HI WELCOME BACK TO THE MEETING OF THE ASSEMBLY HOUSING
COMMITTEE HELD A MEETING OF JUNE THE EIGHTH TWENTY TWENTY
ONE AT THIS POINT WE DO HAVE ENOUGH MEMBERS TO ESTABLISH A
QUORUM MADAM SECRETARY COULD YOU PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
Q.
HERE SHE'LL HERE AIRTEL AIRTEL HERE GABRIEL KALRA KILEY
KEVIN KILEY HERE MAIENSCHEIN QUIKSILVER HERE QUICK SILVER
HAIR WICKS LOOKS HERE AS I PREVIOUSLY STATED -- WE ARE
OBSERVING COVER NINETEEN SAFETY CONSIDERATIONS WHICH MEANS
PHYSICAL DISTANCING HERE IN THE COMMITTEE ROOM -- IT ALSO MEANS
THAT WE HAVE INDIVIDUALS WHO ARE TESTIFYING NOT JUST IN THIS
ROOM BUT AT OUR WITNESS VIDEO CONFERENCING ROOM AS WELL AS
OUR REMOTE TESTIMONY STATIONS AS WELL AS FOR MODERATE A
TELEPHONE SERVICE WHERE THE CALL IN NUMBER IS EIGHT SEVEN
SEVEN SIX NINE TWO EIGHT NINE FIVE SEVEN ACCESS CODE ONE
THREE ONE FIVE FOUR TWO OH TWO IF ANYONE HAS ANY QUESTIONS
YOU CAN CALL COMMITTEE AT NINE SIX THREE ONE NINE TWO ZERO
EIGHT FIVE AND WE ARE ALSO ACCEPTING WRITTEN TESTIMONY
ARE AND I'LL JUST MENTION THAT FOR ME WITNESSES EITHER SUPPORT
OR OPPOSITION EACH BUILDING UP TO THE MAIN WITNESSES
WILL GET TWO MINUTES EACH AND THEN FOR ALL OF THE WITNESSES
WHEN CALLING TO REGISTER YOUR SUPPORT OPPOSITION PLEASE STATE
ONLY YOUR NAME ORGANIZATION FOR SENATE BILL WITH THAT WE HAVE
FIVE BILLS ON OUR GENDER WE HAVE TWO BILLS ON CONSENT I'D
LIKE TO TAKE A MOTION TO BEFORE THE CONSENT AGENDA IS THERE
SECOND SECOND THERE'S A MOTION AND A SECOND ITEM SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL SO SB FOUR THREE TWO TO PASS TO THE
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY AND SB FIVE EIGHTY ONE TO PASS
TO THE ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS SHE'LL SHE'LL
I'D SAY ARE TÔI C.
R.
TO AYE GABRIEL GABRIEL I KALRA KILEY KILEY AYE MAIENSCHEIN
QUICK SILVA QUIKSILVER I WICKS LICKS I CONSENT TO JUMP PASSES
THAT'S NOT GOING FALL WATER TO FILE ITEM ONE SB THREE
NINETY ONE SENATOR MEN THANK YOU FOR PATIENTS THANK YOU
CHURCHILL THANK YOU MEMBERS THANKING THE COMMITTEE STAFF
OF AND WORKING WITH US ON THIS BILL SB THREE NINETY ONE
AS AN EMERGENCY MEASURE THAT AUTHORIZES COMMON INTEREST
DEVELOPMENT BOARDS INCLUDING HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATIONS TO
SAFELY MEET VIA TELECONFERENCE DURING EMERGENCIES AND
DISASTERS INSURERS THAT FAIR PARTICIPATION IN THESE MEETINGS
IS ASSESSABLE TO MEMBERS IN RESPONSE TO THE ONGOING
PANDEMIC THE GOVERNOR ISSUED AN EXECUTIVE ORDER LAST YEAR
ALLOWING LOCAL GOVERNMENT AND STATE AGENCIES TO MEET AND
VOTE REMOTELY YOU KNOW SIMILAR ACTION HAS YET BEEN TAKEN
FOR HOAS THE DAVIS STERLING COMMON INTEREST DEVELOPMENT ACT
REQUIRES A CHOICE TO PROVIDE A PHYSICAL MEETING LOCATION FOR
ALL TELECONFERENCE MEETINGS WHICH AS YOU CAN IMAGINE AS
POSE A SIGNIFICANT HEALTH RISK IN THE MIDST OF THE ONGOING
PANDEMIC IN THE LAST YEAR HOAS HAVE FOUND THAT IT ORGANIZING
IN PERSON MEETINGS AS CURRENTLY REQUIRED UNDER EXISTING LAW HAS
OFTEN BEEN IMPRACTICAL ON SAFE OR EVEN LEGAL SOME OF THESE
HOAS HAVE CONDUCTED MEETINGS BY VIDEO OR PHONE WITH LIMITED
OR NO PROCEDURES IN RESPONSE TO THIS CALIFORNIA CALIFORNIA
LAW REVISION COMMISSION WORK LAST FALL TO CRAFT A VERY
NARROW POLICY RECOMMENDATION AND THAT IS WHAT SITS BEFORE
YOU TODAY SB THREE NINETY ONE SIMPLY WAIVE THE REQUIREMENT
TO PROVIDE AN IN PERSON MEETING LOCATION FOR TELECONFERENCE
MEETINGS DURING A DECLARED EMERGENCY OR DISASTER AND
PROVIDES PROCEDURES FOR THOSE TELECONFERENCE MEETINGS TO
ENSURE THAT PARTICIPATION IS FULLY ACCESSIBLE TO MEMBERS
THIS BILL REQUIRES HOAS TO FULFILL THE FOLLOWING
REQUIREMENTS THEY MUST PROVIDE CLEAR TECHNICAL
ASSISTANCE INSTRUCTIONS ON HOW TO PARTICIPATE THE MEETING
NOTICE MUST INCLUDE THE TELEPHONE NUMBER AND EMAIL
OF A PERSON WHO CAN PROVIDE TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE WITH THE
TELECONFERENCE PROCESS BOTH BEFORE AND DURING THE MEETING
THEY MUST ENSURE THAT EVERY DIRECTOR AND MEMBER HAS THE
SAME ABILITY TO PARTICIPATE IN THE MEETING THAT WOULD EXIST IF
THE MEETING WERE HELD IN PERSON ANY VOTE OF THE DIRECTOR SHALL
BE CONDUCTED BY A ROLL CALL VOTE AND LASTLY PARTICIPATION
PRESIDENT SHALL BE GIVEN THE OPTION OF PARTICIPATING BY
PHONE FROM WILDFIRES TO GLOBAL PANDEMICS RECENT EMERGENCIES
IN CALIFORNIA SHOWED HAVE SHOWN THAT IS NOT ALWAYS POSSIBLE
OR SAFE FOR -- SOCIAL ASIANS TO PROVIDE IN PERSON MEETING
LOCATIONS THAT IS WHY SB THREE NINETY ONE A PERMISSIVE BILL
THAT SIMPLY GIVES H.
AWAY AS ANOTHER OPTION TO MEET SAFELY DURING TIMES OF
EMERGENCIES AGAIN THE SAME OPTION THAT HAS ALREADY BEEN
EXTENDED THE LOCAL GOVERNMENTS AND STATE AGENCIES IS SO
URGENTLY NEEDED TODAY TO PROVIDE TESTIMONY WE HAVE
BRIAN A PAIR OF THE CALIFORNIA LAW REVISION COMMISSION
AND -- PATCHELL A COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION ATTORNEY THE
ATTORNEY FROM ORANGE COUNTY WHOSE FIRM PROVIDES LEGAL
COUNSEL FOR HUNDREDS OF ASSOCIATIONS THANK YOU THANK
YOU SENATOR LET'S NOW GO TO THE FIRST WITNESSES ARE
ONLY BRIAN HUBERT AND DARK PATCHELL TO THE OPERATOR
GOOD AFTERNOON --
GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIR AND MEMBERS CAN YOU
HEAR ME WE CAN INDEED
THIS IS BRIAN HIBBARD ON THE DIRECTOR OF THE LAW REVISION
COMMISSION AS SENATOR MAN EXPLAINED -- THIS BILL IS BASED
ON A COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION I AM AVAILABLE TODAY TO ANSWER
ANY QUESTIONS YOU MIGHT HAVE ABOUT THE THE COMMISSION'S
RECOMMENDATION ALL EXPLAIN ANYTHING THOUGH IT IS UNCLEAR
-- THE ONLY OTHER THING I WOULD ADD IS THAT THE THE
COMMISSION PROPOSED THAT THIS URGENCY BILL BECAUSE WE HAD
HEARD IN OUR MEETINGS WITH THAT MANY ASSOCIATIONS WERE
ALREADY HOLDING MEETINGS BY TELECONFERENCE WITHOUT
PROVIDING ANY POLLUTION LOCATION IN VIOLATION OF
EXISTING LAW AND -- THAT EXPOSES ALL THE DECISIONS MADE
AT THOSE MEETINGS TO BEING CHALLENGED AS ON LONG ISLAND SO
WE WANTED TO GET C.
