.
02:44:53.717 --> 02:44:55.085
IT'S A PRETTY SIMPLE BILL IN
02:44:55.151 --> 02:44:57.187
TERMS OF ITS CONCEPT -- WE
02:44:57.254 --> 02:44:58.054
PASSED OUT OF THE HOUSING
02:44:58.121 --> 02:45:00.457
COMMITTEE WE WOULD RESPECTFULLY
02:45:00.523 --> 02:45:02.459
ASK YOUR AYE VOTE AND WITH ME
02:45:02.525 --> 02:45:03.393
IT'S TESTIFIED TODAY'S CATHERINE
02:45:03.460 --> 02:45:05.262
BRACE FROM TECH EQUITY AND THERE
02:45:05.328 --> 02:45:06.529
ARE SOME AMENDMENTS AS LISTED
02:45:06.596 --> 02:45:07.664
THE ANALYSIS YOU'RE TAKING THOSE
02:45:07.731 --> 02:45:09.933
IS OFFSHORE -- YES THANK YOU
02:45:10.000 --> 02:45:10.467
THANK YOU THANK YOU FIRST
02:45:10.533 --> 02:45:11.635
WITNESS HI THANK YOU MISTER
02:45:11.701 --> 02:45:12.402
CHAIR AND MEMBERS OF THE
02:45:12.469 --> 02:45:13.503
COMMITTEE I AM CAPTAIN BRACEY
02:45:13.570 --> 02:45:14.738
I'M THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF
02:45:14.804 --> 02:45:16.206
THE TECH EQUITY COLLABORATIVE --
02:45:16.273 --> 02:45:17.407
WE ARE AN ORGANIZATION BASED IN
02:45:17.474 --> 02:45:19.376
THE BAY AREA THAT BELIEVES THAT
02:45:19.442 --> 02:45:20.877
OUR STATE'S TECH DRIVEN ECONOMY
02:45:20.944 --> 02:45:22.279
CAN AND SHOULD CREATE BROAD
02:45:22.345 --> 02:45:23.546
BASED OPPORTUNITY FOR ALL
02:45:23.613 --> 02:45:24.514
RESIDENTS.
02:45:24.581 --> 02:45:26.049
ARE CORE MEMBERSHIP CONSISTS OF
02:45:26.116 --> 02:45:27.684
RANK AND FILE TECH WORKERS WHO
02:45:27.751 --> 02:45:28.818
WANT TO USE THEIR UNIQUE POWERS
02:45:28.885 --> 02:45:30.420
RESIDENTS OF CALIFORNIA TO PUSH
02:45:30.487 --> 02:45:31.688
FOR POLICY CHANGES.
02:45:31.755 --> 02:45:32.789
THAT WILL ALLOW THE BENEFITS
02:45:32.856 --> 02:45:34.858
CREATED BY OUR BOOMING ECONOMY
02:45:34.924 --> 02:45:36.326
TO ACCRUE MORE PEOPLE SOLVING
02:45:36.393 --> 02:45:38.228
HOUSING CRISIS IS OBVIOUSLY A
02:45:38.295 --> 02:45:39.029
CRITICAL ELEMENT OF THAT
02:45:39.095 --> 02:45:39.596
EQUATION.
02:45:39.663 --> 02:45:41.164
AS TECH WORKERS WE ARE ACUTELY
02:45:41.231 --> 02:45:42.332
AWARE OF THE IMPACT WE ARE
02:45:42.399 --> 02:45:43.466
HAVING ON HOUSING COSTS IN
02:45:43.533 --> 02:45:45.769
CALIFORNIA WE FEEL THIS CRISIS
02:45:45.835 --> 02:45:47.437
TO AS MANY OF US PAY WELL MORE
02:45:47.504 --> 02:45:48.071
THAN A THIRD OF OUR INCOMES FOR
02:45:48.138 --> 02:45:48.905
HOUSING.
02:45:48.972 --> 02:45:49.939
WE KNOW THAT THIS IS
02:45:50.006 --> 02:45:51.374
UNSUSTAINABLE PARTICULARLY FOR
02:45:51.441 --> 02:45:56.680
NEIGHBORS WHO ARE NURSES
02:45:56.746 --> 02:45:58.515
TEACHERS BUS DRIVERS JANITOR.
02:45:58.581 --> 02:45:59.115
AND OTHERS TO DO THE CRITICAL
02:45:59.182 --> 02:45:59.949
WORK OUR COMMUNITIES NEED TO
02:46:00.016 --> 02:46:00.884
THRIVE IN FOR OUR NEIGHBORS HAVE
02:46:00.950 --> 02:46:01.518
BEEN MADE HOMELESS ORBIT OR BEEN
02:46:01.584 --> 02:46:02.185
DISPLACED BECAUSE OF THE LACK OF
02:46:02.252 --> 02:46:03.353
AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
02:46:03.420 --> 02:46:04.454
AS TECH WORKERS WE ALSO
02:46:04.521 --> 02:46:05.522
UNDERSTAND THE IMPORTANCE OF
02:46:05.588 --> 02:46:07.490
HAVING RELIABLE DATA TO INFORM
02:46:07.557 --> 02:46:08.825
DECISION MAKING.
02:46:08.892 --> 02:46:10.160
OVER THE PAST FEW YEARS AS WE
02:46:10.226 --> 02:46:11.428
HAVE BEGUN TO ENGAGE IN HOUSING
02:46:11.494 --> 02:46:12.929
ADVOCACY WORK WE HAVE FOUND THE
02:46:12.996 --> 02:46:14.431
POLICY CONVERSATION AROUND TEN A
02:46:14.497 --> 02:46:15.932
PROTECTIONS TO BE TAKING PLACE
02:46:15.999 --> 02:46:17.834
AND THE ABSENCE OF REAL DATA
02:46:17.901 --> 02:46:19.536
ABOUT THE EXTENT OF THE PROBLEM.
02:46:19.602 --> 02:46:21.738
NO ONE REALLY KNOWS HOW MUCH
02:46:21.805 --> 02:46:22.372
RENTS ARE INCREASING ACROSS THE
02:46:22.439 --> 02:46:23.206
STATE.
02:46:23.273 --> 02:46:24.741
AT THE DATA THAT DOES EXIST FROM
02:46:24.808 --> 02:46:25.775
PLACES LIKE THE AMERICAN
02:46:25.842 --> 02:46:27.377
COMMUNITY SURVEY AND PRIVATE
02:46:27.444 --> 02:46:29.179
COMPANIES LIKE ZILLOW ARE
02:46:29.245 --> 02:46:31.548
INSUFFICIENT IN MANY WAYS THEIR
02:46:31.614 --> 02:46:33.583
PROPRIETARY EXPENSIVE -- NOT
02:46:33.650 --> 02:46:34.617
COMPREHENSIVE AND THEY TEND TO
02:46:34.684 --> 02:46:36.119
REPORT TOP LINE DATA SUCH AS
02:46:36.186 --> 02:46:38.054
AVERAGES IN ORDER TO MAKE SMART
02:46:38.121 --> 02:46:40.056
HOUSING POLICY WE NEED GRANULAR
02:46:40.123 --> 02:46:41.591
TRANSPARENT AND COMPREHENSIVE
02:46:41.658 --> 02:46:43.159
DATA ABOUT RENTAL PRICES THAT
02:46:43.226 --> 02:46:44.461
CAN ONLY BE GATHERED BY ASKING
02:46:44.527 --> 02:46:45.729
THE LANDLORDS TO SUBMIT THEM
02:46:45.795 --> 02:46:46.629
DIRECTLY.
02:46:46.696 --> 02:46:47.430
WE'RE HAPPY TO STAND WITH
02:46:47.497 --> 02:46:48.631
ASSEMBLY MEMBER WICKS ON THIS
02:46:48.698 --> 02:46:49.866
BILL AND WE RESPECTFULLY ASK
02:46:49.933 --> 02:46:52.469
YOUR AYE BOATS THANK YOU THANK
02:46:52.535 --> 02:46:59.075
YOU ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT
02:46:59.142 --> 02:46:59.376
[inaudible]
02:46:59.442 --> 02:47:00.944
UPDATE.
02:47:01.010 --> 02:47:01.945
HI DAVID ONLY HAVE THE BAY AREA
02:47:02.011 --> 02:47:02.946
HOUSING ADVOCACY COALITION IN
02:47:03.012 --> 02:47:05.849
SUPPORT.
02:47:05.915 --> 02:47:06.950
SUCH A HARD IN ON BEHALF OF THE
02:47:07.016 --> 02:47:07.817
WESTERN CENTER ON LAW AND
02:47:07.884 --> 02:47:09.853
POVERTY AND THE CALIFORNIA RURAL
02:47:09.919 --> 02:47:10.820
LEGAL ASSISTANCE FOUNDATION IN
02:47:10.887 --> 02:47:11.988
SUPPORT.
02:47:12.055 --> 02:47:13.623
THANK YOU ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT.
02:47:13.690 --> 02:47:30.206
SEEING NONE IS THERE OPPOSITION
02:47:35.612 --> 02:47:35.678
.
02:47:35.678 --> 02:47:36.746
HI THE ONLY BE WITH THE A
02:47:36.813 --> 02:47:38.748
CALIFORNIA APARTMENT SOCIAL FROM
02:47:38.815 --> 02:47:40.884
HERE IN OPPOSITION -- WE WE
02:47:40.950 --> 02:47:42.819
UNDERSTAND THE INTENT OF WHAT
02:47:42.886 --> 02:47:44.621
THE A SOMEONE TRYING TO DO --
02:47:44.687 --> 02:47:45.955
BUT WE STILL BELIEVE THERE'S NO
02:47:46.022 --> 02:47:47.524
RATIONAL REASON FOR MANAGING
02:47:47.590 --> 02:47:49.025
THIS EXTENSIVE INFORMATION.
02:47:49.092 --> 02:47:51.027
FOR A PUBLIC WEBSITE AND NO
02:47:51.094 --> 02:47:51.928
PLAUSIBLE ARGUMENT THAT THIS
02:47:51.995 --> 02:47:53.129
INFORMATION WE USE IN A
02:47:53.196 --> 02:47:55.131
PRODUCTIVE WAY TO ADDRESS THE
02:47:55.198 --> 02:47:56.666
CURRENT HOUSING CRISIS -- INVADE
02:47:56.733 --> 02:47:57.967
THE PRIVACY OF OWNERS AND
02:47:58.034 --> 02:47:59.002
TENANTS WHO LIVE IN RENTAL UNITS
02:47:59.068 --> 02:48:00.370
BY REQUIRING.
02:48:00.437 --> 02:48:02.172
DISCLOSURES OF THEIR DRESS
02:48:02.238 --> 02:48:03.740
UTILITY COSTS THE NUMBER AND
02:48:03.807 --> 02:48:05.208
SIZE OF THEIR BEDROOMS.
02:48:05.275 --> 02:48:07.944
AND BATHROOMS AND ALSO MAKE TENS
02:48:08.011 --> 02:48:09.779
RIGHT PAYMENT HISTORY OR NON
02:48:09.846 --> 02:48:11.481
PAYMENT PUBLIC.
02:48:11.548 --> 02:48:13.349
IT ALSO REQUIRES MEMBERS
02:48:13.416 --> 02:48:13.950
DISCLOSE INFORMATION ABOUT THE
02:48:14.017 --> 02:48:16.486
PENSIONS.
02:48:16.553 --> 02:48:19.289
WHEN IT?
02:48:19.355 --> 02:48:19.923
WHEN THE INFORMATION BE MASKED?
02:48:19.989 --> 02:48:21.624
BY THE COURTS FOR PRIVACY
02:48:21.691 --> 02:48:23.026
REASONS -- THE PUBLIC
02:48:23.092 --> 02:48:24.260
INFORMATION WILL MAKE IT EASY
02:48:24.327 --> 02:48:24.828
FOR TENNIS THE NEIGHBORS. TO
02:48:24.894 --> 02:48:26.896
FIND PRIVATE INFORMATION SUCH AS
02:48:26.963 --> 02:48:28.798
RENT THAT THE REBBE NEIGHBORS
02:48:28.865 --> 02:48:29.566
ARE PAYING.
02:48:29.632 --> 02:48:31.000
WHY CERTAIN FAMILY MEMBER MOVED
02:48:31.067 --> 02:48:32.869
AWAY OR FAMILY?
02:48:32.936 --> 02:48:33.970
HOUSE WOULD MOVE THE WAY OR HOW
02:48:34.037 --> 02:48:35.505
SMALL THE APARTMENT IS.
02:48:35.572 --> 02:48:37.106
THAT LARGE FAMILIES LIMóN AND
02:48:37.173 --> 02:48:38.274
THE BILL WOULD ALSO REQUIRE
02:48:38.341 --> 02:48:39.542
POPULOUS PROVIDE EXACT SQUARE
02:48:39.609 --> 02:48:43.112
FOOTAGE OTHER UNITS UNDER STATE
02:48:43.179 --> 02:48:45.114
LAW NOW.
02:48:45.181 --> 02:48:46.483
BILLS ARE NOT ALLOWED TO DEMAND
02:48:46.549 --> 02:48:48.718
ENTRY AND INTRIGUE AGAINST A
02:48:48.785 --> 02:48:50.119
TENNIS WISHES COLLECT THAT
02:48:50.186 --> 02:48:52.822
INFORMATION.
02:48:52.889 --> 02:48:54.190
AND THE LAST THING I'LL SAY.
02:48:54.257 --> 02:48:56.459
IS THE ANALYSIS POINTS OUT THAT.
02:48:56.526 --> 02:48:58.027
DE ON PAGE SIX THAT THE A
02:48:58.094 --> 02:48:59.095
COMPANY A COMPANY TRADE OFFS
02:48:59.162 --> 02:49:00.763
IMPROV STILL WORTH THE BENEFIT.
02:49:00.830 --> 02:49:01.130
I GUESS WE ASK.
02:49:01.197 --> 02:49:02.198
WHAT?
02:49:02.265 --> 02:49:05.134
THE BENEFIT IS -- FOR IF IT'S
02:49:05.201 --> 02:49:06.569
FOR THE TENANT GROUPS IF YOU
02:49:06.636 --> 02:49:07.937
LOOK ON THE SUPPORT LIST THERE'S
02:49:08.004 --> 02:49:10.306
NO TENANT RIGHTS ADVOCATES --
02:49:10.373 --> 02:49:11.574
LISTED IN SUPPORT AND
02:49:11.641 --> 02:49:12.742
ADDITIONALLY.
02:49:12.809 --> 02:49:14.911
WE BELIEVE THE INFORMATION CAN
02:49:14.978 --> 02:49:17.614
BE GATHERED NOW -- AND NOT NEED
02:49:17.680 --> 02:49:19.215
TO CREATE A STATEWIDE DATABASE
02:49:19.282 --> 02:49:21.117
COMPANIES LIKE COSTAR --
02:49:21.184 --> 02:49:22.852
COLLECTORS TYPE INFORMATION NOW
02:49:22.919 --> 02:49:25.188
AND IT IS PRETTY -- IT'S
02:49:25.255 --> 02:49:26.656
EXTENSIVE AND DESCRIPTIVE.
02:49:26.723 --> 02:49:28.424
CAM THAT COMPANY ALSO HAS A
02:49:28.491 --> 02:49:30.326
BELIEVE THREE CONTRACTS WITH THE
02:49:30.393 --> 02:49:31.427
STATE -- ONE BEING THE
02:49:31.494 --> 02:49:33.162
DEPARTMENT GENERAL SERVICES AND
02:49:33.229 --> 02:49:35.798
ADDITIONALLY TWENTY CONTRACTS
02:49:35.865 --> 02:49:37.567
ARE TWENTY PLUS CONTRACTS WITH
02:49:37.634 --> 02:49:39.802
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS -- DOING THIS
02:49:39.869 --> 02:49:40.770
TYPE OF INFORMATION COLLECTED
02:49:40.837 --> 02:49:42.272
SOME INFORMATION SO WE BELIEVE
02:49:42.338 --> 02:49:45.174
LOOKING AT BAM OR FOLKS LIKE
02:49:45.241 --> 02:49:48.645
THEM OUT IN THE UNIVERSE NOW.
02:49:48.711 --> 02:49:52.882
IS BETTER THAN QUEEN A BRAND NEW
02:49:52.949 --> 02:49:54.484
STATEWIDE DATABASE [inaudible]
02:49:54.551 --> 02:49:57.120
THANK YOU.
02:49:57.186 --> 02:49:58.888
CHAIRMAN MEMBERS MY NAME IS TIM
02:49:58.955 --> 02:49:59.756
CAN MEREKA A WITH CALIFORNIA
02:49:59.822 --> 02:50:00.423
STRATEGIC ADVISERS ON BEHALF OF
02:50:00.490 --> 02:50:00.924
THE AFFORDABLE HOUSING
02:50:00.990 --> 02:50:01.724
MANAGEMENT ASSOCIATION OF
02:50:01.791 --> 02:50:02.158
PACIFIC SOUTHWEST.
02:50:02.225 --> 02:50:03.626
WE CAME IN WITH A LATE OPPOSE
02:50:03.693 --> 02:50:04.928
UNLESS AMENDED AND I JUST WANT
02:50:04.994 --> 02:50:06.029
TO ACTUALLY THINK THE AUTHOR AND
02:50:06.095 --> 02:50:07.163
THEIR STAFF BECAUSE THEY HAVE
02:50:07.230 --> 02:50:08.264
BEEN WORKING WITH US.
02:50:08.331 --> 02:50:09.532
MEMBERS ARE OUR GROUP
02:50:09.599 --> 02:50:10.500
SPECIFICALLY OUR CLIENTS
02:50:10.567 --> 02:50:12.335
REPRESENT A 100% DEED RESTRICTED
02:50:12.402 --> 02:50:13.670
PROPERTIES THAT ARE ALREADY
02:50:13.736 --> 02:50:15.705
COMPREHENSIVELY MONITORED
02:50:15.772 --> 02:50:16.806
REPORTED AND TRACKED.
02:50:16.873 --> 02:50:18.308
NOT ONLY THROUGH FEDERAL AND
02:50:18.374 --> 02:50:19.976
STATE AGREEMENT SPECIFIC PACIFIC
02:50:20.043 --> 02:50:21.878
WE THROUGH THE STATE OF
02:50:21.945 --> 02:50:22.979
TREASURY'S OFFICE.
02:50:23.046 --> 02:50:23.613
THE TREASURY'S OFFICE RIGHT NOW
02:50:23.680 --> 02:50:25.214
HAS ALL OF THIS INFORMATION SO
02:50:25.281 --> 02:50:26.950
FOR US WEIRD BASICALLY ASKING
02:50:27.016 --> 02:50:28.284
THAT YOU KNOW THIS ADDITIONAL
02:50:28.351 --> 02:50:29.586
REPORTING REQUIREMENT WHEN IT'S
02:50:29.652 --> 02:50:30.219
ALREADY BEING DONE IS
02:50:30.286 --> 02:50:31.554
UNNECESSARILY BURDENSOME FOR OUR
02:50:31.621 --> 02:50:32.255
MEMBERS.
02:50:32.322 --> 02:50:33.556
WE ARE WORKING WITH THE AUTHOR
02:50:33.623 --> 02:50:34.691
TO SEE IF THERE MIGHT BE A WAY
02:50:34.757 --> 02:50:36.392
IF NOT EXEMPTING OUR MEMBERS
02:50:36.459 --> 02:50:38.361
MAYBE POSSIBLY PULLING THAT DATA
02:50:38.428 --> 02:50:39.195
FROM THE SECRETARY OF STATE'S
02:50:39.262 --> 02:50:40.563
OFFICE.
02:50:40.630 --> 02:50:41.264
BECAUSE WE ARE AFFORDABLE
02:50:41.331 --> 02:50:42.632
HOUSING GROUP OBVIOUSLY OUR
02:50:42.699 --> 02:50:44.133
MEMBERS ARE NONPROFIT AND SO
02:50:44.200 --> 02:50:45.735
THEY LIVE WITH MARGINS AND SO WE
02:50:45.802 --> 02:50:46.769
WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT WE ARE
02:50:46.836 --> 02:50:47.437
NOT.
02:50:47.503 --> 02:50:48.671
A NECESSARILY BIRD DANCING THEM
02:50:48.738 --> 02:50:50.073
WE THINK THAT THE DIRECTION THE
02:50:50.139 --> 02:50:51.507
BILL MAKES A LOT OF SENSE LIKE I
02:50:51.574 --> 02:50:54.043
SAID WE SUPPORT REPORTING.
02:50:54.110 --> 02:50:55.244
IT'S JUST DO IN A WAY THAT
02:50:55.311 --> 02:50:56.479
DOESN'T.
02:50:56.546 --> 02:50:58.848
DUPLICATE -- BE DUPLICATIVE FOR
02:50:58.915 --> 02:50:59.449
AND REDUNDANT FOR OUR MEMBERS
02:50:59.515 --> 02:51:02.285
THANK YOU.
02:51:02.352 --> 02:51:02.785
THANK YOU ANYONE ELSE IN
02:51:02.852 --> 02:51:04.887
OPPOSITION.
02:51:04.954 --> 02:51:06.022
I'D SAY NONE OF BRING IT BACK TO
02:51:06.089 --> 02:51:08.925
THE COMMITTEE QUESTIONS COMMENTS.
02:51:08.992 --> 02:51:09.225
GALLAGHER.
02:51:09.292 --> 02:51:09.892
SO I'VE BEEN THINKING ABOUT YOUR
02:51:09.959 --> 02:51:12.195
BILL AND I MEAN FOR ME OBVIOUSLY.
02:51:12.261 --> 02:51:13.296
YOU KNOW.
02:51:13.363 --> 02:51:14.263
THEM THE BIGGEST THING IS
02:51:14.330 --> 02:51:15.732
HAPPENING MY DISTRICT IS IS A
02:51:15.798 --> 02:51:18.301
WILDFIRE AND ESPECIALLY IN THESE.
02:51:18.368 --> 02:51:19.702
YOU KNOW CRISIS SITUATIONS
02:51:19.769 --> 02:51:22.905
DISASTROUS SITUATIONS.
02:51:22.972 --> 02:51:24.007
THE REAL CONCERN IS THAT THERE
02:51:24.073 --> 02:51:26.242
IS LIKE RENTS BIKING AND THERE'S
02:51:26.309 --> 02:51:28.144
EVICTIONS GOING ON THAT
02:51:28.211 --> 02:51:29.212
OTHERWISE WOULDN'T HAPPEN AND
02:51:29.278 --> 02:51:33.249
THAT RENTS ARE BEING YOU KNOW --
02:51:33.316 --> 02:51:34.851
BASICALLY ARBITRARILY AND
02:51:34.917 --> 02:51:36.719
INFLATED -- FOR A LOT OF PEOPLE
02:51:36.786 --> 02:51:37.787
WHO ARE.
02:51:37.854 --> 02:51:39.622
LOOKING FOR DESPERATELY FOR
02:51:39.689 --> 02:51:41.357
HOUSING -- AND SO IN THAT
02:51:41.424 --> 02:51:43.026
CONTEXT IN AND I THINK
02:51:43.092 --> 02:51:44.794
ULTIMATELY IN THE IN THE HOUSE
02:51:44.861 --> 02:51:45.862
FOR IN SOLVING OUR HOUSING
02:51:45.928 --> 02:51:48.731
CRISIS ARE OUR ULTIMATE.
02:51:48.798 --> 02:51:50.266
SOLUTION IS INCREASING SUPPLY
02:51:50.333 --> 02:51:52.035
LIKE WE HAVE TO BUILD MORE
02:51:52.101 --> 02:51:54.237
HOUSING -- IN THE FACT THAT WE
02:51:54.303 --> 02:51:55.738
HAVEN'T BEEN DOING THAT WHETHER
02:51:55.805 --> 02:51:57.240
BECAUSE OF BURDENSOME
02:51:57.306 --> 02:51:59.809
REGULATIONS OR BECAUSE THE NAME
02:51:59.876 --> 02:52:01.177
BE ISM AND LOCAL [inaudible]
02:52:01.244 --> 02:52:03.279
RESTRICTIONS -- FOR WHATEVER
02:52:03.346 --> 02:52:04.714
REASON WE HAVEN'T BUILT A LOT OF
02:52:04.781 --> 02:52:06.182
HOUSING AND THAT ONLY MAKES THE
02:52:06.249 --> 02:52:07.850
PROBLEM WORSE BECAUSE WE HAVE
02:52:07.917 --> 02:52:10.753
THIS LIMITED.
02:52:10.820 --> 02:52:12.055
NO UNIVERSE OF HOUSING.
02:52:12.121 --> 02:52:13.523
THERE'S ONLY STE ONLY SO MUCH IN
02:52:13.589 --> 02:52:15.091
IT IN THAT THAT INCREASES I
02:52:15.158 --> 02:52:16.993
THINK ULTIMATELY THE COST.
02:52:17.060 --> 02:52:19.328
THE OF RENTS OF PURCHASES OF
02:52:19.395 --> 02:52:23.866
HOME SO -- BUT I GUESS MY ON THE
02:52:23.933 --> 02:52:25.401
OTHER SIDE THAT MY CONCERN WOULD
02:52:25.468 --> 02:52:27.236
BE OKAY BILL YOU KNOW HOW IS
02:52:27.303 --> 02:52:28.204
THIS.
02:52:28.271 --> 02:52:30.506
INFORMATION GOING TO BE UTILIZED
02:52:30.573 --> 02:52:31.174
RIGHT BECAUSE I AND I AGREE WITH
02:52:31.240 --> 02:52:32.475
YOU WE SHOULD.
02:52:32.542 --> 02:52:34.177
I ALSO WANT TO SEE EVIDENCE SO
02:52:34.243 --> 02:52:35.878
WANT TO SEE DATA RIGHT -- BUT WE
02:52:35.945 --> 02:52:37.714
CAN OFF OFTEN INTERPRET THAT
02:52:37.780 --> 02:52:40.416
DATA DIFFERENTLY -- AND I THINK
02:52:40.483 --> 02:52:42.351
IN THE IN THE GENERAL'S SCOPE OF
02:52:42.418 --> 02:52:43.553
THINGS.
02:52:43.619 --> 02:52:44.620
I DON'T WANT TO GET INTO THE
02:52:44.687 --> 02:52:45.922
BUSINESS OF TELLING PEOPLE WHAT
02:52:45.988 --> 02:52:48.758
THEY SHOULD RENT THEIR HOMES.
02:52:48.825 --> 02:52:50.460
FOR THE I DON'T BELIEVE IN RENT
02:52:50.526 --> 02:52:52.895
CONTROL -- I DO BELIEVE IN
02:52:52.962 --> 02:52:55.331
PROTECTING AGAINST ABUSES LIKE
02:52:55.398 --> 02:52:56.532
LIKE THAT WE HAVE SEEN.
02:52:56.599 --> 02:53:00.069
YOU KNOW SOMETIMES IN THESE
02:53:00.136 --> 02:53:01.337
EMERGENCY SITUATIONS.
02:53:01.404 --> 02:53:01.971
SO I DON'T KNOW IF THERE'S A WAY
02:53:02.038 --> 02:53:02.939
TO I MEAN IS THAT SOMETHING THAT
02:53:03.005 --> 02:53:04.807
YOU THOUGHT ABOUT AND AND AND I
02:53:04.874 --> 02:53:06.375
GUESS LAST PROBABLY THE PRIVACY.
02:53:06.442 --> 02:53:07.944
ISSUES THAT I I KNOW YOU'VE BEEN
02:53:08.010 --> 02:53:10.313
WORKING WITH OPPOSITION ON SO
02:53:10.379 --> 02:53:10.880
MAYBE YOU CAN JUST KIND OF
02:53:10.947 --> 02:53:11.914
ADDRESS THAT.
02:53:11.981 --> 02:53:15.485
THAT WAS A LOT OF TICKET BUT NO
02:53:15.551 --> 02:53:16.352
HOUSING IS A BIG ISSUE IN A FEW
02:53:16.419 --> 02:53:19.255
A ONE IT BUILD MORE HOMES I GOT
02:53:19.322 --> 02:53:20.857
ANOTHER BILL FOR YOU SO.
02:53:20.923 --> 02:53:22.859
I GOT.
02:53:22.925 --> 02:53:23.960
ONE BUT I AGREE WITH YOU KNOW
02:53:24.026 --> 02:53:24.627
THE ISSUES AROUND WILD FIRES IN
02:53:24.694 --> 02:53:25.728
THE SPIKES AND RENT YOU KNOW
02:53:25.795 --> 02:53:27.964
THIS BILL DOESN'T SEEK -- TO PUT
02:53:28.030 --> 02:53:29.365
ANY KIND OF RENTER PROTECTIONS
02:53:29.432 --> 02:53:30.533
ON THOSE THERE'S OTHER BILLS I
02:53:30.600 --> 02:53:31.934
THINK AIMING TO ADDRESS THAT
02:53:32.001 --> 02:53:33.436
ISSUE IN PARTICULAR WHICH I'M
02:53:33.503 --> 02:53:35.471
ALSO SUPPORT OF OF AND I DO
02:53:35.538 --> 02:53:36.105
BELIEVE WE NEED TO BUILD MORE
02:53:36.172 --> 02:53:36.773
HOUSING.
02:53:36.839 --> 02:53:38.775
SO I THINK ALL OF THE ABOVE IS
02:53:38.841 --> 02:53:39.442
IS CRITICAL AND I THINK WE BOTH
02:53:39.509 --> 02:53:39.909
NEED.
02:53:39.976 --> 02:53:41.310
TO BOTH PROTECT RENTERS AND
02:53:41.377 --> 02:53:42.678
BUILD HOUSING IN DOING BOTH OF
02:53:42.745 --> 02:53:43.679
THOSE THINGS OFTEN I THINK IN
02:53:43.746 --> 02:53:44.480
THIS DEBATE.
02:53:44.547 --> 02:53:45.381
THOSE TWO SIDES GET PITTED
02:53:45.448 --> 02:53:46.783
AGAINST EACH OTHER AND I THINK
02:53:46.849 --> 02:53:48.184
WE HAVE TO DO BOTH RIGHT -- IN
02:53:48.251 --> 02:53:49.819
TERMS OF THE THE PRIVACY
02:53:49.886 --> 02:53:51.687
PROTECTIONS -- OUR GOAL HERE IS
02:53:51.754 --> 02:53:53.523
NOT TO EXPOSE ANYONE'S IDENTITY
02:53:53.589 --> 02:53:55.191
OR YOU KNOW ANYTHING THAT NATURE
02:53:55.258 --> 02:53:57.293
WE ARE GOING TO ADOPT AND ARE AT
02:53:57.360 --> 02:53:57.627
HAVE ADOPTED.
02:53:57.693 --> 02:53:58.961
BOTH STATE AND FEDERAL PRIVACY
02:53:59.028 --> 02:54:00.596
LAWS TO ENSURE THAT WE ARE
02:54:00.663 --> 02:54:01.998
PROTECTING PRIVACY NAMES OF
02:54:02.064 --> 02:54:03.900
TENANTS WILL NOT BE PUBLIC --
02:54:03.966 --> 02:54:05.301
NAMES OF LANDLORDS WILL NOT BE
02:54:05.368 --> 02:54:07.103
PUBLIC IT'S JUST THE INFORMATION
02:54:07.170 --> 02:54:08.938
ON WHAT ARE THESE UNITS BEING
02:54:09.005 --> 02:54:11.240
RENTED -- FOR YOU KNOW ARE ARE
02:54:11.307 --> 02:54:13.242
THERE -- YOU KNOW EVICTIONS THAT
02:54:13.309 --> 02:54:14.644
WE'VE SEEN I'M WHAT IS THE DAD
02:54:14.710 --> 02:54:15.778
IT WOULD THAT WE CAN COLLECT SO
02:54:15.845 --> 02:54:17.747
THAT YOU KNOW ORGANIZATIONS LIKE
02:54:17.814 --> 02:54:19.215
THE TURNER CENTER UC BERKELEY
02:54:19.282 --> 02:54:20.750
THE FOCUS ON HOW WE CAN.
02:54:20.817 --> 02:54:22.118
TAKE THIS DATA AND UNDERSTAND
02:54:22.185 --> 02:54:23.786
AND ANALYZE THAT -- YOU KNOW HOW
02:54:23.853 --> 02:54:25.421
THEY CAN -- ACCESS THAT I THINK
02:54:25.488 --> 02:54:26.522
IS VERY IMPORTANT RIGHT NOW
02:54:26.589 --> 02:54:28.024
THEY'RE JUST ISN'T THAT DAD AT
02:54:28.090 --> 02:54:29.525
THE STATEWIDE LEVEL TO DO IT AND
02:54:29.592 --> 02:54:31.227
WE'RE HAPPY TO TALK MORE ABOUT
02:54:31.294 --> 02:54:33.062
PRIVACY PROTECTIONS AS YOU KNOW
02:54:33.129 --> 02:54:34.530
I'M A BIG ADVOCATE ON PRIVACY --
02:54:34.597 --> 02:54:35.898
AND AND WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT
02:54:35.965 --> 02:54:38.100
WE WE GUARD AGAINST ANY KIND OF
02:54:38.167 --> 02:54:39.402
COMPROMISE COMPROMISING
02:54:39.468 --> 02:54:41.704
SITUATIONS ON THE PRIVACY ISSUE --
02:54:41.771 --> 02:54:43.005
WELL IF I COULD ALSO JUST
02:54:43.072 --> 02:54:43.840
ADDRESS SOME OF THE POINTS THAT
02:54:43.906 --> 02:54:45.741
WERE RAISED HERE AS WELL -- YOU
02:54:45.808 --> 02:54:47.677
KNOW WE DO HAVE TENANTS GROUPS
02:54:47.743 --> 02:54:49.579
THAT ARE ADVOCATING FOR THIS --
02:54:49.645 --> 02:54:50.346
IN TERMS OF OUR LIST OF
02:54:50.413 --> 02:54:52.114
SUPPORTERS HAVING TECH EQUITY IS
02:54:52.181 --> 02:54:52.949
ONE IN PARTICULAR THE WESTERN
02:54:53.015 --> 02:54:55.651
CENTER YOU KNOW AIDS HEALTHCARE
02:54:55.718 --> 02:54:58.287
FOUNDATION ALL OF OUR SPONSORS
02:54:58.354 --> 02:54:59.789
AND AND FOLKS ARE ADVOCATING ON
02:54:59.856 --> 02:55:01.324
THIS ARE VERY THOUGHTFUL
02:55:01.390 --> 02:55:03.426
ADVOCATES IN THE TENETS SPACE SO.
02:55:03.492 --> 02:55:05.461
I WOULD JUST YOU KNOW A KINDLY
02:55:05.528 --> 02:55:06.963
DISAGREE WITH THAT ASSESSMENT
02:55:07.029 --> 02:55:08.364
AND WITH REGARD TO YOUR SHOES
02:55:08.431 --> 02:55:09.298
YOU KNOW WE JUST GOT THIS
02:55:09.365 --> 02:55:11.200
OPPOSITION LETTER VERY LATE
02:55:11.267 --> 02:55:12.068
WE'RE HAPPY TO KEEP TALKING
02:55:12.134 --> 02:55:12.735
ABOUT IT.
02:55:12.802 --> 02:55:13.169
AND WE WANT TO WORK
02:55:13.236 --> 02:55:15.504
COLLABORATIVELY AND WE ALSO YOU
02:55:15.571 --> 02:55:16.372
KNOW WE TOOK THE REALTORS
02:55:16.439 --> 02:55:18.074
AMENDMENTS THEY RAISE SOME
02:55:18.140 --> 02:55:18.708
AMENDMENTS WE TOOK THOSE IN THE
02:55:18.774 --> 02:55:22.678
LAST COMMITTEE TO TO MOVE THE
02:55:22.745 --> 02:55:23.412
BILL FORWARD SO.
02:55:23.479 --> 02:55:24.080
WE WANT TO WORK WITH FOLKS HERE
02:55:24.146 --> 02:55:24.814
IN TERMS OF GETTING THIS BILL
02:55:24.881 --> 02:55:25.314
THROUGH AND WANT TO BE
02:55:25.381 --> 02:55:25.948
THOUGHTFUL IN THE PRIVACY STUFF
02:55:26.015 --> 02:55:26.515
AND LOOK FORWARD TO CONTINUE
02:55:26.582 --> 02:55:27.183
CONVERSATIONS WITH THE APARTMENT
02:55:27.250 --> 02:55:28.417
ASSOCIATION ON THAT.
02:55:28.484 --> 02:55:29.719
AND I DO HEAR YOUR CONCERN ABOUT
02:55:29.785 --> 02:55:30.253
THE PRIVACY PIECE SO I'M
02:55:30.319 --> 02:55:32.688
COMMITTED TO TWENTY TO SAFEGUARD
02:55:32.755 --> 02:55:35.091
AGAINST THAT ISSUE.
02:55:35.157 --> 02:55:37.159
I DON'T KNOW IF I ANSWERED ALL
02:55:37.226 --> 02:55:37.760
YOUR QUESTIONS ASSEMBLY MEMBER
02:55:37.827 --> 02:55:38.761
OKAY.
02:55:38.828 --> 02:55:41.297
OTHER QUESTIONS ARE COVERED.
02:55:41.364 --> 02:55:43.199
ALL RIGHT SEEING NONE. SIX YOU
02:55:43.266 --> 02:55:44.967
MAY CLOSE WELL I WOULD
02:55:45.034 --> 02:55:46.168
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE VOTE.
02:55:46.235 --> 02:55:48.004
THANK YOU I'M LOOKING FOR A A
02:55:48.070 --> 02:55:50.506
MOTION MOTIONS TO PASS AS
02:55:50.573 --> 02:55:52.475
AMENDED TO APPROPRIATIONS.
02:55:52.541 --> 02:55:53.776
THERE'S A MOTION IS THERE A
02:55:53.843 --> 02:55:55.611
SECOND AND THE SECOND THANK YOU --
02:55:55.678 --> 02:55:56.712
ROLE PLEASE.
02:55:56.779 --> 02:55:59.448
STONE BY STONE AYE GALLAGHER
02:55:59.515 --> 02:55:59.749
[inaudible]
02:55:59.815 --> 02:56:01.450
CHAO.
02:56:01.517 --> 02:56:03.619
GALLAGHER I CHAU CHIU.
02:56:03.686 --> 02:56:05.755
GONZALEZ.
02:56:05.821 --> 02:56:06.956
BECAUSE I HOLDEN.
02:56:07.023 --> 02:56:08.791
HOLDEN AYE KALRA.
02:56:08.858 --> 02:56:10.159
COLOR I KILEY MAIENSCHEIN
02:56:10.226 --> 02:56:13.396
OBERNOLTE PETRIE-NORRIS.
02:56:13.462 --> 02:56:18.034
PETRIE-NORRIS I REYES.
02:56:18.100 --> 02:56:18.668
NEEDS ONE MORE SO PLACE THE BILL
02:56:18.734 --> 02:56:22.571
OF THANK YOU [inaudible]
02:56:22.638 --> 02:56:24.307
THIS RUBIO.
02:56:24.373 --> 02:56:28.044
YOU HAVE TO BILLS BEFORE US AB.
02:56:28.110 --> 02:56:30.713
TEN SEVENTY THREE AND A. B.
02:56:30.780 --> 02:56:31.314
FOURTEEN SEVENTEEN YOU HAVE A
02:56:31.380 --> 02:56:32.882
PREFERENCE.
02:56:32.949 --> 02:56:36.852
ALL RIGHT LET'S START WITH AB.
02:56:36.919 --> 02:56:37.386
TEN SEVENTY THREE OUR ITEM
02:56:37.453 --> 02:56:40.523
NUMBER.
02:56:40.589 --> 02:56:42.325
EIGHT I THANK YOU MISTER
02:56:42.391 --> 02:56:43.225
CHAIRMAN COMMITTEE MEMBERS A
02:56:43.292 --> 02:56:45.094
TODAY I'M PRESENTING AB TEN
02:56:45.161 --> 02:56:45.728
SEVENTY THREE WHICH AUTHORIZES
02:56:45.795 --> 02:56:46.862
THE ATTORNEY GENERAL TO ENTER
02:56:46.929 --> 02:56:47.930
INTO AN AGREEMENT WITH
02:56:47.997 --> 02:56:49.198
IMMIGRATION AND CUSTOMS
02:56:49.265 --> 02:56:50.933
ENFORCEMENT. TO LIMIT
02:56:51.000 --> 02:56:52.168
ENFORCEMENT ACTIVITIES AT THE
02:56:52.234 --> 02:56:53.436
VICTIM SERVICES LOCATIONS
02:56:53.502 --> 02:56:54.337
MENTIONED IN THE ATTORNEY
02:56:54.403 --> 02:56:56.238
GENERAL OCTOBER TWENTY EIGHTEEN
02:56:56.305 --> 02:56:57.840
MODEL POLICIES ON IMMIGRATION
02:56:57.907 --> 02:56:58.941
ENFORCEMENT.
