WEBVTT
00:29:06.010 --> 00:29:09.347
READY TO GO, MR VICE CHAIR. HEY,
00:29:09.414 --> 00:29:13.785
MAN. OKAY WELCOME TO THE
00:29:13.852 --> 00:29:15.453
ASSEMBLY LOCAL GOVERNMENT
00:29:15.520 --> 00:29:17.188
COMMITTEE HEARING. I'D LIKE TO
00:29:17.255 --> 00:29:18.623
REMIND THE PUBLIC THAT FOR THIS
00:29:18.690 --> 00:29:19.958
AND FUTURE HEARINGS, TESTIMONY
00:29:20.024 --> 00:29:21.593
WILL BE IN PERSON AS WE'RE NO
00:29:21.659 --> 00:29:22.694
LONGER USING THE MODERATED
00:29:22.760 --> 00:29:24.462
TELEPHONE SERVICE. WE ALSO
00:29:24.529 --> 00:29:25.663
ACCEPT WRITTEN TESTIMONY THROUGH
00:29:25.730 --> 00:29:27.532
THE POSITION LETTER PORTAL. AND
00:29:27.599 --> 00:29:30.702
THE COMMITTEE'S WEBSITE. OKAY
00:29:30.768 --> 00:29:31.569
AND HERE ARE SOME QUICK GROUND
00:29:31.636 --> 00:29:33.738
RULES FOR APPROPRIATE CONDUCT.
00:29:33.805 --> 00:29:34.772
THE ASSEMBLY HAS EXPERIENCED A
00:29:34.839 --> 00:29:35.874
NUMBER OF DISRUPTIONS TO THE
00:29:35.940 --> 00:29:36.808
COMMITTEE. AND FOUR PROCEEDINGS
00:29:36.875 --> 00:29:40.845
IN THE LAST FEW YEARS. AH
00:29:40.912 --> 00:29:42.313
CONDUCT THAT DISRUPTS, DISTURBS
00:29:42.380 --> 00:29:44.315
OR OTHERWISE IMPEDES ORDERLY
00:29:44.382 --> 00:29:44.849
CONDUCT OF THE HEARING IS
00:29:44.916 --> 00:29:46.117
PROHIBITED. SUCH ORDER MAY
00:29:46.184 --> 00:29:48.453
INCLUDE TALKING OR MAKING LOUD
00:29:48.520 --> 00:29:49.454
NOISES FROM THE AUDIENCE
00:29:49.521 --> 00:29:52.090
ENTERING LOUD THREATENING OR
00:29:52.157 --> 00:29:53.091
ABUSIVE LANGUAGE SPEAKING LONGER
00:29:53.158 --> 00:29:55.927
THAN THE TIME ALLOTTED. WHAT
00:29:55.994 --> 00:29:58.363
KIND OF SOFT ON THAT ONE
00:29:58.429 --> 00:29:59.631
ETENDED DISCUSSION OF MATTERS
00:29:59.697 --> 00:30:01.499
NOT RELATED TO THE SUBJECT OF
00:30:01.566 --> 00:30:03.501
THE HEARING OR BILL. ARE ANY
00:30:03.568 --> 00:30:05.570
OTHER DISRUPTIVE ACTS TO ADDRESS
00:30:05.637 --> 00:30:07.172
ANY DISRUPTIVE CONDUCT? I'LL
00:30:07.238 --> 00:30:08.873
TAKE THE FOLLOWING STEPS OF AN
00:30:08.940 --> 00:30:09.674
INDIVIDUAL DISRUPTS OUR HEARING
00:30:09.741 --> 00:30:11.042
PROCESS. I'LL DIRECT THEM TO
00:30:11.109 --> 00:30:12.977
STOP AND MORE OF THEM THAT
00:30:13.044 --> 00:30:14.179
CONTINUED DISRUPTIONS MAY RESULT
00:30:14.245 --> 00:30:15.780
IN REMOVAL FROM THE CAPITOL
00:30:15.847 --> 00:30:17.315
BUILDING. I'LL ALSO DOCUMENT ON
00:30:17.382 --> 00:30:18.516
THE RECORD THAT THE INDIVIDUAL
00:30:18.583 --> 00:30:20.084
INVOLVED AND THE NATURE OF THE
00:30:20.151 --> 00:30:22.954
DISRUPTIVE CONDUCT. I MADE
00:30:23.021 --> 00:30:24.656
TEMPORARILY RECESS. THE HEARING
00:30:24.722 --> 00:30:26.457
AND THE CONDUCT DOES NOT STOP
00:30:26.524 --> 00:30:28.159
OUR REQUEST THE ASSISTANCE OF
00:30:28.226 --> 00:30:29.360
THE SERGEANTS AND ESCORTING THE
00:30:29.427 --> 00:30:30.295
INDIVIDUAL FROM THE HEARING
00:30:30.361 --> 00:30:32.430
ROOM. OKAY WE HAVE NINE AND NINE
00:30:32.497 --> 00:30:34.532
ITEMS ON THE AGENDA TODAY. ONE
00:30:34.599 --> 00:30:35.633
OF THOSE ITEMS IS PROPOSED FOR
00:30:35.700 --> 00:30:39.237
CONSENT ITEM NINE. SB 14 89 BY
00:30:39.304 --> 00:30:40.238
THE GOVERNANCE OF FINANCE
00:30:40.305 --> 00:30:42.707
COMMITTEE. WE'LL HEAR ALL OTHER
00:30:42.774 --> 00:30:44.642
BILLS IN THE ORDER SHOWN ON THE
00:30:44.709 --> 00:30:45.843
AGENDA UNLESS OTHERWISE NOTED.
00:30:45.910 --> 00:30:47.345
WILL TAKE UP TO PRIMARY
00:30:47.412 --> 00:30:48.646
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT AND UP TO
00:30:48.713 --> 00:30:49.847
TWO PRIMARY WITNESSES. AN
00:30:49.914 --> 00:30:52.317
OPPOSITION FOR EACH BILL. THESE
00:30:52.383 --> 00:30:53.351
WITNESSES WILL HAVE THREE
00:30:53.418 --> 00:30:54.452
MINUTES EACH TO PROVIDE THEIR
00:30:54.519 --> 00:30:56.721
TESTIMONY. ALL SUBSEQUENT
00:30:56.788 --> 00:30:58.056
WITNESSES SHOULD STATE THEIR
00:30:58.122 --> 00:31:00.391
NAME, THEIR ORGANIZATION AND
00:31:00.458 --> 00:31:01.459
THEIR POSITION ON THE BILL. ONLY
00:31:01.526 --> 00:31:02.827
IN ADDITION, ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
00:31:02.894 --> 00:31:04.829
SANTIAGO WILL BE SITTING IN FOR
00:31:04.896 --> 00:31:05.430
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S ROBERT REVIS
00:31:05.496 --> 00:31:08.833
FOR TODAY'S HEARING. YEAH. I
00:31:08.900 --> 00:31:10.501
DON'T SEE HIM HERE, BUT I'M SURE
00:31:10.568 --> 00:31:12.470
HE'LL COME HERE EVENTUALLY. AND
00:31:12.537 --> 00:31:13.838
OUR FIRST BILL ON TODAY'S AGENDA
00:31:13.905 --> 00:31:16.407
IS SB. 8 91 BY SENATOR HERZBERG.
00:31:16.474 --> 00:31:18.309
YOU MAY PROCEED IF YOU'RE READY.
00:31:18.376 --> 00:31:20.011
MR CHAIRMAN. THANK YOU SO VERY
00:31:20.078 --> 00:31:21.980
MUCH. YOU'RE LOOKING VERY GOOD
00:31:22.046 --> 00:31:22.947
TODAY. THANK YOU. INSPIRING,
00:31:23.014 --> 00:31:27.619
INSPIRING. TALKING TO HIM. MY
00:31:27.685 --> 00:31:29.087
AIRPLANE PARTNER, ER, IT'S GOOD.
00:31:29.153 --> 00:31:34.325
SO, UM LET'S START WITH THIS 0.1
00:31:34.392 --> 00:31:36.828
OF THE THINGS THAT WE DO IN THIS
00:31:36.894 --> 00:31:37.729
JOB HERE IN THE LEGISLATURE IS
00:31:37.795 --> 00:31:39.831
TO MAKE SURE THAT THE LAWS WE
00:31:39.897 --> 00:31:40.999
WRITE, ACTUALLY DO WHAT THEY'RE
00:31:41.065 --> 00:31:42.934
SUPPOSED TO DO. THAT THEY ARE
00:31:43.001 --> 00:31:43.701
ENFORCED IN THE APPROPRIATE WAY
00:31:43.768 --> 00:31:44.902
, OR THEY ACHIEVED THE
00:31:44.969 --> 00:31:47.305
APPROPRIATE RESULTS IN 2000 AND
00:31:47.372 --> 00:31:50.942
19. I CARRIED A MEASURE SB TWO.
00:31:51.009 --> 00:31:52.810
OH THREE, WHICH DEALT WITH THE
00:31:52.877 --> 00:31:53.945
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT UNDER THE
00:31:54.012 --> 00:31:55.813
FEDERAL CLEAN WATER ACT.
00:31:55.880 --> 00:31:57.415
PROHIBITS ENTITIES FROM
00:31:57.482 --> 00:31:59.817
DISCHARGING ANY POLLUTANTS FROM
00:31:59.884 --> 00:32:01.986
A POINT SOURCE IN U. S WATERS
00:32:02.053 --> 00:32:05.823
INTO THE OCEAN. AND SO WHAT WE
00:32:05.890 --> 00:32:08.693
DID BACK THEN WAS WE CREATED A
00:32:08.760 --> 00:32:10.461
PROCESS WHERE WE SAID OKAY. WE
00:32:10.528 --> 00:32:11.763
HAD A TREMENDOUS NUMBER OF
00:32:11.829 --> 00:32:12.730
ENTITIES THAT WEREN'T
00:32:12.797 --> 00:32:15.466
REGISTERING. AND ALTHOUGH
00:32:15.533 --> 00:32:16.434
THERE'S A DROUGHT THERE'S STILL
00:32:16.501 --> 00:32:19.070
IS AND PARTICULARLY A
00:32:19.137 --> 00:32:20.038
SIGNIFICANT CHALLENGE WITH
00:32:20.104 --> 00:32:22.106
RESPECT TO STORMWATER RUNOFF.
00:32:22.173 --> 00:32:24.475
95% OF ALL CALIFORNIA WATERWAYS
00:32:24.542 --> 00:32:25.376
ARE CONSIDERED IMPAIR OR
00:32:25.443 --> 00:32:26.944
IMPAIRED OR HIGHLY POLLUTED, AND
00:32:27.011 --> 00:32:27.979
THAT'S ACTUALLY GETTING WORSE
00:32:28.046 --> 00:32:30.048
WHEN THERE'S LESS WATER. FIRST
00:32:30.114 --> 00:32:32.317
SERIES OF OBVIOUS REASONS. AND
00:32:32.383 --> 00:32:34.052
SO WHAT WE'RE DOING IN THIS WHAT
00:32:34.118 --> 00:32:36.721
WE DID IN 2000 AND 19. WE SAID
00:32:36.788 --> 00:32:38.589
LOOK, WHEN YOU FILL OUT YOUR
00:32:38.656 --> 00:32:39.223
BUSINESS LICENSE, JUST WE WANT
00:32:39.290 --> 00:32:41.225
YOU TO CHECK A BOX AND SHOW THAT
00:32:41.292 --> 00:32:42.927
YOU'VE COMPLIED. AND WE WERE
00:32:42.994 --> 00:32:44.662
ABLE TO GET A PRETTY SUBSTANTIAL
00:32:44.729 --> 00:32:45.997
RESPONSEAS A RESULT OF THAT,
00:32:46.064 --> 00:32:47.298
BUT SOME JURISDICTIONS SAID,
00:32:47.365 --> 00:32:48.966
WELL, WE DON'T HAVE BUSINESS
00:32:49.033 --> 00:32:50.034
LICENSES WE'VE GOT. WHAT WERE
00:32:50.101 --> 00:32:52.070
THEY CALLED BUSINESS
00:32:52.136 --> 00:32:53.204
CERTIFICATES, AND THE LAW
00:32:53.271 --> 00:32:54.605
DOESN'T SAY CERTIFICATES INTO
00:32:54.672 --> 00:32:58.142
THAT WE SAY WE'RE BACK. WE AIN'T
00:32:58.209 --> 00:32:59.544
LETTING YOU SLIP THROUGH THE
00:32:59.610 --> 00:33:01.446
CRACKS. THERE HAS BEEN QUITE
00:33:01.512 --> 00:33:03.414
EFFECTIVE IMPACT AS A RESULT OF
00:33:03.481 --> 00:33:05.616
WHAT WE'VE DONE, BUT THE BUT BUT
00:33:05.683 --> 00:33:09.821
THIS IS IMPORTANT. THE THIS IS
00:33:09.887 --> 00:33:12.824
AN ISSUE THAT, UM, IS NOT A BIG
00:33:12.890 --> 00:33:14.859
IMPOSITION ON BUSINESSES, BUT WE
00:33:14.926 --> 00:33:16.728
HAVE TO MAKE SURE THAT THEY
00:33:16.794 --> 00:33:17.762
COMPLY WITH THESE INDUSTRIAL
00:33:17.829 --> 00:33:18.796
FACILITIES THAT THEY GET THEIR
00:33:18.863 --> 00:33:20.832
INDUSTRIAL GENERAL PERMIT. TO
00:33:20.898 --> 00:33:22.200
COMPLY WITH THIS THE FEDERAL
00:33:22.266 --> 00:33:23.968
STANDARDS AND SO WITH THAT I'VE
00:33:24.035 --> 00:33:25.970
GOT A WITNESS HERE. I CAN TALK
00:33:26.037 --> 00:33:27.472
MORE, BUT I DON'T THINK I NEED
00:33:27.538 --> 00:33:29.040
TO CODY PHILLIPS OF THE
00:33:29.107 --> 00:33:30.007
CALIFORNIA COAST KEEPER ALLIANCE
00:33:30.074 --> 00:33:31.843
WHO HAS BEEN WITH US FOR THE
00:33:31.909 --> 00:33:33.845
LAST MANY YEARS. ENGAGED IN THIS
00:33:33.911 --> 00:33:35.480
ENDEAVOR, AND HE'S STILL FIGHTS
00:33:35.546 --> 00:33:37.715
THE FIGHT. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:33:37.782 --> 00:33:40.952
YOU MAY PROCEED, SIR. GOOD
00:33:41.018 --> 00:33:42.453
AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS CODY
00:33:42.520 --> 00:33:43.354
PHILLIPS FROM CALIFORNIA COAST
00:33:43.421 --> 00:33:45.456
KEEPER ALLIANCE. AS THE SENATOR
00:33:45.523 --> 00:33:47.558
EXPLAINED, WE PASSED SB 205
00:33:47.625 --> 00:33:49.360
SEVERAL YEARS AGO TO CREATE AN
00:33:49.427 --> 00:33:50.862
ELEGANT SOLUTION TO THE PROBLEM
00:33:50.928 --> 00:33:51.629
OF INDUSTRIAL FACILITIES, NOT
00:33:51.696 --> 00:33:52.663
ENROLLING IN THE INDUSTRIAL
00:33:52.730 --> 00:33:53.998
STORMWATER PERMIT. AS REQUIRED
00:33:54.065 --> 00:33:57.034
BY LAW. S P. 205 WAS A
00:33:57.101 --> 00:33:58.469
BIPARTISAN BILL WITH THE
00:33:58.536 --> 00:33:59.937
REGULATED COMMUNITY SUPPORT
00:34:00.004 --> 00:34:01.472
BECAUSE THE BILL CREATED AN EVEN
00:34:01.539 --> 00:34:03.274
PLAYING FIELD FOR ALL INDUSTRIAL
00:34:03.341 --> 00:34:05.843
FACILITIES, AND THE BILL IS
00:34:05.910 --> 00:34:07.345
WORKING TODAY. WE BELIEVE AT
00:34:07.412 --> 00:34:09.213
LEAST HALF OF ALL THE NINE NON
00:34:09.280 --> 00:34:10.815
FILERS IN THE STATE HAVE NOW
00:34:10.882 --> 00:34:11.983
PROPERLY ENROLLED IN THE
00:34:12.049 --> 00:34:13.084
STORMWATER PERMIT AND ON THEIR
00:34:13.151 --> 00:34:15.052
WAY TO COMPLIANCE. HOWEVER SINCE
00:34:15.119 --> 00:34:15.820
THE BILL WAS IMPLEMENTED, WE
00:34:15.887 --> 00:34:17.355
HAVE SEEN A FEW PARTIES
00:34:17.422 --> 00:34:18.556
ATTEMPTING TO AVOID COMPLIANCE
00:34:18.623 --> 00:34:21.592
AND SB 8 91 IS INTENDED TO CLOSE
00:34:21.659 --> 00:34:23.961
THOSE LOOPHOLES. IT DOES IT IN
00:34:24.028 --> 00:34:25.463
THREE WAYS. FIRST SP A. 91
00:34:25.530 --> 00:34:27.198
CLARIFIES THAT THE ORIGINAL
00:34:27.265 --> 00:34:28.966
INTENT ALL BUSINESS
00:34:29.033 --> 00:34:32.136
LICENSE LIKE ACTIVITIES. AS THE
00:34:32.203 --> 00:34:33.004
SENATOR WAS SAYING, THERE ARE
00:34:33.070 --> 00:34:34.739
CERTAIN CITIES AND MAJOR CITIES
00:34:34.806 --> 00:34:36.641
LIKE SAN DIEGO, LOS ANGELES AND
00:34:36.707 --> 00:34:38.709
SAN JOSE THAT HAVE BUSINESS
00:34:38.776 --> 00:34:40.211
CERTIFICATES AND NOT BUSINESS
00:34:40.278 --> 00:34:41.913
LICENSES. THESE ARE ESSENTIALLY
00:34:41.979 --> 00:34:43.681
THE SAME PROCESS, BUT THOSE
00:34:43.748 --> 00:34:44.715
CITIES CLAIM THAT THEIR
00:34:44.782 --> 00:34:45.716
CERTIFICATE IS MERELY FOR
00:34:45.783 --> 00:34:47.118
COLLECTING REVENUE. THAT WAS THE
00:34:47.185 --> 00:34:48.820
SAME ARGUMENT WE HEARD DURING
00:34:48.886 --> 00:34:52.056
THE LAST TIME. UM AND THE OLD
00:34:52.123 --> 00:34:53.724
BILL WAS INTENDED TO APPLY TO
00:34:53.791 --> 00:34:54.992
ALL APPROVALS TO DO BUSINESS IN
00:34:55.059 --> 00:34:56.761
THE REGION. AND THIS JUST CLOSES
00:34:56.828 --> 00:34:58.696
THAT LOOPHOLE. SECOND WE NOTICED
00:34:58.763 --> 00:34:59.430
THAT CERTAIN INDUSTRIAL
00:34:59.497 --> 00:35:00.431
FACILITIES WERE RECEIVING
00:35:00.498 --> 00:35:01.666
BUSINESS LICENSES WITHOUT
00:35:01.732 --> 00:35:03.067
GETTING THE PROPER STORMWATER
00:35:03.134 --> 00:35:05.536
PERMIT COVERAGE. LOCAL NGOS HAVE
00:35:05.603 --> 00:35:06.737
ATTEMPTED TO GET THE INFORMATION
00:35:06.804 --> 00:35:08.473
THAT WAS FILED IN THOSE BUSINESS
00:35:08.539 --> 00:35:09.540
LICENSES, BUT THE LOCAL
00:35:09.607 --> 00:35:10.708
GOVERNMENTS HAVE BEEN UNWILLING
00:35:10.775 --> 00:35:11.742
TO SHARE THOSE APPLICATION
00:35:11.809 --> 00:35:14.145
DETAILS. SB 8 91 ALLOWS THE
00:35:14.212 --> 00:35:15.713
PUBLIC TO OBTAIN CERTAIN
00:35:15.780 --> 00:35:16.581
INFORMATION AND, MOST
00:35:16.647 --> 00:35:17.448
IMPORTANTLY, THE STORMWATER
00:35:17.515 --> 00:35:19.584
PERMIT IDENTIFICATION NUMBER SO
00:35:19.650 --> 00:35:20.685
THAT WE CAN CROSS REFERENCE THE
00:35:20.751 --> 00:35:23.321
INFORMATION WITH WHAT THE STATE
00:35:23.387 --> 00:35:24.188
WATER BOARD HAS IN ORDER TO
00:35:24.255 --> 00:35:26.057
VERIFY THE ACCURACY. FINALLY SPN
00:35:26.123 --> 00:35:28.025
91 REQUIRES NEW PERMIT FEES TO
00:35:28.092 --> 00:35:29.494
BE USED FOR SITE INSPECTIONS.
00:35:29.560 --> 00:35:31.496
WE'VE NOTICED A LOT OF NEW
00:35:31.562 --> 00:35:32.497
ENROLLEES, CLAIMING THAT THEY
00:35:32.563 --> 00:35:33.831
ARE EXEMPT FROM THE STORMWATER
00:35:33.898 --> 00:35:36.000
PERMIT AND SB 8 91 WOULD PROVIDE
00:35:36.067 --> 00:35:38.202
SOME GROUND TRUTH THING IN ORDER
00:35:38.269 --> 00:35:39.370
TO VERIFY THAT THOSE EXEMPT
00:35:39.437 --> 00:35:40.304
FACILITIES ARE TRULY NOT
00:35:40.371 --> 00:35:42.039
DISCHARGING STORM WATER. THANK
00:35:42.106 --> 00:35:43.341
YOU, AND WE RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
00:35:43.407 --> 00:35:46.177
YOUR VOTE ON THIS. OKAY THANK
00:35:46.244 --> 00:35:47.578
YOU VERY MUCH. DO WE HAVE
00:35:47.645 --> 00:35:49.247
ANYBODY ELSE IN THE ROOM THAT
00:35:49.313 --> 00:35:50.381
WOULD LIKE TO EXPRESS THEIR
00:35:50.448 --> 00:35:53.050
SUPPORT FOR SENATE BILL 8 91.
00:35:53.117 --> 00:35:58.089
SAYING NONE. DO WE HAVE ANY
00:35:58.155 --> 00:35:59.423
WITNESSES AND OPPOSITION THAT
00:35:59.490 --> 00:36:01.692
WOULD LIKE TO EXPRESS THEIR LACK
00:36:01.759 --> 00:36:03.828
OF SUPPORT FOR THIS MEASURE
00:36:03.895 --> 00:36:04.595
POINT OF PERSONAL PRIVILEGE WITH
00:36:04.662 --> 00:36:06.731
896,000 PEOPLE ON THE PHONE
00:36:06.797 --> 00:36:07.732
LINES, WHICH WOULD HAVE COME
00:36:07.798 --> 00:36:09.800
THROUGH IN THE SENATE CAUSE. BUT
00:36:09.867 --> 00:36:11.302
SINCE YOU DON'T LOVE PHONE LINES
00:36:11.369 --> 00:36:12.436
ANYMORE, WE'RE JUST GOING TO
00:36:12.503 --> 00:36:13.604
SEND IN LETTERS OF SUPPORT.
00:36:13.671 --> 00:36:18.109
THANK YOU. OKAY? POINT WELL
00:36:18.175 --> 00:36:23.414
TAKEN. ALL RIGHT. UH IS THERE
00:36:23.481 --> 00:36:24.982
ANYBODY WHO WOULD LIKE TO
00:36:25.049 --> 00:36:26.017
EXPRESS OPPOSITION AT ALL IN
00:36:26.083 --> 00:36:29.420
THIS ROOM? SAYING NONE. DO WE
00:36:29.487 --> 00:36:32.256
HAVE ANY COMMENTS? FROM THE
00:36:32.323 --> 00:36:38.796
BENCH UP HERE. THAT'S A BENCH.
00:36:38.863 --> 00:36:44.702
OKAY? SAYING NINE YOU'RE FREE TO
00:36:44.769 --> 00:36:45.603
CLOSE CENTER. THANK YOU VERY
00:36:45.670 --> 00:36:47.838
MUCH, AND I JUST WANT TO KNOW
00:36:47.905 --> 00:36:49.840
THAT THERE WAS AN EXEMPTION FOR
00:36:49.907 --> 00:36:51.142
THE PEOPLE OF SANTA MONICA. BUT
00:36:51.208 --> 00:36:53.010
WE TOOK THAT OUT BECAUSE WE WANT
00:36:53.077 --> 00:36:53.544
TO MAKE SURE THAT THEY ARE
00:36:53.611 --> 00:36:54.679
PROTECTED AS WELL. IT'S
00:36:54.745 --> 00:36:56.414
CRITICALLY IMPORTANT, BUT WITH
00:36:56.480 --> 00:36:57.949
THAT EXTRA IPHONES ALL RIGHT.
00:36:58.015 --> 00:36:58.983
THAT'S RIGHT. THAT'S WHAT I
00:36:59.050 --> 00:37:03.054
MENTIONED IT. VERY FUNNY. THANK
00:37:03.120 --> 00:37:04.655
YOU SO MUCH. WE APPRECIATE THAT
00:37:04.722 --> 00:37:05.556
. WE'RE CURRENTLY IN
00:37:05.623 --> 00:37:08.659
SUBCOMMITTEE. FASHION RIGHT NOW,
00:37:08.726 --> 00:37:11.162
SO WE'RE NOT ABLE TO TAKE ANY
00:37:11.228 --> 00:37:13.331
OTHER ACTION. SOONER WIECKOWSKI
00:37:13.397 --> 00:37:14.865
. IT'S YOUR OPPORTUNITY NOW TO
00:37:14.932 --> 00:37:17.935
PRESENT SENATE BILL 8 97 CHAIR
00:37:18.002 --> 00:37:20.071
LACKEY TO START LET ME ACCEPT
00:37:20.137 --> 00:37:22.139
ALL THEAMENDMENTS LAID OUT BY
00:37:22.206 --> 00:37:24.041
THE COMMITTEE IN THE ANALYSIS.
00:37:24.108 --> 00:37:28.045
UM SP 897 BUILDS ON PREVIOUS EU
00:37:28.112 --> 00:37:30.314
LEGISLATION THAT
00:37:30.381 --> 00:37:31.749
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BLOOM, AND I
00:37:31.816 --> 00:37:33.417
AND OTHERS HAVE WORKED ON OVER
00:37:33.484 --> 00:37:35.953
THE LAST SIX YEARS TO ADDRESSING
00:37:36.020 --> 00:37:37.788
SOME OF THE ENDURING BARRIERS TO
00:37:37.855 --> 00:37:38.956
80 YOU CONSTRUCTION MUCH OF THE
00:37:39.023 --> 00:37:42.426
BILL, IN FACT, ALL OF THE BILL.
00:37:42.493 --> 00:37:44.962
UH SURROUNDS FEEDBACK THAT MY
00:37:45.029 --> 00:37:47.999
OFFICE AND THE H C D HAS
00:37:48.065 --> 00:37:48.599
RECEIVED OVER THE YEARS FROM
00:37:48.666 --> 00:37:50.034
ACTUAL HOMEOWNERS. CONSTITUENTS
00:37:50.101 --> 00:37:52.937
OF OURS WHO ARE FACING OBSTACLES
00:37:53.004 --> 00:37:54.705
AND HAVING THEIR DESIRES TO HAVE
00:37:54.772 --> 00:37:59.510
A D YOU SUPPRESSED 80 US AS WE
00:37:59.577 --> 00:38:01.345
KNOW, ALLOW HOMEOWNERS, LOTS OF
00:38:01.412 --> 00:38:03.447
FREEDOM AND BETTER USE OF THEIR
00:38:03.514 --> 00:38:04.315
PROPERTY THAT PROVIDES
00:38:04.382 --> 00:38:05.816
ADDITIONAL AND GENERALLY
00:38:05.883 --> 00:38:09.053
AFFORDABLE RENTAL. UH
00:38:09.120 --> 00:38:10.688
OPPORTUNITIES FOR PEOPLE IN THE
00:38:10.755 --> 00:38:12.089
COMMUNITY AND IT ALSO VERY
00:38:12.156 --> 00:38:13.791
IMPORTANTLY, WE DON'T NORMALLY
00:38:13.858 --> 00:38:15.593
STRESS THIS, BUT IT HELPS PEOPLE
00:38:15.660 --> 00:38:16.927
BUILD WEALTH IN THE COMMUNITIES
00:38:16.994 --> 00:38:19.163
. A LOT OF PEOPL AREN'T ABLE TO
00:38:19.230 --> 00:38:20.965
DO THAT, OR JUST DIDN'T EXIST.
00:38:21.032 --> 00:38:22.967
IT ALSO HELPS OUT LUKE
00:38:23.034 --> 00:38:24.568
LOCALITIES FROM ACROSS THE STATE
00:38:24.635 --> 00:38:26.103
. THE LOT OF LOCALITIES ARE
00:38:26.170 --> 00:38:27.672
CHALLENGED BY READING THEIR
00:38:27.738 --> 00:38:29.940
MEETING THEIR REGIONAL HOUSING
00:38:30.007 --> 00:38:31.676
NEEDS, AND 80 US REPRESENT AN
00:38:31.742 --> 00:38:32.677
INSTRUMENT FOR THE STATE'S
00:38:32.743 --> 00:38:36.180
HOUSING PRODUCTION. THIS BILL
00:38:36.247 --> 00:38:38.816
897 ADDRESSES THE ISSUE OF UN
00:38:38.883 --> 00:38:39.950
PERMITTED TO USE THE BILL WOULD
00:38:40.017 --> 00:38:41.085
PROHIBIT LOCAL AGENCY FROM
00:38:41.152 --> 00:38:43.354
DENYING A PERMIT FOR UNPERMITTED
00:38:43.421 --> 00:38:45.289
80 YOU BUILT BEFORE? UH, 2000
00:38:45.356 --> 00:38:48.225
AND 18. UNLESS THERE'S A HEALTH
00:38:48.292 --> 00:38:49.660
AND SAFETY VIOLATION. WE WE'VE
00:38:49.727 --> 00:38:51.295
HAD THAT IN THERE, BUT WE DON'T
00:38:51.362 --> 00:38:52.797
WANT PEOPLE TO KEEP MOVING THE
00:38:52.863 --> 00:38:54.999
LINE. SO WE SAID IN 2000, SINCE
00:38:55.066 --> 00:38:57.435
WE DID PASS, A LOT OF BILLS IN
00:38:57.501 --> 00:38:58.703
2016 GAVE ONE YEAR AS LONG AS
00:38:58.769 --> 00:38:59.937
THE CITY'S COMPLYING WITH STATE
00:39:00.004 --> 00:39:01.772
LAW. THERE'S A STREAMLINING OF
00:39:01.839 --> 00:39:03.207
PERMITTING AND CONSTRUCTION
00:39:03.274 --> 00:39:05.443
PROCESSES. IT ALLOWS THESE UNITS
00:39:05.509 --> 00:39:07.311
AND HOMEOWNERS TO PROVIDE THESE
00:39:07.378 --> 00:39:08.312
HOUSING OPTION TO SAY, LOOK
00:39:08.379 --> 00:39:09.947
FORWARD TO SO WITH THIS
00:39:10.014 --> 00:39:11.348
ADDRESSES SOME OF THE BARRIERS.