ID'S BACK ON A LAWFUL PUTTING FOR THEIR MEETINGS AS QUICKLY
AS POSSIBLE TO MINIMIZE THAT COMPLICATION -- THAT THAT'S ALL
THE THAT I HAVE TO SAY AND LIKE I SAID I'M AVAILABLE TO ANSWER
ANY QUESTIONS YOU MIGHT HAVE THANK YOU THANK YOU VERY MUCH
LET'S GO TO THE NEXT WITNESS
CHAIRPERSON CHIU AN ASSEMBLY MEMBERS THIS IS YOUR PATCHELL
AND AS WAS MENTIONED BY SENATOR -- THAT I MEAN I AM
AN ATTORNEY WE REPRESENT THAT YOU MIGHT FOR MANY HUNDREDS OF
COMMUNITY ASSOCIATIONS IN THE STATE OF THE COMMON INTEREST
DEVELOPMENTS IN COMMUNITIES ARE GOVERNED BY A VOLUNTEER
HOMEOWNERS WHO ARE REQUIRED TO ACT IN PART THROUGH THE OPEN
OPEN MEETINGS OF THE BOARD AND AS WITH STATED EARLIER
CURRENT LAW REQUIRES THAT THESE OPEN MEETINGS PROVIDE
FOR A PHYSICAL LOCATION FOR THE ASSOCIATION MEMBERS TO
ATTEND EVER AS WE ALL KNOW IN THE LAST SIXTEEN MONTHS LOCAL
AND STATE MANDATES PREVENTED THOSE PHYSICAL GATHERINGS
AND EVEN IF TECHNICALLY NOT PROHIBITED VOLUNTEER
BOARD MEMBERS RESIDENTS AND PROFESSIONAL MANAGEMENT HAD
SERIOUS CONCERNS ABOUT HOLDING OF PHYSICAL LOCATIONS OPEN AS
SUCH IT VERY CRITICAL EXTREMELY BUSY TIME AND AGAIN IN OUR
COMMUNITIES IT BECAME VERY DIFFICULT FOR A VOLUNTEER BOARD
TO DO THEIR JOB BY NECESSITY TO BROWN ACTED OTHER LAWS WERE
QUICKLY MODIFIED BUT DID SEE A COMMON INTEREST COMMUNITIES
DID NOT SEE THAT RELIEF SO NONETHELESS EVEN WITHOUT THE
CHANGE TO THE LAW AT DRIVEN BY THE SAME NECESSITIES OF
GOVERNMENTAL AGENCIES AND WITH SOME PROTECTION FROM OUR
GOVERNOR'S ORDERS COMMENTED OUR COMMUNITY STARTED CONDUCTING
THEIR OPEN MEETINGS BY VIDEO CONFERENCE AND DISCUSS ENABLED
OUR COMMUNITY TO CONTINUE TO FUNCTION WHILE PROTECTING ALL
INVOLVED FROM THAT EXPOSURE TO CO THAT AT THAT POINT WE SAW
SOMETHING REALLY INTERESTING START TO HAPPEN ACROSS THE
BOARD WE STOCK IN UNITY ATTENDANCE AND INVOLVEMENT
SIGNIFICANTLY INCREASING A COUPLE OF EXAMPLES HERE IN
ORANGE COUNTY BOTH ARE AGE RESTRICTED COMMUNITIES ONE
WITH A THOUSAND DOORS -- AND HOMES CORDED IF MORE THAN A
HUNDRED PERCENT INCREASE IN PARTICIPATION IN THE MEETINGS
ONCE THEY WENT ONLINE WE HAVE ANOTHER AGE RESTRICTED
COMMUNITY UP TWENTY FIVE HUNDRED HOMES THAT ARE IS
REPORTING GREATER THAN THREE HUNDRED PART -- PERCENT
INCREASE IN PARTICIPATION SB THREE NINETY ONE VERY
SIMPLY ADDRESSES THIS ISSUE FOR OUR COMMUNITIES DURING
TIMES OF EMERGENCY AND ALLOWS THEM TO CONDUCT THEIR BOARD
MEETINGS WITHOUT A PHYSICAL LOCATION IN A MANNER JUST
LIKE THIS CALL ALL OF THIS WHILE ENHANCING NOTICE
REQUIREMENTS ENHANCING THE TECHNICAL SUPPORT REQUIREMENTS
AND WHILE MAINTAINING ALL THE PRE EXISTING COMMUNITY
RECORD KEEPING REQUIREMENTS SO FOR THAT PROTECTION OF
OUR RESIDENTIAL COMMUNITIES AND THOSE WHO LIVE WITHIN
THEM I PERSONALLY URGE YOU TO SUPPORT SB THREE NINETY ONE
WITH YOUR VOTE TODAY AND I THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME AND
I'LL REMAIN ON THE LINE FOR ANY QUESTIONS THAT MAY ARISE
THANK YOU VERY MUCH LET'S NOW GO TO WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION
I UNDERSTAND WE HAVE TO OUR HUNDRED KELLY AND TOM SERVER
IF THE OPERATOR IF YOU COULD PLEASE ALLOW THEM TO SPEAK
HELLO LIKE WE CAN ORGANISE CAL OKAY THANK YOU MY NAME
IS KELLY AND I AM NOT A LAWYER I AM VERY LEGISLATIVE
DIRECTOR OF THE CALIFORNIA LINE WHICH RETIRED AMERICANS
WE HAVE OVER A MILLION MEMBERS WE HAVE MANY MEMBERS WHO
ARE ALSO DISABLED INVOLVED REALLY LIKE A VERY GOOD START
NOT A BIG DEAL AND IT'S NOT EVEN A GOOD DEAL CALIFORNIA
WANT TO TIRED AMERICANS EACH ALL FOR ONE POINT FIVE MILLION
SENIORS LIVING IN CALIFORNIA HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION
THE BILL WOULD BE A BASE MOLDING RIGHT TO ENSURE
THAT ASSOCIATION ALEXION ARE CLEAN AND FAIR BY ELIMINATING
THE REQUIREMENT THAT THERE IS A PHYSICAL LOCATION FOR
HEATING YOU ARE ALL WHAT APPEARS TO ON THE BALLOT
WHAT'S UP TO CAMERA COLOR SOLUTION ESPECIALLY FOR
SENIORS THAT HAVE NO INTERNET NO CELL PHONE AND THERE ARE
MANY OF US DO NOT HAVE EITHER TRANSPARENCY IN ELECTIONS AND
NEEDING HUGE ISSUE WAS IN THE NOVEMBER PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION
EVERY ELECTION THE ALL THE WHITE OF FOR PEOPLE TO BE
ABLE TO WITNESS AND MONITOR THE HARM COUNTING OF BALLOTS
TO BE ABLE TO AND HERE AND UNDERSTAND WHAT IS GOING ON
IT'S IMPORTANT TRANSPARENCY IS ALSO A FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT
BECAUSE EACH ELECTION THREE NINE ONE TAKE AWAY THAT RIGHT
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE CLUB THERE ANOTHER LEVEL OF
GOVERNMENT AND EFFECTIVE DAILY LIFE PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES
SUCH I KNOW THAT YOU ARE ALLOWING ME TO SPEAK ON THE
PHONE HERE I KNOW THAT THERE IS A VERY GOOD THING I KNOW
HAVING THESE VERY IMPORTANT THAT YOU UNDERSTAND THAT NOT
EVERYONE THEY DID NOT HAVE CELL PHONES SH AND MANY PEOPLE AB A
REQUIREMENT ON THE CALL E.
D.
A.
R.