02:56:59.008 --> 02:57:00.042
I WOULD LIKE TO START BY
02:57:00.109 --> 02:57:01.344
THANKING THE COMMITTEE AND THEIR
02:57:01.410 --> 02:57:03.079
STAFF FOR WORKING THOROUGHLY
02:57:03.145 --> 02:57:04.981
WITH OUR OFFICE ON THIS BILL --
02:57:05.047 --> 02:57:06.415
EXISTING LAW PROHIBITS A STATE
02:57:06.482 --> 02:57:08.150
OR LOCAL LAW ENFORCEMENT AGENCY
02:57:08.217 --> 02:57:09.885
INCLUDING SCHOOL POLICE AND
02:57:09.952 --> 02:57:11.287
SECURITY DEPARTMENTS FROM USING
02:57:11.354 --> 02:57:12.989
MONEY OR PERSON PERSONNEL TO
02:57:13.055 --> 02:57:15.424
INVESTIGATE INTERROGATE DETAIN
02:57:15.491 --> 02:57:17.693
DETECT OR ARREST PERSONS. FOR
02:57:17.760 --> 02:57:19.128
IMMIGRATION ENFORCEMENT PURPOSES.
02:57:19.195 --> 02:57:20.763
SB FIFTY FOUR REQUIRED THE
02:57:20.830 --> 02:57:22.264
ATTORNEY GENERAL TO ESTABLISH
02:57:22.331 --> 02:57:23.299
MODEL POLICIES LIMITING
02:57:23.366 --> 02:57:24.667
ASSISTANCE WITH IMMIGRATION
02:57:24.734 --> 02:57:28.104
ENFORCEMENT TO THE FULLEST
02:57:28.170 --> 02:57:29.472
EXTENT POSSIBLE.
02:57:29.538 --> 02:57:30.439
WE HAVE HAD ORGANIZATIONS WE
02:57:30.506 --> 02:57:32.074
REACH OUT TO US AND INFORM US
02:57:32.141 --> 02:57:33.342
THAT THEY HAVE SEEN A DECLINE IN
02:57:33.409 --> 02:57:35.211
UNDOCUMENTED IMMIGRANTS SEEKING
02:57:35.277 --> 02:57:37.546
SERVICES FOR DOMESTIC AND SEXUAL
02:57:37.613 --> 02:57:39.648
VIOLENCE SINCE.
02:57:39.715 --> 02:57:40.216
TWENTY SIXTEEN THIS BILL IS
02:57:40.282 --> 02:57:41.884
IMPORTANT TO ME BECAUSE I WAS
02:57:41.951 --> 02:57:43.853
UNDOCUMENTED ARE WITHIN
02:57:43.919 --> 02:57:45.187
UNDOCUMENTED IMMIGRANTS AND I
02:57:45.254 --> 02:57:46.155
HAVE AN IMMEDIATE FAMILY MEMBER
02:57:46.222 --> 02:57:48.024
WHO IS A SURVIVOR OF DOMESTIC
02:57:48.090 --> 02:57:49.358
VIOLENCE.
02:57:49.425 --> 02:57:51.260
I KNOW FIRST HAND THE FEARS THE
02:57:51.327 --> 02:57:53.162
STRESS THE CONFUSION OF TRYING
02:57:53.229 --> 02:57:54.363
TO SURVIVE MOMENT BY MOMENT
02:57:54.430 --> 02:57:56.832
KNOWING YOU CAN BE TORN FROM
02:57:56.899 --> 02:57:57.466
YOUR FAMILY AND DEPORTED AT ANY
02:57:57.533 --> 02:57:58.401
TIME.
02:57:58.467 --> 02:58:00.636
THIS FEAR IS REAL AND IT'S
02:58:00.703 --> 02:58:01.737
SOMETHING I WILL NEVER FORGET.
02:58:01.804 --> 02:58:02.872
I KNOW THE PAIN OF MY FATHER
02:58:02.938 --> 02:58:04.740
BEING ASKED FOR HIS DOCUMENTS
02:58:04.807 --> 02:58:06.275
AND BEING UNABLE TO PROVIDE THEM.
02:58:06.342 --> 02:58:08.210
I KNOW THE VISION MY PARENTS HAD
02:58:08.277 --> 02:58:09.311
FOR US A VISION THAT IS FOR
02:58:09.378 --> 02:58:11.981
FAILED AS BOTH ME AND MY SISTER.
02:58:12.048 --> 02:58:13.616
ARE NOW SERVING IN THE STATE
02:58:13.682 --> 02:58:14.917
LEGISLATURE.
02:58:14.984 --> 02:58:16.318
I HAVE SEEN FIRSTHAND THE PAIN
02:58:16.385 --> 02:58:19.822
OF MY FAMILY MEMBER -- WHILE SHE
02:58:19.889 --> 02:58:21.090
WAS GOING THROUGH -- DOMESTIC
02:58:21.157 --> 02:58:22.792
VIOLENCE.
02:58:22.858 --> 02:58:25.161
I UNDERSTAND HOW DIFFICULT IT IS
02:58:25.227 --> 02:58:26.429
TO ASK FOR HELP WITH PROPER
02:58:26.495 --> 02:58:27.730
DOCUMENTATION.
02:58:27.797 --> 02:58:29.465
MOST UNDOCUMENTED SURVIVORS ARE
02:58:29.532 --> 02:58:30.933
TOO AFRAID TO ASK FOR HELP.
02:58:31.000 --> 02:58:32.468
BECAUSE OF THE FEAR OF BEING
02:58:32.535 --> 02:58:34.103
RIPPED AWAY FROM THEIR FAMILIES.
02:58:34.170 --> 02:58:35.938
LET ME BE CLEAR ICE CANNOT BE
02:58:36.005 --> 02:58:37.506
PERMANENTLY STOPPED FROM
02:58:37.573 --> 02:58:40.376
ENTERING THESE LOCATIONS HOWEVER.
02:58:40.443 --> 02:58:42.044
AB TEN SEVENTY THREE WILL HELP
02:58:42.111 --> 02:58:43.112
REMEDY THESE FEARS BY WORKING
02:58:43.179 --> 02:58:45.047
WITH THE ICE ON HELPING PROTECT
02:58:45.114 --> 02:58:48.284
THE SURVIVORS IN THESE LOCATIONS.
02:58:48.350 --> 02:58:52.388
THANK YOU AND I DON'T HAVE ANY
02:58:52.455 --> 02:58:53.689
WITNESSES I JUST.
02:58:53.756 --> 02:58:55.124
WANT TO REALLY APPRECIATE THE
02:58:55.191 --> 02:58:56.525
THE COMMITTEE FOR WORKING WITH
02:58:56.592 --> 02:58:58.260
US TO WORK THROUGH THESE --
02:58:58.327 --> 02:59:01.697
THROUGH THE ISSUES THAT WE HAD --
02:59:01.764 --> 02:59:03.866
WITH THIS BILL AND I
02:59:03.933 --> 02:59:06.435
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE.
02:59:06.502 --> 02:59:07.036
THANK YOU WOULD ANYONE LIKE TO
02:59:07.103 --> 02:59:08.437
SPEAK IN SUPPORT.
02:59:08.504 --> 02:59:11.040
THE MORNING ASTRONOMERS TWENTY
02:59:11.107 --> 02:59:12.575
SUMMERS AGO.
02:59:12.641 --> 02:59:13.542
ALBERTA TO COME OUT OF THE
02:59:13.609 --> 02:59:14.243
CALIFORNIA AB CAN ATTORNEYS
02:59:14.310 --> 02:59:16.712
ASSOCIATION IN STRONG SUPPORT OF
02:59:16.779 --> 02:59:17.012
THE MEASURE.
02:59:17.079 --> 02:59:18.781
THANK YOU.
02:59:18.848 --> 02:59:19.949
CHRIS RESPONSES WHICH IRELAND
02:59:20.015 --> 02:59:21.083
STRONG SUPPORT WE JUST FORMER
02:59:21.150 --> 02:59:22.284
POSITION LAST WEEK.
02:59:22.351 --> 02:59:24.954
THANK YOU ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT.
02:59:25.020 --> 02:59:28.124
SEEING NONE IS THERE OPPOSITION.
02:59:28.190 --> 02:59:29.658
SEEING NONE BRING IT BACK TO THE
02:59:29.725 --> 02:59:31.360
COMMITTEE FOR QUESTIONS OR
02:59:31.427 --> 02:59:32.728
COMMENTS.
02:59:32.795 --> 02:59:34.530
THANK YOU WE DO HAVE A MOTION
02:59:34.597 --> 02:59:39.001
AND A SECOND.
02:59:39.068 --> 02:59:40.402
RIGHT THIS RUBIO EVEN
02:59:40.469 --> 02:59:41.370
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR VOTE
02:59:41.437 --> 02:59:42.872
THANK YOU WE DO THE MOTION IS TO
02:59:42.938 --> 02:59:44.540
PASS TO APPROPRIATIONS KALRA
02:59:44.607 --> 02:59:46.075
PLEASE STONE BY STONE AYE
02:59:46.142 --> 02:59:48.277
GALLAGHER CHAU CHIU.
02:59:48.344 --> 02:59:51.747
GONZALEZ GONZALEZ I HOLDEN.
02:59:51.814 --> 02:59:53.015
HOLDEN AYE KALRA.
02:59:53.082 --> 02:59:56.085
KALRA AYE KILEY MAIENSCHEIN
02:59:56.152 --> 02:59:57.419
OBERNOLTE.
02:59:57.486 --> 03:00:03.159
PETRIE-NORRIS PETRIE-NORRIS IRIS.
03:00:03.225 --> 03:00:05.594
THERE NEEDS TO MORE ABOUT IT IS
03:00:05.661 --> 03:00:05.961
THE DOG COLLAR.
03:00:06.028 --> 03:00:06.595
THANK YOU.
03:00:06.662 --> 03:00:08.364
AND YOU ALSO HAVE ITEM NUMBER
03:00:08.430 --> 03:00:09.999
FIFTEEN A. B..
03:00:10.065 --> 03:00:10.566
FOURTEEN SEVENTEEN THANK YOU
03:00:10.633 --> 03:00:10.900
MISTER CHAIR.
03:00:10.966 --> 03:00:11.500
THANK YOU FOR ALLOWING ME TO
03:00:11.567 --> 03:00:13.269
PRESENT AB FOURTEEN SEVENTEEN AN
03:00:13.335 --> 03:00:15.137
ACT RELATING TO THE ADVERTISING
03:00:15.204 --> 03:00:16.172
OF AND LICENSE CANNABIS
03:00:16.238 --> 03:00:17.006
BUSINESSES.
03:00:17.072 --> 03:00:19.041
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR AND YOUR
03:00:19.108 --> 03:00:19.675
STAFF FOR HELPING US WITH THAT
03:00:19.742 --> 03:00:20.709
AUTHOR PROPOSED AMENDMENTS
03:00:20.776 --> 03:00:23.579
DESCRIBED IN THE ANALYSIS AND
03:00:23.646 --> 03:00:24.613
HELPING US STRENGTH AND THE BILL.
03:00:24.680 --> 03:00:25.514
AS YOU KNOW THE STATE OF
03:00:25.581 --> 03:00:26.649
CALIFORNIA STARTED ISSUING STATE
03:00:26.715 --> 03:00:28.951
LICENSES AT THE BEGINNING OF THE
03:00:29.018 --> 03:00:30.819
OF LAST YEAR FOR CANNABIS
03:00:30.886 --> 03:00:31.420
BUSINESSES TO OPERATE IN THE
03:00:31.487 --> 03:00:32.454
STATE.
03:00:32.521 --> 03:00:33.722
DESPITE SOME SUCCESS DURING THE
03:00:33.789 --> 03:00:35.124
FIRST YEAR OF LEGAL SALES THE
03:00:35.191 --> 03:00:36.725
BLACK MARKET HAS CONTINUED TO
03:00:36.792 --> 03:00:38.093
FLOURISH DRIVING DOWN LEGAL
03:00:38.160 --> 03:00:39.094
SALES.
03:00:39.161 --> 03:00:40.529
ACCORDING TO A RECENT REPORT BY
03:00:40.596 --> 03:00:42.464
THE CANNABIS ADVISORY COMMITTEE
03:00:42.531 --> 03:00:44.500
LACK OF ENFORCEMENT IS CREATING
03:00:44.567 --> 03:00:45.701
A THRIVING ENVIRONMENT FOR THE
03:00:45.768 --> 03:00:48.304
UNREGULATED UNDERGROUND MARKET.
03:00:48.370 --> 03:00:49.471
IN ADDITION TO DWINDLING TAX
03:00:49.538 --> 03:00:51.473
REVENUES THE UNDERGROUND MARKET
03:00:51.540 --> 03:00:52.875
PRESENT SERIOUS PUBLIC SAFETY
03:00:52.942 --> 03:00:54.543
AND PUBLIC HEALTH THREATS TO OUR
03:00:54.610 --> 03:00:55.544
COMMUNITIES.
03:00:55.611 --> 03:00:56.612
IN ADDITION THE CANNABIS
03:00:56.679 --> 03:00:58.547
PRODUCTS SOLD AT THESE LOCATIONS
03:00:58.614 --> 03:01:00.849
DOES NOT MEET ESTABLISHED
03:01:00.916 --> 03:01:03.719
QUALITY STANDARDS AND EVADES
03:01:03.786 --> 03:01:05.854
STATE TESTING.
03:01:05.921 --> 03:01:06.689
COME COMBATING THE UNDERGROUND
03:01:06.755 --> 03:01:07.523
MARKET IS A KEY POLICY GOAL FOR
03:01:07.590 --> 03:01:08.624
THE LEGISLATURE THIS YEAR.
03:01:08.691 --> 03:01:09.725
THIS BILL WOULD TARGET THE BLACK
03:01:09.792 --> 03:01:10.826
MARKET BY CRACKING DOWN ON A
03:01:10.893 --> 03:01:13.229
SPECIFIC PROBLEM THE ADVERTISING
03:01:13.295 --> 03:01:15.698
OF ILLEGAL OPERATIONS FOR PROFIT.
03:01:15.764 --> 03:01:18.067
AB FOURTEEN SEVENTEEN WILL
03:01:18.133 --> 03:01:19.034
CREATE CIVIL PROBLEM NO
03:01:19.101 --> 03:01:20.169
PENALTIES FOR ENTITIES WOULD
03:01:20.236 --> 03:01:21.670
DECIDE TO ADVERTISE THE LEGAL
03:01:21.737 --> 03:01:22.972
OPERATIONS IN EXCHANGE FOR
03:01:23.038 --> 03:01:23.839
PROFIT.
03:01:23.906 --> 03:01:25.841
AS THE LEGISLATURE WE CANNOT SAY
03:01:25.908 --> 03:01:26.742
THAT WE ARE TAKING THE CANNABIS
03:01:26.809 --> 03:01:28.477
BLACK MARKET SERIOUSLY IF WE
03:01:28.544 --> 03:01:30.012
ALLOW THE UNREGULATED.
03:01:30.079 --> 03:01:31.280
PROMOTION AND ADVERTISEMENT OF
03:01:31.347 --> 03:01:32.815
ILLEGAL BUSINESSES TO EXIST
03:01:32.881 --> 03:01:34.350
WITHOUT CONSEQUENCE.
03:01:34.416 --> 03:01:35.184
WE KNOW THAT THESE
03:01:35.251 --> 03:01:36.352
ADVERTISEMENTS DRIVE BUSINESS
03:01:36.418 --> 03:01:37.753
TOWARDS ILLEGAL OPERATORS AND
03:01:37.820 --> 03:01:39.421
MUST FIND A WAY TO RESTRICT THIS
03:01:39.488 --> 03:01:40.356
PRACTICE.
03:01:40.422 --> 03:01:41.490
THANK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO
03:01:41.557 --> 03:01:42.992
PRESENT TODAY AND I WILL NOW
03:01:43.058 --> 03:01:44.860
TURN THE MIKE OVER TO OUR
03:01:44.927 --> 03:01:45.995
SPONSORS AND SUPPORTERS THANK
03:01:46.061 --> 03:01:47.596
YOU WE DO HAVE THE MOST IN A
03:01:47.663 --> 03:01:49.365
SECOND AND YOU MENTIONED THE
03:01:49.431 --> 03:01:50.432
MEMBERS WHO ARE TAKING THOSE IS
03:01:50.499 --> 03:01:51.934
OFTEN YES.
03:01:52.001 --> 03:01:53.435
JUST TO BE CLEAR THANK YOU MARIN --
03:01:53.502 --> 03:01:54.570
CALIFORNIA ADVOCACY ON BEHALF OF
03:01:54.637 --> 03:01:55.638
THE THAT KIND OF HIS BUSINESS
03:01:55.704 --> 03:02:00.109
ASSOCIATION HERE -- WHAT JERRY
03:02:00.175 --> 03:02:02.778
KILEY -- THANK YOU VERY TIME AND
03:02:02.845 --> 03:02:04.313
CHAIR KYLE ON THE PRESIDENT OF
03:02:04.380 --> 03:02:04.847
THE UNITED CAMAS BUSINESS
03:02:04.913 --> 03:02:05.948
ASSOCIATION -- AB FOURTEEN
03:02:06.015 --> 03:02:06.482
SEVENTEEN IS NOT A BILL TO
03:02:06.548 --> 03:02:06.982
RESTRICT ADVERTISING AND
03:02:07.049 --> 03:02:08.584
TECHNOLOGY OF LEGAL BUSINESSES
03:02:08.651 --> 03:02:09.618
THIS BILL THAN EFFORT TO HOLD A
03:02:09.685 --> 03:02:10.953
SMALL NUMBER OF TECHNOLOGY
03:02:11.020 --> 03:02:11.787
PLATFORMS.
03:02:11.854 --> 03:02:13.322
ACCOUNTABLE FOR THEIR DELIBERATE
03:02:13.389 --> 03:02:14.590
IGNORANCE THE CLIENT THEY
03:02:14.657 --> 03:02:16.659
FACILITATE PROFIT FACILITATE
03:02:16.725 --> 03:02:18.294
FAIL FOR AND PROFITS OFF THOUGH
03:02:18.360 --> 03:02:19.795
THE LEGAL FAILED CAMPUS LAWS OR
03:02:19.862 --> 03:02:22.064
STATE REGULATED SO ADVERTISING
03:02:22.131 --> 03:02:23.299
SHOULD BE AS WELL.
03:02:23.365 --> 03:02:24.733
IN THE CITY OF LOS ANGELES THERE
03:02:24.800 --> 03:02:26.802
ARE OVER TWO THOUSAND ADVERTISED
03:02:26.869 --> 03:02:28.737
RETAIL LOCATIONS ON TECHNOLOGY
03:02:28.804 --> 03:02:31.507
PLATFORMS A HUNDRED AND EIGHTY
03:02:31.573 --> 03:02:32.675
ONE OF THOSE LOCATIONS ARE LEGAL
03:02:32.741 --> 03:02:34.276
OVERWHELMINGLY THE CONSUMERS ARE
03:02:34.343 --> 03:02:35.177
CONFUSED WITH DECEPTIVE
03:02:35.244 --> 03:02:36.912
ADVERTISEMENT THAT ARE DESIGNED
03:02:36.979 --> 03:02:37.513
TO STRIP AWAY.
03:02:37.579 --> 03:02:39.548
THE MARKERS THAT DIFFERENTIATE A
03:02:39.615 --> 03:02:41.050
LEGAL AND ILLEGAL CANNABIS
03:02:41.116 --> 03:02:42.584
BUSINESS IT IS TIME FOR THIS
03:02:42.651 --> 03:02:44.153
DELIBERATE IGNORANCE OF WHO YOUR
03:02:44.219 --> 03:02:46.322
ADVERTISING FOR IS THE REASON
03:02:46.388 --> 03:02:47.923
WHY WE ARE HAVING THIS BILL.
03:02:47.990 --> 03:02:49.358
THESE TECHNOLOGY PLATFORMS HAVE
03:02:49.425 --> 03:02:50.759
MANY INSTRUCTIONAL VIDEOS
03:02:50.826 --> 03:02:52.328
EDUCATING THE CONSUMER ON SO
03:02:52.394 --> 03:02:53.829
MANY DIFFERENT ASPECTS OF
03:02:53.896 --> 03:02:55.464
CANNABIS FROM BROAD DESCRIPTIONS
03:02:55.531 --> 03:02:56.298
OF WHAT CANNABIS IS IN THE
03:02:56.365 --> 03:02:57.333
HISTORY.
03:02:57.399 --> 03:02:58.734
OF IT AND THE NEW WANTS NATURE
03:02:58.801 --> 03:02:59.635
OF CANADA NOISE THEIR
03:02:59.702 --> 03:03:01.537
PHYSIOLOGICAL FAX NO WHERE IN
03:03:01.603 --> 03:03:03.572
THIS VAST LIBRARY OF EDUCATIONAL
03:03:03.639 --> 03:03:05.674
VIDEOS IS ONE ON HOW TO FIND A
03:03:05.741 --> 03:03:07.276
LEGAL BUSINESS OR LEGAL
03:03:07.343 --> 03:03:09.044
DISPENSARY OR WHAT PUBLIC SAFETY
03:03:09.111 --> 03:03:10.112
ISSUES THERE ARE.
03:03:10.179 --> 03:03:11.313
IF YOU SHOP IN ANY LEGAL
03:03:11.380 --> 03:03:12.815
FACILITY.
03:03:12.881 --> 03:03:14.016
THESE CANNABIS CENTRIC PLATFORMS
03:03:14.083 --> 03:03:15.384
HAVE DUG DEEP AND PROVIDE
03:03:15.451 --> 03:03:17.419
EDUCATION ON EMERGING INDUSTRY
03:03:17.486 --> 03:03:18.987
AND LEFT OUT HOW TO SUPPORT ITS
03:03:19.054 --> 03:03:20.723
LEGAL GROWTH WE'D MAPS IS THIS
03:03:20.789 --> 03:03:22.091
VIOLATOR THAT WOULD RATHER
03:03:22.157 --> 03:03:23.759
SUPPORT THE ILLICIT MARKET.
03:03:23.826 --> 03:03:24.693
THAN TO PROFIT OFF THE ILLEGAL
03:03:24.760 --> 03:03:26.428
SALE OF THAT SUPPORT THE TAX
03:03:26.495 --> 03:03:27.629
PAYING ENTITIES TO KEEP THE
03:03:27.696 --> 03:03:28.997
GROWTH THIS INDUSTRY SAFE
03:03:29.064 --> 03:03:30.632
CONTROLLED AND REGULATED.
03:03:30.699 --> 03:03:31.900
THE GOOD PART OF THE STORY IS
03:03:31.967 --> 03:03:33.969
THAT THERE ARE GOOD ACTORS THE
03:03:34.036 --> 03:03:35.137
CAMPUS ADVERTISING WORLD.
03:03:35.204 --> 03:03:36.939
BUT I FOUND THE MORAL COMPASS
03:03:37.005 --> 03:03:38.807
AND EVER AND HAVE REMOVED AND
03:03:38.874 --> 03:03:41.477
RESTRICTED ADVERTISING. TO JUST
03:03:41.543 --> 03:03:42.444
LEGAL CANNABIS BUSINESSES ONLY
03:03:42.511 --> 03:03:43.979
LEAVE FULLY THE MOST VISITED
03:03:44.046 --> 03:03:46.849
CANNABIS WEBSITE IN THE WORLD --
03:03:46.915 --> 03:03:48.150
HAS REMOVED ALL I'M LICENSE CAN
03:03:48.217 --> 03:03:50.586
WITH BUSINESSES IN MARCH OF
03:03:50.652 --> 03:03:51.387
TWENTY EIGHTEEN AND CONTINUES TO
03:03:51.453 --> 03:03:53.155
RESTRICT ANY ADVERTISEMENTS FROM
03:03:53.222 --> 03:03:54.923
ILLEGAL BUSINESS AT LEAST FULLY
03:03:54.990 --> 03:03:56.525
MADE A CONSCIOUS EFFORT TO
03:03:56.592 --> 03:04:01.263
FOLLOW STATE LAW.
03:04:01.330 --> 03:04:03.031
IN THAT WE ALLOW PLATFORMS LIKE
03:04:03.098 --> 03:04:04.500
WE'D MATH TO CONTINUE TO PROFIT
03:04:04.566 --> 03:04:05.134
AND BOLDLY LEGAL OPERATIONS SO
03:04:05.200 --> 03:04:05.667
WITH LOOKING.
03:04:05.734 --> 03:04:06.235
THE OTHER WAY WHILE ILLEGAL
03:04:06.301 --> 03:04:06.869
BUSINESS TO SATURATE THE MARKET
03:04:06.935 --> 03:04:08.137
MORE TECHNOLOGY PLATFORMS ARE
03:04:08.203 --> 03:04:09.304
FOLLOWING THE PROFITABLE
03:04:09.371 --> 03:04:10.873
BUSINESS MODEL OF SUPPORTING
03:04:10.939 --> 03:04:12.074
ILLEGAL BUSINESSES.
03:04:12.141 --> 03:04:13.275
AND THE SLIPPERY SLOPE OF MAKING
03:04:13.342 --> 03:04:14.977
ENFORCEMENT AND TAX COLLECTION
03:04:15.043 --> 03:04:16.345
NEAR IMPOSSIBLE OR JUST TO
03:04:16.412 --> 03:04:18.447
INSPECT IT TO JUST TOO EXPENSIVE
03:04:18.514 --> 03:04:19.948
FOR LOCAL MUNICIPALITIES.
03:04:20.015 --> 03:04:20.849
THIS BILL OF AN EFFORT TO
03:04:20.916 --> 03:04:22.518
DECENTRALIZE THE ENFORCEMENT OF
03:04:22.584 --> 03:04:23.786
WHAT IS AN EXPENSIVE AND
03:04:23.852 --> 03:04:25.254
DAUNTING TASK FOR LOCAL LAW
03:04:25.320 --> 03:04:27.189
ENFORCEMENT TO HOLD ENABLERS OF
03:04:27.256 --> 03:04:28.090
THE LEGAL BUSINESSES.
03:04:28.157 --> 03:04:29.525
ACCOUNTABLE THEIR BILLBOARDS
03:04:29.591 --> 03:04:31.393
MAGAZINES INTERNET ADS FLYERS
03:04:31.460 --> 03:04:33.729
MOBILE APPS AND OTHER PLATFORMS
03:04:33.796 --> 03:04:34.797
TO MONITOR AND THE MOST
03:04:34.863 --> 03:04:36.398
EFFECTIVE AND COST EFFECTIVE WAY
03:04:36.465 --> 03:04:37.599
OF DOING THIS IS TO EDUCATE THE
03:04:37.666 --> 03:04:39.668
PUBLIC AND INCENTIVIZE THEIR
03:04:39.735 --> 03:04:41.770
MONITORING -- FOR INAPPROPRIATE
03:04:41.837 --> 03:04:43.672
CONTENT WE'VE RESTRICTED THIS
03:04:43.739 --> 03:04:44.973
KIND OF ADVERTISING OF ILLEGAL
03:04:45.040 --> 03:04:46.942
ACTIVITY BEFORE AND THE OWNERS A
03:04:47.009 --> 03:04:48.410
BACK PAGE DOT COM HAVE SERVE
03:04:48.477 --> 03:04:50.379
JAIL TIME FOR THEIR AIDING AND
03:04:50.446 --> 03:04:51.914
ABETTING OF ILLEGAL ACTIVITY.
03:04:51.980 --> 03:04:54.383
SO THIS IS NOT A PRECEDENT
03:04:54.450 --> 03:04:56.385
SETTING BILL.
03:04:56.452 --> 03:04:59.488
LAS VEGAS THAT WE'D MAP THE
03:04:59.555 --> 03:05:00.088
SYSTEM THE FIFTH AND THE FIFTH
03:05:00.155 --> 03:05:01.824
LETTER -- FROM THE TURNING
03:05:01.890 --> 03:05:02.758
DEPARTMENT TO WRAP UP PLEASE THE
03:05:02.825 --> 03:05:03.792
PROBLEM -- AND THEY'VE BEEN HELD
03:05:03.859 --> 03:05:04.493
ACCOUNTABLE MANY OTHER STATES OF
03:05:04.560 --> 03:05:05.761
HELD TECHNOLOGY PLATFORMS
03:05:05.828 --> 03:05:07.463
ACCOUNTABLE AND THEY HAVE ALL
03:05:07.529 --> 03:05:09.131
COMPLIED I WOULD LIKE THE STATE
03:05:09.198 --> 03:05:10.666
OF CALIFORNIA THE WHOLE THESE
03:05:10.732 --> 03:05:12.868
TECHNOLOGY PLATFORMS ACCOUNTABLE
03:05:12.935 --> 03:05:14.369
AND GUIDE THE MARKET. TO A SAFE
03:05:14.436 --> 03:05:15.370
AN ACQUITTAL POSITION FOR THE
03:05:15.437 --> 03:05:16.872
REST OF THE WORLD TO EMULATE
03:05:16.939 --> 03:05:18.774
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
03:05:18.841 --> 03:05:20.976
THANK YOU ACCESS PLEASE IT'S
03:05:21.043 --> 03:05:22.211
CHAMBER MEMBERS COMMITTEE
03:05:22.277 --> 03:05:23.378
ALBERTO TO RECALL ON BEHALF THE
03:05:23.445 --> 03:05:24.813
UNITED FOOD AND COMMERCIAL
03:05:24.880 --> 03:05:26.748
WORKERS WESTERN STATES COUNSEL.
03:05:26.815 --> 03:05:27.349
YOU FEW DOUBLES BEEN INVOLVED
03:05:27.416 --> 03:05:28.717
WITH THE WITH THE CANNABIS
03:05:28.784 --> 03:05:30.185
INDUSTRY FROM THE OUTSET THE
03:05:30.252 --> 03:05:30.652
STATE WIDE INITIATIVES
03:05:30.719 --> 03:05:31.186
LEGISLATION.
03:05:31.253 --> 03:05:32.421
REGULATIONS.
03:05:32.488 --> 03:05:33.655
OUR PRINCIPAL OBJECTIVE IS TO
03:05:33.722 --> 03:05:34.323
RAISE THE SENATE LIVING IN THIS
03:05:34.389 --> 03:05:37.025
INDUSTRY ONE OF THE FACTORS THAT
03:05:37.092 --> 03:05:37.626
IS SEVERELY UNDERCUTTING OUR
03:05:37.693 --> 03:05:38.393
EFFORTS.
03:05:38.460 --> 03:05:44.733
IS THE ILLICIT MARKET PLACE THIS
03:05:44.800 --> 03:05:47.336
BILL CUTS INTO THAT.
03:05:47.402 --> 03:05:48.971
THE PUBLIC PARTNERSHIP AND GIVES
03:05:49.037 --> 03:05:49.538
ANOTHER TOOL FOR ENFORCEMENT
03:05:49.605 --> 03:05:50.906
WHICH IS A VERY LIKE IN THE
03:05:50.973 --> 03:05:52.508
STATE LOCAL LEVEL.
03:05:52.574 --> 03:05:53.108
RESPECT ASTRONOMICAL THANK YOU
03:05:53.175 --> 03:05:54.276
THANK YOU WOULD ANYONE ELSE LIKE
03:05:54.343 --> 03:05:56.011
TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT. TO COME
03:05:56.078 --> 03:05:57.145
FORWARD GIVE US YOUR NAME AND
03:05:57.212 --> 03:05:59.915
YOUR AFFILIATION PLEASE.
03:05:59.982 --> 03:06:00.482
JIM CRAIG ON BEHALF OF THE
03:06:00.549 --> 03:06:02.818
BUILDINGS IN SUPPORT.
03:06:02.885 --> 03:06:04.820
DANIEL SHARP CENTRAL AMERICAN
03:06:04.887 --> 03:06:05.454
RESOURCE CENTER OF CALIFORNIA IN
03:06:05.521 --> 03:06:08.156
SUPPORT.
03:06:08.223 --> 03:06:09.491
JOHN AKITA DIRECTOR OF THE LA
03:06:09.558 --> 03:06:10.459
COUNTY DEPARTMENT CONSUMER
03:06:10.526 --> 03:06:11.894
BUSINESS AFFAIRS ON BEHALF OF LA
03:06:11.960 --> 03:06:13.495
COUNTY.
03:06:13.562 --> 03:06:17.466
IN SUPPORT AS OF LAST WEEK.
03:06:17.533 --> 03:06:19.334
CHRIS RESPONSIBLE CHIRLA AND
03:06:19.401 --> 03:06:19.835
SUPPORT WE JUST FROM THE
03:06:19.902 --> 03:06:21.603
POSITION LAST WEEK.
03:06:21.670 --> 03:06:24.139
THANK YOU ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT.
03:06:24.206 --> 03:06:29.745
SEEING NONE IS THERE OPPOSITION.
03:06:29.811 --> 03:06:30.679
STRUCTURE MEMBERS OF THE
03:06:30.746 --> 03:06:32.047
COMMITTEE JIM HE WORKED WITH
03:06:32.114 --> 03:06:32.748
CALIFORNIA NEWS PUBLISHERS
03:06:32.814 --> 03:06:34.449
ASSOCIATION WE WANT TO THANK THE
03:06:34.516 --> 03:06:36.385
AUTHOR AND YOUR STAFF FOR
03:06:36.451 --> 03:06:37.052
WORKING WITH US ON THE
03:06:37.119 --> 03:06:38.654
AMENDMENTS. TO ADDRESS THE
03:06:38.720 --> 03:06:41.390
CONCERNS THAT WE RAISED AND OF
03:06:41.456 --> 03:06:42.691
WHAT YOU KNOW THE WERE NEUTRAL
03:06:42.758 --> 03:06:43.525
IN THE BILL NOW THANK YOU.
03:06:43.592 --> 03:06:44.760
RIGHT THANK YOU ANYONE ELSE IN
03:06:44.826 --> 03:06:47.796
OPPOSITION NEUTRAL OTHERWISE.
03:06:47.863 --> 03:06:49.097
ALRIGHT SING NONE OF BRING IT
03:06:49.164 --> 03:06:50.132
BACK TO THE COMMITTEE
03:06:50.198 --> 03:06:50.432
[inaudible]
03:06:50.499 --> 03:06:54.069
QUESTIONS COMMENTS.
03:06:54.136 --> 03:06:58.507
SIGNUP THIS REVIEW YOU MAY CLOSE
03:06:58.574 --> 03:06:59.441
YOU HAVE A MOTION AND A SECOND
03:06:59.508 --> 03:07:01.076
THE MOTION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED
03:07:01.143 --> 03:07:02.411
TO APPROPRIATIONS CALL THE ROLL
03:07:02.477 --> 03:07:03.779
PLEASE STONE BY STONE AYE
03:07:03.845 --> 03:07:05.781
GALLAGHER CHAU.
03:07:05.847 --> 03:07:07.883
CHIU GONZALEZ.
03:07:07.950 --> 03:07:09.518
GONZALEZ I HOLDEN.
03:07:09.585 --> 03:07:10.986
HOLDEN AYE KALRA.
03:07:11.053 --> 03:07:13.355
KALRA AYE KILEY MAIENSCHEIN
03:07:13.422 --> 03:07:18.961
OBERNOLTE PETRIE-NORRIS REYES.
03:07:19.027 --> 03:07:20.095
THE BILL NEEDS THREE MORE SO
03:07:20.162 --> 03:07:21.863
PROTOCOL THANK YOU THANK YOU
03:07:21.930 --> 03:07:22.164
[inaudible]
03:07:22.230 --> 03:07:28.804
RIGHT.
03:07:28.870 --> 03:07:29.371
RIGHT MR COLOR ARE YOU READY
03:07:29.438 --> 03:07:30.105
PERCENT.
03:07:30.172 --> 03:07:33.275
SO WE'LL START WITH.
03:07:33.342 --> 03:07:34.876
AB FOUR OH THREE YOU HAVE TO
03:07:34.943 --> 03:07:36.878
BILLS GIVE A PREFERENCE.
03:07:36.945 --> 03:07:38.046
RIGHT WILL START WITH A BEFORE --
03:07:38.113 --> 03:07:44.987
THREE THEN.
03:07:45.053 --> 03:07:46.388
WE DO HAVE A MOTION IS THERE
03:07:46.455 --> 03:07:48.657
SECONDS.
03:07:48.724 --> 03:08:00.869
AND A SECOND THANK YOU.
03:08:00.936 --> 03:08:01.970
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMEMBERS
03:08:02.037 --> 03:08:04.039
AB FOUR OH THREE INCREASES THE
03:08:04.106 --> 03:08:05.340
STATURE LIMITATIONS FOR FILING A
03:08:05.407 --> 03:08:07.209
WORKER RETALIATION CLAIM FROM
03:08:07.275 --> 03:08:09.044
SIX MONTHS. TO THREE YEARS AND
03:08:09.111 --> 03:08:10.145
HAS THE ABILITY TO SEEK
03:08:10.212 --> 03:08:11.480
ATTORNEY'S FEES FOR FAILING.
03:08:11.546 --> 03:08:13.582
EMPLOYEES WORKPLACE RETALIATION
03:08:13.649 --> 03:08:15.517
OCCURS AND EMPLOYERS JUST CHARGE
03:08:15.584 --> 03:08:17.185
THREATEN WITH DOES CHARGE DEMOTE
03:08:17.252 --> 03:08:19.287
SUSPEND OR SUBJECT EMPLOYEES TO
03:08:19.354 --> 03:08:21.590
AN ADVERSE ACTION FOR EXERCISING
03:08:21.657 --> 03:08:22.157
THEIR RIGHTS UNDER THE LABOR
03:08:22.224 --> 03:08:23.158
CODE.
03:08:23.225 --> 03:08:24.660
POINTS RETALIATION CAN RANGE
03:08:24.726 --> 03:08:25.127
FROM SUBTLE WORKPLACE
03:08:25.193 --> 03:08:27.763
INTIMIDATION TO OUTRIGHT THREATS
03:08:27.829 --> 03:08:28.897
SUCH AS THREATENING DEPORTATION.
03:08:28.964 --> 03:08:30.632
IT IS TWO THOUSAND SEVENTEEN
03:08:30.699 --> 03:08:31.967
RETALIATION COMPLAINT REPORT THE
03:08:32.034 --> 03:08:33.035
LABOR COMMISSION REPORT
03:08:33.101 --> 03:08:34.603
ACCEPTING OVER TWENTY FIVE
03:08:34.670 --> 03:08:35.570
HUNDRED CASES PER INVESTIGATION
03:08:35.637 --> 03:08:37.906
RESULTING IN OVER. FIFTY TWO
03:08:37.973 --> 03:08:40.142
HUNDRED VIOLATIONS ALLEGED.
03:08:40.208 --> 03:08:41.843
ACCEPTED COMPLAINTS MAY ALLEGE
03:08:41.910 --> 03:08:42.944
MULTIPLE VIOLATIONS.
03:08:43.011 --> 03:08:45.013
ROUGHLY HALF OF THE COMPLAINTS
03:08:45.080 --> 03:08:46.181
ALLEGED VIOLATIONS LABOR COULD
03:08:46.248 --> 03:08:47.349
LET NO TWO POINT FIVE WHICH
03:08:47.416 --> 03:08:48.817
PROTECTS WHISTLE BLOWERS
03:08:48.884 --> 03:08:51.353
SPECIFICALLY FROM ITALIAN XIN.
03:08:51.420 --> 03:08:52.587
TELL USES ONLY PERVASIVE BUT
03:08:52.654 --> 03:08:54.022
ALSO A GROWING PROBLEM TO THE
03:08:54.089 --> 03:08:55.123
CURRENT POLITICAL CLIMATE
03:08:55.190 --> 03:08:56.391
SURROUNDING IMMIGRATION.
03:08:56.458 --> 03:08:57.592
IMMIGRANT WORKERS ARE OFTEN
03:08:57.659 --> 03:08:58.960
AFRAID TO COME FORWARD WORKPLACE
03:08:59.027 --> 03:09:00.529
RETALIATION CLAIMS FOR A VARIETY
03:09:00.595 --> 03:09:02.798
OF REASONS HOWEVER WHEN THEY DO
03:09:02.864 --> 03:09:03.999
ESPECIALLY GIVEN.
