WEBVTT
00:29:15.687 --> 00:29:19.124
WELCOME TO THE ASSEMBLY LOCAL
00:29:19.190 --> 00:29:20.792
GOVERNMENT COMMITTEE HERE ON
00:29:20.859 --> 00:29:24.062
JUNE 15TH 2022. I WOULD LIKE TO
00:29:24.129 --> 00:29:26.297
REMIND THE PUBLIC THAT FOR THIS
00:29:26.364 --> 00:29:27.398
AND FUTURE HEARINGS, TESTIMONY
00:29:27.465 --> 00:29:28.566
WILL BE IN PERSON AS WE NO
00:29:28.633 --> 00:29:30.869
LONGER ARE USING A MODERATED
00:29:30.935 --> 00:29:32.670
TELEPHONE SERVICE. WE ALSO
00:29:32.737 --> 00:29:34.005
ACCEPT WRITTEN TESTIMONY THROUGH
00:29:34.072 --> 00:29:35.073
THE POSITION LETTER PORTAL ON
00:29:35.140 --> 00:29:39.244
THE COMMITTEE'S WEBSITE. LET'S
00:29:39.310 --> 00:29:40.745
COVER THE GROUND RULES FOR
00:29:40.812 --> 00:29:41.980
APPROPRIATE CONDUCT. THE
00:29:42.046 --> 00:29:42.914
ASSEMBLY HAS EXPERIENCED A
00:29:42.981 --> 00:29:44.315
NUMBER OF DISRUPTIONS TO
00:29:44.382 --> 00:29:45.483
COMMITTEE AND FOUR PROCEEDINGS
00:29:45.550 --> 00:29:48.353
IN THE PAST YEARS. CONDUCT THAT
00:29:48.419 --> 00:29:50.655
DISRUPTS, DISTURBS OR OTHERWISE
00:29:50.722 --> 00:29:52.023
IMPEDE. THE ORDERLY CONDUCT OF
00:29:52.090 --> 00:29:54.292
THE HEARING IS PROHIBITED. SUCH
00:29:54.359 --> 00:29:56.694
CONTACT CONDUCT WILL INCLUDE OR
00:29:56.761 --> 00:29:58.062
MAY INCLUDE TALKING AND MAKING
00:29:58.129 --> 00:29:59.998
LOUD NOISES FROM THE AUDIENCE.
00:30:00.064 --> 00:30:01.566
UTTERING LOUDER THREATENING OR
00:30:01.633 --> 00:30:02.233
ABUSIVE LANGUAGE SPEAKING LONGER
00:30:02.300 --> 00:30:05.003
THAN THE TIME ALLOWED, ALLOTTED.
00:30:05.069 --> 00:30:06.704
EXTENDED DISCUSSION OF MATTERS
00:30:06.771 --> 00:30:08.473
NOT RELATED TO THE SUBJECT OF
00:30:08.540 --> 00:30:10.408
THE HEARING OR BILL OR ANY OTHER
00:30:10.475 --> 00:30:12.544
DISRUPTIVE ACTS. TO ADDRESS ANY
00:30:12.610 --> 00:30:13.878
DISRUPTIVE CONDUCT. I WILL TAKE
00:30:13.945 --> 00:30:15.880
THE FOLLOWING STEPS. IF AN
00:30:15.947 --> 00:30:16.981
INDIVIDUAL DISRUPTS OUR HEARING
00:30:17.048 --> 00:30:18.550
PROCESS, I WILL DIRECT THEM TO
00:30:18.616 --> 00:30:19.784
STOP AND WARN THEM THAT
00:30:19.851 --> 00:30:20.985
CONTINUED DISRUPTIONS MAY RESULT
00:30:21.052 --> 00:30:22.820
IN THE REMOVAL FROM THE CAPITOL
00:30:22.887 --> 00:30:25.490
BUILDING. I WILL ALSO DOCUMENT
00:30:25.557 --> 00:30:27.025
ON RECORD THE INDIVIDUAL
00:30:27.091 --> 00:30:28.126
INVOLVED IN THE NATURE OF THE
00:30:28.193 --> 00:30:29.027
DISRUPTIVE CONDUCT. I MAY
00:30:29.093 --> 00:30:29.994
TEMPORARILY RECESSED THE
00:30:30.061 --> 00:30:33.665
HEARING. IF THE CONDUCT DOES NOT
00:30:33.731 --> 00:30:35.333
STOP, I WILL REQUEST THE
00:30:35.400 --> 00:30:36.367
ASSISTANCE OF THE SERGEANTS AND
00:30:36.434 --> 00:30:37.368
ESCORTING THE INDIVIDUAL FROM
00:30:37.435 --> 00:30:39.938
THE HEARING ROOM. SO TODAY WE
00:30:40.004 --> 00:30:42.140
HAVE 11 ITEMS ON THE AGENDA. WE
00:30:42.207 --> 00:30:44.876
DO NOT HAVE ANY CONSENT ITEMS.
00:30:44.943 --> 00:30:46.477
SENATOR NEWMAN WILL BE
00:30:46.544 --> 00:30:49.414
PRESENTING SP 12 91 ON BEHALF OF
00:30:49.480 --> 00:30:51.549
SENATOR ARCHULETTA TODAY. WE
00:30:51.616 --> 00:30:53.518
WILL HEAR ALL OTHER BILLS IN THE
00:30:53.585 --> 00:30:55.053
ORDER SHOWN ON THE AGENDA UNLESS
00:30:55.119 --> 00:30:58.389
OTHERWISE NOTED. OR WE WILL TAKE
00:30:58.456 --> 00:31:00.058
UP TO PRIMARY WITNESSES AND
00:31:00.124 --> 00:31:01.993
SUPPORT AND TO PRIMARY WITNESSES
00:31:02.060 --> 00:31:03.761
AND OPPOSITION. THESE WITNESSES
00:31:03.828 --> 00:31:05.997
WILL HAVE THREE MINUTES EACH TO
00:31:06.064 --> 00:31:08.266
PROVIDE THEIR TESTIMONY. ALL
00:31:08.333 --> 00:31:09.968
SUBSEQUENT WITNESSES SHOULD
00:31:10.034 --> 00:31:11.002
STATE THEIR NAME, THEIR
00:31:11.069 --> 00:31:12.837
ORGANIZATION AND THEIR POSITION
00:31:12.904 --> 00:31:16.641
ON THE BILL. ONLY WE DO NOT HAVE
00:31:16.708 --> 00:31:18.710
A QUORUM, SO WE WILL OPERATE AS
00:31:18.776 --> 00:31:21.613
A SUBCOMMITTEE. OUR FIRST BILL
00:31:21.679 --> 00:31:24.616
TODAY ON THE AGENDA IS SP 3 61
00:31:24.682 --> 00:31:26.951
BY SENATOR HAMBURG SENATOR
00:31:27.018 --> 00:31:28.453
UMBERG, PLEASE PROCEED WHEN YOU
00:31:28.519 --> 00:31:30.655
ARE READY AND THIS IS ITEM ONE
00:31:30.722 --> 00:31:42.767
SB 3 61. WELCOME, SIR. HERE. IS
00:31:42.834 --> 00:31:45.103
A GUT AND AMEND, UM, BUT IT IS
00:31:45.169 --> 00:31:48.606
FOR A GOOD PURPOSE. WE WILL BE
00:31:48.673 --> 00:31:49.307
ACCEPTING ALL THE COMMITTEES
00:31:49.374 --> 00:31:53.778
SUGGESTED AMENDMENTS. SB 3 61
00:31:53.845 --> 00:31:55.246
ADDRESSES SOME UNFORESEEN
00:31:55.313 --> 00:31:56.347
CONSEQUENCES OF THE SURPLUS LAND
00:31:56.414 --> 00:31:59.751
ACT. AND THOSE UNFORESEEN
00:31:59.817 --> 00:32:01.252
CONSEQUENCES WERE RECENTLY
00:32:01.319 --> 00:32:02.954
HIGHLIGHTED IN THE CITY OF
00:32:03.021 --> 00:32:04.022
ANAHEIM IN CONNECTION WITH THE
00:32:04.088 --> 00:32:08.293
CITY OF ANAHEIM'S, UM POTENTIAL
00:32:08.359 --> 00:32:10.395
SALE OF ANAHEIM STADIUM
00:32:10.461 --> 00:32:12.697
STATEMENT. IT'S ENVIRONMENTS TO
00:32:12.764 --> 00:32:13.798
TEAM FORMERLY KNOWN AS THE
00:32:13.865 --> 00:32:17.869
ANAHEIM ANGELS. WHAT HAPPENED
00:32:17.935 --> 00:32:19.871
WAS THAT IN MY VIEW, IS, IS IT
00:32:19.937 --> 00:32:24.475
THE AH! CITY. AND IN CONJUNCTION
00:32:24.542 --> 00:32:26.644
WITH THE ANGELS VIOLATED THE
00:32:26.711 --> 00:32:27.845
SURPLUS LAND ACT IN A NUMBER OF
00:32:27.912 --> 00:32:30.515
DIFFERENT WAYS. AH H C D.
00:32:30.581 --> 00:32:31.816
NOTIFIED THE CITY APRIL 28TH
00:32:31.883 --> 00:32:34.852
2021 THAT THEY WERE POTENTIALLY
00:32:34.919 --> 00:32:36.020
IN VIOLATION SUBSEQUENTLY SAID
00:32:36.087 --> 00:32:37.922
YOU ARE IN VIOLATION. UM,
00:32:37.989 --> 00:32:40.825
HOWEVER, UM BECAUSE OF THE
00:32:40.892 --> 00:32:42.994
READING BY APPARENTLY HCG AS
00:32:43.061 --> 00:32:45.396
WELL OF THE SURPLUS LAND ACT.
00:32:45.463 --> 00:32:47.131
THE PENALTY WAS SIMPLY A $96
00:32:47.198 --> 00:32:48.333
MILLION FINE 30% OF THE SALES
00:32:48.399 --> 00:32:51.869
PRICE. BEING TRANSFERRED FROM
00:32:51.936 --> 00:32:52.870
ONE HAND TO ANOTHER HAND,
00:32:52.937 --> 00:32:54.505
PUTTING A POT OF MONEY FOR
00:32:54.572 --> 00:32:56.374
PURPOSES OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
00:32:56.441 --> 00:32:58.776
IN ANAHEIM. WHAT THIS BILL DOES
00:32:58.843 --> 00:33:01.112
THIS MAKES CLEAR AND EMPOWERS H
00:33:01.179 --> 00:33:03.414
C D TO UNWIND THE DEAL IF THE
00:33:03.481 --> 00:33:05.049
DEAL IS SUCH THAT IT'S IN
00:33:05.116 --> 00:33:07.185
VIOLATION SURPLUS LAND ACT THAT
00:33:07.251 --> 00:33:09.754
H C D HAS THE POWER TO BEGIN THE
00:33:09.821 --> 00:33:10.988
PROCESS. A NEW IN THAT
00:33:11.055 --> 00:33:12.623
ACCOMPLISHES THE PURPOSE OF THE
00:33:12.690 --> 00:33:13.858
SURPLUS LAND ACT. AS I
00:33:13.925 --> 00:33:16.027
UNDERSTAND IT ONE WAS TO MAKE
00:33:16.094 --> 00:33:18.863
SURE THAT THAT TAXPAYERS GOT A
00:33:18.930 --> 00:33:21.733
FAIR PRICE FOR THE LAND BEING
00:33:21.799 --> 00:33:22.934
SOLD. AND THEN SECONDLY, THAT WE
00:33:23.000 --> 00:33:26.738
WERE COGNIZANT OF THE CHALLENGES
00:33:26.804 --> 00:33:27.338
CONCERNING AFFORDABLE HOUSING
00:33:27.405 --> 00:33:30.241
AND REQUIRED 25. UNDER CERTAIN
00:33:30.308 --> 00:33:32.477
CIRCUMSTANCES TO BE AFFORDABLE
00:33:32.543 --> 00:33:33.578
HOUSING IN THE PROJECT AS
00:33:33.644 --> 00:33:37.515
ANTICIPATED. NOW THE ANAHEIM
00:33:37.582 --> 00:33:40.118
SITUATION GOT A BIT MORE
00:33:40.184 --> 00:33:41.252
COMPLICATED AFTER THE FBI
00:33:41.319 --> 00:33:43.154
REVEALED THAT THERE WAS IN MY
00:33:43.221 --> 00:33:44.355
VIEW SIGNIFICANT CORRUPTION IN
00:33:44.422 --> 00:33:46.457
CONNECTION WITH THAT SALE AS
00:33:46.524 --> 00:33:47.525
WELL. IT'S SOMETHING
00:33:47.592 --> 00:33:48.459
SUBSEQUENTLY BEEN UNWOUND,
00:33:48.526 --> 00:33:51.763
HOWEVER. WHAT DID THAT MEANS IS
00:33:51.829 --> 00:33:53.231
BASICALLY GO BACK TO AH, THE
00:33:53.297 --> 00:33:58.569
SITUATION. THAT EXISTED PRIOR TO
00:33:58.636 --> 00:34:01.773
2000 AND 19 AND WHICH IS FAIR
00:34:01.839 --> 00:34:03.374
ALLOWS THE CITY NOW TO
00:34:03.441 --> 00:34:05.376
RENEGOTIATE EITHER RELEASE OR
00:34:05.443 --> 00:34:07.478
SALE. UM, IN A WAY THAT IS
00:34:07.545 --> 00:34:09.947
WITHIN THE UM, WITHIN THE
00:34:10.014 --> 00:34:12.350
CONFINES OF SURPLUS LAND ACT AND
00:34:12.417 --> 00:34:13.885
WHICH IS FAIR TO THE TAXPAYERS
00:34:13.951 --> 00:34:15.887
OF ANAHEIM. I HAVE NO WITNESSES
00:34:15.953 --> 00:34:17.822
HERE WITH ME. LOTS OF FOLKS IN
00:34:17.889 --> 00:34:19.757
SUPPORT, BUT NO WITNESSES HERE
00:34:19.824 --> 00:34:22.760
WITH ME. AND I URGE YOU TO VOTE.
00:34:22.827 --> 00:34:24.429
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. IS THERE
00:34:24.495 --> 00:34:25.930
ANYONE ELSE IN THIS AUDIENCE
00:34:25.997 --> 00:34:27.765
THAT MIGHT BE WANTING TO STAND
00:34:27.832 --> 00:34:28.666
UP AND SUPPORT THE BILL? PLEASE
00:34:28.733 --> 00:34:40.011
COME UP TO THE MICROPHONE HERE.
00:34:40.077 --> 00:34:41.279
GOOD AFTERNOON COMMITTEE MEMBERS
00:34:41.345 --> 00:34:42.447
. MY NAME IS ABRAM DIAZ, THE
00:34:42.513 --> 00:34:44.015
NONPROFIT HOUSING ASSOCIATION IN
00:34:44.081 --> 00:34:45.483
NORTHERN CALIFORNIA. WE HAVEN'T
00:34:45.550 --> 00:34:47.285
SUBMITTED AN OFFICIAL LETTER ON
00:34:47.351 --> 00:34:47.919
THE VILLAGES SHIP. I WANTED TO
00:34:47.985 --> 00:34:49.020
THANK THE AUTHOR AND THE
00:34:49.086 --> 00:34:50.721
COMMITTEE STAFF FOR THEIR WORK
00:34:50.788 --> 00:34:52.356
ON THE BILL. AND YOUR WORK TO
00:34:52.423 --> 00:34:53.958
PROTECT THE SURPLUS LAND ACT. WE
00:34:54.025 --> 00:34:55.326
PROVIDED SOME FEEDBACK AND THANK
00:34:55.393 --> 00:34:56.861
YOU SO MUCH FOR HEARING US OUT
00:34:56.928 --> 00:34:58.162
AND WE LOOK FORWARD TO HOPEFULLY
00:34:58.229 --> 00:35:00.331
SUPPORT OUR SUPPORT BETTER VERY
00:35:00.398 --> 00:35:01.499
SOON. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. IS
00:35:01.566 --> 00:35:03.334
THERE ANYONE ELSE WHO WOULD LIKE
00:35:03.401 --> 00:35:04.635
TO SUPPORT THE BILL? SEEING
00:35:04.702 --> 00:35:05.770
NONE. IS THERE ANYONE HERE IN
00:35:05.837 --> 00:35:11.843
OPPOSITION OF THE BILL? WELCOME.
00:35:11.909 --> 00:35:13.845
AND YOU CAN HAVE A SEAT HERE. IF
00:35:13.911 --> 00:35:18.249
YOU'D LIKE TO THANK YOU. THANK
00:35:18.316 --> 00:35:20.284
YOU, MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS JEAN
00:35:20.351 --> 00:35:21.853
HURST HERE TODAY ON BEHALF OF
00:35:21.919 --> 00:35:23.387
THE URBAN COUNTIES OF CALIFORNIA
00:35:23.454 --> 00:35:24.388
, THE RURAL COUNTY
00:35:24.455 --> 00:35:25.957
REPRESENTATIVES OF CALIFORNIA ON
00:35:26.023 --> 00:35:28.292
MY BEHALF OF MY COLLEAGUES AT
00:35:28.359 --> 00:35:28.926
THE CALIFORNIA STATE ASSOCIATION
00:35:28.993 --> 00:35:29.994
AND THE LEAGUE OF CALIFORNIA
00:35:30.061 --> 00:35:31.929
CITIES. WE DID HAVE AN OPPOSING
00:35:31.996 --> 00:35:32.930
THIS AMENDED POSITION ON THE
00:35:32.997 --> 00:35:34.899
MEASURE BUT WILL BE REVIEWING
00:35:34.966 --> 00:35:36.534
THE AMENDMENTS AND RECONSIDERING
00:35:36.601 --> 00:35:37.935
OUR POSITION AS SOON AS THE
00:35:38.002 --> 00:35:39.470
LANGUAGES IMPRINT. THANK YOU.
00:35:39.537 --> 00:35:41.706
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. ANYONE ELSE
00:35:41.772 --> 00:35:44.008
IN OPPOSITION OF THE BILL? A
00:35:44.075 --> 00:35:45.877
SINGING NUN. UM, ARE THERE ANY
00:35:45.943 --> 00:35:50.314
QUESTIONS OF THE COMMITTEE?
00:35:50.381 --> 00:35:51.349
OKAY, SEEING NONE ENTERTAIN A
00:35:51.415 --> 00:35:55.620
MOTION. I WOULDN'T HAVE A CORN.
00:35:55.686 --> 00:35:58.289
SORRY, DOGGONE. IT WILL HAVE TO
00:35:58.356 --> 00:35:59.090
DO THAT LATER. WOULD YOU LIKE TO
00:35:59.156 --> 00:36:01.893
CLOSE? UH THANK YOU, ONCE AGAIN
00:36:01.959 --> 00:36:04.662
FOR YOUR WORK ON THIS BILL IS A
00:36:04.729 --> 00:36:05.329
VERY IMPORTANT ISSUE. WE NEED TO
00:36:05.396 --> 00:36:07.498
MAKE SURE THAT ESPECIALLY AS IT
00:36:07.565 --> 00:36:11.369
RELATES TO LAW IS CLEAR AND THAT
00:36:11.435 --> 00:36:12.603
THERE ARE ADEQUATE REMEDIES TO
00:36:12.670 --> 00:36:14.539
ADDRESS ANY VIOLATION. URGENT. I
00:36:14.605 --> 00:36:18.309
VOTE. THANK YOU. AND, UM UM I
00:36:18.376 --> 00:36:19.844
REALLY APPRECIATE YOU
00:36:19.911 --> 00:36:20.811
ACKNOWLEDGING THE COMMITTEE
00:36:20.878 --> 00:36:22.380
BECAUSEWE DID WORK REALLY HARD
00:36:22.446 --> 00:36:24.448
TRYING TO GET THIS TO SOMETHING
00:36:24.515 --> 00:36:25.616
THAT WAS DOABLE THAT PEOPLE
00:36:25.683 --> 00:36:27.184
WOULD BE ABLE TO ACCEPT. AND
00:36:27.251 --> 00:36:28.719
YOUR DISTRICT EXPERIENCE THE
00:36:28.786 --> 00:36:30.187
FIRST VIOLATION OF THE NEWLY
00:36:30.254 --> 00:36:32.623
REVISED SUPPLIES SURPLUS LAND
00:36:32.690 --> 00:36:34.659
ACT WITH THE ABORTED SALE OF THE
00:36:34.725 --> 00:36:36.627
ANGEL ST STADIUM. THE SITUATION
00:36:36.694 --> 00:36:38.195
WAS PARTICULARLY DIFFICULT IN
00:36:38.262 --> 00:36:40.264
YOUR EFFORTS TO ADDRESS THIS ARE
00:36:40.331 --> 00:36:41.332
TO BE COMMENDED, AND WE REALLY
00:36:41.399 --> 00:36:42.800
DO APPRECIATE. I'M SURE YOUR
00:36:42.867 --> 00:36:44.769
CONSTITUENTS APPRECIATE AS WELL.
00:36:44.835 --> 00:36:46.270
THE COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS WILL
00:36:46.337 --> 00:36:47.772
ENSURE THAT ANY FUTURE DEAL
00:36:47.838 --> 00:36:49.407
RELATED TO THAT PROPERTY OR THE
00:36:49.473 --> 00:36:50.775
SURROUNDING COMMUNITIES IS
00:36:50.841 --> 00:36:52.410
SUBJECT TO AN ADDITIONAL LAYER
00:36:52.476 --> 00:36:54.412
OF SECURITY. I AM PLEASED TO
00:36:54.478 --> 00:36:55.479
SUPPORT YOUR BILL WITH THE
00:36:55.546 --> 00:36:56.881
COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS. AND WHEN
00:36:56.948 --> 00:36:59.550
WE DO, WE WILL TAKE A SEPARATE
00:36:59.617 --> 00:37:00.952
VOTE ONCE WE GET A QUORUM. ALL
00:37:01.018 --> 00:37:02.153
RIGHT. THANK YOU. MADAM CHAIR,
00:37:02.219 --> 00:37:06.524
SENATOR MEMBERS. THANK YOU. OKAY
00:37:06.591 --> 00:37:09.293
WE HAVE AN ITEM NUMBER TWO SP 3
00:37:09.360 --> 00:37:12.463
79, SENATOR WEINER WELCOME. AND
00:37:12.530 --> 00:37:28.613
ENTER.
00:37:29.814 --> 00:37:32.250
I THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR. I WANT
00:37:32.316 --> 00:37:33.117
TO THANK YOU AND YOUR COMMITTEE
00:37:33.184 --> 00:37:35.353
STAFF FOR WORKING WITH US, AND
00:37:35.419 --> 00:37:36.520
WE'RE HAPPY TO ACCEPT THE
00:37:36.587 --> 00:37:37.488
COMMITTEE'S AMENDMENTS OUTLINED
00:37:37.555 --> 00:37:41.492
IN THE ANALYSIS. SP 3 79 WILL
00:37:41.559 --> 00:37:43.394
REQUIRE JURISDICTIONS OF A
00:37:43.461 --> 00:37:44.729
CERTAIN SIZE EXEMPTING THE
00:37:44.795 --> 00:37:46.964
SMALLEST CITIES AND COUNTIES TO
00:37:47.031 --> 00:37:48.366
IMPLEMENT AUTOMATED SALT ONLINE
00:37:48.432 --> 00:37:52.770
SOLAR PERMITTING. FOR SIMPLE
00:37:52.837 --> 00:37:54.472
RESIDENTIAL, ROOFTOP, SOLAR AND
00:37:54.538 --> 00:37:58.509
SOLAR PLUS STORAGE SYSTEMS. I
00:37:58.576 --> 00:37:59.377
WILL NOTE THAT IN LAST YEAR'S
00:37:59.443 --> 00:38:03.648
BUDGET, WE OBTAINED $20 MILLION
00:38:03.714 --> 00:38:05.916
TO HELP CITIES THAT NEED SOME
00:38:05.983 --> 00:38:07.485
FINANCIAL HELP TO IMPLEMENT.
00:38:07.551 --> 00:38:12.256
THIS PROGRAM. UH WE KNOW THAT
00:38:12.323 --> 00:38:13.758
CURRENT SOLAR PERMITTING CAN BE
00:38:13.824 --> 00:38:16.227
QUITE CUMBERSOME, NOT IN EVERY
00:38:16.293 --> 00:38:18.763
CITY BUT IN A NUMBER OF CITIES
00:38:18.829 --> 00:38:21.699
CAN TAKE QUITE A BIT OF TIME AND
00:38:21.766 --> 00:38:23.000
CAN INCREASE THE SOFT COSTS. OF
00:38:23.067 --> 00:38:24.602
GETTING SOLAR AND SOLAR PLUS
00:38:24.669 --> 00:38:26.671
STORAGE ON THE PEOPLE'S ROOFS.
00:38:26.737 --> 00:38:28.205
IT CAN BE A DETERRENT FOR
00:38:28.272 --> 00:38:31.142
CUSTOMERS TO EVEN CONSIDER SOLAR
00:38:31.208 --> 00:38:33.411
AND WE KNOW THAT SOLAR IS A KEY
00:38:33.477 --> 00:38:45.423
PART OF OUR FUTURE ENERGY MIX.
00:38:45.489 --> 00:38:49.493
OKAY. OKAY, THERE WE GO. UM
00:38:49.560 --> 00:38:52.496
AUTOMATE, UH, AUTOMATED, SOLAR
00:38:52.563 --> 00:38:53.998
PERMITTING, IS ALREADY IN PLACE
00:38:54.065 --> 00:38:55.733
IN SOME CALIFORNIA CITIES TO
00:38:55.800 --> 00:38:56.333
GREAT SUCCESS, AND JOSE, FOR
00:38:56.400 --> 00:38:57.435
EXAMPLE, SAW A DRAMATIC
00:38:57.501 --> 00:39:01.605
INCREASE. IN PERMIT APPLICATIONS
00:39:01.672 --> 00:39:03.474
FOR SOLAR AFTER IT IMPLEMENTED
00:39:03.541 --> 00:39:06.177
ITS AUTOMATED SOLAR SYSTEM.
00:39:06.243 --> 00:39:08.345
ALTHOUGH SP 3 79 DOES NOT
00:39:08.412 --> 00:39:09.747
REQUIRE, BUT ANY PARTICULAR
00:39:09.814 --> 00:39:13.017
PLATFORM B<c.cyan> WE ANTICIPATE THAT</c>
00:39:13.084 --> 00:39:14.518
A LOT OF CITIES WILL USE
00:39:14.585 --> 00:39:16.987
SOMETHING CALLED SOLAR APP. PLUS
00:39:17.054 --> 00:39:19.957
WHICH WAS DEVELOPED BY THE
00:39:20.024 --> 00:39:21.792
NATIONAL RENEWABLE ENERGY LABS
00:39:21.859 --> 00:39:22.960
OF THE U. S. DEPARTMENT OF
00:39:23.027 --> 00:39:27.131
ENERGY. CREATED WITH A BROAD
00:39:27.198 --> 00:39:29.500
CROSS SECTION OF STAKEHOLDERS,
00:39:29.567 --> 00:39:31.435
INCLUDING FIRE OFFICIALS,
00:39:31.502 --> 00:39:34.138
BUILDING OFFICIALS AND SO FORTH.
00:39:34.205 --> 00:39:37.975
SOLAR OUT PLUS IS FREE. AND IT'S
00:39:38.042 --> 00:39:39.777
VERY EASY TO IMPLEMENT VERY
00:39:39.844 --> 00:39:42.747
SIMPLE AND STRAIGHTFORWARD. UM
00:39:42.813 --> 00:39:44.949
AND THE U. S. DEPARTMENT OF
00:39:45.015 --> 00:39:46.383
ENERGY HAS ALSO COMMITTED $50
00:39:46.450 --> 00:39:48.586
MILLION OVER THE COMING YEARS TO
00:39:48.652 --> 00:39:50.988
KEEP IT CURRENT AND UPDATED, UM
00:39:51.055 --> 00:39:53.991
AND SO FORTH, SO THIS IS A
00:39:54.058 --> 00:39:55.559
STRONG STEP FORWARD FOR
00:39:55.626 --> 00:39:57.895
CALIFORNIA AND OUR MOVE. TOWARDS
00:39:57.962 --> 00:39:59.396
100% CLEAN ENERGY, AND I
00:39:59.463 --> 00:40:02.133
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR I VOTE
00:40:02.199 --> 00:40:04.535
WITH ME TODAY TESTIFY OR FROM
00:40:04.602 --> 00:40:06.904
MARCO MARCO SPONSORS OR PALOMA'S
00:40:06.971 --> 00:40:07.972
NARROWS LOBATO, THE POLICY
00:40:08.038 --> 00:40:10.941
ASSOCIATE AT SPUR. AND LAURA D.
00:40:11.008 --> 00:40:12.676
IN THE STATE DIRECTOR
00:40:12.743 --> 00:40:14.512
ENVIRONMENT HELPS GREAT. THANK
00:40:14.578 --> 00:40:17.281
YOU. WELCOME. PLEASE BEGIN.
00:40:17.348 --> 00:40:18.816
GREAT THANK YOU. HI THERE. MY
00:40:18.883 --> 00:40:21.252
NAME IS PALOMA CISNEROS LOBATO
00:40:21.318 --> 00:40:23.387
POLICY ASSOCIATED SPUR 100 YEAR
00:40:23.454 --> 00:40:25.222
OLD THINK TANK IN THE BAY AREA.
00:40:25.289 --> 00:40:27.291
THANK YOU SO MUCH TO THE AUTHOR
00:40:27.358 --> 00:40:27.892
AND HIS STAFF FOR THEIR
00:40:27.958 --> 00:40:29.760
LEADERSHIP ON THIS BILL INTO THE
00:40:29.827 --> 00:40:31.362
CHAIR AND COMMITTEE STAFF WHO
00:40:31.428 --> 00:40:32.596
WORKED WITH US SO PRODUCTIVELY
00:40:32.663 --> 00:40:33.931
AS WELL. SPUR IS CO SPONSORING.
