THE ASSEMBLY PRIVACY AND
CONSUMER PROTECTION HEARING WILL
BE LIMITING TESTIMONY TO TWO
WITNESSES FOR SUPPORT. TWO FOR
OPPOSITION. EACH WITNESSES WILL
BE ALLOWED, UM TWO MINUTES TO
PRESENT THEIR TESTIMONY. UM,
WE'LL BE TAKING PUBLIC COMMENT.
YOU KNOW THE DRILL. I WANNA
WELCOME ASSEMBLY MEMBER DICKSON,
WHO WE PARTICIPATING IN OUR
HEARING TODAY IN PLACE OF
ASSEMBLY MEMBER FONG, UM, NOT
HERE YET, BUT WILL BE UH, WE
HAVE THREE POSTS ON THE AGENDA
TODAY WITH ONE BEING ON CONSENT
CALENDAR. LET'S CALL THE ROLL
AND ESTABLISH FORUM SO WE CAN
VOTE ON THE CONSENT CALENDAR.
ERIC KHAN. BARRICADE HIM. BAR
KHAN PRESENT. PATTERSON
PATTERSON HERE, BRIAN BRIAN
HERE, DIXON HOOVER. IRWIN.
LOWENTHAL. ORTEGA. OR TAKE
ORTEGA HERE, WARD. WORD HERE.
WIX WIX HERE. WILSON WILSON
HERE. A CORM IS ESTABLISHED, SO
WE WILL ENTERTAIN A MOTION ON
THE CONSENT CALENDAR. THE SECOND
ON THE CONSENT CALENDAR. GREAT
UH, SO THE CONSENT CALENDAR IS A
B 1971. STATUS YOU PASS TO THE
EDUCATION COMMITTEE. CHOLERA. ON
THE CONSENT CALENDAR BAR BAR. Kò
HIM I. PATTERSON PATTERSON. I
BRIAN BRIAN I DIXON HOOVER.
LOWENTHAL ORTEGA. ORTEGA I WAR
WORD. I WIX WIX. I WILSON.
WILSON. I. THAT BILL HAS AIDED
APPLE. WE WILL LEAVE IT ALL OPEN
FOR APPS AND MEMBERS. MR.
GRAYSON, YOU ARE FIRST. A B
1849. GOOD AFTERNOON, MADAM
CHAIR AND MEMBERS. I WOULD LIKE
TO FIRST, UH, THANK THE
COMMITTEE FOR THEIR HARD WORK.
UH, THEY DID INCREDIBLE WORK ON
THIS IMPORTANT BILL. AND I WOULD
LIKE TO ACCEPT THE COMMITTEE
SUGGESTED AMENDMENTS. A B 1849
INCLUDES NONMOTORIZED TRAVEL
TRAILERS AND FIFTH WHEEL
TRAILERS INTO THE DEFINITION OF
NEW MOTOR VEHICLE FOR THE
PURPOSES OF THE TANNER CONSUMER
PROTECTION ACT DURING THE
COVID-19 PANDEMIC, RECREATIONAL
VEHICLE SALES SKYROCKETED AND WE
WITNESSED IN CALIFORNIA HERE AT
LEAST A MASSIVE SURGE IN THE
DEMAND. THERE WAS NEARLY 40%
INCREASE IN SALES JUST IN 2021
ALONE. AND EVEN FROM THAT PRIOR
YEAR, SO WITH THE ROBUST DEMAND
FOR R VÆ S¼ CONSUMERS WERE
FINDING THEMSELVES WITH FAULTY
OR EVEN POORLY MADE TRAVEL
TRAILERS AND FIFTH WHEELS, WHILE
CONSUMERS OF NEW MOTOR VEHICLES
MAY BE PROTECTED IN THE LEMON
LAW, NÓ NON MOTORIZED TRAVEL
TRAILERS OR FIFTH WHEELS ARE
UNFORTUNATELY NOT INCLUDED IN
THE SAME, AND I'M STRESSING THE
WORD, SAME LEMON LAW PROTECTIONS
, SPECIFICALLY, PURCHASERS OF
TRAVEL TRAILERS AND FIFTH WHEELS
ARE COVERED IN A BROADER
CONSUMER PROTECTIONS. UNDER THE
SONG BEVERLY ACT, BUT THEY ARE
NOT AFFORDED THE ABILITY TO
ELECT THEIR OWN REMEDY, WHICH
ARE COVERED UNDER THE TANNER
CONSUMER ACT. A B 1849 WILL HELP
PROTECT CONSUMERS AND PROVIDE
LEGAL RECOURSE FOR INDIVIDUALS
WHO UNKNOWINGLY PURCHASE
DEFECTIVE TRAVEL TRAILERS OR
FIFTH WHEELS. SO I AM I AM AWARE
THAT THERE ARE SOME EXISTING
CONCERNS ON THE BILL. I HAVE
ENGAGED IN PRODUCTIVE
CONVERSATIONS WITH THE
STAKEHOLDERS AND I REMAIN FULLY
COMMITTED TO ADDRESSING ANY
POLICY CONCERNS THAT, UH, SHOULD
THE BILL MOVE FORWARD THROUGH
THE LEGISLATIVE PROCESS. THANK
YOU. AND THIS IS STAFF. SO
ANYONE HERE IN SUPPORT OF THE
BILL? OK, SEEING NONE. WE'LL
MOVE. BESIDES THIS HAPPENED, BUT
ANYONE HERE IN OPPOSITION TO THE
BILL, COME JOIN US. RIGHT?