WIREIMAGE FIFTY EIGHT I'M MORE
I DON'T THINK THEY'RE THEY'RE BUILT WEEK URGING NO VOTE
IN NINETY ONE THANK YOU THANK YOU MISS KELLY LET'S
NOT GO TO MISTER SERVER
THANK YOU -- THIS IS TOM SIR I'M ON THE LEGISLATIVE
COMMITTEE OF THE CENTER FOR CALIFORNIA HOMEOWNER
ASSOCIATION LAW WHICH IS THE PROBLEM SB THREE NINETY ONE
BECAUSE OF ITS PROVISION IN PROPOSED SECTION FIFTY FOUR
FIFTY DE THAT PERMIT THE CANCELLATION OF THE OTHERWISE
REQUIRED IN PERSON MEETING TO WITNESS ACCOUNTING ABOUT
THIS PROVISION HAS BEEN AND COMPLETELY UNDERMINED THE
INTEGRITY AND CREDIBILITY OF THE VOTE YOU WILL TAKE THE
HAZARD OF SUBSTITUTING VIRTUAL MEETING IN PLACE OF THE REAL
THING WE PRESENT THREE CAN BE REAL EXAMPLES OF WHICH WE ARE
AWARE VENTURA COUNTY ELECTION GROUP BOARD OF DIRECTORS IN
MARCH THE INSPECTOR CONDUCTED THE TABULATION IN ANOTHER
COUNTY AND NO IN PERSON BUT NOTHING WAS COMMITTED
HOMOTHETIC VIDEO LINK THE WERE UNABLE TO CREATE A BALANCE AND
WE'RE SHOWN ONLY A SPREADSHEET WITH THE TABULATION PROVOKED IN
LOS ANGELES NATURE WE ELECTION IN APRIL THE COUNTING WAS DONE
DURING THE MEETING WITH THE WHOLE OF THE BOARD BRADLEY IN
THE PAST TEN YEARS ALLOWED ONLY FIVE MEMBERS INTO THE BEATING
AND LEFT MANY OTHERS OUT AND ALL THAT COULD BE VIEWED BUT
THE TOP OF THE INSPECTOR CARE ACT AND NO ONE CAN SEE WHAT HE
WAS ACTUALLY DOING THE WORST EXAMPLE OCCURRED TWO WEEKS AGO
WHAT A LOS ANGELES H.
AWAY HELD A VOTE COUNTY MEETING ON THE PHONE WITH NO VIDEO AT
ALL HAVE BEEN DECLARED BECAUSE THE DEATH OF HOSTED VOTE WITH
THE APPROVAL OF THE FESTIVAL SIXTY THOUSAND DOLLARS PER
OWN FINAL POINT THE PETITION WHICH WE ARE OBJECTING TO
COMPLETELY UNDER DURING DURING LAST NOVEMBER'S PRESIDENTIAL
ELECTION WIN THE COPA NINETY AM DEADLY CORRELATING THERE
WERE NO CANCELLATIONS WITHIN PERSON WITNESSING A BALLOT
COUNTY ANYWHERE IN THE UNITED STATES THE ONE ACCEPTS FULL
WALKTHROUGH GUIDE WITH SCORES OF UNSUCCESSFUL CHALLENGES
FILED ON BEHALF OF THE FORMER PRESIDENT HAD TO DO WITH THE
WITNESSING OF DALLAS COUNTY PENNSYLVANIA THE PROVISION
PROJECT -- INHABITANTS IT DOESN'T WORK AND IT'S NOT
NECESSARY WE HAVE OFFERED AN AMENDMENT THAT WE THINK SHOULD
BE ACCEPTABLE TO THE OFFICE AND LOOK FORWARD TO WORKING WITH
THE OFFICE OFFICE ON THE LEAN SIDE WHERE IT'S A NO VOTE ON
IT TWO THREE NINE ONE THANK YOU
THANK YOU LET'S NOT BRING IT BACK TO THE COMMITTEE
ANY COMMENTS AND QUESTIONS
C.
NON I JUST WANT TO THANK THE AUTHOR FOR BRINGING THIS
BILL FORWARD WE KNOW THAT PARTICULAR DURING THIS TIME
PERIOD -- IT'S IMPORTANT FOR US TO PROVIDE A TWO WAYS WITH
SOME GUIDANCE AND HAVE A HOLD REMOTE TELECONFERENCE MEETINGS
DURING THESE EMERGENCIES ARE WALL I THINK WE ALL HOPE THAT
THE WORST OF CO THAT IS BEHIND US ON THIS NEED CONTINUES
ALSO WANT TO JUST NOTE THAT THIS BILL EXPLICITLY GIVES
MEMBERS OF HOAS EXACT SAME PARTICIPATION ABILITIES AS
IF THEY WERE IN AN IN PERSON MEETING AND WE'VE ALSO --
PLACE VERY NARROW CIRCUMSTANCES WHEN A PHYSICAL MEETING WOULD
NOT BE POSSIBLE SO WELL WITH THAT LESSER ANY FINAL COMMENTS
I WANT TO TURN IT BACK TO THE CENTER TO MAKE ANY FINAL
CLOSING APPS THANK YOU TRICKS -- -- I WOULD JUST RESPOND TO
THE OPPOSITION VERY QUICKLY BY POINTING OUT THAT AS YOU
MENTIONED THIS IS A PERMISSIVE BILL THAT IS VERY NARROW IN ITS
SCOPE AND AS FAR AS ELECTIONS I WOULD ACTUALLY ARGUE THAT THE
TESTIMONY FROM THE CALIFORNIA HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION LAW
PROVES OUR POINT WHICH IS THAT HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATIONS ARE
ALREADY ENGAGING IN ELECTIONS REMOTELY BECAUSE THERE'S NO
GUIDANCE ARBIL SPECIFICALLY STATES THAT YOU CAN ONLY HAVE
A REMOTE ELECTION WHEN THERE IS A DECLARED OR PROCLAIM
DISASTER EMERGENCY THAT MAKES IT UNSAFE OR IMPOSSIBLE FOR
PEOPLE TO GATHER IN PERSON IT EXPLICITLY REQUIRES THAT THOSE
MEETING THOSE BALLOTS HAVE TO BE COUNTED AND TABULATED BY
VIDEO CONFERENCE IN FRONT OF A CAMERA IN A LOCATION SUCH
THAT MEMBERS CAN WITNESS THE INSPECTOR OF ELECTIONS COUNTING
AND TABULATING THE VOTES ARE THOSE PROCEDURES DO NOT EXIST
RIGHT NOW AND -- I THINK THIS IS AN IMPORTANT BILL AYE I
WOULD ARGUE IT IS A GOOD BILL AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR
AYE VOTE THANK YOU WANNA GO TO PUBLIC COMMENTS ALLOW MEMBERS
OF THE PUBLIC PROPERTY CREE WERE ON THE PHONE LINES TO
EITHER STATE THEIR SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION TO THIS MEASURE --
SO WITH THAT IF WE COULD GO TO THE OPERATOR IF YOU CORD
THE LINES FOR MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC AND IF YOU SUPPORTER
POSSIBILE SIMPLY STATE THAT FACT YOUR NAME AND ORGANIZATION
THANK YOU IF YOU'RE IN OPPOSITION OR SUPPORT OF
SB THREE NINETY ONE YOU MAY PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO
FOR SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION YOU MAY PRESS ONE AND THEN
ZERO AT MY MOMENT WE DO HAVE A FEW KEY WERE NOT
WE JUST HAVE TO GIVE MY LINE NUMBER AND AGAIN IT'S FOR
SUPPORT AND OR OPPOSITION SB THREE NINETY ONE AND WE WILL
GO TO LINE OF SEVENTY SEVEN YOUR LINE IS OPEN CHAIRED
MEMBERS JENNIFER WATER ON BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
ASSOCIATION OF COMMUNITY MANAGERS IN STRONG SUPPORT
THANK YOU MEXICO TO ALAINA EIGHTY FIVE YOUR LINE IS
OPEN THANK YOU OPERATOR EDWARD CHESHIRE SAN DIEGO
COUNTY FORMER BOARD MEMBER OF PACIFIC RIDGE NEIGHBORHOOD
HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION IN STRONG OPPOSITION
THANK YOU AND ACCESSIBLE TO LINE UP EIGHTY THREE YOUR LINE
IS OPEN THANK YOU CAN YOU HEAR ME OK YES HELLO OKAY MY NAME IS
GUS PETRA BORG I'M THE H.
AWAY OWNER AND FORMER MORE A FORMER H.