00:40:33.998 --> 00:40:35.699
SB 3 79 WITH ENVIRONMENT
00:40:35.766 --> 00:40:37.201
CALIFORNIA BECAUSE WE HAVE MORE
00:40:37.268 --> 00:40:38.869
WORK TO DO TO ADDRESS THE
00:40:38.936 --> 00:40:40.805
CLIMATE CRISIS, THE C E C
00:40:40.871 --> 00:40:42.306
JOINTLY WITH THE PSC AND CARB
00:40:42.373 --> 00:40:43.908
ESTIMATES THAT CALIFORNIA WILL
00:40:43.974 --> 00:40:45.342
NEED TO TRIPLE THE AMOUNT OF
00:40:45.409 --> 00:40:47.344
SOLAR TO MEET 100% CLEAN
00:40:47.411 --> 00:40:49.580
ELECTRICITY GOALS. DESPITE PAST
00:40:49.647 --> 00:40:50.881
LEGISLATIVE REFORMS, IT STILL
00:40:50.948 --> 00:40:52.983
COSTS TOO MUCH AND TAKES TOO
00:40:53.050 --> 00:40:54.118
LONG TO PERMIT A SIMPLE
00:40:54.185 --> 00:40:55.052
RESIDENTIAL ROOFTOP SOLAR
00:40:55.119 --> 00:40:57.288
SYSTEM. SP 3 79. THE SOLAR
00:40:57.354 --> 00:40:59.490
ACCESS ACT IS SIMPLE. A DIRECT
00:40:59.557 --> 00:41:00.891
CITIES AND COUNTIES OVER A
00:41:00.958 --> 00:41:02.193
CERTAIN POPULATION THRESHOLD TO
00:41:02.259 --> 00:41:03.694
IMPLEMENT AUTOMATED PERMITTING
00:41:03.761 --> 00:41:04.662
FOR SIMPLE RESIDENTIAL ROOFTOP
00:41:04.728 --> 00:41:07.364
SOLAR SYSTEMS. TO AUTOMATE
00:41:07.431 --> 00:41:08.265
PERMITTING LOCAL JURISDICTIONS
00:41:08.332 --> 00:41:10.401
CAN USE FREE SOFTWARE DEVELOPED
00:41:10.467 --> 00:41:11.435
BY THE NATIONAL RENEWABLE ENERGY
00:41:11.502 --> 00:41:13.804
LAB, A DIVISION OF THE U. S.
00:41:13.871 --> 00:41:14.805
DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY CALLED
00:41:14.872 --> 00:41:16.774
SOLAR AT, PLUS. THE SOFTWARE WAS
00:41:16.841 --> 00:41:18.275
DEVELOPED WITH THE COUNTRY'S
00:41:18.342 --> 00:41:19.276
MOST RESPECTING BUILDING SAFETY
00:41:19.343 --> 00:41:21.278
ORGANIZATIONS, THE INTERNATIONAL
00:41:21.345 --> 00:41:22.379
ASSOCIATION OF ELECTRICAL
00:41:22.446 --> 00:41:24.281
INSPECTORS, THE NATIONAL FIRE
00:41:24.348 --> 00:41:25.282
PROTECTION ASSOCIATION, THE
00:41:25.349 --> 00:41:26.183
INTERNATIONAL AND THE
00:41:26.250 --> 00:41:28.886
INTERNATIONAL CODE COUNCIL. AND
00:41:28.953 --> 00:41:31.121
INCORPORATES OVER 125 SEPARATE
00:41:31.188 --> 00:41:33.557
PLAN CHECKS WITH SP 3 79,
00:41:33.624 --> 00:41:35.025
CALIFORNIA HAS THE OPPORTUNITY
00:41:35.092 --> 00:41:36.594
TO MAKE MAJOR STRIDES EMPOWERING
00:41:36.660 --> 00:41:37.628
OUR STATE WITH 100% CLEAN
00:41:37.695 --> 00:41:40.264
ENERGY. AND AT NO ADDITIONAL
00:41:40.331 --> 00:41:42.499
COST. WE RESPECTFULLY REQUEST
00:41:42.566 --> 00:41:44.535
YOUR I VOTE ON THIS BILL. THANK
00:41:44.602 --> 00:41:46.670
YOU. THANK YOU. HELLO THERE.
00:41:46.737 --> 00:41:48.639
THANK YOU SO MUCH TEAR
00:41:48.706 --> 00:41:50.641
AGUIAR-CURRY. MY NAME IS LAURA
00:41:50.708 --> 00:41:51.742
DI<c.cyan>. AND I'M, THE STATE</c>
00:41:51.809 --> 00:41:52.243
DIRECTOR FOR ENVIRONMENT
00:41:52.309 --> 00:41:54.912
CALIFORNIA AND WE'RE REALLY
00:41:54.979 --> 00:41:56.580
EXCITED TO BE HERE TODAY AND
00:41:56.647 --> 00:41:59.350
STRONG SUPPORT AS CO SPONSORS OF
00:41:59.416 --> 00:42:00.484
THE SOLAR ACCESS ACT, WORKING
00:42:00.551 --> 00:42:01.518
WITH SENATOR WEINER AND ALSO
00:42:01.585 --> 00:42:05.823
WITH SPUR UM, AND SO, YOU KNOW,
00:42:05.890 --> 00:42:07.391
CALIFORNIA IS ONE OF THE
00:42:07.458 --> 00:42:08.792
SUNNIEST PLACES IN THE ENTIRE
00:42:08.859 --> 00:42:10.895
WORLD. AND WE HAVE REALLY LED
00:42:10.961 --> 00:42:12.863
THE WAY WHEN IT COMES TO
00:42:12.930 --> 00:42:14.098
DEPLOYING THAT WITH ROOFTOP
00:42:14.164 --> 00:42:17.301
SOLAR SYSTEMS. WHICH IS GREAT,
00:42:17.368 --> 00:42:19.003
BECAUSE WE'RE WITH ROOFTOP SOLAR
00:42:19.069 --> 00:42:21.171
. THERE'S NO AIR POLLUTION.
00:42:21.238 --> 00:42:22.806
THERE'S NO SPILLS IN OUR
00:42:22.873 --> 00:42:24.942
BEAUTIFUL COASTLINE. THERE IS NO
00:42:25.009 --> 00:42:26.210
NEW LAND NEEDED TO BE ABLE TO
00:42:26.277 --> 00:42:28.746
CREATE THAT ENERGY. BUT OUR
00:42:28.812 --> 00:42:31.649
POTENTIAL TO EXPAND THAT IS
00:42:31.715 --> 00:42:32.783
ENORMOUS. THE NATIONAL RENEWABLE
00:42:32.850 --> 00:42:34.351
ENERGY LAB HAS ESTIMATED WE
00:42:34.418 --> 00:42:36.720
COULD REACH THREE QUARTERS OF
00:42:36.787 --> 00:42:38.956
OUR ELECTRICITY NEEDS JUST FROM
00:42:39.023 --> 00:42:40.524
CATCHING THE SUN ON EXISTING
00:42:40.591 --> 00:42:43.894
ROOFTOPS IN OUR STATES. FOR TOO
00:42:43.961 --> 00:42:45.763
LONG, THOUGH STANDARD SOLAR
00:42:45.829 --> 00:42:48.332
PERMITS HAVE BEEN TAKING TOO
00:42:48.399 --> 00:42:50.301
LONG. THEY'VE REALLY BURDENED
00:42:50.367 --> 00:42:51.802
LOCAL GOVERNMENT WITH PAPERWORK
00:42:51.869 --> 00:42:54.772
AND HOURS AND HOURS OF TIME. AND
00:42:54.838 --> 00:42:56.106
AS A RESULT, CONSUMERS HAVE
00:42:56.173 --> 00:42:57.441
EXPERIENCED LONG DELAYS JUST
00:42:57.508 --> 00:43:00.110
GETTING A ROUTINE SOLAR PERMIT.
00:43:00.177 --> 00:43:02.613
THANKS TO THE STATE LEGISLATURES
00:43:02.680 --> 00:43:04.648
LEADERSHIP IN ALLOCATING THIS
00:43:04.715 --> 00:43:07.885
$20 MILLION FUNDS AND THE C E C
00:43:07.952 --> 00:43:09.553
HAS SET UP THIS TERRIFIC GRANT
00:43:09.620 --> 00:43:10.654
PROGRAM, THE CALIFORNIA
00:43:10.721 --> 00:43:12.556
AUTOMATIC PERMIT PROGRAM. IT'S
00:43:12.623 --> 00:43:14.825
NO LIVE AND SO EVERY CITY AND
00:43:14.892 --> 00:43:15.926
COUNTY CAN TAKE ADVANTAGE AND
00:43:15.993 --> 00:43:17.094
IT'S GOT ENOUGH RESOURCES TO
00:43:17.161 --> 00:43:18.796
FULLY FUND THIS TRANSITION TO
00:43:18.862 --> 00:43:22.333
AUTOMATE PERMITTING. AND SO
00:43:22.399 --> 00:43:25.336
PASSING SB 3 79 REALLY IS THE
00:43:25.402 --> 00:43:27.771
NEXT STEP NEEDED TO CATALYZE
00:43:27.838 --> 00:43:29.773
ADOPTION AND REALLY TAKE FULL
00:43:29.840 --> 00:43:32.042
ADVANTAGE OF THIS GREAT SOFTWARE
00:43:32.109 --> 00:43:33.277
AND THIS GREAT RESOURCE OF SOUL.
00:43:33.344 --> 00:43:35.946
YOU KNOW, THE SUN SO WE
00:43:36.013 --> 00:43:37.114
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR IPHONE
00:43:37.181 --> 00:43:41.318
AS WELL. THANK YOU. I HOPE
00:43:41.385 --> 00:43:43.220
SOMEONE THAT COMES UP HERE TO
00:43:43.287 --> 00:43:44.054
SUPPORT. THIS IS EXCITED AS SHE
00:43:44.121 --> 00:43:47.758
IS ON THIS BILL. I KNOW THE
00:43:47.825 --> 00:43:50.327
ENTHUSIASMS. FABULOUS OKAY.
00:43:50.394 --> 00:43:51.829
ANYONE WHO WOULD LIKE TO SUPPORT
00:43:51.895 --> 00:43:53.831
THE BILL IF YOU'D LIKE TO COME
00:43:53.897 --> 00:43:55.132
UP TO THE MICROPHONE AND JUST
00:43:55.199 --> 00:44:00.037
STATE YOUR NAME YOUR POSITION. I
00:44:00.104 --> 00:44:03.240
KNOW. COME ON. WE'RE INSPIRED
00:44:03.307 --> 00:44:04.141
MADAM CHAIR IMMEDIATELY ON
00:44:04.208 --> 00:44:05.342
BEHALF OF TESLA AND SUPPORT OF
00:44:05.409 --> 00:44:08.145
THIS BILL. THINK THERE BEN DAVIS
00:44:08.212 --> 00:44:09.279
, CALIFORNIA SOLAR AND STORAGE
00:44:09.346 --> 00:44:11.181
ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT, AND I
00:44:11.248 --> 00:44:12.182
HAVE NEVER MET A PERSON MORE
00:44:12.249 --> 00:44:13.250
EXCITED ABOUT ANYTHING. THEN
00:44:13.317 --> 00:44:16.153
LORD DAHAN. VINCE WARREN MODULE
00:44:16.220 --> 00:44:19.623
WITH CLIMATE CENTER AND SUPPORT
00:44:19.690 --> 00:44:20.724
CORRUPTION. MADAM CHAIRMAN OF
00:44:20.791 --> 00:44:22.893
THE COMMITTEE, ALBERTO TORRICO.
00:44:22.960 --> 00:44:24.061
MAYBE IT DOESN'T SHOW BUT AS
00:44:24.128 --> 00:44:26.463
ENTHUSIASTIC ON THE APP OF 100
00:44:26.530 --> 00:44:29.833
SUPPORT MY NAME IS MAX SNYDER ON
00:44:29.900 --> 00:44:30.934
BEHALF OF SOME POWER AND
00:44:31.001 --> 00:44:35.773
SUPPORT. SYLVIA SALAS SHOW ON
00:44:35.839 --> 00:44:37.107
BEHALF OF THE BOARD OF
00:44:37.174 --> 00:44:38.308
SUPERVISORS FOR THE CITY AND
00:44:38.375 --> 00:44:40.511
COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO AND ALSO
00:44:40.577 --> 00:44:41.745
ON BEHALF OF ADVANCED ENERGY
00:44:41.812 --> 00:44:42.880
ECONOMY BOTH IN STRONG SUPPORT.
00:44:42.946 --> 00:44:45.716
THANK YOU. ROGER DICKINSON FOR
00:44:45.783 --> 00:44:50.521
CIVIC WELL IN SUPPORT. THANKS.
00:44:50.587 --> 00:44:52.122
PAUL WOODS WITH CALIFORNIA
00:44:52.189 --> 00:44:54.992
ADVISORS ON BEHALF OF THESE, UH
00:44:55.059 --> 00:44:56.527
, SORRY, ENERGY INDUSTRIES
00:44:56.593 --> 00:44:57.594
ASSOCIATION OF CALIFORNIA AND
00:44:57.661 --> 00:44:58.829
THE CENTER FOR SUSTAINABLE
00:44:58.896 --> 00:45:04.501
ENERGY. THANK YOU. MADAM CHAIR
00:45:04.568 --> 00:45:05.736
AND MEMBERS TONY GONZALEZ ON
00:45:05.803 --> 00:45:07.337
BEHALF OF 80 SOLAR EXCITEDLY IN
00:45:07.404 --> 00:45:13.977
SUPPORT. MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS
00:45:14.044 --> 00:45:15.846
AND THE RESTAURANT METERS ON
00:45:15.913 --> 00:45:17.681
BEHALF OF THE CITY OF FREMONT.
00:45:17.748 --> 00:45:18.549
WHILE WE DON'T HAVE A FORMAL
00:45:18.615 --> 00:45:19.850
POSITION WE WANT TO THANK THE
00:45:19.917 --> 00:45:21.885
AUTHORS OFFICE AND THE SPONSORS
00:45:21.952 --> 00:45:22.820
FOR HEARING OUT OUR CONCERNS AND
00:45:22.886 --> 00:45:24.455
TAKING THE AMENDMENTS AROUND
00:45:24.521 --> 00:45:25.089
MUNICIPAL LIABILITY ASSURANCES.
00:45:25.155 --> 00:45:26.156
SO THANK YOU VERY MUCH. GREAT.
00:45:26.223 --> 00:45:27.291
THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR ANYONE
00:45:27.357 --> 00:45:30.661
ELSE. SAYING NONE. IS THERE
00:45:30.727 --> 00:45:31.795
ANYONE HERE? WITNESSES IN
00:45:31.862 --> 00:45:36.400
OPPOSITION OF THE BILL? WELL I
00:45:36.467 --> 00:45:37.634
DON'T SEE ANYONE. THAT'S GOOD
00:45:37.701 --> 00:45:44.041
NEWS, HUH? UH, OKAY. IS THERE
00:45:44.108 --> 00:45:49.279
ANY QUESTIONS? THE COMMITTEE. NO
00:45:49.346 --> 00:45:50.380
OKAY, WELL, YOU'RE DOING REALLY
00:45:50.447 --> 00:45:52.116
WELL HERE. YOU GOT ANYONE IN A
00:45:52.182 --> 00:45:54.051
GOOD MOOD? OKAY. WOULD YOU LIKE
00:45:54.118 --> 00:45:56.019
TO CLOSE? RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
00:45:56.086 --> 00:45:58.222
MY VOTE TIME COMES. WE'LL DO
00:45:58.288 --> 00:46:00.390
MOTION AND GET THIS BILL OUT. I
00:46:00.457 --> 00:46:02.259
WOULD IMAGINE, BUT I JUST WANT
00:46:02.326 --> 00:46:04.094
TO THANK YOU FOR THE WORK ON
00:46:04.161 --> 00:46:05.028
THIS, AND WE KNOW HOW IMPORTANT
00:46:05.095 --> 00:46:07.498
IS HOW DIFFICULT IT IS. SOME OF
00:46:07.564 --> 00:46:08.499
THE ROADBLOCKS ARE WITH
00:46:08.565 --> 00:46:09.099
PERMITTING AND IF THERE'S ANY
00:46:09.166 --> 00:46:11.001
WAY TO DO THAT IN STREAMLINE IT.
00:46:11.068 --> 00:46:11.969
FOR OUR SMALL RESIDENTIAL, SO
00:46:12.035 --> 00:46:13.303
SOLAR ENERGY SYSTEMS. LET'S DO
00:46:13.370 --> 00:46:14.972
IT. SO WITH THE AMENDMENTS, I AM
00:46:15.038 --> 00:46:16.006
PLEASED TO SUPPORT YOUR BILL
00:46:16.073 --> 00:46:17.941
FROM THIS EFFORT. SO THANK YOU
00:46:18.008 --> 00:46:20.310
VERY MUCH AND SPREAD THE LOVE.
00:46:20.377 --> 00:46:30.320
CHEERS. THANK YOU. SERGEANTS,
00:46:30.387 --> 00:46:31.622
CAN YOU CONTINUE TO CALL?
00:46:31.688 --> 00:46:43.133
WHERE'S THE SERGEANT? OKAY?
00:46:43.200 --> 00:46:44.935
WE'LL TAKE A PAUSE. HOPEFULLY
00:46:45.002 --> 00:46:46.136
SOMEONE WILL SHOW UP SOONER THAN
00:46:46.203 --> 00:47:02.286
LATER.
00:49:51.455 --> 00:49:53.757
ALL RIGHT. WE ARE ON ITEM NUMBER
00:49:53.824 --> 00:49:56.560
THREE. SB 85 TO SENATOR DODD.
00:49:56.626 --> 00:49:58.428
YOU CAN BEGIN WHEN YOU'RE WHEN
00:49:58.495 --> 00:50:03.367
YOU'RE READY. CHAIR AND MEMBERS
00:50:03.433 --> 00:50:06.403
. THANK YOU VERY MUCH, UM SB 8
00:50:06.470 --> 00:50:08.372
52 WOULD AUTHORIZE LOCAL
00:50:08.438 --> 00:50:09.373
GOVERNMENTS TO FORM COMMUNITY
00:50:09.439 --> 00:50:11.608
RESILIENCE DISTRICTS TO ADDRESS
00:50:11.675 --> 00:50:13.443
CLIMATE CHANGE AT THE LOCAL AND
00:50:13.510 --> 00:50:15.479
REGIONAL LEVEL. FOR THE LAST
00:50:15.545 --> 00:50:17.280
SEVERAL YEARS, THE STATE IS
00:50:17.347 --> 00:50:19.316
RESPONDING TO CLIMATE CHANGED BY
00:50:19.383 --> 00:50:22.552
APPROPRIATING BILLIONS TO FUND A
00:50:22.619 --> 00:50:23.687
VARIETY OF PROGRAMS THAT PREVENT
00:50:23.754 --> 00:50:24.788
AND PROTECT OUR STATE FROM
00:50:24.855 --> 00:50:26.890
CLIMATE CHANGE DANGER. STATE
00:50:26.957 --> 00:50:28.225
PROGRAMS ADDRESS A BROAD RANGE
00:50:28.291 --> 00:50:30.026
OF ISSUES ACROSS THE STATE
00:50:30.093 --> 00:50:32.028
LANDSCAPE. HOWEVER THERE ARE
00:50:32.095 --> 00:50:33.397
DIFFERENT RISKS POSED BY CLIMATE
00:50:33.463 --> 00:50:34.431
CHANGE THAT AFFECT DIFFERENT
00:50:34.498 --> 00:50:36.900
COMMUNITIES IN DIFFERENT WAYS.
00:50:36.967 --> 00:50:38.034
IN SOME COMMUNITIES SUCH AS ONES
00:50:38.101 --> 00:50:41.538
THAT THE CHAIRWOMAN, AND I
00:50:41.605 --> 00:50:43.907
REPRESENT THE THREAT OF WILDFIRE
00:50:43.974 --> 00:50:46.176
IS MOST IMPORTANT IN SOME
00:50:46.243 --> 00:50:46.943
COMMUNITIES, THE MOST SERIOUS
00:50:47.010 --> 00:50:48.545
THREAT RESULTS FROM SEA LEVEL
00:50:48.612 --> 00:50:49.913
RISE IN OTHER COMMUNITIES,
00:50:49.980 --> 00:50:51.982
EXTREME HEAT EVENTS. POSED THE
00:50:52.048 --> 00:50:54.618
GREATEST DANGER. SP 8 52 WILL
00:50:54.684 --> 00:50:56.186
PROVIDE A LOCAL COMMUNITIES A
00:50:56.253 --> 00:50:58.555
TOOL TO PUT THEIR TOOL KITS TO
00:50:58.622 --> 00:51:00.157
HELP COPE WITH AND PREVENT
00:51:00.223 --> 00:51:01.725
CLIMATE RELATED DISASTERS. THAT
00:51:01.792 --> 00:51:05.128
ARE THE MOST CRITICAL TO THEM.
00:51:05.195 --> 00:51:07.330
SB 8 52 PERMITS CITIES AND
00:51:07.397 --> 00:51:08.765
COUNTIES AND SPECIAL DISTRICTS
00:51:08.832 --> 00:51:10.967
TO WORK AS A JOINT ENDEAVOR TO
00:51:11.034 --> 00:51:12.369
DEVELOP PLANS THAT ADDRESS THEIR
00:51:12.436 --> 00:51:14.037
HIGHEST LOCAL CLIMATE CHANGE
00:51:14.104 --> 00:51:16.273
PRIORITIES. THE FINANCING
00:51:16.339 --> 00:51:17.574
MECHANISMS EMBODYING THE BILL
00:51:17.641 --> 00:51:19.543
ALREADY EXIST IN STATE LAW
00:51:19.609 --> 00:51:22.412
TODAY. I WANT TO EMPHASIZE THAT
00:51:22.479 --> 00:51:23.847
EACH ONE OF THE REVENUE RAISING
00:51:23.914 --> 00:51:25.715
MECHANISMS ARE AVAILABLE TO
00:51:25.782 --> 00:51:27.751
CITIES AND COUNTIES ACTING
00:51:27.818 --> 00:51:29.953
INDIVIDUALLY RIGHT NOW, UNDER SB
00:51:30.020 --> 00:51:32.889
50 TO THOSE SAME MECHANISMS.
00:51:32.956 --> 00:51:35.125
WOULD BE AVAILABLE TO THOSE
00:51:35.192 --> 00:51:36.026
LOCAL ENTITIES WORKING TOGETHER
00:51:36.092 --> 00:51:37.127
AS A COMMUNITY RESILIENCE
00:51:37.194 --> 00:51:39.663
FINANCING DISTRICT BECAUSE SOME
00:51:39.729 --> 00:51:41.164
CLIMATE CHANGE PROBLEMS ARE
00:51:41.231 --> 00:51:42.499
BETTER ADDRESSED WHEN LOCAL
00:51:42.566 --> 00:51:42.866
COMMUNITIES WORK
00:51:42.933 --> 00:51:45.535
COLLABORATIVELY. NOTHING IN THIS
00:51:45.602 --> 00:51:47.737
BILL CHANGES THE CONSTITUTIONAL
00:51:47.804 --> 00:51:49.906
REQUIREMENTS FOR VOTER APPROVAL
00:51:49.973 --> 00:51:51.775
AND PUBLIC PARTICIPATION WHERE
00:51:51.842 --> 00:51:53.477
VOTER APPROVAL AND PARTICIPATION
00:51:53.543 --> 00:51:55.212
ARE NOW REQUIRED. MADAM CHAIR I
00:51:55.278 --> 00:51:57.214
COMMIT TO YOU THAT I WILL
00:51:57.280 --> 00:51:58.515
CONTINUE TO WORK WITH YOU. AND
00:51:58.582 --> 00:51:59.749
YOUR CONSULTANT ON ANY CHANGES
00:51:59.816 --> 00:52:01.284
THE BILL MAY UNDERGO. THAT IS,
00:52:01.351 --> 00:52:03.420
AS IT IS CONSIDERED BY THE
00:52:03.487 --> 00:52:04.821
NATURAL RESOURCES AND
00:52:04.888 --> 00:52:06.356
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEES. THIS
00:52:06.423 --> 00:52:07.757
BILL SUPPORTED BY THE NATURE
00:52:07.824 --> 00:52:08.792
CONSERVANCY, CIVIC WELL,
00:52:08.859 --> 00:52:09.926
INSURANCE COMMISSIONER RICARDO
00:52:09.993 --> 00:52:12.762
LARA. THE CALIFORNIA BUILDING
00:52:12.829 --> 00:52:14.397
TRADES COUNCIL, LOCAL
00:52:14.464 --> 00:52:15.432
GOVERNMENT, THE CLIMATE CENTER
00:52:15.499 --> 00:52:18.201
AND MORE HERE TO TESTIFY. FOR
00:52:18.268 --> 00:52:20.704
THE BILL IS FORMER ASSEMBLY
00:52:20.770 --> 00:52:22.439
MEMBER ROGER DICKINSON ON BEHALF
00:52:22.506 --> 00:52:24.808
OF CIVIC WELL AND MIKE PETERSON
00:52:24.875 --> 00:52:26.042
ON BEHALF OF INSURANCE
00:52:26.109 --> 00:52:29.246
COMMISSIONER RICARDO LARA.
00:52:29.312 --> 00:52:31.681
WELCOMES BEGIN WHENEVER YOU WANT
00:52:31.748 --> 00:52:33.750
TO THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR AND
00:52:33.817 --> 00:52:36.152
MEMBERS. I'M ROGER DICKINSON,
00:52:36.219 --> 00:52:37.621
POLICY DIRECTOR FOR CIVIC WILL
00:52:37.687 --> 00:52:39.623
FORMERLY THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT
00:52:39.689 --> 00:52:40.790
COMMISSION AND ONE OF THE
00:52:40.857 --> 00:52:43.493
SPONSORS OF SB 8 52. SENATOR
00:52:43.560 --> 00:52:45.662
DODD HAS DESCRIBED THE BILL WELL
00:52:45.729 --> 00:52:47.430
, AND WE THANK HIM FOR HIS
00:52:47.497 --> 00:52:50.600
LEADERSHIP. SB 8 52 IS DESIGNED
00:52:50.667 --> 00:52:52.202
SEVERAL OBJECTIVES, INCLUDING
00:52:52.269 --> 00:52:54.404
THE FOLLOWING FIRST PROVIDE
00:52:54.471 --> 00:52:55.939
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS AND REGIONS
00:52:56.006 --> 00:52:57.440
WITH THE ABILITY ON A VOLUNTARY
00:52:57.507 --> 00:53:00.010
BASIS TO PUT THE SPOTLIGHT ON
00:53:00.076 --> 00:53:01.111
CLIMATE ACTION AT THE LOCAL
00:53:01.177 --> 00:53:03.680
LEVEL. SECOND PROVIDE LOCAL
00:53:03.747 --> 00:53:05.115
GOVERNMENTS AND REGIONS THE
00:53:05.181 --> 00:53:07.484
STRUCTURAL MEANS TO WORK ON
00:53:07.551 --> 00:53:08.919
CLIMATE AND ITS SUSTAINED
00:53:08.985 --> 00:53:11.288
CERTAIN AND PREDICTABLE MANNER.
00:53:11.354 --> 00:53:13.523
THIRD PROVIDE LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
00:53:13.590 --> 00:53:15.425
WITH THE OPPORTUNITY TO OPTIMIZE
00:53:15.492 --> 00:53:16.593
LOCAL, STATE, FEDERAL AND
00:53:16.660 --> 00:53:19.829
PRIVATE RESOURCES. TO MEET THE
00:53:19.896 --> 00:53:20.997
CLIMATE CHALLENGE IS MOST
00:53:21.064 --> 00:53:23.099
IMPORTANT TO THEIR COMMUNITY.
00:53:23.166 --> 00:53:25.135
FOURTH GIVE LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
00:53:25.201 --> 00:53:27.604
FLEXIBILITY IN ADOPTING THE
00:53:27.671 --> 00:53:28.872
RIGHT FINANCING APPROACH FOR
00:53:28.939 --> 00:53:31.174
THEIR NEEDS AND COMMUNITY AND
00:53:31.241 --> 00:53:33.209
FIFTH GIVE LOCAL GOVERNMENTS AND
00:53:33.276 --> 00:53:35.078
REGIONS THE FLEXIBILITY TO PLAN
00:53:35.145 --> 00:53:36.680
AND IMPLEMENT THE HIGHEST
00:53:36.746 --> 00:53:37.247
PRIORITY PROJECTS. IN THEIR
00:53:37.314 --> 00:53:40.584
LOCALITY. WHILE THE STATE HAS
00:53:40.650 --> 00:53:41.918
ENACTED PROGRAMS AND MADE
00:53:41.985 --> 00:53:43.486
INVESTMENTS TO MEET THE
00:53:43.553 --> 00:53:45.055
INCREASING URGENCY OF THE
00:53:45.121 --> 00:53:47.090
CLIMATE CRISIS, AND THE FEDERAL
00:53:47.157 --> 00:53:48.425
GOVERNMENT HAS TAKEN RECENT
00:53:48.491 --> 00:53:51.328
STEPS TO ALSO DO SO. FAR LESS
00:53:51.394 --> 00:53:52.829
ATTENTION HAS BEEN PAID TO
00:53:52.896 --> 00:53:54.497
DEVELOPING A COHESIVE AND
00:53:54.564 --> 00:53:55.632
COORDINATED APPROACH AT THE
00:53:55.699 --> 00:53:58.401
LOCAL AND REGIONAL LEVEL. AS THE
00:53:58.468 --> 00:53:59.869
GOVERNOR'S CLIMATE ADAPTATION
00:53:59.936 --> 00:54:02.238
STRATEGY EMPHASIZES PARTNERSHIPS
00:54:02.305 --> 00:54:04.441
, COORDINATION AND COLLABORATION
00:54:04.507 --> 00:54:05.875
IN OUR EFFORTS TO BUILD CLIMATE
00:54:05.942 --> 00:54:07.577
RESILIENCE ARE ESSENTIAL, GIVEN
00:54:07.644 --> 00:54:08.645
THE DIVERSITY OF THREATS
00:54:08.712 --> 00:54:11.815
CALIFORNIA FACES LASTLY, LET ME
00:54:11.881 --> 00:54:13.383
JUST UNDERSCORE WHAT SENATOR
00:54:13.450 --> 00:54:15.018
DODD SAID A MOMENT AGO THAT THIS
00:54:15.085 --> 00:54:16.753
BILL DOES NOT CREATE OR
00:54:16.820 --> 00:54:18.321
AUTHORIZED ANY NEW TAXES. ALL
00:54:18.388 --> 00:54:19.956
REVENUE, WHICH COULD BE RAISED
00:54:20.023 --> 00:54:22.025
UNDER THE BILL COULD BE ALREADY
00:54:22.092 --> 00:54:23.026
GENERATED. BY LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
00:54:23.093 --> 00:54:27.330
TODAY. I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
00:54:27.397 --> 00:54:32.502
YOUR VOTE. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
00:54:32.569 --> 00:54:34.137
MM THANK YOU. CHAIR A YEAR.
00:54:34.204 --> 00:54:36.206
CURRY VICE CHAIR. LACKEY AND
00:54:36.272 --> 00:54:37.841
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE.