RIGHT, AND WE WILL GIVE YOU EACH
TWO MINUTES. THANK YOU, MADAM
CHAIR AND MEMBERS. I'M ROSEMARY
SHAHAN, PRESIDENT OF CONSUMERS
FOR AUTO RELIABILITY AND SAFETY.
AND WE WOULD LOVE TO BE ABLE TO
SUPPORT THIS BILL. WE REALLY
APPRECIATE ASSEMBLY MEMBER
GRAYSON'S, UM, INTEREST IN
IMPROVING PROTECTIONS FOR
CALIFORNIA CONSUMERS WHO BUY
THESE VEHICLES A LOT OF TIMES
PLANNING IN ADVANCE TO USE THEM
TO TAKE THEIR FAMILIES ON TRIPS
AND ESPECIALLY LIKE DURING THE
PANDEMIC WHEN IT WAS HAZARDOUS
TO BE IN A HOTEL OR MOTEL. UM
YOU KNOW, THERE'S REALLY NÓ
EXCUSE FOR WHAT HAPPENED.
ASSEMBLY MEMBER GRAYSON. UM
WE'RE BEST KNOWN FOR EXPANDING
PROTECTIONS UNDER CALIFORNIA'S
AUTO LEMON LAW FOR SMALL
BUSINESS OWNERS. MILITARY
PERSONNEL AND OTHERS WHO RELY ON
THE LAW WHEN THEY HAVE VEHICLES
THAT THEY DESPERATELY NEED TO
WORK PROPERLY OR THEIR LIFE
FALLS APART. UM SO WE REGRET
THAT WE'RE IN A POSITION OF
OPPOSING THE BILL AS INTRODUCED,
BUT WE'VE BEEN IN DISCUSSIONS
WITH THE ASSEMBLY MEMBER AND HIS
STAFF AND, UH, APP APPRECIATE
HIS OFFER TO WORK WITH US TO
ENSURE THAT AN INADVERTENT AND
UNINTENDED SEQUENCES ARE
ADDRESSED. AS THE BILL MOVES
THROUGH THE LEGISLATIVE PROCESS.
AND WHO ALSO EXPLORE AVENUES
THAT MAY WORK WELL FOR CONSUMERS
. THAT MAY NOT NECESSARILY
INVOLVE LEGISLATION. SO THANK
YOU. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. THANK
YOU, MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS OF
THE COMMITTEE AND ASSEMBLY.