AWAY DIRECTOR FROM PLASTER COUNTY AND I
AM OPPOSED TO THIS BILL
THANK YOU AND NEXT WE'LL GO TO LINE OF SIXTY
FIVE YOUR LINE IS OPEN
YES CAN YOU HEAR ME WE CAN HEAR YOU YES YOU CAN
HEAR ME WE CAN HEAR YOU
YES I'M GAIL MARTIN IN A SAN DIEGO COUNTY HOMEOWNER
AND -- BOARD MEMBERS -- OPPOSED TO STILL THANK YOU
THANK YOU AND ACCESSIBLE TO LINE OF SEVENTY EIGHT YOUR LINE
IS OPEN HI I MIGRATE TO SWEENEY -- FIND THAT NUMBER IN CONTRA
COSTA COUNTY AND A FORMER BOARD MEMBER AND I OPPOSE THIS BILL
THANK YOU MEXICO LINE OF NINETY TWO YOUR LINE IS
OPEN HI MY NAME IS TINA MONDRAGON'S MEDINA CITY CODE
MORE MEN ERA FORMER BOARD MEMBER AND I OPPOSE THESE DEAL
THANK YOU EXOBYTES A LINE OF EIGHTY NINE YOUR LINE IS OPEN
GOOD AFTERNOON MR CHAIRMAN MEMBERS CARLOS INSURANCE
ON BEHALF OF THE COMMITTEE ASSOCIATION IT'S TO SUPPORT
THANK YOU AN EXTROVERT SO LINE OF NINETY YOUR LINE IS
OPEN HI MY NAME IS DELORES LUCARELLI I'M ON THE BOARD OF
DIRECTORS I'M A SENIOR I MEAN SAN DIEGO CAN SIX SAN DIEGO
COUNTY SAN DIEGO CITY AND I STRONGLY OPPOSE THIS BILL
THANK YOU AND WE HAVE NO FURTHER PUBLIC COMMENT IN
QUEUE AT THIS TIME THANK YOU LET'S BRING BACK TO THE
COMMITTEE AGAIN ANY DISCUSSION IS A MOTION WITH THE BILL FOR
THE SECOND THERE'S A SECOND AND WITHOUT ANY FURTHER
DISCUSSION MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL THE MOTION
IS TO PASS TO THE ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY Q.
R.
TWO R.
I.
C.
R.
TÔI SERTA I'D GABRIEL KALRA KILEY KILEY I'D MAIENSCHEIN
QUICK SILVA KIRK SILVA AYE LICKS THE BILL HAS FOUR VOTES
ON THE BILLS WERE VOTED ON CALL WAIT FOR OTHER MEMBERS TO COME
ABOUT THANK YOU LET'S NOT GO TO FILE ITEM NUMBER TWO SB THREE
NINETY TWO SENATOR ARCHULETA
THANK YOU MR CHAIRMAN MEMBERS
I WOULD LIKE TO GO AHEAD AND PRESENT SENATE BILL THREE
NINETY TWO AND I'M HERE TO -- SHARE THIS WITH YOU BECAUSE
IT IS AN IMPORTANT BILL AND I THINK IT DOES MAKE A LOT
OF HEADWAY HERE I WOULD LIKE TO START BY THANKING THE
CHAIR THANK YOU SIR AND YOUR STAFF FOR WORKING WITH ME ON
THIS BILL AND I'M HAPPY TO ACCEPT THE COMMITTEE SUGGESTED
AMENDMENTS AND THEY PROPOSED AMENDMENTS ON SENATE BILL
THREE NINETY TWO WILL REQUIRE HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATIONS TO
ANNUALLY ASK OUR MEMBERS TO PROVIDE THE FOLLOWING
INFORMATION AN EMAIL AND MAILING ADDRESS A SECONDARY
EMAIL AND THE SECONDARY MAILING ADDRESS ADDITIONALLY
AT THIS POINT AT THIS TIME HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION
MEMBERS PICK THEIR PREFERRED DOCUMENTS DELIVERY METHOD OF
EITHER EMAIL OR PAPER NOTICES UNDER THE DAVIS STERLING ACT
ASSOCIATIONS ARE REQUIRED TO PROVIDE MEMBERS WITH NECESSARY
DOCUMENTS INCLUDING ANNUAL BUDGETS POLICY STATEMENTS
AND OR NOTICES PREVIOUS LITIGATION HAS SOUGHT TO
PROTECT HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION MEMBERS FROM EXORBITANT FEES
RELATED TO DOCUMENT DELIVERY BY LIMITING THE AMOUNT OF
ASSOCIATIONS CAN CHARGE FOR THESE REASONS AND AND AT THIS
APPROPRIATE TIME I THINK THAT WE WE HAVE TO UNDERSTAND THAT
THE FEES SOMETIMES AND COSTS ASSOCIATED UP OUR LITTLE TOO
MUCH AND -- TRADITIONALLY TO FURTHER INCREASE INFORMATION
ACCESSIBILITY LEGISLATURES PASSED SENATE BILL THREE
TWENTY THREE AND TWENTY NINETEEN WHICH REQUIRES
HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATIONS TO DELIVER MEMBERSHIP BOARD
ELECTION RULES BY INDIVIDUAL DELIVERY OR BY POSTING ON
A WEBSITE IN THE MISTER GLOBAL PANDEMIC WERE MAIL
DELIVERIES ARE DELAYED THERE IS VERY COMMON COST SAVINGS
ARE CRITICAL AND CRUCIAL INFORMATION ACCESSIBILITY IS
VITAL UPDATING THESE DELIVERY METHODS TO ALLOW FOR MORE
MEMBERS TO CHOOSE EMAIL AS YOUR PREFERRED DELIVERY METHOD
IS CRITICAL UNDER CURRENT LAW THE DEFAULT DOCUMENT DELIVERY
METHOD HIS TRADITIONAL MAIL THIS BILL IS PROPOSED TO BE
AMENDED PROVIDES PREFERRED DOCUMENT DELIVERY OPTIONS OF
TRADITIONAL MAIL OR EMAIL TO HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION MEMBERS
AND AT THE SAME TIME DO IT IN A TIMELY AND SECURE DELIVERY
SYSTEM WITH SECONDARY BACKUP OPTIONS AND A NEW DEFINITION
OF VALID EMAIL ADDRESSES THE BILL IS AVAILABLE TO ENSURE
THAT DOCUMENT DELIVERIES AT HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATIONS
ARE KEPT UP TO DATE WITH IN OUR EVER CHANGING LANDSCAPE
OF INFORMATION SHARING TECHNOLOGIES THIS BILL RECEIVED
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT AND PASSED OFF THE SENATE FLOOR WITH NO
NO VOTES FOR THESE REASONS AT THE PROPER TIME MISTER CHAIR I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR I.
BOATS AND THE COMMITTEE MEMBERS AND I THANK YOU FOR ALLOWING
ME THIS TIME IN WITH ME ON THE PHONE AND THE LINE IS
JENNIFER SETBACK REPRESENTING THE SPONSOR OF THE BILL WHICH
IS THE CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS SHE WILL ALSO
BE AVAILABLE TO ANSWER ANY TECHNICAL QUESTIONS IF YOU
HAVE ANY THANK YOU THANK YOU CENTER LET'S NOW GO TO YOUR
FIRST AND ONLY WITNESS TO MASS SPEC WILLIAMS ARE FROM
THE CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION REALTORS TO THE OPERATOR
I'M NOT SURE MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE THANK YOU FOR THE
OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK TODAY -- WE ARE THE SPONSORS OF SB THREE
NINETY TWO IT'S HIGH TIME THAT WE HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO
REQUIRE HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATIONS TO DELIVER DOCUMENTS VIA
EMAIL PER THE HOMEOWNERS FOR A CLASS I IT'S IT'S PAST
TIME FOR US TO COME UP WITH TECHNOLOGY AND WE APPRECIATE
YOU CONSIDERING THE BILL WOULD LIKE TO THANK THE AUTHOR FOR
HIS EFFORTS IN CARRYING THE MEASURE IN YOUR STOPS WORK ON
THE RECENT AMENDMENTS WHAT THAT WAS RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR MY
VOTE I'LL BE HERE IF ANYBODY HAVE ANY QUESTIONS THANK YOU
THIS TIME LET'S NOW GO TO THE WITNESSES FOR THE OPPOSITION
WE HAVE TO -- IS MARJORIE MARIE FROM THE CENTER FOR CALIFORNIA
HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION LAW AND MS ELAINE LET LOVE PLANTS
ALSO WERE FROM THE CENTER FOR CALIFORNIA EACH TO A LAW CENTER
IONISATION TO THE OPERATOR
TO THE OPERATOR WITNESSES LINES ARE OPEN
MS MURRAY YOUR MIND YOU'RE A LOT
PLEASE GO I AM A LAYING LEAD LAP PLANT MARJORIE WAS GOING TO
SPEAK MISS MARIE WAS GOING TO SPEAK FIRST -- AND SHE WAS ON
THE LINE MARJORIE ARE YOU THERE OKAY I WILL GO AHEAD ASSEMBLY
MEMBER CHIU AND MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE SIX SB THREE
NINETY TWO HE IS TRYING TO IS AN EIGHT BILLION H.