00:54:37.907 --> 00:54:38.541
MICHAEL PETERSON, DEPUTY
00:54:38.608 --> 00:54:39.976
COMMISSIONER ON CLIMATE AND
00:54:40.043 --> 00:54:41.177
SUSTAINABILITY HERE ON BEHALF OF
00:54:41.244 --> 00:54:42.145
INSURANCE COMMISSIONER RICARDO
00:54:42.212 --> 00:54:43.346
LARA. AND THE CALIFORNIA
00:54:43.413 --> 00:54:45.982
DEPARTMENT OF INSURANCE. AS THE
00:54:46.049 --> 00:54:46.950
BILL'S CO SPONSOR, COMMISSIONER
00:54:47.017 --> 00:54:48.485
. LARA WOULD LIKE TO THANK
00:54:48.551 --> 00:54:50.053
SENATOR DODD FOR HIS LEADERSHIP
00:54:50.120 --> 00:54:51.454
IN AUTHORING THIS IMPORTANT
00:54:51.521 --> 00:54:53.023
CLIMATE RESILIENCY MEASURE IN
00:54:53.089 --> 00:54:54.391
JULY 2021. THE CALIFORNIA
00:54:54.457 --> 00:54:55.458
DEPARTMENT OF INSURANCE,
00:54:55.525 --> 00:54:56.426
RELEASED THE CLIMATE INSURANCE
00:54:56.493 --> 00:54:58.328
REPORT. TITLED PROTECTING
00:54:58.395 --> 00:54:59.629
COMMUNITIES, PRESERVING NATURE
00:54:59.696 --> 00:55:01.231
AND BUILDING RESILIENCY, HOW
00:55:01.297 --> 00:55:03.667
FIRST OF ITS KIND CLIMATE
00:55:03.733 --> 00:55:04.300
INSURANCE WILL HELP COMBAT THE
00:55:04.367 --> 00:55:05.101
COST OF WILDFIRES, EXTREME HEAT
00:55:05.168 --> 00:55:08.271
AND FLOODS. THE REPORT WAS THE
00:55:08.338 --> 00:55:09.305
WORK OF THE CLIMATE INSURANCE
00:55:09.372 --> 00:55:10.073
WORKING GROUP, WHICH WAS
00:55:10.140 --> 00:55:11.241
COMPRISED OF ENVIRONMENTAL
00:55:11.307 --> 00:55:12.809
ADVOCATES, RESEARCHERS AND
00:55:12.876 --> 00:55:14.444
INSURANCE EXPERTS THAT PRESENTED
00:55:14.511 --> 00:55:15.578
40 RECOMMENDATIONS FOR VARIOUS
00:55:15.645 --> 00:55:18.782
POLICIES. TO REDUCE THE COST
00:55:18.848 --> 00:55:20.717
FROM WILDFIRES, EXTREME HEAT AND
00:55:20.784 --> 00:55:21.885
FLOODING, AMONG OTHER CHALLENGES
00:55:21.951 --> 00:55:24.054
, A STRONG MESSAGE COMING OUT OF
00:55:24.120 --> 00:55:25.221
THE CLIMATE INSURANCE REPORT WAS
00:55:25.288 --> 00:55:26.456
THAT IN ORDER TO IMPROVE
00:55:26.523 --> 00:55:27.424
INSURANCE, AVAILABILITY,
00:55:27.490 --> 00:55:30.727
RELIABILITY AND AFFORDABILITY.
00:55:30.794 --> 00:55:31.261
CALIFORNIA NEEDS COMMUNITY
00:55:31.327 --> 00:55:31.961
MITIGATION TO IMPROVE
00:55:32.028 --> 00:55:35.331
DRAMATICALLY. FURTHERMORE THE
00:55:35.398 --> 00:55:36.266
WORKING GROUP EMPHASIZED THE
00:55:36.332 --> 00:55:38.334
IMPORTANCE OF LOCALIZED PRE
00:55:38.401 --> 00:55:39.836
DISASTER MITIGATION THAT FOCUSES
00:55:39.903 --> 00:55:41.938
ON WETLANDS, FOREST MANAGEMENT
00:55:42.005 --> 00:55:43.573
AND URBAN FORESTS IN ORDER TO
00:55:43.640 --> 00:55:44.774
REDUCE THE IMPACT OF WILDFIRES.
00:55:44.841 --> 00:55:47.377
SEVERE STORMS FLOODING SEA LEVEL
00:55:47.444 --> 00:55:49.145
RISE AND EXTREME HEAT AND THUS
00:55:49.212 --> 00:55:50.580
RECOMMENDED THE CREATION OF
00:55:50.647 --> 00:55:51.848
SPECIAL CLIMATE RESILIENCY
00:55:51.915 --> 00:55:52.882
DISTRICTS FOCUSED ON THESE
00:55:52.949 --> 00:55:56.486
CLIMATE SOLUTIONS. SB 852 WOULD
00:55:56.553 --> 00:55:57.887
OVERCOME TWO BARRIERS TO CLIMATE
00:55:57.954 --> 00:55:59.456
ADAPTATION, THE NEED FOR
00:55:59.522 --> 00:56:01.224
FINANCING AND THE IMPORTANCE OF
00:56:01.291 --> 00:56:01.658
CROSS JURISDICTIONAL
00:56:01.725 --> 00:56:04.294
COLLABORATION. AND IS ONE MAJOR
00:56:04.360 --> 00:56:05.628
STEP TOWARDS REDUCING COMMUNITY
00:56:05.695 --> 00:56:07.664
WIDE RISKS AND THEREBY IMPROVING
00:56:07.731 --> 00:56:09.165
INSURANCE AVAILABILITY AND
00:56:09.232 --> 00:56:11.034
AFFORDABILITY BY ALLOWING THESE
00:56:11.101 --> 00:56:12.135
CLIMATE RESILIENCE, DISTRICTS
00:56:12.202 --> 00:56:13.069
AND THEIR CORRESPONDING
00:56:13.136 --> 00:56:15.171
MITIGATION PROJECTS. I
00:56:15.238 --> 00:56:16.906
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR I VOTE
00:56:16.973 --> 00:56:21.511
ON SB 8 52. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
00:56:21.578 --> 00:56:23.012
VERY MUCH. IS THERE ANYONE ELSE
00:56:23.079 --> 00:56:24.848
IN THE AUDIENCE IN SUPPORT OF SB
00:56:24.914 --> 00:56:26.816
8 52? PLEASE JOIN US AT THE
00:56:26.883 --> 00:56:32.255
MICROPHONE. NOON, STEVE ALICANTE
00:56:32.322 --> 00:56:33.256
AFTER THE NAPA VALLEY
00:56:33.323 --> 00:56:34.124
TRANSPORTATION AUTHORITY IN
00:56:34.190 --> 00:56:41.831
SUPPORT. MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS,
00:56:41.898 --> 00:56:43.199
MIKE MONEGAN ON BEHALF OF THE
00:56:43.266 --> 00:56:44.768
CALIFORNIA STATE BUILDING AND
00:56:44.834 --> 00:56:45.769
CONSTRUCTION TRADES COUNCIL AND
00:56:45.835 --> 00:56:50.473
SUPPORT. VINCE. WE'RE AT MARJA
00:56:50.540 --> 00:56:51.541
WITH THE CLIMATE CENTER AND
00:56:51.608 --> 00:56:56.446
SUPPORT. VERONICA VILLALOBOS
00:56:56.513 --> 00:56:57.413
CRUISE ON BEHALF OF THE
00:56:57.480 --> 00:56:58.548
CALIFORNIA FORD ACTION FUNDING
00:56:58.615 --> 00:57:03.386
SUPPORT. MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS,
00:57:03.453 --> 00:57:04.554
LAUREN DE VALENCIA, REPRESENTING
00:57:04.621 --> 00:57:05.455
THE AMERICAN PLANNING
00:57:05.522 --> 00:57:06.389
ASSOCIATION, AND SUPPORT THANK
00:57:06.456 --> 00:57:12.262
YOU. MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS
00:57:12.328 --> 00:57:13.763
SYLVIA SALISH ON BEHALF OF THE
00:57:13.830 --> 00:57:15.498
BOARD OF SUPERVISORS FOR THE
00:57:15.565 --> 00:57:16.599
COUNTY OF HUMBOLDT IN STRONG
00:57:16.666 --> 00:57:19.969
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. CHEROKEE'S
00:57:20.036 --> 00:57:21.671
DONE ON BEHALF OF THE DISTRICT
00:57:21.738 --> 00:57:22.338
COUNCIL OF IRONWORKERS AND
00:57:22.405 --> 00:57:24.374
SUPPORT. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. IS
00:57:24.440 --> 00:57:25.542
THERE ANY OTHER WITNESSES AND
00:57:25.608 --> 00:57:28.178
SUPPORT SEEING NONE. ARE THERE
00:57:28.244 --> 00:57:29.245
ANY WITNESSES AND OPPOSITION OF
00:57:29.312 --> 00:57:32.048
THE BILL? OKAY SEEING NONE. ARE
00:57:32.115 --> 00:57:33.750
THERE ANY QUESTIONS FROM THE
00:57:33.817 --> 00:57:38.188
COMMITTEE? ANY QUESTIONS OF THE
00:57:38.254 --> 00:57:40.623
COMMITTEE. WE DON'T HAVE FORM
00:57:40.690 --> 00:57:48.898
YET. GOOD TRY. YEAH YEAH, I
00:57:48.965 --> 00:57:54.404
KNOW. NO, YOU GOT YOU GOT ME
00:57:54.470 --> 00:57:56.840
THERE. OKAY LET'S SEE HERE. UM
00:57:56.906 --> 00:57:58.041
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE?
00:57:58.107 --> 00:57:59.776
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR I
00:57:59.843 --> 00:58:01.277
VOTE. THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY
00:58:01.344 --> 00:58:02.779
MUCH FOR AUTHORING THIS BILL,
00:58:02.846 --> 00:58:04.948
SENATOR DODD AS IT RECOGNIZES
00:58:05.014 --> 00:58:07.417
THE URGENCY AND THE DIRE NEED
00:58:07.483 --> 00:58:08.418
FOR INCREASED INVESTMENT IN
00:58:08.484 --> 00:58:09.652
CLIMATE CHANGE RELATED PROJECTS.
00:58:09.719 --> 00:58:11.120
UNFORTUNATELY NEED WILL ONLY
00:58:11.187 --> 00:58:13.389
INCREASE IN THE FUTURE. I AGREE
00:58:13.456 --> 00:58:14.524
THAT IT'S A WORTHY GOAL TO ALLOW
00:58:14.591 --> 00:58:16.426
LOCAL AGENCIES TO WORK TOGETHER
00:58:16.492 --> 00:58:18.328
TO COMBAT REGIONAL ISSUES THAT
00:58:18.394 --> 00:58:19.462
CROSSED YOUR JURISDICTIONAL
00:58:19.529 --> 00:58:21.965
BOUNDARIES. AND YOU KNOW,
00:58:22.031 --> 00:58:24.133
CREATING A NEW LOCAL FINANCING
00:58:24.200 --> 00:58:25.435
TOOL, SUCH AS THIS IS ALWAYS
00:58:25.501 --> 00:58:27.971
VERY COMPLEX ENDEAVOR AND
00:58:28.037 --> 00:58:29.405
SUPPORTING YOUR BILL. YOUR
00:58:29.472 --> 00:58:31.407
ABILITY TO CONTINUE TO WORK ON
00:58:31.474 --> 00:58:33.543
THIS IMPORTANT BILL. I ONLY
00:58:33.610 --> 00:58:34.744
ASKED FOR YOUR YOUR COMMITMENT
00:58:34.811 --> 00:58:36.145
AND YOU HAVE DONE THAT. THAT YOU
00:58:36.212 --> 00:58:37.614
AND YOUR STAFF WILL CONTINUE TO
00:58:37.680 --> 00:58:39.148
WORK WITH THIS CLOSELY WITH MY
00:58:39.215 --> 00:58:40.316
COMMITTEE STAFF ON FUTURE
00:58:40.383 --> 00:58:41.551
AMENDMENTS ON THE BILL, SO THANK
00:58:41.618 --> 00:58:43.286
YOU VERY MUCH, AND WE WILL GET
00:58:43.353 --> 00:58:45.388
HIM ENTERTAINING MOTION ONCE WE
00:58:45.455 --> 00:58:47.257
FILL THE SEATS HERE. THANK YOU
00:58:47.323 --> 00:58:48.458
VERY MUCH. THANK YOU VERY MUCH,
00:58:48.524 --> 00:58:52.528
SENATOR. OKAY LETS SEE WHO I
00:58:52.595 --> 00:58:55.531
HAVE. NEXT SENATOR NEWMAN. AS
00:58:55.598 --> 00:58:57.267
PORTANTINO'S HERE. OH I'M SORRY
00:58:57.333 --> 00:58:59.135
, SENATOR PORTANTINO WILL BE
00:58:59.202 --> 00:59:04.173
NEXT. I APOLOGIZE. WHAT? WHAT. I
00:59:04.240 --> 00:59:05.675
DO REALIZE THE COMMITTEE HE
00:59:05.742 --> 00:59:11.481
CHAIRS AS DO I. BUT WHAT IS
00:59:11.547 --> 00:59:12.215
THAT? I DON'T KNOW. WE DON'T
00:59:12.282 --> 00:59:15.251
WANT TO UTTER IT HERE. UH,
00:59:15.318 --> 00:59:17.020
WELCOME, SENATOR PORTANTINO.
00:59:17.086 --> 00:59:18.788
THIS IS ITEM NUMBER FOUR SP 9
00:59:18.855 --> 00:59:22.992
32. THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR AND
00:59:23.059 --> 00:59:26.329
MEMBERS, 9 32 IS A BILL WHICH
00:59:26.396 --> 00:59:28.131
FRANKLY, SEEKS TO MAKE OUR
00:59:28.197 --> 00:59:30.667
STREETS SAFER. AND SAVE LIVES.
00:59:30.733 --> 00:59:32.402
UM I'D LIKE TO START BY
00:59:32.468 --> 00:59:33.236
ACCEPTING THE COMMITTEE
00:59:33.303 --> 00:59:34.938
AMENDMENTS AND COMMENTS EIGHT ON
00:59:35.004 --> 00:59:36.105
PAGE SIX AND SEVEN OF THE
00:59:36.172 --> 00:59:37.941
ANALYSIS AND THANK THE CHAIR AND
00:59:38.007 --> 00:59:39.642
HER STAFF. FOR WORKING CLOSELY
00:59:39.709 --> 00:59:40.777
WITH MY STAFF ON THE AMENDMENTS
00:59:40.843 --> 00:59:42.979
. I APPRECIATE ALL THE ARD WORK
00:59:43.046 --> 00:59:44.447
MEMBERS, DESPITE DECADES OF
00:59:44.514 --> 00:59:45.782
RHETORIC ON THE NEED FOR SAFER
00:59:45.848 --> 00:59:46.883
STREETS, MOST CALIFORNIA STREETS
00:59:46.950 --> 00:59:47.951
HAVE GROWN MORE DANGEROUS IN
00:59:48.017 --> 00:59:50.153
RECENT YEARS. FRANKLY AS I'VE
00:59:50.219 --> 00:59:52.021
BECOME A BIKER, I'VE ALMOST BEEN
00:59:52.088 --> 00:59:53.556
CLIPPED PROBABLY TWO DOZEN
00:59:53.623 --> 00:59:57.427
TIMES. HMM. ACCORDING TO THE
00:59:57.493 --> 00:59:58.761
NATIONAL HIGHWAY TRAFFIC SAFETY
00:59:58.828 --> 01:00:01.297
ADMINISTRATION, 2021 SAW NEARLY
01:00:01.364 --> 01:00:03.299
20% INCREASE IN TRAFFIC
01:00:03.366 --> 01:00:04.968
FATALITIES AND THE FIRST SIX
01:00:05.034 --> 01:00:08.638
MONTHS COMPARED TO 2020. IN 2019
01:00:08.705 --> 01:00:10.239
. SOME CALIFORNIA CITIES LACK
01:00:10.306 --> 01:00:11.774
DATA ON HOW TO ADDRESS THE
01:00:11.841 --> 01:00:13.242
EPIDEMIC OF TRAFFIC VIOLENCE,
01:00:13.309 --> 01:00:15.611
PARTICULARLY REGARDING DEATH AND
01:00:15.678 --> 01:00:16.446
SERIOUS INJURIES TO PEDESTRIANS
01:00:16.512 --> 01:00:17.447
, CYCLISTS AND OTHER HUMAN
01:00:17.513 --> 01:00:19.716
POWERED TRANSIT USERS. IN
01:00:19.782 --> 01:00:20.883
CERTAIN CITIES, WHERE THE MOST
01:00:20.950 --> 01:00:22.518
DANGEROUS STREETS AND CORRIDORS
01:00:22.585 --> 01:00:24.320
HAVE BEEN IDENTIFIED. NO PLAN
01:00:24.387 --> 01:00:25.555
EXISTS TO REMEDY THESE DEADLY
01:00:25.621 --> 01:00:29.158
SOLUTIONS. EVEN IN CITIES THAT
01:00:29.225 --> 01:00:30.426
HAVE DEVELOPED PLANS LIKE LOS
01:00:30.493 --> 01:00:32.729
ANGELES VISION ZERO AND MOBILITY
01:00:32.795 --> 01:00:34.797
PLAN 2035 MEANINGFUL CHANGES
01:00:34.864 --> 01:00:36.032
THAT WOULD SAVE LIVES HAVE YET
01:00:36.099 --> 01:00:39.535
TO BE IMPLEMENTED. SP 9 32 WITH
01:00:39.602 --> 01:00:40.703
COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS REQUIRES A
01:00:40.770 --> 01:00:42.739
COUNTY OR CITY TO IDENTIFY,
01:00:42.805 --> 01:00:44.107
PRIORITIZE AND IMPLEMENT SAFETY
01:00:44.173 --> 01:00:45.341
IMPROVEMENTS BY DEVELOPING
01:00:45.408 --> 01:00:46.776
EVIDENCE BASED STRATEGIES TO
01:00:46.843 --> 01:00:48.644
DEVELOP SAFETY MEASURES THAT ARE
01:00:48.711 --> 01:00:49.512
INTENDED TO ELIMINATE TRAFFIC
01:00:49.579 --> 01:00:50.747
FATALITIES AND PROVIDE FOR
01:00:50.813 --> 01:00:52.782
LIMITED PRIVATE RIGHT OF ACTION.
01:00:52.849 --> 01:00:55.051
UM WITH INJURIES THAT OCCUR
01:00:55.118 --> 01:00:56.519
WITHIN THE RIGHT OF WAY, IF
01:00:56.586 --> 01:00:58.121
IDENTIFIED IN THEIR BICYCLE,
01:00:58.187 --> 01:00:59.655
PEDESTRIAN AND TRAFFIC CALMING
01:00:59.722 --> 01:01:01.691
PLANS. OBVIOUSLY WE CAN HELP
01:01:01.758 --> 01:01:03.659
REDUCE THIS TRAFFIC VIOLENCE. WE
01:01:03.726 --> 01:01:04.927
JUST HAVE TO BE BOLD ENOUGH TO
01:01:04.994 --> 01:01:06.362
DO IT. AND FOR THOSE REASONS, I
01:01:06.429 --> 01:01:07.930
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR MY VOTE ONE
01:01:07.997 --> 01:01:09.399
APPROPRIATE AND HERE TO TESTIFY.
01:01:09.465 --> 01:01:10.767
I HAVE DAVID SNYDER, EXECUTIVE
01:01:10.833 --> 01:01:11.934
DIRECTOR OF CALIFORNIA BIKE
01:01:12.001 --> 01:01:17.340
COALITION. I HOPE I DON'T SEE
01:01:17.407 --> 01:01:21.310
ANYONE. IF YOU DON'T MIND A
01:01:21.377 --> 01:01:22.879
SENATOR, WE'RE GOING TO
01:01:22.945 --> 01:01:24.647
ESTABLISH A QUORUM FIRST, AND
01:01:24.714 --> 01:01:25.948
THEN WE'LL TAKE YOUR DO NOT
01:01:26.015 --> 01:01:28.518
MIND. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
01:01:28.584 --> 01:01:30.219
SECRETARY CURRY HERE, CURRY
01:01:30.286 --> 01:01:34.791
PRESIDENT LACKEY. BLOOM BLOOM
01:01:34.857 --> 01:01:36.292
PRESENT BOERNER HORVATH
01:01:36.359 --> 01:01:40.530
PRESIDENT RAMOS. RAMOS PRESENT
01:01:40.596 --> 01:01:43.399
THREE OF US ROBERT RIVAS OPAL
01:01:43.466 --> 01:01:47.003
REPEL PRESENT BEFORE. THANK YOU.
01:01:47.070 --> 01:01:48.204
WE HAVE A START ESTABLISH A
01:01:48.271 --> 01:01:51.574
QUORUM. HAD MY WITNESS BE HERE.
01:01:51.641 --> 01:01:52.975
HE WOULD SAY WONDERFUL THINGS
01:01:53.042 --> 01:01:54.911
ABOUT THIS JOB. OH OKAY. IS
01:01:54.977 --> 01:01:56.646
THERE ANYONE ELSE IN THE
01:01:56.712 --> 01:01:57.847
AUDIENCE THAT WOULD LIKE TO
01:01:57.914 --> 01:01:58.948
SUPPORT SENATOR PORTANTINO'S
01:01:59.015 --> 01:02:03.853
BILL? A B R S P 9 32. SEEING
01:02:03.920 --> 01:02:05.088
NONE. LOOKS LIKE WE GOT PAST
01:02:05.154 --> 01:02:06.155
THAT ONE. THE OTHER ANY
01:02:06.222 --> 01:02:08.057
OPPOSITION FOR THE BILL. WELCOME
01:02:08.124 --> 01:02:09.926
ON YOU HAVE A SEAT IF YOU'D
01:02:09.992 --> 01:02:19.469
LIKE. YEAH. IT'S FINE. THANK YOU
01:02:19.535 --> 01:02:20.336
VERY MUCH. MADAM CHAIR AND
01:02:20.403 --> 01:02:21.938
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE DAMON
01:02:22.004 --> 01:02:23.906
CONKLIN WITH THE LEGAL
01:02:23.973 --> 01:02:26.876
CALIFORNIA CITIES. WE DO WANT TO
01:02:26.943 --> 01:02:28.044
FIRST AND FOREMOST. THANK THE
01:02:28.111 --> 01:02:30.913
COMMITTEE, THE AUTHOR AND THE
01:02:30.980 --> 01:02:33.116
SPONSORS OF THE BILL FOR THE
01:02:33.182 --> 01:02:34.550
MOST RECENT AMENDMENTS. IT IS
01:02:34.617 --> 01:02:36.119
DEFINITELY A STEP IN THE RIGHT
01:02:36.185 --> 01:02:36.953
DIRECTION. THEY'VE BEEN WORKING
01:02:37.019 --> 01:02:38.154
WITH US VERY IN A VERY
01:02:38.221 --> 01:02:39.856
COLLABORATIVE MANNER, AND WE DO
01:02:39.922 --> 01:02:42.325
APPRECIATE THAT. UM WE DO REMAIN
01:02:42.391 --> 01:02:45.995
OPPOSED FOR THE CREATION OF A
01:02:46.062 --> 01:02:48.965
NEW PRIVATE RIGHT OF ACTION. UM
01:02:49.031 --> 01:02:52.135
THE CREATION OF THIS WOULD UPEND
01:02:52.201 --> 01:02:55.471
DESIGN IMMUNITY THAT CURRENTLY
01:02:55.538 --> 01:02:57.006
IS IN PLACE FOR LOCAL
01:02:57.073 --> 01:02:59.108
GOVERNMENTS. UH MANY SMALL
01:02:59.175 --> 01:03:01.544
GOVERNMENTS THAT RESIDE IN THESE
01:03:01.611 --> 01:03:03.880
10 LARGER COUNTIES THAT THIS NEW
01:03:03.946 --> 01:03:05.281
PRIVATE RIGHT OF ACTION WITH THE
01:03:05.348 --> 01:03:06.549
PROVISIONS OF THE BILL WOULD
01:03:06.616 --> 01:03:10.019
APPLY TO AT SOME OF EITHER
01:03:10.086 --> 01:03:12.121
LACKING OF THE FUNDS, OR THERE
01:03:12.188 --> 01:03:14.290
HAS BEEN POPULATIONS THAT HAVE
01:03:14.357 --> 01:03:15.358
BEEN DISPLACED BECAUSE OF THE
01:03:15.424 --> 01:03:18.261
FIRES. FOR WHICH, UM THIS, UH
01:03:18.327 --> 01:03:19.495
THE CURRENT PROVISIONS OF THE
01:03:19.562 --> 01:03:22.632
BILL WOULD WOULD STILL
01:03:22.698 --> 01:03:24.500
OBLIGATING FORCE THOSE, UH,
01:03:24.567 --> 01:03:26.502
CAPITAL IMPROVEMENTS TO BE MADE
01:03:26.569 --> 01:03:29.505
AND AGAIN WITHOUT ANY FUNDING. I
01:03:29.572 --> 01:03:31.007
KNOW THAT THERE IS A PROVISION
01:03:31.073 --> 01:03:32.642
IN THERE THAT SAYS IT'S THE
01:03:32.708 --> 01:03:33.809
INTENT OF THE LEGISLATURE TO
01:03:33.876 --> 01:03:34.844
DEVELOP A GRANT PROGRAM. AND
01:03:34.911 --> 01:03:37.513
WHILE THEY MAY REVISE INCLUDED
01:03:37.580 --> 01:03:39.215
AT $1.2 BILLION FOR ACTIVE
01:03:39.282 --> 01:03:42.118
TRANSPORTATION, WE'D LOVE TO SEE
01:03:42.185 --> 01:03:43.853
THAT THAT GRANT PROGRAM BE TIED
01:03:43.920 --> 01:03:46.222
. UM AND YOU KNOW IF THIS BILL
01:03:46.289 --> 01:03:49.158
WERE TO MOVE FORWARD, UM WE DO
01:03:49.225 --> 01:03:51.127
BELIEVE THAT IT'S UH, NOT
01:03:51.194 --> 01:03:55.164
APPROPRIATE TO MAKE SUCH
01:03:55.231 --> 01:03:57.333
DETAILED, PRESCRIPTIVE AND
01:03:57.400 --> 01:03:59.535
ARBITRARY DEADLINES IN THE
01:03:59.602 --> 01:04:01.771
CIRCULATION ELEMENT, POSSIBLY
01:04:01.837 --> 01:04:03.406
MORE APPROPRIATE IN A LOCAL
01:04:03.472 --> 01:04:04.740
STREETS AND ROADS SAFETY PLAN
01:04:04.807 --> 01:04:08.511
BUT AGAIN FOR THE FOR YOU KNOW
01:04:08.578 --> 01:04:11.847
FOR THE, UM, THE LIABILITY FOR
01:04:11.914 --> 01:04:13.015
CITIES WHO MANY OF THE SMALL
01:04:13.082 --> 01:04:16.385
ONES HAVE TO PULL THEIR
01:04:16.452 --> 01:04:19.288
RESOURCES ENTER INTO A J P A FOR
01:04:19.355 --> 01:04:22.525
INSURANCE PURPOSES. THOSE LOCALS
01:04:22.592 --> 01:04:23.826
DON'T HAVE ABILITY FOR
01:04:23.893 --> 01:04:27.029
COMMERCIAL LIABILITY, SO THIS
01:04:27.096 --> 01:04:28.431
NEW PRIVATE RIGHT OF ACTION
01:04:28.497 --> 01:04:30.366
WOULD CREATE A NEW, DANGEROUS
01:04:30.433 --> 01:04:31.367
CONDITION AND PLAY SMALLER
01:04:31.434 --> 01:04:32.868
CITIES AT THIS VERY HIGH RISK.
01:04:32.935 --> 01:04:34.470
AND THEY'D BE DROPPED. THEY
01:04:34.537 --> 01:04:36.005
WOULDN'T HAVE THE COVERAGE. SO
01:04:36.072 --> 01:04:36.906
FOR THOSE REASONS WE OPPOSE
01:04:36.973 --> 01:04:38.774
UNLESS AMENDED. THANK YOU VERY
01:04:38.841 --> 01:04:40.543
MUCH FOR YOUR TESTIMONY. IS
01:04:40.610 --> 01:04:41.744
THERE ANYONE ELSE IN OPPOSITION
01:04:41.811 --> 01:04:44.981
TO THE BILL? YOU DON'T NEED A
01:04:45.047 --> 01:04:46.315
JOG. JUST TAKE YOUR TIME. GOOD
01:04:46.382 --> 01:04:47.750
AFTERNOON, MADAM CHAIR CURA ROSS
01:04:47.817 --> 01:04:49.518
ON BEHALF OF THE CITY OF SAN
01:04:49.585 --> 01:04:50.786
MARCOS. WE CERTAINLY APPRECIATE
01:04:50.853 --> 01:04:51.754
THE AMENDMENT BUT REMAIN OPPOSED
01:04:51.821 --> 01:04:54.724
AT THIS TIME. THANK YOU. GOOD
01:04:54.790 --> 01:04:55.825
AFTERNOON AGAIN. MADAM CHAIR
01:04:55.891 --> 01:04:56.759
MEMBERS, LAUREN DE VALENCIA
01:04:56.826 --> 01:04:58.694
REPRESENT THE AMERICAN PLANNING
01:04:58.761 --> 01:05:00.029
ASSOCIATION WOULD JUST LIKE TO
01:05:00.096 --> 01:05:01.931
ECHO THE COMMENTS RAISED BY MY
01:05:01.998 --> 01:05:02.999
COLLEAGUE AT THE LEAGUE OF
01:05:03.065 --> 01:05:04.533
CALIFORNIA CITIES AND WE'RE JUST
01:05:04.600 --> 01:05:05.301
REALLY RHETORIC REITERATE. WE
01:05:05.368 --> 01:05:07.370
APPRECIATE THE AMENDMENTS ON THE
01:05:07.436 --> 01:05:07.903
IMPLEMENTATION. BUT AGAIN,
01:05:07.970 --> 01:05:08.938
THERE'S A LOT OF DETAIL THAT'S
01:05:09.005 --> 01:05:10.106
GOING INTO THE GENERAL PLAN THAT
01:05:10.172 --> 01:05:11.974
WE HAVE CONCERNS WITH. ALSO
01:05:12.041 --> 01:05:13.476
TODAY, RIGHT, UH, REGISTERING
01:05:13.542 --> 01:05:14.810
OPPOSITION FOR THE URBAN
01:05:14.877 --> 01:05:15.878
COUNTIES OF CALIFORNIA,
01:05:15.945 --> 01:05:17.380
CALIFORNIA STATE ASSOCIATION OF
01:05:17.446 --> 01:05:18.981
COUNTIES AND MY COLLEAGUES IN
01:05:19.048 --> 01:05:21.284
THE LINE, SO THAT'S IT AND THANK
01:05:21.350 --> 01:05:22.418
YOU SO MUCH, SENATOR PORTANTINO.
01:05:22.485 --> 01:05:23.486
FOR NOW, WE LOOK FORWARD TO
01:05:23.552 --> 01:05:25.221
CONTINUING TO WORK WITH YOU.
01:05:25.288 --> 01:05:27.490
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. MADAM
01:05:27.556 --> 01:05:28.491
CHAIR AND MEMBERS ERIC TURNER ON
01:05:28.557 --> 01:05:30.793
BEHALF OF THE CITY OF DOWNEY AND
01:05:30.860 --> 01:05:32.028
THE TOWN OF APPLE VALLEY,
01:05:32.094 --> 01:05:33.129
OPPOSED UNLESS AMENDED LINER
01:05:33.195 --> 01:05:34.864
COMMENTS WITH THE LEGAL CITIES.