GRAYSON FOR BRINGING THE BILL
WHICH WE STRANGE THAT TAKING
POSITION BY POSITION. UM M. MY
NAME IS ELLIOT KHAN. I'M A
PRIVATE PRACTITIONING, UH,
CONSUMER PROTECTION ATTORNEY IN
CALIFORNIA SINCE 2011 MY PRIMARY
FOCUS ON BREACH OF WARRANTY
ISSUES, AND I REPRESENT
SUCCESSFULLY REPRESENTED
HUNDREDS OF CALIFORNIA CONSUMERS
IN A WIDE VARIETY OF CONSUMER
PRODUCTS IN CALIFORNIA, RANGING
FROM VEHICLES TO R, VÆ S¼ AND
TRAILERS TO BOATS. I EVEN HAD
CASE DEALING WITH FAUCETS. UM
AND THESE HAVE ALL BEEN BROUGHT
UNDER THE SONG BEVERLY CONSUMER
WARRANTY ACT, UH, GENERALLY WITH
WITH EXCELLENT RESULTS. UM I'M
ALSO A MEMBER OF THE NATIONAL
ASSOCIATION OF CONSUMER
ADVOCATES ON WHOSE BEHALF UH, I
SPEAK TODAY TO VOICE OUR
CONCERNS WITH THE BILL THAT'S
WRITTEN. WHILE WE APPRECIATE THE
PRO CONSUMER INTENT BEHIND THE
BILL, THE BIGGEST CONCERN IS
THAT WE'LL ACTUALLY MAKE THESE
TYPES OF CASES ARE MORE
DIFFICULT TO PROSECUTE. UM AS OF
NOW, IN OUR SHOW BREACH OF
WARRANTY WITH NORMAL CONSUMER
GOOD. YOU SIMPLY HAVE TO SHOW
THAT THERE WAS A DEFECT COVERED
BY THE WARRANTY, WHICH THEY
COULDN'T FIX WITHIN A REASONABLE
NUMBER OF TIMES OR PERIOD OF
TIME. UM, THE BILL IS WRITTEN BY
BRINGING TRAILERS, THE TANNER
WOULD ADD A SUBSTANTIAL
IMPAIRMENT TEST, WHICH REALLY IS
A VEHICLE SPECIFIC TEST THAT THE
USE VALUE OR SAFETY OF THE MOTOR
VEHICLE. UH IT IT IS
SUBSTANTIALLY IMPAIRED TO A
CONSUMER IN THE SAME POSITION AS
THE BUYER, UM, WITH THE TYPES OF
DEFECTS YOU NORMALLY SEE WITH R,
VÆ S¼, OR TRAVEL TRAVEL TRAILERS
WHERE THE REALLY THE ISSUE ISN'T
SO MUCH HOW BAD THE ISSUE IS.
IT'S JUST HOW HOW DARN LONG IT
TAKES THEM TO FIX IT. AH THESE
CASES COULD BE A LOT MORE
DIFFICULT TO PROSECUTE. UM SO
WHILE WE LOOK FORWARD TO WORKING
WITH THE ASSEMBLYMAN, UM TO
AMENDING THE BILL TO EFFECTUATE
THE PRO CONSUMER IN INTENT. UM,
A AS WRITTEN WE MUST VOICE OUR
CONCERNS WITH IT. THANK YOU.
THANK YOU ANYONE ELSE HERE IN
OPPOSITION? UM OR MEET OR IN THE
MIDDLE. UM CAN WE GET THE MIC
SET UP SO WE CAN ADD IN SO THERE
WE GO. CHAIR AND MEMBERS. I'M
MIKE BELOTE FOR THE R VÆ
INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION. WE'VE
DISCUSSED THIS WITH, UH, MR
GRAYSON AND HIS STAFF. UH, AT
SOME LENGTH, UH, IN THE SPIRIT
OF FULL DISCLOSURE AND
TRANSPARENCY. THIS IDEA IS
SOMETHING WE HAVE PONDERED IN
THE PAST. UH, IT'S A LITTLE
COMPLICATED AS THE OPPOSITION
HAS NOTED, UH, THE SIMPLE FACT
IS R VÆ S¼ ARE DIFFERENT THAN
CARS. THEY'RE ESSENTIALLY A
HOUSE ON WHEELS, AND THEY'RE
FULL OF CONSUMER PRODUCTS AND
REFRIGERATORS AND MICROWAVE. AND
TELEVISIONS AND ALL SORTS OF
THINGS. UH, THERE ARE
DIFFERENCES, SOME POINTED OUT IN
THE ANALYSIS SOME NOT, UH, BUT
IT ISN'T AS SIMPLE AS PULLING A
PART OFF OF THE SHELF AS IT IS
WITH A CAR. IT ISN'T A STARTER.
YOU KNOW, YOU MAY HAVE TO
FABRICATE A CABINET, YOU MAY
HAVE TO DO AAA COUNTERTOP AND IT
MAY TAKE SOME TIME. SO R VÆ S¼
ARE DIFFERENT. AND WE HAVE
EXPLORED WITH MR GRACE AND SOME
RECOGNITION OF THAT WERE
DISCUSSION. WE'RE IN DISCUSSION
WITH STAKEHOLDERS ON IT, AND WE
THINK WE MAY WELL GET TO A POINT
WHERE IT WORKS FOR EVERYONE. BUT
FOR US, THE NUMBER ONE PRIORITY
IS HAVING HAPPY CUSTOMERS. WE
SELL THEM ANOTHER UNIT AFTER
THIS ONE, AND, UH, IT'S A IT'S
AN IMPORTANT PART OF COMMERCE.
