﻿WEBVTT

00:30:46.077 --> 00:30:46.911
THANKS FOR BEING

00:30:46.978 --> 00:30:49.113
HERE. WE'RE GOING TO CALL TO

00:30:49.180 --> 00:30:50.548
ORDER OUR SELECT COMMITTEE FOR

00:30:50.615 --> 00:30:52.317
CLIMATE INNOVATION AND

00:30:52.383 --> 00:30:53.418
INFRASTRUCTURE. WE'VE GOT A

00:30:53.484 --> 00:30:56.054
REALLY GREAT PANEL TODAY REALLY

00:30:56.120 --> 00:30:57.055
TALKING ABOUT SOME OF THE

00:30:57.121 --> 00:30:58.823
THINGS THAT ARE SPECIFIC TO

00:30:58.890 --> 00:31:02.093
SONOMA COUNTY AND ALSO

00:31:02.160 --> 00:31:03.494
PERVASIVE THROUGHOUT DIFFERENT

00:31:03.561 --> 00:31:04.963
INDUSTRIES AS WE LOOK FOR

00:31:05.029 --> 00:31:06.864
CLIMATE SOLUTIONS. OUR FIRST

00:31:06.931 --> 00:31:08.933
PANEL IS ON REDUCTION, CAPTURE,

00:31:09.000 --> 00:31:11.069
AND REUSE OF METHANE, METHANE

00:31:11.135 --> 00:31:12.870
FROM DAIRY AND LIVESTOCK

00:31:12.937 --> 00:31:14.105
OPERATIONS. WE'VE GOT SOME

00:31:14.172 --> 00:31:15.506
GREAT SPEAKERS WITH US. WE GOT

00:31:15.573 --> 00:31:17.909
DOUG BERETTA. BERETTA FAMILY

00:31:17.976 --> 00:31:19.377
DAIRY. WE'VE GOT RENATA

00:31:19.444 --> 00:31:20.445
BERLINGER, WHO'S THE EXECUTIVE

00:31:20.511 --> 00:31:21.879
DIRECTOR FOR CAL CAN, AND

00:31:21.946 --> 00:31:23.648
JOSEPH BUTTON, WHO'S THE VICE

00:31:23.715 --> 00:31:25.183
PRESIDENT OF SUSTAINABILITY AND

00:31:25.250 --> 00:31:26.551
STRATEGIC IMPACT FOR STRAUSS

00:31:26.618 --> 00:31:28.686
FAMILY. AND THANK YOU ALL FOR

00:31:28.753 --> 00:31:30.622
BEING HERE. FIRST OF ALL, ON A

00:31:30.688 --> 00:31:31.723
ON A THURSDAY MORNING, WE'RE

00:31:31.789 --> 00:31:33.658
GOING TO GO AND KICK IT OFF, I

00:31:33.725 --> 00:31:34.859
THINK. RENATA, I THINK YOU'RE

00:31:34.926 --> 00:31:36.628
STARTING US OFF. YEAH, GO FOR

00:31:36.694 --> 00:31:39.464
IT. THANKS FOR ORGANIZING THIS

00:31:39.530 --> 00:31:42.066
ASSEMBLY MEMBER AND AND LOGAN

00:31:42.133 --> 00:31:42.867
MEREDITH, TO THE EXTENT YOU HAD

00:31:42.934 --> 00:31:44.502
A ROLE IN IT, APPRECIATE BEING

00:31:44.569 --> 00:31:45.603
HERE. I ESPECIALLY APPRECIATE

00:31:45.670 --> 00:31:47.438
YOU BRINGING THESE TWO GUYS,

00:31:47.505 --> 00:31:49.207
THE ACTUAL PRODUCERS, BECAUSE

00:31:49.274 --> 00:31:51.743
IT'S REALLY IMPORTANT FOR THE

00:31:51.809 --> 00:31:53.211
THEORIES AND POLICIES AND

00:31:53.278 --> 00:31:54.946
FUNDING STREAMS TO WORK FOR

00:31:55.013 --> 00:31:56.447
PEOPLE ON THE GROUND. SO YOU'LL

00:31:56.514 --> 00:31:58.349
GET TO HEAR THEIR STORIES IN A

00:31:58.416 --> 00:32:00.418
MINUTE. SO AGAIN, MY NAME IS

00:32:00.485 --> 00:32:01.853
RENATA BERLINGER WITH THE

00:32:01.919 --> 00:32:02.553
CALIFORNIA CLIMATE AND

00:32:02.620 --> 00:32:04.389
AGRICULTURE NETWORK. OR CAL CAN

00:32:04.455 --> 00:32:05.757
WE'VE BEEN DOING POLICY WORK ON

00:32:05.823 --> 00:32:06.858
CLIMATE SOLUTIONS AND

00:32:06.924 --> 00:32:09.027
AGRICULTURE FOR 17 YEARS. AND

00:32:09.093 --> 00:32:10.428
WE'RE BIG CHAMPIONS OF, OF A

00:32:10.495 --> 00:32:11.663
PROGRAM I'M GOING TO TALK ABOUT

00:32:11.729 --> 00:32:13.698
IN A FEW MINUTES THAT

00:32:13.765 --> 00:32:14.432
INCENTIVIZES PRODUCERS TO

00:32:14.499 --> 00:32:15.867
REDUCE METHANE EMISSIONS ON

00:32:15.933 --> 00:32:20.571
THEIR ON THEIR DAIRY OPERATIONS.

00:32:20.638 --> 00:32:21.806
SO I'M JUST GOING TO START WITH

00:32:21.873 --> 00:32:23.908
A SHORT OVERVIEW OF HOW MANURE

00:32:23.975 --> 00:32:25.209
IS MANAGED. IT'S NOT A SUPER

00:32:25.276 --> 00:32:26.778
FAMILIAR TOPIC FOR MOST PEOPLE

00:32:26.844 --> 00:32:29.247
ANYMORE, BEING SO REMOVED FROM

00:32:29.314 --> 00:32:31.683
AGRICULTURE AND FARMS AS WE ARE.

00:32:31.749 --> 00:32:33.217
WHY THAT MATTERS FROM A CLIMATE

00:32:33.284 --> 00:32:34.986
AND ENVIRONMENTAL PERSPECTIVE

00:32:35.053 --> 00:32:36.888
AND WHAT THE GOALS, WHAT GOALS

00:32:36.954 --> 00:32:38.122
THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA HAS SET

00:32:38.189 --> 00:32:39.657
FOR REDUCING METHANE EMISSIONS.

00:32:39.724 --> 00:32:41.092
AND THEN I'LL TALK ABOUT SOME

00:32:41.159 --> 00:32:42.126
ALTERNATIVE APPROACHES AND

00:32:42.193 --> 00:32:43.628
PROGRAMS TO SUPPORT THAT. AND

00:32:43.695 --> 00:32:45.029
THEN A LITTLE BIT ON THE

00:32:45.096 --> 00:32:46.597
PROGRESS MADE TO DATE AND WHAT

00:32:46.664 --> 00:32:49.267
MORE IS NEEDED NEXT. OH, I GET

00:32:49.334 --> 00:32:50.768
TO I GET TO CHANGE THE SLIDES.

00:32:50.835 --> 00:32:53.104
GREAT. SO I DON'T ASSUME PEOPLE

00:32:53.171 --> 00:32:54.405
KNOW THAT MUCH ABOUT MANURE

00:32:54.472 --> 00:32:55.840
MANAGEMENT. I'M THRILLED THAT

00:32:55.907 --> 00:32:58.409
THIS IS IS A TOPIC AT AN

00:32:58.476 --> 00:33:01.612
INNOVATIONS AND INFRASTRUCTURE

00:33:01.679 --> 00:33:02.613
CONVERSATION, BECAUSE I DON'T

00:33:02.680 --> 00:33:03.715
THINK MOST PEOPLE THINK ABOUT

00:33:03.781 --> 00:33:04.882
MANURE MANAGEMENT AS A

00:33:04.949 --> 00:33:07.352
PARTICULARLY INNOVATIVE OR

00:33:07.418 --> 00:33:08.453
INFRASTRUCTURE ISSUE, BUT THESE

00:33:08.519 --> 00:33:09.554
GUYS CERTAINLY DO. THE WHOLE

00:33:09.620 --> 00:33:11.322
DAIRY INDUSTRY IS VERY MUCH

00:33:11.389 --> 00:33:14.559
CONCERNED ABOUT THAT. SO THIS

00:33:14.625 --> 00:33:15.893
PICTURE, THIS DIAGRAM HERE SORT

00:33:15.960 --> 00:33:17.428
OF DEPICTS, GENERALLY SPEAKING,

00:33:17.495 --> 00:33:20.998
HOW SORT OF THE CONVENTIONAL

00:33:21.065 --> 00:33:23.868
TYPICAL MULTI-DECADAL PROCESS

00:33:23.935 --> 00:33:25.737
HAS BEEN TO, TO DEAL WITH

00:33:25.803 --> 00:33:28.272
MANURE ON DAIRY FARMS

00:33:28.339 --> 00:33:29.374
ORIGINATES IN THE BARN OR IN

00:33:29.440 --> 00:33:31.509
THE, IN THE, IN THE CORRALS FOR

00:33:31.576 --> 00:33:32.910
THOSE WHO ARE PASTURE BASED,

00:33:32.977 --> 00:33:34.345
THE MANURE STAYS OUT ON THE

00:33:34.412 --> 00:33:35.880
PASTURE, WHERE IT'S MUCH LESS

00:33:35.947 --> 00:33:37.682
OF A PROBLEM IN LOTS OF WAYS.

00:33:37.749 --> 00:33:38.916
BUT WHEN IT GETS CONCENTRATED,

00:33:38.983 --> 00:33:40.551
IT HAS TO BE DEALT WITH AND IT

00:33:40.618 --> 00:33:42.420
GETS MOVED OUT OF THOSE BARNS,

00:33:42.487 --> 00:33:43.421
THOSE MILKING BARNS OR

00:33:43.488 --> 00:33:44.789
FREESTYLE BARNS INTO SOMETIMES

00:33:44.856 --> 00:33:46.290
A SLURRY TANK OR SOMETIMES

00:33:46.357 --> 00:33:48.092
DIRECTLY INTO A LAGOON. SO IT'S

00:33:48.159 --> 00:33:49.727
FLUSHED OUT WITH A LOT OF WATER

00:33:49.794 --> 00:33:51.629
AND THEN MOVED INTO THESE

00:33:51.696 --> 00:33:54.265
STORAGE FACILITIES WHERE, WHICH

00:33:54.332 --> 00:33:55.933
IS WHERE THE METHANE, THE

00:33:56.000 --> 00:33:57.402
MAJORITY OF THE METHANE GETS

00:33:57.468 --> 00:33:59.904
PRODUCED IN THESE ANAEROBIC

00:33:59.971 --> 00:34:01.739
LAGOONS. THE THE METHANE IS

00:34:01.806 --> 00:34:03.941
PRODUCED AS THE RESULT OF THE

00:34:04.008 --> 00:34:05.343
DECOMPOSITION OF THAT WASTE

00:34:05.410 --> 00:34:06.544
MATERIAL IN CONDITIONS THAT

00:34:06.611 --> 00:34:07.845
DON'T HAVE OXYGEN. IT'S JUST

00:34:07.912 --> 00:34:10.415
THE BACTERIA THAT DECOMPOSE THE

00:34:10.481 --> 00:34:12.150
MATERIAL ARE ONE OF THEIR

00:34:12.216 --> 00:34:12.917
BYPRODUCTS IS METHANE. AND

00:34:12.984 --> 00:34:14.652
THAT'S WHERE WE GET THE ISSUE.

00:34:14.719 --> 00:34:15.753
ANYTHING, ANY ORGANIC MATERIAL

00:34:15.820 --> 00:34:18.256
THAT DECOMPOSES ANAEROBICALLY

00:34:18.322 --> 00:34:20.057
CREATES METHANE. IT'S TRUE IN

00:34:20.124 --> 00:34:21.459
OUR LANDFILLS. IT'S TRUE IN

00:34:21.526 --> 00:34:22.727
EVEN IN COMPOST PILES, THERE'S

00:34:22.794 --> 00:34:24.228
A LITTLE BIT OF METHANE

00:34:24.295 --> 00:34:28.299
PRODUCED. SO ONCE IT GETS INTO

00:34:28.366 --> 00:34:30.168
THE LAGOON, THE CHOICES FOR THE

00:34:30.234 --> 00:34:31.402
FARMER ARE TO. SOMETIMES

00:34:31.469 --> 00:34:32.703
THEY'LL SEPARATE SOME OF THE

00:34:32.770 --> 00:34:34.138
SOLIDS AND. BUT OFTEN THEY'LL

00:34:34.205 --> 00:34:35.306
END UP SPREADING IT ON CROP

00:34:35.373 --> 00:34:37.008
FIELDS, YOU KNOW, HAY OR FORAGE

00:34:37.074 --> 00:34:38.743
FIELDS TO, TO DISTRIBUTE IT AND

00:34:38.810 --> 00:34:40.678
GET RID OF IT. THE SOLIDS, SOME

00:34:40.745 --> 00:34:42.447
OF THE SOLIDS COLLECT IN THE

00:34:42.513 --> 00:34:43.614
LAGOON. AND THEN THEY GET HAVE

00:34:43.681 --> 00:34:45.550
TO BE SORT OF DREDGED OUT AND,

00:34:45.616 --> 00:34:46.684
AND DEALT WITH. SO THAT'S THE

00:34:46.751 --> 00:34:51.923
TYPICAL APPROACH. THE AND THESE

00:34:51.989 --> 00:34:53.257
ARE JUST A COUPLE OF PICTURES

00:34:53.324 --> 00:34:54.358
THAT SORT OF SHOW WHAT THAT

00:34:54.425 --> 00:34:56.527
LOOKS LIKE ON FARMS. THE TOP

00:34:56.594 --> 00:34:58.262
LEFT CORNER IS THE FLUSHING

00:34:58.329 --> 00:34:59.664
PROCESS, THE LAGOON. THERE'S A

00:34:59.730 --> 00:35:01.265
LAGOON THERE ON THE TOP RIGHT,

00:35:01.332 --> 00:35:03.968
AND THEN THE SPREADING OF THE

00:35:04.035 --> 00:35:06.904
LIQUID LIQUID MANURE WITH

00:35:06.971 --> 00:35:09.373
VARIOUS FORMS OF DISTRIBUTION

00:35:09.440 --> 00:35:10.541
SYSTEMS, YOU CAN SOMETIMES SEE

00:35:10.608 --> 00:35:12.610
IT WITH, WITH THE LIKE THE BIG

00:35:12.677 --> 00:35:15.847
SPRAY, YOU KNOW, PIVOT KIND OF

00:35:15.913 --> 00:35:20.518
EQUIPMENT AS WELL. SO

00:35:20.585 --> 00:35:22.687
RECOGNIZING THIS ISSUE AND ITS

00:35:22.753 --> 00:35:25.122
CONTRIBUTIONS TO CLIMATE CHANGE,

00:35:25.189 --> 00:35:28.526
THE STATE IN 2016 PASSED A BILL

00:35:28.593 --> 00:35:31.362
CALLED SB 1383, WHERE THEY SET

00:35:31.429 --> 00:35:32.964
A TARGET FOR REDUCING EMISSIONS

00:35:33.030 --> 00:35:35.700
FROM DAIRY OPERATIONS OF 40%

00:35:35.766 --> 00:35:38.202
BELOW 2013 LEVELS BY THE YEAR

00:35:38.269 --> 00:35:39.604
2030. SO WE'RE COMING UP ON

00:35:39.670 --> 00:35:42.206
THAT TIME FRAME VERY QUICKLY.

00:35:42.273 --> 00:35:43.441
THE LATEST INVENTORY THAT THE

00:35:43.508 --> 00:35:46.277
AIR RESOURCES DID ON HOW WELL

00:35:46.344 --> 00:35:47.912
WE WERE DOING WAS IN 2024, AND

00:35:47.979 --> 00:35:49.847
THEY SHOWED THAT THE EMISSIONS

00:35:49.914 --> 00:35:52.316
HAD BEEN REDUCED TO ABOUT 13%

00:35:52.383 --> 00:35:54.785
BELOW 2030. SO THE TARGET IS

00:35:54.852 --> 00:35:56.854
40%. AND AS OF TWO YEARS AGO,

00:35:56.921 --> 00:35:58.856
WE WERE AT 13% OR ABOUT A THIRD

00:35:58.923 --> 00:36:00.057
OF THE WAY THERE. SO THERE'S

00:36:00.124 --> 00:36:05.530
SOME WORK TO DO. SO AT CAL, CAN

00:36:05.596 --> 00:36:08.833
WE RECOGNIZE THIS WAS AN

00:36:08.900 --> 00:36:09.901
IMPORTANT ISSUE TO ADDRESS, AND

00:36:09.967 --> 00:36:10.902
THAT FARMERS WOULD NEED

00:36:10.968 --> 00:36:12.036
INCENTIVES AND FINANCIAL

00:36:12.103 --> 00:36:13.437
SUPPORT TO ADDRESS IT. IT'S

00:36:13.504 --> 00:36:14.906
UNREASONABLE, WE WOULD SAY, TO

00:36:14.972 --> 00:36:17.041
ASK FARMERS TO PROVIDE

00:36:17.108 --> 00:36:19.277
COMMUNITY BENEFITS AT AT THEIR

00:36:19.343 --> 00:36:21.846
OWN COST, ESPECIALLY BEFORE THE

00:36:21.913 --> 00:36:23.180
THAT BECOMES THE NEW BUSINESS

00:36:23.247 --> 00:36:24.215
AS USUAL BEFORE THERE'S

00:36:24.282 --> 00:36:26.083
EQUIPMENT THAT'S AFFORDABLE AND

00:36:26.150 --> 00:36:27.852
TECHNOLOGY AND KNOWLEDGE THAT'S

00:36:27.919 --> 00:36:29.654
THAT'S AFFORDABLE. SO WE WORK

00:36:29.720 --> 00:36:31.455
PRETTY HARD TO GET IN PLACE. A

00:36:31.522 --> 00:36:32.523
STATE PROGRAM CALLED THE

00:36:32.590 --> 00:36:34.358
ALTERNATIVE MANURE MANAGEMENT

00:36:34.425 --> 00:36:37.228
PROGRAM, OR AMP FOR SHORT. THAT

00:36:37.295 --> 00:36:41.232
PROGRAM WAS ESTABLISHED IN 2017.

00:36:41.299 --> 00:36:42.633
SO JUST A YEAR AFTER THE. THE

00:36:42.700 --> 00:36:44.201
BILL PASSED WITH THE SETTING

00:36:44.268 --> 00:36:46.871
THE GOALS. SO EVER SINCE THEN,

00:36:46.938 --> 00:36:47.972
THERE HAVE BEEN GRANTS GOING

00:36:48.039 --> 00:36:50.207
OUT TO FARMERS TO, TO CHANGE

00:36:50.274 --> 00:36:51.676
THE APPROACH. AND HERE ARE SOME

00:36:51.742 --> 00:36:53.311
PICTURES ABOUT SOME OF THE WAYS

00:36:53.377 --> 00:36:54.579
THAT THAT CAN HAPPEN. IT'S ONE

00:36:54.645 --> 00:36:56.314
OF THE THINGS THAT'S GOOD ABOUT

00:36:56.380 --> 00:36:57.381
THIS PROGRAM IS IT'S VERY

00:36:57.448 --> 00:36:58.482
ADAPTABLE FARM TO FARM. IT

00:36:58.549 --> 00:37:00.985
DOESN'T IMPOSE A SINGLE

00:37:01.052 --> 00:37:02.420
TECHNOLOGY. IT REALLY THERE'S

00:37:02.486 --> 00:37:04.155
LOTS OF OPTIONS. THE MAIN GOAL

00:37:04.221 --> 00:37:05.389
IS TO SEPARATE THE SOLIDS FROM

00:37:05.456 --> 00:37:07.925
THE LIQUIDS AND COMPOST OR AGE

00:37:07.992 --> 00:37:09.760
AND DRY OUT THOSE THOSE SOLIDS

00:37:09.827 --> 00:37:12.496
AND THEN RECYCLE THE WATER, THE

00:37:12.563 --> 00:37:14.131
LIQUIDS. SO THESE ARE JUST A

00:37:14.198 --> 00:37:16.400
FEW EXAMPLES. AND DOUG, WHEN HE

00:37:16.467 --> 00:37:17.468
GETS TO SPEAK, HE'LL. AND

00:37:17.535 --> 00:37:18.536
ACTUALLY, JOSEPH Tê, I THINK

00:37:18.603 --> 00:37:19.704
BOTH HAVE PICTURES OF THEIR

00:37:19.770 --> 00:37:20.771
SYSTEMS AND THEY'RE. THEY'RE

00:37:20.838 --> 00:37:21.739
ALL DIFFERENT ON EVERY

00:37:21.806 --> 00:37:23.708
DIFFERENT FARM. THE TOP LEFT,

00:37:23.774 --> 00:37:25.810
SORRY. THE IMAGE ON THE LEFT IS

00:37:25.876 --> 00:37:28.379
A, A MECHANICAL SEPARATOR. IT'S

00:37:28.446 --> 00:37:29.547
JUST YOU CAN'T REALLY SEE. BUT

00:37:29.614 --> 00:37:30.848
THERE'S A BIG SCREEN THAT'S

00:37:30.915 --> 00:37:32.717
VERTICAL THERE. AND IT, IT JUST

00:37:32.783 --> 00:37:35.620
SORT OF JUST GRAVITY. IT JUST

00:37:35.686 --> 00:37:37.321
JUST SORT OF SEPARATES THE

00:37:37.388 --> 00:37:38.889
WATER. THE SLURRY COMES DOWN

00:37:38.956 --> 00:37:40.725
THAT SCREEN AND THE SOLIDS FALL

00:37:40.791 --> 00:37:42.593
OUT TO THE BOTTOM AND THE WATER

00:37:42.660 --> 00:37:45.262
IS DIVERTED. IN THE MIDDLE IS

00:37:45.329 --> 00:37:46.464
SOMETHING CALLED A WEEPING WALL.

00:37:46.530 --> 00:37:47.598
IT'S A LITTLE HARD TO TELL

00:37:47.665 --> 00:37:49.367
WHAT'S GOING ON THERE, BUT

00:37:49.433 --> 00:37:50.468
BASICALLY THE MANURE GETS PILED

00:37:50.534 --> 00:37:53.904
INTO THESE BIG CONCRETE, YOU

00:37:53.971 --> 00:37:56.440
KNOW, CONTAINERS. AND IT'S JUST

00:37:56.507 --> 00:37:57.908
GRAVITY THAT LETS THE WATER

00:37:57.975 --> 00:37:59.143
JUST KIND OF SETTLES OUT THE

00:37:59.210 --> 00:38:00.745
BOTTOM AND THEN RUNS OUT

00:38:00.811 --> 00:38:02.480
THROUGH. IT'S ON A SLOPE AND IT

00:38:02.546 --> 00:38:03.681
RUNS OUT THROUGH THE BOTTOM AND

00:38:03.748 --> 00:38:05.483
IS IS COLLECTED. AND THEN THOSE

00:38:05.549 --> 00:38:06.984
SOLIDS HAVE TO BE REMOVED WHEN

00:38:07.051 --> 00:38:09.453
THEY'RE FULL AND COMPOSTED IN

00:38:09.520 --> 00:38:10.388
WHAT'S CALLED WINDROWS, WHICH

00:38:10.454 --> 00:38:12.223
YOU CAN SEE A PICTURE OF IN THE

00:38:12.289 --> 00:38:15.893
BOTTOM BELOW THAT. SO WEEPING

00:38:15.960 --> 00:38:17.328
WALL, SUPER SIMPLE, NO MOVING

00:38:17.395 --> 00:38:19.130
PARTS, JUST THIS BIG, BIG BOX

00:38:19.196 --> 00:38:21.298
WITH GREAT AGREED AT THE END.

00:38:21.365 --> 00:38:23.134
AND THEN HERE ON THE RIGHT IS

00:38:23.200 --> 00:38:24.902
SOMETHING CALLED A COMPOST PACK

00:38:24.969 --> 00:38:27.672
BARN. AND THAT IS A TECHNOLOGY.

00:38:27.738 --> 00:38:28.506
IT'S NOT EVEN A TECHNOLOGY

00:38:28.572 --> 00:38:29.874
REALLY. THEY JUST PUT A LOT OF

00:38:29.940 --> 00:38:31.008
BEDDING INSIDE THE BARN WHERE

00:38:31.075 --> 00:38:33.477
THE ANIMALS ARE AND THEY THEIR

00:38:33.544 --> 00:38:34.945
WASTE AND THE, AND THE BEDDING

00:38:35.012 --> 00:38:36.747
MATERIAL IS, IS AERATED

00:38:36.814 --> 00:38:37.748
REGULARLY. THAT'S WHAT THIS

00:38:37.815 --> 00:38:39.350
FARMER IS DOING. HE'S HE'S HERE

00:38:39.417 --> 00:38:41.419
IN SONOMA COUNTY. HE'S JUST

00:38:41.485 --> 00:38:44.288
AERATING THAT THAT BEDDING VERY

00:38:44.355 --> 00:38:45.356
REGULARLY SO THAT IT DOESN'T

00:38:45.423 --> 00:38:46.624
HAVE THOSE ANAEROBIC CONDITIONS

00:38:46.691 --> 00:38:48.959
AND IT TURNS INTO THIS AMAZING

00:38:49.026 --> 00:38:50.428
COMPOST AND CAN BE THEN REMOVED

00:38:50.494 --> 00:38:52.196
AND USED ELSEWHERE. DOUG WILL

00:38:52.263 --> 00:38:53.864
TELL YOU ABOUT A SYSTEM THAT

00:38:53.931 --> 00:38:54.999
SCRAPES THE MANURE OUT OF THE

00:38:55.066 --> 00:38:56.534
STALLS, AND THEN SEPARATES THE

00:38:56.600 --> 00:38:58.369
SOLIDS WITH A SORT OF AUGER. SO

00:38:58.436 --> 00:38:59.937
IT'S REALLY SIMPLE TECHNOLOGY.

00:39:00.004 --> 00:39:01.172
IT'S NOT DIFFICULT, BUT IT

00:39:01.238 --> 00:39:05.910
ISN'T CHEAP. ANOTHER TECHNIQUE

00:39:05.976 --> 00:39:07.344
THAT'S IMPORTANT FOR METHANE

00:39:07.411 --> 00:39:08.813
REDUCTION IS JUST PUTTING

00:39:08.879 --> 00:39:10.314
KEEPING COWS ON PASTURE MORE OF

00:39:10.381 --> 00:39:11.816
THE TIME BECAUSE THAT MANURE

00:39:11.882 --> 00:39:13.451
THEN GETS DISTRIBUTED. IT'S NOT

00:39:13.517 --> 00:39:14.919
ANAEROBIC. IT'S IT'S OUT ON THE,

00:39:14.985 --> 00:39:18.155
YOU KNOW, ON THE, THE PASTURES

00:39:18.222 --> 00:39:19.356
AND IT JUST GETS INTEGRATED

00:39:19.423 --> 00:39:20.391
RIGHT INTO THE SOIL AND CAN

00:39:20.458 --> 00:39:24.595
HELP IMPROVE SOIL QUALITY. SO

00:39:24.662 --> 00:39:27.498
IN TERMS OF THIS PROGRAM THAT I

00:39:27.565 --> 00:39:30.401
SPOKE ABOUT, AMP, IT OFFERS

00:39:30.468 --> 00:39:32.236
INCENTIVES TO FARMERS UP TO

00:39:32.303 --> 00:39:33.270
THREE QUARTERS OF $1 MILLION

00:39:33.337 --> 00:39:36.140
PER FACILITY, WITH THE GOAL OF

00:39:36.207 --> 00:39:37.975
REDUCING THOSE EMISSIONS. AND

00:39:38.042 --> 00:39:40.111
TO DATE, IN THE LAST IT'S BEEN

00:39:40.177 --> 00:39:41.245
NINE YEARS NOW, I GUESS THERE

00:39:41.312 --> 00:39:43.013
HAVE BEEN ABOUT 200 PROJECTS

00:39:43.080 --> 00:39:44.515
THAT HAVE BEEN FUNDED TO THE

00:39:44.582 --> 00:39:49.820
TUNE OF $127 MILLION AND 1.65

00:39:49.887 --> 00:39:52.323
METRIC TONS OF CO2 EMISSIONS

00:39:52.389 --> 00:39:54.892
REDUCED. IT'S BEEN AN

00:39:54.959 --> 00:39:56.627
INCREDIBLY IMPORTANT PROJECT

00:39:56.694 --> 00:39:58.863
FOR PRODUCERS FOR LOTS OF

00:39:58.929 --> 00:39:59.964
REASONS. I'M GOING TO TALK A

00:40:00.030 --> 00:40:01.031
LITTLE BIT ABOUT THE

00:40:01.098 --> 00:40:04.168
CO-BENEFITS IN A SECOND. WE

00:40:04.235 --> 00:40:06.003
JUST I'LL GET TO THIS IN A

00:40:06.070 --> 00:40:07.204
MINUTE, BUT WE ACTUALLY THINK

00:40:07.271 --> 00:40:09.640
THAT THE REDUCTIONS ARE LARGER

00:40:09.707 --> 00:40:11.075
THAN WHAT HAS BEEN REPORTED.

00:40:11.142 --> 00:40:12.610
AND JUST BECAUSE OF THE WAY THE

00:40:12.676 --> 00:40:14.311
AIR RESOURCES BOARD HAS

00:40:14.378 --> 00:40:15.746
CALCULATED THEM. AND WE DID AN

00:40:15.813 --> 00:40:18.983
ANALYSIS. I'LL TALK ABOUT THAT,

00:40:19.049 --> 00:40:21.285
ADDRESSED THAT, AND AND CAME TO

00:40:21.352 --> 00:40:22.386
THE CONCLUSION THAT THERE'S A

00:40:22.453 --> 00:40:24.755
LOT MORE POTENCY HERE THAN IS

00:40:24.822 --> 00:40:27.725
BEING GIVEN CREDIT FOR. SO IN

00:40:27.792 --> 00:40:29.026
TERMS OF THE CO-BENEFITS, THIS

00:40:29.093 --> 00:40:30.594
IS ONE OF THE THINGS I THINK WE

00:40:30.661 --> 00:40:32.263
FEEL MOST STRONGLY ABOUT, ABOUT

00:40:32.329 --> 00:40:33.497
WHY THIS PROGRAM IS SO VALUABLE.