01:05:34.930 --> 01:05:39.635
THANK YOU. GOOD AFTERNOON. TRACY
01:05:39.702 --> 01:05:40.336
RYAN, RURAL COUNTY
01:05:40.403 --> 01:05:41.871
REPRESENTATIVE CALIFORNIA ALSO
01:05:41.937 --> 01:05:43.139
OPPOSED LESS AMENDED. THANK YOU.
01:05:43.205 --> 01:05:46.208
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. ANYONE ELSE
01:05:46.275 --> 01:05:48.744
IN OPPOSITION. OKAY WE DON'T SEE
01:05:48.811 --> 01:05:49.979
ANYONE ELSE. COMMITTEE MEMBERS.
01:05:50.046 --> 01:05:53.783
DO YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS? I
01:05:53.849 --> 01:05:55.084
DON'T SEE A QUESTION. UM, LIKE
01:05:55.151 --> 01:05:59.021
SOMEONE TO ENTERTAIN AND MOTION.
01:05:59.088 --> 01:06:02.091
EXCUSE ME. WE HAVE A MOTION BY
01:06:02.158 --> 01:06:03.192
TASHA ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S TASHA
01:06:03.259 --> 01:06:06.495
BOERNER HORVATH. AND WE DON'T
01:06:06.562 --> 01:06:11.033
HAVE A SECOND YET. AND WE HAVE A
01:06:11.100 --> 01:06:11.567
SECOND BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
01:06:11.634 --> 01:06:13.102
RAMOS. THANK YOU VERY MUCH, MR
01:06:13.169 --> 01:06:15.871
RAMOS. UM WOULD YOU LIKE TO
01:06:15.938 --> 01:06:17.206
CLOSE? THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR
01:06:17.273 --> 01:06:18.541
AND AGAIN. I APPRECIATE THE WORK
01:06:18.607 --> 01:06:20.176
THAT'S GONE INTO THIS BILL.
01:06:20.242 --> 01:06:21.143
FRANKLY, EVERY POLICY COMMITTEE
01:06:21.210 --> 01:06:22.878
THAT HAS HEARD THIS BILL HAS PUT
01:06:22.945 --> 01:06:26.148
ITS INPUT. AND ITS IMPRINT ON IT
01:06:26.215 --> 01:06:28.017
, AND I THINK IT'S IMPROVED
01:06:28.084 --> 01:06:29.885
ALONG THE WAY. UM OBVIOUSLY THIS
01:06:29.952 --> 01:06:31.120
IS A DIFFICULT CONVERSATION
01:06:31.187 --> 01:06:32.121
BECAUSE WE ACTUALLY WANT TO DO
01:06:32.188 --> 01:06:34.457
SOMETHING. AND THAT REQUIRES
01:06:34.523 --> 01:06:35.558
WILL THAT REQUIRES RESOURCES AND
01:06:35.624 --> 01:06:37.927
THAT REQUIRES ACCOUNTABILITY. IN
01:06:37.993 --> 01:06:39.228
THIS BILL HAS ALL THREE ATTACHED
01:06:39.295 --> 01:06:42.665
TO IT. IT'S NO SECRET THAT OVER
01:06:42.732 --> 01:06:44.967
THE PAST TWO YEARS, I'VE BECOME
01:06:45.034 --> 01:06:46.068
AN AVID BIKER, AND I'VE LEARNED
01:06:46.135 --> 01:06:47.937
A LOT OUT THERE. UM AND I'VE
01:06:48.003 --> 01:06:50.706
SEEN CITIES THAT ARE HAVE
01:06:50.773 --> 01:06:51.407
IMPLEMENTED BIKE SAFETY PLANS
01:06:51.474 --> 01:06:53.109
AND THEIR PLEASURE TO RIDE
01:06:53.175 --> 01:06:55.244
THROUGH AND I'VE BEEN THROUGH
01:06:55.311 --> 01:06:57.513
CITIES THAT HAVEN'T AND THEY'RE
01:06:57.580 --> 01:06:58.247
QUITE DANGEROUS. THE NUMBER OF
01:06:58.314 --> 01:07:00.416
FATALITIES ON OUR STREETS. WE
01:07:00.483 --> 01:07:02.251
KNOW WHERE THESE HOT SPOTS ARE.
01:07:02.318 --> 01:07:04.487
WE JUST HAVE TO DO SOMETHING
01:07:04.553 --> 01:07:05.121
ABOUT IT, AND THAT'S WHAT THIS
01:07:05.187 --> 01:07:07.456
BILL SEEKS TO DO. AND OBVIOUSLY
01:07:07.523 --> 01:07:08.257
THAT'S WHY THE OPPOSITION HAS
01:07:08.324 --> 01:07:10.292
COME OUT BECAUSE IT'S GOING TO
01:07:10.359 --> 01:07:12.361
REQUIRE A LOT OF WORK. AND SO I
01:07:12.428 --> 01:07:13.496
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AND I VOTE.
01:07:13.562 --> 01:07:15.097
THANK THANK YOU VERY MUCH,
01:07:15.164 --> 01:07:17.466
SENATOR AND WORKING WITH THE
01:07:17.533 --> 01:07:18.367
COMMITTEE ON ON THE SCOPE OF
01:07:18.434 --> 01:07:20.636
YOUR BILL, ENSURING THAT CITIES
01:07:20.703 --> 01:07:22.138
AND COUNTIES PLAN TO ENHANCE
01:07:22.204 --> 01:07:24.073
SAFETY CORRIDORS FOR CYCLISTS.
01:07:24.140 --> 01:07:25.541
PEDESTRIANS WILL ENCOURAGE MORE
01:07:25.608 --> 01:07:26.909
PEOPLE TO BIKE TO WORK AND TO
01:07:26.976 --> 01:07:27.910
TAKE OTHER ALTERNATIVES AND
01:07:27.977 --> 01:07:30.913
OTHER VEHICLES. I KNOW THE LOCAL
01:07:30.980 --> 01:07:32.448
LOCAL AGENCIES HAVE SOME
01:07:32.515 --> 01:07:33.649
CONCERNS REGARDING THE PRIVATE
01:07:33.716 --> 01:07:35.584
RIGHT OF ACTION PEACE AND THAT
01:07:35.651 --> 01:07:36.218
YOUR SPONSORS HAVE PROPOSED TO
01:07:36.285 --> 01:07:37.987
FURTHER REFINE THE SCOPE OF THE
01:07:38.053 --> 01:07:40.523
BILL. AS THE BILL MOVES FORWARD
01:07:40.589 --> 01:07:42.191
. PLEASE CONTINUE TO ENGAGE WITH
01:07:42.258 --> 01:07:43.793
MY THIS COMMITTEE STAFF ON
01:07:43.859 --> 01:07:45.895
FUTURE AMENDMENTS. I'M PLEASED
01:07:45.961 --> 01:07:47.062
TO SUPPORT YOUR BILL WITH THE
01:07:47.129 --> 01:07:48.531
COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS. EMOTION IS
01:07:48.597 --> 01:07:50.433
DO PASS AS A MINUTE TO THE
01:07:50.499 --> 01:07:51.500
TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE.
01:07:51.567 --> 01:07:53.202
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
01:07:53.269 --> 01:07:54.203
AGUIAR-CURRY AGUIAR-CURRY. AYE
01:07:54.270 --> 01:07:59.909
LACKEY. BLOOM BLOOM I
01:07:59.975 --> 01:08:06.015
BOERNER HORVATH HARVARD I RAMOS. RAMOS SILAS RIVERS, ROBERT
01:08:06.081 --> 01:08:09.051
RIVAS, ROBERT RIVERSIDE, GOPAL.
01:08:09.118 --> 01:08:12.054
VOEPEL. NO, YOU HAVE ABOUT IS
01:08:12.121 --> 01:08:17.927
51. THANK YOU. OH, IT'S OUT. IS
01:08:17.993 --> 01:08:20.596
IT OUT? IT'S OUT THERE. MR
01:08:20.663 --> 01:08:21.664
PORTANTINO. I APOLOGIZE FOR NOT
01:08:21.730 --> 01:08:24.400
ANNOUNCING THAT RIGHT, SENATOR
01:08:24.467 --> 01:08:27.503
NEWMAN. WE HAVE ITEM NUMBER FIVE
01:08:27.570 --> 01:08:31.540
SB 991, AND YOU CAN PROCEED WITH
01:08:31.607 --> 01:08:32.708
ITEM NUMBER NINE RIGHT AFTER
01:08:32.775 --> 01:08:34.477
THAT FOR MR ARCHULETTA. GOOD.
01:08:34.543 --> 01:08:39.415
YEAH. THANK YOU. GOOD AFTERNOON
01:08:39.482 --> 01:08:41.350
, MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS I AM
01:08:41.417 --> 01:08:42.785
HERE TODAY TO PRESENT SP 991
01:08:42.852 --> 01:08:44.386
BEFORE I BEGIN. I'D LIKE TO
01:08:44.453 --> 01:08:46.188
THINK THAT SHARE AND HER STAFF
01:08:46.255 --> 01:08:48.424
FOR THEIR WORK ON THE BILL, AS
01:08:48.491 --> 01:08:49.558
WELL AS TO ACCEPT THE
01:08:49.625 --> 01:08:50.192
COMMITTEE'S PROPOSED AMENDMENTS.
01:08:50.259 --> 01:08:51.393
WHICH WILL LIMIT THE NUMBER OF
01:08:51.460 --> 01:08:53.295
PROJECTS THAT CAN USE THE
01:08:53.362 --> 01:08:53.796
PROGRESSIVE DESIGN BILL
01:08:53.863 --> 01:08:55.130
CONTRACTING METHOD TO 15
01:08:55.197 --> 01:08:56.699
PROJECTS PER INDIVIDUAL AGENCY.
01:08:56.765 --> 01:08:58.534
SB 991 WILL ALLOW LOCAL WATER
01:08:58.601 --> 01:08:59.802
AGENCIES TO CONTRACT WITH
01:08:59.869 --> 01:09:01.337
ENTITIES THAT USE THE
01:09:01.403 --> 01:09:02.338
PROGRESSIVE DESIGN BUILD
01:09:02.404 --> 01:09:03.339
CONTRACT CONTRACTING MODEL IN
01:09:03.405 --> 01:09:05.274
THE EXECUTION. OF CALIFORNIA.
01:09:05.341 --> 01:09:07.676
PUBLIC WORKS PROJECTS PDB AS
01:09:07.743 --> 01:09:08.944
IT'S COMMONLY REFERRED TO AS AN
01:09:09.011 --> 01:09:10.079
EVOLUTION OF THE TRADITIONAL,
01:09:10.145 --> 01:09:11.747
MORE COMMONLY DEPLOYED DESIGN
01:09:11.814 --> 01:09:12.982
BUILD CONTRACTING MODEL, WHICH
01:09:13.048 --> 01:09:14.783
DEVELOPS DESIGN PACKAGES BASED
01:09:14.850 --> 01:09:15.918
ON PARAMETERS DEFINED BY THE
01:09:15.985 --> 01:09:18.187
CONTRACTING AGENCY, TYPICALLY
01:09:18.254 --> 01:09:19.288
WITHOUT THE AGENCY'S DIRECT
01:09:19.355 --> 01:09:20.723
INPUT DURING THE DESIGN PROCESS.
01:09:20.789 --> 01:09:23.392
DESIGN BUILD IS, AS IT IS
01:09:23.459 --> 01:09:24.426
COMMONLY REFERRED TO AS USEFUL
01:09:24.493 --> 01:09:26.195
FOR PROJECTS THAT ARE NOT
01:09:26.262 --> 01:09:26.929
EXPECTED TO CHANGE BUT CAN BE
01:09:26.996 --> 01:09:28.664
LESS EFFICIENT AND MORE COSTLY
01:09:28.731 --> 01:09:29.999
IF THERE ARE MATERIAL CHANGES
01:09:30.065 --> 01:09:31.166
MADE TO THE PROJECT'S SCOPE AS
01:09:31.233 --> 01:09:33.636
IT PROCEEDS. PROGRESSIVE DESIGN
01:09:33.702 --> 01:09:35.037
BUILDER PDB IS A CONTRACTING
01:09:35.104 --> 01:09:36.539
MODEL IN WHICH A SINGLE ENTITY
01:09:36.605 --> 01:09:38.541
IS HIRED TO DO BOTH THE DESIGN
01:09:38.607 --> 01:09:39.575
AND CONSTRUCTION WORK AT THE
01:09:39.642 --> 01:09:41.977
EARLIEST STAGE OF A PROJECT IN
01:09:42.044 --> 01:09:43.646
RECENT YEARS. THE PDB MODEL IS
01:09:43.712 --> 01:09:44.947
INCREASING POPULARITY BECAUSE IT
01:09:45.014 --> 01:09:46.048
REPRESENTS A VERY COST EFFECTIVE
01:09:46.115 --> 01:09:47.016
FORM OF COLLABORATIVE PROJECT
01:09:47.082 --> 01:09:50.386
DEVELOPMENT. PDB OFFERS AN
01:09:50.452 --> 01:09:51.220
AGENCY THE OPPORTUNITY TO BRING
01:09:51.287 --> 01:09:52.855
A DESIGN BUILDER ONTO THE
01:09:52.922 --> 01:09:54.690
PROJECT TEAM AT AN EARLIER POINT
01:09:54.757 --> 01:09:56.458
IN THE DESIGN PHASE, THIS
01:09:56.525 --> 01:09:57.693
COLLABORATION CAN REDUCE OVERALL
01:09:57.760 --> 01:09:59.628
PROJECT RISKS, COSTS AND
01:09:59.695 --> 01:10:01.096
SCHEDULES. UNDER CURRENT STATUTE
01:10:01.163 --> 01:10:02.231
, HOWEVER, THERE ARE EXPLICIT
01:10:02.298 --> 01:10:04.333
SPECIFICATIONS AND LIMITS. AND
01:10:04.400 --> 01:10:05.801
THE TYPES OF CONTRACTING MODELS
01:10:05.868 --> 01:10:06.969
THAT LOCAL AGENCIES ARE
01:10:07.036 --> 01:10:08.504
PERMITTED TO UTILIZE IN THE
01:10:08.571 --> 01:10:09.305
CONSTRUCTION OF INFRASTRUCTURE
01:10:09.371 --> 01:10:11.840
PROJECTS IN CALIFORNIA IN 2021,
01:10:11.907 --> 01:10:13.175
THE LEGISLATURE GRANTED THE
01:10:13.242 --> 01:10:14.610
DIRECTOR OF GENERAL SERVICES
01:10:14.677 --> 01:10:16.078
AUTHORITY TO USE THE PDB METHOD
01:10:16.145 --> 01:10:18.113
UP FOR UP TO THREE PUBLIC WORKS
01:10:18.180 --> 01:10:19.381
PROJECTS, WHICH WOULD BENEFIT
01:10:19.448 --> 01:10:21.483
FROM THIS CONTRACTING METHOD
01:10:21.550 --> 01:10:22.685
ABOVE THAT NUMBER. HOWEVER LOCAL
01:10:22.751 --> 01:10:23.752
AGENCIES ARE CURRENTLY REQUIRED
01:10:23.819 --> 01:10:25.421
TO SEEK AND RECEIVE LEGISLATIVE
01:10:25.487 --> 01:10:26.922
APPROVAL IN ORDER TO BE
01:10:26.989 --> 01:10:28.023
PERMITTED TO CONTRACT WITH AN
01:10:28.090 --> 01:10:29.558
ENTITY THAT UTILIZES THE PDB
01:10:29.625 --> 01:10:31.527
MODEL FOR DEVELOPING PUBLIC
01:10:31.594 --> 01:10:32.561
WORKS PROJECTS. AGAINST THAT
01:10:32.628 --> 01:10:34.096
BACKDROP, RECENT DATA AND
01:10:34.163 --> 01:10:35.064
FORECASTS HAVE SHOWN THAT
01:10:35.130 --> 01:10:36.332
CALIFORNIA WILL NEED TO DEVELOP
01:10:36.398 --> 01:10:38.467
SUBSTANTIAL ADDITIONAL CAPACITY
01:10:38.534 --> 01:10:39.969
TO TREAT WATER. UNFORTUNATELY
01:10:40.035 --> 01:10:41.670
TECHNOLOGICAL ADVANCEMENTS HAVE
01:10:41.737 --> 01:10:42.171
OPENED THE DOOR TO NEW
01:10:42.237 --> 01:10:43.038
OPPORTUNITIES TO CONVERT
01:10:43.105 --> 01:10:45.074
WASTEWATER INTO DRINKING WATER.
01:10:45.140 --> 01:10:46.809
IN ORDER TO DO SO. IT'S SCALE,
01:10:46.875 --> 01:10:47.409
THOUGH CALIFORNIA'S
01:10:47.476 --> 01:10:49.411
APPROXIMATELY 600 LOCAL WATER
01:10:49.478 --> 01:10:51.046
AGENCIES WILL NEED TO INVEST IN
01:10:51.113 --> 01:10:52.314
NEW INFRASTRUCTURE THAT
01:10:52.381 --> 01:10:53.248
INCORPORATES INNOVATIVE
01:10:53.315 --> 01:10:54.383
TREATMENT METHODS BY AUTHORIZING
01:10:54.450 --> 01:10:57.419
THE EXPANDED UTILIZATION OF PDB.
01:10:57.486 --> 01:10:59.421
SB 991 WILL ALLOW LOCAL WATER
01:10:59.488 --> 01:11:01.056
AGENCY TO MAKE NECESSARY COST
01:11:01.123 --> 01:11:02.458
EFFECTIVE INVESTMENTS IN NEW
01:11:02.524 --> 01:11:03.926
PUBLIC WORKS PROJECTS TO MEET
01:11:03.993 --> 01:11:05.461
THE STATE'S GROWING WATER
01:11:05.527 --> 01:11:06.528
TREATMENT NEEDS WITH ME HERE TO
01:11:06.595 --> 01:11:08.631
TESTIFY IN PERSONS KEITH DONE ON
01:11:08.697 --> 01:11:09.698
BEHALF OF THE WATER,
01:11:09.765 --> 01:11:10.199
COLLABORATIVE DELIVERY,
01:11:10.265 --> 01:11:12.167
SATIATION. AND I AM RESPECTFULLY
01:11:12.234 --> 01:11:13.569
ASKING FOR YOUR VOTE TODAY.
01:11:13.636 --> 01:11:15.304
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. WELCOME
01:11:15.371 --> 01:11:17.606
MADAM CHAIR KEITH DONE HERE IN
01:11:17.673 --> 01:11:19.842
SUPPORT OF SB 991. I'LL BE BRIEF
01:11:19.908 --> 01:11:21.176
. THIS IS A BILL THAT'S ALL
01:11:21.243 --> 01:11:22.177
ABOUT COLLABORATION. WE
01:11:22.244 --> 01:11:23.178
APPRECIATE THE COLLABORATION
01:11:23.245 --> 01:11:24.279
WITH YOUR STAFF AND THIS
01:11:24.346 --> 01:11:26.882
COMMITTEE. PROCUREMENT LAW IN
01:11:26.949 --> 01:11:29.818
CALIFORNIA IS A COBWEB OF
01:11:29.885 --> 01:11:31.487
STATUTES THAT I THINK YOUR STAFF
01:11:31.553 --> 01:11:32.988
HAS DONE AN ADMIRABLE JOB TRYING
01:11:33.055 --> 01:11:34.390
TO HELP BRING ALL THOSE THINGS
01:11:34.456 --> 01:11:36.191
INTO FOCUS. THAT'S A LARGE JOB,
01:11:36.258 --> 01:11:38.427
AND IT'S MUCH APPRECIATED. WE
01:11:38.494 --> 01:11:40.929
BELIEVE THAT IN LOOKING AT THE
01:11:40.996 --> 01:11:43.432
CLIMATE CHANGE IN THE IMPACTS ON
01:11:43.499 --> 01:11:44.466
OUR WATER SYSTEM, THIS IS AN
01:11:44.533 --> 01:11:46.335
IMPORTANT BILL TO HELP LOCAL
01:11:46.402 --> 01:11:47.836
AGENCIES IMPROVE DELIVERY TIMES
01:11:47.903 --> 01:11:48.971
ON WATER PROJECTS. WE HAVE
01:11:49.038 --> 01:11:51.940
PROTECTIONS FOR OUR WORKERS.
01:11:52.007 --> 01:11:53.575
WHICH WE VALUE GREATLY, AND WE'D
01:11:53.642 --> 01:11:54.943
ASK FOR YOUR SUPPORT. I'M HERE
01:11:55.010 --> 01:11:56.812
TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS THAT YOU
01:11:56.879 --> 01:11:57.980
MAY HAVE. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
01:11:58.047 --> 01:11:59.848
VERY MUCH ARE THERE OTHERS IN
01:11:59.915 --> 01:12:01.317
THE ROOM THAT WOULD LIKE TO
01:12:01.383 --> 01:12:04.687
SUPPORT THE BILL. MADAM CHAIR
01:12:04.753 --> 01:12:06.255
MEMBERS. BETH EL ASO ON BEHALF
01:12:06.321 --> 01:12:07.923
OF WATER REUSE CALIFORNIA AND
01:12:07.990 --> 01:12:09.091
THE INLAND EMPIRE UTILITIES
01:12:09.158 --> 01:12:10.159
AGENCY AND STRONG SUPPORT. THANK
01:12:10.225 --> 01:12:15.064
YOU. GOOD AFTERNOON, MADAM CHAIR
01:12:15.130 --> 01:12:16.098
MEMBERS, ERIN AVERY WITH THE
01:12:16.165 --> 01:12:17.166
CALIFORNIA SPECIAL DISTRICTS
01:12:17.232 --> 01:12:18.100
ASSOCIATION AND SUPPORT THANK
01:12:18.167 --> 01:12:23.672
YOU. MADAM TURN MEMBERS, AARON
01:12:23.739 --> 01:12:24.940
EVANS ON BEHALF OF THE SANTA
01:12:25.007 --> 01:12:26.475
CLARA VALLEY WATER DISTRICT
01:12:26.542 --> 01:12:28.010
VALLEY. WATER SUPPORTS THE BILL
01:12:28.077 --> 01:12:29.778
AND APPRECIATES THE AUTHOR AND
01:12:29.845 --> 01:12:30.946
HIS STAFF ARE WORKING WITH US.
01:12:31.013 --> 01:12:36.618
THANK YOU. GOOD AFTERNOON, ROSIE
01:12:36.685 --> 01:12:38.187
THOMPSON WITH METROPOLITAN WATER
01:12:38.253 --> 01:12:39.221
DISTRICT. IN ADDITION TO THE L,
01:12:39.288 --> 01:12:41.090
A COUNTY SANITATION DISTRICT IN
01:12:41.156 --> 01:12:46.028
SUPPORT. AFTERNOON CHRIS ROSE ON
01:12:46.095 --> 01:12:47.162
BEHALF OF SILICON VALLEY
01:12:47.229 --> 01:12:50.065
LEADERSHIP GROUP IN SUPPORT.
01:12:50.132 --> 01:12:51.233
THANK YOU. ARE THERE ANY OTHER
01:12:51.300 --> 01:12:53.702
WITNESES IN SUPPORT? SEEING
01:12:53.769 --> 01:12:54.937
NONE. ARE THERE ANY WITNESSES IN
01:12:55.003 --> 01:12:57.740
OPPOSITION TO THE BILL? SING
01:12:57.806 --> 01:12:58.907
NONE. ARE THERE ANY QUESTIONS OF
01:12:58.974 --> 01:13:04.379
THE COMMITTEE? OKAY, WE HAVE WE
01:13:04.446 --> 01:13:08.450
HAVE A MOTION AND A SECOND.
01:13:08.517 --> 01:13:09.651
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE? I
01:13:09.718 --> 01:13:11.587
WOULD, AND I APOLOGIZE FOR DOING
01:13:11.653 --> 01:13:14.523
THIS, BUT TO QUOTE THE BELOVED.
01:13:14.590 --> 01:13:15.891
TO PARAPHRASE THE BELOVED RAP
01:13:15.958 --> 01:13:17.226
GROUP. NAUGHTY BY NATURE. I'M
01:13:17.292 --> 01:13:19.628
DOWN WITH PDB. YOU KNOW ME AND I
01:13:19.695 --> 01:13:21.563
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR
01:13:21.630 --> 01:13:22.831
SUPPOSED TO DO A SONG SHUFFLE
01:13:22.898 --> 01:13:28.403
OUT. OKAY YOU WERE WAITING FOR
01:13:28.470 --> 01:13:30.639
THAT WEIGHT IN MY HEAD ALL DAY.
01:13:30.706 --> 01:13:32.875
I'M SORRY YEAH WE'RE HAVING A
01:13:32.941 --> 01:13:34.743
LOT OF SMILES IN THIS MEETING
01:13:34.810 --> 01:13:38.947
TODAY. YEAH. SO RESPECT WE WON'T
01:13:39.014 --> 01:13:41.450
SAY SENATOR NEWMAN. I APPRECIATE
01:13:41.517 --> 01:13:42.985
THE WORK ON THE BILL.
01:13:43.051 --> 01:13:44.153
PROGRESSIVE DESIGN BUILD IS
01:13:44.219 --> 01:13:45.654
RELATIVELY NEW PROCUREMENT
01:13:45.721 --> 01:13:46.722
METHOD AND I APPRECIATE THE
01:13:46.789 --> 01:13:49.091
SAFEGUARDS. YOU ALREADY INCLUDED
01:13:49.158 --> 01:13:50.592
IN THE BILL WITH THE ADDITIONAL
01:13:50.659 --> 01:13:51.727
LIMITS IN THE COMMITTEE
01:13:51.794 --> 01:13:52.528
AMENDMENTS. I'M PLEASED TO
01:13:52.594 --> 01:13:53.962
SUPPORT YOUR BILL TODAY, THE
01:13:54.029 --> 01:13:56.465
MOTION IS DUE PASS AS AMENDED TO
01:13:56.532 --> 01:13:57.032
THE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
01:13:57.099 --> 01:13:59.067
SECRETARY, PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
01:13:59.134 --> 01:14:03.605
. CURRY CURRY. I LACKEY. BLOOM.
01:14:03.672 --> 01:14:06.442
BLOOM I BOERNER HORVATH HARDBACK
01:14:06.508 --> 01:14:09.711
I RAMOS RAMOS. I THREE OF US
01:14:09.778 --> 01:14:10.312
ROBERT RIVAS ROBERT RIVERSIDE
01:14:10.379 --> 01:14:17.953
VOEPEL. WE FELT, AYE. 60 MORE.
01:14:18.020 --> 01:14:19.188
OBVIOUSLY A FAN OF YOUR BILL IS
01:14:19.254 --> 01:14:24.092
OUT. THAT'S OKAY. WE'LL MOVE ON
01:14:24.159 --> 01:14:25.561
TO OUR GOING TO TAKE ON ITEM
01:14:25.627 --> 01:14:30.566
NUMBER NINE. SB 12 91, SENATOR
01:14:30.632 --> 01:14:31.600
ARCHULETTA WITH MR NEWMAN,
01:14:31.667 --> 01:14:35.404
PRESENTING TODAY. FEEL FREE TO
01:14:35.470 --> 01:14:36.972
BEGIN WHEN YOU'D LIKE. THANK
01:14:37.039 --> 01:14:38.407
YOU. THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR AND
01:14:38.473 --> 01:14:39.875
MEMBERS I PRESENTING SENATE BILL
01:14:39.942 --> 01:14:41.343
12 91 ON BEHALF OF SENATOR
01:14:41.410 --> 01:14:42.110
ARCHULETTA, WHO IS UNDER THE
01:14:42.177 --> 01:14:44.313
WEATHER. I WOULD LIKE TO START
01:14:44.379 --> 01:14:45.614
BY MAKING CLEAR THAT THE SENATOR
01:14:45.681 --> 01:14:46.748
HAS ACCEPTED THE COMMITTEE
01:14:46.815 --> 01:14:47.583
SUGGESTED AMENDMENTS. AS
01:14:47.649 --> 01:14:50.052
REFLECTED ON PAGE FIVE OF THE
01:14:50.118 --> 01:14:52.187
ANALYSIS. WHEN PASSED. SB 12 91
01:14:52.254 --> 01:14:53.522
WILL DIRECT LOCAL GOVERNMENTS TO
01:14:53.589 --> 01:14:54.723
ADAPT THEIR EXISTING
01:14:54.790 --> 01:14:55.224
ADMINISTRATIVE APPROVAL
01:14:55.290 --> 01:14:57.125
PROCESSES FOR THE PERMITTING OF
01:14:57.192 --> 01:14:58.594
ZERO EMISSION VEHICLE CHARGING
01:14:58.660 --> 01:14:59.595
INFRASTRUCTURE TO INCLUDE
01:14:59.661 --> 01:15:01.630
HYDROGEN FUELING INFRASTRUCTURE
01:15:01.697 --> 01:15:03.432
WHILE ALLOWING FOR DENIALS OF
01:15:03.498 --> 01:15:04.666
THOSE PERMITS, BASED ONLY ON
01:15:04.733 --> 01:15:05.701
DEMONSTRATED HEALTH OR SAFETY
01:15:05.767 --> 01:15:07.803
IMPACTS. HISTORICALLY DEVELOPERS
01:15:07.870 --> 01:15:09.338
OF HYGIENE, RETAIL FUELING
01:15:09.404 --> 01:15:10.205
INFRASTRUCTURE HAVE BEEN DENIED
01:15:10.272 --> 01:15:12.040
PERMITS FOR A VARIETY OF
01:15:12.107 --> 01:15:13.308
REASONS, HAVING LITTLE OR
01:15:13.375 --> 01:15:15.244
NOTHING TO DO DIRECTLY WITH THAT
01:15:15.310 --> 01:15:16.278
INSTALLATION. ONE STATION IN
01:15:16.345 --> 01:15:17.746
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA, FOR EXAMPLE
01:15:17.813 --> 01:15:19.348
, IS DESIGNED TO PERMIT UNTIL
01:15:19.414 --> 01:15:21.884
THEY AGREED TO PAY FOR A TRAFFIC
01:15:21.950 --> 01:15:22.517
LIGHT TO BE INSTALLED DOWN THE
01:15:22.584 --> 01:15:23.185
STREET FROM THE PROPOSED
01:15:23.252 --> 01:15:24.052
STATION. WHILE ANOTHER WAS
01:15:24.119 --> 01:15:25.587
DENIED APPROVAL UNTIL THE
01:15:25.654 --> 01:15:26.722
STATION DEVELOPER AGREED TO PAY
01:15:26.788 --> 01:15:28.357
FOR AN ART INSTALLATION IN ORDER
01:15:28.423 --> 01:15:29.758
TO MEET CALIFORNIA'S FUTURE
01:15:29.825 --> 01:15:31.393
CLEAN TRANSPORTATION GOALS,
01:15:31.460 --> 01:15:32.861
INCLUDING THE TRANSITION TO ZERO
01:15:32.928 --> 01:15:34.997
EMISSION VEHICLE SALES BY 2035.