IT'S AN IMPORTANT PART OF
RECREATION, AND WE WANT TO MAKE
IT WORK. SO WE PLEDGE TO DO
THAT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. I'M
NANCY. EXCUSE ME. NANCY
PEPPERONI WITH THE CONSUMER
ATTORNEYS OF CALIFORNIA.
SIMILARLY WE LOOK FORWARD TO
WORKING WITH THE AUTHOR. WE UM,
HAVE REVIEWED THE BILL. WE
APPRECIATE THE INTENT. WE'D LIKE
TO CONTINUE WORKING ON LANGUAGE.
THANK YOU. HØI SEE NÓ FURTHER
COMMENTS, QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS
FROM THE DÍAS. MOTION AND A
SECOND VERY MUCH LIKE TO THANK
YOU, MADAM CHAIR. I'M SO HONORED
TO HAVE THE MOST PLEASANT
OPPOSITION. SHOW UP TODAY. I DO
WANT TO JUST STIPULATE AGAIN.
PURCHASERS OF TRAVEL TRAILERS
AND FIFTH WHEEL UH, OWNERS ARE
COVERED IN A BROADER CONSUMER
PROTECTION COVERED UNDER THE
SONG BEVERLY ACT, BUT THEY ARE
NOT AFFORDED THE ABILITY TO
ELECT THEIR OWN REMEDY, WHICH
ARE COVERED UNDER THE TANNER
CONSUMER ACT. I DO UNDERSTAND
THE DIFFERENCES AND THAT'S WHY I
AM FULLY COMMITTED TO WORKING
WITH STAKEHOLDERS TO MAKE SURE
WE GET THE LANGUAGE RIGHT. I
DON'T WANT TO UNDERMINE CONSUMER
PROTECTIONS. I ONLY WANT TO MAKE
THEM BETTER AND WORKING WITH
GROUP OF OPPOSITION TO DO THAT.
SO HAVING SAID THAT, I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR I VOTE AND
YOU'RE ACCEPTING COMMITTEE
AMENDMENTS TODAY. I AM PERFECT.
THANK YOU. AND I, YOU KNOW, THE
OPPOSITION LETTER CAME IN LATE
YESTERDAY. BUT UM SOME OF WHAT
WAS IN IT, FOR EXAMPLE, THAT THE
ODOMETER IS AN IMPORTANT PIECE
OF THE TEST AND 11, NOT OTHER
THINGS. I KNOW YOU CAN WORK TO
ADDRESS THROUGH THE PROCESS, AND
I TRUST HAVING HAD CONVERSATIONS
WITH YOU ABOUT YOUR INTENT ON
THIS BILL THAT YOUR INTENT IS TO
PROTECT CONSUMERS, AND THAT'S
WHY I'M HAPPY TO SUPPORT IT
TODAY. UM, I ALSO THOUGHT THE
LETTER WENT A LITTLE FAR IN
SAYING THAT IT BY AMENDING THIS
ONE PIECE OF THE LAW. WE WERE
COMMENTING ON OTHER PIECES OF
THE LAW. I DON'T THINK THAT IS
AN ACCURATE STATEMENT. SO WITH
THAT, UM, LET'S CALL THE ROLL.
OK? ITEM NUMBER ONE A B 1849 BY
ASSEMBLY MEMBER GRAYSON. THE
MOTION IS DUE PASS AS AMENDED BY
A BAR HIM A. PATTERSON PATTERSON
IY. BRIAN, BRIAN, I, DIXON.
HOOVER. IRWIN. LOWENTHAL
LOWENTHAL. I ORTEGA TAKE AN EYE
WORD. B I WIX WIX I WILSON
WILSON. I. THAT BILL HAS EIGHT
VOTES. IT IS OUT, BUT WE'LL
LEAVE THE OPEN FOR ABSA MEMBERS.
THANK YOU, MISS PIN, YOU ARE UP.