00:40:33.564 --> 00:40:35.332
IT'S ONE OF THE REASONS THIS IS

00:40:35.399 --> 00:40:36.600
ONE OF MY FAVORITE PROGRAMS

00:40:36.667 --> 00:40:38.602
THAT THE STATE RUNS. IT'S SORT

00:40:38.669 --> 00:40:40.938
OF TURNING THIS MANURE, THIS

00:40:41.005 --> 00:40:42.873
WASTE PROBLEM INTO THESE. A LOT

00:40:42.940 --> 00:40:45.643
OF OTHER POWERFUL BENEFITS FOR,

00:40:45.709 --> 00:40:48.479
FOR THE COMMUNITY AT LARGE. SO

00:40:48.546 --> 00:40:50.147
ONE OF THE BIG ONES, ESPECIALLY

00:40:50.214 --> 00:40:51.482
THIS IS TRUE IN THE CENTRAL

00:40:51.549 --> 00:40:54.218
VALLEY IS THE WATER QUALITY

00:40:54.285 --> 00:40:56.086
CHALLENGES. WHEN THAT MANURE,

00:40:56.153 --> 00:40:57.621
LIQUID MANURE IS SPREAD ONTO

00:40:57.688 --> 00:40:59.323
THE LANDSCAPE, ONTO HAY FIELDS

00:40:59.390 --> 00:41:03.627
OR SOME OTHER CROP FIELD, IT

00:41:03.694 --> 00:41:06.130
NOT ONLY DOES IT OFF GAS

00:41:06.197 --> 00:41:07.965
METHANE, BUT THERE ARE THERE'S

00:41:08.032 --> 00:41:09.733
LEACHING OF NITRATES INTO THE

00:41:09.800 --> 00:41:10.868
GROUNDWATER, AND NITRATE

00:41:10.935 --> 00:41:11.836
CONTAMINATION OF GROUNDWATER IS

00:41:11.902 --> 00:41:13.304
A VERY BIG PROBLEM IN THE

00:41:13.370 --> 00:41:16.006
VALLEY. IT CAN LEAD TO VARIOUS

00:41:16.073 --> 00:41:17.308
FORMS OF CANCER AND TO

00:41:17.374 --> 00:41:18.742
SOMETHING CALLED BLUE BABY

00:41:18.809 --> 00:41:20.177
SYNDROME. SO IT'S A VERY

00:41:20.244 --> 00:41:22.713
SERIOUS ISSUE. AND THE MORE

00:41:22.780 --> 00:41:24.081
SORT OF SATURATED THE SOILS ARE

00:41:24.148 --> 00:41:25.950
WITH THAT MANURE, THE WORSE THE

00:41:26.016 --> 00:41:27.017
PROBLEM IN THE IN THE

00:41:27.084 --> 00:41:29.153
GROUNDWATER TABLE, THE STATE

00:41:29.220 --> 00:41:30.154
WATER BOARD IS ACTUALLY RIGHT

00:41:30.221 --> 00:41:32.790
NOW LOOKING AT THE REGULATION

00:41:32.857 --> 00:41:34.592
ABOUT HOW TO DEAL WITH THAT AND

00:41:34.658 --> 00:41:36.427
UPDATING IT. AND THERE'S A VERY

00:41:36.493 --> 00:41:37.261
VIBRANT CONVERSATION IN THE

00:41:37.328 --> 00:41:39.263
DAIRY INDUSTRY ABOUT HOW ARE

00:41:39.330 --> 00:41:40.898
PRODUCERS GOING TO BE ABLE TO

00:41:40.965 --> 00:41:41.899
MEET THOSE NEW REGULATIONS.

00:41:41.966 --> 00:41:43.367
WHAT'S THE STRATEGY FOR HELPING

00:41:43.434 --> 00:41:44.702
THEM STAY IN BUSINESS AND

00:41:44.768 --> 00:41:46.604
REDUCE THAT POLLUTION? AND WE

00:41:46.670 --> 00:41:48.639
WOULD SAY THAT IT'S ONE OF THE

00:41:48.706 --> 00:41:50.307
MOST IMPORTANT REASONS THAT AMP

00:41:50.374 --> 00:41:51.575
SHOULD BE CONTINUALLY FUNDED IS

00:41:51.642 --> 00:41:52.943
TO HELP THEM DO THAT, BECAUSE

00:41:53.010 --> 00:41:55.145
THE NITRATE LEACHING IS MUCH

00:41:55.212 --> 00:41:57.681
REDUCED WITH THESE PROJECTS. SO

00:41:57.748 --> 00:41:59.416
IT'LL HELP WITH THE REGULATORY

00:41:59.483 --> 00:42:03.420
COMPLIANCE. IN TERMS OF WATER

00:42:03.487 --> 00:42:04.622
SAVINGS. OOPS. JUST A SECOND

00:42:04.688 --> 00:42:07.391
HERE. I MOVE TOO FAST. I

00:42:07.458 --> 00:42:09.460
MENTIONED THAT THE THE PRIMARY

00:42:09.526 --> 00:42:12.763
SORT OF DESIGN CRITERIA FOR THE

00:42:12.830 --> 00:42:13.831
PROJECTS IS TO SEPARATE THAT

00:42:13.898 --> 00:42:15.566
LIQUID STREAM FROM THE FROM THE

00:42:15.633 --> 00:42:17.835
SOLIDS. AND SO IN DOING SO, YOU

00:42:17.902 --> 00:42:20.304
END UP WITH A CLEANER WATER,

00:42:20.371 --> 00:42:22.573
YOU KNOW, LIQUID AT THE END,

00:42:22.640 --> 00:42:24.475
LESS SOLIDS IN IT. IT HAS ALL

00:42:24.541 --> 00:42:25.676
KINDS OF PRACTICAL VALUE FOR

00:42:25.743 --> 00:42:27.511
PRODUCERS. IT DOESN'T GUM UP

00:42:27.578 --> 00:42:30.381
ALL OF THEIR PIPES AND, AND

00:42:30.447 --> 00:42:32.316
NOZZLES AND SO ON. AND IT ALSO

00:42:32.383 --> 00:42:33.817
ALLOWS THEM TO THEN MORE

00:42:33.884 --> 00:42:34.818
EFFICIENTLY RECYCLE THAT WATER

00:42:34.885 --> 00:42:36.854
FOR MORE FLUSHING OR IRRIGATION.

00:42:36.921 --> 00:42:40.457
IN SOME CASES, I KEEP MOVING ON

00:42:40.524 --> 00:42:42.626
AND IT IMPROVES AIR AND WATER

00:42:42.693 --> 00:42:46.230
QUALITY. THE ANOTHER BYPRODUCT

00:42:46.297 --> 00:42:48.799
OF METHANE OF MANURE IS THAT

00:42:48.866 --> 00:42:51.969
OFF GASSING OF VARIOUS AIR

00:42:52.036 --> 00:42:54.905
POLLUTANTS AND AND ODORS FOR

00:42:54.972 --> 00:42:57.041
PEOPLE IN THE LOCAL COMMUNITY.

00:42:57.107 --> 00:42:59.343
THE. THE EXPERIENCE LIVING NEXT

00:42:59.410 --> 00:43:00.644
TO A DAIRY THAT COMPOSTS

00:43:00.711 --> 00:43:02.079
COMPARED TO ONE THAT HAS LIQUID

00:43:02.146 --> 00:43:04.949
MANURE IS IS VERY DISTINCT. I'M

00:43:05.015 --> 00:43:06.150
SORRY FOR THE FOLKS WHO AREN'T

00:43:06.216 --> 00:43:07.952
HERE, BECAUSE YOU WILL NOT HAVE

00:43:08.018 --> 00:43:09.119
THE OPPORTUNITY TO SEE THIS JAR

00:43:09.186 --> 00:43:11.422
OF LIQUID SLURRY THAT DOUG

00:43:11.488 --> 00:43:12.856
PROVIDED. WOULD YOU MIND TAKING

00:43:12.923 --> 00:43:15.359
THAT UP TO THE TO THE DAIS? I

00:43:15.426 --> 00:43:17.962
WOULD NOT RECOMMEND OPENING IT.

00:43:18.028 --> 00:43:19.096
AND IN CONTRAST HERE YOU CAN

00:43:19.163 --> 00:43:20.965
TAKE THIS ONE TO DOUG. IN

00:43:21.031 --> 00:43:22.232
CONTRAST, THIS IS A COMPOST

00:43:22.299 --> 00:43:23.634
PRODUCT WHICH YOU ARE WELCOME

00:43:23.701 --> 00:43:25.469
TO OPEN AND SMELL AND TOUCH.

00:43:25.536 --> 00:43:30.507
IT'S, IT'S A FAIRLY SHARP

00:43:30.574 --> 00:43:31.976
DIFFERENCE, JUST SORT OF

00:43:32.042 --> 00:43:34.078
VISCERALLY IN, IN THESE TWO

00:43:34.144 --> 00:43:39.183
PRODUCTS AND. THE, THE ODOR IS

00:43:39.249 --> 00:43:40.551
SOMETHING WE MIGHT BE ABLE TO

00:43:40.617 --> 00:43:41.752
LAUGH ABOUT OR, YOU KNOW, WE IN

00:43:41.819 --> 00:43:43.854
SEBASTOPOL, WE CALL IT THE

00:43:43.921 --> 00:43:48.192
SEBASTOPOL. THE THE SONOMA

00:43:48.258 --> 00:43:49.593
AROMA THERE. THANK YOU. SONOMA

00:43:49.660 --> 00:43:51.762
AROMA. YEAH, YEAH. SO WE HAVE A

00:43:51.829 --> 00:43:53.497
LITTLE BIT OF A SENSE OF WHAT

00:43:53.564 --> 00:43:54.665
THAT'S LIKE, BUT BECAUSE MOST

00:43:54.732 --> 00:43:56.400
OF OUR FOLKS PASTURE DAIRY HERE,

00:43:56.467 --> 00:43:58.202
IT'S NOT NEARLY AS PROFOUND AS,

00:43:58.268 --> 00:43:59.703
AS IN OTHER AREAS WHERE THEY

00:43:59.770 --> 00:44:00.771
DON'T HAVE THAT ACCESS TO

00:44:00.838 --> 00:44:02.740
PASTURE. SO IT'S NO, IT'S FUNNY,

00:44:02.806 --> 00:44:03.774
BUT IT'S ALSO NO JOKE,

00:44:03.841 --> 00:44:04.908
ESPECIALLY IF YOU'RE LIVING IN

00:44:04.975 --> 00:44:06.710
A COMMUNITY WHERE THAT'S A YEAR

00:44:06.777 --> 00:44:08.312
ROUND REALITY. AND THEN IN

00:44:08.379 --> 00:44:09.780
TERMS OF ANIMAL AND WORKER

00:44:09.847 --> 00:44:10.814
WELL-BEING, THIS IS ANOTHER

00:44:10.881 --> 00:44:12.249
CO-BENEFIT. THE ANIMALS

00:44:12.316 --> 00:44:14.051
THEMSELVES ARE HEALTHIER, NOT

00:44:14.118 --> 00:44:16.220
STANDING IN THAT SLURRY.

00:44:16.286 --> 00:44:18.055
THEY'RE STANDING IN DRIER

00:44:18.122 --> 00:44:19.556
CONDITIONS. THE WORKERS, IT'S

00:44:19.623 --> 00:44:22.359
LESS SLIPPERY SLIP HAZARD, IT'S

00:44:22.426 --> 00:44:24.528
LESS, YOU KNOW, LESS ODOROUS.

00:44:24.595 --> 00:44:25.963
THERE'S VARIOUS CO-BENEFITS FOR

00:44:26.030 --> 00:44:28.832
THE PEOPLE AND THE ANIMALS. AND

00:44:28.899 --> 00:44:30.634
THEN LASTLY, THE PRODUCTION OF

00:44:30.701 --> 00:44:32.736
COMPOST, ABOUT TWO THIRDS OF OF

00:44:32.803 --> 00:44:34.605
AMP RECIPIENTS, COMPOST OR

00:44:34.671 --> 00:44:36.540
MANURE AND USE IT FOR ALL KINDS

00:44:36.607 --> 00:44:38.442
OF PURPOSES, OFTEN BEDDING FOR

00:44:38.509 --> 00:44:40.711
THE ANIMALS, DRY ON SITE,

00:44:40.778 --> 00:44:41.445
PRODUCE BEDDING. THEY DON'T

00:44:41.512 --> 00:44:43.113
HAVE TO IMPORT IT. THEY DON'T

00:44:43.180 --> 00:44:44.281
HAVE TO USE THE, YOU KNOW,

00:44:44.348 --> 00:44:45.783
THERE'S NO TRANSPORTATION

00:44:45.849 --> 00:44:47.184
RELATED EMISSIONS COMING WHEN

00:44:47.251 --> 00:44:49.753
YOU TRUCK IN IMPORTS. SOME

00:44:49.820 --> 00:44:51.555
APPLY IT TO CROPLAND OR PASTURE

00:44:51.622 --> 00:44:54.725
LAND AS AN AMENDMENT, AND THAT

00:44:54.792 --> 00:44:57.628
CAN INCREASE THE VALUE OF THE

00:44:57.694 --> 00:45:00.531
SOIL QUALITY AND THE COMPOST

00:45:00.597 --> 00:45:02.666
HOLDING CAPACITY OF THOSE SOILS.

00:45:02.733 --> 00:45:04.535
AND SOME OF THEM SELL IT AS A

00:45:04.601 --> 00:45:07.704
AS A REVENUE STREAM. SO IN

00:45:07.771 --> 00:45:10.607
TERMS OF THE POPULARITY OF THIS

00:45:10.674 --> 00:45:12.142
PROGRAM, YOU CAN SEE FROM THIS

00:45:12.209 --> 00:45:13.844
JUST THREE YEAR SNAPSHOT OVER

00:45:13.911 --> 00:45:15.079
THE OVER THE TEN YEARS OF THE

00:45:15.145 --> 00:45:17.081
GRANT PROGRAM, THAT THERE IS A

00:45:17.147 --> 00:45:19.249
LOT OF DEMAND IN THE BEIGE BARS

00:45:19.316 --> 00:45:20.350
COMPARED TO HOW MUCH MONEY HAS

00:45:20.417 --> 00:45:22.119
BEEN AVAILABLE. AND THERE

00:45:22.186 --> 00:45:23.287
HASN'T BEEN MONEY PUT INTO THIS

00:45:23.353 --> 00:45:26.523
PROGRAM SINCE 2024. SO AT THIS

00:45:26.590 --> 00:45:27.958
POINT IN TIME, THERE'S NO

00:45:28.025 --> 00:45:29.693
OPTION FOR MORE PRODUCERS TO

00:45:29.760 --> 00:45:31.495
ADOPT THIS PRACTICE THROUGH THE

00:45:31.562 --> 00:45:35.065
WITH THE HELP OF THE STATE. SO

00:45:35.132 --> 00:45:36.200
OVER THE LIFETIME, THERE'S BEEN

00:45:36.266 --> 00:45:37.968
ABOUT 2 TO 3 TIMES MORE DEMAND

00:45:38.035 --> 00:45:40.504
THAN THERE HAS BEEN FUNDING IN

00:45:40.571 --> 00:45:41.472
THE LAST GRANT CYCLE. I JUST

00:45:41.538 --> 00:45:43.373
WANT TO MAKE A POINT OF THIS.

00:45:43.440 --> 00:45:45.876
THERE WAS $50 MILLION THAT WAS

00:45:45.943 --> 00:45:48.045
APPLIED FOR AND ONLY 21 MILLION

00:45:48.112 --> 00:45:50.547
AVAILABLE. SO THIS IS, WE WOULD

00:45:50.614 --> 00:45:52.382
SAY, A PROBLEM THAT NEEDS

00:45:52.449 --> 00:45:55.586
ADDRESSING. TO MAKE A FINER

00:45:55.652 --> 00:45:57.788
POINT ON THAT, I JUST I'LL JUST

00:45:57.855 --> 00:45:58.922
BRIEFLY TOUCH ON THIS REPORT.

00:45:58.989 --> 00:46:00.791
WE DID ALMOST A YEAR AGO NOW.

00:46:00.858 --> 00:46:02.025
WE LOOKED AT THE DATA FROM THE

00:46:02.092 --> 00:46:03.827
AIR RESOURCES BOARD. WE

00:46:03.894 --> 00:46:04.828
QUESTIONED SOME OF THE

00:46:04.895 --> 00:46:05.662
ASSUMPTIONS THEY'RE MAKING

00:46:05.729 --> 00:46:06.830
ABOUT HOW LONG THESE THESE

00:46:06.897 --> 00:46:08.232
PIECES OF EQUIPMENT LAST. THEY

00:46:08.298 --> 00:46:10.434
ASSUME FIVE YEARS ARE.

00:46:10.501 --> 00:46:11.435
ANECDOTALLY, WE'RE SEEING THAT

00:46:11.502 --> 00:46:12.436
THE EQUIPMENT'S LASTING MORE

00:46:12.503 --> 00:46:15.472
LIKE TEN YEARS. IF YOU WERE TO

00:46:15.539 --> 00:46:16.874
EXTEND THE RETURN ON INVESTMENT

00:46:16.940 --> 00:46:18.542
OVER A TEN YEAR PERIOD OF TIME,

00:46:18.609 --> 00:46:19.643
OBVIOUSLY YOU'LL GET A BETTER

00:46:19.710 --> 00:46:21.512
RETURN ON ON THAT INVESTMENT

00:46:21.578 --> 00:46:23.280
AND MORE REDUCTIONS IN

00:46:23.347 --> 00:46:26.183
EMISSIONS OVER THAT TIME. SO

00:46:26.250 --> 00:46:28.385
IT'S OUR ESTIMATION THAT

00:46:28.452 --> 00:46:29.620
ASSUMING A TEN YEAR LIFESPAN,

00:46:29.686 --> 00:46:30.854
THIS WOULD ACTUALLY BE AMONG

00:46:30.921 --> 00:46:32.322
THE MOST COST EFFECTIVE

00:46:32.389 --> 00:46:33.557
PROGRAMS OF ALL OF THE WAYS

00:46:33.624 --> 00:46:35.192
THAT CALIFORNIA INVESTS IN

00:46:35.259 --> 00:46:36.293
CLIMATE SOLUTIONS. THROUGH THE

00:46:36.360 --> 00:46:37.461
GREENHOUSE GAS REDUCTION FUND,

00:46:37.528 --> 00:46:39.163
THIS ONE RANKS NUMBER FOUR,

00:46:39.229 --> 00:46:40.931
ACCORDING TO OUR CALCULATIONS,

00:46:40.998 --> 00:46:42.299
EVEN WITHOUT OUR CALCULATIONS,

00:46:42.366 --> 00:46:44.067
IT'S STILL IN THE TOP TEN. SO

00:46:44.134 --> 00:46:47.070
IT'S INCREDIBLY COST EFFECTIVE.

00:46:47.137 --> 00:46:48.572
AND THAT'S PARTLY TO DO TO THE

00:46:48.639 --> 00:46:50.174
FACT THAT METHANE IS A VERY

00:46:50.240 --> 00:46:51.408
POTENT GREENHOUSE GAS. SO IT'S,

00:46:51.475 --> 00:46:53.310
YOU KNOW, IT'S EVERY, YOU KNOW,

00:46:53.377 --> 00:46:55.345
TON OF METHANE IS MUCH MORE

00:46:55.412 --> 00:46:56.580
REDUCING. EVERY TON OF METHANE

00:46:56.647 --> 00:46:58.182
IS MUCH MORE IMPACTFUL THAN

00:46:58.248 --> 00:47:03.987
THAN FOCUSING ON CARBON. WE

00:47:04.054 --> 00:47:09.426
ESTIMATE THAT. THAT A GIVEN

00:47:09.493 --> 00:47:11.328
PROJECT CAN REDUCE UP TO 90% OF

00:47:11.395 --> 00:47:13.730
THAT DAIRY'S METHANE THAT COMES

00:47:13.797 --> 00:47:16.200
FROM THE MANURE. THERE'S A

00:47:16.266 --> 00:47:17.634
RANGE ASSOCIATED WITH THAT. IT

00:47:17.701 --> 00:47:19.903
DEPENDS A LOT ON WHICH OF THOSE

00:47:19.970 --> 00:47:21.638
TECHNIQUES ARE USED. THEY VARY

00:47:21.705 --> 00:47:23.407
QUITE A BIT. SO WE DID A WE

00:47:23.473 --> 00:47:25.309
SORT OF BROKE DOWN. WE LOOKED

00:47:25.375 --> 00:47:26.376
AT EACH DIFFERENT KIND OF

00:47:26.443 --> 00:47:27.778
STRATEGY. AND AND THE RANGE IS

00:47:27.844 --> 00:47:30.414
ABOUT 25 TO 90%. SO IT'S A BIG

00:47:30.480 --> 00:47:32.349
IT'S A BIG RANGE. NOW, IF THE

00:47:32.416 --> 00:47:33.517
STATE WERE TO PRIORITIZE THE

00:47:33.584 --> 00:47:35.319
ONES THAT HAVE THE BIGGEST BANG

00:47:35.385 --> 00:47:37.221
FOR THE BUCK, WE WOULD SEE THAT

00:47:37.287 --> 00:47:38.555
AVERAGE COME UP QUITE A BIT IN

00:47:38.622 --> 00:47:39.790
THE MOST AMBITIOUS SCENARIO

00:47:39.856 --> 00:47:41.658
THAT WE LOOKED AT. IF WE ASSUME

00:47:41.725 --> 00:47:45.262
THAT CALIFORNIA DAIRY, 75% OF

00:47:45.329 --> 00:47:47.030
CALIFORNIA DAIRIES ADOPTED AMP

00:47:47.097 --> 00:47:48.532
PRACTICES, WE WOULD SEE

00:47:48.599 --> 00:47:51.034
REDUCTIONS OF UP TO. AS MUCH AS

00:47:51.101 --> 00:47:53.537
THIS IS THE HIGH END, GRANTED,

00:47:53.604 --> 00:47:55.372
4.5 MILLION METRIC TONS OF CO2

00:47:55.439 --> 00:47:56.807
EMISSIONS REDUCED PER YEAR,

00:47:56.873 --> 00:47:58.575
WHICH IS ABOUT ALMOST A MILLION

00:47:58.642 --> 00:48:00.210
CARS TAKEN OFF THE ROAD EVERY

00:48:00.277 --> 00:48:03.380
YEAR. AND THAT AMOUNT, AGAIN,

00:48:03.447 --> 00:48:05.415
THIS IS THE MOST AMBITIOUS, BUT

00:48:05.482 --> 00:48:07.684
THAT AMOUNT WOULD ALMOST CLOSE

00:48:07.751 --> 00:48:09.353
THE GAP THAT WE'RE SEEING IN

00:48:09.419 --> 00:48:12.990
THE STATES. SB 1383 TARGETS.

00:48:13.056 --> 00:48:14.458
IT'S MORE OR LESS THE SAME

00:48:14.524 --> 00:48:15.892
AMOUNT OF MONEY, SAME AMOUNT OF

00:48:15.959 --> 00:48:17.694
EMISSIONS REDUCTIONS. SO

00:48:17.761 --> 00:48:18.929
THERE'S A LOT OF IFS EMBEDDED

00:48:18.996 --> 00:48:21.298
IN THAT. YOU KNOW, IF THE

00:48:21.365 --> 00:48:22.866
DAIRIES REDUCED THEIR EMISSIONS

00:48:22.933 --> 00:48:24.468
BY EACH DAIRY BY 90%, IF THERE

00:48:24.534 --> 00:48:26.670
WAS 75% ADOPTION, YOU KNOW, IF,

00:48:26.737 --> 00:48:28.105
IF, IF, IF, IF, IF THERE WERE

00:48:28.171 --> 00:48:29.906
MONEY FOR IT IS REALLY WHAT IT

00:48:29.973 --> 00:48:31.775
COMES DOWN TO, WE WOULD SEE

00:48:31.842 --> 00:48:32.809
THIS TREMENDOUSLY POWERFUL

00:48:32.876 --> 00:48:35.646
PROGRAM. SO IF ANYONE WANTS TO

00:48:35.712 --> 00:48:37.581
SEE A COPY OF THAT REPORT, I

00:48:37.648 --> 00:48:39.583
CAN GET IT TO YOU. SO I'M GOING

00:48:39.650 --> 00:48:41.018
TO CLOSE JUST WITH A QUICK NOTE

00:48:41.084 --> 00:48:42.886
ABOUT ENTERIC FERMENTATION THAT

00:48:42.953 --> 00:48:43.887
HOPEFULLY TEES UP SOMETHING

00:48:43.954 --> 00:48:45.055
THAT JOSEPH'S GOING TO TALK

00:48:45.122 --> 00:48:46.456
ABOUT, WHICH IS SOME

00:48:46.523 --> 00:48:47.057
EXPERIMENTATION THEY'RE DOING

00:48:47.124 --> 00:48:49.726
AT STRAUSS, BUT SOMETHING TO

00:48:49.793 --> 00:48:51.128
UNDERSTAND ABOUT METHANE AND

00:48:51.194 --> 00:48:52.596
DAIRIES IS IT DOESN'T JUST COME

00:48:52.663 --> 00:48:53.764
FROM THE MANURE, IT'S ALSO FROM

00:48:53.830 --> 00:48:54.998
THE ANIMALS THEMSELVES. AND

00:48:55.065 --> 00:48:56.667
THIS IS WHERE IT GETS A LITTLE

00:48:56.733 --> 00:48:59.069
IMPOLITE, BUT IT CAN. THE

00:48:59.136 --> 00:49:01.238
POLITE TERM FOR THIS IS ENTERIC

00:49:01.305 --> 00:49:02.773
FERMENTATION, AND IT RESULTS IN.

00:49:02.839 --> 00:49:05.542
IT'S THE RESULT OF THE FEED

00:49:05.609 --> 00:49:06.977
BEING DIGESTED INSIDE THE

00:49:07.044 --> 00:49:10.580
ANIMAL, IN THEIR RUMEN. IN

00:49:10.647 --> 00:49:12.382
ANAEROBIC CONDITIONS. SO

00:49:12.449 --> 00:49:13.850
METHANE GETS PRODUCED IN THERE.

00:49:13.917 --> 00:49:14.918
AND THERE'S ONLY TWO CHOICES

00:49:14.985 --> 00:49:16.720
ABOUT WHERE THAT METHANE GOES.

00:49:16.787 --> 00:49:18.121
MOST OF IT COMES OUT IN THE

00:49:18.188 --> 00:49:20.290
FORM OF BURPS. AND IT'S IT'S A

00:49:20.357 --> 00:49:22.092
RATHER SIGNIFICANT AMOUNT OF

00:49:22.159 --> 00:49:24.294
GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS. AND

00:49:24.361 --> 00:49:26.063
THAT'S A PRETTY TRICKY THING TO

00:49:26.129 --> 00:49:28.932
ADDRESS. BUT THERE'S A LOT OF

00:49:28.999 --> 00:49:31.435
RESEARCH GOING ON TO DO SO. SO

00:49:31.501 --> 00:49:33.370
THERE IS ONE FEED ADDITIVE ON

00:49:33.437 --> 00:49:35.038
THE MARKET RIGHT NOW THAT'S

00:49:35.105 --> 00:49:39.042
BEEN APPROVED FOR USE IN COWS.

00:49:39.109 --> 00:49:40.210
THERE ARE OTHER THINGS THAT ARE

00:49:40.277 --> 00:49:41.345
BEING LOOKED AT LIKE BREEDING

00:49:41.411 --> 00:49:43.680
AND GENETICS AND IMPROVED

00:49:43.747 --> 00:49:45.515
GRAZING AND FORAGE MANAGEMENT

00:49:45.582 --> 00:49:46.750
THAT THAT SCIENTISTS ARE TRYING

00:49:46.817 --> 00:49:49.186
TO UNDERSTAND BETTER. BUT AS OF

00:49:49.252 --> 00:49:50.721
NOW, THERE'S ONLY ONE PRODUCT

00:49:50.787 --> 00:49:52.356
THAT CAN BE SOLD IN CALIFORNIA

00:49:52.422 --> 00:49:53.523
ON THE COMMERCIAL MARKET, IT'S

00:49:53.590 --> 00:49:57.427
CALLED 3NOP, THE NUMBER 3NOP.

00:49:57.494 --> 00:50:00.364
IT'S A TRADE NAME IS BOVAR. SO

00:50:00.430 --> 00:50:01.531
JOSEPH IS GOING TO TALK MORE

00:50:01.598 --> 00:50:03.300
ABOUT A SEAWEED BASED PRODUCT

00:50:03.367 --> 00:50:04.368
THAT THEY'RE WORKING ON. AS

00:50:04.434 --> 00:50:05.569
WE'VE KIND OF LOOKED AT THIS

00:50:05.635 --> 00:50:07.504
AND CONSIDERED THE CONSEQUENCES

00:50:07.571 --> 00:50:08.705
FOR PRODUCERS. AND IN TALKING

00:50:08.772 --> 00:50:10.574
WITH A LOT OF PRODUCERS, WE, WE

00:50:10.640 --> 00:50:11.808
CAME UP WITH WHAT WE THINK ARE

00:50:11.875 --> 00:50:13.577
SOME IMPORTANT GUARDRAILS ON

00:50:13.643 --> 00:50:15.712
MOVING FORWARD ON INNOVATIONS

00:50:15.779 --> 00:50:16.813
LIKE THIS. AND I'LL JUST

00:50:16.880 --> 00:50:20.083
BRIEFLY SHARE THEM WHEN

00:50:20.150 --> 00:50:21.485
CONSIDERING WHAT PUBLIC

00:50:21.551 --> 00:50:22.953
INVESTMENT SHOULD BE MADE IN A

00:50:23.019 --> 00:50:24.221
PRODUCT LIKE A FEED, ADDITIVE

00:50:24.287 --> 00:50:27.991
OR AMP OR ANY OTHER SOLUTION,

00:50:28.058 --> 00:50:30.127
WE THINK THAT WE NEED TO BE

00:50:30.193 --> 00:50:31.962
VERY THOUGHTFUL ABOUT TAKING A

00:50:32.028 --> 00:50:34.064
WHOLE FARM. LOOK AT THE AT THE

00:50:34.131 --> 00:50:36.266
IMPACT OF THE PROJECT OR THE

00:50:36.333 --> 00:50:38.001
SOLUTION, AND LOOK AT THE WHOLE

00:50:38.068 --> 00:50:40.237
FEED LIFE SCALE, THE FULL LIFE

00:50:40.303 --> 00:50:41.405
SCALE OF THAT PRODUCT. SO IN

00:50:41.471 --> 00:50:43.306
THE CASE OF A FEED ADDITIVE,

00:50:43.373 --> 00:50:44.408
WHAT GOES INTO THAT? HOW MUCH

00:50:44.474 --> 00:50:46.209
ENERGY IS USED TO PRODUCE IT?

00:50:46.276 --> 00:50:47.411
WHAT ARE THE RAW MATERIALS?

00:50:47.477 --> 00:50:48.445
WHAT ARE THE ENVIRONMENTAL

00:50:48.512 --> 00:50:50.147
IMPACTS OF THOSE? AND ALL THE

00:50:50.213 --> 00:50:51.548
WAY UP THE, THE, THE LIFESPAN

00:50:51.615 --> 00:50:54.251
OF THE PRODUCT. WE REALLY FEEL

00:50:54.317 --> 00:50:56.019
STRONGLY THAT IT'S IMPORTANT TO

00:50:56.086 --> 00:50:57.487
PRIORITIZE SOLUTIONS THAT HAVE

00:50:57.554 --> 00:50:58.955
MULTIPLE BENEFITS, NOT JUST

00:50:59.022 --> 00:51:01.525
METHANE REDUCTION. THERE ARE

00:51:01.591 --> 00:51:04.428
THERE'S SO MUCH POWER IN WITH

00:51:04.494 --> 00:51:06.163
LOOKING AT CLIMATE CHANGE IN

00:51:06.229 --> 00:51:07.197
ADDRESSING A NUMBER OF PROBLEMS.