00:39:11.415 --> 00:39:12.850
SOME OF THE MEMBER MEASURES HAVE
00:39:12.917 --> 00:39:15.686
BEEN TAKEN OUT OF THE BILL. BUT
00:39:15.753 --> 00:39:16.353
THESE ARE THE IDENTIFICATION
00:39:16.420 --> 00:39:17.655
WITH ME. I HAVE ALEX TORRES WITH
00:39:17.722 --> 00:39:22.326
THE BIG AREA COUNCIL. AND LOUIS
00:39:22.393 --> 00:39:23.427
GUARANTEE WITH THE CALIFORNIA MP
00:39:23.494 --> 00:39:25.496
IN SUPPORT OF THE MEASURE. YOU
00:39:25.563 --> 00:39:28.432
MAY PROCEED. THANK YOU. VICE
00:39:28.499 --> 00:39:29.467
CHAIR AND MEMBERS. ALEX TORRES,
00:39:29.533 --> 00:39:30.768
DIRECTOR OF STATE GOVERNMENT
00:39:30.835 --> 00:39:31.635
RELATIONS WITH THE BAY AREA
00:39:31.702 --> 00:39:33.871
COUNCIL HERE TODAY AS A PROUD
00:39:33.938 --> 00:39:35.339
SPONSOR ALONGSIDE OUR FRIENDS AT
00:39:35.406 --> 00:39:37.475
CALIFORNIA. UM BE THE VERY
00:39:37.541 --> 00:39:39.043
COUNCILS, AN EMPLOYER SPONSORED
00:39:39.110 --> 00:39:39.844
PUBLIC POLICY AND ADVOCACY
00:39:39.910 --> 00:39:41.345
ORGANIZATION REPRESENTING ABOUT
00:39:41.412 --> 00:39:42.580
300 OF THE LARGEST EMPLOYERS,
00:39:42.646 --> 00:39:43.547
LARGEST COMPANIES IN THE BAY
00:39:43.614 --> 00:39:47.084
AREA. THE SENATOR ALLUDED TO THE
00:39:47.151 --> 00:39:48.753
FEEDBACK FROM CONSTITUENTS ON
00:39:48.819 --> 00:39:50.888
BARRIERS TO DO CONSTRUCTION OF
00:39:50.955 --> 00:39:52.423
HERE TO GIVE SOME OF THE
00:39:52.490 --> 00:39:53.958
BUSINESS PERSPECTIVE ON THAT
00:39:54.024 --> 00:39:55.493
EACH AND EVERY YEAR FOR THE LAST
00:39:55.559 --> 00:39:57.328
DECADE AND MORE ARE MEMBERS HAVE
00:39:57.394 --> 00:39:59.897
TOLD US THAT THE LACK OF
00:39:59.964 --> 00:40:00.498
AVAILABILITY AND HIGH COST OF
00:40:00.564 --> 00:40:01.332
HOUSING IS THE PRINCIPAL REASON
00:40:01.398 --> 00:40:02.800
WHY THEY'RE NOT HIRING IN THE
00:40:02.867 --> 00:40:03.634
STATE. GROWING IN THE STATE AND
00:40:03.701 --> 00:40:05.903
EVEN IN SOME OF THIS IS OPTING
00:40:05.970 --> 00:40:06.837
TO RELOCATE TO OTHER STATES
00:40:06.904 --> 00:40:08.739
COMPLETELY, UM GOES WITHOUT
00:40:08.806 --> 00:40:09.440
SAYING WE'RE ALL AWARE OF HE
00:40:09.507 --> 00:40:11.842
CRISIS POSES A DIRE RISK TO OUR
00:40:11.909 --> 00:40:12.843
STATE'S ECONOMIC, HEALTH AND
00:40:12.910 --> 00:40:14.078
QUALITY OF LIFE. THE HOUSING
00:40:14.145 --> 00:40:15.513
CRISIS IS MANIFESTED ITSELF. IN
00:40:15.579 --> 00:40:17.715
MANY WAYS, WE HAVE A HOMELESS
00:40:17.782 --> 00:40:18.949
EPIDEMIC IN OUR STREETS WERE
00:40:19.016 --> 00:40:19.550
LOSING LOW INCOME CALIFORNIA
00:40:19.617 --> 00:40:20.918
TOGETHER OTHER STATES AT A
00:40:20.985 --> 00:40:22.620
RECORD PACE, AND WHEN HOUSING
00:40:22.686 --> 00:40:24.155
COSTS ARE FACTORED IN, WE HAVE
00:40:24.221 --> 00:40:25.956
THE HIGHEST CHILD POVERTY RATE
00:40:26.023 --> 00:40:28.058
IN THE NATION. CLEARLY WE HAVE
00:40:28.125 --> 00:40:28.993
TAKEN A LOT OF DIFFERENT
00:40:29.059 --> 00:40:31.862
APPROACHES, BUT WE STILL HAVE
00:40:31.929 --> 00:40:33.430
YET TO FIND THAT SILVER BULLET.
00:40:33.497 --> 00:40:35.833
UM IF THERE EVEN IS ONE EXACTLY
00:40:35.900 --> 00:40:37.468
AS ACCESSORY DWELLING UNITS,
00:40:37.535 --> 00:40:39.236
HOWEVER, HAVE PROVEN TO BE A
00:40:39.303 --> 00:40:40.437
VERY EFFECTIVE STRATEGY AND THE
00:40:40.504 --> 00:40:43.073
DATA BEARS THIS OUT. WHEN THE
00:40:43.140 --> 00:40:44.809
BARRIER AREA COUNCIL FIRST
00:40:44.875 --> 00:40:46.076
WORKED WITH THE SENATOR IN 2016
00:40:46.143 --> 00:40:48.579
TO HELP PASS SB 10 69. THERE
00:40:48.646 --> 00:40:50.681
WERE LESS THAN 280 YOU PERMITS
00:40:50.748 --> 00:40:51.582
ISSUED IN THE WHOLE STATE THAT
00:40:51.649 --> 00:40:54.018
YEAR. THIS YEAR, ACCORDING TO
00:40:54.084 --> 00:40:55.019
TURNER CENTER. PREDICTIONS
00:40:55.085 --> 00:40:55.920
SUGGEST PERMITS MIGHT REACH
00:40:55.986 --> 00:40:59.490
20,000. SB 10 69 BEGAN THE
00:40:59.557 --> 00:41:01.091
PROCESS OF REMOVING THOSE
00:41:01.158 --> 00:41:02.326
IMPEDIMENTS AND BUREAUCRACY THAT
00:41:02.393 --> 00:41:03.994
WE'RE MAKING IT IMPOSSIBLE FOR
00:41:04.061 --> 00:41:04.829
CALIFORNIA HOMEOWNERS TO BUILD
00:41:04.895 --> 00:41:06.831
AN ACCESSORY HOME ON THEIR OWN
00:41:06.897 --> 00:41:07.965
PROPERTY. AND WHAT ARE SOME OF
00:41:08.032 --> 00:41:09.834
THOSE POSSIBILITIES TO HOME FOR
00:41:09.900 --> 00:41:10.601
AN AGING PARENT CHILD RETURNING
00:41:10.668 --> 00:41:11.569
FROM COLLEGE TO AN UNAFFORDABLE
00:41:11.635 --> 00:41:15.439
HOUSING MARKET? OR A UNIT THAT
00:41:15.506 --> 00:41:16.607
CAN BE RENTED TO A LOCAL
00:41:16.674 --> 00:41:18.309
TEACHER, A NURSE, A RESTAURANT
00:41:18.375 --> 00:41:19.844
SERVER. WE'VE MADE GREAT
00:41:19.910 --> 00:41:20.711
PROGRESS HERE, BUT THESE
00:41:20.778 --> 00:41:23.080
IMPEDIMENTS STILL REMAIN. SB 897
00:41:23.147 --> 00:41:24.882
SEEKS TO REMOVE SOME OF THOSE
00:41:24.949 --> 00:41:26.050
IMPEDIMENTS THAT STILL REMAIN
00:41:26.116 --> 00:41:27.785
AND ALLOW HOMEOWNERS TO BENEFIT
00:41:27.852 --> 00:41:29.553
FROM THIS NEW OPPORTUNITY. AND
00:41:29.620 --> 00:41:30.821
EXERCISE THEIR PROPERTY RIGHTS
00:41:30.888 --> 00:41:32.690
AND BUILD HOUSING THAT WE
00:41:32.756 --> 00:41:34.725
CRITICALLY NEED. UM LIKE I SAID
00:41:34.792 --> 00:41:36.227
, THERE ARE NO SILVER BULLETS,
00:41:36.293 --> 00:41:38.596
UH, TO THIS HOUSING CRISIS, BUT
00:41:38.662 --> 00:41:40.064
, UM, 80 YEARS HAVE BEEN
00:41:40.130 --> 00:41:40.931
DESCRIBED AS SILVER BUCK SHOTS.
00:41:40.998 --> 00:41:41.966
LOTS OF SMALL INDIVIDUAL
00:41:42.032 --> 00:41:44.101
SOLUTIONS THAT COMBINED TO MAKE
00:41:44.168 --> 00:41:45.936
A REAL DIFFERENCE IN THE LIVES
00:41:46.003 --> 00:41:47.905
OF CALIFORNIANS. WE'D LIKE TO
00:41:47.972 --> 00:41:49.340
THANK SENATOR WHITE HOUSE AGAIN
00:41:49.406 --> 00:41:50.341
FOR HIS CONTINUED LITERALLY
00:41:50.407 --> 00:41:51.609
LEADERSHIP AND HIS WORK THAT OF
00:41:51.675 --> 00:41:53.344
HIS STAFF ON THIS MEASURE AS
00:41:53.410 --> 00:41:55.679
WELL AS THE WORK OF THIS
00:41:55.746 --> 00:41:56.614
COMMITTEE STAFF. UM AND WE URGE
00:41:56.680 --> 00:42:01.886
YOUR VOTE HERE TODAY. THANK YOU.
00:42:01.952 --> 00:42:03.320
GOOD AFTERNOON. MR VICE CHAIR
00:42:03.387 --> 00:42:04.855
MEMBERS. MY NAME IS LUIS MERANTI
00:42:04.922 --> 00:42:05.890
AND THE LEGISLATIVE DIRECTOR OF
00:42:05.956 --> 00:42:07.858
CALIFORNIA AND BE HERE IN STRONG
00:42:07.925 --> 00:42:10.527
SUPPORT OF SB 8 97. I THINK MY
00:42:10.594 --> 00:42:11.762
COLLEAGUE IN THE CENTER HAVE
00:42:11.829 --> 00:42:13.797
DONE VERY WELL AND DESCRIBING
00:42:13.864 --> 00:42:15.032
WHAT THIS BILL DOES AND WHY IT'S
00:42:15.099 --> 00:42:16.567
VALUABLE. I JUST WANT TO
00:42:16.634 --> 00:42:17.601
HIGHLIGHT THAT. AS MY COLLEAGUE
00:42:17.668 --> 00:42:18.869
MENTIONED 80 YEARS HAVE NOW
00:42:18.936 --> 00:42:20.471
REACHED ABOUT 20,000 HOMES PER
00:42:20.537 --> 00:42:22.573
YEAR, WHICH IS ABOUT 20% OF ALL
00:42:22.640 --> 00:42:23.207
OF CALIFORNIA'S HOUSING
00:42:23.274 --> 00:42:24.942
PRODUCTION. THAT'S IN LARGE PART
00:42:25.009 --> 00:42:26.143
BECAUSE OF LEGISLATIVE
00:42:26.210 --> 00:42:27.278
LEADERSHIP, MAKING SURE THAT ADS
00:42:27.344 --> 00:42:29.079
ARE POSSIBLE AROUND THE STATE.
00:42:29.146 --> 00:42:32.082
KEEP IN MIND A TUS WERE ABOUT 1%
00:42:32.149 --> 00:42:33.083
OF THE STATE'S HOUSING
00:42:33.150 --> 00:42:35.252
PRODUCTION JUST FIVE OR SIX
00:42:35.319 --> 00:42:36.253
YEARS AGO BEFORE MAJOR
00:42:36.320 --> 00:42:38.055
LEGISLATIVE ACTION. THIS BILL
00:42:38.122 --> 00:42:39.623
LIFTS UP A LOT OF THE LESSONS
00:42:39.690 --> 00:42:41.225
WE'VE LEARNED AND IMPLEMENTING A
00:42:41.292 --> 00:42:42.660
D U LAWS ACROSS THE STATE FOR
00:42:42.726 --> 00:42:44.128
EXAMPLE, MOST PROPONENTS ARE
00:42:44.194 --> 00:42:45.029
INDIVIDUAL HOMEOWNERS. THEY
00:42:45.095 --> 00:42:45.963
DON'T HAVE THE LEGISLATURE
00:42:46.030 --> 00:42:47.197
LITIGATED LITIGANT ORI
00:42:47.264 --> 00:42:50.167
RESOURCES. TO REALLY DO BATTLE
00:42:50.234 --> 00:42:51.936
WITH MUCH OF THE LOCAL
00:42:52.002 --> 00:42:53.170
GOVERNMENTS AROUND THE STATE,
00:42:53.237 --> 00:42:54.338
AND THIS BILL HELPS CLARIFY
00:42:54.405 --> 00:42:57.374
IMPORTANT CRITERIA OF A D U LAW
00:42:57.441 --> 00:42:59.143
, SUCH AS THE A PROVEN DENY RULE
00:42:59.209 --> 00:43:01.245
IN FAVOR OF HOMEOWNERS SO THAT
00:43:01.312 --> 00:43:02.446
THE PROCESS IS AT LEAST CLEAR TO
00:43:02.513 --> 00:43:04.014
THEM. NOT NECESSARILY DEFINED IN
00:43:04.081 --> 00:43:05.883
THEIR INCOME, BUT IS AT LEAST
00:43:05.950 --> 00:43:06.850
CLEAR SOMETHING THEY CAN
00:43:06.917 --> 00:43:09.853
NAVIGATE. AH SB 8 97 IS GOING TO
00:43:09.920 --> 00:43:11.822
CONTINUE PROGRESS FORWARD ON
00:43:11.889 --> 00:43:13.691
CALIFORNIA'S A D<c.cyan> IMPLEMENTATION</c>
00:43:13.757 --> 00:43:14.992
AND I STRONGLY URGE YOUR SUPPORT
00:43:15.059 --> 00:43:18.929
FOR TODAY. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
00:43:18.996 --> 00:43:21.065
OKAY DO WE HAVE ANYBODY IN THE
00:43:21.131 --> 00:43:22.866
ROOM LIKE TO EXPRESS THEIR
00:43:22.933 --> 00:43:25.569
SUPPORT FOR THIS SENATE BILL?
00:43:25.636 --> 00:43:27.338
STEPHEN SENSOR, WITH BRAUNSTEIN
00:43:27.404 --> 00:43:28.405
ON BEHALF, HOUSING ACTION
00:43:28.472 --> 00:43:29.406
COALITION AND SUPPORT. THANK
00:43:29.473 --> 00:43:33.911
YOU. MR CHAIR MEMBERS, PAT MORAN
00:43:33.978 --> 00:43:35.279
WITH AARON READING ASSOCIATES
00:43:35.346 --> 00:43:36.146
REPRESENTING THE SOUTHERN
00:43:36.213 --> 00:43:36.680
CALIFORNIA RENTAL HOUSING
00:43:36.747 --> 00:43:40.818
ASSOCIATION AND SUPPORT.
00:43:40.884 --> 00:43:41.685
CORNELIUS BURKE WITH THE
00:43:41.752 --> 00:43:42.753
CALIFORNIA BUILDING INDUSTRY
00:43:42.820 --> 00:43:48.292
ASSOCIATION AND SUPPORT. HOLLY
00:43:48.359 --> 00:43:49.626
FOR MANY DAYS IS WITH LIGHTHOUSE
00:43:49.693 --> 00:43:51.362
PUBLIC AFFAIRS ON BEHALF OF SPUR
00:43:51.428 --> 00:43:55.065
AND SUPPORT. OKAY? DO YOU HAVE
00:43:55.132 --> 00:43:57.835
ANY WITNESSES AND OPPOSITION?
00:43:57.901 --> 00:44:13.851
YOU LIKE TO COME FORWARD.
00:44:13.917 --> 00:44:15.285
STATE YOUR NAME FOR THE RECORD
00:44:15.352 --> 00:44:18.322
AND YOU MAY PROCEED. CHAIR AND
00:44:18.389 --> 00:44:19.556
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE,
00:44:19.623 --> 00:44:20.591
JENNIFER SPECT ON BEHALF OF THE
00:44:20.657 --> 00:44:21.525
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
00:44:21.592 --> 00:44:22.726
REALTORS. IN OPPOSITION TO SB 8
00:44:22.793 --> 00:44:25.229
97 AS PROPOSED TO BE AMENDED,
00:44:25.295 --> 00:44:25.796
THE BILL WOULD INCREASE THE
00:44:25.863 --> 00:44:27.831
HEIGHT MAXIMUM FOR 80 YEARS FROM
00:44:27.898 --> 00:44:29.900
16 TO 18 FT FOR PARCELS AND AN
00:44:29.967 --> 00:44:30.834
EXISTING MULTI STORY BUILDING.
00:44:30.901 --> 00:44:32.970
OR 20 FT FROM MULTI FAMILY OR
00:44:33.037 --> 00:44:34.071
SINGLE FAMILY PARCELS LOCATED
00:44:34.138 --> 00:44:35.906
WITHIN A HALF MILE OF TRANSIT.
00:44:35.973 --> 00:44:37.908
THE BILL ALSO SEEKS TO ADD
00:44:37.975 --> 00:44:39.343
PROVISIONS WHICH ARE CONFUSING
00:44:39.410 --> 00:44:41.045
IN THE PROPOSED AMENDMENTS,
00:44:41.111 --> 00:44:42.212
WHICH SET A MINIMUM HEIGHT
00:44:42.279 --> 00:44:43.380
REQUIREMENT OF 25 FT FOR A D. U.
00:44:43.447 --> 00:44:44.882
S. THAT ARE ATTACHED TO A
00:44:44.948 --> 00:44:46.050
PRIMARY SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENCE
00:44:46.116 --> 00:44:48.152
, WHICH IMPLIES THAT THESE UNITS
00:44:48.218 --> 00:44:49.420
WILL FUNCTION MORE AS A DUPLEX
00:44:49.486 --> 00:44:50.554
AND NOT AS A JUNIOR 80 YOU
00:44:50.621 --> 00:44:51.855
CURRENT LAW AUTHORIZES CITIES
00:44:51.922 --> 00:44:53.057
AND COUNTIES TO RESTRICT EDU
00:44:53.123 --> 00:44:56.427
HEIGHT TO 16 FT, THUS HELPING
00:44:56.493 --> 00:44:57.961
ENSURE THAT 80 US BLEND WITHIN
00:44:58.028 --> 00:44:59.563
THE EXISTING NEIGHBORHOOD. EVEN
00:44:59.630 --> 00:45:00.998
AS PROPOSED TO BE AMENDED. THE
00:45:01.065 --> 00:45:02.466
BILL CREATES CONFUSING STANDARDS
00:45:02.533 --> 00:45:04.168
AND IN CERTAIN INSTANCES WOULD
00:45:04.234 --> 00:45:05.536
BE WOULD SUBSTANTIALLY ALTER THE
00:45:05.602 --> 00:45:07.738
LOOK AND FEEL OF A COMMUNITY. AS
00:45:07.805 --> 00:45:09.807
PROPOSED TO BE AMENDED. THE BILL
00:45:09.873 --> 00:45:10.841
ALSO CREATES CONFUSION AS AWS
00:45:10.908 --> 00:45:11.842
ATTACHED TO A PRIMARY RESIDENT
00:45:11.909 --> 00:45:13.343
PRIMARY RESIDENTS ARE CALLED
00:45:13.410 --> 00:45:14.845
JUNIOR 80 US. THIS MEASURE
00:45:14.912 --> 00:45:17.347
CREATES A NUANCE WHERE AWS COULD
00:45:17.414 --> 00:45:18.882
CONCEIVABLY BE EQUAL IN SIZE OR
00:45:18.949 --> 00:45:19.750
LARGER THAN THE PRIMARY
00:45:19.817 --> 00:45:21.819
RESIDENCE AS IT CREATES A NEW
00:45:21.885 --> 00:45:22.753
MINIMUM HEIGHT REQUIREMENT OF 25
00:45:22.820 --> 00:45:24.421
FT WITHOUT PROVIDING FOR
00:45:24.488 --> 00:45:25.689
CLARIFICATION OF THE SIZE OF THE
00:45:25.756 --> 00:45:27.558
A. D. YOU ATTACHED TO THE
00:45:27.624 --> 00:45:28.725
DWELLING? 80 USED BY THEIR
00:45:28.792 --> 00:45:30.094
NATURE ARE EFFICIENT UNITS THAT
00:45:30.160 --> 00:45:31.728
DO NOT REQUIRE THE SAME HEIGHT
00:45:31.795 --> 00:45:33.197
CONSIDERATIONS AS A SINGLE
00:45:33.263 --> 00:45:34.665
FAMILY HOME IF THE BILL SEEKS TO
00:45:34.731 --> 00:45:35.732
PERMIT A SECOND STORY ADDITION
00:45:35.799 --> 00:45:37.167
TO GARAGES, THE GLOBAL HEIGHT
00:45:37.234 --> 00:45:38.235
INCREASE EVEN IN PERSONS LOCATED
00:45:38.302 --> 00:45:40.437
NEAR TRANSIT. IS NOT NECESSARY
00:45:40.504 --> 00:45:41.538
IN THE AMENDMENTS FOR THE HEIGHT
00:45:41.605 --> 00:45:42.973
INCREASE SHOULD BE MORE
00:45:43.040 --> 00:45:44.341
PRECISELY DRAFTED AS WE MUST BE
00:45:44.408 --> 00:45:46.009
CAREFUL NOT TO CHANGE THE LOOK
00:45:46.076 --> 00:45:46.810
AND FEEL OF EXISTING
00:45:46.877 --> 00:45:47.578
COMMUNITIES, WHICH ALREADY
00:45:47.644 --> 00:45:49.012
MAINTAINS HEIGHT AND DESIGN
00:45:49.079 --> 00:45:50.347
LIMITATIONS. WHILE WE APPRECIATE
00:45:50.414 --> 00:45:51.748
THE COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS, WHICH
00:45:51.815 --> 00:45:52.950
ARE A STEP IN THE RIGHT
00:45:53.016 --> 00:45:54.051
DIRECTION, WE DO CONTINUE TO
00:45:54.118 --> 00:45:55.719
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST A NO VOTE.
00:45:55.786 --> 00:45:57.554
UNTIL OUR REMAINING CONCERNS ARE
00:45:57.621 --> 00:45:58.222
RESOLVED. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
00:45:58.288 --> 00:45:59.456
YOU MAY PROCEED. GOOD AFTERNOON
00:45:59.523 --> 00:46:00.824
VICE CHAIR AND MEMBERS BRADY
00:46:00.891 --> 00:46:01.725
GARDEN ON BEHALF OF THE
00:46:01.792 --> 00:46:03.760
CALIFORNIA BUILDING OFFICIALS
00:46:03.827 --> 00:46:04.661
WOULD LIKE TO THANK THE
00:46:04.728 --> 00:46:05.529
COMMITTEE STAFF THE AUTHORS
00:46:05.596 --> 00:46:06.530
OFFICE FOR THEIR CONTINUED
00:46:06.597 --> 00:46:08.699
CONVERSATIONS ON THE BILL.
00:46:08.765 --> 00:46:10.200
UNFORTUNATELY APPLE STILL HAS
00:46:10.267 --> 00:46:12.102
CONCERNS WITH SB 897 AND IS IN
00:46:12.169 --> 00:46:13.270
RESPECTFUL OPPOSITION TO THE
00:46:13.337 --> 00:46:14.304
SIGNIFICANT SAFETY CONCERNS OF
00:46:14.371 --> 00:46:16.507
THE BILL. SPECIFICALLY CALVO IS
00:46:16.573 --> 00:46:17.875
CONCERNED THAT THE BILL WOULD
00:46:17.941 --> 00:46:19.143
DISALLOW AND OUR OCCUPANT SI
00:46:19.209 --> 00:46:19.843
CHANGING THE LOCAL BUILDING.
00:46:19.910 --> 00:46:22.479
CODE OCCUPANCY CHANGES ARE KEY
00:46:22.546 --> 00:46:24.281
FOR FIRE LIFE SAFETY STANDARDS
00:46:24.348 --> 00:46:25.382
AND TO PROTECT THE PUBLIC FROM
00:46:25.449 --> 00:46:26.550
HARM IN THE BUILDING INDUSTRY.
00:46:26.617 --> 00:46:27.951
FOR EXAMPLE, THE GARAGE
00:46:28.018 --> 00:46:28.886
CONVERSION TO AN 80. YOU WOULD
00:46:28.952 --> 00:46:29.586
NOT HAVE TO COMPLY WITH
00:46:29.653 --> 00:46:31.021
RESIDENTIAL STANDARDS.
00:46:31.088 --> 00:46:32.389
ADDITIONALLY EVEN IN OUR
00:46:32.456 --> 00:46:34.024
OCCUPANCY CHANGE HAS SIGNIFICANT
00:46:34.091 --> 00:46:35.325
DIFFERENCES IN FIRE, SEPARATION
00:46:35.392 --> 00:46:36.693
STANDARDS, FIRE SPRINKLERS AND
00:46:36.760 --> 00:46:37.694
SMOKE ALARMS BETWEEN THE
00:46:37.761 --> 00:46:39.930
DIFFERENT ARE OCCUPANCIES. WE
00:46:39.997 --> 00:46:41.064
ARE CONCERNED THAT THERE COULD
00:46:41.131 --> 00:46:42.499
BE UNDUE HARM TO THE PUBLIC. IF
00:46:42.566 --> 00:46:43.600
THESE STANDARDS ARE NOT MET,
00:46:43.667 --> 00:46:45.435
SHOULD A FIRE OCCUR IN THE
00:46:45.502 --> 00:46:46.603
STRUCTURE? WE APPRECIATE THE
00:46:46.670 --> 00:46:47.938
COMMITTEE'S AMENDMENTS TO BE
00:46:48.005 --> 00:46:49.973
MORE SPECIFIC ON THE ISSUE, BUT
00:46:50.040 --> 00:46:50.941
WOULD PREFER LANGUAGE THAT
00:46:51.008 --> 00:46:52.342
STATES AND OCCUPANCY CHANGE
00:46:52.409 --> 00:46:53.644
UNDER HE LOCAL BUILDING CODE IS
00:46:53.710 --> 00:46:55.612
ALLOWED IF THERE IS A FINDING BY
00:46:55.679 --> 00:46:56.680
THE LOCAL BUILDING. OFFICIAL OR
00:46:56.747 --> 00:46:58.415
ENFORCEMENT AGENCY THAT THERE
00:46:58.482 --> 00:46:59.850
COULD BE A SPECIFIC ADVERSE
00:46:59.917 --> 00:47:01.318
IMPACT TO PUBLIC HEALTH AND
00:47:01.385 --> 00:47:02.719
SAFETY OF THE OCCUPANTS.
00:47:02.786 --> 00:47:04.021
ADDITIONALLY COLLEGE DOES NOT
00:47:04.087 --> 00:47:05.455
SUPPORT ALLOWING A FIVE YEAR
00:47:05.522 --> 00:47:07.090
DELAY IN THE ENFORCEMENT OF
00:47:07.157 --> 00:47:08.091
BUILDING STANDARD VIOLATIONS IN
00:47:08.158 --> 00:47:09.326
THE PRIMARY RESIDENCES. BILLY
00:47:09.393 --> 00:47:10.794
SOUNDS ARE NECESSARY TO PROTECT
00:47:10.861 --> 00:47:13.063
THE PUBLIC FROM HARM AND BY
00:47:13.130 --> 00:47:13.664
ALLOWING HOMEOWNERS TO AVOID
00:47:13.730 --> 00:47:14.531
COMPLYING WITH THE STANDARDS FOR
00:47:14.598 --> 00:47:16.833
THE PRIMARY RESIDENCE. THERE
00:47:16.900 --> 00:47:17.601
COULD BE SEVERE SAFETY
00:47:17.668 --> 00:47:18.368
IMPLICATIONS BECAUSE OF THE
00:47:18.435 --> 00:47:20.070
CURRENT LANGUAGE. SECONDLY SOME
00:47:20.137 --> 00:47:21.071
OF THE NECESSARY STANDARDS
00:47:21.138 --> 00:47:22.573
INCLUDE ENERGY EFFICIENCY
00:47:22.639 --> 00:47:24.107
STANDARDS, AND IF CALIFORNIA
00:47:24.174 --> 00:47:25.075
WANTS TO CONTINUE TO ACHIEVE OUR
00:47:25.142 --> 00:47:25.976
GREEN ENERGY GOALS, THESE
00:47:26.043 --> 00:47:28.078
INNARDS MUST BE COMPLIED WITH TO
00:47:28.145 --> 00:47:29.446
ACHIEVE OUR CLIMATE GOALS. KABUL
00:47:29.513 --> 00:47:30.948
APPRECIATES THE LANGUAGE, GIVING
00:47:31.014 --> 00:47:32.049
DISCRETION TO BUILDING OFFICIALS
00:47:32.115 --> 00:47:34.017
TO DECIDE IF THE LACK OF
00:47:34.084 --> 00:47:35.085
COMPLIANCE WOULD HAVE AN ADVERSE
00:47:35.152 --> 00:47:36.620
IMPACT ON PUBLIC HEALTH AND
00:47:36.687 --> 00:47:37.387
SAFETY, BUT ARE CONCERNED THAT
00:47:37.454 --> 00:47:38.455
THIS BILL COULD SET A BAD
00:47:38.522 --> 00:47:40.290
PRECEDENT IN THE FUTURE OF
00:47:40.357 --> 00:47:41.058
CALIFORNIA'S HOUSING. CALVO
00:47:41.124 --> 00:47:42.392
SUPPORTIVE OF DEVELOPING NEW
00:47:42.459 --> 00:47:44.127
HOUSES AND 80 YEARS TO ADDRESS
00:47:44.194 --> 00:47:45.596
CALIFORNIA'S HOUSING CRISIS.
00:47:45.662 --> 00:47:46.997
HOWEVER, THIS SHOULD BE DONE IN
00:47:47.064 --> 00:47:48.365
A SAFE AND FEASIBLE MANNER.
00:47:48.432 --> 00:47:49.833
UNFORTUNATELY CABO HAS YEAR
00:47:49.900 --> 00:47:50.968
SAFETY CONCERNS WITH THE BILL,
00:47:51.034 --> 00:47:52.836
AND WE RESPECTFULLY URGE A NO
00:47:52.903 --> 00:47:54.037
VOTE ON THIS MEASURE. WE LOOK
00:47:54.104 --> 00:47:55.205
FORWARD TO CONTINUED DIALOGUE
00:47:55.272 --> 00:47:56.807
WITH THE AUTHOR AND SPONSORS OF
00:47:56.873 --> 00:47:57.941
THE BILL TO ADDRESS THEIR
00:47:58.008 --> 00:47:58.775
CONCERNS AND LOOK FORWARD TO
00:47:58.842 --> 00:48:01.078
READING THE AMENDMENTS IN PRINT
00:48:01.144 --> 00:48:01.712
THAT ARE PROPOSED TODAY. THANK
00:48:01.778 --> 00:48:03.847
YOU AND HAVE A GREAT REST THE
00:48:03.914 --> 00:48:04.982
AFTERNOON THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:48:05.048 --> 00:48:06.116
OKAY ANYBODY ELSE WOULD LIKE TO
00:48:06.183 --> 00:48:07.684
EXPRESS THEIR OPPOSITION. FAITH
00:48:07.751 --> 00:48:08.952
BORDERS ON BEHALF OF THE
00:48:09.019 --> 00:48:10.354
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF CODE
00:48:10.420 --> 00:48:11.455
ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS. WE WOULD
00:48:11.521 --> 00:48:13.357
ALIGN OUR OPPOSITION WITH THE
00:48:13.423 --> 00:48:14.992
COMMENTS MADE BY CALVO. THANK
00:48:15.058 --> 00:48:18.829
YOU. THANK YOU. ALYSSA STILL
00:48:18.895 --> 00:48:20.797
HIGH ON BEHALF OF THE CITIES OF
00:48:20.864 --> 00:48:21.732
BAKERSFIELD, CARLSBAD, CORONA
00:48:21.798 --> 00:48:22.833
AND RENTALS PALETTE VARIES IN
00:48:22.899 --> 00:48:23.867
RESPECTFUL OPPOSITION. THANK
00:48:23.934 --> 00:48:29.072
YOU. MR CHAIR MEMBERS, DAVID
00:48:29.139 --> 00:48:30.774
JONES ON BEHALF OF THE CITIES OF
00:48:30.841 --> 00:48:32.876
MARIN, SAN MARCOS AND A SOLANO
00:48:32.943 --> 00:48:34.544
BEACH IN OPPOSITION. THANK YOU.