AWAY ASSOCIATIONS TO EXEMPT THEMSELVES FROM THE CONSUMER
PRODUCT FOR THE C.
PROTECTION LAWS AND ESPECIALLY THOSE OF CALIFORNIA WHICH
ARE MORE RESTRICTIVE THAN MANY OTHER STATES B.
BUT STATE AND FEDERAL PRIVACY LAWS HOLD THAT EMAIL ACCOUNTS
ARE PERSONAL NON PUBLIC INFORMATION INCIDENT INDIVIDUAL
IN HIS NAME THAT I EMAIL ACCOUNT HAS BEEN ESTABLISHED
ALAIN VIGNEAULT OKAY THE EMAIL ACCOUNT IS A PROPERTY OF THE
INDIVIDUAL WHO CREATED THE ACCOUNT AND ONLY THAT PERSON
CAN AUTHORIZE WHETHER OR NOT THE PERSONAL EMAIL BAIT
MAY BE USED FOR RECEIPT OF EMAIL COMMUNICATION AND HE
SPECIFICALLY WHAT DOCUMENT WHAT COMMUNICATION MAYBE
WE SEE THAT EMAIL SB THREE NINETY TWO ONE THE COURTS
TO OFFER AN ALTERNATIVE FOR THE EMAIL HOLDER COCKTAIL IT
DOES NOT SPECIFICALLY DEFINE THE METHODOLOGY IS OPTING OUT
FOR WHAT DOC YET THEY OFTEN SPECIFICALLY WHAT DOCUMENTS
WOULD BE PREACHING AROUND WOULD BE PRODUCED THROUGH THAT
EMAIL IT ALSO REQUIRES TWO EMAIL ACCOUNTS WHICH IS REALLY
SUPERFLUOUS WE ONLY HAVE ONE PHYSICAL MAILING ADDRESS IF I'M
GOING TO RECEIVE EMAILS UNLIKE TRYING TO CREATE I AM GOING TO
GIVE ONE ADDRESS NOT MULTIPLE ADDRESSES SHELL THAT THEY GAIN
I YES MY INFORMATION THAT I AM SHARING THAT IS PRICELESS TO
ME AND SB THIRTY THREE NINETY TWO IS SEEKING TO AVOID THESE
CRITTERS THE REQUIREMENTS THERE'S NO PROVISION IN THAT
FOR DISCLOSURE AND THEREFORE THEY CAN STAND ELEMENT OF
PREGNANCY AND ACCEPTANCE BARDINI GATE AT FULL SAIL SB
THREE NINETY TWO AGAIN DOES NOT DISCLOSE TO THE MEMBERSHIP WHAT
INFORMATION IS BEING COLLECTED FOR WHAT PURPOSE IT WILL BE
A USED WHO IS IT GOING TO BE ASSESSMENT HAD DISSEMINATED
TREAT WE ALL KNOW THAT EVERY OTHER AGENCY BUSINESS MYSELF
INCLUDED I HAVE TO PROVIDE OUR CLIENTS WITH DISCLOSURES ANY
PERSONAL NON PUBLIC INFORMATION REQUIRES DISCLOSURE IT ALSO
REQUIRES HOW WE ARE PROTECTING IT AND THE PURPOSE OF WHICH
IS GOING TO BE USED THAT MUST BE PROVIDED ANNUALLY IT MUST
TELL ME HOW I CAN YEAH YEAH FINALLY WITH SB THREE THIRTY
TWO AND WHAT IS TO BE PROVIDED THERE ARE MANY NOTICES UNDER
THE DAY THE STERLING ACT THAT MUST BE PROVIDED ON PAPER IN
PERSON PERSONAL DILLON THREE SELL GIVEN ALL THE DIFFERENT
ASPECTS TO WHICH MADE HOMEOWNER BOARD CONDUCTS ITS BUSINESS
I WOULDN'T WANT MY PERSONAL INFORMATION BEING SENT TO A
COLLECTION AGENCY BECAUSE I WAS OUT OF TOWN AND MISS THE
PAYMENT OF MY MONTHLY DUES OR IF MY INSURANCE LAPSED OR
WHAT HAVE YOU IF I AGREE TO RECEIVE INFORMATION IT NEEDS
TO BE I WANTED TO KNOW EXACTLY WHAT IT IS I'M AUTHORIZING I
HAVE TO AUTHORIZE ANY OTHER COMPANY I DO BUSINESS WITH I
SPECIFICALLY AUTHORIZED WHAT INFORMATION I'M AUTHORIZING
TO BE TRANSMITTED TO ME A LACK TRYING TO CREATE THEREFORE
IN CONCLUSION HLA BOARDS YES EMAIL DELIVERY IS EFFICIENT
IT CAN'T BE COST SAVINGS BUT THAT MUST COMPLY WITH RULE AND
REGULATION JUST AS EVERY OTHER BUSINESS CASTING IS STILL THERE
FOR ME TELL THIS UNTIL THERE ARE AMENDMENTS AND THAT COMPLY
WITH EXISTING LAW I URGE THE COMMITTEE TO VOTE NOW THANK
YOU THANK YOU LET'S GO TO THE NEXT WITNESS TWO MINUTES PLEASE
TO THE NEXT WITNESS
THANKS VERY ARE YOU THERE
MERRY
CAN YOU HEAR ME
YES YOUR MAKE UP YES WE CAN HEAR YOU'LL PLEASE CONTINUE
HE I WANT TO EMPHASIZE ONE POINT THAT -- THIS PLANT IS
MAKING IN HER PRESENTATION SHE COMPLIANCE OFFICER WITH MORE
THAN TWENTY YEARS EXPERIENCE IN BANKING REQUIRING DETAILED
COMPLIANCE WITH BOTH STATE AND FEDERAL LAWS ON PRIVACY WHAT
IS MISSING FROM THIS BILL FROM SB THREE NINETY TWO IS A VERY
BASIC REQUIREMENTS THAT THE ASSOCIATION OF CHAMBER CONSENT
OF THE HOMEOWNER THIS IS A CORD ASIAN OF STATE AND FEDERAL
PRIVACY LAWS A PRIVATE EMAIL ADDRESS CANNOT BE USED UNLESS
AND UNTIL THE CONSENT OF THE OWNER OF THAT EMAIL ADDRESS
HAS BEEN OBTAINED THAT IS SO IMPORTANT MISSING INGREDIENT
FROM THIS BILL HIT BASICALLY IS TRYING TO EXEMPT HOMEOWNER
ASSOCIATIONS FROM COMPLIANCE WITH THAT ASCENTIAL INGREDIENTS
OF STATE AND FEDERAL PRIVACY LAWS NSC HAS EMPHASIZED THERE
IS ALSO NO GUARANTEE OF WHAT THE PROTECTIONS ARE ONE THE
HOMEOWNER EMAIL DATABASE HAVE BEEN COMPILED NOR ARE THERE
ANY DISCLOSURE REQUIREMENTS AS TO HOW THE DATABASE IS GOING
TO BE USED AND I DO WANT TO STRESS THAT'S ALSO THE ASIAN
UNDER DAVID STERLING AND ALSO UNDER THE FORECLOSURE STATUTES
ARE REQUIRED TO DELIVER THIRTY LEGAL NOTICES IN A STATUTORILY
PRESCRIBED WAY THROUGH CERTAIN METHODS FOR EXAMPLE THE NOTICE
OF ASSESSMENT CLEAN INDICATING THAT ASSESSMENT CERTAINLY I
CAN'T PREDICT THAT UNDER THIS STATUTE ASSOCIATIONS ARE GOING
TO START TO DELIVER LEGAL NOTICES BY EMAIL BECAUSE THERE
IS NO PROHIBITION AGAINST DOING THAT THIS IS NOT JUST A
MATTER OF DELIVERING FINANCIAL REPORTS BUT THE LEVER AND
EVERYTHING UNDER THE SUN TO THE HOMEOWNER TO AN EMAIL
ADDRESS NO MATTER HOW IT HAS BEEN OBTAINED SO WE DO URGE A
NO VOTE ON SB THREE NINETY TWO IT IS INSUFFICIENT TO FRAME
THIS AS A FISCAL AND COST SAVING MEASURE BECAUSE THERE
ARE IMPORTANT DELIVERY AND LEGAL RAMIFICATIONS TO IT WOULD
HAVE BEEN TOTALLY OVERLOOKED THANK YOU I HEAR MUCH NOW LET'S
GO TO MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC THEY WISH TO SPEAK IN PUBLIC
COMMENT EITHER IN SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION TO THIS BILL IF
YOU CAN PLEASE JUST CONNECTION YOUR NAME YOUR ORGANIZATION
AND WHY DO YOU SUPPORT OR OPPOSE TO THE OPERATOR
THANK YOU IF YOU SUPPORT OR OPPOSE THE SB THREE NINETY
TWO YOU MAY PRESS ONE ZERO ONE ZERO FOR SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION
OF SB THREE NINETY TWO AND WE WILL GO TO LINE OF EIGHTY FIVE
YOUR LINE IS OPEN HI THIS IS EDWARD CHESHIRE FROM SAN DIEGO
-- FORMER BOARD MEMBERS OF THE PACIFIC BRIDGE NEIGHBORHOOD
HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION IN STRONG OPPOSITION TO SB
THREE NINETY TWO THANK YOU
THANK YOU NXR GO TO LINE OF EIGHTY THREE YOUR LINE IS OPEN
THREE YEAH HELLO CAN YOU HEAR ME
YES PLEASE GO AHEAD OKAY MY NAME IS GUS FEDERAL BOARD BY
MANAGER WAY HOMEOWNER FORMER H.