00:51:07.264 --> 00:51:08.665
AND WE REALLY FEEL LIKE WE NEED

00:51:08.732 --> 00:51:09.833
TO BE THOUGHTFUL ABOUT

00:51:09.900 --> 00:51:11.535
IMPROVING AIR AND WATER QUALITY,

00:51:11.601 --> 00:51:13.670
WATER QUANTITY, ANIMAL WELFARE,

00:51:13.737 --> 00:51:15.872
WELFARE, WORKER SAFETY, SOIL

00:51:15.939 --> 00:51:16.973
QUALITY. THESE ARE ALL, YOU

00:51:17.040 --> 00:51:18.141
KNOW, WE CAN GET ALL THESE

00:51:18.208 --> 00:51:19.976
RAMIFYING EFFECTS IF WE IF WE

00:51:20.043 --> 00:51:22.012
MAKE GOOD CHOICES, WE WOULD SAY

00:51:22.078 --> 00:51:23.079
ALSO, IT'S REALLY IMPORTANT

00:51:23.146 --> 00:51:24.514
THAT ANY SOLUTION WORKS FOR

00:51:24.581 --> 00:51:25.982
SMALL AND MEDIUM SIZED

00:51:26.049 --> 00:51:27.217
PRODUCERS AND ORGANIC PRODUCERS

00:51:27.284 --> 00:51:28.452
OR PASTURE BASED SYSTEMS. WE

00:51:28.518 --> 00:51:30.320
HAVE TO MAKE SURE THAT THAT THE

00:51:30.387 --> 00:51:31.721
ENTIRE INDUSTRY IS SERVED, NOT

00:51:31.788 --> 00:51:34.958
JUST A SECTOR OF IT. AND IN THE

00:51:35.025 --> 00:51:36.760
EARLY STAGES, IT'S IMPORTANT TO

00:51:36.827 --> 00:51:38.228
COVER THESE COSTS. IT'S

00:51:38.295 --> 00:51:39.229
IMPORTANT TO MAKE SURE THAT

00:51:39.296 --> 00:51:40.330
FARMERS ARE MADE WHOLE FOR

00:51:40.397 --> 00:51:41.798
THESE ECOSYSTEM SERVICES THAT

00:51:41.865 --> 00:51:44.334
THEY'RE PROVIDING. AND FINALLY,

00:51:44.401 --> 00:51:45.836
JUST WE DO HAVE CONCERNS ABOUT

00:51:45.902 --> 00:51:47.737
THE FACT THAT IF THE STATE WERE

00:51:47.804 --> 00:51:48.738
TO INCENTIVIZE THIS FEED

00:51:48.805 --> 00:51:50.006
ADDITIVE, THERE'S ONLY ONE

00:51:50.073 --> 00:51:51.475
MANUFACTURER OUT THERE, AND IT

00:51:51.541 --> 00:51:55.812
FEELS LIKE A LITTLE BIT OF A,

00:51:55.879 --> 00:51:58.348
YOU KNOW, A MARKETING QUESTION,

00:51:58.415 --> 00:51:59.816
YOU KNOW, ABOUT WHETHER IT'S A

00:51:59.883 --> 00:52:01.918
WISE THING TO JUST, YOU KNOW,

00:52:01.985 --> 00:52:02.986
INCENTIVIZE THE SALE OF ONE

00:52:03.053 --> 00:52:06.223
PRODUCT. SO IN CLOSING, I KNOW

00:52:06.289 --> 00:52:08.458
I'VE GONE OVER TIME, WE WOULD

00:52:08.525 --> 00:52:09.826
RECOMMEND TO THE LEGISLATURE

00:52:09.893 --> 00:52:11.061
THAT FOR THE FORESEEABLE FUTURE

00:52:11.127 --> 00:52:13.363
THAT THE PREMIUM BE PUT ON

00:52:13.430 --> 00:52:15.265
THESE AMP SOLUTIONS. THERE'S SO

00:52:15.332 --> 00:52:16.166
MUCH DEMAND FOR THEM, AND

00:52:16.233 --> 00:52:17.400
THERE'S SO MANY CO-BENEFITS

00:52:17.467 --> 00:52:18.969
THAT COME FOR THE FARMER AND

00:52:19.035 --> 00:52:20.036
FOR THEIR COMMUNITIES AND FOR

00:52:20.103 --> 00:52:21.972
ALL OF US AT LARGE AS WE

00:52:22.038 --> 00:52:23.139
GRAPPLE WITH THE CONSEQUENCES

00:52:23.206 --> 00:52:25.308
OF CLIMATE CHANGE. THANKS FOR

00:52:25.375 --> 00:52:27.177
YOUR ATTENTION. THANK YOU SO

00:52:27.244 --> 00:52:28.879
MUCH. AND I THINK WE'LL GO

00:52:28.945 --> 00:52:30.046
THROUGH ALL OF THE

00:52:30.113 --> 00:52:30.914
PRESENTATIONS BEFORE I ASK A

00:52:30.981 --> 00:52:32.516
COUPLE QUESTIONS, IF THAT WORKS.

00:52:32.582 --> 00:52:33.917
AND I THINK, DOUG, I THINK

00:52:33.984 --> 00:52:37.554
YOU'RE NEXT. WE'RE JUST GOING

00:52:37.621 --> 00:52:38.855
TO KEEP GOING THROUGH THOSE

00:52:38.922 --> 00:52:40.123
SAME SLIDES. THAT'S THE LAST

00:52:40.190 --> 00:52:43.360
FOUR SLIDES OF DOUG'S. ALL

00:52:43.426 --> 00:52:45.128
RIGHT. GOOD MORNING. THANK YOU,

00:52:45.195 --> 00:52:46.229
ASSEMBLYMAN ROGERS AND STAFF

00:52:46.296 --> 00:52:49.866
FOR INVITING ME. AS RENATA SAID,

00:52:49.933 --> 00:52:53.403
I WAS ONE OF THE 2019. I

00:52:53.470 --> 00:52:55.972
APPLIED FOR AN AMP. GRANT WAS

00:52:56.039 --> 00:52:57.707
SUCCESSFUL IN IN GETTING THAT

00:52:57.774 --> 00:52:59.142
GRANT. AND WE WERE ABLE TO

00:52:59.209 --> 00:53:02.045
START OUR PROCESS, OUR WORK IN

00:53:02.112 --> 00:53:04.981
2020. ONE OF THE THINGS THAT I

00:53:05.048 --> 00:53:08.518
THINK THIS IS REALLY NEAT TO

00:53:08.585 --> 00:53:09.986
KNOW IS SONOMA COUNTY, SONOMA

00:53:10.053 --> 00:53:12.522
AND MARIN COUNTY HAVE BEEN VERY,

00:53:12.589 --> 00:53:15.058
VERY FORWARD THINKING IN MANURE

00:53:15.125 --> 00:53:17.527
MANAGEMENT FOR MANY, MANY YEARS.

00:53:17.594 --> 00:53:19.362
YOU KNOW, GOING BACK TO THE MID

00:53:19.429 --> 00:53:21.498
80S, WE WERE WHEN THE

00:53:21.565 --> 00:53:22.732
CALIFORNIA FISH AND GAME AT

00:53:22.799 --> 00:53:25.802
THAT TIME LOST THEIR FUNDING

00:53:25.869 --> 00:53:28.338
FOR DOING WATER SURFACE WATER

00:53:28.405 --> 00:53:29.506
SAMPLING. THE DAIRYMEN HERE,

00:53:29.573 --> 00:53:31.207
AND THE INDUSTRY STEPPED UP AND

00:53:31.274 --> 00:53:32.475
STARTED A PROGRAM CLEAR BACK

00:53:32.542 --> 00:53:33.743
THEN TO, TO STAY AHEAD OF

00:53:33.810 --> 00:53:35.512
MANURE MANAGEMENT. SO WE KNOW

00:53:35.579 --> 00:53:36.980
WHAT IT'S WHAT WAS, YOU KNOW,

00:53:37.047 --> 00:53:38.481
ESSENTIAL TO THIS AREA AND WHAT

00:53:38.548 --> 00:53:40.584
NEEDED TO BE DONE. WHEN I

00:53:40.650 --> 00:53:43.086
LOOKED AT THE AMP GRANT, IT WAS

00:53:43.153 --> 00:53:44.187
SOMETHING I THOUGHT, WELL, I'LL

00:53:44.254 --> 00:53:45.555
NEVER, NEVER BE ABLE TO MAKE

00:53:45.622 --> 00:53:46.690
THIS HAPPEN. BUT WITH THE HELP

00:53:46.756 --> 00:53:49.926
OF UC EXTENSION LADY THERE, WE

00:53:49.993 --> 00:53:51.728
WERE ABLE TO SIT DOWN. IT TOOK.

00:53:51.795 --> 00:53:54.030
IT WAS A IT WAS A TOUGH THING

00:53:54.097 --> 00:53:55.832
TO FILL OUT THE GRANT FORM, BUT,

00:53:55.899 --> 00:53:57.734
YOU KNOW, WE WE LUCKED OUT. OUR

00:53:57.801 --> 00:54:00.036
GRANT WAS $600,000. AND IF YOU

00:54:00.103 --> 00:54:02.172
CAN GO THE NEXT SLIDE THERE.

00:54:02.238 --> 00:54:04.407
THIS, AS I WAS SAYING, TALKING

00:54:04.474 --> 00:54:05.909
ABOUT THE SEPARATOR EARLIER IN

00:54:05.976 --> 00:54:07.677
THE PICTURES WAS THIS IS WHAT

00:54:07.744 --> 00:54:10.080
IS CALLED A SCREW A SCREW PRESS

00:54:10.146 --> 00:54:11.514
SEPARATOR. SO IN OUR GRANT, WE

00:54:11.581 --> 00:54:14.050
WERE ABLE TO PUT AUTOMATIC

00:54:14.117 --> 00:54:15.518
SCRAPERS IN OUR FREE STALL BARN,

00:54:15.585 --> 00:54:18.688
WHERE ORIGINALLY WE HAD A SMALL

00:54:18.755 --> 00:54:20.523
TRACTOR SKID STEER THAT. AND

00:54:20.590 --> 00:54:23.059
THAT PUSHED THE MANURE TO A

00:54:23.126 --> 00:54:25.295
LAGOON AT THAT TIME. NOW WE'RE

00:54:25.362 --> 00:54:26.663
ABLE TO RUN THE AUTOMATIC

00:54:26.730 --> 00:54:29.566
SCRAPERS INTO A SMALL SUMP PUMP

00:54:29.633 --> 00:54:31.334
PIT, AND IT PUMPS IT THROUGH

00:54:31.401 --> 00:54:32.502
THIS MACHINE HERE, WHICH IS A

00:54:32.569 --> 00:54:33.903
SCREW PRESS SEPARATOR. AND

00:54:33.970 --> 00:54:36.439
WE'RE SEPARATING THE SOLIDS

00:54:36.506 --> 00:54:37.841
AWAY FROM THE WATER. SO THAT

00:54:37.907 --> 00:54:38.942
SLURRY THAT I HANDED YOU

00:54:39.009 --> 00:54:40.744
EARLIER IS WHAT COMES OUT OF

00:54:40.810 --> 00:54:43.613
OUR BARN. BY THE TIME ABOUT 7

00:54:43.680 --> 00:54:45.415
TO 8 DAYS AFTER IT COMES OUT OF

00:54:45.482 --> 00:54:46.549
THE SEPARATOR AND WE'RE RUNNING

00:54:46.616 --> 00:54:48.618
IT THROUGH WINDROW COMPOST,

00:54:48.685 --> 00:54:49.919
THAT IS THE OTHER MATERIAL THAT

00:54:49.986 --> 00:54:52.288
YOU SEE IN THE BAG. THE THE

00:54:52.355 --> 00:54:53.990
THING THAT WAS, YOU KNOW, IT

00:54:54.057 --> 00:54:55.825
ENDS UP HELPING THE ENVIRONMENT,

00:54:55.892 --> 00:54:58.662
BUT IT ALSO IS HELPING OUT THE

00:54:58.728 --> 00:55:00.363
DAIRIES FOR MANURE MANAGEMENT

00:55:00.430 --> 00:55:03.400
OR, YOU KNOW, WE WERE ONE OF

00:55:03.466 --> 00:55:05.535
THE WE ALWAYS WERE, AS I SAID,

00:55:05.602 --> 00:55:07.704
AHEAD OF THE TIMES, BUT THE

00:55:07.771 --> 00:55:09.506
COST OF THIS EQUIPMENT FOR A

00:55:09.572 --> 00:55:10.940
SMALL SIZED DAIRY WAS REALLY

00:55:11.007 --> 00:55:12.409
TOUGH. SO WHEN THAT GRANT

00:55:12.475 --> 00:55:13.510
BECAME AVAILABLE, IT WAS

00:55:13.576 --> 00:55:14.577
SOMETHING THAT I REALLY, YOU

00:55:14.644 --> 00:55:17.080
KNOW, HOPED THAT I WOULD

00:55:17.147 --> 00:55:18.248
ACHIEVE IT. AND WE ENDED UP

00:55:18.314 --> 00:55:20.984
GRANTING GETTING THAT GRANT.

00:55:21.051 --> 00:55:23.887
WE'VE BEEN NOW. SO 2020, I

00:55:23.953 --> 00:55:26.056
BELIEVE IT WAS A LATE 2020 WHEN

00:55:26.122 --> 00:55:27.691
WHEN EVERYTHING GOT INSTALLED.

00:55:27.757 --> 00:55:29.092
SO WE'RE ALMOST SIX YEARS INTO

00:55:29.159 --> 00:55:31.861
THIS PROJECT. AND AS RENATA

00:55:31.928 --> 00:55:32.996
SAID, YOU KNOW, WHEN THEY'RE

00:55:33.063 --> 00:55:34.798
GIVING ONLY A FIVE YEAR

00:55:34.864 --> 00:55:36.132
LIFESPAN, THIS EQUIPMENT IS

00:55:36.199 --> 00:55:38.034
ALREADY WE'RE AT SIX. THE THING

00:55:38.101 --> 00:55:39.769
IS, IS ONCE WE CHANGE TO THESE

00:55:39.836 --> 00:55:41.271
TYPE OF MANAGEMENT TOOLS, WE'RE

00:55:41.337 --> 00:55:42.939
NOT GOING TO GO AWAY FROM THEM.

00:55:43.006 --> 00:55:44.574
SO I, I REALLY THINK WE ARE

00:55:44.641 --> 00:55:46.943
SEEING A MUCH LARGER, YOU KNOW,

00:55:47.010 --> 00:55:48.011
INCREASE IN THAT REDUCTION

00:55:48.078 --> 00:55:49.846
BECAUSE, YOU KNOW, WE'LL BE IN

00:55:49.913 --> 00:55:51.748
THIS FOR 20 TO 30 YEARS UNLESS

00:55:51.815 --> 00:55:52.849
THERE'S SOMETHING THAT TOTALLY

00:55:52.916 --> 00:55:54.551
COMES DIFFERENT THAT CAN HELP

00:55:54.617 --> 00:55:57.053
OUT. SO THOSE ARE THE, THE, A

00:55:57.120 --> 00:55:58.722
LOT OF THE GOOD THINGS ABOUT,

00:55:58.788 --> 00:56:01.725
YOU KNOW, THESE GRANTS ALSO, I

00:56:01.791 --> 00:56:05.628
THINK WHEN WE LOOK AT THE

00:56:05.695 --> 00:56:06.830
EMISSIONS AND THINGS, YOU KNOW,

00:56:06.896 --> 00:56:09.966
IT'S NOT ONLY HELPED MYSELF BY

00:56:10.033 --> 00:56:12.602
THE DAIRY ITSELF GETTING THAT

00:56:12.669 --> 00:56:14.170
MANURE OUT OF THE PONDS, BUT IT

00:56:14.237 --> 00:56:16.439
SAVED US MONEY OVER A LONG TERM.

00:56:16.506 --> 00:56:17.941
WHEN WE APPLIED FOR THE GRANT,

00:56:18.007 --> 00:56:19.709
ONE OF THE MAIN THINGS THAT WE

00:56:19.776 --> 00:56:21.644
ALSO PUT IN WAS THE COST OF

00:56:21.711 --> 00:56:24.414
DIESEL SAVINGS. AND YOU KNOW,

00:56:24.481 --> 00:56:26.549
WHEN WE PROBABLY SAVED ABOUT

00:56:26.616 --> 00:56:29.452
100 LOADS A YEAR OF THAT WET

00:56:29.519 --> 00:56:30.887
SLURRY BEING HAULED ON THE

00:56:30.954 --> 00:56:33.022
FIELDS TO NOW HAVING THIS NICE,

00:56:33.089 --> 00:56:34.457
DRY, THIS DRY, NICE DRY

00:56:34.524 --> 00:56:36.259
MATERIAL, WHICH THEN ALSO

00:56:36.326 --> 00:56:39.162
HELPED LEAD INTO A COUPLE OTHER

00:56:39.229 --> 00:56:42.732
GRANTS. THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

00:56:42.799 --> 00:56:43.833
ISSUES, AND THOSE WERE CALLED

00:56:43.900 --> 00:56:45.235
HEALTHY SOILS GRANTS. SO NOW

00:56:45.301 --> 00:56:47.036
THAT I HAVE THIS COMPOST, I'M

00:56:47.103 --> 00:56:49.205
ABLE TO BUILD THAT COMPOST AND

00:56:49.272 --> 00:56:51.374
THEN UTILIZE THAT BACK ON

00:56:51.441 --> 00:56:53.209
PASTURE FOR CARBON SEQUESTER,

00:56:53.276 --> 00:56:54.878
WHICH IS NOW HELPING OUT IN A

00:56:54.944 --> 00:56:56.546
IN A TOTAL DIFFERENT AREA AWAY

00:56:56.613 --> 00:56:58.948
FROM THE METHANE ITSELF. OUR,

00:56:59.015 --> 00:57:01.818
OUR PROJECT ALONE, YOU KNOW, WE

00:57:01.885 --> 00:57:03.987
BUT JUST BY THE EMISSION

00:57:04.053 --> 00:57:06.156
SAVINGS, WE'VE TAKEN 173 GAS

00:57:06.222 --> 00:57:08.291
POWERED CARS OFF THE ROAD A

00:57:08.358 --> 00:57:11.194
YEAR. SO AS WE AS WE'RE NOT

00:57:11.261 --> 00:57:12.996
TALKED ABOUT THE NUMBER THERE,

00:57:13.062 --> 00:57:14.798
YOU KNOW, AND THAT'S NOW WE'RE

00:57:14.864 --> 00:57:16.266
AT AT FIVE AND A HALF, ALMOST

00:57:16.332 --> 00:57:18.701
SIX YEARS INTO THIS PROJECT. WE

00:57:18.768 --> 00:57:20.170
ALSO HAVE, YOU KNOW, FIGURED

00:57:20.236 --> 00:57:24.474
INTO THIS ABOUT ENDED UP ABOUT

00:57:24.541 --> 00:57:26.643
5300 GALLONS OF DIESEL FUEL

00:57:26.709 --> 00:57:28.778
BETWEEN WHAT I SAVE ON THE FARM,

00:57:28.845 --> 00:57:32.782
PLUS WHAT WAS BRINGING THE

00:57:32.849 --> 00:57:33.783
TRUCKS THAT WERE THERE,

00:57:33.850 --> 00:57:34.851
SPREADING IT. AND ALSO, AS

00:57:34.918 --> 00:57:36.753
RENATA MENTIONED, WE WERE

00:57:36.820 --> 00:57:40.356
HAULING IN RECYCLED BEACH SAND.

00:57:40.423 --> 00:57:42.559
SO THAT TAKING THAT THAT TRUCK

00:57:42.625 --> 00:57:44.327
OFF, THAT WAS ABOUT FOUR LOADS

00:57:44.394 --> 00:57:46.162
FOR TRANSFER LOADS A MONTH. SO

00:57:46.229 --> 00:57:47.530
WE'VE TAKEN THAT DIESEL AWAY

00:57:47.597 --> 00:57:49.065
ALSO. PLUS, YOU KNOW, THAT MUCH

00:57:49.132 --> 00:57:51.267
LESS OFF OF THE ROAD BEING ABLE

00:57:51.334 --> 00:57:52.702
TO UTILIZE THIS COMPOST RIGHT

00:57:52.769 --> 00:57:54.304
HERE. ALSO FOR BEDDING FOR OUR

00:57:54.370 --> 00:57:56.206
ANIMALS. THAT WAS OUR MAIN

00:57:56.272 --> 00:57:58.007
OBJECTIVE WAS TO COME UP WITH A

00:57:58.074 --> 00:58:00.210
BEAUTIFUL BEDDING. AND IT HAS

00:58:00.276 --> 00:58:01.611
ONE THING THAT HAS, YOU KNOW,

00:58:01.678 --> 00:58:05.148
REALLY HELPED OUR, OUR DAIRY

00:58:05.215 --> 00:58:06.716
WAS JUST THAT COST SAVINGS. AND

00:58:06.783 --> 00:58:09.452
THE, THE CATTLE REALLY ENJOY

00:58:09.519 --> 00:58:12.355
LAYING ON THE COMPOST. I THINK

00:58:12.422 --> 00:58:14.891
ONE OF THE THINGS THAT I'VE

00:58:14.958 --> 00:58:17.026
HEARD ABOUT, YOU KNOW, ABOUT

00:58:17.093 --> 00:58:19.195
THE GRANTS AND NOT BEING ABLE

00:58:19.262 --> 00:58:21.865
TO SEE MORE DAIRYMEN GET IT IS

00:58:21.931 --> 00:58:23.867
THE FUNDING. AND I THINK IT IS

00:58:23.933 --> 00:58:24.734
SOMETHING THAT I WOULD REALLY

00:58:24.801 --> 00:58:26.469
HOPE THAT THE STATE OF

00:58:26.536 --> 00:58:27.470
CALIFORNIA CAN CONTINUE THAT

00:58:27.537 --> 00:58:28.605
FUNDING AND AND POSSIBLY

00:58:28.671 --> 00:58:29.772
INCREASE IT. I KNOW WHERE WE

00:58:29.839 --> 00:58:32.175
ARE WITH THE BUDGET, BUT IT IS

00:58:32.242 --> 00:58:35.044
A VERY ESSENTIAL PROGRAM TO

00:58:35.111 --> 00:58:36.846
DAIRIES THROUGHOUT THE STATE OF

00:58:36.913 --> 00:58:38.948
CALIFORNIA. AND I THINK THAT'S

00:58:39.015 --> 00:58:40.116
ALL I HAVE. UNLESS YOU HAVE

00:58:40.183 --> 00:58:44.888
ANYTHING FOR ME. YEAH. WE'LL

00:58:44.954 --> 00:58:46.522
COME BACK TO YOU WITH A COUPLE

00:58:46.589 --> 00:58:47.657
OF QUESTIONS. IN A FEW MINUTES.

00:58:47.724 --> 00:58:50.193
WE'LL GO TO JOSEPH. WELL, GOOD

00:58:50.260 --> 00:58:51.961
MORNING, AND ASSEMBLY MEMBER

00:58:52.028 --> 00:58:53.396
ROGERS AND TEAM, THANK YOU SO

00:58:53.463 --> 00:58:55.932
MUCH FOR HAVING ME HERE TODAY.

00:58:55.999 --> 00:58:57.200
AGAIN, MY NAME IS JOSEPH BUTTON.

00:58:57.267 --> 00:58:58.468
I WORK AT STRAUS FAMILY

00:58:58.534 --> 00:59:00.203
CREAMERY. I'VE BEEN WORKING AT

00:59:00.270 --> 00:59:02.372
STRAUSS FOR A DECADE, AND

00:59:02.438 --> 00:59:03.506
DURING THAT TIME I'VE BEEN

00:59:03.573 --> 00:59:04.574
LEADING OUR SUSTAINABILITY

00:59:04.641 --> 00:59:06.009
EFFORTS AND PARTNERING WITH OUR

00:59:06.075 --> 00:59:08.244
13 NETWORK DAIRY FARMS. I THINK

00:59:08.311 --> 00:59:09.913
ABOUT METHANE AND MANURE ON A

00:59:09.979 --> 00:59:12.515
DAILY BASIS. I'M ALSO

00:59:12.582 --> 00:59:13.883
NOTORIOUSLY LONG WINDED, SO I'M

00:59:13.950 --> 00:59:17.153
SETTING A TIMER TO TRY TO KEEP

00:59:17.220 --> 00:59:18.955
MY COMMENTS TO POINT,

00:59:19.022 --> 00:59:21.157
ESPECIALLY ON A TOPIC THAT I AM

00:59:21.224 --> 00:59:22.926
SO PASSIONATE ABOUT. AND AS YOU

00:59:22.992 --> 00:59:25.128
CAN SEE, THE DAIRYMEN IN THIS

00:59:25.194 --> 00:59:27.230
REGION ARE SO PASSIONATE ABOUT.

00:59:27.297 --> 00:59:29.065
I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT TO

00:59:29.132 --> 00:59:31.567
MENTION, AS WE BEGIN, THAT

00:59:31.634 --> 00:59:33.002
SONOMA AND MARIN COUNTY HAS A

00:59:33.069 --> 00:59:35.905
RICH DAIRY LEGACY AND HERITAGE,

00:59:35.972 --> 00:59:37.340
AND THERE'S BRANDS LIKE STRAUS

00:59:37.407 --> 00:59:38.808
FAMILY CREAMERY AND CLOVER

00:59:38.875 --> 00:59:40.710
SONOMA AND FARMERS THAT SUPPLY

00:59:40.777 --> 00:59:43.112
MILK FOR ROMANO CHEESE, ORGANIC

00:59:43.179 --> 00:59:44.914
VALLEY AND MANY OTHER NOTABLE

00:59:44.981 --> 00:59:46.683
BRANDS THAT HAVE A GREAT

00:59:46.749 --> 00:59:47.750
REPUTATION IN THE STATE OF

00:59:47.817 --> 00:59:49.986
CALIFORNIA AND NATIONWIDE. AND

00:59:50.053 --> 00:59:51.087
IT'S IMPORTANT TO REMEMBER THAT

00:59:51.154 --> 00:59:52.455
AS WE THINK ABOUT THE

00:59:52.522 --> 00:59:53.523
PROGRESSIVE, AMAZING WORK THAT

00:59:53.589 --> 00:59:55.124
THE FARMERS IN THIS REGION ARE

00:59:55.191 --> 00:59:59.696
DOING. OUR FOUNDER AND

00:59:59.762 --> 01:00:01.464
EXECUTIVE BOARD CHAIR, ALBERT

01:00:01.531 --> 01:00:03.366
STRAUSS, HAS AN AUDACIOUS QUOTE

01:00:03.433 --> 01:00:05.335
THAT HE LIKES TO SAY. AND HE

01:00:05.401 --> 01:00:06.502
SAYS SUSTAINABLE ORGANIC DAIRY

01:00:06.569 --> 01:00:09.038
FARMING IS A CLIMATE CHANGE

01:00:09.105 --> 01:00:11.908
SOLUTION. AND HE SAID THIS MANY

01:00:11.975 --> 01:00:14.777
YEARS AGO TO TRY TO STEM THE

01:00:14.844 --> 01:00:16.579
TIDE. I WOULD SAY THE THE

01:00:16.646 --> 01:00:17.747
SOCIETAL TIDE THAT SAID, WE

01:00:17.814 --> 01:00:19.782
NEED TO ELIMINATE DAIRY

01:00:19.849 --> 01:00:23.453
WORLDWIDE. WHEN YOU LOOK AT IT,

01:00:23.519 --> 01:00:24.887
ALBERT KNOWS THIS FROM

01:00:24.954 --> 01:00:25.922
EXPERIENCE. DOUG KNOWS THIS

01:00:25.989 --> 01:00:28.091
FROM EXPERIENCE. WHEN THE RIGHT

01:00:28.157 --> 01:00:29.826
MANAGEMENT PRACTICES ARE SET IN

01:00:29.892 --> 01:00:31.394
PLACE ON DAIRY FARMS, THEY CAN

01:00:31.461 --> 01:00:33.529
GO FROM A CLIMATE SOURCE TO A

01:00:33.596 --> 01:00:35.231
REAL CLIMATE SOLUTION. THAT'S

01:00:35.298 --> 01:00:37.433
IMPORTANT FOR THE WORLD. DAIRY

01:00:37.500 --> 01:00:39.202
FARMERS PROVIDE A LOT OF THE

01:00:39.268 --> 01:00:42.171
ESSENTIAL NUTRIENTS WORLDWIDE

01:00:42.238 --> 01:00:45.541
FOR SOCIETY, AND DAIRY FARMING

01:00:45.608 --> 01:00:47.276
IS GROWING WORLDWIDE. DEMAND

01:00:47.343 --> 01:00:48.978
FOR DAIRY IS GROWING WORLDWIDE,

01:00:49.045 --> 01:00:50.880
SO ELIMINATION OF DAIRY HAS

01:00:50.947 --> 01:00:52.648
NEVER BEEN A REALISTIC SOLUTION.

01:00:52.715 --> 01:00:54.384
WHAT NEEDS TO HAPPEN IS

01:00:54.450 --> 01:00:55.818
INNOVATION AND MANAGEMENT

01:00:55.885 --> 01:00:57.920
PRACTICE CHANGES TO MAKE SURE

01:00:57.987 --> 01:00:59.022
THAT THE FEED SOURCE THAT

01:00:59.088 --> 01:01:00.923
HUMANS NEED IS REFLECTING OUR

01:01:00.990 --> 01:01:02.658
CLIMATE, FUTURE AND OUR CLIMATE

01:01:02.725 --> 01:01:06.195
NEEDS. SO MANY YEARS AGO,

01:01:06.262 --> 01:01:07.697
ALBERT WALKED INTO MY OFFICE

01:01:07.764 --> 01:01:10.199
AND HE GAVE ME WHAT MANY WOULD

01:01:10.266 --> 01:01:12.769
CALL A RIDICULOUS GOAL. HE SAID,

01:01:12.835 --> 01:01:14.170
JOSEPH, I WANT YOU TO MAKE MY

01:01:14.237 --> 01:01:16.072
DAIRY FARM AND THE OTHER DAIRY

01:01:16.139 --> 01:01:18.141
FARMS IN OUR NETWORK NET CARBON

01:01:18.207 --> 01:01:19.942
NEUTRAL IN THE NEXT FOUR YEARS.