01:15:35.063 --> 01:15:36.331
WE MUST INCREASE THE
01:15:36.398 --> 01:15:37.332
AVAILABILITY, ABILITY OF FUELING
01:15:37.399 --> 01:15:38.934
INFRASTRUCTURE, BOTH FOR BATTERY
01:15:39.001 --> 01:15:40.869
ELECTRIC AND FUEL CELL ELECTRIC
01:15:40.936 --> 01:15:42.170
VEHICLES. STUDIES HAVE FOUND
01:15:42.237 --> 01:15:43.372
THAT BOTH OF THESE ZERO EMISSION
01:15:43.438 --> 01:15:45.674
MODALITIES WILL NECESSARILY BE
01:15:45.741 --> 01:15:46.408
PART OF CALIFORNIA'S
01:15:46.475 --> 01:15:48.110
TRANSPORTATION FLEET. IF WE ARE
01:15:48.176 --> 01:15:50.145
GOING TO MEET THOSE AMBITIOUS
01:15:50.212 --> 01:15:50.946
GOALS, IT SHOULD GO WITHOUT
01:15:51.013 --> 01:15:52.481
SAYING THAT CALIFORNIA CONSUMERS
01:15:52.547 --> 01:15:53.615
ARE NOT LIKELY TO ADOPT ZERO
01:15:53.682 --> 01:15:54.917
EMISSION VEHICLES, ESPECIALLY AT
01:15:54.983 --> 01:15:56.685
THE RATES WE WANT AND NEED THEM
01:15:56.752 --> 01:15:58.153
TO IF THE REQUISITE CHARGING OR
01:15:58.220 --> 01:15:59.521
FUELING INFRASTRUCTURE IS NOT
01:15:59.588 --> 01:16:01.790
WIDELY AVAILABLE TO THAT, AND SB
01:16:01.857 --> 01:16:04.226
12 91 CREATES A PATH TO EASE THE
01:16:04.293 --> 01:16:05.494
INITIAL PERMANENT PROCESS FOR
01:16:05.560 --> 01:16:06.395
RETAIL HYDROGEN, FUELING
01:16:06.461 --> 01:16:07.996
STATIONS THAT WILL SUPPLY FUEL
01:16:08.063 --> 01:16:09.364
TO CALIFORNIA'S GROWING NUMBER
01:16:09.431 --> 01:16:10.799
OF HYGIENE, FUEL CELL ELECTRIC
01:16:10.866 --> 01:16:12.401
CARS. WHILE THIS BILL PRESERVES
01:16:12.467 --> 01:16:13.869
LOCAL AUTHORITY TO DENY A PERMIT
01:16:13.936 --> 01:16:15.470
BASED ON SAFETY, OR PUBLIC
01:16:15.537 --> 01:16:16.471
HEALTH REASONS, THE MEASURE
01:16:16.538 --> 01:16:17.539
REQUIRES LOCAL OFFICIALS. TO
01:16:17.606 --> 01:16:18.874
DISCLOSE CONCERNS AND OFFER
01:16:18.941 --> 01:16:20.442
SOLUTIONS DURING THE PERMITTING
01:16:20.509 --> 01:16:23.245
PROCESS AND SO DOING AS B 12 91
01:16:23.312 --> 01:16:24.112
WILL EASE PERMITTING
01:16:24.179 --> 01:16:25.614
REQUIREMENTS WITHOUT SACRIFICING
01:16:25.681 --> 01:16:27.082
LOCAL CONTROL WHILE ENSURING
01:16:27.149 --> 01:16:28.116
OPPORTUNITIES FOR THE
01:16:28.183 --> 01:16:29.418
INSTALLATION OF ELECTRIC
01:16:29.484 --> 01:16:30.185
CHARGING INFRASTRUCTURE AND
01:16:30.252 --> 01:16:31.019
RETAIL HYDROGEN, FUELING
01:16:31.086 --> 01:16:33.155
STATIONS IN ORDER TO KEEP PACE
01:16:33.221 --> 01:16:34.489
WITH CALIFORNIA'S AMBITIOUS AND
01:16:34.556 --> 01:16:35.857
EMINENTLY WORTHY TRANSPORTATION
01:16:35.924 --> 01:16:37.826
DECARBONIZATION GOALS. THIS BILL
01:16:37.893 --> 01:16:38.994
HAS NO KNOWN OPPOSITION HAS
01:16:39.061 --> 01:16:41.363
RECEIVED BIPARTISAN SUPPORT THUS
01:16:41.430 --> 01:16:42.831
FAR FOR THESE REASONS, I'M
01:16:42.898 --> 01:16:44.499
ASKING FOR YOUR VOTE ON BEHALF
01:16:44.566 --> 01:16:46.335
OF THE CENTER WITH ME HERE TO
01:16:46.401 --> 01:16:48.203
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL
01:16:48.270 --> 01:16:48.804
IS THERESA COOK. REPRESENTING
01:16:48.870 --> 01:16:50.472
THE HYDROGEN CALIFORNIA HYDROGEN
01:16:50.539 --> 01:16:52.441
COALITION. THANK YOU. WELCOME
01:16:52.507 --> 01:16:54.176
THANK YOU. GOOD AFTERNOON,
01:16:54.242 --> 01:16:55.477
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S AND, UH,
01:16:55.544 --> 01:16:56.712
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S EXCUSE ME.
01:16:56.778 --> 01:16:57.879
THERESA COOK ON BEHALF OF THE
01:16:57.946 --> 01:17:00.582
CALIFORNIA HYDROGEN COALITION. I
01:17:00.649 --> 01:17:01.516
THINK THAT SENATOR CATCHED IT
01:17:01.583 --> 01:17:03.585
CAPTURED IT PERFECTLY. WE HAVE A
01:17:03.652 --> 01:17:05.187
VERY BIG CHALLENGE AHEAD OF US
01:17:05.253 --> 01:17:06.588
GETTING TO 100% 0 EMISSION
01:17:06.655 --> 01:17:08.223
VEHICLES. WE KNOW THAT BATTERY
01:17:08.290 --> 01:17:10.092
ELECTRIC AND FUEL CELL ELECTRIC
01:17:10.158 --> 01:17:11.760
ARE GOING TO BE VERY CRITICAL TO
01:17:11.827 --> 01:17:13.261
THAT EFFORT IN THE LIGHT THROUGH
01:17:13.328 --> 01:17:16.131
HEAVY DUTY CLASSES. UM AND SP 12
01:17:16.198 --> 01:17:18.633
91 IS KIND OF A FIRST STEP IN
01:17:18.700 --> 01:17:20.135
THIS PARTNERSHIP THAT WE HAVE
01:17:20.202 --> 01:17:21.603
WITH LOCAL GOVERNMENTS TO GET
01:17:21.670 --> 01:17:22.971
THESE STATIONS BUILT IN ADVANCE
01:17:23.038 --> 01:17:24.940
OF INCREASED VEHICLE DEPLOYMENT.
01:17:25.007 --> 01:17:26.441
IS THE SENATOR POINTED OUT. THE
01:17:26.508 --> 01:17:28.577
BILL STILL PRESERVES EXEMPTIONS
01:17:28.643 --> 01:17:29.578
FOR PUBLIC SAFETY AND HEALTH
01:17:29.644 --> 01:17:32.481
CONCERNS, WHICH YOU KNOW IN SOME
01:17:32.547 --> 01:17:33.749
INSTANCES WILL REQUIRE A LITTLE
01:17:33.815 --> 01:17:36.618
BIT MORE EXTENSIVE REVIEW, BUT
01:17:36.685 --> 01:17:38.120
TO THAT END, YOU KNOW A GREAT
01:17:38.186 --> 01:17:39.154
BILL AND THANK YOU TO THE
01:17:39.221 --> 01:17:41.189
COMMITTEE FOR HAVING MADE IT A
01:17:41.256 --> 01:17:42.424
BETTER BILL AND WE REQUEST YOUR
01:17:42.491 --> 01:17:43.692
SUPPORT TODAY. THANK YOU VERY
01:17:43.759 --> 01:17:45.160
MUCH. ANY OTHER WITNESSES IN
01:17:45.227 --> 01:17:47.562
SUPPORT OF THE BILL? THIS IS
01:17:47.629 --> 01:17:57.572
AGAIN UH SP 12 91 ARCHULETTA.
01:17:57.639 --> 01:17:59.041
MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS, MIKE
01:17:59.107 --> 01:18:00.742
MONNING GOING TO BE UP TO
01:18:00.809 --> 01:18:01.343
CALIFORNIA STATE BUILDING AND
01:18:01.410 --> 01:18:03.011
CONSTRUCTION TRADES COUNCIL IN
01:18:03.078 --> 01:18:04.212
SUPPORT. APPRECIATE ALL THE
01:18:04.279 --> 01:18:05.380
EFFORTS THAT THE SENATOR HAS
01:18:05.447 --> 01:18:12.988
MADE IN THIS SPACE. THANK YOU.
01:18:13.055 --> 01:18:14.356
MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS. CHRIS
01:18:14.423 --> 01:18:15.290
MILLER ON BEHALF OF OVER ON
01:18:15.357 --> 01:18:17.225
FUELS WERE TWEENER RIGHT NOW,
01:18:17.292 --> 01:18:18.760
WHICH IS SUPPORTIVE, AMENDED.
01:18:18.827 --> 01:18:20.395
OBERON THINKS IT'S A GREAT BILL
01:18:20.462 --> 01:18:21.196
REALLY APPRECIATE THE
01:18:21.263 --> 01:18:21.963
LEADERSHIP, BOTH OF THE AUTHOR
01:18:22.030 --> 01:18:24.132
AND SENATOR NEWMAN AS WELL.
01:18:24.199 --> 01:18:24.800
WE'VE BEEN WORKING WITH THE
01:18:24.866 --> 01:18:26.301
OFFICER, AUTHORS OFFICE ON
01:18:26.368 --> 01:18:29.304
RESOLVING THE WE'D LIKE TO SEE A
01:18:29.371 --> 01:18:30.472
SMALL TWEAK IN THE DEFINITION OF
01:18:30.539 --> 01:18:32.274
HYDROGEN FUEL STATIONS. WE THINK
01:18:32.340 --> 01:18:33.375
WE'LL GET THERE BY THE TIME THE
01:18:33.442 --> 01:18:35.310
BILL HAS HEARD OF THE NEXT
01:18:35.377 --> 01:18:36.478
COMMITTEE AND AS SUCH, WE URGE
01:18:36.545 --> 01:18:42.584
YOUR SUPPORT OF THIS MEASURE.
01:18:42.651 --> 01:18:43.685
GOOD AFTERNOON MIX SNYDER ON
01:18:43.752 --> 01:18:44.786
BEHALF OF THEIR LIQUID IN
01:18:44.853 --> 01:18:47.956
SUPPORT. ARE THERE ANY WITNESSES
01:18:48.023 --> 01:18:52.194
IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL? OKAY
01:18:52.260 --> 01:18:53.762
SING. NONE ARE THERE ANY
01:18:53.829 --> 01:18:54.930
OPPOSITION AT ANY WITNESSES IN
01:18:54.996 --> 01:19:00.268
OPPOSITION TO THE BILL? OKAY WE
01:19:00.335 --> 01:19:02.337
DON'T SEE TOO MUCH ACTIVITY OUT
01:19:02.404 --> 01:19:04.206
THERE. OKAY COMMITTEE MEMBERS
01:19:04.272 --> 01:19:06.508
HAVE A MOTION AND A SECOND. ANY
01:19:06.575 --> 01:19:11.613
QUESTIONS? YES. REMEMBER APPEL.
01:19:11.680 --> 01:19:13.582
MADAM CHAIR. I HAVE A COMMENT
01:19:13.648 --> 01:19:15.650
SUPPORT THIS BILL GREATLY. AND
01:19:15.717 --> 01:19:18.954
ONE OF THE REASONS IS LITHIUM.
01:19:19.020 --> 01:19:20.122
THERE IS A GIANT DEMAND FOR
01:19:20.188 --> 01:19:24.092
LITHIUM. FOR THE ELECTRIC CARS
01:19:24.159 --> 01:19:26.461
ALMOST 20 BILLION TONS A YEAR.
01:19:26.528 --> 01:19:29.097
AND WE GET MOST OF OUR LITHIUM.
01:19:29.164 --> 01:19:31.633
A LARGE PERCENT FROM CHINA WHAT
01:19:31.700 --> 01:19:37.672
COULD GO WRONG? SO THE POINT I'M
01:19:37.739 --> 01:19:39.574
MAKING IS THAT I BELIEVE IN MY
01:19:39.641 --> 01:19:43.111
HEART. HYDROGEN IS THE WAVE OF
01:19:43.178 --> 01:19:45.780
THE FUTURE BECAUSE THE BATTERY
01:19:45.847 --> 01:19:49.217
STORAGE WILL SIMPLY NOT WORK.
01:19:49.284 --> 01:19:51.453
WHAT WILL HAPPEN IN MY HUMBLE
01:19:51.520 --> 01:19:52.521
OPINION? WELL, MAYBE NOT SO
01:19:52.587 --> 01:19:55.991
HUMBLE. UM WILL BE THAT BECAUSE
01:19:56.057 --> 01:19:58.727
OF THE LITHIUM SHORTAGES. THAT
01:19:58.793 --> 01:20:02.164
HYDROGEN WILL TAKE OVER AND THE
01:20:02.230 --> 01:20:04.599
LITHIUM WILL BE DIVERTED TO MOST
01:20:04.666 --> 01:20:06.134
OF OUR OTHER APPLIANCES, CARS,
01:20:06.201 --> 01:20:10.105
ETCETERA. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
01:20:10.172 --> 01:20:11.039
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S ANY OTHER
01:20:11.106 --> 01:20:13.375
COMMITTEE. COMMENTS, OKAY,
01:20:13.441 --> 01:20:17.946
SEEING NONE. UM WOULD YOU LIKE
01:20:18.013 --> 01:20:21.016
TO CLOSE? APPRECIATE MR VOCALS,
01:20:21.082 --> 01:20:23.318
COMMENTS AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK
01:20:23.385 --> 01:20:24.653
FOR AND I VOTE. OKAY, THANK YOU
01:20:24.719 --> 01:20:28.089
SO MUCH. SENATOR NEWMAN. FIRST
01:20:28.156 --> 01:20:29.424
OF ALL, THANK YOU FOR PRESENTING
01:20:29.491 --> 01:20:30.559
FOR SENATOR ARCHULETTA
01:20:30.625 --> 01:20:31.860
APPRECIATE THE SENATORS WORKED
01:20:31.927 --> 01:20:33.361
WITH THE COMMITTEE ON THIS BILL.
01:20:33.428 --> 01:20:34.930
WE NEED TO LOOK AT EVERY
01:20:34.996 --> 01:20:36.631
OPPORTUNITY AVAILABLE TO
01:20:36.698 --> 01:20:37.632
EXPERIENCE THE DEVELOPMENT OF
01:20:37.699 --> 01:20:38.967
ZERO EMISSION VEHICLES.
01:20:39.034 --> 01:20:40.202
EXPANDING THE PERMIT
01:20:40.268 --> 01:20:41.870
STREAMLINING TO HYDROGEN FUELING
01:20:41.937 --> 01:20:43.572
STATIONS WILL OBVIOUSLY HELP
01:20:43.638 --> 01:20:45.807
THAT OUT. THANKS TO SENATOR
01:20:45.874 --> 01:20:47.075
ARCHULETTA FOR WORKING WITH OUR
01:20:47.142 --> 01:20:49.044
COMMITTEE TO NARROW THE SCOPE OF
01:20:49.110 --> 01:20:50.245
THE BILL TO NON RESIDENTIAL
01:20:50.312 --> 01:20:52.113
PARCELS. AND ADD A SENSE THAT
01:20:52.180 --> 01:20:53.915
DATE. I AM PLEASED TO SUPPORT
01:20:53.982 --> 01:20:55.083
THE BILL WITH HIS COMMITTEE
01:20:55.150 --> 01:20:56.184
AMENDMENTS. THE MOTION IS DUE
01:20:56.251 --> 01:20:57.085
PASS AS AMENDED TO THE
01:20:57.152 --> 01:20:59.120
TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
01:20:59.187 --> 01:20:59.955
SECRETARY, PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
01:21:00.021 --> 01:21:01.389
AGUIAR-CURRY CURRY, I LACKEY.
01:21:01.456 --> 01:21:07.062
BLOOM. BLOOM I BOERNER HORVATH
01:21:07.128 --> 01:21:10.065
BURNER HARVARD I RAMOS RAMOS
01:21:10.131 --> 01:21:12.434
SIDE THREE OF US, ROBERT RIVAS,
01:21:12.500 --> 01:21:13.535
ROBERT RIVAS SIDE VOEPEL VOEPEL.
01:21:13.602 --> 01:21:19.007
AYE. 60. THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR.
01:21:19.074 --> 01:21:20.709
THANK YOU MEMBERS. THANK YOU
01:21:20.775 --> 01:21:23.111
VERY MUCH FOR PRESENTING. OKAY
01:21:23.178 --> 01:21:24.446
LET'S MOVE ON TO WE HAVE SENATOR
01:21:24.512 --> 01:21:29.284
QUARTO. IS HE HERE? NO. WAS
01:21:29.351 --> 01:21:30.485
HERE. JONES IS HERE. OH, HOLD
01:21:30.552 --> 01:21:39.828
ON. OTHER THAN YOU. OKAY THAT'S
01:21:39.894 --> 01:21:42.464
MY ORDER. IT IS SENATOR JONES.
01:21:42.530 --> 01:21:50.872
ITEM NUMBER SEVEN SB 12 14.
01:21:50.939 --> 01:21:52.340
WELCOME SENATOR. THANK YOU,
01:21:52.407 --> 01:21:53.541
MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS. I'LL
01:21:53.608 --> 01:21:55.310
TRY TO BE QUICK SO WE CAN GET
01:21:55.377 --> 01:21:59.814
SENATOR DURAZO UP HERE. AH WE'RE
01:21:59.881 --> 01:22:01.082
I'M GONNA BE PRESENTING SENATE
01:22:01.149 --> 01:22:02.917
BILL 12 14, WHICH STRIKES A
01:22:02.984 --> 01:22:04.619
BALANCE BETWEEN PROTECTING AND
01:22:04.686 --> 01:22:05.353
ARCHITECTS, INTELLECTUAL
01:22:05.420 --> 01:22:08.089
PROPERTY. PROPERTY RIGHTS UNDER
01:22:08.156 --> 01:22:09.090
FEDERAL COPYRIGHT LAW AND
01:22:09.157 --> 01:22:10.725
FACILITATING IMPORTANT PUBLIC
01:22:10.792 --> 01:22:12.594
PARTICIPATION IN LOCAL PLANNING
01:22:12.661 --> 01:22:14.396
DECISIONS. HIS BILL ESTABLISHES
01:22:14.462 --> 01:22:15.797
AN APPROPRIATE MODEL FOR
01:22:15.864 --> 01:22:17.098
PLANNING DEPARTMENTS TO SHARE
01:22:17.165 --> 01:22:17.932
ARCHITECTURAL DRAWINGS BASED ON
01:22:17.999 --> 01:22:19.000
THE EXISTING MODEL USED BY
01:22:19.067 --> 01:22:21.303
BUILDING DEPARTMENTS.
01:22:21.369 --> 01:22:23.672
SPECIFICALLY SENATE BILL 12 14
01:22:23.738 --> 01:22:25.240
ALLOWS ACCESS TO FULL DETAILED
01:22:25.307 --> 01:22:27.008
ARCHITECTURAL BLUEPRINTS FOR
01:22:27.075 --> 01:22:28.576
PHYSICAL INSPECTION BY ANY
01:22:28.643 --> 01:22:30.011
MEMBER OF THE PUBLIC BY COMING
01:22:30.078 --> 01:22:31.279
INTO THE PLANNING DEPARTMENT,
01:22:31.346 --> 01:22:32.480
BUT RESTRICTS COPYING THOSE
01:22:32.547 --> 01:22:34.582
COPYRIGHTED MATERIALS. UNLESS
01:22:34.649 --> 01:22:36.184
THE OWNER OF THE COPYRIGHT GIVES
01:22:36.251 --> 01:22:38.219
PERMISSION OUTSIDE OF THIS
01:22:38.286 --> 01:22:39.087
PHYSICAL INSPECTION PLANNING
01:22:39.154 --> 01:22:41.356
DEPARTMENTS WOULD BE ABLE TO
01:22:41.423 --> 01:22:42.590
DISPLAY COPYRIGHTED MATERIALS
01:22:42.657 --> 01:22:43.792
DURING PUBLIC HEARINGS AND
01:22:43.858 --> 01:22:45.060
PROVIDE DRAWINGS TO ANY MEMBER
01:22:45.126 --> 01:22:47.162
OF THEIR LEGISLATIVE BODIES. AS
01:22:47.228 --> 01:22:48.930
LONG AS THE COPYRIGHTED DRAWING
01:22:48.997 --> 01:22:50.832
IS NOT STORED ONLINE FOR PUBLIC
01:22:50.899 --> 01:22:53.134
ACCESS. THIS BILL ALSO ALLOWS
01:22:53.201 --> 01:22:54.569
PUBLIC OFFICIALS AND MEMBERS OF
01:22:54.636 --> 01:22:56.204
THE PUBLIC UNLIMITED ACCESS TO
01:22:56.271 --> 01:22:57.339
LESS DETAILED NON COPYRIGHTED
01:22:57.405 --> 01:23:00.342
DRAWINGS, KNOWN AS SITE PLANS.
01:23:00.408 --> 01:23:02.610
AND MASSING DIAGRAMS. WE BELIEVE
01:23:02.677 --> 01:23:04.079
THAT SENATE BILL 12 14 HELPS
01:23:04.145 --> 01:23:05.447
PROVIDE GUIDANCE TO LOCAL
01:23:05.513 --> 01:23:06.948
PLANNING DEPARTMENTS PROTECTS
01:23:07.015 --> 01:23:08.516
INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS OF
01:23:08.583 --> 01:23:10.352
COPYRIGHT HOLDERS AND ENSURES
01:23:10.418 --> 01:23:12.387
FULL ACCESS TO THE PUBLIC AND
01:23:12.454 --> 01:23:13.855
LOCAL PUBLIC OFFICIALS. WITH ME
01:23:13.922 --> 01:23:15.824
TODAY IS MR MIKE BELOTE ON
01:23:15.890 --> 01:23:17.025
BEHALF OF THE AMERICAN INSTITUTE
01:23:17.092 --> 01:23:19.394
OF ARCHITECTS OF CALIFORNIA.
01:23:19.461 --> 01:23:20.962
WELCOME THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR
01:23:21.029 --> 01:23:22.997
AND MEMBERS MIKE BELOW IT ON
01:23:23.064 --> 01:23:24.165
BEHALF OF THE AMERICAN INSTITUTE
01:23:24.232 --> 01:23:26.101
OF ARCHITECTS, CALIFORNIA FIRST
01:23:26.167 --> 01:23:27.569
WANT TO THANK MS MAP FROM THE
01:23:27.635 --> 01:23:28.937
COMMITTEE FOR HER ENGAGEMENT ON
01:23:29.003 --> 01:23:31.039
THIS. WE'VE WORKED REALLY HARD
01:23:31.106 --> 01:23:32.774
ON THIS BILL, AND THE ESSENCE OF
01:23:32.841 --> 01:23:34.376
IT IS, IT TAKES THE MODEL IN
01:23:34.442 --> 01:23:36.478
CURRENT LAW THAT APPLIES TO
01:23:36.544 --> 01:23:38.580
BUILDING DEPARTMENTS AND EXTENDS
01:23:38.646 --> 01:23:39.614
IT TO THE PLANNING DEPARTMENT.
01:23:39.681 --> 01:23:41.583
WE UNDERSTAND THAT THE FUNCTION
01:23:41.649 --> 01:23:42.650
OF EACH IS A LITTLE DIFFERENT,
01:23:42.717 --> 01:23:44.619
BUT THE TENSION IS THE SAME
01:23:44.686 --> 01:23:46.721
BETWEEN PUBLIC PARTICIPATION.
01:23:46.788 --> 01:23:47.756
OBVIOUSLY THE PEOPLE NEED TO
01:23:47.822 --> 01:23:50.024
KNOW WHAT'S GOING ON ON IN THE
01:23:50.091 --> 01:23:52.093
PROPERTY NEAR THEM OR NEXT TO
01:23:52.160 --> 01:23:53.628
THEM, AND THE PUBLIC OFFICIALS
01:23:53.695 --> 01:23:56.164
NEED EVERYTHING THEY CAN GET TO
01:23:56.231 --> 01:23:57.732
MAKE THE PROPER DECISION
01:23:57.799 --> 01:23:59.067
BALANCED AGAINST THE COPYRIGHT
01:23:59.134 --> 01:24:01.436
INTEREST IN FEDERAL LAW. AND SO
01:24:01.503 --> 01:24:02.937
THIS BILL, WE WORKED REAL HARD
01:24:03.004 --> 01:24:05.306
TO STRIKE THAT BALANCE MUCH LIKE
01:24:05.373 --> 01:24:06.941
THE EXISTING LAW RELATING TO
01:24:07.008 --> 01:24:09.077
BUILDING DEPARTMENTS. I CAN ASK
01:24:09.144 --> 01:24:10.178
AND ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS, AND I
01:24:10.245 --> 01:24:13.314
WOULD ASK FOR AN I VOTE. THANK
01:24:13.381 --> 01:24:14.616
YOU. UM ARE THERE ANY OTHER
01:24:14.682 --> 01:24:16.351
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT OF THE
01:24:16.418 --> 01:24:21.523
BILL? MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS,
01:24:21.589 --> 01:24:22.490
MADELINE COOPER, WITH NIELSEN
01:24:22.557 --> 01:24:24.292
MARKS MORE ON BEHALF OF THE
01:24:24.359 --> 01:24:25.326
AMERICAN COUNCIL OF ENGINEERING
01:24:25.393 --> 01:24:26.628
COMPANIES CALIFORNIA AND
01:24:26.694 --> 01:24:30.698
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
01:24:30.765 --> 01:24:31.766
ARE THERE ANY WITNESSES AND
01:24:31.833 --> 01:24:35.303
OPPOSITION TO THE BILL? SEEING
01:24:35.370 --> 01:24:36.538
NONE. ARE THERE ANY QUESTIONS OF
01:24:36.604 --> 01:24:53.388
THE COMMITTEE?
01:24:54.489 --> 01:24:56.491
OKAY UM, THANK YOU FOR
01:24:56.558 --> 01:24:59.327
PRESENTING TODAY, PLEASE CLOSE.
01:24:59.394 --> 01:25:01.596
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR I VOTE.
01:25:01.663 --> 01:25:02.931
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. GREAT THANK
01:25:02.997 --> 01:25:04.933
YOU SO MUCH. AND I WANT TO THANK
01:25:04.999 --> 01:25:06.367
YOU FOR ACKNOWLEDGING MISS MAPP
01:25:06.434 --> 01:25:07.769
WORKING ON THIS BECAUSE WE WANT
01:25:07.836 --> 01:25:09.003
TO MAKE SURE IT'S GONNA BE NICE
01:25:09.070 --> 01:25:12.207
AND SMOOTH, BUT UM THE THIS
01:25:12.273 --> 01:25:13.708
BUILD IS TO ENSURE ARCHITECTURAL
01:25:13.775 --> 01:25:15.243
WORK CONTINUE TO BE
01:25:15.310 --> 01:25:16.711
APPROPRIATELY PROTECTED UNDER
01:25:16.778 --> 01:25:19.714
FEDERAL COPYRIGHT LAW. I SUPPORT
01:25:19.781 --> 01:25:20.782
THE BILL TODAY THE MOTIONS DO
01:25:20.849 --> 01:25:21.883
PASS THROUGH THE JUDICIARY
01:25:21.950 --> 01:25:23.585
COMMITTEE SECRETARY, PLEASE CALL
01:25:23.651 --> 01:25:27.555
THE ROLL CURRY CURRY. I LACKEY
01:25:27.622 --> 01:25:30.391
BLOOM BLOOM I BOERNER HORVATH
01:25:30.458 --> 01:25:33.761
AYE RAMOS. RAMOS AYE,
01:25:33.828 --> 01:25:35.697
THREE OF US ROBERT RIVAS.
01:25:35.763 --> 01:25:41.636
ROBERT RIVAS SIDE VOEPEL. AYE. I
01:25:41.703 --> 01:25:44.539
THINK THERE ARE BUILDS OUT, 60.
01:25:44.606 --> 01:25:45.306
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THANK YOU,
01:25:45.373 --> 01:25:46.574
MADAM CHAIR. APPRECIATE YOU.
01:25:46.641 --> 01:25:48.610
YOU'RE WELCOME. I AS LET'S SEE
01:25:48.676 --> 01:25:50.211
ITEM NUMBER EIGHT. SENATOR
01:25:50.278 --> 01:25:57.285
DURAZO. AND THIS IS SB 12 26.
01:25:57.352 --> 01:26:02.524
WELCOME. THANK YOU, MADAM. CHAIR
01:26:02.590 --> 01:26:04.726
AND MEMBERS GOOD TO SEE YOU ALL.
01:26:04.792 --> 01:26:10.632
UM SB 12 12 26 IS THE BILL THAT
01:26:10.698 --> 01:26:12.066
WILL CONTRIBUTE TO THE STATE
01:26:12.133 --> 01:26:15.470
MEETING ZERO MISSION GOALS BY
01:26:15.537 --> 01:26:17.305
FACILITATING PUBLIC PRIVATE, NON
01:26:17.372 --> 01:26:18.339
PRIVATE PARTNERSHIPS THROUGH A
01:26:18.406 --> 01:26:19.307
JOINT POWERS AUTHORITY
01:26:19.374 --> 01:26:22.577
STRUCTURE. WITH THEIR MISSION
01:26:22.644 --> 01:26:24.946
BEING TO CREATE AND FINANCE
01:26:25.013 --> 01:26:27.615
GREEN PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION,
01:26:27.682 --> 01:26:29.584
INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS. WE KNOW
01:26:29.651 --> 01:26:31.085
CALIFORNIA IS A LEADER GLOBALLY
01:26:31.152 --> 01:26:32.186
TO ADDRESS THE EFFECTS OF
01:26:32.253 --> 01:26:35.957
CLIMATE CHANGE. UM AND, UH, WE
01:26:36.024 --> 01:26:38.059
KNOW THAT TRANSPORTATION BASED
01:26:38.126 --> 01:26:39.460
EMISSIONS ARE OF THE MOST
01:26:39.527 --> 01:26:40.662
SIGNIFICANT SOURCES OF
01:26:40.728 --> 01:26:45.433
CONTAMINATION. THE STATE NEEDS
01:26:45.500 --> 01:26:48.436
TO BUILD GREEN CRITICAL CRITICAL
01:26:48.503 --> 01:26:50.405
GREEN PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION
01:26:50.471 --> 01:26:52.340
INFRASTRUCTURE EVEN MORE THAN
01:26:52.407 --> 01:26:54.709
EVER. LOS ANGELES HAS CURRENTLY
01:26:54.776 --> 01:26:56.444
EXAMPLES OF PROPOSALS FOR
01:26:56.511 --> 01:26:57.512
INNOVATION THAT WOULD FIT IN
01:26:57.579 --> 01:27:00.949
HERE. THE L. A STREETCAR ON
01:27:01.015 --> 01:27:02.650
AERIAL TRAM MONORAIL PROJECT.