AWAY DIRECTOR FROM PLASTER COUNTY ALSO SENIOR CITIZEN
AND I OPPOSE THIS BILL
THANK YOU AND NEXT OVER TO LINE OF SIXTY FIVE YOUR LINE IS OPEN
YES CAN YOU HEAR ME YES PLEASE GO AHEAD YES I'M GAIL MARTIN
FROM SAN DIEGO COUNTY OUR SENIOR IN A -- H.
AWAY FORMER BOARD MEMBER I STRONGLY OPPOSED
THIS BILL THANK YOU
THANK YOU MEXICO SO LINE OF NINETY ONE YOUR LINE IS OPEN
HELLO ADME YES I CAN'T WAIT EIGHT ONE STATE BOARD
PRESIDENT CLINTON YEARS -- UNION CITY ALAMEDA
COUNTY I STRONGLY OPPOSE SB THREE NINETEEN I CAN'T
THANK YOU AND NEXT WE'LL GO TO LINE OF SEVENTY EIGHT
YOUR LINE IS OPEN THANK YOU MARGARET SWEENEY CONTRA
COSTA COUNTY FORMER BOARD MEMBER AND THE HOME OWNER --
I STRONGLY OPPOSE THIS BILL
THANK YOU ELECT ABOUT THE LINE OF NINETY YOUR LINE IS OPEN
I NEED TO HIDING EIGHT AM -- MONDRAGON MONEYNESS UNIQLO
FORMER BOARD MEMBER A NIGHT COOL POSTS BCPL COMPLETELY
STE THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR WE HAVE NO FURTHER PUBLIC
COMMENT THANK YOU AT THIS TIME THANK YOU LET'S BRING
BACK TO THE COMMITTEE AND DISCUSSION TO THE MOISTURE
CENTER RIGHT HERE MY QUESTION IS ABOUT SOME OF THE COMMENTS
ON THAT IF YOU'LL BE GIVING UP THEIR EMAIL IF THEY DON'T
WANT TO GIVE UP THEIR EMAIL AND THEY JUST WANT TO RECEIVE
IT BY MAIL THEY CAN DO THAT WITHOUT PROVIDING THE OTHER
INFORMATION IS THAT CORRECT YES MEMBER I I'D LIKE TO POINT OUT
THAT WITH AMENDMENTS THAT THE CHAIRS ACCEPTED REMEMBER WE'RE
ONLY ASKING ANNUALLY IF THEY LIKE A PARTICULAR METHOD WHICH
IS AGAIN EITHER EMAIL MAILING ADDRESS AND THEY'RE ASKING FOR
SECONDARY IF IT GOES OUT AND -- BECAUSE IT'S SO IMPORTANT
IN THE BUSINESS OF HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATIONS ESPECIALLY WITH
LARGE ONES OVER ONE HUNDRED TWO HUNDRED -- THINGS CHANGE
IN THE BUDGET ASSOCIATION FEES IT IT COULD BE MEETING DATES
-- WE HEARD ABOUT ELECTIONS PRIOR TO THIS MEETING -- IT
COULD BE ISSUES THAT EVERYONE MUST BE OPEN MADE AWARE UP IN
WHATEVER COMMUNICATIONS I'VE GOT TO GET OUT THERE THIS IS
THE BEST WAY TO DO IT THAT'S ALL IT JUST COMMUNICATIONS
AND WITH THE TECHNOLOGY THAT'S OUT THERE WE JUST WANT TO OPEN
THOSE DOORS SO IF THEY DON'T WANT TO BE SUPPORTED IN OUR
MOUTHS AND THEY HAVE THE OPTION TO SAY KEEP BE MAILING IT TO ME
AND I DON'T HAVE TO GET DOCTOR DON'T EMAIL MAIL ALL RIGHT
I JUST WANTED I PROCEED ARE THE AUTHOR EXCEPT IN OUR
COMMITTEE MINUTES REALLY TO MAKE THAT CLEAR SO ON THE
COMMITTEE MEMONS AGAIN ALLOW A JURY MEMBERS TO ELECT WHICH
FORM OF NOTICE THEY WANT TO PROVIDE EMAIL PAPER OR BOTH
NEITHER WOULD BE THE DEFAULT BUT IF THE INDIVIDUAL DOESN'T
PROVIDE AN EMAIL ADDRESS AND ARE GOING TO CONTINUE TO GET
PAPER NOTICES SO I THINK THIS REALLY DOES SORT OF BALANCE --
I THINK THE INTEREST WILL HAVE TO NOT INSURE THAT TO MINIMIZE
PAPER WASTE BUT ALSO ENSURING THAT FOLKS HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY
TO CHOOSE THE DELIVERY METHOD THAT IS SUITED TO THEIR
NEEDS SO WITH THAT MR KILEY
SO I GOT ABOUT POINT BUT ON THE OTHER HAND THIS BILL DOESN'T
JUST AUTHORIZED THE H.