OK? THIS IS A B 2037. GOOD
AFTERNOON, MADAM CHAIR AND
COMMITTEE MEMBERS. I DELIGHTED
TO BE HERE AND NOT BE PRESENTING
ANYTHING TO DO WITH A I IT
SHOULD BE PROBABLY THE BULK OF
YOUR TERM. UM AND FIRST OFF. I
DO WANT TO THANK THE COMMITTEE
AND WE WILL ACCEPT THE COMMITTEE
AMENDMENTS. JUST SO YOU KNOW, A
B 2037 WILL GIVE COUNTY SEALER
THE AUTHORITY TO TEST AND VERIFY
MUNICIPALLY OWNED EV CHARGERS.
COUNTY SEALER ARE TASKED WITH
TESTING AND VERIFYING COMMERCIAL
MEASUREMENT DEVICES SUCH AS
GROCERY STORE SCALES, YOUR GAS
STATION PUMP ALL ALL OF THOSE
GOOD THINGS. UM THEIR JOB IS TO
MAKE SURE YOU GET WHAT YOU PAY
FOR. GENERALLY THE COUNTY
SEALER'S JURISDICTION COVERS
PRIVATELY OWNED EQUIPMENT.
HOWEVER THERE IS CURRENTLY NÓ
ENTITY IN CHARGE OF PUBLICLY
OWNED EV CHARGERS TO ENSURE
COMPETENCE AND PARTIALITY AND
CONSUMER PROTECTION. IT IS
IMPERATIVE THAT COUNTY SEALER
HAVE CLEAR AUTHORITY TO TEST AND
VERIFY PUBLICLY OWNED EV
CHARGERS WITH INFLATION AND
GROWING. DISPARITY PEOPLE ARE
EXPERIENCING HARD TIMES WHEN
EVERY DOLLAR COUNTS. IT'S
CRITICAL THAT YOU GET WHAT YOU
PAY FOR WITH ME HERE TO TESTIFY
ON BEHALF OF THE BILL IS MAD
SILVER ON BEHALF OF THE COUNTY
SEALER. TAKE IT AWAY, MATT.
THANK YOU. GOOD AFTERNOON, MADAM
CHAIR MEMBERS. MATTHEW CLING ON
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
AGRICULTURAL COMMISSIONERS AND
SEERS ASSOCIATION. UH, THANK YOU
FOR PRESENTING MOST OF MY
TESTIMONY. I APPRECIATE THAT. I
WON. I WON'T TELL YOU, UH, WHAT
THE COUNTY SEALER DO IN THE
COUNTY THAT IT'S PRETTY CLEAR.
THEY'RE THERE TO MAKE SURE THAT
YOU GET YOU GET WHAT YOU PAY
FOR. THEY TEST EVERY PUMP METER.
UH SUB SUB METER EVERYTHING THAT
THAT MEASURES ANYTHING THAT'S
BEING SOLD TO YOU AND MAKE SURE
THAT THAT THAT, UH, MEASUREMENT
IS ACCURATE AND YOU'RE GETTING
WHAT YOU PAY FOR AGAIN. UM,
HOWEVER, THERE WAS A 1977
PREDATING ME ATTORNEY GENERAL
OPINION THAT OPINE THAT FOR THE
PURPOSES OF DIVISION FIVE OF THE
B AND P CODE, A PERSON DOES NOT
INCLUDE A MUNICIPALITY. UH,
STATE OR LOCAL GOVERNMENT. UH,
SO WHAT WE'RE TRYING TO DO
THROUGH THIS BILL BASED ON THE
PROLIFERATION OF E VÆ CHARGERS,
WHICH ARE NOW SORT OF A NEW
BUSINESS MODEL BEING ADOPTED BY
CITIES. TO MAKE SURE THAT ANY
WEIGHING AND MEASURING DEVICE
REGARDLESS OF WHETHER IT'S
PRIVATELY OWNED OR PUBLICLY
OWNED, IS UNDER THE JURISDICTION
OF THE COUNTY SEWER AND AGAIN WE
CAN GO IN THERE AND TEST THOSE
AND MAKE SURE THAT THEY'RE
ACCURATE AND CONSUMERS ARE
GETTING WHAT THEY PAY FOR. SO WE
RESPECTFULLY URGE YOUR I VOTE.