01:01:20.009 --> 01:01:21.411
AND I SAID, ALBERT, NOBODY IN

01:01:21.477 --> 01:01:23.179
THE WORLD HAS DONE THIS, AND

01:01:23.246 --> 01:01:24.514
YOU'RE PROVIDING ME NO FUNDING

01:01:24.580 --> 01:01:26.516
TO DO IT. AND HE SAID, LET'S BE

01:01:26.582 --> 01:01:27.583
INNOVATIVE AND CREATIVE. AND I

01:01:27.650 --> 01:01:31.087
SAID, OKAY, LET'S GO. THIS IS A

01:01:31.154 --> 01:01:32.555
BIG TASK. THERE'S NOT A DAIRY

01:01:32.622 --> 01:01:34.457
FARM IN THE WORLD THAT HAS YET

01:01:34.524 --> 01:01:37.927
ACHIEVED THIS GOAL. BUT IN

01:01:37.994 --> 01:01:39.362
PASTURE BASED ORGANIC DAIRY

01:01:39.429 --> 01:01:41.531
FARMING, WE ACTUALLY DO BELIEVE

01:01:41.597 --> 01:01:44.033
THAT IT'S QUITE FEASIBLE. NOT

01:01:44.100 --> 01:01:45.868
ONLY CAN WE ELIMINATE MANY OF

01:01:45.935 --> 01:01:48.037
THE MISSIONS, IN PARTICULAR THE

01:01:48.104 --> 01:01:50.473
METHANE EMISSIONS ON FARMS,

01:01:50.540 --> 01:01:52.308
PASTURE BASED DAIRY FARMS ALSO

01:01:52.375 --> 01:01:55.211
SUPPLY A GREAT SOURCE OF CARBON

01:01:55.278 --> 01:01:56.612
SEQUESTRATION. DOUG JUST TALKED

01:01:56.679 --> 01:02:00.049
ABOUT APPLYING DRY AGED COMPOST

01:02:00.116 --> 01:02:02.018
OR MANURE BASED COMPOST TO

01:02:02.085 --> 01:02:04.587
FIELDS. THAT'S A HUGE SOURCE OF

01:02:04.654 --> 01:02:06.522
CARBON SEQUESTRATION. AND IF

01:02:06.589 --> 01:02:07.824
YOU LOOK AT THE FARMS IN THIS

01:02:07.890 --> 01:02:09.692
REGION AND THE PICTURE THAT I'M

01:02:09.759 --> 01:02:11.794
SHOWING ABOVE, GENERALLY

01:02:11.861 --> 01:02:12.595
SPEAKING, AT LEAST IN THE

01:02:12.662 --> 01:02:14.330
STRAUSS NETWORK, THERE'S AROUND

01:02:14.397 --> 01:02:16.132
350 MILKING COWS ON

01:02:16.199 --> 01:02:18.601
APPROXIMATELY 900 ACRES OF LAND.

01:02:18.668 --> 01:02:20.069
AND WHEN YOU HAVE THAT BALANCE

01:02:20.136 --> 01:02:22.205
OF ANIMAL TO LAND, YOUR

01:02:22.271 --> 01:02:23.606
SEQUESTRATION POTENTIAL IS

01:02:23.673 --> 01:02:27.276
IMMENSE. AND IT ALLOWS YOU TO

01:02:27.343 --> 01:02:28.711
ESSENTIALLY ACHIEVE ON FARM NET

01:02:28.778 --> 01:02:30.213
CARBON NEUTRALITY WITH THE

01:02:30.279 --> 01:02:32.648
RIGHT MANAGEMENT PRACTICES. AND

01:02:32.715 --> 01:02:33.816
HERE'S SIX OF THEM THAT I'LL

01:02:33.883 --> 01:02:35.651
TALK ABOUT TODAY. THIS IS WHAT

01:02:35.718 --> 01:02:38.387
STRAUSS IS DOING TO AIM FOR NET

01:02:38.454 --> 01:02:39.822
CARBON NEUTRALITY IN OUR

01:02:39.889 --> 01:02:41.424
NETWORK. AND WE REALLY BELIEVE

01:02:41.491 --> 01:02:43.392
IT BEGINS WITH ORGANIC

01:02:43.459 --> 01:02:44.393
AGRICULTURE FOR THE REASONS

01:02:44.460 --> 01:02:47.797
I'VE JUST SHARED. PASTURE BASED

01:02:47.864 --> 01:02:49.198
DAIRY FARMING IS ESSENTIAL TO

01:02:49.265 --> 01:02:51.734
GET CLOSE TO NET CARBON

01:02:51.801 --> 01:02:52.768
NEUTRALITY. BUT THAT'S WHERE

01:02:52.835 --> 01:02:54.637
THE INNOVATION REALLY BEGINS.

01:02:54.704 --> 01:02:57.507
SO TAKE A LARGE LANDSCAPE AND

01:02:57.573 --> 01:02:59.976
IMAGINE TRYING TO BUILD YOUR

01:03:00.042 --> 01:03:01.811
CARBON STOCK ON THAT LANDSCAPE

01:03:01.878 --> 01:03:03.646
WHEREVER YOU POSSIBLY CAN. IT

01:03:03.713 --> 01:03:06.482
REALLY DOES START WITH AMP

01:03:06.549 --> 01:03:07.950
PRACTICES, TAKING THE MANURE

01:03:08.017 --> 01:03:10.086
FROM THE FARM, COMPOSTING IT,

01:03:10.153 --> 01:03:12.622
AND REAPPLYING IT TO THE LAND,

01:03:12.688 --> 01:03:14.790
SOMETHING THAT OUR FARMS ARE

01:03:14.857 --> 01:03:16.626
NOTED FOR IN THIS REGION IS

01:03:16.692 --> 01:03:18.661
HAVING TREMENDOUS, TREMENDOUS

01:03:18.728 --> 01:03:21.264
WATER HOLDING CAPACITY. SO

01:03:21.330 --> 01:03:22.698
RIGHT NOW WE'RE RECEIVING A

01:03:22.765 --> 01:03:24.467
WHOLE FLUSH OF RAIN, AND THESE

01:03:24.534 --> 01:03:26.002
FARMS ARE ABSORBING RAIN LIKE

01:03:26.068 --> 01:03:27.737
YOU COULDN'T IMAGINE. AND YOU

01:03:27.803 --> 01:03:29.172
REALLY WON'T SEE THE DIFFERENCE

01:03:29.238 --> 01:03:30.606
UNTIL JUNE AND JULY, WHEN

01:03:30.673 --> 01:03:32.408
THINGS START TO DRY OUT. AND

01:03:32.475 --> 01:03:33.476
YOU'RE DRIVING AROUND MARIN AND

01:03:33.543 --> 01:03:34.977
SONOMA COUNTY, AND YOU NOTICE

01:03:35.044 --> 01:03:36.379
THAT THERE'S SOME VIBRANTLY

01:03:36.445 --> 01:03:38.147
GREEN PLOTS OF LAND NEXT TO

01:03:38.214 --> 01:03:39.949
SOME GOLDEN CALIFORNIA PLOTS OF

01:03:40.016 --> 01:03:41.751
LAND. THOSE VIBRANTLY GREEN

01:03:41.817 --> 01:03:44.654
PLOTS OF LAND ARE DAIRY FARMS.

01:03:44.720 --> 01:03:46.989
THEY ARE LARGELY, IN MOST CASES,

01:03:47.056 --> 01:03:49.325
DRY FARMED, SO THE AVAILABLE

01:03:49.392 --> 01:03:50.426
MOISTURE THEY HAVE IN THEIR

01:03:50.493 --> 01:03:52.195
SOIL IS BEING HELD THERE,

01:03:52.261 --> 01:03:53.296
THANKS TO THE CARBON

01:03:53.362 --> 01:03:54.163
SEQUESTRATION WORK THAT THEY'VE

01:03:54.230 --> 01:03:55.865
BEEN DOING FOR DECADES. AND

01:03:55.932 --> 01:03:58.434
IT'S QUITE INCREDIBLE. ALL OF

01:03:58.501 --> 01:04:00.303
THE FARMS IN THE STRAUSS FAMILY

01:04:00.369 --> 01:04:01.304
CREAMERY NETWORK HAVE SOMETHING

01:04:01.370 --> 01:04:03.005
CALLED A CARBON FARM PLAN.

01:04:03.072 --> 01:04:04.807
THOSE ARE SCIENTIFICALLY BASED

01:04:04.874 --> 01:04:05.875
PLANS THAT HAVE BEEN DEVELOPED

01:04:05.942 --> 01:04:07.643
IN CONCERT WITH RESOURCE

01:04:07.710 --> 01:04:09.478
CONSERVATION DISTRICTS,

01:04:09.545 --> 01:04:10.913
ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENTISTS AND

01:04:10.980 --> 01:04:13.449
RANGELAND ECOLOGISTS. DAIRY

01:04:13.516 --> 01:04:15.251
FARMERS ARE BRILLIANT

01:04:15.318 --> 01:04:16.686
SCIENTISTS AND THEIR CLIMATE

01:04:16.752 --> 01:04:18.120
INNOVATORS. I HAVE A LOT OF

01:04:18.187 --> 01:04:20.289
IDEAS MYSELF, BUT MOST OF THOSE

01:04:20.356 --> 01:04:22.058
IDEAS GO TO DIE WHEN I HAVE

01:04:22.124 --> 01:04:23.159
CONVERSATIONS WITH DAIRY

01:04:23.226 --> 01:04:24.293
FARMERS AND THEY SAY, YOU KNOW

01:04:24.360 --> 01:04:25.428
WHAT? HERE'S A BETTER WAY TO

01:04:25.494 --> 01:04:26.796
APPROACH THAT. AND SO THERE'S,

01:04:26.862 --> 01:04:28.397
THERE'S A LOT TO LEARN FROM

01:04:28.464 --> 01:04:29.999
PEOPLE WHO MANAGE THE LAND AND

01:04:30.066 --> 01:04:32.168
STEWARD THE LAND. TODAY, I'M

01:04:32.235 --> 01:04:34.303
GOING TO FOCUS ON ENTERIC FEED

01:04:34.370 --> 01:04:36.606
SUPPLEMENTS. WE'LL TALK A

01:04:36.672 --> 01:04:38.307
LITTLE BIT ABOUT RED SEAWEED AS

01:04:38.374 --> 01:04:40.743
A POTENTIAL SOLUTION TO

01:04:40.810 --> 01:04:44.447
REDUCING ENTERIC EMISSIONS. BUT

01:04:44.513 --> 01:04:46.182
BEYOND THAT, BEYOND COMPOSTING,

01:04:46.249 --> 01:04:47.283
BEYOND MANURE, SEPARATING.

01:04:47.350 --> 01:04:49.085
THERE'S ALSO INNOVATION TO BE

01:04:49.151 --> 01:04:50.853
HAD, PARTICULARLY ON SMALL AND

01:04:50.920 --> 01:04:53.055
MEDIUM SIZED DAIRIES WITH THE

01:04:53.122 --> 01:04:54.156
LAGOONS. THE LAGOONS ARE STILL

01:04:54.223 --> 01:04:55.558
A SOURCE OF EMISSIONS, AND

01:04:55.625 --> 01:04:57.360
THERE ARE A NUMBER OF SOLUTIONS,

01:04:57.426 --> 01:04:58.861
INCLUDING MICRO DIGESTERS THAT

01:04:58.928 --> 01:05:00.930
CAN SUPPORT REDUCTION OF

01:05:00.997 --> 01:05:03.466
METHANE EMISSIONS. WE'VE

01:05:03.532 --> 01:05:04.533
TOUCHED ON MANURE BASED

01:05:04.600 --> 01:05:06.302
COMPOSTING SYSTEMS. I WOULD SAY

01:05:06.369 --> 01:05:07.436
THOSE ARE ESSENTIAL, AND

01:05:07.503 --> 01:05:09.238
THEY'RE THE REALLY THE STARTING

01:05:09.305 --> 01:05:11.040
POINT FOR A CLIMATE JOURNEY FOR

01:05:11.107 --> 01:05:12.875
DAIRY FARMS. AND I SAY THAT

01:05:12.942 --> 01:05:14.977
BECAUSE THE CO-BENEFITS FOR THE

01:05:15.044 --> 01:05:16.045
FARMER, TREMENDOUS, WHETHER

01:05:16.112 --> 01:05:19.649
IT'S REPLACEMENT OF BEDDING OR

01:05:19.715 --> 01:05:21.817
PRODUCING MORE GRASS, MORE

01:05:21.884 --> 01:05:23.653
FORAGE ON THE FARM ITSELF BY

01:05:23.719 --> 01:05:25.454
GETTING THE BEST QUALITY

01:05:25.521 --> 01:05:26.555
NUTRIENTS THROUGH COMPOST ON

01:05:26.622 --> 01:05:29.725
THAT LAND. DOUG PROBABLY

01:05:29.792 --> 01:05:31.260
EXPERIENCES THIS, BUT OUR FARMS

01:05:31.327 --> 01:05:34.196
ARE ABLE TO FLIP THEIR FIELDS

01:05:34.263 --> 01:05:36.065
IN TERMS OF ANIMAL ROTATIONS

01:05:36.132 --> 01:05:38.768
AND CONSUMPTION OF GRASS 4 TO 6

01:05:38.834 --> 01:05:40.269
TIMES IN A SEASON. AND IF YOU

01:05:40.336 --> 01:05:42.705
LOOK AT NRCS STUDIES AND WHAT

01:05:42.772 --> 01:05:44.874
THEY SAY SHOULD BE POSSIBLE,

01:05:44.940 --> 01:05:47.743
THAT AMOUNT OF GRASS GROWTH FAR

01:05:47.810 --> 01:05:49.245
OUTWEIGHS WHAT SCIENTISTS HAVE

01:05:49.312 --> 01:05:51.013
SEEN AND OBSERVED, AND IT'S

01:05:51.080 --> 01:05:53.149
QUITE SOMETHING TO TAKE INTO

01:05:53.215 --> 01:05:54.250
ACCOUNT, ESPECIALLY WHEN YOU

01:05:54.317 --> 01:05:56.752
THINK ABOUT PHOTOSYNTHESIS AND

01:05:56.819 --> 01:05:58.921
CARBON SEQUESTRATION THROUGH

01:05:58.988 --> 01:06:00.356
FORAGES. WHEN YOU'RE GETTING

01:06:00.423 --> 01:06:02.525
TWO FEET OF GRASS GROWTH 4 TO 6

01:06:02.591 --> 01:06:04.694
TIMES A YEAR, THAT'S A LOT OF

01:06:04.760 --> 01:06:05.728
PHOTOSYNTHESIS. THAT'S A LOT OF

01:06:05.795 --> 01:06:06.962
CARBON SUGARS BEING DEPOSITED

01:06:07.029 --> 01:06:09.365
IN THE SOIL. AND FINALLY,

01:06:09.432 --> 01:06:10.466
INCENTIVES. SO STRAUS FAMILY

01:06:10.533 --> 01:06:11.901
CREAMERY, WE PAY OUR DAIRY

01:06:11.967 --> 01:06:14.036
FARMERS TO DO THIS WORK. IT

01:06:14.103 --> 01:06:15.671
SHOWS UP ON THEIR MILK CHECK ON

01:06:15.738 --> 01:06:18.374
A MONTHLY BASIS. WE ALSO HELP

01:06:18.441 --> 01:06:19.775
THEM GET RESOURCES FROM THE

01:06:19.842 --> 01:06:21.243
STATE AND FROM THE FEDS

01:06:21.310 --> 01:06:22.311
WHENEVER AVAILABLE AND WHENEVER

01:06:22.378 --> 01:06:26.282
IT MAKES SENSE. BUT WE FELT IT

01:06:26.349 --> 01:06:27.750
TO BE THE MOST RESPONSIBLE

01:06:27.817 --> 01:06:28.818
THING TO SAY. FARMERS, WE ARE

01:06:28.884 --> 01:06:30.619
GOING TO PAY YOU FOR DOING THIS

01:06:30.686 --> 01:06:32.755
IMPORTANT WORK FOR SOCIETY, FOR

01:06:32.822 --> 01:06:34.957
OUR COMMUNITIES. AND WE'RE NOT

01:06:35.024 --> 01:06:36.692
JUST GOING TO SAY, GO DO THIS.

01:06:36.759 --> 01:06:38.894
THIS IS THE GOAL. WE PARTNER

01:06:38.961 --> 01:06:40.730
WITH THEM BOTH FINANCIALLY AND

01:06:40.796 --> 01:06:42.098
ON AN INNOVATION BASIS TO

01:06:42.164 --> 01:06:45.000
ACHIEVE THIS WORK. METHANE

01:06:45.067 --> 01:06:46.836
REALLY IS THE BIG IMPACT ITEM.

01:06:46.902 --> 01:06:48.938
SO HERE IS A GHG EMISSION

01:06:49.004 --> 01:06:50.306
INVENTORY OF THE STRAUSS DAIRY

01:06:50.373 --> 01:06:51.807
FARM. THIS IS ALBERT STRAUSS

01:06:51.874 --> 01:06:53.642
FARM. AND IF YOU LOOK AT HIS

01:06:53.709 --> 01:06:56.846
BASELINE INVENTORY BACK IN 2000,

01:06:56.912 --> 01:06:59.048
BEFORE HE HAD AN ANAEROBIC

01:06:59.115 --> 01:07:01.183
DIGESTER IN PLACE, HE WAS

01:07:01.250 --> 01:07:03.719
EMITTING AROUND 2800 METRIC

01:07:03.786 --> 01:07:07.323
TONS OF CO2 PER YEAR. IF YOU

01:07:07.390 --> 01:07:09.859
TAKE OUT THE METHANE AT A 90%

01:07:09.925 --> 01:07:11.260
BASIS, BOTH FROM THE MANURE

01:07:11.327 --> 01:07:14.130
LAGOON THROUGH SEPARATION AND

01:07:14.196 --> 01:07:16.332
COMPOSTING AND THEN CAPTURING

01:07:16.399 --> 01:07:18.834
OF METHANE TO TO COMBUST IN A

01:07:18.901 --> 01:07:20.636
GENSET AND PRODUCE ON FARM

01:07:20.703 --> 01:07:22.438
ELECTRICITY, AND THEN ALSO

01:07:22.505 --> 01:07:24.240
USING RED SEAWEED AS A

01:07:24.306 --> 01:07:25.674
POTENTIAL SOURCE OF ENTERIC

01:07:25.741 --> 01:07:27.843
EMISSIONS. YOU CUT THAT IN OVER

01:07:27.910 --> 01:07:30.045
BY HALF RIGHT THERE. SO METHANE

01:07:30.112 --> 01:07:31.814
HAS THAT HUGE IMPACT. IN

01:07:31.881 --> 01:07:33.983
GENERAL, METHANE IS GOING TO BE

01:07:34.049 --> 01:07:37.186
60% OF THE EMISSIONS ON A

01:07:37.253 --> 01:07:40.756
PASTURE BASED DAIRY FARM.

01:07:40.823 --> 01:07:42.591
HERE'S A PICTURE OF THE STRAUSS

01:07:42.658 --> 01:07:43.859
DAIRY FARM IN THE FOREGROUND.

01:07:43.926 --> 01:07:45.861
YOU SEE THERE THE ONE OF THE

01:07:45.928 --> 01:07:47.997
TWO MANURE SEPARATORS. AND IN

01:07:48.063 --> 01:07:49.398
THE BACKGROUND, THAT THAT BIG

01:07:49.465 --> 01:07:51.967
WHITE BUBBLE IS THE ANAEROBIC

01:07:52.034 --> 01:07:53.135
DIGESTER CAPTURING METHANE FROM

01:07:53.202 --> 01:07:57.339
THE LAGOON, WHICH IS USED TO

01:07:57.406 --> 01:07:58.541
COMBUST THE BIOGAS AND THEN

01:07:58.607 --> 01:08:00.643
PRODUCE ON FARM ELECTRICITY. IT

01:08:00.709 --> 01:08:02.044
JUST SO HAPPENS, AND I'M NOT

01:08:02.111 --> 01:08:03.446
SURE IF THIS IS A COINCIDENCE

01:08:03.512 --> 01:08:06.148
OR A CLIMATE FATE, BUT IF ANY

01:08:06.215 --> 01:08:08.017
OF THESE DAIRY FARMS IN THIS

01:08:08.083 --> 01:08:09.151
REGION, IF THEY ARE CAPTURING

01:08:09.218 --> 01:08:10.352
THE METHANE FROM THEIR LAGOONS

01:08:10.419 --> 01:08:12.121
AND COMBUSTING IT ON FARM, IT'S

01:08:12.188 --> 01:08:13.189
JUST ABOUT COVERS ALL THE

01:08:13.255 --> 01:08:14.390
ELECTRICITY NEEDS THEY HAVE IN

01:08:14.457 --> 01:08:16.125
A GIVEN YEAR. I DON'T KNOW,

01:08:16.192 --> 01:08:17.626
IT'S A IT'S A CREATIVE BALANCE

01:08:17.693 --> 01:08:19.228
THAT NATURE HAS SET UP ON THESE

01:08:19.295 --> 01:08:21.497
FARMS. AND THIS IS A REALLY

01:08:21.564 --> 01:08:22.932
IMPORTANT SOLUTION FOR THE

01:08:22.998 --> 01:08:24.033
STRAUSS DAIRY FARM. BUT THIS

01:08:24.099 --> 01:08:26.168
DOES NOT WORK FOR EVERY PASTURE

01:08:26.235 --> 01:08:28.637
BASED DAIRY FARM. REALLY,

01:08:28.704 --> 01:08:30.139
THERE'S A TECHNOLOGY GAP. I'M

01:08:30.206 --> 01:08:31.574
NOT SURE IF I HAVE A SLIDE FOR

01:08:31.640 --> 01:08:33.375
THIS LATER, BUT THERE ARE

01:08:33.442 --> 01:08:34.643
ANAEROBIC DIGESTER SOLUTIONS

01:08:34.710 --> 01:08:36.912
FOR LARGER DAIRY FARMS. THE

01:08:36.979 --> 01:08:38.781
TECHNOLOGIES IN PARTICULAR THE

01:08:38.848 --> 01:08:40.950
THE COMBUSTION TECHNOLOGY, THE

01:08:41.016 --> 01:08:42.685
GENSET, THE ENGINE THAT COMBUST

01:08:42.751 --> 01:08:44.520
THE BIOGAS. THERE'S NOT A RIGHT

01:08:44.587 --> 01:08:46.322
SIZED MARKET AVAILABLE SOLUTION

01:08:46.388 --> 01:08:48.491
FOR FARMS IN THIS REGION. IF

01:08:48.557 --> 01:08:49.658
THERE WAS, I WOULD IMAGINE THAT

01:08:49.725 --> 01:08:51.694
THE COST OF THIS SOLUTION WOULD

01:08:51.760 --> 01:08:52.761
WOULD PLUMMET AND BECOME

01:08:52.828 --> 01:08:54.230
SOMETHING THAT FARMS WOULD

01:08:54.296 --> 01:08:55.664
CONSIDER AS AN INVESTMENT

01:08:55.731 --> 01:08:58.534
OPPORTUNITY. SO LET'S TALK

01:08:58.601 --> 01:09:01.437
ABOUT RED SEAWEED. IN 2021,

01:09:01.504 --> 01:09:02.872
STRAUSS DAIRY FARM DID AN ON

01:09:02.938 --> 01:09:04.640
FARM COMMERCIAL TRIAL OF RED

01:09:04.707 --> 01:09:07.343
SEAWEED. WE RECEIVED APPROVAL

01:09:07.409 --> 01:09:10.446
FROM THE USDA AND CDFA TO TO DO

01:09:10.513 --> 01:09:13.115
A 60 DAY TRIAL. THAT PICTURE

01:09:13.182 --> 01:09:14.617
THERE IN THE FOREGROUND IS SOME

01:09:14.683 --> 01:09:15.784
OF THE RED SEAWEED IN A BAG

01:09:15.851 --> 01:09:18.687
THAT WAS BEING ADDED TO THE MIX.

01:09:18.754 --> 01:09:21.924
REACTION FOR THE TRIAL. AND

01:09:21.991 --> 01:09:23.759
WHAT WE SAW DURING THAT 60 DAY

01:09:23.826 --> 01:09:25.327
PERIOD IS THAT SOME COWS HAD UP

01:09:25.394 --> 01:09:29.498
TO A 90% EMISSION REDUCTION IN

01:09:29.565 --> 01:09:31.300
ENTERIC METHANE EMISSIONS. IT

01:09:31.367 --> 01:09:32.835
WAS TREMENDOUS. IF YOU LOOK AT

01:09:32.902 --> 01:09:33.769
MARKET AVAILABLE SOLUTIONS,

01:09:33.836 --> 01:09:35.905
THEY TALK ABOUT 30%. THEY TALK

01:09:35.971 --> 01:09:38.741
ABOUT SUB 10%. THIS WAS A

01:09:38.807 --> 01:09:41.677
SOLUTION THAT HAS TREMENDOUS

01:09:41.744 --> 01:09:43.579
CAPABILITY. NOW, IN THAT TRIAL,

01:09:43.646 --> 01:09:45.247
WE WERE JUST USING DRIED

01:09:45.314 --> 01:09:47.516
SEAWEED. IT WAS HARVESTED FROM

01:09:47.583 --> 01:09:49.251
THE OCEAN NEAR THE AZORES

01:09:49.318 --> 01:09:51.754
ISLANDS, DRIED AND THEN FED TO

01:09:51.820 --> 01:09:53.956
COWS. SOME COWS DID NOT LIKE

01:09:54.023 --> 01:09:56.392
THE PUNGENT SMELL. OTHER COWS

01:09:56.458 --> 01:09:57.960
LOVED IT AND GRAVITATED TOWARDS

01:09:58.027 --> 01:10:00.729
IT. SO AS BLUISH AND BARNES HAS

01:10:00.796 --> 01:10:01.630
DEVELOPED THIS SOLUTION,

01:10:01.697 --> 01:10:03.232
THEY'RE ACTUALLY PRODUCING IT

01:10:03.299 --> 01:10:06.101
IN MEXICO AND AND SELLING IT TO

01:10:06.168 --> 01:10:09.038
DAIRY FARMS AND CATTLE FARMS IN

01:10:09.104 --> 01:10:11.974
MEXICO. BUT THIS SOLUTION, AT

01:10:12.041 --> 01:10:14.009
THE TIME, THEY WERE CONSIDERING

01:10:14.076 --> 01:10:16.679
MIXING IT WITH MOLASSES TO MAKE

01:10:16.745 --> 01:10:18.280
IT MORE PALATABLE FOR THE COWS

01:10:18.347 --> 01:10:20.516
THAT DIDN'T PREFER AN OCEAN

01:10:20.583 --> 01:10:22.384
BOUND FLAVOR PROFILE IN THEIR

01:10:22.451 --> 01:10:27.022
FEED MIX. AND SO WE SAW GREAT

01:10:27.089 --> 01:10:28.057
OPPORTUNITY THERE IN THAT

01:10:28.123 --> 01:10:30.392
PARTICULAR SOLUTION. RESEARCH

01:10:30.459 --> 01:10:32.995
ON THAT PARTICULAR RED SEAWEED

01:10:33.062 --> 01:10:34.930
HAS BEEN LED BY UC DAVIS DOCTOR

01:10:34.997 --> 01:10:37.466
ERMIAS. CURB HAS BEEN AN

01:10:37.533 --> 01:10:38.901
INTERNATIONAL LEADER IN LEADING

01:10:38.968 --> 01:10:41.003
THESE STUDIES. AND WHAT WE HAVE

01:10:41.070 --> 01:10:43.238
FOUND IS THAT LARGELY IS A

01:10:43.305 --> 01:10:45.341
GRASS SOLUTION. IN FACT, IT

01:10:45.407 --> 01:10:47.209
WASN'T THE BROMINE THAT WAS THE

01:10:47.276 --> 01:10:48.310
SCIENTIFIC CONCERN THROUGH THE

01:10:48.377 --> 01:10:50.045
TRIALS. IT WAS THE IODINE.

01:10:50.112 --> 01:10:51.513
THEY'VE CREATED A SOLVE FOR

01:10:51.580 --> 01:10:54.783
THAT IN THE PRODUCTION OF THIS

01:10:54.850 --> 01:10:55.851
MATERIAL. BUT WE CANNOT USE

01:10:55.918 --> 01:10:57.386
THIS MATERIAL TODAY. SO THE

01:10:57.453 --> 01:10:59.722
STATE OF CALIFORNIA HAD PUNTED

01:10:59.788 --> 01:11:01.223
APPROVAL OF THIS SUBSTANCE TO

01:11:01.290 --> 01:11:03.492
THE FDA. THE FDA DIDN'T REALLY

01:11:03.559 --> 01:11:05.494
KNOW HOW TO HANDLE A NON-DRUG

01:11:05.561 --> 01:11:07.696
NATURAL SUBSTANCE THAT

01:11:07.763 --> 01:11:09.498
NECESSARILY WASN'T A FEED. IT

01:11:09.565 --> 01:11:11.300
WASN'T A DRUG. IT WAS KIND OF

01:11:11.367 --> 01:11:13.102
THIS QUASI MIDDLE GROUND. I

01:11:13.168 --> 01:11:14.503
THINK THEY WANT TO CALL IT A

01:11:14.570 --> 01:11:15.938
SUPPLEMENT, KIND OF LIKE A

01:11:16.005 --> 01:11:18.807
VITAMIN. AND SO CONGRESS HAS

01:11:18.874 --> 01:11:20.643
ACTUALLY BEEN TRYING TO PASS

01:11:20.709 --> 01:11:23.512
LEGISLATION TO IMPROVE

01:11:23.579 --> 01:11:25.381
APPROVALS AT THE FDA FOR

01:11:25.447 --> 01:11:27.116
SUBSTANCES LIKE THIS. RIGHT NOW,

01:11:27.182 --> 01:11:29.618
THIS SUBSTANCE IS ON A DRUG

01:11:29.685 --> 01:11:31.186
APPROVAL TRACK FOR THE FDA,

01:11:31.253 --> 01:11:33.255
WHICH TAKES AROUND TEN YEARS.

01:11:33.322 --> 01:11:34.823
SO WE'RE JUST PATIENTLY WAITING

01:11:34.890 --> 01:11:36.125
FOR SOMETHING LIKE THIS TO

01:11:36.191 --> 01:11:37.559
BECOME AVAILABLE. BUT HERE'S

01:11:37.626 --> 01:11:39.361
SOME OBSERVATION I MADE. AND

01:11:39.428 --> 01:11:41.530
RENATA KIND OF KEYED IN ON THIS

01:11:41.597 --> 01:11:43.699
EARLIER. ANY PROGRAMS THAT THE

01:11:43.766 --> 01:11:45.501
STATE RECOMMENDS FOR FUTURE

01:11:45.567 --> 01:11:46.735
ENTERIC FEED SUPPLEMENTS SHOULD

01:11:46.802 --> 01:11:48.370
BE VOLUNTARY. FIRST AND

01:11:48.437 --> 01:11:49.772
FOREMOST, SHOULD BE BACKED BY

01:11:49.838 --> 01:11:52.374
THE ABSOLUTE BEST SCIENCE. IT

01:11:52.441 --> 01:11:55.277
SHOULD BE SAFE, RIGHT? IT

01:11:55.344 --> 01:11:56.512
SHOULD BE SAFE FOR THE ANIMALS.