AWAY TO SEND THESE -- NOTICES ELECTRONICALLY BUT ACTUALLY --
REQUIRES THEM TO RIDE SO THAT KINDA SEEMS LIKE SOMETHING
THAT'S PRETTY SPECIFIC FOR US TO BE DECIDING ON BEHALF
OF EVERY CHOICE WHY NOT JUST MAKE IT AUTHORIZED AS OPPOSED
TO WELL MANDATORY WHEN YOU THINK ABOUT YOUR HOMEOWNERS
ASSOCIATION I SHARE THIS WITH SO MANY I'VE BEEN BROUGHT
REAL ESTATE BROKER FOR OVER TWENTY FIVE YEARS AND WHEN
YOU PURCHASE A HOMEOWNERS -- WELL YOU PURCHASED A TOWNHOUSE
CONDOMINIUM WHATEVER THE HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION AND
THE STRUCTURE IS SO VITAL IN THAT PURCHASE PEOPLE DON'T
REALIZE BECAUSE IF YOU DON'T HAVE ENOUGH REVENUES IF YOU
DON'T HAVE IN US -- -- BACKING FROM THE PRESIDENT AND SOME
OF THE BOARD MAINTENANCE IS SO IMPORTANT THE BUDGET IS SO
IMPORTANT TO BE ABLE TO ANALYZE THESE DOCUMENTS IS SO IMPORTANT
AND IF THERE'S A CHANGE BECAUSE REVITALIZING THE SWIMMING POOL
PLACING ROUGH SHOT AN INCREASE IN FEES IT'S IMPORTANT THAT
THEY COMMUNICATE THIS IS THE JUST TO BE ABLE TO COMMUNICATE
IN EVERY POSSIBLE WAY WE CAN AND WE HEARD EARLIER THAT NOW
IN THE WORLD OF ZOOMING THAT THAT'S ALSO NOW ON THE TABLE
BUT WE'VE GOT TO KEEP THE DOORS OPEN AS I KEEP SAYING
AND IT'S VITAL WHEN WE'RE LOOKING AT CITY AND COUNTY
FUNCTIONS OR CITY OR COUNTY REQUIREMENTS THAT MAY AFFECT
THE ASSOCIATION SO EVERYONE'S GOT A NO AND AGAIN LIKE I SAID
THIS IS THAT EVERY ANNUAL SO IT'S AN ANNUAL THING THEY'LL
CHECK AND RECHECK IF YOU WANT TO GET IT BY EMAIL YOU WANT TO
GET IT BY MAIL IF YOU'VE BEEN A CHANGE AND THAT'S IT AND
IF YOU DON'T WANT TO OPT OUT
ANY OTHER QUESTIONS MISS KRYSTAL
I'M HERE I WANT TO THANK THE AUTHOR FOR THIS BILL I
I THINK THAT IT'S A REALLY IMPORTANT BILL AS WE SEEM
MANY OF OUR SENIORS LIVING IN HOAS MY MOTHER LIVES IN
A CONDO ON AROUND AND I KNOW THAT SOMETIMES CORRESPONDENT
HAS BEEN -- CORRESPONDENCES BEEN VERY DELAYED IN SOME OF
THE MAJOR DECISIONS ASHY GETS OLDER IT IS IMPORTANT -- THAT
SHE DOESN'T HAVE AN EMAIL SO BEING ABLE TO HAVE THE CHOICE
FOR OUR FAMILY -- IT TO NOT ONLY GET TO -- THE WRITTEN --
OR PAPER CORRESPONDENCE OR AN EMAIL AS WELL OR BOTH IS REALLY
IMPORTANT -- BECAUSE AGAIN THERE IS THAT CONSTITUENCY OF
SENIORS THAT DON'T INTERFACE ON EMAIL BUT I THINK IT'S
IMPORTANT BILL BECAUSE ALL OF THE FAMILIES THAT ARE INVOLVED
WITH -- SENIORS AS THEY AGE ARE INVOLVED IN WANTING TO
KNOW WHAT'S HAPPENING WITH THAT PARTICULAR RESIDENTS THANK YOU
A FURTHER DISCUSSION POLITICS WITHOUT CENTER ANY FINAL
COMMENTS WELL I WOULD SHE LIKE TO THANK THE CHAIR AGAIN FOR
ACCEPTING THE AMENDMENTS IN THE MEMBERS I I THINK THIS IS
A A GOOD WAY TO TAKE CARE OF SO MANY HOMEOWNERS AND TO PROTECT
THEIR COMMUNICATIONS AND AGAIN AS WE HAD MENTIONED EARLIER
THAT THERE WERE NO NO VOTES -- AND IT WAS -- BIPARTITION
ACROSS THE BOARD IN THE SENATE AND I'D APPRECIATE -- YOUR --
PASSING THIS ON AND -- I URGE A AYE VOTE THANK YOU SENATOR
WITH THAT IS OUR MOTION FOR AS MOTIONS ARE SECOND THERE'S A
SECOND MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL THE MOTION IS TO
PASS AS AMENDED TO THE ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY Q.
R.
Q.
I SEE OUR TO OUR TO OUR TO OUR AYE GABRIEL GABRIEL I
KALRA KILEY MAIENSCHEIN CORK SILVA AYE QUICK SILVA AYE
WITH SIX WEEKS I THE BILL HAS FIVE OF YOUR BILL PASSES AWAY
FROM THE MEMBERS THANK YOU MR AND MEMBERS THANK YOU AND
OUR FINAL ITEM OF THE DAY IS FILE ITEM FIVE S.
B.
FIVE NINETY ONE SENATOR BACK OR WELCOME TO THE HOUSING COULD
GOOD AFTERNOON MISTER CHAIR AND MEMBERS THIS IS MY FIRST
BILL THE ASSEMBLY AND BY HOPE IT DOESN'T OPENING UP
FOR ADDITIONAL HAZING I DID WANT TO SAY IT'S A PLEASURE
TO PRESENT MY FIRST BILL THE ASSEMBLY FOR THIS COMMITTEE
OF MY LONG TIME FRIENDS AT YOUR DAVID CHIU WE JUST OPEN
YOURSELF UP THERE SEVEN ONE PREPARE QUESTIONS PLEASE
SENATOR INTERGENERATIONAL HOUSING MODELS ARE GROWING
IN POPULARITY ACROSS THE NATION THEY SIMULTANEOUSLY
ADDRESS ISOLATION DEPRESSION OFTEN SEEN IN SENIORS WELL
SUPPORTING VULNERABLE YOUTH AS THEY TRANSITION OUT OF FOSTER
CARE AT THE FOSTER SYSTEM AND ESTABLISH ALLIES AS INDEPENDENT
ADULTS OVER THERE'S BEEN AN ISSUE BLOCKING THIS YEAR IN
CALIFORNIA FOR EXAMPLE IN EMERYVILLE THE PROPOSED AN
INTERGENERATIONAL HOUSING PROJECT THAT IS ONE HUNDRED
PERCENT AFFORDABLE THAT WOULD INCLUDE SIXTY EIGHT UNITS
FOR SENIORS AND TRANSITION AGE YOUTH BUT BEFORE HOUSING
PROJECTS FOR SENIORS THAT USED TAX CREDITS WHICH IS NEARLY
ALL SUCH PROJECTS ARE CURRENTLY PROHIBITED FROM INCLUDING
OTHER TYPES OF AFFORDABLE UNITS IN THE SAME BUILDING
THAT'S DESPITE THE WELL DOCUMENTED SOCIAL AND HEALTH
BENEFITS FOR SENIORS AND YOUTH OF THIS KIND OF AFFORDABLE
INTERGENERATIONAL DEVELOPMENTS DEFECTIVE WE PROHIBITED -- HERE
IN CALIFORNIA SO SB FIVE NINE ONE ALLOWS TAX CREDIT FINANCED
AFFORDABLE INTERGENERATIONAL HOUSING PROJECTS BONTA PROVIDED
AT LEAST EIGHTY PERCENT OF THE UNITS ARE OCCUPIED BY SENIORS
IN UP TO TWENTY PERCENT ARE FOR TRANSITION AGE YOUTH I WANT TO
KNOW THAT YOU APPRECIATE THE CONCERNS RAISED BY LEADING H.
CALIFORNIA AND I WILL ADOPT A PROPOSED AMENDMENT CLARIFYING
THAT FUNDING INTENDED FOR SENIOR UNITS CAN ONLY BE USED
ON SENIOR UNITS -- -- FIND THAT BEFORE THIS BILL IS HEARD IN
THE ASSEMBLY JUDICIARY THIS BILL ROLE WE BELIEVE WILL
REDUCE YOUTH HOMELESSNESS INCREASING FOR A HOUSING
PRODUCTION AND STRENGTHEN THE FABRIC OF OUR COMMUNITIES I
RESPECTFULLY URGE YOUR AYE VOTE ON FIVE NINE ONE ON THE
LINE WITH BRIEF TESTIMONY IS COUNCIL MEMBER JOHN WALTERS
CITY OF EMERYVILLE THANK YOU LET'S NOT GO TO YOUR MAIN
WITNESS TO COUNCILMEMBER POWDERS -- NOT A MODERATOR
THANK YOU LINE IS OPEN PLEASE GO AHEAD THANK YOU I BELIEVE
GOOD AFTERNOON -- CHURCH YOU IN NUMBERS OF THE ASSEMBLY HOUSING
COMMITTEE AND THANK YOU TO SENATOR BACKER FOR SPONSORING
SB FIVE NINETY ONE I COULD NOT SAY ANYTHING BETTER THAN
THE STANDARD IN HIS SUMMARY I JUST WOULD LIKE TO EXPRESS OUR
SUPPORT FOR THIS BILL IS THE SPONSOR WE MAY BE THE SMALLEST
WE ARE THE MIGHTIEST LITTLE CITY IN THE BAY AREA HAPPY
TO DO OUR PART IN BUILDING AND EXPANDING THE AFFORDABLE
HOUSING OPTIONS TO BAY AREA RESIDENTS AND OUR GOAL HERE
IS TO ENSURE THAT -- AS THE CENTER NOTED HEALTH AND SOCIAL
BENEFITS COME ALONG WITHOUT THE PACKAGE FOR SENIORS AND WE
BUILD HOUSING FOR TRANSITION AGE FOSTER HOMES USED AS WE
GO I'M AVAILABLE TO ANSWER TECHNICAL QUESTIONS ABOUT THIS
BILL WE ASK FOR YOUR I.