00:48:34.611 --> 00:48:35.812
THANK YOU OK, ANY QUESTIONS FOR
00:48:35.879 --> 00:48:41.718
THE COMMITTEE? SEE NONE. YOU
00:48:41.785 --> 00:48:43.420
MEAN CLOSE THE APPROPRIATE TIME
00:48:43.487 --> 00:48:45.756
I WOULD URGE A MOTION AND A
00:48:45.822 --> 00:48:47.691
SECOND AND I VOTE AND JUST TO
00:48:47.758 --> 00:48:52.162
CLARIFY SOME OF THE CHAOS IT'S
00:48:52.229 --> 00:48:55.565
THE OPPOSITION HAS CREATED IS
00:48:55.632 --> 00:48:56.967
THAT YOU KNOW, WITH THE BUILDING
00:48:57.034 --> 00:48:59.069
OFFICIALS ON THE R TWO AND R
00:48:59.136 --> 00:49:01.238
THREE. THIS IS A SIMPLE YOU HAVE
00:49:01.305 --> 00:49:03.740
A DUPLEX. AND THEN YOU HAVE A
00:49:03.807 --> 00:49:04.841
GARAGE THAT YOU WANT TO CONVERT
00:49:04.908 --> 00:49:06.943
INTO AN EIGHT EU EUROPE WERE
00:49:07.010 --> 00:49:08.312
SAYING YOU'RE ALLOWED TO DO
00:49:08.378 --> 00:49:09.913
THAT. YOU DON'T NEED TO GO TO
00:49:09.980 --> 00:49:11.315
THE LOCAL BUILDING OFFICIAL AND
00:49:11.381 --> 00:49:12.983
GET THEIR THEIR SIGN OFF. YOU'RE
00:49:13.050 --> 00:49:13.550
ALLOWED TO DO THAT. AND THE
00:49:13.617 --> 00:49:15.285
AMENDMENTS THAT WE'VE TAKEN ARE
00:49:15.352 --> 00:49:17.054
SAYING THAT THAT STILL BECOMES
00:49:17.120 --> 00:49:19.556
AN R TWO BECAUSE BUT WHAT THEY
00:49:19.623 --> 00:49:20.924
SUGGESTED IT WOULD BECOME AN R
00:49:20.991 --> 00:49:23.060
THREE BECAUSE IT'S ANOTHER. IT'S
00:49:23.126 --> 00:49:24.761
A IT'S A DIFFERENT CODE, AND
00:49:24.828 --> 00:49:25.962
THAT WOULD NOT BE ALLOWED ON
00:49:26.029 --> 00:49:27.964
THAT LOT. AND THE IDEA IS THAT
00:49:28.031 --> 00:49:30.867
WE WANT PEOPLE TO DO BUILD A D U
00:49:30.934 --> 00:49:33.103
SO THIS WOULD BE STILL BE AN R
00:49:33.170 --> 00:49:34.638
TWO WITH A WITH AN ACCESSORY
00:49:34.705 --> 00:49:37.874
DWELLING UNIT. THAT'S IT AND WE
00:49:37.941 --> 00:49:39.009
UNDERSTAND THAT IT DETACHED
00:49:39.076 --> 00:49:42.312
GARAGES ARE UNOCCUPIED THERE'S
00:49:42.379 --> 00:49:43.980
OWNED AND OCCUPIED AND WERE
00:49:44.047 --> 00:49:45.115
ALLOWED IN THE AMENDMENTS THAT
00:49:45.182 --> 00:49:47.150
YOU CAN MAKE IT. ARGUMENT EVERY
00:49:47.217 --> 00:49:49.052
GARAGE. EVERY GARAGE CONVERSION
00:49:49.119 --> 00:49:50.887
IS NOT SUPPOSED TO BE OCCUPIED
00:49:50.954 --> 00:49:52.456
BY PEOPLE BY FOLKS AND WE KNOW
00:49:52.522 --> 00:49:53.857
THAT THOSE EXISTED. WE HAVE A
00:49:53.924 --> 00:49:55.225
PROCEDURE THAT'S THE THAT'S
00:49:55.292 --> 00:49:56.827
EXISTING LAW THAT YOU CAN. YOU
00:49:56.893 --> 00:49:59.029
CAN GO IN AND GET THEM PERMANENT
00:49:59.096 --> 00:50:00.263
, SO THAT IF YOU CAN GET THAT
00:50:00.330 --> 00:50:03.500
OCCUPANCY CODE SO AGAIN, AS MY
00:50:03.567 --> 00:50:04.968
ADVOCATES HAVE SAID, WE'RE
00:50:05.035 --> 00:50:06.536
TRYING TO MAKE THIS EASIER FOR
00:50:06.603 --> 00:50:07.537
THE INDIVIDUAL. THIS IS A
00:50:07.604 --> 00:50:09.039
HOMEOWNER THAT DOESN'T NEED TO
00:50:09.106 --> 00:50:10.974
GO TO 16 DIFFERENT AGENCIES. UM
00:50:11.041 --> 00:50:15.078
AND I'LL SAY NOTHING ABOUT THE
00:50:15.145 --> 00:50:16.713
HEIGHT. I HAVE TAKEN EVERY
00:50:16.780 --> 00:50:17.914
AMENDMENT THAT THE SENATE
00:50:17.981 --> 00:50:19.082
GOVERNMENT FINANCE, AND THIS
00:50:19.149 --> 00:50:21.485
COMMITTEE HAS ASKED. IT'S A
00:50:21.551 --> 00:50:24.621
LIMITED ABILITY AND SOME LIMITED
00:50:24.688 --> 00:50:26.490
AREAS FOR PEOPLE TO GET A SECOND
00:50:26.556 --> 00:50:28.425
STORY ON ON THE HOUSE AND WHAT
00:50:28.492 --> 00:50:31.328
THAT I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN I
00:50:31.395 --> 00:50:39.403
VOTE. DR THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:50:39.469 --> 00:50:40.437
SENATOR PORTANTINO. YOU'RE UP
00:50:40.504 --> 00:50:53.683
NEXT SER. SENATE BILL 10 67.
00:50:53.750 --> 00:50:55.952
THANK YOU ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
00:50:56.019 --> 00:50:57.521
LACKEY AND MEMBERS TODAY I'M
00:50:57.587 --> 00:51:00.690
PRESENTING SP 10 67 AND EFFORT.
00:51:00.757 --> 00:51:02.025
TO RESTRICT PARKING MINIMUMS IN
00:51:02.092 --> 00:51:03.660
OUR CITIES. I'D LIKE TO START BY
00:51:03.727 --> 00:51:04.561
ACCEPTING THE COMMITTEE
00:51:04.628 --> 00:51:06.797
AMENDMENTS LOCATED ON COMMON 11
00:51:06.863 --> 00:51:07.664
ON PAGE SEVEN OF THE COMMITTEE
00:51:07.731 --> 00:51:10.000
ANALYSIS AND THANK THE CHAIR AND
00:51:10.066 --> 00:51:10.834
COMMITTEE STAFF ARE WORKING WITH
00:51:10.901 --> 00:51:12.035
MY STAFF ON BRINGING US ALONG
00:51:12.102 --> 00:51:14.871
THIS FAR. AS WE KNOW. PARKING
00:51:14.938 --> 00:51:16.072
MINIMUMS REQUIRE PRIVATE
00:51:16.139 --> 00:51:17.707
PROPERTY OWNERS TO PROVIDE AND
00:51:17.774 --> 00:51:18.708
MAINTAIN A CERTAIN NUMBER OF OFF
00:51:18.775 --> 00:51:20.310
STREET PARKING SPACES. THESE
00:51:20.377 --> 00:51:21.711
MINIMUMS IMPOSED FINANCIAL,
00:51:21.778 --> 00:51:22.712
ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL COSTS.
00:51:22.779 --> 00:51:26.550
THE CITIES SB 10 67 WILL
00:51:26.616 --> 00:51:28.718
PROHIBIT A CITY FROM IMPOSING
00:51:28.785 --> 00:51:29.619
PARKING MINIMUM REQUIREMENT ON
00:51:29.686 --> 00:51:31.822
HOUSING DEVELOPMENT PROJECT THAT
00:51:31.888 --> 00:51:33.723
IS LOCATED WITHIN A HALF MILE OF
00:51:33.790 --> 00:51:34.891
PUBLIC TRANSIT IF IT EITHER
00:51:34.958 --> 00:51:38.428
DEDICATES 20. OF THE TOTAL UNITS
00:51:38.495 --> 00:51:39.563
TO A COMBINATION OF LOW AND VERY
00:51:39.629 --> 00:51:41.364
LOW INCOME HOUSEHOLDS, THE
00:51:41.431 --> 00:51:42.199
ELDERLY PERSONS WITH
00:51:42.265 --> 00:51:43.233
DISABILITIES. UM OR, UH,
00:51:43.300 --> 00:51:48.004
STUDENTS. UM AND DEVELOPMENTS
00:51:48.071 --> 00:51:50.073
THAT CONTAIN LESS THAN 20 UNITS
00:51:50.140 --> 00:51:51.575
, ELIMINATING PARKING MINIMUMS
00:51:51.641 --> 00:51:52.909
WITHIN CLOSE PROXIMITY TO PUBLIC
00:51:52.976 --> 00:51:54.678
TRANSIT WITH LESS IN
00:51:54.744 --> 00:51:55.445
CALIFORNIA'S DEPENDENCE ON CARS
00:51:55.512 --> 00:51:56.947
, PROVIDE MORE SPACE FOR WALKING
00:51:57.013 --> 00:51:58.482
AND BIKING AND HELP COUNTERACT
00:51:58.548 --> 00:51:59.382
HOUSING AFFORDABILITY PROBLEMS
00:51:59.449 --> 00:52:01.117
BY CUTTING COSTS FOR TENANTS AND
00:52:01.184 --> 00:52:03.687
DEVELOPERS. IT'LL ALSO SAYS THAT
00:52:03.753 --> 00:52:04.921
IF A DEVELOPER CAN SHOW IN THE
00:52:04.988 --> 00:52:08.558
CITY AGREES THAT REDUCING
00:52:08.625 --> 00:52:10.327
PARKING MINIMUMS ON PROJECTS DO
00:52:10.393 --> 00:52:12.462
NOT IMPACT THAT CITY'S ABILITY
00:52:12.529 --> 00:52:13.964
TO MEET AFFORDABLE HOUSING UNDER
00:52:14.030 --> 00:52:15.031
THE ARENA REQUIREMENTS. THEY
00:52:15.098 --> 00:52:17.000
ALSO CAN MOVE FORWARD WITH THOSE
00:52:17.067 --> 00:52:18.902
DEVELOPMENTS. SO WE'VE TRIED TO
00:52:18.969 --> 00:52:21.338
HIT THE SWEET SPOT BETWEEN THOSE
00:52:21.404 --> 00:52:23.573
WHO WANT TO DO AWAY WITH PARKING
00:52:23.640 --> 00:52:24.174
MINIMUMS COMPLETELY AND THOSE
00:52:24.241 --> 00:52:26.343
WHO CHAMPION AFFORDABLE HOUSING
00:52:26.409 --> 00:52:28.578
AS WELL. AND SO I THINK THE FACT
00:52:28.645 --> 00:52:29.546
THAT WE'RE SORT OF GETTING
00:52:29.613 --> 00:52:31.781
PUSHBACK FROM BOTH SIDES TO ME,
00:52:31.848 --> 00:52:33.517
SAYS WE HIT THE SWEET SPOT. SO
00:52:33.583 --> 00:52:35.485
WHEN YOU HAVE A QUORUM, I WOULD
00:52:35.552 --> 00:52:36.620
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR MY VOTE AS
00:52:36.686 --> 00:52:38.522
APPROPRIATE. OKAY THANK YOU. DO
00:52:38.588 --> 00:52:40.757
YOU HAVE ANYBODY WHO WOULD LIKE
00:52:40.824 --> 00:52:41.825
TO EXPRESS THEIR SUPPORT FOR
00:52:41.892 --> 00:52:42.592
THIS PARTICULAR? SENATE BILL 10
00:52:42.659 --> 00:52:47.731
67. STEPHEN SENSOR, WITH BRAND
00:52:47.797 --> 00:52:49.432
SEEN ON BEHALF OF THE HOUSING
00:52:49.499 --> 00:52:50.400
ACTION, COALITION AND SUPPORT
00:52:50.467 --> 00:52:53.937
THANK YOU. OKAY DID WE HAVE ANY
00:52:54.004 --> 00:52:55.772
OPPONENTS WOULD LIKE TO EXPRESS
00:52:55.839 --> 00:53:05.615
THEIR OPPOSITION AT THIS MOMENT.
00:53:05.682 --> 00:53:07.484
MR CHAIR MEMBERS, DAVID JONES.
00:53:07.551 --> 00:53:09.419
ABOUT HALF OF THE SEASON. WE'RE
00:53:09.486 --> 00:53:10.654
IN SOLANO BEACH AND SAN MARCOS
00:53:10.720 --> 00:53:15.992
IN OPPOSITION. QUÊ OKAY? HOW
00:53:16.059 --> 00:53:19.262
ABOUT ANY COMMENTS? FROM THE
00:53:19.329 --> 00:53:23.033
COMMITTEE. ANY QUESTIONS,COMMENTS? EXPRESSIONS. THAT
00:53:23.099 --> 00:53:27.437
LOOKS LIKE NONE. YOU MAY CLOSE.
00:53:27.504 --> 00:53:30.106
AGAIN HOPEFULLY WE HIT THE SWEET
00:53:30.173 --> 00:53:30.774
SPOT AND RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR MY
00:53:30.840 --> 00:53:33.243
VOTE WHEN YOU HAVE A QUORUM.
00:53:33.310 --> 00:53:36.212
THANK YOU VERY MUCH, SENATOR. T<c.cyan></c>
00:53:36.279 --> 00:53:38.748
I DON'T SEE SENATOR WHO HUESO.
00:53:38.815 --> 00:53:39.816
SO, SENATOR ALAN, YOU'RE UP,
00:53:39.883 --> 00:53:49.826
SIR. 12 90 SENATE BILL 12 90.
00:53:49.893 --> 00:53:51.361
HI, MR CHAIR MEMBERS. I JUST
00:53:51.428 --> 00:53:52.896
WANT TO THANK THE COMMITTEE OF
00:53:52.963 --> 00:53:55.165
THIS CHAIR FOR THE TIME AND
00:53:55.231 --> 00:53:56.533
ATTENTION THAT YOU'VE GIVEN TO
00:53:56.600 --> 00:53:57.367
STAKEHOLDERS. I'M HAPPY TO
00:53:57.434 --> 00:53:58.969
DISCUSS THIS ISSUE THAT WE'RE
00:53:59.035 --> 00:54:00.103
TALKING ABOUT TODAY AND I'M
00:54:00.170 --> 00:54:02.172
GOING TO TAKE ALL THE PROPOSED
00:54:02.238 --> 00:54:03.006
AMENDMENTS OUTLINING THE
00:54:03.073 --> 00:54:04.674
COMMITTEE'S ANALYSIS. UM THIS
00:54:04.741 --> 00:54:06.042
YEAR, OUR LEGISLATURE IS ENGAGED
00:54:06.109 --> 00:54:07.911
IN AN IMPORTANT DEBATE OVER AN
00:54:07.978 --> 00:54:09.846
EFFORT TO PROVIDE MORE
00:54:09.913 --> 00:54:12.415
REASONABLE AND AFFORDABLE LEGAL
00:54:12.482 --> 00:54:14.384
PATHWAYS FOR STREET AND MOBILE
00:54:14.451 --> 00:54:15.485
VENDING THROUGHOUT THE STATE OF
00:54:15.552 --> 00:54:17.020
CALIFORNIA. THAT EFFORT BUILDS
00:54:17.087 --> 00:54:19.222
ON THE GROUND BREAKING WORK. BY
00:54:19.289 --> 00:54:21.491
FORMER SENATOR NOW INSURANCE
00:54:21.558 --> 00:54:23.893
COMMISSIONER RICARDO LARA TO
00:54:23.960 --> 00:54:26.096
DECRIMINALIZE STREET VENDING. I
00:54:26.162 --> 00:54:27.230
SUPPORTED SENATOR LORIS BILL SP
00:54:27.297 --> 00:54:29.532
9 46, AS DID MANY OF YOU. WHEN
00:54:29.599 --> 00:54:31.067
IT PASSED AND WAS SIGNED INTO
00:54:31.134 --> 00:54:33.103
LAW IN 2018, AND TODAY I
00:54:33.169 --> 00:54:36.206
CERTAINLY SUPPORT THE CURRENT
00:54:36.272 --> 00:54:37.240
WORK OF MY COLLEAGUE, SENATOR
00:54:37.307 --> 00:54:38.441
LENA GONZALEZ, IN HER EFFORT TO
00:54:38.508 --> 00:54:39.542
MAKE ESSENTIAL REFORMS TO OUR
00:54:39.609 --> 00:54:41.544
RETAIL FOOD, FOOD COACHES GOT A
00:54:41.611 --> 00:54:43.279
BILL SB 9 72. THAT I SUPPORTED
00:54:43.346 --> 00:54:44.881
ON THE SENATE FLOOR. AND SPOKE
00:54:44.948 --> 00:54:49.119
ABOUT I'M ALSO BRINGING THIS
00:54:49.185 --> 00:54:53.757
BILL TO U. S. B 12 90 BECAUSE
00:54:53.823 --> 00:54:56.059
THERE ARE YOU KNOW A LOT OF
00:54:56.126 --> 00:54:56.826
ISSUES ASSOCIATED WITH STREET
00:54:56.893 --> 00:54:59.195
VENDING THAT I THINK WE ALL WANT
00:54:59.262 --> 00:55:01.431
TO GET A BETTER SENSE OF WE'VE
00:55:01.498 --> 00:55:03.166
GOT SEVERAL PLACES AROUND THE
00:55:03.233 --> 00:55:04.968
STATE THAT ARE HIGHLY TRAFFICKED
00:55:05.035 --> 00:55:06.036
TOURIST DESTINATIONS SUCH AS THE
00:55:06.102 --> 00:55:08.038
SANTA MONICA PIER, BUT ALSO
00:55:08.104 --> 00:55:09.406
BALBOA PARK IN SAN DIEGO.
00:55:09.472 --> 00:55:11.341
FISHERMAN'S WORKED HERE. 39 SAN
00:55:11.408 --> 00:55:12.709
FRANCISCO SEVERAL OTHER PLACES.
00:55:12.776 --> 00:55:17.213
WHERE THE SAFE WORK, UH, VENDORS
00:55:17.280 --> 00:55:18.948
AND THE REGULATION OF THEIR WORK
00:55:19.015 --> 00:55:19.416
HAS BEEN INCREASINGLY
00:55:19.482 --> 00:55:22.218
CHALLENGING. CODE ENFORCEMENT
00:55:22.285 --> 00:55:23.853
OFFICERS, UTILIZING THE CIVIL
00:55:23.920 --> 00:55:24.721
PENALTY STRUCTURE INTO CURRENT
00:55:24.788 --> 00:55:27.090
STATUTE HAVE NOT BEEN ABLE TO
00:55:27.157 --> 00:55:28.091
STOP ROGUE VENDORS FROM
00:55:28.158 --> 00:55:28.992
OPERATING IN AN UNSAFE MANNER.
00:55:29.059 --> 00:55:30.860
THE CITY HAS CHOSEN TO CREATE A
00:55:30.927 --> 00:55:31.628
TASK FORCE THAT BRINGS POLICE
00:55:31.695 --> 00:55:33.129
OFFICERS HAVE APPEARED ENFORCE
00:55:33.196 --> 00:55:34.130
CRIMINAL PENALTIES, WHICH IS NOT
00:55:34.197 --> 00:55:36.866
A GREAT MODEL. IF YOU THINK
00:55:36.933 --> 00:55:38.301
ABOUT IT, GIVEN ALL THE CONCERNS
00:55:38.368 --> 00:55:41.204
THAT ARE OUT THERE UM YOU KNOW,
00:55:41.271 --> 00:55:44.574
WE CERTAINLY SHARE THE VISION OF
00:55:44.641 --> 00:55:45.842
THE FOLKS WHO HAVE RAISED
00:55:45.909 --> 00:55:46.609
CONCERNS ABOUT, UH THE APPROACH
00:55:46.676 --> 00:55:50.380
OF THE CITIES. BECAUSE WE DO
00:55:50.447 --> 00:55:52.582
WANT TO BRING MORE VENDORS OUT
00:55:52.649 --> 00:55:54.184
OF THE SHADOWS. WE WANT TO
00:55:54.250 --> 00:55:55.218
LEGITIMATE THE ENTREPRENEURIAL
00:55:55.285 --> 00:55:56.920
ACTIVITY OF TENS OF THOUSANDS OF
00:55:56.986 --> 00:55:58.388
CALIFORNIANS AROUND THE STATE.
00:55:58.455 --> 00:55:59.956
BRINGS A LOT OF LIFE AND
00:56:00.023 --> 00:56:02.726
VIBRANCY TO OUR STREETS AND TO
00:56:02.792 --> 00:56:04.928
THE FOOD SCENE AS WELL, AND IT
00:56:04.994 --> 00:56:05.929
ALSO PROVIDES OPPORTUNITIES FOR
00:56:05.995 --> 00:56:07.330
UPWARD MOBILITY AND GROWTH FOR
00:56:07.397 --> 00:56:08.264
PARTICULARLY OF IMMIGRANT
00:56:08.331 --> 00:56:11.067
FAMILIES. I ALSO BELIEVE THAT
00:56:11.134 --> 00:56:12.602
CHANGES TO THE RETAIL FOLK FOOD
00:56:12.669 --> 00:56:13.803
CODE ARE ESSENTIAL IN ORDER TO
00:56:13.870 --> 00:56:15.939
MAKE IT EASIER FOR MOBILE
00:56:16.005 --> 00:56:17.207
VENDORS TO GET LICENSES SIMPLY
00:56:17.273 --> 00:56:18.274
TOO DIFFICULT UNDER THE CURRENT
00:56:18.341 --> 00:56:20.276
SET OF RULES. SO ALL THIS BILL
00:56:20.343 --> 00:56:23.980
DOES. AT THIS POINT, WE SCALED
00:56:24.047 --> 00:56:26.282
IT BACK TREMENDOUSLY AFTER
00:56:26.349 --> 00:56:27.817
HEARING CONCERNS FROM FOLKS WE
00:56:27.884 --> 00:56:29.619
BASICALLY MET ALL THE THINGS
00:56:29.686 --> 00:56:31.888
THAT THE PEOPLE WHO VOICED
00:56:31.955 --> 00:56:33.556
OPPOSITION OR CONCERNS ABOUT THE
00:56:33.623 --> 00:56:35.058
BILL HAVE ASKED FOR DROPPED
00:56:35.125 --> 00:56:36.059
EVERYTHING ASSOCIATED WITH ANY
00:56:36.126 --> 00:56:37.827
KIND OF ENFORCEMENT. UM WE'RE
00:56:37.894 --> 00:56:42.699
NOW DOWN TO A STUDY. UM AND A
00:56:42.766 --> 00:56:43.800
STUDY ABOUT ABOUT SOMETHING BUT
00:56:43.867 --> 00:56:45.001
A STUDY ABOUT SOME OF THESE
00:56:45.068 --> 00:56:46.136
REALLY IMPORTANT ISSUES. THE
00:56:46.202 --> 00:56:47.704
BILL WOULD REQUIRE GO BIDS TO
00:56:47.771 --> 00:56:49.739
CONSULT WITH A NUMBER OF
00:56:49.806 --> 00:56:51.174
STAKEHOLDERS ON ISSUES THAT BOTH
00:56:51.241 --> 00:56:52.008
VENDORS AND LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
00:56:52.075 --> 00:56:53.076
EXPERIENCE IN THE VENDING SPACE.
00:56:53.143 --> 00:56:54.377
INCLUDING THE CENTER FOR LABOR
00:56:54.444 --> 00:56:55.879
RESEARCH AND EDUCATION. UCLA THE
00:56:55.945 --> 00:56:57.447
CENTER FOR POVERTY INEQUALITY
00:56:57.514 --> 00:56:58.782
RESEARCH AT UC DAVIS VENDOR
00:56:58.848 --> 00:56:59.649
ORGANIZATIONS, LOCALITIES THAT
00:56:59.716 --> 00:57:01.718
HAVE ADOPTED PENDING ORDINANCES.
00:57:01.785 --> 00:57:02.852
AND WE'RE GOING TO LOOK AT
00:57:02.919 --> 00:57:06.122
EVERYTHING AND. YOU KNOW,
00:57:06.189 --> 00:57:08.224
INCLUDING SOME OF THE THREATS TO
00:57:08.291 --> 00:57:10.026
VENDORS THAT HAVE BEEN FACED
00:57:10.093 --> 00:57:11.628
SOME OF THE DANGERS OF THE
00:57:11.694 --> 00:57:13.229
VENDORS FACE AND THERE'S
00:57:13.296 --> 00:57:13.830
ORGANIZED CRASH SHOES THAT WE
00:57:13.897 --> 00:57:14.864
HEAR ABOUT FROM VENDORS.
00:57:14.931 --> 00:57:15.899
OBVIOUSLY CHALLENGES THAT THEY
00:57:15.965 --> 00:57:18.268
HAVE WITH LOCAL GOVERNMENTS. THE
00:57:18.334 --> 00:57:19.636
CHALLENGES LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
00:57:19.702 --> 00:57:21.571
HAVE WITH THEM, AND WE REALLY
00:57:21.638 --> 00:57:23.373
WANT TO GET TO THE BOTTOM OF A
00:57:23.439 --> 00:57:24.541
LOT OF THE ISSUES THAT ARE
00:57:24.607 --> 00:57:26.476
PLAYED HERE SO WE CAN MAKE
00:57:26.543 --> 00:57:27.911
BETTER DECISIONS IN THE FUTURE.
00:57:27.977 --> 00:57:29.312
GOBI IS WILL PROVIDE THE
00:57:29.379 --> 00:57:30.814
LEGISLATURE THEN WITH
00:57:30.880 --> 00:57:31.447
RECOMMENDATIONS TO BOTH REDUCE
00:57:31.514 --> 00:57:32.081
OCCURRENCES OF REPEAT REPEATED
00:57:32.148 --> 00:57:32.615
NONCOMPLIANCE. WITH LOCAL
00:57:32.682 --> 00:57:33.550
SIDEWALK SIDEWALK VENDING
00:57:33.616 --> 00:57:35.418
ORDINANCES AND REDUCE WAYS.
00:57:35.485 --> 00:57:36.419
REDUCE BARRIERS THAT CURRENTLY
00:57:36.486 --> 00:57:40.089
PREVENT VENDORS. FROM GETTING
00:57:40.156 --> 00:57:41.090
OBTAINING LEGITIMATE PERMITS AND
00:57:41.157 --> 00:57:44.093
MOVING INTO THIS THIS
00:57:44.160 --> 00:57:44.894
ENTREPRENEURIAL SPACE
00:57:44.961 --> 00:57:48.431
LEGITIMATELY. SO I BELIEVE THIS
00:57:48.498 --> 00:57:51.501
PROPOSAL IS PART OF A OF AN
00:57:51.568 --> 00:57:52.869
IMPORTANT IN DEPTH CONVERSATION
00:57:52.936 --> 00:57:54.604
THAT WE'RE GOING TO ENGAGE IN ON
00:57:54.671 --> 00:57:56.005
THE ISSUES THAT LOCALITIES AND
00:57:56.072 --> 00:57:57.073
VENDORS ACROSS THE STATE
00:57:57.140 --> 00:57:59.142
EXPERIENCE. IT'S GOING TO LOOK
00:57:59.209 --> 00:58:00.143
AT EXPERIENCES FROM MANY
00:58:00.210 --> 00:58:01.244
DIFFERENT KINDS OF COMMUNITIES,
00:58:01.311 --> 00:58:02.278
NOT CERTAINLY LOOK AT THE
00:58:02.345 --> 00:58:04.447
HEAVILY TOURISTED AREAS LIKE A
00:58:04.514 --> 00:58:05.615
AROUND IN AND AROUND SANTA
00:58:05.682 --> 00:58:07.517
MONICA PIER, BUT ALSO IN OTHER
00:58:07.584 --> 00:58:08.685
PARTS OF THE STATE THAT HAVE
00:58:08.751 --> 00:58:09.919
VERY DIFFERENT EXPERIENCES. AND
00:58:09.986 --> 00:58:10.954
THE INFORMATION WILL ULTIMATELY
00:58:11.020 --> 00:58:12.655
HELP THE LEGISLATURE FIND BOTH
00:58:12.722 --> 00:58:13.156
INACCESSIBLE PATHWAY FOR
00:58:13.223 --> 00:58:14.057
CALIFORNIA'S MOBILE VENDORS TO
00:58:14.123 --> 00:58:15.758
OPERATE LEGALLY AND THEN DEFY
00:58:15.825 --> 00:58:16.993
MEANINGFUL SCHOOLS FOR LOCAL
00:58:17.060 --> 00:58:17.560
GOVERNMENTS TO ENSURE THAT
00:58:17.627 --> 00:58:18.561
VENDING IS OCCURRING IN CONCERT
00:58:18.628 --> 00:58:22.365
WITH PUBLIC HEALTH. AND SAFETY.
00:58:22.432 --> 00:58:24.667
SO TODAY WITH ME AND SUPPORTED
00:58:24.734 --> 00:58:26.636
SYLVIA SILLY SHOT FROM WHO'S
00:58:26.703 --> 00:58:28.438
SPEAKING ON BEHALF OF THE CITY,
00:58:28.504 --> 00:58:29.505
SANTA MONICA AND AMELIA'S AND
00:58:29.572 --> 00:58:30.740
MONEY FROM THE CALIFORNIA TRAVEL
00:58:30.807 --> 00:58:31.608
ASSOCIATION. I WOULD LIKE TO
00:58:31.674 --> 00:58:33.309
INTERRUPT REAL QUICKLY AND
00:58:33.376 --> 00:58:35.345
ESTABLISH A QUORUM IF WE COULD
00:58:35.411 --> 00:58:39.215
AGUIAR-CURRY BLACKIE PRESIDENT
00:58:39.282 --> 00:58:41.384
BLUM BLUM PRESIDENT BERNARD HARV
00:58:41.451 --> 00:58:43.219
, AC HARVARD PRESIDENT RAMOS
00:58:43.286 --> 00:58:44.454
RAMOS PRESIDENT THREE OF US.
00:58:44.520 --> 00:58:50.326
SANTIAGO. VOEPEL PRESENT QUORUM.
00:58:50.393 --> 00:58:54.397
THANK YOU MAY PROCEED. THANK YOU
00:58:54.464 --> 00:58:56.199
. GOOD AFTERNOON, SYLVIA SALAS
00:58:56.266 --> 00:58:58.001
SHAW HERE ON BEHALF OF THE CITY
00:58:58.067 --> 00:58:59.936
OF SANTA MONICA. THANK YOU TO
00:59:00.003 --> 00:59:01.905
THE COMMITTEE FOR THEIR ANALYSIS
00:59:01.971 --> 00:59:04.440
AND FOR LISTENING TO OUR
00:59:04.507 --> 00:59:07.043
CONCERNS AS RAISED AND REALLY
00:59:07.110 --> 00:59:09.112
FOR LETTING US HAVE A FORUM TO
00:59:09.178 --> 00:59:10.246
DISCUSS THE ISSUES THAT WE'RE
00:59:10.313 --> 00:59:13.016
SEEING LOCALLY. SANTA MONICA WAS
00:59:13.082 --> 00:59:14.317
ONE OF THE FIRST CITIES IN
00:59:14.384 --> 00:59:16.753
CALIFORNIA TO ADOPT AN ORDINANCE
00:59:16.819 --> 00:59:18.187
PERTAINING TO STREET VENDING
00:59:18.254 --> 00:59:20.590
IMMEDIATELY AFTER SP 946 BY
00:59:20.657 --> 00:59:22.225
SENATOR THEN SENATOR LAURA WAS
00:59:22.292 --> 00:59:26.262
SIGNED INTO LAW. TO DATE. WE
00:59:26.329 --> 00:59:29.866
HAVE, UM PERMITTED ALMOST 100. I
00:59:29.933 --> 00:59:33.002
THINK 100 VENDORS. UH JUST AS A
00:59:33.069 --> 00:59:34.504
COMPARISON, THE CITY OF LOS
00:59:34.570 --> 00:59:36.806
ANGELES IN A STUDY THAT'S NOTED
00:59:36.873 --> 00:59:38.975
IN THE ANALYSIS HAS ONLY 165
00:59:39.042 --> 00:59:40.376
PERMITTED VENDORS. SO I THINK
00:59:40.443 --> 00:59:43.212
THIS IS SANTA MONICA IS DOING
00:59:43.279 --> 00:59:43.780
MORE THAN THEIR FAIR SHARE,
00:59:43.846 --> 00:59:44.547
CONSIDERING THE SIZE OF OUR
00:59:44.614 --> 00:59:49.419
CITY. WE STRONGLY SUPPORT THE
00:59:49.485 --> 00:59:52.088
STREAMLINING OF THE RETAIL FOOD
00:59:52.155 --> 00:59:54.090
CODE AND OTHER WAYS FOR MEMBERS
00:59:54.157 --> 00:59:57.593
FOR VENDORS TO GET PERMITTED AND
00:59:57.660 --> 01:00:00.496
BECOME PART OF OUR LOCAL ECONOMY
01:00:00.563 --> 01:00:04.467
. HOWEVER WE DO WE HAVE SEEN AND
01:00:04.534 --> 01:00:05.835
CONFRONTED SOME ISSUES WITH
01:00:05.902 --> 01:00:09.072
FOLKS WHO ARE NON COMPLIANT. AND
01:00:09.138 --> 01:00:11.908
WHO ARE NONCOMPLIANT REPEATEDLY?
01:00:11.975 --> 01:00:14.277
THAT'S WHY WE CAME TO SENATOR
01:00:14.344 --> 01:00:15.511
ALLEN AND ASKED FOR HIS HELP IN
01:00:15.578 --> 01:00:18.247
ADDRESSING THIS ISSUE. CURRENTLY
01:00:18.314 --> 01:00:20.249
THE BILL IS A STUDY. WE THINK
01:00:20.316 --> 01:00:22.151
THAT THE COMMITTEE HAS WE HAVE
01:00:22.218 --> 01:00:23.319
WORKED WITH THE COMMITTEE VERY
01:00:23.386 --> 01:00:24.787
CLOSELY WITH SENATOR ALLEN ON
01:00:24.854 --> 01:00:26.289
THESE AMENDMENTS THAT ADDRESS
01:00:26.356 --> 01:00:27.423
THAT VERY CLEARLY ADDRESSED THE
01:00:27.490 --> 01:00:30.026
CONCERNS THAT WERE RAISED. BY
01:00:30.093 --> 01:00:32.895
THE OPPOSITION. UM IT'S AS
01:00:32.962 --> 01:00:35.064
SENATOR ALLEN NOTED, IT'S GOING
01:00:35.131 --> 01:00:36.699
TO RAISE THE ISSUES OF
01:00:36.766 --> 01:00:37.900
ENFORCEMENT. BUT ALSO WHAT ARE
01:00:37.967 --> 01:00:39.802
THE BARRIERS THAT VENDORS ARE
01:00:39.869 --> 01:00:42.472
SEEING LOCALLY. AND WHAT CAN BE
01:00:42.538 --> 01:00:43.940
DONE TO ADDRESS THEM. THEY'RE
01:00:44.007 --> 01:00:45.008
CONSULTING EVENT, THE
01:00:45.074 --> 01:00:46.943
STAKEHOLDERS IN THE VENDOR
01:00:47.010 --> 01:00:48.811
COMMUNITY AS WELL AS LOCALS AND
01:00:48.878 --> 01:00:53.583
A COUPLE OF RESEARCH. UM CENTERS
01:00:53.649 --> 01:00:55.651
. SO WE STRONGLY ASK FOR YOUR
01:00:55.718 --> 01:00:57.754
SUPPORT. AND PLEASE LET ME KNOW
01:00:57.820 --> 01:00:59.022
IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS. THANK
01:00:59.088 --> 01:01:03.926
YOU. PROCEED. THANK YOU, CHAIR
01:01:03.993 --> 01:01:05.728
AND MEMBERS AND THANK YOU TO THE
01:01:05.795 --> 01:01:07.030
COMMITTEE FOR THEIR WORK ON THIS
01:01:07.096 --> 01:01:08.765
BILL AND THE ANALYSIS AND THANK
01:01:08.831 --> 01:01:10.233
YOU TO SENATOR ALLEN FOR HIS
01:01:10.299 --> 01:01:12.035
WORK ON THIS VERY COMPLICATED
01:01:12.101 --> 01:01:14.771
ISSUE, UM, JUST TO ADD AN
01:01:14.837 --> 01:01:16.239
ADDITIONAL LAYER TO WHAT THE
01:01:16.305 --> 01:01:17.507
SENATOR AND WHAT SYLVIA SAID ON
01:01:17.573 --> 01:01:19.509
BEHALF OF THE CITY. I AM AMELIA
01:01:19.575 --> 01:01:20.443
ZAMANI, THE DIRECTOR OF
01:01:20.510 --> 01:01:22.512
GOVERNMENT AFFAIRS AND PUBLIC
01:01:22.578 --> 01:01:23.179
POLICY FOR THE CALIFORNIA TRAVEL
01:01:23.246 --> 01:01:25.081
ASSOCIATION. WE ARE THE ADVOCACY
01:01:25.148 --> 01:01:25.815
ORGANIZATION REPRESENTING THE
01:01:25.882 --> 01:01:26.716
STATE'S TRAVEL AND TOURISM
01:01:26.783 --> 01:01:29.385
INDUSTRY. OUR MEMBERSHIP
01:01:29.452 --> 01:01:31.554
INCLUDES SOME OF THOSE HIGH
01:01:31.621 --> 01:01:32.422
TOURISM AREAS THAT THE SENATOR
01:01:32.488 --> 01:01:34.157
ALLUDED TO IN HIS OPENING
01:01:34.223 --> 01:01:35.558
FISHERMAN'S WARF FROM PIER 39
01:01:35.625 --> 01:01:37.593
UNION SQUARE IN SAN FRANCISCO.