01:11:56.578 --> 01:11:58.814
IT SHOULD BE SAFE FOR HUMANS,

01:11:58.881 --> 01:12:00.516
AND IT SHOULD BE SAFE FOR THE

01:12:00.582 --> 01:12:01.617
LAND. AND IT SHOULD BE A

01:12:01.684 --> 01:12:02.818
SOLUTION THAT DOESN'T ADD MORE

01:12:02.885 --> 01:12:04.553
CLIMATE IMPACT SOMEWHERE

01:12:04.620 --> 01:12:06.355
MILLIONS OF MILES AWAY. I

01:12:06.422 --> 01:12:08.157
REALLY AM A FAN OF NATURAL

01:12:08.223 --> 01:12:10.726
SOLUTIONS. ANY STATE LED

01:12:10.793 --> 01:12:12.094
PROGRAM SHOULD NOT BENEFIT A

01:12:12.161 --> 01:12:15.364
SINGULAR SOLUTION. MÀ MARKET

01:12:15.431 --> 01:12:16.432
MANIPULATION THROUGH STATE LED

01:12:16.498 --> 01:12:17.633
PROGRAMS IS A REAL THING, AND

01:12:17.700 --> 01:12:19.435
I'VE SEEN EXAMPLES OF IT OVER

01:12:19.501 --> 01:12:22.237
THE PAST DECADE. AND SO ANY

01:12:22.304 --> 01:12:24.339
STATE LED SOLUTION SHOULD

01:12:24.406 --> 01:12:26.208
BENEFIT MULTIPLE SOLUTIONS, AND

01:12:26.275 --> 01:12:27.576
IT SHOULD INCENTIVIZE FARMERS

01:12:27.643 --> 01:12:29.044
FOR PARTICIPATION. THERE ARE

01:12:29.111 --> 01:12:30.746
MANY GOOD WAYS TO DO THIS, AND

01:12:30.813 --> 01:12:32.681
THERE ARE MANY BAD WAYS TO DO

01:12:32.748 --> 01:12:33.982
IT. I THINK THE SIMPLEST WAY IS

01:12:34.049 --> 01:12:35.751
JUST TO SAY, HEY, FARMERS, IF

01:12:35.818 --> 01:12:37.352
YOU ARE BUYING AND USING THIS,

01:12:37.419 --> 01:12:38.754
WE'RE GOING TO PAY YOU FOR

01:12:38.821 --> 01:12:39.955
DOING IT. WE'RE GOING TO ASSUME

01:12:40.022 --> 01:12:41.824
THE EMISSIONS ARE A SET NUMBER

01:12:41.890 --> 01:12:43.692
AND WE'RE JUST GOING TO CALL IT

01:12:43.759 --> 01:12:44.860
A DAY FROM THERE. ANYTHING

01:12:44.927 --> 01:12:45.894
BEYOND THAT IS GOING TO BE

01:12:45.961 --> 01:12:47.062
PROBABLY OVERLY BURDENSOME ON

01:12:47.129 --> 01:12:48.130
FARMERS AND CREATE

01:12:48.197 --> 01:12:49.932
OPPORTUNITIES FOR MARKET

01:12:49.998 --> 01:12:51.333
PLAYERS TO TAKE THE BENEFIT

01:12:51.400 --> 01:12:53.035
FROM FARMERS FOR PARTICIPATING

01:12:53.102 --> 01:12:55.304
IN THIS EFFORT. AND THEN

01:12:55.370 --> 01:12:56.939
FINALLY, I THINK THE STATE CAN

01:12:57.005 --> 01:12:59.274
ACTUALLY LEAD IN CREATING A

01:12:59.341 --> 01:13:01.410
COMPETITIVE MARKET DYNAMIC SO

01:13:01.477 --> 01:13:03.245
THAT FARMERS DON'T BACK INTO

01:13:03.312 --> 01:13:05.414
INCENTIVE PRICING. I THINK I

01:13:05.481 --> 01:13:07.916
SAW THIS IN AMP AND THE DRIP

01:13:07.983 --> 01:13:11.153
PROGRAM, WHERE SUDDENLY ANY AMP

01:13:11.220 --> 01:13:12.488
PROJECT COSTED THREE QUARTERS

01:13:12.554 --> 01:13:14.423
OF $1 MILLION, WHETHER OR NOT

01:13:14.490 --> 01:13:16.058
THREE YEARS BEFORE AMP EXISTED,

01:13:16.125 --> 01:13:18.727
IT WAS A FRACTION OF THAT PRICE.

01:13:18.794 --> 01:13:20.529
SO IT'S IMPORTANT TO DO THE

01:13:20.596 --> 01:13:21.964
WORK BEFOREHAND TO IDENTIFY

01:13:22.030 --> 01:13:24.466
WHAT THE TRUE COST OF THESE

01:13:24.533 --> 01:13:28.771
SOLUTIONS ARE. AND I JUST WANT

01:13:28.837 --> 01:13:29.938
TO RETURN BACK TO THE LAND.

01:13:30.005 --> 01:13:31.306
CLIMATE ACTION ON PASTURE BASED

01:13:31.373 --> 01:13:32.775
ORGANIC DAIRY STARTS WITH THE

01:13:32.841 --> 01:13:34.176
LAND AGAIN. THE FARMS IN THIS

01:13:34.243 --> 01:13:36.345
REGION HAVE AMAZING LEVELS OF

01:13:36.411 --> 01:13:38.547
SOIL ORGANIC MATTER FAR BEYOND

01:13:38.614 --> 01:13:41.016
THE NATIONAL AVERAGE.

01:13:41.083 --> 01:13:42.818
HISTORICALLY, THEY HAVE STORED

01:13:42.885 --> 01:13:44.653
THOUSANDS OF TONS OF CARBON IN

01:13:44.720 --> 01:13:46.922
THESE LANDS IN THIS REGION AND

01:13:46.989 --> 01:13:48.190
ARE DOING A REALLY TREMENDOUS

01:13:48.257 --> 01:13:52.494
JOB. HERE'S JUST A PICTURE OF A

01:13:52.561 --> 01:13:53.996
WINDROW AT THE STRAUSS DAIRY

01:13:54.062 --> 01:13:55.798
FARM ON A CLOUDY DAY. JUST LIKE

01:13:55.864 --> 01:13:58.267
TODAY, THESE THESE PILES NEED

01:13:58.333 --> 01:13:59.468
TO BE TURNED IF THEY'RE NOT

01:13:59.535 --> 01:14:01.570
DONE MECHANICALLY THROUGH

01:14:01.637 --> 01:14:04.139
STABLE EQUIPMENT. BUT THIS

01:14:04.206 --> 01:14:05.707
COMPOST IS RETURNING NUTRIENTS

01:14:05.774 --> 01:14:07.309
AND BIOLOGY TO THE SOIL AND

01:14:07.376 --> 01:14:08.410
BUILDING TREMENDOUS AMOUNTS OF

01:14:08.477 --> 01:14:10.245
SOIL, ORGANIC MATTER AND SOIL

01:14:10.312 --> 01:14:12.614
CARBON. HERE'S A PICTURE OF

01:14:12.681 --> 01:14:14.249
THAT MANURE BEING SPREAD. WE'RE

01:14:14.316 --> 01:14:16.318
NOT TALKING ABOUT PILES OF

01:14:16.385 --> 01:14:18.153
MANURE ON PASTURE LAND. WE'RE

01:14:18.220 --> 01:14:19.955
TALKING ABOUT A QUARTER INCH, A

01:14:20.022 --> 01:14:21.723
HALF AN INCH EVERY FEW YEARS.

01:14:21.790 --> 01:14:23.492
THAT LEADS TO THIS TREMENDOUS

01:14:23.559 --> 01:14:25.994
BENEFIT. AND THE COWS PLAY A

01:14:26.061 --> 01:14:27.830
ROLE. COWS ARE THE REAL CLIMATE

01:14:27.896 --> 01:14:29.698
HEROES A LOT OF TIME. AND IF

01:14:29.765 --> 01:14:31.333
YOU GRAZE THEM APPROPRIATELY,

01:14:31.400 --> 01:14:32.868
IF YOU MOVE THEM AROUND WITH

01:14:32.935 --> 01:14:35.037
MOBILE ELECTRIC FENCING, OR

01:14:35.103 --> 01:14:36.839
HOPEFULLY IN THE FUTURE,

01:14:36.905 --> 01:14:39.007
VIRTUAL FENCING THROUGH COLLAR

01:14:39.074 --> 01:14:40.976
TECHNOLOGY, YOU CAN MAXIMIZE

01:14:41.043 --> 01:14:42.244
THE HEALTH OF THE LAND, THE

01:14:42.311 --> 01:14:43.345
HEALTH OF THE SOIL, THE

01:14:43.412 --> 01:14:45.147
REGROWTH OF THE GRASSES,

01:14:45.214 --> 01:14:46.949
PHOTOSYNTHESIS AND

01:14:47.015 --> 01:14:49.818
SEQUESTRATION POTENTIAL. HERE

01:14:49.885 --> 01:14:51.954
ARE MY STRATEGIES FOR SUCCESS.

01:14:52.020 --> 01:14:53.422
HELPING LEAD A BUSINESS AND

01:14:53.488 --> 01:14:54.189
PARTNERING WITH FARMERS ALONG

01:14:54.256 --> 01:14:57.726
THE WAY IS HAVE TIME BOUND

01:14:57.793 --> 01:14:59.828
ACTION AND HAVE GOALS THAT

01:14:59.895 --> 01:15:01.363
YOU'RE WORKING FORWARD TOGETHER

01:15:01.430 --> 01:15:03.131
WITH FARMERS, NOT AGAINST

01:15:03.198 --> 01:15:05.634
FARMERS. PAY FARMERS INCENTIVES

01:15:05.701 --> 01:15:08.170
FOR DOING PRACTICE BASED WORK.

01:15:08.237 --> 01:15:10.005
WE CAN TIE MEASUREMENT TO WORK,

01:15:10.072 --> 01:15:11.773
BUT IF YOU MAKE MEASUREMENT A

01:15:11.840 --> 01:15:13.208
REQUIREMENT, NOT AS MANY

01:15:13.275 --> 01:15:15.010
FARMERS WILL PARTICIPATE.

01:15:15.077 --> 01:15:16.111
CLIMATE MEASUREMENTS ARE

01:15:16.178 --> 01:15:17.846
COMPLICATED. AND SO I THINK

01:15:17.913 --> 01:15:18.680
PRACTICE BASED MEASUREMENTS ARE

01:15:18.747 --> 01:15:20.249
THE WAY TO GO. THAT'S WHAT

01:15:20.315 --> 01:15:21.316
STRAUSS IS DOING WITH OUR

01:15:21.383 --> 01:15:22.551
NETWORK OF FARMS, AND THEN

01:15:22.618 --> 01:15:23.986
PROVIDE AS MUCH SUPPORT AND

01:15:24.052 --> 01:15:25.354
COMMITMENT TO THE FARMS DOING

01:15:25.420 --> 01:15:26.855
THIS WORK AS POSSIBLE, HELP

01:15:26.922 --> 01:15:28.357
THEM INNOVATE, HELP BRING

01:15:28.423 --> 01:15:29.358
FUNDING TO THE TABLE, HELP

01:15:29.424 --> 01:15:32.261
BRING SOLUTIONS TO THE TABLE,

01:15:32.327 --> 01:15:34.429
AND HELP LAUD THEIR WORK. DOUG

01:15:34.496 --> 01:15:35.931
IS DOING INCREDIBLE WORK. IT'S

01:15:35.998 --> 01:15:37.633
SUCH AN HONOR TO BE AT THIS

01:15:37.699 --> 01:15:39.534
TABLE WITH HIM. AND SO I WANT

01:15:39.601 --> 01:15:40.702
TO THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME

01:15:40.769 --> 01:15:42.571
TODAY. I KEPT IT AS SHORT AS

01:15:42.638 --> 01:15:43.739
POSSIBLE, AND IT'S A REAL HONOR

01:15:43.805 --> 01:15:47.075
TO BE HERE. NÓ. I REALLY

01:15:47.142 --> 01:15:48.844
APPRECIATE IT, AND I'LL

01:15:48.911 --> 01:15:49.912
PROBABLY CUT SOME OF MY

01:15:49.978 --> 01:15:51.513
QUESTIONS SO THAT WE CAN CAN

01:15:51.580 --> 01:15:53.515
KEEP THINGS MOVING. BUT THIS

01:15:53.582 --> 01:15:56.051
REALLY WAS THE INTENT OF THIS

01:15:56.118 --> 01:15:57.152
SELECT COMMITTEE WHEN WE

01:15:57.219 --> 01:15:58.620
STARTED IT TWO YEARS AGO, WAS

01:15:58.687 --> 01:16:01.089
TO LOOK AT WHAT CLIMATE

01:16:01.156 --> 01:16:02.524
SOLUTIONS WERE STARTING TO

01:16:02.591 --> 01:16:03.659
EMERGE, BUT DIDN'T HAVE ENOUGH

01:16:03.725 --> 01:16:05.427
INVESTMENT FROM THE STATE OR

01:16:05.494 --> 01:16:06.828
FROM EMERGING MARKETS TO

01:16:06.895 --> 01:16:08.997
ACTUALLY MAKE THEM VIABLE YET,

01:16:09.064 --> 01:16:10.599
AND TO TRY TO HELP US TO INFORM

01:16:10.666 --> 01:16:12.634
OUR COLLEAGUES ON WHERE THAT

01:16:12.701 --> 01:16:14.036
INVESTMENT NEEDS TO GO. AND

01:16:14.102 --> 01:16:16.505
CERTAINLY, THE AMP PROGRAM, WE

01:16:16.571 --> 01:16:18.040
HELPED LEAD A LETTER ON THAT

01:16:18.106 --> 01:16:20.142
LAST YEAR WITH CECILIA

01:16:20.208 --> 01:16:22.311
AGUIAR-CURRY. I'M SURE WE'LL BE

01:16:22.377 --> 01:16:23.779
DOING THAT AGAIN THIS YEAR AS A

01:16:23.845 --> 01:16:26.248
AS A BUDGET REQUEST, ESPECIALLY

01:16:26.315 --> 01:16:27.950
WHEN YOU KIND OF LOOK AT THE

01:16:28.016 --> 01:16:29.885
TOP DOWN INVESTMENT, WHAT WE

01:16:29.952 --> 01:16:31.320
GET FROM THAT. AND TO YOUR

01:16:31.386 --> 01:16:32.721
POINT, RENATA, WHEN WE WERE

01:16:32.788 --> 01:16:34.122
TALKING ABOUT REAUTHORIZING THE

01:16:34.189 --> 01:16:35.657
CAP AND TRADE PROGRAM, IT

01:16:35.724 --> 01:16:37.092
BECAME VERY APPARENT THAT THE

01:16:37.159 --> 01:16:38.860
BEST BANG FOR OUR BUCK IN TERMS

01:16:38.927 --> 01:16:43.532
OF CARBON SEQUESTRATION, THE

01:16:43.598 --> 01:16:45.867
AMOUNT PER TON CAME FROM NATURE

01:16:45.934 --> 01:16:47.803
BASED SOLUTIONS. AND SO I KNOW

01:16:47.869 --> 01:16:48.904
WE'RE WE'RE DEFINITELY NOT DONE

01:16:48.971 --> 01:16:51.039
WITH THAT. I WANT TO KIND OF

01:16:51.106 --> 01:16:52.207
START WITH THE, THE RED SEAWEED

01:16:52.274 --> 01:16:53.375
FOR A MINUTE, BECAUSE WE

01:16:53.442 --> 01:16:54.743
ACTUALLY DID A COMMITTEE

01:16:54.810 --> 01:16:57.612
HEARING ABOUT A YEAR AGO WITH A

01:16:57.679 --> 01:16:59.414
SEAWEED AND KELP FARMER WHO WAS

01:16:59.481 --> 01:17:01.216
WALKING THROUGH WITH US, ALL OF

01:17:01.283 --> 01:17:02.818
THE DIFFERENT AGENCIES THAT HE

01:17:02.884 --> 01:17:04.619
HAD TO GO THROUGH FOR APPROVALS

01:17:04.686 --> 01:17:05.821
TO ACTUALLY BE ABLE TO OPERATE.

01:17:05.887 --> 01:17:07.022
AND I THINK IT WAS LIKE 14

01:17:07.089 --> 01:17:08.390
DIFFERENT AGENCIES BETWEEN THE

01:17:08.457 --> 01:17:09.858
STATE AND THE FEDERAL

01:17:09.925 --> 01:17:11.693
GOVERNMENT. AND SO YOU

01:17:11.760 --> 01:17:13.829
MENTIONED THE FDA REGULATORY

01:17:13.895 --> 01:17:15.163
PROCESS IS SLOW, COULD TAKE UP

01:17:15.230 --> 01:17:16.698
TO TEN YEARS. SO I GUESS ONE

01:17:16.765 --> 01:17:18.166
QUESTION IS, IS THERE ANYTHING

01:17:18.233 --> 01:17:20.168
THAT THE STATE CAN DO TO TRY TO

01:17:20.235 --> 01:17:21.336
HELP SPEED THAT UP? AND THEN

01:17:21.403 --> 01:17:23.605
THE SECOND IS, HOW CAN WE, FROM

01:17:23.672 --> 01:17:26.775
YOUR PERSPECTIVE, HELP WITH THE

01:17:26.842 --> 01:17:28.910
CREATING THE MARKET FOR THE RED

01:17:28.977 --> 01:17:30.012
SEAWEED SO THAT THERE'S

01:17:30.078 --> 01:17:31.780
ACTUALLY ENOUGH IN PRODUCTION

01:17:31.847 --> 01:17:33.715
TO BE ABLE TO BE A VIABLE

01:17:33.782 --> 01:17:35.417
OPTION FOR FARMERS TO, TO, TO

01:17:35.484 --> 01:17:36.852
SWITCH OVER IF THEY WOULD LIKE

01:17:36.918 --> 01:17:40.022
TO? YEAH, ABSOLUTELY. SO FIRST

01:17:40.088 --> 01:17:41.123
QUESTION, HOW CAN THE STATE

01:17:41.189 --> 01:17:45.093
HELP? IN THEORY, THE STATE

01:17:45.160 --> 01:17:46.261
COULD APPROVE THE SUBSTANCE ON

01:17:46.328 --> 01:17:48.363
THEIR OWN. THEY COULD AGREE

01:17:48.430 --> 01:17:49.531
WITH THE GRASS CONCLUSION AND

01:17:49.598 --> 01:17:52.667
SAY THIS IS A MARKETABLE FEED.

01:17:52.734 --> 01:17:53.869
OUTSIDE OF THAT, THE STATE

01:17:53.935 --> 01:17:56.638
COULD ADVOCATE WITH CONGRESS

01:17:56.705 --> 01:17:59.074
AND AT THE FDA TO SAY, THIS IS

01:17:59.141 --> 01:18:00.075
SOMETHING THAT'S IMPORTANT FOR

01:18:00.142 --> 01:18:01.376
THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA AND OUR

01:18:01.443 --> 01:18:03.078
DAIRY INDUSTRY, AND WE'D LIKE

01:18:03.145 --> 01:18:05.647
TO SEE THIS FAST TRACKED. THERE

01:18:05.714 --> 01:18:07.049
IS A BILL BEFORE CONGRESS, THAT

01:18:07.115 --> 01:18:08.884
INNOVATIVE FEED ACT, WHICH

01:18:08.950 --> 01:18:10.786
STRAUSS IS SUPPORTING TOWARDS

01:18:10.852 --> 01:18:13.121
THAT EFFORT. HOW DO WE BUILD

01:18:13.188 --> 01:18:15.023
THE MARKET? SECOND QUESTION.

01:18:15.090 --> 01:18:17.159
THIS THIS IS A COMPLICATED. YES.

01:18:17.225 --> 01:18:18.593
14 AGENCIES FOR APPROVAL. IT

01:18:18.660 --> 01:18:22.564
SOUNDS LIKE DAIRY FARMING. SO

01:18:22.631 --> 01:18:24.299
IT IS COMPLICATED. AND AT THE

01:18:24.366 --> 01:18:25.567
END OF THE DAY, I'M LOOKING FOR

01:18:25.634 --> 01:18:27.436
AN ORGANIC SOURCE. AND A LOT OF

01:18:27.502 --> 01:18:29.071
THESE COMPANIES ARE EMERGING. I

01:18:29.137 --> 01:18:30.305
THINK ONE OF THE CHALLENGES,

01:18:30.372 --> 01:18:31.573
THOUGH, IS BECAUSE THE UNITED

01:18:31.640 --> 01:18:32.974
STATES AND CALIFORNIA HAS BEEN

01:18:33.041 --> 01:18:34.776
SLOW TO APPROVE THESE

01:18:34.843 --> 01:18:36.945
SUBSTANCES. THEY'RE NOW BEING

01:18:37.012 --> 01:18:38.146
DEVELOPED FOR OTHER MARKETS

01:18:38.213 --> 01:18:39.881
AROUND THE WORLD AUSTRALIA, NEW

01:18:39.948 --> 01:18:42.350
ZEALAND, MEXICO. HOPEFULLY

01:18:42.417 --> 01:18:43.752
THOSE MARKETS DON'T STEAL THE

01:18:43.819 --> 01:18:46.655
SUPPLY THAT WE NEED. BUT WHAT

01:18:46.721 --> 01:18:48.457
I'VE SEEN IS IN THE BACKGROUND,

01:18:48.523 --> 01:18:49.958
THEY'RE WAITING FOR THIS MARKET

01:18:50.025 --> 01:18:51.726
TO EMERGE SO THAT THEY CAN

01:18:51.793 --> 01:18:53.128
SCALE. ONE OF THE QUESTIONS I

01:18:53.195 --> 01:18:55.330
RECEIVED OFTEN, OFTEN IS, WON'T

01:18:55.397 --> 01:18:56.965
THESE COST A LOT? AND IT'S OF

01:18:57.032 --> 01:18:58.166
COURSE, YEAH. AT THE BEGINNING

01:18:58.233 --> 01:19:00.702
OF THE ADOPTION CURVE THEY WILL.

01:19:00.769 --> 01:19:02.170
BUT HOW QUICKLY CAN WE SCALE

01:19:02.237 --> 01:19:03.705
THEM? HOW CAN WE HELP THAT

01:19:03.772 --> 01:19:05.140
TECHNOLOGY ADVANCE? AND I THINK

01:19:05.207 --> 01:19:06.842
IT'S PARTNERING WITH THOSE

01:19:06.908 --> 01:19:08.243
SUPPLIERS. THERE'S AT LEAST A

01:19:08.310 --> 01:19:09.311
HANDFUL THAT ARE DOING RED

01:19:09.377 --> 01:19:10.779
SEAWEED, AND THERE'S MANY OTHER

01:19:10.846 --> 01:19:12.514
WAYS TO PRODUCE IT. I'VE EVEN

01:19:12.581 --> 01:19:13.782
TALKED TO PRODUCERS IN INDIA

01:19:13.849 --> 01:19:16.651
WHO THINK IT COULD BE A WORK

01:19:16.718 --> 01:19:19.788
LIFE DEVELOPMENT JOB FOR

01:19:19.855 --> 01:19:20.856
IMPOVERISHED NEAR THE COAST OF

01:19:20.922 --> 01:19:21.957
INDIA. THEY CAN GROW THIS

01:19:22.023 --> 01:19:24.126
SUBSTANCE. SO I THINK FINDING

01:19:24.192 --> 01:19:26.294
THE VENDORS THAT ARE DOING IT,

01:19:26.361 --> 01:19:27.496
SEEING IF THERE ARE ANY GRANTS

01:19:27.562 --> 01:19:29.397
THAT WE CAN SUPPLY THEM TO HELP

01:19:29.464 --> 01:19:31.700
SCALE THEIR TECHNOLOGY, COULD

01:19:31.766 --> 01:19:33.368
BE VERY HELPFUL AS WE MOVE

01:19:33.435 --> 01:19:35.637
FORWARD ON THIS. AND AGAIN, NOT

01:19:35.704 --> 01:19:37.072
JUST ADVOCATING FOR ONE

01:19:37.139 --> 01:19:38.907
SOLUTION, BUT MANY IN A WHOLE

01:19:38.974 --> 01:19:40.742
MARKET, THERE WILL NEED TO BE A

01:19:40.809 --> 01:19:42.644
LOT OF SEAWEED. NOW, SEAWEED IS

01:19:42.711 --> 01:19:43.879
NOT NEW FOR THE DAIRY INDUSTRY.

01:19:43.945 --> 01:19:45.881
MANY FARMERS HAVE BEEN FEEDING

01:19:45.947 --> 01:19:48.617
KELP AS A AS A FEED SOURCE,

01:19:48.683 --> 01:19:49.651
PARTICULARLY FOR CALVES, FOR

01:19:49.718 --> 01:19:51.586
DECADES. WHAT'S DIFFERENT ABOUT

01:19:51.653 --> 01:19:53.255
THIS PARTICULAR VARIETY OF RED

01:19:53.321 --> 01:19:54.356
SEAWEED IS IT'S JUST VERY

01:19:54.422 --> 01:19:55.824
HIGHLY EFFECTIVE AT REDUCING

01:19:55.891 --> 01:19:58.360
ENTERIC EMISSIONS. UC DAVIS DID

01:19:58.426 --> 01:20:00.462
SOME STUDIES WITH MORE OF A

01:20:00.529 --> 01:20:01.963
STANDARD LOCALLY GROWN SEAWEED,

01:20:02.030 --> 01:20:03.732
AND IT CAN HAVE 20 TO 30%

01:20:03.798 --> 01:20:05.133
EMISSION REDUCTION. THAT'S

01:20:05.200 --> 01:20:07.035
NOTHING TO BAT YOUR EYES AT.

01:20:07.102 --> 01:20:08.803
BUT WHEN YOU'RE LOOKING AT A

01:20:08.870 --> 01:20:09.838
90% SOLUTION, THAT'S VERY

01:20:09.905 --> 01:20:11.306
EXCITING. I WOULD CALL THAT

01:20:11.373 --> 01:20:12.674
MATERIAL IN A GAME CHANGER FOR

01:20:12.741 --> 01:20:15.577
CLIMATE CHANGE. SO INASMUCH AS

01:20:15.644 --> 01:20:18.813
THE STATE CAN HELP ADVOCATE FOR

01:20:18.880 --> 01:20:20.315
REGULATORY PROCESS THAT

01:20:20.382 --> 01:20:22.851
QUICKENS, AND THEN DEVELOPING A

01:20:22.918 --> 01:20:23.852
SMART MARKET WHERE THESE

01:20:23.919 --> 01:20:26.788
MARKETS ARE GIVING FARMERS THE

01:20:26.855 --> 01:20:28.924
OPTION FOR A VERY LOW COST OR

01:20:28.990 --> 01:20:29.925
INCENTIVIZED, MAYBE LET'S JUST

01:20:29.991 --> 01:20:32.894
PAY THEM TO ADOPT THESE, THESE

01:20:32.961 --> 01:20:33.929
ENTERIC FEED SUPPLEMENTS. I

01:20:33.995 --> 01:20:35.397
THINK THAT WOULD HELP REALLY

01:20:35.463 --> 01:20:37.532
MOVE THE MARKETPLACE QUICKLY.

01:20:37.599 --> 01:20:41.136
YEAH. AND IN YOUR PILOT PROGRAM,

01:20:41.203 --> 01:20:42.704
DID YOU TRACK DATA ON HOW MUCH

01:20:42.771 --> 01:20:45.874
MORE EXPENSIVE THE FEED WAS

01:20:45.941 --> 01:20:47.976
USING THE RED SEAWEED? JUST AS

01:20:48.043 --> 01:20:50.145
TO YOUR POINT, AS THE MARKET

01:20:50.212 --> 01:20:51.613
EMERGES, THE PRICE SHOULD COME

01:20:51.680 --> 01:20:53.048
DOWN. BUT WHAT'S OUR KIND OF

01:20:53.114 --> 01:20:54.816
STARTING POINT RIGHT NOW? I

01:20:54.883 --> 01:20:56.985
HAVE NO IDEA. YEAH. SO THE

01:20:57.052 --> 01:21:00.222
SEAWEED WAS PROVIDED AT NO COST.

01:21:00.288 --> 01:21:01.323
ONE INTERESTING THING WITH

01:21:01.389 --> 01:21:03.858
SEAWEED IS IT COULD BE ALSO A

01:21:03.925 --> 01:21:05.994
MINERAL SUPPLEMENT REPLACEMENT.

01:21:06.061 --> 01:21:07.796
SO FARMERS FEED THEIR COWS

01:21:07.862 --> 01:21:10.332
MINERALS TODAY. SO PART OF

01:21:10.398 --> 01:21:11.466
SEAWEED IS YOU KNOW, IT ALSO

01:21:11.533 --> 01:21:13.335
HAS A LOT OF GOOD ESSENTIAL

01:21:13.401 --> 01:21:14.436
MINERALS IN IT. IT COULD

01:21:14.502 --> 01:21:15.570
REPLACE PART OF THOSE FEEDS,

01:21:15.637 --> 01:21:19.674
BUT IT'S TO BE DETERMINED. BUT

01:21:19.741 --> 01:21:21.109
WHAT WE WILL SEE IS THERE WILL

01:21:21.176 --> 01:21:22.844
BE A COST AND THEN WE'LL BE

01:21:22.911 --> 01:21:24.679
ABLE TO FIGURE OUT, OKAY, SO

01:21:24.746 --> 01:21:25.814
WHAT DOES THE INCENTIVE NEED TO

01:21:25.880 --> 01:21:27.983
BE? AND THEN THAT COST AS THESE

01:21:28.049 --> 01:21:29.017
SOLUTIONS SCALE WILL DECREASE

01:21:29.084 --> 01:21:30.852
OVER TIME. BUT TODAY I DON'T

01:21:30.919 --> 01:21:32.654
BELIEVE I HAVE A COST IN US

01:21:32.721 --> 01:21:34.789
DOLLARS. GOTCHA. AND THEN FOR

01:21:34.856 --> 01:21:36.491
DOUG AND RENATE, BOTH OF YOU

01:21:36.558 --> 01:21:39.094
KIND OF MENTIONED THE AMP

01:21:39.160 --> 01:21:41.763
PROCESS. I HEAR YOU ON NEEDING

01:21:41.830 --> 01:21:43.898
MONEY FOR IT, BUT EVEN OUTSIDE

01:21:43.965 --> 01:21:45.767
OF THAT, WHAT I HEARD WAS THE

01:21:45.834 --> 01:21:47.402
PROCESS WAS VERY DIFFICULT FOR

01:21:47.469 --> 01:21:49.904
SOMEBODY WHO WASN'T A BIG SCALE

01:21:49.971 --> 01:21:51.706
FARMER. AND I ALSO HEARD THAT

01:21:51.773 --> 01:21:53.508
THE DOLLARS AREN'T NECESSARILY

01:21:53.575 --> 01:21:56.378
TARGETED TOWARDS THE FARMS.

01:21:56.444 --> 01:21:58.213
THAT WOULD HAVE THE BIGGEST

01:21:58.280 --> 01:21:59.981
IMPACT IN TERMS OF REDUCTION.

01:22:00.048 --> 01:22:02.384
SO IF THE STATE WAS SUCCESSFUL

01:22:02.450 --> 01:22:04.653
IN FUNDING, DO YOU HAVE ANY

01:22:04.719 --> 01:22:05.754
RECOMMENDATIONS ON HOW TO MAKE

01:22:05.820 --> 01:22:08.356
IT EASIER FOR FOLKS WHO WOULD

01:22:08.423 --> 01:22:09.691
BE INTERESTED IN THIS, AND THEN

01:22:09.758 --> 01:22:11.493
ALSO TO MAKE THE PROGRAM MORE

01:22:11.559 --> 01:22:14.029
EFFECTIVE? I THINK FROM A

01:22:14.095 --> 01:22:17.632
FARMER'S PERSPECTIVE, THERE IS

01:22:17.699 --> 01:22:19.367
NOW THERE IS A PROVISION IN

01:22:19.434 --> 01:22:20.635
THERE. WHEN I FIRST GOT MINE,

01:22:20.702 --> 01:22:22.437
THERE WAS NO UPFRONT MONEY. SO

01:22:22.504 --> 01:22:24.839
I PRETTY MUCH BANKROLLED THE

01:22:24.906 --> 01:22:26.675
$600,000 PROJECT. THE WAY THE

01:22:26.741 --> 01:22:29.577
STATE, YOU KNOW, WE COULD

01:22:29.644 --> 01:22:31.313
SUBMIT OUR BILLS QUARTERLY AND

01:22:31.379 --> 01:22:33.148
THEN 6 TO 8 WEEKS, IT WAS PAID.