BOATS THANK YOU THANK YOU THERE ARE NO OPPOSITION WITNESSES SO
LET'S GO TO THE PHONE LINES TO SEE IF THERE ARE ANY MEMBERS
OF THE PUBLIC THAT WISH TO EXPRESS SUPPORT OPPOSITION
TO THIS BILL TO THE OPERATOR IF YOU COULD PLEASE OPEN UP
THE LINES AND FOR MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC PLEASE STATE
YOUR NAME ORGANIZATION AND WHETHER YOU SUPPORTER OPPOSE
THANK YOU HERE IN OPPOSITION OR SUPPORT YOU MAY PRESS ONE
AND THEN ZERO FOR SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION THE PRESS ONE
AND THEN ZERO FOR SB FIVE NINETY ONE AND WE WILL GO
TO LINE OF NINETY FOUR YOUR LINE IS OPEN AT IT AFTER TO
GET AFTERNOON SHERRIN MEMBERS LOSE MONDAY LET CALIFORNIA
BE HERE IN OUR SPORT THANK
THANK YOU NEXT WE'LL GO TO LINE OF SEVENTY SIX YOUR
LINE IS OPEN YES CHAIR PERSON CHIU AND MEMBERS OF THE
COMMITTEE MEETING POLITICAL LOOK EXPRESSING GRATITUDE
TO SENATOR BACKER COMMITTEE STAFF AND SUPPORTING THE
FOLLOWING GROUPS THIS CITY OF BERKLEY THE CITY OF HALF MOON
BAY THE CITY OF OAKLAND THE CITY OF PALO ALTO C.
H.
HOUSING NONPROFIT HOUSING ASSOCIATION OF NORTHERN
CALIFORNIA AND THE PENALTY THANK YOU VERY MUCH
THANK YOU AND ACCESSIBLE TO LINE UP NINETY FIVE YOUR LINE
IS OPEN GOOD AFTERNOON EVERYONE CRESCENTA VERDE ON BEHALF OF A.
R.
P.
IN SUPPORT
THANK YOU AND NEXT WE'LL GO TO LINE OF A SEVENTY
NINE YOUR LINE IS OPEN
GOOD AFTERNOON SHARON MEMBERS RECOMMEND
CONTRIBUTING LEADING H.
CALIFORNIA I JUST WANTED TO NOTED THAT ARTIFICIALLY
REMOVING OUR OPPOSITION AS A RESULT OF THE SENATOR'S
COMMITMENT TO TAKE ON THE AMENDMENT -- YOU MENTIONED
AND JUDICIARY COMMITTEE AND WE GREATLY APPRECIATE HIS
AND THE COMMITTEE'S WORK ON THAT THANK YOU SO MUCH
THANK YOU AND WE HAVE NO FURTHER PUBLIC COMMENT IN
QUEUE AT THIS TIME MISTER CHAIR THANK YOU LET'S BRING
IT BACK TO THE COMMITTEE ONLY JUST FOR STATE TO THE
SENATOR JUST APPRECIATE YOUR CREATIVITY INNOVATION I THINK
WE'RE ALL TRYING TO THINK OF DIFFERENT APPROACHES TO HOUSING
PARTICULARLY WITH OUR GROWING SENIOR POPULATION AND I THINK
THE IDEA OF INTERGENERATIONAL HOUSING AGAIN IT'S A IT'S
A VERY NOVEL ONE BUT ONE I THINK MANY OF US APPRECIATE SO
HAPPY TO SUPPORT IT AND ALSO APPRECIATE YOUR PRODUCTIVE
CONVERSATIONS WITH LEADING H.
AND ENSURING THAT OUR STATE SENIOR SET ASIDE NUMBERS
UPRIVER ARE PRESERVED AT WITH THAT ASSEMBLY MEMBER WORKS
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR JUST WANTED TO THANK THE AUTHOR FOR
BRINGING THE BILL FORWARD -- AND YOUR LEADERSHIP ON THIS
ESPECIALLY AS A FRESHMAN COMING INTO DIVE RIGHT IN AND TACKLE
IT IS IMPORTANT TO THANK YOU FOR THAT I ALSO WANT TO CONFIRM
AND REVEAL IS A SMALL BUT MIGHTY CITY AND DOING THEIR
PART IN BUILDING HOUSING AND APPRECIATE -- COUNCILMEMBER
POWDERS -- TECHNICAL EXPERTISE IN THE BILL AND LEADERSHIP IN
THE SPACE THE BERRIES WELL AND WOULD JUST LOVE TO BE ADDED
ON AS A CO AUTHOR TO THE BILL AND BUT HAPPY TO BE MOVED TO
BELFAST IN THE MIDDLE RIGHT THIS PROMOTION IS OUR SECOND AS
A SECOND OTHER COMMENTS SINAN CENTER ANY FINAL COMMENTS THANK
YOU APPRECIATE THE COMMENTS AND I RESPECTFULLY REQUEST AN AYE
VOTE MADAM SECRETARY THE MOTION IS TO PASS TO THE ASSEMBLY
COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY CHU Q.
I SEE ARE CHAU HI THEY ARE TO AYE GABRIEL GABRIEL I KALRA
KILEY KILEY AYE MAIENSCHEIN MAIENSCHEIN AYE QUICKSILVER
AYE QUICK SILVA AYE WICKES WICKES AT YOUR BILLS ARE
THANK YOU THANK YOU CENTER AND WITH THAT WHEN WE GO THROUGH
THE AGENDA ONE MORE TIME TO ALLOW MEMBERS TO ADD ON
MADAM SECRETARY YOU WANNA START WITH THE CONSENT CALENDAR YES
-- TO BILLS ON CONSENT S.
B.
FOUR THIRTY TWO SB FIVE EIGHTY ONE VOTE IS -- I
GUESS WE DON'T NEED IT KALRA MAIENSCHEIN IN CHINA I HAD
SIX MONTHS AGO TO FOLLOW ONE FILE ITEM ONE SB THREE
NINETY ONE MIN GABRIEL GABRIEL I KALRA MAIENSCHEIN
MAIENSCHEIN AYE WICKS
THAT'S SIX SIX ICE RAGE -- AT THIS TIME I THINK OF
THE MEMBERS HERE ALL OF YOU HAVE ADDED ON TO YOURS BILLS
WILL WAIT FOR SOMEONE NUMBER CURRENTLY KNOWS CHAIRING
OF THE STORM YES WE NEED TO I'M SORRY SB THREE NINETY
TWO KALRA KILEY MANGER MAIN TRANSIT -- AND THEN SIX YEP
FROM
WHAT
THE WHOLE THERE'S NO REASON
THANK YOU FOR --
HE'S I DON'T KNOW
ALL OF YEAH
AT THE
YEAH
OKAY YEAH
WE HAVE
YEAH
WE GOT A LITTLE BIT WIDER
OKAY
YEAH --
OKAY YEAH YEAH YEAH BASICALLY
ARE YOU YEAH
YEAH YEAH -- YOU DO
YEAH
ALL RIGHT YOU WILL I THINK THERE
RIGHT
MISTER CAR CANNELLA GO THROUGH THE AGENDA STARTING WITH THE
CONSENT CALENDAR FILE ITEMS THREE SB FOUR THIRTY TWO Y.
CASKEY FALLEN FOR SB FIVE EIGHTY ONE ACTIONS KALRA KALRA
GOING BACK TO FILE -- FILE AND ONE SB THREE NINETY ONE
MAN KALRA SB FIVE TO SB THREE NINETY TWO ARCHULETA KALRA
ALL RIGHT FILE IN FIVE SB FIVE NINETY ONE BAKER KALRA
OKAY CALL RIGHT AUGUST THAT CONCLUDES OUR MEETING FOR TODAY