01:01:37.660 --> 01:01:39.862
SANTA MONICA PIER. UM OUR
01:01:39.929 --> 01:01:40.997
COALITION ALSO INCLUDES SUFFICE
01:01:41.064 --> 01:01:44.233
STADIUM IN INGLEWOOD. BALBOA
01:01:44.300 --> 01:01:45.301
PARK IN BELMONT PARK IN SAN
01:01:45.368 --> 01:01:47.270
DIEGO AND SANTA CRUZ BOARDWALK
01:01:47.336 --> 01:01:49.138
AS WELL AS VISIT SACRAMENTO
01:01:49.205 --> 01:01:50.306
WHO'S STARTING TO SEE MORE
01:01:50.373 --> 01:01:52.575
UNPERMITTED VENDING SURROUNDING
01:01:52.642 --> 01:01:54.610
YOU KNOW, NIGHTCLUB CLOSURES AND
01:01:54.677 --> 01:01:56.345
IN THE EARLY MORNING HOURS AND
01:01:56.412 --> 01:01:59.715
EVENTS AT GOLDEN ONE SO. YOU
01:01:59.782 --> 01:02:02.151
KNOW, WE AS CAL TRAVEL, THE
01:02:02.218 --> 01:02:03.920
TOURISM INDUSTRY. WE ARE
01:02:03.986 --> 01:02:06.355
SUPPORTIVE OF, UM, LOWERING THE
01:02:06.422 --> 01:02:07.957
BARRIERS FOR STREET VENDING
01:02:08.024 --> 01:02:09.325
STREET. VENDING IS AN IMPORTANT
01:02:09.392 --> 01:02:11.661
PART OF THE CULTURE AND FLAVOR
01:02:11.727 --> 01:02:12.762
OF OUR DESTINATIONS AND
01:02:12.829 --> 01:02:13.696
SOMETHING THAT'S VERY
01:02:13.763 --> 01:02:19.802
ATTRACTIVE. TWO VISITORS. UM, WE. ECHOING WHAT SYLVIA SAID. JUST
01:02:19.869 --> 01:02:21.504
WANT TO ENSURE THAT EVERYONE ON
01:02:21.571 --> 01:02:23.106
BOTH SIDES HAS BENEFITING FROM
01:02:23.172 --> 01:02:24.507
LEGISLATION GOING FORWARD,
01:02:24.574 --> 01:02:25.875
PROTECTING THE VENDORS WHO ARE
01:02:25.942 --> 01:02:27.443
TRYING TO DO WHAT'S RIGHT AS
01:02:27.510 --> 01:02:29.178
THEY'RE SELLING THEIR GOODS AND
01:02:29.245 --> 01:02:30.480
THEIR FOODS AND LOCAL
01:02:30.546 --> 01:02:31.848
GOVERNMENTS WHO ARE TRYING TO
01:02:31.914 --> 01:02:34.684
ENFORCE THEIR ORDINANCES. SO
01:02:34.750 --> 01:02:36.819
WE'RE INTERESTED IN SEEKING ANY
01:02:36.886 --> 01:02:37.687
SOLUTIONS THAT WOULD PROTECT
01:02:37.753 --> 01:02:39.956
VENDORS AS I MENTIONED, AND WE
01:02:40.022 --> 01:02:40.957
BELIEVE THE REPORT CREATED BY
01:02:41.023 --> 01:02:42.492
THIS BILL AS A REASONABLE FIRST
01:02:42.558 --> 01:02:43.693
STEP TO EXPLORE WHAT IS AND
01:02:43.759 --> 01:02:45.561
ISN'T WORKING FOR VENDORS IN OUR
01:02:45.628 --> 01:02:46.629
COMMUNITIES. AS WE SEEK TO
01:02:46.696 --> 01:02:48.231
CONTINUE IMPLEMENTING VENDING
01:02:48.297 --> 01:02:49.699
ORDINANCES. WE HOPE WE CAN
01:02:49.765 --> 01:02:51.834
CONTINUE WORKING ON THIS ISSUE
01:02:51.901 --> 01:02:52.401
TO ENSURE ACCESSIBLE STREET
01:02:52.468 --> 01:02:53.903
VENDING PROGRAMS, AND WE
01:02:53.970 --> 01:02:54.737
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR
01:02:54.804 --> 01:02:56.739
SUPPORT OF THIS MEASURE TODAY.
01:02:56.806 --> 01:02:58.908
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. CAN DO WE
01:02:58.975 --> 01:03:00.309
HAVE ANY OTHER WITNESSES WHO
01:03:00.376 --> 01:03:01.444
WOULD LIKE TO EXPRESS THEIR
01:03:01.511 --> 01:03:04.580
SUPPORT FOR THE SENATE BILL.
01:03:04.647 --> 01:03:05.781
SAYING NONE. DO WE HAVE ANY
01:03:05.848 --> 01:03:08.518
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION? SEE
01:03:08.584 --> 01:03:24.967
SOMEONE COMING FORWARD.
01:03:32.175 --> 01:03:42.485
YOU MAY PROCEED. GOOD AFTERNOON
01:03:42.552 --> 01:03:44.654
. MY NAME IS MARCEL AND I AM A
01:03:44.720 --> 01:03:45.788
LOS ANGELES STREET FOOD VENDOR.
01:03:45.855 --> 01:03:48.424
I AM THE CEO OF MY BUSINESS,
01:03:48.491 --> 01:03:49.926
WHICH IS JAMAICAN FOOD. THIS
01:03:49.992 --> 01:03:51.661
WEEK, A FARMERS MARKET REACHED
01:03:51.727 --> 01:03:53.863
OUT TO ME ASKED TO ME TO BE A
01:03:53.930 --> 01:03:55.131
PART OF THEIR FARMERS MARKET.
01:03:55.198 --> 01:03:56.699
AND THE REQUIREMENTS OR
01:03:56.766 --> 01:03:59.368
ASTRONOMICAL. I WOULD NEED
01:03:59.435 --> 01:04:01.437
ACCESS TO A PREP, SINK A PREP
01:04:01.504 --> 01:04:03.306
KITCHEN OR A SHARED KITCHEN AND
01:04:03.372 --> 01:04:05.374
PAY A HEALTHY FEE. TO THE HEALTH
01:04:05.441 --> 01:04:08.211
DEPARTMENT OF $500. BECAUSE OF
01:04:08.277 --> 01:04:09.579
THIS CURRENT REQUIREMENT. THIS
01:04:09.645 --> 01:04:11.247
IS VERY DIFFICULT FOR ME TO
01:04:11.314 --> 01:04:13.616
OBTAIN AND DUE TO THE LACK OF
01:04:13.683 --> 01:04:15.851
PERMIT. IF I'M CAUGHT, I'LL GET
01:04:15.918 --> 01:04:17.253
A CITATION. THE FEES AND FINES
01:04:17.320 --> 01:04:18.654
ARE DEMANDING AND PUT A HUGE
01:04:18.721 --> 01:04:21.123
DENT IN MY ABILITY TO WORK.
01:04:21.190 --> 01:04:21.958
THERE ARE MANY OTHERS OUT THERE
01:04:22.024 --> 01:04:25.161
LIKE ME WHO FEELS THIS WAY?
01:04:25.228 --> 01:04:27.296
VENDORS ARE PUT IN AN IMPOSSIBLE
01:04:27.363 --> 01:04:28.598
POSITION AND PUTTING THEM IN
01:04:28.664 --> 01:04:29.899
MORE OF A FINANCIAL HARDSHIP
01:04:29.966 --> 01:04:33.402
THAT THEY WERE BEFORE. BUT I AM
01:04:33.469 --> 01:04:35.538
MY BEST INVESTMENT IN ME. THAT
01:04:35.605 --> 01:04:37.440
IS WHY I DO. ST BRENDAN
01:04:37.506 --> 01:04:39.775
CITATIONS PUT ME IN A PLACE OF
01:04:39.842 --> 01:04:40.943
FEELING DEFEATED AND FIGURING
01:04:41.010 --> 01:04:44.247
OUT MY NEXT MOVE. WHY WOULD YOU
01:04:44.313 --> 01:04:46.215
BE INVESTING? WHY ARE YOU NOT
01:04:46.282 --> 01:04:49.085
INVESTING IN VENDORS? STUDIES
01:04:49.151 --> 01:04:50.119
ALREADY SHOWED THAT STREET
01:04:50.186 --> 01:04:51.187
VENDORS ARE PIVOTAL TO THE
01:04:51.254 --> 01:04:53.556
ECONOMY. THE STUDY THAT YOU WILL
01:04:53.623 --> 01:04:56.692
BE FINANCING SHOULD THE BODY GO
01:04:56.759 --> 01:04:58.194
TO HELPING VENDORS GET THEIR
01:04:58.261 --> 01:05:00.596
PERMITS, FUNDING FOR HEALTH
01:05:00.663 --> 01:05:02.365
PERMITS, EDUCATION AND FUNDING
01:05:02.431 --> 01:05:03.299
FOR ACCESSIBLE COMMENTARIES AND
01:05:03.366 --> 01:05:06.636
SHARED KITCHEN. I KNOW HOW
01:05:06.702 --> 01:05:08.771
VENDORS ARE TREATED WITH THIS
01:05:08.838 --> 01:05:10.740
STUDY. WE KNOW THAT THEY'RE
01:05:10.806 --> 01:05:12.675
GOING TO BE PUSHED FROM THIS
01:05:12.742 --> 01:05:13.142
TYPE THE SAME TYPE OF
01:05:13.209 --> 01:05:14.543
ENFORCEMENT ENFORCEMENT I HAVE
01:05:14.610 --> 01:05:15.578
EXPERIENCED IS BOTH
01:05:15.645 --> 01:05:18.948
TRAUMATIZING. AND PUTS ME IN
01:05:19.015 --> 01:05:20.816
DEEP FINANCIAL HARDSHIP WITHOUT
01:05:20.883 --> 01:05:23.486
ANY REAL OPPORTUNITY TO COMPLY.
01:05:23.552 --> 01:05:25.888
WHAT IS GOING TO HAPPEN TO
01:05:25.955 --> 01:05:27.790
VENDORS IN THE AREAS ACROSS
01:05:27.857 --> 01:05:28.824
CALIFORNIA ARE LESS INCLUSIVE OF
01:05:28.891 --> 01:05:31.360
VENDORS IN THEIR ECONOMY. I
01:05:31.427 --> 01:05:33.429
ENCOURAGE YOU TO VOTE NO. ON SB
01:05:33.496 --> 01:05:35.798
12 90 THIS STRAIGHT FROM THE
01:05:35.865 --> 01:05:38.267
VERY REAL ISSUE OF INVESTMENT IN
01:05:38.334 --> 01:05:38.901
ENTREPRENEURS WHO ARE INTEGRAL
01:05:38.968 --> 01:05:41.037
TO OUR ECONOMY. THANK YOU. THANK
01:05:41.103 --> 01:05:44.440
YOU. YOU MAY PROCEDURE. GOOD
01:05:44.507 --> 01:05:46.008
AFTERNOON, MR CHAIRMAN MEMBERS
01:05:46.075 --> 01:05:47.109
CHRISTOPHER SANCHEZ POLICY
01:05:47.176 --> 01:05:48.844
ADVOCATE THE WESTERN CENTER ON
01:05:48.911 --> 01:05:49.478
LAW AND POVERTY, RESPECTFULLY
01:05:49.545 --> 01:05:51.147
OPPOSED TO SP 12 90 YEARS IN
01:05:51.213 --> 01:05:53.049
PRINT. WESTERN CENTER IS PROUD
01:05:53.115 --> 01:05:55.017
TO BE PART OF THE CALIFORNIA
01:05:55.084 --> 01:05:55.918
STREET. MANY COALITION, A
01:05:55.985 --> 01:05:56.952
COALITION MADE UP OF COMMUNITY
01:05:57.019 --> 01:05:58.387
BASED ORGANIZATIONS, SERVICE
01:05:58.454 --> 01:06:00.656
PROVIDERS AND, MOST IMPORTANTLY
01:06:00.723 --> 01:06:02.725
, LED AND DIRECTED EVERY STEP OF
01:06:02.792 --> 01:06:03.959
THE WAY BY STREET VENDORS FROM
01:06:04.026 --> 01:06:05.094
ACROSS THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA.
01:06:05.161 --> 01:06:06.429
DO YOU WANT TO EXPRESS OUR
01:06:06.495 --> 01:06:07.797
APPRECIATION TO THE CHAIR AND
01:06:07.863 --> 01:06:09.398
THE COMMITTEE STAFF AT THE FOR
01:06:09.465 --> 01:06:10.633
MEETING WITH COMMUNITY MEMBERS
01:06:10.700 --> 01:06:11.567
AND HEAR YOUR CONCERNS AND
01:06:11.634 --> 01:06:12.635
WRITING A VERY THOROUGH
01:06:12.702 --> 01:06:13.369
ANALYSIS? WE APPRECIATE THE
01:06:13.436 --> 01:06:14.570
DIRECTION OF THE AMENDMENTS. THE
01:06:14.637 --> 01:06:15.638
COMMITTEE IS PROPOSING TO ENSURE
01:06:15.705 --> 01:06:17.740
THAT ANY RESOURCES THAT ARE
01:06:17.807 --> 01:06:19.909
SPENT ON THE TOPIC OF STREET
01:06:19.975 --> 01:06:21.110
VENDING, TAKES A BALANCED
01:06:21.177 --> 01:06:21.677
APPROACH AND TELLS THE WOLE
01:06:21.744 --> 01:06:22.912
STORY OF STREET VENDING AND HOW
01:06:22.978 --> 01:06:25.114
IT LOOKS LIKE IN CALIFORNIA,
01:06:25.181 --> 01:06:25.648
HOWEVER, ORGANIZATION THE
01:06:25.715 --> 01:06:27.016
COALITION IS UNABLE TO REMOVE
01:06:27.083 --> 01:06:28.384
THE OPPOSITION TODAY. FOR TWO
01:06:28.451 --> 01:06:30.319
MAIN REASONS. FIRST AS I
01:06:30.386 --> 01:06:31.320
MENTIONED, OUR COALITION IS
01:06:31.387 --> 01:06:33.255
DIRECTED BY STREET VENDORS, AND
01:06:33.322 --> 01:06:34.457
WE HAVE NOT HAD THE CHANCE TO
01:06:34.523 --> 01:06:35.391
CHANGE OUR POSITION ARE
01:06:35.458 --> 01:06:36.392
DISCUSSING POSITION WITH OUR
01:06:36.459 --> 01:06:38.894
EXPERT PANEL STREET VENDORS. WHO
01:06:38.961 --> 01:06:40.062
HAS PROVIDED COUNTLESS OF HOURS
01:06:40.129 --> 01:06:41.230
OF GUIDANCE ON OUR LEGISLATIVE
01:06:41.297 --> 01:06:43.899
POSITIONS. SECOND THE ORIGINS OF
01:06:43.966 --> 01:06:45.935
THIS BILL HAS COME FROM A PLACE
01:06:46.001 --> 01:06:47.103
THAT HAS BEEN D<c.cyan> DEHUMANIZING TO</c>
01:06:47.169 --> 01:06:48.504
OUR COMMUNITY. FIRST THE FIRST
01:06:48.571 --> 01:06:49.872
ITERATION OF THE BILL WAS
01:06:49.939 --> 01:06:50.673
CALIFORNIA'S VERSION OF THE SHOW
01:06:50.740 --> 01:06:52.842
ME YOUR PAPERS BILL BY REQUIRING
01:06:52.908 --> 01:06:54.410
VENDORS THE SHOW I D S AND
01:06:54.477 --> 01:06:55.478
IMPOUNDING THEIR CARDS. THEN THE
01:06:55.544 --> 01:06:56.645
DOOR IS AMENDED TO PUT STREET
01:06:56.712 --> 01:06:58.547
VENDORS THAT ARE IN POVERTY, WHO
01:06:58.614 --> 01:06:59.648
ARE RECIPIENTS OF CALIBRATION
01:06:59.715 --> 01:07:01.517
COW WORKS INTO DEBT TRAPS THAT
01:07:01.584 --> 01:07:03.452
PLACE NO FURTHER INTO POVERTY.
01:07:03.519 --> 01:07:04.019
AND NOW TODAY, THE BUILDING
01:07:04.086 --> 01:07:06.756
PRINT IS A STUDY. STREET VENDORS
01:07:06.822 --> 01:07:08.124
FROM THE COALITION ARE TIRED AND
01:07:08.190 --> 01:07:09.692
EXHAUSTED THE SUPPORTERS OF THIS
01:07:09.759 --> 01:07:11.060
BILL CONTINUING TO DEHUMANIZING
01:07:11.127 --> 01:07:12.361
, CRIMINALIZE OUR COMMUNITY THAT
01:07:12.428 --> 01:07:13.596
THE AND THAT IS HAS VERY RACIAL
01:07:13.662 --> 01:07:16.432
UNDERTONES. YOU MAY HAVE HEARD
01:07:16.499 --> 01:07:18.534
FROM THE SUPPORTERS OF SP 12 98
01:07:18.601 --> 01:07:19.435
THAT THERE ARE STREET VENDORS
01:07:19.502 --> 01:07:21.036
WHO SELL CANNABIS, THICKER AND
01:07:21.103 --> 01:07:22.471
STOLEN GOODS. I'M HAPPY TO TELL
01:07:22.538 --> 01:07:24.340
YOU THAT THE VENDORS WE WORK
01:07:24.407 --> 01:07:25.474
WITH THAT ARE TRUE
01:07:25.541 --> 01:07:25.875
REPRESENTATION AND
01:07:25.941 --> 01:07:26.742
REPRESENTATION OF STREET VENDORS
01:07:26.809 --> 01:07:27.843
IN THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA.
01:07:27.910 --> 01:07:29.378
DON'T HAVE ANY CANNABIS IN THE
01:07:29.445 --> 01:07:30.746
TAMALES THAT THE LIKE THAT
01:07:30.813 --> 01:07:32.948
THERE'S NO LIQUOR IN THE DRINK
01:07:33.015 --> 01:07:33.949
CHICKEN. EVERY ITEM STREAM
01:07:34.016 --> 01:07:34.617
UNDERSELL IS PURCHASED WITH THE
01:07:34.683 --> 01:07:35.584
HARD EARNED MONEY THAT THEY'VE
01:07:35.651 --> 01:07:37.219
INVESTED INTO THEIR BUSINESSES.
01:07:37.286 --> 01:07:38.354
LASTLY OUR COALITION IS OPPOSED
01:07:38.421 --> 01:07:40.856
TO THE BILL. BECAUSE OF THE
01:07:40.923 --> 01:07:42.758
STATE'S GOING TO SPEND ANY
01:07:42.825 --> 01:07:43.359
RESOURCES ON STREET VENDING.
01:07:43.426 --> 01:07:44.427
THEY SHOULD SPEND IT EVERY
01:07:44.493 --> 01:07:45.795
SINGLE DIME OF HELPING AND
01:07:45.861 --> 01:07:46.729
ASSISTING STREET VENDORS
01:07:46.796 --> 01:07:47.463
BUILDING THEIR SMALL BUSINESSES
01:07:47.530 --> 01:07:48.597
AND OPEN UP REAL PATHWAYS TO
01:07:48.664 --> 01:07:49.799
BEING ABLE TO EMBRACE THEIR
01:07:49.865 --> 01:07:51.700
UNCLE MICRO ENTREPRENEURSHIP.
01:07:51.767 --> 01:07:54.437
TODAY IT IS FOR THESE REASONS
01:07:54.503 --> 01:07:56.572
THAT WE ASKED FOR YOU TO LOOK AT
01:07:56.639 --> 01:07:57.740
IT CLOSELY AND THAT'S WHY WE
01:07:57.807 --> 01:08:00.009
OPPOSE THE BILL TODAY. OKAY
01:08:00.075 --> 01:08:01.243
THANK YOU. IS THERE ANYBODY ELSE
01:08:01.310 --> 01:08:03.045
WHO WOULD LIKE TO EXPRESS THEIR
01:08:03.112 --> 01:08:09.585
OPPOSITION TO THIS MEASURE?
01:08:09.652 --> 01:08:10.586
NAME, POSITION AND ORGANIZATION,
01:08:10.653 --> 01:08:16.025
PLEASE. HI. MY NAME IS CARLA DE
01:08:16.091 --> 01:08:17.193
PAST THE COMMUNITY, OUR
01:08:17.259 --> 01:08:18.194
COLLECTIVE AND WE ARE OPPOSING
01:08:18.260 --> 01:08:24.800
THIS BILL. THE NUMBER IS ANA
01:08:24.867 --> 01:08:26.202
MARTINEZ AND I AM FROM CHILA. I
01:08:26.268 --> 01:08:28.337
AM FROM LOS ANGELES CITY. AND I
01:08:28.404 --> 01:08:30.539
AM AM ORGANIZER. THANK YOU N OR
01:08:30.606 --> 01:08:39.381
POSE 12 90. QUÊ. THE SERVICE
01:08:39.448 --> 01:08:41.083
REFERENCE FOR THIS. SO THE SOUTH
01:08:41.150 --> 01:08:43.252
HUESO? YES THE STATE COMPTROLLER
01:08:43.319 --> 01:08:54.029
S IT. MM. DOESN'T THANK YOU.
01:08:54.096 --> 01:08:54.864
THEY ASKED ME NOMINATES MIGUEL
01:08:54.930 --> 01:08:58.300
TOURISM MOORLACH. YESTERDAY AND
01:08:58.367 --> 01:09:08.611
CONTRACT HOLIDAY SML. THANK YOU.
01:09:08.677 --> 01:09:12.548
BUENOS DIAS CHAVEZ MINGLE
01:09:12.615 --> 01:09:16.986
COLLECTIVE MONETARIO REYES
01:09:17.052 --> 01:09:17.786
REALISM EVENT. GRACIAS. THANK
01:09:17.853 --> 01:09:29.832
YOU. WHEN I STARTED. MOVING
01:09:29.899 --> 01:09:42.111
QUESTION. ALICE. THANK YOU. HI
01:09:42.177 --> 01:09:43.779
GOOD AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS
01:09:43.846 --> 01:09:45.714
MARLYN SAMARA AND I MUST TREAT
01:09:45.781 --> 01:09:47.316
BENDER IN LOS ANGELES AND
01:09:47.383 --> 01:09:49.685
THOUSANDS, UM, PALMS AND RIGHT
01:09:49.752 --> 01:09:51.720
THERE BY PAUL SPRINGS AND I
01:09:51.787 --> 01:09:54.123
OPPOSE ON S BEING 12 90. THANK
01:09:54.189 --> 01:10:00.129
YOU. GOOD AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS
01:10:00.195 --> 01:10:01.330
LYNETTE ROBINSON. I AM A
01:10:01.397 --> 01:10:02.965
ENTREPRENEUR AND START A
01:10:03.032 --> 01:10:04.466
BUSINESS OWNER IN THE IN AN
01:10:04.533 --> 01:10:06.135
EMPIRE. SOMEBODY NO COUNTY, UM,
01:10:06.201 --> 01:10:08.437
ALSO A STREET VENDOR IN LOS
01:10:08.504 --> 01:10:09.672
ANGELES AND LOS ANGELES COUNTY
01:10:09.738 --> 01:10:12.107
AREAS, AND I, UM OPPOSE SB 12
01:10:12.174 --> 01:10:19.481
90. THANK YOU. MY NAME IS ANNA
01:10:19.548 --> 01:10:21.417
MATTHEWS. I'M A POLICY INTERNET,
01:10:21.483 --> 01:10:22.418
THE WESTERN CENTER ON LAW AND
01:10:22.484 --> 01:10:23.752
POVERTY AND WE STRENGTHS AND
01:10:23.819 --> 01:10:24.787
STRONG OPPOSITION AGAINST THIS
01:10:24.853 --> 01:10:29.792
BILL. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. MY
01:10:29.858 --> 01:10:30.960
NAME'S LYRIC KILOGRAM. THE
01:10:31.026 --> 01:10:32.628
POLICY DIRECTOR AT INCLUSIVE
01:10:32.695 --> 01:10:34.630
ACTION FOR THE CITY BASED IN LOS
01:10:34.697 --> 01:10:40.302
ANGELES, AND WE OPPOSE SB 12 90.
01:10:40.369 --> 01:10:42.104
KÞT MCEWAN, STAFF ATTORNEY WITH
01:10:42.171 --> 01:10:43.839
PUBLIC COUNCIL AND OPPOSITION TO
01:10:43.906 --> 01:10:45.040
THE BILL IN PRINT. THANK YOU.
01:10:45.107 --> 01:10:51.280
THANK YOU. VANESSA MERINO FROM
01:10:51.347 --> 01:10:52.481
WITHIN CALIFORNIA WITH BROWN
01:10:52.548 --> 01:10:54.350
ISSUES AND OPPOSITION OF SB 12
01:10:54.416 --> 01:11:00.356
90. THANK YOU. LOPEZ DIRECTOR OF
01:11:00.422 --> 01:11:01.523
BROWN ISSUES IN OPPOSITION OF
01:11:01.590 --> 01:11:08.697
12, 90. THANK YOU. HI EVERYONE
01:11:08.764 --> 01:11:09.665
IN KIMBERLEY GODINA WITH BROWN
01:11:09.732 --> 01:11:11.634
ISSUES, AND AS A DAUGHTER OF A
01:11:11.700 --> 01:11:12.868
STREET VENDOR FROM SACRAMENTO. I
01:11:12.935 --> 01:11:17.239
STRONGLY OPPOSE AS B 12 90. OKAY
01:11:17.306 --> 01:11:18.340
OPPORTUNITY FOR QUESTIONS FROM
01:11:18.407 --> 01:11:24.013
THE COMMITTEE. COMMENTS.
01:11:24.079 --> 01:11:26.048
CEREMONY SHE MAY PROCEED. THANK
01:11:26.115 --> 01:11:28.951
YOU, MR CHAIR AND JUST HEARING
01:11:29.018 --> 01:11:31.020
THE TESTIMONY IN HEARING SOME OF
01:11:31.086 --> 01:11:32.554
THE CONCERNS THAT ARE THERE AND
01:11:32.621 --> 01:11:34.456
, UM AT THIS POINT, IS THERE
01:11:34.523 --> 01:11:35.658
STILL WORK ABILITY TO WORK OUT
01:11:35.724 --> 01:11:37.393
SOME OF THESE ISSUES THAT ARE
01:11:37.459 --> 01:11:40.763
BEING BROUGHT UP. WELL I MEAN
01:11:40.829 --> 01:11:42.665
THE COMMENTS FOR ME THAT THEY
01:11:42.731 --> 01:11:43.699
OPPOSED THE BILL IN PRINT THE
01:11:43.766 --> 01:11:45.701
BILL AND PRINT THIS STUDY
01:11:45.768 --> 01:11:46.935
PORTION, WHICH IS WHAT WAS STILL
01:11:47.002 --> 01:11:48.103
IN PRINT WAS BASICALLY DRAFTED
01:11:48.170 --> 01:11:52.174
BY THE SENATE FINANCE COMMUNITY
01:11:52.241 --> 01:11:56.011
. WE SAT DOWN AND I KNOW, UM,
01:11:56.078 --> 01:11:57.079
OPPONENTS SAT DOWN EXTENSIVELY
01:11:57.146 --> 01:11:59.915
WITH THE COMMITTEE. AND ALL THE
01:11:59.982 --> 01:12:02.217
AMENDMENTS THAT YOU SEE DRAFTD
01:12:02.284 --> 01:12:04.553
ON PAGE EIGHT. I REALLY DO.
01:12:04.620 --> 01:12:05.788
ADDRESS ALL THE ISSUES THAT HAVE
01:12:05.854 --> 01:12:07.623
BEEN RAISED IN THE LETTER, WHICH
01:12:07.690 --> 01:12:09.591
IS FOR THE HISTORY OF THE
01:12:09.658 --> 01:12:11.660
HISTORY OF THE BUILDING. I'M
01:12:11.727 --> 01:12:12.861
HAPPY TO TALK ABOUT THIS BILL.
01:12:12.928 --> 01:12:14.997
BUT IN TERMS OF THE IN TERMS OF
01:12:15.064 --> 01:12:17.499
HAVING THE COMMITTEE MADE A REAL
01:12:17.566 --> 01:12:19.601
POINT OF TALKING ABOUT,
01:12:19.668 --> 01:12:21.203
INCLUDING AN ENGAGING
01:12:21.270 --> 01:12:21.937
PRIORITIZING ORGANIZATIONS THAT
01:12:22.004 --> 01:12:22.871
REPRESENTS THREE VENDORS AS PART
01:12:22.938 --> 01:12:25.908
OF THE STUDY. LOOKING AT BARRY
01:12:25.974 --> 01:12:27.309
TURNING PERMITS LOOKING AT
01:12:27.376 --> 01:12:28.610
CULTURAL BARRIERS, LANGUAGE
01:12:28.677 --> 01:12:30.746
BARRIERS. UH YOU KNOW, I MEAN,
01:12:30.813 --> 01:12:31.847
JUST TAKE A LOOK AT THE
01:12:31.914 --> 01:12:33.015
AMENDMENTS THAT THAT WERE
01:12:33.082 --> 01:12:34.149
ENTHUSIASTICALLY ACCEPTING. WE
01:12:34.216 --> 01:12:35.417
WERE PART OF THE DEVELOPMENT OF
01:12:35.484 --> 01:12:36.485
THESE AMENDMENTS A LOT. THE
01:12:36.552 --> 01:12:37.586
FOLKS WHO ARE RAISING CONCERNS
01:12:37.653 --> 01:12:38.687
ABOUT THE BILL. TO ENSURE THAT
01:12:38.754 --> 01:12:43.358
THIS IS TRULY A YOU KNOW A STUDY
01:12:43.425 --> 01:12:45.594
THAT, UM THAT YOU KNOW THAT
01:12:45.661 --> 01:12:47.429
THAT'S GONNA GET TO THE BOTTOM
01:12:47.496 --> 01:12:48.597
OF A LOT OF THE ISSUES,
01:12:48.664 --> 01:12:49.665
INCLUDING THAT THE LEGITIMATE
01:12:49.732 --> 01:12:51.467
ISSUES THAT HAVE BEEN RAISED HOW
01:12:51.533 --> 01:12:53.268
DIFFICULT IT IS FOR THE VENDORS,
01:12:53.335 --> 01:12:54.436
I THINK WANT TO JUST HAVE A
01:12:54.503 --> 01:12:55.471
REALLY HOLISTIC LOOK AND
01:12:55.537 --> 01:12:57.306
CERTAINLY IF IT NEEDS TO GO
01:12:57.372 --> 01:12:59.842
FURTHER. AH AND YOU KNOW, I'M
01:12:59.908 --> 01:13:01.076
HAPPY TO HAVE THAT CONVERSATION
01:13:01.143 --> 01:13:02.010
HAPPY TO WORK WITH THE
01:13:02.077 --> 01:13:03.312
COMMITTEE. BUT I THINK YOU'LL
01:13:03.378 --> 01:13:04.546
SEE THAT IT'S PRETTY
01:13:04.613 --> 01:13:08.350
COMPREHENSIVE AND VERY FOCUSED.