03:09:04.066 --> 03:09:06.068
OR DO OR DO TO LACK OF AWARENESS
03:09:06.134 --> 03:09:07.502
THE SHORT STATURE LIMITATIONS
03:09:07.569 --> 03:09:12.841
THE CLAIM IS NO LONGER ELIGIBLE
03:09:12.908 --> 03:09:14.543
TO BE FILED.
03:09:14.609 --> 03:09:15.711
EVEN IF WILL PLAY HAS A STRONG
03:09:15.777 --> 03:09:17.512
CLAIM OFTENTIMES THE BURDEN OF
03:09:17.579 --> 03:09:18.113
PAYING ATTORNEYS FEES CAN BE A
03:09:18.180 --> 03:09:18.680
DETERRENT.
03:09:18.747 --> 03:09:20.482
A DETERRENT FOR TO GRIEVE WORKER
03:09:20.549 --> 03:09:21.950
ESPECIALLY THOSE WITH LOW WAGE.
03:09:22.017 --> 03:09:22.718
TWO YEARS AGO LEGISLATORS AND
03:09:22.784 --> 03:09:24.352
LEGISLATURE ADOPTED THE GOVERNOR
03:09:24.419 --> 03:09:24.953
SIGNED SB NINETY SIX INTO LAW
03:09:25.020 --> 03:09:25.620
WHICH PROVIDED THE DEPARTMENT OF
03:09:25.687 --> 03:09:26.588
LABOR STANDARDS.
03:09:26.655 --> 03:09:28.023
ENFORCEMENT THE RIGHT TO RESUME
03:09:28.090 --> 03:09:29.191
ATTORNEY'S FEES FROM THE
03:09:29.257 --> 03:09:30.692
EMPLOYER IF THE LABOR COMMISSION
03:09:30.759 --> 03:09:31.827
PREVAILS.
03:09:31.893 --> 03:09:33.695
THIS BILL SIMPLY BUILDS UPON SB
03:09:33.762 --> 03:09:35.097
NINETY SIX PROVIDING THAT SAME
03:09:35.163 --> 03:09:36.364
RIGHT TO PRIVATE CHARITIES.
03:09:36.431 --> 03:09:38.166
TAKE THESE RETALIATION CASES
03:09:38.233 --> 03:09:41.002
OFTEN ON PRO BONO STATUS ON
03:09:41.069 --> 03:09:43.138
BEHALF OF WORKERS.
03:09:43.205 --> 03:09:44.806
AND IT ONLY ENTITLES THE FEES IF
03:09:44.873 --> 03:09:45.640
THE WORK PREVAILS IS REALLY A
03:09:45.707 --> 03:09:46.875
KEY COMPONENT.
03:09:46.942 --> 03:09:47.843
THIS IS NOT A BILL THAT IS
03:09:47.909 --> 03:09:48.977
INTENDED TO INCREASE FRIVOLOUS
03:09:49.044 --> 03:09:50.345
LITIGATION AS THE OPPOSITION
03:09:50.412 --> 03:09:51.913
ARGUES RATHER PROVIDES
03:09:51.980 --> 03:09:53.582
ADDITIONAL SENSIBLE AND REGIONAL
03:09:53.648 --> 03:09:55.517
WASTE WORKERS PURSUE RECOURSE
03:09:55.584 --> 03:09:56.852
WHEN THEY HAVE BEEN UNFAIRLY
03:09:56.918 --> 03:09:58.420
RETALIATE AGAINST FOR INVOKING
03:09:58.487 --> 03:09:59.387
THEIR LEGAL RIGHTS UNDER STATE
03:09:59.454 --> 03:10:02.224
LAW. EIGHTY FOUR OH THREE
03:10:02.290 --> 03:10:03.325
STRENGTHENS LEGAL RIGHTS WHISTLE
03:10:03.391 --> 03:10:04.559
BLOWERS FACE TIE ASIAN AND
03:10:04.626 --> 03:10:05.360
ESPECIALLY HELPS LOWER WAGE
03:10:05.427 --> 03:10:06.728
WORKERS ATTAIN LEGAL
03:10:06.795 --> 03:10:07.863
REPRESENTATION.
03:10:07.929 --> 03:10:09.865
WITH ME TO PROVIDE SUPPORTING
03:10:09.931 --> 03:10:11.900
TESTIMONY IS WITH SOBRE TOLD
03:10:11.967 --> 03:10:13.568
FROM SANTA CLARA COUNTY WAKES UP
03:10:13.635 --> 03:10:16.905
COALITION AND CAITLIN VEGAS THE
03:10:16.972 --> 03:10:19.040
CALIFORNIA LABOR FEDERATION.
03:10:19.107 --> 03:10:20.942
THANK YOU FIRST WITH THIS PLEASE.
03:10:21.009 --> 03:10:22.210
MY NAME IS RUTH SILVER TELL BY
03:10:22.277 --> 03:10:23.879
SUPERVISE THE WORKERS RIGHTS
03:10:23.945 --> 03:10:25.847
CLINIC AT ALEXANDER COMMUNITY
03:10:25.914 --> 03:10:27.415
LAW CENTER AT SANTA CLARA
03:10:27.482 --> 03:10:29.184
UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF LAW.
03:10:29.251 --> 03:10:31.086
AND COORDINATE THE WAIT STAFF
03:10:31.153 --> 03:10:34.022
COALITION.
03:10:34.089 --> 03:10:35.624
OF SORRY OR BRING BACK BUT TO
03:10:35.690 --> 03:10:35.991
YOU.
03:10:36.057 --> 03:10:37.192
THANK GOOD MORNING -- THE
03:10:37.259 --> 03:10:38.627
EXISTING LAW PROVIDES WORKERS
03:10:38.693 --> 03:10:40.695
WITH ONLY SIX MONTHS TO FILE A
03:10:40.762 --> 03:10:42.330
CLAIM AT THE LABOR COMMISSION
03:10:42.397 --> 03:10:43.999
FOR WORKERS WHO ARE RETALIATED
03:10:44.065 --> 03:10:45.333
AGAINST BECAUSE THEY COMPLAIN
03:10:45.400 --> 03:10:47.102
ABOUT A VIOLATION OF THE LABOR
03:10:47.169 --> 03:10:48.837
CODE OR FOR WHISTLE BLOWERS.
03:10:48.904 --> 03:10:51.006
I HAVE SUPERVISED THE CLINIC FOR
03:10:51.072 --> 03:10:52.374
FIFTEEN YEARS AND HAVE SEEN THE
03:10:52.440 --> 03:10:54.709
FULL RANGE OF RETALIATION AND
03:10:54.776 --> 03:10:56.211
WHICH WAS A BLOWER CASES FROM
03:10:56.278 --> 03:10:59.080
TERMINATION TO ACTUAL THREATS TO
03:10:59.147 --> 03:11:01.283
KILL. TO WORKER WHO WAS BEATEN
03:11:01.349 --> 03:11:03.685
UP WHEN HE ASKED FOR HIS WAGES
03:11:03.752 --> 03:11:05.720
SINCE THIS SINCE THE ELECTION OF
03:11:05.787 --> 03:11:07.122
DONALD TRUMP THERE HAS BEEN AN
03:11:07.189 --> 03:11:08.356
UP TICK AND THREATS OF
03:11:08.423 --> 03:11:09.457
RETALIATION.
03:11:09.524 --> 03:11:13.328
FROM SEVEN IN TWO THOUSAND AND
03:11:13.395 --> 03:11:13.862
FIFTEEN NINETY FIVE IN TWO
03:11:13.929 --> 03:11:15.030
THOUSAND AND SEVENTEEN AND I
03:11:15.096 --> 03:11:16.665
RECENTLY TALKED TO A DEPUTY
03:11:16.731 --> 03:11:18.366
LABOR COMMISSIONER IN THE
03:11:18.433 --> 03:11:19.835
RETALIATION UNIT UNIT.
03:11:19.901 --> 03:11:21.570
WHO TOLD ME IT IS EVEN HIGHER
03:11:21.636 --> 03:11:23.905
NOW I HAD SEVERAL CASES WHERE
03:11:23.972 --> 03:11:25.507
THE EMPLOYER LEFT MESSAGES ON
03:11:25.574 --> 03:11:27.509
VOICE MAIL WITH THREATS OF
03:11:27.576 --> 03:11:29.277
DEPORTATION WHERE THE EMPLOYER
03:11:29.344 --> 03:11:30.579
THREATEN THE WORKER OVER THE
03:11:30.645 --> 03:11:31.246
PHONE?
03:11:31.313 --> 03:11:32.747
AND SHE WAS ABLE TO LEGALLY
03:11:32.814 --> 03:11:34.616
RECORDED BECAUSE HER BOYFRIEND
03:11:34.683 --> 03:11:36.952
WAS ALSO ON THE PHONE AND SPOKE
03:11:37.018 --> 03:11:38.753
WHERE THE EMPLOYER IS GOING TO
03:11:38.820 --> 03:11:39.788
THE WORKPLACE OF THE WORKER AND
03:11:39.855 --> 03:11:41.790
HER COUSIN AND THREATEN THEM NOT
03:11:41.857 --> 03:11:43.191
ONLY WITH DEPORTATION.
03:11:43.258 --> 03:11:45.227
BUT ALSO WITH THE VIXEN FROM
03:11:45.293 --> 03:11:46.895
THEIR APARTMENT AND A RECENT
03:11:46.962 --> 03:11:48.463
CASE WHERE THE EMPLOYER WAS THE
03:11:48.530 --> 03:11:49.464
ONLY ONE WHO KNEW WHERE THE
03:11:49.531 --> 03:11:51.499
WORKER LIVED REPORTED HIM TOP
03:11:51.566 --> 03:11:52.067
ICE.
03:11:52.133 --> 03:11:53.835
AFTER REFILED THE WAGE CLAIM AND
03:11:53.902 --> 03:11:55.470
ICE PICKED HIM UP AND HE'S NOW
03:11:55.537 --> 03:11:57.973
IN MEXICO A SIX MONTH STATUTE OF
03:11:58.039 --> 03:11:59.941
LIMITATIONS IS TOO SHORT TO IN
03:12:00.008 --> 03:12:01.276
ONE CASE WE HAD.
03:12:01.343 --> 03:12:03.245
A SECURITY GUARD MADE A HEALTH
03:12:03.311 --> 03:12:04.479
AND SAFETY COMPLAINTS AND WAS
03:12:04.546 --> 03:12:06.715
FIRED SHE CAME TO OUR CLINIC
03:12:06.781 --> 03:12:08.583
AFTER SEVEN MONTHS BECAUSE SHE
03:12:08.650 --> 03:12:09.784
THOUGHT THE STATUTE OF
03:12:09.851 --> 03:12:12.120
LIMITATIONS WAS THREE YEARS AS
03:12:12.187 --> 03:12:13.855
IT IS IN WAGE CLAIMS.
03:12:13.922 --> 03:12:14.923
OTHER WORKERS WHO COMPLAINED
03:12:14.990 --> 03:12:16.291
ABOUT UNPAID WAGES AND WERE
03:12:16.358 --> 03:12:18.093
FIRED CAME TO OUR CLINIC TOO
03:12:18.159 --> 03:12:25.100
LATE IN MANY CASES A WORK -- IS
03:12:25.166 --> 03:12:26.434
THREATENED WITH DEPORTATION BUT
03:12:26.501 --> 03:12:28.169
NOT FIRED AND IS AFRAID TO FILE
03:12:28.236 --> 03:12:28.837
WATCH YOUR SHE IS STILL WORKING
03:12:28.904 --> 03:12:29.671
FOR THE EMPLOYER HOWEVER ONCE
03:12:29.738 --> 03:12:30.538
HERE SHE LEAVES THE WORKPLACE
03:12:30.605 --> 03:12:31.273
AND GETS ANOTHER JOB.
03:12:31.339 --> 03:12:32.574
THEY ARE WILLING TO FILE THE
03:12:32.641 --> 03:12:34.576
RETALIATION CLAIM IF THEY FILE
03:12:34.643 --> 03:12:36.244
THE WAGE CLAIM THEY WOULD HAVE
03:12:36.311 --> 03:12:37.779
THREE YEARS HOWEVER.
03:12:37.846 --> 03:12:39.648
IF SIX MONTHS OF A LAPSE SINCE
03:12:39.714 --> 03:12:41.683
THE THREAT THEY CANNOT FILE LOW
03:12:41.750 --> 03:12:43.985
WAGE WORKERS ALSO LACK ACCESS TO
03:12:44.052 --> 03:12:45.387
ATTORNEYS FEES AND RESOURCES
03:12:45.453 --> 03:12:47.389
THEY NEED TIME TO FIND AND
03:12:47.455 --> 03:12:50.125
GATHER EVIDENCE AND GATHER IT.
03:12:50.191 --> 03:12:51.493
THE STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS FOR
03:12:51.559 --> 03:12:53.528
RETALIATION AT ABOUT AT OTHER
03:12:53.595 --> 03:12:57.065
AGENCIES AS LONGER AT THAT LSAT
03:12:57.132 --> 03:12:59.067
THAT'S THE THE LAW THAT SAID
03:12:59.134 --> 03:13:00.302
FORCE BY THE DEPARTMENT OF LABOR
03:13:00.368 --> 03:13:01.970
IS TWO YEARS THREE YEARS OF ITS
03:13:02.037 --> 03:13:04.906
WELL. FOR ONE YEAR AT THE DFG H.
03:13:04.973 --> 03:13:06.441
I HAD WORKED AT THE EEOC AND
03:13:06.508 --> 03:13:08.376
IT'S THREE HUNDRED DAYS IF YOU
03:13:08.443 --> 03:13:10.445
BRING THIS ELEVEN OH TWO POINT
03:13:10.512 --> 03:13:13.081
FIVE IN COURT YOU HAVE TWO YEARS.
03:13:13.148 --> 03:13:14.382
BUT IF YOU BRING IT AT THE LABOR
03:13:14.449 --> 03:13:16.384
COMMISSION YOU ONLY HAVE SIX
03:13:16.451 --> 03:13:18.420
MONTHS AND IF THE WAGE LOSS IS
03:13:18.486 --> 03:13:20.021
LOW THERE'S NO WAY THAT THIS
03:13:20.088 --> 03:13:21.890
WILL BE BROUGHT IN COURT THERE'S
03:13:21.957 --> 03:13:23.024
ALSO WHEN ATTORNEYS THE
03:13:23.091 --> 03:13:23.925
PROVISION.
03:13:23.992 --> 03:13:25.727
AND THERE'S MANY PROVISIONS FOR
03:13:25.794 --> 03:13:27.395
ATTORNEYS FEES AND OTHER
03:13:27.462 --> 03:13:31.032
STATUTES FLSA WHISTLEBLOWER ACT
03:13:31.099 --> 03:13:33.969
AND ALSO FOR AT THE EEOC AND THE
03:13:34.035 --> 03:13:35.503
HOW THE FAIR EMPLOYMENT AND
03:13:35.570 --> 03:13:36.604
HOUSING.
03:13:36.671 --> 03:13:38.073
ARE I MEAN THE DEPARTMENT OF
03:13:38.139 --> 03:13:39.741
FAIR EMPLOYMENT AND HOUSING THAT
03:13:39.808 --> 03:13:41.743
ENFORCES FIAT THE OPPOSITION IS
03:13:41.810 --> 03:13:43.244
CLAIMING THAT IT WILL ENCOURAGE
03:13:43.311 --> 03:13:45.513
FRAIL FRIVOLOUS LITIGATION BUT
03:13:45.580 --> 03:13:47.148
ATTORNEYS LOSE EVERYTHING IF
03:13:47.215 --> 03:13:49.417
THEY BRING A FRIVOLOUSLAWSUIT.
03:13:49.484 --> 03:13:51.319
IN FACT THE BILL WOULD ENCOURAGE
03:13:51.386 --> 03:13:54.189
VALID CASES NOW ATTORNEYS WON'T
03:13:54.255 --> 03:13:55.657
TAKE CASES BECAUSE THERE'S NO
03:13:55.724 --> 03:13:57.826
FEES ATTORNEYS A BRING CLAIMS
03:13:57.892 --> 03:13:59.361
FOR DISCRIMINATION HARASSMENT OR
03:13:59.427 --> 03:14:01.563
WAGE THEFT ARE ABLE TO RECOVER
03:14:01.629 --> 03:14:03.698
ATTORNEY'S FEES. ELEVEN OH TWO
03:14:03.765 --> 03:14:06.134
POINT FIVE IS AT ODDS WITH THOSE.
03:14:06.201 --> 03:14:08.303
THERE'S A STRONG PUBLIC POLICY
03:14:08.370 --> 03:14:10.205
TO PROTECT WORKERS AT RISK FOR
03:14:10.271 --> 03:14:13.742
THEIR JOB OR FOR OPPOSING ABUSES.
03:14:13.808 --> 03:14:15.543
THE BILL IS IMPORTANT TO LOW
03:14:15.610 --> 03:14:17.345
WAGE PREDOMINANTLY IMMIGRANT
03:14:17.412 --> 03:14:24.452
WORKERS THAT I REPRESENT AND I
03:14:24.519 --> 03:14:27.856
URGE YOU TO VOTE YES THANK YOU.
03:14:27.922 --> 03:14:29.457
THANK YOU THAT'S WITH US.
03:14:29.524 --> 03:14:30.125
MR CHAIRMAN MEMBERS CAITLIN VEGA
03:14:30.191 --> 03:14:30.625
FOR THE CALIFORNIA LABOR
03:14:30.692 --> 03:14:31.860
FEDERATION ALSO KAREN STRONG
03:14:31.926 --> 03:14:32.293
SUPPORT.
03:14:32.360 --> 03:14:33.628
I WOULD JUST ADD THAT -- FOR
03:14:33.695 --> 03:14:35.163
EMPLOYERS RETALIATION AS A
03:14:35.230 --> 03:14:37.665
WEAPON USED TO SILENCE WORKERS
03:14:37.732 --> 03:14:39.100
IT'S IT'S AT A PUNISHMENT
03:14:39.167 --> 03:14:41.403
BECAUSE WORKERS SPOKE OUT AND
03:14:41.469 --> 03:14:43.571
REPORTED ISSUES LIKE WAGE THAT
03:14:43.638 --> 03:14:45.740
LIKE UNSAFE WORKING CONDITIONS.
03:14:45.807 --> 03:14:47.442
SO THE WORKER HAS ALREADY HAD
03:14:47.509 --> 03:14:48.910
THEIR RIGHTS VIOLATED SPOKEN OUT
03:14:48.977 --> 03:14:51.246
ABOUT IT AM BEEN PUNISHED OF
03:14:51.312 --> 03:14:52.680
COURSE THEY'RE RELUCTANT TO THEN
03:14:52.747 --> 03:14:54.049
COME FORWARD TO COMPLAIN ABOUT
03:14:54.115 --> 03:14:55.417
RETALIATION BECAUSE THEY'VE
03:14:55.483 --> 03:14:57.585
ALREADY SEEN WHAT WILL HAPPEN
03:14:57.652 --> 03:14:58.920
WHEN THEY SPEAK OUT ABOUT
03:14:58.987 --> 03:15:00.455
WORKPLACE CONDITIONS.
03:15:00.522 --> 03:15:01.956
THAT MAKES IT EVEN MORE
03:15:02.023 --> 03:15:03.324
IMPORTANT AND THAT THE
03:15:03.391 --> 03:15:05.160
RETALIATION STATUTE BE
03:15:05.226 --> 03:15:06.795
LENGTHENED INSTEAD IT'S MUCH
03:15:06.861 --> 03:15:08.263
SHORTER THAN THE UNDERLYING
03:15:08.329 --> 03:15:10.432
VIOLATIONS SO IT IT IT I THINK
03:15:10.498 --> 03:15:12.000
IS THE REVERSE OF WHAT.
03:15:12.067 --> 03:15:13.668
AND NEEDS TO BE THE CASE.
03:15:13.735 --> 03:15:15.437
I WOULD OUT ALSO IN TERMS OF THE
03:15:15.503 --> 03:15:17.138
PUBLIC POLICY THERE BEEN A LOT
03:15:17.205 --> 03:15:19.140
OF REPORTS RECENTLY AROUND --
03:15:19.207 --> 03:15:21.676
THE BOEING WORK FORCE WHEN THEY
03:15:21.743 --> 03:15:23.545
WENT NON UNION AND AND THERE
03:15:23.611 --> 03:15:25.814
WERE ALL THESE SAFETY VIOLATIONS
03:15:25.880 --> 03:15:27.048
THAT WORKERS WANTED TO REPORT
03:15:27.115 --> 03:15:28.750
THEY TOO WERE PUNISHED FOR
03:15:28.817 --> 03:15:30.051
SPEAKING OUT.
03:15:30.118 --> 03:15:31.886
ABOUT THE SAFETY VIOLATIONS SO
03:15:31.953 --> 03:15:33.054
IT'S NOT ONLY ABOUT THE
03:15:33.121 --> 03:15:35.023
INDIVIDUAL WORKER IT'S ABOUT THE
03:15:35.090 --> 03:15:36.157
WORKPLACE CULTURE AND THE
03:15:36.224 --> 03:15:37.759
CULTURE OF FEAR THAT GETS
03:15:37.826 --> 03:15:39.194
CREATED WHEN RETALIATION IS NOT
03:15:39.260 --> 03:15:40.061
TAKEN SERIOUSLY.
03:15:40.128 --> 03:15:41.796
IT'S ALSO ABOUT PUBLIC SAFETY
03:15:41.863 --> 03:15:44.432
AND WORKERS BEING ABLE TO REPORT --
03:15:44.499 --> 03:15:45.967
VIOLATIONS OF THEIR OWN RIGHTS
03:15:46.034 --> 03:15:47.535
AND ALSO ISSUES THAT ARE THREAT
03:15:47.602 --> 03:15:49.404
TO PUBLIC SAFETY AND FOR THEM TO
03:15:49.471 --> 03:15:54.042
BE PROTECTED SO WE'RE HEARD
03:15:54.109 --> 03:15:54.542
STRUCK SUPPORT THIS BILL
03:15:54.609 --> 03:15:54.843
[inaudible]
03:15:54.909 --> 03:15:56.744
THANK YOU.
03:15:56.811 --> 03:15:58.713
THAT'S WHAT THIS THAT ANYONE
03:15:58.780 --> 03:16:00.315
ELSE IN SUPPORT.
03:16:00.381 --> 03:16:00.782
SHE HARD ON BEHALF THE
03:16:00.849 --> 03:16:01.816
CALIFORNIA PLUMMET LAWYERS
03:16:01.883 --> 03:16:04.085
ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT.
03:16:04.152 --> 03:16:05.053
JESSICA CENTER ON BEHALF OF
03:16:05.120 --> 03:16:05.587
EQUAL RIGHTS ADVOCATES IN
03:16:05.653 --> 03:16:06.988
SUPPORT.
03:16:07.055 --> 03:16:08.823
THE LARA STRAND FLORES ON BEHALF
03:16:08.890 --> 03:16:09.357
OF THE CALIFORNIA SCHOOL
03:16:09.424 --> 03:16:13.628
EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT.
03:16:13.695 --> 03:16:15.096
RENEE BORRADOR IS HERE YOU
03:16:15.163 --> 03:16:17.699
CALIFORNIANS SUPPORT.
03:16:17.765 --> 03:16:19.601
CORAL HENDON I STRONGLY SUPPORT
03:16:19.667 --> 03:16:20.468
THIS BILL BECAUSE WORKERS LIKE
03:16:20.535 --> 03:16:23.104
ME SHOULD HAVE MORE TIME TO FILE
03:16:23.171 --> 03:16:24.506
THE RETALIATION EARLY NINETY
03:16:24.572 --> 03:16:26.774
WILL TAKE MORE TESTIMONY WHICH
03:16:26.841 --> 03:16:28.343
IS TAKING NAME AND AFFILIATION.
03:16:28.409 --> 03:16:30.812
I SUPPORT THIS BILL THANK YOU.
03:16:30.879 --> 03:16:31.813
CHRIS RESPONSE WHICH ALLOWED
03:16:31.880 --> 03:16:34.149
STRONG SUPPORT WE JUST TOOK
03:16:34.215 --> 03:16:35.483
POSITION LAST WEEK.
03:16:35.550 --> 03:16:36.885
NO I BOTTOM A WITH CALIFORNIA
03:16:36.951 --> 03:16:38.052
RURAL LEGAL ASSISTANCE
03:16:38.119 --> 03:16:41.189
FOUNDATION IN SUPPORT.
03:16:41.256 --> 03:16:41.890
LEYVA RESERVE YOU WITH THE
03:16:41.956 --> 03:16:43.925
CALIFORNIA PROGRAM POLICY CENTER
03:16:43.992 --> 03:16:46.861
ALSO STRONG SUPPORT THANK YOU
03:16:46.928 --> 03:16:48.696
ANYONE ELSE AND SUPPORTS.
03:16:48.763 --> 03:16:58.072
SEEING NONE IS THERE OPPOSITION.
03:16:58.139 --> 03:17:04.512
THIS DISCOUNT IS.
03:17:04.579 --> 03:17:05.513
TO GOOD MORNING THANK YOU SO
03:17:05.580 --> 03:17:06.514
MUCH FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO
03:17:06.581 --> 03:17:07.682
TESTIFY TODAY MY NAME'S LAURA
03:17:07.749 --> 03:17:09.384
CURTIS AND I'M HERE ON BEHALF OF
03:17:09.450 --> 03:17:10.118
THE CALIFORNIA CHAMBER OF
03:17:10.185 --> 03:17:11.753
COMMERCE -- WE ARE NOT IN
03:17:11.819 --> 03:17:13.321
OPPOSITION TO THE EXTENSION OF
03:17:13.388 --> 03:17:14.822
THE STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS AND
03:17:14.889 --> 03:17:16.057
WITH REGARD TO THE LABOR
03:17:16.124 --> 03:17:17.225
COMMISSIONER DEPARTMENT.
03:17:17.292 --> 03:17:18.793
WE ARE ONLY IN OPPOSITION TO THE
03:17:18.860 --> 03:17:19.494
ONE SIDED ATTORNEY'S FEE
03:17:19.561 --> 03:17:20.962
PROVISION THE REASONS BEING THAT
03:17:21.029 --> 03:17:22.297
WE FEEL THAT THE UNDERMINE CITY
03:17:22.363 --> 03:17:24.599
LOC PROCESS IN TWO WAYS FIRST IT
03:17:24.666 --> 03:17:26.167
UNDERMINES THE PROCESS OF THE
03:17:26.234 --> 03:17:26.834
DEAL AS HE BECAUSE MORE
03:17:26.901 --> 03:17:27.869
INDIVIDUALS.
03:17:27.936 --> 03:17:28.903
IF THEY'RE ALLOWED ONE SIDED
03:17:28.970 --> 03:17:30.104
ATTORNEY'S FEE RECOVERY WILL
03:17:30.171 --> 03:17:31.839
FILE THE CLAIMS IN CIVIL COURT
03:17:31.906 --> 03:17:33.274
DIRECTLY BECAUSE MOST OF THESE
03:17:33.341 --> 03:17:34.108
CLAIMS ARE BROUGHT ON A
03:17:34.175 --> 03:17:35.777
CONTINGENCY FEE BASIS OF THE
03:17:35.843 --> 03:17:37.078
EMPLOYEE ACTUALLY HAS NOTHING TO
03:17:37.145 --> 03:17:38.246
LOSE WHAT THE ATTORNEY MIGHT.
03:17:38.313 --> 03:17:39.714
THE EMPLOYEE HAS NOTHING TO LOSE
03:17:39.781 --> 03:17:40.682
WITH FILING A CLAIM IN CIVIL
03:17:40.748 --> 03:17:42.550
COURT BECAUSE THEY HAVE NO UP
03:17:42.617 --> 03:17:43.284
FRONT COST.
03:17:43.351 --> 03:17:44.385
THAT'S OUR FIRST CONCERN WITH
03:17:44.452 --> 03:17:46.087
THE DEAL AS HE PROCESS THE
03:17:46.154 --> 03:17:46.988
SECOND IS THERE IS SOME
03:17:47.055 --> 03:17:48.856
POTENTIAL AMBIGUITY WITH THE ONE
03:17:48.923 --> 03:17:50.291
SIDED ATTORNEY'S FEES WERE THAT
03:17:50.358 --> 03:17:51.593
COULD BE RECOVERED THROUGH THE
03:17:51.659 --> 03:17:53.127
DEAL AS THE PROCESS ITSELF.
03:17:53.194 --> 03:17:54.028
RIGHT NOW THE DEAL AS THE
03:17:54.095 --> 03:17:56.197
PROCESS HOLDS THE EMPLOYEES HAND
03:17:56.264 --> 03:17:56.764
THEY WALK THEM THROUGH THE
03:17:56.831 --> 03:17:57.599
PROCESS.
03:17:57.665 --> 03:17:58.700
THEIR INVESTIGATOR ACTUALLY
03:17:58.766 --> 03:18:00.034
INVESTIGATE THE CLAIMS THE
03:18:00.101 --> 03:18:01.569
EMPLOYER IS NOT ACTUALLY --
03:18:01.636 --> 03:18:03.204
OFTENTIMES NOT PROVIDE AN
03:18:03.271 --> 03:18:04.839
OPPORTUNITY TO PRESENT EVIDENCE
03:18:04.906 --> 03:18:06.908
OTHER OFTENTIMES NOT A PROVIDE
03:18:06.975 --> 03:18:08.409
AN OPPORTUNITY.
03:18:08.476 --> 03:18:10.812
TO REMEDIATE THERE AT POTENTIAL
03:18:10.878 --> 03:18:12.347
FEES THAT MIGHT AT THE AT THE
03:18:12.413 --> 03:18:13.948
AMOUNT OF THE ATTORNEYS FEES AT
03:18:14.015 --> 03:18:14.916
THE PLAINTIFF'S ATTORNEY MIGHT
03:18:14.983 --> 03:18:15.917
BE BRINGING WITH THIS.
03:18:15.984 --> 03:18:16.851
CLAIM IF IT'S FILED WITH THE
03:18:16.918 --> 03:18:18.886
DALLAS EAT AND SO OUR CONCERN IS
03:18:18.953 --> 03:18:20.255
IS THAT IF MORE OF THESE CLAIMS
03:18:20.321 --> 03:18:21.723
ARE FILED BECAUSE OF THE
03:18:21.789 --> 03:18:22.890
ATTORNEYS FEES PROVISION THAN IT
03:18:22.957 --> 03:18:24.459
WOULD BE ALLOW FOR A MORE
03:18:24.525 --> 03:18:26.094
CONTENTIOUS DELISTED PROCESS.
03:18:26.160 --> 03:18:27.061
IF THAT'S NOT THE CASE AND IT'S
03:18:27.128 --> 03:18:28.263
ONLY ATTORNEYS FEES WITHIN THE
03:18:28.329 --> 03:18:29.797
CIVIL COURT THEN WE SEE MORE
03:18:29.864 --> 03:18:30.798
THESE CLAIMS BEING FILED
03:18:30.865 --> 03:18:32.567
DIRECTLY IN CIVIL COURT AND NOT
03:18:32.634 --> 03:18:33.868
UTILIZING THE DEAL AS THE
03:18:33.935 --> 03:18:35.737
PROCESS AND SO THESE POTENTIAL
03:18:35.803 --> 03:18:37.405
CLAIMS WOULD CLOG UP THERE --
03:18:37.472 --> 03:18:39.073
CIVIL COURT AND SO THOSE ARE
03:18:39.140 --> 03:18:40.942
CONCERNS OVER ALL -- BUT WE ALSO
03:18:41.009 --> 03:18:42.710
AGREED -- FEEL THAT IF THERE ARE
03:18:42.777 --> 03:18:43.578
GOING TO BE ATTORNEYS FEES
03:18:43.645 --> 03:18:45.280
PROVISION ADDED IT SHOULD NOT BE
03:18:45.346 --> 03:18:47.048
ONE SIDED BOTH PARTIES SHOULD
03:18:47.115 --> 03:18:47.715
HAVE STUCK THE SAME STAKE IN THE
03:18:47.782 --> 03:18:48.816
CLAIM.
03:18:48.883 --> 03:18:49.951
THAT WILL DRIVE DOWN FOR FELIZ
03:18:50.018 --> 03:18:51.653
LITIGATION AND THAT'S OUR
03:18:51.719 --> 03:18:53.187
OVERALL CONCERN AND FOR THOSE
03:18:53.254 --> 03:18:54.255
REASONS WE ARE POST THANK YOU
03:18:54.322 --> 03:18:59.927
FOR YOUR TIME.
03:18:59.994 --> 03:19:00.428
THANK YOU ANYONE ELSE IN
03:19:00.495 --> 03:19:02.463
OPPOSITION.
03:19:02.530 --> 03:19:04.065
SINGER BRING BACK TO COMMITTEE
03:19:04.132 --> 03:19:05.867
QUESTIONS COMMENTS.
03:19:05.933 --> 03:19:07.468
SEEING NONE WE MISTER KALRA.
03:19:07.535 --> 03:19:09.137
YOU MAY CLOSE.
03:19:09.203 --> 03:19:10.071
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
03:19:10.138 --> 03:19:12.874
MISTER CHAIR -- AND I APPRECIATE --
03:19:12.940 --> 03:19:15.276
THE THE CHAIR SUPPORT FOR THE
03:19:15.343 --> 03:19:16.144
BILL COMMITTEE SUPPORT FOR THE
03:19:16.210 --> 03:19:18.012
BILL -- AND JUST JUST A COMMENT
03:19:18.079 --> 03:19:20.315
ON ON WHAT THE REALITY IS AND
03:19:20.381 --> 03:19:22.383
THE REALITY IS THAT -- BUT GIVEN
03:19:22.450 --> 03:19:24.018
THE FACT.
03:19:24.085 --> 03:19:25.553
THAT ATTORNEYS MAY LOSE THAT
03:19:25.620 --> 03:19:27.155
WE'RE NOT GONNA REALLY HAVE --
03:19:27.221 --> 03:19:28.456
AN ONSLAUGHT OF ATTORNEYS
03:19:28.523 --> 03:19:30.558
LOOKING FOR LOW WAGE WORKERS
03:19:30.625 --> 03:19:32.327
THAT IN GENERAL HAVE VERY --
03:19:32.393 --> 03:19:33.895
ALTHOUGH POTENTIAL SETTLEMENT
03:19:33.961 --> 03:19:35.963
CLAIMS -- YOU HAVE BEEN TO GO
03:19:36.030 --> 03:19:38.466
AFTER IT AS CLIENTELE TO TAKE TO
03:19:38.533 --> 03:19:39.834
THE COURTS RIGHT NOW ON PLEASE
03:19:39.901 --> 03:19:41.869
REALLY I KNOW GENUINE ABILITY TO
03:19:41.936 --> 03:19:44.038
SEEK JUSTICE IN OUR COURT SYSTEM
03:19:44.105 --> 03:19:44.639
ONE OF THE FEW OUT TO USE THE
03:19:44.706 --> 03:19:48.443
HOT THEY HAVE.
03:19:48.509 --> 03:19:50.111
IS AN EGG IS OF WHAT.
03:19:50.178 --> 03:19:51.446
SILVERTONE DOES IN TERMS OF THE
03:19:51.512 --> 03:19:52.180
LAW CLINIC.
03:19:52.246 --> 03:19:54.182
AND GETTING SOME ATTORNEYS FEES
03:19:54.248 --> 03:19:54.816
ALLOWS A LAW CLINIC TO ACTUALLY
03:19:54.882 --> 03:19:55.817
REPRESENT MORE PEOPLE.
03:19:55.883 --> 03:19:58.820
AND AND ALLOWS THEM TO BE ABLE
03:19:58.886 --> 03:20:01.055
TO OFFER JUSTICE. TO WORKERS AND
03:20:01.122 --> 03:20:02.790
SO THAT'S WHY THE ATTORNEY FEES
03:20:02.857 --> 03:20:05.293
A PORTION IS SO IMPORTANT EIGHT
03:20:05.360 --> 03:20:05.727
IT WON'T.
03:20:05.793 --> 03:20:07.895
I HAD TO GREATER LITIGATION
03:20:07.962 --> 03:20:09.364
AGAIN BECAUSE ONLY THE
03:20:09.430 --> 03:20:10.832
PREVAILING SIDE WILL WIN AND
03:20:10.898 --> 03:20:12.233
THIS IS NOT LIKE OTHER TYPES OF
03:20:12.300 --> 03:20:14.369
CIVIL ACTIONS WERE THE POTENTIAL
03:20:14.435 --> 03:20:17.038
PAY OUT IS GOING TO BE ENORMOUS --
03:20:17.105 --> 03:20:18.106
YOU KNOW I ATTORNEYS ARE VERY
03:20:18.172 --> 03:20:19.507
CAUTIOUS WHEN IT COMES TO USING
03:20:19.574 --> 03:20:21.142
THEIR TIME ESPECIALLY IF THEIR
03:20:21.209 --> 03:20:23.544
GOAL IS TO MAKE MONEY -- THIS IS
03:20:23.611 --> 03:20:24.545
NOT THE ROUTE TO GO -- BUT
03:20:24.612 --> 03:20:25.346
YOU'RE TRYING TO BUY LOW WAGE
03:20:25.413 --> 03:20:26.914
WORKERS BEING TAKEN ADVANTAGE UP
03:20:26.981 --> 03:20:29.317
WHAT IT WILL ALLOW FOR IS THOSE
03:20:29.384 --> 03:20:30.284
LAWYERS THAT ARE.
03:20:30.351 --> 03:20:32.019
ATTEMPTING TO HELP WORKERS SEEK
03:20:32.086 --> 03:20:33.388
JUSTICE TO BE ABLE LEASE GET
03:20:33.454 --> 03:20:35.356
SOME COMPENSATION TO ALLOW THEM
03:20:35.423 --> 03:20:37.091
TO REPRESENT MORE WORKERS AND
03:20:37.158 --> 03:20:40.061
MORE SPECIFICALLY ALLOW OF NON
03:20:40.128 --> 03:20:43.297
PROFITS CLINICS.
03:20:43.364 --> 03:20:43.931
SUCH AS THE ONE THAT MISSED OVER
03:20:43.998 --> 03:20:46.868
TOLD -- BUT RUNS AB TO BE ABLE
03:20:46.934 --> 03:20:52.774
TO REPRESENT -- TO BE ABLE TO
03:20:52.840 --> 03:20:55.743
REPRESENT -- MORE WORKERS AND
03:20:55.810 --> 03:20:57.211
GIVE THEM A VOICE AND IT WON'T
03:20:57.278 --> 03:20:57.779
STOP THE WORKERS FROM GOING
03:20:57.845 --> 03:20:58.780
BEFORE THE LABOR COMMISSION.
03:20:58.846 --> 03:21:02.850
AS WELL AND SO -- IN ANY CASE I
03:21:02.917 --> 03:21:05.386
I STRONGLY.
03:21:05.453 --> 03:21:06.521
ASKED THAT -- WITH THE COMMITTEE
03:21:06.587 --> 03:21:07.188
SUPPORT THIS BILL AND AND OTHERS
03:21:07.255 --> 03:21:07.989
LIKE IT THAT I HAD MORE
03:21:08.055 --> 03:21:09.924
OPPORTUNITY FOR WORKERS TO SEEK
03:21:09.991 --> 03:21:10.358
JUSTICE THANK YOU.
03:21:10.425 --> 03:21:11.492
THANK YOU WE DO HAVE A MOTION A
03:21:11.559 --> 03:21:13.728
SECOND THAT MOTION IS TO PASS TO
03:21:13.795 --> 03:21:15.263
APPROPRIATIONS KALRA PLEASE
03:21:15.329 --> 03:21:17.231
STONE BY STONE AYE GALLAGHER
03:21:17.298 --> 03:21:18.132
CHAU.
03:21:18.199 --> 03:21:20.001
CHIU GONZALEZ.
03:21:20.067 --> 03:21:21.669
GONZALEZ I HOLDEN.
03:21:21.736 --> 03:21:23.337
HOLDEN AYE KALRA AYE KALRA AYE
03:21:23.404 --> 03:21:25.540
KILEY.
03:21:25.606 --> 03:21:27.942
MAIENSCHEIN OBERNOLTE
03:21:28.009 --> 03:21:31.813
PETRIE-NORRIS REYES.
03:21:31.879 --> 03:21:33.648
WITH THE BILL LAW CALL IT NEEDS
03:21:33.714 --> 03:21:34.048
THREE MORE VOTES.