01:22:33.214 --> 01:22:34.549
ALL MY VENDORS WANTED MONEY

01:22:34.616 --> 01:22:36.017
WITHIN 30 DAYS. BUT NOW I

01:22:36.084 --> 01:22:38.186
BELIEVE THERE'S A 25% UPFRONT

01:22:38.253 --> 01:22:40.689
YOU CAN APPLY FOR. ALSO, I

01:22:40.755 --> 01:22:42.057
BELIEVE IT'S CHANGED A LITTLE

01:22:42.123 --> 01:22:43.925
BIT SINCE I DID IT. THERE IS

01:22:43.992 --> 01:22:45.226
MONEY THAT CAN BE PUT IN THERE

01:22:45.293 --> 01:22:47.595
FOR THE TECHNICAL SUPPORT AND

01:22:47.662 --> 01:22:49.531
THAT THAT HAS BEEN HUGE. AND I

01:22:49.597 --> 01:22:50.732
KNOW IT'S EVEN IN SOME OF THE

01:22:50.799 --> 01:22:52.600
OTHER GRANTS. SURE, IT ENDS UP

01:22:52.667 --> 01:22:53.802
TAKING AWAY FROM THE MONEY THAT

01:22:53.868 --> 01:22:55.603
THE FARMER MIGHT GET, BUT YOU

01:22:55.670 --> 01:22:57.605
KNOW, THAT TECHNICAL SUPPORT IS

01:22:57.672 --> 01:23:02.277
IS VERY HELPFUL. YEAH. DOUG

01:23:02.344 --> 01:23:03.712
SUFFERS FROM BEING AN EARLY

01:23:03.778 --> 01:23:06.481
ADOPTER. WHEN THE PROGRAM WAS

01:23:06.548 --> 01:23:08.416
STILL KIND OF GETTING ITS FEET.

01:23:08.483 --> 01:23:09.984
AND ONE, JUST TO PUT A POINT ON

01:23:10.051 --> 01:23:12.053
THAT LAST ONE ABOUT THE. TO

01:23:12.120 --> 01:23:14.356
HELP IT, CAL CAN ALSO SPONSORED

01:23:14.422 --> 01:23:16.324
A BILL AROUND THE SAME TIME AS

01:23:16.391 --> 01:23:17.759
THE AMP PROGRAM WENT INTO PLACE

01:23:17.826 --> 01:23:19.327
TO TAKE A PORTION OF THE

01:23:19.394 --> 01:23:20.395
CLIMATE SMART AG PROGRAM

01:23:20.462 --> 01:23:22.464
FUNDING 5% AND DEVOTE IT TO

01:23:22.530 --> 01:23:23.898
GRANTS FOR. TO PROVIDERS,

01:23:23.965 --> 01:23:25.700
TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE PROVIDERS,

01:23:25.767 --> 01:23:27.836
OFTEN SEEDS OR EXTENSION OR

01:23:27.902 --> 01:23:29.270
NONPROFITS. I DON'T THINK YOU

01:23:29.337 --> 01:23:30.839
WORKED WITH. RANDY WASN'T EVEN

01:23:30.905 --> 01:23:32.907
HERE IN THE COUNTY AT EXTENSION

01:23:32.974 --> 01:23:34.275
WHEN YOU APPLIED, RIGHT? NO,

01:23:34.342 --> 01:23:35.810
RANDY DID HELP ME. BUT IT WAS

01:23:35.877 --> 01:23:37.946
IT WAS ON YOU KNOW, IT WAS JUST

01:23:38.012 --> 01:23:40.081
HELP. WE DIDN'T HAVE TO PAY

01:23:40.148 --> 01:23:42.250
RANDY AT THAT TIME. YEAH, I,

01:23:42.317 --> 01:23:43.485
AND I THINK ONE OF THE OTHER

01:23:43.551 --> 01:23:45.353
THINGS I FORGOT TO MENTION ALSO

01:23:45.420 --> 01:23:46.421
IS, YOU KNOW, ONCE I'VE

01:23:46.488 --> 01:23:48.256
RECEIVED AN AMP GRANT, I CAN'T

01:23:48.323 --> 01:23:50.458
APPLY AGAIN. AND SO I, YOU KNOW,

01:23:50.525 --> 01:23:51.960
I KNOW THERE'S A LOT OF THAT'S

01:23:52.026 --> 01:23:53.762
BECAUSE OF THE MONEY, BUT WHEN

01:23:53.828 --> 01:23:55.563
YOU START MAKING THESE CHANGES

01:23:55.630 --> 01:23:57.065
TO YOUR BUSINESS, THERE'S ALL

01:23:57.132 --> 01:23:58.433
THESE OTHER THINGS THAT COME

01:23:58.500 --> 01:24:00.602
ALONG, YOU KNOW, EQUIPMENT

01:24:00.668 --> 01:24:02.036
NEEDED DOWN THE ROAD TO TURN

01:24:02.103 --> 01:24:03.138
COMPOST AND THINGS LIKE THAT,

01:24:03.204 --> 01:24:04.706
THAT, YOU KNOW, AS YOU MADE

01:24:04.773 --> 01:24:06.007
THIS HUGE CHANGE TO YOUR, YOUR

01:24:06.074 --> 01:24:07.809
BUSINESS MODEL, NOW YOU HAVE TO

01:24:07.876 --> 01:24:09.244
GO OUT AND START, YOU KNOW,

01:24:09.310 --> 01:24:10.745
PURCHASING THOSE THINGS. SO I

01:24:10.812 --> 01:24:11.946
THINK IT WOULD BE HELPFUL IF

01:24:12.013 --> 01:24:13.915
THE, YOU KNOW, THERE WAS A, THE

01:24:13.982 --> 01:24:15.884
ABILITY FOR, YOU KNOW, FUNDERS

01:24:15.950 --> 01:24:21.156
TO BE ABLE TO REAPPLY. AS FAR

01:24:21.222 --> 01:24:23.291
AS IMPROVING THE PROGRAMS ARE

01:24:23.358 --> 01:24:24.726
ALL BEING CONTINUALLY IMPROVED.

01:24:24.793 --> 01:24:26.494
THE CDFA IS, YOU KNOW,

01:24:26.561 --> 01:24:27.996
CONTINUES TO TRY TO FIGURE OUT

01:24:28.062 --> 01:24:29.097
HOW TO MAKE THEM MORE

01:24:29.164 --> 01:24:30.165
ACCESSIBLE, HOW TO MAKE THEM

01:24:30.231 --> 01:24:31.533
MORE EFFECTIVE. THE HEALTHY

01:24:31.599 --> 01:24:33.301
SOILS PROGRAM, THERE'S A SWEET

01:24:33.368 --> 01:24:35.036
PROGRAM FOR WATER CONSERVATION.

01:24:35.103 --> 01:24:36.971
AND THEN THE AMP PROGRAM. I

01:24:37.038 --> 01:24:39.140
THINK THE POINT WE'RE AT, WE

01:24:39.207 --> 01:24:40.608
WOULD AT CAL CAN WE WOULD SAY

01:24:40.675 --> 01:24:42.210
WHAT NEEDS TO HAPPEN NEXT IS

01:24:42.277 --> 01:24:44.145
THAT THE AIR RESOURCES BOARD

01:24:44.212 --> 01:24:47.415
HAS THE AUTHORITY TO REEVALUATE

01:24:47.482 --> 01:24:50.985
HOW IT QUANTIFIES THE THE

01:24:51.052 --> 01:24:52.854
PROJECTS AND COULD MAKE SOME

01:24:52.921 --> 01:24:54.322
RECOMMENDATIONS ABOUT, OR AT

01:24:54.389 --> 01:24:56.124
LEAST AT LEAST SORT OF PUBLISH

01:24:56.191 --> 01:24:58.259
SOME DATA THAT AFFIRMS WHAT WE

01:24:58.326 --> 01:24:59.694
FOUND. YOU KNOW, THAT THAT

01:24:59.761 --> 01:25:00.762
THERE IS THIS SORT OF

01:25:00.829 --> 01:25:01.496
DIFFERENTIAL BETWEEN THE

01:25:01.563 --> 01:25:03.298
DIFFERENT KINDS OF PROJECTS. SO

01:25:03.364 --> 01:25:06.000
I THINK WE NEED SOME VALIDATION

01:25:06.067 --> 01:25:07.969
OF WHAT WE WHAT WE FOUND.

01:25:08.036 --> 01:25:09.737
OFFICIAL VALIDATION AND A

01:25:09.804 --> 01:25:10.505
CONVERSATION WITH THE AIR

01:25:10.572 --> 01:25:11.940
RESOURCES BOARD. WHETHER

01:25:12.006 --> 01:25:13.007
THERE'S A ROLE FOR THE

01:25:13.074 --> 01:25:14.576
LEGISLATURE IN THAT OR NOT, I

01:25:14.642 --> 01:25:16.611
GUESS, REMAINS TO BE SEEN. IT'S

01:25:16.678 --> 01:25:18.413
CURRENTLY TECHNICALLY, YOU KNOW,

01:25:18.480 --> 01:25:19.747
SOMETHING THEY COULD DO, BUT

01:25:19.814 --> 01:25:20.849
THEY MAY NEED SOME SOME

01:25:20.915 --> 01:25:21.916
ENCOURAGEMENT TO DO THAT. OR

01:25:21.983 --> 01:25:24.886
THERE MAY BE SOME CON, YOU KNOW,

01:25:24.953 --> 01:25:25.553
NECESSARY LEGISLATION THAT

01:25:25.620 --> 01:25:27.222
COMES OUT OF THAT IF DEPENDING

01:25:27.288 --> 01:25:28.556
ON WHAT WHAT'S NEEDED FOR, FOR

01:25:28.623 --> 01:25:30.225
THEM TO HAVE THE SORT OF

01:25:30.291 --> 01:25:31.726
AUTHORITY TO, TO, TO SHIFT

01:25:31.793 --> 01:25:34.229
ANYTHING. I MEAN, THE VERY

01:25:34.295 --> 01:25:35.630
SINGLE MOST IMPORTANT THING

01:25:35.697 --> 01:25:38.199
WOULD BE TO, I THINK, LOOK AT

01:25:38.266 --> 01:25:40.401
HOW LONG THESE TECHNOLOGIES ARE

01:25:40.468 --> 01:25:41.536
LASTING AND NOT JUST SORT OF

01:25:41.603 --> 01:25:42.904
RELY ON ANECDOTAL, ANECDOTAL

01:25:42.971 --> 01:25:44.339
EVIDENCE ABOUT THAT. THAT'S

01:25:44.405 --> 01:25:45.740
THAT'S A GAME CHANGER. IF IT'S

01:25:45.807 --> 01:25:47.242
REALLY TEN YEARS, WE'VE HAD TEN

01:25:47.308 --> 01:25:48.943
YEARS OF HISTORY, WE COULD GO

01:25:49.010 --> 01:25:50.111
BACK TO THOSE FIRST COUPLE OF

01:25:50.178 --> 01:25:51.145
GRANT ROUNDS AND SEE HOW

01:25:51.212 --> 01:25:52.614
THEY'RE DOING. THAT WOULD

01:25:52.680 --> 01:25:54.782
REALLY, I THINK, SHIFT THE AT

01:25:54.849 --> 01:25:57.652
LEAST THE MESSAGING AROUND HOW

01:25:57.719 --> 01:26:00.889
POWERFUL THE PROGRAM IS. NOW, I

01:26:00.955 --> 01:26:01.990
REALLY APPRECIATE THAT. AND

01:26:02.056 --> 01:26:03.391
THEN BOTH JOSEPH AND DOUG

01:26:03.458 --> 01:26:05.226
MENTIONED AT DIFFERENT TIMES

01:26:05.293 --> 01:26:08.530
THE COST OF ENERGY. AND ONE

01:26:08.596 --> 01:26:10.131
THING THAT I'D BE INTERESTED IN,

01:26:10.198 --> 01:26:11.299
AND PROBABLY WE DON'T NEED TO

01:26:11.366 --> 01:26:13.234
GET TOO DEEP INTO IT RIGHT NOW,

01:26:13.301 --> 01:26:15.203
BUT IF EITHER OF YOU DO END UP

01:26:15.270 --> 01:26:16.304
HAVING ANY ANALYZES OR THINGS

01:26:16.371 --> 01:26:18.139
THAT THINGS THAT WE CAN SHARE

01:26:18.206 --> 01:26:19.207
WITH OUR COLLEAGUES ABOUT HOW

01:26:19.274 --> 01:26:21.809
THIS WAS ALSO REDUCE YOUR

01:26:21.876 --> 01:26:23.144
ENERGY COSTS, WHICH IS WHAT IT

01:26:23.211 --> 01:26:24.646
SOUNDED LIKE IT DID WITHOUT ALL

01:26:24.712 --> 01:26:27.148
OF THE DIESEL. THAT'S ANOTHER

01:26:27.215 --> 01:26:28.883
COMPELLING ARGUMENT TO BE MADE

01:26:28.950 --> 01:26:29.851
ABOUT MAKING THIS INVESTMENT

01:26:29.918 --> 01:26:32.921
FROM A STATE PERSPECTIVE. YEAH,

01:26:32.987 --> 01:26:35.056
THE COST OF ENERGY IS INSANE.

01:26:35.123 --> 01:26:38.326
SO ONE OF MY FARMS TALKS TO ME

01:26:38.393 --> 01:26:39.761
ABOUT IT OFTEN $0.50 PER

01:26:39.827 --> 01:26:42.163
KILOWATT HOUR OVER DOUBLE WHAT

01:26:42.230 --> 01:26:43.665
THEY WERE PAYING A DECADE AGO.

01:26:43.731 --> 01:26:46.935
AND SO THE ABILITY TO PRODUCE

01:26:47.001 --> 01:26:48.736
ON FARM ELECTRICITY COULD BE

01:26:48.803 --> 01:26:50.171
INCREDIBLE. BUT AGAIN, THE

01:26:50.238 --> 01:26:52.340
MICRO DIGESTER SOLUTION, I

01:26:52.407 --> 01:26:53.808
DON'T FEEL COMFORTABLE

01:26:53.875 --> 01:26:55.209
ADVOCATING IT. ASKING OUR

01:26:55.276 --> 01:26:56.444
FARMERS OUTSIDE OF THE DAIRY

01:26:56.511 --> 01:26:58.479
FARM TO ADOPT IT TODAY, BECAUSE

01:26:58.546 --> 01:26:59.948
THE COST DOESN'T MEET THE

01:27:00.014 --> 01:27:01.015
BENEFIT. THE PAYBACK IS JUST

01:27:01.082 --> 01:27:03.217
NOT THERE. THAT'S WHERE I'D

01:27:03.284 --> 01:27:05.653
LOVE TO SEE THE STATE HELP WITH

01:27:05.720 --> 01:27:08.890
TECHNOLOGY INNOVATION. THERE'S

01:27:08.957 --> 01:27:11.526
JUST NOT A CHEN SET BIOGAS CHEN

01:27:11.593 --> 01:27:13.695
SET THAT WORKS. AND BECAUSE OF

01:27:13.761 --> 01:27:15.029
THAT, THE COST OF THESE

01:27:15.096 --> 01:27:18.266
PROJECTS IS WELL OVER 3 MILLION.

01:27:18.333 --> 01:27:20.268
JUST IF YOU WERE TO BUY ONE OFF

01:27:20.335 --> 01:27:21.502
THE SHELF, WHAT WE NEED THEM TO

01:27:21.569 --> 01:27:24.372
COST TO WORK FOR THE MANY OVER

01:27:24.439 --> 01:27:25.840
100 FARMS IN THE IN THE STATE

01:27:25.907 --> 01:27:28.743
OF CALIFORNIA THAT AREN'T OF

01:27:28.810 --> 01:27:29.877
TRADITIONAL SCALE, THAT MAKES

01:27:29.944 --> 01:27:33.548
IT WORK IS A PROBABLY A 500,000

01:27:33.615 --> 01:27:35.917
TO $1 MILLION SOLUTION. I CAN I

01:27:35.984 --> 01:27:37.151
CAN HELP PROVIDE MORE DETAILS

01:27:37.218 --> 01:27:39.220
ON THAT. BUT THE KEY THING IS

01:27:39.287 --> 01:27:40.655
THAT TECHNOLOGY INNOVATION ON

01:27:40.722 --> 01:27:42.390
THE CHEN SET. AND THEN, YEAH,

01:27:42.457 --> 01:27:44.258
WE COULD HAVE OFF SITE OR ON

01:27:44.325 --> 01:27:46.327
SITE ELECTRICITY OFFSETTING

01:27:46.394 --> 01:27:47.795
COSTS, WHICH WOULD BE IMPORTANT

01:27:47.862 --> 01:27:49.964
AND ALSO RELIABILITY FOR THE

01:27:50.031 --> 01:27:51.633
GRID. I MEAN, WE'RE LOOKING AT

01:27:51.699 --> 01:27:52.467
BATTERY OPPORTUNITIES WITH

01:27:52.533 --> 01:27:54.002
SONOMA CLEAN POWER AND MARIN

01:27:54.068 --> 01:27:56.871
CLEAN ENERGY. ODDLY ENOUGH, THE

01:27:56.938 --> 01:27:58.640
DAIRY FARMERS COULD BE A SOURCE

01:27:58.706 --> 01:28:00.041
OF ENERGY RELIABILITY FOR THE

01:28:00.108 --> 01:28:01.476
RURAL COMMUNITIES IN WESTERN

01:28:01.542 --> 01:28:04.712
MARIN AND SONOMA COUNTY. I

01:28:04.779 --> 01:28:06.180
THINK WHEN YOU TALK ABOUT, YOU

01:28:06.247 --> 01:28:07.715
KNOW, REDUCTION IN ENERGY FOR

01:28:07.782 --> 01:28:09.684
MY FARM, IT THERE WAS NO THERE

01:28:09.751 --> 01:28:11.185
WAS ACTUALLY PROBABLY AN

01:28:11.252 --> 01:28:12.086
EXCEEDANCE BECAUSE I HAD TO PUT.

01:28:12.153 --> 01:28:13.855
I PUT MORE ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT

01:28:13.921 --> 01:28:16.591
IN. SO I SAVED ON MY DIESEL.

01:28:16.658 --> 01:28:18.092
YOU KNOW, WE WENT AHEAD AND WE,

01:28:18.159 --> 01:28:20.561
WE PUT IN A 100 KILOWATT SOLAR

01:28:20.628 --> 01:28:21.963
SYSTEM ON OUR OWN DOLLAR TO

01:28:22.030 --> 01:28:24.532
COVER ABOUT 90% OF OUR

01:28:24.599 --> 01:28:26.334
ELECTRICITY. YOU KNOW WHAT

01:28:26.401 --> 01:28:28.102
WE'VE HEARD FROM THE LARGER

01:28:28.169 --> 01:28:29.203
DAIRIES THAT HAVE PUT DIGESTERS

01:28:29.270 --> 01:28:31.005
IN? IF IT WASN'T FOR LCFF

01:28:31.072 --> 01:28:32.473
CREDITS, THOSE DIGESTERS

01:28:32.540 --> 01:28:33.508
WOULDN'T BE RUNNING. THEY CAN'T

01:28:33.574 --> 01:28:34.609
AFFORD TO KEEP THEM RUNNING.

01:28:34.676 --> 01:28:36.177
AND, YOU KNOW, YOU HAVE TO

01:28:36.244 --> 01:28:37.311
THINK ABOUT IN THE CENTRAL

01:28:37.378 --> 01:28:39.180
VALLEY HOW A LOT OF THE THE

01:28:39.247 --> 01:28:40.381
LARGE SCALE GAS COMPANIES HAVE

01:28:40.448 --> 01:28:41.349
GONE IN AND BUILT THE

01:28:41.416 --> 01:28:42.283
INFRASTRUCTURE FOR THOSE

01:28:42.350 --> 01:28:44.185
DAIRIES TO, TO SHIP THE GAS TO

01:28:44.252 --> 01:28:45.319
THEM AND THEY'RE CLEANING IT

01:28:45.386 --> 01:28:47.121
AND THEN TURNING IT IN, TURN

01:28:47.188 --> 01:28:48.656
AROUND AND SELLING IT WITH THE

01:28:48.723 --> 01:28:49.691
LANDSCAPE HERE IN SONOMA, MARIN

01:28:49.757 --> 01:28:51.125
COUNTY, THAT'S NOT GOING TO

01:28:51.192 --> 01:28:52.593
HAPPEN. SO AS AS YOU KNOW,

01:28:52.660 --> 01:28:54.228
JOSEPH SAID, I THINK IT'S GOING

01:28:54.295 --> 01:28:55.463
TO HAVE TO BE THAT PIECE OF

01:28:55.530 --> 01:28:57.231
EQUIPMENT THAT RUNS THE FARM.

01:28:57.298 --> 01:28:58.433
IT'S NOT LIKE WE'RE GOING TO BE

01:28:58.499 --> 01:29:00.401
ABLE TO SEND IT DOWN THE ROAD.

01:29:00.468 --> 01:29:02.303
YOU KNOW, I MEAN, EVEN IF YOU

01:29:02.370 --> 01:29:03.538
LOOK AT, YOU KNOW, FROM WHERE

01:29:03.604 --> 01:29:06.007
YOUR YOUR EXPERIENCE FROM CITY

01:29:06.074 --> 01:29:08.076
OF SANTA ROSA AND THEIR METHANE,

01:29:08.142 --> 01:29:09.544
YOU KNOW, THEY HAVE A GENERATOR,

01:29:09.610 --> 01:29:10.945
THEY, THEY, THEY'RE DOING ALL

01:29:11.012 --> 01:29:12.046
THAT THEIR SEWER PLANT. AND,

01:29:12.113 --> 01:29:13.481
YOU KNOW, I'M NOT SURE IT'S

01:29:13.548 --> 01:29:14.582
ACTUALLY PRODUCING WHAT YOU

01:29:14.649 --> 01:29:16.050
PROBABLY THOUGHT IT WOULD. SO,

01:29:16.117 --> 01:29:17.985
YOU KNOW, IT'S GOING TO BE FARM

01:29:18.052 --> 01:29:20.688
BY FARM IF WE CAN FIND. AND

01:29:20.755 --> 01:29:22.156
EVERYBODY WE'VE TALKED TO THAT,

01:29:22.223 --> 01:29:25.026
THAT SOLUTION IS JUST NOT THERE.

01:29:25.093 --> 01:29:26.027
WELL, THAT'S REALLY HELPFUL.

01:29:26.094 --> 01:29:29.063
AND I APPRECIATE THAT. AND AS

01:29:29.130 --> 01:29:30.998
MUCH AS I'D LIKE TO KEEP GOING

01:29:31.065 --> 01:29:32.200
A LITTLE DEEPER, WE DO HAVE TO

01:29:32.266 --> 01:29:34.202
MOVE ON TO OUR NEXT PANEL. BUT

01:29:34.268 --> 01:29:36.170
I DO WANT TO THANK THE THREE OF

01:29:36.237 --> 01:29:37.972
YOU FOR TAKING THE TIME THIS

01:29:38.039 --> 01:29:39.107
MORNING TO COME IN TO TALK

01:29:39.173 --> 01:29:40.308
ABOUT THESE THINGS. AND, DOUG,

01:29:40.374 --> 01:29:41.976
I HAVE APPRECIATED BEING ABLE

01:29:42.043 --> 01:29:43.978
TO COME OUT TO YOUR YOUR FARM A

01:29:44.045 --> 01:29:45.213
COUPLE OF TIMES TO ACTUALLY SEE

01:29:45.279 --> 01:29:46.981
THE WORK. AND WE'LL CONTINUE TO,

01:29:47.048 --> 01:29:48.182
TO HIGHLIGHT IT AND PROMOTE IT.

01:29:48.249 --> 01:29:50.084
SO THANK YOU. THANK YOU SO MUCH.

01:29:50.151 --> 01:29:51.185
YEAH. OUR SECOND PANEL IS ON

01:29:51.252 --> 01:29:52.386
CARBON CAPTURE IN CALIFORNIA'S

01:29:52.453 --> 01:29:53.988
CRAFT BREWERIES. WE'RE GOING TO

01:29:54.055 --> 01:29:56.324
BRING UP TWO, TWO SPEAKERS.

01:29:56.390 --> 01:29:57.391
NATALIE CILURZO, WHO'S THE

01:29:57.458 --> 01:29:58.826
RUSSIAN RIVER BREWING COMPANY

01:29:58.893 --> 01:30:00.261
CO-OWNER AND PRESIDENT, AND

01:30:00.328 --> 01:30:01.763
KELSEY MCQUADE CRAIG, WHO IS

01:30:01.829 --> 01:30:03.531
THE CALIFORNIA CRAFT BREWERS

01:30:03.598 --> 01:30:09.303
ASSOCIATION EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR.

01:30:09.370 --> 01:30:10.438
AND I THINK, NATALIE, I THINK

01:30:10.505 --> 01:30:12.306
YOU'RE GOING TO KICK US OFF,

01:30:12.373 --> 01:30:21.883
RIGHT? SURE. AND I ALWAYS LOVE

01:30:21.949 --> 01:30:23.284
GETTING NEW REASONS TO GO AND

01:30:23.351 --> 01:30:30.525
DRINK. BLIND PIG IS MY MY GO TO.

01:30:30.591 --> 01:30:31.726
YOU KNOW, I THINK IT WOULD GO

01:30:31.793 --> 01:30:34.128
WELL WITH THE MANURE. YEAH,

01:30:34.195 --> 01:30:35.897
YEAH. ACTUALLY, I DO HAVE SOME

01:30:35.963 --> 01:30:38.132
PARALLELS IN MY PRESENTATION

01:30:38.199 --> 01:30:39.801
TODAY TO FOLLOW UP WITH THE ONE

01:30:39.867 --> 01:30:41.035
WE JUST HAD, WHICH WAS REALLY

01:30:41.102 --> 01:30:42.804
GREAT, BY THE WAY, THAT WAS

01:30:42.870 --> 01:30:43.938
VERY INTERESTING. I TOOK A LOT

01:30:44.005 --> 01:30:45.139
OF NOTES. GOOD MORNING. THANK

01:30:45.206 --> 01:30:46.407
YOU, ASSEMBLY MEMBER ROGERS,

01:30:46.474 --> 01:30:47.875
FOR HAVING US THIS MORNING TO

01:30:47.942 --> 01:30:49.577
TALK ABOUT CO2 RECOVERY IN THE

01:30:49.644 --> 01:30:50.311
BREWERY. AND THANK YOU,

01:30:50.378 --> 01:30:52.246
MEREDITH AND LOGAN, FOR PUTTING

01:30:52.313 --> 01:30:53.915
ALL OF THIS TOGETHER. WE'RE

01:30:53.981 --> 01:30:56.083
EXCITED TO BE HERE. AND THANK

01:30:56.150 --> 01:30:57.718
YOU TO KELSEY AND CHRIS WALKER

01:30:57.785 --> 01:30:58.920
FOR DRIVING OVER FROM

01:30:58.986 --> 01:31:01.823
SACRAMENTO. SO I AM NATALIE

01:31:01.889 --> 01:31:03.724
CILURZO. I'M THE CO-OWNER WITH

01:31:03.791 --> 01:31:05.960
MY HUSBAND, VINNIE FROM RUSSIAN

01:31:06.027 --> 01:31:07.228
RIVER BREWING COMPANY. WE'VE

01:31:07.295 --> 01:31:09.030
BEEN HERE IN SONOMA COUNTY

01:31:09.096 --> 01:31:12.266
SINCE 1997, BEEN UNDER OUR

01:31:12.333 --> 01:31:14.869
OWNERSHIP SINCE 2003. AND I'M

01:31:14.936 --> 01:31:16.904
HERE TO TALK TO YOU ABOUT CO2

01:31:16.971 --> 01:31:22.476
RECOVERY IN THE BREWERY. SO IN

01:31:22.543 --> 01:31:25.079
THE BREWING INDUSTRY, WE USE

01:31:25.146 --> 01:31:29.450
CO2 IN MULTIPLE WAYS. WE PURGE

01:31:29.517 --> 01:31:32.320
TANKS OF AIR WITH CO2. SO

01:31:32.386 --> 01:31:34.088
OXYGEN IS THE ENEMY OF BEER. IT

01:31:34.155 --> 01:31:36.624
IS. IT IS AN OXIDIZER. AND

01:31:36.691 --> 01:31:38.426
NOBODY LIKES TO DRINK OXIDIZED

01:31:38.492 --> 01:31:39.861
BEER. SO WE'RE ALWAYS CHASING

01:31:39.927 --> 01:31:41.629
OXYGEN IN OUR BEER. AND ONE OF

01:31:41.696 --> 01:31:44.198
THE WAYS WE DO THAT IS WITH CO2.

01:31:44.265 --> 01:31:46.367
WE ALSO USE CO2 TO PURGE KEGS,

01:31:46.434 --> 01:31:48.169
BOTTLES AND CANS. PRIOR TO

01:31:48.236 --> 01:31:49.604
FILLING WITH OUR FINISHED

01:31:49.670 --> 01:31:51.739
PRODUCTS. AND CO2 IS OFTEN

01:31:51.806 --> 01:31:53.207
CALLED THE FIFTH INGREDIENT

01:31:53.274 --> 01:31:55.276
BECAUSE IT IS THE THING THAT WE

01:31:55.343 --> 01:31:56.544
USE TO CARBONATE BEER, RIGHT?

01:31:56.611 --> 01:31:58.412
WE ALL LIKE THE BUBBLES AND THE

01:31:58.479 --> 01:32:01.115
FOAM, BUT CO2 IS ALSO A

01:32:01.182 --> 01:32:03.618
BYPRODUCT OF ALL ALCOHOL

01:32:03.684 --> 01:32:05.052
FERMENTATION, AND IT IS

01:32:05.119 --> 01:32:07.255
GENERALLY RELEASED INTO THE AIR.

01:32:07.321 --> 01:32:10.825
SO WE BUY CO2 TO USE DURING THE

01:32:10.892 --> 01:32:12.627
BREWING PROCESS, AND THEN WE

01:32:12.693 --> 01:32:15.563
MAKE CO2, WHICH WE BLOW OFF

01:32:15.630 --> 01:32:16.964
INTO THE ATMOSPHERE. SO

01:32:17.031 --> 01:32:18.766
WOULDN'T IT MAKE SENSE IF WE

01:32:18.833 --> 01:32:20.902
WERE ABLE TO CAPTURE THAT CO2

01:32:20.968 --> 01:32:23.070
AND THEN REUSE IT IN THE

01:32:23.137 --> 01:32:24.872
BREWING PROCESS? THAT WOULD

01:32:24.939 --> 01:32:26.674
SAVE US TIME. IT WOULD SAVE A

01:32:26.741 --> 01:32:28.643
LOT OF MONEY, AND IT WOULD SURE

01:32:28.709 --> 01:32:30.278
BE A WHOLE LOT BETTER FOR THE

01:32:30.344 --> 01:32:32.613
ENVIRONMENT. BUT CO2 RECOVERY

01:32:32.680 --> 01:32:35.316
IS NOT AS EASY AS IT SOUNDS.