01:13:08.417 --> 01:13:09.785
ACTUALLY, THE COMMITMENTS ARE
01:13:09.852 --> 01:13:12.354
VERY FOCUSED ON THE CHALLENGES
01:13:12.421 --> 01:13:13.722
FACED BY THE COMMUNITY SO WE CAN
01:13:13.789 --> 01:13:15.657
GET A BETTER UNDERSTANDING OF
01:13:15.724 --> 01:13:16.992
THEM AND I JUST HELPED, YOU
01:13:17.059 --> 01:13:18.994
KNOW. BETTER SEEING THE
01:13:19.061 --> 01:13:20.763
CHALLENGES SO WE CAN BOTH MEET
01:13:20.829 --> 01:13:22.664
THE NEEDS OF OUR CITIES AND THE
01:13:22.731 --> 01:13:23.832
VENDOR COMMUNITY. AND THAT'S
01:13:23.899 --> 01:13:24.800
REALLY WHAT WE'RE TRYING TO GET
01:13:24.867 --> 01:13:26.902
OUT HERE WITH ME. I'M HAPPY TO
01:13:26.969 --> 01:13:28.270
TALK ABOUT HISTORY. THE BILL, I
01:13:28.337 --> 01:13:29.905
MEAN THE THINK THROUGH THE CHAIR
01:13:29.972 --> 01:13:31.607
QUESTIONS, NOT IN THE HISTORY OF
01:13:31.673 --> 01:13:32.841
THE MOVING FORWARD WITH THE
01:13:32.908 --> 01:13:35.410
BILL. THE QUESTION IS, I SEE THE
01:13:35.477 --> 01:13:37.212
AMENDMENTS THAT ARE AND BUT
01:13:37.279 --> 01:13:38.914
STILL HEARING THAT THERE STILL
01:13:38.981 --> 01:13:40.783
COULD BE SOME MORE DIALOGUES AND
01:13:40.849 --> 01:13:42.684
MORE DISCUSSION ON SOME OF THESE
01:13:42.751 --> 01:13:43.352
ISSUES. IS HAT SOMETHING YOU'RE
01:13:43.418 --> 01:13:45.654
OPEN TO 100% THANK YOU. ANOTHER
01:13:45.721 --> 01:13:47.756
QUESTION TO THE CHAIR IF I MAKE
01:13:47.823 --> 01:13:49.458
IS, UM THE STATE NOW IS LOOKING
01:13:49.525 --> 01:13:51.059
AT THE STUDY. BUT SHOULD THAT
01:13:51.126 --> 01:13:52.828
STUDY BE MORE EQUIPPED AT THE
01:13:52.895 --> 01:13:56.732
LOCAL LEVEL? OF COURSE, I WILL
01:13:56.799 --> 01:13:58.033
SAY THE CHALLENGE RIGHT HERE.
01:13:58.100 --> 01:13:59.668
ONE OF THE I THINK ONE OF THEM
01:13:59.735 --> 01:14:01.503
ONE OF THE MOST LEGITIMATE
01:14:01.570 --> 01:14:03.572
CRITIQUES OF THE BILL BEFORE WAS
01:14:03.639 --> 01:14:06.542
THAT AND I HEARD FOLKS SAYING,
01:14:06.608 --> 01:14:07.743
HEY, YOU GOT A PROBLEM IN SANTA
01:14:07.810 --> 01:14:09.077
MONICA. WE KNOW THERE'S A
01:14:09.144 --> 01:14:10.345
PROBLEM IN SAN FRANCISCO, SAN
01:14:10.412 --> 01:14:11.413
DIEGO SANTA CRUZ, SANTA BARBARA
01:14:11.480 --> 01:14:13.515
COUPLE PLACES. BUT PASSING A LAW
01:14:13.582 --> 01:14:14.883
THAT'S GOING TO IMPACT EVERYONE
01:14:14.950 --> 01:14:16.652
STATEWIDE. SO YOU KNOW YOU GOT
01:14:16.718 --> 01:14:18.854
THIS PROBLEM HERE, BUT THAT'S
01:14:18.921 --> 01:14:19.855
UNIQUE AND WHAT'S UNIQUE ABOUT
01:14:19.922 --> 01:14:21.890
THE PIER? THERE'S JUST SO MUCH
01:14:21.957 --> 01:14:23.892
TOURIST FOOT TRAFFIC. IT'S A
01:14:23.959 --> 01:14:25.661
PUBLIC PLACE, BUT THERE'S A LOT
01:14:25.727 --> 01:14:26.862
OF TOURIST FOOT TRAFFIC AT
01:14:26.929 --> 01:14:28.330
DISNEYLAND, BUT THAT'S A PRIVATE
01:14:28.397 --> 01:14:29.765
PLACE. SO YOU KNOW, SO THE
01:14:29.832 --> 01:14:30.999
PROVISION OF 9 46 DON'T REALLY
01:14:31.066 --> 01:14:34.403
APPLY. AND SO, UM SO I HEARD
01:14:34.469 --> 01:14:36.905
THAT I MEAN, I UNDERSTAND THAT I
01:14:36.972 --> 01:14:37.806
UNDERSTAND THAT SOME TOWNS AND
01:14:37.873 --> 01:14:39.308
PARTS OF THE STATE ARE GOING TO
01:14:39.374 --> 01:14:40.709
BEHAVE DIFFERENTLY THAN THAN
01:14:40.776 --> 01:14:42.311
THAN SOME OF THE CITIES WE'VE
01:14:42.377 --> 01:14:43.712
JUST MENTIONED, WHICH TEND TO BE
01:14:43.779 --> 01:14:44.947
A LITTLE BIT MORE PROGRESSIVE.
01:14:45.013 --> 01:14:46.648
AH SAN DIEGO, SANTA MONICA, SAN
01:14:46.715 --> 01:14:49.952
FRANCISCO UM AND SO, YOU KNOW, I
01:14:50.018 --> 01:14:51.987
GUESS WHAT I WOULD SAY IS, IF
01:14:52.054 --> 01:14:53.488
WE'RE GOING TO BE LOOKING AT
01:14:53.555 --> 01:14:55.123
STATE POLICY, AND YOU KNOW, I
01:14:55.190 --> 01:14:57.226
VOTED FOR 9 46 AND I'M VOTING
01:14:57.292 --> 01:14:59.127
FOR 9 72 WERE PASSING STATE
01:14:59.194 --> 01:15:00.262
POLICY. DEALING WITH THE VENDING
01:15:00.329 --> 01:15:03.966
ISSUES. UH SO WE'RE GONNA IT'S
01:15:04.032 --> 01:15:05.500
IMPORTANT FOR US TO LOOK
01:15:05.567 --> 01:15:06.935
STATEWIDE. IT'S IMPORTANT FOR US
01:15:07.002 --> 01:15:07.736
TO RECOGNIZE THAT WE SHOULD NOT
01:15:07.803 --> 01:15:10.072
JUST BE DRAFTING LAWS BASED ON
01:15:10.138 --> 01:15:11.139
THE EXPERIENCE OF ONE TOWN
01:15:11.206 --> 01:15:12.241
VERSUS ANOTHER, BUT WE HAVE TO
01:15:12.307 --> 01:15:13.742
LOOK AT BOTH THE HIGH TOURIST
01:15:13.809 --> 01:15:15.010
CENTERS BUT ALSO THE INLAND
01:15:15.077 --> 01:15:16.545
EMPIRE AND ALSO THE CENTRAL
01:15:16.612 --> 01:15:17.579
VALLEY AND ALSO ALL THOSE OTHER
01:15:17.646 --> 01:15:18.580
COMMUNITIES THAT HAVE JUST A
01:15:18.647 --> 01:15:21.483
VERY DIFFERENT DYNAMIC. SO WHILE
01:15:21.550 --> 01:15:22.684
THERE'S NO QUESTION THAT EVERY
01:15:22.751 --> 01:15:23.819
COMMUNITY SHOULD BE DOING THEIR
01:15:23.886 --> 01:15:25.821
OWN DEEP DIVE THAT'S BASED ON
01:15:25.888 --> 01:15:29.758
THE LOCAL DYNAMICS. WE ALSO I
01:15:29.825 --> 01:15:32.160
THINK NEED TO BE ASKING SOME
01:15:32.227 --> 01:15:32.828
QUESTIONS STATEWIDE AS WE TRY TO
01:15:32.895 --> 01:15:34.429
FIGURE OUT HOW TO CONTINUE TO,
01:15:34.496 --> 01:15:37.699
UM TO, YOU KNOW TO WORK IN THIS
01:15:37.766 --> 01:15:38.800
SPACE. DOES THAT MAKE SENSE AS A
01:15:38.867 --> 01:15:40.869
LEGISLATURE MAKES SENSE, BUT IT
01:15:40.936 --> 01:15:43.305
ALSO MAKES SENSE FOR THE LOCAL
01:15:43.372 --> 01:15:44.206
COMMUNITIES TO BE ENGAGED IN THE
01:15:44.273 --> 01:15:46.441
DISCUSSION. IT ISN'T A ONE SIZE
01:15:46.508 --> 01:15:47.743
FITS ALL IN THE STATE OF
01:15:47.809 --> 01:15:48.744
CALIFORNIA, RIGHT? DIFFERENT
01:15:48.810 --> 01:15:49.945
REGIONS. DIFFERENT ECONOMICS,
01:15:50.012 --> 01:15:52.481
DIFFERENT, DIFFERENT TEMPERATURE
01:15:52.547 --> 01:15:53.949
, ENTREPRENEURSHIP, RIGHT MOVING
01:15:54.016 --> 01:15:55.183
FORWARD. EVEN WITHIN THE STREET
01:15:55.250 --> 01:15:56.285
VENDORS, DIFFERENT PRODUCTS THAT
01:15:56.351 --> 01:15:58.520
ARE BEING SOLD IN ONE COUNTY
01:15:58.587 --> 01:16:00.222
VERSUS ANOTHER OR EVEN CITIES,
01:16:00.289 --> 01:16:01.423
FOR THAT MATTER, SO I THINK
01:16:01.490 --> 01:16:03.792
THERE IS A GENUINE NEED FOR THAT
01:16:03.859 --> 01:16:04.693
VOICE TO BE INSERTED. BUT
01:16:04.760 --> 01:16:06.395
HEARING THAT YOU'RE STILL OPEN
01:16:06.461 --> 01:16:07.629
TO DISCUSS SOME OF THESE ISSUES
01:16:07.696 --> 01:16:09.298
MOVING FORWARD. I'M TAKING THAT
01:16:09.364 --> 01:16:10.766
AWAY AS YOUR COMMITMENT TO
01:16:10.832 --> 01:16:12.100
CONTINUE TO WORK ON THESE THINGS
01:16:12.167 --> 01:16:14.136
. PRIOR TO IT REACHES THE
01:16:14.202 --> 01:16:15.170
ASSEMBLY FLOOR. ABSOLUTELY THANK
01:16:15.237 --> 01:16:17.372
YOU. THANK YOU FOR THAT STORY.
01:16:17.439 --> 01:16:22.010
MM. NEVER BLOOM. THANK YOU. AND
01:16:22.077 --> 01:16:25.280
UH, THANK YOU, SENATOR FOR
01:16:25.347 --> 01:16:26.648
BRINGING THIS MEASURE FORWARD. I
01:16:26.715 --> 01:16:28.350
KNOW IT'S BEEN A LOT OF HARD
01:16:28.417 --> 01:16:29.818
WORK. YOU AND I REPRESENT THE
01:16:29.885 --> 01:16:31.954
SAME COMMUNITIES, INCLUDING
01:16:32.020 --> 01:16:33.422
SANTA MONICA, WHICH HAS BEEN A
01:16:33.488 --> 01:16:36.458
FOCAL POINT FOR A LOT OF THE
01:16:36.525 --> 01:16:39.027
ACTIVITY AND CONTROVERSY AROUND
01:16:39.094 --> 01:16:40.996
AROUND STREET VENDING. AND WE,
01:16:41.063 --> 01:16:43.332
UH, YOU KNOW, I SUPPORTED
01:16:43.398 --> 01:16:44.733
SENATOR LAURA'S BILL AND
01:16:44.800 --> 01:16:45.867
CONTINUE TO SUPPORT STREET
01:16:45.934 --> 01:16:51.073
VENDING. UM ONE THING, UH, THAT
01:16:51.139 --> 01:16:52.140
YOU DIDN'T MENTION ABOUT THE
01:16:52.207 --> 01:16:54.176
SANTA MONICA PIER. IS THAT ASIDE
01:16:54.242 --> 01:16:56.378
FROM THE MILLIONS OF VISITORS,
01:16:56.445 --> 01:16:57.746
UM, WHO VISITED ANNUALLY AND
01:16:57.813 --> 01:17:01.483
PARTICULARLY ON WEEKENDS AND AH
01:17:01.550 --> 01:17:03.118
, HOLIDAYS, THERE'S ONLY ONE
01:17:03.185 --> 01:17:05.387
INGRESS AND EGRESS PREDOMINANTLY
01:17:05.454 --> 01:17:07.589
TO THE SANTA MONICA PIER. THERE
01:17:07.656 --> 01:17:08.957
ARE REAL LEGITIMATE SAFETY
01:17:09.024 --> 01:17:16.098
ISSUES. UM AND MY FEAR IS, UM,
01:17:16.164 --> 01:17:21.570
IF SOME KIND OF. AH ORDER IS NOT
01:17:21.636 --> 01:17:23.338
BROUGHT TO THE CHAOS THAT WE SEE
01:17:23.405 --> 01:17:25.240
AROUND SOME OF THESE AREAS, AND
01:17:25.307 --> 01:17:27.609
IT'S NOT JUST THE SANTA MONICA
01:17:27.676 --> 01:17:29.778
PIER. EVENTUALLY SOMETHING BAD
01:17:29.845 --> 01:17:31.780
IS GOING TO IS GOING TO HAPPEN.
01:17:31.847 --> 01:17:33.682
THERE'S CONFLICT BETWEEN VENDORS
01:17:33.749 --> 01:17:35.250
. THERE'S CONFLICT BETWEEN
01:17:35.317 --> 01:17:38.220
VENDORS AND LOCAL BUSINESSES.
01:17:38.286 --> 01:17:39.721
UM, AND THERE'S JUST CROWDED
01:17:39.788 --> 01:17:43.325
CONDITIONS THAT, UM, ARE. IN IN,
01:17:43.392 --> 01:17:52.601
IN MY VIEW, UM UNSAFE AND SO THE. WHILE YOUR ORIGINAL BILL, YOU
01:17:52.667 --> 01:17:54.870
KNOW, MAYBE IT WENT A LITTLE BIT
01:17:54.936 --> 01:17:55.771
TOO FAR. THIS IS NOW WHITTLED
01:17:55.837 --> 01:17:57.906
DOWN TO A STUDY BILL. THAT
01:17:57.973 --> 01:17:59.508
REALLY IS, I THINK VERY, VERY
01:17:59.574 --> 01:18:01.510
CLOSELY TAILORED TO STUDYING THE
01:18:01.576 --> 01:18:03.378
ISSUES THAT EVERYONE HAS RAISED.
01:18:03.445 --> 01:18:05.847
ON ALL SIDES OF THIS ISSUE, AND
01:18:05.914 --> 01:18:08.784
I, UH, SEE THE REPRESENTATIVE
01:18:08.850 --> 01:18:11.887
WESTERN CENTERS AS AS NODDING IN
01:18:11.953 --> 01:18:14.890
ACKNOWLEDGMENT. I THINK THAT UM
01:18:14.956 --> 01:18:17.025
, THE ADMONITION TO TAKE A
01:18:17.092 --> 01:18:19.461
BALANCED APPROACH ON THIS IS
01:18:19.528 --> 01:18:21.563
BEING FOLLOWED BY BY YOUR BILL
01:18:21.630 --> 01:18:23.265
BY THE LANGUAGE AND THE BILL
01:18:23.331 --> 01:18:27.069
NOW. AND, UM YOU KNOW, I
01:18:27.135 --> 01:18:29.638
UNDERSTAND ALSO WHY PEOPLE WOULD
01:18:29.704 --> 01:18:31.706
FEEL BUSINESSPEOPLE. THREE
01:18:31.773 --> 01:18:33.608
VENDORS, UM, WOULD FEEL
01:18:33.675 --> 01:18:34.843
THREATENED BY YOU KNOW, EVEN THE
01:18:34.910 --> 01:18:39.748
STUDY BILL. BECAUSE UH, FOLKS
01:18:39.815 --> 01:18:40.916
ARE STILL LIVING ON THE MARGINS
01:18:40.982 --> 01:18:44.052
AND WHEN YOU LIVE ON THE MARGINS
01:18:44.119 --> 01:18:48.156
ANYTHING THAT, UH, GOVERNMENT
01:18:48.223 --> 01:18:50.692
MAY BE DOING TO ADDRESS AN ISSUE
01:18:50.759 --> 01:18:52.561
IN A SITUATION LIKE THIS CAN BE
01:18:52.627 --> 01:18:53.628
PERCEIVED AS THREATENING. I
01:18:53.695 --> 01:18:55.263
DON'T THINK THAT'S THE INTENT.
01:18:55.330 --> 01:18:58.967
OF THE LEGISLATION. I DON'T
01:18:59.034 --> 01:19:00.469
THINK IT'S INTENT. THE INTENT OF
01:19:00.535 --> 01:19:02.704
THE LOCAL GOVERNMENTS. UM BUT I
01:19:02.771 --> 01:19:04.706
DO BELIEVE THAT THERE ARE PEOPLE
01:19:04.773 --> 01:19:06.708
OUT THERE WHO PROBABLY, YOU KNOW
01:19:06.775 --> 01:19:07.776
, FEEL THAT WAY. AND I
01:19:07.843 --> 01:19:11.279
UNDERSTAND WHY. UM STREET
01:19:11.346 --> 01:19:13.348
VENDORS WOULD FEEL THE AND THEIR
01:19:13.415 --> 01:19:13.982
SUPPORTERS WOULD WOULD FEEL THAT
01:19:14.049 --> 01:19:20.455
WAY. AH! AH I THINK WE NEED TO
01:19:20.522 --> 01:19:22.591
GIVE THIS BILL A CHANCE. AND WE
01:19:22.657 --> 01:19:24.826
NEED TO, UH, ALLOW, UM, THIS
01:19:24.893 --> 01:19:26.394
WORK TO GO FORWARD TO BE
01:19:26.461 --> 01:19:28.263
INCLUSIVE AND I KNOW IF THE
01:19:28.330 --> 01:19:31.133
LANGUAGE IN THE BILL RIGHT NOW
01:19:31.199 --> 01:19:35.904
IS NOT, UM. DOES NOT, UH, I
01:19:35.971 --> 01:19:36.905
THINK IT DOES ADDRESS THE ISSUE
01:19:36.972 --> 01:19:39.508
OF INCLUSIVENESS AND BRINGING IN
01:19:39.574 --> 01:19:41.309
ALL SIDES AND WORKING WITH ALL
01:19:41.376 --> 01:19:42.410
SIDES AND YOU'RE NODDING. AND SO
01:19:42.477 --> 01:19:43.478
MAYBE IT DOESN'T NEED ANY
01:19:43.545 --> 01:19:44.613
CHANGE, BUT THAT NEEDS TO BE
01:19:44.679 --> 01:19:47.549
REFINED. I KNOW YOUR WORK ON IT,
01:19:47.616 --> 01:19:49.284
BECAUSE THAT'S THE KIND OF
01:19:49.351 --> 01:19:52.020
LEGISLATOR THAT YOU ARE AND THAT
01:19:52.087 --> 01:19:53.221
YOU'VE PROVEN TO BE SO OBVIOUS.
01:19:53.288 --> 01:19:56.725
SUPPORTING. THE BILL TODAY AND
01:19:56.791 --> 01:19:58.660
UM, YOU KNOW, I HOPE TO THE
01:19:58.727 --> 01:19:59.928
EXTENT POSSIBLE EVERYBODY'S
01:19:59.995 --> 01:20:02.230
NEEDS HERE ARE GOING TO BE
01:20:02.297 --> 01:20:04.166
ADDRESSED AT SOME POINT, UH, IN
01:20:04.232 --> 01:20:05.834
TIME BECAUSE IT'S AN EXTREMELY
01:20:05.901 --> 01:20:09.471
IMPORTANT ISSUE AND UM. I GUESS
01:20:09.538 --> 01:20:12.407
THAT'S THAT'S ENOUGH. OKAY?
01:20:12.474 --> 01:20:14.309
THANK YOU. DO WE HAVE A MOTION?
01:20:14.376 --> 01:20:19.181
ALMOST THE BILL. OKAY, WE HAVE
01:20:19.247 --> 01:20:20.649
MOTION SECOND. WOULD YOU LIKE TO
01:20:20.715 --> 01:20:21.650
CLOSE SENATOR? APPRECIATE THE
01:20:21.716 --> 01:20:23.585
DISCUSSION, AND I'M CERTAINLY
01:20:23.652 --> 01:20:25.921
HAPPY. I KNOW, AS I SAY. I JUST
01:20:25.987 --> 01:20:28.023
INVITE FOLKS TO LOOK OVER THE
01:20:28.089 --> 01:20:28.623
LANGUAGE ON PG, WHICH ARE THE
01:20:28.690 --> 01:20:29.558
AMENDMENTS THAT EVERYBODY WORKED
01:20:29.624 --> 01:20:30.926
ON. IF THERE'S IF THERE'S
01:20:30.992 --> 01:20:33.528
OPPORTUNITY FOR MORE INCLUSION
01:20:33.595 --> 01:20:34.963
OF VOICES BEYOND WHAT'S HERE, SO
01:20:35.030 --> 01:20:36.531
HAPPY TO HAVE THAT CONVERSATION
01:20:36.598 --> 01:20:37.666
. WE SHOULD PROBABLY MAKE A
01:20:37.732 --> 01:20:38.800
COMMENT MORE EXPLICIT ABOUT
01:20:38.867 --> 01:20:41.836
ABOUT GEOGRAPHIC DIVERSITY. UM
01:20:41.903 --> 01:20:43.338
YOU KNOW, CERTAINLY, YOU KNOW,
01:20:43.405 --> 01:20:44.940
THE ORGANIZATIONS THAT REPRESENT
01:20:45.006 --> 01:20:45.941
SIDEWALK VENDORS ARE INCLUDED
01:20:46.007 --> 01:20:48.443
LOCAL AUTHORITIES. UM YOU KNOW,
01:20:48.510 --> 01:20:49.578
BOTH THOSE THAT HAVE ADOPTED A
01:20:49.644 --> 01:20:51.479
SIDEWALK VENDING ORDINANCE AND
01:20:51.546 --> 01:20:52.314
THOSE THAT HAVEN'T ASSOCIATIONS
01:20:52.380 --> 01:20:52.948
THAT REPRESENT LOCAL AUTHORITIES
01:20:53.014 --> 01:20:54.549
IS INCLUDED. BUT BUT CERTAINLY
01:20:54.616 --> 01:20:56.384
YOU KNOW, FOLKS ON THE COMMITTEE
01:20:56.451 --> 01:20:58.553
OR OTHERS. WHO HAVE RAISED
01:20:58.620 --> 01:20:59.921
CONCERNS ABOUT THE BILL HAVE
01:20:59.988 --> 01:21:01.690
SUGGESTIONS ABOUT ABOUT MAKING
01:21:01.756 --> 01:21:03.024
SURE THAT THE LANGUAGES IS EVEN
01:21:03.091 --> 01:21:05.193
MORE INCLUSIVE THAN IT IS. I'M
01:21:05.260 --> 01:21:06.928
SO HAPPY TO CONSIDER AND WORK
01:21:06.995 --> 01:21:07.896
WITH YOU AND FIGURE OUT HOW TO
01:21:07.963 --> 01:21:11.566
DO THAT. UM SO THEY'RE VERY
01:21:11.633 --> 01:21:12.901
SERIOUS ISSUES. THE OTHER THING
01:21:12.968 --> 01:21:14.669
ABOUT THE PIER IS IT'S YOU KNOW,
01:21:14.736 --> 01:21:16.705
IT'S AN OLD WOODEN PIER AND THIS
01:21:16.771 --> 01:21:18.406
BEEN OPEN FLAME CHALLENGES. AND
01:21:18.473 --> 01:21:19.274
I KNOW THOSE ARE SOME OF THE
01:21:19.341 --> 01:21:20.342
THINGS HAVE BEEN DISCUSSED. UM
01:21:20.408 --> 01:21:22.644
YOU KNOW, WITH SP 9 72 IS THAT
01:21:22.711 --> 01:21:24.346
BILL HAS BEEN MOVING ALONG. UM
01:21:24.412 --> 01:21:26.281
BUT BUT, YOU KNOW, I APPRECIATE
01:21:26.348 --> 01:21:27.849
YOUR ATTENTION TO THIS.
01:21:27.916 --> 01:21:28.850
APPRECIATE THE DIFFICULT
01:21:28.917 --> 01:21:30.018
CONVERSATIONS WE'RE HAVING. I
01:21:30.085 --> 01:21:31.519
THINK WE HAVE TO HAVE THESE
01:21:31.586 --> 01:21:32.020
DIFFICULT CONVERSATIONS,
01:21:32.087 --> 01:21:32.721
INCLUDING THE MANY, MANY
01:21:32.787 --> 01:21:35.624
CHALLENGES FACED BY VENDORS. I'M
01:21:35.690 --> 01:21:37.726
JUST HOPEFUL THAT THAT THAT THIS
01:21:37.792 --> 01:21:38.793
STUDY WILL WILL LEAD WILL SHED
01:21:38.860 --> 01:21:39.828
SOME LIGHT BOTH ON THE
01:21:39.894 --> 01:21:41.296
CHALLENGES FACED BY THE CITIES,
01:21:41.363 --> 01:21:42.530
BUT ALSO THE ISSUES FACED BY THE
01:21:42.597 --> 01:21:44.633
VENDORS THAT HAVE BEEN RAISED.
01:21:44.699 --> 01:21:45.734
IN MANY CONVERSATIONS THAT I'VE
01:21:45.800 --> 01:21:46.801
HAD, I'VE CERTAINLY OVER THE
01:21:46.868 --> 01:21:48.570
COURSE OF THIS. WORK BECOME MUCH
01:21:48.637 --> 01:21:51.039
MORE SENSITIVE TO THE VERY
01:21:51.106 --> 01:21:52.140
SERIOUS CHALLENGES THAT ARE OUT
01:21:52.207 --> 01:21:53.241
THERE FACED BY THE VENDOR
01:21:53.308 --> 01:21:56.044
COMMUNITY THAT THE MIXTURE OF
01:21:56.111 --> 01:21:58.947
POVERTY AND THE REGULATIONS THAT
01:21:59.014 --> 01:22:01.049
HAVE, I THINK, COMBINED TO LEAD
01:22:01.116 --> 01:22:02.083
TO SOME PRETTY UNSATISFACTORY
01:22:02.150 --> 01:22:03.885
OUTCOMES FOR A LOT OF PEOPLE IN
01:22:03.952 --> 01:22:06.421
THE VENDOR COMMUNITY, SO THESE
01:22:06.488 --> 01:22:08.423
ARE ALL THINGS WE NEED. I THINK
01:22:08.490 --> 01:22:09.724
WE CAN AND SHOULD AND MUST LOOK
01:22:09.791 --> 01:22:11.793
AT AS WE'RE TRYING TO FIGURE OUT
01:22:11.860 --> 01:22:12.894
WHY STATEWIDE POLICY. IT'S IN
01:22:12.961 --> 01:22:14.763
THAT SPIRIT THAT I ASKED FOR A
01:22:14.829 --> 01:22:18.266
VOTE. OKAY. THANK YOU. WELL OUT
01:22:18.333 --> 01:22:20.468
OF THE RESPECT FOR CHAIRS,
01:22:20.535 --> 01:22:22.537
AGUIAR-CURRY. I'M GOING TO READ
01:22:22.604 --> 01:22:23.738
HER REMARKS, AND SHE WISHES TO
01:22:23.805 --> 01:22:26.441
EXPRESS THE SENATOR ALLEN. THANK
01:22:26.508 --> 01:22:28.043
YOU FOR ENGAGING WITH HER ABOUT
01:22:28.109 --> 01:22:29.144
YOUR BILL AND ACCEPTING
01:22:29.210 --> 01:22:31.946
COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS. AND SHE
01:22:32.013 --> 01:22:32.881
STATES. THIS ISSUE INVOLVES A
01:22:32.947 --> 01:22:34.516
DEGREE OF COMPLEXITY THAT
01:22:34.582 --> 01:22:35.517
DESERVES ADDITIONAL DATA AND
01:22:35.583 --> 01:22:38.320
INFORMATION. IT IS OUR INTENT
01:22:38.386 --> 01:22:39.454
WITH THE AMENDMENTS TO HELP
01:22:39.521 --> 01:22:41.423
GATHER INFORMATION THE
01:22:41.489 --> 01:22:42.691
LEGISLATURE WILL NEED BEFORE
01:22:42.757 --> 01:22:43.725
CONSIDERING CHANGES TO THIS AREA
01:22:43.792 --> 01:22:45.493
OF LAW. AND THE MOTION IS DO
01:22:45.560 --> 01:22:47.929
PASS. AS AMENDED TO THE
01:22:47.996 --> 01:22:50.965
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE. PLEASE
01:22:51.032 --> 01:22:53.168
CALL THE ROLL. AGUIAR-CURRY
01:22:53.234 --> 01:22:56.004
LACKEY. I SEE I BLOOM BLOOM. I
01:22:56.071 --> 01:22:57.472
BOERNER HORVATH BOERNER HORVATH
01:22:57.539 --> 01:23:01.242
RAMOS. BROUGH? AYE THREE OF US
01:23:01.309 --> 01:23:16.558
SANTIAGO. VOEPEL. AYE. OKAY?
01:23:16.624 --> 01:23:19.494
THANK YOU MEMBERS. THANK YOU.
01:23:19.561 --> 01:23:20.762
OKAY, THAT BY THE WAY, THAT BILL
01:23:20.829 --> 01:23:31.039
IS OUT. OKAY LET'S GO TO, UH
01:23:31.106 --> 01:23:33.875
ITEM ONE SENATE BILL 8, 91
01:23:33.942 --> 01:23:37.112
HERTZBERG. THE MOTION IS DUE
01:23:37.178 --> 01:23:38.947
PASS APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE.
01:23:39.013 --> 01:23:42.484
AGUIAR-CURRY DO WE HAVE A SECOND
01:23:42.550 --> 01:23:48.056
TO GET EMOTIONAL QUIET. MOTION
01:23:48.123 --> 01:23:52.327
SECOND. THANK YOU. YEAH, YOU MAY
01:23:52.394 --> 01:23:56.398
CALL AGUIAR-CURRY BLACKIE.
01:23:56.464 --> 01:24:00.435
BLOOM. BLOOM I BURN NOT VOTING
01:24:00.502 --> 01:24:06.474
BY BLACK, NOT VOTING. TOÀN.
01:24:06.541 --> 01:24:08.843
BURNING HEART THAT ROUBLES
01:24:08.910 --> 01:24:12.480
ALMOST THREE OF US SAD, JANKA.
01:24:12.547 --> 01:24:17.652
FOR PEOPLE NOT VOTING. OKAY.
01:24:17.719 --> 01:24:22.624
WHAT DO WE HAVE NEXT? OKAY
01:24:22.690 --> 01:24:27.328
CENTERVILLE, 8 97 WIECKOWSKI.
01:24:27.395 --> 01:24:28.496
PROMOTION IS WE DON'T HAVE
01:24:28.563 --> 01:24:37.372
EMOTION. HAVE A SECOND. MIGHT
01:24:37.439 --> 01:24:46.080
FAIL. OKAY OKAY IF IT SUCCEEDS
01:24:46.147 --> 01:24:52.887
LATER. NOW HAVE, UM SENATE BILL
01:24:52.954 --> 01:25:02.397
AND 67 PORTANTINO. FOR US BILL
01:25:02.464 --> 01:25:06.401
TENCENT. WE HAVE A MOTION AND A
01:25:06.468 --> 01:25:10.171
SECOND. THE MOTION IS DUE
01:25:10.238 --> 01:25:12.173
PASSING APPROPRIATIONS
01:25:12.240 --> 01:25:17.946
AGUIAR-CURRY LACKEY. NO NO BLUE
01:25:18.012 --> 01:25:22.484
. WELL, I PART OF THAT. BRITAIN
01:25:22.550 --> 01:25:26.754
HARVARD, NO. ROBLES ALMOST THREE
01:25:26.821 --> 01:25:35.263
SANTIAGO VOEPEL. CAN'T GO THERE.
01:25:35.330 --> 01:25:40.735
TO THIS TIME. OKAY. YOU'RE
01:25:40.802 --> 01:25:43.738
RIGHT. CENTERVILLE 11 O'CLOCK
01:25:43.805 --> 01:25:57.819
I'VE. MM. MR CHAIR MEMBERS. IT'S
01:25:57.886 --> 01:26:00.588
MY PLEASURE TO PRESENT SP FIVE
01:26:00.655 --> 01:26:02.790
BILLION WOULD HAVE SUSPENDED OR
01:26:02.857 --> 01:26:03.892
REGIONAL AVAILABLE AND ONLY
01:26:03.958 --> 01:26:08.029
HOUSING AGENT. THROUGHOUT DIEGO
01:26:08.096 --> 01:26:10.098
, SAYS A LOCAL CENTER VILLE.