03:21:34.115 --> 03:21:35.683
SO THAT TAKES US TO ITEM NUMBER
03:21:35.750 --> 03:21:47.695
NINE AB [inaudible]
03:21:47.762 --> 03:22:01.909
ELEVEN SIXTY TWO YEAH
03:22:01.976 --> 03:22:02.210
[inaudible]
03:22:02.276 --> 03:22:05.513
POSSIBLE.
03:22:05.580 --> 03:22:07.315
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR AND
03:22:07.381 --> 03:22:09.016
MEMBERS ASSEMBLY BILL THAT IN
03:22:09.083 --> 03:22:09.817
SIXTY TWO WILL TAKE MEANINGFUL
03:22:09.884 --> 03:22:11.352
ACTION TO CURB AVOIDABLE PLASTIC
03:22:11.419 --> 03:22:14.088
USE A TINY BOTTLE BATH
03:22:14.155 --> 03:22:14.622
TOILETRIES IN THE LODGING
03:22:14.689 --> 03:22:15.289
INDUSTRY.
03:22:15.356 --> 03:22:17.058
THE PROLIFERATION LIBERATION OF
03:22:17.124 --> 03:22:18.092
PLASTIC WAYS HAVING A
03:22:18.159 --> 03:22:20.228
DEVASTATING IMPACT ON OUR
03:22:20.294 --> 03:22:21.662
ENVIRONMENT AND IS PLEASING OUR
03:22:21.729 --> 03:22:22.630
OCEANS.
03:22:22.697 --> 03:22:24.398
STILL USE PLASTIC IS ALSO ADDING
03:22:24.465 --> 03:22:25.766
TO OUR LANDFILLS THOSE TINY
03:22:25.833 --> 03:22:27.235
PLASTIC SHAMPOO BOTTLES AND
03:22:27.301 --> 03:22:28.503
OTHER PERSONAL CARE PRODUCTS
03:22:28.569 --> 03:22:29.370
REPRESENT A SIZEABLE AMOUNT OF
03:22:29.437 --> 03:22:30.171
WASTE.
03:22:30.238 --> 03:22:31.439
THAT CAN EASILY BE ELIMINATED
03:22:31.506 --> 03:22:32.773
THROUGH MORE COST EFFECTIVE AND
03:22:32.840 --> 03:22:34.308
ENVIRONMENTALLY FRIENDLY
03:22:34.375 --> 03:22:35.376
ALTERNATIVES.
03:22:35.443 --> 03:22:37.211
SB ELEVEN SIXTY TWO PROHIBITS A
03:22:37.278 --> 03:22:38.012
LODGING ESTABLISHED FROM
03:22:38.079 --> 03:22:39.881
PROVIDING SMALL PLASTIC BOTTLES
03:22:39.947 --> 03:22:40.848
CONTAINING CHRIS AND PERSONAL
03:22:40.915 --> 03:22:44.952
CARE PRODUCTS. TO A GAS ANY
03:22:45.019 --> 03:22:46.220
SLEEPING ACCOMMODATION.
03:22:46.287 --> 03:22:47.655
CURRENTLY -- THE BILL PROVIDES A
03:22:47.722 --> 03:22:49.190
THREE YEAR OF IMPLEMENTATION
03:22:49.257 --> 03:22:50.658
DELAY TO GET BUSINESSES TIME TO
03:22:50.725 --> 03:22:51.859
DEPLETE THE CURRENT STOCK.
03:22:51.926 --> 03:22:53.261
INSTALL DISPENSERS ENSURE THAT
03:22:53.327 --> 03:22:55.096
DISTRIBUTION OF SUPPLY AND OF X.
03:22:55.162 --> 03:22:55.963
I HAVE EXPRESSED TO THE
03:22:56.030 --> 03:22:57.665
CALIFORNIA HOTEL LODGING
03:22:57.732 --> 03:22:59.133
ASSOCIATION WILLINGNESS TO
03:22:59.200 --> 03:23:02.336
PROVIDE SMALLER ESTABLISHMENTS
03:23:02.403 --> 03:23:03.905
AN EXTRA YEAR TO COMPLY.
03:23:03.971 --> 03:23:04.872
GENTLY MANY BUSINESSES AND
03:23:04.939 --> 03:23:05.840
BRANDS THE HOTEL INDUSTRY --
03:23:05.907 --> 03:23:07.241
ALREADY PHASING OUT THE SMALL
03:23:07.308 --> 03:23:10.278
PLASTIC BOTTLES IN FAVOR OF FOR
03:23:10.344 --> 03:23:11.312
IN FAVOR OF A FILLABLE
03:23:11.379 --> 03:23:12.513
DISPENSERS.
03:23:12.580 --> 03:23:13.848
BY NOT OFFERING SMALL PLASTIC
03:23:13.915 --> 03:23:14.982
BOTTLES OF PERSONAL CARE
03:23:15.049 --> 03:23:16.617
PRODUCTS HOTELS MOTELS AND OTHER
03:23:16.684 --> 03:23:18.185
LODGING ESTABLISHMENTS WE CAN
03:23:18.252 --> 03:23:19.687
REDUCE SINGLE USE PLASTIC
03:23:19.754 --> 03:23:20.855
CONSUMPTION AND INCREASE
03:23:20.922 --> 03:23:23.090
CONSUMER AWARENESS.
03:23:23.157 --> 03:23:25.226
ABOUT USE OF PLASTIC -- IN IN
03:23:25.293 --> 03:23:26.794
FACT THE REASON WHY WE SEE THE
03:23:26.861 --> 03:23:27.595
INDUSTRY MOVING IN THIS
03:23:27.662 --> 03:23:31.198
DIRECTION IS IN MUCH PART DUE TO
03:23:31.265 --> 03:23:32.833
CONSUMER PREFERENCE.
03:23:32.900 --> 03:23:33.501
I'VE BEEN A PRODUCTIVE
03:23:33.568 --> 03:23:34.936
CONVERSATION THE CALIFORNIA
03:23:35.002 --> 03:23:36.504
HOTEL LODGING ASSOCIATION.
03:23:36.571 --> 03:23:38.105
AND REALLY WANT TO THANK THEM --
03:23:38.172 --> 03:23:39.473
FOR PRACTICALLY WORKING WITH US
03:23:39.540 --> 03:23:41.242
TO TRY TO RESOLVE AS MANY
03:23:41.309 --> 03:23:43.277
IMPENDING ISSUES WE MAY HAVE --
03:23:43.344 --> 03:23:45.212
IT IS MY HOPE TO KEEP WORKING
03:23:45.279 --> 03:23:45.980
WITH INDUSTRY INCOME TO THE
03:23:46.047 --> 03:23:48.149
GOVERNMENT ARE MAKING IT CLEAR
03:23:48.215 --> 03:23:48.983
BUT PRODUCTS ARE SUBJECT TO THE
03:23:49.050 --> 03:23:49.884
BILL.
03:23:49.951 --> 03:23:52.620
AND ENFORCEMENT END -- BUT IT'S
03:23:52.687 --> 03:23:54.355
IT'S ALSO.
03:23:54.422 --> 03:23:55.723
GOOD TO KNOW THAT THE INDUSTRY --
03:23:55.790 --> 03:23:57.124
IS SUPPORTIVE OF WHAT WE'RE
03:23:57.191 --> 03:23:58.225
TRYING TO DO BECAUSE THAT'S THE
03:23:58.292 --> 03:23:59.527
DIRECTION ARE GOING AND I THINK
03:23:59.594 --> 03:24:00.861
IT'S AN INDUSTRY THAT HAS BEEN
03:24:00.928 --> 03:24:02.163
AGGRESSIVE ON ISSUES OF THE
03:24:02.229 --> 03:24:03.064
ENVIRONMENT.
03:24:03.130 --> 03:24:04.865
AND THIS IS ONE MORE EXAMPLE
03:24:04.932 --> 03:24:06.601
BECAUSE WE SEE THE INDUSTRY
03:24:06.667 --> 03:24:08.302
MOVING IN THIS DIRECTION ALREADY.
03:24:08.369 --> 03:24:09.837
THE COMMITTEE ANALYSIS RECOGNIZE
03:24:09.904 --> 03:24:11.005
THE CHALLENGES OF APPLYING A
03:24:11.072 --> 03:24:13.341
SAFE HARBOR USED FOR HUMAN
03:24:13.407 --> 03:24:15.076
TRAFFICKING POSTING TO THIS BILL --
03:24:15.142 --> 03:24:16.544
AND HOPEFULLY THERE'S PROGRESS
03:24:16.611 --> 03:24:17.378
TO CLARIFY WHICH PRODUCTS ARE
03:24:17.445 --> 03:24:18.579
COVERED THAT PROVISION WILL NOT
03:24:18.646 --> 03:24:19.747
BE NECESSARY.
03:24:19.814 --> 03:24:21.215
ALSO NOTHING IN THE BILL WOULD
03:24:21.282 --> 03:24:22.383
PROHIBIT HOTEL GUESTS AND BRING
03:24:22.450 --> 03:24:23.751
IN THEIR OWN SMALL BOTTLE
03:24:23.818 --> 03:24:25.019
TOILETRIES PATEL FROM OFFERING
03:24:25.086 --> 03:24:27.388
CONVENIENCE ITEMS OUTSIDE THE
03:24:27.455 --> 03:24:28.789
ACCOMMODATION ROOM.
03:24:28.856 --> 03:24:29.924
WITH SO MANY VIABLE ALTERNATIVES
03:24:29.991 --> 03:24:31.425
PROVIDING SMALL PLASTIC BOTTLES
03:24:31.492 --> 03:24:32.560
OF PERSONAL CARE PRODUCTS LIKE
03:24:32.627 --> 03:24:34.629
SHAMPOO THE LODGING INDUSTRIES
03:24:34.695 --> 03:24:35.997
IN A PRIME POSITION TO PHASE OUT
03:24:36.063 --> 03:24:37.098
THE PRACTICE.
03:24:37.164 --> 03:24:39.867
AND CONTINUE THEIR COMMITMENT TO
03:24:39.934 --> 03:24:41.502
ABOUT OF WHAT ABOUT AMOUNTS TO A
03:24:41.569 --> 03:24:42.370
SHIP A PRODUCING PLASTIC WASTE.
03:24:42.436 --> 03:24:43.304
AND BY SOME ESTIMATES THERE ARE
03:24:43.371 --> 03:24:44.505
AS MANY AS HALF A BILLION OF
03:24:44.572 --> 03:24:45.673
THESE LITTLE BOTTLES.
03:24:45.740 --> 03:24:47.375
THAT ARE PUT IN THE ROOMS IN
03:24:47.441 --> 03:24:49.710
CALIFORNIA IN JUST A SINGLE YEAR
03:24:49.777 --> 03:24:50.745
SO WE'RE NOT TALKING ABOUT A
03:24:50.811 --> 03:24:53.481
SMALL ISSUE ARE SMALL PROBLEM
03:24:53.547 --> 03:24:54.915
EVEN THOUGH THE BOTTLES MAYBES.
03:24:54.982 --> 03:24:56.317
I WOULD BE PROVIDE SUPPORTING
03:24:56.384 --> 03:24:57.652
TESTIMONY IS CAN HEY WHAT
03:24:57.718 --> 03:24:59.520
PRESIDENT OUR COMMUNITIES AND
03:24:59.587 --> 03:25:00.921
GENEVIEVE AVEDON REPRESENT THE
03:25:00.988 --> 03:25:10.097
CLEANS HIS LOBBYING COALITION.
03:25:10.164 --> 03:25:12.333
THANK YOU FIRST WITH US PLEASE.
03:25:12.400 --> 03:25:14.402
HELLO THANK YOU GUYS -- FOR HAVE
03:25:14.468 --> 03:25:15.469
ME SPEAK HERE TODAY MY NAME'S
03:25:15.536 --> 03:25:15.970
KEN HAYWORTH AND FOUNDER
03:25:16.037 --> 03:25:16.937
INVENTOR AND PRESIDENT OF OUR
03:25:17.004 --> 03:25:17.538
COMMUNITIES WE ARE AN AMENITY
03:25:17.605 --> 03:25:18.739
FIXTURE MANUFACTURER BASED HERE
03:25:18.806 --> 03:25:19.607
IN CALIFORNIA BUT DOING BUSINESS
03:25:19.674 --> 03:25:20.941
ALL OVER THE WORLD.
03:25:21.008 --> 03:25:23.611
I'M IN SUPPORT OF ASSEMBLY BILL
03:25:23.678 --> 03:25:24.245
ELEVEN SIXTY TWO I BELIEVE THAT
03:25:24.311 --> 03:25:25.513
FROM MY EXPERIENCE IN OVER NINE
03:25:25.579 --> 03:25:26.614
YEARS IN THE INDUSTRY THAT IT
03:25:26.681 --> 03:25:29.050
SHOULD BE EASY YES DECISION FOR
03:25:29.116 --> 03:25:30.351
ALL OF YOU.
03:25:30.418 --> 03:25:31.686
ENVIRONMENTALLY FOR THE PLANT
03:25:31.752 --> 03:25:32.620
WE'VE ALL SEEN THE PLASTICS ARE
03:25:32.687 --> 03:25:33.788
DOING TO OUR WORLD THE
03:25:33.854 --> 03:25:35.056
IMPLEMENTATION OF THIS BILL WILL
03:25:35.122 --> 03:25:36.390
SAVE UP TO A THOUSAND SMALL
03:25:36.457 --> 03:25:37.725
BOTTLES.
03:25:37.792 --> 03:25:39.827
IN OVER FIVE GALLONS A PARTIALLY
03:25:39.894 --> 03:25:42.196
USE PRODUCT BECAUSE WE ONLY USE
03:25:42.263 --> 03:25:43.898
25% ON AVERAGE.
03:25:43.964 --> 03:25:44.799
OF THOSE LITTLE BOTTLES AND ALL
03:25:44.865 --> 03:25:47.468
OF YOU HAVE BEEN IN HOTELS --
03:25:47.535 --> 03:25:50.171
FROM LANDFILLS PER ROOM PER YEAR
03:25:50.237 --> 03:25:50.838
ADDITIONALLY WILL CREATE
03:25:50.905 --> 03:25:52.339
ANCILLARY SAVINGS AND FREIGHT
03:25:52.406 --> 03:25:53.874
PACKAGING.
03:25:53.941 --> 03:25:55.609
WASTE REMOVAL AND RECYCLING
03:25:55.676 --> 03:25:57.411
FINANCIALLY FOR THE HOTELS IT'LL
03:25:57.478 --> 03:25:58.946
SAVE HER HOTELS BETWEEN THIRTY
03:25:59.013 --> 03:26:00.347
AND 45% FROM THEIR CURRENT
03:26:00.414 --> 03:26:02.216
AMENITY BUDGETS LIMITING THEIR
03:26:02.283 --> 03:26:03.851
FRIGHTENED PACKAGING LOWER IN
03:26:03.918 --> 03:26:05.186
THEIR WASTE AND RECYCLING BILLS.
03:26:05.252 --> 03:26:06.954
FURTHER IT LIMITS OPERATIONAL
03:26:07.021 --> 03:26:08.856
TIMELINES AS TO PLACING PIC
03:26:08.923 --> 03:26:10.357
REDELIVERY AND CLEAN UP OF THE
03:26:10.424 --> 03:26:12.093
SMALL BOTTLED.
03:26:12.159 --> 03:26:13.260
BOTTLES IN THE ROOMS.
03:26:13.327 --> 03:26:14.829
WE COME TO SEE OVER THE LAST FEW
03:26:14.895 --> 03:26:16.297
YEARS A GREAT MOVEMENT ACROSS
03:26:16.363 --> 03:26:17.665
OUR COUNTRY WITH COMPANIES LIKE
03:26:17.732 --> 03:26:19.567
I. H. G. INTER CONTINENTAL HOTEL
03:26:19.633 --> 03:26:21.569
GROUP DISNEY MARRIOTT HYATT AND
03:26:21.635 --> 03:26:22.770
OTHERS PHASING OUT THE USE A
03:26:22.837 --> 03:26:24.071
SMALL BOTTLES WITH FOCUS ON THE
03:26:24.138 --> 03:26:25.306
ENVIRONMENT.
03:26:25.372 --> 03:26:27.508
THIS YEAR ALONE I. H. G. CREATED
03:26:27.575 --> 03:26:28.776
A BRAND STANDARD FOR CANDLE
03:26:28.843 --> 03:26:30.444
WOULD STAY BRIDGE SUITES HOLIDAY
03:26:30.511 --> 03:26:31.712
INN EXPRESS AND EVEN HOTELS WILL
03:26:31.779 --> 03:26:32.413
SAVE.
03:26:32.480 --> 03:26:33.647
OVER A HUNDRED AND THIRTY
03:26:33.714 --> 03:26:35.916
MILLION PLASTIC BOTTLES AND OVER
03:26:35.983 --> 03:26:37.318
FIVE HUNDRED AND TEN THOUSAND
03:26:37.384 --> 03:26:39.386
GALLONS A PARTIALLY USE PRODUCT
03:26:39.453 --> 03:26:40.721
FROM OUR LANDFILLS.
03:26:40.788 --> 03:26:43.791
IMAGINE A GALLON OF MILK FIVE
03:26:43.858 --> 03:26:46.727
HUNDRED AND TEN THOUSAND OTHERS.
03:26:46.794 --> 03:26:47.795
WITH FINANCIAL SAVINGS TO THOSE
03:26:47.862 --> 03:26:50.064
HOTELS OF OVER TWENTY ONE
03:26:50.131 --> 03:26:52.233
MILLION DOLLARS.
03:26:52.299 --> 03:26:54.001
ALSO WE SEEM TO BEEN CONTACTED
03:26:54.068 --> 03:26:55.503
BY MORE MORE FLAGS TO THE DESIRE
03:26:55.569 --> 03:26:57.104
TO MOVE TOWARDS A MORE
03:26:57.171 --> 03:26:58.439
SUSTAINABLE SOLUTION FOR THEIR
03:26:58.506 --> 03:26:59.673
MANY PROGRAMS.
03:26:59.740 --> 03:27:01.742
WE DON'T SEE THIS IS MERELY AN
03:27:01.809 --> 03:27:03.310
ECONOMICAL DECISION.
03:27:03.377 --> 03:27:05.379
WHICH IT CERTAINLY IS BUT MORE A
03:27:05.446 --> 03:27:07.281
SOCIAL AND ENVIRONMENTAL.
03:27:07.348 --> 03:27:08.682
ONE FROM A GUEST PERSPECTIVE DUE
03:27:08.749 --> 03:27:09.750
TO THE SAVINGS HOTELS ARE ABLE
03:27:09.817 --> 03:27:10.818
TO PROVIDE A BETTER QUALITY
03:27:10.885 --> 03:27:11.886
PRODUCT FOR THE GUESTS AND
03:27:11.952 --> 03:27:13.487
FURTHER THAT FURTHER ENHANCES
03:27:13.554 --> 03:27:15.256
THE GUEST EXPERIENCE.
03:27:15.322 --> 03:27:16.457
AND WORKS IN TANDEM WITH THE
03:27:16.524 --> 03:27:18.459
ZERO A SOLUTION THAT THE GUESTS
03:27:18.526 --> 03:27:21.896
ARE EXPECTING -- THIS INCREASE
03:27:21.962 --> 03:27:23.430
IN DEMAND IS FORCED AMENITY
03:27:23.497 --> 03:27:25.199
DISPENSER COMPANIES LIKE MYSELF
03:27:25.266 --> 03:27:26.967
TO CREATE A BETTER GREATER
03:27:27.034 --> 03:27:27.835
DIVERSITY IN THE PRODUCT
03:27:27.902 --> 03:27:29.236
OFFERING IT'S NO LONGER IS THAT
03:27:29.303 --> 03:27:31.005
THE BOX OF GOO THAT YOU MAY
03:27:31.071 --> 03:27:31.272
REMEMBER.
03:27:31.338 --> 03:27:33.641
THERE'S A A MUCH BETTER PRODUCT
03:27:33.707 --> 03:27:38.612
OUT ON THE MARKET -- AND FINALLY
03:27:38.679 --> 03:27:39.680
EVERY DAY WE HEAR ABOUT A
03:27:39.747 --> 03:27:41.315
PLASTIC IS INVADING OUR PLANET
03:27:41.382 --> 03:27:41.849
NOW THERE'S FIVE FLOATING
03:27:41.916 --> 03:27:43.017
ISLANDS.
03:27:43.083 --> 03:27:45.219
THE SIZE OF TEXAS ON OUR OCEANS
03:27:45.286 --> 03:27:46.587
AND WHAT THE COST WOULD BE.
03:27:46.654 --> 03:27:48.088
TO JUST CLEAN UP THE SURFACE OF
03:27:48.155 --> 03:27:49.790
OUR OCEANS SAY NOTHING ABOUT
03:27:49.857 --> 03:27:51.192
WHAT LIES BENEATH.
03:27:51.258 --> 03:27:53.260
YOU ALL HAVE A CHANCE TO MAKE A
03:27:53.327 --> 03:27:54.595
CHANGE TO NOT ONLY LIMITS THE
03:27:54.662 --> 03:27:55.896
OPPORTUNITY FOR PLASTICS TO
03:27:55.963 --> 03:27:57.498
REACH OUR OCEANS BUT ALSO SAVES
03:27:57.565 --> 03:27:59.200
MONEY FOR THE PROPERTIES
03:27:59.266 --> 03:28:00.201
INCORPORATING IT.
03:28:00.267 --> 03:28:01.969
THERE ARE FEW THINGS THAT YOU
03:28:02.036 --> 03:28:02.837
CAN DO.
03:28:02.903 --> 03:28:04.138
TODAY THAT WILL INCREASE THE
03:28:04.205 --> 03:28:05.306
SIZE OF YOUR CONSTITUENTS
03:28:05.372 --> 03:28:06.540
POCKETS.
03:28:06.607 --> 03:28:07.975
AND HELP TO MAKE THE WORLD A
03:28:08.042 --> 03:28:10.044
BETTER PLACE I HOPE THAT YOU
03:28:10.110 --> 03:28:10.578
MAKE A DECISION IT MEANS
03:28:10.644 --> 03:28:12.379
SOMETHING. TO THIS AND FUTURE
03:28:12.446 --> 03:28:15.316
GENERATIONS AND SAY YES TO A. B.
03:28:15.382 --> 03:28:16.350
ELEVEN SIXTY TWO AND INSPIRE A
03:28:16.417 --> 03:28:17.885
POSITIVE CHANGE.
03:28:17.952 --> 03:28:19.386
THANK YOU TODAY FOR YOUR TIME
03:28:19.453 --> 03:28:20.421
AND HOPE YOU'LL JOIN ME IN A
03:28:20.487 --> 03:28:24.859
SPORT FOR ASSEMBLY BILL ELEVEN
03:28:24.925 --> 03:28:25.492
SIXTY TWO THANK YOU THAT'S WHAT
03:28:25.559 --> 03:28:29.864
THIS PLACE.
03:28:29.930 --> 03:28:31.866
GOOD MORNING CHAIR AND MEMBERS.
03:28:31.932 --> 03:28:33.934
MY NAME IS GENEVIEVE AVEDON AND
03:28:34.001 --> 03:28:34.501
I REPRESENT THE CLEAN SEIZE
03:28:34.568 --> 03:28:35.469
LOBBYING COALITION THAT CONSISTS
03:28:35.536 --> 03:28:37.338
OF ELEVEN NONPROFIT ORGANIZATION
03:28:37.404 --> 03:28:38.839
THROUGH CALIFORNIA.
03:28:38.906 --> 03:28:40.307
INCLUDING HEAL THE BAY SURFRIDER
03:28:40.374 --> 03:28:42.643
FOUNDATION SAVE OUR SHORES AND
03:28:42.710 --> 03:28:44.445
MANY OTHERS -- AS YOU KNOW
03:28:44.511 --> 03:28:45.746
PLASTIC POLLUTION AFFECTS EVERY
03:28:45.813 --> 03:28:47.514
STREAM RIVER PARK AND STREET IN
03:28:47.581 --> 03:28:49.683
CALIFORNIA IT STARTS WITH FOSSIL
03:28:49.750 --> 03:28:50.951
FUEL EXTRACTION AND CONTINUES
03:28:51.018 --> 03:28:52.219
THROUGH MANUFACTURING
03:28:52.286 --> 03:28:54.321
TRANSPORTATION USAGE AND
03:28:54.388 --> 03:28:56.290
DISPOSAL.
03:28:56.357 --> 03:28:56.891
PLASTICS HAVE RECENTLY BEEN
03:28:56.957 --> 03:28:58.392
FOUND TO EMIT POTENT GREENHOUSE
03:28:58.459 --> 03:28:58.993
GASES THAT THE AS THEY BREAK
03:28:59.059 --> 03:28:59.593
DOWN.
03:28:59.660 --> 03:29:01.262
AND WITH THE PLAN 40% INCREASE
03:29:01.328 --> 03:29:02.630
IN PLASTIC PRODUCTION OVER THE
03:29:02.696 --> 03:29:04.899
NEXT DECADE UNLESS WE MAKE MAJOR
03:29:04.965 --> 03:29:06.367
POLICY CHANGES TO COUNTER THIS.
03:29:06.433 --> 03:29:08.035
PLASTIC PRODUCTION WILL ACCOUNT
03:29:08.102 --> 03:29:09.637
420% OF GLOBAL FOSSIL FUEL
03:29:09.703 --> 03:29:10.604
CONSUMPTION.
03:29:10.671 --> 03:29:12.006
ADDITIONALLY MICRO PASTA HAVE
03:29:12.072 --> 03:29:13.674
BEEN FOUND IN TAP WATER BOTTLED
03:29:13.741 --> 03:29:15.943
WATER TABLE SALT FISH SELF
03:29:16.010 --> 03:29:17.978
SHELLFISH AGRICULTURAL SOILS AT
03:29:18.045 --> 03:29:18.746
CETERA.
03:29:18.812 --> 03:29:20.881
ALL OF WHICH POSE A POTENTIAL
03:29:20.948 --> 03:29:21.415
THREAT TO HUMAN AND ANIMAL
03:29:21.482 --> 03:29:22.716
HEALTH.
03:29:22.783 --> 03:29:23.751
ALL OF THIS COMES WITH THE
03:29:23.817 --> 03:29:25.119
TREMENDOUS COST TO INDIVIDUALS
03:29:25.185 --> 03:29:26.887
AND COMMUNITIES ECOSYSTEMS AND
03:29:26.954 --> 03:29:28.289
WILDLIFE ALL ALONG THE SUPPLY
03:29:28.355 --> 03:29:29.256
CHAIN.
03:29:29.323 --> 03:29:30.724
CALIFORNIA TAXPAYERS AND LOCAL
03:29:30.791 --> 03:29:32.459
GOVERNMENTS SPEND OVER FOUR
03:29:32.526 --> 03:29:33.460
HUNDRED AND TWENTY MILLION
03:29:33.527 --> 03:29:35.029
DOLLARS ANNUALLY AND ONGOING
03:29:35.095 --> 03:29:36.263
EFFORTS TO CLEAN UP AND PREVENT
03:29:36.330 --> 03:29:37.031
LITTER.
03:29:37.097 --> 03:29:38.999
IN STREET STORM DRAINS PARKS AND
03:29:39.066 --> 03:29:40.067
WATER RATES.
03:29:40.134 --> 03:29:41.669
NOT ONLY IS THIS EXPENSIVE BUT
03:29:41.735 --> 03:29:42.770
IT CANNOT KEEP PACE WITH THE
03:29:42.836 --> 03:29:43.771
PRODUCTION OF SINGLE USE
03:29:43.837 --> 03:29:45.940
DISPOSABLE ITEMS WHICH CONTINUES
03:29:46.006 --> 03:29:47.141
TO GROW EXPONENTIALLY.
03:29:47.207 --> 03:29:48.509
NEITHER CAN EXISTING RECYCLING
03:29:48.575 --> 03:29:50.878
INFRASTRUCTURE WITH LESS THAN 9%
03:29:50.945 --> 03:29:52.413
OF PLASTIC HAVING BEEN RECYCLED
03:29:52.479 --> 03:29:54.048
AND THAT PERCENTAGE DROPPING
03:29:54.114 --> 03:29:55.215
SINCE THE IMPLEMENTATION OF
03:29:55.282 --> 03:29:56.951
POLICIES AND CHINA AND OTHER
03:29:57.017 --> 03:29:57.451
COUNTRIES.
03:29:57.518 --> 03:30:00.120
WHICH IS SEVERELY RESTRICTED THE
03:30:00.187 --> 03:30:00.688
AMOUNT OF FOREIGN WASTE THEY
03:30:00.754 --> 03:30:01.188
ACCEPT.
03:30:01.255 --> 03:30:02.523
COUNTLESS TINY BOTTLES OF
03:30:02.589 --> 03:30:04.024
SHAMPOO CONDITIONER LOTION AND
03:30:04.091 --> 03:30:05.326
OTHER PRODUCTS ARE THROWN AWAY
03:30:05.392 --> 03:30:06.627
EVERY DAY BY THE HOSPITALITY
03:30:06.694 --> 03:30:07.828
INDUSTRY.
03:30:07.895 --> 03:30:08.963
BECAUSE OF THE SIZE OF THESE
03:30:09.029 --> 03:30:10.497
BOTTLES THE CRASH OF A RECYCLING
03:30:10.564 --> 03:30:11.799
MARKET AND THE FACT THAT MOST
03:30:11.865 --> 03:30:13.968
ARE DISCARDED WITH SOME AMOUNT
03:30:14.034 --> 03:30:15.269
OF PRODUCT STILL IN THEM.
03:30:15.336 --> 03:30:16.603
THEY ARE NOT RECYCLABLE IN MOST
03:30:16.670 --> 03:30:18.305
COMMUNITIES MORE SUSTAINABLE
03:30:18.372 --> 03:30:19.873
METHODS LIKE WALL MOUNTED
03:30:19.940 --> 03:30:21.208
DISPENSERS TO PROVIDE GUESTS
03:30:21.275 --> 03:30:22.076
WITH THESE PERSONAL CARE
03:30:22.142 --> 03:30:23.377
PRODUCTS EXIST AND ARE BEING
03:30:23.444 --> 03:30:25.946
USED AS I'M SURE YOU'VE SEEN AS
03:30:26.013 --> 03:30:27.648
CAN HAS REFERRED.
03:30:27.715 --> 03:30:28.682
TO ALL COMMUNITIES SUCH AS SANTA
03:30:28.749 --> 03:30:29.984
CRUZ A MODERATE AREAS ARE
03:30:30.050 --> 03:30:31.485
ACTIVELY WORKING TO REMEDY THIS
03:30:31.552 --> 03:30:32.953
ISSUE ESTATE MIGHT MEASURE WILL
03:30:33.020 --> 03:30:34.922
ELIMINATE THE NEED FOR COMMUNITY
03:30:34.989 --> 03:30:36.457
BY COMMUNITY APPROACH.
03:30:36.523 --> 03:30:38.559
THUS WE EAT RESPECTFULLY URGE
03:30:38.625 --> 03:30:40.594
YOUR AYE VOTE ON THIS IMPORTANT
03:30:40.661 --> 03:30:43.097
MEASURE THANK YOU THANK YOU.
03:30:43.163 --> 03:30:44.365
ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT.
03:30:44.431 --> 03:30:45.532
IF YOU GIVE US YOUR NAME AND
03:30:45.599 --> 03:30:47.167
YOUR AFFILIATION PLACE.
03:30:47.234 --> 03:30:47.935
FLOOR COMMON BEHALF OF SIERRA
03:30:48.002 --> 03:30:49.436
CLUB CALIFORNIANS SUPPORT AND
03:30:49.503 --> 03:30:50.637
I'VE ALSO BEEN ASKED TO REGISTER
03:30:50.704 --> 03:30:53.240
SUPPORT FOR CALIFORNIA LEAGUE OF
03:30:53.307 --> 03:30:56.377
CONSERVATION VOTERS THANK YOU.
03:30:56.443 --> 03:30:57.945
KILLER ROBINSON ON BEHALF OF
03:30:58.012 --> 03:30:58.979
RETHINK WASTE IN SUPPORT THANK
03:30:59.046 --> 03:31:00.347
YOU THANK YOU ANYONE ELSE AND
03:31:00.414 --> 03:31:02.449
SUPPORTS.
03:31:02.516 --> 03:31:12.159
SEEING NONE IS THERE OPPOSITION
03:31:12.226 --> 03:31:12.459
[inaudible]
03:31:12.526 --> 03:31:21.235
YEAH.
03:31:21.301 --> 03:31:21.969
GOOD MORNING MISTER CHAIR JOHN
03:31:22.036 --> 03:31:23.037
CALLED ONE HALF THE CALIFORNIA
03:31:23.103 --> 03:31:25.639
HOTEL LODGING ASSOCIATION WE'RE
03:31:25.706 --> 03:31:27.141
WE'RE NOT OPPOSED TO WHAT THE
03:31:27.207 --> 03:31:28.208
WE'VE HAD DISCUSSIONS WITH THE
03:31:28.275 --> 03:31:29.610
AUTO WE'RE NOT OPPOSED TO WHAT
03:31:29.676 --> 03:31:31.378
THE AUTHOR IS TRYING TO DO --
03:31:31.445 --> 03:31:32.846
WAIT WE THINK WE HAVE SOME VERY
03:31:32.913 --> 03:31:34.715
REASONABLE AMENDMENTS THAT WE'VE
03:31:34.782 --> 03:31:35.983
TALKED HIM ABOUT FIRST -- OUR
03:31:36.050 --> 03:31:37.017
INDUSTRIES A LEADER IN
03:31:37.084 --> 03:31:38.218
SUSTAINABILITY IN HAS
03:31:38.285 --> 03:31:39.987
DEMONSTRATED A HAS BEEN TALKED
03:31:40.054 --> 03:31:42.122
ABOUT TANGIBLE COMMITMENT TO
03:31:42.189 --> 03:31:43.590
ENVIRONMENTAL STEWARDSHIP THE
03:31:43.657 --> 03:31:44.658
INTERNATIONAL.
03:31:44.725 --> 03:31:46.093
THE I. H. G. INTERNATIONAL
03:31:46.160 --> 03:31:47.694
CONTINENTAL HOTELS GROUP HAS
03:31:47.761 --> 03:31:49.296
RECEIVED THE HIGHEST SCORE FOR
03:31:49.363 --> 03:31:50.330
THE INDUSTRY.
03:31:50.397 --> 03:31:51.865
ON THE CORPORATE SUSTAINABILITY
03:31:51.932 --> 03:31:53.333
ASSESSMENT HILTON HAS REDUCE
03:31:53.400 --> 03:31:55.736
LANDFILL WASTE BY 41% ACROSS
03:31:55.803 --> 03:31:58.005
MANAGED HOTEL SINCE TWO THOUSAND
03:31:58.072 --> 03:31:58.939
EIGHT HI IT HAS COMMITTED TO
03:31:59.006 --> 03:32:01.108
DIVERTING 40% OF ITS WASTE.
03:32:01.175 --> 03:32:02.543
FROM LANDFILLS MARRIOTT
03:32:02.609 --> 03:32:04.011
INTERNATIONAL HAS SET A GOAL TO
03:32:04.078 --> 03:32:05.813
REDUCE ITS WAYS IT SOUNDS TO THE
03:32:05.879 --> 03:32:11.085
LANDFILLS BY. 45% BY.
03:32:11.151 --> 03:32:11.852
TWENTY TWENTY FIVE SO WE TAKEN
03:32:11.919 --> 03:32:12.453
RECOGNIZED IN INNOVATIVE STEPS
03:32:12.519 --> 03:32:13.053
TO CREATE A MORE SUSTAINABLE
03:32:13.120 --> 03:32:15.989
FUTURE WHICH IS WHY WE ASK.
03:32:16.056 --> 03:32:17.224
FOR THIS COMMITTEE THIS AUTHORED
03:32:17.291 --> 03:32:18.892
IS TO CONSIDER SOME AMENDMENTS
03:32:18.959 --> 03:32:19.827
TO HELP.
03:32:19.893 --> 03:32:21.495
AB ELEVEN SIXTY TWO MEN MELD
03:32:21.562 --> 03:32:23.664
WITH THESE EXISTING
03:32:23.730 --> 03:32:24.865
ENVIRONMENTAL INITIATIVES.
03:32:24.932 --> 03:32:26.433
WE RESPECTFULLY ASK THE SCOPE OF
03:32:26.500 --> 03:32:28.202
THE BILL BE LIMITED TO SHOWER OR
03:32:28.268 --> 03:32:29.736
BATH ACCESSORIES WHICH THE
03:32:29.803 --> 03:32:31.438
INDUSTRY HAS ALREADY BEGUN IN
03:32:31.505 --> 03:32:32.773
EARNEST OVER THE PAST DECADE.
03:32:32.840 --> 03:32:34.208
WITH SEVERAL HOTEL BRANDS
03:32:34.274 --> 03:32:35.609
ALREADY MOVING AWAY AS IT HAS
03:32:35.676 --> 03:32:37.744
BEEN DISCUSS FROM THE SINGLE YOU
03:32:37.811 --> 03:32:39.012
SHAMPOO CONDITIONER AND LIQUID
03:32:39.079 --> 03:32:40.414
SOAP.
03:32:40.481 --> 03:32:41.815
WE THINK -- THE DEFINITIONS AND
03:32:41.882 --> 03:32:44.084
MAKE MADE EXPAND MAY GO UP
03:32:44.151 --> 03:32:45.686
BEYOND THAT GROUP IN NATURAL
03:32:45.752 --> 03:32:48.021
RESOURCES COMMITTEE FOR EXAMPLE --
03:32:48.088 --> 03:32:49.957
THE CHAIR LAURA FRIEDMAN ASKED
03:32:50.023 --> 03:32:51.425
WHETHER MOUTHWASH WOULD BE
03:32:51.492 --> 03:32:53.293
COVERED TO FACE WILL BE COVERED
03:32:53.360 --> 03:32:55.362
YEAH AND THE WAY THE BILL'S
03:32:55.429 --> 03:32:56.096
WRITTEN TODAY PROBABLY YES.
03:32:56.163 --> 03:32:57.097
SO WE WOULD WE WOULD LIKE TO
03:32:57.164 --> 03:32:59.166
KNOW THAT -- SECONDLY THE BILL
03:32:59.233 --> 03:33:00.901
HAS TWO SECTIONS OF FOR
03:33:00.968 --> 03:33:02.769
ENFORCEMENT ONE SECTION WOULD
03:33:02.836 --> 03:33:04.438
HAVE THIS LAW ENFORCED BY CITY
03:33:04.505 --> 03:33:05.873
ATTORNEY COUNTY COUNCIL OR
03:33:05.939 --> 03:33:07.274
ATTORNEY GENERAL.
03:33:07.341 --> 03:33:08.709
WE'RE OKAY WITH THAT -- BUT THE
03:33:08.775 --> 03:33:09.843
BILL ALSO GIVES ENFORCEMENT
03:33:09.910 --> 03:33:12.346
AUTHORITY TO QUOTE A STATE OR
03:33:12.412 --> 03:33:14.815
LOCAL AGENCY WITH AUTHORITY TO
03:33:14.882 --> 03:33:15.916
INSPECT SLEEPING ACCOMMODATIONS.
03:33:15.983 --> 03:33:18.152
WE HAVE NO IDEA WHO THAT IS ON
03:33:18.218 --> 03:33:20.954
THE STATE LEVEL -- AND WITH FIVE
03:33:21.021 --> 03:33:22.356
HUNDRED CITIES IN FOR FIFTY
03:33:22.422 --> 03:33:23.257
EIGHT COUNTIES NOT CLEAR THAT'S
03:33:23.323 --> 03:33:24.892
GOING TO BE ON A LOCAL LEVEL WE
03:33:24.958 --> 03:33:26.326
THINK IT'S SEXUAL ONLY CAUSE
03:33:26.393 --> 03:33:29.062
CONFUSION WE SUGGEST A SECTION
03:33:29.129 --> 03:33:30.430
BE ELIMINATED IN THE ENFORCEMENT.
03:33:30.497 --> 03:33:32.266
IN THE BILL FOR THE CITY
03:33:32.332 --> 03:33:34.334
ATTORNEY THE COUNTY COUNCIL AND
03:33:34.401 --> 03:33:35.536
THE AGE YOU WERE REMAIN.
03:33:35.602 --> 03:33:37.404
WE HAVE ALSO ASKED FOR
03:33:37.471 --> 03:33:39.039
PREEMPTION OF LOW OF LOCAL
03:33:39.106 --> 03:33:41.742
ORDINANCES ENACTED AFTER THE
03:33:41.808 --> 03:33:43.110
PASSAGE OF THE BILL.