THANK YOU. THANK YOU ANYONE ELSE
IN SUPPORT? GOOD AFTERNOON,
MADAM. GOOD AFTERNOON. MADAM
CHAIR MEMBERS, ELIZABETH
ESPINOSA HERE TODAY ON BEHALF OF
THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS IN THE
COUNTY OF SANTA CLARA IN
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
HØI MEMBERS. MY NAME IS MEGAN
MACKEL BURG. AND I'M HERE ON
BEHALF OF THE E VÆ CHARGING
ASSOCIATION. UM, WE DON'T HAVE
AN OFFICIAL POSITION YET, BUT
REALLY WANT TO THANK THE AUTHOR
FOR HER WORK, UM, AND TAKING THE
COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS AND LOOKING
FORWARD TO CONTINUING
CONVERSATIONS. THANK YOU. ANYONE
HERE IN OPPOSITION TO THE BILL?
THAT MOTION A SECOND. OK, SEE
OPPOSITION. ANY MEMBERS HAVE
QUESTIONS? YEAH. GO AHEAD. UM
FIRST OF ALL TWO QUESTIONS. HOW
WOULD A I HELP WITH THIS
PROCESS? JUST KIDDING. IT'S MY
FAVORITE. ONLY IF YOU'RE ON THIS
COMMITTEE. YOU PROBABLY HAD ONE
TOO MANY OF THOSE MEETINGS. SO,
UM, BUT I JUST WANNA SAY I I'M
IN SUPPORT OF APPLYING THE SAME
UH, RULES AND RESTRICTIONS TO
GOVERNMENT AGENCIES AS WE DO THE
PRIVATE SECTOR. SO, UH, HAPPY TO
SUPPORT THIS BILL TODAY. THANK
YOU. THANK YOU ANY OTHER
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS? SEEING
NONE. FIRST TIME I LEARNED WHAT
YOU DID. I FOUND IT TO BE ONE OF
THE MOST FASCINATING CONSUMER
PROTECTIONS OUT THERE. SO I
APPRECIATE THE WORK YOU DO AND
EXPANDING IT OUT. AND WOULD YOU
LIKE TO CLOSE? I JUST
RESPECTFULLY QUESTION I VOTE.
THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR THE
MOTION IN SECONDS. LET'S CALL
THE ROLL. ITEM NUMBER THREE A B
2037 BY SOME MEMBER PIN. THE
MOTION IS DUE PASS AS AMENDED TO
THE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE BY
KHAN KHAN. I. PATTERSON
PATTERSON. I AM BRIAN. BRIAN I.
DIXON. HOOVER. IRWIN LOWENTHAL.
LOWENTHAL, I ORTEGA OR TAKE A
EYE WARD WARD. I WIX WIX. I
WILSON WILSON. I AND BEFORE YOU
LEAVE ASSEMBLY MEMBER. IT'S MY
UNDERSTANDING THAT OUR COMMITTEE
MEMBER MR IRWIN WANTS TO BE
ADDED AS A PRINCIPAL CO AUTHOR.
SO I AGREE WITH YOU. THANK YOU
FOR REMINDING ME. YES OK, UM IF
SOME OF THEM ARE URBAN WILL BE
ADDED PERFECT. THANK YOU. THANK
YOU SO MUCH. AND THAT HAS EIGHT
VOTES. IT'S OUT, BUT WE WILL
LEAVE IT ALL OPEN FOR ABSENT
MEMBERS. WE'LL GO BACK TO CALL
THE ROLL. ON CONSENT AND OTHER
THINGS AND FOR MEMBERS WHO ARE
NOT HERE. YOU HAVE MINUTES TO
GET HERE TO ADD ON WE WILL LEAVE
IT OPEN. YEAH.
THEY'RE ON THE ON THE CONSENT
CALENDAR. DIXON HOOVER. IRWIN
LOWENTHAL. LOWENTHAL. AYE, THANK
YOU. I. HEY. RIGHT? I.
ITALIAN RIGHT?
WE WILL CALL THE ROLL FOR THE
ABSENT MEMBERS WHO ARE NOW HERE.
WELCOME. I REMEMBER ONE OF THE
CONS ON THE CONSENT CALENDAR.
DIXON DIXON, I HOOVER HOOVER. I
IRWIN ITEM NUMBER TWO A B 1849
BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER GRAYSON. THE
MOTION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED.
THE VOTE NOW IS 80. DIXON DIXON.
I HOOVER HOOVER. I LET'S SEE. 10
0. UM ITEM NUMBER THREE A B 2037
BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER PIN. THE
MOTION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED TO
THE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE.
THE VOTE NOW IS 80. DIXON DIXON,
I HOOVER HOOVER. I THANK YOU.
VERY GOOD. THANK YOU. THIS
HEARING WILL BE ADJOURNED.