01:26:10.164 --> 01:26:12.867
THIS CALLED THE HOUSING SHORTAGE
01:26:12.934 --> 01:26:16.004
MONEY. I DON'T HAVE TO EXPLAIN
01:26:16.070 --> 01:26:18.973
ANYWAY. ANY VIEW ISSUES HOUSING
01:26:19.040 --> 01:26:19.974
ABILITY PORTABLE FOR THE
01:26:20.041 --> 01:26:24.512
VILLAGE. AND CORNEA. THIS BILL
01:26:24.579 --> 01:26:27.482
HELP IN ADDITIONAL FOOD TO HELP
01:26:27.549 --> 01:26:31.819
GENERATE HOW LOCALLY. AH WOULD
01:26:31.886 --> 01:26:35.423
CREATE LOCAL ASSOCIATION OF
01:26:35.490 --> 01:26:41.129
CONSENT. SANDER OF THE, UH OF
01:26:41.195 --> 01:26:43.131
WHO ALLOW THEM TO RATE INDIAN
01:26:43.197 --> 01:26:47.001
HEALTH, LOCAL GOVERNMENTS.
01:26:47.068 --> 01:26:50.405
DURATION OF THE FOUR OF THEM TO
01:26:50.471 --> 01:26:55.009
BE SERVICED ENERGY CITIES POTATO
01:26:55.076 --> 01:27:01.382
AND YOU, GENERAL. I MEAN THEY
01:27:01.449 --> 01:27:07.555
BOOTS AND AH INVOLVED. DESIGNING
01:27:07.622 --> 01:27:18.600
THE NETWORK. SO YEAH, TÔI. IT IS
01:27:18.666 --> 01:27:21.469
THE MOST, UH TWO PROPOSED DID IT
01:27:21.536 --> 01:27:26.174
INSTEAD? PAT DON'T EAT BASED
01:27:26.240 --> 01:27:35.483
STATION. IN THAT IN HOUSE, HELP.
01:27:35.550 --> 01:27:40.421
NATIONS TO BUILD TWO GENERAL.
01:27:40.488 --> 01:27:47.261
RESTUDY EXTREMES. OF ALL TRAFFIC
01:27:47.328 --> 01:27:55.136
THAT, UH, PROJECT TO SOMEBODY
01:27:55.203 --> 01:27:58.940
STILL EXPECT PROGRAM. DEFINITELY
01:27:59.007 --> 01:28:04.879
IT'S MOST SLEEP A PANIC. AND FUN
01:28:04.946 --> 01:28:09.017
. COOL AH, YOU KNOW, WORKING ALL
01:28:09.083 --> 01:28:11.419
YEAR ON THIS PROJECT VIDAK:
01:28:11.486 --> 01:28:13.154
CEREBRAL AMOUNT OF WORK, UH,
01:28:13.221 --> 01:28:17.492
WORKING WITH COMMUNITY. THERE
01:28:17.558 --> 01:28:20.228
HAS BEEN A LITTLE, UH, A MULTI
01:28:20.294 --> 01:28:24.999
STAKEHOLDER CONWAY. AH PROCESS
01:28:25.066 --> 01:28:29.804
TO DEDIATED TO SIGN THIS ROBUST
01:28:29.871 --> 01:28:30.405
STAKEHOLDER PROCESS WITH FIVE
01:28:30.471 --> 01:28:35.043
AND SEVEN IT IS SIX HOUSING TASK
01:28:35.109 --> 01:28:37.578
FORCE MEETING DEDICATED TO THE
01:28:37.645 --> 01:28:39.814
ISSUE LOCALLY AND OF COURSE,
01:28:39.881 --> 01:28:40.748
WHAT WE HEAR IN THE LEGISLATIVE,
01:28:40.815 --> 01:28:44.318
SO WE WORKED WITH BETWEEN THIS
01:28:44.385 --> 01:28:49.524
MODEL AFTER BILLS. THROUGH SUCH
01:28:49.590 --> 01:28:52.160
AN UNDERCURRENT, LIKE I THINK
01:28:52.226 --> 01:28:55.196
IT'S VERY IMPORTANT TOOLS ARE
01:28:55.263 --> 01:29:00.334
ATTACKED THE AMOUNT OF. THAT
01:29:00.401 --> 01:29:03.971
BUILDING THIS TASK FIRST SUPPORT
01:29:04.038 --> 01:29:10.912
TODAY AND HAVE WOULD BE AH! YEAH
01:29:10.978 --> 01:29:14.816
SORRY. REPRESENTING THE
01:29:14.882 --> 01:29:19.854
TRAINING, BUT. THE VISION. WAS
01:29:19.921 --> 01:29:23.191
THERE THE FIRST TIME SAYING DAY
01:29:23.257 --> 01:29:25.693
MORNING THIS BIT HERE SPEAKING,
01:29:25.760 --> 01:29:31.165
YOU JUST POINT. SO AFTER THE
01:29:31.232 --> 01:29:35.703
IT'S CALLUM SUPPORT SPORTS DAY.
01:29:35.770 --> 01:29:38.139
JUST THE MENTION BEEN FELT
01:29:38.206 --> 01:29:40.775
THROUGH A BUSLOAD ENGAGEMENT.
01:29:40.842 --> 01:29:42.243
OUR LOCAL BUILDING TRADES
01:29:42.310 --> 01:29:44.345
PARTICIPANTS. HUMOR HOUSING
01:29:44.412 --> 01:29:46.647
PLATT FORCE, UM, SUB COMMUNITIES
01:29:46.714 --> 01:29:47.949
FOR THE PAST SEVERAL MONTHS
01:29:48.015 --> 01:29:49.150
LONG, DOZENS OF OTHER REGIONAL
01:29:49.217 --> 01:29:51.385
LEADERS AND HOUSING COLORS. THE
01:29:51.452 --> 01:29:53.287
PROCESS FOR EVERYONE WAS ALL
01:29:53.354 --> 01:29:54.689
VOICES ARE HEARD. EVERY ASPECT
01:29:54.756 --> 01:29:57.825
OF THE BILL WAS WORKSHOP WEEK.
01:29:57.892 --> 01:30:00.128
WE DISCUSSED CONCEPT PROVIDER
01:30:00.194 --> 01:30:02.130
VOTE REFERENCES TO SUBMIT
01:30:02.196 --> 01:30:04.132
WRITTEN BACK UP ALONG EACH STEP
01:30:04.198 --> 01:30:07.935
OF THE WAY. THE COACHES, PERIOD
01:30:08.002 --> 01:30:10.304
OR OR LOST, THAT'S APPROPRIATE
01:30:10.371 --> 01:30:13.307
BECAUSE I WAS READING THAT IT
01:30:13.374 --> 01:30:15.109
STRONGLY SUPPORTED BY
01:30:15.176 --> 01:30:16.711
ORGANIZATIONS REPRESENT SAND
01:30:16.778 --> 01:30:20.114
VEGAN, LIKE LOCAL CHAPTERS, DW
01:30:20.181 --> 01:30:22.016
ACTION CAMPAIGN SENATOR WORK
01:30:22.083 --> 01:30:23.251
PARTNERSHIPS IN THE REGIONAL
01:30:23.317 --> 01:30:24.352
TASK FORCE ABOUT HOMELESSNESS.
01:30:24.418 --> 01:30:29.056
LISK COURSE. THE SENDING
01:30:29.123 --> 01:30:29.791
CONSTRUCTION COUNCIL SANDALS IN
01:30:29.857 --> 01:30:33.895
CONSTRUCTION. THE BUILDING
01:30:33.961 --> 01:30:35.129
EXISTING REGIONAL STRUCTURES.
01:30:35.196 --> 01:30:37.198
THE AGENCY IS ITS OWN ENTITY IS
01:30:37.265 --> 01:30:39.901
CLOSELY ALIGNED WITH EFFORTS AND
01:30:39.967 --> 01:30:40.868
MIRRORS SHIRT, A WEIGHTED VOTING
01:30:40.935 --> 01:30:43.604
PROVISIONS, AND MAYBE 805
01:30:43.671 --> 01:30:45.106
DECISION ALSO INCLUDES CRITICAL
01:30:45.173 --> 01:30:46.374
PROTECTION. ENSURE HIGH QUALITY
01:30:46.440 --> 01:30:47.441
JOBS. WORKING PROTECTION TO
01:30:47.508 --> 01:30:48.509
UPLOAD WORKING FAMILIES IN OUR
01:30:48.576 --> 01:30:51.312
COMMUNITIES. WE'VE ALL HEARD
01:30:51.379 --> 01:30:52.814
THAT STRONG LABOR STANDARDS
01:30:52.880 --> 01:30:53.581
WON'T ALLOW PRIVATE HOUSING
01:30:53.648 --> 01:30:55.550
PROJECTS PENCIL DO YOU KNOW IT
01:30:55.616 --> 01:30:56.851
DOESN'T ALSO PISTOL MONEY THE
01:30:56.918 --> 01:30:59.320
PUBLIC WE NEED TO PROVIDE TO
01:30:59.387 --> 01:31:00.254
HELP PROVIDE ENOUGH AFFORDABLE
01:31:00.321 --> 01:31:01.222
HOUSING TO COVER THE NEEDS. BY
01:31:01.289 --> 01:31:04.091
POVERTY WAGES AS A 40% OF THE
01:31:04.158 --> 01:31:05.059
PEOPLE ENROLLED IN CALIFORNIA'S
01:31:05.126 --> 01:31:06.294
MEANS TESTED SAFETY. NET
01:31:06.360 --> 01:31:08.129
PROGRAMS ARE FROM CONSTRUCTION.
01:31:08.196 --> 01:31:08.729
WORKING FAMILIES WERE ALREADY
01:31:08.796 --> 01:31:12.533
SUBSIDIZING THE PROFITS OF THESE
01:31:12.600 --> 01:31:13.501
DEVELOPERS. IT'S APPROPRIATE
01:31:13.568 --> 01:31:15.036
THAT PUBLICLY SUBSIDIZED HOUSING
01:31:15.102 --> 01:31:17.004
PROJECTS THE HIGHEST PUBLIC
01:31:17.071 --> 01:31:18.206
BENEFIT, AND THAT INCLUDES THE
01:31:18.272 --> 01:31:19.240
JOB QUALITY SANDERS IN THIS
01:31:19.307 --> 01:31:21.642
BILL. SENATOR HUESO MENTIONED IN
01:31:21.709 --> 01:31:22.577
CLOSING. THE NEED FOR THE BILL
01:31:22.643 --> 01:31:25.313
IS VERY REAL, AND WE NEED A
01:31:25.379 --> 01:31:26.280
REGIONAL SCALE SOLUTION TO SOLVE
01:31:26.347 --> 01:31:27.682
THIS REGIONAL SCALE PROBLEMS. 11
01:31:27.748 --> 01:31:28.850
5 WILL JUMP START THE
01:31:28.916 --> 01:31:29.851
CONSTRUCTION OF AFFORDABLE AND
01:31:29.917 --> 01:31:31.018
MISSING HOUSING SUPERCHARGER THE
01:31:31.085 --> 01:31:34.188
REGION'S HOUSING EFFORTS. THE
01:31:34.255 --> 01:31:36.724
REASONS THAT WE URGE YOUR
01:31:36.791 --> 01:31:37.325
SUPPORT TODAY. APPRECIATE YOU
01:31:37.391 --> 01:31:38.492
<c.magenta>ISTENING TO MY COMMENTS URGENT.</c>
01:31:38.559 --> 01:31:49.670
YES. VOTE. THANK YOU.
01:31:49.737 --> 01:31:54.141
MM HMM. IS THERE ANYONE HERE IN
01:31:54.208 --> 01:32:01.048
OPPOSITION OF THE BILLS? OKAY,
01:32:01.115 --> 01:32:12.326
I'LL DO THAT. MADAM CHAIR,
01:32:12.393 --> 01:32:13.494
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE GENERAL
01:32:13.561 --> 01:32:14.562
RESPECT ON BEHALF OF THE
01:32:14.629 --> 01:32:15.963
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
01:32:16.030 --> 01:32:17.231
REALTORS HERE IN OPPOSITION TO
01:32:17.298 --> 01:32:19.066
SB 11 OH FIVE UNLESS IT IS
01:32:19.133 --> 01:32:19.734
AMENDED TO LIMIT THE POWERS
01:32:19.800 --> 01:32:21.669
CONVEYED TO THE PROPOSED LOCAL
01:32:21.736 --> 01:32:24.105
AFFORDABLE HOUSING AGENCY. SB 11
01:32:24.171 --> 01:32:25.473
. OH, FIVE GRANTS FAST,
01:32:25.539 --> 01:32:27.008
UNCHECKED BONDING AND TAXING
01:32:27.074 --> 01:32:27.875
AUTHORITY TO AN UNELECTED
01:32:27.942 --> 01:32:29.443
HOUSING AGENCY BOARD IN SAN
01:32:29.510 --> 01:32:31.445
DIEGO, WHICH WOULD CONSIST OF
01:32:31.512 --> 01:32:32.046
SIX APPOINTED REPRESENTATIVES
01:32:32.113 --> 01:32:33.614
SERVING FOR YOUR TERMS THAT CAN
01:32:33.681 --> 01:32:35.449
BY RESOLUTION. OR INITIATIVE
01:32:35.516 --> 01:32:37.251
IMPOSED SPECIAL TAXES ON REAL
01:32:37.318 --> 01:32:39.186
PROPERTY. PARCEL TAXES. GROSS
01:32:39.253 --> 01:32:40.621
RECEIPT. BUSINESS LICENSE TAX IS
01:32:40.688 --> 01:32:42.056
A SPECIAL BUSINESS TAX, A
01:32:42.123 --> 01:32:43.524
DOCUMENTARY TRANSFER, RECORDING
01:32:43.591 --> 01:32:45.526
TAX OR SPECIAL LAND, WINDFALL
01:32:45.593 --> 01:32:48.963
TAX OR A COMMERCIAL LINKAGE Væ.
01:32:49.030 --> 01:32:50.097
THE VAST, UNCHECKED BONDING AND
01:32:50.164 --> 01:32:51.532
TAXING AUTHORITY GRANTED TO THIS
01:32:51.599 --> 01:32:53.100
AGENCY WILL NEGATIVELY IMPACT
01:32:53.167 --> 01:32:54.669
MARKET RATE HOME OWNERSHIP AND
01:32:54.735 --> 01:32:56.437
DEVELOPMENT OPPORTUNITIES BY
01:32:56.504 --> 01:32:57.672
PUTTING THE DREAM OF WEALTH
01:32:57.738 --> 01:32:59.573
INEQUALITY OUT OF THE OUT OF
01:32:59.640 --> 01:33:00.808
REACH FOR OUR STATES WORKING
01:33:00.875 --> 01:33:02.643
FAMILIES. ACCORDING TO OUR STATE
01:33:02.710 --> 01:33:03.878
COMPTROLLER, ADVIL OR IN
01:33:03.945 --> 01:33:06.047
PROPERTY TAXES EQUAL ABOUT $75
01:33:06.113 --> 01:33:07.615
BILLION ANNUALLY. MEANWHILE THE
01:33:07.682 --> 01:33:09.650
EXISTING 5200 SPECIAL DISTRICTS
01:33:09.717 --> 01:33:11.552
WE HAVE IN THE STATE COLLECTING
01:33:11.619 --> 01:33:12.520
ADDITIONAL ESTIMATED $79 BILLION
01:33:12.586 --> 01:33:14.989
ANNUALLY. PAID ENTIRELY BY
01:33:15.056 --> 01:33:16.757
HOMEOWNERS TO FIND THE WIDE
01:33:16.824 --> 01:33:17.925
VARIETY OF SERVICES AND PROGRAMS
01:33:17.992 --> 01:33:19.827
THROUGHOUT THE STATE. THIS TAX
01:33:19.894 --> 01:33:20.795
COLLECTION METHOD IS GROWING
01:33:20.861 --> 01:33:22.830
QUICKLY AND CONTINUES TO PLACE
01:33:22.897 --> 01:33:23.764
PRESSURES ON MARKET RATE HOUSING
01:33:23.831 --> 01:33:25.032
AFFORDABILITY AS NEW PROPERTY
01:33:25.099 --> 01:33:26.033
OWNERS PAY HIGHER PURCHASE
01:33:26.100 --> 01:33:27.969
PRICES AND ARE SADDLED WITH
01:33:28.035 --> 01:33:29.103
HIGHER OVERALL PROPERTY TAXES TO
01:33:29.170 --> 01:33:31.539
GET INTO AND MAINTAIN HOUSING.
01:33:31.605 --> 01:33:33.174
AS HOMEOWNERS STRUGGLE TO AFFORD
01:33:33.240 --> 01:33:34.742
THEIR MONTHLY MORTGAGE. THEY
01:33:34.809 --> 01:33:36.877
SHOULD NOT ALSO BE FORCED TO
01:33:36.944 --> 01:33:37.511
FUND THE COSTS ASSOCIATED WITH
01:33:37.578 --> 01:33:38.379
THE DEVELOPMENT OF DEED
01:33:38.446 --> 01:33:40.047
RESTRICTED AFFORDABLE RENTAL
01:33:40.114 --> 01:33:40.681
HOUSING, WHICH SHOULD BE BORNE
01:33:40.748 --> 01:33:41.682
BY SOCIETY AND DEVELOPERS
01:33:41.749 --> 01:33:42.683
BENEFITING FROM THE ACQUISITION
01:33:42.750 --> 01:33:44.118
AND DEVELOPMENT OF THESE UNITS.
01:33:44.185 --> 01:33:45.586
FURTHERMORE IT IS IMPORTANT TO
01:33:45.653 --> 01:33:46.520
NOTE THAT SEVERAL STUDIES IN
01:33:46.587 --> 01:33:48.489
RECENT YEARS HAVE OPINED THAT
01:33:48.556 --> 01:33:49.957
BLACK AND BROWN COMMUNITIES ARE
01:33:50.024 --> 01:33:51.492
OFTEN ASSESSED HIGHER TAXES AND
01:33:51.559 --> 01:33:53.127
PROPERTY OWNERSHIP, WHICH IS A
01:33:53.194 --> 01:33:54.495
SIGNIFICANT CONCERN AS WE SEEK
01:33:54.562 --> 01:33:55.696
TO BRIDGE THE STATE'S PERSISTENT
01:33:55.763 --> 01:33:58.165
WEALTH GAP. CONTINUING TO EXPAND
01:33:58.232 --> 01:33:59.700
AND GRANT EVEN BROADER SPECIAL
01:33:59.767 --> 01:34:01.168
DISTRICT TAXING AUTHORITY WILL
01:34:01.235 --> 01:34:02.136
CONTINUE TO NEGATIVELY IMPACT
01:34:02.203 --> 01:34:04.171
HOMEOWNERS AND FURTHER FURTHER
01:34:04.238 --> 01:34:05.139
EXACERBATES OUR HOUSING
01:34:05.206 --> 01:34:07.241
AFFORDABILITY CRISIS STATEWIDE,
01:34:07.308 --> 01:34:08.909
SIMPLY STATED SB 11. OH FIVE,
01:34:08.976 --> 01:34:10.644
WILL PUT HOME OWNERSHIP OUT OF
01:34:10.711 --> 01:34:11.746
REACH FOR MANY OF CALIFORNIANS
01:34:11.812 --> 01:34:13.180
WORKING FAMILIES, WHICH IS WHY
01:34:13.247 --> 01:34:14.148
WE RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AND
01:34:14.215 --> 01:34:15.883
ABOUT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY
01:34:15.950 --> 01:34:17.551
MUCH. WELCOME MADAM CHAIR
01:34:17.618 --> 01:34:19.053
MEMBERS, PAT MORAN WITH AARON
01:34:19.120 --> 01:34:19.920
READING ASSOCIATES REPRESENTING
01:34:19.987 --> 01:34:20.821
THE SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA RENTAL
01:34:20.888 --> 01:34:23.591
HOUSING ASSOCIATION. UP OF
01:34:23.657 --> 01:34:24.759
COURSE, WE SUPPORT THE CREATION
01:34:24.825 --> 01:34:27.228
OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING. HOWEVER,
01:34:27.294 --> 01:34:29.663
WE'RE OPPOSED AT SB 11 OH, FIVE.
01:34:29.730 --> 01:34:31.065
THE BILL CREATES ANOTHER LAYER
01:34:31.132 --> 01:34:32.600
OF BUREAUCRACY. AFFORDABLE
01:34:32.666 --> 01:34:34.335
HOUSING PROVIDERS HAVE TO JUMP
01:34:34.402 --> 01:34:35.836
THROUGH TO BUILD AFFORDABLE
01:34:35.903 --> 01:34:37.038
HOUSING IN SAN DIEGO. WE THINK
01:34:37.104 --> 01:34:39.206
THIS BILL IS UNNECESSARY. IN
01:34:39.273 --> 01:34:40.474
FACT, ALL THIS BILL DOES IS
01:34:40.541 --> 01:34:42.243
CREATE AN ENTIRELY NEW
01:34:42.309 --> 01:34:44.412
INDEPENDENT GOVERNING BODY IN
01:34:44.478 --> 01:34:46.881
SAN DIEGO THAT DUPLICATES THE
01:34:46.947 --> 01:34:47.448
POWERS AND COVERS THE SAME
01:34:47.515 --> 01:34:50.217
GEOGRAPHY THAT IS ALREADY VESTED
01:34:50.284 --> 01:34:51.452
WITH THE SANDY OH COUNTY BOARD
01:34:51.519 --> 01:34:53.421
OF SUPERVISORS. WE DON'T
01:34:53.487 --> 01:34:55.022
UNDERSTAND WHY YOU WOULD CREATE
01:34:55.089 --> 01:34:58.759
A STATE MANDATED PROGRAM. UM
01:34:58.826 --> 01:35:01.095
WHEN THEY COUNTY CAN ALREADY DO
01:35:01.162 --> 01:35:03.864
THIS OR CREATE THEIR OWN AH,
01:35:03.931 --> 01:35:07.001
PROGRAM TO DO EXACTLY WHAT THE
01:35:07.068 --> 01:35:08.169
SENATORS BILL DOES, UM, AND
01:35:08.235 --> 01:35:10.471
LET'S MAKE NO MISTAKE. THIS
01:35:10.538 --> 01:35:13.441
ISN'T SANDBAG OPERATING IT. IT'S
01:35:13.507 --> 01:35:15.376
A BRAND NEW BUREAUCRACY WHOSE
01:35:15.443 --> 01:35:18.479
SIX MEMBERS, UM, ALSO ARE
01:35:18.546 --> 01:35:19.947
MEMBERS OF SAN DIEGO NOW AND OUR
01:35:20.014 --> 01:35:21.749
ALTERNATIVE. I READ THE BILL
01:35:21.816 --> 01:35:23.350
CORRECTLY. WE'RE ALSO OPPOSED TO
01:35:23.417 --> 01:35:25.886
THE INCREASED TAXING AUTHORITY,
01:35:25.953 --> 01:35:28.823
UM, THAT ALL THOSE TAXES WILL BE
01:35:28.889 --> 01:35:30.391
ON TOP OF THE TAXES ALREADY PAID
01:35:30.458 --> 01:35:32.927
BY BUSINESSES AND CITIZENS IN
01:35:32.993 --> 01:35:35.463
SAN DIEGO IS AS I UNDERSTAND THE
01:35:35.529 --> 01:35:37.431
BILL, AND FOR THOSE REASONS WERE
01:35:37.498 --> 01:35:38.466
OPPOSED TO THE BILL AND
01:35:38.532 --> 01:35:41.669
ENCOURAGING NO VOTE. THANK YOU.
01:35:41.735 --> 01:35:44.038
THANK YOU VERY MUCH, UM, ANYONE
01:35:44.105 --> 01:35:45.840
ELSE IN OPPOSITION AND ALSO I
01:35:45.906 --> 01:35:47.575
BELIEVE I MISSED OTHERS THAT
01:35:47.641 --> 01:35:48.909
MIGHT HAVE BEEN IN SUPPORT
01:35:48.976 --> 01:35:50.778
EARLIER. SO IF YOU JUST COME TO
01:35:50.845 --> 01:35:52.113
THE MICROPHONE, YOUR NAME YOUR
01:35:52.179 --> 01:35:54.248
POSITION WOULD BE VERY HELPFUL.
01:35:54.315 --> 01:35:55.816
THANK YOU. GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIR
01:35:55.883 --> 01:35:56.617
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE
01:35:56.684 --> 01:35:57.852
CORNELIUS BURKE WITH THE
01:35:57.918 --> 01:35:59.253
CALIFORNIA BUILDING INDUSTRY
01:35:59.320 --> 01:36:00.688
ASSOCIATION. WE HAVE OPPOSED
01:36:00.754 --> 01:36:01.789
UNLESS AMENDED, VERY CONCERNED
01:36:01.856 --> 01:36:04.458
ABOUT THE TAXES. PARTICULARLY
01:36:04.525 --> 01:36:05.626
THE DOUBLE TAXATION, YOU COULD
01:36:05.693 --> 01:36:07.461
PAY A PARCEL TAX AND COMMERCIAL
01:36:07.528 --> 01:36:09.196
LINKAGE FEE. THIS BILL TRIES TO
01:36:09.263 --> 01:36:11.232
SOLVE THE HOUSING CRISIS, WHICH
01:36:11.298 --> 01:36:13.100
WILL NOW CREATE A TAXING CRISIS.
01:36:13.167 --> 01:36:19.306
THANK YOU. MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS
01:36:19.373 --> 01:36:20.007
DAVID JONES, BAPTIST SOLANO
01:36:20.074 --> 01:36:21.909
BEACH IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL.
01:36:21.976 --> 01:36:26.013
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. TOBIAS
01:36:26.080 --> 01:36:27.181
WILK IN WITH THE CALIFORNIA
01:36:27.248 --> 01:36:28.048
TAXPAYERS ASSOCIATION IN
01:36:28.115 --> 01:36:29.150
OPPOSITION TO THE BILL. THANK
01:36:29.216 --> 01:36:34.455
YOU. UNLESS THERE'S SO HIGH ON
01:36:34.522 --> 01:36:36.357
BEHALF OF THE CITY OF CARLSBAD,
01:36:36.423 --> 01:36:40.594
ALSO IN OPPOSITION. REX W HÌNH
01:36:40.661 --> 01:36:41.529
WITH CALIFORNIA BUSINESS
01:36:41.595 --> 01:36:42.029
PROPERTIES ASSOCIATION.
01:36:42.096 --> 01:36:42.730
RESPECTFULLY OPPOSED AS WELL.
01:36:42.796 --> 01:36:47.935
THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
01:36:48.002 --> 01:36:49.003
NATALIE BASTARD. THE CALIFORNIA
01:36:49.069 --> 01:36:50.037
BUSINESSROUNDTABLE,
01:36:50.104 --> 01:36:54.441
RESPECTFULLY OPPOSED. BATTLE IS
01:36:54.508 --> 01:36:55.476
EMBOSSED S A CALIFORNIA AND
01:36:55.543 --> 01:36:58.579
SUPPORT THANK YOU. FIND A
01:36:58.646 --> 01:37:01.115
SUPPORT OUT THERE SOMEWHERE. ALL
01:37:01.182 --> 01:37:06.153
RIGHT. IS THERE ANYONE ELSE?
01:37:06.220 --> 01:37:07.388
JEFF UNION WITH COUNTY
01:37:07.454 --> 01:37:08.189
SUPERVISOR TERRA LAWSON ROOM,
01:37:08.255 --> 01:37:15.162
INDIGO COUNTY. THANK YOU. OKAY,
01:37:15.229 --> 01:37:17.431
SO WE HAVE THE WITNESSES
01:37:17.498 --> 01:37:19.400
SUPPORTED POSITION. ARE THERE
01:37:19.466 --> 01:37:21.802
ANY QUESTIONS OF THE COMMITTEE?
01:37:21.869 --> 01:37:23.170
YES. OKAY. WE'LL START WITH
01:37:23.237 --> 01:37:25.272
SOMETHING REMEMBER LACKING YEAH
01:37:25.339 --> 01:37:28.842
, WE HEARD. YEAH I JUST WANT TO
01:37:28.909 --> 01:37:29.877
CONFIRM WHETHER OR NOT YES SAN
01:37:29.944 --> 01:37:31.278
DIEGO BORDER SUPERVISORS WHETHER
01:37:31.345 --> 01:37:33.047
THEY COULD ESTABLISH HOUSING
01:37:33.113 --> 01:37:36.817
AGENTS ABOUT THIS BILL. THAT CAN
01:37:36.884 --> 01:37:39.687
BE IN THE COUNTY AREAS INCLUDE
01:37:39.753 --> 01:37:40.621
THE OTHER CITIES, THEIR
01:37:40.688 --> 01:37:43.724
JURISDICTION IS THEIR JOURNEY.
01:37:43.791 --> 01:37:47.127
IF THEY WANTED TO CREATE, UH
01:37:47.194 --> 01:37:50.664
WITH OTHER CITIES. IT WOULD
01:37:50.731 --> 01:37:52.900
PREFER A REPRODUCTION OF WHAT
01:37:52.967 --> 01:37:56.737
THAT ALREADY IS. SO BUT I REALLY
01:37:56.804 --> 01:37:58.405
DON'T KNOW IF I ANSWER THAT, IF
01:37:58.472 --> 01:38:02.610
THAT'S WOULD SAY YES. O J HAVE
01:38:02.676 --> 01:38:09.350
BEEN. TO RECREATE ITS JUST DEAR.
01:38:09.416 --> 01:38:14.888
AND GO. RIGHT OUT OF THAT WERE
01:38:14.955 --> 01:38:20.661
WAS HAD. MASHERS BALLOT AND
01:38:20.728 --> 01:38:24.565
PLANNING AROUND. UH HUH? AH AND
01:38:24.632 --> 01:38:26.567
YOU INDIAN PROJECT THE PROBLEMS
01:38:26.634 --> 01:38:30.738
THEY ARE. OKAY THE OPPOSITION
01:38:30.804 --> 01:38:32.539
POINT THE ALLEGATION OF DOUBLE
01:38:32.606 --> 01:38:35.809
TEST, FOR EXAMPLE, LANDMARK AND
01:38:35.876 --> 01:38:36.977
A BOOK, A PARCEL TAX AND
01:38:37.044 --> 01:38:41.649
COMMERCIAL V<c.cyan> IS THAT A FIRST</c>
01:38:41.715 --> 01:38:44.685
OR AND HOW DO YOU ADDRESS STACK
01:38:44.752 --> 01:38:46.353
? I MEAN THAT THAT'S POSSIBLE
01:38:46.420 --> 01:38:51.525
NOW, ANYWHERE. THE ISSUE, BUT I
01:38:51.592 --> 01:38:57.665
BELIEVE IS, UH WHAT? POWER TO DO
01:38:57.731 --> 01:39:03.704
THAT? PLEA MAKEUP. FIRST THE
01:39:03.771 --> 01:39:10.110
SHIP. TOGETHER UH, BIT OF A
01:39:10.177 --> 01:39:13.547
MALLET. YEAH, I DO THIS AND DO
01:39:13.614 --> 01:39:31.632
THAT. WELL, SO 12. SECTION OF.
01:39:31.699 --> 01:39:51.318
HOWEVER, THIS TIME AH.
01:45:25.552 --> 01:45:28.221
UM THREE. I AM CONCERNED ABOUT
01:45:28.288 --> 01:45:30.257
GIVING IT ANOTHER ENTITY POWER
01:45:30.323 --> 01:45:31.925
TO ENACT TAXES, SO WE DO NEED TO
01:45:31.992 --> 01:45:35.429
LOOK AT HOW DO THEY NOT
01:45:35.495 --> 01:45:36.163
DUPLICATE TAXES BECAUSE IF THE
01:45:36.229 --> 01:45:38.532
CITY OF SAN DIEGO HAS A TAX AND
01:45:38.598 --> 01:45:40.000
THEN THIS ENTITY HAS ATTACKS,
01:45:40.067 --> 01:45:41.134
AND THEN THERE'S ANOTHER TAX. WE
01:45:41.201 --> 01:45:43.136
SHOULD HAVE SOME WAY OF CAPPING.
01:45:43.203 --> 01:45:45.338
HOW MUCH WE COULD BE TAXING AND
01:45:45.405 --> 01:45:46.640
ANY TAXES GO AND THEY WILL, YOU
01:45:46.707 --> 01:45:48.508
KNOW, GO TO THE VOTE OF THE
01:45:48.575 --> 01:45:50.377
PEOPLE, SO THAT'S A GOOD THING.