01:32:35.383 --> 01:32:36.751
IT'S SOMETHING THAT WAS REALLY

01:32:36.817 --> 01:32:38.920
ONLY AVAILABLE TO A MUCH LARGER

01:32:38.986 --> 01:32:41.088
BREWERIES, JUST DUE TO THE SIZE

01:32:41.155 --> 01:32:43.991
OF THE SYSTEMS. UNTIL RATHER

01:32:44.058 --> 01:32:46.127
RECENTLY. TECHNOLOGY FOR CO2

01:32:46.193 --> 01:32:47.561
RECOVERY IS GREATLY ADVANCED IN

01:32:47.628 --> 01:32:50.064
ABOUT THE LAST TEN YEARS, WITH

01:32:50.131 --> 01:32:52.199
EQUIPMENT MANUFACTURERS MAKING

01:32:52.266 --> 01:32:54.402
UNITS THAT WORK FOR SMALLER

01:32:54.468 --> 01:32:56.203
BREWERIES LIKE US AND EVEN

01:32:56.270 --> 01:32:57.972
SMALLER. WE'RE A 50,000 BARREL

01:32:58.039 --> 01:33:00.107
A YEAR BREWERY, AND THERE ARE

01:33:00.174 --> 01:33:01.242
SOME BREWERIES THAT ARE ONLY

01:33:01.309 --> 01:33:02.743
MAKING 1000 BARRELS A YEAR THAT

01:33:02.810 --> 01:33:05.579
ARE INSTALLING CO2 RECOVERY.

01:33:05.646 --> 01:33:07.081
AND THEN BECAUSE OF THIS, IT'S

01:33:07.148 --> 01:33:08.816
ALSO BRINGING THE COST DOWN. SO

01:33:08.883 --> 01:33:11.319
THE BARRIERS TO ENTRY ON THAT

01:33:11.385 --> 01:33:13.854
FRONT ARE, ARE MUCH, MUCH LOWER.

01:33:13.921 --> 01:33:15.222
IT'S MUCH MORE ACCESSIBLE

01:33:15.289 --> 01:33:17.558
TECHNOLOGY TO, TO MORE

01:33:17.625 --> 01:33:22.463
BREWERIES. BUT OUR GREATEST

01:33:22.530 --> 01:33:25.333
BARRIER TO DOING CO2 RECOVERY

01:33:25.399 --> 01:33:27.101
CONTINUES TO BE THE CO2

01:33:27.168 --> 01:33:31.472
SUPPLIER. SO THE CO2 SUPPLIER,

01:33:31.539 --> 01:33:33.841
WE IT'S THROUGHOUT THE COUNTRY,

01:33:33.908 --> 01:33:35.209
ANY SIZE BREWERY PRETTY MUCH

01:33:35.276 --> 01:33:36.410
HAS TO SIGN AN AGREEMENT WITH

01:33:36.477 --> 01:33:38.679
THE CO2 SUPPLIER IN ORDER TO BE

01:33:38.746 --> 01:33:40.081
GUARANTEED GETTING ACCESS TO

01:33:40.147 --> 01:33:42.049
THAT SUPPLY AND ALSO KEEPING

01:33:42.116 --> 01:33:45.186
THE COST STEADY. I WON'T SAY

01:33:45.252 --> 01:33:47.321
LESS. I'LL JUST SAY STEADY. BUT

01:33:47.388 --> 01:33:49.490
MOST OF US ARE TIED UP IN LONG

01:33:49.557 --> 01:33:51.625
TERM AUTO RENEWING CONTRACTS

01:33:51.692 --> 01:33:53.060
WITH OUR CO2 SUPPLIERS. THEY'RE

01:33:53.127 --> 01:33:54.562
GENERALLY SEVEN YEARS. AND IF

01:33:54.628 --> 01:33:56.230
YOU DON'T CAPTURE IT IN THE

01:33:56.297 --> 01:33:57.331
WINDOW TO RENEW IT, THEY

01:33:57.398 --> 01:33:58.966
AUTOMATICALLY RENEW. THEY'LL

01:33:59.033 --> 01:34:00.935
JUST DO IT. IF YOU GO OUT AND

01:34:01.002 --> 01:34:02.837
YOU TRY TO GET A BETTER PRICE,

01:34:02.903 --> 01:34:04.238
YOUR YOUR SUPPLIER MIGHT COME

01:34:04.305 --> 01:34:06.440
IN AND, AND BEAT THAT PRICE AND

01:34:06.507 --> 01:34:07.975
THEN THAT AUTOMATICALLY RENEWS

01:34:08.042 --> 01:34:09.710
THE CONTRACT AS WELL. SO YOU

01:34:09.777 --> 01:34:12.480
CAN'T EVEN SHOP AROUND. RIGHT?

01:34:12.546 --> 01:34:15.049
EXACTLY. THE CONTRACT ALSO

01:34:15.116 --> 01:34:16.484
REQUIRES THE BREWERY TO

01:34:16.550 --> 01:34:18.652
PURCHASE A MINIMUM AMOUNT OF

01:34:18.719 --> 01:34:22.323
CO2 PER MONTH AND OR DOES NOT

01:34:22.390 --> 01:34:26.560
ALLOW THE BREWERY TO DO ANY CO2

01:34:26.627 --> 01:34:29.797
RECOVERY. IT'S PRETTY CLEVER.

01:34:29.864 --> 01:34:31.232
THE BREWERY IS NOT ALLOWED TO

01:34:31.298 --> 01:34:32.633
PURCHASE FROM OTHER SUPPLIERS,

01:34:32.700 --> 01:34:34.135
AND THEN THE SUPPLIER IS

01:34:34.201 --> 01:34:35.536
FREQUENTLY LIKE TO CLAIM FORCE

01:34:35.603 --> 01:34:37.438
MAJEURE AT ANY OPPORTUNITY SO

01:34:37.505 --> 01:34:39.173
THEY CAN RAISE THEIR PRICES AND

01:34:39.240 --> 01:34:40.574
LOCK YOU IN, AND STILL PREVENT

01:34:40.641 --> 01:34:42.777
YOU FROM BUYING FROM OTHER

01:34:42.843 --> 01:34:44.578
SUPPLIERS. YOU MIGHT NOT KNOW

01:34:44.645 --> 01:34:45.913
THIS, BUT I MENTIONED THIS TO

01:34:45.980 --> 01:34:48.149
ASSEMBLY MEMBER ROGERS BEFORE,

01:34:48.215 --> 01:34:50.985
BEFORE THE HEARING THAT THE CO2

01:34:51.052 --> 01:34:53.187
SUPPLY IN CALIFORNIA COMES FROM

01:34:53.254 --> 01:34:56.057
OIL REFINERIES. SO BREWERIES,

01:34:56.123 --> 01:34:58.959
WINERIES, EVEN CANNABIS

01:34:59.026 --> 01:35:01.495
PURCHASES OUR CO2 FROM OIL

01:35:01.562 --> 01:35:02.963
REFINERIES. SO DURING THE

01:35:03.030 --> 01:35:04.432
HEIGHT OF THE PANDEMIC, I'M

01:35:04.498 --> 01:35:05.800
SURE MOST OF YOU WEREN'T

01:35:05.866 --> 01:35:08.302
DRIVING VERY MUCH. NOBODY WAS

01:35:08.369 --> 01:35:12.273
DRIVING, WHICH DROVE DOWN THE

01:35:12.339 --> 01:35:16.644
THE CO2 BYPRODUCT FROM THE OIL

01:35:16.710 --> 01:35:18.412
REFINERIES, WHICH THEN MADE A

01:35:18.479 --> 01:35:19.513
SERIOUS SUPPLY AND DEMAND

01:35:19.580 --> 01:35:20.881
PROBLEM BECAUSE EVERYBODY WAS

01:35:20.948 --> 01:35:22.416
PANTRY LOADING, RIGHT.

01:35:22.483 --> 01:35:23.818
EVERYBODY WAS ORDERING BEER AND

01:35:23.884 --> 01:35:25.986
WINE AND ALCOHOL AND ONLINE,

01:35:26.053 --> 01:35:27.788
AND THEY WERE BUYING CASES OF

01:35:27.855 --> 01:35:29.223
SPARKLING THIS AND SPARKLING

01:35:29.290 --> 01:35:30.291
THAT AND LOADING UP AT THEIR

01:35:30.357 --> 01:35:31.992
HOMES. AND SO THERE WAS THE

01:35:32.059 --> 01:35:33.494
DEMAND FOR CO2 WAS INCREASING,

01:35:33.561 --> 01:35:36.030
BUT THE SUPPLY WAS DECREASING

01:35:36.097 --> 01:35:37.465
EXPONENTIALLY, WHICH MADE IT

01:35:37.531 --> 01:35:38.933
REALLY, REALLY DIFFICULT FOR

01:35:38.999 --> 01:35:40.201
BREWERIES. THERE WERE A LOT OF

01:35:40.267 --> 01:35:41.268
BREWERIES THAT ACTUALLY RAN OUT

01:35:41.335 --> 01:35:43.204
OF CO2 AND WERE NOT ABLE TO

01:35:43.270 --> 01:35:45.039
MAKE BEER DURING DURING THE

01:35:45.106 --> 01:35:46.841
PANDEMIC, OUR SUPPLIER ALLOWED

01:35:46.907 --> 01:35:49.343
US TO TEMPORARILY SOURCE CO2

01:35:49.410 --> 01:35:51.145
FROM ANOTHER SUPPLIER, AND THEN

01:35:51.212 --> 01:35:52.613
THEY TRIED TO EXTEND OUR

01:35:52.680 --> 01:35:53.814
CONTRACT FOR THAT EXACT AMOUNT

01:35:53.881 --> 01:35:55.883
OF TIME. IF WE HAD NOT BEEN

01:35:55.950 --> 01:35:56.884
PAYING ATTENTION, THEY WOULD

01:35:56.951 --> 01:35:58.385
HAVE LITERALLY TACKED ON A YEAR

01:35:58.452 --> 01:36:00.020
TO OUR CONTRACT. BUT THANKFULLY,

01:36:00.087 --> 01:36:01.422
MY HUSBAND WAS PAYING ATTENTION

01:36:01.489 --> 01:36:02.890
BECAUSE WE REALLY WANTED TO GET

01:36:02.957 --> 01:36:04.058
OUT OF THIS CONTRACT. WE HAD TO

01:36:04.125 --> 01:36:05.893
GET OUR ATTORNEY INVOLVED AS

01:36:05.960 --> 01:36:07.027
WELL. MY HUSBAND LIKES TO SAY

01:36:07.094 --> 01:36:08.896
THAT IF THEY EVER BROUGHT BACK

01:36:08.963 --> 01:36:10.598
THE SOPRANOS, TONY SOPRANO

01:36:10.664 --> 01:36:13.834
WOULD BE IN THE CO2 BUSINESS.

01:36:13.901 --> 01:36:15.269
SO CO2 RECOVERY HAS BEEN A

01:36:15.336 --> 01:36:16.704
REALLY HOT TOPIC IN OUR

01:36:16.770 --> 01:36:17.972
INDUSTRY OF LATE, WITH BREWERS

01:36:18.038 --> 01:36:19.607
WATCHING THEIR CONTRACTS VERY

01:36:19.673 --> 01:36:21.142
CLOSELY AND EVEN ENGAGING WITH

01:36:21.208 --> 01:36:22.877
THEIR OWN LEGAL COUNSEL TO FIND

01:36:22.943 --> 01:36:24.945
WAYS OUT SO THAT THEY, TOO, CAN

01:36:25.012 --> 01:36:28.949
INSTALL CO2 RECOVERY. SO IN

01:36:29.016 --> 01:36:31.118
JULY OF LAST YEAR, WE AT

01:36:31.185 --> 01:36:32.586
RUSSIAN RIVER COMPLETED

01:36:32.653 --> 01:36:34.388
INSTALLING OUR CO2 RECOVERY

01:36:34.455 --> 01:36:35.890
SYSTEM, WHICH IMMEDIATELY MADE

01:36:35.956 --> 01:36:39.093
US CO2 INDEPENDENT, SUPPLYING

01:36:39.160 --> 01:36:41.195
100% OF OUR CO2 NEEDS OF BOTH

01:36:41.262 --> 01:36:43.330
BREWERIES. IN FACT, WE ARE

01:36:43.397 --> 01:36:44.899
PRODUCING SO MUCH CO2 THAT

01:36:44.965 --> 01:36:46.734
WE'VE HAD TO SELL SOME OFF OVER

01:36:46.800 --> 01:36:48.869
THE PAST YEAR IN ORDER TO MAKE

01:36:48.936 --> 01:36:51.238
MORE ROOM IN THE TANK, AND WE

01:36:51.305 --> 01:36:53.440
EVEN SOLD SOME TO A SEAWEED

01:36:53.507 --> 01:36:55.943
FARMER IN HAWAII WHO IS GROWING

01:36:56.010 --> 01:36:58.179
SEAWEED TO SELL TO CATTLE

01:36:58.245 --> 01:36:59.513
FARMERS TO SUPPLEMENT THEIR

01:36:59.580 --> 01:37:01.348
FEED, TO REDUCE THEIR METHANE

01:37:01.415 --> 01:37:04.251
EMISSIONS FULL CIRCLE. WE WE

01:37:04.318 --> 01:37:05.853
PLAN THIS. YEAH, THAT WAS THAT

01:37:05.920 --> 01:37:07.788
WAS BRILLIANT. SO I KIND OF

01:37:07.855 --> 01:37:08.989
WANT TO TALK TO OUR FARMERS

01:37:09.056 --> 01:37:10.791
AFTER THIS TO SEE IF THERE'S

01:37:10.858 --> 01:37:11.926
ANY OTHER LOCAL FARMERS THAT

01:37:11.992 --> 01:37:14.295
MIGHT BE INTERESTED IN, IN

01:37:14.361 --> 01:37:16.530
PURCHASING SOME CO2 FROM US. SO

01:37:16.597 --> 01:37:18.332
WE'RE NOT INTERESTED IN MAKING

01:37:18.399 --> 01:37:20.801
MONEY SELLING CO2. WE JUST WANT

01:37:20.868 --> 01:37:24.405
TO JUST HELP OUT AND, AND, AND

01:37:24.471 --> 01:37:25.839
DEPLETE OUR TANK SO THAT WE CAN

01:37:25.906 --> 01:37:27.474
CONTINUE TO FILL IT BECAUSE THE

01:37:27.541 --> 01:37:29.376
LAST THING WE WANT IS TO HAVE

01:37:29.443 --> 01:37:30.644
TOO MUCH CO2 AND HAVE TO BLOW

01:37:30.711 --> 01:37:36.984
IT OFF INTO INTO THE ATMOSPHERE.

01:37:37.051 --> 01:37:39.186
SO IN, IN ADDITION, ANOTHER

01:37:39.253 --> 01:37:41.689
BENEFIT TO, YOU KNOW, NOT BEING

01:37:41.755 --> 01:37:43.457
TO CREATING OR MAKING OUR OWN

01:37:43.524 --> 01:37:45.292
CO2, BEING COMPLETELY

01:37:45.359 --> 01:37:47.494
INDEPENDENT, NOT HAVING TO RELY

01:37:47.561 --> 01:37:50.297
ON EXPENSIVE AND UNRELIABLE

01:37:50.364 --> 01:37:52.533
SUPPLIERS. OUR CO2 IS ABOUT AS

01:37:52.600 --> 01:37:55.002
PURE AS IT GETS. AND WE'VE ALSO

01:37:55.069 --> 01:37:56.403
RELEASED OUR REDUCED OUR

01:37:56.470 --> 01:37:58.239
RELIANCE ON FOSSIL FUELS BY NOT

01:37:58.305 --> 01:38:00.007
BUYING IT THROUGH A SOURCE THAT

01:38:00.074 --> 01:38:02.209
COMES FROM AN OIL REFINERY.

01:38:02.276 --> 01:38:04.411
SINCE JULY OF 2025, WE'VE

01:38:04.478 --> 01:38:07.581
COLLECTED 740,000 POUNDS OF CO2,

01:38:07.648 --> 01:38:10.150
AND OUR ROI ON OUR CO2 RECOVERY

01:38:10.217 --> 01:38:14.421
SYSTEM IS ONLY ABOUT FOUR YEARS.

01:38:14.488 --> 01:38:16.657
SO I KNOW MOST OF US ARE GOING

01:38:16.724 --> 01:38:17.825
TO BE HEADING TO THE BREWERY

01:38:17.891 --> 01:38:19.627
AFTER THIS, AND I'LL SHOW YOU

01:38:19.693 --> 01:38:21.662
OUR CO2 RECOVERY SYSTEM IN IN

01:38:21.729 --> 01:38:22.796
PERSON, BUT I THOUGHT I WOULD

01:38:22.863 --> 01:38:24.765
JUST KIND OF TOUCH ON IT AS A,

01:38:24.832 --> 01:38:26.834
FROM A HIGH LEVEL, HOW IT WORKS.

01:38:26.900 --> 01:38:29.570
SO THE CO2 FROM FERMENTATION

01:38:29.637 --> 01:38:31.405
TANKS PASSES THROUGH THE FOAM

01:38:31.472 --> 01:38:33.207
TRAPS. SO IT'S COLLECTED IN

01:38:33.274 --> 01:38:34.608
PIPES, PASSES THROUGH THE FOAM

01:38:34.675 --> 01:38:37.177
TRAP, AND THEN COLLECTS ALL THE

01:38:37.244 --> 01:38:39.647
EXCESS FOAM. THEN IT ENTERS

01:38:39.713 --> 01:38:41.815
INTO OUR UNITS, OUR DALAM UNITS

01:38:41.882 --> 01:38:43.517
THAT WE HAVE THREE OF THEM AT

01:38:43.584 --> 01:38:44.585
THE BREWERY, WHICH YOU'LL SEE

01:38:44.652 --> 01:38:46.120
IN A LITTLE BIT ALL THE

01:38:46.186 --> 01:38:47.955
FERMENTATION BYPRODUCTS SUCH AS

01:38:48.022 --> 01:38:50.124
ACETALDEHYDE, DMS, ETHANOL,

01:38:50.190 --> 01:38:52.226
ETHYL ACETATE OR SCRUBBED ARE

01:38:52.293 --> 01:38:54.428
REMOVED FROM THE CO2. THE CO2

01:38:54.495 --> 01:38:56.230
IS THEN COMPRESSED AND IT'S

01:38:56.297 --> 01:38:57.631
COOLED TO HELP STABILIZE THE

01:38:57.698 --> 01:38:59.133
FLOW THROUGH THE UNITS, AND

01:38:59.199 --> 01:39:00.200
THEN IT PASSES THROUGH THE

01:39:00.267 --> 01:39:02.303
DRYING PROCESS. AFTER THIS, THE

01:39:02.369 --> 01:39:04.471
CO2 IS CONDENSED INTO A LIQUID

01:39:04.538 --> 01:39:06.640
FORM, AND ANY REMAINING OXYGEN

01:39:06.707 --> 01:39:08.842
IS COMPLETELY REMOVED FROM THE

01:39:08.909 --> 01:39:14.248
CO2. SO OUR CO2 IS 99.95% PURE.

01:39:14.315 --> 01:39:15.716
WE TURNED IT INTO LIQUID AND

01:39:15.783 --> 01:39:17.284
THEN IT IS PUMPED TO OUR

01:39:17.351 --> 01:39:18.519
OUTDOOR STORAGE TANK FOR FUTURE

01:39:18.585 --> 01:39:19.953
USE, WHICH WE THEN BRING BACK

01:39:20.020 --> 01:39:22.489
INTO THE BREWERY. FOR ALL THE

01:39:22.556 --> 01:39:23.924
THINGS I TOLD YOU ABOUT EARLIER,

01:39:23.991 --> 01:39:25.726
PURGING TANKS AND PACKAGING AND

01:39:25.793 --> 01:39:27.194
ALL THAT. SO IT'S THIS

01:39:27.261 --> 01:39:31.231
WONDERFUL CIRCULAR LOOP. AND

01:39:31.298 --> 01:39:32.533
HERE'S JUST SOME PICTURES OF

01:39:32.599 --> 01:39:34.201
OUR SYSTEM IN CASE YOU'RE NOT

01:39:34.268 --> 01:39:35.436
ABLE TO JOIN US FOR THE TOUR

01:39:35.502 --> 01:39:37.304
LATER. YOU CAN SEE THE HARD

01:39:37.371 --> 01:39:39.440
PIPING AT THE BOTTOM OF THE THE

01:39:39.506 --> 01:39:41.208
TANKS, THE FERMENTATION TANKS,

01:39:41.275 --> 01:39:42.743
THE CO2 IS COLLECTED IN THE

01:39:42.810 --> 01:39:44.812
HARD PIPING, THEN GOES THROUGH

01:39:44.878 --> 01:39:46.280
THE FOAM TRAP, HEADS OVER TO

01:39:46.347 --> 01:39:48.382
THE DALAM SYSTEM, WHERE IT THEN

01:39:48.449 --> 01:39:49.450
GOES THROUGH THIS PROCESS OF

01:39:49.516 --> 01:39:51.285
BEING CLEANED AND THEN

01:39:51.352 --> 01:39:52.686
CONDENSED INTO LIQUID FORM

01:39:52.753 --> 01:39:55.255
HEADS OUTSIDE TO THE LIQUID CO2

01:39:55.322 --> 01:39:57.791
STORAGE TANK, OR WE PUT THEM

01:39:57.858 --> 01:39:59.193
INTO THESE SMALLER LITTLE TANKS

01:39:59.259 --> 01:40:00.661
CALLED DOERS, AND WE TRANSFER

01:40:00.728 --> 01:40:02.796
THEM TO THE SANTA ROSA PUB FOR

01:40:02.863 --> 01:40:04.365
USE DOWN THERE, WHICH IS PRETTY

01:40:04.431 --> 01:40:05.666
COOL. AND THEN IF ANOTHER

01:40:05.733 --> 01:40:07.501
BREWERY OR ANOTHER, SAY, A

01:40:07.568 --> 01:40:09.303
CANNABIS COMPANY WANTS TO BUY

01:40:09.370 --> 01:40:10.504
SOME FROM US AS WELL, THEY

01:40:10.571 --> 01:40:12.306
WOULD JUST SHOW UP WITH THEIR

01:40:12.373 --> 01:40:13.474
OWN DOERS. VERY, VERY EASY FOR

01:40:13.540 --> 01:40:15.309
US TO FILL, ALMOST LIKE GETTING

01:40:15.376 --> 01:40:16.410
A PROPANE TANK FILLED. IT'S

01:40:16.477 --> 01:40:18.645
SUPER, SUPER EASY AND REALLY,

01:40:18.712 --> 01:40:24.752
REALLY SAFE AS WELL. ALL RIGHT.

01:40:24.818 --> 01:40:27.287
THAT'S ALL I GOT. I HAVE THIS

01:40:27.354 --> 01:40:28.722
IS SUPPOSED TO BE A LITTLE

01:40:28.789 --> 01:40:30.524
VIDEO. OH, IT DIDN'T WORK. OH

01:40:30.591 --> 01:40:32.326
WELL, IT'S SUPPOSED TO BE

01:40:32.393 --> 01:40:35.229
BUBBLY. WELL, THANK YOU VERY

01:40:35.295 --> 01:40:37.030
MUCH FOR YOUR TIME TODAY. I

01:40:37.097 --> 01:40:38.832
HOPE YOU LEARNED A LITTLE BIT

01:40:38.899 --> 01:40:40.234
ABOUT CO2 RECOVERY IN THE

01:40:40.300 --> 01:40:41.735
BREWERY, AND I HOPE YOU'RE ABLE

01:40:41.802 --> 01:40:43.103
TO JOIN. JOIN ME LATER FOR THE

01:40:43.170 --> 01:40:45.272
TOUR AND SOME SAMPLES AND LUNCH.

01:40:45.339 --> 01:40:50.244
THANK YOU. THANK YOU FOR HAVING

01:40:50.310 --> 01:40:52.479
US HERE TODAY. I'M KELSEY

01:40:52.546 --> 01:40:54.615
MCQUADE, CRAIG, I AM THE

01:40:54.681 --> 01:40:56.049
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE

01:40:56.116 --> 01:40:57.885
CALIFORNIA CRAFT BREWERS

01:40:57.951 --> 01:41:00.053
ASSOCIATION. WE REPRESENT THE

01:41:00.120 --> 01:41:02.956
OVER 1000 BREWERIES IN

01:41:03.023 --> 01:41:06.527
CALIFORNIA. WE HAVE SOME OF THE

01:41:06.593 --> 01:41:07.995
LARGEST. WE HAVE THE SECOND

01:41:08.061 --> 01:41:09.763
LARGEST BREWERY IN THE COUNTRY

01:41:09.830 --> 01:41:12.299
AND ALSO, YOU KNOW, DOWN TO

01:41:12.366 --> 01:41:14.067
FIVE BARREL A YEAR

01:41:14.134 --> 01:41:15.869
MICROBREWERIES. SO WE COVER A

01:41:15.936 --> 01:41:18.772
LARGE SWATH OF THE CRAFT BEER

01:41:18.839 --> 01:41:21.975
INDUSTRY. AND, YOU KNOW, I, I'M

01:41:22.042 --> 01:41:23.710
VERY HAPPY THAT WE'RE ABLE TO

01:41:23.777 --> 01:41:26.680
BE REPRESENTED HERE TODAY.

01:41:26.747 --> 01:41:29.216
CRAFT BEER HAS ALWAYS BEEN AN

01:41:29.283 --> 01:41:31.351
INNOVATOR IN MAKING SUSTAINABLE

01:41:31.418 --> 01:41:34.588
AND GREEN BUSINESS, WHETHER IT

01:41:34.655 --> 01:41:38.192
WAS, YOU KNOW, SIERRA NEVADA

01:41:38.258 --> 01:41:40.727
INSTALLING SOLAR PANELS DECADES

01:41:40.794 --> 01:41:44.031
AGO TO NOW, THE CARBON RECOVERY

01:41:44.097 --> 01:41:46.834
SYSTEMS OF TODAY. CRAFT BEER

01:41:46.900 --> 01:41:48.602
HAS ALWAYS TRIED TO FIND WAYS

01:41:48.669 --> 01:41:51.572
TO IMPROVE THEIR SUSTAINABILITY.

01:41:51.638 --> 01:41:53.207
WE HAVE A LOT OF MEMBERS THAT

01:41:53.273 --> 01:41:57.644
DO 1% FOR THE PLANET OR SPENT

01:41:57.711 --> 01:41:59.813
GRAIN DONATIONS TO FARMERS

01:41:59.880 --> 01:42:03.016
TRYING TO HELP KEEP OUR OUR

01:42:03.083 --> 01:42:06.253
INGREDIENTS AND WATER FLOWING,

01:42:06.320 --> 01:42:07.721
BECAUSE EVERYTHING THAT GOES

01:42:07.788 --> 01:42:11.391
INTO BEER DEPENDS ON A HEALTHY

01:42:11.458 --> 01:42:15.996
ENVIRONMENT. SO I WAS I WANT TO

01:42:16.063 --> 01:42:18.131
START WITH A DISCLAIMER THAT I

01:42:18.198 --> 01:42:20.467
AM NOT AN ENGINEER OR AN EXPERT

01:42:20.534 --> 01:42:22.236
IN CO2 RECOVERY. I'M REALLY

01:42:22.302 --> 01:42:25.005
GLAD THAT NATALIE GAVE YOU SOME

01:42:25.072 --> 01:42:26.807
DIAGRAMS AND A LITTLE MORE

01:42:26.874 --> 01:42:28.942
DETAIL ON THE RECOVERY PROCESS

01:42:29.009 --> 01:42:31.845
AT THEIR AT AT RUSSIAN RIVER.

01:42:31.912 --> 01:42:34.348
BECAUSE I AM NOT AN EXPERT IN

01:42:34.414 --> 01:42:36.517
THAT. WHAT I AM AN EXPERT IN IS

01:42:36.583 --> 01:42:37.985
OUR MEMBERSHIP AND WHAT THEY

01:42:38.051 --> 01:42:40.821
ARE FACING AND THEIR

01:42:40.888 --> 01:42:41.922
EXPERIENCES IN TRYING TO

01:42:41.989 --> 01:42:46.593
UTILIZE THIS TECHNOLOGY.

01:42:46.660 --> 01:42:48.795
CURRENTLY, THERE ARE THREE

01:42:48.862 --> 01:42:51.632
OPTIONS AVAILABLE FOR BREWERIES

01:42:51.698 --> 01:42:57.437
LOOKING TO CAPTURE CO2. AND

01:42:57.504 --> 01:42:59.540
MOVE AWAY FROM THAT TRADITIONAL

01:42:59.606 --> 01:43:02.442
CARBON DIOXIDE THAT WE GET FROM

01:43:02.509 --> 01:43:05.646
REFINERIES. AND BEFORE I JUMP

01:43:05.712 --> 01:43:07.147
INTO THOSE THREE, I DO WANT TO

01:43:07.214 --> 01:43:08.749
STRESS THAT THIS IS NOT A ONE

01:43:08.815 --> 01:43:11.084
SIZE FITS ALL METHOD. AS

01:43:11.151 --> 01:43:12.519
NATALIE HAD MENTIONED, THIS

01:43:12.586 --> 01:43:14.154
USED TO BE SOMETHING THAT WAS

01:43:14.221 --> 01:43:15.422
ONLY AVAILABLE TO THE VERY

01:43:15.489 --> 01:43:19.726
LARGE BREWERIES. SIERRA NEVADA

01:43:19.793 --> 01:43:21.862
IMPLEMENTED THEIR CARBON CO2

01:43:21.929 --> 01:43:24.364
RECOVERY IN 2005, BUT WE

01:43:24.431 --> 01:43:26.934
HAVEN'T REALLY SEEN AN UPTICK

01:43:27.000 --> 01:43:29.803
IN BREWERIES DOING THIS UNTIL

01:43:29.870 --> 01:43:32.439
PROBABLY SINCE 2020, WHEN MORE

01:43:32.506 --> 01:43:34.107
OF THE MID-SIZE OR REGIONAL

01:43:34.174 --> 01:43:35.542
BREWERIES COULD START JUMPING

01:43:35.609 --> 01:43:37.744
IN ON THAT TECHNOLOGY. THERE'S

01:43:37.811 --> 01:43:40.948
MORE SCALABLE OPTIONS NOW, BUT

01:43:41.014 --> 01:43:43.150
STILL, EVERY BREWERY RUNS A

01:43:43.216 --> 01:43:44.585
DIFFERENT MODEL, DIFFERENT

01:43:44.651 --> 01:43:45.986
PRODUCTION SIZE, DIFFERENT

01:43:46.053 --> 01:43:47.521
PRODUCTION SCHEDULE. SO SOME OF

01:43:47.588 --> 01:43:49.957
THESE TECHNOLOGIES AREN'T AS

01:43:50.023 --> 01:43:53.193
IDEAL UNLESS YOU'RE BREWING FOR

01:43:53.260 --> 01:43:56.830
LONGER PERIODS OF TIME. SO IT

01:43:56.897 --> 01:43:59.700
REALLY, REALLY DEPENDS ON THE

01:43:59.766 --> 01:44:02.936
STRUCTURE, HOW WHICH PROCESS

01:44:03.003 --> 01:44:07.608
BREWERIES COULD USE. SO THE

01:44:07.674 --> 01:44:10.811
FIRST ONE IS WHAT NATALIE

01:44:10.877 --> 01:44:11.945
DISCUSSED THAT RUSSIAN RIVER

01:44:12.012 --> 01:44:16.216
USE CO2 RECOVERY WHERE YOU PULL

01:44:16.283 --> 01:44:18.385
CO2. THAT'S A BYPRODUCT OF THE

01:44:18.452 --> 01:44:21.655
BREWING PROCESS. REFINE IT,

01:44:21.722 --> 01:44:24.157
MAKE IT, YOU KNOW, MOST OF THE

01:44:24.224 --> 01:44:25.225
PRODUCTS, THERE'S A COUPLE

01:44:25.292 --> 01:44:27.027
COMPANIES THAT MAKE CO2

01:44:27.094 --> 01:44:30.631
RECOVERY SYSTEMS, ALL OF THEM

01:44:30.697 --> 01:44:35.335
PRODUCE AROUND 99% PURE CO2 AND

01:44:35.402 --> 01:44:37.137
LIQUID FORM THAT THEN CAN BE

01:44:37.204 --> 01:44:40.707
REUSED IN THE BREWING PROCESS.