01:27:02.717 --> 01:27:05.820
THESE ARE ALL PROPOSALS THAT
01:27:05.887 --> 01:27:07.989
COULD CONCEIVABLY MOVE FORWARD,
01:27:08.056 --> 01:27:09.924
THE NONPROFIT AND PHILANTHROPIC
01:27:09.991 --> 01:27:11.526
SECTOR HAVE ALREADY BECOME
01:27:11.593 --> 01:27:13.061
INVOLVED IN FUNDING AND
01:27:13.127 --> 01:27:15.430
OPERATING SEVERAL PREVIOUSLY
01:27:15.496 --> 01:27:17.465
GOVERNMENT DOMINATED PUBLIC
01:27:17.532 --> 01:27:19.334
SERVICES FROM HOUSING TO SOCIAL
01:27:19.400 --> 01:27:20.902
SERVICES, BUT NOT YET. PUBLIC
01:27:20.969 --> 01:27:24.439
TRANSPORTATION. A TRUE PUBLIC
01:27:24.505 --> 01:27:26.341
PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP TO REALIZE
01:27:26.407 --> 01:27:28.376
THE ROLLOUT OF CRITICAL GREEN
01:27:28.443 --> 01:27:30.445
PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION PROJECTS
01:27:30.511 --> 01:27:32.880
CAN BE FACILITATED BY ALLOWING
01:27:32.947 --> 01:27:34.882
NON PROFITS A OLE ON JOINT
01:27:34.949 --> 01:27:37.919
POWERS. AUTHORITIES. WHILE JOINT
01:27:37.986 --> 01:27:40.188
POWER AUTHORITY LAW TYPICALLY IS
01:27:40.254 --> 01:27:42.523
USED TO AUTHORIZE TWO OR MORE
01:27:42.590 --> 01:27:43.992
PUBLIC AGENCIES THROUGH A
01:27:44.058 --> 01:27:45.860
CONTRACTUAL AGREEMENT TO JOINTLY
01:27:45.927 --> 01:27:47.795
EXERCISE COMMON POWERS.
01:27:47.862 --> 01:27:50.164
LEGISLATION HAS EXPANDED THE
01:27:50.231 --> 01:27:52.400
ABILITY FOR PRIVATE PARTIES TO
01:27:52.467 --> 01:27:54.836
BECOME A PART OF SUCH AGREEMENTS
01:27:54.902 --> 01:27:56.337
AS IT HAS BEEN DONE FOR
01:27:56.404 --> 01:27:57.572
HOSPITALS AND HOMELESS SERVICES
01:27:57.639 --> 01:28:00.842
. 12 26 ADOPTS A SIMILAR MODEL.
01:28:00.908 --> 01:28:02.276
TO PROMOTE PUBLIC PRIVATE BUILD
01:28:02.343 --> 01:28:05.446
OUT OF GREEN TRANSPORTATION.
01:28:05.513 --> 01:28:07.615
THROUGH ENCOURAGING AND ALLOWING
01:28:07.682 --> 01:28:09.951
SUCH PARTNERSHIPS TO TAKE PLACE.
01:28:10.018 --> 01:28:12.920
12 26 WILL CONTRIBUTE TO MEETING
01:28:12.987 --> 01:28:13.955
THE STATE'S EMISSIONS REDUCTIONS
01:28:14.022 --> 01:28:16.958
GOALS AND HELP MAKE PUBLIC
01:28:17.025 --> 01:28:19.427
TRANSPORTATION MORE ACCESSIBLE
01:28:19.494 --> 01:28:20.595
WITH ME. IS MARCUS TWICE
01:28:20.662 --> 01:28:25.600
TWILIGHT. YEAH FROM THE
01:28:25.667 --> 01:28:26.434
CALIFORNIA SPECIAL DISTRICT
01:28:26.501 --> 01:28:27.468
ASSOCIATION TO TESTIFY AND
01:28:27.535 --> 01:28:31.706
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. GOOD
01:28:31.773 --> 01:28:33.241
AFTERNOON, MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS.
01:28:33.307 --> 01:28:35.343
I'LL BE BRIEF MARCUS DETWEILER
01:28:35.410 --> 01:28:36.210
WITH THE CALIFORNIA SPECIAL
01:28:36.277 --> 01:28:38.346
DISTRICTS ASSOCIATION. CSD
01:28:38.413 --> 01:28:39.914
REPRESENTS ALL TYPES OF SPECIAL
01:28:39.981 --> 01:28:40.748
DISTRICT THROUGHOUT THE STATE.
01:28:40.815 --> 01:28:43.217
UH THOSE PROVIDERS OF FIRE
01:28:43.284 --> 01:28:44.452
PROTECTION, LIBRARY SERVICES,
01:28:44.519 --> 01:28:47.321
WATER WASTEWATER, ETCETERA. AH
01:28:47.388 --> 01:28:49.691
AS THE SENATOR PREVIOUSLY STATED
01:28:49.757 --> 01:28:52.460
SB 12 26 TAKES AN INCREMENTAL
01:28:52.527 --> 01:28:54.228
STEP FORWARD BY ALLOWING SPECIAL
01:28:54.295 --> 01:28:55.997
DISTRICTS AS WELL AS OTHER LOCAL
01:28:56.064 --> 01:28:57.198
PUBLIC ENTITIES TO PARTNER WITH
01:28:57.265 --> 01:29:01.469
PRIVATE. FIVE OH, ONE C THREES
01:29:01.536 --> 01:29:02.570
FOR THE PURPOSE OF DEVELOPING
01:29:02.637 --> 01:29:05.606
DEPLOYING AND OPERATING. SUCH
01:29:05.673 --> 01:29:06.474
INFRASTRUCTURE THAT WOULD HELP
01:29:06.541 --> 01:29:07.909
ALLOW THE STATE REACH ITS
01:29:07.975 --> 01:29:10.111
CLIMATE CHANGE GOALS AND HELP
01:29:10.178 --> 01:29:11.045
DEPLOY CLIMATE ADAPTATION
01:29:11.112 --> 01:29:13.781
PROJECTS. CSD A IS VERY THANKFUL
01:29:13.848 --> 01:29:15.483
TO THE SENATOR FOR BRINGING THIS
01:29:15.550 --> 01:29:16.751
MEASURE FORWARD AND THANKFUL FOR
01:29:16.818 --> 01:29:17.218
THE COMMITTEE FOR ITS
01:29:17.285 --> 01:29:19.587
CONSIDERATION HERE TODAY, AND WE
01:29:19.654 --> 01:29:20.588
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR I
01:29:20.655 --> 01:29:21.622
VOTE. THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY
01:29:21.689 --> 01:29:23.357
MUCH OTHER OTHER WITNESSES IN
01:29:23.424 --> 01:29:27.695
SUPPORT. MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS
01:29:27.762 --> 01:29:29.363
ALEX TORRES WITH THE BAYAREA
01:29:29.430 --> 01:29:34.102
COUNCIL AND SUPPORT THANK YOU.
01:29:34.168 --> 01:29:35.770
GOOD AFTERNOON, MADAM CHAIR AND
01:29:35.837 --> 01:29:37.038
MEMBERS CON HOLLY BEHALF THE
01:29:37.105 --> 01:29:38.372
CITY OF LONG BEACH AND SUPPORT.
01:29:38.439 --> 01:29:40.942
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. ARE THERE
01:29:41.008 --> 01:29:42.610
ANY OTHER WITNESSES AND SUPPORT
01:29:42.677 --> 01:29:43.911
SEEING NONE ANY WITNESSES IN
01:29:43.978 --> 01:29:47.048
OPPOSITION? SEEING NONE. ARE
01:29:47.115 --> 01:29:48.716
THERE ANY QUESTIONS OF THE
01:29:48.783 --> 01:29:52.153
COMMITTEE? NO, I WOULD SAY,
01:29:52.220 --> 01:29:57.358
SAYING NO. UM THERE WAS A MOTION
01:29:57.425 --> 01:29:58.626
ALREADY BY US. SOME REMEMBER
01:29:58.693 --> 01:30:00.361
RAMOS AND SECONDED BY
01:30:00.428 --> 01:30:01.896
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BOOK BORN OR
01:30:01.963 --> 01:30:06.968
HARVARD? BERNARD? JESUS, PLEASE.
01:30:07.034 --> 01:30:08.770
MAYBE I NEED, YOU KNOW, NEVER
01:30:08.836 --> 01:30:10.705
MIND. WE WON'T GO THERE ANYWAY.
01:30:10.772 --> 01:30:11.672
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE? I
01:30:11.739 --> 01:30:13.341
RESPECTFULLY ASK ABOUT THANK YOU
01:30:13.407 --> 01:30:17.345
VERY MUCH. OKAY, UM. SENATOR
01:30:17.411 --> 01:30:19.714
ROSE. I SUPPORT YOUR BILL. UM
01:30:19.781 --> 01:30:21.048
YOUR WORK TO FACILITATE
01:30:21.115 --> 01:30:22.483
AGREEMENTS BETWEEN NONPROFITS
01:30:22.550 --> 01:30:24.085
AND GOVERNMENT AGENCIES THAT
01:30:24.152 --> 01:30:25.286
WILL HELP BUILD OUT OUR STATES.
01:30:25.353 --> 01:30:26.854
ZERO EMISSION. TRANSPORTATION
01:30:26.921 --> 01:30:30.091
INFRASTRUCTURE IS GREAT. I WILL
01:30:30.158 --> 01:30:32.126
BE VOTING I TODAY AND THE
01:30:32.193 --> 01:30:32.827
MOTIONS DO PASS TO THE
01:30:32.894 --> 01:30:33.628
TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
01:30:33.694 --> 01:30:35.129
SECRETARY. PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
01:30:35.196 --> 01:30:39.801
CURRY CURRY. I LACKEY BLOOM. I
01:30:39.867 --> 01:30:43.037
BOERNER HORVATH MARVET I RAMOS
01:30:43.104 --> 01:30:44.872
RAMOS. I THREE OF US ROBERT
01:30:44.939 --> 01:30:47.074
REVIS ROBERT RIVAS SIDE VOEPEL
01:30:47.141 --> 01:30:52.680
NÓ. BILLS OUT 51. THANK YOU,
01:30:52.747 --> 01:30:57.318
COLLEAGUES. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
01:30:57.385 --> 01:31:03.991
LOOKS LIKE AH, YES. MS KAMLAGER
01:31:04.058 --> 01:31:07.562
ITEM NUMBER 10 SP 13 73.
01:31:07.628 --> 01:31:11.999
WELCOME. THANK YOU VERY MUCH,
01:31:12.066 --> 01:31:14.969
MADAM CHAIR. GOOD AFTERNOON. TO
01:31:15.036 --> 01:31:19.707
YOU AND MEMBERS OVER THE BELT.
01:31:19.774 --> 01:31:21.108
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. OKAY
01:31:21.175 --> 01:31:24.178
THAT'S IT. NO MORE, UM, HERE
01:31:24.245 --> 01:31:28.082
TODAY TO PRESENT SB 13 73. I AM
01:31:28.149 --> 01:31:29.650
ACCEPTING THE COMMITTEE
01:31:29.717 --> 01:31:30.852
AMENDMENTS. SO I'M ACCEPTING THE
01:31:30.918 --> 01:31:34.589
COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS. 13 73 IS A
01:31:34.655 --> 01:31:36.057
DISTRICT BILL THAT GIVES AN
01:31:36.123 --> 01:31:36.924
ADDITIONAL TWO YEARS TWO
01:31:36.991 --> 01:31:38.993
REMAINING PROPERTY OWNED BY A
01:31:39.060 --> 01:31:41.495
FORMER REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY TO
01:31:41.562 --> 01:31:42.263
DEVELOP LARGE SCALE PROJECTS IN
01:31:42.330 --> 01:31:45.466
URBAN AND UNDER RESOURCED AREAS.
01:31:45.533 --> 01:31:47.034
GIVEN THE CHALLENGES CREATED BY
01:31:47.101 --> 01:31:49.003
THE COVID 19 PANDEMIC, LOCAL
01:31:49.070 --> 01:31:50.504
AGENCIES DEALT WITH STAFFING
01:31:50.571 --> 01:31:52.707
SHORTAGES AND EMERGENCY RESPONSE
01:31:52.773 --> 01:31:54.275
INITIATIVES THAT MADE IT
01:31:54.342 --> 01:31:55.843
DIFFICULT TO MOVE NON PANDEMIC
01:31:55.910 --> 01:31:59.213
RELATED ISSUES TO RESOLUTION.
01:31:59.280 --> 01:32:01.983
THE ADDITIONAL TIME IS REQUIRED
01:32:02.049 --> 01:32:03.584
TO ENSURE THAT THE PUBLICLY
01:32:03.651 --> 01:32:06.120
OWNED PROPERTY PROVIDES PUBLIC
01:32:06.187 --> 01:32:07.521
BENEFITS ALONG WITH THE HIGHEST
01:32:07.588 --> 01:32:09.690
AND BEST USE FOR THE COMMUNITY.
01:32:09.757 --> 01:32:10.758
SO CURRENTLY ACCORDING TO THE
01:32:10.825 --> 01:32:13.094
SURPLUS LANDS ACT THE PROJECTS
01:32:13.160 --> 01:32:16.163
OUTLINED AND SB 13 73 ARE
01:32:16.230 --> 01:32:19.133
REQUIRED TO HAVE ALL OUTSTANDING
01:32:19.200 --> 01:32:21.135
ISSUES RESOLVED BY AUGUST. 1
01:32:21.202 --> 01:32:23.437
2022 IN ORDER TO BE FULLY
01:32:23.504 --> 01:32:24.839
DISPOSED OF BY DECEMBER, 31.
01:32:24.906 --> 01:32:29.510
2022. GIVEN THE UNFORESEEN
01:32:29.577 --> 01:32:31.112
CHALLENGES RAISED BY THE
01:32:31.178 --> 01:32:33.447
PANDEMIC, SENATE BILL 13 73
01:32:33.514 --> 01:32:35.516
WOULD EXTEND THE DATE BY WHICH
01:32:35.583 --> 01:32:36.083
THE DISPOSITION OF PROPERTY
01:32:36.150 --> 01:32:37.318
OWNED BY A FORMER REDEVELOPMENT
01:32:37.385 --> 01:32:40.922
AGENCY. TO BE COMPLETED BY
01:32:40.988 --> 01:32:43.658
DECEMBER. 31 2020 FOR THE
01:32:43.724 --> 01:32:45.493
EXTENSION WOULD ONLY APPLY TO
01:32:45.559 --> 01:32:46.961
PROPERTIES THAT ARE LOCATED IN A
01:32:47.028 --> 01:32:48.829
LOCAL AGENCY WITH A POPULATION
01:32:48.896 --> 01:32:51.465
OF OVER TWO MILLION PEOPLE. IN
01:32:51.532 --> 01:32:53.534
ADDITION, THE LOCAL AGENCY HAS
01:32:53.601 --> 01:32:55.236
EITHER AN OPTION AGREEMENT DULY
01:32:55.303 --> 01:32:57.004
AUTHORIZED BY THE LOCAL AGENCIES
01:32:57.071 --> 01:32:58.940
GOVERNING BODY TO PURCHASE THE
01:32:59.006 --> 01:33:00.007
PROPERTY FROM THE FORMER
01:33:00.074 --> 01:33:00.908
REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY OR AN
01:33:00.975 --> 01:33:04.011
EXCLUSIVE NEGOTIATION AGREEMENT.
01:33:04.078 --> 01:33:06.013
WITH A PRIVATE ENTITY TO DEVELOP
01:33:06.080 --> 01:33:07.615
THE SUBJECT PROPERTY FOR
01:33:07.682 --> 01:33:09.050
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT OR HOUSING
01:33:09.116 --> 01:33:11.252
PURPOSES. SO WITH ME AND SUPPORT
01:33:11.319 --> 01:33:13.054
TODAY IS SYLVIA SOLELY SHAW,
01:33:13.120 --> 01:33:14.789
REPRESENTING THE CITY OF LOS
01:33:14.855 --> 01:33:16.123
ANGELES, AND AT THE APPROPRIATE
01:33:16.190 --> 01:33:17.258
TIME, I WOULD RESPECTFULLY ASK
01:33:17.325 --> 01:33:19.393
FOR YOUR VOTE. THANK YOU.
01:33:19.460 --> 01:33:21.896
WELCOME THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR
01:33:21.963 --> 01:33:23.531
AND MEMBERS SYLVIA'S ALICIA HERE
01:33:23.597 --> 01:33:25.533
ON BEHALF OF THE CITY OF LOS
01:33:25.599 --> 01:33:26.901
ANGELES. AND WHILE THE CITY HAS
01:33:26.968 --> 01:33:28.469
MADE SIGNIFICANT STRIDES TO
01:33:28.536 --> 01:33:29.537
PURSUE DEVELOPMENT ON EACH OF
01:33:29.603 --> 01:33:32.006
THESE SITES, AS SENATOR KAMLAGER
01:33:32.073 --> 01:33:34.408
MENTIONED THE COVID 19 PANDEMIC
01:33:34.475 --> 01:33:35.977
RELATED ECONOMIC DOWNTURN AND
01:33:36.043 --> 01:33:37.345
OTHER FACTORS HAVE CONTRIBUTED
01:33:37.411 --> 01:33:38.946
TO DELAYS IN ADVANCING THESE
01:33:39.013 --> 01:33:42.383
TRANSACTIONS. SP 13 73 WOULD
01:33:42.450 --> 01:33:43.951
SIMPLY EXTEND THE DATE BY TWO
01:33:44.018 --> 01:33:45.953
YEARS FOR THE DISPOSITION OF
01:33:46.020 --> 01:33:48.389
PROPERTY OWNED BY THE SUCCESSOR
01:33:48.456 --> 01:33:50.458
AGENCY IN LOS ANGELES, UH, TO
01:33:50.524 --> 01:33:52.026
EMPHASIZE THAT DOES NOT REMOVE
01:33:52.093 --> 01:33:53.561
ANY OF THE EXISTING PROVISIONS
01:33:53.627 --> 01:33:55.096
OF THE SURPLUS LAND ACT THAT
01:33:55.162 --> 01:33:57.031
APPLIES TO THESE PROPERTIES.
01:33:57.098 --> 01:33:58.199
EACH OF THESE PROPERTIES HAS OR
01:33:58.265 --> 01:34:02.003
WILL BE. UM MEET THE PROCEDURAL
01:34:02.069 --> 01:34:03.504
PROVISIONS OF THE BILL, AS WELL
01:34:03.571 --> 01:34:05.006
AS BE REVIEWED BY THE STATE'S
01:34:05.072 --> 01:34:06.240
DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING AND
01:34:06.307 --> 01:34:07.675
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT, AND THE
01:34:07.742 --> 01:34:08.909
BILL SIMPLY JUST PROVIDES THIS
01:34:08.976 --> 01:34:11.612
EXTENSION OF TIME. THESE
01:34:11.679 --> 01:34:14.015
PROJECTS POTENTIALLY COULD LEAD
01:34:14.081 --> 01:34:16.684
IN A COMBINATION TO OVER 8000
01:34:16.751 --> 01:34:18.185
JOBS BEING CREATED IN THE CITY
01:34:18.252 --> 01:34:19.754
OF LOS ANGELES. AND WE ASK FOR
01:34:19.820 --> 01:34:20.921
YOUR SUPPORT. THANK YOU. THANK
01:34:20.988 --> 01:34:22.023
YOU VERY MUCH. ARE THERE ANY
01:34:22.089 --> 01:34:23.791
OTHER WITNESSES IN SUPPORT OF
01:34:23.858 --> 01:34:29.330
THE BILL? I'M CHAIR MEMBERS,
01:34:29.397 --> 01:34:31.699
MIKE MONEGAN ON BEHALF OF THE
01:34:31.766 --> 01:34:32.733
CALIFORNIA STATE BUILDING AND
01:34:32.800 --> 01:34:33.367
CONSTRUCTION TRADES COUNCIL IN
01:34:33.434 --> 01:34:38.005
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. ANY OTHER
01:34:38.072 --> 01:34:40.141
WITNESSES AND SUPPORT, SAYING
01:34:40.207 --> 01:34:41.308
NONE. ARE THERE ANY WITNESSES IN
01:34:41.375 --> 01:34:45.813
OPPOSITION? SEEING NONE. ARE
01:34:45.880 --> 01:34:47.515
THERE ANY QUESTIONS OF THE
01:34:47.581 --> 01:34:51.052
COMMITTEE? YES SOMEONE MEMBER OF
01:34:51.118 --> 01:34:52.987
OPAL COMMENT. UM, I SUPPORT THIS
01:34:53.054 --> 01:34:55.623
BILL. WHY NOT? MAKE IT
01:34:55.689 --> 01:34:59.193
CALIFORNIA WIDE. WHY JUST LOS
01:34:59.260 --> 01:35:04.999
ANGELES. THAT HAS BEEN A
01:35:05.066 --> 01:35:06.534
QUESTION. ASKED BY MANY SENATORS
01:35:06.600 --> 01:35:09.003
AND ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S, UM AND SO
01:35:09.070 --> 01:35:11.005
THIS IS SPECIFIC TO THE DISTRICT
01:35:11.072 --> 01:35:13.140
. THERE ARE 10 PROPERTIES THAT
01:35:13.207 --> 01:35:14.375
NEEDED TO BE DISPOSED OF. THESE
01:35:14.442 --> 01:35:17.645
ARE THE REMAINING THREE PARCELS
01:35:17.711 --> 01:35:19.146
WITHIN THE CITY OF LOS ANGELES
01:35:19.213 --> 01:35:20.815
WOULD CERTAINLY BE HAPPY TO
01:35:20.881 --> 01:35:21.715
SUPPORT SOMEONE ELSE'S BILL THAT
01:35:21.782 --> 01:35:23.584
WOULD MAKE IT STATEWIDE. THANK
01:35:23.651 --> 01:35:28.522
YOU. ANY OTHER QUESTIONS. OKAY
01:35:28.589 --> 01:35:30.658
SEEING NONE. UM WE HAVE A MOTION
01:35:30.724 --> 01:35:32.560
BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S RAMOS A
01:35:32.626 --> 01:35:35.963
SECOND BY, UH, BOERNER HORVATH.
01:35:36.030 --> 01:35:40.935
AH! I KNOW, BUT I WORK HARD AT
01:35:41.001 --> 01:35:42.570
THIS RIGHT? WOULD YOU LIKE TO
01:35:42.636 --> 01:35:45.005
CLOSE? I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
01:35:45.072 --> 01:35:49.076
YOUR I VOTE. THANK YOU SO MUCH.
01:35:49.143 --> 01:35:51.145
UM THIS IS A GREAT BILL, AND I'M
01:35:51.212 --> 01:35:52.480
GLAD THAT YOU'RE TAKING CARE OF.
01:35:52.546 --> 01:35:54.181
IT HELPS PRESERVE THE PRIORITY
01:35:54.248 --> 01:35:56.083
PROJECTS IN YOUR DISTRICT. THANK
01:35:56.150 --> 01:35:57.051
YOU FOR WORKING WITH US ON THE
01:35:57.118 --> 01:35:58.085
TECHNICAL AMENDMENTS WITH THE
01:35:58.152 --> 01:35:59.120
COMMUNITY TO CLARIFY THE
01:35:59.186 --> 01:36:01.455
LANGUAGE. PLACE TO SUPPORT YOUR
01:36:01.522 --> 01:36:02.990
BILL TODAY. WITH THE COMMITTEE
01:36:03.057 --> 01:36:04.892
AMENDMENTS. THE MOTION IS DUE
01:36:04.959 --> 01:36:07.528
PASS AS AMENDED TO THE HOUSE, UH
01:36:07.595 --> 01:36:08.395
, HOUSING AND COMMUNITY
01:36:08.462 --> 01:36:09.897
DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE SECRETARY
01:36:09.964 --> 01:36:11.332
. PLEASE CALL THE ROLL CURRY
01:36:11.398 --> 01:36:16.370
CURRY. I LACKEY BLOOM. BLOOM I
01:36:16.437 --> 01:36:18.205
BERNARD BACK BOERNER HORVATH?
01:36:18.272 --> 01:36:19.507
AYE RAMOS RAMOS SALAS RIVERS,
01:36:19.573 --> 01:36:23.177
ROBERT RIVAS. ROBERT RIVAS,
01:36:23.244 --> 01:36:26.847
SYBIL PAL, I SUCCEED. BUILDS OUT
01:36:26.914 --> 01:36:27.948
60. THANK YOU VERY MUCH,
01:36:28.015 --> 01:36:40.528
SENATOR.
01:36:40.594 --> 01:36:42.796
OKAY WE HAVE A COUPLE OF CLEAN
01:36:42.863 --> 01:36:43.864
UP THINGS THAT WE COULD DO RIGHT
01:36:43.931 --> 01:36:48.869
NOW. UM. LET'S SEE. WE HAVE ITEM
01:36:48.936 --> 01:36:53.641
NUMBER I AM NUMBER ONE SB 3 61.
01:36:53.707 --> 01:36:59.246
WE NEED A MOTION. I BELIEVE THAT
01:36:59.313 --> 01:37:00.414
SOME OF THEM ARE RAMOS AND
01:37:00.481 --> 01:37:06.487
BLOOM. OKAY? SECRETARY
01:37:06.554 --> 01:37:07.388
AGUIAR-CURRY. AYE CURRY. I
01:37:07.454 --> 01:37:09.523
LACKEY BLOOM. BLOOM. I
01:37:09.590 --> 01:37:15.129
BOERNER HORVATH RAMOS. RAMOS A
01:37:15.196 --> 01:37:17.298
THREE OF US ROBERT RIVAS
01:37:17.364 --> 01:37:19.266
ROBERT RIVAS. AYE VOEPEL I, IT'S
01:37:19.333 --> 01:37:28.175
FINE. WE'RE GETTING ONE ELSE.
01:37:28.242 --> 01:37:37.651
THE MOST. ANNOUNCE. OH, THAT
01:37:37.718 --> 01:37:39.753
BILL WAS DO PASS AS AMENDED TO
01:37:39.820 --> 01:37:40.554
THE HOUSING AND COMMUNITY
01:37:40.621 --> 01:37:42.623
DEVELOPMENT. RIGHT? AND THE VOTE
01:37:42.690 --> 01:37:47.394
WAS 50. APOLOGIZE. OKAY, WE HAVE
01:37:47.461 --> 01:37:53.133
ITEM NUMBER TWO. SB 3 79. THIS
01:37:53.200 --> 01:37:54.368
IS DO PASS AS AMENDED TO
01:37:54.435 --> 01:37:57.271
UTILITIES AND ENERGY. WE NEED A
01:37:57.338 --> 01:38:03.077
MOTION. UM REMEMBER BLOOM AND
01:38:03.143 --> 01:38:06.513
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S RAMOS
01:38:06.580 --> 01:38:09.016
AGUIAR-CURRY AYE CURRY. I LACKEY
01:38:09.083 --> 01:38:10.918
BLOOM. BLUE EYED
01:38:10.985 --> 01:38:15.356
BOERNER HORVATH. BRAVO'S MOST
01:38:15.422 --> 01:38:16.390
SIDE, LOOSE RIVERS, ROBERT
01:38:16.457 --> 01:38:20.227
RIVAS. ROBERT RIVAS SIDE VOEPEL.
01:38:20.294 --> 01:38:29.169
CORRECT. PROPEL. NO, THAT'S 40.
01:38:29.236 --> 01:38:34.241
FOR ONE. I'M SORRY. OKAY, WE'LL
01:38:34.308 --> 01:38:36.477
KEEP THE ROLE OPEN FOR THAT ONE.
01:38:36.543 --> 01:38:43.017
OKAY? ALRIGHT WE HAVE ITEM
01:38:43.083 --> 01:38:46.320
NUMBER THREE SB 8 50 TO DO PASS
01:38:46.387 --> 01:38:48.555
TO NATURAL RESOURCES. WE NEED A
01:38:48.622 --> 01:38:56.030
MOTION. SOME REMEMBER RAMOS,
01:38:56.096 --> 01:38:59.233
SECOND BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BLOOM
01:38:59.300 --> 01:39:01.302
. AGUIAR-CURRY CURRY, I LUCKY
01:39:01.368 --> 01:39:09.677
BLOOM. BLOOM. I BOERNER HORVATH. RAMOS RAMOS. I THREE OF US
01:39:09.743 --> 01:39:12.413
ROBERT RIVAS RIVAS SIDE VOEPEL.
01:39:12.479 --> 01:39:19.687
VOEPEL NO 40. OKAY. WE WILL COME
01:39:19.753 --> 01:39:20.954
BACK TO THAT WHEN WE GET MORE OF
01:39:21.021 --> 01:39:34.168
THE MEMBERS HERE. PRINT.
01:39:34.234 --> 01:39:37.571
SERGEANT. SERGEANT, CAN WE CALL?
01:39:37.638 --> 01:39:41.241
UM SENATOR STERN. AND SENATOR
01:39:41.308 --> 01:39:57.558
CORTEZ, PLEASE.
01:40:17.578 --> 01:40:21.382
BOERNER HORVATH UP FOR ABOUT.
01:40:21.448 --> 01:40:38.665
BOERNER HORVATH.
01:40:38.732 --> 01:40:49.209
RESPONSE. OH, SURE. OKAY. WE'RE
01:40:49.276 --> 01:40:54.081
GOING TO OPEN THE. NO WE'RE
01:40:54.148 --> 01:40:58.485
GOING TO OPEN THE ROLE AND ON SB
01:40:58.552 --> 01:41:04.024
379 THAT IS WIENER. UM. D<c.cyan> PASS</c>
01:41:04.091 --> 01:41:04.958
AS AMENDED TO UTILITIES AND
01:41:05.025 --> 01:41:08.796
ENERGY HARDBACK BOERNER HORVATH.