01:45:50.444 --> 01:45:52.312
UM MAYOR MAYOR GLORIA HAD
01:45:52.379 --> 01:45:53.580
EXPRESSED CONCERN WITH THE
01:45:53.647 --> 01:45:54.648
VOTING STRUCTURE. I THINK THAT
01:45:54.715 --> 01:45:57.384
CONCERN IS VERY VALID. IF
01:45:57.451 --> 01:45:58.385
THERE'S JUST A REPRESENTATIVE
01:45:58.452 --> 01:46:01.755
FROM FROM NORTH COUNTY ARAB
01:46:01.822 --> 01:46:02.823
NORTH COASTAL RIGHT, THAT'S
01:46:02.889 --> 01:46:06.059
WASTING NEXT. BROKEN DOWN FROM
01:46:06.126 --> 01:46:07.894
THE NORTH NORTHWEST PART OF THE
01:46:07.961 --> 01:46:10.564
COUNTY. UM THAT'S NOT A
01:46:10.630 --> 01:46:12.265
GUARANTEE THAT FOLKS PAYING
01:46:12.332 --> 01:46:15.001
THOSE TAXES HAVE A SAY ON THAT
01:46:15.068 --> 01:46:16.737
BOARD. THE WAY IT WORKS IS NORTH
01:46:16.803 --> 01:46:18.338
COUNTY COASTAL WOULD APPOINT ONE
01:46:18.405 --> 01:46:20.273
BOARD MEMBER HAVE ONE ALTERNATE
01:46:20.340 --> 01:46:21.408
. THERE'S NO GUARANTEE THERE'S
01:46:21.475 --> 01:46:22.776
REPRESENTATION. WE DON'T USE
01:46:22.843 --> 01:46:24.644
JUST MAYORS, SO I DON'T WANT TO
01:46:24.711 --> 01:46:26.513
USE JUST MAYORS WITH WHOEVER IS
01:46:26.580 --> 01:46:27.481
APPOINTED TO STAND OUT. UM
01:46:27.547 --> 01:46:29.683
SHOULD BE THERE, BUT I THINK WE
01:46:29.750 --> 01:46:30.650
SHOULD LOOK AT THAT VOTING
01:46:30.717 --> 01:46:32.152
STRUCTURE AND MAKE IT MORE LIKE,
01:46:32.219 --> 01:46:34.020
UM AND, UH, THE WAY THE SANDBAG
01:46:34.087 --> 01:46:36.456
RADIO A B A, OR FIVE INTENDED IT
01:46:36.523 --> 01:46:37.591
TO BE, UM, I WOULD LIKE TO SEE
01:46:37.657 --> 01:46:39.659
SUPPORT LETTER FROM THE COUNTY.
01:46:39.726 --> 01:46:42.229
UM I THINK THAT SHOULD COME
01:46:42.295 --> 01:46:42.896
FORWARD BEFORE. YOU KNOW. SHOULD
01:46:42.963 --> 01:46:44.297
THIS GET OUT OF APPROACH BEFORE
01:46:44.364 --> 01:46:45.932
THIS GOES TO THE FLOOR AND THE
01:46:45.999 --> 01:46:47.367
ASSEMBLY? I WOULD LIKE TO SEE
01:46:47.434 --> 01:46:49.236
THAT SUPPORT LETTER FROM THE
01:46:49.302 --> 01:46:50.437
COUNTY. UM AND I'D REALLY LIKE
01:46:50.504 --> 01:46:52.539
TO ENCOURAGE YOU, SENATOR UR
01:46:52.606 --> 01:46:55.742
VERY EXPENSIVE, EXPENSIVE, UH,
01:46:55.809 --> 01:46:59.846
EXPERIENCED LEGISLATOR TAKEN ME
01:46:59.913 --> 01:47:01.948
OUT TO DINNER YET? NO NO, NO. SO
01:47:02.015 --> 01:47:05.619
WEIRD. UM EXPERIENCE. LEGISLATOR
01:47:05.685 --> 01:47:07.120
YOU KNOW HOW TO WORK WITH
01:47:07.187 --> 01:47:08.321
OPPOSITION. I ENCOURAGE YOU TO
01:47:08.388 --> 01:47:09.422
CONTINUE TO WORK WITH THIS
01:47:09.489 --> 01:47:10.957
OPPOSITION JUST TO HELP RESOLVE
01:47:11.024 --> 01:47:12.425
SOME OF THESE CONCERNS THAT I
01:47:12.492 --> 01:47:15.862
HAVE, UM AND I THINK WE NEED TO
01:47:15.929 --> 01:47:17.330
ENSURE THAT WE DON'T HAVE
01:47:17.397 --> 01:47:17.998
UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES. THERE'S
01:47:18.064 --> 01:47:19.733
A VALUE TO THE SMALL STUDIES TO
01:47:19.800 --> 01:47:22.302
HAVING LIKE A BRAIN TRUST OF HOW
01:47:22.369 --> 01:47:22.936
DO YOU ACTUALLY CREATE POLICIES
01:47:23.003 --> 01:47:23.570
THAT GET MORE AFFORDABLE
01:47:23.637 --> 01:47:26.973
HOUSING? AND REDUCE THE COST OF
01:47:27.040 --> 01:47:28.008
LIVING IN SAN DIEGO. THAT'S
01:47:28.074 --> 01:47:30.644
ABSOLUTELY 100% OF VALUED OF
01:47:30.710 --> 01:47:32.379
VALUE ADD, I THINK FOR SMALL
01:47:32.445 --> 01:47:33.947
CITIES. I THINK THAT'S YOU KNOW,
01:47:34.014 --> 01:47:36.149
ONE OF THE REASONS YOU'LL SEE
01:47:36.216 --> 01:47:37.384
THIS ON A BEACH SUPPORT. BY THE
01:47:37.450 --> 01:47:38.585
WAY, IT'S SOLANA BEACH. I KNOW
01:47:38.652 --> 01:47:40.487
YOU GUYS LIKE TO SAY SOLANO ALL
01:47:40.554 --> 01:47:43.056
THE TIME UP HERE, BUT IT'S ALANA
01:47:43.123 --> 01:47:43.824
DOWN WHERE I'M FROM. SELENA
01:47:43.890 --> 01:47:45.425
BEACH. UM BECAUSE WE DO NEED TO
01:47:45.492 --> 01:47:46.660
HAVE SOME MECHANISM. WE NEED A
01:47:46.726 --> 01:47:48.461
MECHANISM FOR MATCHING FUNDS FOR
01:47:48.528 --> 01:47:49.763
CITIES, ESPECIALLY ON THE COAST.
01:47:49.830 --> 01:47:50.931
THE COST OF LAND IS JUST SO
01:47:50.997 --> 01:47:52.599
RIDICULOUSLY HIGH, SO THERE'S A
01:47:52.666 --> 01:47:54.000
VALUE IN DOING IT, BUT WE HAVE
01:47:54.067 --> 01:47:55.669
TO MAKE SURE THAT THERE'S NO
01:47:55.735 --> 01:47:56.169
UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES
01:47:56.236 --> 01:47:57.070
APPROPRIATE GUARDRAILS. SO UM,
01:47:57.137 --> 01:47:59.239
WITH THAT I'M WILLING TO SUPPORT
01:47:59.306 --> 01:48:01.975
TODAY. UM I DO HAVE SOME MAJOR
01:48:02.042 --> 01:48:03.610
CONCERNS, AND I DO RESERVE THE
01:48:03.677 --> 01:48:05.779
RIGHT TO VOTE. NO ON THE FLOOR
01:48:05.846 --> 01:48:06.980
IF THOSE CONCERNS HAVE NOT BEEN
01:48:07.047 --> 01:48:08.815
RESOLVED, THANK YOU VERY MUCH I
01:48:08.882 --> 01:48:11.184
APPRECIATE AND I UNDERSTAND YOUR
01:48:11.251 --> 01:48:12.352
CONCERNS VERY MUCH. WHEN WE
01:48:12.419 --> 01:48:14.588
STARTED DOWN THIS PROCESS. I
01:48:14.654 --> 01:48:16.590
SHARED SOME OF THOSE SAME
01:48:16.656 --> 01:48:17.457
CONCERNS AND I FEEL THAT WE'VE
01:48:17.524 --> 01:48:18.425
COME UP WITH A BILL THAT
01:48:18.491 --> 01:48:19.426
ADDRESSES MANY, INCLUDING THAT
01:48:19.492 --> 01:48:21.928
FUNDS. ARE SPECIFICALLY
01:48:21.995 --> 01:48:23.597
EARMARKED TO GO BACK TO THE
01:48:23.663 --> 01:48:24.531
COMMUNITIES THAT COME FROM,
01:48:24.598 --> 01:48:26.199
THERE'S A 50% PROVISIONS THAT
01:48:26.266 --> 01:48:27.167
WILL BE INVESTED IN THE
01:48:27.234 --> 01:48:28.869
COMMUNITY. THEY COME BACK FOR A
01:48:28.935 --> 01:48:30.103
MINUTE AND THE OTHER FUNDS CAN
01:48:30.170 --> 01:48:32.239
BE INVESTED. WHERE THERE IS A
01:48:32.305 --> 01:48:33.373
HIGHER NEED FOR AFFORDABLE
01:48:33.440 --> 01:48:36.209
HOUSING. AND AS YOU KNOW, IN OUR
01:48:36.276 --> 01:48:38.144
COUNTY A LOT OF PEOPLE DON'T
01:48:38.211 --> 01:48:39.246
WORK IN THE COMMUNITIES THEY
01:48:39.312 --> 01:48:43.550
LIVE IN. AND THAT IS A BIG
01:48:43.617 --> 01:48:44.551
PROBLEM FOR CERTAIN COMMUNITIES
01:48:44.618 --> 01:48:45.986
THAT HAVE TO COMMUTE. AFTER
01:48:46.052 --> 01:48:48.622
OFTENTIMES OUTSIDE THE COUNTY.
01:48:48.688 --> 01:48:50.523
OFTEN TIMES WE HAVE PEOPLE THAT
01:48:50.590 --> 01:48:51.791
WORK IN 10 DIEGO SOUTH OF THE
01:48:51.858 --> 01:48:54.027
BORDER IN MEXICO. THAT'S ALSO A
01:48:54.094 --> 01:48:56.897
BIG PROBLEM, SO WE NEED TO CITE
01:48:56.963 --> 01:48:58.832
THESE HOUSES CLOSER TO WHERE THE
01:48:58.899 --> 01:49:01.334
JOB CLOSER TO WHERE WE CAN. THE
01:49:01.401 --> 01:49:02.502
OUR WORKERS CAN CONNECT WITH
01:49:02.569 --> 01:49:06.273
MASS TRANSIT. AND THERE WHEN YOU
01:49:06.339 --> 01:49:07.974
LOOK AT IT COUNTY AGENCY THAT
01:49:08.041 --> 01:49:11.211
COULD SELECTIVELY PICKED YOU
01:49:11.278 --> 01:49:12.345
KNOW, TWO OR THREE CITIES TO
01:49:12.412 --> 01:49:14.581
WORK WITH AND LEAVE OUT BREAST
01:49:14.648 --> 01:49:16.383
AND IT REALLY DOESN'T ACHIEVE
01:49:16.449 --> 01:49:18.551
OUR GOALS. WE NEED A, UH, CREATE
01:49:18.618 --> 01:49:20.153
AN ORGANIZATION THAT ENCOMPASSES
01:49:20.220 --> 01:49:21.488
ALL OF SANDY WILL COUNTIES NEEDS
01:49:21.554 --> 01:49:23.957
THAT INCLUDES EVERYONE. BECAUSE
01:49:24.024 --> 01:49:27.360
EVERYONE IN SAN DIEGO IS PART OF
01:49:27.427 --> 01:49:29.329
THE FABRIC OF THE COUNTY. THEY
01:49:29.396 --> 01:49:31.431
SHARE THE SAME RESOURCES. PEOPLE
01:49:31.498 --> 01:49:32.732
COME ALL THE WAY FROM ESCONDIDO
01:49:32.799 --> 01:49:34.935
TO VISIT OUR BUBBLE APART. AND
01:49:35.001 --> 01:49:35.702
OUR MISSION BUILDING OUR BEACHES
01:49:35.769 --> 01:49:39.806
AND OFTEN TIMES OFTEN TIMES IT'S
01:49:39.873 --> 01:49:40.974
THE SENDING AGO. TAXPAYERS THAT
01:49:41.041 --> 01:49:44.044
SHOULDER A LOT OF THE COST OF
01:49:44.110 --> 01:49:50.050
AH! BEACH CLEANING RESTORATION,
01:49:50.116 --> 01:49:54.220
LAW ENFORCEMENT AND. YOU KNOW,
01:49:54.287 --> 01:49:55.488
WE CAN'T GET AROUND THAT. AND
01:49:55.555 --> 01:49:56.923
I'M NOT SAYING THAT WE SHOULD.
01:49:56.990 --> 01:49:59.159
I'M JUST SAYING THAT'S THE WAY
01:49:59.225 --> 01:50:00.627
OUR COMMUNITIES WORK. OFTEN
01:50:00.694 --> 01:50:02.162
TIMES. PEOPLE DON'T STAY WITHIN
01:50:02.228 --> 01:50:04.064
THEIR CITIES TO ENJOY THE
01:50:04.130 --> 01:50:07.133
RESOURCES THEY HAVE. AND I HOPE
01:50:07.200 --> 01:50:07.701
THEY DON'T I WANT PEOPLE TO
01:50:07.767 --> 01:50:08.835
VISIT. NOT ONLY ARE COUNTY BUT
01:50:08.902 --> 01:50:10.937
OTHER COUNTIES, BUT WE ALSO HAVE
01:50:11.004 --> 01:50:12.205
TO UNDERSTAND THAT AFFORDABLE
01:50:12.272 --> 01:50:16.142
HOUSING PIERS OF STRATEGIC
01:50:16.209 --> 01:50:18.211
IMPORTANCE TO THE SUCCESS OF OUR
01:50:18.278 --> 01:50:20.680
BUSINESSES AND TO THE SUCCESS OF
01:50:20.747 --> 01:50:22.382
THE HEALTH OF THE PEOPLE THAT
01:50:22.449 --> 01:50:24.217
ARE LIVING IN OUR CITY. SO THIS
01:50:24.284 --> 01:50:26.119
IS YOU KNOW, I HAVE WORKED THAT
01:50:26.186 --> 01:50:26.853
CREATED AFFORDABLE HOUSING
01:50:26.920 --> 01:50:30.957
THROUGHOUT. THREE COUNTIES. AND
01:50:31.024 --> 01:50:32.625
I HAVE WORKED IN DEVELOPING IN
01:50:32.692 --> 01:50:34.594
MY NEIGHBORHOOD. I HELPED BUILD
01:50:34.661 --> 01:50:36.496
A THREE STORY PROJECT THAT IS
01:50:36.563 --> 01:50:40.467
PRETTY BIG. OF OVER 100 UNITS A
01:50:40.533 --> 01:50:42.969
BLOCK AWAY FROM MY HOUSE, YOU
01:50:43.036 --> 01:50:43.803
KNOW, SO I'M NOT ONE OF THOSE
01:50:43.870 --> 01:50:45.972
PEOPLE THAT SAY, WELL, I'M NOT
01:50:46.039 --> 01:50:47.140
GOING TO BUILD AFFORDABLE
01:50:47.207 --> 01:50:48.241
HOUSING AND LOW INCOME HOUSING
01:50:48.308 --> 01:50:49.376
IN MY NEIGHBORHOOD NÓI. AS A
01:50:49.442 --> 01:50:51.011
COUNCIL MEMBER, I TOOK
01:50:51.077 --> 01:50:52.178
LEADERSHIP AND CREATING HIGH
01:50:52.245 --> 01:50:53.346
QUALITY PROJECT. IN MY
01:50:53.413 --> 01:50:56.883
NEIGHBORHOOD. THAT PROVIDED LOW
01:50:56.950 --> 01:50:59.452
INCOME, HIGH DENSITY HIGH
01:50:59.519 --> 01:51:01.554
DENSITY, LOW INCOME, AFFORDABLE
01:51:01.621 --> 01:51:02.655
HOUSING FOR THE PEOPLE IN THE
01:51:02.722 --> 01:51:04.491
COMMUNITY AND PROUD OF IT SO
01:51:04.557 --> 01:51:05.558
BEAUTIFUL PROJECT AND I HAVE
01:51:05.625 --> 01:51:08.028
BUILT MANY MORE LIKE IT
01:51:08.094 --> 01:51:08.628
THROUGHOUT THE COUNTY. AND I'M
01:51:08.695 --> 01:51:09.596
PROUD OF THAT AS WELL. AND I
01:51:09.662 --> 01:51:12.532
HAVE UNLIKE YOU KNOW, UH, WELL,
01:51:12.599 --> 01:51:13.900
ALL DUE RESPECT TO THE OPPONENTS
01:51:13.967 --> 01:51:15.468
, THEY'RE NOT FROM SAN DIEGO.
01:51:15.535 --> 01:51:16.803
THEY DON'T KNOW HOW OUR COUNTY
01:51:16.870 --> 01:51:18.772
WORKS. THEY DON'T KNOW HOW
01:51:18.838 --> 01:51:20.006
SANDBAG WORKS. I HAVE SERVED ON
01:51:20.073 --> 01:51:21.841
THE BOARD OF SANDBAG. I HAVE
01:51:21.908 --> 01:51:22.442
BEEN INVOLVED. AND DISPERSING
01:51:22.509 --> 01:51:26.246
THOSE FUNDS COUNTYWIDE AND. I
01:51:26.312 --> 01:51:29.115
WANT TO CREATE A PROCESS THAT
01:51:29.182 --> 01:51:31.117
ENSURES THAT FUNDING IS
01:51:31.184 --> 01:51:32.285
DISTRIBUTED EQUITABLY. THAT'S
01:51:32.352 --> 01:51:33.820
WHY THIS BILL IS WRITTEN THIS
01:51:33.887 --> 01:51:35.655
WAY. IN ADDITION TO THAT, I
01:51:35.722 --> 01:51:36.723
WANNA CREATIVE PROCESS THAT
01:51:36.790 --> 01:51:39.225
HELPED BRING MORE VALUE. AS
01:51:39.292 --> 01:51:43.229
CALIFORNIA IS GIVING OUT. $2
01:51:43.296 --> 01:51:43.997
MILLION IN THIS ROUND FOR
01:51:44.064 --> 01:51:47.333
AFFORDABLE HOUSING THIS AGENCY
01:51:47.400 --> 01:51:49.235
TO RECEIVE HELP DISTRIBUTE IT
01:51:49.302 --> 01:51:49.869
THROUGHOUT THE COUNTY AND HELP
01:51:49.936 --> 01:51:52.238
PROVIDE SUPPORT TO THE SMALLER
01:51:52.305 --> 01:51:53.406
CITIES, SMALLER CITIES TO NOT TO
01:51:53.473 --> 01:51:57.243
HAVE VIBRANT HOUSING AGENCIES.
01:51:57.310 --> 01:51:58.611
THEY DON'T HAVE ENOUGH STAFF.
01:51:58.678 --> 01:52:01.147
I'M THINKING OF IMPERIAL BEACH
01:52:01.214 --> 01:52:02.415
IS A BIG SUPPORTER OF THIS BILL
01:52:02.482 --> 01:52:03.516
BECAUSE THEY WANT PORTABLE
01:52:03.583 --> 01:52:04.784
HOUSING. WANT TO BUILD IT. THEY
01:52:04.851 --> 01:52:07.654
HAVE SITES WHERE BUT THEY DON'T
01:52:07.720 --> 01:52:09.589
HAVE A STAFF. THEY DON'T HAVE AN
01:52:09.656 --> 01:52:11.825
OFFICE. THEY NEED SUPPORT THIS
01:52:11.891 --> 01:52:15.562
AGENT TO PROVIDE THAT SUPPORT.
01:52:15.628 --> 01:52:18.198
HELP TAKE THE PEOPLE TO IMPERIAL
01:52:18.264 --> 01:52:23.603
BEACH CITY IS INVITED FUN.
01:52:23.670 --> 01:52:24.437
HAPPENED THERE. CITIES SUPPORT
01:52:24.504 --> 01:52:27.507
THIS CITY AND ALL OF THIS
01:52:27.574 --> 01:52:30.410
REPRESENTATIVES FROM SOME OF
01:52:30.477 --> 01:52:32.345
THIS BECAUSE OUR INTEREST IT'S
01:52:32.412 --> 01:52:45.258
NOT EVERY. LIKE THERE WAS GOLD.
01:52:45.325 --> 01:53:00.807
SO THERE ARE VARIANTS. AH! THAT
01:53:00.874 --> 01:53:01.641
ALL RIGHT? WE CHOOSE YOUR
01:53:01.708 --> 01:53:17.857
APPROACH.
01:53:29.035 --> 01:53:48.021
THAT, UH.
01:57:48.327 --> 01:57:56.202
UM, YOU, UH, ADDRESS AID? UH UM
01:57:56.269 --> 01:58:04.477
YEAH. BILL STARTS AT THE MEDIA.
01:58:04.544 --> 01:58:07.213
BEEN TO THE SERVICE SYSTEM. OH,
01:58:07.280 --> 01:58:12.218
I'M. THEY'RE GOING TO GET THIS
01:58:12.285 --> 01:58:16.055
BILL. UH AND I THINK YOU HAVE TO
01:58:16.122 --> 01:58:19.025
LOOK AT POPULATIONS THAT THAT
01:58:19.091 --> 01:58:22.528
ARE IN HOUSING. WHEN WE LOOK AT
01:58:22.595 --> 01:58:31.170
100 20. D<c.cyan>ENERGIES. HAS BEEN TO</c>
01:58:31.237 --> 01:58:51.891
ENSURE. IN THE AREA.
01:58:53.726 --> 01:58:56.262
THAT AND
01:58:56.329 --> 01:59:46.345
I'M JUST. A LITTLE BIT. TÌM NOT. NO MATTER.
02:01:29.982 --> 02:01:46.899
BUT. APARTMENT RAMA THREE OF US.
02:01:46.966 --> 02:02:04.417
RIGHT NOW. MUCH. MEMBER. JUST AS
02:02:04.483 --> 02:02:09.221
A FOLLOW UP 8 91 VOTES AND SO,
02:02:09.288 --> 02:02:18.297
YOU KNOW, CALL. THE LETTER. ITEM
02:02:18.364 --> 02:02:23.335
NUMBER SIX S E 13 93. GOOD
02:02:23.402 --> 02:02:29.542
AFTERNOON, MADAM CHAIR. THANK
02:02:29.608 --> 02:02:31.444
YOU SO VERY MUCH. I WILL BE
02:02:31.510 --> 02:02:34.480
BRIEF. UH MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS.
02:02:34.547 --> 02:02:36.749
THANK YOU SO MUCH, AND I'LL TRY
02:02:36.816 --> 02:02:38.517
TO GET THROUGH THIS AS QUICKLY
02:02:38.584 --> 02:02:39.618
AS POSSIBLE. IT'S BEEN A LONG
02:02:39.685 --> 02:02:41.821
AFTER FOR ALL OF YOU. I'M SURE
02:02:41.887 --> 02:02:44.056
TODAY I'M PRESENTING SENATOR 13
02:02:44.123 --> 02:02:45.424
93, WHICH SEEKS SOME OF THE
02:02:45.491 --> 02:02:48.861
SIGNIFICANT CHANGES. CHALLENGES
02:02:48.928 --> 02:02:52.364
IN DECARBONIZATION IN CALIFORNIA
02:02:52.431 --> 02:02:54.100
, EXISTING BUILDINGS TALKING
02:02:54.166 --> 02:02:57.403
ABOUT CALIFORNIA EXISTING LITTLE
02:02:57.470 --> 02:02:59.271
93 WOULD REQUIRE LOCAL
02:02:59.338 --> 02:03:02.641
GOVERNMENTS CONSIDER KEYWORD IS
02:03:02.708 --> 02:03:04.243
CONSIDERED GUIDANCE AND BEST
02:03:04.310 --> 02:03:06.112
PRACTICES FROM THE CALIFORNIA
02:03:06.178 --> 02:03:07.413
ENERGY COMMISSION BEFORE
02:03:07.480 --> 02:03:09.348
APPROVING ORDINANCES THAT
02:03:09.415 --> 02:03:10.983
REQUIRE GAS APPLIANCES TO BE
02:03:11.050 --> 02:03:12.284
REPLACED WITH ELECTRICAL PLANTS
02:03:12.351 --> 02:03:15.888
IS THE ENERGY COMMISSION WOULD
02:03:15.955 --> 02:03:18.157
PROVIDE TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE TO
02:03:18.224 --> 02:03:20.893
THE CITY'S AT REQUEST. THE BILL
02:03:20.960 --> 02:03:21.660
WILL REQUIRE LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
02:03:21.727 --> 02:03:24.663
WITHIN 60 DAYS OF ADAPTATION. TO
02:03:24.730 --> 02:03:26.899
SUBMIT TO THE COMMISSION A COPY
02:03:26.966 --> 02:03:28.300
OF THE ORDINANCE AND WOULD THEN
02:03:28.367 --> 02:03:29.502
REQUIRE THE COMMISSION TO
02:03:29.568 --> 02:03:31.137
DETERMINE WHETHER THE LOCAL
02:03:31.203 --> 02:03:32.238
GOVERNMENT CONSIDERED THE
02:03:32.304 --> 02:03:34.974
COMMISSION'S GUIDANCE. IF THE
02:03:35.040 --> 02:03:36.609
COMMISSION GUIDANCE I'M SORRY IF
02:03:36.675 --> 02:03:38.077
THE COMMISSION DETERMINES THAT
02:03:38.144 --> 02:03:39.645
THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT DID NOT
02:03:39.712 --> 02:03:41.413
CONSIDER THE GUIDANCE, THE BILL
02:03:41.480 --> 02:03:42.081
WOULD ALLOW THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT
02:03:42.148 --> 02:03:45.251
TO GO BACK. AND CONSIDER THE
02:03:45.317 --> 02:03:47.486
GUIDANCE, MAKE ANY MODIFICATIONS
02:03:47.553 --> 02:03:49.989
IF NECESSARY, AND RESUBMIT THE
02:03:50.055 --> 02:03:53.025
ORDINANCE WHEN IT COMES TO
02:03:53.092 --> 02:03:54.059
BUILDING DECARBONIZATION,
02:03:54.126 --> 02:03:55.060
CALIFORNIA HAS LARGELY FOCUSED
02:03:55.127 --> 02:03:58.164
ON NEW CONSTRUCTION. IN FACT,
02:03:58.230 --> 02:03:59.698
OVER THE PAST SEVERAL YEARS,
02:03:59.765 --> 02:04:01.133
MANY LOCAL JURISDICTIONS HAVE
02:04:01.200 --> 02:04:03.302
ADOPTED WHAT ARE OFTEN REFERRED
02:04:03.369 --> 02:04:07.106
TO AS REACH CODES REACH CODES,
02:04:07.173 --> 02:04:08.474
WHICH ARE LOCAL ENERGY
02:04:08.541 --> 02:04:09.008
ORDINANCES REQUIRING MORE
02:04:09.074 --> 02:04:11.644
STRINGENT ENERGY REQUIREMENTS.
02:04:11.710 --> 02:04:13.345
THAN THOSE SET BY CALIFORNIA
02:04:13.412 --> 02:04:15.581
ENERGY CODE IS RICH CODES, WHICH
02:04:15.648 --> 02:04:18.684
ADDRESS NEW CONSTRUCTION. MUST
02:04:18.751 --> 02:04:20.519
BE REVIEWED AND APPROVED BY THE
02:04:20.586 --> 02:04:21.887
CALIFORNIA ENERGY COMMISSION.
02:04:21.954 --> 02:04:24.690
THIS BILL IS A MORE AH, I'M
02:04:24.757 --> 02:04:26.959
SORRY. THIS BILL IS MUCH MORE
02:04:27.026 --> 02:04:27.960
STRINGENT REQUIREMENTS THEN WE
02:04:28.027 --> 02:04:31.797
ARE SEEKING IN THIS BILL. SO
02:04:31.864 --> 02:04:34.266
CONSEQUENTLY, THERE ARE THERE
02:04:34.333 --> 02:04:34.867
ARE UNIQUE CHALLENGES.
02:04:34.934 --> 02:04:37.503
ASSOCIATED DECARBONIZATION AND
02:04:37.570 --> 02:04:38.871
THE CARBONIZED EXISTING
02:04:38.938 --> 02:04:40.739
BUILDINGS COME TO NEW BUILDINGS
02:04:40.806 --> 02:04:42.041
. CALIFORNIA ENERGY COMMISSION
02:04:42.107 --> 02:04:45.511
RECENTLY IDENTIFIED COST MOST
02:04:45.578 --> 02:04:47.546
SIGNIFICANT BARRIER, ACCORDING
02:04:47.613 --> 02:04:48.914
TO THE COMMISSION AND ELECTRIC
02:04:48.981 --> 02:04:51.116
PANEL UPGRADE WOULD COST
02:04:51.183 --> 02:04:54.286
ANYWHERE FROM 2500 TO $4000 FOR
02:04:54.353 --> 02:04:54.920
HOME OR PROPERTY OWNERS COSTS
02:04:54.987 --> 02:04:58.591
DISPROPORTIONATELY. WILL AFFECT
02:04:58.657 --> 02:04:59.692
LOWER INCOME AND DISADVANTAGED
02:04:59.758 --> 02:05:02.394
COMMUNITIES. AS LOCAL
02:05:02.461 --> 02:05:04.763
JURISDICTIONS MAY ADOPT, OR
02:05:04.830 --> 02:05:06.198
MAYBE ADOPTING ORDINANCES TO
02:05:06.265 --> 02:05:07.967
ADDRESS EXISTING BUILDINGS.
02:05:08.033 --> 02:05:10.002
CALIFORNIA LAW MUST BE UPGRADED
02:05:10.069 --> 02:05:11.437
TO ENSURE THAT THESE ORDINANCES
02:05:11.503 --> 02:05:12.671
ARE ADOPTED WHILE TAKING
02:05:12.738 --> 02:05:13.572
IMPORTANT FACTORS INTO
02:05:13.639 --> 02:05:16.008
CONSIDERATION. RECENT AMENDMENTS
02:05:16.075 --> 02:05:19.211
HAVE BEEN REMOVED. THE
02:05:19.278 --> 02:05:19.979
OPPOSITION HAS HAVE REMOVED
02:05:20.045 --> 02:05:23.716
THEIR OPPOSITION. SO LET ME SAY
02:05:23.782 --> 02:05:24.884
IT AGAIN, PLEASE. RECENT
02:05:24.950 --> 02:05:26.051
AMENDMENTS HAVE REMOVED
02:05:26.118 --> 02:05:28.153
OPPOSITION FROM THE LEAGUE, THE
02:05:28.220 --> 02:05:30.189
STATE ASSOCIATION OF COUNTIES
02:05:30.256 --> 02:05:30.756
NATURAL RESOURCES, DEFENSE
02:05:30.823 --> 02:05:33.993
COUNCIL, SIERRA CLUB AND OTHERS.
02:05:34.059 --> 02:05:35.027
I WANT TO THANK ALL THE
02:05:35.094 --> 02:05:37.096
STAKEHOLDERS FOR WORKING WITH ME
02:05:37.162 --> 02:05:38.130
THROUGHOUT THIS LEGISLATIVE
02:05:38.197 --> 02:05:40.566
PROCESS ON THE BILL AND WITH ME
02:05:40.633 --> 02:05:42.701
TODAY TO TESTIFY IF YOU HAVE ANY
02:05:42.768 --> 02:05:43.769
FURTHER QUESTIONS IS ANTHONY
02:05:43.836 --> 02:05:46.205
SAMPSON ON BEHALF OF THE OLD
02:05:46.272 --> 02:05:46.739
SMITH CORPORATION, AND I
02:05:46.805 --> 02:05:50.075
RESPECTFULLY ASK YEAR I VOTE
02:05:50.142 --> 02:05:51.610
GREAT. THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR
02:05:51.677 --> 02:05:53.646
AND MEMBERS, ANTHONY SAMPSON ON
02:05:53.712 --> 02:05:55.547
BEHALF OF A SMITH CORPORATION
02:05:55.614 --> 02:05:56.282
ARGEST WATER HEATER
02:05:56.348 --> 02:05:58.017
MANUFACTURER IN NORTH AMERICA,
02:05:58.083 --> 02:05:58.951
INCLUDING ELECTRIC HEAT PUMP
02:05:59.018 --> 02:06:01.754
WATER HEATERS. I THINK THAT THE
02:06:01.820 --> 02:06:03.389
FUNDAMENTAL OBJECTIVE HERE IS TO
02:06:03.455 --> 02:06:06.258
MAKE SURE THAT LOCAL EFFORTS TO
02:06:06.325 --> 02:06:08.460
DE CARBONIZED EXISTING BUILDINGS
02:06:08.527 --> 02:06:10.429
WORKS IN A PRAGMATIC WAY. THERE
02:06:10.496 --> 02:06:11.530
ARE UNIQUE CHALLENGES AS THE
02:06:11.597 --> 02:06:13.866
SENATE MENTIONED ASSOCIATE D
02:06:13.933 --> 02:06:16.001
CARBON IZING EXISTING BUILDINGS
02:06:16.068 --> 02:06:18.203
THAT SIMPLY NOT PRESENT AS IT
02:06:18.270 --> 02:06:20.072
RELATES TO NEW CONSTRUCTION,
02:06:20.139 --> 02:06:22.975
EVEN WITH NEW CONSTRUCTION, AND
02:06:23.042 --> 02:06:25.477
AS THE SENATOR NOTED FOR RETAIL
02:06:25.544 --> 02:06:27.413
WITH THE C E C APPROVAL THROUGH
02:06:27.479 --> 02:06:30.416
A REVIEW PROCESS, ALL SAYING IN
02:06:30.482 --> 02:06:32.418
THIS BILL IS THAT LOCAL WHEN
02:06:32.484 --> 02:06:34.520
LOOKING AT EXISTING BUILDING
02:06:34.586 --> 02:06:36.121
ORDINANCE REQUIRING THE
02:06:36.188 --> 02:06:37.356
SWITCHING FOR US TO A LECTURE
02:06:37.423 --> 02:06:40.592
CONSIDER STATEMENTS AND THEN THE
02:06:40.659 --> 02:06:43.595
STATE THE C E C REVIEW TO ENSURE
02:06:43.662 --> 02:06:44.997
THAT THAT THAT THOSE WERE
02:06:45.064 --> 02:06:46.532
CONSIDERED AND THEN THAT'S IT.