03:33:43.177 --> 03:33:44.111
NOT NOT SO WHAT WOULD NOT
03:33:44.178 --> 03:33:44.711
PREEMPT YEARS THAT THE SANTA
03:33:44.778 --> 03:33:46.947
CRUZ -- THE SANTA CRUZ ORDINANCE
03:33:47.014 --> 03:33:48.482
BUT WE DON'T WANT TO HAVE TO
03:33:48.549 --> 03:33:49.550
DEAL WITH THE NEW REQUIREMENTS
03:33:49.616 --> 03:33:51.118
ON A CITY CITY BY CITY BASIS
03:33:51.185 --> 03:33:52.452
AFTER THE INDUSTRY.
03:33:52.519 --> 03:33:53.320
HAS.
03:33:53.387 --> 03:33:55.255
COME UP WITH A DEAL HERE AND
03:33:55.322 --> 03:33:57.758
WE'VE PAID MILLIONS OF DOLLARS
03:33:57.824 --> 03:33:59.927
TO TO COMPLY WITH THE LAW -- AS
03:33:59.993 --> 03:34:01.461
A AS TALK ABOUT WE'VE REQUESTED
03:34:01.528 --> 03:34:02.462
A RIGHT TO CURE PROVISIONS
03:34:02.529 --> 03:34:04.565
SIMILAR TO WHAT'S REQUIRED IN
03:34:04.631 --> 03:34:05.165
THE HUMAN TRAFFICKING SIGNAGE
03:34:05.232 --> 03:34:07.634
LAW -- LASTLY WE REQUEST AN
03:34:07.701 --> 03:34:09.369
IMPLEMENTATION DATE OF JANUARY
03:34:09.436 --> 03:34:11.672
FIRST TWENTY TWENTY FIVE FOR ALL
03:34:11.738 --> 03:34:13.340
OF LODGING ESTABLISHMENTS WITH
03:34:13.407 --> 03:34:15.576
FIFTY ROOMS ARE MORE AND TWENTY
03:34:15.642 --> 03:34:16.109
TWENTY SIX FOR THE SMALLER
03:34:16.176 --> 03:34:17.110
ESTABLISHMENTS.
03:34:17.177 --> 03:34:18.879
THIS IS A LONGER THAN WHAT'S IN
03:34:18.946 --> 03:34:21.281
THE PRESS PRESENT BILL BUT OUR
03:34:21.348 --> 03:34:23.183
OUR OUR MEMBERS BELIEVE THAT
03:34:23.250 --> 03:34:24.685
IT'S GOING TO TAKE SOME TIME NOT
03:34:24.751 --> 03:34:25.986
ONLY.
03:34:26.053 --> 03:34:27.387
THE CONTRACTS THEYHAVE EXIST
03:34:27.454 --> 03:34:29.122
BUT MAKING THE TRANSITION BUT
03:34:29.189 --> 03:34:31.425
ALSO TRYING TO FIND OUT WHAT THE
03:34:31.491 --> 03:34:33.460
CONSUMER WANTS WHAT THE WHAT THE
03:34:33.527 --> 03:34:36.163
CONSUMER WANTS -- AGAIN WE'RE
03:34:36.230 --> 03:34:38.265
NOT TRYING TO YOU KNOW WE'RE NOT
03:34:38.332 --> 03:34:39.800
TRYING TO GET A WOOD GOT THIS
03:34:39.866 --> 03:34:40.701
BILL GOT THIS LAW WHAT WE'RE
03:34:40.767 --> 03:34:43.503
TRYING TO DO IS WORK WITH WORK
03:34:43.570 --> 03:34:44.972
WITH THE AUTHOR WAS SO WE CAN
03:34:45.038 --> 03:34:47.040
PHASES WE CAN PHASE THIS BILL IN
03:34:47.107 --> 03:34:48.508
IN A MANNER THAT WORKS WITH THE
03:34:48.575 --> 03:34:52.045
PUBLIC.
03:34:52.112 --> 03:34:53.647
AND WORKS WITH THE THE INDUSTRY
03:34:53.714 --> 03:34:53.947
[inaudible]
03:34:54.014 --> 03:34:56.450
THANK YOU.
03:34:56.516 --> 03:34:57.784
EXCEPT FOR THIS.
03:34:57.851 --> 03:34:58.318
GOOD MORNING MISTER CHAIR
03:34:58.385 --> 03:34:58.852
MANUALLY ON BEHALF OF THE
03:34:58.919 --> 03:34:59.486
PERSONAL CARE PRODUCTS COUNCIL A
03:34:59.553 --> 03:35:00.120
TRADE ASSOCIATION REPRESENTING
03:35:00.187 --> 03:35:01.288
ABOUT SIX HUNDRED SMALL MEDIUM
03:35:01.355 --> 03:35:03.223
LARGE COSMETIC AND PERSONAL CARE
03:35:03.290 --> 03:35:04.124
COMPANIES.
03:35:04.191 --> 03:35:05.325
MANY OF THEM LOCATED HERE IN
03:35:05.392 --> 03:35:06.927
CALIFORNIA WE ALSO HAVE TO
03:35:06.994 --> 03:35:08.729
REGISTER RESPECTFULLY ARE OPPOSE
03:35:08.795 --> 03:35:10.197
UNLESS AMENDED POSITION ON THIS
03:35:10.264 --> 03:35:12.499
BILL -- WE WOULD ALIGN OURSELVES
03:35:12.566 --> 03:35:14.101
WITH A SOME OF THE CONCERNS OF
03:35:14.167 --> 03:35:16.236
THE HOTEL INDUSTRY AS STATED --
03:35:16.303 --> 03:35:17.771
BEFORE I GO INTO THAT I ALSO
03:35:17.838 --> 03:35:19.373
THINK I SHOULD NOTE THAT OUR
03:35:19.439 --> 03:35:20.574
INDUSTRY TO IS TAKING THE ISSUE
03:35:20.641 --> 03:35:22.876
OF SUSTAINABILITY VERY SERIOUSLY.
03:35:22.943 --> 03:35:24.645
WE HAVE FORMED A THIRD PARTY
03:35:24.711 --> 03:35:26.346
COALITION GROUP -- CALLED THE
03:35:26.413 --> 03:35:28.615
SUSTAINABILITY -- IN PACKAGING
03:35:28.682 --> 03:35:30.484
IN BECAUSE MEDICS SPICE FOR
03:35:30.550 --> 03:35:31.852
SHORT.
03:35:31.918 --> 03:35:33.120
AND WE'RE LOOKING AT ISSUES
03:35:33.186 --> 03:35:34.855
AROUND RECYCLABILITY COMPOSED
03:35:34.921 --> 03:35:36.323
ABILITY AND EVEN -- BIODEGRADE
03:35:36.390 --> 03:35:38.191
ABILITY OF THE THE BOTTLES THAT
03:35:38.258 --> 03:35:39.326
WE ARE USING SO WE'RE TAKING
03:35:39.393 --> 03:35:41.395
THIS ISSUE VERY SERIOUSLY.
03:35:41.461 --> 03:35:43.130
THERE ARE ALSO TWO PENDING BILLS
03:35:43.196 --> 03:35:44.665
IN THE LEGISLATURE THAT LOOK AT
03:35:44.731 --> 03:35:46.266
THIS ISSUE MORE BROADLY --
03:35:46.333 --> 03:35:48.402
AROUND PACKAGING AND AND PRODUCT
03:35:48.468 --> 03:35:50.237
PACKAGING IN PARTICULAR -- IN
03:35:50.304 --> 03:35:51.638
THE CITY'S SUSTAINABILITY THERE
03:35:51.705 --> 03:35:54.508
OF AND WE ARE ACTIVELY AND
03:35:54.574 --> 03:35:56.176
CONVERSATIONS WITH THE BILL
03:35:56.243 --> 03:35:57.811
SPONSORS -- ON THOSE TWO
03:35:57.878 --> 03:36:00.280
MEASURES -- WHERE WE ALIGN WITH
03:36:00.347 --> 03:36:01.982
THE HOTEL INDUSTRY AND THEIR
03:36:02.049 --> 03:36:03.617
CONCERNS IS NUMBER ONE WE'D LIKE?
03:36:03.684 --> 03:36:05.052
TO INCREASE OR PUSHED OUT
03:36:05.118 --> 03:36:06.753
IMPLEMENTATION DATE AS WELL NOT
03:36:06.820 --> 03:36:08.522
ONLY WELL THAT AID SOME OF THE
03:36:08.588 --> 03:36:10.257
SMALLER HOTEL CHAINS BUT IT WILL
03:36:10.324 --> 03:36:11.858
ALSO HELP SOME OF THE SMALLER
03:36:11.925 --> 03:36:13.226
AND MEDIUM SIZED.
03:36:13.293 --> 03:36:14.995
COSMETIC COMPANIES -- THAT
03:36:15.062 --> 03:36:16.530
AREN'T AS NIMBLE OR DON'T HAVE
03:36:16.596 --> 03:36:17.798
AS MUCH RESOURCES AS SOME OF THE
03:36:17.864 --> 03:36:19.599
LRGER MULTINATIONAL
03:36:19.666 --> 03:36:20.967
CONGLOMERATES THAT HAVE SET VERY
03:36:21.034 --> 03:36:23.036
AGGRESSIVE DATES FOR RELATIVE TO
03:36:23.103 --> 03:36:24.738
SUSTAINABILITY -- WE LIKE TO
03:36:24.805 --> 03:36:26.673
GIVE THE SMALLER MEDIUM SIZE
03:36:26.740 --> 03:36:28.775
COMPANIES MORE TIME -- THE
03:36:28.842 --> 03:36:30.844
SECOND ISSUE IS WE ALSO ALIGNED
03:36:30.911 --> 03:36:32.245
WITH THE HOTEL INDUSTRY'S
03:36:32.312 --> 03:36:33.947
CONCERNS AROUND THE LIMITING THE
03:36:34.014 --> 03:36:35.682
SCOPE OF THE PRODUCTS WE WOULD
03:36:35.749 --> 03:36:37.617
LIKE TO SEE AND UNDERSTAND --
03:36:37.684 --> 03:36:39.219
WHAT THE THE SCOPE OF THE BILL
03:36:39.286 --> 03:36:41.755
IS BECAUSE RIGHT NOW IT'S -- SO
03:36:41.822 --> 03:36:44.958
CONDITIONER AT SHAMPOO LOTION
03:36:45.025 --> 03:36:46.293
BUT NOT LIMITED TO THOSE
03:36:46.360 --> 03:36:46.793
PRODUCTS WOULD LIKE TO
03:36:46.860 --> 03:36:47.794
UNDERSTAND.
03:36:47.861 --> 03:36:54.735
THE SCOPE AND THEN LASTLY --
03:36:54.801 --> 03:36:56.636
PERMISSION TO USE PROPS.
03:36:56.703 --> 03:37:00.107
YES -- THE THE BILL DEFINES THEY
03:37:00.173 --> 03:37:01.708
SMALL -- FOR PURPOSES OF BILL
03:37:01.775 --> 03:37:03.210
WHAT WHAT THE BILL WOULD BAN IS
03:37:03.276 --> 03:37:06.213
ANYTHING TWELVE OUNCES OR BELOW.
03:37:06.279 --> 03:37:07.314
AND WHEN WE LOOKED AT THE BILL
03:37:07.381 --> 03:37:08.281
WE ARE.
03:37:08.348 --> 03:37:09.850
NOT REALLY FAMILIAR WITH WHAT
03:37:09.916 --> 03:37:11.351
TWELVE OUNCES REALLY LOOKS LIKE
03:37:11.418 --> 03:37:13.587
HERE'S WHAT YOU'LL FIND IN MOST
03:37:13.653 --> 03:37:15.689
HOTELS WHICH IS ONE POINT TWO
03:37:15.756 --> 03:37:17.257
NOW ONE POINT TWO OUNCES.
03:37:17.324 --> 03:37:19.359
OR THERE ABOUTS AND THE BILL
03:37:19.426 --> 03:37:21.828
WOULD BAN -- PRODUCTS ANYTHING
03:37:21.895 --> 03:37:23.530
LESS THAN TWELVE LIEU ANSWERS OR
03:37:23.597 --> 03:37:24.564
BELOW.
03:37:24.631 --> 03:37:26.199
NOT MANY HOTELS ARE GIVING
03:37:26.266 --> 03:37:29.436
PATRONS THE SIZE OF A BOTTLE --
03:37:29.503 --> 03:37:30.437
WE WOULD LIKE TO SEE THE BILL
03:37:30.504 --> 03:37:31.438
MORE CLOSELY ALIGNED WITH THE
03:37:31.505 --> 03:37:32.672
PRODUCTS THAT ARE PROVIDED TO
03:37:32.739 --> 03:37:34.541
THE PATRONS WHICH IS AROUND ONE
03:37:34.608 --> 03:37:36.443
POINT TWO OUNCS -- WE FEEL MUCH
03:37:36.510 --> 03:37:37.978
MORE COMFORTABLE WITH THAT
03:37:38.044 --> 03:37:40.080
APPROACH -- WERE ALSO CONCERNED
03:37:40.147 --> 03:37:42.382
ABOUT THE BILLS -- POTENTIAL TO
03:37:42.449 --> 03:37:45.051
BAND THE HOTEL LOBBIES OR THAT
03:37:45.118 --> 03:37:46.453
THE GIFT SHOPS FROM SELLING
03:37:46.520 --> 03:37:49.923
PRODUCTS WHICH THEY OFTEN DO SO
03:37:49.990 --> 03:37:53.894
WITH THOSE A CLOSE MY COMMENTS.
03:37:53.960 --> 03:37:54.761
THANK YOU.
03:37:54.828 --> 03:37:55.862
ANYONE ELSE IN OPPOSITION
03:37:55.929 --> 03:37:56.396
BECAUSE YOUR NAME AND YOUR
03:37:56.463 --> 03:37:57.998
AFFILIATION THANK YOU MISTER
03:37:58.064 --> 03:37:58.899
CHAIRMAN FIRST ON CAP KHIMIK YOU
03:37:58.965 --> 03:37:59.766
KEPT CAN ASSOCIATES ON BEHALF
03:37:59.833 --> 03:38:00.567
THE CALIFORNIA MANUFACTURERS AND
03:38:00.634 --> 03:38:01.835
TECHNOLOGY ASSOCIATION WE
03:38:01.902 --> 03:38:03.370
APOLOGIZE FOR THE LATE NOTICE --
03:38:03.437 --> 03:38:04.738
BUT WE ALIGN OUR COMMENTS IN
03:38:04.805 --> 03:38:06.473
OPPOSED UNLESS AMENDED POSITION
03:38:06.540 --> 03:38:11.812
OUT WITH THE PERSON THANK YOU.
03:38:11.878 --> 03:38:12.379
WHEN CHAIR AT A REGULAR ON
03:38:12.446 --> 03:38:13.013
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA CHAMBER
03:38:13.079 --> 03:38:14.014
OF COMMERCE WE ALSO ALIGN OUR
03:38:14.080 --> 03:38:15.715
COMMENTS WE HAVE AN OPPOSE
03:38:15.782 --> 03:38:18.718
UNLESS AMENDED POSITION THANKS?
03:38:18.785 --> 03:38:19.920
HELLO AFFECT WORKERS FOR THE
03:38:19.986 --> 03:38:21.121
SEMINAL BAND OF MISSION INDIANS
03:38:21.188 --> 03:38:23.657
THE TRIBE HAS -- TO OFF SITE --
03:38:23.723 --> 03:38:26.460
OFF RESERVATION HOTELS WOULD BE
03:38:26.526 --> 03:38:29.696
AFFECTED AND WORKING WITH THE
03:38:29.763 --> 03:38:31.898
HOW THE AUTHOR HAS STAFF NOW
03:38:31.965 --> 03:38:33.934
WHEN WE HONOR OUR QUESTION
03:38:34.000 --> 03:38:36.002
AMENDMENTS OF THOSE OF THE
03:38:36.069 --> 03:38:37.103
INDUSTRY THANK YOU.
03:38:37.170 --> 03:38:37.604
THANK YOU ANYONE ELSE IN
03:38:37.671 --> 03:38:39.206
OPPOSITION.
03:38:39.272 --> 03:38:40.440
ALL RIGHT SEE NONE THE BRING IT
03:38:40.507 --> 03:38:42.242
BACK QUESTIONS COMMENTS WAS
03:38:42.309 --> 03:38:43.410
YOUNGER.
03:38:43.477 --> 03:38:44.611
YEAH SO I GUESS WHAT I'M
03:38:44.678 --> 03:38:45.512
THINKING ABOUT HERE'S LIKE WHY
03:38:45.579 --> 03:38:46.680
DO WE NEED A BAND EXACTLY RIGHT
03:38:46.746 --> 03:38:48.081
I MEAN. ONE I'M JUST NOT A BIG
03:38:48.148 --> 03:38:50.150
FAN OF OF BANDS -- AND YEAH I
03:38:50.217 --> 03:38:51.518
LIKE THESE THINGS MAN I I
03:38:51.585 --> 03:38:53.286
COLLECT THESE STUFF IN THE HOTEL
03:38:53.353 --> 03:38:54.654
ROOM TO BRING THEM HOME.
03:38:54.721 --> 03:38:55.922
AND IT SEEMS TO ME AND THIS IS
03:38:55.989 --> 03:38:58.625
JUST MY SUBJECTIVE OBVIOUS THI
03:38:58.692 --> 03:39:00.794
IS LIKE AN EASIER THING TO
03:39:00.861 --> 03:39:02.095
RECYCLE RIGHT LIKE.
03:39:02.162 --> 03:39:03.897
IS THIS YOU KNOW TO ME IT'S LIKE
03:39:03.964 --> 03:39:04.865
THAT'S THE THAT'S ONE OF THE
03:39:04.931 --> 03:39:05.665
FIRST THINGS I WOULD TO ALONG
03:39:05.732 --> 03:39:08.468
WITH MY MILK JUGS INTO THE BLUE
03:39:08.535 --> 03:39:10.570
RECYCLE BIN YOU KNOW -- BUT
03:39:10.637 --> 03:39:11.938
THAT'S JUST ME RIGHT I MEAN SO
03:39:12.005 --> 03:39:13.540
IS THERE SOME DATA OUT THERE AND
03:39:13.607 --> 03:39:14.641
MAYBE YOU ALREADY TALKED ABOUT
03:39:14.708 --> 03:39:16.076
THIS IT SHOWS THAT.
03:39:16.142 --> 03:39:18.078
THESE ARE JUST NOT RECYCLED AT
03:39:18.144 --> 03:39:19.980
ALL THAT I MEAN WHAT WHAT IS
03:39:20.046 --> 03:39:24.384
THAT DATE AND MAYBE YOU CAN JUST.
03:39:24.451 --> 03:39:26.953
LAY THAT OUT FOR THE AND FEEL
03:39:27.020 --> 03:39:27.554
FREE TO FOLLOW UP.
03:39:27.621 --> 03:39:28.355
MY EXPERT TESTIMONY BUT A ONE OF
03:39:28.421 --> 03:39:30.123
THE ISSUES IS THE CONTAMINATION --
03:39:30.190 --> 03:39:34.861
ISSUE -- THE INFO.
03:39:34.928 --> 03:39:37.297
MY UNDERSTANDING OF ACTUALLY
03:39:37.364 --> 03:39:38.298
FROM MY CITY COUNCIL DAYS THAT
03:39:38.365 --> 03:39:38.899
THERE'S A LOT ISSUE A
03:39:38.965 --> 03:39:41.601
CONTAMINATION RECYCLES CYCLES
03:39:41.668 --> 03:39:43.003
THAT FEDERAL BEING RECYCLABLE --
03:39:43.069 --> 03:39:45.138
AND ALSO SIZE THE THE SMALLER
03:39:45.205 --> 03:39:45.772
THE ITEMS LESS LIKELY THEY ARE
03:39:45.839 --> 03:39:47.474
TO BE -- ARE TO BE RECYCLED I
03:39:47.541 --> 03:39:49.276
DON'T KNOW IF WE HAVE EXACTED ON
03:39:49.342 --> 03:39:50.277
BOTTLES ITSELF HOWEVER I WILL
03:39:50.343 --> 03:39:51.011
SAY.
03:39:51.077 --> 03:39:52.712
THAT THE OWNERS THIS BILL CAME
03:39:52.779 --> 03:39:55.482
FROM -- INFORMATION HEARING THAT
03:39:55.549 --> 03:39:57.350
MR SHARE A HELD IN SANTA CRUZ
03:39:57.417 --> 03:39:58.885
AND THERE WAS A PRESENTATION
03:39:58.952 --> 03:40:01.821
THAT DID -- AND I'D BE HAPPY.
03:40:01.888 --> 03:40:03.423
TO FOLLOW UP AND AND GET SOME OF
03:40:03.490 --> 03:40:05.191
THE REPORTS THAT -- MIGHT LEAD
03:40:05.258 --> 03:40:05.725
TO THIS BEING ONE OF THE
03:40:05.792 --> 03:40:07.427
SUGGESTIONS TO REDUCE PLASTIC
03:40:07.494 --> 03:40:09.095
WASTE THAT MAY HAVE MORE DATA OR
03:40:09.162 --> 03:40:11.932
MORE POTENTIAL INFORMATION AS TO
03:40:11.998 --> 03:40:12.632
THE SCOPE OF THE ISSUE.
03:40:12.699 --> 03:40:14.234
BY NO CONTAMINATION IS A BIG
03:40:14.301 --> 03:40:15.869
PART OF IT AS WELL AS THE SIZE
03:40:15.936 --> 03:40:22.008
THAT LEADS TO A LOWER LIKELIHOOD
03:40:22.075 --> 03:40:23.677
OF IT BEING RECYCLED.
03:40:23.743 --> 03:40:25.278
I'LL JUST ADD THAT ARE RECYCLING
03:40:25.345 --> 03:40:27.047
MARKET IS IS CRASHING I MEAN
03:40:27.113 --> 03:40:28.148
WE'RE IN A CRISIS ONLY NUMBER
03:40:28.214 --> 03:40:29.049
ONE TO NUMBER TWOS OR IF THERE'S
03:40:29.115 --> 03:40:31.618
A MARKET -- FOR AND SO BECAUSE
03:40:31.685 --> 03:40:33.653
OF THAT WHAT'S GOING ON WITH
03:40:33.720 --> 03:40:34.554
CHINA RIGHT NOW YEAH YEAH.
03:40:34.621 --> 03:40:38.024
SO A LOT OF A LOT OF THESE ITEMS --
03:40:38.091 --> 03:40:39.793
ESPECIALLY THE ONE OF THE
03:40:39.859 --> 03:40:41.227
EXAMPLES THAT WAS SHOWN EIGHT
03:40:41.294 --> 03:40:43.063
DON'T BELIEVE IS A ONE OR TWO SO
03:40:43.129 --> 03:40:44.197
IF YOU BUT THEN YOU RECYCLE BIN.
03:40:44.264 --> 03:40:45.131
IT'S JUST GOING TO CONTAMINATE
03:40:45.198 --> 03:40:46.433
RECYCLING IN EITHER GO TO
03:40:46.499 --> 03:40:49.402
LANDFILL -- BUILD UP IN IN THE
03:40:49.469 --> 03:40:51.037
RECYCLING CENTERS I ALSO HAVE
03:40:51.104 --> 03:40:52.472
THE TWINS YOU KNOW SO I I USE A
03:40:52.539 --> 03:40:57.911
LOT OF WIPES AND SO YOU KNOW WE
03:40:57.978 --> 03:40:58.411
HAD THAT PREVIOUS BILL.
03:40:58.478 --> 03:40:59.980
ANYWAY.
03:41:00.046 --> 03:41:00.880
IT WAS -- SO AND THEN IT SOUNDS
03:41:00.947 --> 03:41:01.648
LIKE THE INDUSTRY'S MOVING AWAY
03:41:01.715 --> 03:41:02.282
FROM THIS RIGHT LIKE IT SOUNDS
03:41:02.349 --> 03:41:03.149
LIKE A LOT OF PEOPLE ARE
03:41:03.216 --> 03:41:04.718
ACTUALLY MOVING AWAY ALREADY.
03:41:04.784 --> 03:41:06.553
SO IF THEY'RE ALREADY KIND OF
03:41:06.620 --> 03:41:08.154
MOVE IN THAT DIRECTION.
03:41:08.221 --> 03:41:10.490
YEAH I MEAN DO WE AGAIN WE NEED.
03:41:10.557 --> 03:41:12.225
AN ALL OUT BAN WELL I THINK THAT
03:41:12.292 --> 03:41:13.093
THAT YOU KNOW THE ARGUMENT
03:41:13.159 --> 03:41:14.427
BEFORE BY THE WAY IF THE IF
03:41:14.494 --> 03:41:16.329
INDUSTRY WASN'T AND WE ARE
03:41:16.396 --> 03:41:17.530
PUTTING THIS IN PLACE THE
03:41:17.597 --> 03:41:18.531
ARGUMENT WOULD BE WHILE YOU'RE
03:41:18.598 --> 03:41:19.966
ENFORCING SOMETHING THAT.
03:41:20.033 --> 03:41:21.835
WE DON'T WANT TO DO I THINK THAT
03:41:21.901 --> 03:41:24.304
IT'S A IT SHOULD BE.
03:41:24.371 --> 03:41:25.405
GOT MORE GREATLY APPRECIATED
03:41:25.472 --> 03:41:27.240
THAT A BILL COMES FOR THAT'S
03:41:27.307 --> 03:41:28.541
ACTUALLY ENCOURAGING THE CONTACT
03:41:28.608 --> 03:41:29.743
THAT'S ALREADY OCCURRING IN THE
03:41:29.809 --> 03:41:31.378
TRENDS THAT ARE OCCURRING.
03:41:31.444 --> 03:41:33.313
BY MAKING IT A STATEWIDE POLICY
03:41:33.380 --> 03:41:34.514
RATHER THAN HAVING JURISDICTIONS
03:41:34.581 --> 03:41:36.916
DO IT ONE BY ONE WHICH WHICH IS
03:41:36.983 --> 03:41:37.817
ONE OF THE ISSUES THAT WE
03:41:37.884 --> 03:41:38.652
DISCUSSED THEY DISCUSSED MISSED
03:41:38.718 --> 03:41:40.587
CALL OTHER DAY.
03:41:40.654 --> 03:41:44.691
YESTERDAY -- OR RATHER THAN --
03:41:44.758 --> 03:41:46.459
OF HAVING A DIFFERENT SET OF
03:41:46.526 --> 03:41:48.762
PROTOCOLS WHAT YOU DO IS YOU
03:41:48.828 --> 03:41:49.963
SIMPLY IS OKAY YOU'RE MOVING
03:41:50.030 --> 03:41:50.764
INSTRUCTION ANYWAY.
03:41:50.830 --> 03:41:52.232
LET'S MOVE FORWARD IT ALLOWS
03:41:52.298 --> 03:41:54.567
INDUSTRY -- ORGANIZATIONS TO
03:41:54.634 --> 03:41:56.236
HELP FACILITATE THE TRANSITION --
03:41:56.302 --> 03:41:58.805
ESPECIALLY FOR SMALLER HOTELS I
03:41:58.872 --> 03:41:59.773
HAD ALLOWS LARGER SHOULD HOTELS
03:41:59.839 --> 03:42:02.075
TO SET AN EXPECTATION AS TO HOW
03:42:02.142 --> 03:42:03.076
THEY'RE GONNA HAVE THEIR SUPPLY
03:42:03.143 --> 03:42:04.511
CHAIN SET UP -- BUT THE BOTTOM
03:42:04.577 --> 03:42:07.247
LINE IS THAT WE HAVE TO DO MORE.
03:42:07.313 --> 03:42:08.948
TO A LIMITED AMOUNT OF CLASSES
03:42:09.015 --> 03:42:10.550
COMING IN OF PEOPLE BEING
03:42:10.617 --> 03:42:12.285
PRODUCED AN ENTRY ALWAYS STREAM
03:42:12.352 --> 03:42:14.587
AND THIS IS JUST ONE OF MANY
03:42:14.654 --> 03:42:16.389
THINGS WE NEED TO DO -- IT'S
03:42:16.456 --> 03:42:19.159
ALIGNED WITH OTHER EFFORTS TO A
03:42:19.225 --> 03:42:20.160
TO MOVE AWAY FROM SEEN THESE
03:42:20.226 --> 03:42:21.594
PLASTIC IN OUR STATE THAT I KNOW
03:42:21.661 --> 03:42:22.462
THAT WHEN BURKE MANY MEMBERS
03:42:22.529 --> 03:42:23.329
BECAUSE ALSO OTHERS.
03:42:23.396 --> 03:42:25.765
ARE WORKING ON AND BUT YOU CAN
03:42:25.832 --> 03:42:26.833
HAVE THAT GOAL BUT YOU HAVE TO
03:42:26.900 --> 03:42:29.035
HAVE ACTUALLY MORE SPECIFIC
03:42:29.102 --> 03:42:30.136
INITIATIVES TO ACTUALLY MOVE
03:42:30.203 --> 03:42:31.304
TOWARDS THAT GOAL.
03:42:31.371 --> 03:42:33.073
AND SO THIS IS AGAIN IT'S A
03:42:33.139 --> 03:42:34.607
PUBLIC POLICY.
03:42:34.674 --> 03:42:35.909
DEBATE AS TO WHETHER IT'S
03:42:35.975 --> 03:42:45.652
VALUABLE FOR US TO GET RID OF
03:42:45.719 --> 03:42:47.253
THESE SINGLE USE PLASTIC BOTTLES.
03:42:47.320 --> 03:42:48.888
TOILETRIES AND I JUST THINK THE
03:42:48.955 --> 03:42:49.856
FACT INDUSTRIES ALREADY MOVING
03:42:49.923 --> 03:42:52.559
THAT DIRECTION HOST OF ASSAULTED
03:42:52.625 --> 03:42:53.193
AND MAKES IT MORE VIBRANT WHY WE
03:42:53.259 --> 03:42:55.228
SHOULD DO IT.
03:42:55.295 --> 03:42:56.963
WITHOUT -- I WENT THANK YOU FOR
03:42:57.030 --> 03:42:58.264
THE BELL A AT THERE'S THE
03:42:58.331 --> 03:43:00.533
PERSONAL SIDE OF ME DOESN'T WANT
03:43:00.600 --> 03:43:01.468
HI LITTLE.
03:43:01.534 --> 03:43:04.104
BOTTLES TAKEN BECAUSE I REALLY
03:43:04.170 --> 03:43:07.107
LIKE TO TAKE THEM HOME --
03:43:07.173 --> 03:43:08.308
CULTURAL.
03:43:08.374 --> 03:43:13.480
WE DON'T WASTE -- BUT BILLIONS
03:43:13.546 --> 03:43:15.281
OF WASTE IN THE SEVEN I'M
03:43:15.348 --> 03:43:17.350
TALKING ABOUT AT SO BUT I AM BUT
03:43:17.417 --> 03:43:18.118
I UNDERSTAND I MEAN THAT'S
03:43:18.184 --> 03:43:19.018
PERSON I KNOW 91% OF PLASTICS
03:43:19.085 --> 03:43:19.753
THAT WE PRODUCE DON'T GET
03:43:19.819 --> 03:43:21.121
RECYCLED AND SO WE WOULD THAT WE
03:43:21.187 --> 03:43:22.956
HAVE KIND OF A AT I NEED TO DO
03:43:23.022 --> 03:43:23.723
SOMETHING.
03:43:23.790 --> 03:43:25.391
I DO HAVE A QUESTION ABOUT LIKE --
03:43:25.458 --> 03:43:26.960
THE REQUEST LIKE AT THE FRONT
03:43:27.026 --> 03:43:28.595
DESK IF YOU FORGET TO PASTE MORE
03:43:28.661 --> 03:43:30.764
THAT WILL BE AVAILABLE AND ABLE
03:43:30.830 --> 03:43:31.664
TO BE GIVEN TO YOU IN A SMALL
03:43:31.731 --> 03:43:33.633
SIZE SO THAT WILL STILL BE
03:43:33.700 --> 03:43:35.869
AVAILABLE AS WELL AS THE THE HAS
03:43:35.935 --> 03:43:37.971
SHOPS THERE IN THE LOBBIES.
03:43:38.037 --> 03:43:39.005
THAT SELL SMALL SIZE PRODUCTS
03:43:39.072 --> 03:43:40.106
WILL ALSO STILL BE A BE
03:43:40.173 --> 03:43:44.077
AVAILABLE THIS IS JUST IN THE IN
03:43:44.144 --> 03:43:45.912
COMBINATION WITH ITSELF.
03:43:45.979 --> 03:43:46.913
OKAY -- IN THIS IS JUST HOTELS
03:43:46.980 --> 03:43:48.414
NOT SPAS.
03:43:48.481 --> 03:43:50.316
THIS IS A OF A LODGING YES
03:43:50.383 --> 03:43:51.818
THAT'S CORRECT Là LODGING
03:43:51.885 --> 03:43:52.652
ESTABLISHMENTS PLEDGE MISTER
03:43:52.719 --> 03:43:54.220
THAT'S CORRECT THANK YOU I I'M
03:43:54.287 --> 03:43:54.854
OF THE BILL IF IT HAS BEEN MOVED
03:43:54.921 --> 03:43:57.390
IT HAS NOT BEEN MOVE THAT IS A
03:43:57.457 --> 03:43:59.659
MOTION TO HAVE A SECOND.
03:43:59.726 --> 03:44:00.460
THANK YOU WE DO HAVE A MOTION
03:44:00.527 --> 03:44:02.695
AND A SECOND.
03:44:02.762 --> 03:44:05.064
RIGHT OTHER QUESTIONS COMMENTS.
03:44:05.131 --> 03:44:06.065
SEEING NONE MISTER CARR YOU MAY
03:44:06.132 --> 03:44:07.100
CLOSE THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR AND
03:44:07.167 --> 03:44:08.835
JUST RESPOND -- AND I I DO WANT
03:44:08.902 --> 03:44:11.504
TO THANK OPPOSITION I THINK THAT
03:44:11.571 --> 03:44:13.239
THE AGAIN BOTH WITH OVER THERE
03:44:13.306 --> 03:44:14.440
IS THE PERSONAL CARE INDUSTRY OR
03:44:14.507 --> 03:44:15.375
THE LODGING INDUSTRY.
03:44:15.441 --> 03:44:16.342
OTHER BOTH MOVING IN THAT
03:44:16.409 --> 03:44:18.144
DIRECTION AND IN THE IN THE
03:44:18.211 --> 03:44:18.778
RIGHT DIRECTION AS FAR AS WERE
03:44:18.845 --> 03:44:21.614
CONCERNED -- SPECIFICALLY -- IN
03:44:21.681 --> 03:44:23.283
TERMS OF CLARA FIND DEFINITIONS
03:44:23.349 --> 03:44:23.817
AND I HAD A REALLY GOOD
03:44:23.883 --> 03:44:25.552
CONVERSATION YESTERDAY THIS CALL
03:44:25.618 --> 03:44:26.152
WELL ABOUT IT WE'RE GOING TO
03:44:26.219 --> 03:44:27.187
CONTINUE TO HAVE CONVERSATIONS
03:44:27.253 --> 03:44:28.955
BUT I DO AGREE I THINK WE NEED
03:44:29.022 --> 03:44:30.824
TO HAVE GREATER CLARIFICATION.
03:44:30.890 --> 03:44:32.258
AS TO BOTH OF THE WITNESSES ARE
03:44:32.325 --> 03:44:34.027
CONCERNS AND WE WILL CONTINUE TO
03:44:34.093 --> 03:44:35.495
WORK ON THAT TO HAVE A MORE
03:44:35.562 --> 03:44:37.864
CLARITY IN TERMS DEFINITIONS --
03:44:37.931 --> 03:44:39.566
WE ADDED SOME ADDITIONAL
03:44:39.632 --> 03:44:41.301
LANGUAGE I THINK THE ADDED SOME
03:44:41.367 --> 03:44:42.969
CLARITY IN ONE REGARD BUT
03:44:43.036 --> 03:44:44.437
CRITICS ON CONFUSION OTHER SUB
03:44:44.504 --> 03:44:45.405
GOING TO CONTINUE TO WORK ON
03:44:45.471 --> 03:44:46.105
THAT.
03:44:46.172 --> 03:44:55.682
AND IN TERMS OF THE THE ISSUE OF
03:44:55.748 --> 03:44:57.617
LOCAL VERSES OTHER ENFORCEMENT
03:44:57.684 --> 03:44:58.918
THE REASON WHY WE HAVE THE LOCAL --
03:44:58.985 --> 03:45:00.753
WHETHER IT'S COUNTY PUBLIC CALL
03:45:00.820 --> 03:45:01.654
FOR OF LOCAL CULTURES IS -- THE
03:45:01.721 --> 03:45:02.322
REALITY IS PRAGMATICALLY THEY'RE
03:45:02.388 --> 03:45:04.023
THE ONES ARE MORE LIKELY THEY'RE
03:45:04.090 --> 03:45:04.824
GOING TO BE ABLE.
03:45:04.891 --> 03:45:07.126
TO SEE AND IDENTIFY THE FACT
03:45:07.193 --> 03:45:08.761
THAT A HOTEL -- MAY NOT BE
03:45:08.828 --> 03:45:10.864
COMPLYING AND LET'S KEEP IN MIND
03:45:10.930 --> 03:45:12.632
THAT IN THAT CASE THE FIRST
03:45:12.699 --> 03:45:14.567
VIOLATIONS A WARNING LETTER SO
03:45:14.634 --> 03:45:15.435
IT WE'RE NOT INTENDED TO BE
03:45:15.501 --> 03:45:15.969
PUNITIVE.
03:45:16.035 --> 03:45:17.904
IT IN THAT REGARD WE JUST WANT
03:45:17.971 --> 03:45:19.205
TO MAKE SURE THAT ONCE THE AND
03:45:19.272 --> 03:45:21.140
THE ISSUES IDENTIFIED THAT IT
03:45:21.207 --> 03:45:22.508
COULD BE RECTIFIED IN A WAY THAT.
03:45:22.575 --> 03:45:24.277
THAT'S AS EFFICIENT AS POSSIBLE
03:45:24.344 --> 03:45:26.412
AND AGAIN THE AMENDMENTS THAT
03:45:26.479 --> 03:45:27.080
WE'VE ADDED AND WILL CONTINUE TO
03:45:27.146 --> 03:45:30.250
ADD -- EXTEND THE TIMELINE TO
03:45:30.316 --> 03:45:32.785
THREE YEARS AND WORK WE'VE UP IN --
03:45:32.852 --> 03:45:34.287
ON THE RECORD HERE ARE IN
03:45:34.354 --> 03:45:36.189
AGREEMENT THAT WILL EXTEND INTO
03:45:36.256 --> 03:45:36.656
FOUR YEARS FOR SMALLER
03:45:36.723 --> 03:45:37.957
ESTABLISHMENTS AND WE THINK
03:45:38.024 --> 03:45:39.993
THAT'LL BE SOMETHING THAT I WILL
03:45:40.059 --> 03:45:40.560
GET PLENTY OF TIME FOR THAT
03:45:40.627 --> 03:45:41.561
ADJUSTMENT.
03:45:41.628 --> 03:45:43.129
AND IN TERMS OF PREEMPTION THIS
03:45:43.196 --> 03:45:44.397
IS AN ISSUE THAT WAS FIRST AT
03:45:44.464 --> 03:45:45.531
LEAST IN DIALOGUE BROUGHT UP
03:45:45.598 --> 03:45:46.766
YESTERDAY BUT WE HAD A VERY GOOD
03:45:46.833 --> 03:45:48.368
CONVERSATION ON THAT I THINK
03:45:48.434 --> 03:45:49.669
COULD BE SOMETHING THAT -- WE
03:45:49.736 --> 03:45:51.070
COULD WORK ON IN TERMS TO MAKE
03:45:51.137 --> 03:45:52.071
IT EASIER FOR LOCAL
03:45:52.138 --> 03:45:52.839
JURISDICTIONS NOT HAVE TO GO
03:45:52.906 --> 03:45:54.774
THROUGH THE PROCESS OF NOT
03:45:54.841 --> 03:45:55.842
HAVING LOCAL ORDINANCES IF WE
03:45:55.909 --> 03:45:56.943
COME TO AN AGREEMENT THAT WE
03:45:57.010 --> 03:45:58.077
BELIEVE MAKE SENSE.
03:45:58.144 --> 03:45:59.512
THAT -- THERE COULD BE AN
03:45:59.579 --> 03:46:00.480
OPPORTUNITY TO CONTINUE TO TALK
03:46:00.546 --> 03:46:02.282
ABOUT LOCAL PREEMPTION BUT AGAIN
03:46:02.348 --> 03:46:02.849
I REALLY WANT TO THANK THE
03:46:02.916 --> 03:46:04.384
OPPOSITION THAT WE GOT A LOT OF
03:46:04.450 --> 03:46:05.485
DIALOGUE.