01:41:08.862 --> 01:41:15.502
OKAY, THAT BUILDS UP 51. THEN WE
01:41:15.569 --> 01:41:19.039
HAVE SP 8 52 DODD D<c.cyan>PASSED A</c>
01:41:19.106 --> 01:41:20.441
NATURAL RESOURCES
01:41:20.507 --> 01:41:23.844
BOERNER HORVATH. AND THAT BUILDS
01:41:23.911 --> 01:41:33.153
OUT 51. WHEN WE HAVE AN ADD ON
01:41:33.220 --> 01:41:35.589
FOR YOU, IF YOU'D LIKE ON, UH SP
01:41:35.656 --> 01:41:39.226
3 61 NUMBER BUT THE HARVARD I,
01:41:39.293 --> 01:41:41.295
THAT'S 60. THAT ONE THAT BUILDS
01:41:41.361 --> 01:42:01.181
OUT 60. WAS ALREADY.
01:44:13.013 --> 01:44:15.215
OKAY THIS IS ITEM NUMBER SIX. SB
01:44:15.282 --> 01:44:17.084
1100 BY SENATOR COURT HAZY
01:44:17.150 --> 01:44:20.687
WELCOME, SIR. THANK YOU. UM,
01:44:20.754 --> 01:44:22.556
THANK YOU VERY MUCH, MADAM
01:44:22.623 --> 01:44:24.958
CHAIR. ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S AND I'M
01:44:25.025 --> 01:44:30.530
PLEASED TO PRESENT SP 1100. TO
01:44:30.597 --> 01:44:32.099
ENSURE ACCESSIBLE, SAFE AND
01:44:32.165 --> 01:44:33.467
DEMOCRATIC PUBLIC MEETINGS
01:44:33.533 --> 01:44:35.068
ACROSS CALIFORNIA PUBLIC
01:44:35.135 --> 01:44:36.136
OFFICIALS AND PUBLIC ATTENDEES
01:44:36.203 --> 01:44:39.640
ACROSS THE STATE. CONTINUE TO
01:44:39.706 --> 01:44:40.207
DEAL WITH DISORDERLY CONDUCT
01:44:40.273 --> 01:44:42.576
DURING MEETINGS AT SUCH A HIGH
01:44:42.643 --> 01:44:43.377
MAGNITUDE THAT CRITICAL BUSINESS
01:44:43.443 --> 01:44:45.178
IN THE LEGISLATIVE PROCESS AS A
01:44:45.245 --> 01:44:46.713
WHOLE. HAS OFTEN TIMES BECOME
01:44:46.780 --> 01:44:50.317
IMPAIRED. I'M GOING TO SHARE
01:44:50.384 --> 01:44:51.918
ONLY A FEW RECENT EXAMPLES THAT
01:44:51.985 --> 01:44:54.521
SPEAK TO THE NEED FOR SP 1100.
01:44:54.588 --> 01:44:55.789
I'M SURE YOU'VE HEARD OF SIMILAR
01:44:55.856 --> 01:44:56.890
INSTANCES IN YOUR OWN ASSEMBLY
01:44:56.957 --> 01:44:59.693
DISTRICTS. IN 2021 LAS CARTAS
01:44:59.760 --> 01:45:02.829
MAYOR MARIKO SOK AND HER FAMILY
01:45:02.896 --> 01:45:04.231
AS WELL AS OTHER MEMBERS OF THE
01:45:04.297 --> 01:45:05.532
CITY COUNCIL FACE DISRUPTIVE
01:45:05.599 --> 01:45:06.867
ACTIONS TARGETED BULLYING
01:45:06.933 --> 01:45:09.936
HARASSMENT EFFORTS. AT PUBLIC
01:45:10.003 --> 01:45:11.438
MEETINGS FOR CITY COUNCIL
01:45:11.505 --> 01:45:13.140
MEETINGS, INCLUDING ANTI LGBTQ
01:45:13.206 --> 01:45:16.443
IN ANTI ÁP. AYE, RHETORIC. THIS
01:45:16.510 --> 01:45:18.679
YEAR AND LAST THE POTENTIAL YOUR
01:45:18.745 --> 01:45:20.681
BELINDA UNIFIED SCHOOL BOARD HAD
01:45:20.747 --> 01:45:21.314
TO END MULTIPLE MEETINGS EARLY
01:45:21.381 --> 01:45:23.917
DUE TO MEETING DISRUPTIONS.
01:45:23.984 --> 01:45:25.719
RECENT SAN DIEGO BOARD OF
01:45:25.786 --> 01:45:26.953
SUPERVISORS MEETINGS HAVE ALSO
01:45:27.020 --> 01:45:27.988
MADE NATIONAL HEADLINES IN PART
01:45:28.055 --> 01:45:30.090
DUE TO RACIST COMMENTS AS WELL
01:45:30.157 --> 01:45:31.191
AS THREATS OF VIOLENCE AND
01:45:31.258 --> 01:45:33.460
PERSONAL ATTACKS. WE'VE HEARD
01:45:33.527 --> 01:45:34.428
FROM MANY LOCAL GOVERNMENTS AND
01:45:34.494 --> 01:45:35.929
PUBLIC OFFICIALS AS WELL AS
01:45:35.996 --> 01:45:37.164
COMMUNITY MEMBERS, THE NEED FOR
01:45:37.230 --> 01:45:39.533
CLARITY ON WHAT AUTHORITY A
01:45:39.599 --> 01:45:41.368
LEGISLATIVE BODY CAN EXERCISE IN
01:45:41.435 --> 01:45:42.836
REGARD TO REMOVING AN INDIVIDUAL
01:45:42.903 --> 01:45:43.770
WHO'S DISRUPTING A PUBLIC
01:45:43.837 --> 01:45:44.971
MEETING. DUE IN PART TO THE WIDE
01:45:45.038 --> 01:45:47.107
RANGING AH, OPINIONS AND
01:45:47.174 --> 01:45:50.177
INTERPRETATIONS OF COUNTY
01:45:50.243 --> 01:45:51.244
COUNCILS AND CITY ATTORNEYS
01:45:51.311 --> 01:45:54.047
ACROSS THE STATE. IT'S BECOME
01:45:54.114 --> 01:45:55.082
INCREASINGLY CLEAR THAT THE
01:45:55.148 --> 01:45:56.983
MECHANISMS PROVIDED BY THE BROWN
01:45:57.050 --> 01:45:57.918
ACT TO DEAL WITH DISRUPTIONS
01:45:57.984 --> 01:45:59.419
DURING BROWN ACTED PUBLIC
01:45:59.486 --> 01:46:03.056
MEETINGS. ARE INSUFFICIENT. SO
01:46:03.123 --> 01:46:05.325
IT'S THE BELIEF IN THE STATEMENT
01:46:05.392 --> 01:46:07.360
OF THIS BILL THAT WE MUST SET A
01:46:07.427 --> 01:46:08.829
BARE MINIMUM BY ESTABLISHING
01:46:08.895 --> 01:46:10.397
COMMON SENSE MECHANISMS TO
01:46:10.464 --> 01:46:11.832
DEESCALATE SIGNIFICANT
01:46:11.898 --> 01:46:13.033
DISRUPTIONS, MEMBERS OF THE
01:46:13.100 --> 01:46:15.001
LEGISLATIVE BODY TO RETURN TO
01:46:15.068 --> 01:46:15.569
THEIR IMPORTANT GOVERNMENTAL
01:46:15.635 --> 01:46:17.504
BUSINESS. IN A SWIFT MANNER. SB
01:46:17.571 --> 01:46:18.839
1100 WOULD ENHANCE PUBLIC ACCESS
01:46:18.905 --> 01:46:22.476
TO MEETINGS. I'LL NOTE THAT WE
01:46:22.542 --> 01:46:24.811
WORK CLOSELY WITH THE BLUE.
01:46:24.878 --> 01:46:27.047
OTHER FIRST AMENDMENT ADVOCATES
01:46:27.114 --> 01:46:29.382
MANY ATTORNEYS TO ENSURE
01:46:29.449 --> 01:46:30.817
LANGUAGE IN THIS BILL WOULD BE
01:46:30.884 --> 01:46:32.219
IMPLEMENTED CONSISTENT WITH
01:46:32.285 --> 01:46:33.754
FIRST AMENDMENT PRINCIPLES AND
01:46:33.820 --> 01:46:35.722
EXPRESSLY STATED OUR INTENT TO
01:46:35.789 --> 01:46:36.957
PROTECT CIVIL LIBERTIES AND OUR
01:46:37.023 --> 01:46:39.226
DEMOCRATIC PROCESS. AND NOT TO
01:46:39.292 --> 01:46:42.863
PROHIBIT PUBLIC CRITICISM. WITH
01:46:42.929 --> 01:46:46.333
ME TODAY, OR SPONSORS OF SP 1100
01:46:46.399 --> 01:46:47.734
JEFF NEAL, REPRESENTING THE
01:46:47.801 --> 01:46:48.869
CALIFORNIA STATE ASSOCIATION OF
01:46:48.935 --> 01:46:51.204
COUNTIES TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT. AS
01:46:51.271 --> 01:46:52.305
WELL AS JEAN HEARST,
01:46:52.372 --> 01:46:53.306
REPRESENTING URBAN COUNTIES OF
01:46:53.373 --> 01:46:55.675
CALIFORNIA. THANK YOU. AND I
01:46:55.742 --> 01:46:56.243
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR I
01:46:56.309 --> 01:47:00.046
VOTE. NO. WELCOME. GOOD
01:47:00.113 --> 01:47:07.187
AFTERNOON. MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS,
01:47:07.254 --> 01:47:08.355
JEFF NEAL WITH THE CALIFORNIA
01:47:08.421 --> 01:47:10.557
STATE ASSOCIATION OF COUNTIES,
01:47:10.624 --> 01:47:13.193
UM, THANKFUL FOR THE SENATOR
01:47:13.260 --> 01:47:14.828
AUTHORING THIS BILL, AS YOU
01:47:14.895 --> 01:47:16.797
KNOW, THIS IS AN ISSUE THAT MANY
01:47:16.863 --> 01:47:18.532
OF OUR MEMBERS AS WELL AS OTHER
01:47:18.598 --> 01:47:19.666
LOCAL AGENCIES HAVE BEEN DEALING
01:47:19.733 --> 01:47:22.602
WITH. AND WHILE TO THE EXTENT
01:47:22.669 --> 01:47:25.071
THAT THIS BILL EITHER ADDS
01:47:25.138 --> 01:47:26.239
AUTHORITY, OR CLARIFIES EXISTING
01:47:26.306 --> 01:47:29.309
CASE LAW INTO STATUTE WE'VE
01:47:29.376 --> 01:47:31.311
HEARD PLENTY OF STORIES FROM
01:47:31.378 --> 01:47:32.946
LEGISLATIVE BODIES NOT ONLY
01:47:33.013 --> 01:47:34.247
GOVERNING BODIES, BUT THE MANY
01:47:34.314 --> 01:47:37.951
OTHER ADVISORY BODIES THAT OFTEN
01:47:38.018 --> 01:47:39.219
DON'T HAVE COUNSEL IN THE ROOM
01:47:39.286 --> 01:47:40.153
DURING THEIR MEETINGS, WHETHER
01:47:40.220 --> 01:47:41.988
IT'S VERY SMALLER AGENCY OR FOR
01:47:42.055 --> 01:47:45.058
A AH, SMALLER LEGISLATIVE BODY
01:47:45.125 --> 01:47:46.693
AT A LARGER AGENCY. SO TO THE
01:47:46.760 --> 01:47:48.094
EXTENT THAT THAT PUTTING THIS
01:47:48.161 --> 01:47:50.063
EXPLICITLY INTO STATUTE WILL
01:47:50.130 --> 01:47:52.332
MAKE IT CLEAR TO THOSE MEMBERS
01:47:52.399 --> 01:47:54.167
WHO WE'VE HEARD STORIES OF THEM,
01:47:54.234 --> 01:47:55.969
NOT KNOWING THAT THEY HAD THE
01:47:56.036 --> 01:47:57.137
AUTHORITY TO REMOVE MEMBERS
01:47:57.204 --> 01:47:58.138
WITHOUT, FOR EXAMPLE, CHARGING
01:47:58.205 --> 01:48:00.040
THEM WITH A CRIME. THIS WILL
01:48:00.106 --> 01:48:02.342
HELP DEAL WITH THOSE SITUATIONS
01:48:02.409 --> 01:48:04.444
THAT HAVE BECOME, UNFORTUNATELY
01:48:04.511 --> 01:48:05.946
INCREASINGLY COMMON AND
01:48:06.012 --> 01:48:07.214
INCREASINGLY DANGEROUS, SO
01:48:07.280 --> 01:48:08.548
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR VOTE.
01:48:08.615 --> 01:48:13.320
THANK YOU. MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS
01:48:13.386 --> 01:48:14.855
JEAN HURST HERE TODAY ON BEHALF
01:48:14.921 --> 01:48:16.389
OF THE URBAN COUNTIES OF
01:48:16.456 --> 01:48:17.958
CALIFORNIA, ALSO IN STRONG
01:48:18.024 --> 01:48:20.994
SUPPORT OF SB 1100 REALLY WANT
01:48:21.061 --> 01:48:22.229
TO EXTEND OUR APPRECIATION TO
01:48:22.295 --> 01:48:24.865
THE COMMITTEE, YOUR STAFF AS
01:48:24.931 --> 01:48:26.333
WELL AS SENATOR CORTES AND HIS
01:48:26.399 --> 01:48:27.200
STAFF FOR REALLY BRINGING THE
01:48:27.267 --> 01:48:29.936
STAKEHOLDERS TOGETHER TO COME TO
01:48:30.003 --> 01:48:31.338
A REASONABLE AGREEMENT ABOUT HOW
01:48:31.404 --> 01:48:32.806
TO PROCEED ON WHAT WE BELIEVE IS
01:48:32.873 --> 01:48:34.741
A VERY IMPORTANT ADDITION TO THE
01:48:34.808 --> 01:48:38.912
BROWN ACT. THAT HELPS ENSURE THE
01:48:38.979 --> 01:48:40.380
PROMISE OF THE BROWN ACT TO
01:48:40.447 --> 01:48:42.482
ALLOW MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC TO
01:48:42.549 --> 01:48:43.617
PARTICIPATE IN THE CONDUCT OF
01:48:43.683 --> 01:48:44.351
THE PUBLIC'S BUSINESS BOTH
01:48:44.417 --> 01:48:45.185
SAFELY AND PRODUCTIVELY. WE
01:48:45.252 --> 01:48:46.887
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR VOTE
01:48:46.953 --> 01:48:49.856
TODAY. OH EXCUSE ME. ALSO IN
01:48:49.923 --> 01:48:51.391
SUPPORT THE SANTA CLARA COUNTY
01:48:51.458 --> 01:48:53.093
BOARD OF SUPERVISORS. THANK YOU.
01:48:53.159 --> 01:48:54.227
I APOLOGIZE FOR THAT. THANK YOU
01:48:54.294 --> 01:48:56.062
VERY MUCH ARE OTHER WITNESSES IN
01:48:56.129 --> 01:49:00.967
SUPPORT? GOOD AFTERNOON, MADAM
01:49:01.034 --> 01:49:02.102
CHAIR MEMBERS, SAM NASHER WITH
01:49:02.168 --> 01:49:03.837
LOS ANGELES COUNTY OFFICE OF
01:49:03.904 --> 01:49:04.871
EDUCATION AND SUPPORT. THANK
01:49:04.938 --> 01:49:11.311
YOU. QUÊ. GOOD AFTERNOON, MARCUS
01:49:11.378 --> 01:49:12.712
DETWEILER WITH THE CALIFORNIA
01:49:12.779 --> 01:49:13.747
SPECIAL DISTRICTS ASSOCIATION IN
01:49:13.813 --> 01:49:15.282
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
01:49:15.348 --> 01:49:18.084
ANY OTHER WITNESSES IN SUPPORT?
01:49:18.151 --> 01:49:19.319
SING NONE AND HE WITNESSES, AN
01:49:19.386 --> 01:49:29.696
OPPOSITION. ONE OF YOU. AND YOU
01:49:29.763 --> 01:49:31.131
CAN HAVE A SEAT HERE IF YOU'D
01:49:31.197 --> 01:49:36.803
LIKE, BECAUSE YOUR OPPOSITION.
01:49:36.870 --> 01:49:37.904
THIS IS REMINDING OF THREE
01:49:37.971 --> 01:49:40.173
MINUTES. YES, THANK YOU. GOOD
01:49:40.240 --> 01:49:42.375
AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS DARLENE L.
01:49:42.442 --> 01:49:44.611
KISA AND I'M CO FOUNDER OF
01:49:44.678 --> 01:49:45.812
PROTECTION OF THE EDUCATIONAL
01:49:45.879 --> 01:49:48.381
RIGHTS OF KIDS. WE ARE NONPROFIT
01:49:48.448 --> 01:49:49.449
, NONPARTISAN ORGANIZATION THAT
01:49:49.516 --> 01:49:50.450
SERVES STUDENTS AND FAMILIES
01:49:50.517 --> 01:49:51.351
THROUGHOUT THE STATE. REGARDING
01:49:51.418 --> 01:49:54.955
EDUCATION RIGHTS. AS COLLEGE
01:49:55.021 --> 01:49:56.923
FACULTY. I DO ATTEND BOARD
01:49:56.990 --> 01:49:57.958
MEETINGS. I ATTEND BOARD
01:49:58.024 --> 01:49:58.858
MEETINGS FOR MY CHILDREN'S
01:49:58.925 --> 01:50:00.060
SCHOOL DISTRICT, AND I ALSO
01:50:00.126 --> 01:50:01.027
ATTEND PUBLIC HEARINGS FOR OUR
01:50:01.094 --> 01:50:04.597
ORGANIZATION. GIVEN THAT EVEN AT
01:50:04.664 --> 01:50:05.765
THE BEGINNING OF THIS HEARING,
01:50:05.832 --> 01:50:08.068
MADAM CHAIR YOU HAVE CLEARLY
01:50:08.134 --> 01:50:09.903
STATED THE RULES OF DECORUM AND
01:50:09.970 --> 01:50:11.338
WHAT WILL HAPPEN IF ANYONE ACTS
01:50:11.404 --> 01:50:13.139
OUT OF THESE RULES, INCLUDING
01:50:13.206 --> 01:50:14.641
POTENTIAL REMOVAL OF THOSE WHO
01:50:14.708 --> 01:50:15.942
CONTINUE TO BE DISRUPTIVE AFTER
01:50:16.009 --> 01:50:17.777
WARNING. I ALSO SEE THIS HAPPEN
01:50:17.844 --> 01:50:20.547
AT LOCAL PUBLIC HEARINGS. AS WE
01:50:20.613 --> 01:50:21.614
ARE TRANSITIONING OUT OF AN
01:50:21.681 --> 01:50:24.617
EXTENDED LOCKDOWN. I WOULD SAY
01:50:24.684 --> 01:50:26.720
IT IS NOT THE RIGHT TIME FOR A
01:50:26.786 --> 01:50:28.688
BILL LIKE THIS. WE NEED TO SHOW
01:50:28.755 --> 01:50:30.423
GRACE IN THE SAME WAY THAT WE
01:50:30.490 --> 01:50:32.625
HAVE SHOWN GRACE TO THE SOCIAL
01:50:32.692 --> 01:50:34.127
JUSTICE PROTESTERS. THOSE WHO
01:50:34.194 --> 01:50:35.395
ARE PERCEIVED AS DISRUPTIVE IN
01:50:35.462 --> 01:50:36.730
PUBLIC HEARINGS ARE JUST COMING
01:50:36.796 --> 01:50:38.765
OUT OF A LONG PANDEMIC LOCKED
01:50:38.832 --> 01:50:40.000
DOWN IN THEIR HOMES FOR SEVERAL
01:50:40.066 --> 01:50:42.502
YEARS AND MONTHS. IT IS
01:50:42.569 --> 01:50:44.537
IMPORTANT TO HEAR THINGS OF A
01:50:44.604 --> 01:50:45.038
DIFFERENT PERSPECTIVE OR
01:50:45.105 --> 01:50:47.874
VIEWPOINT. HOW CAN WE ENSURE
01:50:47.941 --> 01:50:49.142
THAT THOSE WHO HAVE A DIFFERENT
01:50:49.209 --> 01:50:51.478
VIEW WON'T EASILY BE CAST OUT
01:50:51.544 --> 01:50:52.545
FOR BEING SOMEONE WHO DISRUPTS
01:50:52.612 --> 01:50:55.081
DISTURBS, IMPEDES OR RENDERS. UM
01:50:55.148 --> 01:51:00.053
THE MEETING INFEASIBLE. SB 1100
01:51:00.120 --> 01:51:01.154
DOES NOT HAVE ANY LANGUAGE TO
01:51:01.221 --> 01:51:02.455
ENSURE THAT MEETING PARTICIPANTS
01:51:02.522 --> 01:51:04.024
WITH DIFFERING VIEWPOINTS AND
01:51:04.090 --> 01:51:06.092
OPINIONS WILL NOT BE TARGETED
01:51:06.159 --> 01:51:07.694
RETALIATED AGAINST BY THE
01:51:07.761 --> 01:51:09.562
MEETING BOARD BY LABELING THEM
01:51:09.629 --> 01:51:10.797
AS OUT OF DECORUM. FOR MINUSCULE
01:51:10.864 --> 01:51:14.200
BEHAVIORS. THANK YOU FOR YOUR
01:51:14.267 --> 01:51:15.068
ATTENTION AND CONSIDERING
01:51:15.135 --> 01:51:17.203
CONSIDERATION, I RESPECTFULLY
01:51:17.270 --> 01:51:20.407
ASKED TO ABSTAIN ON SP 1100. I'M
01:51:20.473 --> 01:51:22.675
HERE WITH A MEMBER OF MY
01:51:22.742 --> 01:51:24.044
ORGANIZATION WHO WOULD ALSO LIKE
01:51:24.110 --> 01:51:24.878
TO SPEAK. THAT'S FINE. THANK
01:51:24.944 --> 01:51:26.679
YOU. GOOD AFTERNOON, MADAM CHAIR
01:51:26.746 --> 01:51:28.014
AND MEMBERS. MY NAME IS KASHA
01:51:28.081 --> 01:51:30.216
WILLIAMS. I'M A PROUD NEW
01:51:30.283 --> 01:51:32.152
CITIZEN OF THIS COUNTRY. I'M
01:51:32.218 --> 01:51:33.987
ALSO A SCHOOL LIBRARIAN AT
01:51:34.054 --> 01:51:35.488
ELEMENTARY SCHOOL AND ALSO
01:51:35.555 --> 01:51:37.023
APPARENT I'VE BEEN ATTENDING
01:51:37.090 --> 01:51:38.091
MANY SCHOOL BOARD MEETINGS, BOTH
01:51:38.158 --> 01:51:39.826
AS A PARENT AND AS A SCHOOL
01:51:39.893 --> 01:51:42.562
EMPLOYEE. AND I DO UNDERSTAND
01:51:42.629 --> 01:51:45.799
THE CONCERN. HOWEVER I HAVE SOME
01:51:45.865 --> 01:51:46.933
RESERVATIONS IN REGARDS OF SB
01:51:47.000 --> 01:51:52.472
1100. I BY ATTENDING SCHOOL
01:51:52.539 --> 01:51:53.239
BOARD MEETINGS, I NOTICED
01:51:53.306 --> 01:51:55.542
EVERYBODY HAS A DIFFERENT WAY OF
01:51:55.608 --> 01:51:56.276
EXPRESSING THEIR FREEDOM OF
01:51:56.342 --> 01:51:59.045
SPEECH FOR SAY, SOME PEOPLE GET
01:51:59.112 --> 01:52:00.080
VERY EMOTIONAL START CRYING.
01:52:00.146 --> 01:52:01.548
SOME PEOPLE GET VERY PASSIONATE.
01:52:01.614 --> 01:52:05.652
AND THEY RAISED THEIR VOICE.
01:52:05.718 --> 01:52:07.020
LOOKING AT THE LANGUAGE OF THE
01:52:07.087 --> 01:52:09.989
BILL. IT STATES THAT SB 1100
01:52:10.056 --> 01:52:12.358
WITHOUT ARISE, THE PRESIDING
01:52:12.425 --> 01:52:13.526
MEMBER OF THE LEGISLATIVE BODY
01:52:13.593 --> 01:52:15.795
CONDUCTING A MEETING TO REMOVE
01:52:15.862 --> 01:52:18.064
AN INDIVIDUAL FOR WILLFULLY
01:52:18.131 --> 01:52:18.965
INTERRUPTED THE MEETING. IN MY
01:52:19.032 --> 01:52:21.668
MIND, IT IS QUESTIONABLE, BUT
01:52:21.734 --> 01:52:22.569
THE PRESIDING MEMBER COULD
01:52:22.635 --> 01:52:24.571
DEFINED AS INTERRUPTING SO
01:52:24.637 --> 01:52:25.772
THEREFORE I WOULD ASK FOR
01:52:25.839 --> 01:52:29.142
ABSTAIN. ON 1100 TODAY. THANK
01:52:29.209 --> 01:52:33.680
YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR
01:52:33.746 --> 01:52:34.848
BOTH OF YOU FOR YOUR TESTIMONY%
01:52:34.914 --> 01:52:36.883
TODAY. UM ARE THERE ANY OTHER
01:52:36.950 --> 01:52:37.951
PEOPLE IN OPPOSITION TO THE
01:52:38.017 --> 01:52:40.920
BILL? SING NONE. ARE THERE ANY
01:52:40.987 --> 01:52:43.356
QUESTIONS OF THE COMMITTEE? YES.
01:52:43.423 --> 01:52:44.190
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S VOEPEL.
01:52:44.257 --> 01:52:47.227
COMMENT. I CANNOT SUPPORT THIS
01:52:47.293 --> 01:52:50.630
BILL. IT'S ANOTHER CHIP AWAY AT
01:52:50.697 --> 01:52:53.900
THE FIRST AMENDMENT. I WAS MAYOR
01:52:53.967 --> 01:52:56.936
OF MY CITY FOR 16 YEARS AND I
01:52:57.003 --> 01:52:58.505
WAS CRITICIZED BY SOME MEMBERS
01:52:58.571 --> 01:52:59.939
OF MY CITY COUNCIL FOR BEING TOO
01:53:00.006 --> 01:53:03.810
LENIENT. ON CITIZENS THAT WOULD
01:53:03.877 --> 01:53:09.215
CUSS OR GET SO ANGRY AT WHAT
01:53:09.282 --> 01:53:11.451
THEY PERCEIVED THE CITY COUNCIL
01:53:11.518 --> 01:53:12.919
DOING THAT THEY WOULD SPIT ON
01:53:12.986 --> 01:53:15.855
THE MICROPHONE. UM SOME OF THEM
01:53:15.922 --> 01:53:20.827
WOULD SAY THINGS. RAZOR VOICE
01:53:20.894 --> 01:53:22.562
AND SAY, I'M GONNA KICK YOUR
01:53:22.629 --> 01:53:26.332
POLITICAL REAR END. WELL. THAT
01:53:26.399 --> 01:53:28.234
BEATS KICKING YOUR REAR END.
01:53:28.301 --> 01:53:30.370
THAT WOULD BE A THREAT.
01:53:30.436 --> 01:53:31.538
POLITICAL REAR ENDS A DIFFERENT
01:53:31.604 --> 01:53:36.876
DEAL. AND COUNCIL MEMBERS AND
01:53:36.943 --> 01:53:38.111
MAYORS OR SCHOOL BOARD MEMBERS,
01:53:38.178 --> 01:53:42.115
ESPECIALLY MIGHT CONSIDER
01:53:42.182 --> 01:53:44.817
KICKING YOUR POLITICAL REAR END
01:53:44.884 --> 01:53:48.121
A DIRECT THREAT BECAUSE NOW
01:53:48.188 --> 01:53:49.756
THEIR POLITICAL REAR END MAY BE
01:53:49.822 --> 01:53:50.924
THROWN OUT OF OFFICE. SO AT THE
01:53:50.990 --> 01:53:53.927
MOMENT OF EMOTION. PEOPLE SAY
01:53:53.993 --> 01:54:00.867
THINGS. AND. IT'S UP TO THE
01:54:00.934 --> 01:54:03.369
GOVERNING BODY TO JUST GO WITH
01:54:03.436 --> 01:54:05.705
THE FLOW. THEY GET TO THREE
01:54:05.772 --> 01:54:07.540
MINUTES. WHATEVER IT IS, AND IF
01:54:07.607 --> 01:54:09.943
THEY'RE AN IDIOT. PEOPLE KNOW
01:54:10.009 --> 01:54:11.110
THEY'RE IDIOTS, BUT IT'S CALLED
01:54:11.177 --> 01:54:14.914
FREE SPEECH. I'M FREE TO BE AN
01:54:14.981 --> 01:54:16.182
IDIOT. ESPECIALLY UP HERE.
01:54:16.249 --> 01:54:20.553
RIGHT, MADAM CHAIR. SO POINT I'M
01:54:20.620 --> 01:54:23.289
MAKING IS THIS IS ANOTHER ATTACK
01:54:23.356 --> 01:54:26.926
ON THE FIRST AMENDMENT. OF
01:54:26.993 --> 01:54:28.294
COURSE, YOU CANNOT SAY THINGS
01:54:28.361 --> 01:54:29.395
LIKE FIRE IN A THEATER.
01:54:29.462 --> 01:54:32.131
EVERYBODY KNOWS THAT. BUT WHEN
01:54:32.198 --> 01:54:34.267
WE'RE AT A SCHOOL BOARD MEETING
01:54:34.334 --> 01:54:38.104
AND PARENTS ARE UPSET. THEY'RE
01:54:38.171 --> 01:54:40.473
JUST REGULAR CIVILIANS. THEY'RE
01:54:40.540 --> 01:54:41.608
NOT PROFESSIONAL POLITICIANS,
01:54:41.674 --> 01:54:46.179
THEY DON'T KNOW. HOW TO SPEAK
01:54:46.246 --> 01:54:46.779
POLITICALLY CORRECT. THEY'RE
01:54:46.846 --> 01:54:50.917
JUST ANGRY. THIS BILL. WILL
01:54:50.984 --> 01:54:57.123
ALLOW THE LEADER. OF THE BOARD
01:54:57.190 --> 01:55:00.193
TO JUST THROW PEOPLE OUT. WHAT
01:55:00.260 --> 01:55:03.830
IF IT'S THEIR POLITICAL ENEMIES?