02:06:46.598 --> 02:06:47.566
IT'S A MINISTERIAL DETERMINATION
02:06:47.633 --> 02:06:48.734
. WAS IT CONSIDERED OR WAS IT
02:06:48.801 --> 02:06:51.170
NOT? IT DOESN'T DICTATE. OR
02:06:51.236 --> 02:06:52.938
REQUIRE CERTAIN OUTCOMES,
02:06:53.005 --> 02:06:54.440
ADMITTEDLY VERSION OF THE
02:06:54.506 --> 02:06:56.008
BUILDINGS MORE AGGRESSIVE DID
02:06:56.075 --> 02:06:59.645
REQUIRE THAT THAT OBJECTION.
02:06:59.712 --> 02:07:01.380
THESE STATE ASSOCIATED COUNTIES
02:07:01.447 --> 02:07:03.148
AND INDIVIDUAL CITIES. WE HAVE
02:07:03.215 --> 02:07:04.850
WORKED VERY CLOSELY WITH THE
02:07:04.917 --> 02:07:05.784
OPPOSITION, BUT THE COURSE OF
02:07:05.851 --> 02:07:07.252
THE PROCESS AND ATHLETES. THE
02:07:07.319 --> 02:07:09.888
BILL IS 10 AND APPRECIATE THE
02:07:09.955 --> 02:07:11.090
CONSIDERATION OF THIS BILL, AND
02:07:11.156 --> 02:07:13.258
CERTAINLY HAS ANSWER ANY
02:07:13.325 --> 02:07:15.728
QUESTIONS? THANK YOU. Q. R
02:07:15.794 --> 02:07:17.763
OTHERS IN THE, UM, THAT
02:07:17.830 --> 02:07:20.366
SUPPORTING THE BILL. NOT AS
02:07:20.432 --> 02:07:30.442
OPPOSITION. MHM. ALSO SO HIGH ON
02:07:30.509 --> 02:07:32.144
BEHALF OF THE CITY OF SANTA ROSA
02:07:32.211 --> 02:07:33.612
IN OPPOSITION. THANK YOU VERY
02:07:33.679 --> 02:07:39.284
MUCH. OKAY, SAYING NONE OTHER
02:07:39.351 --> 02:07:44.223
ANY QUESTIONS OF THE COMMITTEE.
02:07:44.289 --> 02:07:47.993
SIX OKAY. WE HAVE MOTION BY, UH
02:07:48.060 --> 02:07:49.695
, SOME REMEMBER BOERNER HORVATH
02:07:49.762 --> 02:07:54.266
AND A SPY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S.
02:07:54.333 --> 02:08:01.140
CLOSE BASICALLY, YEAH. GREAT
02:08:01.206 --> 02:08:04.376
THANK YOU SO MUCH FILTH. WE
02:08:04.443 --> 02:08:08.747
HEARD YOU. UM ACHIEVING CRITICAL
02:08:08.814 --> 02:08:13.185
STEP CLUTCH. FINISHED
02:08:13.252 --> 02:08:18.924
THOUGHTFUL. TÂM. TIM'S THIS
02:08:18.991 --> 02:08:22.327
TODAY WITHOUT PUSHES DOESN'T
02:08:22.394 --> 02:08:24.997
CREATIONS FISCAL LITTLE, VERY
02:08:25.064 --> 02:08:32.204
LACKING. FLOOD. BACK. FROM
02:08:32.271 --> 02:08:58.197
OUTSIDE OF SCOOPS. SANTIAGO. AH!
02:08:58.263 --> 02:09:18.817
WAS ABROAD. LIKE.
02:09:22.821 --> 02:09:49.515
I DON'T REMEMBER. OH, MODERATOR.
02:09:53.418 --> 02:10:08.700
SERIE PLAN.
02:12:44.623 --> 02:12:47.726
OVER MOTION, PLEASE. ALRIGHT,
02:12:47.793 --> 02:12:52.230
THIS IS SUMMER. BE SOMEBODY.
02:12:52.297 --> 02:13:08.380
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S. SORRY. I. DOG,
02:13:08.447 --> 02:13:14.119
SANTIAGO VOEPEL BY 60. OKAY
02:13:14.186 --> 02:13:30.435
YOURSELF. ZERO.
02:13:59.064 --> 02:14:01.032
HEY, WE'RE GONNA GO BACK AND DO
02:14:01.099 --> 02:14:02.200
SOME CLEANUP HERE. UM, ITEM
02:14:02.267 --> 02:14:05.871
NUMBER TWO. SB 897, SENATOR
02:14:05.937 --> 02:14:07.806
WIECKOWSKI. WE HAVE ACTION, BUT
02:14:07.873 --> 02:14:10.409
WE DO NOT HAVE A SECOND. OKAY WE
02:14:10.475 --> 02:14:12.377
HAVE A SECOND BY ASSEMBLING
02:14:12.444 --> 02:14:18.350
MEMBER OF SANTIAGO. SECRETARY
02:14:18.417 --> 02:14:21.186
TAKE YOUR ROLE MOTION. OH, I
02:14:21.253 --> 02:14:24.423
THOUGHT WE HAD A MOTION. I MEAN
02:14:24.489 --> 02:14:26.491
THAT MOST OF ACTION ACTION SORRY
02:14:26.558 --> 02:14:34.399
WE NEEDED. YEAH, OKAY. SO THIS
02:14:34.466 --> 02:14:38.136
IS DO PASS AS AMENDED. UM WE
02:14:38.203 --> 02:14:39.704
HAVE A MOTION BY
02:14:39.771 --> 02:14:41.506
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BLOOM AND A
02:14:41.573 --> 02:14:43.208
SECOND BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
02:14:43.275 --> 02:14:46.478
SANTIAGO AGUIAR-CURRY CURRY. I
02:14:46.545 --> 02:14:48.613
LACKEY, BLACKIE NO BLOOM. BLOOM.
02:14:48.680 --> 02:14:53.351
I BOERNER HORVATH RAMOS. CRUMBLE
02:14:53.418 --> 02:14:56.721
SIDE LOST RIVERS. SANTIAGO
02:14:56.788 --> 02:15:01.593
SANTIAGO, I VOEPEL NÓ FORCING.
02:15:01.660 --> 02:15:02.794
HEY, BOB. BILLS FOR ZEROS ON
02:15:02.861 --> 02:15:08.900
CALL. LET'S MAKE THAT 42 ON
02:15:08.967 --> 02:15:12.270
ASSEMBLY. RIGHT? YEAH. EXCUSE ME
02:15:12.337 --> 02:15:34.526
FOR TWO ON SP 897897. ON A CALL.
02:15:49.674 --> 02:15:51.343
ALRIGHT, MORE CLEANUP ON FEET 8
02:15:51.409 --> 02:15:56.414
91 ON CALL. AGUIAR-CURRY AYE,
02:15:56.481 --> 02:16:00.619
CURRY. AYE. THREE OF US SANTIAGO
02:16:00.685 --> 02:16:13.298
SANTIAGO. AYE. BILLS OUT 50. SB
02:16:13.365 --> 02:16:18.637
10 67 PORTANTINO. THE ACTION IS
02:16:18.703 --> 02:16:22.073
TO PASS AS AMENDED. CURRY CURRY
02:16:22.140 --> 02:16:25.610
, BLACKIE BLACKIE NO.
02:16:25.677 --> 02:16:27.512
THREE OF US SANTIAGO SANTIAGO. I
02:16:27.579 --> 02:16:32.551
SEE. PORTS THREE OKAY. BILL IS
02:16:32.617 --> 02:16:43.795
FOR THREE. THE MOTION ON THAT
02:16:43.862 --> 02:16:45.897
BILL IS A DO PASS AS AMENDED TO
02:16:45.964 --> 02:16:48.300
APPROPRIATION. AND THE 453
02:16:48.366 --> 02:17:04.449
NOTES.
02:17:08.286 --> 02:17:09.487
YOU'D THINK BY NOW I'D HAVE THIS
02:17:09.554 --> 02:17:14.693
DOWN, WOULDN'T YOU? YEAH. OKAY
02:17:14.759 --> 02:17:17.095
UM, WE DID. SB 8 91 DO PASS TO
02:17:17.162 --> 02:17:21.299
APPROPRIATIONS THAT IS FIVE.
02:17:21.366 --> 02:17:23.234
ZERO AND IT IS ON NO ONE GETS
02:17:23.301 --> 02:17:41.353
UP, OKAY? WE GOT THEM ALL NOW.
02:19:01.366 --> 02:19:03.935
GO AHEAD WITH, UH SENATE BILL 14
02:19:04.002 --> 02:19:11.810
49. QUÊ FOR OFFICE. I'M
02:19:11.876 --> 02:19:13.712
PRESENTING FOR CENTER CABALLERO
02:19:13.778 --> 02:19:17.949
S B 14 9. THANK YOU FOR THE
02:19:18.016 --> 02:19:19.284
PRESENT THIS BILL, THE
02:19:19.350 --> 02:19:20.952
UNINCORPORATED AREA ANNEXATIONS
02:19:21.019 --> 02:19:23.088
FROM THROUGHOUT THE STATE,
02:19:23.154 --> 02:19:24.856
ORGANIZED AND HAVE INHABITED
02:19:24.923 --> 02:19:26.357
AREAS, AREAS IN THE COUNTY
02:19:26.424 --> 02:19:29.828
INCORPORATED. AND INCORPORATED
02:19:29.894 --> 02:19:30.261
THERE, SURROUNDED BY
02:19:30.328 --> 02:19:31.863
INCORPORATES CITY RESIDENTS.
02:19:31.930 --> 02:19:34.099
THESE UNINCORPORATED AREAS HAVE
02:19:34.165 --> 02:19:35.934
NO LOCAL REPRESENTATION INSTEAD
02:19:36.000 --> 02:19:37.268
ARE GOVERNED BY THE COUNTY BOARD
02:19:37.335 --> 02:19:39.471
OF SUPERVISORS. IN THESE AREAS,
02:19:39.537 --> 02:19:40.672
ESPECIALLY IMPORTANT
02:19:40.739 --> 02:19:41.539
DISADVANTAGED COMMUNITIES, THE
02:19:41.606 --> 02:19:42.941
LEVEL OF BASIC INFRASTRUCTURE
02:19:43.007 --> 02:19:45.043
AND SERVICES IS MINIMAL, IF ANY
02:19:45.110 --> 02:19:47.145
EXISTS AT ALL. MEMBERS TO
02:19:47.212 --> 02:19:48.513
ILLUSTRATE THE NEED FOR THIS
02:19:48.580 --> 02:19:51.149
BILL. I ASK YOU TO PUT YOURSELF
02:19:51.216 --> 02:19:51.716
IN THE SHOES OF SOMEONE WHO
02:19:51.783 --> 02:19:53.852
LIVES IN A POOR, RURAL
02:19:53.918 --> 02:19:54.452
UNINCORPORATED AREA. IMAGINE A
02:19:54.519 --> 02:19:55.420
PAENT WALKING THEIR CHILD TO
02:19:55.487 --> 02:19:57.455
SCHOOL ONE DAY AFTER HEAVY NIGHT
02:19:57.522 --> 02:19:58.456
OF RAIN BECAUSE THE COMMUNITY
02:19:58.523 --> 02:19:59.457
LACKS PROPER SIDEWALKS AND STORM
02:19:59.524 --> 02:20:01.459
DRAINAGE. THE BUILDING IS FORCED
02:20:01.526 --> 02:20:03.695
TO WALK IN THE MIDDLE OF THE
02:20:03.762 --> 02:20:04.462
ROAD IN ORDER TO AVOID FLOODED
02:20:04.529 --> 02:20:06.397
OR MUDDY AREAS, PUTTING THEM AT
02:20:06.464 --> 02:20:09.734
RISK OF COLLISION WITH PASSING
02:20:09.801 --> 02:20:11.536
VEHICLES. THIS IS THE REALITY
02:20:11.603 --> 02:20:13.371
FOR MANY PEOPLE LIVING IN AN
02:20:13.438 --> 02:20:14.439
INCORPORATED AREAS. BECAUSE
02:20:14.506 --> 02:20:15.607
THESE COMMUNITIES DO NOT HAVE
02:20:15.673 --> 02:20:17.442
THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT TO PROVIDE
02:20:17.509 --> 02:20:18.576
SERVICES THEY MUST MAKE DO WITH
02:20:18.643 --> 02:20:20.445
LITTLE PUBLIC HEALTH AND SAFETY
02:20:20.512 --> 02:20:22.347
INFRASTRUCTURE EXISTS THE
02:20:22.413 --> 02:20:23.515
DIFFERENCE IN THE LEVEL OF
02:20:23.581 --> 02:20:25.350
SERVICE PROVIDED WITHIN A CITY
02:20:25.416 --> 02:20:27.585
VERSUS WITHIN UNINCORPORATED IS
02:20:27.652 --> 02:20:29.053
EVEN MORE NOTICEABLE WHEN THE
02:20:29.120 --> 02:20:30.155
UNINCORPORATED AREA HAPPENS TO
02:20:30.221 --> 02:20:32.123
BE FULLY SURROUNDED BY CITIES,
02:20:32.190 --> 02:20:34.025
BOUNDARIES. CREATING AN
02:20:34.092 --> 02:20:36.294
UNINCORPORATED ISLAND IN MANY
02:20:36.361 --> 02:20:37.829
<c.green>ASES LEADING RIGHT UP TO THE</c>
02:20:37.896 --> 02:20:39.330
BOUNDARIES OF THE UNINCORPORATED
02:20:39.397 --> 02:20:41.633
ISLAND THERE MAY THERE MAY BE
02:20:41.699 --> 02:20:42.634
PAVE ROADS, SIDEWALKS, CURBS,
02:20:42.700 --> 02:20:44.569
GUTTERS AND STREET LIGHTS ONLY
02:20:44.636 --> 02:20:45.136
DISAPPEAR IMMEDIATELY UPON
02:20:45.203 --> 02:20:47.772
ENTERING THE BOUNDARIES. OF AN
02:20:47.839 --> 02:20:49.207
UNINCORPORATED ISLAND AND THEN
02:20:49.274 --> 02:20:51.509
REAPPEAR UPON ENTERING THE CITY
02:20:51.576 --> 02:20:52.944
BOUNDARIES ON THE OTHER SIDE.
02:20:53.011 --> 02:20:55.113
WHILE EXISTING LOUD NOW LAW NOW
02:20:55.180 --> 02:20:56.548
PREVENTS A CITY FROM
02:20:56.614 --> 02:20:58.082
LEAPFROGGING OVER UNINCORPORATED
02:20:58.149 --> 02:20:59.851
AREAS WHEN EXPANDING ITS BORDERS
02:20:59.918 --> 02:21:01.553
, THE UNINCORPORATED ISLANDS
02:21:01.619 --> 02:21:02.754
CREATED FROM YEARS OF CITIES
02:21:02.821 --> 02:21:04.889
PICKING AND CHOOSING. WHICH
02:21:04.956 --> 02:21:07.058
AREAS THEY WISH TO ANNEX REMAINS
02:21:07.125 --> 02:21:08.726
. THIS IS PART AND DUE TO THE
02:21:08.793 --> 02:21:10.695
COST OF BUILD AND CONNECT A
02:21:10.762 --> 02:21:11.563
COMMUNITY TO CITY INFRASTRUCTURE
02:21:11.629 --> 02:21:13.398
, WHICH ACTS AS A DISINCENTIVE
02:21:13.464 --> 02:21:16.067
FOR CITIES TO PURSUE ANNEXATION.
02:21:16.134 --> 02:21:18.436
THAT IS WHY I'VE INTRODUCED SB
02:21:18.503 --> 02:21:20.672
14 49 THIS YEAR TO ENCOURAGE
02:21:20.738 --> 02:21:22.173
CITIES AND COUNTIES TO JOINTLY
02:21:22.240 --> 02:21:23.007
PURSUE ANNEXATIONS OF
02:21:23.074 --> 02:21:25.476
UNINCORPORATED AREAS AND PROVIDE
02:21:25.543 --> 02:21:27.478
THE BASIC NEEDS THAT MOST PEOPLE
02:21:27.545 --> 02:21:28.513
TAKE FOR GRANTED AND TAKE
02:21:28.580 --> 02:21:29.747
ANOTHER STEP TO ELIMINATE THESE
02:21:29.814 --> 02:21:32.450
ISLANDS. SPECIFICALLY AS BEFORE
02:21:32.517 --> 02:21:34.619
THINE 40 WILL CREATE A NEW GRANT
02:21:34.686 --> 02:21:36.187
PROGRAM WITHIN THE GOVERNOR'S
02:21:36.254 --> 02:21:37.455
OFFICE OF PLANNING AND RESEARCH
02:21:37.522 --> 02:21:39.224
TO PROVIDE AN INCENTIVE THROUGH
02:21:39.290 --> 02:21:40.525
A MATCHING GRANT PROGRAM FOR
02:21:40.592 --> 02:21:41.960
CITIES AND COUNTIES WHO ANNEXED
02:21:42.026 --> 02:21:43.528
UNINCORPORATED AREAS FOR
02:21:43.595 --> 02:21:44.963
PURPOSES OF FUNDING
02:21:45.029 --> 02:21:46.364
INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS RELATED
02:21:46.431 --> 02:21:47.565
TO HEALTH AND SAFETY, SUCH AS
02:21:47.632 --> 02:21:50.335
SEWER SERVICE. SIDEWALKS, CURBS
02:21:50.401 --> 02:21:53.538
AND STORMWATER MANAGEMENT-SYSTEMS. OPR WILL BE REQUIRED TO
02:21:53.605 --> 02:21:55.673
PRIORITIZE GRANTS FOR ANNEXATION
02:21:55.740 --> 02:21:57.175
OF DISADVANTAGED, UNINCORPORATED
02:21:57.242 --> 02:21:58.710
COMMUNITIES AND TO WORK WITH
02:21:58.776 --> 02:22:00.044
SPECIFIC STAKEHOLDERS THAT
02:22:00.111 --> 02:22:02.013
REPRESENTS THE COUNTIES AND THE
02:22:02.080 --> 02:22:02.480
LOCAL AGENCY FORMATION
02:22:02.547 --> 02:22:04.148
COMMISSIONS. DEVELOPED THE
02:22:04.215 --> 02:22:06.518
PROGRAM HERE WITH ME TODAY TO
02:22:06.584 --> 02:22:08.853
TESTIFY AND SUPPORT OF THIS BILL
02:22:08.920 --> 02:22:10.822
IS NICK ROMMEL. HI. HELLO.
02:22:10.889 --> 02:22:12.023
LEGISLATIVE REPRESENTATIVE WITH
02:22:12.090 --> 02:22:17.829
THE CAT WITH WITH CAL CITIES.
02:22:17.896 --> 02:22:19.397
THANK YOU CAN REMEMBER GRANDMA
02:22:19.464 --> 02:22:21.266
WITH THE LEAGUE OF CALIFORNIA
02:22:21.332 --> 02:22:22.934
CITIES WE FIRST WANT TO COMMEND
02:22:23.001 --> 02:22:23.501
SECRETARY CAVALLERO FOR HER
02:22:23.568 --> 02:22:25.236
LEADERSHIP ON THIS ISSUE. THANK
02:22:25.303 --> 02:22:27.705
YOU TO THE CHAIR AS WELL. UM
02:22:27.772 --> 02:22:30.708
CITIES HAVE FOR YEARS BEEN
02:22:30.775 --> 02:22:32.977
TRYING TO FINANCE ANNEXATIONS
02:22:33.044 --> 02:22:33.411
PRIMARILY OF THESE
02:22:33.478 --> 02:22:34.112
DISADVANTAGING GREAT
02:22:34.178 --> 02:22:37.815
COMMUNITIES. SINCE 1011 WHEN THE
02:22:37.882 --> 02:22:39.951
PROPERTY TAX ADJUSTMENT SWEPT
02:22:40.018 --> 02:22:41.486
AWAY FROM CITIES HAVE HAD A
02:22:41.552 --> 02:22:43.021
DIFFICULT TIME MAKING THE
02:22:43.087 --> 02:22:44.622
PROJECT PENCIL OUT IN THESE
02:22:44.689 --> 02:22:46.891
COMMUNITIES. SO WE THANK YOU FOR
02:22:46.958 --> 02:22:47.892
YOUR LEADERSHIP. AND WE
02:22:47.959 --> 02:22:53.464
APPRECIATE YOUR SUPPORT. THANK
02:22:53.531 --> 02:22:54.832
YOU, MR CHAIR MEMBERS JEAN HURST
02:22:54.899 --> 02:22:56.434
HERE TODAY ON BEHALF OF THE
02:22:56.501 --> 02:22:57.969
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF LOCAL
02:22:58.036 --> 02:22:59.070
AGENCY FORMATION, COMMISSIONS
02:22:59.137 --> 02:23:01.072
AND THE CITY OF SAN YOU KNOW IN
02:23:01.139 --> 02:23:17.221
SPORT.
02:23:22.493 --> 02:23:25.063
UM SB 14 49 WILL PROVIDE A GREAT
02:23:25.129 --> 02:23:26.564
TOOL FOR CITIES WHO WISH TO
02:23:26.631 --> 02:23:27.398
EXTEND THEIR SERVICES TO
02:23:27.465 --> 02:23:28.933
UNINCORPORATED COMMUNITIES THAT
02:23:29.000 --> 02:23:30.668
ARE LACKING BASIC SERVICES AND
02:23:30.735 --> 02:23:32.036
INFRASTRUCTURE BUT HAVE BEEN
02:23:32.103 --> 02:23:34.005
UNABLE TO DUE TO FINANCIAL
02:23:34.072 --> 02:23:36.007
BARRIERS. THANK YOU MEMBERS FOR
02:23:36.074 --> 02:23:37.508
THE OPPORTUNITY TO PRESENT SP 14
02:23:37.575 --> 02:23:39.210
49 TODAY AND I RESPECTFULLY
02:23:39.277 --> 02:23:43.681
REQUEST YOUR I VOTE.
02:23:43.748 --> 02:23:47.785
AGUIAR-CURRY. EXCUSE ME. THE
02:23:47.852 --> 02:23:49.954
MOTION IS A DO PASS TO
02:23:50.021 --> 02:23:52.190
APPROPRIATIONS. THANK YOU. AGRA
02:23:52.256 --> 02:23:55.960
CURRY CURRY. I LACKEY LACKEY I
02:23:56.027 --> 02:23:58.296
BLOOM BLOOM I BOERNER HORVATH
02:23:58.363 --> 02:24:02.300
ROUBLES. BROUGH SIDE THREE OF US
02:24:02.367 --> 02:24:05.436
THREE OF US SIZE SANTIAGO.
02:24:05.503 --> 02:24:11.175
SANTIAGO I VOEPEL AYE. 70. THANK
02:24:11.242 --> 02:24:38.136
YOU VERY MUCH. M
02:25:42.366 --> 02:25:46.204
VE ME 52, AND IT'S UP.
02:25:46.270 --> 02:25:47.672
PLEASURE ADDING. IT'S OKAY. IT'S
02:25:47.738 --> 02:26:01.185
OKAY. IT'S THE LAST MEETING.
02:26:01.252 --> 02:26:05.456
UH SP 10 67, WHICH WAS ITEM
02:26:05.523 --> 02:26:06.390
NUMBER THREE, SENATOR
02:26:06.457 --> 02:26:09.861
PORTANTINO. D<c.cyan> PASS AS AMENDED</c>
02:26:09.927 --> 02:26:14.232
TO APPROPRIATIONS. THREE OF US.
02:26:14.298 --> 02:26:29.981
AYE. BILL IS OUT 53. ITEM NUMBER
02:26:30.047 --> 02:26:33.151
FOUR SP 11 05 HUESO DO PASS AS
02:26:33.217 --> 02:26:37.088
AMENDED TO APPROPRIATIONS. THREE
02:26:37.155 --> 02:26:38.489
BUS THREE OF US EYES SANTIAGO
02:26:38.556 --> 02:26:45.997
SANTIAGO NO, NO, NO. 62. BILL IS
02:26:46.063 --> 02:26:57.275
SIX TO BILL IS OUT. AH NEXT. WE
02:26:57.341 --> 02:27:01.045
HAVE S B 13 93 OUR CHILDREN TO
02:27:01.112 --> 02:27:03.381
ITEM NUMBER SIX DO PASS AS
02:27:03.447 --> 02:27:05.983
AMENDED TO APPROPRIATIONS.
02:27:06.050 --> 02:27:11.389
BLACKY I BOERNER HORVATH.
02:27:11.455 --> 02:27:13.624
THREE OF US THREE OF US SIDE.
02:27:13.691 --> 02:27:17.895
SANTIAGO SANTIAGO, I 70. BILL IS
02:27:17.962 --> 02:27:23.968
OUT 70. CALENDAR. AND DO THE
02:27:24.035 --> 02:27:27.705
CONSENT CALENDAR. DO PASS THE
02:27:27.772 --> 02:27:33.578
PRO PRO, OKAY? BOERNER HORVATH.
02:27:33.644 --> 02:27:36.747
THREE OF US THREE OF US SIDE 70
02:27:36.814 --> 02:27:43.521
AND SENT IS OUT 70. EVERYONE'S
02:27:43.588 --> 02:27:49.026
NOW WE DO ADD ONS. UM SP 8 91
02:27:49.093 --> 02:27:52.296
HERZBERG, WHICH ITEM NUMBER ONE.
02:27:52.363 --> 02:27:55.333
THREE OF US THREE OF US SIDE.
02:27:55.399 --> 02:27:58.169
FINAL VOTE IS 60 IS 60 DO PAST
02:27:58.236 --> 02:28:05.309
APPROPRIATIONS. NEXT IS, UM.
02:28:05.376 --> 02:28:07.979
ITEM NUMBER FIVE SP 12 90 ALAN
02:28:08.045 --> 02:28:09.547
DO PASS AS AMENDED TO
02:28:09.614 --> 02:28:12.783
APPROPRIATIONS AGUIAR-CURRY I
02:28:12.850 --> 02:28:14.352
REAL CURRY ISLANDS RIVAS
02:28:14.418 --> 02:28:20.491
PREVIOUS I, SANTIAGO. VOTING 70.
02:28:20.558 --> 02:28:30.134
BUILDS OUT 70. NEXT SP 14 49
02:28:30.201 --> 02:28:32.970
ITEM NUMBER SEVEN CABALLERO. D<c.cyan></c>
02:28:33.037 --> 02:28:34.605
PASS TO APPROPRIATIONS.
02:28:34.672 --> 02:28:38.976
BOERNER HORVATH. FILLS OUT.
02:28:39.043 --> 02:28:48.152
YEAH, 70. AH SUPER NEED 76 ITEM
02:28:48.219 --> 02:28:50.755
NUMBER EIGHT. SP 14 76 BRADFORD
02:28:50.821 --> 02:28:54.825
BRADFORD DO PASS AS AMENDED.
02:28:54.892 --> 02:28:56.560
BOERNER HORVATH THREE OF US
02:28:56.627 --> 02:29:08.939
THREE OF US. I 17 FILLS OUT 70.
02:29:09.006 --> 02:29:29.627
IN 67. THINK SHE DID.
02:29:29.694 --> 02:29:30.795
THAT WAS THE FIRST WOMAN DID
02:29:30.861 --> 02:29:38.135
YEAH. JUST TO CONFIRM. UM SB 10
02:29:38.202 --> 02:29:40.871
67 IS OUT. IT WAS DUE PAST AS
02:29:40.938 --> 02:29:43.074
AMENDED TO APPROPRIATIONS AND
02:29:43.140 --> 02:29:45.042
THAT WAS 53. AND I'M SORRY. THE
02:29:45.109 --> 02:29:46.043
MICROPHONES WERE OFF AT THE
02:29:46.110 --> 02:30:02.893
TIME. OKAY, WE SIT.
02:30:42.032 --> 02:30:44.969
SB 8 97 WITKOWSKI PASSES A
02:30:45.035 --> 02:30:46.036
MINUTE TO APPROPRIATION
02:30:46.103 --> 02:30:48.806
BOERNER HORVATH. BOERNER HORVATH
02:30:48.873 --> 02:30:56.013
NO FINAL VOTE IS 53. SP 30 93
02:30:56.080 --> 02:31:00.651
ARCHULETTA. THE MOST. THE ACTION
02:31:00.718 --> 02:31:03.254
IS DO PASS AS A MINUTE TO
02:31:03.320 --> 02:31:07.958
APPROPRIATION. BOERNER HORVATH.
02:31:08.025 --> 02:31:09.059
BOERNER HORVATH I DON'T VOTE IS
02:31:09.126 --> 02:31:19.703
80. SP 14 49 IS THAT DO PASS?
02:31:19.770 --> 02:31:23.407
BOERNER HORVATH. T<c.cyan></c>
02:31:23.474 --> 02:31:26.644
APPROPRIATIONS. BUT BERNHARDT
02:31:26.710 --> 02:31:35.486
VET AYE. FINAL VOTE IS 80. SB 14
02:31:35.553 --> 02:31:37.922
76 DO PASS AS AMENDED. TO THE
02:31:37.988 --> 02:31:44.395
FLOOR. BOERNER HORVATH BRADFORD.
02:31:44.462 --> 02:31:45.663
BETTER HARD THAT I FINAL VOTE IS
02:31:45.729 --> 02:31:53.003
80. CONSENT CALENDAR. SP 14 89
02:31:53.070 --> 02:31:53.504
DO PASTOR APPROPRIATION
02:31:53.571 --> 02:31:54.138
RECOMMENDED CONSENT
02:31:54.205 --> 02:31:57.308
BOERNER HORVATH. SO HARD THAT I
02:31:57.374 --> 02:32:09.353
FINAL ABOUT 80. SO I BEFORE WE
02:32:09.420 --> 02:32:11.922
CLOSE TODAY, THE COMMITTEE TODAY
02:32:11.989 --> 02:32:13.190
AND THERE'S NOT EVERYBODY HERE,
02:32:13.257 --> 02:32:14.792
BUT I'D LIKE TO TAKE THIS
02:32:14.859 --> 02:32:16.160
OPPORTUNITY. MY ASSEMBLY FELLOW
02:32:16.227 --> 02:32:18.195
RAINER RAINER APOSTLE TO STAND
02:32:18.262 --> 02:32:20.130
AND ALLOW US TO RECOGNIZE THEM
02:32:20.197 --> 02:32:21.765
FOR THEIR WORK. WITH THE
02:32:21.832 --> 02:32:23.467
COMMITTEE TODAY AND FOR THE
02:32:23.534 --> 02:32:29.573
WHOLE SYSTEM. IN ADDITION TO ALL
02:32:29.640 --> 02:32:31.609
THE THINGS ARE FELLOWS DO EVERY
02:32:31.675 --> 02:32:32.910
YEAR TO KEEP THE WHEELS TURNING
02:32:32.977 --> 02:32:34.645
IN. OUR PERSONAL OFFICES ARE
02:32:34.712 --> 02:32:36.447
ALSO TOOK ON THE DUTIES OF
02:32:36.514 --> 02:32:37.481
COMMUNITY CONSULTANT. THANK YOU,
02:32:37.548 --> 02:32:40.050
RAINER FOR ALL YOUR HARD WORK.
02:32:40.117 --> 02:32:42.486
TAKING ON ALL THESE ROLES. WE
02:32:42.553 --> 02:32:43.721
REALLY APPRECIATE IT. AND IT
02:32:43.787 --> 02:32:45.689
ALSO LIKE TO THANK THE COMMITTEE
02:32:45.756 --> 02:32:47.458
FOR ALWAYS ATTENDING AND BEING
02:32:47.525 --> 02:32:50.127
INVOLVED AND MY CONSULTING TEAM.
02:32:50.194 --> 02:32:51.295
THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR THE
02:32:51.362 --> 02:32:52.329
ENTIRE TEAM. THIS HAS BEEN A
02:32:52.396 --> 02:32:56.467
GOOD YEAR. LET'S MOVE ON. THANK
02:32:56.534 --> 02:32:58.936
YOU. YES I LIKE TO THANK OUR
02:32:59.003 --> 02:32:59.470
WONDERFUL CHAIR OF LOCAL
02:32:59.537 --> 02:33:00.938
GOVERNMENT. YOU DO SUCH A GOOD
02:33:01.005 --> 02:33:03.474
JOB AT LIKE YOU AND YOUR TEAM
02:33:03.541 --> 02:33:04.975
ANALYZING THE BILLS WORKING WITH
02:33:05.042 --> 02:33:06.911
MEMBERS. IT'S JUST AMAZING. IT'S
02:33:06.977 --> 02:33:08.012
A PLEASURE SERVING ON YOUR
02:33:08.078 --> 02:33:09.847
COMMITTEE. THANK YOU. I WANTED
02:33:09.914 --> 02:33:11.482
TO SAY GOODBYE TO MR BLOOM,
02:33:11.549 --> 02:33:13.384
BECAUSE THIS IS THE LAST TIME IN
02:33:13.450 --> 02:33:15.085
LOCAL GOVERNMENT. HE LEFT ME SO
02:33:15.152 --> 02:33:18.355
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BLEW HIM. YEAH.
02:33:18.422 --> 02:33:19.590
THANK YOU FOR ALL YOUR SERVICE.
02:33:19.657 --> 02:33:21.926
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BLOOM. WITH
02:33:21.992 --> 02:33:24.295
THAT WE ARE GENERALLY WE
02:33:24.361 --> 02:33:25.396
ADJOURNED THE MEETING. THANK YOU
02:33:25.462 --> 02:33:41.612
VERY MUCH.