03:46:05.551 --> 03:46:07.020
THE ENTIRE PROCESS AND I WANT TO
03:46:07.086 --> 03:46:09.455
REMIND FOLKS THAT EVEN IN BEFORE
03:46:09.522 --> 03:46:10.123
THIS BILL IS EITHER INTRODUCED I
03:46:10.189 --> 03:46:11.557
SAT WITH THE HOTEL LODGING
03:46:11.624 --> 03:46:12.959
ASSOCIATION TO DISCUSS IT
03:46:13.026 --> 03:46:14.193
BECAUSE I UNDERSTAND THAT THIS
03:46:14.260 --> 03:46:15.228
NEEDS TO BE A COLLABORATIVE
03:46:15.295 --> 03:46:16.129
EFFORT AS MUCH AS POSSIBLE AND
03:46:16.195 --> 03:46:16.629
SO.
03:46:16.696 --> 03:46:18.831
I DO APPRECIATE OPPOSITION WITH
03:46:18.898 --> 03:46:21.367
THAT ASK FOR AND I'M UP AND WHEN
03:46:21.434 --> 03:46:22.835
I BUILT THANK YOU WE DO HAVE A
03:46:22.902 --> 03:46:23.636
MOTION A SECOND THE MOTION IS TO
03:46:23.703 --> 03:46:24.971
PASS TO APPROPRIATIONS CALL THE
03:46:25.038 --> 03:46:26.940
ROLL PLEASE STONE BY STONE AYE
03:46:27.006 --> 03:46:28.141
GALLAGHER.
03:46:28.207 --> 03:46:37.417
GALLAGHER NO CHAO CHIU.
03:46:37.483 --> 03:46:39.218
GONZALEZ.
03:46:39.285 --> 03:46:40.586
GONZALEZ I HOLDEN.
03:46:40.653 --> 03:46:42.522
HOLDEN AYE KALRA AYE KALRA AYE
03:46:42.588 --> 03:46:43.690
KILEY MAIENSCHEIN.
03:46:43.756 --> 03:46:45.391
MAINTAIN AYE OBERNOLTE OBERNOLTE
03:46:45.458 --> 03:46:46.926
NO PETRIE-NORRIS.
03:46:46.993 --> 03:46:48.795
PETRIE-NORRIS I REYES.
03:46:48.861 --> 03:46:52.832
REYES I THE BILL IS OUT THANK
03:46:52.899 --> 03:46:55.969
YOU.
03:46:56.035 --> 03:46:56.602
ALL RIGHTS -- THIS TAKES US TO
03:46:56.669 --> 03:46:57.537
ITEM NUMBER TWELVE A. B.
03:46:57.603 --> 03:47:11.918
THIRTEEN THIRTY TWO MISTER BONTA.
03:47:11.985 --> 03:47:13.319
GOOD MORNING MORNING THANK YOU
03:47:13.386 --> 03:47:14.220
MISTER CHAIR THANK YOU
03:47:14.287 --> 03:47:15.221
COLLEAGUES AND STAFF THE
03:47:15.288 --> 03:47:18.524
OPPORTUNITY TO PRESENT A. B..
03:47:18.591 --> 03:47:19.359
THIRTEEN THIRTY TWO WHICH IS A
03:47:19.425 --> 03:47:21.828
POLICY THAT STANDS UP FOR AND
03:47:21.894 --> 03:47:23.162
DEFENDS AND PROTECTS OUR
03:47:23.229 --> 03:47:24.697
IMMIGRANTS HERE IN CALIFORNIA
03:47:24.764 --> 03:47:26.399
CONSISTENT WITH SB FIFTY FOUR
03:47:26.466 --> 03:47:27.633
ARE SANCTUARY STATE ACT.
03:47:27.700 --> 03:47:29.936
FROM A COUPLE YEARS AGO WHEN IT
03:47:30.003 --> 03:47:31.537
BASICALLY SAYS THAT.
03:47:31.604 --> 03:47:33.506
NO CITY OR COUNTY OR STATE
03:47:33.573 --> 03:47:36.376
JURISDICTION SHALL DO.
03:47:36.442 --> 03:47:38.111
SO HAVE A CONTRACT TO DO
03:47:38.177 --> 03:47:40.446
BUSINESS WITH A A COMPANY.
03:47:40.513 --> 03:47:41.514
THAT.
03:47:41.581 --> 03:47:43.916
ENGAGES IN DATA BROKE GREEN OR
03:47:43.983 --> 03:47:45.351
EXTREME VETTING OR TO DENT
03:47:45.418 --> 03:47:47.620
DETENTION FACILITY SUPPORT THAT
03:47:47.687 --> 03:47:49.155
LEADS TO THE DEPORTATION.
03:47:49.222 --> 03:47:52.625
OR DETENTION OF OUR FELLOW
03:47:52.692 --> 03:47:56.029
CALIFORNIANS AND THE COMPANIES.
03:47:56.095 --> 03:47:57.864
CAN MAKE A DECISION AND AND NOT
03:47:57.930 --> 03:47:59.932
SHARE DATA.
03:47:59.999 --> 03:48:01.901
IN ASSIST ARM ICE OR THE
03:48:01.968 --> 03:48:03.136
CALIFORNIA BORDER PATROL IN
03:48:03.202 --> 03:48:05.338
WHICH CASE THEY ARE ELIGIBLE TO
03:48:05.405 --> 03:48:05.972
HAVE A CONTRACT WITH US BUT IF
03:48:06.039 --> 03:48:09.008
THEY DO THEN THAT UNDERMINES IT
03:48:09.075 --> 03:48:10.410
IS AN AND RUN IN A LOOP HOLE
03:48:10.476 --> 03:48:11.511
AROUND A SANCTUARY STATE
03:48:11.577 --> 03:48:12.445
PROVISIONS.
03:48:12.512 --> 03:48:13.246
I WE YES IT WE ARE SEXUALLY
03:48:13.312 --> 03:48:16.449
USING A STATE TAX DOLLARS.
03:48:16.516 --> 03:48:18.651
TO DEPORT DETAIN.
03:48:18.718 --> 03:48:20.186
IMMIGRANTS HERE IN CALIFORNIA --
03:48:20.253 --> 03:48:20.987
WE TOOK SOME A NUMBER OF
03:48:21.054 --> 03:48:22.388
AMENDMENTS TO HELP.
03:48:22.455 --> 03:48:24.190
MAKE THE PROCESS LESS BURDENSOME
03:48:24.257 --> 03:48:26.292
ON LOCALS THAT WERE I AM.
03:48:26.359 --> 03:48:27.493
EXPRESSING SOME CONCERNS ABOUT
03:48:27.560 --> 03:48:29.195
THAT NOW THE DOJ WOULD BE
03:48:29.262 --> 03:48:30.630
RESPONSIBLE FOR IDENTIFYING AND
03:48:30.696 --> 03:48:32.231
PUBLISHING A LIST OF COMPANIES.
03:48:32.298 --> 03:48:34.133
THAT PROVIDE PROHIBITS SERVICES
03:48:34.200 --> 03:48:36.402
TO FEDERAL IMMIGRATION AGENCIES
03:48:36.469 --> 03:48:37.036
WE ALSO HAVE A COMPONENT OF THE
03:48:37.103 --> 03:48:38.037
BILL THAT.
03:48:38.104 --> 03:48:41.441
ALLOWS -- OUR PUBLIC AGENCIES TO
03:48:41.507 --> 03:48:43.209
DO BUSINESS WITH COMPANIES WHEN
03:48:43.276 --> 03:48:43.676
THERE IS NO REASONABLE
03:48:43.743 --> 03:48:44.410
ALTERNATIVE.
03:48:44.477 --> 03:48:45.244
I THINK THESE ARE ALL
03:48:45.311 --> 03:48:47.380
APPROPRIATE STEPS TO MAKE THE
03:48:47.447 --> 03:48:49.282
BILL I'M MORE AND IMPLEMENTABLE
03:48:49.348 --> 03:48:50.383
AND MORE PRACTICAL.
03:48:50.450 --> 03:48:51.584
I APPRECIATE YOUR WORK MISTER
03:48:51.651 --> 03:48:53.719
CHAIR -- AND YOUR STAFF WORK I
03:48:53.786 --> 03:48:56.322
WITH MY TEAM A TO HELP GET THE
03:48:56.389 --> 03:48:57.957
BILL TAB WHERE IT IS WITH THE
03:48:58.024 --> 03:48:59.225
WITH THE AMENDMENTS THAT IT HAS --
03:48:59.292 --> 03:49:00.793
AND TO I THANK YOU FOR YOUR
03:49:00.860 --> 03:49:01.928
CONSIDERATION TODAY I
03:49:01.994 --> 03:49:03.062
RESPECTFULLY ASK THE AYE VOTE.
03:49:03.129 --> 03:49:04.797
I HAVE WITH ME TO TESTIFY IN
03:49:04.864 --> 03:49:06.365
SUPPORT BRIAN HOPE.
03:49:06.432 --> 03:49:08.201
FOR SECURE JUSTICE LES LOVERS
03:49:08.267 --> 03:49:09.936
ABI CALIFORNIA IMMIGRANT POLICY
03:49:10.002 --> 03:49:12.672
CENTER AND MAHMOUD TO REACT
03:49:12.738 --> 03:49:14.774
COUNCIL OF ON ON AMERICAN
03:49:14.841 --> 03:49:15.508
ISLAMIC RELATIONS.
03:49:15.575 --> 03:49:16.576
THANK YOU SO JUST TO BE CLEAR
03:49:16.642 --> 03:49:19.212
THE MEMBERS ARE LISTED IN THE
03:49:19.278 --> 03:49:20.746
ANALYSIS YOU'RE TAKING AS
03:49:20.813 --> 03:49:21.180
AUTHORS AND TAKEN.
03:49:21.247 --> 03:49:23.015
THANK YOU PERFECT RIGHT FIRST
03:49:23.082 --> 03:49:24.484
WITNESS PLEASE.
03:49:24.550 --> 03:49:25.351
HONORABLE ASSEMBLY MEMBERS MY
03:49:25.418 --> 03:49:26.552
NAME IS BRIAN HOPE FOR AN
03:49:26.619 --> 03:49:28.087
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF SECURE
03:49:28.154 --> 03:49:35.761
JUSTICE ALPHA CHAIR OAKLAND
03:49:35.828 --> 03:49:37.363
PRIVACY COMMISSION.
03:49:37.430 --> 03:49:38.631
I WANT TO THANK MEMBER BONTA AND
03:49:38.698 --> 03:49:39.932
IS LEGISLATIVE AIDE GRAHAM DRAKE
03:49:39.999 --> 03:49:41.300
FOR WORKING WITH OUR COALITION.
03:49:41.367 --> 03:49:42.535
AND YOUR WONDERFUL CONSULTANT
03:49:42.602 --> 03:49:44.504
JUST MAKING A CENT THANK YOU FOR
03:49:44.570 --> 03:49:46.772
LETTING ME INVADE YOUR WEEKEND --
03:49:46.839 --> 03:49:47.340
I WANT TO SHARE WITH YOU THE
03:49:47.406 --> 03:49:47.974
INSPIRATION FOR THIS BILL WHICH
03:49:48.040 --> 03:49:48.574
CAME FROM TWO OF MY CHILDHOOD
03:49:48.641 --> 03:49:50.209
FRIENDS AT WORK IN SEPARATE
03:49:50.276 --> 03:49:50.943
FINANCIAL AID OFFICES.
03:49:51.010 --> 03:49:51.911
THERE IS SHARING WITH ME THE
03:49:51.978 --> 03:49:53.212
pAND GPS PROTECTED STUDENTS FROM
03:49:53.279 --> 03:49:54.614
APPLYING FOR FINANCIAL AID.
03:49:54.680 --> 03:49:55.815
BECAUSE THEIR PARENTS WERE
03:49:55.882 --> 03:49:56.949
SCARED TO PROVIDE DATA TO THE
03:49:57.016 --> 03:49:58.050
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT.
03:49:58.117 --> 03:49:59.552
AROUND THE SAME TIME IN ALAMEDA
03:49:59.619 --> 03:50:01.287
COUNTY SUPERVISOR SHARED WITH ME
03:50:01.354 --> 03:50:02.955
THE RESULTS OF THE LOCAL HEALTH
03:50:03.022 --> 03:50:03.723
CARE ENROLLMENTS.
03:50:03.789 --> 03:50:05.291
AS A COUNTIES LARGE IMMIGRATION
03:50:05.358 --> 03:50:06.959
POPULATION CHOSE TO FOREGO
03:50:07.026 --> 03:50:07.693
HEALTH CARE THAT THEY'RE
03:50:07.760 --> 03:50:09.929
ENTITLED TO BY OPERATION OF LAW.
03:50:09.996 --> 03:50:11.964
RATHER THAN PROVIDE DATA TO THE
03:50:12.031 --> 03:50:13.065
FEDS.
03:50:13.132 --> 03:50:13.933
IMAGINE BEING THOSE PARENTS
03:50:14.000 --> 03:50:15.101
CHOOSING TO REJECT HEALTH CARE
03:50:15.168 --> 03:50:16.302
AND FINANCIAL AID FOR YOUR KIDS
03:50:16.369 --> 03:50:20.306
BECAUSE YOU'RE TERRIFIED THAT
03:50:20.373 --> 03:50:21.707
THEY ARE YOU WILL BE DEPORTED.
03:50:21.774 --> 03:50:22.475
I WANT TO SHARE WITH YOU A QUOTE
03:50:22.542 --> 03:50:24.177
FROM A RECENT LEGISLATIVE EFFORT
03:50:24.243 --> 03:50:26.345
I WORKED ON WAS -- BART.
03:50:26.412 --> 03:50:27.647
PART WAS FOUNDED SHARE DATA WITH
03:50:27.713 --> 03:50:29.115
ICE THERE CENTURY TRANSIT
03:50:29.182 --> 03:50:30.349
DISTRICT.
03:50:30.416 --> 03:50:31.217
PUT IT IN A MERCURY NEWS
03:50:31.284 --> 03:50:31.851
CALIFORNIA IMMIGRANT IS JUSTICE
03:50:31.918 --> 03:50:33.085
ALLIANCE THE WORD SANCTUARY HAS
03:50:33.152 --> 03:50:34.587
LOST A LOT OF ITS STRENGTH.
03:50:34.654 --> 03:50:35.888
TRUST IN ANY STATE AGENCY TO
03:50:35.955 --> 03:50:37.623
FULLY SUPPORT THE UNDOCUMENTED
03:50:37.690 --> 03:50:39.325
COMMUNITY THROUGH CENTURY FARCES
03:50:39.392 --> 03:50:40.960
IT'S SOMETHING WE ARE NO LONGER
03:50:41.027 --> 03:50:42.061
GAMBLING WITH.
03:50:42.128 --> 03:50:43.863
THIS IS OUR CONCERN THIS BILL IS
03:50:43.930 --> 03:50:45.064
STRAIGHT FORWARD IF YOU PROVIDE
03:50:45.131 --> 03:50:46.632
SPECIFIC SERVICES TO FEDERAL
03:50:46.699 --> 03:50:47.800
IMMIGRATION AGENCIES YOUR
03:50:47.867 --> 03:50:49.302
INELIGIBLE TO RECEIVE ARE SCARCE
03:50:49.368 --> 03:50:50.903
TAXPAYER DOLLARS.
03:50:50.970 --> 03:50:52.171
THIS WOULD BETTER ALIGN OUR
03:50:52.238 --> 03:50:53.773
BUDGET WITH OUR VALUES.
03:50:53.839 --> 03:50:54.974
THIS IS NOT A NEW CONCEPT
03:50:55.041 --> 03:50:56.876
PURSUANT TO A BE EIGHTEEN EIGHTY
03:50:56.943 --> 03:50:58.211
SEVEN THE STATE ALREADY USES ITS
03:50:58.277 --> 03:51:00.146
ECONOMIC POWER IN SUPPORT LGBT
03:51:00.213 --> 03:51:01.113
Q. FOLKS.
03:51:01.180 --> 03:51:02.548
PROHIBITING STATE FUNDED OR
03:51:02.615 --> 03:51:03.683
STATE SPONSORED TRAVEL TO
03:51:03.749 --> 03:51:04.517
CERTAIN STATES WITH
03:51:04.584 --> 03:51:05.851
DISCRIMINATORY LAWS AND WE'RE
03:51:05.918 --> 03:51:07.220
ASKING YOU TO CONTINUE TO BE
03:51:07.286 --> 03:51:08.421
SUPPORTIVE OF OUR CALIFORNIA
03:51:08.487 --> 03:51:10.423
RESIDENTS BEING DISCRIMINATED
03:51:10.489 --> 03:51:11.190
AGAINST.
03:51:11.257 --> 03:51:13.159
THE DOJ IS NOW RESPONSIBLE FOR
03:51:13.226 --> 03:51:14.794
IT -- UNDER EIGHTEEN EIGHTY
03:51:14.860 --> 03:51:15.294
SEVEN THE DOJ IS ALSO
03:51:15.361 --> 03:51:16.996
RESPONSIBLE FOR IDENTIFYING THE
03:51:17.063 --> 03:51:18.497
LIST OF OFFENDING STATES.
03:51:18.564 --> 03:51:19.832
MANY LOCALITIES HAVE ADOPTED
03:51:19.899 --> 03:51:21.200
ANTI NUCLEAR WEAPONS ORDINANCES
03:51:21.267 --> 03:51:22.401
BORDER WALL CONTRACTOR
03:51:22.468 --> 03:51:24.837
PROHIBITIONS AND SIMILAR TRAVEL
03:51:24.904 --> 03:51:26.606
BANS -- THOSE LOCALITIES HAVE
03:51:26.672 --> 03:51:27.573
BEEN ABLE TO COMPLY AND REVIEW
03:51:27.640 --> 03:51:30.243
CONTRACTS WITHOUT HURTING THEIR
03:51:30.309 --> 03:51:32.979
BUDGETS -- RICHMOND ENACTED A
03:51:33.045 --> 03:51:33.679
SOMEWHERE Là LAST JUNE BERKELEY
03:51:33.746 --> 03:51:35.514
IS EXPECTED TO DO SO TONIGHT
03:51:35.581 --> 03:51:36.582
WE'RE ON THE CONSENT CALENDAR.
03:51:36.649 --> 03:51:38.317
OAKLAND WILL BE VOTING ON MAY
03:51:38.384 --> 03:51:39.485
FOURTEENTH.
03:51:39.552 --> 03:51:40.586
MY PUBLIC RECORD REQUEST SHOW
03:51:40.653 --> 03:51:41.954
THAT TWO TO THREE CONTRACTS AT
03:51:42.021 --> 03:51:45.258
ISSUE -- PER CITY IS THE AVERAGE
03:51:45.324 --> 03:51:47.893
COUNTIES WITH JAILS WOULD HAVE
03:51:47.960 --> 03:51:48.527
FIVE TO SIX CONTRACTS THERE ARE
03:51:48.594 --> 03:51:50.296
BECAUSE THE ANALYSIS SHOWS THERE
03:51:50.363 --> 03:51:51.564
IS A MULTITUDE OF VENDORS IN
03:51:51.631 --> 03:51:52.632
EACH OF THESE CATEGORIES.
03:51:52.698 --> 03:51:54.634
WE BELIEVE THERE ARE REASONABLE
03:51:54.700 --> 03:51:56.202
ALTERNATIVES.
03:51:56.269 --> 03:51:57.370
BY HAVING TO DO J. IDENTIFY THAT
03:51:57.436 --> 03:51:59.972
LAST LOCAL ENTITIES ARE RELIEVED
03:52:00.039 --> 03:52:01.607
OF THE BURDEN.
03:52:01.674 --> 03:52:02.441
BY THE DOJ FIRST NOTIFYING THOSE
03:52:02.508 --> 03:52:03.576
COMPANIES IT SHIFTS THE BURDEN
03:52:03.643 --> 03:52:04.644
TO THEM TO PROVE THEY DO NOT
03:52:04.710 --> 03:52:06.145
PROVIDE SUCH SERVICES.
03:52:06.212 --> 03:52:07.513
BY HAVING THIS PROHIBITION AND
03:52:07.580 --> 03:52:08.981
LOCAL CONTRACTING SOLICITATIONS
03:52:09.048 --> 03:52:10.816
NOTICES LOCAL GOVERNMENTS WILL
03:52:10.883 --> 03:52:12.218
BE ASSURE THAT RESPONSE OF
03:52:12.285 --> 03:52:13.753
BIDDERS ARE QUALIFIED AND NOT
03:52:13.819 --> 03:52:15.788
PROVIDING SUCH SERVICES.
03:52:15.855 --> 03:52:16.756
WE ALL KNOW OUR WORLD WAR TWO
03:52:16.822 --> 03:52:17.823
HISTORY.
03:52:17.890 --> 03:52:19.525
THAT SEEMINGLY BENIGN DATA
03:52:19.592 --> 03:52:20.993
COLLECTED BY CENSUS BUREAU'S WAS
03:52:21.060 --> 03:52:22.528
USED BY BOTH AMERICAN AND
03:52:22.595 --> 03:52:25.531
EUROPEAN GOVERNMENTS TO TARGET
03:52:25.598 --> 03:52:26.766
CERTAIN POPULATIONS.
03:52:26.832 --> 03:52:27.900
WE HAVE THESE LOOPHOLES ARE GAPS
03:52:27.967 --> 03:52:30.336
IN OUR EXISTING CENTURY STATUTES
03:52:30.403 --> 03:52:31.370
AND WE'RE ASKING YOU TO HELP
03:52:31.437 --> 03:52:32.705
FILL THEM.
03:52:32.772 --> 03:52:35.041
WE ASK YOUR SUPPORT OF THIS BILL.
03:52:35.107 --> 03:52:35.708
THANK YOU THAT'S WHAT THIS PLACE
03:52:35.775 --> 03:52:37.410
GOOD MORNING MISTER CHAIR AND
03:52:37.476 --> 03:52:38.911
MEMBERS THAT LAY LOWER IS THAT
03:52:38.978 --> 03:52:40.079
THE WITH THE CALIFORNIA
03:52:40.146 --> 03:52:41.681
IMMIGRANT POLICY CENTER.
03:52:41.747 --> 03:52:43.349
I AM PROUD TO BE HERE IN SUPPORT
03:52:43.416 --> 03:52:44.984
OF THIS BILL TODAY OUR
03:52:45.051 --> 03:52:47.420
ORGANIZATION IN TWO THOUSAND
03:52:47.486 --> 03:52:49.822
SEVENTEEN SUPPORTED PROUDLY SB
03:52:49.889 --> 03:52:50.690
FIFTY FOR THE CALIFORNIA VALUES
03:52:50.756 --> 03:52:52.258
ACT WHICH WAS PASSED INTO LAW
03:52:52.325 --> 03:52:53.359
AND HAS BEEN.
03:52:53.426 --> 03:52:54.860
DUBBED BY THE MEDIA FOR BETTER
03:52:54.927 --> 03:52:57.296
OR WORSE AS BEST STATE SANCTUARY
03:52:57.363 --> 03:53:00.466
LAW -- THE SIMILARLY A. B.
03:53:00.533 --> 03:53:01.067
THIRTEEN THIRTY TWO WOULD MAKE
03:53:01.133 --> 03:53:02.968
IMPORTANT STEPS IN EXTENDING THE
03:53:03.035 --> 03:53:05.671
PROTECTIONS IN SB FIFTY FOUR TO
03:53:05.738 --> 03:53:06.806
MAKE SURE THAT THEY'RE TRULY
03:53:06.872 --> 03:53:08.507
REALITY FOR ALL OF OUR STATES
03:53:08.574 --> 03:53:09.241
RESIDENTS.
03:53:09.308 --> 03:53:10.710
WERE BECOMING INCREASINGLY
03:53:10.776 --> 03:53:12.278
CONCERNED ABOUT THE USE OF
03:53:12.345 --> 03:53:14.947
PRIVATE CORPORATE DATABASES AND
03:53:15.014 --> 03:53:15.781
THE WAYS THOSE HAVE THE
03:53:15.848 --> 03:53:17.183
POTENTIAL TO COMPROMISE THE
03:53:17.249 --> 03:53:19.085
PRIVACYINTERESTS OF OUR STATES
03:53:19.151 --> 03:53:20.219
IMMIGRANTS.
03:53:20.286 --> 03:53:21.754
IN PARTICULAR UNDOCUMENTED
03:53:21.821 --> 03:53:23.989
IMMIGRANTS -- AS WELL AS FOLKS
03:53:24.056 --> 03:53:26.559
WHO'VE BEEN GRANTED A TEMPORARY
03:53:26.625 --> 03:53:28.160
LAWFUL PRESENCE BY THE FEDERAL
03:53:28.227 --> 03:53:29.829
GOVERNMENT THIS WOULD INCLUDE
03:53:29.895 --> 03:53:31.931
POPULATIONS SUCH AS STOCK --
03:53:31.997 --> 03:53:33.933
THAT ARE PARTICULARLY VULNERABLE
03:53:33.999 --> 03:53:35.901
IN THESE TIMES -- CURRENTLY THE
03:53:35.968 --> 03:53:37.570
DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND SECURITY
03:53:37.636 --> 03:53:39.939
HASAN OPERATING BUDGET OF FORTY
03:53:40.005 --> 03:53:41.907
FOUR BILLION DOLLARS AND IT IS
03:53:41.974 --> 03:53:44.176
EVER GROWING. 10% OF THAT MONEY
03:53:44.243 --> 03:53:45.711
GOES DIRECTLY TOWARDS DATA
03:53:45.778 --> 03:53:47.747
MANAGEMENT SO THAT'S TO SAY 10%
03:53:47.813 --> 03:53:48.814
OF THAT MONEY.
03:53:48.881 --> 03:53:50.516
GOES TOWARDS PURCHASING THE
03:53:50.583 --> 03:53:53.185
PRIVATE INFORMATION OF RESIDENCE --
03:53:53.252 --> 03:53:54.954
IN OUR STATE AND ACROSS THE
03:53:55.020 --> 03:53:55.855
COUNTRY.
03:53:55.921 --> 03:53:57.056
CALIFORNIA IS HOME TO THE
03:53:57.123 --> 03:53:59.191
LARGEST IMMIGRANT POPULATION IN
03:53:59.258 --> 03:54:01.494
THE ENTIRE COUNTRY WERE ALSO
03:54:01.560 --> 03:54:04.263
HOME TO SILICON VALLEY -- AMAZON
03:54:04.330 --> 03:54:06.665
HAS BEEN ONE OF THE MOST NOTED
03:54:06.732 --> 03:54:08.234
AND REPORTED UPON OFFENDERS IN
03:54:08.300 --> 03:54:09.402
TERMS OF SELLING AND
03:54:09.468 --> 03:54:11.270
PARTICIPATING -- IN THIS
03:54:11.337 --> 03:54:13.706
DETENTION AND DEPORTATION SCHEMA
03:54:13.773 --> 03:54:15.040
AND SO WE THINK THAT THERE IS A
03:54:15.107 --> 03:54:17.176
UNIQUE OPPORTUNITY AND
03:54:17.243 --> 03:54:18.644
RESPONSIBILITY HERE IN
03:54:18.711 --> 03:54:20.513
CALIFORNIA. TO DEMONSTRATE
03:54:20.579 --> 03:54:22.581
LEADERSHIP BY EXTENDING THE
03:54:22.648 --> 03:54:23.949
PROTECTIONS THAT WE HAVE
03:54:24.016 --> 03:54:25.551
AFFORDED TO OUR STATE IT
03:54:25.618 --> 03:54:27.119
CITIZENS AT TO OUR RESIDENTS
03:54:27.186 --> 03:54:28.454
WITH RESPECT.
03:54:28.521 --> 03:54:30.656
TO PROTECTING THEIR PHYSICAL
03:54:30.723 --> 03:54:35.294
INTERACTIONS -- WITH FEDERAL
03:54:35.361 --> 03:54:36.362
IMMIGRATION AUTHORITIES AND
03:54:36.429 --> 03:54:37.129
EXTENDING THAT TO THE VIRTUAL
03:54:37.196 --> 03:54:37.663
ROUND BY PROTECTING THEIR
03:54:37.730 --> 03:54:38.864
PRIVATE DATA AS WELL AND WE
03:54:38.931 --> 03:54:39.999
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR
03:54:40.065 --> 03:54:42.401
SUPPORT THANK YOU.
03:54:42.468 --> 03:54:45.438
THANK YOU THAT'S THAT IS PLEASE.
03:54:45.504 --> 03:54:45.971
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR AND
03:54:46.038 --> 03:54:48.140
COMMITTEE MEMBERS.
03:54:48.207 --> 03:54:49.642
WITH THE AREA FROM THE COUNCIL
03:54:49.708 --> 03:54:51.544
ON AMERICAN ISLAMIC RELATIONS.
03:54:51.610 --> 03:54:52.778
IN THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA AS
03:54:52.845 --> 03:54:54.647
THE SANCTUARY STATE WE CURRENTLY
03:54:54.713 --> 03:54:56.315
LIMIT LOCAL AND STATE AGENCIES
03:54:56.382 --> 03:54:57.450
AND THEIR INTERACTIONS WITH
03:54:57.516 --> 03:54:59.185
FEDERAL IMMIGRATION AGENCIES.
03:54:59.251 --> 03:55:00.753
YEAH OUR TAXPAYER DOLLARS
03:55:00.820 --> 03:55:01.987
CONTINUE TO BE USED TO SUPPLY
03:55:02.054 --> 03:55:03.489
TECHNOLOGY AND DATA THAT ARE
03:55:03.556 --> 03:55:04.557
THEN USED ON ONE OF OUR
03:55:04.623 --> 03:55:05.591
POPULATIONS.
03:55:05.658 --> 03:55:08.627
BY THOSE VERY SAME AGENCIES.
03:55:08.694 --> 03:55:10.396
NOW THERE'S NO SURPRISE THAT
03:55:10.463 --> 03:55:11.797
THERE'S A LACK OF TRUST FROM
03:55:11.864 --> 03:55:13.866
AMERICAN AND COMMUNITY WITH THE
03:55:13.933 --> 03:55:15.234
INFLUX OF SURVEILLANCE.
03:55:15.301 --> 03:55:17.136
EXTREME VETTING AND THE RISE OF
03:55:17.203 --> 03:55:19.271
HATE CRIMES THAT ARE FAR GREATER
03:55:19.338 --> 03:55:22.174
TODAY THAN THEY WERE AFTER.
03:55:22.241 --> 03:55:22.708
NINE ELEVEN CURRENTLY OUR
03:55:22.775 --> 03:55:25.511
COMMUNITY IS RIDDLED WITH FBI
03:55:25.578 --> 03:55:27.313
AND ICE INFORMANTS.
03:55:27.379 --> 03:55:29.114
AND THE DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND
03:55:29.181 --> 03:55:30.649
SECURITY'S COUNTERING VIOLENT
03:55:30.716 --> 03:55:32.885
EXTREMISM PROGRAM -- STATEWIDE
03:55:32.952 --> 03:55:34.720
KNOWN AS PREVENTING VIOLENT EX
03:55:34.787 --> 03:55:36.455
WAS A PROGRAM.
03:55:36.522 --> 03:55:38.357
FUNDS NONPROFITS TO THE VEIL
03:55:38.424 --> 03:55:40.626
MUSLIMS AND REFUGEES.
03:55:40.693 --> 03:55:42.094
AND COOPERATE WITH DHS.
03:55:42.161 --> 03:55:43.863
COMPANIES SHOULD NOT BE IN THE
03:55:43.929 --> 03:55:46.532
BUSINESS OF ENHANCING AND
03:55:46.599 --> 03:55:48.400
PROVIDING SUPPORT. FOR ISIS
03:55:48.467 --> 03:55:50.703
DIRTY WORK.
03:55:50.769 --> 03:55:52.705
COMPANY PROVIDING DATA BROKER
03:55:52.771 --> 03:55:54.640
EXTREME VETTING AND DETENTION
03:55:54.707 --> 03:55:56.242
FACILITY SUPPORT SERVICES ARE IN
03:55:56.308 --> 03:55:58.010
CLEAR CONFLICT WITH THE
03:55:58.077 --> 03:55:59.545
CALIFORNIA VALLEY'S ACT.
03:55:59.612 --> 03:56:01.013
THIS IS WHY CARE IS IN FULL
03:56:01.080 --> 03:56:03.682
SUPPORT OF AB THIRTEEN THIRTY
03:56:03.749 --> 03:56:05.251
TWO THANK YOU.
03:56:05.317 --> 03:56:08.821
THANK YOU ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT.
03:56:08.888 --> 03:56:09.922
IF YOU GIVE US YOUR NAME AND
03:56:09.989 --> 03:56:14.226
YOUR AFFILIATION PLEASE.
03:56:14.293 --> 03:56:15.227
REBEKAH GONZALEZ NATIONAL
03:56:15.294 --> 03:56:16.929
ASSOCIATION OF SOCIAL WORKERS
03:56:16.996 --> 03:56:19.632
CALIFORNIA CHAPTER.
03:56:19.698 --> 03:56:21.166
EMILY GOLDMAN EDUCATORS FOR MIKE
03:56:21.233 --> 03:56:22.268
AND JUSTICE IN THE S. G.
03:56:22.334 --> 03:56:24.069
TRANSPARENCY INITIATIVE AND VERY
03:56:24.136 --> 03:56:27.139
MUCH SUPPORT.
03:56:27.206 --> 03:56:28.474
JULIE CHAPMAN OF INDIVISIBLE
03:56:28.541 --> 03:56:30.743
SACRAMENTO AND CALIFORNIA
03:56:30.809 --> 03:56:31.977
INDIVISIBLE STATE STRONG AND
03:56:32.044 --> 03:56:36.315
WERE IN FULL SUPPORT.
03:56:36.382 --> 03:56:37.516
DOUG TROUBLE.
03:56:37.583 --> 03:56:38.951
INDIVISIBLE SACRAMENTO IN
03:56:39.018 --> 03:56:41.253
INDIVISIBLE STATE STRONG IN
03:56:41.320 --> 03:56:42.621
SUPPORT.
03:56:42.688 --> 03:56:44.156
THANK YOU ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT.
03:56:44.223 --> 03:56:57.670
SEEING NONE IS THERE OPPOSITION.
03:56:57.736 --> 03:57:00.739
GOOD MORNING I THINK IT'S STILL
03:57:00.806 --> 03:57:04.009
MORNING.
03:57:04.076 --> 03:57:05.511
A ROB WHICH SHE FOR THE CUSTOMER
03:57:05.578 --> 03:57:07.212
OF COMMERCE -- AND WE ARE
03:57:07.279 --> 03:57:08.647
STRONGLY OPPOSED TO THIS BILL AS
03:57:08.714 --> 03:57:10.449
A JOB KILLER -- BECAUSE IT WOULD
03:57:10.516 --> 03:57:11.283
FORCE.
03:57:11.350 --> 03:57:12.585
RESPECTED INDUSTRY STANDARD
03:57:12.651 --> 03:57:14.353
BUSINESSES OUT OF CALIFORNIA
03:57:14.420 --> 03:57:16.055
BASED ON WHAT.
03:57:16.121 --> 03:57:18.057
WE'VE DISAPPEAR OF VAGUE --
03:57:18.123 --> 03:57:20.526
BLACKLIST -- WOULD LIKE TO THANK
03:57:20.593 --> 03:57:21.727
STAFF FOR SPEAKING TO US WE HAVE
03:57:21.794 --> 03:57:22.661
BEEN IN TOUCH WITH THE OFFICE
03:57:22.728 --> 03:57:23.696
OFFICE AND WE APPRECIATE THAT
03:57:23.762 --> 03:57:25.497
TME HOWEVER OUR PRIMARY CONCERN
03:57:25.564 --> 03:57:26.765
STILL HAVE NOT BEEN ADDRESSED.
03:57:26.832 --> 03:57:29.335
ON TO CLARIFY SOME WHAT WHAT WE
03:57:29.401 --> 03:57:31.403
DO IS MISINFORMATION ABOUT THIS.
03:57:31.470 --> 03:57:31.971
WE APPRECIATE THE AUTHOR'S
03:57:32.037 --> 03:57:33.706
HEARTFELT AND AND EVERYONE HEARS
03:57:33.772 --> 03:57:35.708
A HEARTFELT CONCERN ABOUT THE
03:57:35.774 --> 03:57:36.575
FEDERAL IMMIGRATION POLICY.
03:57:36.642 --> 03:57:38.143
ON HOWEVER AND AND WE DO NOT
03:57:38.210 --> 03:57:39.578
OPPOSE THIS SET OF ANY SUPPORT
03:57:39.645 --> 03:57:40.846
FOR THAT POLICY THIS BILL IS
03:57:40.913 --> 03:57:42.648
MUCH BROADER THAN THAT POLICY IS
03:57:42.715 --> 03:57:45.017
MUCH MORE TROUBLING IMPLICATIONS
03:57:45.084 --> 03:57:48.220
FOR THE BUSINESS COMMUNITY -- SO --
03:57:48.287 --> 03:57:49.021
FIRST THAT'S DEAL WITH THIS
03:57:49.088 --> 03:57:52.091
BEING A A PRECISE OR OR DETAILED
03:57:52.157 --> 03:57:54.326
BLACKLIST THAT IS NOT THE CASE
03:57:54.393 --> 03:57:54.960
OF THE BLACKLIST IS TO FIND TWO
03:57:55.027 --> 03:57:55.461
WAYS.
03:57:55.527 --> 03:57:56.929
BY WHETHER OR NOT A FEDERAL
03:57:56.996 --> 03:57:58.397
GOVERNMENT AGENCY THAT YOU WOULD
03:57:58.464 --> 03:57:59.798
CONTRACT WITH PROVIDES
03:57:59.865 --> 03:58:02.501
IMMIGRATION RELATED SERVICES --
03:58:02.568 --> 03:58:04.670
THAT TERM IS NOT CLEARLY DEFINED
03:58:04.737 --> 03:58:07.840
AND AS A COMMON SENSE WOULD SAKE
03:58:07.906 --> 03:58:09.575
SURE IT INCLUDES ICE OR SEE KEEP
03:58:09.642 --> 03:58:10.976
A CUSTOMS AND BORDER PATROL.
03:58:11.043 --> 03:58:11.543
BUT DEPARTMENT STATE ISSUES
03:58:11.610 --> 03:58:13.178
IMMIGRATION DOCUMENTS TO PART OF
03:58:13.245 --> 03:58:15.280
EDUCATION TEACHES CLASSES --
03:58:15.347 --> 03:58:16.415
DEPART OF JUSTICE HILLS
03:58:16.482 --> 03:58:17.816
IMMIGRATION COURTS SO WE'RE NOT
03:58:17.883 --> 03:58:20.052
TALKING ABOUT A SMALL DEFINED
03:58:20.119 --> 03:58:21.687
LIST OF JUST ICE CAN'T WORK
03:58:21.754 --> 03:58:22.287
WE'RE TALKING ABOUT ANYONE A
03:58:22.354 --> 03:58:24.223
CONTRACT WITH HUGE SUAS THE
03:58:24.289 --> 03:58:25.224
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT.
03:58:25.290 --> 03:58:29.528
NOW HAVING -- THE CONCERNS UP BY
03:58:29.595 --> 03:58:30.095
THAT THEY CAN DO BUSINESS IN
03:58:30.162 --> 03:58:33.766
CALIFORNIA -- AND WITH RESPECT
03:58:33.832 --> 03:58:34.600
TO THE MOMENT KICKING THAT TO
03:58:34.667 --> 03:58:35.934
DOJ -- COULD NOT TO THE JUST NOT
03:58:36.001 --> 03:58:36.568
ADDRESS OUR CONCERN BECAUSE THE
03:58:36.635 --> 03:58:37.436
DOJ WILL CONFRONT THE EXACT SAME
03:58:37.503 --> 03:58:39.371
VAGUE LANGUAGE WHICH IS IN FRONT
03:58:39.438 --> 03:58:40.139
OF US TODAY.