01:55:03.896 --> 01:55:05.131
OOH NOW WE'RE IN A DIFFERENT
01:55:05.198 --> 01:55:06.866
TERRITORY THERE. SO THAT'S MY
01:55:06.933 --> 01:55:10.136
COMMENT. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
01:55:10.203 --> 01:55:11.004
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S AND THE OTHER
01:55:11.070 --> 01:55:16.743
COMMENTS. OKAY WE HAVE A MOTION
01:55:16.809 --> 01:55:17.176
BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
01:55:17.243 --> 01:55:19.979
BOERNER HORVATH. SECOND BY SOME
01:55:20.046 --> 01:55:27.086
REMEMBER BLOOM. UM. WOULD YOU
01:55:27.153 --> 01:55:28.388
LIKE TO CLOSE? THANK YOU, MADAM
01:55:28.454 --> 01:55:31.724
CHAIR. AND I'LL JUST SAY A FEW
01:55:31.791 --> 01:55:36.596
WORDS. AS I CLOSE ABOUT THE
01:55:36.663 --> 01:55:39.165
FIRST AMENDMENT AS WE STARTED TO
01:55:39.232 --> 01:55:40.233
FASHION THE SPILL MY
01:55:40.300 --> 01:55:43.303
INSTRUCTIONS TO WHICH WAS
01:55:43.369 --> 01:55:44.937
REQUESTED BY LOCAL GOVERNMENT,
01:55:45.004 --> 01:55:47.140
BY THE WAY, BUT MY INSTRUCTIONS
01:55:47.206 --> 01:55:48.675
TO MY OWN STAFF ALLEGED COUNCIL
01:55:48.741 --> 01:55:50.610
AND EVERYONE WHO WORKED ON THE
01:55:50.677 --> 01:55:51.711
BILL AS AN ATTORNEY AS AN
01:55:51.778 --> 01:55:53.379
ATTORNEY WHO PRACTICED
01:55:53.446 --> 01:55:55.448
CONSTITUTIONAL LAW IS THERE'S TO
01:55:55.515 --> 01:55:58.251
BE ABSOLUTELY NO CONTENT BASED
01:55:58.318 --> 01:55:59.619
REGULATION IN THIS BILL, WHAT
01:55:59.686 --> 01:56:02.221
PEOPLE SAY. THEY GET TO SAY
01:56:02.288 --> 01:56:03.489
EXACTLY AS THE MEMBER JUST
01:56:03.556 --> 01:56:06.392
OUTLINED. THEY GET TO SAY IT FOR
01:56:06.459 --> 01:56:09.462
A PRESCRIBED PERIOD OF TIME. IF
01:56:09.529 --> 01:56:11.130
THEY DECIDE NOT TO SEE THE
01:56:11.197 --> 01:56:12.265
MICROPHONE FOR 10 MINUTES AND
01:56:12.332 --> 01:56:13.266
THEY'VE BEEN ALLOWED TWO
01:56:13.333 --> 01:56:15.601
MINUTES. THAT MIGHT BE
01:56:15.668 --> 01:56:17.670
INTERPRETED AS AS A DISRUPTION
01:56:17.737 --> 01:56:18.971
OF THE MEETING DISALLOWING THE
01:56:19.038 --> 01:56:20.373
PROCEEDINGS OF THE MEETING TO GO
01:56:20.440 --> 01:56:23.176
ON IF THEY CHARGED THE DAIS.
01:56:23.242 --> 01:56:23.710
THAT WOULD BE, I THINK,
01:56:23.776 --> 01:56:24.977
CONSIDERED A DISRUPTION OF THE
01:56:25.044 --> 01:56:26.479
MEETING. NO NO WORDS WHATSOEVER.
01:56:26.546 --> 01:56:30.950
NO WORDS WHATSOEVER. THERE. OUR
01:56:31.017 --> 01:56:33.119
ISSUES IN THE BROWN AT CURRENTLY
01:56:33.186 --> 01:56:34.754
WHICH ALREADY ALLOWS THE BODY TO
01:56:34.821 --> 01:56:35.988
REMOVE SOMEBODY FOR DISRUPTING
01:56:36.055 --> 01:56:40.126
THE MEETING. ALREADY ALLOWS THAT
01:56:40.193 --> 01:56:42.161
BUT DOESN'T INDICATE THEN
01:56:42.228 --> 01:56:43.830
WHETHER OR NOT A VOTE IS NEEDED
01:56:43.896 --> 01:56:45.331
OR NOT NEEDED. THAT WAS
01:56:45.398 --> 01:56:46.566
CLARIFIED BY ALL THE PARTIES
01:56:46.632 --> 01:56:48.534
THAT CAME TOGETHER HERE TO SAY.
01:56:48.601 --> 01:56:50.937
THERE NEEDS TO BE A SINGULAR
01:56:51.003 --> 01:56:53.039
PERSON WHO PRESIDES OVER THAT
01:56:53.106 --> 01:56:55.174
ISSUE, ESPECIALLY IN EXIGENT
01:56:55.241 --> 01:56:56.476
CIRCUMSTANCES WHERE THERE IS AN
01:56:56.542 --> 01:56:59.545
ACTUAL THREAT TO THE BODY.
01:56:59.612 --> 01:57:02.348
DEFINITIONS WERE LEFT OUT IN THE
01:57:02.415 --> 01:57:03.783
BROWN ACT, EVEN THE DEFINITION
01:57:03.850 --> 01:57:06.185
OF WHAT CONSTITUTES A WILLFUL
01:57:06.252 --> 01:57:07.086
INTERRUPTION OR WOLF OF
01:57:07.153 --> 01:57:09.455
DISRUPTION. SO IN SOME WAYS,
01:57:09.522 --> 01:57:10.823
THIS IS CLEANED UP AND TIGHTENED
01:57:10.890 --> 01:57:13.693
UP TO TRY TO CREATE MORE
01:57:13.760 --> 01:57:16.896
FAIRNESS, NOT LESS FAIRNESS.
01:57:16.963 --> 01:57:18.765
THROUGHOUT ALL ALL THE BROWN
01:57:18.831 --> 01:57:21.434
ACTED AGENCIES IN CALIFORNIA, SO
01:57:21.501 --> 01:57:24.303
THERE'S HAS CAUSED AS POSSIBLE
01:57:24.370 --> 01:57:25.605
TO NOT ONLY FAIRNESS AND
01:57:25.671 --> 01:57:26.472
EVENHANDEDNESS BUT A SINGULAR
01:57:26.539 --> 01:57:30.209
INTERPRETATION AS TO WHAT AND
01:57:30.276 --> 01:57:32.412
WHEN FOLKS SHOULD BE DOING THAT
01:57:32.478 --> 01:57:34.647
ARE PRESIDING OVER MEETINGS.
01:57:34.714 --> 01:57:36.983
THEY GET SO UNRULY THAT THE BODY
01:57:37.049 --> 01:57:38.951
CANNOT CARRY ON ITS BUSINESS. I
01:57:39.018 --> 01:57:40.153
THINK THAT ANYONE WHO HAS BEEN
01:57:40.219 --> 01:57:41.354
IN LOCAL GOVERNMENT CERTAINLY I
01:57:41.421 --> 01:57:44.557
AM ONE OF THOSE FOR 20 YEARS.
01:57:44.624 --> 01:57:47.527
HAS EXPERIENCED THAT SO VICKS
01:57:47.593 --> 01:57:48.928
EXPERIENCE EVEN BEYOND THAT,
01:57:48.995 --> 01:57:49.962
HAVING TO HAVE A RESTRAINING
01:57:50.029 --> 01:57:53.332
ORDERS. AND BEING THREATENED
01:57:53.399 --> 01:57:54.434
JUST YESTERDAY IN THE CITY OF
01:57:54.500 --> 01:57:56.235
SAN JOSE. AN ELECTED OFFICIAL
01:57:56.302 --> 01:57:59.272
COUNCIL MEMBER. DAVID DAVIS FROM
01:57:59.338 --> 01:58:03.376
THE CITY OF SAN JOSE. UM
01:58:03.443 --> 01:58:04.944
REPORTED A PIPE BOMB IN HER
01:58:05.011 --> 01:58:06.446
HOUSE AND HAD HER NEIGHBORHOOD
01:58:06.512 --> 01:58:07.980
HAD TO BE EVACUATED. WE DON'T
01:58:08.047 --> 01:58:09.949
KNOW WHO WE DON'T KNOW WHO THE
01:58:10.016 --> 01:58:14.654
SUSPECT IS YET. UM BUT I THINK
01:58:14.720 --> 01:58:15.855
THOSE OF US WHO SERVED IN THE
01:58:15.922 --> 01:58:18.124
LOCAL GOVERNMENT WOULD NOT BE AT
01:58:18.191 --> 01:58:19.292
ALL SURPRISED TO FIND OUT THAT
01:58:19.358 --> 01:58:22.528
IT WAS SOMEBODY WHO HAD BECOME
01:58:22.595 --> 01:58:24.697
DISRUPTIVE IN A IN A MEETING.
01:58:24.764 --> 01:58:27.467
THAT IS A RIGHT AGAIN SO LONG AS
01:58:27.533 --> 01:58:28.501
THEY DON'T VIOLATE THIS
01:58:28.568 --> 01:58:30.636
DEFINITION OF WHAT'S DISRUPTIVE.
01:58:30.703 --> 01:58:33.372
SO WITH THAT, I THINK THE BILL
01:58:33.439 --> 01:58:37.276
AS AS VETTED UM AND SUPPORTED BY
01:58:37.343 --> 01:58:41.013
PAGES AND PAGES OF FOLKS. WHO
01:58:41.080 --> 01:58:43.115
ARE SUPPORTERS OF THE BILL AT
01:58:43.182 --> 01:58:46.619
THIS POINT IS THE KIND OF
01:58:46.686 --> 01:58:47.320
IMPROVEMENT THAT WILL KEEP
01:58:47.386 --> 01:58:49.489
PEOPLE SAFE AND PROTECT THE
01:58:49.555 --> 01:58:51.023
FIRST AMENDMENT RIGHTS OF ALL
01:58:51.090 --> 01:58:52.758
THOSE HO WERE IN CHAMBERS AND
01:58:52.825 --> 01:58:55.428
HEARING ROOMS TRYING TO GET
01:58:55.495 --> 01:58:56.462
THEIR OPPORTUNITY TO PETITION
01:58:56.529 --> 01:58:57.630
THEIR GOVERNMENT. AND WITH THAT,
01:58:57.697 --> 01:58:59.398
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR I
01:58:59.465 --> 01:59:02.068
VOTE. THANK YOU, SENATOR CORTEZ
01:59:02.134 --> 01:59:04.170
, AND WE BOTH SHARE A GRAVE
01:59:04.237 --> 01:59:06.405
CONCERN FOR SAFETY AND WELFARE
01:59:06.472 --> 01:59:08.040
OF OUR LOCAL, UH ELECTED
01:59:08.107 --> 01:59:08.941
OFFICIALS AND THEIR
01:59:09.008 --> 01:59:12.411
CONSTITUENTS. UH WHO HAVE BEEN
01:59:12.478 --> 01:59:14.313
FACING INCREASINGLY FRIGHTENING
01:59:14.380 --> 01:59:15.615
AND OFFENSIVE ACTS DURING OPEN
01:59:15.681 --> 01:59:18.451
MEETINGS IN RECENT YEARS? I FEEL
01:59:18.518 --> 01:59:19.285
LIKE YOUR BILL IS REASONABLE
01:59:19.352 --> 01:59:21.454
CLARIFICATION OF THE STEPS LOCAL
01:59:21.521 --> 01:59:23.022
BOARDS AND CITY MEMBERS CAN TAKE
01:59:23.089 --> 01:59:24.290
TO REMOVE A PERSON WHO'S
01:59:24.357 --> 01:59:25.491
ENGAGING IN DISRUPTIVE OR
01:59:25.558 --> 01:59:28.060
THREATNING BEHAVIOR. ALLOWING
01:59:28.127 --> 01:59:29.195
OUR LOCAL AGENCIES AND THE
01:59:29.262 --> 01:59:31.063
PUBLIC TO COMPLETE THE PEOPLE'S
01:59:31.130 --> 01:59:32.131
BUSINESS AND IS SAFE AND
01:59:32.198 --> 01:59:34.133
EFFICIENT MANNER AND PLEASED TO
01:59:34.200 --> 01:59:35.601
SUPPORT YOUR BILL TODAY, AND I
01:59:35.668 --> 01:59:37.370
LIKE TO BE ADDED AS A CO AUTHOR.
01:59:37.436 --> 01:59:40.172
MOTIONS DO PASS TO THE JUDICIARY
01:59:40.239 --> 01:59:41.674
COMMITTEE SECRETARY, PLEASE CALL
01:59:41.741 --> 01:59:44.644
THE ROLL. AGREE OUR CURRY CURRY
01:59:44.710 --> 01:59:47.647
. AYE LACKEY BLOOM. I
01:59:47.713 --> 01:59:51.083
BOERNER HORVATH HARVARD. I RAMOS
01:59:51.150 --> 01:59:52.285
RAMOS. AYE THREE OF US ASIDE
01:59:52.351 --> 01:59:56.022
ROBERT RIVAS. ROBERT RIVAS SIDE
01:59:56.088 --> 02:00:00.560
VOEPEL. NO, YOU HAVE 61 BILLS
02:00:00.626 --> 02:00:02.762
OUT. 61 THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
02:00:02.828 --> 02:00:03.963
THANK YOU. AND BE HAPPY TO HAVE
02:00:04.030 --> 02:00:05.932
YOU AS A CO AUTHOR. OKAY, THANK
02:00:05.998 --> 02:00:22.048
YOU.
02:00:43.703 --> 02:00:46.772
UM WE WILL GO AHEAD AND, UH,
02:00:46.839 --> 02:00:48.441
TAKE UP BILLS FOR ADD ONS.
02:00:48.507 --> 02:00:52.678
SECRETARY. PLEASE CALL PLEASE
02:00:52.745 --> 02:00:56.616
PROCEED. SP 3 61 ON BERG. THE
02:00:56.682 --> 02:00:57.883
MOTION IS DUE PASS AS ADMITTED
02:00:57.950 --> 02:00:58.951
TO HOUSING AND COMMUNITY
02:00:59.018 --> 02:01:01.654
DEVELOPMENT. THREE OF US
02:01:01.721 --> 02:01:03.556
THREE OF US I? THAT'S 70 VITAL
02:01:03.623 --> 02:01:09.929
VOTE IS 70. FINAL BOAT 70. SB 3
02:01:09.996 --> 02:01:18.604
79 WIENER. WAIT. IT'S SO
02:01:18.671 --> 02:01:26.145
INTERESTING. TAKE THAT WINDOW.
02:01:26.212 --> 02:01:30.783
UH ON SP 3 61. UH CURRENT. IT'S
02:01:30.850 --> 02:01:36.822
70. IT'S NOT FINAL YET. SP 3 79
02:01:36.889 --> 02:01:38.391
WAYNER DO PASS AS AMENDED TO
02:01:38.457 --> 02:01:40.660
UTILITIES AND ENERGY THREE OF US
02:01:40.726 --> 02:01:45.898
THREE OF US I 61 SOME 61. YOU
02:01:45.965 --> 02:01:54.940
DON'T HAVE TO. RIGHT RIGHT. SB
02:01:55.007 --> 02:01:58.144
82 DOT PASSED TO NATURAL
02:01:58.210 --> 02:02:03.983
RESOURCES THREE OF US, AYE. SP 9
02:02:04.050 --> 02:02:06.385
32 PORTANTINO MOTION IS DUE
02:02:06.452 --> 02:02:07.653
PASSES HAVE BEEN TO
02:02:07.720 --> 02:02:08.821
TRANSPORTATION THREE OF US
02:02:08.888 --> 02:02:13.459
THREE OF US, AYE. SP 991 NEWMAN.
02:02:13.526 --> 02:02:15.061
THE MOTION IS DUE PASSES HAVE
02:02:15.127 --> 02:02:15.895
BEEN TO APPROPRIATIONS
02:02:15.961 --> 02:02:22.368
THREE OF US. AYE. SP 12 14 JONES
02:02:22.435 --> 02:02:23.536
. THE MOTIONS DO PASSENGERS DISH
02:02:23.602 --> 02:02:27.773
THREE OF US. THREE OF US. AYE.
02:02:27.840 --> 02:02:31.644
AS WE 12 26 TERRAZZO MOTION IS
02:02:31.711 --> 02:02:33.612
DO PASS THE TRANSPORTATION
02:02:33.679 --> 02:02:34.146
TRANSPORTATION THREE OF US
02:02:34.213 --> 02:02:38.217
THREE OF US, AYE. SP 12 91
02:02:38.284 --> 02:02:40.119
ARCHULETTA. THE MOTIONS DO PASS
02:02:40.186 --> 02:02:41.020
A MAN TO TRANSPORTATION
02:02:41.087 --> 02:02:45.624
THREE OF US THREE OF US, AYE. SP
02:02:45.691 --> 02:02:48.194
13 73 KAMLAGER. THE MOTION IS
02:02:48.260 --> 02:02:50.629
DUE PASS AS AMENDED THE HOUSING
02:02:50.696 --> 02:02:51.530
AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
02:02:51.597 --> 02:02:57.536
THREE OF US. AYE. YOUR PRODUCT.
02:02:57.603 --> 02:03:11.817
OKAY?
02:03:11.884 --> 02:03:31.804
JUST ONE.
02:10:23.682 --> 02:10:26.885
EXCUSE ME WITNESSES IN SUPPORT.
02:10:26.952 --> 02:10:35.127
SURE. TODAY ON BEHALF OF THE
02:10:35.194 --> 02:10:36.128
CALIFORNIA NATIVE PLANT SOCIETY
02:10:36.195 --> 02:10:37.863
AND SUPPORT OF SENATE BILL 14
02:10:37.930 --> 02:10:40.566
25. CN PS IS A NONPROFIT
02:10:40.632 --> 02:10:42.234
ENVIRONMENTAL ORGANIZATION WITH
02:10:42.301 --> 02:10:44.903
OVER 11,000 MEMBERS ACROSS 35
02:10:44.970 --> 02:10:46.038
CHAPTERS IN CALIFORNIA AND BAJA
02:10:46.104 --> 02:10:48.941
CALIFORNIA MEXICO. CMP S
02:10:49.007 --> 02:10:50.576
MISSION IS TO PROTECT
02:10:50.642 --> 02:10:51.109
CALIFORNIA'S NATIVE PLANT
02:10:51.176 --> 02:10:52.911
HERITAGE AND PRESERVE IT FOR
02:10:52.978 --> 02:10:54.346
FUTURE GENERATIONS THROUGH THE
02:10:54.413 --> 02:10:55.547
APPLICATION OF SCIENCE,
02:10:55.614 --> 02:10:56.582
RESEARCH, EDUCATION AND
02:10:56.648 --> 02:11:00.018
CONSERVATION. CALIFORNIA IS A
02:11:00.085 --> 02:11:02.955
BIODIVERSITY HOTSPOT WITH 6500
02:11:03.021 --> 02:11:04.323
NATIVE PLANTS, MORE THAN ONE
02:11:04.389 --> 02:11:06.391
THIRD OF WHICH ARE FOUND ONLY IN
02:11:06.458 --> 02:11:08.060
CALIFORNIA. UNFORTUNATELY
02:11:08.126 --> 02:11:09.161
CLIMATE CHANGE AND LOSS OF
02:11:09.228 --> 02:11:10.028
HABITAT THREATEN OUR STATE'S
02:11:10.095 --> 02:11:12.331
WORLD RECOGNIZED BIODIVERSITY.
02:11:12.397 --> 02:11:13.565
THIS IS A PROBLEM NOT ONLY FOR
02:11:13.632 --> 02:11:19.738
THE UNIQUE. I MEAN, THAT DEPENDS
02:11:19.805 --> 02:11:20.939
ON THE ECOSYSTEM SERVICES, THE
02:11:21.006 --> 02:11:24.710
SPECIES PROVIDING SP 14 25 WILL
02:11:24.776 --> 02:11:26.144
HELP ADDRESS THESE THREATS TO
02:11:26.211 --> 02:11:27.646
CALIFORNIA'S ECOSYSTEMS BY
02:11:27.713 --> 02:11:29.348
REQUIRING CITIES AND COUNTIES TO
02:11:29.414 --> 02:11:30.816
UPDATE THEIR OPEN SPACE ELEMENTS
02:11:30.882 --> 02:11:31.984
UNDER THEIR GENERAL PLANS BY
02:11:32.050 --> 02:11:35.821
JANUARY, 26 2026. AND FOR THOSE
02:11:35.887 --> 02:11:37.322
UPDATES TO INCLUDE PLANS AND AN
02:11:37.389 --> 02:11:39.024
ACTION PROGRAM TO ADDRESS
02:11:39.091 --> 02:11:40.392
SPECIFIC ISSUES, INCLUDING
02:11:40.459 --> 02:11:41.760
EQUITABLE ACCESS TO NATURE,
02:11:41.827 --> 02:11:43.962
CLIMATE, RESILIENCE AND OTHER CO
02:11:44.029 --> 02:11:45.330
BENEFITS OF OPEN SPACE AND RE
02:11:45.397 --> 02:11:48.634
WILDING OPPORTUNITIES. SP 14 25
02:11:48.700 --> 02:11:49.668
WOULD FURTHER CALIFORNIA'S
02:11:49.735 --> 02:11:51.670
BIODIVERSITY AND CLIMATE GOALS
02:11:51.737 --> 02:11:52.838
BY PROMOTING LONG TERM WELL
02:11:52.904 --> 02:11:54.706
INFORMED LAND USE PLANNING AT
02:11:54.773 --> 02:11:56.742
THE LOCAL LEVEL. CURRENTLY MANY
02:11:56.808 --> 02:11:58.343
JURISDICTIONS HAVE OPEN SPACE
02:11:58.410 --> 02:11:59.945
ELEMENTS THAT HAVE NOT BEEN
02:12:00.012 --> 02:12:02.080
UPDATED FOR DECADES UNDER SP 14
02:12:02.147 --> 02:12:04.483
25 THESE OPEN SPACE ELEMENTS
02:12:04.549 --> 02:12:05.550
WILL BE UPDATED TO IDENTIFY
02:12:05.617 --> 02:12:06.852
IMPORTANT OPEN SPACE LOCATIONS
02:12:06.918 --> 02:12:09.755
AND ATTRIBUTES. THEY WILL
02:12:09.821 --> 02:12:10.355
BENEFIT COMMUNITIES THAT HAVE
02:12:10.422 --> 02:12:11.823
HAD LITTLE OR NO ACCESS TO THE
02:12:11.890 --> 02:12:14.159
OUTDOORS. AS WELL AS PROTECT
02:12:14.226 --> 02:12:15.427
WILDLIFE CORRIDORS, RESTORE
02:12:15.494 --> 02:12:17.262
BIODIVERSITY, PROVIDE CLEAN
02:12:17.329 --> 02:12:18.997
WATER AND CLEAN AIR AND CREATE
02:12:19.064 --> 02:12:21.099
IMPROVED RESILIENCE TO THE WORST
02:12:21.166 --> 02:12:23.568
IMPACTS FROM CLIMATE CHANGE.
02:12:23.635 --> 02:12:25.671
THIS BILL IS A COMMON SENSE
02:12:25.737 --> 02:12:26.204
SOLUTION THAT WILL PROMOTE
02:12:26.271 --> 02:12:27.239
BETTER LAND USE DECISIONS FOR
02:12:27.306 --> 02:12:29.308
THE BENEFIT OF ALL CALIFORNIANS
02:12:29.374 --> 02:12:30.575
. FOR THESE REASONS, WE URGE AND
02:12:30.642 --> 02:12:32.744
I VOTE ON SB 14 25. THANK YOU.
02:12:32.811 --> 02:12:34.713
THANK YOU. ARE THERE ANY OTHER
02:12:34.780 --> 02:12:40.185
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT? GOOD
02:12:40.252 --> 02:12:41.353
AFTERNOON ABIGAIL, MILE ON
02:12:41.420 --> 02:12:42.587
BEHALF OF THE MID PENINSULA
02:12:42.654 --> 02:12:43.822
REGIONAL OPEN SPACE DISTRICT AND
02:12:43.889 --> 02:12:46.558
SUPPORT THANK YOU. ARE THERE ANY
02:12:46.625 --> 02:12:47.959
OTHER WITNESSES IN SUPPORT,
02:12:48.026 --> 02:12:48.794
SAYING NONE ANY WITNESSES AND
02:12:48.860 --> 02:12:52.064
OPPOSITION. SEEING NONE. ARE
02:12:52.130 --> 02:12:53.799
THERE ANY QUESTIONS OF THE
02:12:53.865 --> 02:12:58.437
COMMITTEE? OKAY UM, WE HAVE A
02:12:58.503 --> 02:12:59.438
MOTION BY SOMEBODY MEMBER
02:12:59.504 --> 02:13:01.873
BOERNER HORVATH AND SECONDED BY
02:13:01.940 --> 02:13:05.243
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S THREE OF US. UM
02:13:05.310 --> 02:13:06.478
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE
02:13:06.545 --> 02:13:08.547
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR A VOTE.
02:13:08.613 --> 02:13:14.286
OKAY, HOLD ON HERE. I'M PLEASED
02:13:14.353 --> 02:13:15.787
TO SUPPORT YOUR BILL TODAY,
02:13:15.854 --> 02:13:17.689
WHICH WILL ENSURE A LONG DELAYED
02:13:17.756 --> 02:13:19.658
THAT LONG DELAYED OPEN SPACE
02:13:19.725 --> 02:13:21.259
PLANS ARE UPDATED TO REFLECT THE
02:13:21.326 --> 02:13:22.961
WORLD THAT WE LIVE IN TODAY. UM
02:13:23.028 --> 02:13:23.962
THE MOTIONS DO PASS THE
02:13:24.029 --> 02:13:26.064
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE.
02:13:26.131 --> 02:13:27.766
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
02:13:27.833 --> 02:13:32.204
CURRY CURRY. I LACKEY BLOOM.
02:13:32.270 --> 02:13:34.272
BLOOM I BOERNER HORVATH HIGH
02:13:34.339 --> 02:13:36.408
BOERNER HORVATH. AYE, RAMOS
02:13:36.475 --> 02:13:39.044
RAMOS. I THREE OF US
02:13:39.111 --> 02:13:40.579
ROBERT RIVAS ROBERT RIVAS SIDE
02:13:40.645 --> 02:13:45.684
VOEPEL VOEPEL NO 61. BILLS OUT
02:13:45.751 --> 02:14:02.200
61. THANK YOU.
02:14:02.267 --> 02:14:03.902
WE'RE GONNA LEAVE THE ROLE OPEN
02:14:03.969 --> 02:14:05.370
FOR THE NEXT FIVE MINUTES. THANK
02:14:05.437 --> 02:14:06.438
YOU. COMMITTEE MEMBERS FOR YOUR
02:14:06.505 --> 02:14:22.821
PARTICIPATION TODAY.
02:22:54.399 --> 02:23:07.679
CLICK THAT STATE.
02:23:07.745 --> 02:23:09.781
OKAY WE WILL NOW BE TAKING UP
02:23:09.847 --> 02:23:11.616
BILLS FOR ADD ON SECRETARY.
02:23:11.683 --> 02:23:15.353
PLEASE PROCEED. SP 3 61 HAMBURG
02:23:15.420 --> 02:23:16.154
DO PASS AS AMENDED TO HOUSING
02:23:16.220 --> 02:23:19.724
AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT LACKEY
02:23:19.791 --> 02:23:27.098
, NO FINAL COUNT IS SEVEN. ONE.
02:23:27.165 --> 02:23:30.301
SP 3 79 WAITER MOTION. THE
02:23:30.368 --> 02:23:32.537
ACTION IS DO PASS AS A MINUTE TO
02:23:32.603 --> 02:23:34.138
UTILITIES AND ENERGY LACKEY NOT
02:23:34.205 --> 02:23:37.175
VOTING LUCKY, NOT VOTING. FINAL
02:23:37.241 --> 02:23:43.848
VOTE IS 61. AS WE ATE 52 DOT THE
02:23:43.915 --> 02:23:46.484
ACTION IS DO PASS AND NATURAL
02:23:46.551 --> 02:23:49.053
RESOURCES LACKEY. NO FINAL VOTE
02:23:49.120 --> 02:23:57.862
IS 52. NOW SIX TO I'M SORRY. S
02:23:57.929 --> 02:24:00.631
39 32 PORTANTINO. THE ACCIDENTS
02:24:00.698 --> 02:24:02.166
DO PASS AS A MINUTE TO
02:24:02.233 --> 02:24:06.637
TRANSPORTATION. NO. THE FINAL
02:24:06.704 --> 02:24:08.973
VOTE. BLACK IS NO FINAL VOTE IS
02:24:09.040 --> 02:24:16.914
62. AS WE 991 NEWMAN. THE
02:24:16.981 --> 02:24:18.182
ACTIONS DO PASSES HAVE BEEN INTO
02:24:18.249 --> 02:24:21.019
APPROPRIATION. BLACKIE. TEST FOR
02:24:21.085 --> 02:24:24.722
SURPRISES. YES. BLACKY YES. THE
02:24:24.789 --> 02:24:32.663
FINAL VOTE IS 80. SP 12 14 JONES
02:24:32.730 --> 02:24:34.599
. THE ACTION IS DUE PASTOR
02:24:34.665 --> 02:24:38.503
JUDICIARY. LACKEY THIS IS 12 14
02:24:38.569 --> 02:24:40.772
. CORRECT CORRECT? YES YES. THE
02:24:40.838 --> 02:24:45.943
FINAL VOTE IS 80. SP 12 26
02:24:46.010 --> 02:24:47.478
TERRAZZO. THE ACTION IS DO PASS
02:24:47.545 --> 02:24:51.449
THE TRANSPORTATION BLACKIE. NO
02:24:51.516 --> 02:24:57.822
NO FINAL VOTE IS 62. SB 12 91
02:24:57.889 --> 02:24:59.857
ARCHULETTA THEY ACTUALLY DO PASS
02:24:59.924 --> 02:25:02.226
AS A MINUTE TO TRANSPORTATION.
02:25:02.293 --> 02:25:04.762
BLACKY YES, YES. FINAL VOTE IS
02:25:04.829 --> 02:25:11.069
80. SB 13 33 KAMLAGER. THE
02:25:11.135 --> 02:25:12.804
ACTIONS DO PASS US A MINUTE TO
02:25:12.870 --> 02:25:14.372
HOUSING AND COMMUNITY
02:25:14.439 --> 02:25:16.607
DEVELOPMENT. LACKEY VOTING
02:25:16.674 --> 02:25:22.180
VOTING FINAL VOTE IS 70. SB 1100
02:25:22.246 --> 02:25:27.518
CORTEZ E. THE ACTION IS DUE.
02:25:27.585 --> 02:25:32.657
PASTOR JUDICIARY LACKEY. NO, UH,
02:25:32.723 --> 02:25:34.759
LIKE TO SAY ON THAT ONE, BUT
02:25:34.826 --> 02:25:37.762
THAT'S OKAY. LUCKY NO FINAL VOTE
02:25:37.829 --> 02:25:46.170
IS 62. AND SP 14 25 STERNE. THE
02:25:46.237 --> 02:25:47.705
ACCIDENTS DO PASS TO
02:25:47.772 --> 02:25:50.575
APPROPRIATION BLACKIE BOARDING
02:25:50.641 --> 02:25:55.613
VOTING. FINAL VOTE IS 61. IT WAS
02:25:55.680 --> 02:25:57.949
GOOD. OKAY THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
02:25:58.015 --> 02:26:00.084
VERY TO MAKE YOUR WAY. WE
02:26:00.151 --> 02:26:01.652
UNDERSTAND, UM LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
02:26:01.719 --> 02:26:16.734
ADJOURNS.