01:44:40.774 --> 01:44:43.577
I DIDN'T CALL OUT ANY SPECIFIC

01:44:43.644 --> 01:44:45.779
BRANDS BECAUSE I DON'T WANT TO

01:44:45.846 --> 01:44:47.614
SUPPORT ONE OVER THE OTHER, AND

01:44:47.681 --> 01:44:50.050
MANY OF THEM ACTUALLY ARE

01:44:50.117 --> 01:44:51.251
ALLIED TRADE MEMBERS OF OURS

01:44:51.318 --> 01:44:55.856
THAT WE WORK VERY CLOSELY WITH.

01:44:55.922 --> 01:44:58.392
BUT THERE ARE A COUPLE OF

01:44:58.458 --> 01:44:59.526
BREWERIES IN CALIFORNIA THAT

01:44:59.593 --> 01:45:02.295
ARE DOING THE CO2 RECOVERY. I

01:45:02.362 --> 01:45:03.830
ALREADY MENTIONED SIERRA NEVADA,

01:45:03.897 --> 01:45:06.600
RUSSIAN RIVER, FIRESTONE WALKER

01:45:06.667 --> 01:45:08.835
JUST INSTALLED A VERY LARGE

01:45:08.902 --> 01:45:11.338
SYSTEM THAT WILL CAPTURE ABOUT

01:45:11.405 --> 01:45:12.739
4 MILLION POUNDS OF CO2 EVERY

01:45:12.806 --> 01:45:16.677
YEAR. ALVARADO STREET PIZZA

01:45:16.743 --> 01:45:19.546
PORT DOWN IN SAN DIEGO, SOCIETY,

01:45:19.613 --> 01:45:21.748
ALSO IN SAN DIEGO, AND PURE

01:45:21.815 --> 01:45:25.752
PROJECT. THE OTHER. ONE OF THE

01:45:25.819 --> 01:45:29.256
OTHER OPTIONS IS ONE THAT GOT A

01:45:29.322 --> 01:45:31.858
LOT OF PRESS IN THE LAST YEAR

01:45:31.925 --> 01:45:34.327
IS THE DIRECT AIR CAPTURE. SO

01:45:34.394 --> 01:45:35.429
CURRENTLY THERE'S ONLY ONE

01:45:35.495 --> 01:45:37.631
BREWERY DOING DIRECT AIR

01:45:37.698 --> 01:45:40.500
CAPTURE CO2, AND THAT'S ALMANAC

01:45:40.567 --> 01:45:43.704
DOWN IN ALAMEDA. BASICALLY THIS

01:45:43.770 --> 01:45:47.340
SYSTEM, IT'S BEEN USED MORE IN

01:45:47.407 --> 01:45:50.510
LARGER PRODUCTION MANUFACTURING

01:45:50.577 --> 01:45:53.814
FACILITIES. BUT FOR CRAFT BEER,

01:45:53.880 --> 01:45:57.017
THEY FINALLY CREATED A SMALLER

01:45:57.084 --> 01:45:59.186
SYSTEM THAT CAN FIT ON THE

01:45:59.252 --> 01:46:01.688
BREWING THE BREWERY PROPERTY.

01:46:01.755 --> 01:46:04.191
IT TAKES AN AMBIENT AIR AND

01:46:04.257 --> 01:46:07.094
COLLECTS. IT SEPARATES OUT THE

01:46:07.160 --> 01:46:09.262
CO2, REFINES IT, MAKES IT PURE,

01:46:09.329 --> 01:46:11.898
AND THEN IS NO LONGER, YOU KNOW,

01:46:11.965 --> 01:46:13.500
IN THE ATMOSPHERE AND CAN BE

01:46:13.567 --> 01:46:17.204
USED IN THE BREWING PROCESS. SO

01:46:17.270 --> 01:46:19.005
THAT'S STILL YOU'RE STILL

01:46:19.072 --> 01:46:21.541
PRODUCING CO2 IN THE PROCESS OF

01:46:21.608 --> 01:46:24.745
BREWING, BUT THEY'RE PULLING IN

01:46:24.811 --> 01:46:26.947
AND ACTUALLY USING BEER MORE AS

01:46:27.013 --> 01:46:30.851
A CARBON SEQUESTRATION THAN

01:46:30.917 --> 01:46:31.952
ANYTHING ELSE, WHICH IS KIND OF

01:46:32.018 --> 01:46:35.522
A COOL CONCEPT. THE LAST

01:46:35.589 --> 01:46:37.390
TECHNOLOGY IS ONE I ACTUALLY

01:46:37.457 --> 01:46:38.892
JUST LEARNED ABOUT LAST WEEK AT

01:46:38.959 --> 01:46:42.429
OUR ANNUAL CONFERENCE. THERE IS

01:46:42.496 --> 01:46:45.298
A NEW TECHNOLOGY, NEWER NEW

01:46:45.365 --> 01:46:46.733
TECHNOLOGY TO CRAFT BEER. IT'S

01:46:46.800 --> 01:46:48.835
BEEN USED ACTUALLY IN DAIRY

01:46:48.902 --> 01:46:51.705
FARMING FOR A WHILE. SO AGAIN,

01:46:51.772 --> 01:46:56.443
FULL CIRCLE IS REFRIGERATION

01:46:56.510 --> 01:46:59.346
THAT IS FUELED BY THAT. IT USES

01:46:59.412 --> 01:47:01.848
CO2 AS A REFRIGERANT. SO NOT

01:47:01.915 --> 01:47:04.684
ONLY ARE YOU TAKING CO2 OUT OF

01:47:04.751 --> 01:47:06.887
THE AIR, YOU'RE ALSO REMOVING

01:47:06.953 --> 01:47:10.457
THOSE REALLY POLLUTING

01:47:10.524 --> 01:47:12.692
REFRIGERANTS THAT ARE TYPICALLY

01:47:12.759 --> 01:47:15.996
USED. SO THIS TECHNOLOGY HAS

01:47:16.062 --> 01:47:19.499
NOW BEEN SCALED DOWN TO FIT ON

01:47:19.566 --> 01:47:22.068
A ON A BREWERY'S PROPERTY AND

01:47:22.135 --> 01:47:27.040
NOT A GIANT. SET OF EQUIPMENT.

01:47:27.107 --> 01:47:30.043
BUT BASICALLY YOU CAN RECOVER

01:47:30.110 --> 01:47:31.711
THE CO2 FROM THE BREWING

01:47:31.778 --> 01:47:33.914
PROCESS, REFINE IT, AND THEN

01:47:33.980 --> 01:47:36.016
USE IT AS A REFRIGERANT FOR

01:47:36.082 --> 01:47:38.985
GLYCOL COOLERS. AND THERE'S ALL

01:47:39.052 --> 01:47:41.087
THEY'RE ALSO TESTING TECHNOLOGY

01:47:41.154 --> 01:47:43.256
TO USE IT AS A HEATER TO TO

01:47:43.323 --> 01:47:47.627
HEAT WATER WITH THE CO2 AND USE

01:47:47.694 --> 01:47:50.130
IT FOR SANITIZING TANKS AND

01:47:50.197 --> 01:47:51.498
WASHING DOWN FLOORS AND

01:47:51.565 --> 01:47:56.970
EVERYTHING. AND REALLY COOL

01:47:57.037 --> 01:48:00.173
APPLICATION. SO THEY'RE

01:48:00.240 --> 01:48:01.975
STARTING TO PICK UP. THEY'RE

01:48:02.042 --> 01:48:05.245
ACTUALLY TESTING IT. HANNIBAL

01:48:05.312 --> 01:48:10.250
LAGER IN NAPA, LOOKING AT HOW

01:48:10.317 --> 01:48:12.752
MUCH LOSS AND HEAT LOSS OR, YOU

01:48:12.819 --> 01:48:16.022
KNOW, THE EFFICACY OF IT, BUT

01:48:16.089 --> 01:48:17.424
THEY'RE STARTING TO SCALE UP

01:48:17.490 --> 01:48:19.626
AND, AND SELL MORE TO OTHER

01:48:19.693 --> 01:48:21.761
CRAFT BREWERIES. SO THAT'S

01:48:21.828 --> 01:48:23.530
SOMETHING THAT WILL BE ON THE

01:48:23.597 --> 01:48:27.534
HORIZON. AND REALLY PROVIDE

01:48:27.601 --> 01:48:29.703
THAT ADDED BENEFIT OF REMOVING

01:48:29.769 --> 01:48:32.572
REFRIGERANTS AS WELL. NATALIE

01:48:32.639 --> 01:48:35.809
TALKED A BIT ABOUT THE

01:48:35.876 --> 01:48:37.611
CHALLENGES OF DOING CO2

01:48:37.677 --> 01:48:40.447
RECOVERY IN BREWERIES. REALLY

01:48:40.513 --> 01:48:41.915
TIME AND TIME AGAIN, WHAT I

01:48:41.982 --> 01:48:44.451
HEAR FROM BOTH THE VENDORS OF

01:48:44.517 --> 01:48:46.953
THIS TECHNOLOGY AND THE

01:48:47.020 --> 01:48:49.823
BREWERIES IS THAT IT IS THE CO2

01:48:49.890 --> 01:48:51.057
CONTRACTS, IT IS THE CONTRACTS

01:48:51.124 --> 01:48:53.793
WITH THE REFINERIES AND NOT

01:48:53.860 --> 01:48:55.528
BEING ABLE TO GET OUT OF THEM.

01:48:55.595 --> 01:48:57.731
THERE'S A LOT OF COERCIVE

01:48:57.797 --> 01:48:59.900
CONTRACTING THAT GOES ON. AND

01:48:59.966 --> 01:49:02.102
PEOPLE WHO WANT TO USE THIS

01:49:02.168 --> 01:49:05.105
TECHNOLOGY AND GET INTO DOING

01:49:05.171 --> 01:49:08.942
THE RIGHT THING ARE PROHIBITED

01:49:09.009 --> 01:49:10.410
UNTIL THEY CAN GET OUT OF THEIR

01:49:10.477 --> 01:49:12.512
CO2 CONTRACT. AND SO THAT'S

01:49:12.579 --> 01:49:16.116
BEEN THE BIG BARRIER TO ENTRY.

01:49:16.182 --> 01:49:18.952
THESE UNITS OFTEN PAY FOR

01:49:19.019 --> 01:49:21.888
THEMSELVES PRETTY QUICKLY. FOR

01:49:21.955 --> 01:49:23.323
SMALLER BREWERIES, THAT IS

01:49:23.390 --> 01:49:25.091
STILL AN ISSUE. THE UPFRONT

01:49:25.158 --> 01:49:28.662
FINANCIAL COST OF IT, TRYING TO

01:49:28.728 --> 01:49:32.332
FLOAT THAT EXPENSE UNTIL YOU'RE

01:49:32.399 --> 01:49:33.433
ACTUALLY SEEING THE RETURNS ON

01:49:33.500 --> 01:49:35.502
THE INVESTMENT IS A PROBLEM FOR

01:49:35.568 --> 01:49:40.206
THE SMALLER OPERATIONS. BUT,

01:49:40.273 --> 01:49:41.608
YOU KNOW, THAT IS SOMETHING

01:49:41.675 --> 01:49:43.443
THAT COULD BE ADDRESSED

01:49:43.510 --> 01:49:47.380
POTENTIALLY THROUGH LEGISLATION

01:49:47.447 --> 01:49:51.651
OR, OR REBATES. BUT AT THE END

01:49:51.718 --> 01:49:52.886
OF THE DAY, IF YOU CAN'T GET

01:49:52.953 --> 01:49:54.988
OUT OF YOUR CO2 CONTRACT, YOU

01:49:55.055 --> 01:49:58.591
YOU CAN'T DO THE TECHNOLOGY. I

01:49:58.658 --> 01:50:00.760
DO KNOW IN CONVERSATIONS WITH

01:50:00.827 --> 01:50:05.098
THOSE INDUSTRY PARTNERS, THE

01:50:05.165 --> 01:50:06.866
CO2 REFRIGERATION SYSTEM, THERE

01:50:06.933 --> 01:50:08.768
WAS A REBATE PROGRAM THROUGH

01:50:08.835 --> 01:50:12.639
THE STATE YEARS AGO, I THINK

01:50:12.706 --> 01:50:14.007
POTENTIALLY THROUGH THE FEDS. I

01:50:14.074 --> 01:50:17.010
HAVEN'T CONFIRMED THAT FOR

01:50:17.077 --> 01:50:18.378
THOSE FOR INSTALLING THOSE

01:50:18.445 --> 01:50:20.180
SYSTEMS, THOSE CO2

01:50:20.246 --> 01:50:21.648
REFRIGERATION SYSTEMS, BUT IT

01:50:21.715 --> 01:50:24.918
WAS ONLY FOR THE LARGE SCALE

01:50:24.985 --> 01:50:26.319
SYSTEMS AND NOT THE SMALLER

01:50:26.386 --> 01:50:28.488
SCALE THAT WOULD BE USED AT A

01:50:28.555 --> 01:50:30.991
BREWERY. SO THAT IS SOMETHING

01:50:31.057 --> 01:50:32.592
THAT IS AN OBSTACLE TO ADOPTION

01:50:32.659 --> 01:50:35.362
OF THAT TECHNOLOGY. BY AND

01:50:35.428 --> 01:50:38.264
LARGE, WHEN I TALK TO SOME OF

01:50:38.331 --> 01:50:39.599
THE COMPANIES THAT DO THIS

01:50:39.666 --> 01:50:41.134
TECHNOLOGY, THEY SAID, YOU KNOW,

01:50:41.201 --> 01:50:43.236
IT'S REALLY NOT A MATTER OF

01:50:43.303 --> 01:50:44.738
PERMITTING. FOR SOME, IT'S A

01:50:44.804 --> 01:50:47.574
MATTER OF COST. IT'S REALLY

01:50:47.640 --> 01:50:50.543
THOSE CONTRACTS. SO I KNOW

01:50:50.610 --> 01:50:52.879
THERE WILL BE A WAVE OF

01:50:52.946 --> 01:50:55.081
BREWERIES LOOKING TO ADOPT THIS

01:50:55.148 --> 01:50:57.317
TECHNOLOGY ONCE THEY CAN GET

01:50:57.384 --> 01:50:58.918
OUT OF ONCE THEY TIME IT

01:50:58.985 --> 01:51:00.220
CORRECTLY AND CATCH IT BEFORE

01:51:00.286 --> 01:51:03.390
THAT AUTO RENEWAL. BUT UNTIL

01:51:03.456 --> 01:51:06.292
THEN, WE'RE SEEING, YOU KNOW,

01:51:06.359 --> 01:51:09.162
SMALL PICKUP ACROSS THE STATE.

01:51:09.229 --> 01:51:10.630
BUT I KNOW THERE'S QUITE A

01:51:10.697 --> 01:51:12.699
WAITING LIST THAT WANTS TO BE

01:51:12.766 --> 01:51:16.002
ABLE TO DO THIS TECHNOLOGY. SO

01:51:16.069 --> 01:51:18.872
LOOKING FORWARD, I WOULD URGE

01:51:18.938 --> 01:51:21.007
THE SELECT COMMITTEE AND THE

01:51:21.074 --> 01:51:24.644
ASSEMBLY TO TAKE INTO ACCOUNT

01:51:24.711 --> 01:51:27.447
THAT NOT ALL BREWERIES ARE IN A

01:51:27.514 --> 01:51:28.581
POSITION TO ADOPT THIS

01:51:28.648 --> 01:51:29.682
TECHNOLOGY, EVEN IF THEY WANT

01:51:29.749 --> 01:51:31.851
TO. WHILE THERE'S FAR MORE

01:51:31.918 --> 01:51:33.953
OPTIONS ON THE MARKET NOW FOR

01:51:34.020 --> 01:51:36.890
SCALABILITY, IT'S STILL NOT A

01:51:36.956 --> 01:51:40.093
FIT FOR EVERY SINGLE OPERATION,

01:51:40.160 --> 01:51:43.363
BUT IT IS A HUGELY PROMISING

01:51:43.430 --> 01:51:44.764
TECHNOLOGY, AND WE SHOULD DO

01:51:44.831 --> 01:51:46.599
WHATEVER WE CAN TO INCENTIVIZE

01:51:46.666 --> 01:51:49.836
ADOPTION AND ENCOURAGE ADOPTION

01:51:49.903 --> 01:51:52.739
AND REMOVE OBSTACLES FOR

01:51:52.806 --> 01:51:55.208
BREWERIES THAT WANT TO USE THIS

01:51:55.275 --> 01:52:01.347
TECHNOLOGY. IT'S YOU KNOW,

01:52:01.414 --> 01:52:02.615
THERE'S A LOT OF PEOPLE WHO ARE

01:52:02.682 --> 01:52:05.351
REALLY EXCITED ABOUT THIS

01:52:05.418 --> 01:52:07.520
APPLICATION, AND HOPEFULLY WE

01:52:07.587 --> 01:52:08.955
CAN ENCOURAGE THEM AND

01:52:09.022 --> 01:52:11.458
INCENTIVIZE IT. LIKE I SAID

01:52:11.524 --> 01:52:12.492
EARLIER, CRAFT BEER REALLY

01:52:12.559 --> 01:52:14.260
PRIDES ITSELF ON BEING A GOOD

01:52:14.327 --> 01:52:17.931
ENVIRONMENTAL STEWARD. AND

01:52:17.997 --> 01:52:18.998
CALIFORNIA'S CRAFT BREWERIES

01:52:19.065 --> 01:52:21.134
HAVE BEEN AT THE FOREFRONT OF

01:52:21.201 --> 01:52:22.635
SUSTAINABILITY FOR DECADES. AND

01:52:22.702 --> 01:52:24.737
WE WILL CONTINUE TO BE SO. AND

01:52:24.804 --> 01:52:27.640
I LOOK FORWARD IN. QUBA LOOKS

01:52:27.707 --> 01:52:31.211
FORWARD TO WORKING WITH YOU ALL

01:52:31.277 --> 01:52:33.379
ON GETTING. LOWERING THE

01:52:33.446 --> 01:52:34.814
BARRIERS TO ADOPTION FOR CO2

01:52:34.881 --> 01:52:36.416
RECOVERY TECHNOLOGY AND GETTING

01:52:36.483 --> 01:52:37.617
IT IN THE HANDS OF MORE

01:52:37.684 --> 01:52:40.753
BREWERIES. THANK YOU. THANK YOU

01:52:40.820 --> 01:52:42.655
SO MUCH. AND I KNOW WE ARE

01:52:42.722 --> 01:52:44.591
COMING UP ON THE TOUR, SO I'LL

01:52:44.657 --> 01:52:45.692
BE ASKING SOME QUESTIONS AS WE

01:52:45.758 --> 01:52:47.594
DO THAT. BUT KIND OF JUST

01:52:47.660 --> 01:52:49.262
BROADLY SPEAKING, OBVIOUSLY, I

01:52:49.329 --> 01:52:52.499
HEARD THAT THE CONTRACT KIND OF

01:52:52.565 --> 01:52:55.135
MONOPOLY IS THE BIGGEST BARRIER

01:52:55.201 --> 01:52:56.603
FOR THE INDUSTRY'S UPTAKE OF

01:52:56.669 --> 01:52:58.304
THIS TYPE OF TECHNOLOGY. ARE

01:52:58.371 --> 01:53:00.340
THERE ANY OTHER THINGS THAT WE

01:53:00.406 --> 01:53:01.474
SHOULD BE LOOKING AT, WHETHER

01:53:01.541 --> 01:53:04.377
IT'S REGULATORY, LOCAL

01:53:04.444 --> 01:53:06.212
PERMITTING, WHAT OTHER WERE

01:53:06.279 --> 01:53:07.580
THERE ANY OTHER SUBSTANTIAL

01:53:07.647 --> 01:53:09.382
BARRIERS THAT THAT THAT YOU IN

01:53:09.449 --> 01:53:11.551
PARTICULAR RAN INTO IN THE

01:53:11.618 --> 01:53:12.952
ADOPTION THAT WE SHOULD LOOK AT?

01:53:13.019 --> 01:53:14.554
WE REALLY DIDN'T WE DIDN'T HAVE

01:53:14.621 --> 01:53:17.323
ANY PERMITTING ISSUES. THERE

01:53:17.390 --> 01:53:19.359
WEREN'T ANY I MEAN, TARIFFS.

01:53:19.425 --> 01:53:21.561
BUT YOU CAN'T HELP THAT. THAT'S

01:53:21.628 --> 01:53:23.329
NOT NOT A STATE PROBLEM. THAT'S

01:53:23.396 --> 01:53:24.731
A THAT'S ANOTHER PROBLEM FOR

01:53:24.797 --> 01:53:26.566
ANOTHER CONVERSATION. BUT, YOU

01:53:26.633 --> 01:53:28.701
KNOW, THAT'S THAT'S AN ISSUE

01:53:28.768 --> 01:53:30.904
HAVING TO PAY FOR EQUIPMENT

01:53:30.970 --> 01:53:32.272
THAT POTENTIALLY COMES FROM

01:53:32.338 --> 01:53:34.474
OVERSEAS. THE DALAM UNITS ARE

01:53:34.541 --> 01:53:36.976
WHICH ARE SMALL AND VERY EASY

01:53:37.043 --> 01:53:39.546
FOR SMALLER BREWERIES TO

01:53:39.612 --> 01:53:43.082
ACQUIRE AND INSTALL COME FROM

01:53:43.149 --> 01:53:44.951
COPENHAGEN. SO THERE'S GOING TO

01:53:45.018 --> 01:53:46.386
BE, YOU KNOW, TARIFFS ARE THE

01:53:46.452 --> 01:53:48.855
NEW A NEW BARRIER TO ENTRY, THE

01:53:48.922 --> 01:53:49.923
CONTRACTS YOU CAN'T HELP US

01:53:49.989 --> 01:53:52.158
WITH BECAUSE IT'S, YOU KNOW,

01:53:52.225 --> 01:53:54.360
PRIVATE BUSINESS. BUT, YOU KNOW,

01:53:54.427 --> 01:53:56.062
I THINK JUST MAKING SURE THAT

01:53:56.129 --> 01:53:59.299
THERE AREN'T ANY NEW NEW STATE

01:53:59.365 --> 01:54:00.800
REGULATIONS TO MAKE IT EVEN

01:54:00.867 --> 01:54:02.902
HARDER FOR US TO DO BUSINESS IN

01:54:02.969 --> 01:54:04.003
CALIFORNIA, WE'RE ALL TRYING TO

01:54:04.070 --> 01:54:05.438
DO THE RIGHT THING FROM THE

01:54:05.505 --> 01:54:07.407
FARMERS TO THE TO THE BREWERIES

01:54:07.473 --> 01:54:09.042
TO THE WINERIES TO CANNABIS.

01:54:09.108 --> 01:54:10.476
YOU KNOW, WE ALL WANT TO DO

01:54:10.543 --> 01:54:11.477
WHAT'S RIGHT FOR THE

01:54:11.544 --> 01:54:12.645
ENVIRONMENT. AND WE JUST WE

01:54:12.712 --> 01:54:15.215
NEED LESS, LESS HURDLES SO THAT

01:54:15.281 --> 01:54:17.684
WE CAN DO, DO GOOD BECAUSE

01:54:17.750 --> 01:54:19.452
WE'RE ALL ON BOARD FOR, FOR A

01:54:19.519 --> 01:54:20.687
GREENER ENVIRONMENT. WE JUST,

01:54:20.753 --> 01:54:23.423
WE JUST NEED TO NOT, YOU KNOW,

01:54:23.489 --> 01:54:25.959
HAVE YET ANOTHER BARRICADE OR

01:54:26.025 --> 01:54:27.827
RED TAPE OR SOMETHING THAT WE

01:54:27.894 --> 01:54:30.663
HAVE TO GET. BUT YEAH, I'D SAY

01:54:30.730 --> 01:54:32.832
REALLY, FOR US, IT'S, IT'S,

01:54:32.899 --> 01:54:34.267
IT'S SPECIFIC TO OUR INDUSTRY

01:54:34.334 --> 01:54:36.803
IS THE CONTRACTS. YEAH, THE

01:54:36.869 --> 01:54:37.570
CONTRACTS ARE WHAT I HEAR TIME

01:54:37.637 --> 01:54:40.039
AND TIME AGAIN. AND THEN FOR

01:54:40.106 --> 01:54:41.808
SOME SMALLER BREWERIES, THE

01:54:41.874 --> 01:54:43.977
UPFRONT COST IS A BIT OF AN

01:54:44.043 --> 01:54:46.479
OBSTACLE. IF THEY CAN OVERCOME

01:54:46.546 --> 01:54:48.248
THAT, THEN THEY DO SEE THAT

01:54:48.314 --> 01:54:50.416
RETURN ON INVESTMENT PRETTY

01:54:50.483 --> 01:54:55.021
QUICKLY. SO THOSE ARE THE BIG

01:54:55.088 --> 01:54:56.122
ONES. I HAVEN'T HEARD MUCH

01:54:56.189 --> 01:54:58.391
ABOUT PERMITTING OR I DON'T

01:54:58.458 --> 01:55:00.193
KNOW, LET'S SAY, WITH THE, YOU

01:55:00.260 --> 01:55:03.062
KNOW, DIRECT AIR CAPTURE. I'M

01:55:03.129 --> 01:55:04.931
SURE THAT TECHNOLOGY MIGHT HAVE

01:55:04.998 --> 01:55:06.599
A LITTLE BIT MORE ON THE

01:55:06.666 --> 01:55:08.067
PERMITTING SIDE WHEN YOU COME

01:55:08.134 --> 01:55:10.603
TO RECOVERY WITHIN THE BREWING

01:55:10.670 --> 01:55:12.772
PROCESS. THERE'S NOT MANY

01:55:12.839 --> 01:55:17.043
OBSTACLES TO THAT. BUT YEAH,

01:55:17.110 --> 01:55:20.146
REALLY COST AND CONTRACTS.

01:55:20.213 --> 01:55:22.849
THAT'S THE BIG ONE. YEAH. OKAY.

01:55:22.915 --> 01:55:24.017
YEAH. LET'S GO AHEAD AND PAUSE

01:55:24.083 --> 01:55:25.952
HERE. WE'LL PICK IT UP ON THE

01:55:26.019 --> 01:55:27.220
TOUR. YEAH. BUT I'M GOING TO

01:55:27.287 --> 01:55:29.122
OPEN IT UP TO DO PUBLIC COMMENT

01:55:29.188 --> 01:55:31.124
FOR FOLKS ON EITHER OF THE TWO

01:55:31.190 --> 01:55:32.191
PANELS. IF THERE'S ANYBODY IN

01:55:32.258 --> 01:55:33.860
THE AUDIENCE WHO WANTS TO TO

01:55:33.926 --> 01:55:36.162
MAKE A COUPLE COMMENTS, MR.

01:55:36.229 --> 01:55:40.533
MAYOR. NØ OH, COME ON, YOU HAVE

01:55:40.600 --> 01:55:42.435
NEVER BEEN QUIET A DAY IN YOUR

01:55:42.502 --> 01:55:45.905
LIFE. NO. I'M GOOD. YOU'RE

01:55:45.972 --> 01:55:48.775
DOING A HELL OF A JOB. ALL

01:55:48.841 --> 01:55:50.576
RIGHT, THEN WE WILL GO AHEAD

01:55:50.643 --> 01:55:51.778
AND PAUSE HERE. I JUST WANT TO

01:55:51.844 --> 01:55:53.613
SAY THANK YOU REALLY FAST TO

01:55:53.680 --> 01:55:54.814
THE CITY OF HEALDSBURG FOR

01:55:54.881 --> 01:55:56.616
LETTING US USE THE ROOM AND FOR

01:55:56.683 --> 01:55:57.817
ALWAYS BEING A GOOD PARTNER. I

01:55:57.884 --> 01:55:59.719
WANT TO THANK KEN AND HIS TEAM

01:55:59.786 --> 01:56:00.920
FOR COMING OVER FROM SACRAMENTO

01:56:00.987 --> 01:56:02.622
TO DO THE AUDIO VISUAL. AND

01:56:02.689 --> 01:56:03.690
THEN FOR ALL OF OUR

01:56:03.756 --> 01:56:05.692
PARTICIPANTS IN THIS AS AS WE

01:56:05.758 --> 01:56:07.126
MENTIONED, THIS SELECT

01:56:07.193 --> 01:56:08.294
COMMITTEE DOES HAVE MORE THAN

01:56:08.361 --> 01:56:10.196
ONE MEMBER ON IT. IT'S HARD TO

01:56:10.263 --> 01:56:11.531
GET PEOPLE SCHEDULED RIGHT

01:56:11.597 --> 01:56:13.366
BEFORE THE HOLIDAYS, BUT THAT'S

01:56:13.433 --> 01:56:15.435
WHY WE MADE IT AVAILABLE VIA

01:56:15.501 --> 01:56:17.537
VIDEO FOR FOR STAFF AND FOR

01:56:17.603 --> 01:56:18.638
MEMBERS. AND WE'LL CERTAINLY BE

01:56:18.705 --> 01:56:20.106
TAKING A LOT OF THIS BACK TO

01:56:20.173 --> 01:56:21.240
SACRAMENTO WHEN WE ARE LOOKING

01:56:21.307 --> 01:56:22.975
AT LEGISLATION FOR NEXT YEAR.

01:56:23.042 --> 01:56:24.177
SO WE'LL GO AHEAD AND ADJOURN

01:56:24.243 --> 01:56:26.546
HERE. LET'S GET TO THE TOUR.

01:56:26.612 --> 01:56:43.730
THANK YOU, THANK YOU.