03:58:40.205 --> 03:58:41.373
AND THEY WILL BE ASK WHAT IS
03:58:41.440 --> 03:58:42.708
IMMIGRATION RELATED AND THEY
03:58:42.775 --> 03:58:44.643
WILL BE UNABLE TO AVOID THE FACT
03:58:44.710 --> 03:58:46.679
THAT OUR STATE AND MANY OTHERS
03:58:46.745 --> 03:58:49.148
ARE INVOLVED IN -- AS TO THE
03:58:49.214 --> 03:58:50.783
SCALE OF THE COMPANY'S COVERED --
03:58:50.849 --> 03:58:51.417
BECAUSE THE BLACKLIST WOULD BE
03:58:51.483 --> 03:58:53.652
CITIES SO BAG IT'S HARD FOR US
03:58:53.719 --> 03:58:54.853
TO EVEN AS A BUSINESS COMMUNITY.
03:58:54.920 --> 03:58:56.689
ASSESS HOW MANY BUSINESSES WOULD
03:58:56.755 --> 03:58:58.457
BE COVERED BY THIS AND EVEN WHAT
03:58:58.524 --> 03:59:01.860
SECTORS -- THE WHAT WE DO KNOW
03:59:01.927 --> 03:59:03.862
IS PRESUMABLY MANY MANY TECH
03:59:03.929 --> 03:59:05.064
COMPANIES TO BE COVERED BECAUSE
03:59:05.130 --> 03:59:06.532
THE BILL TARGETS.
03:59:06.598 --> 03:59:08.367
COMPANIES THAT GATHER DATA OR
03:59:08.434 --> 03:59:11.103
ANALYZE DATA -- BUT SOME OF THE
03:59:11.170 --> 03:59:12.538
EXAMPLES THAT WERE INCLUDED IN
03:59:12.604 --> 03:59:14.473
THE AUTHORS -- INITIAL DRAFT
03:59:14.540 --> 03:59:16.141
RECITALS DID YOU EXAMPLES OF
03:59:16.208 --> 03:59:17.576
REALLY HOW CATACLYSMIC THE
03:59:17.643 --> 03:59:19.411
IMPLICATIONS OF OF THIS BILL
03:59:19.478 --> 03:59:20.946
WOULD BE TO ANYONE OPERATING ON
03:59:21.013 --> 03:59:22.147
PUBLIC AND IN CALIFORNIA.
03:59:22.214 --> 03:59:24.483
BY FORBIDDING BASIC NECESSARY
03:59:24.550 --> 03:59:26.552
INDUSTRY WIDE STANDARDSERVICES.
03:59:26.618 --> 03:59:27.252
MICROSOFT.
03:59:27.319 --> 03:59:28.821
I'M I'M SURE EVERYONE IN THIS
03:59:28.887 --> 03:59:30.456
ROOM AND I I CAN'T SEVERAL BY
03:59:30.522 --> 03:59:33.092
SOON WE ALL USE -- MICROSOFT
03:59:33.158 --> 03:59:34.259
WORD MICROSOFT OUTLOOK.
03:59:34.326 --> 03:59:35.594
MICROSOFT TO BE OFF LIMITS UNDER
03:59:35.661 --> 03:59:36.895
THIS BILL BECAUSE MICROSOFT HAS
03:59:36.962 --> 03:59:38.497
AN A. I. THAT ANALYZES DATA FOR
03:59:38.564 --> 03:59:39.698
THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT.
03:59:39.765 --> 03:59:40.699
SO EVERY PUBLIC AND IN
03:59:40.766 --> 03:59:41.967
CALIFORNIA WOULD NEED TO FIND A
03:59:42.034 --> 03:59:43.602
NEW EMAIL SERVER -- AND I'LL
03:59:43.669 --> 03:59:44.636
DEAL WITH THE REASON ALTERNATIVE
03:59:44.703 --> 03:59:46.105
LANGUAGE LATER BUT THAT DOES NOT
03:59:46.171 --> 03:59:49.174
ADDRESS THAT -- THOMSON REUTERS
03:59:49.241 --> 03:59:49.975
LEXIS NEXIS AT THREE OTHER
03:59:50.042 --> 03:59:51.877
ATTORNEYS IN THIS ROOM WE ALL
03:59:51.944 --> 03:59:53.011
KNOW THAT A LEXIS NEXIS
03:59:53.078 --> 03:59:54.847
WESTLOWER FUNDAMENTAL
03:59:54.913 --> 03:59:56.648
FUNDAMENTAL PROJECTS.
03:59:56.715 --> 03:59:57.416
THEY ALSO BE OFF LIMITS INTO
03:59:57.483 --> 04:00:00.319
THIS BILL BECAUSE THOSE
04:00:00.385 --> 04:00:02.154
COMPANIES ACCUMULATE THAT.
04:00:02.221 --> 04:00:04.656
IBM JUST AS MENTIONED AMAZON I
04:00:04.723 --> 04:00:06.725
DON'T KNOW -- YEAH I CAN'T
04:00:06.792 --> 04:00:08.260
PROJECT FOR YOU THE VOTE THE
04:00:08.327 --> 04:00:10.129
BREATH HERE BECAUSE THE VEGAS
04:00:10.195 --> 04:00:11.230
THE TERMS BUT WE'RE TALKING UP
04:00:11.296 --> 04:00:13.532
FOR BIDDING BASIC INDUSTRY WIDE
04:00:13.599 --> 04:00:13.799
SERVICES.
04:00:13.866 --> 04:00:19.004
IN CALIFORNIA -- LET'S SEE --
04:00:19.071 --> 04:00:21.607
NEXT APPOINTMENT TOUCH ON IS
04:00:21.673 --> 04:00:24.009
THAT THE THIS IS IN MANY WAYS
04:00:24.076 --> 04:00:25.410
OVER KILL THE MAY HAVE NO POINT --
04:00:25.477 --> 04:00:26.044
WE'RE TALKING ABOUT TARGETING A
04:00:26.111 --> 04:00:28.080
FEDERAL POLICY WHICH WAS PUT IN
04:00:28.147 --> 04:00:29.548
FOR THE EXECUTIVE BRANCH AND
04:00:29.615 --> 04:00:30.883
COULD BE CHANGED TOMORROW IF
04:00:30.949 --> 04:00:32.384
TRUMP WANTED TO OR CHANGED AT
04:00:32.451 --> 04:00:34.019
THE NEXT ELECTION TWENTY TWENTY
04:00:34.086 --> 04:00:35.020
AND PUTTING A CALIFORNIA LAW
04:00:35.087 --> 04:00:36.355
PROHIBITION.
04:00:36.421 --> 04:00:38.357
BASED ON THAT SO LET'S JUST SAY
04:00:38.423 --> 04:00:39.958
TRUMP WAS THE ELECTION TWENTY
04:00:40.025 --> 04:00:40.526
TWENTY THIS BILL GOES INTO
04:00:40.592 --> 04:00:41.560
EFFECT IN THE LAW ON THE BOOKS
04:00:41.627 --> 04:00:43.061
MAKING CONTRACTING CALIFORNIA
04:00:43.128 --> 04:00:44.997
THAT MUCH MORE DIFFICULT.
04:00:45.063 --> 04:00:47.232
WHEN THE POLICY IS GONNA?
04:00:47.299 --> 04:00:48.934
SO IT IS ALSO JUST THAT IN THAT
04:00:49.001 --> 04:00:50.202
WAY THE WRONG RESPONSE.
04:00:50.269 --> 04:00:52.004
AB I THINK IT WAS TEN SEVENTY
04:00:52.070 --> 04:00:53.272
NINE THAT JUST CAME UP THAT
04:00:53.338 --> 04:00:55.174
DEALS WITH ICE IMPLICATIONS WE
04:00:55.240 --> 04:00:56.975
YOU KNOW UNDERSTAND THAT AND
04:00:57.042 --> 04:00:59.244
BECAUSE WE ARE NOT OPPOSED.
04:00:59.311 --> 04:00:59.845
TO FOR YOU KNOW DEALING WITH
04:00:59.912 --> 04:01:01.413
FEDERAL POLICY THE CHAIR DID NOT
04:01:01.480 --> 04:01:03.749
WEIGH IN BUT THIS IS WELL BEYOND.
04:01:03.816 --> 04:01:05.617
THAT AREA OF CONCERN IT'S JUST
04:01:05.684 --> 04:01:08.787
THE WRONG RESPONSE -- AND WE'RE
04:01:08.854 --> 04:01:10.322
GLAD TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS I
04:01:10.389 --> 04:01:11.190
THINK THERE'S A LOT OF
04:01:11.256 --> 04:01:12.257
MISINFORMATION GOING AROUND
04:01:12.324 --> 04:01:14.493
ABOUT THIS BILL BUT FOR INTEREST
04:01:14.560 --> 04:01:15.227
OF TIME AND WE'VE BEEN HERE A
04:01:15.294 --> 04:01:17.896
LONG TIME -- I WILL STOP THERE
04:01:17.963 --> 04:01:20.599
AND PASSES OVER -- TO TO DANGER
04:01:20.666 --> 04:01:22.734
WITH THE PUBLIC PERSPECTIVE.
04:01:22.801 --> 04:01:23.368
THANK YOU THANK GOODNESS PLEASE
04:01:23.435 --> 04:01:24.970
GOOD AFTERNOON HAD CHAIR MEMBERS
04:01:25.037 --> 04:01:26.805
OF NOT QUITE YET DâN HUTCHINGS
04:01:26.872 --> 04:01:28.607
DELETED CALIFORNIA CITIES -- WE
04:01:28.674 --> 04:01:29.975
DO APPRECIATE THAT THE THE
04:01:30.042 --> 04:01:31.310
ATTEMPTS MADE BY THE AUTHOR AND
04:01:31.376 --> 04:01:36.481
SPONSORS TO ADDRESSING CONCERNS.
04:01:36.548 --> 04:01:38.684
THE MEASURE AS WAS STATED CRACK
04:01:38.750 --> 04:01:40.519
CREATES A A BLACK LIST OF%
04:01:40.586 --> 04:01:41.987
COMPANIES THAT IS ALL TO FIND AN
04:01:42.054 --> 04:01:42.955
OVERLY BROAD I WOULD DIRECT YOUR
04:01:43.021 --> 04:01:44.056
ATTENTION.
04:01:44.122 --> 04:01:45.991
TO SECTION SEVENTY TWO EIGHT
04:01:46.058 --> 04:01:47.159
THREE POINT FIVE ONE WHICH
04:01:47.226 --> 04:01:48.527
PROVIDES REALLY AN ALL
04:01:48.594 --> 04:01:49.795
ENCOMPASSING CABBIE OUGHT -- FOR
04:01:49.862 --> 04:01:51.230
IMMIGRATION RELATED SERVICES
04:01:51.296 --> 04:01:52.431
WHICH REALLY YOU KNOW IT SAYS
04:01:52.497 --> 04:01:53.498
THAT YEAH DO YOU KNOW MAY
04:01:53.565 --> 04:01:55.934
INCLUDE BUT IS NOT LIMITED -- TO
04:01:56.001 --> 04:01:57.803
IT IN OUR ASSESSMENT IT COULD
04:01:57.870 --> 04:01:59.404
ACTUALLY SPEND ALL FOREIGN FORTY
04:01:59.471 --> 04:02:00.372
FIVE AGENCIES OF THE FEDERAL
04:02:00.439 --> 04:02:01.573
GOVERNMENT -- CERTAINLY
04:02:01.640 --> 04:02:02.441
SOMETHING WE DON'T WANT TO DO
04:02:02.507 --> 04:02:04.109
AND SO BY BY DOING BY BEING SO
04:02:04.176 --> 04:02:05.777
BROAD -- IT IMPEDES LOCAL
04:02:05.844 --> 04:02:06.979
AGENCIES ABILITY TO DO LEGAL
04:02:07.045 --> 04:02:09.248
RESEARCH -- DEFEND THEMSELVES
04:02:09.314 --> 04:02:10.782
FROM LAWSUITS WOULD HINDER LAW
04:02:10.849 --> 04:02:12.217
ENFORCEMENT'S ABILITY TO ENTER
04:02:12.284 --> 04:02:13.919
EVEN POLICE REPORTS INTEGRATING
04:02:13.986 --> 04:02:15.520
THAT WITH OUR NAME A ONE
04:02:15.587 --> 04:02:17.923
DISPATCH SYSTEMS -- THERE IS A A
04:02:17.990 --> 04:02:19.625
POTENTIAL LOSS OF OF GRANT
04:02:19.691 --> 04:02:20.759
FUNDING OR COMPLETING NEW
04:02:20.826 --> 04:02:22.828
APPLICATIONS DO A LACK OF ACCESS
04:02:22.895 --> 04:02:23.996
TO RESEARCH TOOLS BANNED BY THE
04:02:24.062 --> 04:02:26.131
BILL -- UP FOR IT ALSO FORCES
04:02:26.198 --> 04:02:27.399
EACH AGENCY TO REVIEW EVERY
04:02:27.466 --> 04:02:29.201
CONTRACT PURCHASE ORDER YOU KNOW
04:02:29.268 --> 04:02:30.335
EVEN SMALL CITIES AFFECT
04:02:30.402 --> 04:02:31.837
THOUSANDS AND THOUSANDS OF BY
04:02:31.904 --> 04:02:34.706
PURCHASE ORDERS AND AND AND IN
04:02:34.773 --> 04:02:35.908
IN CONTRACTS THEY MAY ISSUE.
04:02:35.974 --> 04:02:36.508
IT'S GONNA HAVE TO HAVE US GO
04:02:36.575 --> 04:02:37.542
OUT THERE AND REVIEW AND ENSURE
04:02:37.609 --> 04:02:39.111
THAT WERE NOT ON YOU KNOW THAT
04:02:39.177 --> 04:02:40.712
WE ARE WE ARE IN COMPLIANCE WITH.
04:02:40.779 --> 04:02:42.614
THE LISTING TERM BY THE DOJ --
04:02:42.681 --> 04:02:44.850
ADDITIONALLY ALTHOUGH IT YOU
04:02:44.917 --> 04:02:46.485
THAT THE BURDEN HAS BEEN PLACED
04:02:46.551 --> 04:02:47.986
ON DOJ TO ESTABLISH THIS LESSON
04:02:48.053 --> 04:02:49.488
DOES NOT PROVIDE ANY PROTECTION
04:02:49.554 --> 04:02:50.255
OR DIDN'T VACATION FOR CITIES
04:02:50.322 --> 04:02:53.492
WHO ARE STILL VERY VERY MUCH --
04:02:53.558 --> 04:02:56.161
LIABLE I SHOULD THEY SHOULD THEY
04:02:56.228 --> 04:02:57.963
YOU KNOW NOT K<c.cyan> CONFORM WITH</c>
04:02:58.030 --> 04:02:59.498
THE EVER CHANGING SORT OF BLACK
04:02:59.564 --> 04:03:00.132
LET'S THAT IS BEING CREATED BY
04:03:00.198 --> 04:03:03.769
DOJ -- YOU KNOW IT ALSO YOU KNOW
04:03:03.835 --> 04:03:05.270
ONE OF THE THINGS WE FIND YOU
04:03:05.337 --> 04:03:06.438
KNOW THIS MUCH IS THE THE
04:03:06.505 --> 04:03:06.939
SPONSORS.
04:03:07.005 --> 04:03:08.607
IS VERY NARROWLY SCOPED IF YOU
04:03:08.674 --> 04:03:10.108
LOOK AT SEVEN TWO EIGHT THREE
04:03:10.175 --> 04:03:11.376
POINT FIVE SIX THE BILL IT
04:03:11.443 --> 04:03:14.546
CLEARLY SAYS THAT ALL-- STATURE
04:03:14.613 --> 04:03:16.281
TO BE INTERPRETED BROADLY TO
04:03:16.348 --> 04:03:17.482
EFFECTUATE THE THE TIP TO
04:03:17.549 --> 04:03:18.050
EFFECTUATE THE CHAPTER THAT
04:03:18.116 --> 04:03:18.717
SCARES US.
04:03:18.784 --> 04:03:19.918
BECAUSE NOW YOU'RE LOOKING AT
04:03:19.985 --> 04:03:20.852
THIS FROM THE MOST BROADEST POP
04:03:20.919 --> 04:03:22.454
POSSIBLE TERMS HOW CAN THIS BE
04:03:22.521 --> 04:03:24.122
IMPACTED THIS IS NOT NEARLY IN
04:03:24.189 --> 04:03:26.992
SCOUT -- SO ALL TOLD A. B.
04:03:27.059 --> 04:03:27.592
THIRTEEN THIRTY TWO BUT STILL
04:03:27.659 --> 04:03:28.894
EMPTY THE GOVERNMENT'S ABILITY
04:03:28.961 --> 04:03:29.861
TO LEGAL RESEARCH IT WOULD
04:03:29.928 --> 04:03:30.896
IMPEDE LAW ENFORCEMENT'S ABILITY
04:03:30.963 --> 04:03:32.230
TO UTILIZE A BEST AVAILABLE
04:03:32.297 --> 04:03:42.107
TOOLS TO KEEP THE PUBLIC SAFE --
04:03:42.174 --> 04:03:43.508
IT WOULD HARM AGENCIES ABILITIES
04:03:43.575 --> 04:03:44.543
TO FINANCIAL AND REGULATORY
04:03:44.609 --> 04:03:45.477
OBLIGATIONS I WILL INCREASE THE
04:03:45.544 --> 04:03:47.279
WORKLOAD -- AND DRIVE A COST
04:03:47.346 --> 04:03:49.214
INCREASE DECISIONAL -- AVENUES
04:03:49.281 --> 04:03:50.882
FOR THE EDUCATION. FOR OUR
04:03:50.949 --> 04:03:52.184
CITIES COUNTY SPECIAL DISTRICTS --
04:03:52.250 --> 04:03:53.518
AND AND AGAIN ALL OPPOSED BY
04:03:53.585 --> 04:03:54.553
SAYING WE ARE WE ARE IN A VERY
04:03:54.619 --> 04:03:56.088
PRECARIOUS MOMENT IN TIME YEAH
04:03:56.154 --> 04:03:56.989
I'M AYE AND ON TOP OF ALL MY
04:03:57.055 --> 04:03:57.789
OTHER DUTIES ON THE FEDERAL
04:03:57.856 --> 04:03:58.957
POLICY THE IS ON FOR THE LEAGUE
04:03:59.024 --> 04:03:59.624
OF CITIES AND SO I DEAL WITH ARE.
04:03:59.691 --> 04:04:00.759
SOME OF THAT THE ISSUES WE HAVE
04:04:00.826 --> 04:04:02.928
FEDERALLY EVERYONE FED IN IN DC
04:04:02.995 --> 04:04:04.062
JUST. EIGHTY TALKING ABOUT THAT
04:04:04.129 --> 04:04:05.130
THEY KNOW WHAT'S GOING ON IN
04:04:05.197 --> 04:04:06.031
THIS IS THIS IS A VERY TEMPORARY
04:04:06.098 --> 04:04:07.366
MOMENT IN TIME AND WE'RE PLACING
04:04:07.432 --> 04:04:08.433
LIFELONG.
04:04:08.500 --> 04:04:10.135
YOU KNOW IT BE YOU KNOW A
04:04:10.202 --> 04:04:12.204
RESTRICTIONS ON ON ON ON
04:04:12.270 --> 04:04:13.872
CONTRACTS IS VERY VERY GOOD
04:04:13.939 --> 04:04:15.207
COMPANIES THAT ACTUALLY SERVE
04:04:15.273 --> 04:04:16.074
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS AND SERVE THE
04:04:16.141 --> 04:04:18.076
PEOPLE THAT WE REPRESENT SO WITH
04:04:18.143 --> 04:04:18.410
THAT WE MUST.
04:04:18.477 --> 04:04:20.312
CONTINUE TO OPPOSE.
04:04:20.379 --> 04:04:20.846
THANK YOU ANYONE ELSE IN
04:04:20.912 --> 04:04:22.748
OPPOSITION YOU GIVE US YOUR NAME
04:04:22.814 --> 04:04:24.583
AND YOUR AFFILIATION PLEASE GOOD
04:04:24.649 --> 04:04:25.083
MORNING MR TURN MEMBERS
04:04:25.150 --> 04:04:25.884
COURCELLES ALONE BEHALF THE
04:04:25.951 --> 04:04:31.123
CALIFORNIA STATE SHERIFFS
04:04:31.189 --> 04:04:33.892
ASSOCIATION IN OPPOSITION.
04:04:33.959 --> 04:04:34.459
BELIEVE A POINT IS HERE ON
04:04:34.526 --> 04:04:35.093
BEHALF OF THE ASSOCIATED GENERAL
04:04:35.160 --> 04:04:35.660
CONTRACTORS A CALIFORNIA IN
04:04:35.727 --> 04:04:37.596
OPPOSITION.
04:04:37.662 --> 04:04:38.497
MAX PER THE CALIFORNIA POLICE
04:04:38.563 --> 04:04:39.865
CHIEFS ASSOCIATION AND THE CITY
04:04:39.931 --> 04:04:40.632
OF RIVERSIDE ALSO IN OPPOSITION
04:04:40.699 --> 04:04:43.468
THANK YOU.
04:04:43.535 --> 04:04:43.969
CORNING GENTLE TECHNION
04:04:44.036 --> 04:04:46.705
OPPOSITION.
04:04:46.772 --> 04:04:47.305
THOROUGHBRED ON BEHALF OF THE
04:04:47.372 --> 04:04:49.274
ASSOCIATION OF CALIFORNIA
04:04:49.341 --> 04:04:51.343
HEALTHCARE DISTRICTS OPPOSITION.
04:04:51.410 --> 04:04:52.544
MISTER CHAIR CRISPY KAYLEE ON
04:04:52.611 --> 04:04:53.345
BEHALF OF THE COMPUTING
04:04:53.412 --> 04:04:55.347
TECHNOLOGY INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION
04:04:55.414 --> 04:04:58.050
IN OPPOSITION.
04:04:58.116 --> 04:04:59.217
JEFF NEAL WITH THE CALIFORNIA
04:04:59.284 --> 04:05:00.886
STATE ASSOCIATION OF COUNTIES
04:05:00.952 --> 04:05:03.522
ALSO POST.
04:05:03.588 --> 04:05:05.057
JEAN HEARST HERE TODAY ON BEHALF
04:05:05.123 --> 04:05:06.792
OF THE URBAN COUNTIES OF
04:05:06.858 --> 04:05:08.960
CALIFORNIA ALSO IN OPPOSITION.
04:05:09.027 --> 04:05:09.928
DON'T GIVE US FOR THE CALIFORNIA
04:05:09.995 --> 04:05:11.329
SPECIAL DISTRICTS ASSOCIATION IN
04:05:11.396 --> 04:05:14.132
OPPOSITION.
04:05:14.199 --> 04:05:14.900
CLEAR SHOT HIM WITH THE
04:05:14.966 --> 04:05:16.802
INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY INDUSTRY
04:05:16.868 --> 04:05:19.471
COUNCIL IN OPPOSITION.
04:05:19.538 --> 04:05:19.971
THANK YOU ANYONE ELSE IN
04:05:20.038 --> 04:05:21.640
OPPOSITION.
04:05:21.706 --> 04:05:22.741
I'D SAY NONE OF BRING IT BACK TO
04:05:22.808 --> 04:05:30.382
THE COMMITTEE QUESTIONS COMMENTS.
04:05:30.449 --> 04:05:32.951
SALAS I'M GONNA GO FOR THIS
04:05:33.018 --> 04:05:34.219
OBVIOUSLY I'M OF THE BILL.
04:05:34.286 --> 04:05:35.620
IT HAS BEEN MOVED YET BUT I'M I
04:05:35.687 --> 04:05:36.988
AM CONCERNED.
04:05:37.055 --> 04:05:38.356
I'M GONNA PRESENT A BILL TODAY
04:05:38.423 --> 04:05:40.025
IN THE MORE WE LEARN.
04:05:40.092 --> 04:05:41.860
THE MORE WE REALIZE -- THERE ARE
04:05:41.927 --> 04:05:44.229
NO ASSURANCES WE CAN MAKE TO OUR
04:05:44.296 --> 04:05:48.133
COMMUNITIES ABOUT THEIR DATA --
04:05:48.200 --> 04:05:49.801
IT DOESN'T MATTER WHO WE
04:05:49.868 --> 04:05:51.703
CONTRACT WITH OUR OWN. EIGHT
04:05:51.770 --> 04:05:53.305
GOVERNMENT HAS.
04:05:53.371 --> 04:05:55.807
ALLOWED OUR DATA TO BE SHARED
04:05:55.874 --> 04:05:57.943
WITH THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT --
04:05:58.009 --> 04:06:01.580
UNDER A VARIETY OF OF THE
04:06:01.646 --> 04:06:03.815
PROVISIONS IN OUR LAW WE WE HAD
04:06:03.882 --> 04:06:04.950
A MEETING YESTERDAY WITH THE DOJ
04:06:05.016 --> 04:06:07.385
M. AND THE GOVERNOR'S OFFICE AND
04:06:07.452 --> 04:06:09.121
I THINK I I'M.
04:06:09.187 --> 04:06:11.089
A LITTLE TAKEN ABACK SO.
04:06:11.156 --> 04:06:11.690
NOTHING THAT WE SHOULDN'T DO
04:06:11.756 --> 04:06:14.526
ANYTHING -- BUT I I'M GOING MORE
04:06:14.593 --> 04:06:15.360
MORE CONCERNED THAT WE'RE GIVING
04:06:15.427 --> 04:06:16.428
FALSE.
04:06:16.495 --> 04:06:18.130
PROMISES TO OUR COMMUNITIES
04:06:18.196 --> 04:06:19.564
ABOUT THEIR DATA AND ARE IN
04:06:19.631 --> 04:06:22.534
ABOUT OUR ABILITY TO STOP --
04:06:22.601 --> 04:06:24.269
DERANGED PRESIDENT PROBLEM FROM
04:06:24.336 --> 04:06:27.172
UTILIZING NOT -- TO TERRORIZE
04:06:27.239 --> 04:06:29.374
OUR COMMUNITY SOUTH I'M GONNA
04:06:29.441 --> 04:06:31.109
SUPPORT THIS TODAY I WANT TO
04:06:31.176 --> 04:06:32.844
CONTINUE TO WORK WITH -- THAT
04:06:32.911 --> 04:06:34.579
THE AUTHOR ON THIS BECAUSE I
04:06:34.646 --> 04:06:36.615
THINK THAT THAT IS AN IMPORTANT
04:06:36.681 --> 04:06:38.517
FEATURE -- YOU KNOW I'VE BEEN
04:06:38.583 --> 04:06:40.719
ASKED ABOUT THIS BILL LOT IN AND
04:06:40.785 --> 04:06:44.623
HOW IMPORTANT THIS IS AND I'M
04:06:44.689 --> 04:06:45.724
STARTING TO BELIEVE THAT.
04:06:45.790 --> 04:06:46.892
NOTHING WE CAN DO IS REALLY
04:06:46.958 --> 04:06:47.926
GONNA KEEP THE DATA OF OUR
04:06:47.993 --> 04:06:49.528
COMMUNITIES OUT OF THE HANDS.
04:06:49.594 --> 04:06:51.329
OF THIS ADMINISTRATION SO JUST
04:06:51.396 --> 04:06:53.565
THAT'S KIND OF A I DON'T THINK
04:06:53.632 --> 04:06:57.135
SHE WHERE ANYTHING.
04:06:57.202 --> 04:06:58.403
I THINK IT WOULD GIVE A MOST AND
04:06:58.470 --> 04:07:00.405
IS THERE A SECOND.
04:07:00.472 --> 04:07:03.241
THANK YOU AND A SECOND.
04:07:03.308 --> 04:07:04.910
SERVICE BONTA AYE THANK YOU FOR
04:07:04.976 --> 04:07:06.311
BRINGING THIS FORWARD.
04:07:06.378 --> 04:07:07.612
I DO SORT OF SHUDDER WHEN WE
04:07:07.679 --> 04:07:08.680
TALK ABOUT THIS NOTION OF
04:07:08.747 --> 04:07:11.016
SANCTUARY STATE BECAUSE SB FIFTY
04:07:11.082 --> 04:07:12.150
FOUR DID NOT IN FACT CREATE A
04:07:12.217 --> 04:07:13.785
SANCTUARY STATE IT'S THAT'S
04:07:13.852 --> 04:07:15.387
THAT'S JUST POLITICAL RHETORIC.
04:07:15.453 --> 04:07:16.855
I WISH WE COULD I WISH THERE WAS
04:07:16.922 --> 04:07:19.558
MORE THAT THAT WE COULD DO TO
04:07:19.624 --> 04:07:20.258
PROTECT OUR CITIZENS.
04:07:20.325 --> 04:07:23.195
ACTUALLY IN IN.
04:07:23.261 --> 04:07:25.063
THIS NEAR TIME FRAME WHEN WE'RE
04:07:25.130 --> 04:07:27.966
STRUGGLING WITH VERY AGGRESSIVE
04:07:28.033 --> 04:07:30.035
IN ABUSIVE FEDERAL POLICY.
04:07:30.101 --> 04:07:31.636
THE THE ONE POINT THAT THE
04:07:31.703 --> 04:07:32.671
OPPOSITION BRINGS THAT I THINK
04:07:32.737 --> 04:07:34.706
WE NEED TO BE COGNIZANT OF AND
04:07:34.773 --> 04:07:36.007
I'M SUPPORTING THIS BILL AS IT
04:07:36.074 --> 04:07:37.742
AS IT MOVES FORWARD.
04:07:37.809 --> 04:07:39.477
BUT WE'RE PUTTING IN PLACE
04:07:39.544 --> 04:07:40.812
STRUCTURES AND LAWS IN THE STATE
04:07:40.879 --> 04:07:43.281
OF CALIFORNIA THAT ONCE WE GET A
04:07:43.348 --> 04:07:45.050
MORE RATIONAL FEDERAL GOVERNMENT
04:07:45.116 --> 04:07:47.252
WE'RE GONNA PUT PROBABLY HAVE TO
04:07:47.319 --> 04:07:48.853
GO BACK AND FIGURE OUT.
04:07:48.920 --> 04:07:50.655
HOW TO ADDRESS THOSE AND I THINK
04:07:50.722 --> 04:07:51.790
THAT'S SOMETHING THAT WE NEED TO
04:07:51.856 --> 04:07:53.792
BE VERY COGNIZANT UP AS AS WE
04:07:53.858 --> 04:07:55.193
MOVE FORWARD SO WE CAN BE
04:07:55.260 --> 04:07:57.562
PROTECTIVE BUT UNWINDING THINGS
04:07:57.629 --> 04:07:59.698
THAT ARE NO LONGER NECESSARY?
04:07:59.764 --> 04:08:01.099
PERHAPS OVERLY RESTRICTIVE SEEMS
04:08:01.166 --> 04:08:04.135
SOMETHING THAT THAT WE'RE GONNA
04:08:04.202 --> 04:08:07.038
HAVE TO TAKE VERY VERY SERIOUSLY.
04:08:07.105 --> 04:08:08.139
ALL RIGHT -- THIS VOTE TO MAKE
04:08:08.206 --> 04:08:09.708
CLOTHES.
04:08:09.774 --> 04:08:11.309
THANK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO
04:08:11.376 --> 04:08:13.878
PRESENT TODAY I APPRECIATE THE
04:08:13.945 --> 04:08:17.282
CONCERNS RAISED BY THE CHAIR AND
04:08:17.349 --> 04:08:19.317
BY THE PROVISIONS CHAIR -- I
04:08:19.384 --> 04:08:20.585
THINK IT IS IMPORTANT WE DON'T
04:08:20.652 --> 04:08:23.388
OVER PROMISE OUR OUR COMMUNITIES
04:08:23.455 --> 04:08:24.623
WHAT WE MAY NOT BE ABLE TO
04:08:24.689 --> 04:08:26.324
DELIVER.
04:08:26.391 --> 04:08:27.726
BUT I DO THINK THAT THIS BILL
04:08:27.792 --> 04:08:29.227
MAKES IMPORTANT PROGRESS ANIMALS
04:08:29.294 --> 04:08:30.128
IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION IT'S
04:08:30.195 --> 04:08:30.762
HELPFUL.
04:08:30.829 --> 04:08:32.430
IT IT CAN CHANGE LIVES IT CAN
04:08:32.497 --> 04:08:35.367
PROTECT -- CALIFORNIANS IT MIGHT
04:08:35.433 --> 04:08:36.534
NOT BE THE POLICY OR THE CURE
04:08:36.601 --> 04:08:39.371
ALL -- BUT IT IT MAKES PROGRESS
04:08:39.437 --> 04:08:40.772
AND IT IS REALLY IMPORTANT IN
04:08:40.839 --> 04:08:41.806
RESPONSE.
04:08:41.873 --> 04:08:43.375
TO AT THE MOMENT AT AND I
04:08:43.441 --> 04:08:44.342
UNDERSTAND THAT MUCH OF WHAT
04:08:44.409 --> 04:08:45.844
WE'RE DOING TERMS FOR A POLICIES
04:08:45.910 --> 04:08:47.245
MAKING SURE WE WE STAFF FOR
04:08:47.312 --> 04:08:48.613
VALUES TO PROTECT.
04:08:48.680 --> 04:08:50.615
ARM ARE PEOPLE BASED ON THIS
04:08:50.682 --> 04:08:52.384
MOMENT AND IF THE MOMENT CHANGES
04:08:52.450 --> 04:08:53.885
AND I HOPE IT DOES.
04:08:53.952 --> 04:08:55.553
I BELIEVE IT WILL -- WE CAN
04:08:55.620 --> 04:08:56.688
REACT ACCORDINGLY THEN THAT'S
04:08:56.755 --> 04:08:58.256
THE BEAUTY OF HAVING LEGISLATION
04:08:58.323 --> 04:08:59.958
THAT WE INTRODUCED EVERY YEAR --
04:09:00.025 --> 04:09:01.526
NO ONE SAYS THIS IS BEING
04:09:01.593 --> 04:09:02.093
WRITTEN IN STONE BUT THIS IS
04:09:02.160 --> 04:09:03.228
NEEDED NOW.
04:09:03.295 --> 04:09:04.729
AND THIS WILL HELP PEOPLE TODAY.
04:09:04.796 --> 04:09:05.997
AND SO I APPRECIATE THE
04:09:06.064 --> 04:09:10.168
OPPORTUNITY TO PRESENT TODAY AND
04:09:10.235 --> 04:09:11.436
RESPECTFULLY ASK DR -- THANK YOU
04:09:11.503 --> 04:09:12.304
WE DO HAVE A MOTION AND A SECOND
04:09:12.370 --> 04:09:13.071
THAT MOTION IS TO PASS AS
04:09:13.138 --> 04:09:14.606
AMENDED TO APPROPRIATIONS CALL
04:09:14.673 --> 04:09:16.741
THE ROLL PLEASE STONE BY STONE
04:09:16.808 --> 04:09:18.076
AYE GALLAGHER.
04:09:18.143 --> 04:09:18.810
CHAU.
04:09:18.877 --> 04:09:20.111
CHAU AYE CHU.
04:09:20.178 --> 04:09:22.414
CHU AYE GONZALEZ.
04:09:22.480 --> 04:09:24.582
AND SALAS AYE HOLDEN.
04:09:24.649 --> 04:09:26.651
HOLDEN AYE KALRA.
04:09:26.718 --> 04:09:28.987
KALRA AYE KILEY.
04:09:29.054 --> 04:09:31.156
KILEY NO MAIENSCHEIN.
04:09:31.222 --> 04:09:32.724
MAIENSCHEIN I OBERNOLTE.
04:09:32.791 --> 04:09:34.826
OBERNOLTE NO PETRIE-NORRIS
04:09:34.893 --> 04:09:35.126
[inaudible]
04:09:35.193 --> 04:09:40.332
REYES.
04:09:40.398 --> 04:09:41.966
THE BILL IS OUT THANK YOU.
04:09:42.033 --> 04:09:42.767
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR THANK YOU
04:09:42.834 --> 04:09:47.405
COLLEAGUES THANK YOU STAFF THANK
04:09:47.472 --> 04:09:47.972
FOURTEEN NINETY SEVEN MISTER
04:09:48.039 --> 04:10:04.089
HOLD
04:10:27.545 --> 04:10:27.712
[inaudible]
04:10:27.779 --> 04:10:29.647
THIS OLD.
04:10:29.714 --> 04:10:31.082
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR OUT ITS
04:10:31.149 --> 04:10:32.150
BY.
04:10:32.217 --> 04:10:34.853
PLEASURE TO PRESENT A BE
04:10:34.919 --> 04:10:35.420
FOURTEEN NINETY SEVEN TO YOU
04:10:35.487 --> 04:10:37.055
TODAY I WANT TO THANK THE STAFF
04:10:37.122 --> 04:10:39.057
FOR WORKING WITH US AND ALWAYS
04:10:39.124 --> 04:10:40.625
BEING CONSTRUCTED AND AND GUIDES
04:10:40.692 --> 04:10:42.894
US ALSO WOULD LIKE TO THANK OUR
04:10:42.961 --> 04:10:44.763
STAKEHOLDERS WHO HAVE WORKED ARE
04:10:44.829 --> 04:10:46.398
CLOSELY WITH US ON THIS ISSUE AS
04:10:46.464 --> 04:10:49.901
WELL -- A. B. FOURTEEN NINETY
04:10:49.968 --> 04:10:50.969
SEVEN SUBJECTS PROPERTY.
04:10:51.035 --> 04:10:54.272
ON A HOSTED PLATFORM TO ANTI
04:10:54.339 --> 04:10:55.140
DISCRIMINATION LAWS.
04:10:55.206 --> 04:10:55.907
THE CREATION.
04:10:55.974 --> 04:10:59.077
OF OF THE CREATION OF A NEW OF
04:10:59.144 --> 04:11:00.812
NEW MARKETS FACILITATED BY THE
04:11:00.879 --> 04:11:04.783
INTERNET OR A LEGAL GRAY AREA.
04:11:04.849 --> 04:11:07.519
AND EVER CHANGING WORLD IT IS
04:11:07.585 --> 04:11:09.454
NECESSARY OUR LAWS NECESSARY FOR
04:11:09.521 --> 04:11:10.622
LAWS TO REFLECT THE
04:11:10.688 --> 04:11:12.257
TECHNOLOGICAL ADVANCEMENTS THAT
04:11:12.323 --> 04:11:13.591
ARE BEING MADE.
04:11:13.658 --> 04:11:15.093
CURRENTLY THE DEPARTMENT OF FAIR
04:11:15.160 --> 04:11:16.628
EMPLOYMENT AND HOUSING HANDLES
04:11:16.694 --> 04:11:18.363
DISCRIMINATION COMPLAINTS ON
04:11:18.430 --> 04:11:21.366
HOSTING PLATFORMS. FOURTEEN
04:11:21.433 --> 04:11:21.933
NINETY SEVEN WILL CODIFY THE
04:11:22.000 --> 04:11:23.468
CURRENT PRACTICE AND EMPOWER THE
04:11:23.535 --> 04:11:24.469
DEPARTMENT TO CONTINUE
04:11:24.536 --> 04:11:26.104
INVESTIGATING.
04:11:26.171 --> 04:11:28.907
AND HANDLING THESE COMPLAINTS I
04:11:28.973 --> 04:11:29.507
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR AYE
04:11:29.574 --> 04:11:32.277
BUT THANK YOU.
04:11:32.343 --> 04:11:32.877
SO ANYONE WHO'D LIKE TO BEGIN
04:11:32.944 --> 04:11:35.413
SUPPORT.
04:11:35.480 --> 04:11:35.914
SEEING NONE IS THERE ANY
04:11:35.980 --> 04:11:38.450
OPPOSITION.
04:11:38.516 --> 04:11:40.151
SEEING NONE THANK YOU THERE IS A
04:11:40.218 --> 04:11:41.453
MOTION TO HAVE A SECOND AND A
04:11:41.519 --> 04:11:43.688
SECOND.
04:11:43.755 --> 04:11:46.691
ANY COMMENTS FROM COMMITTEE.
04:11:46.758 --> 04:11:47.992
SING THEN MISS ALL THE MAKE
04:11:48.059 --> 04:11:48.760
CLOTHES I RESPECTFULLY ASK HER
04:11:48.827 --> 04:11:50.395
ABOUT THANK YOU.
04:11:50.462 --> 04:11:51.863
THE MOST IT IS TO PASS TO
04:11:51.930 --> 04:11:52.964
APPROPRIATIONS CALL THE ROLL
04:11:53.031 --> 04:11:55.099
PLEASE STONE BY STONE AYE
04:11:55.166 --> 04:11:57.235
GALLAGHER CHAU.
04:11:57.302 --> 04:11:59.804
CHOW I CHIU.
04:11:59.871 --> 04:12:01.206
GONZALEZ.
04:12:01.272 --> 04:12:02.273
GONZALEZ I HOLDEN.
04:12:02.340 --> 04:12:03.808
HOLDEN AYE KALRA.
04:12:03.875 --> 04:12:05.677
KALRA AYE KILEY.
04:12:05.743 --> 04:12:07.512
KILEY AYE MAIENSCHEIN.
04:12:07.579 --> 04:12:09.214
MENTION I OBERNOLTE.
04:12:09.280 --> 04:12:14.252
OBERNOLTE I PETRIE-NORRIS REYES.
04:12:14.319 --> 04:12:15.887
THAT BILL IS OUT THANK YOU AND
04:12:15.954 --> 04:12:17.989
OUR FINAL ITEM IS ITEM TWENTY
04:12:18.056 --> 04:12:19.757
ONE A. B. SEVENTEEN FORTY SEVEN
04:12:19.824 --> 04:12:27.532
MS GONZALEZ.
04:12:27.599 --> 04:12:29.234
MORNING AT EIGHT AFTERNOON
04:12:29.300 --> 04:12:31.503
MISTER CHAIR IT'S STILL MORNING
04:12:31.569 --> 04:12:33.638
ALL RIGHT [inaudible]
04:12:33.705 --> 04:12:36.074
FAIRLY -- SIX YEARS AGO
04:12:36.140 --> 04:12:37.308
CALIFORNIA IMMIGRANTS GAIN THE
04:12:37.375 --> 04:12:38.443
RIGHT TO DRIVER'S LICENSE SO
04:12:38.510 --> 04:12:39.410
THEY COULD BE LAW ABIDING
04:12:39.477 --> 04:12:40.778
DRIVERS AN EFFORT AIMED AT
04:12:40.845 --> 04:12:42.347
PROVIDING US ALL PEACE OF MIND
04:12:42.413 --> 04:12:43.181
ON THE ROAD.
04:12:43.248 --> 04:12:45.083
NOW FEAR IS UNDERMINING THE AB
04:12:45.149 --> 04:12:46.451
SIXTY LICENSE PROGRAM AND IT
04:12:46.518 --> 04:12:47.585
SHOULD.
04:12:47.652 --> 04:12:49.120
RECENT REPORTS HAVE UNCOVERED
04:12:49.187 --> 04:12:51.222
THAT ICE HAS BEEN ACCESSING
04:12:51.289 --> 04:12:52.690
STATE RUN DATABASES CONTAINING
04:12:52.757 --> 04:12:54.292
INFORMATION ABOUT INDIVIDUALS
04:12:54.359 --> 04:12:56.728
WITH LICENSES THAT WERE MADE
04:12:56.794 --> 04:12:58.563
AVAILABLE UNDER AB.
04:12:58.630 --> 04:13:00.098
SIXTY THIS BILL PROHIBITS
04:13:00.164 --> 04:13:01.266
CALIFORNIA LAW ENFORCEMENT
04:13:01.332 --> 04:13:02.934
AGENCIES FROM MAKING THEIR
04:13:03.001 --> 04:13:04.369
DATABASES INCLUDING.
04:13:04.435 --> 04:13:05.537
THOSE MAINTAINED BY PRIVATE
04:13:05.603 --> 04:13:07.205
VENDORS A BELT AVAILABLE FOR THE
04:13:07.272 --> 04:13:08.540
PURPOSE OF IMMIGRATION
04:13:08.606 --> 04:13:09.340
ENFORCEMENT.
04:13:09.407 --> 04:13:10.241
THIS WOULD NOT APPLIED
04:13:10.308 --> 04:13:11.409
INFORMATION WITHIN THOSE
04:13:11.476 --> 04:13:13.311
DATABASES ON INDIVIDUALS WITH AN
04:13:13.378 --> 04:13:15.113
ACTIVE ARREST WARRANT ONE
04:13:15.179 --> 04:13:16.748
FORSMAN AGENCIES WITH ACCESS TO
04:13:16.814 --> 04:13:17.682
CLASS ARE.
04:13:17.749 --> 04:13:19.117
ALLOWED TO ACCESS CERTAIN
04:13:19.183 --> 04:13:20.118
INFORMATION FROM A DRIVER'S
04:13:20.184 --> 04:13:21.886
LICENSE OR IDENTIFICATION CARD
04:13:21.953 --> 04:13:23.588
RECORDS INCLUDING NAME DATE OF
04:13:23.655 --> 04:13:25.390
BIRTH RESIDENTS AND OR MAILING
04:13:25.456 --> 04:13:26.991
ADDRESS AND PHOTOS AS WELL.
04:13:27.058 --> 04:13:28.593
AS ANY PREVIOUS ARREST
04:13:28.660 --> 04:13:30.361
INFORMATION ACCIDENTS IN ANY
04:13:30.428 --> 04:13:32.564
LICENSING ACTIONS TAKEN BY THE
04:13:32.630 --> 04:13:34.032
DMV THE DMB ASSERTS THAT DOES
04:13:34.098 --> 04:13:35.633
NOT RELEASE ANY APPLICANT
04:13:35.700 --> 04:13:36.968
DOCUMENTS EXCEPT IN RESPONSE TO
04:13:37.035 --> 04:13:38.202
A CRIMINAL SUBPOENA.
04:13:38.269 --> 04:13:40.004
A COURT ORDER OR CERTIFICATION
04:13:40.071 --> 04:13:41.205
FROM LAW ENFORCEMENT ATTEMPTING
04:13:41.272 --> 04:13:42.941
TO AN URGENT HEALTH OR SAFETY
04:13:43.007 --> 04:13:43.541
NEED FOR THE RELEASE OF THESE
04:13:43.608 --> 04:13:44.475
DOCUMENTS.
04:13:44.542 --> 04:13:48.112
THESE FEDERAL IMMIGRATION POLICY
04:13:48.179 --> 04:13:48.913
TACTICS ARE CONCERNING.
04:13:48.980 --> 04:13:50.348
AB SEVENTEEN FORTY SEVEN LIMITS
04:13:50.415 --> 04:13:52.050
INVOLVEMENT STATE LOCAL LAW
04:13:52.116 --> 04:13:53.051
ENFORCEMENT AGENCIES IN FEDERAL
04:13:53.117 --> 04:13:54.619
IMMIGRATION ENFORCEMENT IT IS
04:13:54.686 --> 04:13:55.753
IMPERATIVE THAT WE PROTECT THE
04:13:55.820 --> 04:13:57.221
PRIVACY OF CALIFORNIA RESIDENTS
04:13:57.288 --> 04:13:58.356
I UNDERSTAND.
04:13:58.423 --> 04:13:59.223
THAT CURRENTLY THE BILL WILL
04:13:59.290 --> 04:14:01.559
ONLY PARTIALLY ACHIEVE THE GOAL
04:14:01.626 --> 04:14:02.527
TO LIMIT ACCESS TO STATE
04:14:02.594 --> 04:14:03.528
DATABASES FOR IMMIGRATION
04:14:03.595 --> 04:14:04.596
PURPOSES.
04:14:04.662 --> 04:14:05.863
I'M COMMITTED TO WORKING TO
04:14:05.930 --> 04:14:07.732
CLOSE LOOPHOLES ALTHOUGH I'M
04:14:07.799 --> 04:14:10.134
BECOMING LESS.
04:14:10.201 --> 04:14:11.836
ENSURE THAT WE WILL BE ABLE --
04:14:11.903 --> 04:14:13.938
TO BUT FOR TODAY TO MOVE THE
04:14:14.005 --> 04:14:14.572
SPORT I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN
04:14:14.639 --> 04:14:15.373
AYE VOTE.
04:14:15.440 --> 04:14:16.507
THANK YOU AND THERE ARE
04:14:16.574 --> 04:14:17.508
AMENDMENTS IN THE ANALYSIS
04:14:17.575 --> 04:14:18.109
YOU'RE TAKING THOSE YES I AM
04:14:18.176 --> 04:14:19.544
TAKING THE AMENDMENTS THANK YOU
04:14:19.611 --> 04:14:20.678
SO MUCH.
04:14:20.745 --> 04:14:22.947
HI -- GOOD AFTERNOON MY NAME IS
04:14:23.014 --> 04:14:24.282
JOSEPH THE GEL OF DIRECTOR
04:14:24.349 --> 04:14:24.816
POLICY ADVOCATES WHO WOULD
04:14:24.882 --> 04:14:25.817
CHIRLA THE COALITION FOR HUMANE
04:14:25.883 --> 04:14:27.418
IMMIGRANT RIGHTS I'M HERE STRONG
04:14:27.485 --> 04:14:30.254
SUPPORTER OF AB. SEVENTEEN FORTY
04:14:30.321 --> 04:14:31.155
SEVEN HE IMMIGRATION OF FOR
04:14:31.222 --> 04:14:32.790
ENFORCEMENT POSSIBLE FROM HUMAN
04:14:32.857 --> 04:14:34.759
ENFORCEMENT TO AUTOMATED
04:14:34.826 --> 04:14:36.995
ENFORCEMENT WE SOLD A PEAK WIND
04:14:37.061 --> 04:14:38.396
SECURE COMMITTEES -- WAS CREATED
04:14:38.463 --> 04:14:39.797
UNDER THE BUSH ADMINISTRATION
04:14:39.864 --> 04:14:42.233
DID MORE INTO THE PRIORITY
04:14:42.300 --> 04:14:44.102
ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM KNOWN AS BAD --
04:14:44.168 --> 04:14:45.970
THESE AUTOMATED SYSTEMS ARE
04:14:46.037 --> 04:14:47.505
RESULTING IN THE RUSSIAN BETWEEN --
04:14:47.572 --> 04:14:48.873
IMMIGRANT COMMUNITIES AND LAW
04:14:48.940 --> 04:14:50.341
ENFORCEMENT AS WELL AS OTHER
04:14:50.408 --> 04:14:53.277
STATE AGENCIES -- SINCE THE
04:14:53.344 --> 04:14:55.046
ELIMINATION OF AB SIXTY S.
04:14:55.113 --> 04:14:56.648
ONLINE IT CHIRLA HAS HER OF
04:14:56.714 --> 04:15:04.188
CASES BROUGHT TO OUR ATTENTION
04:15:04.255 --> 04:15:06.290
THAT DIEM BE ITS STAFF.
04:15:06.357 --> 04:15:07.025
THE DMB IS THAT I'M SORRY OF
04:15:07.091 --> 04:15:08.526
INDIVIDUALS WHO HAD NO CRIMINAL
04:15:08.593 --> 04:15:11.062
OFFENSE AB JUST IMMIGRATION --
04:15:11.129 --> 04:15:11.763
THE PETITION ORDER ON THE RECORD.
04:15:11.829 --> 04:15:13.931
ONCE THEY GOT A DRIVER LICENSE --
04:15:13.998 --> 04:15:15.033
WE SAW ALL THE EXPERIENCE I WAS
04:15:15.099 --> 04:15:16.000
GOING TO THEIR HOUSE THIS IS
04:15:16.067 --> 04:15:17.769
EXAMPLE OF OF GABRIELLE WHO WAS
04:15:17.835 --> 04:15:19.370
THE REMOVAL PROCEEDINGS A FORMER
04:15:19.437 --> 04:15:20.438
RESIDENT OF WEST COVINA WHO
04:15:20.505 --> 04:15:21.906
APPLY FOR AB SIXTY DRIVER.
04:15:21.973 --> 04:15:23.141
AT USING HIS REAL NAME HE ONLY
04:15:23.207 --> 04:15:23.708
HAD A AT THE PETITION ORDER
04:15:23.775 --> 04:15:25.910
UNDER HIS RECORD WEEKS LATER
04:15:25.977 --> 04:15:27.445
HOMELESS SECURITY INVESTIGATION
04:15:27.512 --> 04:15:29.614
UNIT ICE JUST OF HIS HOUSE AND
04:15:29.681 --> 04:15:30.815
PICKED HIM UP AND DEPORT HIM --
04:15:30.882 --> 04:15:32.250
THIS BILL BILLS ON THE
04:15:32.316 --> 04:15:33.918
PROTECTIONS OF AB SIXTY WITHOUT
04:15:33.985 --> 04:15:36.821
INTERFERING WITH FEDERAL -- LOSS
04:15:36.888 --> 04:15:38.189
AT BUT ALSO MAKE SURE IS THAT
04:15:38.256 --> 04:15:40.491
IMMIGRANTS ARE ARE ENSURE TO
04:15:40.558 --> 04:15:42.026
APPLY FOR A DRIVER'S LICENSING
04:15:42.093 --> 04:15:42.894
INTERACTED AT THE CLOSE A
04:15:42.960 --> 04:15:44.028
LOOPHOLE AND FOR ALL THOSE
04:15:44.095 --> 04:15:45.930
REASONS WE WILL REQUEST AN APPLE.
04:15:45.997 --> 04:15:51.402
THANK YOU THANK YOU ANYONE ELSE
04:15:51.469 --> 04:15:53.838
IN SUPPORT.
04:15:53.905 --> 04:15:54.639
LEYVA RESERVE YOU AT THE
04:15:54.706 --> 04:15:56.841
CALIFORNIA IMMIGRANT POLICY
04:15:56.908 --> 04:15:59.377
CENTER AND STRONG SUPPORT.
04:15:59.444 --> 04:16:00.778
MY ANGER MAYES FAILURE OF
04:16:00.845 --> 04:16:03.247
CALIFORNIANS SUPPORT.
04:16:03.314 --> 04:16:04.949
DANIEL SHARP WITH CUT AS IN THE
04:16:05.016 --> 04:16:06.751
CENTRAL AMERICAN RESOURCE CENTER
04:16:06.818 --> 04:16:10.154
OF CALIFORNIA IN STRONG SUPPORT.
04:16:10.221 --> 04:16:11.422
NO I BOTTOM ALL REPRESENTING
04:16:11.489 --> 04:16:13.091
CALIFORNIA RURAL LEGAL
04:16:13.157 --> 04:16:13.725
ASSISTANCE FOUNDATION IN STRONG
04:16:13.791 --> 04:16:16.728
SUPPORT.
04:16:16.794 --> 04:16:18.362
BRIAN -- FOR SECURE JUST AS
04:16:18.429 --> 04:16:20.331
STRONG SUPPORT THANK YOU.
04:16:20.398 --> 04:16:21.766
AND WHAT ELSE IN SUPPORT SEEING
04:16:21.833 --> 04:16:24.535
NONE IS THERE OPPOSITION.
04:16:24.602 --> 04:16:25.136
SEE NONE OF BRING BACK TO THE
04:16:25.203 --> 04:16:27.071
COMMITTEE [inaudible]
04:16:27.138 --> 04:16:29.073
QUESTIONS COMMENTS [inaudible]
04:16:29.140 --> 04:16:31.709
MOTION.
04:16:31.776 --> 04:16:33.611
SO WE DO HAVE A MOTION AND A
04:16:33.678 --> 04:16:35.279
SECOND.
04:16:35.346 --> 04:16:36.581
WAS WITH ALL TO MAKE CLOTHES.
04:16:36.647 --> 04:16:37.582
THANK YOU YOU KNOW WE PASSED A.
04:16:37.648 --> 04:16:40.251
B. SIXTY IN ORDER TO MAKE OUR
04:16:40.318 --> 04:16:42.019
STREETS SAFER IN -- MANY OF US
04:16:42.086 --> 04:16:43.354
WENT OUT INTO OUR COMMUNITIES
04:16:43.421 --> 04:16:46.023
AND ENCOURAGE FOLKS TO APPLY FOR
04:16:46.090 --> 04:16:47.892
A DRIVER'S LICENSE AND INSURANCE
04:16:47.959 --> 04:16:49.494
AS ENSURE THAT WE HAD.
04:16:49.560 --> 04:16:51.195
FEWER UNLICENSED DRIVERS
04:16:51.262 --> 04:16:52.764
UNINSURED DRIVER CENTER STREET
04:16:52.830 --> 04:16:54.165
WE GAVE THEM ASSURANCES THAT THE
04:16:54.232 --> 04:16:55.333
DMV OF COURSE WOULD NOT SHARE
04:16:55.399 --> 04:16:57.568
THEIR INFORMATION -- EXCEPT THAT
04:16:57.635 --> 04:16:59.237
REQUIRED BY LAW IN LITTLE DID WE
04:16:59.303 --> 04:17:00.271
KNOW THAT REQUIRED A LOT
04:17:00.338 --> 04:17:01.672
INCLUDES CLASS.
04:17:01.739 --> 04:17:03.374
LITTLE DID WE KNOW THAT THAT
04:17:03.441 --> 04:17:05.877
WOULD BE USED -- BY ICE FOR
04:17:05.943 --> 04:17:08.045
DEPORTATION ORDERS -- OR REST TO
04:17:08.112 --> 04:17:10.148
LOOK FOLKS UP AND GET THEIR
04:17:10.214 --> 04:17:11.983
CURRENT ADDRESS AND PHOTO.
04:17:12.049 --> 04:17:13.951
SO NOW WE ARE IN A POSITION TO
04:17:14.018 --> 04:17:15.153
TO A ONE BE HONEST WITH THEIR
04:17:15.219 --> 04:17:16.821
COMMUNITIES ABOUT THE THE
04:17:16.888 --> 04:17:19.257
MISTAKEN ASSURANCES WE GAVE THEM.
04:17:19.323 --> 04:17:20.958
BUT TO TO TRY TO STOP THIS
04:17:21.025 --> 04:17:23.194
PRACTICE FROM HAPPENING NAY --
04:17:23.261 --> 04:17:24.428
RESPECT LAST NIGHT ABOUT.
04:17:24.495 --> 04:17:25.429
THANK YOU WE DO HAVE A MOTION A
04:17:25.496 --> 04:17:26.898
SECOND MOTIONS TO PASS AS
04:17:26.964 --> 04:17:28.366
AMENDED TO APPROPRIATIONS CALL
04:17:28.432 --> 04:17:31.035
THE ROLL PLEASE STONE BYSTONE
04:17:31.102 --> 04:17:31.402
AYE GALLAGHER.
04:17:31.469 --> 04:17:35.573
CHOW.
04:17:35.640 --> 04:17:36.841
CHOW I CHIU.
04:17:36.908 --> 04:17:39.544
GONZALEZ GONZALEZ I HOLDEN.
04:17:39.610 --> 04:17:41.679
HOLDEN AYE KALRA.
04:17:41.746 --> 04:17:43.080
KALRA AYE KILEY.
04:17:43.147 --> 04:17:44.782
KILEY NO MAIENSCHEIN.
04:17:44.849 --> 04:17:46.651
IN CHINA HI OBERNOLTE.
04:17:46.717 --> 04:17:49.053
OBERNOLTE NO PETRIE-NORRIS.
04:17:49.120 --> 04:17:51.222
PETRIE-NORRIS I REYES.
04:17:51.289 --> 04:17:52.757
THAT BILL IS OUT.
04:17:52.824 --> 04:17:54.425
RIGHT WE HAVE QUITE A BIT OF
04:17:54.492 --> 04:17:56.828
CATCH UP WORK TO DO SO WE'RE
04:17:56.894 --> 04:17:58.696
GONNA ROLL THROUGH THE AGENDA.
04:17:58.763 --> 04:18:00.064
STARTING WITH CONSENT CALL THE
04:18:00.131 --> 04:18:00.932
ABSENT MEMBERS.
04:18:00.998 --> 04:18:02.433
GALLAGHER [inaudible]
04:18:02.500 --> 04:18:05.303
CHIU.
04:18:05.369 --> 04:18:07.471
CHIU I HOLDEN.
04:18:07.538 --> 04:18:09.073
HOLDEN AYE KILEY.
04:18:09.140 --> 04:18:10.875
KILEY AYE.
04:18:10.942 --> 04:18:14.145
SO -- ITEM NUMBER TWO AB TWO
04:18:14.212 --> 04:18:14.679
FORTY TWO CALL THE ABSENT
04:18:14.745 --> 04:18:15.279
MEMBERS.
04:18:15.346 --> 04:18:17.181
GALLAGHER.
04:18:17.248 --> 04:18:18.216
CHU.
04:18:18.282 --> 04:18:20.451
CHU AYE HOLDEN.
04:18:20.518 --> 04:18:23.955
HOLDEN AYE KILEY.
04:18:24.021 --> 04:18:27.191
ITEM NUMBER THREE IS ON CALL AB
04:18:27.258 --> 04:18:27.792
THREE SEVENTY EIGHT I'M GONNA
04:18:27.859 --> 04:18:29.160
LIFT THE CALL [inaudible]
04:18:29.227 --> 04:18:31.095
CHAU.
04:18:31.162 --> 04:18:32.597
CHAO AYE CHU.
04:18:32.663 --> 04:18:34.699
CHU AYE KILEY.
04:18:34.765 --> 04:18:36.968
KILEY NO OBERNOLTE.
04:18:37.034 --> 04:18:39.904
OBERNOLTE NO RADIUS.
04:18:39.971 --> 04:18:42.173
THE BILL IS OUT ITEM NUMBER FOUR
04:18:42.240 --> 04:18:45.610
IS AB FOUR OH THREE IS ON CALL
04:18:45.676 --> 04:18:47.278
I'M GONNA LIFT THE CALL.
04:18:47.345 --> 04:18:50.781
GALLAGHER CHOW CHOW I CHU.
04:18:50.848 --> 04:18:52.450
CHU AYE KILEY.
04:18:52.516 --> 04:18:54.485
KILEY NO MAIENSCHEIN MAIENSCHEIN
04:18:54.552 --> 04:18:56.988
I OBERNOLTE OBERNOLTE NO
04:18:57.054 --> 04:18:59.490
PETRIE-NORRIS.
04:18:59.557 --> 04:19:00.925
PETRIE-NORRIS I REYES.
04:19:00.992 --> 04:19:03.461
THAT BILL IS OUT ITEM NUMBER
04:19:03.527 --> 04:19:05.429
FIVE AB SEVEN TWENTY FOUR IS ON
04:19:05.496 --> 04:19:06.530
CALL I'M GONNA LIFT THE CALL
04:19:06.597 --> 04:19:06.831
[inaudible]
04:19:06.898 --> 04:19:09.033
CHAO [inaudible]
04:19:09.100 --> 04:19:13.037
CHIU. TWO I KILEY.
04:19:13.104 --> 04:19:15.072
MAIENSCHEIN MAIENSCHEIN I
04:19:15.139 --> 04:19:16.874
OBERNOLTE.
04:19:16.941 --> 04:19:20.711
OBERNOLTE NO REYES.
04:19:20.778 --> 04:19:24.248
THAT BILL IS OUT ITEM NUMBER.
04:19:24.315 --> 04:19:25.016
SIX CALL THE UP THE MEMBERS
04:19:25.082 --> 04:19:28.085
PLEASE AB SEVEN FIFTY EIGHT
04:19:28.152 --> 04:19:29.887
CARILLO CHOW.
04:19:29.954 --> 04:19:32.290
CHOW I CHU.
04:19:32.356 --> 04:19:36.260
CHU AYE KILEY.
04:19:36.327 --> 04:19:37.929
ITEM NUMBER SEVEN ALREADY PASSED
04:19:37.995 --> 04:19:39.597
THAT IS AB EIGHT THIRTEEN
04:19:39.664 --> 04:19:42.199
FRAZIER CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
04:19:42.266 --> 04:19:42.466
GALLAGHER.
04:19:42.533 --> 04:19:44.101
CHIU.
04:19:44.168 --> 04:19:45.903
CHIU AYE HOLDEN.
04:19:45.970 --> 04:19:47.438
HOLDEN AYE KILEY.
04:19:47.505 --> 04:19:48.839
KILEY AYE.
04:19:48.906 --> 04:19:51.275
ITEM NUMBER EIGHT AB TEN SEVENTY
04:19:51.342 --> 04:19:53.244
THREE RUBIO IS ON CALL MIDDLE IF
04:19:53.311 --> 04:19:54.979
THE CALL.
04:19:55.046 --> 04:19:55.279
GALLAGHER.
04:19:55.346 --> 04:19:57.214
CHOW.
04:19:57.281 --> 04:20:03.454
CHOW I CHIU.
04:20:03.521 --> 04:20:04.956
CHIU I KILEY NUMBER.
04:20:05.022 --> 04:20:06.457
MAIENSCHEIN.
04:20:06.524 --> 04:20:08.092
MAIENSCHEIN I OBERNOLTE
04:20:08.159 --> 04:20:08.392
[inaudible]
04:20:08.459 --> 04:20:11.262
REYES.
04:20:11.329 --> 04:20:13.497
THAT BILL IS OUT ITEM NUMBER
04:20:13.564 --> 04:20:15.633
NINE AB ELEVEN SIXTY TWO KALRA
04:20:15.700 --> 04:20:17.435
HAS ALREADY PASSED CALL THE UP
04:20:17.501 --> 04:20:20.071
TO MEMBERS CHAO.
04:20:20.137 --> 04:20:22.306
CHAO AYE CHU.
04:20:22.373 --> 04:20:24.108
CHU AYE KILEY.
04:20:24.175 --> 04:20:25.476
KILEY DOWN.
04:20:25.543 --> 04:20:28.446
ITEM NUMBER TEN ELEVEN EIGHTY AB
04:20:28.512 --> 04:20:29.046
ELEVEN EIGHTY FOUR GLORIA HAS
04:20:29.113 --> 04:20:30.281
ALREADY PASSED CALL THE OF THE
04:20:30.348 --> 04:20:31.582
MEMBERS GALLAGHER.
04:20:31.649 --> 04:20:32.950
CHU.
04:20:33.017 --> 04:20:35.119
CHU AYE HOLDEN.
04:20:35.186 --> 04:20:36.821
HOLDEN AYE KILEY [inaudible]
04:20:36.887 --> 04:20:38.789
KILEY AYE.
04:20:38.856 --> 04:20:41.492
ITEM NUMBER ELEVEN AB THIRTEEN
04:20:41.559 --> 04:20:42.259
TWENTY FOUR LEVINE HAS ALREADY
04:20:42.326 --> 04:20:43.861
PASSED CALL THE OF THE MEMBERS
04:20:43.928 --> 04:20:45.162
GALLAGHER.
04:20:45.229 --> 04:20:46.397
CHU.
04:20:46.464 --> 04:20:48.532
CHU AYE HOLDEN.
04:20:48.599 --> 04:20:52.236
HOLDEN AYE KILEY KILEY NO.
04:20:52.303 --> 04:20:54.839
ITEM NUMBER TWELVE AB THIRTEEN
04:20:54.905 --> 04:20:56.107
THIRTY TWO BONTA CALL THE ABSENT
04:20:56.173 --> 04:20:58.376
MEMBERS GALLAGHER [inaudible]
04:20:58.442 --> 04:21:00.077
PETRIE-NORRIS.
04:21:00.144 --> 04:21:02.079
PETRIE-NORRIS I REYES.
04:21:02.146 --> 04:21:04.882
I REMEMBER THIRTEEN AB THIRTEEN
04:21:04.949 --> 04:21:07.118
FORTY TWO LOCAL THE UPS A MEMBER
04:21:07.184 --> 04:21:08.986
GALLAGHER CHU.
04:21:09.053 --> 04:21:10.855
CHU AYE HOLDEN.
04:21:10.921 --> 04:21:12.056
HOLDEN AYE KILEY.
04:21:12.123 --> 04:21:13.290
KILEY NO.
04:21:13.357 --> 04:21:15.926
ITEM NUMBER FOURTEEN A. B.
04:21:15.993 --> 04:21:16.827
THIRTEEN SIXTY IS ON A CALL OF A
04:21:16.894 --> 04:21:18.162
LIFT THE CALL.
04:21:18.229 --> 04:21:19.830
GALLAGHER CHOW.
04:21:19.897 --> 04:21:21.165
CHOW I CHU.
04:21:21.232 --> 04:21:22.533
CHU AYE KILEY.
04:21:22.600 --> 04:21:24.702
KILEY NO MAIENSCHEIN MAIENSCHEIN
04:21:24.769 --> 04:21:27.338
AYE OBERNOLTE.
04:21:27.405 --> 04:21:30.741
OBERNOLTE NO RADIUS.
04:21:30.808 --> 04:21:31.809
THAT BILL IS OUT.
04:21:31.876 --> 04:21:34.779
I REMEMBER FIFTEEN AB FOURTEEN
04:21:34.845 --> 04:21:35.946
SEVENTEEN RUBIO IS ON CALL IN A
04:21:36.013 --> 04:21:37.615
LIFT THE CALL.
04:21:37.681 --> 04:21:39.116
GALLAGHER CHOW.
04:21:39.183 --> 04:21:41.185
CHOW I CHU.
04:21:41.252 --> 04:21:43.421
CHU AYE KILEY.
04:21:43.487 --> 04:21:45.256
KILEY NO MAIENSCHEIN.
04:21:45.322 --> 04:21:46.190
MAIENSCHEIN I OBERNOLTE.
04:21:46.257 --> 04:21:49.427
OBERNOLTE NO PETRIE-NORRIS.
04:21:49.493 --> 04:21:51.629
PETRIE-NORRIS I REYES.
04:21:51.695 --> 04:21:53.130
THAT BILL IS OUT.
04:21:53.197 --> 04:21:56.167
ITEM NUMBER SIXTEEN A. B.
04:21:56.233 --> 04:21:57.401
FOURTEEN NINETY SEVEN HOLDEN
04:21:57.468 --> 04:21:58.936
CALL THE OF SOME MEMBERS
04:21:59.003 --> 04:21:59.203
GALLAGHER.
04:21:59.270 --> 04:22:03.140
CHIU. TWO I PETRIE-NORRIS
04:22:03.207 --> 04:22:03.441
[inaudible]
04:22:03.507 --> 04:22:05.276
PETRIE-NORRIS IRIS.
04:22:05.342 --> 04:22:08.646
ITEM NUMBER SEVENTEEN AB SIX
04:22:08.712 --> 04:22:10.047
ZERO SEVEN BURNER HORVATH IS ON
04:22:10.114 --> 04:22:12.817
CALL IN A LIFT THE CALL CHOW.
04:22:12.883 --> 04:22:15.119
CHOW I CHU.
04:22:15.186 --> 04:22:17.221
CHU AYE KILEY.
04:22:17.288 --> 04:22:18.756
KILEY AYE MAIENSCHEIN
04:22:18.823 --> 04:22:20.691
MAIENSCHEIN AYE OBERNOLTE
04:22:20.758 --> 04:22:22.393
OBERNOLTE AYE RADIUS.
04:22:22.460 --> 04:22:24.929
THAT BILL IS OUT ITEM NUMBER.
04:22:24.995 --> 04:22:26.931
EIGHTEEN AB SIXTEEN TWENTY EIGHT
04:22:26.997 --> 04:22:28.699
REVERSE ROBERT RIVAS IS ON CALL
04:22:28.766 --> 04:22:30.434
AND LIFT THE CALL.
04:22:30.501 --> 04:22:33.771
CHOW CHOW I CHU.
04:22:33.838 --> 04:22:35.206
CHU AYE KALRA.
04:22:35.272 --> 04:22:37.208
KALRA AYE KILEY.
04:22:37.274 --> 04:22:39.810
KILEY NO OBERNOLTE OBERNOLTE NO
04:22:39.877 --> 04:22:41.178
RAMOS.
04:22:41.245 --> 04:22:46.350
AND GALLAGHER NO.
04:22:46.417 --> 04:22:47.718
THE BILL IS OUT.
04:22:47.785 --> 04:22:51.522
ITEM NUMBER NINETEEN A. B.
04:22:51.589 --> 04:22:52.089
SIXTEEN SIXTY SEVEN SANTIAGO
04:22:52.156 --> 04:22:53.657
CHAO.
04:22:53.724 --> 04:22:55.659
CHAO AYE CHU.
04:22:55.726 --> 04:22:57.661
CHU AYE HOLDEN.
04:22:57.728 --> 04:22:59.497
HOLDEN AYE KILEY [inaudible]
04:22:59.563 --> 04:23:00.664
KILEY AYE.
04:23:00.731 --> 04:23:03.134
I REMEMBER TWENTY AB SIXTEEN
04:23:03.200 --> 04:23:04.568
SEVENTY TWO BLOOM CALL THE UP TO
04:23:04.635 --> 04:23:05.336
MEMBERS.
04:23:05.402 --> 04:23:07.304
CHAO.
04:23:07.371 --> 04:23:09.607
CHAO AYE CHU.
04:23:09.673 --> 04:23:11.842
CHU AYE KILEY.
04:23:11.909 --> 04:23:15.679
ITEM NUMBER TWENTY ONE AB
04:23:15.746 --> 04:23:16.280
SEVENTEEN FORTY SEVEN GONZALEZ
04:23:16.347 --> 04:23:16.780
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
04:23:16.847 --> 04:23:17.081
[inaudible]
04:23:17.148 --> 04:23:21.519
GALLAGHER.
04:23:21.585 --> 04:23:21.886
CHIU.
04:23:21.952 --> 04:23:25.122
CHIU I REYES [inaudible]
04:23:25.189 --> 04:23:29.160
REYES AYE [inaudible]
04:23:29.226 --> 04:23:30.094
GALLAGHER NO.
04:23:30.161 --> 04:23:32.563
ITEM NUMBER TWENTY TWO AB
04:23:32.630 --> 04:23:33.797
SEVENTEEN FIFTY THREE CARILLO
04:23:33.864 --> 04:23:35.900
SOKOLOVA LIFT THE CALL.
04:23:35.966 --> 04:23:37.635
CHOW.
04:23:37.701 --> 04:23:41.705
CHOW I CHIU. TO AYE KILEY.
04:23:41.772 --> 04:23:42.973
KILEY NO MAIENSCHEIN.
04:23:43.040 --> 04:23:44.942
MAIENSCHEIN I OBERNOLTE.
04:23:45.009 --> 04:23:47.278
OBERNOLTE NO RADIUS.
04:23:47.344 --> 04:23:48.312
REYES AYE.
04:23:48.379 --> 04:23:49.313
THAT BILL IS OUT RIGHT WILL GO
04:23:49.380 --> 04:23:51.682
BACK TO THE LIST ONE MORE TIME.
04:23:51.749 --> 04:23:53.517
EVERY BILL HAS PASSED THIS
04:23:53.584 --> 04:23:55.019
COMMITTEE SO WE'RE JUST AT
04:23:55.085 --> 04:23:57.121
ALLOWING ADD ONS TO THE
04:23:57.188 --> 04:23:57.521
DIFFERENT BILLS.
04:23:57.588 --> 04:23:58.556
THE CONSENT.
04:23:58.622 --> 04:24:01.125
CALENDAR PLEASE GALLAGHER.
04:24:01.192 --> 04:24:05.296
GALLAGHER I I REMEMBER TO AB
04:24:05.362 --> 04:24:05.596
[inaudible]
04:24:05.663 --> 04:24:09.967
TWO FORTY TWO GALLAGHER.
04:24:10.034 --> 04:24:12.369
ITEM NUMBER THREE AB THREE
04:24:12.436 --> 04:24:13.437
SEVENTY EIGHT Là M<c.cyan></c>
04:24:13.504 --> 04:24:13.737
[inaudible]
04:24:13.804 --> 04:24:16.240
REYES [inaudible]
04:24:16.307 --> 04:24:20.211
REYES I ITEM NUMBER FOR A BEFORE
04:24:20.277 --> 04:24:20.544
THREE KALRA.
04:24:20.611 --> 04:24:22.646
GALLAGHER.
04:24:22.713 --> 04:24:24.548
GALLAGHER NO RADIUS.
04:24:24.615 --> 04:24:25.382
REYES AYE.
04:24:25.449 --> 04:24:29.320
ITEM NUMBER FIVE A. B. SEVEN
04:24:29.386 --> 04:24:29.720
TWENTY FOUR WEEKS.
04:24:29.787 --> 04:24:31.121
REYES [inaudible]
04:24:31.188 --> 04:24:32.289
HI.
04:24:32.356 --> 04:24:33.724
BUT A NUMBER SIX AB SEVEN FIFTY
04:24:33.791 --> 04:24:34.925
EIGHT CARILLO.
04:24:34.992 --> 04:24:38.062
OKAY ITEM NUMBER SEVEN AB EIGHT
04:24:38.128 --> 04:24:39.663
THIRTEEN FRAZIER GALLAGHER.
04:24:39.730 --> 04:24:41.432
GALLAGHER AYE.
04:24:41.498 --> 04:24:44.435
ITEM NUMBER EIGHT AB TEN SEVENTY
04:24:44.501 --> 04:24:48.872
THREE RUBIO GALLAGHER.
04:24:48.939 --> 04:24:51.575
RAMOS I REYES AYE.
04:24:51.642 --> 04:24:53.210
ITEM NUMBER NINE AB ELEVEN SIXTY
04:24:53.277 --> 04:24:54.011
TWO KALRA.
04:24:54.078 --> 04:24:56.480
GOT EVERYBODY ITEM NUMBER TEN A.
04:24:56.547 --> 04:24:57.915
B. ELEVEN EIGHTY FOUR GLORIA.
04:24:57.982 --> 04:25:03.854
GALLAGHER.
04:25:03.921 --> 04:25:06.357
ITEM NUMBER ELEVEN AB THIRTEEN
04:25:06.423 --> 04:25:10.394
TWENTY FOUR LEVINE GALLAGHER
04:25:10.461 --> 04:25:10.694
[inaudible]
04:25:10.761 --> 04:25:12.062
GALLAGHER DON'T.
04:25:12.129 --> 04:25:14.531
I REMEMBER TWELVE A. B. THIRTEEN
04:25:14.598 --> 04:25:17.868
THIRTY TWO BONTA GALLAGHER.
04:25:17.935 --> 04:25:19.870
GALLAGHER NO RADIUS [inaudible]
04:25:19.937 --> 04:25:23.841
I I'VE NEVER THIRTEEN A. B.
04:25:23.907 --> 04:25:24.341
THIRTEEN FORTY TWO LOW.
04:25:24.408 --> 04:25:25.342
GALLAGHER.
04:25:25.409 --> 04:25:26.910
GALLAGHER NO.
04:25:26.977 --> 04:25:28.279
ITEM NUMBER FOURTEEN A. B.
04:25:28.345 --> 04:25:29.947
THIRTEEN SIXTY TING.
04:25:30.014 --> 04:25:31.749
GALLAGHER.
04:25:31.815 --> 04:25:33.384
GALLAGHER NO RADIUS.
04:25:33.450 --> 04:25:34.418
REYES HI.
04:25:34.485 --> 04:25:36.754
I DO NUMBER FIFTEEN A. B.
04:25:36.820 --> 04:25:37.955
FOURTEEN SEVENTEEN RUBIO
04:25:38.022 --> 04:25:38.255
[inaudible]
04:25:38.322 --> 04:25:40.824
GALLAGHER [inaudible]
04:25:40.891 --> 04:25:42.459
RAMOS.
04:25:42.526 --> 04:25:44.928
REYES SIDE I HAVE OVER SIXTEEN
04:25:44.995 --> 04:25:46.930
A. B. FOURTEEN NINETY SEVEN
04:25:46.997 --> 04:25:47.164
HOLDEN.
04:25:47.231 --> 04:25:48.899
GALLAGHER.
04:25:48.966 --> 04:25:50.501
GALLAGHER AYE RADIUS.
04:25:50.567 --> 04:25:53.604
REYES AYE BOTTOM NUMBER
04:25:53.671 --> 04:25:54.872
SEVENTEEN BURNER HERVE.
04:25:54.938 --> 04:25:57.241
RADIUS.
04:25:57.308 --> 04:25:58.409
REYES AYE.
04:25:58.475 --> 04:26:00.411
I'VE NEVER EIGHTEEN AB SIXTEEN
04:26:00.477 --> 04:26:01.612
TWENTY EIGHT REVERSE ROBERT
04:26:01.679 --> 04:26:03.480
RIVAS RADIUS.
04:26:03.547 --> 04:26:04.081
REYES AYE.
04:26:04.148 --> 04:26:06.383
I REMEMBER NINETEEN AB SIXTEEN
04:26:06.450 --> 04:26:06.984
SIXTEEN SEVEN SANTIAGO WE HAVE
04:26:07.051 --> 04:26:09.987
EVERYBODY ITEM NUMBER TWENTY AB
04:26:10.054 --> 04:26:10.721
SIXTEEN SEVENTY TWO BLOOM.
04:26:10.788 --> 04:26:15.192
THAT EVERYBODY I REMEMBER TWENTY
04:26:15.259 --> 04:26:19.563
ONE WE HAVE EVERYONE ITEM.TWENTY TWO ALL RIGHT WE HAVE
04:26:19.630 --> 04:26:20.130
EVERYONE THANK YOU FOR YOUR
04:26:20.197 --> 04:26:37.581
PATIENCE WE ARE ADJOURNED